116
NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by Charles E. Harris Langley Research Center, Hampton, Virginia National Aeronautics and Space Administration Langley Research Center Hampton, Virginia 23681-2199 August 1998 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19980237207 2018-12-03T08:03:37+00:00Z

Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

NASA / TM-1998-208714

Implementation Plan for the NASA Centerof Excellence for Structures and Materials

Edited byCharles E. Harris

Langley Research Center, Hampton, Virginia

National Aeronautics and

Space Administration

Langley Research CenterHampton, Virginia 23681-2199

August 1998

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19980237207 2018-12-03T08:03:37+00:00Z

Page 2: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Available from the following:

NASA Center for AeroSpace Information (CASI)7121 Standard Drive

Hanover, MD 21076-1320

(301) 621-0390

National Technical Information Service (NTIS)

5285 Port Royal Road

Springfield, VA 22161-2171(703) 487-4650

Page 3: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Executive Summary

This report presents the implementation plans of the Center of Excellence (COE) forStructures and Materials. The plan documented herein is the result of an Agencywide planningactivity led by the Office of the Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials at LangleyResearch Center (LaRC). The COE Leadership Team, with a representative from each NASAField Center, was established to assist LaRC in fulfilling the responsibilities of the COE. TheLeadership Team developed the plan presented in this report.

The Structures and Materials COE will provide the leadership for coordination, planning,advocacy, and assessment of the structures and materials research and technology developmentactivities throughout the Agency. The COE will promote the development of new material systemsand processes, innovative structural mechanics and dynamics design and analysis methods,experimental techniques, and advanced structural concepts through technology validation foraircraft, space transportation vehicles, science instruments and spacecraft. The COE will addresstechnology challenges to enable more affordable, lighter weight, higher strength and stiffness,

safer, and more durable vehicles for subsonic, supersonic, and sustained hypersonic flight, earthand other planetary atmospheric entry, and for spacecraft flight throughout the solar system.

The Structures and Materials COE will implement the following five specific functionalresponsibilities:

1. Conduct a periodic assessment of the current technical capabilities in relation to futureAgency missions and technology requirements.

2. Maintain and enhance the preeminent technical capabilities distributed throughout theAgency.

3. Proactively participate i'n planning future Agency programs.

4. Serve as the primary point-of-contact for requests for structures and materials technical

information and for requests to participate in urgent investigations of critical problems.

5. Build strategic alliances / partnerships with all NASA Field Centers, other COE's, industry,academia, other Government Agencies, and international partners.

The COE will be led by the COE Office at Langley Research Center with strategicpartnerships established among the NASA Field Centers, forming the COE Community. The COEOffice will provide the strategic leadership required to implement the functional responsibilities ofthe COE. The COE Community will be responsible for maintaining and enhancing the preeminenttechnical and programmatic expertise and ground test facilities and laboratories distributed

throughout the Agency. The COE Community will develop and maintain partnerships withindustry, academia, and other Government Agencies to leverage external programs and resourcesto achieve NASA strategic objectives. The COE Office will coordinate with the other COE's and

key NASA Headquarters Offices, as appropriate, to effectively and efficiently meet the researchand technology needs of all the NASA Strategic Enterprises.

Page 4: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Table of Contents

1.02.03.04.05.06.07.08.09.010.011.012.0

IntroductionMissionVision

AuthorityTechnology ScopeInventory of Agencywide Technical CapabilitiesFunctional Responsibilities and Implementation PlansCOE Leadership TeamSummary of Responsibilities

Agencywide Collaborative Activity Leads to Revolutionary New TechnologyConcluding Remarks: Keys to SuccessReferences

Appendix: Inventory of Technical Capabilities

Page #

11133461212141515

16

List of Figures

Figure 1. NASA Center Partners in the COE CommunityFigure 2. The COE Technology ScopeFigure 3. Periodic assessments of the current technical capabilitiesFigure 4. Notional diagram of the process for program development

Page #

2277

List of Tables

Table 1. Disciplinary Technical SkillsTable 2. Facilities and Laboratories

Table 3. FY 98 Programs and Civil Service WorkforceTable 4. Existing Disciplinary Working GroupsTable 5. Existing Disciplinary Alliances

Page #

455911

Page 5: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Implementation Plan

for the

NASA Center of Excellence

for

Structures and Materials

1.0 Introduction

This report presents the implementation plans of the Center of Excellence (COE) for

Structures and Materials. The plan documented herein is the result of an Agencywide planningactivity led by the Office of the Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials at Langley

Research Center (LaRC). Under LaRC's leadership, a partnership has been established among thenine (9) NASA Field Centers, shown in Figure 1, with dedicated structures and materials

capabilities. The COE Leadership Team, with a representative from each NASA Field Center, wasestablished to assist LaRC in fulfilling the responsibilities of the COE. The Leadership Teamdeveloped the plan presented in this report.

2.0 Mission

The Structures and Materials COE will provide the leadership for coordination, planning,advocacy, and assessment of the structures and materials research and technology developmentactivities throughout the Agency. The COE will promote the development of new material systemsand processes, innovative structural, mechanics and dynamics design and analysis methods,experimental tecfiniques, and advanced structural concepts through technology validation foraircraft, space transportation vehicles, science instruments and spacecraft. The COE will addresstechnology challenges to enable more affordable, lighter weight, higher strength and stiffness,

safer, and more durable vehicles for subsonic, supersonic, and sustained hypersonic flight, earthand other planetary atmospheric entry, and for spacecraft flight throughout the solar system.

The COE will be led by the COE Office at Langley Research Center with strategicpartnerships established among the NASA Field Centers, forming the COE Community. The COEOffice will provide the strategic leadership required to implement the functional responsibilities ofthe COE. The COE Community will be responsible for maintaining and enhancing the preeminenttechnical and programmatic expertise and ground test facilities and laboratories distributed

throughout the Agency. The COE Community will develop and maintain partnerships withindustry, academia, and other Government Agencies to leverage external programs and resourcesto achieve NASA strategic objectives. The COE Office will coordinate with the other COE's and

key NASA Headquarters Offices, as appropriate, to effectively and efficiently meet the researchand technology needs of all the NASA Strategic Enterprises.

3.0 Vision

The COE Office is the Agencywide technical conscience for structures and materials

technologies and fulfills a strategic leadership function. The Agency will benefit from the COECommunity through the effective and efficient utility of the comprehensive inventory of technicalcapabilities distributed across the Agency, coordination of these capabilities, leading andparticipating in strategic planning, and maintaining and enhancing the preeminent Agency corecompetency in structures and materials.

Page 6: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Ames Research CenterLewis Research Center

Jet

PropulsionLaboratory

Dryden Flight Research Center

Johnson Space Center

Marshall

Space

FlightCenter

Goddard Space Flight Center

Langley /_/_

Research ._

Center _f_

Kennedy Space Center

Figure 1. NASA Center Partners in the COE Community

Fundamental --tl_ Proof of Feasibility --ID,. Validation

__pUnderstanding'("_'[_'s°2"l_"_i[ /& Analyses_m [__i & Testing i

_,ircraft (ASTT_ i. ;J .

_I.aRC: Airframe Mat and Str (L.I for AST, HSR, Safety, and Airframe Systems)_iI q& I

iLeRC: Turbomach. Mat and Sir (L. I for Aeropropulaion, iAerospace Power) _[

i q_ OEM Industry, DFRC: flight operntions_ airlines

Space TransportatiOn Vehicles (ASTT, HEDS, ES, SS) i

LaRC: Pri. Str. & Met. TPS, ARC: TPS, MSFC: Cryotank !

-LeRC: Turbo Mat & St, MSFC: Sp Prop Met & Str :

xk( MSFC : Dev & App (L.II), JSC: L.I HEDSI

._pacecraft and Spa(_e Station (HEDS, E_, SS) !

CLaRC : Advanced Materials and Structures Concept

Applications

KSC I industry

i

JPL & GSFC : Dev & App (L.II)r JSC: L.I HEDS_ industry ._

Figure 2. The COE Technology Scope

Page 7: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

4.0 Authority

The Agency authority invested in the Structures and Materials COE is assigned to LaRC inthe NASA Strategic Plan [1]. Further guidance and responsibilities are outlined in the NASAStrategic Management Handbook [2]. The COE is required to conduct periodic assessments of thestatus of the Agency technical capabilities with the expectation that the specific recommendationscontained in these assessments will be acted on by the Center Directors, Enterprise AssociateAdministrators, Office of Chief Technologist, Office of the Chief Engineer, TechnologyLeadership Council, and the Capital Investment Council, as appropriate.

5.0 Technology Scope

The technology scope of the COE, illustrated schematically in Figure 2, includes researchprograms, technology development and demonstration programs; and the application of structuresand materials technologies to NASA atmospheric flight missions, space launch operations, spaceand earth sciences missions, and the Space Station. (The Lead Center assignments for majorAgency programs are designated by L.I or L.II in Figure 2.)

The technology scope encompasses the airframe and engine of subsonic, supersonic, andhypersonic aircraft; primary structure, cryotank, thermal protection systems, and propulsionsystems of space transportation vehicles; space science instruments, and power and structuralcomponents of spacecraft; the Space Station; earth and other planetary atmospheric entry vehicles,and human space/planetary habitats.

The partnerships among the 9 NASA Field Centers is based on the following specifictechnology application focus at each Center:

Ames Research Center: thermal protection systems

Dryden Flight Research Center: atmospheric flight qualification, demonstration, andevaluation

Goddard Space Flight Center: space and earth science missions and technologydevelopment

Jet Propulsion Laboratory: spacecraft and space science instrument development andapplications

Johnson Space Center (including the White Sand Test Facility): space shuttle, spacestation, and advanced spacecraft development and applications

Kennedy Space Center: materials characterization and failure analysis in support ofspace launch operations

Langley Research Center: airframe primary structure; primary structure, cryotank, andmetallic thermal protection systems of space transportation vehicles; and advanced conceptsfor spacecraft and space science instruments

Lewis Research Center: turbomachinery for aircraft engines and space transportationvehicles; aerospace power; power for LEO, MEO, and GSO planetary spacecraft, andspace experiments

Marshall Space Flight Center: primary and secondary structure, cryotanks, andTPS/insulation for integrated space transportation and propulsion system structure; andadvanced space instruments, payloads, and subsystems

3

Page 8: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

6.0 Inventory of Agencywide Technical Capabilities

A detailed inventory of the Agencywide structures and materials technical capabilities is

given in the Appendix. The inventory includes a listing of the disciplinary technical skills relativeto specific applications, description of the dedicated structures and materials facilities andlaboratories, and the FY 98 Programs with the associated structures and materials civil serviceworkforce for each Center in the COE Community. Over 300 disciplinary skills are listed in the

inventory. A summary of these skills is given in Table 1. Over 100 dedicated facilities andlaboratories are described in the inventory. A summary of these experimental capabilities are givenin Table 2. The structures and materials workforce is supporting all 4 NASA Enterprises and 71programs are listed in the inventory. A summary of the civil service workforce is given in Table 3.Examples of recent structures and materials technical accomplishments from each NASA Center is

also given in the Appendix.

