48
H H I I E E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games (with Entry/Exit Examples) by Ariel Pakes, Michael Ostrovsky And Steve Berry May 2004 Harvard University Cambridge, Massachusetts This paper can be downloaded without charge from: http://post.economics.harvard.edu/hier/2004papers/2004list.html The Social Science Research Network Electronic Paper Collection: http://ssrn.com/abstract=566864

Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

HH II EE RR

Harvard Institute of Economic Research

Discussion Paper Number 2036

Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

(with Entry/Exit Examples)

by

Ariel Pakes, Michael Ostrovsky And Steve Berry

May 2004

Harvard University

Cambridge, Massachusetts

This paper can be downloaded without charge from: http://post.economics.harvard.edu/hier/2004papers/2004list.html

The Social Science Research Network Electronic Paper Collection:

http://ssrn.com/abstract=566864

Page 2: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

����� ���� ��� ���� �� ������������� ���� ������� � �! ��"���#�$�&%'���()���! *�%,+.-���� �( /'� � �"�

021 �3 �� �-4 ���+65 879�3 :87.��� ����"�<;>=@?A<B

C8D@EGF�H�I9J�K<FMLON�P EGQSRTJ�F>HVUWL2XYD[Z>\]LYK_^`NaJ�bTced_XYFf\gF&hiFMD[Dj^`Nkml9nporqpnpotsvu.w�xyqfz2ot{|xy}~O��l9nporqpnpots�u.w�xyqfz2ot{tx�}~8npw�s���np��z�u9w�x�qfz2o�{|x�}~����

km�"x�ot{�}Vs�o�np��}Y���O��w�zi�S�O�M�>��}���x�{4s�o�np��}��&nY~��p���p�����

� �p�����3�2 r�¡�¢¤£¦¥�§2¨�§j©«ª�¬®­|¯¤¥G£±°¤©«ª²¥�³G¢¤©´§¤ª²­rµ2¶·©�¸¹­rº)©�¥�³G£±¸»¨�³G£¦¯�¼.³G¢�©V°¤£¦¥�³�ª²£·µ2½¤³G£·­|¯�­rº]§2¨�¾r­�¿j¥À£¦¯Á¨°¤£±¥G¬®ª²©«³�©T°¤¾Â¯¤¨r¸�£±¬!¼|¨r¸"©rÃSºÄ­Â¬«½2¥G£±¯�¼�­|¯V¸"­�°�©�¶±¥ÆÅ`¢¤©«ªG©T³G¢�©"¼r­|¨r¶M£±¥Æ³�­�¶±©�¨�ª²¯V¨�µj­|½�³Æ³G¢�©»°¤£±¥Èdz�ª²£·µ2½¤³G£·­|¯�­rº_ɤª²¸»¥�Êf©�¯t³�ªG¾6¨r¯2°6©®Ë�£·³a¬®­|¥�³G¥�Ìi¡�¢�©�£±°¤©�¨�£±¥»³�­9µj©«¼|£±¯�Å`£·³G¢�¯�­|¯6§2¨�ªÍ¨r¸"©«³�ª²£±¬É¤ª²¥�³Î¥G³G¨�¼r©»©�¥�³G£±¸»¨�³�©�¥]­rº�©�¯t³�ªG¾V¨r¯¤°V¬®­|¯�³G£±¯Â½¤¨�³G£·­|¯.Ϩr¶±½¤©�¥Æ­rµ¤³G¨r£±¯�©�°VµÂ¾4¬®­|¸"§2½�³G£±¯¤¼$¥G¨r¸"§2¶·©¨�Ïr©«ª²¨�¼r©�¥Î­rºM³G¢�©]ª²©�¨r¶±£·Ð«©�°Ñ¬®­|¯t³G£±¯Â½¤¨�³G£·­|¯´Ï�¨r¶±½�©�¥<­rºM©�¯t³�ªÍ¨r¯t³G¥gÅ`¢�­ °�­ ©�¯t³�©«ª_¨r¯¤°Ñ£±¯¤¬«½¤¸)µj©�¯t³G¥Å`¢�­$°�­$¬®­|¯�³G£±¯Â½�©rÌ�Òg¯¤°�©«ªÎ¬®©«ªG³G¨r£¦¯.¨r¥G¥G½2¸"§¤³G£·­|¯¤¥g³G¢�©�¥G©»Ï¨r¶¦½�©�¥Î¨�ªG©�¶¦£±¯�©�¨�ªÆºÄ½2¯¤¬®³G£·­|¯¤¥Æ­rº�³G¢�©§2¨�ª²¨r¸"©«³�©«ªÍ¥»­rºÆ³G¢�©$§¤ª²­rµ2¶·©�¸ÀÃ*¨r¯¤°6¢�©�¯¤¬®©´¨�ªG©�¯�­r³�¬®­|¸»§2½�³G¨�³G£·­|¯¤¨r¶¦¶·¾.µ2½¤ª²°�©�¯¤¥�­|¸»©À³�­.½¤¥�©rÌÓ ³�³�©�¯t³G£±­|¯a£±¥M¼|£·Ïr©�¯»³�­)³G¢�©`¥G¸»¨r¶¦¶¤¥G¨r¸"§2¶±©�§¤ªG­rµ2¶·©�¸Ô­rº[©�¥G³G£±¸»¨�³G£·­|¯"©«ª²ªG­rª>£±¯»³G¢�©`¯�­|¯"§Õ¨�ª²¨r¸"©«³ÈǪ²£±¬]©�¥�³G£±¸»¨�³�©�¥Æ¨r¯¤°´³G¢¤£±¥<¶·©�¨r°¤¥<³�­ ¨a§¤ªG©«ºÄ©«ªG©�¯¤¬®©!ºÖ­rªÆ½¤¥�©)­rºM§2¨�ªG³G£¦¬«½¤¶±¨�ª²¶·¾�¥G£±¸»§2¶·©Î©�¥�³G£¦¸»¨�³�©�¥g­rº¬®­|¯t³G£¦¯�½¤¨�³G£±­|¯ÀϨr¶¦½�©�¥�¨r¯¤°$¸»­|¸"©�¯t³G¥�Ì

×�ØaÙ*ÚÜÛtÝ�Þ|ßÎà3á�ÛtÞ)â�ã�ß�ÙÍäÍå�æ[Ý«ÚfçOÝ®è�ÙÍäÍåé2Ý�ÞtêëÙÍäOç�ÙÍÞ|ß«Ý�äÈì�å�í�Ý�ä�è)îpÛ�Ý�ï`ðÂÙ²äÜñòÝ�êóÞ¤åà3ÙGô�õ>á�ïÆêóÞ|êëÚ�ö�å|ç�á«èÝ�ÞÎà3á«÷®Ý�Þ|á«÷�êóø�åàÝ�øÈßÎæjá�ä�Ú�ÙÍäÍårÝ�Þtì)ùOÛ�Ý�ÞtÝ3ãyêòãMúÚ�ÙÍÞ|û�áã�ü±á�äfÛ|ÙÍñëý|ü±þ|ñ¤äÜÙ²ï_Ý�äÜßrã�Ý�Þtì]Ú�Û|Ù�ÿ*ú��$ü±á3ä��tÞtÝ�ÞtøGêòÝ�ñ¤ã�þ|ý|ýÂá�ä�Ú��=

Page 3: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

������������ ��������������� �����������! "���#���$%�&��� ��'�)(*�� �+��,-��.(�/102���3�4+$56���7� -89 ����-�: "��;<� >=@?A�4+��B�C%�EDF ����#��GH I;H/J=F��0�KL�:�&�G1!MN��I��/O8

P�QHRTSVUXWIU�Y[ZV\HY^]IY[_T`IUHS"Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4RT`IeLS�a4Z4W>a4Y[fIRTY[SVgXWISbY[\�`�eha4QHY)SbaiZijHkla4jHZbY*`Imn\HRdSik^ZiY^aiY*\po%eXWIcqRTkf�WIcqY[S^rFsX`�ZtYuW,SiYq`Im:Y&v-U1`�SbRdaiRT`�e�w1x:YqUHZiY^SiY^e�a@WI_d_B`�jHZyZbY[Sijp_da4SyRde*a4QHYFk[`Ie�aiYlv%a�`Im:`IeHY�YlvpWIcqUH_TY,zyW\po%eXWIcqRTk�f�WIcVY�`,m2Y[e�aiZbo.WIeH\.Ylv-R{aurq|}e~WI\p\HRdaiRT`�e*ai`)R{a4SnRTcqU�`�Zba4WIeHk[Y�ai`�RTeH\HjpSba4ZbR�WI_B`�Zif�W,eHRT�[W,a4Rd`�e�wa4QpY�Y[e�a4Z�oH�>Ylv-RdayY&vHW,cVUH_dY�RT_d_TjHS�a4ZiW,a4Y^S�Z4W>a4QHY^Z�x:Y^_T_��bjpSbatx�Q�o*x�YFeHY[Y^\!aiQHY[SbYFY[SbaiRTcVW,a4Rd`�e�S�a4ZiW,a4Y^f�RTY^SWIeH\�a4QpYEcVW#�b`�Z:UHZi`�gp_TY[cqS2a4QHW,a�WIZiRdSiYyRTe�\pY^]�Y^_T`�UpRTeHfFa4QHY^c)r

|}eLUHWIZbaiRTk[jp_�WIZ^w�a4QH`�jpf�QhaiQHY�SijHep��k[`�S�a4Sq`Im�Y[e�a4Z�o3WIeH\3a4QHY�SbY[_T_:`I��],WI_TjpY[SN�`IZ�k[`�S�a4S��FWISbSi`%k[R{�W,aiY[\!x�Rda4Q.Ylv-R{a@W,ZiYF�IYlo�\pY^a4Y^ZicqRTeXW,e�aiSy`Im�aiQHYq\po%eXWIcqRTk[Sy`Im�cVWIZi�,Y^a�WI\>�bjHS�a4cqY[e�a4Sya4`NU�`�_TRdk^o�W,eH\Y[e�]%RTZb`�eHcqY[e�a�W,_�k�QXW,eHf�Y[S^w<\XW>a�W"`�eNa4QHY^SiY�SbjHeH�Nk[`�S�a4S�WIZiY�c�jHk�Q*QXW,Zi\HY^Z�a4`q�XeH\�aiQXWIe*\HW,a�Wq`�e�a4QpY\HYla4Y[ZbcVRdeXWIe�a4S�`ImBk[jHZbZiY[e�anUpZi`I�HaiSi�'r2��StWFZiY^SijH_{a�x�Y@QXWu]IY@a4`qRTepm�Y^Z�aiQHYEYlv%a4Y^e�a�`Im�SbjHeH��k[`�S�a4S�m�Zi`�c`IaiQHY[Z2],WIZbR�WIgH_dY[S:x�Qp`�SiYyg�Y[QXWu]%RT`�Z�\pY[U�Y[eH\HS�`�e�aiQHY[cNr�P�QHYn],WIZiRTWIgH_TY�a4QXW>a�RTS�cq`�Sba�\pRTZiY^k^ai_doVZiY[_TW,a4Y^\a4`ya4QpY�k^`�SbaiS�`,m<Y^e�aiZboFRdS�Y^e�a4ZboFR{a4SbY[_dm�rOPO`�jHSbY�aiQHY�k[`�eHepY[k^aiRT`�eqg�Y^a}x�Y[Y[e6WIk^aijXWI_XY[e�aiZboqWIeH\Fa4QpY�k^`�SbaiS`Im1Y[e�a4Z�oqRTeFY[S�a4RTcVW,aiRT`�e�x�Y�epY[Y[\"Wtm�Z4WIcqY^x�`�Zi��x�QHRTk�Q"WI_T_d`#x�S�jpS�ai`�k^`�cqUHjpa4Y�aiQHY�]IW,_TjHY�`Im<Y[e�a4Y^ZiRdeHf�SbRTcqRT_TWIZi_{o�w'a4`ycVWI�IY�jHSbY�`,m1aiQHY�ZiY^_�W,aiRT`�eHSbQHRTU�g�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e"SbY[_T_p`I�6],WI_TjpY[S�WIeH\qYlv-R{auw�x�Y�epY[Y[\Fa4`yg�Y�WIgH_TYa4`@kuWI_dk[jH_TW,a4Y�a4QHY�]IW,_TjHY�`Im�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jHRdeHf��lrBP�QH`�jHf�Q�SbjHk�Q�m�Z4WIcqY^x�`�Zb�%S:QXWu]�Yng�Y[Y[e�Wu],WIRd_�WIgH_dY2m�`�Z:Sb`�cqYa4RdcVYV��YIr�fHrdw<��ZiRTk^Si`�e*WIeH\���WI�IY^S[w ='����� �lwXa4QpY[RTZ�RTcqUH_dRTkuW>a4RT`IeHS2kuW,e�eH`Ia�g1Y�jHSiY^\�\HRTZbY[k^ai_do�Rde*Y[S�a4RTcVW>�a4Rd`�e"x�R{a4QH`�j-a�Y[eHk^`�jHe�a4Y^ZiRdeHf�SijHgpSba�W,e�aiR�WI_<k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_JUHZb`�gH_TY^cVSn��x�RdaiQ6k[jpZiZiY^e�a�k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_WIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^S�aiQHY[SbYEUpZi`�gH_dY[cqS�WIZiYy`Im�aiY[e�RTepSijHZbcV`�jpe�a4WIgH_dY'��r

��S�W*k^`�eHSbY[��jHY[epk[Y�a4QHY"cV`%\HY[_dS�aiQXW,a�QHW']IY�g1Y^Y[e jHSbY[\ a4`*WIeXWI_{o-�^Y"Y^e�aiZbo�WIeH\ Ylv-R{a�\HY^k[RTSbRT`�epSRTeha4QHY)UXWIS�a6QXWu]�Y*WI_T_�g�Y[Y[eLa}x:`,�¡U1Y^ZiRd`-\LcV`%\HY[_dS[¢�SiY^Y�£:ZiY^SieXW,QXWIe$WIeH\¥¤�Y^RTSbS�� =u��¦�§ W,eH\ ='���Õ= �lw£:Y^ZiZbo3� ='����¨ �lwCWIep\�cq`�ZiY�ZbY[k^Y[e�a4_{o�w�©�WI�^�[Y[`�� ¨IªIª�¨ ��WIep\�«-Y^RTc¬� ¨Iª�ª�¨ �lr�P2x�`,�}U�Y[ZbRT`%\!cV`%\HY[_dSnWIZbYY[SbSiY^e�aiR�WI_d_dohSba4W,a4Rdk*WIep\7WISiSbjHcqY�Wux2Wuo�SbjHeH�Lk[`�S�a4S[r­��WIZbai_doLWIS�W�ZiY[SbjH_daVa4QHY�Y[cqUHRTZbRTkuW,_2x:`�Zb�¥Rdea4QpY[SiYVUXWIU�Y[ZbS@Sba4Wuo�Y[\3Wux:Wuo�m�Zb`�c®YlvpWIcqRTeHRdeHf�a4QHYVRTcqUXWIkla4Sy`Im�U�`�_TRdk^o�`�Z�Y^e�]-RdZi`�epcVY^e�a4WI_�k�QXWIeHf�Y^S`�e!a4QHYFS�a4Zijpk^a4jpZiYF`Im�W�f�R{]�Y^e�RdeH\HjHS�a4Zbo*`#]IY[Zna4RdcVY,w�m�`-k^jHSiRdeHf�RTeHS�a4Y[WI\!`�e�UpZi`']%RT\HRdeHfNW�m�ZiWIcqY^x�`�Zi�m�`�Z�k�QXWIZ4W,k^a4Y^ZiRd�[RTepf@\HR{�<Y^ZiY[epk[Y[S�RdeVaiQHYte�jHc�g�Y[Z�`ImOWIk^aiRd]IY��XZbcVS:WIk[Zb`�SiS�W�k[Zi`ISiS2SbY[k^aiRT`�e�`,m�c"W,Zi�IYla4S^r©)`�ZbYt\HYla�WIRd_TY[\6WIeXWI_{o-SbRTS�`ImCY[e�]%RTZb`�eHcqY[e�a�WI_1`�Z:U�`�_dRTk^oqRdSiSijpY[S[wpS4Wuo6`Im�aiQHYt_dRT�IY^_doqY^�1Y[kla4S�`ImOW�cVY^Zif�Y^Z`�e�SijHgHSbY[��jHY^e�aFY^e�a4Zbo.`�Zy`Im2W)k�QXW,eHf�Y"Rde�U�Y[epSiRT`Ie�`�ZEQHY[WI_daiQ�k[WIZiYqZijH_dY[SE`�e~Y&v-RdauwOZiY^��jHRTZbY[\�cq`�ZiY\HYla�WIRd_�`�e�SijHep��k[`�S�a4S�WIeH\NQH`'x¯�XZbcVS�ZbYuWIkla�ai`�a4QHY^c)r°ÍùOÛ|Ù�ìrÙmøGêòãyêóá�Þ_á�ü¤Ý �täÜï�á�Þ�±fÛtÙGÚ�ÛtÙ²ä@ÚÜá�Ù�²rêëÚSêòãSìrÙ²Ú�Ù²äÜïÆêëÞtÙÍìÆð�è�±fÛtÙGÚ�ÛtÙ²äSêëÚÜãpøGá3Þ3ÚÜêëÞ�þtÝ�Ú�êóá�ÞÆ÷«Ý�ñóþ|ÙMêòã@û3ä�ÙmÝ«Ú�ÙÍäjÚ�ÛtÝ�ÞêëÚÜãSã�Ù²ñóñ|á�ô)÷«Ý�ñóþ|Ù�åÝ�ÞtìgÚÜÛ|ÙMñòÝ«Ú�Ú�Ù²äSêóã[á�ü·Ú�ÙÍÞÎÝ�ãÜãyárøGêòÝ«ÚÜÙÍì�±fê ÚÜÛÆü¦Ý�øGÚ�á�äÈã@Ý3ã[ÛtÝ�äÈì<Ú�á�ïÆÙÍÝ3ãyþtä�ÙMÝ3ã�³yû3áárì'±fêóñóñµ´tå«Ú�Û|Ù�÷®Ý�ñëþtÙfá�üÚ�ÛtÙ �tä�ït¶ ãOð|þ|êóñóì|êëÞ|ûÎÝ�Þtì)Ùb·þ|êóý|ïÆÙ²ÞÚMêëÞTêëÚÜã�³ÜãyÙmøGá3ÞtìÎðÂÙÍãyÚ¸´_Ý�ñ ÚÜÙ²äÜÞtÝ«ÚÜêë÷3Ù>ÙÍïgýtñëá«è�ïÆÙ²ÞÚÍå|Ý�Þtì,¹«á�äføGñóÙÍÝ�Þ'ºÄþtý!ø²á3ãyÚÜã��jùOÛtÙýÂá�Ú�ÙÍÞÚ�êòÝ�ñ¤ÙÍÞ3ÚÜäÜÝ�ÞÚÜãb¶�ã�þ|Þ|ß!øGáã�ÚÈãfø²Ý�Þ!ðÂÙ�ñóÝ�ä�û3Ù²ñóèÎìrÙGÚÜÙ²äÜïgêóÞ|Ùmì)ð�è_ÚÜÛ|Ù�Ú�êóïÆÙ`Ý�Þ�ì]Ù²ôÂá3äyÚfäÜÙb·þ|êóä�ÙmìÎÚÜáÆü±á�äÜï`þ|ñòÝ«ÚÜÙ*êòìrÙmÝ�ãÍåÚ�Ùmã�ÚMï_Ý�ä�ß3ÙGÚÜãÍårÝ�ÞtìTÝ3ø²øGÙmã�ã�ðÂá�ÚÜÛTãyÚÜÝ�äyÚÜþ|ýTø²Ý�ýtê ÚÈÝ�ñ2Ý�ÞtìÎÚÜÛ|Ù�äÜÙb·þ|êòãyêëÚ�Ù�ýÂÙ²äÜïgêòãÜãyêóá�Þtã��

¨

Page 4: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

P�QHY�Y[WIZi_{o m�Z4WIcqY^x�`�Zb�%Sqm�`�Z�a4QHY�WIeXWI_{o%SiRTSF`ImtY[e�a4Z�o¥W,eH\�Ylv-R{aVx�Y[ZbY*WI_dSi`!a4QHYN�XZiS�a6UXWIU�Y[ZbSqai`Ylv-UH_dRTk^Rda4_{o~k^`�eHSbRT\HY^ZFaiQHY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiRT`�e RdSiSijpY[S�a4QXW>a"W,ZiRTSbY6x�QHY[eha4QHY�cq`-\pY[_2jHSbY[\ha4`.Sba4ZbjHk^aijHZiY�a4QpY\XW,a4W�\H`-Y^S�eH`Ia�f�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4YyW�jHepRT��jHYnY[��jHRd_TRdgHZiRdjHc)r�P�QHYnjHeHRd��jHY[eHY^SiS�RTSbSijHYyQXWI\�g�Y[Y^e)Y^cVUHQHWISiRd�[Y[\�Rdea4QpY�a4QHY^`�ZiYla4RdkuWI_1_TRdaiY[ZiW,a4jHZbY�`�e"Y[e�a4Z�o�wJWIeH\�g�`IaiQ�£:ZiY^SieXW,QXWIeNWIeH\�¤�Y[RdSiSy� ='���Y= gX��WIeH\�£�Y[ZiZ�o!� ='����¨ �k[`IeHSiRd\HY[ZbY[\~R{a4SnRdcVUXW,k^an`�e.Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRT`�e�RTe!cV`%\HY^_TStx�QHY^ZiYqSijHeH��k^`�SbaiSyk[`�jH_d\.],WIZ�o!WIcq`�eHf�WIfIY[e�a4S^r�$QHY^e cq`%\HY[_dSV\H` ep`Ia6QXWu]IY�W�jHeHRT��jHY�Si`�_djpa4Rd`�e¥R{a6RTS^w�RTe�f�Y^eHY[ZiWI_¸w�ep`Ia�U�`�SiSbRTgH_dY)a4`~\HY^aiY[ZicqRTepYa4QpY�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a}o"`,m�WFf�Rd]IY[eN`�jpaik[`�cqYyk[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eXWI_<`�e)`IgHSiY^Zb],WIgH_dY[S�WIeH\�a4QHYn],WI_TjpYE`,m�W�UXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^Z]�Y^k^ai`�Z[rnP�QHRdStZijp_TY[S�`�jpatcVWIe�o)Sba�W,eH\XWIZb\�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS[r�P�QHY�jHepRT��jHY[epY[SiSyRdSiSijpY�g1Y^kuWIcqY@Yl]�Y^e�cq`�ZiYRTcqU�`�Zba4WIe�a�`IeHk[Y�x:Y:WI_T_d`#x�Y[\Em�`�ZCa4QHY�ZiYuW,_TRTSbc `ImXk^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e�],WI_djHY[SCx�QHRTk�Q@\HRd�1Y[ZbY[\�WIk^Zi`�SbS�WIfIY[e�a4S^wm�`�Zya4QHY^e�aiQHY"e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im2U�`�SbSiRTgp_TYqY[��jHRT_dRTgHZbR�W6RdeHk[ZbYuWISbY[\�cVWIZi�,Y[\H_{o�r�P�QHY"`�ZiRdf�RTeXW,_�WIeXWI_{o%SiRTSyQHY^ZiY,w\HjHY�a4`@©�WI�^�[Y[`�� ¨Iª�ª�¨ ��WIeH\�«%Y[RTc � ¨Iª�ª�¨ �lw%WI_T_d`'x:Y^\Vk^`�e�a4RTe�jXW>a4RT`Ieq],WI_djHY[S�a4`�\HRd�1Y[Z�x�RdaiQ��b_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e��WIeH\"g1Y^f�WIe6Rde�]IY[S�a4RTf�W,a4RdeHf@Y&v-aiY[eHSbRT`�epS:x�QHRTk�Q�W,ZiY�k^ZijHk^R�WI_Ja4`�a4QHY�Sba4jp\po6`Im�c"WIe�oqZiYla�WIRd_<W,eH\6SiY^Zb]%RTk^YSiY^k^ai`�ZiS^r

� jHZ�f�`�W,_�QHY^ZiY�RdS�a4`�cVWI�,Y"a4QHYVa4Z4W,eHSiR{a4RT`Ie�m�Zi`Ic aiQHY"a}x�`�U1Y^ZiRT`%\�SbY^aiaiRTeHf*ai`�a4ZbjH_do�\po%eXWIcqRTkcq`-\HY^_TS�`Im�Y^e�aiZbo�WIeH\*Y&v-Rdaur�PO`6\H`6Sb`"x�Y�x�RT_d_CUHZi`']%RT\HY@WVSbY^an`Im�WISiSbjHcVU-a4RT`IeHS�jpeH\HY[Z�x�QHRTk�Q�aiQHY[ZbYRTS�`�eH_{oN`�eHY@SbY^a�`Im�Y[��jHRd_TRTgpZiRTjpc U1`I_TRTk^RTY^S�aiQXW,a�WIZiY�k[`�epSiRTS�a4Y^e�a�x�Rda4Q)a4QHY�\XW,a�Wqf�Y[epY[Z4W>a4RTepf6UHZi`%k[Y^SiS^r��Y�x�RT_d_�aiQHY[e�SbQH`'x¯QH`'x Si`IcVYtSbRTcqUH_TY�RT\pYuWIS^wpRT\pYuWIS:aiQXW,a:kuWIe�g�Y�]%RTYlx:Y^\)W,S2Ylv%a4Y^eHSiRd`�eHS�`ImB©)j-a4Q���S� =u��Y= ��`�ZiRdf�RTeHWI_�x:`�Zb�Jw�kuWIe�g1Y�jpSiY[\�ai`6\HY[_dRd]IY[Z�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS�aiQXW,ayW,ZiY@g�`IaiQ� ������a4`6k^`�cVUpjpa4Y�W,eH\f�Zb`�jHeH\HY^\)Rde�x�QXW,a���������������������� �!�"# $Ir

%�&('*),+.-.'0/�13254�+(6879-('�:#;

PO`�\HY^aiY[ZicqRTepY@x�QHY^aiQHY[ZyW6U�`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y^e�a4Z4W,e�aV�WIe�RTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�a���SiQH`IjH_T\*Y^e�a4Y[Zq��k[`�e�aiRTe�jHY'��x�Y�eHY^Y[\a4QpY�Ylv-U�Y[kla4Y[\�\pRTSik^`�jHe�a4Y^\6],WI_TjHY�`Im<m�jpa4jHZbY�eHYla2k[WISiQ=<H`#x�S:SiQH`�jp_T\VaiQHY��HZic Y[e�a4Y^Zn��k[`�e�a4Rde�jHY'�&r�P�QHYU�`Ia4Y^e�aiR�WI_:Y[e�a4ZiWIe�aqx�Rd_T_�Y[e�a4Y^ZqR{m�a4QHRdS�Y[e�a4Z�o�],WI_TjHY�RdS�f�ZiY[W,a4Y^Z�a4QHY^ehaiQHY�Y[e�a4Z�o�m�Y[Y���SiRTcqRT_TWIZi_{o�wBWIeRTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�a�x�Rd_T_:k^`�e�a4Rde%jpYNR{m�a4QHY�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e ],WI_djHY6RTS�fIZiYuW>a4Y[Z�aiQXWIe3a4QHY�SbY[_d_{�}`,�¥],WI_TjpY'�lr � jpZcqYuWISbjHZiY6`,m�aiQHY�Y[e�aiZbo~],WI_djHY[S�m�Zi`�c W*UXWIZ�a4RTk^jH_�W,Z�S�a�W,aiY6RTS�W,e3W']IY[ZiWIf�Y�`Im�a4QpY6\HRTSbk[`�jpe�aiY[\3],WI_TjHY`Im�eHYlaVk[WISiQ�<X`'x�S>�����?���������@ ��AB"# $�g�o�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S�x�QH`.\HRT\ Y^e�aiY[ZqW,a�aiQXW,aFS�a�W,aiYIr3«-RdcVRd_�WIZb_doIw�`�jpZcqYuWISbjHZiY�`Im<aiQHY�k[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�eF]IW,_TjHY^S�m�Zb`�c a4QHW,a:S�a�W,aiY�RdS�a4QHY�������������\HRdSik^`�jHe�a4Y^\"],WI_TjHY�`Im<eHY^a�kuW,SiQ<X`'x�S�YuWIZbeHY[\�g�o6RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a4S2x�QH`F\HRd\6k[`�e�aiRTe�jHYtm�Zi`Ic aiQXW,a�Sba4W,a4Y,r�P�QHY[SbYycVY[WISijHZbY[S�`ImOY^e�aiZbo�W,eH\k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e!],WI_TjpY[SEc"WI�,YqaiQHYqZiY[_TW,a4Rd`�eHSbQHRTU!g�Y^a}x�Y[Y[e�aiQHY"cq`%\HY[_�WIep\�a4QpYV\XW>a�WNaiZ4WIepSiUXWIZbY[e�auwBWmWIklauwXx�QHRTk�QNa4`�fIY^a4QpY[Z�x�Rda4Q�a4QpY�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�Z9� S�k[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�eXW,_�YuWISbYIw�SiRdcVUH_dRd�XY^S�Zi`�gpjHSbaieHY[SbSnWIeXWI_{o%SiRTSf�ZbYuW,ai_do�r

� eHk[Y.x:Y.QXWu]�Y�k[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[e�a�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`Im�Y^e�aiZbo WIeH\ k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e$],WI_TjpY[S[w�a4QHY.ZiY^Sba)`Im�a4QpYY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRT`�e!UHZb`�gH_dY[c RdS�SbRTcqUH_TY,rC��YV`�g-a�WIRde~WNk[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[e�a@Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4YF`Im�a4QHYqUHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a}o*`Im�Y^e�a4Zbok[`IeH\HRdaiRT`�eHWI_�`�e¥aiQHY�UXW,Z4WIcqY^aiY[ZiSV`ImtaiQHY�cq`-\pY[_�WISVaiQHY�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda}o `ImnWIe�Y[e�aiZ4WIe�a�\HZiWux�RTeHf~WIeY[e�aiZbo�m�Y^Y�_TY[SbS�a4QXW,e�a4QHY�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[\ Y^e�a4Zbo~]IW,_TjHY,r�«-RdcVRd_�WIZb_doIwOaiQHY�UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o!`,m�W,ehRdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�aYlv-R{a4RTepf~RTSFa4QpY�UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a}o `Imy\HZiW'x�RdeHf�W�SiY[_d_{�¡`I�7],WI_TjHYNf�ZbYuW,aiY[ZVaiQHY[eLa4QHY*k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�eh],WI_djHYIr

D

Page 5: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

��YqaiQHY[e~�HeH\�aiQHYq],WI_djHYF`Im2aiQHYVcq`%\HY[_�� SyUXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^ZiSna4QHW,a@cVWI�,YVR{a4SyUHZiY^\HRTkla4Rd`�eHSym�`�ZyY[e�a4Z�o~W,eH\Ylv-R{a�ZiW,a4Y^S>�iWISyk[_d`�SiYqWISyU�`�SiSbRTgH_dY ��a4`�a4QHYFZiW,a4Y^SE`IgHSiY^Zb]�Y^\�RTe�aiQHYV\HW,a�WprF��_da4Y^ZieXW>a4Rd]IY�cVYla4ZbRTk[Stm�`IZk[_d`�SiY^eHY[SbS2UHZb`-\Hjpk[YnWI_{a4Y^ZieXW,aiRd]IY@��Zi`%`Iab�¡eJ��k[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[e�a�W,eH\6WIS�o%cVUpai`Ia4RdkuWI_d_do�ep`�ZicVWI_XY[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS^wpW,eH\x�YqUpZi`']%RT\HYFWIe�Y&v%a4Y[epSiRd]IYV\pRTSik^jHSiSbRT`�e!`Im�aiQHY�\HRd�1Y[ZbY[eHk^Y[SnRde*a4QHY^RTZtk^`�cVUpjpa�W,aiRT`�eHWI_BW,eH\!Sba�W>a4RTS�a4RdkuWI_UHZb`�U1Y^ZbaiRTY[S^r

� jHZ�jHSiY�`Im%a4QpY�W']IY[ZiWIf�Y�`Im%ZiY[WI_TRd�[Y[\nm�jpaijHZiY�],WI_djHY[SCW,SCWIeyY[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZ1m�`�Z�aiQHY�Ylv-U�Y[k^aiY[\�\HRTSbk[`�jHe�aiY[\m�jpaijHZiY@],WI_djHY[S�a4QXW>at\HY^k[RTSbRT`�epSnWIZiY�gXWISbY[\!jHU�`�e�a4jpZieHSt`IjHZtUHZb`�gH_TY^c RTe�a4`�WVSiY[cqR{�¡UXWIZiWIcVYla4ZbRTkyY[S�a4R{�cVW,a4Rd`�e)UpZi`�gH_dY[cNr�P�QpY@�XZiS�anSba4WIf�Y�UHZi`']%RT\HY^SnW"eH`Ie3�`�Z�SiY^cVR���UXW,Z4WIcqY^aiZiRTkEY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY@`ImBa4QHY�Y^e�a4ZboWIeH\!k^`�e�a4RTe�jXW>a4RT`Ie�],WI_TjHY^S[r�P�QHY�SiY^k[`�eH\.Sba4WIf�Y�aiZiYuW>a4Sta4QpY[SiY�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^SyWIS�a4ZbjHY�],WI_TjpY[SnRTe!W6UHWIZ4W>�cqY^a4ZbRTk�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Rd`�e�UpZi`�gH_dY[cNr �~Y@UHZi`']%RT\HYFW,SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�epS�jHeH\pY[Ztx�QHRdk�Q!aiQHY@�XZbSbayS�a�WIf�Y@eHY[Y^\.`IeH_dog�Y2\H`�eHY�`IeHk[Y,r�P�QXW,a�RdS�x�Y�\p`neH`Ia�eHY^Y[\�a4`nk^`�cqUHjpa4Y�W�k[`�cqUH_TRdkuW,aiY[\@�-vpY^\VU�`�Rde�aB`�Z�cVW,a4ZbR{v�RTe�]IY[ZiSbYYuW,k�Q�aiRTcqY�x�YnY^],WI_TjHW,a4Y�aiQHYn`�g%�bY^k^aiRd]�Ynm�jHepk^a4Rd`�e�W,a�\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a�]IW,_TjHY^S2`ImCa4QHYnUHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[Z:]IY[kla4`�Z^r���SW�ZbY[Sijp_dauw�aiQHY6k^`�cVUpjpa�W,aiRT`�eHWI_�gHjHZb\HY[e3`Im�aiQHRTS�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZ�RdS[w�R{m�WIe�o%aiQHRTepfHw � � �=�3����"3a4QXW>a�`Im�a4QpYY[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS2m�`IZ2a4QHYySiRdcVUp_TYtS�a�W,aiRTknY[e�aiZbo�cq`-\pY[_TS^r

P�QHY:UHWIU1Y^ZCg1Y^f�RTeHS�x�R{a4Qya4QHY�SiRdcVUH_dY[S�aCY[e�a4Z�oH�>Ylv-Rda�cV`%\HY^_¸w#W�cV`%\HY[_�x�R{a4QE`�eHY�Y[e�aiZboE_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eyW,eH\W��-vpY^\�e�jHc�g�Y[ZO`ImXU�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S�Rde�Yl]�Y[Z�o@U�Y[ZbRT`%\�r(�~Y�a4QHY^e�SiQp`#x3Qp`#x ai`�fIY[eHY^Z4WI_dRT�[Y�a4`�WI_T_d`'xm�`�Znc�jp_da4RdUH_TY@Y[e�a4Z�o!_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eHStWIeH\�WNZiWIeH\H`�c e%jpc�g1Y^Zy`Im2U�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S^r � eHk[Yqk[`IeHk[Y^Upa4jXW,_RTSbSijHY^SqWIZiY�k^_�WIZbRd�XY^\�w�W�e%jpc�g1Y^ZF`Im�cV`%\HRd�HkuW,aiRT`�eHSEa4QXW>aF_TYuW,\�a4`.WI_daiY[ZbeXW,a4R{]�Y6Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS�Sijpf�f�Y[S�aa4QpY[cqSiY[_{]�Y^S[r P�QHY.WI_{a4Y^ZieXW,aiRd]IY[S6QXWu]IY.\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a�k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_�WIeH\$\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`IeXWI_�UHZi`�U�Y[Z�a4RdY[S[wWIeH\NSi`qWIZbYnx:`�Z�a4QNk[`�epSiRT\pY[ZiRdeHfHr

��S�WqZbY[SbjH_da[wHx:YEUHZi`']%RT\pYEmWIRdZi_{o"\HYla�WIRd_TY^\�©N`�e�a4Y � WIZi_d`qZbY[SbjH_daiS�`�e�a}x�`"YlvpWIcqUH_dY[S[z�`�epYyx�R{a4Q)WSiRdeHf�_dYt_T`%kuW,aiRT`�e<wHWIeH\�aiQHYy`Ia4QHY^Z�x�Rda4Q�a}x�`V_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHS^rBP�QHY@©)`�e�a4Y � WIZb_T`FZiY^SijH_{a4S^wHx�QHY[eNk[`�c@gHRTeHY^\x�RdaiQ�WIeNWIeXWI_{o�a4RTk�\HRTSbk[jHSbSiRd`�e�`ImCx�Q�o"a4QHYlo�`-k^k[jHZ^wHY[ep\NjpUNg�Y[RdeHf�Ylv%aiZiY[cqY[_{o6Rdepm�`�ZicVW,aiRd]�Y,rB��cV`�epfa4QpY�WI_{a4Y^ZieXW,aiRd]IY[S�x:Y�k[`IeHSiRd\HY[Z�`�eH_{o�`�eHY,w%U�Y[ZbQXWIUHS�a}x:`pw-SbQH`�jH_d\Vg�Y�k^`�eHSbRT\HY^ZiY[\Vg�oFZiY[SbYuWIZbk�QHY[ZbS[wXW,eH\a4QpY�g�Y[S�atU�Y[Zbm�`IZicqRTeHfqWI_{a4Y[ZbeXW,aiRd]�Y^S�WIZiY�WI_TSb`qaiQHY=� ������k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_T_{o"gpjHZi\HY^eHSi`IcVY,r�©)`�ZiY^`']�Y[Z^wa4QpYNk^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_:gpjHZi\HY^e¥`Im�a4QHY^SiYNY[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�RdS�SicVWI_T_2Y^eH`�jHfIQhai`!aiQHRTep�~a4QXW>aqaiQHY�Y^�1Y[kla4Rd]IY_TRdcVR{a�W,aiRT`�e�a4`6aiQHYFY[cqUHRTZbRTk[WI_�WIeHWI_do%SiRdSt`Im�Y[e�a4Z�o!WIeH\.Ylv-R{ayk[`�S�a4Snx�RT_d_Bg�Y[k[`IcVY�aiQHYFZiRTk�QpeHY[SbS�`Im�a4QpY\XW,a4WpwHZiW,a4QHY^Z�a4QXWIeNk[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�eXW,_�m�Y[WISiRdgHRT_dRda}o�r

��SCx:Y�x�RT_d_IU�`�RTe�aC`�j-a�`IjHZCUHZi`%k[Y^\HjHZiY^S�k[WIZiZ�onk[`ISba4SOg�`Ia4QERTena4Y^ZicqSC`ImHW,SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�epS[w,WIeH\ERTena4Y^ZicqS`Im�aiQHYnWIgpRT_TR{a}o@ai`�jHSiY�a4QHY�ZiY[SbjH_daiS:Rde"SijpgHSiY^�%jpY[e�a�WIeXWI_{o-SbRTS^r �~Y�k[`�epk[_Tjp\HY�x�R{a4Q�WE\HRTSbk[jHSbSiRT`Ie6`Im�a4QpYZi`IgHjHSbaieHY[SbS�`Im�`�jHZ�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z�x�Rda4Q�ZbY[SiU�Y[kla�ai`qWISiSbjHcVU-a4RT`IeHS�a4QXW,a�W,ZiYy_TRd�IY[_{oVai`Fg1YyUHZb`�gH_TY^c"W>a4RTk,r

� '�13:�� '�-�� 4�� '0/ :���(/ '

£:Ylm�`�ZiY�UHZb`-k^Y[Y^\HRTeHf�ai`�a4QHY�\pY^a�W,RT_TS^w�W~x:`�Zb\$`�e�a4QHY�ZbY[_TW,a4Y^\7_TRdaiY[ZiW,a4jHZbY�RdS6RTe7`�Zb\HY[Z^r |¡a6RTS6`�jpZWIgHRd_TR{a}o)ai`Nm�`�Zbc eH`�epUXWIZ4W,cVYla4ZiRdk�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[Sy`Im:aiQHYqY[e�a4Z�o.WIeH\~k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e�]IW,_TjHY^SyaiQXW,a�Y[eXW,gH_TY^SjHSna4`�k^RTZbk[jHc@]IY[e�aya4QHYFk^`�cVUpjpa�W,aiRT`�eHWI_�UpZi`�gH_dY[cqS�a4QHW,ayQXWu]�YFQHRdeH\HY[ZbY[\!a4QHY�Y^cVUpRTZiRdkuWI_�WIeXW,_do%SiRdSt`Im\po%eXWIcqRTk:cV`%\HY[_dS�`Im�cVWIZi�,Y^a4S^r��`Iai��WIeH\V©)Rd_T_TY^Z2� ='��� D �Ox:Y^ZiY�a4QpY��HZiSba�ai`yjHSiY�SiY^cVR �}UXW,Z4WIcqY^aiZiRTk^SOai`

Page 6: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

SiRdcVUp_TRdm�o"k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_�gpjHZi\HY^eHStRde*W"\po%eXW,cVRdk�UHZb`�gH_dY[cN¢JaiQHY^o)jHSbY@SiY^cVR �}UXW,Z4WIcqY^aiZiRTknY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S`Im�a4QHY�k�QH`�Rdk[Y�`Im1\HRTSbk[ZbY^a4Y�k^`�e�a4Zi`I_TS�a4`ySiRdcVUp_TRdm�oEa4QpY[RTZ�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Rd`�eFWI_TfI`�ZiR{a4QHcNr�P�QHY �`Iai��W,eH\6©NRT_T_dY[ZUXWIU�Y[ZB\HYuWI_dS�x�R{a4QFW�SbRTeHf�_dY2WIfIY[e�a�UHZb`�gH_TY^c)w>x�QHRT_dY2W�SbjHgHSbY[��jHY[e�a�UXWIU�Y[Z�g�o � _d_TYloEWIeH\F�BW,�IY[S�� ='���� �jHSbY[S�SbY[cqR{�}UHWIZ4WIcqY^aiZiRdk[SCY[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[SB`,mHa4QHY�k�QH`�Rdk[Y2`ImH\HRTSbk[ZiYla4Y�W,eH\�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jH`�jpS�a4`�SiRTcqUH_dRdm�otY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S`ImBW�c�jH_daiRTUH_dYtWIfIY[e�a�\po%eXWIcqRTknf�WIcqYIr

P�QHY[ZbY.WIZiY�WI_TSb` W�e�jHc�g�Y[Z6`ImEUXW,U1Y^ZiS�k[jpZiZiY^e�a4_do �bRde�UHZi`%k[Y^SiS �HwtWI_d_�x�ZiRdaba4Y^e7RTeH\HY^U1Y^eH\HY^e�ai_doIwa4QHW,a6UHZbY[SbY[e�a�ZiY^_�W,aiY[\�ZbY[Sijp_da4S^rAP�QHY*k^_T`�SbY[Sba"a4`�`�jpZ6UXWIU�Y[ZVRTS6W�UXWIU�Y[Z6g�oL��f�jHRdZiZbY[f�WIgpRTZiRTW�W,eH\©)RdZ4W6� ¨Iª�ª D ��x�QpRTk�Q6Rde�aiZi`%\HjHk^Y[S:`IeHY�`,m�a4QHY�WI_daiY[ZbeXW,a4R{]�Y�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�k[`IeHSiRd\HY[ZbY[\�RTeq`�jHZ�Ylv%a4Y^eHSiRd`�eHS^r��fIjHRTZbZiY[f�WIgHRTZbR�W�WIeH\�©)RTZiW�� ¨Iª�ª D �tm�`%k[jHS�`�e�W�cq`%\HY[_�x�RdaiQ �b_d`�f�R{a ���Y&v-aiZiY^cVYq]IW,_TjHYu�yY^ZiZi`IZiS�W,eH\Y[cqUHQXW,SiRT�^YIw�k^`�e�a4ZiWIZbo)a4`6`�jpZtk[`�epk[_TjpSiRT`IeHS[w<aiQHY�Y � k^RTY^eHk^o!W,\p],WIe�a�WIf�Y^St`Im�W"cVW>v-RTc�jpc _dRT�,Y[_TRdQH`%`-\Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�Z[r)��Y^SiY^eH\H`�Z�m�Y[ZqWIeH\3«%k�QHcVRd\pab���tY[eHfI_�WIZu� ¨Iª�ª D ��c"W,�IY�WIe~R¸r�R¸r�\�r�UHZb`�gHR{a�WISbSijHcqUpaiRT`�e W,eH\RTcqUH_dY[cqY[e�a6a4QpY�Y^cVUHRdZiRdkuWI_nW,eXWI_T`If `Im@aiQHY�Rd\HY[e�aiRd�Xk[W,a4Rd`�e WIZif�jpcVY^e�aNRde¯©)WIf�eXWIk�WIeH\ P�QHY[Sbc"W,Z� ¨,ª�ª�¨ �&r2P�QHY[RdZ�W,UHUHZi`�WIk�Q�a4`qS4W,cVUH_dRTeHfFY^ZiZi`IZ�RdS�\HR{�<Y^ZiY^e�a�a4QHWIe)aiQXW,a�RTe�a4QHY�`Ia4QHY^Z�UHWIU1Y^ZiS�WIS�aiQHY^oUH_TWIk[Y�W�a4Rdf�Q�a"ZbY[SbaiZiRdk^a4Rd`�e�`�eLa4QHY)\HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�eL`Im=�" $������"���� ��`�jpaik[`�cqY[S^w�Z4W,aiQHY[Zqa4QXW,e�a�WI��RTepfa4QpYEaiZ4WI\HR{a4Rd`�eXWI_�W,UHUHZi`�WIk�Q�`ImBZiY^Sba4ZbRTkla4RTepfVUHZbRTcqRdaiRd]�Y^S�WIeH\Nx:`�Zb��RTeHfV`�jpa�a4QHYERTcqUH_TRdkuW,aiRT`�epS:`Im�a4QH`�SbYZiY^SbaiZiRTkla4Rd`�eHS6`�eLa4QHY�Y^eH\H`�f�Y^eH`�jHS���jXW,e�aiRdaiRTY[S"`ImERTe�a4Y^ZiY[S�aur £2W#�iW,ZiR¸w�£�Y[eH�>WIZb\ W,eH\�Y^]%RTe � ¨Iª�ª � �k[`IeHSiRd\HY[Z�cVR v-Y[\Nk[`�e�a4Rde�jH`�jHS�\HRTSbk[ZbY^a4Y�k[`�e�aiZi`�_dS[wXgHjpa�WI_dSi`qQXWu]�Y�W,e�Y[e�aiZbo�Ylv-R{a�Y&vHW,cVUH_dYnx�Rda4QN_T`If�RdaY[ZbZi`�ZbS[r)P�QHY[RdZ�WIUHUpZi`�WIk�Q RdS�\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a�RTe�a4QXW,aEa4QpY^o.�XZiS�a�eH`�e-�¡UXWIZiWIcVYla4ZbRTkuW,_T_do�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiYVQH`'x a4QpYk[`Ie�aiZi`�_dSEWIZiYq\HY^aiY[ZbcVRdeHY[\�g�o�aiQHYqSba�W>a4YF]IW,ZiR�W,gH_TY^SE`,m:a4QpYVUHZb`�gH_dY[c � W,SERde �`Ia4�VWIeH\�©)RT_d_TY^Z[w ='��� DWIeH\ � _T_dY^o"WIeH\)�BWI�,Y[S[w ='����� �lw�WIeH\�aiQHY[eNjHSiYya4Qp`�SiYyY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S2ai`VSbRTc�jH_TW,a4Y�k[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�e6],WI_TjpY[S��'r

��_d_�a4QHY^SiY.Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�k^`�jH_T\$g�Y!jHSiY^\ ai`LY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y�aiQHY!UXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[ZbS�`Im�aiQHY�],WIZiRTWIgH_TY�UHZi`I�pam�jHeHkla4Rd`�e�w�WIS�x�Y[_d_HWIS�aiQHY2\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�e�`Im�Y[e�aiZbo�W,eH\FYlv-Rda�m�Y^Y[S^r�P�QHZi`IjHf�QH`�j-auw�QH`'x�Y^]�Y^Z[w�x:Y2m�`%k[jpS�`�eY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRTeHf�aiQHY�\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�e�`Im�Y^e�a4Zbo)WIep\�Ylv-R{a�m�Y^Y[S�WIS�R{a�RTS�a4QHY^SiY@UHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[ZbS�aiQXW,a�WIZiYE\HR � k^jH_daa4`�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y"x�R{a4QH`Ijpa�jHSbRTeHf*aiQHY�SbaiZijHkla4jHZbY�`Im�W*\po%eXWIcqRTk"f�WIcVY,r!P�QHRTS�_dYuWI\HS@jHS�a4`!Wu]�`IRT\ R¸r�R¸r�\�rYlv%aiZiY[cqY�]IW,_TjHY�`�Z�R¸r�R¸r�\�r�eH`�ZicVWI_X\HRdSbaijHZigXW,eHk[Y^S[r�P�QH`�SbYtWISbSijHcqUpaiRT`�eHS�RdcVUH_{o@aiQXW,a�a4QHY�Y[e�aiZboqk[`�S�a4S�Wf�R{]�Y[eFU�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_pY[e�aiZ4WIe�a�mWIk^Y[S�RTe�\HR{�<Y^ZiY^e�a�_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHSORTe�aiQHY�S4WIcqY2cVWIZi�,Y^a�WIZbY�RTeH\HY^U1Y^eH\HY^e�a�`,m<`�epYWIeH`,a4QHY^Z:WIep\"QXWu]�Y�m�jH_T_XSbjHUHU�`�Zba[wpW,eH\VaiQHY[SbY�RTcqUH_dRTkuW>a4RT`IeHSBk[WIe"g�Y���jHR{a4Y�jHeHZbYuWI_dRTSbaiRTk,rB��_dSi`Hw%W,a�_dYuWIS�aRTeySbU1Y^k[R�W,_�kuWISbY[S[w,`�jHZCSiRdcVUp_TY�WIeXW,_do�a4Rdk�Si`�_djpa4Rd`�eHS�\H`�eH`IaOZbY[��jHRTZbY�a4QHY �`,a4�l��©)RT_d_TY^Z�RTe�]�Y^ZiSbRT`�eE`�Z�],WI_TjHYm�jHeHkla4Rd`�e3Rda4Y^Z4W,aiRT`�epS[r sBRdeXWI_d_do�w�x:YNUHZiY^SiY^e�aVYlv%aiY[eHSbRd]�Y*©)`�e�a4Y � WIZb_T`!ZiY^SijH_{a4SF`�e a4QpYNcq`%\HY[ZiW,a4Y^_doSiRd�[Y^\hSiWIcqUH_TY^S�a4QHW,a�|}eH\HjpSba4ZbR�WI_ � Zbf�WIeHRd�uW,aiRT`�e�ZiY^SiYuW,Zik�QHY^ZiS�mWIk[Y,r�P�QpY[e a4QHY6�HZiSbaFS�a�WIfIY6ZiY^�%jpRTZiY^SeH`�e%�}UXWIZiWIcqY^a4ZbRTk^S�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�W>atWFe�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im�Sba4W,a4Y^S�aiQXW,a�RTS�U�`Ia4Y^e�aiR�WI_d_do"_�WIZbf�Y[Z�a4QpY[e)aiQHY@e�jHc@g1Y^Z`ImJjHep\HY[Zb_do%RTeHfn`IgHSiY^Zb],W,a4Rd`�eHS�`Ie�c"W,Zi�IYla4S^r �~Y:SiQH`'xha4QXW,a�`�jHZ�SbRTcqUH_TY^Z�cqY^aiQH`-\pSBx:`IZi�@��jHR{a4Y:x�Y[_d_pRdea4QpRTS�kuW,SiYEWIeH\�Ylv-UH_TWIRTe6x�Q�oIwJx�QpRT_TY�a4QHYy`IaiQHY[Z�cqY^aiQH`-\pS2x:Yyk[`IeHSiRd\HY[Z^wXRTeHk^_TjH\HRdeHf�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS2gXWISbY[\

