31
1 N I E H T D E T I N U S E T A T S T C I R T S I D T R U O C R O F E H T T C I R T S I D F O G N I M O Y W E E R F H C E E P S , f f i t n i a l P , E S A C . O N 2 1-V C- 7 2 1 - S W S VS. R E B O T C O , 3 2 1 0 2 8 2 : 8 . M . A - 5 0 : 9 . M . A L A R E D E F N O I T C E L E N O I S S I M M O C , R E P S A C , G N I M O Y W t n a d n e f e D . T P I R C S N A R T F O C I N O H P E L E T L A R O G N I L U R N O S ' F F I T N I A L P N O I T O M R O F Y R A N I M I L E R P N O I T C N U J N I E R O F E B E H T E L B A R O N O H T T O C S . W L H A D V A K S D E T I N U S E T A T S T C I R T S I D E G D U J : S E C N A R A E P P A r o F : f f i t n i a l P n h o J . B t h g i e p S 1 2 0 4 r e d y n S , e n n e y e h C g n i m o y W 1 0 0 2 8 n e h p e t S . R n i e l K G N I M O Y W Y T R E B I L P U O R G 2 0 9 1 s e m o h T , e u n e v A S e t i u 1 0 2 , e n n e y e h C g n i m o y W 1 0 0 2 8 n i m a j n e B . T r r a B 7 3 7 0 1 g n i t n u H e n a L , e l l i v k c o R d n a l y r a M 0 5 8 0 2 r o F : t n a d n e f e D n i r E . R k a p o l h C d i v a D . B r e k l o K v a d A i t o N L A R E D E F N O I T C E L E N O I S S I M M O C 9 9 9 E t e e r t S W N , n o t g n i h s a W C D 3 6 4 0 2 s a l o h c i N o l l a s s a V D E T I N U S E T A T S E N R O T T A S ' Y E C I F F O . PO. x o B 8 6 6 , e n n e y e h C g n i m o y W 3 0 0 2 8 - 8 6 6 0

IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

1

NI EHT DETINU SETATS TCIRTSID TRUOC ROF EHT TCIRTSID FO GNIMOYW

EERF HCEEPS ,

ffitnialP , ESAC .ON 21 - VC - 721 - SWS

VS. REBOTCO ,3 2102 82:8 .M.A - 50:9 .M.A

LAREDEF NOITCELE NOISSIMMOC , REPSAC , GNIMOYW

tnadnefeD .

TPIRCSNART FO CINOHPELET LARO GNILUR NO S'FFITNIALP NOITOM ROF YRANIMILERP NOITCNUJNI

EROFEB EHT ELBARONOH TTOCS .W LHADVAKS DETINU SETATS TCIRTSID EGDUJ

:SECNARAEPPA

roF :ffitnialP nhoJ .B thgiepS 1204 redynS

,enneyehC gnimoyW 10028

nehpetS .R nielK GNIMOYW YTREBIL PUORG

2091 semohT ,eunevA S etiu 102,enneyehC gnimoyW 10028

nimajneB .T rraB 73701 gnitnuH enaL

,ellivkcoR dnalyraM 05802

roF :tnadnefeD nirE .R kapolhC divaD .B rekloK

vadA itoN LAREDEF NOITCELE NOISSIMMOC

999 E teertS WN ,notgnihsaW CD 36402

salohciN ollassaV DETINU SETATS ENROTTA S'Y ECIFFO

.P O. xoB 866 ,enneyehC gnimoyW 30028 - 8660

Page 2: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

2

1 :SECNARAEPPA )2 fo 2 egaP(

2 :yB detropeR eimaJ .L ,hcirdneH RSC - RPR - RRC laiciffO laredeF truoC retropeR

3 .U S. tcirtsiD esuohtruoC 111 htuoS ,ttocloW mooR 712

4 ,repsaC gnimoyW 10628 )703( 562 - 25 08

5

6

7

8

9

01

11

21

31

41

51

61

71

81

91

02

12

22

32

42

52

Page 3: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

3

1 NOITATIC XEDNI

2 v nitsuA . nagihciM rebmahC fo ecremmoC , 494 .S.U ,256 0991 ...................................... 6

3 dawA .v xairiZ , 076 d3.F ,1111 ta ,5211

4 01( ht riC . )2102 .......... .............................. . 51

5 yelkcuB v. oelaV , 424 .S.U ,1 6791 ...................... 7

6 detinU snezitiC v. CEF , 855 .S.U ,013 031 ,678.tC.S 0102 ........................ 6

7 CEF .v lavivruS noitacudE ,dnuF detaroprocnI ,

8 2( 592 ta ,582 d3.F 56 d riC . )5991 ...................... . 91

9 v CEF . nisnocsiW thgiR ot efiL , 155 .S.U ,944 7002 ...................................... 8

01 llennoCcM .v laredeF noitcelE noissimmoC ,

11 S.U 045 . ,39 3002 ....................................... 6

21 Y ocixeM weN v dezinagrO htuo . arerreH , 116 d3.F ,966 676 01( ht tiucriC )0102 ................... . 71

31 ehT laeR hturT tuobA ,noitrobA .cnI .v

41 noissimmoC noitcelE laredeF 555 ,445 d3.F 186 , 4( ht .riC )2102 ........................................ .. 11

51 retniW .v larutaN ecruoseR esnefeD licnuoC ,

61 S.U 555 . 7 ta ,02 8002 .................................. 51

71

81

91

02

12

22

32

42

52

Page 4: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

4

1 TRUOC EHT : dooG ,gninrom .lesnuoc

2 :RRAB .RM dooG ,gninrom ruoY .ronoH

3 :KAPOLHC .SM dooG .gninrom

4 TRUOC EHT : truoC si in noisses ni eht rettam fo eerF

5 hceepS susrev eht laredeF noitcelE ,noissimmoC esaC rebmuN

6 21 - VC - .721 I eton eht ecneserp fo .rM ,thgiepS .rM nielK dna

7 .rM rraB no flaheb fo sffitnialp -- ffitnialp dna eht ecneserp

8 fo .rM ,rekloK .sM kapolhC dna rM . itoN no flaheb fo eht

9 ,tnadnefed laredeF noitcelE .noissimmoC

10 sihT rettam semoc erofeb eht truoC no s'ffitnialp

11 noitom rof yranimilerp evitcnujni feiler tnausrup ot eluR 56 fo

21 eht laredeF seluR fo liviC .erudecorP ,ffitnialP desab nopu

31 ella deg tnemegnirfni fo sti lanoitutitsnoc ,sthgir skees ot

41 evah siht truoC niojne ,tnadnefed eht laredeF noitcelE

51 ,noissimmoC morf tnemecrofne fo suoirav yrotaluger snoisivorp

61 dna .seicilop ehT truoC sdnif dna sredro sa :swollof

17 sA ot eht uorgkcab dn ni siht ,rettam ffitnialP eerF

81 hceepS si na ,detaroprocninu tiforpnon noitaicossa demrof no

91 yraurbeF ,12 ,2102 dna si desirpmoc fo eerht gnimoyW .stnediser

02 eerF s'hceepS detats noissim si ot etomorp dna tcetorp eerf

12 ,hceeps detimil nemnrevog t dna yllanoitutitsnoc --

22 lanoitutitsnoc ytilibatnuocca dna ot etacovda snoitisop no

32 suoirav lacitilop ,seussi gnidulcni eerf ,hceeps latnemnorivne

42 ,ycilop nug ,sthgir dnal sthgir dna lortnoc revo lanosrep

52 .erachtlaeh stI swalyb eriuqer taht ti etarepo yltnednepedni

Page 5: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

5

1 fo lacitilop ,setadidnac seettimmoc dna lacitilop .seitrap eeS

2 eht tnialpmoC , shpargaraP 1 dna ,01 dna tibihxE A ot tibihxE .1

3 eerF hceepS skees ot nur suoirav stnemesitrevda gnisserdda

4 lacitilop seussi dna skees ot agne eg ni gnisiardnuf morf rehto

5 ekil - dednim slaudividni ot troppus sti snoitisop hguorht cilbup

6 .aidem

7 nO yluJ ,62 ,2102 ffitnialp delif siht ,noitca

8 gnignellahc niatrec CEF snoitaluger taht ffitnialp segella

9 egdirba sti tsriF tnemdnemA .smodeerf pS ,yllacifice ffitnialp

01 sgnirb laicaf dna sa" "deilppa segnellahc tsniaga 11 ,R.F.C

11 noitceS ,)b(22.001 gnigella sti noitinifed fo sserpxe"

21 "ycacovda si yllanoitutitsnocnu eugav dna ylrevo daorb dna

31 sreggirt emosnedrub noitartsiger dna gnitroper r stnemeriuqe

41 hcihw tca sa eht lanoitcnuf tnelaviuqe fo a roirp tniartser fo

51 lacitilop .hceeps

16 ffitnialP rehtruf segnellahc eht ytilanoitutitsnoc fo

71 eht s'CEF noitaterpretni dna tnemecrofne ssecorp gnidrager

81 lacitilop eettimmoc ,sutats ticilos noita ,stset eht rojam"

91 "esoprup tset dna sserpxe ycacovda .snoitanimreted eeS

02 tnialpmoC , hpargaraP .2

21 nI redro ot dnatsrednu dna ezylana eht seussi ,desiar

22 ti si lufpleh ot yal tuo eht elbacilppa yrotutats dna

32 yrotaluger krowemarf dna ulove noit fo wal gnitceffa lacitilop

42 sngiapmac dna .snoitcele tI si osla lufpleh ot ,yfitnedi ot

52 eht tnetxe ,elba eht deviecrep slive thguos ot eb deliatruc yb

Page 6: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

6

1 siht tes fo ngiapmac .swal ehT yramirp esoprup fo eht laredeF

2 noitcelE ngiapmaC tcA fo ,1791 retfaniereh ehT" "tcA ro ",ACEF"

