Google Accused of Stealing Balloon Tech Behind Project Loon

7262019 Google Accused of Stealing Balloon Tech Behind Project Loon

httpslidepdfcomreaderfullgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-tech-behind-project-loon 16

W O R L D (

H T T P T H T A C K

C O M C A T G O R Y

W O R L D )

G o o g l e a c c u s e d o f s t e a l i n g a l l o o n n e t w o r k t e c h e h i n d P r o j e c t L o o n

A l i c e M a c G r e g o r(

h t t p s t h e s t a c k

c o m

a u t h o r

a l i c e -

m a c g r e g o r ) T h u 1 6 J u n 2 0 1 6 1 2 0 6 p m

G o o g l e rsquo

s n e w p a r e n t

c o m p a n A l p h a e t h a s f o u

i t s e l f f a c e d w i t h a l a w s u i t t h i

w e e k

w h i c h c l a i m s t h a t t h e

t e c h g i a n t s t o l e t h e i d e a e h

i t s W i -

F i -

e m i t t i n g a l l o o n n e t w o r k

P r o j e c t L o o n (

h t t p s w w w

g o o g l e

c o m

l o o n )

T h e p a c e D a t a C o r p o r a t i o n o f C h a n d l e r

A r i z o n a

䗳 l e d t h e s u i t (

h t t p s c d n 1

v o x -

c d n

c o m

u p l o a d s c h o r u s _ a s s e t

䗳 l e 6 6 5 3 9 9 5

s p a c e d a t a c o r p 0

p d f ) [

P D F ]

e a r

t h i s w e e k a n d i s a r g u i n g t h a t i t c u r r e n t l h o l d s p a t e n t s f o r a a l l o o n -

a s e d s s t e m w h i c h c a r r i e s r o a d a n d a n t e n n a e t o c r e a t e a w i r e l e s s d a t a n e t w o r k i n

r e m o t e a n d m i l i t a r l o c a t i o n s

T h e o r g a n i s a t i o n i s s u i n g A l p h a e t f o r i n f r i n g e m e n t i n t h e N o r t h e r n C a l i f o r n i a D i s t r i c t C o u r t

A c c o r d i n g t o t h e 䗳 l e

A l p h a e t rsquo

s P r o j e c t L o o n r e a c h e s c o p r i g h t o f U

P a t e n t 6 6 2 8 9 4 1 (

h t t p s w w w

g o o g l e

c o m

p a t e n t s

U 6 6 2 8 9 4 1

d q = 6

6 2 8

9 4 1 amp

h l =

e n amp

s a = X amp

v e d =

0 a h U K w i T 0 s D H 7 a r N A h V G -

2 M K H f 3 c C e M Q 6 A I H D A A ) lsquo

A i r o r n e c o n s t e l l a t i o n o f c o m m u n i c a t i o n s p l a t f o r m s a n d m e t h o d rsquo

a

U P a t e n t 7 8 0 1 5 2 2

( h t t p s w w w

g o o g l e

c o m

p a t e n t s

U 7 8 0 1 5 2 2

d q

= 7 8 0 1

5 2 2

amp h l

= e n

amp s a

= X amp v e d

= 0 a h U K w j 7 x 5 P u 9 K r N A h U I w 2 M K H a d A o Q 6 A I H j A )

lsquo U n m a n n e d l i g h t e r

- t h a n

- a i r s a f e t e r m i n a t i o n a n d r e c o v e r m e t h o d s rsquo

T h e s e p a t e n t s o t h p r e -

d a t e L o o n a n d w e r e g r a n t e d f o r u s e w i t h t w o s s t e m s

n a m e d lsquo k a t rsquo

a n d lsquo

k i t e rsquo w h i c h p a c e D a t a u s e s t o d e l i v e r a l l o o n - a s e d

d a t a s e r v i c e s t o U

a r m e d f o r c e s

T h e c o m p a n a l s o h o l d s l i c e n s e s f r o m t h e F e d e r a l C o m m u n i c a t i o n s C o m m i s s i o n (

F C C )

t o p r o v i d e r o a d a n d s p e c t r u m

s e r v i c e s a c r o s s r e m o t e a r e a s o f A l a s k a a n d t h e G u l f o f M e x i c o

p a c e D a t a f u r t h e r a d d s i n t h e c o m p l a i n t t h a t a s m a n a s 1 0 G o o g l e r e p r e s e n t a t i v e s

i n c l u d i n g c o -

f o u n d e r s L a r r P a g e a n d e r g e r i n

h a d m e t w i t h t h e p a

D a t a t e a m i n 2 0 0 7 a n d 2 0 0 8 t o d i s c u s s p o t e n t i a l p a r t n e r s h i p s

T h e s e m e e t i n g s c o v e r e d c o n 䗳 d e n t i a l d e t a i l s o n p a c e D a t a rsquo

s p a t e n t e d t e c h n o l o g

T h e p l a i n t i 䕶 e x p l a i n s t h a t G o o g l e d i d n o t a g r e e t o t h e c o l l a o r a t i o n

a n d i n s t e a d c h o s e t o s t e a l t r a d e s e c r e t s a n d s t a r t e d d e v e l o p i n g i t s o w n a l l o o n n e t w o r k

