Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
In the
~upreme ((ourt of tbe Wniteb ~tates
NORTHEAST AIRLINES, INC., et al.,
Aupellanta,
7 I I I I I I I I I I
No, 70-212
NEW HAMPSHIRE AERONAUTICS COMMISSION, et al,'
Anoelleea.
Pagea 1 thru 41
Waah1ngton, n. c. February 24, 1972
:r~Pt1CA1'!t:, 11 C,!l ~0-. ·:117 C'F 18 ~~11'1' BY 'B:'1:'('l'IAHUC El~l'ROSTA1 ~, ('fl 0'TllEll FAC'· .X: .J. MEANS _ l-ft0Jl~I'I'Ei' IJIDE!I TB£
C'flDEft f( R'4 AGPil:!Ct:lrr -
HOOVER REPORTING COMPANY, I NC. ~ial 'R,_epcrurs
Wa,hingt<>D, 0 . C. ~46 -6666
' ,_,
C ,
w '"
' cc __, ,.,, '-" ~
v.
IN ·r1 sur r r,,_
r .•. '· : :
;, . Iiic. .. ;• IP JI l ·J') , r;c_ L . .;ION, ct r • ,
: ;
o:iae
,
,, ' • :
;
t ~sh~ ,g,·o 1, D. c.,
'i,1 i: .;.y. l?cb:..t.ary 24 : "-'12.
a -;clc I,.'..., . • I •
0"1.
I
'
'
'(4, T
:, :, ,.. • o. .. ,j.
L < J.'E'
• .. 0 J •
"J~C' J!l, r,;1i c:: ~-•1eti.:,e or the United Si:at:?c !'lQIJGL: 1;, ",.ssc ci ate, .:;ust: c~ B. ~T1'LN, JR. , .ns~oc:. ate Just:i c~· , , , .·r ,
...;.so~il t-o ,Junt:· ce · oci, e J't•t>l;ice
,<;I "I•., ... .n. r : .c . ,
. LT', ,I. h • ........
pr CI ·:i.~c.(; J l:t'1. ;c "':'.t.·'..:c .., u...:tice S()Cinte Ju,;·;:ice C. "'" ,.. ... . .
'
w.
,. z.,,_~ ,.J & Ii •ilt<...l, Wcshingt·n,
,:,:( UJ::1 DC 'l'.l l Stat Qj_
Cor c-o. I He\
, .• , ~o., Cl•!a1:y, G?'i::tlieb, S·cecn 1 2SJ Cont c'· 5.ct-i: Avenue, N. W. , ~- c. ~0016; for the Ap?c~l;::n;:s.
.. , , ECQ. , · '~~is ::.en : :r\;:·;;ornf?Y Genera:., Nt,.;\ Hump ... :hi,i:-e, 3::.a·-~! Ho,.1se 1n·.1e,;, H'- p•;hir 0 3:,01; fo- t:ice l'ppel lees.
0 !'" T Z ?; &
r- ·· . .t\ .. Guz..,,_._!'l' or : ---· --··--···-• ... · ?I.GE
,Jf"ll".n It. .. : •o~·, ZJ;,:. r l•, for tlP. •~pcllar~s
1.. ich · l r t: I , ' ':. , £or t, ~· 'l iJ c :.'.'I
P~2,CE~!:?.!~!:!~ I•'· • C, ,. F . us •Jc., URG H. 1-~ . 11 hoar · rgum i;;.
no~;: in 70-212, !, -c;nua , • i;:l;;.n
Aoron11ut!c,, Coir...i. si n.
{' "'":
I f
t. t.utc •
ur th
Hr. Ile> l lory, yo1•. moy procs,ea w1. P<'Vcr you• :.:c ready.
OP L 1\ ,r.u,11:N"" OF .:om R. MJI ,r.or,", Jr,., "'.;Q.,
JN Ell ,1,F o.~ 'i'F, 1.PPE ,I l'l'
l • .. 0 •• ''lr • Ch. "'f J•1 ;·.i '- 1 Tlaj' ii; pl~ ti!"C u,e
' i 1 ,. c., ·o t: ..., i lt4.: to · h<'. c se j t !. t az-gt ed,
'1
.; Ii re.,
di jt a .~"" t of i:hc " prerno Court of
1 ·1 ,i ">nr;tituticni 1 a llc,w l'arr.pshire StatE:
' r '- J ll,Ar..: r i •).;;.nc-n le.Ought ··o enjoin enforcemen't
t tu.: 1 •1hic- iJr >OSCO 0,1 i:h(' tdr:..ineD -- thiz tax is
c 1 t • irli , no'· t'ie p s Jengc : -- impoocs on th(.
·.rl ·1 i: •• c C! ? 0 I Jll · ::: :..r p.:c-ieng r enplen:i.ng frcm
u',..lines contencle'l that the _ '1 .r .• n. ri: or T
t- .l ·~ U'lC I)\.: .on , u d l ··•he const3 t ,cion.!'!l ::-ight to
t1 V l, h • - '[(" ' .L s .. < •d i:1'. eot1aJ. p: of-eci:5.c!l claue·e.
t t· l u n , '1 1 ,pshi:.·L t Hli'!lfc1:red ·l:he •
., ur · C. i vl ·acts, <:O th Supreme Court
; . i g ry 3 ,, , r ..; ·. i: can do.
Cc 't' I on .J nuary ?.C) , . 9·, , b. ld that
c· n t - uJ. 1.:;,.nc not tte passe'lger, ~nd
4 th .. ·.; ) ·i: -·~ ' t ' l :t I'
fc-~· r·i (' Ol . 1: ., 1l t • c Jll' • It hr: r t'l • the
ircid. r oi h < , .. le on tl e
ii: h ~ld 1a-h ·. nnla,~ · n' "r- .... , l vl, v int.,:5 Jt ~;: .... e-vc,1i· • .i·~
II .d tr. •
,., t, . i. •6, a " id, ir ... >">se~ c •
1 1 ' llC' L ' " ,... ... I \,.. p .. r ,. :?,1L!0X ·o all
l
;
of •
l , !.>ll
I • ,_ ..
•
f • sh't: . i ::._; :t 'f'~ • tf, •
, ... 1 ll '1 · l." - :) l ). ,1 ::; Wi'C l tl gr.o J 3 :?ig t
l' "0, r 't:. " '-J·_ C .. ,;c
,.. < :t". ,: c rri rs, cc'1t c-i: car ... iP.r ir a chn:i:ter
'
,, I
1t 'l u
n r \ t:. (.
·, ·,:, i ,c:>, ">": OvC'r 12, SOCI pouncs x:.;,
c ,.b ctn c ur'i.cr-:i with pl;;nes oi J.eso ·han
,~ ••
ti n t. · 1:r.- c., ·1:i0rr c ~d:, whe. the
c t'l . c;; ' • ,L, np. ,r€ to the air;o:r·c
.<' .. n c. 11.:~, li;d ,.. Ll ~--.:'L h-i.; no ·::errninal l:ime
C 11 r thi'l ch ~CJ" or i:ax are
i:.t ~c c>r.n, 1~ i. m, the ,t.11te A •r,,n.:.iutics
n t h t.
j l I , in3 .• J 5) per.-:e.-1t to t 1e
t t ,,ri-<.,f'
t
Tl, "=- i r., no r ,uir mcnt that- t'1c m1•nicipali ties
• n, t. • C v~ cc , I n C •• rr:i rt f -:.. 'I - 'i:~(!,. • Th
•mici"' .i. ; 'l , in ... _ro ,vuti~ .. ft· ,d -Ch~ funds
collected t•nq ir C ~pt J:t' 42~ 0 . ·:.:h New H,mr.>l'hire laws, but the
r venu coll c_ rt. cui,:i1.·
C ollec c. e·· 42'3, it'n collectea under
0 • l 1 'i'
I . I y • > I .. (" 1J Honor.