Table 1. Disciplinary Technical Skills

Technical Capabilities

New materials development

LaRC LeRC T ARC DFRC MSFC JSC+WSTF

Materials processing & fabrication technology

Materials characterization &.failure analysis

Materials durability & fatigue and fracture

Tribology (coatings, lubricants, & bearings)

Nondestructive evaluation sciences & NDE/I R', RaD,S

Structural mechanics, strength, & design meth. Rf, RaD,S

Dynamics, vibration & modal analysis & tests Rf, RaD.S

Structural acoustics methodology & testing R f, Ra

Aeroelasticity analysis methods & testing R f, Ra, D

Flight hardware design, fabrication, & testing D, S

MPC

R r, R a

MPC

Rf, R a

• MPCR f, Ra,D, S

MPCR f, R a

KSC GSFC JPL

MPC C

Rf Ra Rf, Ra , D

MPC C MPCRf, Ra Rf, RaD, S Ra, D, S MPD, S PD, S PD, S

MPC C M'PC MPCMPD, S MPD, S PD, SRf Ra,D,S Rf, RaD, S Ra, D,S Ra.D,S

MPC Mt_ MRf, Ra Ra, D, S MPD, S Ra, D. S MPD, S

Rf, Ra R a, D, S S D, S

R_'Ra Ra, D, S Ra, D, S S D,S D,SD,S

Rf Ra, D,S D,S Ra D,S S D,S S S

Rf, Ra D,S Ra, D,S Ra, D, S S D,S D,S D,S

Rf, Ra D,S D,S S D,S D,S D,S

Rf, Ra, D, S Ra, D, S

D,S D,S D,S D,S D,S S D,S D,S

Capability Code: M = metallic alloys and compositesP = polymers and compositesC = high temperature ceramic and refractory materials and compositesRf = fundamental research, and Ra = applied (focused) research

D = technology development and demonstrationS = innovative engineering for mission supportxT= high temperature propulsion materials and structures

Page 9: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Table 2. Facilities and Laboratories

Laboratories and Facilities

Polymers and composites

Metals and composites

Ceramics, refractory mat'l and composites

Mat'ls characterization, analysis, and properties

Durability and mission simulation

Fatigue and fracture

Tribology (coatings, lubricants, & bearings)

Nondestructive evaluation sciences and NDE/I

High temperature, high heat flux facilities

Large component structural test facilities

Structural dynamics, vibration, and acoustics

Thermal vacuum and space simulator facilities

Electromechanieai, MEMS/MOMS, & actuators

Aerothermodynamic structures facilities

Spacecraft / instrument fab, assembly & testing

Unique facilities with specialized capability

LaRC LeRC IARC DFRC MSFC[ JSC+WSTF

R&D R&D D, S D, S

R&D R&D R&D, S D, S

R&D R&D R&D: D, S

R&D,S R&D,S R&D R&D,S D,S

R&D R&D R&D, S

R&D R&D R&D, S D, S

R&D R&D, S

R&D, S R&D, S R&D, S D, S

R&D R&D R&D R&D D, S D, S

R&D R&D D, S D, S

R&D,S R&D,S R&D, S D, S D, S

R&D,S R&D, S D, S

R&D R&D R&D, S D, S D, S

R&D R&D D, S

D,S D,S D,S D,S

TDT, IDRF ITurbomac Arc Jet Flight Large tests,

ALDF Comp Test Complex Loads Turbopump

COLTS Complex Lab LOX & LH

KSC GSFC JPL

D,S D,S

D,S D,S

D,S

R&D, S R&D, S D, S

D,S D,S

R&D, S D, S D, S

D,S

S D,S D,S

D,S D,S

D,S D,S

D,S D,S D,S

D, S D, S R&D, S

D,S D,S

&re Jets. Beach Site Centrifuge, 13'& 27'Nat Testing Corrosion, Outgassing Space:n Haz. Env. LETF 6 DOF Simulator

R = research D = technology development and demonstration S = support of flight hardware

Table 3. FY 98 Programs and Civil Service Workforce

By Technical Function LaRC LeRC ARC

Research and Technology 236 183 31Development

Facility & Laboratory 184 117 16Operations

Flight Hardware Designand Fabrication 20 26 2

By Enterprise

Aeronautics and SpaceTransportation Technology

DFRC MSFC JSC KSC GSFC JPL Totals+WSTF

11 119 0 13 30 49 672

15 0 22 53 18 42 455

1 210 47 3 259 149 729

Human Exploration and

Development of Space

Earth Science

Space Science

Other programs

Total Workforce, CS FTE's

LaRC LeRC ARC DFRC MSFC JSC KSC GSFC JPL 'Totals+WSTF

368 294 43 26 106 2 17 0 0 856

9 5 0 0 150 67 52 0 0 283

8 1 0 0 5 0 0 53 107 174

29 18 6 0 30 0 0 162 130 375

26 8 0 1 38 0 0 92 3 168

440 326 49 27 329 69 69 307 24O 1856

Page 10: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

7.0 Functional Responsibilities and Implementation Plans

Using the guidance provided in the NASA Strategic Management Handbook, the Center ofExcellence for Structures and Materials has adopted the following five (5) specific functional

responsibilities:

1. Conduct a periodic assessment of the current technical capabilities in relation to future

Agency missions and technology requirements.

2. Maintain and enhance the preeminent technical capabilities distributed throughout the

Agency.

3. Proactively participate in planning future Agency programs.

4. Serve as the primary point-of-contact for requests for structures and materials technicalinformation and for requests to participate in urgent investigations of critical problems("911 calls").

5. Build strategic alliances / partnerships with all NASA Field Centers, other COE's,industry, academia, other Government Agencies, and international partners.

The tasks required to implement each functional responsibility are described in the

following sections.

7.1 Conduct a periodic assessment of the current technical capabilities in relationto future Agency missions and technology requirements.

A process has been developed for conducting the periodic assessment of the current.technical capabilities distributed throughout the COE Community. This process is outlined in theprocess flow diagram shown in Figure 3. The COE will implement the following specific tasks:

1. The COE Office will compile and publish an inventory of the Agency's structures and materials

capabilities. Each Center will provide the following data:• technical capabilities,• description of facilities and laboratories,• current FY programs and associated civil service workforce (FTE's),• recent accomplishments and problems solved,• identify future Agency missions/needs and technical requirements,• identify examples of a "technology push" that enables a future Agency mission.

2. Each Center will conduct a self-assessment of strengths, weaknesses, and gaps with respect to

Enterprise goals and objectives.

3. The COE Office will coordinate the Center self-assessments, identify overarching themes,

develop list of deficiencies, and benchmark NASA capabilities to those of outside organizations,as appropriate.

4. The COE Office will lead the development of recommendations to address deficiencies, andproactively advocate appropriate implementation of the recommendations.

5. Each Center will develop a Structures and Materials Facilities and Laboratories Brochuresuitable for public dissemination.

6

Page 11: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Needs

[dentified

COE Community• Vision and Mission

• Center partnerships• Technology scope• Inventory of capabilities

* Programs & workforce

Do capabilitiesexist to

satisfy need?

yes

Deficiencies

Identified

Add

capabilityto COE ?

yes

refer

need

outside

COEX

Can supplier Develop / Add

of capability Capability

help?yes,

Collaborate!

Figure 3. Periodic assessments of the current technical capabilities

COEis

Proactive

COEis

Reactive

CustomerNeeds

ConceptsDefinitions

TechnologyRequirements

TechnologyRoadmaps

Program

Imp

Concepts

Figure 4. Notional diagram of the process for program development

7

Page 12: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

7.2 Maintain and enhance the preeminent technical capabilities distributed

throughout the Agency.

The responsibility to maintain and enhance the preeminent technical capabilities distributedthroughout the Agency resides with the line management at each participating Center. The COEwill establish Working Groups in specific technical areas that cross-cut the structures and materialscommunity. The purpose of these Working Groups will be to discuss common problems, share

experiences, and form partnerships where cooperative activities are mutually beneficial. It isanticipated that several Working Groups will be established as standing committees to address themaintenance and enhancement of technical skills and expertise. However, Working Groups toaddress the enhancement of Facilities and Laboratories will only be established when the need

arises from the periodic assessment of current technical capabilities. The COE will implement the

following specific tasks:

1. The COE Office will coordinate the establishment of Working Groups by conducting a canvas

of the COE Community to obtain a list of existing relevant Working Groups, identify candidatetechnical areas for new Working Groups, and gage the interest in participating. (Table 4 contains alist of some of the existing NASA Working Groups.)

2. The COE Office will initiate a discussion with existing Working Groups that may be

appropriate to facilitate the objectives of the COE.

3. Where sufficient interest exists to create a new Working Group, the COE Office will lead the

development of a charter, solicit names of the members from the interested Centers, and a kick-offmeeting will be organized.

4. The COE Community will voluntarily participate in those Working Groups that directly benefit

the participating Centers.

7.3 Proactively participate in planning future Agency programs.

A notional diagram of the NASA process for program creation, implementation, andmission support is shown in Figure 4. The COE will be proactive in planning future programs and

Agency missions. This proactive role will help insure that all future programs are planned with anappropriate structures and materials content. Also, visionary plans for long-term developments instructures and materials will be advocated as examples of technologies that can enable future

Agency missions that are not currently conceived. The (OE will implement the following tasks:

1. The COE Office will coordinate the support for planning future programs as requests are

received and opportunities identified.

2. The COE Community will voluntarily participate in the planning activities as

requests/opportunities arise.

3. The responsibility to communicate throughout the COE Community the information regardingrequests and opportunities is jointly shared by the COE Office and the COE Community members.

4. The COE Office will engage in regular discussions wi_:h key personnel in Enterprise and

Program Offices. These discussions are intended to be i_formational in content. (Advocacy forimplementing recommendations is part of the responsibility for conducting periodic assessments ofcurrent technical capabilities.)

5. The COE will organize and participate in workshops of specific technical issues of interest tothe COE Community. Emphasis will be given to the long-term view, especially where structuresand materials has an opportunity to provide a "technology push" that enables a future Agencymission. (Participation on the organizing committee and in the workshop is voluntary.)

Page 13: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Table 4. Existing Disciplinary Working Groups

• NASA NDE Working Group• NASA Materials and Processes Working Group• NASA Fracture Control Panel

• NASA Design, Analysis, Test, and Verification Working Group• Engineering Standards Steering Committee• NASA Reliability Board• Vibroacoustics Standards Panel

• NASA Space Mechanisms Working Group• NASA Microdynamics Working Group• NASA Structural Dynamics Working Group• Telerobotic Intercenter Working Group• NASA Structures Probabilistics Working Group• Loads Standards Panel

• Life Prediction of Ceramic Matrix Composites for RLV Applications• Fracture Toughness Testing of Lithium-Aluminum Shuttle Tank Replacement Materials• Characterization of NASA-derived Advanced Polymeric Materials• Space Environments and Effects Program: Meteroid & Orbital Debris, Materials & Processes,

and Ionizing Radiation Technical Working Groups• Headquarters S&MA Structures Probabilistics Working Group• Shuttle Replacement Technology Team• NASA Operational Environment Team• ECoA Intercenter Planning Team for the Environmental Initiative• EOs Structural/Mechanical/Dynamic Loads and Environment Integration of Launch Vehicles• Structural Stability Research Council• Synthetic Thinned-Aperture Radiometer (STAR) Development Team• Structural Stability Research Council• Langley Smart Structures Technical Committee• The Technical Cooperation Program on Structures & Dynamics of Aeronautical Vehicles• Gust Specialists Committee

9

Page 14: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

7.4 Serve as the primary point-of-contact for requests for structures andmaterials technical information and for requests to participate in urgentinvestigations of critical problems ("911 calls").

In order to fulfill the reactive role illustrated notionally in Figure 4, the COE will implementthe following specific tasks:

1. The COE Office will respond to requests for technical information as the need arises. The COEOffice will use the Directory of Key Personnel (points-of-contact included in the CapabilitiesInventory) provided by each Center as a source of referrals when the Office cannot fulfill a request.

2. The COE Office will assign action items to appropriate Centers when requests to participate inurgent investigations of critical problems ("911 calls") are received.

3. The COE Community will voluntarily participate in "911 calls" at a level judged to beappropriate by the Center(s) receiving the request from the COE Office.

4. Those requests for technical information or "911 calls" that involve multiple Centers will becommunicated throughout the COE Community by the COE Office and/or the members of theCommunity.

7.5 Build strategic alliances / partnerships with all NASA Field Centers, otherCOE's, industry, academia, other Government Agencies, and internationalpartners.

The foundation of the Cehter'of Excellence for Structures and Materials is the partnershipestablished among the NASA Field Centers. The voluntary participation of all NASA Field

Centers in the COE partnership is viewed to be essential for success. The NASA community ofexcellence in structures and materials will benefit from alliances with external organizations.Numerous alliances and partnerships already exist between members of the COE Community andexternal organizations.

In the context of the COE Implementation Plan, an alliance will be defined as an enduringrelationship, connecting parties with common interests (needs), that does not disappear withspecific programs. The COE will implement the following specific tasks:

1. The COE Office will canvas the COE Community, compile, and distribute a list of existingstructures and materials alliances. (Table 5 contains a list of some of the existing alliances.)

2. The COE Community will identify opportunities for oth_._r community partners to join existingalliances.

3. The list of alliances will be evaluated by the COE Office and Community to identify needs notcurrently fulfilled by the existing alliances.

4. The COE Office will inform the COE Community of opportunities to form new alliances.

5. The specific actions to form new alliances will be the vcluntary initiative of the individualmembers of the COE Community.