3 saw ot timil eht ytilautca dna ecnaraeppa fo noitpurroc

4 gnitluser morf eht gnivig fo egral smus fo yenom dna eht

5 gnidneps fo yenom ni lacitilop sngiapmac rof laredef .eciffo

6 ,suhT rednu eltiT ,2 detinU setatS ,edoC noitceS ,a144

7 snoitatimil era desopmi nopu eht tnuoma fo snoitubirtnoc taht

8 nac eb edam yltcerid ot setadidnac rof laredef eciffo dna eht

9 serutidnepxe taht a etadidnac yam ekam ni gninnur rof .eciffo

01 erehT erew osla snrecnoc gnidrager pedni tnedne serutidnepxe

11 hcihw erew ton edam yb a etadidnac rof laredef eciffo tub

21 sselehtenon a nosrep gnitacovda rof eht noitcele ro taefed fo a

31 ylraelc deifitnedi .etadidnac esehT tnednepedni ,serutidnepxe

41 ni ,trap evig esir ot eht seussi erofeb eht truoC ni siht .esac

15 roirP ot eht detinU setatS emerpuS s'truoC noisiced ni

61 detinU snezitiC susrev laredeF noitcelE noissimmoC , 031 emerpuS

71 truoC ,678 ,0102 eht laredef wal detibihorp snoitaroproc dna

81 snoinu morf gnisu yrusaert ,sdnuf ,yenom ot ekam tnednepedni

91 serutidnepxe rof hceeps taht saw rehtie denifed sa

02 gnireenoitcele noitacinummoc ro rof hceeps ylsserpxe gnitacovda

12 eht noitcele ro taefed fo a .etadidnac sihT noisulcerp no

22 etaroproc serutidnepxe rof gnireenoitcele cinummoc snoita saw

32 dlehpu ni llennoCcM susrev laredeF noitcelE noissimmoC , 045

42 .S.U ,39 .3002 ,revewoH ni gniod ,os eht emerpuS truoC deiler

52 nopu sti roirp gnidloh ni nitsuA susrev nagihciM rebmahC fo

Page 7: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

7

1 ecremmoC , 494 .S.U ,256 0991 emerpuS truoC siced noi hcihw

2 dlehpu eht etatS fo s'nagihciM tcerid noitcirtser no eht

3 tnednepedni serutidnepxe fo sdnuf yb a noitaroproc taht

4 detroppus ro desoppo yna etadidnac rof etats .eciffo

5 nI detinU snezitiC , eht emerpuS truoC delurrevo sti

6 noisiced ni itsuA n dna dleh lanoitutitsnocnu eltiT ,2 detinU

7 setatS ,edoC noitceS s'b144 snoitcirtser no etaroproc

8 tnednepedni .serutidnepxe nI ,noitidda eht truoC ni snezitiC

9 detinU delurrevo taht noitrop fo llennoCcM hcihw dah dlehpu

01 stnemdnema ot noitceS )b(613 fo ,ACEF gnidulcerp snoitaroproc

11 dna snoinu morf gnisu rieht lareneg yrusaert ,sdnuf ,yenom ot

21 ecnanif gnireenoitcele .snoitacinummoc eeS detinU snezitiC ta

31 ;319 llennoCcM ta 302 hguorht .502

14 etipseD siht noisulcnoc no eht noisulcerp fo

51 pxe ,serutidne ti si yllauqe fi ton erom tnacifingis ot eht

61 smialc ni siht esac ot eton tahw eht truoC ni detinU snezitiC

71 dnuof saw yllanoitutitsnoc .elbissimrep nI detinU snezitiC ,

81 ereht saw osla a egnellahc edam ot eht remialcsid dna

91 erusolcsid r stnemeriuqe rednu eltiT ,2 detinU setatS ,edoC

02 noitceS .d144 nI gnizylana eseht remialcsid dna erusolcsid

12 ,stnemeriuqer eht truoC ni detinU snezitiC :deton remialcsiD"

22 dna erusolcsid stnemeriuqer yam nedrub eht ytiliba ot ,kaeps

32 tub yeht esopmi on gniliec no ngiapmac - detaler ",seitivitca

42 gnitic yelkcuB , 424 .S.U ta ,46 dna od" ton tneverp enoyna morf

52 ",gnikaeps gnitic llennoCcM , arpus , ta .102 ehT truoC sah

Page 8: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

8

1 hcihw "yniturcs gnitcaxe" ot stnemeriuqer eseht detcejbus

2 sbus" a seriuqer erusolcsid eht neewteb "noitaler laitnat

3 .tseretni latnemnrevog "tnatropmi yltneiciffus" a dna deriuqer

4 yelkcuB , arpus .46 ta , ehT truoC tnew ,no ni detinU snezitiC ,

5 stnemeriuqer remialcsid dna erusolcsid eht taht edulcnoc ot

6 r ,lanoitutitsnoc erew ni sisylana sti gnimriffae llennoCcM sa

7 .snoisivorp erusolcsid eht ot deniatrep ti .dI ta .519

8 ehT esac wal sah osla nward snoitcnitsid neewteb

9 .ycacovda eussi dna ycacovda ngiapmac oT taht ,tnetxe ni

01 R nisnocsiW susrev noissimmoC noitcelE laredeF efiL ot thgi ,

11 S.U 155 . ,944 eht emerpuS ,truoC ni ,7002 dleh taht yrotutats

21 stnemesitrevda ot sdnuf etaroproc fo esu eht no snoitcirtser

31 ot desoppo sa stnemesitrevda "ycacovda eussi" erew taht

41 .lanoitutitsnocnu erew "ycacovda sserpxe"

15 nI aer gnihc taht ,noisulcnoc eht truoC deton taht eht

61 sserpxe fo tnelaviuqe lanoitcnuf" eht ton saw eussi ta hceeps

71 ".hceeps ngiapmac yfitsuj ot dleh stseretni eht ,suhT

81 lanoitcnuf sti ro hceeps ngiapmac etaroproc gnitcirtser

91 itsuj ton did tnelaviuqe "ycacovda eussi" eht gnitcirtser yf

02 ni devlovni hceeps efiL ot thgiR nisnocsiW . nI gnikam siht

12 htiw detaicossa sregnad eht taht deton truoC eht ,noitcnitsid

22 seod tnelaviuqe lanoitcnuf sti ro hceeps ngiapmac ro ycacovda

32 ot tcepser htiw tsixe ton .ycacovda eussi eeS nisnocsiW thgiR

42 efiL ot .074 ta , tI si dniheb siht llaw fo tnedecerp taht eht

52 .derusaem eb tsum smialc s'ffitnialp fo tirem ehT noitinifed

Page 9: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

9

1 fo eseht smret si tnatropmi ot eht sisylana fo eht seussi

2 .detneserp

3 rednU eht laredeF noitcelE ngiapmaC tcA fo ,1791

4 tnednepedni" "erutidnepxe si denifed sa na" erutidnepxe

5 ylsserpxe gnitacovda eht noitcele ro taefed fo a ylraelc

6 deifitnedi "etadidnac dna ton edam yb ro ni noitanidrooc htiw a

7 etadidnac ro lacitilop ytrap ro .eettimmoc eeS eltiT ,2 detinU

8 setatS ,edoC noitceS .)71(134

9 nA "erutidnepxe" si denifed sa yna" ,esahcrup ,tnemyap

01 ,noitubirtsid ,naol ,ecnavda tisoped ro tfig fo yenom ro

11 gnihtyna fo eulav edam yb yna nosrep rof eht sesoprup fo

21 gnicneulfni a yn noitcele rof laredef ".eciffo eeS noitceS

31 ,)i()A()9(134 eltiT .2

14 rednU 11 ,R.F.C noitceS ,22.001 ylsserpxe" "gnitacovda

51 si denifed sa yna noitacinummoc taht )a( sesu sesarhp hcus sa

61 etov" rof eht ",tnediserp tceleer" ruoy ",namssergnoc ppus" tro

71 eht citarcomeD ",eenimon tsac" ruoy tollab rof eht nacilbupeR

81 regnellahc rof .S.U etaneS ni ",aigroeG htimS" rof ",ssergnoC

91 lliB" yaKcM ni ",49' etov" orp - "efil ro etov" orp - "eciohc

02 deinapmocca yb a gnitsil fo ylraelc deifitnedi setadidnac

12 debircsed sa orp - efil ro orp - ,eciohc etov" tsniaga dlO

22 ";yrokciH "taefed" deinapmocca yb a erutcip fo eno ro erom

32 ;setadidnac tcejer" eht "tnebmucni ro snoitacinummoc fo

42 ngiapmac snagols ro laudividni sdrow hcihw ni txetnoc nac evah

52 on rehto elbanosaer gninaem naht ot egru eht noitcele ro taefed

Page 10: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

01

1 fo eno ro erom ylraelc deifitnedi setadidnac hcus sa ,sretsop

2 repmub ,srekcits ,stnemesitrevda te ,aretec hcihw ,yas s'noxiN"

3 eht ;"eno retraC" ;"67' "hsuB/nagaeR" ro ;"!eladnoM" ro

4 sbuS noitce )b( fo noitceS 22.001 hcihw :sedivorp nehW" nekat

5 sa a elohw dna htiw detimil ecnerefer ot lanretxe ,stneve hcus

6 sa eht ytimixorp ot eht ,noitcele dluoc ylno eb deterpretni yb

7 a elbanosaer nosrep sa gniniatnoc ycacovda fo eht noitcele ro

8 fed tae fo eno ro erom ylraelc deifitnedi setadidnac ,esuaceb

9 ,eno eht larotcele noitrop fo eht noitacinummoc si

01 ,elbakatsimnu suougibmanu dna evitseggus fo ylno eno ;gninaem

11 ,dna ,owt elbanosaer sdnim dluoc ton reffid sa ot rehtehw ti

21 segaruocne ca snoit ot tcele ro taefed eno ro erom ylraelc

31 deifitnedi setadidnac ro segaruocne emos rehto dnik fo .noitca

14 A nosrep ro ,noitazinagro rehto naht a lacitilop

51 ,eettimmoc taht secnanif tnednepedni serutidnepxe gnitagergga

61 erom naht 052$ a radnelac raey si deriuqer ot elif htiw eht CEF

71 a erusolcsid troper taht ,seifitnedi aila retni , eht etad dna

81 tnuoma fo hcae erutidnepxe dna enoyna ohw detubirtnoc revo 002$

91 ot rehtruf .ti eeS detinU setatS ,edoC noitceS )c(434 fo

02 eltiT ;2 dna 11 .R.F.C , noitceS .)e(01.901

21 ehT tcA rehtruf senifed a lacitilop" ",eettimmoc

22 ylnommoc nwonk sa a ",CAP" sa yna" ,eettimmoc ,bulc noitaicossa

32 ro rehto puorg fo snosrep hcihw seviecer snoitubirtnoc

42 gnitagergga ni ssecxe fo 000,1$ gnirud a radnelac raey ro hcihw

52 sekam serutidnepxe gnitagergga ni ssecxe fo 000,1$ gnirud a

Page 11: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

11

1 radnelac ".raey eltiT ,2 detinU setatS ,edoC noitceS

2 .)A()4(134 ehT smret "serutidnepxe" dna "snoitubirtnoc" ,era

3 ni ,nrut denifed ot ssapmocne yna gnidneps ro gnisiardnuf rof"

4 eht esoprup fo gnicneulfni yna noitcele rof laredef ".eciffo

5 eeS snoitceS )i()A()8(134 dna .)i()A()9(134

6 nI yelkcuB susrev oelaV , 424 .S.U ,1 ,6791 eht emerpuS

7 truoC deworran eht yrotutats noitinifed fo a ,CAP gnitimil sti

8 hcaer ot ylno" cne ssapmo snoitazinagro taht era rednu eht

9 lortnoc fo a etadidnac ro eht rojam' 'esoprup fo hcihw si eht

01 noitanimon ro noitcele fo a .etadidnac nA noitazinagro taht si

11 ton dellortnoc yb a etadidnac tsum erofereht retsiger sa a CAP

21 fi sti itubirtnoc sno ro serutidnepxe deecxe 000,1$ dna sti

31 rojam' 'esoprup si eht noitanimon ro noitcele fo a laredef

41 ".etadidnac eeS ehT laeR hturT tuobA ,noitrobA .cnI susrev

51 laredeF noitcelE noissimmoC , 186 d3.F ,445 ,555 htruoF tiucriC

61 2102 ,noisiced niereh retfa " AATR ".

