- 1. Regional AE Conference Wilmington, North CarolinaJuly 26,
2005 REALTORS The Do-Not-Call Law Means You Telemarketing e-Mailing
Faxing
2. Part One: Do Not Call 3. Telemarketing Definitions
- Seller:any person who offers to provide goods or services to
the customer in exchange for consideration.
- Telemarketing:a plan or program or campaign which is conducted
to induce the purchase of goods or services . . .
4. Legislative Background: Telemarketing Laws
- Telephone Consumer Protection Act of 1991 (TCPA) and
accompanying FCC regulations.
- Telemarketing and Consumer Fraud and Abuse Prevention Act of
1994 and accompanying FTC regulations.
- Do-Not-Call Implementation Act of 2004(effectiveOctober 16,
2003)
5. Previously Existing RestrictionsPursuant to Telemarketing
Regulations
- Calls may only be made between the hours of8:00 a.m. and 9:00
p.m.
- Callers mustdisclose all material informationabout the goods or
services they are offering and the terms of the sale.
- Companies are required to maintain their own
company-specificdo-not-call listand honor consumer requests to be
placed on the list.
- Companies are required to havewritten policieson maintaining
their do-not-call lists.
6. Restrictions Pursuant to the 2003Do-Not-Call Implementation
Act
- Congress gave the FTC a mandate to create aNational Do-Not-Call
Registryfor residential numbers.
- Telemarketersarerequired to scrubtheir calling lists against
the Registry at least once every month.
- Telemarketers and sellers areprohibited from callinga phone
number listed on the Registry (exceptions exist).
7. Existing Business Relationship Exemption
- A business relationship based upon atransactionbetween the
company and the consumer within the previous 18 months.
- Or, within 3 months of aninquiry , application or request by
the consumer.
- Prior written permissionto call.
8.
- Unsolicitedautodialedorprerecordedcalls are prohibited to any
cell phone even if there is an established business
relationship.
- Personal cell phone users may add their numbers to the DNC
registry.
The Truth About Cell Phones andthe DNC 9. Exempt
- Tax-exempt non-profit organizations (c)(3) not (C)(6)
Note: The regulations only apply to residential phone numbers.
10. Compliance Requirements 11. Telemarketers Must Register
- www.telemarketing.donotcall.gov
- Provide name, address, Federal ID (organization profile)
- Designate a Contact Person
- Certify that your company is in compliance with all
telemarketing laws.
12. Database Access
- You will be given a Subscription Account Number (SAN) and a
password.
- You may download the full lists of five area codes and purchase
software to scrub the FTC lists against the numbers you wish to
call.
- You may check up to 100 numbers (per log-in) interactively in
groups of ten numbers at a time.
13. Cost
- First 5 area codes are free additional codes $40 each (proposal
to increase to $56)
- Instant access to lists when paid by a credit card
- Must renew subscriptions annually
14. Transmit Your Name and Number:
- The FTC requires telemarketers to transmit their telephone
number and, if possible, their name to consumers Caller ID services
for all interstate calls.
- A telemarketers use of calling equipment that cant transmit
Caller ID information is no excuse for failure to transmit the
required information .
- the FCC rules prohibit blocking of company information through
a caller identification service. The Rules further require that a
business must provide a number in the caller ID where consumers can
call the business during normal business hours and make a
business-specific do-not-call request.
15. Safe Harbor Provision: calls made in error
- You will not be held liable if you have in place and practice
the following seven point office policy:
16. Office Policy
- Register with the FTC and create an Organization Profile on
line.
- Adopt written office procedures for making sales calls.
- Train your office and sales staff.
- Require your agents to scrub any numbers they have against a
current FTC list before making sales calls.
- Check agent compliance periodically.
- Maintain your own agency do-not-call list.
- Be able to show proof of a registry update within last
month.
17. Is There a Limit?
- There is no number limit to the "safe harbor"
protections.However, note that safe harbor is for"inadvertent
callsto a number on the Registry, since the company's policy should
prevent all calls to these numbers.So, if there are numerous
"inadvertent" calls, then the Company probably doesn't have a very
effective office policy and so is at risk for being liable for
violating the Rules.
18. February 18 thFCC Order
- Prohibits calls toFSBOswhose numbers are on the Do-Not-Call
list unless the real estate professional is representing a
potential buyer and the purpose of the call is to discuss the
potential sale of the property to the represented buyer.
- Real estate professionals are not permitted to callexpired
listings(with whom they do NOT have an existing business
relationship) orFSBOsfor the purpose of offering services if these
numbers are on the Do-Not-Call list.
