1
U(D54G1D)y+"!&!@!=!/ WASHINGTON — President Obama on Tuesday commuted all but four months of the remaining prison sentence of Chelsea Man- ning, the Army intelligence ana- lyst convicted of a 2010 leak that revealed American military and diplomatic activities across the world, disrupted Mr. Obama’s ad- ministration and brought global prominence to WikiLeaks, the re- cipient of those disclosures. The decision by Mr. Obama res- cued Ms. Manning, who twice tried to kill herself last year, from an uncertain future as a transgen- der woman incarcerated at the men’s military prison at Fort Leavenworth, Kan. She has been jailed for nearly seven years, and her 35-year sentence was by far the longest punishment ever im- posed in the United States for a leak conviction. At the same time that Mr. Obama commuted the sentence of Ms. Manning, a low-ranking en- listed soldier at the time of her leaks, he also pardoned James E. Cartwright, the retired Marine general and former vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff who pleaded guilty to lying about his conversations with reporters to F.B.I. agents investigating a leak of classified information about cyberattacks on Iran’s nuclear program. [Page A3.] The two acts of clemency were a remarkable final step for a presi- dent whose administration car- ried out an unprecedented crimi- nal crackdown on leaks of govern- ment secrets. Depending on how they are counted, the Obama ad- ministration has prosecuted ei- ther nine or 10 such cases, more than were charged under all pre- vious presidencies combined. In addition, Mr. Obama on Tues- day commuted the sentence of Os- car Lopez Rivera, who was part of a Puerto Rican nationalist group that carried out a string of bomb- ings in the late 1970s and early 1980s; the other members of that group had long since been freed. Mr. Obama also granted 63 other pardons and 207 other commuta- tions, mostly for drug offenders. Under the terms of the commu- tation announced by the White House on Tuesday, Ms. Manning is set to be freed on May 17 of this year rather than in 2045. A senior administration official said the 120-day delay was part of a stand- ard transition period for commu- tations to time served, and was de- signed to allow for such steps as finding a place for Ms. Manning to live after her release. The commutation also relieved the Defense Department of the difficult responsibility of Ms. Man- ning’s incarceration as she pushes for treatment for her gender dys- phoria, including sex reassign- ment surgery, that the military has no experience providing. But the move was sharply criti- cized by several prominent Re- publicans, including the chairmen of the House and Senate armed services committees, Representa- tive Mac Thornberry of Texas and Senator John McCain of Arizona, who called her leaks “espionage” OBAMA COMMUTES MANNING’S TERM IN U.S. LEAK CASE Ex-Army Analyst’s Sentence Ran to 2045 — A Retired General Is Pardoned By CHARLIE SAVAGE Chelsea Manning U.S. ARMY, VIA ASSOCIATED PRESS Continued on Page A3 WASHINGTON Eighteen million people could lose their in- surance within a year and individ- ual insurance premiums would shoot upward if Congress re- pealed major provisions of the Af- fordable Care Act while leaving other parts in place, the nonparti- san Congressional Budget Office said on Tuesday. A report by the office sharply in- creases pressure on Republicans to come up with a comprehensive plan to replace the health care law. It is likely to doom the idea of vot- ing to dismantle the 2010 health law almost immediately, with an effective date set sometime in the future while Congress works to- ward a replacement. If nothing followed the gutting of President Obama’s signature domestic achievement, the budg- et office said, 32 million people could lose their health insurance by 2026, and premiums in the indi- vidual insurance market could double. Senator Susan Collins, Re- publican of Maine, showed the un- ease of some in her party when she said that repealing the health care law and delaying a replace- ment could send insurance mar- kets into “a death spiral.” She detected “a growing con- sensus among members of both the Senate and the House that we must fix Obamacare and provide reforms at nearly the same time that we repeal the law,” she said on the Senate floor on Tuesday. The new budget office report, issued after a weekend of protests against repeal, will only add to the headaches that President-elect Donald J. Trump and congres- sional Republicans face in their rush to take apart Mr. Obama’s Pressure on G.O.P. as Repeal May Strip Millions of Coverage By ROBERT PEAR Senator Susan Collins AL DRAGO/THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page A16 WASHINGTON — In one way at least, President-elect Donald J. Trump has already surpassed all of his recent predecessors. It took Barack Obama 18 months in the White House for his approval rating to slip to 44 percent in Gallup polling, and it took George W. Bush 4½ years to fall that far. Mr. Trump got there before even being sworn in. Indeed, Mr. Trump will take office on Friday with less popular support than any new president in modern times, according to an array of surveys, a sign that he has failed to rally Americans behind him, beyond the base that helped him win in November. Rather than a unifying moment, his transition to power has seen a continuation of the polarization of the election last year. Where other presidents used the weeks before their inaugura- tion to put the animosities of the campaign behind them and to try to knit the country together again, Mr. Trump has ap- proached the interregnum as if he were a television wrestling star. He has taken on a civil rights icon, a Hollywood actress, intelligence agencies, defense contractors, European leaders and President Obama. The heal- ing theme common at this stage in the four-year presidential cycle is absent. “He seems to want to engage with every windmill that he can find, rather