35
Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability 30th of April 2013 Fundaçao Calouste Gulbenkian Lisbon The need for fiscal consolidation. Recent developments in Spain Nuria Badenes Plá [email protected] INSTITUTO DE ESTUDIOS FISCALES, Madrid. Spain

Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    8

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability

30th of April 2013

Fundaçao Calouste Gulbenkian

Lisbon

The need for fiscal consolidation.

Recent developments in Spain

Nuria Badenes Plá

[email protected]

INSTITUTO DE ESTUDIOS FISCALES, Madrid. Spain

Page 2: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Why is there a need for fiscal consolidation?

The evolution of the basic parameters of tax structures until 2007 reflected a stable,

almost unchanged in fiscal models, culminating the adaptation process associated

with the strongest period of economic expansion that began in the 90s.

In 2008 and after a period of evolution of tax structures fairly stable, the economic

scenario was reversed and dragged radical fiscal and budgetary policies. Some figures

show the seriousness of the situation.

-2

-1,5

-1

-0,5

0

0,5

1

1,5

2

2,5

2006T

I

2006T

II

2006T

III

2006T

IV

2007T

I

2007T

II

2007T

III

2007T

IV

2008T

I

2008T

II

2008T

III

2008T

IV

2009T

I

2009T

II

2009T

III

2009T

IV

2010T

I

2010T

II

2010T

III

2010T

IV

2011T

I

2011T

II

Quaterly variation

GDP (market prices) rate of variation

Page 3: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

-140.000,00 €

-120.000,00 €

-100.000,00 €

-80.000,00 €

-60.000,00 €

-40.000,00 €

-20.000,00 €

0,00 €

20.000,00 €

40.000,00 €

1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Million €

Evolution of Spanish deficit (million €)

Page 4: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

In 2008, the economic crisis led to a drop of 0.4 points of revenue collection GDP

in the EU countries and a general slowing in the growth figures. Spain was not

immune to this general trend, and the impact was much deeper (4.4 points of GDP)

.

0

50.000

100.000

150.000

200.000

250.000

1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Personal Income tax Corporate Tax VAT Excise Taxes

Anual revenue in thousand €

Page 5: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

From 2011 the need to combine expenditure and revenue adjustments set a new

challenge for Fiscal Reform: to choose the least harmful tax options in the

production function and achieve compatibility with consolidation strategies,

growth and reducing inequality.

Some EU countries opted for quick-impact reforms (eliminating tax benefits and

increasing rates), basically in income taxation.

These proposals are being controversial in light of the analysis of international

organizations, as it has been shown that it is preferable for achieving economic

growth to use consumption, property and the environment as tax bases, rather

than the imposition of income.

Since the early nineties, Spain has remained untouched by the growing importance

of energy and environmental taxation and green fiscal reform in most countries of

the EU and OECD. Environmental Taxation in Spain has been confined to the

initiatives of the regional governments, with little relevance of collection tax

figures.

Conclusion: Spain counts on environmental taxes whose only environmental

feature is its name.

Page 6: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Some evidence:

Total environmental tax revenues as a share of total revenues from taxes and

social contributions (%). 2010

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

Page 7: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Some evidence: 2010

0 0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 3 3,5 4 4,5

Lithuania

Ireland

Greece

Spain

Romania

France

Belgium

Austria

Slovakia

Malta

Germany

EU (27 countries)

Italy

Portugal

United Kingdom

Czech Republic

Norway

Latvia

Luxembourg

Poland

Finland

Netherlands

Hungary

Bulgaria

Estonia

Sweden

Cyprus

Slovenia

Denmark

Diference Environmental taxation/GDP Enviromental expenditure/GDP

Page 8: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Some evidence: 2010

Anual per capita € paid for environmental taxes

117 139 154 192 227 240 254 318 340 377 405

456 485 535 555 584 618 631 632 668 670 676 719

810 826 930

1023

1420

1689 1707

1908

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

Page 9: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN SPAIN:

The Spanish Government identified the deficit as the main problem that threatens the

economic sustainability of the electricity system and announced its intention to take

measures for correction. (24.000 million € accumulated gap, 2,5% of GDP; 4.281 million € in 2012)

Royal Decree-Law 1/2012 sought a temporary limit costs for the electrical system by

removing economic incentives for production of electricity in facilities under

special regime.

