1
it is sometimes difficult to grasp a global anatomic image due to the limited scope field during the laparoscopic gastrectomy, dual-phase 3D CT angiography is useful and essential modality to visualize pre- cise anatomy around stomach preoperatively and to perform safety treatment. 54.16. Happiness with Operative Conduct Correlates with Self-Rates Surgeon Personality Characteristics. P. A. Knoll, J. J. Stulberg, B. Champagne, H. Reynolds, Jr, C. P. Delaney, E. L. Marderstein; University Hospitals Case Medical Center, Cleveland, OH Introduction: Scales to predict postoperative complications are gen- erally derived from easy to measure preoperative laboratory values and intraoperative conduct is given insufficient weight. While subjec- tive ratings by surgeons of their happiness with operative conduct for an individual operation may predict the likelihood of a postoperative complication, individual surgeon personality may strongly affect these measures. The purpose of this study was to demonstrate the ef- fect of surgeon personality on happiness with operative conduct. Methods: As part of an ongoing study of postoperative complications, the 4 surgeons in the Division of Colorectal Surgery are asked to rate their level of happiness with operative conduct and their level of hap- piness with staff/equipment at the conclusion of each surgical proce- dure. Personality testing was performed using the validated instruments: Big Five Inventory Version 54 and the Oxford Happi- ness Questionnaire. Correlation was performed between the postop- erative ratings and the personality testing. Results: Surgeon happiness with operative conduct was recorded for a cohort of 131 pa- tients and averaged 7.8 out of 10. Surgeon happiness with staff/equip- ment averaged 8.1 out of 10. As expected for the Big Five Inventory, surgeons self-rated highest on the scale for conscientiousness (mean 4.4 of 5) and slightly lower on the scales for extraversion, agreeable- ness, openness and neuroticism (3.5-3.8 of 5). Surgeon happiness with operative conduct correlated best with their self-rated conscien- tiousness (R 2 ¼ 0.65) but there was no correlation with the other per- sonality domains. Surgeon happiness with staff/equipment also correlated well with their self-rated conscientiousness (R 2 ¼ 0.95) and inversely with self-rated neuroticism (R 2 ¼ 0.60) but did not cor- relate with the other domains. Surgeon happiness with operative con- duct correlated well with self-rated overall happiness on the Oxford scale (R 2 ¼ 0.62). Within the domains of this scale, self-rated life sat- isfaction (R 2 ¼ 0.81) and calmness (R 2 ¼ 0.85) showed particularly ro- bust correlation with surgeon happiness with operative conduct. By contrast, surgeon happiness with staff/equipment had only a fair cor- relation with self-rated overall happiness on the Oxford scale. The self-rated calmness domain (R 2 ¼ 0.87) had an excellent correlation with happiness with staff/equipment while all other domains did not correlate well. Conclusions: Surgeon self-rated conscientious- ness and calmness was strongly associated with level of happiness with operative conduct and level of happiness with staff/equipment. Self-rated neuroticism had a moderate inverse relationship with sur- geon happiness with staff/equipment. Surgeon self-rated overall hap- piness correlated well with surgeon happiness with operative conduct. Surgeon self-perception and personality influence their feel- ings about operative conduct. Differences in personality may account for some of the variability in measures of surgeon happiness at the completion of an operation. 54.17. The Impact of Endoscopic Retrograde Cholangiopan- creaticography on Length of Stay. R. C. Britt, T. Novosel, L. Weireter, S. F. Reed, J. N. Collins, L. Britt; Eastern Virginia Medical School, Norfolk, VA Background: Endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreaticography (ERCP) performed either before or after laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) is a commonly used modality for the management of choledocho- lithiasis. We assess the impact of pre and post-operative ERCP on length of stay. Methods: A retrospective review was done of a prospec- tively collected database encompassing all patients with biliary dis- ease admitted to the Acute Care Surgery Service over two years. Diagnosis, operations performed, time from admission to operation, length of stay (LOS), and complications were assessed. Results: 190 patients with biliary disease were operated on, with 22 having preop ERCP and 26 postop. There was no difference in the age or co morbid- ities between the three groups. The patients who did not require ERCP had a significantly shorter LOS (4.9 vs 9.1 days, p < 0.0001) as well as a significantly shorter time from admission to operation (55.3 vs. 84.3 hours, p < 0.01). There was no significant difference in the LOS for the pre versus postoperative ERCP groups (8.6 vs. 9.6 days, p ¼ 0.75), but the post-operative ERCP group had a significantly shorter time for admission to operation (64.6 vs. 106.6 hours, p < 0.02). No patients had an unsuccessful post-operative ERCP. 34 of the 142 patients who did not need ERCP had a negative intraoper- ative cholangiogram, with three patients having choledocholithiasis on cholangiogram treated with laparoscopic common bile duct explo- ration and clearance. The 37 patients who had intraoperative cholan- giogram did have a significantly shorter LOS (5.3 vs 9.1, p < 0.04) and a trend towards shorter time from admission to operation (67.6 vs. 84.3 hours, p ¼ 0.25) than the patients requiring ERCP. Conclusion: The need for ERCP significantly lengthens hospital length of stay and time from admission to operation. An appropriate treatment algo- rithm for suscepted choledocholithiasis may be laparoscopic cholecys- tectomy with intraoperative cholangiogram and possible attempt at laparoscopic stone clearance, followed by judicious use of ERCP as necessary. 54.18. Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy Conversion Rates Two Decades Later: An Analysis of Surgeon and Patient- Specific Factors Resulting in Open Conversion. S. V. Sakpal, S. S. Bindra, C. Paruthi, R. S. Chamberlain; Saint Barnabas Medical Center, Livingston, NJ Background: Although we are more than two decades into the lap- aroscopic era, nationwide laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) conver- sion rates remain in excess of 10% in some series. 1 We sought to analyze patient-specific features in converted LCs, and determine the impact of surgeon-specific factors on conversions. Methods: A total of 2,205 LCs (74.7% female and 25.3% males; average age of 50.5 years [range 1-96]) performed at a large tertiary community hospital over a 5-year period (May 2004-October 2008) were ana- lyzed retrospectively. Results: The overall conversion rate for the study period was 4.94%. The number of cholecystectomies peaked ASSOCIATION FOR ACADEMIC SURGERY AND SOCIETY OF UNIVERSITY SURGEONS—ABSTRACTS 388