�ÍùOÛ|ÙføGá3Þ3ÚÜêëÞ�þ|á3þtãYøGá�ÞÚÜä�á3ñøÍÝ�ã�ÙpêòãjÝ�ñòãyá*øGá�Þ�ãyêòìrÙ²äÜÙÍì`ð�è�çpÙÍä�äÜè�Ý�Þtì<æ[Ý�ß3ÙÍã� ����������2Ý�Þtì<æ[Ý�ß3ÙÍãÍå®æjá3äyÚÜÙ²äYÝ�Þtì`Øaá3ñ ü±äÈÝ�ï �����������±fÛ|á]þtãyÙ�³��"þ|Ú�Û|êòÝ�Þ>´]êóì|ÙÍÝ�ã>ãyêóïÆêëñòÝ�ä�Ú�á]Ú�Û|áãyÙ<þtãyÙmì"êóÞ"Ú�Û|êòã*ýtÝ�ýÂÙ²ä�Ú�á!ìrÙ²÷3Ù²ñóá�ý»Ý�Þ�ÙÍãyÚ�êóïÆÝ�Ú�á3ä�ðtÝ3ãyÙmì"á�Þ �täÈãyÚá�äÈìrÙÍäÎøGá�Þ�ìrê ÚÜêëá3ÞtãÆü±á3ä]ÝÀìrè�ÞtÝ�ïÆêòø"û3Ý�ïÆÙTÝ�ÞtìÑü±á�ä� ±ï`þtñ ÚÜê�º þ|Þ|êëÚ��]Ý�þtøGÚ�êóá�ÞtãÍåpäÜÙÍã�ýÂÙÍø�ÚÜêë÷3Ù²ñóè ���@êóÞtÝ®÷� ����������gý|äÜá«÷�êóìrÙmãÝ�ãÜã�þ|ïÆýrÚ�êóá�Þtã1±fÛ|êòøÈÛ)ÙÍÞtÝ�ðtñëÙ>á�Þ|Ù>Ú�ágá�ðrÚÈÝ�êóÞ]Ùmã�ÚÜêëï_Ý«ÚÜÙÍãpü±äÜá�ï Ú�ÛtÙ*ã�ÙÍø²á�Þtì)ã�ÚÈÝ�û�Ù>á�üÕÝ`Ú�êóïÆêëÞtûgûÝ�ïÆÙ�å3Ú�ÛtÙ ��äÜãyÚOãyÚÜÝ�û�Ù>á�ü±fÛ|êòøÈÛ"ìrÙGÚÜÙ²äÜïgêóÞ|Ùmã�Ú�Û|Ù�á3äÜìrÙÍäOá�üjÙ²ÞÚ�äÜè �

Page 7: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

`�e�_TRd�IY^_TRTQp`-`%\"m�jHeHkla4Rd`�eHS[wX\p`qep`Iaur

� � ���� ���� �-4 ���+65 879�3 �� �����"�����Yng1Y^f�RTe�x�RdaiQ�Wq©�WIZi�,`']���Y^Zbm�Y[klat����jHRd_TRTgpZiRTjpc � ©�WISb�%RdeNWIeH\�P�RTZb`�_TY,w ='��¦I¦ ��m�`�Z2aiQHYncV`%\HY^_1x�RdaiQ`�eH_{o `�eHYNY[e�aiZboh_T`%kuW,aiRT`�e3W,eH\LaiQHY)SiWIcqY)e�jHc�g�Y[Zq`Im�U1`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y[e�aiZ4WIe�a4S"RTe3YuWIk�Q¥U1Y^ZiRT`%\�rLP�QHYf�Y^eHY[ZiWI_TRd�uW,aiRT`�e*ai`)c�jp_da4RdUH_TY@Y[e�a4Z�o�_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHSyWIep\~WNZ4WIeH\p`�c e�jHc�g�Y[ZE`Im2U�`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S�RTSEWSbaiZ4WIRdf�Q�aim�`�Z�x2W,Zi\�Ylv%a4Y^eHSiRd`�eNk[`�eHSbRT\HY^ZiY^\�_�W>a4Y[Z^r

�Y^a���g1Yqa4QHY6e�jHc@g1Y^Z@`Im�WIfIY[e�a4S�W,k^a4R{]�Y"W,a@aiQHY6g�Y[f�RdeHeHRTepf�`Im�Y[WIk�Q U�Y[ZiRd`-\<w ���g1Y"W)]�Y^k^ai`�Z`Im�Y&v-`�f�Y[ep`�jHStUHZb`I�Ha�SiQHR{m�a4Y[ZbS�x�QHRdk�Q*Y^]I`�_d]IY�WIS�WV�XeHR{a4YESba�W>a4Y�©)WIZi�,`#])UHZb`-k^Y[SiS^w�WIeH\*WISiSbjHcVYEa4QXW>aa4QpY[ZiY�RdSFW.`�epYl�}U�Y[ZbRT`%\ UHZi`,�Ha�m�jHeHkla4RT`Ie3aiQXW,aqRTS�\pY^a4Y^ZicqRTeHY^\3g�o~a4QHY^SiY�]IW,ZiR�W,gH_TY^S[w�S4Wuo����������p¢����lwx�QHY^ZiY���RTS�W�UXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[Z2]IY[kla4`�Z�a4`Fg�YEY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^\�r

��eFRTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�a�k�Qp`-`�SbY[S�a4`nY&v-Rda�RdmJk^jHZiZbY[e�a�UHZb`I�Ha4S�Up_TjHSBaiQHY�\HRdSik[`IjHe�a4Y[\qSiY^_T_-`I�"],WI_djHY2RTSBf�ZiY[W,a4Y^Za4QHWIe�UHZi`,�Ha4S2Up_TjHS:aiQHYt\HRdSik^`�jHe�a4Y^\Nk^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�eV],WI_djHYIr�«-`@Rdm��NRdS:a4QpYtSiY^_T_�`I�3��`�Z:Y&vpR{a&��],WI_djHYtW,eH\ª������= RdS�aiQHYy\HRTSbk[`�jpe�a�ZiW,a4Y,wpa4QHY>�i£�Y[_T_dc"W,e���Y[��jXW>a4RT`Ie�m�`IZ�aiQHYn],WI_TjHYn`,m�WIe�RdeHk[jHc@g1Y^e�a�RdS

�6�������p¢������I�! #"�$&%�'(���������-¢����*) � ���+���,�����p¢��I�-) � �/.V�,�����p¢�����01� � = �x�QHY^ZiY2�/.V�43 ��RdS�aiQHYtk^`�e�a4RTe�jXW>a4RT`IeV],WI_TjpYIr�|¡m�aiQHYtcVW>vqRTS�a4QpY��XZiS�a:aiY[Zic RdeHSiRd\HY�aiQHY�k^jHZi_{oVgpZ4WIk��,Y^a4S^wa4QpYERdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a�Y&v-Rda4S^r

|¡m65�RTS�aiQHY�e%jpc�g1Y^ZC`ImpY^e�a4Z4W,e�aiS[w7%�RdS�a4QHY�e�jHc�g�Y[ZC`Im-Ylv-Rdai`�ZiS���g1`,a4Qy`Im%x�QHRTk�Q�WIZiY�jpeH��eH`'x�e�W,aCa4QpYa4RdcVY2aiQHY�RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a4S ��\HY^k[RdSiRT`IeHS:W,ZiY�c"W,\HY'�&wpWIep\98O�:3 ��RTS�eH`Ia4W,a4Rd`�e�m�`�Z�WEUHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a}o�\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�e�wa4QpY[e;��."�:3 ��RTS<�bjHS�a�aiQHY�Ylv-U1Y^k^a4W,a4Rd`�e���`#]IY[Z�a4QHY�U�`�SiSbRTgH_dY�e�jHc@g1Y^ZiS�`Im�Y&vpR{a4`�ZbS[w%Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S�WIeH\q]IW,_TjHY^S`ImOa4QHYyUHZb`I�Ha�SiQpRdm�a4Y^ZiS4�:`Im�aiQHYyeHYlv%a�U1Y^ZiRd`-\���S�ZiY[WI_TRd�uW,aiRT`�e"`Im�aiQHYn],WI_TjHYtm�jpeHk^aiRT`�e�w6�6�43 �lwH`�Z

�/.V�,�����p¢��I�=< � ¨ �>?4@ AB@ CEDF(G D �"�,�H)I5KJL%*���NMO�P�QMT¢����R8O� $6�6MTSU�I��86V��W5&�X%!S �����Y�XZ[ = �R8O�W�NMTSU���P\

]�`,a4Y�a4QXW>a�ai`Em�`IZic aiQHRTS�Y&vpU�Y[kla�W,aiRT`�eFx�Y�eHY^Y[\qa4`ym�`�Zic aiQHY�RTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a ��S�U1Y^Zik[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS�`Im1a4QHY�_TRd�IY^_doe�jHc�g�Y[Zy`Im�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4SEWIeH\.Ylv-R{a4`�ZbS=� ��" $_^��W^ ��" ��� ��"@�3�!^�"#���a`Hb��"!�c^���� �� d=� ��"!�W^�"!��^�"��Iw�U�Y[Zbk[Y[U-a4RT`IeHSa4QHW,a�x:Yyx�ZiR{a4YyWIS�aiQHYyUHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRda}oV\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�e

86Vl�W5&�+%!S �����Y��Ze = �x�QHY^ZiYZf = RTS�ep`Ia�W,aiRT`�eNm�`�Z�aiQHY�RdeHk[jHc@g1Y^e�atk[`�e�a4Rde�jHRTeHfpr �~Y@eHY[Y^\!aiQHY[SbY�U�Y[Zik^Y[UpaiRT`�epSng1Y^kuWIjHSbYa4QpY�RdeHk[jHc@g1Y^e�a:kuWIepeH`Ia�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y�QHRdS�ZbY^aijHZieHS�a4`Ek[`�e�aiRTe�jHRTepf�x�RdaiQH`�jpa�WIeVRT\HY[W�`Im<QH`'x$c"W,e�oF`,a4QHY^Z�XZbcVS�x�RT_d_Hg1Y�WIk^aiRd]IYIr�|¡a�RTS�a4QHY�ZiY^��jHRTZbY[cqY[e�a�aiQXW,a�a4QHY^SiY�U1Y^Zik[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS�g1Y�k[`�epSiRTS�a4Y^e�a�x�RdaiQVg�Y[QXWu]%RT`IZa4QHW,a�x�RT_d_�f�Y[epY[Z4W>a4Yy`�jHZ�Y^�%jpRT_TRdgHZiRdjHc k[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eHS^r

Page 8: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

��eXW,_T`�f�`IjHSi_{o�w1x�YqWISiSbjHcqY�a4QXW,a�a4QHY�Y^e�a4Z4W,e�aEc�jpSbank^`�cVcqRda�a4`�Y^e�a4Y[ZbRTeHf�`�epY�U1Y^ZiRd`-\�g�Y^m�`�ZbY�RdaYuW,ZieHS�WIe�o�UHZb`I�HauwpSi`Fa4QHYn],WI_TjpYn`ImBY^e�a4Zbo�RdS

���"�,�����p¢��I�=< � D �>?4@ AB@ CED

F G D �"��� )I5cJ %*��� M �P� M �R8O� $6� M S ����8 ? �,5&�X%!S �����Y��Z ? = �R8O�W� M SU��� �x�QHY^ZiY 8 ? �W5&�X%!S �����Y�XZ ? = �UHZb`#]%Rd\HY[S"aiQHY*U�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_�Y^e�a4Z4W,e�a � S�U�Y[Zbk[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS6`ImnaiQHY�_dRT�,Y[_do3e�jHc@g1Y^Z6`ImyY[e�aiZ4WIe�a4S�W,eH\�Ylv-R{a4`�ZbS� ��" $_^��,^ ��" ��� ��" ^�� �"!� �AP^�"��IwH`�Z�k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeXWI_<`Ie Z ? = r

P�QHYEU1`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y^e�aiZ4WIe�a�Y[e�aiY[ZiS�Rdm

� ���6�������-¢��������x�QHY^ZiY��NRTS�R{a4S�SijpeH�6k[`ISba�`ImBY^e�a4Zbo��#r

�~Y�eH`'x _TRdSbaO`�jHZOWISbSijHcqUpaiRT`�eHS�WIeH\Ea4QHY^e@a4jpZie�ai`�W�\HY^a4WIRT_dY[\EYlv-UH_TWIeXW,aiRT`�eE`ImpaiQHY[RdZ�RdcVUp_TRTk[W,a4Rd`�eHS^r

�� � ��� � 4�� +���� ��!^���� ��� ����`= �3����� �"!�?AB�*��" $8��&^�� $� � ^ � ^ ��"��=��A ` � $��� ^R`������ ��"# ��� �����*������!/b� �_^�"!"6^�"�� �:d ���! �!�A ^ � $�� ��" $C�3�����

��� � �!�A ��A ��"! � $ "!�a`Hb��A �:d � ��� �"!�,^?��� �"!��A ��"!����^�"@ ��� � �!�AP^ � $$# $��"���� $�b ��%'&(� ��" $ ���!$_^ ���?AP^,b � �,^ ��" ��)��A

* ���! ����",+ � � ���3� �:d��"!�?AB�-� � ���/.10%�32QSU���4�5� ��^ � � ����� �=����� �A9b�����" $��:d6� 7 ª � ��" $* ���! A �����AB"�� � � ��&^��,^�"���� � ���/. G �43,SU�I�8�5� ��^ � �>��A ��� ����`= $C"���"!"# � ���,^9)�8�

��A ^ � ^ � $ � ��)��A �,^R`= ��" $=����A � � � ` ��A4+ ��3� ��: "#���a`Hb��"!��� ��" $ �"!�?A ��"!���;+�"���� ���! � $_^ ���?A ^,b �=<�,^ ��" ��" $>���! ^�A ��� " A ��� ^?> ���W^ ��"��8� b ��� $��,"�����+�"���� �3�! A ��� ^?> ���,^ ��"�� �:d����! ^�A � � ` �!��W^�����A �#�� � ���!�A 9^ �������N``=��?AP^ �2^�"Bd ��AP` ���W^ ��",� ���2^�"A@� ^R`��5B,C�C � & �

D ÿMá�Ú�ÙfÚÜÛtÝ«Ú<±pÙMÝ�ä�ÙfÞ|á�ÚSû�êó÷�êëÞtû�Ú�Û|Ù>ý�á�Ú�Ù²ÞÚÜêóÝ�ñtÙ²ÞÚÜäÜÝ�Þ3Ú[ÚÜÛ|ÙMýÂá3ãÜãyêóð|êóñëêëÚ�ègá�ü�±�Ý�ê ÚÜêëÞtû�Ý�ÞtìgÚÜÛ|Ù²Þ_ÙÍÞ3ÚÜÙ²äÜêëÞtû�êëÞ_ÚÜÛ|ÙMÞ|Ù�²�ÚýÂÙ²äÜêëárì�±fê ÚÜÛ)ÚÜÛ|Ù�ãÜÝ�ïÆÙ*ã�ÙGÚÜþ|ý"øGáã�ÚÈã �[ùÕáÆì|áÆã�á:±pÙ�±�á�þ|ñòì]Û�Ý®÷�Ù>Ú�áÆß�ÙÍÙ²ý)Ú�äÈÝ�øÈß_á�üÕÚ�Û|Ù�÷«Ý�ñóþ|Ù�á�üYÝgý�á�Ú�ÙÍÞ3ÚÜêóÝ�ñ�Ù²ÞÚ�äÈÝ�ÞÚmåãÜÝ®èFE5GIH KJMLONPLRQ ��å^±fÛ|êòøÈÛ�±pá3þ|ñóìÆðÂÙMÚÜÛ|ÙMï_Ý�²rêóï`þ|ï á�ü�ESH KJMLRN �PT"QÆÝ�ÞtìgÚÜÛ|Ù�Ù�²�ýÂÙÍøGÚ�Ùmì_÷«Ý�ñóþ|ÙMá�ü�ðÂÙ²êóÞ|û`Ý�ýÂá�ÚÜÙ²ÞÚ�êòÝ�ñÙ²ÞÚÜäÜÝ�Þ3Ú�±fêëÚ�ÛÀã�þ|Þ|ß�ø²á3ãyÚ5Q êóÞ Ú�Û|Ù_ÞtÙ�²�Ú�ý�ÙÍä�êóárì �_ùOÛ|ÙÎÝ�ÞtÝ�ñëèrã�êóãB±�á�þ|ñòì�Ú�Û|ÙÍÞ ýtä�árøGÙÍÙÍìaï`þtøÈÛaÚ�ÛtÙÎã�Ý�ïgÙ2±OÝ®è»Ý�ãB±�ÙìráÎðÂÙ²ñóá�±�åÂÙ�²|øGÙÍýrÚ�ÚÜÛtÝ«Ú*Þ|á�±*±pÙ�±�á�þtñóìTÛtÝ®÷3Ù�Ú�á]ß�Ù²ÙÍý"Ú�äÈÝ�øÈß)á�ü[ÚÜÛ|Ù`ñóêëß3Ù²ñóè!ì|êóãyÚ�äÜêëðtþrÚ�êóá�Þ»á�üjÚ�Û|Ù<ý�á�Ú�Ù²ÞÚÜêóÝ�ñÕÙÍÞ3ÚÜäÜÝ�ÞÚÜãb¶Q%¶ ã ±êëÚ�±fêóñëñOìrÙ²ýÂÙ²Þ�ìÀá�Þ�ÚÜÛ|Ù]÷«Ý�ñóþ|Ù)á�üfÙ²ÞÚ�äÜè êëÞ$ýtä�êóá�ä�ýÂÙ²äÜêóá�ìtã � �1UMá�± Ú�Û|êòã<êóã<ìrá�Þ|Ù!ìrÙ²ýÂÙ²Þ�ì|ã`á3Þ�Ú�Û|Ù!Ý�ãÜãyþtïgý|Ú�êóá�Þû�á«÷3Ù²äÜÞ|êóÞ|û�Ú�Û|Ù*Ù²÷3á�ñóþrÚ�êóá�Þ_á�üÕÝ�ýÂá�ÚÜÙ²ÞÚ�êòÝ�ñÂÙ²ÞÚÜäÜÝ�Þ3Úi¶ ãVQ]á«÷�Ù²äSÚ�êóïÆÙ �XW>þ|äÈã@êòã@ÚÜÛ|Ù*Ù�²�Ú�äÜÙ²ïÆÙ>øÍÝ�ã�Ù�êóÞ�±fÛ|êòøÈÛÎêëüÕÝ�ýÂá�ÚÜÙ²ÞÚ�êòÝ�ñÙ²ÞÚÜäÜÝ�Þ3ÚMìrá�ÙmãOÞ|á�ÚMÙÍÞ3ÚÜÙ²ä�±fÛ|ÙÍÞ!Ú�Û|Ù�ÙÍÞ3ÚÜä�è]ý�áã�ã�êëðtêëñóê Ú�è)Ý�ý|ýÂÙÍÝ�äÜãÍåÚ�ÛtÝ�ÚMý�áã�ã�êëðtêëñóê Ú�è)ìrêóãÜÝ�ýtý�ÙmÝ�äÈã �

§

Page 9: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

B ��� "!�?A ��"!����� ��" $ ^�"#����`Hb��"!�������!�A � � �W^ ��"�� �:d ���! � A �_b � b�^�� ^��W^ � �:d ��&^�� ��" $ �"!��AB�Lb � �3�! ^�A� � ` �!��,^�� ��A � ^�" �!�AP^ � $��,$� �!�" $ ��"!��� ��"��,� ���� �A# �3�! � � b � ^ �����*� )��_^�� � b � ^�"Bd ��AP` ���,^ ��" ���������� �,^R`= & �

��� � �! ) �������,^ ��" �:d �3�!5� A � ! �!� ��^ dB� �A �8�Y�=�-^ � ����)��A�"# $ b � ���!��*��A8+ ��) � ���_^�" C < '�8O�:3WS ��� ��� �� � �� ª � = ��\B\B\ � ���W0 �����W"������ ������������� ª d ��A )��AB���� � � ��" $9���43 �2^ �/b�����" $� $"! �

��Y�k^`�cVY�gXWIk���ai`@WEcV`�ZbY�\HY^a4WIRT_dY[\F\HRTSbk[jHSbSiRd`�e"`Im<a4QHY�ZiY^Sba4ZbRTkla4RT`IeHS�RTcqUH_TRdY[\�g�oFa4QHY^SiYtW,SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�epS\HRdZiY[kla4_{o�W,m�aiY[Z�Ylv-UH_TWIRTepRTeHf�aiQHYEWISiSbjHcVU-a4RT`IeHS �XRdcVUH_dRTk[W,a4Rd`�eHS[r

P�QHRTSVcV`%\HY^_�RdS"W�SiU�Y[k[RTWI_�kuWISbY*`ImtaiQHY�cq`%\HY[_�RTe¥��ZiRTk^Si`�e�WIeH\���WI�IY^S.� ='�I��� �FWIeH\¥Sb`�QXWIS"W©�WIZb�I`'])U1Y^Zbm�Y[klatY^�%jpRT_TRdgHZiRdjHcNwHgHjpa�a4QHY^ZiY@cVWuo�g1Y�cV`IZiYya4QXWIe)`�eHY�`Im�a4QpY[c �SbY[Y �t`�ZiWISi�^Y[_dSi��RBW,eH\«pW,aba4Y^Zba4Q�x:WIRdaiYIw ¨Iª�ª D �lrC��WIk�QEY[��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc$f�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4Y^SOW��HeHRdaiY�Sba�W>a4Y�©�WIZb�I`']nk�QXW,RTeyRTeq���������<k^`�jHUH_dY[S^r|�r�YIr�a4QpY�\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`Ieq`,m�U1`ISiSiRdgH_TY@�,�������B� S2RdeqaiQHY�epYlv%a2U�Y[ZbRT`%\"\HY^U1Y^eH\HS2`�ep_doF`�eqa4QHY�k[jHZbZiY[e�an�,�������� W,eH\~eH`,a@`�e�Y[R{a4QHY^Z�UHZbRT`�ZnQpRTSbai`�Zbo!`IZEaiRTcqYqR{a4SbY[_dm4�lwOWIep\�a4QpY[ZiYVRTSEWIe �LSbjHk�Q�a4QXW>auwOUHZi`']%RT\HY^\~a4QpYk[jpZiZiY^e�a �qRTSC_T`'x�Y[Z�a4QXW,e@Rda[w'x:Y�x�RT_T_IeHY^]IY[Z�`�gpSiY[Z�]�Y:WIe�� 7 ��rBP�QHY�cVWIZi�,Y^a�RTSCSiRdcVUH_{oteH`,aBUHZb`I�Ha4WIgH_TYY[ep`�jHf�Q�a4`FRTep\HjHk[YyY^e�aiZbo�R{mOaiQHY[ZbY@W,ZiY �!`�Z�cq`�ZiYnRdeHk[jHc@g1Y^e�aiS[r

|}eH\HY^Y[\�w�`�epY:kuW,e�f�`tW�gHRdaOm�jHZ�a4QHY^Z[r�sX`�Z�WIe�o�Y[��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHcNw'Y^]IY[Z�o@U�`�SiSbRTgH_dY�SbY[��jHY^eHk[Y�`Im-'-��� :������P0x�RT_d_�Y^]IY[e�a4jXW,_T_do x:WIeH\pY[Z6Rde�ai`~W.ZiY^k[jHZbZiY[e�a�SbjHgHSbY^a6`,mta4QHY)U1`ISiSiRdgH_TY����������Fk[`�jpUH_TY^S[w2SiW'o$#�w�W,eH\`�eHk^Y ��� :������RTSqRTeha4QHYNSiYla%# R{aFx�RT_T_�S�a�WuohRTeLRdaFm�`�ZiYl]�Y^Z�� sXZbY[Y[\pc"WIe<w ='��¦ D �lr���_T_�Sba4W,a4Y^S"RTe&#�bk^`�cVc@jHeHRTk[W,a4Y9��x�RdaiQNY[WIk�Q�`,a4QHY^Z[wXWIep\Nx�Rd_T_<Yl]�Y^e�aijXWI_d_do�g�Yn]-RdSiR{a4Y[\�cVWIe�o6a4RdcVY^S('ur

|¡aFRTS�RTcqU1`�Z�a�WIe�a�a4`*eH`,a4Y6a4QHW,a�a4Qp`�jHf�Q `�jpZ�WISiSbjHcqUpa4Rd`�eHS�\H`�ep`Ia�f�jXW,Z4WIe�a4Y^Y�W*jHeHRd�%jpY6Y[��jHR �_TRdgHZiRdjHcNw�a4QHYlo3\H`~RdeHSijHZbY�a4QXW,a>���!�A ;^ � ��"!��� ��"# () ��^�� ^,b AP^��a` �3������^ � � ��"�� ^ ��� �"!�1�!^���� � �_^9)��"$ ��� � ���"#�A ���,^�"�� � A � � � �lr���S�WqZbY[SbjH_da[wHx:Yyx�RT_d_�g1YEWIgp_TYta4`qjHSbYEaiQHY�\HW,a�W�RdaiSiY^_dmOa4` �bUHRTk��"`�jpa �Fa4QpYY[��jHRd_TRdgHZiRdjHcAa4QXW,a�RdS�UH_�Wuo�Y^\�w%WIeH\qW,a�_dYuWIS�a�m�`�Z�_�WIZbf�Y�Y[ep`�jHf�QqS4WIcqUH_dY[S[w�x�Y�x�RT_d_pUHRdk���`�jpa�aiQHY�k[`�ZbZiY[kla`�eHY,r�P�QHRTS:RTS2W,_T_Jx:YtZbY[��jHRdZiY�ai`�\HY^]IY[_T`IU�k[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[e�a�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS�m�`�Z�a4QHYnUHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[ZbS:`Im�aiQHYtcq`-\HY^_¸r

P�`�SiY^Y:a4QXW>aOaiQHY:\HW,a�W�kuWIe�g1Y�jHSiY^\@a4`�UHRTk��y`�j-a�aiQHY�Y^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHcNw'eH`IaiY�aiQXW,auz���R��<a4QHY:WIf�Y^e�aiS�`IeH_dok[`IeH\HRdaiRT`�e.a4QHY^RTZ�U1Y^Zik[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS�`�e�a4QHY6g�Y[QHW']%Rd`�Z�`Im�aiQHY[RdZ@k[`IcVU�Y^aiRda4`IZiSE`�e�a4QHY"UHjHgH_dRTk[_{o.Wu]IW,RT_�W,gH_TYRTe-m�`�ZicVW,a4Rd`�e���`�e~�,�������i�&wJWIeH\��RdR���UHZbY[k^RTSiY^_do6aiQHYyS4WIcqYnRTe-m�`�ZicVW,a4Rd`�e"RdS�Wu]IW,RT_�W,gH_TY�a4`�a4QHYyY^k[`�eH`IcVY&�a4ZbRTk^R�WIe�r�©)`�ZiY^`']�Y[Z^wXRTe�Y[��jHRd_TRdgHZiRdjHc a4QHYnZbYuWI_dRT�[Y^\�\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�e"`ImBY^e�a4Z4W,e�aiS�WIeH\�Ylv-Rdai`�ZiS2m�Zb`�c Y[WIk�QSba4W,a4Yyc�jpSba�g1Ynk^`�eHSbRTSbaiY[e�a�x�Rda4Q�aiQHY[SbY�U�Y[Zbk[Y[R{]�Y^\�\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`IeHSy�¸«�a�WIZbZ�WIeH\ �`Hw ='����� �lr* �|á3ä�ã�êóïgýtñëêòøGêëÚ�è�å�ÚÜÛ|ä�á3þ|û�Ûtá�þrÚB±pÙ�±fêëñóñ[Ý�ãÜãyþ|ïÆÙ`Ú�ÛtÝ�Ú*ÚÜÛ|Ù²äÜÙ<Ý�ä�Ù<Þ|á!þ|Þ|ß�Þ|á�±fÞ»ýtÝ�äÜÝ�ïÆÙGÚ�ÙÍäÜã�êëÞ�Ú�Û|Ù�+ -, �Mü±þ|ÞtøGÚ�êóá�Þ¤åÝ�Þ�ìÎü±árøGþ�ãfá�Þ!ÙÍãyÚ�êóï_Ý«Ú�êóÞ|ûÆÚÜÛ|Ù�ýtÝ�äÈÝ�ïÆÙ²Ú�Ù²äÈãOìrÙGÚÜÙ²äÜïÆêëÞ|êóÞ|ûgÚ�ÛtÙ�Ù²ÞÚ�äÜè]Ý�Þ�ì]Ù�²�êëÚ�ìrêòã�ÚÜä�êóð|þrÚÜêëá3Þtã/.tãyÙÍÙ*Ú�Û|Ù�êóÞÚ�äÜá�ì|þtø�ÚÜêëá3Þ �0>³Èîpá3ïgï<þ|Þ|êòø²Ý�Ú�Ùb´�ÛtÙ²äÜÙ»ãyêóïÆý|ñëèÑïÆÙÍÝ�Þtã_ÚÜÛtÝ«ÚÎÚÜÛ|Ù�ýtä�á3ðtÝ�ð|êóñóê Ú�è´á�ü*Ú�äÈÝ�Þtã�ê ÚÜêëÞtûÀü±ä�á3ï á3Þ|Ù�ãyÚÜÝ«ÚÜÙ"Ú�á´Ý�Þ|á�Ú�Û|ÙÍä ±êóÞÝ�Þ�èTÞ�þ|ï`ðÂÙ²ä*á�üpý�ÙÍä�êóárì|ã ��êòã>ýÂá3ã�êëÚ�êó÷�Ù �21 ü�å¤êóÞaÝ3ì|ìrêëÚ�êóá�Þ¤åÂÚ�ÛtÙgìrêòãyÚ�äÜêëð|þ|Ú�êóá�Þ�á�üSÙ�²rêëÚ�Ý�Þtì"ÙÍÞ3ÚÜä�è!ü±ÙÍÙÍã*ÛtÝ®÷�Ù<þ|Þ�ð�á3þ|ÞtìrÙmìã�þ|ý|ýÂá�ä�ÚÜãÍåÕÝ�Þ�ì Ý�ñëñXN>¶ ã�øGá3ïgï<þ|Þ|êòø²Ý�Ú�Ù�±fêëÚ�ÛÀÙÍÝ3øÈÛaá�Ú�Û|ÙÍä ¦ã�á4365]êóã�Ù²äÜû�árìrêòø ��å2Ú�Û|ÙÍÞ Ú�Û|ÙÍä�Ù_êòã�Ù�²|Ý3ø�Ú�ñóè�á3Þ|Ù_äÜÙÍøGþtä�äÜÙ²ÞÚøGñòÝ�ãÜãOü±á3ä�ÙÍÝ3øÈÛ"Ùb·þ|êóñëêóð|äÜêëþtï!å�Ý�Þ�ìTê Ú*êóã>á�üjÚ�ÛtÙ�ü±á�äÜï87:9<; ?JMLON �>= �@? J�? JMLRN@ACB�D �MùÕáÎý|äÜá«÷�Ù�ÚÜÛ|êòã>Ý3ã�ã�Ù²ä�Ú�êóá�ÞTêëÚã�þ�EÎøGÙÍãpÚÜágÞtá�Ú�Ù*ÚÜÛtÝ«ÚMÝ�Þ�è KJMLRN ��ø²á�ïÆï`þ|ÞtêóøÍÝ«Ú�Ùmã<±fê ÚÜÛ ��-LON �@ü±á�äfãyá3ïÆÙ NFA�B9Ý�Þtì;Ngê ÚÈãyÙÍñ üYêóãOÙÍä�û3árìrêóø �YùOÛtêóãOêóïÆý|ñëêóÙÍãÚ�Û�Ý«Ú�Ý�ñóñ�ýÂá�êóÞ3ÚÈãfêóÞTÝ�Þ�è_ä�ÙmøGþ|äÜä�ÙÍÞÚfø²ñóÝ3ã�ãOø²á�ïÆï`þ|ÞtêóøÍÝ«Ú�Ù�±fêëÚ�ÛTÙÍÝ3øÈÛ)á�Ú�Û|ÙÍä��

¦

Page 10: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

]�`'xAZbY[kuW,_T_<aiQXW,a�a4QHYy\XW>a�W�x�RT_T_1Y^]IY[e�a4jXW,_T_do�x:WIeH\pY[Z�RTe�a4`�a4QpYEZbY[k^jHZiZbY[e�a�SbjHgHSbY^at`,mBU�`�RTe�aiS@� #N�lwWIeH\~`�eHk[Y"RTe #¬x�Rd_T_�]%RTSbRda�YuWIk�Q3U�`�RTe�a�RTe~R{a�ZbY[U�YuW,aiY[\H_{o�r���S@a4QpY6S4WIcqUH_dYVf�Yla4S�_TWIZifIYIw�x�Y6`�g-a�WIRdeWIe�Y[cqUHRTZbRTkuW,_�\HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�e!`Im�Y^e�a4Z4W,e�aiS�WIeH\~Ylv-Rdai`�ZiSym�Zi`�c®Y[WIk�Q �,������� :#�w�WIeH\�g�o�aiQHYV_TWux `Im_�W,Zif�Y�e%jpc�g1Y^ZiS2aiQXW,a�\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�eVx�Rd_T_�k[`�e�]�Y^Zif�Ynai`@a4QHYn\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�eVx�QpRTk�Q�f�Y[epY[Z4W>a4Y[\�R{ay� W,_Tcq`�SbaSijpZiY[_{op�lr���S�eH`Ia4Y^\NaiQHRTS�c�jpSba�g1YnaiQHYy\HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�e6aiQHY@W,f�Y[e�a4S�jHSbYEai`qm�`IZic aiQHY[RdZ�U1Y^Zik[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS^w�Sb`x�YtQXWu]�Y��bjHSba:RT\HY^e�aiRd�XY^\VaiQHY�U�Y[Zbk[Y[R{]�Y^\�\HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�eHS�eHY^Y[\HY^\6m�`�Z�WIf�Y[e�aiS�a4`�c"W,�IY�aiQHY[RdZ�\pY[k[RdSiRd`�eHS[r

� R{]�Y^eEaiQH`�SiY�U�Y[Zik^Y[R{]�Y[\�\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�epS[w#Y[��jXW,aiRT`�epS:� = ��WIeH\"� ¨ ��f�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4Y�W�jHeHRd�%jpY�g�Y[S�aBZbY[SiU�`�eHSbYm�`�Z�YuWIk�Q�RTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�atW,eH\�U�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�aur�P�QHRTS�RTSB�bjHS�a�a4QpYEmWIcqRT_dR�WIZ�Sba4W,a4Y^cVY^e�a�a4QXW>a�ZbYuWIkla4RT`Iem�jHeHkla4Rd`�eHSVWIZiY)f�Y[eHY^ZiRdkuWI_d_do jHepRT��jHYIw�W,eH\�kuW,e¥g�Y�UHZb`#]IY[e7jHSbRTeHf~£:_�W,k���x�Y[_d_ ��SVaiQHY[`�ZbY[c m�`�ZqSiRdeHf�_TYWIf�Y^e�a�\po%eXWIcqRTk�UHZb`�f�Z4W,cVS^r�«-RdeHk[Y2aiQHY[ZbY�RdS�`�eH_{o�`�epY�U�`�_dRTk^oyaiQXW,a�RTS�k^`�eHSbRTSbaiY[e�a�x�RdaiQqg�`IaiQFaiQHY�\XW,a4WWIeH\�`�jHZ�Y^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc W,SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�epS�W,a�YuWIk�Qh���������4 #�w<WIeH\*`�epk[Y@x�Y�WIZbY@RTeNa4QHY�SiYla # x�Y�Sba4W'oa4QpY[ZiYnm�`�ZbY^]IY[Z[wHaiQHY[ZbYyRTS�W�jHeHRd��jHYyY[��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc m�`�Z�W,e�o"SijHgpf�WIcqYES�a�WIZ�a4RdeHf�m�Zi`�c WIe�o!���������2k^`�jHUH_dYRTe #¬� W�SiYla�x�QHRTk�QNkuWIeNg�YERd\HY[e�aiRd�XY^\�m�Zb`�c aiQHYy\XW,a�W����[r

�~Y.eH`'x®k^`�cVY!gXW,k���a4`3a4QHY._TRdcVR{a�W,aiRT`�eHSq`Im@`�jHZNWISiSbjHcqUpa4Rd`�eHS[r �BW,Zba ¨ `,m���SbSijHcqUpaiRT`�e =RTcqUH_dRTY[SFa4QHW,a6a4QpY[ZiY!W,ZiY*eH` S�a�W,aiY�],WIZiRTWIgH_dY[SVaiQXW,a6aiQHY!WIf�Y^e�a4S�k[`IeH\HRdaiRT`�eLa4QHY^RTZ"U�Y[Zbk[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS�`�e�wgHjpaEa4QpYVY^k[`�eH`IcVYla4ZiRdk[RTWIe!\H`-Y^S�ep`Ia@`IgHSiY^Zb]�Y,r�|}e�aiQHRTSyk[`Ie�aiYlv%a@x�Y"SbQH`�jH_d\�ep`Ia4YFa4QXW>a������������yk[WIeZiY^UHZiY^SiY^e�a>��9�! ��� $!UHZi`I�pa4SEk[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eXWI_B`�e�aiQHYVRdepm�`�Zbc"W,aiRT`�e*W'],WIRd_�WIgp_TYFW,aya4QpYVg�Y[f�RdeHeHRdeHf�`Im2a4QpYU�Y[ZiRd`-\<r���kla4jXWI_<UHZi`I�pa4S�k[`IjH_T\6QHW']IYEWI\H\HR{a4RT`IeXWI_JRT\HRd`�Sbo%eHk^Z4W,aiRTk�WIeH\J�,`IZ2k[`�cqcq`�e6k[`IcVU�`�eHY^e�aiS2a4QXW>aWIZbY "���� �_b�� �A )� $�g�o.a4QHYVY[k^`�eH`�cqY^aiZiRTk^R�WIe<¢�RTeH\pY[Y[\~eH`Ia4QpRTeHf)RTe�aiQHRTSEUXWIU�Y[Z�k�QXWIeHfIY[S�R{m�Ylv-U�Y[k^aiY[\UHZb`I�Ha4SFQXWu]IY�WIe3jHep`�gHSiY^Zb]IY[\�k^`�cVU�`�eHY^e�a�a4QXW,a�x:WISFRTep\HY[U�Y[eH\pY[e�a"`']IY[Z�a4RdcVY,r �`'x�Y^]�Y^Z[w2R{m�a4QHRdSk[`IcVU�`�eHY^e�a"x:Y^ZiY�SiY^ZiRTWI_T_{o k[`�ZbZiY^_�W,aiY[\�w�`�ZVRdmna4QpY[ZiY)x:Y^ZiY!WIe�R r R r \¥jHeH`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\ k[`IcVU�`�eHY^e�aVa4QXW>ak�QXWIepf�Y[\NY[��jHRd_TRTgpZiRTjpc U�Y[Zbk[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS�� W�SbjHeHSiU�`Ia[wHm�`�Z�YlvpWIcqUH_TYu�lwpaiQHY[e�x�Ynx:`�jp_T\�QXWu]�Yya4`�k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`Iek[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�WIeH\*Y^e�a4ZboN],WI_TjpY[S�`Ie*jHeH`�gpSiY[Z�]�Y^\.SbQH`%k��%S^wCWIeH\�aiQHY@SbRTcqUH_TYya4Y^k�QHeHRd�%jpY[SnRTe�aiZi`%\HjHk[Y^\g�Y[_T`'x�ai`@Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y�a4QH`ISiY�],WI_djHY[S�kuW,e"eH`Ia�\H`Ea4QHRdS�k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeHRTeHfprB¤�Y[_TW,a4Y^\6WISbSijHcqUpa4Rd`�eHS�QXWu]�Y�g1Y^Y[eYlv%aiY[eHSbRd]�Y^_doFjHSbY[\VWIeH\F\HRdSik[jpSiSiY^\"Rde�a4QHY�k[`Ie�aiYlv%a�`Im�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiRTeHftSbRTeHfI_TY�WIfIY[e�a�\po%eXWIcqRTk2cq`-\pY[_TS��SiY^Y�BW,�IY[S^w =u��� � wpWIeH\�a4QHYy_TR{a4Y^Z4W,aijHZiYtk^RdaiY[\�a4QHY^ZiY'�&r

� eHY�cq`�ZbY�U1`�Rde�a�`IeV��SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�e = r ¨ r ��Y�SiQH`'x7a4QHW,a�a4QHRdS�W,SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�eFY^eXWIgH_dY[S�jHS�ai`�Rd\HY[e�aiRdm�oa4QpYEY^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc k�QH`�SbY[e�Rde�a4QHYyUXWIS�auwHaiQ%jpS �bSb`�_d]%RdeHf��a4QpYEY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Rd`�e6UHZb`�gH_TY^c f�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4Y^\)g�o�a4QpYU�`�SiSbRTgHRd_TRda}o�`ImXc�jp_da4RdUH_TYBY[��jHRT_dRTgHZbR�Wpr�|¡aB\H`%Y[SOeH`Iauw,QH`'x:Yl]�Y^Z[w�Y[eHWIgH_TY�jHSCa4`�jpSiY�aiQHY:ZbY[SbjH_daiS�a4`�Y^],WI_djXW,aiYU�`�_TRdk^o�k�QHWIeHf�Y^S:`�Z�`IaiQHY[Z�k�QXWIepf�Y[S�RTe�a4QHY�Y[e�]%RTZb`�eHcqY[e�aur � epk[Y�x:Y�k�QXWIeHf�Y�a4QpY�Y^e�]-RdZi`�epcVY^e�a:WyeHY^xY[��jHRd_TRdgHZiRdjHc x�Rd_T_1g1Yyk�QH`�SbY[e�w�Si`qUHZbY[\HRdk^a4Rd`�eHS�k[WIeHeH`Ia�g�Yyc"WI\pYyx�R{a4QH`Ijpa�Wqcq`�ZbYn\HY^a4WIRT_dY[\NWIeXWI_{o%SiRTS� ùOÛ|Ù²äÜÙÎêòã`Ý"ìrÙ²ÚÜÝ�êëñpïgêòãÜãyêóÞ|û»Û|ÙÍä�Ù �!ùOÛtá�þ|û3Û ýÂá�êóÞÚÜã`êëÞ 7 øÍÝ�Þ�á�Þ|ñóè�øGá�ïÆï<þ|Þ|êòø²Ý«ÚÜÙ�±fê ÚÜÛ$á�ÚÜÛ|Ù²ä`ý�á3êëÞÚÜã`êëÞ 7&êëüá�ý|Ú�êóïÆÝ�ñpýÂá�ñóêòøGêóÙÍãgÝ�äÜÙÎü±á�ñóñóá�±pÙmì�åYÚ�Û|ÙÍä�Ù!Ý�äÜÙ]ãyá3ïÆÙ]ýÂá�êóÞ3ÚÈã²å�³�ð�á3þ|Þtì|Ý�ä�è�ýÂá�êóÞÚÜ㸴"êëÞ�Ú�Û|Ù)Ú�ÙÍä�ïÆêóÞ|á�ñóá�û3èaá�ü�æ[Ý�ß3ÙÍã�Ý�Þtì

�»ømí*þ|êëäÜÙ ����������GåtÚÜÛtÝ«Ú�øGá3þ|ñóì�øGá�ïÆï<þ|Þ|êòø²Ý«ÚÜÙ�±fêëÚ�Û»ýÂá�êóÞÚÜã*á�þ|ÚÜã�êóìrÙ<á�ü�7�êëü@ü±ÙÍÝ3ãyêóð|ñóÙ`ð|þ|Ú�ã�þ|ðÂá�ýrÚÜêëï_Ý�ñYýÂá�ñóêóø²êëÙmãO±�Ù²äÜÙü±á�ñóñóá�±pÙmì �[ù2ágü±þ|ñóñëè!Ý�ÞtÝ�ñëè�öÍÙ*Ùi·þ|êëñóêóð|ä�êòÝ<ü±á�äMã�þ|ð|ûÝ�ïÆÙÍã�êóÞ7»åtð�á3þ|Þtì|Ý�ä�èÎýÂá�êóÞÚÜãfÞtÙ²ÙÍì]Ú�á_ðÂÙ�Ú�äÜÙÍÝ�Ú�Ùmì)ã�Ù²ýtÝ�äÜÝ�Ú�ÙÍñëè ÖãyÙÍÙæ[Ý�ß3ÙÍãOÝ�Þ�ì �»ømí*þ|êóä�Ù3å ��������� � 1�ÞTá3þ|äMø²Ý3ãyÙ*Ú�ÛtÙ�á�Þ|ñóè]ìrÙmøGêòãyêóá�Þtã�ÚÜÛtÝ«ÚMêóÞ�÷�á3ñë÷3Ù>ðÂá�þ|Þ�ì|Ý�äÜèÎýÂá�êóÞ3ÚÈãfÝ�äÜÙ*Ú�Û|Ù�ìrÙmøGêòãyêóá�Þ�ãOá�üÙ²ÞÚÜäÜÝ�Þ3ÚÈãfÝ«ÚMÚÜÛ|Ù�ï_Ý�²rêóï`þ|ï Jaá3ðtã�Ù²äÜ÷�ÙÍì]ü±á�ä>Ý�Þ�è]û3êë÷3Ù²Þ"N .tÚ�Û�þtã�±�Ù�ø²Ý�Þ!ÙmÝ�ã�êëñóè]êòã�á�ñòÝ«Ú�Ù*ÚÜÛ|Ù²ïTå�Ý�Þtì!Þ|á�ÚMþtãyÙ�Ú�Û|ÙÍïWêóÞÚ�ÛtÙ�ÙÍãyÚ�êóïÆÝ�Ú�êóá�ÞTÝ�ñóû�á3ä�êëÚ�Û|ï �

Page 11: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

`Im�a4QHY�ZbY[_TW,a4Rd`�eHSiQpRTU g�Y^a}x�Y[Y[eha4QHY�Y^�%jpRT_TRdgHZiRTW)k�QH`ISiY[eLRTe�aiQHY�UXWISbaVWIep\3aiQH`�SbY�aiQXW,aqWIZbY�_TRd�IY[_{o�ai`UHZbY^],WIRT_<RTe�a4QHYnm�jpaijHZiY,wJW�a4`�UHRdktx�QHRTk�Q<wHa4QH`�jpf�Q)RdcVU�`�Z�a�WIe�auw-RTS�g�Y^oI`�eH\�a4QHYySik^`�U�Y�`ImOa4QpRTS�UXWIU�Y[Z^r

����� ����� E²HÍETD@E ��� hiF>RTJf\)EGZ<D ���Y)eH`'x k�QXW,Z4WIkla4Y[ZbRT�^Y)Y^�%jpRT_TRdgHZiRdjHc g�Y[QHW']%Rd`�Z[w2g�Y[fIRTeHeHRdeHf�x�RdaiQLa4QHW,a"`,mtRTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�aiS[w�WIep\La4QpY[ecq`#]%RdeHf�a4`Fa4QXW>a�`ImBU�`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y[e�aiZ4WIe�a4S^r

«-RTepk[YyY[e�a4Z�oNWIeH\NYlv-Rda�\HY^k[RdSiRT`IeHS�WIZiYySiRdc�jH_{a�WIeHY^`�jHS�W,eH\)RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a4S@�U�`Ia4Y^e�aiR�WI_<Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S���WIZbYRT\pY[e�a4RdkuWI_njHU a4`3a4QHY.\HZiW'x `Ie Y&vpR{a ��Y[e�a4Z�op��m�Y[Y^S[wtm�`�ZNWIe RTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a ��SNg1Y^QXWu]-Rd`�Z�a4`hg1Y.gXWISbY[\`�e () ��^�� ^,b AP^��a` U1Y^Zik[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS�R{a `�� ���"U�Y[Zik^Y[R{]�Y.WI_T_�k[`IcVU�Y^aiRTeHf�RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a4S6a4` QHW']IY*a4QHY�SiWIcqYUHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a}oV`,m�Y&v-Rdauw-a4QXW,a�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda}oqg1Y^RTeHf�aiQHYnUHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a}oqaiQXW,a2aiQHYyZ4WIep\H`�c \pZ4Wux¯`Ie�aiQHYnYlv-R{am�Y[YnRdS:f�ZbYuW,aiY[Z:aiQXWIe6aiQHYt],WI_TjHY�`ImOk[`�e�aiRTe�jHRTepfHr�|�r�YIr�a4QHY�U1Y^Zik[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS�eHY^Y[\HY^\�a4`�m�`�Zbc k^`�e�a4RTe�jXW>a4RT`Ie],WI_TjpY[S�WIZbYym�`IZicqY[\NWIS

8 V �,5&�X%!S �����Y��Z[ = �! � A ��%*�X� J = S �����Y���I��8 V �,5YS �����Y��Ze = � � � �x�QHY^ZiYym�`�Z 2 � %

A ��%*�42QS �����Y���I�! ���A � .G ' �/.V�,�����Y�����(SU� 0 ��� A�� = J .