10

Page 15: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Table 5. Existing Disciplinary Alliances

• Life Prediction of Metal Matrix Composite Ring Structure (NASA LeRC, and DoD)• Life Prediction of Toughned Ceramics for Heat Engines (NASA LeRC, and ORNL)• T700 Engine Lfie Management Program (NASA LeRC, and DoD)• Guide Consortium on Turbomachinery Forced Response (NASA, DoD, and industry)• High Cycle Fatigue Program (NASA LeRC, and DoD)

• Interagency Advanced Power Group, Thermal Management Subgroup (NASA, DoD, and DoE)• Carbon-Carbon Spacecraft Radiator Partnership (NASA, DoD, and Industry)• Shock and Vibration Information and Analysis Center (SAVIAC), Technical Advisory Group

(NASA, DoD, DoE, and industry)

• International Structural Optimization Workshop (NASA, ESA, academia, and industry)• Government Flight Flutter Test Council (NASA, DoD)

• DFRC Flight Test Center Alliance for Flutter Testing (NASA DFRC, and USAFFRC)• Corrosion Technology (NASA KSC, NRL)• Advanced Materials Processing & Analysis Center (NASA KSC, UCF)• Advanced Composites Working Group Steering Committee (NASA, DoD)

• Mil Handbook 17 Working Group to develop the Specification for SiC/A1 MMC(NASA, DoD, FAA, and Industry)

• Mil Handbook 17 Working Group on Specialized Data Development(NASA, DoD, FAA, and industry)

• MMC Working Group for Versailles Project on Advanced Materials and Standards(consortium of laboratories in 8 countries)

• JANNAF Material Properties and Processing Panel (NASA, DoD)

• Integrated High Payoff Rocket Propulsion Technology Materials Working Group (NASA, DoD)• ISS Materials and Processes Analysis and Integration Team (NASA, industry)• NASA/USAF Wind Tunnel'Alliance: facilities with arc heaters

(NASA ARC, JSC, LaRC, and the USAF AEDC)• NATO Research Test Orginization: for TPS and arc jet testing (NATO members)• Rotorcraft Leadership Team (NASA, Army)• Rotorcraft HUMS Team (NASA, Army)• Civil Tilt Rotor Capacity Planning Team (NASA, industry)• Lower Density Higher Temperature Polymer Matrix Composite Partnership (JPL, USAFRL)• Composite Structures Design Working Group (NASA, DoD, FAA, and industry)• Airframe Structural Integrity Working Group (NASA, DoD, FAA, and industry)• Composite Armor Group (NASA, Army)

• Transportation Research Board: Pavement Surface Properties Committee(NASA, DOT, DoD, and industry)

• AGARD Working Group on experimental steady and unsteady aerodynamic data(AGARD member countries)

• IHFFET Steering Committee (NASA LeRC and DoD)• IHPTET Fiber Consortium (NASA LeRC, DoD, and engine companies)

11

Page 16: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

8.0 COE Leadership Team

The Director of each participating Center has appointed a member to serve on the COELeadership Team. The designated member will serve as the single-point-of-contact forcoordinating all tasks that are the responsibility of each Center, listed in Section 9.2 below. TheLeadership Team will meet annually to review the COE progress, prioritize recommendations, andprovide guidance for future activities. The members of the current Leadership Team are:

• Charles E. Harris, Chief Technologist for Structures and Materials, COE Office, LangleyResearch Center, Leadership Team Chairperson

• Mark J. Shuart, Chief, Materials Division, and in alternating years, Woodrow Whitlow,Jr., Chief, Structures Division, Langley Research Center

• Hugh R. Gray, Chief, Materials Division, Lewis Research Center

• Ann F. Whitaker, Director, Materials and Processes Laboratory, and in alternating years,W. Randy Humphries, Director, Structures and Dynamics Laboratory, Marshall SpaceFlight Center

• Michael V. DeAngelis, Ast. Director, Research Engineering Directorate, Dryden FlightResearch Center

• Michael C. Lou, Member Technical Staff, Jet Propulsion Laboratory

• Steven J. Brodeur, Ast. Chief, Mechanical Systems Center, Goddard Space FlightCenter

• James O. Arnold, Chief, Space Technology Division, Ames Research Center

• Edward T. Chimenti, Chief, Structures and Mechanics Division, Johnson Space Center

• Timothy R. Bollo, Chief, Materials Science Division, Kennedy Space Center

9.0 Summary of Responsibilities

9.1 Specific Responsibilities of the COE Office

The COE Office at Langley Research Center is responsible for the following specific tasks:

1. Compile and publish an inventory of the Agency's structures and materials capabilities.

2. Coordinate the Center self-assessments, identify overa:'ching themes, develop list ofdeficiencies, and benchmark NASA capabilities to those of outside organizations, as appropriate.

3. Lead the development of recommendations to address deficiencies, and proactively advocateappropriate implementation of the recommendations.

4. Coordinate the establishment of Working Groups, as needed.

5. Initiate a discussion with existing Working Groups that may be appropriate to facilitate theobjectives of the COE.

12

Page 17: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

6. Leadthedevelopmentof thecharterfor newWorkingGroups,solicitnamesof themembersfrom theinterestedCenters,andorganizeakick-off meeting.

7. Coordinatethesupportfor planningfutureprogramsasrequestsarereceivedandopportunitiesidentified.

8. CommunicatethroughouttheCOECommunitythe informationregardingrequestsandopportunitiesto participateinplanningactivities.

9. Engagein regular(informational)discussionswith keypersonnelin EnterpriseandProgramOffices.

10. Organize and participate in workshops of specific technical issues of interest to the COECommunity.

11. Respond to requests for technical information using the Directory of Key Personnel as asource of referrals when the Office cannot fulfill a request.

12. Assign action items to appropriate Centers when requests to participate in urgent investigationsof critical problems ("911 calls") are received.

13. Communicate throughout the COE community those requests for technical information or"911 calls" that involve multiple Centers.

14. Canvas the COE Community, compile, and distribute a list of existing structures and materialsalliances.

15. Evaluate the list of alliances to identify needs not currently fulfilled by the existing alliances.

16. The COE Office will inform the COE Community of opportunities to form new alliances.

9.2 Summary of the Specific Responsibilities of each Center

Each Center in the COE Community is responsible for the following specific tasks:

1. Provide the data for the inventory of the Agency's structures and materials capabilities.

2. Conduct a periodic self-assessment of strengths, weaknesses, and gaps with respect toEnterprise goals and objectives.

3. Develop a Structures and Materials Facilities and Laboratories Brochure suitable for publicdissemination.

4. Voluntarily participate in those Working Groups that directly benefit the participating Center.

5. Voluntarily participate in the planning activities as requests and opportunities arise.

6. Communicate throughout the COE Community the information regarding requests andopportunities to participate in planning activities.

7. Voluntarily participate in workshops of specific technical issues of interest to the COECommunity.

13

Page 18: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

8. Voluntarilyparticipatein "911 calls"ata leveljudgedto beappropriateby theCenter(s)receivingtherequestfrom theCOEOffice.

9. CommunicatethroughouttheCOECommunitythoserequestsfor technicalinformationor "911calls" thatinvolvemultipleCenters.

10. Providealist of existingstructuresandmaterialsalliances.

11.Identifyopportunitiesfor othercommunityparmersto join existingalliances.

12. Evaluatethelist of alliancesto identifyneedsnotcurrentlyfulfilled by theexistingalliances.

13. Thespecificactionsto form new alliances will be the voluntary initiative of the individualmembers of the COE Community.

14. Appoint a member to serve on the COE Leadership Team. The Member will attend the annualLeadership Team Meeting to review the COE progress, prioritize recommendations, and provide

guidance for the next year.

10.0 Agencywide Collaborative Activity Leads to Revolutionary New Technology

It is interesting to note that one of NASA's most significant and lasting technicalcontributions in the field of structures and materials was a direct result of a collaborative effort

among all the NASA Field Centers. In January 1964, key personnel from all NASA Field Centersgathered at Headquarters in Washington to discuss efforts underway to improve structural analysismethods, particularly as it applied to the shell configurations commonly used in aerospacestructure. Each representative described how his group had written special-purpose computerprograms to analyze particular shell configurations. After this meeting, NASA Headquarterscommissioned an ad hoc committee, with a representative from each NASA Center, to investigate

the state of analysis methods in the aerospace industry. The first action taken by the committeewas to visit the aircraft companies which were doing prominent work in developing computer-

commlt_.ee s ws_ts to the aircraft companiesbased advanced structural analysis methods. The " " ' " "revealed that no single computer program incorporated enough of the best analysis features desired

by NASA. Therefore, the committee recommended to Headquarters that NASA sponsor thedevelopment of its own computer program as a means to upgrade the analytical capability of thewhole aerospace industry. Headquarters endorsed the recommendation and selected Goddard

Space Flight Center (GSFC) to manage the development of the computer program. Under theleadership of GSFC, the ad hoc committee developed a visionary and thorough technicalspecification for the computer program and released a Request for Proposals in July of 1965.Much of the eventual success of the project was directly a:tributed to the initial work of the NASAcommittee in developing the thorough specification for the computer program [3]. In December1965, NASA awarded two Phase I contracts for preparation of a Technical Evaluation Report, one

to a team led by the MacNeal-Schwendler Corporation (MSC) and one to the team led by DouglasAircraft Company. After an evaluation of the two competing Phase I Reports and the associatedPhase II proposals, MSC was selected as the recipient of the Phase II contract and begandevelopment of the computer program in July 1966. Shoaly thereafter, NASA designated thename of the computer program to be the N_..AASAS__T_Tructur_lANalysis (NASTRAN) ComputerProgram. The contracting team completed the computer program in 1969 and delivered it to all theNASA Field Centers. In February 1970, the Program Office at Goddard was disbanded. Later

that year, NASA Headquarters established the NASTRAN Systems Management Office (NSMO)at Langley Research Center. The NSMO had the dual mission of maintaining NASTRAN anddeveloping new capabilities for the program. A NASTRAN Advisory Group was set up to

14

Page 19: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

provideguidanceto theNSMO. ThisAdvisoryGroupconsistedof membersfrom eachof theNASACentersandwas,in effect,acontinuationof theadhoccommitteewhichdraftedtheinitialNASTRANspecificationin 1964. In November1970,NASTRANwasreleasedto thepublicthroughtheCOSMICDistributionCenterattheUniversityof Georgiafor thepriceof $1750.Lessthanayearlaterin September,thefirst NASTRANUsersConferenceheldatLangleyResearchCenterwasattendedby about200representativesof therapidlygrowingusercommunity.Thusweretheoriginsof themostsuccessfulfiniteelementstructuralanalysiscomputercodeusedthroughouttheworld andin virtually all industrialsectors.

11.0 Concluding Remarks: Keys to Success

The implementation plan documented herein relies on three fundamental keys to success.These keys to success are building the COE community, a commitment of resources by theparticipating Centers, and developing high-payoff advanced technologies. First, the Structures andMaterials COE Community is built on the voluntary partnership among 9 NASA Field Centers.Strategic alliances with external organizations will expand the Community. Collaborative activities

among the Community partners will evolve from the thorough knowledge of the technicalcapabilities of each Community member. The COE communications network will fostercollaboration. Second, the COE Community does not anticipate that the COE Office will be a

source of funding to support research, technology development, or mission support. However,membership in the COE Community requires that each Center provide those resources necessary toimplement the responsibilities listed in section 9.2 above. Third, it is encumbent upon the COECommunity to identify and develop those high-payoff advanced technologies that enable future

Agency missions. Each of these three "keys to success" are essential to achieving a meaningfulfulfillment of the requirements set forth in this implementation plan.

12.0 References

1. NASA Strategic Plan, NASA Policy Directive (NPD)-1000.1, National Aeronautics and SpaceAdministration, Washington, D. C., 20546, 1998, page 15.

2. NASA Strategic Management Handbook, National Aeronautics and Space Administration,Washington, D. C., 20546, 1996, pages 14-15.

3. The MacNeal-Schwendler Corporation, The First Twenty Five Years, by Dr. Richard H.MacNeal, The MacNeal-Schwendler Corporation, Major Aerospace and Defense Accounts, 1000Howard Blvd., Suite 105, Mount Laurel, NJ 08054, 1988.

15

Page 20: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Appendix: Inventory of Technical Capabilities

This Appendix contains the Agencywide inventory of structures and materials technical

capabilities. The inventory contains the following data for each Center:

• summary of technical capabilities• directory of technical points of contact• FY 98 programs and the associated structures and materials civil service workforce• brief summaries of recent technical accomplishments

• technical skills mapped against specific applications• descriptions of the dedicated structures and materials facilities and laboratories.

Some of the data in the inventory, such as the listing of programs and the associated civil

service workforce, may only be valid for the year in which it was compiled, FY 98. The COEexpects to update and publish the inventory on a periodic basis.

Table of Contents:

Langley Research CenterLewis Research CenterAmes Research Center

Dryden Flight Research CenterMarshall Space Flight CenterGoddard Space Flight CenterJet Propulsion LaboratoryJohnson Space CenterJSC: at White Sands Test Facility

Kennedy Space CenterStennis Space Center Facility

Page Number

A.IA. 13A. 24A. 34A. 41A. 52A. 65A. 76A. 83A. 87A. 95

16

Page 21: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 22: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II

0

m

m

Page 23: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 24: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 25: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 26: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 27: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 28: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

¢0

¢n

O

F3i • , • . - ..... , , • .............. ""- I

E E

• • : : ....... : : • •

O ' • : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : " : : : : : : :a,, : i i : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

. , , , . . , - ..... , , • ..............

,,.. 'o ........ ! i_!!':!! ! !"!:"i .... _!!!'.!!!!!!! !!!!: ' • : : : : : : : " : : : :cbo: :_:_:O_o:__u:

_]1 ,,,-, ._ .... _¢.)'_O'_ • • • Ir .............. . ..... _ . .n', ee. n-,_,ee. _ee. ee, iDn..,._.. _._. .... aeee.ee n". _' . . . ,_ ......

