Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Form4 (FR2→FR3)
Interim Report
Project Title Biodiversity-driven Nutrient Cycling and Human Well-being in
Social-Ecological Systems
Abbreviated Title e-REC Project
Project Category Individual Collaboration Project
Project Leader OKUDA Noboru
Homepage Ex. http://www.chikyu.ac.jp/xxx/.
Keywords Biodiversity, Ecosystem service, Human well-being,
Nutrient balance, Watershed governance
Proposed project
period
□ 3 years Full Research
□ 4 years Full Research
■ 5 years Full Research
Check the applicable box.
Contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1. ACHIEVEMENTS IN FULL RESEARCH TO DATE
2. AMENDMENTS TO RESEARCH OBJECTIVES AND METHODS AS NECESSARY
3. RESEARCH PLAN
4. RESPONSE TO REVIEWER COMMENTS
5. MOST NOTABLE OUTPUTS TO DATE
6. PROJECT ORGANIZATION AND MEMBERS
7. FIGURES AND SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Summarize the proposal within two pages. Figures, tables and pictures can be included here. Supplementary figures, tables and pictures should be put in Section 8.
a) Research objectives and background
Technological innovation in food production resulted in population growth,
increase in life expectancy and economic prosperity. However, overexploitation of the
basal resources leads to disturbance of natural biogeochemical cycles of
macronutrients, such as nitrogen and phosphorus, in watersheds. Such nutrient
imbalances have caused serious environmental problems, contributing to cultural
eutrophication and water pollution. The nutrient imbalances also skew biological
communities toward overwhelming superiority of nuisance species, as in the case of
harmful algal blooms. The anthropogenic disturbances in the nutrient cycling result
in deterioration of ecosystem services in quality and quantity through the loss of
ecosystem functions provided by biodiversity. At present, it has been recognized that
nutrient imbalances and biodiversity loss are so common and prevalent throughout
the planet, posing a risk to sustainable human development (Rockström et al. 2009).
To solve these nutrient imbalance-associated issues emerging at a watershed scale,
we aim to develop a method of adaptive watershed governance, in which biodiversity,
nutrient cycling and human well-being are enhanced as the primary components for
sustainable social-ecological systems.
b) Research methods and organization
Conventionally, governments and researchers have hitherto pay attention to
elucidate causality of environmental pollutions for practice of watershed
management, in which planning and decision-making are made for solution of public
issues based on scientific rationality, often taking institutional and technological
approaches. However, the modern nutrient imbalance-associated issues are
complicated and elusive not only because much of nutrients are loaded from non-
point sources, such as domestic and agricultural wastes, but also because a driver of
nutrient resource exploitation is remote from the source of nutrient pollution. In
addition, most of citizens, especially in developed societies, are not so interested in the
nutrient imbalance-associated issues because they never suffer from nutrient
pollution through their daily life, which is physically isolated from the nature. Rather,
they are concerned about social issues related to their life and livelihood than about
environmental issues. With the increasing population in society, the conventional
watershed management has difficulty in comprehensive solution of environmental
issues without social involvement.
Considering such limitation of the top-down approaches, we facilitate cross-
linkage of multi-level governance, in which a variety of stakeholders are involved in
enhancement of biodiversity, nutrient cycling and well-being for sustainability of
social-ecological systems, according to our hypothesis that these three components
are interdependent to each other through community activities, like gears (Fig. 1). In
local communities from upstream through downstream to coastal areas of the
watershed, we begin with action research, in which community member are
empowered for conservation of indigenous nature, defined as indigenous
environmental icon. By our definition, the indigenous environmental icon is not
always meaningful ecologically but culturally for the community members in the
context of their life and livelihood. It also has the potential to enhance community-
based well-being. When some of community members, who feel worthwhile and
satisfactory through conservation of the environmental icon, share its cultural values
with others, the community-based well-being is collectively enhanced through
accumulation of bonding social capitals. Then, the enhancement of community-based
well-being positively feeds back to biodiversity conservation and thus biodiversity-
driven nutrient cycling (processes at the local scale in Fig. 1).
If such community activities contribute to enhancement of nutrient cycling at a
watershed scale, they provide a watershed society with public interests in terms of
ecosystem services beyond indigenous cultural values for the local community.