Subsequently approved Royal Decree-law 13/2012 and 20/2012, which established a

new set of urgent measures to contain the costs of certain activities and regulated

costs of the electricity system, with the goal of reducing temporary mismatches

for 2012, both for the electricity sector to the gas, respect the deficit limit set for 2012

and achieve tariff sufficiency in 2013.

Given the failure of these measures to contain the tariff deficit, the Government

found it necessary to introduce new tax figures to cover certain costs of the electric

system.

According to government estimates, the revenue derived from new tax measures in

electricity and gas will be approximately 2,900 million €.

Page 10: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN SPAIN:

Law 15/2012 of 27 December of Fiscal Measures on Energy Sustainability :

This law regulates three new taxes:

1. Tax on the value of the production of electric energy

2. Tax on the production of nuclear fuel and radioactive waste resulting from nuclear

power generation

3. Tax on nuclear fuel and radioactive waste storage in centralized facilities

Other measures:

• Creation of a fee for the use of inland waters for the production of electricity

• Modification of natural gas and coal tax rates

• Removal of exemptions for energy products used in the production of electricity and

cogeneration of electricity and useful heat.

1. Tax on the value of the production of electric energy

2. Tax on the production of spent nuclear fuel and radioactive waste resulting from

nuclear power generation

3. Tax on nuclear fuel and radioactive waste storage in centralized facilities

• Creation of a fee for the use of inland waters for the production of electricity

• Modification of natural gas and coal tax rates

• Removal of exemptions for energy products used in the production of electricity

and cogeneration of electricity and useful heat.

Page 11: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

TAX ON THE VALUE OF ELECTRICITY PRODUCTION

It is levied on production activities and incorporation into the electric power system

in the Spanish electricity system (production and incorporation into the electric power system, measured in

central bars)

All economic compensations shall be considered (market + bonus, incentive and / or

supplements, if any) in the calculation of taxable base.

The tax rate is unique, 7% “ad valorem”, to be applied to income earned by each of

the electricity production facilities.

The taxable event occurs on the last day of the tax period, coinciding with the

calendar year. Taxpayers are required to self-assess the tax and enter the quota within

the month of November after tax accrual. However, four account payments on

account will be made between the 1st and 20th of the months of May, September,

November and February the following year. (for consideration of definitive measures

of electricity)

Page 12: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

TAX ON PRODUCTION OF SPENT NUCLEAR FUEL AND

RADIOACTIVE WASTE RESULTING FROM NUCLEAR-ELECTRIC

POWER GENERATION

Levied on the production of spent nuclear fuel and radioactive waste resulting from

nuclear power generation.

The taxable base is determined for each facility

Tax rates that apply to each base are:

Tax Base Tax Rate

Kilograms of heavy metal (uranium and plutonium) content in nuclear fuel

produced during the tax period, understood as that fuel

irradiated in the nuclear reactor during the tax period has been

removed permanently.

2.190 €/kg

Cubic meters of radioactive waste of low and intermediate activity level

which have been prepared for temporary storage on the same site of the

installation during the tax period.

6.000 €/ m3

Cubic meters of radioactive waste of very low activity level, which

have been prepared for temporarily storage in the same site of the installation

during the tax period

1.000 €/m3

Page 13: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

TAX ON SPENT NUCLEAR FUEL AND RADIOACTIVE WASTE

STORAGE IN CENTRALIZED FACILITIES

Levied on the storage of spent nuclear fuel and radioactive waste at a centralized

facility. The tax replaces and unifies the existing regional taxes on this subject.