19. Home Business Phones
- Y our call to a home-based business should be related to the
actual business being conducted in the home if the number is in the
DNC Registry.
20. FCC February 18 thOrder:
- In issuing this Order, the FCC made a strong statement
indicating its unwillingness to consider further exemptions from
the Do-Not-Call rules.
21. Creating ConsumerExpectations
- AReasonable Expectation of a call backis the standard
referenced in the comments accompanying the DNC Rules.
- If you register consumers at open houses be sure to have in big
bold letters: BY PROVIDING MY NAME AND PHONE NUMBER BELOW I AGREE
TO RECEIVE A CALL-BACK FROM THIS AGENCY.
- If you use an automated system that provides information on
homes and captures the number of the caller (an inquiry) you are
allowed to call-back for up to three months.
22.
- If you have a VOW andin the "Terms of Use" agreement state: "by
registering at this site you agree to receive calls from this
agency" it is possible you could call as long as you meet the DNC
requirements for gathering consent.
- You will need the consumer's signature and phone number for
written consent to receive calls and the consumer must have a clear
indication that they are consenting to receive calls from the
brokerage.
- Since electronic signatures are a state law issue, it would be
wise to work with an attorney.
23. Statistics
- 85,000,000 numbers have been registeredby 60,000,000 Americans
as of February 2005.
- In 2004 . 768,677 registered (GA), 689,181 (NC), 288,023 (SC)
and 654,784 (VA).
- 2004 reported violations 15,649 (GA), 11,478 (NC), 6,393 (SC)
and 25,580 (VA).
- 78% are reporting far fewer calls or none at all since they
registered.
- Since the regulations were enacted residential calls have been
reduced from an average of 30 per month to 6.
24. Upheld US Supreme Court October 4, 2004
- A telemarketers right to free speech is not violated by the
governments do-not-call list.
- The do-not-call registry directly advances governments
important interest in safeguarding personal privacy.
25. Consumer Complaints
- by phone: 1-888-382-1222.
- Consumers must report the date of the call andeitherthe name or
the phone number of the company that called.
26. Penalty
- Telemarketers who disregard the registry may be fined up to
$11,000 per call.
27. A Recent Example
- March 2005 Phoenix based Dynasty Mortgage was cited by the FCC
for 70 calls to 50 homes and fined the maximum of $11,000 per
violation ($770,000)
- Dynasty had been warned in December of 2003
28. Preemption of State Law
- Portions of State DNC regulations which are more restrictive
than the Federal DNC laws apply.
- SC and VA have no State DNC laws. GA ($10/yr
www.ganocall.com)
- Some state lists are not merged with the federal list.
29. State Law Example:
- Wisconsin does not add its DNC list to the "Federal DNC
Registry," so Wisconsin REALTORS have to scrub the Wisconsin DNC
list and the Federal DNC list separately.
- A telemarketer registering with DATCP must pay the following
annual fees, or an annual fee of $20,000 whichever is less:
-
- An annual registration fee: $700 (first year) and $500 for each
year thereafter.
-
- An annual fee of $75 for each telephone line used by the
registrant (or the registrant's employees or individual agents) to
make telephone solicitations.
-
- An annual fee of $1,000 for each copy or additional address to
which the registrant requests DATCP to send the No Call List in
hard copy print form ($25 if e-mail or CD format).
30. Wisconsin Experience:
- The most effective exemption is to secure advance permission to
call the home -- and now the cell -- numbers of the consumer. The
agents tend to work with e-mails, calls to office phones, snail
mail, personal visits, etc. There is no easy exemption here! We
have had agents who relied heavily on telephone prospecting leave
the industry, a few brokers selling or downsizing their businesses,
etc. It is truly awful!
- Director of Legal Services
31. Part Two: CAN SPAM 32. CAN-SPAM Legislation
- Effective date January 1, 2004.
- CAN SPAM (Controlling the Assault of Non-Solicited Pornography
and Marketing Act)
- Sought by retailers, marketers and ISPs seeking a single set of
rules to preempt 35 state spam laws.
33. Unlike Do-Not-Call
- CAN SPAMdoes not banany solicited or unsolicited e-mails.
(Congress authorized but the FTC did not create a do-not-spam
registry.)
- CAN SPAMidentifies practices to be followedby those who send
commercial e-mails originating in the US.
- CAN SPAM bans certainfraudulent or deceptive practicesand
criminalizes techniques used by spammers to avoid detection.
- CAN SPAM pre-empts state spam lawsexceptportions of state law
that prohibitfalsity or deceptionin any e-mail or attachment.
