Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    1/360

    "#$%" #& '($)&*&+, &- ./(0

    )&**$)#$0 $""'," /( '(#12&%&*&+,3 %",)1/'#2,3 $4&*5#/&(3'(0 $%/"#$.&*&+,

    !"#$%"& ()*#+%,

    6789: ';9:89: /:?@7AB3 (BC 6B;8BD*9:E9:

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    2/360

    "#$%&'(' )#%&*%&+ , -.# "#+/( 01#*% 2/3#4 "#*/#&5 6789 : !"#$%&'(') +, -./0

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    3/360

    "#$%&'()* + ,-./0 ,-1. 2% 345#6 7A#6 869:,; - 1 . < = > ? / ,

    7@@ &'()*5 &A5A&BAC: D&'6*AC '6 *)A E6'*AC F*4*A5 #G 7HA&'94: I# $4&* #G *)'5 2##JH4% 2A K5AC #& &A$CK9AC '6 46% H466A& L)4*5#ABA& L'*)#K* L&'**A6 $A&H'55'#6GH"#$%& '(%&$%& )&*+ AM9A$* '6 *)A 945A #G 2&'AG NK#*4*'#65 '6 &AB'AL5 G#& '69@K5'#6'6 4 H4(4O'6A0 6AL5$4$A&0 #& 2C945*:

    P'2&4&% #G "#6(&A55 "4*4@#('6(Q'6QDK2@'94*'#6 R4*4

    S4*A5#60 T&A(#&%:F*A$5 *# 46 A9#@#(% #G H'6C:

    U")46C@A& $K2@'94*'#65 G#& )A4@*) 59'A69A5VWA$&'6*: X&'('64@@% $K2@'5)ACY F46 Z&469'5# Y")46C@A& DK2: "#:0 ,-./: ['*) 6AL $&AG:"#@@A9*'#6 #G 4&*'9@A5 &A$&'6*AC GH B4&'#K5$A&'#C'94@5:\])A $K2@'5)AC L#&J #G T&A(#&% S4*A5#6^Y $:869@KCA5 '6CAM:,: 76*)$#@#(%0 "K@*K&4@_"#@@A9*AC L#&J5:/: `6#L@AC(A0 ])A#&% #G_"#@@A9*AC L#&J5: ?: D5%9)'4*&% _ "#@@A9*AC L#&J5: >:

    aB#@K*'#6 _ "#@@A9*AC L#&J5:8: ]'*@A: 88: FA&'A5: bRIPcY ,: 76*)$#@#(%0 "K@*K&4@_9#@@A9*AC L#&J5: /:

    a9#@#(% _ 9#@@A9*AC L#&J5:

    aB#@K*'#6 _ 9#@@A9*AC L#&J5: >: F9)'O#$)&A6'9D5%9)#@#(%_9#@@A9*AC L#&J5: =: ])'6J'6(_9#@@A9*ACL#&J5: TI < S?/-5 ,-./4dTI,??8FSI ;Q1.

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    4/360

    !"#$%#$&

    !"#$%#$& ("#" "$%" &'()*+( ,"#- "$.% &'()*+( ."#/ )0'(10'2 "3"#4 567'028+7506 "/

    ) *+,- ./ 01-+234516 )7-#" 9:;?@:A 1BC 2> 7BDEFG H:; DE < 9@II=:JK ---#- 9:;F@:A 1BC 2> )L:EMBN:EJK -,-#/ 9:;F@:A *O>@; HS 9@MB 2> T>@ UE>SJK /V-#V 9:;F@:A 1BC 2> 7BDEFG RNN:E; >E &MD^_:=>FC >\ < QMBD`>YBL:ED@Y 2CE\ QMBD`>YBL:ED=: >\ Q>NEK -4.V#/ &L>O=:NG DE +:;

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    5/360

    "#$ % &'(')*+,-*.,/- /0 12*.'3/-43 &56'78 9:;"#" . @ L9K

    8 "#$% '9( :$+,+, +3 %;- )5/0/12 /< =+34 >>?:#C N>/+ @'>3*,66'3 ./ E*-

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    6/360

    !"! !$%! &'()*+(

    " #$%& '&&( )(& )* +,&-),. /$0&1)( 21 1034&(01 *), 0#,&& .&$,1 $(4 " 5$1 $'6& 0)#&67 #89 1&6&:0 0#& &11$.1 5#8:# $,& #&,& ',)3-#0 0)-&0#&, *), 0#& *8,10 089& 8( )(&%)639&; " '&68&%& 0#$0 0#81 81 $ %&,. 897),0$(0 '))5#) $,& 1&$,:#8(- *), $ '&00&, 3(4&,10$(48(- )* 0#&91&6%&1 $(4 0#&8,5),64;

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

    E), $ 9$( 0) :#$(-& #81 '$18:= 7&,:&708)(C4&0&,98(8(- '&68&*1 > 5#$0 /$0&1)(:$661 #81 &7810&9)6)-8:$6 7,&981&1>#& 9310 *8,10 '&C:)9& $5$,& 0#$0 ,&$680. 81 ()0(&:&11$,86. $1 #& '&68&%&1 80 0) '&; @#81 81 ()0 $( &$1. ), :)9*),0$'6& 0#8(- 0) 6&$,(=$(4 9)10 9&( 8( #810),. #$%& 7,)'$'6. '&&( $'6& 0) $%)84 0#8(

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    7/360

    "#$% "#&" "#'()'(* '+ ,#&" -./ 0. ,#$( -./ +"/0- & "$1"2..)3 45+.6 ". 5$&7( ". "#'()6-./ %/+" #&8$ & "$&9#$7 ,#. 9&( "#'()3 :#$ 5., 5$8$5 .; ,#&"

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    8/360

    !"# !%&' ()*+,-*

    "#$%' ()*$+&, -)+ .&,/ &. 01&*2,% 3$#)45$2*1+6 78,*& *9$ +):$ #2;$# ,& :),4), +*$< *-24$=>

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    9/360

    "#$%&$'()* + ,-'. /-0 12#$$#+ 20 /-0 3'(#4,&1(-4' -',-12($0+ 5#$.4#* 6$)( 20 -6 /$7$#$ 08$29-'. 2', 7#-(-'. -' 2 64#$-.' )2'.&2.$: ;$48)$ ,-, '4( 0-$*4', 2,)$ (4 2 6$7 7/$' (/$ 14))$1(-4' 6-#0( 288$2#$,:

    @* 2,H-1$ (4 #$2,$#0 74&), >$ (4 /2'. 4' (4 (/$ 1/2))$'.$ 20 7$)) 20 (/$ 266-#)$ '&1)$2# ,-02#4(/ $,&12(-4' 2', /$2)-'. (/2( 7-)) H2)&$ 2', $'/2'1$ (/$ 14

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    10/360

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    11/360

    "#$%&$#' ()&% *+% + ,-+./ /0 %/1$2 3/)# -04# 05 /)# 6+-+$07#% 05 8"%/-+9/&0. &.:0;;1.&9+/&0.' ?+2 @+4#2> ?0). A#+B4+.$> +.$ C&44 D-2 E0&.#$ ;# /0 50-; +%;+44 -#%#+-9) /#+; *&/)&. /)# F'8' @0%G&/+4'

    C1/ +,+&. /)#-# *+% 5+&41-#' H1- ,-+./ *+% 50- 0.42 /*0 2#+-%> :)#%/#- C+-.+-$)+$ -#/&-#$> +.$ &. /)# 0G&.&0. 05 /)# D01.$+/&0. %/+55 *# $&$ .0/ )+I# #.01,)-#%14/% /0 E1%/&52 -#.#*+4' ()# ,-+./ -+. 01/> "1/ ;2 /#+; 402+442 %/+2#$ *&/) ;#*&/)01/ G+2' ()# *0-B *#./ 0.> +.$> + 5#* $+2% +5/#- /)# #.$ 05 /)# ,-+./> *)&4# J*+% *-&/&., + $#%G#-+/# 4#//#- /0 K0-"#-/ A.#- 50- )&% +$I&9# +"01/ *)#-# /0 ,#/ /)#.#7/ ,-+./> /)# $01"4# "&.$ )2G0/)#%&% 5#44 &./0 G4+9#'

    D&.+442 D-+.B D-#;0./LM;&/) +.$ /)# N+92 D01.$+/&0. %+I#$ 1%'85/#- /)+/ /)#-# *#-# ,-+./% 5-0; /)# D01.$+/&0.% D1.$ 50- 6%29)&+/-2 +.$ 5-0;

    /)# K+/&0.+4 J.%/&/1/# 05 N#./+4 @#+4/)'O-+$1+442 &/ +GG#+-#$ /)+/ 50- /)# .#7/ +$I+.9#% &. /)# %/1$2 05 40,&9+4 /2G&., &.

