Upload
failiendur
View
230
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
1/26
#$%#
"&$%'('()*#&+,
-#+#$&%.
/)*0#*%#
1234!"#$ '(")
"#$%&'(# )(*+,*- "../(&%
0,12/(#+ 3*$142,*'$+(,1 5+6%(&4
7"0358- 0&1+*& 2,* 9&$#& $1%
0,12/(#+ 5+6%(&4
*+,-!&+&.
/0!1+,-23&+0!1 402-5+/+&+6- /0!45+/&
&23!140273&+0!8
:&;& #,12/(#+ +*$142,*'$+(,1- +*$14*$+(,1$/- (%&1+(+;- .&$#& &%6#$+(,1-
.&$#& *&4&$*#? '&+?,%,/,@;
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
2/26
5$67# )0 /)*'#*'+
391&23/& :
+!&20,;/&+0! - 32& & 0,12/(#+ 3*$142,*'$+(,1FG "4 $ .*$#+(#&-
(+ (4 %&&./; +(&% +, #,14(%&*$+(,14 ,2 (%&1+(+;F 3?(4 .$.&* 46''$*(H&4 $1%
4;1+?&4(H&4 #6**&1+ +?(1I(1@ (1 +?& +*$14*$+(,1$/ $..*,$#? +, #,12/(#+
+*$142,*'$+(,1 $4 +?& #6**&1+ 4+$+&J,2J+?&J$*+ (1 .&$#& +?&,*;F 3?(4 $..*,$#?
61%&*/(&4 +?& .*$#+(#& ,2 E/(#(+(>& 0,12/(#+ 3*$142,*'$+(,1 $1% ,.&14 '$1; 1&& ,2
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
4/26
L
9*'&):;%'()*3?(4 .$.&* +$I& +?& +?&'& ,2 D(%&1+(+; #,12/(#+4G $1% +
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
5/26
[
&.(4+&',/,@(#$/ $1% ,1+,/,@(#$/ 4?(2+4 +?$+ +,,I ./$#& %6*(1@ (+4 %&>&/,.'&1+F
:&; +?&,*&+(#$/ 2,61%$+(,14 4+&''(1@ 2*,' +*$14.&*4,1$/ .4;#?,/,@;- +?&
./6*$/(+; ,2 .&$#&N4 2*$'&&F
3?& +&*' D+*$14.&*4,1$/G #$'& (1+, .,.6/$* 64$@& $4 +?& 2(&/% ,2
+*$14.&*4,1$/ .4;#?,/,@; %&>&/,.&% ,6+ ,2 +?& .*&>(,64/; &K(4+(1@ 4#?,,/4 ,2
?6'$1(4+(# .4;#?,/,@;F 3*$14.&*4,1$/ .4;#?,/,@; W*,2 $',1@ '$1; ,+?&*4F
3?& +&*' (+4&/2- +*$14.&*4,1$/- #$1 C& C*,I&1 %,
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
6/26
`
5&$*+&$'()*$73?& +&*' D+*$14*$+(,1$/G ?$4 '$1; ,*(@(14 $1% (1+&*.*&+$+(,14F "+ (+4 #,*&- (+4
%&2(1(+(,1 #/,4&/; '(**,*4 +?$+ ,2 +*$14.&*4,1$/ (1 +?$+ (+ (4 $1 $..*,$#? +?$+ @,&4
C&;,1% ,* +*$14@*&44&4 *$+(,1$/(+;F S1 $ 4('(/$* 1,+& ,2 #$6+(,1- R(/C&*N4
#,''&1+ ,1 +*$14.&*4,1$/(+; #$1 $/4, C& '(**,*&% ?&*& (1 +?$+ +*$14*$+(,1$/
'&$14 *$+(,1$/ '-,% 1,+ *$+(,1$/ ./$,%0 3, #,1264& +?(4 .,(1+ (4 $ #,'',1-
+?,6@? @*$>&- &.(4+&',/,@(#$/ &**,* ,2+&1 2,61% (1 $..*,$#?&4 +?$+ $*& #/,4&* +,
+?& 4,J#$//&% DQ&< "@&G ',>&'&1+F R(/C&* +&*'4 +?(4 &**,* (1 +?(1I(1@ +?&
D9*&a3*$14G 2$//$#;-
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
7/26
^
C$64& $// +?$+ $*&- $*& $// +?$+ (4F Y*,' +?(4 .,(1+ ,2 >(&
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
8/26
_
#?*,1,4,.?; &'&*@&F U(2& $1% +('& C,'& 4+*$(@?+ /(1&4 2*,' C(*+? +, $
.$*$%(4& ,* %$'1$+(,1 +?$+ 2,//,(&
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
9/26
g
