Internal Monitoring Report for Land Acquisition and ...€¦ · GoK and ADB, relevant Kazakhstan laws, and ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (2009). 5. This Internal Monitoring Report

Internal Monitoring Report for Land Acquisition and Resettlement

November 2014

KAZ: CAREC Corridor 2 (Mangystau Oblast Section)

Investment Program – Tranche 2

Prepared by the Committee of Roads of the Republic of Kazakhstan for the Asian Development Bank.

Internal Monitoring Report for Land Acquisition and Resettlement KAZ: CAREC Corridor 2 (Mangistau Oblast Section) Investment Program, Tranche 2

1

Internal Monitoring Report for Land Acquisition and Resettlement Document Stage: Final Loan Number: 2967-KAZ Date: 30 November 2014

KAZ: CAREC Corridor 2 (Mangystau Oblast Section) Investment Program Tranche 2


ABBREVIATIONS

ADB

CAREC

DDR

GoK

RoK

MFF

CoR

PMC

KazAutoZhol

GosNPTsZem

CSC

LAR

LARF

LARP

LLP

DP

HH

LE

Ha

KZT

SPS

Asian Development Bank

Central Asia Regional Economic Cooperation Program

Government of Kazakhstan

Due Diligence Report

Republic of Kazakhstan

Multi-Tranche Financing Facility

Committee of Roads

Project Management Consultant

Joint Stock Company (JSC) «NC KazAutoZhol»

Land State Scientific and Production Center for Management

Construction Supervision Consultant

Land Acquisition and Resettlement

Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework

Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan

Displaced Person

Limited Liability Partnership

Household

Legal entity

hectare

Kazakh Tenge

Safeguard Policy Statement (2009)


INTRODUCTION

1. The Central Asia Regional Economic Cooperation Program (CAREC) Transport Corridor 2 Investment Program proposed by the Government of Kazakhstan (GoK) for funding by the Asian Development Bank (ADB) aims to rehabilitate/upgrade the roads Manasha – Aktau, Beineu-Akzhigit and the Zhetybai-Zhana Ozen – Fetisovo – to the border with Turkmenistan in Mangystau Oblast through a Multi-Tranche Financing Facility (MFF). 2. The MFF is divided into three tranches:

Tranche 1 is covering the road section from km 372.6 (Manashy river) to km 514.3 (Sai-Utes) and km 574 to km 632.3 (Shetpe). Tranche 2 is expected to upgrade the remaining sections from km 632, 3 to km 802 and the section (Shetpe-Beineu-Aktau). Tranche 3 will upgrade Beineu – Akzhigit section and Zhetybai – Turkmenistan border.

3. Tranche 2 comprises upgrading of a total of 169.97 kilometers road. The road will be rehabilitated and partly reconstructed in accordance with the national highway categories I and II. Technically the road length can be divided into 2 sections:

Section 1 (Category I) includes the entire route between Shetpe bypass start (km 632.3), to the end of Shetpe bypass (km 644), and continuing to Zhetibay bypass (km 711-719) until joining the national highway from Zhanaozen and Turkmenistan to Aktau (km 719);

Section 2 (Category II) includes the stretch between Zhetibay junction (km 719) westwards to Aktau urban periphery, at the junction at km 802.27.

4. The Draft Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan (LARP) for CAREC Corridor 2 (Mangystau Oblast Section) Investment Program Tranche 2 was prepared in November 2012 and updated in August 2014 by the Committee of Roads (CoR), Ministry of Investments and Development (MID) in compliance with the Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework (LARF) agreed between GoK and ADB, relevant Kazakhstan laws, and ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (2009). 5. This Internal Monitoring Report for LARP relates to Tranche 2 of the CAREC Corridor 2 (Mangystau Oblast Section) Investment Program and provides analysis of implementation of the LARP at km 632.3 to km 802 road section. The objectives of the Report are to:

a) Verify that resettlement activities implemented for the project comply with the approved Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan (LARP) and ADB's Safeguard Policy Statement (2009);

b) Verify that DPs have restored their living standards; 6. This Report reflects the current situation of land acquisition and resettlement related activities and issues. This includes opinions of DPs, whose land/property related interests and rights have been affected as a result of the implementation of Tranche 2. The key information contained in this Report is:

a) Land acquisition procedures; b) Impacts of the land acquisition and resettlement; c) Information on compensation;


