2
U N I V E R S I T Y O F C I N C I N N A T I GREEN FUTURES Scenario Planning in Cincinnati’s East End Neighborhood INTRODUCTION The East End currently faces issues of vacancy and risk of flooding, and seeks to address this through development strategies that are tailored to the area’s natural environment. The team proposes two possible futures for the East End, along with design interventions to improve the neighborhood’s resiliency and sustainability in the coming years. To inform our design decisions, we engaged in: community meetings, background and site condition analyses, and landscape infrastructure case studies. DEMOGRAPHICS NEIGHBORHOOD CONDITIONS Cincinnati’s East End neighborhood stretches seven miles along the Ohio River, to the east of downtown. Early industry and railroad construction along the river spurred its development; however, reduced residential investment and increased building deterioration discouraged growth from the mid-20th century on. Population peaked in the 1950s at about 12,000 people, and has steadily declined since. 1,518 people resided in the East End in 2010 (1,692 people in 2000 and 2,415 people in 1990). The East End has been predominately composed of white residents for the past 20 years. From 2000-2010, the percentage of white residents increased from 81.3% to 86%, while the percentage of African-Americans living in the area dropped from 18.7% to 11%. Other racial groups comprise less than 3% of population. In 2010, 50% of neighborhood households were classified as “non-family.” 33% of households were married-couple families, and 17% were single-parent families. The 2010 median income for East End households was $45,592; however, East End household income is not normally distributed—the two largest categories of income earnings are 1) between $30,000-$34,999 (83 households), and 2) between $150,000-$199,999 (74 households). In 2010, 324 individuals (roughly 21% of the population) were classified as living in poverty. The majority of East End residents utilize a private vehicle to travel to work. Very few residents (between 2-5%) used public transportation between 2000-2010. LAND USE & CITY PROPERTY Below are maps of both land use and city-owned property. Over 50% of the land in the East End is owned by Cincinnati, making the city an important player in the future of the neighborhood. The city’s presence can be seen particularly in recreational space and the Lunken Airport. However, there are also strong sections of commercial use in the neighborhood, as well as community services and amenities. There are some differences between the land use map and the city owned property map. For instance, the area north of the Lunken Airport is labeled as “heavy industry,” although in reality that is in part the location of a golf course. However, the land use map still illustrates the prevalence of industrial use and the large swaths of land dedicated to low-intensity uses such as junkyards and chemical storage. 0 0.65 1.3 1.95 2.6 0.325 Miles EXISTING BUSINESS & SERVICES Along with city-owned land, there are important sections of commercial and industrial use in the East End. For instance, Eli’s Barbecue is an anchor for the area that the neighborhood hopes to turn into an entertainment district. BrewRiver GastroPub is another burgeoning destination restaurant/bar that may spur further restaurant and retail development. Historically, the East End was heavily industrial, and some of this character still exists along the river. The western tip of the neighborhood still has active light industry. In the southern portion are several used car and auto parts dealers. There are also other business options in this area, like the Rivertowne Marina and its accompanying businesses such as the Four Seasons Yacht Club and Sea Ray of Cincinnati. TRANSPORTATION ACCESS The Transportation Networks map displays the limited accessibility in the East End due to few external access points, limited intersections, and numerous cul-de-sacs. There is one main access road into the East End from the East, four from the North, and one from the West. The East End is served by one bus route, route 28, which serves the area approximately every hour. Bus routes 24 and 30 are also accessed by the community, but the stops are in Columbia Tusculum to the North. Bike lanes were recently installed on Riverside Dr., which will be a section of the Ohio River Trail that will eventually stretch 23 miles from Coney Island to Sayler Park. The Oasis Commuter Rail line is currently being studied, and could provide transit to the area in the future. VACANT PROPERTIES Vacancy rates are high in the East End neighborhood. The map below shows vacant parcels in red with all other, presumably occupied or public right-of-way parcels, in beige. Vacant parcels tend to be either along Columbia Parkway to the north or along the Ohio River to the south. The land area in the East End totals about 2.75 square miles. Of that, 2.46 square miles of the parcels are occupied (roughly 89%). That leaves about 0.29 square miles (or 11% of the total land) that are vacant. The chart below on the right displays the share of vacancy based on the area of parcels. The chart below on the left, on the other hand, shows the percentage of vacant parcels based on the number of parcels. There are 3,093 parcels in the East End; of them, 2,147 are occupied and 946 are vacant, or 69% and 31% respectively. This means that even though only 11% of the total area is vacant, the number of vacant parcels are disproportionately higher, consuming 31% of the total number of parcels. WATER & VEGETATION With miles of riverbank, the East End Neighborhood is vulnerable to natural changes in the rivers trajectory, as well as flooding. Water quality remains a high concern for not only the East End Neighborhood, but also Cincinnati and the Ohio River Watershed as a whole, as The Ohio River Basin is occupied by over 25 million people and provides drinking water for more than five million people. Frequency of Moderate Stage Flooding or Above: Flooded 37 times in the last 114 years 32% chance of a Moderate Stage flood or Greater Currently, the East End Neighborhood supports a large percentage of land with vegetative cover, with vegetation along the river serving as a buffer. Many of the trees, shrubs, grasses, and flowers found in the East End Neighborhood are moisture tolerant and can withstand having their roots submerged in water. RECREATION OPPORTUNITIES The East End holds different recreational opportunities. The river front section of the community is limited by the existing infrastructure. The North Eastern portion and Central areas of the community represent the optimal areas for recreational opportunities, with the Lunken Complex, Schmidt Recreation complex, and Otto Armleder being among the already existing establishments. The community of the East End offers a wide range of recreational options, from high end boating, to recreational ball fields, to basic walking trails. This range of opportunities attracts a diverse socioeconomic demographic to the community. The East End has great potential to be the “playground” of Cincinnati due to the proximity to the downtown core and to the pre-existing recreational infrastructure. SOURCES [1] City Planning Department. 