73
Indirect Costs Indirect Costs Overview Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator Cost Negotiator Division of Cost Determination/OAMS/OASAM/BOC Division of Cost Determination/OAMS/OASAM/BOC 202-693-4105; 202-693-4105; [email protected] [email protected]

Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Indirect Costs Indirect Costs OverviewOverview

Washington, D.C. - August 2008Washington, D.C. - August 2008USDOL/VETSUSDOL/VETS

Competitive Grantees Training ConferenceCompetitive Grantees Training Conference

Presented by Damon TomchickPresented by Damon TomchickCost NegotiatorCost NegotiatorDivision of Cost Division of Cost

Determination/OAMS/OASAM/BOCDetermination/OAMS/OASAM/BOC202-693-4105; 202-693-4105; [email protected]@dol.gov

Page 2: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Topics We Will CoverTopics We Will Cover

……and most importantly…and most importantly…

Answers to your questions!Answers to your questions!

Page 3: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Topics We Will CoverTopics We Will Cover

Definitions/TermsDefinitions/Terms Who needs a rate and whyWho needs a rate and why Recovery of costsRecovery of costs OMB Circular A-122 (2 CFR Part 230) – OMB Circular A-122 (2 CFR Part 230) –

general conceptsgeneral concepts Allowable, Allocable and Reasonable costsAllowable, Allocable and Reasonable costs Direct versus IndirectDirect versus Indirect Rate typesRate types Indirect Cost Rate Negotiation ProcessIndirect Cost Rate Negotiation Process Submission of ICR ProposalsSubmission of ICR Proposals Example of an ICR agreementExample of an ICR agreement

Page 4: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Some cost allocation Some cost allocation terminologyterminology

Page 5: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Total Costs Total Costs ==Direct CostsDirect Costs

PlusPlus

Indirect CostsIndirect Costs

LessLess

Applicable CreditsApplicable Credits

Page 6: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

What are direct costs?What are direct costs?

Costs that are readily identified Costs that are readily identified with a particular cost objective. with a particular cost objective.

Examples (program specific):Examples (program specific): Salaries – VETS program staffSalaries – VETS program staff Space – sq. ft. occupied by direct staffSpace – sq. ft. occupied by direct staff Supplies – used by direct staffSupplies – used by direct staff Communications – used by direct staffCommunications – used by direct staff

Page 7: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Costs that are Costs that are notnot readily readily identifiable with a particular cost identifiable with a particular cost objective. objective.

Examples:Examples: Salaries – Executive Director, Accountant, Salaries – Executive Director, Accountant,

etc.etc. Space – sq. ft. occupied by Space – sq. ft. occupied by indirect staffindirect staff Supplies – used by Supplies – used by indirect staffindirect staff Communications – used by Communications – used by indirect staffindirect staff

What are indirect What are indirect costs?costs?

Page 8: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

What are Applicable Credits?What are Applicable Credits?

Receipt or negative expenditure Receipt or negative expenditure type transactions, which offset type transactions, which offset or reduce expense items that are or reduce expense items that are allocable to grants or contracts allocable to grants or contracts as direct or indirect costs. as direct or indirect costs.

Examples include:Examples include: Purchase discounts, refunds, rebates or Purchase discounts, refunds, rebates or

allowancesallowances Sales of scrap or incidental servicesSales of scrap or incidental services Adjustments of overpayments or Adjustments of overpayments or

erroneous chargeserroneous charges

Page 9: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Which organizations need to Which organizations need to have an approved indirect have an approved indirect

cost rate?cost rate?

$ $ Single Funding Single Funding SourceSourceIndirect cost rate not Indirect cost rate not

neededneeded

$$$ $$$ Multiple Funding Multiple Funding SourcesSourcesIndirect cost rate Indirect cost rate

neededneeded

Page 10: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Which Federal Which Federal agency agency

is Cognizant?is Cognizant?