2 0 1 1

w h i c h h a s s i n c e e c o m e P r o j e c t L o o n

lsquo P r o j e c t L o o n i m p r o p e r l a n d u n l a w f u l l u t i l i z e s p a c e D a t a

rsquo s c o n 䗳 d e n t i a l i n f o r m a t i o n a n d t r a d e s e c r e t s w h i c h p a c e D a t a d i s c l o s e d t o D e f e n d a n t G o o g l e

p u r s u a n t t o a 2 0 0 7 M u t u a l C o n 䗳 d e n t i a l i t a n d N o n -

D i s c l o s u r e A g r e e m e n t rsquo t h e c o m p l a i n t s t a t e s

T h e s u i t s e e k s d a m a g e s f o r t w o c o u n t s o f p a t e n t i n f r i n g e m e n t

a s w e l l a s t w o c o u n t s o f m i s a p p r o p r i a t i o n o f t r a d e s e c r e t s a n d r e a c h o f w r i t t e n c o n t r a c t

G o o g l e i s e t t o c o m m e n t o n t h e c a s e

6 (httpsplusgooglecomshare

url=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F162Fgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon2F3Futm_source3DgooglePlus26utm_medium3Dsocial26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfare)

19 (httpstwittercomshare

original_referer=amptext=Google+accused+of+stealing+balloon+network+tech+behind+Project+Loonampurl=httpsthestackcomworld2016061accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon3Futm_source3Dtwitter26utm_medium3Dsocial26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfareampvia=StackTime)

10 (httpwwwfacebookcomsharephp

u=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F162Fgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon2F3Futm_source3Dfacebook26utm_medium3Dsocial26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfare)

1

1 (httpswwwlinkedincomcwsshare

url=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F162Fgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon2F3Futm_source3DlinkedIn26utm_medium3Dsocial26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfare)

1 (httpswwwredditcomsubmit

url=httpsthestackcomworld20160616google-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loonamptitle=Google+accused+of+stealing+balloon+network+tech+behind+Project+Loon)

(httpwwwstumbleuponcomsubmiturl=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F162Fgoogle-accused-of-stealoon2F3Futm_source3Dstumbleupon26utm_medium3D social26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfareamptitle=Google+accused+of+stealinTotal Shares 38

983144

983155

983146

983138

983142

983137

983153

11Like

( h t t p s t h e s t a c k

c o m )

e a r c h


c o m

f e e d )

N W (


c o m ) C O M M U N I T Y (


c o m

a r t i c l e s ) D U C A T I O N (


c o m

e d u c a t i o n ) M A G A Z I N


c o m

d c m ) A O U T U


c o m

a d v e r t i s e

- a t

- t h e

- s t a c k )

N W (




c o m



c o m



c o m

d c m ) A O U T U


c o m

a d v e r t i s e

- a t

- t h e

- s t a c k )



G o o g l e rsquo

s P r o j e c t L o o n c o u l d i n t e r f e r e w i t h m o i l e o p e r a t i o n s


c o m

i o t

2 0 1 5

1 2

1 1

g o o g l e s

- p r o j e c t

- l o o n

- c o u l d

- i n t e r f e r e

- w i t h

- m o i l e

- o p e r a t i o n s )

G o o g l e t e s t i n g P r o j e c t L o o n

C o n c e r n s a r e w i t h o u t f a c t u a l a s i s


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 1

2 9

g o o g l e

- t e s t i n g

- p r o j e c t

- l o o n

- c o n c e r n s

- a r e

- w i t h o u t

- f a c t u a l

- a s i s )

G o o g l e r e l e a s e s t r e e t V i e w d a t a f o r n a t i o n a l r e s e r v e s i n K e n a


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 5

0 9

1 5

g o o g l e

- m a p s

- k e n a - s a m u r u

- r e s e r v e s )

T A G

C O N N C T I V I T Y (

H T T P T H T A C K

C O M

T A G

C O N N C T I V I T Y ) G O O G L (

H T T P T H T A C K

C O M

T A G

G O O G L )

L G A L (

H T T P T H T A C K

C O M

T A G L G A L

) N W (

H T T P T H T A C K

C O M

T A G

N W )

e n d u s a c o r r e c t i o n a o u t t h i s a r t i c l e (

m a i l t o

c o r r e c t i o n s

t h e s t a c k

c o m

s u j e c t =

T h e

2 0 t a c k

2 0 991251 2 0 a r t i c l e

2 0 c o r r e c t i o n

2 0 -

2 0 G o o g l e

2 0 a c c u s e d

2 0 o f 2 0 s t e a l i n g

2 0 a l l o o n

2 0 n e t w o r k

2 0 t e c h

2 0 e h i n d

2 0 P r o j e c t

2 0 L o o n 2 0

( A r t i c l e

2 0 I D

2 0 3 9 7 8 6 ) )

e n d u s a n e w s t i p ( s e n d - a -

n e w s -

t i p -

t o -

t h e - s t a c k

)

e c o m e a c o n t r i u t o r ( e c o m e - a -

c o n t r i u t o r )

