10

Click here to load reader

HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

HOW MANY PEOPLEARE KILLED BY

LIGHTNING EACH YEAR?

by MARTIN A. UMAN

ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED IN

ALL ABOUT LIGHTNINGDOVER PUBLICATIONS, NEW YORK, 1986

Page 2: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED IN

ALL ABOUT LIGHTNINGDOVER PUBLICATIONS, NEW YORK, 1986

HOW MANY PEOPLEARE KILLED BY

LIGHTNING EACH YEAR?

by MARTIN A. UMAN

Although no exact figures on lightning fatalities are available— there is no central agency to which lightning accidents mustbe reported—various studies (Refs. 3.1, 3.2, 3.3, 3.4) haveplaced the average annual number of deaths in the U.S. at 100,137, 151, 300, and even 600. Whatever the exact number, light-ning causes more direct deaths than any other weather phe-nomena. Snowstorms cause more indirect deaths (e.g., heartattacks from shoveling the driveway). Tornadoes cause abouthalf as many deaths as lightning but inflict much more prop-erty damage. It is perhaps surprising that about two-thirds ofthe people involved in lightning accidents subsequently make acomplete recovery. Most, if not all, of these survivors are prob-

Page 3: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

ably not directly struck by lightning, but rather receive electri-cal shock from being in the close vicinity of a strike.

About 70% of all fatal lightning accidents involve one per-son, about 15% occur in groups of two, the remainder involvesthree or more deaths per lightning event. Between 75 and 85%of all lightning deaths and injuries are to men, probably be-cause they are more likely to be out-of-doors. About 70% of allinjuries and fatalities occur in the afternoon, about 20% be-tween 6 p.m. and midnight (Ref. 3.1).

The largest single category of lightning deaths (12 to 15% ofall fatalities) is composed of those unfortunate individuals whoseek refuge under trees during thunderstorms and have theirsheltering trees struck by lightning. Perhaps one-third of theseare golfers. Two additional categories in which large numbersof lightning fatalities occur are designated “Open Water” and“Tractors”, each claiming about 10% of the total fatalities.“Open Water” includes people fishing, swimming, on beaches,piers, and levees, in boats, and on water skis; “Tractors” in-cludes people on, in, or near farm tractors or other implements,construction equipment, cars, and trucks (Refs. 3.1, 3.3).

Most lightning deaths occur outdoors. Over 30% of all light-ning deaths involve people who work outdoors; over 25% ofall deaths involve outdoor recreationists. A breakdown of deathsand injuries to farmers and ranchers and to outdoorrecreationists for the 20-year period 1950 through 1969 is givenin Table 3.1. The apparent increase from the 1950s to the 1960sin the number and percentage of deaths to outdoor recreationistsis perhaps due to the increasing number of outdoorrecreationists. Table 3.2 gives more detailed data on death andinjury to outdoor recreationists, while Table 3.3 breaks downthe “Open Water” category of Table 3.2.

In addition to humans, animals are killed by lightning. In1968, lightning caused the death of 464 cattle (362 killed di-rectly, the remainder by lightning-caused fires), 13 horses (11killed directly), 42 hogs, 2 dogs, and 1 white ox resident in amuseum pasture (Ref. 3.4).

From the foregoing it is obvious what you should not dowhen out-of-doors during a thunderstorm: do not make a light-