Page 11: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

For For nonprofit organizationsnonprofit organizations, , the largest dollar volume of the largest dollar volume of directdirect Federal funding is Federal funding is

normally used to determine normally used to determine the cognizant Federal the cognizant Federal agency. (This may be agency. (This may be

negotiated between Federal negotiated between Federal agencies.)agencies.)

Page 12: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

www.whitehouse.govOMB Circulars:

http://www.dol.gov/oasam/programs/boc/costdeterminationguide/main.htm

DCD’s Website:

Page 13: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator
Page 14: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Attachment AAttachment A: General Principles: General Principles

Attachment BAttachment B: Selected Items of : Selected Items of CostCost

Attachment C: Attachment C: NPs not subject to NPs not subject to this Circular this Circular

Structure of A-122 (2 CFR Part Structure of A-122 (2 CFR Part 230)230)

Page 15: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Feds bear “fair share” of costsFeds bear “fair share” of costs Provide guidelines for organizations Provide guidelines for organizations

concerning reimbursement requirementsconcerning reimbursement requirements Provide uniform standards of allowabilityProvide uniform standards of allowability Provide uniform standards of allocationProvide uniform standards of allocation Do not supersede limitations imposed by Do not supersede limitations imposed by

lawlaw Simplify intergovernmental relationsSimplify intergovernmental relations Encourage consistency in treatment of costsEncourage consistency in treatment of costs

Objectives of the Objectives of the Circular(s)Circular(s)

Page 16: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Basic premise of the Circulars:Basic premise of the Circulars:To be chargeable to a Federal To be chargeable to a Federal grant/contract, indirect costs grant/contract, indirect costs

must be:must be:

Reasonable Allocable

Allowable

Page 17: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

To be Allowable, costs To be Allowable, costs must:must:

Be reasonable and allocableBe reasonable and allocable Conform to any limitations or exclusions Conform to any limitations or exclusions

set forth in the cost principles or the awardset forth in the cost principles or the award Be consistent with policies and procedures Be consistent with policies and procedures

afforded afforded allall activities of the organization activities of the organization Be accorded consistent treatmentBe accorded consistent treatment Be determined in accordance with GAAPBe determined in accordance with GAAP Not already be included in a cost sharing Not already be included in a cost sharing

or matching requirementor matching requirement Be adequately Be adequately documenteddocumented

Page 18: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

A cost is allocable to a Federal award if it is A cost is allocable to a Federal award if it is treated consistently with other costs incurred treated consistently with other costs incurred for the same purpose in like circumstances for the same purpose in like circumstances and if it:and if it:– Is incurred specifically for the awardIs incurred specifically for the award– Benefits the award and other work and can Benefits the award and other work and can

be distributed based on be distributed based on benefits receivedbenefits received, , oror

– Is necessary for the overall operation of the Is necessary for the overall operation of the organization, although a direct relationship organization, although a direct relationship to a particular cost objective cannot be to a particular cost objective cannot be shownshown

Shifting of costs between awards to overcome Shifting of costs between awards to overcome funding deficiencies is funding deficiencies is notnot allowed allowed

Allocable CostsAllocable Costs

Page 19: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

A cost is allocable to a particular A cost is allocable to a particular cost objective in accordance with cost objective in accordance with the relativethe relative benefits received benefits received..

An allocable cost benefits a cost An allocable cost benefits a cost objective -- either objective -- either directldirectly, or y, or indirectlyindirectly..– Examples: VETS staff salaries, occupancy Examples: VETS staff salaries, occupancy

costs, Fiscal Officer’s supplies.costs, Fiscal Officer’s supplies.

Allocable Costs (cont’d)Allocable Costs (cont’d)

Page 20: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

““A cost is reasonable if, in its nature A cost is reasonable if, in its nature or amount, does not exceed that which or amount, does not exceed that which would be incurred by a prudent person would be incurred by a prudent person under the circumstances prevailing at under the circumstances prevailing at the time the decision was made to the time the decision was made to incur the costs.”incur the costs.”