0 - ell ..:ir~ t .tn my imp zs;;.on th.:?t th~ New
F.. ?'lh, :..· .... upr ('' r e no r fcrenc to this allocat;.on
of 50 p c . t o t·1,. c"meial fund?
1 .~. • r. o .. Y: 'l'hat · a cor~.:ict,
~J it a gu~d belo1?
• T., r, I .. t: . ' • r 1ued on t:1 J notion tor
, r:' .. l' h or. ·· t, 's
' . '
L J i.i:'o i ' the A-,penc.i>=, as I recajl,
t . Lt ;.g , 3'a ,na. ;,.,.n...- O\;er to page 42 ,
r , 't ,·'r> "l t n1ised r;: ·.or tc the motion for
• l (
• ,0 • cc,., r ct, ·ion:- lono.·. rt uas
L ic <-o t: 1. o· c fox· r ho· irg.
r 0 t • , • for <-h, d, ,i.:.1 of t'le l!\Ob.on it
(i
~n' t t c.. 6 · • .., , ... ') ...
!!I J.:ing ;;he
Jo .. 0 l '1Ut' C'
.0 U Cl \ r
ir
Q
..:e t.:in ce ?
1 :. .t<
y
" 4
T
:.o
q :: to th" o. ?ron.i 1::.: cs .fund, which is
i: ~ar h !'c: 10 porr.ent goes ·to the
.: n,; + , . \.. .:u ',"l ·~ u,dcr 'che terms Ct
rli\. I l v . t?l<.1. c:o p~rcent qoes ·to the
'(' r.c. ,t t the M m.i. tpt.}.:' -~y •
'• ,ff' 4'cc--Jrd t• •• v in i-c ho'I' , he f~c:Lliti 'f:
Y: ':.here is in 'Ch') rec.:ird ju_ ·- the
• :1.cm· ·n ·- . .. 1 • r·n~al Gi'd that type of:
. I u. Tl ' :11, -< ti'" n or.
6 \111. :ii, 1.. l:y .,on. r:!.b .itu any ~untla to
r :?
• : Oh, \· , i th'nk it clCC"S. I think that's
, .. .. ,: o. •
ll ':1'~ CCC• sh_,..., thac7
l • J. -0 • (: co ot. -- I cennot S£iY the....: :;he
r C r: ., 'r l ,. h1. i I t• nk .'.t IS i ;l!Jt
' 'lo. .. St.ct C ·o •tic 1 -u-r flnance en,thing
t i· t: • t ) • ) . • 'l' <' •
' ·on t, .. , c·; fund, u.1de the
I 1 C 0 l I;. l ,i:\,: •• I: IS rl o Ldc,: ,
, ' } t. ' iv d t l -a • h t ~et Jte or
., n no·i·E a ir>curr .;. <!I': t 1e v 1rious lli:i:·9orL_.
T 1 1~69 ~·-, 'l:Ut , · hi.::h i t, e Oll :c. tci cirig b mt .~v,
d)ri£; n">t l,a, th.:r~ s n~ p;.?v.i..-io:11 i>na tn~ s~ te Aeron,.:iuti;:el
Co •miEsion c r. d i·,.s f:u:raL for. ,enerdl ,n,ia'i:ioi'l or fo.·
i;Jp O. > d. ti·
t h •c ·p~111 the ,unc., en ,mv p .. 11:t:ir.ular
u:Lrpor ... , or ·"·h ' ·t fr.;im 111ich the f-11dr; 1 ~re r t•~iveci.
C
.. ... ... 1-J ., r Y: No •·-• t ,<'J ther~ '- tlerlin, in
c i .:i.c-. t'1._ , c,r .i. '1' ,c. L .c._,., .. a.
{' ·• C\'11,.?
. '
: .. r .
,. foll" 1 -
o; ) ...... t;.>..
Q •
• I
r J , • ' c, , ou. · Honor.
!l "' l ~:..: !)tte too?
0 • , Y, u Hor.or.
' t: 1 ~• '.:al~ it '-"'P ':h€re -
e ... , s.ir.
M ::.re, <·be :,upr~na Couri.:, ~c,fused
J._j; :_ .!_~ '-'!. ur,cl th Pa. i nc r case!", specj_fic-
> l' fr,:.c ot fol .owi1 c; those' 1 ar tha·l:
c· l tie ,lls enCTc-r llnC. ,1nt on t.he
-l "d it ,; C~St:.! L."'~€::.
0 .,, r~ t'1c l' n'L r cnsc, al"d
i: t ·~ 1 Vt ju• t: '1rgucd.- ~!t~
B
., .S.; •.l C. C 1n n 'l ')'rot nd thi:. • th.;.~ the ·ru, liar
on '1.:hc pr, en"'. .,a I , . :- ' And it
1 ~u
J ~•~y cas
.:: < t t c ~;i ~h, rcu i J app 'l, ,o -;. '1e gr.t" und
• ' 1.J • ,1 tt. · o• ,y, ccl'.'.cc;; d ·:c 90 _. 11i:o
, r. 1 d · '1' t c.- .n tJ· .: 'lrJor, •
'"! ._ ('r1 r~ ,-•c ... : h , • C' . :; ,
r r o J ) . i' i •~~tttc, hit one applicabl~ ,nly
"'-' ··!l ·· ,, ... , ,,. ,: cu.11r, r 2. '(t hui upheld
.o· ea, -re it; vpi'1io:ri, ~n it advisory
o c-11 tr, t l j ::. ; o· · by · 1 yon~ t._, tl''l .f · ict ')n inter<;tute
< U I r
c; 3 'l t r .• d . l: : 1..". .:J~___£~, , • .I Hc.mpJhir£. • • • I . t ., f. · tnt I; lt ~- u •nps·,..Lr-2 ~u"Orerne Court
4. --·· llat. ... 'ght-to·· ~c•,, 1 -:::i ;er. , including
C • .. -°.:!:•., noi.. L pl v ...,.:,.caur: J t tax in • t.. , :runpnhi.1:e if' en
'h .1 on :lm p u.:;cn "r,. { e contend that
{ ,., >f l vi I' . t •r.m ni.ng t,' t :h' tmc i.n N;u
r r o·:: th p~5 Pf~ r,
l C, t r' '1 .. L.; ~ro oi:r ~· ·n r til;n~r to follow
• , . ,. &, ' ~au C rf ;_ V.U tha .. tho-;e
l ' ' •d t . •r ... 4,, ti~ 'l:.m ,o~er to ta, i • .u
(
t i -~ 'll holt,,.n that i: ) act. o[
. ' (. • " ,,J· • .... i, ci~r>nc r.f te'lc<>t .on, is
9
'11 olly an l.nt1 sl·.::te ev-:?nt.
Q i:. ,:.11ory.
l R. lll'L. CRi: Yo'l, '/(J'lr l,c,nor.
