240
UCI University of California, Irvine ÀÑÏÅÊÒÛ ÃÐÓÇÈÍÎ-ÀÁÕÀÇÑÊÎÃÎ ÊÎÍÔËÈÊÒÀ 7 Ìàòåðèàëû ãðóçèíî-àáõàçñêîé êîíôåðåíöèè: Ïàêò ñòàáèëüíîñòè íà Êàâêàçå è ñòðàòåãèÿ ìèðîòâîð÷åñêîãî ïðîöåññà Ñî÷è, 19-23 ìàðòà 2001 ã. Èðâàéí

Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

������������� ������� ����������

���������� ������������

�� ������

��������������� !��"#��$%!&�%! '��� (��)*��%��$��"��+ !$��� ����,%���

��$�������-�.��!�,!�/�$%!�!�0�!(�$$�1

�!/�2�34�56�.�����5773��8

������

����

Page 2: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�$0�%�������� !��"#��$%!�!�%! '��%��

9:;<=>:� ?@� >A<� B<?CDEFG�9HIAFJEFG� K?G@LE=>

�������� ��� ��

���� ������

��� �����������

����� ������� �� !�� "��� � ������� �#� � $���� %� "

���� &����"� ��� '� �� (�!����� ' ���� �)

* �#��$��� +� ,--.� /��������#� %� *��% ���0� ������

1 ���� 1������� ��2� �� 3.4.

������0� *��% ���� 5,657�4.--

8595:� ;,9�.,,7

8595:� ;,9�.499� %<

Page 3: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��M�N� ��

O?C<P?CQ )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))4

���R�$�!,�� )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))6

�� �%!���R�S���8�=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B�F��>�G� )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 7

��������%�"�8�=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B�HCI�F��>�G��>�>�JEHKCDEALK>��>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))),-

T.����MU���� �-2������V�����S,���8�O�PGBI�Q�RAS�GBI�T�EACKJU�BHK�?BV�E@?B))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))6.

��R��� ����0�8�=E�BJ��BK�B�?K�K@E��@?E�E��Q�?�KAE���BK@E��KJK��EME�W?�T��P�KMPCB�E���BI ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))));6

MU! ��!����R���#)�X?��?KMBB�JB�E@?�EB?KCD@?�����?KE�BBB����T��>?B>K ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) .,.

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�YABCB@B�Q�XPSPJB��HE�B�TE@CKT�EJKZP?EV�EME�TK�BEH� )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) .9.

�"�$��!.���0$�-)�F�T�EK>?�J�P�KMPCB�E���BI)�[EGJEZ�U�CBT�EJKZP?EV�UK�JEHKCB\ )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) .4;

����"�W��"���S,���8�]A�KVK��UK����@E�JK@?�P^�ZBG�D ))))))) ,,.

XYZZFCE<: )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) ,33

Page 4: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

Page 5: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

O[\]^[\_

��������������������� �"������������� %�������� ����������$�%� "���� $��

����� ��������� %����� � �$�������2�� �%����)������� _��������� �� �����#

����/��������#� %�*��% ���0�������0�!����%����$�%� "�����&����"����'� �

(�!�����' ���� �)

���� ����������� ��� ������ �"��!���� %� "� ������ _���� � �%������������ ��

1 ���0� ���0�a����.5�,30�,--.)����������������!������������ �� ����������� �

���� �������������#)��������� ���"���� ��������������$���� �����������b

��"���)

����� ����� %�������� ��!�����8.:�����1������#�����% ������*���c�8,:

����#���� %��������������� %���������������� �%����c�83:���� ������ ������ ���$

������"�$���"����c����89:������������$������$���)

�����!������%�������"������!������������ �������<������ �����������������

� �%������)�d�� $����!�� e ��� ��� f������0� �� %��� �� %� ���� g�����

a��� �����/��������#��������/������1����0�������������� ���#��� !���� �

%��� "������� ��� �� ���� ��� �#������������ %�����2��������������$)�(��

�<���������������� ��������������� ������������������ %������������$��%% ���

����"�� ��� �%�����2 ����� �������! ���)�&���������"�� �� ""���� �� �

�� _���� $ ��� ��� ���������� ��� � �"������������ ��� ������� ���$������

������$������$���������#2��$�� �%�����)�f������b����������� ����� "����

�����#�������� �)������������������������������������ �"�)

&��!��� "��# ��%������� ���������� ������ �"�����!������%���

���������)��������� �������� _����� ����� ����������������������% �� !��$

��"��� ����������*(�����2�h#� )� "0���2�h"#"��)� "0

�$��h��)��)

���� ������ %� ����`����� ������� ��� ��� � "��g�$����� �������� ��

������� �� ���� ��������� �� �����ii�#���)��)��)��i$���i����"���$i

���)��"�)

&�����$���%��� �������%%�� %�����*��������������% ������0�j�" ���#

���j���� �"�����������*������% ��("��������� $�""���% ��������"_ �

� ������� ���� �����������$������������$� %������� �"�)

9CQF�`GFL�`;F2*������% ��("��������� $�""��

aFF>F�bFIFC<E:AcELE2*��������������% ������0�j�" ���#����j���� �"���

aFYLF�BFCH2*������% �� � �����������* �%�����1�����0�/��������#� %�*��% ���0�������

Page 6: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��M����d��

=K�KH���JB�@KHDJE���UTP@>�@K�BB�TPACB>�NB�0��EG�B>kK�����KGPCD?��

?K�T�EHECZ�^LKME@I�HB�CEM�� E� ��GCBV�US� �@TK>?�S� M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME>E�lCB>?�)�XTE�@E�� W?EME�T�EK>?�� Q�F�CBlE��B�@>B��P�B�K�@B?K?� �� M)������K0�lB���@B�PK?@I�E��mE�HEJ�nBCDIJ��B�mCE�U�oD^CB?)

p?E?�?EJ�@E@?��CK��TE�G�TB@IJ�HB@>P@@B�����>E�lK�K�NBB0�T�ESEHB��kK������J>�S���kKME�T�EK>?����M)�XEVB�@�.5�TE�,3�J��?��,--.�M)�[E�BGAKZ���BK�TE�?E�E��B��K��I?BNU0�G�TB@B�AUCB�E?�KH�>?B�E���U0��E��U@>�GU����BI�PV�@?�B>E��>E�lK�K�NBB��E@T�EBG�EHI?@I�AKG�>�>BS�CBAE�@PLK@?�K���US�BGJK�K�B�)�]@�E��UK�?KJU0�EA@PZH��kBK@I����>E�lK�K�NBB��.:�=�>?@?�ABCD�E@?B�HCI�F��>�G�0�,:�B�?K�K@U�@?E�E����>E�lCB>?K0�3:�T�EJKZP�?EV�UK�JEHKCB�P�KMPCB�E���BI�>E�lCB>?�0�9:�@?��?KMBB�JB�E?�E�VK@?��)

[TK��UK������kP�>E�lK�K�NB^�AUC�T�BMC�kK��W>@TK�?�@E�@?E�E�U�Q��kBJ�ME@?KJ�AUC�qZE��=EC�rKHK��S0�T�ElK@@E��[E@?EV�EME�JK��E�B?�@>EME�P�B�K�@B?K?��8XsR:0��@KJB��E�BG�K@?�U����?E��G�JKV�?KCD�US�>�BMTE�?KE�BB�B�T��>?B>K� M��ZH��@>EME�JB�E?�E�VK@?��0�BJK^LB��AECDkE�ETU?��K�?ECD>E�PV�@?BI���JB�E?�E�VK@>BS�B�BNB�?B��S0��E�B��P>E�EH@?��?�>BJB�B�BNB�?B��JB��E�J�EMBS�@?����S�JB��)�tU�TET�E@BCB�KME�TEHK�CB?D@I�@�EBJ�J�K�BKJ�E���kBS�NKCIS�B���kK��HKI?KCD�E@?B0���?�>ZK��U�@?PTB?D�TE�@?��?KMBIJ�JB�E?�E�VK@?���B����CBGP�B�?K�K@E��>E�lCB>?P^�LBS�@?E�E�)�uME�@EEALK�BI��UCBCB@D���EZB�CK��P^�HB@>P@@B^0�TPACB>P�KJP^���H���EJ��UTP@>K)

tU�APHKJ���HU���kBJ�E?>CB>�J�>�>����W?E?0�?�>�B����APHPLBK��UTP@�>B���kKME�@AE��B>��Q�E�B�T�BMEHI?@I�HCI�TC��B�E���BI�H�CD�K�kK��HKI�?KCD�E@?B�����J>�S�T�EK>?�)�[U�JEZK?K�@�IG�?D@I�@��KH�>?E��JB�B�>EE�HB���?E��JB� T�EK>?�� TE� WCK>?�E��E�� TEV?K� Q� �E?� BS� �H�K@��*(�����2�h#� )� "0���2�h"#"��)$�0��$��h��)��)

=EC�U��?K>@?��@KS�@KJB��UTP@>E������P@@>EJ�IGU>K�B���MCB�@>BK��K�G^JK� �K>E?E�US� BG� �BS� JEZ�E� ���?B� �� ��?K��K?K� ��� @��?K� �����i�#���)��)��)��i$���i����"���$i���)��"�)

tU�AC�MEH���U�@E?�PH�B>�J�F��>�G@>EME�B�@?B?P?��JB��0�HKJE>���?BB�B���G�B?BI�B�vK�?���MPJ��B?���US�T�EM��JJ�G��BS�AECDkP^�TEJELDT�B��KH�>?B�E���BB�B�BGH��BB�W?EME��UTP@>�)

��R��� ����0�2vK�?��MPJ��B?���US�T�EM��JJ

��������%����S,���2F��>�G@>B��B�@?B?P?�JB��0�HKJE>��?BB�B���G�B?BI

�!������"2vK�?��B@@CKHE���B��JB�E?�E�VK@?���B�>E�lCB>?ECEMBB0�F�CBlE��B��@>B��P�B�K�@B?K?0�������

Page 7: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�� �%!���R�S����$$!(��(�-�.!�!R�#�e��$�!,�������

�����������f �������d����

=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B�F��>�G��Q�kB�E>EJ�@k?�A�U��B��@KEAwKJC^�

LB��HE>PJK�?0�@EGH�^LB���KCB>ECKT�P^��EGJEZ�E@?D�HCI�J�EME@?E�

�E��K��B�TCEHE?�E��E��HB@>P@@BB�@�JUS���G�US�HKI?KCK��B�W>@TK��

?E�)�=�>?�ES��?U��K?�kB�E>B��@TK>?���ET�E@E�0���VB��I�@�MKETECB?B�

VK@>EME�B�@?��?KMBVK@>EME�G��VK�BI�F��>�G��B�>E�V�I�PG>E��NBE��CD�

�UJB�B�?K�K@�JB���GCBV�US�@PAwK>?E�����KMBE�K)�p?E0�K@?K@?�K��E0

TES��CD��I�B�BNB�?B��0�?�>�>�>�E�����JK�K��E���T���CK��������G�K�

kK�BK���kK��T�EACKJU0�B0�@EE?�K?@?�K��E0�JU��K�JEZKJ�AU?D�K^��K�

HE�ECD�U)�u@CB�B@SEHB?D�BG�?KS�EALBS�T�B�NBTE�0�V?E�HKJE>��?BI0

@�EAEH��@CE���B��UAE���B�W>E�EJBVK@>B�P@?E�VB�EK�EA��GE���BK0�E@�

�E����EK����T�B�NBT�S�J�>@BJ�CD�EME�@�JEPT���CK�BI0�@�JB�TE�@KAK

I�CI^?@I�M����?BIJB�@?�ABCD�E@?B�B�JB��0�?E���Z�K�k�I�V�@?D�W?EME

T�>?��JEMC��AU�@?�?D�PVKA�B>EJ0�>�>E?E�EJP�JU�APHKJ�EA��L�?D@I��

��kK��TE�@KH�K��E��ZBG�B)�[�=�>?K��K�ME�E�B?@I��B�E�VKJ�?�>EJ0�V?E

�K�AUCE�@>�G��E����DkK0��E�KME��K@EJ�K��UJ�HE@?EB�@?�EJ�I�CIK?@I

?E0�V?E�J�EMBK�T�B�NBTU0�?KE�K?BVK@>BK�B�T��>?BVK@>BK0�TE��EGJEZ�

�E@?B��H�T?B�E���U�>���kBJ��K�CBIJ�B�@EA���U���EH�EJ�HE>PJK�?K)

[�JEK��T�KGK�?�NBB�B���H���E����AE?K�I�@>E�NK�?�B�P^@D���

?KS��ET�E@�S0�>E?E�UK�ACBZK�>�JEBJ�T�ElK@@BE��CD�UJ�G���BIJ0�B

��V�P�@�T���E�E�TECB?BVK@>BS��@TK>?E�)�X�JEK��?EV>B�G�K�BI0��@K

TECEZK�BI�W?EME�HE>PJK�?��JEZ�E���@@J�?�B��?D���H�PS��@TK>?�S�

TECB?BVK@>EJ�B�T���E�EJ)

=�>?���VB��K?@I�@�T�KHCEZK�BI�B���@@JE?�K�BI�?�KS�MC���US

�UV�ME����G�KkK�BI�>E�lCB>?E�����F��>�GK)�p?E0��E�TK��US0�u��E�

@E^G�>�>�TE?K�NB�CD�U��T��?�K��B�>�>��KV?E0�>�VKJP�JU�HECZ�U

@?�KJB?D@I)�[E��?E�US0�EAL�I��E�J�?B���I�A�G�0�?E�K@?D�G�>E�U0�>E�

?E�UK�����kKJ��KMBE�K�HECZ�U�@EE?�K?@?�E��?D�H�PM�H�PMP)�����?�K�

?DBS0�W>E�EJBVK@>�I�@?�ABCD�E@?D0�BCB�W>E�EJBVK@>EK���G�B?BK��

�KMBE�K�>�>�EH�E�BG�MC���US�P@CE�B��TECB?BVK@>E��@?�ABCD�E@?B)

]VK�D�B�?K�K@�E�B�G�J��VB�E�AUCE�AU���V�?D�HB@>P@@B^�@�TK��

�EME�l�>?E��0��E0�>�@EZ�CK�B^0�I�HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E��ET�E@�H�CK>EME

Page 8: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

APHPLKME��>�>�?E��K��K�B?@I0�V?E�@KMEH�I0�G��?���BCB�MHK�?E���ACBZ���

kKJ�APHPLKJ�TK�@TK>?B���VCK�@?�����u��E@E^GK�HCI�@?����F��>�G�

@?��K?�VKJ�?E��K�CD�UJ)�[?E�EK0�V?E��>NK�?B�PK?@I���=�>?K�Q�W?E

PV�@?BK�@�JEME�u��E@E^G����?EJ�TE?K�NB�CD�EJ�EAwKHB�K�BB0�E�>E�

?E�EJ�GHK@D�BHK?��KVD�Q�?E�K@?D0�EALK>��>�G@>EJ�@EEALK@?�K�BCB�ME�

@PH��@?�K)�[�W?P�TK�@TK>?B�P�I�?EZK��K��K�^0�?�>�>�>0�SE?D�GHK@D�B

ME�E�B?@I0�V?E�u��E@E^G�JEM�AU���@�TEHHK�Z�?D�Q�B�W>E�EJBVK@>B0�B

@�?EV>B�G�K�BI�@?�ABCD�E@?B0�B�@�?EV>B�G�K�BI�HKJBCB?��BG�NBB�W?E�

GE�U�Q��E��KHD�W?E��@K�JEMCE�AU�T�EB@SEHB?D�B�����J>�S�x�XuF�0

>E?E�U��@PLK@?�PK?�PZK��K@>ECD>E�CK?0�EH��>E����T�E?IZK�BB��@KME

W?EME���KJK�B�JU�>�>�?E��K�TEVP�@?�E��CB�@>ECD>E��BAPHD�@K�DKG�E�

ME��JKk�?KCD@?��0�@>ECD>E��BAPHD�@K�DKG�E��TEHHK�Z>B�E?�u��E@E�

^G��BCB�>�>BS�?E�E?HKCD�US�K��ETK�@>BS�@?������E?�EkK�BB�x�Xu�

F�)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�?�>�ZK�APHK?���ACBZ��kKJ�APHPLKJ�@�C^AUJ�@EEA�

LK@?�EJ0�@EGH���UJ����F��>�GK)

FEMH���KVD�BHK?�E��E�J�?B��E�T���E�US��@TK>?�S�P�KMPCB�E���

�BI�>E�lCB>?E�0�TK��EK0�V?E��@?�K?����TE�K@?>P�H�I0�W?E�HKJE>��?B�

VK@>B��>E�@?B?PNBE��CD�U��@?�E�)�[�>�>BS�AU�ME@PH��@?��S�JU��B

ZBCB�B�>�>BJ�AU��B�AUCE�APHPLKK���kKME�ME@PH��@?�K��E�?K��B?E�

�B�CD�EME�P@?�E�@?���B�>E�lCB>?E�����F��>�GK0�I@�E�EH�E�Q�V?EAU

�UZB?D0�W?B�ME@PH��@?���HECZ�U���G�B��?D@I�TE�?KJ�JEHKCIJ�B�EA�

LKT�BG����UJ�T�B�NBT�J0�>E?E�UK�P@?��E�CK�U�JB�E�UJ�HKJE>�

��?BVK@>BJ� @EEALK@?�EJ)�n� @?���� B� ���EHE��F��>�G�� 8E@EAK��E

^Z�EME�F��>�G�:��K?�H�PMEME��UAE��)�tU��K�zE@@BI0��K�XEKHB�K��

�UK�s?�?U�B��K�>�>�I��BAPHD�H�PM�I��KCB>�I�HK�Z����BCB�W>E�EJB�

VK@>B��MBM��?0�V?EAU�@���JB�@VB?�CB@D�@�?�>BJB0�>�>BK�JU�K@?D)�[@K

JU�Q�J�CK�D>BK�ME@PH��@?��0�>E?E�UK�HECZ�U�BM��?D�TE�EHEA�K��

�UJ�EALKT�BG����UJ�T���BC�J0�V?EAU��UZB?D�B���G�B��?D@I)

=K��UJ�?�>BJ�T���BCEJ�I�CIK?@I�]@�E��E��{�>E�0�?)K)�FE�@?B�

?PNBI0�>E?E��I�HECZ���AU?D�ECBNK?�E�K�BKJ���kK��T���E�E��@B@?K�

JU�B��K�CD�E��ZBG�B)�]���HECZ���T�E�EGMC�@B?D�T�����VKCE�K>�0

T�����JK�DkB�@?�0�T���E����JB��EK� @E@PLK@?�E���BK���GCBV�US

EALB��B�@EGH�?D�@B@?KJP�HKJE>��?BVK@>EME�B�TC^��CB@?BVK@>EME

T���CK�BI0�E@�E����P^����P@?E�VB�US�T�EG��V�US�B�TEHE?VK?�US

ME@PH��@?�K��US�B�@?B?P?�S)�]H�E��BG�MC���US�T�KHTE@UCE>�ZBG�

�K@TE@EA�E@?B�?�>BS�>E�@?B?PNB��I�CIK?@I�T�E�EGMC�kK�BK�J�>@B�

Page 9: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

J�CD�US�TEC�EJEVB��JK@?�US�@�JEPT���CK�B�0�VK?>B��TK�KVK�D�BS

W>@>C^GB��US�B�@K�DKG�US�>EJTK?K�NB��@�JB�BJ�CD�UJ��JKk�?KCD�

@?�EJ�@E�@?E�E�U�NK�?��)�qCI�@?����?BT���K@TPACB>�F��>�G�0����K��

�E0��KEASEHBJE�T�BG���BK�>E�@?B?PNBK��@PLK@?�E���BI��@BJJK?�BV�

�EME�ME@PH��@?�K��EME�P@?�E�@?��)

[@K��UkK@>�G���EK�E?��ZK�E�B���=�>?K�X?�ABCD�E@?B�B��K�T�K�

?K�HPK?����E�BMB��CD�E@?D)�[�>�>E��AU�@?���K�JU��K�ZBCB0���KHB�EJ

M�PGB�@>EJ�ME@PH��@?�K��JK@?K�@�RAS�GBK�0���@E^G�EJ�BCB�B�EJ�ME�

@PH��@?�K0�W?B�T�B�NBTU�HECZ�E�T�E�EGMC�k�?D�B�P��Z�?D�C^AEK

ME@PH��@?�K��EK�EA��GE���BK)

YKJ��K�JK�KK0��K>EJK�H�NBB���?E�E��=�>?��X?�ABCD�E@?B�E@�

?��CI^?�VP�@?�E��KPHE�CK?�E�K��E@?B)�|K@JE?�I����EAwKJ�HE>PJK��

?�0�TE�J�EMBJ�>C VK�UJ��ET�E@�J�VKME�?E��K�S��?�K?0�E@?�K?@I�ELP�

LK�BK0�V?E���?E�U�AEICB@D�G�?�E�P?D�AECKK�T�EACKJ�?BV�UK��ET�E�

@U)�[GI?D0� ��T�BJK�0� �K>EJK�H�NB^�E� ��KHK�BB�J�EZK@?�K��EME

M��ZH��@?��)�R�?E�U�=�>?���BMHK��K�PTEJB��^?0�E�>�>EJ�J�EZK@?�K��

�EJ�M��ZH��@?�K�BHK?��KVD���SEHB?�CB���W?P�JEHKCD�zE@@BI�BCB��K?0

K@?D�CB���GCBVBI���@?�?P@K�W?BS�M��ZH��@?��BCB��K?0�T�@TE�?�>�>EME

ME@PH��@?���APHK?�BJK?D�@BCP�HCI�G�M���BV�EME�TECDGE���BI�B�?)H)

q�PME��?�>E��T�EACKJE�0����JE���GMCIH0�I�CIK?@I��K>EJK�H�NBI�E

?EJ0�V?E�lKHK��CBG�NBI�B��@BJJK?�BI�����kBS�@?����S�HECZ�U�G�?���

MB��?D0�TE�>����K��JK�K0�lB���@E�E�A^HZK?�P^�B���CEME�P^�TECB?B�

>P)�]H�EG��V�E0�V?E�W?E�>C^VK�E��B���Z�K�kB���ET�E@0��E�HE�?KS�TE�0

TE>��P��KMBE�E���K�APHK?��K�CD�US�J�?K�B�CD�E�lB���@E�US��UV��

ME�0�BS�W>E�EJBVK@>EK���G�B?BK0�E@EAK��E���O�PGBB0�T�KH@?��B?D�?�PH�

�E)�p?���K>EJK�H�NBI��UMCIHB?�@>E�KK�>�>�TK�K�K@K�BK��KkK�BI�?�PH�

�EME�B�T�EACKJ�?BV�EME��ET�E@�����APHPLKK0�VKJ�>�>�TETU?>��E?�K?�)

qCI�JK�I�W?E�@�JEK��KT�BKJCKJEK�T�KHCEZK�BK0�TE?EJP�V?E��

P@CE�BIS0�>EMH��JU�ME�E�BJ�@PAwK>?P0�V?E�H�KJ�KJP�TEC�P^�@�JE@?E�

I?KCD�E@?D0�?E�K@?D�T���E�����UAE�U�JK@?�US�E�M��E�0�VK?>E�ET�K�

HKCK��UK�>EJTK?K�NBB�B�?)H)�@E��@KJB�HKJE>��?BVK@>BJB�B�@?B?P�

?�JB0��E�HEA��CIKJ0�V?E�lB���@U�APHKJ�>E�?�ECB�E��?D�@�JB0�TE?E�

JP�V?E�I�CIKJ@I�NK�?�EJ�B��@K���CEMB�BHP?�>���J�Q�@�JEK��?EV>B

G�K�BI0�W?E��K�K��E0�@�?�>BJ�TEHSEHEJ�JU�@�E���T�BHKJ�>�?E��@B?P�

�NBB0�>E?E��I�@K�V�@���O�PGBB)�n���@�K@?D�G�>E��E�@�JEPT���CK�BB0�P

��@�AUCB��UAE�U���JK@?�UK�E�M��U�@�JEPT���CK�BI0�K@?D�>E�@?B?P�

Page 10: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

NBE��UK�M����?BB�@�JEPT���CK�BI0��E��BVKME�BG�W?EME��K��UkCE0

TE?EJP�V?E��@KJ�W?BJ�?�>���GU��KJUJ�@�JE@?EI?KCD�UJ�JK@?�UJ

E�M���J�T�BSEHB?@I��U>CI�VB��?D�P�NK�?���>�ZHU��C��B�B�>�ZHU�

?���@lK�0�>E?E�U��HECZK��BH?B������G�B?BK�W?BS�@�JUS��KMBE�E�)

|��K��EK0�ZKC�?KCD�KK�AUCB�AU��K>EJK�H�NBB�E�VK?>E�ET�KHKCK��

�US�A^HZK?�E�lB���@E�US�T���EJEVBIS0�V?EAU�AUCE��BH�E0����>EJ

>�>�I�E?�K?@?�K��E@?D�Q�>EJP�T�B��HCKZB?�JK@?�EK�BJPLK@?�E0�JK�

@?�UK��K@P�@U�B�>�>�T�EB@SEHB?���@T�KHKCK�BK�lB���@E�0�>�>0����

T�BJK�0�T�B�BJ�^?@I��KkK�BI�JKZHP�NK�?�EJ�B��KMBE�EJ���@VK?

B@TECDGE���BI�@?��?KMBVK@>BS��K@P�@E�)

]VK�D�Z�CD0�V?E��E�J�EMBS�JK@?�S�=�>?��VP�@?�PK?@I��CBI�BK

JBl��E�HKJE>��?BV�E@?B�^Z�E>��>�G@>BS��K@TPACB>)�Y�J�ME�E�B?�

@I�E��KEASEHBJE@?B���V�?D�HCI�M��ZH��@>EME�EALK@?������XK�K��EJ

F��>�GK�@TKNB�CD�P^�EA��GE��?KCD�P^�T�EM��JJP�TE�T����J�VKCE�

�K>�)�=EVKJP�?ECD>E����XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK\�p?E�EVK�D�?�K�EZ��I�?K��

HK�NBI0�>E?E��I��B>�>��K�@TE@EA@?�PK?�@EGH��B^�HKJE>��?BVK@>EME

@?�EI�B�TEEL�K�B^�G�LB?U�T����VKCE�K>����O�PGBB)�Y�>�I�TEGBNBI

T�KH@?��B?KCK����GCBV�US�T���B?KCD@?�K��US�B��KT���B?KCD@?�K��

�US�K��ETK�@>BS�E�M��BG�NB��@CPZB?�TEHHK�Z>E����kKJP�T���B�

?KCD@?�P�B�@EGH�K?�A��DK�U�HCI�HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�@BC���@?���K)�=E�

W?EJP�I�AU��K�@?�C��@�?�>BJ�PZ��EEHPkK�CK�BKJ�TK�KTB@U��?D��@K

@EE?�K?@?�P^LBK�TP�>?U�=�>?�)

FEMH���VB?U��KkD@I���HE>PJK�?0��UGU��^?�PHB�CK�BK�>E�?��@�

?U���K>E?E�UK�?KJU���@@J�?�B��^?@I�>����K�>E�>�K?�E0����K>E?E�

�UK��A@EC^?�E�TE�K�S�E@?�E)�]VK�D�B�?K�K@�E0�V?E�?�J0�MHK��KVD

PZK�BHK?�E�>E�>�K?�US�JEJK�?�S�lKHK��CBG�NBB�BCB�>E�lKHK��CB�

G�NBB�>��>�G@>BS�ME@PH��@?�0���?E�U�J�EME�ME�E�I?�E�HK?�CIS0�>E?E�

�UK�HECZ�U�@ETP?@?�E��?D�@EGH��B^�?�>EME�@EEALK@?����E�KHB�E�

��C^?K0�E�J�EME@?E�E��KJ�B�H�E��EJ�M��ZH��@?�K0�E�>��>�G@>EJ�ME�

@PH��@?�K0�MHK�APHK?�KHB�U��T�@TE�?�B��@I>BK�ME@PH��@?�K��UK�BCB

W?�BVK@>BK���G���BI�APHP?�>�>�AU��EJB��CD�UJB�BJK��JB�HCI�EA�

C�H�?KCI�W?EME�T�@TE�?�)

]?�?E��V�@?B0�MHK��KVD�BHK?�EA�B�E@?����US�HKC�S�Q��G�BJEE?�E�

kK�BIS�@�H�PMBJB�ME@PH��@?��JB0�@�]]|0�@�JKZHP���EH�UJB�E�M��

�BG�NBIJB�Q�E@?�K?@I��TKV�?CK�BK0�V?E���?E�U�=�>?���GICB�P@?��

u��E@E^G��B�TK�KTB@�CB�KME�HCI���@0�H�ZK��K�TU?�I@D�PVK@?D�@TKNB�

Page 11: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

lB>P��KMBE���BCB�T�E���CBGB�E��?D�KME�ME�D>B��ETU?)�R�W?��@TKNB�

lB>�0�HCI�JK�I��E��@I>EJ�@CPV�K0�@E@?EB?���?EJ�V?E�F��>�G0�B�W?EME

�KCDGI�G�AU��?D0�Q�W?E�?��V�@?D�JB��0���>E?E�E��?ECD>E�V?E�AUCB�ME�I�

VBK�>E�lCB>?U0�W?E�?��V�@?D�JB��0���>E?E�E��>E�lCB>?U��@K�KLK�HCI?�

@I0�W?E�Q�@?���U�B����EHU0�>E?E�UK��K�>EMH��?E���HK�I?��HN�?EJ��K>K

B�H�ZK��K�����V�CK�H��HN�?EME0���@KMEH�I0��VK��0�TEG��VK���AE�ECB@D

G���KG��B@BJE@?D0�G��@EA@?�K��P^���C^?P0�@EA@?�K��EK�M��ZH��@?�E0

VCK�@?�E���]]|0�G��@�EB�ME@PH��@?�K��UK�IGU>B0�G��@�E^�?K��B?E�

�B^�@E�@�EBJB�M���BN�JB����>��?K)

=�KHCEZK���I�TK�@TK>?B���JEZK?�AU?D�B�?�BMP^LK��B�B�?K�

�K@�E��HCI�F��>�G�0��E�I�EVK�D�AE^@D0�V?E�>��>�G@>BK��K@TPACB>B��K

@EMC�@I?@I�@>�G�?D�}�K?~�?EJP0�G��V?E�E�B�AE�ECB@D��@K�W?B�MEHU�B�G�

V?E�AE�^?@I�TE�@K��HK�D0�?E�K@?D�W?E�EVK�D�AECKG�K���I�?KJ�)

z�GCBVBI�@�u��ETE�0�MHK�W?B�T�EACKJU�?EZK�@PLK@?�E��CB0��E

@PLK@?�E��CB�H���E0�@CKHP^LBK���E�TK��US0�P�K��ETK�@>BS����EHE�

EVK�D�HECM�I�B@?E�BI�TE@?�EK�BI�B���G�B?BI�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?Bc��E�

�?E�US0�u��ET�0�TE�@����K�B^�@�F��>�GEJ0�BJKK?���@?EILBK0��K�CD�

�UK0�EVK�D���Z�UK�W>E�EJBVK@>BK�B�?K�K@U0�>E?E�UK�?�>��G�BJE�

@�IG��U0�V?E0����K��E0�HEJB�B�P^?���H��@KJB�E@?�CD�UJB�VP�@?���

JB�Q���NBE��CD�UJB0�W?�BVK@>BJB�B�?)H)�YE0�V?E�@?�CE�TE?�KA�E@�

?D^�HCI�K��ETK�@>BS����EHE�0�>�@EZ�CK�B^0�TE>��KLK��K�@?�CE�HK��

@?�B?KCD�E@?D^����F��>�GK0���B@>P@@?�K��EK�KHB�@?�E�JU�PZK�TK�K�

ZBCB�B��EG���L�?D@I���G�H��B>?E��K�@EAB��K?@I)

]VK�D�B�?K�K@�UJ0�K@CB��K��P?D@I�>�T�EACKJ�?B>K���GM���BVK�

�BI�>EJTK?K�NB��B�TEC�EJEVB�0�I�CIK?@I�TECEZK�BK�E�@?�?P@K�TECB�

NBB��E�EME�ME@PH��@?�K��EME�EA��GE���BI)�XEMC�@�E�HE>PJK�?P0�BJK?D

@�E^�TECBNB^�Q�W?E�W>@>C^GB��EK�T���E��@KS�@PAwK>?E�)�=ECBNBI

��@@J�?�B��K?@I�>�>�M����?�AKGET�@�E@?B�JK@?�US�W?�BVK@>BS�M�PTT)

qCI�JK�I�W?E��A@EC^?�E��KT�BKJCKJE0�TE?EJP�V?E0�K@CB�JU�ME�E�BJ

E�@?�ABCD�E@?B����KMBE�K0�JU�HECZ�U�EVK�D�VK?>E�ET�KHKCB?D�@?��

?P@��@KS��EE�PZK��US�@BC�Q�TECBNBB�B��EK��US)�u@CB�JU�ME�E�BJ�E

@?�ABCD�E@?B�B���?E�ZK���KJI�ME�E�BJ0�V?E�P��@KS�W?BS�@KT���?B@?@�

>BS�M�PTT0�B�P�M�PGB�@>E�0���JI�@>E�0��GK�A��HZ��@>E�0�?E�K@?D�P

HEJB�B�P^LBS�M�PTT�?EZK0�K@CB�P�>�ZHE��BG��BS�APHK?�@�EB�TECB�

NBI0�>E?E��I0�TC^@�>E��@KJP�?EJP0�V?E�P��BS�@KMEH�I�PZK�K@?D0�APHK?

KLK�B�TEHHK�Z����|RY]�B�?)H)0�>?E�?E�HECZK��M����?B�E��?D�8>�@E�

Page 12: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

Z�CK�B^0�I��K�P�BHKC��W?EME���=�>?K:0�V?E�W?B�TECBNK�@>BK�@BCU��K

@?��P?�G��?���EAU>�E�K��UJB�W>@?�KJB@?@>BJB�@BC�JB0��E�CPVkK

�EE�PZK��UJB0�?E�K@?D�@�CPVkBJB�@�KH@?��JB0�VKJ�@KMEH�I)�|K���HE

G�AU��?D0�V?E�>E�lCB>?���RAS�GBB���V�C@I�BJK��E�@���EH�����KK�?K��

�B?E�B^�TECBNK�@>BS0����K��EK��US�@BC�O�PGBB)

y��K�JEMP�TK�K�?B�>�VB@?E�TECB?BVK@>BJ��@TK>?�J�=�>?�0��K

>E@�P�kB@D�EVK�D�AECKG�K��E��HCI�JK�I�?KJU0�G�?�E�P?E����@�JE�

@C�AE��V�@?B�HE>PJK�?�)�R�?E�U�@��CBCB���EHB��>E?KC�RAS�GB^�B

RHZ��B^0�vSB���CD@>B���KMBE��B�qZ���SK?B)�X�?�>BJ�TEHSEHEJ�>

HKCP�JU�H�CK>E��K�P�HKJ)�Y�>E��@?�?P@�EHB��>E�E��KT�BKJCKJ�HCI

�@KS�@?E�E�)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E��KkK�BI�HCI���G�US��KMBE�E���K�JEMP?

AU?D�EHB��>E�UJB����G�UK��KMBE�U�?�KAP^?���G�EME�TEHSEH�0�TE?E�

JP�V?E�@B?P�NBI�?�J�@KMEH�I��A@EC^?�E���G��I)�tU��K�JEZKJ�ME�E�

�B?D�E�KHB�US�@?�P>?P��S�BCB�E�KHB�EJ�G�>E�EH�?KCD@?�K�BCB�E�T�B�

�I?BB�M�PGB�@>BJ�T��C�JK�?EJ�>�>BS�?E�EHB��>E�US�@?�?P@E�0����

T�BJK�0�HCI�RAS�GBB�B�HCI�qZ���SK?B�Q�W?E�T�E@?E��K�K�CD�E0��K

ME�E�I�PZK�E�T��>?BVK@>BS�TE@CKH@?�BIS�?�>BS�k�ME�)

]VK�D���Z�E�E?JK?B?D0�V?E���?E�U�=�>?��@@UC�^?@I����@EMC��

@BI0�H���UK�MC���JB�BCB�JB�B@?��JB�ME@PH��@?�0�>�>����B�BNB�?B�

�U0�>E?E�UK�@TE@EA@?�P^?�JB�P�B�@?�ABCD�E@?B����KMBE�K)��KCE�K>P0

T�EZB��^LKJP���EH�EJ�BG�W?BS�ME@PH��@?�0�>E?E�U��>�ZHU��HK�D

@CPk�K?�G�I�CK�BI�@�EKME�T���B?KCD@?���B���AC^H�K?�G��KME�HK�@?�B�

IJB0�EVK�D�?�PH�E�TE�K�B?D���VK@?�E@?D�?�>BS�G�I�CK�B�)�|�HE�AU?D

EVK�D���B��UJ�VKCE�K>EJ0�V?EAU�@?�EB?D�>�>BK�?E�BCC^GBB�����K�K

��@PLK@?�E���BK�TECB?BVK@>E���ECB)��B?�I�W?E?�=�>?0��@K���KJI����

?U>�KkD@I����NB?�?U��T�KGBHK�?�O�PGBB�BCB�JB�B@?��B�E@?����US

HKC�O�PGBB�G�I�BC)))0�BCB�JB�B@?��B�E@?����US�HKC�R�JK�BB0�BCB

T�KGBHK�?�RGK�A��HZ���)))��?E�W?E�G��VB?\�F�VKJP�W?B�NB?�?U\�|�kB

T���B?KCB�T�E@?E�SE?I?��UMCIHK?D�AECDkBJB�HKJE>��?�JB0�@EMC�@�

�UJB�����@K���HB�JB���B�@?�ABCD�E@?B0��E�@�EK��TE�@KH�K��E��HKI�

?KCD�E@?D^�?EV�E��K�@TE@EA@?�P^?��B���G�KkK�B^�>E�lCB>?E�0��B

G�>C�H>K�TK��US�>�J�K��HCI��K�CBG�NBB�SE?I�AU�TK��US�M����?B�

HKJE>��?BVK@>EME���G�B?BI)

|K�JK�KK���Z�UJ�I�CIK?@I�?E?�l�>?0�V?E���?E�U�NB?B�P^?�G�I��

CK�BI�?ECD>E�MC���?�KS�ME@PH��@?���Z�EME�F��>�G�)�YE�K@?D0�K@CB

JB�B@?��B�E@?����US�HKC�O�PGBB0�>�>�W?E�NB?B�PK?@I���=�>?K0�ME�E�

Page 13: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�B?0�V?E�E��@EMC�@K��@E��@KJB�JK��JB�HCI�P�KMPCB�E���BI�>E�lCB>�

?�0���J�W?E��BVKME��E�EME��K�H�K?�Q�EA�W?EJ�E�B�ME�E�I?�PZK��E@KJD

CK?)�|E�TEVKJP�?E��B>?E��K�G�SE?KC0��K�@VKC��PZ�UJ�EA��?B?D@I�@

?KJB�ZK��ET�E@�JB�>�E@?�CD�UJ�@PAwK>?�J�BCB�E@?�CD�UJ�C^HIJ0

>E?E�UK�T�KH@?��CI^?��?E�UK�@?E�E�U�>E�lCB>?E���E��@KS�W?BS�@?���

��S�Q���R�JK�BB0�RGK�A��HZ��K0�O�PGBB�B�zE@@BB)�|K?�@EJ�K�BI0

V?E���HB�@B^JB�P?�E���UMEHU���k�TECB?BVK@>B��B@?KACBkJK�?���

@CE��S�H�@?�@EMC�@BK�����@K0�CBkD�AU�P@>E�B?D���G�KkK�BK�>E�lCB>�

?�0� SE?I���CBNE�lE�@�J�ZE���I� @B?P�NBI0� >EMH��EH�E��CBkD��ECB

T�KGBHK�?��BCB�JB�B@?���B�E@?����US�HKC�HCI��K�CBG�NBB�TE@?���

CK��E��NKCB��KHE@?�?EV�E)

F�?EJP�ZK�EVK�D�B�?�BMP^LK��UMCIHB?�lE�JPC��}?�B�TC^@�?�B

TC^@�H��~)�p?B�}?�B�TC^@�?�B�TC^@�H��~�EG��V�^?��}?�B~�Q�O�PGBI0

R�JK�BI0�RGK�A��HZ��0��?E�EK�}?�B~�Q�W?E�YP�NBI0�zE@@BI0�����0��

}H��~�Q�W?E�RJK�B>��B�u��E@E^G)�F�@EZ�CK�B^0�B�>�JEKJP�AECDkEJP

PHB�CK�B^0�W?��lE�JPC���K�PVB?U��K?�E@?�CD�US�@?E�E��>E�lCB>�

?E�0�?E�K@?D��K@D�W?E?�HE>PJK�?�ME�E�B?�E�?EJ0�V?E�@TK����RJK�B>�0

u��E@E^G�B�zE@@BI�})))APHP?�T�KHC�M�?D�>E�>�K?�UK�TEHSEHU0�)))AP�

HP?�T�BMC�k�?D��@K�E@?�CD�UK�>E�?�>?�UK�M�PTTU�>�HB�CEMP�B�APHP?

T�KH@?��CI?D�TE�K@?>P�H�I�HCI�W?EME�HB�CEM��B�HCI���G�KkK�BI�>E��

lCB>?E�~)�R�G�?KJ0�TE@CK�T�BMC�kK�BI�>�HB�CEMP�@?�����KMBE���TC^@

@E@KHK��Q�YP�NBB�B������0�APHK?���G��AE?���>E�KV�U��HE>PJK�?�B

TEI�I?@I�>E�KV�UK��KGPCD?�?U)�p?��@B@?KJ��ETI?D�?�>B�>�>�I�?E��K

EVK�D��K�CD��I0�TE?EJP�V?E�W?E�G��VB?0�V?E�@TK����>?E�?E�APHK?�HB>�

?E��?D���J0�V?E�HKC�?D0���TE?EJ�JU�Q�E@?�CD�UK�@?E�E�U�Q�APHKJ��K�

k�?D0�>�>�W?E�HKC�?D0�ETI?D�?�>B�G��H�PMBS0�AKG�BS��K�CD�EME�PV�@?BI)

R�W?E��BVKME��K�BGJK�B?0�TE?EJP�V?E�?�>�I�JEHKCD���AE?�C��B��E���K�

JI�XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�0�T�E@?E�?EMH��HB>?E��CB�H�PMBK0���@�J�@NK���

�B��?E?�ZK���B>?E��K�@T��kB��K?�J�K�BI�?KS0�>?E�I�CI^?@I�MC���U�

JB�BM�E>�JB���W?EJ�@NK���BB�Q�@?E�E����>E�lCB>?K)�OE�E�B?D0�V?E

�ECI�XsR0�u��E@E^G��B�zE@@BB�Q�W?E�TECE�B���HKC�0���K@CB�>��K�

HEA��B?D�@EMC�@BK�@?�����KMBE��0�?E�W?E�PZK�>E�KN�T�EACKJU�Q�W?E

ZK�T�E@?E��K�K�CD�E)�p?E�JEZK?�SE�EkE�@JE?�K?D@I����APJ�MK0��E

�B>EMH���K�APHK?���AE?�?D����F��>�GK)

YE�K@?D�@�JP^�AECDkP^�T�EACKJP�I��BZP���@�JEJ�TEHSEHK�>�W?E�

T�EACKJK)�]�>�>E��AU�JEHKCB�JU�TE@CK��K�ME�E�BCB0�W?E�PZK�EG��V��

Page 14: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

K?0�V?E�E?@?���K�BK�E?�TK��E��V�CD�EME�HB�CEM��?KS0�HCI�>EME�W?E

ZBG�K��E���Z�E0�?KS0�HCI�>EME�E���@EGH�K?@I0�PZK�I�CIK?@I��KT���

�BCD�UJ��KkK�BKJ0���G��VB?0�JU��B@>PKJ�T�E��CB?D��K@D�T�ENK@@)

tU�ME�E�BCB�E�?EJ0�V?E�JEZ�E���V�?D�HB�CEM�H�PS�����US�@PAwK>�

?E�0���>�>BJB�APHP?��KGPCD?�?U�Q�TE>�ZK?�@�J�HB�CEM)�|E��E?�?�>E�

TEHSEH0�>E?E�U����G��AE?�����W?EJ�T�>?K0�@�J�TE�@KAK�PZK���@?ECD>E

�KT�BKJCKJ0�V?E�E�0�I�HPJ�^0�T�E@?E��K�HE�KHK?�W?E?�T�ENK@@�HE�>��

>BS�?E�@K�DKG�US��KGPCD?�?E�)

[�G�>C^VK�BK�KLK���G�TE�?E�^0�T�BVKJ��K�BG��KZCB�E@?B�Q�I

EVK�D�@K�DKG�E�AC�MEH�����?KJ0�>?E��CEZBC�@�E��?�PH���W?E?�HE>P�

JK�?0�TE?EJP�V?E�P���@�SE?I�AU�K@?D�V?E�?E0�E�VKJ�JU�JEZKJ�ME�E�

�B?D0���@@PZH�?D�Q�JEZKJ�@EMC�k�?D@I�BCB��K�@EMC�k�?D@I0��E��@K�

?�>B�K@?D�V?E�?E0�@�VKME�JU�JEZKJ���V�?D�@K�DKG�U��HB�CEM)

��KLK���G��AKG�TEC�EME�@E?�PH�BVK@?���B�M����?B�E����EME�@E�

MC�@BI��@KS�@?E�E�0�PV�@?�P^LBS���>E�lCB>?K0��B�E�>�>EJ�=�>?K�X?��

ABCD�E@?B�ME�E�B?D��K�EGJEZ�E)���@�JEK�MC���EK�Q�V?EAU�@PAwK>?U

E@EG��CB0�V?E�AKG�PVK?��BS��G�BJ�US�B�?K�K@E��8TECB?BVK@>BS0�W>E�

�EJBVK@>BS�BCB�@?��?KMBVK@>BS:�B�@?�EB?KCD@?���HKJE>��?BVK@>EME

ME@PH��@?����@K�TETU?>B�P@?��E�CK�BI�@?�ABCD�E@?B�B�JB������F���

>�GK�APHP?���T��@�U)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�y�SE?KC� P?EV�B?D���@VK?� KHB�E���E�J�?B��E�A�GU)��?E�GHK@D�BJKK?@I����BHP\�=E�JU@CB���?E�E��W?EME�T�EK>?�0

HECZ�E�@EGH���?D@I�KHB�EK�T���E�EK�T�E@?���@?�E\

�� �%!���R�S���8�q�0��KVD�BHK?�E�KHB�EJ�T���E�EJ�T�E@?���@?�K0��BJK��E0�E�@EGH��BB�JEHKCB��E�J�?B��E��A�GU0�>E?E��I�TE?EJ�AP�

HK?�@CPZB?D�JEHKCD^�HCI��@KS�W?BS�ME@PH��@?�)�=�KHTEC�M�K?@I0�V?E

>�ZH�I�@?�����BJKK?�@�E^�>E�@?B?PNB^0��E�W?B�>E�@?B?PNBB�HECZ�

�U�AU?D��K>E?E�UJ�EA��GEJ�}JEHKCD�E�EA��AE?��U~�@�PV�@?BKJ��@KS

@?���)���?��ZK�@�J�I�T�EACKJ��Q��KVD�BHK?�?ECD>E�E�@PLK@?�P^LBS

@?����S0�?E�K@?D���H�MC���UJB�T�B�NBT�JB0�>E?E�UK�TE?EJ�E?��GI?�

@I�����kBS�>E�@?B?PNBIS0�HECZ�U���AE?�?D�M�PGB�U0���JI�K0��GK��

A��HZ��NU�B�zE@@BI)�R�TE?EJ�>�ZH�I�@?�����T�B�BJ�K?�@�E^�@EA�

@?�K��P^�>E�@?B?PNB^)���?��ZK�T�ENKHP���TE��@KJ�G�>E��J�B��@KJ

Page 15: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

E@?�CD�UJ��E�J�?B��UJ��>?�J0�?E�K@?D�T�KHTEC�M�K?@I�KHB��I�T���

�E��I�A�G�0�KHB��I�@B@?KJ�0��E���G�UK�T���E�UK��>?U)

M���� �/%�"�-8�y��K�TE�IC0�>?E�@EGH�K?�W?P�TECBNB^�HCI�P@JB�K�BI�KHE�ECD�US\�X�JB�@EGH�^?\

�� �%!���R�S���8�q�0�E�B�@�JB�@KAK�@EGH�^?)

M���� �/%�"�-8�]�B�KLK�T�B�CK>�^?���?E�NK��B�H�PMBS0�>?E�@EMC��

@K�\

�� �%!���R�S���8�|K?0���?E�NK���K�T�B�CK>�^?0���?E�NU�@�JB�AP�HP?�TEJEM�?D���TE�UkK�BB�T�ElK@@BE��CBGJ��TECBNK�@>BS�@BC)

��������%�"�8�RAS�GBI�?EZK�APHK?�BJK?D�@�E^�TECBNB^)

�������!"�#�-8�R�JU�T�E?B��>EME�APHKJ�BJK?D\���� � ������

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�y�SE?KC�P?EV�B?D���@VK?�XK�K��EME�F��>�G�)�xUCE@>�G��E0�V?E�W?B�G�>E�EH�?KCD@?���BCB�T���E�UK��>?U�HECZ�U�AU?D

T�E����@B�E���U�>�>BJB�?E�HK�@?�BIJB����XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK)�q�\

�� �%!���R�S���8�=E?EJP�V?E�XK�K��U��F��>�G���@@J�?�B��K?@I>�>�V�@?D�W?EME�EALKME�ME@PH��@?���BCB�@EEALK@?���ME@PH��@?�)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�[�?�>EJ�@CPV�K0�T�KHTEC�M�K?@I0�V?E�G�>E�EH�?KCD�@?�E����K@TPACB>�S�XK�K��EME�F��>�G��?EZK�HECZ�E�AU?D�TEHEM���E

TEH�W?B�EALBK�A�C��@U�

��������%�"�8�p?E�EALKK��ETK�@>BK�@?��H��?U�

�� �%!���R�S���8�[@I�T�EACKJ����?EJ0�V?E�W?E?�T�>?0�TE�@�EK��@P?B0@EGH���HCI�P�KMPCB�E���BI�T�EACKJ�����Z�EJ�F��>�GK0��E�TEVKJP�

?E�TE?EJ����K>E?E�US�JEJK�?�S�?�J�BHK?��KVD�B�E�XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK)

[@K�W?E�EVK�D��KTE�I?�E)�F�>P^��ECD�BM��K?�XK�K��U��F��>�G���W?EJ

@EGH�^LKJ@I�EALKJ�ME@PH��@?�K�BCB�@EEALK@?�K�ME@PH��@?�\�{HK@D

Page 16: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�BMHK��BVKME��K�@>�G��E�E�?EJ0���>�>E��lE�JK�XK�K��U��F��>�G�APHK?

��W?EJ�PV�@?�E��?D)�{��VB?�CB�W?E0�V?E�XK�K��U��F��>�G��USEHB?�BG

zE@@BB�B�@?��E�B?@I�V�@?D^�W?EME��E�EME�@EEALK@?��\��CB�W?E�G���

VB?0�V?E�zE@@BI�@�J��>�>�?�>E��I�@?��E�B?@I�V�@?D^�W?EME�>��>�G@>E�

ME�ME@PH��@?��\�]A�W?EJ���?E�U�PZK��K�ME�E�I?)�=EW?EJP�W?E�EVK�D

T�EACKJ�?BV�E)�OHK�?E�����V�CK�HE>PJK�?��TK�KVB@CI^?@I�O�PGBI0

R�JK�BI0�RGK�A��HZ���B�XK�K��U��F��>�G0���TE?EJ�PZK�?ECD>E�O�P�

GBI0�R�JK�BI�B�RGK�A��HZ��)�]�XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK�����G�US�JK@?�S

V?E�?E���TB@��E0��E��K�EVK�D�VK?>E)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�|�@>ECD>E�I�TE�IC�BG���kKME��U@?PTCK�BI0���E�

HB?@I� KHB��I���C^?�0�H�E��EK� M��ZH��@?�E)�[�Kk�KTECB?BVK@>�I

HKI?KCD�E@?D�?EZK�APHK?�KHB�E�\

�� �%!���R�S���8�[�T�>?K�ME�E�B?@I0�V?E��@K�@?���U�E@?��P?@IVCK��JB�]]|)�tKZHP���EH�UK�E�M��BG�NBB��K�P@J�?�B��^?�VCK��

@?�E��KT�BG����US�ME@PH��@?�0��E�?�J�ZK�ME�E�B?@I0�V?E�E@?�K?@I

�EGJEZ�E@?D�HCI�H�P@?E�E��BS�HEME�E�E��B�@EMC�kK�B��JKZHP�JKZ�

HP���EH�UJB�E�M��BG�NBIJB�B�V�@?IJB�W?BS�ME@PH��@?�)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�{��VB?�CB�W?E0�V?E�T�KHC�M�KJUK�JK�U�PLKJCI�

^?�BCB�EM���BVB��^?�@P�K�K�B?K?0���T�BJK�0�O�PGBB\

�� �%!���R�S���8�|K?0�I�W?EME��K�ME�E�BC���|E0�>E�KV�E0���kK

ME@PH��@?�E�EA�W?EJ�HPJ�K?)�u@CB�JU�APHKJ�@?�EB?D�@KMEH�I�P�KMPCB�

�E���BK�>E�lCB>?E�����F��>�GK�TE�?E��JEHKCB0�>E?E��I�GHK@D�T�KH�

C�M�K?@I�Q���KHK�BK�H�E��EME�BCB�?�E��EME�M��ZH��@?��0�EALK�����

C^?U�B�?)H)�Q�?E�W?E�APHK?�EVK�D��K�K�CD�E)�=E?EJP�V?E�@?���U0�>E?E�

�UK�?ECD>E�V?E�AE�ECB@D�B�T�EHECZ�^?�AE�E?D@I�G��@�EK�M��ZH���

@?�E0�G��@�E^�@EA@?�K��P^���C^?P0�G��@�E��@EA@?�K��U��IGU>�B�?)H)0

?�>�T�E@?E�E?��@KME�W?EME��K�E?>�ZP?@I)�=EW?EJP�I�AUC��EVK�D�@>KT�

?BVK@>B���@?�EK���TE�W?EJP�TE�EHP)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8��?E�JEZ�E�@>�G�?D�E���KHK�BB�EALK����C^�

?U\��?E�APHK?�@���NBE��CD�E�\

Page 17: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�� �%!���R�S���8�p?E�APHK?�>�>�}K��E~�Q�?E�K@?D���C^?��JEZK?AU?D��EJB��CD�E�0��E�KHB�E�0��E�TE?EJ�@>C�HU��K?@I��TKV�?CK�BK0

V?E��KT���BCD�E�BJK?D�H�ZK��EJB��CD�UK���G���BI)

[E?�E�IGU>K���T�>?K�TEVKJP�?E��BVKME��K�ME�E�B?@I)�OE�E�B?@I

EAE��@KJ0��E��K�E�IGU>K)�|��K��EK0���?E�U�HPJ�CB0�V?E�W?E�EVK�D�AE�

CKG�K��U���ET�E@�B�CPVkK�KME��K�>�@�?D@I)

M���� �/%�"�-8�R�>?E�>E�>�K?�E�T�KHCEZBC�@EGH��BK�W?EME�T�>?�\

��������%����S,���8�p?E�BHKI�ME@TEHB���[���HK��X?PC�)

��������%�"�8�qCI� ?EME0� V?EAU� @?�ABCBGB�E��?D� @B?P�NB^���

�Z�EJ�F��>�GK0�CBHK�U�>��>�G@>BS�ME@PH��@?��B�qKJB�KCD�EA��?B�

CB@D�@�T�BGU�EJ�@EGH�?D�@E�JK@?�P^�T�EM��JJP�HK�@?�B�)

��,� ��.�S,���8�FE�>�K?�E�W?E?�T�>?�TEHME?E�BC�vK�?��K��E�TK�@>BS�TECB?BVK@>BS�B@@CKHE���B�)

��������%�"�8�q�0�E�B���G��AE?VB>B0���T�E�EGMC�@BC�W?P�BHK^�t�>@

[���HK��X?PC)

�!������"8�F�>��@K�?�>B�APHP?�@?�EB?D@I���Kk�BK�E?�EkK�BI\

�� �%!���R�S���8�tKZHP���EH�UK�E�M��BG�NBB�Q�]]|0�]xXu�B

?)H)� Q��K�T�KHP@J�?�B��^?�VCK�@?����KT�BG����US� ME@PH��@?�0��E

APHP?�T��>?B>E��?D@I�H�P@?E�E��BK�@EMC�kK�BI)�[�T�>?K�TK�KVB@CK�

�U�EAC�@?B0���>E?E�US�W?E�JEZ�E�@HKC�?D�Q�@TE�?0�>PCD?P���B�?)H)

=�EACKJU�ZK�E?�EkK�B��@�H�PMBJB�@?����JB�APHP?��Kk�?D@I�@�JB�

JB�W?BJB�@?����JB)�YE�K@?D�K@CB�APHK?��Kk�?D@I��ET�E@�E�@EMC�kK�

�BB�JKZHP�|�ME��UJ�F���A�SEJ�B�xKCDMBK�0�?E�W?E��Kk�?D�xKCDMBB)

��R��� ����0�8�n�JK�I��ET�E@�TE�TE�EHP�H�E��EME�M��ZH��@?��)�JKK?@I����BHP�M��ZH��@?�E�EAwKHB�K��EME�B�@�EKME�ME@PH��@?��\

�� �%!���R�S���8�]VK�D�SE�EkB���ET�E@)�|E�I��K�JEMP�����KME

E?�K?B?D)�=�>?��BMHK��K�E?�KV�K?����W?E?��ET�E@)�[��V�CK��KVD�BHK?�E

Page 18: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

?EJ0�V?E�RGK�A��HZ���B�R�JK�B^�P@?��B��K?�H�E��EK�M��ZH��@?�E

EAKBS�@?���)�[�H�PME��V�@?B��KVD�BHK?�E�M��ZH��@?�K�@�EKME�ME@PH���

@?���TC^@�M��ZH��@?�K�EAwKHB�K��EME�>��>�G@>EME�ME@PH��@?��)�=E�

?EJ�PZK0���@TKNB�CD�EJ�T���M��lK�E�T�@TE�?K0�ME�E�B?@I0�V?E�HEC�

ZK��AU?D���KHK��KHB�U��T�@TE�?�EAwKHB�K��EME�>��>�G@>EME�ME@P�

H��@?��0�>�>���u��E@E^GK)�����W?EJ�T�@TE�?K�TI?U��TP�>?0�TI?�I�M���

l�0�APHK?�M��lE��}��NBE��CD�E@?D~0�?E�K@?D�?�J�JEZ�E�G�TB@�?D�}M�P�

GB�~0�}VKVK�KN~0�}�AS�G~�B�?)H)�YE�K@?D���?�KS���G�US�JK@?�S�H�^?@I

��G�UK��KNKT?U)�[��V�CK�T�B�KHK�U���>�VK@?�K�T�BJK���R�JK�BI�B

RGK�A��HZ��0�TE?EJ�BHK?�B�lE�J�NBI�E�H�PS�M��ZH��@?��S�Q�@�EKME

ME@PH��@?���TC^@�EALKME0���H�CDkK�ME�E�B?@I�E�T�@TE�?K�B�VK?>E

P>�GU��K?@I0�V?E�W?E�KHB�U��T�@TE�?�EAwKHB�K��EME�>��>�G@>EME�ME�

@PH��@?��� HCI� �@KS0� �� >E?E�EJ�T�KHP@JE?�K��� M��l��}��NBE��CD�

�E@?D~)

��R��� ����0�8�=�E���NBE��CD�E@?D�I�TE�BJ�^)�|E�T�B�VKJ�?P?H�E��EK�M��ZH��@?�E\

�� �%!���R�S���8�p?E�HK�@?�B?KCD�E��KTE�I?�E)

��������%�"�8�[BHBJE0�W?E�>�>E��?E�TEW?�T�U��T�ENK@@�

��,� ��.�S,���8�{HK@D��KVD�BHK?�E�?�E��EJ�M��ZH��@?�K0�?E�K@?DVKCE�K>�JEZK?�AU?D�EH�E��KJK��E�M��ZH��B�EJ�RAS�GBB�B�O�PGBB

B�?�K?DK��@?���U)

�0��%�8�qCI�A^�E>��?E��APHK?�J�EME���AE?U)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�n�JK�I�K@?D�KLK��ET�E@)�u@CB�T�KHTECEZB?D0�V?E

�KT�BG����UK�ME@PH��@?���Q�HETP@?BJ0�RAS�GBI�Q�@EMC�@�U����>��

>BK�?E�JK�U�Q�T�KHTECEZBJ0����KHB�P^���C^?P�?BT��}K��E~�BCB���

H�E��EK�M��ZH��@?�E�Q�JEZK?�CB�W?E�TE@CPZB?D�HCI�O�PGBB��K>E?E�

�UJ�@?BJPCEJ�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU�T�B�I?D�W?B�JK�U0�BCB�E�B��@K�����E

�KT�BKJCKJU\

�� �%!���R�S���8�qCI�JK�I�CBV�E�W?E�@�JEK�MC���EK)�[�W?BS��ET��E@�S�I�@EMC�@���@�?KJ0�V?E�GHK@D�T�KHC�M�K?@I0�?)K)�@E��@KJB�JK��JB0

Page 19: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

>E?E�UK�T�B�KHP?�>��K�CD�E��@?�ABCD�E@?B�B�JB�P)�|E0�>�@EZ�CK�

�B^0�P�JK�I�?�>EK��TKV�?CK�BK0�V?E�M�PGB�@>�I�TECB?BVK@>�I�WCB?�

E?�K@K?@I�>�W?BJ�T�KHCEZK�BIJ�AKG�W�?PGB�GJ�)�|E0��EGJEZ�E0�E��

APHK?��U�PZHK���@EMC�@B?D@I�TEH�JKZHP���EH�UJ�H��CK�BKJ)�y�TE�

V?B�P�K�K��0�V?E�K@CB�APHK?�@K�DKG�EK�JKZHP���EH�EK�H��CK�BK�TC^@

@EMC�@BK�|�ME��EME�F���A�S�0�RAS�GBB0��Z�E��]@K?BB�B� ?)H)0� ?E0

���K��EK0�B�T�BG����UK�ME@PH��@?������W?E�TE�HP?)�=E?EJP�V?E�HCI

�BS�Q��E��@I>EJ�@CPV�K0�HCI�O�PGBB�Q�EVK�D���Z���JKZHP���EH��I

�KTP?�NBI)�p?E�KHB�@?�K��EK�@�KH@?�E0����>E?E�EK�JU�JEZKJ�@KMEH�

�I�TECEZB?D@I)

�������!"�#�-8�FEMH����GME�E��BHK?�E�H�E��EJ�M��ZH��@?�K0�?E�V?EBJKK?@I����BHP0�K@CB�?�J�VK?U�K�@?E�E�U�Q�O�PGBI0�R�JK�BI0�RGK��

A��HZ���B0�@>�ZKJ0�zE@@BI\�X>�ZKJ0�M��ZH��B��O�PGBB�JEZK?�TE

�UAE�P��GI?D�KLK�EH�E�>�>EK�?E�M��ZH��@?�E�BCB�E��JEZK?��GI?D�M��Z�

H��@?�E��@KS�E@?�CD�US�?�KS�KHB�BN\

�� �%!���R�S���8�p?E��KI@�E)

��,� ��.�S,���8�y�BJKC��EGJEZ�E@?D�CBV�E�EAL�?D@I�@���?E���

JB)�]�B�BJK^?����BHP0�V?E�K@?D�M��ZH��@?�E�EALK>��>�G@>EK�B��JK@�

?K�@�W?BJ�K@?D�M��ZH��@?�E0�@>�ZKJ0�M�PGB�@>EK0�����@CPV�K�?�>BS

EA��GE���B�0�>�>�F���A�S0�RAS�GBI0�HETEC�B?KCD�E�KLK��AS�G@>EK0

>���A�S@>EK0�E@K?B�@>EK)

�������%�"�8�p?E0����K��EK0�APHK?�>�>���s�K�N��BB�Q�?�B�P�E��I

M��ZH��@?��)

�� �%!���R�S���8�qCI���GwI@�K�BI�I�T�EV?P�EVK�D�J�CK�D>B��T����M��l)�tEZK?�AU?D0�TE@CK�W?EME�@?��K?�TE�I?�KK)�{HK@D���TB@��E�

}=�@TE�?�APHK?�BJK?D���G���BK�}�Z�E�F��>�G@>EK�@EEALK@?�E~0�B��

�KJ�APHK?�>E�>�K?BGB�E�����ME@PH��@?�K���I�T�B��HCKZ�E@?D�CBV�

�E@?B�~�������� �������������

Page 20: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��������%�"�g� ���0!RR��U%��R�.!%��������0��,�/��!,�%�

�����������f �����M�h���d����������M��f���i���d������j�� ����g��

������������

=�B�CK>�?KCD�E@?D�BHKB�EALK>��>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB�T�KH@?���

CIK?@I��TEC�K�EVK�BH�E�)�|K@JE?�I����?E0�V?E���GCBV�UK��KMBE�U

F��>�G�����T�E?IZK�BB��K>E��TET�H�CB�TEH��CBI�BK�BCB��SEHBCB��

@E@?��������0�YP�NBB�B�zE@@BB0�ELPLK�BK�EALKME�>PCD?P��EME�B

HPSE��EME�KHB�@?���@ES���BCE@D)�]@EG���BK�T�B��HCKZ�E@?B�>�F���

>�GP0�>�>��>�G@>E��NB�BCBG�NBB�PZK��K���G�B�BNBB�E��CE�TETU?>B

���EHE��F��>�G��EAwKHB�B?D@I� ���K>P^�>PCD?P��E�TECB?BVK@>P^

EAL�E@?D0�T�BVKJ�>�ZH�I�BG�?�>BS�TETU?E>�T�EB@SEHBC������E�EJ

B@?E�BVK@>EJ��B?>K)�qE@?�?EV�E��@TEJ�B?D�TC��U�@EGH��BI�F��>�G�

@>E��>E�lKHK��NBB0�>E?E�UK��TK��UK�AUCB�EG�PVK�U��K@�E��.5.7�M)

���=K��EJ�OE�@>EJ�@wKGHK��E�[C�HB>��>�GK0�>EMH��AUCE�G�I�CK�E�E

@EGH��BB�XE^G��EAwKHB�K��US�ME�NK��XK�K��EME�F��>�G��B�q�MK@�

?���)�p?B�BHKB�TECPVBCB�@�EK�H�CD�K�kKK���G�B?BK���TE@CKHP^LBK

JK@INU�����T�KCK�.5.;�M)�{�>��>�G@>B��@K�J�EAwI�BC�E�@EGH��BB��K�

G��B@BJE��E?�zE@@BB�lKHK��?B��E���K@TPACB>B0�T���H�� @�J� @K�J

T�E@PLK@?�E��C�CBkD�HE�J�I�?EME�ZK�MEH�)�F�>�BG�K@?�E0�@�.5,,�TE

.536�MM)�@PLK@?�E��C��{�>��>�G@>�I�lKHK��NBI0�>PH���SEHBCB�O�PGBI0

R�JK�BI�B�RGK�A��HZ��)

F�>�TE@CK�T�HK�BI�N��@>E��zE@@BB0�?�>�B�TE@CK���@T�H��XXXz

BHKI�EAwKHB�K�BI�F��>�G��EA�KC���E�P^�ZBG�D)�|KCDGI��K�P�BHK?D

���CEMB^�JKZHP�T�E�EGMC�kK�BKJ�XE^G��EAwKHB�K��US�ME�NK��F���

>�G��B�q�MK@?����8.5.7�M):�B�@EGH��BKJ�FE�lKHK��NBB�ME�@>BS����EHE�

F��>�G��8FO|F:0�TK��U��@wKGH�>E?E�E��T�EkKC���.5;5�M)���XPSPJK)�YE

EA@?EI?KCD@?�E0�V?E�@EGH��BK�FO|F�T�EB@SEHBCE����lE�K�EAE@?�B��

kBS@I�HE�>����E@?B�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BS�E?�EkK�B��8>�E���UK�@?EC>�

�E�K�BI�B CI�.5;5�M):0�@HKC�CE��K�EGJEZ�UJ�PV�@?BK����KJ�M�PGB�)

uLK�EH���TETU?>��EAwKHB�K�BI�AUC��T�KHT�B�I?����@K�?IA�K

.55,�M)0�>EMH��qZ)�qPH�K��B�{)�O�J@�SP�HB��T�E�KCB���O�EG�EJ�}>�PM�

CU��@?EC~0����>E?E�EJ�EA@PZH�C�@D�BHKI�@EGH��BI�F��>�G@>EME�qEJ�)

Page 21: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

nV�@?�B>B��@?�KVB�T�B�ICB�>EJJ^�B>K0���>E?E�EJ�T�BGU��CB��@K

���EHU0� ME@PH��@?��0� EALK@?�K��UK�B� �KCBMBEG�UK�EAwKHB�K�BI0

TECB?BVK@>BK�T��?BB�B�H�BZK�BI�F��>�G��E>�G�?D��@KJK��EK�@EHK��

@?�BK�E@PLK@?�CK�B^�W?E��BHKB)�xUCE�G�I�CK�E0�V?E���@EGH���KJEJ

F��>�G@>EJ�qEJK�>�ZHEJP����EHP�APHP?�EAK@TKVK�U�AKGET�@�E@?D�B

@�EAEH�EK���G�B?BK)�=���H�0���YABCB@B��@K�T�EB@SEHILKK���O�EG�EJ

�E@T�B�ICB�>����K�E?�BN�?KCD�E0�TE@>ECD>P�TE�B�BNB�?B�K�@�K�M�

�P?EME�T�KGBHK�?��{)�O�J@�SP�HB�0���SEHB�kKME@I���O�EG�EJ���BG�

M���BB0��E���KJI�W?E���@?�KVB�AUCE�T�B�I?E�HE�ECD�E��KG>EK�G�I��

CK�BK�EA�}E@PZHK�BB��EK��EME�TK�K�E�E?��B�T�K@?PT�US�HK�@?�B�

?)�)�OE@@E�K?��O�PGBB��E�MC��K�@�sK���H��HGK�B�E?�K?@?�K��E@?B��P�

>E�EH@?���zE@@B�@>E��mKHK��NBB�TK�KH�M�PGB�@>BJ�B��AS�G@>BJ����

�EH�JB~0���?�>ZK�?�KAE���BK�E�}�KG�JKHCB?KCD�EJ��E@@?��E�CK�BB

>E�@?B?PNBE��E���C�@?B���O�PGBB0��U�EH��>���?KCD�US��E�@>�@�?K��

�B?E�BB�RAS�GBB~).

[�Z�E�E?JK?B?D0�V?E���R�JK�BB�@�@�JEME���V�C��HE�ECD�E�T�E�

SC�H�E�E?�K@CB@D�>�TETU?>�J�?�>EME��EH�0���GU��I�BS�}HK@?�P>?B��

�E��B�?KM��NBK�~)�[���JI�@>BS�TECB?BVK@>BS�>�PM�S��U@>�GU��CB@D

TEHEG�K�BI0�V?E�G���@KJB�B�BNB�?B��JB�EAwKHB�K�BI�F��>�G��@?EB?

YP�NBI0�JKV?�^L�I�EA�P@BCK�BB�@�EKME��CBI�BI����KMBE�K)

zK�CD�EK�EAwKHB�K�BK�F��>�G��KLK��B>EMH���K�E@PLK@?�CICE@D

@�BGP0����@KMH��T�EB@SEHBCE�@�K�SP0�TE�B�BNB�?B�K�?KS�BCB�B�US���K�

k�BS�@BC�B0�K@?K@?�K��E0���@EE?�K?@?�BB�@�BS�B�?K�K@�JB)�F�>�@T���

�KHCB�E�E?JKV�K?�])�q�JK�B�0����DkK�F��>�G��E@T�B�BJ�C@I���K�

k�BJ�JB�EJ�>�>�lE�TE@?�>�>E��CBAE�JK?�ETECBB�BCB�ZK�>�>�KK�E>�

��B��)�X�JE@?EI?KCD�E��MKETECB?BVK@>E���ECB�E���K�BM��C�B���SE�

HBC@I�>�>�AU���K�B@?E�BB), ���W?E��E�J�EMEJ�EAP@CE�CK�E�AK@>E�KV�

�UJB�B�AK@VB@CK��UJB�>E�lCB>?�JB0�TE�EZHK��UJB��@K��T�KHkK�

@?�P^LK��B@?E�BK���KMBE��0�TE@?EI��E�BGJK�I�kK�@I���@@?��E�>E�

@BC����F��>�GK�B��E>�PM��KME)�oE?I�BG�K@?�U��TECB?ECEM�VKVK�@>EME

T�EB@SEZHK�BI�R)�R�?E�S��E��B�T�KHPT�KZH�C�>��>�GNK�0�V?E0��E^I

JKZHP�@EAE�0�E�B��B>EMH���K�APHP?��B�@�EAEH�UJB0��B��KG��B@BJU�

JB0���IH�CB�@KMEH�I�@�JB�>��>�GNU���@BC�S�T�E?B�E@?EI?D���G�K��

�P�kK�@I�MKETECB?BVK@>E��BM�K�G��ME@TEH@?�E���F��>�G@>EJ��KMBE�

�K)�p?P�BM�P��KHP?�?�>BK�@K�DKG�UK��>?E�U�>�>�zE@@BI0�{�T�H��I�u��

�ET��B�XsR�T�B��>?B��EJ�PV�@?BB��CBI?KCD�US��KMBE��CD�US�ME�

Page 22: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

@PH��@?��[E@?E>��Q�������B�YP�NBB)�XCKHE��?KCD�E0��K�APHK?�T�KP�K�

CBVK�BKJ�@>�G�?D0�V?E�AE�DA��G��TECB?BVK@>B��B�W>E�EJBVK@>B��>E��

?�ECD���H�F��>�GEJ�I�CIK?@I�EH�BJ�BG�ET�KHKCI^LBS�l�>?E�E��@E�

��KJK��E��@B?P�NBB)

�� ���������� �������� �������

�?�>0���TE@CKH�KK�HK@I?BCK?BK�AUC��T�EHKJE�@?�B�E������KME�

?E��E@?D�>��>�GNK��>�EAwKHB�K�B^�AKG��JKk�?KCD@?�����Kk�BS�@BC)

=E��BHBJEJP0�MC���UJ�T�KTI?@?�BKJ�E@?�K?@I��KPJK�BK�@lE�JPCB�

�E��?D��K>BK�EALBK�NK��E@?B�BCB�B�?K�K@U0�V?E��K�EGJEZ�E�>EJ�

TK�@B�E��?D��B�TK�@TK>?B�E���Kl?I�EME�T�EN�K?��BI0��B�H�PMBJB

G�J��VB�UJB�EAKL��BIJB)�[EGJEZ�E0�EH���BG�T�BVB��>�EK?@I���?EJ0

@VB?�K?�TECB?ECEM�R)��@>��HK�I�0�V?E�@KMEH�I����F��>�GK��K�G�>E��

VBC@I�T�ENK@@��U��AE?>B���NBE��CD�E��@�JEBHK�?BlB>�NBB�B�@?��

�E�CK�BI���NBE��CD�US�ME@PH��@?��Q�T�ENK@@0�>E?E�U��T�EB@SEHBC

��u��ETK����T�E?IZK�BB�.4�.5���)�=EW?EJP0�TE�J��B^�R)��@>��HK�I�

��0�TETU?>B�B�?KM��NBB��K�JEMP?�AU?D�P@TKk�UJB�HE�?KS�TE�0�TE>�

�K�G�>E�VBCE@D�ElE�JCK�BK���NBE��CD�E��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�@E��@K�

JB�T�B@PLBJB�K���?�BAP?�JB0�?�>BJB0���T�BJK�0�>�>���NBE��CD��I

TECB?BVK@>�I�>PCD?P��)�3

[���@?EILKK���KJI�JU�I�CIKJ@I�@�BHK?KCIJB�KLK�EH�E��TETU?�

>B�EAwKHB�K�BI�F��>�G�)�[��EIA�K�.555�M)����X�JJB?K�]xXu���X?�J�

APCK�T�KGBHK�?�RGK�A��HZ����O)�RCBK��EG�PVBC0���CBHK�U�R�JK�BB

B�O�PGBB�z)�FEV��I��B�p)�sK���H��HGK�TEHHK�Z�CB�BHK^���G��AE?>B

B�T�B�I?BI�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B�HCI�F��>�G�)�=EGZK0��E���KJI��BGB?�

��O�PGB^0���I����K�,---�M)0�AU�kB��T�KGBHK�?�YP�NBB�X)�qKJB�KCD

�U@?PTBC���TEHHK�Z>P�?�>EME�T�>?�0�>E?E�U��@TE@EA@?�E��C�AU�AK�

GET�@�E@?B�B�@?�ABCD�E@?B����F��>�GK)�]H��>E��E��@KS�W?BS��U@?PT�

CK�BIS��KVD�kC���K�E�>�>EJ�?E�>E�>�K?�EJ�TC��K0���EA�EALK��BHKK)�[

E?�K?����W?E?�T�BGU��,;�I����I�,---�M)�[K�SE��U��>EJB@@���]xXu

TE�T����J�JK�DkB�@?��t)�[���HK��X?PC�T�KHCEZBC�@lE�JB�E��?D

��AEVP^�M�PTTP�T�B�}vK�?�K�K��ETK�@>BS�TECB?BVK@>BS�B@@CKHE���

�B�~�8vu=�:0�>E?E��I�G��IC�@D�AU�TEHME?E�>E���EGJEZ�E��JEHKCB

TECB?BVK@>E��B�W>E�EJBVK@>E��B�?KM��NBB�F��>�G@>EME��KMBE��)�[@K

CK?E�T�EHECZ�CB@D��>?B��UK�HB@>P@@BB�B�TEKGH>B�VCK�E����AEVK�

Page 23: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

M�PTTU�vu=��TE���GCBV�UJ��KMBE��J��Z�EME�F��>�G�0��>C^V�I�B

?)�)�ME�IVBK�?EV>B�Q�|�ME��U��F���A�S0�RAS�GB^0��Z�P^�]@K?B^�B

E?�E@B?KCD�E�JB��P^�RHZ��B^)�F���@?EILKJP���KJK�B���?E�U���G�

��AE?VB>B�T�KHC�M�^?�lE�JPCP�B�?KM��NBB�3�3�,0� V?E�EG��V�K?�

8RGK�A��HZ���Q�R�JK�BI�Q�O�PGBI:���8zE@@BI�Q�YP�NBI�Q�����:��

8XsR�Q�u��ET�:)�[E?�>�>��UMCIHB?���EALBS�VK�?�S�JEHKCD0�T�KHC��

M�KJ�I���AEVK��M�PTTE��vu=�)

��� ���� � !" # $��%���&

.) P�KMPCB�E���BK�>E�lCB>?E����|�ME��EJ�F���A�SK0�RAS�GBB�B

�Z�E��]@K?BBc

,) EAK@TKVK�BK��KMBE��CD�E��AKGET�@�E@?B�TEH�WMBHE��]xXuc

3) B�BNB�?B�U�TE�lE�JB�E���B^��Z�E�F��>�G@>EME�@EEALK@?��)

��� ���� � ������� �� '#��� ���#%#�# �#��() �*�����&

.) HK�@?�BI�u��E@E^G��B�zE@@BB�TE���G�B?B^�@E?�PH�BVK@?�����

�Z�EJ�F��>�GKc

,) P@BCK�BK��ECB��K��EJE�@>EME�W>E�EJBVK@>EME�@E?�PH�BVK@?��c

3) P>�KTCK�BK�T���E�US�E@�E��HCI�?���GB?���Kl?B�B�M�G��8@?�?P@

F�@TB�@>EME�JE�I0�T�E?E>EC�TE�?���GB?�UJ��Kl?K��B�M�GET�E�E�

H�J:)

=C^@�@EGH��BK�JKS��BGJ��HCI�@?��?KMBB�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B0

>E�@PCD?�NB��B�>EE�HB��NBB)

[��KGPCD?�?K�>E�@PCD?�NB��VCK�E����AEVK��M�PTTU�B�BGPVK�BI

�K�>NBB����KMBE�K����E@�E��UK�T�B�NBTU�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B�AUCB

@HKC��U�@CKHP^LBK���GwI@�K�BI)

.) |KEASEHBJ��@KEAwKJC^LB�0�J�EME@?E�E��B��TEHSEH0�E@�E����

�U�������CBVBB�@�IGK��JKZHP�>E�lCB>?�JB�����Z�EJ�F��>�GK

B��K>E��>EETK��NBB���@?E�E�P�T���CCKCD�EME��KkK�BI)�p?B�@�I�

GB�@?��E�BCB@D��@K�AECKK�EVK�BH�UJB�TE�JK�K�TEKGHE>���G���

AE?VB>E��TE��KMBE�P)�Y�>0�]@K?BI�EZBH�K?�P�KMPCB�E���BI���RA�

S�GBB0���RAS�GBI���AC^H�K?�G��?KJ0�>�>�W?E�T�EBGE�HK?���|�ME��

�EJ�F���A�SK)�OEHU�T�ESEHI?0���HBTCEJ�?U�]]|�B�]xXu��@K�KLK

Page 24: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�KHP?�EHB����P�H�TK�KME�E�E��G��H�PMBJ)�YECD>E��KCB>BK�HK�Z��

�U�JEMP?�E@PLK@?�B?D�E?SEH�E?�@SKJU�T�E?B�E@?EI�BI0�>EMH��EH��

>EJ��H��BM�E>E��@VB?�K?�@KAI���SEHILK�@I�TEH�G�LB?E��zE@@BB0

��H�PM�I�Q�{�T�H�)�RCD?K���?B�E��?�>E��@SKJK�JEZK?�@?�?D�P�K�

MPCB�E���BK�>E�lCB>?E��TEH�WMBHE��]xXu0�BJK^LK��VK?>E�@lE��

JPCB�E����EK�G�H��BK�HE@?BVD��@KEAwKJC^LKME�J�EME@?E�E��

�KME��KkK�BI�HCI�F��>�G@>EME��KMBE��)�R�?E�U�@VB?�^?��KEASE�

HBJUJ�BGJK�B?D�@PLK@?�P^LB��A�C��@�@BC0�V?EAU�B�zE@@BI0�B

{�T�H�T�EHECZ�CB�P@TKk�E�@E@PLK@?�E��?D0��E�@���G�UJ��K@EJ)

XE?�PH�BVK@?�E�JEZK?�T�B�?B�@�W>E�EJBVK@>BJB0�TECB?BVK@�

>BJB�B�@ENB�CD�UJB��UMEH�JB0�>EMH��F��>�G���NKCEJ��UBM��K?

E?�PCPVkK�BI�B��K@?BNBE��EME�>CBJ�?�0�V?E�T�K���?B?�KME�BG

�KMBE��0�V�K��?EME�>E�lCB>?�JB0���JB��U�0�TE@?>E�lCB>?�U�)

,) oE?I�T�BE�B?K?�B�APHK?�E?H�����G�KkK�B^�>E�lCB>?E�0�JKZHP�

���EH�EK�@EEALK@?�E��K�HECZ�E�ZH�?D0�TE>��>E�lCB>?U�APHP?

P�KMPCB�E���U)�|�T�E?B�0�WCKJK�?U��E�EME��KMBE��CD�EME�P@?�

�E�@?���JEMP?�AU?D��@?�EK�U���TECB?BVK@>EK�P�KMPCB�E���BK

>E�lCB>?E�)�=EI�CK�BK��E�US�TK�@TK>?B��W>E�EJBVK@>EME�B�TE�

CB?BVK@>EME�@E?�PH�BVK@?���APHK?�@TE@EA@?�E��?D�B�?KM��NBB)

p?B�WCKJK�?U��KMBE��CD�E��B�?KM��NBB0�>�>�@VB?�^?���?E�U�HE�

>PJK�?�0�JEMP?�E?>�U?D��CD?K���?B��UK�TP?B�HCI�T�E@�KLK��E�

ME�TECB?BVK@>EME�CBHK�@?�����E?CBVBK�E?�AK@TK�@TK>?B��E��AE�D�

AU�G��}�KG��B@BJE@?D~�T�E?B��}?K��B?E�B�CD�E��NKCE@?�E@?B~)

3) F�>�TBkP?���G��AE?VB>B�=�>?�0�B@TECDGE���BK�@E��KJK��EME�K��

�ETK�@>EME�ETU?����P�KMPCB�E���BB�W?�E�@KT���?B@?@>BS�>E�l�

CB>?E���EGJJEZ�E0�>�>���@?����S�@�P@?E�VB�E��HKJE>��?BK��8XK�

�K���I���C��HBI�B�xKCDMBI:0�?�>�B���@C�AUS�ME@PH��@?��S�AU�kK�

�ME@C��BB0�>E?E�UK�BJK^?��K>E?E�UK�EALBK�@�F��>�GEJ�VK�?U)

vu=��T�KHC�M�K?�>EJTCK>@�E�B�@?�PJK�?�CD�U��TEHSEH�Q�B@�

TECDGE���BK�?�>BS�JKS��BGJE��>�>�@E�JK@?�UK�TEC�EJEVBI0��G��

BJEG��B@BJE@?D0����K�@?�E�W?�BVK@>BS�EALB��B�>PCD?P�0��KMBE�

��CD��I�B�?KM��NBI�B�J�EMEI�P@��I�@B@?KJ��PT���CK�BI0�B�EMH�

�@BJJK?�BV��I�8?)K)�@E@?EIL�I�BG�ME@PH��@?���B�@PAME@PH��@?�K��

�US�EA��GE���B�0�@E?�PH�BV�^LBS�TE�ET�KHKCK��UJ�lP�>NBIJ:)

R�?E�U�E?JKV�^?0�V?E���SEHK�T�E�KHK��US����KMBE�K�>E�@PCD?��

Page 25: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

NB�0��@?�KV�CB@D�B�?K0�>?E�E?J�SB��C@I�E?�}�KTEHSEHILBS�K��E�

TK�@>BS�JEHKCK�~0��E�ME��GHE�V�LK�T�EI�CIC@I�ZB�E��B�?K�K@�B

E?�E@B?KCD�E��KTCESEK�T�KH@?��CK�BK�EA�W?BS�JEHKCIS)

9) ]@EAK��E���Z�E����?B�ET?BJ�CD�U��A�C��@�JKZHP��KkK�BKJ�T�E�

ACKJ��Z�EME�F��>�G��B�AECKK�kB�E>BJ��KMBE��CD�UJ�TE�IH>EJ

@�PVK?EJ�B�?K�K@E��zE@@BB0�>E?E��I�T�EI�CIK?�EAK@TE>EK��E@?D��

@�IGB�@�APHPLBJ�XK�K��EME�F��>�G�)�[�APHPLKJ�zE@@BI�JEZK?��U�

BM��?D�E?�P@?��E�CK�BI�TE�IH>������Z�EJ�F��>�GK)�=�EN�K?��

�BK�B�E?>�U?E@?D�H���EME��KMBE��0����IHP�@�P>�KTCK�BKJ�HKJE>�

��?BB�B�M��ZH��@>EME�EALK@?��0�JEMP?�E>�G�?D�TEGB?B��EK��CBI�

�BK����H�BZK�BK�XK�K��EME�F��>�G����W?EJ�ZK���T���CK�BB)�X?���

?KMBI�?�>EME��EH��JEZK?��>C^V�?D�W>E�EJBVK@>P^�B�lB���@E�P^

TEHHK�Z>P� M��zE@@BB�B�XK�K��EME�F��>�G��@E�@?E�E�U�u��E@E^�

G��B�JKZHP���EH�US�lB���@E�US��MK�?@?�0�V?EAU�@�KHB�T�EVKME

@EGH�?D�B�l��@?�P>?P��P^�E@D0�@EKHB�I^LP^�XK�K��U��F��>�G

B�[KCB>B��kKC>E�U��TP?D�Q�[E@?E>�{�T�H)

q�PMBJ���Z�UJ�B�@?�PJK�?EJ�JEZK?�@?�?D��>?B�BG�NBI��K��E�

JE�@>EME�@E?�PH�BVK@?��)

4) vu=��E?JKV�K?0�V?E�W?E?��@KEAwKJC^LB��J�EME@?E�E��B��T�E�

NK@@�B�HECZK��AU?D�BHK�?BlBNB�E����>�>�=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B

HCI�F��>�G�0�B�W?E?�?K�JB��PZK��EkKC���CK>@B>E��TECB?BVK@>BS

CBHK�E��>��>�G@>EME��KMBE��)�[�>�>P^�CBAE�ZK@?>P^�@?�P>?P�P

W?E�TE>���K��ETCE?BCE@D0�B�=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B�HCI�F��>�G��Q�W?E

�K�T�KHC�M�KJ�I�JEHKCD0���@>E�KK��@KEAwKJC^L�I�J�EME@?E�E��

�II��KMBE��CD��I�B�BNB�?B��)�[�W?E��@�IGB���?E�U�lE�JPCB�P�

^?�@CKHP^LBK�T�B�NBTU�

� E?HKCB�kBK@I�EA��GE���BI�8RAS�GBI0��Z��I�]@K?BI�B�|��

ME��U��F���A�S:��K�BJK^?�E@�E���B��HCI�?�KAE���B��E�T�B�

G���BB�BS�TEC�E���KG��B@BJE@?Bc

� ?�>�I�TECB?BVK@>�I�>E�@?�P>NBI0� >�>�=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B0

JEZK?�T�KHE@?��B?D�BJ���BCPVkBK�k��@U�HCI�P@TKS�)

q�CKK�E�B�AECKK�TEH�EA�E���@@J�?�B��^?�T���EJK��E@?D�T�K�

?K�GB��}E?HKCB�kBS@I�KHB�BN~����TEC�P^��KG��B@BJE@?D0�T�BG���

Page 26: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

��I0�V?E��E>�PM�T���E�US��ET�E@E��TEHEA�EME��EH��BHP?�Z��>BK�HK�

A�?U�JKZHP�TECB?ECEM�JB0� ��GHKCI^LBJB�NK��E@?B�CBAK��CD�E�

HKJE>��?BB)�]H�B���@@J�?�B��^?�T���E���� @�JEET�KHKCK�BK� >�>

HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�T���E0�B�TCKAB@NB?���EK�T���E����@KNK@@B^0�TE�BS

J�K�B^0�HECZ�E�AU?D�T�BG���E�8sE?C��HBI�B�F�KAK>�Q�T�BJK�U

�KH���KME���KJK�B0�MHK�AECDkB�@?�E�E>�G�CE@D��K�@>CE��E�>��KG��B�

@BJE@?B0�SE?I���@CPV�K�B�EME��KkK�BI�rE�HE��B�]??����HECZ�U�AUCB

AU�KME�T�B�I?D:)�q�PMBK�?KE�K?B>B�AECKK�>E�@K���?B��U�B�@VB?�^?0

V?E�@�EAEH��@KNK@@BB�V�K��?��HKM��H�NBK��>�VK@?���HKJE>��?BVK@�

>EME�T���CK�BI)�u@CB�TCKAB@NB?���EK�T���E�@KNK@@BB�APHK?�T�BG���

�E0�TE�U@B?@I��B@>�?EME0�V?E�@?�KJILKK@I�>�@KNK@@BB�JK�DkB�@?�E

JEZK?�TE@?EI��E�k��?�ZB�E��?D�AECDkB�@?�E�B�TEHEA��I�@B@?KJ�

APHK?�@>CE����>��K@?�ABCD�E@?B)�|�BAECKK�ZK�>E�@K���?B��UK�TE�

CB?ECEMB�P@?��E�BCB�TK�KVK�D�P@CE�B�0��KEASEHBJUS�HCI�T�BG���

�BI�T��������@KNK@@B^�

� W?E�HECZ�U�AU?D�SE�EkE�BHK�?BlBNB�E����UK���NBI�B�?K��B�

?E�BIc

� HECZ���AU?D�EAwK>?B���I�T�BVB���HCI�E?HKCK�BI0� ��T�BJK�0

HB@>�BJB��NBI���E?�EkK�BB�JK�DkB�@?��c

� HECZ���AU?D��EGJEZ�E@?D�WllK>?B��EME�PT���CK�BI0��>C^V�I

M����?BB�HCI��E�US�JK�DkB�@?�0� �� ?�>ZK�E?�K?@?�K��E@?D� G�

�EGJEZ�UK��KM�?B��UK���Kk�BK�TE@CKH@?�BI)

q�CKK���?E�U�=�>?��P>�GU��^?0�V?E�TECB?BVK@>BK�CBHK�U�>E�l�

CB>?�US��KMBE�E��F��>�G�0�>�>�B�EZBH�CE@D0�T�E�KCB��KlK�K�HPJU

��TECDGP��KG��B@BJE@?B�@�KHB�@�EKME�}W?�BVK@>B�EVBLK��EME~���@K�

CK�BI)�]H��>E� @E�K�kK��E�EVK�BH�E0� @VB?�^?���G��AE?VB>B0� V?E

JB�E�UK�HK�Z��U�B�JKZHP���EH�UK�E�M��BG�NBB��K�TEHHK�ZB��^?

BS��KG��B@BJE@?D)�=E�J�K�B^���?E�E��HE>PJK�?�0�RAS�GBI�B��Z��I

]@K?BI��K��TEC�K�E?�KV�^?�H���UJ�P@CE�BIJ0���|�ME��U��F���A�S

TEHSEHB?�AECDkK0��E�K@?D��B@>0�V?E�KME��KG��B@BJE@?D�APHK?��@KME

CBkD�k�MEJ�>�TEC�E��B�?KM��NBB�@�R�JK�BK�0����V?E��E�EK��KG��B�

@BJEK�ME@PH��@?�E�BJKCE�AU�T���E�T�K?K�HE��?D)�Y�>E��T�KNKHK�?

E?HKCK�BI�TE@�KH@?�EJ��E��U�AUC�AU�@CBk>EJ�@K�DKG�UJ�@BM��CEJ

HCI�H�PMBS�?K��B?E�B�0�T�K?K�HP^LBS����E?HKCK�BK)�p?E�JEMCE�AU

Page 27: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

T�B�K@?B�>�@�JUJ�@K�DKG�UJ�TE@CKH@?�BIJ���TE@?>EJJP�B@?BVK@>BS

@?����S�u��ETU)�=�B�BJ�I��E���BJ��BK��@K��UkK@>�G���EK0���?E�U

HKC�^?��U�EH0�V?E�>E�@K���?BGJ�JKZHP���EH�EME�@EEALK@?���BJKK?

TEH�@EAE���K@DJ��@K�DKG�P^�TEV�P)��G�W?EME0�TE�J�K�B^���G��AE?VB�

>E��HE>PJK�?�0�@CKHPK?0�V?E�HECZK��AU?D�HE@?BM�P?�>E�@K�@P@�JKZHP

@P�K�K��UJB�ME@PH��@?��JB��Z�EME�F��>�G�0�zE@@BK�0�H�PMBJB�HK��

Z���JB�B�JKZHP���EH�UJB�E�M��BG�NBIJB�E?�E@B?KCD�E��K�EGJEZ�

�E@?B�T�BG���BI�TEC�E���KG��B@BJE@?B�H���US�EA��GE���B�)

����������� ����������������� �� ��� ��������

=E�J�K�B^���?E�E��HE>PJK�?�0�RAS�GBI�@K�V�@���SEHB?@I���?I�

ZKCK�kKJ�TECEZK�BB)�[EG���?�>���?P��CD�EJP�SEGI�@?�P0�EM�EJ�UK

��G�PkK�BI0�ETP@?K�kBK�>P�E�?U0�G�A�EkK��UK�@KCD@>ESEGI�@?�K��

�UK�PMEHDI�Q�?�>E�U�TE@CKH@?�BI��E��U)�vu=��PTEJB��K?�E�H�PS

TEHSEH�S�>�P�KMPCB�E���B^�H���EME�>E�lCB>?�)�=K��U��Q�?)�)�TC��

o�B�H����0�T�KHC�M�^LKME�TEHKCB?D�RAS�GB^�TE�XPSPJP���� Z�P^

8M�PGB�@>P^:�V�@?D�B�@K�K��P^�8�AS�G@>P^:)�xKCDMB�@>�I�JEHKCD�lK�

HK��CBG�NBB�O�PGBB�8T�KHCEZK�BI�AKCDMB�@>BS�W>@TK�?E�0���V�@?�E�

@?B0�x)�FETTB?K�@�:�BJKK?��KV?E�EALKK�@�lKHK��?B��E��@B@?KJE��ME�

@PH��@?�K��EME�P@?�E�@?���xKCDMBB)�q����I�JEHKCD�T�KHTEC�M�K?

?�>P^�@B@?KJP�T���CK�BI0�>E?E��I�@JEMC��AU�M����?B�E��?D��AS�G�J

TECE�B�P�JK@?���T���B?KCD@?�K)�=�KGBHK�?�HECZK��ME�E�B?D�TE��A�

S�G@>B0���T�KJDK��JB�B@?��JEM�AU�AU?D�M�PGB�EJ)�F�EJK�?EME0�JEMC�

AU�@PLK@?�E��?D�B���K?K��B?E�B�CD��I�@B@?KJ��PT���CK�BI�HCI�E@�

�E��US�>PCD?P��US�@EEALK@?��Q��AS�G@>EME0�M�PGB�@>EME0���?�>ZK

��JI�@>EME�B��P@@>EME0���G��B@BJE@?B�E?��KEASEHBJE@?B)�p?B�>PCD�

?P��UK�@EEALK@?���BJKCB�AU�>EJTK?K�NB^���EAC�@?B�EA��GE���BI0

>PCD?P�U�B�T�KH@?��B?KCD@?���B�?K�K@E��@EEALK@?��)�]�B�E@PLK@?��

CICB�AU�@�EB�>EJTK?K�NBB�TE��@K�� ?K��B?E�BB�RAS�GBB)�RAS�GBI

?�>ZK�JEMC��AU�BJK?D�@�EK�T�KH@?��B?KCD@?�E���^Z�E�>��>�G@>EJ

@EEALK@?�K)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�TE�J�K�B^���?E�E��HE>PJK�?�0�RAS�GBI�TECPVB�

C��AU��U@E>P^�@?KTK�D���?E�EJBB)�]���BJKC��AU�TEC�P^�@B@?KJP

PT���CK�BI�B�>E�@?B?PNB^)�tKZHP���EH�EK�T�KH@?��B?KCD@?�E���

@�JEJ��U@E>EJ�P�E��K�E@PLK@?�CICE@D�AU�VK�KG�O�PGB^0��E�@PLK�

Page 28: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

@?�E��CE�AU�EM���BVK��EK�T���E�G�>C^V�?D�JKZHP���EH�UK�@EMC��

kK�BI�B�HEME�E�U�B�G��T�KHKC�JB�?K��B?E�BB�RAS�GBB)�p?E0���GPJK�

K?@I0�JEMCE�AU��>C^V�?D�B�@�IGB�@��HUM@>BJ�B�VK�>K@@>BJ�@EEALK�

@?��JB0�ACBG>BJB��AS�G�J0�V?E�E@EAE�TEHVK�>B��^?���?E�U�HE>PJK��

?�)�[�?E�ZK���KJI�AKZK�N�J�HECZ�E�AU?D�T�KHE@?��CK�E�EALKK�T���

�E���� �EG���LK�BK0�TEHHK�Z���EK�JKZHP���EH�UJ�@EEALK@?�EJ0

>E?E�EK�HECZ�E��GI?D����@KAI��K>E�@?�P>NB^�B��E@@?��E�CK�BK)��?E

ZK�>�@�K?@I��KMPCB�E���BI�BJJBM��NBE��E��TECB?B>B�8G��B@>C^VK�

�BKJ�PTEJI�P?US��ET�E@E���EG���LK�BI�AKZK�NK�:0�E�B�JEMP?����

SEHB?D@I���@lK�K�>EJTK?K�NBB�XPSPJ��B�YABCB@B)�p?E�JEMCE�AU0�TE

J�K�B^���?E�E�0�H�?D��AS�G@>EJP�@EEALK@?�P�M����?B�E����P^�G��

LB?P�E?�J�@@E�E��BJJBM��NBB�H�PMBS�W?�BVK@>BS�M�PTT)�O��ZH���

@?�E�JEZK?�AU?D�M�PGB�@>BJ�HCI�G�M���BV�US�T�@TE�?E��B��AS�G@�

>BJ�Q�HCI���P?�K��BS)��B?KCB�RAS�GBB�JEMCB�AU�?�>ZK�B@TECDGE�

��?D�B��E@@B�@>BK�T�@TE�?��>�>��CD?K���?B��U�����B��?0�BCB�H�E��

�EK�M��ZH��@?�E)

=�KHTEC�M�K?@I0�V?E�RAS�GBI�JEMC��AU�BJK?D��K>E?E�UK��EE�P�

ZK��UK�@BCU�8��NBE��CD�P^�M���HB^:�B�TECBNB^)�]H��>E����TK�K�

SEH�U��TK�BEH�AKGET�@�E@?D�HECZ���AU?D�M����?B�E�����JKZHP���

�EH�UJB�@BC�JB�TE�TEHHK�Z��B^�JB��)�=E�J�K�B^���?E�E��=�>?�0

@KMEH�Ik�B��MBA�BH��E@@B�@>BS�8X|O:�JB�E?�E�NK��B���AC^H�?K�

CK��]]|�HECZK��AU?D�TK�K@JE?�K�)�]�B��K���@E@?EI�BB�EAK@TKVB?D

AKGET�@�E@?D��EG���?B�kBS@I�AKZK�NK�)�zKkK�BK0�TE�J�K�B^�vu=�0

JEZK?�AU?D����HK�E�@�TEJELD^�JB�E?�E�VK@>BS�@BC�]xXu)

q�CKK�T�KHC�M�K?@I�TEC�E@?D^�E?JK�B?D�ACE>�HP0���EHI�?E�ME�

�U���KZBJ�B�?�JEZK��UK�T���BC����@EE?�K?@?�BB�@�M�PGB�@>BJ�G��

>E�EH�?KCD@?�EJ)�u@CB�AU�O�PGBI�BJKC��WllK>?B��P^�@�EAEH�P^

?E�ME�C^�@�zE@@BK�0�@VB?�^?���?E�U�=�>?�0�W?E�BJKCE�AU�TEGB?B��

�EK��CBI�BK����RAS�GB^)��?E�>�@�K?@I�lB���@E�E��@B@?KJU0�E?HKCD�

��I��AS�G@>�I���C^?���K�T�KHTEC�M�K?@I0��E��EGJEZ�E�T���CCKCD�EK

SEZHK�BK��E@@B�@>E��B�M�PGB�@>E����C^?U)�[EGJEZ�U���GCBVBI��

��GCBV�US��KMBE��S����� MK�Q�T�KBJPLK@?�K��E�M�PGB�@>�I���C^?�0

�����@K�K�K�Q��E@@B�@>�I)�RAS�GBI�@JEZK?�BJK?D�G��VB?KCD�P^���?E�

�EJB^���EAC�@?B�lB���@E�E��TECB?B>B0�B@>C^V�I�?��BlU�B��>NBG�

�UK�@AE�U0�>E?E�UK�APHP?���E@�E��EJ�M�PGB�@>BJB)�XB@?KJ��@ENB�

�CD�E��G�LB?U�B��U��AE?>��JB>�EW>E�EJBVK@>E��TECB?B>B�APHP?��

Page 29: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�KHK�BB�RAS�GBB)�[�?E�ZK���KJI�E@�E��UK�W>E�EJBVK@>BK�B�l���

@?�P>?P�U0�?�>BK�>�>�@?��?KMBVK@>BK�HE�EMB0�ZKCKG�EHE�EZ�UK�TP?B0

TE�?U�B��W�ETE�?U0��Kl?KT�E�EHU�B�WCK>?�E@?��NBB�APHP?���SEHB?D�

@I���@E�JK@?�EJ��KHK�BB)

=E�JEKJP0��K?��BVKME�PHB�B?KCD�EME���?EJ0�V?E�CBHK�U�?�KS�{��

>��>�G@>BS�ME@PH��@?��B�AU�kB��T�KGBHK�?�YP�NBB�qKJB�KCD��>?B��

�E��U@?PT�^?���TEHHK�Z>P�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B)�[�TE@CKH�KK���KJI

���{�T�HK�@?�CB�T�EI�CI?D@I�T�BG��>B��K>E?E�EME���GEV��E���BI��

E?�EkK�BB��E�US��KG��B@BJUS�ME@PH��@?���Z�EME�F��>�G�)�Y�>BK

?K�JB�U�>�>�}�K@E@?EI�kKK@I�ME@PH��@?�E~0�}@B�H�EJ�@C�AEME�ME@P�

H��@?��~�TEH��GPJK��^?�TEM�IGkBK��� >E��PTNBB��KZBJU0� @C�AUK

M��ZH��@>BK�EALK@?���B�T�EBG�EC�VB�E��B>E������@KS�P�E��IS�PT�

���CK�BI)�zK�CBG�NBI�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B�TEH�WMBHE��]xXu�B�T�B

�>?B��EJ�PV�@?BB�H�PMBS�K��ETK�@>BS�@?�P>?P��B�XsR�JEMC��AU

PT�EVB?D�E@�E�U��E�US��KG��B@BJUS�ME@PH��@?��B�T�B�CKVD��E�UK

B��K@?BNBB)�qCI�YP�NBB�W?��BHKI�?EZK�T�KH@?��CIK?@I��K@DJ��TK�@�

TK>?B��E�0�TE@>ECD>P�JEZK?�@TE@EA@?�E��?D��K�CBG�NBB�H���E��U�

��kB��KJUS�TC��E��P@BCK�BI�KK��ECB����KMBE�K)

�?E�ZK�>�@�K?@I�@?����{�T�H�0�?E�BS�E?�EkK�BK�>�E@PLK@?�CK�

�B^�F��>�G@>EME�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B�JEZK?�AU?D��K�@?ECD�EH�EG��V�

�UJ)�X�EH�E��@?E�E�U0��KCDGI�E?�BN�?D0�V?E��K�CBG�NBI�TEHEA�EME

TC����JEMC��AU�@?�?D�HCI�{�T�H���K>E��M����?BK��E?�TEI�CK�BI���G�

HKCB?KCD�E��CB�BB��HECD��Z�EME�F��>�G�)�[�?E�ZK���KJI0�K@?D�P>��

G��BI����?E0�V?E���K��ETK�@>BS�TECB?BVK@>BS�>�PM�S�PZK���AC^H�K?�

@I��K>E?E��I�P@?�CE@?D�E?��@K�EGJEZ�US�T�>?E��@?�ABCD�E@?B)���EMH�

T�BSEHBCE@D�@CUk�?D�E?�K��ETK�@>BS����CB?B>E��B�@EJ�K�BI�?�>E�

ME��EH���T�EK>?�W?E?��K@DJ��HE�EME@?EILB�0�@EMC�@I?@I�CB�K��ETK�@�

>BK���CEMETC�?KCDLB>B�TC�?B?D�G��@?�ABCD�E@?D����F��>�GK\�xECKK

?EME0��K?�TEC�E��P�K�K��E@?B�H�ZK���?EJ0�V?E�F��>�G��E@T�B�BJ�K?�

@I�K��ETK�N�JB�>�>�V�@?D�u��ETU)�]ALK@?�K��EK�J�K�BK����{�T�HK

HE�ECD�E�@K�DKG�E�EG�AEVK�E�?KJB�PM�EG�JB0�>E?E�UK�B@SEHI?�E?�F���

>�G��B�>��>�GNK��Q����>E?B>B0�T�K@?PT�E@?D0�JBM��NBI)

[�?E�ZK���KJI�JKZHP�>C^VK�UJB�lBMP��JB�=�>?��Q�O�PGBK�0

R�JK�BK��B�RGK�A��HZ��EJ�Q��K�@?ECD�PZ�AKGEAC�V�UK��G�BJEE?�E�

kK�BI)�u�K����B�x�>P�?�>�B��K�HE@?BMCB�@PLK@?�K��EME�T�E�U����

P@?��E�CK�BB�HEA�E@E@KH@>BS�E?�EkK�B�)�|K>E?E�UK�TECB?ECEMB

Page 30: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�BHI?�TE?K�NB�CD�P^�PM�EGP��EG�B>�E�K�BI�M�PGB�E���JI�@>EME�>E��

lCB>?�����KMBE��S�>EJT�>?�EME�T�EZB���BI���JI�@>EME���@KCK�BI��

O�PGBB)

XE�K�kK��E�EVK�BH�E0�V?E�E?�EkK�BK�zE@@BB�>�=�>?P�@?�ABCD�

�E@?B�APHK?�BJK?D��Kk�^LKK�G��VK�BK0�V?E�T�K>��@�E�E@EG��^?�B

��?E�U�HE>PJK�?�)�=E@CKH�BK�T�BGU��^?�zE@@B^�VK?VK���?B>PCB�E�

��?D�@�EB�NKCB�����Z�EJ�F��>�GK)�]H��>E�K@?D�E@�E���BI�@EJ�K�

��?D@I0�V?E�zE@@BI�ME?E���E?�K?B?D����W?E?��UGE�)�|K�E?�K�M�I���T�B��

NBTK�BHK^�EALK>��>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB0�zE@@BI0�TE��BHBJEJP0�T�KH�

TEVB?�K?0�V?EAU�B�BNB�?B���B@SEHBC��E?��KK0����K�E?���Kk�BS�BM�E�

>E�)�F�>�P>�GU��K?��U@E>ETE@?��CK��U��T�KH@?��B?KCD�t�q�zm�X?)

�K��I�@>B���}[�Kk�KTECB?BVK@>�I�CB�BI���{�>��>�GDK���T���CK��

���?E0�V?EAU�@ES���B?D�@CEZB�kB�@I����KMBE�K�A�C��@�@BC�B��K�HE�

TP@?B?D�TEI�CK�BI��EK��US�@?�P>?P���K�KMBE��CD�US� ME@PH��@?�

�ACBGB���kK��^Z�E��M���BNU)�=�BVB�U�HCI�?�>E��EAK@TE>EK��E@�

?B�P���@�BJK^?@I~)�q�CKK�W?E?�ZK���?E��E?JKV�K?0�V?E�tE@>���ME?E��

T�B�K?@?�E��?D�C^AUK�B�BNB�?B�U0��K���T���CK��UK����TK�K@JE?�

�EK��E�@?��?KMBVK@>EME�@?�?P@�>�E�B�@EGH��BK���GHKCB?KCD�US�CB�

�B�)9 �]H�E��KJK��E�tE@>����UH�BM�K?�@�EB�B�?KM��NBE��UK�B�B�

NB�?B�U�Q��@?�KVB�}F��>�G@>E��VK?�K�>B~�8zE@@BI0�R�JK�BI0�O�P�

GBI0�RGK�A��HZ��:�����J>�S�?)�)�}FB@CE�EH@>EME�T�ENK@@�~)�p?��BHKI

�TK��UK�AUC��EG�PVK���KLK�CK?EJ�.556�M)�����@?�KVK�T�KGBHK�?E�

?�KS�G�>��>�G@>BS�ME@PH��@?��B�zm�8}F��>�G@>�I�VK?�K�>�~:)�X�KHB

T�BE�B?K?�US�T�B�NBTE��W?E��B�BNB�?B�U��P��ZK�BK�@B@?KJU��K�

MBE��CD�E��AKGET�@�E@?B0�@P�K�K�B?K?��B�?K��B?E�B�CD�E��NKCE@?�

�E@?B�H�PM�H�PM�c�T�BG���BK��KHETP@?BJE@?B����IGU���BI�>�>BS�

CBAE�T�BE�B?K?E���E���Kk�K��TECB?B>K�B�W>E�EJBVK@>EJ���G�B?BBc

�KT�BKJCKJE@?D�HK�@?�B�0��KHPLBS�>�BGJK�K�B^�@CEZB�kBS@I�B��

?K�K@E��B�A�C��@��@BC����F��>�GK0���?EJ�VB@CK�G��@VK?�P�KCBVK�BI

�CBI�BI�BG��K0�E@EAK��E��EK��E�TECB?BVK@>EME�T�B@P?@?�BI�|RY])

=EGZK�W?��B�BNB�?B���AUC��TEHHK�Z����B�[)�=P?B�UJ)�nVB?U��I

�@K��UkK@>�G���EK0�?�PH�E�EZBH�?D0�V?E����H���EJ�W?�TK�tE@>��

APHK?�T�B�K?@?�E��?D�TETU?>B�T�K?�E�B?D���ZBG�D�T�B�NBTU�=�>?�

@?�ABCD�E@?B0�>E?E�UK�T�KHP@J�?�B��^?0���V�@?�E@?B0�@�K�?U���BK

�E@@B�@>EME��EK��EME�T�B@P?@?�BI����KMBE�K��Z�EME�F��>�G�)�oE?I

H�CD�K�kB��SEH�@EAU?B��T�KHPM�H�?D�?�PH�E)

Page 31: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

|KEASEHBJE�@>�G�?D�B�E�T�BVB��S��KM�?B��E���K�>NBB����H���

�U��HE>PJK�?���TECB?BVK@>BS�>�PM�S�RAS�GBB)

� =�KZHK��@KME0�]xXu��K�T�B��HCKZB?�>�VB@CP�?KS�JKZHP���EH�

�US�E�M��BG�NB�0�>E?E�UK�TECDGP^?@I���RAS�GBB�@BJT�?BK�0��

TETU?>B�]xXu�TE�U@B?D�P�E�K�D�@�EKME�T�B@P?@?�BI�GHK@D��U�

GU��^?0�>�>�T���BCE0��KM�?B��P^��K�>NB^)

� =�KHCEZK�BI0�@lE�JPCB�E����UK���=�>?K0��K��K@P?��BVKME�T�B��

NBTB�CD�E��E�EME�HCI�RAS�GBB)�[SEZHK�BK���O�PGB^��B���>EK�

JK�K��K�@?��E�B?@I�AECKK�T�B�CK>�?KCD�UJ�E?�?EME0�V?E�W?E�AP�

HK?�@B�S�E�BGB�E���E�@��SEZHK�BKJ��Z�E��]@K?BB�?PH��ZK0��

F���A�S��Q���RGK�A��HZ��)�=E�@P?B�HKC�0�T�KHCEZK�BI���NKCEJ

�TEC�K�P>C�HU��^?@I���PZK�@PLK@?�E���kBK���@E�K?@>P^�WTESP

8TE@CK�@JK�?B��)�X?�CB��:�@SKJU�E?�EkK�B��JKZHP�O�PGB�@>E�

XXz�B�RAS�G@>E��RXXz0�>EMH��SE?D�B��KElBNB�CD�E0��KMC�@�E0

�E�@PLK@?�E��CB��K>BK�HEME�E�K��E@?B�E���NBE��CD�EJ�@E@?��

�K�E�M��E��PT���CK�BI)

� [EGJEZ�E0�K@CB�AU��KVD�kC��E�@EGH��BB��K>EKME�lKHK��?B��E�

>E�lKHK��?B��EME� EA��GE���BI� 8��T�BJK�0��Z�E>��>�G@>B�

XE^G:0�>PH����>�VK@?�K�����US�@PAwK>?E���SEHBCB�AU�kK@?D��K�

MBE��CD�US�KHB�BN�Q�RAS�GBI0�RGK�A��HZ��0�R�JK�BI0�O�PGBI0

|�ME��U��F���A�S�B��Z��I�]@K?BI�Q�W?E�JEMCE�AU�@?�?D�?KJE�

HCI�@K�DKG�EME�EA@PZHK�BI)�Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�lE�JPC��3�3�,�JEMC�

AU�?���@lE�JB�E��?D@I���lE�JPCP�6�3�,)�]H��>E�@>C�HU��K?@I

�TKV�?CK�BK0�V?E���?E�U�BHKB�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B�TE>���K�ME?E�

�U�>�E?>�GP�E?�@?��US�@SKJ)

� z��K�@?�E�@?E�E�0�I�CI^LKK@I�HCI�RAS�GBB�T�BE�B?K?�UJ�T�B��

NBTEJ0��B>�>��K��TB@U��K?@I���T�KHC�M�KJP^�JEHKCD)

� �|K�T�KHC�M�^?@I��E�UK�TE�@P?B�lE�JU���Kk�KME�T�KH@?��B?KCD�

@?��0�>E?E�UK�JEMCB�AU�@K�DKG�E�G�B�?K�K@E��?D�@PLK@?�P^LBK

HK�l�>?E�ME@PH��@?��)

� �@?E�B>E�>PCD?P��EK��EH@?�E��AS�GE��@��K>E?E�UJB����EH�JB

XK�K��EME�F��>�G�0�>�>�B��EEALK��ET�E@U0�@�IG���UK�@�ET�KHK�

CK��UJB�>��>�G@>BJB�NK��E@?IJB0�E>�G�CB@D����TK�BlK�BB���B�

Page 32: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

J��BI���?E�E�0�@>E�NK�?�B�E���kBS@I�B@>C^VB?KCD�E����P�B�

�K�@�CD�E�K��ETK�@>BS�NK��E@?IS0�V?E�HKC�K?�W?P�BHK^�JK�KK

T�B�CK>�?KCD�E��HCI�RAS�GBB)

u@CB�@PJJB�E��?D��@K0�?E�JEZ�E�@�BG�IH�E��HECK��P�K�K��E@?B

@>�G�?D0�V?E����U�Kk�KJ��BHK�H����I�B�BNB�?B���B�A�GE�UK�T�B�NB�

TU�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B��K�E?�KV�^?�B�?K�K@�J�RAS�GBB)�|BV?E��K

@�BHK?KCD@?�PK?�E�?EJ0�V?E�H����I�JEHKCD�PVB?U��K?�ZBG�K��UK�B��

?K�K@U�RAS�GBB���AECDkK��@?KTK�B0�VKJ�H�PMBK�@SKJU�P�KMPCB�E���

�BI�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?�)

Y�PH�E���@@VB?U��?D0�V?E�RAS�GBI�T�EI�B?�@?ECD��U@E>P^�@?K�

TK�D��CD?�PBGJ��B�E?>�ZK?@I�E?�BHKB�@�EK��@EA@?�K��E��ME@PH��@?�K��

�E@?B���HB�?EME0�V?EAU�TEJEVD�O�PGBB�B�H�PJ�H�PMBJ�ME@PH��@?��J

{�>��>�GDI���ME@PH��@?�K��EJ�@?�EB?KCD@?�K)

[�?E�ZK���KJI�=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B�HCI�F��>�G��@EHK�ZB?��K>E?E�

�UK�HE�ECD�E�B�?K�K@�UK�T�KHCEZK�BI)�[EGJEZ�E0�NK��E@?D�HE>P�

JK�?��B���?EJ0�V?E�E��JEZK?�@?�?D�E?T����E��?EV>E��HCI��E�US�HB@�

>P@@B��B�B@@CKHE���B��E��EGJEZ�US�TEHSEH�S�>�T�EACKJK�EALK>���

>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB)

.�z)�RCBK�0�}F��>�G@>B��qEJ~���GMCIH�BG�RGK�A��HZ���0���@A)�}p?�BVK@>BK�B

�KMBE��CD�UK�>E�lCB>?U���u���GBB~0�>�)�.0�.5570�@?�)�.6,),�])�q�JK�BI0�|��EH��I�HBTCEJ�?BI�>�>�lK�EJK��>��>�G@>E��>PCD?P�U��B@?E>B

B�@JU@C0���@A)�}zECD��KElBNB�CD�E��HBTCEJ�?BB���JB�E?�E�VK@>EJ�>E�lCB>?K~0

������0�.5550�@?�)�.39)3�R)��@>��HK�I�0�OE@PH��@?�K��EK�@?�EB?KCD@?�E�B�TEB@>�TECB?BVK@>E��BHK��

?BV�E@?B����E�US�@?����S�{�>��>�GDI0�}vK�?��CD��I�RGBI�B�F��>�G~0�,�---0��,8;:0

@?�)�.73�.79)9�X?)��K��I�@>B�0�F��>�G@>B���K>?E���E@@B�@>E��HBTCEJ�?BB0�}vK�?��CD��I

RGBI�B�F��>�G~0��48..:0�@?�)�.-6�.-7)

Page 33: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

T.����MU���� �-8�F�>���J�T�KH@?��CIK?@I0�>�>BJB�HECZ�U�AU?D@�IGB�@�XK�K��UJ�F��>�GEJ\��?E�HECZ�U�T�KHCEZB?D�E�M��BG�NBB

BCB�E?HKCD�UK�ME@PH��@?��\��?E�APHK?�T�BKJCKJE���W?EJ�@JU@CK\

��������%�"�8�YP?��@��PTB��K?@I���T�EACKJP�M���BNU����=@EP)�p?�M���BN�0�TE�@P?B0�I�CIK?@I�B�lBGBVK@>BJ0�B�T@BSECEMBVK@>BJ�A��DK�

�EJ0�T�KTI?@?�P^LBJ��E�J�CD�UJ�@�IGIJ�@�XK�K��UJ�F��>�GEJ)�qCI

�AS�GE�0�>�>�HCI�J�CEME�W?�E@�0�W?B�@�IGB�JEMCB�AU?D��K>E?E�E��M��

���?BK��?EME0�V?E0��K@JE?�I������kP�J�CEVB@CK��E@?D0�JU��K�EH�B)

t�K� @K�V�@� ?�PH�E�E?�K?B?D0� >�>BJB�BJK��E�JEMCB�AU�AU?D� W?B

�G�BJEE?�EkK�BI0�>�>�B�@?B?PNBE��CBGB�E��?D�W?B�@�IGB0��E�EA�W?EJ

��HE�HPJ�?D)�OC���EK0�V?EAU�AUCE�TE�BJ��BK��KEASEHBJE@?B�W?BS

�G�BJEE?�EkK�B�0�����W?EJ�HE>PJK�?K0�>�@EZ�CK�B^0�W?EME��K?��@VB�

?�K?@I0�V?E��AS�GE���TEC�K�P@?��B��K?�EALK�BK�?ECD>E�@�^Z�E>���

>�G@>BJB����EH�JB0��@>ECDGD�ME�E�B?@I�E�?EJ0�V?E��AS�GU�AECKK�ACBG>B

@K�K�E>��>�GN�J0��E�BG�W?EME��BVKME��K��U?K>�K?)

M���� �/%�"�-8�F�>��U�@VB?�K?K0�W?E�T�IJEK�TK�KCEZK�BK�@?��H���?E��u��E@E^G��BCB�ZK�V?E�?E��E�EK\

��������%�"�8�|K�T�IJEK)�|E�VP�@?�PK?@I0�V?E�=�>?�@EGH���C@I��A�^@@KCD@>BS�>�AB�K?�S0�EVK�D�H�CK>E�E?�F��>�G�)�|K@JE?�I����?E0

V?E�W?B�C^HB�GHK@D�AU��CB0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�E�B��K�EVK�D�SE�EkE�TE�B�

J�^?0�V?E�JU�KLK���SEHBJ@I����H�PMEJ�B@?E�BVK@>EJ�W?�TK)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�]M�EJ�EK�@T�@BAE0�I�@CPk�C���@�@�AECDkBJ

PHE�ECD@?�BKJ)�[E?��U�@>�G�CB0�V?E�K@CB�AU��KVD�kC��E�>�>BS�?E��G��

BJEE?�EkK�BIS�JKZHP�kK@?D^�����UJB�@PAwK>?�JB0�?E�?�>E��TEH�

SEH�JEZ�E�AUCE�AU�EA@PZH�?D)

��������%�"�8�|E�W?E�?ECD>E�JEK�CBV�EK�J�K�BK)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�q�0�J�K�B�?K�K@�E���kK�J�K�BK)�F�>��U

@VB?�K?K0�CBV�E�HCI���@0�HCI�?E��@�KHU0�>E?E�P^��U�T�KH@?��CIK?K0��

VKJ�T�KBJPLK@?�E�EALK�BI�kK@?B�����US� @PAwK>?E�\��KJ� ?�>E�

TEHSEH�CPVkK�H�PMEME�Q�P@?��E�CK�BI�H�P@?E�E��BS�E?�EkK�B��JKZ�

HP�O�PGBK��B�RAS�GBK�\

Page 34: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

��������%�"�8�FEMH��@?E�E�U�>E�lCB>?��I�CI^?@I���@?ECD>E��K�����UJB0�>�>�O�PGBI�B�RAS�GBI0�C^A�I��EGJEZ�E@?D�>�>�?E�@A�C���

@B�E��?D�W?E��K���K�@?�E�HCI�RAS�GBB��UMCIHB?�HE�ECD�E�T�B�CK>��

?KCD�E)�p?E?�TEHSEH�JEZK?��K>E?E�UJ�EA��GEJ�@A�C��@B�E��?D�ELP�

LK�BK�?EME0�V?E�JU�E@?�CB@D�EHB�����EHB��@�O�PGBK�)

T.����MU���� �-8�n�JK�I��K��ET�E@)�y�T�E@?E�SEVP�P?EV�B?D��K>E�?E�UK�T�KH@?��CK�BI0�>E?E�UK�E?��GBCB@D�����kKJ��U@?PTCK�BB�B

>E?E�UK�JEZ�E�P@CUk�?D�B���O�PGBB)�[�O�PGBB�?EZK�J�EMBK�ME�E�I?0

V?E�JU���SEHBJ@I����>�>EJ�?E�H�PMEJ�P�E��K���G�B?BI0�V?E�JU��K

?�>BK0�>�>���u��ETK0�V?E�?K��E�JU�B�G�>E�U0�TE�>E?E�UJ�ZB�P?���

{�T�HK0�HCI���@�AK@TECKG�U�B��KT�BKJCKJU)�y��K�SEVP�TECKJBGB�E�

��?D���H���U��JEJK�?0��E�HECZK����TEJ�B?D0�V?E��K�M�PGB�U�B��K

�AS�GU�T�BHPJ�CB0�@>�ZKJ0�P�B�K�@B?K?U0��K�JU�T�BHPJ�CB�?�>BK

PV�KZHK�BI0�>�>�T��C�JK�?)�tEZK?�AU?D0�JU�JEMCB�AU�BJK?D�H�PMBK

lE�JU�T���CK�BI0��E�@K�V�@�JU�BJKKJ�BJK��E�W?B0�B��@K�W?B�lE�JU�Q

K��ETK�@>BK)�]�B0�?�>�BCB�B��VK0���AE?�^?)�tEZK?�AU?D0�JU�Q�B�M�P�

GB�U0�B��AS�GU�Q�SE?BJ�TE>�G�?D�@KAI���>�>EJ�?E�E�BMB��CD�EJ��BHK0

SE?BJ�TE>�G�?D0�V?E�GHK@D��K�HK�@?�PK?�?E0�V?E���AE?�K?�P�H�PMBS�

]HB��JE��H�PM0���T�BJK�0�ME�E�BC0�V?E�T@BSE���CBG0�T@BSECEMBI���M�

B��K>E?E�UK�T@BSECEMBVK@>BK�T�ENKHP�U����M�PGB���K�HK�@?�P^?)����

� �������|E�W?E�E��kP?BC)�tEZK?�AU?D0��@K�?�>B�B���J0�B���J�@?EB?

