HSE Audit of Catholic Church Dioceses

~ Department ot ~ Heatth&Chlldr~n

I:XPLA.""" TOln HJM I:WOMIlI"OR

II.I:1'OIHS OF ItSt: ,\UVlT OF CATUOLIC IHOCI:s r-s

1 .. <i~"" .. ",,11«1 -.- f""" Ih< ....... " b)-\ho M,ni"'" fo< au ld"" .fY;

();:~lh« lUOS,~ ,he IlSI; ,~..,.... thK tilt f<OOmmtndol"", oft'" f<m> l"'1uif) "...,

I><'oll,mrl<m< .. <d b) , .. 1>01 .. Cbun:h 1_ ...... Thr ~lmi""r·. "'l,."tf=II<O in.

1IO,1OOOl oud" ofC .. ~" ,,,""" <I""' .... Ih< .. ", or"tod. "' .. '0 ,,..,,,ir>< ""

('h"",h', ,"ikl "",,«1;"" p<><1i<<> ..... '" odd ..... in I ... "i,. nll';'~ Fhl "",,.,,.,J

u.,,,,I,..,, (oj ,/0< Prou<""" """ II '<if<r<' of CIU/","- ""r <o,1eI proIt<'''"' and ",<I ran:

«><1«f'" ,hal mipo '~"i8'"

on "'" • 'o\~mb<, 200', tho 0".."",,,., WI up ,r.. Dubhn An;i>;lOo«s< (""nn;,.,..., of

'm<>,ipl""'- On ~ ~",rrnb<t !OOI.1h< ~hni .... for Ch, ld"", ,,""" .. It>< IIS~ 10"""'1

II>< IM,ho "",folK>«'>< C;ommi,.;o., oflMe<tipllOn', .. "",or .. r<r<n«. """ .... 7 ....

I ... IU, '"'I ..... rtho 16 0<_ ~OOI fot. fIIIional .tIIl i, ofc .. holi< a-h [)"", ....

,,, ...... -, .. '-WI

"""" ...... ,,_ ... -.I ........ _c ..... _._ Fn .... ,.,.a....Jo "'".-,--- ± .... __ ... , .. ' .... _ ..... ..

, r._ JoII_" ___ * u",,,,,/o> ,,,-,,, _'"_ ...... ,.-....... ......... *"'*_ ..... IrQ ._IM .. II,"." ., ....... "'~""'_/p",, .... ,_ .. "..-""" ... _ ..... -

1 .... J'It!'<" of"'" II'E .."ON! .....ti' to >to ... I" "'" <k><-..t>tion .. "",hod

1'" "ooool...,j" b) u.. IISl "'.0 , ... pi««! on 4 o... .. mb« :>008 ",Il! Iho ........ ,"""" '" "'" \\ .. ,1<, r .. Child...., .... YOOlh Mr.ir>ofil> «f""I on , .. Clo) .... 6)00;<1<.

1 .. IN- i, rom~"",,,,,, .. m' ...... h, of !l.<hPOUO Clt\I<t> .... Ih< "'pori of ..... aid" ;, <>p«t«I in .... 1), 1009,

\, pan or ... """'om< ofu.. II~E '''''<>lip'''''' inlO 1 .. C~'"" ~_ • "'~ .... i' "b<i"& ond<rtOkcn of.1I ,hild ",-,;001 _ ""pI_ maolc .''''' ,~ in u.. l>i.,.",. ofCIo}n< .... "nK bo<~ '" 1'1'16, ",I>cn '('/n/J &>-' A""'., fb a.<ri/o<' Q

('hwd, ~,_ ' "." Introd..""j b) Ih< Cod-dic Cho.w<h_ Th< liSE <'" II>&< ,.., "", ,,.j,, ",11 b< <ornpl<t<d by ,"" <POI ofM...,h :>()O\I,

7 J........, 100'1 --_ .. _-"'-_ ..... ---_. .. " ... --_ ... __ ........ ..,.

R£I'()RTS 01' liSE .. l DI·r Of C .. TUOUC DIOCf.St:S

.. I" 1.t:' 1 · , , ~KS rRO'1 III \lSTI:R '-OR CIIlI.URt~": 1'0 CEO OF USE

RI:QI: f.STIN(i TillS .. l ·Dr r .

- (SCHEOUU!J

L<t, .. of l~ 0c10bc0. lOOS _ MWII<r r .. Clul..k'em 10 CEO of USE ..... _UOOIIS@ .... _0(<111 ..... ' ......... , o.l

II "',<II .. F .... Ropon· .. '" , ,,-1/

II '-019_. t, .lOOS_M_bn._ .. cro .... IISE 1mklD, T.",. ofRor.....,.. of C, •• ,,_ orln_,pion. ... ilLo .... _ fo< .udn orUi 0<I0bcr. 2005 ',....1)

In ........... ll)_·.~_IISEw ...... "udII~ __ I"-"

(0) l . .... ofl5 )WL<.!006 _C~OofHse to M ....... f ... a.1dmI ,.',IIL "f"IoIo .. ,"." __ r~ 1J)

~'l.daolt2()('--.b'r.lOO6_croolIlS~ .. \I_bClu_ .. "". ·..n-_0I4c,,1; ·no ,,.1$1

leI Lett ... of May. 2001 rr..m CEO cfUSE .. 1.1, ....... fo< a.1:ImL •. , .. furthct ....... OIldoo.r~. • 1,..2"1

\' USe_of4Do< " .!OOIlh.d',. ___ ~-r..J . . hr-<" d! ... ' .11{-"' ... -... .. IM [}o", •• </0.,.,_ • 1"0 __ '''' ""_,,..,-.rll{'-_~I"'nw.or..-.. I. dTW'lr", 1"-JJ J .·,111 .... 1'01""""" >11><111"'''''_ (., ....... _lJSop·· ,1001_....... '_Onolnf ....

...... 0 I 'N' 41' ,,,,,,,-'-I,_,Jj

'-_ ".,..lOO1 &0. HSE .. 0 "_., •• " •• •.•• ,,..,, Jlr

(,u) L<t' ......... 1 O<kt".1007 _ ~ 10 lise _111 .. .-01 ;1.". '~lI ,

( .. , !, .. USE ...... _,60<.\ •. ~' ... n. plhtpJl ,

(v, ....... tIoI<d I~O<_.lOO1 .. D.pw~'''''' rr..m HSEi..!",_ ~ .. 1>00 been _pod fo< foil, . ....... I,..,.SJ /

.". ,,-,_ n AflnL!OOI&o.cm .... ". .., -.. '" So". I 2~ ....... C : .1', Ooon:Io("BSC'C'Cl .. Ii~t ~..." ,""_"","'U,, .-.1 .... ,_...­.. ,lILotbcr .... .- ........ /'qrU /

___ __....._;, ""t~_.· ....... """' .. I

•

Od,bor,2ClolS

H ..... b Servioco~, lIlo<kO.l"Fbor. "-tpI< 0;, .... po. .. c ... "'. ~-.... [lutojioJ

,..,..._ ....... 1b<""""<>f!b< """,",,,. tho _ ... of .............. r_ .n .. A! .hoI .... "'" d ...... on ......... jO<Ibll1IKd <Xl lS (lct, ..... l(lOS. Ai ""'~ _ .. ,......." tb: Go ... "... -'! 1IIoC! "",*,,,_10"" _ BIShop' • ...... ' ...,' ... lhn .. L. ' ... IOdr<......" 0<lIl oot-.-.clJo ....... F .. "",.",kGu;.;.; ..... o{l996 ..... ".c ....... '''", " •• ' """0' ..... I ..... ., ..;J,I be .,+1:.... eo! no Go'OI" oloo __ !hoI!"'oId _. '" ,.,. lise 'IIQ .. "",.Iloiot _ .... ;duoI biaI>:>polO __ 110:

, ... " t ''''''' ....... Ullj>i<a" .. d.

O"'oh ................ " •• ' ,., ...... _ ...... ,"'''''''''. " ~._ "",;0/1_ ->.cd oo<lT«\''''"y"' .... 0' Of~ ... Iho_ k>o,..... sIoould '" inIfud ....... ill "P ora.- TIl;" Jl<'uP """,01 ''''''P''A ,II< Dto<o.. 110 Gorcio I;, 'xee • ..J Llor HSe """ ..-, ... ", .. ", ... .roqr .... uI <1Cn.:aJ child ... ,oaI .t>.nr .~..Jd .. ~ .. It& .. ,..;.,., ... ""'_ \a1"",,,*10 •. = , .. ..... .. 11"0(\01'), I .... ..w ... '- ..... 1ooI1i1b< II$!; __ ....... """_ III< hZt.., '0: '" 1oI""·'\lrn.;) ~;.... Group <nl "' ""U<Il .no! ................ ",," ..... '.',· ... ' .• __ .... 1 ...... ,". ' 'c ____ -. _., ........ ""'-...... L_ ............ "" ....-.... _efi ... ,~) .... -"" .......... 1 1tio/Ia',' ,.1 ._"''''''' ........ ' :ao, .... Go ""

n.. ...... ""'~.<rn; •• ,l~ ,u/r or ,I .. H~~ '" • __ • """"""or • .. ill> ilk .."... __ ~-.!joq ''I'",,:h<1n ... DOtifytho H ''''''''''' "'~j 1"""- .. .. • 0 .. _. It ..,~ ....... 0.1...,. ...... __ il .... ,~ ... ..J, ......... ""'~rl"nor-

l',elT. <lfC <)~hcr n:v<,Jmmernlai kHl~ contained in Ihe T'~p<)" wruch aI'" of impvrt;,,,,.:e lu II "" Ch\lf~h. TI"" "am """'m"'~OOalio, '" ",h;';11 ,,,r~-r IU Ilk;: Church ~ulhorilio.::; (unJ ull"" U'll~IlI:;;lIIllIl~ wurlill~ wilb chil..hcu) 10ft' IIllaclJi:J.

