1

!

!

!

"!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

#$%&'()*!#$%*++*!

,$-./(!,$'&+$.0!

,(%1$/!2$)!3**.4*)!

,(%1$/!5&'6$/7!

899:!

!"#$%!&'(!%&)!*'(($+!,&!-#%&%!

!.//0+('&,(,$1!%&)!20&1(+%,&(1!30+!402%4!/+02$11,&5!

2

;%$/*4&%6!

!

5<(=!%*=*$%><!4$=!?&)*!()!+<*!>&)+*0+!&@!$!%*=*$%><!7%&1*>+!=*+!.7!A-!B$)=!C*)<&&%)D!$==&>($+*!

7%&@*==&%! $+! +<*!E$F*)()F*)! G)(2*%=(+-D! +<*! H*+<*%'$)?=D! $)?! +<*! I*=('(*)>*! ;&.)?$+(&)J! 5<*!

7%&1*>+! 4$=! $! =+.?-! &)! &77&%+.)(+(*=! $)?! >&)=+%$()+=! @&%! =/$''! =>$'*! @$%/*%=! +&! A*>&/*!

*)+%*7%*)*.%=D! 4(+<! +<*! $(/! +&! @()?! )*4! ()=(F<+=! &)! =+%$+*F(*=! @&%! 7&2*%+-! %*?.>+(&)! ()! K.AL

K$<$%$)!M@%(>$J!!

!

5<(=!%*7&%+!(=!$!%*=.'+!&@!$!=(?*!7%&1*>+!&)!+<*!&77&%+.)(+(*=!&@!=<*$!).+=!@&%!H&%+<*%)!N<$)$J!;(2*!

=+.?*)+=!4*)+!+&!N<$)$!()!+<*!7*%(&?!&@!,$-!O!P>+&A*%!899QD!$)?!>$%%(*?!&.+!?(@@*%*)+!=+.?(*=!&)!

+<*!=<*$!).+! ()!?(@@*%*)+!=+.?-!$%*$=J!5<*!@()?()F=!&@!+<*=*!=+.?(*=!$%*!A%&.F<+!+&F*+<*%! ()! +<(=!

%*7&%+J!!

3

M>6)&4'*?F*/*)+=!

!

!

E*! 4&.'?! '(6*! +&! *07%*==! &.%! F%$+(+.?*! +&! +<*! >&//.)(+-! &@! R7$%*! @&%! +<*(%! <&=7(+$'(+-! $)?!

%*$?()*==!+&!<*'7S!*=7*>($''-!&.%!<&=+!@$/('-!,%!#&''()=!$)?!<(=!4(@*!T$)$)+..%$J!!

!

M! =7*>($'!4&%?! &@! +<$)6=! F&*=! +&!M)F*'()$!R$==$4D! K<*('$!U&%?$$D! 5$/$%!M/()$! K.'*/$)$!$)?!

VA%$<(/!&.%!()+*%7%*+*%=D!@&%!+<*(%!F%*$+!<*'7J!!!

E*!+<$)6!M.F.=+()*D!W$>6D!K*A$=+($)!G''&D!K*2*%&!U*7$$'$D!,$<*=<D!U(>6!2$)!?*%!N**=+D!I$7<$*'!

;'&%!$)?!X&<)!@&%!+<*(%!2$'.$A'*!()=(F<+=!$)?!7%$>+(>$'!$?2(>*J!!

!

P.%! @*''&4! =+.?*)+=! *=7*>($''-! ,&)(Y.*D! X$)! X&%(=D! ,*''*D! ,()6D! 3(=$D! E&.+*%! $)?! H$=<(%.!

K.'*/$)$!@&%!+<*(%!$?2(=*!$)?!>&/7$)-J!!

!!

E*!4&.'?!'(6*!+&!+<$)6!B$)=!C*)<&&%)D!N*%+1$)!T*>0!$)?!X&%(=!2$)!?*%!R$/7!@&%!+<*(%!()=7(%$+(&)!

$)?!@&%!/$6()F!+<(=!%*=*$%><!7%&1*>+!7&==(A'*J!

!

E*! 4$)+! +&! +<$)6! @.%+<*%/&%*Z! [7'&%*D! #**=! B$F*%$$+=D! R**=! 2$)! ?*%! N**=+D! 5&/&! V=<(6$4$!

\XV#M]D! ^$=.6&! R.=$6$%(! \GHU_]D!M?(=$! 3$)=$<! ^$6.A.! \M@%(>$)! 8999!H*+4&%6]D! ;*'(>(+$=! \^(7$'$$!

K.)F+$$D! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! 4&/*)! F%&.7]D! C.F*)($! M6.*+*! \H$$=$6'*! 3+?J]D! \`$)*==$!

\E$.-(%(! +%-! a! =**D! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! 4&/*)! F%&.7]D! X&<$)$! #<*@@$! \#,M]D! W$>6! \GUK!

K+.?*)+]D! 54(D! C%(>$D! U$)(*'D! P/$%D! I-$)D! +<*! ><(*@=! &@! R7$%*D! R$%)(! $)?! X(%$7$J!,*+*&%&'&F(>$'!

K*%2(>*=!U*7$%+/*)+!&@!E$D!K+$+(=+(>$'!K*%2(>*=!U*7$%+/*)+!&@!E$J!U%J!_J!3&2*++!\=>(*)+(@(>!*07*%+!

&)! =<*$! $)?! K$2$))$<! ;%.(+=! #&/7$)-]D! U%J! XJMJ! ^(?$)$! \GUK! 7%&@*==&%! $)?! ><(*@]D! ,$<*=<!

_&.?-$'!\7B?!=+.?*)+!&)!=<*$]D!!5<*&7<('*!T$/$!\K$2$))$<!;%.(+=!#&/7$)-]D!+<*!+%$?*%=!&@!+<*!

H$+(&)$'! M==&>($+(&)! &@! K<*$! ;$%/*%=D! _%&>*==&%=! $)?! 5%$?*%=D! $)?! +<*! 4&/*)! +%$?()F! =<*$!

A.++*%!&)!+<*!MA&$A&!/$%6*+D!5$/$'*J!

!

M)?!$''!+<*!&+<*%=!4<&!<*'7*?!$)?!()=7(%*?!.=J!!

4

!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&

6+%7$80+9::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ;!

<29&084$)5$7$&(1:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: =!

<&)!%44!(#$!0(#$+1!8#0!#$4/$)!%&)!,&1/,+$)!'1> ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: =!

"'77%+? :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: @!V)+%&?.>+(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbc!

K<*$!7%&?.>+(&)bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbc!

K<*$!A.++*%!+%$?*bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbd!

K<*$!>&=/*+(>=bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbQ!

C07&%+*%=!&@!@()(=<*?!=<*$!7%&?.>+ bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbQ!

G%A$)!=<*$!A.++*%!>&)=./*%= bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb:!

A&(+0)'2(,0&::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: BC!E<-!+<(=!%*7&%+e bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbf9!

E<*%*!?&*=!=<*$!>&/*!@%&/ebbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbf9!

K+%.>+.%*!&@!%*7&%+ bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbff!

!"#$%&%%%'%%()*+%,-.%/012-3.41,%+,2%/013*554,6777777777777777777777777777777777777777789!

D#%/($+!B!"#$%!&'(!/+0)'2(,0&:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: B=!fJf! 5%**D!@%.(+!$)?!).+ bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbfg!

fJ8! !5%**!/$)$F*/*)+!$)?!%*F*)*%$+(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbfh!

fJg! 5<*!=<*$!).+!7(>6*%=bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbfd!

fJi!! V/7&%+$)>*!&@!=<*$!@&%!'(2*'(<&&?bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbfQ!

D#%/($+!;! "#$%!&'(!/+02$11,&5:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ;C!8Jf!! U%-()F!&@!6*%)*'= bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb89!

8J8!! K<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb88!

j.$)+(+-!&A+$()*? bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb8h!

D0&24'1,0&1!E!),12'11,0&!F<GH!A::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ;I!_%&?.>+(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb8Q!

P77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=!&)!7%&>*==()Fbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb8Q!

!+0.% &&%:%()*+%.0+2*05;%1,%.)*%<13+<%=+0>*.%+,2% 4,%?4,45)*2%/012-3.5%4,%.)*%51-.)%1?%@)+,+%+,2%?10%*A/10. 77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777779B!

D#%/($+!=! J'?$+1!%&)!1$44$+1!03!1#$%!*'(($+!%(!(#$!402%4!7%+9$( ::::::::::::::::::::::::::: =C!5<*!=.77'-!><$()!$)?!(+k=!$>+&%=!&)!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+ bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbg9!

gJg!! j.$'(+- bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbgd!

gJi! #&)=+%$()+=!$)?!&77&%+.)(+(*=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!+%$?*%= bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbgQ!

gJh! 5%*)?=!&2*%!+<*!'$=+!-*$%= bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbg:!

gJc! #&)>'.=(&)=bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbg:!

D#%/($+!K! "7%44L12%4$!$&(+$/+$&$'+1!/+02$11,&5!2017$(,21!*%1$)!0&!1#$%!*'(($+!,&!-#%&% ::::: KB!iJf! V)+%&?.>+(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbif!

iJ8! 5<*!/$%6*+ bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbif!

iJ8Jf! ,$%6*+!=(l* bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbif!

iJ8J8!,$%6*+!7'$-*%= bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbi8!

iJ8Jg!_%&?.>+!%$)F* bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbi8!

iJi! H&%+<!2*%=.=!K&.+<!N<$)$bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbig!

iJh! P77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbii!

iJc! #&)>'.=(&)=!$)?!?(=>.==(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbih!

5

D#%/($+!M! NO/0+($+1!03!3,&,1#$)!1#$%!/+0)'2(1 ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: K@!hJf! V)+%&?.>+(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbic!

hJ8! #$+*F&%(*=!&@!*07&%+*%= bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbic!

hJg! N&2*%)/*)+!A&?(*=!()2&'2*?!()!*07&%+!&@!=<*$ bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbiQ!

hJgJf! #&>&$!T&$%?bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbi:!

hJi! M==(=+$)>*!+&!7%&?.>*%=!$)?!*07&%+*%= bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbh9!

hJh! P77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbhf!

hJc! #&)>'.=(&)=!$)?!?(=>.==(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbh8!

D#%/($+!@!!! P+*%&!1#$%!*'(($+!20&1'7$+1 ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: M=!cJf! V)+%&?.>+(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbhg!

cJ8! #&)=./7+(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbhg!

cJg!! K.A=+(+.+*=!@&%!=<*$!A.++*% bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbci!

cJi! V)!=./ bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbcc!

D#%/($+!Q!!H#$!2%1$!03!R/%+$S ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: @I!dJf! _%&>*==()FbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbcQ!

dJ8! T.-()F!$)?!=*''()F!&@!=<*$!A.++*% bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbc:!

dJg! M>>*==!+&!/$%6*+ bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbc:!

dJi! M>>*==!+&!+%$)=7&%+$+(&) bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbc:!

dJh! K.77'-!$)?!?*/$)? bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbd9!

dJc! K<*$!).+=!@$>+&%-!()!R7$%*e bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbd9!

C1,3<-541,5%D%2453-5541,%!"#$%&& 777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777E8!

G$3$+$&2$1 :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: QK!

<FFNTUAV!A!!L!U$(%,41!0&!+$1$%+2#!7$(#0)1!F<GH!B:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: QQ!

<FFNTUAV!AA!L!W'$1(,0&&%,+$1 ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: QI!MJ!! j.*=+(&))$(%*!=<*$!).+!$2$('$A('(+- bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbdQ!

TJ! j.*=+(&))$(%*!>&)=./*%=!&@!=<*$!A.++*% bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbQh!

!

!

6

K.//$%-!

!

V)+%&?.>+(&)!

5<*!$(/!()!+<(=!%*=*$%><!4$=!+&!?&!$!@(%=+!*07'&%$+(&)!.7&)!+<*!&77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=!@&%!

'&>$'! >&//.)(+(*=D! 7%&>*==&%=! $)?! +%$?*%=! ()! N<$)$! +&! *$%)! /&%*! @%&/! =<*$! A.=()*==J! 5<(=!

%*=*$%><!4$=!?&)*!4(+<!@(2*!=+.?*)+=!()!899Q!()!+<*!@%$/*4&%6!&@!$!'$%F*%!%*=*$%><!7%&1*>+!4<(><!

4$=! $A&.+! %.%$'! @$%/*%=! $)?! *)+%*7%*)*.%=<(7! ()! N<$)$J! V)! +&+$'! fh! =+.?*)+=! '()6*?! +&! +<*!

G)(2*%=(+-!&@!E$F*)()F*)!4*%*!()2&'2*?!()!+<*!&2*%$''!7%&1*>+J!

M!%*F(&)$'!&2*%2(*4!&@!+<*!=<*$!=.77'-!><$()!(=!/$?*D!4<(><!()>'.?*=!+<*!7%&?.>+(&)!=-=+*/=!&@!

=<*$!).+=D!+<*!7%&>*==()FD!+%$?*%=!()!=<*$!A.++*%D!$)?!=<*$!A.++*%!>&)=./*%=J!5<(=!$77%&$><!4$=!

.=*?D!A*>$.=*!(+!4$=!A*'(*2*?!+<$+!6)&4'*?F*!&)!+<*!4&%6()F=!$)?!>&))*>+(&)=!4(+<()!+<*!=<*$!

=.77'-!><$()!(=!*==*)+($'!+&!@()?!+<*!$A&2*!/*)+(&)*?!&77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=J!

!

V)!+<*!G77*%!E*=+!%*F(&)D!%*=*$%><!&)!=<*$!).+!7%&?.>+(&)!=-=+*/!4$=!>&)?.>+*?D!4<('*!$%&.)?!

5$/$'*!\H&%+<*%)!I*F(&)]!$)?!()!M>>%$D!+<*!%*=*$%><!&)!'&>$'!+%$?*!$)?!*07&%+!&@!>&=/*+(>!=<*$!

A.++*%! 7%&?.>+=!4$=! >$%%(*?! &.+J! M''! %*=*$%><!4$=! A$=*?! &)! =+%.>+.%*?! ()+*%2(*4=J! T*=(?*=! +<*!

/$()! %*=*$%><! +<*%*! 4*%*! $'=&! =&/*! .)=+%.>+.%*?! ()+*%2(*4=! @&%! *0$/7'*! 4(+<! 7*&7'*! @%&/!

%*=*$%><!()=+(+.+*=D!+%$?*%=!&%!@%&/!'&>$'!$.+<&%(+(*=J!!!

!

K<*$!7%&?.>+(&)!

5<*!).+! +<$+! (=! ()2&'2*?! ()!+<(=!%*=*$%><! (=! +<*!=<*$!).+!4<(><! (=! +<*!=**?!&@!+<*!=<*$!@%.(+! +<$+!

F%&4=!&)!+<*!=<*$!+%**J!5<(=!+%**!(=!$)!()?(F*)&.=!+%**!=7*>(*=!+&!/$)-!>&.)+%(*=!()!K.ALK$<$%$)!

M@%(>$! $)?! ()! +<*=*! >&.)+%(*=! +<*! =<*$! +%**! $)?! (+=! /$)-! .=*=! <$2*! A**)! 6)&4)! @&%! &2*%!

>*)+.%(*=J!E<$+!/$6*=! +<(=! >%&7! =7*>($'! (=! +<$+D! &+<*%! +<$)! 4(+<! &+<*%! >%&7=D! =<*$! A.=()*==! (=!

+%$?(+(&)$''-!4&/*)k=!A.=()*==!$)?!(+!(=!$!=&.%>*!&@!()>&/*!@&%!/$)-!@$/('(*=!'(2()F!()!%.%$'!$%*$=J!!

!

5<*%*!$%*!/$)-!7<-=(>$'!@$>+&%=!+<$+!()@'.*)>*!=<*$!+%**!-(*'?!'(6*!4*$+<*%D!A.=<!@(%*=\)$+.%$'!$)?!

/$)L/$?*]D!?%&.F<+D!>$+*%7(''$%!7'$F.*=!$)?!7%.)()FJ!P)!$'!'&)F*%!+*%/!$)+<%&7&F*)(>!=*'*>+(&)!

&@! +<*! +%**=D! +<*! $F*!$)?! %*F*)*%$+(&)! ()@'.*)>*! +<*! =<*$! ).+! -(*'?J!P)*!&@! +<*!/$()! >&)>*%)=!

*07%*==*?!A-!2$%(&.=!$.+<&%=!(=!+<*/!)&+(>()F!$)!$F()F!+%*)?!&@!=<*$!+%**=!4<(><!+<*-!$>>&.)+!+&!

+<*!=<&%+*)()F!&@!@$''&4!7*%(&?=!?.*!+&!'$)?!7%*==.%*!$)?!7&7.'$+(&)!F%&4+<J!V@!)**?!@&%!/&)*-!(=!

<(F<!&)!$!=<&%+!+*%/D!=<*$!+%**=!>$)!A*!A.%)+!@&%!><$%>&$'!7%&?.>+(&)J!V)>%*$=()F!=<*$!).+!-(*'?!

/(F<+! A*! $)?! &77&%+.)(+-! +&! ()>%*$=*! ()>&/*@%&/! +<(=! ).+D! <&4*2*%! (+! )**?=! +&! A*! +$6*)! ()+&!

$>>&.)+!+<$+!()>%*$=*?!-(*'?!?&*=!)&+!$.+&/$+(>$''-!'*$?!+&!()>%*$=*!()!()>&/*!4(+<&.+!()>%*$=*!

()!?*/$)?J!!

!

M)&+<*%!&77&%+.)(+-! (=! +&! ()2*=+! ()!=<*$!6*%)*'=! ()! +<*!<$%2*=+! =*$=&)!$)?!=*''! +<*/! ()! +<*!?%-!

=*$=&)D!$=!7%(>*=!/(F<+!%(=*!.7!+&!+<%**@&'?!()!+<*!?%-!=*$=&)!$=!>&/7$%*?!+&!+<*!<$%2*=+!=*$=&)!

\<$%2*=+!899dZ!9Dff!GKmn6FD!!?%-!899dZ!9DgcZ!GKmn6F]J!B&4*2*%D!+<(=!(=!&)'-!$!%*$'(=+(>!&77&%+.)(+-!

@&%! +<&=*! 4<&! $%*! )&+! ()! (//*?($+*! )**?! &@! /&)*-! ()! +<*! '*$)! =*$=&)! $)?! >$)! ()2*=+J! 5<*!

7&&%*=+!4(''!)**?!+&!=*''!$''!+<*!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!(//*?($+*'-!+&!A.-!@&&?!()!+<*!'*$)!=*$=&)D!*2*)!

+<&.F<!+<(=!(=!+<*!=*$=&)!4<*)!@&&?!(=!/&=+!*07*)=(2*!$)?!7%(>*=!+<*-!F*+!@&%!+<*(%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!

7

(=! '&4*=+J!,&%*&2*%D! +<(=!-*$%!&@! '*$)!=*$=&)!899Qn899:!?*/&)=+%$+*?!+<$+! ()2*=+/*)+!?&*=)k+!

$'4$-=! '*$?! +&! =.>>*==!$=! @&%!*0$/7'*! ()!5$/$'*!$=! =+&>6=!&@! =<*$!6*%)*'=!7('*?!.7D!A.+!A.-*%=!

?(?)k+!$77*$%J!!

!

K<*$!4$=!@&.)?!+&!A*!&@!=(F)(@(>$)+!(/7&%+$)>*!@&%!+<*!%.%$'!7*&7'*!()!+<*!G77*%!E*=+!I*F(&)D!$=!

@&%!/$)-!@$/('(*=!()>&/*!@%&/!=<*$!!>&)+%(A.+*?!+&!$!Y.$%+*%!&%!()!=&/*!>$=*=!/&%*!+<$)!<$'@!&@!

$!-*$%'-!()>&/*!&@!$!<&.=*<&'?J!T*=(?*=!+<*!/&)*+$%-!2$'.*!=<*$!(=!$'=&!&@!).+%(+(&)$'!2$'.*!$=!(+!

(=!$)!(/7&%+$)+!=&.%>*!&@!@$+=!$)?!2(+$/()=J!!

!

_%&>*==()FZ!/$).$'!2=!=*/(L$.+&/$+*?!!

V)! +<(=! %*=*$%><! /$).$'! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! (=! >&/7$%*?! 4(+<D! =*/(L$.+&/$+*?! A.++*%!

*0+%$>+(&)J! C@@(>(*)>-! &@! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! 4$=! <(F<*%! 4(+<! =*/(L$.+&/$+*?! *0+%$>+(&)! \o!

*0+%$>+(&)!4(+<! +<*! $(?! &@!/$><()*%-]D! $=! f! 6F! &@! =<*$! A.++*%!4$=! &A+$()*?! @%&/! g! 6F! &@! =<*$!

6*%)*'=! ?.%()F! /$).$'! *0+%$>+(&)D! 4<('*! +<*! =$/*! $/&.)+! 4$=! *0+%$>+*?! @%&/! 8Jh6F! &@! =<*$!

6*%)*'=!?.%()F!+<*!=*/(L$.+&/$+*?!7%&>*==J!!

M'+<&.F<!+<*!*0+%$>+(&)!7%&>*==!(=!'*==!*@@(>(*)+!4(+<!/$).$'!=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)D!(+!4$=!@&.)?!

+&! A*!/&%*! 7%&@(+$A'*! $=! >&/7$%*?! +&!/*><$)(l*?! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! ?.*! +&! +<*! @.*'>&=+D!

/$()+*)$)>*!>&=+D!$)?!>&=+!&@!+<*!=<*$!6*%)*'=!+<$+!$%*! ()2&'2*?!4(+<!+<*!/*><$)(l*?!7%&>*==J!

_%(>*!@&%!4<(><!=<*$!A.++*%!>$)!A*!=&'?!7*%!4*(F<+!\&%!7%(>*!7*%!2&'./*D!$=!=/$''!+%$?*%=!?&!)&+!

<$2*!4*(F<()F! =>$'*=! $)?! +%$?*! 7*%! 2&'./*]! (=! <(F<*%! (@! +<*! A.++*%! (=! =&'?! ()! =/$''! 7&%+(&)=! $=!

>&/7$%*?!+&!=$'*!()!A.'6!Y.$)+(+(*=J!!

!

K<*$!A.++*%!+%$?*!

,$)-! $>+&%=! $%*! ()2&'2*?! ()! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%! =.77'-! ><$()J! 5<*! =.77'-! ><$()! &@! ).+=! $)?! =<*$!

A.++*%!(=!>&/7'*0!$=!+<*%*!$%*!/$)-!$>+&%=!()2&'2*?J!!

P)! 5$/$'*!/$%6*+! \N<$)$D! H&%+<*%)! I*F(&)]! +<%**! +-7*=! &@! A.'6! +%$?*%=! $%*! ?(=+()F.(=<*?Z! f]!

'&>$'!+%$?*%=!8]!+%$?*%=!@%&/!+<*!K&.+<!&@!N<$)$!g]!+%$?*%=!4<&!$'=&!+%$?*!$A%&$?J!V)2&'2*/*)+!()!

4<&'*=$'*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!+%$?*!(=!/$()'-!4&/*)k=!A.=()*==D!A.+!$=!+<*!=<*$!/$%6*+!(=!F%&4()F!+<*!

)./A*%!&@!/*)!()2&'2*?!()!=<*$!A.=()*==!(=!$'=&!()>%*$=()FJ!!

,(??'*/*)!4<&!F&+! <(%*?!A-! '$%F*! >&/7$)(*=! $%*! +<*! '$%F*=+!A.-*%=J! 5<*-!?&!)&+! &)'-! F&! +<*!

/$%6*+=!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%D!A.+!$'=&!F*+!()+&!>&)+$>+!4(+<!'&>$'!2(''$F*!>&//.)(+(*=D!4&/*)!F%&.7=D!

$)?!7%&>*==()F!=(+*=!4(+<!+<*!7.%7&=*!+&!A.-!=<*$!A.++*%J!!

!

K<*$!A.++*%! (=!7%(>*?! '&4*%!7*%!6F! (@!A&.F<+! ()! '$%F*!Y.$)+(+(*=J!B&4*2*%D! '(++'*! (=!6)&4)!&)!+<*!

A.++*%!Y.$)+(+-!!()2&'2*?!()!+%$?*D!?.*!+&!'$>6!&@!%*>&%?=!6*7+!A-!+<&=*!()2&'2*?J!!!

#<$%$>+*%(=+(>=! %*'*2$)+! @&%! =<*$! A.++*%! Y.$'(+-! $%*Z! >&'&.%D! +*0+.%*D! /*'+()F! 7&()+D! /&(=+.%*!

>&)+*)+D! $)?! 7.%(+-J! B$%?! A.++*%! (=! >&)=(?*%*?! F&&?! $=! (+! (/7'(*=! '&4! /&(=+.%*! >&)+*)+! $)?!

+<*%*@&%*!<(F<!@$+!>&)+*)+J!!

5<*! -*''&4! >&'&.%! >&/*=! @%&/! +<*! %&&+! *0+%$>+! 4<(><! (=! =&/*+(/*=! $??*?! +&! +<*! A.++*%J! 5<*!

*07&%+!()?.=+%-!(=!/&%*!?*/$)?()F!&)!+<*!Y.$'(+-!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%D!$)?!+<*-!%*Y.(%*!$!>*%+$()!

?*F%**! &@! >&)=(=+*)>-!&@! Y.$'(+-J! 5<(=! (=! $! >&)=+%$()+! @&%! +%$?(+(&)$''-! =<*$!*0+%$>+(&)D! $=!A.++*%!

*0+%$>+*?! 4(+<! +<*=*! /*+<&?=! F*)*%$''-! 2$%-! +&&! /.><! ()! Y.$'(+-J! B&4*2*%D! +<(=! &@@*%=! $)!

&77&%+.)(+-!(@!Y.$'(+-!>$)!A*!/$?*!/&%*!>&)=(=+*)+!A-!A*++*%!>&)+%&''*?!*0+%$>+(&)!/*+<&?=J!!

!

8

P)!+<*!&)*!<$)?!=<*$!).+!$)?!=<*$!A.++*%!7%&?.>+(&)!(=!()>%*$=()FD!4<('*!&)!+<*!&+<*%!<$)?!'&>$'!

=<*$!A.++*%!>&)=./7+(&)!$%&.)?!5$/$'*!=**/=!+&!A*!?*>%*$=()FJ!M!7&==(A'*!*07'$)$+(&)!@&%!+<*!

?*>%*$=*?!>&)=./7+(&)!(=!+<$+!7*&7'*!/$6*!/&%*!.=*!&@!$'+*%)$+(2*!&('!7%&?.>+=D!&@!4<(><!/$)-!

$%*! (/7&%+*?! 4<('*! +<*! ()>%*$=*?! 7%&?.>+(&)! >$)! A*! *07'$()*?! A-! $)! ()>%*$=*?! =<*$! ?*/$)?!

@%&/!A&+<!+<*!=&.+<!N<$)$($)!$)?!!()+*%)$+(&)$'!=<*$!/$%6*+J!

!

K<*$!>&=/*+(>=!

V)!N<$)$! +<*%*! $%*!A.=()*==*=! =*+!.7! +<$+!<$2*! =+$%+*?!7%&?.>()F! >&=/*+(>! 7%&?.>+=!A$=*?! &)!

=<*$! A.++*%J! 5<*! 7%&?.>+(&)! &@! >&=/*+(>=! >$)! A*! ()>%*$=*?! +&! $! <(F<*%! '*2*'! $=! 4*''! $+! +<*!

Y.$)+(+$+(2*! =(?*! $=!4*''! $=! +<*! Y.$'(+$+(2*! =(?*J! _%*=*)+'-D! +<*! '&>$'! >&=/*+(>! >&/7$)(*=! .=()F!

=<*$! ()! +<*(%! 7%&?.>+=! $%*! %*'$+(2*'-! =/$''! $)?! +<*-! $%*! )&+! 7%&>*==()F! +<*! 4<&'*! -*$%! %&.)?!

A*>$.=*!+<*-!&@+*)!?&)k+!=+&>6!+&&!/.><D!A.+!7%&>*==!4<*)!+<*-!%*>*(2*!&%?*%=J!5<*!>&/7$)(*=!

&@+*)!?&)k+!<$2*!'$%F*!=+&%$F*!%&&/=!$)?!(+!(=!%*'$+(2*'-!%(=6-!+&!7%&?.>*!()!$?2$)>*!A*>$.=*!+<*!

7%&?.>+=!<$2*!$!%*=+%(>+*?!?.%$A('(+-J!

5<*!/$()! >&/7*+(+(&)! @&%! +<*! =<*$O>&=/*+(>=! (=! +<*! >&=/*+(>=!/$?*! &.+! &@! >&>&$! A.++*%! $)?!

(/7&%+*?!>$%*!7%&?.>+=J!H&)*+<*'*==D!?*/$)?! @&%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=! (=! ()>%*$=()FS!*=7*>($''-! ()! +<*!

GKD!X$7$)!$)?!C.%&7*!J!

!

M! @(%=+! (/7&%+$)+!>&)=+%$()+! (=! +<$+!=&/*! ()7.+=!)*>*==$%-! @&%!7%&>*==()F! +<*!=<*$!A.++*%! ()+&!$!

<(F<!Y.$'(+-!*)?!7%&?.>+D!$%*!=>$%>*'-!$2$('$A'*!&%!*07*)=(2*J!!

#&/7$)(*=!/(F<+!/(==!&.+!&)!7%&@(+!@%&/!$!4(?*%!+$%F*+!F%&.7=D!$=!+<*!>&/7$)(*=!7%&?.>()F!=<*$!

>&=/*+(>=!&@+*)!>&7-!7%&?.>+!>&)>*7+=!@%&/!&+<*%!>&/7$)(*=J!!

#&)>*%)()F!()>&/*!F*)*%$+(&)!@%&/!=<*$!A.=()*==!(+!(=!+<*!>$=*!+<$+!+<*!>&/7$)(*=!4<&!7%&>*==!

+<*! ).+=! &%! A.++*%! ()+&! <(F<! Y.$'(+-! @()(=<*?! 7%&?.>+=! $%*! $''! A$=*?! ()! K&.+<*%)!N<$)$J!E<(><!

/$6*=! +<$+! +<*! 7&&%*%! 7*&7'*! ()! +<*! )&%+<D! =+$-! 7&&%*%! $)?! ?&)k+! F$()! &7+(/$'! @%&/! +<*! =<*$!

7%&?.>+!A*>$.=*!()!F*)*%$'D!+<*-!&)'-!=.77'-!+<*!%$4!/$+*%($'J!

!

5<*! @(%=+! %*$=&)! 4<-! /&=+! =<*$! >&=/*+(>=! >&/7$)(*=! $%*! /&=+'-! =(+.$+*?! =&.+<! (=! +<$+! (+! (=!

*>&)&/(>$''-!/&%*!$++%$>+(2*!!+&!A*!'&>$+*?!>'&=*!+&!5*/$D!+<*!/$()!<$%A&.%!&@!N<$)$!$)?!$'=&!

A*>$.=*! ! +<*! %*Y.(%*?! ()F%*?(*)+=! +<$+! $%*! (/7&%+$)+! .=.$''-! $%%(2*! @%&/! +<*! <$%A&.%J! V@! +<*!

()7.+=! *)+*%! +<*! >&.)+%-! ()! +<*! K&.+<! $)?! <$2*! +&! A*! +%$)=7&%+*?! .7! H&%+<! +<(=! 4(''! %*=.'+! ()!

()>%*$=*?!+%$)=7&%+$+(&)!>&=+=J!

T*=(?*=! +<(=! +<*! =&.+<! (=! /&%*! ?*2*'&7*?! +<$)! +<*! )&%+<J! _&4*%! >.+=! &>>.%! /&%*! @%*Y.*)+'-D!

%&$?=!$%*!'*==!4*''!/$()+$()*?D!'*==!+*><)&'&F-!$)?!*07*%+(=*!(=!$2$('$A'*!()!+<*!)&%+<!$)?!4$+*%!(=!

/&%*!=>$%>*!()!+<*!)&%+<J!5<(=!/$6*=!(+!/&%*!?(@@(>.'+!+&!<$2*!$!A.=()*==!

!C07&%+*%=!&@!@()(=<*?!=<*$!7%&?.>+!

K<*$! (=!/$()'-! *07&%+*?! ()! +<*! @&%/! &@! =<*$! 6*%)*'=D! %$+<*%! +<$)! =<*$! A.++*%! &%! @()(=<*?! =<*$!

7%&?.>+=J! V)@&%/$+(&)! >$)! A*! @&.)?! &)! &2*%=*$! =<*$! 6*%)*'! *07&%+=J! B&4*2*%D! %*>&%?=! &)!

&2*%'$)?! *07&%+=D! %*>&%?=! &)! *07&%+! Y.$)+(+(*=! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! $)?! @()(=<*?! =<*$! 7%&?.>+=! $%*!

'$>6()FJ!!!

M>>&%?()F!+&!+<*!()+*%2(*4*?!*07&%+*%=!&@!@()(=<*?!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!$)!(/7&%+$)+!>&)=+%$()+!(=!+<$+!

+<*!7%&?.>*%=!$)?!*07&%+*%=!<$2*!?(@@(>.'+-!F*++()F!$>>*==!+&!+<*!A.-*%=D!*=7*>($''-!4<*)!+<*-!$%*!

&2*%=*$=J!

9

P77&%+.)(+(*=!@&%!7%&?.>*%=!&@!@()(=<*?!7%&?.>+=!/(F<+!A*!+&!2(=(+!+%$?*!@$(%=!+&!F*+!()+&!>&)+$>+!

4(+<!7&+*)+($'!A.-*%=!&%!+&!@()?!$!4$-!+&!?(=+()F.(=<!+<*/=*'2*=!@%&/!&+<*%!A-!/$6()F!?(@@*%*)+!

+-7*=!&@!=<*$!7%&?.>+=J!5<*!+(/*!$)?!@()$)>*=!)**?*?!+&!F*+!$!7*%/(+!@&%!=*''()F!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!(=!

/*)+(&)*?!$=!$!>&)=+%$()+J!T*=(?*=!+<(=!(+!4$=!=$(?!+<$+!+<*!F&2*%)/*)+!(=!)&+!$>+(2*'-!=.77&%+()F!

*07&%+*%=! &@! +<*! 7%&?.>+=D! $)?! +<*! F&2*%)/*)+! ?&*=)k+! 6**7! +%$>6! &)! $/&.)+=! &@! A.++*%!

7%&?.>*?! $)?! *07&%+*?J! B&4*2*%D! +<*! E*=+! M@%(>$! 5%$?*! B.AD! 4$=! =$(?! +&! /&%*! $>+(2*'-!

=.77&%+()F!*07&%+*%=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!\7%&?.>+=]J!

!

G%A$)!=<*$!A.++*%!>&)=./*%=!!

5<*!%*=.'+=!&@!$!%*=*$%><!&)!+<*!2(*4!&@!>&)=./*%=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%! ()!+<*!.%A$)!$%*$!&@!+<*!>(+-!

5$/$'*D! '&>$+*?! ()! +<*!H&%+<*%)!I*F(&)! ()!N<$)$! (=!7%*=*)+*?J!_*&7'*!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%!4(+<()!

+<(=!%*=*$%><!$%*!/&=+'-!)&)!*?.>$+*?!/(??'*!$F*?!4&/*)!=*''()F!@&&?!?(=<*=!$)?!=)$>6=!$+!+<*(%!

<&/*=!$)?!$'&)F!=+%**+!=(?*=J!#&)=./*%=!'()6*?!+<*!@&''&4()F!A.++*%!><$%$>+*%(=+(>=!+&!(+=!Y.$'(+-Z!

>&'&.%D!=/*''D!+$=+*!$)?!/&(=+.%*!>&)+*)+J!

E<(+*!A.++*%! (=!7%*@*%%*?!A-!/&=+! ()!+<*!H&%+<*%)!%*F(&)D!$=! (+! (=!=**)!$=!7.%*!A.++*%!$)?!/&=+!

=.(+$A'*! @&%! >&&6()FJ! ^*''&4! A.++*%! (=! F*)*%$''-! /&%*! 7&7.'$%! ()! +<*! K&.+<*%)! %*F(&)=D! $=! +<*!

>&'&.%! (=! @&.)?! /&%*! $++%$>+(2*! $)?! +<*! =<*$! =/*''! (=! '*==! ?.*! +&! +<*! %&&+! $??(+(2*=J! M''!

%*=7&)?*)+=! 7&()+*?! &.+! +<$+! +<*! ><&(>*! @&%! $! >*%+$()! +-7*! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! ?*7*)?=! &)! +<*!

7.%7&=*!@&%!+<*!A.++*%D!(+=!7%(>*D!+<*!4$-!(+!4$=!7%&>*==*?!$)?!(+=!$2$('$A('(+-J!!

E<*)!=<*$!A.++*%!4$=!=$(?!+&!A*!?(='(6*?!+<*!/$()!/*)+(&)*?!%*$=&)=!4*%*!+<$+!+<*-!?(='(6*?!+<*!

=/*''!$)?!+$=+*D!&%! ()! +<*!>$=*!&@! @&&?!=*''*%=!+<$+! +<*-!4*%*!$@%$(?!+<$+!+<*(%!>.=+&/*%=!4&.'?!

?(='(6*!(+J!!

V+! 4$=! /*)+(&)*?! +<$+! '&>$'! >&)=./7+(&)! &@! =<*! A.++*%! ?*>%*$=*?! ?.*! +&! +<*! ()>%*$=*! ()!

$2$('$A('(+-!$)?!7&7.'$%(+-!&@!$'+*%)$+(2*!7%&?.>+=D! '(6*!7$'/!&('! @&%!>&&6()F!&%!/&?*%)!=6()!>$%*!

7%&?.>+=! $)?! +<$+! ?*/$)?! @%&/! +<*! =&.+<! &@!N<$)$! ()>%*$=*?! ?&! +&! +<*! ()>%*$=*?! 6)&4'*?F*!

+<*%*!&)!+<*!7%&?.>+!$)?!(+=!/$)-!.=*=J!U.*!+&!+<(=! ()>%*$=*?!?*/$)?!>&)=./*%=!+<()6!+<$+! ()!

+&+$'!+<*%*!(=!/&%*!=<*$!A.++*!7%&?.>+(&)!)&4!$!?$-=!+<$)!()!+<*(%!><('?<&&?!

!

G)'*==!R7$%*!<$=!$!F.$%$)+**?!$)?!?(%*>+!A.-*%!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!()!'$%F*!Y.$)+(+(*=!@&%!$!@(0*?!7%(>*!

+<$+! (=!<(F<*%! +<$)! +<*!>&=+!7%(>*D! =<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)! (=!)&+!7%&@(+$A'*J!,$()!>&)=+%$()+=!$%*!

@.*'!>&=+=D!<(F<!+%$)=7&%+!>&=+=!?.*!+&!%*/&+*)*==!&@!+<*!2(''$F*!4<(><!/$6*=!%*F.'$%!=$'*!()!A.'6!

Y.$)+(+(*=!.)7%&@(+$A'*J!!P+<*%!>&)=+%$()+=!$%*!'(/(+*?!$>>*=!+&!=7$%*!7$%+=D!'$>6!&@!*07*%+(=*D!'$>6!

&@!>$7$>(+-!+&!=*>.%*!+<*!@$>+&%-!A.('?()F!$)?!(+=!>&)+*)+!@%&/!+<*@+J!!!

10

V)+%&?.>+(&)!

E<-!+<(=!%*7&%+e!!

M)!$(/!&@!+<(=!%*7&%+!(=!+&!F*)*%$+*!A*++*%!.)?*%=+$)?()F!&@!+<*!7%&?.>+(&)!$)?!+%$?*!()!+<*!=<*$!

><$()!()!N<$)$D!$)?!()!+<(=!4$-!+&!@$>('(+$+*!+<&=*!*)F$F()F!()!A.=()*==D!7&'(>-!/$6()F!&%!%*=*$%><!

()! +<*! =<*$! =*>+&%J! 5<*! $.+<&%=! $'=&! <&7*! +<$+! 7&2*%+-! %*?.>+(&)! =+%$+*F(*=! A-! HNPk=! &%!

F&2*%)/*)+=! +<$+! ()>'.?*! =<*$!A.=()*==! $=!&)!&@! (+=! +&&'=! >$)!A*!$77'(*?!/&%*!*@@*>+(2*'-!4(+<!

A*++*%!.)?*%=+$)?()F!&@!+<*!=<*$!=.77'-!><$()J!5<(=!$++*)+(&)!@&%!7&2*%+-!%*?.>+(&)!(=!%*@'*>+*?!()!

+<*!%*7&%+!A-!+<*!=*$%><!@&%!&77&%+.)(+(*=!@&%!+<*!%.%$'!7&&%!$)?!'&>$'!+%$?*%=!()!N<$)$!+&!A*)*@(+!

/&%*!@%&/!=<*$!A.=()*==J!5<(=!%*7&%+!(=!A$=*?!&)!'(+*%$+.%*!$)?!&)!@(*'?4&%6!?&)*!A*+4**)!M7%('!

$)?!P>+&A*%!899Q!A-!@&.%!=+.?*)+=!+<$+!+&&6!7$%+!&@!$!7%&1*>+! @%&/!+<*!E$F*)()F*)!G)(2*%=(+-!

$)?!+<*!I*=('(*)>*!@&.)?$+(&)J!V+!4$=!)&+*?!+<$+!)&!%*7&%+!-*+!*0(=+*?!+<$+!+%(*?!+&!A%()F!+&F*+<*%!

()@&%/$+(&)! &)! =<*$! 7%&?.>+(&)D! 7%&>*==()F! $)?! +%$?*! ()! N<$)$D! $'+<&.F<! _J! 3&2*++! ?(?! 4%(+*!

/$)-!?(@@*%*)+! %*7&%+=! +<$+! +&F*+<*%!7%&2(?*!$!A%&$?! %$)F*!&@! ()@&%/$+(&)!&)! =<*$!/$%6*+=! ()!

N<$)$J! 5<(=! %*7&%+! (=! $)!*@@&%+! +&!A%()F! +&F*+<*%!*0(=+()F! ()@&%/$+(&)!4(+<! +<*! $??(+(&)!&@! @(*'?!

%*=*$%><!+&!/$6*!$)!&2*%2(*4!&@!+<*!=.77'-!><$()!&@!=<*$!6*%)*'=!$)?!=<*$!A.++*%!4(+<()!N<$)$D!

$)?!@&%!$!=/$''!7$%+!&)!+<*!()+*%)$+(&)$'!+%$?*J!V)!+<*!*)?!&@!+<*!%*7&%+!4*!4(=<!+&!<(F<'(F<+!+<*!

&77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=! @&%! '&>$'!>&//.)(+(*=!+<$+!$%*! ()2&'2*?!7%&?.>+(&)D!7%&>*==()F!&%!

$)?! +%$?*! +&! *$%)! /&%*! @%&/! =<*$! A.=()*==J! V)! 7%&>*==()F! $)?! +%$?*! $! ?(=+()>+(&)! (=! /$?*!

A*+4**)!=<*$!6*%)*'=!$)?!=<*$!A.++*%!$=!+<*=*!$77'-!+&!+4&!?(@@*%*)+!/$%6*+=J!!!

E<*%*!?&*=!=<*$!>&/*!@%&/e!

K<*$! +%**=! F%&4! ()! $! '$%F*! 7$%+! &@! K.ALK$<$%$)! M@%(>$J! 5<(=! =<*$! +%**! (=! (/7&%+$)+! @&%! +<*!

'(2*'(<&&?=!&@!+<*!%.%$'!7&7.'$+(&)!$=!(+!<$=!A**)!@&%!&2*%!>*)+.%(*=!\3&2*++!a!B$YD!8999]J!M'/&=+!

*2*%-!7$%+!&@!+<*!+%**!<$=!(+=!.=*D!@&%!*0$/7'*Z!+<*!@%.(+!(=!*$+*)!$)?!+<*!'*$2*=!$%*!.=*?!$=!@&??*%!

$)?!=*%2*!$=!$)!()F%*?(*)+!@&%!/$6()F!$'6$'()*!$)?!7$()+!\3&2*++!a!B$Y!8999]J!

_%*=*)+'-! =<*$! (=! *07&%+*?! +&! ;%$)>*D! N%*$+! T%(+$()D! +<*!H*+<*%'$)?=D! U*)/$%6D! H&%+<! M/*%(>$!

$)?! X$7$)! \C'($=! a! #$%)*-D! 899d]J! V)! +<*=*! >&.)+%(*=! (+! (=! 7%&>*==*?! ()! $! 4(?*! %$)F*! &@! @&&?!

7%&?.>+=! ()>'.?()F! ><&>&'$+*! $)?! (+! (=! $'=&! A*>&/()F! /&%*! 7&7.'$%! ()! +<*! >&=/*+(>! ()?.=+%-!

\K><%*>6*)A*%F!8999]J!V)!7%&?.>+=!&@!/.'+()$+(&)$'=!=<*$!(=!&@+*)!.=*?!()!>&/A()$+(&)!4(+<!7$'/!

&('D!&%!(''(7*!V)!899g!=<*$!A.++*%!A*>$/*!&)*!&@!+<*!=(0!2*F*+$A'*!@$+=!$''&4*?!A-!+<*!CG!+&!=*%2*!

$=! $!#&>&$!T.++*%! CY.(2$'*)+! \#TC]J!P)*!&@! +<*!/*)+(&)*?!$?2$)+$F*=!&@! =<*$!A.++*%! (=! +<$+! (+!

A%()F=!.7!+<*!/*'+()F!7&()+!&@!\K><%*>6*)A*%F!8999]J!!

K<*$!+%**=!&>>.%=!)$+.%$''-!()!$!h9996/!'&)F!l&)*!=+%*+><()F!@%&/!K.?$)!+&!N.()*$D!4(+<!$!4(?+<!

&@!h99!6/!$)?!>$)!A*!@&.)?!()!*(F<+**)!?(@@*%*)+!>&.)+%(*=!4<(><!()>'.?*Z!K*)*F$'D!N.()*$D!,$'(D!

V2&%-! #&$=+D!N<$)$D! 5&F&D! T*)()D! T.%6()$! ;$=&D! H(F*%($D!H(F*%D! #<$?!#$/*%&&)D! #*)+%$'! M@%(>$)!

I*7.A'(>D! GF$)?$D! #&)F&D! R*)-$! $)?! K.?$)D! $=! ?*7(>+*?! ()! @(FfJ! V)! N<$)$! +<*! =<*$! +%**! &)'-!

F%&4=! ()! +<*!H&%+<*%)!%*F(&)=!4<*%*! +<*!>'(/$+*! (=!?%-*%!>&/7$%*?!+&! +<*! =&.+<J!5-7(>$''-! +<*!

=<*$!&>>.%%*)>*!l&)*!'(*=!()!+<*!l&)*!&@!c99!$)?!fi99//!&@!$)).$'!%$()@$''!\U;K#D!8999]J!

!

11

!

;(F.%*!9Jf!L!U(=+%(A.+(&)!&@!+<*!=<*$!+%**=!\C'($=!a!#$%)*-D!899d]!

!

E<$+!/$6*=!=<*$!$)!()+*%*=+()F!7%&?.>+!@&%!7&2*%+-!%*?.>+(&)e!

5<*%*! (=! $! >&/A()$+(&)! &@! $=7*>+=! +<$+!/$6*! +<*! =<*$! ).+=! $)! ()+*%*=+()F! 7%&?.>+! @&%! 7&2*%+-!

%*?.>+(&)J! V)!N<$)$!+<*!/$1&%(+-!&@!+<*!7&&%!$%*!7*&7'*!4<&! '(2*! ()!%.%$'!$%*$=! ()!+<*!)&%+<*%)!

7$%+=! &@!N<$)$J! 5<*! 7&&%*=+! $%*! .=.$''-! @$%/*%=J! M)).$'! %$()@$''! '(*=! $%&.)?! f999//!7*%! -*$%!

4<(><! /*$)=! +<$+! +<*! >'(/$+*! (=! .)=.(+$A'*! @&%! +<*! >.'+(2$+(&)! &@! >%&7=! '(6*! 7$'/D! &%! >&>&$D!

<&4*2*%!+<*!>'(/$+*!(=!=.(+$A'*!@&%! +<*!=<*$!+%**!+&!F%&4!\U;K#D8999]J!;&%!=<*$!).+!7%&?.>+(&)!

'(++'*! ()2*=+/*)+! (=! )**?*?! $=! +<*! =<*$! +%**! (=! $)! ()?(F*)&.=! =7*>(*=! $)?! (+! &>>.%=! ()! '$%F*!

)./A*%=!()!+<*!4<&'*!&@!)&%+<*%)!N<$)$D!+<*!&)'-!()2*=+/*)+!)**?*?!(=!+(/*!$)?!'$A&%!+&!7(>6!

+<*! @%.(+=J! M)&+<*%! $=7*>+! &@! =<*$D! &+<*%! +<$)! /$)-! &+<*%! >%&7=D! (=! +<$+! (+! F*)*%$+*=! ()>&/*!

=7*>(@(>$''-! @&%!4&/*)!$=! (+! (=! +%$?(+(&)$''-! =**)! $=!4&/*)k=k! A.=()*==! \C'($=! $)?!#$%)*-!899d]J!

T*=(?*=! +<(=D! =<*$! @%.(+=! $%*! &)*! &@! +<*! @*4! )$+.%$'! %*=&.%>*=! $>>*==(A'*! @&%! +<*! '$)?'*==! 7&&%!

\@(*'?!&A=*%2$+(&)=]J!;()$''-D!+<*%*!(=!=(F)(@(>$)+!?*/$)?!@&%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!A&+<!4(+<()!N<$)$!$=!

&)!+<*!()+*%)$+(&)$'!/$%6*+D!4<(><!(=!(/7&%+$)+!@&%!+<*!()>&/*!F*)*%$+()F!7&+*)+($'!&@!=<*$J!!

K+%.>+.%*!&@!%*7&%+!

5<*! =+%.>+.%*!&@! +<*! %*7&%+! (=!&%?*%*?!A-! @.)>+(&)!4(+<()! +<*! =.77'-! ><$()D!4<(><! (=!$=! @&''&4=Z!

7%&?.>*%=D! 7%&>*==&%=D! +%$?*%=D! $)?! >&)=./*%=J! 5<*! %*7&%+! >&)=(=+=! &@! =(0! ><$7+*%=J! 5<*! @(%=+!

><$7+*%! (=!$A&.+! +<*! =<*$!7%&?.>+(&)!=-=+*/!$)?!+<*!=<*$!).+!7(>6*%=D! %*7%*=*)+*?!A-! +<*!A&0!

p_%&?.>*%=q!()!@(FJ!fJfJ!5<*!=*>&)?!><$7+*%!(=!$A&.+!=/$''!=>$'*!7%&>*==()F!&@!=<*$!).+=!()+&!=<*$!

A.++*%J! 5<*! +<(%?! ><$7+*%! (=! $A&.+! +%$?*! &@! =<*$!A.++*%! $)?! =<*$!).+=!&)! '&>$'!/$%6*+=J! 5<(=! (=!

@&''&4*?!A-!><$7+*%!@&.%!()!4<(><!+<*!@&>.=!'(*=!&)!+<*!N<$)$($)!=<*$!A.++*%!>&=/*+(>=!A.=()*==J!

#<$7+*%!h! (=!$A&.+!+<*!*07&%+!&@!@()(=<*?!=<*$!7%&?.>+=J!5<*!'$=+!><$7+*%D!><$7+*%!cD!@&>.=*=!&)!

+<*!'&>$'!=<*$!A.++*%!>&)=./7+(&)!+%*)?=!()!+<*!H&%+<*%)!%*F(&)!&@!N<$)$J!V)+*%)$+(&)$'!A.-*%=!

&@!=<*$!).+=D!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!@()(=<*?!=<*$!A.++*%!7%&?.>+=!<$2*!)&+!A**)!+$6*)!()+&!$>>&.)+!()!

+<(=!%*=*$%><!$)?!+<.=!'*$2*=!=7$>*!@&%!@.%+<*%!%*=*$%><J!!

V)!+<*!*)?!&@! +<*!%*7&%+!$!>$=*!=+.?-! (=!F(2*)!&)!$!2(''$F*!&@!R7$%*D!$)?!$)!$==*==/*)+! (=!/$?*!

4<$+!+<*!7&==(A('(+(*=!$)?!+<*!>&)=+%$()+=!$%*!@&%!+<(=!>&//.)(+-!+&!*$%)!/&%*!&)!=<*$!A.=()*==J!!

!

12

!

!

;(F.%*! 9J8! L! K><*/$+(>! &2*%2(*4! &@! =.77'-!

><$()!

;(F.%*!9Jg!L!P2*%2(*4!&@!=+.?-!$%*$=!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

C$><!><$7+*%!4$=!A$=*?!&)! ()+*%'()6*?D!A.+! =*7$%$+*'-! >&)?.>+*?! @(*'?! =+.?(*=!4(+<!*$><! =+.?-!

<$2()F!(+k=!&4)!=+.?-!$%*$!$)?!/*+<&?&'&F-J!5<*!%*=*$%><!&)!+<*!7%&?.>+(&)!$)?!7%&>*==()F!\#BJ!

f!a8]!4$=!>$%%(*?!&.+! ()!+<%**!>&//.)(+(*=! ()!G77*%!E*=+!I*F(&)!&@!N<$)$!\=**!@(F.%*!g]J!5<*!

%*=*$%><! &)! +%$?*%=D! =<*$! A.++*%! >&=/*+(>=D! $)?! =<*$! A.++*%! >&)=./*%=! \#<J! gD! iD! hD! c]! 4$=!

>&)?.>+*?! ()! +<*! )&%+<*%)! %*F(&)D! $%&.)?! 5$/$'*D! $)?! ()! M>>%$J! M''! %*=*$%><! 4$=! A$=*?! &)!

()+*%2(*4=!4(+<! '&>$'! 7&7.'$+(&)=! $)?! 7*&7'*! ()2&'2*?! ()! +<*! =<*$! A.=()*==J! ;&%!/&%*! ?*+$('*?!

()@&%/$+(&)!&)!+<*!%*=*$%><!/*+<&?=!=**!M77*)?(0!fJ!!

!

!

13

F<GH!A!!!L!!"#$%!&'(!/+0)'2(,0&!%&)!/+02$11,&5!!!

5<*!%*=*$%><!()!+<(=!=*>+(&)!4$=!>$%%(*?!&.+!()!+<*!G77*%!E*=+!I*F(&)!&@!N<$)$J!5<*!@&>.=!&@!+<*!

%*=*$%><!(=!*07%*==*?!A-!+<*!@&''&4()F!%*=*$%><!Y.*=+(&)=Z!E<$+!(=!+<*!7%*=*)+!=+$+*!&@!+<*!=<*$!

).+!7%&?.>+(&)!$)?!4<$+!$%*!+<*!&77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=!@&%!+<*!'&>$'=!+&!*$%)!/&%*!@%&/!

7%&?.>+(&)e!E<$+! (=! +<*! >&=+LA*)*@(+! &@! =/$''! =>$'*! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)Z! /$).$'! $)?! =*/(L

$.+&/$+*?e! M??(+(&)$''-! $! >$=*! =+.?-!4$=! ?&)*! &)! +<*! =.(+$A('(+-! &@! +<*! 7'$>*/*)+! &@! $! =<*$!

A.++*%!7%&?.>+(&)!@$>+&%-!()!+<*!2(''$F*!&@!R7$%*J!;&%!+<(=!$==*==/*)+!4*!>&)=(?*%*?!+<*!@&''&4()F!

@$>+&%=Z!7%&?.>+(&)!>$7$>(+-D!+%$)=7&%+$+(&)!>&=+!+&!7&+*)+($'!>.=+&/*%=!$)?!>.'+.%$'!@$>+&%=J!!

!

!

!

#<$7+*%!f!K<*$!).+!7%&?.>+(&)!!

!

V)! +<(=!><$7+*%!A$>6F%&.)?! ()@&%/$+(&)! (=!F(2*)!&)! +<*!7%&?.>+(&)!=-=+*/!&@! +<*!=<*$!).+J!5<*!

$(/!(=!+&!F(2*!/&%*!()=(F<+!()!+<*!7<-=(>$'D!=&>(&L*>&)&/(>$'!$)?!>.'+.%$'!>&)+*0+!()!4<(><!+<*!).+!

(=!7%&?.>*?D!$)?!<&4!+<(=!%*'$+*=!+&!+<*!'(2*'(<&&?!&@!+<*!%.%$'!7&7.'$+(&)J!!

!

fJf! 5%**D!@%.(+!$)?!).+!

5<*!=<*$! +%**D!`(+*''$%($!7$%$?&0$D!A*'&)F=! +&! +<*! @$/('-!&@!K$7&+$>*$*J!5<*!).+=! +<$+! +<(=! +%**!

7%&?.>*=!>$)!>&)+$()!@%&/!89r!.7!+&!h9r!*?(A'*!@$+J!5<*!=<*$!+%**!7&7.'$+(&)!&@!C$=+!M@%(>$!(=!

+<*!=.A=7*>(*=!)('&+(>$D!4<(><!7%&?.>*=!+<*!/&%*!'(Y.(?!+-7*!&@!=<*$!@$+S!+<(=!(=!?.*!+&!(+=!<(F<*%!