17 lacitiloP seettimmoc tsum ylpmoc htiw niatrec

81 lanoitazinagro dna erusolcsid .stnemeriuqer yehT tsum retsiger

91 htiw eht CEF dna elif cidoirep stroper rof erusolcsid ot eht

02 cilbup fo rieht latot gnitarepo sesnepxe dna hsac no dnah sa

12 llew sa rieht stpiecer dna stnemesrubsid htiw detimil

22 snoitpecxe rof tsom snoitcasnart woleb a 002 - rallod .dlohserht

32 eeS eltiT ,2 detinU setatS ,edoC snoitceS 334 dna .434 hcaE

42 CAP tsum evah a rerusaert ohw sniatniam sti sdrocer dna a

52 rapes yleta detangised knab .tnuocca sCAP osla tsum ,esolcsid

Page 12: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

21

1 ni rieht ylraluger deludehcs ,stroper lanoitidda noitamrofni

2 tuoba rieht tnednepedni ,serutidnepxe gnidulcni eht ,etad

3 tnuoma dna setadidnac detroppus ro desoppo rof hcae tnednepedni

4 pxe erutidne revo ,002$ snoitceS ,)iii()H()4()b(434 .)iii()B()6(

5 ,yllanoitiddA sCAP tsum yfitnedi sevlesmeht hguorht sremialcsid

6 no lla fo rieht cilbup lacitilop ,gnisitrevda no rieht etisbew

7 dna ni ssam .sliame 11 ,R.F.C noitceS .)1()a(11.011

8 nI ,7002 retfa gniredisnoc dna gniviecer cilbup

9 ,stnemmoc eht CEF dediced ton ot etaglumorp a wen noitinifed fo

01 lacitilop" "eettimmoc tub daetsni ot eunitnoc sti gnidnatsgnol

11 ecitcarp fo gninimreted hcae s'noitazinagro rojam esoprup

21 hguorht a esac - yb - ac es sisylana fo na s'noitazinagro .tcudnoc

31 ehT dehsilbup eciton fo siht noisiced denialpxe taht elihw eht

41 rojam" "esoprup tset nac eb deifsitas hguorht" yltneiciffus

51 evisnetxe gnidneps no laredef ngiapmac ",ytivitca 27 laredeF

61 retsigeR ,5955 065 ,1 a tcaf - evisnetni sisylana fo hcae

71 s'noitazinagro ,tcudnoc gnidulcni cilbup ,stnemetats

81 gnisiardnuf slaeppa dna gnidneps no rehto ,ytivitca nac eb

91 evitcurtsni ni gnitaulave eht s'noitazinagro ngiapmac

02 seitivitca derapmoc ot sti seitivitca rnu detale ot .sngiapmac

12 .dI ta 1065 hguorht .206

22 ehT tcA senifed "noitubirtnoc" ot edulcni yna" ,tfig

32 ,noitpircsbus ,naol ecnavda ro tisoped fo yenom ro gnihtyna fo

42 eulav edam yb yna nosrep rof eht sesoprup fo gnicneulfni yna

52 noitcele rof redef la ".eciffo 2 detinU setatS ,edoC noitceS

Page 13: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

31

1 .)i()A()8(134 ehT tcA seriuqer yna" "nosrep ohw sticilos" yna

2 noitubirtnoc hguorht yna gnitsacdaorb ,noitats ,repapswen

3 ,enizagam roodtuo gnisitrevda ,ytilicaf gniliam ro yna rehto

4 epyt fo lareneg bup cil lacitilop "gnisitrevda ot edulcni a

5 deificeps remialcsid ni eht .noitaticilos .dI , noitceS

6 ;)a(d144 dna ees osla 11 ,.R.F.C noitceS .)3()a(11.011

7 ffitnialP sehsiw ot yap rof stnemesitrevda ni suoirav

8 aidem steltuo taht lliw gnirb ot thgil a rav ytei fo cilbup

9 seussi hcus sa nug ,sthgir dnal ,sthgir latnemnorivne ,ycilop

01 erachtlaeh dna eerf ,hceeps gnidulcni rieht noitcennoc htiw

11 cilbup stnavres dna setadidnac rof cilbup .eciffo eerF hceepS

21 snalp ot nur eseht stnemesitrevda morf eht erp tnes ot rebmevoN

31 dna rehtruf kaeps tuoba detaler seussi sa yeht esira neewteb

41 rebmevoN sa .llew eeS eht tnialpmoC , ta hpargaraP .31

15 ffitnialP skees ot ecnanif dna etubirtsid eseht

61 snoitacinummoc tuohtiw gniretsiger sa a lacitilop eettimmoc ro

17 gniylpmoc htiw eht remialcsid dna erusolcsid snoitagilbo

81 deriuqer rof niatrec sepyt fo ngiapmac - detaler .snoitacinummoc

91 eerF hceepS osla sdnetni ot ticilos snoitanod fo sdnuf ot

02 ecnanif lanoitidda deifitnedinu stnemesitrevda llew dnoyeb eht

12 2 210 larotcele .elcyc ffitnialP stneserper ti si ton rednu eht

22 lortnoc fo yna laredef etadidnac ron seod ti ,evah sa sti rojam

32 ,esoprup eht noitcele ro taefed fo ylraelc deifitnedi

42 setadidnac rof laredef eciffo -- ees tnialpmoC , hpargaraP 41 --

52 dna ffitnialp stsisni ti sdnetni ot egagne ylelos ni eussi"

Page 14: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

41

1 ".ycacovda s'ffitnialP tsrif esuac fo noitca segella noitceS

2 )b(22.001 si lanoitutitsnocnu no sti ecaf esuaceb ti seog

3 dnoyeb" yna reporp noitcurtsnoc fo sserpxe ycacovda dna sreffo

4 on raelc ecnadiug -- ro senilediug rof srekaeps ot roliat rieht

5 yllanoitutitsnoc detcetorp tcudnoc dna ,hceeps dna ti sliaf ot"

6 timil sti noitacilppa ot serutidnepxe rof snoitacinummoc taht

7 ni sserpxe smret etacovda eht noitcele ro taefed fo a lraelc y

8 deifitnedi etadidnac rof laredef "eciffo ni ecnadrocca htiw

9 yelkcuB . eeS tnialpmoC , shpargaraP 47 dna .57

10 ffitnialP segella taht noitceS )b(22.001 si

11 lanoitutitsnocnu sa deilppa esuaceb eht CEF sniatniam" a

21 ecitcarp fo gniylppa a yteirav fo coh da , esac - yb - esac srotcaf

31 ni hcae tnemecrofne ,rettam yrosivda noinipo dna noitaredisnoc

41 fo eht noitaluger ni ".noitseuq eeS tnialpmoC ta hpargaraP ;67

51 dna eht CEF seilppa ti ot revoc detcetorp eussi" "ycacovda

61 .snoitacinummoc tnialpmoC , ta hpargaraP .77

17 s'ffitnialP dnoces esuac fo noitca segella taht

81 noitceS )b(22.001 si lanoitutitsnocnu esuaceb eht yvaeh"

