1
Distinguishing Characters: Early-stagE larvaE • Slash-like hypaxial melanophores • Pigment around notochord p and on caudal margin • Most slender body: Flexion stage = 16.9% BD/SL latE-stagE larvaE • Slash-like hypaxial melanophores • Pigment along edge of caudal margin • Most slender body: Poslexion stage = 19.9% BD/SL Limanda aspera Limanda aspera were previously known from the descripon and illustraons of a developmental series presented in Pertseva- Ostroumova (1961). However, some discrepancies were noted in the pigmentaon between the material we compiled and that depicted in Pertseva-Ostroumova’s series. Reproducons of those illustraons were of generally poor quality, therefore a new developmental series was illustrated. Limanda proboscidea Preflexion and early flexion-stage larvae of Limanda proboscidea were inially idenfied using the characters and illustraons in Grigor’ev (2004). Late flexion and poslexion stage larvae were originally thought to be Arcc Flounder ( Pleuronectes glacialis ). However, counts of anal-fin rays were determined to be too high for that species (45-58 L. proboscidea vs. 33-46 P. glacialis ) and a DNA barcode match further verified the idenficaons as L. proboscidea (C. W. Mecklenburg, pers. comm.). Limanda sakhalinensis Preflexion and early flexion larvae of Limanda sakhalinensis were inially idenfied as Spiny Flounder (Acanthopsea nadeshnyi) based on the descripon and illustraons presented by Pertseva-Ostroumova (1961). Since our larvae were collected in Arcc waters and A. nadeshnyi has not been reported from the Arcc (Mecklenburg et al. 2011; B. Sheiko, pers. comm.), we concluded that these specimens are L. sakhalinensis based on meriscs (myomere count) and similaries in pigmentaon and morphology to other Limanda species larvae. Larval illustraons by Ashlee Overdick Introduction Interest in assessment of Arcc ecosystems has increased recently as the result of climate change; in parcular, diminished sea ice coverage and concentraon. Increased potenal for oil and gas development and expanded transportaon routes are other notable economic consideraons. A goal of several scienfic programs including the Arcc Ecosystem Integrated Survey (Arcc EIS); Chukchi Acouscs, Oceanography, and Zooplankton (CHAOZ); and Russian-American- Long-Term Census of the Arcc (RUSALCA) is to assess the abundance and distribuon of ichthyoplankton in Arcc ecosystems. Central to the success of these programs is the ability to idenfy organisms at all life stages. Idenficaon of all life stages of fishes is necessary for baseline assessments of populaon structure and abundance and to understand life history processes. The Recruitment Processes Program at the Alaska Fisheries Science Center has begun work on an idenficaon guide of early life stages of fish found in Arcc waters. The first family addressed will be the Pleuronecdae (right-eyed flounders). Mecklenburg et al. (2011) reported 10 species from the Arcc Ocean seas and adjacent boreal waters. Of these, members of the genus Limanda in the northern Bering, Chukchi, and Beaufort seas are among the most abundant species collected and are the focus of this study. Three species are known in the Arcc: Limanda aspera (Yellowfin Sole), L. proboscidea (Longhead Dab), and L. sakhalinensis (Sakhalin Sole). Methods The study area is in the North Pacific Ocean, defined with a southern boundary in the Bering Sea at latude 62°N and extending northward into the Chukchi and Beaufort seas, which at present is the northern limit of our sampling. This area is well within the boundary of the Arcc marine ichthyofaunal region as defined by Mecklenburg et al. (2011). Larvae were collected during 12 cruises from 2004 to 2013 with a 60-cm bongo sampler and 1-m Tucker sled trawl; boom depth at most staons was 10–50 m. Morphometric measurements were taken on the right side of up to 50 larvae of each species, when possible; body depth is defined as the vercal distance from dorsal to ventral body margin at the center of the anus. Selected specimens were cleared and differenally stained to count merisc structures and follow sequence of fin development. Identification of Larvae of Three Arctic Species of Limanda (Family Pleuronectidae) Distinguishing Characters: Early-stagE larvaE • Slash-like hypaxial melanophores • Pigment on anal fin latE-stagE larvaE • Few melanophores on caudal fin • Small size at transformaon ( 16.2 mm SL) Distinguishing Characters: Early-stagE larvaE • Pigment along dorsal margin of body • Two “bars” of pigment on postanal body • Deepest body depth: Flexion stage = 24.0% BD/SL latE-stagE larvaE • Patches along dorsal and anal margins and fins • Deepest body depth: Poslexion stage = 37.8% BD/SL • Large size at transformaon (>35.1 mm SL) Deborah Blood, Morgan Busby, Ann Matarese, and Lisa De Forest recruitment Processes Program resource assessment and Conservaon Engineering Division alaska Fisheries science Center, NOaa Fisheries 7600 sand Point Way NE, seale, Washington 98115, Usa Cleared and stained transformaon-stage larva of Limanda proboscidea (36.0 mm sl). Photo by Karna McKinney. although Limanda aspera larvae are found as far south as Kodiak Island in the gulf of alaska, arcc specimens are found from Norton sound to Point Franklin. It is the most commonly occurring of the Limanda species and by far the most abundant; in areas of highest abundance, catches are more than 100 mes greater than either of the other two species. Limanda proboscidea larvae have the widest arcc distribuon of the Limanda species; they are found just south of Norton sound to the area off Cape Halke in the Beaufort sea. Limanda sakhalinensis larvae are uncommon within the arcc area; at the present me we have collected only 16 specimens. Found from outside Norton sound to Cape lisburne, most larvae have been collected outside Kotzebue sound. rEFErENCEs Grigor’ev, S.S. 2004. Description of the longhead dab Limanda proboscidea (Pleuronectidae) larvae from the Sea of Okhotsk. Journal of Ichthyology 44:152-157. Mecklenburg, C. W., T. A. Mecklenburg, and L. K. Thorsteinson. 2002. Fishes of Alaska, 1037 p. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, MD. Mecklenburg, C.W., P.R. Møller, and D. Steinke. 2011. Biodiversity of Arctic marine fishes: taxonomy and zoogeography. Marine Biodiversity 41:109-140. Pertseva-Ostroumova, T.A. 1961. The reproduction and development of far-eastern flounders. Tr. Inst. Okeanol. Akad. Nauk. SSSR., 484 p. e recommendations and general content presented in this poster do not necessarily represent the views or position of the Department of Commerce, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, or the National Marine Fisheries Service. Adult illustraons: Mecklenburg et al. 2002