J w~!UkI ~l:;.., like 10 tlmw ,I'mlr OIUentkm lu reoor.mu.n:I;l(ioll E6 which s("I;:::; (ilal c>.i~li"l> ,m u,,~cll'cl1 ls fut joinl m~cslil!"( ion or susr=leJ chilJ """u~1 ubu"" C\J>!C:j

shuuld tr~ 'l'O.,,-e firmly e3lablishcd bel "..:en An Garrl~ Siochar., ~nd Ihe HSE in .;,ruer I" en:;urc err 0.:1"''''') in UUlcun"" unrJ :ll:IL~'livily lu vu.:lilll:!. My urr,club wi II Ix in cunl~CI cC'ilh YUU !iC1",mldy in 1'.'1!"ro III follow-up issues I!" ..... -ally fut It.: HSE a,w.! w CUI1~ul! yuu o!} II", kgi~lulivc " ,\;"n",,~ ,odalio n,; ,,,,bid , ~I'\: kilLg ""L\~iJCJ1:J """ !\Iuller uf lJrl!c,k'Y.

As Ihi!: m~l!:.:r i!; 11"1' uf such Impor.'Hl<:C I would ""Ill<;$( 1:1:11 lhe liSE make Clln'''", wilh Ih,' ,,,JI~ iJuHI bisbu~ a, a ",all~' 0 r ufllcncy II! WIlH"en<;<! "11 awil uf "hi!J pr\.lll'G1 ion pTU~ 1 i~cs and wmpliam:c wil h Hw repurl' ~ l'\:CummenJn( lOJru;, I'l",'~ I\:purl bock IU nl<: >Ill OjOun lI:l pu!lllillk ulk, iniuul 11l""liJ'l!~ 111m: boxu hdJ W>oJ lilI;""" ,,,nngemcnb ha "e been pUI in place. Thlllk ytl" rl!r )'Uur C(H)pcr.1livn in ;:mlluq; in l'Ja,.;c 11rL.:"" IIIoo,;coJure:. (OJ Iry IOJ """'OJ) ~ Ihut ~h;IJrcn will he p'''h:u~J mUr<: cfT""l; v,,;y in Ihe tulOJ'"

Bri;,n LClliioall, T.O., MlII~~I~" "or (·hikll"~u.

1

3.

""'1_ Brmdao 0.­a" ,f Ex""", •• Ofl!ecr _Sa, ",e."""",. B_D,11onI~ ,. ........ S<rmB ........ c...... PartpocS' -, ~ >';o, .. nlc.lOO!

~rtft< .... y .... ..-.n~~""" .. 'bdr;, ""GO'... ') 7 dar"'''' ... S ... ~c flfam ___ ... ' ' .. oIcio1dKDal_ ..... "" dot DolJbo Ar<:bcboc .....

I .... _. CCW'oflbo: "'-~ IDII P',' . lCmIoltt!~ ... lilt C 1'1_ ..... _ 7""" I __ .,..;

-- Ton_;", follo..,.,.._t,,,. .. _ .... M;.,;PFTbll __ o.~"",Ct 1", .. • ..... s.......,. ... u..M+b' ' ........ , .... ""') .... bt _"I -._ly"," prooo:l:no .. """ .. "'" R ...... of"'" !nob Cllboli, Btll:op$' Ad\'t""Y C""""' .... Orilcl SOl ...... _ by _ rod Rob_ ChtJd Sc>.0>l-,-, F", ""Uk .... 0 dI ~ (19M) ..... .,) ''":"q '_.f":=,"doo; ........ .

I, T ... _ ... r.l'-LIlI • DOIlIklll> .. _ lilt 1.1"'.- b 1teaIIb_ :!::iI:It",,'."'C."b, f. , .. dotS-.., ... bo II ,_" 'u,ly

,.,., '. flfll:oof ..... ~ ...... _ .. II:oo,.h.' ... r..)/_.., ,~ ,Idt ...... :~ October. 200~. tbo pOll""" '" ilia< 41", ... ,'

~p.*'" provod< .. _lull: loa_ .,,_,:; , .. ,.. .. , ... _.fclulcl~p ..,. I h .... """':torF ... ', Il<po~'. ,_"""oO" ..... III _b d,"'.,. .... '/If""';' 011100 CnmmIFri-' ThlO TWOO I _aoIoIo:j_ ..... ~ .... i $ , • ... Lbo ..... • , .. _"'" :loLa', , "'" I .. :be H.SE.

; ".,' .... "'''', p';V01<s-a..ryH"F DNmm 10_ )'OIII'.m.: ... Ihn_COII "- .. _ .. ~i< .. d ",""" .. = .. _byllloltSE..,,1 .

_ ....... ,' $ __ .lvory_4P' .. _ .. ; '"

"" .... -_ .... ,,---.---.

"""~<h","nl =1"""'" (wilt< 1'"" ... ;00 of ,1\;1..." and look f"",·ard 00 mertmg YO" .henl)".

Sri"" Uruhm, TO ~'n'!it<r fOf Cn;ld","

.0<1 ..... _ .. : c>-, ' .... - ........... -.----

r 7 = ....... Ik~_ lblllo \tria EornAM

\ll ....... 1.-.1.,. !ioaoo.tJo. o..p.o_ 01 H~",~" CIoololttoo. Howkl ... H_. 0.\011.: .

Clftl«"'tho"'_~Gj I'CCC tk.o!d'I So" .... u.a.n ...

_ I'" 0.. .., .. H",I""". ~.

T~I 01 6J5l31O

F,,- 01 63.'!= E....u _U;"1"""aldl~

I .... 1'1 ...... 10 pr<OYIoIoI 0 1\1""", updaooln "'PO" '" tho fftTd IItpon. ThIo wlII bo ..... ~ Illpoo1l""'_ by "'" lUll'" _ Eua.n .... tool,... p~r M""" ... ~!I\an "" our P'"", ," "' ""~ ____ <en!"-.d In "'" ~ E..a-d P"""""" ] upda ... Jar _ 0/ ":.Ed .... Ito """ IIIp<oo1IW1i1o '" tool"'"" IIwo, .. rA--.·'·Io& .... ....mo.oIWOO . , ... pptoeoIby .... , loop .... "" ....... ." ... _"qo .......... _ ... _k"'--. .. pl, .... _"'" " • ',_oIfftTdoncl ''''0l0i,,. ",_o-d'oD '.ca._ lJi fll .......... Oourdo CMoSo!w-

1,,.. ,wboo-,,,"-"'Hlbot_., ' ..... ,......p". "II-loy = .... ,"'tII<,Io«<>I1cJ.oI '; ,,'"'.in .. _ ...... ' K'o/","!opl=,"'" .., .. ~ on .... fftTd IIIpcn "'"' _ .... ,dod ... __ , nil.,.", .J .. " .... "". _, ... ' 00' ....... .,d" w .. "'" «odIpInod by til< ..... ."., --.., _",_ ,,, ........ otIi<o 00' "" M" .. _100- a..w ..... " wu qro<"OI'~ po", .. d .. "k .... mno""'" of .... ,.,d,,, .... '11110 ..... U<!" d_ pr<rvIdf Y.I".~10 "" ...... """ .. " ....... , .... bo-nt-f" 00' conopl<ol<oo'o 0/ """...-.- ";S "'" ~ .. _"'po<n, .. ly .. ...- opploc:o_ 01 "" po ............. Ito 1NI,"Idu.o\ <-.

H""'",,, .. rloo .. · ... oN, "'''''" II<ports 01 dtn<a1 ....... "' ......... <1>""'" Of

..... o;po<tI"" _~'" tho • ....,!Ion 01 tM Hol,., St, .K< E.«<u",," "'" ....I" p''"'' ..... 11 ...... f,e".d .. iI\.·ahubIt Iot,od_oon.- ... _ ....... "'" .-.pI, _oIOaotd1AooII ... , ... ,'" h' .. ) __ .....,._ ..... own ....... pcOOto and po,..,d~ ..... Tho HS! hod ........ tly ..... """'piu>, pMfOd Iv;' I»' h OMC ... ""," ,n i''''''«'''pl-wi'" r I .. and p,,..od-. ",., __ "' ",.-...,..".,.,. ..... ' d_~loit ... ""d ........ : ,If ....... , .......... + ..... ___ """Wi. 5'.""" ..... pIde-

I """,Id "'''''" add ""5 whllM """to<! bo' .. -""!ndmd1.uol·,,t ,. ond ""'""" .... 0Wd C:-~"""""," .... 01"'"",w"" or' ""'IT_+,e"d -...._ belMw" tM ..... _ ..... ~ ... ft ..... _ I .......... tM -...... 01 >OI51n1otm.t ...... !n<Iud",& """"'" """ .... ..- ... ,_ ..... 1»' _ ... __ , .... 1ormo1>Cn0i1nOt<.~c-u..._1 1M ..... 'nod _ ....... "POi ... ""' ..... lypOol ..... _ ............... ..-.. ...,._add_ ...... po' •• "d ""'''' ............. d u" .. _

Tho ........ 01 QUId .... f .... tM N ....... QIIId. ,, ___ WId WoII_ 0I0Uld.-C .. ,,' .... WId .................... "'....,. ..... ~ ..... _01 chIcIp"""'cn __ .............. <w,udl)< Ioftoc _co 5"-. lor 0ffln.0I0 .. r- own ~......,!.

I w ...... _,....rloo _ Su.ica bo<1I ...... ""'_ .. eo ': ' .... _ ..... , _ III om ....... ""PfC''' tM ................ .....,. 01 o;Nidom _ II" would loot 01 ..... ,..,.,. f{Sl elfie .... .....,.,.1d 1>1 pluood .. ..-)'<IU, 0110<1.110 .. d"""" rloo __ ,"' ........ "d roport.

~9c.\)Q\~,O '""\. "' . ..... ... «; ,ob.,.,[);_

M •• ",)' C ..... "'"Mr .. C ... ';n.ln, Con

'7

""

~~Iil[t~ i

f'~

tf!fli

lO ~

[tlif'

~f ...

..

~ tt

l'[.

• li

t' i·,

~-

I I' i

' ~

l ~

, 'U

lfti

~ I.t [l~Hid,~,~f

• 1!

" i

[dL~

~ nH

m~l.