&'*(>!$>(?!>&)+*)+!()!+<*!6*%)*'=!\*JFJ!.7!+&!h9!+&!s!c9!r!()!GF$)?$]J!5<*!K<*$!+%**!7&7.'$+(&)!()!

+<*!E*=+! &@! M@%(>$D! @%&/!H(F*%($! +&! K*)*F$'D! (=! $! +%**! &@! +<*! =.A=7*>(*=! 7$%$?&0$! &@! `(+*''$%($!

7$%$?&0$! $)?! 7%&?.>*=! /&%*! =&'(?! =<*$! A.++*%! $=! (+! >&)+$()=! /&%*! =+*$%(>! $>(?! \U;K#! 8999D!

,$%$)l!899i]J!P.%!%*=*$%><!$%*$!'(*=!()!+<*!%*F(&)!&@!+<*!7$%$?&0$!=.A=7*>(*=J!5<*!2(+*''$%($!+%**!

=7*>(*=!$%*!$'=&!=&/*+(/*=!>&)@.=*?!4(+<!+<*!/$'*!K<*$!).+!+%**!3&7<(%$!3$)>*&'$+!\3&2*++!$)?!

B$Y!8999D!_IP5M]J!

V)! K.ALK$<$%$)! M@%(>$! +<*%*!/$)-! ?(@@*%*)+! F*)*+(>! 2$%(*+(*=! &@! =<*$! +%**=! \;*%%(=! *+! $'J! 899f]J!

M.+<&%=! >&)=(?*%! ?&/*=+(>$+*?! &%! =*/(L?&/*=+(>$+*?! $=! +<*-! $%*! )&+! 7'$)+*?! A.+! ?*7*)?! &)!

)$+.%$'!%*F*)*%$+(&)D!$)?!=*/(L?&/*=+(>$+*?!A*>$.=*!+<*%*!<$=!A**)!$!>*)+.%-!'&)F!+%$?(+(&)!&@!

$)+%&7<(>!=*'*>+(&)!&@!=<*$!+%**=!A$=*?!&)!+<*!+%**=!-(*'?D!$F*!$)?!=(l*!\3&2*+!a!B$Y!8999D!R*''-!

*+!$'J!899d]J!!!!!!!!!!!!

N*)*%$''-!=<*$!+%**=!$%*!2$'.*?!@&%!+<*(%!@%.(+=!$)?!+<*!).+=!A-!+<*!%.%$'!>&//.)(+(*=J!5<*!@%.(+=!

$%*!*$+*)!$)?!+<*!=<*$!).+=!>$)!A*!=&'?!&%!7%&>*==*?!()+&!A.++*%!4<(><!/$-!A*!.=*?!@&%!>&&6()FD!

=6()! >%*$/D!&%!/*?(>()*J!,.'+(7'*!7$%+=!&@! +<*! =<*$! +%**! >$)!A*!.=*?Z! +<*! A$%6! >$)!A*!.=*?!$=!

/*?(>()*D!+<*!'*$2*=!$%*!.=*?!+&!/$6*!7$()+D!+<*!4&&?!@&%!.+*)=('=D!@.%)(+.%*!&%!$=!>&)=+%.>+(&)!

/$+*%($'J!;.%+<*%/&%*D!+<*!=<*$!+%**!4&&?!(=!.=*?!$=!@(%*4&&?!&%!+<*!/$6()F!&@!><$%>&$'J!5<*!>&L

7%&?.>+=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!>$)!A*!.=*?!+&!/(0!4(+<!=&('!/$+*%($'!@&%!7'$=+*%()FJ!5<*=*!>&L

7%&?.>+=! >$)! A*! .=*?! $=! @.*'! $)?! +<*! $=<*=! +<$+! $%*! '*@+! $@+*%! A.%)()F! >$)! A*! .=*?! @&%! +<*!

*0+%$>+(&)! &@! $'6$'()*J! K<*$! A.++*%! (=! $'=&! =&/*+(/*=!/(0*?! 4(+<! ?(@@*%*)+! +-7*=! &@! $'6$'()*! +&!

/$6*! =&$7J! K<*$! +%**=! $%*! >&//&)! $)?! &@+*)! ?&/()$+()F! 4&&?'$)?! =7*>(*=! ()! K.ALK$<$%$)!

14

$F%(>.'+.%$'!7$%6'$)?=J!5<*=*!7$%6'$)?=!$%*!@(*'?=!.=*?!@&%!>%&7!>.'+(2$+(&)!4<*%*!=<*$!+%**=!F%&4!

()!A*+4**)!+<*!>%&7=J!!

!!

!

! ! !

!!

;(F.%*! fJg! L! MF%(>.'+.%$'! 7$%6'$)?D! 4(+<! =<*$!

+%**=!!!!

!!!;(F.%*!fJi!L!K<*$!@%.(+!

!

K<*$! +%**=! =+$%+! +&! A*$%! @%.(+=! $+! +<*! $F*! &@! fhL89! -*$%=D! $)?! %*$><*=!/$+.%(+-! @%&/! $A&.+! ih!

-*$%=J!5<*!+%**!>$)!7%&?.>*!@%.(+=!.7!+&!(+=!899+<!-*$%!&%!/&%*J!5<*!-(*'?!&@!+<*!=<*$!@%.(+=!>$)!

2$%-!=+%&)F'-!2$%-!=(F)(@(>$)+'-!7*%!+%**!$=!4$=!?*/&)=+%$+*?!A-!%*=*$%><!?&)*!A-!T&@@$!\T&@@$!*+!

$''JDf::c]J!5<*!?(@@*%*)>*!()!-(*'?!A*+4**)!$)!$2*%$F*!-(*'?()F!+%**!$)?!$!F&&?!-(*'?()F!+%**!>$)!

?(@@*%! .7! +&! @(2*@&'?J! V)! +<*(%! %*=*$%><! +<*! $2*%$F*! -(*'?! &@! $! +%**!4$=! &2*%! d99! ).+=! 7*%! +%**D!

4<(><!>&%%*=7&)?=!4(+<!t!8Ji!6F!()!+*%/=!&@!?%-!6*%)*'L4*(F<+D!4<('*!()!$)&+<*%!=+.?-!$)!$2*%$F*!

-(*'?! &@! h! 6F! &@! 6*%)*'=! 7*%! +%**! 4$=! %*>&%?*?! \K><%*>6*)A*%FD! 899i]J! T*=(?*=! 2$%-()F! -(*'?=!

A*+4**)! +%**=D! +<*! -(*'?! &@! $! +%**! $'=&! 2$%(*=! 7*%! -*$%! 4<(><! 4$=! $'=&! /*)+(&)*?! A-! +<*!

%*=7&)?*)+=!()!&.%!=+.?-J!!

;%.(+()F!&@!+<*!=<*$!+%**!=+$%+=!()!U*>*/A*%!$)?!X$).$%-D!=**?=!/$+.%*!?.%()F!,$%><!+(''!,$-!$)?!

+<*!@%.(+=!$%*!%*$?-!@&%!7(>6()F!@%&/!M7%('!+(''!M.F.=+J!5<*!=<*$!@%.(+!(=!$!F%**)!@%.(+!+<$+!%*=*/A'*=!

+<*! =<$7*! $)?! =(l*! &@! $! 7'./J!P)*! @%.(+! )&%/$''-! >&)+$()=! f! =**?D! A.+! &>>$=(&)$''-! <$=! 8! &%! g!

\U;K#D8999]J!5<*!%*=7&)?*)+=!*07'$()*?!+<$+!+<*!%(7*)*==!&@!+<*!).+!>$)!A*!=**)!@%&/!+<*!>&'&%!

&@!+<*!).+=!=<*''J!E<*)!.)%(7*!+<*!=<*''!4(''!<$2*!$!(2&%-!4<(+*!>&'&%D!4<*)!(+!(=!%(7*!(+!4(''!<$2*!$!

?$%6!A%&4)!>&'&%D!$=!2(=(A'*!@%&/!@(F!gJ!

!

!

!

;(F.%*!fJh!L!I(7*)*==!$>>&%?()F!+&!>&'&.%J!3*@+Z!%(7*D!/(??'*Z!=*/(L%(7*D!%(F<+S!.)%(7*J!

!

15

K&D!+<*!>&'&%!&@!+<*!).+=<*''!>$)!+*''!=&/*+<()F!$A&.+!+<*!).+!Y.$'(+-J!B&4*2*%D!+<*!).+!=(l*!?&*=!

)&+!>&%%*'$+*!4(+<!+<*!@$+!>&)+*)+!$>>&%?()F!+&!+<*!=+.?-!A-!3&2*++!a!B$Y!\8999]J!

!

B>B>B!! "#$%!(+$$!?,$4)!%&)!$O($+&%4!3%2(0+1!

;$>+&%=! '(6*!4*$+<*%D!A.=<!@(%*=D!7%*=*)>*!&@! ()=*>+=!$)?!7$%$=(+*=!>$)!<$2*!=(F)(@(>$)+! ()@'.*)>*!

&)!+<*!-(*'?!&@!+<*!+%**=!\R*''-!*+!$'J!899iD!U4&/&<!899i]J!M>>&%?()F!+&!U4&/&<!\899i]!?%&.F<+=!

>$)!'*$?!+&!4%()6'()F!&@!+<*!=**?!&%!*2*)!$A&%+(&)!&@!=<*$!@%.(+!F%&4+<J!I*=7&)?*)+=!/*)+(&)*?!

+<$+!=+%&)F!4()?=!&%!<*$2-!%$()!=<&4*%!>$)!/$6*! @'&4*%=!?%&7!?&4)!$)?!+<*-!$'=&!/*)+(&)*?!

+<*!)*F$+(2*!*@@*>+=!&@!?%&.F<+=!&)!=<*$!).+!-(*'?J!P+<*%!@$>+&%=!4*%*!+<*!?$/$F*!+<$+!A.=<!@(%*=!

>$)!>$.=*!+&!+<*!@'&4*%=D!+<*!@%.(+=!$)?n&%!+<*!+%**J!I*=7&)?*)+=!/*)+(&)*?!+<$+!+<*!=*2*%(+-!&@!

+<*!?$/$F*!>$.=*?!A-!@(%*!(=!7$%+'-!%*'$+*?!+&!+<*!=*$=&)!()!4<(><!+<*!@(%*!&>>.%=J!V@!@(%*=!&>>.%!()!

+<*! A*F())()F! &@! +<*! ?%-! =*$=&)! +<*! /&(=+! ()! +<*! 2*F*+$+(&)! $)?! =&('! (=! %*'$+(2*'-! <(F<D! 4<(><!

>$.=*=! +<*! ()+*)=(+-! &@! +<*! @(%*! +&! A*! =/$''*%J! V)! +<*! ?%-! =*$=&)D! +<*! 2*F*+$+(&)! >&)+$()=! '(++'*!

/&(=+D!4<(><!>$.=*=!/&%*!()+*)=*!@(%*=D!>$.=()F!/&%*!?$/$F*!+&!+<*!=<*$!+%**=J!K&/*!&@!+<*!@(%*=!

$%*!=*+!A-!<./$)=!4(+<!+<*!()+*)+(&)!+&!F*+!%(?!&@!'&4!2*F*+$+(&)!+&!?*>%*$=*!+<*!%(=6!&@!F*++()F!

A(++*)!A-! =)$6*=J! ;(%*=! >$)! $'=&!A*! =*+!4(+<! +<*! $(/! +&! <.)+! @&%! pA.=<!/*$+qJ! C=7*>($''-! -&.)F!

=<*$!+%**=!$%*!*$=('-!6(''*?!A-!@(%*D!4<(><!$@@*>+=!+%**!%*F*)*%$+(&)J!!

#$+*%7(''$%!=7*>(*=!$%*!$'=&!>&//&)!()!+<*!)&%+<!&@!N<$)$!$)?!$@@*>+!+<*!@&'($F*!$)?!@%.(+=!&@!+<*!

=<*$! +%**! \U4&/&<! 899gD! U4&/&<! 899i]J! M! '$%F*! Y.$)+(+-! &@! >$+*%7(''$%=! $)?! +%**! @&'($F*!

?$/$F*!4$=!%*>&%?*?!()!+<*!@(*'?!?.%()F!+<(=!%*=*$%><!()!+<*!@(%=+!4**6!&@!M.F.=+!899QJ!M>>&%?()F!

+&! +<*! %*=7&)?*)+! +<*! >$+*%7(''$%=!4*%*! $! 7%&A'*/D! A.+! +<*-!4&.'?! F&! $4$-! $.+&/$+(>$''-J! M)!

(/7&%+$)+! ()=*>+! @&%! +<*!=<*$! +%**D! '(6*! @&%!/$)-!+%**=D! (=! +<*!A**=!4<(><! (=! %*=7&)=(A'*! @&%! +<*!

7&''()$+(&)!&@!+<*!@%.(+=!\U4&/&<D!899g]J!5<*!=<*$!+%**!F%&4=!&)!?(@@*%*)+!=&('!+-7*=!$)?!<*(F<+=D!

*0>*7+!@&%!'&4!7'$>*=!+<$+!F*+!%*F.'$%'-!@'&&?*?!\T&@@$!*+!$'J!f::c]J!U(=7*%=(&)!&@!+<*!=<*$!).+=!(=!

?&)*!A-!$)(/$'=!'(6*!/&)6*-=!$)?!A$+=J!!

5<*!/(=+'*+&*!(=!$!7$%$=(+(>!7'$)+!$)?!(+!(=!2*%-!>&//&)!&)!+<*!=<*$!+%**=!()!+<*!H&%+<!&@!N<$)$!

\#IVN!8998]J!5<*!%*=7&)?*)+=!=+$+*!+<$+!+<*!/(=+'*+&*!$@@*>+=!+<*!@%.(+!-(*'?!$)?!+<$+!(@!+<*%*!$%*!

+&&!/$)-!&)!+<*!+%**!+<*!+%**!?(*=!&@@J!!

!

fJ8! !5%**!/$)$F*/*)+!$)?!%*F*)*%$+(&)!

5%$?(+(&)$'!/$)$F*/*)+!&@!=<*$!+%**=!(=!+&!=*'*>+(2*'-!/$()+$()!+<*!+%**=!&)!'$)?=!+<$+!(=!>'*$%*?!

@&%!+<*!7.%7&=*!&@!>.'+(2$+(&)J!5<*!$)+%&7<(>!=*'*>+(&)!&@!+%**=!&)!+<*(%!=(l*D!$F*D!$)?!-(*'?D!%*=.'+=!

()! $! %*'$+(2*! <(F<*%! -(*'?()F! $)?! %*'$+(2*! '$%F*%! +%**=! ()! @$%/! '$)?=! \U1&==$! *+! $'J! 899d]J! M!

7*%>*)+$F*!&@!d9L!:9!r!&@!4&&?-!A(&/$==! >&)=(=+=!&@! =<*$! +%**=!&)! @$%/*?! '$)?=D!4<('*! +<(=! (=!

)*$%!+&!f9!r!()!.)/$)$F*?!'$)?=D!$>>&%?()F!$!%*=*$%><!?&)*!A-!3&2*++!$)?!B$Y!\8999]!()!GF$)?$J!

I*F*)*%$+(&)! &>>.%=! )$+.%$''-! $)?! +<*! %*F*)*%$+(&)! &>>.%=! >&)+().&.='-! ()! .)/$)$F*?! '$)?=D!

4<('*!$)?!&)!@$%/!'$)?=!%*F*)*%$+(&)!&>>.%=!/$()'-!?.%()F!@$''&4!7*%(&?=J!V)!+<*!@$%/()F!=*$=&)!

$''!=/$''!2*F*+$+(&)!(=!%*/&2*?!?.%()F!7'&.F<()FD!()>'.?()F!+<*!=/$''!=<*$!+%**=J!5<$+!(=!$'=&!4<-!

@$''&4()F!$)?!+<*!'*)F+<!&@!@$''&4()F!(=!>&)=(?*%*?!$=!$!>%.>($'!@$>+&%!@&%!=<*$!+%**!%*F*)*%$+(&)!

\3&2*++!a!B$Y!8999D!K><%*>6*)A*%F!899i]J!!

P)*!&@!+<*!%*$=&)=!4<-!=*++()F!.7!$!7'$)+$+(&)!$)?!?&/*=+(>$+(&)!&@!=<*$!+%**=!(=!+(/*!+$6()F!(=!

?.*!+&!+<*!'&)F!+%**!/$+.%$+(&)!7*%(&?J!5<*!+%**=!?&)k+!=+$%+!@%.(+()F!.)+('!$@+*%!fhL!89!-*$%=D!$)?!

%*$><*=!&7+(/./!-(*'?=!)&+!.)+('!(+=!i9+<!-*$%J!!

16

N%$@+()F! (=! &)*! &@! +<*!/*+<&?=! +<$+! >&.'?! A*! ()+*%*=+()F! @&%! =<&%+*)()F! +<*! 7*%(&?! )**?*?! @&%!

=<*$!+%**=!+&!=+$%+!-(*'?()FJ!I*=*$%><!&)!=<*$!+%**!F%$@+()F!<$=!A**)!>$%%(*?!&.+!A-!K$)&.!*+!$'J!

\899i]! $)?! =<&4*?! +<$+! +<*! F%$@+()F! &@! &)+&F*)*+(>$''-! &'?! =>(&)=! &)! -&.)F*%! =7*>(/*)=! >$)!

%*=.'+! ()! =<*$! +%**=! +<$+! =+$%+! @%.(+()F!4(+<()! +4&! -*$%=J! 5<*!/$1&%(+-! &@! +<*! %*=7&)?*)+=!4*%*!

.)@$/('($%!4(+<!F%$@+()FJ!V)!=&/*!>$=*=!@$%/*%=!<$?!*2*%!<*$%?!&@!(+!$)?!()!+4&!>$=*=!F%$@+()F!4$=!

$>+.$''-! $77'(*?J!P)*!/$)! @%&/!R7$%*D! <$?!F%$@+*?! +<%**! =7*>(/*)=!&@!$! =<*$!).+! +%**!.7&)!$!

/$)F&!+%**D!$)?!=$(?! +<$+!*$><!=7*>(/*)!<$?!?(*?!4(+<()!$!@*4!-*$%=J!5<*%*! (=!$!>$=*! ()!X(%$7$!

4<*%*!=*2*%$'!=<*$!+%**!<$?!A**)!=.>>*==@.''-!F%$@+*?J!V)!+<*!#IVN!()=+(+.+*!()!T&'*D!A%$)><*=!&@!

&'?*%! =<*$! +%**=! $%*!F%$@+*?!&)! -&.)F*%! =<*$! +%**=J! K<*$!A%$)><*=! $%*! $'=&!F%$@+*?!&)!>$=<*4!

+%**=D! /$)F&! +%**=! $)?! $'=&! &)! &+<*%! +%**! +-7*=J! 5<*! #IVN! (=! $'=&! >&)?.>+()F! %*=*$%><! &)!

F*%/()$+(&)!$)?!<(F<!-(*'?()F!=7*>(*=!\2(=(+!+&!#IVN!()!X.'-!899Q]J!

!

T&0!fJf!L!#$=<*4!$)?!=<*$!!

!

M! @$%/*%! ()! R7$%*! ()!)&%+<*%)!N<$)$!&4)=!$! +%**!7'$)+$+(&)!4(+<! =<*$!$)?! >$=<*4! +%**=J! 5<(=!

>&/A()$+(&)!%$(=*=!!()+*%*=+!$=!+<*!<$%2*=+!=*$=&)!&@!+<*!+4&!=7*>(*=!&>>.%!()!?(@@*%*)+!=*$=&)=J!

#$=<*4! +%**=! <$2*! +<*(%! <$%2*=+! =*$=&)! ()! +<*! ?%-! =*$=&)D! $! 7*%(&?! ()! 4<(><! '(++'*! 4&%6! (=!

$2$('$A'*J! 5<(=! >$=<*4L=<*$! >&/A()$+(&)! >$)! F*)*%$+*! $??(+(&)$'! 4&%6! $)?! ()>&/*J! 5<(=!

>&/A()$+(&)!4$=!$'=&!)&+*?!$=!$!&77&%+.)(+-!A-!K><%*>6*)A*%F!()!<*%!%*=*$%><!()!T*)()!\899i]J!

!

!

!

K&/*! @$%/*%=! =$(?! +<$+! +<*-!.=*?! @*%+('(l*%=!A*@&%*D! A.+! +<$+! +<*-!?(?!)&+!.=*! (+! ()! +<*! @$%/()F!

=*$=&)!&@!899Q!?.*!+&!+<*!<(F<!7%(>*=J!5<*!7%(>*=!@&%!@*%+('(l*%=!?&.A'*?!A*+4**)!=7%()F!899d!$)?!

=7%()F!899Q!$>>&%?()F!+&!+<*!%*=7&)?*)+=D!4<(><!>$)!A*!*07'$()*?!?.*!+&!+<*!@.*'!7%(>*=!+<$+!<$?!

$'/&=+!?&.A'*?!()!+<(=!=$/*!7*%(&?!\()?*0/.)?(D!899:]J!!

fJ8J8!! K.=+$()$A('(+-!&@!+%**!/$)$F*/*)+!

K*2*%$'! $.+<&%=! *07%*==*?! +<*(%! >&)>*%)!&)! +<*! '$>6! &@! %*F*)*%$+(&)!&@! +<*! =<*$! +%**=! $)?! +<*!

?*>%*$=()F! =<*$! +%**! ?*)=(+-! ()! ?(@@*%*)+! >&.)+%(*=! &@! K.ALK$<$%$)! M@%(>$! \R*''-! *+! $'! 899d]J!

_&7.'$+(&)!7%*==.%*!>$.=*=!@$''&4!7*%(&?=!+&!F%&4!=<&%+*%!\P6.''&!*+!$'J!899i]J!K&/*!@$%/*%=!()!

&.%!%*=*$%><!$%*$!@$%/!&)!+<*(%!'$)?!>&)+().&.='-D!A*>$.=*!+<*-!<$2*!+&&!'(++'*!'$)?!@&%!@$''&4()FD!

4<(><!<$=!)*F$+(2*!(/7$>+!&)!=<*$!+%**!%*F*)*%$+(&)D!A.+!$'=&!<$=!)*F$+(2*!(/7$>+!&)!=&('!Y.$'(+-!

$)?!>%&7!-(*'?!()!F*)*%$'J!

M>>&%?()F!+&!N(1=A*%+=!*+!$'!\f::i]D!=<*$!+%**!?*)=(+-!<$?!?*>%*$=*?!4(+<!$77%&0(/$+*'-!ih!r!()!

T.%6()$! ;$=&D! A*+4**)! f:hd! $)?! f:QQ! \5*6'*<$(/$)&+! 899iD! C'($=! $)?! #$%)*-! 899d]! $)?! +%**!

7&7.'$+(&)! ?*>%*$=*?! @%&/! 8g9! +%**=! <$Lf! +&! ff! +%**=! <$Lf! ()! K.?$)! A*+4**)! f:i9! $)?! 899g!

\5*6'*<$(/$)&+! ! 899i]J! T*=(?*=! +<(=! =&/*! $'=&! =+$+*! +<$+! +<*%*! (=! $! +%*)?! &@! $F()F! &@! +<*! =<*$!

+%**=!4<(><!>$)!A*!*07'$()*?!A-!$!'$>6!&@!%*F*)*%$+(&)\3&2*++!$)?!B$Y!8999D!P6.''&!*+!$'J!899i]J!

V)!&.%!%*=*$%><!$%*$!%*=7&)?*)+=!()?(>$+*?!+<$+!+<*!2(''$F*!><(*@=!$)?!*$%+<!7%(*=+!?(=>&.%$F*!&%!

@&%A(?! +<*! >.++()F! ?&4)! &@! =<*$! +%**=J! V)! X(%$7$! +<*%*! 4$=! *2*)! $! >$=*! 4<*%*! 7*&7'*! 4*%*!

$%%*=+*?!$)?!@()*?!@&%!>.++()F!=<*$!+%**=!&)!+<*(%!&4)!'$)?J!K&/*!=<*$!+%**=!$%*!>.+!?&4)!&%!$%*!

A.%)+!@&%!+<*!7.%7&=*!><$%>&$'!/$6()F!$)?!=$'*J!V+!4$=!$'=&!/*)+(&)*?!+<$+!+<*!.=*!&@!><$%>&$'!(=!

$!%*'$+(2*'-!)*4!7<*)&/*)&)!()!+<*!%*F(&)!$)?!+<$+!(+!4$=!()+%&?.>*?!&)'-!=&/*!?*>$?*=!$F&J!!

;%&/! $! @$%/*%=! 7*%=7*>+(2*! =<*$! +%**=! $%*! =**)! $=! ()+*%>*7+&%=! &@! =.)'(F<+! @&%! +<*! >%&7=D!

?*>%*$=()F!>%&7!-(*'?J!B&4*2*%!(+!4$=!@&.)?!+<$+!=<*$!+%**=!()!@$%/!'$)?!>$)!>&)+%(A.+*!+&!>%&7!

17

F%&4+<! +<%&.F<! =&('! (/7%&2*/*)+! $)?! ?*>%*$=()F! *2$7&+%$)=7(%$+(&)! \5*6'*<$(/$)&+D! 899i]J! M!

@(*'?! =+.?-! ?&)*! A-! T&@@$! *+! $'J! \8999]! =<&4*?! +<$+! =&('!/&(=+.%*D! &%F$)(>! >$%A&)! >&)+*)+! $)?!

7&+$==(./!>&)+*)+!4$=!<(F<*%!)*$%!+&! +<*!=<*$! +%**J!^(*'?!&@!>%&7=!4*%*! '&4*=+!.)?*%!+<*! +%**!

>%&4)!$)?!<(F<*=+! $+! +<*!*?F*! &@! +<*! =<*$! +%**! >%&4)J! ;%&/! +<(=! (+! >&.'?!A*! >&)>'.?*?! +<$+! $!

>*%+$()!$/&.)+!&@!=<*$!+%**=!=+$)?()F!()!+<*!@$%/!'$)?D!4$=!)&+!&)'-!F&&?!@&%!+<*!-(*'?!&@!=<*$!

).+=D!A.+!$'=&!@&%!>%&7!-(*'?J!!

K&/*+(/*=!+<*-!$%*!%*/&2*?!A*>$.=*!&@!+<(=!&%!7%.)*?J!_%.)()F!&@!+<*!+%**!A%$)><*=!$'=&!&>>.%=!

@&%!+<*!7.%7&=*!&@!()>%*$=()F!=<*$!@%.(+!-(*'?!&@!&'?*%!+%**=J!5%$>+&%!7'&.F<()F!(=!$'=&!*07*>+*?!+&!

<$2*!)*F$+(2*!*@@*>+=!&)!=<*$!+%**!?*)=(+-D!A.+!(=!)&+!\-*+]!2*%-!>&//&)!()!+<*!=+.?-!$%*$J!V)!+<*!

@(*'?! '$%F*! 2$%($A('(+-! ?(@@*%*)>*=! ()! +%**! ?*)=(+-D! A.+! $'=&! ?(=+%(A.+(&)! &@! +%**! F(%+<!4*%*! 2(=(A'*!

A*+4**)! ?(@@*%*)+! 7'&+=D! 4<(><! /(F<+! ()?(>$+*! ?(@@*%*)+! /$)$F*/*)+! $77%&$><*=! &@! +<*! +%**=!

?*7*)?()F!&)!+<*!'$)?!&4)*%J!

!

fJg! 5<*!=<*$!).+!7(>6*%=!

K<*$!).+!7(>6()F!$)?!+<*!7%&>*==()F!&@!).+=! ()+&!A.++*%! (=! +%$?(+(&)$''-!?&)*!A-!4&/*)!\C'($=!a!

#$%)*-D!899d]J!5<*!%*=7&)?*)+=! ()! +<*! %*=*$%><!$%*$! ()?(>$+*?!+<$+!=&/*!/*)!>&''*>+! +<*!).+=D!

A.+! )&)*! &@! +<*/! *0+%$>+! A.++*%! @%&/! (+J! K&/*! %*=7&)?*)+=! =$(?! +<$+! +<*%*! $%*! /&%*! /*)!

>&''*>+()F!)&4!+<$)!()!+<*!7$=+!?.*!+&!+<*!%(=*!()!7%(>*=!&@@*%*?!@&%!+<*!).+=J!!

K<*$! ).+! 7(>6()F! (=! $! ?$('-! $>+(2(+-J!E&/*)! $)?! ><('?%*)! .=.$''-! >&''*>+! =<*$! ).+=! *$%'-! ()! +<*!

/&%)()F!\@%&/!hJg9!+&!QJg9]!4(+<()!f!Lg!6/!%$?(.=!@%&/!+<*%*!<&.=*J!P)!$2*%$F*!+<*-!F&!7(>6()F!i!

?$-=!7*%!4**6J!5<*!4&/*)!=*+!&.+!*$%'-!A*>$.=*!+<*%*!(=!>&/7*+(+(&)!A*+4**)!7(>6*%=S!+<*!@(%=+!

+&!7(>6!4(''!F*+!+<*!@%.(+=J!N*)*%$''-!+<*!).+!7(>6*%=!F&!A$%*!@**+!&%!+<*-!4*$%!='(77*%=J!P)*!&@!+<*!

/*)+(&)*?!7%&A'*/=!A-!+<*!/$1&%(+-!&@!+<*!%*=7&)?*)+=!(=!%*'$+*?!+&!*$%'-!7(>6()F!4<*)!+<*%*k=!

'(++'*!'(F<+!$)?!2(=(A('(+-!(=!'&4D!(=!+<*!%(=6!+&!F*+!A(++*)!A-!=>&%7(&)=!&%!=)$6*=D!$=!$'=&!=)$6*=!$%*!

$++%$>+*?!+&!+<*!=<*$!@%.(+J!5<(=!(=!$!%(=6D!@&%!$!A(+*=!&@!=)$6*=!+<$+!&>>.%!()!+<*!)&%+<!&@!N<$)$!>$)!

A*!/&%+$'J!!

K&/*!4&/*)!$)?!><('?%*)!=<$6*!+<*!=<*$! +%**!&%! +<%&4!4(+<!=+(>6=! ()+&! +<*!A%$)><*=! +&!/$6*!

+<*!@%.(+=!@$''D!A.+!/&=+!$%*!$4$%*!&@!+<*!@$>+!+<$+!+<(=!>$)!/$6*!.)%(7*!@%.(+=!@$''D!$)?!+<$+!@%&/!

).+=!&@!.)%(7*!@%.(+=!'*==!=<*$!A.++*%!>$)!A*!&A+$()*?!?.*!+&!+<*!'&4*%!@$+!>&)+*)+J!!

!I*=7&)?*)+=! ()?(>$+*?!+<*-!?&!)&+!F&!@$%! ()+&!+<*!A.=<!+&!>&''*>+!=<*$!).+=D!&%! @(%*4&&?J!5<*-!

=$(?!+<(=!4$=!A*>$.=*!+<*-!4*%*!$@%$(?!)&!+&!F*+!<*'7! ()!>$=*!&@!$>>(?*)+=!$)?n&%!A*>$.=*!+<*-!

4*%*!$@%$(?!+&!/**+!F<&=+=J!!

V)!+<*=*!>&//.)(+(*=!+<*%*!$%*!+%$?(+(&)$'!%.'*=!&)!4<*%*!&)*!>$)!&%!>$))&+!7(>6J!P)*!>$)!7(>6!

+<*!@%.(+=!&)!&)*=!&4)!>.'+(2$+*?!'$)?S!)&!&)*!*'=*!(=!$''&4*?!+&!7(>6D!.)'*==!+<*!&4)*%!7*%/(+=!(+J!

V)!/&=+! >$=*=! *0+*)?*?! @$/('-! &@! +<*! &4)*%! (=! $''&4*?! >&''*>+! ).+=! &)! +<*! '$)?J! h:! &.+! &@! c9!

%*=7&)?*)+=!=+$+*?!+<$+!$)-&)*!(=!$''&4*?!+&!7(>6!).+=!@%&/!@$''&4!&%!A.=<!$)?J!!

!

P)!>.'+(2$+*?!@$%/!'$)?=D!p(''*F$'q!7(>6()F!(=!>&//&)S!+<&=*!4<&!$%*!)&+!7*%/(++*?!+&!7(>6!@%.(+=!

>&/*! $)?! 7(>6! +<*/!4<*)! +<*! @$%/*%! (=! )&+! $%&.)?J!E(+<! +<*! @$%/*%! <$2()F! 7'&+=! &@! '$)?! &)!

?(@@*%*)+!'&>$+(&)=D!=&/*+(/*=!/('*=!$4$-!@%&/!<&/*D!(''*F$'!7(>6()F!(=!?(@@(>.'+!+&!7%*2*)+J!!

!

18

fJi!! V/7&%+$)>*!&@!=<*$!@&%!'(2*'(<&&?!

5<*!/$()!$>+(2(+-! ()! +<*! %*=*$%><!$%*$!4$=! $F%(>.'+.%*!4(+<!>%&7=! $=!F%&.)?).+=D!A*$)=D!/$(l*D!

/(''*+D!=&%F<./D!%(>*D!&6%$D!+&/$+&*=D!$)?!&)(&)=J!M'=&!'(2*=+&>6!=.><!$=!F&$+=D!><(>6*)=!&%!@&4'=!

$%*!>&//&)J!3(2*=+&>6!>$)!=*%2*!$=!>$7(+$'!=$2()FJ!,&=+!@$%/*%=!()!+<(=!%*F(&)!?&!)&+!<$2*!/.><!

'$)?D!f!O!h!<$J!5<*=*!@$%/*%=!()!+<*!=+.?-!$%*$!/$()'-!7%&?.>*!@&%!+<*(%!&4)!>&)=./7+(&)=!%$+<*%!

+<$)! @&%!$!/$%6*+! \=.A=(=+*)>*! @$%/()F]J! V)!$!F&&?!-*$%!7$%+! &@! +<*!<$%2*=+! >$)!A*! =&'?! +&!A.-!

&+<*%!+-7*!&@!@&&?=D!=**?=!&%!@*%+('(l*%=J!V)!-*$%=!&@!@$('*?!<$%2*=+!+<*!<$%2*=+!/(F<+!A*!'(++'*D!$)?!

4<*)!(+!(=!+&&!'(++'*!$)?!)&!>$7(+$'!&%!<*'7!(=!$+!<$)?!+<(=!>$)!'*$?!+&!@&&?!=<&%+$F*J!

5<*!$2*%$F*!$/&.)+!&@!).+=!>&''*>+*?!?.%()F!+<*!@%.(+()F!=*$=&)!Q9!6F!&@!6*%)*'=J!5<(=!<$=!$!2$'.*!

&@!GKm!fh!()!+<*!=<*$!7(>6()F!=*$=&)D!*)!>$)!%*$><!+&!$!2$'.*!&@!GKmg9!$@+*%!+<*!7(>6()F!=*$=&)J!

V)>&/*! @%&/! >%&7! =*''()F! ()! +<*! GEI! >&//.)(+(*=! 2$%(*=! @%&/! )*F$+(2*! \)*+! $/&.)+! &@! @&&?!

A&.F<+]!+&!.7!+&!g9!GKmJ!

E<*)!+<*!@()$)>($'!=(+.$+(&)!7*%/(+=!=<*$!).+=!$%*!&@+*)!=+&%*?!$)?!.=*?!@&%!<&/*!>&)=./7+(&)!

&%!=&'?!4<*)!7%(>*=!$%*!<(F<*%J!P2*%!<$'@!&@!+<*!%*=7&)?*)+=!&@! +<*!GEI!=.%2*-! ()?(>$+*?!+<*-!

4&.'?!A.-!=<*$!).+=!()!+<*!7(>6()F!=*$=&)!$)?!=*''! ()!+(/*=!4<*)!!7%(>*=!$%*!<(F<*%D!(@!+<*-!<$?!

+<*!/&)*-!+&! ()2*=+J!5<*!7&&%*=+! @$%/*%=!4(+<!@$('*?!<$%2*=+=!$%*!@&%>*?!+&!=*''! +<*!).+=! ()! +<*!

7(>6()F!=*$=&)!4<*)!7%(>*=!$%*!'&4!+&!A.-!@&&?!&%!7$-!@&%!=.??*)!/*?(>$'!>&=+=!&%!@.)*%$'!>&=+=J!

5<*-!/(F<+!><&&=*!+&!A.-!=<*$!A.++*%!()!+<*!'*$)!=*$=&)!@&%!$!<(F<*%!7%(>*!+<$)!+<*-!7%(>*!+<*-!

F&+!@&%!(+!*$%'(*%!&)D!/$6()F!$!)*+!'&==J!

T*=(?*=!+<*!*>&)&/(>!7&+*)+($'!=<*$!@%.(+!$'=&!<$=!).+%(+(&.=!2$'.*J!5<*!@%.(+()F!?.%()F!+<*!()!+<*!

'*$)!=*$=&)!4<*)!@&&?!=+&>6=!$%*!'&4!A.+!4<*)!)**?!@&%!'$A&.%!(=!<(F<!\,$%$)lD!*+!$'J!899g]J!V)!

+<(=! =*$=&)! $)-! $??(+(&)$'! @&&?! (=! 4*'>&/*! $)?! +<*! =<*$! @%.(+! =*%2*=! $=! $)! (/7&%+$)+! $)?!

).+%(+(&.=! =)$>6J! K<*$! A.++*%D! @&%! )&)L7$=+&%$'! $%*$=n>.'+.%*=! $%*! +<*! &)'-! =&.%>*! &@! @$+! ()! +<*!

?(*+=!&@!/$)-!'&>$'!>&//.)(+(*=! ()!K.ALK$<$%$)!M@%(>$!\K><%*>6*)A*%FD!8999]J!T*=(?*=!+<(=!=<*$!

A.++*%!>&)+$()=!2(+$/()!CD!M!$)?!;!\I*)@%&4D!899Q]!

,&)*-!@%&/!=<*$!F*)*%$''-!F&*=!+&!+<*!4&/*)!$)?!+<(=!(=!&)*!&@!+<*!2*%-!@*4!=&.%>*=!&@!()>&/*!

@&%!+<*/J!E(+<!+<*!/&)*-!+<*!4&/*)!F*+!@%&/!=*''()F!+<*!).+=!&%!+<*!A.++*%D!+<*-!F*)*%$''-!A.-!

@&&?D!>'&+<*=!&%!7$-!=><&&'!@**=!$)?!/*?(>$'!>$%*J!!

C=7*>($''-!@&%!+<*!-*$%=!&@!@$('*?!<$%2*=+D!()>&/*!@%&/!=<*$!/(F<+!=*%2*!$=!$)!*0+%$!A.@@*%!+&!A*!

$A'*!+&!A.-!@&&?J!M)?!$'=&!@&%!+<&=*!4<&!$%*!7&&%!$)?!'$)?'*==D!=<*$!).+!7(>6()F!$)?!=*''()F!>$)!

A*!>%.>($'!@&%!=.%2(2$'!$=!(+!(=!&)*!&@!+<*!@*4!)$+.%$'!%*=&.%>*=!+<*-!<$2*!$>>*==!+&!&@!*>&)&/(>$'!

2$'.*J!!

E&/*)! +%$?(+(&)$''-!?&!)&+!&4)! '$)?D! @&%! +<*! '$)?&4)*%=<(7! (=!7$%+!&@! +<*!7$+%($%><$'! =-=+*/J!

E(?&4=D!<&4*2*%D!>$)!()<*%(+!+<*!'$)?!&@!+<*(%!?*>*$=*?!<.=A$)?D!()!=&/*!>$=*=!'$)?!(=!>'$(/*?!

A$>6!A-!+<*!<.=A$)?k=!@$/('-J!M)&+<*%!4$-!()!4<(><!4&/*)!>$)!A*>&/*!&4)*%!&@!$!7(*>*!&@!'$)?!

(=!A-!7.%><$=*J!_*&7'*!+<$+!?&!)&+!&4)!'$)?!?&!<$2*!$>>*==!+&!=<*$!).+=! (@!+<*%*!$%*!=<*$!).+=!

F%&4()F!&)!@$''&4!'$)?!&%!A.=<!'$)?!&)!4$'6()F!?(=+$)>*J!B&4*2*%D!?.*!+&!7&7.'$+(&)!F%&4+<!+<*!

$/&.)+!&@!@$''&4!$)?!A.=<!'$)?!(=!?*>%*$=()FD!4<('*!>&/7*+(+(&)!@&%!).+=!(=!()>%*$=()FJ!

_%(>*=!&@@*%*?!()!%.%$'!$%*$=!$%*!F*)*%$''-!'*==!+<$)!()!A*++*%!>&))*>+*?!$)?!'$%F*%!+&4)=J!V)!X.'-!

899Q!7%(>*=!&@!).+=!7*%!6F!4*%*!$=!@&''&4=Z!!

!

5$A'*!fJf!L!_%(>*=!&@!=<*$!6*%)*'=!()!GKmn6F!&2*%!+(/*!@&%!+<*!7'$>*=!&@!R7$%*D!R$%)(!$)?!X(%$7$u!!

! R7$%*!! R$%)(! X(%$7$!

B$%2*=+!899d! 9D9d!L9D9:! 9D9:!! 9Dff!!

3*$)!899d! G7!+&!9Dgf! e! \*=+(/$+*?! G7!+&!9Dgc!

19

9Dgi]!

B$%2*=+!899Q!! 9Jff!O!9Jfi!! 9JfiL!9Jfc! 9JfcO9J8g!

u!)&+*!+<$+!+<*=*!7%(>*=!><$)F*!4(+<()!+<*!'*$)n<$%2*=+!=*$=&)=!$=!4*''J!

!

V)!+<*!<$%2*=+!=*$=&)!$!=+$)?$%?!=(l*?!A$F!&@!Qh6F!&@!>&.'?!>&=+!$%&.)?!fg!GKmD!4<('*!()!+<*!'*$)!

=*$=&)! (+! >$)! F*+! $=! <(F<! $=! gf!GKm! @&%! +<*! =$/*!4*(F<+! &@! ).+=J!E(+<! +<*! *=+(/$+*?! $2*%$F*!

$)).$'! ()>&/*!&@! $! @$%/*%=! ()>&/*! =&/*4<*%*! ()! A*+4**)! h9Lf99!GKm! ()! +<(=! %*F(&)D! ()>&/*!

@%&/!=<*$!>$)!>&)+%(A.+*!=(F)(@(>$)+'-J!

!

!

!

!

!

20

#<$7+*%!8! K<*$!).+!7%&>*==()F!!

V)! +<(=!><$7+*%!$!?*=>%(7+(&)!4(''!A*!F(2*)!&)!+<*!7%&>*==()F!=+*7=!)**?*?! +&!&A+$()!?%(*?!=<*$!

6*%)*'=!$)?!()!+<*!=*>&)?!7$%+!&@!+<*!><$7+*%!+<*!7%&>*==()F!=+*7=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!4(''!

A*!*07'$()*?J!!

!

8Jf!! U%-()F!&@!6*%)*'=!

M@+*%!+<*!=<*$!).+=!$%*!>&''*>+*?!+<*!).+=!F&!+<%&.F<!@(2*!7%&>*==()F!=+*7=!A*@&%*!+<*-!$%*!7'$>*?!

()!=+&%$F*D!7.+!&.+!@&%!=$'*!&%!A*@&%*!A.++*%!>$)!A*!*0+%$>+*?!@%&/!+<*/J!5<*!7%&>*==!&@!&A+$()()F!

?%(*?!6*%)*'=!(=!?*7(>+*?!=><*/$+(>$''-!()!@(F.%*!8JfJ!!

!

;(F.%*!8Jf!L!K+*7=!&@!7%&>*==()F!@%*=<'-!7(>6*?!).+=!()+&!?%(*?!6*%)*'=!

!

;>B>B!! G$70X%4!03!/'4/!!

M@+*%!+<*!).+=!<$2*!A**)!>&''*>+*?D!+<*!7.'7!&@!+<*!=<*$!@%.(+!(=!%*/&2*?J!5<*!7.'7!>&)+$()=!<(F<!

$/&.)+=!&@!=.F$%!+<$+!*)>&.%$F*=!+<*!F%&4+<!&@!@.)F(!4<(><!?*>%*$=*=!&('!>&)+*)+!&@!+<*!6*%)*'J!

K&!+<*!7.%7&=*!&@!+<*!%*/&2$'!&@!7.'7!(=!+&!7%*2*)+!@.%+<*%!F%&4+<!&@!@.)F(J!!

;>B>;!! J0,4,&5!

M@+*%! ?*7.'7()F! +<*! ).+=! $%*! A&('*?! +&! +*%/()$+*! +<*! F*%/()$+(&)! 7%&>*==! &@! +<*! ).+=J! 5<*!

F*%/()$+(&)!7%&>*==!=+$%+=!4(+<()!$!@*4!?$-=!$@+*%!+<*!<$2*!@$''*)!+&!+<*!F%&.)?!$)?!'*$?=!+&!+<*!

@&%/$+(&)!&@!@%**!@$++-!$>(?=D!4<(><!4(''!%*=.'+!()!7&&%*%!=<*$!A.++*%!Y.$'(+-!$)?!>$)!>$.=*!$!pA$?q!

+$=+*J!M@+*%!+<*!).+=!<$2*!A**)!>&&6*?!@&%!$A&.+!ih!/().+*=!$=<!(=!$??*?!+&!+<*!).+=J!M>>&%?()F!

+&! +<*! '&>$'=! +<(=! =+*7! =+&7=! +<*! @&%/$+(&)! &@! =+$%><! $)?! (=! )**?*?! +&! =.>>*==@.''-! &A+$()! =<*$!

A.++*%! '$+*%! &)J! M>>&%?()F! +&! +<*! XV#M! \899d]! 7%&'&)F*?! A&('()F! &@! +<*! @%.(+=! +*)?=! +&! ?*=+%&-!

?*=(%$A'*!)$+.%$'! >&/7&.)?=! +<$+!6**7!+<*!6*%)*'! ()!F&&?!>&)?(+(&)J!5<*!7%&>*==&%=!=+$+*! +<$+!

A&('()F! @&%! $! 7%&'&)F*?! 7*%(&?! /$6*=! *0+%$>+(&)! &@! A.++*%! ?.%()F! /&%*! ?(@@(>.'+D! &%! *2*)!

(/7&==(A'*!'$+*%!&)J!

;>B>=!! U+?,&5!&'(1!

E<*)!A&('()F!(=!@()(=<*?!+<*!).+=!$%*!'*@+!&)!+<*!F%&.)?!&%!&)!+<*!%&&@!@&%!$!>&.7'*!&@!?$-=!+&!?%-!

()!+<*!=.)J!M+!+<*!*)?!&@!+<(=!?%-()F!=+*7D!+<*!/&(=+.%*!>&)+*)+!&@!+<*!).+=!4(''!A*!$77%&0(/$+*'-!

Qr! &@! +<*(%! 4*(F<+! \XV#MD! 899d]J! K<*$! >$)! ).+=!4(''! +.%)! A'$>6! (@! +<*! ).+=! >$))&+! ?%-! 4*''D! @&%!

*0$/7'*!(@!+<*-!$%*!4*++*?!A-!%$()!&%!4<*)!?(%*>+!=.)'(F<+!(=!)&+!$2$('$A'*J!_&&%'-!?%(*?!&%!A'$>6!

).+=!@*+><!'&4*%!7%(>*=!&)!+<*!/$%6*+!+<$)!4*''L?%(*?!6*%)*'=J!!

21

;>B>K! G$70X%4!1#$44!!

5<*!).+=!$%*!4*''L?%(*?!4<*)!+<*-!7%&?.>*!$!%$++'()F!)&(=*!4<*)!=<$6*)J!M+!+<(=!7&()+D!+<*!=<*''!

<$=! ?*+$><*?! @%&/! +<*! 6*%)*'! $)?! +<*! =<*''! >$)! A*! *$=('-! %*/&2*?! A-! <$)?! $@+*%! +<*! ).+! (=!

>%$>6*?J!#%$>6()F!&@!+<*!=<*''!(=!?&)*!A-!F*)+'-!7&.)?()F!+<*!).+=!4(+<!$!/&%+$%!&%!=+&)*J!!

;>B>M!! U+?,&5!9$+&$41!!

5<*!6*%)*'=! $%*! +<*)!?%(*?! @&%! $)&+<*%!g! +&!h!?$-=J!M@+*%! +<(=! +<*!/&(=+.%*!>&)+*)+=! ()! 6*%)*'=!

=<&.'?!A*!$A&.+!fr!&@!+<*(%!4*(F<+!\XV#MD!899d]J!5<(=!(=!?&)*!+&!7%*2*)+!@.)F(!+&!F%&4!()!+<*!).+J!

V)! +$A'*fJ! +<*! %*=.'+=! &@! +(/*!&@! '$A&.%!$)?! %*=&.%>*! >&=+=! $%*! =<&4)!7*%!7%&>*==()F! =+*7J! 5<(=!

4$=!/*$=.%*?! ?.%()F! =<*$! ).+! 7%&>*==()F! A-!4&/*)! ()! +<*! R7$%*! >&//.)(+-J! V)! +$A'*! 8Jf! $)!

&2*%2(*4! (=! F(2*)! &)! +<*! %*=&.%>*=! >&=+D! '$A&.%! +(/*D! $(/! &@! +<*! =+*7D! $)?! +&&'=! .=*?! 7*%!

7%&>*==()F!=+*7J!!

!

5$A'*!8Jf!L!K><*/$+(>!&2*%2(*4Z!!7%&>*==()F!=+*7=!&@!F*++()F!+<*!).+=!%*$?-!@&%!=+&%$F*!!

!

K+*7=! PA1*>+(2*! j.$)+(+-!

.=*?!

j.$)+(+-!

&A+$()*?!

5(/*! G=*?!

+&&'=!

G=*?!

%*=&.%>*=!

#&=+!

%*=&.%>*=!

uf!

#&//*)+

=!

I*/&2$'!

&@!7.'7!

M2&(?! @.)F(!

F%&4+<!

g9! 6F!

@%.(+=!

fh! 6F!

@%*=<!

).+=!

f!<!! L!! L! L! L!

T&('()F! &@!

).+=!

K+&7!

F*%/()$+(&)!

fh! 6F!

@%*=<!

).+=!

fh! 6F!

A&('*?!

).+=!

!

f<uf!

V%&)!

>&&6()F!

7&+D!

A$=6*+n!

7*%@&%$+

*?!/*+$'!

A$=()!

!

E$+*%Zff!

3D!

;(%*4&&?D!!!

M=<!!

E$+*%Z! v!

9D9fh!N#!

!

;(%*4&&?Z!

f!N#!

!

!

_%&'&)F*?!

A&('()F! w!

?*=+%&-=!

?*=(%*?!!

>&/7&.)

?=!!

U%-()F!

).+=!

U*+$><!

6*%)*'=!

@%&/! =<*''D!

$2&(?! @.)F(!

$)?! +.%)!

A'$>6!

fh! 6F!

A&('*?!

).+=!

:! 6F!

?%(*?!

).+=!

g!+&!Q!

?$-=!

u8!

L! L! L! +&&! /.><!

%$()@$''!

?.%()F!

?%-()F!

7%&>*==!w!

A'$>6!

6*%)*'=!

I*/&2$'!

&@!=<*''!

I*/&2*!

6*%)*'=!

@%&/!=<*''!

:! 6F!

?%(*?!

).+=!

d!+&!Q!!6F!

6*%)*'=!

x!<! ,&%+$%!!

a! 7*=+'*!

n!=+&)*!

L! L! L!

U%-()F!

6*%)*'=!

M2&(?!

F%&4()F!

@.)F(!

d! 6F!

6*%)*'=!

).+=!

c! 6F!

?%(*?!

6*%)*'=!

g+&! !h!

?$-=!

n! L! L! +&&! /.><!

%$()@$''!

?.%()F!

?%-()F!

7%&>*==!w!

A'$>6!

6*%)*'=!

22

f!!5(/*!)*>*==$%-!+&!>&''*>+!4$+*%!$)?!@(%*4&&?!(=!)&+!()>'.?*?!

8!4*$+<*%!?*7*)?*)+S!/&%*!=.)D!'*==!+(/*!)**?*?!+&!?%-!

!

P)>*! +<*! 6*%)*'=! $%*! ?%(*?! +<*-! $%*! *(+<*%! =+&%*?D! &%! +<*-! $%*! =&'?! &%! 7%&>*==*?! %(F<+! $4$-J!

N*)*%$''-D!=<*$!6*%)*'=!=+&%*?!()! '$%F*!7'$=+(>!=$>6=! ()=(?*!$!=+&%$F*!%&&/J!V)!N<$)$!+<*%*!4*%*!

+4&!+-7*=!&@!=+$)?$%?!=(l*?!A$F=!4<(><!$%*!+<*!&)*!+<$+!>$)!>&)+$()!f89!6F!&@!=<*$!6*%)*'=!\i9!

>&>&!A&4'=f!&@!6*%)*'=]D!$)?!+<*!=/$''*%!A$F!>$)!>&)+$()!:9!6F!&@!6*%)*'=!\g9!>&>&!A&4'=]J!!

!

U.%()F!=+&%$F*!+<*!6*%)*'=!=&/*+(/*=!F*+!()@*=+*?!4(+<!@.)F(J!5<(=!(=!+<*!>$=*!4<*)!+<*!).+=!$%*!

)&+! 4*''! ?%(*?D! &%! 4<*)! +<*! ).+=! $%*! =+&%*?! ()! <./(?! >&)?(+(&)=J! 5&! F*+! %(?! &@! +<*! @.)F(! +<*!

6*%)*'=!$%*!4$=<*?!4(+<!@%*=<!4$+*%!$)?!%*L?%(*?!@&%!$!>&.7'*!&@!?$-=J!P+<*%!7%&A'*/=!+<$+!&>>.%!

?.%()F!=+&%$F*!$%*!/$FF&+=!+<$+!*$+!+<*!).+=J!!

!

!

8J8!! K<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!

K<*$!A.++*%!>$)!A*!*0+%$>+*?! ()!?(@@*%*)+!4$-=J!,*+<&?=!&@!*0+%$>+(&)!>$)!?(@@*%! >&//.)(+-!&%!

%*F(&)J!;&%!*0$/7'*D! ()!T.%6()$!;$=&!+<*!).+=!$%*!A.%(*?! ()+&!+<*!F%&.)?!+&!=+&7!+<*!).+=! @%&/!

F*%/()$+()FD!4<('*!()!N<$)$!+<*!).+=!$%*!A&('*?!+&!=+&7!F*%/()$+(&)!\3&2*++D!899i]J!

,$).$'!*0+%$>+(&)!<*%*!(=!?*=>%(A*?!$=!(+!4$=!&A=*%2*?!()!+<*!()!+<*!2(''$F*!&@!R7$%*D!$)?!=(/('$%!

4$-=! &@! 7%&>*==()F! <$2*! A**)! &A=*%2*?! ()! +<*! H&%+<*%)! %*F(&)J! 5&! >&/7$%*! >&=+LA*)*@(+=! @&%!

/$).$'! *0+%$>+(&)!4(+<! +<$+! &@! ! =*/(L$.+&/$+*?! *0+%$>+(&)D! =/$''L=>$'*! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)!

@$>+&%(*=!()!X(%$7$!4*%*!2(=(+*?J!!

M+!+<*!*)?!&@!+<*!><$7+*%!&+<*%!*0$/7'*=!&)!=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!/*+<&?=!4(''!A*!F(2*)D!+&!F(2*!

+<*! %*$?*%! $)! &2*%2(*4! &@! +<*! ?(@@*%*)+! /*+<&?=! .=*?D! A&+<! '&>$''-D! %*F(&)$''-D! $)?!

()+*%)$+(&)$''-J!M=!4$=!/*)+(&)*?!A*@&%*D!=<*$!A.++*%!>$)!A*!*0+%$>+*?!@%&/!=<*$!6*%)*'=J!V)!+<(=!

=*>+(&)!+<*!7%&>*==()F!=+*7=!+&4$%?=!+<(=!*0+%$>+(&)!$%*!?*=>%(A*?!=+*7!A-!=+*7!J!

5&!7%&>*==!+<*!).+=!()+&!A.++*%D!$)!$??(+(&)$'!=(0!7%&>*==()F!=+*7=!$%*!%*Y.(%*?!$=!?*7(>+*?!A*'&4!

()!@(F.%*!8J8J!

!

;(F.%*!8J8!L!K+*7=!&@!7%&>*==()F!=<*$!6*%)*'=!()+&!=<*$!A.++*%!!

!

;>;>B!! H+%),(,0&%4!7%&'%4!$O(+%2(,0&!!

E<*)!+<*!4&/*)!*0+%$>+!=<*$!A.++*%D!$!/$0(/./!&@!=(0!+&!+4*'2*!6F!&@!6*%)*'=!(=!7%&>*==*?!$+!$!

+(/*J!5<(=!(=!A*>$.=*!=&/*!7%&>*==()F!=+*7=!)**?!+&!A*!?&)*!&)!+<*!=$/*!?$-!4(+<!'(/(+*?!+(/*!

()+*%2$'=D!$)?!4(+<!+&&!/.><!Y.$)+(+-!A*()F!7%&>*==*?!$+!+<*!=$/*!+(/*D!+<(=!(=!)&+!7&==(A'*J!5<*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!f!1Coco bowl is a standard sized bowl that is used as a method to measure many edible goods, widely used in markets all over Ghana

as an alternative to weighing scale which are seldom used by small traders. One coco bowl can contain about 2.4 kg of shea kernels. However, one bowl of kernels bought actually weighs 3 kg, because the sellers/buyers usually add one big handful. !