CX' . Cl"'C" ') • '. t ... i b z_ . • l •Ji.• • 0 !Y• :Y£'l, t,"f "=•
r, .lQ .. 4
,. vo11 objoc. t;hi\t th typ? of tal'.<.>~ ,., .. 're: t'.! :r :ng ~·1 tl1 he~ T. - 0,1 tlce net ,,f c-r pl c rt0Y1;( rit or on ':he
c.o 1.miurc-,..,, d, T gri.nt •ou, you c~n ...'i1 d the,•_ sor·i: of di.,ti.nc-
,u::.o sw 1:i.t, • cu:.: Hcnor, that it --
tn '.: ,.,. ,.. 'h:it-, ·t •t I C'.Hl"e::.,e tc, b. tl1~ r~ght l:o travel is
· •.vol v •d ;- i .,!l It t!1 t , _,.. ;:a .,h} sicc 1. 1 'hat. h.~re th ...
t I a i:, in th' s c ..,c, on the carrier
ed b' the nt l'i f p&.<i~c.nt< ts; but ·· think th<.c :.t's
I:: . ,._ "'t( 1 z. 1'!t '· ly or, the pa a .nger, w:-1ei:e ii:' s
d t , C r- t ! j , . 'ld. ' r r i '• c-an do th.1t, I think th11t
't 1 C. " ... . , i'i: ~' e:-:c:..ciP .nq the powe:c tc
0
l. i i
I 1 l .,,, n.. c ~:..:.: e.
1 '(. t, , co 1cc •. tln.t: a p "J!;t'nger do·•. n' t. have
,_•n• • • • J ... ,; \.· V
ltJ
11~. -'JI: Oh,• -~c:1c:. e .;h,;,; i" do "n't '1 vc the
.
n '.)iO\l h11c' vl.r,:11 'L )' C) " d-:-o .. ha~ .,; . .,i:e
' ·" ,? <. \ C' )C, I •i s in which '( St t.e 0 ;he l ·,al
t r l 'y . t'l 'l .. lo • r e ·e, . i.l the
'3 ..... r ._ \, ,.' ~utic l!lj . p !:>" .... n?
P. r J, 'l Ill'.' Hell r. I ur(!-1 ':hat th y
1. t ..:,w, t ~' ~h; • t et ti - ca'1o~ C .s-d in all o'.: the
.• o (; h .; I • ,r ' •r n 1.,., e:d )l )'1 .h v,st nc.. t;lcr of ways i-n
C t . s t ·:1 •~i ... ' c..n ~'Ji . rr. ,a ,, qt i: • Oh vf 1 1 _) j f_ s C!llllC up.
,.. C, ( {'\:_" ,· . c.i r· i ~0$ '· ind• r.q ~~eet, . , .,. t· '.., .. ~t 0~ ,,, I· The rental;
1;.0C • d r'-.Ls . me :i:hey --) ir.
. I :-. Vf> gro ..J-t cei ,t,i ·:::axe'3.
'> ;..~1e .. ·•1~ of --ea • ._.,,_ i;.l:.vh:!.nq t'le sa C
o l b un l &> r .iqt t. t., VC'l?
: C , You•,• . en~. , r c<e'C·ainly do. I
;
-~ ', lo·,., .. -~Y t ' l C'"lf:O I: -::h
' ic u ' n k~ r . ; lC? - •
1'1. ' ') i.'": .. ,. , ot.rJ i:o be t• ~im tely -.tl.!.Ch .d
.t ; t ") . l Pl"iC ct t ai'spoxtat' ion..
·t :I ., r· of .,J .:r-f r ol ar, ,., : pe.,nv for-
l.i
penn~• on I:he h d of 1:h" p r on t; avel · r,.:r .l:rom, for £,,:ample,
L ~. ,;_._. t.:> :lo,· n. r1" acc,ni'l a' •.;,ox:t, ,it,1 11:hi.ch I'rr. lairly .. . .
• H .... ,:, !, ' ~.101t, c~u1d t,nd, Y'ill sure, a
g~.at <' l cf , c, -nc1t, ·•nd cou:..d p;:o, ... hly, \>iith c .::air
'"l~ ., v~ tr "fi: .'. re, cc,, ld ju.· i.fy a very l"'i<Jh
npl£1f •me.·· er, qP. wi.i::'i.out. tha. chu qe b,'ing c'ltce ·s .. vc.
LU; it I ?U:t.d C'lr ... '.nly bu:.:d r.
nnd no. -.:,n if i~ ii t·1 t.
11,ow. , 'Sc-., , r c. ip.:o, u pz-ope ·ty i.pportioned grc ::;s-
r ipt C. - o.
tu " . of ) ( ~.l
<. 3 , ....
r. : .. 0~
gc..t .., .,
'- .o
to t , , ,l- .i t
ot·~c .)
> .r . ... n ei
C . '= er:i ~"" t. ...
{ •
" zJ r i
... g, j ~f: <
.., t ..
l t f
pre '-rl , e ~---~r icir d i.1c " o.,r, LC o\:h""I
F O"lCrl.y t C.11 ii· lir,o , tint wou).d he. borne
.. c.1 · 'J t l. 1 l..,l OJ.~ i:i ... ti . t.c l :·cat inf.te, d
'" i; C, "'l;i_ ,g .r-... ._!r ·nq to leave Lacon:.a
1 l: a V :y di 'fercnt thing. It wou:,.d
' 1 to y con··rol of ':he Civil AeroncutJ.cs
. obligat;;.o·~ and t~a pOWC'l:. to allocate '. , Jlat , .E. so t!lcy can ca1ry out its
g tha. e ntt·on is <!Jerv.:?C. !:>y comm rd.al
t, ari :·u..;t pa tict•'.l..ir ;..uutc.
lL ~,n,r
0 :t ;
•c c:-'"
'
IT(' I
.•
'It a .,11ding . e which, I ~al:~
i. ,., 'I', 1-,•1ld b..! a a:c on the act of
ll bttd<" 'I cor re" ' -:.c l: ta;,, 011
.. '· e c.Ct of • .. 1p:..ctn~ment?
. 1
0 t
01 · .onor, I view u landing
r:'rport, anc r think that
it,
:;2
t sica ... lv c · • I ·t i d:h. .;h&n ,
I L '+ 0 . l',T" ,._nt: 0 e of tJ .. ,. p ::> ' t JI I :Ce inq (.1 c:irportt ' .. ') t C !;",; nly (' lf the ct J i;h1 t
p ··op .e do l: th_ h I - i '>C. • ,ut i'ter t1'ey V . , ' . • t, e • '1 y' e u 1n':l rm lil/' •
0 ' r re u i ·t 1h .1 they "· r.fl,
• .. • w • 8 r; t'l.y ~- U[ing :lt.
:,J ' It--, 1· <:" ting on t 11c
- ) 't ;
n 1.{ , ).)' C t: r • tion, i tho ~ct
1 h ' i I; r • 0 r e,i,ari •
, d
) ', O':' ) •:r.i::r, of· det ,:t, t' no·;: w:I i;h
L ' . - . I pu o. dcp,ri:u:r.e.
0 l .. fl.c;h+- C ' ed ~d you go to tho
C. • • 'l ; d u i.~ .ound the:r:-e, yot• I l."'3 prob'lbll•
t.
r , ! '1 u'ru or:~c. d n Cl planC'<1€:,1t
• l (- .. , I ::> er, fo th l purpo~e of
·u
\' t , 5.rnc- t. l: :h t: t:i ~?