Through dissemination of our scientific knowledge to the watershed society, we can
facilitate social involvement in conservation activities and green consuming of
environmentally friendly community’s products by non-community members who
appreciate the public interests, resulting in accumulation of bridging social capitals
and increase in economic incentives (processes at the watershed scale in Fig. 1). The
public interests may also solicit institutional support for the conservation activities
from local governments. Through integration of local and scientific knowledge, the
community-based well-being will be further enhanced, leading to empowerment of
community activities for environmental restoration as well as for biodiversity
conservation. In order to facilitate social involvement and linkage among a variety of
stakeholders in the watershed society, we will organize a watershed forum, in which
new environmental knowledge may be created to make the watershed system more
sustainable.
To practice the adaptive watershed governance based on transdisciplinary
science, we organized 7 discipline-based research units, which to put forward and test
working hypotheses on natural and social processes through the governance, and 15
site-specific or issue-specific working groups to co-work with a variety of stakeholders
in society from local to watershed scales (Fig. 2). We compare outcomes of our
watershed governance between contrasting two watershed systems, Lake Biwa
Watershed in Japan and Laguna de Bay Watershed in Philippines as models for
infrastructure-oriented and high-loading societies, respectively. For each of the two
societies, we have some focal communities across the longitudinal gradient of
watershed to view site-specificity in social-environmental issues and their solution
strategy. While finding constraints of the multi-level governance from our practices
and gathering social and ecological data on other watersheds from literature survey,
we will discuss applicability and limitation of our governance approach to a wide
range of watershed societies around the world.
1. ACHIEVEMENTS IN FULL RESEARCH TO DATE Compile this section within two pages. Figures, tables and pictures can be included here. Supplementary figures, tables and pictures should be put in Section 8.
To apply a method of our multi-level governance to the Yasu River sub-watershed of
Lake Biwa, we practiced action research to empower local communities for
conservation of indigenous environmental icons (subject a), while we conducted
synoptic researches on biodiversity, nutrient cycling and well-being in its whole
catchment to assess public interests of conservation activities (b-d). In parallel, we
applied our governance approach to the Silang-Santa Rosa sub-watershed of Laguna
de Bay to compare its outcomes with each other (e). We are also thinking out how to
construct international framework for the watershed governance (f).
a) Action research in local communities
We launched the action research in a local community located in the middle-
stream of Yasu River sub-watershed. Through recognition of indigenous nature and
mutual learning of its cultural values, we regarded a brown frog as an indigenous
environmental icon and worked on its conservation. The GIS-based spatial statistics
revealed that the brown frog prefers to spawn in the paddy fields with wetland
biotopes (Fig. 3a). This scientific knowledge facilitated farmers’ engagement in
conservation activities, in which paddy field irrigation system was modified from
modern to traditional one (Fig. 3b, c). Inquiry survey based on a grounded theory
revealed that participants altered their environmental consciousness, in which their
well-being was closely linked to natural capitals, through the conservation activities
(Fig. 4).
We also conducted the field survey on nutrient loadings from the paddy fields.
There was a tendency that the traditional irrigation system is effective in reduction
of phosphate loadings during the irrigation period, compared to the modern system,
though it was not statistically significant because of small sample size (Fig. 5).
b) Synoptic research on biodiversity and nutrient cycling
In the whole catchment of Yasu River, we conducted synoptic field research to
visualize spatial pattern of biodiversity and nutrient cycling during irrigation period,
which are comparable to the previous data on those during non-irrigation period. The
data analysis is now going on to assess not only the impact of the paddy field
irrigation on the biodiversity and nutrient cycling but also the relative contribution
of community conservation activities to reduction of anthropogenic nutrient loadings.
c) Assessment of public interests
Prior to assessment of public interests from the community conservation activities,
we established some advanced technique to monitor nutrient cycling at a watershed
scale. Sequential extraction method to isolate and quantify speciation of particulate
phosphorous (PP) was used to evaluate its bioavailability and assess its potential
impacts on coastal ecosystems. In the previous year, we reported that coastal
zoobenthos diversity is depauperated by habitat degradation due to siltation from the
paddy fields in the catchment. In Yasu River, the PP accounts for 85.2% of the total
phosphorous loaded from its catchment, reaching to 18.9t of annual loading on the
lake basin (Ohkubo 2008). It has been believed that the PP loaded from the
catchment quickly sinks to the coastal area and sequestered to the lake sediment as
immobile phosphorous. Our present research gave evidence that much of PP in river
waters is derived from the paddy fields during the irrigation period (Fig. 6a, b). The
sequential extraction method showed that the PP includes much of bioavailable P
(Fig. 6c), suggesting the possibility that the bioavailable P can be regenerated to the
water column after the sedimentation and thus cause eutrophication.
