Hammond Pearce Challenges to Renewables in a More Abundant Natural Gas World.012110.Ppt[1]

8/3/2019 Hammond Pearce Challenges to Renewables in a More Abundant Natural Gas World.012110.Ppt[1]

1/38

!0,7.0,2243/7

70.9473899:943,#080,7.

$22438425,339073,943,

@fff,f-fffJ

%#!4.47:2:893%0,8

,3:,7


2/38


3/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

$,0,87;3,303307:944

W 74290207.,3!09740:23899:90W $,0,88/0130/,83,9:7,,817428,01472,9438

W $,0,88,3:3.4;03943,,884:7.0,439.4,-0/209,30998,3/8,3/209,30/7,908

W $,0847/3,7,;038:11.03950720,-994,420,331:1494900-47090701470574/:.943706:70817,.9:708942574;050720,-9

W 47070.0398,008,7047439,,3/300/,791.,892:,9430/7,:.17,.9:7394574/:.0

W $31.,39,/;,3.08347439,/73,3/0892:,94390.34408,700,/394908,0-442/7,:.17,.9:738902489831.,39419080

W 892,90841949,3,9:7,,87084:7.083479207.,0.00/%.198,0,87084:7.08,4309398,880882039,..4:3931474;07%.14170.4;07,-03,9:7,,8.42-33&$,3/,3,/,

W 3577054794/073$,0,80;0452039390&$90&$89,90/9,990.:7703970.4;07,-07084:7.00892,90574;/08034:3,9:7,,8948:5590&$147903090,789070892,908.,7798,-4;00,78


4/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

$,0!,8

W 4:7

,308;0%

094-0.4204304190,70893,9:7,,810/8390&$

:77039=41&$8,0,8574/:.943

,7.0:84790,89

094-0.4204304190,70893,9:7,,810/8390&$

:77039;0782,574/:.943

,73099%,7089574/:.310/390&$94/,,3/574/:.08=41,8,0,8390&$

,0990;0#

:77039=41&$8,0,8574/:.943

W 907$,0!,8

,03

,0990;0

44/147/

473#;07

&9.,

,99,344,

:743


5/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

',/,9390$,0%4#0.039$3,9:70%7,38,.9438

W 434-%307 8,7097,38,.943

-3949,;,:03.:/08-33/0-9

W %49,08,50,0

,8,700/9480,3907089398:58970,2,73099$,0,8809894

%49,!&$147-3

,8,84,70094/8.:88,'390,047/$,09%%,3/94479%%30;,:,9380;07,,3,/,33,9:7,,88,05,83.9,88433907089


6/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

$,0!,.4342.81742,3/%

9f

J

%

,,

D

%n

%$,n

-ff

'

-ff

'

f f

J

f

,fn

9f

D

%n

J

%,,

f

%$n

9f

f$

f

,fn

f

f

fJf

@O9fJf

f

!,.4342.8

$4:7.0

%!,.4342.8

$4:7.0%

W'07##80;03,943,9,857.08

W11.03.08,3/574/:.9;984:/09-099074;07920

W6:089438,9,7097084/0.4342.8


7/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

:7703973.9;9%703/8,3/$19

W &$,8/70.90/7.4:3970,.0/,3,92043.94-07,3/,8254/0/=174250,0;08

W %02,4794190789,9070/74550/070/73;079.,080,/394,28191,;4732470574/:.9;00.4342.:3.43;03943,7084:7.014.:80/47439,08

W 8,82507:0419:2-47439,08,;0Y,9,70;079.,08,3/!7,9089,9,70;079.,08

$4:7.0$2998

7,541#4:39,30-0%50&$,870.90/#4:39

$4:7.0$2998

n n n

fn

n f f I nf

n ,f n

fn

nfff

f


8/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

#4:3970,/43,3/&3.43;03943,!74/:.943:944

9n

f

@

f

n9

n

9

n

%n

$

@ f , f D n f

$4:7.0$,0,8!7207,3/$

W 81994,7/24700.4342.,3/574/:.9;047439,08/74;090

70.039574/:.943749=749,3/8,9703/08003.70,8343147,7/

W &3.43;03943,7084:7.0574;/0902,7099,3,-:3/,39,..088-03;0394741,89,9-0439040703/4190.489.:7;038:7390,-99420093,9:7,,8/02,3/147901470800,-01:9:70