34. Key Definition:Commercial Electronic Mail Message
- Any electronic mail message theprimary purposeof which is the
commercial advertisement or promotion of a commercial product or
service.
35. Exempt transactional or relationship e-mails whose primary
purpose is to:
- Facilitate, complete or confirm a commercial transaction that
the recipient has previously agreed to enter into with the sender
.
- Provide warranty information, product recall information or
safety or security information for a product or service purchased
or used by the recipient.
- Provide information of a change in the terms, features, status,
, membership, ongoing purchase or use of products or services
offered by the sender and used by the recipient.
- Provide information directly related to an employment
relationship or benefit plan in which the recipient is
enrolled.
- Deliver goods or services that the recipient is entitled to
receive under the terms of a transaction that the recipient has
previously entered into with the sender.
36. How to determine:primary purpose
- 1) E-mail contentsolely advertises or promotes a product or
serviceit is commercial.
- 2) E-mail containsboth commercial and transactional or
relationship contentit is commercial if either:
- a) recipient deems from the subject line that the e-mail
advertises or promotes a product or service
- b) transactional or relationship content is not located at or
near the beginning of the e-mail.
37.
- 3) E-mail containsboth commercial and non-commercial contentit
is commercial if:
- a) recipient concludes from the subject line that the e-mail is
commercial.
- b) recipient concludes from the text that the main purpose of
the e-mail is to advertise or promote a product or service.
38. If you send a commercial e-mail it must include:
- A clear and conspicuous notice that the message is an
advertisement or solicitation.
- A legitimate return e-mail address.
- An Internet-based mechanism by which the recipient may opt-out
of future commercial e-mail messages. The opt-out address must
remain active for 30 days after the transmission of the e-mail
(dont let your mail box fill up) and opt-outs must be honored
within 10 days.
39. Enforcement:
- Federal and State Regulators
- ISPs (may sue for injunctive relief and damages)
40. Safe Harbor
- There is no Safe harbor and the FTC did not provide a blanket
exemption for nonprofit associations.
- However, in actions brought by AGs and ISPs courts are
permitted to consider whether defendants have followed reasonable
compliance procedures when awarding damages.
41. Civil and Criminal Penalties:
- $250 per violation ($750 if willful)
- 3 years in prison for deception, falsifying header information,
hacking, sending large numbers of commercial e-mails or falsifying
registration.
- 5 years in prison if committed in furtherance of a felony
42. September 16 th :
- The Federal Trade Commission gave limited endorsement to
offering cash rewards to people who help track down e-mail
spammers
43. Also
- You may not harvest e-mail messages automatically or purchase
harvested e-mail addresses.
- Once a recipient opts-out of e-mail communication, the Act
prohibits the sale, lease, exchange, transfer or release of that
persons e-mail addresses to anyone else for any purpose.
44. Spam Facts
- There are some 95,000 spam messages sent every day.
- 15% of all opt-out buttons are fake.
- 80% of all spam is sent by 600 people.
- Can-Spam compliance rose from one-half of one percent in
December 03 to 7% in December 04.
45. Part Three: Do Not FAX!
- June 24 ththe Senate passed S.714
- June 27 ththe FCC issued a stay of the fax rules until January
9, 2006.
- June 28 ththe House passed S.714
- July 9 thPresident Bush signed S.714 into law
46. Legislative Background
- Telephone Consumer Protection Act of 1991 (TCPA) prohibits the
sending of unsolicited facsimile advertisements to a business or
residence without theexpress permission or invitationof the
recipient.
- PL 102-243 bans sending unsolicited commercial faxes unless
there exists an existing business relationship with the
recipient.
47. Established Business Relationship (EBR) Examples:
- REALTOR Association to REALTOR
48. The FCC Rule Would Have Eliminated the EBR andR equired
prior to sending a fax:
- 1) express written permission from recipient,
- 2) the recipients specified fax number
- 3) signature of the fax recipient
49.
- Unsolicited commercial faxes may be sent without prior
permission as long as:
-
- An established business relationship predates the enactment of
the Junk Fax Prevention Act, or
-
- In the case of a new established business relationship, the fax
number was provided voluntarily by the recipient or is publicly
available in a published directory, advertisement or website to
which the recipient gave the fax number for publication.
-
- One may not purchase fax list from third parties
S.714 Compliance 50.