    90;;1.&9+/&0. J %)014$ *0-B *&/) +.&;+4 ;+/#-&+4> +.$ J %/+-/#$ /0 *0-B *&/)09/0G1%' N2 *&5#> P0&%> *0-B#$ *&/) ;#> +.$ 50- 0I#- + 2#+- *# B#G/ + $0Q#.09/0G1%#% &. 01- 4&I&., -00;' ()&% G-#4&;&.+-2 *0-B *+% G-0;&%&., "1/ .##$#$ /0 "#-#G#+/#$ +.$ #7/#.$#$ 1.$#- "#//#- 90.$&/&0.%' D0- /)&% .0 ,-+./% *#-# +I+&4+"4#'

    8/ /)&% G0&./> ?0). P&442 9+;# 50-*+-$ +.$ &.I&/#$ ;# /0 "# /)# $&-#9/0- 05 )&%$04G)&. 4+"0-+/0-2 &. /)# F&-,&. J%4+.$%' J *0-B#$ /)#-# 50- +"01/ + 2#+- +.$ "#9+;#&./#-#%/#$ &. /)# G-0"4#;% 05 9#/+9#+. 90;;1.&9+/&0.> "1/ J /)&.B J +; .0/ 91/ 01/ /0+$;&.&%/#- + 4+"0-+/0-2 $1"&01%42 51.$#$ &. + G4+9# *)#-# /)# 40,&%/&9% +-#&./04#-+"42 $&55&914/'

    J/ *+% *)&4# J *+% %/-1,,4&., *&/) /)#%# G-0"4#;% /)+/ J -#9#&I#$ + :+-##-R#I#40G;#./ 8*+-$ 1.$#- /)# K+/&0.+4 J.%/&/1/# 05 N#./+4 @#+4/)' ()#%# +*+-$%*#-# +$;&.&%/#-#$ "2 C#-/ C00/)#> +.$ J 0*# ;19) /0 )&% 90./&.1#$ 5+&/) +.$&./#-#%/'

    J. STUV> (+240- 6-20- 05 /)# H9#+.&9 D01.$+/&0. &. @+*+&& &.I&/#$ ;# /0 *0-B &.)&% H9#+.&9 J.%/&/1/# 0. 9#/+9#+. +.$ 0/)#- G-0"4#;% 05 +.&;+4 +.$ )1;+.

    90;;1.&9+/&0.' J/ &% )#-# /)+/ J )+I# *-&//#. ;0-# /)+. )+45 05 /)# G-#%#./ "00B>&.941$&., /)# *)04# 05 6+-/ F'

    A)&4# &. @+*+&&> J )+I# +4%0 "##. *0-B&., -#9#./42 *&/) /)# :14/1-# P#+-.&.,J.%/&/1/# 05 /)# W+%/LA#%/ :#./#- &. /)# =.&I#-%&/2 05 @+*+&&> +.$ 0*# %0;#/)#0-#/&9+4 &.%&,)/% -#,+-$&., P#+-.&., JJJ /0 $&%91%%&0.% )#4$ &. /)+/ J.%/&/1/#'

    N2 $#"/ /0 /)# A#..#-LO-#. D01.$+/&0. &% #I&$#./ 5-0; /)# 5+9/ /)+/ /)# "00B90./+&.% .0 4#%% /)+. 501- G0%&/&0. G+G#-% *-&//#. 50- A#..#-LO-#. 90.5#-#.9#%' J*&%) +4%0 /0 /)+.B G#-%0.+442 N-%' P&/+ H%;1.$%#.> /)# R&-#9/0- 05 X#%#+-9) 05 /)+/D01.$+/&0.'

    N+.2 +4%0 )+I# 4+"0-#$ +40., /)# -0+$ /0 )#4G ;#' N0%/ 05 /)#%# 9+..0/ "#;#./&0.#$ )#-#> "1/ J ;1%/ G+-/&914+-42 /)+.B R-' F#-. :+--044> *)0 G-#G+-#$ /)#"&"4&0,-+G)2> +.$ ;2 %#9-#/+-2> ?1$&/) F+. M400/#.> *)0 4+"0-#$ *&/) +991-+92/)-01,) 40., )01-% &. G-#G+-&., /)&% "00B 50- G-#%%'

    D&.+442 /)#-# &% /)# $#"/ /)+/ #I#-2 ;+. 05 %9.9# 0*#% /0 /)# ,&+./% 05 /)# G+%/'J/ &% .0 ;#+. 90;50-/> +/ /&;#% *)#. /)# .#7/ &$#+ 9+..0/ "# 501.$ +.$ /)# *)04#

    #./#-G-&%# %##;% 51/&4#> /0 -#;#;"#- /)+/ ,-#+/#- ;#. )+I# *-#%/4#$ *&/) /)# %+;#G-0"4#;%' N2 G#-%0.+4 &.%G&-+/&0. )+% 0*#$ ;19) /0 /)# ;#. *)0 0I#- /)# 4+%/ YZZ2#+-% )+I# B#G/ +4&I# /)# &$#+ 05 1.&/2 "#/*##. ;&.$ +.$ "0$2[ P+;+-9B> /)#501.$#- 05 #I041/&0.+-2 /)#0-2> ;&%#-+"4#> 04$> +.$ "4&.$> +.$ $+;.#$ "2 :1I->

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    12/360

    "#$ %&'(&)&* (+ ,-&.(/' 01&/2($+3 4(''(/5 6'/7&8 2#& -$&2 /+* -/(+2&18 "#$ 9/":2#1$;

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    13/360

    !"# %&'()*+,'%)&

    !"#"! %&' ()*'+)' ,- .*+/ 0+/ 12/'23

    "#$ %&%'$ () %#&* +((, () -(''$-%$. $**/0* /1. '$-%23$* &* &1%$1.$. 43$-&*$'0 %(.$)&1$ %#$ -(1%$1%*5 "#$ $**/0*6 *43$/. (7$3 %#&3%08)&7$ 0$/3*6 -(9+&1$ %( 43(4(*$ /1$: :/0 () %#&1,&1; /+(2% &.$/* /1. /+(2% %#(*$ /;;3$;/%$* () &.$/* :#&-# < -/''=9&1.*5> "#&* :/0 () %#&1,&1; < -/'' %#$ =$-('(;0 () 9&1.6> (3 %#$ $-('(;0 () &.$/*5

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    14/360

    "#$% '()' "%$$#*#&+#, - ().# /##& 0'*1+2 "13/4 - ().# 0)%" .)51#67 '()' )&7 0'1"78(%+( '(*980 6%5(' 1:9& '(# &)'1*# 9$ ;9*"#*< 9* ;:)''#*&< %& '(# 1&%.#*0# %0 01*#67&9&'*%.%)64

    =1' '(%0 )&08#* 9&67 /#50 '(# >1#0'%9&4- 10#" '9 '#)+( )& %&$9*3)6 +91*0# $9* :07+(%)'*%+ *#0%"#&'0 %& '(# ?#'#*)&0

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

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    15/360

    "#$ %&'()'* #'% +#)$$ ,-./*012 30 +#$ .$4+5 6 .&1+$% 7')&-/1 1-)+1 -4/0&0+$)8)$+$% %'+'5 1/,# '1 ' 4&.* )$,-)% -4 #/*'0 -) '0&*'. 9$#'7&-)5 ' %$1,)&8+&-0-4 '0 $:8$)&*$0+5 ' %$1,)&8+&-0 -) 8#-+-()'8# -4 ' 9$$+.$;1 .$(5 -) ' )$,-)%$% #/*'0/++$)'0,$2 6 1+)$11$% +#$ 4',+ +#'+ $,+ &1 *$'1/)$% '('&01+ +#$ ?$&(#+ -4 1-*$ -+#$) -9>$,+ -) )$(&1+$)$%-0 ' *$B+$)2 "#$ #/*'0 7-&,$ &1 +)'014-)*$% &0+- 7')&'9.$ *'(0$+&C'+&-01 -4 +'8$2D-)$-7$)5 '.?'@1 '0% &0$7&+'9.@5 +#$)$ &1 ' 1$.$,+&-0 -4 %'+' 9$,'/1$ +#$ +-+'./0&7$)1$5 8'1+ '0% 8)$1$0+5 &1 0-+ 1/9>$,+ +- -91$)7'+&-0 4)-* '0@ (&7$0 -91$)7$);18-1&+&-02

    60 ' 1+)&,+ 1$01$5 +#$)$4-)$5 0- %'+' ')$ +)/.@

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    16/360

    "#$"%&'( )*++ ,% "#--%"'%. /$. *0&-#1%. 2$'*+ /' +/(' '3%4 /-% )#-'34 #5 / &+/"% *$ '3%+*(' #5 52$./0%$'/+(6 7,#2' 5*5'4 4%/-( #5 )#-8 *$ )3*"3 '3#2(/$.( #5 "+%1%- 0%$3/1% 3/. '3%*- (3/-% 3/1%9 *$ 5/"'9 &-#.2"%. / -*"3 "-#& #5 (%1%-/+ 32$.-%. 3%2-*('*""#$"%&'(9 ,2'9 /+/(9 ("/-"%+4 / (*$:+% &-*$"*&+% )#-'34 #5 / &+/"% *$ '3% +*(' #552$./0%$'/+(6

    ;' *( /++ '## "+%/- '3/' '3% 1/(' 0/&+/*$( '3% "3/$:% ,4 :*1*$: / $/0% '# /5*"'*'*#2( ?"/2(%9@ +#"/'%. *$ #$% #- #'3%- "#0$%$' #5 '3% *$'%-/"'*$: (4('%06 I*'3%-'3% #&*20 "#$'/*$( / -%*5*%. .#-0*'*1% &-*$"*&+%9 #- '3% 0/$ "#$'/*$( / -%*5*%. $%%.5#- (+%%&9 /$ /.#-0*'#(*(9 )3*"3 *( ?%>&-%((%.@ *$ 3*( -%($(% '# #&*206