~hH.~

! i f

I ~ {

11["

",.

-"""

I-H

'"

• i

-1

~ ,,

"~

i ,t"

"'I~t

,[-r

.. '

) •

; •

, ~

.',h

'!.

.!

[0,.

,. >

.1"1

' 1

1 •

, •

~1"~

'!J

~;

I!;i~t -

IiH'I:'.~

1 i

~ i

i I

. t

I -

• niHi

l ttl

mm m

m J f

• J I !

I

,

,'I:t

t:

t~~"1 '

.f

I! 1

," f s'

~9

• §

.

.

. .,

~

;:

c Q

..

==

3

:::,-

3 a !

?, ;g

• I"l

C

o" ~

.~.

::."

",0

g ~-

, •

n • 0

0

a;

P.o .

... , ,

, ,

• •

=a

: n

• • · -. , . ••

., .- • • • • · " • • " . • • •• · - • • -. •

~P'O' __ ~ _ D, .......... CWd COlO \.boq<n' 5d 'IOoic .. onaI)'$IS oflllo .. ; "' ___ ..... ""'_ .. _IIIo ... ok?' if ...... '''', _fI"l<'I" mror-... ot,fllloy_ ...... ty-...ot', . .. A .11" .... F_"", .. _CWd C .. MM. i .. !hoIt M,r, .. otIlloD,obop', =1""" ......... do,,, ,' .. _" 5 11 5'1'" Dr"_, ... t """'0NIy00. A.dllQw< ..... oIt.

Tht""""_ ....... '.l' , •• .-.." .. " . of ... , ....

I CWd' .. · •• P, ", " .... ,iI< ? = !" ? .. ) T, •

Sen"'" I, CUd Pro" ,,' ,. p," II. _ " .. .." .....

AJ? 0 *"<WI'" ....,..'p~'_ ••• CWd '_' __ "50' PoIq'" _""", .. ~f_'oIxl .... _"",,~ "

• o...~o...""", • OU:Is.. .... ~·F' .... L .. kb.CItotdoll.q· ,5(o.-Book) • CItoI_ Ftr1I. ,,_ 0. hl.,,," fi><" , 'nz .... "'01,.,.010.;_ • I\'orlina .. ,tlt CItildtotI .... \'""", hoopIo "' .... Catbolt, Chutch C-""'Y

.. !fd .....

A """"""'" ..................... 0, '" .. ' .............. u ... _._ .... c;,..., BooIt IF ......... -ork fi>< 0 C'!rIn:h 11. ......... 1!196) JUt6cI,- .... Ow o.ldrm 0... Churcll. TIl< HS~ ~ 11\1, Ow 0.1_ 0.... ChI!rcl! i • ........ ~y bout, ..... ,1«1 by Ill< C1oun:h 8,..",... oonfImt<d Iho! ............. poI.<I. hod. _ """"~ ood .... 1 l>H><aa ond ..... '" odd""", I'u!IItoo Oudt pOI", ....... hi." UDpI'COI""" for ..... "f,<1OIOII .... ""-'"1 of ... 1eI ...... _ ,,,,,Mo,

l'1t1J Cod< .fC ..... La. S' 'M""'_ s-o ..... T .. 010 ,\~ P,,,,,,io ZOOI

A okutled, 1 ". ",how pol ...... d",tt,"_loaIlyand,,·hoI_waore>n ~'" ....... poIl<>CS._ ........... Il10'''=',,,, or"l,..,o I ...... prov>.ded l>J. oa:It D . n.... ... t , ~ ...... ~ ... '" wI'.!c¥eI ... 1nIIt.....-.? ,. t ... , ... oa:ItD " .... _'*"""H ................. 1 ",of ~,..;, .... , .... r"_ of_ III< ~ ... ....ru". ... pn<tIOt. ... __ .-............. , .. ,ofS , SofdtoAiIIIn. .............. ~1uf--.f)-tq .... • m yol'c., ... ,_ "ot _"'"' ...... rltt_ot,. ... ., •.. '''"'' IIIoy _ .. , .... lIy " , '.

'1

:=,~,,,,,, of'" •• ,.' __ ' • __ .... 0 cIopOba ..... ,",-._"".blpoWioIt._ Oi' .....

~poalkally .. rd ... __ tl"" '11_",,' , .. " ' ... ofIlloF .... ~( .. " '·B)adlO ... ,"itdddetaiJ ... ~ .. , ' '''' ...... rr 1 ...... II>c,.."~"'~ .... ,, ..... d .. of ... "_""'......,, ' " '.,_ "ra.od Lo ill !d,....., L«uI!.m", I ..... .. An:hb,~ S<:on Brad~ of 000'<>~ ". lOO6.

-.... all 75 Of """"' n .. h ........ dIIloI hoo Iooooa. _ dOf ,F", ..... _ ..... y .. ~!"u-t.Io ... _i S· w ...... HSE""" .... GonIoS' Ie .........

<101>1':' ....................... ,....,...,..,

... _ of_ ..... ,....., by''''''''''' .. ..... .. "'" ......,. Soon< BLOIoops ""'_od mao Childrm r .... tile ~ .. oooolG ...... , 5 Iortbo ,,""0' P ..... w.,~ ofaul ...... (1999) _ "'" ,""""" tho phru< -..;_ &lOy" ........ '.)'1 m..., .... ·"!un II>< ... , ........ta.,. day" _ ","I tilt !CO< h '-"", ""-Iod .. Of

....,,<>011 ofd!.ild ... 001 _ II "'" "",01«>00 of..... "". -"'" far a", da. ..... FIrIIP.l! .... l.~) ......... , 1 w""'of .... clonft 5 .. lMIIbctof 8'*",,_Iboor_'b •• ~of_7n'''ay~ ... ' O"#by"-.. 2 TEIIN" '" III< o.r.dItao 4II.'onyC lice.

___ .r .-, .... ~"""" 011 a. ' of5tmooIIlIIII_of= p -.1 , , Of_ ', ......... _""' .... ,""'* ..... )'" ____ D · i $ liiCI_ !M),,"~._.....,t_ .. ~.n. :5'", .' m'ofctliW_lIIl_ If< ,,,,..lI0II '''''' ... _01Il00.''1100''''',,.,'> ........ 0. t '~ wu .... ,"0' t ..... nil • .., .......... klP'. Tholli""".~ fOld.IbaI .. """ .. _ • ...,....tJ .. ,. 0<1000 i. uk ... 10 P' ':1 cbd ...... __ 'bI .... by .... .. , ..... ,,""ft""''''· w. _= "",.... IlIIIIIbo 1"" t os III""''''' izI ......... 10 .. oIlepd __ if. HSE _"'AtlGonIoS_"' .......... _ .. _ ......... _~."j ,.",. __ boo, "'''11' .. lOr" • • .... 10.,..... ..... _

7'E ... &be r,. .ak pdcI_ and OurCh' , iG Our CIud; F • to_

~.p..o .. -. · ..... 0,': ......... """"' ... ""_".,.. .... _ltIW)"l'_ ."'IISE ..... GoodoI ,.:' ....... ::. :_ .. f ...... _C ..... u .. P' ' coandOurCN'wOurC" .. d"., .. d u.-.ia_C, .r ... ..... 'l<CS : : " , _ 01'1"_10 011 ....... __ -.I all tV • If< _ftod 10

"" GoIdoo .... ' .. liSE-

fO

The......,1)' of,,' " ' " otAI<d 'Ihc)' IIod • ctmd III'" _ -....., ,"OF"_ bot " " .• dlooppo;""'tIlO __ ..... 0 m'_'~ do -. tlthoullt ...... 10",,01<"01:0 ... 111> .... " .... _IOb<.....t.n.~~.o.c.c , tllppllOd«>pICSof,..;n, .... I1tO _ _ lily'" Iho VoillDlOO< o.-"doptllU~ A_ format, W< ....... od",..:IthallIH: TtaIIIIftIP,,,,, ... _""' ....... 01=,'11, ,. 'r'i:ttloo, ..... 1tqIon.

"' ..... " ... of .......... Q : .8" ,' •• , " ,,,& .. ""'-r" p/aoe.., ...... ·'Ihc)'_ ..... deotpalOd..... r' ""_tal .... _, ..... 1111. <ItS, "Fof __ .. _lIIII"fa,oIiDHSP,-.I·", An GanIo So .!. R~..,.,d "",,'_ r. > I, " _ """'or ~ ",!be F ......... "'" """"'" .... 10 """'1',,-. "lib 0.. a.;\dra 0.. Cht.trd>, A14 : '"i<»> .. non, ... tho """''' .... thai .. ......... y In .... , All djo ..... """",cd 10 h>", • • allid """""""" A,d,Ua<y Ponol or. Chikil'fot<a"" ).i_,,,,,,, c.:....nincc: III ......u"" ".,.,_ upll .. ofll>o Billoopo po<IY>ded ,r~d_"" of ........ a ",I ... ""th --",. _<III m ......... "' __ Of ' ''''''yof D RoI, ....... M,· ..... .. htdt_lcddteH$[ ', .. I __ I ....... , "T

IItOI.B,ohop .... y ... _ ... of,I .. iDdteHSE ........ a.dtoS r II ·of k"tLdOfn, ... chiid ....... , I ,of om .. .................. dteh .......... n .. ' ",_IboHSEIooi._ ... I' IbyCitordltA'd "'es.

QuaI_", replJa dcmono<nIcd .. ,. ~ ...... , pt' I· ..... f_oed in Our CIt,Id"", Our Cbun:lt. Cba ..... A .............. odecbct<t ",OL ,J ....... _ of _ "' ..... i<IoeR«d '" ""' rq>l_

...... _< , ,of .............. '· I ....... _iD_ • ..,. __ or ",ow"."'A-' ,01 .,,0( __ "'" n' ... __ ...... ,1tt1ho ___ ""'- """"'fiod Ioeiow' b :.- """

• ~"'" Ouod<l,_ (n._ F .... , '""""" .. """"""")1"'"'+''''''' 1'1"'" 0!ru<1Y '" otder "'......,.. ..,..,'001' .... ,. dte _ of .. r.....,..". o;Iuld....,.