G 'N�/.V�,�����Y���I�7SU� 0�� A��" $ 86V&�,5YS �����Y��Ze = �RTS�k^`�eHSbRTSbaiY[e�a�x�Rda4Q�aiQHYyg1Y^QXWu]-Rd`�Z�`Im�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S^r

���%jpRT_TRdgHZiRdjHc®ZiY^��jHRTZbY[S�a4QHW,a�WI_d_�U�`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y^e�a4Z4W,e�aiS�QXWu]�Y6aiQHY6S4W,cVY6UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda}o�`Im�Y^e�aiY[ZbRTeHfHwa4QHW,a@UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda}o�g�Y[RdeHfNaiQHY"UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda}o�aiQXW,a�a4QHYqZ4WIep\H`�c \HZ4Wux `�e.a4QHYVY[e�a4Z�o!m�Y[Y"RdS�_dY[SbS�a4QHWIea4QpYE],WI_djHY�`,m�Y[e�a4Z�o�r � `�eHSbY[��jHY^e�ai_doIw<RTe () �a^�� ^,b AP^���` a4QHY�U1Y^Zik^Y[UpaiRT`�eHS�ZiY^�%jpRTZiY^\)ai`"kuW,_Tk[jp_�W,aiYEY^e�a4Zbo],WI_TjpY[S�S4W>a4RTS�m�o

8 ? �,5&�X%!S �����Y��Z ? = �! � A ��%*���=S �����Y�����R8 ? �W5YS �����Y��Z ? = � �x�QHY^ZiY� A ��%*���=S �����Y�����2RdS�\HY^�XepY[\*W,S�Rde�Y[��jXW,aiRT`�e�� � �lwXWIep\

8 ? �,5YS �����Y��Z ? = �! � ? �W5cJ = � % J = S �����Y���I� � � � �x�QHY^ZiY ��� � 5

? �W5&��� S �����Y����� <����? � . 0 ' � � �6�������Y�����7S ��0 ? � = J . 0 ' � ���"�,�����Y�����(SU� 0�� �!� ? \]�`IaiYna4QXW,a�aiQHRTS�RdcVUH_dRTY^S�a4QHW,a�m�`�Z�RTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�aiS86Vl�W5YS �����a��Ze = �!<I8C�W5YS �����Y���I� � ? �,5&� % S �����a�����P\

='ª

Page 12: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

� ������������������� ���"��(]�"�� ����-��#��- � ��> ���� �a ����-I�|}eqY[��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc­a4QpY�U�Y[Zbk[Y[U-a4RT`IeHS�`,m<U�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_XY[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S�WIeH\qRTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a4S�c�jHS�a�g�Y�k[`�epSiRTS�a4Y^e�a�x�RdaiQx�QXW,a:RTS:WIk^aijXWI_T_{o�`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\<r�P�QHRdS�mWIkla2_dYuWI\HS�\HRTZbY[kla4_do�ai`�W�e�jHc@g1Y^Z2`ImCWI_{a4Y^ZieXW,aiRd]IY�a}x�`,�}S�a4Y^U�SiY[cqR{�UXWIZiWIcqY^a4ZbRTk�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbStm�`�Zta4QpYqUHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[ZbSn`Im�aiQHYFcV`%\HY^_¸wCWIeH\�x�YVg�Y[fIRTe�x�RdaiQ!aiQHYFSiRdcVUH_dY[S�an`Ima4QpY[cNr�|¡a4S��XZiS�a2SbaiY[U�k^`�cVUpjpa4Y^S2Wu]�Y^Z4WIf�Y^S2`Im�aiQHY�ZbYuWI_dRT�^Y[\qk[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�e���Y[e�a4Z�op��],WI_TjpY[S:`,mCWI_T_H�HZicqSx�QH`�\HRT\3k[`Ie�aiRTe�jHY~�Y^e�aiY[Z4�VW,aVWI_{a4Y[ZbeXW,aiRd]�Y6],WI_djHY[SF`Im��,�������lr�«-RTepk[Y)WIf�Y[e�aiS ��Ylv-U�Y[k^a4W,a4Rd`�eHSqc�jHS�ag�Y�k[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[e�aFx�RdaiQ3Wu]�Y[ZiWIf�Y�ZiY[WI_TRd�uW,aiRT`�epS[wBaiQHY[SbY)Wu]IY[Z4W,f�Y[S�x�RT_d_�k^`�e�]�Y^Zif�Y�a4`*aiQHY6a4ZbjHY�Ylv-U�Y[k^aiY[\k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e*�Y^e�aiZbop��],WI_djHY[S�x:YtWIZiY�W,m�a4Y^Z[r�P�QHY�SiY[k^`�eH\�S�a4Y[U�`,m�a4QHY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiRT`�eqUHZi`%k[Y^\HjHZbY�a4ZbYuW,aiSa4QpY[SiY.Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�`Im�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e ��Y[e�a4Z�oH�6],WI_TjpY[S�WIS�a4QpY�W,k^a4jHWI_nk[`�e�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e ��Y[e�a4Z�oH�6],WI_TjpY[S[wWIeH\�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�a4QHY�cq`%\HY[_�� S�UXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[ZbSng�o��Haba4RTepf"a4QHY�cq`%\HY[_�� StUpZiY[\pRTk^aiRT`�epS�m�`�ZtY^e�a4Zbo�WIeH\�Ylv-R{ak[`IeH\HRdaiRT`�eHWI_<`�eNWI_{a4Y^ZieXW,aiRd]IYnUXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[Z2],WI_djHY[S�ai`FaiQHYy\XW,a4WF`Ie)Y^e�aiZbo�W,eH\)Y&v-Rda�Z4W>a4Y[S^r

� `�eH\HR{a4Rd`�eXWI_-`�e�`�jHZ�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[S�`,m1Y^e�a4Zbo�WIeH\Fk[`�e�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�w,a4QHY^ZiY�WIZiY�k^_T`�SbY[\�m�`�Zbc Y&vpUpZiY[SbSiRd`�eHSm�`�Zya4QHY"Y[e�a4Z�o�WIep\�Ylv-Rda�Z4W>a4Y[S@UHZiY^\HRTkla4Y[\~g�o.a4QpY"cq`-\HY^_¸r)©)`�ZbY[`']�Y^Z[w�W,a@_TY[WISba�jHeH\HY^Z�k[`Ie�]IY[eHRdY[e�aSiU�Y[k^Rd�Xk[W,a4Rd`�e"m�`�Z�a4QHY�\HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�eV`ImCYlv-Rda�],WI_TjHY^Sy� W,eH\6ZiY^f�WIZb\H_TY^SiS2`Im�aiQHYnWISbSijHcqUpaiRT`�e6`Ie6a4QHYt\pRTS��a4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`Ieq`,m�Y[e�aiZbo�],WI_TjpY[S��&w�`�jHZ�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`Im ��."�:3 ��WIeH\ ���6�:3 ��WIZbY�_dRTeHY[WIZ�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�eHS�`Im<],WIZbR�WIgp_TY[Sa4QHW,a�kuWIeNg�Ynk[`�eHS�a4ZbjHk^aiY[\�\pRTZiY^k^ai_do"m�Zb`�c aiQHYy\XW,a4WqW,eH\)QpY[_T\��pv-Y^\Nm�`�Z2aiQHYyY[e�a4RdZiYnY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4RT`Ie�ZijHe�rP�Q�jHS�aiQH`�jHf�Q)`�jHZ�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z�RTS�Wqa}x�`6SbaiY[U*Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z^wXRda9^ � "�����WVeHY^SbaiY[\*�pv-Y[\�U1`�Rde�a�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z��aiQHY�\XW,a�Wya4ZiWIeHSbm�`IZicVW,a4Rd`�e�x�QHRTk�Q"RTS�ZiY^�%jpRTZiY^\"a4`E`�gpa4WIRTeFa4QpY�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[S�`Im �/."�:3 ��WIeH\ �/�"�43 ��eHY^Y[\eH`Iatg1Y�ZbY[\H`IeHY�Y^]IY[Zbo�a4RTcqY�x�Y�Y^],WI_djXW,aiY@a4QHY�`Ig%�bY[kla4Rd]IY�m�jHeHkla4RT`Ie!W,anW6\HR{�<Y^ZiY^e�an],WI_djHY@`,m�aiQHY�UXW>�Z4W,cVYla4Y[Z2]IY[kla4`�Z4�lr�P�QHRTS�RdS2a4QHYyZiY[WISi`Ie�aiQHYyY[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z2\H`%Y[S�eH`Ia�QHW']IY@W�SbRTf�eHR{�XkuW,e�a�k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_gHjHZb\HY[e<r

�~Y.Sba4WIZbaNx�RdaiQ aiQHY.`�eH_do�\HY^a4WIRT_dY[\ kuWI_dk[jH_TW,a4Rd`�e7`[email protected]�Y[Z���a4QXW>a�ZbY[��jHRTZbY[\ a4`hk[`�cqUHjpaiY`�jHZ�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S@`,mK�/.V�43 �yWIeH\����6�:3 �lr,��Y"a4QHY^e�k[`IcVYVgXWIk��!a4`�aiQHY"Rde�aijHRdaiRT`�e.jHeH\pY[Zi_{o%RTeHf�aiQHY[SbYY[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS�W,eH\NWq\HRdSik^jHSiSbRT`�e�`Im�a4QHY^RTZ�RTcqUH_dRTkuW>a4RT`IeHS�m�`�Z2a4QHYyY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4RT`Ie�WI_Tf�`IZiRdaiQHcNr

��� � L¤X[E � J*XYFML Z� ��� k�� � J�bTc���� k�� � �� `�eHSbRT\HY^ZFWIe RTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�a�Rde3W*c"W,Zi�IYla�x�RdaiQ�� J = `,a4QHY^Z�RTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a4SFWIep\ UXWIZbaiRTk^jH_�WIZE],WI_TjHYV`Im�p¢�R¸r�YIr�aiQHY"cVWIZb�IY^a�RTS@Rde~S�a�W,aiY!�,�������lr�|¡m�aiQHY6RdeHk[jHc@g1Y^e�a�\HY[k^RT\HY^S@a4`*k^`�e�a4Rde%jpYIw�QHRdS��Y&v-U1Y^k^a4Y^\J�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�],WI_djHYnRTS�Y^�%jHWI_�a4`

�9."�������-¢���� �9V� D @ CED � ���,��MO���NM � ) � � G D � c"W#v 'N�9."��� M ���NM�¢��I� �P�6M 06S � MO���NM � �&� � � �x�QHY^ZiY

* � M WIeH\ � M WIZbY�a4QpY@eHY&v-atU1Y^ZiRT`%\���S�],WI_djHY[S�`Im��,��������WIeH\e� M RTS�a4QpY�RTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a ��S�\pZ4Wux `�e�a4QpYY&vpR{a�],WI_TjHYnRde�a4QXW,a�U�Y[ZbRT`%\�wXWIep\

=�=

Page 13: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

* � V� D @ CED �:3 ��a4WI�IY^SEaiQHYFYlv-U1Y^k^a4W,a4Rd`�e!`Im�aiQHY�m�jpa4jpZiYFSba4W,a4YFk[`IeH\HRdaiRT`�eHWI_B`�e�aiQHYFRTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�ayRdaiSiY[_{mk^`�e�a4RTe�jHRdeHfHr� R{]�Y^e�WVZbYuWI_dRT�uW>a4RT`Ie�`Im��,� M ��� M ��aiQHY�RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a�x�RT_d_�Ylv-Rda�Rdm!� M 7#�/.V�,� M ��� M ¢����&w1Sb`VaiQHY@Y&vpU�Y[k&�

a�W>a4RT`Ie�`Im�aiQHYyk[`�e�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�],WI_TjpYtm�Zi`�c WqZbYuWI_dRT�uW>a4RT`Ie"`Im��,� M ��� M �:RdS�f�Rd]IY[eNg�o�G D � c"W>vQ'N��."��� M ��� M ¢��I� �P� M 06S � M ��� M � � § �

�12�'N� � ��.V�,� MO���NM�¢��I�P0N�9."��� MO���NM�¢��I� )��12�'N� 7���.V�,� MO���NM�¢����P0��%� �6MTSU�QM 7��/.V�,��MO��� M�¢���� �T\PO`VSbRTcqUH_TR{m�oqaiQHRTS�Y&v-UHZiY^SiSiRd`�e�_dY^a

8 A �,��MR���NM{�!<��12 'N� 7��/.V�,��MO���NM�¢�����0g�Y*a4QHY�Y&vpR{a�UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o¯��a4QHRdS6RTS�W,e `Ig%�bY[klaNx�Y�kuW,e Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Yu�lw�WIeH\$RTeHR{a4RTWI_T_{o WISbSijHcqY�a4QXW,a��\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4Y[S�Y&v-U1`�epY[e�a4RTWI_T_{o!�O.V�T�1�! = Jf5 ��������� G �2Si`Fa4QHW,a

�%� �!S � 7 �9."��� MR��� M�¢��I� � ��."��� MO���NM�¢��I� )� ���x�Yyf�Y[epY[Z4W,_TRT�^Yn`�e�a4QHRdS�WISiSbjHcqUpa4Rd`�e�g1Y^_T`'x��lr�«-jpgHSbaiRda4j-a4RTepf�a4QHY^SiYy]IW,_TjHY^S�RTe�a4`)� § �lwXWIep\�aiQHYyZiY^SijH_{aRTe�ai`�� � ��x�Y�f�Yla�/.V�,�����p¢��I� �� V� D @ CED �U���,� M ��� M � ) � � = J 8 A �,� M ��� M �i�6�/.V�,� M ��� M ¢���� ) � 8 A �,� M ��� M ���,�/.V�,� M ��� M ¢���� )� C� �

�9V� D @ CED � ����� MR��� M{� ) � ��.V�,��MR���NMT¢���� ) � 8 A �,� M ���NM{�� � \ � ¦ ��~Y�ep`#x eHY^Y[\3Si`�cqY6cVW,a4ZbR{v�eH`Ia4W,a4Rd`�e�r���ZiZ4W,eHf�Y��/.V�,�����p¢��I�@RTe�a4`)a4QHY6]IY[k^ai`�ZH�/.V�W�I�lw�Ylv-R{a

UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^S�RTe�a4`qa4QHY�]�Y[kla4`�Z 8 A w�W,eH\*RTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�aiS ��U1Y^Zik[Y^Rd]IY[\�a4ZiWIeHSiR{a4Rd`�e)UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�Rde�ai`"a4QpYcVW,a4ZbR{v�� V r�P�QHY[e

�/."�,��� <�� V � � ) � ��.V�W���*) � Y8 A � �� V � � ) � Y8 A � ) � � V �/.V�W���P\ � � ����%jHW,a4Rd`�eh� � ��k[`�cqUHjpaiY[S9�/.V�43 ��WIS�aiQHY�SijHc `Im�Ylv-U�Y[k^aiY[\.k[jHZbZiY^e�aEZbY^a4jpZieHSyWIep\.R{a4SbY[_dm���x�QHY[ZbY

eH`'x k[jHZbZiY[e�aFZbY^a4jpZieHSFRTepk[_Tjp\HYVaiQHY�Ylv-U�Y[k^aiY[\hYlv-k[Y^SiSqZiYla4jHZbeHS�m�Zi`�c a4QpY�U1`�SbSiRdgHRT_dRda}o!`Im�Ylv-R{a&�lr!PO`Si`I_d]�Ynm�`�Z �9."�,���i�2SbjHgHSbaiRdaijpa4Yya4QHYyY&vpUpZiY[SbSiRd`�e)m�`�ZK��."�,���2RTe�� � �:RTe�a4`�a4QpY�ZbRTf�Q�a�QXWIep\)SbRT\HYy`ImOa4QXW>aS4W,cVYnY^�%jHW,a4Rd`�e�W,eH\�Rda4Y^Z4W,aiYta4`qf�Y^a

��.V�W�I� �� V �U� ) � Y8 A ��) � � V � � � ) � a8 A ��) � � � V � �/."�,��� � ='ª �\ \ \ �>

��� �� � � �V � � ) � a8 A � ����/J � � V ������� V � � ) � a8 A �W�

a4QpYEk^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e�]IW,_TjHYnRde6a4Y[ZbcVS�`ImOa4QpYEY&v-U1Y^k^a4Y^\*\HRdSik[`IjHe�a4Y[\�],WI_TjpYn`ImBk^jHZiZbY[e�a�ZiY^aijHZiepS[r

=#¨

Page 14: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

P�QXW,aVRTS�k^`�e�a4RTe�jXW>a4RT`Ieh],WI_djHY[SFkuW,eLg�Y�k[`�cqUHjpaiY[\¥g�o a4WI��RTeHf�a4QpY)Y&vpU�Y[kla�W,aiRT`�eh`']�Y^ZqaiQHY)\pRTS��k[`IjHe�a4Y[\�m�jpaijHZiY�ZiYla4jHZbeHS�a4QXW>aBa4QpY��XZbc k^`�jH_T\@YuWIZbe�`#]IY[Z�W,_da4Y^ZieXW>a4Rd]IY:U�`�SiSbRTgH_dY�m�j-a4jHZbY2S4WIcqUH_dY�UXW>a4QHS^rP�QHRdStRTcqUH_TRdY[S�a4QXW>a�x�Y�kuWIe�`�g-a�WIRde�W6k[`�epSiRTS�a4Y^e�ayY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y�`Im�a4QHY�k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e�],WI_TjpY@g�o�Wu]�Y^Z4WIf>�RTepfN`']IY[Zya4QHYF\HRdSik[`IjHe�a4Y[\ ��m�jpaijHZiY9�)ZbY^a4jpZieHS�WIk^aijXWI_d_do*Y[WIZiepY[\.g�o�aiQHY��XZicqSnx�QH`Nk[`�e�a4Rde�jHY[\.m�Zi`�cSba4W,a4Y6�,�������lrt©)`�ZbY@UHZbY[k[RdSiY^_do�x:Y�x�RT_T_�k^`�cqUHjpa4Y�k[`�epSiRTS�a4Y^e�a�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�`,m�a4QHYEa4ZiWIeHSiR{a4Rd`�e�W,eH\*Ylv-R{aUHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^S[w-R¸r�YIr:`,m � V WIeH\ 8 A wJWIeH\)SijHgHS�a4R{a4jpaiYEaiQHY[c Rde�ai`*� ='ª �&r:£�o�aiQHYEk[`�e�a4Rde�jH`�jHS�c"W,UHUHRTepfa4QpY[`�ZbY[c aiQHRTS�x�RT_d_<f�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4YEW�k[`IeHSiRdSba4Y^e�a�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Yn`Im ��.Fr

�Y^a�@�,������� '��:z���� :������= �,�������P0

g�YyaiQHYySiYla�`,mBU�Y[ZbRT`%\HS2x�RdaiQ�aiQHYyS4WIcqYV�,�������lr�P�QHY^e�wJg�o6a4QHY�©�W,Zi�I`']�UHZb`�U�Y[Zba}oIw�8 A �,������� =� �@�,������� >���� � � @ C �

%6�RTSNW3SijHc `,m��k^`�eH\HR{a4Rd`�eXWI_d_dop�qRdeH\HY[U�Y[ep\HY[e�a*\pZ4Wux�S)`Ie aiQHY�Y&v-RdaNUHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o¥WIeH\ k[`�e�]IY[ZifIY[S)ai`8 A ����������UpZi`']%RT\HY^\ � �@�,�������� ¯r

�Y^a � V @ � � @ C � @ � � D @ C:D � g�Y�WIeVRTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a ��S:UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda}o�`,m<a4ZiWIeHSbRda4RdeHf"�RTeFa4QpY�eHY&v%a2U�Y[ZiRd`-\X��ai`@S�a�W,aiY�,� M ��� M �lw�k^`�eH\HR{a4Rd`�eXWI_O`�e�eH`IatYlv-RdaiRTeHf�Rde*Sba4W,a4YN���������&w�R¸r�YIrna4QpY�Y[_dY[cqY[e�an`Im�cVW,a4ZbR{v � V RTe*aiQHY�Zi`'xk[`IZiZiY^SiU�`�eH\HRdeHf!a4`~S�a�W,aiY��,�������qW,eH\¥k^`�_TjHcqe3k[`�ZbZiY^SiU�`�eH\HRdeHf�ai`�S�a�W,aiY���� M ��� M �lrLP�QHY[e<w2UHZi`']%RT\pY[\� �@�,��������� ¯w�x:Y�k[WIe7`�gpa4WIRTe¥k[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[e�a�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y�`,mEaiQHRTSVUHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}ohW,S"a4QHY*m�ZiWIk^aiRT`�eL`ImRTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�aiS�eH`Ia�Y&vpR{a4RdeHf�RTe"Sba�W>a4Yq�,��������x�QH`�aiZ4WIepSiRda:a4`�Sba4W,a4Y��,� M ��� M ��Rde"a4QpYneHYlv%a�U�Y[ZiRd`-\<w%aiQXW,a�RdS

�� V @ � � @ C � @ � � D @ C D � � ���� � � @ C � ���;J %6 � =�� � ������� @ C ����� � � � � D @ CED ���� ���� � � @ C � �,�;J %6 � �

x�QHY^ZiY =�� � ������� @ C ����� � � � � D @ C D ��� RdSNaiQHY~RdeH\HRTk[W,a4`IZ�m�jpeHk^aiRT`�e¯x�QpRTk�Q¯a4WI�IY^S*`�e¯aiQHY�],WI_djHY�`,mF`�eHY�x�QpY[e�,���� � ������ � � �,� M ��� M ��WIeH\3�[Y^Zi`!Y[_dSiY^x�QpY[ZiY,r ]�`IaiY6a4QXW,a[w�a4`.WIk[k^`�jHe�a�m�`�Z�aiQHY6mWIk^a�aiQXW,a�aiQHY�RTe-�k[jpc�g1Y^e�a4S�k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`Ie.aiQHY[RdZ�k[WI_Tk^jH_�W,aiRT`�epSn`�e~a4QpY[cqSiY[_{]�Y^S@k[`Ie�aiRTe�jHRdeHfHw�x�YVx�Y[Rdf�Q�a@aiQHYVaiZ4WIeHSbRdaiRT`�eHSm�Zi`Ic �,�������tRTe*aiQHYF\HRd�1Y[ZbY[e�ayU�Y[ZiRd`-\pSng�o�a4QHY�e�jHc�g�Y[Zy`Im�RTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�aiStx�QH`�W,k^a4jHWI_T_{o�k^`�e�a4RTe�jHYFRdea4Qp`�SiYyU�Y[ZiRd`-\pS��ur

«-jHgHS�a4R{a4jpaiRTeHf@aiQHY[SbYnY[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S2Rde�ai`�Y[��jXW>a4RT`Ie!� ='ª �lw-x�Ytf�Yla�`�jHZ:k[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[e�a�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y�`Im���. W,S���."�,��� �>

��� �� � �� �V � � ) � �8 A � � ��J � �� V � ��� �� V �U� ) � �8 A �T\ � =�= �

�ÍùOÛ|Ù²äÜÙÎÝ�äÜÙ_Ý�ñëÚ�ÙÍä�ÞtÝ�Ú�êó÷�Ù2±OÝ®è�ã>ÚÜá"û�ÙGÚ�ÚÜáTÚ�Û|êòã�ü±á3ä�ï<þ|ñóÝ � �|äÜá�ï�á3þ|ä�Ùb·þ|êóñóêëð|äÜêóþ|ïvÝ3ã�ã�þ|ïÆýrÚ�êóá�Þ�ã*Ú�Û|ÙÎþtÞ[±�Ù²êóû�ÛÚÜÙÍìÚ�äÈÝ�Þ�ãyêëÚ�êóá�Þtãfü±ä�á3ï ?JMLON �fÝ�äÜÙ�û�ÙÍÞ|Ù²äÈÝ«ÚÜÙÍì!ð�è! �" .OJMLON �$#% �&".OJMLON �('tùOÛ|Ù`êëÞtø²þ|ï`ðÂÙ²ÞÚ�øGá�ïÆý|þ|Ú�ÙÍã>øGá3Þ3ÚÜêëÞ�þtÝ�Ú�êóá�ÞT÷«Ý�ñóþ|ÙÍãøGá3ÞtìrêëÚ�êóá�ÞtÝ�ñSá3Þ$ê ÚÈãyÙÍñ ü*øGá�ÞÚÜêëÞ�þ|êóÞ|ûtå[ã�á�êëÚgÝ®÷3Ù²äÈÝ�û�Ùmã�±fê ÚÜÛ) �" .OJ�*XT � LRN+* �,#- �&".OJ�*OLRN+* �.'jâ>ã<Ý�ä�Ùmãyþtñ Ú<Ú�á�á3ðrÚÜÝ�êëÞ$Ý�Þþ|Þ�ð|êòÝ�ã�ÙÍìÆÙmã�ÚÜêëï_Ý«ÚÜÙ�á�ü�Ú�Û|Ù�øGá3Þ3ÚÜêëÞ�þtÝ�Ú�êóá�Þ_÷«Ý�ñóþ|Ùmã@þtã�ÙÍì_ð�èÆêóÞtøGþ|ï<ð�ÙÍÞÚÜã1±fÛ|Ù²Þ_ÚÜÛ|Ù²èÆï_Ý�ß3ÙfÚ�ÛtÙ²êóä�ìrÙmøGêòãyêóá�Þ�ã�±�ÙMÞ|ÙÍÙÍìÆÚÜáï`þtñ ÚÜêëý|ñóèTÙÍÝ3øÈÛ!äÜÙÍÝ�ñëêóöÍÝ�Ú�êóá�Þt±fêëÚ�Û/ �" .OJ * T � LON * �102 �" .OJ * LRN * �6943 �'T 5" * 08J * ��6�073 �'T!8:9* 6p±fÛ|êòøÈÛ"êóãMÚ�Û|Ù�±pÙÍêëû3Û3Ú�Ý�ð�á«÷3Ùá�Þ�øGÙ�±pÙ�ã�þ|ðtãyÚ�êëÚ�þrÚÜÙ/;8:9* 9 � *�<�=?>A@�B 5DC " * 0 � *�<�=E>F@�B 5DC J * ü±á�äG8:9* �= D

Page 15: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

� � ��� H²EGQfJ*X[EGZgbTL J�bTc���F�bTFMD[J�H²E��fJ*XjE²Z<bTL �]�`,a4Y@�XZbSbataiQXW,a�`�jHZ�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`Im�k^`�e�a4RTe�jXW>a4RT`Ie�],WI_TjHY^StWIZbY��bjHS�ata4QpY�Wu]�Y[ZiWIf�Y^Sn`Im�a4QHY@\HRTSbk[`�jHe�aiY[\],WI_TjpY[S�`Im%a4QHY�ZbY^aijHZieHSC`Im%a4QpY�RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a4S�x�QH`�\HRT\nk^`�e�a4Rde%jpY��WI\>�bjHS�a4Y^\Eai`�W,k[k[`IjHe�aOm�`IZ�a4QHY�mWIkla�a4QXW>aa4QpY�RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�aCk[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eHS�`IeER{a4SbY[_dm%k^`�e�a4RTe�jHRdeHf��&rOP�QpRTS�RTS�aiQHY�SiY^eHSiY�RTetx�QHRdk�Q�`IjHZ�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z<cVWI�IY^Sa4QpY"ZiY^_�W,aiRT`�epSiQHRdU.g�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e�a4QHYV\XW,a4W�WIeH\.a4QHYVcV`%\HY^_�aiZ4WIepSiUXWIZbY[e�auw�a4Q�jHS@SbRTcqUH_TR{m�o%RTeHf�Zb`�gHjHS�a4eHY^SiSWIeXW,_do%SiRdS[r7|¡aVRTSVWI_TSb`.aiQHY)ZbYuWISb`�e¥x�Y�Y&vpU�Y[kla�`�jHZqY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[SFa4`.c"W,�IY�Y^cVUpRTZiRdkuWI_:SiY[epSiYIr���ep_TY[SbSRTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�aiSEQHW']IYVU�Y[Zbk[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHSna4QXW>a@W,ZiYFSbo%SbaiY[cVW,a4RdkuWI_d_do)gHR�W,SiY[\<wCaiQHYqWIk^aijXWI_�Wu]�Y^Z4WIfIYV`Im�ZiY[WI_TRd�[Y^\k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�eN],WI_TjHY^S�SbQH`�jH_d\*g�Y@k[_d`�SiYya4`Va4QHY�Ylv-U1Y^k^aiY[\�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�eN],WI_TjHY^S�jHSbY[\�g�o�a4QHY@WIf�Y^e�aiSRTe�cVWI��RTeHf�aiQHY[RdZ�\HY[k^RTSbRT`�eHS^r

«-Y[k^`�eH\�w%eH`IaiY�QH`'x¥Y[WISbo�Rda�RdS�a4`nk[`IcVUHj-a4Y�`�jHZ�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`Im�k[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�e�],WI_TjpY[S[w�`IZ ���.V�W���&r�|¡m� RTS:��eH`'x�e.�WIeH\"x�YnjHSijHWI_T_{o�a4QHRdeH��a4QXW,a�a4QHY�UHZiRd`�Z�RTepm�`�Zbc"W>a4RT`IeFx�YnQXWu]�Y�`�e � RTS:_dRT�,Y[_do�ai`�Sbx:WIcqUa4QpYERdepm�`�Zbc"W,aiRT`�eV`�e � Wu]IW,RT_�W,gH_TY�m�Zi`�c Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4RdeHf�WIeNY[e�a4Z�o�cq`-\HY^_��&w-a4QpY[e

���."�,��� � � ) �$ � =#¨ �m�`�Z � � �;J � �� V � ��� �� V WIeH\ �$ � ���;J � �� V � ��� �8 A rh£:`Ia4Q � WIeH\ �$�W,ZiY�RTeH\pY[U�Y[eH\HY^e�aV`,m�a4QpYUXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^Z�]IY[k^ai`�Z�WIep\ kuWIe~aiQHY[ZbY^m�`�ZbY6g�Y6k[`�cqUHjpaiY[\�`IeHk[Y�W>a@a4QpY6g1Y^f�RTepeHRTeHf)`Im2aiQHY6Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRT`�eZi`Ijpa4RdeHY�WIeH\qQHY[_d\"RTeFcqY[cq`�Zbo@a4QHY^ZiYuW>m�a4Y[Z^r�«-`�Rdm1UHZi`I�pa4S�x:Y^ZiY�_TRTepYuWIZ�m�jHepk^a4Rd`�eHS�`Im �%w�a4QHY��XZiS�a:S�a�WIfIYY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�`Im�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�],WI_djHY[S�WIZbYEWI_TSb`Hr

��eNWIeXW,_T`�f�`IjHS2kuW,_Tk[jp_�W,aiRT`�eVUHZi`%\HjHk^Y[S�k[`�epSiRTS�a4Y^e�a��HZiSba�S�a�WIfIYnY[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S2`Im�Y[e�a4Z�o"],WI_djHY[S^r�sJ`IZ�WU�`Ia4Y^e�aiR�WI_<Y[e�a4ZiWIe�auwHa4QpYEY&v-U1Y^k^a4Y^\�],WI_TjpYn`ImBY^e�a4Zbo�Rde�Sba4W,a4YV�,��������RTS

���"�,�����p¢��I�= �� ?� D @ CED �U����� M ��� M � ) � �/.V�,� M ��� M ¢���� ) � a8 A �,� M ��� M � �`�Z^wHRTe�cVW,a4ZbR{v"eH`Ia�W>a4RT`Ie�w �/�"�W�I�= �� ? �R� ) � ��.V�W��� ) � 8 A C� � � = D �x�QHY^ZiYna4QHYnY^_TY^cVY^e�aiS�`ImCa4QHYncVW,a4ZbR{v�� ? wHS4Wuo � ?:@ � � @ C � @ � � D @ CED � wHUHZb`']-Rd\HYyW�U1`,a4Y[e�aiR�WI_1Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a ��S�UHZb`�gXW>�gHRd_TRda}oV`Im�Sba4WIZbaiRTeHf�`�U�Y[ZiW,a4Rd`�eHS�W,a�S�a�W,aiYV�,� M ��� M �:k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeXWI_<`Ie)R{a�Y[e�a4Y^ZiRdeHfVRde�Sba�W>a4YV�,�������lr

� `�eHSbRTSbaiY[e�a�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�`ImJa4QpY[SiY�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S�WIZiY�`�g-a�WIRdeHY[\qWIS�aiQHY2m�Z4WIkla4Rd`�e�`ImJa4QH`ISiY�x�QH`yY[e�a4Y^ZRTe�S�a�W,aiY"���������2x�Qp`qaiQHY[eNg1Y^f�RTe�`�U�Y[ZiW,a4Rd`�eHS�S�a�W,aiY"��� M ��� M �&wpa4QXW>a�RdS�g�o�

�� ?:@ � � @ C � @ � � D @ C D � � ���� � � @ C � �,5� � = � � � ����� @ C ����� � � � � D @ CED ���� ���� � � @ C � �W5� � \

�ÍùOÛ|Ùq±�Ù²êóû�ÛÚÈã�Ý�äÜÙ$ìrÙÍä�êó÷�Ùmì�ü±ä�á3ï ÚÜÛ|Ù�äÈÝ«ÚÜêëá�á�ü_ý|ä�á3ðtÝ�ðtêëñóê ÚÜêëÙmã»þtã�ÙÍì6ðè9Ú�ÛtÙ�ýÂá�Ú�ÙÍÞÚ�êòÝ�ñ`ÙÍÞÚ�äÈÝ�ÞÚ»Ú�á.ü±á�äÜï êëÚÜãÙ�²rýÂÙÍøGÚ�ÙÍì�Ù²ÞÚ�äÜè�÷«Ý�ñóþ|Ù ·Ú�ÛtÙÍã�ÙÑø²á�ÞtìrêëÚ�êóá�ÞÁá�Þ�Ú�Û|ÙÑÙ²ÞÚ�äÈÝ�ÞÚ Ù²ÞÚ�ÙÍä�êóÞ|û �»Ú�á9Ú�ÛtÙ´á3ðtãyÙÍä�÷3ÙÍì�ÙÍÞ3ÚÜä�è�ýtä�á3ðtÝ�ð|êóñóê ÚÜêëÙmã�á3ä � &�T � L�� T � � 02 � & L�� ��å4±fÛ|êòøÈÛ�ø²Ý�Þ�ð�ÙJ±fäÜêëÚyÚ�ÙÍÞ�Ý�ã ×� =?>A@�B 5DC � *�<�=E>A@7B 51C�� �������������� >A@7B 51C � � � >F@ �� "! B 5 �� "! C$# >A@&%5B 5 % C � L�±fÛ|ÙÍä�Ù ;8' KJMLRN ��9×� =?>A@�B 5DC � *�<�=?>A@�B 5DC �� �

= �

Page 16: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

��k^k[`�Zb\HRTepf�_doVx:YE`�gpa4WIRTe�`�jpZ�k[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[e�a�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiYn`Im!� � WIS�� �6�W�I� ���� ) � � � = � �

x�QHY^ZiY �� < �� ? ) � �� ? � � � c< � �� ? �$ ) � �� ? �8 A \P�QHY�SiRdcVUp_TRTk^Rda}o"`Im�a4QHY�m�`�Zic `Im�aiQHY�Si`I_TjpaiRT`�eNm�`�Z�� ���.V�W���P� ��/�"�W�I�i��\HRd\�eH`,an\HY[U�Y[ep\ ��� ������`�e

a4QpYq\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�e*`Im�Y^e�aiZbo!k^`�SbaiS[r�P�QHRdStmWIk^ayf�Y^eHY[ZiWI_TRd�[Y^Sta4`6a4QpYqcq`%\HY[_Ox�Rda4Q!c�jp_da4RdUH_TY�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�epS[wWIeH\"Y[eXWIgp_TY[S�jHS�a4`@jpSiYtZbYuWI_dRTSbaiRTk��b`�Rde�a:\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�eHS�`Im�Y^e�aiZboqk[`ISba4S�RTe�a4`Ea4QHY�c�jH_{a4RTUp_TY�_T`%kuW>a4RT`IeHS�`Ima4QHW,a�cV`%\HY^_<x�RdaiQH`�jpa�RdeHk[ZbYuWISbRTeHf�a4QpYEk^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_<gpjHZi\HY^e�`ImOa4QpYEY^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z:SiRTfIeHRd�Xk[WIe�a4_{o�r

� e!aiQHY�`IaiQHY[ZnQHWIeH\�w<aiQH`�SbY�Si`�_djpa4Rd`�eHStk[WIe�g1Y^k[`�cqY�Si`IcVYlx�QXW,ancq`�ZiY@k[`�cqUH_TY&v�x�QpY[e�a4QHY�\pRTS��a4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`Ie�`Im:Y&v-Rdanm�Y[Y^S�RdSneH`IayY&vpU�`�eHY^e�a4R�W,_¸r�P�QHYqUHZi`IU1Y^Zba}o�`Im�a4QpYq\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�e�`Im�Ylv-Rdaym�Y^Y[Sna4QXW>aY[eHWIgH_TY^SBa4QpY2jHSiY�`,mXa4QHY2cVW,aiZiR{vERde�]�Y[ZbSiRd`�e�RTSOa4QXW,a ��� � SU� 7 ���(�-RTSB_TRTepYuWIZORTe�������aiQHY2Y&vpU�`�eHY^e�a4R�W,_pRTSBWSiU�Y[k^R�WI_-kuWISbY�`ImJa4QHRdS��&r�P�QH`IjHf�Q�a4QHRdS�_TRdeHYuW,ZiRda}oEW,SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�e@c"Wuo�g1Y�WtfI`-`%\@�XZbSba�WIUHUpZi`uv-RTcVW,a4Rd`�eEm�`IZa4QpY2\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�eE`ImJSbY[_T_-`I�q]IW,_TjHY^S�x�Y:x:`IjH_T\�_dRT�IY�a4`�g1Y�W,gH_TY�a4`tf�Y^eHY[ZiWI_TRd�[Y�� W,aB_TY[WISba�m�`�ZBZb`�gHjHS�a4eHY^SiSWIeXW,_do%SiRdS��lr�|¡m<x�Y�jHSbY�W,e�o�`Ia4QHY^Z�m�`IZic m�`�Z5.

G�43 ��W,eH\VZbY[U�YuW,a�aiQHY�_d`�f�Rdk2RTe�a4QpY�_TWISba�SbjHgHSiY^k^aiRT`�e�w�a4QpY[e

W,m�aiY[Z2SbjHgHSbaiRdaijpa4RdeHf�`�jHZ2k^`�eHSbRTSbaiY[e�a�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S:m�`IZ:a4QHY^RTZ:aiQHY[`IZiY^aiRTk[WI_<k^`�jHe�a4Y^ZiUXWIZ�a4S^wHa4QHY��-vpY^\)U�`�Rde�aWIeXW,_T`�f�`IjHS:a4`qY[��jXW>a4RT`Ie~� ='ª �:g�Y[k^`�cVY^S

������W��� �� V�� � ) � � � = J �8 A �� ������,��� � ) � � �8 A �A�%� �!S � 7 ������W�I� � ��c�x�QHY^ZiY¥� = J �8 A ��� ������W���6RdS6a4QHY!]�Y^k^a4`IZ�m�`IZicqY[\ g�o�c�jH_daiRTUH_{o%RTeHf�Y[WIk�Q = J �8 A �,�������"x�Rda4Q$a4QpYk[`IZiZiY^SiU�`�eH\HRdeHf ������,���^�,�������lwpx�QpRT_TY �8 A � �%� �!S � 7 ������W�I� �<RTS2a4QpYt]�Y[kla4`�Z2m�`IZicqY[\�g�o�c�jH_{a4RdUH_do%RTepf� YuW,k�Q.Y^_TY^cVY^e�at`Im �8 A �,��������g�o�aiQHY�k[`IZiZiY^SiU�`�eH\HRdeHf ��� � SU� 7 ������W�I�[��������� �¸rEP�QHRdSnY[��jXW,aiRT`�e�S�o-S�a4Y^cRTS�k[`�e�a4ZiWIk^aiRT`�e�c"WIUpUHRTeHfpw�WIeH\*aiQHY[ZbY^m�`�ZbY�RTStY[WISbo)a4`�Sb`�_d]IYIw�Rdm�aiQHY�\HY^ZiR{]IW>a4Rd]IY�`Im ��� � SU� 7 %��Bx�RdaiQZiY^SiU�Y[klana4` %.RTS�_TY^SiS�aiQXWIe�`�Z�Y[��jXWI_Oa4`6`IeHY�Y^]IY[Z�o%x�QpY[ZiY�� W,k^a4jHWI_T_{o�w � =��_� x�RT_d_C\H`��lr�P�QHRTS�x�Rd_T_Cg�Ya4ZbjHYFRdm�a4QpYq\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�e$.

G�43 ��RdSt_T`If,�}k^`�eHkuWu]IY���SiY^Y �Y[k���cVWIe~W,eH\ �`�eH`�ZbYN� ='�I��ª �lwC��Zb`�U1`ISiRdaiRT`�e

= � � � wOWIe~W,SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�e!SiW,a4RdSb�XY^\�g�o!cq`�Sbay`Im�a4QpYq\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�eHSnjHSbY[\�RTe�Y[cqUHRdZiRTk[WI_�x�`�Zb�h�eH`�Zbc"W,_¸w_T`If�RTS�a4RTk,w-Y&v%a4ZiY^cVYn],WI_djHYIwXf�W,cVcVWpw%g1Yla�Wpw���Y[RdgHjH_T_ wpW,eH\)Sb`V`IeJ�lr

� eHk[Y2x�Y�QXWu]�YE� ���.V�W���P� ��/�"�W�I�i�lw,x:Y�k[WIe�m�`�Zic k[`IeHSiRdSba4Y^e�a�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�`ImXaiQHY2UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a}oy`ImJYlv-R{aWIeH\~`Im�Y[e�aiZbo.k[`�ep\HRdaiRT`�eXW,_�`�e��NWIS�� = J .

G� ��9."�,���(SU���b�EW,eH\ .10�� ����"�W�I�7SU�I�i�&wBZiY^SiU�Y[kla4Rd]IY[_{o�rNP�QHY

SiY^k[`�ep\)S�a�WIf�Yy`ImOa4QpYyWI_Tf�`IZiRdaiQHc �Ha4S�aiQHY[SbYEUpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�a4`�a4QHYnY&v-Rda�WIeH\NY[e�aiZbo�ZiW,a4Y^S�`IgHSiY^Zb]�Y^\�Rdea4QpYn\XW,a�W-r �~Ynk^`�cVYngHWIk��"a4`FW�cq`�ZiY�\HY^a4WIRT_dY[\�\HRdSik[jpSiSiRd`�e�`ImCa4QHYnUpZi`�U�Y[Z�a4RTY^S�`Im�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�x�QpRTk�Q\H`ya4QHRdS�RTeFSiY^k^aiRT`�e D g�Y[_d`'xyr�sX`�Z�eH`'x$WI_d_-x�Y�x:WIe�a�a4`yeH`IaiY�RdS�a4QXW,a�aiQHY�k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_-k[`�cqUH_TY&v-Rda}o×��mù2áTã�Ù²Ù<Ú�Û|êòã*ñëÙ²Ú�� �" ��ð�ÙgÚÜÛ|Ù<á3ý�ÙÍäÜÝ�Ú�á3äMÚ�Û�Ý«Ú�ý|äÜá�ì|þtøGÙmãMÚÜÛ|Ù<äÜêóû�ÛÚ*Û�Ý�ÞtìaãyêòìrÙgá�ü@ÚÜÛ|êóã*Ùi·3þ�Ý«Ú�êóá�ÞE±fÛ|Ù²Þ �E�� 9 "Ý�Þ�ìañóÙGÚ��("��gìrÙÍÞ|á�ÚÜÙÆÚ�Û|Ù]ïÆÝ&²rêëï<þ|ï8ÙÍñëÙÍïgÙÍÞÚ�á�üOÚ�Û|Ù_÷3ÙÍøGÚ�á�ä " �)ùOÛ|ÙÍÞ$ãyêóÞtø²Ù�����êòã`Ý �»Ý�äÜß�á«÷"ï_Ý�Ú�äÜê�²�å�� � 5" × �XT� �" ° �!�2?#"�� 3 � T ;8:9 � # 5" × T/" ° � 6%$&" 3�;8:9 # ?H 3 ')( '+*)" × 6PT H 3 ')( ',*)" ° 6 � 6-� �/.�ÞtìrÙ²äÕÚ�ÛtÙSñóá�û�ø²á�ÞtøÍÝ®÷�ÙSø²á�ÞtìrêëÚ�êóá�Þ�ã( H 3 ')( ',*)" × 6�T H 3 '�( '0* " ° 61( ?2( " × T/" ° (u±fÛtêóøÈÛ¤åtû�êó÷�Ù²Þ]Ú�ÛtÝ�Ú ��? ;8�9 ? �3årý|ä�á«÷3ÙÍãpÚ�ÛtÙ�ä�Ùmãyþ|ñëÚ��

=#�

Page 17: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

`Im�a4QHY^SiYNY[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiSFRTSFk[`IcVUXW,Z4WIgH_dY6a4`�a4QHW,a"`,m�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbSFm�`IZ�a4QHYNSiRdcVUH_dY[S�aFSba�W>a4RTk�Y^e�aiZbop�,Y&vpR{acq`-\HY^_TSy�WIeH\�a4QHY^SiYEcV`%\HY^_TS�WIZbYyeHY[R{a4QHY^Z�\po%eXWIcqRTkneH`�Z�\H`�aiQHY^oNWI_d_T`'x$m�`�Z�WIe�o�QHYla4Y^Zi`�f�Y^eHY[R{a}op�lr

�~YFx:WIe�a@a4`Nk[`IeHk[_djH\HYFa4QHRdSESbY[kla4RT`Ie�g�o.ZiY^cVRdeH\HRTepf6a4QHYqZiY[WI\HY[ZE`Im2WIe~RdcVUH_dRTk[W,a4Rd`�e�`Im:`�jHZEWIS��SijpcVUpaiRT`�epS:a4QXW>a�c"WuoVg1Y�UHZi`�gp_TY[cVW,aiRTk�RTe6UXW,Zba4Rdk[jH_TWIZ2W,UHUH_TRdkuW,aiRT`�epS[r � jHZ:cV`%\HY[_1WISbSijHcqY[S�a4QHW,a2a4QpYS4W,cVUH_dYyUXW,a4QpS�Y^c"WIeHW,a4RdeHf�m�Zi`�c WFf�R{]�Y[e��,��������QXWu]�YIzn�R��2Wq\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�e6x�QpRTk�Q�\p`-Y^S�eH`,a�\HY^U1Y^eH\`�e�`,a4QHY^ZEm�Y[W,a4jHZbY[S�`,m2a4QHYq�XZicqS �CY^e�]%RdZi`�eHcqY[e�a�WIeH\$��RTR���ZbYuWI_dRT�[W,a4Rd`�eHSnx�QHRTk�Q�WIZiYVRTeH\HY^U1Y^eH\HY^e�a@`Im`�eHY)WIeH`,a4QHY^Z[rh|¡a"RdS�m�`�Z�a4QHRdSqZbYuWISb`�eLaiQXW,aFa4QpY)Wu]IY[Z4W,f�Y�`Im�a4QpY[SiY)ZiY[WI_TRd�uW,aiRT`�eHS@k[`�e�]�Y^Zif�Y^S"a4`!a4QpYk[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e6WIeH\�Y[e�a4Z�o"],WI_djHY[S2`,m�Rde�a4Y[ZbY[S�aur�|¡m�w-m�`�Z:YlvpWIcqUH_TY,w-x�Yyx�Y[ZbYtx:`IZi��RTeHf�x�R{a4Q�UXW,eHY[_�\HW,a�WpwWIeH\6aiQHY[ZbY�x:WIS�W@eXW,aiRT`�eHWI_JZiY[fIjH_�W,aiRT`�eqx�QHRTk�Q�Rde�<XjHY^eHk[Y^\�a4QHYtZbYuWI_dRT�[W,a4Rd`�eHS�`Im�����S�RTe�W,_T_�c"WIZb�IYla4S2RdeW�UXWIZ�a4RTk^jH_�W,Z2U1Y^ZiRd`-\�w%a4QHYEWu]�Y^Z4WIfIYE`,mBZbYuWI_dRT�[Y^\�k[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�e6],WI_TjpY[S�WIk[Zb`�SiS�aiQHY[SbY�cVWIZi�,Y^aiS�Rde6a4QXW>aU�Y[ZiRd`-\�x:`�jp_T\ eH`Ia�k[`�e�]�Y^Zif�Y�ai`�a4QHY�k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e~],WI_TjpY[S@x�QHRdk�Q \HY^aiY[ZbcVRdeHY[\ SbY[_T_�`I��\pY[k[RdSiRd`�eHS[r� m�k[`�jpZiSiY@Rdm�x�Y�`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\!ZbY[U�YuW,aiY[\*k�QXW,eHf�Y[SnRde�ZbY[f�jH_TW,a4Rd`�eHS^w1W,eH\�a4QpY�UHZi`%k[Y^SiStfIY[eHY^Z4W,aiRTeHfqa4QH`�SbYk�QXWIepf�Y[S�x:Y^ZiYEY[Zbf�`-\pRTkIw-a4QHY^e)`�jpZ�W']IY[ZiWIf�Y[S�x�`�jH_T\Ng�YEk^`�eHSbRTSbaiY[e�aur

��� P � HÈX[E � HGF��$ZÎQfJ*X[EGZ<bTL J�bTc�� J�bTc"Z � � ���YVf�Y^eHY[ZiWI_TRd�[Y�ai`�WI_d_T`'x m�`�Znc�jH_{a4RTUp_TY�Y^e�aiZbo!_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHSyWIeH\�W�Z4WIeH\p`�c e�jHc�g�Y[ZE`Im�U1`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y[e%�a4ZiWIe�a4S^r���_T_d`#x�RdeHf�m�`IZ2c�jH_{a4RTUp_TY�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eHS�k�QXWIeHfIY[S2a4QpYnY[e�a4Z�o�cV`%\HY^_1m�Zi`Ic W�gHRdeH`�cqR�WI_Xai`FWFc@jH_daiR{�eH`�cqR�W,_�cq`%\HY[_Jx�RdaiQ6a4QHYtc@jpa4jXW,_T_doFY&v-k[_TjpSiRd]IYyWIeH\�Y&vpQHWIjHSbaiRd]IYn`�jpa4k^`�cqY[S2g�Y[RdeHfHz�Y^e�aiY[Z�Rde6_T`%kuW,aiRT`�e= w�Y^e�aiY[ZyRTe!_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e ¨ w�r^r[r[wC`�Znep`IayY[e�a4Y^ZEW,aEWI_T_ r���_T_d`#x�RdeHf"m�`�ZtW�ZiWIeH\H`Ic e�jHc�g�Y[Zy`Im�U1`,a4Y[e�aiR�WI_Y[e�aiZ4WIe�a4S@k�QXWIeHf�Y^S@a4QpY"cq`-\HY^_�m�`�Z�`IgHSiY^Zb],W,a4Rd`�eHS�`�e~Y^e�aiZbo.m�Zi`�c W)Sba�W,eH\XWIZb\�c�jH_{a4RTep`�cVRTWI_Bcq`%\HY[_RTe�ai`"WFcVR v%a4jHZbYE`,m�c�jH_{a4RdeH`�cqR�WI_dS�x�QHY^ZiYEx:Y�cVR v�`']�Y^Z�a4QpYEaiQHY�e�jHc@g1Y^Z�`ImBU1`,a4Y[e�aiR�WI_�Y^e�aiZ4WIe�aiS��`IZa4QpY�SiRT�^Y�`Im�a4QHY�SiWIcVUp_TY'�ym�`�Z@a4QpYNc@jH_daiRTeH`�cqR�W,_�\HZ4Wux�S[r �`'x:Yl]�Y^Z[w�WI_d_�aiQHY�`Ia4QpY[ZFWISbU1Y^k^a4SF`Im�a4QpYa}x�`,�}S�a4Y[U"Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Rd`�eFSbaiZ4W,aiY[fIoqZiY^c"W,RTeqRTe�a�WIklauw%Si`Ea4QHY�ZiYuW,\HY[Z�x�QH`�RdS�eH`,a:Rde�aiY[ZbY[SbaiY[\6RdeqaiQHY�\pY^a�W,RT_TSkuW,e)Sb�%RdUNaiQHRTS�SbjHgHSbY[k^aiRT`�e)WIeH\Ncq`#]IYy\HRTZbY[k^ai_doVa4`�a4QHYySbY[k^aiRT`�eN\HRdSik[jpSiSiRdeHfVWI_daiY[ZieHW,a4R{]�YnY[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS^r

�~YF\HYla�WIRd_�W�cV`%\HY^_Bx�RdaiQ!a}x�`N_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eHS�WIeH\�W�Z4WIeH\p`�c e�jHc�g�Y[Zy`Im�U�`Ia4Y^e�aiR�WI_BY[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S"��a4QpYYlv%aiY[eHSbRT`�e�a4`yW��XeHRdaiY2e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`ImJY^e�a4Zbo@_T`%kuW,aiRT`�epS�RdS�SbaiZ4WIRdf�Q�aim�`�Z�x2WIZb\J�lr�P�`n�,Y[Y^UVcVW,aiaiY[ZbS�WIS�SbRTcqUH_TYWISnU�`�SiSbRTgH_dY�x:YFcVWIRTe�a4WIRTe�WI_T_�`Im:��SiSbjHcVU-a4RT`Ie = ��x�RdaiQ.`Ig�]%Rd`�jHSn\HR{�<Y^ZiY[epk[Y[SyRde�eH`Ia�W>a4RT`Ie*a4`NWI_T_d`'xm�`�Z2a}x�`V_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHS4��Ylv-k[Y^Upa = r ¨ ��x�QHRTk�QN\HYuW,_TS�x�RdaiQ�aiQHYySijHep��k[`�S�a4S�`Im�Y[e�a4Z�oNWIeH\NYlv-Rda��lr�� � ��� � 4�� +�� : "���� � $ �:d ��� ����` � �W^ ��" ��� B � ���� ���a`=

* ���! "!��`Hb��A �:d � ��� �"!�W^?��� �"!�?A ��"!�3�^�"� ��� �=�!�AP^ � $ ^ � ��" ^�" $� �!�" $��"!� A ��" $�� ` $�A � � dBA � `���!�$_^ ����AP^,b ���W^ ��" '�8C� � S ����0�

� � d ��A � ! "6^�� %5�* � ��� �"!�W^?���!�"!�?A ��"!��� � ��" �"!� �A ^�"���"!������"# �:d ���! �3� � ��� � ���,^ ��"�� ��" $ ��� )� �"!��AB� � � ���C�O� � �8� � �^�" �3�!F! A ��� ��" $ � � ��" $ ��� � ���W^ ��"���A � �! ���W^9)�����(� � �!�A �3�! )� ��� ��A��R� � � � � ��^ � �>$�A � �[dBA � `

���!�$_^ ����AP^,b ���W^ ��"�12�'P� � � 2 � $ � � � � � 2 � 02< . 0 �32 � � 2 � SU�I�

= �

Page 18: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

� ��^ � ��^ � ^�" $� �!�" $��"!� ��)��A �,^R`=���" $ ����A � � � � ���"!���8� ��" $

* ��"#� ^�" � ����AB�,^ ��� � ��A ��� � ���,^ ��",�(���! �"!��A ��"!� � ��"!"����#� �!^�� � ����� � ���,^ ��"��8��b � � � ��" ��&^��(��� A � ^9)���"8��&^��6d �:dc� � ��^ � � ^ � ��" ^ � ^ � $ � $�A � � "/dBA � ` .