than focus on the large aspect of assuming the Trump Enters Office Unbent And Disliked Lowest Rating Ever For a New President WHITE HOUSE MEMO By PETER BAKER DOCTORS WITHOUT BORDERS, VIA ASSOCIATED PRESS Dozens were killed and hundreds hurt Tuesday in a mistake by the Nigerian military. Page A4. Hunting Militants, Hitting Refugees DAVOS, Switzerland — In a world troubled by grave uncer- tainties over the basics govern- ing trade, security and the mis- sion to limit climate change, President Xi Jinping of China on Tuesday portrayed his nation as a responsible global citizen dedi- cated to furthering international integration. That a leader of the People’s Republic of China can stake a claim to the mantle of leadership in the realm of free trade speaks to the unforeseen, even surreal alteration of the global order in recent months. His message, delivered here in the Swiss Alps at the annual gathering of the World Economic Forum, appeared meticulously timed to the tumultuous moment at hand. He was speaking three days before Donald J. Trump was to be inaugurated president of the United States, raising the prospect of a trade war with China, and on the same day that Prime Minister Theresa May of Britain outlined plans to pursue her country’s departure from the European Union. The Chinese leader used his Xi Casts China As Champion Of Openness By PETER S. GOODMAN Continued on Page B5 NEWS ANALYSIS LONDON — “Get on with it.” With those words early in a ma- jor speech on Tuesday, Prime Min- ister Theresa May charted Brit- ain’s course toward a clean break with the European Union and ex- pressed her fondest hope: that the time for “division and discord” is over. Her much-anticipated speech outlined what promised to be a hugely complex, drawn-out nego- tiation, and it defined the broad objectives, but not the details, of British withdrawal. “The United Kingdom is leaving the European Union, and my job is to get the right deal for Britain as we do,” she said. With the address, Mrs. May be- gan the jockeying that will lead to a break after more than four dec- ades of tight integration, and de- fine Britain’s relations with its neighbors for decades to come. She confirmed that Britain is determined to regain control of migration from the European Un- ion and rejected the supremacy of the European Court of Justice. That stance is anathema to the European Union, which has made the free movement of people — as well as goods, capital and services — a bedrock principle and which British Premier Outlines Path To a Clean Break With the E.U. By STEPHEN CASTLE and STEVEN ERLANGER Regaining control of immigration was one objective laid out by Prime Minister Theresa May in Tuesday’s “Brexit” speech. MATT DUNHAM/ASSOCIATED PRESS Continued on Page A9 WASHINGTON When Speaker Paul D. Ryan needed to stop rebellious fellow Republicans from defanging a popular con- gressional ethics watchdog office this month, he called a friend from Wisconsin, Reince Priebus, the in- coming White House chief of staff, for some stealthy help. Mr. Ryan asked Mr. Priebus, the congenial and cunning chairman of the Republican National Com- mittee, for a favor: Could Presi- dent-elect Donald J. Trump inter- vene? At the urging of Mr. Priebus, Mr. Trump quickly posted a pair of scolding posts on Twitter: Did Congress really have to make the gutting of the popular Office of Congressional Ethics “their num- ber one act and priority?” he asked, quickly bringing the insur- rection to a messy but welcome end for Mr. Ryan. This is the way that many main- G.O.P. Hopes A Chief of Staff Brings Stability By GLENN THRUSH and MAGGIE HABERMAN Continued on Page A14 By promoting plans to add jobs in the United States, companies are hoping to curry favor with the Trump administration. Page A16. Jobs as Political Capital Continued on Page A14 Hidden for more than 70 years in the muck of a Nazi death camp in Po- land, a pendant has been traced to a 14- year-old victim. And it is almost identical to one Anne Frank owned. PAGE A9 INTERNATIONAL A4-9 A Pendant’s Story of Loss Late Edition VOL. CLXVI . . . No. 57,481 + © 2017 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 18, 2017 Barack Obama began his presidency with bold strokes, but his aspirations later were checked by a Republican Congress. Sixth in a series. PAGES A12-13 NATIONAL A10-18 The Obama Era The prosecution said Noor Salman knew of her husband’s plan to attack an Orlando, Fla., nightclub. PAGE A10 Wife of Mass Killer Is Charged Despite being the betting favorite in 15 of 16 N.F.L. games this season, New Eng- land beat the spread 13 times. PAGE B8 SPORTSWEDNESDAY B8-12 Smart Money Takes Patriots Mark Zuckerberg denied that Oculus, a virtual reality company acquired by Facebook, stole technology. PAGE B1 BUSINESS DAY B1-7 Facebook Chief Testifies With just days left, President Obama must decide whether to go ahead and arm Syrian Kurds against ISIS or leave the issue to the next president. PAGE A8 Obama’s Options on Syria Ichiran, a Japa- nese restaurant in Brooklyn, offers “flavor concentration booths,” where diners can enjoy their soup in solitude. PAGE D7 FOOD D1-8 Ruminating on Ramen Frank Bruni PAGE A23 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A22-23 Rebekah Mercer, a Museum of Natural History trustee, donates to groups skeptical of climate change. PAGE C1 ARTS C1-7 Science, Money and Politics The dissident performer Pyotr Pavlen- sky says he will seek asylum. PAGE C1 Russian Artist Flees to France Governor Cuomo unveiled his $152 billion plan through a series of closed- door meetings with senators. PAGE A19 NEW YORK A19-21 State Budget’s Quiet Rollout A horse with a black jockey, trainer and owners won a top race on Martin Luther King’s Birthday. Left, co-owner Gaston Grant. PAGE A19 Victory Carries Extra Weight Today, morning fog, some rain early, cloudy, high 45. Tonight, clouds breaking, low 38. Tomorrow, partly sunny, mild, light wind, high 50. Weather map appears on Page C8. $2.50