, , , • , . . • ..... , , .• , .... , . . • ..............

-., :_o',5 : : : :_0: : :O : : :_ : :_ : : : : : : : : : : :.... ,,,," - .re . • '[E • • re. ........,.- ._ i_. , . . It' _" : : . • • - : :•" : : : : : .......

_) ,,,.1',,,,.1',,_. " 2,-_ r : 2 . 2 : • : 2 . " : : 2 _ _ : ....

I I I | [ I I I I I I I I I I i I i I I I

• . , • , o . • ..... . . , • ..............

• . , • . , , • ..... , . , , ..............• , , • . . . • ..... . . , . ..............

4L_ , . , . . , . • ..... . . , • ..............

.__ • . . • . . . • ..... . . . • ..... : : _ : : : : : ',e" _ ......................• . . • . . . • ..... . . , • ..............

O " ................................ , , • . , . . ..... , . , • ..............

, . , • . , . • ..... , . , , .............._# , , , • . , , • ..... . . , • ..............

......... '... ,...,..._.. "...:..._ "-..:... ;..:...:,.. ;.. -...>..2...'...'...'...:... ;.._.. • -..._. • .2. • .'... :. • .:. • .:..._...:. •: : ....,,I,,,#

..... .,,-: : : : : !o_i_ui ioi,3 :',$ : :o:o_" i i i i i i ioi i i i i

..... _"=-':=_'m::-':= :m: : _ ....... m.....m.. : : : : : :.¢_c:_,¢.-_c.,¢ :_: : _,._ i i i i i i i_i ....

: : : '. : : : ........................• , , , , , , • ..... , , . • ..............

¢" "".G........ i'"i"y"! "i ""! "? i ""'i'"!'"i'"i"i"i"!'"!"i"i" i'T"!"!"!iiii!"i'"I_ _ ...............................'- m i,o!oi_i,3_i_,.2i_,,2i i i_iuui_ i,3dd i i i ! i !moi__o._ !

. . , • , . . - ..... . , , • ..............

_ ' . , • . . . . ..... , , , • .............. . , , , . , • ..... , , , • ..............

............. :.. :.. _..:.. :...-..._..._...,,.•.,.•.:...?••:••S.•.7•-.•._.•.?•? .-2 ••:..: ••_..•.:--,.•-? -:••? •:..-'..•-2.

_. ." ...............................• . , • , . . • ..... , , . . ..............

:ee:l_:n':_:n-_l_.n'; : :n':e_:l_ n':n-_K.n"l____ • .' rr'__-I_. fl'_.a_ u-_r_r'n". . .

.- !_,!_,_C:__-__; • "_C'_'_.__.:_ :_.:'_,_,_;_.'_:_,,. _:.a._i_i_i_: ! !_!.ai_i-,.-,._-,.._ :-':.9-':-':_I-t._-':._-_:-t._- : : : : : : : :: :: : : : : : : ..............

! _ ' I 1 I I " ' I ! [ I ! ! ! I I I I I ! l 1 ! ! I ' I ! 1. , . • . , . . ..... , , , • ..............

.c: i ' i i i i i i i i i i i i ! ! i i i i i : i i i i : i : i i

• , , • . , , : ..... . o . • ..............

............. : ............... :. ..... ,..- ..-.._..._...'. .................... . ..... • ........................ _..._...m : : : .... :: :: : : :::: :: : :: ::::: :: : :

, , . . , , . , . . . . , . ,

m:m:m m im_im_im:: :m:m_:_m: mm _m

I

-> .'-,.: .: -°coco ° g ® __oo_-. o o

• o') -'_ "- _ ,,..-¢7, _..>.>._.=_ , o=,=__,,, ® ,___ ---_-_'____-n..,T,_'t:: o-_.c _"o _ _ _ ,- ,- c __ .N C:. o .=,, _ r" o _-,_'o _- -s

_0 0 >,,,, --- _: ,- r _ 0 0 _ _ ---___ .... m ,_ E o m _ c_m_ ° °_'-_

o¢_.,- -, _- m E ¢_ Z.,_,.__.__ c-= c • m = o-._g-o_"- ." ¢.-

__ ._ _._ "_ __ _._ 0 0 0 _- e"

-- .--._-_-_ _ __, r- e- ¢_ D e_ • ._ m0 ,.n 1:::: -=- :='- DEO0 E c== _ :.o o E._E o __ -- m m _=._o o _ o,,, >

/

Page 29: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

o

8

0

• . . • . , . . ..... . . , ° .............

• . .... , . . . .............

• . . • . . . . ..... . . . • .............

• . . . , , , " ..... . . . • .............

_ .......... ._._,:.`:..:..:.._.,_,.,:.._``.,_._,,,`_,;.`:,`t..:..:.`,:.,:._.:...;.``_`.:..:.,:`.:..:.,:`.:.._-,,. . . . . . . ..... . . . . .............- . . . . . , _ ..... . , . . .............

, . ° , . . . . ..... . . . ° .............

_ " , . • . , ° . ..... ° . ° . .............

_ ..............- ....:...:.........:..:..;..:...:..:...:...:...:...:..;..:........:...:...:......:....:::::::.......................:: : - .i : : :t_o: :to: :to: :o_t_t_tOto_O :_ : : : : : : : : :_ :: :_-= :_: :_: :_._._. :_.: : :: :: : :

_ • : ; -_<- .<: ._.._ . . ._.,_ .........._ C .........................:.. :_._: :._ :._: :__I'_'I_,_._ :_: ::::: :: :

- i::i: ii !i ii il : ::i i: i ii iiiii ii i; ; ; ; i Z _ ...... . ................

] Z ]Z] Z] ii !i ii ! iii !i i ii iiiii !i i

............. ; • ": • • : • • _'" ",' • -.- • ".- • -_ • -:- - • i - ,;. • ," • -'- - ,'- • ,;, • ,;. • ,:- - ,:- • ,.'- • ,:, • -i --:, • • ,:, • :,, • ", • -,'. • '_.. ". • i, • .:...

_ i i_dr..,d i i : i i i i i i ! ! ! i ! !_i i i i i ! i i ! i_ ; !_11_!_ ; ; ; ; • • • ; ;!1_; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;

_ "_<< : : : .... : : : .... < .........._i I- " : _ .... : : : : : : : : : : ::: : : : : : : : : :i! :i iii i : ::: :: : :: ::: :: :: :

I_ _- i ! i i i i ! : i ! i i i ! i i : : : :" " " " " " " "..........

<.. ,_< <. . . • <.

tO 0 ::::: :: :: :: :: :::: :: : :: ::::: :: :•---. ........ i.-:..:--i..i ......... :--.i...i-.i-..i.-;-..--:----.:-.._.;...:... ;..;.. ;.. ;.. ;..;..;..;..;...:...

-" : i ! : : : : : : : : : ! : : : i i ! ! i i i i i i i i : :

v, _ "11_11_ 11_:11_ Ii_;11_ Ii_1_ I1_:0_ I_!_1_ Ii_ "_" _11I I__ ....• . ;_._._. • _;; • . _._;; ._. • _ ;_,; _,_ ._. ; ; ; ;:4 :.,._:._:'f__'t_i._:._._._ :_.-_:____ : : : :

,- : ::: :: :: :: ...: :: : :: ::::: :: :_I "_ ! ! i i i i ! i i i : : : : : : : : : :

" :.. :: : ::: .... :: ::::: :: :__ w :ii:: :: :: :: :: iiii iii ii i!iii i! i0 ............. ;..;.._...:...:..."...;...i.._..'..'..'..'. ; _ :. :. _ :.._ : " : :. :...;...:...;...; :

,.- ; • -I_11_ - • ; .... I:I_ lr.C_. ,I-- • 11_ -I_lr-_l_lll_ ....'1_ _ :<'<'<:_<'_<:<_:<'<:_.< :_<'<:',_<:<<< : : : :

I

- _ o : _. _ o_ E = • o

_._ _ 0 .- _ _ _ _ .- _

- / _ _ _ __ _o _ _ 0 0 0 _ _- 1 c C_ __ = _ • c _= o E = _---_ >_ --_ _ o

1 w-- _ __ -- E N ....

r w _ 0 _ 0 C 0 _ -_ 0 _ C "_ _ _ _-, C _ 0 _ _- _ _" -- _|l _ _ _ _ 0 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ; _ _ _ .-- -- _ _ _U _,. _ .'1_.

__ Eo_>_,_ o E __ _ .... _0 0 _- C _" _- r C _ ---

0 O_ 0 -- 0 0 _-.-- 'l-- _ 0

0 0.-.0.. m m E c _ o 0 c .___Q- _ _= o=._ .... '-' -., • E - _- o.: _,._o m m=-_ __ E.__

0 _ P -,--' _ _ ¢'" _ 0 0 O--.,-, __, 0 • __ _ 0 E :.= _ -- ,,,

Page 30: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 31: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 32: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

{

8

o

llm

llm

m

llm

0I=

Page 33: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 34: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 35: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 36: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 37: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 38: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

E [" .=-

N.=r-

o

_ ._,_

._ ='_ .

.d _._

-_o-_-__ ,_

-_

_ "_°

.>. =.£ N

-_ _-r-_

H_N

H.-=

-_ = ='r.

ee _

_o _

_.._

6_ _:_

_._ _

Page 39: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 40: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II ...... : : : :: : : : : : : :: : : : : : : : : : : :iO: :tjO.'O!tJ : : : : : : : : : : :O_t_(J_ "(J(J(J(_O:O:E:: :l:l::l:_Cl:::_ : : " : : : • : : : :CI:::IZ;E:IZ:E:o¢T ¢_ e, "I:I:I:Z:E:II:_I:_:ww

®,- _ = : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :: :: : : : : :...................... _. .o. .....

•_ tO u ....... : : : : . . . : : _ ® :" _ L'_ _ : : : : : : : ...... : : : ...... .._ ...a ....._1 _ '4"* : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : ............

_m I_. _ : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : . . ::............:: .......... .....!ii

• r = : . . : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

_(') m , , , , , I , , , , , , , , , , , ' ' ' '

•-- :rr. ,WiZ;n- I:l:rr:_rr:rrlZ; :rr, m [Z;n':_'n-:Q:n'E" :_Ei_IZ:E::IE_':u-01 .w: : m_w. ww:_.w.w _ :_.: _.'_l_w:_w" _ -_ _m_w: _,

IE]I t" 1--1: :.__]__J.__li__,l.J. mmml:--I--i: .--t--_-!--Jr.J..J_l:,-I.--m--' :-'-'--_._l--I.--]-.J.--',_ III : : : . . : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

•1_ • :. : : : : : : : : : : ' • • : : : : : : : : : : : : : :I_ ............. :'". "'.'".'": ......... :" ':""" i" ":'"""' "_"""-."' ":""':' ' ":""":""":'"":""" '."'""" :."" """ "" ' "."" '.'" ":"' '."" ":'""

tit) :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

n i:: EE E :EEi iE E EE EEEII Ei E_ E))E) EE EE )! E) ))EE EE E )) ))EEE EE E

I=: "_ ........i'"r"r"i....i"i"'i"':'"F'!'".""F"i"?'"i'"i'"T!"!'"F"Fi' ii iF!"!"i"I-" : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

!,__ I_ : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

0 : • • : : : : : : : : : : : ": : : : : : : : : : : : :

:ii::ii iii iii :: :: :: :: :: :: :: ::0 i i ! i i : : ! i : i i..i..i..'..i...E...L.i...i...)..;..i..i..i.,i....i-.i......,.: i i i i E i i i i i i i i i i i E i E E : : : : ! i ! i E

i_ ,w ................ : : : : : : : :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

i m ;';i; ii 'i ;i ;; iZi; ii i ;,,I[,[ :: :

'" "' ) : : i ) i E i E E i E : : E i i E i i i i ! i i E i E

............. "..;..; ......... " - .:- - - :- - ). • .:..1-. - ..'- • -.'- - -:- .]-..: ...... i - -:- - - ) - - .:- • :.. • .:. • -:- - -:- - -:- - -:- - -:- - -:- • .:. - -.mnm ... ® :: .... :::::::

:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

, _ ....... ; ......................

im / *-''0 (/) (_ (1) 1= _- (!) ,^ _,_

U o.,.. (o E E E "o "c-- I=.E: (1) _, m (_ >, ._., • ."0 (,,) _ _i.E .-- _ . ..-. 0 E c Eo E o -c (- 0 c0o o _ 0 o -- E > m .E _0 • 0

i_l _- ,-,,_. w .. - 0.9 _ mr __ _o-m'o .__ (_ E ,, (_--.