R L A T D A R T I C L


url=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F162Fgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon2F3Futm_source3DgooglePlus26utm_medium3Dsocial 26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfare)


or iginal_referer=amptext=Google+accused+of+stealing+balloon+network+tech+behind+Project+Loonampurl=httpsthestackcomworld2016061accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon3Futm_source3Dtwitter26utm_medium3Dsocial26utm _campaign3DSocialWarfareampvia=StackTime)


u=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F16 2Fgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon2F3Futm_source3Dfacebook26utm_medium3Dsocial 26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfare)

1


ur l=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F16 2Fgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon2F3Futm_source3DlinkedIn26utm_medium3Dsocial2 6utm_campaign3DSocialWarfare)


ur l=httpsthestackcomworld20160616google-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loonamptitle=Google+accused+of+stealing+balloon+network+tech+behind+Project+Loon)

(httpwwwstumbleuponcomsubmiturl=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F162Fgoogle-accused-of-sloon2F3Futm_source3Dstumbleupon26utm_medium3Dsoc ial26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfareamptitle=Google+accused+of+stealinTotal Shares 38

983144

983155

983146

983138

983142

983137

983153


c o m )

e a r c h


c o m

f e e d )

N W (




c o m



c o m



c o m

d c m ) A O U T U


c o m

a d v e r t i s e

- a t

- t h e

- s t a c k )

N W (




c o m



c o m



c o m

d c m ) A O U T U


c o m

a d v e r t i s e

- a t

- t h e

- s t a c k )



G o o g l e s u m i t s p a t e n t a p p l i c a t i o n f o r o n l i n e v o t i n g


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 2

1 8

g o o g l e

- s u m i t s

- p a t e n t

- f o r

- o n l i n e

- v o t i n g )

p a c e r o o t s t o p r o e u n i v e r s e f o r g a l a c t i c s e c r e t s


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

s p a c e - r o o t s

- t o

- p r o e

- u n i v e r s e

- f o r

- g a l a c t i c

- s e c r e t s )

L A rsquo

s s m a r t L D s t r e e t l i g h t s o o s t w i r e l e s s c o n n e c t i v i t


c o m

i o t

2 0 1 5

1 1

0 6

l a s

- s m a r t

- l e d

- s t r e e t

- l i g h t s

- o o s t

- w i r e l e s s

- c o n n e c t i v i t )



6 Comments 1

bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull

US Patent 6628941 lsquoAirborne constellation of communications platforms and methodrsquo and US Patent 7801522 lsquoUnmanned lighter-than-air safe termination and

recovery methodsrsquo

hese both sound like ver y general Patents to me Like I patent square shaped tablets Or hovering or drifting in atmosphere for network communciation It could

rebook aginst google for patenting using sea based platforms as data severs Which also is a general idea If no on has Patented making misc patents dibs

bull bull

Soraya Xel bull

Bear in mind this isnt just a patent fight Space Data met with Google for a potential partnership And Space Data isnt a patent troll They actually develo

and deployed the actual technology

bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull

Seriously- suspending routers from balloons to make some sort of adhock network Im sure many of us have had this idea before A stolen idea vs someone

else coming up with the same idea is always frustrating but at the same time kinda shows both you were cutting edge Dont seek to own it or have the t-shirt

before it was popular Just know that youre on the cutting edge too

bull bull

Patrick Curl bull

Theyre google -- they can do whatever they want kindof like the political establishment -- they are above laws and regulationsor so theyd like you to think

bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull

I honestly disagree They employ smart people they pull from creative areas- have you honestly never thought you invented something only to find out tha

someone else came up with the idea earlier

I swear that I invented the Jet Ski when I was like 8 years old- like motorcycle but boat I drew up designed on graph paper etc- mine had a glass shield

hough but also used thermodynamic for propulsion (initial versions used a prop)

Jet skis or whatever were around years before I came up with that I was just a kid Still though- a stolen idea or just something that other people as smart

you might also independently come up with is a grey area And the flaw in patent law in the US To insist on generalizing such as shape of controller or

magnets vs the purpose of real innovation to make an arms race for getting money back on it I all it all BS In the modern age Just MIT open source it if

you have the guts to

bull bull

Soraya Xel bull

They employ smart people and condemn them to some of the most mundane jobs available And Google didnt independently invent this They m

with Space Data looked at their confidential research and then stole it

( h t t p s w w w

f a c e o o k

c o m

T h e t a c k d o t c o m

)

( h t t p s t w i t t e r

c o m

s t a c k t i m e

)

( h t t p s w w w

l i n k e d i n

c o m

g r p

h o m e

g i d = 7 4 5 5 5 4 9 amp

t r k =

m _

g r o u p s -

t i l e -

g r p )

( h t t p s p l u s

g o o g l e

c o m

1 0 6 9 3 4 7 7 8 1 6 8 4 5 4 2 5 5 0 1 0

p o s t s

)



U C R I T O O U R N W L T T R (


c o m

n e w s l e t t e r -

s u s c r i p t i o n )