G��43,SU��� ^ d ���!2^�"#����`Hb��"!�S� ��� ^�" �3�! ! A ���

��� � ���,^ ��" ��" $ ��" ^ � ^ � $ � $�A � � dBA � ` .G� �43,SU���2^ d ���!9^�"#���a`Hb��"!�5� ���9^�" ���! � � ��" $C��� � ���,^ ��" �

«-RdeHk[Y/� � W,eH\ � � WIZbYE\pZ4Wux�S�`Ie�aiQHYyY[e�a4Z�o�k[`�S�a4S�`ImOa4QHYySiWIcVYyW,f�Y[e�a�RTeNWI_{a4Y[ZbeXW,aiRd]�Yn_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHS^w-a4QpYmWIkla�a4QHW,an`�jHZ�WISiSbjHcqUpa4Rd`�eHSnWI_d_T`'x aiQHY@a}x�`�Y[e�a4Z�o*k[`ISba4Stai`6g�Y@m�ZiY^Y[_doNk^`�ZiZbY[_�W>a4Y[\*WI\H\HSnZbYuWI_dRTSic ai`a4QpYEcq`%\HY[_���SiY^Y�g�Y[_d`#x��&r

�~Y�g�Y[f�Rde�x�Rda4Q�aiQHY�RTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a ��S�UHZi`IgH_TY^c)r CYlaiaiRTeHf���RTeH\HY&v�a4QpY�\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eHS�WIeH\Fc"W,���RTepfq`Ig�]%Rd`�jHS�eH`Ia�W>a4RT`IeXWI_�k�QXW,eHf�Y[S^w�aiQHY�£:Y[_d_TcVWIe�Y[��jXW,aiRT`�eNm�`�Z�WIeNRTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a�Rde�a4QHYya}x:`V_T`%kuW,aiRT`�ecq`-\HY^_�RTS

���¸��������� � �,���p¢P������� "�$&%9'(���¡��������� � ������� ) � ���X��� �,������� � �������*) � �9.��¸��������� � �,���p¢�����01�x�QHY^ZiY ��.�� �,���,�X� � �����p¢��I� >CED @ ?�� @ ?�� @ A���� @ A��

F G D �"�,��� )25��,Jc%��,�X� � � ) 5 � �,Jc% � �,���NMR�P�6M �R8O� $6�6M ��8 V @� �,5�����5 � ���X%����X% � �ES ������� � �R���Y��Z �Q = ��8O�,�NM S ��� �

WIeH\ 8 V @ � �W5�����5 � ���X%����X% � �ES ���,�X� � �����Y��Z �Q = �UHZb`#]%Rd\HY[S�a4QHYna}o%U�YC�BRdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a ��S�U�Y[Zbk[Y[R{]�Y^\�UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a}o"`Im��W5�����5 � ���X%����X% � �d�2k[`�ep\HRdaiRT`�eXW,_<`�e�a4QXW>aRTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�a�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jHRdeHfHr

�IjHSbaNW,S6RTe¥aiQHY�cq`-\HY^_�x�R{a4Q$W�SbRTeHf�_dY)_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e�w2aiQHY*RTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�a6]%RdY^x�S�WI_d_�R{a4S"k^`�cqU1Yla4Rdai`�ZiSRTe�W�UXWIZ�a4RTk^jH_�W,Z�_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e�WIS�RT\HY^e�a4RTk[WI_¸r � `�eHSiY^��jHY[e�a4_{o�w�RTe�Y^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc R{a�U�Y[Zbk[Y[R{]�Y^SFW�gHRTep`�cVRTWI_\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`IeN`,m�Ylv-Rdai`�ZiS�m�Zi`�c Y[WIk�Q*_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e�wpx�R{a4Q)aiQHY@gpRTeH`�cqR�W,_�UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o"\HY^aiY[ZbcVRdeHY[\)g�oNa4QpYm�Z4W,k^a4Rd`�eq`Im�\HZiWux�S:`�eqa4QHY�Ylv-Rda�m�Y[Y�a4QXW>a:W,ZiY�_�WIZbf�Y[Z�a4QHWIeVaiQHY�_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e���S�k[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�eF]IW,_TjHY,r�©)`�ZbYm�`�Zbc"WI_d_doIw-RdeNY^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc

86V @ � �W5�����5 � ���X%����X% � �ES ������� � �����a��Z �Q = �! 86V @ � �,5�����5 � �ES ���R�X� � �����Y��Z �Q = �� �� ��%��������YJ = S ������� � �������� � � ��% � �,��� � � S ������� � ������� �x�QHY^ZiY

A � �R%*�42�S ������� � �,���Y����� < � �A �,.G� ' �/.�� ��������� � �����a�����(S ��0 ��� A�� = J .

G� ' ��.��¸��������� � �,���Y�����(S ��0�� A �

=#§

Page 19: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

WIe@WIeXWI_d`�f�`�jHS�\pY^�XeHR{a4Rd`�e�Qp`�_T\HSCm�`�Z � � ��% � �,��� � �ES ���R��� � �������lw�W,eH\�aiQHY:U�Y[Zbk[Y[R{]�Y^\�Y[e�a4Z�oEUHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S^wR¸r�YIrQ8 V @ � �W5�����5 � �ES ������� � �����a��Z �Q = �&w,c@jHSba�Y[��jXWI_�aiQHY�Y^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc Y[e�a4Z�oyUHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S<\HY^�XepY[\�g�Y[_d`#xyr«-RTepk[YFY[e�a4ZiWIe�a4SEg1Y^k[`�cqYFRTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a4SEW,ayaiQHYFg1Y^f�RTeHepRTeHf�`Im�a4QpYVU�Y[ZbRT`%\!W,m�a4Y^ZEY^e�a4Zbo.W,eH\�QHW']IY

Ylv-R{a�U1Y^Zik[Y^Upa4Rd`�eHS�a4QHW,a�WIZiYnk^`�eHSiRdSbaiY[e�a�x�R{a4Q�Y[��jHRd_TRdgHZiRdjHc g�Y[QHW']%Rd`�Z[w

�/� � �,���,��� � �R���p¢��I�= >?4@ AB@ CEDF G D ��� �,���O) 5���Jc%��W��� � � ) 5 � �,Jc% � �,���NMR�P�6M �R8O� $6�6M �� A � �R%��������ES �����Y���I�� A � � ��% � ����� � �ES �����Y������8 ?4@

� �W5YS �����a��Z ?� = ��8C�W�NMWSU���P�x�QHY^ZiY9� �,� � ��� � ��WIep\ 8 ?:@ � �,5YS �����Y��Z ?� = �UHZb`#]%Rd\HY[S2aiQHYnY[��jHRd_TRTgpZiRTjpc \HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�e6`,mOaiQHYte�jHc�g�Y[Z�`,m�Y^e�a4Z4W,e�aiS�k[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eXWI_�`�e6aiQHYnU1`,a4Y[e�aiR�WI_Y[e�aiZ4WIe�a��"!� �AP^�"�� ^�" ��� � ���,^ ��" �}r

P�QHYt`�ep_doqg1Y^QXWu]%RT`�ZiWI_J\HRd�1Y[ZbY[eHk^YtRTeqa4QHY�cV`�ZbY�fIY[eHY^Z4WI_�cV`%\HY^_1RdS�aiQXW,a2ep`#x W�U1`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_JY[e�a4ZiWIe�ax�RT_d_JY[e�a4Y^Z�RTe�a4`�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�e%�CR{mOWIeH\6`IeH_doqRdm�Rda2RdS2W@g�Y^aba4Y^Z�WI_daiY[ZbeXW,a4R{]�Y�a4QXWIe b����3�6eH`Ia2Y^e�a4Y[ZbRTeHfFW>a�WI_d_¸wWIeH\NY[e�aiY[ZiRdeHfFRTe�a4`F_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e J��wJR r Y,r ^ �

� � � �¸�,������� � �����Y��������� � $ � � � ��� �¸��������� � �,���Y������J � �V� � �/� � � �,� � �,�X�������Y���I� J � � �,\ � =#� ���SbRTeHf*aiQHRTS�mW,k^auw�x�Y��XeH\ a4QHY�Y^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc Y[e�aiZbo \HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�e~Rde�a}x:`.SbaiY[UHS^z6x:Y��XZbSba��XeH\3a4QpYY[��jHRd_TRdgHZiRdjHc Y[e�aiZbo)\HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�eNk[`�ep\HRdaiRT`�eXW,_O`Ie�WVUXW,Zba4Rdk[jH_TWIZ�e%jpc�g1Y^Z�`Im�U1`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_OY[e�a4ZiWIe�a4SF��`�e���&w�WIeH\)a4QHY^e.Rde�a4Y[fIZ4W,aiY@`�jpat`#]IY[ZtaiQHY�\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`Ie�`Im�U�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_�Y^e�aiZ4WIe�aiSnf�Rd]IY[e�RTe���SiSbjHcqUpa4Rd`�e¨ r

P�`*WIe�o~U�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_�Y^e�a4Z4W,e�a[w�a4QHY"ZiY[cVWIRdeHRTeHf�U�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_�Y^e�aiZ4WIe�aiS�\HZ4Wux m�Zi`Ic a4QHY6SiWIcqY"\HRdSba4ZbR{�gHjpaiRT`�e�`Im�Y[e�a4Z�o�m�Y[Y^S[r � `�eHSbY[��jHY[e�ai_do�w�aiQHY�UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o�`,mt�,5�����5 � �{��Y[e�aiZ4WIe�a4Syk^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeXWI_C`�e � RdS\HYla4Y[ZbcVRdeHY[\�g�o�a4QpYEc@jH_daiRTeH`�cqR�W,_�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�RTeH\pjHk[Y^\)g�o�a4QpYE\pY[k[RdSiRd`�e�ZijH_dYyWIg1`']IYIr�P�QXW,a�RTS�R{m

" � <��12 'P� � 7 � �/� � �,� � ��� � �B3 �[$ � � � � 7 � ��� � �,� � ��� � ��3 �P0 � � = � �" � <��12 'P� � � � �/� �¡��� � �X� � �B3 �[$ � � � � 7 � � � � ��� � ��� � �B3 ��J � � � � ��� � ��� � �B3 � ) � � 0 ��$ � �" � <�� 2 'P� � � � ��� � �,� � ��� � �B3 �[$ � � � � 7 � ��� � �,� � ��� � ��3 ��J � �/� � �,� � ��� � �B3 �-) � � 0 �

R¸r�YIr2�," �(��" � ��" � �BWIZbY:a4QpY�UHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[SC`Im1W�U�`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_pY^e�aiZ4WIe�a�eH`,a�Y[e�aiY[ZiRdeHfHw�Y^e�aiY[ZbRTeHfnRde�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�e= wpWIeH\�Y[e�aiY[ZiRdeHf�RTe"_T`%kuW,aiRT`�e ¨ wpZbY[SbU1Y^k^a4R{]�Y^_do�w-a4QHY^e�W�U1`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a2x�QH`Fk[`�ep\HRdaiRT`�eHS�`�e ��J =`IaiQHY[Z�U�`Ia4Y^e�aiR�WI_<Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S�WIeH\NY[e�a4Y^ZiS�RTe�_T`%kuW>a4RT`Ie ��x�RT_d_<SbY^a

8 ?4@ � �,5��W��5 � � S �����a��Z ?� = �8�@�! ".�W5��YJ = ��5 � �R�8� J = ¢X" �B��" � ��" � �P�='¦

Page 20: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

x�QHY^ZiY/".��2 � �42 � �42-¢X" �B��" � ��" � �2RdS�aiQHY@c@jH_daiRTeH`�cqR�W,_1UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a}o"`,m�k[Y^_T_�SiRd�[Y^S��32 J 2 � J 2 � � 2 � �42 � �f�R{]�Y[eNk[Y^_T_�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S2`Im�" �(��" � �X" � WIeH\)WFS4WIcqUH_TYnSbRT�^Y6��e%jpc�g1Y^Z�`Im�U�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S4��`Im 2-wR¸r�YIr

".�32 � �42 � �42%¢�" �B��" � �X" � �!< 2���32 J 2 � J 2 � ��� 2 � � 2 � � " ��� �

� � ���� " � ��" ���� �

UHZb`#]%Rd\HY[\ 5�� ) 5 � �6� � �`IaiQHY[Z�x�RTSiY2".�:3 �! ª �&r|}e�a4Y[fIZ4W,aiRTeHfF`�jpa�`']�Y^Z�a4QHYy\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`Ie�`Im �qwHx:Yy`�g-a�WIRdeNY^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc U�Y[Zik^Y[UpaiRT`�epS�WIS

8 ?:@ � �W5�����5 � �ES �����Y��Z ?� = �! >��� � ?�� � ? ��� � ".�,5�� J = ��5 � �R�4� J = ¢�" �B��" � �X" � � � �V�O��S ���

� � � �"�3� S �I� \ � �P�QHYERTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a ��S�U1Y^Zik[Y^Rd]IY[\�Y^e�a4Zbo�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�WIZiYyf�R{]�Y^e)g�o

8 V @ � �W5��,��5 � � S ������� � �����a��Z �Q = �! 8C�W5�����5 � � S �����Y���I� >��� � ?�� � ? ��� � ".�,5��W��5 � ���8�q¢�" �B��" � ��" � � �V�O��S7���P\

P�QHYnWI\#�bjHSbaicVY^e�aiS:a4`�a4QHY�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Rd`�eqUHZi`%k[Y^\HjHZiY�ZiY[��jHRdZiY^\"m�`�Z�aiQHY�fIY[eHY^Z4WI_dRT�[Y^\6cq`-\HY^_�WIZiY�WI_TSb`SbaiZ4WIRdf�Q�aim�`�Z�x2W,Zi\�r � jHZF�XZiS�a6Sba4WIf�Y)Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^SV`,mnk[`�e�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�eLWIeH\�Y^e�a4Zboh],WI_TjpY[SVWIZiYN`�gpa4WIRTeHY^\g�o*k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeHRTeHfV`�e*a4QpY�SiYlay`Im�U1Y^ZiRd`-\HS�a4QXW,atQXWu]�YFW6UXWIZ�a4Rdk[jH_TWIZ�],WI_djHY@`,mt��� � �X� � �����&w�k[`IcVUHj-a4RTepfx�Y[RTfIQ�aiY[\�SiWIcqUH_TY�Wu]�Y^Z4WIfIY[S�`Im-a4QHY�ZiY[WI_TRd�[Y^\�Y^e�aiZbo�WIeH\Ek[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�ey],WI_TjpY[SCm�Zi`�c¯aiQHY�a}x:`t_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHSW,aBYuWIk�Q�SbjHk�Q�Sba4W,a4Y,w�WIeH\@aiQHY[eFW,UHUH_do%RdeHf�aiQHY:cVW,a4ZbR{vyRde�]�Y[ZbSiRd`�e�m�`�Zic@jH_�W�a4`�SiRTcqUH_dRdm�otaiQHY:k[WI_Tk^jH_�W,aiRT`�e`Im1Y[e�a4Z�oqWIeH\qYlv-Rda�],WI_djHY[S�RdeFaiY[ZbcVS�`Im�a4QHY�\XW>a�WEWIeH\ �-r���SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�`Im-�yWIZiY�\HY^ZiR{]�Y[\Vg�o��HaiaiRTeHfna4QpYY[e�aiZbo�W,eH\�Ylv-RdatZ4W,aiY[S�m�Zb`�c a4QHY�\HR{�<Y^ZiY^e�at_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eHS�UHZbY[\HRdk^a4Y^\�g�o�a4QpY[SiY�k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e�WIeH\�Y^e�a4Zbo],WI_TjpY[S�WIeH\N\HR{�<Y^ZiY[e�a�],WI_TjpY[S�`Im �@a4`�a4QHYyY^e�aiZboNWIep\)Y&vpR{a�Z4W,aiY[S�RTe�aiQHYy\XW,a�W-r

� `�eHSbRTSbaiY[e�a�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[SO`ImJW,e@RTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�a � SBWIeH\�W,e�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a ��SBU�Y[Zbk[Y[R{]�Y^\�a4Z4W,eHSiR{a4RT`Ie�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[Sm�Zi`Ic Sba4W,a4YV��������� � �������2ai`FSba�W>a4YV�,� M � ��� M � � ��� M ��WIZbYnf�Rd]IY[eNg�o

�� V @ �� � � @ � �� @ C � @ � � D � @ � D �� @ CED � � ���� � � � @ � �� @ C � �,� � JL% � � =�� � � �� ����� @ � ���� ����� @ C ����� � � � � D � @ � D �� @ CED ���

� ���� � � � @ � ��� @ C � �,� � JL% � �WIeH\

�� ?:@ �� � � @ � �� @ C � @ � � D � @ � D �� @ CED � =

� �@�,���,�X� � ������� ����� � � � @ � �� @ C � 5 � =�� � � �� ����� @ � ��� ����� @ C ����� � � � � D � @ � D ��� @ CED ���

� ���� � � � @ � �� @ C � 5 � \�� � > ���� C��� ��

> ���� C êòãOÝ`ýÂá�ÚÜÙ²ÞÚ�êòÝ�ñ�ÙÍÞÚ�äÈÝ�ÞÚb¶ ãSýÂÙ²äÈøGÙÍêë÷3ÙÍì]ý|ä�á3ðtÝ�ðtêëñóê Ú�èÆÚÜÛtÝ«ÚOÚÜÛ|Ù²äÜÙ*Ý�ä�Ù H T �>á�Ú�Û|ÙÍä�ýÂá�ÚÜÙ²ÞÚ�êòÝ�ñ�ÙÍÞ3ÚÜäÜÝ�ÞÚÜã��

='�

Page 21: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

��SEg�Y^m�`�ZbYFaiQHY[SbY"e�jHc�g�Y[ZbS@W,ZiYqeH`IaEY[��jXWI_�a4`�a4QpYqY^cVUpRTZiRdkuWI_�m�ZiY[��jHY^eHk^o�`Im�a4Z4W,eHSiR{a4RT`Ie*m�Zi`�c®S�a�W,aiY�,������� � �������<ai`�S�a�W,aiY��,� M � �X� M � � ��� M �<`IZ�a4` � ����������� � �,����� ��� � ���� � � � @ � ��� @ C � = � � � �� ����� @ � ���� ����� @ C ����� � � � � D � @ � D ��� @ CED ��� wgHjpa�Z4W,aiQHY[ZOa4`nW�x�Y[Rdf�Q�a4Y^\FW']IY[ZiWIf�Y�`ImXaiQHY[SbY:a4ZiWIeHSiR{a4Rd`�eHS[rOP�QHY2x�Y[Rdf�Q�a4S[w,x�QHRTk�QFWIk^k[`�jpe�aBm�`�Z�aiQHY:mWIklaa4QHW,a2a4QpYnRTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a��U�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_1Y^e�aiZ4WIe�a���k^`�cqUHjpa4Y^S�k[`�e�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e"],WI_djHY[S:k[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eXWI_�`�e�k[`Ie�aiRTe-�jHRdeHf6��Y[e�a4Y^ZiRdeHf��lw%kuW,e"g�Y�SbQH`'x�e"a4`�Y[��jXWI_ � = J��R% � � ���d� � � � = J �8�� A ��������� � ������� �<WIeH\ 5 � � � � �5 � �����,��� � �R����� � wx�QHY^ZiY � �5 � �,������� � �������1 � �@�,������� � ������� ��� � ���� � � � @ � �� @ C � 5 � � � r���UHU�Y[ep\HR{v = \HY[ZbRd]�Y^S�a4QpYEm�`�Zbc�jH_TW�m�`IZa4QpYEY^e�a4Zbo�x�Y[Rdf�Q�a4S^r

P2x:`��HeXWI_JU1`IRTe�a4S�WIg�`�jpa�a4QHY�cV`%\HY[_Xx�R{a4Q"c@jH_daiRTUH_dY�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eHS^r�sBRdZiS�auw%WIS�RTeVaiQHY�SbRTeHfI_TY�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�ecq`-\HY^_¸w,f�Rd]IY[e�a4QHY:c"W,aiZiR v@Rde�]�Y[ZbSiRd`�e�m�`�Zic�jp_�W�m�`IZ�k[`�e�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�],WI_djHY[S^wIa4QHY�k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_%gHjHZi\pY[e`Im�`�g-a�WIRdeHRTeHfVY[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�m�`�Z�a4QHY@UXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[ZbSt`Im�a4QpRTS�cq`%\HY[_ORTStcqRTepRTcVWI_¸r�P�QHY^ZiY�RTS^w<QH`'x�Y^]IY[Z[wCa4QpYgHjHZb\HY[e�`Im�`�gpa�W,RTeHRdeHf"a4QpY"©)WIZi�,`#]�aiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�e�cVW,aiZiR{v*WIeH\.k[`IcVUHj-a4RTepf�Rda4SnRde�]�Y[ZbSiY,wOx�QHRdk�Q�fIZi`'x�SU�`�_do%eH`�cqR�W,_T_dotRTe�a4QHY�e�jHc@g1Y^Z�`,m1\pRTSbaiRTeHkla�Sba4W,a4Y^S��WIeH\�a4QpRTS�RTepk[ZiY[WISiY^S�RTe�a4QpY�e�jHc@g1Y^Z�`Im<_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHS4�lr��S�x�Y�x�RT_d_�SiQH`'x­Rde)`�jpZt©)`Ie�aiY � WIZb_T`FYlvpWIcqUH_dY[S�g1Y^_T`'xywJf�Rd]IY[e)aiQHY@SbRTcqUH_TRdk[R{a}o"`Im�a4QHY�ZiY^Sba�`Im�a4QpYY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRT`�e7UpZi`%k[Y[\pjHZiY,wta4QHRdS ��SiY^aijHU��3a4RdcVY�k[WIe Y[WISiRd_do¥g1Y^k[`�cqY�a4QHY.\H`�cqRTeXW,e�a�k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_gHjHZb\HY[e<w1W,eH\�Rda�x�RT_d_<g�YyYlv-k[Y^SiSiR{]�Y�RdmOx:YyRTepk[ZiY[WISiYnaiQHYye%jpc�g1Y^Z�`ImB_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHS2Y^eH`�jHfIQ�r

«-Y[k^`�eH\�w�WIep\hUpZi`�gXW,gH_do.cq`�ZiYVRTcqU1`�Z�a�WIe�a[wBa4QH`IjHf�Q `�jHZ�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�ZiY[cVWIRde�k[`�epSiRTS�a4Y^e�a�x�QpY[ex�YNRdeHk[ZbYuWISbY�a4QHY�e�jHc�g�Y[ZF`Im�Y^e�aiZbo3_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHS���`�Z[w�m�`�Z�aiQXW,a�cVW,aba4Y[Z^w�a4QHY�e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im�Sba4W,a4Y^SFU1Y^Z_T`%kuW>a4RT`IeJ�lw'a4QpY[RTZCSbc"WI_d_�S4WIcqUH_dY�UpZi`�U�Y[Z�a4RTY^S�x�Rd_T_�k�QXW,eHf�YIrB|}e@UXWIZ�a4Rdk[jH_TWIZ[w>g1`,a4Q�aiQHY�SicVWI_T_�SiWIcVUp_TY�gHR�W,SWIeH\V]IW,ZiR�W,eHk[Y�`Im�`�jHZ�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z�x�Rd_T_X\HY^U1Y^eH\�`�e"aiQHY�],WIZbR�WIeHk^Y[S�`Im�a4QHY�eH`�eHUHWIZ4WIcqY^aiZiRdk�k^`�cVU�`�eHY^e�a� WqU1`IRTe�a�x�Y�k^`�cVY�gXWIk���a4`"RTe�fIZiYuW>a4Y[Z�\HYla�WIRd_�UHZbY[SbY[e�a4_{oH�&rtsX`�Z�WVf�R{]�Y^e*SiRd�[Y[\�\XW,a�WVSiY^a�a4QHY�_�WIZbf�Y[Za4QpY�e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im�\pRTSbaiRTeHkla�Sba�W>a4Y[S��_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHS2a4RdcVY^S�Sba�W>a4Y[S�U1Y^Z�_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eJ�&wpa4QHYym�Y^x�Y[Z�a4QHYEe�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im`�gHSbY[Z�]IW>a4RT`IeHS:U�Y[Z�Sba�W>a4YIwpWIeH\"aiQHY�_TWIZifIY[Z�a4QHY�],WIZbR�WIepk[Y�RTeVaiQHY��XZbSba:Sba�W,f�Y�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[S�RTS�_TRd�IY[_{o�a4`�g�YIr��S�W)ZbY[SbjH_da[w�WISyx:YVRTeHk^ZiY[WISiYFa4QHYqe�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im2S�a�W,aiY[S�m�`IZ�WNf�Rd]IY[e�SiRT�^Y[\�S4WIcqUH_TY�x�Y"cVWuo!QXWu]�YVai`x�`�ZiZ�o"cq`�ZiY�WIg�`�jpa:SicVWI_T_JS4W,cVUH_dY�gpR�WISbY[Sy�WIS�x�Y[_d_<WIS:_�WIZbf�Y[Z�],WIZiRTWIeHk[Y^S��&r�|¡a2RdS�m�`�Z�a4QHRdS:ZiY[WISi`Ie"a4QXW>ax�Y�ZbY[U�`�Zba�`�eqWyZiYuW,Si`�eXW,gH_do�Y&v%a4Y[epSiRd]IYn©)`Ie�aiY � W,Zi_T`yS�a4jH\poF`,m��bjHS�a�QH`'x�a4QHY^SiY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�U�Y[Z�m�`�Zicg�Y[_T`'xyr���Snx:YFx�RT_d_�SbY[YIwCa4QpYqSbc"W,_T_BSiWIcqUH_TY�gpR�WISbY[SEWIZiY�UpZiY[\pRTk^a4WIgH_{o*cq`�ZiY�ep`Ia4Rdk[YuW,gH_TY�Rde�Si`�cqY�`Ima4QpY�W,_da4Y^ZieXW>a4Rd]IYnY[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�W,eXWI_do%�^Y[\�a4QXWIeNRTe�`,a4QHY^ZiS[r×�°!.�ã�êëÞtûÆÚ�Û|êòãfÙ�²rý|äÜÙÍãÜã�êëá3ÞÎü±á�äOÚÜÛ|Ù�±�Ù²êóû�ÛÚÜã�ÚÜÛ|Ù�Ú�±pá<ü±á�äÜï`þtñóÝÆÝ�äÜÙ�åräÜÙÍã�ýÂÙÍø�ÚÜêë÷3Ù²ñóè

� � KJ�� LOJ�����LRN � >*�<�=?>A@���B @���B 5DC3 � T �" �* 04J�� � 63 � T ;8�� 9 KJ���LOJ����9LON ��6 � � >A@��� � "! B @��� �� "! B 5 �� "! C$# >A@ % � B @ % �� B 5 % C �

Ý�Þ�ì�

� � ?J��9L3J����9LON � >*�<�=E>A@��5B @���5B 5DC& �*

3 � �& � KJ � L3J ��� LON ��6 � � >A@��� � ! B @��� �� "! B 5 �� "! C$# >A@ % � B @ % �� B 5 % C � '

¨Iª

Page 22: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

� � �3 *�"��-��a ������ � 1 ���M�4 ��T� ��> ���� �a *���`�c�P�QHY*Rd\HYuW,SV\HRdSik^jHSiSbY[\ WIg�`#]IY�k[WIe�g�Y�k[`Ic�gHRTepY[\7WIep\J�,`�ZqcV`%\HR{�XY[\hRTeL\HRd�1Y[ZbY[e�a"x:Wuo-S6ai`~`�g-a�WIRdeWI_{a4Y[ZbeXW,aiRd]�YFY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS[r"P�QpRTSESiY[kla4Rd`�e�x�Rd_T_�\HRdSik[jpSiS@SbY^]IY[Z4W,_�`Im:a4QHY^SiY6W,_da4Y^ZieXW>a4Rd]IY[S^r6P�QHZi`IjHf�QH`�j-ax�YEx�Rd_T_�WISbSijHcqYya4QXW,a�aiQHYye%jpc�g1Y^Z�`,m�`�gHSbY[Z�]IW>a4RT`IeHS�W,a�YuWIk�Q�`Im�W��XeHR{a4YySiYla�`,m��,�������2Sba4W,a4Y^S�fIZi`'x�Sx�RdaiQH`�jpaBg1`IjHeH\@x�R{a4Q�SiWIcVUp_TY:SbRT�^YIrB��S�eH`IaiY[\�`IjHZBcq`-\pY[_TRdeHf�WISiSbjHcVU-a4RT`IeHSBRdeHSijHZbY:a4QpRTSCx:`�jp_T\�`%k[k[jpZRdm�a4QHYE\XW,a4Wqk[WIcqYEm�Zb`�c WVSbRTeHfI_TYy_T`�epfFaiRTcqYySiY[ZbRTY^S[r�|¡a�x:`IjH_T\�WI_TSb`V`%k[k^jHZ�R{m�`�jpZ�\HW,a�Wqk[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[\)`ImW�UXWIeHY^_�`Im2\HR{�<Y^ZiY^e�aEcVWIZi�,Y^aiS6��`�ZnRTeH\pjHSbaiZiRTY^S���x�RdaiQ�RdeHRdaiR�WI_Ok[`IeH\HRdaiRT`�epSnZiY[S�a4ZbRTk^aiY[\�RTe.W�x:Wuo�a4QXW>aRTepSijHZbY[StSbj � k[RTY^e�at]%RTSiR{a4S�a4`�WVSicVWI_T_Ce�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im�Sba4W,a4Y^S[rn��RdaiQHY[Z�SiYlan`Im�k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeHS�RdeHSijpZiY�aiQXW,atWI_T_Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS2ai`Fg1YyRTe�aiZi`%\HjHk[Y^\�QHY[ZbY@WIZbY�� �1�¡k[`�epSiRTS�a4Y^e�a�WIep\)W,Sbo%cVU-a4`IaiRTkuW,_T_doVeH`�Zbc"W,_��`IZ � � ]t�&r

P�QHY�W,_da4Y^ZieXW>a4Rd]IYyY[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�x�RT_d_�QXWu]�Y�g�`IaiQ)\HR{�<Y^ZiY^e�a�k[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�eXW,_�gHjHZb\HY[eHStWIeH\�\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`IeHS*��_�WIZbf�YNWIS"x�Y[_d_�WISVSicVWI_T_�SiWIcVUp_TYIw�a4QH`�jpf�Q$WISVx�Y*SbQXWI_T_�SbY[Y*a4QpRTSqRTS6W�kuWISbY�x�QHY[ZbYa4QpY�UHZb`�U1Y^ZbaiRTY[SV`Imna4QpY[RTZVSicVWI_T_�SiWIcqUH_TYN\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�epS"WIZbY�_dRT�IY^_do ai`�g1Y)UXWIZ�a4RTk^jH_�W,Zi_do�RTcqU1`�Z�a�WIe�am�`�ZnW,UHUH_TRdY[\*x�`�Zi�-�&r���m�a4Y^ZnkuW,aiY[f�`IZiRT�^RTeHfVa4QHYFWI_{a4Y^ZieXW,aiRd]IY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiSnW,eH\!UHZi`']%RT\HRdeHf�WIe!RTe-m�`�ZicVWI_a4QpY[`�ZbY^a4RdkuWI_X\pRTSik^jHSiSbRT`�eq`Im�a4QHY^RTZ�UHZb`�U1Y^ZbaiRTY[S^w�x:Y�UHZi`']%RT\pY�ZiW,a4QpY[Z�Ylv%a4Y^eHSiR{]�Yt©)`�e�a4Y � WIZi_d`yZiY[SbjH_daiS�`�eQH`'x¯aiQHY^o�U�Y[Z�m�`�Zic RTe�a}x�`VY&vHW,cVUH_dY[S^z�W�SbRTeHf�_dYyWIeH\NW�a}x:`q_T`%kuW,aiRT`�e"YlvpWIcqUH_TY,r

P2x:`)f�Y[epY[Z4W,_�U�`�Rde�aiSySiQH`�jp_T\.g1Yq�IY^Upa@Rde�cqRTep\!x�QpRT_TY�k^`�eHSbRT\HY^ZiRTepfNaiQHYqWI_daiY[ZieHW,a4R{]�Y[S^r"��_T_�`�jpZY[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS�W,ZiYnSiY^cVR �}UXW,Z4WIcqY^aiZiRTk�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS2x�R{a4Q�a4QHYyUHZb`�U�Y[ZbaiRTY^S2a4QXW,a

* aiQHY)ep`�eHUXWIZiWIcqY^a4ZbRTk�k^`�cVU�`�eHY^e�a4S���a4QpY*©�W,Zi�I`']3a4ZiWIeHSbRda4Rd`�e3c"W>a4ZiRdk[Y^SVW,eH\¥Y&vpR{aVWIeH\¥Y^e�a4ZboUHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S�eHY[Y^\HY[\!a4`�k[`IcVUHj-a4Y ��/. WIeH\ �������Y^e�a4Y[ZnaiQHY�`�g%�bY^k^a4R{]�Y�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�e!RTe!W6eH`�e%�_dRTeHY[WIZ:x:W'oIw�WIeH\

* aiQHY�],WIZiRTWIeHk[Y@`Im�a4QHY�UXW,Z4WIcqY^aiZiRTk@k[`�cqU1`IeHY[e�aq��`Im ����\HY^U1Y^eH\HSy`�e�a4QHY�],WIZbR�WIepk[Y�`Im�aiQHY��XZiS�aS�a�WIf�YyeH`IeHUXWIZiWIcVYla4ZbRTktY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[S^r

P�QHY�eH`�eH_dRTeHY[WIZiR{a}o@`Im1a4QHY�`�g��bY[k^aiRd]IY�m�jHepk^a4Rd`�eFRTe�a4QpY��HZiSba�Sba4WIf�Y�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRT`�e�Y^ZiZb`�ZiS�RTcqUH_dRTY[SOa4QXW>a`�jHZCUXW,Z4WIcqY^aiY[ZCY[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[SCWIZbY�_dRT�IY^_do�a4`�g1Y�gHRTWISiY^\�RdeESbc"W,_T_�SiWIcVUp_TY[S^r�«%RTeHk^YIw,WISOx�Y�x�RT_T_,SiY^YIw�RdeESb`�cqYS4W,cVUH_dY[S�a4QpYtWu]�Y^Z4WIf�Y�e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im�`�gpSiY[Z�],W,a4Rd`�eHS�U1Y^Zt��������� �bk^Y[_T_ �ykuWIe6g�Y�WIS�Sbc"W,_T_XWIS�a}x�`�`�Z�a4QHZbY[Y,wa4QpRTS�SicVWI_d_-SiWIcVUp_TY�gHRTWIS�kuW,eqg�Y�eH`IaiRTk[Y[WIgH_dYIrOP�QXW,a�gHR�W,SBx�RT_d_p\HR{�<Y^Z��Si`IcVYla4RTcqY[SB\HZ4WIcVW,aiRTkuW,_T_dop�<x�RdaiQa4QpYtYlv%a4Y^e�a�`Im�a4QHY�eH`�eH_dRTeHY[WIZiR{a}oFRTeH\pjHk[Y^\�g�oqa4QpY�m�`�Zic `Im�aiQHYt`�g��bY[k^aiRd]IY�m�jHeHkla4RT`Ie�wHWIep\6SiRdeHk[Y�aiQHY[ZbYWIZbYyWFe�jHc@g1Y^Z�`,m�WI_{a4Y^ZieXW,aiRd]IYt`�g%�bY^k^a4R{]�Yym�jHeHkla4RT`IeHS2a4`Fk�QH`%`�SiYnm�Zb`�c)wp`�eHYncqRTf�Q�a2x:WIe�a�a4`�a�WI�,Yna4QHRdSRTe�ai`VW,k[k[`IjHe�a�Rde�k�QH`-`ISiRTepfVW,cV`�epf�a4QHY^c � � r

|¡a�RTS�U�`�SiSbRTgH_dY�a4`@jHSiYtS�a�WIep\XWIZi\�SbY[cqR{�¡UXWIZ4W,cVYla4ZiRdk�m�`�Zic�jp_�Wna4`�`�g-a�WIRdeVa4QpYnWISbo%cqUpa4`,a4RTk�],WIZiRTWIeHk^Y`Im�`�jHZnUHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[ZtY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S[w�gHjpanaiQHY[ZbY�RTSn_dRdaiai_TYEZiY[WISi`�e�ai`�m�`%k[jpSn`�e*a4QH`ISiY�m�`�Zic@jH_�W"QpY[ZiY,r�P�QHRdSRTS�g�Y[k[WIjHSiYEx:Y�QXWu]�Y@WVk[`IcVUH_dY^aiYEcq`%\HY[_CWIep\NaiQHY@k^`�cVUpjpa�W,aiRT`�eHWI_�gHjHZb\HY[e)`Im�`�g-a�WIRdeHRTeHf�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S× �ÍâMÞ!Ý�ñëÚ�Ù²äÜÞtÝ�Ú�êó÷�ÙO±�á�þtñóì_ðÂÙ>Ú�á<ì|Ù²÷�ÙÍñëá3ý]ã�ïÆÝ�ñëñ�ãÜÝ�ïÆý|ñóÙ�ð|êòÝ�ã�øGá3ä�äÜÙÍøGÚ�êóá�ÞtãÍå3Ý`ä�á3þrÚ�Ù�±pÙ*ìrá<Þtá�Ú�ø²á�Þtã�êòìrÙ²ä�Û|Ù²äÜÙ �jâMñòã�áÚ�Ûtä�á3þ|û�Û|á3þrÚ�±�Ù]êóû�Þ|á3ä�ÙÎÚ�Û|Ù)ý|ä�á3ð|ñóÙ²ï�á�ü�ìrÙÍ÷�ÙÍñëá3ý|êëÞtûTÚ�ÙÍãyÚÜãgá�üMá�þ|ä<ïgárìrÙÍñÖå[ÙÍ÷�ÙÍÞ�Ú�Û|á3þ|û�Û$êëÚ_øGñóÙÍÝ�äÜñóèaêòã`ýÂá3ãÜã�êëð|ñóÙ_ÚÜáìrÙÍ÷�Ù²ñóá�ýTã�þtøÈÛ]ÚÜÙÍãyÚÜã��

¨Õ=

Page 23: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

m�Zi`Ic a4QXW,a:cV`%\HY^_XRTS�cVRdeHRTcVWI_¸rCP�Q�jHS2R{a�RTS�ZiY[_TW,a4R{]�Y^_do�Y[WISboqa4`�`�gpa�W,RTe"Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`Im�Sba�W,eH\XWIZb\6Y[ZbZi`�ZbSm�Zi`Ic¬W*UXWIZiWIcqY^a4ZbRTk6g�`%`Ia4S�a4Z4W,U � � r~P�QpY�mW,k^a�a4QHW,a�a4QpY)W,Sbo%cVU-a4`IaiRTk"],WIZbR�WIeHk^Y[S�`Im�aiQHY�UXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^ZY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[Sy\H`�\HY^U1Y^eH\~`�e!a4QpYq],WIZbR�WIeHk^Y�`Im�a4QHYqeH`�eHUHWIZ4WIcqY^aiZiRdk�k[`�cqU1`IeHY[e�aV��aiQXW,aya4QpYqY^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZRTSEeH`Ia �iWI\HWIUpa4R{]�Y9���nm�`I_T_T`'x�Snm�Zi`Ic a4QHYqmWIk^aEa4QXW>a�aiQHY"\HY^ZiR{]IW>a4Rd]IYV`,m:a4QpY"`�g%�bY^k^aiRd]�YVm�jHeHk^aiRT`�e!x�RdaiQZiY^SiU�Y[kla�ai`FaiQHYyY[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�`Im ��/. WIep\ ���� \p`VeH`,a�QXWu]�Y�WFk^`�eH\HR{a4Rd`�eXWI_1Ylv-U1Y^k^a4W,a4Rd`�e)`,mB�^Y[Zi`pr

��_{a4Y[ZbeXW,aiRd]�Y � � ]$Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS�kuWIeVg1Y�`�g-a�WIRdeHY[\Fg�o�],WIZbo%RTepfEY[WIk�Q"`,m<a4QpY�aiQHZiY^Y�\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a�cVW#�b`�Zk[`IcVU�`�eHY^e�aiS"`Im�a4QHY�WI_Tf�`IZiRdaiQHcNr �~Y)k[`�epSiRT\pY[Z �beXW,aijHZ4WI_ ��SbjHf�f�Y^SbaiRT`�eHSVm�`�ZVY[WIk�Q�`Im�a4QHY^SiY*k^`�cF�U�`�eHY[e�aiS[r ��S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�Z"k[WIe7g�Y�`�gpa�W,RTeHY^\�g�o�k[`Ic�gHRTepRTeHf W,e�oLSijpf�f�Y[S�a4Rd`�e�m�`�Z6Y[WIk�Q$`Imya4QHY�aiQHZiY^Yk[`IcVU�`�eHY^e�aiS[r ��Y@k^`�eHSiRd\HY[Z�WI_d_�U1`�SbSiRdgHRT_dRda4RdY[S2RdeNaiQHY�©N`�e�a4Y � W,Zi_T`qYlvpWIcqUH_dY[S[r �Y[ZbY�RdS�Wq_TRTS�a4RdeHf�`Ima4QpYEk^`�cqU1`�epY[e�a4S�WIeH\N`�jHZ�SbjHf�f�Y^SbaiRT`�eHS�m�`�Z�Y[WIk�Q�r= r�P�QHYy`�g��bY[k^aiRd]IYEm�jHepk^a4Rd`�e�jHSiY^\�Rde�aiQHYySiY^k[`�eH\NSba4WIf�Y,r�|}e�a4QpRTS�k[`Ie�aiYlv%a�x:YEk[`�epSiRT\pY[Z

� W��6aiQHYqUHSiY^jH\H`�_d`�f,�¡_TRT�,Y[_dRTQH`%`-\�m�jHepk^a4Rd`�e�w�x�QHRdk�Q�Rde!aiQHYqSiRTepf�_TY�_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e�cq`-\HY^_Bx�`�jH_T\.g�Ym�`IZicqY[\�g�o�SijHcqcVRdeHf

����%64��5��S ��� ��� J %6 �p_T`�f5. G ' ���. b�W���(SU� 0 )�%6I_d`�f � = J .G ' ���.2��,���(SU��0 �

) 5�>_T`�fS. 0 ' ����9��W���(SU� 0 ) ��% J�5� �p_d`�f � = J . 0 ' ����9b�,���(SU��0��`']IY[Z��&wJWIeH\

�gX��W�cqY^aiQH`%\6`ImOcV`IcVY^e�a:Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�a4QXW,a:cVRdeHRTcqRT�^Y[S�W�eH`�Zbc Rde"a4QpYt\HRd�1Y[ZbY[eHk^Yng1Yla}x:Y^Y[eaiQHY"\HW,a�W�`�e�aiQHYqSba�W>a4YqSiU�Y[k[R{�Xk"Y^e�a4Zbo.W,eH\~Y&vpR{a@ZiW,a4Y^S@W,eH\�aiQHYVY^e�a4Zbo�WIep\~Ylv-R{a@ZiW,a4Y^SUpZiY[\pRTk^aiY[\Ng�o6a4QHYycq`-\pY[_1m�`IZ�\HRd�1Y[ZbY[e�a�],WI_TjHY^S�`Im���� WIeH\NSi`FcqRTf�Q�a�g�YnkuW,_T_TY^\�W�UHSiY^jH\H`cqRTepRTc�jHc ZC��Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z4�lwpWIeH\

�ku�NW�cqY^aiQH`-\!`Im�cq`�cVY^e�anY[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�aiQXW,aEcqRTeHRdcVRd�[Y[S�W�eH`�Zbc RTe�aiQHY)� Wu]�Y^Z4WIf�YF`']�Y^ZEWI_T_S�a�W,aiY[S4�N`Im�a4QHY.\HRd�1Y[ZbY[eHk^Y~g�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e a4QHY�WIk^aijXWI_yY[e�aiZbo WIeH\ Ylv-Rda)Z4W>a4Y[S)WIeH\ a4QHY.Y[e%�aiZ4WIe�aiS��,Y&vpR{a4S�UHZiY^\HRTkla4Y^\)g�o6aiQHYycV`%\HY[_1m�`�Z�\HRd�1Y[ZbY[e�a�],WI_TjHY^S�`Im � � !'r

¨ r�P�QHY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiRT`�e�`Im�aiQHYya4Z4W,eHSiR{a4RT`Ie)UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S2g�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e�Sba�W>a4Y[S^r�|}e�a4QHRdS�k^`�e�a4Y&v-a�x:Y�k[`�e%�SbRT\HY^Z

× D ú�êóÞtøGÙB±pÙ>ÛtÝ®÷�Ù�ÙÍãyÚ�êóïÆÝ�Ú�ÙmãSá�ü2øGá�ÞÚÜêëÞ�þtÝ�Ú�êóá�ÞÎÝ�Þ�ì_Ù²ÞÚ�äÜèÆ÷«Ý�ñóþ|ÙÍã�øGá3ÞtìrêëÚ�êóá�ÞtÝ�ñ�á3Þ KJMLRN �Gå^±�Ù>øÍÝ�ÞÎþtã�Ù�á3þ|äSÙmã�ÚÜêëï_Ý�Ú�ÙÍãá�ü��_Ý�Þtì 8 N�� ( N �SÚ�áÆû�ÙÍÞ|Ù²äÈÝ«ÚÜÙ>êóÞtìrÙÍý�ÙÍÞtìrÙ²ÞÚ�ãÜÝ�ïÆý|ñóÙÍãOá�üYã�êëöÍÙ*Ùi·þtÝ�ñÂÚ�á_á3þ|äfã�Ý�ïÆý|ñëÙ�ã�êëöÍÙ �[ùÕágá3ðrÚÜÝ�êëÞ)Ú�ÛtÙ*ý�Ý�äÈÝ�ïÆÙGÚÜä�êòøðÂáá�ÚÜãyÚ�äÈÝ�ýy±�ÙÆãyêóïÆý|ñëè"Ùmã�ÚÜêëï_Ý�Ú�Ù��)ü±äÜá�ïÔÙÍÝ3øÈÛ»á�ü@ÚÜÛ|ÙÍã�ÙgýtãyÙÍþtìrá!äÜÝ�Þtìrá3ïÔãÜÝ�ïÆý|ñóÙÍã*Ý�Þ�ìTÚÜÝ�ß�Ù<Ú�Û|Ùg÷«Ý�äÜêóÝ�ÞtøGÙ<á�ü[Ú�Ûtá3ã�ÙÙÍãyÚ�êóï_Ý«ÚÜÙÍã��×�*�1�Þ_á�þ|ä �"á�ÞÚ�Ù�î�Ý�äÜñëá�Ù�²|Ý�ïgýtñëÙmã[Ú�ÛtÙMÞ�þ|ï`ðÂÙ²ä@á�ü�ýtÝ�äÈÝ�ïÆÙGÚÜÙ²äÈãjÙb·þtÝ�ñóãjÚÜÛ|Ù�Þ�þ|ï<ð�ÙÍä@á�ü�ñóárø²Ý«ÚÜêëá3Þ_ãyýÂÙÍø²ê ��øMÙ²ÞÚ�äÜè<Ý�ÞtìÙ�²rêëÚfäÜÝ�Ú�ÙÍãfã�á<Ú�ÛtÝ�ÚfÚ�Û|ÙmãyÙ�ïÆá�ïÆÙ²ÞÚÈã�±fêëñóñ���þtãyÚMêóì|Ù²ÞÚ�êëü±èÎÚÜÛ|Ù�ýtÝ�äÈÝ�ïÆÙGÚÜÙ²äÈã � 1 üYÚ�Û|ÙÍä�Ù�±�Ù²äÜÙ*ïÆá3ä�Ù*ýtÝ�äÈÝ�ïÆÙ²Ú�Ù²äÈã<±pÙ�±�á�þ|ñòìÛtÝ®÷3Ù<ÚÜá»Ý�ì|ì�ø²á«÷®Ý�ä�êòÝ�Þ�øGÙÍã*ðÂÙGÚ�±�Ù²ÙÍÞaÚÜÛ|ÙÎý|äÜÙÍì|êóøGÚ�êóá�Þ�Ù²äÜä�á3äÜã�Ý�ÞtìaÚ�Û|ÙÎ÷«Ý�ñëþ|Ù_á�üpÚÜÛ|Ù]ãyÚÜÝ�Ú�Ù_÷«Ý�äÜêóÝ�ð|ñóÙÍã*Ú�á"êòìrÙÍÞ3ÚÜê ü±èaÚ�ÛtÙïÆárìrÙ²ñ �

¨�¨

Page 24: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

� W���jpSiRTepfqaiQHYyY[cqUHRTZbRTkuW,_�©�W,Zi�I`']�cVW,a4ZbR{v�� WIS�WIg�`']�Yu�lw�WIeH\�gX��k^`�cqUHjpa4RdeHf6Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[S�`Im�a4QHY@Y[e�a4Z�o�WIeH\�Y&v-RdanUHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S�W,atY[WIk�Q!_T`%kuW,aiRT`�e�W,atY[WIk�Q

���������lwyWIeH\ a4QHY^e jpSiRTepfhaiQHY�gpRTeH`�cqR�W,_��`IZ�c�jH_daiRTeH`IcVRTWI_���m�`�Zic@jH_�W~ai`Lf�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4Y!a4QpY©)WIZi�,`#]*c"W,aiZiR v�a4QHY^SiY�UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^S�RTcqUH_doIr ��Y�kuWI_d_OaiQHY�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[S�`�gpa4WIRTeHY^\*RTe)a4QHRdSx:Wuo�a4QHY>�bS�a4ZbjHk^aijHZ4WI_ ��a4Z4W,eHSiR{a4RT`Ie�c"W,aiZiR v<r

D r�P�QHY�k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`Ie�`Im��XZbSbayS�a�WIf�Y@k[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�e�WIep\�Y[e�a4Z�o�],WI_TjpY[S�k^`�eH\HR{a4Rd`�eXWI_O`�e�aiQHY�Y[S�a4R{�cVW,a4Y^\�a4Z4W,eHSiR{a4RT`Ie�UHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S^rB|}e�a4QpRTS�k[`�e�aiYlv%a�x�Yyk[`�epSiRT\pY[Z� W���jpSiRTepfqaiQHYy\HRTSbk[`�jHe�aiY[\NSijHc `ImOm�jpaijHZiYyUHZb`I�Ha4S�f�R{]�Y^e)g�o6aiQHYnm�`�Zic�jp_�W�WIg�`']�YIwJW,eH\�gX��jpSiRTepf�W"SiRdeHf�_dY�W,f�Y[e�an\po%eXW,cVRdk�UHZb`�f�ZiWIcVcqRTepfqepY[SbaiY[\*�pv-Y^\�U1`�Rde�atWI_df�`�ZbRda4Qpc)¢XR r Y,r�x�Y