= / _ _ _"=--.--_ __ E_ _ ___LJ_ _ _o o _ _ _ _r: _ _,_UL m ,_ 0"0 .,-*.,.-_" O. ._'

IJ._ (t_ 0 El 0 *-' "" (1) _.- _-- -- _" _L" i'- t- _) "_ t" O'-- _) _ _ _• ,,. :,,= .-- r- r" t'- • 0 .- 0 "-- I::: _) __ .Q _ C:: 0 -- _-d_ / -- 2 _- _ _ o o==_ ..9 o o"o..-'_ o_ E _ ml.-9-_ E p n _ m.-

I _,: -J ,,_-_ E _ m - o _ _ o E _ c o "_ E c)-r r''o O-o o E_ -u'_= _u-':

_ .-- f.) 0 ,_ (I)> 0 _ E -- _ C_ _ • _ "_•1_ _ E 0 _. 0 _- _. ._ _' u). E _.-- E • "_ ,,_, ,,_ c_ ,../ _ -oJ=_'='o E _, _,._.__. _- m o-- m -_- F _-. P _u_ o v_ E_ >It5 m (I) _-C%E c E-_ r- _0 I::LL _. W O'= m o

/ •_ (,I _ • E • _ 0 0.0.'10 0 _0 .-- .,-,"0 0 0 •"- --E o m E E.o_ _.9 _mm_ m m.o.-O_o I= I: m_ _- _o mo.=. o._= _-

_ _ 0 O-- (I)_ h" "_ _- _ • 0 E _.- :3 .C __ I_ -_ ._ -- 0 I- O. ,-_"E --. 0 0 .Em m "_ -- > _ • Q. m • _:_ 0)(I) m c__/I r" j= 0.0 _.._ .,-. 0 jE r" ., • 0-=. _- := o _ o.,-_.,-, o ,'- > c _ = > hi--f_ • m ,- E._- o) I::_ .,. _,_ _ ,. ca ,... (I) _ O) 0),.._ n r-, m ._ .r- ,,

I

Page 41: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

_e 0 ' _"_,_ : : ....... :,'m ' .m • .e e_.m, ®._o

n • : : --'. ,,-,- .... : : : : :..1:--71 : :,,,J : :,_{ _l--I_J: ,.,.1:,--_:,_1m .............. :...:...;..:..:..:.._...:..:...:.:...:...:...i..i..i.._...:..:...:...:..:...:.._..:. ..i . i i.!

(_ _ : : : : : : : i : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :_'_ o i : : i i i : ........... '_ . .o • • .,,.

'_ _. _ : i i ! i i i : : : ..... : ........ "_ ' " ' : : :"_ ..._. ........ !...i...i...i...i..i..i ......... :..:...:...:...:..:.....:..:..:..:...:..-...:..: : : : : • • .-h _ .., : : : : : ::"_ "= i : : : : : :2 E _ : : : i ii

I I I I I " I I I I I I I I I i I I I I I

_ ,- r-,, ' zo ooo: o_(.,m i i i i i i i i_uoi _oiu:c_o: :oic_iooi :to :uocac_ :°',-i. ,,.. ,,- ,,..:_ _

__ "_' ' _ _ _ _i _, _,:_ -,i .'-'i .-, .-' -': :-:-.,: .-,-: :- :._ -' .-.' _ :.-*-; ...ft...9"_) , ill . . . . . . . . .....

E ..................................... '.......!..,:...;...:...:...;..:......:...:...-.......:...:...:...:...:...:.......,....:...:..-..-..-...:..-...'....:...• . , , . , . . ..... . . . , ..............

"-- t_ " " : ...................0 n i ii! : :: i: :: : i iiii ii i ii iiiii ii ii

........ .....iiiiiiiii!iiii,,.- _ i i i ! i i i i i i i i i :: i i ! i i i i i i i i i i i i

I-- '_ : i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i

t,,JI O : ; ; : : : : : : ................................... i..:..:.-i-.i ......... :.--i-..i.-i-.-,-. ;.- ;--.:--'..-:----.;..-:.-. ;--:.-;...:.. ;.. ;..;.. ;.. ;...:...:...

_. ,-: : i ! : : : : : : : : ! i i i : i ! i i i i i i i i i i i i itr_ : : : : : : : : : : : : .. : : : .. : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

•:" : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : i i : : : : :

n : : :: : : :: :: :: : : : ::: :: : :: : :: :: :: : :: " " : : ' i ; i " " : ' : : " : ....I ........ . .... [ . I . . I . . : I I , :

" . :UU:C_O:O:UU:OU:UU:OU O:UU_UU :O_: :o.UUU ,,_uou•-- n".n.,.mmn"l:Z:n'-n-_m,'.n"-"...c..-.:::...,._.._.,- .rr .... ,,. •O'} ' e : • • • ..... --.. ._ ,,,.t,'.l_..,",'= ,- . .mm._ _e._m. .... em:w ®e _.®e. :m.: :m:_m :.,,,:e:®

(_ '- . ,..a ..I, ,..a ...a .._ ,..a ,..d ,..._ ,..a. --a ...m....._ ...I. ,...1: ...] ...I ..i....,i ..a ...a. . -- ....I , -i.....I- _Ji.. I,,I,,I ...................... _-I,-I . .'i . ............. '..i..i...i...i...i..i...i..i...!..i..]...i...i...i.i i ." i i i.'. .!...i...i...i...i..i .i. i i.

&,= _ • : : : : : : . : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :• E : : ; : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :'_ _ : : i i : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

,,.- . : : • : : ..................'t::: : : : : : : : : : : : : : i i i i ] i i i i i ! i i i i i i i

i i ii] ]! ii !i ii iiii i! i ii !iii! !i i!

_t_ c_ ,- _ _= .e_ e : .__ o ._ _ ca. m 1:

I _f" u) .'__ o _ o (D .,n. (D{- o ,,,-, o (D (n --

,_ ,,._ (,=, .,_, --- r" . _ (1) O. .=9 O r- "' --- U) _-' 'r- (D _ • (/) CO 0 0 ,r-....co . -,-' o__. _ _c: o E m _o = m_ _ _ o m 00 m u,

• w C t-" ',.a ',-.' r-.J' t- L _. .-- 0"} ,%.a. (1)I" _.. -- _ "-- 0 _ C ]:: > "_ C_ _.. CO _ 0.,.-,•" O O) O ,,,., O,,._ r- U) (I),_ ", .- ,...,_ - m (,, o,- o,u_ o o ._ -, • -

._= l _ = c-_ ,-,.__-.._c u) I:: m >-- _ • E >,.- o -= W _..,-.-- ,._ .... 0 ;._, __ a. F: .,_.-- • ...I I:: _ .o_ o--'o m _o m c_R_ .__mm_ w .o R =.m o _ o_,-._

l _ "" _ c "" M" " _ _ _ c_,,,., ,.u .m c .- ,,_ ,._ ° ;::: _ "-- 0 '''*'_'_'- -'2O- .._ _ _ _D'sO')X_.-/ B • N 0 C C--- w O _'- _j "" _"- _) t._j "I_ _'=" _'_ u > ,,_._ Q,. C j_ _c o > :m _ • _ _ • -- C:n .-ll,, / 0 c: .- ,,.. • _ m,... ,,_ ,_ > _,c ,.- i= -,-, .,_ ,..

•-- ce F: O O O c _) "D O (D (n {n ._ 0 O O _I c "_ o c _>,-- (_ -/0 CD (D. (D.,._ • jO r- c _ t_ • _ O (I) (I) "-- --- (/) O f_I_ _) (D "-- O > _- "_ .,- "O _ "O (n -- O ,,-C _..,-, "_ ._ (D (/} f_9 U) (D" w= w,., (t_"-- --- O {_.

_) _ O O O F" _n U) "_ _= - - " " _- -- X O r" __ • - -- ,u ---_ ----(D O (D _ --- _- (D _- _- (D- _ _I (n - -- (D. O __ (I}•--- : .->-= --. o=°_'- _ _ - E"-" ._ o..-. > ® ,_ .=oU"_ ..-, _lJ "-.. (/) 0)_, _= .,=, r .,-. • 0')_ .._ 0.,. _' -

m m -_ 6 _ w -- _ -- -- ._'-- _" (i) _ _ vJ _u _ _-- C _ _ _ _

._ a "u_ 03 E m 8._>.c__ _- E _-= ___--= E_ .= E_o- a "-_ _>,R • m

-, o.._ p o m c o o o o._.c o---. m =__E x _ --_uC E • ,-- -- - m __ "-_m -->" . .,. ca. u_ ,--c £'c = _ -o.._ __ c'_ o o _ m E _o m_= __ o= E o _ID,. o "- .,-, E E E E E ..... -,.,..--.,.-, _ = "- o =-.. u o ,-- "- ,-_" m • O r. , o ----m.o c ._-c-- E --- _= E

O

_oo

O

=o

Page 42: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

ll

IlL

0

II

• Q

0m X

mW

U @

_ C_o

Page 43: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 44: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 45: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II

0rr

m_d

¢.)m

c-O0

0

nm

mo

iim

C

¢.)

0

L_iim

a0

Cq _O_Cq

4 44444

6 66_66

©°_

°_ 0.-_ _ _._

°,_-I

_ -__

o _ o

Page 46: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 47: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 48: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Ii__ _

C_glmml

m

,4d

m

m

Eo "_

_E

.°_ _

Page 49: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

I L : : : : : : : - : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :i iiii ii ii ii iiiiii ii i ii !iiii !iiilii ii ii ii iiiii! ii :-: ::::: ::

,'1::: o. ! i i i i ! i i i ! ! i i i ! i i i i i i i ! i i i i ! iw _ ............. L ..:,..'..,..;.. -'.. ;...:...:...'." .;...i.....;..;.._.. ;...:..;.. ,:.o,...;...;.. ;..: ..; ..: .. :.."...

= u = ::::::: :: :: ::::.::: iiiiiiiiii® ® _ _ : : : : :o: : :o _:_ :,,:_ : : : : : : : : : : : :

(0) "'_ .......... :'"i"'!'"."".'":":'" :"i"'i"i'"i'"i"'!"!".'"i"i"i"!'"i"'."-'i--i'-i--i--i-.-i-.'..._w "_ i i i i i i i i i i ioio! i i i ! i i i ! i i ! i i i i_ _ : : : : : : : : : : : ::::: : : : : : : : : : : : : : :,,, ::::::::::::::::::::: :-::::::::,'- :::::::i::::::::::: ::::-:::::_ (,,,) .... • ............

e" "_ i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i

_., ,,, i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i ! i i i i i i i i i ! i............. ;'-''-!" '.. _:_:_._:_;_;_;_._.-_:_.._:_:_.._.._._._-.._2_:._

A 13. :_[:_.¢_.¢_:_:_._:<1:_:_:,_:_[._:<:¢_:_[. : : : : : : : : :

.......... .- i i!::i "t" : • • : : : : : : : : : : . : . : : : : : : . :

.I.-- ¢_ : : : : : :0_: .... . : .(.,I. , : .........

: - • ,.,- : : : : : : : : : :<: : : .........¢) _' : i i : : :<: : : : : : ! i i : : : i i i i i i i i i i¢_) 0 : ; : : : : : : i : : : : : ; : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

............. i.-:..:.-i..i ...... i.--:-..... i ..... i .... :..:...:...i-- ?-i.-.'..:--:-- :--:..:-. :..:.. ;.-: ....!_, -" : ! ! :.: :.: : : : : : : i i : : : : i i ! i i i i i ! i

(/) : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

wn : i i : : : : • : :: : : ; ;' : :: ; : : : : : : : : :R _ !iii! i! ii ii ii iiii ii i ii ii!ii i!

_ "N ii!ii ii ii ii ::i : i iiiii i!i_ e-- . . : : : : : : : : .........,._ w : i i : : : : i : : : : : i i : : : : i i i i i i ! ! i i

E iiiii ii ii ii !! !ii : ii iii!i ii_)il ,_ 6.... ....... !.. !.. i...i...i...!..!... !..!...i..!....!..-...i...i...i...i...!. ?.. !...!.. !...i...i...i...i...i...i...i ....

t'_ • - " : : : : " ..... : .........•- . Z : ..... " " • • : : : : : : ' • •

"_ : : : : : :: :: :: : : :: : : :: : :: : :: :: ::

dr't _ ,-- > :,. -_

_'0 > (1) ¢1)

°- o(, / _)-=m >=_ ._o= ® o g

I m - -=_-o___>_ o_ __-_o-

, .- :. ®,-,o_o_-_= _=E _- ,-,

n _ u -- _= o o._._ • o _I ,,, a: _o_.'_-.=,=®_Ea.-_o®, -'-'_°'T_

¢0 ¢_ "_ _'_- "_o_ __ _ _ _ "---o_i _ _ o ..... _-l--09-Jl--l--< <

Page 50: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II " " " ' ' ' " - ..... " " - .............ii!ii ii :i i! !:!! ..............0 : • : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : " 1 1 "

............. "..;..;..:..;..;..;...:.,.k..:.;,..L,.i..;. ;..;..:...L,;...:,,.:..L..;........;,.:..;.,',..

s_ : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : ..............U = : : : : : : : :: :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : ::o0

_'-' o _1 _ : :tO: : :_=.,_ :re: : : : : ..............:: : : : : : : : : : : : :_i ,, _a : :n-: : :1_;--._. ..............