Some considerations might be:Some considerations might be:– Effect on Federal program dollarsEffect on Federal program dollars– Prudence under the circumstancesPrudence under the circumstances– Deviations from established practicesDeviations from established practices

Reasonable CostsReasonable Costs

Page 21: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Unallowable CostsUnallowable Costs

– Specifically identified in the Specifically identified in the grant/contract as being unallowablegrant/contract as being unallowable

– Specifically identified in Circular A-Specifically identified in Circular A-122 as being unallowable122 as being unallowable

– Does not meet the criteria listed in Does not meet the criteria listed in Circular A-122 to be allowableCircular A-122 to be allowable

Page 22: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Documentation for Documentation for CompensationCompensation

Because it’s usually the largest item Because it’s usually the largest item of administrative direct/indirect cost of administrative direct/indirect cost under any given DOL grant/contractunder any given DOL grant/contract

Because it is so often the subject of Because it is so often the subject of audit questioned costsaudit questioned costs

Why emphasize this?

Page 23: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Must be reasonable and in accord Must be reasonable and in accord with established practicewith established practice

Must be supported in accordance Must be supported in accordance with applicable Circular subsections with applicable Circular subsections (support of salaries and wages)(support of salaries and wages)

Compensation forCompensation forPersonnel ServicesPersonnel Services

Page 24: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Charges to Federal awards must beCharges to Federal awards must be::

– Based on documented payroll, Based on documented payroll, approved by a responsible, or an approved by a responsible, or an authorized, official of the organizationauthorized, official of the organization

– Supported by Personnel Activity Supported by Personnel Activity Reports (PAR, aka, time distribution Reports (PAR, aka, time distribution report)report)

Compensation forCompensation forPersonnel Services(cont’d)Personnel Services(cont’d)

Page 25: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

PARs must meet the following PARs must meet the following standards:standards:– Reflect after-the-fact distribution of effortReflect after-the-fact distribution of effort– Must account for total activity for which the Must account for total activity for which the

employee is compensatedemployee is compensated– Must be signed by the employeeMust be signed by the employee– Be prepared at least monthly and coincide Be prepared at least monthly and coincide

with one or more pay periodswith one or more pay periods

Compensation forCompensation forPersonnel Services(cont’d)Personnel Services(cont’d)

Page 26: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

– PAR standards will apply where PAR standards will apply where employees work on...employees work on...

Compensation forCompensation forPersonnel Services(cont’d)Personnel Services(cont’d)

Page 27: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

More than one Federal More than one Federal awardaward

Employee

HUDGran

t

VETSGrant

Page 28: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

A Federal award and a A Federal award and a non-Federal awardnon-Federal award

Employee

VETSGrant

StateProgram

Page 29: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

An indirect cost activity An indirect cost activity and a direct cost activityand a direct cost activity

Employee

AccountantCDBG

Accountant

Page 30: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Two or more indirect activities Two or more indirect activities which are allocated using different which are allocated using different

allocation basesallocation bases

Employee

AccountantBudgetAnalyst

Page 31: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

An unallowable activity An unallowable activity and a direct or indirect and a direct or indirect

cost activitycost activityEmployee

CFOLegislative

Liaison

(Lobbying Activity)

Page 32: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

What is a Cost Allocation What is a Cost Allocation Plan?Plan?

A document that identifies and A document that identifies and explains, the distribution of explains, the distribution of allowable direct and indirect allowable direct and indirect costs, and declares the allocation costs, and declares the allocation methods used for distribution.methods used for distribution.

Federally-approved

Cost Allocation Plan

Page 33: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

What is an Indirect Cost What is an Indirect Cost Rate?Rate?

A ratio (whereby an indirect cost pool is A ratio (whereby an indirect cost pool is divided by a direct cost base), which divided by a direct cost base), which is then expressed as a percentage. is then expressed as a percentage.

Page 34: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Pool

Base = Rate

How to compute an

indirect cost rate

Page 35: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Indirect Cost RateIndirect Cost Rate

ExampleExample

Indirect Cost Pool =Indirect Cost Pool = $ 10,000 $ 10,000

Distribution Base =Distribution Base = $100,000 $100,000(Salaries & Benefits)(Salaries & Benefits)

Indirect Cost Rate =Indirect Cost Rate = 10%10%

Page 36: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

What purposes are served What purposes are served by having the rate?by having the rate?