    7$.9 "3/-/"'%-*('*"/++49 /++ (2"3 34'3%(%( /-% ?.#-0*'*1%@ *$ '3% (%$(% '3/' '3%4&2' '# (+%%& '3% ?"-*'*"/+ 5/"2+'4@ D/$#'3%- -%*5*%. 5*"'*'*#2( "/2(%E )*'3*$ '3% ("*%$'*('3*0(%+56

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

    /$. )*++ +%/. #$ '# .%-*1/'*1% 34'3%(%( $# +%(( ?.#-0*'*1%@ '3/$ '3/' 5-#0 )3*"3)% ('/-'%.6

    ;$ 5/"'9 '3% 02+'*&+*"/'*#$ #5 .#-0*'*1% 34'3%(%( *( / (40&'#0 #5 %>"%((*1%&-%5%-%$"% 5#- *$.2"'*#$9 /$. '3*( &-%5%-%$"% 02(' /+J)/4( +%/. '# (#0%'3*$: +*8% '3%&-%(%$' ('/'% #5 '3% ,%3/1*#-/+ ("*%$"%(G / 0/(( #5 M2/(*J'3%#-%'*"/+ (&%"2+/'*#$2$"#$$%"'%. )*'3 /$4 "#-% #5 52$./0%$'/+ 8$#)+%.:%6

    ;$ "#$'-/('9 ; '-4 '# '%/"3 ('2.%$'(G /$. '3*( "#++%"'*#$ #5 %((/4( *( 1%-4 02"3"#$"%-$%. )*'3 '-4*$: '# "#002$*"/'% '3*( '3%(*(G'3/' *$ ("*%$'*5*" -%(%/-"3 4#2('/-' 5-#0 ')# ,%:*$$*$:(9 %/"3 #5 )3*"3 3/( *'( #)$ 8*$. #5 /2'3#-*'4N '3%#,(%-1/'*#$( "/$$#' ,% .%$*%.9 /$. '3% 52$./0%$'/+( 02(' ,% 5*''%.6 O#2 02('/"3*%1% / (#-' #5 &*$"%-( 0/$%21%-6

    ;5 4#2 /-% (2-1%4*$: / &*%"% #5 +/$.9 #- 0/&&*$: '3% ('/-(9 4#2 3/1% ')# ,#.*%(#5 8$#)+%.:%9 $%*'3%- #5 )3*"3 "/$ ,% *:$#-%.6 A3%-% /-% 4#2- #)$ %0&*-*"/+0%/(2-%0%$'( #$ '3% #$% 3/$. /$. '3%-% *( I2"+*.%/$ :%#0%'-4 #$ '3% #'3%-6 ;5 '3%(%')# "/$$#' ,% 0/.% '# 5*' '#:%'3%-9 '3%$ %*'3%- '3% ./'/ /-% )-#$: #- 4#2 3/1%

    /-:2%. )-#$:+4 5-#0 '3%0 #- 4#2 3/1% 0/.% / 0/

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    17/360

    "#$%& '"( ) *+$ ,"(($& -./0(. .0&+.1 .(&1$23 $1 " 4",1"'.(& )+"- #.&&.1 +$5- +042.",. 1"&+.1 &+"( "-- &$ &+. .604&0(7 8%(75. $/ +"5/9#":.- +32$&+.4.4;

    4"3 /1$' &+. &0'. $/ D.*&$( &$ &+. 5"&. (0(.&..(&+ ,.(&%13>&+. -$'0("(& 21.$,,%2"&0$( $/ 4,0.(,. *"4 *0&+ &+$4. ,+"0(4 $/ ,"%4. "(- .//.,&*+0,+ ,$%5- #. 1./.11.- &$ /$1,.4 "(- 0'2",&4; E+. '"&+.'"&0,4 "="05"#5. &$ D.*&$(*"4 21.2$(-.1"(&53 ?%"(&0&"&0=.> "(- &+04 /",&> ,$'#0(.- *0&+ &+. ,.(&1"5 /$,%4 %2$(/$1,.4 "(- 0'2",&4> 5.- '.( &$ '."4%1. *0&+ 1.'"1:"#5. ",,%1",3 ?%"(&0&0.4 $/

    -04&"(,.> &0'.> '"&&.1> "(- .(.173;F4 &+. '."4%1.'.(&4 $/ &+. 4%1=.3$1 '%4& 80#. *0&+ G%,50-."( 7.$'.&13> 4$

    4,0.(&0/0, &+$%7+& +"- &$ 80#. *0&+ &+. 71."& ,$(4.1="&0=. 5"*4; E+. -.4,102&0$( $/ "(3.=.(& .6"'0(.- #3 " 2+340,04& $1 ,+.'04& *"4 &$ #. /$%(-.- %2$( #%-7.&4 $/ '"44"(- .(.173> "(- &+04 1%5. 7"=. " 2"1&0,%5"1 :0(- $/ 107$1 &$ &+. *+$5. $/ &+$%7+& 0(&+. +"1- 4,0.(,.4;

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

    @& *$%5- +"=. #..( '$1. /1%0&/%5 &$ &+0(: $/ 5",: $/ .(.173 "4 21.=.(&0=. $/#.+"=0$1> 40(,. 0( &+. .(- " 4&"1=0(7 '"( *055 ,."4. &$ #.9+"=.; @ #.50.=.> *1$(70( ,+$$40(7 K.(.173L "4 &+. /$%(-"&0$( /$1 &+"& #10-7.;

    @/ '"44 "(- 5.(7&+ "1. 0("221$210"&. /$1 &+. -.4,10#0(7 $/ #.+"=0$1> &+.( .(.17304 %(50:.53 &$ #. '$1. "221$210"&.; F/&.1 "55> .(.173 04 N"44 6 Q.5$,0&3B> "(- ($#.+"=0$1"5 4,0.(&04& 1."553 0(404&4 &+"& K243,+0, .(.173L 04 $/ &+.4. -0'.(40$(4;

    @& 04 (.,.44"13> &+.1./$1.> &$ 5$$: "7"0( "'$(7 &+. /%(-"'.(&"54 /$1 "("221$210"&. 4.& $/ 0-."4 "7"0(4& *+0,+ *. ,"( &.4& $%1 +.%104&0, +32$&+.4.4;

    4$ *. 4+$%5-

    ,$(&0(%. *0&+ 0(-%,&0$( %(&05 *. 7.& " /%(-"'.(&"5 "(4*.1;@ #.50.=. &+"& 0& 04 40'253 ($& &1%. &+"& &+. /%(-"'.(&"54 $/ 4,0.(,. #.7"( 0(

    0(-%,&0$( /1$' .62.10.(,.> "(- @ 4%77.4& &+"& 0( &+. 4."1,+ /$1 " #10-7.+."- "'$(7&+. /%(-"'.(&"54 *. 4+$%5- 7$ #",: &$ &+. =.13 #.70((0(74 $/ 4,0.(&0/0, "(-

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    18/360

    "#$%&'&"#$( )#&*+#), (-.)/$0%1 )& / "-.$&2 3-4&.- '($-0(-5 "#$%&'&"#15 /02 .-%$+$&0#/2 3-6(&7- '-"/./)- /()$8$)$-' '-"/./)-%1 "*.'*-2 31 ".&4-''$&0/%' $0 '-"/./)-2$'($"%$0-'9

    :&0'$2-.5 4&. -;/7"%-5 )#- (-0)./% &.$+$0 71)# &4 $)# >#$(# )#$' 71)# $'(&0(-.0-2?

    @0 )#- 3-+$00$0+ A&2 (.-/)-2 )#- #-/8-0 /02 )#- -/.)#9 B02 )#--/.)# >/' >$)#&*) 4&.75 /02 8&$2, /02 2/.C0-'' >/' *"&0 )#- 4/(-&4 )#- 2--"9 B02 )#- D"$.$) &4 A&2 7&8-2 *"&0 )#- 4/(- &4 )#->/)-.'9

    B02 A&2 '/$25 E-) )#-.- 3- %$+#)F /02 )#-.- >/' %$+#)9 B02 A&2'/> )#- %$+#)5 )#/) $) >/' +&&2F /02 A&2 2$8$2-2 )#- %$+#) 4.&7 )#-

    2/.C0-''9 B02 A&2 (/%%-2 )#- %$+#) G/15 /02 )#- 2/.C0-'' #- (/%%-2H$+#)9 B02 )#- -8-0$0+ /02 )#- 7&.0$0+ >-.- )#- 4$.') 2/19

    B02 A&2 '/$25 E-) )#-.- 3- / 4$.7/7-0) $0 )#- 7$2') &4 )#->/)-.'5 /02 %-) $) 2$8$2- )#- >/)-.' 4.&7 )#- >/)-.'9 B02 A&2 7/2-)#- 4$.7/7-0)5 /02 2$8$2-2 )#- >/)-.' >#$(# >-.- *02-. )#-4$.7/7-0) 4.&7 )#- >/)-.' >#$(# >-.- /3&8- )#- 4$.7/7-0)F /02 $)>/' '&9 B02 A&2 (/%%-2 )#- 4$.7/7-0) I-/8-09 B02 )#- -8-0$0+/02 )#- 7&.0$0+ >-.- )#- '-(&02 2/19