_ : :<: : :<:<_:< i<i i i i i : : : : : : : : : : : : : :Q- m ::::: ::i: :: :: :: ..............

® m ¢J) '_ ......... :"::":""i"!"!":"!"i"!'"i ...... :":"!"!"Y'!"!T]'":'"!"_"!"i'"!"i ...._ _ i ii i : :: :: :: ::: : :: : :: ::::: ::_" _ ::::: :: :: :: :: ::: : :: : :: ::::: ::_,_ _ " . ............

ml: ¢-- : : : : : : : : . . : : : , . • : . : : . : : : : : : : ;--_ -- . . . . ......... • . . ............., " " , , , , , , , , ' " " I ! : , , : _ _ ! ! ! ! ! !

,- : : .... :.. :::: ..............•I,-- un _ "_ : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

[I ............._,_ 0 • ..... ::

0.-- LU • : : ............ • .............

............. ;.., .... ;..'...:.... ...... ....,......;.._ ..-.. < .... ....,....... =..,... ;...... ,.. ;.., ...... ,,...

1: . ::dd :: dddoid ::::::::::::::::::::0 g_ :_rr:_.n-:_n-:_ : : i EQ. _ :<_¢<:_<_<<.<<:._ : : : : i i ! ! ! i i i E i i i E i

- _ !!!!_!_!!ii! .............._ _ ........ i..._.._..i..i.._..i...i..T..i.!...i...i..i..i..!..i..T._..Z..i.._..!..!..!..i..!..::..i...

I'-- 0 : : : : : : : : : i i : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

® _ :_i::: _ :::::::::::::::::::

_II 0 i ! i i i i : ! : : ! !.i..i..i..i...!...i.i...:...;..:..;..i..i..i..i.._..i...

_Q. ." i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i :: i i i i i i i : : : : : :

In :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

. i T ; i : i i i i i " i i i i i t t _ I n I x I n

11-__.:,,:::::::::::,:::::,,,,,,,,:::::::::::.- ::::: :: .: :: :: :: : :: : : ........"_ ::::: :: : : :::i !! ! ii iilii i

_1_ : : : : : : : • : . : . . : " ..............o_ : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

s._ : . . : : : : : : : : : : . . : : : : : : :.............. ,:., .:...: ......... - ..... "..-.. -..:....:.. -...:,, .:...: ........... •...:.. -...:...:...:...:...:...:...: ....

._" _ " : : ....... : : : : i ! i i i i i ! i i i ! i i

ii::ii ii : :: :: :::: :: : :: ::::: ::

i .............

.o I m >_ 8 -8•,-, II- _- -_ o

0 e'- *-, _F, I E _ o)m=(_o.__-..

<l = 8®_-".-+>+o_

° --CO) o ._m Eo=

r_ '-"-u .... < m_ • m

I I_l _ q- "_ > >,' ' (_._ I-- G-"_ 03 --'1:3 ,+.,I _o

I u_ .C _ c-_=_- ,-u@o I:l _ _ _-. _ _ r'" _)r_ _ CO

ox_ o o.__.,-, n _ o •

Page 51: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

mm

0

J

|l

Im

m

|m

0

0o-

II

o

r-

r- 0X

-i i.

_o

Page 52: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

w

.coQ •

elm

llm

m

if

0

LI.

0n,",<

Page 53: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

iim

00

IBm

0

o_.I

mm

m

iim

I_L

0

,<

'Eu

'o'_X

wUJ

E _ ""

_o _o

_ _ -_-_.,. _ .. _j _ _ ._

_'_ _ _ "_- 0 _=

•-' 0

_ = -_"_2

_,_._ ...- _

_ N

<::= o=

== 'I_

_'_ _ =

•,_, _ _,_

=- =£

a, ._ _: = ".=

• m _ ¢,)

8 :_ = .,=_-_ _ -= .=

,-,,

Page 54: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

L._

G_uld

.,CC_L_

O_

u_

w

_ 0o_

c_ E

0

c_E•-- 0

_ 0

_ 0_s_ ._

olm_

m

f-

il

Page 55: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

UI:Z::IJL

U

C@UNi,,-

lid

m

Uit

r,,,

@U

1i...liD

II

r,q

!

o,@

,Ac,@

0

I::::

0

I I

I I I I

°_ ° _,,-_

4.,.I• ,,,-.,

0<_:_

_ --_

.._ _ _

o,ml

°__

Page 56: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

m

0)

0

0I=I_L0

Page 57: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

LLJ

Page 58: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

a,_

: : : : : : : ......... . ............• . . • , . . • . .... . . ° • ............• . , • . o . • . .... o , , . ............

• . .... . • ° . ............• : : : : : : ...... . • ,• . • • , • , • , .... o o . • ............• . . • . o . , o .... • ° . • ............

ii ...............• . .... , o . • .....

• . o • . o . • o .... , o . • ............

_o o • o =G_ _i _o_o!.! ! i oi iooi. oi _ ioi iooioi i io• • .... , ° . . ............

o . .... . . . • ............

i i i ! ! i ! ......................u ......................• . .... . o . • ............

o o .... , , , o ............

max I : : : : : : : . ........ o ...... . , • . o . • , .... o , . . ............

. o . o . . . ° . .... . , . . ............• . .... , ° , .............

• ° , • o , • • . .... • . o • ............• . .... , • o ° ............

• , .... . , o . ............

:'::::: ......................i i i i I i i i i a i i i i i i i i i i i i• . , • . , . ..... . . . • ............• o , . . . , • . .... , . . • ............

_ • . , • . , , • . .... . . . • ............• . . • , . . • . .... . . . • ............

i

4"-- • . . • • • . • • .... . . . • ............i

. , .... . . , , ............i I . i a i m i

• . . • , . . • . .... . . , • ............

0 e- ....... ..............• , . • , . . • . .... , . . • ............m • , . • • ° . " ' .... • - • " ............

u.,. : : : : : . '. : : : : : : . . . . ............• _, , . . • ..... : : : : : : : - : : : : :

............. : ...... s'';'''. ......... .'''_'','''_''_ ............ .'''. "';''','''s'':°';'''.°'_'';''r'';''s'"

:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::0 u_ :m : : : : : i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i ? ica. i

...... ...... _ __; __; __ _ __ ___ __:. __:___ __ __ __- . _: ______ _____ __ _: ___:___ __ _____: __ __: __; __: __ __• o .... , , • • ............C _,_ : : : : : : : ......................

m e,, ....... .....................• , . • . , , o . .... . . . ° ............

• . .... . . o • ............_ : : : - : : : ...... , , • • ............Q I p

H I I

v • . , . . . • • . .... , , . • ............

_ ....... .....................• . , • . . . • . .... , . . • ............• , , • , , . o , .... , . . • ............

I,P ¢_ ....... • ...................... . , • • . , • , .... , . , • ............

_,, ." ....... . .....................• , .... , , , • ............

i__oi i .........: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

.. : n" n"- _ _ n'-: ....,._ ._u_'u_'u.: ......................... . . . .

_ _ c_-c_-_: .......................• , • ..... , , , • ............

• , o • • ° . : ..... - o • ' ............ I

T .. , 1 I I ' " [ I I [ . ' I I I 1 : : : : : : : : :• . . . ..... : : : .............

!c_ i ! ! i i : : : : : : : : : .............• , .... , . . • ............

• _ "_ : : : : : : : : '. : : : : : : : : : .........

:_. . : : : •

,,=, : i]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]• . . • • , . - . .... , . . • ............

........... i i i!! ;i_ "" - .............. : :: :" : :::: ::• . , . . , . • , .... , , . . ............

• . .... . , , • . ,

......................" ......................• • ..... , . . • ............• , .... . o . • ............

• Lr. LL: ......................• , • ..... . . . • ............'l: _ _ _: _: _: ......................, o . • • , , • , .... . o . • ............• . . • , , . • , .... . , . • ............• . . , , , , • o .... . . . • ............

I

_E

_ _ _a

_ __ E_

.__- _•_ _ .__

"_o_

Page 59: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

• . . . . . . ° ..... . . . • ............

"a i i i i i ii :: :: : : : :: : :_ : :: : :: :: ::

0 ID t__ ""_ ........ L":'"" ' "; "'; ' " :'" :' "'"":'" "'" ;'":'" "_ "';'" :" " "' " :' "'L';'";' "': "'L"; --"-" '-:-'_" " ": "_

0 "- iii!i ii ii i! ii i iil ii iii !iiii ii•I-P _

iiiiiii iiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iiii_ U.l _ _. : : : : : : : : : : : : : ' " " : : ...........

........... .....i..i.L • • " : ...... . . . • ............

IL" : : . : : : • : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :i I I I I i I i

•1_ m i i i i ! i ! : i i i i i i i i i ! i ! i i i i i i i

l" "_ } i } } i } i i ! } : : : } ! } i } : : : : : : :.t_ t- : : : : : : : ...... : : : : : : :

" : i " " " : " : : : : : ' " " : : : : : : : : .................. :"":."',"":--':--_--"-" - .:-'-"-'.-i.-.i.- i- ..:-.-:. --:--.:...:'--:-..'. --:--i-. i- -i--i- •}...: - . : ........ . ...............

_ :_ : i i i : i i i : : : i i } i i i i i in _: :_E'[:I::: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

(:_ ,.i. 'u.-u. ..... : ..... : : : ...........

" 11 '- :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::--.#........

,- i:: i ii :: : ::: : ...........

0 : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

:iiiii:: :: ii i :: i ! i i !i i i :: i i i :: i

0 ::::: : ................ ::•--. ........ i.._.._..i..i...!..:...i..._..._.._..._.._......_.....:..._._..._..._..`.._..:.._..:.:: i. i

O. _-" : i i : : : i : ! i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i : : : : :¢/) ¢_ i_ i i_i_ i i i i ! i i i i i i i i ! !

• :n-n- :. :rr:n,-. : : : . . . , : : ..........."_.. :l.k'U.' : "LI.'I.I. ...... : : : • • : : : : : : : : : :" :

_J[ : . . • , :_ :, I_ ; ;" i ii i ii i }i :: ;:

Ii I

w : : : : : :: :: :: : : } }i : :: : :: : :: i} :t-- :(.._ : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : . .

l.IJ il:_ : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :II. • : : : : : : • : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

111•- :_:l_:D::lr:n':lr:rr:l:E: IZ::: : : • : : : : - ' : .... : • : -• t_tt_u.-ui. II.".u.-tt.. tt.- . • : : : : • : : • : : : : • : . : .

._-- :r_'O:C_:I:3:I:_:I_C::_ : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

e" _ Em -

I n" .--,' .,_ o t:"---- / _ c- >.,_ m =

/ "., o ¢_ _'o o

/ _ _E m _-Ei m "c- _- tJ)

-- I _ = >.__ _: _ _ - _

-- __D o_ c- o u)a _ ::. ¢_ "¢D ,__'0 u) 0 _-- --,, _ c-._ C1.. > 0 _ rn E .£: 0 .. _

_ _ .,_, _ ® =

0 _ • _ _-.--

I ----" _" ___"_ _ _-__

Page 60: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II

L.

0

L.

0

"0

II

III

II

0

LI.

0rrLI.a

IIW

m.m

Q

_ue-

ra x

_l.IJ

0-l e-

_e

___o_=

_._. _

}. oE

=.__

_.__ __ ._t--_ .__ o

r ° I--, _ ._ __._ _ _

_o_.__ _ _._ "'_ _._

m

o

o

°_ _

0

_M

i

0

0

r_

n_ o0

_.._._,,_

_._a

.__ _

°_

_ _ .._

_._ _

Page 61: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II

Page 62: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 63: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

m!

o

n_

o°_

0

n

Q.

E

X

00ffl

0._-

¢,D¢,D

ffl°_

0

0

E

f-

ffl

C_

0z

Page 64: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

ll

1

Q.

0(,,I0

1

8

o

Page 65: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 66: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 67: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 68: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 69: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 70: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

IIW

o

2

W.

Page 71: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

0

e

Page 72: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II_wco

mL,.

• e)'*" o

r,- utll x

cnUl

_ocno

L.

G)

iim

m

I_L

Page 73: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II

o__

,,IdL_

0C_

,,Id

o0

"oa.

o

m

E_

m

i

Page 74: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

0

I

0

_ _ _-_ _ _

Page 75: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

_om

- ,,_ u,.O0'

0')

>,,,ILV

0

0

0')

O.

:<4)r-

e-

t-O

i--

Page 76: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

I,I.

s...

0

s_

0

0s_

n

0I,I.o0(.0

0

0CO

-_ °_

o_ _ =_

i;,.i

m

0I-i11I-I,I.

mo

oI,I.m

-_ _ -_ _' o& "_

0 i_=

n _ _IJ

:3

(J

k

_J

m

I_," 0 I.