IN U.S. LEAK CASE MANNING S TERM OBAMA COMMUTES · the White House for his approval rating to slip to 44 percent in Gallup polling, and it took George W. Bush 4½ years to fall that

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: IN U.S. LEAK CASE MANNING S TERM OBAMA COMMUTES · the White House for his approval rating to slip to 44 percent in Gallup polling, and it took George W. Bush 4½ years to fall that

C M Y K Nxxx,2017-01-18,A,001,Bs-4C,E2_+

U(D54G1D)y+"!&!@!=!/

WASHINGTON — PresidentObama on Tuesday commuted allbut four months of the remainingprison sentence of Chelsea Man-ning, the Army intelligence ana-lyst convicted of a 2010 leak thatrevealed American military anddiplomatic activities across theworld, disrupted Mr. Obama’s ad-ministration and brought globalprominence to WikiLeaks, the re-cipient of those disclosures.

The decision by Mr. Obama res-cued Ms. Manning, who twicetried to kill herself last year, froman uncertain future as a transgen-der woman incarcerated at themen’s military prison at FortLeavenworth, Kan. She has beenjailed for nearly seven years, andher 35-year sentence was by farthe longest punishment ever im-posed in the United States for aleak conviction.

At the same time that Mr.Obama commuted the sentence ofMs. Manning, a low-ranking en-listed soldier at the time of herleaks, he also pardoned James E.Cartwright, the retired Marinegeneral and former vice chairmanof the Joint Chiefs of Staff whopleaded guilty to lying about hisconversations with reporters toF.B.I. agents investigating a leakof classified information aboutcyberattacks on Iran’s nuclearprogram. [Page A3.]

The two acts of clemency were aremarkable final step for a presi-dent whose administration car-ried out an unprecedented crimi-nal crackdown on leaks of govern-ment secrets. Depending on howthey are counted, the Obama ad-ministration has prosecuted ei-ther nine or 10 such cases, morethan were charged under all pre-vious presidencies combined.

In addition, Mr. Obama on Tues-day commuted the sentence of Os-

car Lopez Rivera, who was part ofa Puerto Rican nationalist groupthat carried out a string of bomb-ings in the late 1970s and early1980s; the other members of thatgroup had long since been freed.Mr. Obama also granted 63 otherpardons and 207 other commuta-tions, mostly for drug offenders.

Under the terms of the commu-tation announced by the WhiteHouse on Tuesday, Ms. Manningis set to be freed on May 17 of thisyear rather than in 2045. A senioradministration official said the120-day delay was part of a stand-ard transition period for commu-tations to time served, and was de-signed to allow for such steps asfinding a place for Ms. Manning tolive after her release.

The commutation also relievedthe Defense Department of thedifficult responsibility of Ms. Man-ning’s incarceration as she pushesfor treatment for her gender dys-phoria, including sex reassign-ment surgery, that the militaryhas no experience providing.