Phosphate oxygen isotope (δ18Op) analysis was also used to identify the source of
phosphorous loadings from the catchment of Yasu River. Although we previously had
technical problem of contamination in the process of phosphate sample purification
for the isotope analysis, we solved this problem using a modified method, except for
organic P-rich samples. We found that natural and anthropogenic P sources from this
catchment have unique isotope signatures (Fig. 7). For most of river water samples,
their δ18Op values did not reach at isotope-exchange equilibrium, suggesting that all
of loaded phosphates are not biologically recycled in stream. The δ18Op values tended
to be higher with increasing proportional area of cropland in the catchment,
suggesting that agricultural P sources are loaded on river ecosystems though they
have not yet been identified (Fig. 8).
d) Assessment of subjective well-being
We need to know social demands and concerns in order to facilitate social
involvement in community activities and solicit institutional support for these
activities from local governments. For this purpose, we conducted comprehensive
questionnaire survey on subjective well-being and ecosystem services, targeted at the
watershed society (more than 30 thousand of households). A preliminary analysis of
multilevel structural equation modelling revealed that natural and social capitals
have site-specific effects on subjective well-being.
e) Application of governance approach to other watersheds
Considering applicability of our watershed governance to developing societies
with high-loading, we conducted basic questionnaire survey on life and livelihood,
targets at three local communities from upstream, middle-stream and downstream
of the Silang-Santa Rosa sub-watershed, in which residents strongly depends on
groundwater resources for drinking and irrigation. Our nutrient research revealed
that groundwater nitrate concentration is higher than a guideline value of health risk
at a given site, possibly due to anthropogenic loadings (Fig. 10 & 11).
We also estimated in-stream nutrient uptake rate in this watershed with tracer
addition experiment (TASCC sensu Covino et al. 2010). Although most of sampling
stations show P-excess in nutrient balances, the phosphorous uptake rates were
higher by 1-3 orders than those for Yasu River. In order to examine whether such
high phosphorous uptake is specific to our study watershed or common in tropical
streams, we conducted the synoptic research on the nutrient spiral metrics in the
Marikina River sub-watershed which is located adjacent to the mega-city Manila.
f) International framework
To trace phosphorous flows in the processes of production, distribution and
consumption in a society of the Lake Biwa Watershed, we collected statistical data on
an input-output table for phosphorous flow analysis. We also have considered
feasibility to assess how much direct and indirect flows of phosphorous resources can
place environmental loadings on developing countries.
2. AMENDMENTS TO RESEARCH OBJECTIVES AND METHODS AS NECESSARY Use this section to indicate whether or not your Research Objectives and Methods have changed in light of achievements and problems confronted in the PR period. Indicate clearly where the new plan differs from that described in Form 2 (PR→FR1)
According to PEC comments, we conducted inquiry survey targeted at residents and
local governments in the Silang-Santa Rosa sub-watershed of Laguna de Bay
because our research framework of watershed governance, especially what is an
environmental issue and who are key stakeholders in this governance, is unclear.
Based on the inquiry survey, we found that they are concerned about the sustainable
use of groundwater resources and the health risk of groundwater pollution but not
about biodiversity loss emerging in this watershed. Considering priority to their life
and livelihood, thus, we partly shifted our research focus of our governance from
biodiversity to groundwater resources. In the next fiscal year, we will hold a workshop
to discuss how to solve the groundwater pollution among a variety of stakeholders in
this watershed. On one hand, we may need to take top-down approaches of
institutional and technological solutions because the magnitude and intensity of the
groundwater pollution are beyond the potential for community-based governance to
solve this issue at the watershed scale. On the other hand, we try to empower a rural
farmer community for conservation of indigenous nature in the middle stream of this
watershed, where there are some scopes for community-based solution.