Identification of Larvae of Three Arctic Species of ... been reported from the Arctic (Mecklenburg et al. 2011; B. Sheiko, pers. comm.), we concluded that these specimens are L. sakhalinensis

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Identification of Larvae of Three Arctic Species of ... been reported from the Arctic (Mecklenburg et al. 2011; B. Sheiko, pers. comm.), we concluded that these specimens are L. sakhalinensis

Distinguishing Characters:

Early-stagE larvaE

•Slash-likehypaxialmelanophores

•Pigmentaroundnotochordtipandoncaudalmargin

•Mostslenderbody:Flexionstage=16.9%BD/SL

latE-stagE larvaE

•Slash-likehypaxialmelanophores

•Pigmentalongedgeofcaudalmargin

•Mostslenderbody:Postflexionstage=19.9%BD/SL

Limanda asperaLimanda aspera werepreviouslyknownfromthedescriptionandillustrationsofadevelopmentalseriespresentedinPertseva-Ostroumova(1961).However,somediscrepancieswerenotedinthepigmentationbetweenthematerialwecompiledandthatdepictedinPertseva-Ostroumova’sseries.Reproductionsofthoseillustrationswereofgenerallypoorquality,thereforeanewdevelopmentalserieswasillustrated.

Limanda proboscideaPreflexionandearlyflexion-stagelarvaeofLimanda proboscideawereinitiallyidentifiedusingthecharactersandillustrationsinGrigor’ev(2004).LateflexionandpostflexionstagelarvaewereoriginallythoughttobeArcticFlounder(Pleuronectes glacialis).However,countsofanal-finraysweredeterminedtobetoohighforthatspecies(45-58L. proboscidea vs.33-46P. glacialis)andaDNAbarcodematchfurtherverifiedtheidentificationsasL. proboscidea(C.W.Mecklenburg,pers.comm.).

Limanda sakhalinensisPreflexionandearlyflexionlarvaeofLimanda sakhalinensis wereinitiallyidentifiedasSpinyFlounder(Acanthopsetta nadeshnyi)basedonthedescriptionandillustrationspresentedbyPertseva-Ostroumova(1961).SinceourlarvaewerecollectedinArcticwatersandA. nadeshnyihasnotbeenreportedfromtheArctic(Mecklenburgetal.2011;B.Sheiko,pers.comm.),weconcludedthatthesespecimensareL. sakhalinensisbasedonmeristics(myomerecount)andsimilaritiesinpigmentationandmorphologytootherLimanda specieslarvae.

LarvalillustrationsbyAshleeOverdick

IntroductionInterestinassessmentofArcticecosystemshasincreasedrecentlyastheresultofclimatechange;inparticular,diminishedseaicecoverageandconcentration.Increasedpotentialforoilandgasdevelopmentandexpandedtransportationroutesareothernotableeconomicconsiderations.AgoalofseveralscientificprogramsincludingtheArcticEcosystemIntegratedSurvey(ArcticEIS);ChukchiAcoustics,Oceanography,andZooplankton(CHAOZ);andRussian-American-Long-TermCensusoftheArctic(RUSALCA)istoassesstheabundanceanddistributionofichthyoplanktoninArcticecosystems.Centraltothesuccessoftheseprogramsistheabilitytoidentifyorganismsatalllifestages.Identificationofalllifestagesoffishesisnecessaryforbaselineassessmentsofpopulationstructureandabundanceandtounderstandlifehistoryprocesses.