Compliance with Federal Compliance with Federal regulations; e.g., OMB regulations; e.g., OMB Circulars A-122, A-87 & A-21Circulars A-122, A-87 & A-21

Management InformationManagement Information

Documentation for auditorsDocumentation for auditors

Page 37: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Indirect Cost RateIndirect Cost RateCommon Allocation BasesCommon Allocation Bases

Direct S/W including FBDirect S/W including FB

Direct S/W including release time, Direct S/W including release time, but excluding all other FBbut excluding all other FB

Modified Total Direct Cost (various)Modified Total Direct Cost (various)– Total Direct Costs excluding capital Total Direct Costs excluding capital

expenditures and flow-through expenditures and flow-through fundingfunding

Page 38: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Indirect Cost Rate Calculation/Distribution Using "Total Direct Salaries"as the Allocation Base

All OtherTotal Unallowable Indirect Total FundingCosts Costs Costs Direct VETS Sources

A=(B+C+D) B C D=E+F E F

Salaries $589,000 $70,000 $519,000 $219,000 $300,000Benefits $176,700 $21,000 $155,700 $65,700 $90,000Other Costs $171,000 $10,000 $59,000 $102,000 $40,000 $62,000

Total $936,700 * $10,000 $150,000 $776,700 $324,700 a $452,000

Indirect Costs $150,000 $63,295 b $86,705Total Direct Salaries $519,000Indirect Rate 28.9%

Total Costs per Cost Center $387,995 a+b $538,705

Page 39: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Indirect Cost Rate Calculation/Distribution Using "Total Direct Costs"as the Allocation Base

All OtherTotal Unallowable Indirect Total FundingCosts Costs Costs Direct VETS Sources

A=(B+C+D) B C D=E+F E F

Salaries $589,000 $70,000 $519,000 $219,000 $300,000Benefits $176,700 $21,000 $155,700 $65,700 $90,000Other Costs $171,000 $10,000 $59,000 $102,000 $40,000 $62,000

Total $936,700 * $10,000 $150,000 $776,700 $324,700 a $452,000

Indirect Costs $150,000 $62,708 b $87,292Total Direct Costs $776,700Indirect Rate 19.3%

Total Costs per Cost Center $387,408 a+b $539,292

* Must reconcile to the Financial Statements.

Page 40: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Cost Allocation versus

Cost Reimbursement

Two Separate Concepts…

Page 41: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Cost AllocationCost Allocation Cost allocation is the measurement of Cost allocation is the measurement of

allowable costs that are then allocated allowable costs that are then allocated based on based on benefits receivedbenefits received by each by each program/agency.program/agency.

Use A-122, A-87, A-21 guidelines in the Use A-122, A-87, A-21 guidelines in the cost allocation process.cost allocation process.

The cost principles provide the guidance The cost principles provide the guidance for determining a Federal program’s share for determining a Federal program’s share of both direct and indirect costs. of both direct and indirect costs. They They have no authority over the actual payment have no authority over the actual payment of the costs. The payment is governed by of the costs. The payment is governed by the terms of the grant document or the the terms of the grant document or the legislation authorizing the program.legislation authorizing the program.

Page 42: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Cost ReimbursementCost Reimbursement Cost reimbursement is the process Cost reimbursement is the process

where Federal dollars are used to where Federal dollars are used to reimburse grantee organizations for reimburse grantee organizations for allowable costs.allowable costs.

Use grant language/cost limitations Use grant language/cost limitations

and legislative constraints as and legislative constraints as guidelines in the payment process.guidelines in the payment process.