L a t e s t p o s t s

G o o g l e a c c u s e d o f s t e a l i n g a l l o o n n e t w o r k t e c h e h i n d P r o j e c t L o o n (


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 6

g o o g l e - a c c u s e d -

o f -

s t e a l i n g -

a l l o o n -

n e t w o r k -

t e c h -

e h i n d -

p r o j e c t -

l o o n )

G a i t r e c o g n i t i o n m a d e p o s s i l e f o r v e r l o w -

r e s o l u t i o n v i d e o (


c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

g a i t -

r e c o g n i t i o n -

m a d e -

p o s s i l e -

f o r -

v e r -

l o w -

r e s o l u t i o n -

v i d e o - 2

)

O n l i n e l a c k m a r k e t s e l l s a c c e s s t o 7 0

0 0 0 c o m p r o m i s e d s e r v e r s (


c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

o n l i n e -

l a c k -

m a r k e t -

s e l l s - a c c e s s

t o - 7 0 0 0 0 -

c o m p r o m i s e d -

s e r v e r s )

A n d r o i d c r e a t o r s e e s a f u t u r e p o w e r e d o n e a l m i g h t A I (


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

a n d r o i d -

c r e a t o r - s e e s - a -

f u t u r e -

p o w e r e d -

o n e -

a l m i g h t -

a i )

a f a r i 1 0 l o c k s F l a s h

d e f a u l t s t o H T M L 5 (


c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

s a f a r i -

1 0 -

l o c k s - a s h -

d e f a u l t s -

t o -

h t m l 5 )

p a c e r o o t s t o p r o e u n i v e r s e f o r g a l a c t i c s e c r e t s (


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4 s p a c e -

r o o t s -

t o -

p r o e -

u n i v e r s e -

f o r -

g a l a c t i c -

s e c r e t s )

C h i n a

U

m a k i n g m o v e s t o i m p l e m e n t c e r s e c u r i t a g r e e m e n t s (


c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n a - u - s -

m a k i n g -

m o v e s -

t o -

i m p l e m e n t -

c e r s e c u r i t -

a g r e e m e n t s )

C h i n e s e i n v e s t o r s l o o k t o U

t e c h c o m p a n i e s a f t e r e c o n o m i c s l o w d o w n a t h o m e (


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n e s e -

i n v e s t o r s -

l o o k -

t o - u - s -

t e c h -

c o m p a n i e s -

a f t e r -

e c o n o m i c -

s l o w d o w n -

a t -

h o m e )

T a c t i c a l r a d i o Y N A P t o a c t a s m i l i t a r lsquo

n e r v o u s s s t e m rsquo (


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

t a c t i c a l -

r a d i o - s n a p s -

t o -

a c t -

a s -

m i l i t a r -

n e r v o u s -

s s t e m )

N e w g a d g e t c a n c l o n e 1 5 c o n t a c t l e s s c a r d s a s e c o n d (


c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

n e w - g a d g e t -

c a n -

c l o n e -

1 5 -

c o n t a c t l e s s -

c a r d s -

s e c o n d )

K e e p i n g t h e h u m a n c o n n e c t e d i n m a r t C i t i e s (


c o m

i o t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

k e e p i n g -

t h e -

h u m a n -

c o n n e c t e d -

i n -

s m a r t -

c i t i e s )

A p p l e t o g e n e r a t e r e n e w a l e e n e r g f r o m l a n d 䗳 l l g a s (


c o m

d a t a -

c e n t r e

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 0

a p p l e -

t o -

g e n e r a t e -

r e n e w a l e -

e n e r g -

f r o

l a n d 䗳 l l -

g a s )


c o m )

( h t t p s w w w

f a c e o o k

c o m


) ( h t t p s t w i t t e r

c o m

s t a c k t i m e

) ( h t t p s p l u s

g o o g l e

c o m

1 0 6 9 3 4 7 7 8 1 6 8 4 5 4 2 5 5 0 1 0

p o s t s

)

( h t t p s w w w

l i n k e d i n

c o m

g r p

h o m e

g i d = 7 4 5 5 5 4 9 amp

t r k =

m _

g r o u p s -

t i l e -

g r p )

( f e e d )

C l o s e r t i l l M e d i a L t d

u i t e 1 2

x h i i t i o n

H o u s e

A d d i s o n r i d g e P l a c e

L o n d o n W 1 4 8 X P

U n i t e d K i n g d o m

A o u t T h e t a c k

T h e T e a m ( t h e -

s t a c k -

t e a m )

C o n t a c t ( t h e -

s t a c k -

c o n t a c t -

d e t a i l s )

A d v e r t i s e a t T h e t a c k ( a d v e r t i s e -

a t -

t h e -

s t a c k )


n e w s -

t i p -

t o -

t h e -

s t a c k )

P r i v a c p o l i c ( p r i v a c )

C o o k i e p o l i c ( c o o k i e s )