T�EVK@?D�T�KHCEZK�BI�T�>?��@�H�PME��?EV>B�G�K�BI0�JEZK?�AU?D0����KJ

�@K�?�>B�K@?D�V?E�?E�TECKG�EK)�y�ME�E�^��K�?ECD>E�E�H���EJ�JEJK�?K)

��������%�"�8�Q�FE�KV�E0�JU�H���E�BJKKJ�B�P�B�K�@B?K?U0�B�T���C�JK�?U0�B�J�EMEK�H�PMEK0��E�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E���k��TECB?BVK@>�I

>PCD?P���KLK�?�>�H�CK>��E?0�HETP@?BJ0�k�K�N��@>E��BCB�AKCDMB�@>E�

8SE?I�?�J�?EZK0�>E�KV�E0�K@?D�@�EB�T�EACKJU:)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�JU

KLK��K�ME?E�U�E?>�G�?D@I�E?�?EME0�V?E�JU0�T�KZHK��@KME�Q��AS�GU�BCB

M�PGB�U�

T.����MU���� �-8�|K?0�I��K�W?E�BJKC����BHP)

��������%�"�8�n���@�@K�V�@�?E?�W?�T0�>EMH��JU�KLK��K��U�E@CB�BG

?KS�HK?@>BS�k?��BkK>��>NK�?B�E���BI�@�EKME�>�>EME�?E���NBE��CD�

Page 35: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�EME�ME@PH��@?��0���NBE��CD�US�B�@?B?P?E�0�M��ZH��@?��)�YB��?B�

ME�E�BC�0�V?E���IH�CB�O�PGBI�@KMEH�I�ME?E���E?>�G�?D@I�E?�?EME0�V?E�@

?�>BJ�?�PHEJ�AUCE�K^�G��EK���E���AE�DAK)�YE�ZK�@�JEK�JEZ�E�@>��

G�?D�B�EA��AS�G�S)�tU�KLK0�JEZK?�AU?D0��K�B@TBCB�KLK�W?P�V�kP�HE

H��)�tEZK?�AU?D0���W?E��V�kK��BVKME�SE�EkKME�B��K?0��E�JU�HECZ�U

VK�KG�W?E�T�E�?B0�V?EAU�AECKK�E�M��BV�E�TK�K�?B����>�>P^�?E�H�P�

MP^�@?PTK�D)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�|�?KCC��|P�BK���0��U���@�EKJ�HE>C�HK�@>�G�CB0V?E���W?EJ�T�EK>?K��K?��BVKME��E�EME)))

��������%�"�8�p?E0�JEZK?�AU?D0�T�KP�KCBVK�BK)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�y�SE?KC�P?EV�B?D���BVKME��E�EME�TE�@����K�B^�@�VKJ\

��������%�"�8�=E�@����K�B^�@�?KJ0�V?E�T�KHC�M�K?�x�P�E�FETTB�?K�@)�FEMH��I�TB@�C��@�E��HE>C�H0�I�BJKC�����BHP�BJK��E�KME0�TE?EJP

V?E�KME�BHKB�T�E@J�?�B��^?@I���>�ZHE��@?�EV>K)�]��Q�AKCDMBKN�B

TE@?EI��E�EVK�D���@?E�VB�E��KHK?�BJK��E�@�E^�CB�B^)�y�W?E�BJKC�

���BHP)�FE�KV�E0�K@?D�V?E�?E��E�EK)�X�J��W?��BHKI�Q�HE@?�?EV�E��E��I

HCI�K��ETK�NK�0��E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�I��K�P�BHKC���E�US�TEHSEHE�0�>E�

?E�US�I�?�>�H���E�PZK�ZHP)

��,� ��.�S,���8�|E�UK�T�KHCEZK�BI�>�@�^?@I�E?�EkK�BI�>�XK�

�K��EJP�B��Z�EJP�F��>�GP0�>�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BJ�E?�EkK�BIJ)

��������%�"�8�q�0�HCI�JK�I�W?E�AUCE�@�JUJ�MC���UJ)

��,� ��.�S,���8�y��K�E@JKC^@D�>EJJK�?B�E��?D��U@?PTCK�BI)y�SE?KC�AU�@>�G�?D��K@>ECD>E�@CE��E�@�JEJ�=�>?K�@?�ABCD�E@?B)

t�K�AU�SE?KCE@D�TE?EJ�P@CUk�?D�E?���kBS�>ECCKM�BS�E?�EkK�

�BK�>���G�UJ�JEHKCIJ�B�?KM��NBB)���?KM��NBI0����K��EK0��K�JEZK?

AU?D�@�JENKCD^)�]���HECZ���@?��B?D�@KAK�NKCD^��KV?E�B�EK0�B�HEC�

Z���AU?D�>�>�I�?E�H�BZPL�I�@BC�0�>E?E��I�T�B�KHK?���HK�@?�BK�JK�

S��BGJ�B�?KM��NBB)�R�AKG�W?EME��@K�W?B�BHKB�B�>E�@?�P>NBB�E@?��P?�

@I����APJ�MK)�=ECB?B>B�JEMP?�BG��KZCB�E@?B�@>�G�?D0�V?E�E�B�G�B�?K�

�K@E���U0��E�H�CDkK�HKCE��K�TE�HK?)

Page 36: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

t�K�CBV�E�BHKI� Z�E>��>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB�@�J��TE�@KAK�B�?K�

�K@��0��E�J�K�EVK�D�?�PH�E�T�KH@?��B?D�F��>�G�BCB��Z�U��F��>�G

ZBG�K@TE@EA�E��TECB?BVK@>E�� KHB�BNK�)���?KM��NBI�B�?K�K@PK?

JK�I�@�H�PME��?EV>B�G�K�BI�Q�@�?EV>B�G�K�BI�?���GB?�E��l�GU0�ET�K�

HKCK��EME�W?�T�����TP?B�>�K��E�?C��?BVK@>E��B�?KM��NBB)�u@CB�JU

TE@JE?�BJ����H�PMBK��KMBE�U0�@>�ZKJ0����vK�?��CD�P^�u��ETP�BCB

���x�C>��U0�?E�?�J�TEHEA�UK�T�>?U�@?�ABCD�E@?B�AUCB�ET�KHKCK��

�UJ�W?�TEJ����TP?B�>�B�?KM��NBB�W?BS�@?������EALKK��ETK�@>BK�B

�?C��?BVK@>BK�B�@?B?P?U)�|�HE�E?JK?B?D0�V?E��B�EHB��BS�W?BS�T�>�

?E��@?�ABCD�E@?B��K�T�KHP@J�?�B��C�@EGH��BI�@PTK���NBE��CD�US

B�@?B?P?E��Q��B����x�C>���S0��B���vK�?��CD�E��u��ETK)�[�W?EJ�T�>�

?K�K@?D�ET�KHKCK��UK�B�?K�K@�UK�BHKB0��E��K�CBGJ0�TE�JEKJP0��K

@�J�I�@BCD��I�KME�@?E�E��)

y�SE?KC�AU�E?JK?B?D��K>E?E�UK�JEJK�?U)�[E�TK��US0�K@CB�A��?D

��>�VK@?�K�T�BJK���K��ETK�@>P^�B�?KM��NB^0�?E�?�J�?EZK�TI?DHK@I?

CK?�?EJP���G�H�AUCE�@K�DKG�EK�T�E?B�E@?EI�BK)�xUC�����HK���ET�K�

HKCK���I� @BC�� T�E?B�0� ��T�BJK�0� B@?E�BVK@>EME�T�E?B�E@?EI�BI

m���NBB�B�OK�J��BB)�|E�V?EAU�W?E?�l���>E��KJKN>B��>E�@K�@P@

@E@?EIC@I0�TE��HEABCE@D�@EGH��BK�?�>EME�B�@?B?P?�0�>�>�|RY]0�B

�JK�B>��@>EK�T�B@P?@?�BK����>E�?B�K�?K)�p?E�JEZ�E�@VB?�?D�M�����

?BK��@?�ABCD�E@?B)�t�K�?�PH�E�T�KH@?��B?D0�>�>�I�@BC��JEZK?�G��

TEC�B?D���>PPJ�AKGET�@�E@?B����F��>�GK0�V?EAU�H�?D�M����?BB�AKGE�

T�@�E@?B�?E��ZK�RAS�GBB�E?�O�PGBB�BCB�R�JK�BB�E?��

�� �%!���R�S���8�|�NBE��CD�UK�TECBNBB�

��,� ��.�S,���8�X�J�lE�J�?�}3���3���,~�?EZK�J�K�>�ZK?@I�J�CE��K�CB@?BV�UJ)�=E�JEKJP0�O�PGBI0�RAS�GBI0��Z��I�]@K?BI0�F���A�S0

R�JK�BI0�RGK�A��HZ���Q�E�B��@K�JEMP?�HEME�E�B?D@I0��E�V?EAU�����0

YP�NBI�B�zE@@BI���kCB�JKZHP�@EAE��?EV>B�@ET�B>E@�E�K�BI0�TE?�K�

APK?@I�KLK�TI?DHK@I?�CK?)�Y�>�V?E�?P?�VK�K@VP��J�EME�BM�E>E�)�=E�

JEKJP0�ME��GHE�WllK>?B��KK�APHK?�lE�JPC��}3�Q�3���,~)�|E�@�J��BHKI

�Z�EME�BGJK�K�BI0���TEHEABK�@K�K��EME0�x�C?B�@>EME�BGJK�K�BI0

J�K�>�ZK?@I�B�?K�K@�E�0�B�K@CB�K��ETK�@>BK�BCB��JK�B>��@>BK����

CEMETC�?KCDLB>B�APHP?��>C�HU��?D���W?E�HK�DMB0�?E�BHKI�JEZK?�@?�?D

ZBG�K@TE@EA�E�)

Page 37: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�HKI�@EGH��BI�EALKME��U�>��BCB�GE�U�@�EAEH�E��?E�ME�CB0�TE�

JEKJP0�HECZ���AU?D�EH�E��BG�NKCK����kKME�@EEALK@?��0�TE?EJP�V?E

EALB���U�E>0�>E?E�U��APHK?�@E@?EI?D�BG�TI?��HN�?B�JBCCBE�E��TE�

?�KAB?KCK��Q�W?E��KV?E�AECDkKK0�VKJ�TI?D0�?�B�BCB�kK@?D�JBCCB�

E�E�)����K@?BNB��APHK?0����K��EK0�ME��GHE�AECDkK0��E�?P?�T�BHK?@I

�Kk�?D�T�EACKJU0�@�EH�E��@?E�E�U0�ACE>�H0�@�H�PME��@?E�E�U�Q�AK�

ZK�NK�0�TE?EJP�V?E�@�EAEH�U��EALB���U�E>�Q�W?E�EG��V�K?�@�EAEH�

�EK�TK�KJKLK�BK�>�TB?�C�0�T�EHP>?E�0�C^HK��B�BHK�)

qCI�W?EME�JEZ�E�@EGH�?D�ET�KHKCK��P^�B�@?B?PNBE��CD�P^�@�K�

HP)��HKI�JKZT��C�JK�?@>E���@@�JACKB�J�K�>�ZK?@I�B�?K�K@�E�0��E

?�PH�E�T�KH@?��B?D�E�M��BG�NB^�T�IJUS��UAE�E�)�[EGJEZ�E0�W?E

APHK?��KV?E���TEHEABK�=��C�JK�?@>E���@@�JACKB�XE�K?��u��ETU0�MHK

G�@KH�^?�PZK�HK�@?�P^LBK�BGA����UK�HKTP?�?U�Q�W?E�ME��GHE��K�

�CD�K�)�YE�ZK�>�@�K?@I�B�@E�K?��JB�B@?�E�)�p?E��@�0����K��EK0�APHK?

@TE@EA@?�E��?D�B�?KM��NBB)�]�>�>EJ�?E�@PTK���NBE��CD�EJ�G�>E�E�

H�?KCD@?�K�ME�E�B?D0����K��EK0��K�@?EB?)�xECKK�T���BCD�E�APHK?�@?��

�B?D� @�EK��NKCD^�M��JE�BG�NB^�G�>E�EH�?KCD@?�0� �� E@EAK��E@?B0

@EGH��BK�AECKK�BCB�JK�KK�KHB�EME���CEME�EME��KZBJ�0�?�JEZK��EME

�KZBJ�0�EALBS�@?��H��?E��HCI�T�EHP>?E�0�EALBS�T���BC�HCI�A��>E�

BCB�HCI�@?��SE�US�>�JT��B�)�[@K�W?E�APHK?�@TE@EA@?�E��?D��E@?P

B��K@?BNB�0��E���HE�TE�BJ�?D0�V?E�W?E�@�IG��E�@�EVK�D�J�EMBJB�T�E�

ACKJ�JB)�u��ETK�@>B��XE^G�Q��K�KHB�@?�K���I�JEHKCD0��K�KHB�@?�K��

��I�lE�J��B�?KM��NBB)�[�T�>?K�T�KHC�M�^?@I���G�EME��EH��JEHKCB)

|��JE���GMCIH0�AECKK��@KME�>��KMBE�P�TEHSEHB?�JEHKCD�|�l?��Q�AKG

@EGH��BI���H��NBE��CD�US�B�@?B?P?E�0�T�KHP@J�?�B��^LBS�EALK�

ME�BM�E>�����EALKJ�T�E@?���@?�K)�[JK@?E�W?EME0�TE�JEKJP0�ME��GHE

AECKK�WllK>?B��UJ�APHK?�@EGH�?D�EALBK�T���BC��BM�U0�E@?��B��T�B

W?EJ��@��J�EZK@?�E�@PLK@?�P^LBS�BM�E>E�)�=E?EJP�V?E�J�K�>�ZK?�

@I�J�CE�K�EI?�UJ0�V?E����H���EJ�W?�TK�PH�@?@I�HE@?BVD�AECDkKME

P�E��I�B�?KM��NBB)

[�T�>?K�KLK�E?��ZK���BHKI�E�@EGH��BB�M��ZH��@>E���@@�JACKB0

ABG�K@��@@�JACKB)�[@��W?E0����K��EK0�JEZ�E�B��PZ�E�HKC�?D0��E�MC���

�EK�Q���HE�@?��B?D��K�CB@?BVK@>BK�NKCB)�u@CB���V�?D�@�>�>BS�?E�AECD�

kBS�BHK��B�BS��K�CBG�NBI��K�TECPVB?@I0�?E��EG�B>k�I�TE@CK�W?EME

l�P@?��NBI���HECME�G�?E�JEGB?�T�ENK@@0�?)K)�B�?KM��NBE��UK�B�B�

NB�?B�U�APHP?���?�C>B��?D@I����W?E?��KM�?B��U��ETU?)

Page 38: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

=EW?EJP�E?�@�JE��BHKB�B�?KM��NBB�E?>�GU��?D@I��K���HE0��E���HE

AU?D�EVK�D�@>�EJ�UJB���B�?KM��NBE��US��JABNBIS)�p?B�T�EACKJU

ME��GHE�CKMVK��Kk�?D�TEW?�T�E)�rPVkK�HK�@?�E��?D�TE@?KTK��E0�k�M

G��k�MEJ0�VKJ�@��GP�����CB��?D@I����@�JUK�?�PH�UK�T�EACKJU0�>E?E�

�UK�@K�V�@0�W?E��@KJ�BG�K@?�E0��B>?E��K�@TE@EAK����G�KkB?D0���BG�G�

W?EME�B�W?B�J�CK�D>BK��ET�E@U��K��Kk�?@I)�����EAE�E?0�K@CB�APHP?

T�KNKHK�?U�TEGB?B��EME�>E�>�K?�EME�@E?�PH�BVK@?������KkK�BB�W?BS

J�CK�D>BS�T�EACKJ0�?E���>ETB?@I�TEGB?B��U��ETU?�@E?�PH�BVK@?��0

B�TE?EJ�ME��GHE�CKMVK�APHK?��Kk�?D�B�?�PH�UK�T�EACKJU�Q���T�B�

JK�0��ET�E@U�TECB?BVK@>EME�@?�?P@��8TE�JEKJP0�W?B��ET�E@U��KEASE�

HBJE�E?CEZB?D�����KET�KHKCK��EK���KJI0�TE?EJP�V?E�@K�V�@�BS��K�

kK�BK��K�K�CD�E:)

��R��� ����0�8�rK����@>�G�C0�V?E�JEHKCB�HECZ�U�T�KHC�M�?D@I����@VK?K����ET�KHKCK��P^�NKCD)�X�JB�TE�@KAK�E�B���IH�CB�T�KH@?��CI�

^?�E@EAU��B�?K�K@0�SE?I�EA@PZH�?D�BS�B�?K�K@�E)��G�@�JEME���G���BI

W?EME�HE>PJK�?�0�}=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B~0��BH�E0�V?E�E��HCI�?EME�B�T�KH�

C�M�K?@I0�V?EAU�TETU?�?D@I�HEAB?D@I�P@?E�VB�EME�����E�K@BI����KMB�

E�K)���J�K�>�ZK?@I0�W?��NKCD�HE@?E����?EME0�V?EAU�E��K��HPJ�?D)

qK�@?�B?KCD�E0�>EMH�0���T�BJK�0���@lK�K�ABG�K@��>E�>P�B�P^�

LBK�lB�JU��Kk�^?�T�EACKJU��K�VK�KG�TEH��CK�BK�H�PM�H�PM�0������

SEHI?��EGJEZ�E@?D�@E@PLK@?�E��?D�B��G�BJEHK�@?�E��?D���KHB�E�

>E�TE��NBB0�?E�W?E�BHK?����TECDGP�EAKBJ�@?E�E��J)�YKJ�AECKK0�K@CB

JU��@TEJ�BJ�EA�W?BS�}TC^@�?�B~�Q�����K0�zE@@BB�B�YP�NBB)�tU

V�@?E�B@TECDGPKJ�TE�I?BK�}?�K?DK��@BCU~0�ME�E�BJ�E�?EJ0�>�>�W?B

?�K?DB�@BCU�PJK^?�@KI?D���GHE��JKZHP�J�CUJB�@?����JB)�u@CB�JU

���@�JEJ�HKCK��K�BJ����EGJEZ�E@?D�>��>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB�B�HK��

@?�B?KCD�E� K@?D� @K�DKG�UK�EAwKHB�I^LBK�JEJK�?U0� ?E�TEHEA��I

B�?KM��NBI�AUC��AU�EVK�D�@BCD�UJ�>EGU�KJ�T�E?B��?�>BS�J��BTP�

CINB�)�[E��@I>EJ�@CPV�K0����K��EK0�CKMVK�AUCE�AU�T�E?B�E@?EI?D�B

B@>�?D�@E^G�B>E����ACBZ��kKJ�E>�PZK�BB)

=E�I?�E0�V?E�H�ZK�K@CB�AU�AUC�����HK���T�K>��@��I�lE�JPC��B

�@K�@?E�E�U�@��K��@EMC�@BCB@D0�?E��@K�����E��K�EGJEZ�E�EH�EJEJK��

?�E�TK�K�?B����@E�K�kK��E��E�U��P�E�K�D��G�BJEHK�@?�BI)�|E�PZK

@�J���?JE@lK�����GJUkCK�B��EA�W?E��B�?KM��NBB�BJKK?�TEGB?B��

�U��@JU@C)

Page 39: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

tEZK?�AU?D0�BJKCE�AU�@JU@C�TETU?�?D@I��UHKCB?D�>�>P^�?E

E?HKCD�P^�@lK�P�Q�TP@?D�W?E�APHP?0���T�BJK�0�?���@TE�?�UK�>EJJP�

�B>�NBB�BCB�TEV?E�UK�@B@?KJU�BCB�KLK�V?E�?E0�V?E��K�>�@�K?@I��T�I�

JP^�TECB?BVK@>EME�@?�?P@�)�[E��@I>EJ�@CPV�K0�JEZ�E�AUCE�AU�TE�

TU?�?D@I��UHKCB?D�W?B��ET�E@U�BG�@lK�U�TECB?BVK@>BS�T�EACKJ�B

��K@?B�>�>P^�?E�E?HKCD�P^�KHB�P^�@B@?KJP��G�BJEHK�@?�BI�B�lP��

>NBE�B�E���BI�����@KJ��Z�EJ�F��>�GK)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E�BJKCE�AU

TEGB?B��EK��CBI�BK����SEH�TK�KME�E�E��EA�B�?KM��NBB�B0�JEZK?�AU?D0

TE?EJ�AUCE�AU�CKMVK����?B�lE�JPCP0�>E?E��I�PHE�CK?�E�BC��AU��@KS)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�y�HPJ�^0�V?E0��E�TK��US0��PZ�E0�V?EAU�E�T�>?K>�>�JEZ�E�AECDkK�G��CB���@EEALK@?��S0�HCI�>E?E�US�E��T�KHC�M�K?�

@I)�qK�@?�B?KCD�E0�>�>�@>�G�C��|�?KCC�0�JEZK?�AU?D0��K>E?E�UK��C��

@?B�Q�I��K�ME�E�^�E�O�PGBB0��E���RAS�GBB0�JEZK?�AU?D�Q�KME��K�VB?��

CB0��K����CBGB�E��CB0����E?��GICB�B�@��GP�@>�G�CB�Q��K�SE?BJ)

[E��?E�US0��@K�?�>B��K�@?EB?0����K��EK0�G�AU��?D0�V?E0�>�>�G��

lB>@B�E��CB�@�JB���?E�U�B�E?JK?BCB�HE>C�HVB>B0�W?E?�T�>?�E?>�U?

HCI�BGJK�K�B�0�HETEC�K�B��B�T�KHCEZK�B�)�YE�K@?D0�I���HK^@D0�V?E

W?E��K� >�>�I�?E� G�@?U�k�I0� E>E�V�?KCD��I�lE�J�0� �K�TEHCKZ�L�I

�B>�>BJ�BGJK�K�BIJ)�|�@>ECD>E�J�K�BG�K@?�E0��B>?E�BG�?KS0�HCI�>EME

W?E?�T�>?�T�KH��G��V�C@I0���H��BJ��K���AE?�C0��K���E@BC��B>�>BS

T�KHCEZK�B��B�?)H)�uME�T�E@?E��GICB�B�E?�K�MCB)

��������%�"�8�=EVKJP�?U�ME�E�BkD0�V?E�E?�K�MCB\

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�=E�>����K��JK�K0�P���@�T�EBGEkCE�BJK��E�?�>)

��������%�"�8�n���@�Q�H�0��E���H�PMBS�JK@?�S��B>?E��BVKME��K�E?��K�M�C)

�� �%!���R�S���8��OE@PH��@?�K���I�>EJB@@BI���AE?�K?)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�|P0�W?E�PZK�SE�EkB��T�KNKHK�?)

y�HPJ�^0�V?E�T�>?�E>�G�C@I�E?��ZK�BKJ��K@TE@EA�E@?B�W?BS�ME�

@PH��@?��P@?��E�B?D�@?�ABCD�E@?D����KMBE�K)�{��T�EkKHkB��TK�BEH

EA���PZBCE@D0�V?E����@�JEJ�HKCK�W?B��EG�B>kBK����F��>�GK�>��GBME�

Page 40: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

@PH��@?���B��KT�BG����UK�ME@PH��@?����K�JEMP?�T�B�BJ�?D�@K�DKG�

�UK��KkK�BI�TE�P�KMPCB�E���B^�>E�lCB>?�)�=EW?EJP��USEH����?��

>EME��EH��JKZHP���EH�UK�M����?BB0�JKZHP���EH�UK�E�M��BG�NBB0

�@KMH��TECKGK�)�p?E�TEJEM�K?�@EGH�?D�?�>P^�@B?P�NB^0�T�B�>E?E�E�

@?��E�B?@I��EGJEZ�UJ�T�B�I?BK��KkK�B�)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E���HE

B@TECDGE��?D)���SE?I�JEZK?�T�KHC�M�?D@I�Q�B�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�T�KHC��

M�K?@I�Q�J�EME��K�K�CD�EME0�E?�K�M�?D�BCB�ET?EJ�E?J�SB��?D@I�E?

�@KS�T�KHCEZK�B���@K�?�>B��K�@?EB?)�qCI�?EME0�V?EAU�T�B�I?D��KkK�

�BK�TE�?�>BJ���Z�UJ��ET�E@�J0��PZ���B�@?��NBI0�@TE@EA��I�T�B�

�BJ�?D��KkK�BI)�]>�G�CE@D0�V?E��E�UK�>��>�G@>BK�>��GBME@PH��@?��

�K�JEMP?�T�B�BJ�?D�?�>BS��KkK�B�0�TE?EJP�V?E�E�B�BJK��E�>��GBME�

@PH��@?��0�TE@>ECD>P��K�BJK^?���@�EKJ���@TE�IZK�BB�@EE?�K?@?�P^�

LBS�B�@?B?P?E�)��J�EVK�D�?�PH�E����V?E�?E�ETK�K?D@I0�?�PH�E�T�B�

�BJ�?D��KkK�BI0�?�PH�E�BS��K�CBGE�U��?D0�?�PH�E�>E�?�ECB�E��?D

�UTEC�K�BK�?KS��KkK�B�0�>E?E�UK�JEMP?�AU?D�T�B�I?U)�]�B�AEI?@I

T�B�BJ�?D��KkK�BI0�TE?EJP�V?E��K?�WllK>?B��US�JKS��BGJE��>E�?�

�ECI)

p?E�B��UGU��K?��KEASEHBJE@?D�TEI�CK�BI�?�>BS�JKZHP���EH�US

B�BNB�?B�0�@�>E?E�UJB0�I�HPJ�^0��@K�?�>B���HE���AE?�?D)�y�@K�V�@

ME�E�^�E�T�B�NBTB�CD�EJ�JEJK�?K)

�?E�>�@�K?@I�>�>BS�?E�>E�>�K?�US��KLK�0�?E�J�K0���T�BJK�0�T�KH�

@?��CIK?@I0�V?E�?�J�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�J�EME��K�K�CD�EME)�[E�TK��US0

T�KHC�M�K?@I�>�>�AU�>�>E��?E�E>E�V�?KCD�U�����B��?)�tEZ�E�TE�?B

TEW?�T�UJ�TP?KJ�Q��UHKCB?D�BG�W?EME�T�>?��>�>BK�?E�JEJK�?U0�>E?E�

�UK���T�B�NBTK�PZK�@PLK@?�P^?����K�CD�E@?B0�B�PG�>E�B?D�W?E�@E�

@?EI�BK)�|�T�BJK�0�V?E�>�@�K?@I�?KS�TP�>?E�0� MHK�T�BG��K?@I0�V?E

�KT�BG����UK�EA��GE���BI�BJK^?�T���E����@�EB��EE�PZK��UK�@BCU)

]�B�BS�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�BJK^?0�B�W?E�JEZ�E�PG�>E�B?D)�p?E�WCKJK�?

ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�HCI�W?BS�EA��GE���B��Q�BJK?D�@�EB��EE�PZK��UK

@BCU�PZK����G�>E��EJ�E@�E���BB0�K@CB�W?E�APHK?�T�BG���E)

uLK�>�>BK�?E�TEHEA�UK�JEJK�?U�JEZ�E�?�J��UHKCB?D)�u@?D�>��

>E��?E�T�EM�K@@���E?�EkK�BB0�JEZK?�AU?D0�H�E��EME�M��ZH��@?��)

tEZ�E��K���@T�E@?���I?D�W?E?�T�B�NBT�����@K���@KCK�BK0��E�T�K�

HP@JE?�K?D�>�>BK�?E�V�@?BV�UK�JK�U���W?E��EAC�@?B)�YE�K@?D�JEZ�E

�UHKCB?D�BG�W?EME�T�>?��>�>E��?E���NBE��CD�U��W>@?��>?0�>E?E�U�

E?��Z�K?�PZK�@CEZB�kP^@I�@B?P�NB^0�B�CKMB?BJBGB�E��?D�KK)�XHK�

Page 41: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

C�?D�?�>EME��EH��TEW?�T�P^�@SKJP0�>E?E��I�@JEZK?�TE?EJ��U�K@?B���

V?E�?E��E�EK�B0�JEZK?�AU?D0�G�@?��B?�TE@JE?�K?D�TE��E�EJP�B����>��

>BK�?E�H�PMBK��KLB)

�������!"�#�-8�t�K�W?E��KJ�EZ>E���TEJB��K?�@EA���BK0�E@PHB��

kKK�=�@?K���>���}y�KME��K�VB?�C0��E�E���KT���~)�tU�?EZK�T�>?��K

VB?�CB0�B�@T�@BAE0�YB��?B��B�|�?KCC�0�V?E��U0�JU���HKKJ@I0�?EV�E

��J�BGCEZBCB0�V?E�?�J���TB@��E)����VK�@?����UJ�AUCE�AU��@����kK

EA@PZHK�BK)

y�HPJ�C�E��ET�E@K0�>E?E�U��?P?�AUC�G�H������>�>EJ�>E�?K>@?K

�@K�?�>B�JEZK?�T�ESEHB?D�>��>�G@>�I�B�?KM��NBI\�{HK@D�ME�E�BCE@D0

V?E�JEZ�E�AUCE�AU��UHKCB?D�>�>BK�?E�E?HKCD�UK�@lK�U�BCB�W?�TU0

B�I��@TEJ�BC�E�FK�?K�AK�B�@>EJ�T�ENK@@K0�����J>�S�>E?E�EME�kKC

TEB@>�P�KMPCB�E���BI�>E�lCB>?��JKZHP�=�BH�K@?�E�DKJ�B�tECHE�

�E�)�]VK�D�J�EMBK�W>@TK�?U�?EMH��ME�E�BCB0�V?E�HE@?BM�P?�AECDkE�

P@TKS0�TE?EJP�V?E�PH�CE@D�P�?B�E?�T�EACKJU�@?�?P@E�0�E?�TECB?BVK@�

>BS�@TE�E�0�B��UHKCB?D�@lK�U0�>E?E�UK�T�KH@?��CI^?�EALB��B�?K�

�K@�HCI�T�BH�K@?�E�NK��B�JECH����)�[�?KVK�BK�TI?B�CK?�PV�@?�B>B

T�ENK@@��@EAB��CB@D�B�TBCB�TB�E)�p?E��@K���V�CE@D���FK�?K�AK�B0

TEW?EJP�T�ENK@@�B���GU��K?@I�>K�?K�AK�B�@>BJ)�=E?EJ�E�B�@EAB���

CB@D���H�PMBS�JK@?�S0�HEME���B��CB@D�EA�EALBS��EJK��S�J�kB�0�>��

>BS�?E�EALBS�HE>PJK�?�S0�>�>BS�?E�JKCEV�S0�>E?E�UJB�JEZ�E�AUCE

G��BJ�?D@I�@E�JK@?�E)�R���>E�NK�>E�NE���@K�@KMEH�I��BHI?0�V?E�E�B

��SEHI?@I�T��>?BVK@>B����@?�HBB�>ECC�T@�)�=E?EJP�V?E��K�@��AE?�C�

@SKJ�0�TE�>E?E�E��TEW?�T�E0�VK�KG��KkK�BK�E?HKCD�US�T�EACKJ0�JEZ�

�E�TEHE�?B�>�@�JE��MC���E��T�EACKJK�B��KkB?D�KK0�>EMH���@��E@?�CD�

�EK�APHK?��KkK�E)

y�AE^@D0�V?E�JU�?EZK�?�>BJ�EA��GEJ���@@J�?�B��KJ�T�ENK@@U

^Z�E>��>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB0�HPJ�I��KkB?D0���T�BJK�0��ET�E@�M��Z�

H��@?���BCB�T�@TE�?E��B�?)H)�[@K�W?E�APHK?��UMCIHK?D�EVK�D�WlKJK��

�E����H���EJ�W?�TK0�>EMH���@K�?�>B���NBE��CD�UK�B�?K�K@U�T�K���

CB�P^?���H��@KJB�E@?�CD�UJB�B�?K�K@�JB)

]TI?D�?�>B0�W?E?�T�>?�E�@?�ABCD�E@?B���J�H�K?�u��ET�)�|E�K@CB

�@TEJ�B?D�T�E�T�EACKJP�K��ETK�@>E��B�?KM��NBB�Q�?E�K��ETK�NU�KK

�@K�?�>B��Kk�^?0�B@SEHI�BG�@�EBS�@EA@?�K��US�B�?K�K@E�)�]�B�KK

HECME�EA@PZH�CB0�P��BS�AUC�@�E�0�E?CBV�U��E?���kKME0�B@?E�BVK@�

Page 42: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

>B��ETU?0�H�PMBK�P@CE�BI)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�E�B�AECDkK�PVB?U��CB

@�EB��K�CD�UK��EGJEZ�E@?B)��?E�B�?K�K@�E�Q�B�J�K�>�ZK?@I0���W?EJ

?EZK�>�>E��?E�G��>�Q�T�>?�E�@?�ABCD�E@?B�TBkP?���xKCDMBB0�B��EEALK

TE@?JEHK��B@?@>BK�JEHKCB��AS�GE�M�PGB�@>EME� ME@PH��@?��� >���J

T�BSEHI?�BG�xKCDMBB)�=�B�W?EJ�E�B�@�JB0����JE���GMCIH0���G��CB���

^?@I)�y��E@T�B�BJ�^�W?E�?�>�Q�K@CB���J�TCESE0�?E�B���J�APHK?�SPZK)

YE�K@?D�P��BS�ETU?��K�TECPVBC@I0�?�>�E�B�SE?I?0�V?EAU�?E0�V?E�P��BS

�K�TECPVBCE@D0�TECPVBCE@D�P���@)

t�K�>�ZK?@I0� V?E� KHB�@?�K���I��EGJEZ�E@?D�EALK>��>�G@>E�

B�?KM��NBB�8JEZK?�AU?D0� Z�E>��>�G@>E�:�Q�W?E�B�?KM��NBI����P�E��

�K�M��ZH��@>EME�EALK@?����?P?�PZK�AUC��K�CD�U���KGPCD?�?)�|�@>ECD>E

I�G��^0�C^AUK�TK�KME�E�U0�>�@�^?@I�CB�E�B��ET�E@���EG���LK�BI

AKZK�NK��BCB�H�PMBS�>�>BS�CBAE�JEJK�?E�0�@�IG���US�@�TECB?BVK@�

>BJ�@?�?P@EJ0�G�SEHI?���?PTB>�B�T�EACKJ���K��Kk�K?@I)�[@KMH��EVK�D

@CEZ�E��UHKCB?D��KMBE��Q�O�PGBI0�RAS�GBI0�?�B�BCB�kK@?D�Q�W?E��@K�

MH��T�EACKJ�)�|E����P�E��K�M��ZH��@>BS�E�M��BG�NB����TE@CKH�BK

TI?D�CK?�AUC�HE@?BM�P?� ?�>E��T��>?BVK@>B��>E�@K�@P@0� >EMH�� �@K

T�BSEHI?�>�@EMC�@B^�E�?EJ0�V?EAU�E@?��B?D���@?E�E�K�@?�?P@U�B�HEME�

�E�B?D@I�E�?EJ0�V?E�M��ZH��@>EK�EALK@?�E�Q�W?E�EALK@?�E�AKG�M���

�BN0�TEC�M�I0� V?E�TE@?�EK�BK�HE�K�BI�HCI�AECDkK��@?�ABCD�E@?B

JEZK?�AU?D�HE@?BM�P?E�VK�KG�EAwKHB�K�BK�C HK�)

YKJ�AECKK0�V?E�B�B@?E�BVK@>B��ETU?�AUC0�|�?KCC����TEJ�BC�0

V?E�AUC��{�>��>�G@>�I�mKHK��NBI)�tU�PZK�W?E�BJKCB0��E�@K�V�@�T�KH�

C�M�K?@I0�>�>�AU����E�E��lE�JK0��E�T��>?BVK@>B�?E�ZK�@�JEK)�=E?EJP

V?E���{�>��>�G@>E��mKHK��NBB�?EZK��K�AUCB�E@EAK��E�PV?K�U��KMBE�

�U0�>E?E�UK�@KMEH�I�I�CI^?@I�>�>�AU�@�JET�E�EGMC�kK��UJB0�B�TE�

W?EJP0�I�@VB?�^0�W?��lKHK��NBI���EALKJ�?E�B���G��CBC�@D)�u@CB�AU

kK@?D�ME@PH��@?�����^MK�F��>�G��AUCB�������EJ�TECEZK�BB0�JEZK?

AU?D0�{�>��>�G@>�I�mKHK��NBI�@PJKC��AU�E?HKCB?D@I���@�EK���KJI�E?

zE@@BB0�B�@K�V�@�JU�@���JB�EA@PZH�CB�AU�@E�K�kK��E�B�UK�T�EACK�

JU)�|E�?�>�TECPVBCE@D0�V?E�PVCB��K��@K�B�?K�K@U)���OE�@>�I�FE�lK�

HK��NBI0�E�>E?E�E���AS�GU��@KMH��C^AI?�ME�E�B?D0�V?E�}P���@�AUC

ETU?~)))�|P�>�>E��W?E�AUC�ETU?\�]VK�D�J�CU��TE���KJK�B)�����T�B��

NBTK0�E��P���@�?ECD>E���TC��K��E@TEJB���B�0�T�BI?�E��T�JI?B�E�T�E�

kCEJ0�V?E�JU��@K�?�>B�@PJKCB�W?E�@HKC�?D)�����.5;5�M)���GME�E��kKC

�K�E��EGJEZ�EJ�ME@PH��@?�K)�|�@>ECD>E�I�ELPL�C�?EMH�0���GME�E�U

Page 43: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�KCB@D�AECDkK���TC��K�HPSE��EME�KHB�@?��0��KZKCB�>�>E��?E�?K��B�

?E�B�CD�E��KHB�BNU)�p?E���zE@@BB�B�EMH���UMEH�E�T�KH@?��B?D��@K

��B�EJ�@�K?K)�XK�V�@0���T�BJK�0�?�J�@?��B?@I��ET�E@�E��KCB>E���K��

>K@BB�� I>EAU��@K� �HUMB�B� �AS�GU�SE?I?�EAwKHB�B?D@I�B�E?S��?B?D

F��@�EH��)�nHEA�E�TECB?B>�J0�E�B�EA�W?EJ�B�ME�E�I?)

F�>�JU�JEMCB�AU��K�MB�E��?D����=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B\�tEZK?

AU?D0�HK�@?�B?KCD�E0���J���AE?�?D���?EJ���T���CK�BB0���>E?E�EJ�JU

�K�CD�E�V?E�?E�JEZKJ�@HKC�?D\�y�HPJ�^0�JEZK?0���J�HK�@?�B?KCD�E

HPJ�?D�E�TE@?�EK�BB�M��ZH��@>EME�EALK@?��0�V?EAU�E�E�@EE?�K?@?�E�

��CE�EALKT�B�I?UJ�K��ETK�@>BJ��E�J�J\�tEZK?�AU?D0�?EMH��B�C^�

HIJ�CKMVK�APHK?��E@T�B�BJ�?D�W?B�JEHKCB0�>E?E�UK�T�BSEHI?�@�{�T��

H�)�=E?EJP�V?E����@KMEH�Ik�B��HK�D��@K0�V?E�T�BSEHB?�@�{�T�H�0��U�

GU��K?�@ET�E?B�CK�BK)�[�O�PGBB�Q��K?0�TE?EJP�V?E�O�PGBI�E�BK�?B�

�E��������{�T�H)�R�RAS�GBI�JPV�K?@I0�BLK?�E�BK�?B�0��B>�>��K�JE�

ZK?����?B)�]���A�C��@B�PK?�Q�?E�zE@@BB0�?E�YP�NBB�PM�EZ�K?0�V?E

TK�KE�BK�?B�PK?@I)�X�H�PME��@?E�E�U0�JEZK?�AU?D0�E���AUC��AU�ME�

?E���>�>�>EJP�?E�T�EV�EJP�@E^GP�B�@�O�PGBK�0�K@CB�AU��BHKC��?�J

�EGJEZ�E@?D�HCI�@�EK��@?�ABCD�E@?B)�y�>�W?EJP�E?�EkP@D�@�>�>BJ�

?E�@>KT@B@EJ)

FE�KV�E0�AUCE�AU�ZKC�?KCD�E�TK�K�K@?B�W?E?�=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B

����P@@>B��IGU>0�V?EAU�C^HB�BJKCB��EGJEZ�E@?D�TEHPJ�?D)�|��W?E

��HE���KJI)�XK�V�@�JU��K�?�>BK�W>@TK�?U0�V?EAU�@E�@CE��YB��?B��B

|�?KCCU�AU@?�K�D>E��KkB?D0�T�B�I?D���J�T�>?�E�@?�ABCD�E@?B�BCB

�K?0�BCB��U��GB?D�@�EK�E?�EkK�BK)�y�T�E@?E��KJ�EME�@EJ�K��^@D)

�� �%!���R�S���8���lE�J�NBI�EA�W?EJ�T�>?K�K@?D�����?K��K?K)

�������!"�#�-8�O�PGBI��KHD�E?E���C����@�E?���?K��K?�)�|K?���?K���K?����RAS�GBB0��K?)

!R������RU,���R��8�y�?EZK�SEVP�TEAC�MEH��B?D�|�?KCCP�B�YB��?B�0TE?EJP�V?E�J�EME���G�T�BSEHBCE@D�@CUk�?D0�V?E�@PLK@?�PK?�?�>E��T�>?0

>E?E�U����GU��K?@I�}T�>?EJ�@?�ABCD�E@?B~0��E��B���GP��K�T�BSEHB�

CE@D�@CUk�?D�E��KJ�>E�>�K?�E0�B�HE�@BS�TE��I�KME�KLK��K�VB?�C)

�G�@KMEH�Ik�BS�HE>C�HE��I�TECPVBC�>�>EK�?E�WCKJK�?���EK�T�KH�

@?��CK�BK�E�?EJ0�V?E�@EAE��T�KH@?��CIK?�W?E?�HE>PJK�?)�[�JEKJ�TE�

Page 44: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�BJ��BB0�@?�ABCD�E@?D�GHK@D�����IK?@I�B�?KM��NBB0�B�JEZ�E�AUCE

AU0����K��EK0���G��?D�KME�T�>?EJ�EA�B�?KM��NBB)�F�>�ME�E�BC��|��

?KCC�0����DkK�PZK�T�KHT�B�BJ�CB@D�TETU?>B��K�CBGE��?D�BHK^�B��

?KM��NBB����F��>�GK)�oE?I�����kK��B@?E�BB�PZK�@PLK@?�PK?��K>E?E�

�U��E?�BN�?KCD�U��ETU?0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�B�?KM��NBI�Q�W?E�?E?�T�E�

NK@@0�>�>E?E�EJP�JU�HECZ�U�@?�KJB?D@I)�=E?EJP�V?E0�H�ZK���TC��K

��G�KkK�BI�>E�lCB>?E�0��K�EI?�E@?D���G�KkK�BI�>E�lCB>?��AECD�

kK�����J>�S�>�>E��?E�NKCE@?�E@?B0�VKJ�K@CB�JU�APHKJ�BGECB�E���U

H�PM�E?�H�PM�)�=EW?EJP�@�J�T�ENK@@�B�?KM��NBB�JEZ�E�?ECD>E�T�B�

�K?@?�E��?D0�H�ZK�K@CB�E��@PLK@?�PK?���>�VK@?�K�TE>���K��K�CBGE����

�EME�HE>PJK�?�0��E�@PLK@?�PK?�>�>�BHKI)

|��K��EK0��KCDGI�@>�G�?D0�V?E�?E?����B��?0�>E?E�U��GHK@D�T�KH�

@?��CK�0�>�>E��?E�E>E�V�?KCD�U�)�p?E�H�ZK��KJU@CBJE0�K@CB�JU�?P?

��TBkKJ�?�>E��E>E�V�?KCD�U�����B��?�B�TEC�U��@NK���B��?EME0�V?E

HECZ�E�T�EBGE�?B0���@�JUS�TEH�EA�US�HK?�CIS)�|E0��BHBJE0�W?E�HK��

@?�B?KCD�E���HE�T�KH@?��B?D0�>�>�ME�E�BC�RAK@�CEJ0�>�>�E?>�U?P^0

���K�E>E�V�?KCD�P^�@B@?KJP0���HE�BH?B���W?EJ���T���CK�BB�B��@K

��KJI�>E��K>?B�E��?D0�HEA��CI?D�B�HETEC�I?D)

�?E�>�@�K?@I�BHKB�TEW?�T�E@?B�B�E�?EJ0�>�>�E@PLK@?�CI?D�T�E�

NK@@�B�?KM��NBB)�qK�@?�B?KCD�E0� ?�PH�E�T�KH@?��B?D0� V?E�>?E�?E

��TBkK?��A@EC^?�E�P�B�K�@�CD�U�0�BHK�CD�U�����B��?�B�?KM��NBB0

>E?E�U��@KMEH�I�ZK���HE�E@PLK@?�B?D�@BJPCD?���E0���EH�EJ���KJK��

�EJ�E?�KG>K)�[BHBJE0�W?E�>�>E��?E�T�ENK@@0�>�>E?E�EJP�JU�HECZ�U

@?�KJB?D@I�B�TEW?�T�E0�TEEVK�KH�E��Kk�?D��ET�E@U�Q�>�>�W?B�ME@P�

H��@?���HECZ�U��K�?ECD>E��KMPCB�E��?D�E?�EkK�BI�H�PM�@�H�PMEJ0��E

B�>�>�E�B�HECZ�U��TB@�?D@I���EALKJB�E�E��>E�?K>@?)

tU��K�@JEZKJ��TB@�?D@I���EALKJB�E�E��>E�?K>@?0�K@CB��K�AP�

HKJ���@@J�?�B��?D�@KAI���>��>�G@>EJ�>E�?K>@?K)�u@CB0���T�BJK�0�O�P�

GBI�APHK?���@@J�?�B��?D�@KAI���K�>��>�G@>EME�>E�?K>@?�0�E����K�APHK?

I�CI?D@I�O�PGBK�)�|K�?ECD>E���MKEM��lBVK@>EJ�TC��K0��E�B���>PCD?P��

�EJ�TC��K0���W>E�EJBVK@>EJ�TC��K�O�PGBI�HECZ���T�KH@?��B?D�@KAI

����J>�S�>��>�G@>EME�>E�?K>@?�0� >��>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB)�Y�>�ZK�B

RAS�GBI0�B�RGK�A��HZ��0�B�R�JK�BI�B�?)H)

y0�AKGP@CE��E0�@EMC�@K��@�|�?KCCE�0�V?E��KCDGI��K�PVB?U��?D

JEJK�?�XK�K��EME�F��>�G�)�|E�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�T�KH@?��CK��U�����

�B��?����W?EJ�W?�TK�?EZK�HE@?�?EVK�0�TE?EJP�V?E�K@CB�AU���?E�U

Page 45: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�>C^VBCB�XK�K��U��F��>�G0�E�B�AU0����K��EK0��EkCB���AECDkP^

>E�l�E�?�NB^�@�zE@@BK�0�B�W?E��UG��CE�AU��K�B�?KM��NB^0���HK�

GB�?KM��NB^0�I�BCE@D�AU�>�>BJ�?E�HK@?�P>?B��UJ�WCKJK�?EJ)�|E

H�ZK�K@CB�E@PLK@?�B?D�B�?KM��NBE��U��T�ENK@@�����J>�S��Z�E�

ME�F��>�G�0�E��APHK?�>�>�AU�@�EKEA��G�E��ETE�E��HCI��@KME�F��>��

G�0���?EJ�VB@CK�B�HCI�@K�K�E>��>�G@>BS����EH�E@?K�0�V?EAU�E�B�@E�

�BK�?B�E��CB@D�B�H�BM�CB@D�����T���CK�BB�W?EME�B�?KM��NBE��E�

ME�T�ENK@@�)

F?E�?E�HECZK����V�?D)�[@��@��GP��K�T�EB@SEHB?)�=EW?EJP�I�@VB�

?�^0�V?E�@�JP�W?P�BHK^0�H�ZK�K@CB�E����K�E@PLK@?�B?@I�B�H�ZK�K@CB

E���BJKK?�>ECE@@�CD�EK�>ECBVK@?�E�>�>BS�?E��KHE@?�?>E�0�E?�K�M�?D

�@K�?�>B��K�@?EB?)�|�EAE�E?0���HE�KK�EAHPJ�?D�B���@T�E@?���I?D)�|�HE

EG��>EJB?D�C^HK��@�W?BJB�BHKIJB0���@T�E@?���I?D�TEHEA�UK�HE>P�

JK�?U�B�H�ZK�T�BGU��?D�>�?EJP0�V?EAU�>?E�?E�V?E�?E�HETEC�IC)�y

@VB?�^0�V?E�K@CB�JU���K@KJ�>�>BK�?E�HETEC�K�BI0�@�EB�>E�@?�P>�

?B��UK�JU@CB���W?EJ�TC��K0�?E�JU�?EZK�APHKJ�@TE@EA@?�E��?D�W?EJP

T�ENK@@P�B�?KM��NBB)

�������!"�#�-8�F?E���K@K?\

!R������RU,���R��8�r^A�I�BHKI�NK���)�|�HE�@��V�C��BGPVB?D�W?E?HE>PJK�?�HK?�CD�E0�B��K�?ECD>E�JU0��E�B�H�PMBK�?EZK�HECZ�U�BGP�

VB?D)�tU�HECZ�U�ETPACB>E��?D�KME���@�EKJ�@AE��B>K)

�����M�.� �-8�y�SE?KC�AU�@��GP�G�I�B?D0�V?E�I�T�E?B��B>��@I>E�HKGB�?KM��NBB�B�@?E�E��B>�B�?KM��NBB0�?KJ�AECKK�>EMH���KVD�BHK?�E

F��>�GK)�XKMEH�I�JU�BJKKJ�l�>?���GHKCK��E@?B�F��>�G�)���AECKK

?EME0�T�E?K>�^LBK�T�ENK@@U�Q�MKETECB?BVK@>BK0�@ENB�CD�UK�Q�E�B

KLK�AECKK�PMCPACI^?�HKGB�?KM�B�E����E@?D)

F��>�G��@KMH��AUC�HE@?�?EV�E�B�?KM�B�E����UJ���@ENB�CD�EJ0

>PCD?P��EJ0�HPSE��EJ0�W>ECEMBVK@>EJ0��E��@KS�E?�EkK�BIS)�F��>�G

T�KH@?��CIC�@EAE��KHB�EK�T�E@?���@?�E)�F�@EZ�CK�B^0�@KMEH�I�W?E�

ME��K?)�=EW?EJP0�>EMH���KVD�BHK?�EA�EALK>��>�G@>E��BHKK�BCB�T�>?K

@?�ABCD�E@?B0�I�>�TEHEA�EME��EH���U@>�GU���BIJ�B�BHKIJ�E?�EkP@D

TECEZB?KCD�E)���I�@�PHE�ECD@?�BKJ0�@�B�?K�K@EJ�@CPk�C�EAEBS����

kBS�HE>C�HVB>E�)

Page 46: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�0�>@?�?B�ME�E�I0��K@JE?�I����>�B?B>P����H�K@�W?EME�HE>PJK�?�

@E�@?E�E�U�?KS�BCB�B�US����CB?B>E�0���AC^H�?KCK��Q�I�@�TE�BJ��B�

KJ�E?�EkP@D�>�TEHEA�E��>�B?B>K0��E���?E�ZK���KJI�@�PHE�CK?�E�K�B�

KJ�SE?KC�AU�E?JK?B?D0�V?E�I��BZP�>�>E��?E�ET�KHKCK��U��T�EM�K@@��

TE�BJ��BB�F��>�G�� @E� @?E�E�U�G�T�H�US����CB?B>E�)�u@CB�?K�ZK

��?E�U0�>E?E�UK� @E@?��CICB�W?E?�HE>PJK�?0�T�B�ICB@D�AU� G���KME

AP>��CD�E��K@>ECD>E�CK?�?EJP���G�H0���IH�CB�?�J�TEI�BCB@D�AU�H�ZK

W?B�>PNUK�l��GU0�@>�ZKJ0�E��EH@?�K�BCB�E��KEASEHBJE@?B�@ES���K�

�BI�>�>BS�?E�E?�EkK�B�0�@�IGK���AS�GE��@�@K�K�E>��>�G@>BJB����E�

H�JB)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�EALK@?�K��E�TECB?BVK@>�I�JU@CD�u��ETU���G�

�B��K?@I���W?EJ���T���CK�BB0�B�HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E���HE�T�B�K?@?�E��?D)

X�H�PME��@?E�E�U0�@�J��BHKI0�>�>�J�K�T�KH@?��CIK?@I0�TE>��KLK

@CBk>EJ�WlKJK�����K�?ECD>E�HCI�u��ETU0��E�B�HCI���@�@�JBS)�]AUV�

�E�?�>�I�TECB?BVK@>�I�B�?KM��NBI�BCB0�@>�ZKJ0�>�>BK�?E��CDI�@U

�EK��E�TECB?BVK@>EME0�W>E�EJBVK@>EME0�>PCD?P��EME�BCB�W>ECEMBVK@�

>EME�S���>?K���Q�E�B���@?PT�^?�TE@CK�?EME0�>�>�HE@?�?EV�E�VK?>E

E@JU@CK�U0�E@EG���U�?K>PLBK��K�CBB�B��EEALK��K�CBB)

[E?0�@>�ZKJ0�K��ETK�@>B���CDI�@�A�GB�PK?@I����A�GK�EALKME�K��

�ETK�@>EME�JK�?�CB?K?�0�EALK�0�S���>?K��E��HCI��@KS�K��ETK�@>BS

���EHE��@B@?KJU�NK��E@?�E��E�BK�?�NBB0�EALKME�HCI��@KS�K��ETK��

@>BS����EHE����SK?BT��TE�KHK�BI)�YE�ZK�@�JEK�JU�JEZKJ�@>�G�?D�E

?KS�BCB�B�US��E@?EV�US��CDI�@�S)�p?E��K�T�E@?E�VDI�?E�T�BSE?D�Q

@>�ZKJ0�TECB?BVK@>BK��JABNBB�BCB�TECB?BVK@>BK�B�?K�K@Uc��K@EJ�

�K��E0�E�B�?EZK�T�B@P?@?�P^?0��E�E�B�lE�JB�P^?@I����E@�E�K�>��

>BS�?E�A�GE�US�H���US)���HPJ�^0�V?E�>EMH��JU�APHKJ�ME�E�B?D�E�TE�

CB?BVK@>E��B�?KM��NBB�?KTK�D�PZK�F��>�G�0�E���?EZK�HECZ���ETB�

��?D@I����?�>BK�A�GE�UK�H���UK)�]�B�K@?D0��E0�>�@EZ�CK�B^0�E�B��K

E@JU@CK�U)�����J0�TE��@K���K�EI?�E@?B�@CKHPK?�P@BCB?D�@�EK���BJ��

�BK�>�E@JU@CK�B^0�>�TE�BJ��B^0�>�BGPVK�B^�W?BS��K�CB�)

xUCE�AU0����JE���GMCIH0�ZKC�?KCD�E�8I�GHK@D���GHKCI^�JU@CB0

>E?E�UK�PZK��U@>�GU��CB@D�HE�JK�I:0�K@CB�AU�W?P���AE?P�T�EHECZ��

CB��K�?ECD>E�K��ETK�@>BK�@TKNB�CB@?U����CB?B>B0���>��K��AUCB�AU

TEH>C^VK�U�B�T�KH@?��B?KCB�@�JEME�F��>�G�)��@TECDGPI�?E?�WJTB�

�BVK@>B��J�?K�B�C0�>E?E�U��BJKK?@I�GHK@D�����CBVBB0���kB�C^HB

JEMCB�AU�T�B�K@?B�TECDGP0�K@CB�E�B��JK@?K�@E�@�EBJB�K��ETK�@>BJB

>ECCKM�JB�APHP?���AE?�?D���H�?�>BJ�T�EK>?EJ)

Page 47: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

[JK@?K�@�?KJ0�GHK@D�I��E���AC^H�^?@I�H���TEHSEH�)�y�SE?KC�AU

@>�G�?D0�V?E���T�B�NBTK�GHK@D�JEMP?�AU?D���G�UK�TEHSEHU)�|E�E?�EH�

�EME�TEHSEH��I�SE?KC�AU�T�KHE@?K�KVD�@�EBS�>ECCKM0�B�@�JEME�@KAI��

TK��P^�EVK�KHD�Q�W?E�>E�w^�>?P��U��TEHSEH)�|�J���ZK��H�PME��Q

�>�HKJBVK@>B��TEHSEH)�u@CB�JU�APHKJ���G��A�?U��?D��>�HKJBVK@�

>B��TEHSEH�B�MK�K�B�E��?D�TECB?BVK@>P^�T���E�P^�JEHKCD0�E���JE�

ZK?�E>�G�?D@I�B@?E�BVK@>B�TK�@TK>?B��E�)�[E?0�TEZ�CP�0�P�JK�I��@�)

�������!"�#�-8�tEZ�E�G�H�?D��ET�E@\�y�SEVP�G��?D�Q�>EMH�0���>�>EK

��KJI�F��>�G�T�KH@?��CIC�KHB�EK�T�E@?���@?�E0�K@CB��U�BJKK?K��

�BHP�@?�ABCD�E@?D\

�����M�.� �-8�[�TECB?BVK@>EJ�@JU@CK�BCB�>PCD?P��EJ\

�������!"�#�-8�[�>�>EJ��BAPHD)�OKEM��lBVK@>B0�I�G��^0�JU��@K���K�JI��JK@?K)

�����M�.� �-8�X>�ZKJ0�K@CB�H�ZK�JU��EGDJKJ�zE@@B�@>P^�BJTK��B^��FE�KV�E0����E@KJ��HN�?EJ0�HK�I?��HN�?EJ��K>�S�F��>�G�AUC

��GHKCK�0�TE>��GHK@D�kCB��E��U)�|E�TE?EJ���@E@?��K�XE�K?@>EME�XE�

^G��F��>�G�E@?���C@I�>�>�AU�KHB�UJ)

�������!"�#�-8�[�VKJ�W?E��U��Z�CE@D\

�����M�.� �-8�X>�ZKJ0� @KMEH�I�JU�TK�KSEHBJ�ME@PH��@?�K��P^M���BNP)�|�J�T�BSEHB?@I�T�KEHECK��?D�>�>BK�?E�M���BNU0��K��E\�tU

�K�?ECD>E���GHKCK�U�@E�@�EBJB�@E@KHIJB0��EH@?�K��UJB�TCKJK���

JB0��E�K@?D�KHB�UK����EHU0�>E?E�UK�E>�G�CB@D���GHKCK��UJB)�|��

T�BJK�0�CKGMB�U0�E@K?B�U��l�>?BVK@>B�EHB��B�?E?�ZK�W?�E@�E>�G�C@I

��GHKCK��UJ)

�������!"�#�-8�=ECPV�K?@I0�V?E�KHB�@?�K��EK���KJI0�>EMH��F��>�GAUC�KHB�UJ�B�@?�ABCD�UJ�Q�W?E�WTES��XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�)

�����M�.� �-8�|K?0�B����DkK�?EZK)�F��>�G��K��@KMH��AUC���GHKCK�)

Page 48: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�������!"�#�-8�]CKM�|K@?E�E�BV0�I�G�H�C��ET�E@��K�BG���KH�E@?B)[U�@>�G�CB0�V?E�@KMEH�I�JU�BJKKJ�l�>?���GHKCK�BI�F��>�G�0�SE?I

���DkK�E��T�KH@?��CIC�@EAE��KHB�EK�T�E@?���@?�E)�[�>�>E��lE�JK0

��>�>EJ�lE�J�?K�W?E�AUCE\

�����M�.� �-8�[�>PCD?P��E�NB�BCBG�NBE��EJ�@JU@CK�@CE��0���W>E�CEMBVK@>EJ�@JU@CK�@CE���F��>�G�T�KH@?��CIC�KHB�EK�T�E@?���@?�E�

�������!"�#�-8�y�@EJ�K��^@D���@VK?�NB�BCBG�NBE��EME0�?P?�?�>BKB@?E�BVK@>BK�HKA�B��[GI?D0���T�BJK�0�RGK�A��HZ���

�����M�.� �-8�F@?�?B0�x�?�C0�?U�T���BCD�E�PTEJI�PC�EA�RGK�A��H�Z��K)�RGK�A��HZ��NU���>��>�G@>B��>E�?K>@?�JK�DkK��TB@U��^?@I)

�������!"�#�-8�R���JI�K�E?�E@I?�@KAI�>�RGBB)

�����M�.� �-8�q�0���JI�K�?EZK)�R��E?�M�PGB�U�

�������!"�#�-8�FE�EVK0�E@?�CB@D�M�PGB�U�B��AS�GU)��+',�- �����

[U�>PH����@�?EC>�K?K\

�����M�.� �-8�O�PGB�U0��AS�GU�B�@K�K�E>��>�GNU�Q�W?E0�HK�@?�B�?KCD�E0����@�JEJ�HKCK�F��>�G)

��������%�"�8�y�VP�@?�P^0�V?E�]CKM�|K@?E�E�BV�AECKK�ET?BJB@�?BVK����E?�EkK�BB�W?EME�HE>PJK�?��B��EEALK�W?E��BHKB)�F�>��U�HP�

J�K?K0�>�>�JEZ�E�T�KEHECK?D0����JE���GMCIH0�@�JEK�MC���EK�B�?�PH�E�

��G�KkBJEK�T�E?B�E�KVBK�Q�JKZHP�B�?K�K@�JB�zE@@BB�B�{�T�H�\

u@CB��K�@PJK?D�T�KEHECK?D�W?B�T�E?B�E�KVBI0�?E�F��>�G��@K�KLK�AP�

HK?���GHB��?D@I�BJB)

�����M�.� �-8�y�@���JB�@EMC�@K�0��E�@�H�PME��@?E�E�U0�@KMEH�I�F���>�G�HKGB�?KM�B�E���0�B�zE@@BI�TECPV�K?��EGJEZ�E@?D0�>E�KV�E0�E>��

GU��?D�AECDkKK��CBI�BK)�u@CB�F��>�G���@�JEJ�HKCK�TE�HK?�TE�TP?B

B�?KM��NBB0�zE@@BB0�>E�KV�E0�T�BHK?@I�@VB?�?D@I�@�>��>�G@>BJ�l�>�

?E�EJ�ME��GHE�AECDkK0��KZKCB�@KMEH�I)

Page 49: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�0��%�8�[�W?EJ�@JU@CK���@�CKMVK�HKGB�?KM�B�E��?D0�VKJ�B�?KM�B��E��?D)

!R������RU,���R��8�tEZ�E�G�H�?D�KLK�EHB���ET�E@\�8y�B�@�J�@KAK

KME�G�H�^):�FEJP�APHK?��UMEHK��B�?KM�B�E����U��F��>�G\�zE@@BB\

F��>�GP\�{�T�HP\�[E@?E>P\

�����M�.� �-8�u@CB�W?��B�?KM��NBI�APHK?�T�EB@SEHB?D�@BC�JB���K�k�BJB0�?E0�>E�KV�E0�TE��@K���K�EI?�E@?B�W?E�APHK?��UMEH�E�BJ)�|E

K@CB�B�JU�APHKJ�T�B�BJ�?D�PV�@?BK0�K@CB�F��>�G�T�BJK?�PV�@?BK��

W?EJ�T�ENK@@K0�?E�F��>�G0�K@?K@?�K��E0�PV?K?�@�EB�@EA@?�K��UK�B��

?K�K@U)��M�E�B�PI�B�?K�K@U���Kk�BS�@BC0���Kk�KME�JB��0�JU�@���JB

�B>�>BS�T�EACKJ��KkB?D��K�@JEZKJ)�|E���T�ENK@@K�W?E��B�?KM��NBB

B�P@?��E�CK�BI�EALK��TECB?B>E�T���E�E��JEHKCB0�JU0�K@?K@?�K��E0

APHKJ�PVB?U��?D�@�EB�@EA@?�K��UK�B�?K�K@U)����VK0�>�>���H���EJ

@CPV�K0���kB�B�?K�K@U0�K@?K@?�K��E0��K�APHP?�PVB?U��?D@I)

��R��� ����0�8�y�?EZK�SE?KC��@T�E@B?D0�>EJP�W?E��UMEH�E)�t�K

>�ZK?@I0���>��?>E@�EV�EJ�TC��K�Q�W?E�HE@?�?EV�E��UMEH�E�{�T�HP��

@�IGB�@�}sKC>E�UJ�TP?KJ~)�[KHD�ME�E�I?�E��KEASEHBJE@?B�EAK@TK�

VK�BI�@?�ABCD�E@?B����KMBE�K�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU�JEZ�E�AUCE�@TE>E��E

TK�K>�VB��?D��Kl?D)�R���HECME@�EV�EJ�TC��K0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�W?E��U�

MEH�E�B�@�JEJP�F��>�GP)�y��K�HPJ�^0�V?E�G�T�H�UK�HK�Z��U�?��?BCB

AU�J�EME�HK�KM�@�PVK?EJ�?EME0�V?E�W?��B�?KM��NBI�l�>?BVK@>B�@E�

GH�@?�@BCP0�@�>E?E�E��T�BHK?@I�@VB?�?D@I)�|E���ACBZ��kKJ�APHPLKJ0

BJKI����BHP�TK�@TK>?B�U��Kl?I�EME�TP?B0�K@CB�W?E?�T�>?�APHK?�M��

���?B�E��?D�@?�ABCD�E@?D0�?E�W?E0����K��EK0�APHK?��UMEH�E�T�KZHK

�@KME�{�T�HP)�[�W?EJ�@JU@CK�zE@@BB�W?E0���T�E?B�0��K�UMEH�E)

R�KLK�I�SE?KC��T�KHCEZB?D�H���EK�EA@PZHK�BK�T�>?��TK�K�K@?B

�����MCB�@>B��IGU>�B�TK�KH�?D�KME���?E��J�@���kBJB��ET�E@�JB�B

T�KHCEZK�BIJB0�B�����kB�JK@?�UK�E�M��BG�NBB�?EZK)

M���� �/%�"�-8�y��K�TECB?ECEM0��K�?�>E��ETU?�U��VKCE�K>0�>�>��@KT�B@P?@?�P^LBK�GHK@D)�y�JEMP���@@PZH�?D�?ECD>E�B@SEHI�BG�GH���EME

@JU@C�)�[E?�@�J�@TE�0�>E?E�U��@K�V�@�GHK@D��EG�B>0�ME�E�B?�E�?EJ0

V?E���P?�B�@�JBS�@EEALK@?��HE@?�?EV�US�E@�E���B��HCI�?�>E��B��

Page 50: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

?KM��NBB��K?)�=EW?EJP�K@CB�AU���?E�U�W?EME�?K>@?��T�K@CKHE��CB

NKCB0�>E?E�UK���@�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�B�?K�K@P^?0�@?�ABCD�E@?D�B�?)T)0�B

��@@J�?�B��CB�AU�F��>�G�>�>��KV?E�KHB�EK0�?E�E�B�EAIG�?KCD�E��>C^�

VBCB�AU�B�XK�K��U��F��>�G0��K�GB��I����zE@@B^)�u@CB�F��>�G�Q�W?E

KHB�EK�NKCEK0�?E��K�JEZK?�AU?D0�V?EAU��Z�U��F��>�G�E?HKCD�E�@E�

GH�C�AU�>�>P^�?E�B�?KM��NB^0���XK�K��U��F��>�G�E@?�C@I�AU�G��AE��

?EJ)�p?E�>�>E��?E��E�@K�@0�W?E��A@EC^?�E��KTE�I?�E)

��������%�"�8�tEZK?0�E�B�B�SE?KCB0��E�AEICB@D�zE@@BB)

M���� �/%�"�-8�u@CB�AU�E�B0�HK�@?�B?KCD�E0�T�K@CKHE��CB��K�>��>BK�?E�TECB?BVK@>BK�NKCB0���H�PMBK�Q�NB�BCBG�NBE��UK�B�?)H)0�?E0

J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�E�B��>C^VBCB�AU�B�XK�K��U��F��>�G)�{HK@D��KTE�

�I?�E�Q��E?0�@>�ZKJ0�=�>?�EHEA�BCB�MC��U�?�KS��KHPLBS�ME@PH��@?��Q

BJK^?@I����BHP�R�JK�BI0�RGK�A��HZ�����@K�EHEA�BCB0��E�RAS�GBI0

F���A�S0��Z��I�]@K?BI��K��>C^VK�U���KME�EA@PZHK�BK�B�KME�T�B�I�

?BK)�Y�>��KHD��USEHB?\�u@CB�ZK�E�B��>C^VK�U���T�B�I?BK�W?EME��K�

kK�BI0�?E�E�B�HECZ�U�AU?D��>C^VK�U�?ECD>E��������US�P@CE�BIS�@E

�@KJB)

��������%�"�8�y�ZK�@>�G�C�0�V?E���kB�T�KH@?��B?KCB��EEALK��K

G�SE?KCB�KME�EA@PZH�?D)�]�B�@>�G�CB0�V?E�W?E�HCI���@��KT�BKJCKJE)

M���� �/%�"�-8�|K?0�I�BJK^����BHP�Q�>�>�@�JB�@E@?��B?KCB�TC��B��P^?�T�B�BJ�?D�W?E?�T�>?\

�� ������/%!��-8�]�B0����K��EK0�@VB?�^?0�V?E�KME�APHP?�T�B�BJ�?DJKZHP���EH�E�T�BG����UK�ME@PH��@?��)

M���� �/%�"�-8����VB?0�JU�BJKKJ�T�E@?E�@E�K?@>P^�@B@?KJP0�?ECD�>E���H�PME��lE�JK�Q��@��?P�ZK�BK���SB^����EHE�0����ZB�)�p?E�@E�K?�

@>�I���?E�EJBI0�?ECD>E���G���BK�H�PMEK)�[E?�TEVKJP�I�@EJ�K��^@D)

]�B�ME�E�I?�EA�BM�E>�S0��E�P�JK�I�?�>EK�VP�@?�E0�V?E�BM�E>�JB�I�CI�

^?@I�@�JB�@E@?��B?KCB�W?EME�T�>?�)�]�B�Q�BM�E>B0�>E?E�UK0����K��

�EK0�T�K@CKHE��CB�AECKK�T��MJ�?BVK@>BK0�ACBZ��kBK�TECB?BVK@>BK

NKCB0����K�B@>�K��^^�G�AE?P�E�@?�ABCD�E@?B�B�JB�K�SE?I�AU���^Z�

Page 51: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�E��V�@?B�F��>�G�)��G�?EME0�V?E�I�G��^0�P�JK�I�@EGH�K?@I�?�>EK��TK�

V�?CK�BK�Q�W?E�T�E@?E�>�>�I�?E�TK�K?�@E�>�)�=E?EJ�?�J�kC���KVD�E

>�>BS�?E�TECBNK�@>BS�E�M���S�HCI�P@JB�K�BI�@KT���?B@?E�)))

��������%�"�8�p?E��K�?�>)�]�B�HETP@>�^?@I���>�ZHEJ�BG�W?BS�EA���GE���B��

M���� �/%�"�-8�q�0��E�TE?EJ��E?�W?���@I�@CEZ��I�@B@?KJ��M��ZH���@?��)�{�TP?�KkD@I�T�E@?E)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�T�KHC�M�?D�BHKB�B�@E�

@?��CI?D�?�>BK�T�EK>?U�HECZ�U�@�JB�>��>�GNU�Q�@�T�B�CKVK�BKJ0

>E�KV�E0�@TKNB�CB@?E��BG�JB�E�US�B�JKZHP���EH�US�B�@?B?P?E�)

|E�@�JB�>��>�GNU0��>C^V�I�XK�K��U��F��>�G0�HECZ�U�AU?D��>C^VK�

�U���W?E?�T�ENK@@)

���?KM��NBI�Q�W?E�EVK�D�SE�EkE0�W?E�T�K>��@�E)�|E�HCI�VKME\

tU�ZK�AECDkK�G��KJ0�HCI�VKME�W?E���HE�>��>�GN�J0�VKJ�>?E�?E�H�P�

ME�0�>�>�AU�E���B�AUC�G��>EJ�@�@B?P�NBK��GHK@D0�>�>�AU�HECME��B

EAL�C@I�@���JB)

�������!"�#�-8�[U�?�>�ME�E�B?K0�>�>�APH?E���J�K��ETK�NU�T�KHC��M�^?�@?�KCI?D�H�PM���H�PM�)

��,� ��.�S,���8�]�>��>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB�B��>C^VK�BB�XK�K���EME�F��>�G����W?E?�T�ENK@@��XK�K��U��F��>�G�Q�W?E�@E@?����I�V�@�

?D^�zE@@BB0�B��>C^VK�BK�XK�K��EME�F��>�G����W?E?�T�ENK@@�APHK?

EG��V�?D��>C^VK�BK�zE@@BB0���C^AE��B�?KM��NBE��U��T�ENK@@0��>C^�

V�^LB��zE@@B^0��A@EC^?�E��KT�BKJCKJ�HCI�O�PGBB)

�������!"�#�-8�Y�>��E?�MHK�@EA�>��G��U?�)

��,� ��.�S,���8�O�PGB^�B�?KM��NBI0�TE�JEKJP0�B�?K�K@PK?���?E�@?KTK�B0���>�>E��APHK?�@TE@EA@?�E��?D�KK�E>E�V�?KCD�E��B�?KM��NBB

��>�>BK�?E�K��ETK�@>BK�BCB���?E�@>BK�@?�P>?P�U)�YE�K@?D�B�?KM���

NBI�>�>�@EGH��BK�>�>EME�?E�lE���@?�ABCD�E@?B0�>E?E�U��APHK?�EAK@�

TKVB��?D�ZBG�K@TE@EA�E@?D�M�PGB�@>EME�ME@PH��@?��0�B��K�AECKK�?EME)

X�J��BHKI�@EGH��BI�>�>EME�?E�>��>�G@>EME�EA��GE���BI�J�K�T�KH�

@?��CIK?@I��A@EC^?�E�AK@TK�@TK>?B��E�0�TE?EJP�V?E����KMBE�K��K?

Page 52: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

HCI� W?EME��K@P�@�)���?KM��NBI�EG��V�K?0� V?E� APHK?� MEJEMK�BG�NBI

>�>EME�?E��KMBE��0�B��@K��K����EJK��E@?B�APHP?�>KJ�?E��U�E��K�U)

[��KMBE�K��K?�?�>BS��K@P�@E�0�V?EAU��@K�W?E��U�E��I?D)

t�K�EVK�D�?�PH�E�T�KH@?��B?D�@KAK�>��>�G@>BK�NK��E@?B0�>E?E�

�UK�JEMCB�AU�@?�?D�lP�H�JK�?EJ�>��>�G@>E��B�?KM��NBB)�uHB�@?�K��

�UK�NK��E@?�UK�E�BK�?B�U0� >E?E�UK�T�BKJCKJU�HCI�O�PGBB0� W?E

K��ETK�@>BK�NK��E@?B�Q�HKJE>��?BI0��K�SE�K�@?�E�G�>E��0�T�����VKCE�

�K>��B�?)T)�RCD?K���?B�U�W?BJ�NK��E@?IJ��K?)�u@CB��GMCI�P?D�@�W>E�

�EJBVK@>E��?EV>B�G�K�BI0�EALB���U�E>�Q�W?E�SE�EkE0��E��K���@?ECD�

>E0�V?EAU�BG�G��W?EME�E?>�G�?D@I�E?�K��ETK�@>E��B�?KM��NBB)�Y�>�V?E0

J�K�@E�@KJ��K�I@�E0��EGJEZ�E�CB�W?E��EEALK)

��������%�"�8�y�SE?KC��AU�@T�E@B?D�Q����K�HETP@>�K?K�CB��U0�V?EG��?���BCB�VK�KG�MEH0�VK�KG�H�����O�PGBB�JEZK?�@JK�B?D@I��C�@?D0�KK

TECB?BVK@>�I�E�BK�?�NBI� @E�K�kK��E�BGJK�B?@I�B�T�KAU���BK��

KHB�EJ�T�E@?���@?�K�@�zE@@BK��APHK?��E@T�B�BJ�?D@I�H�ZK�M�PGB��

@>BJ�EALK@?�EJ�EVK�D�TECEZB?KCD�E\

t�K�>�ZK?@I0�?E0�V?E��U�ME�E�B?K�Q�W?E�KLK��K�J�K�BK��@K��O�P�

GBB)�=E?EJP�V?E0���T�BJK�0�|EH����BHB?�>�>BK�?E�EALK>��>�G@>BK

NK��E@?B�B�>�>EK�?E�KHB�@?�E)�y�T���BCD�E�@lE�JPCB�E��C�\

��,� ��.�S,���8�y�?EZK�AU���H��BHK?D0��E���?E�>�@�K?@I�EALK�

>��>�G@>BS�NK��E@?K�0�TE�W?EJP�TE�EHP�JEZ�E�@TE�B?D)�|E�E���Kk�

�KTECB?BVK@>EJ�>P�@K0�TE�JEKJP0���O�PGBB��B>?E��K�@TE�B?0�>�EJK

�A@EC^?�E�J��MB��CD�US�TECB?BVK@>BS�@BC)�[C�@?D�JEZK?�@JK�B?D�

@I0��E��K>?E��M�PGB�@>E��TECB?B>B�E@?��K?@I�AKG�BGJK�K�B�)

YK�T��?BB0�>E?E�UK���?P^?�G��AECKK�?KTCUK�E?�EkK�BI�@�zE@@B�

K�0��K���AB��^?�����UAE��S�B�H�PS�T�ENK�?E��Q�I�BJK^����BHP�uHB�

�P^�>EJJP�B@?BVK@>P^�T��?B^�O�PGBB)�R��@K�E@?�CD�UK�TECB?BVK@�

>BK�@BCU�Q�H�0�JEZK?�AU?D0�JKZHP��BJB�EVK�D�@BCD�UK���G�EMC�@BI0

�E�?E0�V?E�O�PGBI�HECZ���@?�KJB?D@I���u��ETP0�W?E��B�P�>EME��K��UGU�

��K?�@EJ�K�B�)

R�V?E�>�@�K?@I�W?BS�>��>�G@>BS�NK��E@?K�0�?E0�JEZK?�AU?D0�W?E

>�>�I�?E�@TKNBlBVK@>�I�lE�J��ME@?KT�BBJ@?���Q�W?E�S���>?K��E�HCI

>��>�GNK�)�|E�?E�ZK�@�JEK�JEZ�E��UVB?�?D�P�Y�NB?����E?�EkK�BB

MK�J��@>BS�TCKJK�)�t�K�EVK�D�?�PH�E�T�KH@?��B?D�@KAK�>E�>�K?�E0

Page 53: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

V?E�?�>EK�}>��>�G@>BK�NK��E@?B~)�u@CB�>?E��BAPHD�@JEZK?�@lE�JP�

CB�E��?D0�?E�JEZ�E�APHK?��U@>�G�?D@I�AECKK�>E�>�K?�E)

�� ������/%!��-8�rK���0��U�@>�G�CB0�V?E�HCI�O�PGBB��KT�BKJCKJEPV�@?BK�zE@@BB���W?EJ�T�ENK@@K)��G�K@?�E�CB���J0�V?E�sK���H��HGK0

>EJJK�?B�PI�W?P�B�BNB�?B�P�qKJB�KCI0�T�IJE�G�I�BC0�V?E�AKG�PV�@�

?BI�zE@@BB�W?E?�T�ENK@@��K�EGJEZK�\�p?E�EHB��JEJK�?)����?E�E�

�ET�E@0�>�>�AU�����G�B?BK�?KJU0�>E?E�P^�G�?�E�PC��|�?KCC��Q��U

ME�E�B?K��H���T�ENK�?����@KCK�BI)�|��VKJ�E@�E���U���kB�T�EM�E�

GU\�n�JK�I�H�PMBK�H���UK�E�?EJ0�>�>E��T�BJK��E�T�ENK�?���@KCK�BI

8I��K�ME�E�^�E�TECB?BVK@>BS�>�PM�S:��U@>�GU��K?@I�G��>�>P^�E�BK��

?�NB^�8I�GHK@D��K�ME�E�^�E�?E��T��?BB0�>E?E�P^��U���G��CB:)�|��VKJ

E@�E���U���kB�@CE��\

��,� ��.�S,���8�y�@>�G�C0�V?E�I�BJK^����BHP�uHB�P^�>EJJP�B@�?BVK@>P^�T��?B^)�p?E�KHB�@?�K���I�T��?BI��|P�H�0�KLK�}=��?BI

CEGU~�Q��E��I�T��?BI0�?ECD>E�V?E�@EGH����I0��E�W?E��K@K�DKG�E)

�� ������/%!��-8�[U��K�E?�K?BCB����JE���?E�E���ET�E@0�MHK�I�ME�E��BC�E�?EJ0�V?E�G�I�BC�sK���H��HGK�EA�PV�@?BB�zE@@BB)

��,� ��.�S,���8�sK���H��HGK�J�EME�VKME�G�I�CIC)�]��MC����ME@P�

H��@?��0�B�KJP�T�BSEHB?@I�HKC�?D�>�>BK�?E�?�>?BVK@>BK�P@?PT>B0��E

W?B�?�>?BVK@>BK�P@?PT>B�Q�V�@?D�AECDkE��@?��?KMBB0���W?��@?��?KMBI��

��NBE��CD�US�B�?K�K@�S�O�PGBB0�V?EAU�O�PGBI�@E@?EIC�@D�>�>�ME@P�

H��@?�E)�uHB�@?�K��U��k��@�HCI�W?EME�Q�@?�?D�V�@?D^�K��ETK�@>EME

@EEALK@?��0�B�B@?E�BVK@>B�O�PGBI��@KMH��@?�KJBC�@D�>�u��ETK)

F�@EZ�CK�B^0�W?E��K��@KMH����SEHBCE�E?>CB>�@E�@?E�E�U�u��E�

TU0��E�@K�V�@�P���@�K@?D�k��@�B0�TE�JEKJP0�W?E?�k��@��B>?E��K�PTP@�

?B?)

MU! ��!����R���#8�[�E@�E��EJ0��@K�HB@>P@@BB�AUCB��E>�PM�T�BKJ�CKJE@?B�T�KHCEZK��EME�=�>?�)�F�>�I�TE�BJ�^0�W?E?�=�>?�I�CIK?@I

EH�BJ�BG����B��?E����G�KkK�BI�T�EACKJU)�{HK@D�JU��@?�KV�KJ�ET�

�KHKCK��U��TEHSEH�>���@@JE?�K�B^�H���E��T�EACKJU)���J�K�SE?K�

CE@D�AU�G��?D0�@EMC�@�U�CB��U�@�?KJ0�>�>�lE�JPCB�PK?@I���W?EJ�HE>P�

Page 54: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

JK�?K��AS�G@>�I�T�EACKJ���>C^VK�EK��KkK�BK�W?E��T�EACKJU�HECZ�

�E�ETB��?D@I����PHE�CK?�E�K�BK�?�KAE���B��RAS�GBB����TECPVK�BK

TECB?BVK@>BS�TEC�EJEVB�����KMBE�K�8K@?K@?�K��E0����IHP�@��EG����

LK�BKJ�B���GJKLK�BKJ�AKZK�NK�:)�p?E�JEZK?��KJ�EZ>E���@?E�E�

ZB?D�M�PGB�@>EK�HKJEM��lBVK@>EK�AECDkB�@?�E)

=�EACKJ��lE�JPCB�PK?@I�>�>�AU���H�PS�V�@?IS��TECB?BVK@>EK

T�BG���BK�RAS�GBB�?K@�E�P�IGU��K?@I�@�T�ENK@@EJ��EG���LK�BI�AK�

ZK�NK��BG�O�PGBB)�y�CIK?@I�CB�W?E�>C^VK�UJ��KkK�BKJ�T�EACKJU\

�������!"�#�-8�]H�BJ�BG�>C^VK�US)

MU! ��!����R���#8�=�E@?E�J�K�AUCE�B�?K�K@�E)�=E?EJP�V?E���E@�E��P��KkK�BI�T�EACKJU�RAS�GBB�E�B��GICB��E?�W?P�lE�JPCB�E�>P)

��������%�"�8�y�HPJ�^0�V?E0�JEZK?�AU?D0�JU�W?E?��ET�E@�TE?EJEA@PHBJ0�TE?EJP�V?E�E��EVK�D���Z�U�)

�������!"�#�-8�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E�EVK�D�AECDkE���ET�E@�B�JU��K

PCEZBJ@I��E���KJK�B)�y�T�KHC�M�^�W?E?��ET�E@�EA@PHB?D�TEGZK0��

@K�V�@�G�>E�VB?D�@�EB���@@PZHK�BI�TE�TE�EHP�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B0

>E?E�EME�JU��K�G��KJ)

�� �%!���R�S���8�y�SE?KC��AU�E?�K?B?D�����KT�IJE���ET�E@�|��?KCCU)�]���@T�E@BC�0�HPJ�KJ�CB�JU�E�?EJ0�V?E��C�@?D���O�PGBB�JEZK?

@JK�B?D@I0�?)K)���HKKJ@I�CB�JU����?E0�V?E��C�@?D���O�PGBB�@JK�B?@I)

y�T�E@?E�SEVP�@>�G�?D0�V?E��K�?E�V?E���HKKJ@I0���W?E�KHB�@?�K���I

��k����HKZH�)�|E�I�@EMC�@���@�rK���EJ0�V?E0����K��EK0�KLK�HECME��

O�PGBB�>��C�@?B��K�T�BHP?�@BCU�@�H�PMBJ��K>?E�EJ�E�BK�?�NBB)

|E�I�SE?KC��@>�G�?D�B�E�H�PMEJ)�]HB��BG�>C^VK�US��ET�E@E��HCI

JK�I�Q�W?E��ET�E@0�TEVKJP�W?B�@?���U�Q�B�T�BG����UK0�B��KT�BG����

�UK0�ME@PH��@?���BCB�ME@PH��@?�K��UK�EA��GE���BI�Q�HECZ�U�EAwK�

HB�B?D@I\�YE�K@?D0�V?E�HECZ�E�@?�?D�JE?B�EJ�HCI�EAwKHB�K�BI0�>�E�

JK�?EME0�V?E���J��@KJ��KEASEHBJ��@?�ABCD�E@?D�B�JU��@K�SE?BJ�JB��

�EME�@EZB?KCD@?��\�p?E��KHD�JEZ�E�>�>�?E��KkB?D�B�AKG�?EME0�V?EAU

ZB?D���EH�EJ�ME@PH��@?�K)�tU��@K�JEZKJ�T�E@?E�TK�K@?�?D�@?�KCI?D

H�PM���H�PM�0�B����W?EJ�>E�KN��@K��W?E��T�EACKJK)�=E?EJP�V?E0�@����

Page 55: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�B��I�@�u��ETK�@>BJ�XE^GEJ0�JU��K�HECZ�U�G�AU��?D0�B�I�SEVP�@KAK

B��@KJ���J���TEJ�B?D0�V?E�u��ETK�@>B��XE^G�@lE�JB�E��C@I�>�>

>E�KV�U��W?�T���G�B?BI�@E?�PH�BVK@?���TE��KAECDkBJ��ET�E@�J0

>E?E�EK���V�CE@D�PZK�TE@CK�[?E�E��JB�E�E���E��U0��E�B�HE�?EME0

>E�KV�E0�?EZK�AUCE)�YE0�V?E�@>�G�C�rK����T�E�|RY]�Q�W?E�EH�E0���I

SEVP�@>E�NK�?�B�E��?D@I����H�PMEJ)�Y�J�@EGH�CE@D�XEEALK@?�E�PMCI

B�@?�CB�Q�?E�K@?D�W?E�AUC��EH���EVK�D�>E�>�K?��I�T�EACKJ�?B>�0�BCB

EHB��ABG�K@�TC��)�xUC��ET�E@0�AUC��T�EACKJ��Q�B�W?B�@?���U�EAwK�

HB�BCB@D��E>�PM�H���E��T�EACKJU)

=EW?EJP�?E0�E�VKJ�ME�E�BC��R�H��E�TEV?E�E��BCB�?���@TE�?�E��

BCB0���T�BJK�0�?KCKlE��E�>EJJP�B>�NBE��E��@�IGB0�BJKK?�@JU@C)

YE�K@?D�GHK@D�EVK�D�J�EME�J�CK�D>BS�ABG�K@�TC��E�0�>E?E�UK�JEZ�E

E@PLK@?�B?D�@KMEH�I0�G��?��0���@CKHP^LKJ�MEHP�BCB���?KVK�BK�H�PS

CK?)�]H�E�Q�W?E�W>E�EJBVK@>�I�@lK��0�>E?E��I�EVK�D���Z��)�R��?E�EK

Q�W?E�TECB?BVK@>BK�@H�BMB0�>E?E�UK�JEMP?���V�?D@I�����kBS�@?���

��S)���I��A@EC^?�E�@EMC�@���@�x�?�CEJ0�>EMH��E��ME�E�BC�E��KT���B�

?KCD@?�K��US�E�M��BG�NBIS)�|��JE���GMCIH0���TECB?BVK@>E��@lK�K

K@?D�?�B��ET�E@�0�>E?E�UK���kB�@?���U0���kB�EA��GE���BI�JEMP?

�Kk�?D�PZK�@KMEH�I)���W?B��KkK�BI�@�JB�@EAE��JEMP?��K@?B�>�@?��

ABCD�EJP�HKJE>��?BVK@>EJP�F��>�GP0�>E?E�U��G��?��0�JEZK?�AU?D0�B

EAwKHB�B?@I)

[E�TK��US0�W?E�JK@?�EK�@�JEPT���CK�BK0�>E?E�EJP��BV?E��K�JK�

k�K?)�p?E��K�lKHK��CBGJ0��K�>E�lKHK��CBGJ0�W?E��K�EALKK�ME@PH���

@?�E0�W?E�T�E@?E�@KC�0�ME�EH�0����E�U0�>E?E�UK�HECZ�U���G�B��?D@I

B�@EHK�@?�E��?D�HKJE>��?BVK@>EJP���G�B?B^��@K��@?���U)�YE�K@?D

W?E��K�AECDk�I�TECB?B>�0�W?E��KV?E�H�PMEK0�K@CB�JU0�W?B�@?���U0�G��

AE?BJ@I�E�@�EBS�ME@PH��@?��S)�[E��?E�US0�W?E��KT���B?KCD@?�K��UK

E�M��BG�NBB0�?E�K@?D�M��ZH��@>EK�EALK@?�E0�E�>E?E�EJ�ME�E�BC�x��

?�C0�B�TEW?EJP�I�AECDkK�EA�W?EJ��K�APHP�ME�E�B?D)�����?�K?DBS0�W?E

@�EAEH��@CE��0�BCB�@�EAEH�UK�J�@@�JKHB�0�>E?E�UK�?EZK��K�HECZ�U

G��B@K?D�E?�?EME0�>�>BK�APHP?�E?�EkK�BI�P���@�@��AS�G�JB�BCB�P����

JI��@��GK�A��HZ��N�JB)�qCI�W?EME��K�?�KAPK?@I��B�EALKME�ME@PH���

@?��0��B�>�>BS��BAPHD�T�>?E�)�YE�K@?D�JU��@K�HECZ�U�HEME�E�B?D@I0

>�>�@>�G�C�rK���0�E�T���BC�S�BM�U0�>�>BS�?E�SE�EkBS0�HKJE>��?B�

VK@>BS�T���BC�S�BM�U)�|E�TEVKJP�W?EME��K�T�EB@SEHB?���W>E�EJB>K\

tU�T�BSEHBJ�>�T�EACKJK�>P�BNU�B�I�N�)�YE�K@?D�K@CB�JU�ME�E�BJ�E

Page 56: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

@�EAEH�E��W>E�EJBVK@>E��GE�K0�?E�W?E�@�EAEH�EK�TK�KH�BZK�BK�C^�

HK�0�K@CB�ME�E�BJ�E���G�B?BB�EALKME�?���@TE�?��Q���B��BCB�ZKCKG�

�EHE�EZ�EME0�?E�W?E�PZK0�@�JE�@EAE�0�T�KHTEC�M�K?�@?�ABCBG�NB^0

TE?EJP�V?E�W?E�HECZ�E�AU?D�AKG�PM�EGU�ZBG�B�B�?)H)�|��K��EK0���W?EJ

�@I�T�EACKJ�0�V?E�JU�HECZ�U�BGA��?D�?KJU0��K�@�IG���UK�@�TK�KH�B�

ZK�BKJ�C^HK�0�TE?EJP�V?E�W?E�PZK�E?�E@B?@I�>�?E��MC���E��NKCB0

>E?E��I���GU��K?@I��A@EC^?�E��@?�ABCD�E@?D^�B��A@EC^?�E��AKGE�

T�@�E@?D^)�tEZ�E�G�?�E�P?D�H�PMBK��ET�E@U�Q���T�BJK�0�?P�ZK�TE�

V?E�P^�@�IGD�BCB�>EJJP�B>�NBB0�>E?E�UK�JK�DkK�>�@�^?@I�VKCE�K�

VK@>BS�TK�KH�BZK�B�0���AECDkK�H�BZK�BI�?E���E��B�B�lE�J�NBB)

[@��W?E���>E�KV�EJ�B?EMK�G��B@B?�E?�TECB?BVK@>E���ECB���kBS�ME@P�

H��@?��B�TECB?B>E�0� >E?E�UK�HECZ�U�T�B�?B�>� @EMC�@B^�TE� W?BJ

�ET�E@�J�B�HEME�E�B?D@I�E�@EAC^HK�BB�?KS�EAKL��B�0�>E?E�UK�E�B

H�^?������G�US�>E�lK�K�NBIS�B��@?�KV�S)

=E�TE�EHP��ET�E@��M����rKHK��S�)�y�P�K�K��0�V?E���kB��AS�G@�

>BK�>ECCKMB�KJP�E?�K?I?��y��K�HPJ�^0�V?E�O�PGBI�?�>�@?��B?��ET�E@�

�EG���LK�BK���@BCD@?�K��E�TK�KJKLK��US�CBN�Q�B@>C^V�K?�CB�E�E

BCB�EACKMV�K?�T�BG���BK0��CD?K���?B���CB�W?E�BCB�T���CCKCD�EK�H�B�

ZK�BK�>�T�BG���B^\�Y�>EME�I���O�PGBB��B>EMH���K�@CUk�C�0�TEW?EJP

I��K�HPJ�^0�V?E�HCI�O�PGBB�W?E�>C^V�>��KkK�B^��ET�E@��E�T�BG���

�BB�BCB��KT�BG���BB)

�������!"�#�-8�rK�����@K�?�>B�KLK���G��K��PC�JK�I�>�T�EACKJK�B��

?K�K@E�)�nZ�>ECB�JU�ME�E�BJ�E�=�>?K�@?�ABCD�E@?B0�EA�EALK>��>�G�

@>E��B�?KM��NBB0�JU��@K���KJI��EG���L�KJ@I�>��ET�E@P�Q�@PLK@?�P�

^?�CB�EALK>��>�G@>BK�NK��E@?B)�[�T�B�NBTK0�EALK>��>�G@>BK�NK��

�E@?B0�>E�KV�E0�B@@CKHE��CB@D0��E�I��K�G��^�8JEZK?�AU?D0�>?E�?E�BG

��@�G��K?:�?�>BS�>EHBlBNB�E����US�NK��E@?K�0�EALBS�NK��E@?K����

F��>�GK0� >E?E�UK�AUCB�AU�T�BKJCKJU�HCI� �@KS����EHE��F��>�G�)

tEZK?�AU?D0�E�B�K@?D0��E0��E��@I>EJ�@CPV�K0�E�B��K�BGPVK�U)�YKJ

AECKK��K�BGPVK�U�EALK>��>�G@>BK�B�?K�K@U0�?E�K@?D��K�BGPVK�E�V?E�

CBAE0�V?E�JEMCE�AU�T�KH@?��CI?D�B�?K�K@�HCI��@KS�T�KH@?��B?KCK�

F��>�G�)

R��E?�V?E�>�@�K?@I�l�>?E���zE@@BB0�I�G�H���C��ET�E@0�TEVKJP��KVD

BHK?�E�XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK0����K�E�zE@@BB\�u��ET��B�?P?�>�>�AU�G�AU���

K?�MKEM��lBVK@>EK�TECEZK�BK��[�TE@CKH�KK���KJI�@CEZBC�@D�?�>�I

Page 57: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

?K�HK�NBI�B����P�E��K��KT���B?KCD@?�K��US�E�M��BG�NB��Q�O�PGBI0

R�JK�BI0�RGK�A��HZ���B�XK�K��U��F��>�G)�F�>�?E���=I?BME�@>K�I

@T�E@BC�P�T�KH@?��B?KCK��q�?@>EME�@E�K?��TE�AKZK�N�J��}R�V?E0�XK�

�K��U��F��>�G�T�E�EGMC�@BC�@KAI��KG��B@BJE���K@TPACB>E�\~�=EVK�

JP��K�@JE?�K?D�T���HK���CBNE\�p?E�zE@@BI0�K@CB�ME�E�B?D�>�>�K@?D0�?E

K@?D�l�>?BVK@>B)����EG�B>�K?�T�EACKJ�)

|E�I�SE?KC�@T�E@B?D���@0�rK���0�>�>��A@EC^?�E�TE�IHEV�EME�VK�

CE�K>��B��A@EC^?�E�P�K�K�0�V?E��U�J�K�VK@?�E�E?�K?B?K)�[U�ME�E�B�

?K0�V?E�=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B�JEZK?�AU?D�@>E�KK�^Z�E>��>�G@>BJ0�TE�

?EJP�V?E�O�PGBI��K�T�BKJCK?�PV�@?BI�zE@@BB)�y�TE�BJ�^�EG�AEVK��

�E@?D)�y�@T��kB��^��>�>��U�HPJ�K?K0�TECEZ���P>P����@K�HNK�Q�K@CB

�@K�?�>B��>C^VBJ�XK�K��U��F��>�G���=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B�B0���GPJK�

K?@I0�zE@@BI�APHK?��>C^VK�����W?B�T�ENK@@U0�>�>��U�HPJ�K?K0�P�>EME

BG����EHE��F��>�G��AECDkK�k��@E��HEME�E�B?D@I�@�zE@@BK�0�V?EAU

>E�?�ECB�E��?D� W?P� @?�ABCD�E@?D� Q� P�O�PGBB0�R�JK�BB0�RAS�GBB0

]@K?BB0�P�>EME\�y��K�SEVP�@K�V�@��EG���L�?D���@�>�B@?E�BVK@>EJP

T�EkCEJP)�|E�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E��U�G�I�?�>�AECKG�K��E�ET�@�K?K@D

?EME0�V?E���@CPV�K�PV�@?BI�zE@@BB�O�PGBI�APHK?�BJK?D�JK�DkK0�VKJ

>?E�CBAE)�y�ET�@�^@D0�V?E���EAE�E?)�=E?EJP�V?E��@KMH��AU��CE�?�>0

V?E�T�EACKJU�zE@@BB����F��>�GK��Kk�CB@D�@�TEJELD^�O�PGBB)���I

HPJ�^0�V?E��U�@K�V�@�>�>�AU�E�KV>E��T�B>B�PCB@D��JEC0�O�PGBI�AE�

B?@I�zE@@BB0����E?��AS�GU�@K�V�@�@>�ZP?��}|K?0�BS�?EZK��>C^VBJ~)

�?E�KLK�T�KH@?��CIK?@I�J�K�ET�@�UJ���W?E��@B?P�NBB)�=EVKJP

=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B�HCI�JK�I��KT�BKJCKJ0�>EMH��ME�E�B?@I�?ECD>E�E

^MK�F��>�G�\�n��AS�GE��KHB�@?�K���I�TEHHK�Z>����TC��K�T@BSECEMB�

VK@>EJ0�HPSE��EJ0�W>E�EJBVK@>EJ0��EK��EJ�B�C^AEJ�H�PMEJ�Q�W?E

�EH@?�K��UK����EHU0�>E?E�UK�T�EZB��^?����XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK0� �

G��VB?0���zE@@BB)��@>C^V�?D�W?P�V�@?D�BG�=�>?��@?�ABCD�E@?B����F���

>�GK0�I�HPJ�^0��K�K�CD�E0�TE?EJP�V?E0�TE�>����K��JK�K0�RAS�GBI��B�

>EMH���K�APHK?�@KAI�VP�@?�E��?D�P�K�K��E����W?EJ�^Z�E>��>�G@>EJ

E?�KG>K0���>E?E�EJ��U�B@>C^V�K?K�B�?K�K@U�XK�K��EME�F��>�G�)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�y�C^AC^�B�V�@?E�PTE?�KACI^�?K�@CE��0�>E�?E�UK��@TEJ�BC�RAK@�CEJ�Q�B�}>��GB~0�B�}T@K�HE~)�[�?�>E��@B?P�NBB

V�@?E�AU��KJ�B�JU)�y�@K�V�@��U@?PT�^�>�>�>��GBT�KH@KH�?KCD�>���

GBT��?BB0�TECPM��ZH��B��T@K�HEME@PH��@?��)�qPJ�^0�V?E�W?B�ET�K�

Page 58: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

HKCK�BI��A@EC^?�E�?EV�E�ETB@U��^?�?P�@B?P�NB^0�?P�@�KHP0���>E?E�

�E��JU���SEHBJ@I)

y�E?�KVP�VK@?�E�G��@�JEME�@KAI)�u@CB�O�PGBI�TEH�BJK?��P>B�B

@>�ZK?0�V?E�JU�l��MJK�?���EK�ME@PH��@?�E0�V?E�JU�T�B�U>CB�ZB?D

TEH�TE>�E�B?KCD@?�EJ�H�PMBS�@?����Q�TEH�TE>�E�B?KCD@?�EJ�YKMK�

����0�tE@>�U0�X?�JAPC��B�?)H)0�V?E�JU�PTP@?BCB��EGJEZ�E@?D�@E�

GH��BI��KG��B@BJEME�ME@PH��@?��0��KG��B@BJEME�HKJE>��?BVK@>EME

EALK@?���Q�HK@I?D�CK?�>�>�?E�@?���CB@D0�B���EHK�AU��BVKME��K��Uk�

CE)))�u@CB�M�PGB�@>EK��P>E�EH@?�E�B�M�PGB�@>B�����EH�T�BG��^?

?�>EK�TE��ZK�BK0�B��E?�Q�W?E�I�E?�KV�^���J�B�x�?�CP�Q�HETP@?BJ0

O�PGBI�T�B�BJ�K?�?�>EK�T��MJ�?BVK@>EK��KkK�BK��O�PGBI��EG����

L�K?@I����EH�P^�EAB?KCD�Q���CE�E�zE@@BB0�?EMH���A@EC^?�E�T���

x�?�C0�>EMH����TEJB��K?���J�EA�B@?E�BB)�YEMH�0�K@?K@?�K��E0�BK����

SBVK@>�I�?�B�H��Q�tE@>��0�YABCB@B0�XPSPJB�Q�APHK?��E@@?��E�CK�

��)�[�?�>E��@B?P�NBB0�>EMH��O�PGBI��K�JEZK?�T�BJB�B?D@I�@�HKGB��

?KM��NBK��?EME�ME@PH��@?��0�>E?E�EK0�SE?D�B����APJ�MK0��E�@PLK@?�P�

K?0�B�RAS�GBI0�B��Z��I�]@K?BI�VB@CI?@I�G��O�PGBK��8K@CB�M�PGB�U

T�B�BJ�^?� ?�>EK� �KkK�BK:0� B�RAS�GBI� ��E�D� @?��E�B?@I� V�@?D^

O�PGBB0���@�J��O�PGBI�B0�TE@�KH@?�EJ�O�PGBB0�B�RAS�GBI�Q�EAK�@?��

�E�I?@I�V�@?D^�zE@@BB)))�y�SEVP���HKI?D@I0�V?E�M�PGB�@>B�����EH

�K� TEJK�IK?� E�BK�?�NB^� Q� �� TK��P^� EVK�KHD0� HKJE>��?BVK@>BK

@?�P>?P�U���O�PGBB0�>E?E�UK��K�EVK�D�@BCD�U0��E�?KJ��K�JK�KK�TE>�

PHK�ZB��^?�O�PGB^�E?�?�>E��E�BK�?�NBB)))�n���@0�P���kKME��P>E�

�EH@?��0�E�BK�?�NBI�?�>�I��@K�K�E�G�T�H��I)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�@K�K�E�

G�T�H��I�E�BK�?�NBI�@KAI�B@VK�T�C�)�p?E��E�BK�?�NBK��?E����XK�

�K�0�?E����{�T�H�M�PGB�@>EK�T���B?KCD@?�E0�M�PGB�@>EK��P>E�EH@?�E

>�>�?E�@ES���BCE�@KAI���>E�NK�H��HN�?EME��K>�0�B��EEALK�@ES���IK?

@KAI)�|�k�tEB@K��Q�sK���H��HGK�Q�PZK�T���B?�AECDkK�?�BHN�?B

CK?0��E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�KME��EGJEZ�E@?B�B@VK�T��U)�]���K�HE?I�K?0�I

��HK^@D0�HE�@E�E>��CK?�T���CK�BI)

Y�>�V?E0�I���HK^@D0�V?E�O�PGBI�KLK�TE@?���K?@I��U�?B�BG�W?EME

G�J>�P?EME�>�PM��B�@EGH�?D�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�EALK@?�E)�|E0�@�H�PME�

@?E�E�U0�P�JK�I��K?�E@EAUS���HKZH����?E0�V?E�E���@JEZK?��KkB?D�W?P

T�EACKJP)�u@CB�E����K�@JEZK?��KkB?D�W?P�T�EACKJP0�?E�?EMH��E��0

>E�KV�E0� �E�HK?��� @ME�E�� @�zE@@BK�0� �� �E@@B�@>BK��K���kB@?@>BK

��@?�EK�BI��U�K�EVK�BH�U)�zE@@BI��KHK?�HE�ECD�E�P@TKk�P^��K����

Page 59: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

kB@?@>P^�>��>�G@>P^�TECB?B>P)�p?E�@>�GU��K?@I�B����XK�K��EJ�F���

>�GK0�B����RGK�A��HZ��K0�B��EEALK�TE��@KJP�}^Z�EJP�TK�BJK?�P~)

�����n>��B�K�P�zE@@BB�HE@?�?EV�E�JEL��I�B�P@TKk��I��K���kB@?@�

>�I�TECB?B>�)�y���HK^@D0�V?E��AS�G�J�E?�W?EME�APHK?��K�CKMVK0�TE?EJP

V?E�O�PGBB���?E?�CB?���E��zE@@BB0�>E�KV�E0�H�HP?��EGJEZ�E@?D�>E��

?�ECB�E��?D�RAS�GB^�H�CK>E��K�HKJE>��?BVK@>BJB�JK?EH�JB)

y�HPJ�^0�V?E���kB�@E�JK@?�UK�HK�@?�BI�8T���H�0�I�J�CE���HK�

^@D����W?E:�JEMCB�AU�@TE@EA@?�E��?D�?EJP0�VKJP�AECKK�BCB�JK�KK

T�BCBV�EK�EALK@?�E���O�PGBB�@�JE�TE�@KAK�APHK?�@TE@EA@?�E��?D�Q

@EGH��B^�T�BCBV�EME�HKJE>��?BVK@>EME�EALK@?���B� ��RAS�GBB0�B

��EAE�E?)�p?B��ET�E@U�@�IG��U�H�PM�@�H�PMEJ)�|K�?ECD>E�O�PGBI�E>��

GU��K?@I��K@TE@EA�E���KkB?D�@�EB�MC���UK�T�EACKJU�AKG�P�KMPCB�

�E���BI�@B?P�NBB�@�RAS�GBK��8I�@K�V�@�ME�E�^��K�E�?K��B?E�B�CD�

�E��NKCE@?�E@?B0���SE?D�E�>�>EJ�?E�T�BKJCKJEJ�P�KMPCB�E���BB:0

�E0�HPJ�^0�V?E�B���H�RAS�GBK�0�>�>�H�JE>CE��JKV0��B@B?�PM�EG��@E

@?E�E�U�O�PGBB)�tEZK?0�AU?D0�B�EMH��W?E�T@K�HEPM�EG�0�JBl0��E�?��

>�I�T�EACKJ�����@�JEJ�HKCK�@PLK@?�PK?)���J�K�>�ZK?@I0�K@CB�ME�E�

�B?D�VK@?�E0�T�EACKJ��?K��B?E�B�CD�E��NKCE@?�E@?B�HCI�TEH��CI^�

LKME�AECDkB�@?���AECKK�BCB�JK�KK���NBE��CD�E�HKJE>��?BVK@>BS

T�B�CK>�?KCD�US�TECB?BVK@>BS�EALK@?�K��US�M�PTT���O�PGBB�TE>�

KLK0� >� @V�@?D^0��K� I�CIK?@I�?KJ�KHB�@?�K��UJ�T���JK?�EJ0�BG�G�

>E?E�EME�E�B�ME?E�U�AUCB�AU�E?>�G�?D@I�E?�@�EAEHU0�E?��KG��B@BJE�

@?B�B�E?�TK�@TK>?B�U�HE@?E��E��ZBG�B)

uLK��K@>ECD>E�@CE��E�=�>?K�@?�ABCD�E@?B)�y�?EZK�@>KT?BVK@>B

E?�EkP@D�>��EGJEZ�E@?B�@PLK@?�E���BI�KHB�EME�F��>�G�)�=�EACKJ�

��JI�����F��>�GK�Q�W?E�T�EACKJ�0�B�T�EACKJ��BHK�?BV�E@?B�R�JK�

�BB0���@>ECD>E�E�B�@KAI�@VB?�^?�>��>�GN�JB�Q�W?E�?EZK�@K�DKG��I

T�EACKJ�)�O�PGB�U�B�@K�K�E>��>�GNU�HE@?�?EV�E�E?CBV�^?@I�H�PM

E?�H�PM�0�K@?D�J�EME�EALKME0��E�J�EME���G�US�E�BK�?B�E�)�p?E��E

J�EMEJ���GHKCIK?�B���@�@���JB�Q�O�PGB^�B�RAS�GB^0�M�PGB��B��AS��

GE�)�|E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�W?��E?>�U?�I�>�BM��JEZK?

H�?D�>�>BK�?E�>E�>�K?�UK��KGPCD?�?U)�tU��K���AE?�CB�HCI�@KAI0�HCI

��@�TE��AE?�CB�K��ETK�NU)�u@?K@?�K��E0�E�B��K�JEMP?�H�?D�B@VK��

TU��^LKME�E?�K?�����AECKG�K��UK��ET�E@U0�B�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�JU

HECZ�U��>C VB?D@I�����AE?P���H�W?BJ�HE>PJK�?EJ��t�K�>�ZK?@I0

V?E�JU�HECZ�U�PVK@?D��@K�T�KHC�M�KJUK����B��?U)�xPHK?�CB�W?E�KHB�

Page 60: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�U��F��>�G�BCB�H�P@?E�E��KK�P�KMPCB�E���BK�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BS�BCB

��JI�E��GK�A��HZ��@>BS�T�EACKJ�Q�?�J�APHK?��BH�E)

��,� ��.�S,���8�y�EVK�D�>E�E?>E�E?�KVP�����ET�E@�E�T�EACKJK?K��B?E�B�CD�E��NKCE@?�E@?B�HCI���NBE��CD�E�E�BK�?B�E����US

C^HK�)�y�W?E�JEMP��U��GB?D�@CE��JB�RHK��PW����}rPVkK0�V?EAU�V�@?D

@?���U�AUC��@�EAEH�E�0�VKJ��@I�@?�����AUC��AU��K@�EAEH�E�0��E

KHB�E�~)�Y�>�V?E�CPVkK�TE@?�EB?D�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�EALK@?�E����?E�

?K��B?E�BB0�>E?E�P^�@K�V�@�>E�?�ECB�PK?���kK�T���B?KCD@?�E0�VKJ�

|�@VK?�XK�K��EME�F��>�G�)�[E?���W?EJ�I�B��BZP�@�JP^�AECDkP^

ET�@�E@?D)�u@CB���C�HI?@I�E?�EkK�BI�JKZHP�O�PGBK��B�zE@@BK��B

O�PGBI��K��K?@I�>�?E��B@?E�BVK@>E���ECB0�>�>�I�AUC��P��KK���HK�I?�

��HN�?EJ��K>K0�?E�W?E��@��APHK?��E���KH�M�PGB�@>BJ���NBE��CD�UJ

B�?K�K@�J)�tU��K�@JEZKJ�TE@?�EB?D���NBE��CD�EK�ME@PH��@?�E0�>�>0

@>�ZKJ0���YP�NBB�BCB�R�@?�BB)�tU��K�JEZKJ�TE@?�EB?D�M��ZH��@�

>EK�EALK@?�E0�@�EAEH�U���U�E>0�HKJE>��?B^�B�T���E�EK�ME@PH���

@?�E�����kBS�@EA@?�K��US��KMBE��S0�B��A@EC^?�E��K�K�CD�E0�V?EAU

JU�W?E�KLK�B�W>@TE�?B�E��CB�>PH��?E)�tU��K�JEZKJ����K@?B�TE�I�

HE>���@EA@?�K��EJ�ME@PH��@?�K0���>�>�JU�JEZKJ�W?E�HKC�?D����XK�K��

�EJ�F��>�GK\

�������!"�#�-8��?EAU�@ES���B?D�HE@?EB�@?�E0�JU�HECZ�U�E?>�G�?D�@I�E?��EH@?�K��US����EHE�0�V?E�CB\

��,� ��.�S,���8�zE@@BB0����K��EK0�APHK?��UMEH�E0�K@CB�O�PGBITEJEZK?�V?E�?E�?�J��KMPCB�E��?D����XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK)�|E��UMEH�E

CB�W?E�HCI�O�PGBB�Q�E?�CK>�?D@I�E?�@EA@?�K��US���NBE��CD�US�B�?K�

�K@E�\�R���NBE��CD�U��B�?K�K@��EJK��EHB��HCI�O�PGBB�Q�W?E�TE@?�

�EB?D�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�EALK@?�E���O�PGBB)

Page 61: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

T.����MU���� �-2������V�����S,���

���h�k�������h)���������M� ��W ����

mBCE@El�tK��A�t�J��H�k�BCB0���GJUkCII�E�M�PGB�@>E���KG��

�B@BJE@?B0�V�@?E�NB?B�E��C��U@>�GU���BK�t�S�?JU�O��HB�E�G��VK�

�BB��KG��B@BJE@?B�HCI���HBB)�F�>�E?JKV�C�O��HB0�E��@EG��K?0�V?E

TE@CK�EA�K?K�BI��KG��B@BJE@?B�JK@?E�T�E@�KLK��EME�A�B?��@>EME

A^�E>��?��G��JK?�>E��PJTB�E����U��B�HB��>B��A^�E>��?c��E�AKG

�KG��B@BJE@?B�B�HB�NU��B>EMH���K�PG��^?0�>?E�E�B����@�JEJ�HKCK�B

VKME�@?EI?).

[E���KJK����@TCK@>����NBE��CD�EME�H�BZK�BI���O�PGBB�JU�TE�

V?B��K�HPJ�CB�E�M�IHPLKJ�M�PGB�@>EJ�A^�E>��?K0���G��VB?0��K���G�

JUkCICB�E��K�CD�E���KG��B@BJE@?B0�E�?EJ0�V?E��K�CD��I��KG��B@B�

JE@?D�Q�W?E��K�@>��HB�E���BK�CEGP�ME��B�TE�?E�K�BK�NB?�?�BG�M�P�

GB�@>E��TEWGBB0����KV?E�AECKK�T�EG�BVK@>EK�Q�ME@PH��@?�K��U��A H�

ZK?0�T�EACKJU�@�W�K�MK?B>E�0�G�TPLK��EK�@KCD@>EK�SEGI�@?�E�B�?)H)0

B� ?)T)�|E� W?E�B��K�CD��I��KG��B@BJE@?D� >�ZHEME� M��ZH��B��0� AKG

EZBH��BI�JBCE@?B�@E�@?E�E�U�ETK>�^LKME�KME�ME@PH��@?��)�=I?��H�

N�?D�CK?���G�H�C^HK�0���GJUkCI^LBS�EA�W?BS�T�EACKJ�S0�AUCE�>����

�K�J�CE�Q���TPACBV�EJ�T�E@?���@?�K0�G�SCK@?�P?EJ�B�TK�KTEC�K��

�EJ��KElE�JB�kBJB@I�ZKC��BIJB�B��K��?B>PCB�E����UJB�EZBH��

�BIJB0�BS�MECE@�AUC�TEV?B��K@CUkK�)

�K�KG�.4�CK?�TEI�BCE@D�EM�EJ�EK�>ECBVK@?�E�C^HK�0�>E?E�UK�?KJ

?ECD>E�B�G��BJ�^?@I0�V?E���GJUkCI^?�EA�W?BS�T�EACKJ�S0�B�BJK��E

��TPACBV�EJ�T�E@?���@?�K0��E����TP?B�>�BS��KkK�B^�JU��K�T�EH�B�

�PCB@D��B����TIHD)�tU0�EMCIHU��I@D0��BHBJ�CBkD��PB�U�BCB0��U���

Z�I@D�lECD>CE��UJ�IGU>EJ0�ME�U�?�PTE��B�JE�K�>�E�B)�qPJ�KJ0���

T�E?IZK�BB���kK���KHECME���KG��B@BJE@?B�J�EMBK�BG���@�?�>�B��K

TE�ICB0�>?E�JU����@�JEJ�HKCK�B�VKME�JU�@?EBJ)

����K>0�@�KHB�J�EMBS��K?��HBNBE��US�I�CK�B�0�AUC�E?JKVK��B

@?�KJB?KCD�UJ��E@?EJ���NBE��CD�EME�@�JE@EG���BI)�u@CB�@����B?D

@E��KJK��P^��P@@>E�VKVK�@>P^��E��P�@��P@@>E�>��>�G@>BJB��E����

JB�����@?ECK?BI0���TE@CKH�KJ�@CPV�K�JU��K�EA���PZBJ�8�����V�CD�

Page 62: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�EJ�W?�TK:�T�K@CE�P?EME����NBE��CD�EME�l�>?E���0���EAE�E?�Q�����

NBE��CD�U��l�>?E����EG�B>�BJK��E��@CKH@?�BK�W?BS��E��)

|PZ�E�PVK@?D�B�?E0�V?E�?)�)����NBE��CD�EK�ME@PH��@?�E��Q�@����

�B?KCD�E��E�EK�I�CK�BK0��K�BJK^LKK��BVKME�EALKME�@�?��HBNBE��

�UJB�lKEH�CD�UJB�N��@?��JB�B�>�IZK@?��JB)�|�NBE��CD��I�BHK��

?BV�E@?D���P?�B�lKEH�CD�E��>PCD?P�U�E@EG��K?@I�VK�KG��KCBMBEG�

�P^�B�IGU>E�P^�EAL�E@?D)�[�W?EJ�KK�T�B�NBTB�CD�EK�E?CBVBK�E?

G�T�H�EME���NBE��CD�EME� ME@PH��@?��0� E@�E�U��^LKME@I����BHKK

@P�K�K��E@?B���NBB�B�@P�K�K��EME�M��ZH��B��)

RAS�G@>�I�BHK�?BV�E@?D�PZK�@PLK@?�PK?0�B��K�BJKK?��B>�>EME

G��VK�BI0�>EMH��E����EG�B>C�)�[�O�PGBB�W?EME�TE�BJ�?D��K�SE?I?0�SE?I

JU��K�P�K�K�U0�V?E�TE�BJ��BK�@PLK@?�PK?�B���@�JE��RAS�GBB)�qKCE

��?EJ0�V?E���NBE��CD��I�BHK�?BV�E@?D��K�G��B@B?�E?��B@?E�BVK@>EME

��MPJK�?��0� ?)K)�E?�?EME0�>?E����DkK�TE@?�EBC�@�EB���NBE��CD�UK

T�JI?�B>B)��JK��E��B@?E�BVK@>B����MPJK�?��G�@?��CIK?�M�PGB��ME�

�E�B?D0�V?E���U�Kk�BK��AS�GU��G�@KCBCB�RAS�GB^��������������)

8BCB�V?E��AS�GU�Q�W?E��K��AS�GU:0����AS�GE��Q�B@>�?D�@CKHU�@�EKME

TK�J��K�?�EME�?�J�T�B@P?@?�BI�@�HEB@?E�BVK@>BS���KJK�)

{HK@D��EG�B>�K?�EVK�D�B�?K�K@�U��T���HE>@���B@?E�BVK@>B�����

MPJK�?���K�?ECD>E���GEAL�K?��AS�GE��B�M�PGB�0��E�EH�E��KJK��E�B

�T�B�IGU��K?��BS�H�PM�>�H�PMP0�@?��I����EHB��B�?E?�ZK�P�E�K�D�@�JE�

@EG���BI)���M�PGB�U0�B��AS�GU�EHB��>E�E�HE�K�I^?��B@?E�BVK@>EJP

��MPJK�?P�0��K�I?���KME�NK��E@?�EK�G��VK�BK0�E?CBV�I@D�H�PM�E?�H�P�

M��CBkD���EH�EJ��HCI�M�PGB��RAS�GBI�Q�B@?E�BVK@>�I�T�E�B�NBI�O�P�

GBB0���HCI��AS�GE��Q��KG��B@BJ�I�E?�B@?E�BVK@>E��O�PGBB���NBE��CD�

�E�ME@PH��@?�K���I�KHB�BN�0�?E�B�HKCE����T�E?IZK�BB�@�EK��B@?E�

�BB�?K�I�k�I��KG��B@BJE@?D�BG�G��M�PGB�@>BS�BJTK�@>BS��JABNB�)

��@?E�BVK@>B����MPJK�?���K�?ECD>E�HKC�K?�W?E?�@TE��AK@>E�KV�

�UJ0��E�P�EHB?�KME���HKA�B�B@?E�BB0���HKA�B�B@?E�BB�Q�W?E�PZK�JB�

lECEMBI�B�JBlE?�E�VK@?�E)�[EG�B>�^?��AS�G@>BK�JBlU�B�JBlU�M�P�

GB�@>BK)�qCI�M�PGB����K@PLK@?�P^L�I��RAS�GBI�Q��KV?E���EHK��J��

CK�D>E��zE@@BB�0�>E?E��I�SEVK?�E?�I?D�P�O�PGBB��KG��B@BJE@?Dc�HCI

�AS�GE��ZK�O�PGBI�Q��J�C�I�BJTK�BI�0�TU?�^L�I@I�E?�I?D�P��KG��B�

@BJE��RAS�GBB�B��KG��B@BJE@?D0�B���NBE��CD�P^�BHK�?BV�E@?D)�|E0

TEG�ECD?K0�@T�E@B?K��U0����KHD�M�PGB�U�B��K�@>�U��^?�@�E^�JKV?P�Q

C^AUJ�@TE@EAEJ��K��P?D�RAS�GB^���CE�E�KHB�E��B��KHKCBJE��O�P�

Page 63: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

GBB\�R�@�H�PME��@?E�E�U0�B��AS�GU��K�@>�U��^?�@�EBS0�JIM>E��U���

Z�I@D0�@BJT�?B��>�zE@@BB\�F�>EK�ZK�GHK@D�JBlE?�E�VK@?�E0���G�B�P

?KS0�B�H�PMBS�@�EB��KGE�U�B��K@EJUK���MPJK�?U\

|E�JBl�Q�W?E��KHD��K�T�E@?E�CEZD�B��KT���H�0�JBl�BJKK?�EM�EJ�

�P^�EAwI@�B?KCD�P^�@BCP0�?�>�>�>��U@?��B��K?�NKCE@?�P^�>��?B�P

JB��0��K�HETP@>�^LP^��B>�>E��H�PME��?EV>B�G�K�BI)�[�W?EJ�JB�K

�AS�GU�?ECD>E��TI?�I�>ECE�����B��BVKME�AECDkK0���M�PGB�U�Q��M�K@�

@E�U�B�AECDkK��BVKME��tBl�Q�W?E�>EMH��PZK��@K�I@�E�B��K��PZ�E

�B>�>BS�H�CD�K�kBS�EAwI@�K�B�)

R�H�K��qJB?�BK�BV�X�S��E�0� ET�KHKCII�O�PGB^�>�>� �J�CP^

BJTK�B^�0�BJKC����BHP0���TK��P^�EVK�KHD0�KK�?K��B?E�B�CD�P^���G�

�EkK�@?�E@?D�B�MK?K�EMK��E@?D0��K�>�@�I@D�T�B�W?EJ�BHKECEMBVK@>E�

ME��ET�E@�)�|E�K@CB�JEZ�E�ME�E�B?D�E�O�PGBB�>�>�EA�BJTK�BB0�?E

TK��U��T�BG��>�BJTK�BB�Q�W?E���CBVBK�BJTK�@>E��BHKECEMBB)�[�H���

�EJ�@CPV�K���CBNE�BHKECEMBI���VB@?EJ��BHK�Q�BHKECEMBI��K@E@?EI��

kK�@I�BJTK�BB)

[�VKJ�ZK�G�>C V�K?@I�W?��BHKECEMBI0�B�TEVKJP�JU�ETB@U��KJ�O�P�

GB^�>�>��K@E@?EI�kP^@I�BJTK�B^\�|�V�KJ�@E��?E�EME��ET�E@�)��J�

TK�BI�G�T�H�EME�EA��GN��TEH��GPJK��K?�VK?>EK���GHKCK�BK��PT���CI�

^LBS��B��PT���CIKJUS�)�Y�>0�JK?�ETECB^�T�KH@?��CI^?�?K0�>?E�PT�

���CIK?�B��C�HKK?�?KS�B>E��@�JEPT���CK�BI0���>ECE�BI0���EAE�E?�Q

W?E�?E0�V?E�PT���CIK?@I�BG��K0�TE@>ECD>P�ZB?KCB�>ECE�BB��K��C�HK^?