1992. East End Riverfront: Community Development Plan and Guidelines. Cincinnati, OH. [2] Community Design Center. 2014. East End Garden District Study: An Urban Design Menu: Exhilarate Activate Savor. Cincinnati, OH. [3] Department of Planning and Buildings. 2012. East End Statistical Neighborhood Approximation. Cincinnati, OH. Accessed February 16, 2014. http://www.cincinnati-oh.gov/planning/linkservid/ B4ABFF98-EC1B-9A36-D291C3F90AA55325/showMeta/0. [4] U.S. Census Bureau. U.S. Demography 1970 to Present. Prepared by Social Explorer. Accessed February 16, 2014. http://www.socialexplorer.com/89AACD3A4F1E4E1/explore. [5] 2010. Ecology: The River and Its Watershed. Ohio River Foundation. Accessed February 18, 2014. http://www.ohioriverfdn.org/about_the_river/ecology/index.html. [6] Cronin, Amanda. “Restoring Paradise in Moscow, Idaho.” landandwater.com. http://www.landandwater.com/features/vol47no2/vol47no2_1.html (accessed April 13, 2014). [7] City of Cincinnati Recreation Commission. “THERAPEUTIC RECREATION.” cincinnati-oh.gov. http://www.cincinnati-oh.gov/recreation/inclusion-therapeutic-recreation/. (accessed April 13, 2014). [8] City of Cincinnati Recreation Commission. “Lindner Tennis Center.” cincinnati-oh.gov. http://www.cincinnati-oh.gov/recreation/athletics/tennis/lindner-tennis-center/. (accessed April 13, 2014). [9] Four Seasons Marina. “Welcom to Four Seasons Marina!.” fourseasonsmarina.com. http://www.fourseasonsmarina.com/. (accessed April 13, 2014). TEAM Ian Blanding Ellen Deatrick Alan Edwards Justin Lamorella Lucy Stoll Sara Woolf University of Cincinnati Master of Community Planning students Total Privately Owned Land Total City Owned Land 0 0.75 1.5 2.25 3 0.375 Miles Legend Land Use Commercial Education Heavy Industry Institutional Light Industry MultiFamily Mixed Use Unknown Office Parks and Recreation Public Service Planned Unit Development Single Family Two Family Vacant Rivers Cincinnati Neighborhoods Other Legend City Owned Land AIRPORT PLAYGROUND COLUMBIA PARKWAY EDEN PARK WATERFRONT FERRY STREET PARK & GREENSPACE FIRE HOUSE #18 FORMERLY CARREL STREET UNLOADING TERM GREENSPACE LEBLOND ATHLETIC FIELD & REC CENTER LITTLE MIAMI RIVER SCENIC PARK LITTLE MIAMI SPORTS COMPLEX LITTLE MIAMI WASTE TREATMENT PLANT LUNKEN AIRPORT MAIN PUMPING STATION MEMORIAL PIONEER CEMETERY RAKESTRAW FIELD & PLAYGROUND SCHMIDT PLAYFIELD SCHOFF HOCKEY FIELD TURKEY RIDGE PLAYGROUND WATER CONDUIT PRIVATELY OWNED LAND RIVERS CINCINNATI NEIGHBORHOODS OTHER CITY OWNED LAND Other Land COLUMBIA PARKWAY FIRE HOUSE #18 FORMERLY CARREL STREET UNLOADING TERMINAL LITTLE MIAMI WASTE TREATMENT PLANT LUNKEN AIRPORT MAIN PUMPING STATION MEMORIAL PIONEER CEMETERY WATER CONDUIT OTHER CITY OWNED LAND GREENSPACE TOTAL Privately Owned vs. City Owned Property City Owned Property City Owned Property - Greenspace Prevalence East End Land Use Ault Park Sunrise, 2011. aultparksunrise.com Google Maps, 2014. googlemaps.com Urban Ohio, 2006. www.urbanohio.com Queen City Tour, 2011.queencitytour.blogspot.com ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! EAST END WALNUT HILLS HYDE PARK MOUNT LOOKOUT LINWOOD COLUMBIA TUSCULUM EAST WALNUT HILLS MOUNT ADAMS CALIFORNIA MOUNT WASHINGTON CBD/RIVERFRONT AVONDALE MOUNT AUBURN ± Legend Intersections ! Culdesacs Access Points Oasis Line Street Hierarchy Highway Other Principle Arterial Minor Arterial Collector Local River East End 0 0.4 0.8 0.2 Miles EAST END WALNUT HILLS COLUMBIA TUSCULUM MOUNT LOOKOUT HYDE PARK EAST WALNUT HILLS LINWOOD MOUNT ADAMS CALIFORNIA CBD/RIVERFRONT ± Legend Sidewalks Streets River East End 0 0.5 1 0.25 Miles Bike Infrastructure ± Legend Pavement Buildings River FEMA floodway 2010 1997 Flood 100 Year Flood Floodstage: 56 East End 0 0.5 1 0.25 Miles Nate Wessel - http://www.cincymap.org/ OKI - Eastern Corridor Population Density, Census 2010 Median Household Income, Census 2010 Household Types Socialexplorer.com Vacant Properties by Number LINWOOD CALIFORNIA WALNUT HILLS HYDE PARK COLUMBIA TUSCULUM MOUNT WASHINGTON EAST WALNUT HILLS CBD/RIVERFRONT MOUNT ADAMS ± Legend Parcels East End Occupied Vacant 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 Miles 0.75 1 11% 89% % Vacant Parcels % Occupied Parcels Vacant Parcels by Area 31% 69% % Vacant Parcels % Occupied Parcels Vacant Parcels by Total Number St. Rosa Church Riverview East Academy Lunken Airfields Lunken Airport Flood Plains and Flood History The Oasis Rail Line Transportation Networks Bus Routes Bike Routes CAGIS 2012 CAGIS 2012 [10] Metropolitan Sewer District of Greater Cincinnati. “MONTHLY PROJECT REPORTS.” projectgroundwork.org. http://projectgroundwork.org/downloads/l3/MonthlyProjectReport_2013.05.31_Little%20Miami.pdf. (accessed April 13, 2014). [11] Ohio River Launch Club. “Welcome!.” orlconline.org. http://www.orlconline.org/. (accessed April 13, 2014). [12] The Ohio Erie Trail. “About Us.” ohiotoerietrail.org. http://www.ohiotoerietrail.org/Home.aspx. http://www.ohioriverpaddlefest.org/ohio-river-trail/. (accessed April 13, 2014). [13] Landscape Architecture Foundation. ”Buffalo Bayou Promenade Case Study.” www.lafoundation.org/. (accessed February 25, 2014) [14] Buffalo Bayou Partnership. “Sabine to Bagby.”http://www.buffalobayou.org/sabinebagby.html (accessed February 25, 2014) [15] Global Eco-village Network (GEN). ”Buffalo Bayou Promenade Case Study.” http://gen.ecovillage.org/. (accessed February 28, 2014) [16] Kirby, Andy. “Redefining social and environmental relations at the eco-village at Ithaca: A case study” Journal of Environmental Psychology 23 (2003): 325 -331. [17] Cincinnati Area GIS, Accessed 2014. [18] City of Cincinnati, Transportation and Engineering. About Lunken Airport. 2014. CAGIS 2014 CAGIS 2014 CAGIS 2014 CAGIS 2014 Markland Locks & Dam East End after 1997 Flood via Flickr, William Alden III http://www.cincinnativiews.net/floods.htm http://wwx.inhs.illinois.edu/research/ vmg/bhnysckl/ Socialexplorer.com Four Seasons Marina http://www.yelp.com/biz/four-seasons-marina-cincinnati http://www.building-cincinnati.com/2011/02/open-house-to-share-recommendations-for.html Lunken Bike Trail Ohio River Trail Reeves Golf Course http://www.ohioriverpaddlefest.org/ohio-river-trail/ http://www.cincinnatiusa.com/Attractions/detail.asp?AttractionID=263 Bush Honeysuckle Purple Loosestrife http://www.kingcounty.gov/environment/animal- sAndPlants/noxious-weeds/weed-identification/ purple-loosestrife.aspx http://www.lrl.usace.army.mil/Missions/CivilWorks/Navigation/ LocksandDams.aspx http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:East-End-Cincinnati-map.jpg