• What is storage of spent nuclear fuel and radioactive waste? any activity

involving their immobilization, temporarily or permanently, regardless of how.

• What is a centralized installation? an installation that stores these materials from

different facilities or sources.

There is also some exemption for the storage of radioactive waste from medical

or scientific activities…

Page 14: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Tax base and rates are as follows:

Tax base Tax rate

Difference between the weight of the heavy metal content of spent nuclear

fuel stored at the end and the beginning of the tax period

70 €/Kg.

Difference between the volume of long life high-level radioactive waste, other

than spent nuclear fuel, or long life intermediate activity level, which are

stored, at the end and the beginning of the tax period, expressed in cubic

meters

30.000 €/m3

Volume of radioactive waste of medium, low or very low activity, introduced

into the storage facility during the tax period, expressed in cubic meters

Medium and low activity

10.000 €/m3

Very low activity:

2.000 €/m3

Page 15: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

MODIFICATION OF EXCISE TAXES

Natural gas:

Natural gas has been enjoying a zero tax rate, temporarily allowed by Directive

2003/96/EC. Now, there is a positive rate for natural gas used as fuel in stationary

engines, as well as to natural gas for purposes other than fuel.

However, there is a reduced tax on natural gas for commercial purposes if they are

not processes used in electric generation and cogeneration

Coal:

To take a similar approach to the production of electricity from fossil energy

sources, a raise on the tax rate on coal

Fueloils and gasoils:

At the same time, specific rates on fuel oils and gas oils intended for electrical

energy production or cogeneration of electricity and useful heat are created.

Water Duty:

A new duty on the use or exploitation of inland water for hydroelectric purposes

Page 16: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Until 31-12-2012 From 1-1-2013

General rate Special rate

Leaded gasoline 433,79 €/1.000 l. 433,79 €/1.000 l. 24 €/1.000 l.

Unleaded Gasoline 98 I.O. or

higher octane

431,92 €/1.000 l. 431,92 €/1.000 l. 24 €/1.000 l.

Other unleaded gasoline 400,69 €/1.000 l. 400,69 €/1.000 l. 24 €/1.000 l.

Diesel for general use 307 €/1.000 l. 307 €/1.000 l. 24 €/1.000 l.

Diesel used as fuel in the applications described in

paragraph 2 of Article 54 and, in general, as a fuel

(except for the production of electricity or

cogeneration 29,15 €/1.000 l)

78,71 €/1.000 l. 78,71 €/1.000 l. 6 €/1.000 l.

Fuel oils (except for the production of electricity or

cogeneration 12 €/Tn)

14 €/Ton. 14 €/Ton. 1€/Ton.

Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) for general use 57,47 €/Ton. 57,47 €/Ton.

(Unchanged)

LPG for uses other than fuel 0 €/Ton 15 €/Ton.

Natural Gas for general use 0 €/Ton 1,15 €/Gj

Natural gas for purposes other than those of fuel, as

well as natural gas for use as fuel in stationary

engines

0 €/Ton 0,65 €/Gj

If natural gas is intended for professional use and

not processes electricity generation and cogeneration

0 €/Ton 0,15 €/Gj

Page 17: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Until 31-12-2012 From 1-1-2013

General rate Special rate

Kerosene for general use 306 €/1.000 l. 306 €/1.000 l. 24 €/1.000 l.

Kerosene destined for use other than fuel 78,71 €/1.000 l. 78,71€/1.000 l.

Unchanged

Bio-ethanol and bio-methanol for use as fuel: 0 €/1.000 l.

a) Biomethanol and bioethanol mixed with

unleaded gasoline of 98 IO or higher octane

431,92 €/1.000 l. 24 €/1.000 l.

b) Bio-ethanol and bio-methanol, mixed with

other unleaded gasoline or unmixed

400,69 €/1.000 l 24 €/1.000 l.

Biodiesel for use as fuel 0 €/1.000 l. 307 €/1.000 l. 24 €/1.000 l.