4

II. OBJECTIVES OF INTERNAL MONITORING AND METHODOLOGY

7. Monitoring was conducted in November 2014 by national consultant (PMC), with assistance of JSC MOB «NC KazAutoZhol» and akimats of Mangistay, Munaily, and Karakia rayons. The consultant reviewed documents provided by JSC MOB «NC KazAutoZhol», Mangistay, Munaily and Karakia rayon akimats, including corrective actions proposed in approved LARP updated in August 2014. 8. The following actions have been performed as a part of monitoring process:

Review of LARP, procedures on entitlement, independent evaluation reports and compensation payments processes;

Review of documents regarding provision of compensation including decisions from relevant state institutions;

Implementation of monitoring of land acquisition. III. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT1

9. ADB has agreed to make a loan to the RoK with $371.300.000 million (Loan Agreement 2967-KAZ) for implementing the CAREC Corridor 2 (Mangystau Oblast Section) Investment Program Tranche 2 (hereinafter the Project) on 18 June 2013. The Project comprises reconstruction of 169.97 kilometers between the settlement of Shetpe and the city of Aktau and its construction supervision. The road will be reconstructed in accordance with the national highway categories. Technically, the road length can be divided into 2 sections:

Section 1 includes the entire route between Shetpe bypass start (km 632.3) to the end of Shetpe bypass (km 644), and continuing to Zhetibay bypass (km 711-719) up to the junction with the national highway from Zhanaozen and Turkmenistan to Aktau (km 719);

Section 2 includes the stretch between Zhetibay junction (km 719) westwards to Aktau urban periphery, at the junction at km 802.27.

Civil works are divided into four contract packages:

Lot 1 (km 632.3 – km 675);

Lot 2 (km 675 – km 719);

Lot 3 (km 719 – km 754);

Lot 4 (km 754 – km 802.27).

The works involve the followings:

Upgrading of Section 1 (total length 85.44km) to Category II road between Shetpe bypass (km 632.3 -km 644), and Zhetibay bypass (km 711-719). The section ends at junction on km 719. On this section is anticipated to construct the following:

5 cattle crossings for livestock;

bridge;

32 culverts;

1 overpass

Section 1 - 632.3 km – 719 belongs to the second category.

1 Information on Project Description (paragraphs 9-10) provided in this Chapter is based on Land Acquisition and

Resettlement Framework, Project 43439-KAZ, November 2012


5

Section 2 (total length 83,891 km) involves the stretch between Zhetibay Junction end (km 719) westwards to Aktau urban periphery at the junction at km 802.27. This section includes the followings:

5 cattle crossings for livestock;

1 junction;

33 culverts;

bridge on the river Ashiagar;

1 overpass;

Railroad

This section includes (km 719 - km. 786) upgrading of the existing road to technical category 1B

(total length 68.296 km) with four lane, traffic strip and widening of the roadbed to 27.5 m on the

top.

Construction of a road junction at the intersection of two levels of roads "Aktau - Zhanaozen" and

"Shetpe - Kuryk" on km 720 with four-lane carriageway passing through the top of the road

"Shetpe - Kuryk."

The section (total length 15.595 km) belongs to category III passing urban periphery (km 786 - km

802.27) and involves repairing of carriageway and pavement.

10. During the construction phase, land may also be needed temporarily for batching plants, field

offices/workers’ camps, and temporary bypasses. However, civil works contracts will

require the contractor to be responsible for the temporary acquisition and reinstatement of all

and required outside of the right of way for construction camps, offices, borrow pits, materials

storage sites, materials processing sites and haul roads. Contractor is assumed to prefer to

rent State land, rather than private property, during construction works.

In addition, temporarily used lands are required to be returned to their original state after work

completed.

11. The Contractor, “Cengiz Inshaat” (Turkey) has been selected. The Contract has been signed on 23.06.2014. In November this year Contractor stated mobilization, construction of camp and construction works at one of the road sections (earth) despite of LARP is not fully implemented.