• The SUle .- .. ~Ir '. '" Ihe 1eJo.,0I>m reIJIIU"d on.."., 10 l1tO"foe~ ....... _o(olM It ~ -';o_.r-"plaoe ..... ,,,,,,,"", Ifd-.I

1/

• Eeulr't r'of .... ...r--.IOCI.Ol __ ... tr'k7" r .....

..... """' ..... y f<EI!"E"d.

• ~ ... ' ',.. " ..... C' 'fora 5'._ ...... ...t_ ....... """

• 00000 .... S ...... """"Jh .... liSE _ '" _ ItIo e ....... nu..:t. "'. 'cia OIlEd "' .. i, .. o:blf ....... ..,_ ""' ...... y"' ...... ,,"-( .... 1:1, ....... _

"""""" ... rt

A .","l>«ordN_..-I by .... B""""" __ """"" .... ""'._ """', , r d by 00>",,",,,, •• _ 'I" no RICh ............ dr,.,,~'>", Mr, '"

, ...... Tho liSE. rar ItS,.., it ,""""""..,<l> _ Dc .. " 1M ... dN i ..... or_ of -. .... nll """'" :tOOl '"0 • ...,..,.... l1li '"" I I ......... '!<CO.

1;1.

dendl. A

Audil of C.tholie Chu,tI'I', Cu"..nl Ch!ld PI'OtKIlon PoIky, Pr-.eUCH and P_u'H in campi"'"", with ferno Re""" Roeommendatl .....

1.1 Do.""D: ZOpt.,uzlChold Pwl ""lPoicy1 PIN .. fumotn I CI09J oIlhZ11 POIqIWIIh ,.,...., _

, 1 HH a. ""'''1IOIcJ' _ .. I • .., lOy a. 'to __ ofa.C.II ..... Cto.oa\ ....., ..... " •• baz of .... Ch.lIt _ lOy otII "' ... ", .. 7

13 ...... ~ WI)' _ Church 1><+ I ~ _ ....... tn)'

...... z_ "",.. Idoooillllcz" ''''''' "' .. z"lg oIo:NIcI ... ..... . z'zgz"'-'?

'-0 W aQ pIN .. fl.,,.., t ~ of .......... '" """""'"'"

1 4 I-Iow .. tr:e poIoe)r d ............. *' Icv-z!}.nd".,.., ........... ,."'.., ~ '" _1I'oe1'" poky" btQ\IgIK "'!hi ClentIOn 01 011 PI ........ ,.11IfId "..",~ 01 tr:e /IUtIIIC """"' h5! .. o:onllle! IIoitt\ the Dl<!c I lion an ongoong ba ... 1

1 ~ Wh5!1 ~ _".,..,,1 "1 "' pltc,z '" ......... !hoI •• ~I 01 tr:e OIOCZH .'" _'" of end lie .. ~ the DkN: Illn ChoId --"""

1 e ~ <141_ '-' ,.,.... 0....:77Z .. PIlI to ....,IE •• , the ............... 1 __ 01 tr:e FttnI Rtopon _ rtIw. 'I.;:r<4ly lei the ChurcII A_ MId .. <I4!"h' ,1:10.11 N 77Z PIOI'i<It r.dic.otlw ll!ll&c."

" Do. a. 0I0C11l '- • ........-.. Ttl 01 g!'dll '11. I.g Chid SenoooI "1M'" '_!Iorio "". Cto.oa\ R" 01 &1 0""&7Z&, Of O"'CMdr ..... 0... Church. Of 0..,.1111 Ctft?

13

II No, ..r..t C!'WcI PI"''K''> i pm( I 'ULW ......... (IIIW' tt.rn.n. CCII>Y oN! you: "'Ill<> I'!he ~ dOh, from !he II'wM ... 1IIIitod_11

1.8 114,," roll .... , ... doni to, _l1'li Do , pilon ICI """II ••• 0.. C't I' •• Our ~ C/IIId P,«+ .... P;' _ P''' ...... 1or 1M

"

c._ 0rur<:I! .. 1,,', '" _ .. _!ri' "'III?

VWD NO 0 Who _ ..... l1'li ••• I '''''IW' "'!he CI*I "',.*' .""'51 _ •• "" PIC'" W ""'" ' I , .. 0.. CIo ': .~ 0.. Ch.od! _ .... 1herw bor • _"--..of_.,. C',..., ........ _!ri, 11

In .. _I': II _ • " kfro:Mo 0"1_1 " I IN! • c:t:iII;Il'ow lIMn, or .~, M .. zt,' 5i()o .Id by. ""-lor R"'." l1'li"-' ~ 10 II» HSE lndIor No Gofooj SocN", ('J """""" <IfIoy, thol. wrltWi l1'li '*'I -..:g dO'(/

"'0 Ifno, _yroll7 PIO ... grye. dN<:top\lon 01_"" P'1>C*I ...... ~

-~

22 Oou 1hI Oooel .. how • "''''11''''fod _ 10 whom .~-oot>OnI or I<JSOOCION 01 <:NId ...... , ot>u ...... ~

"'0 Who " Il00' per"",,7 W .... "1iIW'O;I Of qI,II/oIIco,.,... cIoet lIP. pe<won 110 ... '" .... 1iOn 10 ""'" ..... l1'li ~ _n7 How o><a<:tIy _,~ __ 10"" C'<><:1 .. ndzhgIlO7

2.3 f ...... ong .... ~o(cIWI .. _ .... __ n"""'>«:l ....

~ •• "" """ ptOC.dUL" ... ,.,.,' ad '" .... ,1JOn 10_7

2. II __ gtOUL"I<It lot COO_., _ In NIobotr teo on ~ '" ctIIId "XI.", "i77 _, .a.on " w..n by _ Don 55 .. P<OI.a doldo ... """'PI It til _._by ..... ·';1 ,~

2 5 WlIal pnx:ed ....... '. """"ad In ... lab:)n to In .1Ieged .tl<JMr W an "',,"bg.abOn by It"4 KSE ._ An Gardol S~"" _ !hal It"4re is ~ ~ fOf I Pf')MCUIlon DU! .... ~bIe ground. tot r::oncem cent", ... to.J<lSt?

2.ft "1oIowing "" oJoogIbOn 01 child "'>n>aI'bI.M ~ 10 cIeI .. ,,"OId!ha1 It.. allIIQed 8l>IJ_ s/Ioula IIep ._ or takft adrriniWa!lve ....... b<Jt ICIamantly ...r ..... to r:IO 50, _I pnx:eduru .... _void?

2.7 Whal IC!1On os 18kon by It"4 Oio<:ew In ..... Wn 10 It"4 Irleged v!cbm or Io'ia .... _ In lliegabon of seru.1 atluMo n.. been made ana .... """'bIII grounds .xill?

2.8 FoIc"ing an .neoolo>n of ..,x""II""" _ pnx:ed" ... Is IGb .. aa by the Doocese lll>e .IIegecI.-IctIm Of It"4 I~ \O'IaJm', ""renlls) __ no, MU1I'1rSlher ""me ........ Iac! to ItII HSE or An Gard. Soocnalll (" ) 7

2.Q WhaI """"" tna PI""",,,u," a><isl In .-.I00I1 to !he _nng of 1nformI1I0II bemoon "' the ... "'""nl partiH IUCIl " the eM 'UII'Ir:><1Cles, Ihe .~ .-IctIm .rId the IIIeged _",lOr """"" In .leQaloon of C/,,!<l ..,,,,,,,leWoe "". been rna""'?

3) Tr~",lnli

3 1 00<08 \til' 0i<:><:eM _. C/'IId Pri>1""""n T""n!:>il Progremmo? r.1 D No D

3.2 II yes pl ..... Q"'" • lhorI ""'scription of It"4 T ... lnlng PrPg"'''''''''. Pie .... 11'<'''"'''' • co~ 01 the ~ and plea .... Ise IpeeiIy ....., dell-.,.I_ P""OI,ammo?

programme?

"'0

3.4 II IN T ... ",ong Prpgr."""" a>natsten1 ""'" It.. Keepoing S8f. Prog,,"nme? en-. Keeplng Safe lrening ptOQ"'mtIIOt is • module, programme ""''''''''pad by !I'oo YoIIm_ ~ Agency aeoog'- to "' .... _"""' .. on _ 01 chid prOlactoon.

"'0

I:>

" Does "'" Training Pmgrarrwne contain the rna'" elementl reco_ln!he F ..... Rej)O/Il .•. The "-lu,," of chIk! ....... abuse lncM:Iing the lac! !/\at " may I)e

pe~In"ed by 1'6"""'" ~ OUIWard IPPU""" II "... of ptCreuoona~$m Ind ""~_ify,

"'I CO~or'6( "f. """,RIng 11111 .... It>u ... I$likely "' '" .buM. vuO No 0

,"" II'l've ps)d'clogic.ol """"'11'0 caused "' _:

V"O No 0

M DoH 1M treltlinl,l ptOgnI"""- ~1Iy ~,esa !tie P«SOr\&I f.II.PI>!'SlbItrty of IN 11.1" In Ihe Ooo<::e$e ~ -.IIh Childret\ 01 their oblog.abOn 10 """'~ ... llIega!ons and lIJopociona 01 cNIc! .. """I .bu .. 10 !hoi Heanh SIMCe Executive 1"<1 An Gardl Sod\aNl CO) 10 ensuce the "",t_ of CIIiId"",?

3.7 Hallhe Dk>cese olear _ 01 CQndICl "'II~ \he WIly In ",tum Irn",·o.ctoon with dlildf8l\ IhouIc! occur p.a~t1y In fIlla\JM 10 those _. _ "- unlUPe",q.d ..,.,. .. 10 Child,...,?

')

"

"

¥nO NoD .

Slrue'",,,

Descnt>e lhe ChIkI Prcle<:tiOn SlIUCIuru l/tat the DoootM currenll)i h ..... In place and how tI'1e .. relate "' !he deslgnalOd pelS(>(Ylftl for hAndling and rfICfIiW'o\I "iegatJotUl and suspicions of ohiId ... uol abuse and fWfening 10 !he HSE 1_ At> Gordal $_"" rn Plea .. IncI\>de • d'-llrBmmoo~ nopre_~bO<1 oIlhe $UUCIuffI W poulblo?

