12
ANNALJ OF MEDICINE THE PIMA PARADOX D hr f,ilrllat tk,! 1\.n oblk?nl!?t1ttu'r rt'? f'\{-ro Lt! r h! < n o, !_ \ zo". r*, dflnres.t 10 .' \J e Cir tu ( t-:rcoon ord! Pim lDdm dbe lt n r smdr lIM, dusc sJ llrbrkslq shnh lmls 3 ia k i:d b<! blon ihe€ b! i 3us of ds.n\rind Shek lrd Plw.od brJg{ cohlt sid. Do6 qj5s@$ d.5rt.c u;r.,;r, r ril.d -ii\ trrd mrs rnl luil Th. dse( in L\*. Pus is .-'ri, -d bren. d:ln.d oa ms bY ir. d;id @,rn orPh*ilx, jG h'ru hou'; d;€ E lh! oonh. The idby Cih Rrti n d4 !d L\e 6<l& ofNhar !!d cushnr ,qush rDd €Pnv berDs rlii.h 6e ?in: Nd rc !1ndna r lo.s :on!. T}. od! p&gossnrg bsndiig in S$rc! is l g|rnog ldw duog hd ,hl Hr Hu t(!D lGDo'irl HosPiBI

Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

ANNALJ OF MEDICINE

THE PIMA PARADOXD hr f,ilrllat tk,! 1\.n oblk?nl!?t1ttu'r rt'?

f '\{-ro Lt! r h! < n o, !_

\ z o " . r * , d f l n r e s . t 1 0 . '\J e Cir tu ( t-:rcoon ord!Pim lDdm dbe lt n r smdr lIM,dusc sJ llrbrkslq shnh lmls 3ia k i:d b<! blon ihe€ b! i 3us ofds.n\rind Shek lrd Plw.od brJg{

cohlt sid. Do6 qj5s@$ d.5rt.cu;r.,;r, r ril.d -ii\ trrd mrsrnl luil Th. dse( in L\*. Pus is.-'ri, -d bren. d:ln.d oa ms bYir. d;id @,rn orPh*ilx, jG h'ruhou'; d;€ E lh! oonh. The idbyCih Rrti n d4 !d L\e 6<l& ofNhar!!d cushnr ,qush rDd €Pnv berDsrlii.h 6e ?in: Nd rc !1ndna r lo.s

:on!. T}. od! p&gossnrg bsndiig inS$rc! is l g|rnog ldw duog hd

,hl Hr Hu t(!D lGDo'irl HosPiBI

Page 2: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

Tft Pitu u. hnor nor-rriourrbr og hR: rhr Dr drhs sasP rth. wond. vnb r[c qepriod ool, ofde )_rn lrid.n oadq\r!,pr;inc,{no,g tirs. oft: rilh 6,. o, rh..nnror d: d. oaci!b44 Lt. dirf,.l.To rd*!ri L dn.d \..h dbq !.

r!:!3. ri3 3 qut trDixher io E di!:1iiso( ir i! a{ unherd oaio 5is(oi rnr lduL6 io {.igh frE i:uiddPduod!, ror [email protected] ro b. r*.ing!!m drb.:5. r ior .hdldr Nuos m.nsd nto.n o br rlftdv dirbt:i1 [r ,F.di:!r-o b. briod. b irr ldi a i,mbF be sinn.d o r whrttdun or o bed+mdor m [der dirL$n \\lhm

bn$rd.-rn cr ntrton3i9.T.4r. 1

hidc .h. niddL slhol ildli; r \,{rkied to b! h3tf 5p4d, ihcr-qen.ds.hir Dd b4:\ l.b, bah loncnuq,i.r b \! dE h6Pnrt. ort or$.dib.i pubL.,h.dih !d*d bld sc o5.rvhen 5h. b.gI 5 .duenoi progm onoulidon a, cnl r.s €o sh. lri€a @srn lirb *6nd gidus, io srh rhirhrrd&o b.for ir rs b hft "\r'r -?ELndd rh. ddsion Lr tids didnr sJi

,.rgri urn lI.::s.:i gidel str ::i.

r.d hn. tu 3. r!!i-:( Thor r::

Frdn $t 5.:r;a :\: r_.].t{.;:: : f !h4 hI! i : : : .d i . ] i : i . tnd.! ]

.:annC ,\'lv 6: P:a: a? $ obsE l::rntr5:G<uc!::lD.obaLn'iiL,t;::l,:ui rir $r::ooi }r obs,. i1

i iioi Orc.r.aon.::r 'b. ln. Pi-r:rirgir. riLlci i Eir turEsi( oi r!

.f,ioo, ot hn; ! ri. dd.n fie ei.Ptsr Nh' uli::: rf;:,. ind drcuarr!!a $dtr h,-::rr :pr { nori,.:i:r,in6 oaplcD. UoJ. odmdir:-.r:rc5 rhjr 4siridoa rs rt-F io e.:l:! Ih. Pinr!::dnioi,l di! c5e:li:rro buds, hirr isqsa, poEl

".:d, ed pn.it :,!6 riom :iY d:!::nooi oul. d::. \rift nilgld dolt.:iibhck Riled jri:bbir squ$Yi5h F -o: Gih Rini id \ridr, rqu$h. :ib:s grt$n il r3rrJ d6.ft ne$ tsii. .od oitb! sTnc \\idd $'a [r. -.,tr the Pim in Llrrcr otirLf ::i:ie li id, lid i.r "ie3m ro.r i,l.on{ -{.T.n!E Thlr &didoid ;:::tjd b&d riiiel b i\t1s Pd dnr :r:

Tn* nd! di{ "is doni o ria Prr.oi rir Iifro(. \'l!lh h]d todg b<! l

n.xr oGni: rd so de Pimii'L\riirj3.rd..r - rd!rng.. xtr no\r r !r-bii$ \ I H rcnsrh6 s! birg rcrnda.n cn4, on rhe d.or (ll ir iheY

eir5i. r (ir: rca otus Th* studi* rsrrron ila itso trnrovfted Hlurbl.d:$ ro hov dirb{. }!tu, hqr obai$h P&-q:u vom:n rtr $ !5.n chn&.n.lld horf blnx Dihbolsd n drcd bv,.i3hr 3ni .{l brd, in< @ll]boErid!b:rE:o L\e \ I.H. .',1 L\. Ptnr is one.ide ms( Iiniil iJidodsbjps jn nod*o n.di.!l (nmlnith olc tuc6llavcpd!tr .!ic thjm, 6!r ]!c 'o orcilr h:d a(v sur*s helPing rhe Pinrlcr r.ishr.Ior _,n. prcddiig rndrohn . L\. hud&dr oa&solh papcci6oibins 6.n b.dJy prce$6, rld th.iiEDin.d .ftB ofh.dih w&q )r{

'I Nd to b! r iuas, I s.d ro volkii ih. cLhi. I u*l ro b. iI glng ho:60* scios our rod h.hing pcopl.i.ou. dhb{ns :trd ob*iaa,"

'fec:a

\vdt. !!ho h*ds ih. rib.\ Public!:nrh crpfretu. rold n.. "l ihdu-ghi

f n P , a t l , t . r r . i t . . . 1 t : : , : r t t a . ) , . , r | r : r - ] , j i r - 3 - "

, ? . n ! t ) . a b 6 ) t t .

Page 3: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

:h:. rar ir ae.rtr red<d-:fomrr:,i. Bm th{ rcii Lnrf,:::1. Thnhii r;.r lsue! " \1:n * t !fr. siodod n@5: \1h' kl toi3. r':iri blrt!]!!. lon hJi{, doh hd iarl sh.

dg. h! oa! thii3 ro rr m p-pi:. Thirh vbs&u s5orll do ls cornd ueuuy g{ rh:i ,o 0r. n in.'

The P:tu h',r buili i Dnw }all*sce,n in do,rio{D s3atoi, snh Iv.isht ,@a ed ! Imn*iud. Th.v

rnion xrn.d d Pc*hool.: rd tu*gnd!6, and n a! ribJ 6rdidd' ngnsi,l.nriii hd]rl61 foda choir!ft riYof vegcabl.s o! of ndr, sl Th.r ;d0ing, !D orhd woids, whd publn-hElth Ploi.$ion'ls u. $ppo ro bcdo;ng Bui rs,,rs u hd b '..

"w" E hd kids who w. di,b€nc,yhor no$ds h:d diabd$ dd d.otr did\:is and hd drcd otkidr4 6ilui o!! ol (h€ nib. s nuririoDrsE rordn. lbut rrriDr ih4 n\{ {o!td BkI difi.dc-drn n would notivr.L\ro to L..p th& dier udtr ronrcl. l(iosr\." Sh. 3dr trp hn ir.r d6L,wrl}rd io ! bqokh.ii ]nd our.!:d ou(nrc botds otCon-Cola. O;. L{s dold gli$ boftt.. Trr. o6d lrs a mod-<m pldic bo.J!, vhich onf,d ove'iL "Th. o.igin.l Cok bonl:. in rhrxin{en dni.s.1rG sir md I hilaoures.' Sh. h.ld up n\( pl6ir bnd.'\N in.y & mrk€ring o': !@ d rsioqt. sxvidg. Thrt! rivc:id* rheoignd snins 5;.. Th. rkDonddsEguh hubu@r ls o huid?d ud5i\r c,lona. b!, .ow rcure ,qo. d.doubl. cheRbug., vhi.h is tbu hu'drtd ind fd!ft-6r crldi.s Portidnsiza u. gEdng vN ou ofqrL: E{ing i oor rb.d hus( olror. Th.hct tn3, p.opL e hungr_1 is \al doEo! th! kr of vhv dq {L' ! old h(n\2t I hd com. ro Srcrcn, d. nont1in4 oi ft waghr bafr!, i! ordd ro6nd out Nlui 6nY wlk i! 6shringob.siq Sh. [email protected] { m. md ,hdgg.d"wiE rh. hr p.opt rho .duld cU

h tn! .slv airdan-5i$4, n rboutIh. dm. d. ]...I.H. €rn srunbLd onih. Pin4 kkiifrn pd Gd ofnlddL-€td rlidrd nd rh. .ljni.d J.6niio! ofobsiq To.lq dr 6gu" G 32 3p{ eft. BenE rh. .r\ iindeen