GREEN FUTURES - University of Cincinnati€¦ · UNIVERSIT Y OF CINCINNATI GREEN FUTURES Scenario Planning in Cincinnati’s East End Neighborhood INTRODUCTION The East End currently

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: GREEN FUTURES - University of Cincinnati€¦ · UNIVERSIT Y OF CINCINNATI GREEN FUTURES Scenario Planning in Cincinnati’s East End Neighborhood INTRODUCTION The East End currently

U N I V E R S I T Y O F C I N C I N N A T I

GREEN FUTURESScenario Planning in Cincinnati’s East End Neighborhood

I N T R O D U C T I O N

The East End currently faces issues of vacancy and risk of flooding, and seeks to address this through development strategies that are tailored

to the area’s natural environment. The team proposes two possible futures for the East End, along with design interventions to improve

the neighborhood’s resiliency and sustainability in the coming years. To inform our design decisions, we engaged in: community meetings,

background and site condition analyses, and landscape infrastructure case studies.

D E M O G R A P H I C S

N E I G H B O R H O O D C O N D I T I O N S

Cincinnati’s East End neighborhood stretches seven miles along the Ohio River, to the east of downtown. Early industry and railroad construction along the river spurred its development; however, reduced residential investment and increased building deterioration discouraged growth from the mid-20th century on. Population peaked in the 1950s at about 12,000 people, and has steadily declined since. 1,518 people resided in the East End in 2010 (1,692 people in 2000 and 2,415 people in 1990).

The East End has been predominately composed of white residents for the past 20 years. From 2000-2010, the percentage of white residents increased from 81.3% to 86%, while the percentage of African-Americans living in the area dropped from 18.7% to 11%. Other racial groups comprise less than 3% of population. In 2010, 50% of neighborhood households were classified as “non-family.” 33% of households were married-couple families, and 17% were single-parent families.