23

7%&>*==()F! =+*7=! )**?*?! @&%! +%$?(+(&)$'! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! $)?! +<$+! 4(''! ?*=>%(A*?! ()! +<(=!

=*>+(&)!$%*Z!fJ!A%*$6()F!8J!%&$=+()FD!gJ!7&.)?()F!iJ!F%()?()F!hJ!A*$+()F!$)?!cJ!A&('()FJ!!

!

;>;>B!<>!J+$%9,&5!

5<*!@(%=+!=+*7!(=!+&!(=!+&!A%*$6!+<*!6*%)*'=!()+&!=/$''!7(*>*=!=&!+<$+!+<*-!$%*!7%*7$%*?!@&%!%&$=+()FJ!

T%*$6()F!(=!?&)*!4(+<!$!/&%+$%!$)?!7*=+'*J!!

!

;>;>B!J>!G0%1(,&5!

5<*)! +<*=*! ).+! 7(*>*=! $%*! %&$=+*?J! M@+*%! +<(=! =+*7! (+! (=! 2(+$'! +<$+! $''! +<*! 7%&>*==! +<$+! @&''&4Z!

7&.)?()FD!F%()?()FD!A*$+()F!$)?!A&('()F!$%*!?&)*!4(+<!'(/(+*?!+(/*!()+*%2$'=J!I&$=+()F!(=!=+&77*?!

4<*)! +<*! 6*%)*'=! $++$()! $! ?**7! A%&4)! >&'&.%! $)?! 4<*)! +<*-! >$)! A*! *$=('-! A%&6*)! A-! <$)?J!

M>>&%?()F! +&! K><%*>6*)A*%F! \899i]! %&$=+()F! $+! $! +*/7*%$+.%*! >'&=*! +&! f89y#! 4(''! '*$?! +&!

/$0(/./! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! 4(+<&.+! +<*! 6*%)*'! F*++()F! A.%)+J! T.++*%! *0+%$>+*?! @%&/! A.%)*?!

6*%)*'!A(+=!4(''!A*>&/*!A'$>6!$)?!>$)k+!A*!=&'?!&)!+<*!/$%6*+J!!

!

;>;>B!D>!F0'&),&5!

P)>*!%&$=+*?D!7(*>*=!$%*!$F$()!7&.)?*?!4(+<!$!/&%+$%!$)?!7*=+'*!+&!&A+$()!$!A%&4)LA'$>6!7$=+*J!

5<*!7$=+*!(=!+<*)!%*/&2*?!$)?!7.+!()!$!>&&6()F!7&+!(=!<*$+*?!+&!@$>('(+$+*!+<*!F%()?()F!=+*7!4<(><!

(=!)*0+J!!

!

;>;>B!U>!-+,&),&5!

5<*! <*$+*?! A'$>6! 7$=+*! (=! F%()?*?! 4(+<! $! F%()?()F! =+&)*! &)! $! @'$+! =+&)*! =.%@$>*J! 5<(=! =+*7! (=!

()?(>$+*?!A-!+<*!%*=7&)?*)+=!+&!A*!+<*!<$%?*=+J!5<(=!=+*7!(=!$!2(+$'!7$%+!@&%!+<*!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!

7%&>*==D!@&%!+<*!+<&%&.F<)*==!$+!4<(><!+<*!F%()?()F!(=!?&)*!4(''!A*!$!?*+*%/()$)+!@$>+&%!@&%!+<*!

Y.$)+(+-!&@!A.++*%!+<$+!(=!*2*)+.$''-!&A+$()*?J!

!

;>;>B!N>!J$%(,&5!!

T*@&%*! +<*!7$=+*! (=! A*$+*)D!4$%/!4$+*%! (=!/(0*?! ()+&! +<*!7$=+*J!E$%/!4$+*%! (=! $??*?! =*2*%$'!

+(/*=!?.%()F! +<*!A*$+()F! +&! 6**7!+<*!7$=+*!$+!$! %*'$+(2*!<(F<! +*/7*%$+.%*!A*>$.=*! (@! +<*!7$=+*!

A*>&/*=! +&! >&'?! +<*!/$==! A*>&/*=! +<&.F<! $)?! A*$+()F! A*>&/*=! ?(@@(>.'+J! U.%()F! +<*! A*$+()F!

7%&>*==!+<*!A.++*%!=<&.'?!$77*$%!$=!$!>%*$/-!/$==!@'&$+()F!&)!+&7!&@!+<*!/(0+.%*D!=**!@(F.%*!8JgJ!

!

!

24

!

;(F.%*!8Jg!L!#%*$/-!/$==!=*7$%$+()F!@%&/!A%&4)!4$+*%!!!!

!

;>;>B!6>!J0,4,&5!

5<(=!/$==!(=!+<*)!4$=<*?!&)>*!&%!+4(>*!A*@&%*!A&('()FJ!E$=<()F!4(''!%*/&2*!.)4$)+*?!=<*$!).+!

$)?!>&)+$/()$)+!>&/7&.)?=!@%&/!+<*!A.++*%D!<&4*2*%!(+!$'=&!%*/&2*=!2(+$/()=!$)?!+$=+*S!=&!+&&!

/.><!4$=<()F! (=!.)?*=(%$A'*J!5&!&A+$()! +<*!A.++*%! +<*!>%*$/-!/$==! (=!A&('*?! ()!$! >&&6()F!7&+J!

U.*!+<*!'&4*%!A&('()F!7&()+!&@!4$+*%!>&/7$%*?!+&!+<*!A.++*%D!+<*!4$+*%!4(''!*2$7&%$+*!'*$2()F!+<*!

A.++*%!A*<()?J!E&/*)!%*/&2*!7&+!@%&/!+<*!@(%*!$)?!4$(+!$!@*4!/().+*=!@&%!+<*!&('!+&!>&&'!?&4)!

$)?!?*>$)+!+&!%*/&2*!$)-!%*/$()()F!(/7.%(+(*=D!'*$2()F!$!>'*$%!-*''&4!&('J!M@+*%!+<(=!+<*!&('!(=!'*@+!

+&!>&&'!?&4)D!(+!4(''!+.%)!()+&!$!=&'(?!4<(+*!A.++*%J!5<*!'$A&.%!$)?!%*=&.%>*!>&=+=!@&%!*$><!&@!+<*!

?*=>%(A*?!=+*7=!$%*!!=<&4)!()!+$A'*!8J8J!!

!

!

5$A'*!8J8!L!5$A'*!8JfZ!K><*/$+(>!&2*%2(*4!&@!7%&>*==()F!=+*7=!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!

!

K+*7=! PA1*>+(2*! j.$)+(+-!

.=*?!

j.$)+(+-!

&A+$()*?!

5(/*f! G=*?!

+&&'=!

I*=&.%>*=!

.=*?!!

I*=&.%>*!

>&=+=8!

j.$'(+-!

T%*$6()F! I*?.>*!

=(l*! &@!

6*%)*'=!

@&%!

.)(@&%/!

%&$=+()F!

:! 6F! ! &@!

6*%)*'=!

:!6F!!

R*%)*'!

7(*>*=!

z! <! O!

f<!

,&%+$%!

a!7*=+'*!

L! L!! +<*!@()*%!+<*!

7(*>*=D! +<*!

/&%*!

.)(@&%/! +<*!

%&$=+()FJ!

I&$=+()F! ,$6*!

F%()?()F!

*$=(*%!

:!6F!!

R*%)*'!

7(*>*=!

:!6F!

I&$=+*?!

7(*>*=!

f!x!!

!

T&('!7&+! ;(%*4&&?! L! _%&'&)F*?!

%&$=+()F! w!

A'$>6! =<*$!

A.++*%!

_&.)?()F! I*?.>*!

=(l*! &@!

A%&6*)!

%&$=+*?!

6*%)*'=! +&!

/$6*!

F%()?()F!

:6F!

I&$=+*?!

7(*>*=!

:6F!

7$=+*!

4(+<!

7(*>*=!

z!<!

!!

,&%+$%!

a!7*=+'*!

L! L! L!

25

*$=(*%!

N%()?()F! ! :!6F!

_$=+*!

4(+<!

7(*>*=!

:6F!

7$=+*!

f{!<! L!!

8<!

N%()?()F!

=+&)*!!!

a! A&('!

7&+!

;(%*4&&?!! L! 5<*! @()*%!

+<*! F%()?()F!

(=! +<*! /&%*!

+<*! =<*$!

A.++*%!

*0+%$>+!

A*$+()F! C0+%$>+!

=<*$!

A.++*%!

:6F!

7$=+*!

h!+&!c!6F!

#%*$/-!

/(0+.%*!

!

f<! O!

f{!<!

,*+$'!

A$=()!

3.6*4$%/!

4$+*%! v!

f93!

L! L!

T&('()F! `$7&%(l*!

'*@+!4$+*%!

h!+&!c!6F!

#%*$/-!

/(0+.%*!

g!6F!

A.++*%!

f<! T&('!7&+! ;(%*4&&?! L! !

f!C0>'.?()F!+<*!+(/*!)*>*==$%-!+&!>&''*>+!4$+*%!$)?!@(%*4&&?!+&!+<*!<&.=*!

8!,&=+'-D!4&/*)!F&!+&!>&''*>+!4$+*%!\A&%*!$'']!$)?!@(%*4&&?!\@$%/'$)?]!

!

!

j.$)+(+-!&A+$()*?!!

5<*! Y.$)+(+-! &A+$()*?! @%&/! :! 6F! &@! ?%(*?! 6*%)*'=! (=! $A&.+! g! 6F! &@! A.++*%D! =&! >&)2*%=(&)! @%&/!

6*%)*'! 4*(F<+! +&! A.++*%! 4*(F<+! (=! ?&)*! 4(+<! fngJ! 5<*! Y.$)+(+-! &A+$()*?! ?*7*)?=! &)! +<*!

.)(@&%/(+-! $)?! +*/7*%$+.%*! &@! %&$=+()FD! &)! +<*! @()*)*==! &@! F%()?()F! $)?! +<*! %(7*)*==! +<*! ).+=!

.=*?J!5<*!/&%*!&7+(/$'!+<*!%&$=+()FD!+<*!@()*%!+<*!F%()?()F!$)?!/&%*!&7+(/$'!+<*!%(7*)*==!&@!+<*!

).+=!.=*?!+<*!/&%*!A.++*%!+<$+!>$)!A*!&A+$()*?J!!

V)!+<*!*07*%(/*)+=!&)!*0+%$>+(&)!%$+*=!>&)?.>+*?!A-!^|!*+!$'J!\899d]!$)&+<*%!*0+%$>+(&)!/*+<&?!

4$=!.=*?Z!*0+%$>+(&)!4(+<!$!7%*==()F!/$><()*J!V)!+<*=*!*07*%(/*)+=!+<*!@()*)*==!&@!F%()?()F!4$=!

$'=&!@&.)?!+&!A*!&@!/$()!(/7&%+$)>*J!

!

!

T&0!8Jf!L!3&>$'!=&$7!/$6()F!

!

B&/*!/$?*! =&$7! ()!N<$)$! (=! .=.$''-!/$?*! @%&/!7$'/!&('D! A.+! =&/*!4&/*)!$'=&!/$6*! =&$7!

@%&/! =<*$! A.++*%J! G=.$''-! +<(=! (=! .=*?! @&%! <&/*L>&)=./7+(&)! $)?! ()! =&/*! >$=*=! +<*! =&$7! (=!

/$?*!()!'$%F*!Y.$)+(+(*=!@&%!+<*!7.%7&=*!&@!=*''()F!$)?!=&!F*)*%$+*=!>$=<!()>&/*J!!K<*$!=&$7!(=!

A$=*?!&)!$!A'*)?!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!$'6$'()*!\7&+$=<]J!

PA+$()()F!$'6$'()*!!

M'6$'()*!(=!&A+$()*?!A-!A&('()F!$)?!@('+*%()F!+<*!$=<!&A+$()*?!@%&/!A.%)+!'*$2*=!&@!>*%+$()!+%**=J!

M''! +%**=! >&)+$()()F!$'6$'()*!>$)!A*!.=*?J! V)! +<*! =+.?-!$%*$=! +%**=! +<*! @&''&4()F! +%**=D!$/&)F!

&+<*%=D!4*%*!.=*?!@&%!$'6$'()*!*0+%$>+(&)Z!!!

A%$)><*=!$)?!'*$2*=!&@!H(/!+%**!\Ml$?(%$><+$!V)?(>$]!

A%$)><*=D!'*$2*=!$)?!=<*''=!&@!+<*!@%.(+!&@!U$4$?$4$!+%**!\_$%6($!T(F'&A&=$]!

,(''*+!=+*/!\$@+*%!<$%2*=+()F]!

,(=+'*+&*!\7$%$=(+*!&@!+<*!=<*$!+%**]! ! !

!

26

,$6()F!+<*!=&$7!

K<*$!=&$7!>&)+$()=!&)'-!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!$'6$'()*!4(+<!$!%$+(&!&@!>'&=*!+&!fZfJ!5<*!%(F<+)*==!&@!

+<*! =&$7! /(0+.%*! (=! ?*+*%/()*?! A-! +<*! /$6*%! A-! (+=! +$=+*J! ,$6()F! =&$7! (=! $! +%(>6-! 7%&>*==!

A*>$.=*!(@!+<*!()F%*?(*)+=!$%*!)&+!$??*?!()!F&&?!7%&7&%+(&)=!+<*!/(0+.%*!4(''!)&+!+.%)!+&!=&$7J!

!!

!

!

;>;>;!! "7%44!12%4$!%'(07%($)!/+02$11,&5!

V)!+<*!+&4)!&@!X(%$7$!()!+<*!G77*%!E*=+!I*F(&)D!+<*!'$A&.%D!%*=&.%>*!$)?!/$()+*)$)>*!>&=+=!4*%*!

/*$=.%*?!@&%!+4&!?(@@*%*)+!=/$''!=>$'*!=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!@$>+&%(*=J!5<*!%*=.'+=!4*%*!.=*?!+&!

>&/7$%*!+<*!>&=+LA*)*@(+=!&@!+<*!=/$''!=>$'*!7%&>*==()F!4(+<!+<$+!&@!+<*!/$).$'!7%&>*==()FJ!!

5<*! *07*%(/*)+! =*+! .7Z! V)! A&+<! @$>+&%(*=! =<*$! A.++*%!4$=! *0+%$>+*?! @%&/! $A&.+! dh! 6F! &@! =<*$!

).+=J!5<*!4*(F<+!&@!).+=!7%&>*==*?!$)?!+<*!4*(F<+!&@!+<*!*0+%$>+*?!A.++*%!(=!>&/7$%*?!@&%!A&+<!

@$>+&%(*=J! ! 5<*! &.+>&/*! &@! +<*! *0+%$>+(&)! %$+*! ()! A&+<! @$>+&%(*=! +.%)*?! &.+! +&! A*! +<*! =$/*D!

)$/*'-Z!!9Di!6F!&@!A.++*%!4$=!*0+%$>+*?!@%&/!f!6F!&@!=<*$!).+=J!!

5<*!4&/*)!F%&.7=!=+$+*?!+<$+!$!%.))()F!=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!@$>+&%-!>$)!7%&>*==!899!L!8h9!6F!

&@!).+=!$!?$-!4<(><!>$)!%*=.'+!()!Q9L!f99!6F!n?$-!&@!A.++*%!*0+%$>+*?J!5<*!'(/(+()F!@$>+&%!@&%!+<*!

7%&>*==()F!>$7$>(+-!4$=!+<*!%&$=+()F!/$><()*D!4<(><!>$)!7%&>*==!Qh!6F!()!i!<&.%=J!5<*!@$>+&%(*=!

&@!+<*!/$()!/$()+*)$)>*!>&=+!

V)! +$A'*! 8Jg! +<*! %*=&.%>*! >&=+=! $)?! '$A&.%! >&=+=! $%*! 4%(++*)! ?&4)J! 5<(=! ()>'.?*=! $''! >&=+! @&%!

%.))()F!+<*!/$><()*=Z!?(*=*'D!*'*>+%(>(+-D!@(%*4&&?D!$)?!4$+*%J!,$()+*)$)>*!>&=+=!$%*!*=+(/$+*?J!

3$A&.%!>&=+=!$%*!>$'>.'$+*?!&)!+<*!A$=*=!&@!$!4$F*!&@!9DcQGKmn?$-J!!

!

5$A'*!8Jg!L!C)*%F-!>&=+=!()!X(%$7$!L!X.'-!899Q!

! _%(>*!uf!

U(*=*'! 9Dcg!GKmn'!

C)F()*!&('! fD8d!GKmn'!!\E$]!!

fDQ!GKmn'!\X(%$7$]!

;(%*4&&?! 9DcQ!GKmn!<*$?'&$?!

C'*>+%(>(+-! 9Jf9!GKmnRE<!

uf>&)2*%=(&)!%$+*!N<$)$!>*?(=!+&!GKm!.=*?!Z!fN#!o!9JcQ!GKm!

u8!H&+*!+<$+!+<*=*!$%*!7%(>*=!?.%()F!7*$6!4&%'?!&('!7%(>*=!A*+4**)!$7%('L!$.F.=+!899QJ!!

!

!

V)! +<*! @&''&4()F! +$A'*!8Ji! +<*! %*=.'+=!&@! +<*!>&=+LA*)*@(+! $==*==/*)+!&@! +<*! +4&!=<*$!*0+%$>+(&)!

@$>+&%(*=! (=!?*7(>+*?J!M'=&!>&=+LA*)*@(+! @&%!/$).$'!*0+%$>+(&)! (=! ()>'.?*?J!;&%!/$).$'!*0+%$>+(&)!

+4&!?(@@*%*)+!$==*==/*)+!/*+<&?=!4*%*!.=*?J!,$).$'!O%.%$'D!$==./*=!+<$+!+<*%*!(=!)&!&+<*%!1&A!

$2$('$A'*!$)?!+<$+!+<*%*!+<$+! @(%*4&&?!$)?!4$+*%!<$2*!)&!*>&)&/(>$'!2$'.*D!$'+<&.F<!+<(=!)**?!

)&+!A*!)*>*==$%('-!+<*!>$=*!@&%!$''!%.%$'!$%*$=J!5<*)!+<*!/$).$'!)&)L%.%$'!*0+%$>+(&)D!$==./*=!+<$+!

'$A&.%!+(/*!7.+!()+&!*0+%$>+(&)!>&.'?!<$2*!A**)!=7*)+!*'=*4<*%*!$)?!@&%!*$><!?$-!&@!4&%6!f!N#!

>&.'?!<$2*!A**)!*$%)*?D!(+!$'=&!$==./*=!+<*!%*=&.%>*=\!@(%*4&&?D!4$+*%]!>&.'?!<$2*!A**)!=&'?D!(@!

(+!<$?!)&+!A**)!.=*?!@&%!+<*!=<*$!*0+%$>+(&)!7%&>*==J!!!

!

27

!

5$A'*!8Ji!L!#&=+LA*)*@(+!$)$'-=(=!&@!+4&!=<*$!*0+%$>+(&)!@$>+&%(*=!

uh! _%&>*==()F!!

>&=+=! ()!

GKmn! 6F!

KTC!uf!

_%(>*u8! &@!

=<*$!

6*%)*'=! ()!

GKm! n! 6F!

KTC!

5P5M3!

*0+%$>+(&)!

>&=+=!

GKmn6F!

KT!

M2*%$F*!

7%(>*ug!&@!

KT! ()!

GKmn6F!!

\A.'6]!!!

M2*%$F*!

7%(>*!ui!&@!

=<*$!

A.++*%! ()!

GKmn6F!

\=/$''L

Y.$)+J]!

M2*%$F*!

7%&@(+uh!!

\GKm]! (@! =&'?!

()!A.'6!

M2*%$F*!

7%&@(+uh! (@!

=&'?! =/$''!

Y.$)+(+(*=!

;$>+&%-!!

^(7$$'$!

9Dh8! 9DcQ! fD89! 9Dd8! fDQd! L!9DiQ!

!

}!9Dc8!

;$>+&%-!!

E$-(%(!

9DiQ! 9DcQ! fDfc! 9Dd8! fDQd! L!9Dii! }!9Ddf!

,$).$'D!!

%.%$'!

L! 9Dif! 9Dif! 9Dd8! fDQd! }!9Dgf! }!fDic!

,$).$'D!!

)&)L

%.%$'!

9Did! 9Dif! 9DQQ! 9Dd8! fDQd! L!9Dfc! }!!9D::!

uf!KTo=<*$!A.++*%S!KTC!o!=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+*?!

u8! A$=*?! &)! 7%(>*=! &@! =<*$! 6*%)*'=D! *)?! X.'-! &@! 899Q! \! ()! X(%$7$Z! 9D88! GKm! n6FD! ()! R7$%*Z! 9Dfi!

GKmn6F]!

ug!A$=*?!&)!7%(>*!&@@*%*?!A-!/(??'*/$)!()!E$!\f!+&!fDf!N#n6F!&@!=<*$!AJ!o!9DcQ!O!9Ddh!GKmn6F]!

ui?*7*)?=! &)! 4*(F<+! &@! A$''=! =&'?J! ;(0*?! 7%(>*! 7*%! A$''! \9D9giGKmnA$'']D! A.+! 4*(F<+! 2$%(*=!

A*+4**)!fg!F!$)?!g9!F!()!%*=*$%><!$%*$J!!

uh!/().=\L]!()?(>$+*=!'&==J!!

!

V@! '$A&.%! >&=+=! $%*! )&+! ()>'.?*?D! 4<(><! >$)! A*! %*'*2$)+! @&%! %.%$'! 7'$>*=! 4<*%*! +<*%*! (=! )&!

*/7'&-/*)+D! +<$)! /$).$'! *0+%$>+(&)! (=! 7%&@(+$A'*! A&+<! (@! =&'?! ()! A.'6! Y.$)+(+(*=! $)?! ()! =/$''!

Y.$)+(+(*=J!K*/(L$.+&/$+*?!7%&>*==()F!(=!&)'-!7%&@(+$A'*!(@!=&'?!()!=/$''!Y.$)+(+(*=J!T.+!+<(=!4&.'?!

'*$?! +&! $! &2*%! @'&&?()F! &@! +<*! '&>$'!/$%6*+! $)?!4(''! ?(=+.%A! +<*! '&>$'!/$%6*+D! '*$?()F! +&! '&4*%!

7%(>*=J!!

uh! 5<*! 7%(>*! &@! =<*$! 6*%)*'=! ()! GKm! )**?*?! @&%! *0+%$>+(&)! &@! f! 6F! =<*$! A.++*%! \?(@@*%*)+! @&%!

/$).$'!$)?!=*/(L$.+&/$+*?]D!(=!()@'.*)>*?!A-!+<*!7%(>*!&@!=<*$!6*%)*'=!&)!+<*!&)*!<$)?D!$)?!+<*!

A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! %$+*! &)! +<*! &+<*%! <$)?J! 5<*! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! %$+*! @&%! =*/(L$.+&/$+*?!

7%&>*==()F!(=!<(F<*%D!A.+!+<*!7%(>*=!@&%!+<*!6*%)*'=!4*%*!$'=&!<(F<*%!()!+<*!+&4)!4<*%*!+<(=!=*/(L

$.+&/$+*?!7%&>*==()F! +$6*=!7'$>*J! ;&%! +<*!*0+%$>+(&)!&@!f6F!&@! =<*$!A.++*%!/$).$''-!gD9g6F!&@!

6*%)*'=!$%*!%*Y.(%*?D!$)?!@&%!=*/(L$.+&/$+*?!*0+%$>+(&)!8Dh6F!&@!6*%)*'=!$%*!%*Y.(%*?!+&!@&%!+<*!

*0+%$>+(&)!&@!f!6F!&@!=<*$!A.++*%J!

!

!

28

#&)>'.=(&)=!a!?(=>.==(&)!_MI5!V!

!

V)! +<(=! ><$7+*%! +<*! >&)>'.=(&)=! &)! +<*! &77&%+.)(+(*=! $)?! >&)=+%$()+=! @&%! '&>$'! >&//.)(+(*=! ()!

N<$)$!+&!*$%)!/&%*!@%&/!7%&?.>+(&)D!7%&>*==()F!$)?!+%$?*!$%*!F(2*)J!!

!

_%&?.>+(&)!

5<*%*!(=!$!>&)=+%$()+!()!+<*!7%&?.>+(&)!$=!(+!(=!<$%?!+&!()@'.*)>*!+<*!+&+$'!=<*$!).+!-(*'?J!_'$)+()F!

/&%*!+%**=!$=!(+!4(''!+$6*!$+!'*$=+!fh!-*$%=!A*@&%*!+<*%*!$%*!%*+.%)=!&@!()2*=+/*)+J!T*=(?*=!+<(=!+<*!

-(*'?! (=! ?*7*)?*)+! &)!/$)-! *)2(%&)/*)+$'! @$>+&%=D!4<('*! +<*%*! (=! '(++'*! <./$)! ()+*%2*)+(&)! &)!

+<*=*!@$>+&%=! \'$>6!&@! (%%(F$+(&)D! ()@%$=+%.>+.%*!$)?! '$>6!&@!/*$)=!+&! @(F<+!7'$F.*=]J!;*%+('(l*%!.=*!

/(F<+!()>%*$=*!-(*'?!$'+<&.F<!+<(=!%*Y.(%*=!@.%+<*%!=+.?-J!5<*)!+<*%*!$%*!A.=<!@(%*=D!A&+<!)$+.%$'!

$)?!<./$)! =*+! @(%*=D! +<$+!?*>%*$=*!-(*'?!$)?! %*F*)*%$+(&)J!M)&+<*%!$=7*>+! >&)>*%)()F!-(*'?!&)!

+<*! '&)F! +*%/! (=! %*F*)*%$+(&)J! I*F*)*%$+(&)! ?&*=! &>>.%D! A.+! (+! (=! .)>'*$%! 4<*+<*%! +<*!

%*F*)*%$+(&)!%$+*!>$)!7$=*!.7!4(+<!+<*!$F()FD!?-()F!&@!+<*!$'%*$?-!*0(=+()F!+%**=J!5<*!@$>+&%=!+<$+!

$%*! >&)=(?*%*?!/&=+! +<%*$+*)()F! @&%! %*F*)*%$+(&)! ()! +<*! =+.?-!$%*! (=! +<*! >.++()F!?&4)!&@! =<*$!

+%**=!$)?!+<*!'$>6!&@!=.@@(>(*)+!@$''&4()F!+&!*)$A'*!%*F*)*%$+(&)J!B&4*2*%D!()>%*$=*?!7%&?.>+(&)!

?&*=! )&+! )*>*==$%('-! '*$?! +&! ()>%*$=*?! ()>&/*! (@! (+! /$6*=! +<*! 7%(>*=! F&! ?&4)J! 5<*! 7(>6()F! &@!

.)%(7*!).+=!?.*!+&!=<$6()F!&@!+%**=D!>$)!A*!*07'$()*?!A-!+<*!>&/7*+(+(&)!A*+4**)!7(>6*%=J!!

!

P77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=!&)!7%&>*==()F!

V)! +<(=! %*=*$%><! /$).$'! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! (=! >&/7$%*?! 4(+<D! =*/(L$.+&/$+*?! A.++*%!

*0+%$>+(&)J!C@@(>(*)>-!&@!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!4$=!<(F<*%!4(+<!=*/(L$.+&/$+*?!*0+%$>+(&)D!$=!f!6F!&@!

=<*$! A.++*%!4$=! &A+$()*?! @%&/!g! 6F! &@! =<*$! 6*%)*'=! ?.%()F!/$).$'! *0+%$>+(&)D!4<('*! +<*! =$/*!

$/&.)+!4$=!*0+%$>+*?!@%&/!8Jh6F!&@!=<*$!6*%)*'=!?.%()F!+<*!=*/(L$.+&/$+*?!7%&>*==J!B&4*2*%D!

7%&?.>+(&)!>&=+!$%*!<(F<*%!@&%!=*/(L$.+&/$+*?!7%&>*==()FJ!!!

!

#&)=+%$()+=!()!=*/(L$.+&/$+*?!7%&>*==()F!$%*!+<*!>&/A()$+(&)!&@!<(F<!=<*$!6*%)*'!7%(>*=!$)?!+<*!

<(F<! @.*'!$)?!/$()+*)$)>*!>&=+!$>>&%?()F!+&!7%(>*=! ()!899QD!4<(><!/$6*! =<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!

.)7%&@(+$A'*J! !M??(+(&)$''-D! '$>6!&@!=7$%*L7$%+=!+<$+!$%*!)&+!*$=('-!&A+$()$A'*!$)?!'$>6!&@!@()$)>*!

>$.=*!%*7$%$+(&)=!+&!F*+!7&=+7&)*?J!!,$).$'!7%&>*==()F!%*'(*=!&)!'&>$'!$2$('$A'-!%*=&.%>*=!$)?!(=!

+<*%*@&%*! $! =.=+$()$A'*! A.=()*==J! V+! ()2&'2*=! '&4*%! 7%&?.>+(&)! >&=+=! $)?! +<*%*@&%*! (=! /&%*!

7%&@(+$A'*!*2*)!(@!'&)F*%!'$A&.%!<&.%=!(=!+$6*)!()+&!$>>&.)+J!5<*%*@&%*!/$).$'!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!(=!

$!F&&?!&77&%+.)(+-!@&%!()>&/*!F*)*%$+(&)D!*=7*>($''-!()!7'$>*=!4<*%*!*/7'&-/*)+!(=!=>$%>*J!H&+*!

+<$+! +<*! 7%&@(+$A('(+-! (=! <(F<'-! ?*7*)?*)+! &)! @.*'! 7%(>*D! =<*$! 6*%)*'! $)?! =<*$! A.++*%! 7%(>*=J!

T*>$.=*! +<*! 7%(>*=! &@! +<*=*! F&&?=! $%*! =.A1*>+! +&! @%*Y.*)+! ><$)F*=D! +<(=! 4(''! $@@*>+! &)! +<*!

7%&@(+$A('(+-!&2*%!+(/*J!

!

P)*! &@! +<*! 7&==(A'*! ()>&/*! F*)*%$+()F! &77&%+.)(+(*=! (=! +&! ()2*=+! ()! A.-()F! =<*$! 6*%)*'=! ()! +<*!

<$%2*=+! =*$=&)!$)?!=*''! +<*/! ()! +<*!?%-! =*$=&)D! $=!7%(>*=!/(F<+! %(=*!.7! +&! +<%**@&'?! ()! +<*!?%-!

=*$=&)!$=!>&/7$%*?!+&!+<*!<$%2*=+!=*$=&)!\!<$%2*=+!899dZ!9Dff!GKmn6FD!!?%-!899dZ!9DgcZ!GKmn6F]J!

B&4*2*%D!+<(=!(=!&)'-!$!%*$'(=+(>!&77&%+.)(+-!@&%!+<&=*!4<&!$%*!)&+!()!(//*?($+*!)**?!&@!/&)*-!()!

+<*!'*$)!=*$=&)!$)?!>$)!()2*=+J!5<*!7&&%*=+!4(''!)**?!+&!=*''!$''!+<*!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!(//*?($+*'-!+&!

29

A.-! @&&?! ()! +<*! '*$)! =*$=&)D! *2*)! +<&.F<! +<(=! (=! +<*! =*$=&)!4<*)! @&&?! (=!/&=+! *07*)=(2*! $)?!

7%(>*=!+<*-!F*+!@&%!+<*(%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!(=!'&4*=+J!!

V@!+&&!/$)-!).+=!$%*!=+&%*?!()!+<*!?%-!=*$=&)!+<$)!+<*!7%(>*=!/(F<+!)&+!F&!.7!$+!$''!$)?!()2*=+&%=!

/$-!@()?!+<*/=*'2*=!=+.>6!4(+<!+<*(%!).+=!.)=&'?D!$=!4$=!4<$+!<$77*)*?!()!+<*!?%-!$+!+<*!*)?!&@!

899Q!!

!

!

!

H&+*Z!4<*)!@()$'(l()F!+<*!%*7&%+D!)*4=!>$/*!@%&/!#IV!()!N<$)$D!+<$+!+<*!7%&?.>+(&)!&@!=<*$!).+=!

@%&/! =<*$! +%**=! $@+*%! 7'$)+()F! >$)!A*! %*?.>*?! @%&/!fh! +&!d! -*$%=! \N<$)$)*4=+&?$-]J! 5<(=! <$=!

<&4*2*%!)&+!A**)!&@@(>($''-!>&)@(%/*?!-*+J!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

30

F%+(!AA!Y!"#$%!(+%)$+1Z!0&!(#$!402%4!7%+9$(!%&)!,&!3,&,1#$)!/+0)'2(1!,&!(#$!10'(#!03!-#%&%!%&)!30+!$O/0+(!!

5<(=!=*>&)?!$)?!'$=+!7$%+!&@!+<*!%*7&%+!>&)+$()=!+<*!'$=+!@&.%!><$7+*%=!&)!=<*$!+%$?*D!.%A$)!=<*$!

A.++*%!>&)=./7+(&)!@&''&4*?!.7!A-!$!>$=*!=+.?-J!!

!

!

#<$7+*%!g! T.-*%=!$)?!=*''*%=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$+!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+!

!

5<*!@&>.=!()!+<(=!><$7+*%!(=!&)!4<*+<*%!+<*!+%$?*%=!$%*!$A'*!+&!=$+(=@-!+<*!?*/$)?!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!

()!Y.$)+(+(*=!$)?! ()!Y.$'(+-!=*+!A-!+<*!)*0+!A.-*%J!5<(=!%*=*$%><!Y.*=+(&)! (=!*07'$()*?!4(+<!=.AL

Y.*=+(&)=!>&)>*%)()F!+<*!Y.$)+(+-D!Y.$'(+-!$)?!7%(>*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!+<$+!+<*!+%$?*%=!A.-!$)?!=*''J!

M++*)+(&)!(=!F(2*)!+&!+<*!+-7*!&@!=+&%$F*D!7$>6$F()F!$)?!+%$)=7&%+$+(&)!.=*?!&)!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+!

()! +<*!=<*$!A.++*%! +%$?*J!U(@@*%*)+!$>+&%=!$)?! +<*(%! ()+*%$>+(&)=!4(+<()! +<*! +%$?*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!

$%*! (''.=+%$+*?! ()! @(F.%*! gJfJ! 5<(=! ><$7+*%! 4(''! *'$A&%$+*! &)! +<*=*! $>+&%=! $)?! +<*! @'&4! &@! =<*$!

A.++*%!4(+<()!+<*!'&>$'!+%$?*D!4(+<!=7*>($'!@&>.=!&)!+<*!4<&'*=$'*%=!&)!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+J!5<*!/$()!

$++*)+(&)!&@!+<(=!@(*'?!%*=*$%><!(=!4(+<!+<*!4&/*)!4<&!+%$?*!()!A.'6=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%D!$=!+<*-!$%*!

=(+.$+*?!$+!A&++&/!7$%+!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!=.77'-!><$()J!5<*!<-7&+<*=(=!(=!+<$+!+<*=*!4&/*)!\$)?!

/*)]!+%$?()F!()!A.'6!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!&)!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+!<$2*!+<*!/&=+!?(@@(>.'+-!()!/**+()F!.7!+&!

+<*!=+$)?$%?=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!=*+!A-!+<*!A.-*%J!V+!/.=+!A*!=$(?!+<$+!+<(=!=+.?-!(=!?&)*!4(+<()!+<*!

>(+-!&@!5$/$'*D!()!N<$)$!()!+<*!-*$%!899QD!$)?!>$)!A*!>&)=(?*%*?!$!>$=*!=+.?-J!5<*!&A=*%2$+(&)=!

$)?! >&)>'.=(&)=! ()! +<(=! ><$7+*%! $%*! +-7(>$'! @&%! +<(=! >$=*! $)?! &)*!<$2*! +&!A*! >$%*@.'! ()!?%$4()F!

F*)*%$'!>&)>'.=(&)=J!!!

!

5<*!=.77'-!><$()!$)?!(+k=!$>+&%=!&)!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+!

!

5<*!=.77'-!><$()!&@!=<*$!).+=!$)?!A.++*%!(=!>&/7'*0!$=!+<*%*!$%*!/$)-!$>+&%=!()2&'2*?J!V)!@(F.%*!

gJf!$!=(/7'(@(*?!=.77'-!><$()!&@!=<*$!A.++*%! (=!F(2*)J!5<*!A.-*%=!()!+<(=!><$7+*%!$%*!+<*!$>+&%=!$+!

+<*! *)?! &@! *$><! $%%&4! ()! +<*! =.77'-! ><$()D! (J*J! +<*! A&0*=!4<*%*! +<*! @'&4! &@! A.++*%! $%%(2*=! $+J!

5<*=*!$%*!4<&'*=$'*%=!\8]D!%*+$('*%=!\g]!$)?!>&)=./*%=!\i]J!5<*!=*''*%=!&%!=.77'(*%=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!

$%*!+<*!7%&?.>*%=!\f]!&@!=<*$!A.++*%D!!+<*!4<&'*=$'*%=!\8]!$)?!+<*!%*+$('*%=!\g]!\@(F.%*!gJf]J!!

!

5<*!7%&?.>*%=!\f]D!4&/*)!4&%6()F!()?(2(?.$''-!&%!()!F%&.7=D!=*''!+&!4<&'*=$'*%=!\8]D!+&!%*+$('*%=!\g]!

$)?!+&!>&)=./*%=!\i]J!_%&?.>*%=!$)?!=<*$!A.++*%!7%&>*==&%=!>$)!A*!=**)!$=!%*+$('*%=!$=!+<*-!=*''!

@%&/! $! @(0*?! '&>$+(&)J! ;&%! *0$/7'*D! +<*! A.++*%! >$)! A*! =&'?! @%&/! +<*! A.('?()F! 4<*%*! A.++*%! (=!

7%&?.>*?D! @%&/! '&>$'!/$%6*+=!&%! @%&/! +<*!7%&?.>*%=k! <&/*=J!N*)*%$''-D! +<*!4&/*)!7%&?.>*%=!

6**7! =&/*! &@! +<*! A.++*%! @&%! +<*(%! &4)! <&.=*<&'?D!4<(><!/$6*=! +<*/! >&)=./*%=! $+! +<*! =$/*!

+(/*J!5<*%*!$%*!)&!=+$+(=+(>$'!%*>&%?=!&@!$/&.)+=!&@!A.++*%!+<$+!+<*!4&/*)!$%*!6**7()F!@&%!+<*(%!

&4)!.=*D! @&%! +<*-!)&%! $)-! =+$+(=+(>$'! A&$%?! 6**7=! $)-! %*>&%?=! &@! (+J! V+! >&.'?! $'=&!A*! +<$+! =&/*!

=(/7'-!?&!)&+!4(=<!+&!+*''!<&4!/.><!+<*-!.=*!$=!+<*-!$%*!)&+!$'4$-=!!=.77&=*?!+&!6**7!=&/*!&@!

+<*! A.++*%! $7$%+! \_*%=&)$'! >&//.)(>$+(&)! U%J! ^(?$)$D! +<*! 7%&?.>*%=D! +<*! +%$?()F!4&/*)D! $)?!

>&)=./*%=D!899Q]J!

!

31

=>! G$(%,4$+1! \=/$''!

$/&.)+=!&@!A.++*%]!

>]! E<&'*=$'*%=! \*07&%+Z! E*=+!

M@%(>$D!C.%&7*D!GJKJM]!

P4)!!

>&)=./7+(&)!

K>!D0&1'7$+1!

;>![#04$1%4$+1!\*'49!03!*'(($+]!! !

A]!E<&'*=$'*%=!\K&.+<!N<$)$]!

$]!E&/*)!a!/*)!+%$?*%=!\.%A$)]!

B>! F+0)'2$+1! &@! =<*$! A.++*%!\'&>$'!4&/*)]!

- V)?(2(?.$'!

- N%&.7=!

V)!)&%+<*%)!N<$)$D!%*+$('*%=!()!=<*$!A.++*%!\g]!$%*!4&/*)!=*''()F!=<*$!A.++*%!()!=/$''!$/&.)+=!\()!

Y.$)+(+(*=!&@! fhLi9! F%$/=]!&%! ()!A&4'=! \>$J! h6F]J!P+<*%! +<$)! +<*! 7%&?.>*%=! %*+$('*%=! $%*!A.-()F!

@%&/!7%&?.>*%=!&%!4<&'*=$'*%=!+&!=*''!+<*!A.++*%!()!=/$''*%!$/&.)+=!+&!()?(2(?.$'=D!<&.=*<&'?=!&%!

A.=()*==!4&/*)!4<&!>&&6!$)?!=*''!/*$'=!$)?!=)$>6=!\@(F.%*!gJfZ!\i]!>&)=./*%=]J!!

!

V)!N<$)$!?(@@*%*)+!4<&'*=$'*%=!<$2*!A**)!(?*)+(@(*?J!E<&'*=$'*%=!\8]!()!=<*$!A.++*%!$>>&.)+*?!()!

H&%+<!N<$)$!$%*Z!$]!/*)!$)?!4&/*)!4<&!$%*!+%$?()F!()!'$%F*!$/&.)+=!@%&/!$!@(0*?!'&>$+(&)!&)!

$)!.%A$)!/$%6*+D!A]!/*)!$)?!4&/*)!@%&/!+<*!=&.+<!&@!N<$)$!$)?!>]!/*)!$)?!4&/*)!+%$?()F!

$A%&$?! ()!A.'6!Y.$)+(+(*=J!5<*! +%$?*%=! @%&/!+<*!)&%+<*%)!.%A$)!/$%6*+=!=*''! +<*(%!A.++*%! +&! +<*!

&+<*%!4<&'*=$'*%=! @%&/! +<*! =&.+<! $)?! $=! $)!*07&%+!7%&?.>+J! 5%$?*%=! @%&/! =&.+<*%)!N<$)$! $%*!

=*''()F! +<*! A.++*%! +&! *07&%+*%=! $=!4*''J! 5<.=! *07&%+! +%$?*%=!A.-! +<*(%! =<*$!A.++*%!?(%*>+'-! @%&/!

7%&?.>*%=D!$)?!@%&/!+<*!.%A$)!$)?!=&.+<*%)!4<&'*=$'*%=J!5<*!'&>$'!+%$?*!()!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!/&=+'-!

?&)*!A-!4&/*)D!$)?!=&/*!/*)D!A.+!+<*%*!=**/=!+&!A*!$!+%*)?!&@!()>%*$=*?!()2&'2*/*)+!&@!/*)!

()!=<*$!A.++*%!A.=()*==!4<(><!$)?!/(F<+!A*!%*'$+*?!+&!+<*!'$%F*%!Y.$)+(+(*=!A.++*%!A*()F!*07&%+*?J!

H&! =+$+(=+(>=! 4*%*! @&.)?! @&%! +<(=! =+$+*/*)+! $)?! (=!/$?*! A-! &A=*%2$+(&)! \U%J! ^(?$)$D! _*%=&)$'!

#&//.)(>$+(&)D!899Q]!

!

;(F.%*!gJf!L!5<*!=<*$!A.++*%!=.77'-!><$()!

!

!

32

=>B>B! [07$&!1#0/9$$/$+1!0&!(#$!<*0%*0!7%+9$(!,&!H%7%4$!\%]!

M+!+<*!'&>$'!MA&$A&!/$%6*+! ()!5$/$'*!+<&=*!+%$?()F! ()!A.'6=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!<$2*!$!=+&%*!&)!+<*!

/$%6*+J!8c!=+&%*=D!&@!?(@@*%*)+!=(l*=D!4*%*!&A=*%2*?J!M%&.)?!:9!+&!:hr!!

&@!+<*!=+&%*=!4*%*!%.)!A-!4&/*)!$)?!f9!+&!hr!

A-!/*)J!V+!(=!>&//&)!+<$+!$!=<*$!A.++*%!=+&%*!(=!

=<$%*?!A-!$!)./A*%!&@!()?(2(?.$'=D!$)?!&@+*)!(+!

(=!+<*!&'?*=+!7*%=&)!4<&!(=!+<*!=+&%*!&4)*%!\=**!

A&0! gJf]J! ! T*=(?*=! =<*$! A.++*%D! +<*-! $'=&! =*''!

&+<*%! 7%&?.>+=! '(6*! =<*$! 6*%)*'=D! /$(l*! &%!

A*$)=J!!

5<*! =+&%*! 6**7*%=! +%$?()F! (=! =<*$! A.++*%! F&! +&!

+<*!=.%%&.)?()F!2(''$F*=!&)!+<*!/$%6*+!?$-=!O!()!

+<*!)&%+<!&@!N<$)$!*2*%-!c!?$-=!L!+&!A.-!A&4'=!

\>$J!h6F]!$)?!A(F!>$'$A$=<*=!\fcL8h6F]!@%&/!+<*!

2(''$F*! 4&/*)! 4<&! 7%&>*==! +<*! ).+=! ()+&!

T&0!gJf!!M!@$/('-!A.=()*==!!

^&.)F*%! @$/('-!/*/A*%=! >$)! A*! ()! ><$%F*! $=!

4*''! ()! +<*! =+&%$F*! %&&/=! &@! =<*$! A.++*%J!!

C=7*>($''-!4<*)!+<*%*!(=!*)&.F<!/&)*-!&%!+<*!

@$/('-! <$=! /&%*! =+&%*=J! 5<(=! 4$=! +<*! >$=*! &@!

V/$! ;$(l<$J! V/$! ;$(l<$! (=! +<*! ?$.F<+*%! &@! +<*!

'$?-! &4)()F! +<*! =+&%*J! T.+! ;$(l<$! (=! +<*! &)*!

%.))()F! +<*! A.=()*==! ()! =<*$! A.++*%J! B*%!

/&+<*%! >&/*=! &)>*! ()! $! 4<('*J! B*%! $.)+! (=!

<*'7()F! &.+! ()! +<*! =+&%*! $)?! +&! 6**7! K(=+*%!

;$(l<$!>&/7$)-J!M!@$/('-!A.=()*==J!

!

1 2

5

3

4 1. A calabash is rapped in paper, 2. The rapped calabashes go into the burlap sack, 3. Last calabash goes into the sack, 4. The sack is tight firmly by rope, 5. Sack with three calabashes of shea butter is ready to be sold and transported.

33

A.++*%J! 5<*! 4&/*)! 7%&>*==&%=! $'=&! >&/*! +&! +<*! >(+-! 4<*%*! +<*-! =*''! +<*! A.++*%! +&! +<*! =+&%*!

&4)*%=J!M!=+&%*!>$)!!;(F.%*!gJ8!L!5<%**!>$'$A$=<*=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$%*!7$>6*?!()!$!A.%'$7!=$>6!!

>&)+$()! ! $)! $2*%$F*! &@! g99! =$>6=!4(+<! +<*! =$>6=!4*(F<()F! $%&.)?! c9! +&! :96F! \=**! +$A'*! gJf! $+!

=*>+(&)!gJg]J!V)!@(F.%*!gJ8!(+!(=!(''.=+%$+*?!<&4!=.><!$!=$>6!(=!7$>6*?J!#$'$A$=<*=!4(+<!=<*$!A.++*%!

$%*!>&2*%*?!4(+<!7$7*%!@%&/!$!@&%/*%!>*/*)+!A$FJ!5<*!=$>6!(=!=*$'*?!4(+<!%&7*J!

!

=>B>;! H+%)$+1!3+07!(#$!"0'(#!03!-#%&%!\*]!

M!@*4!?*>$?*=!$F&D!/.><!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!7%&>*==*?!'&>$''-!()!+<*!+<%**!)&%+<*%)!%*F(&)=!4$=!

=&'?! +&! +<*! K&.+<! &@! N<$)$J! 5<*! +%$?*%=! $)?! +<*(%! $F*)+=! ()! A.++*%! 4*%*! /$()'-! 4&/*)!4<&!

+%$2*''*?!.7!)&%+<!+&!A.-!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J! V)!+<*!=&.+<!+<*!A.++*%!4$=!=&'?!&)!+<*!/$%6*+=!$)?!

.=*?!A-!<&.=*<&'?=J!5<*%*!4$=!%*'$+(2*'-!$!'(++'*!*07&%+!$+!+<$+!+(/*!\3&2*++D!899h$]J!E&/*)!$)?!

/*)! @%&/!+<*!=&.+<!=+(''! >&/*!+&!7%&>*==&%=! ()! +<*!2(''$F*=!$)?!+&! +<*!=<&76**7*%=!&)!+<*!>(+-!

/$%6*+!+&!A.-!A.++*%J!,$%6*+!4&/*)D!/*?(>()*!/*)!$)?!'&>$'!%*@()*%(*=!A.-!=*2*%$'!=$>6=D!4(+<!

$)! $2*%$F*! $/&.)+! &@! f9! =$>6=! \=**! @(F.%*! gJgS! 7*%=&)$'! >&//.)(>$+(&)! 4(+<! +<*! .%A$)! =<*$!

+%$?*%=D!899Q]J!_%&A$A'-!+<*-!A.-!@&%!*07&%+!$=!4*''!+&!=*''!$+!+<*!<$%A&.%!&@!5*/$!&%!$>%&==!+<*!

>&.)+%-!A&$%?*%=!+&!#~+*!?kV2&(%!$)?!T*)()J!

!

!

!

;(F.%*!gJg!L!;*4!=$>6=!\<*%*!g]!A&.F<+!A-!

$!4&/$)!%*$?-!@&%!+<*!'&%%-!+%$)=7&%+!

!

=>B>=! ^,))4$7$&!%&)!807$&Z!%5$&(1!%&)!207/%&,$1!\2Z!)]!

P+<*%!4<&'*=$'*%=!$%*!/(??'*/*)!$)?!4&/*)! @&%! >&/7$)(*=D!$F*)+=! @&%! +<&=*!/(??'*/*)!$)?!

4&/*)D! $)?! $F*)+=! @&%! >&/7$)(*=J! 5<*-! >&''*>+! '$%F*%! Y.$)+(+(*=! &@! A.++*%! +<$)! .%A$)!

=<&76**7*%=!A-!F&()F!+&!?(@@*%*)+!'&>$+(&)=!+&!A.-J!5<*-!?&!A.=()*==!?(%*>+'-!4(+<!4&/*)!F%&.7=!

&%!7%&>*==()F!>*)+%*=!&%!4(+<!7%&>*==&%=n()?(2(?.$'!7%&>*==&%=! ()!$!2(''$F*D!+<*-!F&!+&!+<*!.%A$)!

=+&%*=J!5<*=*!$>+&%=!=*''!+<*!A.++*%!@&%!�%*F(&)$'k!*07&%+D!+%$?*!4(+<()!E*=+LM@%(>$D!$)?!*07&%+!+&!

&+<*%!M@%(>$)!>&.)+%(*=!$)?!+&!C.%&7*D!M=($!$)?!+<*!GJKJ!

!

,&=+!&@! +<*! '$%F*!A.-*%=!$%*! +%$?()F! ()! +<*!).+=D! %$+<*%! +<$)!+<*!A.++*%J!5&!F(2*!$)! (?*$!&@! +<*!

$/&.)+=!&@!).+=!A*()F!+%$?*?!A-!/(??'*/*)D!<*%*!$)!*0$/7'*!&@!$!=.A=+$)+($'!+%$?*%Z!M>>&%?()F!

34

+&!/%J!M'<$$F(!T$$A$D! +<*!><$(%/$)!&@!+<*!H&%+<*%)!I*F(&)!&@!+<*!H$+(&)$'!M==&>($+(&)!&@!K<*$!

;$%/*%=D!_%&>*==&%=!$)?!T.-*%=!$)?!<*!(=!+%$?*%!()!=<*$!).+=D!<*!(=!$A'*!+&!>&''*>+!$)!$/&.)+!&@!

i9J999! +&! h9J999! +&))*=! &@! ).+=! @%&/! +<*! ?(@@*%*)+! 7$%+(*=! ()! $! -*$%! 4<*)! +<*! =<*$! ).+=! $%*!

$A.)?$)+!()!+<*!@%.(+()F!=*$=&)J!!

!

!!! !!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!! !

!

K&/*!&@!+<*!A(F!>&/7$)(*=!4&%'?4(?*!$)?!)$+(&)$''-!$%*!M$%<.=R$%'=<$/)!\MMR!K4*?*)]D!3&?*%=!

#%&6'$$)! \5<*!H*+<*%'$)?=]D!MU,!a!E('/$%! \M=($]D! g;! \X$7$)]D!N<$)$!H.+=D!P'$/!N<$)$! 3+?J!8!

$)?!/$)-!/&%*J!

gJ8! j.$)+(+-!$)?!_%(>*=!

!

E(+<()!+<*!%*+$('()F!=/$''!$/&.)+=!&@!A.++*%!$%*!+%$?*?J!V)!!

4<&'*=$'()F! '$%F*! $/&.)+=! &@! =<*$!A.++*%! $%*! =&'?J! V)!

+$A'*!gJf!+<*!Y.$)+(+(*=!$)?!7%(>*=!@&%!4<(><!+<*!A.++*%!

(=!=&'?!$%*!(''.=+%$+*?J!

P)! +<*! '&>$'! /$%6*+=! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%! (=! /*$=.%*?! ()!

=/$''!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

=(l*=D! ()! A&4'=D! >$'$A$=<*=! $)?! ()! =$>6=J! 5<*! =/$''!

$/&.)+=!$%*!=/$''!%&.)?!A&4'=!$A'*!+&!@(+! ()!+<*!7$'/!

&@!-&.%!<$)?!\=**!@(F.%*!gJi]J!5<*-!4*(F<!$%&.)?!fh!+&!

i9! F%$/=J! M! A&4'! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! 4*(F<=! i! +&! d! 6F!

\@(F.%*!gJh]!$)?!$!>$'$A$=<!4(+<!=<*$!A.++*%!\@(F.%*!gJc]!

>$)! 4*(F<! A*+4**)! fc! $)?! 8Q! 6FJ! 5<*! $/&.)+! &@!

A.++*%! +<$+! @(+=! ()+&! +<%**! >$'$A$=<*=! (=! >'&=*! +&! +<*!

$/&.)+!+<$+!F&*=!()+&!&)*!=$>6D!4<(><!4$-=!$%&.)?!Q9!

+&!:9!6F!\=**!@(F.%*!gJd!$)?!@(F.%*!gJ8]J!5<*!7%(>*!@&%!$!

A&4'! $+! +<*! +(/*! &@! ?$+$! >&''*>+(&)! \'&4L7%(>*! =*$=&)!

899Q]D! 4<*)! A&.F<+! ?(%*>+'-! @%&/! 7%&>*==&%=D! 4$=! ()!

+<*! %$)F*! &@! g! +&! h! N<$)$! >*?(*=! \fJQh! +&! gJf9! *.%&]!

$)?!89!+&!g9!N<$)$!>*?(*=!\ffJ8h!+&!fhJc9!*.%&]!@&%!$!

>$'$A$=<J!G%A$)!+%$?*%=D!<&4*2*%D!=&'?!$!A&4'!@&%!h!&%!

c!N<#! \gJf9!+&!gJdh!*.%&]!$)?!$!>$'$A$=<! ()! +<*!%$)F*!

&@!8h! +&!gh!N<#! \fhJc9! +&!8fJ:9!*.%&]J!P)*!=$>6!4$=!=&'?! @&%!Q9! +&!:9!N<#! \h9! +&!hcJ8h!*.%&]J!

;(F.%*!gJd!=<&4=!=$>6=!+<$+!$%*!=+&%*?!()!$!=+&%$F*!%&&/!&)!+<*!>(+-!/$%6*+!&@!5$/$'*J!

!

5$A'*!gJf!=<&4=!<&4!+<*!7%(>*!7*%!6F!>$)!2$%-! @&%!?(@@*%*)+!=*''*%=!$)?! @&%!?(@@*%*)+!Y.$)+(+(*=J!

;&%! +<*! 7%&?.>*%=! $)?! %*+$('*%=! (+! =**/=!/&%*! 7%&@(+$A'*! +&! =*''! =/$''! $/&.)+=! &@! =<*$! A.++*%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!8!http://www.aak.com/; http://www.croklaan.com/; http://www.adm.com & http://www.wilmar-international.com/

http://www.ghananuts.com; http://www.olamonline.com !

!

;(F.%*!gJi!L!E&/*)!=*''()F!=/$''!=(l*=!

&@!=<*$!A.++*%!&)!+<*!MA&$A&!/$%6*+D!

5$/$'*! \vg9F%$/=! @&%! 9J9h!N<#D! 9J9g!

*.%&]!

35

>&/7$%*?!+&!+<*!A&4'!$)?!>$'$A$=<*=!2&'./*=J!!M=!+<*!7%(>*!7*%!6F!@&%!+<*!=/$''!$/&.)+=!(=!9Jdh!

*.%&D!4<*)!=&'?!$+!i9!F%$/=D!+<*!7%(>*=!7*%!6F!&@!+<*!A&4'!\9Jgd!+&!9Jh9!*.%&n6F]!$)?!>$'$A$=<*=!

\9Jd9!+&!9Jc8!*.%&n6F]!(=!>&)=(?*%*?!<(F<*%!()!+$A'*!gJfJ!

!

!