!\. P{cmq. oi P({hoot g 5 \'ho

\r::. oEn\rshr wn nom ).s pq ri:

t:.: ; ' hr iorc lhr.piJliiolo5*r:x Cl$ Ttua Ob$i._ n\i n. F:D'rlc ad 3ro$Lv oE$eigh.. ir: b nt

hMdcd 3nd nh-r pd <d i! n\! pariri:n !ds. 'nre ve looked n rcldsh .ddrriond lerel, na. rid dhnn

io! {olids, aod ir! acr-' hd b nYdi ddc;s mv gsup dr E !d e!pi!.olins L\is |jid ol weight g]in,"K:L\.'iDe fl.grl, a lao (*fh tpid.nloloAi* r (he Ndion,l C.nE. torH<]th Shdsdr', *ts "Ir's rl okr rnewodd In chior, th. prwlcna ofob.sid n vmishing! lo\ rd th.v acshNins m indak ln lvsarn Slnoq ir i5 rcry high, ud ihcr d sho*-ing m intrde.'h d. $m. pldod, s.i-.!ft hlr unlork.d mMv ol ob*i., s

gia! . rhoiough .dusdoD io rhe priDopl!5 of slod ndrinor, l*drh dubshar sprung up EoD ooi rod or rh.couln rc moth.i di?dng h$ becoo.l rligioi. nd herli\ 6od . mrkdioq ph< oon.Don. Noi. oin h* mrcc:d. ft is lh. Pinr Drdor i! ihE6shi

"sii.si obs'n rlL (h. +-gs th*

rukld i! lubirg bchso* L!. drunk,jrjring rDd ookils ud ; crqoulg'13 ,Ii.gs [ke sf. se\ rod ihc u! olnr bdB-dueioo. nvrcoar morilrioD dddr ftn ro vor!.Io. or.

ir3. "Shce r:rY p.opl..uDor lo<mu6\ v?ight Do olnd hor hrd deyq od pomodv (grin vhii*r in.rdr 1o$.' .h. .dno$ oi lrr ru"r Erg 6t hmat tJ')tuiht \.rl)\ oD

doo:{spe on did dubl spcrid rbod,

mftd to b. on tk ords ol s3c biiLoirc sjo bilion }!d! n srcd $rhoodd ir$.? rlh. Pininho e [email protected] bv tn. inm.dh& ud bngiblcas.qucDrts of obsiq vho hnt er.,1co.eiubl. Ddiilr'ion cm( {oPil.c.ks nlm snlg rhci! \ev id ix-o6i. *6* hope n .h.E 6! the rr oisl

In dr rinin! [talr. thcr i: ,o,i.,hiig.dcd GNrDod S!id-E.-l

iior bflin l.ioi: orJ.hiNdai brrn u!u*.1 p$ioi io. eiicg Ti< i aldloue \E d.d6.d ix r c*ft issre rtih.jduo,l rv@rg', ioJ n\r iriidoon.*!nin-q!' u!@!NU?nL obrsion \i$inod +in!.,1bv ts \riins *ecs 1peri.n mdrphof ior lh. ra. rL.appft ii lr trd.onrclhble odn$ior

!k nAmni.ln socicft r rvholcH.ft ir a did edn ton . CoummdSrnd.om. p"ricot, r 6}n-ik-!ar oldsbk. vi.dm {ho hd pErioslr' dn-p1i1td no Eoft ihm l prrtuiaon io

".u rlo; rr!!.ir Thq!l -! q'.

1.&, J;.dld-se dn5ici brcshr

r $ rd;ibdi I( E;ri& .\ f.'i +Pi

hrid Gnb6e$; rtunrh h. qid"'

rh. e$in r.-n.d.;.ian? di -id.ior. 1]; !rcm! pc8 .rie rion rh! 6i

Ts L\{! ao *r siv our oi !s p@b-t kF: Eles r.s, millions oi.{Dsi.s bN bek oudiring n.{ rppmkhsid dtrriiiod @d &d. n*lv il otwhi.he bsd oa rh. idd 'hr o,monngor ob*$,or \irh rood k riv jusi rn1ft* orr.hdjque rbr th. i+r ituns

cEd n h.a moE drdriollr )Ppo(ha(o .udno. hN. fail.d. .{ aDi! *o!ldel of.oEq rhr rh. *minglY odl6slpplv oa ih6. bools pdrs 6en hckofdnacy, sina iforc oath6. dnc sd:tLv wo*ed dd. uolLl b. od ntd6! dodlL Bs ihir's dor qur i ,,11:tu dl, th. n.dic,] *hblihm.ri roo,hs ber qivinq -Ara.nrd dusiiioElx.ue $ioua ibL .Fc( we hrr

c]]ona thii we bun, tha nr *n.ot10$ w.ighi ifw do.t (dn. oNn

!n<$. rd nicd 6dd doss hsi.l inrbsh qs<$k,rndtu6 hdP o wnoolfcucn rhii hbe G gsd 0d 5ugi r

in $hlr bnd Thd aN ofc E

Page 4: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

361. r rtuili| a:ta\ :h, drir n tirh:: r!: ::q q ;:: :1!h or 6. r&i<\::i::! rc:l.i.i i:: au,: ands bse:i! ro!i3: ro,tirn Dni booki:ad.!a! Ii: i:-.: cn:n tov ori.trft n.cicd orio-f. h5 b<n wolsn d.,sr !h:r];ioo is m(oo nsn:..5ltjmrl i:r n!fth linding o4

. .]Jarbrr rh: n.i FPlru dif dairc,omedr. b::.:ncl., n orE in,Eaid by the bi'.:iaoton.-' b4oa-rtr 3ftt Se:r Siij,-?i4r b;.j.."Ti: ZdD.," \!i:i ljtb BiU Llko.sord I m ion :od ! InicoPilr andh5 *! tnnditlt::rc foun<D ho_q!tla Hi, {tu-l boof "|l4kr i<, i c z o m ' . 8 5 0 . : : b a r . [ < L _ aror !lc.d {(k ll:{ionn: a rumocdto b. oD lh. zofr di.r. ind so 4.Hd\ai Scn ad Pcid.di Ctinion.aad iilou !:ltr ;r :li6t anv mdorooosrc rn th..ounr* nshr low

booli'zon. ?cjrq vhls ii Nriouainill qdr ticF b. l4d&d on IdtrpiY hbt. D:r J. tori. Thev ii.mbiiious bools. alt.d *irh r.inicildi ;lois dfaooi ci:misB, ocnbo-!n,lbhoM, L-:o4 ud ohrru.h:.ji sddEr 4 rp@idv k4inqs P-doad.. id.: ii;adtowh ck6inra:.d(r d -J:. icr Powrfin hdubror:Ious dtu< r. ;tnti ri{d" k lan.nr!: a kind di h::l-.*ci€n6j dPritul

Th. !c b .tr:::iq rh. zon.,.c.ddii? rc s.u. :: [qtnis]our.u6o-hrd.:ks. wh.' E! * .;Lohilnr5,hq .-:, \!d si-lrr{h. PddKnoid f 5 r i . r d n s i r ; r h o m o i ! l h r

I t

"Wll i.flf,I Ute dn $z nm aid Ilound a tbat Mite fihlatfit 'tL. alt /b! n,E, i!Lo A nulz |fttub,ttr'

dii rcSdn* ihi sbrrg€ oi.n.gr PE

noc.ubohrdfts * d.P<ode.r oD Jlknds of rhings. iidudiag hon, rir ro!aE md {hdh.r lik mi dnb cs.rlu hre x gtold. pcdnPqniotr oqrdiistrli i erGanc. c<!.,:l i rPotn3.rh< harilr fd ForedroarhrPcrc!

rdd.n ob. Th. pi; h-. r;.obL.-,,nh ob*ia hd $r n:k* rh:n erobL.m qir. di.bdc .16-* .h.;,|.\qv buid Hsh Lrsk oaidslli i nih. resuk df obanrl :rhs ncor $eeuf oiob*in whcD I Gd rht i!-surD ,cdotr of-Thc zo'r'b c<ddRe,ci, m .m.lirus roliso of medicii. r sb.tld u-;6in *ho ir rlnqyr<dg.d b bc th< counn! liidi!{i",,lb aped, I .o,ld h.i. hi6 sn.Ji,;hi .*h.r h.d.h. op"n."- ;i b.inion r FDd did$ion $th S.rs. id Iourdri be[.v. ih< :turl tnr come omof rhG gNi.oourh," h! srid "t ihink

whn ses woutd h$r s b€li.r n!h* vh.o n com* b wcighr lo$ rcu!bddy trsK som< NndsofrJtrn5 ditfd.Ddr ircn o.Ien-thrr th. .ombinlnon oa rhe i-@d lr {i n noa di-.rr ihrn ih! rmounr. To lhn .od, helnc *hr he dlr ro ,lmriig'and

rn, ldlurion is i dt4 in \hich *honFECr nlk uD io nort thm foapd.a! ofdl-otoiB @sum.d (6 oplPs.o ro h. tu* Pi ad or no& con-sun.d q mo$ i4.iQnt, *nh frrrd ?'bun .dni1s ro rhirry F. anr4.h \hinni'iig L5! Pftii tour ro$r.: ndo b.Ndi rubolrdnks ndprci.ii n, in 5!6'r o?i!ion, diticat tork.:9r3 iosuli' ; rnkL "Tt. zoliiiduda ! tlindr o: complicr.d in-

sdcdons tu hdo erdds 6M o\ howo do ihi"ss lil. *1."h; 6.n mtq* Pro€m lrquuEE.DF In R$unnG('sew;rh rh. e@i',usiiqr|1c B]Dofrbu. h"nd . i gud.. Th.:-d.;t oiPrcEi! lhr.3n li( inid Fr pnn nErllv lor plokiD block Thr's abouron. chick<n brc*r o. ] ourc dic.d

l( shourd b. sdd a\r lhe tind dfdier5 i 6 a q g € , s , r p n r i r . n ! r i , L o BFollovrnq (n. zon! di.r.rluu drto6ofnba, iitsh i!n. ftsh rgdibt!5, rrdhsh. bd v.. lnlc cd m<r Cood rutsrition. rho;sh, noi rc.llv lhr pdiars.rsi u3lmmr n rhr b.iig in rhe

l.--L\x. 5v .dffi;ri.g cr6oh\d,;ried th. prtdu(ioo ot i'sulin Eg $DbE* bu ob$$ion wirh ao.d ud 6rid1h.ohllv d'( rh. vlY rcur bodvft .k..w;ish, r".... ; rj. m oig;ing md usualv trushring sm€L rorror p6Plc," h. wi{es.'In d. zon. nis prir65, a!ro* auromad.,

Do4 rhe zon. .nnr Yes rnd no.c.nJnt\. I ploF ! slr oM3 J morch.JihfJ di{.h.r'[ |!d b.R( rbolrtn.oslc. Bur ih. ider .hr lh.c ;em.ihing m:gnJ rho!r [epre nrdn $irhin r rp< 6! rrqr 5 J Ldr{i.dg. lnsufii n si^ph. ho,mdn.