W !741.574/:.9431742:3.43;03943,5,8070/:.090706:70/78..094..094005574/:.9431,9

fff

f%ff $$ ;@ ; ;$; 9f f

f $I $f

ff fff

Jf

,fnf

f fn f% ,@

ff$f@

ff

@ f D f f f

f%I nff $$ ;@ ; ;$; 9f f

f$I $f

fff

@f

ffnf

n

9ff

@f Df I nf f

f%nff $$ ;@ ; ;$; 9f f

n

f$I $f

%@

fff

9ff

@ f D f n f f

@f Df f


9/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

$0892,908,,870.90/#3.70,801742%74:--,80/43,!,79,.4342.#0.4;07

D n f n If I nf n n f

f f f f f I nf f n f

f f @ f I nf If n f

f ff ffnfInf ffnf

J f f n I nf 9 f n f

f J f f 9 f I n f n f

,fnf f Inf

Jf

9ff

f ff

f9n+

Dn%DJ

f9n+

f+D

W ,80/434:77/7;03,88:5524/000892,90574/:.94394/0.303.1/-,3/94/0.30-,3

,//943,.1/-:30

W ;03,3050.9,943147,5,79,70.4;073900.4342,8/02,3/-038943.70,803.4:50/9/0.33574/:.9430,39.5,90903/:897300/94,//=,8/70.90/78940058:55,3//02,3/3-,,3.0/08590254798,3/,88:233472,0,907

W #0,7/08841900.4342.8.03,7400254907-0,300/94,//,307017429478-:9:9,943702,349470887803;8430/94-07:3333:3/074:7-089.,808.03,740-049050,3.94-07

$4:7.0!$2998$22438425,339073,943,

,fn nf

9

n

%,n

$

nfn

ff

9n n$

n$

ff

9nn$n$

+


10/38


11/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

&$,8!74/:.943

f

n

f

n

f

n

f

n

&$,9,8!74/:.943.1/

$4:7.0

W&$3,9:7,,8574/:.943,8-.1/3.9

W085909089005/7453907.4:3990574/:.9433.9,8/43:89-.1/174270.47/-.1/30-

W.9574/:.943,8-.1/

W30,78574/:.94370--.1/47


12/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

6:01,.943//94384:/-0$31.,393

490!740.98,708:-0.9941:7907/0,8

4:397 ,.9 !72,7,709 " " " " " "

07, %7,3 9,39.,83

",9,7 ",9,7,8%7,3 :7450&

",9,7 #,8,8%7,3

:897,, $%7,3 ,5,3470,

3/4308 , %,3: 0.48,

0203 0203%7,3 &$470,

0203 0203%7,3 &$470, #:8 8, $,,3 8,

",9,7 ",9,7,8%7,3 :7450&

",9,7 #,8,8%7,3 8,907

",9,7 ",9,7,8%7,3 8,

",9,7 ",9,7,8'%7,3 8,

%49,

6:01,.943,5,.9$:22,7-.1/


13/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

254798-4:397-.1/

D

fn

f

f

ff

f

@ff

54798-4:397-.1/

@f

@f

f

;ff

f

-f

ff

f

,fff

0,94383;4;0/3%7,/0


14/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

#0,8,5,.9

Df-,ffn

9

ff

ff

ff

9

-ff

f9f

f-

9f

@fDfffn

D-

Df

,nffff

ff,n

f,n

fffff

@f-,ffn

fffn

ff

, 9fff

f

fffnf ,

f fffff ,

9nD ff

f ,fff ,f

f ff ;

ff ;

f ff ,f fn- ,

fn ff ,

D ff -

,fn

f ,f

fff ff ,f

D f ;

9f ,fn

, f

; ,


15/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

408470-:3/,39,9:7,,8!70;039 #030,-0307/45943

W 4W

$:-8/8:55479

,8.425203987030,-08

#030,-08574/:.09909434.,7-43

#030,-0!479144$9,3/,7/8

3.70,83!8.7:9341,8

7:/094,88570,/8:554798,8,8,97,385479,9431:0

W :9.0,53,9:7,,8/408.70,90,0,/3/1479080.947


16/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

$:-8/$:55479

W 147,.42-30/..0,85,39,922-9:,89,943.,7-4357.08

W 384703/8

W %4:94.4250901473/-:990708,8:-8/!74/:.943%,70/941

.05.48090,5,3/2,3/,908.892:,90/02,3/

W 3,//9439070,70455479:3908944073/90.344.4898,80,84907,9073,9;0030790.344084;07920


17/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

,842520398#030,-08

W 470,-:3/,393,9:7,,882:.2470,970,994.4,,3/3:.0,75407-4914730-:/8.4,3:0,3/0893.,5,.9.4,

W 390&$.4,3/:897489=943841/02,3/41:99.4,-:73/:09440757.0/3,9:7,,8

W ,8170/0307,943.,3..0:5/436:.2,39/0,94.4252039939072990397030,-054070307,943


18/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

#030,-08!74/:.0990944,7-43

W 0904-,,72324;0203929-050,3902547,79070889,89743/0870,243.903894,;0.0,3072470011.03914728410307,943

W 0,8574/:.08088.,7-439,3/408.4,989574/:.08.,7-43


19/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

!745480/2,9008,943&$288438

@Jffnffnf%#

Df,, @Jffnfffn,,%

@fD,, ffnnff

Dnf,,,,%

nnfnnDnffnnf

%

,,

nn @ff f nf f

Df

n

DD

n

nn

@ff

f

nf

f

Dnn

n

9

f

-ff

f


20/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

!745480/2,9008,94325,.9949073,9;0307

Jf fnfnffnf"