91 snoitaluger dna ecnailpmoc "stnemeriuqer detaicossa htiw eht

02 s'CEF yrartibra noitacifissalc fo emos hceeps sa sserpxe

12 ovda ycac stca sa eht lanoitcnuf tnelaviuqe fo a roirp

22 .tniartser eeS tnialpmoC , shpargaraP 18 dna .28 s'ffitnialP

32 driht esuac fo noitca segella ti tonnac yllacitsilaer esiar

42 sdnuf ro kees snoitanod eud ot eht emosrebmuc noitacilppa fo

52 eht s'CEF cnu yllanoitutitsno eugav noitaticilos ,sdradnats

Page 15: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

51

1 gnitibihni ti morf gnitaicossa" htiw ekil - dednim slaudividni

2 dna gnikaeps tuo ot esiar ssenerawa fo ".seussi tnialpmoC , ta

3 hpargaraP .78

4 ,yllaniF s'ffitnialp htruof esuac fo noitca segella

5 taht eht s'CEF noitacilppa fo eht rojam" "esoprup tset ot

6 enimreted lacitilop eettimmoc sutats si lanoitutitsnocnu

7 esuaceb ti setaulave erom naht na s'noitazinagro tnednepedni

8 serutidnepxe dna gnidnuof .stnemucod eeS tnialpmoC , ta

9 hpargaraP .301 yB eht tneserp ,noitom ffitnialp skees a

01 yranimilerp noitcnujni gniniojne eht CEF morf gnicrofne eht

11 degnellahc snoisivorp dna seicilop yllaicaf dna sa deilppa

21 litnu a lanif gniraeh no eht stirem yam eb .dleh

13 ehT dradnats fo weiver elbacilppa ot siht rettam

41 seriuqer taht ot niatbo na yranidroartxe ydemer fo a

51 yranimilerp ,noitcnujni ffitnialp tsum wohs taht ruof srotcaf

61 hgiew ni sti :rovaf ,enO ti si yllaitnatsbus ylekil ot deeccus

71 no eht ;stirem ,owt ti lliw reffus elbaraperri yrujni fi ht e

81 noitcnujni si ;deined ,eerht sti denetaerht yrujni shgiewtuo

91 eht yrujni eht gnisoppo ytrap lliw reffus rednu eht ;noitcnujni

02 ,dna ,ruof eht noitcnujni dluow ton eb esrevda ot eht cilbup

12 .tseretni eeS dawA , A-W-A- ,D susrev ,xairiZ Z-I-R-I-A-X,

22 076 d3.F ,1111 ta ,5211 htneT tiucriC ,2102 gnitic retniW

32 susrev larutaN ecruoseR esnefeD licnuoC , 555 .S.U 7 ta ,02

42 .8002 yranimilerP snoitcnujni taht retla eht sutats ouq ro

52 droffa eht tnavom lla eht feiler taht ti lliw revocer ta eht

Page 16: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

61

1 noisulcnoc fo a lluf lairt no eht stirem era derovafsid dna

2 tsum eb erom ylesolc .deziniturcs .dI nI hcus ,secnatsni eht

3 gnivom ytrap tsum ekam a" gnorts gniwohs htob htiw drager ot

4 eht doohilekil fo sseccus no eht stirem dna htiw drager ot eht

5 b ecnala fo ".smrah .dI

6 ffitnialP seugra taht esuaceb eht s'CEF yrotaluger

7 erutcurts stca sa eht lanoitcnuf tnelaviuqe fo a roirp

8 ,tniartser ti stressa taht tcirts yniturcs si detnarraw ot

9 weiver fo sti .smialc tA eht eroc fo s'ffitnialp ,segnellahc

01 ,revewoh era selur dna seicilop hcihw tnemelpmi ylno eht

11 erusolcsid .stnemeriuqer ehT noitseuq erofeb eht truoC si ton

21 rehtehw ffitnialp nac ekam serutidnepxe rof eht hceeps ti

31 sesoporp ron esiar yenom tuohtiw noitatimil tub ylpmis rehtehw

41 it tsum edivorp erusolcsid fo s'ti larotcele .ycacovda

15 gnillortnoC tnedecerp seod ton troppus na tnemugra

61 taht tcirts yniturcs si .elbacilppa sA ,deton remialcsid" dna

71 erusolcsid stnemeriuqer yam nedrub eht ytiliba ot ,kaeps tub

81 yeht esopmi on c gnilie no ngiapmac - detaler seitivitca dna od

91 ton tneverp enoyna morf .gnikaeps ehT truoC sah detcejbus

02 eseht stnemeriuqer ot gnitcaxe' ,'yniturcs hcihw seriuqer a

12 laitnatsbus' 'noitaler neewteb eht erusolcsid tnemeriuqer dna a

22 yltneiciffus' pmi 'tnatro latnemnrevog .tseretni eeS snezitiC

32 detinU susrev CEF , 855 .S.U 13 0. eeS osla AATR susrev CEF , 186

42 d3.F .445 ,ylralimiS eht htneT tiucriC sah deton taht

52 snoitaluger gniriuqer ,erusolcsid sa dehsiugnitsid morf

Page 17: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

71

1 snoitaluger taht timil eht tnuoma fo hceeps a puorg yam

2 ,ekatrednu era tcejbus ot eht gnitcaxe" ".yniturcs eeS

3 weN ocixeM htuoY dezinagrO susrev arerreH , 116 d3.F ,966 ,676

4 0102 htneT tiucriC .noisiced

5 ehT erusolcsid dna lanoitazinagro stnemeriuqer rof

6 tnednepedni pxe serutidne dna lacitilop seettimmoc era" ton sa

7 emosnedrub no hceeps sa era stimil desopmi no ngiapmac

8 seitivitca ro stimil desopmi no snoitubirtnoc ot eht

9 serutidnepxe yb ".sngiapmac AATR , 186 ,d3.F ta .845

01 ,ylgnidroccA na etaidemretni level fo cs ynitur nwonk sa

11 gnitcaxe" "yniturcs si eht etairporppa dradnats ot ylppa ni

21 gniweiver snoisivorp taht esopmi erusolcsid stnemeriuqer hcus

31 sa eht noitaluger dna ycilop ta eussi .ereh eeS AATR , ta .945

14 nI smret fo eht eussi sa ot eht noitutitsnoc ytila fo

51 11 ,.R.F.C noitceS 0001 -- ro ,)b(22.001 " detinU snezitiC

61 stroppus eht s'CEF esu fo a lanoitcnuf tnelaviuqe tset ni

71 gninifed sserpxe' '.ycacovda fI yrotadnam erusolcsid

81 stnemeriuqer era elbissimrep nehw deilppa ot sda taht ylerem

91 em noitn a laredef ,etadidnac neht gniylppa eht emas nedrub ot

02 sda taht og rehtruf dna era eht lanoitcnuf tnelaviuqe fo

12 sserpxe ycacovda tonnac yllacitamotua eb ".elbissimrepmi eeS

22 AATR , 186 d3.F 155 - .25

23 ehT" egaugnal fo noitceS )b(22.001 si isnoc tnets htiw

42 eht tset rof eht lanoitcnuf tnelaviuqe fo sserpxe ycacovda taht

52 saw detpoda ni nisnocsiW thgiR ot efiL , a tset taht eht

Page 18: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

81

1 gnillortnoc noinipo yllacificeps detats saw ton ylbissimrepmi

2 ".eugav .dI , ta ,255 gnitic CEF susrev isnocsiW n thgiR ot

3 efiL , ta ,474 etontooF .7

4 hguohtlA" ti si eurt taht eht egaugnal fo noitceS

5 )b(22.001 seod ton yltcaxe rorrim eht lanoitcnuf tnelaviuqe

6 noitinifed ni nisnocsiW thgiR ot efiL , eht ecnereffid neewteb

7 eht owt stset era ton .lufgninaem dnI ,dee eht tset rednu

8 noitceS )b(22.001 si ylekil reworran naht eht eno detalucitra

9 ni nisnocsiW thgiR ot efiL ecnis ti seriuqer a noitacinummoc ot

01 evah na larotcele' 'noitrop taht si elbakatsimnu dna

11 ".suougibmanu AATR , ta .255

12 ehT tcaf taht ht e CEF dluoc ton ylevisulcnoc eerga sa

31 ot rehtehw niatrec fo s'ffitnialp desoporp sda detutitsnoc

41 sserpxe ycacovda rednu sti snoitaluger dna seicilop seod ton

51 ekam noitceS )b(22.001 yllanoitutitsnocnu .eugav sihT tcaf

61 sevorp elttil esuaceb sesac taht llaf esolc ot eht enil lliw

71 ylbativeni esira nehw gniylppa noitceS .)b(22.001 sihT dnik fo

81 ytluciffid si ylpmis tnerehni ni yna dnik fo sdradnats - desab

91 .tset eeS AATR , ta .455 tI osla yam tcelfer eht tnerehni

02 melborp ni na lauqe rebmun fo srenoissimmoc dna eht etanutrofnu

12 lacitilop ;edivid ,tub ni yna ,tneve taht seod ton etadilavni

22 eht .ssecorp

23 gninruT ot rehtehw eht erusolcsid stnemeriuqer

42 dereggirt yb )b(22.001 tca sa a roirp .tniartser nI" yelkcuB ,

52 eht emerpuS truoC lpxe denia taht erusolcsid dluoc eb deifitsuj

Page 19: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

91

1 desab no a latnemnrevog tseretni ni gnidivorp eht etarotcele

2 htiw noitamrofni tuoba eht secruos fo noitcele - detaler

3 ".gnidneps eeS detinU snezitiC ta .419 tI dlehpu" a

4 erusolcsid tnemeriuqer rof epedni tnedn serutidnepxe neve hguoht

5 ti detadilavni a noisivorp taht desopmi a gniliec no esoht

6 ".serutidnepxe eeS detinU snezitiC ta .519

7 nI siht ,esac ffitnialp sliaf ot etartsnomed woh yna

8 fo eht degnellahc ,snoisivorp enon fo hcihw esopmi yna

9 rtser snoitci ro snoitatimil no sti ,hceeps noitcnuf sa a roirp

01 .tniartser ehT ffitnialp sraeppa ot kees ot dnapxe eht

11 noissucsid ni detinU snezitiC sa ot eht noitamrof fo a CAP dna

21 eht snedrub desopmi nopu gniog hguorht taht ,ssecorp tub siht

31 truoC seod ton dnif taht esoht emas snedrub era suogolana ni

41 siht esac dna suht od ton tca sa a roirp tniartser ro eht

51 tnelaviuqe fo eht .emas

16 sA ot eht ytilanoitutitsnoc fo eht noitaticilos

71 ,dradnats ni gnitaulave rehtehw s'ffitnialp noitanod seuqer st

81 dluow etutitsnoc "snoitaticilos" fo ,snoitubirtnoc eht CEF

91 deyolpme eht dnoceS s'tiucriC :tset erusolcsiD si deriuqer fi"

02 a noitacinummoc sniatnoc snoitaticilos ylraelc gnitacidni taht

12 eht snoitubirtnoc lliw eb detegrat ot eht noitcele ro ed taef fo

22 a ylraelc deifitnedi etadidnac rof laredef ".eciffo CEF susrev

32 lavivruS noitacudE ,dnuF detaroprocnI , 56 d3.F ,582 ta ;592

42 dnoceS tiucriC ,5991 " FES " .retfaniereh tfarD B dnuof owt fo

52 s'ffitnialp desoporp noitanod stseuqer lliw ticilos

Page 20: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

02

1 snoitubirtnoc dna owt lliw .ton tnialpmoC , tibihxE ,C ta egap

2 .71 tfarD B fo eht noinipo fo eht CEF ylbanosaer seilppa -- fo

3 eht yrosivda ,noinipo I dluohs ,etats ylbanosaer seilppa eht

4 FES dradnats rof snoitaticilos ni gnihcaer siht isulcnoc .no

5 ehT dnoceS ,tiucriC ni FES , dezingocer taht eht

6 erusolcsid stnemeriuqer rof snoitaticilos evres" tnatropmi

7 tsriF tnemdnemA .seulav laitnetoP srotubirtnoc era deltitne ot

8 wonk taht yeht era gnitroppus tnednepedni scitirc fo a

9 etadidnac dna ton a puorg taht yam eb ni eugael htiw taht

01 s'etadidnac .tnenoppo noitceS )3()a(d144 si suht a' elbanosaer

11 dna yllaminim evitcirtser ',dohtem yelkcuB , 424 ,.S.U ta ,28 fo

21 gnirusne nepo larotcele noititepmoc taht seod ton yludnu hcnert

31 nopu na idni s'laudiv tsriF tnemdnemA ".sthgir FES , 56 d3.F ta

41 .692

15 I dluow :dda desaB nopu detinU snezitiC s' sisylana

61 dna eht ecnawolla fo etaroproc ,snoitubirtnoc eht gnitroper

71 stnemeriuqer emoceb neve erom tnacifingis esuaceb eht etaroproc

81 erutcurts d seo ton wolla noitacifitnedi fo eht laudividni ohw

91 si gnikam eht hceeps ta .eussi

20 ehT ytilanoitutitsnoc -- sa ot eht ytilanoitutitsnoc

12 fo eht rojam" "esoprup tset dna lacitilop" eettimmoc :"sutats

22 gniwolloF" yelkcuB , eht noissimmoC detpoda a op ycil fo

32 gninimreted CAP sutats no a esac - yb - esac .sisab eeS lacitiloP

42 eettimmoC ,sutatS 27 laredeF retsigeR ,5955 6955 - ,79 siht 7002'