SbjHgHS�a4Rdaijpa4Y�a4QpYNUpZi`I�HaFm�jHepk^a4Rd`�ehWIeH\hY[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[SF`Im�a4QHY�a4ZiWIeHSiR{a4Rd`�e UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRdaiRTY^S@RTe�ai`aiQHY�k^`�e�a4ZiWIk^aiRT`�eVc"WIUpUHRTeHfE\HYl�XeHRTepf�W�SbRTeHfI_TY�WIf�Y^e�a � S�],WI_TjHY�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�e���Y[��jXW,aiRT`�e = ��W,eH\k^`�cqUHjpa4YyR{a�m�`�Z�YuWIk�QN\HR{�<Y^ZiY[e�a �N�SbY[Yyg1Y^_T`'x¯m�`IZ�\HY^a4WIRT_dS��lr

sBRTeHWI_T_{o@eH`,a4Y�a4QXW>a�f�Rd]IY[eVWIe�oF`�eHY�`Im�a4QHY^SiY�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�x�Y�k^`�jH_T\qWI_{x2Wuo%S�Rda4Y^Z4W,aiY�`�eFa4`EWEc@jH_daiR{�Sba4WIf�Y�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z[r�P�QHY�SbY[k[`IeH\6Sba4WIf�Y�jHSiY^S:a4QpY��XZbSba�Sba4WIf�Y�UXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[Z�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�a4`�k[`�cqUHjpaiY�Y^e�a4ZboWIeH\NYlv-R{a�],WI_djHY[S�x�QHRdk�Q�W,ZiYyjHSiY^\�RdeNk^`�e>�bjHepk^a4Rd`�e�x�Rda4Q�a4QpYy�HZiSba�Sba4WIf�YyY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�WIZbYna4`qk[`�cqUHjpaiYY[e�aiZbo�WIep\NY&v-Rda�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S[w�x�QHRdk�Q�wHRTe6aijHZie<wJWIZiYtjpSiY[\�a4`Fk^`�cVUpjpa4YnS�a4Zijpk^a4jpZ4WI_<aiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�e"UHZi`�g%�WIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^S�WIeXWI_d`�f�`�jHS�a4`"aiQH`�SbY�RTe3� ¨ gJ�lryP�QHY�epY^x Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`Im�aiZ4WIeHSbRdaiRT`�e)UHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S�WIZbY@a4QpY[ejHSbY[\*a4`VUHZi`%\HjHk^Y�eHYlxA�XZiS�atSba4WIf�Y�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`Im�k[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�e)WIeH\*Y^e�aiZboN],WI_TjHY^S�Y^Rda4QpY[Z�jHSiRdeHf"a4QpYcVW,a4ZbR{v�Rde�]�Y[ZbSiRd`�e�Rde�� D W��2`�Z�a4QHYEeHY[S�a4Y^\��pv-Y[\*U�`�Rde�a�Rde�� D gJ�lr:|}eH\HY[Y^\�a4QpY@Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�Z�RTeN��fIjHRTZbZiYl�f�WIgpRTZiRTWtWIeH\V©)RdZ4Wq� ¨,ª�ª D ��ep`Ia4Y^\VRdeq`IjHZ�RTe�a4Zb`-\pjHk^aiRT`�e�RdS[w�RTe�`IjHZ�a4Y[ZbcVRdeH`�_d`�fIo�wIWnUHSiY^jH\H`Ec"W>v-Rdc�jHc_TRd�IY^_TRTQp`-`%\�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�Z�WISnRTeh� = W���aiQXW,ayjHSbY[Sna4QHY�S�a4ZbjHk^aijHZ4WI_�aiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�e�c"W,aiZiRdk[Y[S�RTeh� ¨ gJ�tWIeH\�a4QpYeHY^Sba4Y^\ �pv-Y[\ U�`�RTe�a@ai`*k[`IcVUHj-a4Y"Y^e�a4Zbo�WIeH\�k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e�],WI_djHY[S�W,S@RTe7� D gJ�&w�WIeH\�a4QHYlo~mWu]�`�Z@Wc�jH_{a4R �}SbaiY[UF]�Y^ZiSiRd`�e�`Im�aiQHY[RdZ�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z�x�QHRdk�Q6RdaiY[Z4W>a4Y[S�RTeqa4QHRdS�x:Wuo � '#r ��Y�SbQH`�jH_d\6eH`IaiY�a4QHW,a�aiQHY[ZbYRTS�ep`Vf�jHWIZ4WIe�aiY[Yna4QXW>a�a4QHYyRdaiY[ZiW,a4Rd`�eHS�RTcqUHZb`#]IYta4QHYyY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[S�`IZ�aiQXW,a�aiQHY^o�x�Rd_T_<k^`�e�]�Y^Zif�Yya4`VWIe�o��a4QpRTeHf*��x�Y@k[`IcVYEgXWIk���a4`Vg1`IaiQ)aiQHY[SbY�U1`IRTe�a4S�g1Y^_T`'x��lw�`�Z^w1R{mBa4QpY^oN\H`6k^`�e�]�Y[Zbf�YIw1a4QHYlo)k^`�e�]�Y^Zif�Y@ai`Si`IcVYla4QHRdeHf�a4QXW,a�RdS�k[`�epSiRTS�a4Y^e�a�x�RdaiQ�`�jHZ�WISbSijHcqUpa4Rd`�eHS�`�e�a4QpYEk�Qp`�RTk^YE`,mBY^�%jpRT_TRdgHZiRdjHcNr

� ��� � Z � � F�bgXjL Zgb XjRTF CvHÈXjFMD@bTJ*XjEG\<F � L2XjE � J*XYZ<D[L �� 1 � '0/ +(:�� 4�� '������ ' � 4�� '�� �.+� � 4�� + ;��Y�WI_TZbYuWI\-o@eH`,a4Y[\�aiQXW,a�aiQHY2],WIZiRTWIeHk^Y:`Im1WI_d_%`,m1`IjHZ�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiSOx�RT_d_%g�Y�\HYla4Y[ZbcVRdeHY[S^w�RTe@UXWIZba[w�g�o@a4QpY],WIZiRTWIeHk^YE`,m�a4QHYy�XZbSbatS�a4Y^U�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS�`Im ��.V�43 ��WIep\ ���"�43 �&r2��S�WVZbY[SbjH_da�a4QHYEUHSbY[jH\H`"c"W>v-Rdc�jHc×�0ÍâMû3þ|êëäÜäÜÙ²û3Ý�ð|êóä�êòÝ�Ý�Þtì �"êëäÈÝ�äÜÙb·þ|êóä�Ù�ê � ê � ì �[Ù�²ÚÜä�ÙÍïÆÙM÷«Ý�ñóþ|Ù>ìrêòãyÚ�äÜêëð|þ|Ú�êóá�ÞtãSü±á�ä�ð�á�Ú�Û_ÚÜÛ|Ù*Ù²ÞÚ�äÜègü±Ù²ÙÍã�Ý�Þ�ìÆÚ�Û|Ù*ãyÙÍñëñÂá�ô÷«Ý�ñóþ|ÙÍã ¦Ý3ã¤êóÞ� fþtãyÚÍå ��������� �2ùOÛ|êòã2Ý3ã�ã�þ|ïÆýrÚ�êóá�Þ�êóïÆý|ñóêëÙmã¤ÚÜÛtÝ«Ú¤ÚÜÛ|ÙSÙÍÞÚ�äÜè*ø²á3ãyÚÜã�ü±á3ä¤ÚÜÛ|ÙSãÜÝ�ïÆÙSÝ�û3Ù²ÞÚ2êóÞ�ìrêëôÂÙÍä�ÙÍÞ3ÚYñëárøÍÝ«Ú�êóá�Þ�ãÝ�äÜÙ�êëÞ�ìrÙ²ýÂÙ²Þtì|Ù²ÞÚ�Ý�Þtì)ÛtÝ®÷3Ù>ü±þtñëñ2ã�þ|ý|ýÂá�ä�Ú ±ê � Ù �jÚ�ÛtÙ²è�±fêóñóñ�ð�Ù�ñòÝ�äÜû�Ù�Þ|ÙÍû3Ý«ÚÜêë÷3Ù>Þ�þ|ï<ð�ÙÍäÜã�±fêëÚ�Û"ã�á�ïÆÙ�ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êëñóêëÚ�è � �

¨ D

Page 25: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

_TRd�IY^_TRTQp`-`%\VY^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z�x�RT_d_1eH`,a�g1YtWISbo%cqUpa4`IaiRTk[WI_T_{oFY � k[RdY[e�a�Y^]IY[eNjHeH\HY^Z�Sba�W,eH\XWIZb\NZbY[f�jp_�WIZbRda}oqk[`�e%�\HR{a4RT`IeHS[r�|}e*WI\p\HRdaiRT`�e�Rdm�a4QHY^ZiYERTS�WF_T`'x:Y^Z�g�`�jHep\�`�e�a4QHYE\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`IeN`,m�Y[e�aiZbo�m�Y[Y^S�a4QHW,a�c�jHSba�g�YY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[\3�WIeH\*\pY[U�Y[eH\HRdeHf6`�e)a4QHY�UpZi`I�Ha�m�jHeHkla4RT`Ie*SijHk�Q.W"g�`�jHep\*cVRdf�Q�a�g�Y@ZbY[��jHRdZiY[\*ai`6RTepSijHZbYa4QHW,aVaiQHY�©�WIZi�,`']Lk�QHWIRTeLf�Y[eHY^Z4W,aiY[\Lg�o3aiQHY�cq`-\pY[_�RTS��XepRda4Y,w2SiY^Y*WISbSijHcqUpaiRT`�e = r ¨ �lw�`�eHYN`Imta4QpYUXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^ZiSya4`Ng1YqY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[\.\HY^�HeHY[S@W)U�`�RTe�ay`Im�SbjHUHU�`�Zba�`Im�a4QHYq_TRd�IY[_dRTQH`%`%\h��x�QHRdk�Q~RTe�],WI_dRT\XW,aiY[Sa4QpY6ZiY^f�jH_�W,ZiRda}o!k^`�eH\HR{a4Rd`�eHSEZiY[��jHRdZiY^\~m�`�Z�aiQHY"Y � k[RTY^eHk^o~`Im�a4QpY"cVW>v-RTc�jHc®_dRT�,Y[_TRdQH`%`-\!Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiSm�`�Z�c�jp_da4RdeH`�cqR�WI_dS�Y^]�Y^e�R{m�aiQHYyk[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�e�WIeH\NY[e�aiZbo�],WI_TjpY[S2x�Y[ZiYEk[`IcVUHj-a4Y[\�x�RdaiQH`�jpa�Y^ZiZb`�Z��&r

«-`LaiQHY!jHSijHWI_�_dRTcqRdaiRTeHf�WIZifIjHcVY^e�a4SNRTe$mW']I`�Z�`Im�cVW>v-RTc@jHc _dRT�IY^_TRdQH`-`%\�\H`LeH`Ia)WIUHUp_do7QHY^ZiY,r©)`�ZbY[`']�Y^Z@a4QpY[ZiYVWIZbYqa}x�`�WIZbf�jHcqY[e�a4Syx�QHRTk�Q~SiQH`�jp_T\~_dYuWI\.jHSEa4`�x:`�ZbZbo�WIg�`�jpaEa4QHYqSicVWI_d_�S4WIcqUH_TYUHZb`�U1Y^ZbaiRTY[S�`Im�aiQHYEUHSiY^jH\H`�cVW>v-RTc�jHc _TRT�,Y[_dRTQH`%`-\�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z^r�sBRdZiSba�aiQHY�SbY[eHSbRdaiRd]%Rda}o�`ImBa4QHY�UHSiY^jH\H`cVW>v-RTc�jHc _dRT�IY^_TRdQH`-`%\FY[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z�ai`�a4QHYtY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Rd`�e"Y^ZiZi`IZ2RTe"aiQHYnk[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e6WIeH\�Ylv-R{a2],WI_TjHY^S:RdS\HYla4Y[ZbcVRdeHY[\�g�o.aiQHYq\HY[ZbRd],W,a4R{]�YF`Im2aiQHYq_T`�f�`Im2aiQHYqUHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S�`Im�Ylv-R{a@W,eH\~Y^e�aiZbo!x�RdaiQ~ZbY[SiU�Y[klaa4`qa4QHY^SiY@],WI_djHY[S^¢<R r Y,r�g�o)`�eHY@`']IY[Z�aiQHY�aiZijHY�UHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S^r �$QHY^e*a4QH`�SbY@UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S�WIZbY@SicVWI_d_¸wWIeH\Na4QHYloN`Im�a4Y^e*WIZbY@RTeNY[e�aiZbop�,Ylv-R{at\XW,a4WVSbY^a4S^w1aiQXW,a�\HY[ZbRd],W,aiRd]�Yyx�RT_d_�g1Yy]�Y^Zbo)_�WIZbf�YEWIeH\)c"W>v-Rdc�jHc_TRd�IY^_TRTQp`-`%\Vx�Rd_T_<aiY[eH\�a4`FUHZb`-\Hjpk[YyY[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS2x�R{a4Q�U1`%`�Z2�XepRda4YnSiWIcqUH_TYnU�Y[Z�m�`�ZicVWIeHk^YIr

«-Y[k^`�eH\�w�WIep\�k[`�epk[Y[U-a4jXWI_d_do.��jHRdaiY6\HRdSba4RdeHk^a[wBSbRTeHk^Y"a4QHY"UHSiY^jH\H`!_TRd�IY[_dRTQH`%`%\�� SnUpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[SEWIZbYeH`Ia�aiQHY�a4ZijpY�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S:��aiQHY^oqWIZbY�k[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eHY^\�`�eVY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^\VW,eH\Vep`Ia�a4QHY�aiZijHY�Y[e�a4Z�oFWIeH\qYlv-R{a],WI_TjpY[S��&w�Y^]IY[e�a4S�k[WIe `%k[k[jpZ�x�QHRdk�Q�a4QHY6UpSiY[jp\H`�_TRd�IY[_dRTQH`%`%\�W,SiSiRdf�eHS��[Y[Zb`�UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o�a4`3��m�`�Z@W,e�o� ��y�lw<Y^]�Y^e�aiQH`�jHf�Q*aiQHY�S4W,cVY�Yl]�Y[e�aiS�c�jpSbanQXWu]IYqep`�eH�[Y^Zi`NUHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o�Rde*a4QHY�aiZijHY�_dRT�,Y[_TRdQH`%`-\�Y^_TSbYNaiQHY^ohk[`IjH_T\LeH`Iaq`-k^k[jHZ4�lr7|¡mn`IeH_do3`�epY)SbjHk�Q�Y^]IY[e�a�`%k[k^jHZiSqa4QHYNUHSiY^jH\H`�_dRT�,Y[_TRdQH`%`-\�x�Rd_T_�g�YjHeH\pY^�XeHY^\.��aiQHY�_d`�f,�}_dRT�,Y[_TRdQH`%`-\�RTS�eHY[f�W>a4Rd]IY�Rdep�XeHR{a}o�m�`�Z:W,_T_Q���&wpW,eH\"a4QpY�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRT`�eFUHZb`-k^Y[\HjpZiY�x�Rd_T_gHZbYuWI�*\p`#x�e<r � jHZnY&vpWIcVUp_TY[Syg�Y[_d`#x RT_d_TjHS�a4ZiW,a4YEa4QXW,anaiQHRTSnRdSn_TRd�IY[_{o)ai`�QXWIUHU�Y[e.Y^]IY[e~Rde!ZiY[_TW,a4R{]�Y^_doSiRdcVUp_TYtcq`-\pY[_TS^r

©)`']%RTeHfya4`na4QpY=��UHSiY^jH\H`EcVRdeHRTc�jpc Z � �y`�g%�bY^k^aiRd]�Y�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�eFRTeN� = gJ��RdauwI_TRT�,Y2a4QHY�_d`�f,�}_dRT�,Y[_TRdQH`%`-\�wRTS�WI_TSb`6_TRd�IY^_do�a4`"QXWu]�Y�UHZb`�gH_TY^cVS�x�RdaiQ*eH`�eH_dRTeHY[WIZiR{a4RdY[S�RTe*R{a4S�`�g%�bY[kla4R{]�Y@m�jHepk^a4Rd`�e�rtPO`�SiY^Y�a4QHRdS[w1_TY^a� RTep\HYlv)Sba4W,a4Y^S[w �. 0� �,��� .10%� ��/� � �,���b��RTep\HYlvNY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[\)Y[e�a4Z�o�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S^wXWIeH\*ep`Ia4Yya4QXW>a�a4QpY�XZbSba�`�Zi\HY^Z�k^`�eH\HR{a4Rd`�e�m�`�Z�a4QHYEY[e�a4Z�o�UXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^ZiS�RTe�a4QHYya4QpY�UHSbY[jH\p`6cVRdeHRTc@jHc ZC��Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZ�RTS�Wx�Y[RTfIQ�aiY[\)Wu]�Y[ZiWIf�YE`Im

� �� ? � � ��J �. 0� �,��� ��� �. 0� �,���� � <

� �� ? � � ��J . 0� �W�I� � � �. 0� �,���� � ) � . 0� �W����J � �. 0� �,��� � � �.10� �W���

� � ) � � �. 0� �,����J �. 0� �W�I� � � �. 0� �W�I�� � �

x�QHY^ZiY/� RTe�a4Y^f�Z4W,aiY[S�`']�Y^Z�SiWIcqUH_TRdeHf@],WIZiRTWIeHk^Yt`ImOa4QHYyY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�`ImOa4QpYnY[e�a4Z�oNWIeH\�Ylv-Rda�],WI_djHY[S^r��2a� � �uw�a4QpYVa4ZbjHY"],WI_djHY"`ImK�%wBa4QpY6Ylv-U�Y[k^a4W,a4Rd`�e�`Im�aiQHYV�HZiSba@a4Y[Zbc Rde�aiQHY6_�W,Sba�Y^��jXW,a4Rd`�e�RdS��^Y[Zi`pr�`'x�Y^]IY[Z2SbRTeHk^Y �. 0 �43 ��RdS�W�eH`�ep_TRTepYuWIZ�m�jHepk^a4Rd`�eq`Im�a4QpY��XZbSba�Sba4WIf�Y�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Rd`�eFY[ZbZi`�Z^w-W,eH\ �. 0 �43 ��W,eH\���� �� ���� WIZbYFk[`�eHS�a4ZbjHk^aiY[\�m�Zi`Ic a4QHYqS4W,cVYqY[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[Sy`Im �� � �WIeH\�QHY[eHk^Y6WIZbYFk[`�ZbZiY[_TW,a4Y^\J�lwOg�`Ia4Q.`Im

¨ �

Page 26: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

a4QpY@_�W,Sba�a}x:`Va4Y[ZbcVS�QXWu]�Y�WVeH`�ep�[Y[Zb`6Ylv-U�Y[kla�W,aiRT`�e�r���StWqZiY[SbjH_da�Wq],WI_djHYE`Im!� � �nSbQH`�jH_d\�eH`Ia�g�YYlv-U�Y[kla4Y[\Na4`qUHZi`%\HjHk^YEWFcqRTepRTc�jHc ai`qaiQHYn�XZiS�a�`IZi\HY^Z�k[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eHSE�W,a�_TY[WISba�Rde��HeHRdaiYESiWIcqUH_TY^S��lr

P�QHY�mWIkla"aiQXW,a6`IjHZq�HZiSba6Sba�W,f�Y�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[SV`ImnY^e�aiZboh],WI_TjHY^S"k^`�e�a�WIRde�Y[ZbZi`�ZbS"RTcqUH_dRTY[S�aiQXW,a6WIeWIeXW,_T`�f�jpYEai`Va4QpY@gHRTWIS�k[WIjHSbY[\�g�o)aiQHY��HZiSba�`Im�aiQHY@_TWISba�a}x:`6aiY[ZbcVS�x�RT_d_Og�Y@UpZiY[SbY[e�anRde*WI_d_OcqY^aiQH`%\`Im:cV`�cqY[e�aiSnY[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiSygXWISbY[\~`Ie.aiQHYF\HRd�1Y[ZbY[eHk^YVg�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e�a4QHYF`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\�WIeH\~`IjHZyY[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^Sn`Ima4QpYnY[e�a4Z�o6Z4W>a4Y[S^r��`'x�Y^]�Y^Z�aiQHYtgHRTWIS2k[WIjHSiY^\�g�oVa4QHYn_TWISba�a4Y^Zic RdS�W�ZiY^SijH_{a�`Im�aiQHYtmWIk^a:a4QXW,a2UHSiY^jH\H`cqRTeHRdc�jHc Z � RTS�jHSbRTeHfVWIe ��RTeHS�a4ZijpcVY^e�a �*��R¸r�YIr � � �� � � �� � �2x�QpRTk�Q�RdS�k[`�ZbZiY[_TW,a4Y^\Nx�R{a4QNa4QHYyY[ZbZi`�Z�RTe�a4QpYY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiYy`ImBaiQHY@UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a}o�r�P�Q�jHStRdmOx�Y@ZiY^UH_�W,k[Y[\ � ���� � � �� � RTe�a4QHYya4`IU�Y[��jXW>a4RT`Ie)x�RdaiQ�W,e�oN��eH`'x�em�jHeHkla4Rd`�e)`,m�aiQHY�`IgHSiY^Zb]�Y^\*Sba4W,a4Yn],WIZbR�WIgH_dY[S^wpa4QHYE_�W,Sba�a4Y^Zic x�`�jH_d\)QHW']IY@Y&vpU�Y[kla�W,aiRT`�eN�[Y^Zi`Fm�`�Z�WI_T_-�WIeH\ � r � `�epSiY[��jHY^e�a4_do)Rda�x�`�jH_d\�Wu]�Y^Z4WIfIY�`�j-atWIk^Zi`�SbS�S�a�W,aiY[S�WIeH\Na4Y[ep\�eH`Ia�ai`VUHZb`-\pjHk[Y�WqUpZi`�gH_dY[cRTe)`�jHZ�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS � � r�P�QHY�SbRTcqUH_TY^Z�cqY^aiQH`%\�`Im�cq`�cqY[e�a ��S�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�Z�RTe�� = ku��RTS�W"SiU�Y[k^R�WI_OkuW,SiY�Rdex�QHRdk�Q6a4QHY,��RTeHS�a4ZijpcVY^e�a �@g�Y[k^`�cVY^S �b`�epY �@m�`�Z:WI_T_J`�gpSiY[Z�],W,a4Rd`�eHS[wpWIeH\�QHY^eHk[YnR{a:QHWIS2`�eHY�_TY^SiS �bgpR�WIS �a4Y^Zic aiQHY[e�a4QpYEUpSiY[jp\H`"cqRTeHRdc�jHc Z � Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z:RTe�� = gX�lr� ��� 43/ 4 :!1 � �� � / � ��(/ :!1 % / :!+ 4 � 4�� +�� :�� /�4 ' ;P�QHY�Y[cqUHRTZbRTkuW,_�a4Z4W,eHSiR{a4RT`IeEcVW,aiZiRTk^Y[S�WIZiY�k[`IcVUHj-a4Y[\@WISB\pY[Sik^ZiRdg1Y^\�WIg�`#]IYIr ��Y�`�gpa�W,RTeya4QHY�Sba4ZbjHk^aijHZ4W,_a4ZiWIeHSbRda4Rd`�eNc"W,aiZiR vNWIS�m�`I_T_T`'x�S^r�sBRTZbSba�k[`�cqUHjpaiY@cVW>v-RTc�jHc _TRT�,Y[_dRTQH`%`-\�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`Im�aiQHY�aiQHY@Y^e�a4ZboWIeH\�Ylv-RdaOUHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S1m�`IZOY[WIk�Q�S�a�W,aiYIrB|}eya4QpY�SbRTcqUH_TY�k[WISiY�`ImXW��pv-Y[\@e%jpc�g1Y^Z�`,mHU�`Ia4Y^e�aiR�WI_�Y^e�a4Z4W,e�aiSa4QpY[SiY�WIZbYnf�Rd]IY[eNg�o�aiQHYEWu]�Y[ZiWIf�Ynm�Z4W,k^a4Rd`�e�Y[e�a4Y^ZiRdeHfqWIeH\NYlv-RdaiRTeHfFW,a�aiQXW,a�Sba4W,a4Yy`�Z�g�o

�� A �,������� � ���� � � @ C � %6� ���� � � @ C � � W,eH\ �� ? ��������� � ���� � � @ C � 5�

� ���� � � @ C � % \P�QHY^e�jHSbYyaiQHYna4QHYygHRdeH`�cqR�WI_Jm�`�Zbc�jH_�W

�8O��%!S �����Y�XZe = � � A �R%*���;J = S �������!< � � ���A � �� A �,������� A � = J �� A ��������� � � ��� � A �WIeH\

�8O�,5YS ������� � ? �,5&� % S �������=<�� ? � �� ? ��������� ? � = J �� ? �,������� � � ? �a4`If�Y^aiQHY[Znx�RdaiQ�a4QHYV©�WIZb�I`']!UHZb`-k^Y[SiSEf�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4RdeHf �pwOai`�k[`�cqUHjpaiYFaiQHYFUHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRdaiRTY^S�`Imt�,� M � J% )#5&��� M �yf�R{]�Y^e7�,�������nm�Zi`�c aiQHY"U�`�RTe�a�`Im2]%RTYlx `Im�W,e~RTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�a[rN��eXWI_d`�f�`�jHSEYlv-UHZbY[SbSiRT`IeHS�WIZbYjHSbY[\)ai`Fk[`�cqUHjpaiYyaiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�e�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�m�Zi`�c a4QHYyU�`�RTe�a�`ImO]%RTYlx `ImBWqU�`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y[e�aiZ4WIe�aur

|}e��XeHR{a4Y:SiWIcqUH_TY^SBjHSbY2`ImHaiQHY2SbaiZijHkla4jHZiWI_-aiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�e�c"W>a4ZiR vyRTS�_TRd�IY[_{ona4`tfIY[eHY^Z4W,aiY:a}x:`nUpZi`�gH_dY[cqS[rsBRdZiSba�aiQHY�aiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�epS�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^\qm�Zb`�c a4QHY�gHRdeH`�cqR�WI_pm�`IZic�jH_TWtx�RT_T_-a�WI�,Y�jHS�a4`ESba�W>a4Y[S�eH`Ia�`�gHSbY[Zb]IY[\× � ùOÛ|Ù]Ý�ä�û3þ|ïÆÙ²ÞÚ�Û|Ù²äÜÙÆêóã�÷3Ù²äÜè�ã�êëïÆêóñóÝ�ä�Ú�áTÚÜÛ|ÙÎÝ�äÜû�þ|ïÆÙÍÞ3Ú�Ý�û3Ý�êóÞtãyÚ�þtãyêóÞ|û"Þ|á3Þ'º ñëêóÞ|ÙÍÝ�ä�ñëÙmÝ�ãyÚ`ã ·þtÝ�ä�Ùmã>Ú�á"ÙÍãyÚ�êóï_Ý«ÚÜÙäÜÙ²û�äÜÙÍãÜã�êëá3Þ�ü±þ|ÞtøGÚ�êóá�ÞtãX±fÛtÙ²Þ<Ú�Û|ÙfäÜÙ²û3ä�Ùmã�ã�êëá3Þ�ü±þ|ÞtøGÚ�êóá�ÞÆêëÚÜã�Ù²ñëüÂêòã@ã�êëï<þ|ñóÝ�Ú�Ùmì�±fêëÚ�Û_Ý �tÞ|êëÚ�ÙfÞ�þ|ï<ð�ÙÍä[á�üÂã�êóï`þ|ñòÝ«ÚÜêëá3ÞgìräÈÝ4±Mã/.ã�Ù²Ù�é2Ý�ôÂá3Þ3ÚmåPW*ã�ãÜÝ�äÈì]Ý�Þtì��[þ|á�Þtûtå ������ �

¨��

Page 27: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

RTe�a4QpY�\XW>a�Wpr2PO`"k^`�cqUHjpa4Yya4QpYE�XZbSba�Sba�W,f�Y�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`,m=��.V�43 ��W,eH\ ���"�43 �2x�Y�x�Rd_T_�aiQHY[e)QXWu]�Y�ai`RTcqUHjpaiYta4QHYyY^e�aiZboNWIep\)Y&vpR{a�Z4W,aiY[S�m�Zi`�c a4QH`�SbYySba�W>a4Y[S@�SbRTeHk^Ynx:YE\H`qeH`Ia�`�gHSbY[Zb]IYEaiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�epS2m�Zi`�ca4QpY[SiYyS�a�W,aiY[S��&wJWIeH\�a4QpYnRTcqUHjpa�W>a4RT`Ie6Y[ZbZi`�ZbS2x�RT_T_1W,�1Y[kla�`�jHZ�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS � � r�«-Y^k[`�eH\<wHa4`Ff�`�m�Zi`Ic a4QpYgHRdeH`�cqR�WI_�UHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S�a4`)aiQHYqUHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S�eHY[Y^\HY[\~m�`IZyaiQHYFa4Z4W,eHSiR{a4RT`IeHSnm�Zi`�c �3a4` � M ZiY^�%jpRTZiY^Sa4QpY"k[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�e.`Im�WNk[`�e�]�`I_TjpaiRT`�e�`Im�UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a}o*\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`IeHS[w�WIeH\~aiQHY[e�a4QHYVRTe�]�Y^ZiSiRd`�e~`,m�W_�W,Zif�Y^Z�©�WIZi�,`']Fc"W,aiZiR v���`�Z�RTe�a4Y^f�Z4W,aiRT`�e�`']IY[Z�WE_TWIZif�Y^Z�e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im<m�j-a4jHZbY�S�a�W,aiY[S�RdmJx�Y�jHSbY�aiQHY��pv-Y[\U�`�RTe�a�RTe D gJ�&r:P�QHRdS�RdeHk[ZbYuWISbY[S�a4QHYEk[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�eXW,_�gHjHZb\HY[e)`ImBaiQHY�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z^wXWIeH\Na4QHYERTepk[ZiY[WISiYyRdS_TRd�IY^_doqa4`qg1Yn_TWIZif�Y^Z2a4QHYy_TWIZif�Y^Z:a4QpYEe�jHc@g1Y^Z�`,mBS�a�W,aiYy],WIZbR�WIgp_TY[S�Rde6a4QHYycq`-\pY[_¸r

� 4 � �.+ � '�- � :M��� 13'�� :�� & � ;��>' � ' - � 4��5'�-��;� 4?+ � � � / ���.V�43 � :�+ - ��/�"�43 � ;P�QHY�S4WIcqUH_TYEUXW,aiQ�k[WI_Tk^jH_�W,aiRT`�e�RdS�Y&vpUp_�WIRdeHY[\�WIg1`']IYIr�P�QHY�eHY^Sba4Y^\*�pv-Y[\*U�`�Rde�a�WI_df�`�ZiR{a4QHc �XeH\HS�RdaiSY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�`Im�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�],WI_djHY[S�g�o�k[`IcVUHj-a4RTepf�a4QHYyk[`Ie�aiZ4WIkla4Rd`�e�c"WIUpUHRTeHf

��6�,�����p¢P�*����� "�$ % � ���,�����p¢��I� ) � ���X���,�����p¢���� ) � ���."�������p¢���� x�QHY^ZiY

��/.V�,�����p¢��I� < >?4@ AB@ C DF ��"�,�H)I5cJ %*��� M �P�<�R8O� $6�!SU��� �8C�,5&�X%!S �����Y��Ze = ��8O�,� M S ��� �

WIeH\ �8O�:3 �:ZiYlm�Y[ZbS�ai`FY[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^\�UHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S^r�2a�_dYuWIS�a�Rde)k[WISiY^S�x�QHY^ZiYEa4QHYEc"W>a4ZiR v�RTe�]IY[ZiSbRT`�eNm�`�Zic@jH_�W�RTe~� � ��RdS�Wu],WIRd_�WIgH_dYIw%a4QHYEeHY[S�a4Y^\*�pv-Y[\

U�`�RTe�a�kuWI_dk[jH_TW,a4Rd`�eqx�Rd_T_JRTepk[ZiY[WISiY�a4QHYtk^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_JgHjHZb\HY[e�`Im�aiQHY�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z^r �$QHY^e6x:YtjpSiYta4QpYcVW,a4ZbR{v�Rde�]IY[ZbSiRT`Ie)a4QpY@RTe�]IY[ZiSbRT`�e)RdaiSiY[_{m�RdS�`IeH_do�\H`IeHY@`�epk[YIr �$QHY^e�x�Y@jHSbY�a4QpY@eHY^Sba4Y^\��pv-Y[\�U�`�Rde�aa4QpYt�pv-Y[\NU1`�Rde�a�kuWI_dk[jH_TW,a4Rd`�e"epY[Y[\pS�ai`�g1Yn\H`IeHYnY^]IY[Zbo�aiRTcqY�x�YyY^],WI_TjHW,a4YnW�\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a�]�Y[kla4`�Z�`ImOa4QpYUXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^ZiS�\HYla4Y[ZbcVRdeHRTepf�SiY^_T_�`I�*],WI_djHY[S�`�Z�UpZi`I�HaiS�RTe�a4QHYySbYuWIZbk�Q*WI_df�`�ZiR{a4QHc � r

P�QHY"Y&v%a4Z4W)k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_�gpjHZi\HY^e�`Im�a4QHYF�pv-Y[\ U�`�RTe�aEf�Zb`#x�SEYlv-U�`�eHY^e�aiR�WI_d_do�Rde.aiQHY"e�jHc@g1Y^Z`Im:Sba�W>a4YF]IW,ZiR�W,gH_TY^Sq�`�ZE_T`%kuW,aiRT`�epS�� � � cVWI��RTeHf�R{a�QHWIZi\HY^ZEai`)jpSiY"Rde!cV`�ZbYFk[`�cqUH_TY&v!UHZb`�gH_TY^cVS^wBW,eH\x�RT_d_<RdeHk[ZbYuWISbY�Rde�aiQHYye�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im�UHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[ZbS2a4`qg1YyY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[\�� W,S�aiQHRTS2x�Rd_T_<a}o%UHRdkuWI_d_doVZiY^�%jpRTZiYya4QpYY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRT`�e.WI_df�`�ZbRda4Qpc a4`)\H`�cq`�ZiYFm�jHeHkla4Rd`�e~Yl]IW,_TjXW,aiRT`�epSERde�R{a4SESiY[WIZik�Q UHZb`-k^Y[\HjpZiY'�&r)P�QpY6Ylv%a4ZiW× �ÍùOÛ|Ù²äÜÙÎï_Ý®è�ðÂÙ]Ý»ã�êóïgêóñòÝ�ä�ý|äÜá�ðtñëÙÍï�ü±á�ä�Ú�Û|Ù)Ù²ïÆý|êóä�êòø²Ý�ñ[Ú�äÈÝ�Þtã�êëÚ�êóá�Þ�ï_Ý«Ú�äÜê ²að|þrÚgê Ú<êóã`ï`þtøÈÛÀñóÙÍãÜã�ã�Ù²÷�ÙÍä�Ù �@1 ü�±�Ùü±á�ñóñóá�±�Ý`ã�êëÞ|û3ñëÙ�Ú�êóïÆÙ*ã�Ù²äÜêëÙmã@ÚÜÛ|Ù²äÜÙ�êòãpÚ�Û|Ù*êòã�ã�þ|Ù�á�ü�±fÛ|ÙGÚÜÛ|Ù²ä�ÚÜÛ|Ù>ñòÝ�ãyÚpá3ðtã�Ù²äÜ÷®Ý�Ú�êóá�Þ_êòãOÝ�ÞÎá3ðtãyÙÍä�÷«Ý�Ú�êóá�Þ�±fÛ|êòøÈÛ]ÛtÝ3ãSðÂÙ²ÙÍÞ÷�êóã�êëÚ�ÙÍì!ðÂÙGü±á3ä�Ù � 1 üjê Ú>ÛtÝ�ã�±�Ù�ÛtÝ®÷3Ù*Ùmã�ÚÜêëï_Ý�Ú�ÙÍãMá�ü@Ý�ñóñ¤äÜÙb·þ|êóä�ÙmìÎÚÜäÜÝ�ÞtãyêëÚ�êóá�Þ�ã � 1 üjÞtá�ÚC±�Ù�Þ|Ù²Ùmì!Ú�á_êóïgýtþrÚ�Ù�Ùmã�ÚÜêëï_Ý�Ú�ÙÍãMá�üÚ�ÛtÙ�ÚÜäÜÝ�ÞtãyêëÚ�êóá�Þ�ãSü±äÜá�ï ÚÜÛ|êóãOñòÝ�ãyÚ�ãyÚÜÝ�Ú�Ù � 1 üp±pÙ*ÛtÝ®÷3Ù>Ý�ý�Ý�Þ|ÙÍñÂá�ü �täÜï_ãSÚÜÛ|Ù²Þ�±pÙ*ïÆêëû3ÛÚ�ÛtÝ®÷3ÙMÚÜá<êóïÆý|þrÚ�Ù*ÚÜäÜÝ�ÞtãyêëÚ�êóá�Þ�ã@ü±á3äÚ�ÛtÙ�ñóÝ3ã�ÚMãyÚÜÝ«ÚÜÙÍãOá�üYÙmÝ�øÈÛ!ýtÝ�Þ|ÙÍñ�ïÆÙ²ï`ðÂÙ²ä �× ��1 ü�±pÙ]Ý3ã�ã�þ|ïÆÙÆÚ�ÛtÙ]ãyÙÍñëñSá�ô´÷«Ý�ñëþ|ÙÎì|êóãyÚ�äÜêëðtþrÚ�Ùmã�ê � ê � ì �]Ú�è�ýÂÙ�1-1�Ù�²�ÚÜä�ÙÍïgÙ_÷«Ý�ñëþ|Ù)Ý�ã�êóÞÀâMû�þtêëäÜä�ÙÍû3Ý�ð|êëäÜêòÝ)Ý�Þtì �"êóäÜÝtå

�������tå3ÚÜÛ|Ù�êóÞ3ÚÜÙ²û3äÜÝ�ñÂá«÷3Ù²ä '"Û�Ý�ãfÝ�ÞTÝ�Þ�Ý�ñóè3ÚÜêóø>ü±á3ä�ïL±fÛ|êóøÈÛ!ï_Ý�ß3ÙÍãOÙÍÝ3øÈÛ)øÍÝ�ñòøGþ|ñòÝ«ÚÜêëá3Þ)á�üÕÚÜÛ|Ù �#²rÙÍì)ý�á3êëÞÚMÙmÝ�ã�êëÙÍä��° �mâ�øGÚ�þtÝ�ñëñóè»Ý�ãMÚ�Û|Ùgý|äÜá�ì|þtø�Ú*á�ü@Ú�±�áÎÙ�²rýÂá�Þ|ÙÍÞÚ�êòÝ�ñòã�.�á�ÞtÙ�ü±á�ä>Ú�ÛtÙ`Þ�þ|ï`ðÂÙ²ä*á�üpý�á3êëÞÚÜã�±fÛ|êòøÈÛ»Þ|ÙÍÙÍì"ÚÜá]ðÂÙ`ÙÍ÷®Ý�ñëþ�Ý«Ú�ÙmìêóÞ)ÚÜÛ|Ù �#²rÙÍì)ýÂá�êóÞ3Ú�øÍÝ�ñòøGþ|ñòÝ«ÚÜêëá3Þ¤å|Ý�Þ�ì]á3Þ|Ù�ü±á�äMø²á�ïÆý|þrÚÜêëÞ|ûgÚÜÛ|Ù�ü±þrÚ�þtä�Ù�÷«Ý�ñóþ|Ù�Ý�ÚOÙmÝ�øÈÛ!ý�á3êëÞÚ

¨��

Page 28: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

gHjHZb\HY[e�x�Rd_T_%WI_dSi`tg�Y:k^`�cVU�`�jHep\HY[\�x�QHY^e�x:Y:jHSiY�R{aBRde�k[`�c@gHRTeXW>a4RT`IeEx�R{a4Q@aiQHY:S�a4Zijpk^a4jpZ4WI_paiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�ecVW,a4ZbR{v1wHWIS�aiQHRTS2x�Rd_T_<ZbY[��jHRdZiYyjHS�a4`qkuWI_dk[jH_TW,a4Y�a4QHYn�pv-Y[\)U1`IRTe�a4S�W,a�cq`�ZbYnSba�W>a4Y[S^r

|¡m<aiQHY[ZbY�RdS�WIeqWI\p],WIe�a�WIfIY�`,m1aiQHY�eHY[S�a4Y[\q�pv-Y[\VU1`�Rde�a�Rda�RTS�aiQXW,a�aiQHY�Sba4ZbjHk^aijHZiY�Rda�UpZi`']%RT\HY^S�cqRTfIQ�a_TY[WI\)ai`6cq`�ZiYEUHZiY^k[RdSiY��HZiSbatSba�W,f�Y@Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4YE`Im�a4QpY@k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�WIeH\*Y^e�a4ZboN],WI_TjpY[S[r ��Y@YlvpWIcqRTepYa4QpRTS�U�`�SiSbRTgHRd_TRda}oVg�Y[_T`'xyr

� � ��-4 �� � � ���� �P�QHY�©)`�e�a4Y � WIZi_d`VZbY[Sijp_da4S�WIZbY@\HY^SiRTfIeHY[\Na4`"fIRd]�Yya4QpY�ZbYuWI\HY^ZtWqSiY[epSiY�`ImBg1`,a4Q)aiQHY@k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_gHjHZb\HY[e�W,eH\"a4QpYt\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�epS�W,SiSi`%k[RTW,a4Y^\"x�RdaiQ"a4QpY�],WIZiRd`�jHS�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS[r �~Y�g1Y^f�RTeqx�Rda4Q6W@SiRdeHf�_TY_T`%kuW>a4RT`Ie6YlvpWIcqUH_TYyW,eH\NaiQHY[eNcq`#]IYna4`�a}x:`V_T`%kuW,aiRT`�epS[r

P�QHZi`IjHf�QH`�j-anx:Y�m�`%k[jHSt`Ie.Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4RdeHfVaiQHY�\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�e)`Im�Y[e�a4Z�o*m�Y[Y^SyWIeH\!SiY^_T_ �}`I�!],WI_TjpY[S[wCW,Sa4QpY[SiY�WIZiY�aiQHY�UXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[ZbSqaiQXW,aqkuW,eHeH`Iaqg�Y)Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[\ m�Zb`�c¬Sba4W,a4Rdk�cV`%\HY[_dS�`ImtcVWIZb�IY^aiS[r ]�`IaiYa4QHW,a2a4QpRTS�k�QH`�Rdk[YncqRTeHRdcVRd�[Y^S�aiQHYnRTeHk^ZiY[WISiYnRde�k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_�gHjHZb\HY[eNRTe6cq`']%RTeHf�m�Zb`�c aiQHYncVW,a4ZbR{vRTe�]IY[ZiSbRT`�eqa4`Ea4QHY��pv-Y[\�U�`�RTe�a���m�Zb`�c D Wna4` D g6WIg�`']�Yu�lwHW,S�x�Y[ZbY�x�YtWI_dSi`ya4`@Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y�UXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^ZiS�`Ima4QpY�UHZb`I�Ha:m�jpeHk^aiRT`�e�w�a4QpY��pv-Y[\�U�`�Rde�a�x�`�jH_d\6QXWu]�Y�ai`@g�Y�Yl]IW,_TjXW,aiY[\6cVWIe�oFcq`�ZiY�a4RdcVY^S�aiQXWIe6R{a�x�Rd_T_g�YEYl],WI_TjXW>a4YnRTe�aiQHYyZiY[SbjH_daiS�UHZiY^SiY[e�aiY[\�g�Y[_d`'x ��x�QpRT_TY�a4QHYycVW,a4ZbR{v�Rde�]�Y[ZbSiRd`�e�`�eH_do"`-k^k[jHZbS�`IeHk[Yu�lr

|}e�g�`IaiQ�YlvpWIcqUH_TY^Stx:YqQXWu]�YF\H`�epYFWI_T_�kuWI_dk[jH_TW,a4Rd`�eHS�m�`IZnSiR{v*S4WIcqUH_dY�\HY[SbRTf�epS[wOWI_T_�`Im�x�QHRTk�Q�WIZbYUXWIepY[_TS^r ��Y6k[`�epSiRT\pY[Z�],WIZ�o%RTeHf�aiQHY"aiRTcqYV\HRdcVY^eHSiRd`�e7�9�bP ���yg1Yla}x:Y^Y[e3PK � WIeH\ PK =#� w�WIeH\�a4QpYe�jHc�g�Y[Z�`ImOcVWIZi�,Y^aiS�`�Z:a4QpYnk[Zi`ISiS�SiY^k^a4Rd`�eXWI_1\HRTcqY[epSiRT`Ie.�`�jHZ�� � ����g�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e � ¨��Iª w � �Iª�ª wXW,eH\� ='ª�ª�ª r�©)jpk�Q�`ImHa4QpY:YuW,Zi_TRdY[Z�x�`�Zi�y`�e�Y[e�a4Z�o�x:WISB`Ie@ZiY^_�W,aiRd]IY[_doyRdSi`�_TW,a4Y^\�cVWIZb�IY^aiS���SiY[Y:£:ZiY^SieXW,QXWIeWIeH\3¤�Y[RdSiS^w ='��¦�§ w�WIeH\3©)WI�[�^Y[`Hw ¨Iª�ª�¨ �lr)P�QHY�e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im�ZbY[_TW,a4R{]�Y[_{o!RTSb`�_�W,aiY[\�c"WIZb�IYla4S�Rde3«-`�jpaiQ�nWI�,`Ia�WtRdS ¨��Iª w,x�QHRTk�QqYlv-UH_TWIRTeHSB`�jHZ�Sbc"WI_d_TY^Sba�SiWIcqUH_TY2SbRT�^YIw�WIeH\�aiQHY�SijHUpU1`�Z�a�`Im�`�jHZ �t],WIZiRTWIgH_dY�x:WISk�QH`�SbY[eNa4`Ff�Rd]IYyjHS�a4QHYEWIUHUpZi`uv-RTcVW,a4YnZiWIeHf�Yn`Im�U�`�UHjH_TW,a4Rd`�e�SiRd�[Y[S�Rde�aiQHY�«-`�jpaiQ��nW,�I`Ia4WFcVWIZb�IY^aiS[r

�~Y)ZiY^U1`�Z�a6W!SiY^_TY^k^a4Rd`�e¥`,m�a4QpY�ZiY^SijH_{a4SFa4QXW>a"SbY[Y[c Sbj � k[RTY^e�a6a4`.k[`�e�]IY^oha4QHY)UHZi`�gp_TY[cqS�a4QXW>akuW,e WIZiRdSiYqRTe.jHSiRdeHf�aiQHY[SbYVa4Y^k�QHeHRd�%jpY[S[r)P�QHY6ZbY[U�`�ZbaiY[\~S�a�WIep\XWIZi\~Y[ZiZb`�ZiS@WIZiYVk[`�cqUHjpaiY[\.m�Zi`�c®a4QpY\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`Ie�`ImBY^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS2`']�Y^Z�RdeH\HY[U�Y[ep\HY[e�at©)`�e�a4Y � WIZb_T`F\XW,a4WFSbY^aiS[r

� ��� � RTF d)EÍb��<HGF �$ZÎQfJ*XjE²Z<b ��� J ��� HGF �� jHZ�SiRdeHf�_dY�_T`%kuW>a4RT`Ie6YlvpWIcqUH_TY�jHSiY^S�W � `IjHZieH`,a�cV`%\HY[_�x�RdaiQ�_TRTepYuWIZ�\HY[cVWIeH\�a4`�\pY^a4Y^ZicqRTeHYn`Ijpa4UHj-aWIeH\NUHZb`I�Ha4S�k[`IeH\HRdaiRT`�eHWI_<`�e~�,�������&r � QXWIepf�Y[S�RTe �VSbQHRdm�a�aiQHYy\HY[cVWIeH\Nk[jHZ�]�Y�`#]IY[Z�a4RdcVY,¢pa4QHYlo�UH_�Wuoa4QpYnZi`�_dYn`ImOU1`�UpjH_�W,aiRT`�e"SiRT�^YnRTeN£:ZbY[SieHWIQXWIeNWIeH\)¤�Y[RTSbSE� ='�I¦�§ �lrB��UHUHZb`�UHZbR�W,aiYnk�QH`�RTk^Yn`ImOUXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^Z],WI_TjpY[S�f�R{]�Y[S�jHS�a4QpYym�`I_T_T`'x�RdeHf�SiRdeHf�_dYtU1Y^ZiRd`-\�UHZb`I�Ha�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�e

���,������� ¨ ���� = ) ��� � �

¨�§

Page 29: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

WIeH\�x�Y�W,SiSijpcVYna4QHW,a �/ ��� � � �@��RTS2a4QpYESbY[k^`�eH\�`IZi\HY^Z�©�WIZi�,`']�UHZi`%k[Y^SiS���� � ��6) � �� �

x�QHY^ZiY � w,aiQHY2f�Zb`'x�a4Q�ZiW,a4Y,w�RTSBW��XZiS�a�`�Zb\HY[Z�©�WIZi�,`']@UHZb`-k^Y[SbS���a4QpRTSOf�Y[eHY^Z4W,aiY[S�U�Y[ZbSiRTS�a4Y^eHk[Y2Rde�f�Zb`#x�aiQZ4W>a4Y[S^w�W6UHQHY^eH`�cqY[eXW"a}o%UHRdkuWI_d_do�`�gpSiY[Z�]�Y^\.m�`�Z�a4QHY@U1`�UpjH_�W,aiRT`�epS�`Im�Sbc"WI_d_�a4`'x�eHS��&ryP�Q%jpSta4QHY�S�a�W,aiY],WIZiRTWIgH_dY[S:m�`�Z2aiQHYy\po%eXWIcqRTknUHZb`�gH_dY[c WIZbYq�,��� � �����lr

�~YEWISbSijHcqYna4QXW>a�aiQHYy\HY[epSiRda}o6`Im�aiQHYy\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�e�`,mBY^e�aiZbo�m�Y^Y[S�RTS�f�R{]�Y^e)g�o

� �O� �2I� #$ � �32 J =�� $%�+5�% 8 � J $1��2 J =�� $%� � � =#§ �m�`�Z 2 3� =-� $6�27�lrOP�QHRTS�RTS�W�jHeHRdcV`%\XWI_�\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�e�x�R{a4Q�U1`�SbRdaiRd]�Y�\HY[epSiRda}o�`�eH_{oEW,a�U�`�Rde�aiS 2 7 =�� $WIeH\�W�cV`%\HYVW,a ¨�� $Xr ]�`,a4YVaiQXW,a�$!\pY^�XeHY^SFW�g�`�jHeH\XW,Zbo.`Im�a4QpY"SijpUHU1`IZba�m�`�Z���r�P�QHY"Ylv-RTS�a4Y[epk[Y`Im�a4QHRdSng1`IjHeH\XWIZ�o*RdeHSijHZbY[Sna4QHW,ana4QHY^ZiY�x�RT_d_Bg�Y�eH`NY[e�a4Z�o*x�QHY[e!a4QpY[ZiYqWIZbYFW�Sij � k[RdY[e�a�e%jpc�g1Y^Zn`ImRTepk[jHc�g�Y[e�aiS[r�P�QHYESiY[_d_{�¡`I�)],WI_djHYnRTS�\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Y^\)Y&v-U1`�epY[e�a4RTWI_T_{oVx�R{a4Q�UXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^Z �r

��e7W,k^a4jHWI_�Y[��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc `ImtaiQHY�cq`-\pY[_2m�`�ZF],WI_TjHY^SV`,m2$� \ D W,eH\ \ §�� x:WIS"k^`�cqUHjpa4Y^\jHSbRTeHf�WE]IW,ZiR�W,e�a:`Im�a4QpYtWI_df�`�ZiR{a4QHc UpZiY[SbY[e�a4Y^\�RTe���WI�IY^S�WIeH\N©)k � jHRdZiY�� ='��� � ����a4QHY�]IW,ZiR�W,e�a�SiRdcVUp_doSiQ�jpaiS�\H`'x�e a4QHY6Rde�]�Y[S�a4cqY[e�aF\HY^k[RTSbRT`�e Rde~a4QHW,a�cq`-\pY[_��&r!«%a4W,a4Y"],WIZbR�WIgp_TY ��x:WISFWI_d_T`'x�Y[\~ai`�a�WI�,Y`�e � � ],WI_TjHY^SNW,ae\ ª�� RdeHk[ZbY[cqY[e�a4SNWIeH\$x�Y�W,_T_T`'x�Y[\$a4QHZbY[Y!f�Zb`#x�aiQ ZiW,a4Y^S��4\ ª�� � ª ��J�\ ª�� � � � r P�QHYcVW>v-RTc�jHc e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`ImC�XZbcVS2m�`�Z�`IjHZ�UXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^ZiRT�[W,a4Rd`�e"x:WIS�eHRTepY^a4Y^Y[e�wJW,eH\NaiQHRTS�RdcVUp_TRTY^S�aiQXW,a�a4QpY�bk[WIZi\HRdeXWI_dRda}o��@`Im�aiQHYnSba4W,a4Y�SiUXWIk^YIwX`�Z�a4QHYne�jHc@g1Y^Z2`ImO\HRTS�a4RdeHk^an�,��� � ������]�Y^k^ai`�ZiS�U�`�SiSbRTgH_dYIw-RTS2W,g1`�j-aa}x�`Va4Qp`�jHS4W,eH\�SbY^]�Y^e*Q�jHeH\HZbY[\�r:P�QHY ��\XW,a�W �qx:WIS�`�gpa�W,RTeHY^\)g�o�jHSbRTeHfFa4QHYyk^`�cVUpjpa4Y^\�Y[��jHRd_TRdgHZiRdjHcU�`�_TRdk[RTY^S:a4`FSbRTc�jH_TW,a4Y�S4WIcqUH_TYnUHW,a4QHS^r�P�QHYyS4WIcqYy\XW,a�W�x:WIS�jHSiY^\)m�`�Z�W,_T_�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS[r