3. RESEARCH PLAN Describe in detail the activities to be undertaken by the next evaluation.
1) Community-based governance in the Yasu River sub-watershed
We are going on 5 case studies of community-based governance in the Yasu River
sub-watershed. In the upstream forestry community, we are planning to conduct the
field research to examine how forest thinning can enhance nutrient cycling in the
forest floors, facilitating effective utilization of lumbers by community and out-
community members. We will apply the δ18Op technique to trace phosphate dynamics
in the soils. In the middle-stream farmer community, we will conduct the field and
laboratory experiments to examine how traditional irrigation systems can enhance
biodiversity and microbial nutrient recycling in the paddy fields, using the δ18Op
analysis. In the downstream farmer community, we will establish a method of fish
otolith Sr isotope (87Sr/86Sr) analysis to trace pelagic fish migration for spawning in
the nursery paddy fields, which can contribute to animal-driven nutrient
transportation from the lake to croplands. In the coastal community, in which lagoon
restoration is practiced, we will assess effects of fishway construction on the fish
spawning migration to this lagoon, using the fish otolith 87Sr/86Sr analysis and
environmental DNA technique. We will also conduct the field research to assess
microbial nutrient recycling in this lagoon, based on the δ18Op analysis. Also in the
coastal areas, urban and fishery communities recently suffer from macrophyte
overgrowth. We already conducted laboratory experiments to examine how
macrophyte composts can enhance microbial nutrient recycling in the cropland soils.
To facilitate social involvement in the macrophyte composts, we will hold a workshop
with a variety of stakeholders in the coastal communities.
2) Scaling-up of governance from local communities to a watershed society
We already conducted synoptic surveys to monitor spatial pattern of biodiversity
and nutrient cycling in the whole catchment of Yasu River. Based on these scientific
knowledge, we will assess public interests of conservation activities in our focal
communities, that is, how these activities contribute to nutrient recycling as one of
ecosystem services at the watershed scale. To solicit institutional support for these
community activities from local governments, we are now under construction of
institutional framework, reinforcing cooperative relationships with local
governmental sectors (Fig. 9). In order to facilitate social involvement in the
community activities as participants or green consumers, we will disseminate our
scientific knowledge on public interests yielded from these activities to the watershed
society. Prior to this action, we already conducted questionnaire survey in a whole
catchment of Yasu River to search for social demands and concerns in the watershed
society. Based on results from multilevel structural equation modelling, we are
planning to organize a watershed forum, in which we will call a variety of
stakeholders in the watershed society in order to facilitate social involvement in
community activities for biodiversity conservation and environmental restoration.
3) Application of governance approach to the Silan-Santa Rosa sub-watershed
In the previous year, we conducted stable isotope research with δ15NO3 analysis to
identify the source of nitrogen pollution and trace the nitrogen dynamics in the
Silang-Santa Rosa sub-watershed. We will hold an international workshop jointing
with the Nutrient Management Research Unit in the Philippines in March, 2017 to
discuss research progress and implementation plans for FR3. We will also hold a
workshop for residents and local governmental sectors in this watershed to discuss
the solution strategy for the nitrogen pollution.
Although we found in the previous field research that phosphorous loadings and
the resultant eutrophication are so serious in this watershed, we have not yet come
to conclusion what is the source of phosphorous pollution. That is why we are ready
to introduce the δ18Op technique to the laboratory of our counterpart, Laguna Lake
Developmental Authority, in the Philippines. We will conduct the synoptic sampling
of dissolved phosphate in river and ground waters to identify the source of
phosphorous loadings. It is challenging to conduct δ15NO3-δ18Op dual analyses, which
may enable us view the spatial pattern of phosphorous and nitrogen loadings and
thus the ecological consequences of the resultant spatial heterogeneity in nutrient
imbalances.
While we urgently need to take top-down approaches of nutrient management,
we also practice community-based governance in the middle-stream farmer
community, named Carmen Barangay, where a communal spring is managed by
community members for multipurpose use. We will conduct the action research to
empower them for conservation of this spring, which has the potential for
enhancement of well-being through accumulation of social capitals.
4. RESPONSE TO REVIEWER COMMENTS Use this section to respond to any outstanding reviewer comments (especially the comments given by PEC and the others)
As PEC pointed out, I agree that I did not sufficiently show scientific evidence in my
presentation. It might have been also unclear how biodiversity, nutrient cycling and
well-being are interdependently linked to each other in our research scheme of
watershed governance and how our comparison between the Lake Biwa and Laguna
de Bay Watershed can be extended to the global scale. In the forthcoming meeting, I
would like to improve my presentation, paying my special attention to the following
two points: 1) Research scheme of watershed governance and 2) Extension of
watershed governance to the global scale. Please see Section 1 for details of
achievements.
1) Research scheme of watershed governance
According to a working hypothesis that biodiversity, nutrient cycling and well-
being are interdependently enhanced through community activities (Fig. 1), we are
monitoring these three components at both local and watershed scales with the
progress of our watershed governance in the Yasu River sub-watershed of Lake Biwa.
