53
Going Nationwide . . . Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman, Architect

Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Going Nationwide . . .Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice

Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer

Sergio Moya, Construction Manager

David Murray, Apprentice

Keith Soloman, Architect

Page 2: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Road

Pacific Ocean

Sunny Pond

Page 3: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

$4.00$4.05$4.10$4.15$4.20$4.25$4.30$4.35$4.40$4.45$4.50$4.55

Cost (millions)

ConcreteBlock

BearingWalls

StructuralSteel &

Metal Deck

PrecastConcrete

Plank,ConcreteBeams

CompositeBeam &Cast In

Place Slab

Structural Material

Estimate Summary: Building Scheme 1

Page 4: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 5: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 6: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 7: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 8: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Scheme III

Page 9: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 10: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 11: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

WeatherWeather

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Sep

tem

ber

Oct

ob

er

No

vem

ber

Dec

emb

er

Jan

uar

y

Feb

ruar

y

Mar

ch

Ap

ril

May

Jun

e

July

Au

gu

st

Page 12: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 13: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 14: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

0 50 100

Scheme3

Scheme4

EgressDaylightAcousticsPrivacySecuritySpace AdjancecyOccupancySpace Allocation

Performance Based Trade-offs

Page 15: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Rationale . . . Scheme 4

Page 16: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Rationale . . . Scheme 4

Site Plan

Ocean View

Pond

Page 17: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Rationale . . . Scheme 4

Perspective

Page 18: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Scheme 4

1st level Plan

Office

Auditorium

Lab

Student Off.

Classroom

Page 19: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Scheme 4

2nd level Plan

Office

Seminar

Lab

Student Off.

Classroom

Page 20: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Scheme 4

3rd level Plan

Office

Seminar

Lab

Student Off.

Classroom

Page 21: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Structural Analysis

Gravity Loads DL = 120psf LL = 80psf

for preliminary design estimated live load between school and auditorium occupancies

Roof LL = 20psf

Page 22: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Sap2000

Page 23: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

P-T Reinforcement Layout

Page 24: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Missing Column

Page 25: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

No Column, No Problem?

Preliminary Analysis Extreme Moments! 1534 k-ft

O.S.

Page 26: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

No Problem!

Transfer Beams all 3 levels stiffness

proportional Stresses equally

distributed

Page 27: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Structural Analysis

Lateral Loads UBC 97’ Static Force Response Spectra

94’ UBC spectrumsoil type : S2Zone 35% damping

Page 28: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Load Path Diagram

Page 29: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Cad highlight MRF

Page 30: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Ductile Frame Detail

Size of the Members... Fitting in all the

Steel!Use Columns with

large gross area p=1-3%

Keep Beams wide to allow for adjustment of steel during detailing.

Page 31: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Sap2000

Page 32: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Moment diagram

Page 33: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Maximum Inelastic Deflections

Page 34: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Rationale . . . Scheme 4

Page 35: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 36: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Expediting

EnclosureEnclosurePrecast Exterior WallsPrecast Exterior WallsPrefabricated FormworkPrefabricated Formwork

Page 37: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 38: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,
Page 39: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Site LayoutSite Layout

Page 40: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

$4,400,000

$4,500,000

$4,600,000

$4,700,000

$4,800,000

$4,900,000

$5,000,000

$5,100,000

Winter Spring

Scheme 3 - Cost Variation

Enclosure

Construction

Page 41: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Scheme 3: Cost Composition

General Conditions24%

Site Work0%

Concrete12%

Metals18%

Exterior Closure11%

Roofing1%

Interior Construction8%

Conveying2%

Mechanical7%

Electrical10%

Special Construction7%

Page 42: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

$-

$1,000,000

$2,000,000

$3,000,000

$4,000,000

$5,000,000

$6,000,000

$7,000,000

$8,000,000

$9,000,000

$10,000,000

Winter Spring

Scheme 4 - Cost Variation

Enclosure

Construction

Page 43: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Scheme 4: Cost Composition

General Conditions20%

Site Work0%

Estructure27%

Exterior Closure15%

Roofing1%

Interior Construction9%

Conveying1%

Mechanical9%

Electrical12%

Special Construction6%

Page 44: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Costs for Alternative Exterior Walls

$5,400,000

$5,600,000

$5,800,000

$6,000,000

$6,200,000

$6,400,000

$6,600,000

$6,800,000

Series1 $5,915,833 $6,151,286 $6,425,662 $6,654,675

Precast Concrete Stainless Steel Projection Titanium

Budget Difference 224,167 (11,286) (285,662) (514,675) % 4% 0% -5% -8%

Page 45: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

January 15, 2012January 15, 2012

Page 46: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Milestones: May 1, 2012Milestones: May 1, 2012

Page 47: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

HVAC Systems

Page 48: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Two-pipe VAV Reheat System

Page 49: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Hydronic Radiant Floor

Page 50: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Hydronic Radiant Ceiling

Page 51: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Hydronic System

Buderus G-515:

Commercial Cast Iron Boiler

Page 52: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,

Going Nationwide . . .Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice

Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer

Sergio Moya, Construction Manager

David Murray, Apprentice

Keith Soloman, Architect

Page 53: Going Nationwide... Kristy Kinsel, Apprentice Andrew Sparks, Structural Engineer Sergio Moya, Construction Manager David Murray, Apprentice Keith Soloman,