YI

llr$

Page 5: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

$ndia:a flJ! ru5:i:hec ii re!6 i.lh. Bd:n m.&!;r!rl roi--: lI(,;:ouli :, : ,,pori L\:: tu b.$ @robo'rtirq.i::r;t he ::n rF< ui unhhec i! ne inm iFa:6 ou ) ri tlr; iF r.uci! oir!!!di$ oEPdi

llion ;1:-de tF: i{ah io fai mdroEiD ari lo* 'n ciiohldnft1 udri,. *.ond lo\v in ;: :nd porciD andhieb ; r:-bohtdaE-d M grcupsol ob$. n n. -qJft ri.hr B tu d$3,Lh. mo on th. lov-rs5oh\dnE didhid 1os: nor wiqht lhn Lh. m.n o!th. hish-dbohrdnG dl.! Sld con-duds n m rhE ftd! L\xi il r€u r@tro 1os \.igh ]!u ibosld $ PrcGi!md shu ftibohldi$ {.adlr! nshow5 nodinq of d. :on cebohY_dnH psmoa uE! &.!'iod: proEiorE !k a diurctu. Oq I wll or sq$neode oo r hish-P5€in dtt 'ill J_

highL.-j'hrdne dn:. .i-pl' b.dseof d.hriaior \Vh.a : Jmilx ndrvr conaucctl s.:d rab liar (_rrrch.. rilnd (tu xn! $om rh€.(RLs-rh<D n\r .R:s oi,}hdnndnhld atD:d ouF(h. !.th( lo$ on ft.No d;: Ns lnddlr idc!ftrl Th.kfl Gr: how lou {:. in olLrd ftrdiii! ho\! fluch $u 3: Cdoies, lot!]Iboh,inGs, r! siil l r'hd nlRcaTh. diir li.J. *dti oi fte zori svnrn is :::r. d6pn. Su6s.xPDstulFios db"d inruli. ru h. hG dore is.one u! rirh rnol\.: 10Y lJldne didH. do.;i ,lo lhe od ior ht lddds.br !om: nudionn6 h!. .rlcftEd(hn if 1,u tblLoN Srr! pc,diPnonsit[giN::r rlu n hr. h r m6t sad_tdd hlilad inod., 1 dr! $d r trv_enE.o iudrd ilod6 r div viru.nyrn$m .u loa i{ighl Th. Pioblem*irh 1os cdo.n di*5, oitouse, i, Lh!o dD. en nry or n\.o toi very loDsIur a( Ss. "DnR b$.d oi ddn. €sdicrior ud .non. !ni6 uuinv 6n,"h! mEs in rhe tlood .hlPu of'Th.zonc_jEi d he n dout io pt$nt hsM.t!oic-esd.a!d f d.do'i.-linitddl.L "P:opl. o. Esoidnc ais g.t 'itdoi ri.iiii: hung. ud dcpnv.,l. They

9 off dair d dr Pr .h! 4 snr nrroi lPorol\ n m.dtu hd\ ri both!! fcl bld rbout ih.nstv* hr odh.lins .Dq3h wL! pova, dieiplin , o.

Tha: r. tror, ho*ri lhe kinds of.ondri{ioi .hr. *6 t bdrhd Ss

Hi! 5J$ b6ir dN irki dinr L\n i!d! Zoi. rou cri "'d< Fd seNtcddC hd :bd more lrt r fthirE Tvt5u bv etlosinq.' Bv de dE. h.! 6inh.C,:.m bls itld up his djd * Iherr$q ro Yi-.&!f otn-me'li.rl in a!._iDs\\tndn sei.n: ism hrr dis**b cancn an,l on ro rlcoholGm dPMS. H. \ds, _Di P.uL Ka dr.sin. phrri.ili Bith lhoE I dil thciDs pilor study'---y4, S!*: d isiu* n\. rbioq 6r ss, too-"told reri. *ory of;m o! '"s pNiedts, r 6J9'

Prql os hd on r Zoe llrcsbtr aE.Mdrfr;rE\ nqi& o^ d! orclFn 3h.

;4r E' -Grcn'\oijrii! rhi,n. ".

h . r ' , I l F u ' K f t d i 3 s 9 o , L h ' J { ' q

dn,Ni d4<b2hr \19 rh< !$n- hJd

h r , r l h : i r ! b ] d , r l n . - i . d

Pd dou !ou! odoh\dEt' md ,!drll.;t;,i. sbn ex,ling tht5 sid oa

ftiDg. b *c1r. th. condusbo thd.h":G '"id i;. di.i boo[ som.h"*dlr$ l!$ rhm hN iri s.id s.s,rid rll, isni tlt on\ di.t sp.cirlGrvho rcdr ro b. nxkiog things uP.Thev rU *.m o be Daking ding5 uPBur iard na r tu3. nunbq oi PoPu_l!' diet books i! su(*sioq rvhlt ssrikine G thr d.v !l nrm rc b. Dak_ns ih;ng. up r Pre.isd' rh< aLm.en

k i5 i frh. djd-boor +nft hjd ,ncffpok d *r oi nuniE ruls $d.o'v<nrioiq ud.ll Ihr nltm E ho\Yikiltnlv ihon tu1.s .nd converrioo'm db;d rc. Sd, ror {uPlq b.qins GI6l] dd dspddd.ni hn hL\dacd of r h<d r(sk n 6ffr{h!=, r\ftd oiDroods" dd hh h.d.

Judy Moro'iE .liior dl Tl. tuceDi€r R.pbd' (thcc nooihs di ih.

"izs barrud !n), cls us. 'I {*

riEE dr. l3ftat ldd in rhr cl*s. indI tn; iie pn! ihrt ooF r lir l:jd. i n k n o q . . . I v t i l w r v s t h c t l *ooc rlucmtl' ciot! for iie Err''iuMiD K:on;. i! his bsr+ld ThcRohrioD Di.!," vit*. "l .rg od. oathd* fn kids rrho hrd no m.mdfl oi.E! bqing L\in ldneld. t hft memo'is $lh s oo! bons rbl! @ run hn

LAU6H ATTACK

a l-riro grositrg rf ii l\s!ti|;Jdrs Legunbo *n(rhrorgh Hdl ir r g3:o Lie

rpofts cor :nd Lnd b lrugh 3bour r."You sm b. .nd;g. 6m,'h. sx,ssp.aking oa ih. rrc. ihugs ud dthsroring $ls oi dsnvd he !n<$cd*rf h; til irr.'Iflou hirc 1lo, orhrd aoovor( in..;c"ii rom. r '.You dnrm $.n.'whlPpd thir ud{rc. nrr rhr d.n€d L.g!'nmo

"ho r h gh ^hool w$ \o<c \ro'l.ik h rc B. IIo$ Tilkarive. hs ettrd t u ; i u o . s n n e H s ! d o r t 'm r n ; h ; q . . I L m b o ] l o ! r h i d"Spi. O Rrma,'won hid irt Gio*

rhelrr 'c"

r.s h. hrsben r grn9r,i _ c ! h @ s \ \ ! . r m n 5 . s r i ' ! h ' r o

wons loo, Th);k 6r Ercorhjng Juri!r_.;!": r dlalrnt clovn r'6n H.uin "SplLn , fd rh. 6:n TY5.lt iD "Ro-m.o rnd Jdid

_ BuI lh. gldi l$lt iD_,bebdrrnsion oihiDself thr he pl.ls

His oa'd on. nro tdc'pr*,-!c*." G bin.d s r l.Di_d.mi quu-pscudo iurcbiogilphi: it! a io'ossojoun dow Lrdno mtmoa hr. irrth. Coa Tl"lft, oo Bbd'qr oP.n_ns Febru!n 1:rh, Fur L.guzrmo,

,F; +ow . rD uEdor iohLLo-.\ngds "d,ntur

lr,Es B.Emqrjndol

do sondhioq to 5ib me b! In. brxr

@i'dd n I c.i6c nimi., md|t m;* LiL. i poiir guud ln "I!e*,'F. rddios hlrs io 6. rudnn&dn cdl dour his ubql.nr lniidhoon:r olhq iims, ui(h hn P@dn Pr!ich.- hr inhdks (h. tlnnd, rdd cl-rir$ whd sowd hn mcmory Ht s!n eior vidt I coo.dius \4Y sdwo.ds. Hr d*dibd thr lvo.ldo.olord wrls d th. onnge mohlr.@d df bis p$o6 ho6.,'Thd*€q"4 b --irn" L\. insid. or 1 Prerq_AmonR rhe Diov r<doR. ic

;d." w ', -.,b*,1".'gtu "ai'is r th. Foqrls.d Sfts Kod.L1Ii.d chi.len *h.t he oot woikedI 6und out lhrt th. .tlil ingtdi.n.