At the local scale, we began with action research to empower local communities for
conservation of indigenous nature, defined as indigenous environmental icon. Based
on inquiry survey, we examined how community-based well-being is enhanced
through sharing of its cultural values among the community members and
accumulation of bonding social capitals. We are also monitoring how biodiversity and
nutrient cycling are enhanced at the local scale through the conservation activities
(subject a in Section 1).
In parallel, we conducted synoptic surveys to monitor spatial pattern of
biodiversity and nutrient cycling at the watershed scale, using some advanced
technique (b-c). Based on these results, we will assess public interests of conservation
activities, that is, how they can contribute to nutrient recycling at the watershed scale
as one of ecosystem services. To solicit local governmental support for these
community activities, we are under construction of institutional framework, while co-
working with local governmental sectors. Prior to dissemination of our scientific
knowledge on the public interests to the watershed society, it is necessary to search
for social demands and concerns related to natural and social components in the
watershed system. With this knowledge, we would like to think out how to call for
social involvement in the community activities as participants or green consumers.
For this purpose, we conducted questionnaire survey in a whole watershed to perform
multilevel structural equation modelling, by which we examine how social and
natural capitals affect subjective well-being at individual, local and watershed scales,
and what affects its site-specific pattern (d).
To facilitate linkages among local communities as well as among a variety of
stakeholders in a watershed society, we will organize a watershed forum in FR4.
Finally, we will assess how our watershed governance is effective in enhancement of
biodiversity, nutrient cycling and well-being at the watershed scale, using a scenario
model.
2) Extension of watershed governance to the global scale
In the Silang-Santa Rosa sub-watershed of Laguna de Bay, which is contrasting
to the Yasu River sub-watershed, we conducted questionnaire and inquiry surveys
targeted at residents and local governments to know their interests and concerns
about natural and social components in the watershed system. Based on these results,
we found that they are concerned about the sustainable and safety use of
groundwater resources, which are essential to their life and livelihood but whose
accessibility is limited due to overexploitation. Our nutrient research revealed that
groundwater nitrate concentration is higher than the guideline for safety drinking
waters recommended by WHO at a given site (e). Considering this result, we will
organize international and local workshops to discuss implementation plans for the
watershed governance in FR3. In FR4, we will also organize a watershed forum in
the same way as the Yasu River sub-watershed.
Through comparative approach, we will discuss applicability and limitation of our
governance approach to other watershed systems on a global scale up to FR4. For
this purpose, we will also conduct a literature survey to collect data on natural and
social properties of major watershed systems in the world and have interviews to
researchers who have practiced the watershed governance.
We are also considering extension and feasibility of phosphorous flow analysis in
a developed watershed society to assess how much direct and indirect flows of
phosphorous resources can place environmental loadings on developing watershed
societies (f)..
5. MOST NOTABLE OUTPUTS TO DATE Please provide the most notable outputs (no more than 15 outputs) below. Please note that the authors of the works to be listed here will be included in Section “7. PROJECT ORGANIZATION AND MEMBERS.” References should be consistent with the format used in the RIHN annual report. All outputs will be provided on Form2 “Outputs to Date.” Please indicate the original language if you have achievement(s) in non-English languages. Example: …(in Japanese).
Project members and core-members are underlined and double-underlined,
respectively.
1) Akamatsu F, Y. Suzuki, Y. Kato, C. Yoshimizu & I. Tayasu (2016) A comparison
of freeze-dry and oven-dry preparation methods for bulk and compound-specific
carbon stable isotope analyses: examples using the benthic macroinvertebrates
Stenopsyche marmorata and Epeorus latifolium. Rapid Commun Mass
Spectrom 30: 137-142
2) Asano, S., K. Wakita, I. Saizen & N. Okuda (2016) Can the spawn of the
Japanese brown frog (Rana japonica, Ranidae) be a local environmental index to
evaluate environmentally friendly rice paddies? The proceeding of 37th Asian
Conference on Remote Sensing Ab0263:1-9
3) Ban, S., T. Toda, K. Ishikawa & A. Kohzu (2016) Possibility of a recycling-
oriented society through sustainable utilization of aquatic weed biomass.
Journal of Environmental Conservation Engineering, 45 (9): 30-35
4) Boyero, L., R. G. Pearson, C. Hui, M. O. Gessner, J. Pérez, M. A. Alexandrou, M.