?KS�B>E��@�JEPT���CK�BI)�p?��JU@CD�@E�K�kK��E�I@�E�B��KH�P@JU@�

CK��E�AUC���U@>�G����CE�HEJ�x�CDlP�EJ���.5.-�M)���T�C�?K�EALB�0�MHK

E���U@?PT�C�@�HE>C�HEJ�}]�@E@?EI�BB�BJTK�@>BS�HKC���uMBT?K~)�,

X�W?E��?EV>B�G�K�BI0�zE@@B�@>�I�BJTK�BI�Q�W?E�BJTK�BI�@E�K��

kK��E�H�PMEME�TE�IH>�0�?�>�>�>����K��@�@�JEME���V�C����NBE��CD�EK

B�BJTK�@>EK��@?PTBCB����K��G�KkBJU��>E�lCB>?0�>E?E�U��HCB?@I

TE�@K��HK�D)�F�>����T�BVB�P�H���EME�T�E?B�E�KVBI�JEZ�E�P>�G�?D

����JAB��CK�?�U��S���>?K��TK?�E�@>BS��KlE�J0����IHP�@�JEHK��B�

G�NBK��zE@@BB�PT�EVB�kBS��A@EC^?�P^�JE���SB^)�X�G�T�H�E��?EV�

>B�G�K�BI0���zE@@B�@>E��BJTK�BB��K�AUCE�@�JEPT���CI^LK�@I�JK?�

�ETECBB�B�PT���CIKJUS�>ECE�B��Q�PT���CIKJUJB�AUCB��@K��B�ME��

HU���E@@0�B�PM�^JU��lB��0�B�H�PM�@?KTK��>�CJU>)

Y�>�I���GEALK��E@?D�JKZHP�ME@PH��@?�K��E���C�@?D^�B�EALK�

@?�EJ�?�KAE��C��>EJTK�@�NBB�8��T@BSE���CB?BVK@>EJ�@JU@CK:)�[U�

Page 64: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

SEH�AUC����HK����BGEA�K?K�BB��B?E�B>B�ZK�?�K��E@?B���P@@>B�����

�EH��K�JK�DkK�@?��H�K?�E?��A@EC^?B@?@>E���C�@?B�8�0�JEZK?0�H�ZK

AECDkK:0�VKJ�PM�K?�KJUK�BJTK�@>BK����EHU)�[�����K>K0��E���KJK��

>EJJP�B@?BVK@>EME��KZBJ�0�W?E��B?E�B>��T�K?K�TKC��ET�KHKCK��P^

JEHBlB>�NB^���P@@>B�����EH��K�JK�DkK�E@?�CD�US����EHE��TE@?�

��H�C�E?�AECDkK�B>E�)�F����BJ��U��ZK�BKJ�H���E���B?E�B>B�AUCE

G�I�CK�BK�xE�B@��uCDNB���8KLK�T�B�ME�A�VK�@>EJ�T���CK�BB:0�V?E

zE@@BI�Q�>�>�EH���BG�@E^G�US��K@TPACB>�Q�?EZK�JEZK?�8TE�>E�@?B?P�

NBB:��U�?B�BG�XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�JEZ�E�G�>C^VB?D0�V?E�ME@PH��@?�K���I��C�@?D��

zE@@BB��@KMH���E@T�B�BJ�C�@D�>�>��VPZ�I��C�@?D��BCB��C�@?D��VP�

ZBS��8}zEJ��E�U�Q��KJNU~0�}AECDkK�B>B�Q�K��KB~:0�TEW?EJP��P@�

@>B�����EH��K��K@K?��B>�>E��E?�K?@?�K��E@?B�G��W?P��C�@?D0��B�E���

?U��@KMH��H�PMBK)

[�M�PGB�@>E��>PCD?P�K��K?�PH�E�G�JK?B?D�E?MECE@>B�?E��ZK��B�

?E�B>B��JU��K��K@KJ��B>�>E��E?�K?@?�K��E@?B� G����@BCD@?�K��EK

TK�K@KCK�BK��AS�GE��JP@PCDJ�����YP�NB^��������)�Q�?�>E���AUC�

BJTK�@>�I�TECB?B>�c�JU��K��K@KJ��B>�>E��E?�K?@?�K��E@?B�G��?E0

V?E�xK�BI�HKC�C���RAS�GBB�Q�M�PGB�@>�I�B�?KCCBMK�NBI��K�JK�DkK

TE@?��H�C��E?�xK�BB���37�EJ)�|E�>?E�?EMH���K@K?�E?�K?@?�K��E@?D�G�

>���?KCD�UK�JK�U�T�E?B���E@@?��kBS��AS�GE��B�E@K?B��T�B�>��?>E�

M�PGB�@>E���KG��B@BJE@?B\�FE�KV�E�ZK0�JK�DkK�B>B�Q�E?��BS�JU

TE@?��H�CB�KLK�AECDkK0�VKJ��AS�GU�B�E@K?B�U��JK@?K��GI?UK��BJK��

�E�TE��B�K�JK�DkK�B>E��JU�TE?K�ICB��KG��B@BJE@?D)�=�EHECZ�I��

?EJ�ZK�HPSK0�JEZ�E�G�>C^VB?D0�V?E�����G�IGU���BB��KH���BS�E@K�

?B�@>BS�B��AS�G@>BS�>E�lCB>?E��TE�B��U0�@EE?�K?@?�K��E0��KZBJU

O�J@�SP�HBI�B�sK���H��HGK)

�JTK�B�CBGJ�M�PGB�@>E��BHKECEMBB�EA���PZB��K?@I���T@K��

HECBAK��CD�US��U@>�GU���BIS�?BT��}�����@�CKZB?�AECDkK�E?�K?�

@?�K��E@?B~0�}E?���@�AECDkK�?�KAPK?@I~)�[E��@KJ�W?EJ�AECDkK��J��

CEBJTK�@>EME�kE�B�BGJ��0�VKJ���EHBEG�EJ�P?�K�ZHK�BB0�V?E��A�

S�GE���K�@PLK@?�PK?���T�B�EHK)�|��@�JEJ�HKCK��B?E�B>��ZK�?�K��

�E@?B�E>�GU��K?@I�EAE�E?�E��@?E�E�E��T@K�HECBAK��CD�EME�@E�

@?��H��BI�>��J�CUJ�@BJ�)��JK��E�GHK@D�@>�U��K?@I��K@E@?EI?KCD�

�E@?D�B��BLK?��M�PGB�@>E��BHKECEMBB����AK@>E�KV�EJ�@�JEPJBCK�

�BB�B��U@?��CK�BB�@KAI�ZK�?�E����Kk�BS�HKJE�BVK@>BS�@BC���

Page 65: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

lE�K��K@TE@EA�E@?B�PT���CI?D�@EAE�0��K�ME�E�I�PZK�EA�PT���CK�

�BB�H�PMBJB)

O�PGBI����H���EJ�W?�TK�T�E��CBC��W>G�JK������KG��B@BJE@?D0

�K��UHK�Z�C��B@TU?��BK��KG��B@BJE@?D^�TE�EH�E��T�E@?E��T�B�

VB�K��EALK@?�E��K�@JEMCE�E@EG��?D0�V?E��E�EK��KG��B@BJEK�ME@P�

H��@?�E0��E��I�ME@PH��@?�K���I��C�@?D�Q�W?E�KME�ME@PH��@?�E0�W?E

KME��C�@?D0����K�VDI��BAPHD�KLK)�YEV�E�?�>�ZK��K�AUCE�E@EG���E0�V?E

K@CB��Z��I�]@K?BI�B�RAS�GBI�Q�@E@?���UK�V�@?B�KHB�E��B��KHKCB�

JE��O�PGBB0�?E��AS�GU�B�E@K?B�U�Q�W?E���kB�M��ZH��K�Q��K�VDB�

�BAPHD�VPZBK)�XVB?�I�BS�B@TEC�B?KCIJB�8H�ZK�AK@@EG��?KCD�UJB:

VPZBS�8VB?�����E@@B�@>BS:�>EG�K�0�JU�T��>?BVK@>B��U?K@�BCB��A�

S�GE��B�E@K?B��BG�T�E@?���@?�����kK��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B���@lK�K

��kKME�ZK�JUkCK�BI)

|E�TEVKJP�?EMH��@�J��JU@CD0�V?E�RAS�GBI�JEZK?��U�?B�BG�@E@?��

���O�PGBB0��UGU��K?�?�>EK�B@@?PTCK�BK�@�KHB�AECDkK��V�@?B���kKME

EALK@?��\�=E?EJP�V?E0�SE?I�JU�PZK�H���E��K���@@J�?�B��CB��AS�GE�

>�>�@E@?���P^�V�@?D���kKME�EALK@?���8�T�EVKJ0�>�ZK?@I0�?�>EK�ELP�

LK�BK�AUCE��G�BJ�UJ:�Q��E�?K��B?E�BI�RAS�GBB���@EG���BB�}T�E�

@?EME�M�PGB�����@KMH��E@?���C�@D�B@>E��E�M�PGB�@>E��GKJCK�)�]VK�D

@�EKEA��G��I�@B?P�NBI��?K��B?E�BI�Q���k�0����?B?PCD�U������EH�Q

VPZE�0�K@CB��K�@>�G�?D����ZHKA�U�)

RAS�G@>B��PVK�U��])�|)�q�JK�BI�HE�ECD�E�PH�V�E�PCE�BC�H���

�EK�T�E?B�E�KVBK��}XP?D�W?EME�T�E?B�E�KVBI�@E@?EB?���@CKHP^LKJ�

�AS�GU�TE�@�JE@EG���B^�M�PGB�@>E��@?E�E�U�Q�W?E�E?HKCD�U�����EH

B��K�I�CI^?@I�V�@?D^�M�PGB�@>EME�W?�E@�0��E�RAS�GBI�8?K��B?E�BI:�Q

W?E�V�@?D�O�PGBB)�O�PGB�@>�I� @?E�E����U�PZHK���T�BG����?D0� V?E

�AS�GU�Q��AE�BMK�U����W?E��?K��B?E�BB0��E�@�J��?K��B?E�BI�Q�M�P�

GB�@>�I�~3 �[BHBJE0�H���EK�T�E?B�E�KVBK����CEMBV�E��H�E��EJP

B@?E�BVK@>EJP�@?�?P@P��RAS�GBB���P?�B�M�PGB�@>E��B��AS�G@>E��>PCD�

?P�)�tEZ�E�@>�G�?D0�V?E���>�>EJ�?E�@JU@CK��@PLK@?�P^?��H�K�RAS��

GBB�Q�RAS�GBI�>�>��V�@?D��O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBI�>�>�@�JE@?EI?KCD�EK

NKCEK)�YE?�ZK�])�|)�q�JK�BI�E?JKV�K?��}�[�TE�BJ��BB�lK�EJK��

�RAS�GBI��B���AS�GU��@PLK@?�P^?�H�K�TECI��UK�>E�NKTNBB��]H�B

TE�BJ�^?�RAS�GB^�>�>�V�@?D�O�PGBB0�H�PMBK�ZK�TE�BJ�^?�KK�>�>

@�JE@?EI?KCD�EK�W?�E>PCD?P��EK�BCB�>PCD?P��E�B@?E�BVK@>EK�EA���

GE���BK)�=�B�W?EJ�I�SE?KC�AU�@>�G�?D0�V?E�B�?K0�B�H�PMBK0�K@CB��GI?D0

Page 66: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

@>�ZKJ0�P�E�K�D���P>B0���EALKJ0�@@UC�^?@I����EH�B�B�?K�ZK�B@?EV�

�B>B)))�m�>?BVK@>B�J�?K�B�C�EHB��B�?E?�ZK)�n�RAS�GBB��K�JEZK?�AU?D

H�PS�B@?E�B�)�]H���B@?E�BI0�EH����K�CD�E@?D)�q�PS�B�AECKK��K�CD�E�

@?K���K�AU��K?��B�P�M�PGB�0��B�P��AS�GE�)�zK�CD�E@?D�EH���B�?��ZK~)9

�JK��E���H���E��?EV>K�B��EG�B>�K?�T�EACKJ���AS�G@>E��BHK�?BV�E�

@?B�Q�>�>BJ�EA��GEJ�JEZ�E��E@@?��E�B?D��BG��V�CD�EK�KHB�@?�E��B

T�KEHECK?D��KZKC�?KCD�P^���GH�EK��E@?D\�RAS�G@>B��PVK�U��TU�

?�K?@I�T�KEHECK?D�W?E�T�E?B�E�KVBK�@�TEJELD^���@kB�K�BI�>E�?K>�

@?�0���EHI�B�RAS�GB^0�B�O�PGB^���AECKK�kB�E>EK0�EALK>��>�G@>EK

NKCEK��}�RAS�GBI�B���@�JEJ�HKCK�I�CIK?@I�V�@?D^�>�>E��?E�H�PME�0

AECKK�>�PT�E��EAL�E@?B0��E��K�O�PGBB�Q���EALK>��>�G@>EME�@ENBE�

>PCD?P��EME�T�E@?���@?��)�[T�EVKJ0�?�>E^�ZK�V�@?D^�W?EME�T�E@?����

@?���I�CIK?@I�B�@�J��O�PGBI)))����AS�GU0�B�M�PGB�U�BHK�?BlBNB�P^?

@KAI�>�>����@EA@?�K��E�W?�BVK@>EJ�P�E��K0�?�>�B����P�E��K�EALK>���

>�G@>E��@ENBE>PCD?P��E��EAL�E@?B��|E��AS�GU��B>EMH���K�E@EG���

��CB�@KAI�VK�KG�M�PGB�@>P^�@ENBE>PCD?P��P^�EAL�E@?D~)4

{HK@D��EG�B>�K?��K�JK�KK�@CEZ�U���ET�E@��V?E�?�>EK�>��>�G@>�I

BHK�?BV�E@?D\�FEMH��JU�ME�E�BJ0���T�BJK�0�EA�K��ETK�@>E��BCB�E

G�T�H�E��BHK�?BV�E@?B0�AECKK�BCB�JK�KK�TE�I?�E0�V?E���H���EJ�@CP�

V�K�TEH��GPJK��K?@I�>�>EK�?E�T�E@?���@?�E�EALBS�NK��E@?K�0�EALBK

T�KH@?��CK�BI�E�T����S�VKCE�K>�0�AECKK�BCB�JK�KK�MEJEMK��EK�W>E�

�EJBVK@>EK�B�T���E�EK�T�E@?���@?�E0�JEZ�E�ME�E�B?D�EA�EALBS�>PCD�

?P��US�NK��E@?IS�B�?)H)0�B�?)T)�X�W?E��?EV>B�G�K�BI0�>��>�G@>�I�BHK��

?BV�E@?D�Q�TE�I?BK�HE�ECD�E�T�EACKJ�?BV�EK�B���@TCU�V�?EK)�u@CB

W?E�EG��V�K?�KHB�EK�>PCD?P��EK�T�E@?���@?�E0��PZ�E��UVCK�B?D�>��

>P^�?E�B����B��?�P^�>PCD?P��P^�JEHKCD�HCI�?�>BS�lK�EJK�E�0�>�>

��JI�@>�I�>PCD?P��0�XK�K��U��F��>�G0�]@K?BI0�RGK�A��HZ���B�?)H)

]A�KHB�EJ�T���E�EJ�BCB�W>E�EJBVK@>EJ�T�E@?���@?�K0�TE�JEKJP0

ME�E�B?D�KLK����E0��K�ME�E�I�PZK�EA�EALBS�CBAK��CD�US�NK��E@?IS)

u@CB�>��>�G@>�I�BHK�?BV�E@?D�TEH��GPJK��K?�W?�BVK@>P^�BCB�IGU�

>E�P^�EAL�E@?D0�?E�GHK@D�HKC��EA@?EI?�KLK�@CEZ�KK)�uHB�@?�K��U�

T�BG��>��K>E?E�EME�KHB�@?���Q�W?E�>ECE�B�CD�EK�T�EkCEK���P?�B

zE@@B�@>E��BJTK�BB�B���P?�B�XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�F��>�G�>�>�@ENB�CD�E�>PCD?P��U��lK�EJK��BJK�

K?�ET�KHKCK��U��B@?E�BVK@>B��>E�?K>@?)�]���EG�B>�����V�CK������K>�

>�>�>E�NKT?�BJTK�@>EME�JUkCK�BI)�F��>�G�Q�W?E�?E0�V?E�PT���CIK?@I0

Page 67: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

��zE@@BI�Q�W?E�?E0�V?E�PT���CIK?)�YECD>E���?�>EJ�>E�?K>@?K�JEZ�E��K�

T�E?B�E�KVB�E�ME�E�B?D�E�>��>�G@>E��BHK�?BV�E@?B)�|E�?EMH��E>�ZK?�

@I0�V?E�O�PGBI�E?�^HD��K�BHK�?BlBNB�E��C��@KAI����EALK>��>�G@>EJ

P�E��K0���T�E?B��Q���@E@?��K��E@@B�@>E��BJTK�BB�O�PGBI��>?B��E�AE�

�EC�@D�T�E?B��>��>�G@>BS� ME�NK�0�BHK�?BlBNB�PI�@KAI� @�zE@@BK�)

�JK��E�GHK@D�AK�K?���V�CE�M�PGB�@>�I�BJTK�@>�I�BHKECEMBI)

u@CB�TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�XK�K��EJP�F��>�GP��E@@B�@>�I�TECB?B>�

AUC��?BTBV�E�>ECE�BG�?E�@>E�0�?E�@�O�PGBK��HKC��EA@?EI?�TE@CEZ�

�KK)�[E�TK��US0����ElBNB�CD�EJ�IGU>K��@KMH��TEHVK�>B��CE@D0�V?E

O�PGBI�HEA�E�ECD�E����PVBC��@KAI��KHB�E�K��E��zE@@BB0�@T�@�I@D

?KJ�@�JUJ�E?�JP@PCDJ��@>EME�TE��AELK�BI)�[E��?E�US0�O�PGBI�8>�>

[E@?EV��I0�?�>�B�{�T�H��I:�AUC��T�B@EKHB�K���>�zE@@BB�>�>�N���

@?�E0��E@@B�@>B��BJTK��?E��T�B�IC�?B?PC��N��I�M�PGB�@>EME�0����

YBlCB@�AUC���T���CK��N��@>B����JK@?�B>)�Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�@?�?P@

�SEZHK�BI�>��>�G@>BS����EHE�����E@@B�@>P^�BJTK�B^�AUC��KEHB�

��>E�0�E?@^H��T�B�BCKMB�E����E@?D�EH�BS�B��KT�B�BCKMB�E����E@?D

H�PMBS�B�T�B�@E�K?@>EJ��KZBJK)

�HK�?BV�E@?D�Q�I�CK�BK�B@?E�BVK@>EK0�E�E�JK�IK?@I�E?�WTESB�>

WTESK)�[����������)�TE�z)o)�O�PGBI�E@EG����C��@KAI���@B�E���JI�@>EJ

>E�?K>@?K0�����VB��I�@��o��)�E���PZK�V�@?D��BG��?B�@>EME�JB��)�q��

�BH�X?�EB?KCD�8���������):0�@EGH���I�@�E^�BJTK�B^0�EMCIHU��C@I���

�BG��?B�@>B��EA��GKN)�[�������������)�JEZ�E�ME�E�B?D�E�?�EI>E�

BHK�?BV�E@?B)�p?E0��E�TK��US0�EVK�D�@BCD��I�T���E@C����I�BHK�?BV�

�E@?D�8E?@^H��B�?IM��>�KHB�E�K��E��zE@@BB:0�AECKK�@C�A�I�EALKS�B�

@?B��@>�I�BHK�?BV�E@?D� 8E?@^H�� G�T�H�UK�JB@@BB�|)���PA�>BHWK

8��A�S�:�B�X)�X)�]�AKCB��B0���@T�E@?���K�BK�>�?ECBVK@?�����O�P�

GBB:0�KLK�AECKK�@C�A�I���E@?EV��I��BHK�?BV�E@?D)��JK��E�@�J�I�@BCD�

��I�BHK�?BV�E@?D�8T���E@C����I:�B�T�KHET�KHKCBC��M�PGB�@>E��E@�

@B�@>BK�E?�EkK�BI)

|��@E��KJK��EJ�W?�TK�@PLK@?�PK?�PZK�NKC�I��K�K�BN��BHK�?BV�

�E@?K���>PCD?P��E�IGU>E��I�8E���@�J�I�@BCD��I0�?�>�>�>�M�PGB�U0��

E@�E��EJ0�T�B��HCKZ�?�>�?�KJ��K�EB@TE�KH��BIJ�Q�T���E@C���EJP0

JP@PCDJ��@>EJP�B��BJ@>E�>�?ECBVK@>EJP0�SE?I�@PLK@?�P^?�HE�ECD�

�E�@BCD�UK�EALB�U�A�T?B@?E�0�@�BHK?KCK���KME�U�B�J�EZK@?�E�H�P�

MBS:0�G�T�H��I0�T���E@C���E���NBE��CB@?BVK@>�I�B�>��>�G@>�I�8@��

J�I�@C�A�I:)

Page 68: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

tKZHP�W?BJB�@�JEBHK�?BlB>�NBIJB�@PLK@?�P^?�MK?K�EMK��UK

E?�EkK�BI����T�BJK�0�>PCD?P��E�IGU>E��I�BHK�?BV�E@?D��>C^V�K?

��@KAI��@K�E@?�CD�UK�@�JEBHK�?BlB>�NBB0�G�T�H��I�B�T���E@C����I

BCB�HETEC�I^?0�BCB�E?�BN�^?�H�PM�H�PM�0���>��>�G@>�I�JEZK?�@CP�

ZB?D�T�BH�?>EJ�>E��@KJ�?�KJ)�u@CB�JU���@@JE?�BJ�BS�TE�@CKHP^�

LBJ�T�BG��>�J��MCPAB��EKiTE�K�S�E@?�EK0��>?P�CD�EKi�K�>?P�CD�EK0

MCEA�CD�EKiCE>�CD�EK0�?E�TECPVBJ�@CKHP^LP^�>��?B�P��>PCD?P��E�

IGU>E��I�BHK�?BV�E@?D�Q�MCPAB���I0��>?P�CD��I0�MCEA�CD��I�8?)K)�JE�

ZK?���GHKCI?D@I�B�T���E@C���UJB0�B�JP@PCDJ���JB�B�?)H):c�G�T�H��I

Q�TE�K�S�E@?��I0��>?P�CD��I0�MCEA�CD��Ic�T���E@C����I�Q�MCPAB���I0

�>?P�CD��I0�CE>�CD��Ic�>��>�G@>�I�Q�TE�K�S�E@?��I0��K�>?P�CD��I0

MCEA�CD��I)

�?E�?�>EK�>��>�G@>�I�BHK�?BV�E@?D�HCI��@E��KJK��EME�@�KH�KME

M�PGB���\�]VK�D�M�PAE�Q�W?E�C��Hk�l?0��S���>?K���8ME�HE@?D0��EB��

@?�K��E@?D0�P��ZK�BK�>�@?��kBJ�B�?)H)0�B�?)T):0���?�ETECEMBVK@>B�

?BT�8�CBNE�>��>�G@>E����NBE��CD�E@?B�:�Q�?)K)�?�B�B�CD�U����AE�

TE�K�S�E@?�US�T�BG��>E�0�>E?E�U���B>KJ��K�E?�BN�K?@I)�=E�])�|)

q�JK�BI0�HCI��AS�G@>E��>PCD?P�U�EALK>��>�G@>B��>E�?K>@?�B�>���

>�G@>�I�BHK�?BV�E@?D�Q��KLD�E?�^HD��K�?�B�B�CD��I)�[�E?CBVBK�E?

@E��KJK��E��O�PGBB0�H���P^�BHK�?BV�E@?D����AS�G@>EJ�>E�?K>@?K

JEZ�E�>��CBlBNB�E��?D�>�>�MCPAB��P^0��>?P�CD�P^�B�MCEA�CD�P^)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�K@CB�B@SEHB?D�BG�T�B�I?US���JB�>�B?K�BK�0��K�

�EGJEZ�E����?B��B�EH�P�BHK�?BV�E@?D0���>E�?K>@?K�>E?E�E��O�PGBI�B

RAS�GBI�@ET�B>�@�CB@D�AU����MCPAB��EJ0��>?P�CD�EJ�B�MCEA�CD�EJ

P�E��IS)�xECKK�?EME0�HPJ�K?@I0�TE�K�S�E@?�UK�TK�K@KVK�BI�@�?KVK�B�

KJ���KJK�B�?EZK�APHP?�@?B��?D@I)�uHB�@?�K��EK0�V?E�TE>��KLK�@�IGU�

��K?��AS�GE��B�M�PGB��Q�W?E�BJK��E�?E0�V?E�BS���GHKCIK?�Q�?K��B?E�BI)

X��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U0�GHK@D��@K�I@�E�Q�W?E�B@>E���I�?K��B?E�BI

�AS�GE�0�B�P��BS��K?��B>�>EME�H�PMEME�E?KVK@?��0���M�PGB�U�Q�ME@?B

8W?E���CPVkKJ�@CPV�K:)�O�PGB�@>�I�@?E�E����K�@EMC�@���?ECD>E���EH�

�EJ�Q�M�PGB�U��K�ME@?B0�RAS�GBI�Q�EALKK�E?KVK@?�E��AS�GE��B�M�PGB�)

|�J�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�M�PGB�@>�I�@?E�E���HECZ�����HB>�CD�E�TK�KE@JU@�

CB?D�lK�EJK���RAS�GBB�>�>�?K��B?E�BB�)�|BZK�JU�TETU?�KJ@I�BG�

CEZB?D�@�E�����B��?�?�>EME�TK�KE@JU@CK�BI)

|�k�B@SEH�U��?KGB@�Q��K�B@?E�BVK@>B�0���lBCE@El@>B�0�BCB0

K@CB�SE?B?K0�>PCD?P�ECEMBVK@>B�)�RAS�GBI�B�W?�BVK@>BK��AS�GU0�@

Page 69: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

H���E�� ?EV>B� G�K�BI�Q� W?E� ?K0� >?E�@EGH�C�EALKM�PGB�@>P^�ME@P�

H��@?�K��E@?D0�E�B�AUCB�����V�CK�B���V�CEJ�EALKM�PGB�@>E��ME@P�

H��@?�K��E@?B��rKE�����Q�AUC�B��AS�G@>BJ�N��KJ0�B�N��KJ�{�T�H�E�

O�PGBB)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0���JEJK�?�>E�lCB>?��8BCB��E��U:�RAS�GBI�HCI

O�PGBB���SEHBC�@D��K����TECB?BVK@>E�0� �����B@?E�BVK@>E��>��?K)

[@?PTBCB�JKZHP�@EAE����>E�lCB>?�B�@?�CB��EK��?D�>��?��B@?E�BVK@�

>�I�B�>��?��TECB?BVK@>�I)�O�PGBI�@�TEJELD^��E��U�TETU?�C�@D��K��

�P?D�@�E^�@EA@?�K��P^�B@?E�B^0�>E?E��I���?E?�JEJK�?��@I��PkC��

���?K��B?E�B^�RAS�GBB)�|E��AS�GE��?�J�PZK��K�AUCE0�AUCB��VPZBK�)

]?@^H���E��I�JBlECEMBI��}YK��AS�GU�AUCB�M�PGB��JB0���W?B���AS��

GU��Q��K��AS�GU0�TE?EJP�V?E��K�M�PGB�U~)

qCI�O�PGBB�RAS�GBI�E>�G�C�@D�?E��J�?>E�0�E?>PH��E����UkC��B

>PH���KEASEHBJE�AUCE��K��P?D@I0���?E��E?�BJP?�)�]VK�D���Z�E0�V?E

?EMH�0�>�>�B�@K�V�@0�M�PGB�U�RAS�GB^��E@T�B�BJ�CB�?ECD>E���?K�JB�

��S���EG���LK�BI�0�T�BG����I�?KJ�@�JUJ�@�E��E?�U��E?��TK��E���

V�C�)�Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0��@K�T�EB@SEHBCE�@?�EME���EAE�E?�TE�E?�EkK�

�B^�>�?KGB@P�])�|)�q�JK�BI�Q�}EHB�����EH0�EH���B@?E�BI0�EH����K�CD�

�E@?D~)�|��@�JEJ�HKCK�8K@CB�����@�JEJ�HKCK�����@�JEJ�HKCK�@PLK�

@?�PK?:�}?�J�TKCB�H�K�>C��B�?P�U�i����H�PS���GCBV�US�IGU>�S~)�8|){��

AECEN>B�:

YP?��PZ�E�@>�G�?D0�V?E��K�CD�E@?K��AU��K?�@>ECD>E�PMEH�E)�p?E

?E?�CB?��BGJ�ME�E�BC���J0�V?E��K�CD�E@?D�Q�EH��0�B@?B���EH��)�|K?

EH�E��MCEA�CD�E��B@?B�U0�K@?D�J�EZK@?�E�CE>�CD�US�B@?B�0�>E?E�

�UK�?KJ�BCB�B�UJ�@TE@EAEJ�>EJJP�BNB�P^?�8BCB��K�>EJJP�BNB�P�

^?:�H�PM�@�H�PMEJ���MCEA�CD�EJ�T�E@?���@?�K)

Y�>��E?0�@PLK@?�PK?�J�EZK@?�E�JB�E�0�J�EZK@?�E��K�CD�E@?K�0

J�EZK@?�E�O�PGB��B�RAS�GB�0��K>E?E�UK�BG��BS��E^^?�H�PM�@�H�P�

MEJ0��K>E?E�UK�G��?D��K�G��^?�H�PM�H�PM�0����K>E?E�UK���G��A�?U���

^?�@E�JK@?�UK�T�EK>?U�B�TECPV�^?� M���?U�E?� G�T�H�US�lE�HE�0

?���@lE�JB�PI�>E�lCB>?�BG��EK��E�TECB?BVK@>EME�l�>?E�����l�>�

?E��W>E�EJBVK@>B�0�TECDGU�E?�>E?E�EME0� ME�E�I�@CE��JB�tBS�BC�

xPCM�>E���Q�NKCU����ME�)

|E��K��KJ@I�>��TK��E��V�C�J�)�Y�>��E?0��TK��E��V�CE��G�SE?KCE

E?HKCB?D@I0�E?>�G�?D@I�E?��TK��E��V�CD@?���)�[�>�>EJ�?E�@JU@CK0�@

>PCD?P�ECEMBVK@>E��?EV>B�G�K�BI0�W?E�?E�ZK�@�JEK0�>�>�K@CB�O�PGBI

Page 70: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

E?HKCBC�@D�AU�E?�O�PGBB�8>�>���@�EK���KJI��U��GBC@I�t)�t�J��H�k�

�BCB:�BCB�=�P@@BI��UkC��AU�BG�OK�J��BB0�EAwKHB�K��E��KK�ZK�P@B�

CBIJB�8��@EGH��BB�EALKMK�J��@>EME�ME@PH��@?���T�P@U0�APHPVB�W?�

�BVK@>B��K�MK�J��N�JB0���A�C?�JB0�@UM��CB�MC���P^��ECD:)�[KHD0

�U��Z�I@D�lBCE@El@>B0�W?E�O�PGBI�AUC��V�@?D^�RAS�GBB0����K����

EAE�E?)�|E���V�CE��KB@?E�BV�E0�B@?E�BI��@KMH��G�AU���BK�TK��E���

V�C0�E?�U��B�E?HKCK�BK�E?��BS)��@?E�BI�Q�W?E��@KMH��B@?E�BI�E?HKCK�

�BI0�TE?K�B0�G�A�K�BI)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�RAS�GBI�G�SE?KC���U�?B�BG�O�PGBB�B���E�?B���

B@?E�B^0��E�HCI�W?EME��KEASEHBJE�AUCE�@EGH�?D�@�E^�@EA@?�K��P^

B@?E�B^0��E?HKCD�P^�B@?E�B^�0�B@?E�B^0�E?HKCD�P^�E?�O�PGBB0�B@?E�

�B^�E?HKCK�BI�E?�O�PGBB)�FEMH��������������)�O�PGBI�TETU?�C�@D��U��

?B�BG�@B�E���JI�@>E��E�>PJK�U0�E����G�AUC���@�EK�EA��LK�BK���S�B�

@?B��@?�E0��G�AUC���@�EKME�EALKME�@�R�JK�BK��T�E@�K?B?KCI�O�BME�

�BI�=��lI�@>EME�B�G��E�E�@EGH��C��B@?E�B^�@�EKME�EA��LK�BI)

FEMH��JU�ME�E�BJ0�V?E�O�PGBI�HECZ���TK�KE@JU@CB?D�>E�NKT?

�RAS�GBB�>�>�?K��B?E�BB�0�W?E�G��VB?0�V?E�E���HECZ���E?>�G�?D@I�E?

TE�BJ��BI�B@?E�BB�>�>�?K��B?E�BB0�>�>�P?ETBVK@>EME�C��Hk�l?�0

MHK�N��B?�TK��E��V�CD�EK�KHB�@?�E�8I�HPJ�^0�V?E�?EV�E�?�>�I�ZK�P?E�

TBI�Q�T�KH@?��CK�BK�E�TK��E��V�CD�EJ�>��>�G@>EJ�KHB�@?�K:)�|K�?ECD�

>E�RAS�GBI�HECZ���E?HKCB?D@I�E?�O�PGBB0��E�B�O�PGBI�HECZ���E?>��

G�?D@I�E?�@�EKME��BG��V�CD�EME��TE�BJ��BI�B@?E�BB0�P�?B�E?�?K��B�

?E�B�CD�EME�>��K��TEHSEH��B0���>E�KV�EJ�B?EMK0�E?HKCB?D@I�E?�RAS��

GBB)�|KEASEHBJE0�V?EAU�B�?E?0�B�H�PME�����EH�E@?�CB@D���KHB�K�@

@EAE�0�@E�@�EK���KG��B@BJE@?D^0�E?>�G��LB@D�E?�EA��G�����M��B�P?E�

TBVK@>BS�BHK�?BV�E@?K�)

OE?E�U�CB�JU�>�?�>EJP�TE�E�E?P�@EAU?B�\�F�>�E?JKV�K?�x)�FE�

A�SBI0�}K@CB�O�PGBI�E?>�ZK?@I�E?�?K��B?E�B�CD�E��NKCE@?�E@?B0�?E

?EMH���EG�B>�K?�T�EACKJ����RAS�GBB0�TE?EJP�V?E0�VK@?�E�ME�E�I0��E���

G���KG��B@BJE@?D���>�>E��?E�JK�K�H�C���AS�G�J��EGJEZ�E@?D�BHK�?B�

lBNB�E��?D@I�B�E@EG��?D0�V?E�E�B�SE?I?�E?HKCB?D@I)�|��@KMEH�Ik�B�

HK�D�J�K�H�ZK�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�JU��K�ME?E�U�>�?EJP0�V?E�O�PGBI�@>�ZK?�

�tU�T�BG��KJ���kP��KG��B@BJE@?D��B���@��H�PM�T�BG��^?)��?E�JU

APHKJ�HKC�?D\~6

tEZK?�AU?D0�JU�G�AKM�KJ��TK�KH0��E���J�>�ZK?@I0�V?E��EG�B>CB

@JP?�UK�T�KHTE@UC>B�>�T�BG���B^��AS�G@>E���KG��B@BJE@?B���E�

Page 71: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

TK��US0��AS�G@>B���ET�E@�TE?K�IC�AUCP^�E@?�E?P0����K>E?E�US�@CE�

IS�EALK@?����EG�B>CE�ET�KHKCK��EK�����EHPkBK�>�W?E��?KJKc��E��?E�

�US0�TEI�CI^?@I��@K�AECDkK�B�AECDkK�TPACB>�NB�0�MHK���@@J�?�B���

^?@I���G�EEA��G�UK�>EJT�EJB@@�UK����B��?U�P�KMPCB�E���BI�M�P�

GB�E��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?�0��TCE?D�HE�TEC�EME�T�BG���BI��KG��B@B�

JE@?B�RAS�GBB0�K@CB�APHP?��EG���LK�U��@K�AKZK�NUc���?�K?DBS0�T�E�

G�T�H��I�TECB?B>��O�PGBB�Q�W?E��K�T�BSE?D�E?HKCD�US�TECB?B>E�0��

T��MJ�?BV�EK� @?�KJCK�BK� �CBI?KCD�US�>�PME����kKME� EALK@?��)

r^AE�����EH�JEZK?����T�E?IZK�BB�@�EK��B@?E�BB0���G��B@BJE@?B�E?

��G�US�EA@?EI?KCD@?�0�JK�I?D�@�E^�E�BK�?�NB^0�BHK�?BV�E@?D0�>E��

?K>@?0�E?>�GU��?D@I�E?�@EA@?�K��EME�T�EkCEME�B�?)H)�O�PGBI0�>�>��

�KH�CK>EJ�T�EkCEJ�YP�NBI0�TK�KE�BK�?B�E��C�@D����AC�ME@E@?EI�

�BK�B�T�EN�K?��BK�G�T�H�EME�EA��GN�0�HCI��KK�@K�V�@���Z����K��A@?�

��>?��I�HPSE��E@?D�8>E?E��I0����HKCK0�V�@?E�EAE��VB��K?@I���@BCBKJ

TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�AECKK�@C�AUJ����EH�J:0���>E�>�K?�EK�AC�ME@E@?EI�

�BK�@�EBS�M��ZH��)

|K�BJKI�G��VB?KCD�US�T�B�EH�US��K@P�@E�0�?�>BK�@?���U0�>�>

O�PGBI0�JEMP?���@@VB?U��?D�?ECD>E����AU@?�EK�E�C�HK�BK�G�T�H�U�

JB�?KS�ECEMBIJB)�p?E�?�KAPK?�TK�KP@?�E�@?����@K��@B@?KJU�EA��GE�

���BI)�F�@EZ�CK�B^0����W?EJ�TP?B�P���@��EG�B>CB�AECDkBK�?�PH�E�

@?B)�tU�@VB?�KJ0�V?E��@K�@E��KJK��UK�T�EACKJU�O�PGBB0���VB��I�E?

TEC�E��>E��PJTB�E����E@?B��U@kBS�WkKCE�E���C�@?B0�>E�V�I���G�

��CEJ�@KCD@>EME�SEGI�@?��0�@�IG��U�@�E?@P?@?�BKJ�EA��GE���BI��E�

�EME�?BT��B��KBJK�BKJ�TECEZB?KCD�EME�ETU?��V�@?�EME�?�PH�)�X?�KJ�

CK�BK�>�EA�E�CK�B^��@����KJI�HK>C��B�PK?@I0��E����HKCK�EALK@?�E

?K�TB?�EM�EJ�UK�?�PH�E@?B���E@PLK@?�CK�BB�TK�KP@?�E�@?�����AE�

?�^LBS�TE�B�K�NBB�@ENB�CD�US�@B@?KJ�8@B@?KJU�EA��GE���BI0�>PCD�

?P��US�B�@?B?PNB�0�@KCD@>EME�SEGI�@?��0�GH���EES���K�BI0�TK�B?K��

NB���E��@B@?KJU�B�?)H):)�|KEASEHBJE���PVB?D@I��E�UJ����U>�J0��

�K� PTE��?D����E@?�?>B� @E�K?@>E�0� AECDkK��V�@?D^��KT�BMEH�E���

�E�US�P@CE�BIS0�EA��GE����E@?B)

|��W?EJ�TP?B��K�EGJEZ�E�@��GP�ZK�HEAB?D@I��@K�EGJEZ�US�P@�

TKSE�)�|E���Z�E��K�G�J>�P?D@I���@KAK�TE@CK�ET�KHKCK��US��KPH�V

8�TEC�K�K@?K@?�K��US:0�>EJTK�@B�PI��KPH�VB�ELPLK�BKJ�@EA@?�K��

�E��P�B>�CD�E@?B�B�B@>C^VB?KCD�E@?B)��JK��E�W?E�T�EB@SEHB?�@K��

V�@���O�PGBB)

Page 72: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

{�T�H�P^�E�BK�?�NB^�JU�TE�BJ�KJ�>�>�T�B�K�ZK��E@?D�@E�E�

>PT�E@?B�?�KS�E@�E�ETEC�M�^LBS�WCKJK�?E��Q�W?E�CBAK��CD�UK�NK��

�E@?B� 8?)K)� @P�K�K��E@?D�CBV�E@?B0� G�LB?��T����VKCE�K>��B�JK�D�

kB�@?��Q���NBE��CD�US0��KCBMBEG�US0�@K>@P�CD�US�B�?)H):0�HKJE>���

?BI���T�ENKHP��EJ�@JU@CK�B�@�EAEH�U���U�E>)�tU���O�PGBB�V�@?E

@?��BJ�?KCKMP�TK�KH�CEk�HD^0�>EMH��EAwI�CIKJ�MC���E����kK��NK�

CD^��@?PTCK�BK���|RY]�B�u��E@E^G0�G�AU��I0�V?E�MC���EK�Q�W?E�E@�

�EAEHB?D�V�@?�U��?�PH�B�TEHHK�Z�?D�E?HKCD�EME�VKCE�K>�)

|K��PZ�E�G�AU��?D�B�E�?EJ0�V?E��K>E?E�UK�G�T�H�UK�JKS��BGJU0

APHPVB� �BJTE�?B�E����UJB�0�BCB��E�@K�TK�K@?�^?���AE?�?D0�BCB

��VB��^?���AE?�?D���H�PMEJ��KZBJK0�T�B@TE@�ACB��I@D�>�JK@?�UJ

P@CE�BIJ)�[�TK��P^�EVK�KHD0�W?E�>�@�K?@I�HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�T�ENK�

HP��8J�EMET��?B��E@?D0��@KEALBK��UAE�U:0�>E?E�UK�TK�K�BJ�^?@I

CKMVK0�VKJ�CBAK��CD�UK�NK��E@?B0��E�B�AECDkK�TEH�K�ZK�U�W�EGBB

8EA�W?EJ��KEH�E>��?�E�TB@�C�M�PGB�@>B��TECB?ECEM�O)�|EHBI:)

Y�>0�T��C�JK�?@>BK�B�T�KGBHK�?@>BK��UAE�U���O�PGBB�T�K����

?BCB@D���TE@CKH�BK�MEHU���VB@?P^�lE�J�CD�E@?D�BG�G��?EME0�V?E�@P�

LK@?�P^L�I��C�@?D�CKM>E�J��BTPCB�PK?�BS��KGPCD?�?�JB0��K�@?K@�I�

I@D�H�ZK�l�CD@BlB>�NB�)�|E�V?E�E@EAK��E���@?E��ZB��K?�Q�W?E�TE�

��CD��I��K?K�TBJE@?D�TE�E?�EkK�B^�>��KCBMBEG�UJ�JK�DkB�@?��J0

@�KHB�>E?E�US�>EGCEJ�E?TPLK�BI�@?�CB�@�BHK?KCB��KME�U)�|�NBE�

��CD��I��K?K�TBJE@?D�T�K���?BC�@D����KCBMBEG�P^)�F�@EZ�CK�B^0

BG��@KME��UkK@>�G���EME��K>E?E�UK���kB�@EM��ZH��K�G�>C^V�^?0

V?E����DkK�AUCE�CPVkKc�EkBA>B���kKME�T���B?KCD@?���E�B�T�BTB�

@U��^?�{�T�HP�B�HKC�^?��U�EH�E�KME��?CK?�E��EJ��CBI�BB�)

rBV�E�HCI���@�{�T�H�Q�W?E��K��U@E>�I�>PCD?P��0�TK�KH�>E?E�E�

�PZ�E�@?EI?D���@?��SK�B�?�KTK?K0��E��UJ�@VK?EJ���EAE�E?�Q�W?E0��

>�>EJ�?E�@JU@CK0��M�IG�U���?�PH0�}AKG�AEZK@?��0�AKG��HES�E�K�DI~0

?�PH0�EA��LK��U����TK��P^�EVK�KHD����GKJC^0���PZK�TE?EJ�����KAE)

[UkK�JU�ME�E�BCB�E�J�EZK@?�K��K�CD�E@?K��B�B@?B�0�E�?EJ0�V?E

O�PGB��B�RAS�GB��Q�?EZK�J�EZK@?�E)�tKZHP��BJB�JEMP?�@PLK@?�E�

��?D�ET�KHKCK��EK�VB@CE�>E��KCINB�)�tU�ETB@�CB�@CPV��0�>EMH��E�B

�E^^?�H�PM�@�H�PMEJ)�[?E�E�����B��?0�BCB��?E��I��K�CD�E@?D0�>EMH�

E�B�JB��E�@E@PLK@?�P^?�Q�W?E�JU�@���JB0�GHK@D�B�?KTK�D)�R�@�EB

��@@PZHK�BI�SE?KCE@D�AU�G��K�kB?D����?EJ����B��?K0�>EMH��E�B�G��?D

�K�G��^?�H�PM�E�H�PMK)

Page 73: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

=K��EK0�V?E�@��GP�T�BSEHB?���MECE�P�Q�W?E�JU@CD�E�?KS��AS�G@>BS

B� M�PGB�@>BS�J�CDVB>�S�B�HK�EV>�S0�>E?E�UK��EHBCB@D�PZK�TE@CK

>E�lCB>?�)��J0����K��EK0�CK?�;�5)�=�E�HK?���KJI0�B���kB�@���JB���P>B

B�T����P>B�APHP?�8BCB��K�APHP?:�T�KH@?��CI?D�@KAK0�V?E�ZK�W?E�?�>EK

Q�YBlCB@iYABCB@B�B�XPSPJiXPSPJB)�]VK�D�B�?K�K@�E�AUCE�AU�TEHP�

J�?D�GHK@D�B�?KTK�D�E��BS0�EA�BS�T�KH@?��CK�BIS�B��K�>NBIS0���lE��

JB�E���BB�>E?E�US�JU�PZK� @K�V�@�T�B�BJ�KJ�PV�@?BK)�[� MECE�P

T�BSEHI?���G�UK����CEMBB�Q���T�BJK�0�JECEHE��>�CD>P??@>B��B��

?KCCBMK�?0�k�M�^LB��TE�CE�HE�@>BJ�PCBN�J�8��T�B�NBTK0�T�KH@?��

�B?D��K?�PH�E:c�BCB��E?�?�>EK��,-.-�M)0�tE@>��0�JECEHE��M�PGB�@>B�

JKC>B��ABG�K@JK��@�EAEH�E�T�EH�K?�J��H��B�U����v�K?�EJ�APCD���

�K�8W?E����@TK>?K�@�EAEHU�T�KH@?��B?D�?�PH�E0�K@CB0�>E�KV�E0��KVD��K

BHK?�E��?���E��@�EAEHK��Q�BGC^ACK��EJ��BHK�@�EAEHU����P@@>E��CB�

?K��?P�K:)�R�JEZ�E�T�KH@?��B?D�B�AECKK�?EV�UK����CEMBB��TECI>��

@E��KJK��EJ�[BCD�^@K�BCB�@�>@E�KN���zBMK)��CB0�JEZK?�AU?D0�EA

W?EJ��K���HE�HPJ�?D�Q�H�PMBK0�?K0�>?E�TEPJ�KK���@�@���JB0�APHP?�HP�

J�?D�EA�W?EJ�G��?��\

|E�HPJ�K?@I0�K@?D�AECKK�B�?K�K@�U��@CPV��0�>EMH��O�PGBI�B�RA�

S�GBI�G��?D��K�G��^?�H�PM�E�H�PMK)�p?E?�T�BJK���K�BG�APHPLKME0���BG

T�EkCEME)�y�ETI?D�T�ENB?B�P^�])�|)�q�JK�BI��}[�@EGH���US�M�PGB�

��JB�B��AS�G�JB�>PCD?P��S�G�kBl�E���E�J�CE�B�lE�J�NBB�H�PM�E

H�PMK)�]A��AS�G@>EJ����?@>EJ�WTE@K�M�PGB�U�J�CE�V?E�G��^?0�>�>�B

�AS�GU�Q�E�M�PGB�@>EJ�WTE@K�}RJB���B��B~)���G�VKJ���HE�AUCE��A�

S�G@>EJP����EHP�@EGH���?D�@�E��@EA@?�K��U��W?�E>PCD?P��U��JB�0

K@CB�B@?E�BVK@>BK��AS�GU��@KMH��ZBCB���M�PGB�@>E��>PCD?P��E��@�K�

HK0�TEVKJP�E�B��K�@?�CB��E@B?KCIJB�W?E��M�PGB�@>E��>PCD?P�U\~7

t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�W?E�EVK�D�T�EHP>?B���I�B�?EV�E�@lE�JPCB�E����

��I�JU@CD0�>E?E��I�T�E�ENB�PK?�>�H�CD�K�kBJ���GJUkCK�BIJ)

z�G�B��I�TEHSEH��AS�G@>EME�PVK�EME0�JEZ�E�AUCE�AU�T�E�K@?B

��GM���BVK�BK�JKZHP�?BTECEMBK��>PCD?P��B�?KE�BK��JKZ>PCD?P��US

>EJJP�B>�NB�)�tU�V�@?E�ME�E�BJ�E�@SEH@?��S�JKZHP���GCBV�UJB

>PCD?P��JB0�EA�EALBS�B����B��?�S�B�?)H)�|E�?�>BK�@SEH@?��0�H�ZK

EVK�D���MCIH�UK�B��K@EJUK0�JEMP?�@PLK@?�E��?D�8B�@PLK@?�P^?:�AKG

�@I>E��JKZ>PCD?P��E��>EJJP�B>�NBBc�?�>�I�>EJJP�B>�NBI�B�EMH�

T�E@?E��K�EGJEZ���BG�G��T�E@?���@?�K��E��E?H�CK��E@?B0���B�EMH�0

��EAE�E?0�BG�G����KJK��D���KEA��?BJE@?B)

Page 74: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

|PZ�E�PVK@?D�B�EH�P�JK?EHECEMBVK@>P^� ?E�>E@?D�Q� @SEH@?�E

JKZHP�ET�KHKCK��UJB�>PCD?P��JB��@KMH��lB>@B�PK?���Kk�B����AC^�

H�?KCD�8TP?KkK@?�K��B>0�PVK�U�:0�B�TEW?EJP�EA���PZK��UK�BJ�@SEH�

@?���Q�W?E��K�l�>?U�@�JE@EG���BI�H���US�>PCD?P�0���l�>?U���AC^HK�

�BI0�V�@?E�ETE@�KHE����UK�?E��>PCD?P�E��>�>E?E�E��T�B��HCKZB?

��AC^H�?KCD)

�?E�ZK�>�@�K?@I�>PCD?P��US�>EJJP�B>�NB�0�GHK@D��@K�T�EB@SE�

HB?���EAE�E?�Q�l�>?U�>EJJP�B>�NBB���TK��P^�EVK�KHD�E@EG��^?@I

��P?�B�H���US�>PCD?P�0���Kk�B����AC^H�?KCD�PG��K?�W?B�l�>?U�?ECD�

>E�TE?EJ�B�?ECD>E�@�TEJELD^�W?BS�>PCD?P�)�X�?EV>B�G�K�BI�?BTECE�

MBB�>PCD?P�U0�JU�JEZKJ�EA���PZB?D�@>ECD>E�PMEH�E�@SEH@?��JKZHP

M�PGB�@>E��B��AS�G@>E��>PCD?P��JB0��E0�HK�@?�B?KCD�E0�>�>�ME�E�B?

])�|)�q�JK�BI0�l�>?U�>PCD?P��E��>EJJP�B>�NBB�APHK?����?B�EVK�D

?�PH�E)

p?B�l�>?U�EA���PZB��^?@I�TE�H�PMBJ��K>?E��J��O�PGBI�Q�R��

JK�BI0�O�PGBI�Q�=�CK@?B��0�O�PGBI�Q�[BG��?BI0�O�PGBI�Q�����0�O�P�

GBI�QzE@@BI0�O�PGBI�Q��BJ@>E�>�?ECBVK@>�I�JB@@BI�B�?)H)0�B�?)T)0�@

EH�E��@?E�E�U0���@�H�PME��Q�RAS�GBI�Q�XK�K��U��F��>�G0�RAS�GBI�Q

zE@@BI0�RAS�GBI�Q�@>BlU0�RAS�GBI�Q�E@K?B�U0�RAS�GBI�Q�YP�NBI0�RA�

S�GBI�Q�OK�PI�B�?)H)0�B�?)T)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�JU�JEZKJ�ETB@�?D�>�>�JB�BJPJ�?�B�RAS�GBB�

EH���Q�E�>E?E�E��M�PGB�@>BK�B@?EV�B>B�ME�E�I?�>�>�E�B�BNB�?E�K

@EGH��BI�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME�N��@?��0�H�PM�I�Q��KG��B@BJ�I�RAS�GBI0

TEH�K�M�^L�I@I����T�E?IZK�BB��@K��@�EK��B@?E�BB���T�HK�BIJ�@E

@?E�E�U�O�PGBB0�?�K?DI�Q��KBG�K@?��I�RAS�GBI)�[BHBJE0�TK���I�BG

�BS���M�PGB�@>B��l��?�GJ0�T�EHP>?�M�PGB�@>EME����NB@@BGJ�0�>E?E�

�U���BHB?����EC��S��K��EME�JE�I�CBkD�@�EK�E?��ZK�BK0�CBkD�@EA�

@?�K��P^�?K�D0����K��K�CD�EME��H�PMEME�0��K�@�EKME�@E@KH�0�P�>E?E�E�

ME�@�EB�HE@?EB�@?���B�@�EB��KHE@?�?>B)��JK��E���W?EJ�G�>C^V�K?@I

BJTK�@>EK��U@E>EJK�BK���kK��>PCD?P�U)

�)1)�F�ZK?@I0�TECPVBC�@D�HE@?�?EV�E�T�E@?�����I�>��?B��0�BGEA�

��Z�^L�I�?�B��K�CD�E@?B�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BS��G�BJEE?�EkK�B�)�p?�

>��?B���T�B�NBTB�CD�E��KTEC��I0�E����K�JEZK?�ES��?B?D��@K�J�E�

ZK@?�E��K�CD�E@?K��B�CE>�CD�US�B@?B�)�|K�@>�E^0�>EMH��JU�TB@�CB

W?P�@�E^�@?�?D^0�I��@K���KJI�HK�Z�C���MECE�K�@B?P�NB^0�ETB@���P^

Page 75: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

��EH�EJ�ME�IVE�C^ABJEJ�J�E^�?K>@?K)�y�BJK^����BHP���@@>�G�oE�SK

rPB@��xE�SK@��}X�H���@SEHILBS@I�?�ETE>~)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�xE��

SK@�@�TE��GB?KCD�E��?EV�E@?D^�PCE�BC�@P?D�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BS�E?�E�

kK�B��Q�@�W?E��?EV>B�G�K�BI0�I���G��C�AU�KME�KHB�@?�K��UJ�M�PGB�E�

�AS�G@>BJ�TB@�?KCKJ)

[�W?EJ���@@>�GK�>B?�B@?�RCDAK��ME�E�B?�@�EKJP�APHPLKJP�PAB��

NK�AP>��CD�E�@CKHP^LKK��}]���K�BC�8�KVD�BHK?�E�TB@�?KCK�v^��=W�K0

�UJUkCK��EJ�AE�SK@E�@>EJ�TK�@E��ZK)�Q �� .��:���AK@VB@CK��E@?D

��KJK��US��IHE�0�����@?PLP^0�MECE�E>�PZB?KCD�P^�@K?D���@SEHI�

LBS@I0�@SEHILBS@I�B�T���CCKCD�US���KJK�)���W?��>�������KJK�0�>E�

?E�UK�@ACBZ�^?@I0��K?�I?@I0�TK�K>�KLB��^?@I�BCB��K>�G���K>EJ�?�>

B��K�@ET�B>�@�^?@I0�G�>C^V�K?���@KAK��@K�JU@CBJUK��EGJEZ�E@?B)

[�AECDkB�@?�K�W?BS���KJK��JU�@���JB��K�@PLK@?�PKJc���>�>BS�?E

@PLK@?�PK?K��U0���I�Q��K?c���H�PMBS�K@?D�I0��E��K?���@c���B�US�@PLK�

@?�PKJ�JU�EA�)�[�EH�EJ�BG��BS0�>EMH��@V�@?CB�U��@CPV����UT�C�J�K0

�U�I�BCB@D���JE��HEJc���H�PMEJ�Q��U0�T�ESEHI�TE�@�HP0���kCB�JK�I

JK�?�UJc���?�K?DKJ�Q�I�T�EBG�EkP�W?B�ZK�@CE��0��E�@�J�I�Q�JB��Z0

T�BG��>)))�[KV�E���G�K?�CII@D0���KJI��KHK?�>��KB@VB@CBJUJ����B���

?�J�APHPLKME)�[�EH�EJ�BG��BS�I�Q���k����M~);

�� .�

.�t)�t�J��H�k�BCB)�[�KHK�BK���lBCE@ElB^)�YABCB@B0�.55,0�@).,�8M�PG):),�g�!���&)�1��)�d��������")���!�� ��0�.57;0���)�3,�33)3�])�|)�q�JK�BI)�RAS�G@>E�M�PGB�@>B��>E�lCB>?��T�EACKJU�B�TK�@TK>?B�U�P�K�

MPCB�E���BI�ii�R@TK>?U�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?�0��UT)�40�������0�,--.0�@)3,7)9�Y�J�ZK)4�Y�J�ZK0�@)�3,;)6�Y�J�ZK0�@).;,)7�Y�J�ZK0�@).-6);�o)�r)�xE�SK@)�XEV)���?�KS�?EJ�S0�?)��0�@@)�3,;�3,5)

Page 76: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�t�K�B�?K�K@�E�AECKK�TEH�EA�E�PG��?D���kK

J�K�BK�TE�TE�EHP���G�US�E�BK�?B�E�)�[�HE>C�HK��U�PTEJB��K?K�M�P�

GB�@>BK�E�BK�?B�U0� �AS�G@>BK�E�BK�?B�U0� M�PGB�E��BG��?B�@>BK0

M�PGB�E��P@@>BK�B�?)H)�[�VKJ��U��BHB?K�E@EAP^���G�BNP���E�BK�?B�

��S\�tK�I�B�?K�K@PK?�lP�H�JK�?�CD��I���G�BN��JKZHP�M�PGB�@>B�

JB�B��AS�G@>BJB�E�BK�?B��JB)

T.����MU���� �-8�[ET�E@��K@DJ��?�PH�U�)�y��K�G��^0����V?E�E�B�K�?B�E��C�@D�RAS�GBI)�|E�K@CB�PVK@?D0�V?E�E���AUC����@E@?��K�O�P�

GBB�8SE?I�W?E��K��@KMH��AUCE�?�>:0�?E�E>�ZK?@I0�V?E�P���@�AUCB�EALBK

E�BK�?B�U)�=�EACKJ����?EJ0�V?E�K@CB�JU�E�BK�?B�PKJ@I����{�T�H0�?E

�AS�GU�HPJ�^?0�V?E�W?E��E���KH�RAS�GBB)�O�PGB�U�ZK�HPJ�^?0�V?E

K@CB�P���@�APHK?�E�BK�?�NBI����zE@@B^0�?EMH��T�EBM��K?�O�PGBI)�=�E�

ACKJ����?EJ0�V?E�P���@���G�UK�E�BK�?�NBB0�B�JU��K�JEZKJ����?B�V?E�

?E�EALKK0�T�BKJCKJEK�HCI�EAKBS�@?E�E��Q�HCI���@�B�HCI� �AS�GE�)

tEZ�E�T�KH@?��B?D�B�?�>P^�>��?B�P�Q�T�B�TECB?BVK@>E��E�BK�?��

NBB����zE@@B^�>PCD?P��EK���G�B?BK�E�BK�?B�PK?@I����{�T�H)�|E�W?E

�K�K�CD�E0�JU�TECPVBJ�>�>EME�?E�>K�?����)

��������%�"�8�p?E�EVK�D�@CEZ�U��JEJK�?)�|K�>�ZK?@I�CB���J0�V?EC^A�I�E�BK�?�NBI��@K�?�>B�ET�KHKCIK?@I�VB@?E�T��MJ�?BVK@>BJB

B�?K�K@�JB\�RAS�GE���@KMH��PT�K>�CB�G��?E0�V?E�E�B�E�BK�?B�E���

CB@D����AECDkK�B>E�0����@E�K?@>P^��C�@?D0���?E���KJI�>�>�O�PGBI

E�BK�?B�E��C�@D����H�PMBK�@BCU)�|E0�>�>��K��E�G�JK?BC��AS�G@>B�

B@?E�B>�X?��B@C���r�>EA�0�K@CB�AU�O�PGBI�E�BK�?B�E��C�@D����AECD�

kK�B>E�0�?E��AS�GU�EAIG�?KCD�E�@?�CB�AU�E�BK�?B�E��?D@I����JK�D�

kK�B>E�)�R���@E��KJK��E��@B?P�NBB0�K@CB��EEA��GB?D�VB@?E�MBTE?K�

?BVK@>B0�V?E�O�PGBI���V�K?�E�BK�?B�E��?D@I����zE@@B^0�B@>C^V�K?�

@I�CB��EGJEZ�E@?D�?EME0�V?E�RAS�GBI��H�PM���V�K?�@>CE�I?D@I�>�G��

T�H�E��E�BK�?�NBB0�>�>���J�>�ZK?@I\

T.����MU���� �-8��B@?E�MBTE?K?BVK@>B�?�>EK��TEC�K��EGJEZ�E)�|E��@>ECD>E�W?E�APHK?��K�CD�E\�p?E?��ET�E@��K@DJ��@CEZ�U�)�|U�Kk�B�

@?�?P@�RAS�GBB��K�TEG�ECIK?��KkB?D��ET�E@�E�BK�?�NBB�TEC�E@?D^

T��MJ�?BVK@>B)�u@CB�JU�APHKJ�E�BK�?B�E��?D@I����zE@@B^0�@JEZK?�CB

RAS�GBI�T�E?B�ETE@?��B?D�zE@@BB�H�PMP^�>�>P^��BAPHD�E�BK�?�NB^\

Page 77: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

!R������RU,���R��8�y�T�KHTEC�M�C0�V?E�P���@���HE>C�HK�APHK?�TEH��I?��ET�E@�TE�TE�EHP�BHK�?BV�E@?B)�y�ZH�C�W?EME�JEJK�?��B�SE?KC

AU0�V?EAU��U���H�PS�@CE��S�W?E?�JEJK�?�E?JK?BCB)

T.����MU���� �-8�[�HE>C�HK�P�JK�I�E?JKVK��W?E?�JEJK�?)�[�V�@?�E�@?B0�W?E?��ET�E@�G�?��MB��K?@I���JEK��TECKJB>K�@�M��EJ�q�JK�BI0

>E?E�U��P?�K�ZH�K?0�V?E�>��>�G@>�I�BHK�?BV�E@?D�>EMH���BAPHD�>��

>BJ�?E�EA��GEJ�EAwKHB�B?���@)�FEMH��l���NPG�ME�E�B?0�V?E�E��T�B�

��HCKZB?�K��ETK�@>E��>PCD?P�K0�@��GP�I@�E0�>�>BK�NK��E@?B�E��TEH�

��GPJK��K?)�]��TEH��GPJK��K?�K��ETK�@>P^�>PCD?P�P0�MHK�lP�>NBE�

�B�P^?�HKJE>��?BVK@>BK�B�@?B?P?U0�MHK�@EAC^H�^?@I�T�����VKCE�

�K>�0�MHK�P�B�K�@B?K?U�AUCB�KLK�VK?U�K@?��TI?D@E?�CK?�?EJP���G�H0

MHK�C�?B�@>B��IGU>�AUC�EALBJ�B�?)T)�|��F��>�GK�I��K��BZP��B>�>BS

>PCD?P��US�P�B�K�@�CB�0�>E?E�UK���@�EAwKHB�I^?0�>�EJK�?KS0�>E?E�

�UK�@PLK@?�P^?��KGHK�Q�B���u��ETK0�B����F��>�GK)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�K@CB

JU�APHKJ�E�BK�?B�E��?D@I����>��>�G@>P^�BHK�?BV�E@?D0�?E�@EGH��

HBJ�CBkD�EVK�D�S�PT>P^�JBlECEMB^0�>E?E��I�T�B�TK��EJ�T��>?B�

VK@>EJ�T�BJK�K�BB���G��CB?@I�B��BVKME��K�H�@?)�F��>�G@>�I�BHK��

?BV�E@?D�P�JK�I��UGU��K?�@EJ�K�BI�>�>�?�>E��I)�tU�@?���KJ@I��U��

?B�BG�TECEZK�BI�B�NKTCIKJ@I�G��V?E�?E��KTE�I?�EK0��K��?B>PCB�E�

����EK0��K��TB@���EK)�|K>E?E��I�M�PGB�U�ME�E�I?0�V?E�JU�E�BMB��CD�

�UK0�P�B>�CD�UK0�B�>EMH��I�G�H�^��ET�E@0���VKJ�BJK��E���k��E�BMB�

��CD�E@?D0���VKJ�BJK��E���k��P�B>�CD�E@?D0�VKJ�JU�E?CBV�KJ@I�E?

H�PMBS�C^HK�0���>E�NK�>E�NE��E>�GU��K?@I0�V?E���kB�NK��E@?B�EH�E�

��KJK��E�E>�GU��^?@I�B�EALKVKCE�KVK@>BJB�NK��E@?IJB)�=�EACK�

J��KLK�B���?EJ0�V?E�BK���SBI�NK��E@?K����HB>�CD�E�JK�IK?@I���M�P�

GB�@>EJ�EALK@?�K)�YEJP�HE>�G�?KCD@?�E�Q��VK��k�KK��U@?PTCK�BK0

>EMH��AUCE�TEHVK�>�P?E0�V?E�HCI�ET�KHKCK��E��V�@?B���kBS�M��Z�

H���@�EAEH��CBV�E@?B�B�T�����VKCE�K>��@?�CB�?KJB�NK��E@?IJB0�G�

>E?E�UK��PZ�E�AE�E?D@I�B�>E?E�UK��PZ�E�G�LBL�?D)�YE�K@?D�T�EB@�

SEHB?�?���@lE�J�NBI�NK��E@?K�)

�� ������/%!��-8�n�JK�I�H���>E�E?>BS��ET�E@��>�pJG��P)�[���kKJ

HE>C�HK�K@?D�l��GU�E�?EJ0�V?E��K>E?E�UK�HKI?KCB�M�PGB�@>E��>PCD?P�

�U0�>�>�AU�ET���HU��I@D0�P?�K�ZH�^?0�V?E�JU��K��K@KJ��B>�>E��E?�

�K?@?�K��E@?B�G����@BCD@?�K��EK�TK�K@KCK�BK��AS�GE��J�S�HZB�E�

Page 78: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�������)���YP�NB^)�|E0���@>ECD>E�BG�K@?�E0��UH�^LBK@I�HKI?KCB�M�P�

GB�@>E��>PCD?P�U���HK�I?��HN�?EJ��K>K0�?E?�ZK��CDI����V���HGK0��KE�

H�E>��?�E�TPACBV�E��U@?PT�CB�@�E@PZHK�BKJ�TECB?B>B�N��BGJ�0�>E�

?E��I��U�PHBC��G��VB?KCD�P^�V�@?D��AS�GE��TK�K@KCB?D@I)�F�EJK�?EME0

V�@?D�M�PGB�@>BS�@�ILK��B>E�0�@EHK�@?�PI���@T�E@?���K�B^�S�B@?B�

��@?���@�KHB�ET�KHKCK��E��V�@?B��AS�GE����]V�JVB�@>EJ����E�K0����

T�BJK�0�>�>�AU�G�LB?BCB�BS�TK�KH�N��KJ�B�E?�TK�K@KCK�BI)

���?E�E���ET�E@)�n���@���?EJ�ZK�HE>C�HK�T�IJE�@?��B?@I��ET�E@

E� ?EJ0�>?E�ZK��K@K?�E?�K?@?�K��E@?D� G��>���?KCD�UK�JK�U�T�E?B�

�E@@?��kBS��AS�GE��B�E@K?B���E���KJI�>E�E?>EME�TK�BEH��M�PGB�@�

>E���KG��B@BJE@?B�8BJK^?@I����BHP�.5.;�,.�MEHU:)�[U��@K�DKG�HPJ��

K?K0�V?E�W?E�AUCB�>���?KCD�UK�JK�U�T�E?B��W?BS����EHE�\�|E��KHD

JK�DkK�B>B�?EV�E�?�>�ZK�TEH��CICB�T�E@E�K?@>BK�B�T�EAECDkK�B@?�

@>BK��E@@?��BI�B���H�PMBS��KMBE��S�O�PGBB�Q���qPkK?@?>EJ0�r��V�

SP?@>EJ�B�H�)�F�?EJP�ZK0�V�@?D��AS�GE��TEHHK�ZB��C��JK�DkK�B@?@�

>EK��P>E�EH@?�E0���H�PM�I�V�@?D�TEHHK�ZB��C��AECDkK�B>E�)�{HK@D0

���K��EK0�AECKK�AUC�T�EI�CK���K�W?�BVK@>B�0���>C�@@E�U��TEHSEH�B

�ET�E@��C�@?B0�SE?I�E�B�B�TK�K@K>�CB@D)

T.����MU���� �-8�y�TE@?���^@D�E?�K?B?D����W?B��ET�E@U)�FEMH��ITB@�C0�V?E��B>?E��K��GIC����@KAI�E?�K?@?�K��E@?D�G��TK�K@KCK�BK��A�

S�GE����HK�I?��HN�?EJ��K>K0�I�TEH��GPJK��C0�V?E�JU��@KMH��8B�E@E�

AK��E�O�PGBI:�@?���KJ@I�E@�EAEHB?D@I�E?�E?�K?@?�K��E@?B)�p?E�>��

>�I�?E�@?��?KMBI�TEI�BC�@D�P���@0�V?E�JU��K��B�E��?U0��@KMH���B�E�

��?�>?E�?E�H�PME�0�>�>BK�?E���Kk�BK�@BCU)���JU�TE@?EI��E�@@UC�KJ�

@I����W?E)�u@CB���BJ�?KCD�E���@@JE?�K?D0�@>�ZKJ0�B@?E�BVK@>BK�l�>�

?U0�?E�JEZ�E�@EMC�@B?D@I�@�?KJ0�V?E�zE@@BI�JKk�C����J�E@PLK@?�B?D

@�E^��KG��B@BJP^�TECB?B>P�BCB�YP�NBI�JKk�C��>�>EK�?E���KJI0�BCB

=K�@BI0�BCB�H�PMBK�ME@PH��@?���JKk�CB���J�T�E�K@?B�?�>P^�@�E^

�KG��B@BJP^�TECB?BVK@>P^�CB�B^)�|E�I�HPJ�^0�V?E�TEH�?�>BJB

�U@>�GU���BIJB�@>�U��K?@I�CBkD�EH�E�Q�ZKC��BK�@�I?D�@�@KAI�E?�

�K?@?�K��E@?D�G��?E0�V?E�T�EB@SEHBCE�����kKJ�T�E@?���@?�K)�FE�KV�

�E0�AUCB��K>E?E�UK�C^HB0�HETP@?BJ0��CDI����V���HGK0�>E?E�U��TB�

@�C�EA�W?EJ)����K>E?E�UK�H�PMBK�M�PGB�@>BK�HKI?KCB�>PCD?P�U�?EME

��KJK�B�TB@�CB�EA�W?EJ0��E���NKCEJ��K�AUCE��B>�>E���K�>NBB)��G�BS

�K�>NBB��BVKME��K��UkCE0�TE?EJP�V?E�E����K�TECPVBC����G�B?BI)

Page 79: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

R�V?E�>�@�K?@I���kKME��ET�E@��E���kK��>E�E?>E���KG��B@BJE@�

?B0�T�EACKJ��@E@?EB?���?EJ0�V?E��B�?EMH��B0�JEZK?�AU?D0��B�@K�V�@

JU��K�@T��kB��CB0�@>�ZKJ�?�>0���kBS�H�PGK�0���kBS�T��?�K�E��Q

�AS�GE��B�E@K?B�����VKME�SE?I?�E�B\�|B>?E��K��KC�HB�CEM��@��BJB0��K

AUCE�?�>EME���GME�E��)�y�JEMP�@>�G�?D0�V?E�AKG�HB�CEM�0�AKG�EALK�BI0

AKG��G�BJ�EME�TE�BJ��BI��@I>BK�JK�U0�>E?E�UK�T�KHT�BJP?�T�E?B��

�B>B�H�PM�T�E?B��H�PM�0�JEZ�E�@VB?�?D�>���?KCD�UJB�JK��JB)�FPCD�

?P���HB�CEM��Q�W?E�AECDk�I�>PCD?P��)�|E�K@CB�JU��K���GME���B��KJ�@

��kBJ���@KCK�BKJ�BCB�@���kBJB�T��?�K��JB0�@��AS�G�JB�BCB�@�E@K�

?B��JB0�B�@EAB��KJ@I�B�H�CDkK�?�>�ZB?D�Q�AKG�HB�CEM�0�AKG�HB@>P@�

@B�0�?E�K@?D�PM�EG�0�V?E��KGPCD?�?0�>�>E?E�EJP�JU�T�BHKJ0�ETI?D�ZK

APHK?���@BCBKJ)�y�W?E�BJK^����BHP)

��,� ��.�S,���8�y�AU�SE?KC�G�H�?D��ET�E@�EA�E�BK�?�NBB)�p?E>�@�K?@I��K���Kk�KTECB?BVK@>EME�>P�@�0��0�@>E�KK��@KME0���P?�K��K�

TECB?B>B)�[EEALK�?E0�HCI�J�CK�D>BS�@?���0�>�>E�E��I�CIK?@I�O�PGBI0

I�@VB?�^��K�EVK�D��>?P�CD�E����Kk�^^�TECB?B>P)�p?E��@K�?�>B�?�

�E@>EkD0�>E?E�P^�JEMP?�@KAK�TEG�ECB?D�AECDkBK�@?���U�8I�BJK^��

�BHP�@K�DKG�P^���Kk�^^�TECB?B>P:)�qCI�JK�I�{�T�H�Q�W?E�?ECD>E��K��

SE�K�@?�E�G�>E��0�V�@?��I�@EA@?�K��E@?D0�HKJE>��?BI0�T�����VKCE�K�

>�0�M��ZH��@>EK�EALK@?�E0�B�?P?0�TE�JEKJP0��B>�>BS�>EJT�EJB@@E��AU?D

�K�JEZK?)��?E�>�@�K?@I�RAS�GBB0�J�K�AUCE�AU�B�?K�K@�E�TE@CPk�?D

��kBS�H�PGK��Q�>�>�AU�E�B�@lE�JPCB�E��CB�?K�NK��E@?B0�>E?E�UK�HCI

�BS��KGUACKJU�B�>EJT�EJK?�NBI�>E?E�US��K�JEZK?�AU?D�ET���H���

�B���>�>BS�P@CE�BIS��B>�>BJB�T��MJ�?BVK@>BJB�@EEA��ZK�BIJB)

�������!"�#�-8�y�?�>�TE�IC0�V?E�G�T�H�UK�NK��E@?B��KE@TE�BJU0�K�TEH�K�M�^?@I��B>�>BJ�@EJ�K�BIJ0�B�>EJT�EJB@@E���K�JEZK?�AU?D0

B�W?E�Q�E�BK�?�NBI�O�PGBB0����U�@T��kB��K?K�?EV>P�G�K�BI��AS�G@>E�

@?E�E�U8

T.����MU���� �-8�tEI�?EV>��G�K�BI�?�>�I�ZK0�>�>�B�?�EI0�rK���)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�n�JK�I�?�>E��P?EV�I^LB���ET�E@)�[E?�GHK@D�P

��@�B�?K�K@�EK���@@PZHK�BK0��E�I0�JEZK?�AU?D0��K�@E�@KJ�TE�IC)�[U

��TB@�CB0�V?E�X�S��E��ET�KHKCIC�O�PGB^�>�>�J�CP^�BJTK�B^0�B��U

B�?K�T�K?B�E��CB�W?E��U@>�GU���BK���?EJ�@JU@CK0�V?E�E��BJKC��

Page 80: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�BHP�?K��B?E�B�CD�P^���G�EkK�@?�E@?D�B�MK?K�EMK��E@?D)�t�K�>��

ZK?@I0�V?E�W?E���T�B�NBTK�T���BCD�EK�EAwI@�K�BK�W?EME��U@>�GU���

�BI0�I�?EZK�@�W?BJ�@EMC�@K�)�|E�H�CDkK0�>EMH���U�>�@�K?K@D�BHKECE�

MBB0�V?E��U�BJKK?K����BHP\�u@CB�ME�E�B?D�E�O�PGBB�>�>�EA�BJTK�BB0

?E�TK��U���ET�E@�Q�W?E��ET�E@�BJTK�@>E��BHKECEMBB)�[U�@VB?�K?K0

V?E��K�AUCE��B>�>E��BHKECEMBB0�>E?E��I�JEMC��AU�T�BH�?D�K��@?�?P@

J�CE��BJTK�BB\�t�K�SE?KCE@D�AU�P?EV�B?D)�y��K��@K�GHK@D�TE�IC)

T.����MU���� �-8�q�0�GHK@D�AUC�TE@?��CK���ET�E@�BHKECEMBB)�y�BJKC���BHP���NBE��CB@?BVK@>P^�BHKECEMB^0�>E?E��I�B@TECDGE��C��@��GP

H���B@?E�BVK@>BS���MPJK�?�)�XEMC�@�E�TK��EJP0�TEH�M�PGB��JB�TEH�

��GPJK��^?��@KS0���?EJ�VB@CK�B���@)����?E�EK�Q�W?E�P?�K�ZHK�BK�E

?EJ0�V?E��AS�GNU�Q�T�BkKCDNU0�E�B�?ECD>E�V?E�TEI�BCB@D���W?BS�>���

IS0�?E�K@?D�E�B�Q��K��AE�BMK�U�RAS�GBB�B�?)H)�p?E�AUCE�V�@?D^�?E�

BJTK�@>E��BHKECEMBB0� >E?E��I� ?EMH��ElE�JCIC�@D)�]T�KHKCK��UK

>�PMB��U��Z�CB�W?E�J�K�BK0�B��U0����K��EK0�EA�W?EJ�@CUk�CB)�y

HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E�l��MJK�?�?E��BHKECEMBB0�>E?E�P^��K�P@TKCB�TE@?�E�

B?D)�|E��@KMH��K@?D��EGJEZ�E@?D�?EME0�V?E�?�>�I�BHKECEMBI�APHK?�@lE��

JB�E����0�B���>E�NK�>E�NE��?�>EK�JB�E�EGG�K�BK0�?�>�I�lBCE@ElBI

�K�H�HP?��EGJEZ�E@?D�P�BHK?D�T�EACKJP0�>E?E��I�K@?D����@�JEJ�HKCK)

��?EMH��ETI?D�APHK?���@BCBK)�{HK@D0�>E�KV�E0���ZK���ET�E@�BHKECE�

MBB)�{�B�H�O�J@�SP�HBI�SE?KC�TE@?�EB?D�>�>P^�?E�EALP^�BHKECE�

MB^)�y�G��^0�V?E�����kKJ�T���B?KCD@?�K�T�KHT�B�BJ�CB@D�TETU?>B

@EGH��BI�ElBNB�CD�E����NBE��CD�E��BHKECEMBB�B�EA�W?EJ�AUC��HB@�

>P@@BI)�XC����xEMP0�AECDk�I�V�@?D�M�PGB�@>E��B�?KCCBMK�NBB��K�T�B�

�IC��?�>P^�TETU?>P0�@��GP�AUCE�G�I�CK�E0�V?E�W?E�>�>�I�?E�kBGEl�K�

�BI)�y�BJKC����BHP0�V?E�BJTK�BI��@KMH���PZH�K?@I���>�>E��?E�?KE�BB0

>�>E��?E�BHKECEMBB)�=ETU?>��TE@?�EB?D�?�>P^�BHKECEMB^�AUC�0�B

BHKI0�@EMC�@�E�>E?E�E���AS�GNU�?ECD>E�V?E�TEI�BCB@D�?�J0�MHK�E�B

@K�V�@�T�EZB��^?0�HECZ���AUC��@?�?D�V�@?D^�AECDkE��BHKECEMBB0

>E?E�P^�?EMH��TU?�CB@D�@EGH�?D)�xUC��?�>�I�TETU?>�)

M���� �/%�"�-8�n�JK�I�>���J�?�>E���ET�E@)�FEMH��I�VB?�C���kP�@?�?D^0P�JK�I�AUCE�?�>EK��TKV�?CK�BK0�V?E����K��J�EME��E@?�CDMBB�B�TKV�CB)

T.����MU���� �-8�[U��K�@E�@KJ�T���BCD�E�TE�ICB)

Page 81: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

M���� �/%�"�-8�|E�I�ME�E�^�EA�W?EJ���SE�EkKJ�@JU@CK�@CE��0�>�>�E

��@@?����BB�@�>�>BJ�?E�JBlEJ)�[U�@�JB���T�IJP^�ME�E�B?K�EA�W?EJ0

T���H�0�T�B�IGU��I�>�>�>EJP�?E�>E�>�K?�EJP�@CPV�^0�>E�>�K?�EJP

E?�KG>P�B@?E�BB0��E�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�W?E�JEZ�E�EAEALB?D��RAS�GBI

>�>�l��?�GJ0�>�>��UJUkCK��U�0��UHPJ���U��M�PGB��JB0�O�PGBK�0

JBl)�F�>��U�@VB?�K?K0�AUCE�CB���M�PGB�@>EJ�EALK@?�K�B�@ES���IK?@I

CB�HE�@BS�TE��?�>EK�H�CK>EK0�JEZK?�AU?D0�E?��K�CD�E@?B0�BHK�CBGB�

�E����EK�T�KH@?��CK�BK�EA��AS�G�S\����K���?EJ�CB�T�BVB��0�V?E�M�P�

GB�U�?�>�AECKG�K��E�TK�KZB��^?�TE?K�^�RAS�GBB0�V?E�E�B��K�JEMP?

��@@?�?D@I�@�W?BJ�JBlEJ�Q�JEZK?�AU?D0�BG�G��>�>E��?E�CEZ�E��ME��

HU�B\��?E�W?��T�EACKJ��Q�@>E�KK�BS���P?�K��II0�VKJ�@PLK@?�P^L�I

���K�CD�E@?B\�[�EALKJ0�RAS�GBI�>�>���k�l��?�GJ)

T.����MU���� �-8�p?E�EVK�D�MCPAE>�I�T�EACKJ�)�FE�KV�E0�I��K�@JE�MP�TEC�E@?D^�E?�K?B?D����W?E?��ET�E@)�y��K�T�E�EHBC�WJTB�BVK@>BK

ET�E@U0�V?EAU�TE�I?D0���@>ECD>E�W?E�l��?�GJ0���@>ECD>E��K�CD�E@?D0

B�V?E�@K�V�@�HPJ�^?�M�PGB�U)�tEZK?�AU?D0�W?E��E���0���>E?E�E��@E�

@?IG�^?@I�B�AE�^?@I��K�C^HB0���>�>BK�?E�PZK�B@?E�BVK@>B�@CEZB��

kBK@I�T�KH@?��CK�BI)�XK�V�@�I�JEMP�@>�G�?D0�V?E�JU�ZB�KJ����K�CD�

�EJ�JB�K0�C^HB��E�CKVK�U���>�ZHEH�K��P^�ZBG�D0�BHK?�AE�DA��G�

SCKA0�G��@PLK@?�E���BK)�[@K�W?E��EG���L�K?���@�>��K�CD�E@?B0�?E�K@?D

C^HB0����K��EK0� E@EG��^?��K�CD�UK�T�EACKJU)�r^HB�JEMP?�AU?D

@K�?BJK�?�CD�UJB�B�BJK?D�>�>BK�?E�JBlU0��E��K�CD��I0�ZK@?E>�I0

@?�EM�I�ZBG�D0����K��EK0��K�E@?��CIK?�JK@?E�TECB?BVK@>EJP�@K�?B�

JK�?�CBGJP�BCB�JBlE?�E�VK@?�P)�|��K��EK0���@KCK�BK�@JE?�B?��K�

�CD�E���� W?B�T�EACKJU)�|E�EA��G� �AS�G��>�>0�HETP@?BJ0��E@B?KCI

�UN��@>EME�W?E@��BCB�JE��CB0�JEZK?�AU?D0�B�@ES���BC@I�MHK�?E���?KS

>��IS0�MHK�I�T�EZB��^0���tB�M�KCBB)�|E��KCDGI�ME�E�B?D�EA�EALKJ

?�>EJ��GMCIHK0�TE�JEKJP)

�������!"�#�-8�n�JK�I�H����ET�E@��>�pJG��P)�rK����ME�E�BC�E�G��T�H�E��E�BK�?�NBB0�E�?EJ0�V?E�HCI�O�PGBB�Q�W?E�KHB�@?�K��U���USEH

BG�?EME�>ECC�T@�0���>E?E�EJ�E�����SEHB?@I)�[U�ME�E�BCB0�V?E�>��>�G�

@>�I�BHK�?BV�E@?D�SE?D�B�JEZK?�AU?D�EAwKHB�I^LBJ���V�CEJ0��E

I�CIK?@I�EVK�D�S�PT>E�0�WlKJK��E��B��KTE�I?�E�)�F�>��U�HPJ�K?K0

K@CB�O�PGBI�B�RAS�GBI�B��@K�>��>�G@>BK����EHU�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�@�I?E

Page 82: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

TE�K�I?���G�T�H�P^�E�BK�?�NB^0�@JEZK?�CB�W?E�@?�?D�EAwKHB�I^�

LBJ���V�CEJ����F��>�GK\�p?E�TK��U���ET�E@)

��T�EHECZK�BK�W?EME��ET�E@�)�[U�TBkK?K0�V?E��K?�EH�E��MCE�

A�CD�E��B@?B�U0�V?E�W?E�?E?�CB?��BGJ���J�HB>?PK?0�V?E��K�CD�E@?D

B�B@?B���JEZK?�AU?D�?ECD>E�EH�E�0�?E�K@?D�?E?�CB?��BGJ�P?�K�ZH�K?

��CBVBK�EH�E��B@?B�U)�y��K��E��@KJ�@EMC�@K��@���JB)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E

K@?D�EH���MCEA�CD��I�B@?B��)�q�PMEK�HKCE0�V?E�JU�@���JB�>��K�0�JE�

ZK?�AU?D0��K�@?�KJBJ@I0��E�@?�KJCK�BK�>��K��Q�K@?D�H�BZK�BK�>�T�E�

M�K@@P0��TK�KH)�|K�>�ZK?@I�CB���J0�V?E�E?�BN��BK��EEALK�>�>E��?E

MCEA�CD�E��B@?B�U�B�T�KHTEV?K�BK��K>BS�J�CK�D>BS�VK�KHP^LBS@I

B@?B��JEZK?���K@?B���@���G�ACPZHK�BK\�8z�GME�E��@K�V�@��K�BHK?�E

>E�lCB>?K):�tU�T�E@?E�G�?K�IKJ@I���W?BS�J�CUS�B@?B��S�B���V�KJ

T�BH���?D��K>BJ�CE>�CD�UJ�B@?B��J�EVK�D� MCEA�CD�U��S���>?K�)

[U�T�KHTEC�M�K?K0�V?E��EEALK��K?�B@?B�\�y�TE�BJ�^0��U�Q��K�K�P^�

LB��VKCE�K>0��E��KPZKCB���@?ECD>E\�y��B@>ECD>E��K�@EJ�K��^@D0

V?E�I�>�B@?B�K��K�TEHEkKC�B��K�TEHE�HP0��E��@K�?�>B�@?�KJC^@D)

T.����MU���� �-8��?E�>�@�K?@I���kKME�TK��EME��ET�E@��E�?EJ0�JE�

MP?�CB���@�EAwKHB�B?D�K��ETK�@>BK�NK��E@?B�Q����K��EK0�W?E?��ET�

�E@��U�G�H�K?K��K�?ECD>E�J�K0��E�B�@KAK)��0�JEZK?�AU?D0�W?E���@�EAwK�

HB�B?)�u@CB�T��MJ�?BVK@>B�E?�K@?B@D�>�W?EJP��ET�E@P�Q�V?E�JEMP?

T�B�K@?B�W?B�NK��E@?B�>�ZHEJP�VKCE�K>P�Q�?E�T��MJ�?BGJ�TEH@>��

GU��K?�TECEZB?KCD�U��E?�K?)�u@CB���J�T�BHK?@I�@?�EB?D�T��MJ�?B�

VK@>EK�EALK@?�E0���>E?E�EJ�APHP?�G�LBLK�U��@K�T�����>�ZHEME�VK�

CE�K>�0�?E�MBTE?K?BVK@>B�?�>BK�NK��E@?B�HECZ�U���@�EAwKHB�I?D)

|E�I��K�G��^0���@>ECD>E�>��>�G@>BK�@PAwK>?U�ME?E�U�W?E�T�B�I?D)

=ECB?BVK@>�I�WCB?�0�I�HPJ�^0�ME?E��)�[�O�PGBB�V�@?E�ME�E�I?��>EMH�0

��>E�NK�>E�NE�0���@?PTB?�HKJE>��?BI\�y��@KMH�����CBGB�P^�?�>BK

�U��ZK�BI)�n�C^HK��TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�HKJE>��?BB�?�>BK�ZK�EZBH��

�BI0�>�>BK�AUCB�TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�>EJJP�BGJP)�qKJE>��?BI��B>EMH�

�K���@?PTB?�AKG���kKME�PV�@?BI)�u@CB�JU����B�HB�BHP�CD�EJ�P�E��K

�K�APHKJ�AE�E?D@I�G����kB�T����0�HKJE>��?BI��B>EMH���K���@?PTB?)

|B�EHB��A^�E>��?�BCB�VB�E��B>��K�@>�ZK?���J��}=EZ�CP�@?�0�AK�B�

?K���kB�T����~)�tU�HECZ�U��@K�BGJK�B?D0�HECZ�U�AE�E?D@I�G��W?B

T��������B�HB�BHP�CD�EJ�P�E��K)�YEMH�0�JEZK?�AU?D0�JU�B�TE@?�EBJ

>�>E��?E�EALB��JB�)�OE?E�U�JU�BCB��K�ME?E�U0��E�T�EACKJ����?EJ0

Page 83: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

V?E�JU�JEZKJ�lE�JB�E��?D�@�EK�ME@PH��@?�E0�EALK@?�E�?ECD>E���

G�T�H�US�NK��E@?IS)

R�V?E�>�@�K?@I�B@?B�U0�?E�H�K�?U@IVB�CK?�?EJP���G�H�EH�EJP��KE�

�HB����EJP�VKCE�K>P�G�H�CB��ET�E@��}�?E�K@?D�B@?B��\~0�B�E��?EMH�

T�EJECV�C)�y�BJK^����BHP�o�B@?�)��?E�?�>EK�B@?B��\����EEALK�@P�

LK@?�P^?�CB�EALBK�@?��H��?U���W?EJ�@JU@CK\�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�K��E�

TK�@>BK�NK��E@?B0�H�ZK�T�����VKCE�K>�0�HETP@>�^?��EGJEZ�E@?D�@P�

LK@?�E���BI�J�EMBS�B@?B�)�X>�ZKJ0�I�JEMP�AU?D�@�BHK?KCKJ��KME�

�U�B��K�B?D���xEM��@EMC�@�E�BS�T�KH@?��CK�BIJ�BCB�AU?D�E�?EHE>�

@�CD�UJ�T�KH@?��B?KCKJ�M�PGB�@>E��NK�>�B0�BCB�JP@PCDJ��B�EJ)

p?B�NK��E@?B�M����?B�P^?���J�T���E��K�B?D�����GCBV�UK�B@?B�U)�y

ME�E�^�E�CBV�US�B@?B��S)�n�>�ZHEME�BG���@�K@?D�CBV�UK0�TK�@E��CD�

�UK�B@?B�U0�B�W?B�B@?B�U�HECZ�U�>�>�?E�@PLK@?�E��?D)�y�W?E�BJK^

���BHP0�>EMH��ME�E�^0�V?E�B@?B��J�EME)�FE�KV�E0�BS�J�EME)

�������!"�#�-8�YE�K@?D��U�HETP@>�K?K0�V?E��@K�B@?B�U0�>E?E�UK��K��CD�E�@PLK@?�P^?0�HECZ�U�@E@PLK@?�E��?D\

T.����MU���� �-8�FE�KV�E)�]AIG�?KCD�E)

�������!"�#�-8�|E�K@?D�B�l�kB@?@>BK�B@?B�U)

T.����MU���� �-8�|K?0�?P?�I�SEVP���K@?B�P?EV�K�BK��K@CB�W?��B@?B����PM�EZ�K?�JEKJP�@PLK@?�E���B^�BCB�G�I�CIK?0�V?E�HECZ���@PLK�

@?�E��?D�?ECD>E�E��0�V?E�?ECD>E�E���BJKK?�T���E����@PLK@?�E���BK0

?E�?�>BK�B@?B�U�JU�HECZ�U�EAPGH�?D)

MU! ��!����R���#8�|�@>ECD>E�I�TE�BJ�^0�W?E?�HE>C�H�AUC���T����CK�����?E0�V?EAU�H�?D�@ENBECEMBVK@>EK�ET�KHKCK�BK��K>E?E�UJ�TE�

�I?BIJ)�[�T�B�NBTK�ZK��@KJ�TE�I?�E0�V?E�BHK�?BV�E@?D�G�CEZK��

MK�K?BVK@>B)�����HE>C�HK0�B���HB@>P@@BIS�JEK���BJ��BK�T�B�CK>CE

?E0�V?E�BHK�?BV�E@?D��AS�GE��B�M�PGB��@BCD�E�G��B@B?�E?�EA��G������

M�0�E?���CBVBI�EA��G�����M�)�=�KZHK�VKJ�@PHB?D�E�?EJ0�>?E�I�?�>E�0

��HE�TE@JE?�K?D����?E0�>?E�JE�����M)�p?E?�@?K�KE?BT�P��AS�GE��Q�T�B�

@P?@?�BK�O�PGBB�B�{�T�H�0�P�M�PGB��Q�T�B@P?@?�BK�zE@@BB�B�[E@?E>�)

tE���ET�E@�G�>C^V�K?@I���@CKHP^LKJ)�tEZ�E�CB�T�KH@?��B?D�@KAK0

Page 84: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

V?E�>EMH���BAPHD���@?PTB?�?�>EK���KJI0�>EMH��@?��K?��EGJEZ�UJ�>E��

@?�PB�E���BK�BHK�?BV�E@?B0��K�T�BAKM�I�>�EA��GP����M�0���B@SEHI�BG

>�>BS�?E�TEGB?B��US�TECEZK�B�\�F�>BK�BGJK�K�BI�HECZ�U�T�EBGE��

?B0�V?EAU�?�>�I��EGJEZ�E@?D�@?�C���K�CD�E�\

T.����MU���� �-8�tU�E?CBV�KJ@I�E?�ZB�E?�EME�JB���?KJ0�V?E�VK�

CE�K>��K�TEC�E@?D^�ET�KHKCK��MK�K?BVK@>BJB�H���UJB)�tU�JEZKJ

JK�I?D�@�E^�BHK�?BV�E@?D)�[EC>0�HETP@?BJ0��K�JEZK?�@?�?D�EAKGDI�

�E��BCB�H�PMBJ�@PLK@?�EJ0���I�JEMP�@?�?D�H�PMBJ�VKCE�K>EJ)�o�B@�

?B��@?�E�HETP@>�K?�W?E)�qETP@?BJ0�X��C�T�K���L�K?@I���=��C�0��

sK���H��HGK�T�K���L�K?@I���OKE�MBI�sK���H��HGK)�rBV�E�I��K�^��

?�>BK�VKCE�KVK@>BK�BGJK�K�BI0�I�HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E��EGJEZ�E)�|E�V?E�>��

@�K?@I�@ENB�CD�EME�>E�@?�PB�E���BI�JB��0�>EMH��>�ZHEK�P?�E�JU��E@�

@?����CB��KJ�JB�0���k��>�ZHEH�K���I�lBCE@ElBI�TEH@>�GU��K?���J0

>PH��BH?B)�FEMH���AS�GU�BCB�M�PGB�U�>E�@?�PB�P^?���kP�>�ZHEH�K��

�P^�lBCE@ElB^�BCB���kK�JB�E�EGG�K�BK0�?E�EAKBJ���kBJ�@?E�E��J

JKk�K?�?E0�V?E�P���@��K?�HE@?�?EV�E��B�lE�J�NBB�H�PM�E�H�PMK0���W?EJ

I�@EMC�@K��@�M��EJ�q�JK�BI)�=�E@?E�JU�B@?E�BVK@>B�@ET�B>�@�CB@D0�B

TKV�CD�E�?E0�V?E�AECDk�I�V�@?D���kKME���@KCK�BI�H�PM�H�PM���K�G��K?)

{HK@D��IHEJ�@E�J�E��@BHB?�JE��H�PM�YK�MBG)�|E�E�0�>�@EZ�CK�B^0��K

PJKK?�ME�E�B?D�TE��AS�G@>B0�SE?I�B�ZBC���XPSPJB)

�� ������/%!��-8�|P0�TE��AS�G@>B��K�PJKC��ME�E�B?D�B�ET�KHKCK����I�V�@?D��AS�GE�)�{HK@D�EVK�D�J�EME�JEJK�?E�)

T.����MU���� �-8�YEMH���PZ�E�@>�G�?D�B�?E0�V?E�H�PM�I�V�@?D��AS��GE��PJKC��ME�E�B?D�TE�M�PGB�@>B0��E�W?E�TE�H�PMBJ�T�BVB��J)�tE�

ZK?�AU?D0�E�B�W?E�@>�ZP?�G����@)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8��@T��NU0�>E?E�UK�ZB�P?���F�?�CE�BB0�T�K�>��@�E��C�HK^?�>�?�CE�@>BJ�IGU>EJ)����VK�BJ�?�PH�E�APHK?�?�J�ZB?D)

�� ������/%!��-8�rBV�E�I�VK�KG�T�K@@P���.5;;�;5�MM)�@?��BC��ET�E@E�?EJ0�V?EAU���K@?B����HEA�E�ECD�E��E@�E�K�l�>PCD?�?B��EK�BGPVK�

�BK��AS�G@>EME�IGU>����M�PGB�@>BS�k>EC�S�B�M�PGB�@>EME�IGU>��Q��

�AS�G@>BS0�?�>BJ�EA��GEJ�T�KHC�M�C���K@?B�W?B�T�KHJK?U���k>ECD�

Page 85: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�P^�T�EM��JJP)�p?E��UG��CE�AP��P^��K�>NB^)�=�B�@EE?�K?@?�P^�

LK��TECB?B>K�JEZ�E�AUCE�@EGH�?D�P@CE�BI�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU�M�PGB�U0

ZB�PLBK���RAS�GBB0�JEMCB���k>EC�S�HEA�E�ECD�E�BGPV�?D��AS�G@>B�

IGU>0�B��AS�GU����AS�G@>BS�k>EC�S�JEMCB�AU�HEA�E�ECD�E�BGPV�?D

M�PGB�@>B�)

T.����MU���� �-8�u@CB�M�PGB�U�@K�V�@�TK�KZB��^?0�V?E�RAS�GBIE?HKCK���E?�O�PGBB0�?E���W?EJ�JU�HECZ�U��B�B?D��KAI)�FEMH��I�AU��C

��XPSPJB0�I��BHKC0�>�>�JEB�H�PGDI�V�@?E�@JKICB@D���H��AS�G@>BJ�T�E�

BG�EkK�BKJ�BCB��AS�G@>BJB�@CE��JB)�[E?�?�>BK0�>�G�CE@D�AU0�JKCE�

VB�MCPAE>E����I?�VKCE�K>�0�B�W?E���HE�SE�EkE�E@EG��?D)�tU��@KMH�

@JE?�KCB�@�U@E>�0��E�@K�V�@���J�T�BSEHB?@I�@JE?�K?D�B�@�BGP�?EZK)

��I�@>�G�C�AU0�V?E�TEGBNBI�@�BGP��K�EVK�D�T�BI?��I��>EMH��@JE?�BkD

@�BGP0����?KAI�@JE?�I?�@�K�SP)�FEMH��JU�@JE?�BJ�@�K�SP0�JU��K�G�JK�

V�KJ0�>�>�H�PMBK�BG�G��W?EME�TK�KZB��^?)�Y�>�V?E�T�EACKJ���K@DJ�

@CEZ��I)��?E�JEZK?���@�EAwKHB�B?D\�Y�PH�E�E?�K?B?D����W?E?��ET�

�E@�Q�K@?D�CB�V?E�?E�TEGB?B��EK�@�EAKBS�@?E�E�0�G��V?E�JU�HECZ�U

HK�Z�?D@I0�B�V?E�TEJEZK?�EAwKHB�B?D@I)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�[ET�E@�AUC�TE@?��CK��?�>��JEZ�E�CB�TE@?��EB?D�BHK�?BV�E@?D�AKG�EA��G�����M�0�T�E@?E����TEGB?B��EJ�ETU?K\

T.����MU���� �-8�xKG�EA��G�����M��BHK�?BV�E@?D�JEZ�E�TE@?�EB?D?ECD>E����TEGB?B��EJ�ETU?K0��E�W?E��K@DJ��?�PH��I�G�H�V�)�X?�EB?D

ZK�BHK�?BV�E@?D����EA��GK����M��Q�W?E�EVK�D�CKM>�I�G�H�V�)�|E�>EMH�

E���@?�EB?@I�AKG�EA��G�����M�0�?E��PZ���?�>�I�ZK���AE?�0�>�>P^�JU

@K�V�@�GHK@D�T�E�EHBJ)�y��@?�KV�^@D�@���JB��E��?E�E����G0��E�HP�

J�^0�V?E�JU�PZK�V?E�?E�G��KJ�H�PM�E�H�PMK�B�P���@0�JEZK?�AU?D0�V?E�

?E���P?�B�BGJK�BCE@D)�Y�>�V?E�?�>BK��@?�KVB��PZ�U)�tEZK?�AU?D0

K@?D�B�H�PMBK�ETE�U0����>E?E�US�JEZ�E�@?�EB?D�BHK�?BV�E@?D)�y��K

G��^0�V?E�W?E�?�>EK0��E�V?E�?E�HECZ�E�AU?D�Q����K��EK0�V?E�?E�JEZ�E

���?B)

Page 86: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

��R��� ����0�g� �����.� ���� �#�0�!���..2��#�.$%�&�R!.�e !S�$�,�

�� ��� ���� �����d����� �k

����d� �����d��� ����T����������d� �h

tU�@KMEH�I�T�B@?PTBCB�>�EVK�D���Z�E��B�@CEZ�E��?KJK�Q�B�?K�

�K@U�@?E�E�)�=�EACKJ��HK�@?�B?KCD�E��KTEHwKJ��I�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU

KK�MCPAE>E�T�E���CBGB�E��?D�B�EA@PHB?D�����J>�S�EH�E���@?�KVB)�[

VKJ��KEASEHBJE@?D�EA@PZHK�BI�W?E��?KJU\�tU��@K�I�CIKJ@I�@�BHK�

?KCIJB�?EME0�>�>�?E�JEGB?@I�TK�KME�E��U��T�ENK@@)�tU���AC^H�KJ0

>�>���KJI�E?���KJK�B�T�EB@SEHI?���EALKJ�?E�PZK�@?��kBK��B?P�CD�

�UJB�H�P@?E�E��BK��@?�KVB�TE�P@?��E�CK�B^�JK��HE�K�BI�TEH�WMB�

HE��]]|)�]lBNB�CD�UK�TK�KME�E�U0���E@�E��EJ0�G�lB>@B�E��CB@D

���?E��@?�HBB0�>EMH��EA@PZH�^?@I��ET�E@U0�>E?E�UK�JEMP?�@?EI?D���

TE�K@?>K�H�I�APHPLBS�TK�KME�E�E�)�|E�TEGBNBB�@?E�E�0���@>ECD>E

JU�JEZKJ�@PHB?D0�EVK�D�H���E��K�JK�ICB@D�B�E@?�^?@I�T�E?B�ETE�

CEZ�UJB�B��G�BJEB@>C^V�^LBJB)�[�W?E��@B?P�NBB0�>E?E�P^�OBI

|EHBI���G��C�}�KP@?E�VB�E��?PTB>E�E��@?�ABCD�E@?D^~0��PZ�E�B@�

>�?D��E�UK�TP?B0�>E?E�UK�JEMCB�AU�T�B�K@?B�>�TK�KE@JU@CK�B^�@E�

��KJK��EME�T�ENK@@��P�KMPCB�E���BI)�XKMEH�I�JU�@?EBJ�TK�KH�G��

H�VK��Q����?B�AECKK�T�BKJCKJP^�B�T�EHP>?B��P^�@?��?KMB^�P�KMP�

CB�E���BI0�VKJ�TK�BEHBVK@>EK�8TEV?B��B?E�BVK@>EK:�T�KHwI�CK�BK

TEGBNB�)�q���EK��U@?PTCK�BK�TE@�ILK�E���@@JE?�K�B^�EH�E��BG

�EGJEZ�E@?K��EA�E�CK�BI�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME�HB�CEM��VK�KG�KME�@JK�

LK�BK����P@CE����CBG��B�?K�K@E��@?E�E�)

u@?D��K@>ECD>E� T�BVB�0� ?E�JEGILBS�TK�KME�E��U��T�ENK@@)

X�J�I�EVK�BH��I�BG��BS�Q�W?E��K�EGJEZ�E@?D����H���EJ�W?�TK����?B

�G�BJET�BKJCKJP^�lE�JPCP0�>E?E��I�JEMC��AU�T�BJB�B?D�EAK�@?E�

�E�U)�XC�AE@?D�JE?B��NBB0�@?BJPCB�P^LK��TK�KME�E��P^�HKI?KCD�

�E@?D0�JEZK?�AU?D�EAwI@�K���B��KHE@?�?EV�E��E@EG����E@?D^�@?E�

�E��JB��G�BJEG��B@BJE@?B)�|E0����JE���GMCIH0�AECKK�MCPAE>E��T�B�

VB�E��I�CIK?@I��KI@�EK�T�KH@?��CK�BK��K�?ECD>E�EA�B�?K�K@�S�T�E�

?B��B>�0��E�B�EA�B�?K�K@�S�@�EK��@?���U)�=EVKJP�JU�@VB?�KJ0�V?E

?�>E��TEHSEH�Q�@?�EB?D�P�KMPCB�E���BK����E@�E�K�TE�BJ��BI�B�����

Page 87: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

CBG��B�?K�K@E��APHK?�AECKK�T�EHP>?B��UJ\�F�>�JU�G��KJ0�TEGBNBB

@?E�E��Q�W?E0���EALKJ�?E0�?�KAE���BI0�W?E�PZK�>E�KV�UK�lE�JPCU

ZKC�KJEME��KkK�BI�>E�lCB>?��HCI�>�ZHE��@?E�E�U)�|E�TEGBNBB0�>�>

BG�K@?�E0���H@?��B��^?@I���H�B�?K�K@�JB0���>E?E�US�E?��Z�^?@I�B

AECKK�MCPAE>BK��PZHU)��KJ�G��VB?KCD�KK�>E�lCB>?�B�VKJ�E@?�KK�T�E�

?B�E@?EI�BK0�?KJ�AECDkKK��CBI�BK����KME���G�B?BK�B��EG�B>�E�K�BK

E>�GU��^?�EALK@?�K��UK0�?)K)���HCBV�E@?�UK�B�?K�K@U�B�TE?�KA�

�E@?B)�|K��UGU��K?�@EJ�K�B��?E?�l�>?0�V?E�EH�BJ�BG�@�JUS�@BCD�US

l�>?E�E�0�@TE@EA@?�P^LBS�J��BlK@?�NBB�>E�lCB>?�0�>�>���G�B�I��

CIK?@I�T�E?B�E��T���CK��E@?D0�BCB�@?EC>�E�K�BK�B�?K�K@E�)�=EW?E�

JP�@?��?KMBI���G�KkK�BI�>E�lCB>?��HECZ����>C^V�?D���@KAI�B�TE�

B@>�@TE@EAE��P@?��E�CK�BI�A�C��@��B�?K�K@E�)�|������K��@?�HBB

G��EZHK�BI�>E�lCB>?��KME���G�B?B^�@TE@EA@?�PK?�B���GCBVBK�NK��

�E@?�US�P@?��E�E>)�u@CB�>E�lCB>?��I�@B?P�NBI�JEZK?�@lE�JB�E�

��?D@I����E@�E�K�T�E?B�ETECEZ�US�NK��E@?K�0�?E����TP?B�>�lE�JB�

�E���B^�G�KCEME�>E�lCB>?��NK��E@?�UK�T�E?B�E�KVBI�T�K���L�^?@I

��T�E?B�EAE�@?�E�B�?K�K@E�)�=E�JK�K�lE�JB�E���BI�>E�lCB>?��T�E�

B@SEHB?�@�EKEA��G��I�>�B@?�CCBG�NBI�B�?K�K@E��@?E�E�0��KT�BJB�

�BJE@?D�>E?E�US��@K�I@�KK���VB��K?�E@EG����?D@I�T�E?B�E@?EILB�

JB�M�PTT�JB)���?K�K@U�EAwI�CI^?@I0���H��BJB���H@?��B��^?@I�TE�

GBNBB0�>E?E�UK0���@�E^�EVK�KHD0�HB>?P^?�>E�>�K?�UK�NKCB�B�HK��

@?�BI)�Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0����K�CD�E@?B0�H�BZK�BK�E?�NK��E@?�US���G�

CBVB��VK�KG�E@EG���BK�B�?K�K@E��>�TEGBNBIJ�EAEG��VBCE���G�B?BK

>E�lCB>?�)�=EW?EJP�CEMBV�E�T�KHTECEZB?D0�V?E���T�ENK@@K�P�KMPCB�

�E���BI�EA��?�EK�H�BZK�BK��E?�TEGBNB��>�B�?K�K@�J0���G�?KJ�B��PZ�

H�J�B�NK��E@?�UJ�P@?��E�>�J�TEJEZK?�@�BGB?D�E@?�E?P�>E�l�E�?��

NBB)�FEMH��EA@PZH�^?@I�TEGBNBB0���@BCP�?EME0�V?E�E�B�H�^?@I���HE@�

?�?EV�E�ZK@?>BS�lE�JPCB�E�>�S0�@>C�HU��K?@I��K��@KMH��TEGB?B��

��I�B�>E�@?�P>?B���I��?JE@lK���HCI�HB�CEM�)�[EGJEZ�E0���J�AUCE

AU�CKMVK�TE�I?D�H�PM�H�PM�0�K@CB�AU�JU�TK�KkCB����IGU>�B�?K�K@E�0

ET�@K�B��@?E�E��B�NK��E@?�US���GCBVB�0�TE@>ECD>P�W?E?�IGU>�Q�AE�

CKK�MCPAE>B�)�]��JK�KK�@TE@EA@?�PK?�>E�l�E�?�NBB0�VKJ�IGU>�TEGB�

NB�)�p?E�JEMCE�AU�H�?D�@?BJPC�B�TK�KME�E��EJP�T�ENK@@P)

��?K�K@U��KEASEHBJE����CBGB�E��?D�B�EA@PZH�?D�KLK�B�TE?EJP0

V?E�P���@0�AKG�@EJ�K�BI0�K@?D��K�?ECD>E�T�E?B�ETECEZ�UK0��E�B�@E@PLK�

@?�P^LBK�B�?K�K@U0�>E?E�UK��K�T�KHTEC�M�^?��G�BJ�EME�B@>C^VK�BI)

Page 88: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

xECKK�?EME0�JEZ�E����?B�B�EALBK�B�?K�K@U)����E?0�K@CB�JU�@PJKKJ�ET�K�

HKCB?D�B�I@�E�T�KH@?��B?D��K>E?E�UK�@E@PLK@?�P^LBK�BCB�H�ZK�EA�

LBK�B�?K�K@U0�?E�W?E0��EGJEZ�E0�TEG�ECB?���J�T�B�?B�>�TK�KlE�JPCB�

�E�>K���kBS�TEGBNB����AECKK�>E�@?�P>?B��EJ�>C^VK)�{���BK�B�TE�BJ��

�BK�B�?K�K@E��H�PME��@?E�E�U�TEG�ECB?���J�?�>�@lE�JPCB�E��?D��K�

��G�KkBJP^�@KMEH�I�G�H�VP0�V?EAU��KkK�BK��@K�?�>B�@?�CE��EGJEZ�UJ)

�]H��>E�@CEZ�E@?D��KHK�BI�TEHEA�EME�HB�CEM�0�>�>�PZK�E?JKV�CE@D

�UkK0�@E@?EB?��K�?ECD>E����KEASEHBJE@?B�TE�I?D�B�?K�K@U�T�E?B��B�

>�)�qE@?�?EV�E�?�PH�E��G�H�VK��I�CIK?@I�TE�BJ��BK�B�lE�JPCB�E���BK

@�EBS�@EA@?�K��US�B�?K�K@E�)�p?E�?�KAPK?0�TE�JK�DkK��JK�K0��C�HK�BI

TEC�E��B�lE�J�NBK��EA��>?P�CD�EJ�@E@?EI�BB�����GCBV�US�@lK��S

ZBG�B0���?�>ZK�E�?K�HK�NBIS���G�B?BI�BCB��KM�K@@�)�qCI���@>�U?BI�MCP�

AB��US0��K��@KMH��E@EG����US�B�?K�K@E��TECKG�E�AUCE�AU�E??�C>B��?D@I

E?�@lE�JPCB�E����US���NBE��CD�US�B�?K�K@E�0�?)K)�E?�E@EG����US�TE�

?�KA�E@?K��ME@PH��@?��)�]H��>E0�K@CB�JU�APHKJ�ME�E�B?D�E���NBE��CD�

�EJ�B�?K�K@K0�?E�T�BSEHB?@I�T�BG��?D0�V?E�E?��AE?>��@�JBS�>�B?K�BK�

KME�ET�KHKCK�BI�B�E@JU@CK�BK�MKETECB?BVK@>EME0�@ENB�CD�E�W>E�EJB�

VK@>EME0�>PCD?P��EME0�>E�lK@@BE��CD�EME�B�H�PMBS�T���JK?�E��lE�JB�

�E���BI���NBE��CD�EME�B�?K�K@��T�KH@?��CIK?�@EAE��HE@?�?EV�E�@CEZ�

�P^�T�EACKJP)�|�@>ECD>E���J�BG�K@?�E0�EAK�>E�lCB>?P^LBK�@?E�E�U

KLK��K�H�CB�VK?>BS�E?�K?E�����W?B��ET�E@U)

�F�G�CE@D�AU0�ME�E�I�T��>?BVK@>B�E�C^AE��T�EACKJK0�JU0�?�>�BCB

B��VK0�>�@�KJ@I��ET�E@��B�?K�K@E�)�|E�T�B�AECKK�@K�DKG�EJ�EA@PZHK�

�BB�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�@?�C>B��KkD@I�@�AECDkBJB�@CEZ�E@?IJB)�tU0��

E@�E��EJ0�>E�KV�E0�APHKJ�ME�E�B?D�E�TECB?BVK@>BS�B�?K�K@�S)���TEH

TECB?BVK@>BJB�B�?K�K@�JB�APHKJ�TEH��GPJK��?D�E@EG����EK�EAEALK��

�EK�TE�BJ��BK�TE?�KA�E@?K����NBE��CD�US�B�@ENB�CD�US�M�PTT�B�H�P�

MBS��>?E�E��TECB?BVK@>E��HKI?KCD�E@?B�B�TECB?BVK@>BS�E?�EkK�B�)�[

B�?K�K@�S�K@?D�@PAwK>?B���I�B�EAwK>?B���I�@?E�E�U)�]AwK>?B���I�@E�

@?��CI^L�I�B�?K�K@E��Q�W?E�?���K�CD��I�@ENB�CD�E�TECB?BVK@>�I�@B?P�

�NBI0���>E?E�E��JU�ZB�KJ)���?K�K@U0�>E?E�UK�JEMP?�AU?D�B��KE@EG���

��KJUJB0�T�EI�CI^?@I�����kK��ZBG�B�PZK����BHK�BHKECEMBB0����BHK

��NBE��CD�US�@BJ�ECE�)���J�K�>�ZK?@I0�AUCE�AU�TECKG�E�E@EG��?D�B@�

?EV�B>�T�EB@SEZHK�BI�W?BS�@BJ�ECE�0�TE?EJP�V?E0��K@JE?�I����@�E^

@PAwK>?B��P^�T�B�EHP0�E�B�EVK�D��K�CD�U�B��TEC�K��K�CD�E�HK�@?�P^?

���TECB?B>P0�>E?E��I�H�CK>E��K��@KMH���P>E�EH@?�PK?@I�?ECD>E�@EG��?KCD�

Page 89: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�UJB�HK�@?�BIJB�B�V�@?E�TEH�K�ZK����CBI�B^�@?BSB��US�T�ENK@@E�)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�@PAwK>?B���I�@E@?��CI^L�I�B�?K�K@E��Q�W?E�TE�BJ��

�BK���kBS�TE?�KA�E@?K�)����K��@KMH��W?E���kK�TE�BJ��BK�HK�@?�B?KCD�

�E�E?�KV�K?�?�KAE���BIJ��K�CD�E@?B)�p?E�Q�EH���BG�?�PH�E@?K�)�q�PM�I

G�>C V�K?@I���?EJ0�V?E�TECB?BVK@>BK�B�?K�K@U��K�MEJEMK��U)�|��@�JEJ

HKCK�@CEZ�E����?B�?K�EAEAL�^LBK�TE?�KA�E@?B0�>E?E�UK�E?�KV�CB�AU

B�?K�K@�J��@KS�@CEK��EALK@?��)�=EW?EJP0�>EMH��JU�G�HPJU��KJ@I�E�TE�

GBNBIS0��UH�BM�KJUS�@?E�E��JB�>E�lCB>?�0��EG�B>�K?��ET�E@0���>�>E�

@?KTK�B�E�B�E?��Z�^?�B�?K�K@U��@KME���@KCK�BI�@?���U\�=E@>ECD>P

C^AEK�GHE�E�EK�EALK@?�E��K�JEZK?�AU?D�EH�E�EH�UJ�B�T�KH@?��CIK?

@EAE��@CEZ�P^�@?�P>?P�P0�@E@?EILP^�BG���GCBV�US�@?��?0�M�PTT�B�EAwK�

HB�K�B�0�BJK^LBS�@�EB�E@EAUK�B�?K�K@U0�@>E�KK��@KME0��K�K�CD�E0�V?E�

AU�HK�@?�K���I�TECB?B>��@?�EBC�@D�����@KEALBS�B�?K�K@�S)�q�PMEK�HKCE0

V?E�TECB?BVK@>B��>?B���I�V�@?D�EALK@?���JEZK?�@?�EB?D�@�E^�T�EM��J�

JP�?�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�V?EAU�TE��EGJEZ�E@?B�PVB?U��?D�B�@E�JKL�?D�B�?K�

�K@U�AECDkB�@?���EALK@?��)�[EGJEZ�E0��K��@K�TECB?B>B�@?�KJI?@I�>

?EJP0�V?EAU�@K�DKG�E�B�E?>�U?E����CBGB�E��?D�B�T�EME���B��?D�B�?K�K�

@U0�CKZ�LBK���E@�E�K�BS�TEGBNB��B�HK�@?�B�)�|E�J�K�T�KH@?��CIK?@I0

V?E�E@EG����?D0����V?E���HK�@?�B?KCD�E@?B���T���CK���?��BCB�B��I�TE�

CB?B>�0��KEASEHBJE)�u@CB�JU��K�APHKJ�E�BK�?B�E��?D@I���W?BS��ET�E�

@�S0�?E��K�@PJKKJ�E?CBVB?D�TECB?B>P0���T���CK��P^����AC�ME����EH�0�E?

EA@CPZB���BI�B�?K�K@E��T���ILK��WCB?U0���T�BJK�)�tEZ�E�?�>ZK��K

G�JK?B?D0�>�>�@>C�HU��K?@I�T���HE>@�CD��I�@B?P�NBI0�T�B�>E?E�E��T�B�

E�B?K?�B�?K�K@E��?B?PCD�E����NBB���T�E�EHBJE��TECB?B>K���VB��K?

T�E?B�E�KVB?D�B@?B��EJP���NBE��CD�EJP�B�?K�K@P�ME@PH��@?��0�>E?E�

�EK�@?�EB?�W?����NBI)�|��JE���GMCIH0���@@JE?�K�BK��ET�E@E�0�@�IG���

�US�@�ET�KHKCK�BKJ���NBE��CD�EME�B�?K�K@�0�@TE@EA@?�E��CE�AU�?EJP0

V?EAU�EALK@?�E�AECDkK�E�BK�?B�E��CE@D���T�EB@SEHILBS�TECB?BVK@�

>BS�T�ENK@@�S�B�JEMCE�E@PLK@?�CI?D�AECKK�E@EG����U���UAE�0���G��VB?0

B�AECKK��>?B��E�PV�@?�E��?D���TECB?BVK@>E��ZBG�B�B��K�CBGE�U��?D

@�EB�TECB?BVK@>BK�B�M��ZH��@>BK�T����)��?�>0�I@�EK�T�KH@?��CK�BK�E

@EA@?�K��US�B�?K�K@�S�I�CIK?@I��KEASEHBJUJ�P@CE�BKJ�HCI��KHK�BI

>E�@?�P>?B��EME�HB�CEM��@�T�E?B�ETECEZ�E��@?E�E�E�)

[�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EJ�>E�lCB>?K�TK�K>�KLB��^?@I��K�?ECD>E�M�P�

GB�@>BK�B��AS�G@>BK�B�?K�K@U0��E�?�>ZK�B�P@?�KJCK�BI�AECKK�>�PT�

�US�BM�E>E�0�V?E�HECZ�E�PVB?U��?D@I�>�ZHE��BG�@?E�E�)�=ECB?B>�

Page 90: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

?�>�@CEZ��0�V?E����K>E?E�US�JEJK�?�S�?�PH�E�E?HKCB?D�EH�E�E?�H�P�

MEME)�|E�TE�BJ�?D�BJK��E�@�EB�B�?K�K@U�AKG���Kk�BS��CBI�B�0�E?�

CBV�?D�BS�E?�B�?K�K@E��AECKK�>�PT�US�@BC0�G�B�?K�K@E����US����K�

MBE�K0� T�E@?E��KEASEHBJE)�F��>�G@>BK�B�?K�K@U� G�T�H�US� @?���0

��T�BJK�0�EVK�D�SE�EkE�@lE�JPCB�E���U0�E@EG���U�B�T�EME�E�K�

�U)�[�@�IGB�@�}sKC>E�UJ�TP?KJ~�E�B�HE@?�?EV�E�V�@?E�E@�KL�^?@I

��CB?K��?P�K0�B��K?��B>�>BS�@EJ�K�B�0�V?E���@CEZ�EJ�TK�KTCK?K�BB

B�?K�K@E��@EA@?�K��E�>��>�G@>BS�@PAwK>?E��B�?K�K@U�{�T�H��BM���

^?�@K�DKG�P^��ECD)�[E?0���T�BJK�0�V?E�TBkK?��JK�B>��@>B��TECB�

?ECEM�R)�FEW��E?�E@B?KCD�E�O�PGBB��}O�PGBI�>�>�AU�HK�ZB?���@�EBS

�P>�S�>C^V�E?��E�E?����F��>�G0�I�CIK?@I�TC�NH��JEJ�HCI��USEH��G��

T�H�US�@?����>�F�@TB^�B�sKC>E�EJP�TP?B~)�O�PGBI0�T�EV�E�E�BK��

?B�E�����I����XsR0�I�CIK?@I�MC���UJ�@E^G�B>EJ�XsR����KMBE�K)

=E�@CE��J��JK�B>��@>EME�@K��?E���X)�x��P�AK>�0�O�PGBI�Q�W?E�M���B�

N��JKZHP�|RY]�B��E�UJ�sKC>E�UJ�TP?KJ0�E���I�CIK?@I�E@�E��UJ

T��?�K�EJ�YP�NBB0�@E^G�BNU�XsR0�V?E�EVK�D���Z�E�@E�J�EMBS�?E�

VK>� G�K�BI�Q� @?��?KMBVK@>E�0� �EK��E��B�>EJJK�VK@>E�)��@SEHI�BG

W?EME0��K@?�ABCD�E@?D�O�PGBB�JEZK?�TE@?��B?D�TEH�PM�EGP��K@D��KMB�

E�0���>E?E�EJ�G�B�?K�K@E����{�T�H0�B�TEW?EJP��ET�E@U�@?�ABCD�E@�

?B����F��>�GK�I�CI^?@I�?�>ZK�@?��?KMBVK@>BJB�B�?K�K@�JB�G�T�H�

�US�@?���)�|�T�BJK�0��K@?�P>?P�BG�NBI�B�PCPVkK�BK�B�l��@?�P>�

?P�U�?���@TE�?�US�B�>EJJP�B>�NBE��US�J�MB@?��CK��?�>ZK�I�CI�

K?@I��K�?ECD>E�B�?K�K@EJ�@�JBS�@?�����Z�EME�F��>�G�0��E�B�{�T�H�)

FEMH��T�KH@?��B?KCB�T���B?KCD@?���XsR�TE@?��BCB�TK�KH�XK��?EJ

�ET�E@�EA�P�KCBVK�BB�TEJELB�@?����J�RGBB�B�F��>�G�0�E�B���G��CB

W?P�T�EM��JJP��KAECDkBJ��>C�HEJ���APHPLKK��JK�B>��@>EME����E�

H�)�YE�K@?D���T�EME���B��KJUS�B�?K�K@�S�{�T�H���KVD��K�BHK?�E��>C��

HK���APHPLKK�F��>�G��BCB�>�>EME��BAPHD�>��>�G@>EME����EH�)�]H��>E

TE�I?D��ECD���Kk�BS�@BC�?EZK��K��@KMH��T�E@?E)�Y�>0���T�BJK�0��

E?CBVBK�E?�G�T�H�US�HK�Z��0�HE@?�?EV�E�TE@CKHE��?KCD�E�HK�@?�P�

^LBS����KMBE�K�B���I?�E�T�EME���B��^LBS�@�EB�B�?K�K@U����F���

>�GK0�zE@@BI�JKVK?@I�JKZHP�T�E?B�E�KVB�UJB�W>E�EJBVK@>BJB�B�TE�

CB?BVK@>BJB�B�?K�K@�JB�B��KHK?�HE@?�?EV�E��KTE@CKHE��?KCD�P^

TECB?B>P)�zE@@B�@>BK�MKETECB?BVK@>BK�B�?K�K@U�GHK@D�@?�C>B��^?�

@I�@�W>E�EJBVK@>BJB)�OKETECB?BVK@>BK�B�?K�K@U�zE@@BB�@E@?EI?��

EAK@TKVK�BB�@?�ABCD�E@?B����F��>�GK0�V?E�PHK�ZB��CE�AU�KME�E?�}��@�

Page 91: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

>�VB���BI~0�PVB?U��I�@CEZ�EK�TECEZK�BK����XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK)�R�@

H�PME��@?E�E�U�Q�W>E�EJBVK@>BK�B�?K�K@U�HB>?P^?�zE@@BB�T�E?B�E�

TECEZ�P^�TECB?B>P)�]TI?D�JU��EG���L�KJ@I�>�W?EJP��Kl?K�E@�EJP

TP?B�Q�K@CB��Z�U��F��>�G�APHK?�@?�ABCD�UJ0�?E0�@>E�KK��@KME0��Kl?D

TE?KVK?���EASEH�zE@@BB)�=ECPV�K?@I0�V?E���W>E�EJBVK@>EJ�TC��K�zE@�

@BI�J�EMEK�?K�IK?�E?�@?�ABCD�E@?B����F��>�GK)�tK?��BK�JKZHP�W?BJB

B�?K�K@�JB�@BCD�E�E?��Z�K?@I�B����TE@�KH�BVK@>E���ECB�zE@@BB��

P�KMPCB�E���BB�>��>�G@>BS�>E�lCB>?E�0�B�����@K��KK�TECB?B>K����F���

>�GK)�p?���KET�KHKCK��E@?D�@PLK@?�K��E�@>�GU��K?@I�B����TECEZK�BB

RAS�GBB0��ECD�>E?E�E��@��E@@B�@>E��?EV>B�G�K�BI�TE@?EI��E�JK�IK?@I

��G��B@BJE@?B�E?�?EME0�>�>BK��E@@B�@>BK�B�?K�K@U���H���U��JEJK�?