nffffnffn ,

ffDfnnf @fn

W ffDnnnn%fnW -ffffDnnnffnff

f%n$

W -fnffnnfJJJnfnffn @ffJfffnffnf @fnnDffnJ

Dfnffffnfffffffnf

fDnnnffnffnfn%fnn$

nfff

nfff fnn

n-fff

@ffn

%Jffnfn

J

%

%

$,J

%,,

nn

,

J

f

9

nf

9ff @ff

-nf

-f

@f

@f


21/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

,7-4308,94325,.99407.,398

9- - - ,

@$

,J

!!,7-43390389 :0-#043

@ f@$,J

f

@

n

f

,7-43390389-:0%50

W47.4,170/0307,94789,94507,9032,7098070,880989057.0415407#3%0,87,393!,89,3/##30397,!.,7-4308,943,890549039,94831.,3970/:.02,738

W1.,7-4308,94388973039034:.42-30/..0,88098,;090,-994/85,.0.4,170/.,5,.90850.,390$4:90,89

W 32,70980700,97,90.42-:89439:7-30%

,8,88098419038099057.0415407011.039%,8,8809884:/800,-03019385,78570,/8

W!-03019817428973039.,7-4308,943

:7703908,9435,880/3904:8080970201,;47,-094.4,-,80/207.,398,3/84:/.,:80232,0,7338/09720394;0790309/0.,/0


22/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

%5./3#69;636&;.51.91:

&;.;95./3769;636:;.51.91

&;.;95./3769;6366.3

1:9:.69 .5.9

&63.9.;9.;53/3R ;9.091;69:63.9690:;649:;195./3:5031:56595./3.3;95.;9:690:

/

/

!/

/

!/ ":

/0667:

/

544:63.9690:;649:;198945;

'/

'/

"/ ":/0667:3.945:

'/

!/

&/

!/03/

"/

.9:/;3;/6.3

/

"/

/!%/

!/

/.55.3509.:3.::%5./3:

%/

'/

!/

!/ #/

/

/

/

/

!/ ":/0667:45:

'%4;:.5509.:59;.3:.3:/

%#/

:;.;:..5%#&:;.;:.6.3:

&/

"%/ 3.9;3;: /:4.339;3;:

//


23/38


24/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42


25/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

7:/0,8$570,/$:554798,8,8,%7,385479,943:0

W 42570880/3,9:7,,88.0,5079,3/080,3/,8430W #09,5:2557.08147949,,4341,843006:;,03934:8943,3/0;03407349075,7984190.4:39707089,943847550303,9:7,,882470,;,,-0

W %8.425,7089709,,8430,9,

W %08570,/4147/8.4:398039.3,3/1,8:89847941

90,;07,0/8.4:391474;0790,890,7841W !49039,14190949,7043,97:.31009390&$89.0/94

3,9:7,,8984:/06:,9094-38,33:,47.1/413.702039,/02,3/


26/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

7:/0,8$570,/$:554798,8,8,%7,385479,943:0


27/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

9073,9;03070%703/8147

4.,7-43-3-:92,-0,30307-

47074-:89.,59,2,7098

4384/,943

09907/02,3/,3/13,3.3

0739070897,908


28/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

43.:843

W $,0,8,550,7894-0,831.,39.,3094900307,3/8.,50

W 470,-:3/,393,9:7,,8/4082,092470/11.:994,/4597030,-08-:99/408349570;039,/45943

W 470,-:3/,393,9:7,,8:92,908,0,/3/147907030,-00307

80.947

W %070,70.4252039,7,/45943897,90081477030,-08,3/3,9:7,,8-7/01:094407.,7-4307,,3/84:9431477030,-0390729903.

W 0-00;098415,7,24:3925479,3.09,93;08947814.:8439480,9073,9;0030790.344089,9:897,9090.0,70895,994-0.4230.4342.94:9,8:-8/


29/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

"


30/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

5503/


31/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

%0.344489425,7843

-nn

nff

%0.344 ,59,4890;070/:0

48922-9:

0;00/489

.0398

0;00/489

9943

.0398

0;00/489

9943

.0398

&$389,0/,5,.9

09$:2207

,5,.9

4-,

389,0/

,5,.9

307

438:2594394

!74/:.0

4, =-41.4,

,9:7,,8

42-30/.0 -9:

,9:7,,8!0,07 -9:

/74 700 700

:.0,7 41:7,3:2

-9:

$4,7!' 700 700

3/38470 700 700

3/118470 700 700

%7,/9

43,307

9073,9;0307


32/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

3/


33/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

3/749470.,89

Jnf%,J

nfJnf@,

#043..:2

03/41

%49,

..:2

207.,8

:7450

$4:9,898,

!,.1.