A. S. Graca, B. J. Cardinale, R. J. Albariño, M. Arunachalam, L. A. Barmuta, A.
J. Boulton, A. Bruder, M. Callisto, E. Chauvet, R. G. Death, D. Dudgeon, A. C.
Encalada, V. Ferreira, R. Figueroa, A. S. Flecker, J. F. Goncalves Jr, J. Helson, T.
Iwata, T. Jinggut, J. Mathooko, C. Mathuriau, C. M’Erimba, M. S. Moretti, C.
M. Pringle, A. Ramirez, L. Ratnarajah, J. Rincon, C. M. Yule (2016) Biotic and
abiotic variables influencing plant litter breakdown in streams: a global study.
Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 283. 20152664
5) Fujiwara Y., T. Iwata, J. Urabe & S. Takeda (2016) Life history traits and
ecological conditions influencing the symbiotic relationship between the
flatworm Stylochoplana pusilla and host snail Monodonta labio. Journal of the
Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 96 (3): 667-672
6) Ho, P.-C., N. Okuda, T. Miki, M. Itoh, F.-K. Shiah, C.-W. Chang, S. S.-Y. Hsiao,
S.-J. Kao, M. Fujibayashi & C.-H. Hsieh (2016) Summer profundal hypoxia
determines the coupling of methanotrophic production and the pelagic food web
in a subtropical reservoir. Freshwater Biology 61: 1694–1706
7) Ikeya, T. (2016) Activities for Japanese conservation area as the UNESCO
world natural heritages and biosphere reserves: Towards participatory
approach by local communities: A review. Journal of Nature Restoration and
Conservation, 8: 1, 3 – 22 (in Japanese)
8) Ishikawa N. F., H. Togashi, Y. Kato, M. Yoshimura, Y. Kohmatsu, C. Yoshimizu,
N.-O. Ogawa, N. Ohte, N. Tokuchi, N. Ohkouchi & I. Tayasu (2016) Terrestrial-
aquatic linkage on stream food webs along a forest chronosequence: multi-
isotopic evidence. Ecology 97: 1146-1158
9) Iwata, T. (2016) Methane cycling in wetlands and lakes. Kawamura, K. et al.
eds., Encyclopedia of low temperature science.Asakura Publishing, Tokyo,
pp.233-234. ISBN: 978-4-254-16128-1 (In Japanese)
10) Kawanobe, K. & T. Ikeya (2016) An examination of fixatives and sample storage
temperatures for marine phytoplankton preservation: comprehensive policies on
quality and risk control. Bull. Plankton Soc. Japan, 63: 55 - 65 (in Japanese)
11) Koyama, M., S. Yamamoto, K. Ishikawa, S. Ban & T. Toda (2016) Inhibition of
anaerobic digestion by dissolved lignin derived from alkaline pre-treatment of
an aquatic macrophyte. Chemical Engineering Journal, 311: 55-62
12) Liu, X. & S. Ban (2016) Effects of acclimatization on metabolic plasticity of
Eodiaptomus japonicus (Copepoda: Calanoida) determined using an optical
oxygen meter. Journal of Plankton Research, doi:10.1093/plankt/fbw084
13) Ohba, S., N. Okuda & S. Kudo (2016) Sexual selection of male parental care in
giant water bugs. Royal Society open science 3: 150720
14) Okuda, N., S. Asano & K. Wakita (2017) Adaptive watershed governance based
on transdisciplinary science: Biodiversity-driven nutrient cycling and human
well-being. Geography, 62 (1): 32-39 (in Japanese)
15) Tordesillas, D.T., N.K.P. Abaya, M.A.S. Dayo, L.E.B. Marquez, R.D.S. Papa & S.
Ban (2016) Effect of temperature on life history traits of the invasive calanoid
copepod Arctodiaptomus dorsalis (Marsh, 1907) from Lake Taal, Philippines.
Plankton & Benthos Research 11: 1-7
6. PROJECT ORGANIZATION AND MEMBERS Please describe the organization of the Project in one page. The possible content includes sub-groups with its brief description and names of project leader, in-house project members and project members who make significant contributions to the project. Please use “Century” in size 12 for letters to be used in description. In addition to what will be presented here, please fill out Form3 “Project members” to list all the project members.
Our project is composed of 7 discipline-based research units, which to put
forward and test working hypotheses on natural and social processes of
watershed governances, and 15 site-specific or issue-specific working groups
to co-work with a variety of stakeholders in society from local to watershed
scales (Fig. 2). Each research unit and working group has a unit leader and a
group coordinator, respectively. Core-member is composed of a project leader
(Noboru Okuda), unit leaders and executive office.