� ;3� ;3� � ' � 1 � � /-� � � &.' � 4?+(6 13' �S� : � 43� + � �5-('�1 ;P�WIgH_TY = UHZb`']-Rd\HY[SEa4QHYVZiY^SijH_{a4S[rNP�QHY"�HZiSba@UXWIeHY^_�`,m�a4QHYqa�WIgH_dYVRdS@W �bUHR{]�`Ia �)a�W,gH_TYFx�QHRTk�Q~\HY^�XepY[Sa4QpYqY^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbStRTe�aiQHY�\HRd�1Y[ZbY[e�aEk[`�_djHcqeHS[r�P�QpYF�HZiSbaEZb`#x `Im�a4QXW,ayUHWIeHY[_�SbU1Y^k[R{�XY[Sna4QpYq`Ig%�bY[kla4Rd]IYm�jHeHkla4Rd`�e.� � s��:jHSbY[\�r�|¡m���. ª x:Yt�Ha�aiQHYycVY[WIe.�`']IY[Z�WI_T_1`�gHSbY[Zb],W,aiRT`�epS��:`ImCa4QpYnY[e�a4Z�o�WIeH\�Ylv-R{aUHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^S�UpZiY[\pRTk^aiY[\.g�o*a4QHYFcq`-\pY[_Bai`�aiQHY�\XW,a4Wpw�Rdm��/. = x:YqjHSbYFaiQHYFUHSiY^jH\H`N_TRd�IY[_dRTQH`%`%\�wWIeH\)Rdm���. ¨ x�Y�cqRTepRTcqRT�[Y�a4QHYESijHc `ImBSi��jXWIZbY[St`,mBa4QpY�\HR{�<Y^ZiY^eHk[Y�g1Yla}x:Y^Y[e*a4QpY�Y^cVUHRdZiRdkuWI_�W,eH\a4QpYEY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`Im�aiQHYySba4W,a4YnSbU1Y^k[Rd�HkEY^e�a4Zbo�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�x:Y^RTf�Q�a4Y^\)g�o6aiQHYyRTe�]�Y^ZiSbY�`ImOa4QpYEe�jHc@g1Y^Z`Im1a4RTcqY[S�a4QHW,a�a4QHY�\XW,a�Wn]%RTSbRda4Y^\VaiQXW,a�Sba�W>a4YIrBP�QHYt��¤7Zi`'x$`Im1a4QHY�UHRd]I`Ia�a�WIgH_dY�RdeH\HRdkuW,aiY[S�x�QHRTk�Qq�XZiS�aSba4WIf�YtUpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�WIZbYtjHSiY^\�RTe6Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4RT`Ie�rB|¡m � � = x:YtjpSiY[\��bS�a4ZbjHk^aijHZ4WI_ �@a4ZiWIeHSbRda4Rd`�e6UHZb`�gXW>�gHRd_TRdaiRTY^Sn��x�YEY[SbaiRTcVW,a4YyY^e�aiZboNWIep\)Y&vpR{a�UHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S:WIeH\NjHSiYya4QpY[c WIeH\�a4QpY�gHRdeH`�cqR�WI_Jm�`�Zbc�jH_�W@ai`°È×�ØVÛ|Ù²Þ�2*�9 ' ��|å�2*�� × 9 ' ��E±fêëÚ�Û4ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êëñóêëÚ�è ' � ��Ý�Þtì �2*�� × 9�@±fêëÚ�Û4ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êóñëêëÚ�è ' ����4ùOÛ|Ù!Ú�äÈÝ�Þtã�êëÚ�êóá�Þý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êóñëêëÚ�êóÙÍãB±fÛ|ÙÍÞ��2* 9 T ' ��)Ý�äÜÙÆÝ�ÞtÝ�ñëá3û�á�þ�ã²å�Ý�Þ�ìE±fÛ|ÙÍÞ��2*�9 �|å��2*�� × 9 ��±fê ÚÜÛ ýtä�á3ðtÝ�ð|êóñóê Ú�è-' �!Ý�ÞtìaïÆá«÷�ÙÍã>ÚÜáÙÍÝ3øÈÛ`á�ütÚ�ÛtÙOÝ�ñ ÚÜÙ²äÜÞtÝ«ÚÜêë÷3ÙÍã-±fê ÚÜÛ<ýtä�á3ðtÝ�ð|êóñóê Ú�è ' � � �Õâ�Ú@øGá3ä�Þ|ÙÍäÜãÕá�ü�Ú�Û|ÙOýÂÙ²äÜïÆêóãÜãyêóð|ñóÙ N>÷«Ý�ñëþ|Ùmã²å®ÚÜÛ|Ùfý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êóñëêëÚ�è�á�ü�ïÆá«÷�êóÞ|ûá�þ|ÚMá�ü�B9êòãMã�ÙGÚfÚÜágöÍÙ²äÜágÝ�Þtì!ê ÚÈãfý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êóñëêëÚ�è_êóã�Ý�ì|ìrÙmìÎÚÜáÆÚ�Û|Ù�ÞtÙ�²�ÚMøGñóá3ã�ÙÍãyÚOÞ�þ|ï<ð�ÙÍä��

¨I¦

Page 30: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

k[`IcVUHj-a4Y�aiZ4WIeHSbRdaiRT`�e6UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S4�lw�x�QHY^ZiYuW,S�R{m ���# ª x�YnjHSbY[\�a4QHYnY^cVUpRTZiRdkuWI_XaiZ4WIeHSbRdaiRT`�eVUHZi`�g%�WIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^SE�`�Z �� Rde)a4QpY@eH`Ia4W,a4Rd`�e)WIg1`']IY'�lr�P�QHY��ts¥Zi`'x­RdeH\HRTk[W,a4Y^S�Qp`#xAaiQHY��HZiSba�Sba4WIf�Y@Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S`Im:�T�9."�:3 �P�P�/�"�43 �b��WIZbYnk[`�cqUHjpaiY[\�r�|¡m�� . = a4QpY[e��T�9."�:3 � ���/�6�:3 �b�:WIZiY�k[`�cqUHjpaiY[\6]%R�W�W@epY[SbaiY[\�pv-Y[\~U1`�Rde�auw�x�QHY[ZbYuWIS�Rdm ��. ª a4QpY[SiYF],WI_TjpY[S�WIZiY�m�`�jHep\~g�o.WNSbRTeHfI_TYFc"W>a4ZiR v�Rde�]IY[ZbSiRT`Ie~W,aEa4QpYg�Y[f�RdeHeHRTepf�`ImBY[WIk�Q�ZbjHe�r

�BWIepY[_<� UHZb`#]%Rd\HY[S�a4QHY�ZiY[SbjH_daiS�x�QpY[e � ='ª�ª�ª WIeH\"PK ='� r�P�QHY^SiYtZbY[Sijp_da4S:WIZiY�ZiY[WISiSbjHZiRdeHf�SbRTeHk^Ya4QpY^oERTeH\pRTkuW>a4Y�a4QXW,a[w�W,a�_TY[WISba�RTeEa4QHY�`�eHY�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eEcq`-\HY^_¸w'x�RdaiQ�W�gHRTf�Y[eH`�jpf�Q�S4W,cVUH_dY:W,_T_�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS��x�`�Zi�0�EZiY[WISi`�eHWIgH_do�x�Y[_d_O��aiQH`�jHf�QFa4QpY[ZiY�RTS�Sb`�cqY�RdeH\HRdkuW,aiRT`�e�RdeFaiQHRTS�UXW,eHY[_HaiQXW,a�UHSiY^jH\H`�c"W>v-Rdc�jHc_TRd�IY^_TRTQp`-`%\~\H`%Y[S�x�`�ZiSbY�a4QXWIe3a4QpYN`,a4QHY^Z�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�� �}� r ��WIeHY[_�£ UHZb`#]%Rd\HY[SFY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�m�Zb`�c `�jpZSicVWI_d_TY[S�a�S4W,cVUH_dYyWIeH\NW,a�a4QHW,a�S4WIcqUH_dYnSiRT�^Ynx:Yy_TY[WIZie�cq`�ZiYyW,g1`�j-a�a4QHYyY[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS9�HU�Y[Zbm�`IZicVWIeHk[Y,r

��_d_:a4QHY�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[SF`Im $~RdehUHWIeHY[_�£ SiY^Y[c¬ai`.QHW']IY*WIe3jHU�x:WIZi\LgHR�W,SFWIeH\3a4QHY�gHRTWISqWIUHU�YuWIZbS_�W,Zif�Y^Z�RdeNaiQHY � s! = �`�Z�UHSbY[jH\H`�cq_TYu�:Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS^r � eNa4QHY�`Ia4QpY[Z�QXWIeH\�aiQHY � s ª Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�`Im LWIZiY �bZbRTf�Q�ay`�e��HwOWIeH\�a4QHY � s! = Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[SyWIZbYqk^_T`�SbYIwCgHjpayaiQHY � s ¨ Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[Sn`,m hkuWIe.g�YUHZb`�gH_TY^c"W>a4RTk,r ]�`Ia4YyWI_dSi`�a4QHW,a2a4Qp`�jHf�Q�a4QHY^ZiYncVWuo6g�YyWFgpR�WIS�UHZb`�gH_dY[c Rde�Si`�cqYn`ImCa4QpYEY^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS[wY^]IY[e~W,aE`�jHZySicVWI_T_dY[S�anS4WIcqUH_dY�SiRT�^YIwCa4QHYFUXW,Z4WIcqY^aiY[ZnY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[SEWIZbYq��jHR{a4Y�UHZbY[k^RTSiY���aiQHYFYlv-k[Y^Upa4Rd`�eQHY^ZiYERTS2a4QpY � s! ¨ Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiYy`Im !x�QHRdk�Q)Sb`�cVYla4RdcVY^S�RTS�eH`Ia�x�Y[_d_OY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^\J�lr�©)`IZiY[`']IY[ZtW,S���WIeHY^_� SiQH`'x�S[w%`�eHk^Y2x:Y�RdeHk[ZbYuWISbY2a4QHY�SbRT�[Y�`,m�aiQHY�\XW,a4WnSiY^a�aiQHY�gHRTWIS�UHZb`�gH_TY^c \HRdS4WIUpU1Y[WIZiS�ZiW,a4QpY[Z�Z4W,UHRT\H_{o�r

��e3jHU�x:WIZi\hgHR�W,S�RTef$.RTcqUH_TRdY[S�W*\H`'x�e�x:WIZb\LgHRTWIS�Rde�a4QHY�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y6`Im =�� $Jr�sX`�Z@aiQHY � s! =Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�Z2`�Z�UHSbY[jH\p`"cq_TYtY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�Z:aiQHYyY[S�a4RTcVW,aiYn`Im =�� $VQXWIS�ai`qg�Yy_T`'x�Y[Z�a4QXW,eNaiQHYy_T`'x:Y^Sba�Y[S�a4R{�cVW,a4Y^\NY^e�a4Zbo�],WI_djHYEW,a�x�QHRdk�Q)Sb`�cVYyU�`Ia4Y^e�a4R�W,_�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a�Y^e�a4Y[ZbY[\�r�|}e)Sbc"W,_T_�SiWIcVUp_TY[S2aiQHYycVRdeHRTc@jHcY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[\�Y^e�a4Zbo�],WI_TjHYqx�RT_d_�aiY[eH\�ai`*g�Y6_T`'x�Y[Z@aiQXWIe�a4QpY6cVRdeHRTc@jHc a4ZbjHY6Y^e�aiZbo.],WI_TjHY,w�WIeH\~x�Rd_T_a4Y^eH\�a4`�cVWI�,Y �$�7�$Xr � eHYnkuW,e�jHSiYyW�SbY[k[`IeH\�`�Zi\HY^Z2Ylv-UXW,eHSiRd`�e�a4`�_d`-`��qW,a:a4QHYnSbc"WI_d_JS4WIcqUH_TY�gHR�W,SRTe)a4QHY �/. ª Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZ�`Im=$NWIeH\�SbQH`'x­a4QXW,atRda�\HY[U�Y[eH\pSn`�e*a4QHY@\HY[ZbRd],W,a4R{]�Y�`Im�a4QHY@\HY[eHSbRda}o)`Im$*W,anaiQHYqU1`�Rde�a4Stx�QHRdk�Q~f�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4YFY[e�aiZbo�rq|}e�WI_Tcq`�SbaEW,_T_B`,m:a4QpY[SiYq`�gHSbY[Z�]IW>a4RT`IeHSna4QHRdSn\HY[ZbRd],W,a4R{]�Y�RdSU�`�SiR{a4Rd]IYIwXW,eH\NaiQXW,a�WIk^k[`�jpe�aiS�m�`IZ2a4QHYyU�`�SiR{a4Rd]IYn\HY^]%RTW,a4Rd`�eHS�RTe�aiQH`�SiYyY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS[r]�`�cVW,aiaiY[Z�a4QHY�SiWIcVUp_TY@SbRT�^Y@a4QHY �/. ª ��`�ZtSiRdcVUp_TYEcVYla4QH`%\�`Im�cq`�cVY^e�a4S���Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�QHWI\g�`Ia4Q�SicVWI_T_dY[ZygHR�W,SiY[S ��" $�SicVWI_d_TY[Zn],WIZbR�WIeHk^Y[SEa4QHY^e~a4QH`ISiY"`,m�Y[R{a4QHY^Z�a4QpY"UHSbY[jH\H`�cq_TY)� ��. = �lw`�Z�a4QHY�UpSiY[jp\H`�cVRdeHRTc�jpc ZC�q�`�Z ��. ¨ ��Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS[rn©N`�ZiY^`#]IY[ZtaiQHRTS�x2WIStaiZijHYEm�`�ZtW,_T_OS4WIcqUH_TY\HY^SiRTfIeHS[r�sX`�Z�Rde�aijHRdaiRT`�e�`Ieqx�Q�o�a4QpRTS�`-k^k[jHZbS�k^`�cqUXWIZiY�aiQHY�Zi`'x7_�W,g1Y^_TY[\ � �,��� � �����&w�x�QpRTk�QqUHZi`']%RT\HY^S° °Íâ�ãSÞ|á�ÚÜÙÍìgê ü�±�ÙfþtãyÙMãyÚ�äÜþtøGÚ�þ|äÈÝ�ñrý|äÜá�ð�Ý�ð|êóñëêëÚ�êóÙÍãH±�Ù�±fêóñëñ|ÞtÙ²ÙÍìgÙmã�ÚÜêëï_Ý«ÚÜÙÍã[á�üÂÙÍÞÚ�äÜè`Ý�ÞtìgÙ�²�êëÚ@ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êóñëêëÚ�êóÙÍã[Ý�Ú@ý�á3êëÞÚÜãÞ|á�ÚOá3ðtã�Ù²äÜ÷�ÙÍìÎêëÞ!Ú�ÛtÙ�ìtÝ«ÚÜÝ �MUMÙ²äÜÙ�êóãOÛtá�±�±pÙ�á3ðrÚÜÝ�êëÞ)Ú�Û|ÙÍï �@â�ãÜãyþ|ïÆÙ*Ú�Û�Ý«ÚOü±á�äMÝ<û�êó÷�ÙÍÞ;N:±�Ù*á3Þ|ñóè_á�ðtã�Ù²äÜ÷�Ù>ð�ÙÍÛtÝ®÷�êëá3äü±äÜá�ï 3 J × N � L3J ° N � 6 �ÆùOÛ|ÙÍÞ = ±ê �*ê üVJ A 3 � L3J × ?N ��6[Ú�ÛtÙ_ý|ä�á3ðtÝ�ðtêëñóê Ú�è"á�üpÙÍÞ3ÚÜä�è�êóã�Ùi·3þ�Ý�ñYÚ�á!Ú�ÛtÙ_ý|ä�á3ðtÝ�ðtêëñóê Ú�è"á�üpÙÍÞ3ÚÜä�èêóÞ$ã�ÚÈÝ«Ú�Ù6J × ?N ��Ý�Þtì Ú�Û|Ù)ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êëñóêëÚ�è�á�üfÙ�²�êëÚ`êòã�öÍÙ²äÜá .[êëüVJ A 3 J ° N � L�����" 6SÚÜÛ|ÙÎÙ²ÞÚÜä�è ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êëñóêëÚ�è�êòã`ã�ÙGÚ�ÚÜá»ö²ÙÍä�á�åÝ�Þ�ì»ÚÜÛ|Ù_Ù�²rêëÚ�ý|ä�á3ðtÝ�ðtêëñóê Ú�è"êòã�ã�ÙGÚ�Ú�áTÚÜÛtÝ«Ú�Ý�Ú5J ° ?N � .jÝ�Þ�ì ¦êëêóê �*êëü�Ú�Û|ÙÍä�Ù_êòã�Ý!Û|á�ñóÙÆêëÞtã�êòìrÙÆÚ�Û|ÙÎã�ÙGÚ 3 J × N � L3J ° N � 6@Ú�ÛtÙÙ�²rêëÚ�ýtä�á3ðtÝ�ð|êóñóê Ú�èÆêòãpã�ÙGÚOÙb·þtÝ�ñ�ÚÜá�ÚÜÛ|Ù*ø²ñëáãyÙmã�Ú�á�ðtã�Ù²äÜ÷�Ùmì_Ù�²rêëÚ�ýtä�á3ðtÝ�ð|êóñóê Ú�ègð�ÙÍñëá�±.ê Úmå|Ý�ÞtìÆÚÜÛ|Ù*Ù²ÞÚ�äÜè_ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êëñóêëÚ�è<êòãOãyÙ²ÚÚ�á!ÚÜÛ|Ù_øGñóá3ã�ÙÍãyÚ*á3ðtãyÙÍä�÷3ÙÍì"ÙÍÞÚ�äÜè»ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êëñóêëÚ�èTÝ�ð�á«÷3Ù<êëÚ�� 1 ü1±�ÙÆþtã�Ù<ÙÍïgýtêëäÜêóøÍÝ�ñ[ý|äÜá�ð�Ý�ð|êóñëêëÚ�êóÙÍã�Ý�Þtìy±�Ù_ãyá3ïgÙ²Ú�êóïÆÙÍã*û�Ù²ÚÚ�á]Ú�ÙÍä�ïÆêóÞtÝ�ñYøGá�Þ�ìrê ÚÜêëá3Þtã�±fÛ|êóøÈÛaÝ�äÜÙ�Þ|á�Ú*÷êòã�ê ÚÜÙÍì"ý|äÜêóá�äMÚÜáÎÚÜÛ|Ù�ÚÜÙ²äÜïgêóÞtÝ�ñÕýÂÙ²äÜêëárì�å�Ý�Þ�ì"Û|Ù²Þ�øGÙ<ì|áÎÞ|á�Ú*ÛtÝ®÷�Ù`Ù²ïÆý|êóä�êòø²Ý�ñÙÍãyÚ�êóï_Ý«ÚÜÙÍã�á�üpÚÜäÜÝ�ÞtãyêëÚ�êóá�Þ ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êóñëêëÚ�êóÙÍã�� �|á3ä�Ú�ÛtÙÍã�ÙÆÚ�äÈÝ�Þtã�ê ÚÜêëá3Þtã�±�ÙÆÚÜÝ�ß3ÙgÚ�Û|Ù]Ý®÷3Ù²äÈÝ�û3Ù�Ú�äÈÝ�Þ�ãyêëÚ�êóá�Þ ý|äÜá�ðtÝ�ð|êëñóêëÚ�êóÙÍã�ü±á3äÚ�ÛtÙ�øGÙ²ñóñòãOÞ|ÙÍÝ�ä�Ùmã�ÚOÚ�ágÚÜÛ|Ù�Ú�ÙÍä�ïÆêóÞtÝ�ñ2ø²Ù²ñóñ�±pÙÍêëû3ÛÚ�ÙÍì)ð�èÎÚÜÛ|Ù�Þ�þ|ï`ðÂÙ²äfá�ü2Ú�êóïÆÙÍãOÚÜÛ|ÙÍã�Ù�øGÙÍñëñòã�±�Ù²äÜÙ*á3ðtã�Ù²äÜ÷�ÙÍì �

¨I�

Page 31: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

a4QpYqe�jHc@g1Y^Z�`Im�Sba4W,a4Y^S�Yl]�Y^ZE]%RTSbRdaiY[\!RTe�a4QpYVZbjHe�� � ¨ D x�QHY^e~PK � W,eH\ ��¨I� x�QHY[e�PK ='� �lw�a4`�a4QpYe�jHc�g�Y[Zy`Im:`�gHSiY^Zb],W,aiRT`�eHSq��`�Z9. � ��w =#¨I�Iª x�QHY[e�PK � WIep\ D §I�Iª x�QHY[e�PK ='� �lrFP�QXW,aERdSyx�QpY[ePK � x�Y�WIZiYyk[`IeHSbaiZijHkla4RTepfVa4QpYEZb`'x�S�`Im�a4QHYEY[cqUHRdZiRTk[WI_1aiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�e�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S:x�QpRTk�QN\HY^aiY[ZicqRTepYa4QpY6©�W,Zi�I`'].a4ZiWIeHSiR{a4Rd`�e!c"W,aiZiR v<wOWIep\�a4Q�jHSEa4QHZb`�jHf�Q.a4QHYqRTe�]IY[ZiSbYVm�`�Zbc�jH_TW�aiQHYVk^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e~W,eH\Y[e�aiZbo�],WI_djHY[S^w�x�R{a4Q a4QpZiY[Y�`IgHSiY^Zb]�Y^\LaiZ4WIeHSbRdaiRT`�eHS��`�e3Wu]�Y^Z4WIfIY'�lr~��SqW*ZiY^SijH_{aF`�eHY�cqRTf�Q�a�Y&vpU�Y[klaa4QpY@Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�`Im�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�WIeH\*Y^e�a4ZboN],WI_TjpY[S�ai`"k^`�e�a�WIRde*eH`�e�a4ZbRd]%R�W,_OSiWIcqUH_TRdeHfFY[ZiZb`�Z[w<WIeH\�W,SYlv-UH_TWIRTepY[\�RdeNaiQHY@_TWISba�SbY[k^aiRT`�eNa4QXW>a�Y^ZiZi`IZ�RdS�_dRT�IY^_do6ai`"QXWu]IY@c�jHk�Q�_�WIZbf�Y[Z�RTcqUXWIkla4S�`�eNa4QHY�UHSiY^jH\H`cVW>v-RTc�jHc _TRd�IY^_TRTQp`-`%\�WIeH\�aiQHYyUHSiY^jH\H`"cqRTepRTc�jHc ZC��Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS2a4QHWIe)`Ie�aiQHY � s! ª Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z^r

�$QXW,aERTSyS�a4ZiRd��RTeHf�RTS��bjpSba�QH`'x x:Y^_T_�aiQHY � s ª Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�Zn\H`%Y[Snx�R{a4Q!a4QHRdSEe�jHc@g1Y^ZE`,m2`�gHSbY[Z��],W,a4Rd`�eHS^r��2anPK =#� a4QHY^ZiY@RdStWIe*W']IY[ZiWIf�Y�`Im�SbR{v)`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\�aiZ4WIeHSbRdaiRT`�eHS�U�Y[Z�S�a�W,aiY�]%RTSbRdaiY[\�WIep\�a4QXW>aSiY^Y[cqS2a4`Fg�YtY[eH`IjHf�Q�a4` �beHWIRT_ ��a4QpYnUXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[ZbS[wXW,eH\�x�Rda4Q6aiQHZiY^Yta4ZiWIeHSiR{a4Rd`�eHS:U�Y[Z�S�a�W,aiYq� W,a2PK � �x�Y�\H`�ZiY[WISi`�eHWIgH_doNx�Y[_T_ r � m�k[`�jHZbSiY,w�YuWIk�Q!`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\!a4ZiWIeHSbRda4Rd`�e*Wu]IY[Z4W,f�Y[Sn`']�Y^ZyWI_T_OS4W,cVUH_dY@U�`�RTe�aiSZiY[WIk�QHY^\Lm�Zi`Ic aiQHY�Sba�W>a4Y�Rda�aiZ4WIepSiRdaiY[\ a4`pw�Sb` ��� �3`�gHSbY[Zb]IY[\ha4Z4W,eHSiR{a4RT`Ie RTS�RdcVUH_dRTk^Rda4_{o � )��A � �_^�"��`']�Y^Z�WI_d_<SiWIcVUp_TYnUXW,aiQHS�m�Zi`�c a4QHYyU�`�RTe�a�aiZ4WIeHSbRdaiY[\�a4`Hr

P�QHY@\pRd�1Y[ZiY^eHk[Y^StRTe�a4QpY�\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�eHS�f�Y[epY[Z4W>a4Y[\�g�o�aiQHY@W,_da4Y^ZieXW>a4Rd]IY��/. ª Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�WIZbYSicVWI_d_¸r �`'x�Y^]�Y^Z�a4QHY^ZiY�WIZbY � ��A����\pRd�1Y[ZiY^eHk[Y^S�RTe�a4QHY^RTZEk[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_�gHjHZb\HY[epS[r �$QHY^e3x�Y6jHSbYSbaiZijHkla4jHZiWI_�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S�� ��¤ = ��x:YnQHW']IYna4`�k[`IcVUHj-a4YtY^Rda4QpY[Z�W�cVW,a4ZbR{vqRde�]IY[ZbSiYy`�Z�W��-vpY^\)U�`�Rde�ax�RdaiQ�m�`�jHZ�a4`ESiR v�aiRTcqY[S�a4QpY�e�jHc@g1Y^Z�`,m<S�a�W,aiY[S��k^`�cVUHWIZiY2aiQHY � ����� � �����BZi`'xyw�x�QHRTk�QVRTS�a4QpY�e�jHc@g1Y^Z`Im<Sba�W>a4Y[S�x�QHY^e���¤ ª w%WIeH\qa4QHY � �8"Zb`'xyw%x�QHRdk�Q"RdS�aiQHY�e%jpc�g1Y^Z�x�QpY[e���¤ = �lrB|}eqa4QHY�kuW,SiY�`,m<a4QpYcVW,a4ZbR{v)RTe�]�Y^ZiSbYN�R¸r�YIr�� . ª ��a4QpRTStk[WIjHSiY^SyWIe�RTepk[ZiY[WISiY�Rde*k[`IcVUHj-a4Y�a4RdcVYE`Im�mWIkla4`�ZbStg1Yla}x:Y^Y[e �

WIeH\ § wpW,eH\"`�epk[Y�x�Ytf�`Ea4`Ea4QHY�eHY[S�a4Y[\6�-vpY^\6U�`�RTe�a�kuWI_dk[jH_TW,a4Rd`�e�a4QHY�k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_XgHjpZi\HY^e6`Im�a4QpYSbaiZijHkla4jHZiWI_�UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRdaiRTY^S�RdeHk[ZbYuWISbY[Sym�jHZbaiQHY[Z^wOai`Ng�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e � WIeH\ ='ª a4RdcVY^Sta4QHYFk[`IcVUHj-a4Y�a4RdcVY@m�`IZa4QpYEY^cVUpRTZiRdkuWI_<UHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S � �^r�P�QHYE`�eHYEU�`�SiR{a4Rd]IYnSijHZbUHZiRdSiYERTe�a4QpYEY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�m�Zb`�c aiQHYySba4ZbjHk^aijHZ4W,_UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^SBRdS�a4QHY�mWIkla�a4QXW,a�aiQHY�RTcqUHjpa�W>a4RT`Ie�`Im1Y[e�a4Z�oFWIeH\qYlv-Rda�ZiW,a4Y^S�W,a�a4QHY�U�`�RTe�a4S�ep`Ia�WIk^aijXWI_d_do]%RTSbRda4Y^\�\H`%Y[S�eH`Ia�SiY[Y^c ai`"k[WIjHSiY�WVeH`IaiRTk^YuWIgH_dY�gpR�WIS�RTeNa4QHY�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S[r�P�QHRdS�RTS�a4ZbjHY@Yl]�Y^e*a4QH`�jpf�Qa4QpY�RTcqUHjpa4Y^\*Sba4W,a4Y^SyWIZiY�x:Y^_T_�`']�Y^ZnY[Rdf�Q�a}o*U�Y[Zik^Y[e�ay`Im�a4QpY�a4`Ia4WI_�e�jHc@g1Y^Zn`Im�Sba�W>a4Y[S�ryP�QHY�epY[SbaiY[\�pv-Y[\�U�`�Rde�a�a4RdcVY^S:WIZbYtWI_{x2Wuo%S2_TWIZif�Y^Z�aiQXWIe6aiQHY�cVW,a4ZbR{vqRde�]IY[ZbSiYta4RdcVY^S[w%gHjpa�a4QHYt\pRd�1Y[ZiY^eHk[Y�RTS�c�jHk�Qcq`�ZiYneH`,a4RTk^YuWIgp_TYtx�QHY^eNx�Y�jpSiYySbaiZijHkla4jHZiWI_CUHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S^r

P�QHYV©)`�e�a4Y � W,Zi_T`�ZbY[SbjH_daiStm�Zi`�c a4QHY�cq`%\HY[_Ox�Rda4Q!`�epY�Y[e�a4Z�o*_T`%kuW>a4RT`Ie�WIZiY@UHZiYlaia}o�k^_TYuW,Z[rEP�QHYcqY^a4Qp`-\n`Im-cq`�cVY^e�a4S�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS<a4QXW>a��Ha�a4QHY�Wu]IY[Z4W,f�Y�Y[e�a4Z�oyWIeH\yYlv-R{aCZ4W,aiY[S�m�Zi`Ic a4QpY�]IW,ZiRT`IjHS�Sba4W,a4Y^S��aiQHY ��. ª Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS��:QHW']IYyg1`IaiQ)g�Y^aba4Y^Z�\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�eHS�W,eH\�RTcqU1`�SbYn_TY^SiS�`ImBWqk^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_gHjHZb\HY[e<r)P�QHY^ZiY6RdS�ep`Ia@c@jHk�Q�\HR{�<Y^ZiY[epk[Y"Rde�aiQHYV\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�eHSy`Im2aiQHY �/. ª Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS^wBW,eH\SiRdeHk[YEa4QHYEk[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�eXW,_�gHjHZi\pY[e*`ImBa4QHY ��� = Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZ�RdS�Si`6c�jpk�Q*_�WIZbf�Y[Z^wHa4QHY^ZiY�RTS�Wqk^_TYuW,ZUHZbY^m�Y[ZbY[eHk^Ynm�`�Z2Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS�a4QXW>a�SiYla ��. �/. ª Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z[r�P�QpY[ZiYnRdS:]�Y^Zbo"_TRdaba4_dY�\HR{�<Y^ZiY^eHk[YnRdeY[R{a4QHY^ZCU1Y^Zbm�`�Zbc"WIepk[Y�`�ZCRTeEk[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_IgHjHZi\pY[e@g�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e�a4QHY�SbRTcqUH_TY^SbaOY[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z[w'a4QpY�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Zx�RdaiQ �/. � � � . ª w�WIeH\�aiQHY"Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Ztx�QpRTk�Q~jpSiY[S���. � � ª gHj-a�aiQHYVepY[SbaiY[\°��ÍùOÛ|ÙÍã�Ù�äÈÝ«Ú�êóá3ãOÝ�ä�Ù�ï`þ�øÈÛ�±�á�äÈãyÙ>ü±á�äOÚÜÛ|Ù W � 9 ��Ý�Þtì]Ú�Û|Ù W � 9 �<ÙÍãyÚ�êóï_Ý«ÚÜá�äÈã ¦þ|ý!Ú�áÎÝ<ü¦Ý�øGÚ�á3äfá�ü � ��� �

D ª

Page 32: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

�pv-Y[\)U1`IRTe�a2m�`�Z�k[WI_Tk^jH_�W,aiRTeHf�],WI_djHY[SE�W��. = �lr��S�ep`Ia4Y^\�w�x:Y^ZiY6x�Y�\H`�RdeHf*W*cq`�ZiYqk[`IcVUH_dYlv~UHZi`IgH_TY^c `IZ@Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRTeHfNcq`�ZiYVUXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[ZbS[w�x�Y

x�`�jH_T\$SbY[Y.cV`�ZbY�`Im@W3k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_�UpZiY^m�Y^ZiY^eHk[Y!m�`�Z6a4QpY �/. � � ��. ª `']�Y[Z�a4QpY��. � � ª gHjpa2��. = Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZ[r � e!aiQHY�`IaiQHY[ZtQHWIeH\�w�aiQHY[ZbY�\H`-Y^SnSiY^Y[c ai`�g1YFW6Sb_TRTfIQ�aRTcqUHZb`#]IY[cqY[e�a�Rde�aiQHY:S�a�W,aiRTSbaiRTk[WI_�U1Y^Zbm�`�Zbc"WIepk[Y�`ImXa4QHY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZOx�R{a4Q���. = `#]IY[Z �/. ª Rde@a4QpYSicVWI_d_TY[S�aOS4WIcqUH_TY��UHWIeHY[_p£��lw,WIeH\�a4QHRdS�QHY^_T\�jpU�RTeEa4QHY�_TRTcqRdaiY[\ye�jHc�g�Y[Z�`ImJZijHepS�x�Y2\HRT\Ex�RdaiQ�SicVWI_T_dY[ZS4W,cVUH_dY@SbRT�[Y^Sta4QHY^e�a4QH`�SbY�UHZbY[SiY^e�a4Y[\�QHY[ZbYIr�«-`�R{atRTS�UHZi`�gHWIgH_doNa4QpY�kuWISbY�a4QXW>ata4QHY@k�QH`�RTk^Y�g1Yla}x:Y^Y[ea4QpY ��. ��� ��. ª W,eH\*a4QHY �/. ��� ª gHj-a��/. = Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiSt\HY^U1Y^eH\HSy`�e�a4QpYk�QXWIZiWIk^aiY[ZbRTSbaiRTk^SE`,m:a4QpYVUHZb`�gH_dY[c®WIep\.aiQHYFS4WIcqUH_TYFg�Y[RdeHfNWIeXWI_{o-�^Y[\�rqP�QHYq`Ia4QpY[ZERTcqU1`�Z�a�WIe�anU�`�Rde�aa4`VeH`IaiY�RdS�aiQXW,a�eHY[R{a4QHY^Z�`ImBa4QHY^SiY�a}x�`6Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS�RdS�UHWIZbaiRTk[jp_�WIZb_do6k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_T_{o"gpjHZi\HY^eHSi`IcVY,¢a4QpY�k^`�cVUpjpa4Y�a4RdcVY�x�RdaiQV`IjHZ�Sbc"W,_T_TY^Sba�SiWIcVUp_TY�SiRd�[Y�W']IY[ZiWIf�Y[\�W,g1`�j-a�aiY[eVSiY[k^`�eH\HS^wXWIeH\VRda�x:WIS�`IeH_doWIg�`�jpatW"QXWI_{m�W"cqRTe�jpa4Y�`�e*`�jpZ�_�W,Zif�Y^SbatSiWIcqUH_TY,r�|�r�YIr�aiQHY@m�Z4W,cVYlx:`�Zb��SiQH`�jp_T\*Y^eXWIgH_dY�ZiY^SiYuW,Zik�QHY^ZiSa4`�WIeXW,_do%�[Y�c�jHk�QVcV`IZiY�k[`IcVUH_dYlvFUpZi`�gH_dY[cqS�WIeH\J�>`�Z�Y[eHf�W,f�Y�RTeqWE��jHR{a4Y�gHR{a�`,m<Zb`�gHjHS�a4eHY^SiS�WIeHWI_do%SiRdS[r

� � � RTF ��� Z �$ZÎQfJ*X[EGZgb � � J ��� HGF �� jHZta}x�`)_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e*YlvpWIcqUH_dY�RTSnRTe�aiQHY�SiUHRdZiR{ay`Im:©�WI�[�^Y[`J� ¨Iª�ª�¨ �tx�Qp`NY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^SyW�cq`%\HY[_�`,m:k^`�cF�U�Y^a4R{a4Rd`�e3WIcq`�eHf�]�Y^Zba4RdkuWI_d_do \pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a4R�W>a4Y[\ ��R¸r�YIrhQHRTf�QLWIeH\h_T`'x �%jHWI_TR{a}oH�@cq`IaiY[_TS^rLP�QpY)\HY^c"W,eH\k[jpZb]�YqRTS�\HY[ZbRd]�Y^\.m�Zb`�c W�\HRdSik^ZiY^aiY�k�QH`�Rdk[YFcV`%\HY^_¸rE|¡m�aiQHYFk[`�eHSbjHcqY[Znk[`IeHSijHcqY[Sy`�epYq`,m�aiQHYFf�`%`-\HScVWIZi�,Y^a4Y^\�w�Rda�kuW,e�k�QH`-`ISiY�Y[R{a4QHY^Z�aiQHY�_T`'x3`�Z�QHRTf�Q@�%jHWI_TR{a}o�fI`-`%\�r � `�eHSijpcVY^ZiS ��WIZiY2\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a4R�W>a4Y[\@g�oa4QpY[RTZ�UHZbRTk[Y�k[`%Y � k[RdY[e�aF��cVY[WIe�a�ai`6cqRTcqRTkta4QpY[RTZ�cVWIZif�RdeXWI_�j-a4RT_dRda}o�`,m�RTeHk^`�cqY'�lw�WIep\�a4QHY�RTe�]�Y^ZiSbY�`Ima4QHW,a:k^`-Y � k[RTY^e�an��x�QHRTk�Q6SbQH`�jH_d\"g�Y�RdeHk[ZbYuWISbRTeHfERTeVRTeHk^`�cqY'��\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiY[S�Ylv-U�`�eHY^e�aiR�WI_d_doIr�P�QHY�cq`%\HY[_f�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4Y^S�\HY^c"W,eH\�m�`�Z2a4QHYy_d`#x¯WIeH\NQHRdf�Q��%jHWI_TR{a}o6`�UpaiRT`�epS[wHZbY[SiU�Y[kla4R{]�Y[_{o�wJWIS

� � � �N5 ����� �� � J�5 ����� � � � �� � � � �WIeH\ � � � �N5 ��� � � � � �� � � � �� �UHZb`#]%Rd\HY[\�� �� � � � � � 7�� � � �`,a4QHY^Zbx�RTSbYIw � � ª �lr

��WIk�Q"`Im1a4QHY@�,� � ��� � ���HZicqS�k�Qp`-`�SbY�Wn��jXWIe�aiRda}o�a4`EcVWIZi�,Y^a�RTeFa4QHY^RTZ�_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e�w�WIep\VUHZbRTk^Y[S�WI\>�bjHS�aa4`�a4QHYE��jHeHRT��jHYu� � `�jHZbeH`Ia�Y^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc UpZiRTk^Y:]�Y^k^ai`�Z[r�P�QpY�UHZi`I�pa�`ImX�XZbc ��cVWIe�jpmWIkla4jHZbRTeHf�UHZi`%\HjHkla� WIZiYnk^`�cVUpjpa4Y^\ �b`��VRdeHY �qWIS��� @ � � 8�� J����'����� @ � J����� �

x�QHY^ZiY�����RTS�aiQHY�cVWIZbf�RTeXW,_pk[`ISba�`Im�UHZb`-\pjHk^a � w78���RTS�R{a4S�Y[��jHRd_TRTgpZiRTjpc UHZbRTk^YIw%WIeH\����� RTS�RdaiS��-vpY^\"k^`�Sba[r��YESbY^a V �V � 7 � � wJWIS�a4QHRdS�f�jXWIZiWIe�a4Y[Y^S�U1`�SbRdaiRd]�YnY^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc ��jXWIe�a4R{a4RTY^S[r

D =

Page 33: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

�~YFeH`'x _TRTS�ata4QpYVW,SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�epSn`�e!Y[e�a4Z�o.WIeH\!Ylv-Rda[r�P�QHY[ZbYVRdSnW�jHeHRdm�`IZic \HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�e�`Im�a4QpYe�jHc�g�Y[Zy`Im:U1`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y^e�aiZ4WIe�aiSEx�R{a4Q �"�3��� =�� � m�`�Z1� � ª � = � ¨ � D ��RTe!Y[WIk�Q~U�Y[ZbRT`%\�r �$QHY[e~WU�`Ia4Y^e�aiR�WI_�Y^e�a4Z4W,e�a�WIUHU�YuWIZbS@R{a�ZbY[k^Y[Rd]IY[S@WIe~RdeH\HY[U�Y[ep\HY[e�a�\HZiWux `�e �� ®�O� � � � � �tm�Zi`�c .10%�43 �B3WS��I�WIeH\�k[WIe�Y[e�aiY[ZtRde�W,ancq`�Sba�`�eHY�`,m�a4QHY�cVWIZb�IY^aiS[r�«-RdeHk[Y � � WIep\ � � ZbY9<XY^k^ay\HR{�<Y^ZiY^eHk[Y^StRTe�W6fIRd]�Y^eRTep\HRd]%RT\pjXWI_ ��S�k[`�S�ay`Im�gHjHRd_T\HRdeHfVaiQHY�QHRTfIQ�WIeH\*aiQHY�_T`'x­��jXWI_dRda}o)cV`IaiY[_ORTe!W"UHWIZbaiRTk[jp_�WIZ�c"WIZb�IYlauw<x�YWI_d_T`'x aiQHY[c®a4`)g1YVk[`�ZbZiY^_�W,aiY[\�r�|}eH\pY[Y[\�x�Y6cVWI�IYFa4QpY"ZiY[WISi`IeXWIgH_dY6WISbSijHcqUpa4Rd`�e!a4QXW,a�a4QHYqk[`ISba@ai`W�f�Rd]IY[e!RTep\HRd]%RT\pjXWI_O`Im:gpjHRT_d\HRTeHfqa4QHYFQHRdf�Q���jXWI_dRda}o)cV`IaiY[_�Rde!W�f�Rd]IY[e!c"W,Zi�IYlayRTSt_TWIZifIY[Z�aiQXWIe�a4QXW>aRTep\HRd]%RT\pjXWI_ ��S2k^`�Sba�`Im�gHjHRd_T\HRdeHf@a4QpYE_d`'x¯��jXWI_dRda}o"cV`IaiY[_�Rde�a4QHYyS4W,cVYncVWIZi�,Y^a[wXR¸r�YIr�x�Y@WISbSijHcqY

� � 7 � � x�Rda4Q�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a}o"`IeHY_\|}e)UHWIZbaiRTk[jp_�WIZ:aiQHYyk[`�S�a�`ImBY^e�a4Zbo6RTe�a4`�a4QpYE_d`'x¯��jXWI_dRda}oVUHZi`%\HjHkla�\HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiY[S�WIS�\H`%Y[S�a4QpYEY^e�a4Zbo

k[`ISbanRde�a4QHY@`�eHY@_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e�cq`%\HY[_��SbY[Y�Y^�%jHW,a4Rd`�e =#§ ��x�RdaiQ*UXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^Z $ � x�QHRT_dY�aiQHY�k[`ISban`Im�Y^e�a4ZboRTe�ai`FaiQHYyQHRTfIQN��jXW,_TRda}oVUHZb`-\Hjpk^a�RTS�f�R{]�Y^e)g�o

� � �� � ) 2x�QHY^ZiYFa4QHYF\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`Ie*`Im�2"RTSnf�R{]�Y[e.g�o�Y[��jXW>a4RT`Ie¥� =#§ ��x�R{a4Q.UXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[Z2$ � � � r�P�Q�jHSEa4QHY^ZiYqWIZbYa}x�`NY^e�a4Zbo*UXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[ZbSta4`�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y��,$ � ��$ � �lr���v-R{anm�Y[Y[SyW,ZiY�\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4Y[\�R r R r \<rEY&v-U1`�epY[e�a4RTWI_Bx�RdaiQUXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^ZiS�� � �� � �2RTe�a4QHYna}x�`V_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHS^r � `�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`Ie�`ImBaiQHYyY[��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc WIeH\�f�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4Rd`�e�`Ima4QpY�\XW>a�W�jpSiY[\Vm�`�Z�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Rd`�e�RTS�\H`�eHY�RTe"WEcVWIeHepY[Z�WIeXWI_d`�f�`�jHS�ai`�QH`'x$R{a�x:WIS�\H`�eHY�m�`�Z�a4QHY�SiRdeHf�_TY_T`%kuW>a4RT`Ie6YlvpWIcqUH_TY,r

� ; �5;3� � ' � 1 � � /-� � � &.' %���� �5� :�� 4�� + � �5:M��� 13' ;P�QHY�©)`�e�a4Y � WIZb_T`yZiY^SijH_{a4S�m�`�Z�_TWIZif�Y�SiWIcqUH_TY^S�W,ZiY�SiUp_TRda�g�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e"a�W,gH_TY ¨ ��m�`IZ�a4QHY � s! = `�Z�UHSiY^jH\H`cq_TY@Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS���WIeH\�a�W,gH_TY D ��m�`�Z�a4QHY � s! ª W,eH\ � s! ¨ Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS4�lrnP�QHY^ZiY�RTS�W �bSba4WIZba ��Zi`'xRTe)a4QHY�UHR{]�`Ia�a�WIgH_dY�m�`�Z�a4QHY�Sb`�cVY@`Im�a4QHY�a}x�`�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�e)ZijHepS[¢�x�QHY^e�S�a�WIZ�aP = x:Y�S�a�WIZ�ata4QpY�SiYuW,Zik�Qm�Zi`Ic a4QpY��/. �� � #��. ª Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�Z � ![r

PBW,gH_TY ¨ SijpcVcVWIZiRd�[Y^S�ZbY[Sijp_da4S�`�e*UHSbY[jH\p`�cV_dYEY^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�m�Zi`Ic UXWIeHY^_TS�x�R{a4Q � =#� WIep\ . �Iª�ªIª r � Rd]IY[e�aiQHRTS�W,cV`�jpe�a�`ImJ\XW,a4WpwIa4QpY2a�WIgH_dY:RdS�\HY[SbRTf�epY[\�a4`�aiY[_d_pjHS�x�QHYla4QHY^Z�UHSiY^jH\H`ycq_TY���x:`�Zb��S �W,aVWI_d_ � 'lr¥P�QHY)WIeHS�x:Y^ZVRdSqUpSiY[jp\H`~cq_TY $�� �,"�����x:`�Zb�Jr���Y)_TWIg1Y^_TY^\LW!SiY[WIZik�QLSba4WIZbaiRTeHf�m�Zi`Ic Wk[Y^Zba4WIRTe�U1`�Rde�a ��jHeHSijpk[k[Y^SiS�m�jH_ �*x�QHY^e�a4QHY ]�Y^_T\HY^Z���©NYuWI\�SiYuW,Zik�Q3WI_df�`�ZiR{a4QHc RTe�©�W,a4_TWIg.k[`�jH_d\~eH`,a�XeH\�W�U�`�SbRda4R{]�Y�]IW,_TjHY�m�`�Z�aiQHYn_TRd�IY[_dRTQH`%`%\�r5�$QHY[e�a4QpY[ZiYtx:WIS�W,e�jHeHSijpk[k[Y^SiS�m�jH_CRTeHR{a4R�W,_Xk[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eVm�`IZ° D â�øGÚ�þtÝ�ñëñóè�±�Ù�þtãyÙ�ÝÆìrêòãÜøGäÜÙGÚ�êóö²Ùmì]÷3Ù²äÈãyêóá�Þ)á�üYÚ�Û|Ù�ì|Ù²Þtã�ê Ú�è]êëÞTÙb·þtÝ�Ú�êóá�Þ � ���Sü±á�äOÚÜÛ|Ù��gì|êóãyÚ�äÜêëðtþrÚ�êóá�Þ �° *�1 Ú�êóã�ãyÚ�äÈÝ�êóû�ÛÚyü±á3ä ±OÝ�äÈì!Ú�á �tÞ�ìaÝ!ö²ÙÍä�á)Ú�á)Ú�ÛtÙ �täÜãyÚ�á�äÈìrÙ²ä�øGá3ÞtìrêëÚ�êóá�Þ êëÞaÚ�ÛtÙ���� 9 �!äÜþ|ÞtãÍå2ã�á�±�Ùgì|êóì Þ|á�Ú>ÚÜä�èÝ�ñëÚ�ÙÍä�Þ�Ý«Ú�êó÷�Ù�ãyÚÜÝ�ä�Ú�êóÞ|ûÆ÷«Ý�ñóþ|ÙÍã�ü±á3äOÚ�Û|ÙÍï �° 0mú�êóÞtøGÙ�±fêëÚ�Û!Ú�Ûtêóãfï<þtøÈÛTì|Ý«ÚÈÝ �»á�ÞÚ�Ù`î�Ý�äÜñóá<äÜÙ²ýÂÙGÚÜê ÚÜêëá3Þtã�ÚÜÝ�ß�Ù�·þ|ê ÚÜÙ�Ýgð|ê ÚMá�üYø²á�ïÆý|þrÚÜÙ²äOÚ�êóïÆÙ�åtÝ�Þtì�±pÙ�ß�Þ|Ù�±9Ú�ÛtÙÝ�Þ�ã±�Ù²ä�±fêëÚ�Û"Ýgä�ÙÍñóÝ�Ú�êó÷�Ù²ñóè]ã�ï_Ý�ñóñ�Þþtï`ðÂÙ²äfá�üjäÜÙ²ýÂÙGÚ�êëÚ�êóá�Þ�ã²å'±�Ù�ã�ÚÜá�ý|ýÂÙÍì]Ú�ÛtêóãfäÜþ|Þ"Ý«Ú� 9 �� �

D ¨

Page 34: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

Wnf�Rd]IY[eF\XW,a4WnSiY^a[w�x:Y�a4ZbRTY^\VW,eH`Ia4QpY[Z�RTepRda4RTWI_�k[`�ep\HRdaiRT`�e�w�WIeH\Fk[`�e�aiRTe�jHY[\qjHe�a4Rd_px�Y�S�a�WIZ�a4Y^\qaiQHY�SiYuW,Zik�QW,a�aiY[eN\HRd�1Y[ZbY[e�a�Z4WIep\H`�cq_doVSiY[_dY[kla4Y[\NU�`�RTe�a4S�ep`�eHYy`ImOx�QHRTk�QNZiY^SijH_{a4Y[\�Rde)W�U�`�SiR{a4R{]�Yt_dRT�IY^_TRdQH`-`%\�r��2aa4QHW,a�U1`�Rde�a�x:Y�kuWI_d_TY^\�a4QHY�SiY[WIZik�QV`�eqaiQHY�\XW,a4WESbY^a�jHeHSbjHk[k^Y[SiS�m�jH_¸wpWIeH\qcV`']IY[\Vai`na4QHY�eHYlv%a�\XW,a4WySbY^a[rP�QHYnSbjHg-�}UHWIeHY[_�_TWIg�Y[_TY^\ �bSbjHk[k^Y[SiS�Z4W>a4Y ��UpZi`']%RT\HY^S�aiQHY�m�ZiWIk^aiRT`�e�`ImCaiQHYta4RdcVY�x�QHY[e�a4QpRTS�SijpgHZi`�j-a4RTepYZiY^k[`�Zb\HY[\�W �bSijHk^k[Y^SiS �pr:P�QHYyUHSbY[jH\H`VcV_dYt\H`%Y[S�eH`Ia�x�`�Zi� ` � ���2`ImOa4QHYna4RdcVY,r

P�QHYyZiY[WISi`�e�m�`�Z�a4QHYy�[Y^Zi`FUHSbY[jH\H`F_dRT�IY^_TRdQH`-`%\"RdS:a4QHW,a�a4QHYt�HZiSba�S�a�WIfIYnRTS2UHZb`-\pjHk[RdeHfFW ��/� � �:3 �F7���� � �43 ��m�`IZOk[WIeH\HRd\XW,aiY�UHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[Z�],WI_TjpY[S�x�QHY[e�a4QHY^ZiY�RTSCRTenmWIklaBY^e�aiZboyRde�_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e ¨ rB«-RTeHk^Y�aiQHY�k[`�S�a`Im�Y[e�a4Z�o�RTe�_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e ¨ RTS�W,_dx:W'o%S�QHRdf�QHY[Z�a4QXWIe�RdeN_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�e = wpRdmO`�jHZ�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[\�Y^e�a4Zbo�],WI_djHY[S2x�Y[ZbYa4ZbjHYIw-Y[e�a4Z�o"Rde6_T`%kuW>a4RT`Ie = x:`�jp_T\6eHYl]�Y^Z�QXWIUHU�Y[e!��QHY[epk[Yta4QpY��[Y^Zi`�_dRT�IY^_TRdQH`-`%\J�&rOP�QpYtZiY[WISi`�e"Rda�\H`-Y^SQXWIUpU1Y^e.RdS�g�Y[k[WIjHSiY � � � �:3 � � �/� � �43 �l¢�R¸r�YIrtaiQHY�\HRdSba4jpZigXWIepk[Y[SnRde�a4QpY��XZiS�anSba4WIf�Y�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[StQHW']IYZiYl]�Y^ZiSiY^\~a4QpY�`�Zi\HY^Zy`Im�a4QHY�a}x�`)Y^e�aiZbo*],WI_djHY[S^rq«-RTepk[Y�a4QpYqUpSiY[jp\H`)_dRT�,Y[_TRdQH`%`-\)\H`-Y^SyeH`IayZiY^k[`�fIeHRT�^Ya4QpYEU�`�SbSiRTgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S�f�Y[eHY^Z4W,aiY[\Ng�o6�XZiS�a�Sba�W,f�YnY[S�a4RTcVW,aiRT`�e6Y^ZiZb`�Z[wHR{a�kuWIe�ZbY[k[`IZi\)WFUpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda}oq`Im��[Y[Zb`m�`�Z�Yl]�Y[e�aiS�x�QHRdk�QV\p`EQHWIUHU�Y[e�r ]�`Ia4Y2aiQXW,a�WI_d_-a4QpRTS�QXWIS�ai`E\p`ERdS�QXWIUHU�Y[eq`�eHk^Y�WIcV`IeHfta4QHY�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S`ImOa4QHYyY^e�aiZbo�],WI_djHY[S2m�`�Z�W,_T_<aiQHYySba�W>a4Y[S�]%RTSbRdaiY[\�m�`�Z2a4QpYEUpSiY[jp\H`"cq_TY�ai`qmW,RT_¸r