- The fax bill requires thatallunsolicited commercial faxes
include an opt-out provision on the first page of the fax. The
opt-out mechanism will need to be made available 24hours/7 days and
at no cost to the consumer. Examples of a cost-free op-out
mechanism include an email address to which to reply, a local phone
number with message option,and an 800 number with message option. A
phone number that is a long-distance or toll call would not meet
the bill's requirements. Expect further clarification via
rulemaking.
- The bill clarifies that verbal permission to fax is an allowed
means of granting express permission to fax.
51.
- The issue of what constitutes an "advertisement" (does this
include newspaper ads, mag ads, , business cards, stationery,
etc.?) will need to be clarified by rulemaking.
- Despite adoption of this Federal law, state laws on the sending
of unsolicited faxes areNOTpreempted.Senders must comply with both
the Federal law and with any applicable state laws.The Federal law
will not allow an unsolicited fax to be sent where doing so is
prohibited by state law.
52. FCC Proposed Penalties :
- $1500 per blast fax to strangers
53. FCC Proposed Enforcement
- Consumer may sue sender directly
- State AGs office may bring action
- Complaint filed with the FCC:
- http://www.fcc.gov/cgb/complaints.html
54. 55. Existing EnforcementActions
- Charter One Bank $1,800,000
- Seventeen Motors $7,000,000
56. Class Actions 57. 58.
- Busbia v. Direct TV, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1034 (Ga. Super. Apr.
30, 2001) (interlocutory uinjunction to preserve evidence)
- Carnett's, Inc. v. Hammond, 610 S.E.2d 529, 2005 TCPA Rep. 1337
(Ga. 2005) (reversal)
- Garver v. Susquehanna Radio Corp., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1027 (Ga.
Fulton County Mar. 20, 2001) (order denying Def. mtn. to dismiss
[vacated on other grounds and remanded])
- Hammond v. Carnett's, Inc., 596 S.E.2d 729, 2004 TCPA Rep 1274
(Ga. App. March 12, 2004) pet. cert. filed Mar. 28, 2004. (appeal
reversing denial of class certification)
- Hooters of Augusta, Inc. v. Am. Global Ins. Co., 272 F.Supp.2d
1365, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1165, 2003 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 12681 (S.D.Ga.
July 23, 2003) (order finding insurance policy covers TCPA
damages)
- McGarry v. Cingular Wireless, LLC, -- S.E.2d --, 2004 TCPA Rep.
1277, 2004 WL 574864 (Ga.App. Mar. 24, 2004) (order affirming
denial of class cert.)
- McGarry v. Cingular Wireless, LLC, 599 S.E.2d 34, 2004 TCPA
Rep. 1282 (Ga.App. Mar. 24, 2004) (order affirming denial of class
cert.)
- Nicholson v. Hooters of Augusta, Inc., 1998 TCPA Rep. 1004 (Ga.
Super. Aug. 26, 1998) (Order granting class certification)
- Nicholson v. Hooters of Augusta, Inc., 537 S.E.2d 468, 245
Ga.App. 363, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1153 (Ga. App. 2000) (en banc) (appeal
affirming class cert. and rejecting opt-out)
- Schneider v. Susquehanna Radio Corp., 581 S.E.2d 603, 2003 TCPA
Rep. 1203 (Ga. App. 2003) (affirmed in part and reversed in part
and remanded)
59.
- Prime TV, LLC v. Travelers Ins. Co., 223 F.Supp.2d 744, 2002
TCPA Rep. 1113 (M.D.N.C. 2002) (insurance coverage)
- State of North Carolina ex rel. Cooper v. Debt Mgmt. Foundation
Svcs., Inc., 2004 TCPA Rep. 1313 (E.D.N.C. March 8, 2004) (motion
to remand granted)
- Int'l Science & Tech. Inst., Inc. v. Inacom Commun., Inc.,
106 F.3d 1146, 1997 TCPA Rep. 1172 (4th Cir. 1997) (order affirming
dismissal for lack of subject matter jurisdiction)
- Resource Bankshares Corp. v. St. Paul Mercury Ins. Co., 323
F.Supp.2d 709, 2004 TCPA Rep. 1298 (E.D. Va. July 1, 2004). (order
finding duty to defend)
60. South Carolina Cases: Agostinelli v. L.M. Comm. of South
Carolina, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1049 (S.C. Magis. Feb. 14, 2002)
(judgment)Agostinelli v. Roberts Mtg. Co., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1054
(S.C. Magis. Mar. 25, 2002) (order and judgment)Allendale County
Bank v. Fax.com, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1043 (S.C. C.P. Nov. 28,
2001) (TRO to preserve records)Battery, Inc. v. United Parcel
Service, Inc., 2002 TCPA Rep. 1143 (S.C. C.P. Jul 26, 2002) (order
granting class cert. [settlement])Biggerstaff v. CSJ Consulting and
Jay M. Taylor, 2001 TCPA Rep. 1126 (S.C. Magis. Apr. 20, 2001)
(default judgment)Biggerstaff v. Computer Products, 1999 TCPA Rep.