Page 43: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Methods of CalculationMethods of Calculation Simplified MethodSimplified Method

– Federal awards are not materialFederal awards are not material

– Organization has only a single functionOrganization has only a single function

– All programs benefit from indirect costs All programs benefit from indirect costs

to about the same degreeto about the same degree

Page 44: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Methods of Calculation Methods of Calculation (cont’d)(cont’d)

Multiple Allocation BaseMultiple Allocation Base

– All programs do not benefit to the All programs do not benefit to the same degreesame degree

– Indirect costs are pooled and allocated Indirect costs are pooled and allocated to direct cost objectives based on to direct cost objectives based on various distribution bases (for various distribution bases (for example, # of transactions, # of example, # of transactions, # of purchase orders, # of FTE’s)purchase orders, # of FTE’s)

– Primarily used by A-87 organizations Primarily used by A-87 organizations that capture costs by department or that capture costs by department or division (for example, accounting, division (for example, accounting, purchasing, personnel, etc.)purchasing, personnel, etc.)

Page 45: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Methods of Calculation Methods of Calculation (cont’d)(cont’d)

Direct Allocation MethodDirect Allocation Method

– All costs are charged directly to programs to All costs are charged directly to programs to except for general administrationexcept for general administration

– Preferred method used by a majority of Preferred method used by a majority of nonprofit organizationsnonprofit organizations

– Various bases are selected to “directly Various bases are selected to “directly allocate” costs to programs(for example, allocate” costs to programs(for example, space allocated based on square footage space allocated based on square footage occupied)occupied)

– See DCD website for guide to this methodSee DCD website for guide to this method

Page 46: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Allocation of CostsAllocation of Costs

Any methodAny method of distribution can of distribution can be used if it results in an be used if it results in an equitable distribution of costs equitable distribution of costs based on based on “benefits received”“benefits received”..

Page 47: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

What’s Allocable?What’s Allocable?

T ypica l N onprofit C orpora tion, Inc.

F isca l O ffice r S ec /R ecep t

H U DP rog ram s

D O LP rog ram s

N on -F ed era lP rog ram s

O p era tin g P rog ram s

E xecu tiveD irec to r

Pool

Base

Typical Non-Profit Organization

Page 48: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

AllocationAllocation involves assigning costs to involves assigning costs to the benefiting objective(s) equitably. the benefiting objective(s) equitably. This process is This process is covered by A-87, A-122 covered by A-87, A-122 and other cost principles.and other cost principles.

ClassificationClassification of costs involves placing of costs involves placing costs into some category such as costs into some category such as administration, program, or some administration, program, or some other category as other category as prescribed by prescribed by statutestatute..

Allocation versus ClassificationAllocation versus Classification

Page 49: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Direct vs. Indirect CostsDirect vs. Indirect Costs

The decision to treat a cost as either a The decision to treat a cost as either a direct direct costcost or an indirect costs depends or an indirect costs depends upon the treatment of that cost within upon the treatment of that cost within the grantee's accounting system.the grantee's accounting system.

Cost Policy Statements (CPS) provide Cost Policy Statements (CPS) provide documentation on how the grantee documentation on how the grantee treats costs within the accounting treats costs within the accounting system.system.

Page 50: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Direct vs. Indirect CostsDirect vs. Indirect Costs

Ind S/WSuppliesSpace

Program S/WSuppliesSpace

T ypica l N onprofit C orpora tion, Inc.

F isca l O ffice r S ec /R ecep t

H U DP rog ram s

D O LP rog ram s

N on -F ed era lP rog ram s

O p era tin g P rog ram s

E xecu tiveD irec to r

Typical Non-Profit Organization

Page 51: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Types of Indirect Cost RatesTypes of Indirect Cost Rates

Page 52: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Types of Indirect Cost Rates Types of Indirect Cost Rates (cont’d)(cont’d)

BillingBilling CeilingCeiling ProvisionalProvisional FinalFinal FixedFixed PredeterminePredetermine

dd

Hmmm?

Page 53: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Billing RateBilling Rate

Rate stated in the award to allow Rate stated in the award to allow recovery of indirect costs until an recovery of indirect costs until an indirect cost proposal is completed indirect cost proposal is completed and submitted. and submitted.