«-RTepk[Y�aiQHYnUHZiY^k[RdSiRT`Ie6`Im�a4QpYt�XZiS�a�Sba4WIf�YtY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[S2W,a�W�U�`�RTe�a2WIZiYnWEm�jHeHk^aiRT`�e"`ImCa4QHYte�jHc@g1Y^Z2`Ima4RdcVY^S�aiQXW,atU�`�Rde�a�x2W,St]-RdSiR{a4Y[\<w1x�Y�a4QH`�jpf�Q�atx:Y@cVRdf�Q�atRTcqUHZb`#]IY�aiQHY�U�Y[Zbm�`IZicVWIeHk[Y�`Im�a4QHY@UHSiY^jH\H`_TRd�IY^_TRTQp`-`%\~Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS�Rdm�x�Y�aiZiRdcVcqY[\�U�`�Rde�aiS�x�QHRTk�Q3x�Y[ZiY�]%RTSbRdaiY[\3RTepm�ZbY[��jHY^e�ai_doIr�P�QHY �bSijHk^k[Y^SiSSijpg-�}UXW,eHY[_ ��UHZiY^SiY[e�aiS�SbjHk[k^Y[SbS�ZiW,a4Rd`�S�x�QHY^e�x:Yna4ZbRTcqcVY^\VaiQHYt`�eHY&�}QXW,_dmC`ImCa4QpYnSba�W>a4Y[S2]%RdSiRdaiY[\"x�QpRTk�Qx�Y[ZiY�]-RdSiR{a4Y[\Na4QHY�_TY[WISba�e�jHc�g�Y[Zt`ImBa4RTcqY[S��9��a4ZbRTc �r � Sba�W>a4Y[S ���lw<WIeH\Nx�QHY[e*x�Y@a4ZbRTcqcVY^\NWI_T_CSba4W,a4Y^Sa4QHW,a�x:Y^ZiY�]-RdSiR{a4Y[\q_TY^SiS�a4QHWIeqaiY[eqa4RTcqY[S��9��a4ZbRTc ='ª ]%RTSbRda4S ���lr�P�ZbRTcqcVRdeHft\H`%Y[S�RTcqUHZb`#]IY�`�jHZ�Sijpk[k[Y^SiSZ4W>a4YIw�gHjpa@RdaERTSESbaiRT_T_�ep`Ia4Rdk[YuW,gH_do!g�Y[_d`#x `�eHYIr�P�QHYVeHYlv%a�UHWIeHY[_�UHZb`']-Rd\HY[S�a4QHYqY[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[Sym�Zi`�c®a4QpYa4ZbRTcqcVY^\6Zijpe�x�R{a4Q6aiQHYyQHRTf�QpY[Sba�SbjHk[k^Y[SbS�ZiW,a4Y,r�|¡a�RTS�k[_dYuWIZ�a4QXW,a:a4QHYna4ZbRTcqcVRdeHfERTS�g�`Ia4Q�gHRTWISiRdeHf�a4QpYY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�WIeH\�k[WIjHSbRTeHf�aiQHY[RdZE],WIZbR�WIepk[YVai`�f�`)jHU �Rde�Sb`�cqY"kuW,SiY[S@\HZ4WIcVW,aiRTkuW,_T_dop�&r=�~YVk[`�epk[_Tjp\HYa4QHW,aq`�eHY�SiQH`IjH_T\heH`IaFg�Y�jHSiRdeHf�UpSiY[jp\H`~cq_TY,w�W>aV_dYuWIS�aFeH`IaFx�RdaiQH`�jpaFSb`�cqY)W,j-v-RT_TRTWIZbo�UHZb`-k^Y[\HjHZbYa4QHW,aNWIcqY[_TRd`�Z4W>a4Y[Sqa4QHY!UHZb`�gH_dY[cqS�kuWIjHSbY[\ g�o$RTcqUHZiY^k[RTSbY��XZbSbaNSba4WIf�Y!Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�`ImEY[e�aiZbo7],WI_TjpY[S[r� `�eHSbY[��jHY^e�ai_do�x�YE\p`VeH`,a�UHZiY^SiY[e�a�a4QHY^c RTe�x�QXW,a�m�`�_d_T`'x�S � � r

PBW,gH_TY D UHZb`']-Rd\HY[S�aiQHY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS6`Igpa�WIRdeHY[\�m�Zb`�c � s! ª WIep\ � s! ¨ x�QHY^e � ='� W,eH\. =uª�ª�ª rOP�QHY�SbaiZiRd�%RdeHftU�`�RTe�a�m�Zi`�c­a4QHRdS�a4WIgH_TY�RTSBaiQXW,a�x�QHY[e�x�Y�jHSiY �/. ¨ ��x:Y�jHSbY2a4QHY:UHSiY^jH\H`cqRTeHRdc�jHc Z � Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�Z���a4QHYyY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�`Im �k[WIeNg1Yn]�Y^ZboN\HR{�<Y^ZiY[e�a�m�Zi`Ic a4QpY[RTZ�aiZijHYn],WI_TjpY[S[wJW,eH\Y^]IY[e~x�QpY[e~aiQHY^o�WIZbYVeH`,a@Sb`�\HR{�<Y^ZiY[e�aEa4QHY^RTZn],WIZiRTWIeHk^Y[S�WIZiYqc"W,Zi�IY^\H_do*QHRTf�QpY[Zya4QXWIe.a4QH`ISiYq`Im2a4QpY� s! ª Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS[r�|}e�aiQHY�a}x�`6_T`%kuW>a4RT`IeNcq`%\HY[_�a4QpY[ZiY@WIZiY�_TY^SiS�RTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a4StRde)Y[WIk�Q�Sba4W,a4Y6�SbRTeHk^Ya4QpY^o)WIZiYEeH`'x­SiUp_TRda�g�Y^a}x�Y[Y^e*a}x:`6_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eHS4�lr:P�QpY�WIkla4jXWI_C`�j-a4k[`IcVY^S�m�`�Z�YuW,k�Q�a4ZiWIeHSiR{a4Rd`�e�g1Y^QXWu]�Y_TRd�IY�W@c�jH_{a4RdeH`�cqR�WI_px�R{a4Q ����\HZ4Wux�S[wHWIeH\"x�R{a4Q ����Sbc"WI_d_TY^Z�aiQHY^oVQXWu]�Yncq`�ZbY�],WIZbR�WIeHk^YIr���S�W@ZbY[Sijp_dauwY^]IY[e$x�RdaiQ�ZiY^_�W,aiRd]�Y^_doh_�W,Zif�Y)S4WIcqUH_TY^S[w�a4QpY*UHZiY^_TRdcVRdeXWIZbo�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS"`,m�k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e7WIeH\7Y^e�a4Zbo],WI_TjpY[S@k[WIe�g�YV��jHR{a4YVeH`�RTS�o�rNP�QXW,a@eH`�RTSbYIwOx�QHY[e k^`�c�gHRdeHY[\.x�Rda4Q�a4QHY"WIk[k^Y[e�a4jXW>a4RT`Ie�`Im2aiQHY"Y^ZiZi`IZ° � ùOÛ|á�þtû�Ûn±�Ù`ìrêòì"øGá�ïÆý|þ|Ú�Ù�ÚÜÛ|Ù²ï ±fêëÚ�Û"äÜÙÍã�þ|ñëÚÜã>ãyêóïÆêëñòÝ�äfÚÜá_Ú�Ûtá3ã�Ù�ý|äÜÙÍã�Ù²ÞÚ�Ùmì!Ý�ð�á«÷3Ù�� �pØ Ù�Þ|á�Ú�Ù�ÚÜÛtÝ«ÚB±fÛ|Ù²Þ"è3á�þêëÚ�Ù²äÈÝ«ÚÜÙ�á�Þ)Ú�Û|Ù�ýtã�Ù²þ�ìrá_ïÆñëÙ�ÙÍãyÚ�êóï_Ý«ÚÜá�äÈã�Ú�Û|ÙÍè]á�ÞtñëèÎû3ÙGÚ�±�á�äÈãyÙ3å�Ý3ã�Ú�Û|Ù�êëÚ�ÙÍäÜÝ�Ú�Ùmì)ã�þtø²ø²ÙÍãÜãOäÜÝ�Ú�Ù�ø²Ý�Þ)á3Þ|ñóèÎû�á_ìrá�±fÞ �

DD

Page 35: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

a4QHW,atZbY[Sijp_da4S�m�Zi`�c a4QpY�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�eXWI_Cm�`�Zic `Im�aiQHY@`Ig%�bY[kla4Rd]IY�m�jHeHkla4RT`Ie�RTe)a4QHY � s ¨ Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS'��SiY^Ya4QpYq\pRTSik^jHSiSbRT`�e!Rde�SiY[kla4Rd`�e D r ¨ ���(�uw�cVWI�IY^SyaiQH`�SbYqY^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbStUHZb`�gH_TY^c"W>a4RTk,r���Sy`�eHY�cqRTf�Q�anY&vpU�Y[klaa4QpY[SiYFUHZb`�gH_dY[cqSt`�eH_{o�f�Ylanx:`IZiSiY�x�R{a4Q!SicVWI_d_TY[Z�S4W,cVUH_dY[S^w�Si`�x:Y�m�`%k[jpSta4QHY�ZbY[Sbay`,m�aiQHY�\HRTSbk[jHSbSiRd`�e`�e�a4QpY � s! ª Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S^r

� e�a4QHY�`Ia4QpY[Z�QXWIeH\�wJx�RdaiQ)aiQHRTS�S4WIcqUH_TYySbRT�[Y@WI_T_�aiQHY �/. ª Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�\H`VmWIRdZi_{o6x:Y^_T_ r�P�QHYY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�`Im 7a4QHW,a�jHSbYNS�a4ZbjHk^aijHZ4WI_�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S"�R r Y,r � s! ª w�gHjpaq��¤ = �@\H`!SiY^Y[c ai`.QHW']IY_�W,Zif�Y^Z�cVY[WIe�Si��jXWIZbY�Y^ZiZi`IZ[wHx�QHRdk�Q)_dRT�IY^_do"k[`�ZbZiY[SbU1`IeH\HS�a4`Fa4QHYnmWIkla�aiQXW,a�a4QpY^o�QXWu]IY�a4`FRdcVUHj-a4YnY[e%�a4Z�o�W,eH\�Ylv-Rda�Z4W,aiY[SBm�`�ZBWIg�`�jpa ¦���� `ImXaiQHY2S�a�W,aiY[S�a4QpY^o�k^`�cqUHjpa4Y:Y[e�a4Z�o�WIeH\�k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�e@],WI_TjpY[S�m�`IZ�k^`�cqUXWIZiY � �,��� � ������a4` � �8Am�`IZOaiQHY[SbY:k[`I_TjHcqeHS��&r�©N`�ZiY�SbaiZiRT��RdeHfHw#QH`'x:Yl]�Y^Z[w�RTSCa4QpY�ZiW,a4QHY^Z�S�a�WIZb�n\HRdm��m�Y[ZbY[eHk^Y[S2RdeqaiQHY�k^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_XgHjHZb\HY[epS:`Im�aiQHYtW,_da4Y^ZieXW>a4Rd]IY � s ª Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS^r���SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�x�QpRTk�QjHSbYqS�a4ZbjHk^aijHZ4WI_BUHZi`�gHWIgHRT_dRdaiRTY[S�WIeH\ �ts! ª W,ZiY��Hm�aiY[Y[e�aiRTcqY[SnWISnk^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_T_{o�gHjHZb\HY[eHSb`�cqYVW,SY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[SOx�QHRTk�Q�jHSbY2Y[cqUHRdZiRTk[WI_�UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^SOWIeH\ �ts! ª w�WIep\�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^SOaiQXW,aBjHSiY2aiQHY��pv-Y^\qU�`�Rde�ak[`Ic�gHRTepY[\ � �ns! = �2x�RdaiQ)aiQHY@S�a4Zijpk^a4jpZ4WI_OUHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRdaiRTY^S�WIZiYEa}x:Y^e�a}o)a4RdcVY^S�cq`�ZbY�k^`�cVUpjpa�W,aiRT`�eHWI_T_{ogHjHZb\HY[epSi`�cqYIr � ehaiQHY�`Ia4QpY[Z�QXWIep\haiQHY�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�x�QHRTk�QhjHSbYNaiQHY�Y[cqUHRTZbRTkuW,_�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S�W,eH\],WI_TjpY�m�jHeHkla4RT`IeNR{a4Y^Z4W,aiRT`�eHS:WIZiYn`IeH_do"WIg�`�jpa ='ª�� cq`�ZiYngHjpZi\HY^eHSi`�cqYta4QpY[e�a4QH`�SbYna4QXW,a2jHSiYna4QpYnc"W>�a4ZbR{vVRTe�]IY[ZiSbRT`�e6WIeH\"aiQHYtY[cqUHRdZiRTk[WI_JUHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRdaiRTY^S���a4Qp`�jHf�Q�wpWIS:ep`Ia4Y^\�w-aiQHRTS�x:`�jp_T\�RTepk[ZiY[WISiY�x:Y^ZiYtx�YWI_dSi`FY[S�a4RTcVW,aiRTeHf�UpZi`I�Ha�m�jHepk^a4Rd`�e�UXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^ZiS��&r

PBW,gH_TY � UHZi`']%RT\HY^SEaiQHYqY[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^Stm�Zi`�c SicVWI_T_dY[ZtSiWIcVUp_TY[S^r6«%RTeHk^YqaiQHYFe%jpc�g1Y^Z�`,m:RdeHk[jHc@g1Y^e�aiSU�Y[Z�aiZ4WIeHSbRdaiRT`�e*RdSnWIg�`�jpayW"aiQHRTZb\*`Im�x�QXW,atRdatx:WISnRTe*W6SiRTcqRT_TWIZ�SiRd�[Y[\!SiWIcVUp_TY@Rde*a4QHY@`�eHYl�¡_T`%kuW,aiRT`�ecq`-\HY^_��`�e�Wu]�Y[ZiWIf�Y,w�aiQHY[ZbY�WIZbY�W,Zi`�jHep\ � RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a4S�RTe�a4QHYE`�eHY&�}_T`%kuW>a4RT`IeNY&vpWIcVUp_TYEWIeH\�WIZi`�jpeH\¨ RTeHk^jHc�g�Y[e�a4S�RTeqYuWIk�QV_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eFRTeFa4QpY�a}x�`,�}_d`-k[W,a4Rd`�eFkuWISbY'�&w%x�Y�SbQH`�jH_d\"eH`Ia�g�Y�SbjHZiUpZiRTSbY[\"x�QpY[e"x�YSiY^Y@_TWIZif�Y^Z�SicVWI_T_�SiWIcqUH_TYygHRTWISiY^StWIeH\)_�WIZbf�Y[Z�S�a�WIep\XWIZi\�Y[ZiZb`�ZiS�a4QHWIe�Rde)P�WIgH_dY = r �`'x:Yl]�Y^Z[w��bjpSbanW,SRTe)a4QXW,a�a�WIgH_dYIw<WIS�x�Y�RTeHk^ZiYuW,SiY�Y[R{a4QHY^Z�a4QpY�_TY^eHfIa4Q�`Im�a4QHY�UHWIeHY[_B`�Z�aiQHY�SiRd�[Y�`Im�R{a4S�k^Zi`�SbSnSiY^k^a4Rd`�eXWI_\HRdcVY^eHSiRd`�e�w-aiQHY[SbY�gpR�WISbY[S�WIeH\NSba4WIeH\XWIZb\)Y^ZiZb`�ZiS�f�`F\H`'x�eNZ4W,aiQHY[Z�Z4W,UHRT\H_{o�r

� `�cqUXWIZiRdeHfFa4QHYy],WIZiRd`�jHS ��. ª Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�x:Y�SiY^Y�a4QHW,a�RdeNaiQHY"� �# � ��. ¨��Iª ��SiWIcqUH_TY^Sa4QpY�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS�aiQXW,a�jHSbY�SbaiZijHkla4jHZiWI_JUHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRdaiRTY^S�� ��¤ = ��\H`Eg�Y^aiaiY[Z�`�eVaiQHY $ ��S�gHjpa�c�jHk�Q"x�`�ZiSbY`�e�aiQHY M � r���S�x�Y2RTepk[ZiY[WISiY�SiWIcqUH_TY�SiRT�^Y:a4QpY2UHZi`IgH_TY^c­x�R{a4Q�aiQHY2Y[cqUHRdZiRTk[WI_�UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o ��S�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S`ImHaiQHY $!��SB\HRdS4WIUpU1Y[WIZiSOZ4W,aiQHY[Z�Z4WIUpRT\H_{o�w>c�jHk�Q�cq`�ZiY�ZiWIUHRT\p_dotaiQXWIe@aiQHY:UHZb`�gH_dY[cqSCx�R{a4QEa4QHY�Sba4ZbjHk^aijHZ4W,_UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a}o ��SCY[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[SB`,mHa4QHY � S^r�«-RdeHk[Y�a4QHY:UHZi`�gp_TY[c x�QpY[e�jHSbRTeHf�aiQHY:Y^cVUpRTZiRdkuWI_�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�RdSRTe�aiQHY�UpZiY[k^RTSbRT`�eF`Im�a4QHY��XZbSba�Sba4WIf�Y�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S[w%WIep\qaiQHY�UHZi`�gp_TY[c RTe�a4QHY�SbaiZijHkla4jHZiWI_XUHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^SBRdSk[`IcVU�`�jHeH\pY[\�g�oEa4QHY�mWIk^a�a4QXW,a�Rda�QXWISOa4`tRdcVUpjpa4Y�Y[e�aiZbo@WIeH\�Y&vpR{a�ZiW,a4Y^S�m�`�ZBWIg1`Ijpa ¦���� `ImXa4QpY:Sba4W,a4Y^SRda�jHSbY[S[w�aiQHRTSOZiY^SijH_{a�SbQH`�jH_d\�QXWu]�Y2g�Y[Y^e�Ylv-U�Y[kla4Y[\<r � e�a4QHY�`Ia4QHY^ZBQXW,eH\�Rda�RTcqUH_dRTY[S�aiQXW,aBY^]�Y^eFW,a�� � � ��. �Iª�ª ��Rda:RTS2UHZbY^aba}o6k[_dYuWIZ�a4QXW,a:x:YnUHZbY^m�Y^Z2Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS2gHWISiY^\N`Ie�Y[cqUHRTZbRTkuW,_�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S^w-W,eH\a4QpRTSCk[`�epk[_TjpSiRT`Ie�RdSOZbY[Rdepm�`�Zik^Y[\�W,aO_�WIZbf�Y[Z�SiWIcqUH_TY�SiRd�[Y^S[r�©N`�ZiY^`#]IY[ZOa4QHY�k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_,gHjHZb\HY[e�`,mpa4QpY° �²ØaÙ!Þ|á�Ú�ÙÎÚÜÛtÝ«Ú<Ú�Û|Ù)ä�Ùmãyþtñ ÚÈã`á3ÞÀÚ�Û|Ù W � 9 �TÙÍãyÚ�êóï_Ý«Ú�á3ä�±�Ù²äÜÙÎÞ|á�Úgìrþ|Ù]Ú�á Ý"ü±Ù�± á3þrÚ�ñóêóÙ²äÈã ��ùOÛ�Ý«Ú<êòã`Ú�Û|ÙTÝ�øGÚ�þtÝ�ñ

�"á3Þ3ÚÜÙ*î�Ý�äÜñóá�ìrêóãyÚ�äÜêóð|þrÚ�êóá�Þ]á�ü�Ú�Û|ÙIW � 9 ��ÙÍãyÚ�êóï_Ý«Ú�á3äÜãSìrêóìÎÞ|á�Úpø²á�ÞÚÜÝ�êëÞÎÝ`ãyêóÞ|û�ñóÙMá3äpÝ�ü±Ùb±VÙÍãyÚ�êóïÆÝ�Ú�á3äÜãjÚÜÛtÝ«ÚOìräÜá«÷�ÙOÚ�ÛtÙ÷«Ý�äÜêóÝ�ÞtøGÙ*äÜÙÍã�þ|ñ ÚÈã �

D �

Page 36: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS�x�QHRTk�QNjHSiYyS�a4Zijpk^a4jpZ4WI_�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[S:RdS2a4Y^eN`IZ�cV`�ZbYta4RdcVY^S:a4QXW>a�`Im�aiQHYyk[`�ZbZiY^SiU�`�eH\HRdeHfY[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS2x�QpRTk�QNjHSiYna4QpYEY^cVUpRTZiRdkuWI_1UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRdaiRTY^S[r

� `�cqUXWIZiRdeHf�aiQHY�a}x�`�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�x�QHRTk�Q"jHSiY �/. �� � ª x�Yt�XeH\"aiQXW,a2Rde"a4QpYtSicVWI_T_dY[S�a�a}x�`S4W,cVUH_dY[S�Rda�RTS�k^_TYuW,Z�aiQXW,a�x:Y�UHZiYlm�Y[Z�a4QHY�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZ�x�QHRTk�Q6\p`-Y^S�aiQHY�cVW,a4ZbR{v�RTe�]�Y^ZiSiRd`�e��W��. ª ��ai`a4QpY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z�x�QpRTk�Q*jHSbY[StaiQHY�eHY^Sba4Y^\��pv-Y[\�U�`�RTe�aF�W�/. = �lr �`'x:Yl]�Y^ZEg�oNa4QHY�a4RTcqYyx:Y�fIY^a�ai`WVSiWIcqUH_TYySiRd�[YE`Im!. �Iª�ª WIeH\ �# =#� wJx�QpY[e*g�`Ia4Q)Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�WIZbY�\H`IRTeHfqZiY[WISi`�eHWIgH_do�x�Y[_d_¸wXa4QpYeHY^Sba4Y^\*�pv-Y[\!U�`�RTe�a�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZ�SbY[Y^cVS�ai`6QXWu]�Y@c"WIZbf�RTeHWI_T_{o6g�Y^aiaiY[Z�U1Y^Zbm�`�Zbc"WIepk[YIr � eHk[Y�WIf�WIRde)a4QpY��. = Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z�RdS�`�eH_do�cVRdeHRTcVWI_T_{oncq`�ZiY�gHjHZb\HY[epSi`�cqY�aiQHY[eqa4QHY ��. ª Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z^w�Wn�XeH\HRdeHfx�QHRdk�Q)RdS�_TRT�,Y[_{o"a4`Fk�QXW,eHf�Ynx:Y^ZiYyx:YEY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRTeHf@cV`�ZbYnUXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^ZiS�`�Z�W�cV`IZiYnk[`IcVUH_dYlv6cV`%\HY[_ r

�~Y�a4ZiRdY[\�ai`6RTcqUHZb`#]IY�aiQHY�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�m�Zi`�c a4QpY@SicVWI_d_TY[S�a�SiWIcqUH_TY�g�o)RdaiY[ZiW,a4RdeHfV`Ie�a4QHY^c)r�P�QHYRdaiY[ZiW,a4Y^\qY^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS�jHSiY^\qaiQHY ��. ª gpjpa ���# ��. = Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�a4`yk^`�eHSbaiZijHkla�a4QHY�Ylv-R{a:W,eH\Y[e�aiZbo�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a4RdY[SCa4QH`�SbY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�RdcVUH_dRTY^\�r � R{]�Y[e�aiQHY[SbY�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[SCx:Y�jpSiY�a4QHY �/. ª gHj-a� � �/. = Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiRT`�e)WI_TfI`�ZiR{a4QHc a4`"`Igpa�WIRde)aiQHY@R{a4Y[ZiW,a4Y^\)],WI_djHY[S�`Im � � r�P�WIgH_dY � UHZi`']%RT\HY^SZiY^SijH_{a4S�m�Zi`Ic RdaiY[ZiW,a4RdeHf�RTe�a4QpRTS2x:W'o�`IeHYna4`�m�`�jHZ2aiRTcqY[S[r

� `�cqUXWIZiRdeHf�aiQHYy� ª � = � = �Ck^`�_TjHcqe@Rde�P�WIgH_TY � a4`�a4QHY:�HZiSbaBRdaiY[Z4W>a4RT`Ie@Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZORTe@P�WIgH_dY � x�Y�SiY^Ya4QHW,a�m�`IZ�`�jpZ:SicVWI_d_TY[S�a�S4WIcqUH_TY�SbRT�[Y�a4QHY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�`Im�a4QpY $ M � x�`�ZiSbY[e�gHjpa�a4QHY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�`Im�a4QpY ��SRTcqUHZb`#]IYIr�|¡a4Y^Z4W,aiRTeHfqa4QHY�SiY^k[`�eH\)a4RTcqYEcV`']�Y^S�jHS�WIUHUHZb`uvpRdc"W>a4Y[_{o�gXWIk���a4`qa4QHY6� ª � = � = �2Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiSm�`�Z�a4QHY$ M � gHj-aneH`'x­a4QHY�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS�`,m�a4QHY M � f�Y^anc@jHk�Q*x:`IZiSiY,r �$QHY[e�x�Y�cV`']IY�a4`6aiQHY@aiQHRTZb\WIeH\Vm�`�jHZbaiQ6RdaiY[ZiW,a4Rd`�eHS�x:Y��HeH\6a4QXW>a:a4QpY�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS�SiY^Y[c a4`�`�Sbk[Rd_T_�W>a4YIw�W,eH\6a4QHY�`�Sik^RT_d_�W,aiRT`�eHS�SbY[Y[ca4`)g1YV`Im�RdeHk[ZbYuWISbRTeHf)c"WIfIeHRdaijH\HYIwOcq`#]%RdeHf�jHSEmWIZbaiQHY[Z@Wux2Wuo!m�Zi`�c®aiQHYVaiZijpaiQ�r �$QpY[e~x�Y6_T`%`���W>aa4QpY�Si_dRTf�Q�a4_{o�_�W,Zif�Y^Z�SiWIcVUp_TY�x�R{a4Q . �Iª�ª WIeH\ � � aiQHY[ZbY�WIZbY@eH`�WIUpUXWIZiY^e�anWI\p],WIe�a4WIf�Y[S�m�Zi`�cRdaiY[ZiW,a4RdeHfFW,a�WI_d_¸r

«-RTepk[Yta4QpYtRdaiY[Z4W>a4RT`IeHS:eHY^Y[\�eH`Ia2k[`�e�]�Y^Zif�Y,wXU1Y^ZiQXW,UHS2a4QHY�`�Sik^RT_T_TW,a4Rd`�eHS�SiQp`�jH_T\�ep`Ia�g�YnW�SijHZbUHZiRdSiY,r©)`�ZbY�m�jHeH\XWIcqY[e�a4WI_T_{o�w�SiRdeHk[Y�x�Y�W,ZiY�eH`E_T`�eHfIY[Z�QH`�_d\HRTepfyaiQHY�a4ZiWIeHSiR{a4Rd`�e�UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRdaiRTY^S��pv-Y[\<w-x�Y�k[WIeeH`q_T`�epf�Y[Z�Zijp_TYn`�jpa�c�jH_{a4RdUH_TY�Y[��jHRT_dRTgHZbR�W@m�`�Z�WFf�Rd]IY[e�],WI_TjHYy`Im�a4QHYEUXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^Z2]�Y^k^a4`IZ[r2��S�WFZiY^SijH_{aRdatRTSnU�`�SiSbRTgH_dY@m�`�Z�aiQHYqWI_Tf�`IZiRdaiQHc a4`��XeH\.W6],WI_TjpY@m�`�Zta4QpY�UXWIZ4W,cVYla4Y[Zt]IY[kla4`�Zna4QHW,ay`�UpaiRTcqRT�[Y^S�a4QpY`�g%�bY^k^aiRd]�Y�m�jHeHkla4RT`IeEm�`�ZOW�\HRd�1Y[ZbY[e�a�Y[��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc a4QXW,eEaiQHY�`IeHY�aiQXW,a�f�Y[epY[Z4W>a4Y[\Ea4QHY�\XW,a4WprB©)`�ZiY^`']�Y[Z^wa4QpY�k[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�eXW,_HgHjHZb\HY[e6`,m�a4QHY�RdaiY[Z4W>a4Y[\qY[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS�RdS�Q�jHf�Y,z�Y^]IY[e"aiQHY�SbRTeHf�_dY�Rda4Y^Z4W,aiRT`�eFcVWI�IY^Sa4QpY[c a}x:Y^e�a}o)a4RdcVY^S�cq`�ZiY�gHjHZb\HY[eHSb`�cqY@a4QHY^e�a4QpY � � � � ��. ª Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS[w1WIeH\�x�QpY[ex�YqR{a4Y^Z4W,aiY@�H]�YFa4RdcVY^S�a4QpY^o!WIZbY�`']�Y[Zy`�epY�Q%jpeH\HZiY^\�aiRTcqY[Stcq`�ZiY@gHjHZi\pY[eHSb`�cVY,r�P�QHY[ZbYFSiY[Y^cVSyeH`,aa4`Fg�YEWIe�o�WIZifIjHcVY^e�a�m�`IZ�Rda4Y^Z4W,aiRTeHf�W,a�WI_T_ r

|}eH\HY^Y[\FRdmHaiQHY[ZbY2RTS�WIe�o@WIZif�jpcVY^e�a�m�`�ZBjpSiRTepftWIe�o�a4QHRdeHftgHj-a�a4QHY�SiRdcVUH_dY[S�aBY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZORda�RTS�`�eH_donm�`IZ`�jHZOSicVWI_d_TY[S�aCS4WIcqUH_dY�SbRT�^Y[S�W,eH\�aiQHY[e�`IeH_donR{mpaiQHY�ZbY[SbYuWIZbk�QHY[Z�RdS�Rde�a4Y[ZbY[S�a4Y[\@RTeEUXWIZbaiRTk^jH_�WIZ�UHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[ZbScq`�ZiY�a4QXWIe@`Ia4QHY^ZiS^r � e@a4QHY:`Ia4QHY^ZBQXW,eH\�w�Yl]�Y[e�x�R{a4Q�cq`-\pY[Z4W>a4Y:SiWIcqUH_TY�SiRd�[Y[S�a4QHY2SbRTcqUH_TY�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiS°��ÍùOÛtÝ«Úgêóã�±pÙ!øGá3Þtã�ÚÜä�þ�ø�Ú�Ùmì Ú�Û|Ù]êëïÆý|ñóêëÙmì�ãyÚ�äÜþtø�ÚÜþ|äÈÝ�ñ@ý|äÜá�ð�Ý�ð|êóñëêëÚ�êóÙÍãÍå[Ý�Þtì ÚÜÛ|Ù²Þ�þtãyÙmì�Ú�ÛtÙ �#²rÙÍì�ýÂá�êóÞÚ`ÚÜá»û�Ù²Ú`Ú�ÛtÙøGá3ÞÚ�êóÞþ�Ý«Ú�êóá�Þ`÷®Ý�ñëþtÙÍãÕû�Ù²ÞtÙ²äÈÝ«Ú�Ùmì�ð�è>ÚÜÛ|ÙÍã�ÙpãyÚ�äÜþtøGÚ�þ|äÈÝ�ñ3Ú�äÈÝ�Þtã�êëÚ�êóá�Þ�ý|äÜá�ð�Ý�ð|êóñëêëÚ�êóÙÍãÕÝ�Þtì<ìrêëôÂÙÍä�ÙÍÞ3ÚY÷«Ý�ñóþ|ÙÍãÕá�ü ��Ú�á*ïgêóÞ|êóïÆêëöÍÙÚ�ÛtÙ W ��9 �gá3ð���ÙÍøGÚ�êó÷�Ù>ü±þ|Þtø�ÚÜêëá3Þ �

D �

Page 37: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

g�`Ia4Q3U�Y[Zbm�`IZic ZiYuW,Si`�eXW,gH_do�x:Y^_T_�WIep\hQHW']IY�W*cqRTepRTcVWI_�k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_�gHjHZb\HY[e�z�jpeH\HY[ZqW�QXWI_{m�WcqRTe�jpa4Ytm�`IZ2a4QHYySicVWI_d_TY[S�a�S4W,cVUH_dYnSiRd�[YyWIeH\��bjHS�a�`']IY[Z�WFcqRTe�jpaiYtm�`�Z2a4QpYE_TWIZifIY[Sba�SiWIcqUH_TY,r

� ��� P Z<bgXjF � J�D@HGZ��id ��� � J�Dj^�J�bTc � � XYF�bTLjEGZgbTL �P�QHY�ZiY^SijH_{a4S�m�Zi`�c `�jHZ�©)`�e�a4Y � WIZb_T`yYlv-U�Y[ZiRdcVY^e�a4S�WIZiY�jHe�jHSbjXWI_d_do�k^_TYuW,Z�k^jpaur �~Y�UHZbY^m�Y[Z�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiSgXWISbY[\�`Ie��R��<a4QHY�SiRTcqUH_dY[SbaO`�g��bY[k^aiRd]IY�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�eHS:�cq`�cVY^e�a4SCa4QXW,a�c�jH_{a4RdUH_do�Sba4W,a4Y�SiU�Y[k[R{�Xk:\pRd�1Y[ZiY^eHk[Y^Sg�Y^a}x�Y[Y[e7`IgHSiY^Zb]�Y^\$WIeH\LY[cqUHRTZbRTkuW,_2Y[e�a4Z�oLWIeH\¥Y&v-RdaVZ4W,aiY[S6W,eH\�W!\HY^aiY[ZbcVRdeHRTS�a4RTk�m�jHepk^a4Rd`�eh`Imta4QpYSba4W,a4Yu�lw<�RdR���a4QpY�Y^cVUHRdZiRdkuWI_paiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�eFcVW,a4ZbR{v1w�WIeH\<w-R{m�Wu],WIRT_TWIgH_dYIwJ��RTRTR��Oa4QpY�cVW,a4ZbR{vFRde�]�Y[ZbSiRd`�e�r �$QXW>aRTS�S�a4ZbRT��RTeHfyRdS�a4QXW,a�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS�x�RdaiQFaiQHY[SbY�UpZi`�U�Y[Z�a4RTY^S�eH`Ia�`�ep_do�SbY[Y[c ai`yQXWu]�Y�g1Ylaia4Y^Z�SicVWI_T_-S4WIcqUH_TY\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`IeHS[w%a4QHYloNWIZiYyWI_dSi`�a4QpYE_dYuWIS�a�k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_d_doqgHjHZb\HY[epSi`�cqYIr

P�QHY[ZbY�RTS�`�eHYEm�jHZbaiQHY[ZnW,\p],WIe�a�WIf�Y�`Im�aiQHY[SbY�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS[r�|}e.©)`Ie�aiY � WIZb_T`Vx�`�Zb�NaiQHY@k^`�cVUpjpa�W>�a4Rd`�eXWI_pgHjHZi\pY[e�WISbSi`%k[RTW,a4Y^\qx�R{a4QqY[SbaiRTcVW,a4RdeHfn`�eVZiY[U�YuW>a4Y[\VS4WIcqUH_dY[S�RTeH\pjHk[Y^S�ZbY[SiY[WIZik�QpY[ZiSn�RTepk[_Tjp\HRTeHfjHS4��a4`6S�a4Rdk��Nx�R{a4Q*ZbY[_�W>a4Rd]IY[_{o)SbRTcqUH_TYEY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRT`�eNUHZb`�gH_TY^cVS^rtP�QHY�Qp`�U1Y,w�QH`'x�Y^]�Y^Z[w�RdS�a4QHW,ata4QpY�Y[S��a4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbSEk[WIe�g�Y"jHSbY[\�Rde~Y^cVUHRdZiRdkuWI_�x�`�Zi��aiQXW,a�W,eXWI_do%�^Y[S@cq`�ZbYVk^`�cVUp_TYlv.Y^e�]-RdZi`�epcVY^e�aiS[w�Rde~`�jpZkuW,SiY�Y[e�]%RTZi`IeHcVY^e�a4S�RTe�x�QHRdk�QqaiQHY[ZbY�WIZbY�cV`IZiY�Sba4W,a4Y�],WIZiRTWIgH_dY[S���cV`�ZbY�_T`%kuW,aiRT`�epS�`�Z�cq`�ZiY�S�a�W,aiY[S�U1Y^Z_T`%kuW>a4RT`IeJ�lw-WIeH\NU1Y^ZiQXW,UHS�cV`�ZbYnjHeH��eH`'x�e�UHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[ZbS[r

P�QHY�k^`�cVUpjpa�W,aiRT`�eHWI_�gHjHZb\HY[e!WISbSi`%k[RTW,a4Y^\�x�RdaiQ�WIe�RdeHk[ZbYuWISbY�RTeNa4QHY�e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`,m�Sba�W>a4Y�],WIZbR�WIgp_TY[S\HY^U1Y^eH\HS�`�eVQp`#xLa4QHY�e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im��XZbSba�Sba4WIf�Y�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�`Im�a4QHY�\HRdSik^`�jHe�a4Y^\"k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�eFW,eH\VY^e�a4Zbo],WI_TjpY[S@RdeHk[ZbYuWISbY[S�RTe�aiQHY6e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`Im�S�a�W,aiYV],WIZiRTWIgH_dY[S[r�|}e�cq`%\HY[_dSyaiQXW,a@jHSiY6Y^cVUpRTZiRdkuWI_�aiZ4WIepSiRdaiRT`�eUHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^S�a4QHRdS:f�Zb`'x�S�WIS2\H`%Y[S�a4QHY�SiRT�^Y�`Im�aiQHYtZbY[k[jpZiZiY^e�a�k[_TWISiS^w-x�QHRdk�Q�RTe"|�r � rpcq`-\pY[_TS�a4Y^eH\HS:ai`g�Y�_TRTepYuWIZb_doyRTe�aiQHY�e�jHc�g�Y[Z�`,m1S�a�W,aiY2],WIZiRTWIgH_TY^S���SiY[Y���WI�IY^S�W,eH\V©)k � jHRTZbYIw ¨,ª�ªY= �&rB|¡mJx:Y�x�Y[ZbY�m�`IZik[Y^\a4`�jpSiY�SbaiZijHkla4jHZiWI_BaiZ4WIeHSbRdaiRT`�e*UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�a4QpY�e%jpc�g1Y^Zt`Im�Sba4W,a4Y^Stx:`IjH_T\�f�Zb`'x Y&vpU�`�eHY^e�a4R�W,_T_doNRdea4QpYEe�jHc@g1Y^Z�`,mBS�a�W,aiYy],WIZbR�WIgp_TY[S^r

P�QHYtRdeHk[ZbYuWISbY[\�k[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�eXW,_�gpjHZi\HY^e�WISiSb`-k^R�W,aiY[\"x�R{a4Q6Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4RdeHf�cq`�ZbY�UXW,Z4WIcqY^aiY[ZiS:Y[��jXWI_dSa4QpY�RTeHk^ZiY[WISiY�Rde�a4QHY@e%jpc�g1Y^Zt`Im�aiRTcqY[S�x�Y�QXWu]�Y�ai`�Y^],WI_djXW,a4YEa4QHY@`�g%�bY[kla4R{]�Y�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�e�W,an\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a�6RTe�_TWIZifIY[Zt\HRdcVY^eHSiRd`�eXWI_OSiY[WIZik�QpY[Sya4RTcqY[S�a4QHY�k^`�cVUpjpa�W,aiRT`�eHWI_�gpjHZi\HY^e�`,m�\p`�RTeHf�Y[WIk�Q.Y^],WI_TjHW,a4Rd`�e�r�$QHY^e6x:YnjHSbY�a4QpYteHY[S�a4Y^\��-vpY^\�U1`IRTe�a�WI_df�`�ZbRda4Qpc)w�Y[WIk�Q6a4RdcVY�x:Y�Y^],WI_TjHW,a4Y�a4QHYt`Ig%�bY[kla4Rd]IY�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�ex�Y*eHY[Y^\�a4`�k^`�cqUHjpa4Y�W��pv-Y[\7U�`�Rde�a[w2x�QHRT_dY�W,_T_�x:Y�eHY[Y^\�a4`�\H`�x�Rda4QLa4QHY*cVW,aiZiR{v RTe�]�Y^ZiSiRd`�e�RdSc�jH_{a4RdUH_doVW���eH`'x�e�RTe�]IY[ZiSbYEaiRTcqY[S�W���eH`'x�e)m�jHepk^a4Rd`�e�`ImOa4QHYyUXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^ZiS^r

��_d_�aiQHRTS�g1`%\HY[S�x:Y^_T_Jm�`�Z�m�jpaijHZiY�Y[cqUHRTZbRTk[WI_JZiY[SbYuWIZbk�QNWIS:R{a2RTcqUH_dRTY[S�aiQXW,a2aiQHY�Yl�<Y^k^aiRd]�Yn_dRTcqRda4W,a4Rd`�e`�e�WIeHWI_do%�[RdeHf�Y^e�aiZbo6WIeH\�Ylv-R{a2m�Y[Y^S�SiQH`�jp_T\6eH`'x g1Y�c�jHk�Q�cV`IZiY�k^_T`�SbY[_{o6WISbSi`%k[RTW,a4Y^\6x�Rda4QVx�QXW,a�a4QpY\XW,a4Wqk[WIe�SbjHUHU�`�Zba�a4QHWIeNx�QHW,a�k[WIe�g�YEk[`�cqUHjpaiY[\�r �`'x:Yl]�Y^Z[w1aiQHY[ZbY@RdS�W>a�_dYuWIS�a�`�eHYEcV`�ZbYnRTSbSijHYE`ImRTcqU�`�Zba4WIeHk[Y�a4`FY[cqUHRTZbRTk[WI_1x�`�Zi�Jw�WIeH\�R{a�c"Wuo"x�Y[_d_�g1Yycq`�ZiYnRdcVU�`�Z�a�WIe�aur

|}e!Y[cqUHRTZbRTkuW,_Cx�`�Zb�)x�YFa}o%UHRdkuWI_d_do�x�`�ZiZ�o�WIg�`�jpataiQHY�SbU1Y^k[Rd�HkuW,aiRT`�e�`Im�aiQHY�cV`%\HY^_�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[\!W,Sc�jHk�Q�WIS�WIg�`�jpa�\HRTS�a4ZbRTgHjpaiRT`�eHWI_<`�Z�k^`�cVUpjpa�W,aiRT`�eHWI_<UHZb`�U�Y[ZbaiRTY^S�k^`�eH\HR{a4Rd`�eXWI_�`IeNaiQHY�k�Qp`�SiY^e�cq`-\HY^_¸rP�QHY�_TRdf�Q�a�k[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�eXW,_-gHjpZi\HY^eV`Im�a4QpY�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS�UHZbY[SbY[e�a4Y^\6QHY[ZbY�SiQH`�jp_T\�mWIk[Rd_TR{a�W,aiY�Zb`�gHjHS�a4eHY^SiSWIeXW,_do%SiRdS�x�Rda4QEZiY^SiU�Y[kla�ai`�cVWIe�oyWISbU1Y^k^a4SO`Im-`�jHZCcq`-\HY^_ ��S�SiU�Y[k^Rd�Xk[W,a4Rd`�eV��a4QpY�RdcVU�`�Zba4WIeHk^Y�`ImH\pRd�1Y[ZiY^e�a

D �

Page 38: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\ S�a�W,aiYV],WIZbR�WIgH_dY[S^wCaiQHY"e�jHc@g1Y^Z�`Im2_T`%kuW,aiRT`�eHSnepY[Y[\pY[\�w�Yla4ku�lr �`'x�Y^]�Y^Z[w�WISEeH`IaiY[\�YuWIZb_TRTY^Z[wa4QpY[ZiYFRdSyW,ay_TY[WISbay`�epYVW,SiU�Y[k^aE`Im�a4QpYqSbU1Y^k[R{�XkuW,aiRT`�e<w�a4QHYFU�`�SiSbRTgH_dY�UHZiY^SiY[epk[Y"`,m:SbY[ZiRTWI_T_{oNk[`�ZbZiY[_TW,a4Y^\jHeH`IgHSiY^Zb]�Y^\ Sba4W,a4YF],WIZiRTWIgH_TY^S[w�a4QHW,aya4QHYqY[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiSnUHZbY[SbY[e�a4Y^\ QHY[ZbY"kuW,e�eH`,a�WIk^k[`�cqcq`-\XW>a4YIr ��YeH`IaiY[\"WIg1`']IY�a4QHW,a:SbRTeHk^Y�`IjHZ�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S�`,m�Y[e�a4Z�oVWIeH\"k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�eq],WI_djHY[S�WIZbY�W,UHUHZi`uv-RTcVW,aiRT`�eHS�ai`a4QpYnWu]�Y[ZiWIf�YnY^e�aiZbo6WIeH\�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�eV]IW,_TjHY^S2WIkla4jXWI_d_doqYuW,ZieHY^\�wpa4QpY[ZiY�x2WIS�Sb`�cqY�ZiY[WISi`Ie�ai`�g�Y[_TRdY^]IYa4QHW,a6UHZb`']-Rd\HY[\7RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a4S�WIep\7U1`IaiY[e�a4RTWI_�Y[e�a4ZiWIe�a4S6x�Y[ZbY�eH`Ia6S�o%Sba4Y^c"W>a4RTk[WI_T_{o3gHR�W,SiY[\7RdeLaiQHY[RdZY^],WI_djXW,aiRT`�eHS^w�`�jHZ:Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS:`Im�Y[e�a4Z�o�WIeH\"Ylv-Rda:k[`�S�a4S2SbQH`�jH_d\6eH`Ia:g1Y�a4`%`@mWIZ�`I�)aiQHYtcVWIZi��Yl]�Y^eNR{ma4QpY[ZiYnx:WIS�WFcqRTSbSiU�Y[k^Rd�Xk[W,a4Rd`�e�`ImOa4QHRdS�Si`�Z�aur

P�`�RT_T_djHSbaiZ4W,aiY�x:Y�k[`�epk[_Tjp\HY�x�R{a4Q@Wt©)`�e�aiY � WIZb_T`�RTe�]�Y^Sba4Rdf�W,aiRT`�eE`ImHaiQHY�SbY[eHSbRdaiRd]%Rda}oy`Impa4QHY�UXWIZ4W,cF�Y^aiY[Z�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S�a4`Fa4QHYEUHZbY[SiY^eHk[Y�`Im�SbY[ZbR�WI_d_doVk[`�ZbZiY[_TW,a4Y^\)jpeH`�gHSbY[Zb]IY[\�S�a�W,aiYE],WIZbR�WIgH_dY[S^r ��YEUHZi`%k[Y^Y[\WIS@m�`I_T_T`'x�S^r�sBRTZbSba�x:Y�k^`�cVUpjpa4Y"aiQHY6Y^�%jpRT_TRdgHZiRdjHc®`Im�W*cq`-\pY[_�a4QXW,a@QXWIS�m�`�jpZ@SiY^ZiRTWI_T_{o!k[`�ZbZiY[_TW,a4Y^\Sba4W,a4Y�],WIZbR�WIgH_dY[S^r ��Y�a4QHY^eLjHSbY�a4QHY�Y^�%jpRT_TRdgHZiRdjHc U1`I_TRTk^RTY^S@a4`�SbRTc�jH_TW,a4Y"\XW,a�W*m�Zb`�c RdeH\HjHS�a4ZiRdY[S�Rdex�QHRdk�QVa4QpY[SiY�m�`�jHZ�Sba4W,a4Y�],WIZiRTWIgH_TY^S�\HY^aiY[ZicqRTepY[\"g�Y[QHW']%Rd`�Z[r ��Y�a4QHY^e �bUHZbY^a4Y^eH\��Ea4QXW,a�a4QpRTS�\XW,a4WEx:WISf�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4Y^\�m�Zi`�c W�cq`-\pY[_�x�Rda4Q~`�eH_do!aiQHZiY^Y6Sba4W,a4Yq]IW,ZiR�W,gH_TY^S[w�WIep\�jHSiY"`�jHZ@Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZbS�WISbSijHcqRTepfa4QHW,a�a4QHY `^ � � �! � ^ ! $"a4QpZiY[YESba4W,a4Yn],WIZbR�WIgH_dY�cq`-\pY[_�f�Y^eHY[ZiW,a4Y^\)aiQHRTS�\XW>a�Wpr

P�QHYy\HY^a4WIRT_dS�WIZbYyWIS�m�`�_T_d`#x�S^r�P�QHYyY[��jHRd_TRdgHZiRdjHc cV`%\HY[_1RTS�`�jpZ2a}x:`F_T`%kuW>a4RT`Ie6cV`%\HY^_<Ylv-k^Y[Upa�a4QXW>aeH`'x¥x�Y�WISiSbjHcVY�aiQXW,a�a4QpY�x�Qp`�_TY�\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�e�`Im1Y[e�a4Z�oFWIeH\qYlv-Rda�m�Y^Y[S�RTS�SbQHRdm�aiY[\FjHUVWIeH\q\H`'x�eV`']�Y^Za4RdcVY�x�Rda4Q�_d`-k[WI_<cVWIZi�,Y^a�k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeHS2a4QXW>a�a4QHYnY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�Z2\p`-Y^S�ep`Ia�k[`�e�aiZi`�_�m�`�Z^r�|}e�UXWIZbaiRTk^jH_�WIZ^w-x�YWISbSijHcqYna4QXW,a:a4QHYy\HRdSba4ZbRTgHj-a4RT`IeHS2`ImOY[e�aiZbo�WIep\)Y&vpR{a�m�Y[Y^S�W,ZiYnSijpg%�bY[kla4Y[\Na4`qW�SiRdc�jH_{a�WIeHY^`�jHS�SbY[ZiRTWI_T_{ok[`IZiZiY^_�W,aiY[\ SbQH`-k��.x�QHRTk�Q�a4WI�IY^S�`�e�a4QpZiY[Y6],WI_djHY[S^z"W)U1`�SbRdaiRd]�Y*�eHY^f�W,aiRd]�Yu��SiQp`-k��~x�QpRTk�Q RTepk[ZiY[WISiY^S�\pY[k[ZbYuWISbY[S4�Vg1`,a4QhY[e�a4Z�o¥W,eH\¥Y&vpR{aVm�Y^Y[Sqg�o ¨I��� w2WIeH\L�[Y^Zi`Hr7P�QHYNU�`�SiR{a4Rd]IY���eHY[f�W,a4R{]�Y'��SbQH`-k��3RdSm�`�_d_T`'x:Y^\�g�o�a4QpY6S4WIcqY"],WI_djHY"x�RdaiQ UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o3r §�� WIep\ ZiY^aijHZiepSFai`*�[Y^Zi`�x�RdaiQ UHZi`IgXWIgHRd_TRda}o3r ¨�� wx�QHRd_TY�W�],WI_TjHY�`Im��^Y[Zb`�RTS�m�`�_T_d`#x�Y[\Vg�o"W��[Y[Zb`@x�RdaiQ6UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a}o�r � WIeH\6cq`']�Y^S:a4`�YuWIk�Q�`Im�aiQHY�`,a4QHY^Z],WI_TjpY[S2x�RdaiQ)UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda}oNr ¨I� r

|}e~a4QpRTS@SbU1Y^k[R{�XkuW,aiRT`�e.a4QHYVU1`ISiSiRdgH_TYF],WI_TjpY[SE`Im�a4QHYVSiQH`%k���S�QXWu]�Y"_�WIZbf�YVRdcVUHWIk^aiSE`Ie�Y[e�a4Z�o�W,eH\Ylv-R{a2g�Y[QXWu]%RT`�Z^r�� U�`�SiR{a4R{]�Y�SiQH`%k��Vo%RTY^_T\HS�Ylv-R{a2Z4W>a4Y[S�x�QHRTk�Q�RdeHk[ZbYuWISbY�g�o6W,g1`�j-a � ª�� Rde"`�eHY�c"WIZb�IYlaWIeH\ �Iª�� RTeNa4QHY�`Ia4QHY^Z[w<WIeH\*f�`IRTeHfFm�Zi`�c WqU1`�SbRdaiRd]�Yya4`6WVeHY^f�W,a4R{]�Y�SiQH`%k���\H`IjHgH_TY^S�aiQHY@Y&vpR{atZiW,a4Y^SWIeH\!k^jpa4StaiQHY�Y[e�a4Z�o*ZiW,a4Y�ai` = � � a4` = � � `Im�RdaiSt`�ZbRTf�RdeXWI_C]IW,_TjHY,rEP�QpYVWu]IY[Z4W,f�Y�],WI_TjHY@`Im�a4QHY�SbQH`-k��RTS��[Y^Zi`Hw�Qp`#x�Y^]IY[Z^wOSb`6x:Y�k[WIe�RTe�aiY[ZiUpZiY^a�x�QXW,ataiQHY�cqRTSiSbU1Y^k[R{�XY[\*cq`%\HY[_�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^StWIS�a4QHY�Wu]IY[Z4W,f�Y],WI_TjpYn`Im�aiQHYyY[e�a4Z�oNWIeH\�Ylv-R{a�m�Y^Y[S^r