Page 4: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

elpoePllA

stsinoitaerceR

roodtuO

srehcnaR

dnasre

mraFn

wonknU

nwon

Kreht

O

rebmu

NtnecreP

rebmu

NtnecreP

rebmu

NtnecreP

rebmu

NtnecreP

)1(†)2(

†)3()4(

)5()6(

)7()8(

)9()01(

)11()21(

)31()41(

)51()61(

)71()81(

)91(

raeYdelli

KderujnI

delliK

derujnIdelli

KderujnI

delliK

derujnIdelli

KderujnI

delliK

derujnIdelli

KderujnI

delliK

derujnIdelli

KderujnI

059195

0701

519.61

2.9121

113.02

1.4102

712.94

8.128

436.31

8.44

159159

9019

715.9

6.5182

215.92

0.1114

332.34

3.0371

749.71

1.34

259188

497

310.8

8.3172

617.03

0.7103

241.43

7.4442

323.72

5.42

359117

898

313.11

3.319

47.21

8.444

650.26

2.7501

521.41

5.52

4591311

30282

938.42

2.9162

230.32

8.5105

283.44

4.049

050.8

6.42

5591311

60211

517.9

3.783

656.33

3.7215

392.54

2.5431

245.11

4.02

6591401

73291

853.81

4.4204

055.83

1.1233

567.13

4.7221

465.11

0.72

7591211

77232

835.02

7.3192

049.52

4.4134

764.83

2.4271

2312.51

7.74

859137

34232

355.13

8.1251

846.02

8.9162

776.53

7.139

563.21

8.62

9591351

62393

654.52

2.7183

158.42

6.5174

5217.03

4.8392

499.81

8.82

0691001

99112

440.12

1.2282

720.82

6.3123

070.23

2.5391

850.91

1.92

1691511

45242

339.02

0.3143

836.92

0.5104

298.43

2.6371

198.41

8.53

2691221

34263

565.92

7.6273

833.03

6.5192

088.32

9.2302

064.61

7.42

3691631

90253

448.52

0.1224

869.03

6.2304

954.92

2.8291

830.41

2.81

4691801

14222

244.02

4.7153

744.23

5.9102

975.81

7.2313

377.82

3.03

5691621

13293

060.13

0.6283

242.03

2.8133

452.62

4.3261

577.21

5.23

669188

88123

674.63

4.0412

728.32

4.4131

468.41

0.4322

120.52

2.11

769137

75113

354.24

7.3371

423.32

3.517

436.9

6.1281

647.42

3.92

8691801

36324

9419.83

1.1483

632.53

9.911

842.01

2.3171

0317.51

8.53

969179

00253

851.63

0.9253

741.63

5.329

133.9

5.5181

466.81

0.23

45026514

494149

785417

8268621

5433321

Tab

le 3

.1: D

eath

s an

d in

juri

es fr

om li

ghtn

ing

in t

he c

onti

guou

s U

nite

d St

ates

dur

ing

1950

–196

9 (R

ef. 3

.4)

* T

otal

s in

196

3 do

not

incl

ude

81 f

atal

itie

s in

an

airl

iner

cra

sh a

ppar

entl

y ca

used

by

light

ning

(C

hapt

er 4

).†

Col

umn

2 eq

uals

the

sum

of

Col

umns

4, 8

, 12

and

16. C

olum

n 3

equa

ls t

he s

um o

f C

olum

ns 5

, 9, 1

3 an

d 17

.

Page 5: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

ning rod of yourself and do not stand beneath a lightning rod.Avoid projecting above the surrounding landscape, as you woulddo if you were standing in an open field, on the beach, or fish-ing from a small boat. Avoid standing under isolated trees orunder any other isolated shelters. (Potentially dangerous sunand rain shelters are often provided on golf courses.) Stay awayfrom wire fences, overground pipes, rails, and other metallicpaths along the ground which could carry lightning currents toyou from a stroke which has hit some distance away. Avoidswimming, since the current from a nearby stroke to the watercan flow through the water to you.

Here’s what you should do if caught out-of-doors during athunderstorm. In an urban area, seek shelter in a building (pref-erably with metal frame and/or with a lightning rod system) orin a car (not a convertible) with the windows rolled up (seeChapter 4). In the wide-open spaces, find a ravine, valley, or, asa last resort, a depression in the ground. Crouch or lie down. Ina wooded area, seek shelter in dense woods or among a thickgrowth of small trees.

Relatively few people are killed indoors by lightning. Thegreatest number of indoor deaths is probably due to lightning-caused fires. Nevertheless, between 1959 and 1965 four peoplewere reported killed by lightning while using their telephones(Ref. 3.1); many others were killed because they were near, orin contact with, fixtures connected to the house plumbing orto appliances that were plugged into the house wiring system.

When lightning strikes a house without a lightning rod sys-tem, the lightning current generally follows the water pipes andelectrical wiring in an attempt to get to ground. It may alsoenter a house on the telephone or electric wires or on the lead-in wires from an exterior TV antenna. (The mast to which anexternal TV antenna is attached, and from which it is electri-cally isolated, should be well connected to ground in accordwith the codes for lightning rod systems.) If the particular con-ductor in which the current is traveling is not well-connectedto ground, the lightning may choose to leave that conductorand jump through the air to what it regards as a better path toground. The trip through the air, or side flash, accounts for a

Page 6: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

significant fraction of indoor lightning fatalities (as well as be-ing one of the ways in which people standing beneath light-ning struck trees can be killed). Thus during a thunderstorm itmakes good sense to stay far away from bath tubs, sinks, plugged-

ekirtsfoemittaytivitcA delliK derujnI

retawneporaenro,no,nI 002 771

gnifloG 59 461

gnikcinciprognipmaC 63 881

scitelhtanignitapicitraprogniweiV 92 56

gnibmilcrognikiH 91 54

elcihevdnalraenro,no,nI 7 8

)erusaelp(gnidirkcabesroH 9 8

*noitaercerrehtO 56 091

**noitaercernwonknU 43 69

latoT 494 149

yrogetaC-buS delliK derujnI

knab,erohsmorfgnihsiF 93 03

taobmorfgnihsiF 33 12

taobrehtO 03 83

gnimmiwS 9 9

*retawnwonknudnarehtO 98 97

latoT 002 771

* Includes sightseers, recreation strollers, youths at play (except athletics) anywhere outdoors, and others.** Persons identified by data source as having been at recreation areas at time they were struck, with nospecific activity indicated.

Table 3.2: Known lightning deaths and injuries among outdoorrecreationists in the 48 contiguous United States during 1950–1969 (Ref. 3.4)

Table 3.3: Analysis of “In, on, or near open water” in Table 3.2(Ref. 3.4)

* Mostly persons on lake or ocean shores or stream banks and persons whose activities were listed in thedata sources only as “fishing” with no indication as to whether they were on shore or in a boat.