. ' • a·· r, V'1l1 are.
' I.. .,_J t 0 ii:po .. ~he· you 1 nc\? • -!, c.. " ·r • :£n "d, yot• a ·e. Yo 1 're usi ng
it wh-n ]O' -
t
1
r, i ,O t •
...
·'s n
#• no and h p ..
,l .o b
l' you qo tl•e:re for an:; pul:pose. If you --
.> o .,.., ti a .-iirpo t, h v~ your · ic' et,
h 1 l' c ~cc .!..led fo.c ,> nie i: .asor,, , • w
I. 1 re -- if you boa ·d tho Pl..i.-· a1
•
in y m nd het •r, if y~u bour~ :he
't <- e O'"f, I Jn 't 'tnow wha .
u .rt oc~ condition
ell, (·. CJ 0 .• of ,rip::- on the E stern
.r y t o· co L C to ,J ~ame airport.,
l I 1?
• l rce..,ture by Nr. l!allory. J
0 si_l ... 1Cc. C or •otr co .m-:int,
o: • t • • Ltic-ns, about CAB allocating funds • ·h .... ii.: 0 .. tL.mal 'rave ai;, • ho~.e? · Are you
1 ~ti. g th t l ·:!li'" •Jndc··w.:~.+-t.en by ,'ec:eral funds?
! • iL. I t J di n't 1ean to say,
I' r, 'I, (' ll ct ur -; : i:h-;y al.locate ro11tes
n . f
c- h C<l ntrv r, :1, r than ;he
g j, er the '""'to Gov•r1mcnt being
r ' r: a \:h . 1 l i1fluenc~, or th,ri::
·o t.ch "I ttent tr it it restr;.ct
. that "t t .
:t ph m c:uesti 1. You're he.re
rep nti, 1 1-, of " ·. "l i l '-' •. ' the . • ,rr., c· .
· , ... v .. '': v· .._ , Y ·1r :, 10 ...
(\ T l :-t «~ \: e lir'~ Stgq ,t s th <> J.',; 01 fo:.:
·1s.c~ ··" b'.
o : uni \:ric. t.rr
ll
th -· )
. th
C: ~v tt) f c.;_ .i~ics?
i '
t.h
C ~ .•. •.; •
ti I 1.d '!'lo,
th n •• P'"C>b<- >ly :-:athn: tha•1 u unifo= ch !'ge
t l[ \'- ,. •
- +- 1 11 ·v · d the J?i:ohJ. r: o tho; o:'. '!:fei:::.nc:; amounts
.,J • r.r.icl ~• c~ of -cw•t>.tir- 1 •
Q o you a v l-1 ~Y r.1iqn;. .~e ~ai:L;f:'.ec~ t:ith hig' .er
l n•' .i.r.
~. • .Li.Ci, ; Yo,1:,: H ,r•'1 =, I s~y the tigher. :1 anding
,. · .-po ts can .:a iue rr,:>ney wi tho 1t, J cl
7 J ';J ' .c L r tJ- Cent =i t1.. ~::.on.
t " j ,1 t r.i.i • ec th~ la'ld.i.nq fees, charge
i: , 'I.: • • • ·l ., 9 ,• vot ou .. c n~y -·· they may , ot like Lt, but
l •
. '
, , .. tr
• '1
O 1 • r do. 't ,-}'I·, t,, I•~ ha 1·9 a -:ons-::.it~,t ion al
C Ut
•• 1 ?
alrlln s ju3t a,n't like landing
. 5
h ' y H
t , r u ' l I i > t 'n 0 l
' X t· n?
y tr ·l
- i i""'ll 1 0 th: w y, th t ,
l ·h - ., of Tr n po ta ·5o I
House Wy ' d
C C • u 0 the
0 re r.,
g 0 t to
•
0 0 r c:harq ' Lil i
I tion f ob aining uniformity
t i in I 0~ raising
-,1 n n t
o: .h rame ch rgf
., tlonal .. or-t
; f rport?
'I , ould b I y 9
of C t "UC.:.ion p r
J.6
. . . t , y , ;: •v v ,:y gr_ ·1 d y, c:.nd d _ .n cnnl:.
,., · on \: (
v,·
• b' c'l ,. _,,., to I ror j a.
''o 'J .l to tl.e, " ,,, i ..... 'T,p 1h.i.r.c. Court:' s ;cei:usal .o
ss .;_ ·, ,. b_ l~eV(. t!l :i•.; ti.e Court -- th!!
O:.t' ': l O C' ' ,1 t ,, H prh:i.re .h t t ";.._(' \LS ll ~.i,:vice
C' e ric. • t;h · n11. , f i.:t 1: : ci 11· o. the Cour 's
n ·n1.
.ld i,:, t ')• nt l ~u~c 01 it-~ fin~inJ ~hat the act of
, u:.. LY intr< •tatc a,;t ,hie I we con,;end i:;
'" l. J UliJ. ', .. ("" . ... ,,1 ati< n i•1 l " H, ~prhirE' .gain showE" that
jc, ;y c. • r: ,1,l,' i.! r v' ... t , .c• .: c.lso sho•1s that
.., I- PJ t' ' t . j :1 ::ub ;t< nti.'.ll!y no
. f .... t ·.t (J. le ! jc"J: ,( y T h ) r 10~ tmced •
.( n:·a t-'1 in~ VJ.J. I )UJd ·,eve -- if yo•1r
(' r • C. C. I • vr . ct ::.t, i. ; ::hat th:'..~ kinc'J
, l t .... _r • .. rr t.1d l'-:-.:n -.. on·:, ·.ir t.rc1.ve1
llv, t') g <. LLp •'l:'t t'tth r f-han
,rfi, ( I tr 0 • t t"~ .i.U, ' -.., -~ .. :~ don't b.o' < • . -'
0 .o. r \ VO C" , 't ½ \'(' t - 'l.llll o½~cction ·t:.o
l
. . . . •· 1 n•U 1g fc 'l ?'c nll
ot•l :i., p go i.n ··o .:he cos, o o.,. i·:eting an air:.ine.
J l, t ,d _ · and, bui: y >u • c. h ,;c l: e .1.me --
• i l-. .u.n , T.n y d'l not ··- I 'rn 30 zy: e.;c'.lse me.
t.• if · t . ai_pori: nuthori ty detei:-rnined, We~.l,
' hav o h v n, m cb -;,1 v i•c f:in,i~c-• an cicpans:i.on and ue 're
goii g to inl :,-e 1 dirg feE.s r;o 1:c can L,ay fc-r them, so \.e
C , of. t'1 b~ d 'r ,oing .;o e: ,m ... they' re don't
'lC" .i.t ... long-tcxc, 1 0 ses on nll the otter i , 'C. • l- a• rpo t, nd so they h vc- :o load ii:. on t:o
l l I • 'Ir 'V -·a,, they'Jl do it by l nding fr.tis.
l·U ,OR .h'l gc.,es into 'cbe gc-r cral c-osti; of
p -r ,t .• ' tt .i , .
( L, •1 •ie rtand, but it's certainly --
[l • r y -- o.nd tn:.- £e th fare f.or.i Laconia
,, 0 ... 0.1 i~ n t bas tl "'ntirely, or t.,VCn .. 1 <lr<]<e measure,
r tt. IC "J • ;Q. Li:.conia 1\.i .. pc ·t. ''.hooe co t,.; are
Ot. .... ;t~ j .... 1.;.-:C f--. '"l v . ecoup t'lo~c CO<'t.t?.