Biodiesel and bio-methanol for use as fuel 0 €/1.000 l. 78,71 €/1.000 l. 6 €/1.000 l.

Section 1.16. Gas oils for the production of

electricity or cogeneration

29,15 €/1.000 l.

Section 1.17. Fuel oils for the production of

electricity or cogeneration

12 €/Ton.

Special rate known as “Green cent”, a duty for enviromental use

Page 18: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Excise Tax on Coal:

To take a similar approach to the production of electricity from natural gas, there is a

raise on tax rate on coal from € 0.15 to € 0.65 per gigajoule

Also removal of the exemption on transactions for preparing coal consumption when

involving the subsequent use for electricity production and cogeneration of electricity

and heat.

Duty to Hydroelectric Generation:

Levied on the use or exploitation of inland waters for hydropower development.

The annual tax rate will be 22% of the value of the tax base.

Exempt from paying this fee: directly exploited hydroelectric by the competent authority

for the management of public water.

Reduction of 90% for:

(i) hydroelectric power installations not exceeding 50 MW (electricity special regime)

(ii) for facilities exceeding 50 MW producing electricity using pumping hydraulic

technology

(iii) for those productions or installations that should be encouraging for overall energy

policy reasons, as determined by regulation.

Page 19: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

REVENUE

Revenue Earnmarking

Budget laws state that each year the revenue will be used to finance the deficit in

electrical system. An amount equal to the sum of:

- The estimate of annual revenues for the state taxes and fees included in the

law 15/2012.

- The estimated revenue from the auctioning of emission permits of

greenhouse gases, with a maximum of 450 million €.

Estimated revenue by the Government: about 2.900 million €.

- New nuclear energy taxes, is estimated to achieve annual revenues of 296.6 million €

- New canon on hydropower generation is estimated a revenue of 304.2 million €

between 2013 and 2015

- New nuclear and hydroelectric impositions, 574 million €

- Natural gas (804 million €), Power generation with coal (268 million €) and fuel oil

(38 million €).

-There will be revenue from the sale of CO2 emission rights for 450 million €.

- The sales tax of 6% electricity, at the state level, 571.7 million €

Page 20: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Gasoline

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Price witout taxes 50,53 57 45,04 56,69 69,03

VAT 14,46 15,49 13,84 16,9 20,11

Hidrocarbon excise tax 37,47 37,44 39,06 40,31 40,26

Retail excise tax on

hidrocarbons (estate

rate) 2,4 2,4 2,4 2,4 2,4

Automotive diesel

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Price witout taxes 53,46 68,2 46,78 58,8 74,27

VAT 13,39 15,74 12,58 15,62 19,33

Hidrocarbon excise tax 27,8 27,8 29,43 30,7 30,7

Retail excise tax on

hidrocarbons (estate

rate) 2,4 2,4 2,4 2,4 2,4

Subsidized diesel

Price witout taxes 51,33 69,96 44,98 57,65 73,2

VAT 9,57 12,55 8,55 11,24 14,7

Hidrocarbon excise tax 7,87 7,87 7,87 7,87 7,87

Retail excise tax on

hidrocarbons (estat

rate) 0,6 0,6 0,6 0,6 0,6

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Retail excise tax on hidrocarbons (estat rate)

Hidrocarbon excise tax

VAT

Price witout taxes

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Prices in cents per liter

The problem of lower taxation of diesel compared to

gasoline persists even after the reform.

Page 21: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Retail excise tax on hidrocarbons (estat rate)

Hidrocarbon excise tax

VAT

Price witout taxes

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Prices in cents per liter

The problem of lower taxation of diesel compared to

gasoline persists even after the reform.