Normally only valid for 90 days.Normally only valid for 90 days.

Page 54: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Ceiling RateCeiling Rate

Set by the Contract/Grant OfficerSet by the Contract/Grant Officer

The maximum rate at which The maximum rate at which indirect costs may be recovered indirect costs may be recovered under a particular awardunder a particular award

Page 55: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Provisional RateProvisional Rate

A rate based on projected information, A rate based on projected information, historical information, or a combination historical information, or a combination of the two for the organization’s fiscal of the two for the organization’s fiscal yearyear

This rate allows for recovery of indirect This rate allows for recovery of indirect costs during the contract/grant period costs during the contract/grant period until the rate can be finalizeduntil the rate can be finalized

Page 56: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Final RateFinal Rate

The experienced indirect cost rate The experienced indirect cost rate based on actual data for the based on actual data for the organization’s fiscal yearorganization’s fiscal year

All provisional indirect cost rates All provisional indirect cost rates must eventually be “finalized”must eventually be “finalized”

Page 57: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Fixed RateFixed Rate A permanent rate that is not subject to A permanent rate that is not subject to

changechange

Any differences between estimated and Any differences between estimated and actual costs are carried forward as actual costs are carried forward as adjustments to rate computations in adjustments to rate computations in future periodsfuture periods

Seldom issued to nonprofit Seldom issued to nonprofit organizationsorganizations

Page 58: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Predetermined RatePredetermined Rate

A rate negotiated for a certain A rate negotiated for a certain length of time, usually several length of time, usually several yearsyears

Not subject to changeNot subject to change

Page 59: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Indirect Cost ClauseIndirect Cost Clause XI. XI. INDIRECT CHARGESINDIRECT CHARGES This clause is applicable to all entities This clause is applicable to all entities (non-profit, for-profit (non-profit, for-profit

organizations, and State and local organizations, etc.)organizations, and State and local organizations, etc.) receiving Federal cost reimbursable grants or contracts. receiving Federal cost reimbursable grants or contracts. Indirect cost charges should be based on allowable, allocable, Indirect cost charges should be based on allowable, allocable, and reasonable costs based on the applicable cost principlesand reasonable costs based on the applicable cost principles [1][1]. It is important to highlight the submission requirements of . It is important to highlight the submission requirements of indirect cost proposals. As an example, OMB Circular A-122, indirect cost proposals. As an example, OMB Circular A-122, Attachment A, Section E. 2. Negotiation and Approval of Attachment A, Section E. 2. Negotiation and Approval of Indirect Rates, states:Indirect Rates, states:

– - - A non-profit organization which has not previously established an indirect cost A non-profit organization which has not previously established an indirect cost raterate with a Federal agency with a Federal agency shallshall submit its initial indirect cost proposal immediately after submit its initial indirect cost proposal immediately after the organization is advised that an award will be made and, the organization is advised that an award will be made and, in no event, later than three in no event, later than three monthsmonths after the effective date of the award. after the effective date of the award.

– - - Organizations that have previously established indirect cost ratesOrganizations that have previously established indirect cost rates mustmust submit submit a new indirect cost proposal to the cognizant agencya new indirect cost proposal to the cognizant agency[2][2] within six months after the close within six months after the close of each fiscal yearof each fiscal year..

Negotiated Indirect Cost Rate Agreements (NICRAs) are used to support Negotiated Indirect Cost Rate Agreements (NICRAs) are used to support indirect cost claims. These documents indirect cost claims. These documents should be current at the time of should be current at the time of the award (See statement on “Adequate NICRAs” further below). The the award (See statement on “Adequate NICRAs” further below). The final rates in the NICRAs are used for “close-out” purposesfinal rates in the NICRAs are used for “close-out” purposes. .

