88
How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy Northwestern Ontario Municipal Association, NOMA September 25, 2014 Bruce M Firestone PhD @ProfBruce

How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy

Northwestern Ontario Municipal Association, NOMASeptember 25, 2014

Bruce M Firestone PhD@ProfBruce

Page 2: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Life in 2050

Page 3: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 4: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Seniors in Ottawa, 2012 & 2032

0 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000

1

2

Series1

Page 5: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Life in 2050

Page 6: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 7: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 8: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 9: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 10: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

2,993,385.83

Page 11: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy

• understand your entrepreneurs• attract entrepreneurs to live in your community• teach people to become entrepreneurs• keep/support your entrepreneurs • how?

Page 12: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy

• listen to Prof Bruce• don’t rely exclusively on senior levels of government• low cost programs that work• family-friendly policies• sustainable economic opportunity• teach, preach, lead• keep the faith

Page 13: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

McNab Braeside

KEY DIFFERENTIATOR?

• playground of the north• vibrant arts & foodie culture, all things Scottish• new brand fabulous lifestyle option for boomers• low-cost housing options• attract/keep/facilitate entrepreneurs• facilitator appointment

Page 14: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

McNab Braeside

NONE OF THE ABOVE

• proactive council and mayor

Page 15: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 16: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

McNab Braeside

Page 17: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

McNab Braeside

-stop exporting $300,000 per year

Page 18: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

McNab Braeside

Page 19: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

McNab Braeside

NEW RESIDENTIAL

• manufactured home capital of Ontario• twin with 2 Florida communities• N = 3,000 NEW SITES

Page 20: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

McNab Braeside

NEW RESIDENTIAL

• live 6 months in M/B and 6 in Florida for $500 per month

Page 21: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

McNab Braeside

EYES ON THE PARK

• safer parks• better utilization• more viable commercial services• new revenue stream (up to $30,000 per month est)• land leases, $150 to $200 per month• inexpensive lots for new residents

Page 22: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 23: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 24: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

McNab BraesideMARKET CHANNELS

• google+ page• google maps

Page 25: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

BUILD BRAND

• marketing creates brand• brand builds trust• trust creates opportunity to sell• sales generates funds for more marketing• most brand conscious generation ever

Page 26: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

MARKET CHANNELS< 9:50 pm PST, March 21st, 2006*

• msm (TV, radio, newspaper, magazine)• website• blog• email• newsletter

* "just setting up my twttr"-Jack Dorsey

Page 27: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

MARKET CHANNELS> 9:50 pm PST, March 21st, 2006

• facebook page/ads• google+ page/google maps/google ad words• twitter feed/ads (https://twitter.com/sweden) • linkedin profile/ads• instagram• youtube channel• tumblr blog

• airbnb.com• pinterest• kijiji ads • events• REALTOR chain• app

Page 28: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 29: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

“Leisure is the new infrastructure, Bruce,” Eric Kuhne, London, England September 2012

Page 30: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

What Can We Learn from Eric Kuhne?

• invested in infrastructure

• roads, water mains, sewers, bridges and later telecom and cell towers

Page 31: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

What Can We Learn from Eric Kuhne?

• Renfrew county, $100/person/day/visitor

• Miami, $249

Page 32: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 33: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 34: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 35: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Wilderness Tours

• Joe Kowalski from Philly Algonquin Park• outfitter–canoe trips• 1st summer disaster• force 4 rapids on Ottawa

Page 36: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Wilderness Tours

• Joe and Robbie Rosenberger• close by market of 1.3 million outdoorsy people with

disposable income• ask farmers for permission to set in/take out• launch Wilderness Tours with two rafts

Page 37: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Wilderness Tours

entrepreneurs would rather ask for forgiveness that beg for permission

Page 38: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Wilderness Tours

• 100s then 1,000s then 10,000s of people show up• rapids terrific, ride short• Joe embraces programming• buys land/builds town• Beachburg pop 900• WT pop 3,500 (weekends)

Page 39: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy

COOMBS, BC

• population ~ 1,327• Vancouver Island, 43.7 kilometres northwest of Nanaimo• top tourist attraction /one of Canada’s weirdest places• huh?