Gasoline

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Price witout taxes 50,53 57 45,04 56,69 69,03

VAT 14,46 15,49 13,84 16,9 20,11

Hidrocarbon excise tax 37,47 37,44 39,06 40,31 40,26

Retail excise tax on hidrocarbons

(estat rate) 2,4 2,4 2,4 2,4 2,4

Consumers price 104,86 112,33 100,34 116,3 131,8

Automotive diesel

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Price witout taxes 53,46 68,2 46,78 58,8 74,27

VAT 13,39 15,74 12,58 15,62 19,33

Hidrocarbon excise tax 27,8 27,8 29,43 30,7 30,7

Retail excise tax on hidrocarbons

(estat rate) 2,4 2,4 2,4 2,4 2,4

Consumers price 97,05 114,14 91,19 107,52 126,7

Subsidized diesel

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Price witout taxes 51,33 69,96 44,98 57,65 73,2

VAT 9,57 12,55 8,55 11,24 14,7

Hidrocarbon excise tax 7,87 7,87 7,87 7,87 7,87

Retail excise tax on hidrocarbons

(estat rate) 0,6 0,6 0,6 0,6 0,6

Consumers price 69,37 90,98 62 77,36 96,37

Page 22: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Why Spanish Government is reluctant to increase tax on diesel?

There is not an official explanation.

One possibility is the desire to protect those sectors that use diesel more intensively,

such as transport and agriculture

Weight of diesel/gasoline compared with total

energy consumption

Diesel Gasoline

Industry 4,0% 0,0%

Transport 63,1% 14,6%

Road 75,4% 18,4%

Train 66,8% 0,0%

Maritime 82,9% 0,0%

Agriculture 70,5% 0,0%

Agriculture: employment 4,1%. PIB 3,6% (2010)

Transport: 5,5% 5%

Other problems have been fixed, such as zero tax on natural gas and coal preferential

treatment

Page 23: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

What about tourism taxation?

There are figures like “ecotax” whose purpose is not clearly related to environmental

protection and it can lead to competition problems if not applied in all the territories. The

theoretical argument is environmental protection, but often the underlying purpose is tax

collection.

The Balearic ecotax (1 € per overnight) was deleted, but between May 1 2002 and October

2003 got 60 million euros, which served to demolish buildings or buying property in the

historic center of Palma. The eco-tax was levied only to hotel guests and revenue was

earmarked exclusively-in theory-to improve the environment of the islands.

Balearic introduced a new eco-tax on car rental without driver in 2012. Examples of eco-

tax in Spain:

- Balearic ecotax for car rental: levied on the rental company, and depends on the

pollution generated. Exempts subsidized electric and hybrids. Between 3 and 7.5 € per car

per day. Two examples of projects to be funded through the ecotasa in Baleares are hiring

unemployed and the creation of new cultural and tourist itineraries under the name of

“Stroll through the Islands”.

- Ecotax on beverage containers (between 5.6 cents and 2.20 €) (indirectly affects the

tourism sector and overall consumers directly)

Catalonian ecotax: from November 1, 2012. Levied in overnight stays, camping, cottages,

lodges and cruises. Between 0.45 and 2.25 per person per day (except under 16 years). The

Government forecasts point to an income of at least 45 million euros. The money would

go to cover the costs of promotion, development and creation of tourism infrastructure

and protection of tourist areas.

Page 24: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Remember that in Spain has risen further the reduced VAT rate of 8 to 10% (affecting

hotels and restaurants) and other active tourism, theme parks, clubs, golf, rose from 8%

non-taxed 10% but 21%. The contribution of tourism to GDP is 11%, and these

measures have generated a huge rejection, although there are those who reject the

arguments apocalyptic decline in tourism. (Spain is still the fourth most visited

destination in the world (surpassed only by the U.S., France and China) and the second

gets more revenue).

Many times we talk about these taxes and environmental, when really they are not,

because the base does not account for environmental degradation, just the nights

that tourists spend in a given housing. The are a tax on tourism, and they lack the

environmental component. The underlying purpose is the exploitation of a resource

buoyant, at least in Spain.

Page 25: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

It is important to remember how we define "green taxes"? They are those whose

central objective is conservation and environmental protection.