AECKK��>?P�CD�U)�XCEZ�E��K@?B���GME�E��EA�B�?K�K@�S0�>EMH��TECB?B�

>��ME@PH��@?���KTE@CKHE��?KCD��0�BK���SBI�B�?K�K@E���K��U@?�EK��0

�K?�@A�C��@B�E����E@?B���P?�K��KME�B���Kk�KME���NBE��CD�EME�B��

?K�K@�)���@?E�HK>C��B�P^?@I�EH�B�B�?K�K@U0����K�CD��I�TECB?B>��@?�E�

B?@I�@EMC�@�E�H�PMBJ�E�BK�?B��J)�|�HE�@>�G�?D0�V?E�W?E�������E��@?K�

TK�B�JEZK?�E?�E@B?D@I�B�>��AS�G@>E�0�B�>�M�PGB�@>E��@?E�E�K)

[TEC�K��EGJEZ�E0�V?E�TECB?BVK@>BK�E�BK�?B�U�>�PT�US�@?���

JEMP?���VKJ�?E�@E�T�H�?D�@�B�?K�K@�JB�@�JBS��KMBE�E�0��E��PZ�E

E@EG����?D0�V?E�W?E�H�CK>E��K�EH�E�B�?E�ZK)�|�J0�>E�KV�E0�EVK�D�T�B�

I?�E�@����B��?D�@KAI�@���G�B?UJB�K��ETK�@>BJB�@?����JB0��E��K�

�CD�UK����CEMBB�V�LK��@K�?�>B�JEZ�E����?B�@�@B?P�NBK����@?����S

�K@>ECD>E�B�EME�P�E��I)�=EW?EJP�J�K�>�ZK?@I�PJK@?�UJ��U@>�GU���

�BK�A��GBCD@>EME�TECB?ECEM��m)�p)�F��HEGE)�]��TBkK?��}XENB�CD��I

?>��D�@E��KJK��EME�EALK@?���B@>C^VB?KCD�E�@CEZ��)�[��KK��TCK�

?K��NKCU��@TK>?��NKCK��B�B�?K�K@E����GCBV�US�M�PTT�B�B�HB�BHE�)

=�EM�K@@�ET�KHKCIK?@I���?K�JB��S���G�EEA��G�US�8H�ZK���G�E��T�

���CK��US:�G�H�V)))�p?B�G�H�VB�@KMEH�I�V�@?E�TE�EZH�^?@I�MCEA�CD�

�E�0����K���NBE��CD�E��T���HBMJE�0�?E�K@?D�E�B�T�EKNB�P^?@I�BG�G�

M���BNU������NBE��CD�UK�EALK@?��0�>E?E�UK�JEMP?�AU?D��KME?E�U

�Kk�?D�W?B�G�H�VB~)�qKCE��K���?EJ0�V?E�G�T�H��I�E�BK�?�NBI�BCB��E@�

@B�@>�I�E�BK�?�NBI��KSE�Ek�)�[ET�E@���?EJ0�T�BkCE�CB�EALK@?�E�>

@EMC�@B^�E?�E@B?KCD�E�@�EKME�APHPLKME0�E@EG����E�CB�E�E�ET�KHK�

CBCE�@�E^�E�BK�?�NB^0�@EE?�K?@?�PK?�CB�BHKECEMBI�@BCD�EME�@E^G�

�B>����NBE��CD�UJ�B�?K�K@�J)���EMH��?K�NK��E@?B0�>E?E�UK��JK@?K

@�VDBJB�?E�B�?K�K@�JB�T�B��E@I?@I�BG��K0�E@?�^?@I�CBkD�HK>C��B�

Page 92: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�PKJUJB��K���@BCP�BS��K@E@?EI?KCD�E@?B0���TE?EJP0�V?E���kB�EALK�

@?����K�ME?E�U�T�B�I?D�BS�TE�@PLK@?�P)�=E?EJP0�V?E�KLK��K�G��K�kK�

�E�EAK@TKVK�BK�?KS�A�GE�US�P@CE�B�0���>E?E�US�JEMC��AU?D�T�EHKC��

���TEHME?E�B?KCD��I���P?�K��II���AE?�)

XKMEH�I�P���@�APHK?��EGJEZ�E@?D��E���KJI�T��>?BVK@>E����AE?U

EA@PHB?D���kK��BHK�BK�>E�>�K?�US�B�?K�K@E��M�PGB�@>E��B��AS�G@�

>E��@?E�E�0�TEW?EJP�I�EVK�D�>��?>E�>E@�P@D�W?EME��ET�E@�)�F�>�PZK

ME�E�BCE@D��UkK0�@�J��T�EACKJ��ET�KHKCK�BI�B�?K�K@E����@?ECD>E

@CEZ���B�J�EMETC��E��0�V?E�HECZ���@?�?D�?KJE��@K�DKG�US����CB?B�

VK@>BS�B@@CKHE���B�)�F�?EJP�ZK0�H���EK��U@?PTCK�BK�TE@�ILK�E��K

@?ECD>E��UI�CK�B^�B�?K�K@E��M�PGB�0��AS�GE��B�H�PMBS�G�B�?K�K@E�

����US�@?E�E��8W?E�AUCE�AU��K�EGJEZ�E���?�>BS�PG>BS���J>�S:0�@>ECD�

>E�TETU?>K���@@JE?�K�BI��EGJEZ�US�T�KBJPLK@?��@�JEME�TEHSEH�0

E@�E����EME����TE�BJ��BB�B�?K�K@E��@?E�E�)

�?�>0�K@CB�>��?>E�ME�E�B?D�EA�B�?K�K@�S�O�PGBB0�?E0����JE���GMCIH0

W?E0�T�KZHK��@KME0�P>�KTCK�BK�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B0���G�B?BK�lKHK��CBG�

J��B�@�JEPT���CK�BI0�EAK@TKVK�BK�@?�ABCD�E@?B0��KEASEHBJE�0���V�@?�

�E@?B0�HCI�B��K@?BNB�0�@�IG���US�@��Kl?KT�E�EHEJ)�X?�ABCD�E@?B�ZK

PM�EZ�K?0���TK��P^�EVK�KHD0��KP�KMPCB�E����E@?D�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME

>E�lCB>?�)�=EW?EJP�TEC�EJ�@k?�A�EK�P�KMPCB�E���BK0������H���EJ�W?��

TK���SEZHK�BK�SE?I�AU�T�KH���B?KCD�E���G�BJET�BKJCKJE��lE�JPCU

P@?E�VB�EME�@E@PLK@?�E���BI0��K@EJ�K��E0�I�CIK?@I�B�?K�K@EJ�O�PGBB)

n>�KTCK�BK�B���G�B?BK�HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�E@�E��M�PGB�@>E��ME@PH��@?�K��

�E@?B�?�>ZK�JEZ�E�E?�K@?B�>�E@�E��UJ�M�PGB�@>BJ�B�?K�K@�J)�]AK@�

TKVK�BK���P?�K��K��B�?KM��NBB0��K@EJ�K��E0�T�KH@?��CIK?���NBE�

��CD�U��B�?K�K@�O�PGBB)�|K�ME�E�I�PZK�EA�E@K?B�@>E��B��HZ��@>E��T�E�

ACKJ�S0��ET�E@U�B�?KM��NBB�E@?�E�@?EI?����M���BN�S�@�R�JK�BK��B�RGK��

A��HZ��EJ)�p?��T�EACKJ��E?��Z�K?@I�B����G�H�V�S�JKZHP���EH�E��TE�

CB?B>B�O�PGBB)�[�B�?K�K@�S�O�PGBB0���T�BJK�0�@EAC^HK�BK�A�C��@���

E?�EkK�BIS�@�R�JK�BK��B�RGK�A��HZ��EJ0�B�?K�K@U�>E?E�US0���@�E^

EVK�KHD0���G�E��T���CK�U��RGK�A��HZ���E�BK�?B�E����T�EG�T�H�E0�KME

ACBZ��kBK�@E^G�B>B�Q�YP�NBI0�[KCB>EA�B?��BI�B�XsR0�R�JK�BI�ZK

AECDkK���T���CK������zE@@B^�B�����)�XCEZ��I�G�H�V��Q�A�C��@B�E��?D

JKZHP�zE@@BK��B�{�T�HEJ��K�?ECD>E�E?�E@B?KCD�E��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>�

?��B�@EA@?�K��EME���P?�K��KME���G�B?BI0��E�B��E��G�BJEE?�EkK�BIS�@

RGK�A��HZ��EJ�B�R�JK�BK�)

Page 93: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

u@CB�E�BK�?B�E��?D@I����J�K�BK��A@EC^?�EME�AECDkB�@?���M�P�

GB�@>BS�TECB?B>E��B���@KCK�BI0�?E��EG���LK�BK�RAS�GBB�TEH�>E�?�

�ECD�?ABCB@@>BS��C�@?K��E�B���G��CB�AU�E@�E��UJ���NBE��CD�UJ

B�?K�K@EJ)�{HK@D�E?>�U��^?@I�AECDkBK��EGJEZ�E@?B�HCI�HB@>P@@B�0

TE?EJP�V?E�K@?D�B�H�PM�I�?EV>��G�K�BI0�@EMC�@�E�>E?E�E����B�?K�K@�SO�PGBB0�T�KZHK��@KME0��K��E@@?����CB��?D�>E�lCB>?EMK��UK��G�BJE�

E?�EkK�BI0���T�BG��?D�@PLK@?�P^LKK�TECEZK�BK�HKC�B�P@?��E�B?D

T��?�K�@>BK�E?�EkK�BI�@�RAS�GBK�)�p?E�@TE@EA@?�E��CE�AU�HKJE>�

��?BVK@>EJP���G�B?B^�EAKBS�@?����@E��@KJB�M����?BIJB�@EAC^HK�

�BI�T����VKCE�K>�0�EAK@TKVB��CE�AU�HECME@�EV�P^�@?�ABCD�E@?D�BP>�KTBCE�AU�JKZHP���EH�U��T�K@?BZ�O�PGBB)

=E�I?�E0�V?E�����GCBV�UK�TK�BEHU�B@?E�BVK@>EME���G�B?BI�B��

?K�K@U�JEMP?�JK�I?D@I)��?E�>�@�K?@I��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U0�?E�PM�EG�

�UZB���B^��AS�G@>EME����EH�� PZK����T�E?IZK�BB�H�PS� @?ECK?B�

HB>?PK?��@K�E@�E��UK�B�?K�K@U��AS�GE�)�|��H���EJ�W?�TK�JEZ�E�@>��G�?D0�V?E�E@�E��UJ���NBE��CD�UJ�B�?K�K@EJ�RAS�GBB�I�CIK?@I�EAK@�

TKVK�BK�@?�ABCD�E@?B�B��KG��B@BJE@?B��AS�G@>EME�ME@PH��@?���>�>

M����?��@ES���K�BI��AS�G@>E��BHK�?BV�E@?B�B�>PCD?P�U)�[�@�IGB�@

W?BJ�TECB?B>��RAS�GBB�HECZ���E�BK�?B�E��?D@I����EAK@TKVK�BK�P@�

?E�VB�EME���G�B?BI���@CEZ�US�MKETECB?BVK@>BS�P@CE�BIS)�[�P?�K��

�BJ��@TK>?EJ���NBE��CD�EME�B�?K�K@��RAS�GBB�I�CIK?@I�B�?KM��NBI�@KME�J�EME��NBE��CD�EME�EALK@?��0���G�B?BK�M��ZH��@>BS�B�TECB�

?BVK@>BS�HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�B�@?B?P?E�)�XTKNBlBVK@>BJ�B�?K�K@EJ

H���EME�TK�BEH��I�CIK?@I�@E�JKLK�BK�EAK@TKVK�BI�HKJEM��lBVK@>E�

AKGET�@�E@?B��AS�GE�0�@ES���K�BI��AS�G@>EME�IGU>��B�>PCD?P�U�@�M��

���?BIJB�@EAC^HK�BI�T�����@KS�M��ZH���RAS�GBB)�OE�E�I�EA�B�?K��K@�S��AS�GE�0�T�BHK?@I��K��P?D@I�>��ET�E@P�E��KMEJEMK��E@?B0��KE�

H�E�EH�E@?B�E@EG����KJUS�EALK@?�EJ�B�?K�K@E�)�FEMH��JB�E�EK�@E�

EALK@?�E�VK�KG�zE@@B^�B�X|O�TU?�K?@I�BGECB�E��?D�RAS�GB^0�T�KH�

TEC�M�I0�V?E�W?E�TEHSEHIL�I�lE�J��H��CK�BI����RAS�GB^0�?E�V�@?D

�AS�GE���BHB?���W?E��JK�K��K�?ECD>E�AECDkEK�GCE0��E�B�@�EKEA��G�EK@�KH@?�E�G�LB?U�@�EK��@�JEAU?�E@?B�E?��CBI�BI�J�@@E�E��>PCD?P�

�U)�=EW?EJP�H�ZK���?�>EJ�J�CK�D>EJ�EALK@?�K0�>�>��AS�G@>EK0��K

T�BSEHB?@I�ME�E�B?D�E�KHB�EJ�TE�BJ��BB�@�EBS�B�?K�K@E�)�q�ZK

@�KHB��AS�G@>EME���@KCK�BI�E@EG����KJUK�B�?K�K@U���GCBV�^?@I0��

K@CB�PVK@?D�J�EME��NBE��CD�U��@E@?���RAS�GBB0�lE�JPCB�E���BK

EALBS�B�?K�K@E���AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U�T�KH@?��CIK?@I�HE@?�?EV�E�@CEZ�

Page 94: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�E��G�H�VK�)�8p?E�E?�E@B?@I0�>E�KV�E�ZK0��K�?ECD>E�>��AS�G@>EJP�EA�

LK@?�P):

F�>�PZK�AUCE�@>�G��E0��>?P�CBG�NBI�@E�JKL�^LBS@I�B�EALBS0��

�K�T�E?B�ETECEZ�US0� B�?K�K@E��APHK?� @TE@EA@?�E��?D�T�EM�K@@P

P�KMPCB�E���BI)�q�ZK��K��H���I@D���MCPAE>B�����CBG�B�?K�K@E�0�JEZ�

�E��UI�B?D�EALB��HCI�RAS�GBB�B�O�PGBB�B�?K�K@���P�KMPCB�E���BB

>E�lCB>?��B�P@?��E�CK�BB�@?�ABCD�E@?B����KMBE�K)�[�NKCIS���G�K�

kK�BI�>E�lCB>?��J�EMBK�TECB?ECEMB�P>�GU��^?�����KEASEHBJE@?D

@E@�KHE?EVK�BI����EALBS�B�?K�K@�S)�Y�>0�O)�Y��S���tEP���B�@VB?��

K?0�V?E�HE�EA@PZHK�BI�@?�?P@��RAS�GBB�EALBJ�B�?K�K@EJ�I�CIK?@I

@EGH��BK�@B�?KG��?�>BS�@ENB�CD�US�B�TECB?BVK@>BS�M����?B�0�>E?E�

�UK�EAK@TKVB��CB�AU�JB����RAS�GBB�B�@T���KHCB�EK���G�KkK�BK�>E��

lCB>?�0�AKGET�@�E@?D���@KCK�BI�B�W>E�EJBVK@>EK�AC�MEHK�@?�BK0�?)K)

A�GB@�UK�TE?�KA�E@?B����EH�)�XEMC�@�E�[)��B�B>A�0�@E��KJK��UK

HKA�?U�E�lE�JK��AS�G@>E��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�HECZ�U�@JK�B?D@I�?K�

J�?B>E��EALBS�B�?K�K@E�)�]H��>E�@KMEH�I�KLK�?�PH�E���G��?D��@K

�EGJEZ�UK�EALBK�B�?K�K@U)�=EW?EJP�TET�EAPKJ0�TE�>����K��JK�K0

�UVCK�B?D�?K�@lK�U0���>E?E�US�JEZ�E�AUCE�AU��K@?B�TEB@>�@E�JK@�

?BJUS�BCB�EALBS�HCI�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB�B�?K�K@E�)�Y�>0���T�BJK�0

EH�E��BG�?�>BS�@lK��J�K�T�KH@?��CIK?@I�@E�K�kK�@?�E���BK���P?�

�K��K��ZBG�B)�|�HKZH��O�PGBB������Kk�^^�TEJELD�B���HKZH��RA�

S�GBB������Kk�KME�@E^G�B>�0�>E?E�U��TEJEM�AU��KkB?D�T�EACKJP

>E�lCB>?�0��K�HECZ�U�T���CBGE��?D�TETU?>B�BG�P?�B�E�M��BGE��?D

B� EAK@TKVB?D�T�EHP>?B��EK�lP�>NBE�B�E���BK� @�EK�� W>E�EJB>B0

@T���KHCB�P^�@B@?KJP�T���E@PHBI0���G�B?EK�JK@?�EK�@�JEPT���CK�

�BK0�@�EAEH�P^�B�B�?K�@B��P^�EALK@?�K��P^�ZBG�D�B�?)H)

]?>�G�E?�P@?��K�kBS�@SKJ��E��G�BJEE?�EkK�BIS0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0

?EZK�AUC�AU�TECKGK��B�HCI�RAS�GBB0�B�HCI�O�PGBB)�[E���KJK���X?�CB�

���K@?K@?�K���I�HB��JB>���G�BJEE?�EkK�B����kBS����EHE��AUC�

���PkK����K�CBG�NBK���M�K@@B��US�TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�RAS�GBB�TC��

�E�)�]H�E�?ECD>E�B@>P@@?�K��EK�TK�K@KCK�BK�ZB?KCK��M�PGB�@>BS�@KC

��RAS�GB^0�NKCK��T���CK��E�AB�kKK�TE�@�JE��AECD�E��HCI��AS�GE�

HKJEM��lBVK@>E��T�EACKJK0�@HKC�CE��KBGAKZ�UJ�H�CD�K�kKK�PMCPA�

CK�BK�>E�lCB>?�)�[E�J�EMEJ�BJK��E�?EMH��AUC��G�CEZK����KM�?B��

��I�T���HBMJ�0�G�H�^L�I�H�CD�K�kKK�PSPHkK�BK��G�BJEE?�EkK�B�

H�PS����EHE�)�p?E?�TC���?EMH���K�AUC�E@PLK@?�CK��HE�>E�N�0��E��

Page 95: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

>�>EJ�?E�@JU@CK�TEHEA��I�@SKJ���KkK�BI��AS�G@>E��T�EACKJU�T�E�

HECZ�K?��CBI?D����PJU�B�@KMEH�I)�t�EMBK���M�PGB�@>EJ�EALK@?�K��K

E@EG��^?��EGHK�@?�BI�W?EME�T�EkCEME0�J�EMBK��K���GHKCI^?�TEHEA�

�U��TEHSEH0��E�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU���@E��KJK��E��TECB?B>K�TK�K@?�CB

T�EI�CI?D@I�@CKHU�@?��EME�JUkCK�BI0��KHE@?�?EV�E�T�E@?E�G�AU?D0�PZ�E�E@EG����E�E?>�G�?D@I�E?�TEHEA�EME�TEHSEH�)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E��K�

>E?E�UK�P@?��K�kBK�@SKJU�K@?D�B���T�KH@?��CK�BIS��AS�G@>E��@?E�

�E�U0�BS�J�K�@CEZ�KK�E@EG��?D�B��UVCK�B?D)�[�W?EJ�T�ENK@@K�E@�E�

AEZHK�BI�E?�@?��US�@SKJ��K�EGJEZ�E�EAE�?B@D�AKG�@K�DKG�EME�HB��

CEM��JKZHP�EALK@?�K��E@?D^�H�PS�@?E�E�)XKMEH�I�NKCB�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB��E�J�EMEJ�ET�KHKCI^?@I�>E��

lCB>?EJ)�t�K�T�KH@?��CIK?@I0�V?E�PSEH�E?�W?E��>E�lCB>?�E��BHKE�

CEMBB0�lE�JPCB�E���BK�TEGB?B��US0�@?��?KMBVK@>BS0�TE�I?�US��@K�

JP�EALK@?�P�NKCK��AUCB�AU���B�?K�K@�S�EAKBS�@?E�E�)

[TEC�K�@E�JK@?BJUJ�B�?K�K@EJ�I�CIK?@I���G�B?BK�M��ZH��@>E�ME�EALK@?�����RAS�GBB�B�O�PGBB)�=E@>ECD>P�EH�BJ�BG���Z�K�kBS

>E��K��>E�lCB>?�� I�CIK?@I�T�EACKJ�� W?�BVK@>E��BHK�?BlB>�NBB0

��G�B?BK�M��ZH��@>EME�@�JE@EG���BI�@JIMVB?�W?�BVK@>B��>EJTE�K�?

��E?�EkK�BIS�JKZHP�C^HDJB�B�APHK?�@TE@EA@?�E��?D��E�J�CBG�NBB

�G�BJEE?�EkK�B�0���G�B?B^�@�IGK���K�?ECD>E����W?�BVK@>E��TEV�K)

qKJE>��?BG�NBI�EALK@?�K��US�B�@?B?P?E��JEMC��AU�@TE@EA@?�E���?D�@EGH��B^�P@CE�B�0��KEASEHBJUS0�V?EAU�@H�B�P?D�@�JK�?�E��?EV�

>B�T�EACKJU0�>E?E�UK�@KMEH�I�>�ZP?@I��K��G�KkBJUJB)�Y�>BK0����

T�BJK�0�>�>�T�EACKJ��AKZK�NK�)�|��JE���GMCIH0���@JKLK�BB��>NK��

?E����W?EJ��ET�E@K�?EZK�JEZK?�AU?D��G�BJ�U��B�?K�K@)�Y�>0�K@CB�AU

��O�PGBB��JK@?E�?EME0�V?EAU�E@?��CI?D�W?P�T�EACKJP��KG�ZB��^LK����E��B�AD^LBJ�TE��K���J���MPJK�?EJ���B�lE�J�NBE��E���E��K�@

RAS�GBK�0�@KMEH�I�AECDkK�G��ICB@D�T����JB�AKZK�NK����@�JE��O�P�

GBB0���RAS�GBI0��JK@?E�?EME0�V?EAU��K��I?�E�E??�C>B��?D�T�KHCEZK�

�BI�TE�BS��EG���LK�B^0�I@�E�T�EME�E�BC��AU�@�EB��K�CD�UK�ET�@K�

�BI0�@�IG���UK�@�PM�EZ�^LK��HKJEM��lBVK@>E��@B?P�NBK�0�B�AECD�kK�G��IC�@D�G�LB?E��T����@�EBS�M��ZH��0��>C V�I�ZB?KCK��O�CD�

@>EME����E���B�H�PMBS�T�KH@?��B?KCK��M�PGB�@>EME���@KCK�BI0�?E��

�KGPCD?�?K�JEMC��AU�@CEZB?D@I�EA@?��E�>�0�@TE@EA@?�P^L�I��G�B�

JETE�BJ��B^���?�>EJ�@CEZ�EJ�B�E@?�EJ��ET�E@K)�Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0

EALB��B�?K�K@�JEZ�E�P�BHK?D���EAK@TKVK�BB�M����?B��@EAC^HK�BI

T����VKCE�K>��>�>���O�PGBB0�?�>�B���RAS�GBB)

Page 96: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

]ALBK�B�?K�K@U�JEZ�E�B@>�?D�B���@lK�K�E�M��BG�NBB�TK�KME�

�E��EME�T�ENK@@�)�Y�>0�TEH>C^VK�BK��K�?��CD�EME�JKHB�?E���>�T�E�

NK@@P�P�KMPCB�E���BI�?EZK�T�KH@?��CIK?��G�BJ�U��B�?K�K@)�FEMH�

JU�TE�BJ�KJ0�V?E�P�TE@�KH�B>E�0�T�B�BJ�^LBS�@K�V�@�PV�@?BK

��P�KMPCB�E���BB0�K@?D�@�EB�@E�K�kK��E�ET�KHKCK��UK�Q���B�EMH��B

�KET�KHKCK��UK0�V?E�KLK�SPZK�Q�B�?K�K@U����KMBE�K0�W?E�G��VB?KCD�

�E�G�?�PH�IK?�T�ENK@@)���TEB@>�?�>EME���@�JEJ�HKCK��K�?��CD�EME

TE@�KH�B>�0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0���B�?K�K@�S�EAKBS�@?E�E�)

[@K��UkK@>�G���EK�@�BHK?KCD@?�PK?�E�?EJ0�V?E�CKM>E0�>E�KV�E0

T�BGU��?D�TK�K�?B���TK�KME�E��EJ�T�ENK@@K����IGU>�B�?K�K@E�0��E

�U��AE?�?D�W?E?�IGU>�EVK�D�@CEZ�E)�F�ZHE��@?E�E�K��KEASEHBJE

T�E�K@?B�@K�DKG�P^����CB?BVK@>P^���AE?P�TE��UI�CK�B^��K�CD�

�US��PZH0�TE��U��AE?>K�>�B?K�BK����NBE��CD�US�B�?K�K@E��B�TE

ET�KHKCK�B^�EAE@�E����E@?B���NBE��CD�US�T�B?IG��B�0��K�ME�E�

�I�PZK�E�TETU?>K�TE�I?D�B�?K�K@U�T�E?B��B>�)�]H��>E0�K@CB�?�>�I

��AE?����V�K?@I0�?E�W?E�@EGH�CE�AU�AECKK�T�BKJCKJP^��?JE@lK�P�B

AECKK�kB�E>EK� T�E@?���@?�E� �� TK�KME�E��S)�u@?D� �@K� E@�E���BI

��HKI?D@I0�V?E�BGPVK�BK�B�TE�BJ��BK��AS�G�JB�B�M�PGB��JB�B�?K�

�K@E��B�ET�@K�B��H�PM�H�PM��APHK?�@TE@EA@?�E��?D�E?SEHP�E?��KT�B�

JB�BJUS�@?�C>B��^LBS@I�TEGBNB�)�X�H�PME��@?E�E�U0����CBG�B��

?K�K@E��@?E�E��TEG�ECB?�ET�KHKCB?D�@E�JK@?BJUK�B�EALBK�B�?K�

�K@U0�E�BK�?�NBI����>E?E�UK�E?�KV�K?�?�KAE���BIJ�@E��KJK��EME

W?�T��P�KMPCB�E���BI)

�$0!�+�!,� �-�����������

.) /�� � )# 0� $��)#�#��=ES��C��B@>P@@?�P�TECB?B>B)�e ���� %�j�" ���#0�� �)�70

.556)

,) 1����� $#2 ��XsR0�@?���U�vK�?��CD�E��RGBB�B�F��>�G���T�EACKJU�B�TK�@�

TK>?B�U��G�BJEE?�EkK�B�)�}vK�?��CD��I�RGBI�B�F��>�G~0���,�8;:0�,---)

3) 3�� 4#)����FE�lCB>?���RAS�GBB����NBE��CD�UK�T�EK>?U�B�TECB?BVK@>BK�EA�

@?EI?KCD@?��)�[�>�)��O�PGB�U�B��AS�GU)�=P?D�>�T�BJB�K�B^)�t)0�.55;)

9) 3�� ����� 56#(������O�PGB�E��AS�G@>B��>E�lCB>?����KMBE��CD�EJ�>E�?K>@?K)

Y�J�ZK)

4) 7�*����� 8���%'���O�PGBI�B�RAS�GBI���T�KHCEZK�BI�>�>E�@?B?PNBE��E��JEHKCB)�[

>�)��=��>?B>��lKHK��CBGJ�)�=EB@>B��CD?K���?B��HCI�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB)�t)0�.555)

Page 97: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�9#��� )#%��)� 1�)� : ��5:�� ��#�#)��� ��'#�� � ���� ��(�5

��� �# #���)��� �; � �����#� ��#�# � ���� �� )��# ������ <"#

9#� =�)����> ����� # ������ �- ����%� �%�- %# ?��%�#�#�> ��#5

?���#� �@��A�B CABB�B��A DB�EA����(> ���#� �������$�% ������ � #5

��� )�(��� % �� # ��#��#�*��%�� ��#F�������

MU! ��!����R���#8�]H�E��BG���Z�K�kBS�G�H�V�T�B����CBGK�>E�l�

CB>?��I�CIK?@I��UI�CK�BK�@�JUS�G��VBJUS�B�?K�K@E��@?E�E�)�tEZ�

�E�CB����?B����AECKK�MCPAE>EJ�P�E��K�?K��K@>ECD>E�>C^VK�US�B�?K�

�K@E�0�PHE�CK?�E�B?D�>E?E�UK�AUCE�AU���Z�KK��@KME\�q����?K�@HKC��

KJ�k�M��TK�KH�����kK��HB@>P@@BB��TET�EAPKJ�ET�KHKCB?D0�JEZK?K

CB��U��UI�B?D�B�?K�K@U0�EALBK�HCI�EAKBS�@?E�E�)�=EG�ECD?K�J�K

��G��?D��K@>ECD>E�B�?K�K@E��BG�?KS0�E�>E?E�US�J�K�HE�KCE@D�P@CU�

k�?D0����U�@>�ZK?K0�@EMC�@�U�CB�@E�J�E�)

Y�B�B�?K�K@��BG�P@CUk���US�J�E��G�>C^V�^?@I���@CKHP^LKJ�

G�LB?��T����VKCE�K>�0�G�LB?��HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�T�ENK@@E��B�G�LB?�

>PCD?P��E��B�W?�BVK@>E��BHK�?BV�E@?B)�p?E�G��VBJE�HCI�EAKBS�@?E�

�E�)�q�PMBJB�@CE��JB0�B�M�PGB�U0�B��AS�GU�SE?I?�G�LB?B?D�T����

VKCE�K>�0�HKJE>��?BVK@>BK�B�@?B?P?U�B�T�ENK@@U0���?�>ZK�@�E^�>PCD�

?P��P^�B�W?�BVK@>P^�BHK�?BV�E@?D)�Y�>�CB�W?E\

��������%�"�8�qCI��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U�W?E��K��E)�y��K�G��^0�?�>�CBW?E�HCI�M�PGB�)

MU! ��!����R���#8�qPJ�^0�JK�I��K�?�>�TE�ICB0�TEG�ECD?K0�I�TETU�?�^@D�@�E��)�y��K�ME�E�^�E�?EJ0�>�VKJP�@?�KJI?@I�@?E�E�U���E?HKCD�

�E@?B)

�� �%!���R�S���8�y�@EMC�@���E?�E@B?KCD�E�TK��US�H�PS�B�?K�K�@E�0��E��K�P�K�K��0�V?E�?�K?B��Q�G�LB?��>PCD?P��E��B�W?�BVK@>E�

BHK�?BV�E@?B�Q�I�CIK?@I�M�PGB�@>BJ�B�?K�K@EJ)

MU! ��!����R���#8�=EG�ECD?K�P?EV�B?D��M�PGB�U��K�G�B�?K�K@E����U���G�LB?K�@�EK��>PCD?P��E��B�W?�BVK@>E��BHK�?BV�E@?B\

�� �%!���R�S���8�p?E��K�@�JEK���Z�EK�@KMEH�I0��K�?E0�V?E�JU�@?����KJ@I�G�LB?B?D)

Page 98: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

MU! ��!����R���#8�[�E?�EkK�BIS�@�zE@@BK�0���T�BJK�0�W?E��K�AUCE

AU���Z�UJ\

�� �%!���R�S���8�=�EACKJ��>PCD?P��E��B�W?�BVK@>E��BHK�?BV�E�@?B\�|K?)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�y�SEVP�P?EV�B?D0�@VB?�^?�CB��AS�GU�HKJE>���?BG�NB^���Z�UJ�B�?K�K@EJ)

�4� ���� #��

��R��� ����0�8�RAS�GBI�G�B�?K�K@E�������HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�T�E�NK@@�S)�t�K�T�KH@?��CIK?@I�EVK�D�@EJ�B?KCD�UJ0�V?E���kK�ME@PH���

@?�E�JEZ�E�E?@?EI?D�AKG�W?BS�T�ENK@@E�)

�4� ���� #��

�������!"�#�-8�FEMH��JU�����kK��J�CE��M�PTTK�ME�E�BCB�E�?EJ0�V?E

��k��NKCD�Q�@?�EB?D��KG��B@BJEK�ME@PH��@?�E0�JU�VK?>E�TE�BJ�CB0

VKME�EZBH�KJ�E?�T�BG���BI�JB�E�UJ�@EEALK@?�EJ)�qCI���@�E@EAK��

�E� ��Z�E�T�BG���BK�{�T�HEJ���kK���KG��B@BJE@?B)�Y�PH�E� @KAK

T�KH@?��B?D0�V?E���kK�ME@PH��@?�E�JEMP?�T�BG��?D0�K@CB�JU��K�AP�

HKJ�@EAC^H�?D�HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�T�B�NBTE�)��?E�>�@�K?@I�@EA@?�K��

�E@?B0�?E�K@CB�JU�KLK��K�ET�KHKCBCB@D0�>�>�KK�HKCB?D0�W?E�KLK��K

G��VB?0�V?E�JU��K�ME?E�U�>�HKJE>��?BVK@>BJ�T�KEA��GE���BIJ�B�NK��

�E@?IJ)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�=�BG��K?K�CB��U�V�@?�P^�@EA@?�K��E@?D>�>��KEASEHBJEK�P@CE�BK�ME@PH��@?��\

�+����� G����� � 4������ � ���� ���

MU! ��!����R���#8�=E@JE?�BJ0�TE�IC�CB�I���@)�=ESEZK0�V?E�EALB�

JB�JEZ�E�@VB?�?D�?ECD>E�H���B�?K�K@�0���H���H�PMBS0��E>�PM�>E?E�US

G��IG�C�@D��K>E?E��I�HB@>P@@BI0� EALBJB�@VB?�?D��KCDGI)�q����?K

TE@JE?�BJ����@�JEJ�CB�HKCK�H���B�?K�K@��T�KH@?��CI^?@I�EALBJB\

Page 99: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

8y���GE�P�BS�TE�@�EKJP0��E��U0��EGJEZ�E0�G�SE?B?K�TK�KlE�JPCB�E�

��?D�TE�@�EKJP):�]HB��Q�W?E�G�LB?��?EME0�V?E��U���GU��K?K�HKJE>���

?BG�NBK��BCB�HKJE>��?BVK@>BJ�T�ENK@@EJ�B�HKJE>��?BVK@>BJB�B��

@?B?P?�JB)�q�PME��Q�G�LB?��T����VKCE�K>�)�=���BCD�E�CB�W?E\

��,� ��.�S,���8�p?E�EH�E�B�?E�ZK)

MU! ��!����R���#8�p?E�JEZK?�@?�?D�EH�E���@KEAwKJC^LK��G��

H�VK�)

��,� ��.�S,���8�R��?E�E��JEZK?�@?�?D�HKJE>��?BVK@>B��T�E�NK@@�B�B�@?B?P?U0�>E?E�UK�@JEMCB�AU�G�LB?B?D�T�����VKCE�K>��B

EAK@TKVB?D�@?�ABCD�E@?D�>�>���O�PGBB0�?�>�B���RAS�GBB)

MU! ��!����R���#8�qKJE>��?BVK@>BK�B�@?B?P?U�AU��^?���G�UK)=EH�T����JB�VKCE�K>��EAUV�E�TEH��GPJK��^?�>E�>�K?�UK�HE>PJK��

?U0���>E?E�US�G�lB>@B�E���U�B�HB�BHP�CD�UK�B�>ECCK>?B��UK�T���

��)�p?B�T�����V�@?E���@@J�?�B��^?@I���E?HKCD�US�HE>PJK�?�S0�E�B�

K�?B�E����US�CBAE����T�����CBV�E@?B0�CBAE����>ECCK>?B��UK�T����)

p?E�JEZ�E���@@J�?�B��?D�>�>�EHB��EALB��B�?K�K@)�u@?D�CB�KLK�V?E�

�BAPHD�BG�W?EME�@TB@>�0�V?E�JEZ�E���@@J�?�B��?D�>�>�EALB��B�?K�

�K@\

�4� ���� #��

MU! ��!����R���#8�xKGET�@�E@?D�B�@?�ABCD�E@?D�Q�W?E�TK��EK)

�7�� �#�#��� # '��#��� #�����

MU! ��!����R���#8�R�V?E��U�JEZK?K�@>�G�?D�TE�TE�EHP�B�?KM��NBB��JB�E�EK�@EEALK@?�E\�xUCE�W?E���@TB@>�S\

�!������"8�tU��U@>�GU��KJ�@�EB�CBV�UK�T�KH@?��CK�BI�BCB��U���

Z�KJ�?K�B�?K�K@U0�>E?E�UK0�@���kK��?EV>B�G�K�BI0�E?��Z�^?�J�K�BK

�@KME�EALK@?��\

Page 100: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

MU! ��!����R���#8��DK�J�K�BK��U��U��Z�CB0�G�TB@U��I�W?B�B�?K��K@U\

��������%�"�8�tU�TU?�CB@D�HPJ�?D�@�?EV>B�G�K�BI�EALK@?��)

MU! ��!����R���#8�=�KHTECEZBJ0�V?E��U��Z�CB@D�EALK@?�K��UK

B�?K�K@U)�y�?EZK�TU?�C@I��UA��?D�BG�@TB@>��?E0�V?E�JEZK?�AU?D�EA�

LBJ)��?�>0�@?�ABCD�E@?D�B�AKGET�@�E@?D)���?KM��NBI)))�[EEALK�?E0

I��K�P�K�K�0�V?E�T���BCD�E�TE�IC���kP�lE�JPCB�E�>P�B�?KM��NBB0

TE�?E�B?K�KK0�TEZ�CP�@?�)

�4� ���� #��

�� ������/%!��-8�=EGBNBB��AS�GE��B�M�PGB�@>BS�ZB?KCK��RAS�GBB�E�J�EMEJ�@E�T�H�^?)���?K0�B�H�PMBK�TEA�B��^?@I0�V?E��Kl?KT�E�E�

HU0�M�GET�E�EHU�JEMP?���G�PkB?D�?P�B�l��@?�P>?P�P0�?P�@�KHP0�?P��P�P0

>E?E��I�AUC�����TEAK�KZDK))

�������!"�#�-8�p?E�?EV>��G�K�BI�M�PGB�)

�4� ���� #��

�������!"�#�-8�y��K�ME�E�BC�E�>P�E�?�E���P�K��n���@��KJ�EZ>E

��G�EK�E?�EkK�BK�>��EHB�K�

�4� ���� #��

MU! ��!����R���#8��?�>0�TE�TE�EHP�B�?KM��NBB�@EMC�@BI��K?\

�!������"8�]AK�@?E�E�U�T�E?B�)

MU! ��!����R���#8�q����?K�TE�HKJ�H�PMBJ�TP?KJ)�[K��KJ@I�>�EA�LBJ�B�?K�K@�J)�|�V�C�@D�B�?K�K@��I0��E�@CEZ��I�HB@>P@@BI)�X���

V�C��TE@JE?�BJ0�V?E�TECPVB?@I�P��AS�GE�0�G�?KJ�Q�P�M�PGB�)�tEZKJ

CB�JU��UI�B?D�,�3�@�JUS���Z�US�B�?K�K@�\�|�V�KJ�@��AS�GE�)

Page 101: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�!������"8��G�?KS0�V?E�EA@PZH�CB@D0�BCB�JEZ�E�T�KHCEZB?D�V?E�?E�E�EK\

MU! ��!����R���#8�|�J�APHK?�B�?K�K@�E�P@CUk�?D�V?E�?E��E�EK0

CPVkK�V?E�?E�>E�>�K?�EK)�n���@�VK?U�K�M�PTTU)�F�ZH�I�T�KH@?��BC�

@�E�����B��?0�@CKM>��E?CBV�^LB�@I�E?�H�PMBS)�=EH�EHI�B?EM0�TP@?D

�AS�G@>�I�@?E�E����UHKCB?�H���?�B�E@�E��US�B�?K�K@�0���G�?KJ�?E�ZK

@�JEK�@HKC�K?�M�PGB�@>�I�@?E�E��)

�����M�.� ��8�]AK@TKVK�BK�AKGET�@�E@?B�HCI���NBE��CD�E��BHK��?BV�E@?B�Q��K�W?�BVK@>E�0�����NBE��CD�E�0���G�T�H�EJ�@JU@CK�@CE�

��0�HCI��@KME���@KCK�BI)�p?E��>C^V�K?��K@P�@U0�>PCD?P�P0�@ENB�CD�UK

B�B�?KCCK>?P�CD�UK��ET�E@U)

MU! ��!����R���#)�]G��V�K?�CB�W?E�HKJEM��lBVK@>P^�@ES����E@?D\

�!������"8�R�H��@EMC�@���@�]CKMEJ0�B0�>EMH��E���ME�E�B?�E�HKJEM���lBVK@>E��AKGET�@�E@?B0�E���BJKK?����BHP�BJK��E��AS�GE�)

MU! ��!����R���#8���?K�K@�E)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�|�NBE��CD��I�BHK�?BV�E@?D�B�HKJEM��lBVK@>�IT�EACKJ��@�EHI?@I�>�?EJP0�V?E�TK�KH��AS�G�JB�@?EB?�T�EACKJ���UZB�

���BI�>�>�lBGBVK@>E��KHB�BNU���@E��KJK��EJ�JB�K)�X?EB?�T�EACK�

J��@ES���K�BI��AS�GE��>�>�W?�E@�0����K�>�>�M��ZH��@>E����NBB0�TE?E�

JP�V?E�?�>EME�TE�BJ��BI���RAS�GBB�@KMEH�I��K?)�p?E�TE�BJ��BK�K@?D

��E@�E��EJ���M��ZH��@>EJ�@K>?E�K0��E���NKCEJ���EALK@?�K�W?EME��K?

Q�K@?D�W?�BVK@>EK�TE�BJ��BK)�=EW?EJP�HCI��AS�GE��T�EACKJU�@CB�

CB@D��qKJE>��?BI�TE�BJ�K?@I��KJ�EZ>E� �A@?��>?�E)�|��TK��EJ

TC��K�@?EB?�AE�DA��G��T�BG��>B���NBB0�G��?E0�E�VKJ�8T���H�0�TE�H�PME�

JP�TE�EHP:�ME�E�BC�t�J��H�k�BCB)

MU! ��!����R���#8�[U��@K�@EMC�@�U�@�RAK@�CEJEJ\

��������%�"�8�q�0�I�@EMC�@���@�RAK@�CEJEJ)

Page 102: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�����M�.� ��8�tEZ�E���K@?B�>�>BK�?E�>E��K>?B�U\

��������%�"�8�[U�@��BJ��K�@EMC�@�U0�P���@�H�PMEK��BHK�BK)���I�@��JB��K�@EMC�@��)�tU�HECZ�U�@>�G�?D0�V?E�P���@���G�UK�?EV>B�G�K�

�BI)

M���� �/%�"�-8�=�BG���BK�@EA@?�K��EME��KG��B@BJEME�ME@PH���@?��)�Y�>�>�>�HCI���@0��AS�GE�0�MC����I�G�H�V��Q�W?E��UZB?D�>�>

���EH0�JU�@�IGU��KJ�W?E�@��K�CBG�NBK��BHKB�@EA@?�K��EME�ME@P�

H��@?��)�tU�PTEJB��CB�E�T����S�VKCE�K>�)�tU�>�W?EJP�@?�KJBJ�

@I0��E�@��V�C���PZ�E�P>�KTB?D�ME@PH��@?�E0�B�?EMH��JU�@JEZKJ

ME�E�B?D�E�HKJE>��?BB)�tU�HECZ�U�BJK?D�M����?BB0�V?E��UZB�

�KJ�>�>����EH)�|��H���EJ�W?�TK���k����EH�@�IGU��K?�W?B�M�����

?BB�@���CBVBKJ�@EA@?�K��EME��KG��B@BJEME�ME@PH��@?��)�|�@�V�@�

?E�PT�K>�^?���?EJ0�V?E�JU�SE?BJ��CB?D@I���zE@@B^�BCB�KLK�>PH��

?E)�tU0�JEZK?�AU?D0�B�@�IGU��KJ���kB�B�?K�K@U�@�zE@@BK�0��E

W?E��K�G��VB?0�V?E�JU�SE?BJ�@?�?D�V�@?D^�zE@@BB)�r^A�I�B�?KM���

NBI���lE�JK�EALK��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�T�B�KHK?�>�?EJP0�V?E�zE@�

@BI�H�ZK�JEZK?�P@>E�B?D�T�ENK@@�B@VKG�E�K�BI���kKME����EH�)

=EW?EJP����H���EJ�W?�TK����?K��B?E�BB0���GU��KJE��RAS�GBK�0

JU�HECZ�U�BJK?D��EGJEZ�E@?D�PG��?D�@KAI0�V?EAU���@��K�HK�M��

CB0��K��>C^V�CB�>PH��?E0��K�?I�PCB�G��PkB0�V?EAU�JU�@�JB�@JEMCB

ET�KHKCB?D@I)

�����M�.� ��8�xKG�PV�@?BI�?KS�C^HK�0�>E?E�UK�>EMH��?E�?�J�ZBCB)))

M���� �/%�"�-8�p?E�H�PME���ET�E@)

��������%�"�8�u@CB�W?B�C^HB�ME?E�U��K��P?D@I���RAS�GB^0�>E?E���I��K�I�CIK?@I�V�@?D^�O�PGBB0�?EMH��E�B�HECZ�U��K��P?D@I)

�� ������/%!��-8�=EVKJP��U����IGU��K?K�@�EK�J�K�BK\

��������%�"�8�y��K����IGU��^)�p?E�JEK�CBV�EK�J�K�BK)�y�ME�E�^EA�B�?K�K@�S)

Page 103: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

MU! ��!����R���#8�=E@JE?�BJ0�TE�IC�CB�I���@)�]HB��TP�>?0�TE�>E�?E�EJP0�>�ZK?@I0����HK�E�@EMC�@BK�?ECD>E�HCI�RAS�GBB�Q�W?E�EAK@TK�

VB?D��UZB���BK��AS�G@>EME����EH�)�|KEASEHBJE@?D�@ES���B?D�BHK��

?BV�E@?D��AS�G@>E��>PCD?P�U�B��AS�G@>B��W?�E@�>�>���NB^)�u@?D�B

���B��?�Q�G�LB?���@KS�ZB?KCK��RAS�GBB)�8[�E@�E��EJ�BJKK?@I����BHP

G�LB?����lBGBVK@>EJ�@JU@CK):�=E�W?EJP�TP�>?P�TEC�E��HEME�E�K��

�E@?B��K?)

��������%�"�8�t�K�>�ZK?@I0���HE�ET�KHKCB?D�T�BE�B?K?�E@?D�Q

V?E�I�CIK?@I�TK��UJ�TE�G��VBJE@?B0���V?E��?E�UJ0��E�B�?E0�B�H�PMEK

HECZ�E�AU?D���@TB@>K)

��,� ��.�S,���8�x�GB@�Q�W?E�@ES���K�BK�W?�E>PCD?P��E��@�JE�AU?�E@?B��AS�GE�)�|�H@?�E�>��Q�W?E�ME@PH��@?�E0�>E?E�EK0�>�>�@>�G��

C��R�H�0��K�JEZK?�@PLK@?�E��?D0�K@CB��K�APHK?�HKJE>��?BB)

��������%�"�8�p?E�>�>���G�T�B�NBTB�CD�E0�V?EAU��@K�C^HB0�>E?E��UK�ZB�P?���RAS�GBB0�SE�EkE�@KAI�VP�@?�E��CB�B�AUCB�G�LBLK�U0

W?E�B�K@?D�HKJE>��?BI�B�G�LB?��T����JK�DkB�@?��B�M��ZH��)

�4� ���� #��

�� �%!���R�S���8�X�JUJ� MC���UJ�B�?K�K@EJ�O�PGBB� I�CIK?@ITE@?�EK�BK�@EA@?�K��EME�ME@PH��@?��0��JK@?K�@�RAS�GBK��BCB�AKG�Q

W?E�@KMEH�I��K�@�J�I�MC����I�T�EACKJ�)�=K��EK�B�MC���EK�Q�V?EAU

O�PGBI�BJKC��HKJE>��?BVK@>BK�B�@?B?P?U0� E@�E����UK����T����S

VKCE�K>��B��K�SE�K�@?�K�G�>E��)�[?E�EK�Q�V?EAU�E���>�>�JEZ�E�AU@�

?�KK�B�TEC�KK�B�?KM�B�E��C�@D���K��ETK�@>BK�BCB�K��E�?C��?BVK@�

>BK�T�ENK@@U)���?�K?DK�Q�J�>@BJ�CD��I�CBAK��CBG�NBI�W>E�EJB>B�B

TE@?�EK�BK��K�CD�US�B�@?B?P?E��HCI��U�EV�E��W>E�EJB>B)

�� ������/%!��-8�y�>�?KME�BVK@>B��K�@EMC�@K��@�J�K�BKJ�YB�B>E�E?EJ0�V?E��K�@?ECD���Z�E0�APHK?�O�PGBI�@�RAS�GBK��BCB��K?)�y�BGCEZP

@�EK�J�K�BK�

.: @ES���K�BK�BCB�@EGH��BK��KG��B@BJEME�ME@PH��@?���8@K�V�@�W?E

ME@PH��@?�E�?ECD>E����APJ�MK:0

Page 104: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

,: �E@@?��E�CK�BK�?K��B?E�B�CD�EME�KHB�@?���@?���U0

3: T�����VKCE�K>����G�T�H�EJ�Q�@�JEJ�kB�E>EJ�Q�TE�BJ��BB�W?EME

@CE��)

��������%����S,���8�YE0�V?E�ME�E�BCB�YB�B>E�B�YK�MBG�Q�E?��ZK��BK�J�K�B�0�>E?E�UK�@PLK@?�P^?���O�PGBB)�y�@VB?�^0�V?E���>�PMP

TECB?B>E�0� >E?E�UK�PT���CI^?� ME@PH��@?�EJ0�T�K��CB�PK?� ?E0� V?E

ME�E�B?�YB�B>E)�YE0�V?E�ME�E�B?�YK�MBG0�AECDkK�T�K��CB�PK?�����@K�

CK�BB0���E@�E��EJ�@�KHB�AKZK�NK�)�=E�JEKJP0�AECDkB�@?�E���@KCK�

�BI�Q�W?E��@K�?�>B��K�AKZK�NU0���?K�C^HB0�>E?E�UK�lE�JB�P^?�T���

�B?KCD@?�E0�����T���B?KCD@?�K���@T�E@?���K�E�TK��EK�J�K�BK�Q�TE�

�BJ��BK�?EME0�V?E��KEASEHBJE�>�>�JEZ�E�AU@?�KK�TE@?�EB?D�HKJE>�

��?BVK@>EK�ME@PH��@?�E)�=E?EJ�E�E�APHK?�@TE@EA�E��K��P?D�RAS�GB^

BCB�HE@?E��E�@��K����GEA��?D@I��BCB�E?TP@?B?D�KK0�HE@?E��E�@��K�

��GE�?B@D�BCB��������G�B�?K�K@E��?D0�V?EAU�E����K��PC�@D���O�P�

GB^0�V?EAU�@EGH�?D�KHB�EK�ME@PH��@?�E)�YECD>E�?�>�I�O�PGBI�@JEZK?

W?E�@HKC�?D)�X�J�I�MC����I�G�H�V��Q�TE@?�EB?D�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�ME�

@PH��@?�E)

��,� ��.�S,���8�y�SEVP�HEA��B?D���KEASEHBJE�EAK@TKVB?D���NB�E��CD�P^�AKGET�@�E@?D)���@�W?E��?EV>B�G�K�BI0�T�EACKJ��RAS�GBB

I�CIK?@I��>?P�CD�E��B�HECZ���AU?D��KkK��0�TE?EJP�V?E�AKG�@?�ABCD�E�

@?B��E>�PM���MP�B��K�EGJEZ�E�E@PLK@?�B?D��B�JKZHP���EH�U��T�E�

K>?�?�PAET�E�EH�0��B�H�PMBK�T�EK>?U0�@�>E?E�UJB���k��TECB?BVK@�

>�I�WCB?��@�IGU��K?�TE@?�EK�BK�ZBG�K@TE@EA�EME�ME@PH��@?���Q�TEC�

�ET����EME�VCK���JKZHP���EH�EME�@EEALK@?��)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�y�@EMC�@K��@�?KJ0�V?E�ME�E�BCB�YB�B>E�BrK���)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�HCI�?E��V�@?B�M�PGB�@>EME�EALK@?��0�>E?E��I

��@@VB?U��K?����?E0�V?E�sK���H��HGK�PH�@?@I��KlE�JB�E��?D�M�P�

GB�@>EK�EALK@?�E���@?ECD>E0�V?E�O�PGBI�T�K���?B?@I����E�J�CD�EK

TC^��CB@?BVK@>EK� ME@PH��@?�E0� B� HCI�V�@?B���kK��TECB?BVK@>E�

WCB?U�T�BE�B?K?EJ0�>E�KV�E0�I�CIK?@I�@EGH��BK�TC^��CB@?BVK@>EME

EALK@?������A�GK�?EME�J�?K�B�C�0�>E?E�U��JU�TECPVBCB�����@CKH�

@?�E�E?�@E�K?@>EME�T�EkCEME)�tU�@K�V�@�BJKKJ�TK@?�P^�O�PGB^0

@E�K?@>P^0�TE@?@E�K?@>P^)�=K�KH���JB�@?EB?�G�H�V��Q�@JEZKJ�CB�JU

Page 105: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

T�K���?B?D�W?P�O�PGB^���TC^��CB@?BVK@>P^�BCB�O�PGBI�E>�ZK?@I

�K@TE@EA�E����@E��KJK��US�P@CE�BIS�MCEA�CBG�NBB�@EGH�?D�T�BCBV�

�EK0��E�J�CD�EK�EALK@?�E�B�ME@PH��@?�E\�XC����xEMP0�JU�TE>����HK�

KJ@I0�V?E���kB��EGJEZ�E@?B��KB@VK�T�KJU0�B�JU��K�@EAB��KJ@I�G��

AB��?D�RAS�GB^�TE@�KH@?�EJ�zE@@BB� B� �JK@?K� @� �AS�G�JB� AU?D

ETI?D���4� ���� #���|E�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�H�ZK�?K�C^HB���M�PGB�@�

>EJ�EALK@?�K0�>E?E�UK�@VB?�^?0�V?E�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�ME@PH��@?�E�B

EALK@?�E�JEZ�E�TE@?�EB?D�Q�?�PH�E0��E�JEZ�E�Q�B�AKG���G�KkK�BI

�AS�G@>E��T�EACKJU0�H�ZK�W?B�C^HB����A@EC^?�EJ�AECDkB�@?�K�@�E�

KJ��K�@�BJ�^?��ET�E@�RAS�GBB�@�TE�K@?>B�H�I0���T�E@?E�TK�K�E@I?

KME����APHPLKK)�xPHPL�I�JEHKCD�Q�W?E�@E@PLK@?�E���BK�O�PGBB�B

RAS�GBB)�F�>E��APHK?�W?��JEHKCD0�APHK?�CB�W?E�KHB�EK�ME@PH��@?�E

BCB�H�PM�I�lE�J��EALKME�T�E@?���@?���Q�W?E��ET�E@�APHPLKME)�u@CB

BG�O�PGBB�TECPVB?@I��E�J�CD�EK�ME@PH��@?�E0�ME��GHE�AECDkK�k���

@E�0�V?E�RAS�GBI�APHK?���W?EJ��KMBE�K�ACBZK��@KS�>�O�PGBB)

]VK�D���Z�U���ET�E@�Q�T�EACKJ��AKGET�@�E@?B)�RAS�G@>P^�T�E�

ACKJP�JU���@@J�?�B��KJ�B���W?EJ�>E�?K>@?K0�B0�JEZK?�AU?D0��TK��UK

��W?EJ�>E�?K>@?K)�z�G�O�PGBI�@EAB��K?@I�E@�EAEHB?D@I�E?��EK��E�TE�

CB?BVK@>EME�T�B@P?@?�BI�zE@@BB0�JU��K�JEZKJ�@JB�B?D@I�8TE>��W?B

�EGJEZ�E@?B�P���@��K�B@VK�T��U:�@�?KJ0�V?EAU�RAS�GBI�AUC��TC�N�

H��JEJ��E@@B�@>EME��EK��E�TECB?BVK@>EME��CBI�BI����O�PGB^�B���

�K@D��Z�U��F��>�G)�|�HE���@@J�?�B��?D��ET�E@�RAS�GBB�B���W?EJ

>E�?K>@?K�Q���>E�?K>@?K�M�PGB�@>E��AKGET�@�E@?B)�O�PGB�@>P^�AKGE�

T�@�E@?D�JU���@@J�?�B��KJ�>�>�AKGET�@�E@?D�E?�HE@?�?EV�E�JEL�E�

ME�BJTK�B�CB@?BVK@>EME���?B@>��zE@@BB�Q�TP?B�@>E��zE@@BB)

!R������RU,���R��8�y�TK�KVB@C^�M�PGB�@>BK�B�?K�K@U�

.: @ES���K�BK�BCB�TE@?�EK�BK�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B0

,: AKGET�@�E@?D0

3: @EAC^HK�BK�T����VKCE�K>�)

MU! ��!����R���#8�tEK�TE�BJ��BK�EH�EME�TP�>?�0�@�>E?E�UJ��@K

@EMC�@�U0�?�>E�E��W?E�T�EHECZK�BK�B�G�LB?��T�ENK@@��lE�JB�E���

�BI�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�O�PGBB0�V?E��>C^V�K?��K�SE�K�@?�E�G�>E��0

HKJE>��?BVK@>BK�T�ENK@@U�B�AKGET�@�E@?D)�=K��EEVK�KH�E��CB�W?E

Page 106: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

B�?K�K@0�@�>E?E�UJ�@EMC�@�U��@K�T�KH@?��B?KCB�M�PGB�@>E��@?E�E�

�U\�u@CB�I�TE�IC���kB�P?EV�K�BI0�?E���G�EMC�@BI�E?�E@B?KCD�E�M�P�

GB�E��AS�G@>BS�E?�EkK�B��@�BJ�^?@I0�>EMH���ET�E@�EA�W?BS�E?�E�

kK�BIS���@@J�?�B��K?@I�����J>�S�W?EME�T�ENK@@�)�=�E@?E�EH�B�T�KH�

TEVB?�^?��Kk�?D�W?E?��ET�E@����DkK0�H�PMBK�Q�TEGZK)

�� �%!���R�S���8�tU��K�ME�E�BJ0����DkK�BCB�TEGZK�HECZK��AU?D

�KkK���AS�G@>B���ET�E@0�JU�ME�E�BJ0�V?E���kK�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�ME�

@PH��@?�E�HECZ�E�@?�EB?D@I��KG��B@BJE�E?�?EME0�>�>�E���KkB?@I)

MU! ��!����R���#8�=EG�ECD?K�PHE@?E�K�B?D@I0�V?E�T���BCD�E���@TE�IC0�?�>�>�>�I��K�P�K�K�0�V?E�W?E�>�>�?E�E?CBV�K?@I�E?�?EME0�V?E

ME�E�BC�I)��?�>0�W?E�T�BE�B?K?0��E�E��T�KHTEC�M�K?��ET�E@U���K@CB�

B��>EMH��)

�� �%!���R�S���8�q�)

MU! ��!����R���#8�oE�EkE)�|E�TE�TE�EHP�T�ENK@@��lE�JB�E���BI

ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B��U��@K�@EMC�@�U\

����� $%����/�$� �%�8�q�)

MU! ��!����R���#8�u@?D�CB�H�PME�����B��?�lE�JPCB�E�>B��?E�EMETP�>?�0�@�>E?E�UJ��@K�@EMC�@�U\

�!������"8�=E�?E�B?K0�TEZ�CP�@?�0�KLK���G)

MU! ��!����R���#8�X��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U�K@?D�H���TP�>?�)�t�K�B�?K�

�K@�E0�K@?D�CB�B�?P?��?E�E��TP�>?)

�� �%!���R�S���8�[?E�UJ�TP�>?EJ�AUC��B�?KM��NBI)

MU! ��!����R���#8���?KM��NBI���u��E@E^G\

�4� ���� #��

Page 107: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

MU! ��!����R���#8�Y�K?DBJ�TP�>?EJ�M�PGB�@>E��@?E�E�U�I�CIK?@ICBAK��CBG�NBI�W>E�EJB>B)

XJU@C�W?EME�PT��Z�K�BI�G�>C^V�K?@I���?EJ0�V?E�K@CB��U�VK?�

>E�T�KH@?��CIK?K�B�?K�K@U�EAKBS�@?E�E�0��U�JEZK?K�lE�JPCB�E�

��?D��ET�E@U�?�>0�V?EAU�P�IGU��?D�W?B�B�?K�K@U�H�PM�@�H�PMEJ)

p?E�H�K?��EGJEZ�E@?D�HPJ�?D�E�@?��?KMBVK@>EJ���G�B?BB)�Y�>BJ

EA��GEJ0����JE���GMCIH0�T�EB@SEHB?�TK�KSEH�E?�JUkCK�BI�?BT�

�BCB�Q�BCB��>�JUkCK�B^��B�Q�B�)�=EG�ECD?K�T�B�K@?B�EHB���K�

@>ECD>E��A@P�H�U��T�BJK�)�[�@�@T��kB��^?��}oE?B?K�VKME��BAPHD

SECEH�K�D>EME�BCB�>ElK\~�[U�JEZK?K�E?�K?B?D��}y�AU��UTBC��EHU

@E�CDHEJ0�?�>�>�>�J�K�SEVK?@I�VKME��BAPHD�SECEH�EME0��E0��JK@?K�@

?KJ0�I�SE?KC�AU�B�>ElK0�TE?EJP�V?E�J�K�����B?@I�KME��>P@~)�tEZ�E

CB��UTB?D�V?E�?E�T�ESC�HB?KCD�EK�B�T�B�W?EJ�TEVP�@?�E��?D��>P@

>ElK\�[E?�?EMH��?E�B�T�BHPJ�CB�>ElK�@E�CDHEJ)��?�>0�>�>�@E�JK@�

?B?D���kB�H���E@�E��US�B�?K�K@�\�F�>BJ�EA��GEJ�JEZ�E�EAK@TK�

VB?D�@ES���K�BK��AS�G@>E��BHK�?BV�E@?B�B�EH�E��KJK��E�TEHHK��

ZB��?D�T�ENK@@���G�B?BI� ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B���O�PGBB\�X�?EV>B

G�K�BI�JK?EHECEMBB0�B�?K�K@�E�TE�I?D0�>�>BJ�EA��GEJ�I��UkKC

���W?E?��ET�E@)�u@CB��U�@TE@EA�U�lE�JPCB�E��?D��ET�E@U0�EAwK�

HB�II�H�����G�US�B�?K�K@�0�?E�>EMH���U�T�B@?PTB?K�>���G��AE?>K

@?��?KMBB0�@?��?KMBI�APHK?�HECZ���E?�KV�?D�����ET�E@U�@��GP�EAK�

BS�@?E�E�)�Y�>0���T�BJK�0��ET�E@0�G�?�E�P?U��rK���EJ0�TE�TE�E�

HP�K��ETK�@>BS�@�IGK�0�JEZ�E�@lE�JPCB�E��?D�?�>��}XTE@EA@?�P�

^?�CB�K��ETK�@>BK�@�IGB�HKJE>��?BVK@>EJP���G�B?B^�M�PGB�@>E�

ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�B�EAK@TKVB��^?�CB�E�B�T�B�W?EJ�@ES���K�BK

�AS�G@>E�� >PCD?P��E�� BHK�?BV�E@?B\~� {�?KJ� @CKHPK?� EA@PHB?D0

@EE?�K?@?�PK?�CB�W?E?�>E�>�K?�U��TEHSEH���kBJ�?�KAE���BIJ�BCB

@?EB?�T�EHPJ�?D�H�PMBK��ET�E@U)

��R��� ����0�8�qZE��=EC�@>�G�C0�V?E�JU�HECZ�U�P?EV�B?D���kB

B�?K�K@U�B�TE?EJ�TETU?�?D@I�E?E�?B�E?�BHKECEMBB�}BCB�Q�BCB~0�?E

K@?D�E?�lB>@�NBB�����G�BJEB@>C V�^LBS�B�?K�K@�S�H�PS�@?E�E�0�>

BHKECEMBB�}B�Q�B~0�T�KHTEC�M�^LK��@E�JKLK�BK�B�?K�K@E�)�]���U�

HKCBC�E@�E��UK�B�?K�K@U0�>E?E�UK�JU�EA@PHBCB0�B�@lE�JPCB�E��C

�ET�E@�?�>BJ�EA��GEJ��}F�>�JU�JEZKJ�HE@?BVD��UZB���BI��AS�GE�

T�B���G�B?BB�M�PGB�@>EME�ME@PH��@?��\~)�rK����?P?�ZK�T�KHCEZBC

Page 108: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

BHK^0�V?E�W?E�JEZ�E�@HKC�?D�VK�KG��SEZHK�BK0�VK�KG�B�?KM�B�E���

�BK���u��E�?C��?BVK@>B��@E^G)

��,� ��.�S,���8��?E�T�EBGE�HK?0�K@CB�O�PGBI�B�RAS�GBI0��@I�W?�?K��B?E�BI0�APHK?�V�@?D^�u��ETU�B�K��E�?C��?BVK@>EME�@EEALK@?��\

[E�TK��US0�HKJE>��?BVK@>BK0�K��ETK�@>BK�@?���U�EVK�D��KH>E��E^�

^?�JKZHP�@EAE�0�?E�K@?D�APHK?�M����?BI�E?��M�K@@BB�@E�@?E�E�U�M�P�

GB�@>EME�AECDkB�@?���TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�J�CEVB@CK��EJP��AS�G@>EJP

���EHP)�[E��?E�US0���@�JE��RAS�GBB�APHP?�@EAC^HK�U�ET�KHKCK��UK

M����?BB�HCI�M�PGB�@>EME���@KCK�BI�RAS�GBB�B��K�APHK?�l�>?E����K�

@?�ABCD�E@?B�BG�G��T�B?K@�K�BI�M�PGB����RAS�GBB�BCB�E??EME0�V?E��

YABCB@B�T�BHP?�>��C�@?B���NBE��CB@?U0�>E?E�UK���G�IZP?��E�P^

�E��P)�YE�K@?D�APHK?�HE@?BM�P?��ET�KHKCK���I�@?�ABCD�E@?D)

�� �%!���R�S���8�p?B�H�K�TEGBNBB0�>E?E�UK�EAEG��VBC�qZE��=EC0�K�>E�lCB>?P^?�H�PM�@�H�PMEJ0�TE?EJP�V?E�HKJE>��?BVK@>�I�O�PGBI

PZK�@�J��TE�@KAK�APHK?�M����?EJ�@ES���K�BI�HKJEM��lBVK@>E��BCB

W?�BVK@>E��BHK�?BV�E@?B��AS�GE�0���APHK?�CB�W?E���@E@?��K�O�PGBB0

�K���@E@?��K�O�PGBB�Q�W?E�PZK�H�PME���ET�E@)�u@CB���O�PGBB��K�APHK?

HKJE>��?BB0�E���E@?��K?@I�PM�EGE��HCI�RAS�GBB0�H�ZK�K@CB�RAS�GBI

APHK?��KG��B@BJ��E?�O�PGBB)

��������%�"�8�F�@EZ�CK�B^0��K�JEMP�@EMC�@B?D@I�@�YB�B>E0�T�B�@KJ�JEKJ�P��ZK�BB�>�HKJE>��?BVK@>BJ�NK��E@?IJ�B��K@JE?�I���

JEK�ZKC��BK�BJ�@CKHE��?D)�xE^@D0�V?E�HKJE>��?BI�@�J��TE�@KAK�E?�

�^HD��K�EAK@TKVB��K?��UZB���BI�J�CUS�W?�E@E�)�|�EAE�E?0�JU�G���

KJ0�V?E���WTESP�HKJE>��?BG�NBB�@PLK@?�PK?��K�CD��I�PM�EG��B@VKG�

�E�K�BI�W?BS�W?�E@E�0�TE?EJP�V?E0�>�>�T���CK�BK�AECDkB�@?��0�E��

EVK�D�ET�@���HCI�J�CUS�W?�BVK@>BS�M�PTT�B��PZ�U�>�>BK�?E�@TKNB�

�CD�UK�G�LB?�UK�JKS��BGJU0�B�@?B?P?U0�>E?E�UK0�>�@EZ�CK�B^0�TE>�

@E�K�kK��E��K�HB@>P?B�P^?@I���M�PGB�@>EJ�EALK@?�K)���I�TE>���K

�BZP�B��K�@CUkP��BVKME�?�>EME0�V?E�H���CE�AU�J�K���HKZHP����?E0

V?E�B�?K�K@U��AS�GE��B�BS�T���E����@PLK@?�E���BK�>�>�W?�BVK@>E�

M�PTTU�APHP?�G�LBLK�U)�tK�I��KJ�EZ>E�TPM�K?0�>EMH��JU�?�>��A@E�

C^?BGB�PKJ�HKJE>��?B^0�HPJ�I0�V?E�E���@�J��JEZK?��KkB?D�>�>BK�

?E�T�EACKJU)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E�@E�@KJ��K�?�>)

Page 109: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

�� �%!���R�S���8�RA@EC^?�E�@���JB�@EMC�@��)

��������%����S,���8�y��KJ�EZ>E��K�@EMC�@K��@�TE@CKH�BJ�G�I�CK��BKJ�YB�B>E)�qKJE>��?BI�Q�W?E��K�NKCD0���T�ENK@@)�qKJE>��?BVK@>EK

ME@PH��@?�E�Q�W?E�ME@PH��@?�E0�>E?E�EK�T�BG��K?0�V?E�C^AUK��ET�E@U

JEZ�E��KkB?D����P�E��K�EALK@?�K��EME�HEME�E��)�=EW?EJP�I�P�K�K�0

V?E�K@CB�ME@PH��@?�E�APHK?����@�JEJ�HKCK�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�Q��K�l�@�H0

�K�EAJ���HCI���AB���BI�EV>E��B�TECPVK�BI�B��K@?BNB�0�?E�E�E�APHK?

@TE@EA�E���G�KkB?D�TEV?B�C^AUK�>E�lCB>?�UK�@B?P�NBB)�u@CB�JU

��@@VB?U��KJ����B�?KM��NB^���u��ETK�@>B��XE^G0�?E�@�JU��CPVkB�

���B��?�HCI�O�PGBB�Q�@KMEH�I�ZK���V�?D��UTEC�I?D�>�ZHEK�P@CE�BK0

�KEASEHBJEK�HCI��@?PTCK�BI���u��ETK�@>B��XE^G)�[�CPVkKJ�@CPV�K

��@�T�BJP?�CK?�VK�KG�.4)�]H�BJ�BG�P@CE�B��APHK?�Q����?B�EALB��IGU>

@��AS�G�JB)�FE�lCB>?�@�RAS�GBK����G�KkB?@I��K����KGPCD?�?K��@?PTCK�

�BI���u��ETK�@>B��XE^G0���EAE�E?���@?PTCK�BK���u��ETK�@>B��XE^G

APHK?��KGPCD?�?EJ���G�KkK�BI�>E�lCB>?��@�RAS�GBK�)

M���� �/%�"�-8�{HK@D�ME�E�I?0�V?E�O�PGBI�@?��K?�T�B�CK>�?KCD�E�HCI�RAS�GBB0�TE@?�EB?�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�T���E�EK�ME@PH��@?�E)�t�K

>�ZK?@I0�V?E�W?E0����K>E?E�EJ��EHK0�@�JEEAJ��)�8=P@?D��K�EABZ�^?@I

?K0�>?E��U@>�G�C�?�>EK�J�K�BK):�=EVKJP0�K@CB�O�PGBI�@TE@EA���TE�

@?�EB?D�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�T���E�EK�ME@PH��@?�E0�JU0��AS�GU0��K�@JE�

ZKJ�W?EME�@HKC�?D0��K�PV�@D�P��BS\�|�J�HCI�W?EME�EAIG�?KCD�E�AU?D��

@E@?��K�O�PGBB\�|K�EAIG�?KCD�E)

��������%�"�8�|E�?KE�K?BVK@>B�JU�JEZKJ�G�SE?K?D)

M���� �/%�"�-8�tU�JEZKJ�G�SE?K?D0��E�I�HPJ�^0�V?E��K�G�SE?BJ)

=E?EJP�V?E��B>�>BK�HKJE>��?BVK@>BK�B�@?B?P?U���JB�K0�>�>�ME�E�B�

C��|�?KCC�0��K�JEMP?�TE>��G�LB?B?D���@�E?0�M�PAE�ME�E�I0�ABECEMB�

VK@>BS�T�ENK@@E��Q�@JKkK�BI0��@@BJBCINBB�B�?)T)�y��K�ME�E�^0�V?E

��HE�BGECB�E��?D�RAS�GB^0�V?EAU�E������BC�@D���@EA@?�K��EJ�@E>P0

�E��@K�����E0�HKJE>��?BI0�H�ZK�@�JEK�CPVkKK�T���E�EK�ME@PH��@?�E0

�K�@JEZK?�E@?��E�B?D�K@?K@?�K��US�T�ENK@@E��@JKkK�BI����EHE�0

T�B�>E?E�US�J�CEVB@CK��U�����EH�@�J�@EAE��?E�K?0�B@VKG�K?���AE�

CKK�J�EMEVB@CK��EJ����EHK)�=EW?EJP�HCI��AS�GE��W?��@B?P�NBI����K�

Page 110: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

>E?E�EJ��EHK�?PTB>E��I)�y�TE�?E�I^��J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�?ECD>E�ZBG�D

��@EA@?�K��US�ME@PH��@?��S�JEZK?�T�EHCB?D���kK�@E@PLK@?�E���BK)

u@CB�G��?���O�PGBI�@?��K?�@�JUJ�CPVkBJ�ME@PH��@?�EJ0�JU��@K�����

�E��K�JEZKJ����KME��E�?B0�TE?EJP�V?E�TE�HK?�K@?K@?�K��U��T�ENK@@0

�@CKH@?�BK�>E?E�EME� G�� MEH�APHK?� �@@BJBCB�E����O�CD@>B�����E�0

VK�KG�MEH�]V�JVB�@>B�����E�0�KLK�VK�KG�MEH�XPSPJ0�B�?)H)�Q�K@?K�

@?�K��U��ABECEMBVK@>B��T�ENK@@0�T�B�>E?E�EJ�EHB���BH�B@VKG�K?

@�J�@EAE�0�AKG�GCEME�PJU@C��>EME�?E�BG��K)

!R������RU,���R��8�y�SEVP�@>�G�?D0�V?E��ET�E@�AUC�TE@?��CK��?�>�>�>�JEMP?��AS�GU�@ES���B?D�@�E��W?�E@�B�BHK�?BV�E@?D�B�EH�E��K�

JK��E�@E@?EI?D�����J>�S� M�PGB�@>EME� ME@PH��@?��\�y� @VB?�^0�V?E

��HKZH�����?E0�V?E�HKJE>��?BVK@>BK�B�@?B?P?U���?EJ�?BVK@>B��@K

�Kk�?�Q�W?E�l��?�GBI)�[?E��I�l��?�GBI�8�K�EABZ��?K@D:�Q�u��E@E^G0

TE?EJP�V?E�=��?��T������K�E?���@�G��B@B?0�T�BJP?���@�BCB��K�T�BJP?)

=EW?EJP�I�@VB?�^0�V?E�W?E?��ET�E@�HECZK���Kk�?D@I����@EA@?�K��US

�K@P�@�S�Q���P?�B�M�PGB�@>EME�B��AS�G@>EME�@EEALK@?�)�=EW?EJP���HE

@EGH�?D�EALKK�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EK�ME@PH��@?�E)�=E?EJP�V?E�B�O�PGBI0

B�RAS�GBI�@?EI?�TK�KH�G�H�VK��TE@?�EB?D�EALKK�ME@PH��@?�E)�XEGH��

�BK�EALKME�ME@PH��@?���PHE�CK?�E�IK?�B�?K�K@U�EAKBS�@?E�E���EAK

@?E�E�U�APHP?�BJK?D�ME@PH��@?�E0�MHK�EA�����EH��@ES���I?�@�EB��K�

TE�?E�BJE@?D�B�>PCD?P��P^�BHK�?BV�E@?D)

T.����MU���� �-8�n�JK�I��TKV�?CK�BK0�V?E��AS�GU�SE?I?�@?�EB?DJE�EW?�BVK@>EK� ME@PH��@?�E0� �� �TKCCINB^�M�PGB�@>E�� @?E�E�U�>

T����J�VKCE�K>���E@T�B�BJ�^?�>�>�>�T>���HCI��E�E��E>>PT�NBB)�=E�

JEKJP0�W?E�E@�E���I�BS�JE?B��NBI)�FEMH��JU�ME�E�BJ�E�T����S�VKCE�

�K>�0�W?E�TEH��GPJK��K?��EG���LK�BK�AKZK�NK�0���W?E��E@T�B�BJ�K?�

@I�>�>��EG���LK�BK�>�?KJ��K�CBIJ0�>E?E�UK�AUCB�HE��E��U)�y�TE�B�

J�^�Q�W?E�@?��S)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E���H���U��JEJK�?�>��?B���BJK��E

?�>�I)

��������%�"�8�zK�CD�E�W?E�BCB��K?\

T.����MU���� �-8�|K�G��^0�JEZK?�AU?D)

Page 111: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

M���� �/%�"�-8���@?D���kKME����EH����SEHB?@I�G��JE�KJ)�|�HE��>C^�

VB?D�B�W?BS�AKZK�NK�0�>E?E�UK�SE?I?��K��P?D@I�HEJE�)�q�HP?�BJ�@?��

?P@�AKZK�NK�0�?EMH��T�EACKJ��APHK?�CKMVK��Kk�?D@I�B�HCI�M�PGB�@>BS

AKZK�NK�)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8���@?E�B������kBS��@?�KV�S0�B�����G�US�TPA�

CB>�NBIS�T�B@P?@?�PK?��ET�E@�J�S�HZB�E�)�|��K��EK0��AS�G@>E��@?E�

�E�K�?�PH�E���@�TE�I?D0��E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�JU�B@>�K��K�E?�KV�KJ0�V?E

JU��K�T�E?B��?EME0�V?EAU��K��P?D�J�S�HZB�E��Q�@>ECD>E�PH�@?@I)�y

V�@?E�EA�W?EJ�ME�E�^)��?E�>�@�K?@I�?EME0�V?E��KT�?�B�NBI�Q�W?E�@CEZ�

�U��T�ENK@@0�W?E���k��T�EACKJ�0���@CPV�K��KEASEHBJE@?B�JU�@JE�

ZKJ�TEJEVD)�XPLK@?�PK?��H�K@�?0�>E?E�U��T�E�KC�W?P�HKTE�?�NB^�Q

W?E�zE@@BI0�T���ET�KKJ�BN��B�N��@>E��zE@@BB0�B�XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�

TE�@�EKJP�MBJ�P0�MK�AP�B�lC�MP)�|K�JU��H�K@�?U��KkK�BI�W?E��T�E�

ACKJU)�|E�JU�JEZKJ�@TE@EA@?�E��?D��KkK�B^)

]?�E@B?KCD�E�?EME0�V?E�ME�E�BC��|�?KCC�)�qKJE>��?BG�NBI�EA�

LK@?����u��ETK����G�V�?EV�E��@?�HBB0�HK�@?�B?KCD�E0���G��VB?KCD�

�E��@?KTK�B�AUC��@�IG����@��@@BJBCINBK��J�CUS����EHE�����?KS

?K��B?E�BIS0�MHK�@EGH���CB@D���NBE��CD�UK�ME@PH��@?��)�qKJE>�

��?BVK@>BK�B�@?B?P?U�@TE@EA@?�E��CB��@@BJBCINBB)�|E�?K����E�

HU0�>E?E�UK�@T�@CB@D0�PZK��E��?E�E��TECE�B�K�����K>�0�E@EAK��E��

?�K?DKJ�?U@IVKCK?BB0��@��AECDkK�B�AECDkK�EA�K?�^?�JKS��BGJU

G�LB?U)�u@?D�X?�����x�@>E�0�>E?E��I�G�LBLK���@�EBJB�TEC�EJE�

VBIJB)�]�B�@�JB�?�>�ME�E�I?)�q�ZK�A�@>E�@>BK���NBE��C�@KT����

?B@?U�ME�E�I?0�V?E�A�@>B��K�HECZ�U�AU�BJK?D�@?ECD>E�TEC�EJEVB�

��@E@?��K��@T��BB��x�@>E�BI�T�E@?E��K�HECZ���AU?D���@E@?��K��@�

T��BB)�|E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�TE@CKH�BK�,-�CK?�BHK?�T�ENK@@��KlE�JB�

�E���BI�B@T��@>EME� EALK@?��0� B� �@�� AECDkK� A�@>E�� MECE@P^?� G�

H�PMBK�T��?BB0�G��B�?KM��NB^�B�EH�E��KJK��E�G��@ES���K�BK�@�EK�

BHK�?BV�E@?B)

n�A�@>E��K@?D�EH�E�@K�DKG�EK�T�KBJPLK@?�E�Q�W?E�u��E@E^G�B

XE�K?��KMBE�E�)�x�@>B��K���SEHI?@I�EHB�����EHB��@��@T��BK�)��@T��

�BI�Q�EVK�D�HKJE>��?BVK@>�I�@?����0��E�@PLK@?�PK?�B�u��E@E^G)

u@?D�H�PME�����B��?0���?E��ZK�u��ETK�Q�r^>@KJAP�M)�8y�AK�P�@?���

�P0�@E��GJK��P^�RAS�GBB):�[�C^?��?�J�AKCDMB�@>�I0����JKZHP���EH�

�E����K�K�KME�B�?K�K@U0�>�>�T���BCE0�T�KH@?��CIK?�xKCDMBI)�=���H�0

Page 112: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

r^>@KJAP�M�BJKK?�T���E�T�KH@?��CI?D�@KAI�>�>�@PAwK>?�JKZHP���

�EH�EME�T�����?�J0�MHK�P��KME�BJK^?@I�E@EAUK�B�?K�K@U)

y��K�B@>C^V�^��EGJEZ�E@?B�B�?�>EME��KkK�BI�M�PGB�E��AS�G@�

>E��T�EACKJU0�?)�K)�@EGH��BK�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�@E�J�EMBJB�JKS��

�BGJ�JB�G�LB?U�BHK�?BV�E@?B��AS�GE�0��E��@K�W?E0�>�>�B�J�EMEK�H�P�

MEK0�G��B@B?�E?�P�E��I�HKJE>��?BG�NBB�O�PGBB0�����G��VB?KCD�E��JK�K

B�RAS�GBB)

tU0����K��EK0��@K�@EMC�@�U�@�?KJ0�V?E�T�B��U�Kk�BS�P@CE�BIS

��?KVK�BK��K@>ECD>BS�CK?��KkK�BI�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>E��T�EACKJU��K

APHK?)�XKMEH�Ik�II���k����AE?��JEZK?�@?�?D�B��K@?BNBK����APHP�

LKK���kBS�E?�EkK�B��Q����H�PM�BG���kBS�@?����TECPV�?@I��E�J�CD�

�UK�HKJE>��?BVK@>BK�EALK@?��)�u@CB�TECPV�?@I0�?EMH���EGJEZ�US

���B��?E��EVK�D�J�EME�Q�>�>���KHB�EJ�ME@PH��@?�K0�?�>�B����@@ENBB�

�E����EJ0�>E?E�EK�APHK?��Kk�?D�EAK�T�EACKJU��B�T�EACKJP�ME@PH���

@?�K��E@?B�O�PGBB0�B�T�EACKJP�@ES���K�BI�BHK�?BV�E@?B��AS�GE�)

|K�EAIG�?KCD�E�HECZ�E�@CPVB?D@I�?�>0�V?E���G��AS�G@>B�����EH�J�CE�

VB@CK��U�0�?E����E�BCB�TEGH�E�M�PGB�@>B�����EH�KME��@@BJBCB�PK?)

[E�TK��US0�O�PGBI0�@C����xEMP0�B@?E�BVK@>B��K�EAC�H�K?�@K�DKG�UJB

�EGJEZ�E@?IJB�HCI��@@BJBCINBB)�q�ZK�?K���NBE��CD�UK�JK�DkB��

@?���O�PGBB0�>E?E�UK����K��T�EZB��^?�Q�B�>P�HU0�B��GK�A��HZ��NU0

B���JI�K�Q�@ES���I^?�@�E^�W?�BVK@>P^�T�B��HCKZ�E@?D)��?E�>�@��

K?@I��AS�GE�0�?E�JKZHP���JB�?�>�I���G�BN����?��HBNBIS0���B@?E�BB0

V?E��K?�E@EAE���EGJEZ�E@?B�B�E@EAE���PZHU�BS��@@BJBCB�E��?D0

?KJ�AECKK0�V?E�?�>E��AECKG�K��U��T�ENK@@��K�����kBS�B�?K�K@�S)

qE�?KS�TE�0�TE>��M�PGB�@>BK�B��AS�G@>BK��K>?E�U���G�B?BI��K

APHP?�@E�JK@?BJUJB0��E�J�CD�EME��KkK�BI�W?E��T�EACKJU��K�AP�

HK?)�u@?D��KkK�BK�T�EACKJU�����J>�S�EA�E�CK��E��zE@@B�@>E��BJ�

TK�BB�BCB�����J>�S�>�>EME�?E�H�PMEME�@EEALK@?��0�MHK���@BCBK�I�CI�

K?@I��UV�MEJ�H��CK�BI0�T@K�HE�KkK�BKJ�W?E��T�EACKJU)�=EW?EJP�P

��@�?�>�I�@CEZ��I�@B?P�NBI)�X�EH�E��@?E�E�U0��KEASEHBJUJ�P@CE�B�

KJ� I�CIK?@I�HKJE>��?BG�NBI���kBS�EALK@?�0� @EGH��BK� @K�DKG�US

HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�B�@?B?P?E��Q�W?E�HCB?KCD�U��T�ENK@@)�X�H�PME�

@?E�E�U0�@�BZK�BK�?E��E?VPZHK��E@?B0�>E?E��I�@PLK@?�PK?�JKZHP

��kBJB����EH�JB)�=E?EJ�HECMEZB?KCB�AKZK�NU0�>E?E�UK�KLK�APHP?

ZB�U0��K��P?@I�@E�@�EBJB�@KJDIJB���RAS�GB^�B�APHP?�VP�@?�E��?D

@KAI�?�J�>�>�HEJ�)

Page 113: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�� ������/%!��-8�XKMEH�I����K@>ECD>BS��U@?PTCK�BIS�T�EG�PV�C�JU@CD�E�?EJ0�V?E���M�PGB�@>EJ�EALK@?�K�B�@�KHB�M�PGB�@>BS�TECB?B�

>E��I>EAU��EG�B>CB�T�KHTE@UC>B�HCI��EGJEZ�EME�T�BG���BI��AS�G@�

>E���KG��B@BJE@?B)�F�>�@>�G�C�pJG��0�}@JP?�UK�T�KHTE@UC>B~)�[B�

GP�CD�E�W?E���EHK�AU�?�>)�|E�@EMC�@B?D@I�@�W?BJ��KCDGI��TE?K�^�E@?�

�E?U��AS�G@>E��T�EACKJU���M�PGB�@>EJ�EALK@?�K�B�TEI�CK�BK�����

�EHPkBI�P�V�@?B�TECB?B>E���B>�>��KCDGI�@VB?�?D�T�KHTE@UC>�JB)�y

EAwI@�I^�W?E�����EHPkBK�?KJ0�V?E��P>E�EH@?�E�O�PGBB��K�@JEMCE

��G�KkB?D��B� MKETECB?BVK@>BK0� �B� ��P?�BTECB?BVK@>BK� �@TK>?U

P�KMPCB�E���BI��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?��Q�B��K�?ECD>E��K�@JEMCE���G�K�

kB?D0��E�H�ZK�B��K�T�BACBGBCE@D�>���G�KkK�B^)�=EW?EJP0����JE�

�GMCIH0�B�P��K>E?E�US�VCK�E����kK��HKCKM�NBB��EG�B>CE�ELPLK�BK0

V?E��K��G�KkK��E@?D��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?��JKk�K?���G�B?B^�O�P�

GBB0�@EGH��B^�M�PGB�@>E��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B0�P?�K�ZHK�B^�HKJE>�

��?BB�B��U�EV�E��W>E�EJB>B)�p?��JU@CD�T�EG�PV�C��B����T�KHUHP�

LK�0�?ABCB@@>E���@?�KVK����U@?PTCK�BB�M�����B�AK��k�BCB)��JK��

�E���W?EJ���G�KGK�I���@@J�?�B��^�B��TKCCINB^�P��Z�KJEME�rK�����>

�KCB>EJP�>��NCK�P�FE���HP�RHK��PW�P)�|E�O�PGBI��K�JEZK?�TEG�E�

CB?D�@KAK�?�>E���E@>EkB0�>E?E�P^�TEG�ECBC��@KAK�{�T�H��I�OK�J��

�BI���@E�K�kK��E�H�PME��B@?E�BVK@>E��EA@?��E�>K�Q�?�J�?EMH��AUC�

@E�K�kK��E�H�PM�I�@B?P�NBI0�P�OK�J��BB�AUCB�H�PMBK��UV�MB�B�TK��

@TK>?B�U)

y� @VB?�^�G�ACPZHK�BKJ�B� ?E0� V?E0�BGA��B�kB@D�E?� �AS�G@>E�

T�EACKJU�B�}E?TP@?B�~��AS�GE�0�O�PGBI�@JEZK?�TE@?�EB?D�@BCD�EK

HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�ME@PH��@?�E)�[KHD�?K���Kk�BK�@BCU0�>E?E�UK0�M�P�

AE�ME�E�I0�B@TECDGE��CB��AS�GE��>�>�HPAB�>P�@�NKCD^�E>�G��BI�H���

CK�BI����O�PGB^0�HCI�PHK�Z��BI�KK���@lK�K�@�EKME��CBI�BI0�W?B�@BCU

�K�E@?��I?�KK���TE>EK0�H�ZK�K@CB�JU�E?TP@?BJ��AS�GE��Q�?KJ�AECKK��K

E@?��I?)�y�P�K�K�0�V?E�W?B�@BCU�G�HK�@?�P^?�H�PMBK��UV�MB0���?EJ

VB@CK�W?�BVK@>BK0�E�B��K�E@?��E�I?@I����E??E�ZK�BB�RAS�GBB�B�AP�

HP?�@?�KJB?D@I�E?E���?D�E?�O�PGBB�B�H�PMBK��KMBE�U�Q�X�JKM�KCE0

RHZ��B^�B�?)H)

YE0�V?E�W?B�@BCU�B@TECDGE��CB��AS�GE��>�>�HPAB�>P�T�E?B��O�P�

GBB0�T�BG����CB�B�?�>BK�BG�K@?�UK��AS�G@>BK�TECB?BVK@>BK�HKI?KCB0

>�>�{P��A�RVA��B�rKE�BH�r�>K�A�I)�F@?�?B0�KLK�9�MEH����G�H�{P��A

RVA��G�I�CIC0�V?E���HKZHU�����AS�G@>P^��KG��B@BJE@?D��E@I?���A�

Page 114: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

@EC^?�E�BCC^GE��U��S���>?K��0�P>�G������?E0�V?E��B>?E��K�T�BG��K?

RAS�GB^��KG��B@BJUJ�ME@PH��@?�EJ)

y�@EMC�@K��@�pJG��EJ�qZMK�K��I���?EJ0�V?E�T�EG�T�H��I�TECB�

?B>���P>E�EH@?���O�PGBB�Q�W?E��K�T�BSE?D�E?HKCD�US�TECB?B>E�0��

T��MJ�?BVK@>EK�@?�KJCK�BK��CBI?KCD�US�>�PME��M�PGB�@>EME�ME@P�

H��@?��)�[�W?EJ�pJG���T����AECDkK0�VKJ�{ABM�K��xZKGB�@>B�0�>E?E�

�U��JK@IN���G�H���B�?K��D^��IHP�M�PGB�@>BS�Xt��G�I�BC0�V?E��AECD�

kB�@?�E���@KCK�BI�O�PGBB�@?�KJB?@I���|RY]�)�xZKGB�@>B���K����

G��C�B@?EV�B>B�B�lE�J�NBB0�>E?E�UK�TEG�ECBCB�KJP�@HKC�?D�?�>E�

�K@DJ��@TE��U���U�EH)

�?E�ZK�>�@�K?@I�G�T�H�E��E�BK�?�NBB��P>E�EH@?���O�PGBB0�?E0

���JE���GMCIH0���TE@CKH�BK�MEHU�E�E�l�>?BVK@>B��BVKME��K�@HKC�CE

HCI�?EME0�V?EAU��K�CD�E���V�?D�@?�EB?KCD@?�E�ME@PH��@?���G�T�H�EME

EA��GN���B���@lK�K�W>E�EJB>B0��B���@lK�K�EAE�E�U0�T�BACBZK�BI�>

@?��H��?�J�|RY])�xECKK�?EME0�@�EK���KTE@CKHE��?KCD�E��TECB?B>E�

E�E���ET�KHKCK��E��@?KTK�B�l�>?BVK@>B�HB@>�KHB?B�E��CE� @�KHB

V�@?B���@KCK�BI�O�PGBB�W?P�E�BK�?�NB^����{�T�H)

|K�CPVkK��KCB�@KAI�B�?K�TECB?B>B0�>E?E�UK���?E��CB�G���E@@?��

�E�CK�BK�XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�0�T�ETE�KHE��CB�AECDkK�B@?@>BK�CEGP��

MB0�?K0�>?E�T��GH�E��C�HK�D�P@?��E�CK�BI�@E�K?@>E���C�@?B���O�PGBB)

]�B0����K��E0��K�TE�BJ�^?0�V?E�TEHEA�UJB�CEGP�M�JB�B�T�BGU��JB

E�B�E??�C>B��^?�E?�@KAI�?P�V�@?D�M�PGB�@>EME�EALK@?��0�>E?E��I�B@�

>�K��K�ZKC�K?�BJK?D�E�BK�?�NB^����zE@@B^)�y�@VB?�^�8B�I�GHK@D��K

E�BMB��CK�:0�V?E�P�KMPCB�E���BK��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?���K�EGJEZ�E

AKG���G�KkK�BI� MKETECB?BVK@>EME� @TE���B�T�E?B�E@?EI�BI�JKZHP

zE@@BK��B�XsR����F��>�GK)

MU! ��!����R���#8�tEB���AC^HK�BI�>�@�^?@I�?EME0�V?E��U���@@J�?�

�B��K?K�>�>�V�@?D���kK��?K>PLK����AE?U0�B�JEZK?�AU?D0�H�ZK��>C^�

VB?K���@E�JK@?�U��E?VK?)�tEK�TK��EK���AC^HK�BK�@E@?EB?���?EJ0�V?E

?�B�B�?K�K@��@?E�E��@E�T�CB)�p?E�Q�G�LB?��T����VKCE�K>�0���G�B?BK

HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�T�ENK@@E��B�B�@?B?P?E��B�TEHHK�Z��BK�@?�ABCD�

�E@?B�B�AKGET�@�E@?B)

y�@VB?�^0�V?E0��GI?UK��JK@?K0�W?B�?�B�TP�>?��JEMP?�TECEZB?D

��V�CE�@TB@>P�?KS�T�B�NBTE��BCB�>�B?K�BK�0�>E?E�U��JEZK?�AU?D

@EMC�@E����JKZHP�H�PJI�@?E�E��JB)�]�B�JEMCB�AU�CKVD���E@�E�P�ETK�

Page 115: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

��?B��E��@B@?KJU�>�B?K�BK��BCB�T�B�NBTE��JB�E@?�EB?KCD@?���B

E?�EkK�B��JKZHP��AS�G�JB�B�M�PGB��JB)

[?E�EK�JEK���AC^HK�BK��>EMH���U��KHK?K�HB@>P@@B^�EA�B�?K�K�

@�S0�B�EMH���EZH�^?@I��E�UK�@TE@EAU�BS�lE�JPCB�E���BI)�tK�I

G�B�?K�K@E��C��EH���BG���kBS��KTCB>0���>E?E�E���K>E?E�UK�B�?K�K�

@U�AUCB�EAwKHB�K�U�TE��E�EJP)�XEMC�@�E�JEK��G�TB@B0�l��G��AUC�

@CKHP^LK����F�>�@E@PLK@?�E��?D����EH�J0�TE>��APHK?�T�EB@SEHB?D

lE�JB�E���BK�HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�ME@PH��@?����O�PGBB�B���RAS�GBB\�

y���SEZP�?�>P^�lE�JPCB�E�>P�C^AETU?�E�0�TE@>ECD>P�E���P>�GU���

K?����E�BK�?�NB^�T�ENK@@��Q�?E�K@?D0�V?E���?E���KJI0�>EMH��EAK�@?E�E�

�U�APHP?�G��I?U�TE@?�EK�BKJ�HKJE>��?BB0��U�APHK?K��K@?B�TEB@>

ET�KHKCK��US�lE�J��G�BJEE?�EkK�B�)

]HB��BG�>EJJK�?��BK�0�>E?E�U��J�K�SE?KCE@D�AU�@HKC�?D�TE�TE�

�EHP�W?E��V�@?B0�JEZ�E�E?�K@?B�>���GHKCP�JK?EHECEMBB)�tK?EHECE�

MBI�@?��B?�TK�KH�@EAE��G�H�VP�Q�>�>��K@?B�TEB@>�>EJAB�B�E���BI

M�PTT�B�?K�K@E�)�y�T�E@?E�SEVP�TE�?E�B?D0�V?E�EHB��BG�@TE@EAE�����

AE?U�@���GCBV�UJB�M�PTT�JB�B�?K�K@E��G�>C^V�K?@I���?EJ0�V?EAU

T���BCD�E�@lE�JPCB�E��?D��ET�E@)�[�H���E��JK?EHECEMBB�KME�PH�V�

�E�@lE�JPCB�E��CB�>�>��ET�E@�E�@TE@EAK�EH�E��KJK��EME�E@PLK@?��

CK�BI�HK�@?�BI�R�B�HK�@?�BI�x)�FE�lCB>?U��@KMH��BJK^?�?K�HK��

NB^�TEH?�C>B��?D�>��K@E�JK@?BJUJ��KL�J)�qB��JB>��>E�lCB>?�

?EC>�K?���@���T�E?B�ETECEZ�US���T���CK�BIS�Q�>���GHKCK�B^��K@CB

�AS�GU�SE?I?�?EME�?E0�?E���J�W?E�EH�EG��V�E��K�TEHSEHB?0�JU�SE?BJ

H�PMEMEc�K@CB�M�PGB�U�SE?I?�?EME�?E0�?E0�AKG�@EJ�K�BI0���J�W?E��K

�PZ�E0�JU�SE?BJ��E?�?E)�{�H�V��TK�KlE�JPCB�E�>B�G�>C^V�K?@I��

?EJ0�>�>�T�BG��?D0�V?E�K@CB�H�K��KLB���G�UK0�W?E�KLK��K�G��VB?0�V?E

E�B��K@E�JK@?BJUK)�|KEASEHBJE����?B�?�E�VK@>B��@TE@EA�BS�P�I�

GU��?D�BS�H�PM�@�H�PMEJ)

Y�K?DK���AC^HK�BK�BJKK?�E?�EkK�BK�>�?EJP0�V?E0����JE���GMCIH0

S���>?K��E�HCI�EAKBS�@?E�E�)�|E�HECZK��@>�G�?D0��U�JEZK?K��K�@E�

MC�@B?D@I�@�?KJ0�>�>�I�EA�W?EJ�@>�ZP)�[VK���JU�@lE�JPCB�E��CB�>�PM

B�?K�K@E����@CKHP^LKJ��ET�E@K���F�>BJ�EA��GEJ�JEZ�E�AUCE�AU

@ES���B?D��AS�G@>P^�BHK�?BV�E@?D�B���?E�ZK���KJI�T�EH�B�P?D�T�E�

NK@@�lE�JB�E���BI�M�PGB�@>E��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B\��|E�JU��K�T�E�

ME�E�BCB�?�>�ZK�VK?>E0�V?E�?E�ZK�JEZ�E�@HKC�?D�B��K��USEHI�BG�>�PM�

B�?K�K@E���AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U)�F�>�I�TE�IC0��KG^JK�H�PS�T�BE�B?K?�

Page 116: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�US�B�?K�K@E���AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U�AUCB�@CKHP^LBJB��TK��U��G�>�

C^V�C@I�����UZB���BB��AS�G@>E��BHK�?BV�E@?B�B�>PCD?P�U~0����?E�

�E����}G�LB?K��@KS�M��ZH��@>BS�T���0�G�LB?K��@KS�ZB?KCK��RAS��

GBB�)�y�TEC�M�^0�V?E�@JU@C�@CKHP^LK��lE�JPCB�E�>B�P@?��B��K?�B

O�PGB^0�B�RAS�GB^���F�>�EAK@TKVB?D�G�LB?P��AS�G@>E��BHK�?BV�E@�

?B�B���?E�ZK���KJI�G�LB?B?D��@KS�ZB?KCK��RAS�GBB\�

[E?�KLK�EH�E���AC^HK�BK��EAK�M�PTTU�B@TU?U��^?�@SEZBK�?�PH�

�E@?B0���P?�K��BK�B���Kk�BK�EH�E��KJK��E)�[E?��ET�E@��>�>0�@EGH��

��I�HKJE>��?BVK@>BK�@?�P>?P�U0�G�LBL�?D�T�B�W?EJ���GCBV�UK�JK�D�

kB�@?��0���SEHILBK@I����ET�KHKCK��E��?K��B?E�BB\�Y�>E���ET�E@

T�BJK�BJ�TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�EAKBJ�M�PTT�J)����VK�ME�E�I0�W?E��K�I��

CIK?@I�T�EACKJE��B@>C^VB?KCD�E�EH�E��M�PTTU)�m�>?BVK@>B0�JEZ�

�E�@>�G�?D0�V?E�P@TKS�EH�E��M�PTTU���W?E��EAC�@?B�@TE@EA@?�PK?�P@�

TKSP�H�PME��M�PTTU)�oEVKkD�TEJEVD�@KAK�Q�TEJEMB�H�PMEJP)�p?E�B

AUCB�?�B�JEB���AC^HK�BI�HCI���V�C��HB@>P@@BB)

T.����MU���� �-8���?K�K@U0�>E?E�UK�JU�GHK@D�TU?�KJ@I�@lE�JP�CB�E��?D0�HK?K�JB�B�E���U���kBJB�@?��S�JB)�n���@�K@?D�@?��SB0�B

��kB�B�?K�K@U�lE�JB�P^?@I���kBJB�@?��S�JB)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�B�EMH�

AU��K?�CPVkK�ETB@�?D���kB�@?��SB0�V?EAU�P�BHK?D�MCPAB�P�B�?K�K�

@E�)�tEZK?�AU?D0���J�CPVkK�ME�E�B?D�E�@?��S�S\�F�>��U�HPJ�K?K\

MU! ��!����R���#8�[U�@T��kB��K?K0�APHK?�CB�TECKG�E�AECKK�NKCK�

��T���CK��E��U@>�G�?D@I�EA�ET�@K�BIS0�>E?E�UK�JEMP?�CKZ�?D���E@�

�E�K�B�?K�K@E�\

T.����MU���� �-8�q�)

MU! ��!����R���#8�X?��SB�CKMVK���GMCIHK?D�Q���E?CBVBB�E?�B�?K�K�@E�0�@?��SB�CKZ�?����TE�K�S�E@?B\

T.����MU���� �-8�q�)

MU! ��!����R���#8�|P0�I�HPJ�^0�V?E�@?��SB�G�CEZK�U����EVK�D�MCP�AE>EJ�P�E��K)�]�B�>E�K�I?@I�>�>���T@BSECEMBB�E?HKCD�US�CBN0�?�>�B

��T@BSECEMBB�M�PTT)�X?��SB�V�@?E�TEAPZH�^?���@�>�HK�@?�BIJ0�>E?E�

Page 117: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�US�JU�@�JB��K�HE�>E�N��TE�BJ�KJ)�FEMH��JU���SEHBJ�@TE@EA��U���

ZK�BI�@?��SE�0�W?E�H�K?���J��EGJEZ�E@?D�BS���@TEG��?D�B��K�AU?D

G�CEZ�B>EJ�W?BS�@?��SE�)�y�?EZK�HPJ�^0�V?E�BGPVK�BK�@?��SE��JE�

ZK?�AU?D�EVK�D�TECKG�E0� SE?I� @?��S�J�@�E�@?�K��E�TEHVK�>B��?D

�KM�?B��EK)���?K�K@U0�K@CB�E�B��U��ZK�U���TEGB?B��E��lE�JK0�EA�

C�H�^?�AECDkK��@BCE�)

=EG�ECD?K�T�B�K@?B�>E�>�K?�U��T�BJK�)�X?�KJCK�BK�EAK@TKVB?D

�UZB���BK��AS�G@>E��>PCD?P�U�@BCD�E�@�IG��E�@E�@?��SEJ�TE?K�I?D

@�E^�>PCD?P�P)�YE�K@?D0��@KMH��JEZ�E����?B��U��ZK�BK�G��VBJUS

P@?�KJCK�B�����BHK�TEGB?B��US�B�?K�K@E�0�TEAPZH�^LBS�>��>?B��

�UJ�HK�@?�BIJ)�|�T�BJK�0�>�>�TEGB?B��E�P@BCB?D�B�TEHHK�Z�?D��A�

S�G@>P^�BHK�?BV�E@?D�B�>PCD?P�P\�F�>��BHB?K0�BHKI�?��ZK0��E�E��

��T���CK�������>?B��U��T�ENK@@)���?K�K@U�JEZ�E�lE�JPCB�E��?D

J�EZK@?�EJ�@TE@EAE�0�B�EH���BG�G�H�V�JK?EHECEMBB�G�>C^V�K?@I��

TEB@>K���BAECKK�T�EHP>?B��EME�@TE@EA�0�>E?E�U��EAK@TKVB?���BAECD�

kP^�TECDGP�HCI�HKC�0�>E?E�UJ��U�G��BJ�K?K@D)�t�K�V�@?E�T�BSEHB�

CE@D���AE?�?D�@E�@?��S�JB0��E��B>EMH���K�EASEHBCE@D�AKG�EA��LK�BI

>���HKZH�J0�TE?EJP�V?E�E�B�P����E�KkB��^?�@?��SB)

��������%�"�8�XPLK@?�PKJ�JU0�M�PGB�U�B��AS�GU0��E���W?EJ�T�E�

@?���@?�K�@PLK@?�P^?�B�H�PMBK�BM�E>B)�X?EC>�E�K�BK�BS�B�?K�K@E�

EVK�D�@BCD�E��CBIK?����HB��JB>P�>E�lCB>?�)�F�>�T�BJB�B?D�B�?K�

�K@U���Kk�BS�BM�E>E�\

�������!"�#�-8�X�TEJELD^��Kl?KT�E�EH�)������

MU! ��!����R���#8�y���A�E@�^��B@P�E>)�YE0�V?E��U�GHK@D�ETB@U���K?K�Q�W?E�H�P@?E�E��BK��G�BJEE?�EkK�BI��AS�GE��B�M�PGB�)�YE�K@?D0�P

��@�K@?D�H�K�@?E�E�U)�|E���P?�B�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB�@PLK@?�P^?�B

H�PMBK0�JK�DkBK�M�PTTU0�>E?E�UK�P@CEZ�I^?�>��?B�P)�����P?�B��K�

MBE�E�0�B���MCEA�CD�EJ�>E�?K>@?K�@PLK@?�P^?�H�PMBK�M�PTTU0�>E?E�

�UK��EGHK�@?�P^?����?E0�V?E��U�HKC�K?K�B�>�>�JU@CB?K)�Y�>�I�>��?B�

���W?E�ME��GHE�ACBZK�>�?E���K�CD�E@?B0�@�>E?E�E���U�BJKK?K�HKCE)

=E�JEKJP0�V?EAU�E?�K?B?D����@�E���ET�E@�TE�TE�EHP���Kk�BS

@BC0��U�JEZK?K�T�EHKC�?D�PT��Z�K�BK���EHK�?KS0�V?E�JU�@���JB�PZK

T�EHKC�CB0�B�TETU?�?D@I�TE�I?D�BS�JE?B�B�P^LBK�B�?K�K@U)�FEMH�

Page 118: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�U�EA���PZB?K�ET�KHKCK��UK0�EALBK�HCI��@KS�B�?K�K@U0��U�T�BACB�

GB?K@D�>�BHKK�@?��?KMBVK@>EME��V?E�)�q�PMBJB�@CE��JB0��@KMH��K@?D

�KV?E0�V?E�JEZK?�EAwKHB�B?D�C^HK�)�=���H�0�TEC�E@?D^�TE�I?D�JE�

?B��NBE��UK�l�>?E�U���Kk�BS�M�PTT�ME��GHE�@CEZ�KK)

y�HPJ�^0���Z�E�TEJ�B?D0�V?E���kB�HK�@?�BI0�HK�@?�BI�M�PGB�

B��AS�GE�0��K�HECZ�U�TEC�E@?D^�G��B@K?D�E?�HK�@?�B��BCB�B�?K�K�

@E����Kk�BS�M�PTT)�Y)K)��K�@CKHPK?�@VB?�?D0�V?E�K@CB�E�B��K�@EMC�@�

�U�@�?KJ0�V?E��U�HKC�K?K0�?E��U��K�@JEZK?K��BVKME�@HKC�?D)�rBV�E�I

�K�^0�V?E�AECKK�P@?E�VB�UK�T�ENK@@U�JB�E@?�EB?KCD@?���B@SEHI?

E?�?KS0�>EJP�T�EACKJ��ACBZK��@KME)�zKkK�BI�BCB�H��CK�BK0�B@SEHI�

LBK�BG��K0�JEMP?�TE�CBI?D����T�EB@SEHILKK0��E0���>E�KV�EJ�@VK?K0

BJK��E�?KJ0�>EME�W?E�>�@�K?@I�AECDkK��@KME0�T�BHK?@I�ZB?D�@�W?BJB

�KkK�BIJB)

y�JEMP�T�B�K@?B�?�>E��T�BJK�)�[�vK�?��CD�E��RJK�B>K�;-�S

MEHE��VP�@?�E��CE@D��CBI�BK���Kk�BS��>?E�E��Q�?�>BS0�>�>�XEKHB�

�K��UK�s?�?U0�FPA�0�XE�K?@>B��XE^G)�t�EMBK�HPJ�CB0�V?E��B>�>BK

P@BCBI0�B@SEHILBK�BG�P?�B�@�JEME��KMBE��0��K�@JEMP?�BGJK�B?D�@B�

?P�NB^�HE�?KS�TE�0�TE>��KK��K��Kk�?�BGJK�B?D�JEL�UK���Kk�BK�@BCU)

=ETU?>B�@E�@?E�E�U�H�PMBS�@?����r�?B�@>E��RJK�B>B�Q�tK>@B>B0

R�MK�?B�U0� p>��HE��� B� x��GBCBB� 8E�B� ��G��CB� W?E� H�BZK�BK

g������:�Q��EGHK�@?�E��?D�����E��U���|B>���MP�0�X�CD��HE�K�B�O���

?KJ�CK�E>�G�CB@D�?LK?�UJB)

[�>E�KV�EJ�@VK?K0�JB�E?�E�VK@>B��T�ENK@@���W?EJ��KMBE�K�@?�C

��G�B��?D@I���P?�B�@�JBS�ME@PH��@?�0��K@JE?�I�H�ZK����?E0�V?E�W?B

JB��UK�B�BNB�?B�U��K�E@EAK��E�����BCB@D�XEKHB�K��UJ�s?�?�J)

p?E?�T�BJK��TE>�GU��K?0�V?E�>EMH��@�J����EH��Kk�K?��GI?D�B�BNB��

?B�P���@�EB��P>B�B�E@PLK@?�B?D�@�EB���JK�K�BI0�W?E�B��T���HP�JE�

ZK?�TE�CBI?D����@�K�SHK�Z��U)�tU�V�@?E��P>E�EH@?�PKJ@I�T�E?B�E�

TECEZ�UJ�T�KH@?��CK�BKJ0�HPJ�I0�V?E��K�EGJEZ�E��BVKME�E@PLK�

@?�B?D0�TE>��W?EME��K�HETP@?I?��KCB>BK�HK�Z��U)�|�HKZ�E@?D�JB�E�

@?�EB?KCD@?���JEZK?�AU?D�EAK@TKVK��0�>EMH��W?E?�T�ENK@@�G��EZH��

K?@I�BJK��E���?EJ�>E�?K>@?K0�MHK�E��HECZK��T�EB@SEHB?D�B���G�B�

��?D@I)�[�W?EJ�@CPV�K�T�ENK@@�G�V�@?P^�E>�GU��K?@I���@?ECD>E�ZBG�

�K@TE@EA�UJ0�V?E�KME��EGHK�@?�BK����@B?P�NB^�T�K�Uk�K?��@IVK@�

>BK�EZBH��BI)�|K�G��^0�E?�K?BC�CB�I������k��ET�E@)�[U0�JEZK?�AU?D0

T�KH@?��CIK?K�@KAK�W?E�TE�H�PMEJP)

Page 119: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

M���� �/%�"�-8�F?E�I�BC@I�B�BNB�?E�EJ�JB��EME�T�ENK@@����?KS@?����S0�CBHK�U�BCB�T�E@?E�����EH\

MU! ��!����R���#8���?K0�B�H�PMBK)�=�ENK@@�T�ESEHBC�����J>�S�?�>��GU��KJEME�vK�?��CD�E�JK�B>��@>EME�TC���0� BCB�TC����]@>���

R�B�@�)�R�B�@�AUC�T�KGBHK�?EJ�FE@?��zB>B0�B�TC���AUC�B�BNBB�E�

������T�KGBHK�?@>EJ�ElB@K���FE@?��zB>K)�xUCB�T�BMC�kK�U�>�PV�@�

?B^�VK?U�K�H�PMBS�ME@PH��@?���W?EME��KMBE���Q�X�CD��HE�0�OE�HP�

��@0�|B>���MP��B�O��?KJ�C�)�=C���T�KHTEC�M�C�H���T�B�NBT�)�=�B��

NBT�TK��U����@K�P@BCBI�HECZ�U�AU?D�EALK�KMBE��CD�UJB)�=�B��

NBT��?E�E���>�ZHEK�ME@PH��@?�E�@�JE�E?�KV�K?�G����P?�K��B��JB��

�U��T�ENK@@)�F�ZHEK�ME@PH��@?�E�HECZ�E�AUCE�PV�KHB?D�@�E^�|�NB�

E��CD�P^�>EJB@@B^�T�BJB�K�BI0���?�>ZK���G��VB?D���KJI0�>EMH��AP�

HK?�EAwI�CK�E�TK�KJB�BK�B��IH�H�PMBS�JK�0���T���CK��US����T�K>���

LK�BK��E��)�Y�J��K�AUCE�P�B�K�@�CD�EME��KNKT?��HCI��@KS�ME@PH��@?�)

|�T�BJK�0���|B>���MP��AUC��@EGH����@?�P>?P���TE���NBE��CD�EJP

T�BJB�K�B^0���>E?E�E����AE?�CB�>EJB@@BB����?�KS�P�E��IS�Q����P>E�

�EH@?�K0���@�KH�KJ�G�K�K�B����P�E��K�J�@@)�Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�TE��@K�

@?���K����>�ZHEJ�P�E��K��KC�@D���AE?��TE���@kB�K�B^�JB��EME�T�E�

NK@@�)�[�O��?KJ�CK�T�ENK@@0���E@�E��EJ0�T�ESEHBC����ME@PH��@?�K��

�EJ�P�E��K)�[�>�ZHEJ�ME@PH��@?�K�kKC�@�E��E@EAU��T�ENK@@0��E�T�B

W?EJ�E@PLK@?�CIC�@D�>EE�HB��NBI���J�@k?�A�S��@KME��KMBE��)

�!������"8�[@K�W?E���VB��CE@D�@�K�SP\�FEJB@@BB�@EGH���CB@D�@�K�SPBCB�TE�B�BNB�?B�K����EH�\

MU! ��!����R���#8�[�>�ZHE��@?���K�TE���G�EJP)�[�|B>���MP�0����T�BJK�0�AUC�?ECVE>�@�BGP0�BG����EH�US�J�@@)

�������!"�#�-8�|E�AC�ME@CE�K�BK�@�K�SP0����K��EK0��@K�?�>B�AUCE)

�!������"8�p?E��C�@?B�@EGH���CB�>EJB@@BB�B�@��>NBE�B�E��CB�JB���EK�H�BZK�BK\

MU! ��!����R���#8�p?E�G��B@KCE�E?�@B?P�NBB)�y��K�JEMP�@>�G�?D}H�~0�TE?EJP�V?E���|B>���MP�0���T�BJK�0�AUCE�TE�H�PMEJP�Q�?�J�JK�

Page 120: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

@?�UK�>EJB@@BB0���E@�E��EJ0�B�BNBB�E��CB@D��KT���B?KCD@?�K��U�

JB�E�M��BG�NBIJB��?�J�PZK�@PLK@?�E��CB�E�M��BG�NBB0�>E?E�UK��TE@�

CKH@?�BB��CBCB@D���@?�P>?P�P)

��TE@CKH�B��>EJJK�?��B�)�p?E?��KMBE��CD�U��TC�����AE?�C���

T�B�NBT�S�T�EG��V�E@?B�B�@B�S�E��E@?B)�=�EG��V�E@?D�TEJEM�C�

PHE@?E�K�B?D@I���?EJ0�V?E�>�ZHEK�ME@PH��@?�E��UTEC�IK?��GI?UK���

@KAI�EAIG�?KCD@?��)�R�@B�S�E��E@?D�EAK@TKVB��C�@D�M��lB>EJ0�TE

>E?E�EJP�ET�KHKCK��UK�HK�@?�BI�����G�US�ME@PH��@?�K�T�EB@SEHB�

CB�EH�E��KJK��E)�=�B�NBTU�@��AE?�CB�SE�EkE0�B0��K@JE?�I����J�E�

ZK@?�E���GwKHB�I^LBS�l�>?E�E�0�T�ENK@@�T�EH�BM�C@I��TK�KH)

[U0�HECZ�E�AU?D0�TEJ�B?K0�V?E�|B>���MP���E@T�B�BJ�CE@D�>�>

ME@PH��@?�E0�ACBG>EK�>�FPAK�B�XE�K?@>EJP�XE^GP0���ETTEGBNBI���|B�

>���MP��lB���@B�E��C�@D�XEKHB�K��UJB�s?�?�JB)�R���X�CD��HE�K

T���B?KCD@?�E�AUCE�ACBG>E�>�XEKHB�K��UJ�s?�?�J0��E�@VB?�CE@D0

V?E�ETTEGBNBI�lB���@B�E��C�@D�XE�K?@>BJ�XE^GEJ)�FE�KV�E�ZK0

BJKCE�JK@?E���Kk�KK�H��CK�BK0��E�@B?P�NB^�?���@lE�JB�E��CE�P@B�

CBK0��EG�B>kKK���P?�B�>E�?K>@?�0����K���K�KME)

!R������RU,���R��8�y�SEVP��K��P?D@I�>���kKJP�T�EK>?P�B�>���kK�

JP�TECEZK�B^)�|B>���MP��HCI���@�T�BJK�0��E�MC���EK�?E0�V?E�T�EB@�

SEHB?�P���@)�F�>�I�TE�IC0�G��>E�E?>B��TK�BEH���k�HE�EME��ME@?D����

kKC�>�>P^�?E�lE�JPCP���kBS��G�BJEE?�EkK�B�)�n�JK�I�@CEZBCE@D

�TKV�?CK�BK0�V?E����KGPCD?�?K�W?BS�TEB@>E��AUC�����HK���T���BCD�

��I�BCB��E��I�lE�JPCB�E�>���ET�E@��Q���VKJ�G�H�V��O�PGBB�B�G�H�V�

RAS�GBB)�y�T�BkKC�>��U�EHP0�V?E�@?��?KMBVK@>BK�}V?E~�Q�W?E��E�U�

���B��?�SE�EkK��TE@?��E�>B�@�JEME��ET�E@�)�|�T�BJK�0�AUC�G�H��

�ET�E@�E�?EJ0�>�>�JEZ�E�@ES���B?D�@�E^��AS�G@>P^�BHK�?BV�E@?D�B

T�B�W?EJ�ZB?D���EH�EJ�ME@PH��@?�K�@�M�PGB��JB)�[BHBJE0�H�ZK�SE�E�

kE�TE@?��CK��U���ET�E@�E�?EJ0�V?E�?�>EK���kK�@?��?KMBVK@>EK�}V?E~0

KLK��K�ET�KHKCIK?�?EME0�>�>�JU�APHKJ�HK�@?�E��?D)�YE�K@?D0���HE�����

?B�@?��?KMBVK@>BK�}>�>~0����K�?ECD>E�@?��?KMBVK@>BK�}>?E~�B�}V?E~)�y

�K�JEMP����?B���W?E��@SKJK�W?E�@?��?KMBVK@>EK�}>�>~)�F�>�KME����?B0

>�>E���?KS�ECEMBI\�=K�KH�JEBJB�MC�G�JB�T�KH@?�C��?E�>�I�>��?B��

��SEZHK�BI�@?��?KMBVK@>EME�}V?E~0�@?��?KMBVK@>EME�}>?E~0��E�J�K

>�ZK?@I0�@?EB?�TEB@>�?D�@?��?KMBVK@>BK�}>�>~)�u@?D�CB�����kK��@SK�

JK�E?�K?����JE���ET�E@\�X>ECD>E�@?EB?�W?E�}>�>~\�����

Page 121: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

MU! ��!����R���#d!$�!/ �&�.� ! ��$%�&�� �,��$����

�������������������f��d�d��������� ���������

=K���I�V�@?D�JEK��T�KGK�?�NBB�TE@�ILK����K>E?E�UJ���GJUk�

CK�BIJ�E�T�ENK@@K�TK�KJK�)�zKVD�APHK?�BH?B�E���kK��>E�>�K?�E�

M�PTTK�B�E�H�PMBS�?�>BS�M�PTT�S)�qCI�W?EME���J�T�BHK?@I�TEHB@>P@�

@B�E��?D)�R��?E��I�V�@?D�APHK?�TE@�ILK���?EJP0�>�>�P@BCB?D�@?��?K�

MBVK@>EK��CBI�BK�HKI?KCD�E@?B�M�PTTU����@B?P�NB^)

�?�>0���VB��KJ�TK��P^�V�@?D)�y�TEC�M�^0�V?E��U�PV�@?�PK?K��

W?E�� M�PTTK�TE?EJP0� V?E� G�B�?K�K@E���U���BGJK�K�BB���@?EILKMETECEZK�BI�HKC�JKZHP�O�PGBK��B�RAS�GBK�)�R��ET�E@0�@�>E?E�EME�J�K

SE?KCE@D�AU���V�?D�B����>E?E�U��SE?KCE@D�AU�P@CUk�?D���kB�E?�K�

?U0�E?�E@B?@I�>�TE�BJ��B^���JB�T�ENK@@��TK�KJK�)�q�PMBJB�@CE���JB��V?E�B�>�>�JK�IK?@I\�u@CB�PMEH�E0�@lE�JPCB�PKJ��ET�E@�AECKK

�>�HKJBVK@>B��>�>E�����k��?KE�BI�TK�KJK�\��CB�AECKK�>E�>�K?�E�>�>���kK�PV�@?BK�����AE?K�W?E��M�PTTU�V?E�?E�BGJK�IK?����AS�G@>E�

M�PGB�@>BS��G�BJEE?�EkK�BIS\

��������%�"�8�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�TE@CK�?EME0�>�>�JU���V�CB�PV��

@?�E��?D���W?EJ�T�EK>?K0���RAS�GBB���V�C�@D�ET�KHKCK���I�HB@>P@�

@BI�TE��ET�E@P�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BS�E?�EkK�B�)�F�?EJP0�VKJ�JU�G��B�J�KJ@I0�E?�EkK�BK���G�EK)�|K��@K�W?E�T�B�K?@?�P^?0��E�AECDkB��

@?�E��K�MB�PK?0����JE���GMCIH0�@HK�Z���E�B�TEGB?B��E)�p?E�PZK�>��>E��?E��KGPCD?�?)�F�EJK�?EME0�TEI�CK�BK���kBS�@?�?K����@AE��B>�S0

>E?E�UK�HE�ECD�E�kB�E>E�NB�>PCB�P^?���EALK@?�K�8JU�@?���KJ@I0

V?EAU�W?E�AUCE�?�>:0�@TE@EA@?�PK?�?EJP0�V?E�C^HB���VB��^?�TK�KE�@JU@CB��?D�T�EACKJP�B0�JEZK?�AU?D0�PSEHI?�E?�HEMJ�?BGJ��B�KHB�E�

JU@CBI���W?E��@lK�K)�xC�MEH��I�W?EJP�T�EK>?P0�JU�@?�CB�KGHB?D�H�PM>�H�PMP)�O�PGB�U�T�BKGZ�CB���RAS�GB^�B��@?�KV�CB@D�?�J�@�PVK�U�

JB0�EALK@?�K��UJB�HKI?KCIJB)�p?E�AUCE�EVK�D��KCKM>E0��E�W?E�AUCE)

t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E��?E��I��@?�KV��T�EBGE�HK?����AECKK��U@E>EJ�P�E���K)�RAS�G@>BK�PV�@?�B>B�?EZK�TE@K?BCB�YABCB@B0��U@?PT�CB�TE�?K�

CK�BHK�B^)�p?E��UG��CE��KGE���@����AS�G@>EJ�EALK@?�K)�|K�G��^0

AUC�CB��KGE���@���M�PGB�@>EJ�EALK@?�K0��E����AS�G@>EJ�Q�AUC)

Page 122: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

!R������RU,���R��8�y�?EZK�SEVP�@>�G�?D�E�@�EKJ�CBV�EJ�ETU?K)nV�@?BK�����AE?K�W?EME�T�EK>?���@KMH��H�K?�>�>E��?E�BJTPCD@)�|��

T�BJK�0�I�CBV�E�T�E�EHBC�J�EZK@?�E�AK@KH�@�AKZK�N�JB�TE�TE�EHP

���EH�E��HBTCEJ�?BB0�T�BJB�K�BI�B�?)H)0�T�E�EHBC�TE�W?BJ�?KJ�J

lE>P@�M�PTTU)�FE�KV�E0�W?E�B@@CKHE��?KCD@>�I���AE?�0��E�EH�E��K�

JK��E�W?E�@EGH�K?�B�EALK@?�K��EK�J�K�BK)��AE�?�>BK��ET�E@U�HB@�

>P?B�P^?@I��KH>E)�R�HB@>P@@BI�PZK�>�>�AU�lE�JB�PK?�J�K�BK�AK�

ZK�NK�)�p?E�EVK�D���Z�E)�uLK�BG�JEKME�CBV�EME�ETU?���AC�MEH��I

BJTPCD@P0�>E?E�U��I�TECPVBC�GHK@D�H���MEH����G�H0�J�K�PH�CE@D�E�M��

�BGE��?D��@?�KVP�@?��K�kB��Q�TEZBCUS��AS�GE��B�M�PGB�0�E�B��@?�K�

V�CB@D�>�>���G���XEVB)�p?E�AUC��T��>?BVK@>B�TK���I��@?�KV�����?��

>EJ�P�E��K�AKG�JKHB�?E���BG��K)�y�@�J�AUC�JKHB�?E�EJ�@E�JK@?�E�@

�AS�G@>BJ�>ECCKME�)�=E?EJ�W?B�@?��K�kB�U��@?�K?BCB@D�KLK���G0�PZK

AKG�JEKME�PV�@?BI0�?E�K@?D�I�BJ�TEJEM�C0��E��@?�K?BCB@D�E�B�PZK�AKG

JK�I�B�EA@PZH�CB��@K�@�MC�GP����MC�G)�XK�V�@�E�B�SE?I?��@?�K?B?D@I��

?�K?B����G)�Y�>E��JE��ETU?)

p?E?�T�EK>?��CBIK?����>�ZHEME�BG���@0���JU0�@E�@�EK��@?E�E�U0

>�>�JEZKJ0��CBIKJ������kK�E>�PZK�BK)�|E�J�@k?�AU��CBI�BI�J�K

?�PH�E�BGJK�B?D)�[�TK�K�U�K0���T�BJK�0�YK�MBG�ME�E�BC�E�J�@k?��

A�S��CBI�BI�B�H�ZK�PTEJB��C�E�?EJ0�V?E��U@E>ETE@?��CK��UK�VB�E��

�B>B�VB?�^?���kB�@AE��B>B0�V?E���BS��KV�S�T�E@>�CDGU��^?�>�>BK�

?E��UVB?���UK����BS�BHKB0�?E�K@?D�@�EKEA��G�EK��CBI�BK�K@?D)�|E�I

�K�JEMP�T�E@CKHB?D�W?E�CBV�E)�q�PMBK0�JEZK?�AU?D0��BHI?�AECKK�?E��

>BK�BGJK�K�BI)

�������!"�#�-8�y��A@EC^?�E�@EMC�@K��@�?KJ0�V?E�ME�E�B?�|�?KCC�0HEA��C^�?ECD>E�EH�E)�|�kB��@?�KVB�8B��K�?ECD>E�����J>�S�W?EME�T�E�

K>?�0����EEALK���TK�KME�E��EJ�T�ENK@@K�����KElBNB�CD�EJ�P�E��K:

H�^?�TE�I?D��C�@?IJ0�?KJ0�>?E�BJKK?�ElBNB�CD�UK�J��H�?U�����KHK�

�BK�TK�KME�E�E�0�V?E�B�BNB�?B���JEZK?�BH?B�B�@�BGP0�V?E�EALK@?�E

�T���K��CBI?D����T�B�I?BK��KkK�B����TK�KME�E��EJ�T�ENK@@K)�[�>��

>E��?E�TK�BEH���AC H�CE@D�ET�KHKCK��EK��KT�BI?BK0�@ET�E?B�CK�BK0

��@�PAKZH�CB0�V?E�W?E�HKCE��C�@?K��B�V?E�JU�HECZ�U�BJ�HE�K�B?D@I0

��@�P�K�ICB��W?E���k���C�@?D0���kK�ME@PH��@?�E0�B��B>?E��B>EMH���K

EAJ��K?���kB�EZBH��BI)�|E�@KMEH�I�PZK�B�EALK@?�E0�B��C�@?B�TE�B�

J�^?0�V?E�JU��K�@EAB��KJ@I�PSEHB?D�E?�E?�K?@?�K��E@?B0�>EMH��>?E�

Page 123: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

?E�>�>�?E�@EAB��K?@I��KkB?D���kP�@PHDAP0�B�V?E�JU�SE?BJ0�V?EAU

TK�KME�E��U��T�ENK@@�AUC�T�EG��V�UJ)�YE0�V?E�JU�HKC�KJ0���kB

@AE��B>B0���kB�TPACB>�NBB0�HB@>P@@BB����?KCK�BHK�BB�Q�W?E�T�B�

JK��?EME0���@>ECD>E�HECZK��AU?D�T�EG��V�UJ�@�J�TK�KME�E��U��T�E�

NK@@)�p?EME��K?����ElBNB�CD�EJ�P�E��K0�TEW?EJP�JU�EVK�D�J�CE�G���

KJ�E�?EJ0�V?E�?�J�T�EB@SEHB?)�y�@K�V�@��K�APHP�T�B�EHB?D�T�BJK�U

�KB�lE�JB�E����E@?B�EALK@?���E��@?�KV�S����ElBNB�CD�EJ�P�E��

�K)�=E�E���C�@?B�EM���BVB��^?@I�CBkD��KAECDkE��B�lE�J�NBK��E

?EJ0�V?E�?�J�?E�B�?�J�?E��@?�K?BCE@D�W��EK�>ECBVK@?�E�C^HK��B�>EK�

V?E�EA@PHBCB)�tU�ZK�H�KJ�EVK�D�J�EME�B�lE�J�NBB)

�����M�.� �-8�y�SE?KC�AU�>EK�V?E�HEA��B?D�>�?EJP0�V?E�@>�G�CB�JEB>ECCKMB)��K�KG�TEHEA�EME��EH��JK�ET�BI?BI�JU�BJKKJ��EGJEZ�E@?D

@ES���B?D�@TE@EA�E@?D�JU@CB?D�B�E@JU@CB��?D��K�CBB���P@CE�BIS0

��>E?E�US�JU�ZB�KJ)�tU�ZB�KJ���ET�@�E��@B?P�NBB0�>EMH��?E?�CB�

?����I�lE�J��B�?KCCK>?P�CD�E��ZBG�B�JEZK?��K��P?D@I�>���J���E�D

VK�KG�>�>BK�?E�H�PMBK�JKS��BGJU0�>EMH��@�JE@EG���BK�EALK@?���lE��

JB�PK?@I�BG�K@?�UJB���J��UV�M�JB)�XKMEH�I�?�>�I�?K�HK�NBI�K@?D

Q�TE�BJ��BK��K�CB��lE�JB�PK?@I�@�K�SP�B����IGU��K?@I�EALK@?�P)

R�JU�?KTK�D�@�JB�TU?�KJ@I�AU?D�PV�@?�B>�JB�W?EME�T�ENK@@��B�lE��

JB�E��?D�@�EK�TE�BJ��BK�BCB�@�E^�?KE�B^�T�EB@SEHILBS�T�ENK@�

@E�)�u@CB0�@>�ZKJ0�JU@CK��E�ENK�B?D�@B?P�NB^0�?E���RAS�GBB�?EZK

T�E@J�?�B��K?@I�ET�KHKCK���I�?���@lE�J�NBI�@�JE@EG���BI��AS�G�

@>EME�EALK@?��)

�� ������/%!��-8�]�?EJ0�>�>EK��CBI�BK�E>�GU��K?�W?E�����IHE�USM��ZH��0�TECB?BVK@>BS�HKI?KCK��B�?KS0�>?E��EEALK�B�?K�K@PK?@I�W?E�

?KJ�?B>E�)�|�?KCC�� ME�E�BC�0� V?E�TE@CKH�II��@?�KV����YABCB@B��

�EIA�K�T�EkCEME�MEH��B�?KCK�BGBE���I�G�TB@D��UG��CB�AECDkE��B��

?K�K@���XPSPJB)�|K�JK�DkB�0���JEZK?0�B�AECDkB��B�?K�K@�W?E��UG���

CE���YABCB@B)�p?��TK�KH�V��AUC���K@>ECD>E���G�TE>�G����TE��?E�EJP

>���CP� ?KCK�BHK�BI0� T�B?EJ���HE�ECD�E�PHEA�EK� �KVK��KK� ��KJI)

F�EJK�?EME0�EVK�D���Z�E0�V?E�J�?K�B�CU�W?BS��@?�KV�TPACB>P^?@I)

]�B�TE?EJ�BGPV�^?@I0���@>ECD>E�J�K�BG�K@?�E0�J�EMBJB�TECB?B>��

JB�B�HECZ�E@?�UJB�CBN�JB��U@E>EME����M�0�T�B?EJ��K@DJ��?L�?KCD�

�E)�8|�@>ECD>E�I�G��^0��P>E�EH@?�EJ�@?���U�?EZK):�XCKHPK?�E?JK�

Page 124: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

?B?D0�V?E�W?E�EVK�D���Z�U��JEJK�?0�TE?EJP�V?E�K@CB�AU�W?B�J�?K�B�

�CU��K�TPACB>E��CB@D0�K@CB�>�ZHU��PV�@?�B>�TE�@�EKJP0���@E>��LK��

�EJ��BHK0���@@>�GU��C�AU�E��@?�KV�S0���NKCEJ�>��?B���AUC��AU��KI@�

��)�y�W?E�G��^0�TE?EJP�V?E�J�EMBK�TECB?B>B0�JEB�>ECCKMB0�AKZK�NU0

T�E@?E�G��>EJUK0�PG���0�V?E�@E@?EIC�@D��@?�KV�0�EVK�D�V�@?E�G�E�I?