1123 (S.C. Magis. Nov. 17, 1999) (order and judgment)Biggerstaff v.
Low Country Drug Screening, 1999 TCPA Rep. 1124 (S.C. Magis. Nov.
29, 1999) (order and judgment)Biggerstaff v. Marriott Int'l, Inc.,
2001 TCPA Rep. 1129 (S.C. C.P. Feb 20, 2001) (order granting class
cert.)Biggerstaff v. Ramada Inn, Coliseum, 2000 TCPA Rep. 1128
(S.C. C.P. Feb. 3, 2000) (order granting class cert.)Biggerstaff v.
SBS Resort Promotions, Inc., 1999 TCPA Rep. 1125 (S.C. Magis. Dec.
15, 1999) (trial decision)Biggerstaff v. Voice Power Telecom.,
Inc., 221 F.Supp.2d 652, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1160 (D.C.S.C. Sep. 13,
2002) (order remanding cause to state court)Biggerstaff v.
Websiteuniversity.com, Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep. 1025 (S.C. Mag. Mar.
20, 2001) (order granting mtn. to strike defenses)Connor v.
Cumpston, 2002 TCPA Rep. 1066 (S.C. Magis. Feb. 13, 2002) (order
and judgment)Lipscomb v. 2nd Wind Heating and Air Conditioning, No.
01-CP-40-4272 (S.C.C.P __________) (*status unknown*)Lipscomb v.
Triangle Rent A Car, Inc., No. 01-CP-40-4271 (S.C.C.P.
____________) (*status unknown*)Lipscomb v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.,
2003 TCPA Rep. 1183 (S.C.C.P. June 26, 2003) (Order granting class
cert [settlement class])OLDAPG, Inc f/k/a Atlantic Pub. Group, Inc.
v. New England Bus. Svcs.,, 2003 TCPA 1195 (S.C.C.P. ______ 2003)
(class cert. [settlement class])Syrett v. Allstate Ins. Co., 2003
TCPA Rep. 1215 (S.C.C.P. Aug. 6, 2003) (order granting class cert
[settlement class])WPS, Inc. v. Lobel Fin., Inc., 2001 TCPA Rep.
1130 (S.C. C.P. Oct. 15, 2001) (order granting class
certification)Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Lipscomb d/b/a Am.
Amusements, 2003 TCPA Rep. 1212 (D.S.C. Mar. 10, 2003) (Order
dismission DJ action 61. 62. What If S.714 Had Not Passed?
- NAR testified that the FCC rules would have caused REALTORS to
create and store 66 million permission forms to support the 6
million home sales last year.
- US Chamber estimated the FCC regulations would have cost the
average small business $5,000 the first year and $3,000 every year
thereafter.
63. The NAR Action Center
64. The NAR Action Center
65. The NAR Action Center
- In just a few clicks of the
- computer mouse you can join
- tens of thousands of other
- REALTORS across America in
- grassroots communications to
- Registration is easy, and with
- your NRDS # it is VERY Quick
66. RESPONDING TO A CALL FOR ACTIONIt Takes Just Seconds to
Respond. The Outcome Can Last ALifetime
- Using NARs Action Center is the easiest wayfor you to
personally influence Congress from your home or office
- NAR will email aCall for Action (CFA)requesting your immediate
response on an important real estate or housing issue.
- NAR Action Center gives you a
- Pre-written letter to send to
- your Representative or Senators in just three clicks.
67. NC, SC, GA & VA REALTORS
- Membership: NC 30,455 SC 13,520 GA 30,179 VA 31,876
- Registered with Action Center as of July 05:NC 6,222 SC 2,287
GA 5,641 VA 5,731
- Average response to Call-to-Action:
- NC 760.2 (2.5%), SC 365.2 (2.7%),
- GA 627.4 (2.08%) and VA 689.0 (2.19%)
68.
- NAR has published a Do-Not-Call, Do-Not-Fax, Do-Not-E-mail
Toolkit to provide REALTORS with briefing materialand compliance
information on the federal the anti-solicitation laws/rules.
- To order the toolkit, please go to: http://www.realtor.org/ Do
Not Call
- or call Information Central at 800/874-6500Request item
number:186-100.
69.