5$A'*!gJf!L!P2*%2(*4!&@!'&>$'!$)?!C.%&7*$)!7%(>*=D!$)?!Y.$)+(+(*=!&@!A.++*%!=&'?!A-!%*+$('*%=!$)?!

4<&'*=$'*%=!&)!+<*!.%A$)!/$%6*+=!()!5$/$'*u!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

;(F.%*! gJh! L! T&4'=! &@! =<*$!

A.++*%!@&%!=$'*!\vh6F]!!

!

;(F.%*! gJc! L! M! >$'$A$=<! &@!

=<*$! A.++*%! &)! $! 4*(F<()F!

=>$'*!\8Q!6F]!

;(F.%*! gJd! L! K$>6=! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! ()! $!

=+&%*!

!

!

;&%!+<*!.%A$)!=+&%*!6**7*%=!+<*!7%(>*!7*%!6F!$%*!<(F<*%!+<$)!+<&=*!&@!+<*!7%&>*==&%=J!;&%!+<&=*!

4<&'*=$'*%=!+<*!>$'$A$=<*=!<$=!+<*!<(F<*=+!7%(>*!7*%!6FD!9J:Q!+&!9JdQ!*.%&n6FJ!V)+*%*=+()F!+&!)&+*!

(=!+<$+!4<*)!+<*!4*(F<+!&@!+<*!A&4'=!$)?!>$'$A$=<*=!F*+!'$%F*%!+<*!7%(>*=!7*%!6F!$%*!'&4*%D!(J*J!$!

Producers and retailers

Store keepers (urban)

Prices selling

Prices selling Local weight

International weight (kg)

Ghana cedis

Euro** p/kg (€) Ghana cedis

Euro** p/kg (€)

Small amounts

0.015 - 0.04kg

0.05 0.03 2.00 - 0.75

Bowl 5kg 3-4 1.85 - 2.50 0.37 - 0.50 5-6 3.10 - 3.75 0.62 - 0.75 Calabash 16-28kg 18-25 11.25 -15.60 0.70 - 0.62 25-35 15.60 - 21.90 0.98 - 0.78 Sack 60-85kg 80-90 50 - 56.25 0.83 - 0.66 * Data collected in July-September 2008. ** Euro rate: 1 euro is 1.60 GhC!

36

<(F<*%!$/&.)+!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!><*$7*%!7*%!6F!@&%!+<*!>.=+&/*%J!5<*!?$+$!&@!4*(F<+=!()!+$A'*!gJf!

$%*!*0+%*/*=D!'&4*=+!$)?!<(F<*=+!4*(F<+=!$%*!F(2*)J!_%(>*=!$%*!)&+!@(0*?D!$=!A$%F$()()F!(=!.=.$''-!

?&)*!$/&)F!+<*!+%$?*%=J!

!

#&=+=!()2&'2*?!()!+<*!7%&>*==!&@!/$6()F!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!+<*!>&=+=!()2&'2*?!()!+<*!+%$?()F!&)!+<*!

'&>$'!/$%6*+!$%*!%$%*'-! (?*)+(@(*?!$)?!%*>&%?*?J!E<*)!$=6*?D!+<*!.%A$)!4&/*)!=$-!+<$+!?%(2*%=!

=&/*+(/*=!<$2*!%*>&%?=!&)!+<*(%!+%$)=7&%+$+(&)!'&$?=J!;&%!*0$/7'*D!+<*!?%(2*%!/(F<+!%*>*(2*!+<*!

?*+$('=!&@!?*'(2*%-!&)!7$7*%!4(+<!$/&.)+!&@!=$>6=!&@!$!>*%+$()!7%&?.>+D!+<*!?*'(2*%-!$??%*==!$)?!

+<*!7%(>*!7$(?! @&%! (+D!A.+!.=.$''-! +<&=*!7$7*%=!$%*)k+!6*7+J!5<*! '$>6!&@! %*>&%?=!/$6*=! (+!<$%?! +&!

*=+(/$+*!+<*!Y.$)+(+(*=!&@!A.++*%!=&'?!7*%!/&)+<!&%!()!$!-*$%J!

!

K&/*! *0$/7'*=! &@! >&=+=! /$?*! A-! =*''*%=! $%*! >&=+=! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)! \=**! 7%*2(&.=!

><$7+*%]D! +%$)=7&%+$+(&)! +&! +<*! /$%6*+=D! +%$)=7&%+$+(&)! +&! +<*! >'(*)+D! 7$>6$F()F! $)?! '&$?()FD!

'$A&.%! +(/*D! >.'+.%$'! $)?! =&>($'! >&=+=J!N(@+=D! ()! +<*! @&%/!&@! =<*$! A.++*%D! $%*! F(2*)! $4$-! A-! +<*!

+%$?*%=! $=! 4*''! +&! A.('?! =&>($'! %*'$+(&)=<(7=J! N(2()F! $4$-! =<*$! A.++*%! (=! >&//&)! &)! =7*>($'!

&>>$=(&)!&@!$!@$/('-!/*/A*%!$)?n&%!$)!*>&)&/(>$'!%*'$+(&)D!'(6*!4<*)!$!)*4!A$A-!(=!A&%)D!&)!$!

4*??()F!&%!&)!$!@.)*%$'J!!

!

V)!+$A'*!gJ8!+<*!>&=+=!$)?!A*)*@(+=!/$?*!A-!+<*!.%A$)!+%$?*%=!()!=<*$!A.++*%!$%*!(''.=+%$+*?J!5<*!

>&=+=!&@!+<*!=$>6!$)?!%&7*D!+<*!/*)!<(%*?!@&%!7$>6()F!$)?!'&$?()F!$%*!7$(?!A-!+<*!A.-*%!&@!=<*$!

A.++*%!$+!+<*!=+&%*!&)!+<*!.%A$)!/$%6*+J!!

!

5$A'*!gJ8!L!#&=+=!$)?!A*)*@(+=!/$?*!A-!+<*!=+&%*!6**7*%=!&)!+<*!.%A$)!/$%6*+D!MA&$A&!5$/$'*!u!

!

!

Costs GhC Euro** Benefit GhC Euro** Store 12 per year 7.5 Bowl 5 3.13

Calabash 25-35 15.63- 21.88

Watchmen

1-2 month/store

0.63- 1.25

Sack 80-90 50 - 56.25 ‘council toll’

1,5 month/store

.94

calabash from rural women

18 – 25

15.60 - 21.90

bowl from rural women

3-4 3.10 - 3.75

young man for packing

1 per sack 0.63

young man for loading

0.50- 1 per sack

0.31 - 0.63

sack/rope . . paper . . transport to and from village market

Depending on distance and on load

.

* Data collected in July/August 2008. ** Euro rate: 1 euro is 1.60 GhC!

37

gJg!! j.$'(+-!

!!

j.$'(+-! (=! $)! (==.*! '&>$''-D! $=! >&)=./*%=! $)?! +%$?*%=! '&&6! $+! +<*! >&'&.%D! +*0+.%*D! +<*! /*'+()F!

$A('(+-D! +<*!/&(=+.%*!>&)+*)+D!>&2*%$F*!$)?!$++%$>+(2*)*==!&@!+<*!A.++*%J!5<*!A.++*%!=&'?!&)!+<*!

'&>$'!/$%6*+!(=!4<(+*!&%!-*''&4!()!>&'&.%J!

!

,*'+()F! &@! +<*! A.++*%! (=! +<*! A(FF*=+! >&)>*%)!

@&%!+<*!+%$?*%=!&)!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+J!M''!=*''*%=!

&@! +<*! A.++*%! +$6*! >$%*! +&! 6**7! +<*! A.++*%! ()!

+<*! =<$?*D! +<*-! >&2*%! (+! $)?! =+&%*! +<*!A.++*%!

()!$! >&&'! $)?!?%-!7'$>*J!I*+$('!4&/*)!&)!+<*!

/$%6*+=D! 4<&! =*''! =/$''! =(l*=! &@! =<*$! A.++*%!

=<&4! +<*! A.++*%! 7$%+'-! .)>&2*%*?D! 4<('*! +<*!

%*=+!(=!>&2*%*?!A-!$!4*+!7(*>*!&@!>'&+<J!!!

!

5<*!/&(=+.%*!>&)+*)+! (=!Y.$'(@(*?!A-! +&.><()F!

$)?!%.AA()F!+<*!A.++*%!+<%&.F<!+<*!@()F*%=J! V@!

+<*!A.++*%!@**'=!=&@+D!(+!(=!>&)=(?*%*?!+&!<$2*!$!

<(F<!/&(=+.%*!>&)+*)+J!5<(=!/*$)=!'*==!A.++*%D!

=&! <$%?! A.++*%! (=! >&)=(?*%*?! $! F&&?! Y.$'(+-!

A.++*%!A-! +%$?*%=! $)?! >&)=./*%=J! \()+*%2(*4=!

+%$?*%=!$)?!>&)=./*%=D!=**!><$7+*%!c!$'=&]J!

!

5<*!?*/$)?!&)!+<*!>&'&.%!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!>$)!2$%-!@%&/!4<(+*!+&!-*''&4!$)?!*2*%-!>&'&.%!+<$+!(=!

()!A*+4**)J!E<(+*!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!7.%*!=<*$!A.++*%D!4<(><!(=!/&=+'-!.=*?!@&%!>&&6()FJ!5<*!-*''&4!

A.++*%!A*>&/*=!-*''&4!A*>$.=*!&@!+<*!%&&+=!+<$+!$%*!$??*?!?.%()F!+<*!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!7%&>*==D!

$)?!(=!@$2&.%*?!()!+<*!=&.+<!&@!N<$)$!@&%!+<*!/$6()F!&@!>&=/*+(>!7%&?.>+=!\()+*%2(*4=!A-!.%A$)!

+%$?()F!4&/*)]J! ^*''&4!A.++*%! (=! >&)=(?*%*?! +&!A*! =&@+*%! +<$)!4<(+*! A.++*%! A-! =*2*%$'!4&/*)!

+%$?*%=J! 3&2*++! \899h]! ?(>+$+*=! +<$+! +<*%*! (=! )&! ?(@@*%*)>*! ()! +*0+.%*! A*+4**)! +<*! ?(@@*%*)+!

>&'&.%*?!A.++*%=!4<*)!+$6*)!()+&!'$A=!@&%!+*=+()FJ!5<*!-*''&4!>&'&.%!&@!+<*!A.++*%!(=!=$(?!+&!/$6*!

(+!/&%*!$++%$>+(2*!@&%!+<*!.=*!()!=6()!7%&?.>+=J!

!

M)&+<*%! ><$%$>+*%(=+(>! /*)+(&)*?! &)! +<*! /$%6*+! 4$=! +<*! +*0+.%*! &@! +<*! A.++*%J! V+! <$=! +&! A*!

=/&&+<!$)?!)&!>&)+$/()$+(&)!=<&.'?!A*!/(0*?!()+&!+<*!A.++*%D!'(6*!@&%!*0$/7'*D!=$)?D!=+&)*=D!&%!

?.=+J!!!

!

5<*! *07&%+! ()?.=+%-! (=! /&%*! ?*/$)?()F! &)! +<*! Y.$'(+-! &@! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%J! #.%%*)+! +%$?(+(&)$'!

7&=+L<$%2*=+! 7%&>*==()F! &@! =<*$! 6*%)*'=! ).+! ()+&! =<*$! A.++*%! %*=.'+=! ()! Y.$'(+-! +<$+! (=! +&&!

()>&)=(=+*)+!@&%!*07&%+!\=**!@&%!@.%+<*%!?*+$('=!><$7+*%!h]J!5<(=!(=!$!>&)=+%$()+!@&%!+%$?(+(&)$''-!=<*$!

*0+%$>+(&)D!<&4*2*%!/(F<+!&@@*%!$)!&77&%+.)(+-!(@!Y.$'(+-!>$)!A*!/$?*!/&%*!>&)=(=+*)+!A-!A*++*%!

>&)+%&''*?!*0+%$>+(&)!/*+<&?=J!!

!

T&0! gJ8! L! ! E$-! &@! 7$>6$F()F! >$'$A$=<*=! &@! =<*$!

A.++*%!()+&!=$>6=!!

5<*! 7%&?.>*%=! <$2*! +<*(%! A.++*%D! ()! A&4'=! $)?!

>$'$A$=<*=D! >&2*%*?! 4(+<! $! >'&+<! $)?! $! =*>&)?!

>'&+<!>&2*%=!*2*%-+<()FJ!!

!

E<*)! +<*! A.++*%! (=! =&'?! +&! $! =+&%*! 6**7*%D! +<*!

>'&+<=!$%*!%*/&2*?!$)?!(+!4(''!A*!>&2*%*?!()!7$7*%J!

5<*! 7$7*%! (=! @%&/! 7$7*%! A$F=! &@! >*/*)+J! 54&!

7$7*%! A$F=! $%*! <&'?()F! +<*! >*/*)+J! 5<*! &.+=(?*!

7$7*%! (=!.=*?!@&%!+<*!>&2*%()F!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!

5<*! ()=(?*! &@! +<*! &.+*%! 7$7*%! +&.><*=! +<*! A.++*%!

$)?!&.+*%!>$'$A$=<J!5<%**!>$'$A$=<*=!$%*!>&2*%*?!

+<$+!4$-D!$)?!A.+!()!$!=$>6!\=**!@(F.%*!gJ8]J!

!

38

!

gJi! #&)=+%$()+=!$)?!&77&%+.)(+(*=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!+%$?*%=!

!

K.77'-!&@!A.++*%!(=!?*7*)?*)+!&)!+<*!=.77'-!$)?!$2$('$A('(+-!&@!+<*!=<*$!).+=J!5<*!7(>6()F!&@!+<*!

=<*$!).+=!=+$%+=!()!,$-nX.)*J!M%&.)?!+<$+!+(/*!+(''!K*7+*/A*%!+<*!=.77'-!&@!A.++*%!(=!'$%F*%!+<$)!

+<*!?*/$)?J!M+!+<(=!+(/*!*=7*>($''-!%.%$'!7%&?.>*%=!$%*!()!)**?!&@!?(%*>+!>$=<J!I.%$'!@$/('(*=!+<$+!

<$2*!'(/(+*?!$/&.)+!&@!/&)*-!$)?!@&&?!$%*!()!?(%*>+!)**?!&@!>$=<!()!+<*!'*$)!=*$=&)J!5<(=!/$6*=!

+<*(%!)*F$+(&)!7&=(+(&)!4*$6D!$)?!+<*)!(+!(=!+<*!.%A$)!4&/*)!4<&!$%*!()!$!?&/()$)+!7&=(+(&)!&@!

?*>(?()F!&)!7%(>*=J!!

!

P)! +<*! '&>$'!/$%6*+!7%(>*!A$%F$()()F! (=!$!.=.$'! $=7*>+!&@!A.-()F! $)?! =*''()FJ! V)! +<*!<(F<! =.77'-!

=*$=&)D!/$)-!%.%$'!7%&?.>*%=!$%*!/&%*!?*7*)?*)+!&)!+<*!7%(>*=!$=6*?!A-!+<*!)*0+!A.-*%!$=!+<*-!

$%*!()!)**?!&@!>$=<J!

!

5<*! /$%6*+! $>>*==D! +<*! %&$?=! $)?! +%$)=7&%+$+(&)! >&=+=! $)?! %*'($A('(+-! $%*! &@+*)! $! >&)=+%$()+D!

*=7*>($''-! ()!)&%+<*%)!N<$)$!$)?!+<*!=/$''!2(''$F*=J!5<*! ()@%$=+%.>+.%*! (=!=+(''!$!/$1&%!>&)=+%$()+!

@&%!+<*!=.77'-!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!+<*!$2$('$A('(+-!&@!A.-*%=!>&/()F!+&!$!2(''$F*!&%!'&>$'!/$%6*+J!

!

!

;%&/!K*7+*/A*%nP>+&A*%!&)4$%?=!.)+('!+<*!)*0+!)*4!=*$=&)!&@!=<*$!).+=!(=!=+$%+()F!\,$-nX.)*]D!

+%$?*%=!4<&!>$)!$@@&%?!(+!$%*!=+&%()F!+<*!=<*$!).+=!$)?!=<*$!A.++*%J!5<*-!4(''!=*''!+<*!=<*$!).+=!

$)?! A.++*%! $+! $! <(F<*%! 7%(>*J! M=! &A=*%2*?! ()! +<*! A*F())()F! /&)+<=! &@! =+&%$F*D! +<*! .%A$)!

=+&%*6**7*%=!(=!A.-()F!A.++*%D!A.+!$%*!)&+!=*''()F!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!H&!7%&@(+!=**/*?!+&!A*!/$?*J!

5<*!>$=*!4$=!+<$+!=&!>$''*?!()2*=+&%=!$%*!$>+.$''-!$==(F)()F!+<*!'&>$'!/(??'*!4&/*)!+&!A.-!=<*$!

A.++*%!@&%!+<*/J!5<*=*!()2*=+&%=!$%*!7*&7'*!4<&!F(2*!/&)*-!+&!+<*!.%A$)!=<*$!A.++*%!+%$?*%!+&!

A.-!$!>*%+$()!Y.$)+(+-!&@!A.++*%J!5<*!.%A$)!=<&76**7*%!4(''!=+&%*!+<*!A.++*%!.)+('!+<*!7%(>*=!$%*!

%(=()FJ!5<*!4&/*)!&)!+<*!/$%6*+!4(''!+<*)!=*''!+<*!A.++*%!$+!$!<(F<*%!7%(>*!$)?!+<*!()2*=+&%!4(''!

F$()!=&/*!7%&@(+J!5<*!/$%6*+!4&/$)!4(''!F*+!<*%!=<$%*!()!+<*!A.=()*==!>&&7*%$+(&)J!5<*!�()2*=+&%k!

<$=!+&!7$-!fN<#!%*)+!$=!4*''!$)?!(=!@%**!+&!F(2*!$)-!&+<*%!$/&.)+!+&!+<*!/$%6*+!4&/$)!/&=+'-!

?*7*)?()F!&)!<&4!=$+(=@(*?!+<*!�()2*=+&%k!(=J!

!

,&%*! $A&.+! +<*! )$+.%*! $)?! (/7'(>$+(&)=! &@! *>&)&/(>! .)>*%+$()+-! @&%! %.%$'! /$%6*+=! $)?!

'(2*'(<&&?=!>$)!A*!@&.)?!()!$)!$%+(>'*!&@!#<$'@()!\#<$'@()D!8999]J!

!

=>K>B! "02,%4!&$(80+9,&5!

P)!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+!+<*!+%$?()F!4&/*)!<*'7!*$><!&+<*%J!5<*-!F&!&)!+.%)=!+&!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+=!+&!

A.-!+<*(%!=<*$!A.++*%!=+&>6D!4<('*!(+!.=.$''-!$%*!+<*!&'?*%!4&/*)!4<&!=+$-!$+!+<*!=+&%*=!$)?!A.-!

A.++*%!@%&/!=<*$!A.++*%!7%&?.>*%=!+<$+!>&/*!A-J!,$)-!&@!+<*=*!7%&?.>*%=!>&/*!@%&/!@$%!$)?!4(''!

F&! =<&77()F!&)! +<*!/$%6*+J!P@+*)! +<*-!>$)! '*$2*! +<*(%! '.FF$F*D!&%!/*%><$)?(=*!A&.F<+!&)! +<*!

/$%6*+D!()!+<*!=+&%*=J!!

T*+4**)! /$)-! +%$?*%=! +<*%*! *0(=+=! $)! .)?*%=+$)?()F! A$=*?! &)! +%.=+! $)?! +<*-! $%*! .=.$''-!

.)@$/('($%!4(+<!()@&%/$+(&)!4<&!=&/*&)*!4&%6=!@&%J!5<*-!/$-A*!6)&4!$!)$/*D!A.+!.=.$''-!)&+!

39

>&/7$)-!&%!4<*%*!$)&+<*%!+%$?*%!>&/*=!@%&/J!M'=&!()!+<*!=+&%*=!'(++'*!%*>&%?=!&@!=$'*=!$%*!6*7+D!

$'+<&.F<!=&/*!%*>&%?=!<$2*!A**)!@&.)?!$+!=&/*!7%&>*==()F!>*)+%*=!$%&.)?!5$/$'*!>(+-J!!

!

!

gJh! 5%*)?=!&2*%!+<*!'$=+!-*$%=!

!

5<*!=<*$!A.++*%!/$%6*+!$%&.)?!5$/$'*!<$=!><$)F*?!&2*%!+<*!'$=+!+*)!-*$%=J!!E<$+!4*!>$)!=**!(=!

+<$+! +<*!=<*$!).+!$)?!=<*$!A.++*%! ()?.=+%-!<$2*! ()>%*$=*?! \3&2*++D!899h]J!P)!+<*!&+<*%!<$)?! (+!

=**/=!+<$+!=<*$!A.++*%!.=*!(=!?*>%*$=()F!$+!<&.=*<&'?!>&)=./7+(&)!'*2*'!()!N<$)$!4(+<()!+<*!>(+-!

\=**!#<$7+*%!c!&)! >&)=./7+(&)]J! 5<*! *07&%+()F! ()?.=+%-! ()! =<*$!).+=! $)?!A.++*%! (=! =<&4()F!$)!

()>%*$=()F! +%*)?! $)?!A*>$.=*!&@! +<(=! '$%F*%!?*/$)?!/&%*!4&/*)!&%F$)(l*! +<*/=*'2*=! ()! =<*$!

A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!&%!+%$?()F!F%&.7=!()=+*$?!&@!&7*%$+()F!()?(2(?.$''-J!T*=(?*=!+<(=D!/&%*!$)?!/&%*!

=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!>*)+%*=!$%*!*=+$A'(=<*?J!5<*!@&%/$+(&)!&@!4&/*)!$==&>($+(&)=!$)?!F%&.7=!

>$)! 7$%+'-! A*! $)! *@@*>+! &@! +<*! 7%(2$+(=$+(&)! &@! +<*! >&>&$! A&$%?! $@+*%! f::9J!,&%*! &)! +<*! >&>&$!

A&$%?!4(''! A*!*07'$()*?! ()! ><$7+*%! hD! pC07&%+*%=!&@! @()(=<*?! =<*$!7%&?.>+=qJ! 5<(=! F&2*%)/*)+$'!

A&?-!()>%*$=*?!+<*!$>+(2(+-!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.=()*==!A-!F(2()F!%.%$'!4&/*)!A*++*%!/$%6*+!$>>*==J!5<*!

/$()! 7.%7&=*! &@! +<*! >&>&$! A&$%?!4$=! +&! &%F$)(l*! +<*! =<*$!/$%6*+! ()! =.><! $!4$-! +<$+! (+! 4$=!

A*++*%!$A'*!+&!/**+!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!=<*$!6*%)*'!?*/$)?!@&%!*07&%+!7.%7&=*=!\=+$+*?!A-!U%J!

^(?$)$D! 899Q]J! 5<*! H$+(&)$'! M==&>($+(&)! &@! K<*$! ;$%/*%=D! _%&>*==&%=! $)?! T.-*%=! <$2*! A**)!

*=+$A'(=<*?!()!899dJ!5<*(%!$(/!(=!+&!<$2*!$!=<*$!A&$%?!=*7$%$+*?!@%&/!+<*!>&>&$!A&$%?D!$)?!+&!A*!

$A'*!+&!@&>.=!/&%*!&)!+<*!&77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!/$6()F!(/7%&2*/*)+=!4(+<()!+<*!=<*$!/$%6*+J!

!

M>>&%?()F! +&! U%J! ^(?$)$! \_*%=&)$'! >&//.)(>$+(&)D! 899Q]D! @(@+-! -*$%=! $F&! +<*! <&.=*<&'?!

>&)=./7+(&)!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$=!*?(A'*!@$+!>&.'?!A*!*=+(/$+*?!c9r!>&/7$%*?!+&!&+<*%!*?(A'*!&('=J!

5&?$-!+<(=!7*%>*)+$F*!(=!>&)=(?*%*?!+&!A*!/.><!'*==!$)?!>$)!A*!*07'$()*?!?.*!+&!+<*!?*>%*$=*?!

7%&?.>+(&)! &@! +%$?(+(&)$'! $F%(>.'+.%$'! >%&7=J! ;&%! *0$/7'*D! '*==! -$/! $)?! >$==$2$! (=! F%&4)!4<('*!

7%&?.>+(&)!&@!%(>*!$)?!=&-$!(=!F*++()F!/&%*!>&//&)!\7*%=&)$'!>&//.)(>$+(&)!U%J!^(?$)$D!899Q]J!

5<*!(/7&%+!&@!=.A=+(+.+*=!@&%!@&&?!$)?!>&=/*+(>=!$%*!%*@'*>+*?!()!+<*!>&)=./7+(&)!7$++*%)=!()!+<*!

<&.=*<&'?!.=*J! V/7&%+!7%&?.>+=!&@!&+<*%!*?(A'*!&('=!'(6*!7$'/!&('D!F%&.)?).+!&('!\7*$).+!&(']!$)?!

&+<*%!2*F*+$A'*!&('=! \=&-$D! =.)@'&4*%]!$%*! =.A=+(+.+*=! @&%! =<*$!A.++*%! ()! >&&6()FJ! !M'=&! =6()>$%*!

7%&?.>+=!$%*!F*++()F!()>%*$=()F'-!7&7.'$%D!>&/7$%*?!+&!=<*$!A.++*%!$=!$!=6()!>%*$/J!C2*)!(@!+<*=*!

7%&?.>+=! $%*!/&%*!*07*)=(2*D! +<*-!$%*!=**)!$=!/&%*! �/&?*%)k! +<$)! +<*!.)%*@()*?!=<*$!A.++*%J!

\@.%+<*%!?*+$('=!><$7+*%!cD!pG%A$)!=<*$!A.++*%!>&)=./7+(&)q]J!!

!

gJc! #&)>'.=(&)=!

!

P)!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+!+<*!=.77'-!><$()!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!>&)=(=+=!&@!7%&?.>*%=D!4<&'*=$'*%=D!%*+$('*%=!

$)?!>&)=./*%=J!5%$?*%=!$%*!>&)@%&)+*?!A-!><$''*)F*=!'(6*!/$%6*+!$>>*==D!>&=+=!&@!+%$)=7&%+$+(&)D!

=*$=&)$'(+-k=!&@!4*$+<*%!$)?!@%.(+()F!=*$=&)D!>.'+.%$'!*2*)+=!$)?!$2$('$A('(+-!&@!A.-*%=J!3&&6()F!$+!

+<*!/$()!Y.*=+(&)!&@!+<(=!4&%6()F!?&>./*)+!&)!pB&4!>$)!'&>$'!7(>6*%=!$)?!7%&>*==&%=!*$%)!/&%*!

@%&/!=<*$!).+=n!=<*$!A.++*%eqD! @&%! +<*! '&>$'! +%$?*! (+!>$)!A*!=$(?! +<$+!)&+!&)'-! '&>$'!7(>6*%=!$)?!

40

7%&>*==&%=!<$2*!?(@@(>.'+-!()!*$%)()F!@%&/!=<*$!A.+!$'=&!+<*!'&>$'!+%$?*%=D!+<*!7%&?.>*%=D!%*+$('*%=!

$)?!4<&'*=$'*%=J!V)!+<*!+*0+!A*'&4!@&''&4=!+<*!>&)>'.=(&)!&)!+<*!=.A1*>+!&@!'&>$'!+%$?*J!

!

M!%*=*$%><!Y.*=+(&)!&)!+<*!'&>$'!+%$?*!(=!@&%/.'$+*?Z!pM%*!+<*!+%$?*%=!$A'*!+&!=$+(=@-!+<*!?*/$)?!

()!Y.$)+(+(*=!$)?! ()!Y.$'(+-!&@!+<*!)*0+!A.-*%eqJ!5<*!%*=.'+!+<$+!>$/*!&.+!(=!)&+!$''! +<$+!>'*$%J! V+!

4$=!)&+!7&==(A'*!+&!&A+$()!$)-!>'*$%!?$+$!@%&/!Y.$)+(+(*=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!=&'?!&%!A&.F<+!&2*%!$)!

>*%+$()!7*%(&?D!@&%!*0$/7'*!&2*%!$!-*$%D!4(+<()!+<*!/&)+<!&@!%*=*$%><J!5<(=!(=!A*>$.=*!/&=+!&@!+<*!

+(/*!)&!%*>&%?=!$%*!6*7+!&@!+<*!A.=()*==!()!$)?!&.+7.+J!5<*!=(+.$+(&)!>$)!A*!?*=>%(A*?!$=!@&''&4=!

4(+<()!+<*!=.77'-!><$()!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!&)!+<*!'&>$'!+%$?*!%*F$%?()F!+&!+<*!=.ALY.*=+(&)Z!pB&4!>$)!

'&>$'! 4&/*)! =+&%*6**7*%=! $)?! %*+$('*%=! *$%)! /&%*! @%&/! =<*$! A.++*%eqJ! 5<*! 7%&?.>*%=! $)?!

4&/*)!4<&'*=$'*%=!\4&/*)!:gr!()!5$/$'*!MA&$A&!/$%6*+]!$%*!?*7*)?*)+!&)!+<*(%!A.-*%D!&+<*%!

/(??'*/*)! $)?! 4&/*)D! =&.+<*%)! +%$?*%=! $)?! *07&%+! >&/7$)(*=J! ,$)-! =/$''! $)?! A(FF*%!

/(??'*/*)!$%*!4(+<()!+<*!=.77'-!><$()D!+<(=!/*$)=!+<$+!+<*!7%&?.>+!(=!&@+*)!)&+!+%$?*?!?(%*>+'-!

+&!>&)=./*%=!&%!>&/7$)(*=!A.+!/$6*=!$!'&)F!4$-!A*@&%*!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!.=*?!&%!*)?=!$+!+<*!

>&)=./*%J! T*>$.=*! &@! +<(=! +<*! 7%&?.>*%=! $)?! =/$''! /(??'*/*)! \4&/*)]D! 4<&'*=$'*%=! $)?!

%*+$('*%=D!?&!)&+!A*)*@(+!&7+(/$''-J!5<*!7%&?.>+!4(''! ()>%*$=*! ()!7%(>*!$+!*2*%-!=+*7!()!+<*!=.77'-!

><$()!A*>$.=*!&@!+<*!=+&%()FD!7$>6$F()F!$)?!+%$)=7&%+$+(&)!>&=+=!()>'.?*?!&@!+<*!)*0+!=*''*%!+&!+<*!

@&''&4()F!A.-*%J!M!=&'.+(&)!@&%!+<*!7%&?.>*%=D!=+&%*6**7*%=!$)?!%*+$('*%=!&)!+<*!'&>$'!/$%6*+!(=!+&!

<$2*! *)&.F<! A.-*%=! $)?! +&! <$2*! %*'($A'*! A.-*%=J! M)&+<*%! 7&==(A'*! =&'.+(&)! (=! +&! <$2*! $! ?(%*>+!

+%$?()F! @%&/! +<*! 7%&?.>*%=D! +&! +<*! +%$?*%=! $)?! +<*! ()?.=+%-! +&! +<*! >&)=./*%J! 5&! >%*$+*!/&%*!

+%$)=7$%*)>-!$)?!>&)+%&'!&)!+<*!+%$?*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!(+=!7%(>*J!

!

M)&+<*%!&77&%+.)(+-! (=! +&!<$2*!A*++*%! >&)+%&'!&2*%! +<*! =<*$!6*%)*'! 7%&>*==()F!$)?! =<*$!A.++*%!

*0+%$>+(&)D! $)?! +<.=! +&! <$2*! $! /&%*! >&)=(=+*)>-! ()! +<*! Y.$'(+-D! $! =+$)?$%?(l*?! /*+<&?J! 5<*!

N<$)$!=+$)?$%?=!A&$%?!$)?!+<*!N<$)$!*07&%+!7%&/&+(&)!>&.)>('!(=!4&%6()F!&)!+<(=!4(+<!?(@@*%*)+!

4&/*)!F%&.7=D!$'+<&.F<!+<*!$>+(2(+-!<$=!+&!>&/*!@%&/!+<*!K&.+<!&@!N<$)$!$)?!(=!=**/()F'-!+&!A*!

)&+!+<$+!*@@*>+(2*!\-*+]!\=**!><$7+*%!hD!=**!$77*)?(0!VVV!a!V`]J!!!

!

,$)-! A.=()*==!4&/*)!4(+<()! +<*! =<*$!/$%6*+! $%*! >&/7'$()()F! &@! +<*! '$>6! &@!/$%6*+D! ?.*! +&!

>&/7*+(+(&)! >&)>*%)()F! Y.$)+(+(*=! $)?! Y.$'(+-D! +<*(%! 7&=(+(&)! &)! +<*! /$%6*+! O! ()?(2(?.$'!

7%&>*==&%=D!4&/*)!F%&.7=D!=/$''!.%A$)!/(??'*!4&/*)!&%!=.>>*==@.'!/(??'*!/*)!$)?!@$>+&%(*=!O!

$)?!+<*!/$%6*+!><$)F*!$=!+<*!*07&%+!/$%6*+!(=!()>%*$=()FJ!5<*!7%&A'*/!>&)=(?*%*?!'$-=!+<*%*@&%*!

/&%*! 4(+<()! +<*! >&//*%>($'! *07*%(*)>*D! +<*! >&/7*+(+(2*! 7%(>()FD! 7%*L@()$)>()F! $)?! @()$)>($'!

&%F$)(=$+(&)D! +<*! +(/()F! &@! ?*'(2*%()F! $)?! Y.$'(+-! >&)+%&'! &@! 7%&>*==()F! $)?! 7$>6$F()F! $)?! (=! $!

/$++*%!&@!+%.=+!$)?!%*'($A('(+-J!M!=&'.+(&)!+&!+<(=!$%*!+<*!>%*$+(&)!&@!7$%+)*%=<(7=D!4<*%*!4&/*)!

F%&.7=!$%*!@&%/*?D!$)?!1&()!*$><!&+<*%!$)?!$%*!>&)+%$>+*?!A-!+<*!A.-()F!&%F$)(=$+(&)=J!I.'*=!$)?!

%*F.'$+(&)=!>&)>*%)()F! +<*=*!>&)+%$>+=!=<&.'?! +<*%*@&%*!A*! 1.?(>($%-! ()! >$=*!&@!A%&6*)!>&)+%$>+!

'*F$'!$>+(&)=!>$)!A*!+$6*)J!5<*!=<*$!/$%6*+!4(+<()!N<$)$!(=!>&/7'(>$+*?!$)?!/$)-!=(?*!$=7*>+=!

4(+<()!+<*!/$%6*+!$%*!+&!A*!?*2*'&7*?J!

!

!

41

#<$7+*%!i! K/$''L=>$'*!*)+%*7%*)*.%=!7%&>*==()F!>&=/*+(>=!A$=*?!&)!=<*$!A.++*%!()!N<$)$!

!

!

iJf! V)+%&?.>+(&)!

V)!N<$)$!+<*%*!(=!$!=/$''!)./A*%!&@!A.=()*==*=!=*+!.7!A-!N<$)$($)=!4<&!7%&>*==!=<*$!A.++*%!()+&!

>&=/*+(>=J!5<*%*!$%*!&@!>&.%=*!)&)LN<$)$($)=!()2&'2*?!$=!4*''D!A.+!+<*!@&>.=!()!+<(=!%*=*$%><!(=!

&)! +<*! =/$''! =>$'*! *)+%*7%*)*.%=! $)?! /&=+! &@! +<*/! $%*! N<$)$($)J! ,&=+! &@! +<*! ()+*%2(*4**=!

?.%()F!+<(=!%*=*$%><!$%*!+<*!&)*=!+<$+!$%*!=**)!A-!+<*!E*=+!M@%(>$!5%$?*!B.A!\EM5B]!$=!�*07&%+!

%*$?-kJ! C07&%+! %*$?-! ()! +<(=! =*)=*!/*$)=! $/&)F!&+<*%! +<()F=! +<$+! +<*! >&/7$)-! >$)!7%&?.>*!$!

=$+(=@-()F!Y.$'(+-!$)?!Y.$)+(+-!$)?!>$)!?*'(2*%!+<(=!&)!+(/*!\GKMVU!EM5BD!899h]J!

!

M!=/$''!7$%+!&@!+<*!7(>6*?!=<*$!6*%)*'=!*)?=!.7!()!>&=/*+(>!7%&?.>+=D!@&%!*07&%+!+<(=!(=!$!%*'$+(2*'-!

)*4! /$%6*+J! K<*$! <$=! ()+*%*=+()F! 7%&7*%+(*=! @&%! +<*! >&=/*+(>! ()?.=+%-S! $/&)F! &+<*%=! +<*!

/&(=+.%(l()FD!$)+(L(%%(+$)+D!%*F*)*%$+(2*D!$)+(L()@'$//$+&%-!*@@*>+=!$)?!+<*!G`L$A=&%A()F!@.)>+(&)J!

5<*=*!7%&7*%+(*=!4(''!)&+!A*!@.%+<*%!?(=>.==*?!()!+<(=!%*7&%+!A.+!/&%*!$A&.+!+<*=*!><*/(>$'!$)?!

7<-=(>$'! 7%&7*%+(*=! >$)! A*! @&.)?! ()! +<*! $%+(>'*! &@! M'$)?*%! $)?! M)?*%==&)! \M'$)?*%! $)?!

M)?*%==&)]J!

!

iJ8! 5<*!/$%6*+!

!

#.%%*)+'-D!+<*!/$()!/$%6*+!@&%!=<*$!>&=/*+(>!7%&?.>+=! (=!)&+! ()!N<$)$!A.+!*=7*>($''-! ()!+<*!GKD!

C.%&7*!$)?!M=($J!5<*%*@&%*!+<*!*)+%*7%*)*.%=!$%*!=*$%><()F!@&%!A.-*%=!()!4*=+*%)!>&.)+%(*=!$)?!

=&!*07&%+!+%$?*!4(''!A*!=+%*==*?!()!+<(=!%*7&%+D!/&%*!$A&.+!+<$+!()!><$7+*%!hJ!!

,&=+!=<*$!A.++*%!7%&?.>+=!$%*!=<(77*?!@%&/!+<*!<$%A&.%!()!5*/$!\()!+<*!=&.+<!&@!N<$)$]D!&)'-!$!

'(++'*!7$%+!&@!+<*!7%&?.>+(&)!(=!+%$)=7&%+*?!&2*%!'$)?!+&!&+<*%!E*=+!M@%(>$)!>&.)+%(*=!\*JFJ!T.%6()$!

;$=&]!$)?!<$%?'-!$)-!A.++*%! (=!+%$)=7&%+*?!A-!$(%J!,&=+!&@!+<*!+(/*!&)'-!=$/7'*=!$%*!=*)+!A-!$(%!

A*>$.=*!+<(=!(=!+<*!@$=+*=+!4$-!&@!+%$)=7&%+J!

!

iJ8Jf! ,$%6*+!=(l*!!

5<*!>.%%*)+!=(l*!&@!+<*!/$%6*+!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!=<*$!>&)+$()()F!>&=/*+(>=! (=!)&+!>'*$%J!U$+$!

$A&.+!Y.$)+(+(*=!7%&?.>*?!A-!+<*!>&/7$)(*=!()!N<$)$!<$=!)&+!A**)!>&/7'*+*'-!>&''*>+*?!-*+!A-!

$)-! &@! +<*! F&2*%)/*)+! $.+<&%(+(*=D! $'+<&.F<! (/7%&2*/*)+! (=! &)! +<*! 4$-! \/&%*! $A&.+! +<(=! ()!

7$%$F%$7<! hJg]D! )&%! (=! +<*%*! Y.$)+(+$+(2*! ()@&%/$+(&)! &)! ?*/$)?J! C=+(/$+()F! Y.$)+(+(*=! &@! +<*!

/$%6*+!@&%!+<*=*!7%&?.>+=!(=!>&/7'(>$+*?D!$=!4*''!A*>$.=*!()+*%2(*4*?!>&/7$)(*=!?(?)k+!F(2*!&.+!

()@&%/$+(&)! *$=('-! $A&.+! Y.$)+(+(*=! 7%&?.>*?! $)?! +%$?*?J! 5<*! >&/7$)(*=! ()2*=+(F$+*?! ()! +<(=!

%*=*$%><!()?(>$+*?!+<$+!+<*-!>&.'?!7%&?.>*!/&%*!(@!+<*-!4*%*!=.%*!+<$+!+<*%*!$%*!A.-*%=!@&%!+<*(%!

7%&?.>+=J!!

5<*!?*/$)?!@&%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!(=!()>%*$=()FS!*=7*>($''-!()!+<*!GKD!X$7$)!$)?!C.%&7*J!

5<*%*!$%*!&7+(&)=!@&%!()>%*$=()F!+<*!/$%6*+!@&%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!A*>$.=*!+<*!/$()!>&/7*+(+&%=!@&%!

=<*$O>&=/*+(>=! $%*! >&=/*+(>=!/$?*! &.+! &@! >&>&$! A.++*%D! >&>&).+! &('! $)?! (/7&%+*?! >&=/*+(>=J!

,&=+!&@!+<*=*!7%&?.>+=!$%*!(/7&%+*?D!$=!+<*%*!$%*!)&+!/$)-!>&=/*+(>!7%&?.>*%=!()!N<$)$J!V@!+<*!

42

=<*$!>&=/*+(>=!>&.'?!A*!.=*?!/&%*!()=+*$?!&@!+<*=*!=.A=+(+.+*=!+<(=!>&.'?!/*$)!$!=<$%7!()>%*$=*!

&@!?*/$)?!$=!4*''! '&>$''-J!M!>&)=+%$()+! (=! +<$+! '&&6()F!$+!>&)=./*%=! ()!N<$)$!+<*-!&@+*)!7%*@*%!

)&)LN<$)$($)!>&=/*+(>=D!A.+!/&%*!$A&.+!+<$+!()!><$7+*%!cJ!

!

iJ8J8!,$%6*+!7'$-*%=!

5<*!>&/7$)(*=!+<$+!$%*!7%&?.>()F!@()(=<*?!7%&?.>+=!$%*!()!F*)*%$'!A$=*?!()!+<*!=&.+<!&@!N<$)$J!

5<*! ()+*%2(*4*?! >&/7$)(*=! ()! M>>%$! $%*! �M''! _.%*! H$+.%*kD! �C'*! MFA*kD! �H$$=$6'*k! $)?! �B$-/&%!

H$+.%$'!>&=/*+(>=kJ!T*=(?*=!+<(=!+<*%*!(=!$!4&/*)!F%&.7!()!K$F)$%(F.!\()!5$/$'*D!)&%+<*%)!%*F(&)]!

+<$+! (=!/$6()F!=&$7=!$)?!*07&%+()F!+<*=*! +&!X$7$)!4(+<!<*'7!&@!+<*!M@%(>$!8999!H*+4&%6!\M8H]D!

XV#MD!M;IMKVM!A.=()*==!>&.)>('!$)?!GHU_!N<$)$J!5<(=!4&/*)!F%&.7!<$=!A**)!()2*=+(F$+*?!()!+<(=!

%*=*$%><!$=!4*''J!

!

K&! @$%! +<*! N<$)$($)! >&/7$)(*=! +<$+! $%*! 7%&?.>()F! >&=/*+(>! 7%&?.>+=! &.+! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! $%*!

%*'$+(2*'-!=/$''!$)?!+<*%*!$%*!&)'-!$!@*4J!5<*!>&/7$)(*=!$%*!%*'$+(2*'-!=/$''!$=!4*''!$)?!$%*!)&+!

7%&>*==()F!+<*!4<&'*!-*$%!%&.)?!A*>$.=*!+<*-!&@+*)!?&)k+!=+&>6!+&&!/.><!A.+!4&%6!/&%*!4<*)!

+<*-!%*>*(2*!&%?*%=J!5<*-!&@+*)!?&)k+!<$2*!'$%F*!=+&%$F*!%&&/=!$)?!A*>$.=*!&@!+<*!7*%(=<$A('(+-!(+!

(=!%*'$+(2*'-!%(=6-!+&!7%&?.>*!()!$?2$)>*D!()!F*)*%$'!=<*$!A.++*%!<$=!$!=+&%$F*!'(@*!&@!$77%&0(/$+*'-!

8!-*$%=J!

5<*%*!$%*!'$%F*!>&/7$)(*=!\*JFJ!3k&%*$'D!3k&>>(+$)*]!.=()F!=<*$!$=!()F%*?(*)+!@&%!>&=/*+(>!7%&?.>+=!

A.+!+<&=*!>&/7$)(*=!$%*!&4)*?!A-!)&)LN<$)$($)=!$)?!7%&?.>+(&)!&@!+<*!7%&?.>+=!?&*=)k+!@()?!

7'$>*!()!N<$)$J!!

!

iJ8Jg!_%&?.>+!%$)F*!

5<*!/$()!@()(=<*?!*07&%+!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!/$?*! ()!N<$)$!>&)=(=+!&@!$!=/$''! %$)F*!&@!7%&?.>+=J! V)!

F*)*%$'Z!A$%=!&@!=<*$!=&$7!()!?(@@*%*)+!2$%(*+(*=!\)$+.%$'!=<*$!A.++*%D!4(+<!$??*?!A$&A$A!'*$2*=D!

<*))$!'*$2*=!&%!A'$>6!=&$7]D!1$%=!4(+<!7.%*!=<*$!A.++*%!&%!4(+<!$??*?!@'$2&.%=D!'(7!>$%*!7%&?.>+=!

()!'(7=+(>6!@&%/D!=<&4*%!7%&?.>+=D!<$)?!$)?!A&?-!>%*$/=!$)?!'&+(&)=J!!

5<*!'()*!&@!7%&?.>+=!>&)=(=+()F!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!='&4'-!()>%*$=()FD!*0$/7'*=!&@!%*'$+(2*!)*4!7%&?.>+=!

$%*!=<$/7&&=!$)?!>&)?(+(&)*%=D!A&?-!'&+(&)=D!/$==$F*!>%*$/=!$)?!=.)=>%**)=J!H*4!/$%6*+=!$%*!

&7*)!$)?!7$%+'-!=+(''!.)*07'&%*?!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%!7%&?.>+=S!*JFJ!=/$''!<&+*'!=&$7=D!()!T.%6()$!;$=&!

+<*%*!$%*!=&/*!>&/7$)(*=!4&%6()F!&)!+<(=J! V)!N<$)$!)&!>&/7$)(*=!$%*! @&.)?!+<$+!/$6*!<&+*'!

=&$7=!>&)=(=+()F!&@!=<*$!A.++*%J!

3&&6()F! $+! +<*! =<*$! *07&%+! >&=/*+(>! 7%&?.>+=D! /$)-! >&=/*+(>! 7%&?.>+=! $%*! F(@+! 4%$77*?S! +<*!

=<*$!A.++*%!(=!&@+*)!7$>6$F*?!()!>$'$A$=<*=!&%!()!>*%$/(>!1$%=!4(+<!$!>*''&7<$)*!>&2*%J!5<(=!$??=!

2$'.*!+&!+<*!7%&?.>+!A.+!$=!4*''!/$6*=!+%$)=7&%+!>&=+=!<(F<*%J!!

!

F+0)'2(,0&!03!2017$(,21!

5<*!()!+<(=!%*=*$%><!()2*=+(F$+*?!7%&?.>*%=!/$?*!>'*$%!+<$+!+<*-!>&.'?!7%&?.>*!/&%*!(@!+<*-!4*%*!

=.%*!+<$+!+<*%*!(=!?*/$)?!@&%!+<*!7%&?.>+=J!M>>&%?()F!+&!+<*!7%&?.>*%=!Y.$'(+-!(=!)&+!$!7%&A'*/D!

A.+! $+! +<*! =$/*! +(/*! &+<*%! =&.%>*=!/$?*! >'*$%! +<$+! +<*! 7%&?.>*?! F&&?=! $%*)k+! $'4$-=! &@! +<*!

?*=(%*?!Y.$)+(+-!$)?!Y.$'(+-J!M)!(/7&%+$)+!(==.*!(=!+<$+!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!$!7*%(=<$A'*!7%&?.>+!4<(><!

43

<$=! +&!A*! +$6*)! ()+&!$>>&.)+!4<*)!7%&?.>()F!7%&?.>+=!&.+!&@! (+S! +<*! '(/(+*?!=+&%$F*! '(@*!/$6*=!

7%&?.>()F!'$%F*!$/&.)+=!()!$?2$)>*!?(@@(>.'+J!

!

A&&0X%(,0&1!

M)! *0$/7'*! &@! $)! ())&2$+(2*! 7%&?.>+! (=! 7%&?.>*?! A-! +<*! >&/7$)-! B$-/&%! )$+.%$'! >&=/*+(>=D!

+<*-!$%*!/$6()F!=&$7!A$=*=S!=<*$!A.++*%!&.+!&@!4<(><!/&%*!'(Y.(?!(=!*0+%$>+*?!$)?!(+!'&&6=!'(6*!A(F!

>%./A=!&%!@'$6*=!&@!A.++*%J!5<*!A.++*%!(=!*07&%+*?!()!+<(=!@&%/!$)?!.=*?!()!>&/7$)(*=!$A%&$?!$=!$!

A$=*! @&%! +<*(%! =&$7=J! 5<(=! (=! +<*! &)'-! >&/7$)-! =**)! 4<(><! (=! /$6()F! +<(=! 6()?! &@! 4<&'*! =$'*!

7%&?.>+!&.+!&@!=<*$!).+=J!

!

5<*%*!$%*!$!@*4!>&/7$)(*=!7%&?.>()F!&%F$)(>!=<*$!A.++*%S!$)!*0$/7'*!&@!+<(=!()!N<$)$!(=!�V?*$'!

_%&2(?*)>*! ;$%/=kS! +<*! >&/7$)-! &@!N*&%F()$! R&&/=&)J! K<*! =+$%+*?! ()! 8998!4(+<! &%F$)(>! =<*$!

A.++*%J!5<*!@(%=+!-*$%!(+!4$=!)*4!$)?!?*/$)?!4$=!'&4D!+<*!=*>&)?!-*$%!(+!()>%*$=*?!$!'&+D!?*/$)?!

$)?!7%&?.>+(&)!>$7$>(+-!()>%*$=*?!=+%&)FJ!5<*%*!(=!$!<(F<!?*/$)?!@&%!&%F$)(>!A.++*%!@%&/!U.A$(J!

5<*! +$%F*+! (=! +<*! /(??'*! $)?! '&4! >'$==! A*>$.=*! +<*! ?*/$)?! &@! +<*! <(F<! >'$==! (=! +&&! '&4J! M!

>&)=+%$()+!()!&%F$)(>!=<*$!(=!+<*!A.%*$.>%$>-!+<$+!>&/*=!4(+<!A*()F!>*%+(@(*?J!

!

iJi! H&%+<!2*%=.=!K&.+<!N<$)$!

5<*%*! (=!$!F$7!A*+4**)!+<*!)&%+<!$)?!+<*!=&.+<!&@!N<$)$D!4<(><!>$)!A*!$??%*==*?! ()!?(@@*%*)+!

4$-=! $=! A**)! *07'$()*?! *$%'(*%! ()! +<*! ()+%&?.>+(&)J! 5<*! )&%+<*%)! 7$%+! (=! 7&&%*%! $)?! '*==!

?*2*'&7*?J!#'(/$+*D!>%&7=D!>.'+.%*!$%*!(/7&%+$)+! (==.*=D!A.+! ()!+<(=!><$7+*%!+<*!*>&)&/(>!F$7!(=!

$)!(/7&%+$)+!(==.*J!5<*!7*&7'*!4<&!$%*!7(>6()F!$)?!7%&>*==()F!+<*!=<*$!).+=!$%*!'&>$+*?!()!+<*!

)&%+<!$)?!$)!(/7&%+$)+!Y.*=+(&)!(=!()!4<(><!4$-!+<*-!>$)!F$()!/&%*!@%&/!+<*!=<*$!A.=()*==J!

5<*! >&/7$)(*=! +<$+! 7%&>*==! +<*! ).+=! &%! A.++*%! ()+&! <(F<! Y.$'(+-! @()(=<*?! 7%&?.>+=! $%*! /$()'-!

'&>$+*?! ()! =&.+<*%)!N<$)$J! 5<*! 7*&7'*! ()! +<*! )&%+<! ?&)k+! F$()! &7+(/$'! @%&/! +<*! =<*$! 7%&?.>+!

A*>$.=*!+<*-!&@+*)!&)'-!=.77'-! +<*!%$4!/$+*%($'J!C=7*>($''-!$??()F!2$'.*!+&!+<*!).+=!>$)!F(2*!$!

<(F<*%!7%&@(+!$)?!()>%*$=*!+<*!()>&/*=!&@!+<*!7*&7'*!()2&'2*?J!!

5<*!@$>+!+<$+!+<*!7%&?.>+=!$%*!&@+*)!7%&>*==*?!()!+<*!=&.+<!<$=!=*2*%$'!%*$=&)=!$)?!%*@'*>+=!=&/*!

&@!+<*!>&)=+%$()+=!+<$+!7*&7'*!@$>*!()!+<*!)&%+<!$)?!+<*!&77&%+.)(+(*=!+<$+!+<*!7*&7'*!<$2*!()!+<*!

=&.+<J!

5<*!@(%=+!%*$=&)!(=!+<$+!(+!(=!*>&)&/(>$''-!/&%*!()+*%*=+()F!+&!A*!'&>$+*?!>'&=*!+&!5*/$S!+<*!/$()!

<$%A&.%! ()! +<*! =&.+<!&@!N<$)$J! 5<*! ()7.+=!)*>*==$%-! @&%!/$6()F! +<*!7%&?.>+=!$%*!*)+*%()F! +<*!

>&.)+%-!/&=+!+<%&.F<!+<*!<$%A&.%D!@&%!*0$/7'*!+<*!7$>6$F()F!/$+*%($'=!$)?!*==*)+($'!&('=J!V@!+<*!

()7.+=! *)+*%! +<*! >&.)+%-! ()! +<*! K&.+<! $)?! <$2*! +&! A*! +%$)=7&%+*?! .7! H&%+<! +<(=! 4(''! %*=.'+! ()!

()>%*$=*?!+%$)=7&%+$+(&)!>&=+=J!

M)&+<*%!(==.*!(=!+<$+!+<*!=&.+<!(=!/&%*!?*2*'&7*?!+<$)!+<*!)&%+<J!_&4*%!>.+=!&>>.%!/&%*!&@+*)D!

%&$?=! $%*!4&%=*D! +<*%*! (=! '*==! <(F<! Y.$'(+-! +*><)&'&F-! $)?! *07*%+(=*! $2$('$A'*! ()! +<*!)&%+<! $)?!

$>>*==!+&!4$+*%!(=!/&%*!?(@@(>.'+J!!

;()$''-! ()! +<*! )&%+<! +<*%*! $%*!/&%*! (''(+*%$+*! $)?! '*==! =><&&'*?! 7*&7'*! +<$)! ()! +<*! =&.+<J! 5<(=!

/$6*=!(+!/&%*!?(@@(>.'+!+&!<$2*!$!A.=()*==J!

,&%*!$A&.+!+<*!)&%+<!=&.+<!%*'$+(&)!>$)!A*!@&.)?!()!$!%*7&%+!@%&/!+<*!>*)+%*!&@!7&'(>-!$)$'-=(=!

\PUVD!899h]!

!

44

iJh! P77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=!

!

M! @(%=+! (/7&%+$)+!>&)=+%$()+! (=! +<$+!=&/*! ()7.+=!)*>*==$%-! @&%!7%&>*==()F! +<*!=<*$!A.++*%! ()+&!$!

<(F<!Y.$'(+-!>&=/*+(>!7%&?.>+D!$%*!=>$%>*'-!$2$('$A'*!&%!*07*)=(2*J!V/7&%+$)+!*0$/7'*=!&@!+<(=!$%*!

7$>6$F()F!/$+*%($'=!$)?!*==*)+($'!&('=J!

5<*!+(/*!&@!?*'(2*%-!&@!+<*!7$>6$F()F!/$+*%($'=!+$6*=!$!%*'$+(2*!'&)F!+(/*!$=!4*''J!5<(=D!*=7*>($''-!

()!%*'$+(&)!+&!+<*!'$>6!&@!=+&%$F*!%&&/!$)?!'$>6!&@!>%*?(+!+&!A.-!'$%F*!Y.$)+(+(*=!&@!+<*=*!()7.+=D!

/$6*=! (+! ?(@@(>.'+! +&! %*=7&)?! +&! .)*07*>+*?! ?*/$)?! @&%! >*%+$()! 7%&?.>+=J! 5<*! '*)F+<! &@! +<*!

?*'(2*%-!+(/*!/(F<+!A*!.)>*%+$()!4<(><!?&*=)k+!<*'7!+<*!7%&?.>+(&)!7'$))()F!7%&>*==!$=!4*''J!!

! _$>6$F()F! (=! $)! (/7&%+$)+! 7%&A'*/D! ()! N<$)$! )&! %*$''-! F&&?! 7$>6$F()F! /$+*%($'=! $%*!

7%&?.>*?!=&!)&4!+<*!/$+*%($'=!<$2*!+&!A*!(/7&%+*?!@%&/!*JFJ!#<()$J!

!

M)&+<*%! >&)=+%$()+! +<$+! +<*! ()+*%2(*4*?! 7%&?.>*%=! $)?! *07&%+*%=! /*)+(&)! (=! .)>*%+$()+-! &@!