The most important reasons for creating environmental taxes are based on the

following premises:

1) Search behaviors that affect the consumption of certain products that

cause less environmental impact on its surroundings

2) To promote and encourage the investment in clean technology, methods

of proper use of inputs and raw materials with less negative environmental

impacts.

3) Generate revenue that may have specific targets for conservation and

maintenance of natural resources.

Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An

environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays principle ", so internalizes pollution costs

generated by activities that are not considering as such environmental expenses and

damages.

The ultimate goal is to create a disincentive so great that generates a change in

pollutant behavior. Therefore it is essential to quantify the effects of taxation, otherwise

the purpose is merely revenue collection. But the evidence shows that taxes are paid and

the environment continues to deteriorate

Green taxes?

Page 26: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

The key to solving the problem of the misuse of environmental taxation may be in the

internalization of a culture of evaluation.

The cause-effect relationship between green taxation and changes in the behavior of

pollutants must be determined.

If these changes do not even take place, is that green taxation is not working.

The desirable characteristics of an environmental tax

- Environmental effectiveness

- Efficient

- Distribution

- Viable in administrative terms

The double dividend argument reinforces the desirability of green taxation. Although

the primary purpose of green taxation is environmental protection, the revenue

obtained in this way can be used to reduce the pressure generated by other distortionary

tax figures, so that the same revenue is obtained more efficiently and redistributive.

For having a double dividend as a reality it is necessary that the revenue from the

environmental taxation is significant and stable over time.

In Spain, the crisis could open an opportunity to introduce true green taxation, but it is

difficult to start from scratch.

ALL THESE NEED FOR

EVALUATION

Page 27: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

FINAL CONCLUSIONS:

1. Environmental taxation has not really taken seriously in Spain for several reasons.

First, because the aim has been basically tax collection, losing the essence that

justifies environmental taxation. In many cases green taxes have green only the

name. Second, because evaluation is necessary to quantify and correct the

contamination externalities involved. Evaluation is necessary also for measuring

the efficacy of the tools, in terms of externality correction, other side effects, in

terms of redistribution or competitiveness of sectors. The evaluation is not

practiced nor ex ante or ex post.

2. Enviromental taxation in the Spanish central level is small and focused on

the energy sector. Some of the mechanisms that generate negative impacts have

been fixed with the latest amendments as subsidies to coal gas or exemption.

Other persist, such as differentiation between the taxation of gasoline and diesel.

Page 28: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

3. The Spanish environmental taxation has been developed through individual

actions at the regional level, without considering national coverage.

Autonomous Communities mainly tax hydroelectric, nuclear and wind

turbines, but without considering the effect of pollution. (For example non-

emitting or renewable technologies are taxed, which goes against the CO2

reduction targets). The non-homogeneus action of the AC autonomic

decisions prevents the achievement of a uniform treatment on the electricity

sector, which is corrected by the establishment of a fee by RDL 20/2012.

4. Once exhausted the traditional tax bases, during the crisis, Spain may open

an alternative route by using green taxation. What may be an opportunity

to improve the overall tax system and take advantage of the double dividend is

not being done, both for the reasons stated above and the difficulty to "start

from scratch" given a consolidated tax system. For a green tax reform was

successful, it would be necessary to carry out coordinated actions by the ACs

both in terms of legislation such as the use of the collection.

5. If the objective is environmental protection, there are other "command and

control" mechanisms that anticipate the final outcome, which is not achieved

with taxes. But environmental taxation is possibly being used as a

revenue-raising tool in times of crisis.

Page 29: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Thank you for your attention

Page 30: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Other information

Page 31: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

How is the Green Taxes structure in Spain?

Central level:

Environmental taxes:

- Tax on hydrocarbons: taxing products specifically intended for use as fuel, or fuel

additives to increase the volume of motor fuels. Is required throughout the Spanish

territory except Canary Islands, Ceuta and Melilla.

-Electricity tax: levied on the manufacture of electric energy.

