24
Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping in Clinical Care James W. Lomax, M.D. Karl Menninger Chair for Psychiatric Education and Brown Foundation Chair in Psychoanalysis

Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered:

Discovering and Managing Spiritual and

Religious Coping in Clinical Care

James W. Lomax, M.D.Karl Menninger Chair for Psychiatric Educationand Brown Foundation Chair in Psychoanalysis

Page 2: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Presentation Objectives

• Why learn about religion and spiritual matters?

• Illustrative clinical stories, interpretation and

framework

• Discussion of your experiences

Page 3: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Disclosure of Interests

• Personal developments

• Institute for Spirituality and Health (ISH)

Page 4: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping
Page 5: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Disclosure of Interests (Cont.)

• Center for Psychoanalytic Studies

• Center for Professionalism

Page 6: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Spiritual Coping

• Frequent response to stress

• Positive and negative implications

• Relationship to “anomalous” experiences

• Religious Ordering, Spiritual Seeking,

Behavioral Activity

Page 7: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Spiritual Struggles

• Dark side to “Seeking the Sacred”

• Intrapsychic, Interpersonal, Supernatural

• Insecurity, Ambivalence, Conflictual

• Predisposing to Mood, Anxiety, Substance

Abuse Disorders

Page 8: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

First Clinical Situation: Fred, Spiritual

Coping After Sacred Losses

• Traumatic End of Career and calling

• Compensation in Professional and Personal

Relationships

• Ongoing tensions

Page 9: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping
Page 10: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping
Page 11: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Treatment of a Very Complicated Grief

• Things mostly improved

• A major gap

• Building an alliance allows revelation

Page 12: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Psychotherapy as “Practice Field”

• Translating therapy into life

• Mutual relief

• “Displaced” recovery of shared love

Page 13: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping
Page 14: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping
Page 15: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping
Page 16: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping
Page 17: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping
Page 18: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Sylvia, Spiritual Struggle

• Surprising irritability and unprofessionalism

• Angrily anticipating my intervention

• Major Depression and Pharmacotherapy

• Getting and using a developmental history

• Spiritual struggles and her psychopathology

Page 19: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Seeking Spiritual Community

• Something missing

• Seeking community

Page 20: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping
Page 21: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Seeking Spiritual Community (Cont.)

• My boundary crossing

• Utility of community partnership

• Finding new community

Page 22: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Connecting Stories to Framework

• Two “Sacred Moments”

• Fred: Using an anomalous/sacred coping

• Sylvia: Struggles coping with “betrayals”

• Therapeutic “practice field”

• Translating therapeutic learning into repaired

(Fred) or new “community” (Sylvia)

Page 23: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Your Experiences Using Patient

Religious, Spiritual Resources

• What is helpful?

• What is “challenging?”

• Use of community partners

Page 24: Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing … Lost... · 2015-12-11 · Gods Lost, Found, and Reconsidered: Discovering and Managing Spiritual and Religious Coping

Thank you