The 2010 median income for East End households was $45,592; however, East End household income is not normally distributed—the two largest categories of income earnings are 1) between $30,000-$34,999 (83 households), and 2) between $150,000-$199,999 (74 households). In 2010, 324 individuals (roughly 21% of the population) were classified as living in poverty. The majority of East End residents utilize a private vehicle to travel to work. Very few residents (between 2-5%) used public transportation between 2000-2010.

LAND USE & CITY PROPERTYBelow are maps of both land use and city-owned property. Over 50% of the land in the East End is owned by Cincinnati, making the city an important player in the future of the neighborhood. The city’s presence can be seen particularly in recreational space and the Lunken Airport. However, there are also strong sections of commercial use in the neighborhood, as well as community services and amenities. There are some differences between the land use map and the city owned property map. For instance, the area north of the Lunken Airport is labeled as “heavy industry,” although in reality that is in part the location of a golf course. However, the land use map still illustrates the prevalence of industrial use and the large swaths of land dedicated to low-intensity uses such as junkyards and chemical storage.

0 0.65 1.3 1.95 2.60.325Miles

Legend

City  Owned  Land

 

AIRPORT  PLAYGROUND

COLUMBIA  PARKWAY

EDEN  PARK  WATERFRONT

FERRY  STREET  PARK  &  GREENSPACE

FIRE  HOUSE  #18

FORMERLY  CARREL  STREET  UNLOADING  TERMINAL

GREENSPACE

LEBLOND  ATHLETIC  FIELD  &  REC  CENTER

LITTLE  MIAMI  RIVER  SCENIC  PARK

LITTLE  MIAMI  SPORTS  COMPLEX

LITTLE  MIAMI  WASTE  TREATMENT  PLANT

LUNKEN  AIRPORT

MAIN  PUMPING  STATION

MEMORIAL  PIONEER  CEMETERY

RAKESTRAW  FIELD  &  PLAYGROUND

SCHMIDT  PLAYFIELD

SCHOFF  HOCKEY  FIELD

TURKEY  RIDGE  PLAYGROUND

WATER  CONDUIT

PRIVATELY  OWNED  LAND

RIVERS

CINCINNATI  NEIGHBORHOODS

OTHER  CITY  OWNED  LAND

Other  Land

EXISTING BUSINESS & SERVICESAlong with city-owned land, there are important sections of commercial and industrial use in the East End. For instance, Eli’s Barbecue is an anchor for the area that the neighborhood hopes to turn into an entertainment district. BrewRiver GastroPub is another burgeoning destination restaurant/bar that may spur further restaurant and retail development.

Historically, the East End was heavily industrial, and some of this character still exists along the river. The western tip of the neighborhood still has active light industry. In the southern portion are several used car and auto parts dealers. There are also other business options in this area, like the Rivertowne Marina and its accompanying businesses such as the Four Seasons Yacht Club and Sea Ray of Cincinnati.

TRANSPORTATION ACCESSThe Transportation Networks map displays the limited accessibility in the East End due to few external access points, limited intersections, and numerous cul-de-sacs. There is one main access road into the East End from the East, four from the North, and one from the West. The East End is served by one bus route, route 28, which serves the area approximately every hour. Bus routes 24 and 30 are also accessed by the community, but the stops are in Columbia Tusculum to the North. Bike lanes were recently installed on Riverside Dr., which will be a section of the Ohio River Trail that will eventually stretch 23 miles from Coney Island to Sayler Park. The Oasis Commuter Rail line is currently being studied, and could provide transit to the area in the future.

VACANT PROPERTIESVacancy rates are high in the East End neighborhood. The map below shows vacant parcels in red with all other, presumably occupied or public right-of-way parcels, in beige. Vacant parcels tend to be either along Columbia Parkway to the north or along the Ohio River to the south. The land area in the East End totals about 2.75 square miles. Of that, 2.46 square miles of the parcels are occupied (roughly 89%). That leaves about 0.29 square miles (or 11% of the total land) that are vacant. The chart below on the right displays the share of vacancy based on the area of parcels. The chart below on the left, on the other hand, shows the percentage of vacant parcels based on the number of parcels. There are 3,093 parcels in the East End; of them, 2,147 are occupied and 946 are vacant, or 69% and 31% respectively. This means that even though only 11% of the total area is vacant, the number of vacant parcels are disproportionately higher, consuming 31% of the total number of parcels.

WATER & VEGETATIONWith miles of riverbank, the East End Neighborhood is vulnerable to natural changes in the rivers trajectory, as well as flooding. Water quality remains a high concern for not only the East End Neighborhood, but also Cincinnati and the Ohio River Watershed as a whole, as The Ohio River Basin is occupied by over 25 million people and provides drinking water for more than five million people.

Frequency of Moderate Stage Flooding or Above: Flooded 37 times in the last 114 years 32% chance of a Moderate Stage flood or Greater

Currently, the East End Neighborhood supports a large percentage of land with vegetative cover, with vegetation along the river serving as a buffer. Many of the trees, shrubs, grasses, and flowers found in the East End Neighborhood are moisture tolerant and can withstand having their roots submerged in water.

RECREATION OPPORTUNITIESThe East End holds different recreational opportunities. The river front section of the community is limited by the existing infrastructure. The North Eastern portion and Central areas of the community represent the optimal areas for recreational opportunities, with the Lunken Complex, Schmidt Recreation complex, and Otto Armleder being among the already existing establishments.