Y.$'(+-!$)?!Y.$)+(+-!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!+<$+!>$)!A*!?*'(2*%*?J!5<*!A.++*%! (=!=.77'(*?!@%&/!+<*!)&%+<!

@%&/!4<(><!+<*!+%$)=7&%+!(=!)&+!$'4$-=!%*'($A'*J!G)*07*>+*?!*2*)+=!'(6*!4*??()F!$)?!@.)*%$'=!>$)!

<$'+!A.=()*==!@&%!?$-=!$)?!?*$?'()*=!=&/*+(/*=!$%*)k+!=+%(>+'-!/*+J!

!

M)! (/7&%+$)+!&77&%+.)(+-!=**)! ()!+<*!4&/*)!F%&.7! ()!K$F)$%(F.!\444J=<*$7&%1*>+J&%F]! (=! +<$+!

+<*-!F&+!<*'7!@%&/!$!)./A*%!&@!HNPk=J!5<*-!4*%*!'()6*?!.7!4(+<!$!A.-*%!()!X$7$)!$)?!+<*%*@&%*!

<$2*! +<*! >&)@(?*)>*! +<$+! +<*(%! 7%&?.>+!4(''! A*! A&.F<+J! 5<(=! *)>&.%$F*=! +<*/! +&! ()>%*$=*! +<*(%!

7%&?.>+(&)!A*>$.=*!+<*-!$%*!=.%*!+<*%*!(=!$!/$%6*+!@&%!+<*(%!7%&?.>+=J!5<(=!>$)!A*!*=7*>($''-!$)!

&77&%+.)(+-!(@!-&.!$%*!'&&6()F!@&%!&+<*%!A.-*%=!-&.%=*'@!$=!4*''D!+<$)!+<*!<*'7!&@!+<*!HNP!>$)!A*!

.=*?!$=!$!=+$%+!.7!@&%!/&%*!A.=()*==!+%$)=$>+(&)=J!!

M+!+<*!=$/*!+(/*!<*'7!@%&/!HNPk=!>$)!A*!$!>&)=+%$()+!$=!(+!/$6*=!+<*!7%&?.>*%=!?*7*)?*)+!&)!

+<&=*!&%F$)(=$+(&)=J! 5<*!&%F$)(=$+(&)=!<$2*!7%&1*>+=! +<$+! $%*! +*/7&%$%-D! (@! +<*!7%&1*>+! =+&7=! (+!

%*/$()=!.)>*%+$()!4<*+<*%!+<*-!4(''!A*!$A'*!+&!>&)+().*!A.=()*==!$)?!@()?!&+<*%!A.-*%=J!!

!

M! A(F! (==.*! ()! +<*! =<*$! A.=()*==! (=! +<*! >&7-()F! &@! 7%&?.>+! >&)>*7+=J! 5<(=! (=! 2(=(A'*! ()! ?(@@*%*)+!

$=7*>+=!&@!+<*!A.=()*==D!@&%!*0$/7'*!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!7$>6$F*?!()!>$'$A$=<*=!$)?!>*%$/(>!1$%=!>$)!

A*! =**)! ()! ?(@@*%*)+! =<&7=! &@! +<*! *07&%+*%=J! M>>&%?()F! +&! +<*! ()+*%2(*4*?! 7%&?.>*%=! &@! =<*$!

7%&?.>+=! +<*-! +%-! +&! A*! ())&2$+(2*! A.+! (+! ?&*=)k+! $'4$-=! +.%)! &.+! +<$+! +<*-! %*$''-! =*''! ?(@@*%*)+!

7%&?.>+=J!H&+!/.><!?(@@*%*)>*!()!\.)(Y.*]!=*''()F!7&()+=!&%!7%&?.>+!'()*=!4$=!@&.)?!A*+4**)!+<*!

?(@@*%*)+!>&/7$)(*=J!M)!&77&%+.)(+-!>&.'?!A*!@&%!$!>&/7$)-!+&!?*2*'&7!$!.)(Y.*!7%&?.>+J!

!

M)!&77&%+.)(+-!>&.'?!A*!+&!.=*!+<*!A-L7%&?.>+=!&@!+<*!=<*$!).+=!$)?!A.++*%J!CJFJ!+<*!=<*$!@%.(+=!

$%*!)&4!*$+*)!A-!+<*!'&>$'!7*&7'*!A.+!(+!>&.'?!A*!()2*=+(F$+*?!(@!+<*-!>&.'?!A*!7%*=*%2*?!=&!+<$+!

+<*-!>$)!A*!>&)=./*?!$+!$!'$+*%!/&/*)+D!&%!+<$+!1$/=!&%!'*/&)$?*=!>&.'?!A*!/$?*!@%&/!+<*=*!

@%.(+=J! M)&+<*%! *0$/7'*! (=! +<*! �A%&4)! 4$+*%k! +<$+! $%(=*=! 4<*)! +<*! A.++*%! (=! 6)*$?*?J! V@! +<(=!

<$%?*)=!(+!(=!&@+*)!.=*?!$=!@.*'!+&!A&('!+<*!A.++*%!A.+!+<*%*!>&.'?!A*!&+<*%!7.%7&=*=!$=!4*''!()!+<*!

?(%*>+(&)!&@!>&)=./7+(&)J!

!

V)>%*$=()F!+<*!'*2*'!&@!6)&4'*?F*!=<$%()F!>$)!A*!$)!&77&%+.)(+-J!3()6*?!+&!6)&4'*?F*!=<$%()F!$%*!

(==.*=!'(6*!+<*!=+$+*!&@!+<*!()@%$=+%.>+.%*!$)?!()@&%/$+(&)!+*><)&'&F-!*Y.(7/*)+J!C'($=!*+!$'!F(2*=!

=&/*!(?*$=!@&%!=&'2()F!6)&4'*?F*!=<$%()F!7%&A'*/=J!CJFJ!7%&?.>*%!>*%+(@(>$+(&)!>&.'?!()>%*$=*!+<*!

()+*%)$+(&)$'!2(=(A('(+-!&@!+<*!>&/7$)(*=!()2&'2*?J!_%&6$%(+*!$)?!5$A'*!;('(*%*!R$%(+*!\5;R]!$%*!+4&!

45

()(+($+(2*=! ()!E*=+! M@%(>$! &@! 7%&1*>+=! $>+(2*! ()! \$/&)F! &+<*%=]! 6)&4'*?F*! =<$%()FD! <$%/&)(l()F!

7%&?.>+!=+$)?$%?=!$)?!7%&/&+()F!$)?!>&&%?()$+()F!+<*!=<*$!A.=()*==!\C'($=!,J!*+!$'D!899c]J!

!

iJc! #&)>'.=(&)=!$)?!?(=>.==(&)!

!

5<*! >&/7$)(*=! $%*! =/$''D! &A2(&.='-! +<*%*! $%*! &7+(&)=! @&%! F%&4+<! A.+! +<*)! +<*! ()! 7%*2(&.=!

7$%$F%$7<!/*)+(&)*?!>&)=+%$()+=!<$2*!+&!A*!@$>*?!$)?!&77&%+.)(+(*=!<$2*!+&!A*!.+('(=*?J!

!

V+! (=! ?(@@(>.'+! +&! F$+<*%! %*'($A'*! Y.$)+(+$+(2*! ?$+$J! 5%$?*%=! $%*! )&+! 2*%-! *$=-! ()! F(2()F! &.+!

()@&%/$+(&)!$A&.+!Y.$)+(+(*=!$)?!7%(>*=J!_$%+'-!A*>$.=*!&@! +<*!>&/7*+(+(&)! ()! +<(=!A.=()*==!A.+!

)&+!+<$+!/$)-!%*>&%?=!$A&.+!Y.$)+(+(*=!+%$?*?!$)?!7%(>*=!()!?(@@*%*)+!-*$%=!$%*!6*7+!$=!4*''J!

!

5<*!7%&?.>+(&)!&@!>&=/*+(>=!>$)!A*!()>%*$=*?!+&!$!<(F<*%!'*2*'D!A&+<!&)!+<*!Y.$)+(+$+(2*!=(?*!$=!

&)!+<*!Y.$'(+$+(2*!=(?*J!!

_%&?.>*%=! &@! =<*$! >&=/*+(>=! $%*! '&&6()F! @&%! /$%6*+! @&%! +<*(%! 7%&?.>+=! $A%&$?J! V+! >&.'?! A*!

()+*%*=+()F! V! +<*-!4&.'?! @&>.=!/&%*!&)! +<*!/$%6*+! ()!N<$)$!$)?!E*=+!M@%(>$J! C=7*>($''-! F(2()F!

$++*)+(&)!+&!>&)=./*%!$4$%*)*==!@&%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!$)?!>%*$+()F!$!/$%6*+!$%*!><$''*)F*=!+<$+!+<*!

7%&?.>*%=! $)?! +%$?*%=! <$2*! +&! @$>*J! 5<*%*! 4&.'?! A*! '*==! +%$)=$>+(&)! >&=+=! ()2&'2*?! $)?! +<*!

7%&?.>*%=! $)?! +%$?*%=! >&.'?! <$2*! /&%*! A$%F$()()F! 7&4*%! ()! >&/7$%(=&)! 4(+<! +<*! /$%6*+=! ()!

4*=+*%)!>&.)+%(*=J!5<(=!>$)!>%*$+*!<(F<*%!7%&@(+!&)!+<*(%!7%&?.>+=J!!

!

M)! (/7&%+$)+! Y.*=+(&)! (=! 4<*+<*%! +<*! 4&/*)! ()! +<*! )&%+<! &@! N<$)$! >$)! A*! ()2&'2*?! ()! +<*!

7%&?.>+(&)!&@!<(F<!Y.$'(+-!>&=/*+(>!7%&?.>+=J!M)?!%*'$+*?!+&!+<(=S!4<$+!$%*!+<*!&77&%+.)(+(*=!@&%!

4&/*)!()!+<*!)&%+<!+&!()>%*$=*!+<*(%!=+$)?$%?!&@!'(2()F!+<%&.F<!+%$?*!()!@()(=<*?!=<*$!\>&=/*+(>]!

7%&?.>+=e!

!

!

46

#<$7+*%!h! C07&%+*%=!&@!@()(=<*?!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!

!

hJf! V)+%&?.>+(&)!

5<*!Q!/$1&%!*07&%+*%=!&@!=<*$!$%*!T.%6()$!;$=&D!,$'(D!N<$)$D!H(F*%($D!#&+*!?kV2&(%*D!T*)()D!5&F&!

$)?!N.()*$L#&)$6%-J!V)!+$A'*!hJf!$)!&2*%2(*4!>$)!A*!@&.)?!&)!+<*!*=+(/$+*?!*07&%+!+&))$F*=!&@!

+<*=*!>&.)+%(*=J!5<*=*!)./A*%=!$%*!*=+(/$+*?!A-!_J!3&2*++!$)?!4*%*!7%*=*)+*?!&)!X.'-!+<*!8Q+<D!

899QJ!g!H(F*%($!(=!+<*!'$%F*=+!7%&?.>*%!&@!=<*$!).+=!A.+!>&)+%(A.+*=!%*'$+(2*'-!&)'-!'(++'*!+&!4&%'?!

*07&%+=!?.*!+&!<*$2-!?&/*=+(>!?*/$)?!\5*><)&=*%2*]J!5<*!/$()!/$%6*+!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!()!+<*!

><&>&'$+*!$)?!2*F*+$A'*!@$+=!()?.=+%-J!V)!+<*!-*$%!8999!+<*!C.%&7*$)!7$%'($/*)+!?*>(?*?!+&!$''&4!

$!/$0(/./!&@!hr!2*F*+$A'*!@$+!$??(+(2*=!+&!A*!.=*?!()!7'$>*!&@!>&>&$!A.++*%!()!+<*!7%&?.>+(&)!&@!

><&>&'$+*J!5<*!7&==(A('(+-!+&!.=*!=<*$!$=!$!#TC!\>&>&$!A.++*%!*Y.(2$'*)+]!<$=!A**)!$)!(/7&%+$)+!

@$>+&%!()!+<*!()>%*$=*?!?*/$)?!@&%!=<*$!&2*%!+<*!'$=+!-*$%=J!!

V)! %*>*)+! -*$%=! +<*! ?*/$)?! @&%! ).+=! ?&.A'*?! 4<('*! +<*! ?*/$)?! @&%! A.++*%! =+$-*?! +<*! =$/*!

\K*6$@]J!

5<*! ()+*%)$+(&)$'! ?*/$)?! @&%! =<*$! A.++*%! ()! >&=/*+(>! 7%&?.>+=! (=! %*>*)+'-! F%&4()FD! +<*! T&?-!

K<&7!<$=!$!'()*!4(+<!=<*$!A.++*%!7%&?.>+=!A.+!()!/$)-!7%&?.>+=!=<*$!(=!$)!\<(??*)]!()F%*?(*)+!$=!

4*''J!5<*!/$%6*+!@&%!>&=/*+(>!7.%7&=*=!&@!=<*$!(=!F%&4()F!A.+!=+(''!=/$''!$)?!.)>*%+$()!>&/7$%*?!

+&!+<*!@&&?!()?.=+%-!\N%*(FD!899c]J!K+$+<$>&=!F(2*=!$)!&7+(/(=+(>!2(*4!&)!+<*!?*/$)?!@%&/!+<*!GK!

@&%! <(F<LY.$'(+-! =<*$! A.++*%! >&=/*+(>! 7%&?.>+=! \K+$+<$>&=D! 899i]J! #&)=./*%! $4$%*)*==! (=! $)!

(/7&%+$)+!@$>+&%!()!+<(=!()>%*$=()F!?*/$)?J!!

!

5$A'*!hJf!L!C07&%+!+&))$F*=!&@!=<*$!).+=!\_J!3&2*++D!899Q]!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

hJ8! #$+*F&%(*=!&@!*07&%+*%=!

C07&%+*%=! >$)! A*! >$+*F&%(l*?! '&&6()F! $+! ?(@@*%*)+! $=7*>+=J! 5<*! +4&!/$()! =.A1*>+=! +<$+! 4(''! A*!

?(=>.==*?! ()! +<(=! 7$%$F%$7<! $%*! +<*! +-7*! &@! 7%&?.>+! \A.'6! A.++*%D! A.'6! 6*%)*'! 2*%=.=! @()(=<*?!

7%&?.>+=]!+<$+!(=!+%$?*?D!$)?!=*>&)?!+<*!=(l*!&@!+<*!>&/7$)-!$)?!+<*%*@&%*!$=!4*''!+<*!()@'.*)>*!

()!+<*!/$%6*+J!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!g!At the national workshop day of the national association of shea nut farmers processors and buyers of Ghana. This

meeting had the topic ‘shea nut in Ghana, the way forward’.!!

! #&.)+%-! C07&%+!+&))$F*!!

\()!f999!/+]!

f! T.%6()$!;$=&! d9!

8! ,$'(! d9!

g! N<$)$! h9!

i! H(F*%($! i9!

h! #&+*!?kV2&(%*! g9!

c! T*)()! 89!

d! 5&F&! fh!

Q! N.()*$L#&)$6%-! d!

47

M>;>B!H?/$!03!/+0)'2(!

K<*$!(=!/$()'-!*07&%+*?!()!+<*!@&%/!&@!=<*$!6*%)*'D!$!=/$''*%!7$%+!(=!*07&%+*?!$=!A.'6!K<*$!A.++*%!

$)?!$!2*%-!=/$''!7$%+!(=!*07&%+*?!()!+<*!@&%/!&@!@()(=<*?!7%&?.>+=J!M)!&2*%2(*4!&@!+<*!Y.$)+(+(*=!

A.++*%!2=!6*%)*'!@&%!+<*!7*%(&?!f::8!O!8998!>$)!A*!@&.)?!()!+<*!=*>&)?!%*7&%+!&@!+<*!EM5B!&)!

+<*!=<*$!2$'.*!><$()!\3&2*++D!899i]J!

M>>&%?()F!+&!=&/*!+%$?*%=!+<*!4*(F<+!7*%!A$F!?(@@*%=!()!A*+4**)!?(@@*%*)+!>&.)+%(*=J!V)!N<$)$!$!

A$F!)&%/$''-!4*(F<=!Qh6F!A.+!()!T.%6()$!;$=&!(+!4*(F<=!Qc!6FJ!H&!=+$)?$%?J!

5<*!+(/*!&@!A.-()F!$)?!=*''()F!(=!2*%-!(/7&%+$)+!()!+<*!=<*$!A.=()*==S!*=7*>($''-!4(+<!+<*!6*%)*'=J!

5<*! '&)F*%! $! ).+! (=! =+&%*?! +<*! ?%(*%! $)?! '(F<+*%! +<*-! $%*J! I*$'! =$'*=! =+$%+! $+! +<*! *)?! &@! X.'-n!

A*F())()F! &@! M.F.=+J! T.-()F! '$+*%! (=! A*++*%! A*>$.=*! +<*! 4$+*%! >&)+*)+! (=! '&4*%D! +<*%*@&%*! (+!

4*(F<=!'*==!$)?!7%(>*!(=!?*+*%/()*?!A-!4*(F<+!=&!(+!(=!><*$7*%J!

!

P)*! &@! +<*! *07*>+$+(&)=! ()! +<(=! %*=*$%><! 4$=! +<$+! <(F<*%! /$%F()=! >&.'?! A*! *$%)*?! A-! +<*!

7%&?.>*%=!&@!A.++*%!A-!=*''()F!+<*(%!7%&?.>+!+&!?(@@*%*)+!/$%6*+=J!T.+!$>+.$''-!+<*!7%(>*=!%*>*(2*?!

@&%! =*''()F! A.++*%! +&! +<*! @&&?! 2*%=.=! +<*! >&=/*+(>=! ()?.=+%-! $%*! +<*! =$/*J!M??()F! 2$'.*! ()! +<*!

@&%/! &@! 7%&>*==()F! +<*! A.++*%! ()+&! >&=/*+(>! 7%&?.>+=! ?&*=! <$2*! $?2$)+$F*=! A.+! ?&*=)k+!

=7*>(@(>$''-!()>%*$=*!+<*!/&)*-!*$%)*?!A-!+<*!4&/*)!4<&!$%*!7%&>*==()F!+<*!).+=!()+&!A.++*%J!!

!

M>;>;!",_$!03!(+%)$+1!

3&&6()F! $+! +<*! =(l*! &@! >&/7$)(*=! +<*-! >$)! A*! >$+*F&%(l*?! $=!4*''J! T*>$.=*! &@! +<*! @&>.=! &@! +<*!

%*=*$%><!(=!&)!+<*!*)+%*7%*)*.%($'!=7(%(+!&@!=/$''!=>$'*!$>+&%=D!=&/*!&@!+<*!'$%F*%!=(l*?!+%$?*%=!4(''!

A*!=<&%+'-!/*)+(&)*?!$)?!+<*!@&>.=!4(''!A*!&)!+<*!=/$''*%!+%$?*%=J!

3$%F*%!=(l*?!A.-*%=!&@!A.++*%!&@+*)!4&%6!4(+<!/(??'*!/*)!+<$+!A.-!$)?!>&''*>+! @&%!+<*/!$+! +<*!

'&>$'!/$%6*+=!$)?!+%$)=7&%+!(+!+&!+<*!<$%A&.%!()!5*/$J!!

C0$/7'*=! &@! '$%F*! *07&%+*%=! $%*!N<$)$! =7*>($'+-! @$+=! ()?.=+%(*=! 3+?J!4<(><! ()! >&&7*%$+(&)!4(+<!

MU,!E('/$%!%*>*)+'-!=*+!.7!$!=<*$!7%&>*==()F!7'$)+!()!5*/$J!5<*-!=*''!=<*$!=+*$%()D!$!2*F*+$A'*!

@$+! +<$+! (=!$)! ()F%*?(*)+! @&%! >&)@*>+(&)$%-! $)?!7$=+%(*=D! $)?! =<*$!&'*()D!4<(><! (=! '(Y.(?!$+! %&&/!

+*/7*%$+.%*!$)?!4&%6=!4*''!@&%!'(Y.(?!=&$7=!$)?!>%*$/=D!$)?!*?(A'*!@$+!\MU,!4*A=(+*]J!M)&+<*%!

*0$/7'*!(=!N<$)$!).+=D!'&>$+*?!()!5*><(/$)!\()!+<*!M=<$)+(!%*F(&)D!+<*!>*)+%*!&@!N<$)$]J!!

5<*!=/$''*%!$!>&/7$)-!+<*!/&%*!'(6*'-!(+!(=!+<$+!+<*!4&/*)!<$2*!$!'(2*'(<&&?!$77%&$><!()=+*$?!&@!

$! A.=()*==! $77%&$><J! 5<*-! &@+*)! '$>6! $! '&)F! +*%/! 7'$))()F! $)?! >&=+LA*)*@(+! >$'>.'$+(&)=! $%*!

<$%?'-!?&)*!4<(><!/$6*=!+<$+!+<*-!*2*)!&@+*)!?&)k+!6)&4!(@!4<$+!+<*-!$%*!?&()F!(=!7%&@(+$A'*J!!

N<$)$($)! +%$?*%=! @()?! (+! <$%?! +&! @()?! A.-*%=! @&%! +<*(%! =<*$! 7%&?.>+=J! U.%()F! +<*! %*=*$%><! +<*!

Y.*=+(&)! &)! <&4! +&! @()?! A.-*%=! $)?! >&)+$>+=! ()! +<*! CG! $)?! GK! 4$=! %*F.'$%'-! <*$%?J! K+$A'*!

?*/$)?!@&%!+<*!7%&?.>+=!(=!(/7&%+$)+!@&%!+<*!=.%2(2$'!&@!+<*(%!A.=()*==J!

!

_%(>*=!@&%!+<*!A.++*%!$%*!&@+*)!+<*!=$/*!@&%!$''!Y.$'(+(*=!&@!A.++*%J!T.-*%=!&@+*)!F(2*!+<*!7%(>*!&@!

F%$?*!g!@&%!$''! +<*!A.++*%!+<*-!A.-S!$>+.$''-!A.++*%!&@!F%$?*!f!=<&.'?!F*+!$!<(F<*%!7%(>*!A.+!+<*!

Y.$)+(+(*=!&@! +<(=!<(F<!Y.$'(+-!A.++*%!$%*!2*%-! =/$''J! 5<(=! (=!.=*?!$=!/$()!$%F./*)+! +&!F(2*!&)*!

7%(>*!()=+*$?!&@!F(2()F!?(@@*%*)+!7%(>*=!@&%!?(@@*%*)+!Y.$'(+-!'*2*'=J!!

!

M)&+<*%!(==.*!(=!+<*!.)>'*$%(+-!$A&.+!+<*!/$%6*+S!+<*!7%(>*=!$)?!+<*!?*/$)?J!

! !

48

5<*%*! $%*! /$)-! +%$?*%=! ()! A.++*%S! =&/*! &@! +<*! >&/7$)(*=! =7&6*)! +&! $%*! K*6$@!

\444J=*6$@F<$)$J>&/]D! +<*! T&?-! =<&7D! K$2$))$! ;%.(+=! #&/7$)-D! T&=A*'D! *+>J! T.+! +<*! /$()!

()+*%*=+!@&%!+<(=!%*=*$%><!4$=!+&!?&!%*=*$%><!$/&)F!+<*!>&/7$)(*=!+<$+!$??!2$'.*!+&!+<*!A.++*%J!!

5<*!T&?-!K<&7! (=!$)!*0$/7'*!&@!$)!*07&%+*%!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!+<$+! (=!?&()F!>&//.)(+-!+%$?*!4(+<!

4&/*)!F%&.7=!()!+<*!H&%+<*%)!%*F(&)!&@!N<$)$J!T&?-!K<&7!(=!=&'?!+&!3kP%*$'!()!899c!A.+!(=!=+(''!

4&%6()F! .)?*%! +<*! )$/*! T&?-! K<&7J! 5<*=*!4&/*)! 7%&?.>*! A.++*%! ()! %*@()*?! @&%/J! 5<*! T&?-!

=<&7! (=! (/7&%+()F! +<*(%! =<*$!A.++*%! @%&/!N<$)$J!5<*-!=+$%+*?!$%&.)?!f::d\T&?-!K<&7D!4*A=(+*!

899:]D! +<*!H&%+<*%)!C/7&4*%/*)+!M==&>($+(&)!\HCM]!>&&%?()$+*=!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!=<(7/*)+!@&%!

+<*!T&?-! K<&7! ()+*%)$+(&)$'J!HCM!A.-=!).+=! @&%! +<*!4&/*)!4<&!7%&?.>*! +<*!A.++*%! @&%! +<*/J!

5<*%*! $%*! ff!4&/*)! F%&.7=! ()2&'2*?! ()>'.?()F! $77%&0(/$+*'-! ih9!4&/*)J! 5<*! )$/*! @&%! +<(=!

>&/7'*+*!F%&.7!(=!5GKCEMD!+<*-!$%*!)&+!@&%>*?!+&!=*''!+&!+<*!T&?-!K<&7!&)'-!A.+!$=!4*''!$''&4*?!

+&! =*''! +&! &+<*%! A.-*%=J! 5<*! 7%(>*! 7$(?! @&%! +<*! A.++*%! (=! ?*>(?*?! A-! +<*! A&?-! =<&7! $)?! (=!

7%*?*+*%/()*?J!N*)*%$''-!+<*!T&?-!=<&7!7$-=!/&%*!+<$)!+<*!/$%6*+!7%(>*D!<&4!*0$>+'-!+<*!7%(>*!

7$(?!@&%!+<*!A.++*%! (=!?*+*%/()*?!(=!)&+!>'*$%J!5<*!4&/*)!$%*!+%$()*?!()!7%&?.>()F!F&&?!Y.$'(+-!

A.++*%J!5<*!4&/*)!/$6*!=&$7!$=!4*''!A.+!?&!)&+!\-*+]!*07&%+!+<(=!A*>$.=*!(+!(=!/&%*!?(@@(>.'+D!(+!

<$=! +&! F&! +<%&.F<!/$)-!/&%*! ><$))*'=J! HCM! =*)?=! +<*! A.++*%! +&! +<*! W$$)=*! P'(*! I$@@()$?*%(1!

\WPID!$)!&('!%*@()*%-!()!+<*!H*+<*%'$)?=]!$)?!$@+*%!+<$+!(+! (=!+%$)=7&%+*?!+&!+<*!T&?-!K<&7!()!+<*!

GRJ! N*+%$?*!N<$)$D! VH#! \U*2*'&7/*)+! $)?!/$%6*+()F! &@! +%$?(+(&)$'! =&$7! @&%! +<*!E*=+!M@%(>$)!

/$%6*+]! (=! $%%$)F()F! +<*! +%$)=7&%+! &@! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%J!

5<*!Y.$)+(+-!+<$+!+<*!T&?-!K<&7!A.-=!(=!$77%&0!899!+&))*=!7*%!-*$%!\(+!(=!*07&%+*?!()!>&)+$()*%=!

4<(><! *$><! >$)! >&)+$()! fQ! +&))*=! &@! A.++*%]J! ;&%/$''-! *2*%-! &@! +<*! ff! F%&.7=! ?*'(2*%=! *$><! f!

+&))*!&@!A.++*%!$)?!+<*!T&?-!K<&7!4&.'?!A.-!fQ!+&))*=!7*%!/&)+<J!T.+!$>>&%?()F!+&!+<*!4&/*)!

+<*-!>&.'?!7%&?.>*!$!'&+!/&%*S!$>>&%?()F!+&!+<*/!$)!*=+(/$+(&)!4$=!+<$+!+<*-!>&.'?!7%&?.>*!hi!

+&))*=!7*%!/&)+<J!5<*!?*/$)?!(=!)&+!$'4$-=!7%*?(>+$A'*!A.+!$>>&%?()F!+&!U$2(?!,*)=$<!&@!HCM!

+<*! 4&/*)! )*2*%! @$('*?! ?*'(2*%()F! +<*! A.++*%J! 5<*-! )*2*%! +*=+*?! 4<$+! +<*! >$7$>(+-! (=! &@! +<*!

4&/*)! $)?! (+! (=! <$%?! +&! *=+(/$+*! 4<$+! +<*(%! /$0(/./! 7%&?.>+(&)! >&.'?! A*J! 5<*! $/&.)+!

?*/$)?*?! ?(@@*%=! +<%&.F<! +<*! -*$%S! *JFJ! ()! U*>*/A*%! \A*>$.=*! &@! #<%(=+/$=]! +<*! ?*/$)?! (=!

<(F<*%!$)?!()!&+<*%!7$%+=!&@!+<*!-*$%!(+!(=!'&4*%J!!

!

K*6$@! (=! $)! M@%(>$)! 7%&?.>*%! $)?! *07&%+*%! &@! =<*$! ).+=! $)?! =7*>($'(l*?! ()! +%$?(+(&)$''-! /$?*!

.)%*@()*?! =<*$! A.++*%! \444J=*6$@F<$)$J>&/]J! V)! $.F.=+! 899Q! $! =<*$! A.++*%! 2(''$F*! (=! &7*)*?!

4(+<! +<*! 7.%7&=*! +&! 7%&>*==! 7%*/(./! Y.$'(+-D! 7.%*! =<*$! A.++*%! 7%&?.>+=J! K*6$@! (=! +<*%*A-!

=+%*==()F!+<$+!()?.=+%($'!7%&>*==()F!+*)?=!+&!$'+*%!+<*!2*%-!+%.*!)$+.%*!&@!=<*$D!$=!$'=&!=+$+*?!A-!

M??$Y.$-! \M??$Y.$-D! 899i]J! 5<*-! .=*! +<(=! $=! =*''()F! $%F./*)+! @&%! +<*(%! =*/(L/*><$)(>$''-!

7%&>*==*?!=<*$!A.++*%J!

!

hJg! N&2*%)/*)+!A&?(*=!()2&'2*?!()!*07&%+!&@!=<*$!

5<*!F&2*%)/*)+!&@!N<$)$! (=! ()2&'2*?! +<%&.F<!$!)./A*%!&@!?*7$%+/*)+=S! ()! +<(=!7$%$F%$7<! +<*!

@&.%!/&=+!(/7&%+$)+!&@@(>*=!()2&'2*?!()!+<*!+%$?*!&@!=<*$!4(''!A*!?(=>.==*?Z!5<*!#&>&$!A&$%?D!+<*!

/()(=+%-! &@! +%$?*! $)?! ()?.=+%-D! +<*! N<$)$! =+$)?$%?=! A&$%?! $)?! +<*! N<$)$! *07&%+! 7%&/&+(&)!

>&.)>('J!!

!

T%*)?$!#<$'@()!<$=!$/&)F!&+<*%!+<()F=!4%(++*)!$A&.+!+<*!()@'.*)>*!&@!+<*!F&2*%)/*)+!()!+<*!=<*$!

()?.=+%-! ()! N<$)$J! C=7*>($''-! +<%&.F<! +<*! >&>&$! A&$%?! +<*-! <$2*! 7'$-*?! $)! (/7&%+$)+! %&'*D! +&!

49

.)?*%=+$)?! +<*! >.%%*)+! =(+.$+(&)! A*++*%! (+! (=! %*>&//*)?*?! +&! %*$?! <*%! $%+(>'*!,$%6*+! %*@&%/=!

$)?!+<*!=+$+*!\#<$'@()D!f::c]J!K<*!(=!$'=&!&)*!&@!+<*!@*4!4%(+*%=!4<&!4%&+*!$!A&&6!$A&.+!+<*!=<*$!

()?.=+%-!\#<$'@()D!899i]J!

hJgJf! #&>&$!T&$%?!

5<*! >&>&$! A&$%?! (=! %*=7&)=(A'*! @&%! >&>&$! $=! 4*''! $=! @&%! =<*$! $)?! >$=<*4J! K<*$! (=! F%&4)! $)?!

/$()'-!7%&>*==*?!()!+<*!)&%+<!$)?!>&>&$!*=7*>($''-!()!+<*!=&.+<!$)?!/(??'*!&@!N<$)$J!!

5<*! >&>&$! A&$%?! <$=! =*2*%$'! &@@(>*=! ()!N<$)$! A.+! +<*!/&=+! )&%+<*%)! &@@(>*! (=! A$=*?! ()! R./$=(!

\4<(><!(=!$)!$77%&0(/$+*!c!<&.%=!?%(2*!@%&/!5$/$'*]J!5<(=!?(=+$)>*!(=!$!7%&A'*/!$>>&%?()F!+&!+<*!

7*&7'*!()!+<*!)&%+<D!!

5<*!>&>&$!%*=*$%><!()=+(+.+*!&@!N<$)$!\#IVN]!(=!7$%+!&@!+<*!>&>&$!A&$%?!$)?!(=!?&()F!%*=*$%><!&)!

=<*$!$=!4*''J!#IVN!<$=!$!%*=*$%><!>*)+%*!()!4(+<!$!=<*$!).%=*%-!()!T&'*!\H&%+<!E*=+!&@!N<$)$]!$)?!

+<*%*!(=!$!%*=*$%><!>*)+%*!()!H*4!5$@&J!T&'*!<$=!A**)!2(=(+*?!$=!7$%+!&@!+<(=!@(*'?!%*=*$%><S!+<*%*!

4$=! $! ).%=*%-!4<*%*! =*2*%$'! *07*%(/*)+=! $%*! A*()F! ?&)*! A-! %*=*$%><*%=!4(+<! F%$@+()F! A.+! )&!

@.%+<*%!%*=*$%><!4(+<!%*=7*>+!+&!+<*!+%$?*!&%!7%&>*==()F!&@!+<*!7%&?.>+J!5<*%*!(=!$!A.('?()F!$+!+<*!

%*=*$%><!>*)+%*!4<(><! (=!.)?*%!>&)=+%.>+(&)!$)?! (=! =.77&=*?! +&!A*>&/*!$!7%&>*==()F!>*)+%*!&@!

=<*$!4<*%*!$=!4*''! %*=*$%><! (=!7'$))*?!+&!A*!?&)*!$A&.+!/$6()F!>&=/*+(>!7%&?.>+=! @%&/!=<*$!

\=&$7=D! >%*$/=! $)?! '&+(&)=! *+>J]! T*=(?*=! +<(=! +<*! <*$?! &@@(>*! &@! #IVN! V=! ()! H*4! 5$@&! \*$=+*%)!

N<$)$]!A.+!+<$+!&)*!(=!)&+!2(=(+*?!?.%()F!+<(=!@(*'?!%*=*$%><J!H&%!$+!+<*!=+$+(&)!()!T&'*!)&%!$+!+<*!

<*$?!&@@(>*! ()!M>>%$! +<*!7*&7'*!4&%6()F!$+! +<*!#&>&$!A&$%?!>&.'?)k+! +*''!4<$+!6()?!&@! %*=*$%><!

$A&.+!=<*$!(=!?&)*!()!H*4!5$@&D!$=!4*''!$=!4<$+!<$77*)=!4(+<!+<*!%*=.'+=J!

!

5<*!#&>&$!A&$%?!6**7=!%*>&%?=!$A&.+!Y.$)+(+(*=!7%&?.>*?!$)?!+%$?*!&@!>&>&$!$)?!(=!(/7&%+$)+!()!

=*++()F!+<*!7%(>*=!+<$+!+<*!7%&?.>*%=!F*+!@&%!+<*!>&>&$J!B&4*2*%D!()!=<*$!+<*!A&$%?!(=!'*==!$>+(2*J!

5<*-!<$2*!%*>&%?=!$A&.+!).+=D!-*+!)&!%*>&%?=!$%*!6*7+!&@! +<*!A.++*%J!M)?!+<*!?$+$!&)!+<*!).+=!

&)'-!>&)+$()=!?$+$!&@!+<*!Y.$)+(+(*=!=<(77*?!+<%&.F<!5*/$!O!)&!%*>&%?=!$A&.+!+%$?*!&2*%!'$)?J!

V)!+<*!)&%+<!/$)-!>&/7'$()+=!$%*!<*$%?!$A&.+!+<*!#&>&$!A&$%?S!$>>&%?()F!+&!+<*!7*&7'*! ()!+<*!

)&%+<! +<*! #&>&$! A&$%?! &)'-! 7$-=! $++*)+(&)! &)! +<*! #&>&$! /$%6*+! $)?! =<&.'?! +<*%*@&%*! )&+!

%*7%*=*)+!+<*!=<*$!).+!7%&?.>*%=J!,$)-!7*&7'*!()!+<*!)&%+<!$%*D!()!@$>+D!()!@$2&.%!&@!=*++()F!.7!$!

=<*$!A&$%?J!!

!

N<$)$!(=!&)*!&@!+<*!'$%F*=+!>&>&$!7%&?.>()F!\$)?!*07&%+()F]!>&.)+%(*=J!#&>&$!(=!/$()'-!7%&?.>*?!

()! +<*! =&.+<!$)?! ()! >*)+%$'!N<$)$J! 5<*! 2*F*+$A'*! @$+! ()! =<*$! ).+=! (=! .=*?! ()! +<*!7%&?.>+(&)!&@!

>$>$&! A.++*%! *Y.(2$'*)+=! \#TCk=]! $)?! .=*?! $=! >&>&$! A.++*%! (/7%&2*%! \#TV]D! +<(=! (=! $! ><*$7!

=.A=+(+.+*!@&%!>&>&$!A.++*%J!5<*!7%(>*=!&@!>&>&$!$)?!=<*$!$%*!+<*%*@&%*!'()6*?!+&!*$><!&+<*%!\;&'?D!

899Q]J!5<(=! (=! +<*!/$()!%*$=&)! @&%! +<*!>&/7*+(+(&)!A*+4**)! +<*!>&>&$!$)?!=<*$!7%&?.>*%=!$)?!

+<*!>&/7'*0(+-!+<$+!+<*!>&>&$!A&$%?!<$=!+&!%*7%*=*)+!A&+<!()+*%*=+=J!!

hJgJ8! ,()(=+%-!&@!5%$?*!$)?!()?.=+%-!\,&5(]!

G)?*%!+<*!/()(=+%-!&@!+%$?*!$)?!()?.=+%-!+<*%*!$%*!$!)./A*%!&@!A&$%?=!4<&!*0*>.+*!+<*!7&'(>-!&@!

+<*!,&5(J!5<&=*!A&$%?=!$%*!+<*!N<$)$!*07&%+!7%&/&+(&)!>&.)>('D!+<*!N<$)$!=+$)?$%?=!A&$%?!$)?!

+<*!HTKKV!\H$+(&)$'!T&$%?!@&%!K/$''!K>$'*!V)?.=+%(*=]J!;&%!+<*!*07&%+!+<*!NC_#!$)?!NKT!$%*!/&=+!

(/7&%+$)+!$)?!4(''!A*!?(=>.==*?!()!+<*!@&''&4()F!7$%$F%$7<=J!!

5<*!,&5(! (=! ?*2*'&7()F! $! )$+(&)$'! =+%$+*F-! &)! =<*$J! V+! <$=! =**)! +<*! ()>%*$=()F! ()+*%*=+! ()! $)?!

?*/$)?! @&%! =<*$! $)?! +<*%*@&%*!4$)+=! +&! =+(/.'$+*! +<(=! A.=()*==!/&%*J! 5<*! 7'$)!4$=! +<$+! +<(=!

)$+(&)$'!=+%$+*F-!4&.'?!A*!>'*$%!A-!P>+&A*%!899Q!A.+!=&!@$%!)&!@()$'!7$7*%!<$=!A**)!$2$('$A'*J!!

50

hJgJg! N<$)$!*07&%+!7%&/&+(&)!>&.)>('!\NC_#]!

V)!N<$)$!+<*!NC_#!(=!%*=7&)=(A'*!@&%!%*>&%?()F!Y.$)+(+(*=!+%$?*?!&2*%!+<*!A&$%?*%=J!5<*!@(F.%*=!

+<$+!+<*-!<$2*!$%*!Y.$)+(+(*=!&@!).+=!=<(77*?!+<%&.F<!+<*!<$%A&.%!&@!5*/$J!K&!+<*!=$/*!=(+.$+(&)!

$=!$+!+<*!#&>&$!A&$%?S!+<*%*!$%*!)&!)./A*%=!$2$('$A'*!&@!).+=!+%$?*?!&2*%!+<*!'$)?!A&$%?*%=!+&!

5&F&D!T*)()D!T.%6()$!;$=&!$)?!#&+*!UkV2&(%*J!T*>$.=*!T.%6()$!;$=&! (=! '$)?'&>6*?!/$)-!).+=!$%*!

>&/()F!@%&/!T.%6()$!;$=&!&2*%!'$)?!+&!+<*!<$%A&.%!@%&/!4<*%*!+<*!).+=!$%*!=<(77*?D!=&!+<*!?$+$!

@%&/!+<*!NC_#!(=!)&+!%*7%*=*)+$+(2*!@&%!+<*!Y.$)+(+-!N<$)$!).+=!*07&%+*?J!!

5<*! N<$)$! C07&%+! _%&/&+(&)! #&.)>('! >&.'?! 7'$-! $!/&%*! >%.>($'! %&'*! ()!/&A('(l()F! 7*&7'*! 4<&!

4$)+!+&!=<$%*!+<*(%!6)&4'*?F*!$)?!*07*%(*)>*!4(+<!&+<*%=!()!&%?*%!+&!()>%*$=*!+<*!*07&%+!&@!=<*$!

A.++*%!@%&/!N<$)$J!

M>=>K! -#%&%!1(%&)%+)1!*0%+)!\-"J]!

5<*!NKT! (=! %*=7&)=(A'*! @&%! +<*! F.$%$)+-! &@! +<*! Y.$'(+-! &@! +<*! 7%&?.>+=J! 5<(=! ()=+(+.+(&)! F(2*=! $!

>*%+(@(>$+*!@&%!*$><!7%&?.>+!+<$+! (=!>*%+(@(*?J!5<*%*! (=!$!=+$)?$%?!@&%! \.)%*@()*?]!=<*$!A.++*%! \NK!

8gQZ!899c]!$)?!$!=+$)?$%?!@&%!=<*$!6*%)*'!\UNK!Q8i!Z!899c]!\M77*)?(0!VVV!$)?!V`]J!V)!5$/$'*!+<*!

%*F(&)$'!NKT!&@@(>*!@&%!+<*!+<%**!)&%+<*%)!%*F(&)=!'&>$+*?D!+<(=!&@@(>*D!$=!4*''!$=!+<*!<*$?Y.$%+*%!

()!M>>%$D!<$=!A**)!2(=(+*?!?.%()F!+<(=!%*=*$%><J!M+!+<*!&@@(>*!()!5$/$'*!+<*%*!4$=!)&!=+$)?$%?!@&%!

=<*$!A.++*%!)&%!@&%!=<*$!6*%)*'!$2$('$A'*D!$'+<&.F<!$''!7%&?.>*%=!$)?!/$)-!+%$?*%=!$)?!*07&%+*%=!

&@! +<*=*! 7%&?.>+=! >$)! A*! @&.)?! ()! +<*! +<%**! )&%+<*%)! %*F(&)=J! M+! +<*! <*$?! &@@(>*! ()! M>>%$! +<*!

=+$)?$%?=!4*%*!$2$('$A'*D!+<*=*!=+$)?$%?=!*$><!)&%/$''-!>&=+!i9!N<#J!!

!

C07&%+*%=!<$2*! +&!<$2*!$)!*07&%+! >*%+(@(>$+*! +&!A*!$''&4*?! +&!*07&%+!7%&?.>+=! $=!4*''! $=! +&!A*!

$''&4*?! +&! =*''! +<*(%! 7%&?.>+! ()! N<$)$J! 5<*! 7%*/(=*=! $%*! ><*>6*?D! (@! +<(=! (=! &6! =$/7'*=! &@! +<*!

7%&?.>+=!4(''!A*!+$6*)!$)?!=*)+!+&!M>>%$!@&%!+*=+()FD!+<*!+&!A*!+*=+*?!>&/7&)*)+=! '(6*!/&(=+.%*!

>&)+*)+!$)?!;%**!;$++-!M>(?=! \;;M]! '*2*'!>$)!A*! @&.)?! ()!M77*)?(0! VVV! $)?! V`J!N*)*%$''-! (+! +$6*=!

$77%&0(/$+*'-!g!+&!i!4**6=!A*@&%*!+<*!%*=.'+=!$%*!>'*$%J!V@!+<*!%*=.'+=!$%*!F&&?!+<*!>&/7$)-!>$)!

A.-! +<*! >*%+(@(>$+*!4<(><! >&=+=! 889!N<#J! 5<(=! >*%+(@(>$+*! <$=! +&! A*! %*)*4*?! $)).$''-J! 5<*!NKT!

7*%(&?(>$''-!7*%@&%/=!.)*07*>+*?!()=7*>+(&)=!+&!><*>6!+<*!>&/7$)(*=J!!

!

hJi! M==(=+$)>*!+&!7%&?.>*%=!$)?!*07&%+*%=!!

M>>&%?()F!+&!$!)./A*%!&@!7*&7'*!()!+<*!()?.=+%-!=&/*!*0$/7'*=!&@!F&2*%)$)>*!=.77&%+!>&.'?!A*!

+<$+! +<*-! >&.'?! '()6! +<*! 7%&?.>*%=! +&! A.-*%=D! F(2*! @()$)>($'! <*'7! +<%&.F<! '&$)=D! A.('?()F!

4$%*<&.=*=!+&!=+&%*!7%&?.>+=D!()>%*$=*!+<*!Y.$'(+-!&@!+<*!%&$?=!+&!$>>*==!$''!$%*$=J!!

U.*! +&! +<*! '$>6! &@! F&2*%)$)>*! =.77&%+! ()! +<*! =<*$! ()?.=+%-! /$)-! HNPk=! $%*! $>+(2*! ()! +<(=!

()?.=+%-J! C0$/7'*=!&@!HNPk=!$%*! +<*! KH`!H*+<*%'$)?=!?*2*'&7/*)+!&%F$)(=$+(&)D! 5*><)&=*%2*D!

M@%(>$! 8999! )*+4&%6D! X$7$)! ()+*%)$+(&)$'! >&&7*%$+(&)! $F*)>-! \XV#M]D! +<*! G)(+*?! H$+(&)=!

U*2*'&7/*)+!_%&F%$//*!\GHU_]!$)?!+<*!M@%$=($!A.=()*==!>&.)>('J!5<*%*!$%*!/(0*?!*07*%(*)>*=!

4(+<!+<*=*!&%F$)(=$+(&)=J!

5*><)&=*%2*!\444J+*><)&=*%2*J&%F]!<*'7=!4&/*)!F%&.7=!A-!7%&2(?()F!+<*/!4(+<!/$><()*=!@&%!

/&%*! *@@(>(*)+! $)?! $?2$)>*?! +*><)(>$'! 7%&>*==()F! &@! +<*! A.++*%D! *JFJ! =&'$%! ?%-*%=D! =.)! A&('*%=D!

>%.=<*%=!$)?!%&=+*%=J!T*=(?*=! +<(=! +<*-!7%&2(?*!F%$)+=!$)?! '()6!4&/*)!+&!?&/*=+(>!$)?! @&%*(F)!

/$%6*+=J! 5*><)&=*%2*! (+=*'@! (=! @.)?*?! A-! GKMVU! \G)(+*?! K+$+*=! MF*)>-! @&%! V)+*%)$+(&)$'!

U*2*'&7/*)+]J!V+!(=!$!=/$''!&%F$)(l$+(&)J!P)*!&@!+<*!7%&A'*/=!+<$+!5*><)&=*%2*!>&/*=!$>%&==!(=!

+<$+! +<*!/$%6*+! @&%!A.++*%! (=! '&4D!)&%/$''-!A.-*%=!>&/*! +&!5*><)&=*%2*!$)?! +<*-! '()6! +<*/!+&!

51

&)*!&%!/&%*!4&/*)!F%&.7=J!5<*!4&/*)!7%&?.>*!&)!?*/$)?J!U(@@*%*)>*=!()!Y.$'(+-!'*2*'!&@!A&+<!

+<*!).+=!$=!+<*!A.++*%!$%*!$!7%&A'*/D!+<(=!>$)!<$2*!?(@@*%*)+!>$.=*=J!CJFJ!).+=!+<$+!$%*!?(%*>+'-!=.)!

?%(*?!F(2*!'&4*%!Y.$'(+-!+<$)!4<*)!$!=&'$%!?%-*%!(=!.=*?J!T.+!$!=&'$%!?%-*%!>&=+=!/&)*-!$)?!*2*)!

4<*)!(+!(=!$2$('$A'*!7*&7'*!?&)k+!$'4$-=!'(6*!+&!.=*!(+!A*>$.=*!?%-()F!+<*!).+=!()!+<*!=.)!(=!+$6()F!

'*==!+(/*!\$>>&%?()F!+&!=&/*!&@!+<*!()+*%2(*4**=]J!!

!

M!'$>6!()!+<*!HNP!=*>+&%!()!N<$)$!(=!+<$+!+<*%*!(=!)&!)*+4&%6S!+<*-!$%*!)&+!=+%.>+.%$''-!'()6*?!4(+<!

*$><!&+<*%D!+<(=!<$=!+<*!%*=.'+!+<$+!+<*!4<**'!(=!()2*)+*?!/&%*!+<$)!&)>*!A-!=*2*%$'!HNPk=!4<(><!

(=!)&+!*@@(>(*)+!$)?!+<.=!.))*>*==$%('-!>&=+=!/&)*-!$)?!+(/*!$)?!&@+*)!F&*=!$+!+<*!*07*)=*!&@!+<*!

7%&?.>*%=J!

!

5<*!=<*$!()?.=+%-!(=!=+(''!/$()'-!$+!7*$=$)+!'*2*'D!+<$+!(=!$!%*$=&)!4<-!+<*!/$%F()=!$%*!&@+*)!'&4J!M!

7&==(A'*!=&'.+(&)!>&.'?!A*!+<$+!+<*!F&2*%)/*)+!=+*7=!()!$)?!$%%$)F*=!F.$%$)+**?!7%(>*=J!M)&+<*%!

&7+(&)! >&.'?! A*! $)! ()>%*$=*! &@! +<*! >&)=./7+(&)! $+! '&>$'! '*2*'S! +<(=! 4(''! ()>%*$=*! +<*! /$%6*+!

?*/$)?! $)?! (=! F&&?! @&%! +<*! *>&)&/-J! V+! /$6*=! +<*! N<$)$($)! +%$?*%=! /&%*! >&/7*+(+(2*! @&%!

@&%*(F)! A.-*%=D! >&.'?! ?*>%*$=*! .)*/7'&-/*)+! $)?! F(2*=!/&%*! =*>.%(+-! @&%! +<*! 7%&?.>*%=! +<$+!

+<*(%!7%&?.>+=!4(''!A*!=&'?D!*2*)!(@!+<*!()+*%)$+(&)$'!?*/$)?!(=!@'.>+.$+()FJ!,&%*!$A&.+!>&)=./*%!

7%*@*%*)>*=!()!N<$)$!>$)!A*!@&.)?!()!><$7+*%!cJ!

!

M)&+<*%!+-7*!&@!&%F$)(=$+(&)!=.77&%+()F!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!7%&?.>*%=!$)?!+%$?*%=!(=!+<*!E*=+!M@%(>$!

5%$?*!B.A!\EM5B]J!5<*!EM5B!=.77&%+=!*07&%+*%=!A-!F(2()F!4&%6=<&7=!$)?!=*/()$%=!$)?!F(2()F!

$==(=+$)>*!+&!1&()!+%$?*!@$(%=J!M)&+<*%!(/7&%+$)+!$>+(2(+-!(=!+<$+!+<*-!$%*!?&()F!%*=*$%><!$)?!&2*%!

+<*! '$=+! -*$%=! <$2*! 7.A'(=<*?! $! )./A*%! &@! %*7&%+=! .)?*%! +<*! =.A1*>+! �5<*! =<*$! A.++*%! 2$'.*!

><$()kJ!5<*=*!%*7&%+=!F(2*!.=*@.'! ()@&%/$+(&)!@&%!+%$?*%=!$)?!7%&>*==&%=!+&!*)<$)>*!F%&4+<!$)?!

7%&/&+(&)!&@!+<*(%!A.=()*==J!!

!

K+$+<$>&=! =+%*==*=! +<$+! @&%! /$%6*+! ?*2*'&7/*)+! (+! (=! (/7&%+$)+! +<$+! )&+! &)'-! >&)=./*%=! A.+!

*=7*>($''-! +<*! /$).@$>+.%*%=! &@! A&?-! $)?! <*$'+<! 7%&?.>+=! =<&.'?! A*! $77%&$><*?! \K+$+<$>&=D!

899i]J! 5<(=! (=! $)! (/7&%+$)+! &77&%+.)(+-D! $)! $>+(2*! /$%6*+()F! $77%&$><! >&.'?! A&&=+! +<*! =<*$!

/$%6*+!()!E*=+!M@%(>$J!!

!

hJh! P77&%+.)(+(*=!$)?!>&)=+%$()+=!!

M>>&%?()F!+&!+<*!()+*%2(*4*?!*07&%+*%=!&@!@()(=<*?!=<*$!7%&?.>+=D!$)!(/7&%+$)+!>&)=+%$()+!(=!+<$+!

+<*! 7%&?.>*%=! $)?! *07&%+*%=! <$2*! ?(@@(>.'+-! F*++()F! $>>*==! +&! A.-*%=D! *=7*>($''-!4<*)! +<*-! $%*!

&2*%=*$=J!!

!

"07$!/011,*4$!0//0+('&,(,$1!(0!0X$+207$!(#,1!20&1(+%,&(S!

! �N&()F!+&!+%$?*!@$(%=k!(=!$)!(/7&%+$)+!&77&%+.)(+-J!V+!(=!$)!(/7&%+$)+!4$-!+&!/**+!7*&7'*!

$)?! F*+! >&))*>+*?! +&! A.-*%=! &2*%=*$=J! V+! (=! $'=&! $)! &77&%+.)(+-! +&! =**! +<*! 7%&?.>+=! &@! +<*!

>&/7*+(+&%=!$)?! +<.=! =**!4<$+! (=!&)! +<*!/$%6*+D! >&/7$%*! +<*!?(@@*%*)+!7%&?.>+=! $)?!?(@@*%*)+!

4$-=!&@!/$%6*+()F!$)?!?(=>&2*%!+<*!F$7=!$)?!&77&%+.)(+(*=!@&%!)*4!7%&?.>+=J!

,$6()F!.=*!&@! +<*! �()+*%)*+k! (=!$)!&77&%+.)(+-D! =&/*!&@! +<*!>&/7$)(*=!<$2*!=+$%+*?!+&!?*2*'&7!

4*A=(+*=!$)?!7.+!+<*/!&)'()*J!C0$/7'*=!&@!+<&=*!>&/7$)(*=!$%*!C'*!$FA*!\<++7Znn*'*$FA*J>&/n]D!

52

M''! _.%*! H$+.%*! \<++7Znn$''7.%*)$+.%*J>&/n]! $)?! H$$=$6'*! \<++7Znn=<*$A.++*%F<J>&/n]J! V+! (=! )&+!

-*+!>'*$%!(@!+<(=!$77*$%$)>*!&)!+<*!()+*%)*+!4(''!F(2*!$!A&&=+!+&!*07&%+!)./A*%=J!!

!

V+!%*'$+(2*'-!+$6*=!$!'&+!&@!+(/*!$)?!$!'&+!&@!/&)*-!+&!F*+!$!>*%+(@(>$+*!@%&/!+<*!N<$)$!K+$)?$%?=!

T&$%?! +&! =*''! +<*! 7%&?.>+! ()!N<$)$! $)?! *07&%+! (+! $=!4*''J! V)! +&+$'! (+! >$)! +$6*! $! -*$%! +&! F*+! +<*!

)*>*==$%-! >*%+(@(>$+*! @%&/! +<*! NKT! +&! A*! $''&4*?! +&! =*''! $)?! *07&%+! +<*! 7%&?.>+J! 5<(=! @&%/! $!

>&)=+%$()+! @&%! *07&%+*%=! +&! <$)?'*! Y.(>6'-D! (+! >&.'?! A*! ()+*%*=+()F! +&! '&&6! $+! &77&%+.)(+(*=! +&!

%*?.>*!+<(=!7*%(&?J!

M! >&)=+%$()+! (=! +<$+! +<*%*!$%*!/$)-! =.A=+(+.+*=! >&/7*+()F!4(+<! =<*$! ()!?(@@*%*)+! =*>+&%=!4<*%*!

=<*$! (=!.=*?J!;&%!*0$/7'*!>&&6()F!&('=!.=*?! ()!N<$)$S!F%&.)?).+!&('D!7$'/).+!&('!$)?!@%-+&'!$%*!

>&/7*+()F!4(+<!=<*$!&('J!#&=/*+(>!7%&?.>+=!'(6*!>&>&$!A.++*%!&%!>&>&).+!&('!+<$+!$%*!.=*?!4<*%*!

=<*$!A.++*%!>&.'?!A*!.=*?D!*+>*+*%$J!5<*!=+%&)F!7&()+=!&@!=<*$!=<&.'?!A*!=+%*==*?!$)?!>&)=./*%!

$4$%*)*==!=<&.'?!A*!()>%*$=*?!()!&%?*%!+&!/$6*!=<*$!$!=+%&)F*%!7%&?.>+!&)!+<*!/$%6*+J!