- Tax on retail sales of certain hydrocarbons (health penny): ceded to CCAA, its

revenue is affected health spending except autonomic component, which is intended

for environmental purposes. Taxes the consumption of certain hydrocarbons, and is

set only available at retail. From January 1, 2013 and will be included repealing the tax

on hydrocarbons.

--Excise tax on certain means of transport: levied on the first registration of transport

elements

- Excise duty on coal.

Page 32: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Introduction of environmental component:

- VAT: reduced rate for collection services and waste treatment, cleaning of sewers

and wastewater treatment, waste exemption deliveries of paper, cardboard and scrap

glass.

- IS: the gross tax deduction of 10% for investments in property, plant and

equipment for environmental protection

- Income Tax: Business Services, the same under IS, and tax exempt capital grants for

sustainable management of forests in forestry

- Tax on hydrocarbons: consideration of a lower tax rate for unleaded petrol off the

lead, liquefied petroleum gas, oils exemption

Page 33: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Subcentral level (Autonomous Communities):

Environmental taxes:

The regions have done a fairly intensive use of environmental figures. Some examples

are:

Water fees, Civil Protection tax, Big mall tax, Controlled disposal of municipal waste fee,

Incineration of municipal waste fee, Tax on Air Pollution, Tax on gas emissions into the

atmosphere, Tax on radioactive waste repository, Tax on hazardous waste, Tax on plastic

bags for single use, Tax on the development of certain activities that affect the

environment, Sanitation tax, Tax on deposit of waste in landfills, Tax on discharges to

coastal waters, Tax on greenhouse gas emissions into the atmosphere, Tax on

environmental impairment caused by certain uses of water stored, by wind farms and

transport facilities of high voltage electricity, Tax on beneficiaries of hunting…

Page 34: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Subcentral level (Local Taxation)

Environmental taxes:

Tax on motor vehicles (local): levied on the ownership of vehicles of this type

suitable for public roads.

Introduction of environmental component:

- Tax on motor vehicles: facultative bonuses up to 75% depending on the type of fuel

and engine characteristics of the vehicle.

- Real Estate tax: Exemption in terms of the surface populated with slow growing

species for the use of cork or wood, and a bonus of up to 50% when systems are

installed for thermal or electrical.

- Business tax: bonus of up to 50% share of production or use of renewable energy

or cogeneration, undertake activities away from populated areas, or establish

transportation plans that reduce energy consumption or emissions.

- Tax on buildings, facilities and works: a bonus of up to 95% for installation of

electrical or thermal use of solar energy.

Page 35: Green Taxation: A Contribution to Sustainability · Taxation is a form (among several) possible to combat environmental degradation. An environmental tax reflects the "polluter pays

Personal Income tax

35%

Corporate Tax 21%

VAT 32%

Excise Taxes 12%

Tax share 2005

Personal Income tax

44%

Corporate Tax 13%

VAT 32%

Excise Taxes 11%

Tax share 2012

Tax revenue in million €

In million €

Personal Income tax Corporate Tax VAT Excise Taxes Total

1995 31.418 7.605 20.337 11.489 70.848

1996 31.674 8.287 21.784 12.344 74.089

1997 33.367 12.634 24.149 12.446 82.596

1998 34.087 13.977 26.242 14.372 88.677

1999 35.460 14.636 30.735 15.425 96.255

2000 36.766 17.207 33.389 16.056 103.418

2001 41.371 17.215 34.673 16.576 109.835

2002 44.344 21.437 36.913 16.150 118.844

2003 46.451 21.920 40.579 16.853 125.803

2004 47.722 26.020 44.507 17.514 135.763

2005 54.723 32.495 49.870 18.022 155.110

2006 62.813 37.208 54.652 18.602 173.275

2007 72.614 44.823 55.851 19.786 193.075

2008 71.341 27.301 48.021 19.570 166.233

2009 63.857 20.188 33.567 19.349 136.961

2010 66.977 16.198 49.086 19.806 152.067

2011 69.803 16.611 49.302 18.983 154.699

2012 70.619 21.435 50.464 18.209 160.727