0

_ _.Z

m _J _

•-_ £

_-°____ ______g

•__ __ _

._ -_ -_ _,_

• • • ° •

0Z

Page 77: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 78: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 79: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 80: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 81: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

• . o .... . ..... . . . , .............

• . .... , , , . .............

I*O _ 0 : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

_- -_ _ a. ! i i i i ! i i i i ! i i i : : i i i i i i i ! i ! i i i !"-- I_ ............. ;.--;.....;..;.. ;. ;...:..'...'_.;...;..:..;..i.. i.. ;...;..;...;...;..;...;..;..;.. ;..;.. ;..; .. ;...00 _ m : :::: :: i: :: ::: ::i ii i ii i!iii !i i

_ _ . :,, :,,'- : __ ,,: _ _ .... _- : _; -' ,, ,__-,T: _ . _ _,,.,, :,, :,,: ,,.,. ,._, : _

_ :_: :_ _._._._._._,_:_._._.___._:__:_

_1_1 t_ • ; : • • j ..... : : ; - : : : : : : : : : : : : :_ Gr} "'L ......... "." :" i":"""i"i'" "'i"'i"i"'i'"i'"!"!"!"i"i"i"i'"i'"i"-'"i".:-.i..i..-i-.'. i -.

LL'U- "'_ I_:_I_'I_U4 • I_LI.''L J4U-'I_U-'I_.'I.I-'I-t-'U-'U-'LI.'U4LI.'IJ.;I_. "_-

I ' ' ' ' ' ! ' '

_ "_ i ! i! ii !i i! ie-

,0 _ : : : : : : : : ; : : : : : : i : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

_ m ! iiii ii ii i} ii iiii ii i ii }iiii iiiI:: _ i i i i i i i ! i! i ! i i i ! i! i ! i ! i i i i i ! i0 _. ! ! i :: ! :: i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i

....... ': : :........: . . . : : : : : : : :: :..............: : : : : : : : : : : : :_ _ , • . " ....... . . . • .............

0 • : : : i : : : : : : : : : : : : ': : : : : : : : : : : : :

] i:!::!!ii!i! !iiiii::i::i::iiiiil

t_ : : " : : : : : : : : • ; ; ; .............................. i..:..i.-i..-i ...... :........... i--i--'-.-..----:--.-.;-.-:-..;.-;.. ;.. ;.-;-. :..;..;..;...: ....

II_ _" : : ! : : : : : : : : : : ! i i i ! i i i i i i i i i i i im : :: : : :: :: :: : : : :: : :: : :: : :: :: :: :

"-- : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : i i i i i i : : :

_ [[ '1 : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

w : : : : : :: :: :: : : : :: : :: : :: : :: :: :: :: : :: :: :: :: : ..: :: : :: ::::: :

"_ ! i i :: :: :::: :: : :: ::::: :: :m c : " : : :: : :::" " : :: : :::: :: :

"' : : i : : : : : : : : : : ! i i i i i i i i i i i !

11°..............oE : :::: :: :: :: :: : :: : :: : :::: :: :m :i! !i : :: :: :::: :: : :: : :: :: :: :

. . : . . : : • . . : : : : ..........::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

:_ i iiii !i ii ii !i i!ii ii } ii iii!! ii i

• • ..... ; ............... _ ....... ,

v / n" -- o_ IT r" < ._ >, _ _.> - E _ ®

_ "-- " _O 0 _I _ c_ 0 _-

"1" -- -- _ IlL _ 0 u_ (/)- :-= 0

. 0 0 }- 0 -_ 0 - __ _r) U_ _- 4" _ __ •

c / _ _o=o__ ° _,,,_ o:_'" _,,,__-_._ :_-= _ _. r- c o _ c _--t) ,-. _. F- E _ -_--C 0 _ o .c J: m o "-_m o _- :_ m _. _,- 2 E m--J_w _ -- '.J w ,..a . _ ,.._ ¢-- r -_ __ . w .,.-. w

.-- _ _ 0 _ O v 0 C _ _ C C " m -_ -_ (D _ _ _ U_ ,,-- _

•-- __ E o m o.- _o.,-, o _ m _m -_: ..... -- E--_= _o .....-_ 0 0 __ r- • "" -- O. >, _ C CD U) 0 00_ 0

0 ---._ _. ,_ ._ _ 0 C _0 _._ _ _.. ,.. C

o _E m o o c o.o _ _ 0 --._ _ • • a.) m m E._ .-, ..o'-

_ E c-- ____n-- -- ,-, _ _- _ _- _ _= _"1='tz'1= • • o _ "_ _u _ _So o'_- _ o o,= oo o m o_ m o._o =_= _ D .... m = c=,hi, o - o.......... o-F-0 0 u. _ z n _ _: < LU "r _ _j =_ =_ =_ 0 0 0 CO CO CO _ _ > n CO CO _ <

Page 82: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

" II"8

(,,-

E

01o

"8(1)

,,o8

• . . ......... . . . . ...........

5,, ....... : " : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : " : :o . . .... • ..... o . . o ...........

w .... • ..... o . . o ...........

. . . .... . ..... o o . • ...........v • . . .... • ..... . o . • ...........

. o .... . • . • ...........o ..... . . . • ...........i

............ :...i..;..'..... -'.. :...:.. :...:.. :...i..;...;.. C. • ;.. :...:..;...:...:- ..:...:.. :.....:..i......_ . • o .... • ..... . o . • ...........

Ill M,J • . o .... • ..... . o . • ...........

"- :o:o:(,,):(,,):o:o.'o o.o:_ _(,/_ .O...O..o_._O.oi i i i i i i i i

("]) _ : : : : : : : - : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

Or) "',_,......... !'" T T":'"!'" !"!'"_"!'" T'!"T" T_"I"_"!'_"!"!" T":'"!"!":'"! T"!"': O: _ _ (.,1:(.,1:0 0:0:{.}:0 ¢,..):(.,)(,,,):._ O0 -¢'-)0 .........

"- ._.t./_.O,Z_._..o]_O,}:O,):O):¢,0¢,,O,_O,):_:_ _. : : : : : : : :

• . . .... • ..... . • • • ...........

i I I I l I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I

• . . .... • ..... . . . • ...........

....... : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

• • o . .... • ..... . • • • ...........

• o . .... • ..... . . . • ...........

• w i ii!i !i i! !i ii i iii i! i ii iiiii i

,_ ............. ....,.., ............... , ........... ;.-; ..... . ; ....• . . . . . : : : ..............

• o . .... • ..... . . . . ...........• . . .... o ..... . . . . ...........

. . . .... • ..... . . . • ......... 0 .

. . . .... • ..... . . o • ...........• . . .... • ..... . . • o ...........

i iiii i! !! iiii!!!i i iiiiiii!°'_ .......................................................................

. . . .... . ..... . o . o ...........• o . .... . ..... . o . • ...........

i i!ii ii ii ii ii !iii ii i ii iii!i i!"- o ............................

_ . . o .... . ..... . o . o ...........i . . o .... . ..... . o . • ...........

. o . ..... . • • • ...........• • . .... • ..... . . o • ...........

_, .............,, ::___`___:__;__;___i._.i___i___i___!__i___]__!.___`_:______!___!_!___]___!__!__!__!__!..!__!__!___:: :. : , ....... : : : ............

!iiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii• o . .... o ..... . . o • ...........

I

I I ! [ I I I [ I ' [ I ! I ...........• o . ....

_ ......... . .... ii ii ii iiii ii i !i iiiiii

"_1 ....... : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : ' •. o . .... • ..... . . o • ...........

III , • , .... " ..... • • • • ...........hill • • . .... • ..... , . . • ...........

• • . .... . ..... . • , • ...........

.... _ ......... .'_...:.........' ........:"• .:... -.. :. •. ,...". ."....-.....":... -...: .............." .'. ".' ,":'•. .................................!• .:... •...:...:...:... :...:...:...:...: ....

I

• . . .... • ..... , . . • ..........._W • . . .... . ..... . . . . ...........

....... !ii iii!!i! iilili !: : : : : : :• , . .... : ..... . o . . .........

P

•,_ _ _ _"0. >,-" ,,, )-" ^--- _ _...,-- _ _ o_r" 0 - .-::3 0 _ _ (l_ (_) (/]fa) j)

-"-o .-o..oo.-o-=.o __o _,E_-_-'_._'_=_ -_

._ g_._ r_'_ ,_ = _,..,-_ o o'___ _ g

, 8 8_ __o"-- "- '- -..,_-o-_ m_ _ .,-, >_.(..., m= w >.,.£:: _A ." ._ _'

0 _ _ _- .'- 0"= "0 .,_,"{3_"-- _-"_ (_ _> (1).'=-->"._ __' _.

.J-mm<-u EN-

Page 83: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

IlL

0

Page 84: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II

u_or)0

Page 85: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

s_

0

!,-

0.12

A-

IIa,.

U

:S.._

e- u

(_LU

"q 1-3o-! e-_o(no

31 ,_ ""

Page 86: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

I

0

LII

[.-.

Page 87: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

t_

Page 88: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 89: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 90: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 91: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 92: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 93: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

I ....... " " " " " " " - . : : : : i i i : : i : • ;: : ; : : : : - : : ' " . ................ :

0 : ........... " : : ' ' : : -" : : : : : " : : " "

,_ " i i ii ii ii ii i ! iii i i iii ! i!!!iiiil'_ .......... :........ ;.. :.. :...L • .:. • ." ..i • .:...: ..:. • ._.. _...L..:...:..._ ..; ...'...: ..L .. ;.. :..;..;..;.. :..;..:...:... _

_O. _ L_ _ : : : : : : : : : : : ! : : : : ,:. • •..................... • •

= _ ._ : ._.._._.i_..._.__ ..._ ._, : :_..._ _ --, _.._: . :._:_:._:_:i_ _._ u : .a..a.:m:m:m:a.: :m. :_ : :=: "_a.! a_ _. _,m: i :a.:m:a.:m:_-

_u.I DI "_ ............ : : ................

,-_'o (/') ""_"..... i ........ i"i"::"i"':: ...... ;:'--i--'i ...... i'"i"i"i'"::'"::'"i"i'"i"i'"i"i"::";:"i"::";:"::"i""

. : : : --_: i_: II_ I . --A . ,_.. ,,_ _ --_. --_. _,.,,,_. ,_. ,_1 ,_l ._. .i_. . ,,_ ,_,_ ,- : ..... : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

i . _ _ ; ! : ; ; ' ' . I I ! _ _ _ , , , , , , ! : I

_ : ::: :: :i:i i i i :i i : : :: i iiiiii::

•l_ e- "_ i i i i i i : i i i ! i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i

+,--- "' i i i i i i i i i i i i i i ! i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i.......... "........ : ............ :''''': ..... :''o'''''"'''"'':''° ........... E..'..:..:..:..;..'..'-.:..,. _ •

C_ • . . - . . ........

"l_ _ i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i ! i i i i i i i i ! io i !!i ::i iii!iii!ii i::!i iiiiii

i :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::"" ';-;..... :........ ! i i" '!'" 'i"'": i 'i'" 'i" "i" ! "_"""i"""!...... ! i T"i"."' i' ii i i i i" ': "'i"""

"- _ : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : ; : : : : : : : i i

0 : : : : : : ::: :: : : : : : : : : :: : :: : : ::::

r'_ ." : : : :: : :: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

_ _iIi I I

"_" : : : : : : : : : : : : i i : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

_ I ,,- ! : : : : : i : i : : : ! i : : i i ! i i i i i i ! ! : :

"_ i iii !! ii!ii i :: i ii i i! iiiiiii!!

,_ u.I : : : : : : i : : i i : : : : : : : : : : : : : i : :........... ; ........ :_.:._.:_..;._;...:.._:_._._:_.;...:._.;.._....i._.!...:.._;...:..;...:._.:_..:...:._.:. :..:. i i

hi _ : : : : : :. :. : • • : : :.. : : : : : : : : : : : . .

i :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::_ i iii ii iiiii i ii ii ii i ii i!!iiiiii

j I ' I " I " I " I I " " " I I ........... I I

,,_ _ I C_ .,T,

0 : n" o ,-- _ ,..,., o.. o ,.-E . E o..