L o n d o n

C l o u d x p o u r o p e (

h t t p w w w

c l o u d e x p o e u r o p e

c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

C l o u d e c u r i t (

h t t p w w w

c l o u d s e c u r i t e x p o e u r o p e

c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

m a r t I o T (

h t t p w w w

s m a r t i o t l o n d o n

c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

D a t a C e n t r e W o r l d (

h t t p w w w

d a t a c e n t r e w o r l d

c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

983110 r a n k f u r t


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

P a r i s


h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

G l o a l t e c h e x p o s f r o m C l o s e r t i l l (

h t t p w w w


c o m

c l o s e r s t i l l -

t e c h n o l o g -

e v e n t s -

c a l e n d a r _ u t m =

t h e s t a c k )




h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

H o n g K o n g

C l o u d x p o A s i a (

h t t p w w w

c l o u d e x p o a s i a h k

c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w

d a t a c e n t r e w o r l d h k

c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

i n g a p o r e


h t t p w w w

c l o u d e x p o a s i a

c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

C l o u d A s i a (

h t t p w w w

c l o u d a s i a

a s i a r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w

d a t a c e n t r e w o r l d a s i a

c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

T h e t a c k i s p o w e r e d

( h t t p s w w w

u k s e r v e r s

c o m )

copy C l o s e r t i l l M e d i a L t d 2 0 1 4

- 2 0 1 6

A l l R i g h t s R e s e r v e d

( h t t p w w w

c l o s e r s t i l l m e d i a

c o m )



G o o g l e rsquo

s P r o j e c t L o o n c o u l d i n t e r f e r e w i t h m o i l e o p e r a t i o n s


c o m

i o t

2 0 1 5

1 2

1 1

g o o g l e s

- p r o j e c t

- l o o n

- c o u l d

- i n t e r f e r e

- w i t h

- m o i l e

- o p e r a t i o n s )

G o o g l e t e s t i n g P r o j e c t L o o n

C o n c e r n s a r e w i t h o u t f a c t u a l a s i s


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 1

2 9

g o o g l e

- t e s t i n g

- p r o j e c t

- l o o n

- c o n c e r n s

- a r e

- w i t h o u t

- f a c t u a l

- a s i s )

G o o g l e r e l e a s e s t r e e t V i e w d a t a f o r n a t i o n a l r e s e r v e s i n K e n a


c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 5

0 9

1 5

g o o g l e

- m a p s

- k e n a - s a m u r u

- r e s e r v e s )

T A G

C O N N C T I V I T Y (

H T T P T H T A C K

C O M

T A G

C O N N C T I V I T Y ) G O O G L (

H T T P T H T A C K

C O M

T A G

G O O G L )

L G A L (

H T T P T H T A C K

C O M

T A G L G A L

) N W (

H T T P T H T A C K

C O M

T A G

N W )

e n d u s a c o r r e c t i o n a o u t t h i s a r t i c l e (

m a i l t o

c o r r e c t i o n s

t h e s t a c k

c o m

s u j e c t =

T h e

2 0 t a c k

2 0 991251 2 0 a r t i c l e

2 0 c o r r e c t i o n

2 0 -

2 0 G o o g l e

2 0 a c c u s e d

2 0 o f 2 0 s t e a l i n g

2 0 a l l o o n

2 0 n e t w o r k

2 0 t e c h

2 0 e h i n d

2 0 P r o j e c t

2 0 L o o n 2 0

( A r t i c l e

2 0 I D

2 0 3 9 7 8 6 ) )


n e w s -

t i p -

t o -

t h e - s t a c k

)

e c o m e a c o n t r i u t o r ( e c o m e - a -

c o n t r i u t o r )

R L A T D A R T I C L


url=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F162Fgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon2F3Futm_source3DgooglePlus26utm_medium3Dsocial 26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfare)


or iginal_referer=amptext=Google+accused+of+stealing+balloon+network+tech+behind+Project+Loonampurl=httpsthestackcomworld2016061accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon3Futm_source3Dtwitter26utm_medium3Dsocial26utm _campaign3DSocialWarfareampvia=StackTime)


u=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F16 2Fgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon2F3Futm_source3Dfacebook26utm_medium3Dsocial 26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfare)

1


ur l=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F16 2Fgoogle-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loon2F3Futm_source3DlinkedIn26utm_medium3Dsocial2 6utm_campaign3DSocialWarfare)


ur l=httpsthestackcomworld20160616google-accused-of-stealing-balloon-network-tech-behind-project-loonamptitle=Google+accused+of+stealing+balloon+network+tech+behind+Project+Loon)

(httpwwwstumbleuponcomsubmiturl=https3A2F2Fthestackcom2Fworld2F20162F062F162Fgoogle-accused-of-sloon2F3Futm_source3Dstumbleupon26utm_medium3Dsoc ial26utm_campaign3DSocialWarfareamptitle=Google+accused+of+stealinTotal Shares 38

983144

983155

983146

983138

983142

983137

983153


c o m )

e a r c h


c o m

f e e d )

N W (




c o m



c o m



c o m

d c m ) A O U T U


c o m

a d v e r t i s e

- a t

- t h e

- s t a c k )