But the move was sharply criti-cized by several prominent Re-publicans, including the chairmenof the House and Senate armedservices committees, Representa-tive Mac Thornberry of Texas andSenator John McCain of Arizona,who called her leaks “espionage”

OBAMA COMMUTESMANNING’S TERM

IN U.S. LEAK CASEEx-Army Analyst’s Sentence Ran to 2045

— A Retired General Is Pardoned

By CHARLIE SAVAGE

Chelsea ManningU.S. ARMY, VIA ASSOCIATED PRESS

Continued on Page A3

WASHINGTON — Eighteenmillion people could lose their in-surance within a year and individ-ual insurance premiums wouldshoot upward if Congress re-pealed major provisions of the Af-fordable Care Act while leavingother parts in place, the nonparti-san Congressional Budget Officesaid on Tuesday.

A report by the office sharply in-creases pressure on Republicansto come up with a comprehensiveplan to replace the health care law.It is likely to doom the idea of vot-ing to dismantle the 2010 healthlaw almost immediately, with aneffective date set sometime in thefuture while Congress works to-ward a replacement.

If nothing followed the guttingof President Obama’s signaturedomestic achievement, the budg-et office said, 32 million peoplecould lose their health insuranceby 2026, and premiums in the indi-vidual insurance market coulddouble. Senator Susan Collins, Re-publican of Maine, showed the un-ease of some in her party when

she said that repealing the healthcare law and delaying a replace-ment could send insurance mar-kets into “a death spiral.”

She detected “a growing con-sensus among members of boththe Senate and the House that wemust fix Obamacare and providereforms at nearly the same timethat we repeal the law,” she said onthe Senate floor on Tuesday.

The new budget office report,issued after a weekend of protestsagainst repeal, will only add to theheadaches that President-electDonald J. Trump and congres-sional Republicans face in theirrush to take apart Mr. Obama’s

Pressure on G.O.P. as RepealMay Strip Millions of Coverage

By ROBERT PEAR

Senator Susan CollinsAL DRAGO/THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page A16

WASHINGTON — In one wayat least, President-elect Donald J.Trump has already surpassed allof his recent predecessors. Ittook Barack Obama 18 months inthe White House for his approvalrating to slip to 44 percent inGallup polling, and it tookGeorge W. Bush 4½ years to fallthat far. Mr. Trump got therebefore even being sworn in.

Indeed, Mr. Trump will takeoffice on Friday with less popularsupport than any new presidentin modern times, according to anarray of surveys, a sign that hehas failed to rally Americansbehind him, beyond the base thathelped him win in November.Rather than a unifying moment,his transition to power has seena continuation of the polarizationof the election last year.

Where other presidents usedthe weeks before their inaugura-tion to put the animosities of thecampaign behind them and to tryto knit the country togetheragain, Mr. Trump has ap-proached the interregnum as ifhe were a television wrestlingstar. He has taken on a civilrights icon, a Hollywood actress,intelligence agencies, defensecontractors, European leadersand President Obama. The heal-ing theme common at this stagein the four-year presidentialcycle is absent.

“He seems to want to engagewith every windmill that he canfind, rather than focus on thelarge aspect of assuming the

Trump EntersOffice UnbentAnd DislikedLowest Rating EverFor a New President

WHITE HOUSE MEMO

By PETER BAKER

DOCTORS WITHOUT BORDERS, VIA ASSOCIATED PRESS

Dozens were killed and hundreds hurt Tuesday in a mistake by the Nigerian military. Page A4.Hunting Militants, Hitting Refugees

DAVOS, Switzerland — In aworld troubled by grave uncer-tainties over the basics govern-ing trade, security and the mis-sion to limit climate change,President Xi Jinping of China onTuesday portrayed his nation asa responsible global citizen dedi-cated to furthering internationalintegration.

That a leader of the People’sRepublic of China can stake aclaim to the mantle of leadershipin the realm of free trade speaksto the unforeseen, even surrealalteration of the global order inrecent months.

His message, delivered here inthe Swiss Alps at the annualgathering of the World EconomicForum, appeared meticulouslytimed to the tumultuous momentat hand. He was speaking threedays before Donald J. Trump wasto be inaugurated president ofthe United States, raising theprospect of a trade war withChina, and on the same day thatPrime Minister Theresa May ofBritain outlined plans to pursueher country’s departure from theEuropean Union.

The Chinese leader used his

Xi Casts ChinaAs ChampionOf OpennessBy PETER S. GOODMAN

Continued on Page B5

NEWS ANALYSIS

LONDON — “Get on with it.”With those words early in a ma-

jor speech on Tuesday, Prime Min-ister Theresa May charted Brit-ain’s course toward a clean breakwith the European Union and ex-pressed her fondest hope: that thetime for “division and discord” isover.

