IBAHRINE Communication and Cultural GlobalisationM.Ibahrine/IBAHRINE... · 5 Communication and Cultural Globalisation ... the supremacy of the market and liberal democracy. ... the

5 Communication and Cultural Globalisation

Lecture by Dr. Mohammed Ibahrinebased on Thussu’s International Communication

AL AKHAWAYN UNIVERSITYSCHOOL OF HUMANITIES AND SOCIAL SCIENCES

COMMUNICATIONS STUDIES

31/10/2006 2

The statement of the dayThe statement of the day

• I hear, I forget

• I see, I remember

• I do, I Understand

Confucius

31/10/2006 3

Structure of the Lecture

• 1. Globalization of Western Culture• 2. The flow of International Television Programmes• 2.1 Hollywood Hegemony • 2.2 • 3. Concerns for Cultural Diversity • 4. Global English • 5. Regionalization and Localization in the Media Market• 5.1 Regionalization in Print journalism • 5.2 Regionalized Advertising• 5.3 Regionalization of Pop Music• 5.4 Global Media local Audience

31/10/2006 4

Structure of the Lecture

• 3. Media exports from the South to the North

3.1 Case 1: TV Globo

3.2 Case 2: The other Hollywood: the Indian

film industry

31/10/2006 5

1. Globalization of Western Culture

• The effects of the explosion in international communication has been mainly preoccupied with the economic dimensions of globalization at the expense of cultural aspects of interactions between and among the world’s peoples

31/10/2006 6


• Is globalization another term for Americanization?

• The general pattern of media ownership indicates that West, led by the USA, dominates the international flow of information and entertainment in all major media sectors

• What is the impact of such one-way flows of global information and entertainment on national and regional media cultures

31/10/2006 7


• It has been argued that international communication and media are leading to the homogenization of culture, but the patterns of global/national/local interactions may be more complex

• The issue of hybridity: How global genres are adapted to siutnational cultural codes

31/10/2006 8


• Some argue that such globally transmitted programming will promote a shared media culture, based on English and American lifestyles and values

• The globalization of the privatized, advertisement-driven model of American commercial television has brought consumer culture to living rooms across the world

• Graphic • As a visual medium, television has much wider reach than the

print media

31/10/2006 9


• The international dissemination of images transcends linguistic barriers

• Television is thus central to what Stuart Hall has called a “global mass culture”, one dominated by the image, imagery, and styles of mass advertising

• This mass culture may be influencing the way people think about their regional or national identities

•

31/10/2006 10


• The globalization of consumerism has been variously described as“Coca-Cola-ization” or “McDonaldization”, creating a credit-card global society modeled on US commercial culture epitomized by Nike and Addidas and their promotion by celebrities like Michael Jordan (Graphic )

• It has been argued that one reason for the global appeal to US popular culture is its openness and mingling of multiplicity of cultures

• The intercultural density may constitute part of the subliminal attraction of American popular media, music, film and television

31/10/2006 11

2. The Flow of International Television Programmes

• The global flow of consumerist messages through international television has been by some as evidence of a new form of cultural imperialism, especially in non-Western world

• The US use its “soft power” to promote its national interest

• The flow of international television programmes from the West to other parts of the world has become more pronounced in the era of multi-channel television

31/10/2006 12


• There is generally one-way traffic from the major-Western-exporting nations to the rest of the world

• In Latin America, virtually all imports are from the USA, even in countries where a strong domestic television industry exists such as Brazil and Mexico

• Even in a country like Britain, with substantial earnings from exporting its own television programmes, the US television presence is still significant

31/10/2006 13


• The US presence on European television has increased substantially, especially in film-based programming, which is often dubbed into local languages

• With a forecast growth in digital satellite subscribers across the continent, the US programmes intake is likely to grow

31/10/2006 14

2.1 Hollywood Hegemony

• The US presence on European television has increased substantially, especially in film-based programming, which is often dubbed into local languages

• With a forecast growth in digital satellite subscribers across the continent, the US programmes intake is likely to grow

31/10/2006 15

Hegemony

• Hegemony is a key term in the critical studies of international communication

• The term hegemony is associated with the Italian Marxist Antonio Gramsci and

• his famous book, Selections from the Prison Notebooks published first in English in 1971

31/10/2006 16

Hegemony

• The term is rooted in the notion that the dominant social group in a society has the capacity to exercise

» intellectual » moral

• direction over society at large

• to build a new system of social alliances to support its aims

31/10/2006 17

Hegemony

Gramsci argued that

• Military force was not necessarily the best instrument to retain power for the ruling classes

