35
Alain L. Kornhauser, PhD Professor, Operations Research & Financial Engineering Director, Program in Transportation Faculty Advisor, Princeton Autonomous Vehicle Engineering (PAVE) Founder, ALK Technologies, Inc. Chairman, Advanced TRansit Association (ATRA) and Vice Chairman, New Jersey Commission on Science and Technology (inactive) Historic Preservation of the Dinky in both Function and Form

Historic Preservation of the Dinky in both Function and Form

  • Upload
    evonne

  • View
    37

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Historic Preservation of the Dinky in both Function and Form. Alain L. Kornhauser, PhD Professor, Operations Research & Financial Engineering Director, Program in Transportation Faculty Advisor, Princeton Autonomous Vehicle Engineering (PAVE) Founder, ALK Technologies, Inc. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Alain L. Kornhauser, PhDProfessor, Operations Research & Financial Engineering

Director, Program in TransportationFaculty Advisor, Princeton Autonomous Vehicle Engineering (PAVE)

Founder, ALK Technologies, Inc.

Chairman, Advanced TRansit Association (ATRA)and

Vice Chairman, New Jersey Commission on Science and Technology (inactive)

Historic Preservation of the Dinky in both

Function and Form

Page 2: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Purpose of Historical Preservation

• Preserve the Function and Form of Historically Important elements of the Built Environment.

• Dinky: – Functioning since 1865– Current Form since about 1915– Station moved in about 1986 to current location

Page 3: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Purpose of Historical Preservation

• Preserve the Function and Form of Historically Important elements of the Built Environment.

• Dinky: – Functioning since 1865

Page 4: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Function Endangered?

Only if Moved Away from “Nassau Street”

Page 5: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Princeton – Princeton Jct. (2.7 Miles)

Location !, Location !, Location! 12

,000

Res

iden

ts (B

oro)

10,0

00 S

tude

nts (

PU, S

emin

ary,

Rid

er)

30,0

00 Jo

bs (B

oro

+ Tw

nshp

; Cen

sus)

Access to the World

Page 6: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Station Moved Twice

Page 7: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form
Page 8: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

50% Walk & Ride ~500 patrons/day

43/150 Solid Top 30%

Page 9: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Grade CrossingsFaculty Road, Princeton Junction

Page 10: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form
Page 11: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form
Page 12: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form
Page 13: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form
Page 14: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form
Page 15: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form
Page 16: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Pre-1985 to Present Terminus~185 feet

http://www.daftlogic.com/projects-google-maps-distance-calculator.htm

Page 17: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form
Page 18: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Princeton – Princeton Jct. (2.7 Miles)

Location !, Location !, Location! 12

,000

Res

iden

ts (B

oro)

10,0

00 S

tude

nts (

PU, S

emin

ary,

Rid

er)

30,0

00 Jo

bs (B

oro

+ Tw

nshp

; Cen

sus)

Page 19: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Area around the Dinky Station

Dinky Station Parking

Garage

Faculty Road

Alexander Road

Arts District

Page 20: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

The Conflict

February 16, 2010

This would be the 3rd time the station has moved towards The junction.

Definitions

Page 21: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

It then 2st moved 170 feet to create better E-W mobility for Forbes Student

from: the end of the platform, to: the Freight Building

The Conflict Arises from the current 3rd attempt at a Dinky Land Grab Land Grab

Page 22: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Walk&Ride Accessibility Lost by Moving the Dinky Terminus South

Assumptions:1. All walk in a straight line to the station2. All Walk&Ride trips production/attraction are

uniformly distributed in the half plane north of the current terminus.

3. Walk&Ride Area Lost =~ R*D*(2*cos q + sin q ) where R = prime walk distance

D = Distance Terminus moved (460 ft)q = sin-1 (D/R)

Page 23: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

¼ Walk&Ride Service Areas49% Prime Walk&Ride Area Lost http://www.daftlogic.com/projects-google-maps-distance-calculator.htm

Nothing is gained to the south to off-set the losses to the north

http://www.daftlogic.com/projects-google-maps-distance-calculator.htm

¼ Mile Walk&Ride Accessibility Analysishttp://www.daftlogic.com/projects-google-maps-distance-calculator.htm

Page 24: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

1/2 Walk&Ride Service Areas24% Prime Walk&Ride Area Losthttp://www.daftlogic.com/projects-google-maps-distance-calculator.htm

Nothing is gained to the south to off-set the losses to the north

http://www.daftlogic.com/projects-google-maps-distance-calculator.htm

1/2 Mile Walk&Ride Accessibility Analysishttp://www.daftlogic.com/projects-google-maps-distance-calculator.htm

Page 25: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Conclusions: Walk&Ride Accessibility Analysis

• 49% loss of ¼ mile prime walking area implies loss of Walk&Riders could be as high as 49% and a 25% loss of Dinky ridership.

•24% loss of ½ mile walking area implies at least a 24% loss of Walk&Riders and at least a 13% loss of Dinky ridership

Page 26: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Congestion @ Alexander & University Place

Page 27: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Flow Pattern @ Alexander & University Pl.

Page 28: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Minimal Conflicts;Readily Accommodates Pedestrians

Page 29: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Endangered?

Page 30: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

50% Walk & Ride ~500 patrons/day

43/150 Solid Top 30%

Page 31: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Preferred Dinky Terminus

Page 32: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Kiss

&Ri

de

FreeB, taxi~10

62

32

25

26

~7

On-street: ~100Small lot: ~62Commute Lot : ~150Total: ~340Yield: ~375 Boarders/day; ~680 McCarter Patrons

62 Baker surface lot ~150

(Commuter Lot)178

(Each Floor of Lot 7)

Existing Dinky Parking

Dinky / McCarter Parking

Page 33: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

Area around the Dinky Station

Dinky Station Parking

Garage

Faculty Road

Alexander Road

Arts District

Page 34: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

The Conflict

February 16, 2010

This would be the 3rd time the station has moved towards The junction.

Definitions

Page 35: Historic Preservation of the Dinky  in both  Function  and Form

The Dinky