('l - .• o in. er l ·tt..;.,:, .ocn.r o:· later ·t•s going
co )J. r .. ... .. C. . ; • : oine;, t-o co.· peo,-,le mere to travel,
• u t' ,1ct C' C' y t - it' ,-:,t going to be ~- oirect:
r ,:- C :·a to Bo ton,
( "I 1 1 · COTI Cl
" tli
\ C'C,PO TC' th r·or, doc n't it?
18
. I • . ry?
Q .. n -"~ e r )- ,j >l'l t q;? J.t 8
+-h t yo\.\' r le ling on to a. lot c. peop th It ,h.J ldn't b.
p •ing C C o tt E' co n fuci /?
L, (' ! - ' rot 11 rce '1,0U m,::e the
j nt i: • 't F 'J n l ·-1 nk tha; it uould • ,
' - . Jj 1 i " fl'.' to I .h.:.nk ,:h ': any of
1 t t 0 on l~n"in~ f a-:,:,e
I Q ' 75 .:o D .().
C ,. ju ir"d J lhtc t1 L'"lber o
l th r. i . 0 t) l I l! mp!lri~ • f tho!.t 1 9
11~ l q. F 1t· it' C, It• 1~ ') >"t dme that way.
0 11, lr. 1 ~)o ""l' # [U po ycJ ccmbine the
> ·1 i l1 h' on t·u on in N'cw Hempshire
y 1 C , .
C. I n .. ~ntc th~ , irx>rt? Do
V , .. h ?
• Ve , do our .o. I 1- in?: th .t
1 n' (' . th , di£ r nc. betv: ra th<:
\':
. . \ ' I: .gt'nq l~ ding ·ees,
n on the
•
.. ' 1
. r.
·J
Q
1 •
I think t ;i'. •
l
l
t
{l
$ :
r. •
•
;
,
)9
h t the 0 C, it's -- well,
t. r n
h t. ?
t . 0 .l: 1' l f : . t t i s e tal' on enple~e en ... ,,
Oil O' n U'l a,: c t qor:y in the Indinr :i
t
I
, h l
1
t' 11
(. h
,
h
0
t
) ?
l
1
C
8 r
r
ndi g
ody off
r!.g 1t.
l di
{ a .. . t I,
]
t SC,
ll r
•
. d, b
, 0\
-i to
(! f
I' p ' l .:ight,
g
tim
cnt
t_ ct of enp~.ne-
.1.::..v,d~, th~ P;_fc;enger
. cc into plctY tt e
land for whet pu1po -?
l<ct sorn~boay, qrote,
red to oay today is,
f .s. No~•, .is I say,
co1stitutionality
bu I'm prcparea to
y _., of tto
i· . i OT. the use ol'; t,he
tou · onor • It's not
20
l dil.. •ct h , ,. ,:
O · cl ii it ·.s
-m. M, '.OF'i .i.t · :s nc,t a d.' :r;,:,c tar. on \;he
ua in n,;er,
) ; nrl l it r tr
• ',0 E: rh tnpll" l q "'"'
l pi:,.· ,1 ' •
u l, ! t c. ' t --
1 • l , J
' :;: 11, r 'n cori-t.-1 ;;o 1;'1at, if I may,
• V _o:i:k, .111 )~ ..... e t.~l" ' '!Xe£ in which it wao
' ( • ... n the ca:.:1~ _r. The- ... e 's no -- i.n i:he
I' ri-C't wi-· Oi th p~;:-engers, but
r r., 1: on :, C .:crier.
r t , ~t, t. n c,. ! 'ln the ma::ter
r ,,,. !'O 1 v. .'1.:,:1,or o" l 3W ':_of~., it was a tax
l • IL • c)w. ,er. Ir, ... t! 0 ~EL .!.~.'I case, it was ll
I I l ... c- Cc,_ iEflc . < Gcr.cr.;J.e Trans-. -- . -- - --------...;. . X C. l (:t C .n .r.
r >f t le, C (' i:iic ~C,t. ·t "'"$ ITIC't ,,ith i:he
• I • +- <'ll e. ' • ,.. . 1 ... ( r1:ic ·, 'lt't not on t:1e
• t' t J. I C t l. ,,n \;h~ o:.:ivilnga of
i • .; ) ( <' t [' - ~n ,!; .he Cour~ look, d
:n
•;.h-rough ct t a~ -, ci .ic< U.y he1 c;';. tha. a•; a legal matter, as
i....r. • • of. chi , t, '~ on i::he car::ier
v~.ewed for c.onr·':.itutio.rnl purrcr;es as a tax directly on the;
pe. ens r.
"~. r~d t - y .~- br~of d, . : d.d no~ di~cu~s
tl n t J ' i11 ' ;< o :, · c.1.
! ' h p e. c- ., ' ·•·
,.~t··., .-1:; m_, !n f •r .•. -, .. St ":t to .:m~ .her-· ~,•hich was also
over d i.r. tho:~ t.t.' tut f i ara fi,1dil'.'q that. ..:hut was
.i;- .-::.:.fically dt"'!.lt wit:1 wii>ther or. not a tax
t .. i~ ty C. r-~ .:c. r;.) ·, · -we j a' 0,1 the carrier or. i:.he
n A l '1 l 0 ld 'i::h.:." it W'i'; :;tcit ?d that, wasn' i:.
i o ~c v·<' ... a c· i:. lX on the passenge:~s.
:..r ... · n 1erfr- 1 v. N-., .:ork, the Jtat. uas specifically
. .. d1,,. · J ·1,, i,;. •·'w I 'l;.a 5 n · n th<' Pa,.§.£. ngcr cases, and th'i!y
· i,; • b~ ,; ut .ly c. · 'ar th t the ~h.:irqc "';;tS r.ot on the
(. .. f.. - - C
( l t
,
l n ... c r , / i.o 'i:ix--fiftv f0r cec"1 ::,at!'engcr,
o·
\J • \ d . c. t 1-.< b .:;- . ..,
:t· <'> 1-.1 t th t~•• -- the
•1pcn no -1 by t:t (. Court
c~ 1 ). ."Je • Ti1£, f ata also arqued
t ,t-c, ur, :1.nd irct't moc;e of
o i;n:1 ._ ta. such. 'J:'hn Co• rt
d ' ti,. U ... .i '?C
l ... :iqu~qe e • ·atu e m l b fr 1 .-.a, . ,. ..: .... 3 on t,"'OSC rr ust be dete; ineoc
ny i '·•· ,1 tur , ' I'' n·· n )£ ,Z l(! . • 11.• d j_ .
i-'i;_ is apparen·< .... . -ti, l th" ')b~cct 0 t ,.,.c t• ' i. i ·,c,qcv'l by tl criteria is
t ' 'l ' of J C s1.:1n c:,f rron y =or
.... ,: r .,,. ;
rr. t. 0 ,x c n ~h <?ss .,. o,m .c fr,r tl,e
0 'i" l .. c • ,1 < ,,g ·h i.l p ,3t.enqe rs ~r. that city,
l •
,.. < l' v .l'.,, L da, t-he <: n' arq, neni: n.1s mado,
' T .. , I f'a ....
''
• C. "- :
C'" .. • r 0. , , , , -g
0 - c- ,:r. in« c s·:..d everybody i.ha~ u•·es ou~
I l Iha· :- r,c-1.lld<~S the pilot,
ll. io , b dl r; eve ybody.