3?& .,4+',%&*1 2$'(/; ,2 .&$#&4 (4 (1&K,*$C/; /(1I&% +, +?& ',%&*1
.&*4.+(>&F 3?& +&*' D.,4+G (1%(#$+&4 +?$+ (+ &K(4+4 $4 $ *&2/+(,1 6.,1
',%&*1(+; (+4&/2 7E#?$>$**($- S1@*6C&*- :,..&14+&(1&*- d )(&+*(#?- LeAA- .F _e[8F
3?& .,4+',%&*1 61%&*4+$1%(1@ C&@(14 &4- &>&*; (%&$- .$*$%(@'- +?,6@?+ $1%
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
10/26
b
$@$(14+ +?& +?*&$+4
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
11/26
]
$%%(+(,1- #,'.*&?&14(>& .(#+6*& ,2 ,+?&* &.(4+&',/,@(#$/ ?(4+,*(&4 2*,' $*,61%
+?& &/,.'&1+$/ .4;#?,/,@;- +?& #$.$#(+; +, !2/%!(1 +?& (%6$/4N #$.$#(+; 2,* 4&/2J
*&2/+(>& #,14#(,641&44F 3?& $C(/(+; +, +?(1I $C,6+ ,1&N4 ,& C,'&
$&/,.'&1+- D>(4(,1J/,@(#FG
3?&*& (4 $ #,**&/$+& ?&*& (1 +?& +*$14(+(,1 2*,' +?&5$#+#!# 7?&$*+8 #?$I*$ +, +?&
6/%+,33+# 7+?*,$+8 #?$I*$j +?& 4(@1(2(#$1#& ,2 +?(4 #,11+(,1 & #$.$#(+; (4 $ I&; .,(1+ (1 '$1; ,2 +?& (4&44+6%&1+4 ,2 '&%(+$+(,1 +,- D/&$*1 +?& C$#I
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
12/26
Ae
#6*&F 3?& &/(#(+(>& #,12/(#+ & $#I1,&*4$/ .*&4#*(.+(>& ',%&/4 ?$>& C&&1 $C$1%,1&%- $//
,1& ?$4 +, *&/; ,1 (4 ,1&N4 ,$1+ +, +?& #,1+$#+ .,(1+4 C&;,1% +?& 46*2$#& ,2 +?& .&*4,1$F
3?&4& $*& +?& 4&K6$/- +?& 4,#(,J&',+(,1$/- +?& '&1+$/- $1% +?& 4.(*(+6$/ /$;&*4
74&& 2(@6*& A8F Y*,' "C*$' O$4/,
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
13/26
AA
%('&14(,1F 3?& 4,1% &K.$14(,1 ?&$*I&14 C$#I +, +?& .*&>(,64 %(4#644(,1 ,2
+?& 1$+6*& ,2 .&$#& ,* *$+?&* .&$#&4 '$1(2&4+4 (1 +?& ./6*$/F 3?64
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
14/26
AL
%&>&/,.(1@ $
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
15/26
A[
(1#*&$4& +*64+ C&+(%6$/4 $1% @*,6.4 46#? $4 +*$14.$*&1#; $1%
$##,61+$C(/(+; '&$46*&4F X6+ (1 +?& &1%- +*64+ (4 2&/+ 1,+ (1+&//+6$//;
61%&*4+,,%F
3?& 1&K+ /$;&* ,2 +?& ',%&/ *&.*&4&1+4 (1 '$1; *&4.+4 +?& DI&;G ,2
&/(#(+(>&
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
16/26
A`
S+ (4 $+ +?(4 .,(1+ +?$+ +?& .*$#+(#$C/& /('(+4 ,2 &/(#(+(>& .&$#&
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
17/26
A^
2*,' $1; .,(1+F S1 +?(4 *&4&$*#? .*,M+- +?& '$.
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
18/26
A_
+?*,6@?,6+ +?& C,%; +?$+ $*& +?& #&1+*$/ #,1%6(+4 2,* +?& 2/,< ,2 /(2& &1&*@; ,*
'"#$#F 3?&; $/4, *&.*&4&1+ +?& $*#?&+;.$/ 4.(*(+6$/ M,6*1&; $4 m,@( .*,@*&44
+?*,6@? +?&(* 4.(*(+6$/ .$+? ,.&1(1@ 6. &$#? #?$I*$ $4 +?& (1%(>(%6$/ 4,6/ ,*
#!#.#$ 4&&I4 /(C&*$+(,1 (1+, +?& 61(>&*4$/ 4,6/ ,* 8"#+.#$0D9,
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
19/26
Ag
*&/$+&% +, +?& O(%%/& Y*&1#?