Happiness with Operative Conduct Correlates with Self-Rates Surgeon Personality Characteristics

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Happiness with Operative Conduct Correlates with Self-Rates Surgeon Personality Characteristics

ASSOCIATION FOR ACADEMIC SURGERY AND SOCIETY OF UNIVERSITY SURGEONS—ABSTRACTS388

it is sometimes difficult to grasp a global anatomic image due to thelimited scope field during the laparoscopic gastrectomy, dual-phase3D CT angiography is useful and essential modality to visualize pre-cise anatomy around stomach preoperatively and to perform safetytreatment.

54.16. Happiness with Operative Conduct Correlates withSelf-Rates Surgeon Personality Characteristics. P. A.Knoll, J. J. Stulberg, B. Champagne, H. Reynolds, Jr, C. P.Delaney, E. L. Marderstein; University Hospitals CaseMedical Center, Cleveland, OH

Introduction: Scales to predict postoperative complications are gen-erally derived from easy to measure preoperative laboratory valuesand intraoperative conduct is given insufficient weight. While subjec-tive ratings by surgeons of their happiness with operative conduct foran individual operation may predict the likelihood of a postoperativecomplication, individual surgeon personality may strongly affectthese measures. The purpose of this study was to demonstrate the ef-fect of surgeon personality on happiness with operative conduct.Methods: As part of an ongoing study of postoperative complications,the 4 surgeons in the Division of Colorectal Surgery are asked to ratetheir level of happiness with operative conduct and their level of hap-piness with staff/equipment at the conclusion of each surgical proce-dure. Personality testing was performed using the validatedinstruments: Big Five Inventory Version 54 and the Oxford Happi-ness Questionnaire. Correlation was performed between the postop-erative ratings and the personality testing. Results: Surgeonhappiness with operative conduct was recorded for a cohort of 131 pa-tients and averaged 7.8 out of 10. Surgeon happiness with staff/equip-ment averaged 8.1 out of 10. As expected for the Big Five Inventory,surgeons self-rated highest on the scale for conscientiousness (mean4.4 of 5) and slightly lower on the scales for extraversion, agreeable-ness, openness and neuroticism (3.5-3.8 of 5). Surgeon happinesswith operative conduct correlated best with their self-rated conscien-tiousness (R2¼ 0.65) but there was no correlation with the other per-sonality domains. Surgeon happiness with staff/equipment alsocorrelated well with their self-rated conscientiousness (R2¼ 0.95)and inversely with self-rated neuroticism (R2¼ 0.60) but did not cor-relate with the other domains. Surgeon happiness with operative con-duct correlated well with self-rated overall happiness on the Oxfordscale (R2¼ 0.62). Within the domains of this scale, self-rated life sat-isfaction (R2¼ 0.81) and calmness (R2¼ 0.85) showed particularly ro-bust correlation with surgeon happiness with operative conduct. By