0 1n it• t n1 ' <.1tio1 a~ uell, and Jo on?
' ., 1A·hinq. U.211., 1 would -;uspect that:
. , ; o bly h< i ,•e<·sive, i'.1 i:hat
ch l
l ~ding by
~- l r
.. r .. :
.._ l
i
23
u.
I ,1 l I 'lO t k I, · rd
iv:· l a t·on d I' 1 0 co~ re l 7. t n.
C F u~ (' (: . l ha- : i.· " Ot I r o ...
L )" C u 1
C. I n ! SQ.,
l\. • \ ,;,_ _;
·~ . Cl f i. i.c , ~y ii:. please the
t·C'ul.r C' iich •e discussing now the
, 3 , le dlf e ·ept from th
t .. ; d, ,. I thin, . t. , • • .,
C .. l i t I > , !ct led ir pas.·pn·•
C f .. -• ' e o!: t C St~te's acil"tie.i,
, . I <l. k_ tom kc ono ~oin' he~e: that our
• ' ~-
r l · ,. , ~pparently , to the
A ort uth>r ' tics with which
rn ic'p .itie,. But, for the
I JO., , t , 11tinq .xpen,c
• -/ or y ·: 1'.l Airport
t n t1i~ particu~ar
?I'
•W t· ': 'h t p,.
Tt ·i C i.;,s ·on, throrqh tt'.: eqisl·t re,
I r V ou. ' -:: . ·v· t ·e, ,t the airpo
C on t > .. .. tJ l • it · ec _·.v
: • , ' 0 .1 0 t'1 u rpotts. ,
wi • t e ut·c Cr, .. _,ion?
1 g . t. ... ::it •s r, • e1ic'e,
y ~'"'ts, .. . l:l'e p ~nt t:'me,
4 0 i co.Lle :tc1 t the a'. rporl:s
r ~e C ) that bot th> State and thf"
i ; ' ri: ll ho 1 co ' · .oute money to he
C" l !. t c,:i I ~·ot j 1st one
'V aca.-nst the
4 ,: ' " au ho1.· ... ~ed, 1n
I. C. r h ri.c:t does not r, mi'i:
C "'e bv t lC c!">r:cier.. The
1~ ·o 'l .. 0. - i'.uthori l:y or
, e lr d, and 50 pei.·cant-
r 0 th Tl'. ;1.., 1 et .o be
l i~ •
, C l d C l'l Ol • b u d for
• c., ·•t 'JC' s ~o the
• .. t, . , l: l most >, rt -- r t en \:t l- ·t mi: t b .. u.ed
25
C, ir • lC t, 'l lcok at the
t n 0 b': l for i..te .... po t
., h. .... )', t ey
C: t.
B • vt ' ' - kn n yo1r ctse, n
t t ?
• . " n i cpin • • Bee e the -· • l1 • 0 Oll: supr.or:ed Ly
: I I ort t ' t X ~s not
r. ! l t t n tte b1 i h . -1,
r •(' h r, nor did \
• J. ,,; r at tac::ec'.
C ow th i:: . t I l ot CXC ssivc
t i p :i. t nl th State
bt t l [ u or~ or t..> each
t ' I t r \) 1 ... of t!-o ,a
t 31, , y C "1: .
• V cl)n ·;r · but ea re'Jre .:han
i f , n l. • !' C 1ly tru 1u. 1 ~. t C ,n ibu nq or,.
0 •
. ' '- l f' tn s h, re
I r. n, 1 l t. b• use
V u· \;. UJt be
u 0 il 0 i
Q j in no pc;i icn o,.. th::.i: recor
-i;o -• •
r '
;-L (?I: . t;i 011, ! ~3 it'i'
'" T • n? re • y. () r !30~ i~ . .. t C:l .., , 1.~
ot t . -ii ' , tt > .. tu·•,,, .. o b•1r . e, , 1.n ,..a
o-Jinio'l, f .l · ! (j t ;o l y t as c-t 1e.: ly ,,_~cd 'llld
). V '1-.J', ! l • ; it i 11ot '<C e.
n""'ec t'. i C. •hire sta<:ute, the
•• al i for t .... c~ State and
·i . ti. , n it 1~ 1ured by :wo
• ') re· ·t an t:. "' herefit provided
t:e •• Lt' a of e l · .,1 "!, onts or th- ll\Jmber
• 0 > t 'IC • to t • qu .. tio:'I that waa pos .d by
t C. • C .:,..,(..\2 d f.irthe-r by -l , Juoti-:.- B1v.-c~-anun
. t' t, t~~.;' ~nc i· r.~ C e. lmd tl.e question
• r ere th~ la ding fee?
ti?·-1 r ,1 ,W!. o th"! aues:.ion,
1 1··,"'' 1 :> , ,LT le. ti. nc• tt' do, without
l lt '•c ~, h,lE eo ec.. 0 i:he Comm:i.1cion
r • i
r l ,. t ble •.,den gainst ti''9 "J : r
t, t- .; I t-h l,ndinq foe.
27
No"N, •h f c:t that Wi! arc opposing ea.ch other hei..-e,
a • the f t \. t , t indicnt " th t the fee is
C itutiv "" . t e r: ' inl'ir:ate th t i. ; is no-.:;, does "tot t.n t t t-h C harl'lo,y 1r1i h req 1:-:-C: to the
A ro1 lU c::, Cc i ·~ • '"hi? L r C no no·c wan. i:o
burd n • le c.' r ., ·o c, an • "i. £> ,i" tu I C' nnct co bu /\£ ts
n • w 1 p!:h~
"I ut \I y . f- ~o ' .. o re ir •. ql.i t~ble, but wh1
·1 i . '; C, Ii, ,..,r \ y 0~ rai~in, this rnone,y? .
') • l t cir .. ir,_., r at the .a.cronaut~.cs
C k i , cLnnet aff'o1d to ha,;,"' their lending
( t al: t1ir Ci I
1 , ."\Ste C. r.d ' c~tc~ that they wotld
t , o t Ol a u_ f c which would allow the
l"n tog o W\,Jl I r :,t j ;_,. tc :.. y, to'Tlorrow, o i: l'
C oJt of doing busin~Ja in Laconia.
C s ,•1ld ju'3t ob iate th<' m:.ccssity of getting
,_ l.? C C c?
., : • I . 1 l . ?t t.
0 iJ ir-
1 p i; p llC't:.ica •
th'-'r th n ir CI l 3 i I(! ,:h ir
,> it ur ,:k.r th, e isting 'l t:.e, tl'. is
' C, ' of r.aisi..,q the mcnc/ and charging
••
,
·-? hi l
t
. c, .. .
f'
I:
•
t'
C ' - ••
• , y
r 1 or
- , C
f
f
l y b"
5
C
' r
...
t
C'
8
c; • t r e , c,,: p -,f · · n?
t ti~ U'1d r tha r
cl- ?
t, Co r 0 1, ancl •rn not a
th '1 r t,a_ was civen to me
C i, \. ·- carrier to do..ib ('
y,:, 1 tr ir: .;o on1, .·.nc • me
t o. lL - t
'I' ot. It'o nn ea.,ie .. for ,.,cu
t rlin" . Iowever, in ~hi?
o- m is y u r~ <1fruid if you
rport C '1:h real
ir f' - a , .. bl lfil 's the
t t -'I, Cle) ?"e np-:,are·1tly
• filh y ·1r, f·?qten·ly re-
'I: C Ir rel .. nc<uis'l. s ito
L :CJ: , ,nd tt 'Y · re ex·r mal·
29
0 c 1y. An +- obl m thut s. vice -- they
i J d co1 i ra •., if a doub e o ... ·
t' ?" , to chy ea.