6

Summary of land acquisition and resettlement impacts is presented in Table 1 below. Details on affected parties and assets are provided in Annex A. Table 1. Summary land acquisition and resettlement impacts

No. Description Number/Amount

1 Total number of permanently affected land plots

a. Leased lands (natural pastureland, industrial, commercial

lands)

b. Privately owned lands

22

12

10

2 Total land (ha) needed for the project

a. Area of land to be taken from state reserved lands (ha)

b. Area of land to be taken from private and leased land (ha)

373.40

279.1292

94.2708

3 Total area of land to be acquired permanently (in hectares)

Including:

a. Leased lands

(natural pastureland, industrial, commercial lands)

b. Privately owned lands

94.2708

70.9917

23.2791

4 Total area of residential land to be acquired permanently (in ha) 0.184

5 Total area of commercial land to be acquired permanently (in ha) 1.2108

6 Total area of agricultural land to be acquired permanently (in ha) 77.8307

7 Total area of industrial land to be acquired permanently (in ha) 15.0453

8 Total number of affected households and legal entities 22

9 Total number of permanently affected legal entities 18

10 Total number of permanently affected households 4

11 Total number of affected structures (permanent) 3

12 Total number of households and legal entities who need to relocate

their houses/business structures-2 residential and 1 gas

station/café

3

13 Total number of households who need to relocate their houses 2

14 Total number of and legal entities who need to relocate 1

15 Total number of APs 36

16 Total number of affected workers 5

17 Total number of vulnerable households 1


Corrective plan implementation: Mangistau rayon

No.

Corrective action Status Note

2 Provide alternative lands to the private land users (2 LEs, 2 HHs)

Alternative lands have been provided, 1 HH legalizes land, 1 HH shows no activity.

2 Les have refused in in writing from lands

Yersultanova Altyn Mukhanova Zhaniyash

Kudaibergenov Zh., Baiterek LLP

3 Provide alternative lands to the land lessees for lease (3 LEs)

The owners have refused in writing from alternative leased lands

Turetayev N., Symbat LLP Zhumakhanov Nauryz, Kozha LLP Bissenov Mukhtar, MKDSM JSC

4 Re-registration of lands for all 7 affected parties (private and leased lands) (preparation of the state acts)

The state acts are prepared for 4 owners

2 HHs – procedural issues

1 LE – refusal from the land, and is slow to receive the new land plot

Turetayev N., Symbat LLP Zhumakhanov Nauryz, Kozha LLP Bissenov Mukhtar, MKDSM JSC Kudaibergenov Zh., Baiterek LLP

Yersultanova Altyn

Mukhanova Zhaniyash

Tlegenov Nurlan

5 Renew and execute lease contracts with 3 LEs

Lease contracts have been prepared Turetayev N., Symbat LLP Zhumakhanov Nauryz, Kozha LLP Bissenov Mukhtar, MKDSM JSC

6. Assist in moving of 2 HHs (provision with the workforce and vehicles for transportation of HH’s stuff and construction

materials

Assistance has been provided. Houses have been demolished in 90%

7.

Payment of compensation to vulnerable HH (Zh. Mukhanova) in amount of KZT 59,898 and her involvement

in the state social program

Not implemented

Procedural matters


1. Yersultanova Altyn: Compensations have been fully paid. The owner has obtained a house with 11 rooms. Living conditions have been improved. The new land plot has been proposed to replace the acquired one. The owner is slow to apply for compensation obtainment.

2. Mukhanova Zhaniyash: Compensations have been fully paid. The owner has obtained the new land plot for construction of a house nearby his son’s house. The new land plot has been proposed to replace the acquired one. The owner has applied for compensation obtainment. The land commission’s decision is the new land plot to be allocated. The land use design is getting prepared.

3. Kudaibergenov Zh., Baiterek LLP: Lease Contract and State Act are prepared. 4. Turetayev N., Symbat LLP: a proprietary right has been specified and the private land changed to leased one. Lease Contract and

State Act are prepared. 5. Tlegenov Nurlan: The owner has refused the land plot in writing. A decision was made to reverse the decision on allocation of land

to private ownership. The owner is slow to obtain an alternative land plot instead of the lost one.

6. Zhumakhanov Nauryz, Kozha LLP: Lease Contract and State Act are prepared. 7. Bissenov Mukhtar, MKDSM JSC: Lease Contract and State Act are prepared. The area of land plot has been specified: initial

24.0078 ha has been changed to 82.1947 ha, the amount of land remained unchanged. Percent of acquisition reduced from 14% to 4%.