The community of the East End offers a wide range of recreational options, from high end boating, to recreational ball fields, to basic walking trails. This range of opportunities attracts a diverse socioeconomic demographic to the community. The East End has great potential to be the “playground” of Cincinnati due to the proximity to the downtown core and to the pre-existing recreational infrastructure.

S O U R C E S[1] City Planning Department. 1992. East End Riverfront: Community Development Plan and Guidelines. Cincinnati, OH. [2] Community Design Center. 2014. East End Garden District Study: An Urban Design Menu: Exhilarate Activate Savor. Cincinnati, OH.[3] Department of Planning and Buildings. 2012. East End Statistical Neighborhood Approximation. Cincinnati, OH. Accessed February 16, 2014. http://www.cincinnati-oh.gov/planning/linkservid/B4ABFF98-EC1B-9A36-D291C3F90AA55325/showMeta/0.[4] U.S. Census Bureau. U.S. Demography 1970 to Present. Prepared by Social Explorer. Accessed February 16, 2014. http://www.socialexplorer.com/89AACD3A4F1E4E1/explore.[5] 2010. Ecology: The River and Its Watershed. Ohio River Foundation. Accessed February 18, 2014. http://www.ohioriverfdn.org/about_the_river/ecology/index.html.[6] Cronin, Amanda. “Restoring Paradise in Moscow, Idaho.” landandwater.com. http://www.landandwater.com/features/vol47no2/vol47no2_1.html (accessed April 13, 2014).[7] City of Cincinnati Recreation Commission. “THERAPEUTIC RECREATION.” cincinnati-oh.gov. http://www.cincinnati-oh.gov/recreation/inclusion-therapeutic-recreation/. (accessed April 13, 2014).[8] City of Cincinnati Recreation Commission. “Lindner Tennis Center.” cincinnati-oh.gov. http://www.cincinnati-oh.gov/recreation/athletics/tennis/lindner-tennis-center/. (accessed April 13, 2014).[9] Four Seasons Marina. “Welcom to Four Seasons Marina!.” fourseasonsmarina.com. http://www.fourseasonsmarina.com/. (accessed April 13, 2014).

T E A MIan BlandingEllen DeatrickAlan EdwardsJustin LamorellaLucy StollSara Woolf

University of Cincinnati Master of Community Planning students

Total  Privately  Owned  Land  

Total  City  Owned  Land  

0 0.75 1.5 2.25 30.375Miles

Legend

Land  Use

Commercial

Education

Heavy  Industry

Institutional

Light  Industry

Multi-­Family

Mixed  Use

Unknown

Office

Parks  and  Recreation

Public  Service

Planned  Unit  Development

Single  Family

Two  Family

Vacant

Rivers

Cincinnati  Neighborhoods

Other

Legend

City  Owned  Land

 

AIRPORT  PLAYGROUND

COLUMBIA  PARKWAY

EDEN  PARK  WATERFRONT

FERRY  STREET  PARK  &  GREENSPACE

FIRE  HOUSE  #18

FORMERLY  CARREL  STREET  UNLOADING  TERMINAL

GREENSPACE

LEBLOND  ATHLETIC  FIELD  &  REC  CENTER

LITTLE  MIAMI  RIVER  SCENIC  PARK

LITTLE  MIAMI  SPORTS  COMPLEX

LITTLE  MIAMI  WASTE  TREATMENT  PLANT

LUNKEN  AIRPORT

MAIN  PUMPING  STATION

MEMORIAL  PIONEER  CEMETERY

RAKESTRAW  FIELD  &  PLAYGROUND

SCHMIDT  PLAYFIELD

SCHOFF  HOCKEY  FIELD

TURKEY  RIDGE  PLAYGROUND

WATER  CONDUIT

PRIVATELY  OWNED  LAND

RIVERS

CINCINNATI  NEIGHBORHOODS

OTHER  CITY  OWNED  LAND

Other  Land

City  Owned  Property  Breakdown  -­‐  Greenspace  Collapsed  

COLUMBIA  PARKWAY  FIRE  HOUSE  #18  FORMERLY  CARREL  STREET  UNLOADING  TERMINAL  LITTLE  MIAMI  WASTE  TREATMENT  PLANT  LUNKEN  AIRPORT  MAIN  PUMPING  STATION  MEMORIAL  PIONEER  CEMETERY  WATER  CONDUIT  OTHER  CITY  OWNED  LAND  GREENSPACE  TOTAL  

Privately Owned vs. City Owned Property

City Owned Property

City Owned Property - Greenspace Prevalence

East End Land Use

Ault Park Sunrise, 2011. aultparksunrise.com Google Maps, 2014. googlemaps.com

Urban Ohio, 2006. www.urbanohio.com

Queen City Tour, 2011.queencitytour.blogspot.com

!

!!

!

!

!!!!

!!