Don the Do:x:e .. ~ve • Child PrntecUon AdvIsory PInel 0/ • 0u0l Pfo!edoon Management CommIaee7 veaD

If )"8' _ I> !hi. OOltlt~oAed ., terml 01 rno""*">lp, ... Iecb:)n qualib,.",. 0'1<1 elPllf'lll'lCe lor tile roil?

43 Doe$.,... Dioc,"e na". ony other slnJC!ure or PltI1l(l<"ne! in_ "' Chid PmlO<;l>:>n?

If"..~t' ••• ~ VelD

Alldil " " PIee .. ptOW:le, from ~ record .. \fie n_ 01 oomploln!s Or

a!legallOtll AOI'U'11i1 lndiviCh,.1> 01 c:h*! se<uooi .btI .. moodo to 1M Dioce .. 0'1<1 wIIIch 1\10". been brought Ie tile onention of the ,,'-'il ._. ItIo1 la, Health Boarn$lHe8l!h SeMc. Executi'te orJdlor An Garda SIOd'IIIno. (0). (~ .. nolll II1II1 Ihls <JUt'II>On only reQUA •• """",ric answe, o.~ "!'eg • ..",. ~inIlA. 2. IUoga,.",. aglin.1 B • 3, 'I!e\Iot>ons ogainsl C. I )

HI ". 011 comploU'1t. or an.gatiOn. 01 child _ual .w.. made to \fie 0I0ce ... tlMn brwgnl to ".,. .U""tIor\ of tile HSE 00<1 An Ga ,~i Siochana rl?

If .... wI'r'f .... 1 ond...no made tho detemlin&tlon?

5.3 Con you coni'""" Imm)'O", _I. tho fo!1:l'MsI'·

• (. ) The ,.".,,_ 01 Religoou. Iforn tho 0I0ce ... "",,'o'IcI"'; 10, C~ 5 ...... 1 AtK.oIe.

• (b) The number 01 Roligoou. Imm tile Dioc, ... CIJ""nt/y under jllYO.ng.ot>on by tile civil Oulf'oonllll. for ohIId .. "",,1 .b ......

(e) The _ of .lIegation. 01 child .. "".1 abu .. against R&fog ..... I""" YOU' Oooce ... inveOlJOllI"';.

• (d) The number of ohIId Hl<\HII abuse allegatiOn. made og.~ ReI!g ..... ln>n'I \fie 0I0ce ... wIIIch __ M1 d",,"~ reportat>le 10 111<1 ciYti allthori1les, Ind tt.. , ... .," wt>y they __ net d. ",''''' reportable.

• laj The ,."."be, of eNd ........ 1 aou... aliegaliOnl made aga",", Refq ..... In>m tile Dioc ... 10' whom tho 8Begolk>n (I> """" """ du","'; unlounde<I by tt.. eMlo_u?

If) By whom ...... they doemed ~ In NCI'i "", .. ?

11

• (u) WIllI ""*"'II ..... u' ,_ • ...,. _In *'" In "'_ 01 IUd'! Rprg .44? .... _ ..... I.)lDII).M ..

• (II) N8 __ ...,..a.g~ ""')<>J _. I,. 01 ""*" _ I'IOt being ~ by the Gorda oneiIorll'll HSE?

• Ii) In 1M _ 01 ... '1I00I_ ot cI"IiId abu .. 19l'''''' I R.,>OiOuI proW>\! to be unIouncIt<!. """'I ttltil' .re ... ken lD OF Ely. IMI person', good ........ __ ?

54 PIu .. OQeOfy.!rom)'OUt ,_as." ,. OJ ... .,, W' 01 R I ....... """' __ ,..,tlW ('~:" 8dhIO"",...,.,,.o... ,..:Iwno

"' ..... ' .... """""'1 """D" •. • I') Tho ........0. ot _ 1Wog ..... "....., "" Doo 7 ""'" 1'Izo .. -.

.... ,01Cled 01 cI"oiIcI ....... obIM.

• Ib) Tho ,.,mbor 01 tudI Reltgc>Yl Ifom the 0"""" ",....,1Iy un<ltor ...... tog.""" by Ito. _ .UIhotIt>H k>< ctOld M"""' lbu .. ?

• Ie) Tho......- 01_ ............. ' ;.ztoor...- I9l'nllM" PIfSOI'II from Il'II o.oc. .. ___ I'IOt ",. , ,j _oW>Ie 10 "'" """ .<.Chon' ••. ..:I Il'II .. ,' M """y !hey __ I'IOt ,"er, j ~ ._-

• (1) Tl!o .......c.. '" chid ...... ~ I; .... -..do Reiog.,... __ "" ..... \I0I'l (I) 01 _ ............ 7'IaI _ 1" TI' UI"IfIII.n»d by ItIo cM1 autho<I; .. 1

• (.) By,..,.."." _l1'li)' dll"* ...-.Iountod In ,...;, "'M7

• (I) N8 the .. any .(hjgI1IOn1 IMI you a ........... ot _ ... nol bemg or NOw> root _ ""","'9"11<1 by the Go"" ondIot Il'II liSE?

• (b) Tho...- ot.....:l'l "I'; .... ""'" __ """,....:tIt lor child

""","'" •• 7

• Ie) TI'Izo number 0I_~' ",fl'8/iliy.....,.. .... '1tgI1IOn to< ""'Ill ..... "1.""""7

• (1) Tho......."., 01 ,',g ...... 01 _ ......... oo(;, • ...,n...,.. "",,,"iOUIfrom )'OUt Oowcl. In· ... • .... .o.d !lui .... ......-,-.c!.

• (.) The nutI'It>ef 01 chid ..,..... abuM .~ _l1l8I OUCh I'rI; ..... __ IN 1lllegetlDn(1) 01 CIIId MuoN '0"" ha-. "". II ~ In _ cae br "'0" __ tMr dll'''''' ....roo.- ...... _ ""'" IN deteo •• _.~?

, (I) Wt-.1 " ............... _ ...... In pIKe lot l'eIogk>us _ ..... '-' :, "~' : j 01 eNd M ..... ", .. ?

• (g) ...... _ roy ~Ioono N1 you ... _ 01_ ". nol ~'ng

(0. "' .. root _) In~td I)yll>l GI~ """'''' IIoe HSE?

5 e ..... _ ItO\' R"g: "born)lO<O' Doc ,I" _ ..... ..",., _ 01'

... on 'dmlnol~ lee.. .rod "" ....... dong 11>1 ".,,, ........ 01 .~

...... loQIllOn into eNd 18 ...... 1 abuse? 1f)'1ll how """I''''''' _ ... _)WIg ••• 0011' .... 01>1 .rod _ a>o< : I' ....... In pIKe '" """""" _ 1: ' 1'1 ...... '" _ •• In h local ............... II IUCI\ pt(IC«' ' .. _In pIKe _II ~ ........ 1

r"O No D (.) F ...... )IO<O' ......... _ """'Y 1' ,';: • 1mrn)lO<O' .... ·, I', _ __ ::",' 1 IofCl'ilcl M"" MOLM "'''''- __ _

'Mglbonl 01 dlold M""'.too.tM ....... ell:;- I ~' WI 1M o.oo.M 0/ /w_. _ iloeoted?

(bl In "'I ....... '" (.) .OW .. _ """'Y Clln. '1M? _ """'Y NK

-.-.,..-~--- ........ ?

(b) "'-'Mlllta ..... ' l,eatrowll...w:..1N Ooc<;ooM t;\OfN/'OII)' ...... In 1M _'" In<:Iu:lotoG IN .............. _ 0I1UC11 _1

58 WNoI -.ppor1 IndIO< _ hIS 1M OoucIM "",,»pno""""<l ,,, ...-.:tomI 01 ,... •• 1 ,buM .rod I/'4It ,._ Irdudng '''1' ~ _ ..... _ .... ....., wno< pMllDr?

1'1

II) SelKt!"" Procl<lu .... IMI C~d .. 01 Cond""l

6.1. WIIaI prolo<::Oltc 0< pn>cedu ........ c:urNntly UHd by the Doc ... 10 ._ 11>0 ... ~fliIiIy of ReIIgIouo. loci Lly P ............ 10 _ wth cnildnon from I child prole<:liQn~?

6 2 Wllal prolOCOls or pn>cedures, n::Iudng vetUr>g. Ire cu...-y .-.d by the Dioc<I ... f""" I chIIcI ~ ~ to ._ the w 'lobMy of co_tos for the DoooI ... 1

1) Other a_ ..... tions Dr Com"","~

7.1 ..... there .ny other obseMltiono 0< c:orrrnentI)OoJ WISh 10 make 0< 10 DIing 10 the onenlion of the ~Ith Servlcol e. ocutto.. I. PlM of IhII • ...,II?

• For those Occese...i!h 0 Cross Border OImenslon ~.se ,tale WhOthtf repor'IS 1Ia .. been ~. 10 the He.!t1'I Servlcol e.ee:uttve Indio< A.n Gordo' $iOC/1ana '" I<> Hu!t1'l & Soc.II Services Tlulli IndIot P~ie8 Service Nortl>em lrellocl or 00 lIIondn.

,-Qat" .

2D

AWNOI)(B

Rocom .... nd.tIotI. from F ..... Report 1'1., ..... .01 to In ... 1 ...... t..nll\.on'. Ion.. to ..... oM 'z tIop Sean 8,..". of

~-. F$ '"'" CI'uttI _ ... t, mutI _ Il'Ol*' ...... ,g, , .. e ..,..11 ,. and

procauas Fo;o ......... !tial r- prMOiS .... poooformIng ,""K~""'" .nd "'eIy and .... ~ " &oe;t de. l.~· , .. e ..." """"" _ U'6 ........,

Fe Aoowoili'''.of..--. of n I -.. .. hO'* _. 00I11w ~ E.'"""" of 1Iw B.o$i'Iop tN: Ad be ..-""" 0. _ QN MIl ~.