52 '.ecitoN rednU siht ,hcaorppa eht noissimmoC tsrif sredisnoc a

Page 21: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

12

1 s'puorg lacitilop seitivitca hcus sa idneps gn no a ralucitrap

2 'larotcele' ro eussi' 'ycacovda ngiapmac -- ees .dI ta 1065 --

3 dna neht ti setaulave na s'noitazinagro rojam' 'esoprup sa

4 delaever yb taht s'puorg cilbup ,stnemetats gnisiardnuf

5 ,slaeppa tnemnrevog sgnilif dna lanoitazinagro cod ".stnemu eeS

6 .dI , AATR , 186 d3.F ta .555

7 nI gnidiced ton ot tpoda a yrotutats noitinifed fo a

8 ,CAP eht CEF denialpxe taht gniylppa" eht rojam' 'esoprup

9 enirtcod seriuqer eht ytilibixelf fo a esac - yb - esac sisylana fo

01 na s'noitazinagro tcudnoc aht t si elbitapmocni htiw a

11 eno - ezis - stif - lla ".elur 27 laredeF retsigeR ta .1065 ehT

21 7002 eciton osla denialpxe" eht krowemarf rof gnihsilbatse

31 lacitilop eettimmoc sutats rednu ACEF dna dessucsid lareves

41 yltnecer devloser evitartsinimda srettam t tah edivorp

51 elbaredisnoc ecnadiug ot lla snoitazinagro gnidrager lacitilop

61 eettimmoc ".sutats 27 laredeF ,retsigeR ta 5955 - .69

17 hguohtlA" yelkcuB did etaerc eht rojam' 'esoprup ,tset

81 ti did ton etadnam a ralucitrap ygolodohtem rof gninimreted na

91 s'noitazinagro rojam ,esoprup dna suht eht noissimmoC saw eerf

02 ot retsinimda ACEF lacitilop eettimmoc snoitaluger rehtie

12 hguorht lacirogetac selur ro hguorht dezilaudividni

22 ".snoitacidujda eeS AATR , 186 ,d3.F ta .655

23 ehT" ytissecen fo a noc lautxet yriuqni si detroppus yb

42 laiciduj snoisiced gniylppa eht rojam' 'esoprup tset hcihw evah

52 desu eht emas tcaf - evisnetni sisylana taht eht noissimmoC sah

Page 22: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

22

1 ".detpoda AATR ta .755 ehT ,noissimmoC ni sti ,ycilop detpoda

2 a elbisnes hcaorppa ot gninimreted rehtehw na noitazinagro

3 seifilauq rof CAP ;sutats ,dna erom ,yltnatropmi eht

4 s'noissimmoC itlum - rotcaf rojam' 'esoprup tset si tnetsisnoc

5 htiw emerpuS truoC tnedecerp dna seod ton yllufwalnu reted

6 detcetorp .hceeps ,ylgnidroccA ew if dn eht ycilop

7 ".lanoitutitsnoc s'tahT AATR ta .855

8 sihT truoC ylralimis sdnif eht ycilop lanoitutitsnoc

9 ni siht ;rettam dna esuaceb eht truoC sdnif eht ffitnialp sah

01 deliaf ot hsilbatse a laitnatsbus doohilekil fo sseccus no eht

11 stirem fo sti a ,snoitc eht ffitnialp si ton deltitne ot a

21 yranimilerp noitcnujni ni siht rettam dna lliw erofereht yned

31 eht detseuqer yranimilerp .noitcnujni

14 I lliw tcerid a etunim redro eb ,deretne gnitaroprocni

51 yb ecnerefer siht s'truoC laro gnilur hcihw ah s neeb

61 debircsnart ro decalp no tpircsnart yb eht truoc .retroper

17 erA ereht yna snoitseuq gnidrager eht rettam ta siht

81 tniop ni ,emit .rM ?rraB

19 :RRAB .RM erehT era on snoitseuq no s'ffitnialp .dne

20 TRUOC EHT : llA .thgir rM . rekloK ro .sM olhC ?kap

21 :KAPOLHC .SM .oN oN snoitseuq ,ereh ruoY .ronoH

22 TRUOC EHT : yreV .llew

23 :OLLASSAV .RM ruoY ,ronoH siht si kciN .ollassaV I

42 tsuj detnaw ot eton rof eht drocer taht I dah denioj eht llac a

52 wef setunim erofeb uoy emac no eht .enil

Page 23: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

32

1 EHT TRUOC : rM ,llew yreV . llassaV o. oS .deton

2 knahT uoy lla . evaH a doog .yad

3 :RRAB .RM .uoy knahT

4 :KAPOLHC .SM .uoy knahT

5 TRUOC EHT : .ssecer ni dnats lliw truoC

6 ehT( sgnideecorp edulcnoc ta 50:9 ).m.a

7

8

9

01

11

21

31

41

51

61

71

81

91

02

12

22

23

42

52

Page 24: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

1 RETROPER ETACIFITREC

2 ,I EIMAJ .L ,HCIRDNEH laiciffO laredeF truoC retropeR

3 ni eht detinU setatS tcirtsiD truoC rof eht tcirtsiD fo

4 ,gnimoyW yfitrec taht eht gniogerof si a tcerroc tpircsnart

5 morf eht drocer fo sgnideecorp ni eht evoba - deltitne .rettam

6 ____21.71.01___ _____________/S/_______________ etaD EIMAJ .L ,HCIRDNEH RSC - RPR - RRC

7 laiciffO laredeF truoC retropeR

8

9

01

11

21

31

41

51

61

71

81

91

02

12

22

32

42

52

Page 25: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

A ytiliba 22:7 71:61

elba 52:5 noitrobA 31:3 41:11

voba e- deltitne 5:42 egdirba 9:5

deinapmocca 22,02:9 tnuocca 52:11

ytilibatnuocca 22:4 tca 41:5 2,2:6 3:9

12:01 22:21 1:31 42:81 41:91

noitca 7:5 31:01 1:41 32,71:41 4:51

snoitca 21:01 11:22 seitivitca 32:7 02:21

02:21 81:61 8:71 1:12

ytivitca 81,51:21 stca :41 12 7:61

ytilautca 3:6 da 21:41

vadA 02:1 dda 51:02

noitidda 8:7 lanoitidda 1:21 02:31

yllanoitiddA 5:21 gnisserdda 3:5

snoitacidujda 22:12 retsinimda 02:12

evitartsinimda 41:12 tpoda 7:12

detpoda 52:71 22:02 1,1:22

sda 02,81:71 31:81 ecnavda 01:9 32:21

vda esre 02:51 stnemesitrevda 3:5

31,21:8 2:01 21,7:31 02:31

gnisitrevda 6:21 3:31 4:31

yrosivda 31:41 3:02 ycacovda 91,21:5 9:8

32,22,91,41,31,9:8 7:01 12,51,3,1:41 41:61 42,12,71:71 41:81 2:12

etacovda 22:4 7:41 gnitacovda 02,21:6

41,5:9 droffa 52:51

agergga gnit 42,51:01 52:01

eerga 21:81 aila 71:01

degella 31:4 segella 8:5 71,01,1:41

52

degnellahc 11:51 8:91 regnellahc 81:9 segnellahc 61,01:5

9:61 gnignellahc 8:5

rebmahC 2:3 52:6 enneyehC 42,61,31:1

kapolhC 91:1 8,3:4 12,02:22 4:32

riC 41,8,4:3 tiucriC 21:3 51:11 22:51 42:61 4:71 42:91 5:02

s'tiucriC 91:91 NOITATIC 1:3

nitic g 52,42:7 22:51 2:81

snezitiC 6:3 61:6 8,5:7 12,71,61,21:7 4:8

22:61 51:71 11,6,3:91 51:02

liviC 21:4 smialc 61:7 52:8 9:61

noitacifissalc 02:41 raelc 4:41

ylraelc 31:6 02,5:9 21,8,1:01 32:31 7:41 22,02:91

esolc 61:81 ylesolc 2:61 bulc

22:01 edoC 6:6 1,7:7 9 8:9

91:01 32,1:11 52:21 semoc 01:4

stnemmoc 9:21 ecremmoC 2:3 1:7

noissimmoC 02,6:1 41,01:3 51,9,5:4 61:6

32:6 01:8 51:11 52,22:02 52,91:12

1:22 srenoissimmoc 02:81

s'noissimmoC 4:22 eettimmoc 81:5 7:9

22,12,51:01 01:21 61:31 6:51 42,12:02

02,61,31:12 oc seettimm 1:5 71:11

6:71 ylnommoc 22:01

noitacinummoc 02:6 51:9 9:01 9:81 02:91

snoitacinummoc 22:6 21:7 32:9 81,61:31

61,6:41 derapmoc 02:21

noititepmoc 21:02 tnialpmoC 02,2:5

desab 21:4 1:91 51:02 sisab 32:02

flaheb 8,7:4 nimajneB 71:1