C , yQ l I t llcing about raicing the sam~
0 " lt .. f' t ... v. 1El,Ji3, on b~ .-nc.easing the
d' y re;,>e> i•1q .he type of dC that New
i? ,i. • i 't the ulti t bu de1 Otl the a.i.rlin.
n 0 t
.. £. u rd '1 on t le ai:eline, I ~hink
.1.y Ov - r, u r tl,e lamp. 're
, ) '>P e ll h rtir,e th burde 1
1 C t t
, i I ... Y"Ur. 1, • ny tha'i: the
(. . th cu. .r'l
, no,, th statu·e
+ o ~•t r.c-ease t1e burden on t
C , o.
t on o ·he cu. :r, £ r?
• u . 1 'j,l: iot:>i; nq herein s"lall
i p ,f on thJ <U toter.
p 0.1, isl' i· it?
, , t t' th) two ai,,pellants
, 1 1 ':. Ii r g .cd to the other air
0 • ,
0 •
t
t r:
f
i
. ' ll p "l
r
' I
bi.
i
y
to
1 a er, 0 i r
r~ is.
nr, ?n th F rti 1 'lr d l ar
C n1.:.&r d b ·o .i. ;_ s
~nn numbe . cf )3opl~ -~hat ge
t 0 0~
j C
t, d n
ld
ti y n:i.ch. no ..
t . ?
the" rlin?
·i h
-S
diff
30
ee,
ow.
on.
nee
s . t on . HOWLVCr, ;'_ f
--:-i y for
i i if tl'ere ·· 3 a land· ng fee:
hinlt :h t. 1i_l go on
• t i~CI s OU~ of t,e CAB.
, i · uo l x ps so. - t 1 t ink
.t in e e out of C\B, , . C
q
! t.
, n tl'E c 1 pass n a
t~ a rot, ncrea~e out ~f th CAB?
"t t
31
r t ti t t:h'r, ax isl vied
ri :.he co 1t ract
ri ti 11 e, th r is.~ rtic4la-ly
o. 1 ,. C rt"i r ,.,c th ir li-.; li'hood,
"I M g 1 l ui t y' e · nc 0 lt Lll the ti e: I
I y 0 t . • n . th ti Iiampi:.hire
C ·1 0 .:h ..:: ,ang..a cf
PC"r n tc e, 1e DC-3 \""-S
C r I I We. y 1 and "lC, I
• c- •
0 tt a:!r c1rri app ars
ch ; of th i port. So most
!'l r at dl!al of the operating ex-
c .. that th I, ai,:ports are,
• • o • 2, , hether the s· fety
d, b us the c3rqo here is
(' ;y d vie ' of courte wou:.a l:e
\ l rcia .. li t • • th.i.nk it•~
' 'h . the: rr . rcic.l flights •
tute r -· an • ed it is
0 cct nd proper J! e fee levied
by th w.i ht 1easurad by
th c,r .i...._r that is the wear and
v, l d, I o, 2, the bencf.i.\:
I:!
b I: • C .. y.
, t • r C sr , '.i, y b U1. a nt
t JC h y id, F 1 'i ula · ly in £' I { p. hir
t t, 1 0 , t y y V y U'l J , ne t o~f ith
C' ?. t V<- iv. t ·i. ic be l 1·C, ch y
le' }' t . (;. ck l'l or eopl So t·ho 1:-e fit •
J. , . u , t car nd t ur d he
-· f" i j ---~- 1 c·2v by
, c.y ic': ;1.
'f . , 0 a 1 d1nq ..:ee i n't
' l ,
.J d r t e c rrier dep mc1inq on two
, n : th nt C h < ircra ·· 'le! t,~, n · ny ::,eople go i:
t. t F< qh ?
. '. riqht. Y ,; , yo •'re ··ight.
l ... nt a out h
¥-,. l.S OU' opinion and • ... _
V to - su1· '.:l-e iJ~nefit
!:. :c fo • in ' nc wh thcr I e - ,
n .. c:nin f r taki:.o~f . ee, < .!
C I in l. an a ard ick to
or , in ffi'J opinion, iG would be
llX the en1-lar ent. a d
t l •n. and 0 fo ·t , b_c ... use
33
) i . l \ ' ou l 1 a , '':. o ld he out of
p
I • 1C nc )Our
0 • +- V i_rr, n:;.)tl or, t C, C rrie-~,.., and ·he
Cl .'l - U!C1G u. ' of' '1 • .ilk iG . 0 t:h.i.n s: I
\ •i t of - p nd 110' -~,y i o:,1" qot ab~a .. d d1: hat
r
i '-= C ,n er i l, ,rroc •
( t t (. t. 0 I o4: p - 'i.ng 01 the
i ,;,t J p 0 1 • ho got aloard at
t acl; i. ,t .i.t?
,;,~t>t.
n 3 • C "Cr·· r do, th .:::vmmon carriers co,
- u ..... . . t I oh~ k a,1d Nort,1 < t
I ,. • t's r· ht, tt. •., 0 0 thet;i.
., u v · t:.11 rn up ttcrc?
in, tt' u w c'c· to· week ha! is •
i tt" t titr .::lc,w ther.i.
• r t_;_,;
c ca.r1c~~, are there?
c-. t. 11cl- r rri .i: , and they , re
.1 - h -~ •r, ~'-Y ,re not tax~d.
,.:. · r , 'r urcl i.· a carcllin
Q
.. r
0
l ,.
th t • r.
l
... l
't :?
c.;
..,
j
i
"J u
t.
-o
t' b . ' i d .. •:n lit '
: 0
f 1
,
. f<. y n
h -' I C.
h C
• u . ...
- I 1 0
t a
-.
y l c" .. c·· r ... : .r,
,.:
·o t.h fee mcl zo C, do nc:.:..
' t>n·· • UC'gL :>n by nny of the
t i . I;;_ iliconsis·':( ,t
I , 'I , ·" E' C F?
th'n:· tc• '? "-''ao a ugc s-
. .,t \ _o FS:,' ~"" t. - ':' f that .. oner . " ,> I bec .. uac of
r · uh · to r . - I ' ·nc1 OVCI the. ugn
__ n e Hi h(.y (; n alte th~ rai:.e'3,
, l l.
1 :I, 't 'l r ne pa.,s on a lanc'i.ng
· r .& to r ute law lllld, in n y
d o f'l • c n,.,t:i.tu~.:.onal --
y COU. l n~ i;s it•
~c t~tory, ttcuq1? How abott --
r p n .. ti t ::.s t.ak(.n ir.to
- .... I h ,'1' t i '•?
•~ -,! ht.
I not l , 'f they have bee~
.I I •
< 5
I . ible,
l r
n
t g
(' , ld.
(I l 0 t • 0 b' v ... y 0
•
0
n .. , or . '1 t.
0 as e're
l t 0 C' Lrg ll c;i_ carr e.
t, it sue ... to re k it
-I; I th ~E! e rort of hir :J
• \ f) th air Ce r.1.er.