Fl. AI O<VfoNHliOnl ~ It-. CaIFIoIoc Church, ........ opereUont t>Mg _emp40',," """ _,~, AI'd(;()rQC£ ____ -..... .. _ II I , ..... " ... Fo;o _ cNat-an from ._ !rom ..... ,111.

Fe 0z\l.I ............ ~ In ........... _ cI""_ al an~ love! mull be .Iot! .nd n,,,. 1)'I1Oo~ " ~_ ""'"" .Iow II'*m _I willi any PI« I. '" .,,' .... .aIe/y.

Fg ~ and .... r':,rzr ...... """"" "'" dC ... ..-cAd ..... tIN • .........,. of tIIiNWIUI' ~ IN way WI """"" .... _ ""'"

"''''''eo'''''''''''-", FlO '"'" cornrnUllll'\l c.n _rate .. racking ~ ~ ~ Oy

-""!I lilh .... ~ Fo;o All GarOaI s.oocro.an. and Fo;o _ _ , .... utr.....-.rorwootoolO'O'lrO' ',.,jor.611 ElhCoo.21.l, tho P ,t >pof IN O>«E II In ,d .... , Fo;oP(E&'&

F" Informotoon mUlt be "",oro!I""" and tran_.o Fo;o IN tzpptOpt\ot& .-FI2 E.wy.&<1_o.Idbe..-IO"--,,,.o:' ,.ofCNcl M ..... _

10 _ ~ ..... """"'" 0. IagIoII>'Y E EI

F'3 One of It-. p!Incopli leHOnl 101......, loom u-. -''l'A'Y M INiI child -..0 ...... y be pttl>W8tlld D)I ~ of apparlill c/1arm. ln1at1001i'1Qt and t-orwn "pule FNQ....mry ~ M 1Iw rapodln_ ..... ob'I""_ wnrcn _dl o.OI'PO'\InI)'of II ri" "'lie ........... II'tE .... 1oom ftom • : l: , .. ' lWig"

Fl~ TIe Clw:icE" ..." .-y ~ .......... h_ wo'~"" 0_ .... ' ",. NiW>; ~Msad ..... "1 &0 CNcI .... mull toCIo.reota m.~ ~ .. .... ........ -. 10 '-""'--'<! Ihw I*SOi1aI ~ (InCIo.>o:hrog ' ...... 1> ... \!'lItO' ;,---'Ii or .111· ... ) 10 ....... It-. ptCoI""""'" 01 ell: ...

.1.1

Gl. T ... 00: 1 .. ...:1 .... y ~.......", _ tlTopIo,s, 03''''Il000 or .PIIO<tIl$ I*SQtIO II) IlOI<tonI of I'gl'ldlca-ol ~ .... '.u 10 cJOld' .... • M ......... _ of con<II.oCI _long _ II'Utoc:IIng WIllI "oirng ~ ..

GO F_ a .... '11i for NIIOI\ItIg WI'.I:"ItI __ ._ .. .­orgf""""'"

... I' . • e I'»

0."

"

IJ" Ju. :'"

M ........ 8n."Lomhan !JoopartmcN. of Halill .I: 0. ..... H.~·kw< Hwo< DublIn!

>' ,

" \ .. ,

1~1O""""_Dftloo""oMHSE_W:"' ... li>aIol_ ... ' : 1 -:co( ~ Oro,' ~_",pl=7"""'_P"._""'P''''''I01bt' I' 'Mnz of"'" f_luqouy i ' rz 'TT" •• lI><yl~"'<lO 1be HS£.

j .. plouod to rep:n "'"' OIl _p of)'OUr ....... ....... '4" 1\ .. <0l0I S.....",. C"""",no< ODd oppomI<d • ''''''' 'l ........ Tho """""u .. w .. ~ .. ,Ill oddreuinl 0.)1 , __ ,""onc!ouanl reIj\Wul, 0<1100 by HSE ond ... abooIIl .. _ ..... by rcmu", ft,'. proj<CI_"_,

" " To rnz Soro __ ......... • m...·Aaal<YCCF v'=-_"'""'oe,.,. doa..Joll'> 5 ,. Pro-ri

;1, ....... tIoo~i ::177",

~" ,_', ...... ='*'_ ....... ..., .... F ..... Go, .. , ~ .. -. The Won ... Pony GIl Ibo l"'I>l.aly cam .... ,. hal o4<Iil--.lly .,..... ",'Id<nc. of , ........ OM! bcoo pr.",,« ,n"""'" 10 _, .... iDtU. • .,..,_ oad i. ",-,,'011 """,.,\cnnf; capo''''1 i._ ",du. "'" HSE 10 , .... .:1 .. "'" ......... od dommd any ..... pa .... It lo~elpo oni'" 1- 0... in ....... _<a> cf~ F".. 10 .... b .... ofour ""'.'''ZTW', .. pa," ... _."'" t><'lod .. ~ ...... Il00_ ,,',III)'OUr -.. Offia", ""...... AzJ aIIalyw 01_ --'« _1'0< =757'Jlooa ~ ...... it ' ..d zb 5 i .... "'" .. 0( ",1I1~ ..d _ry,q "'" ......... >< ..... "I<CO.; ....... _b ..... __

The HSE ""' ___ -... ". ' ~.... )e _.......-0( Oud>Rop M, .... ondGoodOl. __ ""., .. ' __ 10 __ "''''''

.. _ rod 10 """"""<" ."'_ ...... _ .... , :,'''''''' .. : .... ' S-liSE Safl',!\OIDdyo.ld e ... ~ Iwo".been '", .. at ... 10 Iw ..... '" 'uho' .... • d,,, = basi. ODd, .. )'OO .... , ....... ","'" "'""" """"'" "',110 "'" "'"""'" 0/1"''''' Il>tm or ..... '""PIIO'" """ ... ,.,,,,, ........... 0100 "'C1 uI tho 0.- '... 'w, _ _ 0_ """""""" '" """"I ... tho Io<aI iIrI ... 41 'ct' """""' ..... So .. for !be n .. " ..... lup of "'" """""'~_ .. ott """""11 oho!< ... ..,. '" c.. .... " .... of 11.010_ of IfdIa>I (CORl) ODd doe InIIL ),j. '«)' u_ INt.:"'~_~ ..... ~ ..... ., odoImf) '... __ ..... IIwy ... _10<0II1'.', ' .. lIIrIor Ooc;..

",,:::,~_._."7 __ , __ . ., ".-.. _.-~_ ,,'a __ , 13

Al",_~ .... D I .... 'mrz_ ........ , '1"'o( ..... .-..-.uSed by ...- ",." 1taIf. o....cto __ .... tilt pnI&i, III jIO<Uad., 11>0 rut "'" ..,y dioao .. _ of oI1ep1 all ... III ...tod: "" Ibtrnai """,,1 .. 01 hal boa: ....... and wi'",,", ...r_ 10 tilt oI1ep1 ........... ,II be -. ... __ or ...... ) •• ,,"" III odd";.,,, :1:0 1"',' I ~ 1Iloo :1:0 tnu. .... .....,. c ........ _ .... """'" oil "I., or_ ...... _:bcy ... l.--. >bIy ........... .....toIoy ..... , __ lObe .. IjI.le ......... y ........... I' " ....... lI,n

s,· ,'ytboHS':;' 0" 'I 1' ..... ___ .... "..,.,... ..... -.d .. ""tboDqr '" Ia ,,2' ___ ..... :1:0,. I I.....,of ....

_" ..... COIIid_be'd'- _loydooHSE .. ""'·' ,,,,.""k, I ...... _ ._ "po ' ..... HSE -' :1:0 _" or., ..... b.ab<lny. AI • ...... I on of""'_ = .. of ....... _ .. ,.,......fM ........ , 'f,..,'SO .... ..,oII .. "=od..:e.....-y -.. to.......-.le iIIo S ..... "'k Ii> <10 iIo, -".1 ..-",..;ry,,,, all pam .. III' I to, of:.p:"""""- Unfomma:dy I ...... 10 ... ,_ :hM ....... i...aure ""' ..... d """,,,,,. _ ""', I ... IIy Lht HSE" _ ... potO'_ to _I,.., on''''' If'DCY OOIIlmlnees ..... .......-I by .... F ..... 1nqui:y """ I ........... 'd : )'OUI' IUrthcr ""'Im ... "" !los.,., ..

.. .... " ... , Ii> Ib: ... """ ofCllordl C:.IoI ,." w" 1'0 .. <> ..... 1', .. ill .. """ ? ... ""11,::, ...... r .... 1Joq..,-1t I .dnti ............ .-.....,""

I Ioy:l:o liSE -..I C ; '01 0!!ia0Is _ will ... tI_I , I ....... y. led I .... 1 , of..to, ,. I ,I' _ ..... loy I, _001 _01, -..I cIr,' , -abimd, ',_ ............. _: ... ".",11>0_ ......... n .. _.......,:hM "" ....... _ P'" ...u be ,""p'" iii Lht...,._ ,..",... Dnt ........ CIuld c .... ~ ............. _ ............ iItdl....w I:uhops iii

~-III COO'Id_ I ""'" to ...... ,... ofLht liSE', __ .. _ .. r.....,-d,n, IIOd ....,.....,'. _ '1ft"' .... .".., .. ClI! ....... IIOd Y_ .....,.. ond...- "'U"' ..... Ii> ,1"_ .. ,:1: .. 1 _ "',....., 0( tb:s obJ'''''''' lin' ,-.dy:l:o Fern. ~.1" ... ~"'" tb:s ..... 1100)' "'d! b::vc .. be sob •••• ".iiy_n.: "' .... hlb< of """ ---. _Sed -..I .- .Y oI"m .. ...... .....to po I h!O,..... 0.,.", = III IIwo ~ 1 .. _ ... oIol.,"" if,... ..... _ ' _ _ n ... -.lod>_ ... _doI:iIIy.

" • • f ...... B ...... :>no ... l10Mf r,. ... ,;" ()fIl<..-

~.,_~,",_,.· ..... _' __ n ' ,'0.-. __ ._ • , 2.«-

p .... t '

""":I'~.~~~",~~ sw.