Her much-anticipated speechoutlined what promised to be ahugely complex, drawn-out nego-tiation, and it defined the broadobjectives, but not the details, ofBritish withdrawal. “The UnitedKingdom is leaving the EuropeanUnion, and my job is to get theright deal for Britain as we do,”

she said.With the address, Mrs. May be-

gan the jockeying that will lead toa break after more than four dec-ades of tight integration, and de-fine Britain’s relations with itsneighbors for decades to come.

She confirmed that Britain isdetermined to regain control ofmigration from the European Un-ion and rejected the supremacy ofthe European Court of Justice.That stance is anathema to theEuropean Union, which has madethe free movement of people — aswell as goods, capital and services— a bedrock principle and which

British Premier Outlines PathTo a Clean Break With the E.U.

By STEPHEN CASTLE and STEVEN ERLANGER

Regaining control of immigration was one objective laid out byPrime Minister Theresa May in Tuesday’s “Brexit” speech.

MATT DUNHAM/ASSOCIATED PRESS

Continued on Page A9

WASHINGTON — WhenSpeaker Paul D. Ryan needed tostop rebellious fellow Republicansfrom defanging a popular con-gressional ethics watchdog officethis month, he called a friend fromWisconsin, Reince Priebus, the in-coming White House chief of staff,for some stealthy help.

Mr. Ryan asked Mr. Priebus, thecongenial and cunning chairmanof the Republican National Com-mittee, for a favor: Could Presi-dent-elect Donald J. Trump inter-vene?

At the urging of Mr. Priebus, Mr.Trump quickly posted a pair ofscolding posts on Twitter: DidCongress really have to make thegutting of the popular Office ofCongressional Ethics “their num-ber one act and priority?” heasked, quickly bringing the insur-rection to a messy but welcomeend for Mr. Ryan.

This is the way that many main-

G.O.P. HopesA Chief of StaffBrings Stability

By GLENN THRUSHand MAGGIE HABERMAN

Continued on Page A14

By promoting plans to add jobsin the United States, companiesare hoping to curry favor with theTrump administration. Page A16.

Jobs as Political Capital

Continued on Page A14

Hidden for more than 70years in the muck of aNazi death camp in Po-

land, a pendant hasbeen traced to a 14-

year-old victim. Andit is almost identical

to one Anne Frankowned. PAGE A9

INTERNATIONAL A4-9

A Pendant’s Story of Loss

Late Edition

VOL. CLXVI . . . No. 57,481 + © 2017 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 18, 2017

Barack Obama began his presidencywith bold strokes, but his aspirationslater were checked by a RepublicanCongress. Sixth in a series. PAGES A12-13

NATIONAL A10-18

The Obama Era

The prosecution said Noor Salmanknew of her husband’s plan to attack anOrlando, Fla., nightclub. PAGE A10

Wife of Mass Killer Is Charged

Despite being the betting favorite in 15 of16 N.F.L. games this season, New Eng-land beat the spread 13 times. PAGE B8

SPORTSWEDNESDAY B8-12

Smart Money Takes Patriots

Mark Zuckerberg denied that Oculus, avirtual reality company acquired byFacebook, stole technology. PAGE B1

BUSINESS DAY B1-7

Facebook Chief Testifies

With just days left, President Obamamust decide whether to go ahead andarm Syrian Kurds against ISIS or leavethe issue to the next president. PAGE A8

Obama’s Options on Syria

Ichiran, a Japa-nese restaurantin Brooklyn,offers “flavorconcentrationbooths,” wherediners can enjoytheir soup insolitude. PAGE D7

FOOD D1-8

Ruminating on Ramen

Frank Bruni PAGE A23

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A22-23

Rebekah Mercer, a Museum of NaturalHistory trustee, donates to groupsskeptical of climate change. PAGE C1

ARTS C1-7

Science, Money and Politics

The dissident performer Pyotr Pavlen-sky says he will seek asylum. PAGE C1

Russian Artist Flees to France

Governor Cuomo unveiled his $152billion plan through a series of closed-door meetings with senators. PAGE A19

NEW YORK A19-21

State Budget’s Quiet Rollout

A horse with ablack jockey,trainer andowners won a toprace on MartinLuther King’sBirthday. Left,co-owner GastonGrant. PAGE A19

Victory Carries Extra Weight

Today, morning fog, some rain early,cloudy, high 45. Tonight, cloudsbreaking, low 38. Tomorrow, partlysunny, mild, light wind, high 50.Weather map appears on Page C8.

$2.50