N W (




c o m



c o m



c o m

d c m ) A O U T U


c o m

a d v e r t i s e

- a t

- t h e

- s t a c k )





c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 2

1 8

g o o g l e

- s u m i t s

- p a t e n t

- f o r

- o n l i n e

- v o t i n g )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4


- t o

- p r o e

- u n i v e r s e

- f o r

- g a l a c t i c

- s e c r e t s )

L A rsquo



c o m

i o t

2 0 1 5

1 1

0 6

l a s

- s m a r t

- l e d

- s t r e e t

- l i g h t s

- o o s t

- w i r e l e s s




6 Comments 1

bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull





bull bull

Soraya Xel bull



bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull




bull bull

Patrick Curl bull


bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull









bull bull

Soraya Xel bull



( h t t p s w w w

f a c e o o k

c o m


)


c o m

s t a c k t i m e

)

( h t t p s w w w

l i n k e d i n

c o m

g r p

h o m e

g i d = 7 4 5 5 5 4 9 amp

t r k =

m _

g r o u p s -

t i l e -

g r p )

( h t t p s p l u s

g o o g l e

c o m

1 0 6 9 3 4 7 7 8 1 6 8 4 5 4 2 5 5 0 1 0

p o s t s

)





c o m






c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 6


o f -

s t e a l i n g -

a l l o o n -

n e t w o r k -

t e c h -

e h i n d -

p r o j e c t -

l o o n )




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

g a i t -


m a d e -

p o s s i l e -

f o r -

v e r -

l o w -


v i d e o - 2

)




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

o n l i n e -

l a c k -

m a r k e t -


t o - 7 0 0 0 0 -


s e r v e r s )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

a n d r o i d -


f u t u r e -

p o w e r e d -

o n e -

a l m i g h t -

a i )




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

s a f a r i -

1 0 -

l o c k s - a s h -

d e f a u l t s -

t o -

h t m l 5 )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4 s p a c e -

r o o t s -

t o -

p r o e -

u n i v e r s e -

f o r -

g a l a c t i c -

s e c r e t s )

C h i n a

U



c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n a - u - s -

m a k i n g -

m o v e s -

t o -

i m p l e m e n t -






c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n e s e -

i n v e s t o r s -

l o o k -

t o - u - s -

t e c h -

c o m p a n i e s -

a f t e r -

e c o n o m i c -

s l o w d o w n -

a t -

h o m e )




c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

t a c t i c a l -


t o -

a c t -

a s -

m i l i t a r -

n e r v o u s -

s s t e m )



c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3


c a n -

c l o n e -

1 5 -


c a r d s -

s e c o n d )



c o m

i o t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

k e e p i n g -

t h e -

h u m a n -

c o n n e c t e d -

i n -

s m a r t -

c i t i e s )



c o m

d a t a -

c e n t r e

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 0

a p p l e -

t o -

g e n e r a t e -

r e n e w a l e -

e n e r g -

f r o

l a n d 䗳 l l -

g a s )


c o m )

( h t t p s w w w

f a c e o o k

c o m



c o m

s t a c k t i m e


g o o g l e

c o m

1 0 6 9 3 4 7 7 8 1 6 8 4 5 4 2 5 5 0 1 0

p o s t s

)

( h t t p s w w w

l i n k e d i n

c o m

g r p

h o m e

g i d = 7 4 5 5 5 4 9 amp

t r k =

m _

g r o u p s -

t i l e -

g r p )

( f e e d )


u i t e 1 2

x h i i t i o n

H o u s e


L o n d o n W 1 4 8 X P




s t a c k -

t e a m )


s t a c k -

c o n t a c t -

d e t a i l s )


a t -

t h e -

s t a c k )


n e w s -

t i p -

t o -

t h e -

s t a c k )



L o n d o n


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

m a r t I o T (

h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

983110 r a n k f u r t


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

P a r i s


h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m


t e c h n o l o g -

e v e n t s -


t h e s t a c k )




h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

H o n g K o n g


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

i n g a p o r e


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

C l o u d A s i a (

h t t p w w w

c l o u d a s i a

a s i a r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


( h t t p s w w w

u k s e r v e r s

c o m )


- 2 0 1 6


( h t t p w w w


c o m )





c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 2

1 8

g o o g l e

- s u m i t s

- p a t e n t

- f o r

- o n l i n e

- v o t i n g )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4


- t o

- p r o e

- u n i v e r s e

- f o r

- g a l a c t i c

- s e c r e t s )

L A rsquo



c o m

i o t

2 0 1 5

1 1

0 6

l a s

- s m a r t

- l e d

- s t r e e t

- l i g h t s

- o o s t

- w i r e l e s s




6 Comments 1

bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull





bull bull

Soraya Xel bull



bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull




bull bull

Patrick Curl bull


bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull









bull bull

Soraya Xel bull



( h t t p s w w w

f a c e o o k

c o m


)


c o m

s t a c k t i m e

)

( h t t p s w w w

l i n k e d i n

c o m

g r p

h o m e

g i d = 7 4 5 5 5 4 9 amp

t r k =

m _

g r o u p s -

t i l e -

g r p )