dnoyeb 02:31 3:41 lliB 91:9 xoB 32:1

gnirb 8:31 sgnirb 01:5

daorb 21:5 gnitsacdaorb 2:31

yelkcuB 5:3 42:7 4:8 6:11 9:41 42:81

22,11:02 71:12 repmub 2:01

nedrub 22:7 71:61 91:71

snedrub 31,21:91 emosnedrub 31:5 7:71

swalyb 52:4

C C 1:02

radnelac 42,61:01 1:11 llac 42:22

pmac ngia 2,1:6 71,9:8 22,81:8 42,3:9 51:21

91:21 7:71 2:12 sngiapmac 42:5 5:6

02:21 9:71 ngiapmac - detaler

32:7 81:31 81:61 etadidnac 12,31,11,9:6

4:7 7,6:9 11,01,9:11 41:11 22:31 8:41 91:71 22:91 9:02

setadidnac 1:5 8:6 32,02:9 31,8,1:01

3:21 42,11:31 tadidnac s'e 01:02

retraC 3:01 esac 4:1 5:4 41:6 61:7 8:8 41,7:91 sesac 61:81

esac - yb - esac 21:21 21:41 32:02 9:12

hsac 02:11 repsaC 6:1 4:2

tsac 71:9 lacirogetac 12:12

esuac 32,71,1:41 4:51 gniliec 32:7 81:61 5:91 niatrec 8:5 71:11 81:31 31:81

ETACIFITREC 1:42 trec yfi 4:42

aretec 2:01 egnellahc 81:7

32:41 4:51 gnigella 11:5

wolla 81:02 ecnawolla 61:02

retla 42:51 tnemdnemA 9:5 7:02

31:02 stnemdnema 01:7

tnuoma 7:6 81:01 3:21 1:71

suogolana 31:91 sisylana 6:8 1:9 21:21

61:21 51:02 52,9:12 ezylana 12:5

gnizylana 02:7 slaeppa 81:21 5:12

ecnaraeppa 3:6 SECNARAEPPA 11:1

1:2 sraeppa 01:91

elbacilppa 22:5 31:51 61:61

noitacilppa 42,6:41 5:51

deilppa 01:5 11:41 11:51 81:71 seilppa 51:41 3,2:02

ylppa 11:71 gniylppa 21:41 91:71

71:81 42,8:12 hcaorppa 52:02 2:22

etairporppa 71 11: yrartibra 02:41

seugra 6:61 tnemugra 51:61 detalucitra 8:81

stressa 8:61 detaicossa 12:8 91:41 gnitaicossa 1:51 noitaicossa 81:4 22:01

S'YENROTTA 32:1 nitsuA 2:3 52:6 6:7

yllacitamotua 12:71 eunevA 51:1

dawA 3:3 12:51 ssenerawa 2:51

A-W-A-D 12:51 m.a 1 5,5: 6:32

B b 91,21:1 4:01 4:21

42:91 2:02 dnuorgkcab 71:4

ecnalab 5:61 tollab 71:9

knab 52:11 rraB 71:1 7,2:4 81:22

91:22 3:32

Page 26: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

42,41:31 61,41,9:41 22:41 8,2:51 1:02

ecnailpmoc 91:41 ylpmoc 71:11

gniylpmoc 71:31 desirpmoc 91:4

snrecnoc 01:6 edulcnoc 5:8 6:32

noisulcnoc 41:7 51:8 1:61 4:02

cnoc ylevisul 21:81 tcudnoc 71,21:21 5:41

01:12 ssergnoC 81:9

namssergnoc 61:9 noitcennoc 01:31

elbaredisnoc 51:12 noitaredisnoc 31:41

gniredisnoc 8:21 sredisnoc 52:02 tnetsisnoc 32:71 4:22 etutitsnoc 81:91

detutitsnoc 31:81 lanoitutitsnoc 22,31:4

6:8 8,7:22 oc ytilanoitutitsn 61:5

41:71 61:91 02,02:02 yllanoitutitsnoc 12:4

71:7 5:41 noitcurtsnoc 3:41

gniniatnoc 7:01 sniatnoc 02:91

txetnoc 42:9 lautxetnoc 32:12

eunitnoc 01:21 detubirtnoc 81:01 noitubirtnoc 22:21

2:31 snoitubirtnoc 7:6

32:01 21,2:11 8:71 12,81:91 61,1:02

srotubirtnoc 7:02 lortnoc 42:4 9:11

22:31 dellortnoc 11:11 gnillortnoc 51:61 1:81

noitanidrooc 6:9 eroc 9:61

etaroproc 22:6 7:7 81,21:8 71,61:02

noitaroproc 3:7 snoitaroproc 71:6 01:7

tcerroc 4:42 noitpurroc 3:6

licnuoC 51:3 32:51 lesnuoc 1:4

truoc 1:1 2:2 4,4,1:4 61,41,01:4 42,71,41:6

yltcerid 8:6 stnemesrubsid 12:11

remialcsid 12,02,81:7 5:8 71,5:31 61:61

sremialcsid 5:21 esolcsid 52:11

erusolcsid 22,02,91:7 7,5,2:8 71:01 81:11

91:11 71:31 41,11:61 52,12,71:61 21,5:71

71:71 52,32:81 4:91 91:91 6:02

dessucsid 31:12 noissucsid 11:91 derovafsid 1:61 noitcnitsid 12:8

snoitcnitsid 8:8 dehsiugnitsid 52:61

etubirtsid 51:31 noitubirtsid 01:9

tcirtsiD 01,1,1:1 3:2 3:42 3, edivid 12:81

enirtcod 9:12 stnemucod 8:51 5:12

gniod 42:6 noitanod 52,71:91

snoitanod 91:31 42:41 tfarD 42:91 2:02 nward 8:8

eud 42:41

E E 12:1

noitacudE 7:3 32:91 rehtie 91:6 02:12

tcele 21:01 noitcele 02,6:1 41,01:3

41,9,5:4 12,61,21,2:6 32:6 01:8 3:9 52,21,5,

7,6:01 51,31,01,4:11 52:21 32:31 7:41 12:91

gnireenoitcele 22,02:6 21:7

snoitcele 42:5 noitcele - detaler 2:91

larotcele 9:01 12:31 41:61 01:81 21:02

2:12 etarotcele 1:91

sliame 7:21 deyolpme 91:91 ssapmocne 8,3:11 segaruocne

31,21:01 tnemecrofne :4 51

71:5 31:41 gnicrofne 01:51

52,12,61,8,5,1:7 4:8 12,51,11:8 7:11 11:61

91:61 52:81 31:91 22,02,61,9,8,5:22

5,5,1:32 7,3,2:42 esuohtruoC 3:2

s'truoC 51:6 51:22 revoc 51:41 etaerc 71:12 scitirc 8:02

RSC - RPR - RRC 2:2 6:42

emosrebmuc 42:41 deliatruc 52:5

cyc el 12:31 R.F.C 01:5 41:9 02:01 7:21 6:31 51:71

D sregnad 12:8

etad 71:01 2:21 6:42 divaD 91:1

yad 2:32 CD 12:1

dediced 9:21 gnidiced 7:12 noisiced 51:6 6,1:7

61:11 31:21 4:71 snoisiced 42:12

taefed 12,21:6 22,5:9 52:9 21,8:01 32:31 7:41 12:91

tnadnefed 7:1 91, 9:4 41:4

esnefeD 51:3 32:51 denifed 91:6 51,9,4:9

3:11 senifed 12:01 22:21 gninifed 71:71

noitinifed 11:5 52:8 7:11 9:21 6:81 7:12

citarcomeD 71:9 etartsnomed 7:91

deined 81:51 yned 21:22

tisoped 01:9 32:21 debircsed 12:9

detangised 52:11 etipseD 41:7

reted 5:22 snoitanimreted 91:5

enimreted 6:51 gninimreted 11:21

32:02 81:12 2:22 reffid 11:01

ecnereffid 6:81 ytluciffid 81:81

tcerid 2:7 41:22

62

egagne 4:5 52:31 niojne 41:4

gniniojne 01:51 gnirusne 21:02

deretne 41:22 deltitne 7:02 11:22

latnemnorivne 32:4 9:31 lauqe

02:81 yllauqe 51:7

tnelaviuqe 41:5 61:8 22,91:8 12:41 7:61

42,02,61:71 5:81 51:91

nirE 91:1 hsilbatse 01:22

gnihsilbatse 21:12 te 2:01

setaulave 7:51 3:12 gnitaulave 91:21

71:91 tneve 12:81 stneve 5:01

slive 52:5 noitulove 32:5

gnitcaxe 1:8 02:61 11,2:71

yltcaxe 5:81 deecxe 21:11

snoitpecxe 22:11 ssecxe 52,42:01 tibihxE 2,2:5 1:02

tsixe 32:8 dnapxe 01:91

erutidnepxe 9,4,4:9 81:01 4:21

serutidnepxe 01,9:6 22,91,31:6 51,8,3:7

52,51:01 21,2:11 2:21 6:41 8:51 21:61 6:71 9:71 6,4:91

sesnepxe 2:11 0 denialpxe 31:21 52:81

21,8:12 sserpxe 91,11:5 41:8

61:8 02,7,3:41 71:71 42,12:71 41:81 ylsserpxe 02:6 41,5:9 evisnetxe 51:21

tnetxe 52:5 9:8 lanretxe 5:01

yranidroartxe 41:51

F ecaf 2:41

laicaf 01:5 yllaicaf 11:51 ytilicaf 3:31

Page 27: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

tcaf 51,21:81 srotcaf 21:41 51:51

tcaf - evisnetni 61:21 52:12

deliaf 01:22 sliaf 5:41 7:91

llaf 61:81 rovaf 61:51

yraurbeF 91:4 CEF 9,7,6:3 8:5 61:01

91:11 9:21 51,11:41 01:51 32,32:61 2:81 21:81 22,81:91 2 2:0

8:12 ACEF 2:6 01:7 02,31:12 s'CEF 71:5 52,02:41 5:51 6:61 61:71

laredef 02,6:1 2:2 01:3 41:3 41,21,9,5:4 1:6

32,71,61,11,8,5:6 01:8 21,3:9 31,4:11 51:11 52,51,51:21

42,22:31 8:41 91:71 22:91 42:02 61,11:12 7,2:42

