10
1 J R C I s p r a HERACLES: The Myth and the Research a promising future: Born mortal, he became immortal beloved or enemy of HERA? He served Eurysteus for twelve years and performed twelve LABOURS He killed the Lernean Hydra In one day he carried out the dung from the Augea’s stables! He had soon an Italian nickname: Ercules HERACLES HERACLES H H UMAN HEALTH AND UMAN HEALTH AND E E COLOGICAL COLOGICAL R R ISK ISK A A SSESSMENT SSESSMENT FOR FOR C C ONTAMINATED ONTAMINATED L L AND AND IN IN E E U MEMBER U MEMBER S S TATES TATES towards the development of European common references Claudio Carlon, Marco D’Alessandro, Stefan Sommer

HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

1JRC – Ispra

HERACLES: The Myth and the Research

a promising future: Born mortal, he became immortal

beloved or enemy of HERA?

He served Eurysteus for twelve years and performed twelve LABOURS

He killedthe Lernean Hydra

In one day he carried outthe dung from the Augea’s stables!

He had soon an Italian nickname: Ercules

HERACLESHERACLESHHUMAN HEALTH AND UMAN HEALTH AND EECOLOGICALCOLOGICAL

RRISK ISK AASSESSMENT SSESSMENT FOR FOR CCONTAMINATED ONTAMINATED LLAND AND

IN IN EEU MEMBER U MEMBER SSTATESTATES

towards the development of European common references

Claudio Carlon, Marco D’Alessandro, Stefan Sommer

Page 2: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

2JRC – Ispra

Organization orpatronage of events:Workshops, trainings

.. etc.

Organization orpatronage of events:Workshops, trainings

.. etc.

Pilot projectExpert consultation Collection of relevant information fromMember States

Page 3: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

3JRC – Ispra

PreliminaryR.A.

ScreeningR.A.

SiteSpecific

R.A.

RegionalR.A.

Regi

onal

sca

leLo

cal

Sca

le

EEARemoteSensing

Pilot Project on human health and ecological R.A. at site specific scale

Objective 1:demostration and methodologicalimplementation of a multi-criteriabased risk ranking of contaminatedlands and mining sites

Objective 2:evaluation of the impact of differentguideline values on the development of regional inventories and remediationplans

Levels ofassessment

Pilot project

Comparison of GuidanceValues

PreliminaryR.A.

ScreeningR.A.

SiteSpecific

R.A.

Levels ofassessment

RegionalR.A.

EEARemoteSensing

Pilot Project on human health and ecological R.A. at site specific scale

Pilot project

Comparison of GuidanceValues

To be planned

Page 4: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

4JRC – Ispra

EEAPRAMS

TASK 1MCA Risk ranking

Metod implementation

TASK 4Remote sensing

integration

TASK 3 Impact of different

guideline valuesTASK 2

Spatial Resolution

Page 5: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

5JRC – Ispra

Overviewweighting systems

Uncertaintyanalysis

Sourcescharacterization

EEAPRAMS

1) Expert judgement interpretation, e.g. AHP

2) Sensitivity analysis1) Categorization2) Multiple contaminants

1) e.g. Fuzzy analysis; Bayesian statistics.2) Operational interpretation

Page 6: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

6JRC – Ispra

Risk zoning andcumulative risk

G.I.S.integration

Surface water and groundwatersimplified model

Application

Methodological Implementation

Definition ofimpact areas

-Digital river network;-Digital elevation model;-Soil data;-Landcover/Landuse;-Meteorological data.

Page 7: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

7JRC – Ispra

Application

Methodological Implementation

Review of guidance values:assumpions, modelling,application and values;

reasons for differences

Evaluation of impacts of different approaches:- LCA approach- costs; land use limitation; natural resource depletion; environmental protection; short-term/long-term

Comparison of resultsin setting inventories and

remediation plans at regional scale

Page 8: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

8JRC – Ispra

Integration in unidimensional risk ranking

Anomalies detection

Application

Methodological Implementation

Integration in spatial risk assessmentProxi data

Proxi data

1) Identification of mining sites;2) Boundaries of impact areas

REMOTE SENSING ANOMALIES REMOTE SENSING ANOMALIES DETECTED AND MAPPED IN SLOVAKIADETECTED AND MAPPED IN SLOVAKIA

Page 9: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

9JRC – Ispra

Page 10: HERACLES: The Myth and the Research HERACLES · 2008-02-21 · HERACLES HUMAN HEALTH AND ECOLOGICAL RISK ASSESSMENT FOR CONTAMINATED LAND IN EU MEMBER STATES towards the development

10JRC – Ispra

Pilot Project

Integration of results of EU funded

research projects

Web-siteManagement

Expert advisorycommittee

Organization orpatronage of events:Workshops, trainings

.. etc.

Collection of relevant information

from Member States