". _, __ t, -----, !lou",., '

."

_ ..... em

--' p, _.,r.,£ 7 T c-r., .. _.

~,-::::~-=-... ,---.-".--'--.'.,-.. ,.

F-a"r __ ... , '._ot ... E.-"'-'~""''' II • ___ ..;u ...... _, , ............. __ .. _-,' __ 110-,' '... ,d~c.o. ......... ."" .. ,. £0:,0<0 ,w, _ , 0...

'---'" -, ~ -

!. ,

NIX Ill/I

f<\ay , 2007

Mlnlner Brian tenlhan T.D., Minister for Chll<l~n,

'" ! '"

DelYrtment of Hulth and 0111<1."", Kil<la .. Street, Dublin 1.

t' .t

Furttw II> mv IMe' (It the 12"' C> "*, 2006, (COl'\' W"'*') in I· U.·' of the ".... ~ ! W!s/III> _ )'IIU of cle\rl>j".n ... the inl6 .b'ong ... kxlin r ....... tl) theIUM pm'

AIi)'IIU "'-!Toe HSE _ Nqo '-1 til on;ier\!oq ... ...tI of d'IIId "",. I." ", .. tICEi _ comP'iF'CII ~ the kms p·re's ~ ~ the oto)ea 'O'tS 0I1hS aud;! _ til _ an:! •• 'orm thI MiIIIItet for O'ooldren In con>ideo .... ..toed.· or not til ..r. 6ocF'M tl) the CommllSlDn of !~ set uP t7y the Go>"'JM<!~ Parallel wIII1 the deI,·eb)ll.l of tho audit sognofiCllnt Fe9a1 _ ~ enc:counterm wIIId1 "'._ tho HQ/tn ServiCe ExecJtive from ~ the I~ Convnottel RNCtu<e , ..... ,0..- In tho""" Report. FollowIng de\3oOtd COtItUItItioro wItt'o)'OUt 0WtI ~ It _ ~I :IOICF II> '" "!II I . 7 &III! II.dot of '" IC\Xft _ Iho: _ of Ihr WI"*,, IIg;II .. _ ..... II> tho !nli! ..... -.cy CooI".1 II wib1UlCl II> tII..,. •• 18d t7y Ihr ~~I.'" In _....". the ()I!'Q 01 the Attoo .... <>-r .....

A <IfQoJed II.dot tool _ <It, i lll> ..... a W_l _ "" ... 121 .. _ iT i lleil of It.: 0IurcI'I'J CU"1tII'II d'IIId "', .. ..,.., POkY, 1QCt •• ard ,,"-<.no. (Copv _ for liEfe .. ce.) n... .....,;t Q'l71ioM1ore W/I$

formally 6$1e;! to thI Bistws _ RiEIigoc:lls 0nIers an 23'" Oi'!IIbei, 2006. WhOe """'" 01 the ~ SOU9ht he< beIlf' 1cx;d.ooI, ~ he< no! been pgalb!l1n .. a:tIu til progress one SectIon (I.e. Sed:ior'o 5) of thI.udot. The majOrIty of BisI'o:ops ,...,.. ,..sed ...,itIuI W,,*,'6 MId _ thI f1u1tll SeI"Cll « .... me -. w!'IIIIt th!Iy __ an.Ioo.D til ............. iftIi fUIy, In!l>e ot ... oflhr .... i ~R_~t7ythe"....~iIIey~ UNIIIe 10 do to ... 1ft ' 01 S iO'l 5 of the _ 'Ihif $«1 ..... , fOI9"I.

1.1

""til le~ WIfotmM>on on 00I'I'Ipta1l1tS _ ""eiIabonI oJ child _ ,Ilvw .... 1IISt memben d IN! defVy. ""lid ... these a~ MI;I or !\ad ncK

been bo:oughI In lilt 0ID1tJOn of \hi! cMllIItI'IoritllJ...,,!he "'''~'''1fS ~ In tI'IOSII « .. ::eo,,",,. The ~''"_ .....;ot. die! ncI ~ , ..... ena: In .diM, 115 bV I"IIOTIe.

The 8oSIIOCS"'" , u.. SaIlOi1 5 po p" .. :ad insu~ cIifI'oculbls in relation to o:onI'.denWolity and. ito u.. atn-a! of'~ ""." ..... , .. ,!S bewIg po.( In pIac!I In -.... ~ of ~ ,b" J in IN! AucIoI _ p. .Wli: _ "'Jetq ~ Group " -. ..... ttoev __ I.O"IICIe to w,..- tho! oect:r of thI _ <Ii '0 ....... _ ncI I 1''' ""r 5rfO'!I1O tne toll !: _ in !he &sI""'" ~ w,apa,,""'''' Imr F

trill. _lUna! was ~ on 'X'lttj"IIIIII_.

T1"oe .... ,'& SeoVa p..._, ~. l ing COf!S' .... 1OIi wllIl rour OWI"I DU' ~'.c. ,'" .... , In -.nee CD',"",," oJ the AucIoI _!he I ... _, d "'1'" 5. TlII!' • ... "" Ihe 0. i ,_1! sougrc JnronnaIoon on Il.dI ~. PQk>es, 1)o'O?(o""!$, ItnICtInS I!"Id b ... 'O. "" ~ d!he 16] Qo.lltOMli_ '«I',-i!d from B1fhopo """ P'roYInc.IIs oJ Otl*$ If ~II'/ DeIng Ul"ldlrtlketI and my ofI"odIIs wil f<l/W1ird a repott on !;he ~ In rour Oepanmonc on wwietb\. Ikl_. l SIIOo.oId De nateoI u.. II. tIllS .. tIllS ""'"" lOll \iItMOe • Itock like d .,.. ... i:' po'" ....... W\iCtInI_~. 5i , ..... 5 db ""'* QJ i· ........ ... "'10" ;* ... a ~ upon wnocro to ...,.. t...tt...-~ .. 'a ..... .. II;>

CQIIll)ioJnCe WIllI en""""""~. In !he .b ...... d IN! itrfoormetoon SOUOi"lt on !hIS Seaoon ~ will not be J'CiSS'bIe to ~ ~rt\itle tI"Ie apr>"'!.I(In of !he 1)oOC«I<.<e in reIevIr( ases.

On tec:tol)i' d the ',tll)" w'a ..... d: ... !he "n't7', SeoVa e.;o_ 1OU!Iht lIS ""'" le9IIiId.1U which I II.lId"I. The 11917 ICMce M!tS out I)i'll:lib7e tJ(lOOn$ UI> II;> """ ind\r:llnll iegtsIatMI chi,.. CaunsaI did d:feo: an alamative to ,"""sIIt/ve d\atIoe 1/"1 \tie loom of. oorI\def"Coaltty ~ Ho._. t 'Ih<ot,okI be nateoIln!;hls 0WVI0'd tho! Ouch _Gi' en tw.. been _ .. ...........-" pp''''''' __ », by !he Gardal.!he Her,., s.Moe E .... "-.. _

rour ""'" otf' ''''. oJ ..,..,......, II J 00 !he !wl I· ..... po '" tI"IIt InI! Ftms Report 1"01'< i t In tho IgtoI oJ !;his « " , very !ME W'ICe'fI tI\JIt to embarlt on !;he ~ agtU"". ItIW! """'*' ef\QII ",oJor,ge:I !eoaI doscua,,,,,,,, """",odeort on unaNonouJ '~a5 of Bofhopo and ProW-.daIs. W't/'IIIO 9\*IIT,ree oJ. tatDfaauof ouu:ome. Su.:l\ III ~ _"" ... _ "';1;7 .. eo( to dIQ, :.ct. Ihe ... Ii1 of W,O: i',,"y ~ Pl$5IbIo! .....,., 0Ihe0" ...... <aj '7 NotwJlJ<sU,,:IioOO!he II"M""l sa 1M WI 1M ItgII aa.a. the liSE " w ......... __ NIlrI be oct.... .."m<s ' pe.I\aI)$ t!"itoI.OOh _ of Ihe Coowntnoon Of 0Ihe0" boW', wI"IoCFI ""IIi"It addo_ !he outstIincln9 I/lforInatIOIi SOUQhI In tho Audit. It may ,Iso be that WI .,." '00 !he _ Ssues d ..--In; "'* 89*'"'1 ce/I*>u1!Otl and """'"'-tM --...; on 1he'0le0 i d child :ke _ "' •• '" i"., 17IIl 'fOAJI ~ NIlrI ~I 0;0, -.- ways oJ.."." '00 lilt ""bO.IJar dolf\r;oAJes ~ on "SOfd oJ S im S of thllII.O!.

In concIuso:lto, I o:onsdeo«l l in''IlOItao'll to ~ you Qtl de'<!'!>,JI'.oti SO tl'ItI: Il _ 1 ....... 111e ~ W_iKIOO. d!he ~""""""'I " .. uotv staoe. "lInNe, ....... W1In.oI to 1'109' eN ~ d IIIe ~....., qo ' ; ....... n, "' leie.1ei 1'1'1, meet w.u, i:I>I! ~.1OpI IniI PI'ovInoIIIs to _ II\eir IIOSI •• i. We III'mage COIIdudlng !his as 5;11 edily IS possible cY« IIIe __ peo1od foIoMng whocIi ... wjI be in I i><M\C)I to ~ you ....uo I t.iII report Qtl ... 110 do 'IJS.

You", sinu .. ty,

I'n;ItHsor B .. nd.n Drumm, Chltif heciltMo Officer.

~ <II 1hI II ' • 001 0."""" <II PCCC _$, '''''(-tee •. _'oIe,OrS"" •• " " .. , -.

.., .. ~1140 Lo..p..d.