elif 61:01 91:11 delif 7:5

sgnilif 5:12 lanif 21:51

yllaniF 4:51 ecnanif 21:7 02,51:31

secnanif 51:01 dnif 31:91 6:22

sdnif 61:4 9,8:22 tsrif 9:5 1:41 31,7:02

52:02 ytilibixelf 9:12 gniwolloF 22:02

swollof 61:4 etontooF 3:81 gniogerof 4:42 noitamrof 11:91

demrof 81:4 dnuof 71:7 42:91

gnidnuof 1 8:5 ruof 02,51:51

htruof 51:11 4:51 krowemarf 32:5 21:12

eerf 3:1 02,02,71,4:4 32:4 3:5 91,11,01:31 91:12

smodeerf 9:5 lluf 1:61

noitcnuf 9:91 lanoitcnuf 41:5 61:8

22,81:8 12:41 7:61 42,02,61:71 5:81

dnuF 7:3 32:91

gnisiardnuf 4:5 3:11 1:21 8 4:12 sdnuf 81:6 11,3:7 21:8

91:31 42:41 rehtruf 61:5 12,91:01 31:31 02:71

d3.F 41,21,8,3:3 51:11 22:51 42:61 22,9,3:71 32:91 31:02 22,6:12

G lareneg 11:7 4:31 aigroeG 81:9

tfig 01:9 22:21 evig 41:6

gnivig 4:6 og 02:71

seog 2:41 gniog 21:91

doog 3,2,1:4 2 2:3 tnemnrevog 12:4 5:12

latnemnrevog 3:8 22:61 1:91

puorg 51:1 32:01 1:71 9:02

s'puorg 4,1:12 ecnadiug 4:41 51:12

senilediug 4:41 nug 42:4 9:31

H dnah 02:11

smrah 5:61 erachtlaeh 52:4 01:31

gniraeh 21:51 yvaeh 81:41

dleh 6:7 71,11:8 21:51 lufpleh 42,22:5

hcirdneH 2:2 6,2:42 retfaniereh 2:6 61:11

42:91 arerreH 21:3 3:71 yrokciH 22:9

coh 21:41 gnidloh 52:6

ronoH 2:4 32,12:22 ELBARONOH 9:1

gnitnuH 71:1

I dI 7:8 12:21 5:31 2:61

5:61 2:81 6,2:12 noitacifitnedi 81:02

deifitnedi 31:6 02,6:9 31,8,1:01 32:31 8:41

1 22:9 seifitnedi 71:01

yfitnedi 42:5 5:21

iii 4:21 elbissimrepmi 12:71 ylbissimrepmi 1:81

tnemelpmi 01:61 tnatropmi 3:8 1:9

22:61 6:02 yltnatropmi 3:22

esopmi 32:7 81:61 21:71 8:91

desopmi 7:6 8,7:71 21,5:91

edulcni 22:21 4:31 gnidulcni 32:4 71,2:21

01:31 elbitapmocni 01:12 detaroprocnI 7:3

32:91 gnitaroprocni 41:22

tnebmucni 32:9 tnednepedni 31,01:6

81:6 8,3:7 4:9 51:01 3,2:21 7:51 6:71 4:91

8:02 yltnednepedni 52:4

XEDNI 1:3 gnitacidni 02:91 laudividni 42:9 81:02

dezilaudividni 12:12 slaudividni 5:5 1:51

i s'laudividn 31:02 ylbativeni 71:81

gnicneulfni 21:9 4:11 42:21

noitamrofni 1:21 2:91 tnemegnirfni 31:4

tnerehni 91,81:81 gnitibihni 1:51 noitcnujni 9:1 01:51

02,91,81,51:51 21:22 31:22

snoitcnujni 42:51 evitcnujni 11:4

yrujni 91,81,71:51 yriuqni 32:12

isni sts 52:31 secnatsni 2:61 evitcurtsni 91:21

sdnetni 52,91:31 retni 71:01

tseretni 3:8 12:51 22:61 1:91

stseretni 71:8 etaidemretni 01:71 noitaterpretni 71:5

deterpretni 6:01 etadilavni 12:81

detadilavni 5:91 devlovni 02:8

72

elbaraperri 71:51 eussi ,31,9:8 32,91,61

52:31 51:41 41,31:71 91:02 2:12

seussi 32:4 12,4:5 41:6 1:9 31,9:31 2:51

J eimaJ 2:2 6,2:42

nhoJ 21:1 denioj 42:22 EGDUJ 01:1

laiciduj 42:12 yluJ 7:5

deifitsuj 52:81 yfitsuj 91,71:8

K dnik 31:01 81,71:81 nielK 41:1 6:4 wonk 8:02

nwonk 22:01 01:71 rekloK 91:1 8:4 02:22

L L 2:2 6,2:42

dnal 42:4 9:31 enaL 71:1

egaugnal 32:71 4:81 egral 4:6

wal 32:5 71:6 8:8 swal 1:6

yal 22:5 eugael 9:02

level 01:71 YTREBIL 51:1

efiL 9:3 42,02,01:8 52:71 9,6,3:81

thgil 8:31 doohilekil 4:61 01:22

ekil - dednim 5:5 1:51 il tim 3:6 6:41 1:71

noitatimil 31:61 snoitatimil 7:6 9:91

detimil 12:4 5:01 12:11 gnitimil 7:11

stimil 8,7:71 enil 61:81 52:22

gnitsil 02:9 elttil 61:81 naol 01:9 32:21

gnidnatsgnol 01:21

M enizagam 3:31

gniliam 3:31 sniatniam 42:11 11:41

rojam 81:5 31,9:11

Page 28: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

41,11:21 22:31 5:51 12:02 :12 42,91,71,8,3

4:22 gnikam 02:8 91:02

etadnam 81:12 yrotadnam 71:71

dnalyraM 81:1 ssam 7:21

rettam 71,01,4:4 31:41 31:51 71,21,9:22 5:42 srettam 41:12

llennoCcM 01:3 32:6 52,31,9:7 6:8

yaKcM 91:9 gninaem 52:9 01:01

lufgninaem 7:81 derusaem 52:8

aidem 6:5 31 8: noitnem 91:71

ylerem 81:71 tirem 52:8 stirem 71,21:51 4,1:61 11:22 dohtem 11:02

ygolodohtem 81:12 ocixeM 21:3 3:71

nagihciM 2:3 52:6 s'nagihciM 2:7

sdnim 11:01 yllaminim 11:02

etunim 41:22 setunim 52:22

rorrim 5:81 noissim 02:4 eladnoM 3:01

yenom ,5,4:6 81 11:7 01:9 32:21 31:61

gninrom 3,2,1:4 noitom 9:1 11:4 9:51 tnavom 52:51

gnivom 3:61 itlum - rotcaf 4:22

N deworran 7:11 reworran 8:81

larutaN 51:3 32:51 ytissecen 32:12

wen 21:3 9:21 3:71 repapswen 2:31

salohciN 22:1 kciN 32:22

s'noxiN 2:01 noitanimon :11 31,01

eenimon 71:9 tiforpnon 81:4

eton 6:4 61:7 42:22 deton 12:7 12,51:8

82

erudecorP 21:4 sgnideecorp 6:32 5:42

ssecorp 71:5 22:81 21:91

detibihorp 71:6 etomorp 02:4

etaglumorp 9:21 reporp 3:41

desoporp 31:81 52:91 sesoporp 31:61

tcetorp 02:4 detcetorp 51,5:41 6:22

sevorp 61:81 edivorp 41:61 41:12

sedivorp 4:01 gnidivorp 1:91 noisivorp 5:91

snoisivorp 51:4 7:8 11:51 21:71 8:91

ytimixorp 6:01 orp - eciohc 12,91:9 orp - efil 12,91:9

cilbup 5:5 02:11 8,6:21 71:21 11,11,8,4:31 02:51 4:12

dehsilbup 31:21 esahcrup 9:9

esoprup 91:5 1:6 4:11 31,9:11 41,11:21

32:31 5:51 12:02 ,91,71,8,3:12 42 4:22

sesoprup 11:9 42:21 tnausrup 11:4

O.P 32:1

Q seifilauq 3:22 noitseuq 41:41 11:61

snoitseuq 12,91,71:22 ouq 42:51

R R 91,41:1

esiar 32:41 2:51 31:61 desiar 12:5

hcaer 8:11 gnihcaer 51:8 4:02

gnimriffaer 6:8 hsuB/nagaeR 3:01

laeR 31:3 41:11 citsilaer ylla 32:41

elbanosaer 52:9 7:01 11:01 01:02

ylbanosaer 3,2:02 stpiecer 12:11 seviecer 32:01 gniviecer 8:21

ssecer 5:32

seitrap 1:5 ytrap 7:9 91:51 3:61

yap 7:31 tnemyap 9:9 deviecrep 52:5

cidoirep 91:11 elbissimrep 71:7 81:71

nosrep 21:6 11:9 7:01 41:01 1 42:2 1:31

lanosrep 42:4 snosrep 32:01

deniatrep 7:8 sesarhp 51:9

erutcip 22:9 decalp 61:22

ffitnialp 21,4:1 21,7:4 71:4 61,9,8,7:5 7:31

52,12,51:31 01:41 51,9:51 21,6:61 7:91

01:91 11,9:22 sffitnialp 7:4 s'ffitnialp 9:1 01:4

52:8 22,71,1:41 4:51 9:61 31:81 52,71:91 91:22

snalp 21:31 tniop 81:22

seicilop 61:4 11:51 01:61 41:81

ycilop 42:4 9:31 31:71 22:02 8,6,1:22

lacitilop 32:4 4,1,1:5 32,81,51:5 5:6 7:9

12,41:01 71:11 6:21 01:21 61,4:31 6:51

6:71 12:81 32,12:02 02,51,31,1:12

noitrop 9:7 9:01 01:81 noitisop s 22:4 5:5 sretsop 1:01

laitnetoP 7:02 ecitcarp 11:21 21:41

tnedecerp 42:8 51:61 5:22

gnidulcerp 01:7 noisulcerp 12:6 41:7

yranimilerp 9:1 11:4 42,51,01:51 31,21:22

ecneserp 7,6:4 tneserp 21:31 9:51

detneserp 2:9 tnediserp 61:9

tneverp 42:7 91:61 yramirp 6 1:

roirp 41:5 52,51:6 12:41 7:61 42:81

41,9:91 melborp 02:81

42,61:61 1:32 itoN 02:1 8:4

eciton 31:21 52:02 21:12

rebmevoN 41,21:31 rebmun 5:4 02:81

WN 12:1

O snoitagilbo 71:31

niatbo 41:51 REBOTCO 5:1

sreffo 3:41 eciffo 32:1 11,9,8,5:6

4:7 21:9 4:11 2:21 5 42,11:31 8:41 22:91

laiciffO 2:2 7,2:42 dlO 12:9 eno - ezis - stif - lla 11:12 nepo 21:02

etarepo 52:4 gnitarepo 02:11

noinipo 31:41 1:81 3,2:02

tnenoppo 01:02 desoppo 4:7 31:8 3:21 gnisoppo 91:51

laro 8:1 51:22 redro 12:5 41:22 sredro 61:4

noitazinagro 41:01 01:11 2:22

lanoitazinagro 81:11 5:71 5:12

snoitazinagro 8:11 51:12

s'noitazinagro 11:21 91,71,21:21 7:51 3:12

91,01:12 dezinagrO 21:3 3:71

roodtuo 3:31 steltuo 8:31 shgiewtuo 81:51 ylrevo 21:5

delurrevo 9,5:7

P CAP 22:01 42,11,7:11

11:91 32:02 8:12 3:22

AP sC 52:11 5:21 egap 1:2 1:02

hpargaraP 02:5 41:31 42:31 61,41:41 9,3:51

shpargaraP 2:5 9:41 22:41

trap 41:6 ralucitrap 81,1:12

Page 29: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

dezingocer 5:02 drocer 42:22 5:42

sdrocer 42:11 revocer 52:51

tceleer 61:9 ecnerefer 5:01 51:22

tcelfer 91:81 drager 4,3:61

gnidrager 71:5 01:6 51:12 71:22 retsiger 1,11:11 8

61:21 42:02 61,11:12 gniretsiger 61:31 noitartsiger 31:5

ylraluger 1:21 noitaluger 41:41 31:71

snoitaluger 8:5 91:41 52:61 1:71 41:81 02:12

yrotaluger 51:4 32:5 6:61 tcejer 32:9 detaler 31:31 noitaler 2:8 12:61

deiler 42:6 feiler 11:4 52:51

ydemer 41:51 troper 71:01

detropeR 2:2 retroper 2:2 61:22 7,2,1:42 gnitroper 31:5 61:02

stroper 91:11 1:21 stneserper 12:31 nacilbupeR 71:9

detseuqer 31:22 stseuqer 52,71:91

eriuqer 52:4 deriuqer 3:8 61:01

81:31 91:91 tnemeriuqer 12:61

4:91 stnemeriuqer 31:5

22,12,91:7 5,1:8 81:11 91:41 71,11:61 02:61 81,21,5:71 32:81 71,6:02

seriuqer 2:8 1:31 41:51 02:61 9:81

9:12 gniriuqer 52:61 stnediser 91:4

devloser 41:12 ecruoseR 51:3 32:51

tcepser 32:8 tniartser 41:5 22:41

8:61 42:81 41,01:91 gnitcirtser 91,81:8

noitcirtser 2:7 snoitcirtser 7:7 21:8

9:91 evitcirtser 11:02

gnitluser 4:6 delaever 4:12

weiver 31:51 9:61 gniweiver 21:71 thgir

9:3 32,02,01:8 52:71 9,6,2:81 02:22

sthgir 42,42,31:4 9:31 9:31 31:02

esir 41:6 ellivkcoR 81:1

mooR 3:2 AATR 61:11 32:61 9:71

22,31:71 91,11:81 22,6:12 7,1:22

elur 11:4 11:12 selur 21:4 01:61 12:12 gnilur 8:1 51:22

nur 3:5 21:31 gninnur 9:6

S S 6:42

fsitas dei 41:21 deludehcs 1:21

TTOCS 9:1 deziniturcs 2:61

yniturcs 1:8 02,61,8:61 11,01,2:71

dnoces 71:41 42,91:91 5:02

noitceS 11:5 6:6 01,7:7 02:7 41,21,8:9 4:01

02,91:01 1:11 52,7:21 6,5:31 81,01,1:41

32,51:71 71,51,8,4:81 01:02

snoitceS 32,5:11 4:21 ees ,1:5 91 21:7 32:8

21,7:9 91:01 41,5:11 32:11 42,41,6:31 9:41

22,41:41 12,8:51 32,22:61 12,31,2:71

91:81 6,3:91 32:02 22,5,2:12

kees 42:41 01:91 skees 31:4 4,3:5 51:31 9:51

FES 42:91 31,5,4:02 etaneS 81:9

elbisnes 2:22 yletarapes 52:11

stnavres 11:31 evres 6:02

noisses 4:4

tes 1:6 wohs 51:51

gniwohs 3:61 tnacifingis 51:7 71:02

ylralimis 42:61 8:22 ylpmis 31:61 81:81

LHADVAKS 9:1 snagols 42:9

htimS 81:9 redynS 31:1

ylelos 52:31 ticilos 91:31 52:91

noitaticilos 81:5 5:31 52:41 61:91

snoitaticilos 02,81:91 6,4:02

s sticilo 1:31 thguos 52:5 secruos 2:91

htuoS 3:2 kaeps 22:7 31:31 71:61

srekaeps 4:41 gnikaeps 52:7 2:51

91:61 yllacificeps 9:5 1:81

deificeps 5:31 hceeps 3:1 12,81,5:4

32:4 51,3:5 02,91:6 22,02,81,71,61:8

91,11,01:31 02,5:41 21:61 7,1:71 9:91 91:02 6:22

pS s'hcee 02:4 thgiepS 21:1 6:4 gnidneps 5:6 3:11 81,51:21 3:91 1:12

dnats 5:32 dradnats 31:51 11:71

71:91 4:02 sdradnats 52:41 sdradnats - desab

81:81 etats 4,2:7 3:02

detats 02:4 1:81 stnemetats 71:21 4:12

setatS 32,01,1:1 51,6:6 91,7:7 8:9 91:01 1:11 32:11 1 52:2 3:42 noitats 2:31 sutats

81:5 42,6:51 42,32,12:02 61,31:12

3:22 yrotutats 22:5 11:8

7:11 7:12 nehpetS 41:1 srekcits 2:01

teertS 12:1 tcirts 61,8:61

92

gnorts 3:61 erutcurts 7:61 81:02

tcejbus 2:71 detcejbus 1:8 91:61

noitpircsbus 32:21 noitcesbuS :01 4 laitnatsbus 2:8 12:61

01:22 yllaitnatsbus 61:51 deeccus 61:51

sseccus 4:61 01:22 reffus 91,71:51

yltneiciffus 3:8 41:21 22:61

evitseggus 01:01 etiuS 51:1 smus 4:6

troppus 5:5 61:9 51:61 detroppus 4:7 3:21

32:12 gnitroppus 8:02

stroppus 61:71 arpus 52:7 8 4:

emerpuS 42,61,51:6 5,1:7 11:8 6:11 52:81 5:22

lavivruS 7:3 32:91 678.tC.S 6:3

T T 71:1

roliat 4:41 nekat 4:01

detegrat 12:91 CINOHPELET 8:1

htneT 22:51 42:61 4:71 smret 1:9 2:11 7:41 41:71

tset 91:5 41:21 5:51 52,42,61:71 91,7:81

91:91 12:02 42,71:12 22 4: stset 81:5 7:81 knahT 4,3,2:32

driht 32:41 semohT 51:1

denetaerht 81:51 eerht 91:4 81:51

dlohserht 22:11 emit 81:22 eltiT 6:6 91,6:7 31,7:9

02:01 32,1:11 latot 02:11

snoitcasnart 22:11 debircsnart 61:22

tpircsnart 8:1 61:22 4:42

rerusaert 42:11

Page 30: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

saert yru 81:6 11:7 hcnert 21:02

lairt 1:61 dereggirt 42:81

sreggirt 31:5 eurt 4:81

hturT 31:3 41:11 nrut 3:11

gninruT 32:81 owt 11:01 71:51 7:81

42:91 1:02 epyt 4:31

sepyt 81:31

U suougibmanu 01:01

11:81 lanoitutitsnocnu 6:7

41:8 81,11,2:41 6:51 noitutitsnocnu ylla

21:5 52:41 51:81 dnatsrednu 12:5

ekatrednu 2:71 yludnu 21:02

etanutrofnu 02:81 deifitnedinu 02:31

detaroprocninu 81:4 snoinu 81:6 11:7 detinU 32,01,1:1 6:3

61,51,6:6 21,9,6,5:7 12,91,71,61:7 4:8 7:9

91:01 32,1:11 52:21 32:61 51:71 11,6,3:91

3:42 etinU s'd 51:02

yllufwalnu 5:22 elbakatsimnu 01:01

01:81 detalernu 02:21

dlehpu 32:6 9,2:7 3:91 egru 52:9

esu 21:8 61:71 sesu 51:9

S.U 3:2 61,11,9,6,5,2:3 42:6 42,1:7 11:8 81:9 6:11 32:51 32:61 11:02

V v 31,21,01,9,7,6,5,3,2:3

51:3 eugav 21:5 52:41 2:81 51:81

aV oel 5:3 6:11 eulav 11:9 42:21

seulav 7:02 yteirav 8:31 21:41 suoirav 32,51:4 3:5

03

(134 )i()A()8 5:11 1:31 )i()A()9(134 31:9 5:11

334 32:11 434 32:11

)iii()H()4()b(434 4:21 )c(434 91:01

a144 6:6 s'b144 7:7

d144 02:7 )a(d144 6:31

)3()a(d144 01:02 944 9:3 11:8 074 42:8 474 3:81 494 2:3 1:7

5 045 11:3 32:6 445 41:3 51:11 42:61 845 9:71 945 31:71 155 9:3 11:8 155 - 25 22:71 255 11,2:81 455 91:81 555 61,41:3 51:11

32:51 6:12 655 22:12 755 1:22 855 6:3 32:61 7:22

5955 61:21 42:02 5955 - 69 61:12 6955 - 79 42:02 1065 12,61:21 11,2:12

6 6 11,6,2:3 4:21

206 12:21 116 21:3 3:71

46 42:7 4:8 56 8:3 11:4 32:91 2 31:0 256 2:3 1:7 866 32:1 966 21:3 3:71 076 3:3 22:51 676 21:3 3:71 186 41:3 51:11 32:61

22,9:71 22,6:12

7 7 61,5:3 32:51 3:81

27 51:21 42:02 11:12 61:12

47 9:41 57 9:41 67 3:01 41:41 77 61:41

7:31 ollassaV 22:1 32,32:22

1:32 susrev 5:4 52,32,61:6

01:8 11 41,6: 32,12:51 32,32:61 3:71 2:81

22:91 etov 12,91,91,61:9

SV 5:1

W W 9:1

llaw 42:8 detnaw 42:22

detnarraw 8:61 notgnihsaW 12:1

etisbew 6:21 hgiew 61:51

tnew 4:8 retniW 51:3 22:51

nisnocsiW 9:3 02,01:8 32:8 52:71 9,6,2:81 sehsiw 7:31 ttocloW 3:2

sdrow 42:9 gnimoyW 51,31,6,1:1

42,61:1 4:2 91:4 4:42

Y raey 42,61:01 1:11

htuoY 21:3 3:71

Z xairiZ 3:3 12:51

Z-I-R-I-A-X 12:51

$ 000,1$ 52,42:01 21:11

002$ 81:01 4:21 052$ 61:01

1 1 5:3 2,2:5 6:11

01 2:5 ht01 21,4:3

21.71.01 6:42 22.001 41:9 4:01

)b(22.001 11:5 2:41 81,01:41 32,51:71

42,71,51,8,5:81 0001 51:71

301 9:51 73701 71:1

)e(01.901 02:01 11 41:3 01:5 41:9

02:01 7:21 6:31 51:71

)1()a(11.011 7:21 )3()a(11.011 6:31

111 3:2 1111 3:3 22:51 5211 3:3 22:51

21 - VC - 721 6:4 21 - VC - 721 - SWS 4:1 31 41:31

031 6:3 61:6 41 31 42: 51 61,4:3 71 21:3 2:02 91 8:3

2091 51:1 1791 2:6 3:9 6791 5:3 6:11 0991 2:3 1:7 5991 8:3 42:91

2 2 1,1:2 02:5 6:6 91,6:7

31,7:9 02:01 32,1:11 52:21

d2 8:3 02 61:3 32:51

002 - rallod 22:11 3002 11:3 42:6 7002 9:3 11:8 8:21

42:02 21:12 8002 61:3 42:51

102 51:1 52:7 0102 21,6:3 71:6 4:71 2102 5:1 41,4:3 91:4 7:5 61:11 12:31

22:51 302 31:7

36402 12:1 502 31:7

05802 81:1 12 91:4

712 3:2 62 7:5

562 - 0825 4:2 582 8:3 32:91 592 8:3 32:91 692 41:02

3 3 5:1

703 4:2 013 6:3 32:61

)b(613 01:7

4 ht4 41:3

1204 31:1 424 5:3 42:7 6:11

11:02 )71(134 8:9

)A()4(134 2:11

Page 31: IN T HE UNIT ED S TA TE S DI STRICT COURT FO R T HE ...transition.fec.gov/law/litigation/freespeech_dc_transcript.pdfin t he unit ed s ta te s di strict court fo r t he district of

13

8 8 9:3

82:8 5:1 18 22:41 28 22:41 11:02

10028 61,31:1 30028 - 8660 42:1 10628 4:2

78 3:51 678 71:6

9 50:9 5:1 6:32

319 31:7 419 3:91 519 7:8 6:91

39 11:3 42:6 49 1:9 9

999 12:1