Mangistau rayon

No. Owner Address/Residenc

y Cadastral number

Original land area (ha)

Land area acquired (ha)

% of area acquired (ha)

Land ownership status

Owner (HH or LE)

Category of land Land usage

Land is acquired permanently/temporarily

Date of evaluation

Amount of compensation

Use “+”, if it is a market price

1 Yersultanova Altyn

Shetpe, mcr. Kossbulak, 2

– 1

13-198-002-224

0,084 0,084 100%

Private property HH HH Residential land

Permanent 01.07.2013

5 249 300 KZT 34 600 USD

+

2 Mukhanova Zhaniyash

Shetpe, mcr. Kossbulak, 2-2

13-198-002-462

0,1 0,1 100%

Private property HH HH Residential land

Permanent 01.07.2013

7 732 400 KZT 50 900 USD

+

3 Kudaibergenov Zh. Baiterek LLP

Aktau 28-10-151

13-198-002-158

5 0,2203 4,41%

Private property

LE

Industrial

Industrial land

Permanent

n/a

Without compensation

Not applicable

4

Turetayev N. Symbat LLP 87015667080

Zhetybai 13-198-023-011

2000 0,0922 0,005%

Leased land LE Farm household

Agricultural land “Symbat”, Not used

Permanent n/a Without compensation

Not applicable

5 Tlegenov Nurlan

Shetpe, mcr. Ashchibulak, unnumb.

13-198-002-738

0,015 0,0058 38,67% Private property

LE Commercial

Commercial land (shop, café)


Not applicable

6

Zhumakhanov Nauryz Kozha LLP

Shetpe, mcr. Zhanaorpa v, 87013235444 87013235444

13-198-019-033

1500 1,8377 0,12% Leased land (for the term of 49 years)

LE Farm household “Kozha”

Agricultural land

Permanent / Постоянный

n/a Without compensation

Not applicable

7 Bissenov Mukhtar MKDSM JSC

Station Mangyshlak, 87015127901 87015127901

13-198-002-800

82,1947

3,5978 4,37% Leased land (by 2059)

LE Industrial

Manufacturing area, site


Not applicable


Munaily raion: No Corrective Action Status Remarks

1 Provision of alternative lands to private land users (2 LE, 2

HH)

Alternative lands were provided without acquisition

Modification was refused

А.I. Utesinov Sh.К. Shermagambetov "MyrzAbek" JSC - Altyn Tas Group

I.Tastemirov Peasant Farm - Otemuratov Kurmet Saparbayevich

2 Provision lessees with alternative lands (6 LE)

Alternative lands were provided. The owners refused new land plots through waiver in written

form

Unzila Мeyrmanova, . Zh. Meyrmanov U.Karzhaubayeva - “Elaman” peasant

farm Serik Baytubetov peasant farm "Torla"

Аzamat Kalmuratov - “Erik” peasant farm

К.N. Kyzylbayev

3 Re-registration of lands for all 10 affected parties (private and

leased lands) (execution of the state acts)

Lease agreements for leased lands and state act for new lands have been prepared.

See Annex below


1. А.I. Utesinov: change of Decision of akimat of Batyr rural district dd 07.11.2014 on nullifying the Decision on acquisition 0.3252 ha, land plot modified with the

same area land plot, in the same district and the same locality. New state act has been prepared.

2. Sh.К. Shermagambetov: change of Decision of akimat of Kyzyltobe rural district от 07.11.2014 on nullifying the Decision on acquisition 0.1216 ha, land plot

modified with еры same area land plot, in the same district and the same locality. New state act has been prepared.

3. Unzila Мeyrmanova: Total plot area has been clarified — 19,8 ha, instead of 3106,5 ha, acquisition remained the same — 3,4743 ha. Lease agreement

amended dd 06.11.2014, new state act has been prepared.

4. Аzamat Kalmuratov - “Erik” peasant farm, removed from the list of affected parties by the Decision of Munayly raion No.370-к dd 06.11.2014, Modification

of land plot with the same area land plot.

5. Zh. Meyrmanov: Total plot area has been clarified — 901,0 ha, instead of 1000 ha, acquisition remained the same — 8,5122 ha. Lease agreement amended dd

07.11.2014. New state act has been prepared.

6. К.N. Kyzylbayev: removed from the list of affected parties by the Decision of Munayly raion No.370-к dd 06.11.2014

7. U.Karzhaubayeva - “Elaman” peasant farm: Total plot area has been clarified — 1403.9 ha, instead of 1403 ha, acquisition remained the same — 1.6852 ha.

Lease agreement amended dd 07.11.2014. New state act has been prepared

8. “KurykKurylysServis” LLP - owner changed to "MyrzAbek" JSC - Altyn Tas Group, Sales contract 15.01.2014, new state act has been prepared. Modification of land plot. Area changed from Tarla locality to Batyr locality with the same area. 9. I.Tastemirov - Peasant Farm — owner changed to Otemuratov Kurmet Saparbayevich, Sales contract dd 05.02.2009, Total plot area has been clarified —

1227.7 ha instead of 1915.1 ha, acquisition remained the same — 21.125 ha. State act has been prepared.