[1][1] OMB Circular A-122 for non-profit organizations or OMB Circular A-87 for State and local OMB Circular A-122 for non-profit organizations or OMB Circular A-87 for State and local organizations available at: organizations available at: http://http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars/index.htmlwww.whitehouse.gov/omb/circulars/index.html; Federal Acquisition ; Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 31.2 for for-profit organizations available at Regulations, Part 31.2 for for-profit organizations available at http://http://www.arnet.govwww.arnet.gov/far//far/..[2][2] Federal agency providing the preponderance of direct Federal funds. Federal agency providing the preponderance of direct Federal funds.

Page 60: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Submission of IndirectSubmission of IndirectCost Rate ProposalsCost Rate Proposals

Proposals must be submitted annuallyProposals must be submitted annually

– New grantees must submit within New grantees must submit within three months after the effective date three months after the effective date of the award of the award

– No later than six months after the No later than six months after the end of the organization’s fiscal yearend of the organization’s fiscal year

– Extensions of time may be grantedExtensions of time may be granted

(continued)

Page 61: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Submission of IndirectSubmission of IndirectCost Rate ProposalsCost Rate Proposals

Organizational ChartOrganizational Chart Cost Policy StatementCost Policy Statement Financial ReportsFinancial Reports Personnel Cost WorksheetPersonnel Cost Worksheet Allocation of Personnel Allocation of Personnel

CostsCosts

(continued)

Page 62: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Submission of IndirectSubmission of IndirectCost Rate ProposalsCost Rate Proposals

Statement of Employee BenefitsStatement of Employee Benefits

Indirect Cost Rate Proposal(s) reconciled Indirect Cost Rate Proposal(s) reconciled with the financial reports, audit report or with the financial reports, audit report or budgetbudget

A completed Certificate of Indirect Costs A completed Certificate of Indirect Costs (must be signed and dated!)(must be signed and dated!)

A listing of grants and contracts showing A listing of grants and contracts showing source, amounts, and relevant datessource, amounts, and relevant dates

Page 63: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Example of a Negotiated Example of a Negotiated IndirectIndirect

Cost Rate Agreement (NICRA)Cost Rate Agreement (NICRA)

Page 64: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

(An Example)NEGOTIATED INDIRECT COST RATE AGREEMENT

NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION

ORGANIZATION: DATE: December 1, 200X XYZ Nonprofit Agency, Inc. FILE REF: This replaces the Podunk, AL 99999-9999 negotiation agreement dated October 12, 200X October 30, 2000

The indirect cost rate(s) contained herein are for use on grantsand contracts with the Federal Government to which OMBCircular A-122 applies subject to the limitations contained in the Circular and Section II-A, below. The rate(s) were negotiated by XYZ Nonprofit Agency, Inc. and the U. S. Departmentof Labor in accordance with the authority contained in Attachment A,Section E, of the Circular.

Page 65: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Final 7/1/0X 6/30/0X 14.25% All All Programs

Final 7/1/0X 6/30/0X 15.25% All All Programs

Provisional 7/1/0X 6/30/0X 17.17% All All Programs

Provisional 7/1/0X 6/30/0X 16.43% All All Programs (See Special Remarks)

The indirect cost rate(s) contained herein are for use on grantsand contracts with the Federal Government to which OMBCircular A-122 applies subject to the limitations contained in the Circular and Section II-A, below. The rate(s) were negotiated by XYZ Nonprofit Agency, Inc. and the U. S. Departmentof Labor in accordance with the authority contained in Attachment A,Section E, of the Circular.

Effective Period

Type From To Rate * Location Applicable to

Page 66: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

BASE * : Total direct salaries and wages including vacation, holiday and sickpay but excluding all other fringe benefits.

TREATMENT OF FRINGE BENEFITS:

Fringe benefits are specifically identified to each employee and arecharged individually as direct costs. The directly claimed fringebenefits are listed in the Special Remarks Section of this Agreement.

TREATMENT OF PAID ABSENCES:

Vacation, holiday, sick leave and other paid absences are includedin salaries and wages and are claimed on grants, contracts andother agreements as part of the normal cost for salaries and wages. Separate claims for these absences are not made.