._ _ _ - _ _ _, o_ _

0 (D _ (n _ C 0 _ >, ,_ _ m _ IF; (I;I ._. O) X __ U) ::3

'_1_ I .. _- _ • _ c; -- _ _ _ _ _ .,_ t- r_ t- _L_ _ ._- ,- _ 0 ,_._ _.C: ,_-_,_

/ _. ,-I ..o ", _o._'- E ,,- o _ E o o.,. o m _o m

(1).,-, ._ ,_..Q 0 _1 ._ "0 '_--- _ "_ ,,._ _ ,,- = :_ ,,....,"0 _• i f"t >" ._ :D "-- (1) 0,) f.) (_ u) V) 0 0 0 0 0 +_ (_ _-_ .<._ Q) c) _ --, JO 0 <( _ O. u)

I I _ _ _ _ 0 _ _ _ _ _ _ "-- _ I-- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _,i, (1).,_, ._ _' _ .-- _ __ 0 0 '--_ _._ _.. ,,.,(I) _ +_ 0 • ._ >_ C --- ¢- _0 -o _ _ m o .) E = E o'_- .--- _J=•- 0 -- E _-.__._ u_--.c o c = E c E c_ m- co c-- o. _._o m o c _' o • =.- u --

_ _ _._ o.c.c -- o > o _- ,_ ,.. __,,_ c W _. N'O .c: '-I ' _ _L_ I _1 _--" _ "_ _ _ _'_ _ _ _'_ i .'_-- .'_ "_'_ '_ ._ 0 "--0 ._ 0_ _ _'_ ._0 ._'_ _ t_ _

_ mr I--I -' --<0_'7"7 "7 o_ _n >>_nz_n.n'7_I_V

Page 94: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Ill

I._

0

0

8Ill1

Ill

0

nL

IIW

1

Q •

"D'_X

W 1,1,,I

8"6

_m

Page 95: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II

Page 96: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 97: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

_a

.-j

ell

"o

!-

oL_

Ilm

CI

I I / I I I I I

•_ _"_" :_: _S_ __ ._ .

_ee_e

Page 98: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

M

A

(/)

V

0

.,_o

g,

0

0,)

c_

o_._0.-.100

_og ,-,-- (/)'_ _6o

0 00_

o z

._g_._

,..: ai 06

0

0Z

Page 99: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 100: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

I " " " " - ..... ' ' " " ...........

!.- ' • • ' ..... • • • • ...........

m . i !iii ii ii i iii ii i !i iiiii i_o " iii ii ii !i ! iii iii !i i!!ii i

® ;_ i " i ii ii ii ii i iii ii i ii iiii! i

• o . , ..... . . ° • ...........

.........."' (/) "'_ ..... !............... :........-..:....... :.. :...:...:..:..,..:..:...,..:...:.. :...:..:..:..:..:..:...

,,,,* . . ........ : : : ............

_c_ " : : : : : : : : : : : : : ............I I I I I I " I I I I I I I

® ::::::t-- : ...... : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : '. :

_" "5_ i i i ! : ! i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i

_) :_ " i i i ! ! ! ! ! i i i i i ! i i ! i i i i i i i i.......................... i"'i ........ _'"" ..... ;"_ ................. :""":'";"_""'"'"'"" ;'":""

1:: _ i o _ :_ii!ci :: : :: i i: :i i

0 _ i i i iu_:_ i_: i i iu,s i i i i i i i i i i i_ : : : :-,-a:"ac"-ac :._."a: : : :"_ : : : : : : : : : : :-- i ! ii ii ii ii iiii ii i ii iiiii i

_" "._ ..... :............... :':i"i T."!'":'"!":"::i""'!"""!":'"!" !"i"!"!"!""t_ ,-. : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

_ . , • . . • ..........0 • . ....... • • - : : : : : : : :

• _' i : : : i : i i i i ! :: :: i ! i i i i i i i i ! i0 0 : i ii i :: : : i ..............t_ .......... " .............. :'":-- ?-':--':"':-':.-':.-:.-:'.-..'...i-. ?. i--.!...i--i.-i-, i--i.-i--i.-i---

_ • • . . . ..... . . . • ...........

• v," ,,. w wwv_ " U):_ t_C ........•_ : :"_:"_'_.-J_a:'_"_--a:'-a:'-a:-J :_(-a'_ : : : : : : : :_. i i ii :i ii ii iiii :: ! ii i!!i! i

, i I ,I :I I: ,_ iii, ,, _ [, _,,_ _ ,i ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

(_ : : : • : : • . : : : : : : : : : : : :_._ LI.I .... : ...... : : ............(,1 ........... ; ............... i.-.i-.:... :--i ...:..'-. ;.-.:-..:-.._.._..:.- • ;..:..-_..-:. •;...:...:...:...:...:...:...

,_ m : : :i :: ii iii iii ii i ii iiiii i

<_ E :: i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

;_ i i ii ii ii i! iiii i! i ii iiiii i• . . _ ..... . . , • ...........

.-- (Q __ ,.- 0

_-/_, _ _ _8 _''->" '_• o o_"o _ > _":: E "-' ° _- m

o _" E "o ®= __ _ o_ _ o_

m

_ o,®_ 7__-_ o_

o ®_ "o'6,_ E ....... oco ,, _ < _"_ :_c__ _ _,_

Page 101: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

m

0

Page 102: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

elom

L,

_ue-

:S_e

e- u

olUJ

iim

C:00

iim

s_

0ms_

0.Q

"0

iim

iimmiim

(.,1m

IJ.

(JCO-.j

k_

C_ k.

Page 103: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

II

II

0

IL

!--.

"0CZ

0

II

Q

C

:E_o

r-

_m

Page 104: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 105: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 106: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

Elm

00

Elm

s._

0

s_.

0.0

"0

EEm

mmm

Elm

0

LI.I.I.

IIW

wW

o_

f_

Page 107: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

0

0

_w

-r"0

t- 0X

_W

8"6

-i r-

_[ [l¸I¸ ]¸¸¸¸1¸_J

°I°_=

0J

"_

- Eo

o

_ E,--- ._

•E =

£ =

"" 0

_ o_ 0

._ "__ =• _

= _.

___l_°

J "m ___oo r..) 121

_ _=- ._< _ _... _

"_ _ =_ £ _o_

-.- _ __ _ -

....______o

Page 108: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

0

m

c_

0C_14m

,od

I-

0

J

oo

_t0

.oc_

olp_

©

_ _ ,[_°_ _

il

Page 109: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

I

11_

"a

0

CD

l-

eDr-IJ_

0)'*"

o_O-7O00 CD _

_0.,--

0

N-_o

Page 110: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

z_

_._

"0

Z_ ,--.,

°_

•_ _

._.!_

.- _ .._

_-_

"_-_

• • _

°_

'=._oX

_'_• _OJ

• -S_o

_<__= _

._,_ _-_ _

-o _'_

-_._

.-__

..__Nx:o

•_ "-- "0 0

• -- N 0

o= o=

.,m .m,

•,= = ,=

Page 111: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by
Page 112: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

iim

L._

0

0.Q

i,I.

II

Q @

m

X

WIJ, I

u_C

_o

.e

_ E

_ E

_E

E

E0

m

©

m

E

E_

Page 113: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

ll

ll

0

c_

0.Q

"0

0ll

ll

1

ll

c_LI.

0

m

_o e-

um x

WW

"_ r,

°_ _

o_

0

_.-_

• _:-_-_ _._

_'_ =

___°_ ie = N

• _ _,__ •

°,_

_=_'__ °_

_._ °

_= ._'"_. __'_ "_ __

_ _ _._-_

r_

-&0

Page 114: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

0

Page 115: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

@

(l)¢)

mm

¢)

i

"I10Bn

I

0|

00

0

Sll

0

O_0....L

I

O0O0

I

,....i

COO0PO

0(/)

•-I e-.

m t_

o -,ie_._.

n_m°

m

(1)

mll

0(1)

0(1)

i,,,e,

"1"1

mll

m

Page 116: Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for ... · NASA / TM-1998-208714 Implementation Plan for the NASA Center of Excellence for Structures and Materials Edited by

9 L-6e-Z PJ,S ISNV gq peo_JosoJd

(6O-i_ "AeH) glr,3 m_O=l P_Pu_s

J.OVUJ.SgV _-IONOII VLIHFI "0_

90V3000 301Ud "91.

8|1S:I_)Vd dO 1::13gl_flN "S L

pmj!ssepuFlIOVUJ.SBV JO

NOIJ.VOEIISS_I0 KLIEIN::33S "61.

00g.q-0g_- 1,0-01_/. NSN

po=j!SSel_Ufl_ po_ss_pufl3=JVd SIHJ..40 J.HOd::IH =K)

N0tLVOUlSSVIOguunoas "st NmLVOUtSe_O_uunaas "zL

sd!qsaou_.md pue soou_!II_ o!_me.nS '.so!]!l!q!suodsoa

I_UO!lound :so!l!l!q_d_a leo!uqoo,L '.sle.ual_IAI '.so_marmS '.u_ld uo!lmuomoldtuIsnuaL lograns _t

"x.tpuoddv

aql u! pou!muoa s! sle.uolem pue soanlorms u! sot.l!l!qedea [-eo!uqooz opt.ta,(auo_ V jo £aOlUOAU!OA!SUOqo.ldtuooV

•uoda_ s!_ u! poluosoad ueld otp podOlaAOp ua_o,L d!qsaop_oq OtLL '_IOD ottl

jo so!l!l!q!suodsoa oql _u!l[u|n J u.t S)_[_'-I :ls.tsse o1 paqs![q_lso s_A_ 'ao:luoD p[m._I VSVN qo_o tuo.tj oA!ltrluosoadoa

e ql!A_ 'tUeO.[ d!qsaop_aq _IOD OtLL "(D_r-I) aoluoD qaxeoso_I ,(Ol_Ue q 1_ Sl_.UoleIA[pue soJmonal S aoj oOUOllOaX_i

jo aaluo D at O 3o ooU30 at O Xq pa ! XI!A!Z_e_u!utreldap!_ua_v urejo _[ns_ at O st. u!oaoq po]u_mn:_op u_ld aq,L

"Sl_.UOlelAIpue so._m3nals aoj (;qOD) o3UOllOOX_t20 JoluoD OtFljo streld uo.tlmuomoldtu.t oql slu_soad uodoa s!q£(spao_ 00;5 uJntu!xel_l) J.OVH&SaV "£I.

06_0- I_9 ([ Of;) ISVD VSVN :A]!l!q_l!e^V

paepums :uo!lnq.ms]o 6g pue £E so.uo_oleO ]3ofqns

pol.mt!lUfl-pog!sselOUFl

3000 NOLLRGIHISIO "q_L J.N3f131VIS KU'IIB_rlIVAVAMOIJ.nBIHISIO "rCL

$31ON AHVIN:IM=IqddnS t _

t_I L80Z;-866 I-/,NJJVSVN

H38MnN J.EIOdgU AON3_)VONIEIO I INOINPONIEIOSNOdS "0t

PgLLI-q

HgBflflN £HOd3HNOIIV'ZINVOHO ONlflHOdH3d'8

1000-9trff0_; DO 'uol_u!qseA_

uo.uezls!t_.tuapv ooed Sptre sa!m_uo,ov leUO.UeN

(S=I)SSaEIQQV QNV (S)a_VN AON=JlOV ONIEIOUNOIt_3NIHOSNOdS "6

66 ! _- [ 89_ VA 'uozdmeH

ao_,uoD qo_eoso_{£o[i_u_'I VSVN

(S3)SS:IEIOOY ONV (S)=lnVN NOII VZINVDHO 9NlflHOdH3d "L

ao_!Ir-d 'S.LLmH";:1SOl_qD(S)HOH_J_V"9

I0-0 I-E0-ggg _ Sle.UmeI_I

pue saanaorms aoj o3UOllO3X_t3o amu¢ D VSVN oql aoj Ueld uo!lmuotuoIdtu ISUgennu DNIONn=I"_ alzLmns aNY gq.U.L"_,

tunptreaotuoIA [eo!uq_,L 8661 ]sn_nv ]O:IU3AOO S31VQ QNV :ldAJ. 1ElOd:lH "£ 31VO ZHOdgH "i_ I (>lUelq o^eo-i) A'INO 3sn AON=IOV "t

"g0_0_ OG 'uo_u{_lSeM '(B8 !.0-H_0) lOe_d uof1._nPe,d>po_ueded 'Wro_f] pus lueuJe6eut_ to eoglo eq_o,,pue '?,0g'P;_0<3_ VA 'uolJSU!lN'H_3 Legns 'Ae_I_H s!_eO_ g_ k 'slJodeEI pus suogmedo uo_emm_ul _oI el_Jolom!O 'seouueS sueiJenbpeeH uollSu!qsaM 0_ 'ueoJnq s_ql8uFJnpm _o/suoflse_ns 0u!pnlOUi 'uo_euuo_u! to uoBoelloo

s_ugto _ _ _ue _o emtu_to.e uemnq st_g6u_pm0e_ s1_eu_uJaopueS uo_euJJotu_ IO uo_",etloo e,..ll 6uw,_,_a.= pue _u_dmoo pue 'pepeou ep_p e_ 6u_u_e_mu pu_a_._e6'seoJno_ elep 6u_0_e 0u!qomes 'suol_lsu! 5uw_J aol ewB eql 0u,polou! 'esuodse_ aedJnoN L _t_l_Ae O{l_lBtlJ!l_ S_UO!letUJOIU¢_OUQD_IOO s_qlJotuepJnq 6u{_d_ ollqnd

_,0_oz0oNe_O =lgVd NOIIVIN=IINflOOQ 1EIOd=IHpe_oxtdv uno:l