10. Serik Baytubetov peasant farm "Torla": Lease agreement amended dd 07.11.2014, new state act has been prepared. Plot area acquired is without changes.


Munaily Rayon

№ Owner Adress/Location Cadastral number

Intial Land (ha)

Land to be

aqcuired (ha)

% expropri

ation (ha)

Ownership/

Tenure Status

Owner HH/LE

Land type

Land Usag

e

Land to be

acquired permanently/tempor

arily

date of valuation

sum of compensatio

n

mark "+" if it

is market price

1 А.I. Utesinov

29-23-85 app., Aktau 13-203-084-

3396 1 0 0% Private HH

Industrial Land

-

Land swap. Modification

N/A


N/A

2 Sh.К.

Shermagambetov 11-20-30 app.,

Aktau 13-203-099-033

1,5 0 0% Private HH Industrial Land

-


N/A


N/A

3 Unzila

Мeyrmanova 12-44-56 app.,

Aktau, 87017775857 13-203-007-198

19.8 3,4743 17,5%

Leased Land

(for 49 years)

Peasant Farm

Agricultural Land

-

Permanenent

N/A

without compensation N/A

4

Аzamat Kalmuratov - “Erik” peasant

farm

11-23-82 app., Aktau,

87014635658

13-203-007-340

100 0 0%

Leased Land

(for 49 years)

Peasant Farm

Agricultural

Land

-


N/A


N/A

5 Zh. Meyrmanov 12-44-56 app.,

Aktau 13-203-011-076

901,0 8,5122 0,85%

Leased Land for 49 years)

Peasant Farm

Agricultural

Land

-

Permanenent

N/A


6 К.N. Kyzylbayev

23 building, Kurzhymanuly str.,

Zhetybai v., Karakia raion

13-203-011-075

1200 1,1176 0,09%

Leased Land

(for 49 years)

Peasant Farm

Agricultural

Land

-

Permanenent

N/A


7

U.Karzhaubayeva - “Elaman”

peasant farm

57 building, Sagynysh str., Kyzyltobe rural district, Munayly

raion

13-203-011-043

1403,9 1,6852 0,12%

Leased Land

(for 49 years)

Peasant Farm

Agricultural

Land

-

Permanenent

N/A

without compensation

N/A

8

“KurykKurylysServis” LLP

"MyrzAbek" JSC -

Aktau, near the buildings of “Mangistau

- 10 0 0%

Leased Land (for

LE Industrial Land

-


N/A


N/A


Altyn Tas Group

Distribution Power Grid Company” JSC

49years)

9

I.Tastemirov - Peasant Farm -

Otemuratov Kurmet

Saparbayevich

230-2 building, Zhanakurylys

microdist., Zhetybay v., Karakia raion,

87018200258

13-203-011-008

1227,7 21,125 1,7% Private Peasant

Farm

Agricultural

Land

-

Permanenent

N/A without compensation

N/A

10

Serik Baytubetov peasant farm

"Torla"

151-1 building, Zhanakurylys

microdist., Zhetybay v., Karakia raion,

87783048528

13-203-011-135

1363,88

39,9660 2,93%

Leased Land (for

49years)

Peasant Farm

Agricultural

Land

-

Permanenent

N/A without compensation

N/A


Karakiya Rayon:

No Corrective Action Status Remarks

1 Cash compensation for gas station with café-bar “Gularsha”

(Mendikulova G.) in the amount of 27 360 784 KZT

till 10 August 2014 Fully paid

2 Provision lessees with alternative lands (2 LEs) Alternative lands were provided. The owners refused new land plots through waiver

in written form

“MMG” JSC, Nuranov Bek Mirzabekovich "Aktautas" LLP

3 Re-registration of lands for all 4 affected parties (private and

leased lands) (execution of the state acts)


4 Renew and execute leasing agreements with 12 leasing LEs


1. Mendiculova Gulzira - compensation fully paid. The owner dismantled its structures.

2. Otemyratova Gulzhan - land modification was made in equal size and location. State act is prepared.

3. Ulutas” JSC, Tuyakov Zhanabay Elemesovich — removed from the list of affected parties. Lease agreement was not executed. De jure this land is belongs to

government.

4. “Aktautas” JSC and “MMG” JSC - state acts and lease agreements are not ready. Procedural matters. Renewal of old documents is underway, which later will be

replaced by new documents taking into account impacts.