    B02 A&2 '/$25 E-) )#- >/)-.' *02-. )#- #-/8-0 3- +/)#-.-2)&+-)#-. *0)& &0- "%/(-5 /02 %-) )#- 2.1 %/02 /""-/.F /02 $) >/' '&9B02 A&2 (/%%-2 )#- 2.1 %/02 J/.)#, /02 )#- +/)#-.$0+ )&+-)#-. &4 )#->/)-.' (/%%-2 #- D-/'F /02 A&2 '/> )#/) $) >/' +&&29

    B*)#&.$K-2 8-.'$&0

    L*) &4 )#-'- 4$.') )-0 8-.'-' &4 )#*02-.&*' ".&'-5 >- (/0 2./> '&7- &4 )#-".-7$'-' &. 4*02/7-0)/%' &4 /0($-0) :#/%2-/0 )#&*+#) /02 $) $' ')./0+-5 /%7&') --.$-5)& 0&)- #&> 7/01 &4 )#- 4*02/7-0)/%' /02 ".&3%-7' &4 7&2-.0 '($-0(- /.-4&.-'#/2&>-2 $0 )#- /0($-0) 2&(*7-0)9

    MNO P#- ".&3%-7 &4 )#- &.$+$0 /02 0/)*.- &4 7/))-. $' '*77/.$%1 2$'7$''-29MQO P#- "/''/+- 2-/%' /) %-0+)# >$)# )#- ".&3%-7 &4 )#- &.$+$0 &4 &.2-.9MRO B '-"/./)$&0 $' )#*' +-0-./)-2 3-)>--0 )#- )>& '&.)' &4 ".&3%-79 @) $' "&''$3%-

    )#/) )#$' '-"/./)$&0 &4 ".&3%-7' >/' /0 -..&.5 3*)S-..&. &. 0&)S)#- '-"/./)$&0 $'7/$0)/$0-2 $0 )#- 4*02/7-0)/%' &4 7&2-.0 '($-0(-9 P#- (&0'-.8/)$8- %/>' 4&. 7/))-./02 -0-.+1 /.- ')$%% '-"/./)- 4.&7 )#- %/>' &4 &.2-.5 0-+/)$8- -0).&"15 /02$04&.7/)$&09

    MTO L.2- $' '--0 /' / 7/))-. &4 '&.)$0+ /02 2$8$2$0+9 U*) )#- -''-0)$/% 0&)$&0 $0 /%%'&.)$0+ $' )#/) '&7- 2$44-.-0(- '#/%% (/*'- '&7- &)#-. 2$44-.-0(- /) / %/)-. )$7-9 @4 >-

    /.- '&.)$0+ 3%/(C 3/%%' 4.&7 >#$)- 3/%%'5 &. %/.+- 3/%%' 4.&7 '7/%% 3/%%'5 / 2$44-.-0(-/7&0+ )#- 3/%%' $' )& 3- 4&%%&>-2 31 / 2$44-.-0(- $0 )#-$. %&(/)$&0S3/%%' &4 &0- (%/'')& &0- '/(C /02 3/%%' &4 /0&)#-. (%/'' )& /0&)#-.9 V&. '*(# /0 &"-./)$&05 >- 0--2'&7-)#$0+ %$C- / '$-8-5 / )#.-'#&%25 &.5 "/. -;(-%%-0(-5 / '-0'- &.+/09 @) $'

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    19/360

    "#$%&'()#$)*+%, (-%&%./&%, (-)( ) 0%&1%232#4 5#(2(6 '-/"+$ -)3% *%%# 2#3/7%$ (/0%&./&8 (-2' ."#1(2/# /. 1&%)(2#4 )# /(-%&92'% 280&/*)*+% /&$%&:

    ;+/'%+6 +2#7%$ 92(- (-% '/&(2#4 )#$ $232$2#4 2' (-% 86'(%&6 /. 1+)''2.21)(2/#, (/*% ./++/9%$ +)(%& *6 (-% %?(&)/&$2#)&6 -"8)# )1-2%3%8%#( /. #)82#4:

    @( 2' #/( )( )++ 1+%)& (-)( (-% 3)&2/"' 1/80/#%#(' /. (-2' 86(- )&% )++ 0&/$"1(' /.2#$"1(23% &%)'/#2#4 .&/8 %?0%&2%#1%: A#$ (-% 8)(B(%& *%1/8%' '(2++ 8/&% 0"CC+2#49-%# (-2' /&242# 86(- 2' 1/80)&%$ 92(- /(-%&' 9-21- %8*/$6 $2..%&%#( ."#$)8%#()+0&%82'%':

    A8/#4 (-% @)(8"+ /. D%9 E"2#%), (-% 1%#(&)+ /&242# 86(-, +27% (-% E%#%'2' '(/&6,$%)+' 92(- (-% F"%'(2/# /. -/9 $&6 +)#$ 9)' '%0)&)(%$ .&/8 9)(%&: G-%6 ')6 (-)( 2#(-% *%42##2#4 (-% 1&/1/$2+% H)39/78)+2 0)$$+%$ 92(- -2' .&/#( +%4' )#$ 92(- -2'-2#$ +%4'I )#$ -2' 0)$$+2#4 7%0( (-% 8"$ '"'0%#$%$ 2# (-% 9)(%&: G-% 4&%)( 1"+("&%-%&/, H%3%8*")#44), 1)8% 92(- -2' '0%)& )#$ 72++%$ H)39/78)+2: A.(%& (-)( (-%8"$ '%((+%$ )#$ $&6 +)#$ 9)' ./&8%$: H%3%8*")#44) (-%# '()80%$ 92(- -2' .//( /#

    (-% $&6 +)#$, 2:%:, -% 0&/"$+6 $%8/#'(&)(%$ J(-)( 2( 9)' 4//$:KL%&% (-%&% 2' ) '(&/#4%& 1)'% ./& $%&232#4 (-% 86(- .&/8 %?0%&2%#1% 1/8*2#%$

    92(- 2#$"1(23% &%)'/#2#4: A.(%& )++, 8"$ $/%' &%B8)2# 2# '"'0%#'2/# 2. &)#$/8+6'(2&&%$ )#$ $/%' '%((+% 9-%# (-% '(2&B&2#4 1%)'%': M/&%/3%&, (-% @)(8"+ 0%/0+% +23% 2#(-% 3)'( '9)80' /. (-% N%027 O23%& 3)++%6 9-%&% (-% '%0)&)(2/# /. +)#$ .&/8 9)(%& 2'280%&.%1(: @( 2' "#$%&'()#$)*+% (-)( (-%6 824-( *% 2#(%&%'(%$ 2# (-% $2..%&%#(2)(2/# /.+)#$ .&/8 9)(%&:

    @# )#6 1)'%, (-% @)(8"+ -)3% )&&23%$ )( ) (-%/&6 /. /&$%& 9-21- 2' )+8/'( ) 0&%12'%1/#3%&'% /. (-)( /. (-% *//7 /. E%#%'2': @# @)(8"+ (-/"4-(, '/&(2#4 92++ /11"& 2.&)#$/82C)(2/# 2' 0&%3%#(%$: @# E%#%'2', )# )4%#( 2' 2#3/7%$ (/ $/ (-% '/&(2#4 )#$$232$2#4:

    P"( */(- 1"+("&%' )+27% )''"8% ) ."#$)8%#()+ $232'2/# *%(9%%# (-% 0&/*+%8' /.8)(%&2)+ 1&%)(2/# )#$ (-% 0&/*+%8' /. /&$%& )#$ $2..%&%#(2)(2/#:

    O%("#4 #/9 (/ (-% F"%'(2/# /. 9-%(-%& (-% ."#$)8%#()+' /. '12%#1% )#$Q/&0-2+/'/0-6 9%&%, )( (-% 0&282(23% +%3%+, )&&23%$ )( *6 2#$"1(23% &%)'/#2#4 .&/8

    %802&21)+ $)(), 9% .2#$ (-)( (-% )#'9%& 2' #/( '280+%: @( 2' $2..21"+( (/ '%% -/9 (-%$21-/(/86 *%(9%%# '"*'()#1% )#$ ./&8 1/"+$ *% )&&23%$ )( *6 2#$"1(23% )&4"8%#(:D/ 8)#, ).(%& )++, -)' %3%& '%%# /& %?0%&2%#1%$ ./&8+%'' )#$ "#'/&(%$ 8)((%&I R"'( )'#/ 8)# -)' %3%& '%%# /& %?0%&2%#1%$ ) J&)#$/8K %3%#(: @., (-%&%./&%, (-% #/(2/# /. )"#23%&'% J92(-/"( ./&8 )#$ 3/2$K 9)' )&&23%$ )( *6 2#$"1(2/#, 2( 9)' *6 )8/#'(&/"'S)#$ 0%&-)0' %&&/#%/"' S R"80 /. %?(&)0/+)(2/#:

    A#$ %3%# '/, 2( 2' #/( 1+%)& (-)( (-% '()&(2#4 0/2#( .&/8 9-21- (-% 0&282(23%0-2+/'/0-%&' (//7 /.. 9)' /*'%&3)(2/#: @( 2' )( +%)'( %F")++6 +27%+6 (-)( $21-/(/86*%(9%%# ./&8 )#$ '"*'()#1% 9)' )# "#1/#'12/"' $%$"1(2/# .&/8 (-% '"*R%1(B0&%$21)(% &%+)(2/# 2# (-% '(&"1("&% /. 0&282(23% +)#4")4%: G-2', -/9%3%&, 2' ) 8)((%&*%6/#$ (-% &%)1- /. "'%."+ '0%1"+)(2/#:

    P% (-)( )' 2( 8)6, (-% 1%#(&)+S*"( "'")++6 #/( %?0+212( S '"*R%1( 8)((%& /. (-%+%1("&%' 9-21- @ "'%$ (/ 423% (/ 0'61-2)(&21 &%'2$%#(' )#$ /. (-%'% %'')6' 2' (-% *&2$4%*%(9%%# *%-)32/&)+ $)() )#$ (-% J."#$)8%#()+'K/. '12%#1% )#$ 0-2+/'/0-6I )#$ 861&2(21)+ 1/88%#(' )*/3% )*/"( (-% 8%()0-/&21 "'% /. J%#%&46K 2# (-% *%-)32/&)+

    '12%#1%' )$$ "0 (/ ) &)(-%& '280+% )11"')(2/# /. 8)#6 /. 86 1/++%)4"%', (-)( (-%6-)3% (&2%$ (/ *"2+$ (-% *&2$4% (/ (-% 9&/#4 -)+. /. (-% )#12%#( $21-/(/86 *%(9%%#./&8 )#$ '"*'()#1%: G-% 1/#'%&3)(23% +)9' ./& %#%&46 )#$ 8)((%& 1/#1% '"*'()#1%

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    20/360

    "#$%&" $%#' ()"*+ ,-$ *&'$#. /")0&112 34 0)**-'30#$3)'2 )"5#'36#$3)'243((&"&'$3#$3)'2 /#$$&"'2 #'4 1) )'2 #"& *#$$&"1 )( ()"* "#$%&" $%#' 1-71$#'0&+

    83$%3' $%& 7)49 )( (-'4#*&'$#.12 $%#$ %#.( :%30% 4.1 :3$% ()"* %#1 7&&'4"#*#$30#..9 &'"30%&4 3' $%& .#1$ $%3"$9 9"1 79 $%& 4310);&"3&1 )( 097&"'&$301 #'4191$&*1 $%&)"9+

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    21/360

    ! #$%& '( )*&$+,-.*/

    "#$%&%'%(&) * +,-./012, 34 . 5067,84.-306 .902- 40+, :809/,+.-35 429;,5-0 1' ) ,1'',0 /1'& ,1;0 '(18& 1' 18 8'1,, '1-23"# I,, 61=('B/+' >062& >062 70* @,)?0834# I,, 61=('& >062& >062 70* @,)?083 $%* *()' )/%+' '(0 '0--2 /0)6 ).- 2%+6 -%,,& ).-

    '(0 51J)6- %7 AJ ).- 2%+6 8*0)'06& ).- 2%+6 8(%089 H'062& >062 70* @,)?08 *(1?( )60 E'1-2F

    7%6 '()' '(1.=9"# C08& ")--2B/+' '(0 51J)6- %7 AJ ?%+,- /0 ).2K*(060 %. '()' 8(0,73 I.-

    ")--2B-% 2%+ ;.%* *()'9 H ()'0& ()'0 1' *(0. D2 /%%;8 =0' ),, D1G0- +@ *1'(2%+6 /%%;8 ).- L+DD206 '% '),;1.= )/%+' ED1G0- +@F *(0. *08')6'0- *1'( ED+--,0- +@9F

    4# UDDV H *%.-06V /+' H '(1.; 8%BC08B/0?)+80 ,0'0 ),, '(0 8).- +.-06.0)'( ),, '(0 8+=)63 I.- 172%+ ,1;0 H

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    24/360

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    25/360

    "# $%&'( ")**+( ,- .%)/ +01 )2& /2+,'3 /0 -)+ /21& )401/ 5&'',&-( )'* )401/"6789"( )'* )401/ -13)2 )'* -)'*( )'* )401/ :+ 5),'/ 40;( )'* )401/5&'',&-&-?/%)/@- 2,3%/A"# 6%?B .)- C1-/ .0'*&2,'3( /%)/@- )DDA=# 70.( D&/@- -&& ,E B F)' 3&/ ,/ -),* /%,- /,:&A 9&/@- 30 4)FG /0 /%& -)'* )'* /%& -13)2(

    )'* D&/@- -1550-& /%)/ -0:&40*+ -)+- /%)/ %)H,'3 /%& -)'* )/ /%& 40//0: ,- I/,*+J02 I02*&2D+AJ

    "# ")**+( *0&- -0:&40*+ %)H& /0 -)+ -0:&/%,'3 D,G& /%)/ 4&E02& +01 F)' 30 0' /0/)DG )401/ %0. /%,'3- )2& 30,'3 /0 3&/ :,;&* 15 .%&' +01 -/,2 /%&:&-?/%)/@- C1-/ /%& 50,'/A $%&+ -)+ .%)/ /%&+ %05& .,DD %)55&' )'* /%&' B /&DD/%&: ,/ .0'@/ %)55&' 4&F)1-& /%&2& )2& -0 :)'+ 0/%&2 /%,'3- /%)/ :,3%/ %)55&'A8'* B G'0. /%)/ ,/ ,- :02& D,G&D+ /%)/ 0'& 0E /%& :)'+ /%,'3- .,DD %)55&' )'* '0/0'& 0E /%& E&.A

    "# ")**+( +01@2& C1-/ )' 0D* 400G:)G&2( 4)FG,'3 )DD /%& 0/%&2 %02-&- )3),'-/ /%& 0'&%02-& /%)/ B .)'/ /0 4&/ 0'A

    =# $%)/@- 2,3%/( :+ *&)2A B 3&/ /%&: /0 4&/ 0' .%)/ /%&+ F)DD /%& I/,*+J .)+?B G'0./%)/ /%&2& )2& ,'E,',/&D+ :)'+ :1**D&* .)+-?-0 /%,'3- .,DD )D.)+- 30 /0.)2*:1**D& )'* :,;&*'&--A

    "# K1/ .%+ *,*'@/ +01 -)+ /%)/ )/ /%& 4&3,'','3( ")**+< B F01D* %)H& 1'*&2-/00*/%)/ )DD 2,3%/A

    =# >&-( B -1550-& -0A 8'+%0.( ,/@- '0. 4&*/,:&A"# ")**+( .%+ *0 320.'15- %)H& .)2-( ,'-/&)* 0E C1-/ E,3%/,'3 /%& .)+ F%,D*2&' *06% 10+; 61%: A5B.2/ 10+.- 5-76 A0+2 10+; 615-1 *+.2/ 52/-;3A0+2 ;%8 G%7+ .2 ,-%7 ,.60.2/F 52) ' 564 ;%8 J).) ;%8 G51G0 52;10.2/HK52) ;%8 65; J2%10.2/FK ' ).)2(1 42%A 1051 ;%8 A%89)2(1 G51G0 52;10.2/ 1.99 ;%81%9) 7+3

    ' 60599 /% %81 ,.60.2/

    5/5.2 1%7%--%A 52) ' 60599 61.99 42%A 1051 ' 57 829.4+9; 1% G51G0 5 ,.60&"# L81F "5));F ;%8 65.) 599 G%2B+-651.%2 .6 %29; 1+99.2/

    %10+- :+%:9+ 1051 ;%8 5-+ 2%1 52/-; A.10 10+7&

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    28/360

    "##$ %&'()'* +,)- .# $# /#0) .(1- )23(1-") &-4#0/1.-* 5() .%# 6)#67) /18),)- 4&-$ #9. '#/).(&-" %(&3( -)&.()0 #4 .()/ :-)% ;)4#0)*

    < < ?-8(#%@ /#'. 3#-,)0'1.-' 10) #-78 1;#9. %().()0 6)#67) 10) 1-"08 #0

    '#/).(&-"* 5()8 10) ;9'8 .)77&-" )13( #.()0 .(1. .()8 10) 40&)-$78A%(&3( &''#/).&/)' 1 7&)* ?4.)0 177@ %(1. (166)-' %()- .()8 31--#. .(&-: #4 1-8.(&-" .#'18B 5()8 177 4))7 9-3#/4#0.1;7)*

    C> D9. %#97$-E. .(1. ;) &-4#0/1.-@ C1$$8B F /)1-A&-4#0/1.- .(1. .()8 10) -#.30#''B

    => G90)78@ 8)'* D9. &.E' 1 $&44)0)-. '#0. #4 &-4#0/1.- 40#/ H.() 31. &' #- .() /1.*I

    < < C1$$8@ %(8 31--#. 6)#67) J9'. '18 HF 1/ -#. 30#'' 1. 8#9I 1-$ 7). &. "# 1. .(1.B=> ?(@ -#% %) 10) ")..&-" .# .() 0)17 60#;7)/* 5() 6#&-. &' .(1. .() /)''1")' %(&3(

    %) )23(1-") &- ")'.90)' 10) 0)1778 -#. .() '1/) 1' 1-8 .01-'71.- #4 .(#')")'.90)' &-.# %#0$'*

    C> F $#-E. 9-$)0'.1-$*=> F /)1-A.(1. -# 1/#9-. #4 .)77&-" '#/);#$8 &- /)0) %#0$' .(1. #-) &' #0 &' -#.