River Research Unit (Tomoya Iwata): Theoretical and empirical researches
on biodiversity and nutrient cycling in river ecosystems.
Lake Research Unit (Syuhei Ban): Theoretical and empirical researches on
biodiversity and nutrient cycling in lake and lagoon ecosystems.
Terrestrial Research Unit (Takashi Osono): Theoretical and empirical
researches on biodiversity and nutrient cycling in terrestrial ecosystems.
Analytical Research Unit (Ichiro Tayasu): Application of advanced technique
and methods to study biodiversity and nutrient cycling.
Human Research Unit (Kenichi Wakita): Social science researches on
governance, well-being and ecosystem services.
Nutrient Management Unit (Santos-Borja Adelina): Research and politics on
nutrient management to mitigate eutrophication in developing countries.
Network Research Unit (concurrently held by a project leader): Research on
ecosystem networks. It also functions to facilitate linkages among a variety
of stakeholders in society as well as to construct international networking of
governance research.
Fifteen working groups are coordinated by Satoshi Asano, Ikeya Tohru,
Takuya Ishida, Yoshitoshi Uehara, Jun Nishihiro, Hiroshi Kamiya,
Yoshimitsu Taniguchi, Kazuyo Matsubae and some of the above unit leaders.
The former four take charge of the executive office. For each working group,
details of its mission are omitted because of page space limitation.
Kirie Watanabe and Makiko Terai take a role of logistic supports and
public relations as a member of the executive office, respectively.
Fig. 1 A hypothetical schema on how biodiversity, nutrient cycling and well-being are enhanced through multi-level governance. These four gears are interdependently driven by action research to facilitate community activities at local scales. Social-ecological systems become more sustainable when these gears are accelerated for each of communities in the watershed. Processes in which each gear is driven are indicated by arrows.
Fig. 2 Research organization in which each of project members belongs to both discipline-based research units and site-specific or issue-specific working groups. The research units test the hypothesis in Fig. 1, while the working groups facilitate social involvement by a variety of stakeholders from local to watershed scales.
Bridging social capitals
Public interests
Social involvement
Assessment
Bonding social capitals
Well-beingBiodiversityCommunity
activityNutrient cycling
Environmental icon for community-based well-being
Green consuming
Institutional support
Watershed research
Local scale
Watershed scale
Dissemination
Other watersheds
Coast(Urban)
Down-stream(Shina)
Down-stream(Suhara & Awaji)
Middle-stream(Kosaji)
Discipline-based research units
Site-specificworking groups
TerrestrialRU
RiverRU
LakeRU
AnalyticalRU
NetworkRU
HumanRU
Spatial scales
Up-stream(Ohara)
Stakeholder engagement
Producer
Consumer
Company
Government
NPO&NGO Educator
NutrientManagement RU
Lake Shinji WGInba Marsh WG
Hachiro Lagoon WGLake Laguna WG
Lagoon restoration WG
Nurserypaddy field WG
MacrophyteCompost WG
SATOYAMAConservation WG
Forestconservation WG
Catchment
Nutrient flow analysis WG
Dialogue & Mutual learning
Lake BiwaWatershed Governance
method WG
Human well-being WG
Ecosystem service WG
Yasu River WG
Lake Biwa WG Lake basin
Issue-specificworking groups
7. FIGURES AND SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS Post supplementary figures, tables and pictures within five pages.
Fig 3 Spatial statistical analysis based on GIS to examine what characteristics of paddy field are preferred by brown frogs for their winter spawning in the middle-stream community (a). The location of paddy fields in which traditional irrigation systems, such as inner drainage and winter irrigation, were reintroduced for conservation of indigenous nature (b). The conservation activities were empowered after introduction of indigenous environmental
icon to this community (c). Fig. 4 A schematic view of preliminary result from text analysis based on inquiry survey targeted at farmers who practiced traditional (yellow plots) and modern (blue) irrigations. For the farmers who practiced the traditional irrigation, their subjective well-being was closely linked to natural capitals through sharing of knowledge on cultural values of indigenous environmental icon among the community member. Fig. 5 Soluble reactive phosphorous concentration in irrigation waters of paddy fields in which traditional (green) and modern (brown) irrigations were practiced.