Karakiya Rayon

№ Owner Adress/Location Cadastral number

Initial land (ha)

Land to be

acquired

(hа)

% expropri

ation (ha)

Ownership/Tenure Status

Owner HH/LE

Land type

Land Usage

Land to be acquired

permanently/tempor

arily

date of

valuation

sum of compensa

tion

mark "+" if it is

market

price

1

Mendiculova Gulzira

Dukenbayevna

Building 85, Tolkyn housing estate, 29 micridistrict, Aktau,

87015331510

13-197-008-376

0,605

0,605 100% Private LE Commercial Land

Gas station

with café-bar

"Gularsha" cafe-bar

Permanent

18.10.2013

27 360 784 KZT 177 818

USD

+

2

“MMG” JSC, Nuranov Bek Mirzabekovic

h

2 Mic. Aktau, Orda, 713. 212-427

13-197-004 - 585

4629,4

8,1721 0,18%

Leased Land

(for 49 years)

LE Industr

ial Land

User of mineral

resources oil

production

Voluntarily returned the part of

land

N/A

Voluntarily returned the part of

land

N/A

3

“Ulutas” JSC, Tuyakov

Zhanabay Elemesovich

87015202293 13-197-006-957

50 0 0%

Leased Land

(for 49 years)

LE Industr

ial Land

Quarry

Voluntarily retuned the part of

land

N/A

Voluntarely returned the part of the land

N/A

4 “Aktautas”

JSC Serik Sabyrbaev

87015267770 13-197-004-573

12,9 1,5194 11,78%

Leased Land

(for 49 years)

LE Industr

ial Land

Quarry Voluntarily return

land

N/A

No Comepns

ation

N/A

5 Otemyratova

Gulzhan

App.62, Building 1, microdistrict 28, 33-

08-70

13-197-007-035

0,6 0,6 100% Private LE Commercial Land

For building

gas station

Land swap

16.04.2013

Land swap

N/A

External Monitoring Report for Land Acquisition and Resettlement KAZ: CAREC Corridor 2 (Mangistau Oblast Section) Investment Program, Tranche 2

DISCLOSURE

12. Information brochure with project information of CAREC Corridor 2 (Mangistau Oblast Section) Investment Program, Tranche 2 and ADB's resettlement requirements were posted and distributed among the participants during individual consultations. Information brochure provides awareness on project, entitlements to compensation and assistance specified under the project. 13. The final LARP was translated into Russian and disclosed on the website of the Western Europe – Western China Project and ADB upon its endorsement by ADB and CoR/MID. 14. The hard copy of final LARP is available in Akimats of Munaily, Karakya, and Mangystau rayons, also soft copies were posted on websites of Munaily and Karakya rayons. GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISM 15. Grievances may be submitted to personnel of CSC, JSC MOB “KazAutoZhol”, or Akimats (Munaily, Karakya, or Mangystau Rayon, respectively). At these levels Focal Points were designated to receive, assist in solution, preparation of reports or handing over grievances received from APs and local community. The following are the Grievance Focal Points designated for Tranche 2, Investment Program, Corridor 2, CAREC (Mangistau Oblast Section):

a) Focal Point of CSC (full name, contact details) Mr. Krykbaev Nurzhan Nazimbekovich: 8 (7292) – 60-58-52

b) Focal Point of JSC MOB “KazAutoZhol”: Deputy director of JSC MOB “KazAutoZhol”

c) Mr. Krykbaev Nurzhan Nazimbekovich: 8 (7292) – 60-58-52 E-mail: [email protected]

d) Focal Points in Akimats

o Vice Akim of Mangystau Rayon Sarbalayev Abzal Berdibaevich – 8-72931 – 2-11-87

o Vice akim of Munaily rayon Ondabaev Kalnias Ondabaevich – 8-7292 – 46-62-03

o Vice akim of Karakya Rayon Bekov Kidirberdi Andirovich – 8-72937 – 2-13-07

Focal Points in CoR MID Assel Karymbaeva – 8-7172-24-26-11

16. APs or other concerned individuals may visit, call or send a letter or fax to any of the Grievance Focal Points to register their comments or complaints related to land acquisition or other aspects of the project.

mailto:[email protected]

Documents

Internal Monitoring Report for Land Acquisition and ...€¦ · GoK and ADB, relevant Kazakhstan laws, and ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (2009). 5. This Internal Monitoring Report