TheRecruitmentProcessesProgramattheAlaskaFisheriesScienceCenterhasbegunworkonanidentificationguideofearlylifestagesoffishfoundinArcticwaters.ThefirstfamilyaddressedwillbethePleuronectidae(right-eyedflounders).Mecklenburgetal.(2011)reported10speciesfromtheArcticOceanseasandadjacentborealwaters.Ofthese,membersofthegenusLimandainthenorthernBering,Chukchi,andBeaufortseasareamongthemostabundantspeciescollectedandarethefocusofthisstudy.ThreespeciesareknownintheArctic:Limanda aspera (YellowfinSole), L. proboscidea (LongheadDab),andL. sakhalinensis(SakhalinSole).

MethodsThestudyareaisintheNorthPacificOcean,definedwithasouthernboundaryintheBeringSeaatlatitude62°NandextendingnorthwardintotheChukchiandBeaufortseas,whichatpresentisthenorthernlimitofoursampling.ThisareaiswellwithintheboundaryoftheArcticmarineichthyofaunalregionasdefinedbyMecklenburgetal.(2011).Larvaewerecollectedduring12cruisesfrom2004to2013witha60-cmbongosamplerand1-mTuckersledtrawl;bottomdepthatmoststationswas10–50m.Morphometricmeasurementsweretakenontherightsideofupto50larvaeofeachspecies,whenpossible;bodydepthisdefinedastheverticaldistancefromdorsaltoventralbodymarginatthecenteroftheanus.Selectedspecimenswereclearedanddifferentiallystainedtocountmeristicstructuresandfollowsequenceoffindevelopment.

Identification of Larvae of Three Arctic Species of Limanda (Family Pleuronectidae)

Distinguishing Characters:

Early-stagE larvaE

•Slash-likehypaxialmelanophores

•Pigmentonanalfin

latE-stagE larvaE

•Fewmelanophoresoncaudalfin

•Smallsizeattransformation(≤16.2mmSL)

Distinguishing Characters:

Early-stagE larvaE

•Pigmentalongdorsalmarginofbody

•Two“bars”ofpigmentonpostanalbody

•Deepestbodydepth:Flexionstage=24.0%BD/SL

latE-stagE larvaE

•Patchesalongdorsalandanalmarginsandfins

•Deepestbodydepth:Postflexionstage=37.8%BD/SL

•Largesizeattransformation(>35.1mmSL)

Deborah Blood, Morgan Busby, Ann Matarese,

and Lisa De Forestrecruitment Processes Program

resource assessment and Conservation Engineering Division alaska Fisheries science Center, NOaa Fisheries

7600 sand Point Way NE, seattle, Washington 98115, Usa Cleared and stained

transformation-stage larva of Limanda proboscidea (36.0 mm sl).

PhotobyKarnaMcKinney.

although Limanda aspera larvae are found as far south as Kodiak Island in the gulf of alaska, arctic specimens are found from Norton sound to Point Franklin. It is the most commonly occurring of the Limanda species and by far the most abundant; in areas of highest abundance, catches are more than 100 times greater than either of the other two species.

Limanda proboscidea larvae have the widest arctic distribution of the Limanda species; they are found just south of Norton sound to the area off Cape Halkett in the Beaufort sea.

Limanda sakhalinensis larvae are uncommon within the arctic area; at the present time we have collected only 16 specimens. Found from outside Norton sound to Cape lisburne, most larvae have been collected outside Kotzebue sound.

rEFErENCEsGrigor’ev, S.S. 2004. Description of the longhead dab Limanda proboscidea (Pleuronectidae) larvae from

the Sea of Okhotsk. Journal of Ichthyology 44:152-157.Mecklenburg, C. W., T. A. Mecklenburg, and L. K. Thorsteinson. 2002. Fishes of Alaska, 1037 p.

American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, MD. Mecklenburg, C.W., P.R. Møller, and D. Steinke. 2011. Biodiversity of Arctic marine fishes: taxonomy

and zoogeography. Marine Biodiversity 41:109-140. Pertseva-Ostroumova, T.A. 1961. The reproduction and development of far-eastern flounders. Tr. Inst.

Okeanol. Akad. Nauk. SSSR., 484 p.

The recommendations and general content presented in this poster do not necessarily represent the views or position of the Department of Commerce, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, or the National Marine Fisheries Service.

Adultillustrations:Mecklenburgetal.2002