JHO\CAJE BI M) VI DUII'L

Page 6: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

'Dr@ rdt b:irl:ttr&a^r

scs, itr hG Jei ri!.puhlh ?n:tchni "riiu * d lnlio; dir,,.The proplo:n.rdi.t.r D<iy iid 6j,

thjag. Bur ii $uie edili rjiis bouti.r.oundbrblf llnoN L\n .h*! dnE d. ,:krIY woiL" Wbv dod I rh.f \q\r B:eK dor\iobc ih! bsi. biorh.hnrL[N5 Egur.d o.Ddlh. zoD€ " orhsdi.$ donr ha. dncieuo. Th! Zoi.dos. \.t, he add!..Tie b.!uN oa,F.di(m sLirE prckftd in th; hdo\ ntn1r n doddi q! for I 5m de.t otihc kiid oiuoEltsn. *lf-;si6e thrauss oanr P.opL id fer otr dr. dnr\',s!r ...tntr,t q!e!.nshoy \!uhq 6 sh,.ithi. Ihc. di.q oil.lir$ !hI. 4nre * ad rooi;nru-nnE' Ir n rh. vln dh.ioh. of d.Zoo. s]ftn th xlows iu rd[q.ni rclok wighi *iiioqt disciplin..

Or.on'id( u\is 6nn Addc puh,irRdr eulhy b6ra!u.4 N ltc 5 Dfr4i!er! D.L'AD.nB! Nd 1 dr* frni.+.uln*,n $r Fuh3r rc da;r

aiLbuns do6 Fq ror ;(!]l 4(Lb q h l t r c n r d J i c l b o a l b o u . ; h ; isi,n.n forr hnc !n. FslLf 'd i!

n hr|td. lrorsiq so odr c(! rcu !,. u r . o a i u $ u c e n s r c r r ! f ; d r :enF P cd !,r{ d; bioii@r1,,hn6x.dujq{d nn, B{ro a. j.Dr

Ld 6 Pu. ui iq d.6r.h@&dod foq d.SEr d.snd dpL sii*6k..,d th4. few aot.ne: (r) rh.id.r inr dnr inrrclY4 saiiir. is 1hrd: (2) :! di.c, ro b. sk, sy dlr o!rh& di.5 dGitrg vithour ndi6c ijnor r Er1hj (l) bm vou bdjew rhd di(dngrilhor!oiF(!1 mrrhj(r, jdI roo,b.L.qd,hn d qbq qrhodin!.iin( ir 1 ord (j) bkG. in fk, o! rdjds di.dB liihdut *dilic is 1 n)tnr(6).a€pr oi my d;i, whd. di.tinc

Th. erposnolt rqu.n; tfin ih$<bools foldrllr onc pi:k!d, no-n.ni oa .Dlighknmc.r, Irrion olihc one ft. kr6n.llv ooun6 tonothiB l.$ rhrtr !.o.Kion nmtiv..lD aGprion md eYeddon, ddbooks !e df-.dnddct ih.ologi.d.(whod aid Hw.v Dirmord m.4.ftcr his imputsiv., ;6ps e dnsidib Smh B-b!r? A mri h. \!ni oDlr

edoush ro keg uP viL\ or plaYmrs,sng d!{n hn aor dl gafr6 rhr (

o{ olthn drkn*r @m* lishr:ft. EurcLr rldo.ir.vh., ih. ru;-e\phi6 ho$, b: stuEbGd oD th: adj.dh d . h r r D , p n d h n d ( 5 1 6 o u o dh i m { r f i ' h . l , b i i n o f r h ! 3 0 ! r o nunivdsir sliool di ]].dicitr.. Qdirg d.nlnirs h! ould otr $t rbj.<ri.1md ro PEloncPnons, no bR oaturyredr b will bm. $ I Qd o.cqlhins.I $loarty om! (c$ sob(uc repoft . ." REhrl H!u* lho\.! r !o ilrho.016. bsr,.ur!: TLrc{bohJd'rc vd,n_ on. r;d nqa.ru., s Lr 9owjig !D +r 5h.e !\16 s. hyon. pn|!d tor rh.

Qn), ws 1r bne in bed {heD f-docro. cr!.d, p!{poairg h( :ppoi!.mht ld rhddy *ri€ i, morim m4hdn0 .hnn df 4tnr (hn i!vokd rd Pumj54r, I cae[ itd.lnd nb F!.od conldsi "t wiu J\s\b: grrrhd fof du pherrsjg..

'8.u. ton k oough o rtrcqitrr

oolThis riB! I dd I b.tiBt n nEd Dvlli.' Hsty Dirnond, lh. roru.io;d thc_rhi.oi[ioF&PF*ning "Fnro! Ldr. ws rr l musn GYieil oYo

rho*iid mit* ado hooe, vtco h.irPP.rld o ov{h.r dvo p.opt. inIo( oririfr dise$iig ih! Liod; or,trnid i, sd! Babhi " .L.c. n., I)nkRPrd, vho i5 !\is f.uM )n! 4dii$i;igl ln tlr thitr s.nfr roui60u6 I *5 0n mv \hr iq S3nE 8..bxr. Lid. dld I how L\* I B ondr. b'inh of oo! oi rh. dd* Emnk-

The Eu*a nto;.ir is iitdwed,npi.ru- $i,htn r ri! Fe6, br ihcPrhr cLm-h: Fin, r; qJl+ dr.rurhoi showi why his Elcu Nlom.n!lnnh +]!c ho! vliqhi 6n b. tonvilhd( ndia. i5 difr.en( fbn iheE@kr ltoocni of I ihc. o$s dnrbok $hidne ho\r wtisht ru b. Ionvnho( ;cdn;. Trrk i!

_hrdd thh n

3pFu: Di.r6 @ rruIy idrEd b& ider of disciptin., h.dw th.r, !r,dibut ih.L oidiiloo h ! hllw oadn-tiplin I'! ju{ ibr( dtt, lnow rh.dds kn.'oush io rdt?. thlr ifidie( qun4 difiPriD! dr4 wbnt br$L b rouo\e ir Ir.h. smc dmq otors., $ri r rhi d.rr Edizd itur!6r h! jr loolins ror--.di*iplti. $ih,

sibk h: sill d;s, td rh. hoPe thii$ncaay n frilhr b! Tb. Pneni clinos(,:3oiin! borh Pnddv' Hcc n

Page 7: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

ideaini pnudoiymoElt ed oFrtliou5i.i 3s llajcn*n, u &hdcal hgw

ofl.r rnd wU prcpodoDrd botjr:_)ft i5 lh. rDp'op'irnon oidris t[gosirftile L\n Pnmft Lh. sEP€nsion oi

I;..11 .his in rh. pilitologicd LianrFl pheron.iod lhii nighi b.

r .d dc Phoro.opi.r tfi"d. atr( dr.c\p{iE.!6 oid. Haud s€i:l sieniii lUen L:ng.i Lrng.r mdin.drhc appr.idv .dlrnotEsd ida lhxtif }!ua tfling rc pdsudE @m.on.io do sofr.L\irg lor hu, rou e ,1-uy5 b.ft r off if vou pidid. 1 iecoD.Sh. went up to a s&up ofptopte !:ning in lin. o use ! libs!-' lopvirs Da-.hirc ud s.id,'Exo$ mq I h:v. 6Y.p.gs IIr I uk ilr Xdox nachiiei'Skv pe' cent sid 1*. ThcD sh. t-pdrd ih. d!*m.n( on rdhq

quN rc 'Ers* nq I hm 6!. prg$.Ihy I u* lh. Xe6x mxrhinq bms.I n i! a ruh?" Nin.ry-fdu pd .enisxid Yd. Thn much $unds lrlr coD-^.":.nc, ilyou $y,'Becaus I m i" .rush'-ifFuqpldnvourDEd pcd-p1. m wiling rc n.p sid. Bs hneivh.€ ile sddv gds incr*i.g. Lan

im., in thn a* (pleliDg (he spdice*on v(h r sFEneft olrbe ob\ious:''g1G. Eq I hrt 6re prgs. Ihy lur th. Xdq Frhin. b<caus I hrv.io mxL some copns: Th. p4rotlgc

a(dv rhe 5d. * rh! on. in d. pcvious round 0ncn{ht. Pr..nt.Thc klY b g.ting popL io ey rn i!orh{ wo.d5, wisni ih. eiplmdon'6{N$ li! i! a rusli but E{rt tieur da li. wod 'bmus.'whrt F*--Gd wsri ihc subsan.. ofiie .xplanaiio! bur md.ly dr lh.bndl lotlFrhe coljunaion,r rnotprili br rn

'lsnt thi hs di{ bmk wit'r Co'

sid( dr ronNing pegnph, bkn r

I iPddn.e66J4Poigilhcld

r[! sho( a;sNc bcft;i d. &wriq eu

eld d! r;4Fdi5trE. oFbiin(5 or ihq

Dd;r \.6 ]J$u dni fouow lMi5er! L n*ie Jbom rc'-folo$irg!nrrJ, rh. pon.l,6rnesh fitrr h.