!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

EAST  END

WALNUT  HILLS

HYDE  PARK

MOUNT  LOOKOUT

LINWOODCOLUMBIA  TUSCULUM

EAST  WALNUT  HILLS

MOUNT  ADAMS

CALIFORNIA

MOUNT  WASHINGTON

CBD/RIVERFRONT

AVONDALE

MOUNT  AUBURN

±

Legend

Intersections!Culdesacs

Access  Points

Oasis  Line

Street  Hierarchy

Highway

Other  Principle  Arterial

Minor  Arterial

Collector

Local

River

East  End 0 0.4 0.80.2 Miles

EAST END

WALNUT HILLS

COLUMBIA TUSCULUM

MOUNT LOOKOUT

HYDE PARKEAST WALNUT HILLS

LINWOODMOUNT ADAMS

CALIFORNIA

CBD/RIVERFRONT

±LegendSidewalks

Streets

River

East End 0 0.5 10.25 Miles

Bike Infrastructure

±

LegendPavement

Buildings

River

FEMA floodway 2010

1997 Flood

100 Year Flood

Floodstage: 56

East End

0 0.5 10.25 Miles

Nate Wessel - http://www.cincymap.org/

OKI - Eastern Corridor

Population Density, Census 2010

Median Household Income, Census 2010

Household Types

Socialexplorer.com

Vacant Properties by NumberLINWOOD

CALIFORNIA

WALNUT HILLS

HYDE PARK

COLUMBIA TUSCULUM

MOUNT WASHINGTON

EAST WALNUT HILLS

CBD/RIVERFRONT

MOUNT ADAMS

±LegendParcels East End

Occupied

Vacant0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1

Miles

LINWOOD

CALIFORNIA

WALNUT HILLS

HYDE PARK

COLUMBIA TUSCULUM

MOUNT WASHINGTON

EAST WALNUT HILLS

CBD/RIVERFRONT

MOUNT ADAMS

±LegendParcels East End

Occupied

Vacant0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1

Miles

11%

89%

% Vacant Parcels % Occupied Parcels

Vacant Parcels by Area

31%

69%

% Vacant Parcels % Occupied Parcels

Vacant Parcels by Total Number

St. Rosa ChurchRiverview East Academy Lunken Airfields

Lunken Airport

Flood Plains and Flood History

The Oasis Rail Line Transportation Networks

Bus Routes Bike RoutesCAGIS 2012

CAGIS 2012

[10] Metropolitan Sewer District of Greater Cincinnati. “MONTHLY PROJECT REPORTS.” projectgroundwork.org. http://projectgroundwork.org/downloads/l3/MonthlyProjectReport_2013.05.31_Little%20Miami.pdf. (accessed April 13, 2014).[11] Ohio River Launch Club. “Welcome!.” orlconline.org. http://www.orlconline.org/. (accessed April 13, 2014).[12] The Ohio Erie Trail. “About Us.” ohiotoerietrail.org. http://www.ohiotoerietrail.org/Home.aspx. http://www.ohioriverpaddlefest.org/ohio-river-trail/. (accessed April 13, 2014).[13] Landscape Architecture Foundation. ”Buffalo Bayou Promenade Case Study.” www.lafoundation.org/. (accessed February 25, 2014)[14] Buffalo Bayou Partnership. “Sabine to Bagby.”http://www.buffalobayou.org/sabinebagby.html(accessed February 25, 2014)[15] Global Eco-village Network (GEN). ”Buffalo Bayou Promenade Case Study.” http://gen.ecovillage.org/. (accessed February 28, 2014)[16] Kirby, Andy. “Redefining social and environmental relations at the eco-village atIthaca: A case study” Journal of Environmental Psychology 23 (2003): 325 -331.[17] Cincinnati Area GIS, Accessed 2014. [18] City of Cincinnati, Transportation and Engineering. About Lunken Airport. 2014.

CAGIS 2014 CAGIS 2014

CAGIS 2014

CAGIS 2014

Markland Locks & DamEast End after 1997 Flood

via Flickr, William Alden IIIhttp://www.cincinnativiews.net/floods.htm

http://wwx.inhs.illinois.edu/research/vmg/bhnysckl/

Socialexplorer.com

Four Seasons Marina

http://www.yelp.com/biz/four-seasons-marina-cincinnati

http://www.building-cincinnati.com/2011/02/open-house-to-share-recommendations-for.html

Lunken Bike Trail

Ohio River Trail

Reeves Golf Course

http://www.ohioriverpaddlefest.org/ohio-river-trail/

http://www.cincinnatiusa.com/Attractions/detail.asp?AttractionID=263

Bush Honeysuckle Purple Loosestrife

http://www.kingcounty.gov/environment/animal-sAndPlants/noxious-weeds/weed-identification/

purple-loosestrife.aspx

http://www.lrl.usace.army.mil/Missions/CivilWorks/Navigation/LocksandDams.aspx

http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:East-End-Cincinnati-map.jpg

Page 2: GREEN FUTURES - University of Cincinnati€¦ · UNIVERSIT Y OF CINCINNATI GREEN FUTURES Scenario Planning in Cincinnati’s East End Neighborhood INTRODUCTION The East End currently

U N I V E R S I T Y O F C I N C I N N A T I

GREEN FUTURESScenario Planning in Cincinnati’s East End Neighborhood

E X I S T I N G S I T E & I N T E R V E N T I O N S

F R A M E W O R K A

Based on research on the community’s current profile and conditions and an exploration of case studies of green infrastructure best practices, the team determined two possible scenarios for the future of the East End:

In Framework A, the East End capitalizes on industrial assets like its flat topography and proximity to the river, rail lines, and road networks to become an ideal location for green industry.

In Framework B, the East End capitalizes on its proximity to the Ohio and Little Miami Rivers, and to the national bicycle route that will eventually cross through the neighborhood, to become a recreational destination.

Under both frameworks, the neighborhood can take steps to mitigate the effects of flooding, severe weather events, and climate change.