P77&%+.)(+(*=! @&%! +%$?*%=!$%*!F(2*)!A-! +<*!E*=+!M@%(>$!5%$?*!B.AD! +<*-! $%*! $>+(2*'-! =.77&%+()F!

*07&%+*%=! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! \7%&?.>+=]J! ! 5<*%*! (=! %*)*4*?! F&2*%)/*)+! $++*)+(&)! @&%! =<*$D! ()! +<*!

)$+(&)$'!=+%$+*F-!&)!=<*$D!A.+!+<(=!(=!(/7'*/*)+*?!-*+J!5<(=!>$)!+.%)!&.+!+&!A*!$)!&77&%+.)(+-!A.+!

+(/*!<$=!+&!+*''J!!

3$+*'-!(/7%&2*/*)+=!<$2*!A**)!/$?*!&)!+<*!7*%(&?!)**?*?!@&%!+<*!=<*$!+%**!+&!/$+.%*!$)?!F(2*!

@%.(+=J! 5<*!Y.*=+(&)! (=! (@! +<(=! (=!$)!&77&%+.)(+-!&%!)&+J!E<&!4(''! F$()! @%&/!+<(=!)*4!><$)>*!$)?!

<&4!4(''!(+!4&%6!&.+!@&%!+<*!'&>$'!7(>6*%=D!7%&?.>*%=!$)?!7%&>*==&%=!&@!=<*$!(@!7'$)+$+(&)=!4(''!%(=*J!

E<$+! $A&.+! Y.$'(+-! (==.*=S! 4(''! +<*! )*4! 2$%(*+(*=! <$2*! +<*! =$/*! Y.$'(+-! $=7*>+=! $=! +<*! &'?!

()?(F*)&.=!+%**=!+<$+!F%&4!&.+=(?*!()!+<*!4('?e!!

!

5<*!Y.$'(+-!(=!&@+*)!$!>&)=+%$()+D!A$?!).+=!?&!F(2*!A$?!A.++*%D!$)?!+<*%*!=&/*+(/*=!$%*!()=*>+=!()!

+<*!A.++*%!4<*)!)&+! =+&%*?!$)?!7$>6$F*?!4*''J! 5<*!A.++*%! %*$>+=!4(+<!$(%!4<(><!?*>%*$=*=! +<*!

Y.$'(+-D! =&! +<*!A.++*%!=<&.'?!A*!=*$'*?!$(%+(F<+!$)?!=+&%*?! ()!F&&?!>&)?(+(&)=J!5<*!A.++*%!<$=!$!

'&4!=<*'@!'(@*!$)?!+<*%*@&%*!+(/()F!(=!2*%-!(/7&%+$)+J!,&(=+.%*!>&)+*)+!(=!(/7&%+$)+D!<./$)!<$(%=!

>$)! =&/*+(/*=! A*! @&.)?! ()! +<*! A.++*%D! *JFJ! 4<*)! +<*! 4&/*)! $%*! )&+! 4&%6()F! <-F(*)(>$''-!

*)&.F<J!5<*!+-7*!&@!4$+*%!.=*?! (=! (/7&%+$)+D!4<*)! @*+><*?! ()! %.=+-!A&4'=! (+! >$)!&0(?(l*!4<(><!

>$)!?*F%$?*!+<*!A.++*%J!!

hJc! #&)>'.=(&)=!$)?!?(=>.==(&)!

!

5<*%*!(=!$! '$>6!&@!?$+$!$)?!*=7*>($''-!%*'($A'*!Y.$)+(+$+(2*!?$+$!$A&.+!).+=!$)?!*=7*>($''-!A.++*%!

$)?! @()(=<*?! 7%&?.>+=! +%$?*?J! 5<*! F&2*%)/*)+! (=! )&+! $>+(2*'-! =.77&%+()F! *07&%+*%=! &@! +<*!

7%&?.>+=D!$)?!+<*!F&2*%)/*)+!?&*=)k+!6**7!+%$>6!&)!$/&.)+=!&@!A.++*%!7%&?.>*?!$)?!*07&%+*?J!

V+!>&.'?!A*!.=*@.'!(@!/&%*!?$+$!4&.'?!A*!$2$('$A'*!()!&%?*%!+&!6**7!+%$>6!&)!+<*!()?.=+%-!$)?!/$6*!

+<()F=!/&%*!>'*$%J!!

#&/7*+(+(&)! A*+4**)! +%$?*%=! (=! <(F<! $)?! +<*%*@&%*! +<*%*! (=! $! '$>6! &@! &7*))*==D! +<(=! ?&*=)k+!

*)<$)>*! +<*! ()?.=+%-! $)?J! #&&7*%$+(&)! >&.'?! A*! ()+*%*=+()F! *=7*>($''-! =()>*! =&/*! &@! +<*!

7%&?.>*%=n!+%$?*%=!$%*!2*%-!=/$''D!=>$'*!*@@(>(*)>-!>&.'?!A*!()>%*$=*?J_%&?.>+!?(@@*%*)+($+(&)!$)?!

?*2*'&7()F!)*4!())&2$+(&)=!(=!(/7&%+$)+!@&%!+%$?*%=!+&!=.%2(2*!()!+<*!@.+.%*J!j.$'(+-!4(''!A*>&/*!

$!/&%*!$)?!/&%*!(/7&%+$)+!(==.*!$)?!<$=!+&!A*!$??%*==*?!A-!+<*!+%$?*%=J!3&&6()F!$+!+<*!@.+.%*!(+!

(=!(/7&%+$)+!+&!)&+!&)'-!$??%*==!+<*!GKD!CG!$)?!M=($!A.+!$=!4*''!@&>.=!&)!E*=+!M@%(>$!$)?!@()?!&.+!

4<$+!+<*!><$)>*=!$%*!()!+<(=!<.F*!/$%6*+!@&%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=J!!

53

#<$7+*%!c!!! G%A$)!=<*$!A.++*%!>&)=./*%=!!

!

cJf! V)+%&?.>+(&)!

!

5<(=! ><$7+*%! F(2*=! +<*! 2(*4! &@! >&)=./*%=!&@! =<*$!A.++*%! ()! +<*! .%A$)! $%*$!&@! +<*! >(+-! 5$/$'*D!

'&>$+*?! ()! +<*!H&%+<*%)!I*F(&)! ()!N<$)$J!E(+<()! +<%**!4**6=!d9!7*&7'*!$%*! ()+*%2(*4*?J!hh!&@!

+<*/!$%*!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!fh!?&!)&+!.=*!+<*!A.++*%J!5<*!7*&7'*!$%*!><&=*)!$+!%$)?&/!$)?!

$%*!/*+!$'&)F!+<*!=+%**+=D!$+!+<*!/$%6*+!$)?!()!+<*(%!<&.=*=J!5<*=*!()+*%2(*4=!$%*!?&)*!+&!F(2*!$)!

(?*$!&@!4<&!+<*!7*&7'*!$%*!.=()F!&%!)&+!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?! @&%!4<$+!7.%7&=*! +<*-!.=*! (+D! (@!

+<*-!.=*!(+S!$)?!4<-!+<*-!'(6*!&%!?&!)&+!'(6*!=<*$!A.++*%J!M!=+%.>+.%*?!Y.*=+(&))$(%*!(=!F(2*)!+&!+<*!

hh! >&)=./*%=! 4(+<! Y.*=+(&)=! $A&.+! +<*! +-7*! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! +<*-! A.-! $)?! .=*D! $)?! <&4! (+! (=!

7%*=*)+*?! +&! +<*/D! +<*! Y.$)+(+-! $)?! @%*Y.*)>-! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! +<*-! A.-S! (@! +<*-! 7*%>*(2*?! $)-!

><$)F*=! ()! +<*! Y.$)+(+-D! 7%(>*=! $)?! Y.$'(+-! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! &)! +<*!/$%6*+=! &2*%! +(/*! $)?!4<$+!

=.A=+(+.+*=!+<*-!.=*!$=!4*''J!5<*!7*&7'*!\fh]!4<&!?&!)&+!'(6*!+&!.=*!=<*$!A.++*%!$%*!$=6*?!$A&.+!

+<*(%!&7()(&)!4<-!+<*-!4&.'?!)&+!.=*! (+S! (@! +<*-!$%*!$4$%*!$A&.+!+<*!.=*=!$)?!Y.$'(+(*=!&@!=<*$!

A.++*%! $)?! 4<$+! &+<*%! 7%&?.>+=! ?&! +<*-! .=*J! V)! +<*! $77*)?(0! +<*! +4&! Y.*=+(&))$(%*=! @&%!

>&)=./*%=!\V]!$)?!)&)L>&)=./*%=!\VV]!$%*!=.77'*/*)+*?J!

M=! >&/7$%(=&)! $)! *0$/7'*! &@! $! %*=*$%><! ?&)*! ()! ,$'(! $/&)F! =<*$! A.++*%! 7%&?.>*%=! $)?!

>&)=./*%=!>$)!A*!@&.)?!()!+<*!$%+(>'*!&@!M6*%*?&'.D!\M6*%*?&'.D!,J!*+!$']J!

!

!

cJ8! #&)=./7+(&)!

@>;>B! A)$&(,3,2%(,0&!03!20&1'7$+1!

E&/*)!\Qdr]!$)?!/*)!\fgr]!4*%*! ()+*%2(*4*?!&)!/$%6*+=D!&)!+<*!=+%**+=!$)?!()!+<*(%!<&/*=J!

_*&7'*! .=()F! =<*$! A.++*%! 4(+<()! +<(=! %*=*$%><! $%*! /&=+'-! )&)! *?.>$+*?! /(??'*! $F*?! 4&/*)!

=*''()F!@&&?!?(=<*=!$)?!=)$>6=!$+!+<*(%!<&/*=!$)?!$'&)F!=+%**+!=(?*=J!:fr!&@!+<*!hh!>&)=./*%=!$%*!

4&/*)D!$)?!dhr!&@! +<*! +&+$'!>&)=./*%=!?(?!)&+!F&! +&! @&%/$'!=><&&'=! \@(F.%*!cJf]!4<(><!$''! $%*!

4&/*)J!Qdr!&@! +<*!fh!)&)L>&)=./*%=!$%*!4&/*)J! V)! @(F.%*!cJ8! >$)!A*! =**)! +<$+!hir!&@! =<*$!

A.++*%!(=!.=*?!@&%!=*''()FJ!E<*)!$=6*?!$A&.+!+<*!7%&@*==(&)!&@!+<*!>&)=./*%=D!ihr!&@!hh!7*&7'*!(=!

+%$?()FD!/&=+'-!()!@&&?D!c!7*&7'*!$%*!$>+.$''-!+%$?()F!()!=<*$!A.++*%!\ffr]!$=!4*''!$=!.=()F!(+!@&%!

+<*/=*'2*=!$)?!+<*(%!<&.=*<&'?=D!&+<*%=!$%*!.)*/7'&-*?!\ggr]!&%!<$2*!$)!&+<*%!1&A!\ffr]J!

!!

!

!

! ! !

!

54

7%

5%2%

7% 4%

75%

!!!!!

18%

36% 46%

household

householdand sellingselling

!

;(F.%*!cJf!L!!C?.>$+(&)$'!'*2*'!&@!>&)=./*%=! ;(F.%*!cJ8!L!K<*$!A.++*%!.=*!

!

@>;>;! F$+2$,X$)!`'%4,(?!03!(#$!1#$%!*'(($+!*?!(#$!20&1'7$+1!

M@+*%!=&/*!>&)2*%=$+(&)=!4(+<!7*&7'*!4<&!.=*!=<*$!A.++*%!+<*!@&''&4()F!%*/$%6=!$%*!/$?*J!5<*!

%*=.'+=!$%*!+<$+!$!?(=+()F.(=<!(=!/$?*!A*+4**)!4<(+*!$)?!-*''&4!A.++*%!\>&'&.%]!$)?!A*+4**)!<$%?!

A.++*%!$)?!=&@+!A.++*%!\+*0+.%*]J!M)!&+<*%!><$%$>+*%(=+(>!&@!+<*!A.++*%!(=!+<*!=/*''!$)?!+$=+*J!5<*=*!

$%*!+<*!/$()!><$%$>+*%(=+(>=!&)!4<(><!+<*!>&)=./*%!?*>(?*=!+&!=*'*>+!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!&@!<(=!&%!<*%!

><&(>*J!!

!

!;(F.%*! cJg! F(2*=! $)! (?*$! &@! +<*! >&'&.%! 7%*@*%*)>*!

=*'*>+*?! $/&)F! hh! >&)=./*%=J! 5<*! 4<(+*! A.++*%! (=!

7%*@*%%*?! A-! /&=+! \dgr]D! -*''&4! A.++*%! A-! fcr! $)?!

>&)=./*%=! A.-()F! $)-! >&'&.%D! 4<(+*! &%! -*''&4D! (=!

=*'*>+*?! A-! ffrJ! I*$=&)=! F(2*)! A-! +<*! >&)=./*%=!

><&&=()F! 4<(+*D! -*''&4! &%! $)-! &@! +<*! +4&! >&'&.%=! &@!

=<*$!A.++*%!$%*! (''.=+%$+*?! ()! +$A'*!cJfJ!;&%! +<*!><&(>*!

&@!4<(+*!A.++*%!+<*!&7()(&)=!F(2*)!$%*!$A&.+!>&//&)!

.=*D!�A*=+k!><&(>*!@&%!@&&?!7%*7$%$+(&)D!$)?!+<*!)$+.%$'!

=+$+*!&@!+<*!A.++*%J!^*''&4!A.++*%! (=!=**)!$=!$++%$>+(2*!

$)?!$=!$!7%&?.>+! @&%!>&)=./*%=! $)?! +%$?*%=! @%&/!+<*!

=&.+<! &@! N<$)$J! V+! (=! 7*%>*(2*?! +&! F(2*! +<*! A.++*%! $)!

*0+%$!@'$2&.%J!M)-!+-7*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!=*'*>+*?!()!+<*!

()+*%2(*4=!+&!7&()+!&.+!+<$+!+<*!><&(>*!4(''!?*7*)?!&)!

+<*! .=*! A-! +<*! >&)=./*%=! $)?! &)! +<*! $2$('$A('(+-! &@! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%! &)! +<*! /$%6*+J! K&/*!

>&)=./*%=!?&!)&+!7*%>*(2*!$)-!?(@@*%*)>*!A*+4**)!+<*!4<(+*!$)?!-*''&4!A.++*%J!

!

!

!

11%

16%

73%

whiteyellowany

!

;(F.%*! cJg! L! _*%>*)+$F*! &@! =<*$! A.++*%!

>&'&.%!A&.F<+!$/&)F!hh!7*&7'*!

55

5$A'*!cJf!L!I*$=&)=!&@!><&(>*!()!4<(+*D!-*''&4!&%!$)-!+-7*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$/&)F!>&)=./*%=!

!

E<(+*! ^*''&4! M)-!+-7*!

!

#&//&)!.=*!

p! .=*?! +&! (+! ()! G77*%! C$=+!

4<*%*!=<*!(=!@%&/q!

p+<$+! (=! 4<$+! >&=+./*%=! '(6*!

+&!A.-q!

!

#&&6()F!a!>&)=./7+(&)!

pA*=+!@&%!>&&6()Fq!!

pA*++*%! @&%! >&&6()FD! -*''&4!

@&$/=!$=!(@!(+!(=!=&$7q!

pF&&?!@&%!>&)=./7+(&)D!&+<*%!

+-7*! (=! .=*?! @&%! &+<*%!

7.%7&=*=q!

pF&&?!@&%!@&&?!7%*7$%$+(&)q!

pF&&?!@&%!'&>$'!>&)=./7+(&)q!

pE<(+*! &)*! (=! @&%! <&/*!

>&)=./7+(&)! ()! '&>$'!

)&%+<*%)! N<$)$J! ^*''&4!

>&'&.%! (=! 7%*@*%%*?! A-! +<*!

K&.+<q!

!

K6()>$%*!

p#&'&.%! (=! $??*?! +&! -*''&4!

A.++*%D! +<(=! (=! )&+! 2*%-! F&&?!

@&%!+<*!A&?-q!

p.=*!@&%!=6()q!

!

#'*$)! &('! a! )$+.%$'! &('D! )&!

$??(+(2*=!

pE<(+*!&)*!(=!>'*$)!&('q!

pE<(+*!&)*!(=!>'*$%q!

pE<(+*! &)*! (=! )$+.%$'D!

)&+<()F!<$=!A**)!$??*?q!!

p#'*$)!$)?!>&)2()>()Fq!!

p#<*/(>$'=! $%*! $??*?! ()! +<*!

-*''&4!&)*=q!

p^*''&4!&)*!A*>&/*=!?$%6!&('!

$@+*%!/*'+()Fq!

!

M++%$>+(2*!

p^*''&4! >&'&.%! (=! $++%$>+(2*!

$)?!F&&?q!

p^*''&4! A.++*%! (=! /&%*!

$++%$>+(2*q!!

pV+!(=!$++%$>+(2*!+&!A.-*%=q!

!

M++%$>+(2*)*==! +&! =&.+<*%)!

N<$)$!!

p^*''&4! &)*! (=! $++%$>+(2*! @&%!

7*&7'*!@%&/!+<*!K&.+<q!!

!

;'$2&.%!

p^*''&4! A.++*%! F(2*=! $! )(>*!

@'$2&.%q!

p5<*!>&'&.%!()!&('!$??=!@'$2&.%!

+&!(+q!!

!

U*7*)?()F!&)!.=*!!

p#&'&.%!(=!?*7*)?()F!&)!4<$+!

A.-*%=!4$)+q!

!

U*7*)?()F!&)!$2$('$A('(+-!

pK<*$! A.++*%! ><&(>*! (=!

?*7*)?()F! &)! 4<$+! (=!

$2$('$A'*!&)!+<*!/$%6*+q!

!

H&!?(@@*%*)>*!

pM''!=<*$!A.++*%!$%*!+<*!=$/*D!

&)'-!?(@@*%*)>*!()!>&'&.%q!!

p;&%! >&&6()FD! 7*&7'*!4(''! )&+!

=**!+<*!>&'&.%!?(@@*%*)>*q!

!

!

56

M! ?(=+()F.(=<! (=! /$?*! A-! +<*! >&)=./*%=! ()! +<*! +*0+.%*! &@! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%D! <$%?! $)?! =&@+J!

I*=7*>+(2*'-!hgr!&@!+<*!>&)=./*%=!><&=*!@&%!<$%?!A.++*%D!8hr!@&%!=&@+!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!89r!@&%!

$)-!+-7*!&@!A.++*%D!8r!?(?!)&+!<$2*!$)!&7()(&)!\;(F.%*!cJi]J!5$A'*!cJ8!&.+'()*=!?(@@*%*)+!%*$=&)=!

$)?!&7()(&)=!&@!7%*@*%*)>*=!A*+4**)!<$%?D!=&@+!$)?!$)-!+-7*!&@!A.++*%J!j.$'(+(*=!&@!<$%?!A.++*%!

/*)+(&)*?! $%*! A*++*%! 7%*=*%2$+(&)D! '&4!4$+*%! >&)+*)+D! $! <(F<! &('! >&)+*)+D! F&&?! @&%! >&&6()FD! $!

)(>*!+$=+*!$)?!+<*!>&//&)!.=*!&@!<$%?!A.++*%J!5<*!Y.$'(+(*=!&@!=&@+!A.++*%!$%*!*$=-!/*'+()FD!*$=-!

+&!=/*$%!&)!+<*!=6()D!+<*!@%*=<)*==!$)?!(+!>$)!A*!><*$7*%!+<$)!<$%?!A.++*%J!5<*!>$+*F&%-!&@!$)-!

+-7*! &@! +*0+.%*! ><&=*)! A-! +<*! >&)=./*%=! (=! ?&)*! A-! +<*! @&''&4()F! $%F./*)+=Z! =**()F! )&!

?(@@*%*)>*=!()!<$%?!&%!=&@+!A.++*%D!+<*!$2$('$A('(+-!&@!+<*!A.++*%D!><&(>*!?*7*)?()F!&)!+<*!A.-*%=!

$>>*7+$)>*D!><&(>*!?*7*)?()F!&)!+<*!=*$=&)!$)?!=*'*>+(&)!?*7*)?()F!&)!+<*!4$-!+<*!A.++*%!<$=!

A**)!7%&>*==*?J!

!

5<*! /*'+()F! ><$%$>+*%(=+(>! (=! /*)+(&)*?! $=! =&/*+<()F! .=*@.'!

$)?!$=!=&/*+<()F!)&+!.=*@.'!()!>&&6()F!?*7*)?()F!&)!+<*!2(*4!

&@!+<*!>&)=./*%!$)?!+<*!7*%>*7+(&)!+<*!>&)=./*%!<$=!&@!+<*!

7%&?.>+J!5<*%*! (=!$!+(/*!>&)=+%$()+!A-!.=()F!<$%?!A.++*%D!$=! (+!

4(''! +$6*! '&)F*%! @&%! (+! +&! /*'+J! P)! +<*! &+<*%! <$)?! $! <(F<*%!

4$+*%! >&)+*)+! >$)! A*! ?(=+.%A()F! ()! @%-()F! @&&?J! 5<*! -*''&4!

>&'&.%*?!A.++*%!>$)!$'=&!A*!=**)!$=!=&@+!A.++*%D!4<(><!7*&7'*!

@()?!@$2&.%$A'*!$=!=6()>$%*!7%&?.>+J!M)!$==./7+(&)!(=!+<$+!+<*!

4$+*%! >&)+*)+! (=! $'=&!<(F<*%! ()! -*''&4!A.++*%D! A*>$.=*! &@! +<*!

$??*?! %&&+=!4<(><! $A=&%A! +<*!4$+*%J! 5<*! $==./7+(&)! (=! +<$+!

+<*! >&'&.%! -*''&4! $'=&! /$6*=! +<*! $77*$%$)>*! &@! +<*! A.++*%!

/&%*!=&@+J!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!

!

!

!

5$A'*!cJ8!L!I*$=&)=!@&%!><&&=()F!<$%?D!=&@+!&%!$)-!+-7*!&@!+*0+.%*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!A-!>&)=./*%=!

!

B$%?!A.++*%! K&@+!A.++*%! M)-!+-7*!

!

T*++*%!7%*=*%2$+(&)!

pV+! ?&*=! )&+! /*'+! 4<*)! -&.!

6**7!(+q!

pV+!4(''!'$=+!'&)F*%q!!

pV+!(=!*$=(*%!+&!7%*=*%2*q!pK&@+!

&)*=!4(''!)&+!<$%?*)q!

!

3&4!4$+*%!>&)+*)+!

pK&@+! &)*=! >&)+$()! +&! /.><!

4$+*%D! +<(=! (=! )&+! F&&?! @&%!

!

C$=-!/*'+()F!

pK&@+!A.++*%!/*'+=!*$=(*%!+<$)!

<$%?!A.++*%!4<*)!<*$+*?q!!

p;&%!@$=+!/*'+()Fq!

!

K6()>$%*!!

pC$=(*%!+&!%&AA!&)!+<*!A&?-q!

!

;%*=<)*==!!

pK&@+*%D! /*$)=! @%*=<*%!

!

M2$('$A('(+-!!

pV!A.-!4<$+!V!>$)!F*+q!

pE<$+! &+<*%=! '(6*D! (=! &)! +<*!

/$%6*+D! $)?! V! 4(''! '(6*! (+! $=!

4*''q!

!

H&!?(@@*%*)>*!()!+*0+.%*!!

pV!?&!)&+!=**!$)-!?(@@*%*)>*=q!

!

U*7*)?()F! &)! A.-*%=!

20%2%

25%

53%

hardsoftanyother

!

;(F.%*! cJi! L! _*%>*)+$F*! &@!

><&(>*!&)!+*0+.%*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!

$/&)F!hh!>&)=./*%=!

57

>&&6()Fq!!

pK&@+! A.++*%! <$=! +&&! /.><!

4$+*%!()!(+q!

pE$+*%!>&)+*)+!(=!'&4q!!

!

N&&?!@&%!>&&6()F!!

pB$%?!A.++*%!/$6*=!+<*!@%-()F!

'&&6!F&&?q!

p_*&7'*! '(6*! (+! +<*! /&=+! @&%!

>&&6()Fq!!

pN&&?! A.++*%! @&%! >&&6()F!

=+*4q!

!

,&%*!&('!

pB$%?! A.++*%! (=! <*$2(*%D! +<(=!!

/*$)=!/&%*!&('!>&)+*)+q!!

pV+!4(''!)&+!/*'+!*$=('-!

!

T*++*%!+$=+*!

p5<*! +$=+*! (=!A*++*%! +<$)! =&@+!

A.++*%q!

!!

#&//&)!.=*!

pT.-*%=!'(6*!(+!/&%*q!

A.++*%q!!

!

#<*$7*%!

p#<*$7*%!+<$)!<$%?!&)*D!.=*?!

@&%!=&.7!=&!)&!7%&A'*/q!!

!

$>>*7+$)>*!

pU*7*)?()F! &)! 4<$+! +<*!

A.-*%=! '(6*D! =&/*! '(6*! =&@+!

A.++*%D!=&/*!'(6*!<$%?!A.++*%q!

!!

U*7*)?()F!&)!=*$=&)!

pB$%?)*==! ?*7*)?()F! &)!

=*$=&)! $2$('$A('(+-! $+! +(/*!

)**?*?q!!

pK&@+)*==! $)?! <$%?)*==! (=!

?*7*)?()F! &)! %$()-! $)?! ?%-!

=*$=&)! \+*/7*%$+.%*!

&.+=(?*]q!!

!

U*7*)?()F!&)!7%&>*==()F!

pK/&&+<)*==D! <$%?)*==! $)?!

=&@+)*==!(=!?*7*)?()F!&)!<&4!

(+! (=! A&('*?! ?.%()F! +<*!

7%&>*==()F!&@!+<*!A.++*%q!

!

5<*!7$>6$F()F!$)?!7%*=*)+$+(&)!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!+&!+<*!>&)=./*%!>$)!A*!=**)!$=!$!7%&A'*/!+&!

>&)=./*%=J!5<(=!A*>$.=*!&@!*07&=.%*!+&!=.)!$)?!+&!?.=+J!5<*!A.++*%!>$)!A*!7$>6$F*?!()!$!7'$=+(>!

A$F!\7&'-+-)!A$F]D!>&2*%*?!A-!$!>'&+<D!7.+!()!$!>&)+$()*%!&%!()!$!A&4'!&%!>$'$A$=<J!V)!+$A'*!cJg!$)!

&2*%2(*4! (=!F(2*)!&@! +<*!$?2$)+$F*=!7*%=&)=! =**! ()!?(@@*%*)+!4$-=!&@!7$>6$F()FJ! K&/*! %*/$%6=!

$%*!F(2*)!+<$+!=<*$!A.++*%!F(2*)!()!$!>&)+$()*%!4&.'?!A*!)(>*%J!M>+.$''-!+<(=!(=!/&=+'-!?&)*!A-!+<*!

>&)=./*%=!+<*/=*'2*=!$+!<&/*!\7*%=&)$'!>&//.)(>$+(&)!+&!>&)=./*%=]J!

!

#&//*)+=!&)!+<*!7$>6$F()F!\=**!+$A'*!cJg]!$%*!%*'$+*?!+&!>&//&)!.=*D!$=!(+!(=!6)&4)!$)?!.=*?!

A-!F*)*%$+(&)=J!M)!&+<*%!>&//*)+!(=!�4<*)!+<*!7%&>*==()F!&@!+<*!A.++*%!(=!?&)*!()!$!>&%%*>+!4$-D!

+<*%*!4(''! A*! )&! ?(=$?2$)+$F*=kJ! K&! (+!4(''! )&+!/$++*%! ()!4<$+!4$-! (+! (=! F(2*)! +&! +<*! >&)=./*%J!

#&//*)+=! $=! �*$=-! +&! >$%%-k! $)?! $! �?(%*>+! /*$=.%*/*)+! @&%! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%k! $%*! @%*Y.*)+'-!

/*)+(&)*?J!5<%**!7*&7'*!/*)+(&)*?!+<*!*)2(%&)/*)+$'!>&)>*%)!&@!.=()F!7$7*%!$)?!7'$=+(>!A$F=J!

!

!

!

58

5$A'*!cJg!L!E$-!&@!7%*=*)+()F!$)?!7$>6$F()F!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!

!

_&'-+-)n>&2*%$F*! #&2*%*?!A-!>'&+<! #&)+$()*%! T&4'!

!

pC$=-!+&!>$%%-q!

pR**7()F! @%&/!

/*'+()Fq!

pR**7()F!@%&/!?.=+q!

pN&&?! A*>$.=*! &@!

+*0+.%*q!

pT*++*%! )&4! A*>$.=*!

A*@&%*! &)'-! ()! 7$7*%!

&%!'*$2*=q!

pV+!(=!&6$-!'(6*!+<(=q!

pV+!(=!$'4$-=!?&)*!'(6*!

+<(=q!

pE(''! 7.+! (+! ()! $!

>&)+$()*%!$+!<&/*q!

pE*''!7%&+*>+*?q!

p3&&6=!>'*$%!+<(=!4$-q!

p#&'&.%! $)?! +*0+.%*!

>$)!A*!=**)q!

pC$=-! +&! 7$>6! @&%! $!

'(++'*! Y.$)+(+-! $)?! +&!

6**7!(+q!

!

p5$=+*!=+(''!F&&?q!

!

pH(>*! $)?! @$)>-!

>&)+$()*%!(=!)(>*%q!

pH(>*%! +&! 7.+! (+!

?(%*>+'-! ()! $!

>&)+$()*%q!

p_(*>*=! 4(''! )&+!

>%./A'*!+&F*+<*%q!

p3&&6=!)*$+q!

!

pU(%*>+!/*$=.%*q!

p_$7*%! $)?! 7&'-+-)!

$%*! )&+! F&&?! @&%! +<*!

*)2(%&)/*)+q!

!

!

@>;>=! P1%5$!%&)!`'%&(,(,$1!

!

K<*$!A.++*%!(=!.=*?!()!F*)*%$'!@&%!@&&?!7%*7$%$+(&)!$)?!=6()>$%*J!M=!/*)+(&)*?!A*@&%*!hir!\&@!hh!

7*&7'*]! \@(F.%*!cJ8]! $%*!A.-()F! =<*$!A.++*%! @&%! =*''()F! @&&?!$'&)F! +<*! =+%**+=D! &)! +<*!/$%6*+!&%!

@%&/!+<*(%!<&.=*=J!B&.=*<&'?=!$%*!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%!/&=+'-!@&%!>&&6()F!$)?!=6()>$%*J!

!!

59

18%

36% 46%

household

householdand sellingselling

!!!!!!!

!;(F.%*!cJ8!L!K<*$!A.++*%!.=*!

!

!

!

!

!

5<*!$/&.)+=!7*&7'*!A.-!$%*!=/$''!=(l*=!&@!>$J!fh!+&!i9!F%$/=D!A&4'=!\iLc6F]!$)?!>$'$A$=<*=!\fcL

8h6F]J!K/$''!=(l*=!$)?!A&4'=!$%*!A&.F<+!+<*!/&=+D!hhr!$)?!gcr!\=**!@(F.%*!cJh]J!V)!@(F.%*!cJc!+<*!

@%*Y.*)>-! &@! +<*! =/$''! =(l*=! $)?! +<*! A&4'=! $%*! (''.=+%$+*?J! M=! >$)! A*! =**)! i9r! &@! <$'@! &@! +<*!

>&)=./*%=!A.-!9Jh! +&!8!&@! +<*! =/$''! =(l*=! $!/&)+<J!i9r!&@! >&)=./*%=!4<&!A.-! A&4'=D!A.-! $)!

$/&.)+! &@! g! +&! h! A&4'! 7*%!/&)+<J! ;&%! =6()>$%*! =/$''! $/&.)+=! $%*! .=*?! $)?! '$=+! '&)F*%J! K<*$!

A.++*%!@&%!>&&6()F!(=!.=*?!()!'$%F*%!Y.$)+(+(*=J!U*7*)?()F!&)!+<*!<&.=*<&'?!=(l*!&%!?*7*)?()F!&)!

*>&)&/(>$'!.=*!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%D!$=!()!=*''()F!@&&?D!'$%F*%!Y.$)+(+(*=!$%*!.=*?J!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

;(F.%*! cJh! L! M/&.)+=! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! A&.F<+! A-! hh!

>&)=./*%=!

!

F ig u re 5 . F re q u e n c y b o u g h t b y c o ns u m e rs o f s m a ll s ize s a n d o f b o w ls o f s h e a b u tte r in a m o n th

05

1 01 52 02 53 03 54 04 5

0 ,5 -2 3 -5 6 - 1 5 e ve ryd a y(3 0 )

0 ,5 -2 3 -5 6 - 1 5 e ve ryd a y(3 0 )

A m o u n ts o f s h e a b u tte r (s m a ll s iz e s a n d b o w ls )

Freq

uenc

y (%

)

!

60

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

;&%!=6()>$%*!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%! (=!&@+*)!7.+! ()+&!$!=/$''!>&)+$()*%!\>$J!fh9!F%]!$)?!.=*?!@&%!f! +&!8!

/&)+<=J!U*7*)?()F!&)! +<*! =$'*D!$!A.=()*==!4&/$)! ()! @&&?!>$)! ?&!g!?$-=!4(+<!f!A&4'! \h6F]!&@!

A.++*%!$77%&0(/$+*'-J!!

!

V)!>&)+%$=+!+&!>&)=./*%=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%D!fh!)&)!>&)=./*%=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$%*!()+*%2(*4*?J!!

_*&7'*!4<&!$%*!)&+!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%!\fh!7*&7'*]!$%*!$=6*?!(@!+<*-!.=*?!=<*$!A.++*%!A*@&%*!$)?!

@&%!4<$+!%*$=&)!+<*-!=+&77*?!.=()F!(+!\+$A'*!cJi]J!K*2*%$'!%*$=&)=!$%*!+<$+!7*&7'*!?&!.=*!+<*!=<*$!

A.++*%!A.+!&)'-! ()! +<*!?%-! =*$=&)D! +<*!B$%/$++$)! =*$=&)D!4<*)! +<*(%! =6()! (=! 2*%-! ?%-J! #&&6()FD!

/*?(>()$'!$)?!%(+.$'!7.%7&=*=!$%*!.=$F*=!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%J!T.+!&)'-! ()!+(/*!&@!)**?J!;&%!>&&6()F!

&+<*%!*?(A'*!&('=!<$2*!+<*!7%*@*%$)>*!A.+!=<*$!A.++*%!4(''!A*!.=*?!4<*)! (+! (=!><*$7*%!$)?!(@! +<*!

7*%=&)! (=! )&+! $A'*! +&! ><&=*! <(/! &%! <*%=*'@J! ;&%!/*?(>()$'! &)'-! 4<*)! +<*! 7*%=&)! <$=! $! =>$%! &%!

/.=>'*!$>6*J!;&%!%(+.$'!7.%7&=*=!=<*$!A.++*%!4(''!A*!.=*?!&)'-!4<*)!+<*!%(+.$'=!4(''!A*!>$%%(*?!&.+J!

!

!

Figure 5. Frequency bought by consumers of small sizes and of bowls of shea butter in a month

05

1015202530354045

0,5-2 3-5 6- 15 everyday(30)

0,5-2 3-5 6- 15 everyday(30)

Amounts of shea butter (small sizes and bowls)

Freq

uenc

y (%

)

!

;(F.%*!cJc!L!;%*Y.*)>-!A&.F<+!A-!>&)=./*%=!&@!=/$''!=(l*=!$)?!&@!A&4'=!

&@!=<*$!A.++*%!()!$!/&)+<!

Small sizes Bowls

61

5$A'*!cJi!L!E<-!7*&7'*!?&!)&+!.=*!=<*$!A.++*%!$)-/&%*!

!

#&&6()F! K6()>$%*! ,*?(>()$'! I(+.$'!

pU&! )&+! '(6*! (+! ()!

+<*! H&%+<*%)!

I*F(&)q!!

pT*++*%! &('=!

$2$('$A'*! &)!

/$%6*+q!!

pP+<*%! &('=! $%*!

><*$7*%q!

pK<*$! A.++*%! (=!

*07*)=(2*q!

p#<('?%*)!4(''!)&+!

*$+!+<*!@&&?q!!

pB.=A$)?! ?&*=!

)&+!'(6*!(+q!

pG=*! ()! ?%-!

=*$=&)q!!

\B$%/$++$)!

=*$=&)]!!

pH&4! V! >$)!

><&&=*! /-=*'@!

4<$+!V!4$)+q!

pP)'-! 4<*)!

<$2()F! =>$%=D! &%!

&+<*%! 7$()=! &)'-!

.=()F! +&! +%*$+!

=(>6)*==q!

pM+! +<*! /&/*)+!

)&!%(+.$'=q!

!

@>;>K! !G$%10&!03!),14,9$!

!

5<*! =/*''! $)?! +$=+*! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! >$)! A*! >&)=+%$()()F! @$>+&%=! ()! +<*! .=*! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! @&%!

=6()>$%*!$)?!@&%!>&&6()FJ!B$'@!&@!+<*!>&)=./*%=!()+*%2(*4*?!\h9r!&@!hh!7*&7'*]!<$?!)&!7%&A'*/!

()! +<*(%! .=*! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! \=**! @(F.%*! c]J! _*&7'*! $%*! .=()F! $??(+(2*=!4(+<()! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%! +&!

(/7%&2*!(+=k!=/*''!&%!+$=+*J!;&%!*0$/7'*!&)(&)=D!F$%'(>!$)?!&+<*%!=7(>*=!$%*!@%(*?!A*@&%*!+<*!=<*$!

A.++*%! &%! $??*?! $+! +<*! =$/*! +(/*! +&! %*?.>*! +<*! =/*''! $)?! +$=+*! ()! +<*! @&&?J! _*%@./*D! &%$)F*!

7**'=!&%!=7*>(@(>!@%*=<'-!=>*)+*?!=**?=!>$)!A*!$??*?!()!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!$=!=6()>$%*!7%&?.>+J!5<*!

A.++*%!4(''!A*!<*$+*?!+&!/$6*!(+!*$=(*%!+&!=7%*$?!+<*!7*%@./*D!&%$)F*!7**'=!$)?!F%$()=!&%!=7(>*=!

()+&!+<*!A.++*%J!M'=&!4$+*%!(=!.=*?!+&!?('.+*!+<*!A.++*%!$)?!+&!%*?.>*!=/*''!$)?!+$=+*J!V@!=&/*+<()F!

(=!7.+!()+&!+<*!A.++*%!+&!=&@+*)!+<*!+*0+.%*!(=!)&+!/*)+(&)*?J!P+<*%!<$A(+=!/*)+(&)*?!$%*!+<*!.=*!

&@!?(@@*%*)+!A&?-!>%Ä/*=!&%!&+<*%!=6()>$%*!7%&?.>+=!$+! +<*!=$/*!+(/*!+&!>&2*%!+<*!=/*''!&@! +<*!

=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!+&!=&@+*)!+<*!A.++*%J!!

!

M!%*$=&)!/*)+(&)*?!$=!4*''!A-!>&)=./*%=!$)?!A-!)&)L>&)=./*%=!4<&!$%*!%*'.>+$)+!()!.=()F!=<*$!

A.++*%D!(=!+<$+!&+<*%!7*&7'*!4&.'?!A*!$A'*!+&!=/*''!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!5<(=!>$)!>%*$+*!>*%+$()!(?*$=!

$A&.+!+<*!>&)=./*%=!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%D!@&%!*0$/7'*!$A&.+!+<*(%!=&!>$''*?!()*07*)=(2*!><&(>*!&%!

$A&.+!+<*!4$-!+<*-!4(''!$++%$>+!$++*)+(&)!?.*!+&!+<*!=/*''J!K/*''!>$)!A*!$!>&)=+%$()+!()!>&&6()F!$=!

&+<*%=D!+<*!<&.=*<&'?!&%!>.=+&/*%=!?(='(6*!+<*!=/*''!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!&('!()!+<*(%!?(=<J!!

!

V)! +$A'*! cJh! &+<*%! >&//*)+=!&)!?(='(6*=! &@! =<*$!A.++*%! .=*=! $%*!/*)+(&)*?!A-! +<*! >&)=./*%=J!

E(+<()!+<*!7%&>*==()F!&@!+<*!=<*$!).+=!()+&!A.++*%D!+<*!?%-()F!7%&>*==!&@!+<*!).+=!$%*!/*)+(&)*?!

$=!$!>%.>($'!7$%+!4(+<()! +<*!7%&?.>+(&)J!E<*)!+<*!).+=!A*>&/*!/&(=+!A*>$.=*!&@!A$?!?%-()F!&%!

A$?!=+&%$F*D!+<*-!F*%/()$+*!&%!F*+!()@*>+*?!A-!@.)F.=D!+<(=!4(''!'*$?!+&!$!A(++*%!&%!=&.%!+$=+*!&@!+<*!

=<*$!A.++*%!()!>&&6()FJ!

62

P+<*%!)*F$+(2*!$=7*>+=!/*)+(&)*?!A-!>&)=./*%=!4$=!+<*!-*''&4!A.++*%!$)?!+<*!<$%?)*==!&@!+<*!

A.++*%J!5<*!@(%=+!&)*!4$=!/*)+(&)*?!()!+<*!>&)+*0+!&@!)&+!A*()F!=.(+$A'*!@&%!7%*7$%()F!/*$'=J!5<*!

<$%?)*==!&@!+<*!A.++*%!(=!/*)+(&)*?!$=!4*''J!!V+!>&.'?!A*!+<$+!+<(=!<$=!$!)*F$+(2*!*@@*>+!A*>$.=*!(+!

4(''!)&+!/*'+!@$=+!4<*)!.=*?!@&%!>&&6()F!$)?!(@!.=*?!$=!=6()L>%*$/!(+!/(F<+!A*!<$%?!+&!=/*$%J!

49

36

9 50,005,00

10,0015,0020,0025,0030,0035,0040,0045,0050,00

Percentage of dislike of shea butter

none smell taste otherDislikes of shea butter

!

;(F.%*! cJd! L! _*%>*)+$F*! &@! ?(='(6*! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! $/&)F!

>&)=./*%=!

!

!

!

5$A'*!cJh!L!#&//*)+=!&)!?(='(6*=!&@!.=*=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!

!

K/*''!! 5$=+*! P+<*%! H&)*!

;%-+&'! =/*''=!)(>*%!

+<$)!=<*$!A.++*%!

L! pE<*)!

7%*F)$)+D! +<*!

=/*''! /$6*=!

2&/(+q!

I*?.)?$)+! +&! .=*!

=<*$! A.++*%! @&%!

=6()>$%*!

E<*)! >&&6()FD!

&+<*%=! ! >&/7'$()!

&@!+<*!=/*''!

M@+*%! =&/*! +(/*D!

+<*! =/*''! F*+=!

4&%=*!!

P)(&)=! $%*! $??*?!

+&!(/7%&2*!=/*''!

=&/*+(/*=! A$?! \!

A(++*%! A*>$.=*! &@!

A$?! ).+=! +<$+!

F*%/()$+*?!

$'%*$?-! A*@&%*!

7%&>*==]!!

F*%/()$+*?! ).+=!

.=*?D! +$=+! 4(''! A*!

A(++*%!&%!=&.%!

V! 4(''! $??! =7(>*=D!

F()F*%! $)?! &)(&)=!

+&! (+! +&! (/7%&2*!

+<*!+$=+*!

!

-*''&4! A.++*%D! )&+!

F&&?!@&%!>&&6()F!

<$%?)*==!

M??!+&!&('D!/$6*=! +<*!

+$=+*!A*++*%!

E*! $%*! .=()F! (+! =()>*!

()@$)>-D!(+!(=!F&&?!$)?!

=+(''!.=()F!(+!

F%$)?@$+<*%=! 4*%*!

.=()F! (+D! $)?! +<*-!

$%*n4*%*! <*$'+<(*%!

+<$)!.=!

+<$+! (=!<&4!(+! (=!F(2*)!

+&!.=D!)&!7%&A'*/!

?*7*)?()F! &)!

7%&>*==J! E<*)! +&&!

/.><!@(%*D!(+!4(''!A.%)!

+<*! &('! $)?!/$6*! +<*!

A.++*%!A(++*%!

(+!(=!.=*?!@&%!=&!/$)-!

63

E$+*%! (=!$??*?!+&!

)*.+%$'(l*! +<*!

=/*''!

+<()F=!$)?!(+!(=!F&&?!

.=()F! =()>*! ()@$)>-!

+<$+!4$-!

=/*''! $)?! +$=+*! $%*!

)&!7%&A'*/!

!

!

@>;>M! D#%&5$1!,&!`'%&(,(?Z!/+,2$1!%&)!`'%4,(?!/$+2$,X$)!*?!20&1'7$+1!0&!(#$!7%+9$(!!

_*&7'*!$%*!$4$%*!&@!+<*!><$)F*=!&)!+<*!/$%6*+!()!%*F$%?!+&!=<*$!A.++*%J!M!Y.*=+(&)!$=6*?!+&!+<*!

hh!>&)=./*%=!(=Z!(@!+<*%*!(=!/&%*!=<*$!A.++*%!A&.F<+!+&?$-!+<$)!()!+<*(%!><('?<&&?D!f9D!89!+&!h9!

-*$%=!A*@&%*J!5<*!%*=.'+!&@!+<(=!Y.*=+(&)!(=!+<$+!$!'(++'*!A(+!'*==!+<$)!<$'@!&@!+<*!$)=4*%=!%*=7&)?*?!

p-*=q!\iir]!$)?!'(++'*!A(+!/&%*!&@!+<*!<$'@!%*=7&)?*?!p)&q!\hcr]J!5<*!%*/$%6=!@&%!$)=4*%()F!p)&q!

()>'.?*?! +<$+Z! \f]! A*@&%*! (+! 4$=! $! 2*%-! >&//&)! 7%&?.>+S! +<$+! \8]! +&?$-! +<*%*! $%*! /&%*!

=.A=+(+.+*=S! +<$+! \g]! (+! (=! ?*7*)?()F! &)! +<*! =*$=&)! &@! $2$('$A('(+-! &@! +<*! =<*$! ).+=! $)?! +<$+! \i]!

+&?$-!=<*$!A.++*%! (=!/&%*!*07*)=(2*J!;&%!$)=4*%()F!p-*=q!+&!+<*!Y.*=+(&)!O/&%*!=<*$!A.++*%! (=!

A&.F<+!+&?$-!O!+<*!$%F./*)+=!$%*Z!+<$+!\f]!+<*%*!$%*!/$)-!.=*=!*>&)&/(>$''-D!'(6*!+<*!()>%*$=()F!

*07&%+!$)?!+<$+!(+!>$)!A*!%*@()*?!$)?n&%!/$).@$>+.%*?!()!&+<*%!F&&?=S!\8]!+<*%*!(=!$!<(F<!?*/$)?!

@&%!=<*$! ()! +<*!=&.+<S! \g]!+<*%*! (=!/&%*!$4$%*)*==!&@!+<*!/$)-!?(%*>+!.=*=! '(6*!7%*7$%()F!@&&?D!

=6()! >$%*D! /*?(>()$'D! $)?! *2*)! /&.'?()F! A'&>6=! ()! >&)=+%.>+(&)! 4&%6! $%*! /*)+(&)*?S! \i]! =<*$!

A.++*%! (=!=+(''!F*)*%$'!.=*?!@&%!>&&6()FS! \h]!7%(>*=!$%*!><*$7*%! ()!>&/7$%(=&)!+&!&+<*%!=(/('$%!&('!

$)?!=6()>$%*!7%&?.>+=J!U*7*)?()F!&)!+<*!2(*4!&@!+<*!>&)=./*%!+<*!$)=4*%=!$%*!F(2*)J!V+!>$)!A*!

=$(?!+<$+!7*&7'*!$%*!$4$%*!$A&.+!4<$+! (=!<$77*)()F!&)!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!/$%6*+D! +<$+! (+!=+(''! (=!$!

>&//*%>($'!7%&?.>+!A.+!+<*!@&>.=!(=!=<(@+*?!/&%*!A*-&)?!+<*!'&>$'!%*F(&)=J!

E<*)!+<*!Y.*=+(&)=!$A&.+!$!><$)F*!()!Y.$)+(+-!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$%*!$=6*?!+&!+<*!>&)=./*%=!=(/('$%!

%*=.'+=!>$/*!&.+J!MA&.+!+<*!><$)F*!()!7%(>*!&2*%!+(/*D!+<*!()+*%2(*4*?!>&)=./*%=!$%*!=$-()F!+<$+!

A*@&%*!+<*!7%(>*=!4*%*!'*==!\Qhr!&@!hh!7*&7'*]!+<(=!A*>$.=*!&@!$!><$)F*!()!/&)*-!2$'.*D!A*>$.=*!

&@!+<*!'$%F*%!?*/$)?!&@!'&>$'!<&.=*<&'?!>&)=./*%=!$)?!A*>$.=*!&@!$!=/$''*%!/$%6*+J!

!

M!Y.*=+(&)! >&)>*%)()F!Y.$'(+-! ><$)F*!&@! =<*$!A.++*%!F(2*=! +<*! @&''&4()F! %*=.'+=J! K(0! 7*&7'*! $%*!

=$-()F! +<$+! +<*! Y.$'(+-! A*>$/*! '*==! \ffr]D! f9! 7*&7'*! +<$+! +<*! Y.$'(+-! (=! ()>%*$=*?! \fQr]D! gd!

7*&7'*!$%*!=$-()F!+<$+!+<*!Y.$'(+-!%*/$()=!+<*!=$/*!\cdr]!$)?!8!7*%=&)=!?&!)&+!<$2*!$)!&7()(&)!

\ir]J! M%F./*)+=! @&%! +<&=*! $)=4*%=! $%*! F(2*)! ()! +$A'*! cJcJ! K&/*! %*=7&)?*)+=! =$(?! +<$+!

/*><$)(l*?!A.++*%!7%&?.>+(&)!(/7%&2*=!+<*!Y.$'(+-D!A.+!=&/*!/*)+(&)*?!+<*!&77&=(+*J!5<*!+(/*!

=7*)?! +&! 7%&>*==! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%D! (=! =$(?! A-! =&/*! +&!/$6*! $! ?(@@*%*)>*! ()! +<*! Y.$'(+-! &@! +<*!

64

A.++*%J!T*@&%*D!*2*%-+<()F!4(+<()! +<*!7%&>*==!&@!/$6()F!+<*!A.++*%!4$=!.=*?!4$=!/*)+(&)*?!$=!

4*''! $=! $! Y.$'(+-! (==.*J! T.+! +<(=! %*/$%6! (=! /$-A*! )&+! )*>*==$%('-! /*$)+! @&%! +<*! Y.$'(+-! &@! +<*!

A.++*%!(+!=*'@D!$=!/&%*!$=!@&%!+<*!Y.$'(+-!&@!+<*!7%&>*==D!@&%!+<*!/()(/(l()F!$)?!%*>->'()F!&@!4$=+*!

7%&?.>*?!&@! +<*!7%&>*==J!,&=+!&@! +<*! ()+*%2(*4*?!7*&7'*!/*)+(&)*?! +<$+! +<*!Y.$'(+-! %*/$()*?!

+<*!=$/*J!T-!'&&6()F!$+!+<*!A.++*%!+<*-!?&!)&+!=**!$)-!?(@@*%*)>*=!&%!><$)F*=!()!+<*!Y.$'(+-!@%&/!

A*@&%*J!M)?!+<*!><$)F*!()!7%&>*==()F!?(?!)&+!><$)F*!+<*!Y.$'(+-!*(+<*%J!!

!

!

5$A'*!cJc!L!P7()(&)=!&)!+<*!><$)F*!&@!+<*!Y.$'(+-!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!+&?$-!>&/7$%*?!+&!f9!+&!h9!-*$%=!

A*@&%*!

!

3*==! ,&%*! K$/*!

L! _*&7'*! ?&! )&+! +$6*! +<*(%! +(/*!

$)-/&%*!+&!7%&>*==!!

!

L! 5<*! A.++*%! ! (=! /&%*!

$++%$>+(2*!)&4!

L!5<*!_%&>*==()F!(=!=+(''!+<*!=$/*D!

&)'-!'(++'*!/*><$)(=*?!

L! E(+<()! +<*! A.++*%! /$6()F!

7%&>*==D!$??(+(2*=!$%*!$??*?!

!

L! _*&7'*! ?&! 6)&4! /&%*!

<&4!+&!7%&>*==!

L! T-! '&&6()F! )&! ?(@@*%*)>*! (=!

=**)!

L! T*@&%*D! *2*%-+<()F! 4(+<()! +<*!

7%&>*==! &@! /$6()F! A.++*%! 4$=!

.=*?!

L! ,*><$)(=$+(&)!

(/7%&2*=!+<*!Y.$'(+-!

L!H&+<()F!(=!?&)*!+&!(/7%&2*!+<*!

Y.$'(+-!

!

L!3*==!?.*!+&!/*><$)(=$+(&)!

!

L! 5<*%*! $%*! /&%*! =<*$!

).+=!$2$('$A'*!

!

L!5<*!Y.$'(+-!>$)!)&+!><$)F*!

!! !! L!5<*!7%&>*==()F!&@!+<*!A.++*%! (=!

?(@@*%*)+D! A.+! ?(?! )&+! ><$)F*!

Y.$'(+-!

!

!

!

!

!

!

cJg!! K.A=+(+.+*=!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%!

!

5&?$-!&)!+<*! '&>$'!/$%6*+=!/$)-!=.A=+(+.+*=!>$)!%*7'$>*!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!U(@@*%*)+!>&&6()F!&('=!

?*7*)?()F!&)!+<*!@&&?!$)?!?(=<*=!7%*7$%*?!$)?!?*7*)?()F!&)!+<*!7%*@*%*)>*!&@!+<*!>&)=./*%J!

K&/*!7*&7'*!?(='(6*!+&!.=*!=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!@$2&.%!+<()F=!7%&?.>+=!4(+<!7$'/!&('!$=!&%!7*&7'*!?&!

)&+!'(6*!+<*!=/*''!$)?!+$=+*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!()!+<*(%!@&&?J!

!

V)! A&0! cJf! $)?! cJ8! ?(@@*%*)+! =.A=+(+.+*=! @&%! =<*$! A.++*%! $%*! F(2*)J! T&0! cJf! (=! $)! *0$/7'*! &@!

@%*Y.*)+'-!.=*?!*?(A'*!&('=!$)?!+<*%*!7%(>*=!()!899QJ!#&/7$%*?!+&!=<*$!A.++*%!+<*=*!&('=!$%*!/&%*!

*07*)=(2*!\=**!><$7+*%!c]J!#%.?*!=<*$!A.++*%!=&'?!A-!+<*!4&/*)!&)!+<*!/$%6*+=!+&!<&.=*<&'?=!

65

$)?!@&&?!=*''*%=!(=!$+!+<$+!+(/*!$+!/&=+!9Jdh!N<#!@&%!$!6('&J!V)!A&0!cJ8!=&/*!*0$/7'*=!&@!=6()>$%*!

7%&?.>+=! $%*! (''.=+%$+*?J! #&>&$! A.++*%! (=! $! 7&7.'$%! 7%&?.>+D! $)?! <$(%! 7%&?.>+=! $)?! =&$7=! $%*!

=.A=+(+.+*=!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%!$=!4*''J!!

V)+*%*=+()F!+&!)&+*!(=!+<$+!>&)=./*%=!

$)?! )&)L>&)=./*%=! &@! =<*$! A.++*%!

()+*%2(*4*?!?(?!)&+!$'4$-=!7*%>*(2*!

+<*!!

=.A=+(+.+*! 7%&?.>+=! $=! /&%*!

*07*)=(2*!+<$)!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!5<(=!

>$)!A*!?.*!+&!+<*!7%*@*%*)>*! ()!.=*!

&@! %*@()*?! /&%*! /&?*%)! 7%&?.>+=!

4<(><! $%*! $>>&.)+*?! $=! )&+! A*()F!

+&&! *07*)=(2*D! $=! (+! (=! $@@&%?$A'*! +&!

F*+J!

!

!

!

!

T&0! cJ8! L! C0$/7'*=! &@! =6()>$%*! 7%&?.>+=! $2$('$A'*! &)! +<*! /$%6*+! $)?! ()! +<*!

=<&7=D!N<$)$u!

!

_%&?.>+! M/&.)+! _%(>*! 3$)?!&@!7%&?.>+(&)!

L!#&>&$!A.++*%!

!!!!!5*)?%()$!

!!!!!C2*%=<**)!

L!U$%6!$)?!3&2*'-!

L!K&@+!B$(%!

L!GT!G)(2*%=$'!

L!M77'*!!

!!!!!B$(%!@&&?!

!!!!!B$(%!+%*$+/*)+!

!

K&$7=!

U*++&'D!N<*(=<$!D!3.0D!

_%*/(*%D! B$%/&)-D!

_<$%/$7.%! <*%A$'D!

V/7*%($'!'*$+<*%D!!

#$)&*D!3(@*A.&-!

R*-=&$7!A$%!

U.>6=&$7!A$%!

!

f89L8h9!/'!

!

f999!/'!

h99!/'!

f999!/'!

g99!/'!

!

!

!

!

899L8h9!F%!

!

!

!

!