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
20/26
Ab
4?$.&%F 3?*,6@? $& #,14#(,641&44- +?& *&/$+(,14?(. ,2 ,1&N4 ,&4 C&@(14 +, 4?(2+ 73$;/,*- 1a%8F
Y*,' +?& (1+&*1$/ .&*4.+(>& ,2 +?& (1%(>(%6$/- 9$+? *&2&*4 +,
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
21/26
A]
,2 #,12/(#+ +*$142,*'$+(,1G 7)(&+*(#?- LeA[- .F g`8F S+ (4 $ +,,/ 2,* #,12/(#+
+*$142,*'$+(,1 C$64& (+ *&.*&4&1+4 4&/2J&K.*&44(,1 $1% $/4, C$64& (+
*&.*&4&1+4 +?& &/&'&1+ ,2 &- +?& 6/%+,33+# #?$I*$ (4 +?& 2(*4+
+*$14.&*4,1$/ #?$I*$F 3?& >&*; 1$+6*& ,2 >,(#& (4 +*$14.&*4,1$/ C$64& +?&
261#+(,1 ,2 >,(#& (4 +, +*$14'(+ +?& '&$1(1@ ,2 /$1@6$@& C&;,1% +?& '$4I ,2 +?&
.&*4,1$F "4 $ 4+&. (1 +?& $*#?&+;.$/ 4.(*(+6$/ .$+?- +?& 6/%+,33+#& ?$>(1@
+*$14@*&44&% 5$#+#!#& ',>&4 +,& C&;,1% +?& 6/%+,33+# '&$14 +, ',>& C&;,1% /$1@6$@&F U$1@6$@& ?$4
C,'& +?& .*('$*; >&?(#/& 2,* 61%&*4+$1%(1@ *&$/(+;F R(+? 4#*(.+- &$#?
#?$*$#+&* *&.*&4&1+4 $ 4,61% '$%& C; +?& >,(#&F B1#& /$1@6$@& &>,/>&% C&;,1%
(%&,@*$'4 ,* @/;.?4 (1+, 4#*(.+- (+ C$'& $C,6+ $4 2$* *&',>&% 2*,' $ %(*+
.&*#&.+(,1 ,2 *&$/(+; $4 $ /(1@6(4+(# '&%(6' #$1 C& 7O#I&11$- A]]A8F R?&1 $
.&*4,1 ',>&4 C&;,1% /$1@6$@& $1% +?64 C&;,1% ',4+ #,1>&1+(,1$/ #,1#&.+(,14-
+?& ?,/% ,2 +?& &@, ,* DSG C&@(14 +, %(44,/>& $4
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
22/26
Le
+?&
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
23/26
LA
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
24/26
LL
B(C;+Y(@6*& A
3?& S1+*$.&*4,1$/ /$;&*4 ,2 U&%&*$#?N4 .;*$'(%j /$+&*$/ >(&< 7)(&+*(#?-
S1+&*.*&+$+(,14 ,2 9&$#& (1 V(4+,*; $1% 06/+6*&- LeAL- .F LeL8
Y(@6*& L
D3?& (1+&*J$1% (1+*$.&*4,1$/ /$;&*4 ,2 U&%&*$?N4 .;*$'(%j C(*%4J&;& >(&
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
25/26
L[
Y(@6*& [
DB*(&1+$+(,1$/ 0,14(%&*$+(,14 2,* 3*$14*$+(,1$/ 9&$#& R,*IG 73$;/,*- 1a%8
8/12/2019 Identity Considerations for Elicitive Conflict Transformation
26/26
D)&E+ /('#:)(&+*(#?- RF 7LeA[8F =-/>/!/1( ?)$@-/>! A"#$%@)".#!/)$ #$3 !+( A"#$%"#!/)$#- B+/@!
/$ C(#>( C)-/!/>%07RF 5c+H/- d iF V(1%/&;- 3*$14F8 Q&< m,*I= 9$/@*$>& O$#'(//($1F
)(&+*(#?- RF 7LeAL8F D$!("'"(!#!/)$% )@ C(#>( /$ E/%!)"F #$3 ?,-!,"(0Q&< m,*I=
9$/@*$>& O$#'(//$1F
E#?$>$**($- TF- S1@*6C&*- )F- :,..&14+&(1&*- QF- d )(&+*(#?- RF 7LeAA8F 0,1#/64(,1F
S1 RF )(&+*(#?- TF EF "/>$*&H- WF E4+&>$- )F S1@*6C&*- d QF :,..&14+&(1&* 7E%4F8- A+(C#-4"#1( D$!("$#!/)$#- E#$3G))H )@ C(#>( B!,3/(%I 5 ?,-!,"#- C("%'(>!/1(7..F
^]gJ_e_8F Q&< m,*I= 9$/@*$>& O$#'(//$1F
V$*.&*- )F 7LeeAJLeA[8F =$!"F @)" J=$("4FJF Z&+*(&>&% Ae Le- LeA[- 2*,' B1/(1&
E+;',/,@; )(#+(,1$*;=?++.=aa&F
5+c&+H/ - RF- d )(&+*(#?- RF 7Lee_8F " 0$// 2, O$1; 9&$#&4F
3$;/,*- QF 71a%8F 3?& 9&$#&26/ R$**(,* O;4+(#(4' $1% 0,12/(#+ 3*$142,*'$+(,1F
C+N N/%%("!#!/)$F 0$4+&//p1= P1(>&*4(+$+ T$6'& SF
R(/C&*- :F 7A]]^8F B(O& =>)-)4F& B'/"/!,#-/!FI A+( B'/"/! )@ =1)-,!/)$75,1%
E%(+(,1- Z&>(4&% &%F8F X,4+,1= 5?$'C?$/$F
k&1M(- )F 7A]^b8F B)!) 5''")#>+ !) P($07OF Z&(?,- 3*$14F8 3,I;,= U$;'$1
X6%%?(4+ 5,#(&+; 9*&44F