Page 67: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

A. LIMITATIONS: Use of the rate(s) contained in this Agreement is subject to any statutory or administrative limitations and is applicable to a given grant or contract only to the extent that funds are available. Acceptance of the rate(s) agreed to herein is predicated upon the following conditions:(1) that no costs other than those incurred by the grantee/contractor or allocated to the grantee/contractor via an approved central service cost allocation plan were included in its indirect cost pool as finally accepted and that such incurred costs are legal obligations of the grantee/contractor and allowable under the governing cost principles,(2) that the same costs that have been treated as indirect costs have not been claimed as direct costs,(3) that similar types of costs have been accorded consistent treatment, and(4) that the information provided by the grantee/contractor which was used as a basis for acceptance of the rate(s) agreed to herein is not subsequently found to be materially inaccurate.The elements of indirect cost and the type of distribution base(s) used in computing provisional rates are subject to revision when final rates are negotiated. Also, the rates cited in this Agreement are subject to audit.

Page 68: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

B. CHANGES: The grantee/contractor is required to providewritten notification to the indirect cost negotiator prior to implementing any changes which could affect the applicability of the approved rates. Changes in the indirect cost recovery plan, which may result from changes such as the method of accounting or organizational structure, require the prior written approval of the Division of Cost Determination (DCD). Failure to obtain such approval may result in subsequent cost disallowance.

C. NOTIFICATION TO FEDERAL AGENCIES: A copy of this document is to be provided by this organization to other Federal funding sources as a means of notifying them of the Agreement contained herein.

Page 69: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

D. PROVISIONAL-FINAL RATES: The grantee/contractor must submit a proposal to establish a final rate within six months after their fiscal year end. Billings and charges to Federal awards must be adjusted if the final rate varies from the provisional rate. If the final rate is greater than the provisional rate and there are no funds available to cover the additional indirect costs, the organization may not recover all indirect costs. Conversely, if the final rate is less than the provisional rate, the organization will be required to pay back the difference to the funding agency.

Indirect costs allocable to a particular award or other cost objective may not be shifted to other Federal awards to overcome funding deficiencies, or to avoid restrictions imposed by law or by the terms of the award.

Page 70: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

E. SPECIAL REMARKS:

1. Indirect costs charged to Federal grants/contracts by means other than the rate(s) cited in this Agreement should be adjusted to the applicable rate cited herein and applied to the appropriate base to identify the proper amount of indirect costs allocable to the program.

2. Grants/contracts providing for ceilings as to the indirect cost rates(s) or amount(s) which are indicated in Section I above, will be subject to the ceilings stipulated in the contract or grant agreements. The ceiling rate or the rate(s) cited in this Agreement, whichever is lower, will be used to determine the maximum allowable indirect cost on the grant or contract agreement.

Page 71: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

3. Fringe benefits other than paid absences consist of:Worker's Compensation FICAHealth Insurance Pension PlanUnemployment Compensation

4. XYZ Nonprofit Agency, Inc. staff maintain 100% time distribution records. The indirect cost pool consists of: a) Salaries and fringe benefits of the following

positions: Executive Director Dir of Fiscal Svcs Account Tech II Admin Secretary

b) Support costs of the above positions as follows: Professional Services Travel Space Supplies Equipment Leases Insurance & Bonding Publications & Dues Repairs &

Maintenance Communications Postage Miscellaneous

Page 72: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

ACCEPTANCE

BY THE COGNIZANT AGENCY BY THE ORGANIZATION: ON BEHALF OF THE FED GOV: XYZ Nonprofit Agency, Inc. U. S. Department of Labor (Organization) (Agency)

(Signature) (Signature)Jane Doe Victor M. Lopez (Name) (Name)

Executive Director Chief, Division of Cost Determination (Title) (Title)December 1, 2006 December 1, 200X (Date) (Date) Negotiator: Damon Tomchick Telephone No.: (202)693-4105

Page 73: Indirect Costs Overview Washington, D.C. - August 2008 USDOL/VETS Competitive Grantees Training Conference Presented by Damon Tomchick Cost Negotiator

Questions?