TF iid. is uv book $r d.ins .heI did cm, h(mt( n k _Dr AdiniN.w D; ReElurio!.'Hrie i lh. 6F.mioi ludr r is au*. Di A*ins,r humbL @trddr phdci4, n fLr' ( lhd L\r. chins ") H. h.3iN sdlhirgftr riircc. ("Oft .Eoirs I md $outihe vork lhr D. Cridd Dui.m h:ddod. in Nniddo n rh. UniEsis oaF.ni$lqnjr Fning pdito$, h! c-p o m d , o . r l a s c o a h l n g n x i (ibra .qhr hou. " or rood Thnn!ii?,i m.. . . . Thx d!6.d 1@c.") H.ci! hn qsdnhodoi lies oo hids.li:A itbY m{!q hr loas weight H! tschis uoonnodox 168 dn r soup ot .x.cutivs r A.T. &I As if bY m.gic.rh.v los v.ish,.Inmdiblc h. h*cod. up wnh r dnt th*'Produ(ssodv {.ishr lo$" {hiL aiii ig"nolmn on th. amomr oa lood you .an!r.' In 1972, i6pi&d 5v his lision, h"Dus rc! rd rle.. Th. tsu]r is 'D.

liki;i Dn;R;'!l '. i".. ' di. or thc6irj- b* rn3 6ooks oa rl dfr.. In

thi.Mlf iineri<,. he Dubinh6 _Di

ArL;i \aY Di{ Rdriutioo -hirlidn5 md. rhrD !\a< mi[,o' coPilr lDd! on ih( L-. b6rnn{ ilr ror rDor,dl oi r99t. \loft l\3n Mo desd$ oi{iedric rcstrli iNo hc.,lJt md iud,ion hrs .bfrd i. rh. inrtan brA*i!a o*sac h6 rndn.d th. $'nc.CIbohydnti d sxd. Erclthiis dkii qoo,l. En thr hDbu€lr hold th<ts"r Fr Ae nal. hdld $e Fcrchtiie! H.rc n ihc L* of iryrcdnnc lorore of his brl|&r lrishr lo$_ tcodmeid*ioos: s@bled eggs 6f 5irIG.p i! n;d rhl idlls is pobrblr,h. no{ iDnu<Dril di€. ,lodo! ii lh.

r [d sws6 1& ar 6!1 4r!^ r!

,{*itu Pli.r ChiE am's oD themrgjld wighrlo$ prcFnn' or'$m.ihlnq cd.d "kdo5n." Wh.D wu dr rrboh,vdnrs, rls bodv snErts tbrminrc qlvlog!d rid nocs rh.D tir. tdls* Ilrcu G dlpnltd oicIbobrnIits.h6rrs, ]!ur boJr hs ro rum b nr(,N sb&r oI Ii( litl m6dt tir .ndg-rl.A.norg n\! ir,m.dir€ D<nbolt Podu.c oi ftii Er sElkidvn c kftons.

c:lii

/

k"Mv 'try/t i il l, rtuSlh {h. b@N rn rLt "

Page 8: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

orr 50$ trljr !:r hri o s iJ o;ri.n qb:r $,otgi $. tt jJn.r :,uin!, or iirou3h ,n: thgs. by dl,idii(. I D P I l [ : o L ' @ m i ] o r J r 5 o - d r

E 0r ri. f rh: br+rcon hd hrr..'dr rhx snlul ljl. rcrh ropL.s. K*:onr tu 40 cnc d. ft! ofi;r ilrcu..ft._r.": -n4b! iid."i Eu t u l g t r h < n d i B - m s a ' b d h .bi or rli*nis 1*. Pqssiuq mdr o c ! m . I r . E L n o d o l b r r h n ! o ! o .0i'!t ghr {dn: lo!E m |4o1, 3!

R:hd thrpakin xnd tI*! rips bcr,'@om rc! u qu*lr b!{m:d.i 4,r( :tu cDP r'(n pdnds crr r o u q h \ r r c . 1 0 . 5 T h < f t s o ;Pobrdn oto rof sopcic. And,fjbudo $hr lcnni !\, {d addlrnf oros Itrtu t" 3u ruboh,dlrA ';_u! M. q i,i jc aol bu bodr bloEPssre 1o! arl tilo* ton r,td b\ d:ne!,ds drn pr4.ir jd far TnR:gn.b" rnr pdn1i.,r, ihou"h Ittr ilev{:k Fr bodv dj66,;nd dr.\rlghHrd FE aPp.ir_os brL

ro. Ariir, ho\tyd, kfto5is n 6

_.:rgirfrl3,:1JJ l.rrrm! - Llhilh

oiinci fD::.:.:.1r. (To xliJ bilrs tr<co-:iGl5h3lhtoio!:r,' ior.ri:r: Purn ri. &o$trrri rrsh!i:-- r rn LD.r: (o rltdo:is lomolir!:r ir. r:tdEflcodsr-?du blood r:i: ) somrho4 hr hrftsin(J hiftltjrr hir Cnd.ak$o:!J n diFertor i:a $: b1d :iDd oik.

l.id rc p{mb.: vaghr h$ r,vhf hc!5iils tnir, hoNr:r i; a li.J: uGLfI!'Di -{ilnn: Di.t Recolurion.h:$ought thl th! i:! \r i i d. nrnywiDr io 'ti b::50m:'Htrodcdr oi.roles {c !n::r.d olr oa }!uf 6dJvcr.r 6ry i' .!\! :o;n if ksois 3Dd rhon oforhrt in!:iot Elr brokm dowDnor.ulrs da h \bu m djsqosinq ofrhd. clroi.s zr,rv \b* or viole!;.r-.tur-bmjsr a! bEnlinq rd rndwiog !u kid.:r: .o iri.tio;. Aj ihis n4 n < d m f d ! : l q E i q o d r c u di o i i d o k 5 . L L q r u h i . t j . , h . j € rdd rh{ orj3ri:i .dnio! oI AtkjntMkch.oq::ltmrtidollednn,r5o.i:rioa publl:h.d :d.y6ariiqcj-nqu. ofnls ih.c!; goiltiig our ;oDq

n{ft i!D:5. rtrn lmr lorer j( $t!ii,r! ioJ rhe brnr rkty.\!.:,1 rhjnLrrcl !or, r drL r gufdo rh:1 . . r . _ o o , r . r o l r , h i , . o u l J D o iPo5nbq r.dqr nf $e dro:rj. Fulndrim:d;r s!.h di.a - ltr .DL i-riir.).( Dier R.Ni!I;o,_ mi ailjnqn,

m l l r o l n r n , o [ i ! . h ( h , n ! h :.rr. Fi \Job,iLz nx sLb504.! isi1cE, \n.i r i.kniew.d hin. h( oh?da n$v br?oih{is: ihn ldosn h\smor .nn$ dro cooylnr;Drl GodEErlbo[im do5, md ihr n i, .: fr(htr$ thoe'r Pdvry ro b(n ue llr. r o k ! \ n ! , n h r d r 4 n . ; , , r urcf bf h< ddnr $rn o b: o,or.ildde "Nobody ft crnr bei ;bL b\dr; od drr n<chrnism i qlu s l\o,!d hn. l .d.. hq loncJn

Atl!'r ii 3 bic, \trc haiad rr iohn hi. si\i*, Ku ov.! 5i{ ri4. wid adri! <trn rnd J 3run, hrd .dsedr o c u n d . d I $ ! m r . h ! { } L q rmq i hish trP:t.d 6{ buaoi bnl

h. co'rld h. ,ors,l ri. d. shdF: in a59?9n.ft rlttu'. H. i d inrifridn,n3 nguq bs mrordbosqu. xod iD

Prno( H. giy* ih: rPE$io! rhn h. doeri.r trhnid-:ro€xPhio ir deo,is $r h€ 6.dr th. ddJtr

cih -"hr Phobspiq Ei-

aghi ThsrpP.ime;if

nsLt: Bui litljG *.d5 0nk ihis Pirdot. tuthft

For .!mPl., id - 1rr.nPr b conio( hts nd-ds $r eldng pd* choPs.ncrkr, du.k, ud n.k ofrDb ; lburdoa ir gmdror rhcm, Aikins PdiD6 ouidr pimiriv. Erkioo on-oEs hrd litudtv m h.udk6q dsPn€ I hiqh tudnr of iish 1nd art;.ilBur ooe osYious elphn?rioi aor th. Estino pr:,dq G thir cold vr{ ri<i10d *!l mer c lich inn-lrinydds ale"$od"

d. dihn hfJ, k (h in$iunrcd h(-rh. 'brd.

+

' fL na tu dtkt aj)ut o.dkg b,. :.t taLl-

Page 9: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

::!d ,i i:1. Thr dnr6, 6s lome itri:f:.dr 6-r.rn( ofwtnch ftpF

c Dor n rie iid oibra rld dw Fr.!d gndr. u! euqhl id l.donudion& \nLi!d[,{&ns hr rv[ote.htrprion Ji.ar i:r. ii Ndw Di, R.6l,ioi@d do.;i n"k rb. drsd$no! orc!.{l d;nbook authoG rE6r ircn drPhoid.oPi.! EF( rr*ins rsn.

1 Mtlhrd AtkiDs reenv * h. .ondudcd hi5 d,ilv on.-ho$;adio shovo! Ns Yoik! \,!rEL0 W. wd. in 1Mann3rd r(m hous in rhc E6t Fif-tns, sh{. h. ha Ur hadqufts, i! 1d4lc modmin o€ie 6!.d vilh lddd6nnidr. ud $aPs6d. <ulpur. H.sr b.hiod his desk John 1VaI0! inhddphoi*.- his prcdKd pdn.di! &oft oahin. ft {6 a bclu D.rforms...li! 5poke quicl<lj, lnd asilrslu.irg d his ndd od!, bn.dla udth.n d.fdv gav..ou!<r ro tisrcnns

Th. 64t cdt cm. &.n o!o,g.. orhi5 cu phore. CdIg! &ld Atkjns hnc'io ot riglrdids io chol.ndol. Irw*ot sood. Ceolgt wa , y.!y uo-hnldry ms. You a in biB @ubl.,'Arkic sdd."Yo! hn 6 chaae bd di.iwhii do Eu s?o.c!l,.if wi*! Fusidld?sli"

-fq EPFJ br$sju+ 6odr,"c{q.n r ! r d o n r a t ! r y 5 t d o n r o , b m i . ''Th!o dut!- Se dd.'AdiB rir.b* io .spd:dod. "whf Jo Eu h$r

'l h,R d:in Di[! eE]. lid b.ma."Thd\ kru aii! Al](jB.odanr

bc[(. dr* in ihis dd ud lg. Plogr.wr s,in ol)3ujng 6!ii md skim mil|_'Tlri hsv bu re g.ning inrc rcu-bl?l . . . whtrt ,!u need ro do, G.o€<,seiourly, n g.i ahold oa N.* Di.rtudunon fd ju* Ed whr n ers.,

Ai[ns bok uorhn .dt This dEqii B 6!n Robe4 aonfone yeG dl4drc huldr.d pound!, dd PGi$€dof a fomiddle B@Lryo as!!L H.E d*p.oE to lo* r€ighi-up o. 1Lac. {d l$t;r Ai6ns b rall iimdown. 't ieirv do;t know laydJnglbotri di.ii!s," hc eid "r'6 g.ring a

'ks r.IJ, very ds_v,'Aikd bldhi!, slliriing f6nly rc dlc so@i.