B���@@T��kB��^?�JK�I0�T�E@I?�TEHKCB?D@I��TKV�?CK�BIJB0�G��I0�V?E

��M�GK?�E��@?�?DK�I��@��BGCEZB?D��K�JEMP�Q�W?E��K�EGJEZ�E)�=�B?EJ

B�?K�K@P^?@I�AP>��CD�E��@KJ��B�T�E@?E�JU@CIJB0�B�CBV�UJB�>E��

?�>?�JB�JKZHP�PV�@?�B>�JB��@?�KVB)���EMH��TK�KH�^?�T�B�K?U�AP>�

��CD�E� �@KJ)�|K>E?E�UK�B�?K�K@P^?@I0� >�>��UMCIHB?� ?��BCB�B��I

PV�@?�BN���@?�KVB)�������p?B��@?�KVB0�JEZK?�AU?D0��K��Kk�^?�T�E�

ACKJP�>��HB��CD�E0��E��K@P?�ME��GHE�AECDkK���M�PG>B0�VKJ�ElBNB�

�CD�UK�TK�KME�E�U)�p?E�AKG�@EJ�K�BI)�{HK@D��K?�?E��@>E����E@?B0

>E?E��I�K@?D����?KS�TK�KME�E��S)�=EW?EJP�I�PZK�?�B�MEH���K�KGZP���

TK�KME�E�U�ElBNB�CD�EME�S���>?K��)�=�E@?E��K�EVK�D�B�?K�K@�E)

[�G�>C^VK�BK�@>�ZP0�V?E�W?B��@?�KVB��K�T�ESEHI?�AK@@CKH�E��E�B

H�^?�SE�EkP^�TBLP�HCI�G��PAKZ�US�PVK�US�B�TECB?ECEME�0�>E?E�

�UK�APHP?�TE?EJ�TB@�?D�HB@@K�?�NBB)

��������%����S,���8�pllK>?�W?B��@?�KVB�BJK^?)�=E�?EJP0�>�>��K��MB�PK?�EALK@?�K��E@?D������kB��@?�KVB0�E@EAK��E�TE�@?KTK�B�B��

?K�K@�0�>E?E�U���UGU��^?���kB�@AE��B>B0�JEZ�E�@PHB?D0���@>ECD>E

��Z�����EALK@?�K��AS�G@>�I�?KJ�)�y�PAKZH�^@D0�V?E�W?��?KJ���K�?�>

PZ�B���Z��0�TE?EJP�V?E���kB�>�BMB�VB?�^?���E@�E��EJ�AKZK�NU�B

T���B?KCD@?�E���BGM���BB)��B?�^?�EVK�D�>�B?BVK@>B)�FEMH��I�@��BJB

�@?�KV�^@D0�@��GP��BZP�Q�VB?�CB0�TE?EJP�V?E���VB��^?�>�B?B>E��?D)

OE�E�I?��TEVKJP�?U�@>�G�C�?�>�BCB�W?�>0�V?E�BJKC����BHP\�=ECEZB�

?KCD�US�ENK�E>�@�BS�@?E�E�U�EAUV�E��K?)�y�@T��kB��^���KPZKCB

?�J�HCI���@�AECDkK��BVKME�B�?K�K@�EME��K�AUCE\�y���GH�^�W?B�>�B�

MB����HE�ECD�E��U@E>EJ�P�E��K�Q�B���>��NKCI�BB�T�KGBHK�?�0�B��

T��C�JK�?K0��E�>EMH��T�BSEZP�?PH��VK�KG�JK@IN0�@AE��B>B�?�>�ZK

CKZ�?����TEC>�S)�n�M�PGB�@>BS�CBHK�E�0�HKTP?�?E�0�TECB?B>E���K?

��KJK�B0�V?EAU�VB?�?D�>�BMB�E�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>E��T�EACKJK)�|E�K@CB

P��BS�@T�E@B?D0�G��BJ�K?@I�CB�>?E��BAPHD�W?BJ�>E�lCB>?EJ����EA�

LK@?�K��EJ�P�E��K0���?�K?DKJ�@K>?E�K0�E�B�@>�ZP?0�V?E�H�0�V?E�E�B

G��^?0�V?E�K@?D�?�>BK�C^HB0�B���@@>�ZP?���J�J�EME�@>�GE>�E�?EJ0�>�>

Page 125: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

W?E�TECKG�E0��PZ�E�B�WllK>?B��E)�|E�E�B������@��B>EMH���K��USEHI?0

�B>EMH���K�B�?K�K@P^?@I���kBJ�J�K�BKJ)�FEMH��JU�>��BJ�T�BSE�

HBJ0�E�B�EVK�D�P��ZB?KCD�E�@CPk�^?�B�HKC�^?��BH0�V?E�BJ�B�?K�K@�

�E)�X>E�KK��@KME�Q�BG��KZCB�E@?B)�Y�>�V?E�W?��?KJ��HCI�@KMEH�Ik�K�

O�PGBB0�HCI�M�PGB�@>BS�TECB?B>E�0��K�I�CIK?@I�E@�E��E�0���Z�K��

kK�)

�� �%!���R�S���8�|KJ�EME�HEA��C^�>�?EJP0�V?E�@>�G�C�=��?�)�RA�@EC^?�E�@��BJ�@EMC�@��)�XPLK@?�PK?���G�BN��JKZHP��CBI�BKJ�W?E�

HKI?KCD�E@?B����AS�G@>EJ�EALK@?�K�B���M�PGB�@>EJ)�tU���O�PGBB

JEZKJ�B@TECDGE��?D��@K�@PLK@?�P^LBK�JK?EHU0�V?EAU�HE�K@?B�HE

EALK@?���B�lE�J�NB^�EA�W?BS��@?�KV�S��M�GK?U0�?KCK�BHK�BK)�=�E�

ACKJ����?EJ0�V?E0�>�>�@>�G�C�=��?�0���O�PGBB�B�?K�K@�>���kK��HKI�

?KCD�E@?B�T�EI�CIK?@I�@C�AKK0�TE?EJP�V?E�EALK@?�E���RAS�GBB�ME�

��GHE�JK�DkK0�B��H�K@�?E��W?E��B�lE�J�NBB�?EZK�ME��GHE�JK�DkK0

VKJ���O�PGBB)�YE�K@?D���kB��AS�G@>BK�>ECCKMB�JEMP?��CBI?D����EALK�

@?�E�AECDkK0�VKJ�JU0��E�JU0�I�HPJ�^0�JEZKJ�B@TECDGE��?D�AECDkK

@�KH@?��HCI��CBI�BI)�u@CB�>EJP�?E�B�?K�K@�E0���O�PGBB�JEZ�E�TB�

@�?D�B�ME�E�B?D�E�VKJ�PMEH�E0�T�E@?E��B>?E��K�@?��K?�VB?�?D�B�@CP�

k�?D�Q��B>EJP�W?E��K�B�?K�K@�E�B��K���Z�E)

��R��� ����0�8�[���J>�S�W?EME�T�EK>?��JU��TK��UK0�T���CCKCD�E@�|EH��EJ0�T�E�KCB�EVK�D��KAECDkE��@ENBECEMBVK@>B��ET�E@�TE

TE�EHP��K�>NBB���@KCK�BI�����BGB?��AS�G@>EME�T�KGBHK�?��R�HGB��

A����YABCB@B)�zKGPCD?�?U�TE>�G�CB0�V?E�AECDkB�@?�E�C HK��E?�K@�

CB@D�>�W?EJP�@EAU?B^�@�HE@?�?EV�UJ�TE�BJ��BKJ)�y�EZBH�C��ME��G�

HE�AECKK�ZK@?>EME�E?�EkK�BI�>��BGB?P)�p?E�EHB��T�BJK�)�[@K�W?B

>�BMB0�@?�?DB�TEJEMCB�EALK@?�K��EJP�@EG���B^��AS�GE����GMCIHK?D

G��J�@>E�0� @SKJE�� M�PGB���T�E?B��B>�� >�>BK�?E� �K�CD�UK�VK�?U)

�KCE�K>�@�?E��@?E�E�U�PZK�BJKK?�VKCE�KVK@>EK�CBNE)�t�EMBK�PZK

G��^?�PV�@?�B>E��T�EK>?��TE�BJK��J0�TE�l�JBCBIJ0�TE�TEGBNBIJ)

t�EMBK�@?���^?@I�H�ZK�@CKHB?D�G��TPACB>�NBIJB����W?P�?KJP��K�?ECD�

>E�TE���kBJ�@AE��B>�J0��E�B�TE�M�GK?K��F��>�G@>B���>NK�?��Q�?�J

AU��^?�EVK�D�B�?K�K@�UK�@?�?DB)�Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0��E�J�EMEJ�AC�ME�

H��I�W?EJP�T�EK>?P0��BHK�BK�@?�CE�AECKK��K�CD�UJ0��K�@SKJ�?BV�UJ0

>�>�AUCE�@��GP�TE@CK��E��U)

Page 126: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

MU! ��!����R���#8�YKTK�D�TEG�ECD?K�J�K�T�EBCC^@?�B�E��?D���kK

TE�BJ��BK�?KE�BB0����>E?E�E���U�E@�E�U��K?K�@�EB�HK�@?�BI)�=E@CK

W?EME�I�TEME�E�^�EA�ENK�>K�?EME0�>�>�E@JU@CB?D�@?��?KMBVK@>B���K�

GPCD?�?��EGHK�@?�BI�8�"���:)

�?�>0� H����?K� @��V�C����@@JE?�BJ��K@>ECD>E� ��kBS�?KE�B��B

TET�EAPKJ�EACKVD�BS���lE�JPCB�E�>B)�|�T�BJK����E@?��KlE�J�CD�

�US�@�IGK��JKZHP�M��ZH���JB�EAKBS�@?E�E��P�KCBVB?�@?KTK�D�HE�K�

�BI0�PMCPAB?�>EJTCK>@�EK�TE�BJ��BK�>E�lCB>?�)�=�B���KH�K�BB�?��

>EME�TE�BJ��BI���@EE?�K?@?�P^LBK�@EEALK@?���@E>��?B?@I0�TE�B�

GB?@I�@?KTK�D�HEMJ�?BGJ��B�PG>EME�JUkCK�BI)�p?E�TEHME?��CB��K?

EALK@?�E�>��@?PTCK�B^����E�UK�E?�EkK�BI�@�H�PME��@?E�E�E�)�[E?

W?E�PZK�?KE�BI�TK�KJK����CBI�BK�J�CE��M�PTTU�TK�K��@?�K?��E��CBI�

�BK�PZK�AECDkK��M�PTTU)

n���@�K@?D�B�H�PMBK�?KE�BB)�|�T�BJK�0�>?E�?E�@>�G�C0�V?E�@�P�K�

CBVK�BKJ�VB@C��M��ZH��0�PV�@?�P^LBS���T�ENK@@K�P�KMPCB�E���BI0

�EG��@?�K?�KME�T�EG��V�E@?D0��P>E�EH@?�E�@?��E�B?@I�AECKK�E?�K?�

@?�K��UJ�B�TEHE?VK?�UJ)�q�PME��PV�@?�B>��U��GBC@I�@CKM>��B��VK�

�E@?�E?>�U?E@?B�EALK@?��0�AC�MEH��I�?KCK�BHK�B^�B�@�KH@?��J�J�@�

@E�E��B�lE�J�NBB0�@TE@EA@?�PK?���G�B?B^��CD?K���?B��E��JEHKCB0

���>E?E�P^��P>E�EH@?�E�HECZ�E�>�>�?E�E?�K�MB�E��?D)�q�PMBJB�@CE�

��JB0��P>E�EH@?�E�PZK��K�JEZK?�HK�@?�E��?D�?�>0�>�>�HK�@?�E��CE�AU

��B�E��@B?P�NBB)�XEMC�@�E�W?E��?KE�BB0�K@CB�C^HB0�PV�@?�P^LBK��

JB�E?�E�VK@?�K0�TEI�CI^?@I����W>���K�B�E?>�U?E��U@?PT�^?0�?E�TPA�

CB>��@�J����VB��K?�?�KAE��?D�AECDkK�T�EG��V�E@?B�B�E?�@�EKME��P�

>E�EH@?��)�=EW?EJP�T���B?KCB0�V?EAU�ET�KHKCB?D�@�E^�?�>?B>P0�ZK�

C�^?�G��?D0�V?E�T�EB@SEHB?���?�>BS�M�PTT�S)

tK�KK�VKJ�G��,-�JB�P?�JU�TE@?��BCB�@?ECD>E���Z�US��ET�E@E�0

V?E�BS�S��?B?�����K@>ECD>E�HB@@K�?�NB�)�[@K�E�B�HE@?�?EV�E�B�?K�

�K@�U�B�?�KAP^?�BGPVK�BI)�y�HPJ�^0�JU�G�B�?K�K@E���U��K���?EJ0

V?EAU���PV�E�HE>�G�?D�BCB�ET�E�K�M�P?D�>�>E��CBAE�BG��@TK>?E��?E�

BCB�B�E��?KE�BB)�u@CB�JU�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�T�EI@�BCB���kK�TE�BJ��

�BK�TK�KJK�0�AUCE�AU�EVK�D���Z�E���K@?B���HB@>P@@B^���kK�T�KH�

@?��CK�BK�E�?EJ0�>�>�E�B�T�EB@SEHI?)�YEMH��JU�@JEZKJ�@HKC�?D�H�K

�KLB)�[E�TK��US0�JU�@JEZKJ�PVB?D@I�E@JU@CB��?D�@�EB�HK�@?�BI)

p?E�G��VB?0�V?E0�T�BG����I�@PLK@?�E���BK��IH��@CEZ�E@?K��T�B�E@P�

LK@?�CK�BB� G�HPJ���US���JB�TK�KJK�0�JU�TE@?EI��E�EA@PZH�KJ

Page 127: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

��kB�T�KH@?��CK�BI�E�T�EB@SEHILKJ)�[�W?EJ�@JU@CK0�JU�APHKJ�PVB?D�

@I��@^�ZBG�D)

�?�>0��E�TK��US�Q�BGPVK�BK���kBS�@EA@?�K��US�HK�@?�B�)����E�

�?E�US0�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU���k��HKI?KCD�E@?D�@?�C��AECKK�WllK>?B��

�E�0�JU�JEZKJ�@T�E@B?D�@�JBS�@KAI�Q���T�EB@SEHI?�CB����K�CD�E@?B

?K�T�ENK@@U0���>E?E�UK�JU��K�BJ0�E�>E?E�US�JU�HPJ�KJ0�V?E�E�B

T�EB@SEHI?\�|�T�BJK�0���?KVK�BK�,-�JB�P?�E��AK@KHU�PZK�EA���P�

ZBCB@D��K>E?E�UK���G�EMC�@BI)�]H���?KE�BI�TK�KJK��MC�@BC���AECD�

kK�@�IGK�0�AECDkK�J�?K�B�CE�0�AECDkK�E?>�U?E@?B�Q�AECDkK��CBI�

�BI�����P>E�EH@?�E)�XEMC�@�E�H�PME��?KE�BB0��P>E�EHB?KCB��K�VB?��

^?�J�?K�B�CU0�>E?E�UK�TUCI?@I����TEC>�S�B��B����V?E��K��CBI^?)�[

@�IGB�@���kBJB�?KE�BIJB�TK�KJK�0��EG�B>�^?�H����ET�E@���SE?BJ�CB

JU��CBI?D�����P>E�EH@?�E0�B�>�>����@�JEJ�HKCK���AE?�K?���k��?KE�BI

�EGHK�@?�BI\�oE?BJ�CB�JU��CBI?D����AKZK�NK�0�B�ZBG�K@TE@EA���CB

��k��?KE�BI��CBI�BI����AKZK�NK�\

�?�>0��K��KJ@I�>�EA@PZHK�B^�?KE�BB�TK�KJK�)�{����KJI0��UHK�

CK��EK�J�K�HCI�T�KGK�?�NBB0�J�K�SE?KCE@D�AU�T�KHCEZB?D���J�EH�P�

H�K�BHKB0��EHB�kBK@I�BG�ETU?�0�T�BEA�K?K��EME���>E�?K>@?K�H�PME�

@B?P�NBB)�XCPVBCE@D�?�>0�V?E�W?B�BHKB�TEJEMCB�C^HIJ0�TEHEA�UJ

��J0�>E�@?�P>?B��E��EGHK�@?�E��?D����>E�lCB>?)�8y�PTE?�KABC�@CE�E

�@CPVBCE@D�0�TE?EJP�V?E�BHKB�H�CK>E��K��@KMH��EAK@TKVB��^?�>E�@?�

�P>?B��EK��CBI�BK����>E�lCB>?�P^�@B?P�NB^):�=EG�ECD?K�TEHKCB?D@I

H�PJI�@TKNBlBVK@>BJB�E@EAK��E@?IJB0�@�IG���UJB�@��ET�E@EJ�E

@?��?KMBVK@>EJ��EGHK�@?�BB)

tE��IGU>�?�PH�E�TK�K�EHB?D0�TE@>ECD>P��K>E?E�UK�TE�I?BI�?�PH�

�E�TE�I?D�B������MCB�@>EJ)��?�>0�W?B�H�K�BHKB�?�>E�U��@?��?KMBVK@�

>EK��>?E��B�@?��?KMBVK@>EK��V?E�)�OE�E�I�E�TK��E��BHKK0�J�K���HE�HCI

��MCIH�E@?B�@HKC�?D�T��P��B@P�>E�)�y�JEM�AU���@@>�G�?D���J�HCB��

�P^�B@?E�B^0�BG�>E?E�E���EG�B>C��W?��BHKI0��E�EM���BVP@D�>��?>E�

�K�@BK�)�]H���B@?E�BI�@�IG����@��E��E����|B>���MP����;-�S�MEH�S0��

�?E��I�Q�@�>E�lCB>?EJ���XEJ�CB���5-�S)�y���HK^@D0�V?E��U��B>EBJ

EA��GEJ��K�@?��K?K�P�IGU��?D�>E�?K>@?�PTEJI�P?US�H�PS�>E�lCB>�

?E��@���kBJ0��E�@?��?KMBVK@>BK�BHKB�JEMP?�E>�G�?D@I��KCK���?�UJB)

[�EAEBS�@CPV�IS���J�T�BHK?@I�TE��AE?�?D���H�TE�BJ��BKJ�>E��

?K>@?��>E�lCB>?��0�HCI���MCIH�E@?B�BGEA��ZK��EME����BHK�TB��JB�

HU)�[�@CPV�K�@�|B>���MP��JU���AE?�CB�@�B�HK�N�JB�JK@>B?E@0�P�>E�

Page 128: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

?E�US�AUC����?E�EJBI0�B�T���B?KCD@?�EJ)�tK@>B?E@�Q�W?�BVK@>EK

JK�DkB�@?�E���|B>���MP�)�]HB��BG��@TK>?E���E��U�.5;-�S�Q��E���

JKZHP�W?E��M�PTTE��W?�BVK@>EME�JK�DkB�@?���B���NBE��CD�UJ�T���

�B?KCD@?�EJ�@��HB�B@?E�)�R���XEJ�CB�>E�lCB>?�AUC�JKZHP�>C����

JB�B�TEH>C���JB�@EJ�CB�@>E����NBB)

�HKI�@E@?EB?���?EJ0�V?E�@PLK@?�P^?���G�UK�P�E��B��P>E�EH@?��)

u@?D��U@kB��P�E�K�D��C�@?B�8�K�kB���TB��JBHU:0�@�KH�B��B�kB�E�

>BK�J�@@U�T�E@?US�C HK�0�@EEALK@?�E�8E@�E���BK�TB��JBHU:)�=B�

��JBH����MCIH�E�TE>�GU��K?0�V?E���BGP�J�EME�C HK�0������K�SP�Q�EVK�D

J�CE)�y��K�SEVP�@>�G�?D0�V?E�@B?P�NBI�HECZ����UMCIHK?D�BJK��E��TB�

��JBH�CD�E�0�T�E@?E�TB��JBH��TEJEM�K?���MCIH�E�E?EA��GB?D� ?E?

l�>?0�V?E���J�@k?�AK�EALK@?���T�E@?US�C HK��EVK�D�J�EME0���SE�E�

kE�BG�K@?�US�B�PG����KJUS�Q�EVK�D�J�CE)�{HK@D�JU�B���V�KJ�T�EI@�

�I?D�B�ETB@U��?D�TEHSEHU�>�JB��EJP�H�BZK�B^)

u@?D� ?�B� E@�E��US�TEHSEH�)�X�JU��BG�K@?�U��Q� W?E� TEHSEH

�@�K�SP���BG�)�]��ETB��K?@I����HBTCEJ�?BVK@>P^�JEHKCD0�E@�E����

�P^����E?�EkK�BIS�JKZHP���NBIJB�8ME@PH��@?��JB:)�p?��JEHKCD�@E�

HK�ZB?���@KAK��BHK^�@?EC��)�|�k�@?EC�JEM�AU�@?�?D�HBTCEJ�?BVK@�

>BJ�@?ECEJ)�X�EH�E��@?E�E�U��E@@KH�^?�C HB0�T�KH@?��CI^LBK�EH�E

EALK@?�E�BCB�EH�P���NB^0�����T�E?B��Q�?K0�>?E�T�KH@?��CIK?���NB^

T�E?B��B>�)�[�?K�JB�ECEMBB�JKZHP���EH�B>E��W?E���GU��K?@I�@?E�

CEJ�TK�KME�E�E�)

=EJ�B?K�>E�lCB>?�JKZHP����>EJ�B�XEKHB�K��UJB�s?�?�JB\

.55-�MEH)�xECDkE��HCB��U��@?EC)�qZK�J@�xW�>K��T�KH@?��CIK?�XsR0

Y��B>�RGBG�@BHB?���T�E?B�0���JK�KK���Z�UK�TK�@E�U���@@�ZK�U�TE

EAK�@?E�E�U�E?��BS)�mE?E�TT���?U�G�TKV�?CKCB�J��V�UK��KHE�K�VB�

�UK�lBGBE�EJBB�B�@NK�U�AKG�>�>BS�CBAE�T�BG��>E��HB@>P@@BB)

]?�K?@?�K��E@?D�G���KHK�BK�TK�KME�E�E���EGC�M�C�@D����PV�@?�B�

>E�0�PTEC�EJEVK��US�T���B?KCD@?�EJ)�[�@CPV�K�HE@?BZK�BI�>�>E��

�BAPHD�HEME�E�K��E@?B0�E�B�B�HECZ�U�AUCB�HE�K@?B�KK�HE�@�EKME�T���

�B?KCD@?��)�R�T���B?KCD@?�E0�>E�KV�E�ZK0�T�KH@?��CIK?����EH)�Y�>BJ

EA��GEJ0��@�0�V?E�JEMCE�AU?D�GHK@D�HE@?BM�P?E0�EHEA�ICE@D����EHEJ)

�?�>0�NKCD^�T�ENK@@��G��@?ECEJ�TK�KME�E�E��I�CIK?@I�HE@?BZK�

�BK�@EMC�kK�BI0���GU��KJEME�B�EMH��JB��UJ�@EMC�kK�BKJ)�F�>�?ECD�

>E�G�>C^VK�E�JB��EK�@EMC�kK�BK0��EG�B>�K?��KEASEHBJE@?D�HE�K@�

?B�KME�HE�E@?�CD�E��V�@?B�EALK@?��)�p?E?�TEHSEH0�>E�KV�E0�E@�E���

Page 129: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

���B@?E�BB���NB��ME@PH��@?�)�]H��>E��K�CBB�@E��KJK��US�>E�lCB>�

?E��?�>E�U0�V?E�AECDkB�@?�E�BG��BS��EG�B>�K?����TEV�K���P?�K��BS

T�E?B�E�KVB���� @PLK@?�P^LBS� ME@PH��@?��S�BCB��� �KMBE��S0� MHK

lE�JB�PK?@I��E�EK�TE�BJ��BK�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B)�p?��JEHKCD�TE�

�EZH�K?���G�UK�@CEZ�E@?B)�|�T�BJK�0��EG�B>�^?�?�K�BI�B�@TE�U

TE�TE�EHP�?EME0�>?E�HECZK��@BHK?D�G��@?ECEJ�TK�KME�E�E�)�qCI�B@?E�

�BVK@>B���NBE��CD�E�ME@PH��@?�K��E��JEHKCB�W?E��K�I�CIK?@I�@CEZ�

�UJ��ET�E@EJ)�R�HCI�J�EMBS�@E��KJK��US�>E�lCB>?E��Q�W?E�EVK�D

AECDk�I�T�EACKJ�)�[�@�JEJ�CB�HKCK�C^HB0��U@?PT�^LBK�E?�CBN�

���EH�0�I�CI^?@I�B@?B��UJB�T�KH@?��B?KCIJB����EH�\�[�@E@?EI�BB

CB�W?B�C HB���@T�E@?���B?D0�TK�KH�?D�HE@?BM�P?UK�BJB�@EMC�kK�

�BI\�[E?�V?E�@?��B?�W?P�JEHKCD�TEH�AECDkEK�@EJ�K�BK)

�YKTK�D�TK�K�HKJ�>��BZ�K��V�@?B�TB��JBHU)�p?E?�TEHSEH�B�EM�

H����GU��^?�TEHSEHEJ��@�BGP���K�S�)�]���K�?�>�SE�EkE�BG�K@?K�0

>�>�TEHSEH��@�K�SP���BG�)�]��KJ���TB@��E��@KME��K@>ECD>E�>�BM)�|E

G��TE@CKH�BK�.4�CK?�JU��@K�V�LK��BHBJ�T�BJK�U�W?EME�TEHSEH�)�uME

BHKI�?�>E���Q�>�ZHEK�EALK@?�E0�>�ZH�I�JK@?�E@?D0�?�>�BCB�B��VK0

G�?�E�P?��>E�lCB>?EJ)���G�V�@?P^���>�ZHE��JK@?�E@?B�JEZ�E�����

?B�T�KH@?��B?KCK����G�US�@?E�E��>E�lCB>?�)

=EG�ECD?K�T�B�K@?B�T�BJK�)�y��U�E@���XEKHB�K��US�s?�?�S0

���q�CD�KJ�{�T�HK0���]�KME�K)�FEMH��J�K�AUCE�T�BACBGB?KCD�E��E�

@KJD�CK?0�XE�K?@>B��XE^G�B�XEKHB�K��UK�s?�?U�TK�KZB��CB�@K�D�

KG�U��>E�lCB>?0�BG�K@?�U��>�>�>PAB�@>B����>K?�U��>�BGB@)�xPHPVB

J�CK�D>BJ��KAK�>EJ0�I�@CUk�C0�>�>�JEB��EHB?KCB0�B�?KCK�BHK�BK0�B

M�GK?U�Q��@K�?�K�HBCB�E�����MK�0�E�@E�K?@>BS�>EJJP�B@?�S)�������y

?�>��B���GP�B��K��@?�K?BC���ZBG�B��B�EH�EME�@E�K?@>EME�>EJJP�B@?�0

�E���MECE�K�B���@K�HNK�P�JK�I�VK?>E�@lE�JB�E��CB@D�BS�EA��GU)������

�?E0�W?E�AUCB��U\�R�I�HCI���@�AUC0����K��EK0��JK�B>��@>BJ�>�TB?��

CB@?EJ)�tU�ZBCB�����G�US�TECPk��BIS)�]A��G����M����JEKJ�TE�BJ��

�BB��K�T�EKNB�E��C@I����>EME�?E�BG�@E@KH�K��>EJ��?U0�W?E�AUC��K�

>?E0���SEHILB�@I�EVK�D�H�CK>E�E?�JK�I)

|E���.55-0�,---�B�,--.�MEH�S�JU��BHBJ0�V?E���kB����MB�B�JK@?�0

MHK�T�EB@SEHB?���@BCBK0���SEHI?@I��K���H�PMEJ�TECPk��BB)�OKEM���

lBVK@>B�W?E���@BCBK�@E�@KJ��IHEJ)�]�E���JEKJ��EH�EJ�ME�EHK0��

@E@KH�K��HECB�K0���@E@KH�K��HK�K��K�Q�E�E�ACBG>E�E?�HEJ�)����@K�W?E

T�EB@SEHB?�JKZHP�?KJB0�>?E����DkK�ZBC0�>�>�HEA�UK�@E@KHB)

Page 130: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

=EHSEH��@�BGP���K�S��T�KHTEC�M�K?�H�K��KLB)�[E�TK��US0�>�Z�

HU�����@�EKJ�JK@?K��K@K?�E?�K?@?�K��E@?D�G����V�CE�JB��EME�T�E�

NK@@�)���K@CB���VB��K?@I���AE?��TE�TE@?�EK�B^�JB��0�?E�HECZ���AU?D

�U@E>�I�@?KTK�D��E�CKVK��E@?B��@KME�EALK@?��)���W?B�TE�I?BI�E?�

�K?@?�K��E@?B�B�PV�@?BI�I�CI^?@I�V�@?D^�?KE�BB�TK�KJK�0�CKZ�LK�

��E@�E�K�TEHSEH���@�BGP���K�S�)�p?��?KE�BI�MC�@B?0�V?E��KCDGI�ZH�?D0

TE>��>?E��BAPHD�TEH�@?�?KAK�JB�����@K�KA�I�EJ�AC^HK)�|KEASEHBJE

�>C^VB?D@I���T�ENK@@�B��EGHK�@?�E��?D����T�EB@SEHILKK)��HKI�TEH�

SEH���@�BGP���K�S��G�>C^V�K?@I���?EJ0�V?EAU�T�EAB?D�@�BGP�TP?D����

�K�S)���K@CB�MC����I�?�PH�E@?D�TEHSEH���@�K�SP���BG�0�@��K�kB�U

TB��JBHU0�G�>C^V�K?@I���?EJ0�>�>�T�E?EC>�P?D�BHKB���BG0�?E�G�?�PH�

�K�BI�����BGkKJ�P�E��K�TB��JBHU�Q���T�E?�C>B���BB�BS����K�S)�[

TEH�EA�E@?B��H���?D@I��K�APHP)

Y�K?B��TEHSEH�I���GU��^�?�>����USEH�BG�@�KH�KME�P�E��I�)�p?E

�K�G��VB?0�V?E����EH��K�PV�@?�PK?���T�ENK@@K)�[EGJEZ�E0�?EV�KK�AP�

HK?���G��?D�KME��E?�@�KH�KME�P�E��I���K�S�B���BG�)�Y�>E��TEHSEH�ETB�

��K?@I�������CBG�H�PS�?BTE�)�=K��U��?BT�Q��K�?B>�CD�EK�E@JU@CK�

�BK0��K�?B>�CD�U�����CBG)���E�0���TK��P^�EVK�KHD0�@�IG���@��ET�E�

@EJ��>?E�)�]���K�@�IG���@��ET�E@EJ��V?E�)�[K�?B>�CD�U�����CBG�T�KH�

TEC�M�K?�@CKHP^LB���ET�E@��>?E���H���E��@B?P�NBB���@E@?EI�BB��@?P�

TB?D���@�IGD�@�C^HDJB��U@kKME����M��B���?E�ZK���KJI�TEHHK�ZB��?D

@�IGD�@�M�PTT�JB�C^HK�0���SEHILBS@I����BZ�BS�@CEIS�EALK@?��\�p?E?

�>?E��JEZK?�AU?D�V�@?�UJ�CBNEJ0�B�@?B?P?EJ�BCB�NKCE��@K?D^�B��

@?B?P?E�0�BCB�ZK�@ENB�CD�UJ�@CEKJ)

=EG�ECD?K�T�B�K@?B�T�BJK��BG�rBAK�BB)�Y�J�@PLK@?�PK?�|=]0

BG�K@?�EK�TEH���G���BKJ�R@@ENB�NBI����EH�EME�GH���EES���K�BI)�]��

G��BJ�K?@I��ET�E@�JB�GHE�E�DI0�>CB�B>0�B�?)�H)�{���K@>ECD>E�CK?�E�B

T�BEA�KCB�?�>BK�@�IGB0�V?E�B��E���KJI��E��U0�B�@K�V�@0���TE@CK�EK��

�EK���KJI0�E�B�@TE>E��E�JEMP?�TEG�E�B?D�JB�B@?�P�GH���EES���K�BI

��;�P?���B���G��VB?D��@?�KVP����.-�P?��)��S�>CB�B>B���@TECEZK�U�TE

�@K��@?���K)�R�TE@CK�EAKH��E�B�JEMP?���SEHB?D@I�MHK��BAPHD���>�PZ�

>�S0���BGP0�@�KHB�EAUV�US�C^HK�0���GAB��I��ET�E@�?���@lE�J�NBB

>E�lCB>?�)�p?��E�M��BG�NBI�EAC�H�K?��K�?B>�CD�UJB��EGJEZ�E@?I�

JB0�P��BS���C�ZK�U�@�IGB�B�@��K�S�JB0�B�@��BG�JB�H���EME�EALK@?��)

q�PME�����CBG0�H�PM�I�JEHKCD�Q�ME�BGE�?�CD��I)�]���TEH�BJ�K?

B�E���ET�E@)�[�>E�?K>@?K�>�ZHEME�>E�lCB>?��@PLK@?�P^?�CB�BB���G�

Page 131: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

HKC��JKZHP�>E�lCB>?P^LBJB�C HDJB)�p?E�Q�CB�BB�>E�lCB>?�0�CB�

�BB���G�U��)�FE�lBMP��NBI�W?BS�CB�B��JEZK?�AU?D�@�JE����G�E�)�[

AECDkB�@?�K�@CPV�K��?�>EK���GHKCK�BK��EG�B>�K?���@�IGB�@�T�EACK�

JE��BHK�?BV�E@?B)��P���CB@?U�*���V�LK��@KME�E?�E@I?�BS�>�CB�B�

IJ���GHKC��TE�W?�BVK@>EJP�T�BG��>P)�]H��>E�BS�T�B�EH��ME��GHE�@CEZ�

�KK0�VKJ�T�E@?E�W?�BV�E@?D)�Y�>EK���GHKCK�BK�JEZK?�AU?D�@�IG��E�@

IGU>EJ0��KCBMBK�0�W?�BV�E@?D^0�>PCD?P�E�0���?�>ZK�@�MKEM��lBVK@�

>BJ�TECEZK�BKJ)�|E��E��@KS�@CPV�IS�W?B���@SEZHK�BI�TE��ET�E@�J

BHK�?BV�E@?B�TE�EZH�^?���G�U�0���GHKCK�BK���P?�B�EALK@?��)�OE�

�BGE�?�CD�U���ET�E@�@?��B?@I�?�>BJ�EA��GEJ��>?E�BG�H���E��M�PT�

TU���@E@?EI�BB��@?PTB?D���>E�?�>?�@�T�KH@?��B?KCIJB�H�PME�0�>E�l�

CB>?P^LK��M�PTTU�B��K��P?D@I�EA��?�E0��K�TE?K�I��HE�K�BK�@�EK�

M�PTTU\

q����?K�T�B�KHKJ���MCIH�U��T�BJK�0�?)�>)�W?E�EVK�D���Z�E)�qE�

TP@?BJ0��E?�JE�����M)�OE�BGE�?�CD��I��EGJEZ�E@?D�EG��V�K?0�V?E�I

JEMP�TE>B�P?D�M�PTTP0�>�>E?E�E��T�B��HCKZP0�JEMP�TK�K�?B�?P��K�B�

HBJP^�VK�?P0�E�@PLK@?�E���BB�>E?E�E��G��^?��@K0�B��@?PTB?D���@�IGD

@�>E�>�K?�UJ�VKCE�K>EJ�BG�H�PME��M�PTTU0���G�?KJ��K��P?D@I�EA��?�

�E)�z�@@JE?�BJ0�>�>BK�GHK@D�?�PH�E@?B)�FEMH��I�TE>B�P�M�PTTP0�>�>E�

?E�E��T�B��HCKZP0�V?E�@>�ZP?�C^HB�G��JEK��@TB�E�\�X>�ZP?0�V?E�I�Q

T�KH�?KCD)�R�>EMH��I�TEHE�HP�>�T�E?B�ETECEZ�E��M�PTTK0�V?E�@>�ZP?

EAE�J�K���W?E��M�PTTK\�q�0�E�B�@>�ZP?��?U�kTBE�)�=�BSEHB?@I�JK�

?�?D@I�JKZHP��ECIJB�T�KH�?KCI�B�kTBE��)�p?E�H��CK�BK0�@�>E?E�UJ

�U0�I�P�K�K�0�G��>EJU)

F�B?K�BKJ�@E@?EI?KCD�E@?B�H���EME�TEHSEH��I�CIK?@I�KME�@TE�

@EA�E@?D�EAK@TKVB?D�T�E@?���@?�E�@�IGK�)���WllK>?B��E@?D�H���E�

ME�TEHSEH��EAK@TKVB��K?@I�PJK�BKJ�P@?����CB��?D�E?�EkK�BI�@�T�E�

?B�ETECEZ�E��M�PTTE�0�EH�E��KJK��E�@ES���II��G�BJEE?�EkK�BI

@E�@�EK��B@>E��E��M�PTTE�)�p?E�B�K@?D�ME�BGE�?�CD��I��EGJEZ�E@?D)

u@CB�I�T�E@?E�E@?��P@D���@�EK��M�PTTK0�?E�W?E�PZK��K�ME�BGE�?�CD��I

�EGJEZ�E@?D)�u@CB�I�T�B@EKHB�^@D�>�T�E?B�ETECEZ�E�� M�PTTK�B

AECDkK��B>EMH���K��K��P@D0�W?E�?EZK��K�ME�BGE�?�CD�U��TEHSEH)�R

K@CB�I��EEALK��U�HP�BG�HKC�0�?E�W?E���GU��K?@I�PZK�@E�@KJ�TE�H�PME�

JP�Q��E��I�W>E�EJBVK@>�I�ZBG�D)��������?�>0�ME�BGE�?�CD��I��EG�

JEZ�E@?D�T�KHTEC�M�K?�T�E@?���@?�E�HCI�TK�KH�BZK�BI�?PH��B�EA�

��?�E0�@�@ES���K�BKJ�@�IGK��@�EAKBJB�@?E�E��JB)

Page 132: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

=EHSEH��BG�@K�KHB�U�0���@@J�?�B��KJU����>�VK@?�K�@?��?KMBB0

@EVK?�K?��K�?B>�CD�U��B�ME�BGE�?�CD�U��TEHSEHU)�]AwKHB�II�W?B

H�����T���CK�BI0��KEASEHBJE����?B�C^HK�0�>E?E�UK�JEMP?�TEHHK��

ZB��?D�@�IGB�B�@��K�S�JB0�B�@��BG�JB0�B�TE�ME�BGE�?�CB�B��CBI?D��

W?BS�?�KS���T���CK�BIS)�YP?��@��G��B@B?�AECDkK�E?�@�IGK�0�VKJ�E?

lE�JPC�@EMC�kK�B�)�=EW?EJP��KEASEHBJE�T�BCEZB?D�P@BCBI�HCI

@EGH��BI�B�l��@?�P>?P�U0���G�B��?D�@TE@EA�E@?D�P@?����CB��?D���@�

kB�I^LBK@I�E?�EkK�BI)�p?E?�TEHSEH�TU?�K?@I��@K�@�IG�?D)�y���GU�

��^�W?E�T�P?B�E�)�XK�V�@�I�KK�ETBkP)�[U�>EMH���BAPHD���AC^H�CB0

>�>�T�P>�TCK?K?�@�E^�T�P?B�P\�p?E�EVK�D�B�?K�K@�U��T�ENK@@)�X���

V�C��T�P>�TCK?K?�HCB��UK��B?B0���@SEHILBK@I�TE�AECDkEJP���HBP@P0

G�?KJ�@EKHB�IK?�BS0�BHI�TE�>�PMP0�@�>�ZHUJ���GEJ��@K�ACBZK�>�NK�?�

�P)���EMH��T�P>B�T�E?IMB��^?�EH�P�AECDkP^��B?D0�G�?KJ��EG���L��

^?@I0�TCK?I�>E�E?>BK)�q���U��TEHSEH�TESEZ����BS�HKI?KCD�E@?D)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�>C^VK�UJ�JEJK�?EJ��@KME�T�ENK@@��I�CIK?@I��ET�

�E@�E�@?��?KMBVK@>EJ��>?E�)

n�JK�I�K@?D�H���EA��G�0�>E?E�UK�I�EAUV�E�B@TECDGP^�HCI�ETB@��

�BI�?EME0�@?��?KMBV�U��U���@�EKJ�TEHSEHK�BCB��K?0�B�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU

TEJEVD���J�@?�?D�AECKK�@?��?KMBV�UJB)�=EG�ECD?K���V�?D�@�EH�EME

T�KHTECEZK�BI0�E?�E@ILKME@I�>�?KE�BB�TK�KJK���EEALK0�B�>���kK�

M�PTTK���V�@?�E@?B)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E���k��M�PTT����SEHB?@I���@�KH�K�

V�@?B�TB��JBHU)�tEZ�E�T�E�K�B?D0�@EMC�@�U��U�BCB��K?)

�3�(��� �#���� � � 2�� ���)�#�#"� ����

�?�>0�K@CB�JU�BGEA��GBJ�RAS�GB^����BHK�TB��JBHU0�?E��U��@K

��SEHB?K@D�T�BACBGB?KCD�E�TE@K�KHB�K)�p?E�JEK�T�KHTECEZK�BK)�[

JEKJ�TE�BJ��BB���k��?KE�BI�TK�KJK��?�>E����C^HB0��E�CKVK��UK��

T�E@?���@?�E�@�IGK����@K�KHB�K�TB��JBHU0�TU?�^?@I�E>�GU��?D��CB�

I�BK�����K�S�BK�B��BZ�BK�@CEB�TB��JBHU0���?�>ZK�TE�ME�BGE�?�CB)

[ET�E@���?EJ0�T���BCD�P^�CB�@?��?KMB^��U��UA��CB)

F�>�B�pJG��0�I�BGPV�C�@ENBECEMB^)�z�AE?�I���H�HE>?E�@>E��HB@�

@K�?�NBK��TE�@ENBECEMBB0�I���@@J�?�B��C�TEHwKJ�@ENB�CD�EME�H�B�

ZK�BI���XEKHB�K��US�s?�?�S�B�KME���G�B?BK)�tU�B@@CKHE��CB�ZK��

@>EK�H�BZK�BK0�H�BZK�BK�G��E?JK�P�@JK�?�E��>�G�B0�@PHKA�UK��K�

lE�JU0�H�BZK�BK�t��?B���r^?K���FB�M��G��M��ZH��@>BK�T����)�qCI

EAwI@�K�BI�WllK>?B��E@?B�@ENB�CD�EME�H�BZK�BI�?KE�K?B>B�B@TECD�

GE��CB�TE�I?BK�>�B?BVK@>E��J�@@U)��HKI�G�>C^V�C�@D���@CKHP^LKJ�

Page 133: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

>EMH��HE@?�?EV�EK�>ECBVK@?�E�C^HK����H���EJ�EALK@?�K�@VB?�^?0�V?E

�KEASEHBJE�V?E�?E�BGJK�B?D0���@?PT�K?�JEJK�?0�>EMH���H�PM��KEZB�

H���E�T�EB@SEHB?�@H�BM)�]@�E��E��PTE��HKC�K?@I�����E@?�VB@C��KHB�

�EJUkCK��B>E�)�|KEASEHBJE�JEABCBGE��?D�>�>�JEZ�E�AECKK�kB�E�

>BK�@CEB���@KCK�BI)�|�T�BJK�0����Kk@>E��zK@TPACB>K��E���KJI�x���

S�?�E���K�EC^NBB���� PCBN�S�TEI�BCE@D� HE@?�?EV�EK� >ECBVK@?�E

C^HK�0�>E?E�UK�JEMCB�V?E�?E�BGJK�B?D)

p?��?KE�BI��UGU��C��TK@@BJBGJ0�?�>�>�>���B@?E�BB�XEKHB�K��

�US�s?�?E��G���@K�,4-�CK?����HK?@I0����K��EK0��@KME�E>ECE�TI?B�?��

>BS�JEJK�?E�)�[�AECDkB�@?�K�@B?P�NB�0�@�>E?E�UJB�J�K�HE�KCE@D

��AE?�?D�8��XEJ�CB0���XK�K��E����C��HBB0�rBAK�BB0�|B>���MP�:0�JU

B�ACBG>E��K�T�BACBZ�CB@D�>�>�B?BVK@>E��J�@@K)�[�AECDkB�@?�K�ZK�

@?E>BS�>E�lCB>?E��C^HB0�G��BJ��kBK@I�JB�E@?�EB?KCD@?�EJ0���SE�

HBCB@D�TEH�EM�EJ�UJ�H��CK�BKJ�B�AUCB��KJ�EMEVB@CK��U)

�?�>0�I�BGJK�BC�?KE�B^�B��B@P�E>)�y��KkBC0�V?E�JEI���AE?��Q�W?E0

��E@�E��EJ0���AE?��@��>�B?BVK@>BJB�H�EZZ�JB��8��������#���:)�=E�I�

?K��EA��G\�FEMH���U�TKVK?K�SCKA0�>�>BK�>EJTE�K�?U���J��KEASEHBJU\

tP>�0��EH�0�@ECD0��KJ�EME�@�S���0���?�>ZK�LKTE?>��H�EZZK�)�q�EZ�

Z�J��KEASEHBJU�H�K��KLB��?KTCE�B��C�M�)�X�@PSBJB�B�SECEH�UJB�H�EZ�

Z�JB��BVKME��K�TECPVB?@I)���?K�K@�E0�V?E�BG��@KS�>EJTE�K�?E��?ECD�

>E�W?��LKTE?>��@TE@EA���H�?D��E@?��@KJP�E@?�CD�EJP)

=K�KSEHI�>�@ENB�CD�EJP�>E�?K>@?P0�TEHPJ�KJ0�>?E�T�B���CBVBB

�@KS�>EJTE�K�?E�0��C�MB�B�?KTC��@JEZK?�H�?D��E@?��@KJP�E@?�CD�E�

JP\�zE@?�B��CBI�BK��K�BGJK�B?D�VB@CK��E@?D^)�[�>E�lCB>?�US�@B�

?P�NBIS��E@?�B��CBI�BK�BGJK�I^?@I�>�VK@?�EJ�@EA����US��JK@?K

C^HK��B�?KJ0�VKJ�E�B�G��BJ�^?@I�B�>EME�T�B�CK>�^?)�X?��?KMBV�E@?D

G�>C^V�K?@I���?EJ0�V?E�BS��CBI�BK���J�EME�AECDkK0�VKJ�BS�VB@CK��

�E@?D)�|E���HE�EVK�D�?L�?KCD�E�T�EHPJ�?D0�>�>�B�>EME��U�@EAB��K?K0

>�>��U�TEHHK�ZB��K?K�?KTCE�B��C�MP0�TE?EJP�V?E�E?�W?EME�G��B@B?���G�

�B?BK)�y�JEMP�@EA��?D��JK@?K�kK@?K�US��EHB?KCK��?�>@B�B��K�HE�

AB?D@I��CBI�BI������0�K@CB�W?B�kK@?K�E��K�E>�ZP?@I�T�KH@?��B?K�

CIJB�kK@?B���G�US�@EEALK@?��B�K@CB�>�ZHU��BG��BS��K�I�CIK?@I

CBHK�EJ���@�EKJ�@EEALK@?�K)�q�PMBJB�@CE��JB0��U���@@J�?�B��K?K

>E�lCB>?�@�@ENBECEMBVK@>E��?EV>B�G�K�BI)

FE��?E�EJP��B@P�>P�T�BC�M�K?@I�B@?E�BI)�FEMH��I�ZBC���vK�?��CD�

�E��RJK�B>K0���|B>���MP�0�P���@�AUC��J�kB��0����>E?E�P^��K��@KMH�

Page 134: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

JEZ�E�AUCE�TECEZB?D@I)�]H���BG�?�PH�E@?K���EK��EME���KJK�B�G��

>C^V�C�@D���?EJ0�V?E�V�@?E��K�AUCE�AK�GB���HCI�G�T���>B)���EMH��JU

�UKGZ�CB0���HKI@D0�V?E�AK�GB���S��?B?�B����EA��?�U��TP?D�B�JEZ�E

APHK?�G�T���B?D@I�HCI�@CKHP^LK��TEKGH>B)�|K���G�AK�GB��P�JK�I�G��

>��VB��C@I��EVD^)�y�G�@?�K��C����HE�EMK�@�G�MCESkK��J�kB�E�0�EZB�

H�I0�V?E�>?E��BAPHD�TEI�B?@I�B�TEJEZK?)�[�?�>E��@B?P�NBB�EAUV�E

��HKKkD@I0�V?E�>?E��BAPHD�E@?��E�B?@I0�B�W?E�APHK?�SE�EkB��VKCE�K>)

R��E?�T�BJK��KLK�@�?KS���KJK�0�>EMH��I�BGPV�C�lBGBVK@>EK�HK��

@?�BK�@BlE��)�F�>���AE?�K?�@BlE�\�F?E��BAPHD�BG���@�TECDGE��C@I

@BlE�EJ\�������X��V�C��I�SEVP�ETB@�?D�lBGBVK@>EK�HK�@?�BK�@B�

lE��0���G�?KJ�@ENB�CD�EK�T�BJK�K�BK�BHKB�@BlE��)�|KEASEHBJE�TK�

�K>�V�?D�ZBH>E@?D�BG�EH�EME�@E@PH����H�PME�0��E�P���@��K?���@E@�0��K?

B�WCK>?�BVK@?��)�[U�AK�K?K�kC��M0�EHB��>E�KN��@?��CIK?K���@E@PH�@

ZBH>E@?D^0���@�H�PMBJ�>E�NEJ�V?E�HKC�K?K\))�q�0�CPVkK�TB?D�E??PH�

�B�E0�VKJ�AK�GB�)

�?�>0�TEG�ECD?K�EAwI@�B?D�lBGBVK@>EK�HK�@?�BK�@BlE��)�FEMH�

���EH�EJ�>E�NK��EG�B>�K?�H��CK�BK0�?E����H�PMEJ�>E�NK�EA��GPK?@I

��>PPJ0�>E?E�U��BJKK?�@�E�@?�E��?IMB��?D�ZBH>E@?D)�y�SEVP�EAwI@�

�B?D�W?E�TEH�EA�E0�V?EAU��U�TE�ICB��B@P�E>�B���AE?P�@BlE��)��?E�

AU�T�KEHECK?D�@BCP�?IZK@?B0�ZBH>E@?D���HE�TEH@E@�?D)�]���HECZ��

TEH�I?D@I�HE�ET�KHKCK��EME�P�E��I���TK�K>E��@BCK�?IZK@?B)�{�?KJ

E���@?K>�K?���BG0��U?IMB��I�G��@EAE��E@?��kP^@I�ZBH>E@?D)�Y�>0���

T�BJK�K�@BlE����BH�E0�V?E��K?��KEASEHBJE@?B�TK�KZB��?D�G��TK�K�

JKLK�BK�E@?�CD�E��V�@?B�ZBH>E@?B)�[@K0�E�VKJ��U�HECZ�U�TEAK@TE�

>EB?D@I�Q�W?E�>�>0�T�KEHECK��@BCP�?IZK@?B0�TEH@E@�?D�TK��P^�TE��

NB^�ZBH>E@?B�HE���B�U@kKME�P�E��I0�E?>PH��G�?KJ�W?��TE�NBI�P�CK�

VK?�G��@EAE��E@?�CD�P^�ZBH>E@?D)

XENB�CD�U���ET�E@�@E@?EB?���@CKHP^LKJ)�XJEZKJ�CB�JU�@E�

A��?D�C HK�0�>E?E�UK�@JEMP?�T�EH�BM�?D@I��TK�KH��ET�K>B�@BCK�?I�

ZK@?B�B�P�CKVD�G��@EAE��J�EMEVB@CK��P^�J�@@P0���J�EME�T�K�Uk��

^LP^�VB@CE�TK��ET�ESEHNK�\�[ET�E@�TE�I?K�\�[EG���L�I@D�>�HB�

�M��JJK0�JU��BHBJ0�V?E�V�@?D�W?E��@?��?KMBB���?EV�E@?B�E?��Z�K?

BHK^�>�B?BVK@>BS�H�EZZK��BCB�@BlE��)

tE��@CKHP^LB���ET�E@�>���J�?�>E�)�]AC�H�K?�CB���k��M�PTT�

�K�?B>�CD�E��B�ME�BGE�?�CD�E���EGJEZ�E@?IJB\�tEZK?K�CB��U�E>��

GU��?D��CBI�BK�>�>�����U@kKJ0�?�>�B�����BGkKJ�P�E��K�?�>BJ�EA���

Page 135: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

GEJ0�V?EAU���kB�BHKB�TE?I�PCB�G��@EAE��J�EMBS\��CB���J��KHE@?�K?

C^HK�0�>E?E�UK�JEMCB�AU�@?�?D�V�@?D^�W?EME�T�ENK@@�\�Y�>BJ�EA���

GEJ0�W?E��ET�E@U��E>�PM�@?��?KMBVK@>EME��>?E�)�u@CB�I�T���BCD�E

TE�IC��K>E?E�UK�BG���kBS�?KE�B��TK�KJK�0���kK�T�E@?���@?�E0���k�

HB�CEM�M�PTT��BJKC���EGJEZ�E@?D�E>�G�?D��EGHK�@?�BK����@B?P�NB^)

X?��?KMBVK@>EK��>?E��T�KHTEC�M�K?�T�E@?E���ET�E@��>�>�H�CK>E�JU

T�EH�B�PCB@D���@�EK���EGJEZ�E@?B��EGHK�@?�BI\��?�>0���AC^HK�BK

�EJK��EHB��Q�W?E�@?��?KMBVK@>EK��>?E�)

[?E�EK���AC^HK�BK�ME��GHE�>E�EVK�Q�W?E�@?��?KMBVK@>EK��V?E�)

X?��?KMBVK@>EK��V?E��@?��B?�@CKHP^LB���ET�E@��>�>E���ET�E@�BCB

>�>�I�?KJ��TE>�ZK?@I�H�PMBJ�@?ECD�G��VB?KCD�E�0�@JEZK?�@?�?D�?KJ

J�M�B?EJ0�>E?E�U��T�B�CKVK?�>���J�AECDkEK�VB@CE�PV�@?�B>E�\

[E?�>E�>�K?�U��T�BJK��BG��G�BJEE?�EkK�B���K@>ECD>BS��E@�

?EV�E�l�B>��@>BS�ME@PH��@?��Q�XEJ�CB0�plBETBB0�XPH���0�FK�BB�B

H�)�[�W?BS�@?����S�@PLK@?�P^?�>E�lCB>?U�@PMPAE��KMBE��CD�EME�S��

��>?K��)�|�BAECKK�G��VB?KCD�UK�Q���XPH��K)�]@?�CD�UK�@E@KHB�TE

�KMBE�P0�?�>ZK�>�>�B�JKZHP���EH�UK�@BCU�H��CK�BI0���@@J�?�B��^?

XPH���>�>���NB^�B@C�J@>BS�lP�H�JK�?�CB@?E�)�]VK�D� @K�DKG�UK

>E�lCB>?U�JKZHP�W?BJB�@?����JB�T�B�KCB�>���G�U�P�E?�EkK�B�

TEV?B��E��@KS�@lK��S)�=K�KH��BJB�@?EIC��EH���T�EACKJ�0�>E?E��I

EAC�H�C���@KJB�>�VK@?��JB�@?��?KMBVK@>EME��V?E��Q���@?PTCK�BK�TP�

@?U�B)�=P@?U�I�X�S������@?PT�K?���� >�ZHEK�BG���G����US� ME@P�

H��@?�)��?EAU�T�E?B�E@?EI?D�W?EJP���@?PTCK�B^0�E�B�@EGH�CB��KMB�

E��CD�U��@E�K?0�BG�K@?�U��TEH���G���BKJ�u]R[)�]�0���E@�E��EJ0

@TKNB�CBGB�E��C@I����>EETK��NBB�HK�@?�B��TE��ET�E@�J���@?PTCK�

�BI�TP@?U�B0�?�>�>�>�@?��H�CB�E?�W?EME��@K)���>EMH��E�B��@?�KV�CB@D

�JK@?K�>�>�ME@PH��@?����XEJ�CB0�plBETBI0�XPH��0�nM��H�0�FK�BI�B

H�)0�KHB�@?�K��U���ET�E@0�>E?E�U��JEM�BS�EAwKHB�B?D0�AUC��ET�E@

TP@?U�B)�|E�EH��ZHU0��@?�K?B�kB@D�HCI�EA@PZHK�BI��ET�E@��E����

@?PTCK�BB�TP@?U�B0�E�B�EAME�E�BCB�B�@�EB�>E�lCB>?U)�Y�>BJ�EA���

GEJ0��ET�E@�TP@?U�B�@?�C� ?KJ�@�JUJ�@?��?KMBVK@>BJ��V?E�)�p?E?

�ET�E@�AUC���@?ECD>E�G��VBJUJ0�V?E�G�@?��BC��@^�M�PTTP�@EA��?D�

@I0���?�>ZK�@EGH�C�T�E@?���@?�E0���>E?E�EJ�E�B�PZK����@CKHP^LKJ

W?�TK�JEMCB�EA@PZH�?D�B�H�PMBK�T�EACKJU)

R�?KTK�D�JEK��BHK�BK� M�PTT0� TEHEA�US���kK��� �U�T�B�K@K?K

��BAECDkP^�TECDGP0�>EMH��@�IZK?K�@?��?KMBVK@>EK��>?E��@E�@?��?K�

Page 136: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

MBVK@>BJ��V?E�)�[U���SEHB?K@D���T�ENK@@K�E@JU@CK�BI��ET�E@���>?E

�U�B�>�>BJ�EA��GEJ�E>�GU��K?K��EGHK�@?�BK\�F�>�@?��?KMBVK@>B�TE�

HE�?B�>��UAE�P�?KJ0�B�>�>BK�BJK��E�?KJU0�@EHK�Z�LBK���BAECDkB�

TE?K�NB�C0��U�HECZ�U�TEH�BJ�?D0�V?EAU�T�EH�BM�?D�T�ENK@@\�[�>��

>BS��ET�E@�S�G�CEZK����BAECDkB��TE?K�NB�C0�@TE@EA�U��EAwKHB�

�B?D�C^HK�\�{HK@D�I�SE?KC�AU�E@?��E�B?D@I)�[>��?NK0�JEB���AC^HK�

�BI�?�>E�U��M�PTTK0�TEHEA�E����kK�0�TECKG�E�MCPAZK�B@@CKHE��?D�@�EK

TE�BJ��BK�@EA@?�K��E��?KE�BB�TK�KJK�)�F�>BJ�EA��GEJ�?E0�V?E�T�E�

B@SEHB?�GHK@D0��EGHK�@?�PK?����M�PGB�E��AS�G@>B��>E�lCB>?\�F�>E��

��k��?KE�BI�TK�KJK�\�y�EA���PZBC0�V?E�W?B�H����ET�E@��V�@?E�H�^?

?ECVE>�H�PMBJ�@TE@EA�J�JU@CB?D�AECKK�@?��?KMBVK@>B)�{HK@D�I�E@?��

�E�C^@D0�B�JEZ�E�APHK?���V�?D�HB@>P@@B^)

�4� ���� #�

MU! ��!����R���#8�FEMH��I���@���@@T��kB��C�E���kK��?KE�BB�TK�K�

JK�0�J�K�AUCE�B�?K�K@�E�TEG��>EJB?D@I�@���kBJB���AC^HK�BIJB

E?�E@B?KCD�E�?EME0�>�>�T�EB@SEHB?��EGHK�@?�BK)�y�TE�IC0�V?E��U�E>��

GU��K?K��CBI�BK����EALK@?�E�H�ZK�G��T�KHKC�JB�T�E@?���@?�����kK�

ME�HB�CEM�)�t�K�TE>�G�CE@D0�V?E�W?E��EGHK�@?�BK�AECKK�WllK>?B��E

���ME�BGE�?�CD�EJ�P�E��K0��KZKCB�����K�?B>�CD�EJ)�p?E�ME�E�B?�E

@PLK@?�E���BB��K�?B>�CD�EME�T�EAKC�)��?�>0�EH�E��BG�@?��?E�US�?KJ

JEZK?�@?�?D�HB@>P@@BI�E�?EJ0���>�>E��@lK�K�P���@�T�EAKCU)�q�PM�I

�EGJEZ�E@?D�Q�@��GP�T�B@?PTB?D�>�EA@PZHK�B^��V?E��B��>?E�0�TE?E�

JP�V?E�W?E�ETI?D��K��K?���@�>���kK��?KE�BB�TK�KJK�)

��������%�"�8�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�JU�G��B@CB�MHK�?E�TE@K�KHB�K�B��

E@�E��EJ�?�J�B���SEHBJ@I0�TU?�I@D�TE�E��>�>�?E�TEH�I?D@I����K�S0

B�W?E�B�EMH��TECPV�K?@I0�TE�>����K��JK�K0���RAS�GBB)�tEZK?�AU?D0��

O�PGBB�W?E�@CEZ�KK)�|E�P���@�@E�K�kK��E��K?��B>�>E��@?��?KMBB��

E?�EkK�BB��BGkKME�P�E��I0�B�JU�TE>��H�ZK��K�TU?�CB@D�KK��U��AE�

?�?D)�[�E@�E��EJ0�W?E�@�IG��E�@�?KJ0�V?E�JU�@�JB�TE>��KLK��K���kCB

W?EME��V?E�)�tU�@�JB��K�G��KJ0�V?E�JEZK?���@�EAwKHB�B?D0�B�V?E�JU

HECZ�U��K@?B�?PH��Q���BG�B����K�S)

T.����MU���� �-8�=EH��>?E��TEH��GPJK��K?@I�NKCK��I�M�PTT�\

Page 137: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�!������"8�qZE��=EC�BJKC����BHP�PV�@?�B>E��T�EK>?�0�?E�K@?D�?KS0>?E�HECZK��HK�@?�E��?D0�>?E�HECZK����V�?D�JB�E?�E�VK@>B��T�ENK@@)

!R������RU,���R��8�]�VKJ�JU�@K�V�@�ME�E�BJ�Q�E�?EJ0�MHK�JU����SEHBJ@I�����kKJ�T�EK>?K\

�!������"8�YKJ��E?>�U?�)�X��V�C����HE�G�H���?D��ET�E@U0�TEHU?E�ZB?D�@>�G���EK)

��,� ��.�S,���8�|��K��EK0�JEZ�E�BJK?D��K@>ECD>E�@?��?KMBVK@�>BS��V?E��B�@?��?KMBVK@>BS��>?E��B�TK�KTCK@?B��K@>ECD>E�T�P?B�)

|�T�BJK�0����T���B?KCD@?�K��EJ�P�E��K�K@?D�@E?�PH�BVK@?�E���EA�

C�@?B� W�K�MK?B>B)�|�� M��ZH��@>EJ�P�E��K�JEZ�E�@E?�PH�BV�?D� �

EAC�@?B�T����VKCE�K>�0�W>ECEMBB�B�?)H)����@K�W?B�T�P?B�>B�TE?EJ�>�>

AU�TK�KTCK?P?@I0�@CEZ�?@I)�|��K��EK0�?�>�CPVkK0�VKJ�B@>�?D�>�>EK�

?E�@?��?KMBVK@>EK��V?E��BCB�EH�EME�B@?B��EME�@?��?KMBVK@>EME��>?E�)

��R��� ����0�8�qZE��=EC��B>EME��K�EM���BVB��K?0�E��ME�E�B?�E?EJ0�V?E�W?E?��UAE���PZ�E�T�EBG�EHB?D�E@EG����E)

�� �%!���R�S���8�q�0�>E�KV�E)

!R������RU,���R��8�n�JK�I��ET�E@)�qETP@?BJ0�W?��T�P?B���@PLK�

@?�PK?)�F?E�HECZK��ENK�B?D�WllK>?B��E@?D�B�NK��E@?D�W?E����AE?U0

>?E�?E�BG��K�BCB�BG�P?�B\���>�>�I�HECZ���AU?D�EA��?��I�@�IGD\

MU! ��!����R���#8�[U�SE?B?K�P@CUk�?D�JEK�J�K�BK\�]�E�P�JK�I

��HB>�CD�EK)���E?�E@B?KCD�E�ENK�>B0�B�E?�E@B?KCD�E�T�ENK@@�� �

NKCEJ)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�B�?E0�B�H�PMEK�HECZ�E�T�EB@SEHB?D���P?�B�>E��

?K>@?�)��?E�>�@�K?@I�ENK�>B0�I�HPJ�^0�V?E��U�CPVkK�TE�BJ�K?K�>PCD�

?P��U��>E�?K>@?��G�BJEE?�EkK�B�0�>�>BK�@�IGB�BCB�@B@?KJU�@�IGK�

@PLK@?�P^?�BCB�JEMCB�AU�@PLK@?�E��?D)�qCI�VKCE�K>��@E�@?E�E�U

EVK�D�?�PH�E�TEC�E@?D^�TE@?BVD�@B?P�NB^0�TE@>ECD>P�E���Q�V�@?D

>PCD?P��EME�>E�?K>@?�)��G��K�JEZ�E�TEJEVD�?ECD>E����ECB�>�?�CBG��

?E��)�OCPAE>E�TE�I?D��K�BHBJP^�@K?D�E?�EkK�B��JEZ�E�?ECD>E�BG�

�P?�B)�=EW?EJP�SE?KCE@D�AU�E@EAK��E��>NK�?B�E��?D���BJ��BK���

Page 138: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

?EJ0�>�>��� BGPV�K?K T�ENK@@0��������-�ENK�>K�?EME0�MHK���k��@BC�0��

MHK�T�EAKCU)

T.����MU���� �-8�tU�HECZ�U�@EGH���?D�W?P�>�B?BVK@>P^�J�@@P�BCB

��E@B?D�H�EZZB���W?P�>�B?BVK@>BK�J�@@P\��?E�HKC�?D0�K@CB��K?�>�B�

?BVK@>E��J�@@U\�|�kK�EALK@?�E�@BCD�E�E?CBV�K?@I�E?���kKME��JK�

�B>��@>EME�EALK@?��)�Y�J�AECDk�I�M��ZH��@>�I��>?B��E@?D0���JU��K

BJKKJ�ETU?��?�>E���>?B��E@?B0�JU�?ECD>E���VB��KJ)�F�>E�����k�

G�H�V��Q�@EGH���?D�>�B?BVK@>P^�J�@@P0���TE?EJ�HEA��CI?D�?PH��H�EZ�

ZB0�BCB���EAE�E?\

MU! ��!����R���#8�y0�>�>�VKCE�K>�@E�@?E�E�U0�JEMP�?ECD>E�T�KHTE�C�M�?D)�n���@�PZK�@CEZBC@I�ET�KHKCK��U��>�PM�C^HK�0�@CEZBCB@D

ET�KHKCK��UK��G�BJEE?�EkK�BI0��E�@K�V�@��U�TU?�K?K@D���V�?D�T�E�

NK@@�BGJK�K�B�0�E�BK�?B�E����U�����>E�@?�P>?B��UK��G�BJE@�IGB0

B�@TE@EA@?�E��?D�E@EG���B^�T�ENK@@E��JB�E@?�EB?KCD@?��)�u@CB��U

G��?�>BK�TK�KJK�U0�?E��U�B�I�CIK?K@D�BJK��E�?KJB�C^HDJB0�>?E���E�

@B?�H�EZZB)�[@?�K?��ET�E@���>?E��B��V?E���KEASEHBJE�HCI�?EME0�V?E�

AU��EGHK�@?�BK����@PLK@?�P^LP^�EA@?��E�>P���G�B��CE�>�B?BVK�

@>P^�J�@@P\

�����M�.� ��8�qETP@?BJ0�V?E�@�KHB�?KS0�>?E�GHK@D�@EA��C@I0�K@?D@?��?KMBVK@>BK��>?E�0���@?��?KMBVK@>BK��V?E��JU�G��KJ��KTCESE)�F��

>E�U0�TE���kKJP�J�K�B^0���BAECKK�WllK>?B��UK�JKS��BGJU�HK��

@?�BI�W?BS��>?E�0�V?EAU�HE�K@?B�W?B�>�B?BVK@>BK�J�@@U�HE�>�B?B�

VK@>EME�@E@?EI�BI0�HE�>BTK�BI\�F�>�W?E�@HKC�?D\

�������!"�#�-8�Y�>�W?E�E��P���@�SEVK?�PG��?D0����U�KME�@T��kB��K?K�

�����

MU! ��!����R���#8�=�KHTECEZBJ0��U�G��K?K�@?��?KMBVK@>EK��>?E�B�@?��?KMBVK@>EK��V?E�)�y���@�P�K�I^0�V?E�HE@?BVD�W?EME�G���BI�@CEZ�

�KK0�VKJ��U�T�KHTEC�M�K?K)�R�>EMH��W?E�PZK�HE@?BM�P?E0��EG�B>�^?

�E�UK�T�EACKJU)�y�T�B�KHP�?�B�T�BJK��)�]�B��A@EC^?�E���G�UK�B

�K�JEMP?�AU?D�T�IJE�T�BJK�BJU�����kBS�P@CE�BIS0�TE@>ECD>P�@?���

?KMBVK@>EK��>?E��B�@?��?KMBVK@>EK��V?E������G�US�>E�?K>@?�S���G�

Page 139: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�UK)�[�|B>���MP�0��E���KJI��E��U�JKZHP�B�HK�N�JB�JK@>B?E�B�@���

HB�B@?@>BJ�T���B?KCD@?�EJ0���>�VK@?�K�@?��?KMBVK@>EME��>?E���U@�

?PT�CB��KCBMBEG�UK�CBHK�U�@�KH�KME�P�E��I0��E�TEGBNBB��KCBMBEG�

�EME��P>E�EH@?�������E@?EV�EJ�TEAK�KZDK�B���t���MP��AUCB���G�U�

JB)�xUC��@lE�JB�E�����>EJ��H��BG�T�KH@?��B?KCK��EAKBS�@?E�E�)�[

>�VK@?�K�@?��?KMBVK@>EME��V?E���U@?PT�CE�?�KAE���BK���G��AE?�?D

T�KHCEZK�BI�E�?EJ0�>�>���V�?D�TK�KME�E��U��T�ENK@@�JKZHP�T���B�

?KCD@?�EJ�B����EHEJ)�y�JEM�AU�J�EMEK���@@>�G�?D�EA�W?EJ0�TE?EJP

V?E���H���EJ�@CPV�K�JEHKCD�TE@�KH�BVK@?���AUC��EVK�D�C^AETU?�

�E�)

[?E�E��T�BJK��BG�plBETBB)�[�?KVK�BK�TE@CKH�BS�9�S�CK?��KZB�

J��tK�MB@?P��EG�B>CE�E>ECE�.4�E�M��BGE����US�TE�@?��VK@>BS�M�PTT

Q�?�B�VK?U�K�AECDkBK�B�J�EZK@?�E�J�CK�D>BS0�@E@?EI�kBS�BG�T�KH�

@?��B?KCK�� ��GCBV�US� W?�BVK@>BS�JK�DkB�@?�)�X?��?KMBVK@>EK

�>?E�0�TE�@PLK@?�P0��EG�B>CE��E>�PM�?��HBNBE��EME�TE�I?BI��k�J��

M�CB�0�V?E�EG��V�K?��@?��K�kB���)�t�CK�D>�I�M�PTT�0�TK��E��V�CD�

�E�@E@?EI�k�I��@KME�BG�VK?U�KS�VKCE�K>0�B@@CKHE��C��@E@?����@KS

�E^^LBS�M�PTT)��G�>�ZHE��M�PTTU�E�B��UA��CB�EH�EME�H�PS�VKCE�

�K>0�TECDGP^LBS@I�P��ZK�BKJ�Q�@�JUS�JPH�US�@?��K�kB�0�B�EAwK�

HB�BCB�BS���EH�P�M�PTTP0���@VB?U���kP^�.,�.4�VKCE�K>)�]>ECE�6�?B

JK@INK��E�B��@?�KV�CB@D�B�EA@PZH�CB��BHK�BK�>E�lCB>?��>�ZHE�

M�PTTE�)�{�?KJ�E�B�TEHME?E�BCB�TC�?lE�JP�HCI�HB@>P@@B��@�>�ZHE�

M�PTTE�0�B@TECDGPI��UA����US�BJB�@?��K�kB��HCI�>E�?�>?E��@�M�PT�

T�JB�BCB�ZK���>�VK@?�K�HE�K�K��US�CBN0�BJK�kBS�T���E�MECE@��E?

M�PTTU)

R��E?�@E�K�kK��E�H�PME��T�BJK��BG�XK�K��E����C��HBB)�F�>

�U�G��K?K0���XK�K��E����C��HBB���@BCBK�JKZHP�>�?ECB>�JB�B�T�E�

?K@?��?�JB�BJKK?�HECMP^�B@?E�B^)�[�>�ZHEJ�EALK@?�K�Q�>�>�P�>�?E�

CB>E�0�?�>�B�P�T�E?K@?��?E��Q�AUCB�M�PTTU�C^HK�0�T�BAKM��kBS�>

��@BCB^)�p?E�AUCB��EK�BGB�E����UK�M�PTTB�E�>B0�B�J�EMBS�BS�VCK�

�E��T�B�CK>�CB�>�PMECE��E��E?�K?@?�K��E@?B)�R���EALK@?�K�W?B�C^HB

�E@T�B�BJ�CB@D�>�>�MK�EB0�HK�@?�P^LBK�E?�BJK�B�@�EK��V�@?B�EA�

LK@?��)�|E0�TET�H�I���?^�DJP�8��J�EMBK�BG��BS�AUCB�T�BME�E�K�U�>

.60�.;�BCB�,-�MEH�J�G�>C^VK�BI:0�E�B���VB��CB�G�HPJU��?D@I����AUCE

CB���@BCBK���BCPVkBJ�@TE@EAEJ��K�MB�E���BI\�F�>���?^�DJK0�?�>�B

���@�EAEHK���V�CB�lE�JB�E��?D@I�M�PTTU�AU�kBS�AEK�B>E�)

Page 140: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

xU�kBK�AEK�B>B�EAUV�E��K���@@J�?�B��^?@I���>�VK@?�K�JB�E?�

�E�NK�0��E�B�?K�K@�E0�V?E�BJK��E�P��BS�K@?D�B�@�IGB0�B�AECDkE�����

?E�B?K?���@�EBS�@EEALK@?��S)�tU�@?�CB�P@?��B��?D��@?�KVB�AU�kBS

PV�@?�B>E���EK�BGB�E����US�M�PTTB�E�E>�BG�VB@C��T�E?K@?��?E��B

>�?ECB>E�)�|�V�CB�@�?^�KJ)��G�W?BS�C^HK��lE�JB�E��CB@D�>EJ��HU0

>E?E�UK�JEMCB�TE@KL�?D�?K�@EEALK@?��0�>E?E�UK�@VB?�CB@D�ET�@�U�

JB)�XK�V�@�J�EMBK�BG�W?BS�C HK�0�EAwKHB�K��UK���>EJ��HU0�@E@?���

CI^?�HEME�E�U�E�T�K>��LK�BB�EM�I�JKZHP��EK�BGB�E����UJB�E�M��

�BG�NBIJB)�Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�@?��?KMBVK@>BJ��>?E����W?EJ�@CPV�K�I��

CI^?@I�AU�kBK�VCK�U��EK�BGB�E����US�M�PTTB�E�E>)�R�@?��?KMB�

VK@>BJ��V?E��AUC��ET�E@��>�>�@lE�JB�E��?D�T�E@?���@?�E�HCI�T�K�

>��LK�BI�EM�I\�F�>��BHB?K0��B�EHB��>E�?K>@?��K�TESEZ����H�PME�)

Page 141: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

M�,�R����R�� �S,���

��������k�����)M��������������N��W ��������M�

qPJ�^0�HE>C�H�RAK@�CEJ��APHK?��>�HKJBV�UJ0�TEW?EJP�I�APHP

ME�E�B?D�>�>�TECB?B>0�>E?E�U��H���E�B�?K�K@PK?@I�M�PGB�E��AS�G�

@>BJB�T�EACKJ�JB0�T�EACKJ�JB��G�BJEE?�EkK�B�)�t�K�V�@?E�T�B�

SEHBCE@D����L�?D@I��ACBGB�?KS�>�PME�0�>E?E�UK�T�B�BJ�CB��KkK�

�BI0��E0�>�JEKJP�@EZ�CK�B^0�?K��KkK�BI�EVK�D�E?CBV�CB@D�E?���kBS

TEHSEHE��Q�B�?EMH�0�>EMH��JU�EkBA�CB@D0�B�?EMH�0�>EMH���K�?�>�PZ

EkBA�CB@D)�R�E�B��B>EMH���K�EkBA�^?@I0�TE?EJP�V?E�C HIJ0�T�B�B�

J�^LBJ��KkK�BI0�>E?E�UK�?�PH�E�S���>?K�BGE��?D�>�>�TCEH�>�>BS�

?E���@@PZHK�B�0�EkBA>B��K�@�E�@?�K��U)

[�>E�NK�;-�S�Q���V�CK�5-�S�MEHE�0��E���KJK���TK�KJK�0��AS�GU�B

M�PGB�U0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0��UA��CB���G�UK0��CD?K���?B��UK�@TE@EAU

@ES���K�BI�B�P@BCK�BI�@�EK����NBE��CD�E��BHK�?BV�E@?B)�[�RA�

S�GBB0���@>ECD>E�I�TE�BJ�^0�AUCB�E�BK�?B�E���U����PJK�DkK�BK

�ECB�@�KH�KME�G�K�����BK���SBVK@>E��?�B�HK�tE@>���Q�YABCB@B�Q

XPSPJB0����TK�K��@T�KHKCK�BK�lP�>NB��B��EGJEZ�E@?K��YABCB@B

���tE@>�P�B�XPSPJB0�B�VKJ�AECDkK�PH�CE@D�AU�G�A��?D�@KAK0�?)K)

XPSPJB0�?KJ�CPVkK)�[�5-�J�MEHP�l�>?BVK@>B��@P�K�K�B?K?0����AS�G�

@>EJ�TE�BJ��BB0�EG��V�C�TE�UkK�BK�@?�?P@��HE�P�E��I�@E^G�E�

�K@TPACB>B0� ?)K)� @� @ES���K�BKJ�XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�0� ?E�� @B@?KJU0

>E?E��I�?EMH��AUC�)�zE��E�.-�CK?�?EJP���G�H0�.7�J��?��.55.�M)0��AS��

GU�TEHHK�Z�CB�W?P�BHK^�����KlK�K�HPJK�E�@ES���K�BB�B�EA�E�CK�

�BB�XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�)�O�PGB�U���W?EJ��KlK�K�HPJK��K�PV�@?�E���

CB)�����EAE�E?0�3.�J��?��O�PGBI�T�EMECE@E��C������KlK�K�HPJK�G�

�KG��B@BJE@?D0�V?E�EG��V�CE�TEC�U����G�U��@�@E^G�UJ�vK�?�EJ)

O�PGBI�@?��BC��@KAK�NKCD^�E@�EAEZHK�BK�E?�tE@>�U0�>�?EJP�ZK

TP?KJ�>E�l�E�?�NBB�@�F�KJCKJ)�X�H�PME��@?E�E�U0�B�@E�@�EBJB

��P?�K��BJB�?EMH���KMBE��JB�Q�XPSPJB0�vSB���CB0���>�>E��?E�@?K�

TK�B�x�?PJB0� B� @� W?�BVK@>BJB�JK�DkB�@?��JB�O�PGBI� �UA��C�

EVK�D�}T�EHP>?B��U�~�TP?D)�Y)K)�E���EH�E��KJK��E�T�E?B�E@?EIC�

>�>���Kk�BJ0�?�>�B���P?�K��BJ�NK�?��J�@ET�E?B�CK�BI�B�EV�M�J

��T�IZK�BI)�RAS�GBI�ElBNB�CD�E�TEHHK�ZB��C��>E�?�>?U�@�@E^G�

Page 142: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�UJ�vK�?�EJ0���HCI�O�PGBB��E@@B�@>EK��P>E�EH@?�E�8��5-�J0�5.�J

MM)�W?E�AUC�uCDNB�:����>�>EK�?E���KJI�@?�CE�T��?�K�EJ���AE�DAK

T�E?B��W?EME�@E^G�EME�vK�?��0�?)K)�E�BK�?B�U���tE@>�K�AUCB���G�

�UK)

�?E�>�@�K?@I���P?�K��K��?KS�ECEMBB0�K@CB��K�EkBA�^@D0���RA�

S�GBB�@E�K?@>�I��EJK�>C�?P���B�B�?KCCBMK�NBI�8B0�V?E��KJ�CE��Z�

�E0���?EJ�VB@CK�B��K�EJK�>C�?P���I�B�?KCCBMK�NBI:���kCB�EALB�

IGU>0�B��AS�GU�@JEMCB�JEABCBGE��?D�TEV?B��K@D�@�EK����P?�K��B�

�K@P�@�Q�TE�>����K��JK�K0�?�>�E�B��UkCB�����UAE�U�E@K�D^�5.�ME

MEH�)�|EJK�>C�?P���B�}R�HMUC���~�l�>?BVK@>B��U@?PT�CB�>�>�EA�

LK�AS�G@>�I�>E�CBNBI)��?E�>�@�K?@I�M�PGB�0�?P?���P?�K��II�?KS�E�

CEMBI�AUC��H�PM�I��@E�K?@>�I��EJK�>C�?P���B�M�PGB�@>�I�@E�K?@>�I

B�?KCCBMK�NBI�AUCB�l�>?BVK@>B�E?@?���K�U�E?�EALK��NBE��CD�E�

ME�H�BZK�BI)�O�J@�SP�HBI�@JEM�EHK�Z�?D�TEAKHP���H�H�PMBJB�TECB�

?BVK@>BJB�lBMP��JB�B�M�PTT�JB0�>E?E�UK�T�K?K�HE��CB����AECKK

PJK�K��U��B��G�KkK��U��TEHSEH�>��KkK�B^�M�PGB�@>BS�T�EACKJ)

p?B�TC^��CB@?BVK@>BK�M�PTTU��KG>E�E@C�ACB0�?�>�B��K�@lE�JB�E�

���kB@D���@K�DKG�UK�TECB?BVK@>BK�E�M��BG�NBB��B���YABCB@B0��B��

XPSPJB)�F��S�W?BS�M�PTT�I�BC@I�EH�BJ�BG�l�>?E�E��P@BCK�BI�>E��

l�E�?�NBB�JKZHP�M�PGB��JB�B��AS�G�JB)�[�HK>�A�K�.5;;�M)���XPSPJB

AUC�JB?B�M�M�PGB�@>BS��KlE�J�CE�)�Y�J�AUCB���G�UK��U@?PTCK�BI0

�E�I�AU��@TEJ�BC��U@?PTCK�BK�[E�U�[K>P�0�>E?E�U��@>�G�C0�V?E�JU

���HKJ�TP?D�>��AS�G@>BJ�@K�HN�J)�|E�KJP��K�@PZHK�E�AUCE�B@>�?D

TP?D�>��AS�G@>BJ�@K�HN�J�Q�E��E>�G�C@I�ZK�?�E��B^CD@>BS�@EAU?B�

;5�ME�MEH�)��?E�>�@�K?@I��P>E�EHB?KCK��TEAKHB�kKME�}F�PMCEME�@?E�

C�~0�MC���E��TECB?BVK@>E��@BCU�O�PGBB0�?E�BS�E?�EkK�BK�>�RAS�GBB

I�?EV�E�TEJ�^��E�B�@VB?�CB�8B�O�J@�SP�HBI��K���G�EA�W?EJ�ME�E�BC

TPACBV�E:0�V?E��B>�>�I�W?E��K�RAS�GBI0�W?E�@K�K�E�G�T�H��I�V�@?D

O�PGBB)�FEMH��I�E?�BJK�B�J�CEVB@CK��E��ETTEGBNBE��E��M�PTTU���

TK��EJ�ZK�G�@KH��BB�[K�SE��EME�XE�K?��O�PGBB0����EIA�K�.55-�M)0

TE@?��BC��ET�E@�E�@EGH��BB�>EJB@@BB�TE�RAS�GBB0�E?�K?�O�J@�SP��

HBI�AUC�EVK�D�T�E@?UJ�B�VK?>BJ��}p?E�@K�K�E�G�T�H��I�O�PGBI�Q��

RJK�B>K�ZB�P?�?ECD>E��JK�B>��NU0���R�MCBB�ZB�P?�?ECD>E���MCBV��

�K~)�|K�@?��P�>EJJK�?B�E��?D0���@>ECD>E���R�MCBB�ZB�P?�?ECD>E����

MCBV��K0��E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�P��BS�TEHSEHU�AUCB�?�>BK0�B�E��E?>�G�C@I

H�ZK�E?�@EGH��BI�>EJB@@BB�TE�RAS�GBB)�p?E�AUC�TEHSEH��K�?ECD>E

Page 143: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

O�J@�SP�HBI�B��K�?ECD>E�}F�PMCEME�X?EC�~�Q�W?E�AUC�TEHSEH�TEH���

CI^LKME�AECDkB�@?���M�PGB�@>BS��>?B�B@?E�0�H��B�M�PGB�@>EME����

@KCK�BI�8��?EJ�@E@?EI�BB0���>E?E�EJ�E�E�?EMH����SEHBCE@D0�KME�?�PH�

�E�AUCE���G��?D�EALK@?�EJ:)�RAS�GE��E�B��E@T�B�BJ�CB�>�>���NBE�

��CD�EK�JK�DkB�@?�E0�������K�@�HZ���SK?@>BJB���JI��JB�B�E@K?B�

��JB�8>�>����Z�E��]@K?BB0�?�>�B��E���P?�K��K��O�PGBB:)�YEMH�k�II

�KTECB?BVK@>�I�WCB?��E?CBV�E�TE�BJ�C�0�V?E�W?E�CEZD0��E�?KJ��K

JK�KK�TECB?B>��AUC��?�>�I)���TEW?EJP�E�B�l�>?BVK@>B�E?>�GU��CB

�AS�G�J���T���K����@�JEBHK�?BlB>�NB^�B�@ES���K�BK�@�EK��BHK��

?BV�E@?B)�|E�BJK��E�T�B�?E���C�@?B0�CK?EJ�.55.�M)0�T�EBGEkC��TK��

��I�B�HE@?�?EV�E�P@TKk��I�?EMH��@HKC>��JKZHP��C�@?IJB�O�PGBB�B

RAS�GBB�Q�I�BJK^����BHP�@EMC�kK�BK�E�G�>E�K�E��UAE��S���RAS�GBB)

YEMH��ZK�AUCB���K@K�U�TET���>B���FE�@?B?PNB^�RAS�G@>E��RXXz���

W?E��>E�@?B?PNBB�TEI�BC�@D�zK@TPACB>��O�PGBI0�B� �� W?EJ�@JU@CK

FE�@?B?PNBI�RAS�G@>E��RXXz�PZK��EkC����T�E?B�E�KVBK�@�FE�@?B�

?PNBK��XXXz0�MHK�zK@TPACB>B�O�PGBB��K�AUCE0���O�PGBI�KLK���GU���

C�@D�O�PGB�@>E��XXz)�y��K�APHP�>�@�?D@I��@KS�TK�BTK?B�0��E0�>�>�AU

?E��B�AUCE0�?EMH��AUC��HE@?BM�P?��>�>�I�?E�HEME�E�K��E@?D0�B0�J�K

>�ZK?@I0�E?�W?E��TECB?BVK@>E��@HKC>B�AUC�TP?D�B�>�@?�ABCD�EJP��K�

kK�B^�T�EACKJU0�B�>�>E�l�E�?�NBB)�]����K�G�>�U��C��T�EACKJP0

�K��Kk�C��KK0�EH��>E�H���C��EAKBJ�@?E�E��J��EGJEZ�E@?D�?���@lE��

JB�E��?D�W?B�E?�EkK�BI���@?�ABCD�P^�@B@?KJP�@E@PLK@?�E���BI)

]@EAK��E�P@BCBCB@D�TE?�KA�E@?D�B�ZKC��BK�YABCB@B�>E�@PCD�

?B�E��?D@I�@�RAS�GBK�0��K@?B�TK�KME�E�U�@��AS�G@>BJB�CBHK��JB�B

TECB?BVK@>BJB�HKI?KCIJB�TE@CK�ME@PH��@?�K��EME�TK�K�E�E?����O�P�

GBB�>E�N��5.�ME�Q���V�C��5,�ME�MM)���>�>���G�?EMH����V�C���AE?�?D��E�

�EBGA����U��[K�SE��U��XE�K?�RAS�GBB)

[�I����K0�lK���CK0���V�CK�J��?�0�HE��EG��LK�BI�sK���H��HGK0��

O�PGBB���AE?�C�FE�@PCD?�?B��U��@E�K?)�xUC��@EGH����>EJB@@BI�TE

RAS�GBB0�IH�EJ�>E?E�E��AUCB��K@TPACB>��NU)�tU�T�BKGZ�CB���XP�

SPJB0�AUCB��@?�KVB)�|�kBJ�SEGIB�EJ�AUC�{P��A�RVA�0�AECDkK��@KS

JU�EAL�CB@D�@��BJ)�xUCB��@?�KVB�B�@�HKTP?�?�JB�[K�SE��EME�XE�K�

?��RAS�GBB�Q�HE�ECD�E�?IZKCUK��@?�KVB0��E�JK�KK�?IZKCUK0�VKJ��@?�K�

VB�@�HKTP?�?�JB�M�PGB�@>E��l��>NBB0�>E?E�US�?EMH��AECDkK�B�?K�K�

@E��CE0�T�EBGEkKC�CB���YABCB@B�TP?V)�y�H�ZK�TEJ�^�PT�K>B�@E�@?E�

�E�U�[C�HB@C����R�HGB�A�0�>E?E�U��@>�G�C���J��}xPHD�I�@KT���?B@�

Page 144: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

?EJ0�T�B�IC�AU�T�KHCEZK�BK�M�PGB�@>E��l��>NBB0�V?EAU�[K�SE��U�

XE�K?�RAS�GBB���@NK�BC�HK�@?�BI�?ABCB@@>BS�TE�@?��NK��>�>�ME@P�

H��@?�K��U��TK�K�E�E?�B�G�I�BC0�V?E�HE��E@@?��E�CK�BI�G�>E��EME

�P>E�EH@?���O�PGBB�RAS�GBI�E?>�GU��K?@I�E?�TEHVB�K�BI)�xPHD�I�@K�

T���?B@?EJ�Q�I��KHD�E?CBV�E�TE�BJ�^0�V?E�O�J@�SP�HBI��B>EMH���K

�K��K?@I�Q�?�>��E?0�I�AU�G�I�BC0�V?E��K�APHP�T�BG����?D�?P��C�@?D0

>E?E��I�?�J�K@?D0�V?E�HCI���kBS�@��K��E?�EkK�B���K?�T���E�E��A�GU~)

[EEALK�M�PGB�@>�I�l��>NBI�?EMH���KC��@KAI�EVK�D�B�?K�K@�E�8�K�?�

��CD�E��U��Z�I@D:0��E�?KJ��K�JK�KK���J�PH�CE@D0���AE?�I�@��P>E�E�

HB?KCIJB�R�HMUC���0��U��AE?�?D�EALBK�T�EJKZP?EV�UK�TEHSEHU)

p?E�EG��V�CE0�V?E�RAS�G@>�I�RXXz�TK�KBJK�PK?@I���zK@TPACB>P�RA�

S�GBI0� BG�FE�@?B?PNBB�RAS�GBB� B@>C^V�^?@I� @CE��� }XE�K?@>B�

XE^G~0�}@E^G�UK~�B�?)H)0�W?E�AUCE���T�>K?K)

[�>E�NK�lK���CI�.55,�M)�@E@?EICE@D�G�@KH��BK�Q�I�HPJ�^0��E>E�

�EK�G�@KH��BK�Q�FE�@PCD?�?B��EME�@E�K?�)�8XE�K?���GU��C@I�>E�@PCD�

?�?B��UJ0��E0�TE�@P?B0�E��AUC�l�>?BVK@>BJ�T��C�JK�?EJ�O�PGBB�

?PH���SEHBCB�T�KH@?��B?KCB��@KS�AECKK�BCB�JK�KK��CBI?KCD�US�M�PTT

Q�>�EJK�G�B�HB@?E�0�B�T�KH@?��B?KCB��EJK�>C�?P��E��B��K�EJK�>�

C�?P��E��B�?KCCBMK�NBB0�?)K)�EALK@?�K��EK�J�K�BK�W?E?�TECB?BVK�

@>B��>E�@PCD?�?B��U��@E�K?�I��E�T�KH@?��CIC)�tU�@���CB��EJ�o��

B�H�����AUCB�VCK��JB�W?EME�@E�K?�c�����>EJB@@B^��SEHBC�B�OBI�R��

V�A�HGK0�E��B���XPSPJB�KGHBC��JK@?K�@���JB):�y��KC�W?E�G�@KH��BK�>�>

>EE�HB��?E��?EME�TECB?BVK@>EME�FE�@PCD?�?B��EME�@E�K?�)�|��@CK�

HP^LB��HK�D�AUC����G��VK���@K@@BI�[K�SE��EME�XE�K?��RAS�GBB0�B

JU�T�KHC�M�CB���KJK��EJP��P>E�EH@?�P�O�PGBB�T�B�I?D�HK>�K?�E

TK�KBJK�E���BB�RAS�G@>E��RXXz���zK@TPACB>P�RAS�GBI�B�T�KHCE�

ZB?D�[K�SE��EJP�XE�K?P�RAS�GBB�@HKC�?D�?E�ZKc�EH��>E�JU�E>�G��

CB@D���JK�DkB�@?�K0�B0�>�@EZ�CK�B^0�W?���EGJEZ�E@?D���V�?D��K�CD�

�UK�TK�KME�E�U�AUC��PTPLK��)�=E?EJ0�TE@CK��EG���LK�BI�sK���H�

��HGK���O�PGB^0���J��?K�.55,�M)0�>EJB@@B^�TE�RAS�GBB�T�KEA��GE���

CB)�|�@���GA��BCB�H�PMBJB�VCK��JB0� �� >EJB@@BB�TEI�BC@I�rK���

RCK>@BHGK0�KME�@VB?�CB�AECKK�HE�K�K��UJ�CBNEJ�8��TK��P^�EVK�KHD0

sK���H��HGK:0���kB�TEGBNBB��KJ�EME�E@C�ACB0��E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�JU

@JEMCB�TEHME?E�B?D�HE>PJK�?0�>E?E�U����GU��C@I�}XE�JK@?�EK�@E�

MC�kK�BK�OE@@E�K?��zK@TPACB>B�O�PGBI�B�[K�SE��EME�XE�K?��RAS��

GBB~)�=EHSEHU�AUCB�l�>?BVK@>B�?K�ZK0�V?E�B��E���KJK���FE�@PCD?��

Page 145: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

?B��EME�@E�K?�)�[�?E?�ZK�TK�BEH�TEI�BCE@D�B�T�KHCEZK�BK�>�T�EK>?P

HEME�E���M����Y���@��s�JA�)

]A�����B��?��HEME�E���EA�E@�E��S��G�BJEE?�EkK�B����@@J�?�

�B��CB@D���B^�K�.55,�M)�|K@JE?�I����?E0�V?E�JKZHP���kBJ�TEHSEHEJ

B�W?BJ�T�KHCEZK�BKJ�>�T�EK>?P�HEME�E���AUCE�J�EME���GCBVB�0��@K

ZK�T�B�?L�?KCD�EJ���@@JE?�K�BB�@?�CE�I@�E0�V?E�@SEH@?���ME��GHE

AECDkK0�VKJ���GCBVB�)�[�W?EJ�T�KHCEZK�BB�AUC��@?�?DI�30�>E?E��I

MC�@BC�0�V?E�}zK@TPACB>��RAS�GBI�HEA�E�ECD�E�EAwKHB�IK?@I�@�zK@�

TPACB>E��O�PGBI0�EAC�H�K?����@�EK��?K��B?E�BB��@K��TEC�E?E��G�>E�

�EH�?KCD�E�0�B@TEC�B?KCD�E��B�@CPZKA�E���C�@?K�0�>�EJK�?KS�TEC�

�EJEVB�0�>E?E�UK�E?�K@K�U�FE�@?B?PNBIJB�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB�>��K�

HK�B^�zK@TPACB>B�O�PGBI~)�{�?KJ�T�KHTEC�M�CE@D���@@JE?�K?D���G�

M���BVK�BK�TEC�EJEVB��JKZHP�YABCB@B�B�XPSPJB)

n���@�AUC��J�EMEV�@E��I��@?�KV��@�M��EJ�sK���H��HGK)�F��KCB�

>EJP�JEKJP�@EZ�CK�B^0�E���K�TE�IC�@P?D�T�EACKJU)�uME�E?�K?�AUC

?�>BJ��}tU��K�JEZKJ�HETP@?B?D0�V?EAU�@?�?P@�RAS�GBB�AUC��K�?��

>BJ0�>�>�@?�?P@�RHZ��BB)�tU�HECZ�U�@?�?P@EJ�RHZ��BB�PHK�Z�?D

RAS�GB^���O�PGBB~)�tU�TE�ICB0�V?E�E���BVKME��K�TE�IC0�>�?EJP�ZK�P

�KME�AUCB�@K�DKG�UK�T�EACKJU)�F�?EJP���KJK�B�RA�kBHGK���RHZ��

�BB�l�>?BVK@>B�PT��GH�BC�[K�SE��U��XE�K?0� >E?E�U��AUC� ?EMH�

TC^��CB@?BVK@>BJ�8KJP�?�PH�E�AUCE�>E�?�ECB�E��?D��K@D�[K�SE��

�U��XE�K?:0�TEI�BCB@D�@K�DKG�UK�EV�MB���T�IZK��E@?B���tB�M�K�

CBB0�B0����K��EK0��C�@?B�O�PGBB��KkBCB�>�>BJB�?E��U@E>BJB0�T�?�

�BE?BVK@>BJB�CEGP�M�JB�B�BHKIJB�TK�K>�U?D�@PLK@?�P^LBK�T�E�

ACKJU)�y��K�G��^0�EkBACB@D�E�B�BCB��K?)�qPJ�^0�V?E�B���RAS�GBB

AUCB�@BCU0�G�B�?K�K@E����UK���@?EC>�E�K�BB)�]A�RAS�GBB�J�K�@P�

HB?D�?�PH�E0�����YABCB@B�TE@CK�W?EME�E?>�G�0�TE@CK�?EME0�>�>�JU�l�>�

?BVK@>B�AUCB�?�>�ACBG>B�>�G�>C^VK�B^�T�EJKZP?EV�EME�@EMC�kK�

�BI0�I��E�AUC�@HKC����UAE������EK��P^�>E�l�E�?�NB^)�zE@@B�@>BK

�E�@>��AUCB��IHEJ0�.-���MP@?��O�PGBB�AUCB�TK�KH��U�?��>B�Y�44

RS�CNBS@>E��HB�BGBB0�B�.9���MP@?��W?B�?��>B�TEI�BCB@D���RAS�GBB)

qPJ�^0�V?E�?EMH��AUC��PTPLK����EGJEZ�E@?D)

=E?EJ0��E���KJI��E��U0�V�@?E�TEHTB@U��CB@D�T�EJKZP?EV�UK

@EMC�kK�BI�E�T�K>��LK�BB�EM�I0��E�E�B0�>�>�T���BCE0�B@TECDGE���

CB@D�HCI�TEHME?E�>B�@CKHP^LK���EK��E��ETK��NBB0�B�I�HPJ�^0�V?E

E?��BS�AECDkK��UMEHU�TECPV�C���AS�G@>�I�@?E�E��)

Page 146: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

]VK�D�@K�DKG�UJ�AUCE�G�I�CK�BK�9��T�KCI�.559�M)���J�l�>?B�

VK@>B�AUC�TK�KVK�D�?KS�TEC�EJEVB�0�>E?E�UK�E?�EHI?@I���@CPV�K�P�K�

MPCB�E���BI�>E�lCB>?��KHB�EJP�E�M��P��C�@?B0�AUCB�ET�KHKCK�U

@E�JK@?�UK�TEC�EJEVBI�Q���Kk�II�TECB?B>�0�W>E�EJB>�0�T�����VK�

CE�K>�0�W>ECEMBI�B�?)H)�|E�W?E�G�I�CK�BK��K��UG��CE�E@EAEME��E@?E�M�

H�ZK���YABCB@B0�H�ZK�����kBS�>�PM�S0�TE�?E��T�E@?E��T�BVB�K0�V?E

E�E�AUCE�@�IG��E�@�TEHTB@��BKJ�VK?U�KS@?E�E��KME�@EMC�kK�BI�E

�EG���LK�BB�AKZK�NK�0�MHK�AUCE�EME�E�K�E0�V?E��EG���L�^?@I��@K

AKZK�NU0�>�EJK�?KS0�>?E�SE?D�>�>EK�?E�PV�@?BK�T�B�BJ�C���AEK�US

HK�@?�BIS0���?KS�AUCE�@CBk>EJ�J�EME0��JK@?K�@�BS�@KJDIJB)

F�>BK�?E�>E�@PCD?�NBB�TE@CK�W?EME��KCB@D0�B�EMH�����lKHK��?B��

�US�E@�E��S)�[�>E�NK�B^CI�.554�M)���EHK�AUCE�HE@?BM�P?E�B�G��BGB�

�E���E�@EMC�kK�BK0�EH��>E�E�E�?�>�B��K�AUCE�TEHTB@��E0�B0���>E�KN0

JU�HEkCB�HE�@KMEH�Ik�KME�H�I)�O�PGBI�HECMEK���KJI�T�KHC�M�C���K�

TE�I?�P^�}kB�E>P^���?E�EJB^~0��E�TE?EJ�@EMC�@BC�@D����lKHK���

NB^)�XK�V�@� 8AECDkK�����kBS�>�PM�S0�VKJ���ElBNB�CD�US:�@?�CB

ME�E�B?D�E�@EGH��BB�EALKME�ME@PH��@?��)�|E�RAS�GBI�PZK�@�JEET�K�

HKCBC�@D�B�@VB?�K?0�V?E�@�JEET�KHKCK�BK�RAS�GBB�Q�W?E��KG��B@B�

JE@?D)

YKTK�D�@�JU��@CEZ�U���ET�E@��>�>E�U�TK�@TK>?B�U)�t�K�>��

ZK?@I0�V?E�SE�EkBS�TK�@TK>?B���K�EVK�D�J�EME)�y�TK�KVB@C^�?K��EG�

JEZ�UK�@NK���BB0�>E?E�UK0�TE�JEKJP�J�K�B^0�JEMP?�AU?D���GUM���

�U�Q�@TK����?K0�>E?E�UK�I�@VB?�^�AECKK��K�CB@?BVK@>BJB0���TE?EJ0

TE�PAU��^LK�0�?K0�>E?E�UK�I�@VB?�^�JK�KK��K�CB@?BVK@>BJB)�R�TE�

?EJ0���>E�NK0�I��U��ZP�@�EB�TEZKC��BI0�TE?EJP�V?E�k��@��K�CBG�NBB

@�JEME�TE@CKH�KME�@NK���BI�@VB?�^���@?ECD>E�JBGK��UJ0�V?E���G��?D

KME��EGJEZ�UJ�?�PH�E)

F� ���- HI�Q�W?E���BSPHk�I��K�@BI�>BT�@>EME����B��?�)�Y)K)

O�PGBI�ZB�K?�ME��GHE�SPZK0�VKJ�FBT�0���RAS�GBI�ZB�K?�KLK�SPZK0

VKJ�@K�K���I�V�@?D�FBT��0�YP�KN>�I�zK@TPACB>��FBT�)�p?E�l�>?B�

VK@>B�@ES���K�BK��U�Kk�K��@B?P�NBB�Q�O�PGBI�B�RAS�GBI�E@?�^?@I

�K@EA����UJB0��K@E@?EI�kBJB@I�ME@PH��@?��JB)�tKZHP��BJB0�>E�

�KV�E0�K@?D���G�BN���O�PGBI�T�BG����0�RAS�GBI��K�T�BG����c���O�P�

GBB�K@?D�>�>BK�?E�B�@?B?P?U0���RAS�GBB�BS�JK�DkKc�O�PGBI�BJKK?

@�E��N�K?����>��?K0�RAS�GBI��K�BJKK?c��E0�>�>�AUCE�@>�G��E0�EH���Q

W?E�>��GBME@PH��@?�E0� �� �?E��I0�JEZK?�AU?D0� >��GB�>��GB)�z�G�BN�

Page 147: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

JKZHP��BJB��K�EVK�D�AECDk�I)�[�?EJ�@JU@CK0�V?E��B�EH�E0��B�H�PMEK

�K�I�CIK?@I�@E@?EI�kBJ@I�ME@PH��@?�EJ)�[�EAEG�BJEJ�APHPLKJ�?��

>�I�@B?P�NBI�APHK?�T�EHECZ�?D@I)

F� ���- HJ��O�PGBI�T�BG��K?�@�EK�TE��ZK�BK)�|K�>�>BK�?E�?�J

T�E�E@@B�@>BK0�>EJJP�B@?BVK@>BK�BCB��KE>EJJP�B@?BVK@>BK�@BCU0

��AECDk�I�V�@?D�M�PGB�@>E��TECB?BVK@>E��WCB?U�HKC�K?��UAE�����?E0

V?EAU��K��P?D@I���CE�E�zE@@BB0�E?>�G�?D@I�E?�@�EBS�J�CK�D>BS�T�E�

JKZP?EV�US�HE@?BZK�B�0�@EMC�@B?D@I�@�?KJ0�V?E�O�PGBI�E@?�K?@I�V��

@?D^��EK��E�TECB?BVK@>EME�B�W>E�EJBVK@>EME�T�E@?���@?���zE@@BB)

[� ?�>EJ� @CPV�K�HE@?�?EV�E� �KCB>��J��V��I� �K�EI?�E@?D� ?EME0� V?E

BK���SBI�tE@>���Q�YABCB@B�Q�XPSPJB�APHK?��E@@?��E�CK������E�US

lE�J�S)�O�PGB�U�APHP?�BM��?D����KMAB0�B�EMH��H�ZK�EAUM�U��?D�zE@�

@B^0�B�APHP?�W?EJP���HE��?D@I0�JEZK?�AU?D0��@TEJ�I?0�V?E�>EMH��?E

BM��CB���lP?AEC0��E��K@D���k�@P�K�K�B?K?�APHK?�TE�K�S�E@?�UJ)

F� ���- HK��O�PGBI�PSB?�IK?@I�E@�EAEHB?D@I�E?��KZBJ��sK�

���H��HGK�B�KME���@CKH�B>E�)�qKJE>��?BVK@>BK�B�@?B?P?U�P@BCB���

^?@I)�O�PGBI�KLK��K��E�J�CD��I�HKJE>��?BVK@>�I�@?����0��E�PZK���

�KK�TESEZ�c� @B?P�NBI�T�BACBGB?KCD�E�>�>����U�Kk�K��XK�ABB0� �

�ME@C��BB)�=�EG�T�H��I�E�BK�?�NBI�O�PGBB�TE�W?EJP�@NK���B^��K

EG��V�K?���?B�E@@B�@>P^�E�BK�?�NB^0�B�O�PGBI0�PVB?U��I���Kk�BK

B���P?�K��BK�l�>?E�U0�HEAB��K?@I�@EGH��BI�EALKME�ME@PH��@?���@

RAS�GBK�)�p?E�?EZK�APHK?��K�>E�KV�U���KGPCD?�?0���ET�KHKCK���I�@HKC�

>�0�@EGH�^L�I��EGJEZ�E@?D�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU�TK�K��@?B����E�J�CD�EK

EALK@?�E0�BCB0���EAE�E?0�HCI�@CKHP^LK��>E�l�E�?�NBB0�?)K)�>�>E��

?E�?��J��P?)

F� ���- H L�Q�W?E�?EZK�>BT�@>B�����B��?0��E��K�TCESE�0������

@?EILB�0�@E��KJK��U�)�O�PGBI�ZB�K?�?�>�ZK�SE�EkE0�>�>�FBT�0�B

RAS�GBI�ZB�K?�?EZK��KTCESE)�O�PGBI�B�RAS�GBI�EAL�^?@I�JKZHP�@E�

AE��B���>�>E��?E�@?KTK�B���SEHI?@I���EALKJ�T�E@?���@?�K�AKG�>E�>�

�K?BG�NBB�?KS�ECEMBB���SEZHK�BI���EALKJ�T�E@?���@?�K)

���E?�?���K�@BI0�Q�BCB0�@>E�KK0�?E�TEZKC��BK0�T�KHCEZK�BK0�>E?E�

�EK�I��K�JEMP���G��?D��EGJEZ�UJ�@NK���BKJ0�Q�TE�>E?E�E��B�O�PGBI0

B�RAS�GBI�@?��E�I?@I�T�EN�K?�^LBJB0�TC^��CB@?BVK@>BJB0�HKJE>�

��?BVK@>BJB0�TEJEM�^?�H�PM�H�PMP0�HETEC�I^?�H�PM�H�PM�0�B��K�@?ECD

PZ�B���Z�E0�ZB�P?�CB�E�B���KHB�EJ�ME@PH��@?�K�BCB����HP?�H�PMBK

lE�JU�@E@PLK@?�E���BI���EH�EJ�T�E@?���@?�K)�y��VK���PTEJI�PC

Page 148: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

r^>@KJAP�M�TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�@?����J�xK�BC^>@�)�Y�>��E?0�?�>E��>���

>�G@>B��xK�BC^>@0�MHK�=EC��@?��E�B?@I�TEVK?�E��M��ZH��>E��YAB�

CB@B�B�XPSPJB0�=��?��?K�IK?���AE?P0�TE?EJP�V?E�P���@��@K�P�KMPCB�E�

���E0�>EK�>?E�PSEHB?���J��MB��CD�P^�ETTEGBNB^0�AKZK�NU�TUkP?

GHE�E�DKJ0�B�AECDk�I�BS�V�@?D��EG���L�K?@I���RAS�GB^0�x�?�C�ZB�

�K?�T�KBJPLK@?�K��E���YABCB@B0���JU�@���JB�TECPV�KJ�EVK�D��U@E�

>P^0�SE�EkP^�TK�@B^��[@��W?E�I��BZP0��@��JEMP�T�EM�EGB�E��?D0

�E��K�JEMP�T�EM�EGB�E��?D0���>�>E����C^?K�JU�APHKJ�TECPV�?D�AECD�

kBK�HK�DMB�Q���K��E�BCB���HECC���S)�XT�@BAE)

�������!"�#�-8�[@K�W?B�TI?D�JEHKCK�0�@NK���BK�0�W?E�>�>�AU�?�>E�TK@@BJBGJ�BCB��K�CD�UK�JEHKCB\�y�?P?��K��BZP��B�EH�E���K�CD�E�

JEHKCB0�>E?E�P^��U�@KAK�@K�DKG�E�T�KH@?��CIK?K)�n�JK�I�AUCE�ELP�

LK�BK0�V?E��U�@�CKM>BJ�TK@@BJBGJEJ�ME�E�BCB�E��@KS�JEHKCIS)�R

>�>P^��U�T�KHTEVB?�K?K\�F�>P^��BHB?K��UMEH�E�\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�y�T�KHTEVB?�^�4�U��@NK���B�0��E��K�T�E�?B��9�ME)

��������%�"�8�|E�T�E?B��>�>EME��KkB?KCD�E�T�E?B�\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�zKkB?KCD�E�T�E?B��,�ME�B�.�ME0���3����E@�

T�B�BJ�^�>�>��EGJEZ�E@?D�T�EH�BZK�BI��TK�KH)

��0��%�8�YE�K@?D�>�>�W?�T�TK�KSEH��>�9�JP�BCB�4�JP\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�XK�V�@�����EJK�>C�?P��EJ�P�E��K�W?E�G��>E�@K��B�E���E0��E�TEI�CI^?@I��E�UK���P?�K��BK�BM�E>B�

��R��� ����0�8�tEZK?0�I��K�@E�@KJ�PCE�BC�0��E0��@K�?�>B0�>�>BK

��kB�T�KHCEZK�BI\��?E�JEZ�E�AU�@HKC�?D�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU�BGJK�B?D

@B?P�NB^0�K@?D�CB�T�EJKZP?EV�UK�JK�U�HCI�HE@?BZK�BI�AC�MET�B�

I?�EME�B@SEH�\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�HCI�@K�DKG�EME�T�EH�BZK�BI��P�KMPCB�E���BB�>E�lCB>?���KEASEHBJE��KkB?D�EVK�D�@K�DKG�UK

Page 149: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

T�EACKJU���@�JE��O�PGBB�B���@�JE��RAS�GBB)�p?E�T�EACKJ���C�@?B��

O�PGBB0�W?E�T�EACKJ����@kB�K�BI�HKJE>��?BVK@>EME�T�E@?���@?����

O�PGBB�Q�AKG�W?EME�I��K��BZP��EGJEZ�E@?B�@K�DKG�EME�

�������!"�#�-8�FEMH���U�HPJ�CB�EA�W?BS�JEHKCIS0��U0����K��E0�T�KH�@?��CICB�@KAK�>�>BK�?E��EGJEZ�UK�JEHKCB�ME@PH��@?�K��EME�P@?�E��

@?��\�[U�@TKNB�CD�E�W?EME��K�ME�E�BCB�BCB�T�E@?E�@VB?�CB0�V?E�TE�

@>ECD>P�W?E��AS�GE�M�PGB�@>�I��@?�KV�0�?E��ET�E@U�]@K?BB0�qZ����

SK?BB)))�?)K)�P���@���O�PGBB�HE@?�?EV�E�J�EME�>E�lCB>?�US�@B?P�NB�

Q�@�RHZ��BK�0���T�BJK�)�=�KH@?��CICB�CB��U�@KAK0�>�>�W?B�JEHKCB

@E�JK@?I?@I0���>�>EK�T�E@?���@?�E�B���>�>EJ�>�VK@?�K�E�B��E�HP?\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�y�@VB?�^0�V?E�RAS�GBI�B�O�PGBI�I�CI^?@I

TECB?BVK@>BJB�KHB�BN�JB)��?E�ZK�>�@�K?@I��Z�E��]@K?BB0�RH�

Z��BB�B�H�PMBS��KMBE�E��O�PGBB0�?E�E�B�I�CI^?@I���?E�EJ�UJB

V�@?IJB�O�PGBB0�?)K)�TE���kKJP�TEHSEHP�O�PGBI�P@?�EK���TE�T�B��

NBTP��@BJJK?�BV�EME��KMBE��CBGJ�0�TE����CEMBB�@��@T��BK�)�Y)K)

�Z��I�]@K?BI0�RHZ��BI0��JK�K?BI0�F�SK?BI�B�?)H)�Q�W?E���?E�EJ�

�UK��KMBE�U�O�PGBB0���RAS�GBI�B�O�PGBI�I�CI^?@I�ME@PH��@?�EEA�

��GP^LBJB�KHB�BN�JB)�=�BJK��E�?�>E��ZK�TEHSEH0�E@�E����U�

����@BJJK?�BV�EJ��KMBE��CBGJK0�P���@�AUC�B�HE��E��U0�B�TK�KVK�D

�KMBE�E����W?E��JEHKCB�JU���VB��CB�@�RAS�GBB0�@�TEC�EJEVBIJB

TE����CEMBB�@E�X?���E��x�@>E��B�?)H)�X��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U�?EMH�

AUCE�T�KHCEZK�BK�lKHK��NBB)�=E�TEC�EJEVBIJ�W?B�JEHKCB�AUCB

EVK�D�ACBG>B)�=E@CK��E��U0�K@?K@?�K��E0�@B?P�NBI�BGJK�BC�@D�B

RAS�GBI�PZK��B>�>��K��TB@U��K?@I���W?P���P?�K��^^�JEHKCD0�TE�

W?EJP�B�JU�?���@lE�JB�E��CB�@�EB�TEHSEHU�B�@VB?�KJ0�V?E�RAS��

GBI�Q�W?E�E?HKCD��I�KHB�BN�0�W?E�@?E�E��)�X�x�?PJB�E@EAUS�T�E�

ACKJ��K�APHK?0�MC����I�T�EACKJ��RA�kBHGK�Q�>�>�G���AE?�?D�TEAECD�

kK�HK�KM�B�EAK@TKVB?D�@�E^�AKGET�@�E@?D0�AKGET�@�E@?D�@�EK���C��

@?B0�lE�J�CD�E�T�BG����I� �K�SE�K�@?�E� �C�@?B�O�PGBB)��Z�P^

]@K?B^�JU���@@J�?�B��KJ�E?HKCD�E�E?�RAS�GBB0�B�I��K�TE�BJ�^0

TEVKJP�BS���HE���@@J�?�B��?D��JK@?K��K@CB0�HETP@?BJ0�JU���@T�E�

@?���BJ�W?P�JEHKCD�����Z�P^�]@K?B^0� ?E��EG�B>�K?�@B?P�NBI0

>EMH���Z��I�]@K?BI� I�CIK?@I� ME@PH��@?�EJ0� ��XK�K���I�]@K?BI

ME@PH��@?�EJ��K�I�CIK?@I)�p?E�T�E@?E��E�@K�@)

Page 150: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

M���� �/%�"�-)�y�SE?KC�AU��K��P?D@I�>�T�EkCEJP)�FEMH���U�HE��E��

�U�T�BKGZ�CB���XPSPJ�B�T�KHC�M�CB�@�EKJP��P>E�EH@?�P���EHK�AU

TE�U@B?D�@?�?P@�RAS�GBB0���GU��?D�KK�zK@TPACB>E��RAS�GBI0��U�BJK�

CB����BHP�>E�lKHK��?B��EK�P@?�E�@?�E�BCB�V?E�?E�H�PMEK\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�tU�W?E�EA@PZH�CB�T�KBJPLK@?�K��E�@�{P���

AEJ�RVA�0�HE@?�?EV�E��>?B��EK�PV�@?BK�T�B�BJ�C�B�XK�MK��s�JA�)

tU�W?E�T�KHC�M�CB�>�>���GM���BVK�BK�TEC�EJEVB�)�z�G�BN��AUC���

?EJ0�V?E��AS�G@>�I�@?E�E���ME�E�BC��E�APHPLKJ�KHB�EJ�ME@PH��@?�K

>�>�E�lKHK��NBB0���JU�ME�E�BCB�E���GM���BVK�BB�TEC�EJEVB�0�>�>��

X?���K�x�@>E�)�[E?���VKJ�AUC����G�BN�0�B�JU��K�T�BkCB�>�KHB�EJP

J�K�B^�B��K�@JEMCB�PAKHB?D�?ABCB@@>EK��P>E�EH@?�E�H�ZK���?EJ0�V?E

JU�T�KHC�M�CB)��?E�ZK�>�@�K?@I�T�EACKJ�lKHK��CBG�NBB0�O�PGBI�?EMH�

�A@EC^?�E��K�AUC��>�W?EJP�ME?E��)�|E�TE?EJ�JU��KkBCB�H�BM�?D@I

TEW?�T�E�Q�@TK����T�BG��?D�G��RAS�GBK��T���E���GU��?D@I�T�E@?E��K@�

TPACB>E�)�F@?�?B0�O�PGBI�W?BJ�PZK�EVK�D�J�EME��UBM�U��C�0��E���YAB�

CB@B�W?EME��K�TE�BJ�CB��>EMH��BG�>E�@?B?PNBB�RAS�GBB�PAB��CB�@CE��

}@E^G��I~0�}@E�K?@>�I~0�}XXXz~�B�?)H)�Q�W?E0�l�>?BVK@>B0�EG��V�CE0

V?E��@I�TEC�E?��ME@PH��@?�K��E���C�@?B�TE>�0����W?EJ�T�EJKZP?EV�EJ

W?�TK0�E@?�K?@I�G��zK@TPACB>E��O�PGBI)�u@?K@?�K��E0����W?EJ��KCDGI

AUCE�E@?����CB��?D@I0�B�JU�@EAB��CB@D�T�EHECZ�?D�TK�KME�E�U0�V?E�

AU�T�B�?B�>�EALKJP��U�EHP�B�P�BHK?D0�lKHK��NBI�CB�W?E�BCB�V?E�?E

H�PMEK0��E���C^AEJ�@CPV�K���AE?�?D�����J>�S�EALKME�^�BHBVK@>EME

TECI)�F�>��KCB�@KAI0�@>�ZKJ0�>�UJ@>BK�?�?��U�@�P>��B�N�JB\�]�B

�@KMH��@?��BCB�@K�DKG�UK��ET�E@U0��E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�TEHHK�ZB��CB

n>��B�P�T�E?B��tE@>�U�B��Kk�CB�@�EB��ET�E@U�����J>�S�P>��B�@>E�

ME�^�BHBVK@>EME�TECI�B�?K��B?E�B�CD�E��NKCE@?�E@?B�n>��B�U)

�� ������/%!��-8�R�K@CB0�HETP@?BJ0��Z��I�]@K?BI�B�RHZ��BI��K

@EMC�@I?@I����?�>E��@?�?P@0�?EMH��V?E��U�T�KHCEZB?K\�[U�@>�G�CB0

V?E�APHK?��E�@K�@0�K@CB��Z��I�]@K?BI�Q�ME@PH��@?�E0���XK�K���I

�K?0��E��KHD�XK�K���I�]@K?BI�@VB?�K?@I�ME@PH��@?�K��UJ�EA��GE���

�BKJ���@E@?��K�zE@@BB\�u@CB�RHZ��BI�B��Z��I�]@K?BI��K�@EMC�@I?�

@I0�K@CB�H�PMBK��KMBE�U�O�PGBB0�>E?E�UJ��U�H�K?K���?E�EJ�U���KMB�

E��CD�U��@?�?P@0��H�PM�G�SE?I?�TEAECDkK0�?EMH��>�>P^�JEHKCD��U�BJ

T�KHCEZB?K0��K���@@UTCK?@I�CB�W?E��@K\

Page 151: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�FE�KV�E0��@I>�I��KlE�J��V�K��?��ET�@�E@�?IJB)��?E�>�@�K?@I�RHZ��BB0�?E�E���T�B�IC��@�E^��E�P^�>E�@?B?P�

NB^�B�TE�W?E��>E�@?B?PNBB�T�BG��K?�@KAI�V�@?D^�O�PGBB)�[�RHZ��

�BB��K�@?EB?�T�EACKJ���USEH��BG�@E@?����O�PGBB)�[E�TK��US0�BS�TE�

CB?BVK@>EK��P>E�EH@?�E���W?EJ��K�G�B�?K�K@E���E0�P��KME�H�PMBK�T�E�

ACKJU0��E��?E�US0�?�J�T�E@?E��K?�BHK�0��HZ��NU��K�T�KH@?��CI^?