C , - • 1 ag· e. :i:t's an --b• s ri 's:h - airl ·n
it tr> t 1£ ic~s an
r: • I d f re faro?
0 I (. ul
i '\ C • c,i it, tr y?
g
36
. no i ... ' l ' . ... '.'"a V ... ) • . I 1 'l p ,1 "l\.
T OU thin. tt y t · _1 ptob,bly go t h.i
t. t wh h y re ab-orb ·.ng, thc:i, will zuy is
of th .. . \ f •• e,: ) r.:>Ur i or r'l s •
: ce in .. • 11.. ' t y (, i. l
l.
,_ .J
, _c, , .,.tap l' ,;omecne
r that th~ ,JUl'in't "l ss i'
•
I t t n ") way tcl~s th , , in
nn h t ··Ji y do pas& it on
• C n ' y - - i:.ain I jU!li:
·t r .,y Q1! ·!:i io.~ that the l ir-. ; ch requir •fJ the &:i :.1 ii C to
·t b h d f, -~,g, ic:- ·t
t
o. V r i I do ro krow if i-.; is
; , 't c1.l CC-l t to say this
,l C n(Jfl!' ..... •
.. C, th to •
, J t, -- r • I ou"d even say
• t u ' •• ro ·hi1 h ::-e shall
p,: v nt ·i;h
wh .t o V 1• l th N'-' , . p~.,-· r la,1 •
. _T."e. I ._gr .e. You c·n i .czc· ,..e r.:>ur
1" oing f( .. i ~1'o i:. int . f ,: · ng t ·.th D.ny::hinq the Congress is
do ,1g?
l , I: Ri.rt.
1. - 'Ii •. you';· c m. g_;_ng ."I a:i.rL ne
I, : .. c.
. L' .. i
- l'. t.: • 1 ·'s cic;ht. Absolui:cl~• right.
(' , i::'1.. 'i · :i.n~ i:i free <·o do ~.hat it w .. ntf· to
o "th i.:?
.. • D t :
- ' t !: "I. .:. t. i
) .... <Y .oc . e, , es .
il t E CAI ·~ll.; ·c·:1em ·::.r .. ey car 't
. t'..
C ii::?
, .r ·- i. cur posi. t::.on. We e.re not:
I :i. on,~ d \e don't restrict i:he fact
•
( l .~ :;, c: vou i:.re i 'f·rent fl.-cm tte
i ?
llN: Oh y Tn Ia o-:>.i. .i.r ll rn 're C'Oi!S 't.l:;o· E bly
ff~. t •
• l l •;:; .. no iJ .. ... of the 1,ew Har~p~h:i~re
'3 t L .. O ,; ,;i ' .. ~L'Y.lCJ 0 1lt that the Cl.B sayr :he
-:.n t' ?
' hi! . u .• 'l:h t ~lOUl i 1:-t my o,>i,1::.on.
. ., I JS :t '"'t;:t.t .e, 1.md th• ,;~ atuto·:y rch<me,
l , .. ·1 .. .1.t l 1t _c '1~ton )',,,( a to pi. SC,
si \'lly t , .,a r.r t. tlie carr ,c, non lii:;ci:iminatcly
ie--s 11hctt er i;hc: • .:re intr,'!sta .e
o. in~ r't I
t ·lr·;ht ·.- .i.z .;e:· '.at: , fo,:- the 1.-enef!.ts t~ey have ;:ecci' ed
il 1.. :t
<.
,
p
'·
•
'
.
, .
•
t :i.:. , .. t th< St'l+: • re~<:'i vc~ rnur.t go to
C. 1>J0 th r rd to the .. unds ~:hat go to
< l eithet' ~.oe.s t) zJ ,=- nav!.ga·tioiwl
tt t beun spcn~ fo: d.t· n«'';.gational
::, < r , • k :· tist t ei.ic t ;_on: 1..·c •:he airlines
i: c. h ,r ;:
[i.: i
p~ss·ng th tax ,nor-not?
re pn3sin,, the
p :!.on ·tum the last t · !t';,3 -- fror.1 the case .
1 t C fl i osi.t i.on simply ~r: this ;ic "- u Je
i is ,il.Ot • -::sar-ly !l. .ee agninat
•i;. . p --~ "Io
0 d
a d -:, . 0 I'.'
• • l . Ct\
t
• .. f , ... ~I,_; t .. m
,.
for t1hic~ cl '
,,... r "c _
I • . ,
'
r
'• l
-,., . ,._
•
9
ve ... , 'W do
. •;• !. I 0 of y L J hcth.r i . '
':tJ 's r-icth~.
CC' 11 n ·t ·op . ·r, -Jn :'i. .. -.> l.A:inq- ; ' ; on?
o. ,., i c1i r,' Ile ~ot J.dn ''l:.
(' . u' I •• i:VX'C ' h ''ll t> as.;; it on?
ot \.!'I .. ·ct • . .. tl~u••u, .10 • ;:ma ,ie do not ..
it C
•'•h W-1, o·.:, . f'acilit ,,,. e.t the aii:-oo·t . ..
i~ m c_, ob r'htion p:'.al fOl"lll, is th;.s
,h'
9 _) 1 · , • e h VC/, in rt.y O?i 'l~·.on, what i: kno:1
t, : o,. -:, - thn "i ·ports, m.d ·.:h,.y
.,, Ti ga•·, to 1 mdinq l)f ger.<o:,:al
i
v • i;,l n s. t~c··:, t.h.:rt fee , as
, iz .bout . :Jhl: '· ·mes greater at some
P with r g ard to tJ-~ co!!IIT'.a;:-cial
1 bi - o:cc to 1 and a r ,mer al pt·ivate
'1 • t-11 ·, >i:cv r-··s •:he Sta·ce or a
; r;·' J ·t. 1.. r c ; '1CJ foe j . "che "rcccs:.; c f
0
1 ri ' t l t. tl Y r:iy - . h t • ;nob m?
. . 0 , gr - • Ne , i:.t i '; is not
, n't i .. itis a constii:u-
i i , t o' - n. or. Flt.-: it's en
1 i i l t • l ... h :l e n 9c-t · a ..
t l ,, d 0' \.. · r'fic lly poor se-•v· e
t ' , s t i .. . l ' .. ,,~ .... J - ... a face ( f
l 0 ·t··c i I' n the munic:i.1 alities
:ce a d il Ii..
t ., f , t: r.por<-,, i;i'ere 1 re .. C
, h -~ no .:1i f 1: ni: tnan anr other ,
) • t -i. t . q poin-c is 1 hat .
o .. .. n f l for a ,;ich du:ed
elv $1.67 per la.1c.ing;
t' C: r. .I. , i;o > ~ou.nds, $l:2 for
vi i re- . f 0 lcn~.
e js a cert 'n :mo mt of ·1acmony bet1een
.,. C .. r ';. We, 1 an•;_ -::r £ ir
' ,. i 'e' y ~r,q t r ··ov--( e
•
t l ly tr . " cl ve1:~ r} t 1ir g
, , • 'l: i .; . ·.' . .:, ~ly u~e fee
- C it' f)I' >Vid C..
• u T', 'k you, ;,tr. Dunn.
, l
h n ye u, .. 1,::- .. Mi:.l" o ... y •
'1'1 C G i 'I i tttac •
(l t. u on, ·- ll· 2 o'c ... C ' •. n. , i:he cast- ' c..S
'"U i +-s