".1X b, inli, dhout idy Frnch

'Ad r6i $! $t ihft!, in r srhd. br

'Wd| ;ror to,rld so irtush liri[l thn . . Do ]!u [k! esgs ir themomirgr O. x .h4r omd.re,"

"Y*,'Robn sid, his vok. 11ion Eiddy viih nli.l He ..Ied *plrJog a [L eotcnc ofrnc c *.Now h< ws b<iog *ni rorh to !rch .4ebu l3 . i s ' t c r , I do r "

"lfyou jd,: e* rhai way,AdgNb ldbn ! . " ru .nh3 tlisnq pould5 oFin si\ monrhs "

wh.n I lia $iY.d * Arkins hadqwe6.$!n nb*s

&u otth. hdliq r ct m.dic,l

loDcocrioc oahi5 om canon 6 p.oph suffdiry nlm . wi.r,v oadisod.^.Srffing ftum in. 6Jd noo4 we v.oidM io rl. ihnd, md rh.n 6do tI.L\lrd b d! !@n4 aliig rn. eLBoiach rid. L! : sd.l poidt, bu. n didsrik! E! 6 oda dr* I shd,rra br i! th.hadquetr ot !\. rrcnds mo* populu v.ighrlos e\pe( md b. sklngd. ddror oir Soor d I dm.. Aft*vn.hiig {*ift rha I \hs *.dn douibvhiPub|ierl1tioDdsisfutw.wse on d. s4od Rooi He Prstd rhedlvror burton, dM. "!vhv dori vrtaft! th! 5:n5:" I6kd.lr {s jur Isuggddoi. H.looke,l r ne 3D,l th..{ ih. $ns ot dord doos xlong L\.ronidoi Ttiidv.lr he opm.d L\. n-ond. "l $lnl ihi n ii," h! sid, ud whddtd dom,6cr on. nighl md rhtnson\e. ,{r d. b*. oa rtr sEps .ru adoi Th. PL q@, a slcnd!! a.uq io ab.,uritu IEr{ 'ir, P4cd drcugh n:for dr. @m.rt, hc ru ur.dy 1os. Wcw.E i! d. bc.m€u It sen.d * iambody hd go& doq dok shi. in a

\ I /H \ 3 rc rh ! P ,m3 s r r . Th .v v esw. lhn drc,600k *ii

i* n rhii lir Pjm dodt €r 6 wn sthry u*d ro. B( rhd s Nh{ is uldn&Vwong riL\ did bmks. Tl.r i ts iftmd w.r ri. dit dr oadb.nqud ift oiry sdltriion. and w. knoq&omjun looking ri th. Pini, thrilidgs ft rd 6{ sioPL Tb. did of

lnePmr nbid. our io vo6c nrD rr

Lrs.ne s rll rlerlr'rui oi thr e\plh{ion ibr ui! obeiiq h$ h<omec!ia.oi! i! rc-ir r.La. Hrf $ r!o'A'dicus\al|ro$!rkt'&!r.ji.]sv.do Y.s :go ou $e ,4r psioJ.

cng! .rnuican .,E-' dN hs JrcPPld

d;$n. qthin *hy obain h:s hn 6ePim so hnd. dd.a s,e det doni klmio bc in) t $ niv. lho L\. rn df s

't-D. u\E4 0f cosq ; drn Ih{e islon.rhre bqbnd drr hd es.dr th* insulnles obairnh{ .r mak th. conrqueoesofu b:d did or ofr hck oferc.

ged.'ic ii]I;6e Chude Bou'rhsd, r pDri$oi df sd.id uJprcventive medicin. d ],avrl

Univ.cinj in qEbe. Ciq $d on. olrbc qbndi harnrs ob.si* sp..idnr,*ii6rs tlai w huEu bcio$ pbbrblr. ciry *vd.l doz.n gers tlu cdnccdv Elftd ro ou *dghi. "soEr?gd rpp€dt , som! !A@ !d!+ Soor3.tr { ndrbolic nre, some dd rh.peiiionjis oa.\cs cn.gv i. frr orLmiisr., h. told Dc 'ThcE & rlld

lf.djng phEiel {dnry b€1." Bouch:rd did I sddv lor long €o in *hi.hhc iook ! grcup of ocD or rnih!h.ight weighr, rd lifi sole sd olrfid n\.m by r inouend.xlon* r drrsixd s r rtek, aor t h!!dr.J drvs.Thd &orsr wishi Eu iD &c $apEs .ighcn Po!n&. Bur rhe nng.rE ftom of. ro v.o9{ir Poqnds.crcr\! L\. mm vho g]iedjun lindPo@ds wd. d. on$ whos gens hrdgiEn th.n d. fsc. posibl. m.hbolislFlh. on6lho hb ih. nos ..1on* in d:ily lirirs md ft th! l.ri d-6.iE!i r sbliog an. Ther @ porl.who hrrc ile .rn* rine 3oving 610.Trr. Gn { lhc oa- .id of ,Fe {deE clo$r to rh. Pinl io physioldg/.TAc; obsir/ g.,es rhrifti\ norcdavay .s mu.h of ih. ihousnd *n

Olc oa th" kd oks loJ g!o* +pc6 ro b. i. dd.minjng thr obesir-Y n$rh-s rf* b is $9oitr6. ln.nc d*sn .9!!jEcnr i! L\r fcld, c-scardrs t€k r group oln6 and nd.a sn( ot l.sions in ile bs. of $ch

Page 10: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

ru! bnn. As I rcrn. d. aE b.sli

obce rhrn Do@rl n(. Th. tus codd$ion n Phin: L\d. n a u,d oiih.cmo*lr i! ihc b;.in ih4 qoYcis 1DFr ud $dshi, {d ifrd .huge ;h.*nr'goi dn h.mshrlpP.nc mdwighr ,ix (hhB! n(ord,ngt- \lirh

rook : kroDd neP Th.Y rco[ (ho*she bEiodhlgld ns 0d Pur rhrEoo a dd. re!."tYDmi;,e iLe rEountotrood 1.r,.ou1i ff. w;i harp.d.drTl]. Es didni lor wiqhr.In a;. ind50mc inld,r flucodois, rhev.nded uPrr .ndl), lh. smc w.igh. r bc.oft.onr], dn iioc, bciq undtc b lmin.n.n i.r dr.Do,n, ktuq br drns.d.r rcrch.d n br' b(om ng tc$ x

ftn3 u.iv.Giry jn N.vYo* Pub[sheda hndnrk 5tudy *kidauy dupL.*-iig i! humrn 6.inEs ln?t had b!.ndon. v.rs igd in o$. Tlcy found rhrii] )ou ro( w.ight you body Rspondr

*.n to rb.k noE .Sciendx bumin?fdrr cilo.nr 6 do rhc s;! vo.ti'Ld',s ev Fu hrt N! Peopt., side bvsid., rd lh*c peopL. hs. dtdy lh.3m. bod" @mFsido.. luta tii$ch, rfrrnb{ of rh. Ro.k a.llq effi, svr."1tr.v 6odr w.igh a hudrcd md drspouods. Bdr lh.c is on! ditrernc-dr ri6r p.Eod huhj8 his weighr .f-roidc$lr wh c rh. Kond p.rdn, vhouad b wligh nvo iundEd poun&, ndng ro n:indn 3 row< veighi. Th.lcond lin o<d ffr.i pcr (!t t we,cdod.s PC dr ro do hG work H.n .& h$ os:c! ud yill bum 1.s .r-sg)."Thc body of$. seond P.Eon i3blckpEdrlling frliourly iD cspon* to3ll !5* los ve,gnt lt is doEg ftlysfg r .m b gu f bef, rn EsPoa.ro {.ishr p4 by ond$t, dr. R€k.ri:llq ro lound rhr in. body sprtdsuP mcnborisn dd blls nor .ltonsduinc cd!. l( Ei* ro ldr dur wrv.tghl Hmm b.j€s, Lit. dE, !.m!o hrv. r prd.rlnin.d point, .k;g[r L\r in"ji hodv |jn go b glar

oi. tri Prr,{ iD ,hb E+hrory$cm m:v b< r .h.micii (Jl.d t<P-

P!6ri!-whose dB.drcry lour trc*a@, bv leE_ Fncdm4 of thc Howrd

Hu3h$ iledkn Ini,ioe r Ro.[sI:Lrcr Unidsini rdhPd r nun] oi

bei! @ o( b{! or rpP.nc, o spcdup n{$olisn,:nd io bum rc€d 6t.Tl. ih!o* r Llr trr. sM! m4hoi50ru! N'k in htnxi b.iigs.1ilbtr snro oqercr, )6r frt rtnl yi[ Foiurtdqr lcatir, so I ou bodvr"iu do .!4diag ir sn ro gd brck o d'e rqoin.Thar! whl .fftr gdlng 1 nv poMdrovd rh. holidzv (ro! od oa6 FonGtom to ou mm:l w.igh. Bui if].u*r ioo linL or d.ds. bo durh, rh.dco.y g06, 6! oppsitE bipp.6: hpnn Lv.ls 6L'Tl'is n p6b.bl,ihc r!$D n\r litudY !rcr,r*lighllss pu$an Llon 6 mr Fns,"losi F Csqvic. prcsident ol .ndodne rs.r(hmd .liniln irKsdsinoo { E[ lillr &CoBpur', rold mr.'You go G w.ighrwrrh*. You nd rorirg Eighi YouGd good. But d.i rcur I* als srcppbducing lepdi tun mb.( l.prin ir

lnd rnn.Gd .n<gy ?xP.idirua, sojusr * )ou r diog b ro! wi+i rlulo! th. homon. lh* hdpr Fu los.