90770,8

%49,0

,5,.9;070,7

..:2:,90/

,5,.9

fnf+$

J#$J#nf

fff

fff

fn fff

J%f

nn

D,ffn9@ffn

f,ffnf

Dffffnf

fJfffn

,J

f,J f,J #:2:,9;0389,0/

n@,


34/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

$4,7


35/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

$4,7:944

W 0050.9,70,9;089743,8389,0787:89409072,35740.98439074:3/,0,/4190850.:,90//0.30;07,84:/-0,-099070,79,3

W $:5502,3/ 0,700892,934124/:0/02,3/3941549039,8:55

W $!8 00892,902/-9003/41147408,024/:057.08$42070.039.4397,.98,;0-003-09003

W 0,70994,9.072,3970;843


36/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

:77039&$0307,943

Jfff-ffnnff%fnfDnnn

fnnfnfnnffn

Dnnffn

D-f%-nnff

f

9

9

-fff

f

-nf

@f

@f-

f

Df

n n

J

f

%@f+

9I

J

f

f


37/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

&3.43;03943,,8097.8

,n

,fn

%

f

f

%n

f

% f J

ff

J

f$

9f%

f

Jf

9nfn

%

f

Df

%

I

% -f, f

9

ff

J%,,

DJ%n

f%

% $,n

9f%,,n$

f%

%$,n

%$,n

9nf%

n%

n%

n%

n%

@ 9 n % $ ,n

nIff

@f ,f


38/38

!0,7.0,2243/5,2243/822438.439.42

5503/

W 5503/

W 3,890791.,943

!0,7.0,2243/070-.07919,990;080570880/3987080,7.7054799490-089412340/0,..:7,907010.92507843,;08,-4:9908:-0.9.425,308,3/9890780.:7908,3/9,9,;0349-003,2349,3/349-070.0;3/70.9473/70.9.425038,9433 0.,301 47057088390850.1.70.42203/,943847;083987080,7.705479

25479,398.48:70847/09,0/7,9331472,9434949955:-./8.48:70822438.439.42//943,31472,9438,;,,-0:543706:089$22438425,387,93888902.,9047083/;/:,894.5071472,3.0,8&3/07090:97,47;070970,9;094905071472,3.04190 $!3/0,3/98/8.709003078:-80.9474;07,24395074/#080,7.,3,898.425038,9438-,80/:543,24349079389017280307,3;0892039-,3370;03:08$22438425,339073,943,2,800.425038,9431473;0892039-,33807;.0817424907.425,308147 .7080,7..4;07,08574;/0/%01724:/050.99470.0;0.425038,943147,38:.807;.08470311,908.48:70

%87054792,-02,/0,;,,-0390&390/3/42974:/897-:943-$22438425,339073,943,,59,,7098290/,172,:9470/,3/70:,90/-903,3.,$07;.08:947994:3/079,0/083,90/3;0892039-:83088390&390/3/42$22438425,339073,943,,59,,7098290/854.432,3,33;08920397080,7..431.988,;,,-0-706:089%07080,7.7054798/70.90/43,950784384,;0574108843,050703.032,9907870,93943;0892039841,9390/013943413;0892039574108843,8379.03,3.,$07;.08,3/,7098.93,3.,!74249437/07,8,203/0/!507843841,9379.0,94/!309479.425,308:33.47547,90/,884.,943809.4750784384,704907802,709.4:39075,790847390720/,90.:89420783,..47/,3.0990$,3/-4441#:08,3/:/,3.0700;,395078438%07080,7.7054792:89349-0,.90/4347700/:543-,35078438470.0;0993904,70349700;,395078438$22438425,339073,943,,59,,7098290/84.,90/,9$,.;04:80!..,/0,33043/43&390/3/42

8.,207%802,8-,80/4331472,9434-9,30/174284:7.08.$22438425,339073,943,-00;0894-070,-0-:9$22438425,3/40834970570803947,77,3998,..:7,.%0453438,3/0892,908.439,30/39002,70570803990;0841$22438425,3,84190/,90419002,,3/2,-08:-0.994.,3094:95747349.0$22438425,339073,943,349-07085438-014790.43806:03.04170,3.0:543,3453434789,902039.439,30/39802,%802,8.431/039,,3/2,349-070574/:.0/3404735,7994:9905747799035072884341$22438425,339073,943,

Documents

Hammond Pearce Challenges to Renewables in a More Abundant Natural Gas World.012110.Ppt[1]