The map to the left identifies the neighborhood areas targeted for design interventions: bank stabilization is represented by the green line, brownfield remediation will take place within the purple overlay, slope stabilization is shown with the red dotted line, and eco-friendly development will occur within the green overlay.

S O U R C E SB a n k S t a b i l i z a t i o n[1] Friends of the Cacapon. “Riverbanks - How to Stabilize and Repair Them.” cacaponriver.org. http://www.cacaponriver.org/index.php/home-owners-packet/9-riverbanks-how-to-stabilize-and-repair-them. (accessed April 13, 2014).[2] Hanstein, Bobbie. “River bank stabilization project: ‘We finally licked that problem’”. dailybulldog.com. http://www.dailybulldog.com/db/features/river-bank-stabilization-project-we-finally-licked-that-problem/comment-page-1/ (accessed April 13, 2014).[3] Smith, Christopher, Ritter, Laura. “Engineering With Nature Alternative Techniques to Riprap Bank Stabilization.” fema.gov. http://www.fema.gov/pdf/about/regions/regionx/Engineering_With_Nature_Web.pdf (accessed April 13, 2014).

B r o w n f i e l d R e m e d i a t i o n[1] Lay, Jillian Donovan. 1999. “Phytoremediation of Trichloroethylene (TCE).” Restoration and Reclamation Review. http://conservancy.umn.edu/bitstream/59470/1/5.4.Lay.pdf.[2] The Remediation Technoloies Development Forum. “Evaluation of Phytoremediation for Management of Chlorinated Solvents in Soil and Groundwater.” Environmental Protection Agency. http://www.rtdf.org/public/phyto/chlor_solv_management.pdf

T E A MIan BlandingEllen DeatrickAlan EdwardsJustin LamorellaLucy StollSara Woolf

University of Cincinnati Master of Community Planning students

[3] Lasat, Mitch. “The Use of Plants for the Removal of Toxic Metals from Contaminated Soil.” http://www.plantstress.com/articles/toxicity_m/phytoremed.pdfc to dolorpo rempers pietur ma duciam doluptatum cores core sendignim experunt optatetur?

Slope Stabilization[1]City of Milwaukee Department of Public Works[2] Landscape Architecture Foundation, Case Study Briefs[3] Rivers by Design

Eco Development[1] Global Eco-village Network (GEN). ”Buffalo Bayou Promenade Case Study.” http://gen.ecovillage.org/. (accessed February 28, 2014)[2] Kirby, Andy. “Redefining social and environmental relations at the eco-village atIthaca: A case study” Journal of Environmental Psychology 23 (2003): 325 -331.

F R A M E W O R K B

G r e e n I n d u s t r i a l G r o w t hAssumptions:

• The East End will see green industrial growth. Businesses seeking to participate in green industrial practices will locate in the neighborhood, increasing the amount of land use devoted to industry.

• With the expansion of industry, the shipping sector will also grow, requiring more riverfront space.

• Employment will increase in the area to fill positions needed by the new industries.

• The demand for public transit will increase, as workers will want a way to easily access jobs.

• Limited mixed-use residential development will follow the increase in industry, as some workers will want and/or need to live in close proximity to work.

• Overall competition for physical space increases with greater demand for industrial land use, as well as for residential land use for industry employees.

• Recreational opportunities will become more limited, as green space and riverfront space are taken over by business.

R e c r e a t i o n a l D e s t i n a t i o nAssumptions:

• The East End will have increased environmental improvement opportunities.

• The neighborhood’s population will grow, as people seek to live in an environmentally-rich place close to the city.

• Industry in the East End will experience a slight decrease, as land use will turn over to recreational uses.

• The demand for public transit will increase, as residents will want easy access to the city, and visitors will want to easily access the natural amenities in the East End.

• Bike trails will bring visitors and tourists to the area, and will provide a viable commuting option for East End residents.

• An entertainment district will follow transit-oriented development along the Oasis Line and bike trails.

• Recreational opportunities will increase, as the neighborhood will prioritize open green space and riverfront space.

• Climate change mitigation strategies will be imperative to preserve the natural environment of the East End.

BANK STABILIZATION

Propert Loss Along the Ohio

Ü0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.80.1Miles

LegendProperty Lines streatching into the Ohio

Property Lines Timber Pilings

Ohio River

Streets

BROWNFIELD REMEDIATIONIf green industry continues to grow, what strategies can the East End use to mitigate current and future pollution?

Full remediation may not be an option if green industry prospers, but steps can be taken to ensure environmental health and safety. A particular concern is the proximity to the river, as chemicals and pollutants can run off or enter the Ohio River through groundwater. Certain plants may slow the flow of water from these sites.

TCE, found in 50% of Superfund National Priority List sites, is a common industrial contaminant, & difficult to remove due to its physical properties. However, some studies show popular trees to be incredibly effective at not only removing TCE , but depressing the water table and making it difficult for water, and thus, contaminants, to move. Because of their excellent hydraulic control capabilities, poplars make an excellent barrier plant between the river and industrial sites.

SLOPE STABILIZATIONHow will the slope along Riverside Drive be effected by the increased use of the rail transit line as green industrial growth occurs?

Because of the increase in rail and pedestrian traffic at the crest of the hillside bordering Riverside Drive, the slope will require the application of engineered slope stabilization methods. Gabion walls and terracing will allow for the utilization of sections of the slope as public space and landscaping opportunities. These methods will prevent erosion as well as mitigate the increased quantity of contaminated stormwater runoff caused by the increase in development and transit.