obvjosln Nr boJj/r Gr in<m6htdcotk.pu & o.wighi!! ouadul(lircs. 'Thcrc nnl . ri.gl. *Foidr foi IhuniD b.ing o! b adhd," Thon6wadd.n, th. dn .ior ol rh. w.ightard tli ing Disoil{s Cliric r d.Uoivftir/ oaP.ins/vri1, idld Dr"Th! bonr wil Egulr a lnble Bghibur ri v.ry ditle€rt l.Els, dep.ndingon food inhl<! qullitY oI rk di.t,hlgh f* veGus low hi high ysr wsus 10* swer $d d.pmding oi rhcrnduni oa phYsild aftivi*" Ii dso*.ms to b. r g€ii dcil ldn 6 noEL\r itPoini up (hd ro 6ft r do'n-which, iI rlu thilk abo( rh. Pior,nrld p.rftd $ns ln th.n bng [isory in ih. d*.n, ihos Pift who sviv.d vdc dc d^6 el'o *6r rdygdod r sinjng '!igh. duiog doE orpl.lt/n.ry g.od, in odq wor&, rormding rhc l.ph si.n r nu }igh.nd- 3ut L\!E lodd hN 6..n no rdrnug. for rh. on* who we. g.od (ldsiig rcigbr in hiil rid6. T}. rm.is prchbl/ hE Io! th. €r ofus, ilb.nin i l.$ d'midc fom. In o( $o1uiioo!_Y hindrrr n\.e w drot3g! inb€ing rbl. b so. ruy !h(dd !dori6c {i.didls od. dtri h,: To !nd.EEnd ibis i8ElPlx! b.6er S.na

BROKEN VINDOV

r rbi Er6 ifn.diltd! Pcedingtrrc riEr wodd \Ihr }hed nnrin r(dt tu,opai !ou,dj6 vert

io€idg ih. i.{ !n oirhe turn {hcdiw, rhr Fc!.h pajni{ Rob.( D.leumv 5na.h min) people as lh. Erns \qr[. Alhdugh w!$ilv Kandi!,s(rr wo.riig in Mu.ich, :nd FankKupk, ii Piin. (oo[ rh. plung! inroba $sr"di." b.ro* h. did:ii N*D&uDivi Prling' of1911 12 ih(crpru€d rh. nrcnrioi ofih. avrir-gfdr ud ns Por.mi.al sPok{mrn,dc po( Cuilam. 1po0imne. -{polln . roin.d . hn "o,Thiini od6.nb. 6. Purc, non obj.dt, lishrdrcn.h.d lxrcnsidi of cubnE thlr

Th< inrcn$ 6v.-Y.ri ody*rv thnItd b Dd:un.t i absrcr bE dlough

sions of Pris: Rob.ft D.hun!s ScnG," ehnh opms r ih. Gu&q:nh.ifron Lbai* 27th md runs rhrodghNlar 2{rh. Cuncd bv llrk Rd*o-rhil, n $rE rh. n!p5 bv vhich. inrou! inrrconne*d rd.s of prin(ings dotr.6ese.i 1909 $d 1911.rhe misr lini wo.!.d ll16ugh wh*h. !3r[d bc "d6t4dive Phre-iiuhich .h. poLE,6t tods oi ibc siri-S&.iin Chdci, rl. Ei$el Tow<, ardthr dfl qI P{G itrlfrrc lubj.ctdto Cubit iirgm.nmrioi .nd dnb.r-

grd rri.s ot'windo*,"whde hnfoms Jirsont irto lighi color, aodrmo5Ph{c. This Proccs is ..xtl/conphr in ? window (rigii), isody iir r l.i$r picdr .dLd "Th.Thre wiidows.' Hd.. [i. fd vor-uo. h,v. bftn donc awav eiih, aldspre n mk d by wndon5 in tonc:n n r prlntiig on*rud.d wiih .olor i?lon..Thc dDly !.niinjng rrcc of:.i. mnrdrl aorB n r gridljk< rdion iorrh< E'li. Tu{.q: ffibo ofmod-Jd.n@ dn irlik xl.imoriv in D&u,inrys Pxidng: or dxr Fnd las L\h :r rr Llki h. bor. fi.6D3l5Gp q(h ihis 'Dislt' pdn tings: L\. 6n rdial $- qsn.iios b_Y r fudch ri*. !

Page 11: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

xi R!ibrD5( imjc !rc rrcnn.bo.l n1t a.r nt Tn€ 66t Eight haE

o : hmiar 5c i3, 'dadi $. n-

rw to a huod:.. &d ethg: The diifd.r& jn L\. ai34 ol a\e 1o wdElnis i{.r6id.d br d.n gld6. \'vh{..t., d in th,( ibg. n dlemiied bv

Not b!; fr( r.pdn ws di(dded,c*4hec b.Ai *drs ob6. p.optc6r d. homo!.. b r. {h<rhd r frp.mn M 6r bmu* hn bodl did. rprcduc. .dodgh l.prin. Th.y foundrh. opposnq ftt p.opl. had 106 ofLpriq Son. of lh. earh.s ihoughrthjs m.ut .lii rir Lpdn theory *drmnrthri l.pr; didni do lnr n1r suppo&d b do But som. other{i.nti$ nov drinh lh3' G p.ople eeif:nd od arG, il.n boJi6 sinPLy g(lc$ ud I<$ llsiriE to l.piin. Th.bodv sdU pumpr out m*s@ io rhebnin cafing for ihr Edrbd!,E rosPe.d up md ih. aPPdr b sb$J! burih. braio ju* desnt rcspond b lloins:€s wirr d Eurh slsitivig, 6 irdid. Thn n prcbabl] \!hr it is s much.sid b g2in wight rhs ii n ro bsen. Th. hftd lbu g.i, ih. 1* cFrtdv.|o$ oen Ditullr v<ish.rcoror ws

This doaor nan rhr d;eG 6nruo& In .lo$ innhcs in }hicn di-dd5 havc ih. ddDUn. and th. wi!

Por€, to rcsrin d;n.dorns Pdmx-rcndt rc g.i rgJd md \igobc dr-

euids Lrc a nodB' gori, n rhouli.

nrghllo$."Jcrro'Hsiii ' ' 'hoxcodrdindng de *.tidr of i\c i.] Hsrud! iivoning d4 ?ini 'Bu iirluloo[ n roog 6a rEie& LGs oobodrra nuiin ro ps cnr. Thr's {hr

On th. other had, n$v Lhn wi..oming to und*s:nd $e biolot oivegh. giin, n n posibL b srceiYeof dirt a&sr rht {o'nJ adlll wo.LIrrlu bodv ebohg$ }!u djft bv lN-ainsLpdn tdds s Fu lG wighc trct siE esa l.pdn b p.ople on dj*srTh s what 1 nqb{ or dn€ @np-ni*, iidudjng,{.Tgm md lli |inrr cm*ing on nN TieY m dling to dev"lop a l.pri! o! Lpiin{mrogx. pindnt dlee could &(. to 6d1 dcir 6dd-ns inb L\inking rheIi. geaing hRswh.n rhaE esdly g.ning rhidnd"k G v.ry .xs,v io los w.ighr, Jos€Cd rold n.. "The diffi.dt (hing is rooainEi! yoq wcishi lo$. The rhink-i.g is r peoplc Iail b(atrt ih.i!l.pti! go* down. Hd. is vsdc Eplac"D r th*apy *;ih l.prid or hOb protein urlogu! ojsht p&v.ni n\.rtlapk. ft is r subrl. rnd impo'rmrftortp. Whor ir alls you is Ihr l.pdnis rct soiig b bE ! h.gi. blnt u\ai n-lN ]ou to !r whre!.vdu ftii Youha{ b i.id:E lhe wighi lo$ Th.n

,4noLb{ id.c whi.n tl1t Ho6nls-La Roche compsv n .\"bri!g, i5 to6tu on &. pobl.ff oblr p.opl. h0.

db. iica \ouie 3oing b rL! r lo, or',,rf:dJ do. .rnnno3 do\$. \r

go* inro rrr b j. rnJ Fu. r nlru

lhr M1rn6 Thr elegrfi solurjon i5i66odd. pkcin r dria$tqcw

The *.p! ihx rLe phrt io rh(bnjn \yhen ir rc v-ih!lcptinfuss.ge ft |lno,n * .t. ob Parh\qr 3.dmy ndmbs oa L\s. *eps nxr l.od

tion. Usins rh. Ob p hrey to 6gnrob*iry EpG.iB a quiirun le? bepnd !\. $ s ofdi.( drug! dr hivcbe.n rvril.bl. so fi. IeD-ph.\ th<populd Eldioion rcmold frcm L\e

lfi!{s, wN, by onprisq I rhdtlfctude prddud, w)!ch so*cd iDdjacdvrd suppE$ app*n.. Holfnrdn-LaRoche is wo*ing now or 1 d&g.!!<dXenj.,l, a .ompound dr block the$s!pdo! oi didiry ari bv dt incstinc You co ai.!i6u jundonr k .ps mu.h oln inrcu'stEm Th. Jrugn sdc dd h* shoun F,l. 1i nodar,5u(6i in h.lpirg dwondrv ob*e prd.ns los weight. ft !i! probably b..h. ner big did dtug Bu. no on. isprthdiog rhr n hzs insvhd. ner$. pd.!'i,l ol {rr 1 dtug lns roDld'essidze vou lcpti' (<prd(.