    1-"08 &' .() '1/) 1' %(1. #-) /&"(. .)77 .()/ ;8 ")'.90) #0 .#-) #4 ,#&3)*C> D9.@ C1$$8@ 8#9 31--#. (1,) %#0$' %&.(#9. '#/) .#-) #4 ,#&3)@ 31- 8#9B +,)- &4

    '#/);#$8 9')' 1' 7&..7) .#-) 1' () 31-@ .() #.()0 6)#67) %&77 ()10 .(1. () &'(#7$&-" (&/')74 ;13:A1-$ .(1. %&77 ;) 1 '#0. #4 .#-)@ %#-E. &.B

    => K)'AF '966#') '#* ?4.)0 177 .(1.E' %(1. F '1&$ J9'. -#% 1;#9. ")'.90)'A.(1. .()=0)-3(/1- 31- '18 '#/).(&-" '6)3&17 ;8 '.#66&-" (&' ")'.90)'*

    < < D9. .()-@ %(1. $# F /)1- ;8 '18&-" .(1. H/)0) %#0$'I 31- -),)0 3#-,)8 .() '1/)

    /)''1") 1' ")'.90)'A&4 .()0) 10) -# H/)0) %#0$'IBC> L)77@ .() %#0$' /&"(. ;) %0&..)-*=> M#A.(1. %#-E. 7). /) #9. #4 .() $&44&397.8* D)319') %0&..)- %#0$' '.&77 (1,) '#/)

    '#0. #4 0(8.(/ 1-$ .()8 '.&77 (1,) #,)0.#-)'* 5() 6#&-. &' .(1. -# /)0) %#0$')2&'.* 5()0) 10) #-78 %#0$' %&.( )&.()0 ")'.90) #0 .#-) #4 ,#&3) #0 '#/).(&-" #4.() '#0.* D9.@ #4 3#90')@ ")'.90)' %&.(#9. %#0$' 10) 3#//#- )-#9"(*

    < < C1$$8@ %()- .()8 .)13( 9' =0)-3( 1. '3(##7@ %(8 $#-E. .()8 .)13( 9' .# %1,) #90

    (1-$'B=> F $#-E. :-#%* FE/ '90) F $#-E. :-#%* 5(1. &' 60#;1;78 #-) #4 .() 0)1'#-' %(8

    6)#67) 4&-$ 7)10-&-" 71-"91")' '# $&44&397.*

    < < ?-8(#%@ &. &' 177 -#-')-')* F /)1-@ .() -#.- .(1. 71-"91") &' /1$) #4 %#0$' &' 177

    -#-')-')A1-$ %()- F '1&$ .(1. ")'.90)' 3#97$ -#. ;) .01-'71.)$ &-.# H/)0)%#0$'@I F %1' .17:&-" -#-')-')@ ;)319') .()0) &' -# '93( .(&-" 1' H/)0) %#0$'*I

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    29/360

    "#$ %&& '() *+#'%, %#$ -.%//%. %#$ %&& '(%' *'011 2* #3#*)#*)4 5'6* %&& 7%*)$ 3#'() 2$)% '(%' 8/).)9 :3.$* ),2*';%#$ '().) %.) #3#)4

    0'?

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    30/360

    !"# %&'()*+,&- ./*,' 0(1&2 (34 5&63+ 7&86*,29

    "#$%&'()* "#++,- #)( '&(.( /012().#'301. .()30$.45#'&()* 6()'#317, '&(, #)(8"* 9&(,:)( 10' # .0)' 0; %#3'& 85* H; H #< >'4"* H 8 J(':. 700I #' >' 3. %00+ #1+ >' 3. @#+ #@0$' E=7#,31%F #1+

    E%##1' '0 /&(#'4

    "* Q(.K=#)'7, ''85* M$' +0 ,0$ >#1' '0 /&(#' #1+ @7$;; #77 '&( '3#1'(+ '0 /&(#'- '' >0$7+ #. 10'

    .()30$. #@0$' '&( '&31%. >( '#7I #@0$'8 H' >0$7+ #. 017, =7#,31% #%#3'& ,0$8

    5* Q(.- ''

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    31/360

    "# $%& '& ()*+,-& ./0* +*,+*1 "/((23 4&-+ /, /56%7 .%((7*38# 9*+:/ .%((7*:;%& +&'77 / +)

    ? ? ?8# @/'& / .',%&*3 AB'+ '+ ('66'C%7& &) +/23 8'

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    32/360

    " " "#$ %&' ()*+ ,-./. 0./. 1(& 2)34 5'.(,*&3(67 8& 4&' -)9. )3&,-./:8$ %.(;)-),?( 0-), 0. (,)/,.+ @/&2A )3+ B +&3?,

    C3&0 -&0 &/ 0-4 ,-), D.+ '( ,& ,)DC )-. +*@@./.3E. -./. )/. /'D.( )

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    33/360

    "# $%& '(% )*+, &-*& +. /0 *1/*') &*120, 1(3+4*11' *5, ,+, 5(& 30& +5&( 6%,,10)7 /04(%1, 50809 )*' *5'&-+53 50/: ;0 4(%1, (51' )*' 90*,'# N-*&7 ,*%3-&097 +) * ,+9&' 49*42: J5, G9(K*K1' *5 %5.*+9 (50: $%& 10& 60 *440G& +& *&

    .*40 8*1%0: @0)7 +& +) D /-( 6*20 &-0 9%10)O*.&09 *117 D ,( 5(& /*5& %) &( 3( 6*,:

    "# J11 9+3-&: $%&7 "*,,'7 ,( '(% *1)( 4-*530 &-0 9%10)= U(60&+60)=># I667 *5(&-09 ,+9&' 49*42: @0)7 ,*%3-&097 D 4-*530 &-06 4(5)&*5&1': P(& *11 (.

    &-067 K%& )(60 (. &-06:"# D /+)- '(%E, &011 60 /-05 '(%E90 3(+53 &( 4-*530 &-06M

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    34/360

    "# $%%&'()&*+*,-. / 0,)1 / 23456. 748 ,8 ,)-98 5,:( 81*8. /; ,8 0(

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    35/360

    !"# %&'()*+,&- .*/ %,01 2* 3*, 45*/67

    "#$%&'()* "#++,- &./ 0$1& +. ,.$ 23./45#'&()* 6(4 70089 :( #;.$' # (+%(?"* ".3@' ;( AB>>,? 9A B' # >, &./ 0$1&

    +. ,.$ 23./45* C(>>- 0, ;)#B3 /(B%&A #;.$' '/. A( ;(=.)(#3,;.+, 1.$>+ 0#2( # A'(#0 (3%B3(? 9 0(#3 A.0('&B3% >B2(89 +.3@' 23./8;$''&()( /#A A.0(;.+, (>A( /&. + '. +BA1.:() .B> ;(=.)( #3,;.+, 1.$>+ 0#2( #3(3%B3(?

    5* K(A8'' 0#2(A # +B==()(31(? 9 0(#3- B' 0(#3A '' 23./>(+%( BA #>> A.)' .= 23B''(+'.%('&()- .) /.:(3- >B2( 1>.'&- #3+ (#1& (+%( BA .3>, 0(#3B3%=$> .)$A(=$> ;(1#$A( .= '&( .'&() > '&BA 0.)3B3%? E$

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    36/360

    "# $%& '() * +,-. &//0 *1 &2( &23-4) &/ 5( 6%7&3873(9 ,:( 83(+() /1 ;-/# $%&. >,99'. * 9/-?& )((A

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    37/360

    "# $% &'() $*+',) -.+ / 01, 2+ 3.4+' 5,16 6%7+ +%' 7,(6'8( 9'7,+) :%'& 01 4+ 64+%';794,7+41,( 7,0 +'(+( 7,0 3.44@ 7 A4'B'1* A7A'8 4( >& +%8164,@ (+1,'( 7+ 4+)

    C# D16 01 &1. 9'7,E"# / 9'7,F4* &1. +%816 (+1,'( 7+ +61 A4'B'( 1* A7A'8 *819 +%' (79' 04(+7,B' 7,0

    &1. *4,0 +%7+ &1. %4+ 1,' A4'B' 918' 1*+', +%7, +%' 1+%'8= +%', A81>7>?& +%' 1,'+%7+ &1. %4+ 91(+ 64?? >' >4@@'8 +%7, +%' 1+%'8) /, +%' (79' 67&= 4, 7,';794,7+41, &1. +%816 7 ?1+ 1* 3.'(+41,( 7+ +%' (+.0',+(= 7,0 4* &1. *4,0 +%7+ &1.%4+ 918' A4'B'( 1* 5,16?'0@' 4, 1,' (+.0',+ +%7, 4, +%' 1+%'8(= +%', &1. +%4,5+%7+ (+.0',+ 9.(+ 5,16 918') :%7+2( +%' 40'7)