Slope Stabilization techniques utilized:Gabion walls & Terracing

ECO DEVELOPMENT

D E S I G N P R O P O S A L S

In the case of limited land availability, recreational opportunities, and mixed-use residential development how will the demand for housing change?

If the East End were to experience more green industrial growth and shipping opportunities, housing in the Garden District would be more expensive and fewer people would live there because of the limited space and close proximity to industry. A small mixed-use development close to the Oasis Line transit station could be supported. The planting of trees and flood resistant plants would help to mitigate flooding.

How will the demand for housing change in response to increased population, recreational and environmental opportunities, and public transit demand ?

The East end could develop a Transit-Oriented Eco-development to accommodate a mix of land uses and incomes, increased population, climate mitigation, and low impact development. This eco-development would include sustainable flood resistant homes, open space for gardening and flood mitigation, trails and recreational opportunities, and renewable energy sources.

0 0.05 0.10.025 Miles

±Commuter Station

Oasis Commuter Train

Streets

Elevated 0-5’

FEMA Floodway

Legend

Elevated 13-19’

Elevated 5-13’

Farming/Green Space

Bike Path

Pedestrian Path

Green Industry

Mixed Use Development

0 0.05 0.10.025 Miles ±

Commuter Station

Oasis Commuter Train

Streets

Elevated 0-5’

FEMA Floodway

Legend

Elevated 13-19’

Elevated 5-13’

Farming/Green Space

Pedestrian Path

East End Eco-village

Bike Path

Mixed Use Development

Sustainable & Flood Resistant Homes East End Eco-Development

Flood Resistant Building Eco Home

How will the slope along Riverside Drive be effected by the increased use of the rail transit line as recreational opportunities increase?

In order to prevent further erosion of the slope bordering Riverside Drive, landscaping interventions will occur at the crest of the slope bordering the rail line. The intelligent use of vegetation will mitigate the effects of stormwater runoff, and create a more stable ecostystem on the slope. By utilizing less invasive methods of slope stabilization, the natural character of the slope will be maintained, thus adding to the recreational character of the East End Neighborhood.

Slope Stabilization techniques utilized: Varied Plantings & Vegetated Geogrids

How can former industrial sites be made safe and usable for recreational growth in the East End?

Contaminants from previous industrial uses can make the land unsafe, especially for the uses envisioned for the East End in this scenario. Phytoremediation can be used to remove some or all of this contamination.

If industrial use is to decline, salvage yards will be among the first to go. South of the airport, junkyards are sprawling, have excellent visibility from the road (good for future development, bad for current conditions), do little to spur commercial or recreational development, and are aesthetically displeasing. Research shows salvage yards can be remediated using a variety of hyperaccumulator plants that take up heavy metals, a major contaminant found in salvage yards. Heavy metals are expensive to remediate, up to $250/yd3. Phytoremediation is more cost effective at ~$80/yd3.

How will bank stabilization along the Ohio River be accommodated with the increase in Green Industrial growth and demand for shipping?

Because of the increase in green industry and shipping on the Ohio River, the application of bioengineered bank stabilization techniques are needed to assure protection for the land based industries and unloading facilities. Timber Pilings will provide an increased amount of roughness along the portions of the riverbank not utilized by Industry or shipping, slowing down the water along the bank and then promoting the depositing of sediment and the establishment of vegetation as well as wildlife habitat. This then helps with further stabilization of these endangered areas. Bank Stabilization techniques utilized:Timber Pilings

How will bank stabilization along the Ohio River be accommodated with the increased use of the river as recreational asset?

Due to the increased use of the Ohio River as a recreational asset, the application of bioengineered bank stabilization techniques are needed to assure protection of the banks. Timber Pilings will provide an increased amount of protection as well as increasing the vegetation wildlife habitat. With canoe access points being installed in conjunction with the pilings, as well as educational signage, the recreation enthusiasts will have ample opportunity to view and learn about the rehabbing riparian zone along the Ohio River.

Bank Stabilization techniques utilized:Timber Pilings

Propert Loss Along the Ohio

Ü0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.80.1Miles

LegendProperty Lines streatching into the Ohio

Property Lines Timber Pilings

Canoe Access

Environmental Education Signage

Ohio River

Streets

http://inhabitat.com/the-f9-flood-proof-house-stands-tall-above-rising-tides/ http://ny.curbed.com/archives/2013/10/07/elevated_floodproof_resilient_house_head-ed_for_rockaways.php

A Row of Poplar Trees

Nodding Thistle

Indian Mustard

Alpine Pennycress

Wikimedia Commons, 2009. Author: Steve F. http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Poplar_trees_all_in_a_row_-_geograph.org.uk_-_1301682.jpg

Wikimedia Commons, 2008. Author: Indiaphotoblog. http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Yellow_mustard_flower.jpg

Wikimedia Commons, 2010. Author: Lmmahood. http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Nodding_thistle_(Carduus_nutans).JPG

Wikimedia Commons, 2009. Author: Andrew Curtis. http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Alpine_penny-cress_(Thlaspi_alpestre)_-_geograph.org.uk_-

_1222085.jpg

Plan Drawing for Stabilization with Terracing Plan Drawing for Stabilization with Vegetated Mitigation

Stabilization Plan A Stabilization Plan B