• The more effective way to use power was to build a consent by ideological control of cultural

production and distribution

31/10/2006 18

Hegemony

• The dominant social class exerts

moral Intellectual

• leadership through its control of such institutions as

SchoolsReligious bodiesMass media

31/10/2006 19

Hegemony

• In international communication, the notion of hegemony is widely used to

• conceptualize political functions of the media in

propagating maintaining

• the dominant ideology

31/10/2006 20

Hegemony

• In international communication, the notion of hegemony is widely used to

In explaining the process of media communication production

• The dominant ideology shapes the production of news and entertainment

31/10/2006 21

Hegemony

Though the media are notionally free from direct government control,

yet they act as agents of legitimization of the dominant ideology

31/10/2006 22


• One of the most contest issues in global film exports has been the trade in films between the USA and Europe

• The audio-visual market in the EU remains overwhelmingly dominated by American productions

• American productions account for between 60 to 90 per cent of members states’ audio-visual markets

Receipt from cinema ticket salesVideo cassette sales and rental Sales of TV fiction programmes

31/10/2006 23


• The process of trade deregulation and expansion in the US film and television industry in the 1990s has also undermined the heavilysubsidized European film industry

• Mexico’s film industry experienced a dramatic fall in production between 1988 and 1998

• In Japan film production has halved in the past three decades

• The leading Russian studio, Mosfilm, which used to produce up to 50 films a year in the 1970s and 1980s, released only three films in 1997

31/10/2006 24


• European countries have developed joint ventures to deal with thiischallenge

31/10/2006 25

3 Concern for Cultural Diversity

• The standardization of programmes on the world’s cinema and television screens risks the disappearance of cultural and linguistic identities

• Many countries have regulations on maintaining a certain level of programming on television dealing with local content

Canadian Broadcasting Corporation = 60 percent France = 60 percent

31/10/2006 26

4 Global English

• English ahs emerged in the pats two hundred years as the lingua franca of global commerce and communication

• The US assumption of this pre-eminent position ensured the continuation of English as the key language of global communication, with significant implication for the future of the world’s other language

• English has acquired the status of being the language of power and prestige

31/10/2006 27

4 Global English

• This is particularly noticeable in the field of book publishing, where English-language publishers set the literary agenda globally, which is often detrimental to the interest of many Southern writers

• English, preferably American English, the Californian English dialect, the chief of the computer and the Internet and the accepted of global communication

• The growth in multi-channel television, filled with American programming or its local clones, is likely to extend an Americanversion of English language to all parts of the world

31/10/2006 28

Regionalization and Localization in the Media Market

• Although there is enough evidence of the globalization of Western media products to raise profound concern fore cultures outside the USA and UK

• There is also a trend towards the regionalization and localization of media content to suit cultural priorities of audiences and fears of a homogenized world culture may be premature

• It has become a commercial imperative for international media organizations to adapt their product and services to local cultural conditions

31/10/2006 29

Regionalization and Localization in the Media Market

• Even in Europe, regionalization has become a commercial imperative for international broadcasters

• Adaptation of US programming is easier in the countries where English is widely used, as in Scandinavia

• Some see this regionalization of products as a sign of global-local cultural syncretism

• In the Arab world, key Western television channels are increasingly localizing their contents to go beyond the expatriate constituency

• Even the BBC channels have regionalized their content

31/10/2006 30

Global Media and Local Audience?Global Media and Local Audience?

• The providers of global media messages are primarily Western, though they employ an array of regional and local strategies to maximize their audiences and advertising revenues

• Western media texts bring with them images of lifestyles, expected social relations and ways of representing

31/10/2006 31


• While the presence of imported television products on screens in the South and in Europe is undeniable, the consumption of them is by no means a passive, receptive process

• The interactions with mediated Western culture can produce complex results

• People first filter and reorganize what comes from hegemonic culture and then integrate and fuse this with what comes from their own historically memory

31/10/2006 32


• This plurality of interpretations of media messages is borne out by the studies of television, the most powerful global medium

• Although the number of people watching CNN or reading Time magazine in developing countries may be tiny, they are often those with power and influence

• It could be argued that international communication is promoting a globalized, “westernized” elite which believes in the supremacy of the market and liberal democracy

31/10/2006 33


• A pan-Asian cross-media survey in 1999 found that CNN and MTV were the most popular channels among the elite affluent sections of society in Asia

• Rather than creating a homogenized culture, globalization of Western culture my be producing “heterogeneous disjunctions”

• The global-local cultural interaction is leading to a hypridculture, which blurs the boundaries between the modern and the traditional, the high and low culture and the national and the global culture

31/10/2006 34


• Roland Robertson called this mingling “glocalisation” characterized by cultural fusion as a result of adaptation of Western media genres to suit

Local languagesStylesCultural conventions

• using new communication technologies

Documents

IBAHRINE Communication and Cultural GlobalisationM.Ibahrine/IBAHRINE... · 5 Communication and Cultural Globalisation ... the supremacy of the market and liberal democracy. ... the