@KAI���K�O�PGBB�Q�B�A�?PJ@>EK���@KCK�BK0�B���@KCK�BK��@K��RHZ��

�BB)�Y�J��K���W?EJ�T�EACKJ�)��HK�?BlB>�NBI��HZ��NK��Q�W?E�?E0�V?E

E�B�I�CI^?@I�M�PGB��JB)���@?D�BG��BS�@VB?�K?�@KAI�?�>BJB�ZK�EAU>�

�E�K��UJB�M�PGB��JB0�>�>�BJK�K?B�NU0�MP�B�NU0�>�SK?B�NU0�H�P�

M�I�V�@?D�@VB?�K?0�V?E�E�B�AECKK���?E�EJ�U0��E�M�PGB�U)�]�B�JP�

@PCDJ��K0��E��K��USEHI?�G����J>B�M�PGB�@>E��BHK�?BV�E@?B)

�?E�>�@�K?@I��Z�E��]@K?BB�Q�H�0�?�J�APHP?�ET�KHKCK��UK�T�E�

ACKJU0��E�?�J��K?�?�>EME�E?VPZHK�BI�JKZHP�M�PGB��JB�B�E@K?B���

JB0�>�>EK�K@?D�@K�V�@�JKZHP�M�PGB��JB�B��AS�G�JB)�[�>E�NK�>E�NE�0

}@�EAEH��I�W>E�EJBVK@>�I�GE��~�Q��U�E>���p�M�K?B0����M���BNK�@

�Z�E��]@K?BK��Q���AE?�K?0�B�EAK�@?E�E�U�EVK�D�HE�ECD�U)�8m�>?B�

VK@>B��KlE�J�CD��I�?�>�I�EllkE���I�GE��0�W?BJ�ZB�P?�B�M�PGB�U0

B�E@K?B�U):�y��K�HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E�APHK?��KT�KEHECBJE��T�EACKJE�)

[EEALK��B>?E��K�@?��B?����EHB��P�E�K�D�T�EACKJU��Z�E��]@K?BB

B�RAS�GBB)

�������!"�#�-8�u@CB�AU�JU��JK@?K�EA@PHBCB�W?E?��ET�E@0�JEZK?0EA@PZHK�BK�TEkCE�AU�@E�@KJ�TE�H�PMEJP)�u@?D�@JU@C�TEHPJ�?D�EA

W?EJ)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�p?E�PZK�H�PME���ET�E@)�?E�>�@�K?@I�qZ���SK?BB0���T�B�NBTK��ET�E@�@?EB?�?�>��E���BCB

E@?�K?@I���@E@?��K�X�JNSK�qZ���SK?B0�?)K)�?E��AECDkE���HJB�B@?���

?B��E��KHB�BNU0�>E?E��I�@K�V�@�@PLK@?�PK?�HK�l�>?E0�BCB��UHKCI�

K?@I���E?HKCD�P^��HJB�B@?��?B��P^�KHB�BNP0��E�E�T�B@EKHB�K�BB

qZ���SK?BB�>�R�JK�BB�BCB�E��KG��B@BJE@?B�qZ���SK?BB��KVD��K

BHK?0�W?E��K����TE�K@?>K�H�I)�]�?EJ0�V?E�APHK?�VK�KG�3-�CK?0�I�ME�E�B?D

�K�JEMP�Q�JU�@K�V�@��Kk�KJ�@KMEH�Ik�BK�T�EACKJU0��Kk�KJUK��

EAEG�BJEJ�APHPLKJ)�y�G��>EJ�@�T�EACKJE��qZ���SK?BB�B���TE@CK�

H�KK���KJI�?�J�AU��C0��K� ?�>�E@?�E�?�J�@?EB?��ET�E@)�[ET�E@��E

Page 152: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

J�EMEJ�@?EB?�BG�G��?EME0�V?E�M�PGB�@>�I�>E��PJTB�E�����I�@B@?KJ�

JKk�K?��E�J�CD�E��B�?KM��NBB��E�J�CD�US���JI�0�M��ZH���O�PGBB0

TE?EJP�V?E�BJ�JKk�^?�T�EH���?D�@�E^�T�EHP>NB^���YABCB@B0�TE?E�

JP�V?E�?�J�@?ECD>E�TECBNK�@>BS�TE@?E��B�?)H)�Y�J�T�EACKJ���Kk�KJ�

TP?KJ�HKJE>��?BG�NBB)�tU�T�KHC�M�KJ��KMBE��CBG�NB^�O�PGBB0�@E�

GH��BK��KMBE��CD�US�T��C�JK�?E�0�MHK�E�B�JEMCB�AU�@KAI��K�CBGE�

��?D)�]�B�AUCB�AU�T�KH@?��CK�U����KMBE��CD�US�T���B?KCD@?��S)

Y)K)�W?E�EALBK�TEHSEHU��HJB�B@?��?B��E�?K��B?E�B�CD�E���KlE��

JU�B�EALK���KlE�JU)

!.� �M"��8�n�JK�I�?�>EME�ZK�TC�����ET�E@)�[�T�B�NBTK0�AUCB�T�KH�@?��CK�U��@K��EGJEZ�UK�?KE�K?BVK@>BK����B��?U���G�B?BI�@EAU?B�)

uHB�@?�K��U�0����JE���GMCIH0����B��?�@EAU?B�0�>E?E�U���K���@@J�?�

�B��C@I�8�EGJEZ�E0���JK�K��E:�Q�W?E��EK��U�����B��?��KkK�BI�T�E�

ACKJU0�SE?I0�@>�ZKJ�>�T�BJK�P0�?�K?B��@NK���B��MHK�?E�>�>�?E�T�KH�

TEC�M�K?�B�?�>E�����B��?���G�B?BI�@EAU?B�)��.( � �������q�0��KkK�

�BK0�@>�ZKJ0��AS�G@>E��T�EACKJU��EK��UJ�TP?KJ)�qPS�HKJE>��?BG��

NBB\�tU�?E��@K�T�K>��@�E�TE�BJ�KJ0�V?E��KG��B@BJE�E?�?EME0�HK�

JE>��?BV���@?�����BCB��KHKJE>��?BV��0�E����K�E?>�GU��K?@I�E?��K�

HK�BI��EK��US�HK�@?�B�0�TEW?EJP�JU��K�JEZKJ�B@>C^V�?D��KkK�BK

T�EACKJU�BJK��E�?�>BJ�TP?KJ)�|�@>ECD>E��U�HETP@>�K?K��EGJEZ�

�E@?D��KkK�BI�T�EACKJU�NKCE@?�E@?B�O�PGBB�@�TEJELD^��EK��US

HK�@?�B�\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�[EGJEZ�E@?D��EK��US�HK�@?�B��T�B@P?@?�P�K?�B���TK��EJ0�B��E��?E�EJ0�B0���JK�DkK��@?KTK�B0���?�K?DKJ����B���

?K)�[EGDJKJ�SPHkP^��K�@B^�>BT�@>EME����B��?�)�|U�Kk�II�@B?P��

NBI�@�J��TE�@KAK0�K@?K@?�K��E0��K�EM��ZH�K?���@�E?��EK��US�HK�@?�B�0

�E�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�TE�W?EJP�@NK���B^�TEC�EJ�@k?�A�E���E��U��K

@E@?EB?@I0�?�>�>�>�P�M�PGB�@>EME�ME@PH��@?����K?��B�?�>BS�@�KH@?�0

�B�?�>EME�ZKC��BI�Q��E��EK��UK�@?EC>�E�K�BI�AUCB�B0�JEZK?0�KLK

APHP?)�=�B�@ES���K�BB�?�>E��@B?P�NBB��EK��UK�ETK��NBB�@?��P?�V��

@?D^�T�KH�UAE��E��TECB?BVK@>E��>�JT��BB)

�?E�>�@�K?@I��?E�EME����B��?�0�?E0�K@CB�O�PGBI�@?��K?�V�@?D^

�E@@B�@>EME�T�E@?���@?��)�����RAS�GBB����HP?@I�C^HB0�>E?E�UK��K

G�SE?I?��K��P?D@I�>�?E��BG�K@?�E��BK���SBVK@>E��?�B�HK�tE@>���Q

Page 153: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

YABCB@B�Q�XPSPJB0�?EMH��I��K�B@>C^V�^�?�>E���EGJEZ�E@?B�Q��K�B@�

>C^V�^0�V?E��P@@>E�M�PGB�@>BJ��EK��UJ�TEH��GHKCK�BIJ�APHP?�E>��

GU��?D�@ET�E?B�CK�BK��AS�G@>BK�E?�IHU)

�?E�>�@�K?@I�?�K?DKME����B��?�0�@�TECEZB?KCD�UJ�B@SEHEJ�Q�?�J

O�PGBI�E?>�GU��K?@I�E?��EK��EME��KkK�BI0��E�K@CB��@K�ZK��@TEJ�B?D

T�ENK@@U0�>E?E�UK�@K�V�@�BHP?����ME@C��BB�TE@CK�TEAKHU�FEk?P�

�BNU0�H��B�{�T�H���EHK�AU��K�EVK�D�@K�V�@�G�LBL�K?�FE@E�E�B��EEA�

LK��CA��NK�)))�|E�K@CB���?�K?DKJ����B��?K�O�PGBI��KkB?�T�BJK�B?D

@BCP0�HPJ�^0�W?E�APHK?�AECDkE��EkBA>E�)�tEZK?0�APHK?�PM�EG��T�B�

JK�K�BI�@BCU0��E�T�BJK�K�BI�@BCU0�@>E�KK��@KME0��K�APHK?0���K@CB

�@K�?�>B�APHK?0�?E��B>�>EME��EK��EME��KkK�BI�W?E��T�EACKJU��K?)

qETP@?BJ0�O�PGBI�@JEMC��TEAKHB?D���>�>E��?E��E��K�@�RAS�GBK��Q

M�PGB�E��AS�G@>P^�T�EACKJP� W?E��B>�>��K��Kk�K?�� APHK?� @BCD�EK

�AS�G@>EK�H�BZK�BK�@ET�E?B�CK�BI0�B�M�PGB�@>BK��E�@>��?�J��K�AP�

HP?�>E�?�ECB�E��?D�@B?P�NB^)�p?E0�TE�@P?B0�EG��V�K?�E?>�G�O�PGBB�E?

HKJE>��?BVK@>EME���G�B?BI)��?E�SE�EkKK0�?E�@�IG��E�@��K�CD�UJ��K�

kK�BKJ�T�EACKJU0���@?�KJCK�BK�>��EK��EJP��KkK�B^�T�EACKJ��K

T�B�EHB?�>�BS��KkK�B^0�E?�W?EME�TE@?��H�^?�>�>�M�PGB�U0�?�>�B��A�

S�GU)

�� ������/%!��-8�Y�K?B�����B��?�P���@�Q�W?E�O�PGBI�AKG�sK���H�

��HGK�B��E�J�CD�EK�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�ME@PH��@?�E0�I�?�>�TE�IC0�T�E�

G�T�H�E��E�BK�?�NBB0�P@CE��E�@>�ZKJ)�R�HETP@>�K?K�CB��U��E��?E�

�EJ����B��?K0�V?E�O�PGBI�E@?�K?@I��KG��B@BJUJ�ME@PH��@?�EJ0��E�@

ET�KHKCK��E���E@@B�@>E��E�BK�?�NBK�\�y�?�>�TE�IC0��U�BJKK?K��

�BHP0�V?E�O�PGBI��SEHB?���@E@?���zE@@BB0���HETP@>�K?K�CB��U0�V?E�O�P�

GBI�E@?�K?@I��KG��B@BJUJ�ME@PH��@?�EJ0��E�@��E@@B�@>E��E�BK�?��

NBK�0�B�PZK���W?BS���J>�S��E@@EGH�K?@I�?��ZK�?�B�H�0�E�>E?E�E���U

ME�E�B?K\

���?E�E���ET�E@)�[�>�>EJ�BG���kBS����B��?E��8BS�JEMP?�AU?D

KLK�HK@I?>B0��U0����K��E0�@�JUK�MC���UK�@PJJB�E��CB:0���>�>EJ�BG

��kBS����B��?E��CPVkK��@KME0������k��GMCIH0�T�KH@?��CK�E��KkK�BK

T�EACKJU�AKZK�NK�\�����>�>EJ�EAwKJK\�[E?��U�ME�E�BCB�E�59�J�MEHK0

E�HE>PJK�?K0�@�IG���EJ�@��EG���LK�BKJ�>�>E��?E�V�@?B�AKZK�NK�)

F�>��U�@KAK�T�KH@?��CIK?K�P�KMPCB�E���BK�W?E��T�EACKJU\�[�TK��

�EJ����B��?K�I@�E0���TI?EJ�?EZK�T�BJK��E�I@�E0����E��?E�EJ0�?�K�

Page 154: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

?DKJ�B�VK?�K�?EJ�Q�MHK�CPVkK��@KME0�B�MPJ���KK0�B�WllK>?B��KK0�T�KH�

@?��CIK?@I��KkK�BK�T�EACKJU�B�>�>BJ�TP?KJ\�xPHP?�CB��EG���LK�U

�@K�AKZK�NU0�ZKC�^LBK�W?EME0�BCB�?ECD>E�V�@?D�Q�@>�ZKJ0�?�0�>E?E�

��I��K�T�B�BJ�C��PV�@?BI���AEK�US�HK�@?�BIS\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8��?E�>�@�K?@I�@E^G��@�zE@@BK�0�?KE�K?BVK@�>B�I��K�B@>C^V�^0�V?E�G��HK@I?D�TI?��HN�?D�CK?�zE@@BI0�JEZK?�AU?D0

@?��K?��E�J�CD�UJ�HKJE>��?BVK@>BJ�ME@PH��@?�EJ0� G��VB?KCD�E�

V�@?D^�K��E��?C��?BVK@>EME�T�E@?���@?��)�qKJE>��?BG�NB^�zE@@BB

AKG��SEZHK�BI���K��E��?C��?BVK@>EK�T�E@?���@?�E�I�@KAK��K�T�KH�

@?��CI^)�u@CB�zE@@BI�@?��K?�?�>BJ�ZK�{�T�HEJ0�>�>0�@>�ZKJ)))�Q��P0

T�KH@?��BJ�@KAK��{�T�H��I�u��ET�0�yTE�BI0�JKZHP��BJB�zE@@BI0�?�J

XEKHB�K��UK�s?�?U0�B�KLK�J�EME����GKJ�EJ�k��K�HKJE>��?BVK@�

>BS�ME@PH��@?�0���?EJ�VB@CK�B���^Z�EJ�TECPk��BB�Q�?EMH��zE@@BI

APHK?��K����EH�E��>�>E���BAPHD�@?E�E�K0���APHK?�@TE@EA@?�E��?D�@T���

�KHCB�EJP�P�KMPCB�E���B^�T�EACKJU)�[U�EVK�D�EABHKCB@D����?E0

V?E�I�PTE?�KABC�@CE�E�}HECMEZB?KCB~0��E�V?EAU�HEZB?D�HE�HKJE>���

?BG�NBB�zE@@BB0� �PZ�E�AU?D� KLK�AECDkBJB�HECMEZB?KCIJB)�R��

�U�Kk�K��@B?P�NBB0�TE>��zE@@BI��KHK?��K���kB@?@>P^�TECB?B>P0

E����K�I�CIK?@I�M����?EJ�@?�ABCD�E@?B����F��>�GK�Q���EAE�E?0�@TE�

@EA@?�PK?�@ES���K�B^�EV�ME����T�IZK��E@?B�����Z�EJ�F��>�GK�B

��@T���CIK?@I�@�C^HDJB����XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK)

�?E�>�@�K?@I�AKZK�NK�)�y�@VB?�^0�V?E��@K�AKZK�NU�BJK^?�T���

�E�����EG���LK�BK)�7���AKZK�NU�BJK^?�T���E0�B�I��K�@EMC�@K��@

?KJ�@EMC�kK�BKJ0�MHK�@>�G��E��}>�EJK�?KS0�>E?E�UK~�B��UHKCIK?@I

M�PTT�0�>E?E��I�T�B�BJ�C��PV�@?BK����E��K)�y�@VB?�^0�V?E�>�EJK

?EME0� V?E� �@K� AKZK�NU�BJK^?�T���E�����EG���LK�BK0� E�B�BJK^?

T���E�B����TECB?BVK@>BK�T�������O�PGBB)�[U�EM���BVK�U���M��Z�

H��@>BS�T����S0��U��K�T�B�BJ�K?K�PV�@?BI����UAE��S0�B�I�HPJ�^0

V?E���@E��KJK��E��O�PGBB���kB�T�����PLKJCK�U)�=EW?EJP�J�K�>��

ZK?@I0�V?E�AKZK�NU�HECZ�U�TECPVB?D�T���E�AU?D�TEC�ET����UJB

M��ZH���JB�O�PGBB0��K�HEZBH�I@D0�TE>���KkB?@I��ET�E@�BS��EG����

LK�BI���RAS�GB^)�YK�AKZK�NU0�>E?E�UK�G�SE?I?�EAP@?�EB?D@I���H�P�

MBS�V�@?IS�O�PGBB�B�?�J�B�E@?�?D@I0�K@?K@?�K��E0�BJK^?����W?E�T���

�E)����@KJ���J�I@�E0�V?E�TE�J�EMBJ�T�BVB��J��K��@K�@?E�T�ENK�?E�

AKZK�NK���K��P?@I���RAS�GB^0��E�G��VB?KCD��I�BS�V�@?D�8HPJ�^0

Page 155: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

AECDk�I�V�@?D:�?PH���K��K?@I0�K@CB�@B?P�NBI�APHK?�?EJP�@TE@EA@?�E�

��?D)�u@CB��P@@>BK�B�M�PGB�U�G�@?��I?�RAS�GB^���E�D��E�?B���?P�ZK

?�B�HP���>�VK@?�K��BZ�KME0�?�K?DKME�VCK��0�?E�B�?EMH���EG���LK�BK

AKZK�NK��APHK?��K�AKG�T�EACKJ�B�BS�E?�EkK�BI�@��AS�G�JB�APHP?

?EZK���?I�P?UJB)���W?E�H�CK>E��K��KkK�BK�T�EACKJU)�p?E0���EAE�

�E?0�TE�@P?B0�P@PMPAB?�T�EACKJP)�p?E�?E�ZK�@�JEK0�V?E�AUCE���@E�K?�

@>EK���KJI)�[�@E�K?@>EK���KJI�W?��T�EACKJ��AUC��G�Z�?�0�AUCB�?E�

?�CB?���UK�B�@?B?P?U0�>E?E�UK��K�H���CB��EGJEZ�E@?B��U��GB?D�

@I0���TE@CK�@�I?BI�W?BS�B�@?B?P?E��JU�T�BkCB�>�>E�lCB>?P)�8|K

EAIG�?KCD�E���HE�AUCE�T�BSEHB?D�>�>E�lCB>?P0��E�T�E?B�E@?EI�BK

@KAI�TE>�G�CE):

��������%�"�8�|K�HETP@>�K?K�CB��U�KLK�EH�EME�@NK���BI�Q�HETP@�

?BJ0�TETU?>B�E??E�ZK�BI�O�CD@>EME����E���8��JEZK?�AU?D0�B�AECKK

J�@k?�A�E��?K��B?E�BB:�B�P@?��E�CK�BI�?�J�M�PGB�@>E���HJB�B@?�

��NBB0�V?E�JEZK?�T�B�K@?B�>���GHKCP�RAS�GBB\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�p?E���GU��K?@I�}@NK���BKJ�o�B�H����~0�B>���G��AE?>K�W?EME�@NK���BI�T�BV�@?�U�JU�@�=��?E�)���� � ������

p?E�EHB��BG�@NK���BK��B�TEHSEHE��zK@TPACB>��@>E��T��?BB�57�EME

MEH���M�PGB�U�B��AS�GU��K@TE@EA�U�ZB?D��JK@?K0�T�EACKJ�ME��GHE

AECDkK0�VKJ�?EVK>�@ET�B>E@�E�K�BI0�TEW?EJP�M�PGB�U�B��AS�GU���@�

SEHI?@I�B�BHK?���GHKC)�qCI�O�PGBB�JU�T�KHCEZBCB�ZB��U��>P@E>

?K��B?E�BB0���>�>E��BJK��E�Q�W?E�T�KHJK?�TK�KME�E�E�)�[�W?EJ�@CP�

V�K�;7���AKZK�NK���EG���L�^?@I���@�EB�HEJ�0���T�IJEJ�@JU@CK�W?E�

ME�@CE��0��E�HCI�RAS�GBB�W?E�EG��V�K?��KG��B@BJE@?D�G��@VK?�?K��B�

?E�BB�Q��KG��B@BJE@?D���� G��VB?KCD�E�JK�DkK�� ?K��B?E�BB0� VKJ

�U�Kk�II)�R�W?E�EG��V�K?0�V?E�O�PGBI�B�RAS�GBI��K�APHP?�H�PZK@?�K��

�UJB����EH�JB�B�@?����JB��K�?ECD>E���EAEG�BJEJ�APHPLKJ)))�y�AU

�K�SE?KC0�V?EAU�W?E�AUC��K�CB@?BV�U��@NK���B�)

��������%�"�8�R�O�PGBI�T�BG��K?�?�>EK\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�q�0�W?E�EG��V�K?�T�BG���BK�O�PGBK��?�>E�RAS�GBB�Q�EH��>E�AKG�E@EAE����HE@?B)

Page 156: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

��������%�"�8�o�B�H�����W?EME��K�EAKL�C)�]��EAKL�C0�V?E�E��

APHK?���@E@?��K�O�PGBB)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�[�W?E����kK��>E�NKTNBB��K���TB@��E�T�I�

JE0�V?E�?��V�@?D0�}�AS�G@>�I�RAS�GBI~�Q�E���E?HKCD��I0��E�W?E�TEH���

GPJK��K?@I)

��������%�"�8�tU�TE�ICB���k���JK>)

��������%����S,���8�=P@?D�W?E�APHK?�}���B��?EJ�o�B�H����~0��EALKK�ME@PH��@?�E�APHK?�}���B��?EJ�xK�HGK�Bk�BCB~)�t�K�W?E��U�

MEH�E��EA�����B��?U�Q���kB)

��������%�"�8�=�>?�@?�ABCD�E@?B��K�PTEJB��K?���k����B��?)

d!0�!$8�|K�HETP@>�K?K�CB��U�B�?�>E���EGJEZ�U��@NK���B����TE@?�kK���H��HGK�@>B��TK�BEH�Q��K���G�B?BK�HKJE>��?BVK@>BS�B�@?B?P�

?E�0�����?E�B?��BG�NBI�@?���U�B�ZK@?>B���KZBJ0�TE@?�EK��U���K���

AECDkK�B@?@>E��E@�E�K0������}�E�US�T���US~�B�?)T)\�[�EALKJ0�>��

>E��?E����B��?��EG���?��>���?E�B?��BGJP�Q�JEZK?�AU?D0�VBCB�@>B�

���B��?\

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�y�HPJ�^0�W?E�T�B�KCE�AU�O�PGB^�>�>ECC�T�@P)�p?EME�I�TEV?B��K�HETP@>�^)�y�HPJ�^0�P�O�PGBB��K?��K@P�@E����?E�

�B?��BGJ�)�R���G�BS��K?0�JEZK?0����>�>BS�?E��UAE��S�>?E�?E�B��UBM�

��K?0��E�V?EAU�W?E�T�EHCBCE@D�AECDkK��K@>ECD>BS�CK?0�H�ZK��K@>ECD�

>BS�JK@INK��Q��K?0�?�>P^�O�PGB^�I��K��BZP)

��,� ��.�S,���8�y�SE?KC�AU�P?EV�B?D�TI?U�0� }AK�BC^>@>B�~���B��?)�=E�JEKJP0����ECB�xKCDMBB�?�J�TECPV�K?@I�RAS�GBI0�TE?EJP

V?E�TE@CK��EG���LK�BI�AKZK�NK��?P�JEHKCD�x�P�E�FETTB?K�@��Q�?)K)

JEHKCD�E?�EkK�B��M�PGB��B��AS�GNK��Q���HE�APHK?�E@PLK@?�CI?D�PZK

��RAS�GBB)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8��G�W?�BVK@>B�TK@?�E��RAS�GBB�TECPVB?DTC^��CB@?BVK@>EK�HKJE>��?BVK@>EK�EALK@?�E�Q�W?E�EVK�D�@K�DKG��I

Page 157: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

T�EACKJ�0�H�ZK�T�B�?�>BS�?KTCBV�US�P@CE�BIS)�=E�AKCDMB�@>EJP�BCB

TE�H�PMEJP�>�>EJP�CBAE����B��?P�W?E�APHK?�Q�W?E�T�EACKJ����G�KkB�

J�I0�T�B�P@CE�BB�T�KH���B?KCD�EME���G�KkK�BI)))

�� ��� ���R�S���8�y�SE?KC��AU�@>�G�?D��K@>ECD>E�@CE��E�?EJ0�V?E@T��kB��C�YK�MBG�Q�E��Z�E��]@K?BB)�|KJ�EME�G�TEGH�CU��>EJJK��

?��B�0��E�I�SE?KC��AU�>EK�V?E�HEA��B?D�>�?EJP0�V?E�@>�G�C�q�?E�Q�TE�

VKJP��KEHB��>E�E�@?��B?@I��ET�E@�RAS�GBB�B��Z�E��]@K?BB)�]H�

�E��BG�T�BVB��I�CIK?@I�?E0�V?E�CBHK�U��Z�E��]@K?BB�EVK�D�V�@?E

ME�E�I?�E�T����S�E@K?B�0�>E?E�UK�ZBCB���E@?�CD�E��O�PGBB0�?)K)�HCI

�BS�T�EACKJE��I�CIK?@I��K�?ECD>E�?��?K��B?E�BI0�>E?E��I�@KMEH�I

��GU��K?@I��Z�E��]@K?BK�0��E�B�BJPLK@?�E0�>E?E�EK�BJ�T�B��HCK�

Z�CE�G��T�KHKC�JB��Z�E��]@K?BB)�=�EACKJ��E@K?B����E@?�CD�E�

O�PGBB�?�>�I�E@?��I0�V?E�E�B�E?�W?EME��K�JEMP?�P�?B�B�@�JB�EA�W?EJ

�@����KJI�ME�E�I?)

��������%�"�8�]�B�?�KAP^?�>EJTK�@�NBB\

�� ��� ���R�S���8�]�B�?�KAP^?�TEC�E��>EJTK�@�NBB�B��EG����LK�BI���?K�JK@?�0�MHK�ZBCB0�B�HCI���@�W?E�>EGU�D��G��VB?0�W?B�C^HB

@VB?�^?�@KAI�V�@?D^�?E��@?���U0�MHK�E�B�?EMH��ZBCB)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�y�H�J�@T���>P��64�?U@IV�E@K?B��ZBCB������?E�EJ�E��EAC�@?B���@E�K?@>EK���KJI0�.--�?U@IV�Q��E���P?�K��BS��K�

MBE��S�O�PGBB)���E�B��C�HKCB�M�PGB�@>BJ�IGU>EJ0�AUCB�EVK�D�B��

?KM�B�E���U0�TEW?EJP�W?��T�EACKJ��I�CIK?@I�l�>?E�EJ�B�?KM��NBB)

�� ��� ���R�S���8�YE?�l�>?0�V?E�J�EMBK�BG�W?BS�E@K?B�0�>E?E�UKZBCB���E@?�CD�E��O�PGBB0�@K�V�@��EGAPZH�^?�HKC������kBS�@PH�S�Q�TE

TE�EHP�ZBCBL��B�?)H)�Q�@�J�TE�@KAK�TE>�G�?KCK��B�EG��V�K?0�V?E�E�B

@VB?�^?�@KAI�?�>E��ZK�V�@?D^�@?���U0�>�>�B�E@?�CD�UK�KK�ZB?KCB)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�t�EMBS�BG��BS��K�EVK�D�C^AI?���XK�K��E�

]@K?BB)�t�K�V�@?E�ME�E�BCB��}�?E�W?E��U�>PCD?B�B�E��CB���?B�E@�

@B�@>BK���@?�EK�BI\�]�B�P���@�?�>BK���?B�P@@>BK0�W?B���kB�E@K?B�

�U~)

Page 158: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�"�$��!.���0$�-

���������������d� �h)d����N ���������N��W �����M���l

`

YE?0�>?E�AK�K?@I�G����G��AE?>P�>�>E��CBAE�JEHKCB0��K�JEZK?��K

G�H�?D@I��ET�E@EJ�E��EGJEZ�E@?IS�KK�E@PLK@?�CK�BI)�X�J����G���

AE?>�0���T�B�NBTK0��K�T�KH@?��CIK?�@EAE���BVKME�E@EAK��E�G�?�PH�

�B?KCD�EME)�FEJTK?K�?�UK�@TKNB�CB@?U�B�ETU?�UK�TECB?B>B0�AUCE

AU�ZKC��BK�B�P@K�HBK0�@TE@EA�U�T�KHCEZB?D���GCBV�EME��EH��T�E�

K>?U�P�KMPCB�E���BI�B�@E@PLK@?�E���BI)�[�P@CE�BIS�RAS�GBB��@?�K?

T�B� W?EJ��KJB�PKJU���ET�E@�E� �EGJEZ�E@?B��K�CBG�NBB�C^AEME

T�EK>?��B�H�ZK�E�@EGH��BB�@�JE��?�>E���EGJEZ�E@?B)�|KEASEHBJE

@TC��B�E��?D���JEV�UK�P@CE�BI�P�KMPCB�E���BI0����K�?ECD>E�@EMC��

@B?KCD�UK�TP�>?U)�XEGH�?D�@�JB�P@CE�BI0�T�B�>E?E�US�T�EK>?B�E�

���BK�B�JEHKCB�E���BK�BJKCB�AU�@JU@C0�V?E�E@EAK��E�?�PH�E�T�B

S�E@K�B��K@?�ABCD�E@?B0�@PLK@?�P^LBS����KMBE�K)�|PZ���E@EA�I

TECB?B>��@EGH��BI�T�BKJCKJE��JEHKCB0�>E?E��I�@?��K?�@E@?���E�

V�@?D^�TECB?B>B��G�BJEE?�EkK�B��JKZHP�O�PGBK��B�RAS�GBK�)�u@CB

W?EME��K�T�EBGE�HK?0�C^AE��T�EK>?�P�KMPCB�E���BI�B�@E@PLK@?�E���

�BI0�>KJ�AU�E���B�AUC�T�KHCEZK�0�H�ZK�K@CB�E��APHK?�E?�KV�?D��PZ�

H�J�B�TE?�KA�E@?IJ�EAKBS�@?E�E�0�JEZK?�E>�G�?D@I��K�AECKK�VKJ�EVK�

�KH�E��P?ETBK�)

XEGH��BK�P@CE�B��B���JEV�US�>E�@?�P>NB�0�T�BH�^LBS�@JU@C

��AE?K���H�>E�>�K?�UJB�JEHKCIJB�@E@PLK@?�E���BI�8�K�BJKK?�G���

VK�BI�T�EJKZP?EV�UJB�BCB�E>E�V�?KCD�UJB:0�JEZ�E�@�IG�?D�@�?KJ0

V?E����{�T�HK���GU��^?�������$�" ����� ��8TE@?�EK�BK�JE?B��NBB:)

u@?D�ET�KHKCK��U��lBCE@El@>B��@JU@C���W?E��@�IGB)�[E@?EV�EK�@E�

G���BK�8��RAS�GBI0�V?EAU�?�J��B�ME�E�BCB0�>�>��T�EVKJ0�B�O�PGBI0�Q

[E@?E>:�I�CIK?@I�AECKK�B�l��?BCD�UJ�B�B�K�?�UJ0�VKJ�G�T�H�EK0�B

V�@?E�HKJE�@?�B�PK?��K@TE@EA�E@?D�T�KH@?��B?D0� V?E� �>?B��E@?D

VKCE�K>��JEZK?�AU?D���T���CK����K�?ECD>E������Kk�B��JB�0��E�B���

��P?�K��B�)�y�BJK^����BHP��K�@�JETEG���BK0���BJK��E�@�JETE@?�E�

K�BK0�@?�EB?KCD@?�E�B�@EGBH��BK0�H�ZK�K@CB�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�HCI�W?EME

Page 159: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�K?��B>�>BS�T�KHTE@UCE>)�qCI�?�>EME��EH��@EG���BI�JE?B��NBI�BCB

K@?D0�BCB�KK��K?0�TEHEA�E�?EJP0�>�>�B�VP�@?�E�Q�BCB�E�E�K@?D0�BCB�KME

�K?0�K@CB�E�E�K@?D�Q�?E�@��BJ��BVKME��K�TEHKC�KkD0�K@CB�KME��K?0�?E�@

W?BJ�?�>ZK��BVKME��K�TEHKC�KkD)�=EW?EJP�TE@?�EK�BK�JE?B��NBB0

>�>�B��E@TB?��BK�VP�@?��T�B��HCKZB?0�T�KZHK��@KME0�K��ETK�@>E�

NB�BCBG�NBB�B���AE?P���H�T�EK>?�JB�B�JEHKCIJB�@E@PLK@?�E���BI0

��GJUkCK�BI���H�P@CE�BIJB�BS�E@PLK@?�CK�BI0�I���@@J�?�B��^�>�>

EHB��BG�@TE@EAE��K��ETKBG�NBB)

XEGH��BK���JEV�US�>E�@?�P>NB��B�P@CE�B�0�?E�K@?D��K�T�E@?E

T�EK>?B�E���BK�B�JEHKCB�E���BK0��E��#����%����G��AE?>B�B�E@PLK�

@?�CK�BI�?E��BCB�B�E��JEHKCB0�T�KH@?��CIK?@I�G�H�VK��TK��E@?KTK��

�E����Z�E@?B)�|��@KJB���K���x�H�s��CDA�SK0���OK�J��BB0����EIA�K

,---�MEH�0�PV�@?�B>B�E?��AS�G@>E��B�M�PGB�@>E��@?E�E��@?EC>�PCB@D

@�T�EACKJE����JEV�US�P@CE�B�)��G�T�KHCEZK��US�E�M��BG�?E��JB

>E�lK�K�NBB�?KJ�HCI�EA@PZHK�BI�Q�ET�KHKCK�BK�TECB?BVK@>EME�@?��

?P@�0�T�EACKJ��AKZK�NK��B�W>E�EJBVK@>BK�@��>NBB0�AUCB��UA���U

W>E�EJBVK@>BK�@��>NBB)�n�>�ZHEME�BG�PV�@?�B>E��AUCB0��K�EI?�E0

@�EB�T�BVB�U0�HCI�?�>EME��UAE��)�y�E@?��E�BC@I����W?E��?KJK�TE?E�

JP0�V?E�W>E�EJBVK@>BK�@��>NBB�T�KH@?��CICB@D�J�K�TEAEV�UJ�I�CK�

�BKJ���M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EJ�>E�lCB>?K�B�TE?EJP���BAECKK�CKM>E�P@?���

�BJUJ)�[�SEHK�EA@PZHK�BI�EA���PZBCE@D0�EH��>E0�V?E��@K��K�?�>

T�E@?E0�V?E�@�I?BK�@��>NB��I�CIK?@I�H�CK>E��K�EH�E��GE�UJ��>?EJ0

V?E�W?E�T�ENK@@0�?E�K@?D��PZ���BJK��E�TECB?B>��@�I?BI�@��>NB�0�?E

K@?D��KEASEHBJE�ET�KHKCK�BK���JEV�US�P@CE�B�0�HKC�^LBS�@�I?BK

@��>NB���K�CD�E@?D^)

[JK@?E�?EME0�V?EAU�TE@?EI��E�BJK?D����BHP�W?B���JEV�UK�P@CE�

�BI0�PV�@?�B>B�HB@>P@@BB�TE@?KTK��E�E��BS�G�AUCB�B�PH��BCB@D�B@�

>C^VB?KCD�E���V�@?�UK��ET�E@U0�>E?E�UK���K�EALKME0�AECKK�kB�E�

>EME�>E�?K>@?�0�TE?K�ICB��@I>B��@JU@C�B�T��>?BVK@>B�G��KCB���?P�

TB>0��USEH�BG�>E?E�EME�JEZ�E�AUCE����?B�?ECD>E��K��P�kB@D�BCB0

?EV�KK0�TE@?��B��V�@?�UK��ET�E@U���G��B@BJE@?D�E?�EALK��G�H�VB�Q

@�I?BI�@��>NB�)���?�>�APHK?��E��@KS�@CPV�IS0�MHK��K?�EALK��@?��?K�

MBB�HCI�?E��BCB�B�E��EAC�@?B)�Y�>�T�EBGEkCE�AU�B�@�C^AE��H�PME�

�UA����E��?KJE�0�K@CB���JEV�UK�P@CE�BI�AUCB�AU�T�KH��U�G�A�K�

�B^)�=EW?EJP�TEHEA�E� ?EJP0�>�>�T�B�EA@PZHK�BB� W>E�EJBVK@>BS

@��>NB��G�AUCB�E��KEASEHBJE@?B�T�BJK�K�BI�@EE?�K?@?�P^LK��TE�

Page 160: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

CB?B>B�B��B�>�VKJP��K�T�BkCB0�?�>��B�>�VKJP��K�T�BHP?�B���H�PMBS

@CPV�IS0�K@CB��K�TEG�AE?B?D@I�E�TECB?B>K�ET�KHKCK�BI�TECB?BVK@�

>EME�@?�?P@��B�E�TECB?B>K�TE�TE�EHP�T�EACKJU�AKZK�NK�)

XCKHE��?KCD�E0��KEASEHBJE�HPJ�?D�E�TECB?B>K�T�EK>?B�E���BI

B�JEHKCB�E���BI�JB��EME�@E@PLK@?�E���BI�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB)�F�?EJP

ZK�T�EACKJ�0�E�>E?E�E��GHK@D�BHK?��KVD0�I�CIK?@I�J�EME@E@?���E�)

{HK@D�T�BSEHB?@I�PVB?U��?D�B�HK�Z�?D���TECK�G�K�BI�@��GP�J�EZK�

@?�E��KLK�)�r^AE�0�>?E��EGDJK?@I�G��>E�@?�PB�E���BK�>�>E��CBAE

JEHKCB0�HECZK��APHK?0�TE��U��ZK�B^�tK��A��t�J��H�k�BCB0�)��5

"��� �#'�� ����@K�W?B��KLB0��@K�T�B�SEHILBK�EA@?EI?KCD@?���B

��@TEC�M�?D�BS���ET�KHKCK��US�T�ETE�NBIS�B�@EE?�EkK�BIS)

qE�@BS�TE���@K�T�KHCEZK�BI�TE�TE�EHP�P@?�E�@?���ME@PH��@?�K��

�E�T���E�US�E?�EkK�B��JKZHP�O�PGBK��B�RAS�GBK��B@SEHBCB0���E@�

�E��EJ0�E?��KG��B@BJUS�B@@CKHE��?KCK��BCB�M�PTT�B@@CKHE��?KCK�)

oE?I0��EGJEZ�E0�T�B�W?EJ�E�B�E?��Z�CB���?E��BCB�B�E��JK�K�CBAE

ElBNB�CD�P^�8�E��K�I��E��U@>�GU��KJP^:0�?EV>P�G�K�BI0�CBAE�?EV>P

G�K�BI�ET�KHKCK��EME�TECB?BVK@>EME�@TK>?���BCB�T��?BB�8>�>���@CP�

V�K�@�T�KHCEZK�BIJB��K@TPACB>��NK����O�PGBB:)�F�>�AU�?�J��B�AUCE0

W?E��K�JK�IK?�@P?B�HKC��B��@K0�HE�@BS�TE��T�KHT�B�BJ��kBK@I�TE�

TU?>B�T�KHCEZB?D�>�>BK��BAPHD�JEHKCB� @E@PLK@?�E���BI�JEZ�E

��@@J�?�B��?D�>�>�V�@?�UK�TETU?>B��KG��B@BJUS�B@@CKHE��?KCK�0

TE@>ECD>P��B>�>EME�I��EME�TECB?BVK@>EME�BCB�W>E�EJBVK@>EME�CEA�

AB�G���BJB��K�T�E@J�?�B��CE@D)�[��KGPCD?�?K0��K@JE?�I����G�>C^�

V��kBK@I����K>E?E�US�BG��BS�HKCD�UK�B���NBE��CD�UK�T�KHCEZK�

�BI0�E�B�?�>�B�E@?�CB@D��K�E@?�KAE����UJB)�|E�T�B�@CEZB�kBS@I

EA@?EI?KCD@?��S�?�PH�E�EZBH�?D�H�PMEME)�r^AE��T�EK>?0�T�KH@?���

CK��U��>KJ�CBAE�BG��K0�APHK?�@EHK�Z�?D���@KAK�?K�BCB�B�UK��K�UME�

HU�HCI�?E��BCB�B�E��@?E�E�U0�B�C^HB0�E?�>E?E�US�G��B@B?�T�B�I?BK

�KkK�B�0��E�>E?E�UK�@�JB�����G��AE?>K�T�EK>?��PV�@?BI��K�T�B�B�

J�CB0�K@?K@?�K��E0�EA��L�^?���BJ��BK�T�KZHK��@KME�����K�UMEH�

�UK��@TK>?U��EGJEZ�EME�@EMC�kK�BI�B�TEW?EJP�E?�K�M�^?�KME)�[�IH

CB�TEW?EJP�JEZ�E�T�KH@?��B?D�@B?P�NB^0�T�B�>E?E�E��>?E�?E���G���

AE?�K?��K>B��BHK�CD�U��T�EK>?�B�E�0�TP@?D�B�TE@CK�EA@PZHK�BI0�AP�

HK?�T�B�I?�ElBNB�CD�UJB��C�@?IJB�B����EHEJ)

XCKHE��?KCD�E0�HCI�@EGH��BI��KZBJ����BAECDkKME�AC�MET�BI?�

@?�E���BI��KEASEHBJE0�V?EAU���T�ENK@@K���G��AE?>B�T�EK>?E��ME@P�

Page 161: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

H��@?�K��E�T���E�US�E?�EkK�B��T�B�BJ�CB�PV�@?BK��K�?ECD>E�@TK�

NB�CB@?U0�?KS�ECEMB0�PVK�UK0��E�B�?K0�E?�>EME�G��B@B?�T�B�I?BK��K�

kK�B��Q�TECB?B>B0�T�KH@?��B?KCB�ElBNB�CD�US�@?�P>?P�0��CBI?KCD�

�UK�EALK@?�K��UK�HKI?KCB)�p?E�@E�@KJ��K�EG��V�K?0�V?E�T�KHCEZK�

�BI��KG��B@BJUS�PVK�US�B�B�@?B?P?E��B��>�HKJBVK@>BK�>E�?�>?U

PVK�US0���Kk�K��K�@�IG���US�@�ElBNB�CD�UJ�P�E��KJ0��K��PZ�U

BCB�AK@TECKG�U)��S��B���>EK��JK�K��KCDGI���@@J�?�B��?D�>�>�T�E�

@?EK�HETEC�K�BK�>�E?�EkK�BIJ����T���B?KCD@?�K��EJ�BCB�T���B�

?KCD@?�K��E��KT���B?KCD@?�K��EJ�P�E��K)�Y�>BK�>E�?�>?U�BJK^?

G��VK�BK0�>�>�@TE@EA@?�P^LBK�EA��GE���B^�M�PTT��CBI�BI0�B0��E�

�?E�US0�>�>�@TE@EA@?�P^LBK�lE�JB�E���B^���PV�US�WCB?�8E�G��VK�

�BB�WCB?���kB�E>EJ�@JU@CK�W?EME�@CE���I�@>�ZP�VP?D��BZK:)

``

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0� �@?�K?� �ET�E@�E� ?�>EJ�JKS��BGJK���G��AE?>B

@EE?�K?@?�P^LK��JEHKCB0���>E?E�EJ�T�B�BJ�CB�AU�PV�@?BK�>�>�TE�

CB?B>B0�E?�K?@?�K��UK�G��T�B�I?BK��KkK�B�0�?�>�B�@TKNB�CB@?U0��

?�>ZK�T�KH@?��B?KCB�AECKK�kB�E>E��EALK@?�K��E@?B0�>�>�@�M�PGB��

@>E�0�?�>�B�@��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U)�zKVD�BHK?�E���C�ZB���BB ��#F����

�U��AE?>B�@EMC�kK�BI0���P?�B�>E?E�EME�k�M�G��k�MEJ�JEZ�E�APHK?

T�EH�BM�?D@I� >�NKCB)�[EGJEZ�E0���V�CEJ� ?�>EME�T�ENK@@�� @?��K?

TBNP�H@>�I�>E�lK�K�NBI0�T�EkKHk�I���lK���CK�,--.�MEH�)�zK�CD�

�US��KGPCD?�?E��E����K�T�B�K@C��B�AECDkK�@J�SB��C�����EVK�KH�E�

}EAJK��?�PTE�~��M�PGB�@>�I�@?E�E�����@?�B��C�����@?�?P@K�RAS�GBB

��@E@?��K�O�PGBB0��AS�G@>�I�P?�K�ZH�C�0�V?E�@?�?P@��KG��B@BJEME�ME�

@PH��@?���P��KK�PZK�K@?D�B�EA@PZH�?D�GHK@D��KVKME)�|��?EJ�B���@@?��

CB@D0��E�APHKJ�TEJ�B?D0�V?E�W?E�?ECD>E���V�CE0�V?E���H�CD�K�kKJ0

JEZK?�AU?D0�PH�@?@I�@EMC�@E��?D��K>E?E�UK�TEGBNBB0���?�>ZK�AECKK

T���BCD�P^�E�M��BG�NB^�B�T�B�NBT�TEHAE���PV�@?�B>E��TEHEA�EME

�EH���@?�KV0���@JU@CK�T�KH@?��CK��E@?B�kB�E>EME�EALK@?�K��E�TE�

CB?BVK@>EME�@TK>?��)�Y�>EME�T�B�NBT����HE�TE@CKHE��?KCD�E�T�B�

HK�ZB��?D@I0���@kB�B��>�PM�PV�@?�B>E���@?�KV�G��@VK?�ETTEGBNBB)

oE?I�TBNP�H@>�I��@?�KV���K�I�CIC�@D�V�@?D^�ElBNB�CD�EME�TK�

�KME�E��EME�T�ENK@@��B0�@PHI�TE��@KJP0�G�>E�VBC�@D�AKG�KGPCD?�?�E0

��?E��W?BS�@?�E>�@VB?�K?0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0��EGJEZ�UJ�EA��?B?D�����KK

Page 162: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

E@EAEK���BJ��BK)�8=���H�0�W?E�APHK?�BJK?D�@JU@C�?ECD>E�T�B�P@CE�

�BB��KMPCI��EME�T�E�KHK�BI�?�>EME��EH��>E�lK�K�NB��B�AECKK�T�KH�

@?��B?KCD�EME�TEHAE���PV�@?�B>E�:)�qKCE���?EJ0�V?E�I�CBV�E�@>CE�I�

^@D�>�?EJP0�V?E�K@CB�B�APHK?�T�B�I?��>�>�I�CBAE�JEHKCD�E?�EkK�B�

JKZHP�O�PGBK��B�RAS�GBK�0�?E0�@>E�KK��@KME0�W?E�T�EBGE�HK?����E@�E�

�K�>E�@ENBE��CBGJ�0�>E?E�U��I�CIK?@I�?�>ZK���BAECKK�T�BKJCKJE�

lE�JE��HCI�TECB?BVK@>EME�P@?�E�@?���@�JE��RAS�GBB)

XB@?KJ�0�T�B�>E?E�E��}>EJT�EJB@@�BLP?�B���SEHI?�����U@kKJ

P�E��K~�B�>E?E�P^�}JEZ�E�ES���>?K�BGE��?D�>�>��K�SPkKV�P^�HBT�

CEJ�?B^��E��G�BJEE?�EkK�BIS�WCB?0��E@T�EBG�EHILP^�JEHKCD�JKZ�

HP���EH�E��TECB?B>B~. 0�T�KH@?��CIK?@I�J�K���H���EJ�@CPV�K���BAE�

CKK�TEHSEHILK�)�XEMC�@BK�E?�E@B?KCD�E�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB�JE�

ZK?�AU?D�T�B�I?E����E@�E�K�>E�@ENBE��CBGJ�0���W?E���@�E^�EVK�KHD

TEJEZK?�@?��E�CK�B^�>E�@ENBE��CD�E��T��>?B>B���@�JE��RAS�GBB0

?)>)�T�ENK@@�T�B�I?BI��KkK�B����SEHK���AE?U���H�T�EK>?EJ�P�KMPCB�

�E���BI0�TEJEZK?�T�BEA�K?K�B^����U>E��B�PJK�BI���AE?�?D����P�E��

�K��K�SPkKV�E��HBTCEJ�?BB�B�T�BJK�I?D�W?B����U>B�B�PJK�BK�B��

H�PMBS�@CPV�IS)��@SEHI�BG�W?EME0�J�K�SE?KCE@D�AU0��ET�K>B�k�?>E@?B

TEHEA�E����HKZHU0��BHK?D���=BNP�H@>E��>E�lK�K�NBB�?�>E��ZK�G��

V�?E>�>E�@ENBE��CD�E��T��>?B>B0�>�>E��I��BZP���?KS��@?�KV�S0�>E?E�

�UK�T�E�EHI?@I�����J>�S�T�EK>?��=ECU�O��A)

�FE�@ENBE��CBGJ�T�KH@?��CIK?@I���BAECKK�TEHSEHILK��lE�JE�

T�B�I?BI��KkK�BI�B�@EMC�@E����EME�@EGH��BI�>�>�T�EJKZP?EV�E�0

?�>�B�E>E�V�?KCD�E��JEHKCB0��E�K@?D���?E�ZK���KJI��IH�EA@?EI?KCD@?�0

T�KTI?@?�P^LBS�W?EJP)�[E�TK��US0�>E�@ENBE��CBGJ0�>�>�BG�K@?�E0

T�KHTEC�M�K?�P��ZK�BK�J�@@�>�WCB?K0�?)>)�?ECD>E�?�>BJ�P��ZK�BKJ�B

HE�K�BKJ�JEZK?�AU?D�EAK@TKVK�E�BS�AC�ME@>CE��EK�E?�EkK�BK�>�?E�

JEHKCB�P�KMPCB�E���BI0�>E?E��I�APHK?�T�KHCEZK��)�p?E?�l�>?E���

RAS�GBB�E?@P?@?�PK?�TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�ElBNB�CD�UJ��C�@?IJ)�{��TE@�

CK�EK��U��TK�BEH�ElBNB�CD�UK��C�@?B�BG�G��@�EK���K��GPJ�E��TE�

CB?B>B�J�EMEK�TE?K�ICB���MC�G�S�@EA@?�K��EME����EH�0�B�ME�E�B?D�EA

P��ZK�BB�>��BJ�J�@@�JEZ�E�?ECD>E���EVK�D�E?�E@B?KCD�EJ�@JU@CK)

]H��>E�JEZ�E�T�KHTECEZB?D0�V?E�@�?KVK�BKJ���KJK�B�TECEZK�BK���

W?EJ�P�E��K�TE@?KTK��E�BGJK�B?@I0�V?E�APHK?�>E��KCB�E��?D�@�?�>E�

.�z�l�WCD�|HZE>P)��?E�?�>EK�>E�@ENBE��CBGJ\ii�=��>?B>��lKHK��CBGJ�)�=EB@�

>B��CD?K���?B��HCI�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB)�tE@>��0�.5550�@)3-,)

Page 163: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

ZK�TE@?KTK��E�0�TEk�ME�E����AE?E����H�T�EJKZP?EV�UJ�T�EK>?EJ0

TE?EJP�V?E�B���AE?����H�T�EJKZP?EV�UJ�T�EK>?EJ��K�K@?D�EH�EJE�

JK�?�U���>?0���T�ENK@@0�?�KAP^LB���KJ�CE���KJK�B)

[?E�E��l�>?E��Q�W?E��KEASEHBJE@?D�}TEHHK�ZB��?D�@K>�K?�E@?D0

V?EAU�BGAKZ�?D�BGCBk�BS�JKZM�PTTE�US�@@E�~). �]T�KHKCK��U��P�E�

�K�D�@K>�K?�E@?B��KBGAKZK����C^AEJ�@CPV�K0��E�EALK@?�P��KMPCI��E0

TE�JK�K�T�EH�BZK�BI���AE?U���H�@EMC�kK�BKJ0�HECZ�E�TK�BEHBVK@�

>B���GwI@�I?D@I0����>�>EJ�W?�TK���SEHB?@I�W?����AE?��B�>�>EK�@EMC�@BK

HE@?BM�P?E�TE�?EJP�BCB�B�EJP��ET�E@P)�oE?I�?�>E��TEHSEH�M�EGB?�KZK�

JB�P?�E���?�C>B��?D@I�����KTEHME?E�CK��E@?D�EALK@?���>�>�>BJ�CBAE

>EJT�EJB@@�J�@�O�PGBK�0����@PLK@?�P^LB���U@E>B��P�E�K�D��KHE�K�

�BI0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�E���KBGAKZK�0�V?EAU�BGAKZ�?D�CBk�BS�@CPSE��B

�KHE��GPJK�B�0���?�>ZK�HCI�NKCK��T���CK��E��TEHME?E�>B�EALK@?�K��

�EME�J�K�BI)�xC�MET�BI?�EK�EALK@?�K��EK�J�K�BK0� �� @CPV�K0� K@CB

T�ENK@@�P�KMPCB�E���BI�EA�K?K?��K�CD�UK�>E�?P�U0�I�CIK?@I�P@CE�B�

KJ�HCI�T�B�I?BI��KkK�BI�B�KME�PJKCEK�lE�JB�E���BK�B�@EGH��BK�HEC�

Z�E�@?�?D�V�@?D^�EALK��@?��?KMBB)�u@CB�W?EME��K�T�EBGE�HK?0�?E�C^�

AEK�@EMC�kK�BK�JEZK?�AU?D�E?�K�M�P?E�EALK@?�EJ�B�P@BCBI�TE?��VK�

�U�G�I)�]TU?�.554�MEH��@E�GCE@V�@?�UJ�T�E?E>ECEJ�E�M�PGB�E��AS�G@�

>EJ�P�KMPCB�E���BB�8VKME�AU�E���B�@?EBC:�I@�E�TE>�G�C�W?E)

�?�>�Q� >E�@ENBE��CBGJ�>�>�JK?EH�HE@?BZK�BI� @EMC�kK�BI�B

lE�J��ME@PH��@?�K��E�TECB?BVK@>EME�P@?�E�@?���HCI�@�JE��RAS�GBB)

y��K�APHP�GHK@D�TEH�EA�E�E@?����CB��?D@I�����?E�EJ�JEJK�?K�W?E�

lE�JPCU0�TE@>ECD>P�W?E�PZK��USEHB?�G����J>B�H���E��@?�?DB�8>�?EJP

ZK�GHK@D��EG�B>�K?��IH��ET�E@E��B�T�E?B�E�KVB�0�?�KAP^LBS�@TK�

NB�CD�EME�EAHPJU���BI:0��E0�T�EHECZ�I���@@PZHK�BI�EA�P@CE�BIS�B

�EGJEZ�E@?IS���G��AE?>B�B�T�B�I?BI�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB0��KCDGI

�K�@>�G�?D��K@>ECD>E�@CE��E�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B)�OE@PH��@?�K��E@?D

K@?D�?�K?DI�@?E�E�����?�KPMECD�B>K�P@CE�B��HCI�T�B�I?BI�TC����P�K�

MPCB�E���BI)�=K���I�@?E�E���8JK?EH:�Q�>E�@ENBE��CBGJ0��?E��I�@?E�

�E���Q�@�J�T�ENK@@���G��AE?>B�T�EK>?�0�?�K?DI�@?E�E���Q�ME@PH���

@?�K��E@?D)�p?��@?E�E���BCB�W?E�P@CE�BK�I�CIK?@I�@�JE��T�EACKJ��

?BV�E�0��E0�HPJ�K?@I0�B�@�JE���K@EJ�K��E�)�OE@PH��@?�K��E@?D0�E

J�EMBS��@TK>?�S�>E?E�E��JEZ�E�ME�E�B?D0�I�AK�P�GHK@D�>�>�B�@?���

NB^0�@TE@EA�P^�T�B�BJ�?D��KkK�BK)

.�Y�J�ZK0�@)3-3)

Page 164: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

u@CB�HETP@?B?D0�V?E�JEHKCD�APHK?�T�B�I?�0�?E��@?�K?��ET�E@�E�KK

�K�CBG�NBB0�E@PLK@?�CK�BB)�p?E�JEZ�E�@HKC�?D�?ECD>E�T�B�P@CE�BB

��CBVBI�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�>�>�B�@?��NBB0�@TE@EA�E��T�B�BJ�?D��K�

kK�BI�B�T�E�EHB?D�BS���ZBG�D)�p?E0�>E�KV�E0�@PZK��EK�TE�BJ��BK

ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�BCB0�>�>�ME�E�I?�TECB?ECEMB0�V�@?BV�EK�TE�I?BK

ME@PH��@?��)�|E�ME@PH��@?�E���TEC�EJ0��@K@?E�E��KJ�@JU@CK�W?EME�@CE��

T�B�@PLK@?�P^LBS���Kk�BS�B���P?�K��BS�P@CE�BIS�RAS�GBB0��K�EG�

JEZ�E�B0���T�BJK�0�P�KMPCB�E���BK�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BS�E?�EkK�B���

@�E^�EVK�KHD��U@?PT�K?�P@CE�BKJ�HCI�?�>EME��EH��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B)

=EW?EJP�I�@PZ�^�G��VK�BK�W?EME�?K�JB���HE�VB@?E�lP�>NBE��CD�EME0

�E��K@DJ����Z�EME�>�>�B�@?��NBB0� @TE@EA�E��T�B�BJ�?D��KkK�BI0

B�@?��NBK�0�EAC�H�^LK���C�@?D^�V?E�?E��Kk�?D��K����@CE��S0�����

HKCK)�R�?�>EK�V�@?BV�EK�TE�I?BK�ME@PH��@?����K�T�KH@?��CIK?@I��K�EG�

JEZ�UJ��K�CBGE��?D�B�T�B��U�Kk�BS�P@CE�BIS)�u@CB�W?EME��K�T�E�

BGE�HK?0��B>�>BK��KkK�BI��K�APHP?�E@PLK@?�CK�U)�|E�W?��@?E�E���?�K�

PMECD�B>����SEHB?@I��@KNKCE����P>�S��AS�GE�0�B�W?E�P@CE�BK�JEZK?�AU?D

�K�CBGE���E�?ECD>E�BJB�@�JBJB)�{HK@D�PJK@?�E���TEJ�B?D��U@>�GU�

���BK�{P��A��RVA���}|KEASEHBJE�P@?��E�B?D�A��DK�0�G��EM���BVK��E�

TC��>E��>E?E�EME�T�E@?���@?�E�HCI�C^AUS�HEME�E�K��E@?K�~. )

F�EJK�?EME0�@>�G���EK�E�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�BJKK?�G��VK�BK�B��

?EJ�E?�EkK�BB0�V?E���G��KVD�BHK?�EA�P�KMPCB�E���BB�ME@PH��@?�K��

�E�T���E�US�E?�EkK�B�0�?E�HECZ�E�AU?D�B�ME@PH��@?�E�8SE?I�AU��

V�@?BV�EJ�@JU@CK�@CE��:0�@�>E?E�UJ�BJKK?�@JU@C�ME�E�B?D�E�ME@P�

H��@?�K��E�T���E�US�E?�EkK�BIS)�OE@PH��@?�K��E�T���E�UK�E?�E�

kK�BI�JEZ�E�@?�EB?D�?ECD>E�JKZHP�ME@PH��@?��JB0�B��VK�NKCD�TK�

�KME�E�E��B�TE@?�EK�BI�JEHKCB�?K�IK?@I)�=E�I?�E0�V?E�I�ME�E�^��K

��@JU@CK�T�BG����E@?B�BCB��K�T�BG����E@?B�ME@PH��@?��0���H���EJ

@CPV�K��K�W?E���Z�E)�|K��Z�E0�V?E�ME@PH��@?�E��K�T�BG���E0���Z�E0

V?E�E�E�@PLK@?�PK?0�?E�K@?D�JEZK?�E@PLK@?�CI?D�>E�?�ECD����@�EK�

?K��B?E�BB0�JEZK?�M����?B�E��?D�SE?I�AU�JB�BJ�CD�U��T���ETE�I�

HE>�B�@?�ABCD�E@?D0�B�JEZK?�T�B�BJ�?D��KkK�BI0�>�@�^LBK@I�ZBG�

�B��@KME����EH�0�>�>�NKCEME�B�T�KH@?��CI?D�KME��K�CD�UK�B�?K�K@U)

=�B��UTEC�K�BB�W?BS�P@CE�B��JU�JEZKJ�ME�E�B?D�E���CBVBB�ME@P�

H��@?�K��E@?B���K�G��B@BJE@?B�E?�KME�T�BG���BI�BCB��KT�BG���BI)

.�{P��A�RVA�)�u@CB�I��K�TE�HP���TECB?B>P0�?E�TECB?B>��HEAK�K?@I�HE�JK�I)ii

XTKkP�TEHKCB?D@I�@���JB)�XPSPJ0�,---0�@)9)

Page 165: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

=�B��K�UTEC�K�BB�W?BS�P@CE�B��H�ZK�T�BG���BK�JKZHP���EH�UJ

@EEALK@?�EJ��BVKME��K�H�@?)�=�BG���BK0�SE?I�B�EVK�D���Z�U���>?0

@�JE�TE�@KAK��B>�>E��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B��K�@EGH�@?)

|K@ME�E�VB�E@?D��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U��E�J�EMEJ�T�EB@?K>�K?�E?

AK@@BCBI�B�@C�AE@?B)�u@?D�BG�K@?�EK��U��ZK�BK�tBkKCI�mP>E�E�?EJ0

V?E��@K��KkK�BI�ET�@�U)���E��P?EV�IC�Q��K��@K��KkK�BI�TCESB0����@K

ET�@�U0�?E�K@?D�>�>BK�?E�T�EBM�Uk�UK0���>�>BK�?E��K?)�|E���M�PGB�E�

�AS�G@>EJ�@CPV�K0�TESEZK0��@K��KkK�BI�APHP?�BJK��E�TCESB�T�B�E?�

@P?@?�BB�B�@?��NBB0�@TE@EA�E��T�B�BJ�?D��KkK�BI)�RAS�G@>�I�@?E�

�E���BJKK?�ME��GHE�JK�DkK��K@P�@E�0�TEW?EJP��K�BHK?����P@?PT>B)

n@?PTB?D�E���JEZK?�EVK�D��KJ�EME0���TE?K�I?D�JEZK?��@K)�[E��@I>EJ

@CPV�K0�P��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U�K@?D�?�>E��@?��S)�tEZK?�TE>�G�?D@I�T��

��HE>@�CD�UJ0��E0�B@SEHI�BG�W?EME0�O�PGBI�HECZ���AU?D�H�ZK�G�B�?K�

�K@E��������AS�G@>E��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B0�V?EAU�BJK?D�HK�@?�B?KCD�

�E�����ET����EME�T��?�K���TE�TK�KME�E��J0�@�>E?E�UJ�BJKK?�@JU@C

�K@?B�BJK��E�TK�KME�E�U�TE�ME@PH��@?�K��E�T���E�UJ�E?�EkK�B�

IJ)�y�H�CK>�E?�JU@CB�T�BGU��?D�O�PGB^�>�@EHK�@?�B^���HKCK�@?��E��

CK�BI���RAS�GBB��E�J�CD�EME�ME@PH��@?�K��EME�T���ETE�IH>�0�@?��

ABCD�US�B�@?B?P?E��B�?�K�HE���C�@?B0��E���KK�@BC�S0�TE�>����K��JK�K0

�K�JKk�?D�W?EJP)�X�W?E��?EV>B�G�K�BI�C^AUK�TETU?>B�H��CK�BI0�PM�

�EG0�@��>NB��B�T�EV)�@E�K�kK��E�AK@@JU@CK��U)�O�PGB�@>�I�TECB�

?B>����W?EJ�TC��K�HECZ���BGJK�B?D@I�B��K�@?��B?D��E�J�CD�UK�E?�

�EkK�BI�@�RAS�GBK����G��B@BJE@?D�E?�T�EM�K@@����HKCK�P�KMPCB�E���

�BI0��E���EAE�E?0���@@J�?�B��?D�T�EM�K@@���HKCK�P�KMPCB�E���BI0�>�>

G��B@BJU��E?��E�J�CD�US0�TE���@?EILKJP�T��?�K�@>BS�E?�EkK�B�

@�RAS�GBK�)�[@K�W?E�AKGE?�E@B?KCD�E�>�ET�KHKCK�B^�@?�?P@�)���?�>�I

TECB?B>��HECZ��� @?�?D���JEV�UJ�P@CE�BKJ�T�ENK@@����G��AE?>B

JEHKCB�P�KMPCB�E���BI0�EALKME�TC����@E@PLK@?�E���BI)

```

y��K�@CPV���E�PHKCBC�@?ECD>E���BJ��BI�P@CE�BIJ�@EGH��BI�T�E�

JKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB�B��EGJEZ�E@?IJ�KK��K�CBG�NBB)�p?E�Q�E@�E���I

T�EACKJ�)�qCI0�TEZ�CP�0�C^AEME��EH��B�BNB�?B�)�XE���KJK��F��?�

�ET�E@�E�?EJ0�>�>�W?E��EGJEZ�E0�@?�C�T�B�NBTB�CD�UJ�HCI�C^AEME

B�?KCCK>?P�CD�EME�EAE@�E���BI)

Page 166: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

[�H���E��@?�?DK�T�KHTEC�M�K?@I�@B?P�NBI0�>EMH��@?E�E�U�T�B�

�BJ�^?��KkK�BK�@E�JK@?�E�B�@E�JK@?�E���AE?�^?���H�@EGH��BKJ

T�BKJCKJE��JEHKCB)�t��?K��YKE�y�@0���@@J�?�B��I�?�B�TP?B�P�K�

MPCB�E���BI�>E�lCB>?�0�E?JK?BC��}��Kk�II��C�@?D�JEZK?����IG�?D

�KkK�BK�T�E?B�EAE�@?�P^LBJ�@?E�E��J0�B@SEH�>E�lCB>?��JEZK?

@CEZB?D@I�TEH��CBI�BKJ��IH��EH�E@?E�E��BS�HK�@?�B��BCB�ZK�>E��

lCB>?P^LBK�@?E�E�U�JEMP?��KkB?D�PC�HB?D�@�EB���G�EMC�@BI�EA�

LBJB�P@BCBIJB~. )�u@CB�>�>EK��BAPHD��KkK�BK�APHK?�T�B�I?E0�?E

K@?K@?�K��E0��PZ�E�APHK?�>E�?�ECB�E��?D�KME��UTEC�K�BK0�V?E�T�KH�

TEC�M�K?���CBVBK�BCB�@EGH��BK�JKS��BGJE��B�B�@?B?P?E�0�E?�KV�^�

LBS� G�� W?E)�=�B� @C�AE@?B� B� �K��HKZ�E@?B� TECB?BVK@>BS0� @ENB�

�CD�US�B�T���EES���B?KCD�US�@?�P>?P��T�E?B�EAE�@?�P^LBS�@?E�

�E�0�@?��E�B?@I�EVK�BH�E���KEASEHBJE@?D��K>E?E�US�JKZHP���EH�

�US�M����?B�)�RAS�G@>�I�@?E�E����@KMH��@��KHE�K�BKJ�E?�E@B?@I�>

?�>E���EGJEZ�E@?B0���TK��P^�EVK�KHD�BG�G��T�EACKJU�AKZK�NK�0

HCI� >E?E�US0� �� E@�E��EJ�B� ?�KAP^?@I�JKZHP���EH�UK� M����?BB

G�LB?U)�=�B��EG�B>�E�K�BB�>�>BS�CBAE�>ECCBGB��JKZHP���EH�UK

@BCU0���@CPV�K�BS�G�HK�@?�E���BI0�JEMP?�AU?D�B@TECDGE���U�T�E�

?B��RAS�GBB)�Y�>�I��EGJEZ�E@?D0�SE?I�AU0�MBTE?K?BVK@>B�@PLK@?�P�

K?0��K�ME�E�I�PZK�EA�ET�@K�BIS)�=EW?EJP�T�EACKJ��AKZK�NK����T�E�

JKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB�JEZK?�AU?D���@@JE?�K���?ECD>E���EM���BVK��

�EJ���>P�@K)

[EEALK�ZK�M����?BB�JKZHP���EH�EME�@EEALK@?��0�JKZHP���EH�

�US�B�@?B?P?E��TE?�KAP^?@I0�@>E�KK��@KME0���C^AEJ�@CPV�K)�X�IG��E

W?E�>�>���G�@E�@C�AE@?D^�M�PGB�@>E��B��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�0�@�E?@P?@?�B�

KJ�BCB�V�@?BV�UJ���CBVBKJ�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B0���@�IGB�@�VKJ�EAwKJ

B�>EJTCK>@�JK�ET�BI?B�0��KEASEHBJUS�����@KS�@?�HBIS�HE@?BZK�BI

TEC�EJ�@k?�A�EME�P�KMPCB�E���BI0��K�JEZK?�AU?D�TEC�E@?D^��G���

CK�����BS�TCKVB)

XEGH��BK�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB�ET�KHKCIK?@I��KEASEHBJE@?D^

B��KBGAKZ�E@?D^�TECB?B>B�TE@?KTK��EME0���NKCK��EME����HECME@�EV�

�P^�TK�@TK>?B�P��U@?��B���BI�E?�EkK�B��JKZHP�O�PGBK��B�RAS��

GBK�)���@?BV�UK�T�EK>?U�P�KMPCB�E���BI�ME@PH��@?�K��E�T���E�US

.�t��?K��YKE�y�@)�YKE�BI�B�ETU?��KMPCB�E���BI�W?�E��NBE��CD�US�>E�lCB>�

?E���BS�T�BJK�BJE@?D�>�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EJP�>E�lCB>?Pii�O�PGB�U�B��AS�GU)�=P?D�>

T�BJB�K�B^)�tE@>��0�.55;0�@),-5)

Page 167: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

E?�EkK�B��JEZ�E���@@J�?�B��?D�>�>�G�>C�H>P�lP�H�JK�?���EG�EHB�

JEME�GH��BI)�p?P�HKI?KCD�E@?D�JEZ�E���V�?D��K�HEZBH�I@D��KkK�BI

�ET�E@��EA�ET�KHKCK�BB�@?�?P@�)�[�V�@?BV�E��JEHKCB� W?E?�TP�>?

JEZ�E�ETP@?B?D)�Y�>BK�B@@CKHE��?KCB0�>�>�OKE�MB��R�V�A�HGK�T�KH�

C�M�^?�B��E�@K���KJK��E�E?CEZB?D�TK�KME�E�U�E�@?�?P@K�RAS�GBB�B

��CEZB?D�JE��?E�B�����@�JUK�@TE��UK�B�AECKG�K��UK�?KJU). �qK��

@?�B?KCD�E0�SE?I��K�EGJEZ�E�B��K��PZ�E����IGU��?D�JE��?E�B��?��

>EME��EH���KG��B@BJUJ�PVK�UJ0�@TKNB�CB@?�J0��>�HKJBVK@>BJ�>�P�

M�J0��E����TK�KME�E��EJ�P�E��K�BCB����P�E��K�>E�lK�K�NBB0�T�B�

G����E����G��AE?�?D�B�T�KHCEZB?D�T�EJKZP?EV�P^�JEHKCD0�W?E?���K�

JK��U��JE��?E�B��APHK?��KEASEHBJ)�|E�E?�E@B?KCD�E�AKZK�NK����IH

CB��EGJEZ�E�?E�ZK�@�JEK)�[�W?EJ�@CPV�K�M�PGB�@>�I�@?E�E���JEZK?

TE?K�I?D��@I>B��@?BJPC�>�>�>BJ�AU�?E��B�AUCE�HEME�E�K��E@?IJ)

[ET�E@�AKZK�NK���K�JK�KK�E@?�U�0�VKJ��ET�E@�@?�?P@�0��E�TEC�E@�

?D^�EASEHB?D�KME��K�@?EB?)�[�V�@?BV�E�� 8T�EJKZP?EV�E�:�JEHKCB

JEZ�E�T�KHP@JE?�K?D�V�@?BV�EK��KkK�BK�W?E��T�EACKJU0�>�>�W?E�B

T�EB@SEHB?0�>@?�?B�ME�E�I0���HK�@?�B?KCD�E@?B)

|K�HEZBH�I@D��KkK�BI��ET�E@��E�@?�?P@K0�@CKHPK?���V�?D�P@?��

���CB��?D��E�J�CD�UK�E?�EkK�BI�JKZHP��K@TPACB>�JB)�F�>�TBkK?

?E?�ZK�R�V�A�HGK0���HE�E?>�G�?D@I�E?�TECB?B>B��KT�K@@B��B�EMPCD�E�

ME�EVK��K�BI�T�E?B�ETECEZ�E��@?E�E�U), �=E>��@ES���IK?@I�>E�l�

�E�?�NBE��U��TEHSEH0��@K�TK�KME�E�U0��@?�KVB0�>E�@PCD?�NBB0�T�KZ�

HK��@KME�@�PV�@?BKJ�ElBNB�CD�US�CBN�8����KElBNB�CD�EJ�P�E��K

�@K�T�ELK:0�APHP?���@@J�?�B��?D@I�V�@?D^0�T�EHECZK�BKJ�TECB?B>B

>E�l�E�?�NBB�B�>�>�@�KH@?�E��K�HCI���SEZHK�BI�T�BKJCKJEME��K�

kK�BI0���>�>�@TE@EA�T�E?EC>�P?D�EH�E@?E�E��KK��KkK�BK0�V?E���C^�

AEJ�@CPV�K��K�EGJEZ�E)

|KEASEHBJE�TEW?EJP�@�I?BK�W>E�EJBVK@>BS�@��>NB��@�RAS�GBB0

HEME�E�K��E@?D�EA�E?>�U?BB�>EJJP�B>�NB�0�T�K>��LK�BK��TKCCI�

NB��>�>�>E��CBAE���Kk�K��@?E�E�K�@�NKCD^�E@PLK@?�B?D�T�B�PZHK�

�BK)�[�Kk�II�@?E�E���JEZK?�B�HECZ���T�B�BJ�?D�PV�@?BK���M�PGB�

�E��AS�G@>EJ�P�KMPCB�E���BB0�KK�@EHK�@?�BK�B�TEJELD��PZ�U0��E

�KCDGI�?�KAE��?D�E?��KK�@BCE�EME�H��CK�BI���TECDGP�>�>E��CBAE�BG

.�OKE�MB��R�V�A�HGK)�=�KEHECK��I�TE@?�EK��U��@B�H�EJ)ii�F��>�G@>B���>NK�?0

��,0�,--.0�@)�3),�Y�J�ZK0�@)3)

Page 168: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

@?E�E�)�p?E�T�E@?E��K�K�CD�E)�=EW?EJP�E?>�G�E?�?�>BS�EA��LK�B�

HECZK��@?�?D�V�@?D^�EALK��TECB?B>B�E?>�G��E?��KT�K@@B�)

��@?BV�U��T�EK>?�JEZK?0���E@�E��EJ0�@>C�HU��?D@I�BG�?KS�T�E�

K>?E��P�KMPCB�E���BI0�>E?E�UK�PZK�T�KHC�M�CB@D0�?KS�JEHKCK�0�>E?E�

�UK�PZK���G��A�?U��CB@D0��E�AUCB���NKCK�U����E>E�V�?KCD�EK�P�K�

MPCB�E���BK)�|�BAECKK���NBE��CD�UK�B�E@PLK@?�BJUK�WCKJK�?U0

APHPVB�@>EJAB�B�E���U�@�HEA��CK�BKJ��K>E?E�US��E�US�T�KHCEZK�

�B��B�@�PVK?EJ�@CEZB�kBS@I��K�CB�0�JEMP?�@E@?��B?D�@EHK�Z��BK

T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB)�qPJ�K?@I0�@�I?BK�W>E�EJBVK@>BS�@��>NB��B

E?>�U?BK�>EJJP�B>�NB��JEMP?�AU?D�KK�@E@?���UJB�V�@?IJB)

X�JE�JEHKCB�E���BK��K�I�CIK?@I�VKJ�?E�@E�K�kK��E��E�UJ��

B@?E�BB� M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BS�E?�EkK�B�)�[�.5.5�.5,-� MM)0� �� TK�BEH

JK�DkK�B@?@>E��O�PGBB0� >EMH��RAS�GBI�AUC�� G��I?�� M�PGB�@>BJB

�EE�PZK��UJB�lE�JB�E���BIJB0���@?�?P@�RAS�GBB�B�KK�E?�EkK�BI�@

O�PGBK���PZH�CB@D���T���E�EJ�ElE�JCK�BB0�HKTP?�?U�?EMH�k�KME

�AS�G@>EME�T��C�JK�?����AE?�CB���H�T�EK>?EJ�>E�@?B?PNBB�B�AUCB

@E@?��CK�U���GCBV�UK�T�EK>?U0�A�C��@B�E���kBK����M���B�lKHK���

CBGJ�0�>E�lKHK��CBGJ�0�V?E�EAwI@�ICE@D�TECEZK�BKJ����?E?�TK�BEH)

=E@CK��E��U�.55,�.553�MEHE��TK��E��TETU?>E��ET�KHKCB?D�>E�?P�U

T�EJKZP?EV�US�E?�EkK�B��I�BC�@D�@?�?DI�7�{�I�CK�BI�E�JK��S�TE

TECB?BVK@>EJP�P�KMPCB�E���B^�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?��E?�9

�T�KCI�.557�MEH�)�|��@KMEH�Ik�B��HK�D�@�JU����G��AE?���U��B�TEH�

�EA�U��T�EK>?�>E�@?B?PNBE��E��JEHKCB�AUC�T�KHCEZK��[IVK@C��

�EJ��B�B>A�. �B0�SE?I��AS�G@>�I�EALK@?�K��E@?D��@?�K?BC���K�@CBk�

>EJ�AC�MEZKC�?KCD�E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0����KJ�K@?D��IH���NBE��CD�US�B

HKCD�US�T�KHCEZK�B�0�>E?E�UK�JEZ�E��E@T�B�I?D)�q�PMBJ�>E�>�K?�

�UJ0��E��KHE@?�?EV�E���G��AE?���UJ�T�KHCEZK�BKJ�I�CIK?@I�JE�

HKCD�>E�HEJB�BPJ�)�[���BAECKK�G��K�kK��E��lE�JK�W?E?����B��?

TECPVBC��U��ZK�BK���@?�?DK�q�CBCU�=BCB��}tEHKCD�HCI�ME�IVBS

?EVK>~)�tEHKCB�>E�HEJB�BPJ��>�>���BAECKK�T�BKJCKJE��lE�JU�P�K�

MPCB�E���BI�T�BHK�ZB��K?@I�B�JE@>E�@>B��W?�ECEM�XK�MK��R�P?^�

�E�), �u@?D�T�KHCEZK�BI�B�@�M�PGB�@>E��@?E�E�U0��E�?ECD>E���lE�JK

.�XJ)�[IVK@C����B�B>A�)�O�PGBI�B�RAS�GBI��T�KHCEZK�BI�>�>E�@?B?PNBE��E�

JEHKCB)ii=��>?B>��lKHK��CBGJ�)�=EB@>B��CD?K���?B��HCI�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB)�tE@>�

��0�.5550�@)3;7�934),�XJ)�XK�MK��R�P?^�E�)�uLK�EHB�����B��?�P�KMPCB�E���BI�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME

>E�lCB>?�)iiR@TK>?U�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?�0��9)�������0�,---0�@)�5;�.-,)

Page 169: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

EALBS�T�KHCEZK�B��E�lKHK��NBB�B�kB�E>E����?E�EJBB)�F�>�I�JE�

HKCD�T�KHC�M�C�@D�O�PGBK��8��lE�JK���G��AE?���EME�T�EK>?�:�B�T�KH�

C�M�C�@D�CB�E����EEALK����TBNP�H@>E��>E�lK�K�NBB0�J�K��KBG�K@?�

�E)�]lBNB�CD�UK�ZK�@�KHK�BI�EA�W?EJ�EVK�D�@>PH�U)�u@?D�T�KHCE�

ZK�BK�zK@TPACB>��@>E��T��?BB0�T�KH@?��CK��EK� @?�?DK����CB���

o�B�H�����}FE�lCB>?���RAS�GBB�B��EGJEZ�U��TP?D�KME�P�KMPCB�E���

�BI~0. �T�KHC�M�^LKK�lE�JPCP�}KHB�@?�E�TE@�KH@?�EJ���GHKCK�BI~)

q�CD�K�kP^�?���@lE�J�NB^�W?E?�T�B�NBT�T�K?K�TKC�����AE?K�T�KH�

@?��B?KCI�?E��ZK�T��?BB�q��BH��xK�HGK�Bk�BCB�}uHB�@?�E�VK�KG

��GHKCK�BK)�=�EACKJU��KMBE��CBGJ��O�PGBB�B�EALKME�M�PGB�E��A�

S�G@>EME�ME@PH��@?��~),

�G��@KS�W?BS�T�KHCEZK�B�0��EGJEZ�E0�?ECD>E�T�EK>?��)�o�B�H�

������E@B?�VK�?U�BJK��E�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB0�?)>)�@�J���?E��TEH�

VK�>�PC0�V?E�T�KHC�M�KJ�I�>E�NKTNBI��K�I�CIK?@I�T�EK>?EJ��@KEAw�

KJC^LKME�HEME�E��)�]@?�CD�UK�T�KHP@J�?�B��^?�BJK��E�T�EK>?

�@KEAwKJC^LKME�HEME�E��0���@@VB?���EME����HECME@�EV�P^�TK�@TK>�

?B�P)�]H��>E�>E�NKTNBI�M�PGB�@>EME���?E��0�E@�E�����I������GHKCK�

�BB�?K��B?E�BB�RAS�GBB����H�K�V�@?B�Q�@K�K��P^�zK@TPACB>P�RAS��

GBI�B�^Z�U��RAS�G@>B��>���0��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�E����@@J�?�B��K?@I

>�>���BJK�KK�T�BKJCKJ�I)�=EHEA�EK���GHKCK�BK��E@T�B�BJ�K?@I�>�>

���PkK�BK�?K��B?E�B�CD�E��NKCE@?�E@?B�RAS�GBB)�oE?I�T�EK>?�zK@�

TPACB>��@>E��T��?BB�@EHK�ZB?�B�H�PMBK�T�KHCEZK�BI0��E�PZK�TP�>?

E���GHKCK�BB�RAS�GBB0��K�APHPVB�PA���0�HKC�K?��K�EGJEZ�UJ��@K

E@?�CD�EK)�[�@?�?DK�xK�HGK�Bk�BCB�T�B�NBT�}KHB�@?�E�VK�KG���GHK�

CK�BK~���@T�E@?���K�����JKZME@PH��@?�K��UK�E?�EkK�BI0����E?�E�

kK�BI�H�PS�����ET����US�@PAwK>?E������J>�S�EALKME�ME@PH��@?��)

]H�BJ�@CE�EJ�Q�>E�NKTNBI�@E^G�EME�ME@PH��@?��)�{HK@D�T�B�NBT

}KHB�@?�E�VK�KG���GHKCK�BK~�T�BACBZK��>��K�CD�E@?B0��E�W?��T�E�

ACKJ���USEHB?�PZK����ET�KHKCK�BK�@?�?P@�0�����T�EJKZP?EV�E��JE�

HKCB�W?E?��ET�E@�CPVkK��@KME�ETP@?B?D)

F�>BK�JK�U�JEZ�E�T�B�I?D0�>�>BK��KkK�BI�JEZ�E�T�KHCEZB?D

����J>�S�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB0�>�EJK�E?CEZK�BI������KJI��ET�E�

@��E�@?�?P@K�B�E?>�U?BI�?���@TE�?�EME�>E�BHE��\�[�@�EK���KJI0��

.�XJ)�=��>?B>��lKHK��CBGJ�)�=EB@>B��CD?K���?B��HCI�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB)�tE@�

>��0�.5550�@)�343�364),�XJ)�R@TK>?U�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?�0��9)�������0�,---0�@)�;;�54)

Page 170: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

T�EK>?�S�>E�@?B?PNBB�.5.5�.5,-�MM)0�?EMH�k�BK��AS�G@>BK�TECB?B>B

T�KHP@J�?�B��CB�B�@?B?P?�PTEC�EJEVK��EME�E?�O�PGBB�T�B��AS�G@�

>EJ�T���B?KCD@?�K�B�PTEC�EJEVK��EME�E?�RAS�GBB�T�B�M�PGB�@>EJ

T���B?KCD@?�K)�nTEC�EJEVK��UK�B�@�?E��B�@�H�PME��@?E�E�U�BJKCB

����UK�T����)�[�T�EK>?K�@EMC�kK�BI0�TEHME?E�CK��EME���?E���KJI0

W?BJ�PTEC�EJEVK��UJ�T�KHE@?��CICE@D�T���E��� @CPV�K0� K@CB�E�B

P@JE?�I?���?KS�BCB�B�US�HK�@?�BIS�BCB�G�>E�ET�EK>?�S0���E@BJUS��

���EH�U��XE�K?�8?EMH�k�B��T��C�JK�?�Q�R)r):�PLKJCK�BK�B�?K�K�

@E��?E��@?E�E�U0�>E?E�P^�E�B�T�KH@?��CI^?0���E@B?D�@�EB��EG��ZK�

�BI0���K@CB�|��EH�U��XE�K?��K�@EMC�@B?@I�@��BJB0�?E���E@B?D�BS��

@EMC�@B?KCD�P^�>EJB@@B^)�=�KH@?��CIK?@I��EGJEZ�UJ�TK�K�K@?B�W?P

JK�P�B����U�Kk�BK�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BK�E?�EkK�BI)���@?B?P?�PTEC�E�

JEVK��US�B�@EGH��BK�XEMC�@B?KCD�E��>EJB@@BB�TEG�ECI?���@kB�B?D

T�ENK@@�B�@?B?PNBE��CBG�NBB�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BS�E?�EkK�B��B�JE�

MP?���@@J�?�B��?D@I�>�>���KJK���I�JK���HE�TEC�EJ�@k?�A�EME�P�K�

MPCB�E���BI0�HE�?EME�>�>��@K��@TK>?U�E?�EkK�B��APHP?�I@�E�B�ET�K�

HKCK��E�EVK�VK�U)�p?P�JK�P�@CKHPK?���@@J�?�B��?D�>�>�T�KKJ@?�K��

�P^�TE�E?�EkK�B^�>�@EGH��B^���@�EK���KJI�FEE�HB��NBE��EME�@E�

�K?�0��E�XEMC�@B?KCD��I�>EJB@@BI�HECZ���EAC�H�?D�AECKK�kB�E>BJB

lP�>NBIJB�B�TEC�EJEVBIJB0�l�>?BVK@>B��>>PJPCB�E��?D���@KAK��K@D

@TK>?��M�PGB�E��AS�G@>BS�E?�EkK�B�0���?EJ�VB@CK�B���G��AE?>P�T�E�

K>?��TEC�EJ�@k?�A�EME�P�KMPCB�E���BI0��E�����KMPCI��E��E@�E�K0��

�K�TE�JK�K��EG�B>�E�K�BI�}>E�>�K?�US��@TK>?E���ET�E@E�~0�>�>�W?E

AUCE�@lE�JPCB�E���E�HCI�FEE�HB��NBE��EME�@E�K?�)�zKkK�BI�XE�

MC�@B?KCD�E��>EJB@@BB�HECZ�U�BJK?D�EAIG�?KCD�U��S���>?K�)�p?E�Q

��@CPV�K���SEZHK�BI��KkK�BI)�u@CB�@?E�E�U��K���SEHI?��KkK�BI0�?E

E�B�TE�rK�TS��?P0�@EMC�k�^?@I��K�@EMC�k�?D@I)�tEZK?�AU?D0�?E?�ZK

FEE�HB��NBE��U��@E�K?0��UTEC�I^LB��@K�V�@�EVK�D�EM���BVK��UK

lP�>NBB0�@E���KJK�KJ�TK�K��@?K?���AECKK�TEC�EJEV�P^�B��CBI?KCD�

�P^�XEMC�@B?KCD�P^�>EJB@@B^0�lP�>NBB�>E?E�E��JEMP?�AU?D���@�

kB�K�U�G��@VK?�T�BH��BI�K��AECKK���G�E@?E�E��BS�TECB?BVK@>BS

lP�>NB�)�m�>?BVK@>B�KK�JEZ�E���@@J�?�B��?D�>�>�JKZT���B?KCD�

@?�K��U��B�JKZME@PH��@?�K��U��E�M��)

qPJ�K?@I0��K>E?E�UK� ��Z�UK�JK�ET�BI?BI�JEZ�E�T�E�K@?B��

EAC�@?B�W>E�EJBVK@>BS�E?�EkK�B�)�OB��Y��S���tEP���B�T�KHC�M�C

BHK^�T�K���LK�BI�O�CD@>EME����E�����@�EAEH�P^�W>E�EJBVK@>P^

Page 171: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

GE�P0���KJK��E�TEHVB�B��KK�JKZHP���EH�EJP��KZBJP�AKGET�@�E@?B

B�HEA��CIC�Q�}@CKHPK?�E?JK?B?D0�V?E�H�ZK���@KMEH�Ik�K����T�IZK��

�E��@B?P�NBB�O�CB���ET�KHKCK��E��@?KTK�B�PZK��UTEC�IK?�>CB�B��

ME�P^�B��U�EV�P^�lP�>NB^�HCI�EAKBS�@?E�E�~). �=�K���LK�BK�@>ECD

�K@?�ABCD�EME0�@?ECD�B���Z�EME���W>E�EJBVK@>EJ�B�MKEM��lBVK@>EJ

E?�EkK�BB��KMBE�����@?�ABCD�P^�GE�P���EM�EJ�E��@?KTK�B�@EHK��

@?�E��CE�AU�TECEZB?KCD�E��?���@lE�J�NBB�>E�lCB>?�0��K�ME�E�I

PZK�E�T�EVBS��UMEH�S)�RAS�GNK��JEZK?�@JP?B?D���H���EJ�@CPV�K�JKZ�

HP���EH�U���KZBJ�AKGET�@�E@?B0��E��@I>BK�JEMPLBK�AU?D�HCI�RA�

S�GBB��KM�?B��UK�TE@CKH@?�BI� W?EME0�JEMP?�AU?D��K�?��CBGE���U

?EV�UJ0��KH�P@JU@CK��UJ�ET�KHKCK�BKJ�M����?B��B�P@CE�B��?�>E�

ME��KZBJ�0�@?KTK�B�PV�@?BI�B�lP�>NB��@�JBS�M����?E�0�AKGP@CE��E)

qCI��@KS�HECZ�E�AU?D�I@�E0�V?E�O�CD@>B�����E��I�CIK?@I��KE?wKJ�

CKJE��V�@?D^�zK@TPACB>B�RAS�GBI)

[�W>E�EJBVK@>E��EAC�@?B�V�KG�UV���E���Z�E��G�H�VK��HCI�RA�

S�GBB�I�CIK?@I��@K@?E�E��II��K�ABCB?�NBI�>�>���G�PkK��E���E���K�

JI��E��U�V�@?B�B�l��@?�P>?P�U0�?�>�B�T�EHECZ�^LK��HKM��HB�E�

��?D�TE@CK��E��U�E@?��kK�@I�V�@?B)�=EJELD��E��@K@?E�E��K���K��

ABCB?�NBB�W>E�EJB>B�AUC��T�KHCEZK�����@�EK���KJI�JKZHP���EH�

�UJB�E�M��BG�NBIJB0���@�IGB�@�VKJ�RAS�GB^�TE@KL�C��JB@@BI�TE

ET�KHKCK�B^��PZH0�>E?E�E��AUCE�T�E�KHK�E��@K@?E�E��KK�EA@CKHE�

���BK�B����E@�E�K�KME�TEHME?E�CK��EAwKJB@?U��HE>C�H)�]H��>E�T�K�

HE@?��CK�BK�TEJELB�RAS�GBB�M�PGB�@>�I�@?E�E���P�IGU��C��@�EH�E�

��KJK��UJ��EG���LK�BKJ�AKZK�NK������@^�?K��B?E�B^�RAS�GBB0���

V?E�TE@CKH�II��K�@EMC�k�C�@D0�B��K�@EMC�@B?@I0�SE?I�@�EBJB�@BC�JB

��TEC�E��JK�K��E@@?��E�B?D�W>E�EJB>P��K���@E@?EI�BB)�|E�O�PGBI

JEMC��AU� @EHK�@?�E��?D�T�EM��JJK� �@K@?E�E��K�� W>E�EJBVK@>E�

�K�ABCB?�NBB�RAS�GBB0��E�TK��US0�K@CB�APHK?�HE@?BM�P?��HEME�E�K��

�E@?D�E?�E@B?KCD�E�O�CD@>EME����E��0�>�>�@�EAEH�E��W>E�EJBVK@�

>E��GE�U0�V?E���TK��P^�EVK�KHD�APHK?����TECDGP0�T�EZB��^LKJP�?�J

M�PGB�@>EJP���@KCK�B^)�[E��?E�US0�JEMC��AU�AU?D���G��AE?����T�E�

M��JJ��BJTCKJK�?�NBB��EG���LK�BI�AKZK�NK��B�ET�KHKCK�BK�E?HKCD�

�US�CE>�CD�US�?EVK>���H�PMBS����E��S0�>PH��JEMCB�AU��EG���?B?D@I

�KAECDkBK�M�PTTU�AKZK�NK��T�B�@EMC�@BB�JK@?�EME���@KCK�BI�8W?E

.�OB��Y��S���tEP���B)�O�PGB�E��AS�G@>B��>E�lCB>?����KMBE��CD�EJ�>E�?K>�

@?K)iiO�PGB�U�B��AS�GU)�=P?D�>�T�BJB�K�B^)�tE@>��0�.55;0�@)�.4-)

Page 172: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�KEASEHBJEK�P@CE�BK:)�[�?�K?DBS0��AS�G@>�I�@?E�E���H�K?�@EMC�@BK

���TEH>C^VK�BK�>�TK�KME�E��EJP�T�ENK@@P�TE���G��AE?>K�@EMC�kK�

�BI�T�KH@?��B?KCK��AKZK�NK�0� SE?I� AU��� >�VK@?�K���AC H�?KCK�)

RAS�G@>�I�@?E�E����BVKME�E?�W?EME��K�TE?K�IK?0�G�?E�P�E�K�D����Z�

HKA�E@?B�@E�@?E�E�U�AKZK�NK��APHK?�TE�BZK�)�p?E?�k�M�TEJEZK?

E@EG���B^�BJB�@CEZB�kK�@I��K�CD�E@?B�B��U��AE?>K�AECKK���GPJ�

�EME�TEHSEH�)

RAS�GBI�HECZ���BJK?D�@EA@?�K��UK��EE�PZK��UK�@BCU)�[�T�E�

K>?�S�.5.5�.5,-� M)0� �� >E?E�US� ?�>ZK�T�KHP@J�?�B��C�@D�TEHEA��I

JK��0�E�B�>EJTCK>?E��CB@D�TE�?K��B?E�B�CD�EJP�T�BG��>P)�|�CBVBK

@EA@?�K��US��EE�PZK��US�@BC�I�CIK?@I�EAIG�?KCD�UJ�>EJTE�K�?EJ

ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B�B���@?EI?KCD�E���KEASEHBJE@?D^���P@CE�BIS��K�

@?�ABCD�EME�E>�PZK�BI0�>�>�M����?�AKGET�@�E@?B)�RAS�GBI�G�>C^V��

K?�@�O�PGBK��@TKNB�CD�U��HEME�E��BCB��>C^V�K?�E?HKCD�U��TP�>?��

@E�JK@?�EK�EALKK�@EMC�kK�BK0�MHK�EME���B��K?@I0�V?E�?K��B?E�B�CD�

�UK�lE�JB�E���BI�RAS�GBB��K�APHP?�B@TECDGE��?D@I��B�T�B�>�>BS

EA@?EI?KCD@?��S�T�E?B��O�PGBB0�G��B@>C^VK�BKJ�?KS�@CPV�K�0�>EMH��@

KK�@?E�E�U�JEZK?�TE@CKHE��?D�>�>�I�CBAE�TETU?>��@BCE�EME�H��CK�

�BI)�RAS�GBI�?�>ZK�EAIGPK?@I��K�H���?D�B@TECDGE��?D�@�E^�?K��B?E�

�B^�HCI�>�>BS�CBAE����ZHKA�US��>NB��T�E?B��O�PGBB�@E�@?E�E�U

?�K?DKME�ME@PH��@?��)�]�?EJ�ZK0�>�>P^�TECEZB?KCD�P^��ECD�JEZK?

@UM��?D�NB�BCBGE����U��B�@?B?P?��EE�PZK��US�@BC0�I���JK�K��AE�

CKK�TEH�EA�E�ME�E�B?D���H�CD�K�kKJ)

[�EHB?@I� ?�>ZK�T�B�NBT�H�E��EME� M��ZH��@?��0� TE� >E?E�EJP

M��ZH��B��RAS�GBB0�TE��UAE�P0�JEZK?�T�B�I?D�?�>ZK�M��ZH��@?�E

>�>E��CBAE�B�E��@?���U)�|E�W?P�JK�P���HE�P�IG�?D�@���KHK�BKJ�B

T�BG���BKJ��E�US��AS�G@>BS�T�@TE�?E�)�[�V�@?�E@?B0�W?P�B�BNB�?B�

�P��UH�BM�K?���@�EKJ0�TE>��KLK��K�EA���EHE����EJ����B��?K�T�EJK�

ZP?EV�E��JEHKCB0�@PSPJ@>B��TECB?ECEM�q�CBC��=BCB�)

[�T�EHECZK�BK�W>E�EJBVK@>E��CB�BB���@@PZHK�BI0�JEZ�E�G�>�

C^VB?D�?�JEZK��EK�@EMC�kK�BK�JKZHP�RAS�GBK��B�O�PGBK�)�[�@CP�

V�K�E?>�U?BI�>EJJP�B>�NB�� G�>C^VK�BK� ?�>EME� �EH�� @EMC�kK�BI

APHK?�H�ZK��KBGAKZ�UJ�B�@?��K?���V�CEJ�NB�BCBGE����US�E?�EkK�

�B��JKZHP�@?E�E��JB)

{��K�k�I���GJUkCK�BI0�I�@�KHP��EKHB�E�?K�TE@UC>B0�>E?E�UK

GHK@D�T�KH@?��BC)�|�BAECKK�T�BKJCKJUJ�TP?KJ���G��AE?>B�>�>�T�E�

Page 173: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

JKZP?EV�E�0�?�>�B�TEC�EJ�@k?�A�E��JEHKCB�B�P@CE�BKJ�KK��K�CBG��

NBB�I�CIK?@I�TP?D�>E�@ENBE��CBGJ��B�@EGH��BI�V�@?BV�E��ME@PH���

@?�K��E@?B���RAS�GBB0�>E?E��I���@CPV�K�T�B�I?BI�T�EJKZP?EV�E�

JEHKCB�APHK?�B�V�@?BV�E�T�BG����0���?�>ZK�@EGH��BK�T�KH@?��B?KCD�

�E��>EJB@@BB�BCB�TE@?EI��E�HK�@?�P^LK��>E�lK�K�NBB�@�PV�@?BKJ

�@KS�@?E�E�0��K�?ECD>E�TE@�KH�B>E�0��E�B�T�KH@?��B?KCK��E?�AKZK��

NK�)�=�B�@EAC^HK�BB�?�>E��?�KS@?E�E��K��>EJAB��NBB�T�EJKZP?EV�

�UK�B�B�UK�T�EK>?U�JB��EME�P�KMPCB�E���BI�B�@E@PLK@?�E���BI

T�KH@?��CIK?@I��EGJEZ�UJ�B���G��AE?�?D0�B��K�CBGE��?D)

�!������"8�qE���V�C��EA@PZHK�BI�P�JK�I�?�>E���ET�E@��>�>E���TE@�CKHE��?KCD�E@?D�JK��TE�P>�KTCK�B^�HE�K�BI0�?)K)�>�>BK�k�MB�JEZK?

@HKC�?D� >�ZH�I� @?E�E��\�qETP@?BJ0� @� M�PGB�@>E�� @?E�E�U�?�>BJ

k�MEJ�JEZK?�@?�?D�@�I?BK�@��>NB�)�F�>BJ�JEZK?�AU?D�E?�K?�@��AS�G�

@>E��@?E�E�U\

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�p?E�PZK�E?HKCD��I�T�EACKJ�)�qPJ�^0�W?E?��ET�E@��HE�APHK?��Kk�?D�����J>�S�@�JEME�T�ENK@@�)�qKCE���?EJ0�V?E�@�I?BK

W>E�EJBVK@>BS�@��>NB��?EZK�?�KAPK?�@EE?�K?@?�P^LK��TECB?B>B)

XPLK@?�PK?�ET�KHKCK��U��P�E�K�D��KHE�K�BI)�X>�ZKJ0�>EMH��JU��

sCI��B�MK�B���OK�J��BB�ME�E�BCB�EA�W?E��T�EACKJK�B���V�CB��H��

��?D@I���HK?�CB0��H�PM�EA���PZBCE@D0�V?E�H�ZK��AS�G@>�I�@?E�E��0

G�B�?K�K@E�����I���@�I?BB�W>E�EJBVK@>BS�@��>NB�0�BG�G��E?@P?@?�BI

HE�K�BI�JEZK?�VP�@?�E��?D�>�>E��?E�TEH�ES�BCB�?�KAE��?D�@CBk>EJ

AECDkBS�P@?PTE>�@E�@?E�E�U�O�PGBB)

=�EACKJ���E?���VKJ��JEZK?�AU?D0�@�I?BK�W?BS�@��>NB��HECZ�E

AU?D�AKGP@CE��UJ0���JEZK?0��PZ�U�>�>BK�?E�E?�K?�UK�k�MB�B�?)H)0�?E

K@?D�HECZ���AU?D��U��AE?����TECB?B>��@�I?BI�W>E�EJBVK@>BS�@��>�

NB�)�|E�I�HPJ�^0�V?E�@�I?BK�@��>NB��JEZ�E�@E�JK@?B?D�8B�?�>EK�@E�

�JKLK�BK0����K��EK0��KBGAKZ�E:�@�>�>BJ�?E�?�JEZK��UJ�@EMC�kK�

�BKJ�Q�?E�K@?D�@�I?D�W>E�EJBVK@>BK�@��>NBB0�E?>�U?D�>EJJP�B>��

NBB�B�HE@?BVD�?�JEZK��EME�@EMC�kK�BI)�p?E0�I�HPJ�^0���B�?K�K@�S

O�PGBB�?EZK)�oE?I�GHK@D�K@?D0�JEZK?�AU?D0�VB@?E�W>E�EJBVK@>BK��^�

��@U0�>E?E�UK�I�JEMP�B��K�PC��CB��?D0��E�J�K�T�KH@?��CIK?@I0�V?E

E?>�U?BK�>EJJP�B>�NB��E?�KV�K?�B�?K�K@�J�B�M�PGB�@>E��@?E�E�U0

Page 174: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

E�����W?EJ��PZH�K?@I)�R���B�?K�K@�S��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U�Q�@�I?BK�W>E�

�EJBVK@>BS�@��>NB�)�Y�>�V?E�?�JEZK��EK�@EMC�kK�BK�B��@K��KEASE�

HBJEK���HE0�@>E�KK��@KME0�HKC�?D���EH�EJ�T�>K?K)

��������%�"�8�n�JK�I�H����ET�E@�)�=K��U���ET�E@��@VB?�K?K�CB�U��EGJEZ�UJ�@PLK@?�E���BK��EE�PZK��US�@BC0�>EMH��JU��@K�TE�B�

J�KJ0�V?E�W?E�APHP?�J�EME��NBE��CD�UK��EE�PZK��UK�@BCU\�|�@>ECD�

>E��K�CD�E0�V?E��AS�GU�B�M�PGB�U�APHP?�@CPZB?D���EH�E����NBE��CD�

�E��M���HBB0�H��KLK�B��EE�PZK��UK0�B�W?E�T�B�?EJ�ME�D>EJ�ETU?K0

>E?E�U��JU�BJKKJ\

���?E�E���ET�E@��@VB?�K?K�CB��U0�V?E���kB��C�@?B0�8�K�G��^0�>�>

�C�@?B�O�PGBB:�ME?E�U�TEHKCB?D@I�@���JB�B�TEG�ECB?D���J�?EZK�PV��

@?�E��?D���TK�KME�E��EJ�T�ENK@@K\�|�@>ECD>E�I�TE�IC�0��U�@VB?�K?K

�EGJEZ�UJ�@EGH��BK�>�>BS�?E�>EJAB�B�E����US�M�PTT��FE�KV�E0

��BHK�CK�W?E�AUCE�AU�SE�EkE0��E�I�@KMEH�I�@E�K�kK��E��K��BZP�?��

>E��ME?E��E@?B�@E�@?E�E�U���kBS��C�@?K��Q�C^A�I�TETU?>��T�KHCE�

ZB?D�>�>E��?E�@�E��TC����UGU��K?�@E�K�kK��E�ZP?>P^�BS��K�>NB^)

y�W?E�B@TU?�C�����@KAK0�>EMH���BVKME�?�>EME�PZ�@?��k�EME��K�T�KH�

CEZBC�0��E�W?E�TE@CPZBCE�TE�EHEJ�HCI�?�KS�@?�?K�0���>E?E�US�JK�I

l�>?BVK@>B�EA�B�BCB���T�KH�?KCD@?�K���NBE��CD�US�B�?K�K@E�)�F�>

�U�HPJ�K?K0�>�>�W?E�JEZ�E�T�KEHECK?D\

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�y0�>@?�?B0�ME�E�BC�����V�CK�@�EKME��U@?PTCK�BI0V?E�>EMH��V?E�?E�T�KHC�M�K?@I�BCB��EEALK�>?E�?E�G��BJ�K?@I�W?E�

T�EACKJE�0��C�@?B�@JE?�I?�B@>E@�)�p?��T�EACKJ��HK�@?�B?KCD�E�@P�

LK@?�PK?)�p?E�@�EKME��EH��T�EACKJ��TE@?�EK�BI�HE�K�BI�JKZHP��C��

@?IJB�B�EALK@?�K��UJ�BCB�ETTEGBNBE��UJ�@TK>?�EJ)�8=E?EJP�V?E

I�@VB?�^0�V?E���W?EJ�HECZ�U�T�B�I?D�PV�@?BK�B�ETTEGBNBE��UK�@BCU)

X>�ZKJ0���O�PGBB�zK@TPACB>��@>�I�T��?BI�I�CIK?@I�ETTEGBNBE��E�0

B�H�PMBK�ETTEGBNBE��UK�@BCU�JEMP?�PV�@?�E��?D�?EZK):

��������%�"�8�F�>E���K�CD�U��TP?D�TEH>C^VK�BI��KElBNB�CD�USCBN�>�ElBNB�CD�EJP�TK�KME�E��EJP�T�ENK@@P\

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�|��@KMEH�Ik�B��HK�D��C�@?B�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�E?�

�K�M�^?�?�>P^��EGJEZ�E@?D)�|E0��E�TK��US0��EGJEZ�U�BGJK�K�BI�B

Page 175: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

��@�JE���C�@?B0��E��?E�US0�I�T�KHC�M�^�?ECD>E�JEHKCD)�FE�KV�E0��@?��

K?��ET�E@����?KVK�BK�>�>EME���KJK�B�E���JEZK?�AU?D�E@PLK@?�CK���B

>�>�TEH>C^VB?D�?E?�BCB�B�E��@TK>?��EALK@?���>���AE?K���H�?�>BJB

T�EK>?�JB\�p?E?��ET�E@�I�E@?��CI^�E?>�U?UJ0�I��K�JEMP�@K�V�@���

�KME�E?�K?B?D)�t�K�CBV�E�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�?E0�V?E�I�T�KHCEZBC�Q�W?E

KHB�@?�K��U��TP?D0�V?EAU�>�VKJP�?E�T�B�?B0�H�PMEME�TP?B�I�T�E@?E

�K��BZP)�q�PME��TP?D�Q�?E?0�V?E�P���@�PZK�K@?D0�?)K)��C�@?B�MHK�?E�V?E�

?E��Kk�^?0�V?E�?E�T�KHC�M�^?0��E�V?E�?E��K�T�B�BJ�K?@I0���V?E�?E

E?�K�M�K?@I)�|E� K@CB�JEZK?�AU?D��U��AE?����>�>�I�?E�JEHKCD0� ?E

�KEASEHBJ�>E�@K�@P@�@E�@?E�E�U�?KS0�>EME�W?��JEHKCD�APHK?�>�@�?D@I0

B��VK�W?E���IH�CB�APHK?��EGJEZ�E)�|��@KMEH�Ik�B��HK�D��C�@?B0�>

@EZ�CK�B^0�HK�@?�B?KCD�E��K�ME?E�U�B��K�SE?I?)�[EGJEZ�E0�AU��^?

B@>C^VK�BI)�|��sCI��B�M@>E���@?�KVK0���>E?E�E��I�T�B�BJ�C�PV�@�

?BK0�AUCE�TE�EH�EJP0�TE�H���T�KH@?��B?KCI�E?��KT���B?KCD@?�K��US

E�M��BG�NB�0��@K�E@?�CD�UK�AUCB�ElBNB�CD�UK�CBN�0��E�W?E�AUCB

TK�KME�E�U��KElBNB�CD�EME�P�E��I)�qKCE���?EJ0�V?E�>EMH��I�T�KHC��

M�^�>E�lK�K�NB^0�?E�BJK^����BHP0�V?E�W?��>E�lK�K�NBI�Q��K�TK�KME�

�E��U��T�ENK@@0�W?E�>E�lK�K�NBI0���AE?�^L�I���H�@�JE��JEHKCD^

B�T�KHC�M�^L�I��C�@?IJ�ET�KHKCK��UK��KkK�BI)�|E�@��C�@?IJB�HEC�

Z���AU?D�HEME�E�K��E@?D�E�?EJ0�V?E�T�KHCEZK�BI�>E�lK�K�NBB�AP�

HP?�T�B�I?U)

�?E�>�@�K?@I���JBB)�y�BJKC����BHP0�V?E���HE�PG�>E�B?D�@KMEH�

�Ik�KK�TECEZK�BK)�XCPZ�?�M�PGB�U�����JBB�BCB��K�@CPZ�?�Q�W?E�PZK

H�PME���ET�E@)�tEZK?�AU?D0�@E���KJK�KJ0�>EMH��TECEZK�BK�@?�ABCB�

GB�PK?@I�B���V�K?@I�T�ENK@@�T�BJB�K�BI0�B�E�B� @JEMP?� @CPZB?D)

=EVKJP��K�HETP@?B?D0�V?E�E�B�@JEMP?�@CPZB?D�����JBB\�|E�W?E�PZK

H�PME��W?�T)�XK�V�@���HE�PG�>E�B?D�?P�@B?P�NB^0�>E?E��I�PZK�@PLK�

@?�PK?0��KG��B@BJE�E?�?EME0�@CPZ�?�?�J�M�PGB�U�BCB��K?)

�� ������/%!��-8�|KPZKCB�����kKJ�T�EK>?K��KCDGI�AUCE�T�KHCE�

ZB?D�V?E�?E�AECDkKK���IGU>E�EJ��ET�E@K\�y�PZK��K�ME�E�^�EA���JBB

B�?)H)�[U�ME�E�BCB�?ECD>E�E�>PCD?P��E����?E�EJBB)�O�PAE�ME�E�I0�K@CB

�U�BHK?K�TP?KJ�@EGH��BI�EALKME�>E�lKHK��?B��EME�ME@PH��@?��0�K@�

?K@?�K��E0��@?�K?��ET�E@�E�H�PS0�JEZK?0�?�KS0���JEZK?0�B�AECDkKJ

VB@CK�ME@PH��@?�K��US�IGU>E�����?K��B?E�BB�RAS�GBB)�[U�T�KHC��

M�K?K�J�>@BJPJ�?EME0�V?E�JEZK?K�T�KHCEZB?D\

Page 176: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�p?E��K�J�>@BJPJ�?EME0�V?E�I�JEMP�T�KHCEZB?D0W?E�J�>@BJPJ�?EME0�V?E�JEZ�E�@HKC�?D0�B@SEHI�BG�@B?P�NBB)��?E�>�@��

K?@I�>PCD?P��E����?E�EJBB0�?E�W?E0�>E�KV�E0�@?��U��?K�JB�)�]?�E�

@B?KCD�E�IGU>��I�BJK^����BHP0�V?E�M�PGB�@>EK���@KCK�BK�HECZ�E�BJK?D

�EGJEZ�E@?D�TEC�E@?D^��K�CBGE��?D�lP�>NBB�IGU>����AU?P�B�?)H)0

TECPV�?D�EA��GE���BK0�>�>�E�E�W?EME�SEVK?�B�JEZK?)

R�V?E�>�@�K?@I�TECB?BVK@>EME�JEJK�?�0�?E�W?E��K�TECB?BVK@�

>B��JEJK�?���EAUV�EJ�TE�BJ��BB)�y�ME�E�^�GHK@D�E�TECB?BVK@>EJ

PV�@?BB���@JU@CK�>E�@ENBE��CBGJ�)�YE�K@?D0�K@CB���RAS�GBB0�HETP�

@?BJ0�P?�K�HB?@I�W?��JEHKCD�>E�@ENBE��CBGJ�0�?E����KGPCD?�?K�>E��

@K�@P@�0�EALK@?�K��EME�HEME�E��0�M�PGB�@>�I�EALB���@JEZK?�?�>

ZK�PV�@?�E��?D���EALK@?�K��E��ZBG�B����HECK�E��E@�E�K0� >�>�B

E@?�CD�UK���NBE��CD�UK�EALB�U)�u@?K@?�K��E0�E���APHK?�BJK?D

@EE?�K?@?�P^LBK�TECB?BVK@>BK�T����)�|E�HCI�W?EME�HECZ�E�AU?D

@EE?�K?@?�P^LKK�@EMC�kK�BK0�B�?�J�W?E�HECZ�E�AU?D�EME�E�K�E)

t�K�@K�V�@�@CEZ�E�@>�G�?D�G����KK0�>�>�W?E�TE�HK?0�W?E�AUCE�AU

�KJ�EZ>E�CKM>EJU@CK��E�@�JEK��@?E�E�U)��?E�>�@�K?@I�ME@PH���

@?�K��EME�IGU>�0�?E�TEH��GPJK��K?@I�B@TECDGE���BK�KME�>�>�A^�E>�

��?BVK@>EME�IGU>�0�>�>�IGU>��JKZ��NBE��CD�EME�EALK�BI)�YE0�V?E

�U�ME�E�B?K�Q�W?E�PZK�AECKK�kB�E>B��@TK>?�0���W?EJ�@JU@CK�HECZ�

�U��UTP@>�?D@I�M�GK?U�B�?)H)0�W?E��E�J�CD�EK�I�CK�BK�B0�I�@VB?�^0

EAIG�?KCD�EK)

��,� ��.�S,���8�tE���ET�E@� >�@�K?@I�P@?�E�@?���RAS�GBB)�y

SE?KC�AU�P@CUk�?D�E?���@�P?EV�K�BK��>�>�W?B�EALB�U�Q�M�PGB�@>�I0

�AS�G@>�I�B�H�PMBK�Q�APHP?�@E@PLK@?�E��?D�H�PM�@�H�PMEJ\�u@?D�ETU?

��G�US�@?���0�K@?D�ETU?�rB����0�ETU?�xKCDMBB)�[��K>E?E�US�@?���

��S�W?E�lKHK��NBI0���H�PMBS����HK�U�B�UK��KkK�BI0��E�K@CB�JU�SE�

?BJ0�V?EAU�RAS�GBI�AUC��@?�ABCD�E��B�ZBG�K@TE@EA�E��TECB?BVK@�

>E��KHB�BNK�0�?E�AKG�ET�KHKCK��EME�A�C��@��W?E���IH�CB�TECPVB?@I)

F�>���J��BHB?@I�W?E?�A�C��@\�F�>E���APHK?�TECB?BVK@>�I�lE�J����P?�

�BME@PH��@?�K��EME�P@?�E�@?���RAS�GBB\

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�p?E�PZK��USEHB?�G����J>B�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHK�CB)�|E�HPJ�^0�V?E�@A�C��@B�E����E��JEHKCD^�HCI�TECB?BVK@>EME

P@?�E�@?���I�CIK?@I�>�>���G�JEHKCD�>E�@ENBE��CBGJ�)��JK��E�E��

Page 177: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

TEG�ECIK?�@EGH�?D�A�C��@�B�?K�K@E�����E@�E�K�EALK@?�K��EME�HEME�

�E��)

�������!"�#�-8�YU�ME�E�BC�E� �EGJEZ�EJ�H�E��EJ� M��ZH��@?�K)F�>EK��?E�EK�M��ZH��@?�E�HCI��U�Kk�BS�ZB?KCK��RAS�GBB�?U�BJKC

���BHP��M�PGB�@>EK0��E@@B�@>EK�BCB�KLK�>�>EK��BAPHD\�p?E�TK��U�

�ET�E@)

F�>�I�TE�IC0�T��>?BVK@>B0���P@CE�BIS�T�EJKZP?EV�EME�TK�BEH�

�EGJEZ�E��EG���LK�BK�AKZK�NK�)�F�>�?U�@VB?�KkD\�qETP@?BJ0�@P�

LK@?�PK?�T�EJKZP?EV�U��TK�BEH0�>E?E�U���K�P@?��B��K?��B�M�PGB�0

�B��AS�GE�)�z�GPJKK?@I0���HE�HPJ�?D�E�APHPLKJ�P@?�E�@?�K0�AECKK

@?�ABCD�EJ�@?�?P@K0�>E?E�U��P@?��B��C�AU��@KS)�{��W?E?�TK�BEH�JE�

MP?��K��P?D@I��@K�AKZK�NU)�|K�APHK?�CB�W?��@B?P�NBI�HK@?�ABCBGB�E�

��?D�H�CD�K�kB��T�ENK@@�ET�KHKCK�BI�TECB?BVK@>EME�@?�?P@��RAS��

GBB�B�KK��G�BJEE?�EkK�B��@�O�PGBK�\

��?�K?B���ET�E@)�YU�T�KHCEZBC�EVK�D�J�EME��KkK�B�0�>E?E�UK

BCB�JEZ�E��K�CBGE��?D0�BCB��KCDGI0�B�I�T�KHTEC�M�^0�V?E�P�?KAI�K@?D

>�>�I�?E�KLK�AECKK�H�CD�II�TK�@TK>?B��)��?E�?U�BJKKkD����BHP�TE@�

CK�T�EJKZP?EV�EME�TK�BEH�\�FEMH��VKCE�K>�HKC�K?�>�>BK�?E�k�MB0

�K@>ECD>E�k�ME�0�?E�JKZHP�VKJ�B�VKJ0���>�>P^�@?E�E�P\�YE�K@?D0��EG�

JEZ�E�ACK@?ILKK�APHPLKK�BCB��K�EVK�D�ACK@?ILKK0�V?E�?U�T�KHTEC��

M�KkD\

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�y��K�G��^0�V?E�?�>EK�ACK@?ILKK�BCB��K�ACK@?ILKK

APHPLKK)�z�GPJKK?@I0�JU���HKKJ@I0�V?E�APHK?�CPVkK0�K@CB�PH�@?@I

���?B��KkK�BK�TE�>�>BJ�?E��ET�E@�J0�W?E�K@?K@?�K��E)�|E0�JEZK?

AU?D0�GHK@D�T�EBGE�HK?�GKJCK?�I@K�BK0�B�JU��@K�T�E��CBJ@I0�B��K�

ACK@?ILKME�APHPLKME�?EZK��K�APHK?0�W?EME�I��K�G��^)�=�EJKZP?EV��I

JEHKCD�Q�W?E�EHB��BG�W?�TE��P�KMPCB�E���BI�E?�EkK�B�)�y�T�KHTE�

C�M�^0�V?E�K@CB�T�ENK@@���V�K?@I0�?E�E��T�B�KHK?0�BCB�JEZK?�T�B�K�

@?B0�>�TEC�EJP�P�KMPCB�E���B^0���W?E��PZ�E��@KJ0�V?EAU�@?�?D�V�@�

?D^�@E��KJK��EME�JB��)

�?E�>�@�K?@I��EG���LK�BI�AKZK�NK�0�I�GHK@D��K�ME�E�^�E�TEC�EJ

�EG���LK�BB�AKZK�NK�)�p?E?��ET�E@��K��SEHB?���T�EJKZP?EV�P^

JEHKCD0�I�KME��K�PTEJB��C�B��K�G��^0�E?>PH��?U�W?E��GIC)

Page 178: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�������!"�#�-8�|E�AUC�ZK���GME�E��E�?EJ0�V?E0��EGJEZ�E0�AKZK�NU@JEMP?��EG���L�?D@I0�V?E���T�EJKZP?EV�U��TK�BEH��EGJEZ�E��EG�

���LK�BK)�F?E�?E�HETP@>�K?0�V?E��K��P?@I��@K0�>?E�?E�Q�V?E�TECE�B��0

�E��KCDGI�ZK�@>�G�?D0�V?E�3;,�BG��BS0���T�BJK�0�JEMP?0���E@?�CD�UK

�K�JEMP?)�y�@E�K�kK��E�@EMC�@K��@�q��BHEJ�Q�CBAE�E�B�JEMP?��K��

�P?D@I0�CBAE��K?)�u@CB�E��T�K@?PT�B>0�E��HECZK��T�B�?B�B�E?�KV�?D

G��@�EB�HKI�BI�TE�G�>E��J�ME@PH��@?��0���>E?E�EK�E���K��PC@I)�y��K

G��^0�>?E�APHK?��KMPCB�E��?D�W?E?��ET�E@)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�u@?D�T���E�����EG���LK�BK�AKZK�NK�0�B�JU�G���

KJ0�>�>�M�PGB�@>�I�@?E�E���@?��B?�W?E?��ET�E@0��E�K@?D�B��K�CD�E@?D)

XKMEH�I��@K�TE�BJ�^?0�V?E�TEC�EK��EG���LK�BK�AKZK�NK��T�E@?E

�K�EGJEZ�E0�H�ZK�K@CB���RAS�GBB�W?EME�G�SE?I?)�[�?EJ�?E�B�G�>C^�

V�K?@I�@JU@C�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB0�V?EAU�HKC�?D�@KMEH�I�?E0�V?E

JEZ�E�@HKC�?D�@KMEH�I)�|K�?E0�V?EAU�E?JK�B?D�B�G�T�K?B?D�TEC�EK

�EG���LK�BK�AKZK�NK�0����K�T�KH�Kk�?D�KME����W?EJ�W?�TK)�=�B�

G��?D�?P��K�CD�E@?D0�V?E����T�EJKZP?EV�EJ�W?�TK�W?E��K�EGJEZ�E)

]H��>E�JEZ�E�T�E�K@?B��IH��>NB����O�CD@>EJ����E�K)�y��K�B@>C^�

V�^�H�ZK�V�@?BV�P^�BJTCKJK�?�NB^�?�>E��T�EM��JJU0�T�B�W?EJ

JEZ�E�T�KHP@JE?�K?D�>�>BK�?E�V�@?BV�UK�EM���BVK�BI0���MHK�JEZ�

�E0�B@@CKHE��?D����JK@?�S)))�X>�ZKJ0�JEMP?��EG���L�?D@I�TE�T�B��

NBTP��EH@?�K��US�@�IGK��B�?)H)�F�>BK�?E�JK�U�JEZ�E�T�KHP@JE?�

�K?D0��E�?ECD>E���EVK�D�EM���BVK��E��lE�JK)�[@K�W?E���HE���@@J�?�

�B��?D���NKCE@?�E@?B)�]@PLK@?�CK�BK�W?BS�k�ME����>EJTCK>@K�JE�

ZK?�BGJK�B?D�@B?P�NB^���NKCEJ0�B0�JEZK?�AU?D0�APHK?�T�EM�K@@0

BCB�E>�ZK?@I0�V?E�T�EM�K@@��K�EGJEZK�0��E�W?E�?EZK�>�>E��?E��K�

GPCD?�?)

|�@VK?�H�E��EME�M��ZH��@?��)�p?E�>�@�K?@I0�K@?K@?�K��E0��K�?ECD�

>E�M��ZH��@?���O�PGBB)�y�T�KHCEZBC�KME0���E@�E��EJ0�@�T�BNKCEJ���

AKZK�NK��Q�K@CB�E�B��EG���?I?@I0�?E�@JEMP?�BJK?D�H�E��EK�M��ZH���

@?�E0�G�SE?I?�Q�M�PGB�@>EK0��E0�K@?K@?�K��E0�T�B�P@CE�BB0�V?E�@?��P?

B�M��ZH���JB�RAS�GBB)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�H�E��EK�M��ZH��@?�E�Q�W?E�?EZK

ET�KHKCK���I�P@?PT>��@���kK��@?E�E�U)��?E�ZK�>�@�K?@I��@KME���@K�

CK�BB�RAS�GBB0�?E�E�E�JEZK?�BJK?D�B�H�PMBK�M��ZH��@?��)�p?E�?EZK

HECZ�E�AU?D�PG�>E�K�E)

Page 179: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

!.� �M"��8��G��@KME0�V?E�AUCE�@>�G��E0�J�K�AECDkK��@KME�TE����B�

CE@D�T�KHTECEZK�BK0�V?E0�JEZK?�AU?D0�JU��@K�T�E��CBJ@I)���� �

�������oEVP�HETEC�B?D��TP@?D�XEVB�?EZK�T�E��CB?@I0�V?EAU��B>EJP�K�AUCE�EABH�E)

R��ET�E@�P�JK�I�?�>E�)�|K�@EGH�K?@I�CB��TKV�?CK�BK0�V?E��@K�W?E

���@�JEJ�HKCK�PZK�@PLK@?�PK?�B�HK�@?�PK?0�B�TE@?EI��E�HK�@?�P^�

L�I�>E�lK�K�NBI�Q�W?E��BV?E�B�EK0�>�>�FEE�HB��NBE���I�>EJB@@BI\

r^HB�PZK�BJK^?�H�E��EK�M��ZH��@?�E0�T�BVKJ���G�US�@?���0�@��>�

NBB�?EZK�TE@?KTK��E�@�BJ�^?@I0�>�>BJ�?E�EA��GEJ�>EJTK�@B�P^?�

@I0�B��@K�W?B�T�ENK@@U�PZK�BHP?�AKG��@I>E��TE@?EI��E�HK�@?�P^LK�

>EJB@@BB)�|K�K@?D�CB�W?E0�?�>�@>�G�?D0�TETU?>��G�lB>@B�E��?D�@PLK�

@?�P^LP^����@�JEJ�HKCK�@B?P�NB^\

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�FE�KV�E0���>�>E��?E�JK�K�W?E�?�>0��E�?ECD>E���>��>E��?E�JK�K0�TE?EJP�V?E�H�E��EK�M��ZH��@?�E�BJKK?�H�CK>E��K��@K

��@KCK�BK)�|�k��JECEHKZD��EEALK�SEHB?�AKG�T�@TE�?E�)

�������!"�#�-8�q�E��EK�M��ZH��@?�E�Q�W?E�G��VB?0�P���@�APHK?��A�S�G@>EK�M��ZH��@?�E\�F�>EK�E�E�APHK?\�=�BG����EK�JKZHP���EH�UJ

@EEALK@?�EJ\

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�p?E�M��ZH��@?�E0�>E�KV�E0�HECZ�E�AU?D�T�BG���E)

�������!"�#�-8�YEMH���@K�E@?�CD�EK��K�BJKK?�G��VK�BI)�8�� � ������

�"�$��!.���0$�-8��?E�>�@�K?@I�@��>NB�0�W?E�KLK��ET�E@0���AE?�^?

E�B�BCB��K���AE?�^?)�qCI�>EME�?E�E�B���AE?�^?0�HCI�>EME�?E0�JEZK?0�B

�K?)�=E?EJP���G�B��K?@I�>�BJB��CD��I�W>E�EJB>�)�u@?K@?�K��E0�>�B�

JB��C�EASEHB?�C^AUK�@��>NBB�B�@�JP^�ZK@?>P^�ACE>�HP)�F@?�?B0

B�@?B?PNBE��CBG�NBI�W?EME�TEJEZK?�TE@?�EB?D��E�J�CD�UK�W>E�E�

JBVK@>BK�E?�EkK�BI0����K�>�BJB��CD�P^�W>E�EJB>P)

T.����MU���� �-8�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E��ET�E@U0�G�?�E�P?UK�RAK@�CE�

JEJ0�@�JUK�V?E��B����K@?D�>E�>�K?�UK)�u@CB�W?E?�T�EK>?�APHK?�T�E�

HECZ�?D@I�B�JU�APHKJ�EA@PZH�?D�?�>BK��ET�E@U0���k����AE?��@?��K?

B�?K�K@�KK0��@K�T�EACKJU�@?��P?�>E�>�K?�UJB)�Y�>BK�T�EJKZP?EV�

Page 180: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�UK�JEHKCB�Q�>�>�C�>JP@E��I�APJ�M���E�B�TE>�GU��^?0���VKJ�BJK��E

@P?D�T�E?B�E�KVB�0�>�>�I�T�EACKJ�� @�J�I�@CEZ��I�B�>�>BK��E�UK

T�EACKJU�JEMP?��EG�B>�P?D���H�CD�K�kKJ)�p?B��ET�E@U��EC�P^?

�@KS��>�>�BJK��E��@K�HECZ�E�T�EB@SEHB?D0�>�>�HECZK��BH?B�W?E?�T�E�

NK@@\

n�JK�I�?�>E���ET�E@)�X?��?KMBVK@>BJ�}>?E~���>�>EJ�?E�@JU@CK

I�CIKJ@I�B�JU)�|E�K@CB�ME�E�B?D�E�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB0��PZ�E

G�H�?D@I��ET�E@EJ�Q�K@?D�CB�B����U�Kk�KJ�T���B?KCD@?�K�C^HB0

>E?E�UK�JEMP?�@?�?D�@?��?KMBVK@>BJ�}>?E~\�u@?D�CB����U�Kk�K�

@B?P�NBB��EEALK�?�>BK�C^HB0�>E?E�UK�JEMP?�AU?D�G�B�?K�K@E���U

���K�CBG�NBB�TEHEA�E��JEHKCB\�t�K0�>E�KV�E0��K��PZ�U�BJK��0��E

T�KH@?��BJ��CB�?�>�I�@B?P�NBI\�|K>E?E�UK�B�BNB�?B�U��KT���B�

?KCD@?�K��US�E�M��BG�NB���K��K�CBGP^?@I)�|�kB�B�BNB�?B�U�JU

JEZKJ�HE�K@?B0��E�>�>�BS�E@PLK@?�B?D\�F�>��U�@KAK�W?E�T�KH@?���

CIK?K\

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�y�JEMP�E?�K?B?D�?�>��K@CB��KVD�BHK?�E�TK�@E��CB�IS�8�K�BJK��S:0�?E�I�HETP@>�^0�V?E�?�J�K@?D�G�B�?K�K@E����UK�C^HB)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�[U�@>�G�CB0�V?E�C^HB�JEMP?��K��P?D@I��O�CD@>B�����E��B�BJK?D�H�E��EK�M��ZH��@?�E�Q��AS�G@>EK�B�M�PGB�@�

>EK)�]G��V�K?�CB�W?E0�V?E�BS�T�����APHP?�G�LBLK�U\�]G��V�K?�CB�W?E0

V?E�@PLK@?�P^?�E�M��U�JK@?�EME�@�JEPT���CK�BI\�]G��V�K?�CB�W?E0

V?E�M�PGB�@>BK�k>ECU���O�CD@>EJ����E�K�@PA@BHB�P^?@I��AS�G@>BJ

A^HZK?EJ\

��KLK���@VK?�M��ZH��@?��)�X�EH�E��@?E�E�U0�W?E�T�EJKZP?EV�

�EK�@EMC�kK�BK�Q�AKG�EA@PZHK�BI�@?�?P@�)�|��H���U��JEJK�?�RAS��

GBB�>�>��KG��B@BJEME�ME@PH��@?����K?0�?E�K@?D�E����K�T�BG����0��E0

?KJ��K�JK�KK0�APHK?��AS�G@>B��T�@TE�?0�>E?E�U�0���@>ECD>E�I�TE�IC0

APHK?�T�B�BJ�?D@I�M�PGB�@>E��@?E�E�E�0��E@@B�@>E��@?E�E�E��B��@K�

JB�G�B�?K�K@E����UJB�@?E�E��JB)�Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�W?E?�@?�?P@�APHK?

CKM�CBGE������W?EJ�@����B?KCD�E�PG>EJ�>�PMP)�p?E�?�>\�YEMH���ET�E@)

[�O�CD@>EJ����E�K�l�>?BVK@>B�@EGH�K?@I�M�PGB�@>�I�JK@?��I��C�@?D0

�UAE���I��C�@?D)�xPHP?�CB�@PA@BHB�E��?D@I�M�PGB�@>BK�k>ECU���O�CB\

oE?I�AU����APJ�MK\

Page 181: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�n���@�B��AS�G@>BK�k>ECU�@?��H�^?)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E

HECZ�U�AU?D�E�M��U�JK@?�EME�@�JEPT���CK�BI0����ET�E@�@PA@BHB�

�E���BI��KJ�EZ>E�TE@CEZ�KK)�|��K��EK0�W?E�APHK?�G��B@K?D�E?�EA�

LKME�W>E�EJBVK@>EME�TECEZK�BI)�=E@>ECD>P��AS�G@>BK�B�C^AUK�H�P�

MBK�k>ECU���SEHI?@I���TC�VK��EJ�@E@?EI�BB0�?E�JEZ�E�APHK?�T�K�

HP@JE?�K?D�EALP^�T�EM��JJP�lB���@B�E���BI��@KS�k>EC�Q�K@?K�

@?�K��E0�B���O�CB�?EZK)

��������%�"�8�tEZ�E�HETEC�B?D\�=��>?BVK@>B0���O�CD@>EJ����E�

�K�K@?D�M�PGB�@>BK�k>ECU)�|K�G��^0���@>ECD>E�E?>�U?E�E�B���GU���

^?@I�M�PGB�@>BJB0��E�M�PGB�@>B��IGU>�?�J�T�KTEH�K?@I0�B�H�ZK�T�K�

TEH����BK�H�PMBS�T�KHJK?E���KHK?@I����M�PGB�@>EJ�IGU>K)�|E��AS�G�

@>BK��C�@?B�B��EEALK��AS�G@>EK�EALK@?�E�@��K>E?E�E����@?E�EZK��

�E@?D^�E?�E@I?@I�>�?EJP0�V?E�EAPVK�BK��KHK?@I�TE�M�PGB�@>BJ�T�E�

M��JJ�J)�Y�>0�BGPVK�BK�B@?E�BB�BHK?�TE�M�PGB�@>BJ�PVKA�B>�J)�Y��

>BJ�EA��GEJ0�HK?IJ�@�HK?@?���T�B�B��K?@I�B@?E�BVK@>�I�HE>?�B��0

>E?E��I�@E�K�kK��E��K�P@?��B��K?��AS�GE�)�u@?K@?�K��E0�W?E�AK@TE�

>EB?��AS�G@>P^�@?E�E�P)�[�@�B�?K�K@E��C��ElBNB�CD��I�TEGBNBI\�[

tB�B@?K�@?�K�B�E@?����US�HKC�RAS�GBB�I�@CUk�C��?�>P^�?EV>P�G�K�

�BI0�V?E�M�CDNU0�>E�KV�E0�BJK^?�T���E�EAPV�?D@I����M�PGB�@>EJ�IGU�

>K0��E�HECZ�U�AU?D�@EE?�K?@?�P^LBK�PVKA�B>B0�>E?E�UK�P@?��B���

CB�AU��AS�G@>P^�@?E�E�P)

�� �%!���R�S���8�F?E�APHK?�@E@?��CI?D�W?B�PVKA�B>B\

��������%�"�8�y��K�G��^)�]AE��@KJ�W?EJ0����K��EK0���HE�ME�E�B?D)�.( � ��������G�B�B?K0����U�@VB?�K?K0�V?E��AS�GU�JEMP?�HETP@?B?D0

V?EAU����?K��B?E�BB�RAS�GBB�8TE�>����K��JK�K0�JU�@VB?�KJ�W?E�?K��

�B?E�BK��RAS�GBB:�T�KTEH���C�@D�B@?E�BI���?EJ�>E�?K>@?K0�V?E�APH�

?E�AU��AS�GU�Q�T�BkKCDNU\��CB�H�PM�I�?KE�BI�Q�H�P�AE�BMK��E@?B\

p?E�BHKECEMBI0�>E?E�P^�JU��K�T�B�BJ�KJ)

�� ������/%!��-8�T?E��@K�@E�K?@>BK�PVKA�B>B)

��������%�"�8�XE�K?@>BK�PVKA�B>B�AUCB���G�UK)�xUCB�M�PGB�@�>BK�@E�K?@>BK�PVKA�B>B0�AUCB��E@@B�@>BK0�AUCB��AS�G@>BK)�|E�@K��

Page 182: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

V�@��KVD�BHK?�E�M�PGB�@>BS�PVKA�B>�S�B�E�@EE?�K?@?�P^LK��BHKECE�

MBB)�XEMC�@B?K@D0�EH�E�HKCE�T�KTEH���?D����M�PGB�@>EJ�J�?KJ�?B>P0

��H�PMEK�HKCE�Q�B@?E�B^)��.( � ����> ��#���

��,� ��.�S,���8�n���@���VB��K?@I�T�EM��JJ��tB�E�EME�A��>�0

T�KHP@J�?�B��^L�I��KlE�JB�E���BK�@B@?KJU�@�KH�KME�EA��GE���BI)

�HKECEMBGB�E����UK�PVKA�B>B���@�?EZK��K�P@?��B��^?)��0����K��

�EK0���kB�B@?E�B>B����HP?���@KAK�@BCU���TB@�?D�V?E�?E�TEVK@?�KK)

xPHP?�EAwI�CK�U�?K�HK�U0�B��@K�APHK?�HKC�?D@I�TE�>E�>P�@P)�|E��EEA�

LK�?E0���HE�T�KHE@?��CI?D�T���E��UAE���k>EC�J�B��EHB?KCIJ0�W?E

JEI�CBV��I�?EV>��G�K�BI)�u@CB�>?E��BAPHD���qZ���SK?B�SEVK?�BGP�

V�?D�B@?E�B^��KCB>E��R�JK�BB�E?�FB?�I�HE�R?C��?BVK@>EME�TEAK�K�

ZDI0�?E�W?E�KME�T���E0�TP@?D�BGPV�K?)

�������!"�#�-8�y�SEVP�E?�K?B?D�����ET�E@�q��BH�0�APHP?�CB�k>ECU

O�CD@>EME����E���lB���@B�E��?D@I�BG�ME@PH��@?�K��EME�A^HZK?�)��?E

G��VB?�}APHP?~\�q�ZK�K@CB��K�G���AE?�K?�T�EJKZP?EV��I�JEHKCD0�H�ZK

K@CB�JU��EEALK���GAKZBJ@I�����G�UK�@?E�E�U�BCB�EAwKHB�BJ@I�Q

M�CD@>BK�k>ECU�PZK�lB���@B�P^?@I�BG�A^HZK?��RAS�GBB)�q�PMEK

HKCE0�V?E�TCESE�lB���@B�P^?@I0�B�H�PMEK�HKCE0�V?E�@PLK@?�PK?�}�BZ�

�II�GE��~0�>E?E��I��K�>E�?�ECB�PK?@I��B�M�PGB��JB0��B��AS�G�JB�Q

?�J�k>EC�T�E@?E��K?0�B�HK?B�@KMEH�I��K�PV�?@I)�[U0���EHK�AU0�ME�E�B�

?K�E�A�GE�US�T����S�VKCE�K>�0��E�G�AU��K?K�T�B�W?EJ�>�>BK�?E�E@�E��

�UK��KLB)

z�GPJKK?@I0���qZ���SK?BB�JEMP?�BGPV�?D�B@?E�B^�R�JK�BB)�|E

K@CB���?E��ZK�qZ���SK?BB�APHP?�EAPV�?D�B@?E�BB�O�PGBB0���TB@���

�E����JI��JB�@���JI�@>E��?EV>B�G�K�BI0��U0�@>E�KK��@KME0�APHK?K

@JE?�K?D����W?E��K@>ECD>E�B��VK)�u@CB�PVKA�B>�APHK?���TB@���>��

>BJ��BAPHD�H�k��>NP?^�E�@>BJ�B@?E�B>EJ0���?K>@?K�>E?E�EME�O�P�

GBI��EEALK�APHK?�E?@P?@?�E��?D0�?E����K��I>��H�ZK���@?B?P?�@�EAE�

HU0�>E?E�U��@KMEH�I�E?CBV�K?@I�?�>BJ�M��ZH��@>BJ���HB>�CBGJEJ0

APHK?�@JPLK�)�z�GME�E���K�E�?EJ0�V?E���O�CB�@EAB��^?@I�G�>�U��?D

k>ECU)�FEMH��JU�ME�E�BJ�E�?EJ0�V?E��@K�BJK^?�T���E�EAPV�?D@I���

@�EBS�IGU>�S0�JU�TE�BJ�KJ0�V?E�H�ZK�K@CB�AU�JU�EVK�D��K�SE?KCB

W?EME0�?E��K�JEMCB�AU��K�@>�G�?D)�R�JI�K�JEMP?0��P@@>BK�JEMP?0��@K

JEMP?0���M�PGB�U��K�JEMP?\�p?E��K�K�CD�E0����K�CD�E�?E0�V?E�@KMEH�I

Page 183: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

E�B�EAPV�^?@I����@�EBS�IGU>�S)�[ET�E@���?EJ0�TE�>�>BJ�PVKA�B>�J\

F�@EZ�CK�B^0�P���@�H�ZK����AS�G@>BS�k>EC�S�@KMEH�I��AS�G@>BS�PVKA�

�B>E���K�S��?�K?)�F?E�?E�TEJEM�K?)�|E�T�E@?B?K0���O�PGBB�BGH��BK

PVKA�B>E��?EZK�lB���@B�PK?@I��K����M�PGB�@>BK�HK�DMB0�B�lB���@B�

�PK?@I�HE@?�?EV�E�SE�EkE)

=�B�KHP�EHB��T�BJK��?EME0�>�>�@KMEH�I��Kk�^?@I�?�>BK�T�E�

ACKJU)�]VK�D���Z�E0�>�>��E@T�B�BJ�^?@I��K>E?E�UK�B�BNB�?B�U)

p?E��PZ�E�G��?D0�K@CB�JU���@�JEJ�HKCK�SE?BJ�TE@?�EB?D�T�BKJCK�

JUK��G�BJEE?�EkK�BI�B�@HKC�?D��K>E?E�UK�k�MB�>�HE�K�B^)�u@?D

?�>E��B�?K�K@�U��T�EK>?��� M�PGB�@>EJ�lE�HK�XE�E@�� Q�BGH��BK

�AS�G@>BS�>�BM)�=E�BJ�K?K0���VKJ�HKCE��K@?D��K>E?E�U��E??K�E>�AKG�

����@?�K��E@?B���?EJ0�V?E�@��V�C��@ZBM�^?@I��@K���kB���SB�U�B

ABACBE?K>B0���TE?EJ���O�PGBB�APHP?�BGH���?D@I��AS�G@>BK�>�BMB)

�.(> ��#����p?B�>�BMB�BGH�^?@I��K��AS�G@>BJB�PVK�UJB0��K>E?E��UK�BG��BS�TPACB>P^?@I�AKG�@EMC�@E���BI�TE�TE�EHP���?E�@>BS�T���)

8n��K>E?E�US�C^HK�� @?����EK� E?�EkK�BK� >� T�EACKJK� �AS�G@>BS

TPACB>�NB�):�=EVKJP�AU��K�TEJEVD��AS�G@>BJ�BGH�?KCD@?��J�@��

JBJ�BGH���?D�W?B�ZK�>�BMB�����AS�G@>EJ�IGU>K\�=EVKJP�AU��K�@��

JBJ��AS�G�J��Kk�?D0�V?E�BJ���TK��P^�EVK�KHD��KEASEHBJE0�V?E���B�

AECKK��>?P�CD�E\�]VK�D�SE�EkE���E@>Ek�E�BGH���?D���kB�>�BMB��

O�PGBB0�MHK�@E?�B�AKZK�NK�0�>�>��U�ME�E�B?K0��K�BJK^?�WCKJK�?���

�US�P@CE�B��HCI�@PLK@?�E���BI��oE�EkE�BGH���?D��AS�G@>BK�>�B�

MB�@�J�@@E��EkBAE>0�>�BMB0�TE�>E?E�UJ0�T�E@?B?K0�C^HB��EEALK��K

HECZ�U�G��BJ�?D@I0�TE?EJP�V?E��KCDGI�HETP@>�?D�?�>EK�>ECBVK@?�E

EkBAE>�

�p?E�T�BJK��ET�KHKCK��E��TECB?B>B0�>EMH��BG�O�PGBB���J�ETI?D

T�B�E@I?�V?E�?E�ME?E�EK)�p?E0�I�HPJ�^0�HKC�K?@I�HCI�XE�K?��u��ETU)

p?E�HKC�K?@I�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU�PAKHB?D��AS�G@>EK�EALK@?�E0�V?E��U

SE�EkE�>���J�E?�E@B?K@D)�YE�HE�K�BK0�>E?E�EK�JU�TU?�KJ@I�@?�E�

B?D0�JU�HECZ�U��KMPCB�E��?D�@�JB)�=E@�KH�B>B0�>E?E�UK�TEJEM�^?

@?�EB?D�W?E�HE�K�BK0�JEMP?�KME�ZK�B����PkB?D)�RAS�G@>EK�EALK@?�E��

AECDkB�@?�K�@�EKJ��K�@VB?�K?��E�J�CD�UJ�?�>EK�TECEZK�BK�HKC0

>EMH����RAS�GBB��K�BJK^?��EGJEZ�E@?B�BGH���?D�>�BMB�����AS�G@>EJ

IGU>K0��E�TEVKJP�?E�W?B�>�BMB�BGH�^?�HCI���@�����E@>Ek�E��APJ�MK��

O�PGBB)�����T�B�NBTK0�>?E�BJB�E@EAK��E�?E�TECDGPK?@I\�|��K��EK0

��?E�U�BGH��B�0�EAPV�I�>EME�?E��AS�G@>EJP�IGU>P)

Page 184: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

z�GME�E���K�EA�W?EJ0�W?E�EVK�D�@CEZ�U�0�LK>E?CB�U���ET�E@0�B

TE�BJ�^0�V?E���J�@CEZ�E�EA�W?EJ�@PHB?D0�TE?EJP�V?E��U0�HK�@?�B�

?KCD�E0�VP?D�CB��K���TK��U����G�P�BHKCB���@�Q�?�EBS�VK?�K�US��AS��

GE��Q�B�?KTK�D�GHK@D�HKC�K?K�H�CK>E�BHPLBK��U�EHU���>E�?K>@?K�T���

VKCE�K>�)�=EHPJ��?K�E�T����S�VKCE�K>�0�BJKI����BHP0�V?E�JU�?EZK

C^HB0�?EZK�BJKKJ�@�EK���NBE��CD�EK�HE@?EB�@?�E0�VKCE�KVK@>EK�B

T�E@?E�CBV�EK)�|�HE�SE�EkE�G��?D�@B?P�NB^0�TE?EJP�V?E�K@CB�?�J

T�B�BJ�^?��KkK�BI0�@E�K�kK��E��K�G��I�@B?P�NBB0�?E�W?E�B�T�B�E�

HB?�>��E��K)���LK��@KME�?�>�B�AU��K?)

�� ������/%!��-8�qETP@?BJ2�M�PGB�U��K�BJK^?�T�����BGH���?D�>�BMBHCI�RAS�GBB�AKG�@EMC�@E���BI�@��AS�G�JB)�R0���T�BJK�0�HCI�@�EKME

��P?�K��KME�TE?�KACK�BI\�p?E�AUC�@E�JK@?�U��T�EK>?0���@>ECD>E�I

G��^)�tEZK?�AU?D0��U��K���>P�@K\

�������!"�#�-8�{��K?K0���VKJ�HKCE\�p?E�?���UK�@E�JK@?�UK�T�EK>�?U)�=P@?D�@KMEH�I�E?>�U?E�@>�ZP?0�>?E����KJ���AE?�K?)��.(> ��#���

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8��Y�J0�>@?�?B0���AE?�K?�B��AS�G>�0�P�>E?E�

�E��@KJDI0���@>ECD>E�I�G��^0�ZB�K?���RAS�GBB)�y�BJK^����BHP���HBE�

TK�KH�VB�����AS�G@>EJ�IGU>K0�B�W?E���kK�T���E�Q�@CPk�?D�BCB��K�@CP�

k�?D�BS)�|E�?��HK�Pk>���C�HKK?�B��AS�G@>BJ0�B�M�PGB�@>BJ0�E���Q�G�

�AS�GE�0�@KJDI�KK�ZB�K?���RAS�GBB0�B�I�AU��K�E?�E@BC@I�>�W?EJP�?�>

���ZHKA�E�

�������!"�#�-8�tU�ME�E�BJ�@E�K�kK��E�E�H�PMEJ)�n���@�?EZK�K@?D

M�PGB�@>EK���HBE0�B�E�E��K�@�JEK�CPVkKK�M�PGB�@>EK���HBE0�>E?E�EK

@PLK@?�PK?)�|B>?E��K�BJKK?�T�����KME�G�T�K?B?D)�z�GME�E���K�EA�W?EJ)

|E�>EMH��T�KHC�M�K?@I�MPJ��B?���U��T�EK>?���E?�EkK�BB��AS�G@>E�

>PCD?P�U�B�HCI��AS�GE�0�?E���HE�@T�E@B?D0���@>ECD>E�E����J��PZK��B

��@>ECD>E�JU�ME?E�U�KME�T�B�I?D)

�� ��� ���R�S���8�x�?�C0�?U�>EMH���BAPHD�G�H���C�@KAK�W?E?��ET��E@��HCI�>EME�W?E�HKC�K?@I\

Page 185: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�������!"�#�-8�p?E�HKC�CE@D�HCI��AS�GE�)

�� ��� ���R�S���8�|K?0��K�HCI��AS�GE�0�I�EVK�D�SE�EkE�G��^0�TE�

?EJP�V?E���JEK��E�M��BG�NBB�I�TKV�?�C���AS�G@>P^�>E�@?B?PNB^)�{�

�KK��K�TC�?BCB��B�NK�?�0�TE?EJP�V?E�JU�KK���TKV�?�CB�AK@TC�?�E)�y

EVK�D�SE�EkE�G��^0�HCI�>EME�W?E�HKC�CE@D)�p?E��A@EC^?�E��K�?�>0�>�>

?U�ME�E�BkD)��.(> ��#���

��R��� ����0�8�y�SE?KC��AU�@>�G�?D��K@>ECD>E�@CE��TE�TE�EHP�PVKA��B>E�)�OKE�MB��R�V�A�HGK�ME�E�BC0�V?E�@K�V�@���O�PGBB�ME?E�I?@I

�K>E?E�UK��E�UK�PVKA�B>B)�����EH�EJ�BG��E�US�PVKA�B>E���AS�G@>�I

B@?E�BI�ETI?D�E@�E�U��K?@I����MBTE?KGK���ME�E>��)�y�@VB?�^0�V?E

�KEASEHBJE�@EE?�K@?B�T�KBJPLK@?���?E��HKJE>��?BB0�>EMH��>�ZHU�

TBkK?�B�T�KTEH�K?�V?E�SEVK?0�@�?KJ��KM�?B��UJ0�V?E�W?E�JEZK?���K�

@?B�����G�B?BK���kBS�E?�EkK�B����.(> ��#����[E��@I>EJ�@CPV�K0?�>E��PVKA�B>�CBAE�@K�V�@�TKV�?�K?@I0�CBAE�PZK���TKV�?����y�SEVP

G�>E�VB?D�W?P�?KJP�B�@>�G�?D0�V?E�W?��?KE�BI0�>E?E�E��PZK��K�AUCE��

@E�K?@>BS�PVKA�B>�S�TE@CKH�BS�CK?0�TE�>E?E�UJ��U�EAPV�CB@D0���E�D

TEI�CIK?@I���PVKA�US�T�EM��JJ�S0�TE�>E?E�UJ�APHP?�EAPV�?D@I�@E�

��KJK��UK�HK?B)�|K�G��^0�APHP?�CB�W?E�W>@TK�BJK�?�CD�UK�k>ECU

BCB�>�>BK�?E�H�PMBK0��E��K�G�HPJU��?D@I�E�?EJ0�TE�>�>BJ�PVKA�B>�J

APHP?�G��BJ�?D@I�M�CD@>BK�HK?B0�JU��K�JEZKJ)�tEZK?�AU?D0�W?E�AUCE

AU�EVK�D�HKJE>��?BV�E0��E�JU��K�JEZKJ�TEG�ECB?D�@KAK�?�>P^�HK�

JE>��?B^0��K�HPJ�I�E�TE@CKH@?�BIS�TEHEA�E��BHKECEMBB)

�!������"8�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E��@K�@EMC�@�U�@�?KJ0�V?E�BHKECEMBGB�E�

����UK�PVKA�B>B�TCESBK0�B�W?E���@�EAwKHB�IK?)�q����?K�G�>E�VBJ���

W?EJ�B��K��KJ@I�>�EA@PZHK�B^)

��R��� ����0�8�[�W?E?���G�JU��K@>ECD>E�TEJK�ICB�lE�J�?��@?�K�VB��AUC�T�BMC�kK��W>@TK�?0�@TKNB�CB@?�TE�T�EACKJ�J�>E�lCB>?E���

�KMBE��S0�H�CK>BS�E?�F��>�G�0�B�JU�BJKCB�GHK@D�@�KZB���GMCIH�VKCE�

�K>�0��C�HK^LKME�B�?K�K@�E��JK?EHECEMBK�)�qPJ�^0�V?E0�JEZK?�AU?D0

�K�@KMEH�I0��E�TEGZK�JU�TEVP�@?�PKJ0�V?E�W?E�AUCE�HE@?�?EV�E�TE�

CKG�E)�oE?KCE@D�AU�ENK�B?D�W?P��E�P^�lE�JP���AE?U�B�TEHPJ�?D�E

�EGJEZ�EJ�T�EHECZK�BB)

Page 186: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

Y�>�V?E��ET�E@E�0�>�@�^LBS@I�T�EK>?�0�EVK�D�J�EME0��E�@KMEH�I

JU�HECZ�U0���TK��P^�EVK�KHD0�EA@PHB?D�W?B�H���HE>C�H�)

�� ������/%!��-8�|��JE���GMCIH0��U@?PTCK�BK�q��BH��xK�HGK�Bk�

�BCB�AUCE�EVK�D�B�?K�K@�UJ)�y�@EMC�@K�0�V?E���>E�NK�;-�S�Q���V�CK

5-�S�MEHE���AS�G@>�I�@?E�E���@PJKC��JEABCBGE��?D��@K�BJK�kBK@I

�K@P�@U0�@TCE?B���EJK�>C�?P�P0�B�?KCCBMK�NB^�B�H�PMBK�@BCU�HCI

HE@?BZK�BI�?KS�NKCK�0�>E?E�UK�TE@?��BCE��AS�G@>EK�H�BZK�BK)�|K

JEMP��K�@EMC�@B?D@I�B�@�?KJ0�V?E�TE��ZK�BK�PJK�K��EME�>�UC��M�P�

GB�@>BS�TECB?B>E��B�TEAKH��Q�JEZK?�AU?D0���KJK���I�Q���HB>�CE���

CBNK�G�B�HB@?E��@UM��C��?EMH��EVK�D��KM�?B��P^��ECD�HCI�O�PGBB)

oEVP�HEA��B?D�8�EGJEZ�E0�q��BH�@E�J�E��@EMC�@B?@I:0�V?E��AS�G@>�I

@?E�E���@PJKC��?EMH�0���?KS�P@CE�BIS0�B@TECDGE��?D�?�>?BVK@>BK�B

@?��?KMBVK@>BK�EkBA>B�M�PGB�@>BS�TECB?B>E��B��P>E�EH@?��))

FE@�P�kB@D�@EAU?B��5.�ME�MEH�0�q��BH���TEJ�BC���J�E�G�>E�K0

E��UAE��S0�E�@HKC>Kc�JEZK?0�>EJP�?E�W?E�B��K�����B?@I0��E�W?E�T�E�

BGEkCE��,;�Q�,6�Q�..)�=EJ�^�@E�JK@?�P^�T�K@@�>E�lK�K�NB^0�>E?E�

�P^�T�E�EHBCB�TE@CK�W?E��@HKC>B���XPSPJB�[C�HB@C���R�HGB�A��B

F�>E�R@�?B��B�Q�T�KH@KH�?KCB�[K�SE��EME�XE�K?��O�PGBB�B�RAS��

GBB)�uLK�?EMH��TECB?B>B��KEH�EG��V�E�ENK�BCB�W?E�@EAU?BK)�q��B

@K�V�@�EH�B�@VB?�^?0�V?E�W?E?�G�>E��TEG�ECBC������KJI�@JIMVB?D�@B�

?P�NB^0�E?EH�B�P?D���V�CE�>E�lCB>?�0�H�PMBK�Q���EAE�E?0�V?E�W?E

P@>E�BCE�@EG�K���BK�>E�lCB>?�0�?�>�>�>��AS�G@>�I�@?E�E���l�>?B�

VK@>B�TECPVBC��AECDkB�@?�E)

�?E�ZK�>�@�K?@I�?EMH�k�BS�TK�KME�E�E��E��EGJEZ�E@?IS���GM���

�BVK�BI�TEC�EJEVB��JKZHP�YABCB@B�B�XPSPJB0���>E?E�US�PV�@?�E�

��CB��K>E?E�UK�M�PGB�@>BK�B��AS�G@>BK�TECB?B>B0�>E�KV�E0�AUCE�AU

ME��GHE�CPVkK0�K@CB�AU�PH�CE@D�HEME�E�B?D@I�?EMH�)�|E0�J�K�>�ZK?�

@I0�V?E�H�ZK�K@CB�AU�PH�CE@D0�?E0��EGJEZ�E0�W?E��K�@?�CE�AU�M����?B�

K��E?�EAE@?�K�BI�@B?P�NBB�B��EE�PZK��EME�>E�lCB>?�)�oE?I�@K�V�@

?�PH�E�M�H�?D)�qPJ�^0�V?E��B�M�PGB�@>BK0��B��AS�G@>BK�TECB?B>B0��B

�P>E�EH@?�E��K�B@TECDGE��CB�?EMH���@K��UV�MB)�]A�W?EJ�I�ME�E�BC

�P>E�EHB?KCIJ�EAKBS�@?E�E������G�US�lE�J�S�Q��E���KJI�B�?K��D^0

���T�K@@�>E�lK�K�NBIS�B�?)H)

q��BH���J���TEJ�BC0�V?E�����V�CK�5,�ME�MEH����[K�SE��EJ�XE�K�

?K�RAS�GBB�AUC���K@DJ��E�BMB��CD��I�@B?P�NBI)�]��@E@C�C@I����@CE�

Page 187: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

���[C�HB@C����R�HGB�A�0�>E?E�U���K�?ECD>E���J0�q��BH0��E�B��K���G

TE?EJ�ME�E�BC0�V?E�M�PGB�@>�I�l��>NBI�?�KAPK?�H�?D�ENK�>P�?EJP0

V?E�T�EBGEkCE���YABCB@B)�y�SE?KC�AU��KJ�EZ>E�TEI@�B?D�Q�I�T�B�

@P?@?�E��C�����@KS�@K@@BIS�?EME�T��C�JK�?��HE�EK��EME�@EGU��)�]?

BJK�B�l��>NBB�?�>EME�?�KAE���BI��K�AUCE)�[U@?PTBCE��K@>ECD>E

HKTP?�?E��Q�E�?EHE>@�CD�US�G�B�HB@?E�0��K@>ECD>E�VKCE�K>0�>E?E�UK

@?��BCB��ET�E@�E�?EJ0�V?EAU�[K�SE��U��XE�K?�H�C�ENK�>P�T�EB@�

kKHkKJP���YABCB@B)�]�B�T�KHC�M�CB�@�E�����B��?)�[�@BCP�@CEZB��

kBS@I�EA@?EI?KCD@?��8�UAE�U�AUCB���>E�NK�5.�ME�MEH�:0�AECDkB��

@?�E���M�PGB�@>E��l��>NBB�@E@?��CICB�G�B�HB@?U)�=ECE�B���BG��BS

AUCB�E�?EHE>@�CD�UK0�l���?BV�UK�G�B�HB@?U0�H�PMBK�BJ�@BJT�?B�

GB�E��CB0��E�AUCB�ME?E�U�>�>EJT�EJB@@P)�[E�l��>NBB�AUCE�B�JK�D�

kB�@?�E�Q�E?�^HD��K�G�B�HB@?U0��E�E�B���?E���KJI�TE���G�UJ�T�B�

VB��J�TPACBV�E��K��U@>�GU��CB@D�T�E?B��{�B�H��8���K��EK0�P��BS

AUCB����?E�@�EB�E@�E���BI:)�Y�>�V?E�I�@VB?�^0�V?E�[C�HB@C���O�BME�

�DK�BV�H�C���J�EH�E@?E�E��^^�B�lE�J�NB^0�TE?EJP�V?E�E?�BJK�B

M�PGB�@>E��l��>NBB��ET�E@���?�>E��>�?KME�BV�E��lE�JK��K�@?��BC�

@I)�oE?I0�>E�KV�E0��@K�W?E�@EGH���CE�HETEC�B?KCD�P^��K��EG�E@?D�B

@?��BCE��P>E�EH@?�E�[K�SE��EME�XE�K?��B��AS�G@>P^�l��>NB^���EVK�D

�KCE�>EK�TECEZK�BK)

=EJ�^�@CE���RCK>@��H���{ECE?B�@>E�BV��R�>��A�0�HKTP?�?�0�>E�

?E�U�0�E?�KV�I�����U@?PTCK�BK�E�?EHE>@�CD�US�G�B�HB@?E�0�ME�E�BC0

V?E�{�B�H�O�J@�SP�HBI�Q�W?E�JB�P�k�I�?KJ��I��EVD�O�PGBB)�F@?�?B0

TE@CK�W?BS�@CE��M�PGB�@>BK�HKTP?�?U�AECDkK��K�@?��BCB�?�>��ET�E@

Q�JEZK?0�E�B�EVK�D�MCPAE>E�E@JU@CBCB�W?B�@CE��)

�?E�>�@�K?@I�JEHKCK�0�>E?E�UK�T�KHCEZBC�q��BH)�u@?K@?�K��E0

JEZ�E�@TE�B?D0�E@T��B��?D0���@kB�B?D�>ECBVK@?�E����B��?E�0��E�I

P�K�K��8TP@?D����JK�I�APHP?���>CKB��?D�I�CU>B0�I�T�B�U>:0�V?E�P�O�P�

GBB�APHK?��K�CD�U��k��@�P�KMPCB�E��?D��AS�G@>B��>E�lCB>?�?ECD>E

?EMH�0�>EMH��E���@>E��K>?B�PK?�@�E^���Kk�^^�TECB?B>P)�FEMH��E��

@JEZK?�P�KMPCB�E��?D�Q��K����APJ�MK0������@�JEJ�HKCK�Q�E?�EkK�BI�@

zE@@BK�)�zKVD�GHK@D��B���>EKJ�@CPV�K��K�BHK?�E��SEZHK�BB�O�PGBB��

@E@?���zE@@BB)�zKVD0����JE���GMCIH0�BHK?�E�?EJ0�V?E��KG��B@BJEK�M�P�

GB�@>EK�ME@PH��@?�E0�BJKI���ET�KHKCK��E��@?KTK�B�T�E�E@@B�@>P^

��Kk�KTECB?BVK@>P^�E�BK�?�NB^0�TECPVB?�k��@�HCI��KkK�BI�J�E�

MBS�@�EBS�T�EACKJ�Q���?EJ�VB@CK0�HCI�P�KMPCB�E���BI��AS�G@>EME�>E��

Page 188: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

lCB>?�)�|E��K���?�>EJ���G�KGK0�>�>�ME�E�BC�q��BH)�]�0�>�>�@�J��U���

GBC@I0�T�KH@?��BC�W?E?����B��?���J��V�US�?E��S0��E�W?E�KME�T���E)

�?E�>�@�K?@I�JU@CK��RAK@�CEJ�0�?E�E�B�?�KAP^?�?L�?KCD�EME�BGPVK�

�BI0��E@T�B�BJ�?D�BS����@CPS�EVK�D�@CEZ�E)�|E�K@CB�ME�E�B?D�W>@T�

�EJ?EJ0�I0�K@CB��U��K�EABHB?K@D0�@VB?�^0�V?E�W?E�EVK�D�SB?��I�lE��

J��G�J��B?D�M�PGB��8�K�?ECD>E�AKZK�NK�0����EEALK�M�PGB�:���W?E?

J�CK�D>B��>�T>���B���G��P�CB�E����E��lE�JK�HEAB?D@I�E?�O�PGBB

T�BG���BI��KG��B@BJE@?B�RAS�GBB)�8qPJ�^0��U��K�EABHB?K@D):�{HK@D

B�EMH��I�@CUk�C�E?��AS�G@>BS�>ECCKM�B�T��?�K�E�0�V?E�M�PGB�@>�I

@?E�E���@EGH�K?�J�EZK@?�E���G�US�T�EK>?E��HCI�?EME0�V?EAU�>�>�?E

G�J��B?D��AS�G@>P^�@?E�E�P)�R��E?�GHK@D0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�P���@���EVK�D

SB?�E��lE�JK)))�@�VKJ�?E�JEZ�E�@EMC�@B?D@I0�@�VKJ�?E��K?0��E�W?E�TE�

TU?>��HEAB?D@I�@�EKME�H�PMBJ�TP?KJ��F?E�SEVK?0�TP@?D�TET�H�K?��

W?E?�>�T>��)�p?E�BS�T���E)

M���� �/%�"�-8�n�JK�I��ET�E@�>�YK�MBGP)�F�>BJ�@TE@EAEJ��KkB?@I

��k�>E�lCB>?0�>EMH��O�PGBI�EA��?B?@I�>�zE@@BB�B�@EC�NK�ETI?D���V�

�K?��@?���?D�@�@K�K��\

�� ������/%!��-8�y�TE�IC0��U�T�ENB?B�E��CB��U@?PTCK�BK�>��HB�H�?����VCK�U�TECB?A^�E�7;�ME�MEH�)�y�H�CK>�E?�?KS�JU@CK�0�E�>E?E�

�US��U�HPJ�K?K)�RA@EC^?�E��K��PZ�E�GHK@D�@MPL�?D�>��@>B��?EAU

E?�K?B?D0� I� ��TEJ�^��K@>ECD>E� �UHK�ZK>)�|K>E?E�UK�BG�K@?�UK0

��?E�B?K?�UK��AS�G@>BK�TECB?B>B�Q���E@�E��EJ0�{P��A�RVA��Q�T�IJE

ME�E�BCB0�V?E��AS�G@>B��l�>?E��B�T�E?B�E�KVBI�JKZHP�M�PGB��JB�B

�AS�G�JB��E�J�EMEJ�AUCB�PJKCE�B@TECDGE���U�@K�K��E��@?���E��HCI

?EME0�V?EAU�E>�G�?D�H��CK�BK����O�PGB^0�V?EAU�E����K��UkC��BG�@lK�

�U��CBI�BI�zE@@BB0�BG�E�AB?U�zE@@BB)�]A�W?EJ�ME�E�BCB�B�H�PMBK

�AS�G@>BK�TECB?B>B)

��������%�"�8�R��U�@�JB�@�W?BJ��K�@EMC�@�U\

�� ������/%!��-8�u@?K@?�K��E0�AUCB�B@TECDGE���U)�[�.5;;�M)0�>EM�H����YABCB@B�AUC��TK���I�@?PHK�VK@>�I�MECEHE�>��Q��EIA�D@>�I�Q

?EMH�k�B��TK��U��@K>�K?��D�>EJT��?BB�O�PGBB�qZPJAK��=�?B�k�

�BCB�8JEZK?0�PTEJB���BK�W?E��l�JBCBB�B��K��@KJ�GHK@D�T�BI?�E:0

Page 189: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�@?�KV�I@D�@E�@?PHK�?�JB����>?E�EJ�G�CK�P�B�K�@B?K?�0�E?�K?BC���

EHB���ET�E@0�>E?E�U��KJP�G�H�CB��K@CB�O�PGBI�G�SEVK?�E?HKCB?D@I�E?

XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�0�V?E�APHK?�@�RAS�GBK��B��Z�E��]@K?BK�\�]��T�I�

JE�E?�K?BC��E?AK�P?0�E?�BJP?)

��������%�"�8�|E��KHD��K�E?EA��CB\

�� ������/%!��-8���BHBVK@>B��K?)

[U�SE?B?K0�V?EAU�I���@kBl�E��C0�>�>�W?E�APHK?\�FEMH��@?��?KMB�

VK@>BK�B�?K�K@U�zE@@BB�B�O�PGBB���>�>E��?E�@?KTK�B�APHP?�@E�JKLK�

�U�B�zE@@BI�TECPVB?�E?�O�PGBB���>�VK@?�K�P@?PT>B�BCB�>EJT�EJB@@�

TE�@?��?KMBVK@>BJ��ET�E@�J�?E0�V?E�E���EZBH�K?0�T�B�@ES���K�BB

�KG��B@BJE@?B�O�PGBB0�?EMH���UV�MB�P�KMPCB�E���BI�W?EME�>E�lCB>�

?��JEMP?�AU?D�@�JUJB���G�UJB)�|E��K�G��@VK?�>����E@?K�0�>�>��K>E�

?E�UK�T�KHTEC�M�^?)�[EE�PZK��U��TP?D�APHK?��A@EC^?�E��K��PZK�)

��zE@@BI0�K@?K@?�K��E0��K�TEG�ECB?�Q�H�ZK�K@CB�>?E�?E�G�SEVK?�Q�TE�

@IM�?D����T������AS�GE�0�PLKJCI?D�BS0�W?E�APHK?�T�B�J�>@BJ�CD�E

��@kB�K��US�T����S�RAS�GBB)�R�K@CB�VK�KG�.4�,-�CK?�O�PGBI�ETI?D

G�SEVK?��U�?B�BG�E�AB?U�zE@@BB0�?E��AS�G@>B��l�>?E��ETI?D�APHK?

B@TECDGE���)

F@?�?B0���@VK?�T���)�u@CB�AKZK�N�J�APHK?�T�KHE@?��CK����EG�

JEZ�E@?D��K��P?D@I0�E�B�@�AECDkBJ�PHE�ECD@?�BKJ�G�SE?I?�TECDGE�

��?D@I�kB�E>BJB�T����JB�RAS�GBB���@E@?��K�EALKME0�lKHK��?B��E�

ME�BCB�>E�lKHK��?B��EME0�ME@PH��@?��)�=EVKJP�AU��K?\��KJ�AECDkK

HKNK�?��CBG�NBB���P@CE�BIS�>EJT�EJB@@�0�?KJ�CPVkK�HCI�?KS0�>?E

?�J�APHK?�ZB?D)

�����M�.� ��)�[U�EVK�D�J�EME�ME�E�BCB�E��E@@B�@>EJ��CBI�BB���ZBG�D�O�PGBB)�[@K�W?E�T���BCD�E0�I�?EZK�TEC�E@?D^���GHKCI^�?E?

�GMCIH0�V?E�zE@@BI��@KMH��B@TECDGE��C��B�B@TECDGPK?�@PLK@?�P^LBK

T�E?B�E�KVBI�JKZHP�RAS�GBK��B�O�PGBK�0�B�RAS�GBI�AUC��B@TECDGE�

�������>�VK@?�K��UV�M��H��CK�BI����O�PGB^0�B�?)H)�mE�JPCB�E�>B

��G�UK0��E�@P?D�E@?�K?@I��KBGJK��E�0�W?E�TE�I?�E)

F�>��U�@JE?�B?K����?�>BK�@NK���BB���G�B?BI�@EAU?B��8?KJ�AE�

CKK0���HE>C�HK�q��BH��W?E�?EZK�K@?D:��K@CB�O�PGBI0�@>�ZKJ0�APHK?�lE��

JB�E��?D@I0���G�B��?D@I�AKG�RAS�GBB0�>�>�?EMH��zE@@BI�APHK?�E>�GU�

Page 190: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��?D�@�EK��CBI�BK�BCB�H��CK�BK����O�PGB^\����K�HETP@>�K?K�CB��U0

V?E�>ECD�@>E�E�RAS�GBI�@?ECD��KM�?B��E�B@TECDGPK?@I�T�E?B��O�P�

GBB0�?E0�JEZK?0�SE?D��U�B��K�ZKC�K?K0��E��K�CPVkK�CB��EEALK�E?>��

G�?D@I�E?�@�EBS�T�B?IG��B�����RAS�GB^\

�� ������/%!��-8�p?E�EVK�D�@CEZ�U�0�lBCE@El@>B���ET�E@)�{HK@DPZK�G�?��MB��CE@D���>�>E��?E�@?KTK�B0�V?E��K>E?E��I�V�@?D�M�PGB�@�

>BS�TECB?B>E�0��EGJEZ�E0�B�HETP@>�K?�?�>P^�JU@CD0��E�I0�TE�JEKJP0

�VK���PZK�@>�G�C0�V?E��K�CD�E0�HK�l�>?E�RAS�GBI�E?EkC��BCB�KK�E?TP�

@?BCB)�|E�?EMH��H�PMBK�@?���U0���?EJ�VB@CK�zE@@BI0�APHP?�B@>�?D�Q�B

���?B��K@CEZ�E�Q�H�PMBK��UV�MB�H��CK�BI����O�PGB^)�|K�?ECD>E�?K��

�B?E�B�CD�E�MKEM��lBVK@>B��B�W?�BVK@>B��JEJK�?U0��E�B�W>E�EJB�

VK@>BK�B�H�PMBK)�{HK@D��@KMH��HBCKJJ�)

y�@VB?�^0�V?E0�K@CB�AU�zE@@BI�G�SE?KC��HE�>E�N���K�CBGE��?D

�EGJEZ�E@?D�?EME0�V?EAU�RAS�GBI�E?EkC��B�HK�l�>?E0�B�HK�^�K0�?E

E���T�BCEZBC��AU�>�W?EJP�P@BCBI)�|E�E����K�T�BC�M�K?0�TE?EJP

V?E�SEVK?�B@TECDGE��?D�W?E?�JEL�U���UV�M�HCI�E>�G��BI�H��CK�

�BI����O�PGB^0�V?EAU�HK�Z�?D�O�PGB^���TEH�KkK��EJ�@E@?EI�BB)

��VKJ����DkK�M�PGB�@>EK��P>E�EH@?�E�TE�JK?0�V?E�HCI�?EME0�V?E�

AU�W?EJP�T�E?B�E@?EI?D0���HE�B@>�?D��K@>ECD>E����B��?E���CBAE

AU?D�@BCD�UJ�@�JEJP0�CBAE����?B�@BCD�US�@E^G�B>E�0�CBAE�TE�

JK�I?D� E�BK�?�NB^� B� E�BK�?B�E��?D@I� ��� zE@@B^)))� FEMH�� �K?

@BCD�US�@E^G�B>E�0�>E?E�UK��K�CD�E�TEJEM�^?0�>EMH���K?�@�EBS

@BC0�V?EAU�AE�E?D@I�B�T�E?B�E@?EI?D�H��CK�B^�?�>E��AECDkE�0

MBM��?@>E��@?���U0�E@?�K?@I��USEH�Q�TEJK�I?D���Kk�KTECB?BVK@�

>P^�E�BK�?�NB^)�|E�W?E��K�EG��V�K?�>�>BK�?E���?BG�T�H�UK�BCB

��?B�JK�B>��@>BK���@?�EK�BI0�xEZK�PT�@B)�y�HB@?��NBB�P^@D�E?

�KEAECDkK�B>E�0�BCB�E�?EHE>@�CD�US0�>E?E�UK���?P^?�G��XE�K?@�

>B��XE^G��E�B�@�JB�E??�C>B��^?�V�@?D���@KCK�BI�O�PGBB�E?�T�E�

�E@@B�@>E��E�BK�?�NBB�@�EBJB�E�?EHE>@�CD�UJB0��KEAECDkB�B�

@?@>BJB�T�BGU��JB)

y�@VB?�^0�V?E�zE@@BI�TE>���K�BHK?����?E0�V?EAU�HETP@?B?D�^�B�

HBVK@>B��E?SEH�RAS�GBB0�TE?EJP�V?E�K@CB�E���HETP@?B?�W?E�GHK@D0�?E

HECZ���APHK?�HETP@?B?D�W?E�B�MHK�?E�KLK)�qCI��KK�W?E�ET�@�E)�{��^0

V?E�6�CK?���G�H0�W?E�E@EAK��E��K��lBkB�E��CE@D0��E�AUC��TETU?>�

EH�E��@?���U�TE@?��B?D��ET�E@�E�^�BHBVK@>EJ�T�BG���BB�E?SEH�

Page 191: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

RAS�GBB���EH�E��BG�JKZHP���EH�US�E�M��BG�NB�0��E�zE@@BI�?E�TK�

HB�E��C��W?E�HKCE)

��������%�"�8��?E�ZK�W?E�G��@?����0�G��B�?K�K@U�>E?E�E���U�?�>TK�KZB��K?K\

�� ������/%!��-8�p?E�>PCP���UK�@�KHK�BI0�TEW?EJP�I��K�BJK^�T������@>�G�?D0�W?E��K�TPACB>E��CE@D)

!.� �M"��8�=E�I?�EK�HKCE���E����PZK�TEV?B�;�CK?�>�>�G�>E�VBC�@D0B����T�E?IZK�BB��@KME�W?EME���KJK�B0�H��B���T�ENK@@K��EE�PZK��EME

>E�lCB>?�0�RAS�GBI�@CPZBC��@�EKME��EH���UV�MEJ0�@�TEJELD^�>E?E�

�EME��EGHK�@?�P^?����O�PGB^)

=E�I?�E�B�?E0�V?E��KCDGI�AK@>E�KV�E�HECMEK���KJI�B@TECDGE��?D

EHB��B�?E?�ZK��UV�M0�TE?EJP�V?E�B�?K0����>EME�H��I?0�B�?K0�>KJ�J��BTP�

CB�P^?0�>�>�?E�TU?�^?@I�BGAKZ�?D�TK�KM�PG>B0�TEW?EJP���@?PT�K?

JEJK�?0�>EMH��W?B�JKS��BGJU�TK�K@?�^?���AE?�?D)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E

?�>EK���KJI0���ET�KHKCK��EJ�@JU@CK0���@?PTBCE)�|K�EGJEZ�E�AK@>E�

�KV�E�HECME�E>�GU��?D�H��CK�BK)�F�>��U�@KAK�T�KH@?��CIK?K0�>?E�@CK�

HP^LB�0�@�TEJELD^�>E?E�EME�APHP?�T�EBG�KHK�U�?�>BK��UV�Z�UK

H�BZK�BI\

�� ������/%!��-8�q�BZK�BI�PZK�E@PLK@?�CI^?@I�Q����BHK�?EME�ZK

�BGE�EME��KZBJ�)�y��KEH�E>��?�E�ME�E�BC����EVK�D��U@E>EJ�P�E��K

��tE@>�K0�V?E0���KHI��BGE�U���KZBJ�@�O�PGBK�0�zE@@BI�KLK�H�CDkK

E??EC>�PC��E?�@KAI��K�?ECD>E��P>E�EH@?�E�O�PGBB0��E�B�M�PGB�@>EK

EALK@?�E�B�?P�KME�V�@?D0�>E?E��I�TE�J�EMBJ�T�BVB��J�SE?KC��TEH�

HK�ZB��?D�B�@K�V�@�ZKC�K?�TEHHK�ZB��?D�?KTCUK0�SE�EkBK0�P��ZB�

?KCD�UK�HPSE��UK0�TECB?BVK@>BK�B�B�UK�E?�EkK�BI�@�zE@@BK�)���I

HPJ�^�8B�EA�W?EJ��KEH�E>��?�E�ME�E�BCB�M�PGB�@>BK�TECB?B>B:0�V?E

TEHEA�UJB�HK�@?�BIJB0�l�>?BVK@>B�@�JE�?EME��K�ZKC�I0��P>E�EH�

@?�E�zE@@BB�TEJEM�K?�XEKHB�K��UJ�s?�?�J�B�G�T�H�UJ�@?����J

TE@?KTK��E��U?K@�I?D�zE@@B^�BG�O�PGBB�B�@��Z�EME�F��>�G��Q�B

HPSE��E0�B�TECB?BVK@>B0�B�W>E�EJBVK@>B)�p?E�AUC��EVK�D��K�HK>��?�

��I�JK��)�n�JK�I��K?�?�>EME�>EJTCK>@�0��E�P�>�>E��?E�V�@?B�TECB?B�

>E��TEI�BC@I�>EJTCK>@�PLK�A�E@?B��TEVKJP�?ECD>E���J���KCB��BGE�

Page 192: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�U���KZBJ\�=�BVB��0�>E�KV�E0�EVK�D�@�EKEA��G��I��VKVK�@>B��?K��

�E�BGJ)�F�>�APH?E�E�B�TECDGP^?@I��BG�JB�BCB�T�ESEHI?�VK�KG�F==�

p?E�lE�J����>�G��BI)�R�>�>E��APHK?�@CKHP^LB���UV�M0�I��K�SEVP�M��

H�?D)

!.� �M"��8�u@CB�ME�E�B?D��K�E�JKS��BGJK0�JEZK?�CB�>�>�I��BAPHDW?�BVK@>�I�M�PTT����P?�B�O�PGBB�AU?D�B@TECDGE�����>�>�EVK�KH�E�

�UV�M\

�� ������/%!��-8�qPJ�^0�V?E�PZK�AUCB�TETU?>B�B@TECDGE��?D�W?Bl�>?E�U0��E��K�TECPVBCE@D)�=EW?EJP�@K�V�@���@VK?�@HKC������@ENB�

�CD�U��l�>?E��

��������%�"�8�tEZK?�AU?D0��JK@?E�?EME0�V?EAU�@�JBJ�TE@?EI��E

@CPZB?D�@�KH@?�EJ�HCI�J��BTPCINB��B�?�>P^�ZK�@PHDAP�ME?E�B?D�@�E�

BJ�HK?IJ�B���P>�J0�VKJ�TE@?EI��E���SEHB?D@I��E��C�@?B�>�>BS�?E

AECDkBS�TECB?BVK@>BS�BM�E>E�0��K�CPVkK�CB�TE�?B����@HKC>P\�|K

@VB?�K?K�CB��U��EGJEZ�E��HCI�@KAI�ZBG�D����KG��B@BJE��RAS�GBB0

MHK�APHP?�M����?B�E���U��@K�T�����M�PGB�@>EME���@KCK�BI0�>E?E�EK

�EG���?B?@I���@�EB�HEJ�\�YKE�K?BVK@>B)

�� ������/%!��-8�u@CB�ME�E�B?D�E?>�E�K��E0�I��K��K�^0�V?E��U��Kk�KK��AS�G@>EK��P>E�EH@?�E���@E@?EI�BB�M����?B�E��?D�T�����M�P�

GB��J�8B��K�?ECD>E�M�PGB��J:)�|K�SEVP��B>EME�E@>E�AB?D0��E�I�H�ZK

?KE�K?BVK@>B��K�HETP@>�^�?�>E���EGJEZ�E@?B)

y��K�SEVP�>�BV�?D�E�?EJ0�V?E�I�@�JU��AECDkE��T�?�BE?0��E�?E0

V?E�G�>C�HU��K?@I�@�HK?@?���B�>�>BJ�@�J�VKCE�K>�@KAI��E@T�B�BJ�K?0

�@K�W?E�VKJ�H�CDkK0�?KJ�@BCD�KK�@?��E�B?@I)�n�H�PMBS0�JEZK?0�TEVK�

JP�?E���@@KB��K?@I0��E�I�CBV�E�T�E@?E��K�JU@C^�HCI�@KAI�ZBG�B��

H�PME��@?���K�BCB�H�PMEJ�ME@PH��@?�K0�>�EJK�O�PGBB)

=�EZB��4�CK?����n>��B�K0�BJKI�T�K>��@�P^��EGJEZ�E@?D���AE�

?�?D�B�PVB?D@I�H�CDkK0�I��K�G�SE?KC�E@?���?D@I0���SE?KC�ZB?D�?�J0�MHK

ZBC�HE�53�ME�MEH�)��?E�>�@�K?@I�H�PMBS�Q��K�G��^0�I��K��T���K�G���BS

E?�KV�?D0��E�I0���T�BJK�0�B@>C^V�^�?�>P^�lE�JP)�|K���EABHP��B>E�

JP�APHD�@>�G��E0�K@?K@?�K��E)

Page 193: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

��,� ��.�S,���8�y�SE?KC�AU��U@>�G�?D@I���@VK?��EGJEZ�E@?BT�E�E@@B�@>E��E�BK�?�NBB�O�PGBB)�qCI�JK�I���Kk�II�TECB?B>��Q

W?E�T�EHECZK�BK���P?�K��K��TECB?B>B0�B�>EMH���KVD�BHK?�E���kKJ

@?�KJCK�BB��E�?B���u��E@E^G0�?E�W?E�@E�@KJ��K�T�E@?E�Q�@?�?D�VCK�

�EJ�JKZHP���EH�EME�A^�E>��?BVK@>EME�E�M��BGJ�)�u��E@E^G�Q�W?E

HKJE>��?BI�B�@�EAEH�U���U�E>)�FEMH��JU�ME�E�BJ0�V?E�HECZ�U�@?�?D

VCK��JB�|RY]0�W?E��K�T�E@?E�B��K�?ECD>E�M����?BB�AKGET�@�E@?B0��E

W?E�B�M��ZH��@>B��>E�?�ECD���H���JBK�)

u@CB�TE@JE?�K?D����zE@@B^0�V?E�JU�BJKKJ\�FE��PJTB�E����

�EK�ME@PH��@?�E0��E�MC��K�>�MWAWk�B>B0�@C�AU��M��ZH��@>B��@K>�

?E���{�T�H�HCI�JK�I�Q�W?E��K�T�E@?E�TEJELD�O�PGBB�T�E?B��zE@�

@BB0��K�T�E@?E�@E^G�B>�T�E?B��zE@@BB�BCB�?E��ZK�RAS�GBB)�{�T�H

HCI�JK�I�Q�W?E�@?��?KMBVK@>B��@E^G�B>�T�E?B��MC���EME���kKME

���M�0�>E��PJTB�E����US�M�PGB�@>BS�A^�E>��?E�)�[�W?EJ�@JU@�

CK�MC����I�T�EACKJ��HCI�O�PGBB�Q�W?E��K�@?ECD>E�RAS�GBI0�@>ECD>E

�KlE�J����kBS�EALK@?�K��US�B�>E�@?B?PNBE��US�B�@?B?P?E�)

RAS�GB^0�>E?E�P^�JU�TE?K�ICB0�JU�TE?K�ICB��K�T�E@?E�>�>�>��

>P^�?E�MKEM��lBVK@>P^�V�@?D���kK��@?���U)�qCI�J�EMBS�Q�W?E�?�

O�PGBI0�>E?E�E��AECDkK��K?0�B��E@?�CDMBI�TE�TE�EHP�RAS�GBB�Q

W?E�ET�KHKCK��EK�@?�KJCK�BK�>��K@?����NBB)�zK@?����NBB��K�?ECD�

>E�?K��B?E�B�CD�E��NKCE@?�E@?B0���B�?EME�EALK@?�K��E�TECB?B�

VK@>EME�@?�EI0�>E?E�U��P���@�@PLK@?�E��C�HE�TE?K�B�RAS�GBB0�B�I

�K�EVK�D�?E�SE?KC�AU�?PH��TET�@?D)

u@CB�JU�TE@JE?�BJ����@E@KH�^^�R�JK�B^0�>E?E��I�TEAKHBC���

>���A�S@>EJ�>E�lCB>?K0�?E�V?E�JU�?�J�BJKKJ\�p?E�@�K�SJBCB?��B�

GE����EK�ME@PH��@?�E0�MHK��@K�E@�E��UK�@lK�U�EALK@?�K��E��ZBG�B

>E�?�ECB�P^?�TECP�EK��UK0�TECPlKEH�CD�UK�CBHK�U)

F�?�@?�El����RAS�GBB�AUC��>�?�@?�ElE��HCI�?E��O�PGBB0�>E?E�

��I�HCI�JK�I�@E�K�kK��E��KT�BKJCKJ�)����EK��EK�TE��ZK�BK���RA�

S�GBB�TE>�G�CE��KZBG�K@TE@EA�E@?D�?E��JEHKCB�EALK@?�K��EME�P@?�

�E�@?��0�>E?E��I�P���@�@PLK@?�E��C�)�[�W?EJ�@JU@CK��EK��EK�TE���

ZK�BK�TE@CPZBCE�ET�KHKCK��UJ�@?BJPCEJ�HCI�EALK@?�K��EME�EA�

�E�CK�BI)�=E@CK�T�HK�BI�XPSPJB�T�CB�B�H�PMBK�A�@?BE�U�@?��EME

�KZBJ�0�B�AUC�H���ET�KHKCK��U��@?BJPC��KlE�J�J)�Y�>�V?E�JEZ�E

@>�G�?D0�V?E�JB�P@��@KMH��ME��GHE�T�EHP>?B��K�0�VKJ�TC^@)�XE�K��

kK�@?�E�B�EMH��TEH��CIK?)

Page 194: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

rPVkK0�TE�JEKJP0��K�@?�KJB?D@I�>�?EJP0�V?E�AUCE����DkK0���HE

���?B��E�UK�lE�JU��G�BJEE?�EkK�B�0�B�W?B��E�UK�lE�JU�APHP?

ME��GHE�AECKK�T�BKJCKJUJB�B�HCI�M�PGB�@>EME�EALK@?��0�B�HCI��A�

S�G@>EME)�]�lE�J�S�JEZ�E�@TE�B?D0�K@?D���G�UK����B��?U)�|��K��

�EK0�@K�V�@�EVK�D�?�PH�E�ME�E�B?D�E��K�EI?�E@?B�E@PLK@?�CK�BI��G��

BJET�BKJCKJUS�lE�J�@E@PLK@?�E���BI0��E��K�@KMEH�I0�?�>�G��?��

APHK?�k��@�BS�E@PLK@?�B?D0�I���W?EJ�P�K�K�)�|K���HE�E?>�GU��?D@I�E?

W?BS�TETU?E>)�]?>�G�E?�@PLK@?�P^LKME�>P�@��Q�W?E�E?>�G��K�?ECD>E

E?�ET�KHKCK��EME���Kk�KTECB?BVK@>EME�>P�@�0��E�B�E?�k��@��@EGH�?D

�E�P^�O�PGB^)�R�HCI�JK�I�W?E��A@EC^?�E��KT�BKJCKJE)

�����M�.� ��8�y�EHB��BG��K?K���E��W?EME�T�EK>?�)��G�B�B?K0�K@CB�K@>�EJ�E�BCB��K>E��K>?�E��U��Z�^@D0��E�SE?KC�AU�E?JK?B?D�@�EK

AECDkEK�PHE�CK?�E�K�BK��U�Kk�K����kK���@?�KVK�)�|��T�KHUHPLBS

�@?�KV�S�I��K��@?�KV�C�?�>BS�E?>�E�K��US�G�I�CK�B�0�>�>BK�@CUkP��

W?B�H�B�@E�@?E�E�U���kBS�M�PGB�@>BS�>ECCKM)�t�K�W?E�EVK�D�T�BI?�

�E)�y��KJ�EZ>E�E?E�����@K�V�@�B�E?�O�PGBB0�B�E?�RAS�GBB0�B0�TEZ��

CP�0�W?E?�T�EK>?�Q�KHB�@?�K���I��EGJEZ�E@?D�EAL�?D@I�@E�@�EBJB

M�PGB�@>BJB�>ECCKM�JB)

X?�CE�AU?D0�SE?I����WJENBE��CD�EJ0�AU?E�EJ�P�E��K�JU�V�@?E

H�PM�H�PM��PT�K>�KJ0�TE�E��H�ZK��PM�KJ0��E0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E0��K@JE?�

�I�����@K�?�PH�E@?B�B�AKHU0�>E?E�UK��UT�CB����HEC^�O�PGBB�B�RAS��

GBB0�����@?�K��UK�P@?EB���O�PGBB�TE>��KLK�@ES���BCB@D0�B�W?E�JK�I

EVK�D���HPK?0�?�>�>�>�W?E�I�CIK?@I�E@�E���BKJ�HCI�?KS�TK�@TK>?B�0���

>E?E�UK�I���@@VB?U��^)�y��K�HPJ�C0�V?E���O�PGBB�TE@CK�|B>E����V��

��HGK�B�]?����qZBEK���>?E�?E�KLK�JEZK?��E?�?�>���@@PZH�?D�E�@PHDAK

O�PGBB�AKG�RAS�GBB)�FEMH��AU�B�MHK�AU�I��B�EAL�C@I�@�M�PGB��JB0�E�B

�@KMH��ME�E�BCB0�V?E��K�T�KH@?��CI^?�@KAK�O�PGBB�AKG�RAS�GBB0���VB�

��CB@D�HECMBK���@@PZHK�BI0��E�I��@KMH�0�@CPk�I��@K�W?B���@@PZHK�BI0

ELPL�C��K>E?E�EK�ET�@K�BK0�V?E�W?��C^AE�D�>�RAS�GBB��K��@KMH�������

@?�K���)�R�����@?�K��EK���V�CE�HECZ�E�AU?D�E@�E�E���G�BJEE?�EkK�

�B��JKZHP�C^HDJB0��KG��B@BJE�E?�?EME0�I�CI^?@I�CB�E�B�T�KH@?��B�

?KCIJB�EH�EME�W?�E@�0�EH�EME�ME@PH��@?���BCB���G�US�ME@PH��@?�)

���E?���W?BS�T�EK>?�S�q��BH��K@?D�EHB�����B��?�APHPLK��JEHK�

CB�ZBG�B�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB0�MHK�O�PGBI��Kk�K?�@�EB�@EA@?�K��UK�G��

H�VB0���RAS�GBI�@�J���Kk�K?�@�EB)

Page 195: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�W?E�AUCE�AU���BAECKK�T�BKJCKJUJ����B��?EJ

Q��K�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU��EGH�BM�P?D�JKZHP�O�PGBK��B�RAS�GBK��>B?��@�

>P^�@?K�P0���>�>���G�HCI�?EME0�V?EAU�@EGH�?D�A�GP�HCI�>E�@?�P>?B��E�

ME0�����@?�K��EME0� TECKG�EME��G�BJEHK�@?�BI�H�PS� W?BS�EALK@?�)

oE?BJ�JU�?EME�BCB��K?0��E�JU���@�JEJ�HKCK���SEHBJ@I����EH�EJ

MKEM��lBVK@>EJ�T�E@?���@?�K�B�H�PM�E?�H�PM���B>PH���K�HK�KJ@I)

XKMEH�I��AS�G0�K@CB�E����@?EILB��T�?�BE?0�HECZK�0��K@JE?�I���

?E0�V?E����U�KLK�>�E�E?EV�?0�ZKC�?D�GHE�E�DI0�AC�METECPVBI��K�?ECD�

>E�@KAK0��E���TK��P^�EVK�KHD�M�PGB�P0�BAE�W?E�KME�@E@KH)�=E>����O�P�

GBB��K�APHK?�TE�IH>��B�AC�METECPVBI0���IH�CB�JU�@JEZKJ�B�P�@KAI��

RAS�GBB�W?EME�HEAB?D@I0��KG��B@BJE�E?�?EME0�APHP?�CB���kB�ME@PH���

@?���@�JE@?EI?KCD�UJB�B��KG��B@BJUJB)�p?E��E�@K��K�EG��V�K?0�V?E

E�B��K�APHP?�TEHHK�ZB��?D�TECB?B>E�T���E�UK0�W>E�EJBVK@>BK0�>PCD�

?P��UK�B�T�EVBK�E?�EkK�BI0�BAE��B�EH�E�BG�W?BS�EALK@?��@�JE@?EI�

?KCD�E0�BGECB�E����E�@�JEHE@?�?EV�UJ�AU?D��K�JEZK?)�|E���@BCP

�IH��EA@?EI?KCD@?�0�>ECD�@>E�E�JU�@���JB�ME�E�BJ�E��K��@BCD@?�K��

�EJ�P�KMPCB�E���BB�>E�lCB>?�0�?E0�>E�KV�E�ZK0����W?EJ�W?�TK�RAS��

GBI�HECZ����Kk�?D�@�EB�@EA@?�K��UK�G�H�VB0���O�PGBI�Q�@�EB)�tEZK?

AU?D0�APHPLKK�TE>ECK�BK�Q��EGJEZ�E0�B��K�@?ECD�H�CK>EK�Q�G�SEVK?

ZB?D���@E@?��K�M�PGB�@>EME�ME@PH��@?��0�K@CB�E�E�APHK?�CPVkK�EAK@�

TKVB��?D�TE?�KA�E@?B��AS�G@>EME�EALK@?��0��KZKCB�ME@PH��@?�E0�TE�

@?�EK��EK��AS�G�JB)�tU��KHD�W?EME�?EZK��K�G��KJ0��E�V?E��UCDK?@I

?E�ME@PH��@?�E0�>E?E�EK�JU���@�EKJ�@EG���BB�@KMEH�I�JEHKCB�PKJ)

=EW?EJP0��BHBJE0�B��AS�G@>EK�EALK@?�E0�B�M�PGB�@>EK�HECZ�U

T�E�?B�>�>EK�?E�B@TU?��BK)�y�TEC�E@?D^���GHKCI^�J�K�BK0�V?E�M�P�

GB�U�@KMEH�I����B@?E�BVK@>EJ�TK�KCEJK)�|��@�JEJ�HKCK��K�?ECD>E

O�PGBI�B�RAS�GBI0��E�B��K@D�F��>�G0�H��B��@K�JB�E�EK�@EEALK@?�E

TK�KSEHB?�BG�EH�EME�@E@?EI�BI���H�PMEK�Q�W?E��EEALK�TK�KSEH�U�

TK�BEH���MCEA�CD�EJ�J�@k?�AK)�|��F��>�GK�W?E��K@DJ��E@?�E�T�ESE�

HB?0�TE?EJP�V?E���J�T�BSEHB?@I��KBJE�K��E�P@>E�K��UJB�?KJT�JB

TK�KSEHB?D�BG�EH�EME�@E@?EI�BI���H�PMEK)�=E?EJP�W?E?�T�ENK@@�T�E�

SEHB?��K@DJ��AECKG�K��E)�=E�E��JU��K��UHK�ZB��KJ�W?BS�?KJTE�0

W?EME�B@?E�BVK@>EME��B?J�0�TEW?EJP�GHK@D0���>��>�G@>EJ��KMBE�K0�B

BJK^?�JK@?E�?�>BK�>�?�>CBGJU)

[�H���EJ�@CPV�K�SEVP�>E�@?�?B�E��?D�@�J�l�>?�?EME0�V?E�M�PGB��

@>�I�EALK@?�K��E@?D0�C^HB���O�PGBB0� ���CBGB�PI�@B?P�NB^0�@�JB

Page 196: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�U@>�GU��^?�?�>P^�JU@CD)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E0��E�TK��US0�W?E�TE>��

G�?KCD�B�?KCCK>?P�CD�EME�TE?K�NB�C��M�PGB�@>EME�EALK@?��)�[E��?E�

�US0����@�JEJ�HKCK�O�PGBI�ECBNK?�E�IC��>�>P^�?E�@�E^�@EA@?�K��

�P^�lE�JP�HKJE>��?BB)�u@CB�JU�APHKJ�ME�E�B?D�E�M�PGB�@>E��>PCD�

?P�K�����KME�@�KH�K�K>E�DI�BCB�TEGH�KME0�BCB�H�ZK�����0������0����

�K>�0�?E�P�BHBJ0�V?E�O�PGBI�AUC��HE�ECD�E�?�>B�E�BMB��CD�E��@?���

�E�0�E�BMB��CD�UJ�EALK@?�EJ0�E������@�JEJ�HKCK�AUC��NB�BCBGE�

����UJ�EALK@?�EJ���CPVkKJ�@JU@CK�W?EME�@CE��)�YECD>E��E?���oo

�K>K�B@?E�BVK@>BK�>�?�>CBGJU0�>E�KV�E0�@ABCB�O�PGB^�@�B@?B��EME

B@?E�BVK@>EME�TP?B)�y�SEVP���VKJ�?E��EG��GB?D���kKJP�JECEHEJP

>ECCKMK�rK���P)�zK?�E@TK>?B��0��K@EJ�K��E0��PZ��)�[�B@?E�BB�K@?D0

>E�KV�E0�?E0�V?E���J�@KMEH�I�JKk�K?0�E?�W?EME0�K@?K@?�K��E0���HE�E?�

JKZK�U��?D@I)�|E�B@?E�BVK@>�I��K?�E@TK>?B���V�KG�UV���E���Z��

B��PZ��0�AKG�W?EME�JU�APHPLKK��K�TE@?�EBJ)�xPHPLKK�HECZ�E�ETB�

��?D@I����>�>BK�?E�A�GE�UK�TECEZK�BI0�>E?E�UK�@?�EI?@I����B@?E�BB

H���EME�EALK@?��)

���?E�EK0�V?E�J�K�SE?KCE@D�AU�@>�G�?D)�FE�KV�E0��E��G�BJEE?�E�

kK�BIS�RAS�GBB�B�O�PGBB��EG�B>�P?�?�PH�E@?B�@K�DKG�EME�S���>?K�

��)�]H�E�HKCE0�>EMH��EA�W?EJ�ME�E�B?�q��BH�xK�HGK�Bk�BCB�BCB�pJG��

qZMK�K��I)�R�V?E�ZK�ME�E�B?�E@?�CD�EK�M�PGB�@>EK�EALK@?�E�BCB

TECB?BVK@>�I�WCB?�\�n��BS�?EZK�@�EI�CEMB>�0�@�EB�B�?K�K@U0�E?�>E�

?E�US�E�B�?E�CB��K�SE?I?0�?E�CB��K�JEMP?�E?>�G�?D@I)�FE�KV�E0�W?E?

l�>?E��EVK�D�@K�DKG�U�)�|�k��AKH��KLK�B���?EJ0�V?E�zE@@BI�?EZK��K

G�SEVK?0�V?EAU�RAS�GBI�E>�G�C�@D���K�TECB?BVK@>EME�T�E@?���@?��

O�PGBB)�[�W?EJ�zE@@BI��K�G�B�?K�K@E����)�zE@@BI�>�>���G�SEVK?�Q�B��K

@>�U��K?0�V?E�SEVK?�Q�V?EAU�RAS�GBI�E@?���C�@D���@E@?��K�O�PGBB0��E

O�PGBI�T�B�W?EJ�HECZ���AU?D�E�BK�?B�E����E�����zE@@B^)�|E�>ECD

@>E�E�W?E�?�>0�G��VB?0���kBJ�M�PGB�@>BJ�>ECCKM�J0�B���J�?EZK0���HE

HPJ�?D0�>�>BJ�EA��GEJ�CBkB?D�zE@@B^�W?EME��UV�M��H��CK�BI)�F�>

HEAB?D@I�?EME0�V?EAU�JU��K�AUCB��UV�MEJ)�tU���RAS�GBB�HECZ�U�EA

W?EJ�HPJ�?D0��E�B��U�?EZK�HECZ�U�HPJ�?D0�>�>�W?E�@HKC�?D)

qKCE�?E�KLK�B���?EJ0�V?E��K@JE?�I������G�UK�TK�BEHU�Q�AUC��B

�EJ��E�@>�I�zE@@BI0�TE?EJ�@E�K?@>�I0�?KTK�D�HKJE>��?BVK@>�I�Q��E@�

@B�@>�I�TECB?B>��TE�@PLK@?�P��K�BGJK�BC�@D�B���IH�CB���ACBZ��kKK

��KJI�BGJK�B?@I)�]@EAK��E��E@@B�@>�I�TECB?B>�����F��>�GK)�p?E

I�CIK?@I�KK��SBCCK@E�E��TI?E�)�R�TE?EJP�V�KG�UV���E���Z�E0����JE�

Page 197: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�GMCIH0�>�>�@�JE�>��>�G@>EK�@EEALK@?�E0���H���EJ�@CPV�K�O�PGBI�B

RAS�GBI0�APHK?�E@JU@CB��?D�B�TE�BJ�?D�W?B�T�EACKJU�B�T�ENK@@U0��

>�>BK�TECB?BVK@>BK�>E�@?�P>NBB�W?E�APHK?��UCB��?D@I)�p?E�EVK�D

��Z�E)

y0�JEZK?�AU?D0�TE�?E�I^@D0��E�J�K�AUCE�EVK�D�T�BI?�E0�TE?EJP

V?E�GHK@D�I�P@CUk�C��K>E?E�UK���GJUkCK�BI�B��U>C�H>B���W?EJ����

T���CK�BB)�[E��@I>EJ�@CPV�K0�K@?D�BHKB0�>E?E�UK�JEMP?�@CPZB?D���J

@K�DKG�UJ�TEH@TE�DKJ)

�?E�>�@�K?@I�E�BK�?�NBB)�p?E�BJKK?���Z�EK�G��VK�BK)�]�BK�?��

NBB�AU��^?���G�UK��TECB?BVK@>BK0�MKETECB?BVK@>BK0�@ENB�CD�UK0

W>E�EJBVK@>BK0� W>ECEMBVK@>BK0�>PCD?P��E�NB�BCBG�NBE��UK�B�?)H)

FE�KV�E0�@?�KJCK�BK�>�u��ETK0�>�K��ETK�@>BJ�NK��E@?IJ0��K�VPZHE

B�RAS�GBB)�RAS�GBI�?EZK�BJKC����GCBV�UK�E�BK�?�NBB���@�EK��B@?E�

�BB�Q�?E����O�KNB^0�?E����[BG��?B^0�?E����YP�NB^0�?E����zE@@B^0�B

@KMEH�I���E�D0�>�>�V�@?E�ME�E�I?0�RAS�GBI�T�E�E@@B�@>E��E�BK�?��

NBB)�qPJ�^0�PZK�J�EMBK�TE�BJ�^?0�TEVKJP�P���@�T�E�E@@B�@>�I�E�B�

K�?�NBI)�[�TK��P^�EVK�KHD0�TE?EJP0�V?E�JU��K�SE?BJ�B��K�JEZKJ

AU?D�E?E�����UJB�E?�XK�K��EME�F��>�G�0���XK�K��U��F��>�G�E@?��

K?@I���@E@?��K��E@@B�@>EME�TECB?BVK@>EME�T�E@?���@?��)�]H��>E���kB

B�?K�K@U��K�?ECD>E����XK�K��EJ�F��>�GK0��E�B����?K��B?E�BB�YP��

NBB0�xCBZ�KME�[E@?E>�)���>EMH��JU�ME�E�BJ�E���kBS�B�?K�K@�S0�?E

JU�HECZ�U�PVB?U��?D�B�XK�K��U��F��>�G0�B�xCBZ�B��[E@?E>)�YE�ZK

@�JEK�SEVP�@>�G�?D�E?�E@B?KCD�E�O�PGBB�B�M�PGB�@>BS�B�?K�K@E��Q��

RAS�GBB�W?E�?EZK�HECZ�U�TE�BJ�?D)

=�B� �@KJ� ?EJ0� >�>BK�AU�T�ENK@@U��K�T�EB@SEHBCB0� >�>BK�AU

JEHKCB��K��U��A�?U��CB@D�B��K�>�P?BCB@D�AU�����kKJ�@EG���BB0

J�K�>�ZK?@I0���@�JEK�ACBZ��kKK���KJI�JU�HECZ�U�VK?>E�E@EG��?D

?E��KEASEHBJEK0�V?E��PZ�E�M�PGB��J�B��AS�G�J)�|�@>ECD>E�W?E���J

PH�@?@I��K�CD�E0�I��K�G��^0��E�JU�HECZ�U�E?>�G�?D@I�E?�H�PS�JBlE�

CEMKJ0�>E?E�UK�@K�DKG�E���J�JKk�^?�@ACBZ�?D�TEGBNBB�B���C�ZB�

��?D�JE@?U�HE�K�BI�H�PM�>�H�PMP)�tU���RAS�GBB�HECZ�U�BGA��B?D@I

E?�JBlECEMKJU0�V?E�M�PGB�U���kB����MB0��E���W?EJ���J�HECZ�U�TE�

JEVD�M�PGB�U)�R�@�H�PME��@?E�E�U0�@�JB�M�PGB�U�?EZK�HECZ�U�BGA��

�B?D@I�E?�JBlECEMKJU0�V?E�RAS�GBI�I�CIK?@I�V�@?D^�O�PGBB)�=E>�

W?��JBlECEMKJ��APHK?�T�B@P?@?�E��?D���PVKA�B>�S�BCB���@EG���BB0

@�JE@EG���BB�HK?K��BCB��G�E@CUS0�JU��B>EMH���K�@JEZKJ�P�KMPCB�

Page 198: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�E��?D�W?E?�>E�lCB>?)���JU��B>EMH���K�T�BACBGBJ@I�>�?EJP��KGPCD?��

?P0�>E?E�EME�ZHKJ�E?�?E��BCB�B�E��JEHKCB)�|B�EH���BG�W?BS�JEHKCK�

�K�H�@?���J�?EME��KGPCD?�?�0�>�>E?E�EJP�JU�@?�KJBJ@I)

XT�@BAE�AECDkEK�B�BG�B�B?K0�K@CB�I��K�?�>�@>C�H�E��U��GBC@I0

�E�I�SEVP�KLK���G��U@>�G�?D�@�EK�PHE�CK?�E�K�BK�HE>C�H�JB0�B�E@E�

AK��E�HE>C�HEJ�q��BH��xK�HGK�Bk�BCB0��K�?ECD>E�HE>C�HEJ0��E�B

AK@KHE�)��0�>�EJK�?EME0�I���TK��U����G�GHK@D�TEG��>EJBC@I�@�>�CA�?E�

�E�YB�B>E0�@�pJG��EJ0�B�J�K�BS�JU@CB0�@EEA��ZK�BI0�TEHSEHU�EVK�D

TE����BCB@D)���CD0�V?E��K�G��^0���>�>E��JK�K�E�B��CBI^?����M�PGB��

@>EK�EALK@?�E0��E�T�BI?K��@�J�l�>?0�V?E�K@?D�?�>BK�C^HB)�rK���0

>E�KV�E0�?EZK)�t�K�B�?K�K@���@?�C��@�J��zK@TPACB>��@>�I�T��?BI0��

>E?E�E��C^HB�?�>�@�EAEH�E0�MCPAE>E�B�kB�E>E�JU@CI?)�XT�@BAE�G�

��BJ��BK)

��R��� ����0�8�y�SE?KC��AU��EG��GB?D�zEJK�TE�TE�EHP�KME��K�>NBB����U@?PTCK�BK�RAK@�CEJ�)�]��@>�G�C0�V?E�?E0�V?E�T�KHC�M�K?�RAK@��

CEJ0�P���@�PZK�l�>?BVK@>B�@PLK@?�PK?)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0���EAE�E?��?EME0

V?E�T�KHC�M�K?�RAK@�CEJ0�P���@��EEALK��K?)�|K?�M�PTTU�C^HK�0�>E?E�

��I�TE@?EI��E�AU�HPJ�C��E��E�US�TEHSEH�S�>�P�KMPCB�E���B^)�|K?

@B@?KJ�?BVK@>E����AE?U0���?KJ�AECKK0��K�@EA���U�B�?KCCK>?P�CD�UK

@BCU��E>�PM�W?E��G�H�VB)

u@CB�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�APHK?�@EGH����?�>�I�TE@?EI��E�HK�@?�P^�

L�I�>E�lK�K�NBI0�TK�KH�>E?E�E��APHK?�TE@?��CK���ET�KHKCK���I�G��

H�V�0�?E�W?E�AUCE�AU���Z�UJ�k�MEJ��TK�KH)���I�AC�MEH�����RAK@�CE�

JP�G��HK�@?�B?KCD�E�B�?K�K@�P^�BHK^)

T.����MU���� �-8�[E�TK��US0�HECZK��@>�G�?D0�V?E��KVD�ME@TEHB��]CKM��|K@?E�E�BV��JK�I�EVK�D�?�E�PC�)�y��@TEJ�BC���@@>�GU����

kBS�PVB?KCK�0��@K�>�>�?E�EZB�BCE@D���T�JI?B�Q�AUCUK�SE�EkBK�E?�

�EkK�BI)�y�AUC�W?BJ�?�E�P?)

[E��?E�US0�SE?KC�AU��U@?PTB?D�T�E?B��T�lE@���U@?PTCK�BI�ME@�

TEHB���YK�MBG�)�qKCE��K���?EJ0�V?E�I�G�LBL�^�RAK@�CEJ�0�E��@�J

@KAI�JEZK?�G�LB?B?D)�|K�@?EB?�G����kBJB�BCB���kBJB�T�KHCEZK�B�

IJB�TEHEG�K��?D�>�>BK�?E�PCE�>B�BCB�SB?�E@?B)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�T�B�

@P?@?�P^LBK�GHK@D�HE@?BMCB�?E��@?KTK�B�HE�K�BI0�>EMH��JEZ�E�EAE��

?B@D�AKG�SB?�E@?K�)�y�T�KHC�M�^�?�>P^�JEHKCD��TEH�R�BCB�x�TEH��GP�

Page 199: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

JK��?D�?ECD>E�R�B�x�B�AECDkK��BVKME)�tU��K�@JEZKJ�H�CDkK�T�EHEC�

Z�?D���AE?P0�K@CB��@I>B����G�TEH�R�BCB�x�APHKJ�TEH��GPJK��?D���G�

�UK��KLB)�p?E0�?�>�@>�G�?D0��KEASEHBJEK�P@CE�BK�HCI�HB�CEM�)�X�TE�

HEG�K�BIJB�HB�CEM�B��G�BJETE�BJ��BK��K�TECPV�?@I)

�� ������/%!��-8�[�TECB?B>K�AKG�SB?�E@?K���K�AU��K?)

T.����MU���� �-8�|E�JU��K�TECB?B>B��y�JEMP�@>�G�?D�E�@KAK0�V?E

I�CBV�E��K�TECB?B>�B��B>EMH���K�@?��P�TECB?B>EJ)�y�T�KH@?��CI^

B�?K�K@U�@�EB�B�@�EBS�H�PGK�0�>�>�M��ZH��@>EK�CBNE)

�� ������/%!��-8�=�EK>?�RAK@�CEJ��>�@�C@I�TECB?B>B�B�BJKK?�T�I�JEK�E?�EkK�BK�>�TECB?B>K)�y���@�TE�BJ�^0��E��B>�>EME�E@>E�ACK�

�BI�GHK@D��K�AUCE)�]��>�@�C@I�TECB?BVK@>E��JEHKCB0�TEW?EJP0�HP�

J�^0�RAK@�CEJ��K�EABHKC@I����JEB�@CE��)�[�TECB?B>K�AKG�SB?�E@?K�

B�>�T>��E���K�AU��K?0�B��K�?ECD>E���TECB?B>K0��E�B���EALK�BB0�B��E

�@?�KV�S)

M�,�R����R�� �S,���8�y�?EZK�SEVP��U@>�G�?D@I�TE�TE�EHP�HB@>P@�@BB)�]VK�D�B�?K�K@��I�HB@>P@@BI)�=E@>ECD>P�JU����W?EJ�G�>��VB���

KJ�HB@>P@@BE��P^�V�@?D�B�G��?���TK�KSEHBJ����TC��U0�?E�SEVP�TE�

AC�MEH��B?D���@��@KS�B��U@>�G�?D�EH�E�?�>EK�@�EK�T�KH@?��CK�BK0�@�E�

EAEALK��U���U�EH)

y�HPJ�^0�V?E�AECDkB�@?�E�BG���@0�H��B��K�?ECD>E�JU0��E��EEALK

�@K���kB�JU@CILBK�@EM��ZH��K�ES��VK�U�EH�E��T���HBMJE�)�p?P

T���HBMJP�JEZ�E���G��?D�T���HBMJE���KG��B@BJE@?B)���HCI�M�PGB�0

B�HCI��AS�GNK��E@�E���I�NK��E@?D�Q�W?E��KG��B@BJE@?D0�E���@E@?���

CIK?��K>BK���J>B0���>E?E�US�JU�?E�@TE�BJ0�?E�@EMC�k�KJ@I)�|E��K�

�CD�E�JU��KHD�ZB�KJ���JB�K0�MHK��G�BJEG��B@BJE@?D�I�CIK?@I�AECKK

�K�CD�UJ�l�>?EJ0�VKJ��KG��B@BJE@?D)�XKMEH�I����K�CD�EJ�JB�K��G��

BJEG��B@BJE@?D�HEJB�B�PK?���H�@P�K�K�B?K?EJ)�y��K�PVP�B��K�T�E�

�EVK@?�P^0��E�@VB?�^0�V?E���>�>E��?E�JEJK�?���J�T�BHK?@I�TK�K�?B

���@CE���D��G�BJEG��B@BJE@?B)

|�T�BJK�0�>EMH��YK�MBG�ME�E�BC�EA�E�BK�?�NBB0�B�rK����@��BJ

@TE�BC0���]CKM�|K@?E�E�BV�ME�E�BC�E�JBlECEMKJ�S0�E?�>E?E�US���HE

BGA��CI?D@I0��@K�ZK�T�B@P?@?�E��C�JEJK�?0�@�IG���U��@�ET�@K�BKJ�Q

Page 200: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

>?E�V?E�P�>EME�E?�BJK?�B�>?E�PIG�BJ���TC��K�TE?K�B�@�EK���KG��B@B�

JE@?B)�|��K��EK0���J���HE�TEHPJ�?D�E�?EJ0���VKJ�JU�H�PM�E?�H�PM�

�@K�?�>B�G��B@BJ�B�>�>�ZB?D���W?EJ�JB�K0�MHK�MCEA�CBG�NBI�APHK?

HEJB�B�E��?D���H��KMBE��CBG�NBK�)�u@?D�?K�HK�NBB�MCEA�CBG�NBB0

�G�BJEG��B@BJE@?B0�B��KMBE��CBG�NBB)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�JU��@?PT�KJ��

WTESP0�MHK�T�B@P?@?�P^?�EAK�?K�HK�NBB0��E��@K�?�>B�E@�E��E���>NK�?

APHK?����MCEA�CBG�NBB)�R��KMBE��CBG�NBI�APHK?��EG�B>�?D�>�>��K�>�

NBI����MCEA�CBG�NB^)

=EW?EJP�JU�HECZ�U���PVB?D@I��E�E��T���HBMJK�JUkCK�BI0�V?E�

AU���@@J�?�B��?D���kB��G�BJEE?�EkK�BI�B�TK�@TK>?B�U�@�W?BS�TE�

GBNB�)�n�JK�I��K?�>E�>�K?�US��KNKT?E��BCB�>E�>�K?�US�T�EK>?E�0

�E�I�SE?KC�AU�TEHVK�>�P?D0�@EMC�@�E�>�>E��T���HBMJK�JU�ZB�KJ��

��@?EILB��JEJK�?)�XT�@BAE)

!.� �M"��8�y�SE?KC�AU��U��GB?D�T�BG��?KCD�E@?D�G��EVK�D�B�?K��K@�UK�@EEALK�BI)�=�EG�PV�CB��K�?ECD>E��GMCIHU����T�EACKJU�B�BS

ENK�>�0�AUCB��U@>�G��U�B�EVK�D�B�?K�K@�UK�BHKB)�y�SE?KC�AU�@>��

G�?D�E�M�P@?�E��@?E�E�K�W?EME�T�ENK@@�)

[E�TK��US0�I�AU�@����BC���k�T�ENK@@0���>E?E�EJ�PV�@?�P^�PZK

AECDkK�H�PS�CK?0�@�BM�E��}]0�@V�@?CB�VB>�~)�[�W?E��BM�K�K@?D��K@ME�

��KJUK�@PJJU0�>EMH���BZK��K>E?E�EME�P�E��I�PZK��KCDGI�ETP@?B?D�

@I)�tU�T�ESEHBJ�>�>BK�?E�W?�TU0�B�I�HPJ�^��>�>E��ZK��K@ME��KJE�

@PJJU�JU�HE@?BMCB�B�V?E�JEZK?�AU?D���B?EMK\

rBV�E�HCI�JK�I�JEZK?�AU?D�?�>E�����B��?����@CPV�K�@�JEME�E?�

�BN�?KCD�EME���G�B?BI�@EAU?B�0�=��?��>�>��BAPHD����HK?�JEB�E@�

?��>B�B�TK�KH�@?�JEBJ��EH@?�K��B>�J)���� � �������n��KME�AECD�kE��ETU?)�[E?��K@ME��KJ�I�@PJJ�)�[�C^AEJ�@CPV�K�@PLK@?�P^?�>��

>BK�?E�M�P@?�UK��K@ME��KJUK�B?EMB)

|E�I�AU�SE?KC�@>�G�?D0�V?E�H�PMBJ�EVK�D�M�P@?�UJ�JEJK�?EJ

I�CIK?@I�?E0�V?E�JU0�H������EH�0���W?EJ�JB�K�E>�G�CB@D��EEALK��K�

@TE@EA�UJB��P>E�EH@?�E��?D@I���GPJ�UJB��KL�JB)�|�JB��P>E�EHI?

@>E�KK�@ENB�CD�UK�B�@?B�>?U0��KZKCB���GPJ�U��TEHSEH)

[�W?E��@B?P�NBB�JEZ�E�H�ZK�@>�G�?D0�V?E�����kKJ��KMBE�K�HCI

�AS�G@>EME����EH�0�I�CI^LKME@I�EVK�D�J�CK�D>BJ����EHEJ0�@�JP^

AECDkP^�PM�EGP��K@K?���@KAK�M�PGB�@>B�����EH)�YE�K@?D0��B�EHB�����

�EH����GKJCK��K�APHK?�P�BV?EZ�?D��AS�GE�0����E?�M�PGB�@>B�����EH

Page 201: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

JEZK?�BS�P�BV?EZB?D)�=�BVKJ�lBGBVK@>B)����E?�>�>�W?E��B�G�PVB?�Q

B�M�P@?�E0�B�G�K�@>B�Q��E����@�JEJ�HKCK�JEZ�E�@KAK�T�KH@?��B?D0�>�>

W?E�JEMCE�AU�T�EB@SEHB?D0�B�W?E�PZK�T�EB@SEHBCE)�y�ME�E�^�E�?EJ0

V?E�@E@?��CIK?�M�P@?�P^�V�@?D)���W?E���@�JEJ�HKCK�?�>)���T�B�W?EJ

JU�@?EBJ�TK�KH��K�EGJEZ�E@?D^��KkB?D�H���P^�T�EACKJP0�TE?EJP

V?E���KJI�BHK?0�B�J�CE�V?E�JK�IK?@I���EALK@?�K0�>E?E�EK�HECZ�E�AUCE

AU����?B�>�>BK�?E�@TE@EAU��KkK�BI�T�EACKJU)��K@?>E@?D��U@>�GU�

���B����@?K?�@�>�ZHUJ�MEHEJ)���H�ZK�@KMEH�I0�APHD��EGJEZ�E@?D��K�

kK�BI�W?E��T�EACKJU�@BCE�0�E���AUC��AU��KkK���@BCE�UJ�TP?KJ)

F�ZHU��HK�D�JEZ�E�@?�C>B��?D@I�@�?KJ�EM�EJ�UJ�>ECBVK@?�EJ�@?���

H��B�0�>E?E�UK��UGU��K?�W?E�T�E?B�E@?EI�BK0�����kKJ�EALK@?�K��E

�@I>EJ�@CPV�K)���>EMH��JU�ME�E�BJ�E��EGJEZ�E@?B�MCEA�CBG�NBB0�?E

I0�>E�KV�E0�>�W?E��BHKK�E?�EkP@D��K�EVK�D�SE�EkE)�|E��BZP0�V?E�KHB��

@?�K��U��@TE@EA��KkK�BI���kBS�T�EACKJ�CKZB?�BJK��E���W?E��EA�

C�@?B)�xECKK���G�B?UK�BHKB0��EGJEZ�E0�APHP?�ACE>B�E��?D���kB�@E�

NB�CD�UK�B�@?B�>?U�B��K�H�HP?���J��EGJEZ�E@?B��Kk�?D�T�EACKJU

��?�>EJ�ZK@?>EJ�B��KT�BMCIH�EJ��BHK)

y�SE?KC�AU�@>�G�?D�B�E�T�EACKJK�T�B�CK>�?KCD�E@?B)�=E�BJ�^0

V?E�M�PGB�@>�I�@?E�E���EVK�D�SE?KC��AU��BHK?D�RAS�GB^���@E@?��K

O�PGBB)�[�>�>EJ��BHK0�W?E�PZK�H�PME���ET�E@)�|E�JU��B>EMH���K�ME�E�

�BJ�E��G�BJ�E��T�B�CK>�?KCD�E@?B)�zKVD�BHK?�@>E�KK�E�>�>E��?E�?K��

�B?E�BB0�VKJ�EA�W?�BVK@>E��T�B�CK>�?KCD�E@?B0��EGJEZ�E@?B��E��

CKVK�BI���NB�BCBG�NBE��U��T�ENK@@0��G�BJ�EME�>PCD?P��EME�EAEM��

LK�BI)�=E?EJP�V?E�EVK�D�?�PH�E�@KAK�T�KH@?��B?D�@CEZK�BK�H�PS

>PCD?P����@B?P�NBB0���>E?E�E��JU���SEHBJ@I0�V?EAU�TECPVB?D�TECE�

ZB?KCD�U���KGPCD?�?0����K�AECDkE��JB�P@)

F�ZHU����G0�>EMH��JU��@?�KV�KJ@I0�JU�TU?�KJ@I�?L�?KCD�E�T�E�

LPTU��?D�JEJK�?U0�@�IG���UK�@��EGJEZ�E@?D^�T�EH�B�P?D@I�SE?I

AU����>�>E��?E�k�M��TK�KH)�|E�I�HPJ�^0�V?E�����kKJ�EALK@?�K�@PLK�

@?�PK?��E�J�EME���G�AECKK�T�EH�B�P?UK�lE�JU�T��>?BVK@>EME��G�B�

JEHK�@?�BI0��KZKCB�?E0�E�VKJ�JU�@���JB�ME�E�BJ)�=E?EJP�V?E�K@?D

C^HB0�>E?E�UK�@�EAEH�E�KGHI?�TE�EAK�@?E�E�U�M���BNU)�u@?D�C HB0

BJK^LBK��EH@?�K��B>E��TE�EAK�@?E�E�U0�B�@E�K�kK��E�@TE>E��E

EAL�^?@I)�u@?D�C HB0�>E?E�UK�EVK�D��>?B��E�?E�MP^?)���W?E��E�@K

�K�EAIG�?KCD�E�>�BJB��CD�UK�WCKJK�?U0�>E?E�UK�KGHI?���YABCB@B�B

T�B�EGI?�?E������XPSPJ0���BG�XPSPJ���KGP?���YABCB@B�BCB����>�>BK�?E

Page 202: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

H�PMBK��U�>B)�YE�K@?D�HE@?�?EV�E�T��>?BV�UK�C^HB0�>E?E�UK�PZK

TK�Kk�M�PCB�@?E�E�P�?KE�BB�B�TK�KkCB�>��K�CD�E��ZBG�B)�y�HPJ�^0

BJK��E�@�KHB��BS0���BS�T�KH@?��CK�BIS�E�ZBG�B0�JEZK?�AU?D0�BJKK?

@JU@C�B@>�?D�JEHKCB���kBS��G�BJEHK�@?�B�)

��V?EAU�@E�@KJ�PZ��K�AUCE�M�P@?�E�E?�JEKME��U@?PTCK�BI0�I

SE?KC�AU�TEZKC�?D0�V?EAU�JU�AUCB�AECKK�E?>�E�K��UJB)�YE0�V?E0�>

T�BJK�P0�JEMP?�T�EB@SEHB?D�@?EC>�E�K�BI�>�>BS�?E���kBS�J�K�B�

Q�W?E�ME��GHE�AECKK�TECKG�E�B�T�BI?�E0�VKJ�JECV�CB��I0�PCUAVB��I

@?E�E��� ��kBS� �@?�KV0� @>�U��^L�I�B@>�K��BK� T�KH@?��CK�BI� E

ZBG�B)

M���� �/%�"�-8�y�@�PHE�ECD@?�BKJ��U@CPk�C�EA��W?B��U@?PTCK�BI)

qE>C�H�q��BH��J�K�TE����BC@I�@�EK��>E�>�K?�E@?D^0�HE>C�H�RAK�

@�CEJ���A@?��>?�E@?D^)�n��BS0�K@CB��U�G�JK?BCB0�@CEZBC@I�?�>E�

?��HKJ0�B�EA��HE>C�H��HETEC�BCB�H�PM�H�PM�)�FE�KV�E0��K��@K��^���

@U�PCE�BJU����@CPS0��E�HPJ�^0�>EMH��E�B�APHP?���TKV�?��U0�?E�H�HP?

�K�CD�P^0�BCB�EVK�D�ACBG>P^�>��K�CD�E@?B0�>��?B�P�?EME0�V?E�@PLK�

@?�PK?0�V?E��EGJEZ�E�B�V?E�SE?I?�T�B@P?@?�P^LBK�GHK@D)

��V?EAU�>�>�?E�@>��@B?D�M�P@?�U��?E��zEJ���0�I�SE?KC�AU�HEA��

�B?D0�l��?�GB�PI0�EHB��TP�>?�>�?KJ0�>E?E�UK�TK�KVB@CBC���J�q��BH)

F�>�AU�I�SE?KC0�V?EAU�W?E�T�EBGEkCE��{HK@D0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�AECDkK

G��B@B?�E?�M�PGB�@>E��@?E�E�U)��HKI���?EJ0�V?EAU�TK�KBM��?D��@KS�Q

B�@K�K��US0�B� Z�US0�B�G�T�H�US0�B��E@?EV�US�BM�E>E�)�YE�K@?D���G�

�PAB?D�ME�HBK��PGKC0��K�HEZBH�I@D0�TE>��BG�@EG���BI�M�PGB�@>EME

EALK@?���P�HK?�?��JBlECEMKJ�0�E�>E?E�E��@>�G�C�]CKM�|K@?E�E�BV�Q

V?E�RAS�GBI�I�CIK?@I��KE?HKCBJE��V�@?D^�O�PGBB)�qCI�W?EME���O�P�

GBB�HECZK��TEI�B?D@I�TECB?BVK@>B��CBHK��J�@k?�A�� MK�K��C��HK

OECCI��E�m���NBB0�>E?E�U��T�BG��K?�RAS�GB^)

F�>BK��UMEHU�E?�W?EME\

t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�TK���I��UMEH��HCI�@�JE��O�PGBB)�n�JK�I�?�>EK

ELPLK�BK0�V?E�RAS�GBI�Q�W?E�>�>E��?E��PHBJK�?0�?E�JEGILB����G�B�

?BK�O�PGBB)�XEGH�K?@I�ELPLK�BK0�V?E�RAS�GBI�EVK�D�JKk�K?�M�PGB�

��J�@?�?D�@�EAEH�UJB���TEC�EJ�@JU@CK�@CE��0�JKk�K?��@KJP�BS���G�

�B?B^0�HKJE>��?BB0�W?E�>�>E��?E�HP��E��@E�0�>E?E�U�����KL�K?�BS

>�ZHP^��EVD)�=EW?EJP0�E@�EAEHB�kB@D�E?�RAS�GBB0�O�PGBI0�J�K�>��

ZK?@I0��GHES�K?�@�EAEH�KK)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�GHK@D�T�B@P?@?�PK?��K>E?E�

Page 203: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�U���KCBMBEG�U��JEJK�?��O�PGBI�HECZ���HE��@?B�HE� ?EME0� V?EAU

@JB�B?D@I�@�W?BJ)

=E��K�@BB�B@?E�B>E�0�>E?E�US�JU��@K��KHEC^ACB��KJ0�RAS�GBI

@?EIC��P�B@?E>E��M�PGB�@>E��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B)�y��K�SEVP�AU?D�TCE�

SBJ�T�E�E>EJ0��E0�K@CB�TEl��?�GB�E��?D0�?E0��lE�B@?BVK@>B��U���

Z�I@D0�RAS�GBI�JEZK?�@?EI?D�B�P�>E�N��M�PGB�@>E��ME@PH��@?�K��E@�

?B)�]TI?D�?�>B�T�EHECZ�I��KCBMBEG�P^�?KJP0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�RAS�GBI

TE@C����O�PGBB�>�>�B@TU?��BK0�B�O�PGBI�@�W?BJ�B@TU?��BKJ�TE>���K

@T���CIK?@I)�RAS�GBI�K��JKk�K?)�p?E�T�IJ�I��UMEH�)

zUV�MB0�E�>E?E�US�JU�ME�E�BCB0�E?�>E?E�US�JU��@K�@>�BTBJ0�?E

K@?D�H��CK�BK����O�PGB^�VK�KG�RAS�GB^0�W?E?�MC���U���UV�M���?EJ��

?BVK@>B�B@VKG�K?0�K@CB�TK�KBM��?D�AECDkBS�BM�E>E�)

qCI���@�W?E��UMEH�0�TE?EJP�V?E�RAS�GBI0�KK��KT�BG����E@?D0�KK

TEH�KkK��EK�@E@?EI�BK��UGU��K?�VP�@?�E�PLK�A�E@?B0�TE?EJP�V?E

JU�Q��BMHK)�tU0���EHK�AU0�K@?D0��E�T�@TE�?��P���@�@E�K?@>BK0�?)K)�?EME

ME@PH��@?��0�>E?E�EME�H���E��K?)�OKEM��lBVK@>B�JU�>�>�APH?E�@PLK�

@?�PKJ0��E���JB�E�EJ�T�E@?���@?�K0�HPSE��EJ�Q�JU�>�>�l��?EJ0�l���

?�GJ0�>�>�JU�C^ABJ��U��Z�?D@I����W?E���@?�KVK0�B�W?E�@EGH�K?�ELP�

LK�BK�PLK�A�E@?B0�?E�JEGB?���kK�>PCD?P��EK0�HPSE��EK0�W>E�EJB�

VK@>EK�B��@I>EK�H�PMEK���G�B?BK)

Y�>BJ�EA��GEJ0�O�PGBI0��K�T�BG����I�RAS�GB^0�@TE@EA@?�PK?�KK

��P?�K��K��HKM��H�NBB)�]���T�E�EHB?��@K�?P�ZK�@E�K?@>P^�TECB?B�

>P0�?ECD>E���H�PME��lE�JK)�=ECPVB��?�>EK�T�BG���BK0�JU0��AS�GU0

>E�KV�E0�TE>�ZKJ��KGPCD?�?U)�y��K�P�K�K�0�B��K?�M����?B�0�V?E���ACB�

Z��kKK���KJI�JU�TE@?�EBJ�ME@PH��@?�E0��E�TEVKJP�?E�HPJ�^0�V?E

RAS�GBI�@�W?BJ�@T���B?@I0��E�JKk�K?�O�PGBI)�uK�EAwI?BI�Q�?KTK�D

PZK�EAwI?BI��K���T�IJEJ�@JU@CK0��E�lC^BH�UK�>�>BK�?E�EAwI?BI�Q

�@K�KLK�HPk�?�RAS�GB^)�n�JK�I�?�>EK�VP�@?�E)�=EW?EJP0�J�K�>�ZK?�

@I0�O�PGBI�HECZ���@HKC�?D�?�>EK�P@BCBK0�V?EAU���G�B����@KMH���K�

kB?D�W?P�T�EACKJP)�p?E��E�@K��K�B@>C^V�K?�@ACBZK�BI���kBS����E�

HE�0�JEZK?0�H�ZK�APHK?�@TE@EA@?�E��?D0�>EMH��JU�T�BG��KJ�H�PM�H�P�

M�0�>�>���G�UK��KG��B@BJUK�KHB�BNU)�n�JK�I�?�>EK�ELPLK�BK0�V?E

G��?��k�B��HK�D�E?>�U��K?�AECKK�kB�E>BK�TK�@TK>?B�U0�VKJ�W?B

VK�KT�kDB�k�MB�>�P�KMPCB�E���B^�>E�lCB>?�0�>E?E�UK�HKC�^?@I���

ME@PH��@?�K��EJ�P�E��K0�B�P@BCBIJB�W�?PGB�@?E��B��@KS�JB�EC^AB�

�E���@?�EK��US�C HK�)�R��KkK�BK�AECDkK�G��B@B?�E?�O�PGBB0�VKJ�E?

Page 204: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

RAS�GBB)�RAS�GBI�JEZK?�TECPVB?D�T�BG���BK�?ECD>E�E?�O�PGBB0��E?

>�>�I�G��B@BJE@?D�RAS�GBB�E?�O�PGBB)�XPHDAE�E@��I�G��B@BJE@?D)

|�@��B>?E��K�T�BG��K?0�TE>��O�PGBI�W?EME��K�@HKC�K?0�E���HECZ���AU?D

TK��E�0�>?E���@�T�BG��K?0�TEW?EJP�����K��CKZB?�@�J�I�AECDk�I�E?�

�K?@?�K��E@?D)�u@CB�O�PGBI�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�ZKC�K?�RAS�GBB�T�EN�K�

?��BI0��UZB���BI�B�?)H)0�?E�HECZ���TK��E��KK�T�BG��?D)�y��K�TECB�

?B>0��E�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�VK�KG�W?E�E���CKMVK�@JEZK?��KkB?D�J�EMBK

@�EB���Z�UK�T�EACKJU�B�@�J����P?�K��K�E@�EAEHB?@I)

YP?�?�>�I�B@?E�BVK@>�I�T���CCKCD0�I�KLK���G���TEJB��^��B@?E�

�B>B�ME�E�I?0�V?E�RAS�GBI�AUC��P�B@?E>E��M�PGB�@>E��ME@PH��@?�K��

�E@?B)�p?E�AUCE�?U@IVP�CK?���G�H0�B�?KTK�D�B@?E�BI�TE�?E�IK?@I0��E

��GK�>�CD�EJ�E?��ZK�BB0�B�ETI?D�@�RAS�GBB�JEZK?�V?E�?E���V�?D@I

BCB�G�>E�VB?D@I0��E�PZK���H�PME��lE�JK)

RAK@�CEJ��B�q��BH��AC�MEH��^�G��EVK�D�@EHK�Z�?KCD�UK��U@�

?PTCK�BI)

��R��� ����0�8�q�P�0�RAS�GBI���?�EKJ�TE�BJ��BB�HECZ���?ECD>EZH�?D�BCB�E���?EZK�V?E�?E�HECZ���HKC�?D\

M���� �/%�"�-8�|K?0�ZH�?D�Q�W?E�SPHkB�����B��?)�tU��@K�����E�AP�

HKJ�W?EME�HEAB��?D@I)�|E�JU�HECZ�U�TEJEVD�H�PM�H�PMP)�tU�ZK��@K

ME�E�BJ0�V?E�E@�IG��U�?�>BJB�>�KT>BJB�PG�JB)

��R��� ����0�8�p?E�I�TE�IC�0��E�>�>E����k��USEH\�[USEH�BG�W?E�

B@?E�BB�HCI�O�PGBB�Q�W?E�BGJK�B?D�E?�EkK�BK�>�RAS�GBB)�R�TK�KH

>�>BJ��UGE�EJ�@?EB?�RAS�GBI0�>�>P^�@�E^���P?�K��^^�G�H�VP�E��

HECZ����KkB?D\�p?E��KHD���kK�B@TU?��BK�Q��KT�BG����E@?D0�HKM���

H�NBI)��?E�JU�HECZ�U�@HKC�?D\�tU��BHBJ0�V?E�HECZ���@HKC�?D�O�P�

GBI0��E�I��K��K�^0�V?E�V?E�?E�JEZK?��K�CD�E0���HB>�CD�E�BGJK�B?D@I0

K@CB�JU�T�E@?E�APHKJ�EZBH�?D0�>EMH��>?E�?E�@HKC�K?�@�E������@?�K��

�U���UAE�)

M���� �/%�"�-8��H�?D\�|K?)�[E?��VK���ME�E�BCE@D�Q���k�G��PAKZ�

�U��ME@?D�?�>�TE�IC�Q�V?E��AS�GU�B�M�PGB�U��@K�KLK�@�JEBHK�?BlB�

NB�P^?@I�VK�KG�EA��G����M�)�|K�G��^0�>�>���M�PGB�@>EJ�EALK@?�K0��E

���AS�G@>EJ�PZK�?�>�P@?�CB�E?�?�>E��ZBG�B0�V?E�PZK��K�>E�@?�PB�P^?

Page 205: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

EA��G����M�)�qCI�JK�I�B�HCI�J�EMBS�JEBS�G��>EJUS�M�PGB�U�B�O�PGBI

�K�I�CI^?@I����M�JB)��K@?�E�ME�E�I0�M�PGB�U�B�O�PGBI0����K>E?E�EJ

�EHK0�HCI���kKME�HPSE��EME�ETU?��Q�W?E�T�EkCEK)�[�Kk�BK�T�EACK�

JU���@�PZK�JK�DkK��EC�P^?0�VKJ���P?�K��BK�T�EACKJU��AS�GE��B

�AS�G@>EME�EALK@?��)�tU�HECZ�U�@?�EB?D���P?�B�@�EK�ME@PH��@?�E0

�K�HEZBH�I@D0�TE>��O�PGBI���@�T�BG��K?)�YK�MBG�ME�E�BC�E����B��?K0

>EMH��zE@@BI�JEZK?�AECKK��>?B��E��U@?PTB?D����@?E�E�K�O�PGBB0�B

q��BH��K�B@>C^V�C��EGJEZ�E@?B0�V?E���@CPV�K��EGEA�E�CK�BI��EK��

�US�HK�@?�B�� �AS�G@>BK�TEH��GHKCK�BI�E>�ZP?� @ET�E?B�CK�BK)�y

P�K�K�0�V?E�E�B�E>�ZP?�AECDkEK�@ET�E?B�CK�BK0�TE?EJP�V?E�@?�KJ�

CK�BK�>�?EJP0�V?EAU�TE@?�EB?D�@�EK�ME@PH��@?�E0�EVK�D��KCB>E)�]>��

ZP?�@ET�E?B�CK�BK��K�?ECD>E�W?BJ0��E�B���?E�@>BJ�@BC�J�?EZK)�p?E�I

ME�E�^�@E�K�kK��E�@K�DKG�E)��JK^�T���E�?�>�ME�E�B?D0�TE?EJP�V?E

���K>E?E�EJ��EHK�T�BV�@?K��>��E��K)�y�TE?K�IC�����E��K��EH�EME

A��?�0�TE?K�IC�EVK�D�J�EME�ACBG>BS�C^HK�0�B���HB�T�JI?B�A��?�0��

W?E��K�T�ESEHB?�AK@@CKH�E0�?�>���@BCD�E�TK�KBM��?D���@�B���@BCD�E

>PH��?E��>C^VB?D0�J�K�>�ZK?@I0�PZK��K�EGJEZ�E)��CB�JU�B@VKG�KJ

>�>����EH0�BCB�APHKJ�@ET�E?B�CI?D@I�B��K�TEG�ECBJ)

�� ������/%!��-8�[�J��K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E��U�I��E�T�KP�KCBVB��K?K�EGJEZ�E@?B��AS�GE������G�PkK�BB�M�PGB�@>EME�ME@PH��@?��\�|��K��

�EK0�B@SEHB?K�BG��KGPCD?�?E���E��U\�y0�K@?K@?�K��E0��K�SEVP��B>EME

E@>E�ACI?D0��E�T�K>��@�E�BG�K@?�E0�>�>BK�JEL�UK�@BCU�E>�GU��CB

TEHHK�Z>P��AS�G�J)

��KLK�EHB���ET�E@0�TE�TE�EHP�TECB?B>B)�[�TE@CKH�K��V�@?B����

kKME��U@?PTCK�BI��U�@>�G�CB0�V?E�APHK?K�@ET�E?B�CI?D@I)�FEMH��I

T�KHTEC�M�^0�V?E�O�PGBI�T�BJK?��E@@B�@>P^�E�BK�?�NB^0�?E�I�HP�

J�^0�V?E���W?EJ����B��?K�@EE?�K?@?�P^LBK�@BCU�TE@?���^?@I�T�B�

�K@?B�>��C�@?B���XPSPJB�?�>P^�M�PTTP��AS�GNK�0�>E?E��I�APHK?����

@?�EK���?�>�ZK)�YE�K@?D�W?BJ�@BC�J�APHK?��PZ�E��K�KHB�EK��AS�G@>EK

EALK@?�E0�ME?E�EK�>�@TCEVK��E��AE�DAK)

M���� �/%�"�-8�y�E?�KV�^����TK��U���ET�E@��>EMH��I�ME�E�BC�E���G��PkK�BB�M�PGB�@>EME�ME@PH��@?��0�?E�@E�@KJ��K�BJKC����BHP0�V?E��A�

S�GU�TE�HP?�B�G�S��?I?�YABCB@B)�|K?0�I�BJKC����BHP�?K�T@BSECEMBVK@�

>BK0�K@CB�SE?B?K0�B�?BJ�UK0�E?�EkK�BI0�>E?E�UK�@CEZBCB@D����T�E�

Page 206: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

?IZK�BB��K>E��JKZHP��AS�G�JB�B�M�PGB��JB)�y�BJKC����BHP���kP

G��B@BJE@?D0�HPSE��P^�G��B@BJE@?D)�p?E�K@?D0�B��KCDGI�W?E�E?�BN�?D)

YKTK�D�E�?KS�@BC�S0�>E?E�UK�TEHHK�ZB��CB�RAS�GB^��E���KJI

�E��U)�XBCU�AUCB���G�UK0�M�PGB��?EZK�TEHHK�ZB��CB���G�UK�@BCU)

|E�H����?K��EGDJKJ�@TB@>B�?KS0�>?E�TEMBA����W?E���E��K0�>?E�HK�Z�C

E�PZBK����P>�S0�>?E�kKC����?�>P0�>?E�@CEZBC�MECE�U)�p?E�@�JU��MC���

�U��TE>�G�?KCD)�R�>?E��UTP@?BC���?EJ�?�F�C�k�B>E���B�H�C�?KAK

BCB�?U�>PTBC�P��KME�Q�W?E��?E�E@?KTK��U���ET�E@)�|K?��E��0�>E?E�

�UK�AU�G�>��VB��CB@D�BG�G��E?@P?@?�BI�E�PZBI)�]�PZBK��@KMH������

HK?@I)���BG�>E�U@?�US�NKCK��EAUV�E�HEAU��K?@I)��.( � ����> ��#���

F�>BK�AU�@TK>PCINBB��K�AUCB��E>�PM�W?E���E��U0�GK��E0�@?K��

ZK�D��E��U�HCI��AS�G@>EME�@EG���BI�Q�W?E�AE�DA��G��@�EAEHP)�u@CB

@�EAEH��Q�TP@?EK�@CE�E0�?EMH���U�T���U)�u@CB��KG��B@BJE@?D�Q�TP@�

?EK�@CE�E0�K@CB��@K�W?E�?ECD>E�TECB?BVK@>�I�BM��0�?E�H�)�|E�@?K�Z�KJ

�@KME0�V?E�T�EBGEkCE���5,�J0�53�J�B�TE@CKHP^LBS�MEH�S0�AUC��AE�D�

A��G��@�EAEHP�B��UZB���BK��AS�G@>EME�W?�E@�)�RAS�G@>EK�EALK@?�E

@VB?�CE0�V?E��K�JEZK?0�E@?���I@D���CE�K�O�PGBB0��UZB?D�>�>�W?�E@)

[E��@I>EJ�@CPV�K0�W?E�JEK�T�KH@?��CK�BK�EA�W?E���E��K)�=EW?EJP�I

ME�E�^0�V?E�W?��@�EAEH��>PTCK���?�>E��NK�E�0�V?E�JEK�TE>ECK�BK�?�>

T�E@?E�@��K���K���@@?��K?@I0��K�H�@?�@KAI�TE@?��B?D����>ECK�B0�H�ZK

K@CB�APHP?�>����BK�lE�JU)

|�@VK?��E@@B�@>EME����B��?�)�]TI?D�?�>B��U���@@PZH�K?K�>�>

TECB?B>0�SE?I�TECB?B>�GHK@D�q��BH)�[U�ME�E�B?K0�V?E����AS�G@>EJ

EALK@?�K�APHP?�>�W?EJP���KJK�B�@EGH��U�>�>BK�?E�@BCU0�>E?E�UK�APHP?

@�K�?U��?D��P>E�EH@?�E�B�?)H)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�W?E��@K����T�E?IZK�BB

JEKME�TE>ECK�BI��K�EGJEZ�E)

!R������RU,���R��8�uLK��ET�E@�TE�TE�EHP��UGE��)�{��VB?0�HCI

O�PGBB��AS�G@>�I�T�EACKJ��Q��UGE�)�R��E?��KT�BG���BK�O�PGBB�Q�?EZK

�UGE��HCI�RAS�GBB\�R�K@CB�T�EHECZB?D�W?E?��ET�E@�Q�HETP@?BJ0�O�P�

GBI��B>EMH���K�T�BG��K?�RAS�GB^0��K�TEI�B?@I�W?E?�VKCE�K>0�E�>E?E�

�EJ�ME�E�BC�]CKM�|K@?E�E�BV0�?EMH��V?E�T�KHT�BJK?�RAS�GBI\

��������%�"�8�tEZ�E0�I�E?�KVP\�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�?EMH��JU��@K

E@?��KJ@I�J��BE�K?>�JB0��>?K��JB0�BM��^LBJB���VPZBK�BM�U)�[@K

APHK?�T�EHECZ�?D@I�?�>0�>�>�@K�V�@)��?E���J�KLK�E@?�K?@I\�tU�ZK��K

Page 207: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

JEZKJ�@>�G�?D0�V?E���G�O�PGBI���@��K�T�BG��K?0�JU�E?>�GU��KJ@I�E?

@�EK���KG��B@BJE@?B)�m�>?BVK@>B�RAS�GBI�APHK?�E@?���?D@I���K�O�P�

GBB0�B��@K)�R�^�BHBVK@>B�

M���� �/%�"�-8�qPJ�^0� ?P?� �EGJEZ�U�H��� @NK���BI)�]HB�0� K@CBTECB?BVK@>�I�EA@?��E�>����P?�B�RAS�GBB��K�BGJK�B?@I�>�CPVkKJP

BCB���@?PTB?�>�>E��?E�@T�H)�|E�K@?D�AECDkBK���HKZHU0�V?E�TECB?B�

VK@>�I�EA@?��E�>����P?�B�RAS�GBB�BGJK�B?@I�B�RAS�GBI�Q��KT�BG�

����EK���JB�E�EJ�J�@k?�AK�ME@PH��@?�E�Q��@K�����E�APHK?�@�JEHE@�

?�?EV�E��TECB?BVK@>E��KHB�BNK�)�|�kK�EALK@?�E���AE?�CE�@�>E�N�

�E��U0�B���AE?�K?�@K�V�@)�=K�KHE��I0�JU@CIL�I�V�@?D���kKME�EALK�

@?��0��K�EZBH�I�JBCE@?B�E?�T�B�EHU0���H���EJ�@CPV�K�E?�O�PGBB0

T�EHECZ�K?�@?�EB?D�@�EK�EALK@?�E0�V?EAU�E�E�@?�CE�@�JEHE@?�?EV�

�UJ�B�ZBG�K@TE@EA�UJ)�YECD>E�?�>E��TP?D�E@?�K?@I)�[E��@I>EJ�@CP�

V�K0���EAEG�BJEJ�APHPLKJ��B>�>EME�H�PMEME�TP?B��K?)

��������%�"�8�qCI�JK�I�W?E�?EZK�EVK�D���Z�U���ET�E@0�B�JU�>�Z�HU��HK�D�KME�@KAK�G�H�KJ0�B�>�ZHU��HK�D�TE�@�EKJP�E?�KV�KJ)�y�HP�

J�^0�V?E��ET�E@�T�BG���BI�Q��?E�E@?KTK��U��BCB�VK?U�KS@?KTK��

�U�0�TE?EJP�V?E�MC���EK�Q�W?E�?E0�V?E�I�ELPL�^�@KAI�ZB�PLK���

�KG��B@BJE��RAS�GBB0�B0���T�B�NBTK0�@E�K�kK��E��K��Z�E0�APHK?�CB

P�RAS�GBB�@�EK�TE@ECD@?�E���rE�HE�K)�qPJ�^0�V?E��E?�W?E�T�BG���BK

JEZK?�CKVD��KTE@BCD�UJ�A�KJK�KJ������kB�TCKVB�B�H�ZK�P@CEZ�

�B?D���kK�@PLK@?�E���BK)�OC���EK0�V?EAU�JU�@�JB�@KAI�T�BG����CB

B��KCB�>�>��KG��B@BJEK�ME@PH��@?�E0����K�EMCIHU��CB@D����@K�K��BCB

���G�T�H0��K�HPJ�CB0�>�>�TE@?PTB?D0�V?EAU��K�EABHK?D�BCB��K���GH���

Z�?D� >EME�?E)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E0� @EA@?�K��E� ME�E�I0�T�BG���BK��K

BM��K?�?�>E��PZ���Z�E���ECB�HCI�RAS�GBB)

�����M�.� �-8�[ET�E@�TE@?��CK��TE�@PLK@?�P)�|��@�JEJ�?E�HKCK

B@?E�BVK@>B���UGE��K@?D�B�P�O�PGBB0�B�P�RAS�GBB)�O�PGB�@>EK�EALK�

@?�E�HECZ�E�B@>�?D�@�E��E?�K?����W?E?��UGE�0����AS�G@>EK�EALK@?�E�Q

@�E�)�F�>�JU�E?�K?BJ����W?B��UGE�U0�?�>BJB�B�APHP?���kB�TK�@TK>�

?B�U)

F�>BJ�I�T�KH@?��CI^�@KAK�E?�K?����W?E?��UGE�)�[�IH�CB�K@?D�E@�

�E���BK�HPJ�?D0�V?E���ACBZ��kKK���KJI�O�PGBI�T�BG��K?���kP��KG��

Page 208: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

�B@BJE@?D0���IH�CB���J�@CKHPK?�HPJ�?D0�V?E�zE@@BI�T�BG��K?)�|E0

�K@JE?�I����W?E0�>�>�ME�E�BC��|�?KCC��|P�BK���0�JU��K�JEZKJ�TK�K�

@?�?D�@PLK@?�E��?D0��KHD����EH�T�KH@?��CIK?�@EAE��ET�KHKCK��U�

@ENB�CD�U��E�M��BGJ0�@B@?KJP0�EAL�E@?D)�tU�HECZ�U���W?BS�P@CE�

�BIS���SEHB?D�lE�JU�B�@TE@EAU0�JKS��BGJU��UZB���BI)�YE�K@?D�TE>�

W?��EAL�E@?D�@PLK@?�PK?0�E���HECZ���@?�KJB?D@I�>�?EJP0�V?EAU�TEH�

HK�ZB��?D�@�EK�@PLK@?�E���BK0��E@T�EBG�EHB?D�@KAI�B�EAK@TKVB��?D

@�E^�AKGET�@�E@?D)�q�PMEME�TP?B0�H�PMEME�@JU@C��BCB�H�PME��NKCB�P

W?E��EAL�E@?B�I��K��BZP)�XKMEH�I�CKM>E�>�B?B>E��?D�?E0�V?E�T�E�

BGEkCE0� T�KGBHK�?�0� T��C�JK�?)�|E� V�KG�UV���E� ��Z�E0� ���JE�

�GMCIH0�T���BCD�E�@lE�JPCB�E��?D�?P�G�H�VP0�>E?E�P^���J�T�KH@?E�

B?��Kk�?D)�����W?BS�P@CE�BIS0�P@CE�BIS�BGECINBB0�ACE>�HU0�O�PGBI

APHK?���J�T�E?B�E@?EI?D0�APHK?�JKk�?D0���JU�APHKJ�JKk�?D�O�PGBB0�I

@�q�P�EJ�GHK@D�@EMC�@K��Q�JU�H�PM�H�PMP�@KMEH�I�B@?E�BVK@>B�@K�D�

KG�E�JKk�KJ)�[�W?BS�P@CE�BIS���J��PZ�E��H�T?B�E��?D@I�>�TECB?B�

VK@>BJ��K�CBIJ�B���SEHB?D�@TE@EAU�B�lE�JU��UZB���BI)�y�@EMC��

@K��@�q�P�EJ�B�RAK@�CEJEJ0�V?E���kB��U�Kk�BK��C�@?B�B���O�PGBB0

B���RAS�GBB�E>�G�CB@D��K@TE@EA�UJB�T�KHCEZB?D�EALK@?�P�@EE?�

�K?@?�P^LBK�@E��KJK��UJ�P@CE�BIJ�JKS��BGJU��KkK�BI��K�CD�US

G�H�V)�R��KHD�ME@PH��@?�K��UK�@?�P>?P�U0�E�M��U�PT���CK�BI�HCI�?EME

B�@EGH�^?@I0�V?EAU�TEJEVD��Kk�?D�EALK@?�P�W?B�G�H�VB)�[E?�?�>�I

@KAK�T�KH@?��CI^)

!R������RU,���R��8�y�P�K�K�0�V?E�EZBH�?D�T�BG���BI�Q�W?E��K�K��CD�E0�W?E�BCC^GBI)�=E?EJP�V?E0�K@CB�HETP@?BJ0�I�T�BG��^0�BCB�pJ�

G��0�BCB�YK�MBG0�W?E��BVKME��K�G��VB?�Q�HECZ�U�T�BG��?D��C�@?B)�R

�C�@?D��K�T�BG��K?�WCKJK�?���E�BG�G��?EME0�V?E�?�>EK��KkK�BK��KTE�

TPCI��E)�F�>BJ�AU�MPJ���UJ��K�AUCE��P>E�EH@?�E0�>�>�AU�E�E��B

HPJ�CE�E�APHPLKJ�O�PGBB0���C^AE��JEJK�?�B@?E�BB�W?E��KTETPCI��

�EK��KkK�BK�T�B�KHK?�>�TE?K�K��C�@?B)�=EW?EJP�W?E��K�K�CD�E0�APHD

?E��C�@?D�sK���H��HGK�BCB�>�>E���BAPHD�APHPLB��T�KGBHK�?0��@K

����E)

��������%�"�8�qPJ�^0�V?E��C�@?IJ�RAS�GBB�?EZK�@E�K�kK��E��K�

�UMEH�E0�V?EAU�O�PGBI���@�T�BG��C�)�p?E�EVK�D�PHEA�E��K@?D�T�BVB�

����@KS���kBS�AKH)�p?E��K�CD�E@?D0�B�JU�EA�W?EJ�ME�E�BJ)�p?E��U�

Page 209: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

MEH�E�B���kBJ0�B���kBJ��C�@?IJ0�B�?�>�APHK?�T�EHECZ�?D@I�KLK�EVK�D

HECME)�|E��BVKME0�JU�?EZK�T�B@TE@EABCB@D�?�>�ZB?D0�B�APHKJ�?�>

ZB?D)

��R��� ����0�8�|EH���@T�E@BC0�V?E�APHK?�HKC�?D�RAS�GBI0�K@CB�O�P�GBI�?�>�B��K�T�BG��K?�KK��KG��B@BJE@?B)�qPJ�^0�V?E�RAS�GBI0�@VB?�I

W?E��K@T���KHCB�E@?D^0��K�HECZ���T�EHECZ�?D�W?P��K@T���KHCB�E@?D)

u@CB�O�PGBI�?�>�E?�E@B?@I�>���J0�?E�JU��K�HECZ�U�?�>�ZK�E?�E@B?D�

@I�>�O�CD@>EJP����E�P�BCB��EEALK�>�M�PGB�@>EJP���@KCK�B^�BCB�>

��kBJ�JK�DkB�@?��J)�=EW?EJP�I�HPJ�^0�V?E���kBJ�E?�K?EJ�HECZ�

�E�AU?D�TE@?�EK�BK�AECKK�@T���KHCB�EME�EALK@?��0���>E?E�UJ���C��

ZK�U�@CEZ�UK�JKZ��NBE��CD�UK�E?�EkK�BI)�tEZK?�AU?D0�W?E�EVK�D

BHK�CB@?BVK@>B�G�PVB?0��E�I�ME�E�^�E�ZKC�KJE��TEGBNBB�Q�P@?��E��

>K��AS�G@>EME�EALK@?������?E0�V?EAU���GEJ>�P?D�W?E?�>�PM)�OHK�?E

�PZ�E��K��E@T�EBG�EHB?D0��K�E?�KV�?D��K@T���KHCB�E@?D^�����K@T���

�KHCB�E@?D)�y�@VB?�^0�V?E���k��UGE��Q�W?E�@EAC^HK�BK�T����JK�D�

kB�@?��B�H�PMBS���NBE��CD�E@?K�)�|K@JE?�I������kP�HKJEM��lB�

VK@>P^�B�IGU>E�P^�T�EACKJP0��@K�?�>B��KEASEHBJE����?B��EGJEZ�E�

@?B�HE@?E��EME�@E@PLK@?�E���BI�@�H�PMBJB����EH�JB�B�P��Z�?D�BS

T����0����K�G�>��VB��?D�TP?D�@T���KHCB�E@?B�BJK��E�����AS�G@>EJ

���EHK�B�H�CDkK��K��BHK?D�@SEZBS�T�EACKJ�B�T����H�PMBS)�u@CB�JU

SE?BJ�@?�EB?D�ME@PH��@?�E0����K�>PCD?P��P^���?E�EJB^0�?E�JU�HECZ�

�U��KkB?D�W?P�T�EACKJP)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0���k��UGE��BJK��E���?EJ0�V?E�

AU�@��K��@T���B?D@I)

�"�$��!.���0$�-8�]VK�D�M�P@?�E�AUCE�@CPk�?D�J�EMEK�BG�?EME0�V?E

@K�V�@�ME�E�BCE@D)�y0�>E�KV�E0��K�SEVP��B>EME�EABZ�?D0��E�GHK@D�BJKK?

JK@?E�EVK�D�B�l��?BCD�U����@?�E�)�t�K�>�ZK?@I0��@K�W?B���GME�E�

�U0�V?E�zE@@BI�G����@��KkB?�T�EACKJP�8I�PZK��K�ME�E�^�E�?�>EJ�>P�D�

KGK0�V?E�APH?E�AU�?E�ME�NU����M���BNK�P@?�EI?��E�J�CD�UK�M�PGB�E�

�AS�G@>BK�E?�EkK�BI:0�B�?)H)�Q�W?E�PZ�@�U��B�l��?BCBGJ)�tU0�JE�

ZK?�AU?D0�HK�@?�B?KCD�E��K�ME?E�U�>�?EJP0�V?E���GU��K?@I�@?�EB�

?KCD@?�EJ�@K�DKG�US�E?�EkK�B�)�tU��K� @JEMCB�TK�Kk�M�P?D� W?P

M���D)�X�JE�@EAE���BVKME��K�TE@?�EB?@I)�[E��@I>EJ��KkK�BB0�AKGP@�

CE��E0�K@?D�ET�KHKCK��U���B@>)�u@?D�?�>EK��U��ZK�BK���@K�ET�@�E)

|E�>EMH��ME�E�I?0�V?E��@K�ET�@�E0�W?E��K�G��VB?0�V?E��@K�TCESE)�p?E

Page 210: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

G��VB?��K@CB�SEVKkD�V?E�?E��Kk�?D0��PZ�E�@E��@K��E?�K?@?�K��E@?D^

BH?B����ET�KHKCK��U���B@>)

��KLK�EHB��JEJK�?)�F�>�J�K�TE>�G�CE@D0�JU�E>�G�CB@D��KME?E�U

>�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHKCB)�|K���?EJ�@JU@CK0�V?E�T�KHCEZK�BI�AUCB

T�B�I?U�BCB��K�T�B�I?U0���@�J���k�TEHSEH�>�T�EJKZP?EV�E��JEHK�

CB�Q�?EZK�E?��ZK�BK�B�l��?BCBGJ���}BCB�JU�@��GP��@K�TECPVBJ0�BCB

�BVKME��K�TECPVBJ~)�|B>EMH���BVKME�BG�?�>E��TECB?B>B��K��U�HK?)

y0�K@CB�ME�E�B?D�E?>�E�K��E0��EEALK�@VB?�^�W?E��KJPZ@>BJ�TEHSE�

HEJ)�tEI�CBV��I�TECB?B>��GHK@D�@E@?EB?���?EJ0�V?E�SE?I�E?�JK�I�>�>

E?�>E�>�K?�EME�CBN��J�CE�V?E�G��B@B?0��E�JEI�E?�K?@?�K��E@?D�TK�KH

@�JBJ�@EAE��HB>?PK?�J�K�?�>E��@?BCD�TE�KHK�BI0�B�I��K�ZHP0�>EMH��G�

JK�I�V?E�?E��KkB?�zE@@BI�BCB�?E�ME�KN����M���BNK)�=�B�?�>EJ�TEH�

SEHK�JU��B�>�VKJP��K�T�BHKJ)

��������%����S,���8�y�>�>���G�SEVP�@>�G�?D0�V?E��B>�>E��M�P@?B�K�HECZ�E�AU?D)�RAS�GBI��B>EMH���K�@JEZK?�TEJKk�?D�O�PGBB���G�B�

��?D@I0� W?E� �A@P�H0�HCI�JK�I� W?E� �A@EC^?�E��KT�BKJCKJE)�O�PGBB

JKk�K?��K�RAS�GBI0����K@TE@EA�E@?D��KkK�BI��AS�G@>EME��ET�E@�)

[E?���VKJ�T�EACKJ�)�XK�V�@�O�PGBB0���T�BJK�0�JKk�K?�>E��PTNBI0��

�K�RAS�GBI)�XK�V�@�HCI�JK�I�ME��GHE�AECKK���Z�E��T�EACKJE����O�P�

GBB�I�CIK?@I�>E��PTNBI�B�?U@IVB�H�PMBS��ET�E@E�0�B�EHB��BG�@�JUS

TE@CKH�BS��ET�E@E�0�>�>�E���APHK?�E?�E@B?D@I�>�RAS�GBB)�F�@EZ�CK�

�B^0��P>E�EH@?�E�PZK��KkBCE��ET�E@�E?�EkK�B��@�RAS�GBK������MP@?K

.55,�M)0�EVK�D��KPH�V�E�B�EVK�D�MCPTE)�XK�V�@�KJP�PZK��K�HE�RAS�GBB)

[�RAS�GBB��B>�>E��JB@?B>B��K?)����K�H���xEM0�V?EAU�O�PGBI��K�@HKC��

C���B�EH�EME�k�M�0�?EMH��E����K�@E@?EB?@I�>�>�ME@PH��@?�E�B��K�@JEZK?

�Kk�?D��EEALK��B>�>BK��ET�E@U0���?EJ�VB@CK�B��AS�G@>BK)����AS�GU

@�JB�APHP?��Kk�?D�@�E^�@PHDAP0�B�@K�V�@�HECZ�U��Kk�?D0�B��B���>EKJ

@CPV�K��K�HECZ�U�ZH�?D0�TE>��O�PGBI�A�E@B?�BJ�W?E�T�BG���BK)

M���� �/%�"�-8�tU�B��K�ZHKJ)

��������%����S,���8�|K?0���kK��U@?PTCK�BK�AUCE�T�E�BG��E�BJK��

�E�W?BJ�HPSEJ0�JB@?B>E�0�T�EkCUJ0�>E?E�EK�AUCE�?U@IVB�CK?����

G�H��p?EME��K�HECZ�E�AU?D)�u@CB��U�ME?E�U�>�>�ME@PH��@?�E0��U��K

HECZ�U��B>EME�ZH�?D0��U0�>�>�>E��ACD0�HECZ�U�TCU?D���C^AP^�TEME�

Page 211: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

HP)�YE�ZK�@�JEK�B�JU)�u@CB�P���@�APHP?�EALBK�>�>BK�?E�?EV>B�@ET�B�

>E@�E�K�BI0�?E�JU�EAIG�?KCD�E�@ET�B>E@�KJ@I0�I�P�K�K�)�[�JB�K�BHP?

B�?KM��NBE��UK�T�ENK@@U0�B�>�>�AU�JU��K���G�B��CB@D0�JU�EAIG��

?KCD�E�APHKJ��JK@?K����EH�EJ�ME@PH��@?�K0�����G�US�CB0��E���kB�HE�

�EMB�APHP?�EALBK0�TEV?B�EHB��>E��I���C^?�0�B��VK�JU��K��UZB�KJ��

W?EJ�JB�K0�B��VK��K�TECPVB?@I��BVKME)

y�SEVP�E?�K?B?D�zEJ��P0�>E?E�EME�EVK�D�C^AC^�B�P��Z�^0�V?E�O�PGBI

�K@TE@EA�������E��P)�O�PGBI�AUC��@TE@EA�������E��P�?ECD>E�TE?EJP0

V?E�P��KK�AUCB�>�>BK�?E�E@?�?EV�UK��K@P�@U�XE�K?@>EME�XE^G�)�]��

@K�V�@�@BHB?��A@EC^?�E�����PCK)�rBAE�O�PGBI�@?��K?�HKJE>��?BVK@�

>BJ�ME@PH��@?�EJ0�CBAE��EEALK��BVKJ��K�@?��K?0�TEW?EJP��B�?�EBS

>E@?K�0��B�JEBS�>E@?K���BMHK�B@>�?D��K�TE��HEAB?@I)�Y�>�V?E���W?EJ

TC��K�JEMP�?KAI�P@TE>EB?D)���� � ����> �(��

M���� �/%�"�-8�X��GP��BH�E0�V?E�?U�BJKKkD�HKCE�@�M�PAE���K�CD�E�

@?D^)

��������%����S,���8�qCI�JK�I�EVK�D���Z�E�TE>�G�?D��AS�G�J0�V?EO�PGBI�EVK�D�JKHCK��E0��E�V?E�?E�HKC�K?�B�>�>BK�?E�T�ENK@@U�?�J

BHP?)�tU�@?���KJ@I��K�T�BMC�k�?D�@ H��C^HK�0�>E?E�UK0�P�BHK���A�

S�GE�0�APHP?�ME�E�B?D��}>�>�SE�EkE~�B�SCET�?D���C�HEkB)�t�K��@KMH�

SEVK?@I�T�BMC�k�?D�@^H��C^HK�0�>E?E�UK�BJK^?�>�>EK�?E��CBI�BK

���EALK@?�E)�[E?�W?B�C^HB�?EV�E�BJK^?�>�>E��?E��USEH����EALK�

@?�E)���EMH��P�JK�I�@>C�HU��K?@I��TKV�?CK�BK0�V?E��K>E?E�UJ�BG���@

�K�UMEH�E��BHK?D��E�P^�O�PGB^)�YE�K@?D�@TE>E��KK��BHK?D�@?��P^

O�PGB^0��M�K@@B��P^0��K@TE@EA�P^)�tU�SE?BJ0�V?EAU��U��BHKCB0

��@>ECD>E���kB�ZKC��BI�B@>�K��B0�SE?BJ�TE>�G�?D���J0�>�>�P���@

BHP?�BGJK�K�BI)

�������!"�#�-8�p?E��K�G��B@B?�E?���kKME�ZKC��BI0�JU�ZK�HECZ�U

W?E��BHK?D�

��������%�"�8�|�HK�D��EGE�UK�EV>B�

��������%����S,���8�|K?��K?0��EGE�UK�EV>B�>�>���G��K��PZ�U0���HE@�I?D�VK��UK�EV>B0�AECDkK��BVKME)�|�T�BJK�0��B�EHB��@K�DKG�U�

Page 212: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

G�>E����O�PGBB��K�T�ESEHB?���T��C�JK�?K0�K@CB��K�T�ESEHB?�VK�KG

�P>B�YB�B>E�B�rK����0�>E?E�UK�GHK@D���SEHI?@I)�]�B�EA�W?EJ��K�>�B�

V�?0��E�W?E��K�G��VB?0�V?E�W?E��K�?�>)�|�@���@�JEJ�HKCK�J�CE0��E�JU��

?KCD�Ik>�S0�B�JU�EVK�D�J�EMBK��ET�E@U�G�>�U��KJ���O�PGBB0�TK�K�

>�U��KJ0�JEZ�E�@>�G�?D)�|K�JU�T�B�BJ�KJ��KkK�BI0��E�JU�>E�?�E�

CB�PKJ��ET�E@U0����>E?E�UK�JEZKJ��CBI?D)���JU�T�BKGZ�KJ�@^H�0

V?EAU�H�?D���J��EGJEZ�E@?D�W?E�P�BHK?D)�q�PMEK�HKCE0�G�SE?B?K�CB��U

W?E�P�BHK?D)�tU�SE?BJ0�V?EAU��U�P�BHKCB0�V?E���O�PGBB�>�>BK�?E�T�E�

NK@@U0���C^AEJ�@CPV�K0�T�EB@SEHI?)���W?B�T�ENK@@U���@?PT�?KCD�UK)

]�B�JKHCK��UK0�>�@EZ�CK�B^0��E���@?PT�?KCD�UK)�u@CB��U�W?EME��K

SE?B?K�@CUk�?D0�?E�?EMH��J�EMBK�BG���@�T�E@?E�G�I�?��?I?���KJI)�u@CB

JU��K�APHKJ��K�B?D�H�PM�H�PMP0�K@CB�APHP?�>�>BK�?E�G�H�BK�JU@CB���H�PM

W?E��K�?�>0��H�PM�E�B���J���P?�Q�HB�CEM��B>EMH���K�@E@?EB?@I)�n�JK�I

�A@EC^?�E��K?��B>�>EME�ZKC��BI�TP@>�?D���J�TUCD���MC�G��B�T�BMC��

k�?D�?KS�C^HK�0�>E?E�UK�I>EAU�V?E�?E�HKC�^?0��E����@�JEJ�HKCK��B���

V?E��K�@TE@EA�U�B�T�BKS�CB�T�E@?E�XEVB�TE@JE?�K?D)

n���@�>�>�I�@B?P�NBI�@K�V�@���O�PGBB\�[�O�PGBB��K�>NBE�K�U�Q

CBAE��B����V?E��K�@TE@EA�UK�CK�?IB0�CBAE�AKGB�?KCCK>?P�CD�UK����

HB>�CU0�W>@?�KJB@?U)���?KCCK>?�@K�V�@��A@EC^?�E��K����@?E�E�K

�K�>NBE�K�E�)�p?E�I�JEMP�@JKCE�@>�G�?D)�u@CB�>?E�?E�V?E�?E�HKC�K?��

O�PGBB0�JEGM�JB�kK�KCB?0�?E�EAUV�E�W?E�C HB0�>E?E�UK�SE?I?�P?�K��

HB?D�HKJE>��?BVK@>BK0�M��ZH��@>BK�NK��E@?B)�p?��M�PTT��EVK�D�J�C�0

I�B�EMH��kPVP0�V?E�G��^�BS��@KS���CBNE0��E����@�JEJ�HKCK�BS�AECDkK)

y�SEVP0�V?EAU�JU�����kKJ�H�BZK�BB�HE�K�ICB�H�PM�H�PMP)�u@CB

HE�K�BI��K?0���J�APHK?�EVK�D�?IZKCE�T�EH�BM�?D@I��TK�KH)�p?E�ELP�

LK�BK��EG�B>CE�TE@CK��U@?PTCK�BI�x�?�C�0�>EMH��JU�ME�E�BCB�EA

PVKA�B>�S�B@?E�BB)�XCEZBCE@D��TKV�?CK�BK0�>�>�APH?E�JU��BVKME��K

G��KJ)�F?E�?E�H�PME��G��K?0���JU��K�G��KJ0�V?E�T�EB@SEHB?)

��������%�"�8�|E�E���K���@��KHD�BJKC����BHP)

��������%����S,���8�|E�P�JK�I�@CEZBCE@D�?�>EK�ELPLK�BK)

!.� �M"��8�X�JE��@?��k�E��T�EACKJE��I�CIK?@I0�TE�I?�EK�HKCE0

�K�RAS�GBI0���>E��PTNBI)

Page 213: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�0��%���������8��CB�>E�EVK���KZBJ�sK���H��HGK)�=�E@?E�sK���H�

��HGK0�K@CB�@E�@KJ�>E�E?>E)

!.� �M"��8�|K?0�I�HPJ�^0�V?E�@JK���EH�EME�CBHK���H�PMBJ��BVKME�K�H�@?)�FE��PTNBI��EEALK�T�B@PL���E@?EV�EJP�EA��GP�ZBG�B0�B

TK�Kk�M�P?D�VK�KG�W?E�EVK�D�@CEZ�E)���#� � ������ �X>ECD>E�APHK?

HCB?D@I�W?��AB?��0�>EMH��JEZ�E�APHK?�@>�G�?D0�V?E�>E��PTNBI��K�T�KH�

@?��CIK?�PM�EGP�EALK@?�P\

�������!"�#�-8�=��?�0��K�SEVKkD�CB�?U�@>�G�?D0�V?E�TE>���U�@�>E��

�PTNBK���K�TE>E�VB?K0��U��K�@JEZK?K��K�CD�E����?B�EALB��IGU>�@

�AS�G�JB\

��������%����S,���8�xKGP@CE��E)�RAS�G@>B���ET�E@�JEZK?��KkB?D

?ECD>E���G�B?EK0�@BCD�EK�ME@PH��@?�E)�u@CB�JU�@K�V�@�T�BG��KJ�RA�

S�GB^0�W?E��K�G��VB?0�V?E��@K�APHK?���TE�IH>K)�=�BG���BK�RAS�GBB

8H���xEM0�V?EAU�E�E�T�EBGEkCE:�T�EBGE�HK?�?ECD>E�T�B�@BCD�EJ�ME�

@PH��@?�K)�|E�W?E�APHK?�EVK�D�HECMB��T�ENK@@)�tEZK?�AU?D0�W?E�APHK?

TE@CKH�B���>>E�H)�X�T�BG���BI�RAS�GBB���V�K?@I���@?EIL�I�ME@P�

H��@?�K��E@?D�O�PGBB)�|E�W?E�APHK?�EVK�D�TEGH�E0�TEW?EJP���J��K

��HE�ZH�?D)

�� ��� ���R�S���8�=��?��@>�G�C�TEV?B�H�K�?�K?B�BG�?EME0�V?E�SE?K�C��@>�G�?D�I)�y�SE?KC��E?�K?B?D����?E0�E�VKJ�ME�E�BC�q�P�0�E�T�EM�K@@K

O�PGBB0� E� G��B@BJE@?B�T�EM�K@@��E?��KkK�BI��AS�G@>EME� �ET�E@�)

rK���0�=��?��B�I�PZK�?U@IVP���G�ME�E�BCB�EA�W?EJ0�B��K�G��^0�TEVKJP

W?E�?�>�?�PH�E�TE�I?D)�=EVKJP��U���J��K��K�B?K0�>EMH��JU���J��A@E�

C^?�E�B@>�K��K�ME�E�BJ0�V?E�@KMEH�I�RAS�GBI�Q��K�T�EACKJ����O�P�

GBB\�y�SE?KC��@>�G�?D�B�E�>E��PTNBB0��E�=��?��PZK�ME�E�BC)�|K�APHP

TE�?E�I?D)�uHB�@?�K��EK0�V?E�JEZK?���G�PkB?D�M�PGB�@>P^�ME@PH���

@?�K��E@?D�Q�W?E�>E��PTNBI0�AECDkK��BVKME)�XE@?EB?@I�CB���k��ME�

@PH��@?�K��E@?D0�G��B@B?�E?�?KS�VB�E��B>E�0�>E?E�UK�@K�V�@�@BHI?

���@�EBS�JK@?�S�B�HPJ�^?�?ECD>E�E�?EJ0�@>ECD>E���>ETB?D�@KAK�B�@�E�

BJ�@KJDIJ0�B�AECDkK��B�E�VKJ)

�y�EVK�D�H�CK>��E?�JU@CB0�V?E���@�J�EME0�V?E���@�?U@IVB�B�JU

JEZKJ�P@?��B��?D�?U@IV�UK�HKJE�@?��NBB0��U�K@?B����EH����PCBNU

Page 214: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

B�?)H)�[E�TK��US0�O�PGBI�J�CK�D>�I�@?����)�[E��?E�US0�YABCB@B�KLK

JK�DkK)�|�@��KJ�EME0��E���@�HE@?�?EV�E0�JEMP���@�P�K�B?D)�XKMEH�I

��O�PGBB�EVK�D�J�EME�C^HK�0�>E?E�UK0�>�>�ME�E�BC�=��?�0�JEZK?�AU?D0

�KTE@�KH@?�K��E�B��K��Kk�^?��ET�E@U0��E�E>�GU��^?�EVK�D�@BCD�

�EK��CBI�BK��A@EC^?�E�����@K0�V?E�@CPV�K?@I���O�PGBB)�{HK@D�V�@?E

ME�E�B?@I�E�?EJ0�V?E�JU�T�KH@?��CIKJ�CBkD�>�>P^�?E�V�@?D�EALK�

@?���B�>�E@?�CD�UJ��K�BJKKJ�E?�EkK�BI)�y�SEVP���@�P�K�B?D0�V?E�W?E

�K�?�>)���I�@K�V�@�PZK�ME�E�^�E?�BJK�B�JEK��E�M��BG�NBB�Q��K�T�E�

@?E�>�>�M��ZH��>��O�PGBB0���>�>�T�KH@KH�?KCD�EH�E��BG�@�JUS�>�PT�

�US�E�M��BG�NB�0���VB@CK��EJ�@JU@CK)�n�JK�I�>�ZHU��HK�D�T�EB@�

SEHI?�>E�?�>?U�AECKK�VKJ�@E�.,-�.3-�C^HDJB)�p?E�@?�?B@?B>�0���>E�

?E�E���U�JEZK?K�PAKHB?D@I���>�ZHEJ���kKJ�BGH��BB)�{��MEH�W?E�EVK�D

AECDkBK�NBl�U)�p?B�>E�?�>?U��A@EC^?�E���G�UK0�B�I�SEVP�@>�G�?D0

V?E�JU�TU?�KJ@I�@?�EB?D�@�EK�ME@PH��@?�E��K�?ECD>E�VK�KG�?E0�V?E

APHK?���RAS�GBB0���VK�KG�?E0�V?E�APHK?���?E��@?���K0�MHK�JU�ZB�KJ)�y��

@�JEJ�HKCK�@EAB��^@D����K��ZB?D�B��B>PH���K�@EAB��^@D�PKGZ�?D)

|E�@EAB��^@D�AE�E?D@I�G��?E0�V?EAU�JEB�HK?B�ZBCB���?�>E��O�PGBB0��

>E?E�E��I�SEVP0�V?EAU�E�B�ZBCB)���W?E�HCI�JK�I�@�JEK�MC���EK)�=E�

�?E�I^��AKG�RAS�GBB�BCB�@�RAS�GBK��Q�W?E�HCI�JK�I�@�J�I�J�C�I�T�E�

ACKJ�)�qCI�JK�I�AECDk�I�T�EACKJ�0�V?EAU�I�ZBC����ME@PH��@?�K0�V?E�

AU�M�PGB�@>�I�ME@PH��@?�K��E@?D�@E@?EIC�@D)���I��K�^0�V?E�?EMH�

>E�lCB>?�APHK?��KkK�)�y��K�G��^0�>�>�E��APHK?��KkK��Q�APHKJ�CB�JU

ZB?D�����G�US�@?����S�BCB��K?0��E��AS�GU0����K��EK0�PZK�@�JB��Kk�?0

>�>�BJ�AU?D�B�@�>KJ�BJ�CPVkK�AU?D)�X��E@@B�@>E��E�BK�?�NBK�0�@

M�PGB�@>E�0�BCB�@�>�>E��?E�KLK)

��TE@CKH�KK0�V?E�I�SE?KC��AU�@>�G�?D�TE�TE�EHP�W?BS�E?�EkK�B�)

X�JEK�MC���EK0�V?E�HKC�K?���k��E�M��BG�NBI�G��TE@CKH�BK�TEC?E��

MEH��Q�W?E�EVK�D�?K@�UK�>E�?�>?U�@���@BCD@?�K��E�TK�KJKLK��UJB

CBN�JB)�p?E�PZK��K�?��@B?P�NBI0�>EMH��I�T�E@?E�TE?��?BC��NKCUS�4

CK?����AS�G@>E��>EJB@@BB0�>EMH���EG�B>�K?�ELPLK�BK0�V?E�E�B��K�G���

^?0�E�VKJ�BHK?��KVD)�]�B0�B�T���H�0��K�G��^?�B��B>�>��K�TE�JP?0�V?E

W?E�PZK��K�EH�E�ME@PH��@?�E)���PZK��K�EGJEZ�E�ME�E�B?D�E�?EJ0�V?E

K@CB�@KMEH�I���TBkKkD���M�PGB�@>B��T��C�JK�?�>�>E��?E�G�>E��E

@?�?P@K�RAS�GBB0�?E�T��C�JK�?�G��?���KME�T�BJK?)�Y�>�AUCE��VK��0��E

@KMEH�I�B0�I�P�K�K��0�G��?���JEMP?�TEG�E�B?D�B�@T�E@B?D��MHK�?�E�

T�EK>?\�YE�K@?D0���TE@CKH�BK�TEC?E���MEH��JU�TU?�KJ@I�ME�E�B?D�@

Page 215: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

C^HDJB0�@�>E?E�UJB��B>?E���O�PGBB��K�ME�E�B?0�@�M��ZH���JB0�@�>E�

?E�UJB��B>?E��K�ME�E�B?�>�>�@�C HDJB)�]�B�T�E@?E�B�@?�PJK�?0�>E�

?E�UJ��@K���KJI�J��BTPCB�PK?�B���kB�CBHK�U0�B���kB�CBHK�U)�|��

T�BJK�0�JK@IN���G�H���FE�@?B?PNBE��EJ�@PHK�P���@�AUCE�HKCE�E?�BS

BJK�B�Q�EA�BS�T���K����PV�@?BK����UAE��S)�F�@EZ�CK�B^0�JU��K�@JEMCB

�UBM��?D�W?E�HKCE0�B�FE�@?B?PNBE��U��@PH�E?>�G�C��tU�JEMCB�TE�?B

E?@?�B��?D�BS�T������@KME�@�TI?D^�TEHTB@IJB0�H�ZK�@�EH�E�)�=�E@?E

JU�SE?KCB0�V?EAU�>�>�JEZ�E�AECDkK�W?BS�C HK��TE�ICB���Z�E@?D

?EME0�V?EAU�E�B�AUCB�B�?KM�B�E���U���?KS�JK@?�S0�MHK�E�B�ZB�P?)��

TEVKJP�JU�TEkCB���HK>�A�K�,---�MEH�0����K���HK>�A�K�55�ME\�=E?EJP

V?E���HK>�A�K�,---�MEH��P���@�AUCE�PZK�4�?U@IV�VKCE�K>0�>E?E�UK

@>�G�CB0�V?E�SE?I?�MECE@E��?D�?�J0�MHK�ZB�P?)�tU�ETI?D��K�@JEMCB

�UBM��?D�W?E�HKCE0��E�I�P�K�K��0�V?E�G��?���EAIG�?KCD�E�@JEZKJ�Q

JEZK?�AU?D0�H�PMBJB�@TE@EA�JB0�JEZK?�AU?D0�VK�KG�BGJK�K�BI���G��

>E�K�E��UAE��S)

u@?D�B��?E�E��T�EM�K@@B��U��JEJK�?0�>E?E�EME�JU�@JEMCB�HE�

AB?D@I)�p?E�HKCE�E@K?B�0�>E?E�UK�PKS�CB�BG�O�PGBB)�[�@PH�S�CKZ�?

HKC��E�@EA@?�K��E@?B�E@K?B�0�>E?E�P^�E�B�TE?K�ICB���x�>P�B��B0

xE�ZEJB�B�r�MEHKSB)�[�5;�J0�55�J�MEH�S�JU�T�EBM��CB���@PHK�39�HKC�)

=E��@KJ�39�J�HKC�J�@PH�G�I�BC0�V?E�M�PGB�U0�>E?E�UK�ZB�P?���E@?���

CK��US�HEJ�S0�HECZ�U�?�J�ZB?D��[�,---�MEHP�JU�PZK��UBM��CB�6-

HKC)�y�P�K�K��0�V?E�W?E?�T�ENK@@�PZK��K�E@?��E�B?D)�XK�V�@�K@?D�EVK�D

AECDkEK�HE�K�BK�>���kK��E�M��BG�NBB)�XK�V�@�E�B�>���J�EA��L��

^?@I�PZK�@E?�IJB)�]A��L�^?@I��K�?ECD>E�?K0�>?E��K��PC@I�B�ZB�K?

MHK�?E���O�PGBB)�tU�TECPV�KJ�TB@DJ�0�HE>PJK�?�NB^0�BG�[C�HB>���

>�G�0�BG�tE@>�U0�BG�H�PMBS�@?���0�MHK�E�B�ZB�P?)�YE�ZK�@�JEK�HKC�K?�

@I�@K�V�@�B�@�?P�>�JB�JK@SK?B�N�JB)�YE�K@?D�HCI�JK�I�K@?D�H�PMBK

T�EACKJU�B�H�PM�I�JK?EHB>�0�TE�>E?E�E��I�@EAB��^@D�TEJEVD�JEK�

@?���K�@?�?D�HKJE>��?BV�E�0�P��Z�^LK��T�����JK�DkB�@?�)�y�P�K�K�

��0�V?E�W?E?�T�ENK@@�E�@EA@?�K��E@?B�E@K?B����>�>E��?E�JK�K�APHK?

@TE@EA@?�E��?D��KkK�B^�M�PGB�E�E@K?B�@>EME�>E�lCB>?�)�=E?EJP�V?E

E@K?B�@>EK�ME@PH��@?�E�PZK��K�APHK?�J��BTPCB�E��?D�T�EACKJE��AK�

ZK�NK��E@K?B�0�K@CB�E@K?B�U�@?��P?�@E?�IJB��EG���L�?D@I���E@?�CD�

�P^�O�PGB^)�oE?I�AU�W?EME���MPJK�?��P��BS�PZK�AECDkK��K�APHK?)�y

TEJ�^0���57�J�MEHP���]@K?BB�J�K�@>�G�CB0�V?E�E@K?B�U��B>EMH���K

APHP?�ME�E�B?D�@���JB�HE�?KS0�TE��TE>��O�PGBI��K�T�EI�B?�ME?E��E@?D

Page 216: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

V?E�?E�HKC�?D�@�BS�T�EACKJ�JB)�XKMEH�I0�>EMH��I�?�J�AUC����lK���CK0�I

T�B�KGC��W?B�@PHKA�UK�HKC��B�TE>�G�C�0�V?E�W?E�T�EB@SEHB?)�n�JK�I

AUCB�HKC��B���@PH�S�vSB���CB0�MHK�HE�@KMEH�Ik�KME�H�I�E?>�GU��^?

M�PGB��J)�t�K�TE>���BVKME��K�EAKL�^?0��E0�TE�@����K�B^�@�57�J�ME�

HEJ0�TE�>����K��JK�K�ME?E�U�V?E�?E���@@JE?�K?D0�EA@PHB?D�B��KkB?D)

�?EAU�G�>E�VB?D�W?E��U@?PTCK�BK0�SEVP�@>�G�?D0�V?E�JU��@K0�>?E

PV�@?�PK?���TEHEA�US��@?�KV�S�Q�C HB0�>E?E�UK�SE?I?�B��K�CD�E�JE�

MP?��CBI?D����@�EK�EALK@?�E�VK�KG�J�CK�D>BK�HKC�)�p?E�TE?EJP0�V?E�I

?EV�E�G��^0�>�>E��I�SEVP��BHK?D�O�PGB^�VK�KG�.-�CK?)�|E0�>�AECDkEJP

JEKJP�@EZ�CK�B^0�I��K��BZP�?EME�ZK�����kBS��U@?PTCK�BIS�Q�I��K

�BZP0���>�>E��B�@?B?PNBE��CD�E��lE�JK��U��BHB?K�@�EK�ME@PH��@?�E)

R�I�G��^0�VKME�I�SEVP0�TE?EJP�V?E�JEI�T�EACKJ��Q��K�RAS�GBI)�YE0�V?E

ME�E�BC�q�P�0�T�B�EHB?�JK�I�>�JU@CB0�V?E�HCI�RAS�GBB�O�PGBI�Q�W?E

?KJ�0�?E�K@?D��U�SE?B?K0�T�BG���BI�O�PGBB�B�TE@CK�W?EME�@EAB��K?K@D

V?E�?E�HKC�?D0���HCI�JK�I�W?E��K�T�EACKJ�)�[�W?EJ��@I���G�BN��JKZHP

��JB)

�������!"�#�-8�R�JU��@KMH��ME�E�BJ�E�O�PGBB0��B>EMH���K�EA�RAS��GBB)�=E?EJP�V?E0�>EMH���U�ME�E�B?K�EA�RAS�GBB0�?E�BJKK?K�KK����BHP

>�>�V�@?D�O�PGBB)�=EW?EJP�JU�ME�E�BJ�?ECD>E�E�O�PGBB)

�� ��� ���R�S���8�x�?�C0�I�ME�E�^�?KAK0�V?E�I��K�BJK^����BHPRAS�GB^�>�>�V�@?D�O�PGBB�

�������!"�#�-8�y�@�PHE�ECD@?�BKJ�T�E@CPk�C�EA��HE>C�H�)�q�P�

HK�@?�B?KCD�E�T���BCD�E�@>�G�C0�V?E�EHB��Q�AECKK�>E�>�K?�U�0�H�P�

ME��Q�AECKK�MCEA�CD�U�)�p?E�SE�EkE0�V?E�K@?D�>�>BK�?E�@NK���BB0

>E?E�UK�JU�JEMCB�AU�EA@PZH�?D0�B�SE�EkE0�V?E���V�C�@D�?�>�I�HB@�

>P@@BI)�tU�Q�J�CK�D>EK�EALK@?�E0��E�G����JB�K@?D�KLK�AECDkEK�EA�

LK@?�E0���>E?E�EJ�?K�BCB�B�UK�@NK���BB�?EZK��UGE�P?�HB@>P@@BB0

TE?EJP�V?E�W?E�HCI��@KS�EVK�D���Z�E)�RAK@�CEJ���@�EKJ�HE>C�HK�EVK�D

TE�I?�E�B�>E�@?�P>?B��E�ME�E�BC0�V?E���HE0�V?EAU�����G��AE?>K�W?BS

JEHKCK��@E@PLK@?�E���BI�PV�@?�E��CB���GCBV�UK�@TK>?�U�EALK@?��)

��W?EME�P���@�@KMEH�I��K?)�|��K��EK0�M�PGB�@>BK�PV�@?�B>B��@?�KVB

JEMP?�AECDkK��CBI?D�����K�S�BK�WkKCE�U��C�@?B)�tU�?�>EME��CBI�

�BI��K�E>�GU��KJ0�SE?I��KCDGI�@>�G�?D0�V?E���k��?EV>��G�K�BI�E@?�K?�

Page 217: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

@I��KG�JKVK��E��Q���T�E?B�0�E���HK�@?�B?KCD�E��UGU��K?���GCBV�

�UK�WJENBB�B�HK�@?�BI)�Y�PH�E0�>E�KV�E0�G�lB>@B�E��?D0�MHK�BJK��E

B�>�>�JU�TE�CBICB0��E��@K�?�>B�ET�KHKCK��EK� �CBI�BK�K@?D)�t�K

T�KH@?��CIK?@I0�V?E�?�B��@?�KVB���lB�@>�I0�@?�JAPCD@>�I�B�IC?B�@�

>�I���IH�CB�JEMCB�@E@?EI?D@I0�K@CB�AU��K�AUCE��@?�KV�����KT���B�

?KCD@?�K��EJ�P�E��K)

y�HPJ�^0�V?E�W?E�Q�?E0�V?E�I�JEMP�@HKC�?D)�tE���EGJEZ�U���>C�H

��T�EH�BZK�BK�T�ENK@@��Q�W?E�@?���?D@I���G�B��?D�M��ZH��@>EK�EA�

LK@?�E0�V?E�JU�B�HKC�KJ)�[�T�B�NBTK0�W?E�H�ZK���P?�K��II�T�EACK�

J�)�[U�ME�E�B?K0�V?E�T�EACKJ��RAS�GBB��K�@?ECD���Z��)�|E�I��K�HP�

J�^0�V?E�W?E�?�>)�tEZK?�AU?D0�JU��K��C�HKKJ�?E��B�lE�J�NBK�0�>E�

?E�E���C�HKK?K��U0��E�I�HPJ�^0�V?E�B�W?��T�EACKJ��EVK�D���Z��)�y��K

HPJ�^0�V?E��ET�E@�RAS�GBB�Q�W?E�@E�@KJ�PZ�TE@CKH�II�T�EACKJ�0

TE@CK�>E��PTNBB0�TE@CK�G�>E�E�)��.(> �#���"� ����y�SEVP�@>�G�?D0

V?E�JU�HECZ�U�@?�EB?D�E?�EkK�BI0�B�?P?�HECZ�E�PVB?U��?D@I��@K)

q�ZK�K@CB�P���@�APHK?�TE@?�EK�E�@E�K�kK��E���G�B?EK�HKJE>��?B�

VK@>EK�M��ZH��@>EK�EALK@?�E0�H�ZK�?EMH��W?E0����K��EK0�APHK?�JEI

T�EACKJ��Q�HE�K�I?D�BCB��K�HE�K�I?D)�u@CB�I��K��K�^���JE^�AKGET�@�

�E@?D0��B���kB�?�KAE���BI0��B�T�BGU�U�>�@E�K@?B��BVKME��K�BGJK�

�I?0�I�APHP�T�EHECZ�?D�AEI?D@I0�G��VB?0���HE�W?E�EA@PZH�?D�B��K���HE

PHB�CI?D@I0���GH��Z�?D@I�B��T�H�?D���TK@@BJBGJ)

F�>BK�?E�@BCU���@�T�B�KCB�>�?�>EJP�@BCE�EJP�T�E?B�EHK�@?�B^)

|E�T�EACKJU��@K�?�>B�K@?D�B�@K�V�@)�tEK�PV�@?BK���PCPVkK�BB�@B?P�

�NBB�G�>C^V�K?@I���?EJ0�V?E�I�HECZK��HEJ��EVK�D�J�EME���AE?�?D)

XK�V�@��@I�HKI?KCD�E@?D0�>E?E�P^�I�@VB?�^�HCI�@KAI���BAECKK�T�B�

KJCKJE��B��KEASEHBJE��Q�W?E���G�B��?D�M��ZH��@>EK�EALK@?�E�P���@

��RAS�GBB)�u@CB�>�ZHU��M��ZH��B��HK�@?�B?KCD�E�@JEZK?���AE?�?D

?�>0�>�>�JU�@���JB���AE?�KJ0�@B?P�NBI�@?��K?�CPVkK)�|E�@K�V�@��K

S��?�K?��K@P�@E�0�ZB?KCB����E�E���K�BJK^?�H�ZK��EGJEZ�E@?B�VB�

?�?D�M�GK?U)�tU���XPSPJK�B�O�M��S0�HETP@?BJ0�VB?�KJ0�����@KC�S�B

M�GK?�?E��K?��P���@�EVK�D�TCESBK�>EJJP�B>�NBB0��K�?ECD>E�BG�G����Kk�

�K��ACE>�HU0��E�B���P?�K��BS�J�CK�D>BS�}ACE>�H~�J�EME)�|�T�B�

JK�0��K?�JE@?��Q�B�PZK�TEV?���K�TE@?PT�K?���@KC�0��K?���?EAP@��Q�B��K?

TEV?U)�|K�APHK?�ZK�VKCE�K>�>�ZHU��HK�D�,-�>BCEJK?�E��TKk>EJ�SE�

HB?D�G��M�GK?�JB)�]HB����G�TE�HK?0��E��?E�E����G��K�TE�HK?)�|�J�@

�BJB�KLK��PZ�E�ME�E�B?D)�y��K�G��^0�JEZK?0���kK�EALK@?�E�G�SEVK?

Page 218: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�K�CBGE��?D�>�>P^�?E�H�PMP^�JEHKCD)��K@?�E�ME�E�I0�HB�CEM��@�EA�

LK@?�EJ�P���@�T��>?BVK@>B��K?)���@��C�@?D^�>�>�?�>E�EME�HB�CEM��P

��@0�JEZK?�AU?D0�?EZK��K?0��E�JU�V�@?E�HEM�HU��KJ@I0�VKME�E�B�SE�

?I?)�qPJ�^0�V?E�P��BS�?EZK�T�EACKJU0��E�W?E�PZK�H�PME����GME�E��

y�HPJ�^0�V?E��U��K�HECZ�U�EABZ�?D@I0�>EMH��JU��KG>E�ME�E�BJ)�xUCE

AU�SPZK0�K@CB�AU�JU�EASEHBCB�E@?�UK��ET�E@U�B�TE?EJ0�@�HI@D��

��?EAP@0�ME�E�BCB��G�I�T�E@BHKCB�?�B�H�I)

qPJ�^0�V?E� K@CB���k���K�>NBI�TE�TE�EHP�EH�EME�J�CK�D>EME

T�EK>?���UG��C��P���@�AP�^�WJENB�0�I�AU������kKJ�JK@?K�T�E@?E

G�HPJ�C@I0�TEVKJP�W?E?�T�EK>?��UGU��K?�P��AS�GE��?�>P^��KM�?B��

�P^��K�>NB^)�y�HETP@>�^0�V?E��K�P��@KS��AS�GE��W?E��UGU��K?�EHB���

>E�P^��KM�?B��P^��K�>NB^0��E��@K�?�>B��U��K�@E��@KJB��AS�G�JB

��GME���B��K?K)���W?E�JEZ�E�AUCE�EA@PHB?D)�|E���G�W?E��UGU��K?

�K�>NB^0�?E��K���HE�JK�I�M�@B?D)�nZK�M�@BCB0�TE�BJ�K?K0�SE�EkE�E?

W?EME��B���J0��B���J��K�@?�CE0�VK@?�E�ME�E�I)�|�HE��@K�EA@PZH�?D)

YKJ�AECKK���@�?P?��@KME�?E�.-�.4�VKCE�K>)�qPJ�^0�V?E�JU�T�E@?E�HEC�

Z�U�AU?D�@JKCKK)�XJKCKK�HPJ�?D�E�APHPLKJ0�@JKCKK�ME�E�B?D�E�?EJ0

V?E�JU�@K�V�@�BG�@KAI�T�KH@?��CIKJ)�u@CB�AU�I�JEM�H�?D�>E�@?�P>�

?B��P^�JEHKCD0�>E?E�P^��E@T�B�ICB�AU�B�M�PGB�U0�B��AS�GU�B��@K

@EEALK@?�E0�?E�P�K�I^���@0�I�AU�W?E�@HKC�C)�y���kKC�AU����W?E��K@P��

@U0�@�KH@?��0�B�lE�J�NB^)�|E�JU�@���JB�@KMEH�I�TE>��?ECD>E�HPJ��

KJ�EA�W?EJ)�y���kKC�AU����W?E��K@P�@U0�@�KH@?��0�B�lE�J�NB^)�|E

JU�@���JB�@KMEH�I�TE>��?ECD>E�HPJ�KJ�EA�W?EJ)�=ECKG�E�?E0�V?E�JU

BJKKJ��EGJEZ�E@?D�TPACB>E��?D���kB���GJUkCK�BI�B�EA@PZHK�BI)

tEZK?�AU?D0��K��@K���@KCK�BK�O�PGBB�B�RAS�GBB�T�EVB?�K?�W?B�J�?K�

�B�CU0��E�>�>BK�?E�C HB�EAIG�?KCD�E�T�EVB?�^?�B�APHP?�BS����CBGB�

�E��?D)�=E?EJP�V?E�VK�KG�JK@IN�TE@CK�?EME0�>�>�>�BMB���GE�HP?@I0�I

@E�K�kK��E�P�K�K�0� V?E� I� P@CUkP�?���@lE�JB�E����UK�JU@CB�B

BHKB0�>E?E�UK�APHP?���TEC�I?D@I�ZBG�K��E���K�CD�E@?D^0�>E?E�P^

I0�JEZK?�AU?D0�T�EGK��C)�=E?EJP�V?E0�@EG��^@D0�JU�ZB�KJ����?�>E�

AKGPJ�E��@>E�E@?B0���G�B��I�M��ZH��@>EK�EALK@?�E�Q�B�EMH��JVBJ�

@I�JBJE��@KS0�J�CE�>EME�G�JKV�I)�tEZK?�AU?D0�JU�T�EAKZ�CB�JBJE0

T�ETP@?BCB�>�>BK�?E�T�E@?UK�B@?B�U0�>E?E�UK�MHK�?E��IHEJ)�=�EkP

T�ELK�BI0�K@CB�I�>EME�?E�EABHKC�@�EK��WJENBE��CD�E@?D^0��E�I�HK��

@?�B?KCD�E��K�JEMP�ME�E�B?D�E�J�EMBS��KL�S�AK@@?��@?�E�B�W?E0�>E�

�KV�E0�JEI�T�EACKJ�)�xUCE�AU�CPVkK0�K@CB�AU�I�JEM�AU?D�EVK�D�E?�

Page 219: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

@?���K��UJ�B�EAE��@KJ�ME�E�B?D�@TE>E��E0��E�W?��T�EACKJ��JK�I

EVK�D�G�HKC��B�HPJ�^0�V?E���@�?EZK)�q�ZK�rK����0�>E?E�U���K�G��K?0

V?E�?�>EK��E������RAS�GBB�Q�E��?�J��K�AUC�B��TK��UK��AS�GE��P�BHKC

?ECD>E���T�EkCEJ�MEHP)�y�HPJ�^0�W?E�G�HK��K?��@KS0�T�E@?E�����G�E�

@?KTK�B)�F�>�I���G�BN��Q�EHB��T�CKN��KZKkD�BCB�HK@I?D)�xECD�VP��

@?�PK?�>�ZHU��TE���G�EJP�B��K�EGJEZ�E�@EBGJK�B?D�KME�AECD0�JE^

AECD0�?�E^�AECD)�[�Z�E0�V?E�E���P���@�K@?D)

��������%�"�8�y�TE@?���^@D�AU?D�EVK�D�>��?>E�)�x�?�C�T���BCD��E�@>�G�C0�V?E�JU�HECZ�U�ME�E�B?D�EAE��@KJ0�V?E���@��EC�PK?0�H�ZK

K@CB�W?E��EC�PK?�?ECD>E�EH�EME)�tU��K�JEZKJ�E?>�G�?D�KJP���T���K

ME�E�B?D�EA�W?EJ)���HK�@?�B?KCD�E0���HE0����K��EK0���PVB?D@I�AU?D

EVK�D�?K�TKCB�UJB)

t�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E�@KMEH�I�YB�B>E�B�rK����G�?�E�PCB�EVK�D���Z�

�P^�?KJP)�tU0�HK�@?�B?KCD�E�8I�BJK^����BHP��AS�GE�:0�J�CE�ME�E�BJ

E�?EJ0�>�>E��AU�JU�SE?KCB��BHK?D�APHPLP^�RAS�GB^0�>�>E��JU�@EAB�

��KJ@I�KK�@?�EB?D)�|E�I�HPJ�^0�V?E�K@?D�BG�B�I^LBK���@�JEJK�?U

8SE?I��@K�����E���HE�W?E�T�KEHECK��?D:)�u@CB�HCI���@�@KMEH�I�l�>?E�

RAS�GBB��K��Kk�^LB�0�?E0�>�@EZ�CK�B^0�?�>�@CEZBCE@D0�V?E�HCI���@

l�>?E��O�PGBB�Q��Kk�^LB�)���TE�BJ�K?K0��@K0�V?E�JU�APHKJ�ME�E�

�B?D�B�HPJ�?D�E�?E��APHPLK��RAS�GBB0�>E?E�P^�JU�SE?KCB�AU��BHK?D0

W?E�APHK?��@K�?�>B�VK�KG�T�BGJP�M�PGB�@>E��T�EACKJU0�VK�KG�T�EACK�

JP��EG���LK�BI�AKZK�NK�)�|�@C�B��K?@I�@?ECD>E��@I>BS�T�EACKJ0�V?E

EVK�D�?�PH�E�@KMEH�I�>E�@?�PB�E��?D�APHPLP^�RAS�GB^)�y0�>E�KV�E0

@EMC�@��0�V?E�W?E���HE�HKC�?D)�|E���P@CE�BIS0�>EMH��P���@�?�>EK�G�>�U�

?EK�EALK@?�E0�>EMH��CBkD�KHB�BNU�JEMP?�>PH��?E��UKGZ�?D�B��BHK?D0

>�>�ZB�P?�C HB���H�PMBS�@?����S0�>EMH���@K�G���BI�E@�E���U����@E�

�K?@>EJ�ETU?K0�>E?E�U�0�>�>��U�G��K?K0��K@DJ���KM�?B��U�)))�[�RAS��

GBB�@CE�E�}��?E�EJBI~�B�@KMEH�I��UGU��K?�AP>��CD�E��CCK�MB^�B

AKkK�@?�E)�|�HE�TE�I?D�W?E�EALK@?�E)�R�V?EAU�TE�I?D0����K��EK0

��HE�?�J�TEAU��?D�B�TEEAL�?D@I�@�C^HDJB�?�J0�MHK�H�ZK���GME�E��E

T����S�JK�DkB�@?��P���kBS��U@E>ETE@?��CK��US�C^HK�0�T�K?K�HP�

^LBS�AU?D�HKJE>��?�JB0��UGU��K?��K���P^��K�>NB^0�TE?EJP�V?E

E�B�HPJ�^?�E�?EJ0�>�>�W?E�JEZK?�AU?D�E@PLK@?�CK�E����@TK>?K��EG�

���LK�BI�AKZK�NK��B�TECEZK�BI���O�CD@>EJ����E�K)�Y�PH�E�@>�G�?D0

V?E�?�>EK�JK�DkB�@?�E)�[�RAS�GBB��EEALK��@K�AUCB�JK�DkB�@?���

Page 220: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

JB)�|K�AUCE��B>EME0�>?E�@E@?��CIC�AU�AECDkB�@?�E���@KCK�BI���M��5

��%���

!R������RU,���R��8��y�HPJ�^0�V?E�YB�B>E�B�rK����T�E@?E��>�

NK�?B�E��CB�T�EACKJP�>E��PTNBB)�y0���T�BJK�0�?�>�W?E��E@T�B�IC)

p?E�ZBG�K��E���Z��I�T�EACKJ�)�|E����@�JEJ�HKCK�T�EACKJ��>E��PT�

NBB�B��AS�G@>�I�T�EACKJ���G�BJE@�IG��U)�Y�>��K�AU��K?0�V?EAU�EH��

T�EACKJ��AUC��E?E������E?�H�PME�)��M����%���

��������%�"�8�[�>E�KV�EJ�B?EMK0� �E���KJI�EA@PZHK�BI�@�qZE�=ECEJ�rKHK��SEJ�JU��@K�?�>B0����K��EK0�TE�ICB0�V?E�?�>�B��K�@JEM�

CB����?B�EALBS�B�?K�K@E�)�[E?�W?E�EVK�D�?��MBV�E0�TE?EJP�V?E�W?E

EG��V�K?0�V?E�JU��@K�KLK���GHKCK�U)�u@CB�JU0���>E�KN0�TE�JKJ0�>�>

J�K�>�ZK?@I0�V?E���J�PME?E�����>�>�I�?E�E@EA�I�JB@@BI����F��>�GK0

?E�G��^0�V?E�P�J�EMBS�W?E��UGE�K?��KM�?B��P^��K�>NB^)�|E�I�VP��

@?�P^�B�?PB?B��E0� V?E�RAS�GBI�B�O�PGBI�HECZ�U����?B�>�>BK�?E

lE�JU��G�BJEE?�EkK�B�0�>E?E�UK�APHP?��CBI?D����?P�JEHKCD�E?�E�

kK�B�0�>E?E��I�APHK?�@>E�@?�PB�E���������@KJ�F��>�GK)���JEZK?�AU?D0

��J�@PZHK�E����?B�lE�JPCP���G�KkK�BI�W?EME�MKETECB?BVK@>EME�@E�

TK��BVK@?��0�>E?E��I�TEJEZK?�T�BJB�B?D�B�?K�K@U�zE@@BB�B�{�T��

H�����F��>�GK)�p?E0�>E�KV�E0�EM�EJ�U���UGE��HCI���@)

M���� �/%�"�-8�xE^@D0�V?E�JK�I��K�@CPk�CB)�qKCE���?EJ0�V?E�GHK@D

?EZK�T�EI�BC�@D�HB@>�BJB��NBI)�F�>�I\�FEMH��q��BH�@>�G�C��TI?UJ

TP�>?EJ�I�TEJKV?�^0�KJP�TEG�ECBCB)�R�>EMH��I�@>�G�C0�V?E�I�?EZK

SEVP�TEl��?�GB�E��?D0�JK�I�@?�CB�>�B?B>E��?D����� � ������ y��K

G��C0�V?E�P���@�?�>�I���?BT�?BI�>�JK?�lE�BVK@>BJ��U��ZK�BIJ�B

B@?E�BB)�=EW?EJP0�>EMH��I�@>�G�C�E�JB@?B>K0���HK^@D0��U�TE�ICB0�V?E

W?E�JK?�lE��)

uLK�I�@>�G�C�?�>P^�l��GP0�K@CB�TEJ�B?K��V?E�JK�I�B�JEK�EALK�

@?�E����5-���EC�P^?���P?�K��BK�T�EACKJU0����K���Kk�BK)���W?E

G��VB?0�V?E�T�BG���BK�O�PGBK��RAS�GBB�BCB��KT�BG���BK�PZK��K�@?ECD

�>?P�CD�E�HCI��AS�G@>EME�EALK@?��)�|E�I��K�TE�IC0�TEVKJP�?�>�ME�I�

VE�B�?KJTK��JK�?�E�E?�K�MB�E��C�P��Z�KJU��=��?�����W?E�G�I�CK�

�BK)��M����%��� �y��K�ME�E�BC0�V?E�HCI���@�RAS�GBI�Q�MC����I�T�E�

ACKJ�0�I�ME�E�BC0�V?E�W?E�EH���BG�T�EACKJ)�u@CB�AU�E����K�G�HK��C�

��@�G��ZB�EK0��K�AUC��AU�T�EACKJE����M����%���

Page 221: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

����"�W��"���S,���

���W� ��� ����d���� m�N�� fM�-���S� �-������ !��"#��$%!�!�%! '��%�� ��#,������R�.!%�����

=P@?D�G�MC��BK�JEK��@?�?DB��B>EME��K�EABHB?)�oE?BJ�JU�BCB

�K?0��AS�G@>BJ�B�M�PGB�@>BJ����EH�J��@KMH��T�BHK?@I�ZB?D��JK@?K

Q�}�JK@?K~���MKEM��lBVK@>EJ�@JU@CK�W?EME�@CE��)�[�KHB�EJ�CB�ME�

@PH��@?�K�BCB0�K@CB��GMCI�KJ����T�EACKJP�TEkB�K0���KHB�EJ�T�E�

@?���@?�K�NK��E@?K��Q��ET�E@�TE>��E?>�U?U��B�ZHK?�TEC�ENK��E�

ME�E?�K?�)���H�?D�W?E?�E?�K?��B>?E�BG���@�E?HKCD�E��K�@JEZK?)�|B

�AS�G@>�I0��B�M�PGB�@>�I�@?E�E����K���@BC�S����IG�?D�>�>EK�?E��K�

kK�BK�H�PM�H�PMP�B�JB�E�EJP�@EEALK@?�P)�=K�KH���JB�HECMB��TP?D0

B�?K0�>?E�AEB?@I�P@?�?D0�EA�KVK�U�����KPH�VP�Q�BJ��K��KkB?D���>E�

TB�kBK@I�T�EACKJ)

���+�%! '��%��� ��R� !.�n��0�

=ECB?B>��Q�W?E�@E�E>PT�E@?D��U@>�GU���B��B�HK�@?�B�)�Y�>�>�>

��HK�@?�BIS�EAK�@?E�E�U�EM���BVK�U�8>�@V�@?D^:0���J�T�BHK?@I�T�E�

���CBGB�E��?D�?K��U@>�GU���BI0�>E?E�UK�@CUk�CB@D�BG�YABCB@B�B

XPSPJB���?KVK�BK�;�5�CK?)

q�ZK�JBJECK?�U���GMCIH����W?E?�TK�BEH�TE>�GU��K?0�V?E��B>��

>EME�BGJK�K�BI���W?E���B?E�B>K�T��>?BVK@>B��K�T�EBGEkCE)�zB?E�B�

>��B�M�PGB�@>BS0�B��AS�G@>BS��C�@?K����T���CK����K����H�PMP^�@?E�E�

�P0���?ECD>E����?KS0����>EME���@T�E@?���IK?@I�BS�@>PH��I��C�@?D��B

sK���H��HGK0�B�R�HGB�A��@?���^?@I�ET���H�?D�@�EB�HK�@?�BI���MC��

G�S�@�EBS�@EM��ZH���B�W?BJ�T�EHCB?D�@�EK�T�B@P?@?�BK����TE@?P�CB�

HK�����NBB)�]HB��BG��BS��K���@BC�S�TE>E�VB?D�@��B?E�B>E��}�EG����

LK�BI�RAS�GBB~0��?E�EJP��K�PH�K?@I��B����EHB��T�ENK�?�E?>�G�?D@I

E?�G��B@ILK���KG��B@BJE@?B)

�������� ���!���� ���� " YE?�l�>?0�V?E��B�?�0��B�H�PM�I

@?E�E���>E�lCB>?���K�T�KHC�M�C��>�>EME��BAPHD�TC����KME�P�KMPCB�

�F�@EZ�CK�B^0�PV�@?�B>B�>E�lK�K�NBB�BJKCB��EGJEZ�E@?D�EG��>EJB?D@I�@�W?E�

@?�?DK��8?EV�KK0�@�KK�TK��E��V�CD�UJ����B��?EJ:�?ECD>E���TKV�?�EJ��BHK�Q���?E�

T�BKS�?D��K�@JEM)�Q�M�))

Page 222: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�E���BI0�@�BHK?KCD@?�PK?�E�?EJ0�V?E�@?E�E�U��K�@PJKCB�@lE�JB�E�

��?D�WllK>?B��UK�ME@PH��@?���Q�ME@PH��@?��0���>E?E�US�T���B?KCD�

@?���ET�KHKCI^?�E@�E��UK�HCI� EALK@?���T�EACKJU�B� �UH�BM�^?

TC��U�HCI��KkK�BI�W?BS�T�EACKJ)

u@CB���J�CK�D>E��8TE�@����K�B^�@�O�PGBK�:�RAS�GBB�B�@PLK@?�PK?

>�>�I�?��>E�@ECBH�NBI�8��E@�E��EJ0�ET�KHKCIKJ�I��K���B@?D^�>�M�P�

GB��J:0�?E�?ECD>E�V?EAU�EAK@TKVB?D�>��GB?E?�CB?���P^�@B@?KJP��C��

@?B)��?E�>�@�K?@I��KkK�BI�ZBG�K��E���Z�US�HCI�T�E@?US�M��ZH��

T�EACKJ0�?�>�I�G�H�V��TK�KH�@PSPJ@>BJB��C�@?IJB�B��K�@?EB?�Q�E�B0��

E@�E��EJ0�HECZ�U�G�AE?B?D@I�E�@ES���K�BB��KG��B@BJE@?B)��?E�@����

�B?@I�@�W?E��}M���HBEG�E�~�G�H�VK�\

[�@�JE��ZK�O�PGBB�E�>�>E���BAPHD�>E�@ECBH�NBB�B��KVB��K?)�|B

T�E?B�E@?EI�BK�@�zE@@BK��8�ET�E@��EK��US�A�G0�@B?P�NBI���=��>B@�

@>EJ�PLKCDK�BCB��BGE�U���KZBJ:0��B��AS�G@>�I0��B�E@K?B�@>�I�T�E�

ACKJ�0��B�W>E�EJBVK@>BK�?�PH�E@?B�Q��BV?E��K�G�@?��B?�EALK@?�E

>�>�?E�@�K�MB�E��?D����AKGHK�@?�BK�@EA@?�K��EME�T���B?KCD@?��)�R

>E�@ECBH�NBI�EALK@?����E>�PM�TEGB?B��US�NK��E@?K��Q�W?E�?ECD>E

JKV?��HCI�E?HKCD�US�C^HK�)�F�EJK��A@?��>?�EME�}sKC>E�EME�=P?B~0

HCI��K�CBG�NBB�>E?E�EME�?EZK��KHD��PZ�E�@TE@EA�EK�>�PT���CK�B^

T���B?KCD@?�E0�pHP��H�sK���H��HGK��K�T�KHC�M�C�M�PGB�@>EJP�EA�

LK@?�P��BVKME)�F�>�B�[C�HB@C���R�HGB�A�0�E��?EZK��K���@BC�S��K�

kB?D�MC���P^�G�H�VP��@TE@EA@?�E��?D���G�B?B^�B�T�EN�K?��B^�@EA�

@?�K��EME����EH�)

|E�H����?K�G�H�HBJ��ET�E@�Q���JEMCE�CB�AU?D0�V?EAU�TECB?BVK@�

>BK�WCB?U�EAKBS�@?E�E��HK�@?�E��CB�B��VK\�xUC��CB�P��AS�GE��B�M�P�

GB���EGJEZ�E@?D�@�JBJ0�AKG�>�>BS�CBAE�TE@�KH�B>E�0����?B�EALB�

IGU>\��?E�ET�KHKCICE�@EAE���KWllK>?B��E@?D��C�@?K����XPSPJB�B��

YABCB@B\

p?E�TE�EV�U��>�PM��T�KAU���BK���@E@?EI�BB�l�>?BVK@>E���E��

�U�@�O�PGBK��JKk�CE�RAS�GBB�8?EJP�EALK@?�P0�>E?E�EK�E@?�CE@D���

?K��B?E�BB�AU�kK��RAS�G@>E��RXXz�TE@CK��E��U�.55,�53�MM):�G��

�I?D@I�T�EACKJ�JB0� ��Z�UJB�HCI� @EGH��BI��E�J�CD�EME�ME@PH���

@?�K��EME�P@?�E�@?��)�R��K�TE@?�EB���E�J�CD�EME�ME@PH��@?�K��EME

T���CK�BI0�RAS�GBI�CBk�K?�@KAI��EGJEZ�E@?B�ET�KHKCB?D@I���MC���

�EJ��ET�E@K�Q�>�>���C�ZB��?D�SE?D�>�>BK��BAPHD��E�J�CD�UK0�VKCE�

�KVK@>BK�E?�EkK�BI�@�O�PGBK�)

Page 223: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

YKJ� ��KJK�KJ�YABCB@B0� TK�BEHBVK@>B� EAwI�CII� }�AS�G@>P^

T�EACKJP~�MC���E��T�EACKJE��H�I�B�EAKL�I�AKZK�N�J�}�EG���LK�

�BK�RAS�GBB~�>�?�>EJP�?E�MEHP0�?EZK�AUC�G��I?��E�@K��K�P@?�E�@?�EJ

ME@PH��@?��0���P@?�E�@?�EJ�ZBG�B�E?HKCD�US�T�B�BCKMB�E����US

VCK�E��T���B?KCD@?��)�=�B� ?�>EJ�TECEZK�BB� HKC� T���B?KCD@?�E

O�PGBB�B��K�JEMCE��UH�BM�?D�>�>BS�CBAE�B�BNB�?B��HCI��KkK�BI

>E�lCB>?�)

#� �� ���� ���������$�����%��"�[�>�>E��?E�JE�

JK�?�TECB?BVK@>BK�WCB?U�EAKBS�@?E�E��E@EG��CB0�V?E�?�>EK�@E�

@?EI�BK0�JEZK?�AU?D0�B��K�UMEH�E�HCI����EHE�0��E��TEC�K�T�B�

MEH�E�HCI�HE@?BZK�BI�CBV�US�NKCK��@�JBS�VCK�E��W?BS�WCB?)��KJ

AECDkK��K���B@?B0�?KJ�HECDkK�P�KMPCB�E���BK�>E�lCB>?�)��KJ

H�CDkK�E?>C�HU��K?@I�P�KMPCB�E���BK�>E�lCB>?�0�?KJ�@BCD�KK

TEGBNBB�?KS0�>?E�AECDkK��@KS�TE�B��U���@EGH��BB�?�>E��TE�EV�

�E��@B?P�NBB)

Y�J�G�|�H��KBk�BCB�TK�KH�>�ZHUJB�T��C�JK�?@>BJB��UAE���

JB�@?��E�B?@I��KENK�BJE��lBMP�E����MC�G�S�T���ILK��T��?BB�O�P�

GBB��G��|�H��KBk�BCB�VB@CB?@I��K�JK�DkK�4-�?U@IV�MECE@E��Q�@?K�

�KE?BT�HK�@?�PK?)�R�?E0�V?E�P@CE�BI�ZBG�B�|�H��KBk�BCB�B�T�E@?E�

ME�AKZK�N���K@ETE@?��BJU0��K���@VK?��>�>�R�HGB�A��G��I?�P>�KTCK�

�BKJ��AS�G@>E��ME@PH��@?�K��E@?B0�?�>�B�|�H��KBk�BCB�G��I?�}�EG�

���LK�BKJ�RAS�GBB~)

=P@?D��AS�GU�TE�JP?0�V?E�@BHILBK�TK�KH��BJB�M�PGB�U�Q�W?E

�E�@K��K�?K0�P�>EME�@K�V�@��C�@?D���O�PGBB)�p?E�C^HB0�>E?E�US�@�JB

�AS�GU�HECZ�U�>�>�?E�TEHHK�ZB��?D0�K@CB�SE?I?0�V?EAU��E�MC��K�O�P�

GBB�@?EICE�T���B?KCD@?�E0��Kk�^LKK�T�EACKJU0����K�A��H��>E��PJ�

TB�E����US�CBN)

=P@?D�M�PGB�U�T�KH@?��I?�@KAK0�V?E�AUCE�AU0�K@CB���W?E��@?��k�

�E���E��K�TEAKHBCB�M�PGB�U)�[KHD�?��MB>EJBVK@>BK�lBMP�U���kK�

�E�K�kK��B@?E�BB�Q�FB?E���B�BCB��E@KCB��B�Q�HE�@BS�TE��AUCB�AU

MK�EIJB�B�TEAKHB?KCIJB)�F�>E��AUC��AU�?EMH��TECB?BVK@>�I�ZBG�D

��O�PGBB\�XK�V�@�VK�?�?K�V?E0���?EMH��V?E�AUCE�AU\

=P@?D�M�PGB�U�W?E�PV?P?)�=P@?D�TE@JE?�I?����?KS0�@�>KJ�@BHI?

@K�V�@�G��EH�BJ�@?ECEJ0�B�E?H�HP?�@KAK�E?VK?0�>�>�?�PH�E�E?HKCD�UJ

C^HIJ���XPSPJB��U��Z�?D��GMCIHU0��K�@E�T�H�^LBK�@�ElBNB�CD�E�

?EV>E��G�K�BI��AS�G@>EME�T���B?KCD@?��)

Page 224: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

y�TE�?E�I^��G�I�CK�BI�TECB?BVK@>BS�WCB?�EAKBS�@?E�E��T�KH�

��G��VK�U�HCI�@�EBS�ZK)���?K0�B�H�PMBK�AEI?@I0�V?E�>?E�?E�TEHCE�

�B?�BS����}T�KH�?KCD@?�K�@EA@?�K��EME����EH�~)�]�B�AEI?@I��K���

�B@?B�@EA@?�K��EME����EH��B�W?BJ�@TE@EA@?�P^?���GZBM��B^��K�

���B@?B�JKZHP��AS�G@>BJB�B� M�PGB�@>BJB����EH�JB)�|B�?K0��B

H�PMBK��K�G�AE?I?@I�E�?EJ0�V?E�>�>�?E�@JIMVB?D���T�IZK�BK�JKZHP

���EH�JB0�JKZHP�EAUV�UJB�C^HDJB0�JKZHP�?KJB0�>?E�J�EMBK�MEHU

ZBCB��JK@?K)

���� ������&���� ��� �" ���E?�GHK@D�JU�T�BSEHBJ�>�KLK

EH�E��T�EACKJK�Q�>�T�ET�@?B�JKZHP����EH�JB)�y�HPJ�^0�V?E�}�EG�

���LK�BK�AKZK�NK�~�Q�W?E��K�MPJ��B?����I0��K�W>E�EJBVK@>�I0��K

HKJEM��lBVK@>�I0��K�W?�BVK@>�I0�����TK��P^�EVK�KHD�TECB?BVK@>�I

T�EACKJ�)�=ECB?BVK@>�I���?EJ�@JU@CK0�V?E�T�IJEK�EALK�BK�M�PGB�

B��AS�GE��T�KZHK��@KME�TE�CBIK?����TECB?BVK@>BK�lE�U�B���YABCB�

@B0�B���XPSPJB)�nM�@��BK��K���B@?B�JKZHP�T�E@?UJB�C^HDJB�EAI�

G�?KCD�E�@>�ZK?@I����@PHDA�S�?KS0�>?E�@?�EB?�@�E^�TECB?B>P�����K�

���B@?B)

R�>?E�@?�EB?�W?P�TECB?B>P�Q�HE�@BS�TE���KI@�E)�O�PGB�U�EA�B�I�

^?�����GZBM��BB�>E�lCB>?���P@@>BS0��AS�GU0�@E�@�EK��@?E�E�U0��U�

��Z�^?�@>KT@B@�TE�TE�EHP��K�?��CB?K?��]]|�B�H�PMBS�TE@�KH�B�

>E�)�{HK@D�JU�PZK�@?�C>B��KJ@I�@�>E�w^�>?P�E��@KMEH�Ik�KME�H�I)

�! oe %�����$��!R -S ��!�R -

'����������� " [�>E�NK��EIA�I��P>E�EHB?KCB���Kk�KTECB?B�

VK@>BS��KHEJ@?��VK?U�KS��KT�BG����US��K@TPACB>�Q�|�ME��EME�F��

��A�S�0�RAS�GBB0��Z�E��]@K?BB�B�=�BH�K@?�E�DI�Q�PV�KHBCB���

�@?�KVK� ��YB��@TECK� TE@?EI��E� HK�@?�P^LB�� >EE�HB��NBE��U�

E�M���Q�XE�KL��BK�JB�B@?�E��B�E@?����US�HKC0�E?JK?B��T�B�W?EJ0

V?E� @EGH��BK�JB�E?�E�VK@>EME�>E�?B�MK�?������J>�S�E�M��BG�NBB

OnnRt0�EAwKHB�I^LK��O�PGB^0�n>��B�P0�nGAK>B@?��0�RGK�A��HZ��

B�tECHE�P0�T�E?B�E�KVBCE�AU�B�?K�K@�J�XPSPJB0�vSB���CB0�X?KT��

��>K�?��B�YB��@TECI)

RAS�G�J�?�PH�E�8H��B��K?���HEA�E@?B:�E?�BN�?D�@�EB�}E@EAUK

E?�EkK�BI~�@�zE@@BK�)�|K�APHKJ�NB?B�E��?D�HKTP?�?��ME@HPJU�RC>�

@�B@��Q�EA�W?BS�E?�EkK�BIS�ME�E�I?�l�>?U�

Page 225: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

� ��zE@@BB�T�ESEHI?�TEHME?E�>P�.7��AS�G@>BS�?�JEZK��B>E�c.

� @E?�PH�B>B�@PSPJ@>EME���@?B?P?��@PHKA�US�W>@TK�?BG���W?EJ�MEHPT�E�HP?�T��>?B>P���F��@�EH��K�B�zE@?E�K����qE�P),

p?E�ME�E�B?�?ECD>E�E�?EJ0�V?E�TE�@KH�K���I�ZBG�D0���G��VB?0�BJK�?�CD�E@?D0��AS�GE��@�IG����@�^Z�E��zE@@BK�)���M�PGB��J�T�B�HK?@I�@?���?D@I0�V?EAU�T�E@?E���AS�G�TK�K>C^VBC@I�E?�?�>E��G��B@B�JE@?B�E?�zE@@BB�BJK��E����E?�EkK�BI�@�O�PGBK�)�|E0�TE�?E�IKJ0�HCIW?EME�@�J��O�PGBI�HECZ���AU?D�ME@PH��@?�EJ0�@�JE��O�PGBK��HECZ��U�T���B?D�WllK>?B��UK�JK�KHZK�U�TECB?B>B)

!� ��$��!R -S �&�R� +�n�!� �,!�.!U !2��"!� ���!�+%!����#�.�2� !����"���$��.� ���+ !���,�$���!��!$$��8�� �/�� ��!(�� ��+�,�$%���,� �-������ $%�#�0!����%!,2�%!�!����$,-��,�e���S� ����"#��$%!&�0�!"��.��$�,�,!R!.��!$$�&$%�#�"���$��������!����������8�h� ��0���.� +S�e��!�+�p �����, �eq�!$$���,n�!.�%! '��%��2� !��.� !�R�-���������!,� �-�%! '��%���.���R!�U ��$�����+$-�0!$��0� !��.� +S��+�n����!�+8

=�KH@?��B?KCD� T��C�JK�?@>E��l��>NBB� �=�EJUkCK��B>B����>CB��x�?B�k�BCB��U@?PT�K?�@�@EA@?�K��UJ�TC��EJ�P�KMPCB�E����BI�>E�lCB>?�)�|��TK��EJ�W?�TK�T�KHTEC�M�K?@I���@kB�K�BK���K��C��HK�@?�B���E@@B�@>BS�JB�E?�E�VK@>BS�@BC�HE��)�OPJB@?U0���KHK��BK���W?P�GE�P�TEH��GHKCK�B��M�PGB�@>E��TECBNBB�B�ME@AKGET�@�E@�?B0�@EGH��BK�EAwKHB�K��EME��E@@B�@>E�M�PGB�@>EME�k?�A��B�T���lB��E���BK�HE>PJK�?��E�H�CD�K�kKJ�T�KAU���BB��E@@B�@>BS��EK��USA�G���x�?PJB�B�RS�C>�C�>B)�X�J�x�?B�k�BCB�T�BG��K?0�V?E�@EMC�@BK���T�KAU���BK��E@@B�@>BS�A�G�Q�AECDk�I�ZK�?���@�M�PGB�@>E��@?E��E�U0��E�H�PMBS�TK�@TK>?B����TC��K�P�KMPCB�E���BI�E���K��BHB?)�=EKME�@CE��J0�zE@@B^�@K�V�@��K�B�?K�K@P^?�A�GU���[�GB��B�B�OPH�P?K0KK���BJ��BK�TK�K�K@K�E����A�GU���x�?PJB�B�RS�C>�C�>B0����M���BNK@�YP�NBK��Q�VCK�EJ�|RY])3

x�E@�K?@I���MC�G����B��E@?D�W?E��TEGBNBB��>�>�APH?E�@�JBS��A�S�GE���KVKME�@T��kB��?D�Q�T�B>�ZK?�BJ�tE@>��0�B��@K)�oE?I�B�EMH�?�>�B�K@?D)�|E0���T�BJK�0���B�?K��D^��MK�?@?�P�=���J�|D^@�G��

JK@?B?KCD�JB�B@?���EAE�E�U�zE@@BB�RCK>@��H��FE@E����@>�G�C0

V?E�zE@@BI��KC��T�EHECZB?KCD�UK�B��KT�E@?UK�TK�KME�E�U�@��A�

S�G@>E��@?E�E�E�0�HEAB��I@D�@EMC�@BI�XPSPJB�����UTEC�K�BK��K�

.�=���J�|D^@0�.9�lK���CI�,--.),�=���J�|D^@0�.�lK���CI�,--.)3�=���J�|D^@0�7�lK���CI�,--.)

Page 226: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

kK�BI�T�EkCEMEH�KME�@?�JAPCD@>EME�@�JJB?��]xXu�TE��U�EHP�MP�

H�P?@>E��A�GU)

XPSPJB�T�E?B����@kB�K�BI�GE�U�E?�K?@?�K��E@?B��E@@B�@>BS

JB�E?�E�NK�0�@�B�BNB�?B�E��>E?E�EME��U@?PTBC�M�PGB�@>B��T��C��

JK�?��B�)�[�B�?K��D^�?EJP�ZK�=���J�|D^@�@TKNB�CD�U��T�KH@?��

�B?KCD�CBHK���RAS�GBB�TE��ET�E@�J�P�KMPCB�E���BB�>E�lCB>?��R��B

qZK�MK�BI�G�I�BC0�V?E��AS�G@>�I�@?E�E�����B�TEH�>�>BJ��BHEJ���K

TE�HK?����BGJK�K�BK�lE�J�?��T�KAU���BI��E@@B�@>BS�JB�E?�E�NK�

��GE�K�>E�lCB>?�)�=E�KME�@CE��J0�MC����I�G�H�V���E@@B�@>BS��MECP�

AUS�>�@E>��Q���SEZHK�BK����CB�BB���GM���BVK�BI�EM�I�B�JK�I?D�W?E

�KkK�BK��K?�@JU@C�)

XTKNB�CD�U��T�KH@?��B?KCD�OK�K��CD�EME�@K>�K?��I�]]|�TE

M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EJP�P�KMPCB�E���B^�qB?K��xEHK�0�>EJJK�?B�PI�B�B�

NB�?B�P�M�PGB�@>EME�T��C�JK�?��BI0�@>�G�C�=���J�|D^@0�V?E����H���

�EJ�W?�TK�T���E�E��A�GE�0�ET�KHKCI^LK��GE�P�E?�K?@?�K��E@?B��E@�

@B�@>BS�JB�E?�E�NK�0�I�CIK?@I�tE@>E�@>B��HE>PJK�?�.559�M)�B��ET�

�E@�E���K@K�BB����KME�BGJK�K�B���K���@@J�?�B��K?@I).

�?E�ZK�>�@�K?@I�MPH�P?@>E��A�GU0�XPSPJB�@�tE@>�E�0���GPJKK?�

@I0���kCB�EALB��IGU>��JB�B@?��B�E@?����US�HKC��KT�BG����E��zK@�

TPACB>B�RAS�GBI�XK�MK��s�JA��G�I�BC0�V?E���EAJK�����@EMC�@BK��A�

S�G@>E�� @?E�E�U����AK@T�KTI?@?�K��U���U�EH�V�@?B��E@@B�@>EME

�EE�PZK�BI�@�W?E��A�GU0�E@PLK@?�CK��U����HK>�A�K���@EE?�K?@?�BB�@

?�KAE���BIJB�]xXu0�XPSPJB�TECPVBC�E?�zE@@BB�M����?BB�AKGET�@�

�E@?B)�[�B�?K��D^�=���J�|D^@�E��@>�G�C0�V?E�@EMC�@BK�RAS�GBB�AUCE

H��E�����ET�KHKCK��US�P@CE�BIS�0���G��?D�>E?E�UK�E��>�?KME�BVK@�

>B�E?>�G�C@I0� EM���BVB�kB@D� @EEALK�BKJ0� V?E�tE@>���B�XPSPJB

HE@?BMCB�>EJT�EJB@@�0�>E?E�U�����HE@?�?EV�E��@?KTK�B�PHE�CK?�E�

�BC��AS�G@>P^�@?E�E�P�), ��K�KG��K@>ECD>E�H�K��s�JA��G�I�BC0�V?E

���XPSPJB�ME?E�U���@@J�?�B��?D��ET�E@�E�TEH>C^VK�BB�RAS�GBB�>

�E@@B�@>E�AKCE�P@@>EJP�@E^GP�BCB�B�UJ�JKZME@PH��@?�K��UJ�EAwK�

HB�K�BIJ0��E�TE>��?ECD>E����?KE�K?BVK@>EJ�P�E��K�)3

(�����) �� ��������*����������������������" RAS�GU

EVK�D��KG>E��K�MB�P^?�BJK��E����PJK�DkK�BK��ECB��E@@B�@>E��@?E�

.�=���J�|D^@0�.3�lK���CI�,--.),�=���J�|D^@0�..�I����I�,--.)3�=���J�|D^@0�.9�I����I�,--.)

Page 227: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�E�U���TK�KME�E��S�BCB�TEH>C^VK�BK�H�PMBS�@?����B�E�M��BG�NB��>

JB�E?�E�VK@>BJ�P@BCBIJ)��]?>�E�K��E�T�EM�PGB�@>E��. ���GU��K?

R��B�qZK�MK�BI�TEGBNB^�BG�K@?�EME� �JK�B>��@>EME�TECB?ECEM�0

AU�kKME�@E�K?�B>��T�KGBHK�?��XsR�TE���NBE��CD�E��AKGET�@�E@�

?B0�{ABM�K���xZKGB�@>EME0��U@?PTB�kKME�G����EH���RAS�GB^�JKZHP�

���EH�US�TEH��GHKCK�B�)��?EAU�P�KMPCB�E��?D�>E�lCB>?0���HE0�T�KZ�

HK��@KME0�TE>E�VB?D�@���P?�K��K��B���Kk�K��B�?K��K�NBK�����W?E�

?K��B?E�BB0�V?E0���@�E^�EVK�KHD0�PH�@?@I0�K@CB����@JK�P�B�E@?����

�UJ��EE�PZK��UJ�@BC�J�?PH��T�BHK?���@?EILKK��EK��EK�T�KH@?��B�

?KCD@?�E�]xXu0�G�I�BC�xZKGB�@>B��ZP���CB@?�J���[�kB�M?E�K0�E?�

JK?B��T�B�W?EJ0�V?E�J�EMEK�APHK?�G��B@K?D�E?�?EME0���>�>BS�J�@k?��

A�S���C�@?B�H�PME��@?���U��G�SE?I?�W>@TCP�?B�E��?D��AS�G@>P^�T�E�

ACKJP�HCI�E@PLK@?�CK�BI�TECB?BVK@>EME�H��CK�BI����O�PGB^�B�EM���

�BVK�BI�KK��KG��B@BJE@?B),

FEJB?K?�JKZT��C�JK�?@>E���@@�JACKB�]xXu0�G�@KH��BK�>E?E�

�EME�T�ESEHBCE�,,�,3�lK���CI���[K�K0�KHB�EMC�@�E�T�B�IC��KGEC^�

NB^�EA�PV�KZHK�BB�@TKNB�CD�EME�>EJB?K?��TE��ET�E@P�RAS�GBB)�8[

G�@KH��BB�T�B�ICB�PV�@?BK�HKCKM�NBB�49�ME@PH��@?�):�[�T�B�I?E�

FEJB?K?EJ��KGEC^NBB��U��Z�K?@I�MCPAE>�I�EG�AEVK��E@?D��EGJEZ�

�E@?D^�G��VB?KCD�EME�PSPHkK�BI���T�IZK��E��@B?P�NBB���GE�K�>E��

lCB>?�0���?�>ZK��B@>EJ��EGEA�E�CK�BI�>E�lCB>?����@CPV�K0�K@CB�AK�

ZK�NU�B��U�PZHK��UK�TK�K@KCK�NU��K�TECPV�?��EGJEZ�E@?D�AKGE�

T�@�EME�B�HE@?E��EME��EG���LK�BI���@�EB�HEJ�)�FEJB?K?�APHK?��KMP�

CI��E�E?VB?U��?D@I�TE�@B?P�NBB���GE�K�>E�lCB>?��B�E�T�EHKC���E�

��AE?K�TK�KH�tKZT��C�JK�?@>E���@@�JACKK�)�X�.55;� M)� HKCKM�NBI

O�PGBB�TE@?EI��E�@?��BC����tKZT��C�JK�?@>E���@@�JACKK��ET�E@�E

NKCK@EEA��G�E@?B�PV�KZHK�BI�@TKNB�CD�EME�>EJB?K?��TE��ET�E@P

RAS�GBB0��E�BG�G��TEGBNBB��E@@B�@>E��HKCKM�NBB�@EGH�?D�W?P�@?�P>�

?P�P�HE�@BS�TE���K�PH���CE@D)3

[�@K�KHB�K�lK���CI�TEH�WMBHE��XE�K?��u��ETU�B�]]|���=BNP��

HK�@E@?EIC@I�H�PSH�K��U��@KJB�����OE@PH��@?�K��E�T���E�UK��@TK>�

?U�P�KMPCB�E���BI�>E�lCB>?��0�T�EkKHkB��T�B�@ET�KH@KH�?KCD@?�K

@TKNB�CD�EME�T�KH@?��B?KCI�OK�K��CD�EME�XK>�K?��I�]]|�qB?K��

.�=���J�|D^@0�.3�lK���CI�,--.),�=���J�|D^@0�3�lK���CI�,--.)3�=���J�|D^@0�,9�lK���CI�,--.)

Page 228: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

xEHK���B� >EJB@@����XE�K?��u��ETU�TE�T����J�VKCE�K>��RCD���E

oBCD�zEACK@�)�qB?K��xEHK����G��C�W?E?�@KJB�����TK��E��TETU?>E��

M�PGB�@>E��B� �AS�G@>E�� @?E�E��T�B@?PTB?D�>� EA@PZHK�B^�@�JEME

AECKG�K��EME��ET�E@��Q�E�@?�?P@K�RAS�GBB)�=E�J�K�B^�TEJEL�B>�

�AS�G@>EME�CBHK��0�R@?�JP���Y��BI0�@KJB�����E@BC���PV�U��S���>�

?K�0��E0�?KJ��K�JK�KK0�BJKC��ET�KHKCK��EK�TECB?BVK@>EK�G��VK�BK�)

F�>�@EEALBC�=���J�|D^@�R@?�JP��Y��BI0��AS�G@>BK�PV�@?�B>B�@K�

JB�����T�KHCEZBCB��K@?B�HB�CEM���T���E�EJ��P@CK0�@EGH��kKJ@I0

>EMH��TE@CK���G��C��XE�K?@>EME�XE^G��RAS�GBI�EAwI�BC��@KAI��KG��

�B@BJUJ�ME@PH��@?�EJ�Q�TE�J�K�B^��AS�G@>E��@?E�E�U0���G�U��E?�

�EkK�B��JKZHP�YABCB@B�B�XPSPJB�T�EBGEkKC�BJK��E���@�IGB�@�W?BJ

l�>?EJ)�O�PGB�@>�I�ZK�@?E�E���B�T�KH@?��B?KCB�]]|���@?�B��CB���

?EJ0�V?EAU�@VB?�?D�T�BVB�E����G�U���E?�EkK�B���EE�PZK��U��>E��

lCB>?�.55,�53�MM)�Y��BI���G��C�W?B�HK�@?�BI�M�PGB�@>E��HKCKM�NBB�B

T�KH@?��B?KCK��]]|0�?�>�ZK�>�>�B�T�KHCEZK�BK���@@JE?�K?D�T�EK>?

ME?E�ILKME@I�TEH�WMBHE��]]|�HE>PJK�?��E���GM���BVK�BB�TEC�EJE�

VB��JKZHP�YABCB@B�B�XPSPJB0��TETU?>E��@EGH��BI��E�E��ME@PH���

@?�K��E�T���E�E��A�GU�TK�KME�E�E��)�=E�KME�@CE��J0�XPSPJB����W?E

�K�TE�HK?�B��K@?B�TK�KME�E�U����?�>BS�P@CE�BIS��K�APHK?). �[E���KJI

TK�KME�E�E��@�xEHK�EJ���XPSPJB�[C�HB@C���R�HGB�A��E?>�G�C@I�EA�

@PZH�?D� W?E?�HE>PJK�?� E� ��GM���BVK�BB�TEC�EJEVB�)�F�>� @>�G�C

qB?K��xEHK��@TKN>E�P�=���J�|D^@�TE@CK��@?�KVB0��AS�G@>�I�@?E�E�

���@VB?�K?��ET�E@�E�@?�?P@K��KkK��UJ0���@�E^��KG��B@BJE@?D�Q�G�>�

�KTCK��E��>E�@?B?PNBE��E),

[�B�?K��D^�=���J�|D^@�MC����@PSPJ@>EME���Kk�KTECB?BVK@>E�

ME��KHEJ@?���XK�MK��s�JA��G�I�BC0�V?E0��K@JE?�I����TECB?BVK@>EK

H��CK�BK�]]|0�RAS�GBI��K�E?>�ZK?@I�E?�G�lB>@B�E����E����@�EK�

FE�@?B?PNBB��KG��B@BJE@?B�B�ME?E����K@?B��KVD�?ECD>E�E�����ET����

�US�ME@PH��@?�K��E�T���E�US�E?�EkK�BIS)�[�]]|�HECZ�U�W?E�TE�

�I?D�B�T�EI�CI?D�AECDkP^�MBA>E@?D0�>�>�W?E�HKC�K?�MC���U��TE@�KH�

�B>����TK�KME�E��S�Q�zE@@BI0�@>�G�C�s�JA�)3

.�=���J�|D^@0�.3�lK���CI�,--.),�=���J�|D^@0�.,�lK���CI�,--.)3�=���J�|D^@0�6�lK���CI�,--.)

Page 229: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

!,���,!0�!$�

��� ��� �������� ����(���"�|�T��kB��^?@I�M�P@?�UK��ET�

�E@U)

qPJ�CB�CB�>EMH���BAPHD�?K0�>?E��U@?PT�K?�G��T�EG�T�H�P^�E�B�

K�?�NB^�O�PGBB�8B�I���?EJ�VB@CK:0�>�>�@E�JK@?B?D�W?P�E�BK�?�NB^�@

T�E�E@@B�@>E��E�BK�?�NBK���AS�GE�0�K@CB�M�PGB�U�SE?I?0�V?EAU��A�

S�GU�ZBCB��JK@?K�@��BJB���KHB�EJ�ME@PH��@?�K\�]?H�^?�CB�W?B�C^HB

@KAK�E?VK?���?EJ0�>�>E��APHK?�TEGBNBI��AS�GE��B��AS�G@>E��V�@?B�W?E�

ME�}KHB�EME�ME@PH��@?��~0�K@CB���8�KEAEG�BJEJ:�APHPLKJ�M��ZH���J

?�>EME�MBTE?K?BVK@>EME�ME@PH��@?���T�BHK?@I�MECE@E��?D�G��T�B@EK�

HB�K�BK�>�G�T�H�UJ�@?�P>?P��J�AKGET�@�E@?B\��CB��AS�GE���K�T�B�

�BJ�?D�����@VK?\

[�lK���CK�T�KGBHK�?�sK���H��HGK�G�I�BC0�V?E��K�B@>C^V�K?��EG�

JEZ�E@?B�EAwI�CK�BI�O�PGBB�>�,--4�M)��K�?��CD�E��@?���E�0�K@CB�KK

���EH�T�BJK?�?�>EK��KkK�BK)�qCI�JK�I�@?����E��K�?ECD>E�?E0�V?E

YABCB@B��K�B�?K�K@PK?@I�TEGBNBK��XPSPJB�TE�W?EJP��ET�E@P0��E�B

TEGBNBI�@�JEME�XPSPJB��>��EGJEZ�E@?B�EAwI�CK�BI��K�?��CB?K?�

ElBNB�CD�U��XPSPJB�E?�E@B?@I�����EHPk�E�[�B�?K��D^�=���J�

|D^@�R��B�qZK�MK�BI���G��C��ET�E@�E��K�?��CB?K?K���P?�K��BJ

HKCEJ�O�PGBB)�RAS�GB^��K�B�?K�K@PK?0�@?��K?�CB�O�PGBI��K�?��CD�E�

@?���E��BCB��E�HK?���|RY]0�@>�G�C�qZK�MK�BI)�=E�KME�@CE��J0��XP�

SPJB�AECDkK�B�?K�K@PK?0�>�>�O�PGBI�@EAB��K?@I��U@?��B��?D�T���E�

�UK�E?�EkK�BI�@��KG��B@BJE��RAS�GBK��).

|E��KHD�?E0�}>�>�O�PGBI�@EAB��K?@I��U@?��B��?D�T���E�UK�E?�E�

kK�BI�@��KG��B@BJE��RAS�GBK�~0�G��B@B?�B�E?�?EME0�>�>�O�PGBI�@EAB�

��K?@I��U@?��B��?D�T���E�UK�E?�EkK�BI�@�JB�E�UJ�@EEALK@?�EJ)

[KHD�T�BG���BK��KG��B@BJE@?B�RAS�GBB�G��B@B?��K�?ECD>E�E?�zE@�

@BB�BCB�O�PGBB0��E�B�8H�ZK0�JEZK?�AU?D0�T�KZHK��@KME:�E?�?EME�E>�P�

ZK�BI0���>E?E�EJ���J�T�BSEHB?@I�ZB?D)

q�PME��?�PH�U��HCI�@�JBS�M�PGB���ET�E@��>�>�AE�E?D@I�@�}E@�

?��>�JB~�?E��PZ�@�E���E��U\�FEMH�����?K��B?E�BB�@?���U�T��?B�

G��U�HK�@?�P^?�T��>?BVK@>B�TECPElBNB�CD�E0�W?E��BVKME�SE�EkK�

ME��K�ME�E�B?�E�@�JE��@?���K)�F�>�@��BJB�AU?D\�F�>�BGA��B?D@I�E?

?KS0�>?E���KJI�E?���KJK�B�HKC�K?�M�EJ>BK�G�I�CK�BI�HCI�?EME0�V?E�

.�=���J�|D^@0�.;�lK���CI�,--.)

Page 230: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

AU�@?E�E�U��K�@JEMCB�T�B�?B�>�>EJT�EJB@@P\�Y�J�G�|�H��KBk�B�

CB0���T�BJK�0��K�P@?�K?�P?�K�ZH�?D0�V?E��P>E�EH@?�E�O�PGBB0����

@?�B��^LKK����JB��EJ��KkK�BB�T�EACKJU�B�T�EHECZK�BB�TK�KME�

�E�E��@�@PSPJ@>BJB�@KT���?B@?�JB0�?�>BJ�TP?KJ�RAS�GB^��B>EMH�

�K��K��K?)

}[�C^AE��H�PME��@?���K0�MHK�V�@?D�?K��B?E�BB�E>>PTB�E����0��

@E?�B� ?U@IV�C^HK�� @?�CB�AKZK�N�JB0� HK�@?�P^LBK��� ?UCP����M�

T��?BG��U�TECPV�^?�TEHHK�Z>P��C�@?K�0��E���O�PGBB��@��T�EB@SEHB?

��EAE�E?~0�Q�G�I�CIK?�|�H��KBk�BCB)�[�B�?K��D^�=���J�|D^@�E�

G�I�BC0�V?E�M�PGB�@>BK�T��?BG��U�ME��GHE�P�K�K��KK�VP�@?�P^?�@KAI

���?K��B?E�BB0�E>>PTB�E����E�����MEJ0��KZKCB����?K��B?E�BB0�>E��

?�ECB�PKJE���C�@?IJB�O�PGBB)�|��@�EK��?K��B?E�BB�W?B�C^HB�B@TU�

?U��^?�TE@?EI��EK�VP�@?�E�@?��S�0�?�>�>�>���C^AE��JEJK�?�BS�JE�

MP?���K@?E��?D�M�PGB�@>BK�T���EES���B?KCD�UK�E�M��U0�TEW?EJP�E�B

�U�PZHK�U�E?>�GU��?D@I�E?��EE�PZK��E��AE�DAU�T�E?B��@KT���?B@�

?E�0�G�I�CIK?�|�H��KBk�BCB)�=E�J�K�B^�|�H��KBk�BCB0���G�B?B^

T��?BG��@>EME�H�BZK�BI�@K�DKG�E�TE��KHBC�B�TEHTB@���U��@�@PSPJ�

@>BJB�@KT���?B@?�JB�..�B^CI�,---�M)�T�E?E>EC0�@EMC�@�E�>E?E�EJP

?K0�>?E�T�ET�M��HB�PK?�@BCE�E��JK?EH��KkK�BI��AS�G@>E��T�EACK�

JU0�APHP?�T�B�CK>�?D@I�>�PMECE��E��E?�K?@?�K��E@?B�).

tB�B@?����P?�K��BS�HKC�RAS�G@>E��R�?E�EJ�E��zK@TPACB>B��

BGM���BB�t�JP>��|�V>KABI�ET�E�K�M�K?�EA�B�K�BI�@PSPJ@>BS��C�@�

?K����?EJ0�V?E�}CKMB?BJ�UK��C�@?B���?E�EJBB~�TEHHK�ZB��^?�@�IGB

@�T��?BG��@>BJ�H�BZK�BKJ0��E�E?JKV�K?0�V?E�@EVP�@?�PK?�T��?BG��

��J)�F�>�G�I�BC�t�JP>��|�V>KABI����T�K@@�>E�lK�K�NBB0�T���EES�

���B?KCD�UK�E�M��U���?E�EJBB���BGM���BB��C�HK^?�B�lE�J�NBK��E

HKI?KCD�E@?B�T��?BG��)�=E� KME� @CE��J0�B@SEHI�BG� @CEZB�kK�@I� �

RAS�GBB�@B?P�NBB0��K?��BVKME�PHB�B?KCD�EME���?EJ0�V?E���W?EJ��KMB�

E�K�HK�@?�P^?�T��?BG��U)�tB�B@?��E?JK?BC0�V?E�K@CB�AU��K�G��B�

J�C��U�Kk�B��TE@?0�@�J�@lE�JB�E��C�AU�T��?BG��@>B��E?�IH),

=�EACKJ��O�PGBB�BJK��E���W?EJ��P��UV�ME��@?EI?�C^HB0��A@P�H�

�E@?B��U@>�GU���B��>E?E�US��K?�T�KHKC�)�F�>�P@?�EB?D�ME@PH��@?�E0

V?EAU�?�>���@?�EK��UK�C^HB��K��CBICB����T�ENK@@�P�KMPCB�E���BI

>E�lCB>?�\

.�=���J�|D^@0�.9�lK���CI�,--.),�=���J�|D^@0�,�lK���CI�,--.)

Page 231: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

Y�J�G�|�H��KBk�BCB�@VB?�K?0�V?E�HCI��KkK�BI��AS�G@>EME�>E��

lCB>?���KEASEHBJE��E�J�CBGE��?D�M�PGB�E��E@@B�@>BK�E?�EkK�BI

@�PVK?EJ�B�?K�K@E��YABCB@B�B�tE@>�U���W?EJ��KMBE�K)�[EG���LK�BK

RAS�GBB�TEH�^�B@HB>NB^�O�PGBB�G��B@B?�?ECD>E�E?�TEGBNBB�zE@�

@BB0�@>�G�C�E����B�?K��D^�=���J�|D^@)�=E�KME�@CE��J0��@I�TEGBNBI

{�T�H��TE�RAS�GBB��K�BHK?�H�CDkK�T�BG���BI�?K��B?E�B�CD�E��NK�

CE@?�E@?B�O�PGBB�B�T�BGU�E��>�JB��EJP��KkK�B^�T�EACKJU)�]�

@>�G�C0�V?E���@CPV�K0�K@CB�zE@@BI�E>�ZK?��K�CD�P^�TEJELD���P�KMP�

CB�E���BB��AS�G@>E��T�EACKJU0�O�PGBI�JEMC��AU�PVK@?D�B�?K�K@U

tE@>�U����KMBE�K�B�TE�?B����@ES���K�BK��E@@B�@>BS��EK��US�A�G

���@�EK��?K��B?E�BB����T�BKJCKJU��HCI�EAKBS�@?E�E��@�E>)�]�����

G��C��EAwI@�BJE���TEGBNB^�tE@>�U0�>E?E�P^���GH��Z�K?�H�BZK�BK

@E@KH�K��O�PGBB�>�|RY]).

[E?�G��?�>BJB�G�I�CK�BIJB�B��BHB?@I��K�CD��I�G�B�?K�K@E����

�E@?D�|�H��KBk�BCB��TP@?D�O�PGBI�TE�T�KZ�KJP�G��B@B?�zE@@BB0��E

KJP�H�HP?��UV�MB�T���CK�BI���XPSPJB)���?�>BJB�G�I�CK�BIJB�E�

?I�K?�O�PGB^���}CE�E~�zE@@BB��K�JK�DkK0�VKJ��AS�GU�B�M�PGB�E��A�

S�G@>B��>E�lCB>?)

(������ �������� ������� �"�[�?EJ0�V?E�T�EACKJ��O�PGBB

@PLK@?�PK?���XPSPJB0��K?�@EJ�K�BI)�[��EIA�K��AS�G@>BK��C�@?B�T�E�

�EHBCB���]V�JVB�@>EJ����E�K��EK��UK�PVK�BI� @�B@TECDGE���BKJ

?IZKCE��?KS�B>B)�|��PVK�BIS�E?��A�?U��CE@D�E?��ZK�BK��?�>�M�P�

GB�@>E����JBB�@E�@?E�E�U�FEHE�@>EME�PLKCDI�B�@E�@?E�E�U��>��?E�

�BB��K��EME�JE�I)

|E��K�?ECD>E�?ABCB@@>�I�T�EACKJ��@?EB?�TK�KH�XPSPJB)�[KHD��K

?ECD>E���YABCB@B�Q�B���XPSPJB�K@?D�}T��?BI��E��U~)�F�>�HE@?E��UJ

��G�B?BI�B�T�EN�K?��BI��AS�G�J�E?EA��?D�P��KK�TK��K�@?�E���ET�KHK�

CK�BB�TECB?B>B\�[KHD�G��B@BJE@?D�E?�>E�lCB>?��?�>��KCB>�0�V?EAU

����KkK�BK�H�PMBS�T�EACKJ��K�E@?�^?@I�@BC)

R�>�>�@?�EB?D�E?�EkK�BI�@�XK�K��UJ�F��>�GEJ0�K@CB�TEJELD

VKVK�N�J�@E�@?E�E�U�O�PGBB�ME��GHE�AECDkK0�VKJ�@E�@?E�E�U�RAS��

GBB\�[BNK�T�KJDK��T���B?KCD@?����V>K�BB�RSJKH�{�>�K��EA�B�BC

zE@@B^���B�@TB�B�E���BB�PV�@?BI�VKVK�@>BS�HEA�E�ECDNK����M�PGB�

�E��AS�G@>EJ��EE�PZK��EJ�>E�lCB>?K�.55,�53�MM)�[�B�?K��D^0�TK�K�

H���EJ���=���J�|D^@��MK�?@?�EJ���KVK�T�K@@�0�{�>�K��@>�G�C0�V?E

.�=���J�|D^@0�,5�I����I�,--.)

Page 232: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�TE�T�EkK@?�BB�ET�KHKCK��EME���KJK�B�@?�CE��A@EC^?�E�I@�E�0�V?E

G��W?BJ�>E�lCB>?EJ�B�PV�@?BKJ����KJ��K>E?E�US�VKVK�NK��@?EB?�zE@�

@BI0�@?�EIL�I�@�E^�TECB?B>P���E?�EkK�BB�>��>�G@>BS����EHE��TE

T�B�NBTP����GHKCI��B��C�@?�P��)��KVK�NU�@VB?�^?0�V?E�AKG��E@@B��

@>EME��JKk�?KCD@?���M�PGB�U�B��AS�GU�CKM>E�B�@>E�E�T�BHP?�>��G�BJ�

�EJP�@EMC�@B^0�E?JK?BC�{�>�K�).

tEB��U�EHU�EH�EG��V�U����?�>BS�P@CE�BIS�P�KMPCB�E���BK�>E��

lCB>?���K�EGJEZ�E)����AS�GU0�B� M�PGB�U0�B�JB�E�EK� @EEALK@?�E

HECZ�U�@?�KJB?D@I�>�?EJP0�V?EAU�G��@?ECEJ�ElBNB�CD�US�TK�KME�E�

�E��@BHKCB�C^HB0������ # ��� �����#�� �� � '��#��� #��� � ��#5

F���� �� �#'���� �� ���")� >� @?��ILBK�NKCD^��K� �A@?��>?�EK

}P�KMPCB�E���BK�M�PGB�E��AS�G@>EME�>E�lCB>?�~�Q���?E0�>�>�P@?�EB?D

ZBG�D�H�PM�@�H�PMEJ0�V?EA��K�JKk�?D�H�PM�H�PMP�����G�B?BB)

FEMH��@IHP?�G��@?EC�?�>BK�C HB\�FEMH��B���YABCB@B0�B���XPSPJB

APHP?�HKJE>��?BI�B�G�V�?>B�W>E�EJBVK@>BS�P@CE�B��HCI���G�B?BI0

>EMH��AE�DA��G���C�@?D�APHK?�>E�>P�K�NBK��TECB?BVK@>BS�M�PTT0����K

@S��?>E��@?��US�CBHK�E�)

R�TE>��W?EME��K?0�JU�EA�KVK�U�ZB?D���@E@?EI�BB�l�>?BVK@>E�

�E��U)

.�=���J�|D^@0�.4�lK���CI�,--.)

Page 233: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

Xrss9\`]X

+,-.//,�01,2,"�tA<�X>FHELE>u�aF=>�@?C�>A<�KFY=F:Y:�F:�F�s?Q<L�?@�KFY=F:EFG`G><DCF>E?G�p;;8�57�65q

���� ���� %� �1������#����� % �� ����*����!�� %����� ��������� �� ���

d1*g��""��� ���������� ���� ��"����.5550���� ��� ���� ������#����!����)

g����!�����������$� ��� %�����*����!���������%%�������"��������������� ���

!������� ���������� �#�������������� �%�����0�������� %����������#���������)

���������������"�#����"����� ����������*������� ��#���%���� ��%� "

����� ��� !����������������%�)

�%��������� ������ %�����/11`��������� %�*���������$��� ��!�������

����$��)������� � ����1������#�����% ������*���0��������� ���� ���

�0����" ����"�����������������������������������)

�����#���� %������� � ��������������� ����������� %�����2��� ���� �

�������#����$���!����������� ���� �����������"���� %����� � �$�������2

� �%����0�!�����������������#�� �������������� ������������������� ���������!���

� �$���������2��8��!���������!�����2����_�i�$ �� ���������

� �$�i1 ���d�����:)������$��� %�������������#��������������� $��2��������

�����#����� ������������ ���������������� %��������)��%� ��� %�����$ �������

�������������!���8 ��%����:������� %�����% �"���1 �����/�� �0�������� ���� $�

" ����� ��% ������2�0��$ �� ����������1 ���d������� ���� �������

1������#�����% ������*���)

�������� %��*����� ""���#����������$0������������� ���������!���

������%%������"�"����� %������ ""���#�"����������� �������#����_�����)

�������������#�% ���������������%�� �������������� �������� ����������"�"����

%������������ �� ������%���� %�����1 ���*���)

3,456�7.869.:5;<45/58�tHELE:EkXYIAYZE)�v<@?C<�FGQ�9@><C�>A<� G><CEZ�a<CE?Qp;;8�3w3�3wxq

* �%� ���� �����!���� � �$����������2���� ������" ��"�����������

���� �""��� ��a���� .70� .55.�!���� ���� � �$���� � #� ����� ���� ����� �

��%�����"������������2�� ����% ��������������� ���������!�� %�����1 ����

/�� �)��#�������"�������������������� � �$������ ������" ��"������������0

�������" ���" ������% ��������������� !������ $��!��������2� �$��2�� ��

8�&�����������%�����!#�� ����������� %���������2������������)�������

���#� %� � �$���������������1��"�0�j���"����.5;;:������� "��"���!����)

����" ����������� ������� �������� ��� ������� �$��2�� ��� ����������� �

1��"�)�����������!�����������������!� ��"��� �� !�����������������������#

���������������2���������$���� ����%�������%���� �)

Page 234: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

������#�.55,0�%���� "�������!�� ����������% ���1�������2�

��������� � � �$�0� ���������8"�"����� %����� %%�����* ���������* ����:

��� ��������2��!����� �1��"��� �����!���� $�)�/�% ������#0�� ����

��� ������������������� � �$���$ ����"�������!���� ��� �)�8������!���

�� ���#�% ������������2��!� ��� ������������������������ �%� ���� �):���

���� e�#� %�.554���$���"���� ���"��� � ���������� ������0���� ���!��� �

��$���)�1������������������� ��������������#�� �����$��)

���������� ������������� ��% ������%�����8.:�����! ��������� �� %����

*#����" ����8���������� :c�8,:� � �$���������2����� $��2������ ���

���������$�c�83:� � �$������ ��#����� �"����" ������� ���#������$�����

� ������� ���8� "�����$������1������ �#:����"�$���� ��������$���"���

!��������2��� ��������� "" ������c�89:����������������� �����*#����Q

� �$���������2������ ��$�!������ $�0������ "������� ���!�������

���������� "" �������8!��� �������%#��$�����:c�84:�8��������" ���!���%�

�������$������� ��������#):�j�" ���#������ ������#�������0� � �$����

����2�������� ��� ����� ������ ���� ���b��"�����!������� ���#���� ��� ���

�"������� ������� "�� �����% �"�� %�� �<��������8�������� "�����$�����

�����<:)

=>8,2�?<5,2.8,;<45/58�_??Z<Q�>?�yEc<�t?D<>A<C)�z?>�]G?YDA�_<Z?=CF=u>?�X<>>L<�>A<�B<?CDEFG�9HIAFJ�K?G@LE=>�p;;8�553�565q

d��� ��������� %� ����� � ��� ����� ���� �� ������ ������� � � ����%��� ���

������$ ����"��������� ��� ��$��#����$�� ��"�� ��������$��������)��������2�

������ ����������� ������#�!����������$ ����"����$������� "" �����"#0���

���������� ������ �� ����� ����� � �$���� ����#)

�������������%�� ��������"�����������"���� %������ �%�����

.) NOA P�EA�BQAB�� @�A R�BRA�BA� S��O ��OA� Q��A �QT���@B� T��UVAQ�)����

1��"�� $ ����"���� ��� ������ ��� � ����� %�!�� %����0� ��� ���� �������

$ ����"�������� �������� ��#�!������������ ���!��%��� %����� !��������)

,) NOA�WUXO@Y @�A @RRZ���QA� �� V��X�BP �� [Z���@> B�� \A��P�@ �� ��VEA

�OA�� T��UVAQ�)�' ���������0������#���������%%� %�������������� %�' �������

!������������������ ������` �� �� ��j �)�(���# ������ � �$��!�

��� ������ �&������� ������� ���� $���� ��� !������ ������� �������

��� �������!���������� �`����� ������� �� %���������2��%�!��!����

������ $��������������"������\

3) C@B] \A��P�@B� @V�� ���VV O�TA ^�� OAVT ^��Q [Z���@ SO�RO O@� B� �B�A�A��

@� @VV �B �A��VE�BP �OA R�B^V�R�)��������� %� � �$�b���!�����#�0��"2

�����������0��������% �"������� %����� � �$���1����������#��������0

Page 235: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

����#����������0�a)��)0���������$� � �$��� !���`����8� ���������

��������2:)���� ������ �$�����������2�����#����!�����$�� ������$�����

���������`�����"�����#�����������"�������������)���� ����$��

���������0�������� ���� ����� ��� ����! ���$���#�����������2���

� �$�)�' ��`����������"���" ����"� ������ �"�������������! �����

������� �����!��������#�8"�"���� %����d:���������������������2�

8��� ��:����������� �������� %���������8�2���:)

9) NOA ZBR�QT��Q���BP ��@BRA �^ �OA WUXO@Y P�EA�BQAB�������<"���� %�����

!������������ ���������������2� � �$�����"���� ���1�������f�$�

�������� %� ����1�����"���� %�* �%�������!����� ��������2� ����������

�����������������������$�� ���� %���$ ���� ����� ������������$��� ����� �

��������� ����!��������/11`�� ������)����� � �$�����$����������

��$�� ������� ���!���� � �$�� �������2�� ������� �� � ������ %� ���

����2� � �$���!�0� � �� ���� � ������ %� ����1 �����/�� �)�&����� ���

��"����!������!#0����"�����0����� ���������2����������0�!�

� ���� ������"����!���� �#��$� ���������� �����"�������! ��� ���

����2���$ ����� ����������� %��������"���)

4) NOA �B^VZAB��@V _S@� T@���A�` �B U��O NU�V��� @B� aZXOZQ���� ��� $�������

������$ ���� ������� ���������� �$�������% �"������� %���������2�a������#

%����������%%���0�!� �����������������0������������������������!����

����2��������%����#�� �"�)

���������� %���%$����! �������!�� ��������!���� � �$�����������2

��������! ��������� ��"�� �������� ����������"���� �����������������1��"�)

086,�@:,/)@A,8�rGQ<C:>FGQEGD�>A<�`G><C<:>:�?@�>A<�aFC>E<:�p;;8�x{�4{q

�������������#�% ������ � �$�������2���� $��� ���$�����#2��$���� ��

���������)������%��������������$#� %�������"����%� "��������� �� %�� ���� ����

�����"���� ���#2�������������������������������%���� %������������!���

�����������%#�"���#����������% �"���% ������%��� �<�������)������� ��

���"�������� %%�������$ ���� ���� ����)��������� ��"� ������ ���#2�����������

�����0�� �$�!����� �%������$����������0������������"#��� ������ "������

���������������������������������#� ���<����)��������� �� �������������� � $�

��#����� ��������������� "" �����������)�������� ������������������������$

%�� "������� �������� "" ������������!���������������������������� ���������

� ���� ��)

1������� $�0�� !����0����� "��������� �� ��#������������������

����������������������� %����� ���������)��������� ���������%%������ ���������

����������� ��b�� !�����������)�������� �� ��#��������#�� ��<"���� � �$��

Page 236: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

�������2����������0������ ��� ��� %������<���������������� ����)��������

� ������#����)�' ���������0�����������&�������� !����!� ������ ���������

*���� ��� ������ � ��������� ��� ��� ��������� �����#0� `���� ��

� ������� �#��� � "������� ������������������������� ����������� ��� ��������)

`���� %������������ ������� %����������0��������� ��������������� �� �����)

������������#����� %�`���b��� �������!������$���� �� �����������2���

� �$���������)

����������� ������ ������������!��������� ���#� %�������������� ��� ��������0

���� �������#� %� ���������� ��� � �� ����0� ��� ������ ��� � �� � ������ ���!���

� "���������% ���$�����������)������% ���������� ���� $��� ��$��������������

��$ ���������� �� ���������)����� ��������������� � �! ��� ������������$

������ !�� ���������0� ����� ���$� �������� ��� _���%���� �� % �� ������ ��� ��

���������)

����2�b��"������ �����������������������#����������������� �� %

����2� �������#� ��� �����)������% ��� ���� � ���#� �� ��� ��� � � ������ ���

�������b������������� �"�������������� "���<�$� � �������� ����� ��)����

�������������� %�������� ���������������� �����$��������"����������� ����#0

��� ����� �� ������ ��� � ������� ��" ������ �������� ��� ���� $������ ���

��$���� %��������2���)������<���������������� �����������%��������"���� %

���� � �$�������2�� �%������������2�b���������������$��� ��������

! ����� ""���#)

d��� ��#� � ��� ����2�� ��� � �$�� ���� � � "" �� ��������� ��

�������$� ���� � �%����� ��� ������$� � �#�������� %� � ������� ��� � ���

$������� ���� !���� ������ ����� ��� ������#)� ��� � � "������� ��� ���

���������� %������ ���$���" �������������� ������������� ����#)�d��#������

"������ ��� ������ ���� � ����� ��� ��� ����2�� ��� � �$�� % �

$�������$��"����$���0�!���������������#�� �"����� $����� �������

���� � �#� ���"����� �����)�d��� ������ ���"� ��� ���� %� ���� ��%$���0

!���������� ������������ %�� ���������)

���0��%�����2���� � �$�������#����������������� ����b�����������

���%�������"#����� �������� ���� ��������������%%�������)������#���� %����

���������� %�� ����������!��������������"����� "����������� "" �����������

�������������� ������������"�� ��� ��)

BC9,8�DE.8.:,F,G�=,9,�H<,-585;<45/58�B<?CDEFk9HIAFJEF)� `Q<G>E>u� `::Y<:p;;8�{3�|}q

����2��������#��<������������ ���� ��"�����!������������ ���)��� ������

� �$��� �� ��!���� ��������������)�&������ ������������������������ ����

����2�)� ���� � ���� ��� ���� ������� �������#� � ��� � �� ������� �� ���� ����

�$"����� �0�������� ���� ���$�!� ���������������" �"�����������)�����

Page 237: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

���� �������� ���� "����� � �$����� �"������������ ���"� ��#�����2�

"�$������ �����2���������.6���.7������������8!�����"��������� ���"� ��#

����2����� ������ ��$��������2:����� "���������2�� ������������������

���#���������������������������������� ������"��)

��� <����#0����� ������$"����� �����������2���� � �$����$����

���� ���������������"����"��� ����������"�� $���������������% ��������"

� �������� ��������������!���������"��"������#)� � �$�����������2�����#

��������� ������$"����� �)����� ��#���%%��������������� � � �$��������2�

�������� ������� ������ %� � �$������ �����2�������������������������#

������"�����$������ $� ���������� �#������������������"� %� � �$����"�����

"���� ��)

��������2����"��0�d��$�j"���0����������������� ������ �%����!��

� �$���������2���������� "" ���������������#�� �� ��!����������*���

� ���<�)�&��� ���*���� �������#� � � ��������$��� ���"� ��#� � �$��\�

` $��#�������$0�*�����������#�� �� � �$������������� %�����$�� �������

� �����������������0�������������� %���� �����������8�����0�"�������0

��������% ��������0����):0�������������������#�����%�����0�������0������������

%�����%������������������������ � ���������#)

��� ����$�� �d��$�j"���0�����2������������*�����������#����#

���� ��#0����� ���� �������������������������)�/������� ���"� ��#� � �$���0

��������2���������������������#������ % ������$� �����$��%�����)

��� ��� �"� ������� � � %������ "" �� �������#� ��������� % ������$� ��

��$��%������ � � � ��� ��������2� ��� � �$���)����� ���� ����������2� ��

� �$�������!��������������"�Q������� �#)

I5:51J�K<56,;<./58�tA<�X>FHELE>u�aF=>�@?C�>A<�KFY=F:Y:�p;;8�|�3wq

������ ��� %����������$��_���%���#����� ��� %�����"���� ����� ��� %

� ������� �������#� ��� ���� ��$� �� ��� �� � "��� �������#0� ���� ��0� �� � "��

����� �"���)�������������#0�� !����0���������g� ����/�� ��!������ ��������

�������#��� � "�����������0���������#�����������*����� �������!����� �

����"������� �����/�� �������������%���)

��������� ��� %� ��������� ���� �0� ��� ����� � ���������������������� ���

� ������� %� ����*����!���� ���� � � ����� �� �� ����$� � � ���� ����������

������������#�������" ������! ����� ""���#���&������ �� ���� ������/�����

1������ �������������#� ������_�����!����)����������������������!������ !�

���!���� � �� ��������� �#� ���� 1������#� ���� % �� ����*���)� ���#� ���

$�������$��"����$���0�"�� ���#���$���0�������$�� ����� ���% ����������%�

� �<�������� %���%%������� ""������0���" �������������������$ ����"����0

�������������#� %�������������� ��0�"<�""���$���� %�� ������%�$ ����"���

!����"���""������%�������%� "������������$ ����"������������������ �� %

Page 238: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

���

_�������� ��0�������#""�������"������������������)��������� %��������

���������������� �������������������������������������������������$���� �"���

��������������"������ �������� � ����������)

������"���$�� ������������������������������"������#��������������

% ���$��"��������� %�����*����� �������� �%��"��$����������������� ����

����������� %�����������" ���#)����������%��������b���� �������#������������

����"����)

����!������ ���� %� ���� � �"���� ��� � �� ����" ��� ���%�� ��_���� Q

�"����������������� ���� �������)����� �� ��� � �� ��"��� �#���������� ��

���!��������2�0��_��0��������������e������)���������������!�������

��%%����������"����������������%%��������� ����)

�������� %�*��������$��� ��"#����"�������$0���� ��� ������

���������#�� ���� ���������������% ��%���������������0�� "�����$��������#

����% $���� �����% �����������#���)���������� ��������%����_���)

02.;,/JC�L.A;,F,8�9C<�`G><CEZ�s?Q<L:�?@�X<>>L<Z<G>�O<F:EHL<l�p;;8�3}x�3|6q

.) ��# ���!� �������� ������ ��" �����"���������� ��������%��������#)

j���� ���$�" ��������� ����������#���%%����)�* "��������<��������

�<����������� ������������������ %�$�������$���� ���� � ����% �

������"���� ��� � �<�������)� ���� ���������� ����� �� ��� ���� ���� %

����2�����!��������#��� � ����������"���"������ �������!������

������� �������� �������������������#)��������������#�� ���������%�"�! ��

% ���������"���0�� �� ��#������ ����� %� ����$���"���)���� �����������#

���������$��� %������� ��������������#����������������������$� ���

����������� ����� ������!��������"����������� ������ ��" ����)������

�������#�� ������� ���#��� " ���$���������� �� %����������" ����0

� � ���#� ���� !���� ��� �� ���� ����� %� ����� ��� ���!���� � �$�� ��

����2�)�&��� �� ����0� �#� �� � ��� % �� ������"���� ��� � �<�������

!�������� ����� �"�����!� ������ ���������������%����"������������������

��������� %�� ��������)

,) � �������������0��<������������������������ %�������������� � �$����

���2��"���%�����"������"�% ��$�������$��" ����% ��������"���)������

�������#� � � ��������� ��� ����� % ������� ���$���$���"���0� ��� ����

����!����$����#������ �����$ �)

3) * �� ���� ��������������" ����% ��� �����������"�����%����$���"���)

9) &�������" �������� ��������!��������� �����"���"�����)��������������

��#��%���������������������� %�"���$�����"���"�����$�������� �)

Page 239: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��

4) 1������ ������0� � ���0� ��� �!���% ���"���� ��������� ��� ��� ��������

!��������������������� ��� ������� "���������� ���$�������!������

�������#)

6) ���������� � ���� ����������� ���� ����������� %�������"������ � ���

���" �����������������#���������% ������%����� ��� ��)����������"

" ���� � ��� � ������ %� � � "����� �� %� ����" ��� ��� ��� ��� %������

���"����� %� �<�����$� �� � ���0� ���� � "����!��� � ���� ���� ���� ���

�� ��� ���� ������� ��������)���� ���� � � �� � "��� ����� ��� ��� ���

� ""����� ��� ������� ������"����)

F�@EZ�CK�B^0���4����UTP@>���kKME�@AE��B>���>��C�@D

HE@�H��I� �K?EV�E@?D�� HE>C�H�t��B�U� =�M���

�=K�KJKLK��UK�0� G�VB?���U�� ��� >E�lK�K�NBB� �

FE�EAKK�K0�AUC�ETPACB>E����@�TEJK?E����qE>C�H��K

G�VB?U��C@I����>E�lK�K�NBB)�

zKH�>NBI�T�B�E@B?���?E�P�@�EB�BG�B�K�BI)

Page 240: Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

��