    C# -.+ B1.?0 1,' 9'7(.8' 7 A4'B' 1* A7A'8 +%7+ 67&E"# G.8'?& 1,' B1.?0) /+ 94@%+ 'H', >' 3.4+' 7 @110 67& 1* 014,@ 4+) I' 01 9'7(.8' 7

    ?1+ 1* +%4,@( +%7+ 67&) "18 ';79A?'= 6' J.0@' %16 (+81,@ 7 B.A 1* B1**'' 4( >&?1154,@ +1 ('' %16 >?7B5 4+ 4(F+%7+ 4(= 6' ?115 +1 ('' %16 9.B% ?4@%+ 4( (+1AA'0)

    I' +%816 ?4@%+ 67H'( 7+ 4+ 4,(+'70 1* (+1,'(= 4+2( +%' (79' 40'7)C# $%)

    K K KC# -.+ +%',F6%& (%1.?0,2+ 6' 9'7(.8' 5,16?'0@' +%7+ 67&E"# D16E -& 3.4?' 4( +%7+ +%7+ (18+ 1* 9'7(.84,@

    ?'7H'( 1.+ &1.8 A14,+F+%7+ +%'8' 78' 04**'8',+ (18+( 1* 5,16?'0@'F7,0 +%7++%'8'2( 5,164,@ 7>1.+ 5,16?'0@') N,0 1.@%+ 1,' +1 @4H' %4@%'8 9785( +1 +%'(+.0',+ 6%1 B7, 7,(6'8 +%' 640'(+ 3.'(+41,E $8 A'8%7A( +%'8' (%1.?0 >' 704**'8',+ (18+ 1* 9785( *18 '7B% 04**'8',+ (18+ 1* 3.'(+41,)

    C# I'??= 7?? 84@%+) O'+2( 01 +%7+ 7,0 +%', 700 +%' 9785( +1@'+%'8 7,0 +%',P"# L1F6' B1.?0,2+ 700 +%'9 +1@'+%'8) I' 94@%+ 9.?+4A?& 18 04H40' 1,' (18+ 1*

    9785( >& 7,1+%'8 (18+ >.+ 6' B1.?0,2+ 700 +%'9)C# I%& ,1+= C700&E"# -'B7.('F>'B7.(' 6' B1.?0,2+) L1 61,0'8 &1. 01,2+ ?45' 784+%9'+4B 4* +%'& 01,2+

    +'?? &1. +%7+ (18+ 1* +%4,@ 7+ (B%11?FI%7+ 01 +%'& +'?? &1.E M1??&F/ 61,0'86%7+ +%' +'7B%'8( +%4,5 784+%9'+4B 4( 7>1.+)

    C# I%7+ 4( 4+ 7>1.+= C700&E"# L1) O'+2( (+4B5 +1 +%' 3.'(+41, 1* %16 +1 9'7(.8' 5,16?'0@'FN84+%9'+4B 4( 7 ('+

    1* +84B5( *18 +%4,54,@ B?'78?& 7,0 +%' 1,?& *., 4, 4+ 4( J.(+ 4+( B?784+&) N,0 +%' *48(++%4,@ 7>1.+ >'4,@ B?'78 4( ,1+ +1 94; .A 40'7( 6%4B% 78' 8'7??& 04**'8',+ *819 '7B%1+%'8) :%' 40'7 1* +61 187,@'( 4( 8'7??& 04**'8',+ *819 +%' 40'7 1* +61 94?'()-'B7.(' 4* &1. 700 +%'9 +1@'+%'8 &1. 1,?& @'+ *1@ 4, &1.8 %'70)

    C# -.+= C700&= / B7,2+ 5''A 40'7( ('A787+') $.@%+ / +1 01 +%7+E"# L1F L1F $* B1.8(' ,1+) Q19>4,' +%'9) -.+ 01,2+ 700 +%'9) :%7+2( 7??) / 9'7,F

    4* +%' 40'7( 78' ,.9>'8( 7,0 &1. 67,+ +1 B19>4,' +61 04**'8',+ (18+(= +%' +%4,@+1 01 4( +1 9.?+4A?& +%'9 >& '7B% 1+%'8) $8 04H40' +%'9 >& '7B% 1+%'8) N,0 +%',&1.2?? @'+ (19' ,'6 (18+ 1* 40'7= 7 ,'6 (18+ 1* 3.7,+4+&) /* &1. %7H' 94?'( 4, &1.8%'70= 7,0 &1. %7H' %1.8( 4, &1.8 %'70= 7,0 &1. 04H40' +%' 94?'( >& +%' %1.8(=

    &1. @'+ R94?'( A'8 %1.8SF+%7+2( 7 (A''0)C# T'(= C700&) I%7+ 61.?0 / @'+ 4* / 9.?+4A?4'0 +%'9E"# $%F'8F/ (.AA1(' &1.20 @'+ 94?'U%1.8() T'() / 5,16 6%7+ +%'& 78') / 9'7,=

    6%7+ 7 94?'U%1.8 4() /+2( 6%7+ &1. A7& 7 +7;4 084H'8) D4( 9'+'8 9'7(.8'( 94?'(7,0 %' %7( 7 B?1B5 6%4B% 9'7(.8'( %1.8(= 7,0 +%' 9'+'8 7,0 +%' B?1B5 6185

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    38/360

    "#$%"&%' ()* +,-"./-0 "&% ,'1 20 "&% +.-%1 ()* "&%) ." +,-"./-.%1 "&% +.-%3,'1 20 1#+%"&.)$ %-1% 4&.5& +(6%1 +.-%3,'1 .)"# *#--('17

    89 : *.* () %;/%'.+%)" #)5%789 : 4()"%* "# ?.)* #," .? : 5#,-* "&.)6 "4# ",$&"1 (" "&% 1(+% ".+%7 @# : ",$&"

    A:"B1 1,++%'C ()* : ",$&" A:"B1 4.)"%'7C D)* "&%) : "'.%* "# "&.)6 "&% "4#",$&"1 "#$%"&%'7

    89 E," : ?#,)* : 4(1)B" &(F.)$ "4# ",$&"17 : 4(1 #)-0 &(F.)$ #)% ",$&" (2#,"

    &(F.)$ "4# ",$&"17

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    39/360

    !"# %&'()*+,&- ./0 1* 2/34+5 6(7& 8,')34&59:

    "#$%&'()* "#++,- .&, +/ '&01%2 ( /$'401(256#'&()* "/ '&(,5 7 +/18' 91/.: ;' 2/)' /< '&01%2 +/ ,/$ =(#15"* 7 =(#1 .&(1 7 +)#. '&01%2- .&, +/ '&(, ( /$'401(25 6* ;(44- .' #>/$' /'&()

    2/)'2 /< '&01%2?# ( 2044,: 7 @#18' +)#. # @/13()2#'0/1: 7 =(#1 '&01%2:6* B(2?7 .#2 '),01% '/ /$'- "#++,56* I$' .' .#2 &( =#+ #>/$'5 K&- 7 2((?,/$ =(#1 D#1%),:E ;( ( '/ 9((A

    '&/2( './ =(#101%2 /< D=#+E @4(#) 0< .( #)( %/01% '/ '#49 #>/$' I4#9(: I(@#$2( #4/' /< A(/A4( '&/$%&' &( .#2 =#+?)(#44, =#+?@)#L,: J1+ '' .#2 /1( /< '&('&01%2 &( .#2 =#+F#1%), #>/$': J1+ '&(1 &( .#2 =#+F#1%),- '//- #>/$' 2/=(#)'02'2 .&/ A#01'(+ A0@'$)(2 #2 '&/$%& '&01%2 +0+18' ( /$'F401(2: M( @#44(+'&(= D'&( 24/>>()01% 2@&//4:E

    "* M( .#218' 3(), '/4()#1'- .#2 &(- "#++,56* G/4()#1'5 K&- N/+: B(2- 7 91/.?''82 .' '&(, +)$= 01'/ ,/$ #' 2@&//4: O/-

    I4#9( .#2 1/' 3(), '/4()#1': M( +0+18' (3(1 '&019 '/4()#1@( .#2 # %//+ '&01%: 7'.#2 C$2' =/)( 24/>>()01%: M( '&/$%&' 0' >4$))(+ #44 '&( /$'401(2 #1+ =$++4(+(3(),'&01%?'' 0' =#+( #44 @#'2 %)#,: P/ '' 1/>/+, ./$4+ >( #>4( '/ 2((#1,'&01% @4(#)4, #1+ 2)A4,:

    "* B(2- "#++,:6* O/- ''82 1/' '&( #12.(): 7 =(#1 DB(2- "#++,E02 1/' '&( #12.(): J44 '' 2#,2 02

    '' ,/$ +/18' 91/. .' ,/$) /A010/1 02?#1+ ,/$ +/18' %03( # +#=1 .' 72#, /) .' I4#9( 2#,2 #1+ '' '&( 2@&//4 2/ >(/$''/4()#1@( '' ,/$ @#1F1/' '(44 '&( +0

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    40/360

    "# $%&'(# ) *+,-. /,+01 ) *+,-. &%%2 345% .+ .67,/ 8%9: 0%551 ).-& 355 7, 3 2;**5%1"# )-2 &+99:1 ) &; &.%321