PBW,gH_TY � UHZiY^SiY^e�aiS�aiQHY�ZiY[SbjH_daiS�m�Zi`�c �pm�a}o�ZiY^U1Yla4RdaiRT`�epS�`Im1aiQHY�Y[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�Z�`�eVWt]�Y[Z�oF_�WIZbf�Y�S4W,cVUH_dYIrP�QHYlo¥W,ZiY�SbaiZiRT��RdeHfHz6a4QpY)SbY[ZiRTWI_T_{o~k^`�ZiZbY[_TW,a4Y^\LjHep`�gHSiY^Zb]IY[\7Sba4W,a4Y�],WIZbR�WIgH_dY�ZiY^SijH_{a4SFRTeLWISbo%cqUpa4`,a4RTkgHRTWISiY^SnRTe�a4QHY�UHWIZ4WIcqY^aiY[ZnY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4Y[S�`Im2W>aycV`�S�an`�eHYF`�Z�a}x:`NU1Y^Znk[Y^e�a[r�P�QHY[ZbYVRdStSi`IcVY�Rde�aijHRdaiRT`�em�`�Z�a4QHRdS�ZiY^SijH_{aurt|¡atRTS�k^_TY[WIZ�aiQXW,atR{m�a4QpY�k[`�e�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e�],WI_djHY[S�x:Y^ZiY�`�g-a�WIRdeHY[\�W,S�a4QHY@Wu]�Y[ZiWIf�Y�`']�Y^ZZiY[WI_TRd�[Y^\�SiWIcVUp_TYqUXW,a4QpS�`Im:a4QHYq\HRTSbk[`�jpe�aiY[\�],WI_djHYF`Im�ZiYla4jHZbeHS�m�`IZEk^`�e�a4Rde%jpRTeHf)k[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eXWI_B`�e~a4QpYa4QpZiY[Y"Sba�W>a4Y[SN��R¸r�YIr)`�e `�jHZ �b`�gHSbY[Zb]IY[\��!S�a�W,aiY[S��EY^]�Y^ehaiQHY6cqRTSbSiU�Y[k[R{�XY[\~cV`%\HY[_�x�`�jH_T\~UHZi`%\HjHk^Y�W��aiZijHY9�FW']IY[ZiWIf�Yt`Im�aiQHYtk^`�e�a4RTe�jXW>a4RT`Ie"],WI_TjHY^S[r��Y[ZiY�x:YyWIZbY�\HYl�XeHRdeHf�a4QHY�a4ZijpYnWu]�Y[ZiWIf�Ynk^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeXWI_`�eFa4QHY�`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\"Sba�W>a4Y[S�a4`Eg1Y�aiQHY�aiZijHY�],WI_TjpY�k[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eXWI_p`�eVaiQHY�m�`�jHZ�Sba4W,a4Y^Sn�`IeqaiQHY�jpeH`�gHSbY[Zb]IY[\

D §

Page 39: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

WIS�x:Y^_T_�WIS�a4QHY�`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\"Sba�W>a4Y'��Wu]�Y^Z4WIf�Y^\6`']�Y^Z�a4QpY�_dRTcqRda4RdeHf�\pRTSbaiZiRdgHjpa4Rd`�eF`Im<aiQHY�jHeH`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\�S�a�W,aiYk[`IeH\HRdaiRT`�eHWI_<`�e�aiQHYy`�gHSiY^Zb]IY[\*S�a�W,aiY[S[r

�~YVSbaiRT_T_ wCQH`'x:Yl]�Y[Z^w�SiQH`IjH_T\�eH`Ia�Y&v-U1Y^k^a@ai`�f�Yla�k^`�eHSiRdSbaiY[e�a�UXW,Z4WIcqY^aiY[ZEY[SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^S[r �$QXW>a@a4QpY�cqRTSbSiU�Y[k^Rd�XY^\J�q`�g��bY[k^aiRd]IY�m�jHeHkla4RT`Ie¥�Ha4S"RTSFa4QHY�Wu]IY[Z4W,f�Y�m�Z4W,k^a4Rd`�e¥`,myYlv-Rdai`�ZiSqm�Zi`�c a4QpY*`�gHSbY[Zb]IY[\Sba4W,a4Y^S�ai`)a4QpYVUHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a}o*`Im2`�gpa�W,RTeHRdeHfNWIe~Y&vpR{aym�Y[Y"fIZiYuW>a4Y[Zya4QHWIe~`�jpZ�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4YF`Im2aiQHY"Wu]IY[Z4W,f�Yk[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�ey],WI_TjpY�m�Zb`�c¯aiQH`�SiY�Sba4W,a4Y^S[rB|}eEmWIk^aOa4QpY:Wu]�Y^Z4WIfIY:UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a}o�`ImHYlv-RdaCm�Zi`Ic a4QHY�`�gHSbY[Zb]IY[\Sba4W,a4Y^SCRTSCWIeEWu]�Y^Z4WIf�Y�`']�Y^Z�a4QHY�Wu]�Y^Z4WIf�Y�UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a}o�`ImpY&v-Rda�m�Zb`�c aiQHY�jHeH`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\�Sba4W,a4Y^S�k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeXWI_`�e3a4QHYN`�gHSbY[Z�]�Y[\¥Sba�W>a4Y[S^r$«-RdeHk[Y�a4QpY)UHZb`�gXWIgpRT_TR{a}o~`,mtYlv-R{aVRdSFRda4SbY[_{mtW!eH`�eH_dRTeHY[WIZ�m�jHeHkla4Rd`�eL`,m�a4QpYk[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�e6],WI_djHYtk^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeXWI_�`�e�a4QHYnjHep`�gHSiY^Zb]IY[\�S�a�W,aiY[S^wHx�QHY[e�x:YyWu]IY[Z4W,f�Yy`#]IY[Z�Rda:x:Yn\H`FeH`,af�Ylata4QHY�UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda}oN`Im�a4QHY@Ylv-Rdanm�Y^Y�g1Y^RTeHf6fIZiYuW>a4Y[ZtaiQXWIe*aiQHYFWu]�Y[ZiWIf�Y�k^`�e�a4RTe�jXW>a4RT`Ie*]IW,_TjHY,rE��SyWZiY^SijH_{ayY^]IY[e.Rdm�x:YF\H`�QXWu]IYFaiQHY ��aiZijHY9�)Wu]IY[Z4W,f�YFk[`�e�a4Rde�jXW,a4Rd`�e*],WI_TjpY[S[w�aiQHY�cq`-\HY^_BSbQH`�jH_d\.\pY[_TR{]�Y^ZRTepk[`�eHSbRTS�a4Y[e�aqUXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^Z�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[S[r ��UHUXWIZbY[e�a4_{o�w�QH`'x:Yl]�Y^Z[w2x�RdaiQ3`�jHZ�SiU�Y[k^Rd�Xk[W,a4Rd`�e a4QHY�Y&v-aiY[e�a`Im�a4QHY)WISbo%cqUpa4`,a4RTk�gHRTWISFRTe a4QpY)cqRTSbSiU�Y[k[R{�XY[\LY[S�a4RTcVW,ai`�ZiS�RdSqSbc"W,_T_y�WIeH\Lx�YNQXWu]�Y)aiZiRdY[\hSiY^]IY[ZiWI_cq`�ZiY�ZijpeHSqaiQXWIeha4QH`�SbY)ZbY[U�`�ZbaiY[\LRTe3a�WIgH_dY � WI_{x2Wuo%Sqf�Y^aba4RTepf.aiQHRTSFS4W,cVY�ZiY^SijH_{a&�&r �~YN_TY[Wu]�Y)WIeRTe�]IY[SbaiRTf�W>a4RT`Ie"`Im�x�Q�o"aiQHRTS�RTS�a4QHYtk[WISiY�RTe6`�jpZ:YlvpWIcqUH_dYIwHW,eH\"x�QHY^eNR{a:RdS:_dRT�IY^_doFa4`@g1Y�a4ZijpYtRTe6`,a4QHY^ZYlvpWIcqUH_dY[S[wHm�`IZ2m�jpa4jHZbYyZiY[SbYuWIZbk�Q�r

� � ��-�(�����������-��K�P�QHRdS�UHWIU1Y^Z�UHZi`']%RT\pY[\NY[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZiS:m�`�Z2aiQHYyUXWIZiWIcVYla4Y^ZiS�`Im�\HRTSbk[ZbY^a4Yy\po%eXW,cVRdktf�WIcqY[S2aiQXW,a�WIZiYnY[WISboa4`�jHSiY,w-W,eH\�a4QHY^e�YlvpWIcqRTeHY^\@a4QpY[RTZBUHZi`�U�Y[Z�a4RdY[S[r�P�QHY�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiSOZiY^_do�`�eFWISbSijHcqUpa4Rd`�eHSOx�QHRTk�QFRTepSijHZbYa4QHW,a2a4QpY[ZiYyRdS�W�jHeHRT��jHYnY^��jHRT_dRTgHZbRTjHc WISbSi`%k[RTW,a4Y^\�x�R{a4Q6aiQHYnf�Rd]IY[e�\XW,a4W�f�Y[eHY^Z4W,aiRTeHf�UpZi`%k[Y[SbS[r � Rd]�Y^ea4Qp`�SiYnW,SiSijpcVUpaiRT`�epS[w%Rda�RTS:SbQH`'x�e6a4QXW>a2`�eHY�kuWIe�`Igpa�WIRde"k^`�eHSiRdSbaiY[e�a�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S�`Im�Y[e�aiZbo"WIeH\�k[`Ie�aiRTe-�jXW,aiRT`�eF],WI_TjpY[S�g�oVSbRTcqUH_do�WIk[k^jHc�jH_TW,a4RdeHfya4QHY�\HRTSbk[`�jpe�aiY[\"],WI_djHY�`Im�epY^a�ZiY^aijHZiepS �����?���������C ��AB"# $Fg�oa4QpY:Y[e�aiZ4WIe�a4SOx�QH`tY^e�aiY[ZbY[\FW,a�UXWIZ�a4RTk^jH_�W,ZOS�a�W,aiY[S^w�WIeH\Ea4QHY�\HRTSbk[`�jHe�aiY[\@],WI_djHY�`,mXeHY^a�ZiYla4jHZbeHS �����?��������� ��AB"# $�g�o~RdeHk[jpc�g1Y^e�a4S@x�QH`�k[`�e�a4Rde�jHY[\�m�Zb`�c®a4QH`�SbY"S�a�W,aiY[S[r�|¡m�a4QHYVk[`�eH\pRda4Rd`�eXWI_�Y&v-U1Y^k^a�W>a4RT`Ie�`Ima4QpY�Y&vpR{a�m�Y[YIw�k^`�eH\HR{a4RT`IeXWI_H`�eFa4QpY�Y&vpR{a�m�Y[Y�g1Y^RTeHfyf�ZbYuW,aiY[Z�a4QXW,eVa4QpY�k^`�e�a4Rde%jHW,a4Rd`�eq],WI_djHYIw�RdS�_TRTepYuWIZ�Rdea4QpY�k[`Ie�aiRTe�jXW,aiRT`�eq],WI_TjHY@� W,S:Rda�RTS�RTeqa4QHY�Ylv-U1`IeHY[e�a4RTWI_�kuWISbY'�lw%a4QHY^e6a4QHY^SiYt\pRTSik^`�jHe�a4Y^\6],WI_TjHY^S:k[WIe6g�Yk[`IeHSiRdSba4Y^e�a4_do�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[\�jHU�ai`nWtUXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^Z�ai`ng1Y2Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4Y^\@m�Zi`�c W�cVW,a4ZbR{v�RTe�]IY[ZiSbRT`�e�x�QpRTk�Q�eHY^Y[\`�eH_{o�g�Y�\H`IeHY�`�eHk^YFW,ata4QpY�g1Y^f�RTepeHRTeHf"`Im�a4QHY�Y^Sba4Rdc"W>a4RT`Ie�Zijpeh� W6ZiY^SijH_{atx�QHRdk�Q.\p`-Y^SneH`Ian\HY^U1Y^eH\`�e�aiQHY�\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�e�`Im�Y^e�a4Zbo)k[`ISba4S4�lryP�QHRdS�cVWI�IY^S�a4QHY@k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_CgHjHZb\HY[e!`Im�aiQHY@Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�ZSiRdcVRd_�WIZ�a4`�a4QpYqgpjHZi\HY^e~`Im�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,aiRTeHf�W�c�jp_da4RdeH`�cqR�WI_Ccq`-\pY[_�Rde.UpZi`�gXW,gHRT_dRda4RdY[S�x�QHRTk�Q�WIZiYF��eH`'x�em�jHeHkla4Rd`�eHS�`Im�aiQHY6\XW>a�Wpr�sX`�Z�ZiRdk�QHY[Z�\HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�eHS�`Im�Ylv-R{a@m�Y[Y^S�`�jHZ�Y[SbaiRTcVW,a4`IZ�RdS�W*eHY^Sba4Y^\ �pv-Y[\U�`�RTe�a�Y^SbaiRTcVW,a4`�Z^wBgHj-a�a4QHYV�pv-Y[\ U�`�RTe�a�RdS�W�k^`�e�a4ZiWIk^aiRT`�e�cVWIUHUpRTeHf�WIeH\ eHY^Y[\3eH`Ia@g1Y6k^`�cqUHjpa4Y^\x�QHY^e)x�Yy],WIZ�o6a4QpYEY^e�a4Zbo�m�Y^Yy\HRTS�a4ZiRdgHjpaiRT`�e�r

� R{]�Y^e�a4QHY^SiY�RT\pYuWIS^w�W�e%jpc�g1Y^Z6`ImEWI_{a4Y^ZieXW,aiRd]IY�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiSFm�`�ZV`�jHZ6SbY[cqR{�}UHWIZ4WIcqY^aiZiRdkNcq`%\HY[_Sijpf�f�Y[S�a4Y^\�a4QHY^cVSbY[_d]IY[S^r)� a4QHY^`�ZiYla4RTk[WI_�\HRTSbk[jHSbSiRd`�e~SbQH`'x:Y^\3aiQXW,aEa4QHYqmWIk^aEa4QHW,a�aiQHY"c@jH_daiRTeH`�cqR�W,_

D ¦

Page 40: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

UHZb`�gXWIgHRd_TR{a4RTY^S@a4QHW,a"fI`~RTe�ai`.aiQHY)],WIZbRT`�jHSq`�g%�bY^k^aiRd]�YNm�jHeHkla4RT`IeHSVg�Y[RdeHf.cVRdeHRTcqRT�^Y[\ RTeha4QHY)Y[S�a4RTcVW>�a4Rd`�e�WI_df�`�ZbRda4QpcVS�WIZiY�eH`Ia���eH`'x�e�m�jHeHkla4RT`IeHS2`ImCa4QpYt\XW,a4W�WIeH\�UXWIZiWIcqY^a4Y^Z:]�Y^k^ai`�Z[wXgHj-a�Z4W,aiQHY[Z:SiY[cqR{�UXWIZiWIcqY^a4ZbRTk�Y[S�a4RTcVW,aiY[SO`ImXa4QH`ISiY�m�jpeHk^aiRT`�eHS^w�W,�1Y[kla4S�aiQHY2\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�eHSC`ImXa4QpY2WI_{a4Y[ZbeXW,aiRd]�Y�Y[S�a4Rdc"W,ai`�ZiSRTe�\HRd�1Y[ZbY[e�a�x:Wuo-S^r�©)`�ZbY[`']�Y^Z[w�a4QpY:k[`IcVUHj-a�W,aiRT`�eXW,_%gpjHZi\HY^eHS�`ImXaiQHY2W,_da4Y^ZieXW>a4Rd]IY[SBWI_TSb`�],WIZiRdY[\���Si`�cqYl�a4RdcVY^S�c"W,Zi�IY^\H_dop�&r���S�WyZiY[SbjH_da[w-©)`�e�a4Y � WIZb_T`yYlvpWIcqUH_TY^S�x:Y^ZiY�\HY[SbRTf�eHY^\Vai`EUpjHSiQqa4QHY�RTe�]IY[SbaiRTf�W>a4RT`Ie`ImOa4QHYyk^`�cVUpjpa�W,aiRT`�eHWI_�WIep\)\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�eXWI_�UHZi`IU1Y^Zba4RdY[S�`ImOa4QHYyY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS:m�jHZbaiQHY[Z^r

P�QHYNZiY[SbjH_daiS�m�Zi`�c aiQHY)©)`�e�a4Y � WIZb_T`!YlvpWIcqUH_TY^SFSiQH`'x�Y[\LaiQXW,aFa4QpYNSbRTcqUH_TY^SbaFY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbSFWI_TSb`a4Y^eH\HY^\�ai`�QXWu]�YtaiQHYnUHZiYlm�Y[ZbZiY[\�\HRdSbaiZiRTgpjpa4Rd`�eHS[r�©)`�ZbY[`']�Y^Z[wHa4Qp`�SiYnY^Sba4Rdc"W>a4`�ZbS:U�Y[Zbm�`IZicqY[\���jHRdaiY�x�Y[_T_RTeFZbYuWISb`�eXWIgH_{o�SiRd�[Y^\VSiWIcVUp_TY[S^w%WIeH\qQXWI\qcVRdeHRTcVWI_%k[`�cqUHjpa4W,a4Rd`�eXWI_-gHjHZi\pY[eHS^r�P�QHY�Qp`�U1Y�RdS�aiQXW,a�eH`'xa4QpYVYl�<Y^k^a4R{]�Y6gHWIZiZbRTY[Znai`NaiQHY"Y^cVUHRdZiRdkuWI_�W,eXWI_do%SbRTSy`Im2aiQHY[SbY"UHZb`�gH_TY^cVSyk[WIe�g�YVSbQHRdm�aiY[\�m�Zb`�c®g�Y[RTepfa4QpYqk^`�cqUHjpa�W>a4RT`IeXWI_BgpjHZi\HY^e�`,m:`�g-a�WIRdeHRTeHfVa4QHYFY[S�a4Rdc"W,aiY[S^w�a4`�a4QHYFZbRTk�QHeHY^SiSE`Im�a4QHY�\XW>a�W�Wu]IW,RT_�W,gH_TYa4`FSbjHUHU�`�Zba�a4QpY�W,eXWI_do%SbRTS[r

� F �F�D[F�bTQfFML �Ó ¼|½¤£·ªGªG©«¼|¨�µÕ£·ª²£±¨�Ã��)Ì�¨r¯¤°���Ì���£±ª²¨����� � �������Ü°�©�¯�³G£·É2¬«¨�³G£±­|¯)¨r¯¤°���¥G³G£±¸»¨�³G£·­|¯]­rº��g¾Â¯¤¨r¸�£±¬��Æ£±¥G¬®ª²©«³�©��ƨr¸"©�¥���Ã� �!�#"�$#% ­|¥�­|¯´Ò<¯¤£±Ïr©«ª²¥G£·³�¾rÌ% ¨�&�¨�ªÍ£�Ã'��Ì·Ã)(MÌ % ©�¯+*¨�ªÍ°[ÃÕ¨r¯¤°-,�Ì'(@©«Ï�£±¯.���� � ���/�0��¥�³G£±¸�¨�³G£±¯�¼1�g¾�¯¤¨r¸»£±¬��$­�°�©�¶±¥<­rº2�ȸ"§j©«ªGºÖ©�¬®³43*­|¸"§j©«³G£òdzG£·­|¯5��à ���6�#"7$ Ã)8³G¨r¯�ºÄ­rª²°9�:8 % Ì% ©«ªGªG¾rÃ;8YÌ<��=?>�>�� �����0��¥�³G£¦¸»¨�³G£·­|¯ ­rº�¨@��­�°�©�¶Y­rº��>¯t³�ªG¾ £±¯ ³G¢�© Ó £±ª²¶±£±¯�©/�ܯ2°¤½¤¥�³�ªG¾A��Ã�BDC $�E;$��#"GFIHJ� C�K�äÏr­|¶�ÌML��ï�­�ÌON�Ã2§¤§@ÌOP�P�>3ÇQ>A=SR�Ì% ©«ªGªG¾rÃT8Y̨r¯¤° Ó Ì��O¨�*r©�¥D���� � �����0�>¥�³G£±¸»¨�³G£±­|¯�U�ª²­|¸Ô³G¢�©VUO£·ªÍ¥�³XWgªÍ°�©«ªX3*­|¯2°¤£·³G£·­|¯¤¥SºÖ­rªX�g¾Â¯2¨r¸»£±¬Y3*­|¯t³�ª²­|¶±¥7�� �!�#"�$ Ã;�g©«§2¨�ªG³G¸»©�¯t³�­rº2�>¬®­|¯�­|¸»£±¬«¥«Ã5Z\[�]GÏ�[�]�^_[�`5^ba�[�ced�f\`5geh�dG]�i7gkj7ged?iGl% ]7d?i7`5[�m�[�`onqp:lq[�`5^r��lAsDd?gki7it��=?>�P R����M�0�\uv��`Tj0]7wx3�u `5^5gej7geu `�iO�O[�]7w#y\z{]7u i7iD�9[�]7*�dGj7i7�#| H0$?$~}~�!ET���/� K�� "GH��$�E BDC $�E;$�� � C��/C FI�6�S�IFI������� C H�$�" C $�E;$�� � C � � E�E5� K���nk=�n;�5�<l�P������QP�P��ql% ]7d?i7`5[�m�[�`on�pDgk�@u�j7m�wb[�`5^_��dGj0dG]4sDd?g�i7i���=?>�>A=S���@�0��`Tj0]7wb[�`5^-3Vu �v�)dGj7gej7geu `_g�`93Vu `5z{d?`Tj0]�[�j0d?^-��[�]7*�dGj7i��An� $��AH�E K�� $��\��$ � �6FI� C�K��)BDC $�E;$�� � n�h�u clM>�>qn;`+u+lM�qlO�5��l�> R�RS��=G� >ql�\u�]�[�i0�Gd?cki7*qgnof�lo[�`5^���l�8A[�j0j0dG]7j7mT�V[�gkj0d����� � ���/�0U+u �5`�^5[�j7geu `5itu��M�9[�]7*�u�h���dG]7�6d?z{j:���q�5gkckgk�5]�gk�5�_���2 +gki��j0d?`5z{d�n'���+]�gk¡�zG[�j7geu `onA[�`5^_f\`5gk�q�+d?`+d?i7i�� � �6�#"7$x¢ u�]�j7m��Vd?i0j0dG]�`9f/`5gkh�dG]�i7gejQw1[�`5^bj7m5d�Z�uquSh�dG]\��`5i0j7gej7�+j7gku `ol��g�`5[?h'nO(OlY���� � ���@� ¢ u�jvy\ckcVs�geh�[�cki�(�uTu�*£y/c�ge*�d��@��i0j7g��@[�j7gk`+¤�[�`£�M�T��gkckge�5]�gk�5�¥�_uA^+d?cVu��Dj7m+drsDd?ckd?[�i0d�t[�j0d�pDg��@gk`+¤@�t[��vd?�An ���6�#"7$ 8qj7[�`+�6u�]�^on5�\dG��[�]7j7�@d?`�j/u����Mz{u `+u �@gkzGiGl�O]�gkzGi0u `on�s/gkz�m�[�]�^_[�`5^9��[�*�d?i?n)y/]�ged?cM��=?>�>�� ���@�7��[�]7*�u�h��¦��dG]7�6d?z{j4��`5^5�5i0j0]�wx�\wA`5[��@gkzGiG�Vy§U+]�[��vdG�Vu�]7*b�6u�]���@��ge]�gkzG[�c'¨�u�]7*A�An)© "{�S�ª"{«¬$�� B�C $�E;$���� C ­ FI�5®��ª"J� n5h�u clML��qn;`+u+l�=�n5�5��l2�����QP��qlU+]7dGd?^��@[�`on���l���=?¯�P�� ��n � K H�}�$���°²± K �6E+� n'8A�5]�gk`+¤�dG]Y�2dG]�ck[�¤+n ¢ dG�³aOu�]7*'l

´Aµ

Page 41: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

Z/d?z7*A�@[�`on5,+l�[�`�^ % lTZ/u `+u�]7dv��=?¯�¯�����O�0pDm+d\���v��gk]�gkzG[�c�3Vu `Tj0d?`�jMu��oj7m+d/s�uSw#��uq^5d?ck��B�C $�E;$��@"?FIH�� C�K����P ��5�<lk=�=?�A=J�ªN�¯qlZ/u�j0��n�,+lo[�`5^-s�lo�9gkckckdG] ��=?¯�¯�� ���4��3Vu `5^�gej7geu `5[�c23�m+u gkz{dv��]7u���[���gkc�gej7ged?i�[�`�^-j7m+dv��i0j7gk�#[�j7geu `�u��M�\wq`�[��@gkz��uq^+d?c�i7�An�� ±A" © "G�S�ª"{«³$�� BDC $�E;$�� � C�­ FI�5®��ª"J� n�L�An'�5�<lO��L����QP�¯ql(�[��)u `TjGn',+l�,5len5Z�l)Wti7i7[�]�^<n���l+�O�+u `+¤9��=?¯�¯�� ���)�@�Mz{u `+u �vdGj0]�gkzGi�u��2U�gk]�i0j��¦�O]�gkz{d4y/�5z{j7gku `5i7�An'B�C $�E;$��@"?FIH�� C�K�L�� �����<l�¯������Q¯�P�Al�9[�¤ `5[�z#p4lenX[�`5^ ��l�pDm+d?i7�@[�]x���� � ������� ^5d?`�j7ge�6wAgk`+¤_�\wq`�[��@gkzv�tgki7z{]7dGj0dx�\d?zGgki7geu ` ��]7uAz{d?i7i0d?i7�An�BDC $�E;$���#"GFIHJ� C�K;�ªR~��D�5�<l�P�+=J��=?Lql�9[�i0*qg�`onT��lT[�`5^x,+l�pDgk]7u ced���=?¯�P�P ���O�0y p�m+dGu�]7w u��<�\wq`5[��#gkz/Wtckgk¤�u��'u ckw�n �2[�`5^@�7�J�AB�C $�E'$��#"GFIHJ� C�K�nAh�u cl���Lqn`+u+lM�qn��5�<lO�~N�¯��Q¯�¯ql�9[��G�GdGu+n���l����� � ��� �0�O]7uA^5�5z{j93Ym+u gkz{d [�`5^ W4ckge¤�u��)u cew �9[�]7*�dGj-8Aj0]��5z{j7�+]7d?�An�� ±A" ©YK E'® � $��AHJE K�� $��BDC $�E;$�� � C � l�8A�5�#�vdG]?nA�5�<l����A=J�ªN��ql�9�+j7mon�,+l���=?¯�LA=S���V�0s/[�j7geu `5[�c<�O q�)d?z{j7[�j7geu `5i�[�`5^bj7m+d�p�m+dGu�]7w#u��2��]�gkz{d:U+u�]7d?zG[�i7j7i7�AnoB�C $�E'$��#"GFIHJ� C�K�l8'l<WtckcedGwb[�`5^-y�l'�X[�*�d?i#��=?¯�¯�L ���\�0pDm+d �\wq`5[��#gkzGi\u����O]7uA^5�5z{j7gkhqgejQw_gk`9j7m+d�p²d?ced?z{u �@���5`5g�zG[�j7geu `5it���q�5ge�+��vd?`TjD��`5^5�5i0j0]�wq�An�BDC $�E;$��#"?FIH�� C�K�n'h�u cl�L~N+n'`+u+l�Lqn��5��l�=?��L�����=?��¯ RTl�X[�*�d?iGn y�lA��=?¯�¯~NT��� ���\wA`5[��@gkz�8qj0]��5z{j7�+]�[�cq�_uA^+d?ckiG����]7u���ced?�@i²[�`5^���]7u i0�)d?z{j7i7�An�gk` 3\l�8Ag��@iM�6d?^ol ��� ®�� K E C "J��6E B�C $�E'$��#"GFIHJ� C � ­ ��� F6±� �$�H � ®�°2$�ET� H0"{����$���F6±A" BDC $�E;$��#"GFIHJ� C�­ $ C �ª"GFI� no3�[�����]�gk^+¤�d4f\`5geh�dG]�i7gkj¦wr�O]7d?i7i?l�X[�*�d?iGn5y�lT[�`5^x��lA�9zS�t�5ge]�d�n)��=?¯�¯~NT������3�u �v���+j7gk`5¤���[�]�*�uShT�¦�²dG]��!d?z{j ¢ [�i7mx���q�5gkckgk�5]�gk[A� ¢ �5�vdG]�g�zG[�c5���v��ckg �zG[�j7geu `5i�u���[#�/wA`5[��@g�z4�\g��'dG]7d?`Tj7gk[�j0d?^9�O]7uA^5�5z{jD��uq^+d?c��An'©D������nAh�u clM���qn'`+u+l2N+n5�5�<l��������Q��P�¯ql�X[�*�d?iGn<y�l'[�`5^���l)�9zS�t�5gk]7d�nX����+=S���\��8qj0uAz�m5[�i0j7g�z�y\ce¤�u�]�gej7m��@iGn)8Awq�@�@dGj0]�gkz��9[�]7*�u�h9��dG]7�6d?z{jt�M�T��gkckge�5]�gk[[�`5^_p�m+d�� 3��+]�i7d��qu��2�tgk�vd?`�i7geu `5[�ckgkj¦wA�vB�C $�E'$��#"GFIHJ� C�K�n;�2u c²L�¯_�� ��n��5�²=?��LA=J�QPA=�l�X[�*�d?iGn�y�len�,+l?��u�]7j0dG]Sn�[�`�^�3\l?¨�u ce�6]�[�� ���� � ������3�u i0j�U5�5`�z{j7geu `5i<U+]�u � �O]�u�¡5j���[~ +gk�@gk�?[�j7geu `�3Vu `5^�gej7geu `5iG�pDm+d:�Mced?z{j0]�gkz4f/j7gkckgkj¦wr3Y[�i0d?�An � �6�@"�$ Z\[�]7h�[�]�^_f\`5geh�dG]�i�gej¦w�l��d?i0d?`5^+u�]��!dG]?n�� len�[�`5^:��l~8+z�m5�@g�^+j��¦�\d?`+¤ cedG]����� � ���²����^+d?`Tj7ge¡�zG[�j7geu `4[�`�^:��i0j7g��@[�j7geu `tu��+�\wq`5[��#gkz��t[��vd?i7�An� �!�#"�$ (�u `5^+u `98Az�m+uqu cou����Mz{u `+u �@gkzGi�[�`5^ra�[�ced�f\`5geh�dG]�i7gej¦w�ls���i0jGn:,+l���=?¯�P R�� ��W\�5j7gk�#[�c4sDdG��ck[�z{d?�@d?`�j9u��@�:��3 % ��i_��`+¤ g�`+d?iG��y\` �M�v��ge]�gkzG[�c4�_uA^+d?c4u��vZ\[�]7u ck^� �+]�z�m+dG]��An;B�C $�E'$��#"GFIHJ� C�K�n)�����I`+u+l�� ���5��l2¯�¯�¯���=G ���ql8qd?gk�_n��vl����� � ��� ���\dGu�¤�]�[���m5gkz@�tg��)dG]7d?`Tj7gk[�j7geu `�[�`5^�U�gk]��@i��'��`Tj0]7w_�\d?zGgki7geu `5i?��p�m+d��tgk^+dGuxsDdGj7[�gkc²� `�^5�5i��j0]7wA�An � �!�#"�$ n)�:8 % n;8Aj7[�`+�!u�]�^ol8qj7[�]7]Sn�y�l ¨ l�[�`5^ a l 3\l�Z�u ��=?¯�L�¯ ����� ¢ u `+�GdG]7u�� 8+�5� �tg��'dG]�d?`�j7gk[�c4�t[��vd?i��An � $��AH�E K�� $���� � FI�6����� K FI�I$�E� ±A"�$���� K E;® ��� �;� � C�K FI�$�E+� n��5�<lk=?¯�P~N��Q�� Pql

�!

Page 42: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

p�[���ced@=���Wt`+d:(<uAzG[�j7geu `ol

��geh�u�jDp�[���ced��W4U = = = = � � � ��Ms = = = = = =�tU = = = = = =

�X[�`+d?c<y���p�� =?�qn;3�� =G��An;s�� =G�Al[�� l�� Al��� Al��� Al��� Al��� Al���� Al��A= Al��A= Al��A= Al��� Al��� Al��� Al���8+� �I[�� Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al += Al � Al � Al � Al � Al �� �� R�� Al R�� Al R�� Al R�� Al R�� Al R�N Al R�� Al R�N Al R�N Al R�L Al R�� Al R�� Al R��8+� � � � Al += Al += Al += Al += Al += Al � Al += Al += Al += Al += Al += Al +=jS�6j0u�j7[�c6� ���qlk= ���ql�L P~N+l R =?��Al ��Lql�L L��ql�¯ P�¯ql�� N5=?�ql�¯ ���ql�P ��Lql�� ¯��ql N �ql N

�X[�`+d?c % ��p��:�qn;3�4����An�s�� =G�[�� l�� Al���L Al���L Al�� R Al�� R Al N5= Al�� R Al���P Al�� R Al���L Al���L Al�� R Al�� R8+� �I[�� Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al �� �� R�� Al R�R Al R�N Al R�� Al R�N Al R�N Al R~ Al R�� Al R~ =�l �N Al�PA= Al�PA= Al R�R8+� � � � Al � Al �N Al �N Al �N Al �N Al �N Al �N Al �N Al�L� Al���L Al L Al �jS�Ii7dGj7�+�'� ¯ql N ¯ql N L��ql�L L��ql�L ¯ql N ¯ql N L��ql�L L��ql�L ¯ql N ¯ql N L��ql�L L��ql�LjS�Ii7d?[�]�z�m;� Al =�l�� Alk= N5=�l�� Al�� Pql�L Al�� �����ql N Al�� ¯ql�� Lql �~N5=�l��jS�6j0u�j7[�c6� ¯ql N =GAl�¯ L��ql R =G Lql�¯ ¯ql R =?Pql L��ql�¯ ��P�¯ql ¯ql�L =?Pql R Rq=�l�L ���RTl��� � ���������T� N���� N���� N���� N���� N���� N���� N���� N���� N���� N���� N���� N�������� N�L~N N�L~N ����¯ R ����¯ R N�L~N N�L~N ����¯ R ����¯ R N�L~N N�L~N ����¯ R ����¯ R

�X[�`+d?c²3\�5p��v=?�qn'3�4����An�s�� =G�Al[�� l�� Al���� Al���� Al���� Al���� Al��~N Al���� Al���� Al���� Al��A= Al���� Al���� Al����8+� �I[�� Al += Al += Al += Al += Al � Al += Al += Al += Al += Al � Al += Al +=� �� R�� Al R�� Al R�� Al R�� Al R�N Al R�N Al R�� Al R�N Al R�� Al�P�� Al�¯A= Al R�R Al R��8+� � � � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al���L Al�P�L Al � Al �jS�Ii7dGj7�+�'� =?¯ql�� =?¯ql�� R�N R�N =?¯ql�� =?¯ql�� R�N R�N =?¯ql�� =?¯ql�� R�N R�NjS�Ii7d?[�]�z�m;� Al �ql N Alk= N��ql�� Al�¯ =?�ql�P =�l ��L��ql�� Al N =?�ql�� Lql�P � Rq=�l jS�6j0u�j7[�c6� =?¯ql�� �A=�l�L R�N+lk= =�=?Lql�� ��Alk= ���qlk= R��ql ����¯ql�� =?¯ql�L �~N+l N P�Al�P �~N��ql � � ���������T� L���¯ L���¯ L���¯ L���¯ L���¯ L���¯ L���¯ L���¯ L���¯ L���¯ L���¯ L���¯���� L���P L���P ��L�¯A= ��L�¯A= L���P L���P ��L�¯A= ��L�¯A= L���P L���P ��L�¯A= ��L�¯A=

� (<dG¤�d?`�^ol WtU��:W\�A&0d?z{j7geh�d#U��5`5z{j7geu `ol������ ��?=����! ��W4� ¡5j0j7gk`5¤_[?h�dG]�[�¤�dxd?`�j0]�w�[�`5^ d{ Agej4]�[�j0d?iGn�9(��DnV��W4� ¡5j0j7g�`+¤ i0j7[�j0d9i7�'d?zGgk¡�zxd?`�j0]7w [�`5^ d{ Agej#]�[�j0d?iGl �Ms"�t�Mi0j7gk�@[�j0d?i#u��\��]7u���[���g�ckgej7ged?iGl$#�%&���?=' d?�@��ge]�gkzG[�c)��]7u���[���gkc�gej7ged?iGn+i0j0]���z{j7�+]�[�co�5]�u���[���gkckgkj7ged?iGl2�tU��th~[�ck�5d:�6��`5z{j7geu `ol(��)�³��?=' �@[�j0]�ge gk`Th�dG]�i7geu `<n5`+d?i0j0d?^_¡5 qd?^��'u g�`�jGl � � ���������T�DgkiYj7m+d�`T�5���)dG]Yu��Oi0j7[�j0d?i/hqgki�gej0d?^on+��m5g�ced �*�� gkiDj7m+d�`q�5���)dG]Du��i0j7[�j0d?i��6u�]M�/m5gkz�m#�Mdt���5i0j�z{u �v���+j0d/�5]7u���[���g�ckgej7ged?iX��m5d?`�#�%'�§=�l,+ [�`�^.-³[�]7d\j7m+d\z{]�u i7iMi7d?z{j7geu `5[�c)[�`5^j7gk�vd:^�gk�vd?`5i7gku `5iVu��²j7m+d���[�`+d?co[�`5^/%§g�i�j7m+d�`q�5���)dG]Yu��2�vu `Tj0d�zG[�]�ceuv]�dG�'dGj7gkj7geu `5iGl

�10

Page 43: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

p�[���ced��q�MpY�Mu@(�uqzG[�j7gku `5iGn��Mi0d?�5^+u#�9(���l

��geh�u�jDp�[���ced����s = = =�\U = = = =8qj7[�]7j = =

p"� =?�qn'3�4����Al���8A�5zGz{d?i7i��@s�[�j0d�l��i0d?�5^5u �#ced ��q={N N��q={N N��q={N ��q={N N��q={N ���q={Nj0]�gk��� l���i7j7[�j0d?i L��q={N P��q={N =�=��q={N =?���q={N =G��q={N =�=��q={Nj0]�gk���v=G hqgki�gej7i ���q={N ���q={N =�=��q={N ¯��q={N ¯��q={N =?���q={N

��i0j7g��@[�j0d?iY�6]7u � % d?i0j�p²]�gk�bl[+=���l�� Al�� R Al���� Al��~N Al��� Al��� Al���i7^��I[+=S� Al � Al � Al L Al += Al += Al �[ � ��l�� Al���� Al��~N Al�� R Al���� Al��A= Al����i7^��I[ � � Al � Al �N Al �R Al � Al � Alk=�=� =�� = =�lk=SR Al�¯�L Al�P�� =�lk=�= =�lk=G =�l �R8A�v� � =S� Al���L Al���� Al��~N Al���¯ Al���¯ Al���L� � ��l�� Al��A= Al��~N Al N Al��A= Al�� R Al����8A�v� � � � Al P Alk=?� Alk=�= Al ¯ Alk=?� Alk={N

� (<dG¤�d?`�^ lM8qdGd:j7m+d��!uqu�j7`+u�j0d:j0u#p�[���ced@=�l

���

Page 44: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

p�[���ced��q��pD�Mu@(�uqzG[�j7geu `�iGl

�Mgeh�u�j�p�[���ced��WtU � � � � � � � ��Ms = = = = = =�tU = = = = = =8qj7[�]�j = = = =

p�� =?�qn;3� =G��An's"�4��Al[+=���l�� Al��� Al��� Al���¯ Al���¯ Al���¯ Al���¯ Al���¯ Al���¯ Al��A= Al��A= Al�� R Al�� R8A�v�I[+=S� Al += Al += Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Alk=�= Alk=�= Al � Al �[ � ��l�� Al��� Al��� Al��� Al��� Al�� R Al�� R Al���P Al���P N+l N�� ¯ql���¯ N+l���¯ N+l���P8A�v�I[ � � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al �N Al �N Al � Al � =?¯ql���L � RTl���� =?¯ql R�N =?¯ql R�N� =�� = =�l � =�l � =�l L =�l � =?Lql ¯ =?Lql���� =�l���L =�l NTR �A=�l R�� �A=�l���� =�l R�� =�l�¯��8A�v� � =S� Al ¯ Al �R Alk=G Al �R �A=�lk=?� ��Lql���� Al�P�� �ql N�N ���ql � ��Lql���� �ql��� �ql�LA=� � ��l�� Al��A= Al��� Al���� Al��� =GAl Rq= =�=�l N�L Al�P R Al�L�� =�=�l R�P =?¯ql��~N Al�L~N =�l���L8A�v� � � � Al � Al � Al �N Al � �~N+l���P ��Al R�� =�l R�¯ Al���P ��Lql NTR ��Pql���� Alk=?L �ql�P�LjS�Ii0dGj7�5�'� NTR NTR ¯��� ¯��� NTR NTR NTR NTR ¯��� ¯��� ¯��� ¯���jS�Ii0d?[�]�z�m;� ��� � R =SR�R ��P�� ={N�L =?��� =?¯�¯ =?�A= ¯��� ¯���� ����� R ��L����jS�6j0u�j7[�c!� L�¯ R�� =G ¯�L =?�� � =?¯�� =SR�� �~N�L =?L�P =?P R~ =?P���� N�N�N�L ��� R��� � ����� ���T� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯�� ��¯������ L� � L� � �~N�L�� �~N�L�� L� � L� � L� � L� � �~N�L�� �~N�L�� �~N�L�� �~N�L��

� (�dG¤�d?`5^ol 8qdGd\j7m+d/�6uqu�j7`+u�j0dtj0u�p�[���ced =�lM8qj7[�]7j � =\gk`5^�gkzG[�j0d?i�j7m�[�jMj7m+dti0j7[�]7j7g�`+¤�h�[�ck�+d?iM�!u�]�j7m5g�i�d?i0j7g��@[�j0u�][�]7d:j7m5d4d?i0j7gk�@[�j0d?i��!u�]Dj7m5d�i7gk�v�;ced?i0jY�vuA^+d?cO�ªWtU��t��s��\�tU��4���l

� ´

Page 45: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

p²[���ckd4N+��pY�Vu#(<uAzG[�j7geu `5iGl

��geh�u�jDp�[���ced��WtU ��s = = = =�\U = = = =�t[�j7[ p��4�qn;3��4����An�s"�v=G� p��4�qn'3��4���An�s"�v=G�

[+=���l�� Al N5= Al N Al���P Al���P Al��~N Al��~N Al���¯ Al���¯8A�v�I[+=S� Alk=?L Alk={N Al �N Al �N Al � Al � Al � Al �[ � ��l�� Al N�¯ Al N�¯ Al��A= Al��A= Al���¯ Al���¯ Al��� Al���8A�v�I[ � � Alk=?¯ Alk=?P Al �R Al �R Al P Al P Al � Al �N� =�� = =�l���¯ =�l�¯�¯ �ql���� �ql�� R =�l ¯ =�lk={N =�l�P�� =�l�L�P8A�v� � =S� =�l�P�� �ql R�� �qlk=G �qlk=�= Al N5= =�lk=?P Al R�L =�lk=?P� � ��l�� Al�� R �ql�¯�L =�lk=�= =�l N�� Al�LA= Al R�R Al R�� Al�L��8A�v� � � � Al��~N =GAl�P�¯ Al�PA= N+l�L�L Al���¯ �ql N�L Al���P Al�� RjS�Ii0dGj7�+�'� ={N ={N ���� ���� �A= �A= NTR�R NTR�RjS�Ii0d?[�]�z�m'� =G =?� =G+= �~N�¯ =?� =?� =�=?� ����jS�6j0u�j7[�c!� �~N ��L N��A= ��¯�¯ ��� ��L ��P�¯ R�� R� � ���������T� ����� ����� ����� ����� N � N � N � N ��*�� �~NTR �~NTR ��L���P ��L���P N�� R N�� R ��P�� R ��P�� R�t[�j7[ p"� =?�qn'3�4����An;s"� =G� p"� =?�qn;3�4���An's"� =G�

[+=���l�� Al��~N Al��~N Al���P Al���P Al���� Al���� Al���¯ Al���¯8A�v�I[+=S� Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al �[ � ��l�� Al���� Al���� Al��A= Al��A= Al���� Al���� Al��A= Al��A=8A�v�I[ � � Al �N Al �N Al � Al � Al � Al � Al � Al �� =�� = =�l ¯ =�l P =�l���� =�lk=?� =�l � =�l += =�lk=SR =�l �R8A�v� � =S� Al���� Al R�R Al���P Al���P Alk=G Al P Alk=?P Alk=G� � ��l�� Al��~N Al��A= Al�LA= Al���� Al��A= Al��� Al���� Al����8A�v� � � � Al ¯ Al L Alk={N Al P Al � Al � Al L Al �NjS�Ii0dGj7�+�'� � R � R ����� ����� ��L ��L L�L R L�L RjS�Ii0d?[�]�z�m'� ={N =SR =?��L ��L�P =?P ��� ={N�P �� �jS�6j0u�j7[�c!� N N�N L���P R�¯�¯ ��� � R PA=?L ¯ R~� � ���������T� N�L�� N�L�� N�L�� N�L�� ����¯ ����¯ ����¯ ����¯�*�� NTR~ NTR~ ��¯���P ��¯���P ����L ����L �A=?��P �A=?��P

� (<dG¤�d?`�^ol 8qdGd:j7m+d��!uqu�j7`+u�j0d?iDj0u1p²[���ckd?i:=:[�`5^��ql

� �

Page 46: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

p�[���ced��q�O� j0dG]�[�j0d?^9U+]7u � W4U��4An���s� =�n5�tU � =�l

��geh�u�jDp�[���ced��� j0dG]�[�j7geu ` = � � N

�Mi0j7gk�@[�j0d?i p��:�qn;3�4����An;s��4��[+=�� l�� Al��A= Al���P Alk=?� Al���L8+� �I[+=S� Al �N Al � Al �N Al �N[ � � l�� Al���P Al���¯ Al���¯ Al���8+� �I[ � � Al��~N Al L Al N5= Al P� =��v= =�lk=?� RTl��A= =�l N�� RTl����8+� � � =S� Al��A= Pql���L Al�¯ R �ql�¯ R� � � l�� Al��~N �ql���� Al�L�� �ql N�L8+� � � � � Alk={N �ql N�N Al��A= Pql �Rj7g��vd:i0dGj7�+� ���A= ���A= �~N�¯ �����j7g��vd:i0d?[�]�z�m =?P�� ��P�L ���N ����Lj7g��vd:zG�5���5ck[�j7geh�d =G P�P =SR���� ��� R�P ��¯���L

�Mi0j7gk�@[�j0d?i p��:�qn;3�4���An;s��4��[+=�� l�� Al���L Al���P Alk=?¯ Al����8+� �I[+=S� Al � Al � Al � Al �[ � � l�� Al���� Al��A= Al���� Al����8+� �I[ � � Alk=?� Al � Al���� Al �R� =�� =�l P �ql R�� =�l�PA= RTl���8+� � � =S� Alk=?¯ �qlk=?� �ql += �ql���P� � � l�� Al��~N =�l�¯�� Al�L~N N+l���P8+� � � � � Alk=?� �ql���� Al��� �ql�� Rj7g��vd:i0dGj7�+� N�L�P N�L R N�L�L N�L�Pj7g��vd:i0d?[�]�z�m �� � ���~N ����L N Lj7g��vd:zG�5���5ck[�j7geh�d =?��L� �A=?LA= ��P�P�� � R�� R

� (<dG¤�d?`�^ol 8qdGd:j7m+d��!uqu�j7`+u�j0d?iDj0u1p²[���ckd?i:=:[�`5^��ql

���

Page 47: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

p�[���ced�Lq���7��gki�i0�)d?zGge¡5d?^5�v��uq^+d?cªl

��geh�u�jDp�[���ced��WtU ��s = =�\U = =�t[�j7[ p��v=?�qn'3�4����An's"�4��[+=���l�� Al��A= Al��A= Al��� Al���8A�v�I[+=S� Al � Al � Al � Al �[ � ��l�� Al��A= Al��A= Al��� Al���8A�v�I[ � � Al += Al += Al += Al +=� =�� = =�l � =�l += =�l � =�l �8A�v� � =S� Al � Al � Al � Al �� � ��l�� Al��� Al��� Al��A= Al���8A�v� � � � Al += Al += Al � Al +=

� (<dG¤�d?`�^ol 8qdGd:j7m+d��!uqu�j7`+u�j0d?iDj0u1p²[���ckd?i:=:[�`5^��ql

���

Page 48: Harvard Institute of Economic Research · H I E R R Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 2036 Simple Estimators for the Parameters of Discrete Dynamic Games

������������� �� ��������� � ���������� � ���� � � �!���#"�$ %'&�$ (����"�)+*,"-����������!./�������0�1�����2

¨�d�¤�u135g547d?z{j7ckw#j0u#j7m5d:j7m+d��vu63+d?co�/gej7mrj¦�Vu1d87Tj947wbceuAz;:�j7geu<75iGlVpDm+d=47d?i��5cejY�6u>4?:#i7g@7+¤ cedtd87�j94�wrckuqz;:�j7geu<79gki:@i0�)d?zGgA:�coz;:�i7dCBEDGFIHKJML��9N�FIHOJMLQP�l� �9R � R��TSVUVSVRGW �X 7_j7m+d:�vu63+d?c)��gej7mbjQ�Mu1ceuqz;:�j7gku<75iGn

�ZY\[ H BED8H �\D>FIH^] �_H � �`FIH ��� �9a YH �/b��dceP���f Yd[ H � BED8H �\DGFIHg] �_H � �`FIH ���eP ���m+d;4�d

f Y\[ H � D8HhD�HgB �_H � �`FIH ���iP �

D8Hjlk N�HmB �_H � �`FIH ���eP^n #oBVn1]QceP �

:>7p3_g�iYz{u<75i7gki0j0d87Tj7cewxd?i0j7gk�q:�j0d83��Twri7�+�;i0j7gej7�+j7gA75¤

� hDrJ � -sB �_H � �`FIH ���eP Fut vwVx�y_z|{G} [ {Q~>} [ �\�

D Hw �6u>4 v k N�H�B �_H � �`FIH ���iP^n #oBVn!]<cePgA7rj7m���:��'u�h>�:�6u>4����I�A:AlOs0�?z;:>�A�<j7mp:�j

� BED8H �\D>FIH^] �_H � �`FIH ���eP�� vk`� z Y }5� Y ~G} �

NlBED8H �\D>FIH �dnq�9N����9N t �9N���P #CBVn1]GceP �

� �9R8R����� 47u ���7m��=�9�{ 6�Gn

� Yd[ H BED�H �\DGFIH�] �_H � �`FIH ��� �9a YH �/b��dciP�� vk`� z Y } � Y ~>} �

NlBED�HI��b��\D>FIH �dn���bG�9N����9N t �9N��8P n � BVn1]GcePj n � BVn1]>ceP

� bj n � BVn1]<ceP

vk`� Y }5� Y ~G}

BVn���b�PT�I��nBVn��lD8HZ�lDGFIH�PT�@BED�HI��b�PT��D>FIHm� N

k F Y } F Y ~>}� N Y } FutH N Y ~>}FIH � BVn1]GciP �� �p�5�d�e�I�kw��'u>�d�#�d�p��7T�5�q�;4\:G�0u>4o:>7p3�3��875u �q�A7p:G�0u>4vu��r�d�p�A�s�?�q�p:G�d�eu<7 �qw�D�H��lN�H0:>7p3�7+u>�9�-�d�p:G�C�d�A75z��D8H���BED8HZ��b�PT����D�HE�p:>7p3-N Y } FutH �-N�H ��N Y }H�  �d���=�?�T�I:G�d�eu<7��A���@���?�T�p:>�_�0u

D8HN�H j n � BVn1]>ceP

vk`� Y } � Y ~G}

nq�BVn���D8HZ�lDGFIH�PT�@BED�HZ�¡b�PT��DGFIH�� N

k F Y } F Y ~>}� N Y }H N Y ~>}FIH � BVn1]GciP

��f Y\[ H vk`� z Y }¢� Y ~G} �NlBED8H �\D>FIH �dnq�9N � �9N t �9N � P � BVn!]>ceP

��f Y\[ H � BED�H �\DGFIH�] �_H � �`FIH ���eP �:>�?3p�8�d�54d�83u£ ¤

�p¥