No. of spawning
LegendInner drainage 2016
Inner drainage 2015
Inner drainage 2014Winter irrigation
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
2014 2015 2016
Winter irrigation
Inner drainage
Introduction of environmental icon
(a)
(b) (c)
FoodAmphibian
Retirement
FishLivelihood
EnvironmentPaddy field
Well-being
Nvivo ver11 Pro
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
3/31 5/1 6/1 7/2
SRP
co
nc
of
pad
dy
fiel
d w
ater
(m
mo
l L-1
)
Traditional (n=4)
Modern (n=3)Puddling Planting
Fig. 6 The map of sampling stations for sequential extraction method to isolate and quantify speciation of particulate phosphorous (PP) (a). The downstream of main stream (Y4) and two river branches (S1 and Y1), in which the proportional areas of cropland (in parentheses) in their catchment are different from each other. Seasonal pattern of PP, dissolved organic P and soluble reactive P at three stations (b). The PP was further fractionated to each phosphorous speciation in terms of bioavailability (c). NH4Cl-SRP and BD-SRP are considered bioavailable.
Y1
S1
Y4 Yasu River sub-watershedSampling stationS1 (29.7%)Y1 (13.2%)Y4 (21.6%)
(a)
Irrigation Irrigation(b)
Irrigation Irrigation(c)
Fig. 7 Phosphate oxygen isotope (δ18Op) signatures of dissolved inorganic phosphate in river waters and the potential sources of natural and anthropogenic phosphorous loadings in the Yasu River sub-watershed.
Fig. 8 The δ18Op signatures in river waters at each station with different proportional area of cropland in the catchment of Yasu River.
Fig. 9 Institutional framework of governmental support for local community activities in the Yasu River sub-watershed.
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
δ18
OPO
4 (‰
)
Temperature-dependent isotopic
exchange equilibrium
Plutonicrock
Accretionary complex
Sedimentary rock
Fertilizer
Human wastes(Expected value)
Biological recycling
Sewage treatment wastes
Anthropogenic sources Natural sources
River water
10.0
12.0
14.0
16.0
18.0
20.0
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
δ18
OPO
4(‰
)
Proportional area of cropland in catchment
Agri. SectSwage Sect. Fishery SectEnviron. Politic. Sect.
LBRI
Forestry Sect.
Environ. Conserve. Sect
Coastal
Macrophytecomposting
Nursery paddy fields
Forest conservationSATOYAMA
conservation
Down-stream
Middle-stream
Up-streamLagoonrehabilitation
NIES
GIAHS: Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems
Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry & Fisheries Ministry of Environment
Law of Lake Biwa Conservation & Rehabilitation
Municipal
Prefectural
International & National
Municipal Fishery Sect. Municipal Agri. Sect.
Fishery Exp. StationLake Biwa MuseumEnviron. Conserve.
FoundationMunicipal Forestry
Sect.Forestry Cooperative
River
LagoonCoast
Cropland
Forest
Recycling
CNPWatershed system
Fig.10 The nitrate concentration of ground waters in the Silang-Santa Rosa sub-watershed. Plot size represents its concentration. The guideline of nitrate concentration for drinking waters is set at less than 50mg/L by WHO.
Fig. 11 The nitrate nitrogen isotope ratio (δ15NO3) for ground waters in the Silang-Santa Rosa sub-watershed. The high δ15NO3 signals may be due to anthropogenic loadings and denitrification under hypoxic condition.
Year 2010
NO3- (mg/l)
Year 2010
δ15N-NO3- (‰)
Form7-4 (FR2→FR3)
FINANCIAL RESULTS AND PLANNING OF THE PROJECT (決算・予算計画書)
○ Project title:Biodiversity-driven Nutrient Cycling and Human-wellbeing in Socio-Ecological Systems
○ Project leader:OKUDA Noboru
○ Project abbreviation: e-REC Project
RESULTS Unit: 1,000JPY
Fiscal Year and Project
Stage Total
Breakdown of the Total
Facility and
Equipment Supplies Personnel Travel Honorarium Others
PR 9,313 790 1,700 2,803 2,700 470 850
FR1 68,000 3,123 12,421 18,968 9,962 1,368 22,158
FR2 64,000 5,360 10,400 22,400 12,000 1,200 12,640
PLAN
Fiscal Year and Project
Stage Total
Breakdown of the Total
Facility and
Equipment Supplies Personnel Travel Honorarium Others
FR3 64,000 1,000 10,700 22,800 12,000 2,000 15,500
FR4 56,000 0 6,200 22,800 13,000 2,000 12,000
FR5 45,000 0 2,200 22,800 11,000 1,000 8,000
ANNOTATIONS
13.OKUDA Noboru FR213.OKUDA Noboru FR2 budget