( h t t p s p l u s

g o o g l e

c o m

1 0 6 9 3 4 7 7 8 1 6 8 4 5 4 2 5 5 0 1 0

p o s t s

)





c o m






c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 6


o f -

s t e a l i n g -

a l l o o n -

n e t w o r k -

t e c h -

e h i n d -

p r o j e c t -

l o o n )




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

g a i t -


m a d e -

p o s s i l e -

f o r -

v e r -

l o w -


v i d e o - 2

)




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

o n l i n e -

l a c k -

m a r k e t -


t o - 7 0 0 0 0 -


s e r v e r s )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

a n d r o i d -


f u t u r e -

p o w e r e d -

o n e -

a l m i g h t -

a i )




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

s a f a r i -

1 0 -

l o c k s - a s h -

d e f a u l t s -

t o -

h t m l 5 )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4 s p a c e -

r o o t s -

t o -

p r o e -

u n i v e r s e -

f o r -

g a l a c t i c -

s e c r e t s )

C h i n a

U



c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n a - u - s -

m a k i n g -

m o v e s -

t o -

i m p l e m e n t -






c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n e s e -

i n v e s t o r s -

l o o k -

t o - u - s -

t e c h -

c o m p a n i e s -

a f t e r -

e c o n o m i c -

s l o w d o w n -

a t -

h o m e )




c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

t a c t i c a l -


t o -

a c t -

a s -

m i l i t a r -

n e r v o u s -

s s t e m )



c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3


c a n -

c l o n e -

1 5 -


c a r d s -

s e c o n d )



c o m

i o t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

k e e p i n g -

t h e -

h u m a n -

c o n n e c t e d -

i n -

s m a r t -

c i t i e s )



c o m

d a t a -

c e n t r e

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 0

a p p l e -

t o -

g e n e r a t e -

r e n e w a l e -

e n e r g -

f r o

l a n d 䗳 l l -

g a s )


c o m )

( h t t p s w w w

f a c e o o k

c o m



c o m

s t a c k t i m e


g o o g l e

c o m

1 0 6 9 3 4 7 7 8 1 6 8 4 5 4 2 5 5 0 1 0

p o s t s

)

( h t t p s w w w

l i n k e d i n

c o m

g r p

h o m e

g i d = 7 4 5 5 5 4 9 amp

t r k =

m _

g r o u p s -

t i l e -

g r p )

( f e e d )


u i t e 1 2

x h i i t i o n

H o u s e


L o n d o n W 1 4 8 X P




s t a c k -

t e a m )


s t a c k -

c o n t a c t -

d e t a i l s )


a t -

t h e -

s t a c k )


n e w s -

t i p -

t o -

t h e -

s t a c k )



L o n d o n


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

m a r t I o T (

h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

983110 r a n k f u r t


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

P a r i s


h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m


t e c h n o l o g -

e v e n t s -


t h e s t a c k )




h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

H o n g K o n g


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

i n g a p o r e


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

C l o u d A s i a (

h t t p w w w

c l o u d a s i a

a s i a r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


( h t t p s w w w

u k s e r v e r s

c o m )


- 2 0 1 6


( h t t p w w w


c o m )



6 Comments 1

bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull





bull bull

Soraya Xel bull



bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull




bull bull

Patrick Curl bull


bull bull

Jon Klopfer bull









bull bull

Soraya Xel bull



( h t t p s w w w

f a c e o o k

c o m


)


c o m

s t a c k t i m e

)

( h t t p s w w w

l i n k e d i n

c o m

g r p

h o m e

g i d = 7 4 5 5 5 4 9 amp

t r k =

m _

g r o u p s -

t i l e -

g r p )

( h t t p s p l u s

g o o g l e

c o m

1 0 6 9 3 4 7 7 8 1 6 8 4 5 4 2 5 5 0 1 0

p o s t s

)





c o m






c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 6


o f -

s t e a l i n g -

a l l o o n -

n e t w o r k -

t e c h -

e h i n d -

p r o j e c t -

l o o n )




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

g a i t -


m a d e -

p o s s i l e -

f o r -

v e r -

l o w -


v i d e o - 2

)




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

o n l i n e -

l a c k -

m a r k e t -


t o - 7 0 0 0 0 -


s e r v e r s )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

a n d r o i d -


f u t u r e -

p o w e r e d -

o n e -

a l m i g h t -

a i )




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

s a f a r i -

1 0 -

l o c k s - a s h -

d e f a u l t s -

t o -

h t m l 5 )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4 s p a c e -

r o o t s -

t o -

p r o e -

u n i v e r s e -

f o r -

g a l a c t i c -

s e c r e t s )

C h i n a

U



c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n a - u - s -

m a k i n g -

m o v e s -

t o -

i m p l e m e n t -






c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n e s e -

i n v e s t o r s -

l o o k -

t o - u - s -

t e c h -

c o m p a n i e s -

a f t e r -

e c o n o m i c -

s l o w d o w n -

a t -

h o m e )




c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

t a c t i c a l -


t o -

a c t -

a s -

m i l i t a r -

n e r v o u s -

s s t e m )



c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3


c a n -

c l o n e -

1 5 -


c a r d s -

s e c o n d )



c o m

i o t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

k e e p i n g -

t h e -

h u m a n -

c o n n e c t e d -

i n -

s m a r t -

c i t i e s )



c o m

d a t a -

c e n t r e

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 0

a p p l e -

t o -

g e n e r a t e -

r e n e w a l e -

e n e r g -

f r o

l a n d 䗳 l l -

g a s )


c o m )