899Lg99!F%!

g99Li99!F%!

!

8J99!O!gJ99!N<#!

!

QJ99!N<#!

gJ99!N<#!

hJd9!N<#!

!

8Jh9!N<#!

fJ89!N<#!

!

!

fJ99!L!fJQ9!N<#!

!

!

!

!

9Jg9!O!9JQ9!N<#!

9Jh9!O!f!N<#!

!

#~+*!?kV2&(%*!

!

#$)$?$!

#~+*!?kV2&(%*!

#~+*!?kV2&(%*!

H(F*%($!

!

!

!

!

H(F*%($D! G)('*2*%D!

G)('*2*%D!

H(F*%($}N<$)$D!

V)?&)*=($D! K&.+<!

M@%(>$D!N<$)$!

N<$)$!

N<$)$!

N<$)$!

u!?$+$!K*7+*/A*%!899Q!

!

T&0! cJf! L! C0$/7'*=! &@! @%*Y.*)+'-! .=*?! >&&6()F! &('=!

$2$('$A'*!&)!+<*!/$%6*+!$)?!()!+<*!=<&7=D!N<$)$u!!

!

P('! M/&.)+! _%(>*!

_$'/!&('! f!'(+*%! g!N<#!

;%-+&'! f!'(+*%! g!N<#!

N()&! f!'(+*%! gJh9!N<#!

T'.*A$)?!/$%F$%()*! 8h9!/F! fJf9!N<#!

X$F&!/$%F$%()*! :99!/F! g!N<#!

u!?$+$!K*7+*/A*%!899Q!

66

!

;(F.%*!cJQ!O!K6()'(F<+D!!

$! 7&7.'$%! =6()>$%*!

7%&?.>+!$=!4*''J!

!

cJi! V)!=./!

!

,&=+! >&)=./*%=! .=()F! =<*$! A.++*%! ()+*%2(*4*?! $%*! 4&/*)! \Qdr! &@! d9! 7*&7'*]! 4<&! $%*! )&+!

@&%/$'! *?.>$+*?! $)?! $%*! =*''()F! @&&?! $'&)F! +<*! =+%**+! =(?*D! $+! +<*! /$%6*+! =(?*! &%! @%&/! +<*(%!

<&.=*=J!5<*!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!.=*?!$=!*?(A'*!&('!@&%!>&&6()F!$)?!@&%!=6()>$%*!A-!<&.=*<&'?!/*/A*%=!

\icr!&@!hh!>&)=./*%=]D!A-!<&.=*<&'?!/*/A*%=!$)?!()!$??(+(&)!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!.=*?!$=!*?(A'*!&('!()!

=*''()F!'&>$'!=)$>6=!$)?!/*$'=!\fQr!&@!hh!>&)=./*%=]!$)?!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!=&'*'-!A&.F<+!@&%!=*''()F!

@&&?!?(=<*=!>&&6*?!()!=<*$!A.++*%!\gcr!&@!hh!>&)=./*%=]J!!

!

5<*!><$%$>+*%(=+(>=!7*%>*(2*?!A-!>&)=./*%=!$)?!)&)L>&)=./*%=!&)!4<(><!><&(>*=!$%*!/$?*D!$%*!

A*+4**)! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%! >&'&.%! \4<(+*D! -*''&4D! $)-! +-7*]D! A*+4**)! +<*! +*0+.%*! &@! +<*! A.++*%!

\<$%?D!=&@+D!$)-!+-7*]!$)?!+<*!=/*''!$)?!+$=+*J!5<*!()+*%2(*4**=!$%*!$=6*?!$A&.+!+<*(%!><&(>*!&@!

=<*$!A.++*%!A-!+<*!4$-!+<*-!7*%>*(2*!(+k=!Y.$'(+-!\=**!&2*%2(*4!+$A'*!cJd!A*'&4]J!E<(+*!A.++*%!(=!

><&=*)!+<*!/&=+!\=**!$'=&!@(F.%*!cJg]D!7%&A$A'-!A*>$.=*!(+!(=!.=*?!/&%*!@%*Y.*)+'-!()!>&&6()F!$)?!

A&.F<+!()!'$%F*%!Y.$)+(+-!+<$)!-*''&4!A.++*%J!^*''&4!A.++*%!(=!/&%*!F*)*%$'!.=*?!@&%!=6()>$%*!$)?!

=**)! $=! $++%$>+(2*D! *=7*>($''-! @&%! >&)=./*%=! &@! +<*! =&.+<! &@! N<$)$D! +<(=! >&)=(?*%*?! A-! +<*!

)&%+<*%)!.%A$)!+%$?*%=!$)?!>&)=./*%=!\=**!$'=&!+$A'*!cJf]J!B$%?!A.++*%!\><&=*)!A-!hgr]!(=!=**)!

A-!=*2*%$'!$=!>&)+$()()F!'&4!>&)>*)+%$+(&)!&@!4$+*%!$)?!@&%!+<$+!/$++*%!>&)+$()()F!/&%*!&('J!5<*!

=&@+! =<*$!A.++*%! \><&=*)!A-!8hr]! (=! ><&=*)! @&%! +<*! &77&=(+*! %*$=&)!$=! +<*!<$%?!A.++*%D! @&%! (+=k!

*$=-! /*'+()F! A*>$.=*! &@! +<*! <(F<*%! 4$+*%! >&)+*)+J! #&)=./*%=! ><&&=()F! $)-! +-7*! &@! A.++*%!

\><&=*)! A-! 89r]! ?&! )&+! >&)=(?*%! +<*! ?(@@*%*)>*! ()! +*0+.%*D! $)?! $%*! '&&6()F! $+! /&%*! *0+*%)$'!

@$>+&%=!$=!$2$('$A('(+-!\=**!$'=&!+$A'*!cJ8]J!

!

!

5$A'*!cJd!L!P2*%2(*4!&@!7*%>*)+$F*!&@!7*&7'*k=!><&(>*!\hh!7*&7'*]!()!=<*$!A.++*%!!

!

5<*!><&(>*!&@!>&'&.%Z! !

! !

E<(+*! ! dgr!

^*''&4!! fcr!

M)-!>&'&.%! ffr!

5<*!><&(>*!()!+*0+.%*Z!

!

B$%?! ! hgr!

K&@+! ! 8hr!

M)-!+-7*! 89r! !

P+<*%! ! 8r!

!

67

P2*%2(*4!&7()(&)=Z!

!

#&'&.%!

E<(+*Z!!! >&//&)!.=*D!>&&6()FD!7.%*!A.++*%J!

^*''&4Z!! =6()>$%*D!$++%$>+(2*D!$++%$>+(2*!+&!=&.+<*%)!N<$)$D!*0+%$!@'$2&.%!()!

>&&6()FJ!

M)-!>&'&.%Z!! )&!?(@@*%*)>*=!=**)D!>&'&.%!?*7*)?*)+!&)!.=*!$)?!$2$('$A('(+-!&)!/$%6*+!

!

5*0+.%*!

B$%?Z!! ! >&//&)!.=*D!A*++*%!7%*=*%2$+(&)D!'&4!4$+*%!>&)+*)+D!/&%*!&('D!F&&?!@&%!

>&&6()F!

K&@+Z!! ! *$=-!/*'+()FD!=6()>$%*D!@%*=<)*==D!><*$7*%!

M)-!+*0+.%*Z!! ?*7*)?()F!&)!$2$('$A('(+-D!=*$=&)D!7%&>*==()FD!A.-*%=S!)&!?(@@*%*)>*!

!

5<*! Y.$)+(+-! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! >&)=./*%=D! <&.=*<&'?=! $)?! @&&?! =*''*%=D! A.-! $%*! %*'$+(2*'-! =/$''!

$/&.)+=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$+!&)>*J!5<(=!>$)!A*!/$)-!=/$''!7(*>*=!()!&)*!+(/*!$=!4*''J!,&=+!&@!+<*!

=/$''! Y.$)+(+(*=! =&'?! $%*! =/$''! =(l*=! &@! >$J! i9F%$/=! *$><! &%! ()! A&4'=! &@! >$J! h6F! \=**! 7%*2(&.=!

@(F.%*=!cJi!$)?!cJh]J!M/&.)+=!A*+4**)!9Jh! +&!8!&@!=/$''!=(l*=!$%*!A&.F<+!+<*!/&=+! \i9r!&@! +<*!

A.-*%=!&@! =/$''! =(l*=]! 7*%!/&)+<J!j.$)+(+(*=!&@! g! +&!h!A&4'=! 7*%!/&)+<! (=! +<*!/&=+! @%*Y.*)+'-!

A&.F<+!$/&.)+!&@!A&4'=J!

!

H&)L>&)=./*%=!()+*%2(*4*?!\fh!7*%=&)=]!$%*!)&+!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%!A*>$.=*!+<*-!$%*!)&+!@$/('($%!

+&!(+!$)?!F%*4!.7!*'=*4<*%*!&%!*07'$()*?!+<$+!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!.=*?!A*@&%*!4$=!A*++*%!+<$)!()!+<*!

.%A$)!$%*$!&@!5$/$'*J!P+<*%! %*$=&)=!F(2*)!$%*!$A&.+!.=$F*!&)>*! ()!$!4<('*D! @&%!*0$/7'*! ()! +<*!

?%-!=*$=&)D!@&%!/*?(>()$'!&%!%(+.$'!7.%7&=*=J!K&/*!1.=+!?&!)&+!'(6*!+<*!=/*''!$)?!+$=+*!$)?!7%*@*%!

&+<*%!%*@()*?!7%&?.>+=J!M)!&+<*%!%*$=&)!&@!)&+!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!+<*!?(='(6*!+<$+!&+<*%!7*&7'*!

<$2*!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%J!5<*-!4&.'?!A*!%*'.>+$)+!*$+()F!=<*$!A.++*%!?(=<*=!A*>$.=*!&@!+<*!+$=+*!$)?!

=/*''!&%!+<*-!4&.'?!A*!%*'.>+$)+!+&!=/*$%!=<*$!A.++*%!&)!+<*(%!A&?(*=!A*>$.=*!&@!+<*!=>*)+!$)?!

+*0+.%*J! #&)=./*%=! ?&! 6)&4! <&4! +&! (/7%&2*! =+%&)F! =/*''! $)?! +$=+*! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! A-! $??()F!

&)(&)=!$)?!=7(>*=!()!+<*!=<*$!&('!$)?!7*%@./*D!&%$)F*!7**'=D!@%*=<!=>*)+()F!=**?=!&%!&+<*%!A&?-!

>%Ä/*=!!@&%!*0$/7'*!()!+<*!=<*$!=6()>$%*!7%&?.>+J!

5%*)?=!&)!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!/$%6*+!$%*!7*%>*(2*?!A-!+<*!>&)=./*%=!$=!+<*%*!(=!$)!*>&)&/(>!@&>.=!

+<$+!=<(@+*?!/&%*!+&!+<*!=&.+<*%)!%*F(&)=!$)?!+&!+<*!*07&%+!+%$?*J!5<*!4$-!&@!7%&>*==()F!(=!\=*/(]!

/*><$)(l*?J!5<(=!(=!)&+!$'4$-=!7*%>*(2*?!$=!$)!(/7%&2*/*)+!@&%!+<*!Y.$'(+-!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!A-!

+<*! >&)=./*%=J! M>+.$''-! /&=+! >&)=./*%=! %*=7&)?*?! +&! =**! )&! ><$)F*! ()! +<*! Y.$'(+-! ?.*! +&!

/*><$)(l$+(&)!&@!+<*!7%&>*==()F!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!

K.A=+(+.+*=!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%!@%*Y.*)+'-!$>>&.)+*?!$%*!7$'/&('D!�@%-+&'k!$)?!�N()&k!&('J!#&>&$!A.++*%D!

�=6()'(F<+k!$)?!�'.0k!$)?!�6*-k!=&$7!$%*!/*)+(&)*?!A-!/&=+!$=!7&7.'$%!=6()!>$%*!7%&?.>+=J!C2*)!$=!

+<*=*! 7%&?.>+=! $%*! /&%*! *07*)=(2*! +<$)! =<*$! A.++*%D! (+! (=! )&+! $'4$-=! 7*%>*(2*?! +<$+! 4$-! A-!

>&)=./*%=J! ,&?*%)D! %*@()*?! $)?! )(>*'-! 7$>6$F*?! 7%&?.>+=! $%*! 7&7.'$%! $/&)F! +<*! 7*&7'*! ()!

5$/$'*!$'+<&.F<!7*&7'*!?&!6)&4!+<*!<*$'()F!$)?!<*$'+<-!7%&7*%+(*=!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!V)!>$=*=!

&@!)**?D!$=!()!+<*!B$%/$++$)!=*$=&)D!@&%!4&.)?!<*$'()F!&%!@&%!%(+.$'!7.%7&=*=!7*&7'*!?&!()+*)?!+&!

.=*! +<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!M'+<&.F<! +<*!><$)F*! ()! �/&?*%)k!/()?=*+D! (+! =+(''! =**/=!+<$+!/$)-!7*&7'*!

.=*!=<*$!A.++*%!@&%!>&&6()F!'&>$'!?(=<*=!$)?!@&%!=6()>$%*!7.%7&=*=J!

!

68

#<$7+*%!d!!5<*!>$=*!&@!R7$%*Z!!

!

5<*!c9!4&/*)! ()+*%2(*4*?! ()!R7$%*! $%*! $''! ()2&'2*?! ()! +<*!7(>6()F! &@!).+=J!P)'-! =&/*!4&/*)!

=.><! $=! *'?*%'-! &%! =(>6'-! 4&/*)! 4(+<! ?(=$A('(+-! &@! 7(>6()F! ).+=! ?&)k+! *)F$F*! ()! =<*$! ).+=!

>&''*>+(&)J!!

h9! r! &@! 4&/*)! ()+*%2(*4*?! ()! R7$%*! >&''*>+*?! ).+=! @%&/! &)'-! A.=<! A*>$.=*! +<*-! ?&)k+! <$2*!

$>>*==!+&!@$%/'$)?!&%!A*>$.=*!=<*$!+%**=!()!+<*!@$%/'$)?!?&)k+!-(*'?J!g9!r!&@!4&/*)!()+*%2(*4*?!

F&! +&!A&+<!A.=<!$)?!@$%/'$)?!$)?!=+$%+!.=.$''-!A-!F&()F!+&!+<*!A.=<!A*>$.=*!>&/7*+(+(&)!4(+<!

&+<*%!4&/*)!(=!<(F<*=+!+<*%*J!!5<*!&+<*%!89r!&)'-!7(>6!=<*$!).+=!@%&/!+<*!@$%/'$)?J!!

M''! +<*! /*)! ()+*%2(*4*?! &)'-! 7(>6! =<*$! ).+=! &)! +<*(%! @$%/'$)?J! M=! @$%! $=! +<*! ><('?%*)! $%*!

>&)>*%)*?D!8!&@!+<*/!F&!&)'-!+&!+<*!A.=<D!g!&+<*%=!&)'-!+&!+<*!@$%/'$)?!&@!+<*(%!@$%+<*%!$)?!+<*!8!

'$=+!+&!A&+<J!

!

V)!R7$%*D!+<*!$2*%$F*!$/&.)+!&@!=<*$!@%.(+=!>&''*>+*?!7*%!4&/*)!7*%!?$-!$+!7*$6!&@!+<*!@%.(+()F!

=*$=&)!(=!!$A&.+!8h!+&!g9!6FJ!T.+!+<(=!Y.$)+(+-!(=!'*==!$+!+<*!A*F())()F!$)?!*)?()F!&@!+<*!<$%2*=+!

=*$=&)D! $)?! (=! $'=&! '*==! @&%! 4&/*)! &@! &'?! $F*D! 4<&! 4(''! >&''*>+! fh! 6F! &)! $2*%$F*J! V@! +<(=! (=!

*0+%$7&'$+*?!&2*%!+<*!@%.(+()F!=*$=&)D!fi99!6F!&@!@%.(+=!>$)!A*!7(>6*?!4<(><!%*=.'+=! ()!8Q9!6F!&@!

6*%)*'=J!B&4*2*%D! +<*! ()+*%2(*4*?!4&/*)! ()?(>$+*?!+&!>&''*>+!$)!$2*%$F*!&@!fQ9! L!8i9!6FJ!5<(=!

?(@@*%*)>*! >$)! A*! *07'$()*?! A*>$.=*! +<*! 7(>6*%=! $%*! )&+! $A'*! +&! 7(>6! &)! =&/*! ?$-=! ?.*! +&!!

=(>6)*==!&@!+<*/=*'2*=!&%!@$/('-!/*/A*%=!&%!<$2()F!&+<*%!$>+(2(+(*=!=.><!$=!@$%/!4&%6D!@.)*%$'=!

$)?!@$/('-!2(=(+=J!!

!

f!h!4**6=!0!i!?$-=!0!fh!6F!}!:!4**6=!0!i!?$-=!0!g9!6F!o!fi99!6F!&@!@%.(+=!\fgQ9!6F]!

89r!&@!fi99!6F!o!8Q9!6F!&@!6*%)*'=J!!

!

dJf! _%&>*==()F!

M''!+<*!4&/*)!()+*%2(*4*?!()!R7$%*!7%&>*==!).+=!()+&!6*%)*'=!+<*/=*'2*=D!*0>*7+!&)*J!!

M/&)F!+<*!c9!4&/*)!()+*%2(*4*?!()!R7$%*D!hd!4&/*)!.=*!6*%)*'=!@&%!/$6()F!A.++*%J!8!4&/*)!

<$2*!+&!=*''!$''!+<*(%!).+=!+&!A.-!@&&?D!gQ!&@!4&/*)!=*''!$!7$%+!&@!+<*!6*%)*'=!$)?!6**7!=&/*!@&%!

+<*(%!&4)!.=*J!!

M/&)F!+<*!h!/*)! ()+*%2(*4*?D!i!F(2*!=&/*!6*%)*'=!+&!+<*(%!4(2*=!&%!/&+<*%=!$)?!=*''! +<*!%*=+J!

P)*!=*''=!$''!+<*!).+=!+<$+!<*!>&''*>+=J!5<*!d!><('?%*)!()+*%2(*4*?!F(2*!$A&.+!fng!&@!+<*!6*%)*'=!+&!

+<*(%!/&+<*%!$)?!=*''!+<*!%*=+J!!

M/&)F!+<*!hd!$''!7%&>*==!6*%)*'=!()+&!=<*$!A.++*%!+<*/=*'2*=D!<&4*2*%!c!&.+!&@!+<*=*!hd!?(?!)&+!

*0+%$>+!A.++*%!A*>$.=*!+<*!4&%6!(=!+&&!<*$2-!@&%!+<*/!?.*!+&!+<*(%!&'?!$F*J!,&=+!&@!+<*/!7%&>*==!

6*%)*'=!/$).$''-S! &)'-! c! ! F&! +&! +<*! F%()?()F!/$><()*! =&/*+(/*=! ()! R$%)(D! ! K$)+.! &%! X(%$7$J! V)!

F*)*%$'D!+<(=! (=!&)'-!?&)*!4<*)! '$%F*!Y.$)+(+(*=!)**?!+&!A*!7%&>*==*?!$+!+<*!=$/*!+(/*D! @&%!+<*!

7.%7&=*!&@!=*''()FJ!

fc!r!=*''!=&/*!&@!+<*(%!A.++*%J!5<*!&+<*%!Qir!.=*!=<*$!A.++*%!&)'-!@&%!<&/*!>&)=./7+(&)J!E(+<!

&.%!?$+$D!$2*%$F*!$)).$'!>&)=./7+(&)!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!()!R7$%*!<$=!A**)!*=+(/$+*?!$+!hhJc!6F!7*%!

<&.=*<&'?J! 5<*-! >&)=./*! =<*$! A.++*%! ?.%()F! +<*! *)+(%*! -*$%! A.+! /&%*! ?.%()F! +<*! =*$=&)! &@!

@$%/()FD!4<*)! +<*! 6*%)*'=! $)?! A.++*%! $%*! %*$?('-! $2$('$A'*J! M/&)F!4&/*)! ()+*%2(*4*?! $''! .=*!

69

=<*$!A.++*%!@&%!>&&6()FD!8ng!$'=&!.=*!(+!+&!/$6*!=&$7J!P)'-!$!@*4!&@!+<*/!.=*!=<*$!A.++*%!@&%!=6()!

+%*$+/*)+S!(+!(=!/$()'-!.=*?!@&%!A$A-!=6()J!

dJ8! T.-()F!$)?!=*''()F!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!

5<*!Y.$)+(+-!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!A&.F<+!&%!*(+<*%!=&'?!?(@@*%=!$!'&+!7*%!4&/$)J!3$=+!-*$%!\899d]D!=&/*!

&@!+<*/D!?(?)k+!A.-!&%!=*''!$)-+<()FJ!M+!+<*!=$/*!+(/*D!&+<*%=!A&.F<+!8!A$F=!&@!=<*$!).+=!$)?!%*L

=&'?!(+!$+!$!<(F<*%!7%(>*J!3$=+!-*$%D!$/&)F!4&/*)!()+*%2(*4*?D!fng!A&.F<+!).+=!$)?!fng!A&.F<+!

A.++*%J!M/&)F!+<&=*!4<&!A&.F<+!).+=D!8ng!A&.F<+!).+=! +&!/$6*!A.++*%! @&%!<&/*!>&)=./7+(&)!

$)?!fni!@&%!=*''()F!+<*/!'$+*%!4<*)!+<*!7%(>*!F&+!<(F<*%J!f9r!&@!+<*!4&/*)!/$6*!A.++*%!+&!=*''!(+J!

54&!&.+!&@!@(2*!&@!+<*!/*)!()+*%2(*4*?!A&.F<+!=&/*!=<*$!6*%)*'=!).+=!'$=+!-*$%!=+&%*!+<*/D!=*''!

+<*!6*%)*'=!!'$+*%!$+!<(F<*%!7%(>*=J!

K&/*!4&/*)! 7%*@*%! A.-()F! A.++*%! %$+<*%! +<$)! ).+=! A*>$.=*! +<*-! >$)! .=*! (+! (//*?($+*'-! $)?!

A*>$.=*! @%&/! =&/*! ).+=! $%*! &@! '*==! Y.$'(+-! @%&/! 4<(><! )&+! /.><! A.++*%! >$)! A*! *0+%$>+*?J!

B&4*2*%D!=&/*!4&/*)!*07'$()*?!+<$+!+<*-!7%*@*%!A.-()F!).+=!+<$)!A.++*%!A*>$.=*!=&/*!=*''*%=!

7.+!7&%%(?F*!()+&!A.++*%!+&!/$6*!(+!'&&6!<*$2(*%J!!!

E&/*)! 7%*@*%! =*''()F! A.++*%! +&! F*+! $! <(F<*%! 7%&@(+J! B&4*2*%D! /&=+! &@! +<*/! )**?! +&! =*''! +<*!

6*%)*'=D! A*>$.=*! +<*-! $%*! )**?!/&)*-! &)! $! =<&%+! +*%/! $)?! ?&! )&+! <$2*! +(/*! +&! 7%&>*==! +<*!

6*%)*'=!()+&!A.++*%J!!

dJg! M>>*==!+&!/$%6*+!

5<*!=(l*!&@! +<*!/$%6*+! ()!R7$%*!&)!+<*!&)>*!*2*%-!=(0!?$-=!/$%6*+! (=! 2*%-!=/$''! %*'$+(2*! +&! +<*!

)*(F<A&.%()F! 2(''$F*=J!E<('*! ()!&+<*%! 2(''$F*=! '(6*!_(()$D! R$)((! $)?!G'&!/$)-! +%$?*%=! >&/*! @%&/!

&.+=(?*D!+<*!/$%6*+!&@!R7$%*!(=!/&%*!$!=/$''!/$%6*+!$/&)F=+!+<*!()<$A(+$)+=!&@!R7$%*!(+=*'@J!!

5&! %*$><! $! '$%F*%!/$%6*+! ()<$A(+$)+=! &@! R7$%*! F*)*%$''-! +%$2*'! +&! _(()$! &)! (+=!/$%6*+! ?$-J! 5<(=!

/$%6*+!(=!%*'$+(2*'-!)*$%!\f9!6/]!$)?!'$%F*!>&/7$%*?!+&!+<*!&+<*%!2(''$F*=!()!+<*!)*(F<A&.%<&&?J!

5&!F&!@%&/!R7$%*!+&!_(()$!(+!+$6*=!$A&.+!8!<&.%=!A-!@&&+!$)?!ih!/()!A-!A(>->'*J!!

dJi! M>>*==!+&!+%$)=7&%+$+(&)!

R7$%*!'(*=!%*'$+(2*'-!@$%!\}nL!g9!6/]!@%&/!+&4)=!'(6*!H$)?&/!$)?!X(%$7$J!5<*!%&$?=!.)+('!X(%$7$!$%*!

=$)?-! %&$?=! $)?! +<*%*! (=! )&! %*F.'$%! +%$)=7&%+! >&))*>+()F! R7$%*! +&! $?1$>*)+! 2(''$F*=! &%! +&4)=J!

5<*%*!$%*!$!@*4!%*F.'$%'-!/$%6*+!+%.>6=!7$==()F!A-J!5<*%*!(=!&)*!F&()F!@%&/!_(()$!+&!E$D!+<$+!%.)!

+<%&.F<!R7$%*J!B&4*2*%D! (+! +*)?=! +&! A*!&2*%'&$?*?!A*@&%*! (+! %*$><*=!R7$%*! $)?! A*=(?*=! +<(=! (+!

?&*=! )&+! <$2*! $! @(0*?! %&.+*S! (+! =&/*+(/*=! 7$==*=! +<%&.F<! R7$%*D! A.+! =&/*+(/*=! ?&*=)k+! 7$==!

R7$%*!$+!$''J!!

5<*!>&=+!+&!F&!&)!$!/$%6*+!+%.>6n!>$%!+&!_(()$!/$%6*+!>&=+=!9Dd!+&!9Dfi!GKmJ!5&!>$%%-!$!'&$?!&@!+<*!

=(l*!&@!$!=+$)?$%?!+%$)=7&%+!A$F!>&=+!$)!$??(+(&)$'!9DcQ!GKmJ!

,&=+'-!4&/*)! +<$+! >&/*! @%&/! R7$%*! &)! +<*! _(()$!/$%6*+! F&! A-! @&&+! A*>$.=*! +<*-! >$)k+! @()?!

+%$)=7&%+!&%!>$)k+!$@@&%?!(+J!K&!+<*-!>$%%-!7%&?.>+=!&)!+<*(%!<*$?J!N*)*%$''-!+<*!/$0(/./!4*(F<+!

+<*-!>$)!>$%%-!(=!g9!6F!$)?!@&%!+<&=*!4<&!$%*!'*==!=+%&)FD!'(6*!&'?*%!'$?(*=D!>$))&+!>$%%-!/&%*!+<$)!

fh6FJ!;.%+<*%!/&%*D!+<*-!&)'-!<$2*!$>>*=!+&!_(()$!/$%6*+J!X(%$7$D!(=!F*)*%$''-!+&&!@$%D!4<('*!7%(>*=!

&@@*%*?!@&%!+<*!).+=!+<*%*!$%*!<(F<*%!+<$)!()!_(()$J!!

!

K&D!()!899dD!d9!r!&@!+<*!*0><$)F*!&@!+<*!%*=7&)?*)+=!()!R7$%*!4$=!?&)*!&)!_(()$!/$%6*+!$)?!8hr!

()! R7$%*J! 5<*! hr! %*/$()()F! >&)>*%)! *0><$)F*! 4<(><! 4$=! ?&)*! ()! 7'$>*! $%&.)?! '(6*! R$%)((! &%!

X(%$7$J!

70

dJh! K.77'-!$)?!?*/$)?!

E&/*)!?&)k+!>&/7'$()!$A&.+!?(@@(>.'+(*=!+&!=*''J! V)!=&/*!>$=*=!+%$?*%=!>&/*!+&!A.-!$+!<*!@$%/!

F$+*J!P+<*%=!>$)!*$=('-!=*''!$''!+<*-!>$%%-!+&!+<*!/$%6*+D!4(+<!+<*!*0>*7+(&)!&@!+<*!7*%(&?!@%&/!X.'-!

+&!M.F.=+!A*>$.=*!&@!+<*!A(F!=.77'-J!!

V)! =&/*! >$=*=! +<*! 4&/*)! =*''! @&%! $! %*'$+(2*'-! '&4! 7%(>*! $+! +<*! @$%/! F$+*! ?.*! +&! .)>*%+$()+-!

4<*+<*%! $)&+<*%!/(??'*/$)!4(''! 7$==! A-! $)?!4<*+<*%! <(=! &@@*%*?! 7%(>*=!4('! A*! <(F<*%! &%! )&+J!

,$)-!&@!+<*!=<*$!).+!7(>6*%=!$%*!)**?!@&%!/&)*-!&)!+<*!=<&%+!+*%/!$)?!=&!=&/*+(/*=!=*''! +<*!

=<*$!6*%)*'=D!*2*)!+<&.F<!+<*-!*07*>+!7%(>*=!+&!%(=*!4(+<()!$!/&)+<!&%!+4&J!

5<*!4&/*)!%*=7&)?*)+=!()?(>$+*?!+<$+!+<*!/&)*-!@%&/!=<*$!7%&?.>+!(=!=7*)?!&)!+<*!@&''&4()F!

+<()F=S!!hc!r!+&!A.-!=&.7!()F%*?(*)+!&%!@&&?D!8dr!+&!A.-!>'&+<*=D!fh!r!+&!F&!+&!+<*!>&%)!/(''D!f9!r!

+&!7$-!=><&&'=!@**=D!ir!+&!7$-!/*?(>$'!@**=D!c!r!+&!()2*=+!()!7%&?.>+!+<$+!+<*-!>$)!=*''!'$+*%!'(6*!

=<*$!6*%)*'=D!F%&.)?!).+=!&%!F.()*$!>&%)!@&%!/$6()F!'&>$'!A**%J!!

#<('?%*)!.=*=!/&)*-!/$()'-!+&!A.-!=><&&'=!=+.@@=!'(6*!7*)=D!A&&6=D!.)(@&%/!$?!=$)?$'=J!,*)!.=*!

/&)*-! +&! ()2*=+! ()! @$%/! +&&'=! &%! +&! ()2*=+! ()! 7%&?.>+! +<$+! +<*-! >$)! =*''! '$+*%D! '(6*! $)(/$'=! $)?!

F%&.)?).+=J!54&!&@!+<*/!.=*!/&)*-!/&=+'-!+&!A.-!A**%J!;&%!=&/*!&@!7*&7'*!+<*!=*''()F!&@!=<*$!

7%&?.>+=!$%*!+<*!&)'-!=&.%>*!&@!()>&/*D!+<(=!(=!7$%+(>.'$%%-!+<*!>$=*!@&%!><('?%*)!$)?!@&%!&'?!'$?(*=!

4<&!>$)k+!@$%/!$)-/&%*!

!

dJc! K<*$!).+=!@$>+&%-!()!R7$%*e!

K+%*)F+<! &@! +<*! =<*$! ).+! @$>&%-! $%*! +<$+! +<*%*! (=! $)! )$+(&)4(?*! $)?! ()+*%)$+(&)$'! ?*/$)?! @&%!

=<*$!A.++*%!$)?!()!R7$%*!+<*%*!$!%*'$+(2*'-!<(F<!=<*$!).+!7%&?.>+(&)J!T*=(?*=!+<(=!+<*%*!(=!$!HNP!

+<$+!<$=!&@@*%*?!+&!7%&2(?*!@&%!+<*!=<*$!).+!@$>+&%-!>&)=+%.>+(&)!$)?!/$><()*=J!5<*!7%&?.>+(&)!

>$7$>(+-!&@!6*%)*'=!&@!+<*!2(''$F*!(=!*=+(/$+*?!$+!gh!+&)=!7*%!-*$%D!4<(><!4&.'?!%*=.'+!()!fi!+&)!&@!

=<*$!A.++*%!7*%!-*$%J!B&4*2*%!+<*%*!$%*!'$%F*!>&)=+%$()+=!>&)>*%)()F!7%&?.>+(&)!>&=+=D!$)?!+<*!

%*/&+*)*==!&@!+<*!2(''$F*J!5<(=!/$6*=!+<*!7'$>*/*)+!&@!$!=<*$!).+!@$>+&%-!4(+<!+<*!>.%%*)+!7%(>*=!

@&%! @.*'=! $)?! ).+=! $)?! &+<*%! 7%&?.>+(&)! >&=+=! =**/!<$%?'-! 7%&@(+$A'*J! ;%&/! +<*! *07*%(/*)+! &@!

=*/(L$.+&/$+*?!7%&>*==()F!()!X(%$7$D!$)?!6)&4()F!+<$+!%*=&.%>*!>&=+!$)?!+%$)=7&%+!>&=+!4(''!A*!

<(F<*%! +<$)! ()! +<$+! *07*%(/*)+! ?.*! +&! +<*! %*/&+*)*==! &@! +<*! 2(''$F*D! +<*! $??*?! 2$'.*! (=! )&+!

*07*>+*?! +&! 4*(F<! .7! +&! @.*'! $)?! /$()+*)$)>*! >&=+J! ;&%! *0$/7'*=D! /$)-! =7$%*! 7$%+=! &@! +<*!

/$><()*=!$%*!&)'-!=&'?!()!X(%$7$D!&%!()!E$J!!

M>>&%?()F! +&! +<*! %*=.'+=! ()! +$A'*! [J! (+! 4&.?! A*! /&%*! 7%&@(+$A'*! +&! ?&! /$).$'! =<*$! A.++*%!

*0+%$>+(&)! +<$)!+&!7%&>*==! (+!4(+<!+<*!$(?!&@!/$><()*=!*2*)! (@! +<*!*0+%$! '$A&.%!+(/*!)**?*?!@&%!

+<*!*0+%$>+(&)!(=!7$-*?!@&%!()!+<*!'&>$'!?$('-!4$F*J!

71

D0&24'1,0&1!E!),12'11,0&!F<GH!AA!!

!

5<*! >&/7$)(*=! $%*! =/$''D! &A2(&.='-! +<*%*! $%*! &7+(&)=! @&%! F%&4+<! A.+! +<*)! +<*! ()! 7%*2(&.=!

7$%$F%$7<!/*)+(&)*?!>&)=+%$()+=!<$2*!+&!A*!@$>*?!$)?!&77&%+.)(+(*=!<$2*!+&!A*!.+('(=*?J!

!

V+! (=! ?(@@(>.'+! +&! F$+<*%! %*'($A'*! Y.$)+(+$+(2*! ?$+$J! 5%$?*%=! $%*! )&+! 2*%-! *$=-! ()! F(2()F! &.+!

()@&%/$+(&)!$A&.+!Y.$)+(+(*=!$)?!7%(>*=J!_$%+'-!A*>$.=*!&@! +<*!>&/7*+(+(&)! ()! +<(=!A.=()*==!A.+!

)&+!+<$+!/$)-!%*>&%?=!$A&.+!Y.$)+(+(*=!+%$?*?!$)?!7%(>*=!()!?(@@*%*)+!-*$%=!$%*!6*7+!$=!4*''J!

!

5<*!7%&?.>+(&)!&@!>&=/*+(>=!>$)!A*!()>%*$=*?!+&!$!<(F<*%!'*2*'D!A&+<!&)!+<*!Y.$)+(+$+(2*!=(?*!$=!

&)!+<*!Y.$'(+$+(2*!=(?*J!!

_%&?.>*%=! &@! =<*$! >&=/*+(>=! $%*! '&&6()F! @&%! /$%6*+! @&%! +<*(%! 7%&?.>+=! $A%&$?J! V+! >&.'?! A*!

()+*%*=+()F! V! +<*-!4&.'?! @&>.=!/&%*!&)! +<*!/$%6*+! ()!N<$)$!$)?!E*=+!M@%(>$J! C=7*>($''-! F(2()F!

$++*)+(&)!+&!>&)=./*%!$4$%*)*==!@&%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=!$)?!>%*$+()F!$!/$%6*+!$%*!><$''*)F*=!+<$+!+<*!

7%&?.>*%=! $)?! +%$?*%=! <$2*! +&! @$>*J! 5<*%*! 4&.'?! A*! '*==! +%$)=$>+(&)! >&=+=! ()2&'2*?! $)?! +<*!

7%&?.>*%=! $)?! +%$?*%=! >&.'?! <$2*! /&%*! A$%F$()()F! 7&4*%! ()! >&/7$%(=&)! 4(+<! +<*! /$%6*+=! ()!

4*=+*%)!>&.)+%(*=J!5<(=!>$)!>%*$+*!<(F<*%!7%&@(+!&)!+<*(%!7%&?.>+=J!!

!

M)! (/7&%+$)+! Y.*=+(&)! (=! 4<*+<*%! +<*! 4&/*)! ()! +<*! )&%+<! &@! N<$)$! >$)! A*! ()2&'2*?! ()! +<*!

7%&?.>+(&)!&@!<(F<!Y.$'(+-!>&=/*+(>!7%&?.>+=J!M)?!%*'$+*?!+&!+<(=S!4<$+!$%*!+<*!&77&%+.)(+(*=!@&%!

4&/*)!()!+<*!)&%+<!+&!()>%*$=*!+<*(%!=+$)?$%?!&@!'(2()F!+<%&.F<!+%$?*!()!@()(=<*?!=<*$!\>&=/*+(>]!

7%&?.>+=e!

!

5<*%*! (=!?(=>.==(&)!7&==(A'*! $A&.+! (@! +<*! %(F<+!7*&7'*!?(?! +<(=! %*=*$%><J!H&4!$!F%&.7!&@!U.+><n!

;%*)><! =+.?*)+=! 4*)+! +&! N<$)$! +&! ?&! +<(=! %*=*$%><J! V+! >&.'?! A*! Y.*=+(&)*?! (@! +<(=! (=! +<*! A*=+!

><&(>*!A*>$.=*!/$-A*!$!%*=*$%><!'(6*!+<(=!>&.'?!/$-A*!A*++*%!A*!?&)*!A-!()=(?*%=!()!+<*!A.=()*==!

&%!A-!N<$)$($)=!()!+<(=!>$=*!A*>$.=*!+<*-!7%&A$A'-!A*++*%!.)?*%=+$)?!+<*!>.'+.%*J!P)!+<*!&+<*%!

<$)?! $=! �4<(+*k! 7*&7'*! (+! 4$=! *$=(*%! +&! F*+! ()+&! +<*! &@@(>*=! &@! +<*! +%$?*%=! $)?! &@! F&2*%)/*)+!

A.('?()F=J!5<*!4<(+*!=6()!$++%$>+=!$++*)+(&)!$)?!7*&7'*!$%*!<$77-!+<$+!-&.!$%*!()+*%*=+*?!()!+<*(%!

A.=()*==J! T.+! +<*%*@&%*! (+!4$=! *2*)! <$%?*%! +&! *07'$()! +<$+!4*! ?(?)k+! <$2*!/&)*-! +&! A.-! +<*(%!

7%&?.>+=!&%!>&))*>+!+<*/!+&!A.-*%=!()!C.%&7*J!

!

5<*%*!(=!$! '$>6!&@!?$+$!$)?!*=7*>($''-!%*'($A'*!Y.$)+(+$+(2*!?$+$!$A&.+!).+=!$)?!*=7*>($''-!A.++*%!

$)?! @()(=<*?! 7%&?.>+=! +%$?*?J! 5<*! F&2*%)/*)+! (=! )&+! $>+(2*'-! =.77&%+()F! *07&%+*%=! &@! +<*!

7%&?.>+=D!$)?!+<*!F&2*%)/*)+!?&*=)k+!6**7!+%$>6!&)!$/&.)+=!&@!A.++*%!7%&?.>*?!$)?!*07&%+*?J!

V+!>&.'?!A*!.=*@.'!(@!/&%*!?$+$!4&.'?!A*!$2$('$A'*!()!&%?*%!+&!6**7!+%$>6!&)!+<*!()?.=+%-!$)?!/$6*!

+<()F=!/&%*!>'*$%J!!

!

#&/7*+(+(&)! A*+4**)! +%$?*%=! (=! <(F<! $)?! +<*%*@&%*! +<*%*! (=! $! '$>6! &@! &7*))*==D! +<(=! ?&*=)k+!

*)<$)>*! +<*! ()?.=+%-! $)?J! #&&7*%$+(&)! >&.'?! A*! ()+*%*=+()F! *=7*>($''-! =()>*! =&/*! &@! +<*!

7%&?.>*%=n!+%$?*%=!$%*!2*%-!=/$''D!=>$'*!*@@(>(*)>-!>&.'?!A*!()>%*$=*?J!

!

72

_%&?.>+!?(@@*%*)+($+(&)!$)?!?*2*'&7()F!)*4!())&2$+(&)=!(=!(/7&%+$)+!@&%!+%$?*%=!+&!=.%2(2*!()!+<*!

@.+.%*J!j.$'(+-!4(''! A*>&/*!$!/&%*! $)?!/&%*! (/7&%+$)+! (==.*!$)?!<$=! +&!A*! $??%*==*?!A-! +<*!

+%$?*%=J!!

!

3&&6()F!$+!+<*!@.+.%*!(+!(=!(/7&%+$)+!+&!)&+!&)'-!$??%*==!+<*!GKD!CG!$)?!M=($!A.+!$=!4*''!@&>.=!&)!

E*=+!M@%(>$!$)?!@()?!&.+!4<$+!+<*!><$)>*=!$%*!()!+<(=!<.F*!/$%6*+!@&%!=<*$!7%&?.>+=J!!

!

,&=+! >&)=./*%=! .=()F! =<*$! A.++*%! ()+*%2(*4*?! $%*! 4&/*)! \Qdr! &@! d9! 7*&7'*]! 4<&! $%*! )&+!

@&%/$'! *?.>$+*?! $)?! $%*! =*''()F! @&&?! $'&)F! +<*! =+%**+! =(?*D! $+! +<*! /$%6*+! =(?*! &%! @%&/! +<*(%!

<&.=*=J!5<*!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!.=*?!$=!*?(A'*!&('!@&%!>&&6()F!$)?!@&%!=6()>$%*!A-!<&.=*<&'?!/*/A*%=!

\icr!&@!hh!>&)=./*%=]D!A-!<&.=*<&'?!/*/A*%=!$)?!()!$??(+(&)!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!.=*?!$=!*?(A'*!&('!()!

=*''()F!'&>$'!=)$>6=!$)?!/*$'=!\fQr!&@!hh!>&)=./*%=]!$)?!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!=&'*'-!A&.F<+!@&%!=*''()F!

@&&?!?(=<*=!>&&6*?!()!=<*$!A.++*%!\gcr!&@!hh!>&)=./*%=]J!!

!

5<*!><$%$>+*%(=+(>=!7*%>*(2*?!A-!>&)=./*%=!$)?!)&)L>&)=./*%=!&)!4<(><!><&(>*=!$%*!/$?*D!$%*!

A*+4**)! +<*! =<*$! A.++*%! >&'&.%! \4<(+*D! -*''&4D! $)-! +-7*]D! A*+4**)! +<*! +*0+.%*! &@! +<*! A.++*%!

\<$%?D!=&@+D!$)-!+-7*]!$)?!+<*!=/*''!$)?!+$=+*J!5<*!()+*%2(*4**=!$%*!$=6*?!$A&.+!+<*(%!><&(>*!&@!

=<*$!A.++*%!A-!+<*!4$-!+<*-!7*%>*(2*!(+k=!Y.$'(+-!\=**!&2*%2(*4!+$A'*!cJd!A*'&4]J!E<(+*!A.++*%!(=!

><&=*)!+<*!/&=+!\=**!$'=&!@(F.%*!cJg]D!7%&A$A'-!A*>$.=*!(+!(=!.=*?!/&%*!@%*Y.*)+'-!()!>&&6()F!$)?!

A&.F<+!()!'$%F*%!Y.$)+(+-!+<$)!-*''&4!A.++*%J!^*''&4!A.++*%!(=!/&%*!F*)*%$'!.=*?!@&%!=6()>$%*!$)?!

=**)! $=! $++%$>+(2*D! *=7*>($''-! @&%! >&)=./*%=! &@! +<*! =&.+<! &@! N<$)$D! +<(=! >&)=(?*%*?! A-! +<*!

)&%+<*%)!.%A$)!+%$?*%=!$)?!>&)=./*%=!\=**!$'=&!+$A'*!cJf]J!B$%?!A.++*%!\><&=*)!A-!hgr]!(=!=**)!

A-!=*2*%$'!$=!>&)+$()()F!'&4!>&)>*)+%$+(&)!&@!4$+*%!$)?!@&%!+<$+!/$++*%!>&)+$()()F!/&%*!&('J!5<*!

=&@+! =<*$!A.++*%! \><&=*)!A-!8hr]! (=! ><&=*)! @&%! +<*! &77&=(+*! %*$=&)!$=! +<*!<$%?!A.++*%D! @&%! (+=k!

*$=-! /*'+()F! A*>$.=*! &@! +<*! <(F<*%! 4$+*%! >&)+*)+J! #&)=./*%=! ><&&=()F! $)-! +-7*! &@! A.++*%!

\><&=*)! A-! 89r]! ?&! )&+! >&)=(?*%! +<*! ?(@@*%*)>*! ()! +*0+.%*D! $)?! $%*! '&&6()F! $+! /&%*! *0+*%)$'!

@$>+&%=!$=!$2$('$A('(+-!\=**!$'=&!+$A'*!cJ8]J!

!

5<*! Y.$)+(+-! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! >&)=./*%=D! <&.=*<&'?=! $)?! @&&?! =*''*%=D! A.-! $%*! %*'$+(2*'-! =/$''!

$/&.)+=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!$+!&)>*J!5<(=!>$)!A*!/$)-!=/$''!7(*>*=!()!&)*!+(/*!$=!4*''J!,&=+!&@!+<*!

=/$''! Y.$)+(+(*=! =&'?! $%*! =/$''! =(l*=! &@! >$J! i9F%$/=! *$><! &%! ()! A&4'=! &@! >$J! h6F! \=**! 7%*2(&.=!

@(F.%*=!cJi!$)?!cJh]J!M/&.)+=!()!A*+4**)!9Jh!+&!8!&@!=/$''!=(l*=!$%*!A&.F<+!+<*!/&=+!\i9r!&@!+<*!

A.-*%=!&@! =/$''! =(l*=]! 7*%!/&)+<J!j.$)+(+(*=!&@! g! +&!h!A&4'=! 7*%!/&)+<! (=! +<*!/&=+! @%*Y.*)+'-!

A&.F<+!$/&.)+!&@!A&4'=J!

!

H&)L>&)=./*%=!()+*%2(*4*?!\fh!7*%=&)=]!$%*!)&+!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%!A*>$.=*!+<*-!$%*!)&+!@$/('($%!

+&!(+!$)?!F%*4!.7!*'=*4<*%*!&%!*07'$()*?!+<$+!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!.=*?!A*@&%*!4$=!A*++*%!+<$)!()!+<*!

.%A$)!$%*$!&@!5$/$'*J!P+<*%! %*$=&)=!F(2*)!$%*!$A&.+!.=$F*!&)>*! ()!$!4<('*D! @&%!*0$/7'*! ()! +<*!

?%-!=*$=&)D!@&%!/*?(>()$'!&%!%(+.$'!7.%7&=*=J!K&/*!1.=+!?&!)&+!'(6*!+<*!=/*''!$)?!+$=+*!$)?!7%*@*%!

&+<*%!%*@()*?!7%&?.>+=J!M)!&+<*%!%*$=&)!&@!)&+!.=()F!=<*$!A.++*%!(=!+<*!?(='(6*!+<$+!&+<*%!7*&7'*!

<$2*!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%J!5<*-!4&.'?!A*!%*'.>+$)+!*$+()F!=<*$!A.++*%!?(=<*=!A*>$.=*!&@!+<*!+$=+*!$)?!

=/*''!&%!+<*-!4&.'?!A*!%*'.>+$)+!+&!=/*$%!=<*$!A.++*%!&)!+<*(%!A&?(*=!A*>$.=*!&@!+<*!=>*)+!$)?!

+*0+.%*J!

73

#&)=./*%=!?&!6)&4!<&4!+&!(/7%&2*!=+%&)F!=/*''!$)?!+$=+*!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!A-!$??()F!&)(&)=!$)?!

=7(>*=!()!+<*!=<*$!&('!$)?!7*%@./*D!&%$)F*!7**'=D!@%*=<!=>*)+()F!=**?=!&%!&+<*%!A&?-!>%Ä/*=!!@&%!

*0$/7'*!()!+<*!=<*$!=6()>$%*!7%&?.>+J!

!

5%*)?=!&)!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!/$%6*+!$%*!7*%>*(2*?!A-!+<*!>&)=./*%=!$=!+<*%*!(=!$)!*>&)&/(>!@&>.=!

+<$+!=<(@+*?!/&%*!+&!+<*!=&.+<*%)!%*F(&)=!$)?!+&!+<*!*07&%+!+%$?*J!5<*!4$-!&@!7%&>*==()F!(=!\=*/(]!

/*><$)(l*?J!5<(=!(=!)&+!$'4$-=!7*%>*(2*?!$=!$)!(/7%&2*/*)+!@&%!+<*!Y.$'(+-!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!A-!

+<*! >&)=./*%=J! M>+.$''-! /&=+! >&)=./*%=! %*=7&)?*?! +&! =**! )&! ><$)F*! ()! +<*! Y.$'(+-! ?.*! +&!

/*><$)(l$+(&)!&@!+<*!7%&>*==()F!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!

!

K.A=+(+.+*=!@&%!=<*$!A.++*%!@%*Y.*)+'-!$>>&.)+*?!$%*!7$'/&('D!�@%-+&'k!$)?!�N()&k!&('J!#&>&$!A.++*%D!

�=6()'(F<+k!$)?!�'.0k!$)?!�6*-k!=&$7!$%*!/*)+(&)*?!A-!/&=+!$=!7&7.'$%!=6()!>$%*!7%&?.>+=J!C2*)!$=!

+<*=*! 7%&?.>+=! $%*! /&%*! *07*)=(2*! +<$)! =<*$! A.++*%D! (+! (=! )&+! $'4$-=! 7*%>*(2*?! +<$+! 4$-! A-!

>&)=./*%=J! ,&?*%)D! %*@()*?! $)?! )(>*'-! 7$>6$F*?! 7%&?.>+=! $%*! 7&7.'$%! $/&)F! +<*! 7*&7'*! ()!

5$/$'*!$'+<&.F<!7*&7'*!?&!6)&4!+<*!<*$'()F!$)?!<*$'+<-!7%&7*%+(*=!&@!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!V)!>$=*=!

&@!)**?D!$=!()!+<*!B$%/$++$)!=*$=&)D!@&%!4&.)?!<*$'()F!&%!@&%!%(+.$'!7.%7&=*=!7*&7'*!?&!()+*)?!+&!

.=*! +<*!=<*$!A.++*%J!M'+<&.F<! +<*!><$)F*! ()! �/&?*%)k!/()?=*+D! (+! =+(''! =**/=!+<$+!/$)-!7*&7'*!

.=*!=<*$!A.++*%!@&%!>&&6()F!'&>$'!?(=<*=!$)?!@&%!=6()>$%*!7.%7&=*=J!

74

I*@*%*)>*=!

!

!

• M??$Y.$-! XJD!P>+&A*%! 899iJ5<*! K<*$!A.++*%! 2$'.*! ><$()D!I*@()()F! ()!E*=+!M@%(>$D!EM5B!

+*><)(>$'!%*7&%+!)&J!gJ!

• M6*%*?&'.D! ,J! *+! $'J! 5<*! K<*$! ).+! $)?! A.++*%Z! =&>(&L*>&)&/(>! (/7&%+$)>*D! *07&%+! $)?!

*)2(%&)/*)+$'!><$''*)F*=!@&%!,$'($)!4&/*)J!!

• M'$)?*%!XJ!$)?!M)?*%==&)!MJD!5<*!K<*$!A.++*%! @$/('-!O!+<*!>&/7'*+*!*/&''(*)+!%$)F*!@&%!

=6()!@&%/.'$+(&)=J!R$%'=<$/)=!!

• M%><*%! U$)(*'=! ,(?'$)?! >&&7*%$+(&)! \MU,]S! <++7Znn444J$?/J>&/n*)L

GKn4&%'?4(?*nF<$)$n_$F*=n?*@$.'+J$=70!\>&)=.'+*?!()!,$-!899:]!

• T&?-! K<&7S! <++7Znn444J+<*A&?-=<&7L

.=$J>&/nA&?-=<&7nA%&4=*n()F%*?(*)+b?*+$('J1=7e()F%*?(*)+V?oh9989Q! \>&)=.'+*?! ()!

,$%><!899:]!

• T&@@$! *+! $'JD! 8999J! ;(*'?L=>$'*! ()@'.*)>*! &@! 6$%(+|! \`(+*''$%($! 7$%$?&0$]! &)! =&%F<./!

7%&?.>+(&)!()!+<*!K.?$)!l&)*!&@!T.%6()$!;$=&J!MF%&@&%*=+%-!K-=+*/=!i:D!77J!fhgOfdhJ!!

• T&@@$!*+!$'JD!f::cJ!K<*$!).+!\`(+*''$%($!7$%$?&0$]!7%&?.>+(&)!$)?!>&''*>+(&)!()!$F%&@&%*=+%-!

7$%6'$)?=! &@! T.%6()$! ;$=&J! ;&.)?! &)! ;MP! 4*A=(+*Z!

<++7Znn444J@$&J&%Fn?&>%*7nEgdgh*n4gdgh*fdJ<+/!\>&)=.'+*?!()!M.F.=+!899Q]!

• #<$'@()! TJD! 8999J! I(=6-! A.=()*==S! C>&)&/(>! .)>*%+$()+-D! /$%6*+! %*@&%/=! $)?! @*/$'*!

'(2*'(<&&?=!()!H&%+<*$=+!N<$)$J!

• #<$'@()!TJD!899i!K<*$!A.++*%!%*7.A'(>Z!K+$+*!7&4*%D!F'&A$'!/$%6*+=D!$)?!+<*!/$6()F!&@!$)!

()?(F*)&.=!>&//&?(+-!

• #<$'@()D!TJD!f::cJ!,$%6*+!%*@&%/=!$)?!+<*!K+$+*Z!5<*!>$=*!&@!K<*$!()!N<$)$J!5<*!X&.%)$'!&@!

,&?*%)!M@%(>$)!K+.?(*=D!`&'J!giD!H&J!gD!77J!i8fLii9J!!

• #&>&$!I*=*$%><!V)=+(+.+*!N<$)$!\#IVN]D!=.A=+$+(&)!$+!T&'*D!8998J!\>&)=.'+*?!&)!+<*!f=+!&@!

M.F.=+!899Q]!

• U$)(?$!;&%*=+!K**?!#*)+%*!\U;K#]D!8999J!`(+*''$%($!7$%$?&0$!N$*%+)J!@JK**?!3*$@'*+!H&J!h9!

U*>*/A*%!8999J!!!

• U($)?$!*+!$'J!899:J!V/7%&2()F!F%&4+<!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!+%**!\`(+*''$%($!7$%$?&0$!#J;JN$*%+)J]!

=**?'()F=! .=()F! /()*%$'! HD! _! $)?! $%A.=>.'$%! /->&%%<(l$'! \M,]! @.)F(JT(&+*><)&'J! MF%&)J!

K&>J!C)2(%&)!fgD!7J!!:gLf98!

• U1&==$D! TJMJD! *+! $'D! 899QJ! 3$)?! .=*! (/7$>+! &)! `(+*''$%($! 7$%$?&0$! #J;J! N$*%+*)J! =+$)?!

=+%.>+.%*! $)?! ?(=+%(A.+(&)! 7$++*%)=Z! $! >&/7$%(=&)! &@! T(&=7<*%*! I*=*%2*! &@! _*)?1$%(! ()!

M+$>&%$!?(=+%(>+!()!T*)()J!MF%&@&%*=+%-!=-=+*/=D!`&'./*Z!d8D!V==.*!gD!7J!89hL889!

• U4&/&<!CJMJD!899gJ!V)=*>+!=7*>(*=!$==&>($+*?!4(+<!K<*$!).+!+%**!\`(+*''$%($!7$%$?&0$]! ()!

H&%+<*%)!N<$)$D!5%&7J!K>(J899gD!igD!77Jd9Odh!

• U4&/&<!CJMJD!899iJ!U$/$F*!A-!+<*!@%.(+!A&%*%!H*7<&7+*%(0!=7J!$)?!&+<*%!@$>+&%=!()!K<*$!

).+!+%**D!$)?!+<*(%!?(=+%(A.+(&)!()!)&%+<*%)!N<$)$D!5%&7J!K>(J!899iD!iiD!77J!gfOgi!

• C'($=!,J!*+!$'D!899cD!V/7*?(/*)+=!$)?!())&2$+(&)=!()!6)&4'*?F*!=<$%()FZ!+<*!>$=*!&@!+<*!

M@%(>$)!=<*$!=*>+&%D!R,iU!X&.%)$'!8\f]Zh8Lcd!444J6/i?*2J&%Fn1&.%)$'!

• C'($=!,J!$)?!#$%)*-!XJD!899d!M@%(>$)!K<*$!A.++*%Z!$!@*/()(l*?!=.A=(?-!@%&/!)$+.%*J!M@%(>$!

dd!\f]D!!