Page 40: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 41: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy

GOATS ON THE ROOF/Old Country Market

• features family of goats living on roof• employs 100 to 150 people in winter, 250 in summer• attracts 5,000 visitors per day during peak days• spurred other development

Page 42: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy

• Kristian and Solveig Graaten

Page 43: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 44: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Opportunity is Everywhere—but first you must be able to see

• 177 acres near Eganville

• 3 homes + 3 rental cottages

+ 5 RV sites/room for 45 more

• 1,000s of feet of waterfront

• glorious lake

• asking price?

Page 45: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Opportunity is Everywhere—but first you must be able to see

• $740,000

• number of offers?

Page 46: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Opportunity is Everywhere—but first you must be able to see

• huh?

Page 47: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Opportunity is Everywhere—but first you must be able to see

• lacking in branding, panache & differentiation

• highest and best use unknown

• functional program not established

• marketing non existent

• operator fatigue

Page 48: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 49: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

• affordable housing

• renters become “owners”

• entrepreneur/landlord year round income

• community creates new opportunities

• prevent your kids from leaving/reason to return

Page 50: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

No Financing?

• soft capital• home equity loans• future customers• future suppliers/trade credit• strategic partners• micro capital lending• SBL, SR&ED, NRC-IRAP • sponsorship• Consulting• partners/investors• factoring receivables• ESOPs

• credit cards

• issue script

• crowd funding

• seller take back financing

• sweat equity

Page 51: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy

MAIN STREET

• stop trying to compete with Home Depot/Wal-Mart• bring people to live there, commercial follows• relax zoning rules• don’t worry residential property taxes < commercial

Page 52: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 53: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Riverdale

• “Can we move to Riverdale, dad?”

• “I’ve never heard of Riverdale.”

Page 54: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Archie and Veronica and Betty and Jughead—the Pizza Pit

“Why do you want to live in Riverdale, Boo?”

Page 55: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Final Word From Jessica

“The reason everyone likes Riverdale is because everything is in walking distance, the shopping mall, the grocery store, the restaurant(s), the malt shop, yadayada yada. Just thought you might need this bit of info,” Jessica, age 12

Page 56: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 57: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Livable Places

• built better cities circa 1930s than today

• architects allowed urban planners to takeover

Page 58: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Livable Places

• architects told where to put ingress/egress, setbacks to use, high they could build, uses could put structures to, materiality and design strictures

• by people who know NOTHING about design

• urban blight…

Page 59: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

Ever Wonder What If?

• corner stores?

• in-home apartments and granny flats?

• elders stay in community?

• mixed use?

• walkable place?

• front porches?

• mixing together of folks from differing socio-economic strata?

Sounds like a Wonderful Life…

Page 60: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 61: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 63: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 64: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 65: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 66: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

NHL Salaries

• $6.5 million CAD

• $54 million USD

Page 67: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 68: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 69: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 70: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 71: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 72: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 73: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 74: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

www.brucemfirestone.com

Page 75: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 76: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

• NHL is ready for expansion again

• Randy Sexton, MBA, “Let’s do it!”

• Cyril Leeder, CA, “How much is it going to cost?”

Page 77: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

• franchise: $50,000,000

Page 78: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

• buy 600 acres for $7.2 million ($12k/acre)

• rezone

• keep 100 acres/sell 500 acres for $50 million ($112k/acre)

Page 79: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 80: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 81: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 82: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 83: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

• “You will never, ever get an NHL franchise in Ottawa”

Page 84: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 85: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 86: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

POSTSCRIPT

• OMB approves 100-acre Palladium zoning

• balance of lands remains in limbo

• Terrace Investments $80 million write down

• $30 million for privately funded interchange

• pay NHL $50 million for franchise

• Sens play first game Oct 8, 1992

Page 87: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping
Page 88: How to Bootstrap Your Way to a Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy · 2014-09-30 · Thriving and Sustainable Local Economy ... everything is in walking distance, the shopping

@profbruce

@quantum_entity

613.762.8884

[email protected]

www.brucemfirestone.com