42
ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August 7, 2012

ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation

Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit

August 7, 2012

Page 2: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Overview

• Background

• Scope

• Draft Construction Plan

• Results

2

Page 3: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Background • Reliability Assessment is performed pursuant to

Entergy’s Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) Attachment K.

• Objectives:

– Assess of the ability of the Entergy transmission system to perform according to the Planning Criteria.

– Construction Plan Evaluation (CPE) - Evaluate Entergy’s Draft 2013-2017 Construction Plan’s ability to mitigate any performance deficiencies found.

– Provide basis for development of the Base Plan.

3

Page 4: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Background (cont)

• Draft 2013 RA Report was made available for stakeholder review and comment

– Posted on Entergy’s OASIS July 5, 2012

– Stakeholder WebEx held on July 18, 2012

• Final report is posted on Entergy’s OASIS.

– Detailed spreadsheets not included in report are posted on Entergy’s oasis

– Background models, data, and other information are posted on Entergy’s oasis

4

Page 5: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Entergy Planning Criteria

• Planning Criteria

– NERC Planning Standards

– SERC Supplements

– Entergy’s Local Planning Criteria

– Entergy’s Business Practices (Planning Guidelines)

• Posted on Entergy’s OASIS

• NERC Planning Standards being revised

5

Page 6: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

2013 RA Scope

6

• Contingency Scans

Category A (System Intact)

– Overloads identified for flows greater than 100% RATE A

– Voltage identified if outside this range (.95 < V < 1.05)

Category B (N-1)

– Breaker-to-Breaker analysis – Consequential Load (CL) loss reported

– ICT’s 100MW rule – if CL exceeds 100MW, then the bus-to-bus contingency is used to identify overloads and voltage issues

– Overloads identified for flows greater than 100% RATE A

– Voltage identified if outside this range (.92 < V < 1.05)

Page 7: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

2013 RA Scope (cont)

7

• Contingency Scans

Monitored and Contingent Elements

– Entergy and its internal areas 69kV and above

– First Tier 345kV and above

– CLECO & LUS: Transmission elements with nominal voltage 69 kV and higher

• Notes

The impact of Operating Guides will be determined during the development of the Base Plan later in the planning cycle

Re-dispatch will not be used to mitigate the overloads or voltage issues identified unless identified in a formally documented Operating Guide

Non-consequential load loss will be avoided during the development of the Base Plan

Page 8: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

2013 RA Scope (cont)

8

• Reliability Assessment Contingency Scan Models

2011 Series U1 (Including 2012-2016 Approved CP projects)

Near Term

– Summer and Winter Peak 2014 and 2018

Long Term

– Summer Peak 2021

• 2013-2017 CPE Contingency Scan Models

2011 Series U2 (Including Draft 2013-2017 App/Prop CP projects)

Near Term

– Summer and Winter Peak 2014 and 2018

Long Term

– Summer Peak 2021

Page 9: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

2013 RA Scope (cont)

9

• Low Hydro Analysis

2011 Series U1 (Including 2012-2016 Approved CP projects)

Bull Shoals – off

Greers Ferry – off

Sam Rayburn – off

AECC Hydro #2, AECC Hydro #9, Beaver Dam, Blakely, Bull Shoals Dam, Carpenter, Dardanelle Dam, Degray, Greers Ferry, Murray Hydro (LA), Murray Hydro NLR, Norfork, Ozark AECC, Ozark Beach, Rayburn, Remmel, Table Rock, and Toledo Bend at 50% capacity

Page 10: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

2013 RA Scope (cont)

• Load Pocket Analysis (N-1,G-1)

2011 Series U1 (Including 2012-2016 Approved CP projects)

Summer 2018

Western Region

– Lewis Creek U1 - off

Amite South

– Waterford U3 - off

DSG

– Nine Mile U5 - off – Michoud U3 - off

10

Page 11: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Entergy’s Draft Construction Plan

• May 9, 2012: Original Draft CP 2013-2017 Posted

• July 16, 2012: Draft CP 2013-2017 Update 1 Posted

– 5 new projects (2 replaced; 1 accelerated from Horizon Plan)

– 4 delayed projects

– 4 projects changed from Proposed to Approved

– 15 projectes changed from Approved to Completed

• 2012 BP and 2012-2016 CP Differences Report

– No differences in projects

11

Page 12: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Map Legend

12

Page 13: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Arkansas CPE Results

13

Page 14: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

14

McCrory – Bailey SES 161kV

Page 15: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

15

Page 16: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

16

Pine Bluff Arsenal Sub C – White Bluff 115kV

Page 17: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

17

Page 18: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

18

Blakely Dam – Mtn. Pine South 115kV

Hot Springs South – Carpenter Dam 115kV

Page 19: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Mississippi CPE Results

19

Page 20: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

20

Vicksburg East SS – Edwards 115kV

Page 21: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

21

Batesville – Sardis

115kV

Page 22: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

22

Clarksdale IPP – City of

Clarksdale – Clarksdale 115kV

Page 23: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

23

Hernando – Getwell 115kV

Page 24: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Louisiana CPE Results

24

Page 25: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

25

Page 26: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

26

Belle Point – Little Gypsy 230kV

Page 27: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

27

Clovelly – Valentine 115kV

Page 28: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

28

Page 29: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Texas CPE Results

29

Page 30: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

30

Page 31: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

31

Amelia – Helbig Bulk 230kV

Page 32: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

32

Bryan - 69kV – 138kV

Page 33: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Low Hydro Results

33

Page 34: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

34

Page 35: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

35

Beaver Creek – Jena – Standard 115kV

Beaver Creek 115/138kV

Page 36: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

36

Quitman – Heber Springs South 161 kV

Page 37: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

37

Page 38: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

38

Page 39: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

39

HS East – HS Union Carbide 115kV

HS EHV – HS Ind. 115kV HS Union Carbide – HS Ind.

115kV

Page 40: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

Load Pocket Results

40

Page 41: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

41

Porter – Apollo 138kV

Page 42: ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan ...€¦ · ICT 2013 Reliability Assessment and Construction Plan Evaluation Entergy ICT Transmission Planning Summit August

42

QUESTIONS?

Ben Roubique Manager, ICT Planning [email protected] 501.614.3331