Page 7: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

in appliances, telephones, or any objects that have a metallicconnection with the outside.

Telephone and electric companies attempt to design systemswhich discourage lightning from entering houses via their wires.A “lightning protector” (costing about $50, excluding installa-tion) on the main circuit breaker or fuse box will short-circuitto ground lightning current attempting to enter a house on theelectric wires. A similar “lightning protector” is sold for TVlead-in wires. Protection of your house against direct lightningstrikes can be accomplished with a lightning rod system (Chapter2) at a cost of several hundred dollars (including installation).If lightning does enter electrical wiring, it can cause consider-able damage to plugged-in appliances. Although it is safest tounplug all appliances before a thunderstorm, this is somewhatimpractical. For a typical urban house in a region of moderatethunderstorm activity, say Pennsylvania or New York (see Chap-ter 7), the frequency of strikes to the house is statistically aboutonce every hundred years (see Chapters 6 and 7). Saying thesame thing another way, one in every hundred houses is hiteach year.

Lightning “deaths” are often reversible. Many victims whoappear dead, in that they are not breathing and have no heartbeat, can be revived with proper first aid (Ref. 3.5). It is tragicthat this fact is not more widely known. If a victim is still breath-ing, he will, in all probability, recover.

Often, when a person is involved in a lightning accident,heart action and breathing stop instantly. There is medical evi-dence that all metabolism seems to stop (Ref. 3.5). Typicallythe heart starts again, but respiration does not. If the victimdoes not breathe for a prolonged period, he suffers brain dam-age from lack of oxygen. The apparent stopping or slowing ofmetabolism can seemingly lengthen the usual five or six-minuteperiod before appreciable brain damage occurs. A case was re-ported in which the victim apparently did not breathe for be-tween 13 and 22 minutes, and still made an essentially com-plete recovery (Ref. 3.6).

If the victim’s heart has started spontaneously but his breath-ing has not, his airway should first be cleared and then mouth-

Page 8: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

to-mouth artificial respiration given at about one breath every5 seconds. If his heart is not beating (if the victim has no pulse),both heart action and breathing must be restarted. Heart ac-tion can be stimulated by placing the victim on his back andpressing firmly on his chest (on the lower half of the sternumabove the point where the ribs come together) with the heel ofthe hand once every second or slightly faster. A person alonewith the victim should alternate between 15 chest compres-sions and 2 mouth-to-mouth respiration cycles. If two rescuersare present, one should compress the chest at a steady rate ofonce per second while the other gives one breath every fivecompressions timed so that the breath is going in as the handsare coming up. This first aid should be continued until thevictim’s heart action and breathing begin or until professionalmedical help is secured. The above is only a brief explanationof the rudiments of cardio-pulmonary resuscitation (CPR) andis no substitute for a proper education in these life saving pro-cedures (Ref. 3.7).

Page 9: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

REFERENCES

3.1. Zegel, F. H., Lightning Deaths in the United States: ASeven Year Survey from 1959 to 1965, Weatherwise, 20, 168-173, 179, August 1967.

3.2. U.S. Dept. of Commerce, ESSA, Lightning, 1966, U.S.Government Printing Office, Washington, D. C.

3.3. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, Statistical Bul-letin, 33, 8-10, June 1952.

3.4. Unpublished analysis by Alan R. Taylor, Northern For-est Fire Laboratory, USDA Forest Service, Missoula, Montana.Analysis based on data published in Climatological Data, Na-tional Summary, U.S. Department of Commerce, WeatherBureau, Vols. 1-9, 1950-58, and Storm Data, U.S. Departmentof Commerce, ESSA, Vols. I -11, 1959-69.

3.5. Taussig, H. B., “Death” from Lightning and the Possi-bility of Living Again, American Scientist, 57 (No. 3), 306-316 (1969).

3.6. Ravitch, M. M., R. Lane, P. Safar, F. M. Steichen, and P.Knowles, Lightning Stroke, New England Journal of Medicine,264, 36-38 (1961).

3.7 Red Cross, Red Cross CPR Module, The American RedCross, 1980.

ADDITIONAL READING

Golde, R. H., and Lee, W. R., Death by Lightning, Proc.IEE, 123, 1163-1179, October 1976.

Cooper, M. A., Lightning Injuries: Prognostic Signs forDeath, Ann. Emerg.Med., 9, 134-138, March 1980.

Storm Data, Volume 25, No. 12, December 1983, availablefrom Publications Section(E/CC413),the National ClimaticData Center, NOAA, Federal Building, Asheville, N.C. 28801-2696. Contains lightning death and injury statistics by monthand by state for the United States from 1959 to 1983.

Page 10: HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE KILLED BY LIGHTNING … · how many people are killed by lightning each year? by martin a. uman originally published in all about lightning dover publications,

THE EVENT

PETRIFIED LIGHTNING FROM CENTRAL FLORIDA

A PROJECT BY ALLAN MCCOLLUM

CONTEMPORARY ART MUSEUMUNIVERSITY OF SOUTH FLORIDA

MUSEUM OF SCIENCE AND INDUSTRYTAMPA, FLORIDA