.... i ... "' s.,;'''''l'. l)pp ... ....... of 12 .. Il~ .. C~lId .. n,

I " .... ~F'''J: '" _h ," ? =_d... , .• , ..... ".-.,: ......... , ......

l.t 0' F, 01

...,. "'.",... !hr '"l"'" oJ .... 000I<I "''''' <2' • 1"'''''' ...... "'" ~_ .:1(10 ..... , ....... M, r.: Ho"y, .... .,,,'" ),,"'."'., n .... "" ,t:;!' ~'"

, ~"" "'''l't.,l ,ho ", ..... ""J 'lV'w , .. 210 ~t.. 'In'y "~pmonl' r", ...... _ •• , ... ond ....... J~, of ..... ,,~ ... , ..... ...."J, , .m .. /om"",,,, U ... "' .. "" '0 ,.,. ,~.",""" '" 'Ie.oil~ ond ('hd,J ........ " .. I ..... , .....

Lo ....... M < Gu,ntI_ 1'1 .. 1 ... ,,10; ......

1'ri .... '1 '::0_00;:1''' 'onion •• ". , ...

3D

-

•

ibid! StliU f. "he

gil .... _

_ a..-... "i0 I ..... F' . 41l11ow .. . I'CCC gl:w"".:o, 110' .• '"" ...... -I" ... ,'.,,--.

01Il0001 ........ _",, 4101: -~110 ' -, "",,,,15' o .... o..y. -

,,", 01 .. oICLe,. --I ••• 1 __ .7 ....... I I , 2 .... __ .. ' ' 1-"'",,,,

7' I ._"'_~,P" . , .""- ,."._.­_'"' ; ,-.-

,., .... 0*0, ,w" ., ... _ _ V ... L ,DOOiII C- "i ., .- .......... --' ... ' _1 __ ..... .E • ...., ...

" ...

1_ ., .......... "" __ ",. ,..."' ..... I 4"' .... """ _ "".W __ '" --Y-.- .. ,.

,.THULY • •• __ e ...... .

50<"", peee P"utoro"

•

3 z.

1'6'.. t,.w.!j,f_"'" IIeIlII So.1tt !Ecllht

Report on allegations of child sexual abuse In the Diocese of Cloyne and complaints that the investigations of these cases by the Diocese

was Inadeguate

D!!I of "pori

2ll1I,'2OtlII

,

33

T.bl! of Cont,np

. "

1 .. _, R_ .. ..--__ ... __ ...... D 700_Of ....... _

_ ~_ ••••• ~~ n ... CIoont

• 0.',,",," 7 _ .....

"",: ., 'd .... , eo. _ .... 0... __ '·2 --'" Do. , •• , ..... _~._ •• -_

II'" 77 • .~ ____ _

~--. . , .. ._-

-•

'-"

3'1

' . ..... " ,,'," ..... og"""' .......... ."d,,4O"""'0..0 .. ~_

...... _ ...... ,,: ~""<11110""'" _ CItIW __ ' .'44' .b>. """"'" Ik;: ,,('~_. , ",* "'q .... -. .. _

!. WotmaIIoo,.._ ...... DI ..... ctorno

:I. ec-"""',_ ........... ~ COO Tho N .. -'-.s ... ___ '" C,"' .. , .. tho~ .. a...,,, ..... , ........... _,.,. '00. tIv_ ,o. ",,"C .............. -

•

,

, ,

•

, "n1

eDI Pr.

IN '"""I' ... D ..

• Co

•

•

,

·' , .. _ -. ...... _ ..... _ ....... __ .... ' • I

..... ,._. , .... _... '.'__ 1_ lOr " 2'" - .

- I, , ,

" ""'"

~.-

... ........... ·P'· ' ' .... __ ..... _ .... ___ _

... _ .. • 2 ... C>otI __ ",17 .... I ...... 1 I ..

,

, ,

•

P " I , 'M '

All' ,~ __ ... ''''_''' .... _(. ''''N ""0. , ........ .... '" ... _ • "' ,(CIIIlI 0;.. " a 4 ) ... _ .. ""'" .. a _ '" _ • ... _ Ii' 2 ....... 0 .. eoo,no

...... = lodw""'" .... Poi ",., -

•

, • • •

•

,...... .'" __ "" _ .. _ ..... HIII __ Iht ,---........ -~"" ... -,.--.. ,_(__ ha<l) .... Poi .. _ .. " • ' •

, • , 'f

'"

,

•

\

•

,

•

Ito

7 " I

""" OW., .. '. 'w ..... D'~_,, " 0.,... __ "'~' __ "'w, ••• , •• ,n _ .. , : .... -.......

TIoo_ .. _____ w_ , , , •

9"'0 1!III!!na' phb!hl "W:I ; au. "y M· ...... m ........ C ,, 1". T'Ioo ... 5

, , , ,

, ,

, , ,

9"· ....

Tba'''' ,c.o " : , •• Ceo", 55 ... __ ... a...:c.o "'P',,~".n. '... " ....... _Cc;o;(HdPl '_ .... 0 ... ~_. """_"_Pi ..... ".,._ .

• 41

Dop'pn ... 01 • • : '''!on~p''a

"'CVCI"., OurCl!ur<f(", n ... _"'-'" , .. _.w~,.'_. __ _ e· ...... _"' ......... 'p • L .... , , .... _

..

, , . £7 72'777""

Fho ... _ ..... -..._ .. _ .. _ ... C

'. , , •

. •

"

,

"

..... _ .. -,

........... _ .. __ ... 0 ' ..... ;oF.' ,.,. ... C' 01 .... ___ ... _ .. "'c ..... , , '''_''coo,' '"""' __ '" "'.", ... W-

"

•

r

---.' • "5 •• , '

--... _-.... -... __ ... --i

I

" . . -

,

, --_.' .......... "'- -......... __ .. _ ....... __ .. -... _ ... ----_._-.,.::.:-:::-----_ ... __ ..... --_._-I, ~--'--:~=.:-=- -.... __ ._-- .. -.---_. __ . . -:.-:..,-.-_.--_ ... -_ ... _.­... ---_ ... --

,

I

,. -

';FJ-__ ',...-..,. 7 -.. ,-, -.,.,.. -

.---.-:-~ ---, .. --, •

• • -

,,- ~.­......... -. . __ .

----•

'-.

-.. , •

I

I

I

-..... --"~"::: ~:;

,~ ...... ""

I!!!!!'. ~ .. -, , ," . - ....

-

•

.. , ... ',.

•

,. ----

-

•

-

I

•

• 1£

.,',;:'::1\=',,-·-•

I .,. --

= --''-'----", .. -... _---"' ..... " "" .. .,.., ........ -.:

." ..... __ .. ___ • __ n

-.. . -""~ .. ~.-.....­~--

t ... 1I<r "' .... _ ,"""'" I<I,~ ."", ... iooL I ..., ....,n"" .... r .. I1""' ..... . ", .. chof~ m;oN,.,W IISI ~onhCcn C'loIldC ....... _, .... T ..... .. ,. _ 1"«'<,,«1 ,,1lItr • r.x.n.t .... f<>rmo1 "."r._ r""" "" Gw<Ia $«' . Of

_) t<dni."><01 .~uthori ....... ~ .. \IIc........t>Ddi ................... _

rr;.; L ........ '110_

So

-----,"-'.­_ .... -,. ---,---,~-=;;'-'" ' ~-- .... - .. -.. _: 10_ ... '_.-',_ .... · , " --._ .. _ .... -_ .. _---_ .... _ .... -'-_.

,-,,-,-;.:;-- ,==~ ---, -----, --. ---- ----

5'1

I:E '~;~7" __ ---... "',-' Of

' .. _ .....

• ---..

_ .... _-­-­_ .... _ . . --__' ' .u_ -­"­.......... ~ ... " ...... •

,.,.. '" ,.~.-->

57 51 .J. . "57 ~

". -- .

, .>

'I' .•

• 1..

--... ~ .

, • 51' .­" . •

, - , - ,.'

.. OF J.. .• _

,."~' '-:' . ,.L4 ... tJ.,. ... -' .... '

" .

1£ ,.,:::' .. -­---

--'--'" '.' :

,_ ....... _ ....... .-_ • .. "n 7 , __ ........... .-<Ao .. E

55

''''' -,. ... , ... "001. & L2 &05 '(Io2rrCOICj" .... "' .. _ ..... __ ," . '0" oo2C •. ,1N~''''001

-. ...... 21101'1"

T.. _V_" I "ewoe- uC c.c, FWO W .. C..,.... __ .... _ M

__ ,~~'_~_aa ..... __ ~ "'"_ , ... ____ ........ 0"

" ,.., " .a .

......... , ~r'", •• , (1odo .......... 0!IUr) 00 _ or ..... o-,.(C _ ,,,, ~ 2DDI11:0I ,., _ .... ". ... , ,j hltf.O "Oo<r>o_ £ wOO 7 i' • ,--_.

___ ...... _ ... ......, ..... 1 ..... ---...... ,.,.. ........ _'.- .. ...... , .... ",':I .. 1_·'" ",I.' "I _ CII .... 21IOI 11111

'e," 0-,.1' " IJ " ..... 0

IW ... _Do I 1 ... o.y..o..... I ..... ".", __ •

.......... Do ' ....

'-'.'''.

-eo ' .... ___ .... - ..... ' .... '" Y"" ... ,,... """ ''''' ""' .... «1<'0<1_ .... ")"" ..... -' .... ""G""""" ... _ ...... _ --~

",,,"' 1M _

Sent:~ ...... ,7.lCOIZ'12 PI< TO:_I_ ... Cc: .. '''''' .......... , .. . Subjto:t'_<lfOoyno"",,-- ... ~,r; ,",~

, ... """ ... 0 • ... :I<lrotwuary_ .... _....,..."'''''"', __ ."""'''' .... ".. 0' .... ... _ ""'..,... no!" ...... C&>O .... , .. "... no! ___ 10 ,,"' • "."...,. ...... , ''''''' on n. "" •. o! .... _._"'~ ... _,' •

__ root, _.-",onoOl"-9"""'" """*' ... -"_.''''00," ... 000>:0 .. _,,_ ...,.c_ ............. 10 .... _. _ ....... ...."._' ... 10 ___ ..... _ ____ . "1'_. _"""" .. _

Ch>01 E>oeuwoo 0I!0<cr _u., . __ be-... C_ Ctourctl '" .,.,.,.,.

OS II ~r"l 55