75

• ;&'?J!HJD!899QJ!5%$)=)$+(&)$'!=&.%>()F!7%$>+(>*=!()!N<$)$k=!7*%*))($'!>%&7!=*>+&%=J!X&.%)$'!

&@!MF%$%($)!#<$)F*D!`&'J!Q!H&J!fD!77J!:iOf88J!!

• N<$)$)*4=+&?$-Z! <++7Znn444JF<$)$)*4=+&?$-J>&/n)*4=b%*$?/&%*J7<7e(?of9f8! L!

\>&)=.'+*?!&)!88)?!!&@!X.)*!899:]!

• N<$)$! K+$+(=+(>$'! K*%2(>*D! 8999J! _&7.'$+(&)! $)?! B&.=()F! #*)=.=J! \=&.%>*! %*@*%%*?! +&! ()!

/*+<&?=!()!M77*)?(0!V]!

• N(1=A*%=!BJXJ,JD! R*=='*%!XJXJ! a! R)*2*'!,JRJD! f::iJ! U-)$/(>=! $)?! )$+.%$'! %*F*)*%$+(&)! &@!

4&&?-! =7*>(*=! ()! @$%/*?! 7$%6'$)?=! ()! +<*! K$<*'! %*F(&)! \_%&2()>*! &@! _$==&%*D! T.%6()$!

;$=&]J!;&%*=+!C>&'J!,$)$F*JD!ciD!fLf8J!

• N%*(FD!UJD!899cJ!K<*$!A.++*%Z!>&))*>+()F!%.%$'!T.%6()$A*!4&/*)!+&!()+*%)$+(&)$'!/$%6*+=!

+<%&.F<!@$(%!+%$?*J!U*2*'&7/*)+!()!_%$>+(>*D!fcZhD!77J!ich!Å!idhJ!

• B&'+l/$)! XJ! H&2*/A*%! 899iJ! 5<*! K<*$! A.++*%! 2$'.*! ><$()D! K+.?-! =-)+<*=*=! $)?!

%*>&//*)?$+(&)=!@&%!EM5BD!EM5B!+*><)(>$'!%*7&%+!)&J!fJ!!

• B&%(l&)! =&'.+(&)=! =(+*S!T&'*D!N<$)$Z!I*=*$%><!$)?!?*2*'&7/*)+!&@! +<*! =<*$! +%**! $)?! (+=!

7%&?.>+=S! <++7Znn444J=&'.+(&)=L=(+*J&%Fn$%+/$)n7.A'(=<n$%+(>'*b8J=<+/'! L! \>&)=.'+*?! &)!

89+<!&@!U*>*/A*%!899Q]!

• V)?*0/.)?(!4*A=(+*D! 899:J! <++7Znn()?*0/.)?(J>&/n>&//&?(+(*=ne>&//&?(+-o>%.?*L&('L

A%*)+a/&)+<=og99!`(=(+*?!&)!fh+<!&@!X$).$%-!899:J!!

• XV#MD!899dA!5<*!+%($'!7%&F%$/!@&%!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%!()?.=+%-!()!H&%+<*%)!I*F(&)J!!

• R*''-! *+! $'J! 899iJ! K(l*! >'$==! ?(=+%(A.+(&)! $)?! =7$+($'! 7$++*%)! &@! `(+*''$%($! 7$%$?&0$! ()!

%*'$+(&)!+&!@$%/*%=k!7%$>+(>*=!()!,$'(J!MF%&@&%*=+%-!K-=+*/=!c9J!7J!!gOffJ!

• R%(=+!*+!$'JD!899cJ!`&'$+('*!>&/7&.)?=!&@!&%(F()$'!M@%(>$)!A'$>6!$)?!4<(+*!=<*$!A.++*%!@%&/!

5><$?!$)?!#$/*%&&)J!C.%J!XJ!3(7(?!K>(J!5*><)&'J!f9QD!!77J!hQgOhQQ!

• 3&2*++!a!B$YD! 8999J! C2(?*)>*! @&%! $)+<%&7(Y.*! =*'*>+(&)! &@! +<*! K<*$! ).+! +%**! \`(+*''$%($!

7$%$?&0$]J!MF%&@&%*=+%-!K-=+*/=!iQZ!77J!8dgO8QQJ!

• 3&2*++!_JHJD!*+!$'JD!899hJ!K<*$!A.++*%!*07&%+!F.(?*D!GKMVU!EM5BJ!

• 3&2*++!_JHJD!899iJ!5<*!K<*$!A.++*%!2$'.*!><$()D!_%&?.>+(&)D!+%$)=@&%/$+(&)!$)?!/$%6*+()F!

()!E*=+!M@%(>$D!EM5B!+*><)(>$'!%*7&%+!)&J!8J!

• _IP5M!4*A=(+*J!<++7Znn?$+$A$=*J7%&+$J&%Fn_IP5M<+/'n`(+*''$%($r897$%$?&0$bC)J<+/!

• `(=(+*?!&)!U*>*/A*%!ff+<!899QJ!!

• K$)&.! BJ! *+! $'JD! 899iJ! `*F*+$+(2*! 7%&7$F$+(&)! &@! `(+*''$%($! 7$%$?&0$! A-! F%$@+()FJ!

MF%&@&%*=+%-!K-=+*/=!c9D!77J!:gO::J!!

• K><%*>6*)A*%FD! RJD! 899iJ! 5<*! >&)+%(A.+(&)! &@! =<*$! A.++*%! \`(+*''$%($! 7$%$?&0$! #J;J!

N$*%+)*%]! +&! '&>$'! '(2*<&&?=! ()! T*)()D! #<$7+*%! c! &@! ;&%*=+! 7%&?.>+=D! '(2*'(<&&?=! $)?!

>&)=*%2$+(&)J!M@%(>$!`&'./*!8J!

• K<*$!7%&1*>+S!4*A=(+*!444J=<*$7%&1*>+J&%F!!

• K+$+<$>&=! #JD! 899iJ! 5<*! K<*$! A.++*%! 2$'.*! ><$()D! 5<*!GK!/$%6*+! =+.?-D!EM5B! +*><)(>$'!

%*7&%+!)&J!iJ!!

• 5*6'*<$(/$)&+! 899iJ! C07'&(+()F! +<*! 7&+*)+($'! &@! ()?(F*)&.=! $F%&@&%*=+%-! +%**=Z! _$%6($!

A(F'&A&=$!$)?!`(+*''$%($!7$%$?&0$!()!=.ALK$<$%$)!M@%(>$J!MF%&@&%*=+%-!K-=+*/=!cfJ!7J!89d!O!

889!!

• GH#5MUS! 444J.)>+$?J&%Fn()@&>&//n@%$)>$(=n6$%(+*n/$%><*J<+/! \>&)=.'+*?! ()!

U*>*/A*%!899Q]!

76

• PUVD!899hJ!#*)+%*! @&%!7&'(>-!$)$'-=(=! \#C_M]!I*2(=*?!%*7&%+! @&%!U;VU!N<$)$!7%*7$%*?!A-!

PUV!\+<*!P2*%=*$=!U*2*'&7/*)+!V)=+(+.+*]D!M>>%$D!N<$)$D!P>+&A*%!899h!

• P6.''&!*+!$'D!899i!J!3*$@()FD!@'&4*%()F!$)?!@%.(+()F!&@!`(+*''$%($!7$%$?&0$!=.A=7J!)('&+(>$!()!

=$2$))$!7$%6'$)?=!()!GF$)?$J!MF%&@&%*=+%-!=-=+*/=D!`&'./*Z!c9!V==.*Z!f!\899i]D!77Z!ddL:f!

• GKMVU!E*=+!M@%(>$!5%$?*!B.AS!K<*$!A.++*%!*07&%+!F.(?*D!K*7+*/A*%!899h!

• ^*!*+!$'D!899dJ!C+.?*!?*=!7$%$/Ä+%*=!&7|%$+&(%*=!?*!7%*==$F*!/|>$)(Y.*!?*=!$/$)?*=!?*!

`(+*''$%($! 7$%$?&0$! N$*%+)! #J;J! \6$%(+|]! T(&+*><)&'&F(*D! $F%&)&/(*D! =&>(|+|! *+!

*)2(%&))*/*)+D!`&'./*Z!ffD!V==.*!iJ!7!8cd!

77

M__CHUV[!V!!L!U*+$('=!&)!%*=*$%><!/*+<&?=!_MI5!f!

!

I*=*$%><!/*+<&?!$)?!=+.?-!$%*$!!

#<$7+*%! f! $)?! 8! &)! =<*$! ).+! 7%&?.>+(&)! $)?!

7%&>*==()F!%*=.'+=!@%&/!$!>&/A()$+(&)!&@!'(+*%$+.%*!$)?!

@(*'?! %*=*$%><! >$%%(*?! &.+! A-! +4&! =+.?*)+=J! 5<*! @(*'?!

=+.?(*=!4*%*!>&)?.>+*?!()!G77*%!E*=+!I*F(&)D!N<$)$D!

$)?!>&)=(=+*?!&@!()+*%2(*4=!4(+<!'&>$'!@$%/*%=D!+%$?*%=!

$)?!'&>$'!*)+*%7%(=*=J!

P)*! &@! +<*! =+.?*)+=! ?(?! $! %*=*$%><!/&%*! @&>.=*?! &)!

/$).$'!=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)!4<(><!4$=!>&)?.>+*?!()!

+<*! 2(''$F*! &@! R7$%*J! ;&%! +<(=! $! @(0*?! ()+*%2(*4=! 4*%*!

?&)*!4(+<! d8! %*=7&)?*)+=J! 5<*! &+<*%! @(*'?! =+.?-!4$=!

@&>.=*?!/&%*!&)!'$)?!$)?!=<*$!+%**!/$)$F*/*)+D!$)?!

>&)=(=+*?!&@!c9!()+*%2(*4=!()!+<%**!?(@@*%*)+!+&4)=!\89!

7*%! +&4)]Z! R7$%*D! R$%)(! $)?! X(%$7$J! 5<(=! =+.?-! $%*$! (=!

=><*/$+(>$''-!?*7(>+*?!()!@(F!fJ8J!

!X(%$7$! '(*=!c9!6/!)&%+<!&@!+<*!7%&2()>*!>$7(+$'!E$D!$)?!h9!6/!=&.+<! @%&/!+<*!)&%+<*%)!A&%?*%!

4(+<!T.%6()$!;$=&J!5<*!?(=+$)>*!A*+4**)!R7$%*!$)?!X(%$7$!(=!$77%&0(/$+*'-!g96/J!!

5<*! 2*F*+$+(&)! (=! $! +-7(>$'! @&%! $! =$2$))$<! '$)?=>$7*! $)?! +<*! $)).$'! %$()@$''! <$=! A**)! %$)F()F!

@%&/!ch9!+&!fi99!//!A*+4**)!f::d!$)?!899dD!$>>&%?()F!+&!/*$=.%*/*)+=!?&)*!()!E$!\,KUED!

899d]J!5<(=!%$()!/&=+'-!@$''=!A*+4**)!,$-!+&!P>+&A*%J!_&7.'$+(&)!&@!R7$%*! (=!*=+(/$+*?!$+!f999!

()<$A(+$)+=D! R$%)(! <$=! &2*%! 8999! ()<$A(+$)+=D! 4<('*! X(%$7$! <$=! &2*%! :999! \N<$)$! K+$+(=+(>$'!

K*%2(>*D!8999!_B#]J!!

M''! ()@&%/$+(&)! &)! 7%(>*=! 4$=! &A+$()*?! ()! N<$)$! >*?(=D! A.+! (=! >&)2*%+*?! ()+&! GKm! $==./()F! f!

N<$)$! >*?(=! o! 9DcQ! GKmJ! 5<*! 7%(>*=! 7*%! 6F! $%*! A$=*?! $2*%$F*=! &@! 4*(F<*?! Y.$)+(+(*=! &)! '&>$'!

/$%6*+=D!$=!=/$''!+%$?*%=!()!N<$)$!=*''!+<*(%!7%&?.>+=!7*%!2&'./*!%$+<*%!+<$)!7*%!.)(+=!&@!4*(F<+J!

#&=+! A*)*@(+! $==*==/*)+! @&%! /$).$'! *0+%$>+(&)! $=! @&%! =*/(L$.+&/$+*?! =/$''! =>$'*! A.++*%!

*0+%$>+(&)!4*%*!/$?*!$)?!>&/7$%*?J!,*$=.%*/*)+=!&)!/$).$'!7%&>*==()F!4$=!?&)*! ()!R7$%*J!

E<('*! 7%&>*==()F! >&=+=! @&%! =*/(L$.+&/$+*?! A.++*%! *0+%$>+(&)!4$=! ?*%(2*?! @%&/!*07*%(/*)+=! $+!

+4&!?(@@*%*)+!=/$''L=>$'*!=<*$!A.++*%!*0+%$>+(&)! @$>+&%(*=! ()!X(%$7$J!T&+<!@$>+&%(*=!<$?!+<*!=$/*!

/$><()*=!@%&/!+<*!=$/*!7%&?.>*%J!5<*!%*$=&)!+&!><&&=*!=/$''L=>$'*!*0+%$>+(&)!@&%!>&/7$%(=&)!(=!

A*>$.=*!+<(=!(=!/&%*!()!+<*!%*$><!&@!+<*!%.%$'!@$%/*%=D!+<$)!'$%F*!=>$'*!7%&>*==()FJ!!

!

!

Fig1.2 schematic map of study area, Upper West Region Ghana - (10° 44’ N; 2° 36’ W )

78

!

!

M__CHUV[!VV!L!j.*=+(&))$(%*=!

MJ!! j.*=+(&))$(%*!=<*$!).+!$2$('$A('(+-!

!

U&!-&.!7(>6nA.-!()!=<*$!).+=Z!-*=! !)&! !!!!!!j.*=+(&))$(%*!&)!$2$('$A('(+-!&)!=<*$!).+=!!

5<*%*! $%*!/$)-!Y.*=+(&)=D! +<*! ()+*%2(*4!/$-! +$6*!f! &%! f!{!<&.%=! ! \8J]! +<(=! (=! $! %*=*$%><! @&%! $!

.)(2*%=(+-D! (+! (=!)&+! @&%! +<*!F&2*%)/*)+!\g]! V!4(''!)&+!F(2*!$4$-!$)-! ()@&%/$+(&)!$'&)F!4(+<!-&.%!

)$/*D!V!4(''!/$6*!$!F*)*%$'!%*7&%+!\iJ]!V@!@&%!$)-!%*$=&)!-&.!4&.'?!)&+!'(6*!+&!$)=4*%!$)-!&@!+<*!

Y.*=+(&)=!@**'!@%**!)&+!+&J!!

U$+*Z! ! ! VUZ!

5(/*!$+!+<*!=+$%+!&@!+<*!()+*%2(*4Z!! 5(/*!$+!+<*!*)?!&@!+<*!()+*%2(*4Z! !

U(?!+<*!%*=7&)?*)+!<$2*!$)-!7%&A'*/=!()!.)?*%=+$)?()F!$)?!$)=4*%()F!+<*!Y.*=+(&)=e!Ç-*=D!)&É!

E$=!+<*!%*=7&)?*)+!&7*)!$)?!=+%$(F<+@&%4$%?e!Ç-*=D!)&É!

U&! -&.! +<()6! +<(=! 7*%=&)! (=! =.(+$A'*! @&%! ()L?*7+<! =+.?-e! Ç-*=D! )&É! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! #&//*)+=Z!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

NCHCIM3!

fJ!U$F$$%*!)$/*Z! 8J!#<%(=+($)n/.='(/!)$/*Z!

gJ!5&4)Z!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!=()>*ÑÑÑJJ! iJ!7'$>*!&@!A(%+<Z!!!!!!!!!!!!

hJ!$F*Z!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!A(%+<-*$%Z! cJ!<&.=*<&'?!=(l*Z! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! \<&4!/$)-!7*&7'*!?&!-&.!

+$6*!>$%*!&@!}!f]!

dJ!V)?(2(?.$'Z!/n@!!!!F%&.7Z!/!n/(0*?n!@! QJ! ,$%(+$'! =+$+.=Z! ! =()F'*! ! /$%%(*?! ! ! 4(?&4*?! !

?(2&%>*?!!

:J!3*2*'!&@!*?.>$+(&)!>&/7'*+*?Z!H&!*?.>$+(&)!n!7%(/$%-!n!XBK!n!KBK!n55#!n53!

f9J!E<(><!'$)F.$F*=!?&!-&.!=7*$6e!\f]!?$F$$%*!\8]!C)F'(=<D!\g]!P+<*%=L=7*>(@-JJ!!

ffJ! I*'(F(&)Z! \f]! 5%$?(+(&)$'(=+D! \8]! #$+<&'(>D! \g]! &+<*%! #<%(=+($)L=7*>(@-D! \i]! ,.='(/D! \h]! p;%**L

+<()6*%qD!\c]!&+<*%L=7*>(@-JJJ!

f8J!C/7'&-/*)+!=+$+.=Z! */7'&-*?! !.)*/7'&-*?! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !fgJ!P>>.7$+(&)Z! !$! @$%/*%! !

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

fgJ! V@!/$%%(*?Z! 1&A! <.=A$)?ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!fhJ!E<*%*! (=! <*! '(2()F!)&4eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ! fcJ! A&%)! ()!

+<(=!+&4)e!^!n!HD!A&%)!()ÑJJ!

3MHU!PEHCU!

fdJ!B&4!/.><! '$)?!?&!-&.!<$2*!$2$('$A'*! @&%!.=*D! ()>'.?()F! @$''&4!a!A.=<eZ!;$%/! '$)?Z!ÑÑJÑJJ!

;$''&4Z!ÑÑÑÑÑJ!T.=<!Z!Ñ!!!

fQJ!U&!-&.!<$2*!=<*$!).+!+%**=!&)!-&.%!'$)?e! !-*=!!! !)&!

f:J! U&! -&.! &4)! $''! +<(=! '$)?e! ! -*=! ! ! ! )&D! 7$%+($''-n! @.''-! A&%%&4*?!

@%&/ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ!

V@!A&%%&4*?D!89J!<&4!/.><! (=!A&%%&4*?n%*)+*?! @%&/!&+<*%!7*&7'*eZÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ! !8fJ!A&%%&4*?!

@%&/!&4)!@$/('-e!!-!n!)!

88J! B&4! /$)-! -*$%=! <$2*! -&.! A**)! A&%%&4()F! +<(=! 7(*>*! &@! '$)?e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ!

8gJ! U&! -&.! )**?! +&! F(2*! $)-+<()F! +&! +<*! '$)?&4)*%! ()! %*+.%)! &@! A&%%&4()F! +<*! '$)?e! ^! n! H!!!

>&//JZ!ÑJJÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ!

79

8iJ!#$)!+<*!'$)?&4)*%!>'$(/!+<*!'$)?!A$>6!$+!$)-!+(/*e!^!n!H!!

8hJ!M%*!-&.!$'4$-=!$''&4*?!+&!<$%2*=+!*>&)&/(>!+%**=!\*JF!K<*$D!?$4$?$4$]!@%&/!A&%%&4*?!&%!

%*)+*?!'$)?=e!^n!H!nK&/*+(/*=!

8cJ! V@! )&! &%! =&/*+(/*=D! 4<$+! $%*! +<*! $%%$)F*/*)+=! @&%! <$%2*=+()F! +<*=*! +%**=! &)! =.><!

'$)?eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

8dJ!B&4! '&)F! ?&! -&.! +$6*! $! 7(*>*! &@! '$)?! ()+&! $F%(>.'+.%$'! .=*! A*@&%*! (+! (=! '*@+! $=! @$''&4! '$)?e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

8QJ! B&4! /$)-! -*$%=! ?&! -&.! 6**7! -&.%! '$)?=!

@$''&4eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

8:J! E<$+! (=! $! 7%&A'*/! +<$+! >&)>*%)=! $''! +<*! 7*&7'*! &@! +<(=! 2(''$F*! &%! %*F(&)! %(F<+! )&4!

eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

g9J! E<$+! $%*! +<*! &A=+$>'*=! @&%! ()>%*$=()F! +<*! -(*'?! &@! -&.%!

>%&7=eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

gfJ! B&4! >&.'?! -&.! 7%&?.>*! /&%*e! \/&%*! '$)?D! /&%*! @*%+('(l*%D! (%%(F$+(&)D! '$A&.%D!

&+<*%]eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

g8J!M%*!+<*%*!&+<*%!7*&7'*!A&%%&4()F!'$)?!@%&/!-&.!$+!+<(=!/&/*)+e!^!n!H!!!!V@D!)&!!!()!+<*!7$=+e!

^!n!H!!!!

ggJ! B&4! /$)-! 7*&7'*e! ! ÑÑJJ! 7*%=&)\=]! ! ! \f]! ÑÑ! $>%*=! =()>*ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ! \8]ÑÑÑ$>%*=D!

=()>*ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

giJ!M%*!+<*%*!=<*$!).+!+%**=!&)!+<$+!'$)?e! !^*=! !)&!!!!!!!(@!-*=!ghJ!$%*!+<*-!$''&4*?!+&!7(>6!+<*!

@%.(+=e!^!n!H!!!!

!!(@!-*=Z!gcJ!?&!+<*-!<$2*!+&!7$-!-&.!@&%!(+e!!^!n!H!!!gdJ!?&!+<*-!F(2*!7$%+!&@!+<*!<$%2*=+n7%&@(+!+&!

-&.e!!^!n!H!!!!

!

;()?!&.+!A-!F&()F!()+&!+<*!@(*'?!+<(=!=*+!&@!Y.*=+(&)=Z!K(l*!&@!'$)?!+<$+!(=!&4)*?D!4(+<!<*'7!&@!N_K!

>&&%?()$+*=Z!

f! g!

8! i!

!B&4! /$)-! =<*$! +%**=! $%*! +<*%*! &)! +<*! '$)?eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ! B&4! /$)-! <$2*! 2(=(A'*! @%.(+!

-(*'?eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

V,_PI5MH#C!P;!KBCM!

gQJ! M%*! =<*$! ).+=! (/7&%+$)+! +&! -&.e!

E<-eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

g:J! E<$+! (=! +<*! /&=+! (/7&%+$)+! 7%&?.>+! &%! $>+(2(+-! @&%! -&.!

()>&/*eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

i9J! B&4! /.><! ?(?! -&.! *$%)! @%&/! +<(=! /=+J(/7J! >%&7! '$=+! -*$%eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ-*$%!

A*@&%*eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

#P33C#5VHN!

ifJ! E<$+! &A=+$>'*=! n! 7%&A'*/=! ?&! -&.! @$>*! 4<*)! 7(>6()F! =<*$! ).+=e!!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJJ!

!! ! V@! =)$6*! A(+*=Z! *2*%! F&+! A(++*)e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJJ!

i8J! B&4! >$)! +<*=*! 7%&A'*/=! A*! =&'2*?e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJJJJJJJJJJ!

igJ!B&4!/$)-!=<*$!).+=!?(?!-&.!>&''*>+!()Ñ!eZ!

80

^*$%!! j.$)+(+-!\A&4'o$'&)6$D!7$)D!

A$F]!

V@! Y.$)+(+(*=! ?(@@*%! 7*%! -*$%D!

4<-e!

899d! !

899c! !

899h! !

!

iiJ!B&4!/$)-!+(/*=!$!?$-!?&!-&.!F&!7(>6()Fe!Ñ!!+(/*=!$!?$-!!! !$''!?$-! !/&%)()F! !$@+*%)&&)! !

*2*)()F!

ihJ!E<*)!?&!-&.!'*$2*!$)?!4<*)!?&!-&.!>&/*!A$>6!@%&/!7(>6()Fe!;%&/ÑÑ!!+&!ÑÑ!! ! ! ! \a!@%&/!

ÑÑJ!+&J!ÑÑÑ]!o!ÑÑ!<%=n?$-!

icJ!M%*!-&.!$A'*!+&!7(>6!$'/&=+!$''!+<*!@%.(+=!$%*!$2$('$A'*!&)!-&.%!'$)?D!&%!$%*!/$)-!'*@+!.)7(>6*?e!

!!_(>6!$''!! !!)&D!)&+!$''ÑÑÑ!

idJE<$+! 6**7=! -&.! @%&/! 7(>6()F! /&%*! <&.%=! 7*%! ?$-e! ! +(/*! ! <*$'+<! JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

=7*>(@-ZÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJJJJJJ!

iQJ! B&4! /$)-! ?$-=! 7*%! 4**6! ?&! -&.! =7*)?! &)! 7(>6()F! =<*$! ).+=e! ÑÑ?$-=!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

JJÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

i:J! 4<$+! 6**7=! -&.! @%&/! 7(>6()F! &)! &+<*%!

?$-=eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

h9J! E<*)! 4$=! +<*! '$=+! +(/*! -&.! 4*)+! +&! >&''*>+e! ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ$)?! A*@&%*!

+<$+eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!!

hfJ! B&4! /.><! ?(?! -&.! >&''*>+e!

JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ

JJJ!

h8J! ;%&/! 4<$+! +(/*! .)+('! 4<$+! +(/*! (=! +<*! <$%2*=+()F! =*$=&)! &@! +<*! =<*$!

@%.(+=eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

hgJ! U&! -&.! @()?! +<*! +%**=! &)! -&.%! @$%/! +&! A*! F&&?! -(*'?()F! =<*$! +%**=e! ^n! HD<&4! >&/*! -(*'?!

\)&+]4*''eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

hiJ!U&!-&.!$'=&!>&''*>+!=<*$!).+=!@%&/!+<*!A.=<e!!^!!n!H!! ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

hcJ! B&4! $A&.+! +<*! +%**=! &@! +<*! A.=<e! ^! ! n! H! B&4! >&/*! +<*-! -(*'?! \)&+]!

4*''eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

hdJB&4! /$)-! A&4'=! &@! =<*$! @%.(+! >$)! &)*! <$%2*=+! @%&/! $! F&&?! -(*'?()F! =<*$!

+%**eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

hQJ! U&*=! +<*! -(*'?! &@! $! +%**! 2$%-! $! '&+! 7*%! -*$%e! ! ! ^n! HÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ! !! (@! -*=Z! $)-! (?*$!

4<-eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

h:J!E<$+! ?&! -&.! ?&!4(+<! +<*! =<*$! ).+=! $@+*%! 7(>6()Fe! ! ! ! K*''! 6*%)*'=! ?(%*>+'-! ! ! 7%&>*==! =<*$!

A.++*%!! !=+&%*!! !ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

c9J!V@!=<*$!A.++*%D!@&%!<&/*!.=*!&%!!=*''()Fe! !&)'-!<&/*!.=*! !/&=+'-!@&%!<&/*!.=*! !/&=+'-!@&%!

=*''()F! !1.=+!@&%!=*''()F! ÑÑJ!

cfJ!V@!=&$7D!@&%!<&/*!.=*!&%!=*''()Fe! !&)'-!<&/*!.=*! !/&=+'-!@&%!<&/*!.=*! !/&=+'-!@&%!=*''()F! !

1.=+!@&%!=*''()F! ÑÑÑÑÑ!

c8J!B&4!/.><!?(?!-&.!=*''!e!!!!4<*%*!=&'?eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!!!+&!4<&/eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!!

^*$%!! K<*$!6*%)*'=! ,&)+<n7'$>*n7%

(>*!

K<*$!

A.++*%n=&$7!

,&)+<n7'$>*n

7%(>*!

E<-!?(@@e!

899d! ! ! ! !

899c! ! ! ! !

899h! ! ! ! !

!

81

cgJ! U&! -&.! $'=&! .=*! &+<*%! +-7*=! &@! &('nA.++*%! A*=(?*=! =<*$! AJe! ! ! H&D! =<*$! AJ! &)'-J! ! ! ! -*=D! V!

.=*ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ!

ciJ! E<(><! &('nA.++*%! ?&! -&.! 7%*@*%! +&! .=*eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJÑÑÑÑÑhfAJ!

4<-eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

chJ! <&4! /.><! =<*$! A.++*%! ?&! -&.! a! ! -&.%! <&.=*<&'?! >&)=./*! 7*%!

4**6n/&)+<n-*$%eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

ccJ! V=! +<(=! >&)=./7+(&)! +<*! =$/*! +<%&.F<&.+! +<*! -*$%e! ! -*=! !

)&DJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

cdJ! M%*! +<*%*! +$A&&! ?$-=! @&%! =<*$! ).+! 7(>6()Fe! ! ! )&! ! (@! -*=D!!

&)ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

cQJ!V=!+<(=!%*$''-!$!+$A&&L?$-!@&%!-&.D!&%!?&!-&.!=+(''!F&!7(>6()F!&)!+<(=!?$-e!! !V!?&!7(>6!&)!+<(=!?$-!

!)&D!V!?&)k+!7(>6!

c:J!U&!-&.!+<()6!+<*%*!>&.'?!A*!$!>&)=*Y.*)>*!(@!-&.!?&!@$%/!&%!?&!F&!7(>6()F!@%.(+=!&)!+<(=!?$-e!

JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!!

c:AJ! V@! -&.! ?&! 7(>6n@$%/! $)?! F*+! A(++*)! A-! $! =)$6*D! ?&! -&.! $'=&! <$2*! +&! 7$-!

\$)(/$'=n/&)*-e]ÑJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

d9J!E&.'?!-&.!'(6*!+&!>&''*>+!/&%*!).+=!+<$)!-&.!)&%/$''-!?&e!^!n!H!!!!hQ!E<$+!6**7=!-&.!@%&/!

7(>6()F!/&%*eJJJJJJJJJJJJÑÑÑÑÑJ!

dfJ! M%*! -&.! ()! $! $==&>($+(&)nF%&.7! ?&()F! $)-+<()F! 4(+<! +%$?*! ()! =<*$! ).+=! &%! =<*$! A.++*%!

7%&>*==()Fe!!! !-*=! !!H&!

d8J! (@! )&D! <$2*! -&.! *2*%! <*$%?! &@! =.><! $! F%&.7e! H&! ! n! -*=D! V! <*$%?!

&@ÑÑJJÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

dgJ!E&.'?!-&.!'(6*!+&!A*!()!&)*e!^!!n!H!!!c8J!V@!-*=D!$%*!-&.!$'%*$?-!+$6()F!=+*7=!+&!&%F$)(l*!&)*D!&%!

(=! =&/*! &)*! *'=*! ()! -&.%! >'&=*! *)2(%&)/*)+! =+$%+()F! +&! &%F$)(l*! &)*e! ^! ! n! H! \(@! -*=D!

=7*>(@-]ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

M##CK! 5P! 5BC! 5ICCK!

diJ!E<&!(=!$''&4*?!+&!7(>6!+<*!=<*$!).+=!@%&/!+<*!+%**=!&)!-&.%!@$/('(*=!'$)?e!!

! &)'-! <&.=*<&'?! \<.=A$)?D! 4(@*D! ><('?%*)D! F%$)?7$%*)+=]! ! <&.=*<&'?! a! *0+*)?*?! @$/('-! ! !

$)-&)*! ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

dhJ! E<&! 7(>6=! +<*/! ()! 7%$>+(>*e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

dcJ! U&! -&.! <$2*! 7%&A'*/=!4(+<! 7*&7'*! >&/()F! &)! -&.%! '$)?! +&! 7(>6! @%.(+=! �(''*F$''-ke! )&! n! -*=!

!?$('-!7%&A'*/e!^!!n!!HDÑÑÑÑJJ!

ddJ!M%*!-&.!$''&4*?!+&!7(>6!@%&/!&+<*%!7*&7'*=!'$)?e!^n!H!!!!!V=!+<*!A.=<!&4)*?!A-!=&/*&)*e!H!!!n!!!

^!!!!A-!4<&/eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

dQJ! V@! -*=D! $%*! -&.! +<*)! )&+! 7(>6()F! (''*F$''-! &%! (=! (+! $''&4*?! +&! 7(>6! +<*%*e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

d:J!B&4!@$%! (=! +<*!?(=+$)>*!+&!+<*!A.=<!$)?!A$>6!e! ! (+! (=! '(6*!ÑÑÑJ!?(=+$)>*!A*+4**)! !ÑÑ!! !$)?!

ÑÑÑÑ!!!!&%!!!(+k=!ÑÑÑ!6/!

Q9J! U&! $?.'+! /*)! $'=&! 7(>6! =<*$! ).+=e! ^! ! n! H! ! ! !! B&4! 4$=! +<(=! (=! +<*! 7$=+!

eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

QfJ! V@! ?(@@*%*)+D!4<-!?&! -&.! +<()6! (+! (=! )&4!?(@@*%*)+! @%&/!7$=+eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ! Q8J! V=! +<*%*!

'$)?!+<$+!(=!&4)*?!A-!)&!&)*e!^nH!

Q8AJ! #$)! 4&/*)! &4)! '$)?e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ!

82

QgJ! V=! +<*! '$)?! $%&.)?!<*%*! ()! +<*! <$)?=!&@! @$/('(*=!&)'-D! &%! $%*! $'=&!7$%+=!&@! (+! &4)*?!A-! +<*!

F&2*%)/*)+e!ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ!

QiJ! B&4! $A&.+! +<*! =><&&'! +*%%$()D! +<*! >'()(>D! +<*! /$%6*+7'$>*e! E<&! &4)=! (+e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ! QhJ! 3$)?! 7$(?! @&%! 4<*)! )*4! %&$?! (=! A.('+D! 7*%/(==(&)! &@!

'$)?&4)*%!)**?*?eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

TG^VHN!!!QcJ!?(?!-&.!A.-!=<*$!).+=!'$=+!-*$%e!!!^n!H!!!!M)?!()!-*$%=!A*@&%*e!^!n!H!

QdJ! ;&%! 4<$+! .=*e! ! &4)! >&)=./7+(&)! ! 7%&>*==}=*''! ! %*L=*''! 4<*)! 7%(>*! F*+! <(F<*%!!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

^*$%!! j.$)+(+-! \A&4'o$'&)6$D!

7$)D!A$F]!

_*%(&?! 7'$>*! 7%(>*! V@!?(@@J!4<-e!

899d! ! ! ! !

899c! ! ! ! !

899h! ! ! ! !

!

!

K5PIMNC!O!QQJ!K+&%*?!o!>&''*>+*?!}!A&.F<+!!L!=&'?!L!>&)=./*?e!!!

-*$%! j.$)+(+-!=+&%*?! E<*)! ?(?! &4)L7(>6*?! =+&%$F*!

%.)!&.+e!

V@!)./A*%=!?(@@*%D!<&4!>&/*e!!

899d! ! !

899c! ! !

899h! ! !

!

Q:J!G=*!&@!=+&%*?!).+=Z!! !=<JA.++J!&)'-!<&/*!.=*! !=<*$!A.++*%!@&%!<&/*!.=*!$)?!=*''()F! !=*''()F!

6*%)*'=! !ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

:9J!7'$)=!+&!=+&%*!=<*$!).+=!>&/()F!=*$=&)e^!nH!!:fJ!B&4!/$)-!A$F=!?&!-&.!4$)+!()!=+&%*!$+!*)?!

&@!%$()-!=*$=&)eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

:8J! >$)! -&.! F*+! +<(=! $/&.)+! A-! 1.=+!

>&''*>+()FeJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

:gJ!U&!-&.!$(/!+&!<$2*!$!+<*!Y.$)+(+-!&@!=<*$!).+=!=&!+<$+!(+!'$=+=!.)+('!+<*!)*0+!%$()!=*$=&)e!^n!

HÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ!

:iJ! U&! -&.! *2*%! <$2*! 7%&A'*/=! 4(+<! =+&%$F*! &@! =<*$! ).+=e! ! ! H&! ! ! -*=D!

4(+<ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

:hJ!V@!)&D!C2*%!<*$%*?!&@!@.)F<.=!&%!/$FF&+=!A*()F!$!7%&A'*/eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!:cJ!(@!()@*>+*?!A-!

@.)F<.=!).+=!=+(''!.=$A'*eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!:dJ!B&4!?&*=!@.)F<.=!$@@*>+!+<*!Y.$'(+-!&@!+<*!6*%)*'=nA.++*%e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

:QJ!U&! +<*-! =&/*+(/*=!F&!A$?e!!! (@! -*=Z!<&4!/.><!4*)+!A$?! ! @%&/! '$=+! -*$%ZÑÑÑÑ!::J!<&4!

>&/*!+<$+!).+=!F&!A$?eZ!ÑÑÑJJJJJ!

,MHMNC,CH5! ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

f99J! V=! +<*%*! $)-+<()F! -&.! $%*! )&+! $''&4*?! +&! ?&! 4(+<! +<*! =<*$!

+%**eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

f99AJ!U&!-&.!&%!=&/*!&)*!*'=*!>.+!+<*!A%$)><*=!&@!+<*!=<*$!).+!+%**=!\7%.)()F]e! !)&! !! V@!-*=D!

4<-e!ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

f9fJV@!)&!! )&+! @&%!?*>%*$=()F! =<$?*! @&%! +<*! >%&7=e!^! ! n!H!!! )&+! +&! +%-! ()>%*$=*!-(*'?!&@!&'?*%!

+%**=e!ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

f98J!5<*! @(*'?=!4<*%*! +<*!=<*$!+%**=!$%*D!?&!-&.!$77'-!@*%+('(l*%! !&)!+<*! @(*'?=e!^n!H!f9gJ!$77'-!

$)(/$'!?%&77()F=!&)!+<*!@(*'?=e^!nH!

83

f9iJ!U&!-&.!6**7!$''!+<*!-&.)F!+%**=e!^!!n!H!!! f9hJ! (@! -*=D! =&! -&.! ?&)k+! %*/&2*! $)-e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

f9cJ!U&!-&.!=&/*+(/*=!7'$)+!=<*$!+%**=e!!^!!n!H! f9dJ! N%$@+()Fe! ! H&! n! -*=! V! ?(?! (+D! A$=*L+%**!

.=*?Z!ÑÑÑJ!I*=.'+Z!ÑÑJJ!

f9QJ! U&! -&.! =&/*+(/*=! A.%)! =&/*! 7$%+=! &@! -&.%! '$)?e! ^! n! H! ! f9:J! U&*=! +<(=! $@@*>+! +<*! =<*$!

+%**=eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

ff9J! >$)! @(%*! $'=&! A*! A*)*@(>($'! @&%! +<*! @'&4*%()Fn! @%.(+()F! &@! +<*!

+%**=eJJJJJJÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

fffJ! 4<(><! $)(/$'=n! ()=*>+=! $%*! %*=7&)=(A'*! @&%! 7&''()$+()F! +<*! @'&4*%=! &@! +<*! =<*$!

+%**eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

ff8J!U&!-&.!>&/7&=+!<&/*!4$=+*!\'(6*!'*$2*=D!F%&.)?).+!=<*''=D!@&&?L'*@+!&2*%k=]+&!$77'-!+&!+<*!

'$)?e!^!!n!H!

ffgJ! M%*! +<*%*! ()=*>+=! +<$+! <$%/! +<*! =<*$! +%**=e! ! )&! ! -*=D!

)$/*'-ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ!

ffiJ! M)(/$'=D! 7$%$=(+(>! 7'$)+=D! 7$%$=(+*=D! ?(=*$=*=eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ! AJ!

,(=+'*+&*!$!7%&A'*/eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

ffhJ! M)-! $)(/$'=! +<$+! =7&('! +<*! @%.(+=D!

).+=eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

ffc!U&!$)(/$'=!=&/*+(/*=!*$+n<$%/!>%&7=e!^!n!H!!(@!-*=!!4<*)!4$=!'$=+!+(/*eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ<&4!

/.><! ?$/$F*e! ÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ! ! ! 4<&=*! }! 4<(><! $)(/$'=e! ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJÑÑÑÑJJJ?(?! -&.! F*+! $!

%*@.)?eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

ffdJ! U&! -&.! +$6*! $)-! =7*>($'! /*$=.%*=! +&! 7%&+*>+! +<*! =<*$! +%**=e!

JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

ffQJ! U(?! +<*! ><(*@D! +*)?$)$! &%! $)-&)*! @%&/! F&2*%)/*)+! =&/*! +&! +*''! $A&.+! =<*$! +%**=!

/$)$F*/*)+D! @$%/()F!/*+<&?=D!)*4! +*><)&'&F(*=e! !H&! ! ! n! ! ! -*=DÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!ff:J!U&!

+<*-!=$-!$)-+<()F!&)!\)&+]!>.++()FnA.%)()F!+<*/!?&4)e!^!n!!H!

f89J!U&!-&.!<$2*!*)&.F<!'$)?!+&!7%&?.>*!*)&.F<!@&&?!@&%!-&.!&4)!@$/('-e!^!!n!H!!!!f8fJ!U&!-&.!

)**?!/&%*!'$)?e!^!!n!H!

f88!#$)!-&.!F*+!/&%*e!^!!n!H!!!!!!!(@!-*=!4<*%*e!ÑÑÑÑJJ!!f8gJ!7*%/(==(&)!@%&/!$)-&)*!*0>*7+!

'$)?!&4)*%!)**?*?e!^!!n!H!

f8iJ!E<$+!(=!+<*!A*=+!+-7*!&@!4&&?!@&%!/$6()FZ!!

><$%>&$'! @(%*4&&?! M!/&%+$%! #&)=+%.>+(&)!4&&?!

! ! ! !

f8hJ!U&!-&.!=&/*+(/*=!.=*!+<*!=<*$!+%**!@&%!/$6()F!><$%>&$'n@(%*4&&?n!$!/&%+$%n!>&)=+%.>+(&)!

4&&?eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

f8cJ!T*=(?*=!+<*!@%.(+=!$)?!).+=D!$%*!&+<*%!7$%+=!&@!+<*!=<*$!+%**!.=*?!@&%!$)-+<()Fe!

%&&+=! A$%6! 1.(>*! '*$2*=! @'&4*%=! ÑÑÑJJ!

! ! ! ! ! !

f8dJ!U&!-&.!%*/*/A*%!4<*+<*%!()!+<*!7$=+!+<*%*!4*%*!+<*!=$/*!$/&.)+!&@n!/&%*!n!'*==!=<*$!).+!

+%**=eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

f8QJ! E<$+! <$=! ><$)F*?! ()! +<(=! +&4)! =()>*! -&.! 4*%*! -&.)F*%n! @(%=+! >$/*! <*%*e!

JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJ!

f8:J!;&%!-&.D!4<$+!(=!+<*!A(FF*=+!7%&A'*/!>&)>*%)()F!&@!=<*$!7(>6()FD!7%&>*==()FD!=*''()FD!=+&%$F*e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

84

AJ! B&4! >&.'?! -&.! &2*%>&/*!

+<(=eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ

JJJJ!

fg9J! V@!-&.!>$)!><$)F*!&)'-!&)*!+<()F!4<$+!4&.'?!-&.! '(6*!+&!><$)F*!\@(%=+!&7*)!Y.*=+(&)D! '$+*%!

*0$/7'*=! 7&==(A'*Z! A*++*%! +&&'=! @&%! 7%&>*==()FD! /$><()*=D! $>>*=! +&! '&$)D! A*++*%! $>>*=! +&! $!

/$%6*+nA.-*%=D!'*==!>&/7*+(+(&)D!A*++*%!=+&%$F*!@$>('(+-D!(%%(F$+(&)D!/&%*!A&%*<&'*=D!A*++*%!%&$?=D!

A*++*%! /$%6*+! A.('?()F=D! A*++*%! ()@&%/$+(&)! &)! 7%(>*=! *'=*4<*%*]!

ÑJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

fgfJ! U&! -&.! <$2*! $! A.=()*==! 7'$)! n! ?%*$/! n! <&7*=! @&%! -&.%!

@.+.%*eÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJÑÑÑÑÑÑJJÑÑÑÑÑÑJJJ!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

fg8J!U&!-&.!+<()6!7*&7'*!$%*!()!>&)+%&'!&@!+<*(%!&4)!@$+*D!+<*(%!&4)!=.>>*==!\&%!(=!(+!()!+<*!<$)?=!

&@!=&/*!&)*n!=&/*!+<()F!*'=*]e!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

fggJ! U(?! *2*%! $! /(??'*/$)! $77%&$><! -&.! +&! +<*! =*''! 6*%)*'=! +&! <(/n<*%e! H! ! n! ^!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

fgiJ! !! V@! -*=Z! E<*%*! (=! <*J=<*! @%&/ÑÑÑÑÑJÑÑJ! j.$)+(+-ZÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

_%(>*ZÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJJJ!

fghJ! E<*%*! 4&.'?! -&.! %$+<*%! ()2*=+! ()Z! =<*$! ).+! A.=()*==D! ()>%*$=*! -(*'?! &@! -&.%! >%&7=D! &%!

=&/*+<()F!*'=*e!ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

-&.%! <.=A$)?n><('?%*)! 7(>6! =<*$!

).+eJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ!

K&/*+<()F! +&! $??n! >&//*)+=n! Y.*=+(&)=Z!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

ÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑ!

!

!

!

85

TJ! j.*=+(&))$(%*!>&)=./*%=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!!

!

V)+%&?.>+(&)!&@!()+*%2(*4*%Z!^&.%!)$/*J!!!

\fJ]!5<*%*!$%*!/$)-!Y.*=+(&)=D!+<*!()+*%2(*4!/$-!+$6*!.7!+&!g9!/().+*=!!\8J]!+<(=!(=!$!%*=*$%><!@&%!

$!.)(2*%=(+-D!(+!(=!)&+!@&%!+<*!F&2*%)/*)+!\g]!V!4(''!)&+!F(2*!$4$-!$)-!()@&%/$+(&)!$'&)F!4(+<!-&.%!

)$/*D!V!4(''!/$6*!$!F*)*%$'!%*7&%+!\iJ]!V@!@&%!$)-!%*$=&)!-&.!4&.'?!)&+!'(6*!+&!$)=4*%!$)-!&@!+<*!

Y.*=+(&)=!@**'!@%**!)&+!+&J!!

!

U$+*Z! ! !

5(/*!$+!+<*!=+$%+!&@!+<*!()+*%2(*4Z!! 5(/*!$+!+<*!*)?!&@!+<*!()+*%2(*4Z!!

!

#&//*)+=Z!

!

VUCH5V;V#M5VPH!

3&>$+(&)Z!$%*$!()!5$/$'*Z! !$+!+<*!<&/*! !$+!$!/$%6*+! ! !&+<*%Z!H$/*!&@!$%*$Z!

!

)$/*!\/$-A*!$=6*?!$+!+<*!*)?!&@!()+*%2(*4]Z!

MF*Z!!! !Ö!89!! !89L8h! ! !8hLg9! ! g9Lgh!! ghLi9!! i9Lih!! !ihLh9! ! !h9Ld9! ! d9}!8J8!N*)?*%Z! !! !!/$'*! ! !@*/$'*!

8Jg!,$%(+$'!=+$+.=Z!! !=()F'*! ! ! !/$%%(*?!!! !4(?&4*?!! !?(2&%>*?!8Ji!B&.=*<&'?!)./A*%!\7*&7'*!-&.!+$6*!>$%*!&@!}f]Z!!

8Jh!M%*!-&.!'(2()F!()!5$/$'*!,*+%&7&'(=Z! !-*=! !)&D!)$/*!$%*$Z!!

8Jc!K><&&'()F!>&/7'*+*?Z! !)&!*?.>$+(&)! 7%(/$%-! XBK! KBK!! ! &+<*%=Z!!8Jd!P>>.7$+(&)Z! !.)*/7'&-*?! !+%$?()FZ!()ÑÑÑÑJ! ! !P+<*%Z!!

_IPUG#5!

E<$+!+-7*!=<*$A.++*%!?(?!-&.!A.-e!!

K(l*Z! !>$'*A$=<! !A&4'!! !=/$''!=(l*!! !&+<*%n=7*>(@-Z!#&'&.%Z! !4<(+*! ! !-*''&4! !&+<*%=Z!E<-!+<(=!>&'&.%eZ!

!

;&%!4<$+!7%(>*!\(@!(+!?(@@*%=!7*%!=(l*D!F(2*!$!%$)F*!+<*!><*$7*=+!$)?!+<*!/&=+!*07*)=(2*!&)*]e!!

!

V@!=/$''!=(l*=D!<&4!/$)-!?(?!-&.!A.-e!!

!fLh! ! cLf9! ! ffLfh!! fcL89!! 8fLi9!! !i9}!!!!!!!!!

_3M#C!

B&4!/$)-!+(/*=!$!/&)+<!?&!-&.!A.-!=<*$A.++*%e!!

!

E<*%*!?&!-&.!A.-!(+e!! !/$%6*+! !<&/*! ! &+<*%Z!cJf!V=!(+!$'4$-=!=$/*!7'$>*n7*%=&)e!

!=$/*!7'$>*D!=$/*!7*%=&)! ! !=$/*!7'$>*D!?(@@*%*)+!7*%=&)! !

86

!?(@@*%*)+!7'$>*D!?(@@*%*)+!7*%=&)! !?(@@*%*)+!7'$>*D!=$/*!7*%=&)!

!

GKC!

E<&!4(''!A*!.=()F!+<*!=<*$A.++*%e!!!! !-&.%!=*'@! !<&.=*<&'?! ! &+<*%=! $=! ()! +<*-! 4(''! A.-!@%&/!-&.e! !P+<*%Z!dJf!5<*!=<*$A.++*%!(=!.=*?!/&=+!A-Z! !-&.%!=*'@Z! ! !<&.=*<&'?Z! ! ! .=*?! @&%!

=*''()FZ!

!&+<*%Z!!

E<-!?&!-&.!A.-!=<*$A.++*%!\/&%*!&7+(&)=!7&==(A'*Ü]e!

!>&&6()F! ! !=6()>$%*! !/*?(>()*! !&+<*%=Z!!

V@!@&%!>&&6()FD!4<$+!?(=<eÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑÑJ!

E<$+!=(l*!?&!-&.!.=*!()!+<$+!?(=<e!!

B&4!'&)F!4(''!(+!'$=+e!

V=!+<*%*!$)-+<()F!-&.!?&!+&!+<*!=<*$A.++*%!+&!/$6*!(+!)(>*%e!

!

V@!@&%!=6()>$%*D!!4<$+!?&!-&.!'(6*!$A&.+!(+e!!!

E<$+!>&)+$()*%!=(l*!?&!-&.!.=*e!

B&4!'&)F!4(''!(+!'$=+e!

V=!+<*%*!$)-+<()F!-&.!?&!+&!+<*!=<*$A.++*%!+&!/$6*!(+!)(>*%e!

!

V@!@&%!&+<*%!.=*=D!

E<$+!Y.$)+(+-!?&!-&.!.=*e!

B&4!'&)F!4(''!(+!'$=+e!

jGM3V5^!

E<$+!+-7*!?&!-&.!'(6*e!! !=&@+!A.++*%! !<$%?!A.++*%!! !$)-!+-7*!! !&+<*%Z!f8Jf!E<$+!(=!+<*!%*$=&)eZ!

!

fgJ!B&4!(=!+<*!A.++*%!7$>6$F*?!$)?!F(2*)!+&!-&.e!!! !()!$!7$7*%! !()!$!7'$=+(>!%&AA*%n7&'-+-)! ! !()!$!A&4'! ! !!7$>6$F*?!()!$!>&)+$()*%!! !&+<*%Z!!

fgJf!U&!-&.!'(6*!(+!+<$+!4$-e! !-*=! !)&!fgJ8!I*$=&)Z!!!

!

E<$+!?&!-&.!HP5!3VRC!$A&.+!=<*$A.++*%e!!!!!! !+<*%*!(=!)&+<()F!V!?&!)&+!'(6*!\+<*%*!(=!)&!7%&A'*/]

! !=/*''!! !+$=+*!! !&+<*%Z! !

fiJf!I*$=&)Z!

!

#BMHNCK!

U&!7*&7'*!A.-!/&%*!=<*$A.++*%!+&?$-!>&/7$%*?!+&!+<*!�&'?*)!?$-=k!\'(6*89Lh9!-*$%=!$F&]e! !!

!!-*=! ! !!)&!fhJf!B&4!>&/*eZ!! !

!

87

#$)!-&.!=**!$)-!><$)F*=!()!+<*!Y.$)+(+-!4<*)!-&.!4*%*!$!><('?e!E$=!+<*!$/&.)+!&@!=<*$A.++*%!

$+!+<$+!+(/*Z!!!!!!!!! !'*==! ! !/&%*! !=$/*!

B&4!>&/*eZ!

B&4!'&)F!$F&!4$=!+<(=e!\/$6*!$)!*=+(/$+(&)]! !f9!-*$%=!$F&! !89Lg9!-*$%=!$F&! ! h9!

-*$%=!$F&!

!

#$)!-&.!=**!$)-!><$)F*=!()!+<*!7%(>*!$+!+<$+!+(/*e!

!'*==! ! !/&%*! !=$/*!!

fdJf!E<$+!(=!+<*!%*$=&)e!

!

#$)!-&.!=**!$)-!><$)F*=!!()!+<*!Y.$'(+-e!

!'*==! ! !/&%*! !=$/*!

fQJf!E<$+!(=!+<*!%*$=&)e!!

!

!

KGTK5V5G5CK!

E<$+!&+<*%!7%&?.>+=!?&!-&.!.=*!()=+*$?!&@!=<*$A.++*%e!!

#&&6()FZ! !)&!&+<*%!7%&?.>+=!+<$)!=<*$A.++*%! ! ! !7$'/!&('! !@%-+&'!&('! ! !!F%&.)?).+!&('! !&+<*%=Z!L!E<-e!I*$=&)Z! !A*++*%!+$=+*! !><*$7*%!+<$)!=<*$A.++*%! &+<*%Z!K6()>$%*Z! !>&>&$!A.++*%! !=6()!'(F<+! ! !&+<*%!+-7*=Z!L!E<-e!I*$=&)Z! !/&?*%)!7$>6$F*! !=/*''!! !&+<*%=Z!!

!

#J! j.*=+(&))$(%*!)&)L>&)=./*%=!&@!=<*$!A.++*%!

!

V)+%&?.>+(&)!&@!()+*%2(*4*%Z!^&.%!)$/*J!!!

\fJ]!5<*%*!$%*!$!@*4!Y.*=+(&)=D!+<*!()+*%2(*4!/$-!+$6*!$!@*4!!/().+*=!&@!-&.%!+(/*!!\8J]!+<(=!(=!$!

%*=*$%><! @&%! $! .)(2*%=(+-D! (+! (=! )&+! @&%! +<*! F&2*%)/*)+! \g]! V!4(''! )&+! F(2*! $4$-! $)-! ()@&%/$+(&)!

$'&)F!4(+<!-&.%!)$/*D! V!4(''!/$6*!$!F*)*%$'! %*7&%+! \iJ]! V@! @&%!$)-! %*$=&)!-&.!4&.'?!)&+! '(6*! +&!

$)=4*%!$)-!&@!+<*!Y.*=+(&)=!@**'!@%**!)&+!+&J!!

!

U$+*Z! ! !

5(/*!$+!+<*!=+$%+!&@!+<*!()+*%2(*4Z!! 5(/*!$+!+<*!*)?!&@!+<*!()+*%2(*4Z!!

!

#&//*)+=Z!

!

!

VUCH5V;V#M5VPH!

3&>$+(&)Z!$%*$!()!5$/$'*Z! !$+!+<*!<&/*! !$+!$!/$%6*+! ! !&+<*%Z!H$/*!&@!$%*$Z!

!

)$/*!\/$-A*!$=6*?!$+!+<*!*)?!&@!()+*%2(*4]Z!

MF*Z!!! !Ö!89!! !89L8h! ! !8hLg9! ! g9Lgh!! ghLi9!! i9Lih!! !ihLh9! ! !h9Ld9! ! d9}!

88

8J8!N*)?*%Z! !! !!/$'*! ! !@*/$'*!

8Jg!,$%(+$'!=+$+.=Z!! !=()F'*! ! ! !/$%%(*?!!! !4(?&4*?!! !?(2&%>*?!8Ji!B&.=*<&'?!)./A*%!\7*&7'*!-&.!+$6*!>$%*!&@!}f]Z!!

8Jh!M%*!-&.!'(2()F!()!5$/$'*!,*+%&7&'(=Z! !-*=! !)&D!)$/*!$%*$Z!!

8Jc!E<*%*!?(?!-&.!F%&4!.7e!

8Jc!K><&&'()F!>&/7'*+*?Z! !)&!*?.>$+(&)! 7%(/$%-! XBK! KBK!! ! &+<*%=Z!!8Jd!P>>.7$+(&)Z! !.)*/7'&-*?! !*/7'&-*?D!$=Z! ! !P+<*%Z!!

gJ!! E<-!$%*!-&.!)&+!A.-()F!=<*$!A.++*%e!

!

iJ!B$2*!-&.!*2*%!A&.F<+!=<*$!A.++*%e!

B&4!'&)F!$F&!4$=!+<(=e!

;&%!4<$+!?(?!-&.!.=*!+<*!=<*$!A.++*%e!

E<-!$%*!-&.!)&+!.=()F!(+!$)-/&%*e!

!

!

E<$+!$%*!+<*!.=*=!=<*$!A.++*%!<$=e!

!

!

!

E<$+!&+<*%!7%&?.>+=!?&!-&.!7%*@*%!.=()F!@&%!>&&6()Fe!

E<-e!

!

!

E<$+!&+<*%!7%&?.>+=!?&!-&.!7%*@*%!.=()F!@&%!=6()>$%*e!!

dJf!E<-e!

!

!

!!

!