Cmp6dd $l*s $out tI< nql wNoa d,as dd1Pl * ih. thnd bg of r$8. llggld nool-5 ih! addniorddem.nr rhr could finrlv mk diernd dd.n. d as md dibl. lav olo< rci*r wlJdcD +.rJs or th. i$v,lsse r re*odry ioi+ -Whn I L\iiksill hppen n rh peopl. or rh6cmldnitiols }in r.pdri rhri lhev fl.$ rcsponriE b th<n o;rcnmcn!.The/ 1l $y d{ tn.y c not x llE.ddn bI Wcndl'i or McDoidd| Food in

ivi+ ft is dn!rccd trcm ominion.rne.,l ad hung.! w! ar b kin 'im., tosrtsuhE osdrl rc ilE! our hood.Whr lh6i diugs nly m.rn h thrtwc goiDg h b<omc l.s sscPdbLb rhR n*s1grs.'I. $e pd thirlv

Jtm, L\c Daruril rhiionship beMenos bodi.s lnd ou! .nvibm.iH r-lriior rhr !E d.v.lop.d orr thoq-sod' ofElrh$ 6I.0 our of b,ls.cFd p-ir. eho dn"d niort lns *.ull bnrDe dr.r*lvesaho hck ihe,lGcip[n.. (he nh<Bitb{ q.Ik d.

.nq4dtofrghtthcaftmPibyrhci! owD bodi.s io m3inhin.hen cuu.dr wethi, poundscd be Lon. (TrriE tr aro ion.oidlnc! rh* if You cm k€epwight oFlor s .Kcnsiv. pedod-L\r.e ltds, syi lowds.rpdiri e! b. shblishcd )|\lotr pcopl., though, dooth:v. rhr kin,l ofdisciplin.,sd ah ifriet do hrc n the mountor \rishl rhr Ed$ did6 cd .rp.dto loF on r pdmm.Dt b?$ Ear b.Lnicd bv $.;r rtpoinr n.g.. Th.n" LH. ha r ndioorl six*r dilb *-ps.rtioa study going o! nghi noqin vtch n n us;g a poglm of idGnsive, on-o!-on. coesilliis, dn-b oodifioio., rn,l nr md a hr]fhos of4dis. r4lJv o $e if n cmsft oltru.ighi 1bruft6 io lo* avcnP.! rtm df n\ei. bodl w!+t f. ihr

4

Fwiib Lpd! lun * T)p. n diab.tia {s bkod. Gnrmr idinsuln, nmy ov. dght plo

rlc @y bkone iesnrmr toleptin. So why nor d b e-*nsiiiz. deml Th. ida is to6nd ih. Lpln rccpor in ih.b!.in rd iinkrt Nnn ii ro6,L n wdt d vcn ii r arp.$on r n doe ir I thin pd

$n. {Diug.onprnies hrE .cto.llyb6n ptloing ile snc sftrgy N;tithe insuln E(ptos of dilb.n* ) Ai-du C{pftl4 who hd& dt L?d!prcj.( for Roch., lik.D5 th! pqes brwhi.h Lpti. pGs.s $c signrl :bouiir b tn. bEin b r tu.6.i! hr.L.ibrigid., wherc ut r is p!$.,1 fromhmd to hod. "lfvdu hav. .1 dl peopG, you dn p!$ 6. bu.kd md ntrly.6.ieni. he id.'Bur if.rc ofth. p.opl! io ih. thdn i. r{.hil

Page 12: Home | Ecology & Evolutionary Biologyeebweb.arizona.edu/Courses/ECOL223/pima paradox.pdf · Created Date: 2/27/2007 9:36:29 PM

PinL Jrcg.i6 -dn€: rc,r13 6!a $!v or r*o.iig n roi d:i.

+\r r:r5 re. P{i 8.,-u k( s" .Pid.miotogEr{tro cr ssabllc o. ft ciLlRiv{ PiD n ?o( .iqhi R84r1G!, l.d e N.l.H:d;!dir:oo rc \{d@r snG liac..Itounrtirs T6ii. d*tioliionB I a dor Iidjr .ommmidon rh. bord& olsoion h;cbinuahu4 sk! $osad f.(doE dc d.*n. "t hd Inon6oui ih& dirt.rc fq { lesi6ncm )!.s b.tor ih:q" a.Fndr sys. "Th. p,obkn vrd2i I coltd n*r lind hrcrvho kn.w mulh ab.ur ihe;. r!1991, ir jsr h:opedca rhr wliiL.d uo wiih in i,Kriqrtrd{M i! Mdnco " T[. io;.Ywrs : diffirulr oe, bur thi:M*c!d sokrm.,r had junbuft 2 rc?d lD]jnq sono6 lndChihullua, so tha Eh didD,hd. ro naL L\c fidrl6fn- orarry-nit. iftk on hoRbkk'Tl4w€dcd)

r gElP $ho h3,.3.r

B.m-,et .IJ,,,;nr;rD-a;g.Dg id ru: c&, I ihnrk th6c o.;.4 x, (O Frndr..qi 6+;8d;

i . l l ( m h b . r R r ' c d i n * h r t w !vu(o do, rnd d./ n {il$g b sii.t

*mpl6.'H. bush.d 'whrch n ,tnrs

Tt. rrRt. r4 Ld ihc scn i\hdE trhom! to rhc i\ INrd Prmr. dr. durhlhi.mhfr of : bb. tIrt dDe sBd.h.dnon pE.fudry Aizon: ddm to Gotr'r Mqicd Lit. ih. PiBa ot th. cihtur rc*mdoq d.v r. 6h4. liriog in sn:ll dur* oaw6d-rd-dob.arra'6 mmg rh. pii. E&i .u]tiqr

l.Is. or drir 56t rii, dr N,r.H. rlt.nmrnd rc moi. 6in I t! d@hrrhr rrrk 6.n, de krn lI b<.brk 6Eorsd dm6 sbqqfdr ruy* ED dM r ' tin.. Trc hudd m;fii_v of li! md!'oin Pina h0. inb.d ftdi.d. Tnly |av! h<i nlruEdud qighrd rh.u brood suqr h! b..nd.4d dd rti.; lndftE Dd .k hrEbc.! hinld aor s4E ordm:s.. c.n.dc tupb tur b4n elt. hd drltmft:botish hn bei moDiro<d. Th!Ilaioi Pins n tums our. ar: dd

ocisdng nhN.oe.k of ba5, ,.n-16, ud tdfr bnitla'. tridr dr.k.i rtri:ps oDe ! moid! Th+ rk ir1 M5..n l o h u ; & . d a o i i . , : d r { } h n L I{qhd, mq! durh:Pnrof Anzoddo Bu or ih. srqt dd ofd:n;qsrd REoo ur* hou:K.[oaqo&:li. io hrd Physic?l hhdr, th.Ej JrMm3. Ariaoa Aoa Pus ii $b hos.Tl. Nl*re Pina! ae ofdiabaa r.!om:t. Tb.r, ar slstrdy rhon r d,4th.; Ao.n.o dnft+ffi. In !!€[qd{. is tro .ohPi5oi:'I rclrd $f d}4 rlid.' Be'.6 *8. "r,; c.-::;r;bI Andui nndu:t "

Thc. ti, o! @sq i huDd,.,l :5-50$ dor & dny rt, $or h$otu Eonthir. subriscn.: tuDinq is !o w, iobaka a tjnnq in ,14dd bd4 u r*.nq &rt hoN of brd qh;i6t l,nd!F6ibL ii a !o.i.N {h.c n;si Eo?r!sn { 1a.sk Eoo rnn b68._t4a;Dia$. AJi:ooa Pin: wr.d b E(n iorrr. rrnd, dr.y couldii ti b4 b4i du.rha! a hundr.d lrss si,e ih! cil:&L!i vhirh u.d b 'didr ihi Eh.lid 6.sn 6sh dd {d wE fo'cv-ing btu md 4sh, B diErcd $tu lor.om.rm irding. Y. rl.r4 !du. i! th. eMpl. ol rh. M4iqEm P.opl. llo ftlk uih d! PiaofAiizona qr d }. bigg.i Prcbrlr

Y

n o)^)

d.r' h* 4 6iig b Ssht dLb{s mdooqfl t ] 'Ft ldlo_ta.@oDqrh!rjb. d{ ioJrinq 6 6c don., .iti ih.qrr rhingr 4 i5 drrr dxns hr. rob. ii .F.qjt: b ac Ln rh. drud4 oftucoqs b.,!Jd ftiqhi 1d$ dr. shc&.Pn3 .'isn rion. { d.. .odd sqsbtr 4 d r oD. bdr*ujng dr{ {h.me1n.' eorSd inai'llv iiiL, L\: ids L\db.irg sLnde is s anaiBbL-r o?ori advnabr-.oDJnion is sldwl, cdjns Lu oort' wh.n zav-! Esk'nl,qnst iMd;dft p\b\*.d \ 5 Aysuggsdng rhr rh. moiinin. @ns oaobciry h:d h<i ov.6iftd, (h. n.*us grcrd li.n rcsounding di4 r if\t w@ ?! rE.boy on n\. h@L ! nd. i$u. \dn\ ob4i9 ltG o' y ndidd hd ior L\: thotrsfd EM in vincheng hi u@mnd ou qhtis ot lii.:d. i.ighr..d ink or h.n an;.. hv-pftinm, dirbds, sei ad\ids, Fjt-bhdd{ dtk!., Erutu, Fqq b&:d;6s,tini d.nft, si oih{ ach4, pajn,, Dd

bon.Wll$.-* 'r drgsoflo.rg n

h.,ld 6u or n.oory ofh.itn5 inosLdib ll]ns hjghin rfi. snE: Ilidashould Emird L\i pspl. oi Sadhn-ed ,I ih! En oi c r kl-lrr n nii! p6sibL, dtx ,or 1 Pimr, io b. 6t. ]

i ! e

Y

I , F B

e1

ffi(NlI E

TEO

\

, }g..i$

tb,rt+ r f

", {:u

Y

.rt#,{8q

: , [ _

,.\ B

X