( h t t p s w w w

f a c e o o k

c o m



c o m

s t a c k t i m e


g o o g l e

c o m

1 0 6 9 3 4 7 7 8 1 6 8 4 5 4 2 5 5 0 1 0

p o s t s

)

( h t t p s w w w

l i n k e d i n

c o m

g r p

h o m e

g i d = 7 4 5 5 5 4 9 amp

t r k =

m _

g r o u p s -

t i l e -

g r p )

( f e e d )


u i t e 1 2

x h i i t i o n

H o u s e


L o n d o n W 1 4 8 X P




s t a c k -

t e a m )


s t a c k -

c o n t a c t -

d e t a i l s )


a t -

t h e -

s t a c k )


n e w s -

t i p -

t o -

t h e -

s t a c k )



L o n d o n


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

m a r t I o T (

h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

983110 r a n k f u r t


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

P a r i s


h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m


t e c h n o l o g -

e v e n t s -


t h e s t a c k )




h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

H o n g K o n g


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

i n g a p o r e


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

C l o u d A s i a (

h t t p w w w

c l o u d a s i a

a s i a r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


( h t t p s w w w

u k s e r v e r s

c o m )


- 2 0 1 6


( h t t p w w w


c o m )





c o m






c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 6


o f -

s t e a l i n g -

a l l o o n -

n e t w o r k -

t e c h -

e h i n d -

p r o j e c t -

l o o n )




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

g a i t -


m a d e -

p o s s i l e -

f o r -

v e r -

l o w -


v i d e o - 2

)




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

o n l i n e -

l a c k -

m a r k e t -


t o - 7 0 0 0 0 -


s e r v e r s )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

a n d r o i d -


f u t u r e -

p o w e r e d -

o n e -

a l m i g h t -

a i )




c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 5

s a f a r i -

1 0 -

l o c k s - a s h -

d e f a u l t s -

t o -

h t m l 5 )



c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4 s p a c e -

r o o t s -

t o -

p r o e -

u n i v e r s e -

f o r -

g a l a c t i c -

s e c r e t s )

C h i n a

U



c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n a - u - s -

m a k i n g -

m o v e s -

t o -

i m p l e m e n t -






c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 4

c h i n e s e -

i n v e s t o r s -

l o o k -

t o - u - s -

t e c h -

c o m p a n i e s -

a f t e r -

e c o n o m i c -

s l o w d o w n -

a t -

h o m e )




c o m

w o r l d

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

t a c t i c a l -


t o -

a c t -

a s -

m i l i t a r -

n e r v o u s -

s s t e m )



c o m

s e c u r i t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3


c a n -

c l o n e -

1 5 -


c a r d s -

s e c o n d )



c o m

i o t

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 3

k e e p i n g -

t h e -

h u m a n -

c o n n e c t e d -

i n -

s m a r t -

c i t i e s )



c o m

d a t a -

c e n t r e

2 0 1 6

0 6

1 0

a p p l e -

t o -

g e n e r a t e -

r e n e w a l e -

e n e r g -

f r o

l a n d 䗳 l l -

g a s )


c o m )

( h t t p s w w w

f a c e o o k

c o m



c o m

s t a c k t i m e


g o o g l e

c o m

1 0 6 9 3 4 7 7 8 1 6 8 4 5 4 2 5 5 0 1 0

p o s t s

)

( h t t p s w w w

l i n k e d i n

c o m

g r p

h o m e

g i d = 7 4 5 5 5 4 9 amp

t r k =

m _

g r o u p s -

t i l e -

g r p )

( f e e d )


u i t e 1 2

x h i i t i o n

H o u s e


L o n d o n W 1 4 8 X P




s t a c k -

t e a m )


s t a c k -

c o n t a c t -

d e t a i l s )


a t -

t h e -

s t a c k )


n e w s -

t i p -

t o -

t h e -

s t a c k )



L o n d o n


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

m a r t I o T (

h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

983110 r a n k f u r t


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


d e r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

P a r i s


h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m


t e c h n o l o g -

e v e n t s -


t h e s t a c k )




h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

H o n g K o n g


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

i n g a p o r e


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

C l o u d A s i a (

h t t p w w w

c l o u d a s i a

a s i a r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


( h t t p s w w w

u k s e r v e r s

c o m )


- 2 0 1 6


( h t t p w w w


c o m )




h t t p w w w


f r r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

H o n g K o n g


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

i n g a p o r e


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )

C l o u d A s i a (

h t t p w w w

c l o u d a s i a

a s i a r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


h t t p w w w


c o m r e f =

t h e s t a c k )


( h t t p s w w w

u k s e r v e r s

c o m )


- 2 0 1 6


( h t t p w w w


c o m )

Documents

Google Accused of Stealing Balloon Tech Behind Project Loon