contrast, surgeon happiness with staff/equipment had only a fair cor-relation with self-rated overall happiness on the Oxford scale. Theself-rated calmness domain (R2¼ 0.87) had an excellent correlationwith happiness with staff/equipment while all other domains didnot correlate well. Conclusions: Surgeon self-rated conscientious-ness and calmness was strongly associated with level of happinesswith operative conduct and level of happiness with staff/equipment.Self-rated neuroticism had a moderate inverse relationship with sur-geon happiness with staff/equipment. Surgeon self-rated overall hap-piness correlated well with surgeon happiness with operativeconduct. Surgeon self-perception and personality influence their feel-ings about operative conduct. Differences in personality may accountfor some of the variability in measures of surgeon happiness at thecompletion of an operation.

54.17. The Impact of Endoscopic Retrograde Cholangiopan-creaticography on Length of Stay. R. C. Britt, T.Novosel, L. Weireter, S. F. Reed, J. N. Collins, L. Britt;Eastern Virginia Medical School, Norfolk, VA

Background: Endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreaticography(ERCP) performed either before or after laparoscopic cholecystectomy(LC) is a commonly used modality for the management of choledocho-lithiasis. We assess the impact of pre and post-operative ERCP onlength of stay. Methods: A retrospective review was done of a prospec-tively collected database encompassing all patients with biliary dis-ease admitted to the Acute Care Surgery Service over two years.Diagnosis, operations performed, time from admission to operation,length of stay (LOS), and complications were assessed. Results: 190patients with biliary disease were operated on, with 22 having preopERCP and 26 postop. There was no difference in the age or co morbid-ities between the three groups. The patients who did not requireERCP had a significantly shorter LOS (4.9 vs 9.1 days, p< 0.0001)as well as a significantly shorter time from admission to operation(55.3 vs. 84.3 hours, p< 0.01). There was no significant difference inthe LOS for the pre versus postoperative ERCP groups (8.6 vs. 9.6days, p¼ 0.75), but the post-operative ERCP group had a significantlyshorter time for admission to operation (64.6 vs. 106.6 hours,p< 0.02). No patients had an unsuccessful post-operative ERCP. 34of the 142 patients who did not need ERCP had a negative intraoper-ative cholangiogram, with three patients having choledocholithiasison cholangiogram treated with laparoscopic common bile duct explo-ration and clearance. The 37 patients who had intraoperative cholan-giogram did have a significantly shorter LOS (5.3 vs 9.1, p< 0.04) anda trend towards shorter time from admission to operation (67.6 vs.84.3 hours, p¼ 0.25) than the patients requiring ERCP. Conclusion:The need for ERCP significantly lengthens hospital length of stay andtime from admission to operation. An appropriate treatment algo-rithm for suscepted choledocholithiasis may be laparoscopic cholecys-tectomy with intraoperative cholangiogram and possible attempt atlaparoscopic stone clearance, followed by judicious use of ERCP asnecessary.

54.18. Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy Conversion Rates TwoDecades Later: An Analysis of Surgeon and Patient-Specific Factors Resulting in Open Conversion. S. V.Sakpal, S. S. Bindra, C. Paruthi, R. S. Chamberlain; SaintBarnabas Medical Center, Livingston, NJ

Background: Although we are more than two decades into the lap-aroscopic era, nationwide laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) conver-sion rates remain in excess of 10% in some series.1 We sought toanalyze patient-specific features in converted LCs, and determinethe impact of surgeon-specific factors on conversions. Methods: Atotal of 2,205 LCs (74.7% female and 25.3% males; average age of50.5 years [range 1-96]) performed at a large tertiary communityhospital over a 5-year period (May 2004-October 2008) were ana-lyzed retrospectively. Results: The overall conversion rate for thestudy period was 4.94%. The number of cholecystectomies peaked