Upload
theodora-willis
View
215
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Groupinteraction
Cognitive andemotional
processing
Groupdecisions
and records
Subjectivemember
assessments
Tasks and/orpurpose
Groupstructure
Member goals,beliefs, and
characteristics
Localcontext
Socialsystem
Embedded System Framework
Narrative processing
Majoritarianism, argument
distribution, momentum
Jury verdict or finding
Subjective
Assessments of jury service
Trial evidence,jury instruction
Jury size anddecision rule
Juror beliefs, values, and experiences
Courthouse andpresiding judge
Constitution
Social norms
Media system
Civic attitudes/behaviors
Embedded System FrameworkCh. 3 - Juries
Discussion functions and sequencing
Valence and content of
arguments used
Content and quality ofdecision(s)
and/or report
Nature of issueor problem
Group size
Time available
Attitude type and distribution
Argument systems
Embedded System FrameworkCh. 3 - Group decision making
Formal codesand bylaws
Procedural expertiseand traditions
Resources availablefor training/support
Designated grouplongevity and mission
Faithfulness ofprocedural
appropriation
Discussionfunctions andsequencing
Degree andintensity of conflict
Considerationof others’ views
Quality andrepresentativenessof group decision
Duration ofdiscussion
Confidence in(and commitment to)decision and group
Task complexityand importance
Group structure:comm. network,
arrangement,discussion
procedures, anddecision rule
Groupdevelopment
Proceduralknowledge,
expectations,and preferencesProcedural legal
requirements
Norms for arrangingphysical space and
comm. networks
Strong reciprocity
Political culture(democratic norms,power relationships)
Embedded System FrameworkCh. 4 - Group procedures
Integration ofphysical resources
Ideageneration
Informationseeking and
exchange
Attention togroup structure
and process
Originalityand quality of
decisions and/orrecommendations
Effectiveness ofcoordinated action
Satisfaction withprocess and
outcomes
Equality anddynamism of
group structure
Maturity andcohesion of group
Group size andresources
Distribution ofexpertise andexternal ties
Members’ statusconsciousness
and openness todiversity, change,
and new ideas
Emphasis oninnovation and
diversity
Strength of linkbetween statusand expertise
Resourcesdevoted to training
Economic pressureto innovate
Changing workforcedemographics
Social stratification
Anti-discrimination laws
Cultural orientations(individualist/collectivist,hierarchical/egalitarian)
Embedded System Framework: Ch. 5 - Group size, diversity, creativity, information sharing, and related factors
Leadership(facilitation,
role clarification,coordination)
Mutualperformancemonitoring
Backupbehavior
Environmentalmonitoring and
adaptation
Clearcommunication
Teameffectiveness
Task complexityand task type
(coordination vs.cooperative)
Leader roleestablished
Structuralflexibility
Shared mental models
Team orientationand mutual trust
Commitmentto team model
Trainingand support
Authoritystructure
Stress/pressureapplied to learn
Athletic archetypeof teamwork
Collectivistcultural norms
Embedded System FrameworkCh. 6 - Teamwork
Distribution ofspeaking
opportunities/interruptions
Distributionof attention,influence,
and respect
Productivity
Distribution ofrewards/
resources
Satisfaction,comfort, andresentment
Role structure(behavioral
requirements/restrictions)
Status system
Behavioralexpectations
Institutionalizedrole system
Statusallocation
Level of socialstratification
Conventionalrole norms and
distributions
Diffuse statuscharacteristicstereotypes
Embedded System FrameworkCh. 6 - Role and status distribution
Relationalcommunication
and conflict
Groupcohesion
Nature of thetask and/ortask-related
conflict
Distribution offelt and wantedrelational needs
and conflictorientations
Individualist/collectivist norms
Culturally salientrelational tensions
Embedded System FrameworkCh. 7 - Group cohesion formation
Socialization toconform with/adaptprototypical norms
Distribution andmanagement of
deviance (rejection,norm adjustment)
Symbolic conflictand convergence
Dialogue andstorytelling
Group cohesion
Subjectiveassessment of
group’s qualities
Increase/reduction ininter-group stereotypes
and prejudices
Exclusion/departurefrom the group
Task requires intra-and/or inter-group
cooperation vs.competition
Equality of memberstatus relationships
Nature and strengthof group norms
Salience of differentsocial identities (and
primary group identity)
Confidence in one’sindependent judgment
Participants’ diverseidentities and allegiances
(including to other groups)
Inter-group conflictswith other local groups
Organizationalsocialization practices
Institutional supportfor inter-group contact
Pool of social identities,group archetypes, and
salient symbols ordramatic narratives
Individualist/collectivistcultural orientations
Embedded System Framework: Ch. 8 - Normative, symbolic, and identity conflict and convergence
Non-directive/interpretive
group leadership
Self-disclosureand emotional
processing
Dramatic role playingand self-expression
Direct confrontationof emotional conflict
Group/socialskill
Knowledge/understanding of
topics (health, etc.)
Awareness ofown and group’snon-conscious
behavior
Self-esteem/confidence
Cooperative vs.competitive group task
Degree of ambiguity ingroup structure (roles,
procedural norms)
Group cohesion/mutual trust
Participants’ willingnessto express emotion
and engage in conflict
Participants’ personalemotional/psychological
histories and health
Support for groupleadership training
Collaborative, competitive,
or individualisticwork/reward system
Cultural emphasis onpersonal development
General recognitionof non-conscious
processes
Embedded System FrameworkCh. 9 - Group-based personal growth and learning
Embedded Systems Theory summary
Rigor of discussion
Completeness of information exchange
Positive/negativesocial relations
Procedural monitoring/talk
Symbolic expression/Narrative processing
Treatment ofdeviance
Quality of groupdecisions/
performance
Assessment offairness/quality
of group process
Attitudes towarddifferent social
groups
Nature of group task(esp. coop./competitive)
Decision rule anddiscussion procedures
Role/power relationships
Leadership style/ability
Group maturity/flexibility
Group cohesion, trust, and commitment
Distribution of memberbeliefs, attitudes,
information
Member social identitiesand ties to other groups
Member mental health (self-confidence, anxiety)
Institutional support/ training for groups
Competitiveness andequity of power/status relations and rewards
Policies towarddiversity/innovation
Socio-economic divisions/stratification
Cultural orientations(individualist/collectivist,hierarchical/egalitarian)
Pool of group archetypes,roles, social identities,
and cultural myths
Legal/constitutionalprocedural requirements