    ? ? ?(# (3**:' "# $%&'(# @6: 7& .63. &+2%.67,= .+ =%. 3,=9: 34+;.'"# )& 063. &+2%.67,= .+ =%. 3,=9: 34+;.'(# ) 2%3,A34+;. 06%.6%9 .67,=& 638% +;.57,%&1 $+; &37* @755732 B53/% =+. 3,=9:

    34+;. 7.1 C,* .6%, :+; =%. 3,=9: 34+;. 7.1 @6: 7& .63.D (3**:'"# $%&D 7, 3 03: ) .67,/ 7. 7&1 ) .67,/ 7. 23..%9&1 E%963 =%..7,= .6% 67&.+9: 09+,= 3,* &3:7,= .6% H%0& *7* 7.D 3,* .6%, .6%9%-&.6% 2;**5% +> &3:7,= .63. .6% *%&F%,*3,.& &6+;5* 4% 9%&+9 063. .6%793,F%&.+9& *7*,-. *+1 ).-& 355 &5+8%,5:1

    (# $%&D (3**:1"# C55 97=6.D )-55 .9: ,+. .+ =%. 3,=9: 3=37,1 C55 )-2 .9:7,= .+ &3: 7& .63. 2;**5% 7&

    &+2%.67,= .+ =%. 3,=9: 34+;.1 (# (3**:'"# $%&'(# @% 0%9% .35/7,= 34+;. 2;**5% .6% +.6%9 *3:1 C9% 0% 9%355: .35/7,= 34+;. .6%

    &32% .67,= ,+0'"# $%&1 L> F+;9&% 0% 39%1 M63.-& 06: 7.-& 72>7F;5.1 M6% +,5: +,% F+;5* &%% 7. F5%395:1

    ? ? ?"# P%.-& .67,/ 34+;. 3 9%35 F+,F9%.% +;.J3,*J+;. 2;**5%D >+9 3 F63,=%D 3,* &%% 7> .63.

    0755 6%5 F9+Q;%. 7, C57F% 7, @+,*%953,*'(# $%&A07.6 >5327,=+&'"# M63.-& 97=6.1

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    41/360

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

    "# $%;7(< >7- 0122 F,87> 9 K( >71> ,>=. 122 .( F+&&2-& >71> %(0(&; *1% >-22 1> 122 =. 8(,%8 >(71''-%9

    "# $%& >7- 7(('. ((6 0-*1+.- >7-; =. ),87>L-?-);>7,%8 *(+2& F(?- 1%& %(0(&; *(+2& >-22 7(< ,> 7,%8 71?- >( 0- 12,?- .( 1. >( F1D- 1 *(F'2->- F+&&2-34# 5(L7- *(+2& 71?- F1&- ,> 1 F+&&2- 0;M %(6 C .+''(.- ;(+=)- ),87>9 :71>=.

    ,%>-)-.>,%89 E-.6 ,> 71& >( 0- >71> 1 F,%+>-9 C>=. *+),(+. 0+> ;(+=)- ),87>9G-*1+.- ,/ 7-=& F+&&2-& >7,%8. 1%; (>7-) 7- '21;-). *(+2& 71?- 2-1)%-&7(< >( &-12 7 >7- F+&&2,%8 &->1,2.9 C F-1%6 .+''(.- >7- *)(H+-> 217- 7-1&. (/ >7- F122->. J+.> -1& (/ 0-,%8 12,?-6 >7-% >7- '-('2- *(+2& .>,22 2-1)% 1%& >7- 81F- L,> 0- ,F'(..,02-9 G+> (%*- ;(+ 0),%8 2,?- >7,%8. ,%>(,>6 ,> 0-*(F-. ,F'(..,02-9 C 71?- -N'-*>-& >71>9

    "# B(+2&%=> ;(+6 "1&&;3 C .--F. %1>+)12 >( F-94# 51>+)123 K+)-L%1>+)12 -%(+879 G+> C 71?- -N'-*>-& ,> >( 71>

    7-; F1D- >7- 21 0-*1+.- '-('2- 1)- %(> ')-&,*>102-6 1%& >7- '-('2-7- 217-) '-('2- ;->9 :7-)- ,. .(F-P>7,%8 /+%%; 10(+> >71> '(,%>9

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    42/360

    "# $%&'()# * +,-.' /01'2 3-,45-,' 62'7 8,92'%1-: &;,0' '%&' &@2 -,' &B >',-2>B >, ,-7 C,@>2>+,-.' ?1' 1- & 4,@2 &-+ 9&32 '%29>2 ?1'7 H2>B '%26 %&=2 ', 9&32 '%29>2E@2+1A'&;2 ,'%2@41>2 '%2 9&A%1-2> :2' &-:@6 &-+ 311 A,-=2@>&'1,-

    %&+ &- ,0'0@27 J0' 42 A&--,' >22 1' 62' ;2A&0>2 '%2 A,-=2@>&'1,- 1>-.' ?1-1>%2+7

    H,0 A&--,' 2=2@ >22 1' 4%12 1? 6,0 A,022 1'B6,0 4,0

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    43/360

    !"# %&'()*+,&- ./0 ( 12(345

    "#$%&'()* +&, # -.#/01#'&()* 2(-3#/4 .&, # 5$55(' 6/ 7(')8$-&9#0"* :83'';- 46

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    44/360

    "# $%&'()* + )%,* %- + )%,*. /0 *12 %*12, 1+034 5- 6%( )+6 %- + 7+0 *1+* 12 5) + *,(28+7294 *12 50)(9* 8+,,52) + -9+:%, %- ;,(3;50; +375,+*5%0.

    120 + ",20817+0 8+99) + 7+0 + )%,* %- 8+7294 5) 12 ()50; *12 ?1,+)2 )%,* %- 50+06*150; 95@2 *12 )+72 >+6 +) A4 >120 A )+6 *12 )>+0 5) )%,* %- 1(7+0B

    C C C"# A*D) 95@2&*12,2D) + ?+))+;2 50 E+8F2*1. E+8F2*1 5) *+9@50; *% *12 7(,32,2,)

    >1%7 12 5) )20350; %(* *% @599 =+0G(%. H126 89+57 *% F2 7204 +03 12 *299) *127*126 +,2 )%,* %- 720.

    I6&50 *12 8+*+9%;(2 62 ;% -%, 720.+) 1%(03) +03 ;,261%(03)4 7%0;,29)4 )?+0529)4 8(,)4)1%(;1)4 >+*2,J,(;) +03 3275J>%9:2) +,2 892?*+99 F6 *12 0+72 %- 3%;).KE+8F2*14 I8* AAA4 L8202 MN

    1+* 6%( )+53 '()* 0%>. O1+* >+) 5*B PI0%*12, )(F35:5)5%0 %- + 9+,;2,;,%(?BQA 3%0D* *150@ *1+*D) 5* +* +99.

    "# $%4 5*D) 0%* %096 *1+*. E+8F2*14 +-*2, +994 ()2) 3%;) 50 15) )57592. I03 P3%;)Q 72+0)25*12, 0%F92 1%(03) %, )8+:20;2,). A* >%(93 0%* F2 *12 )+72 5- 12 1+3 ()23 *123%72)*58 :+,52*52) %- 8+*)&%, *12 )(F)?2852) %- >593 ,%)2).

    1+* 5) *12 +0)>2, *% 76 G(2)*5%0B O120 + ",20817+08+99) + 7+0 + P)%,* %-Q 8+7294 +03 A )+6 *1+* *12 )>+0 5) P)%,* %-Q 1(7+04 3% >2F%*1 72+0 *12 )+72 *150; F6 P)%,* %-QB

    C C C"# I99 ,5;1*4 92*D) *,6 *% +0+96R2 >1+* P)%,* %-Q 72+0). S2*D) *+@2 + )50;92 )20*2082 +03

    2T+7502 5*. A- A )+6 P*12 ?(??2* U2*,%()1@+ 5) )%,* %- 1(7+04Q A )*+*2 + ,29+*5%0J

    )15?.220 >1+* +03 >1+*B"# =2*>220 532+)4 A *[email protected] + ?(??2* +03 ?2%?92B"# $%. =2*>220 )%72 532+) *1+* A 1+:2 +F%(* + ?(??2* +03 )%72 532+) *1+* A 1+:2

    +F%(* ?2%?92.1581 5) 27?1+*58+996 0%* P)%,* %-.Q E+06

    720 1+:2 ;%02 *% *12 )*+@2 -%, *12 ?,%?%)5*5%0 *1+* *12 F,2+3 +03 >502 +,2 0%*

    P)%,* %-Q *12 F%36 +03 F9%%3.+0 F+992* + )+8,+720*B"# V2)&A *150@ )%&+* 92+)* -%, )%72 ?2%?92. A0 U,%*2)*+0* 9+0;(+;2 >2 75;1* )+6

    *1+* *12 )>+095@2 8%)*(72 +03 7%:2720*) %- *12 3+082, +,2 P%(*>+,3 +03

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    45/360

    "#$#%&' $#()$ *+ $*,' #)-./0 .)0 $1#/#23.& (/.4'5 *+ -*,.)6 732 #) 8.29*&.)(3.(' 29.2 -*3&0 ,.:' 29' %.&&'2 #)2* . ,'/' ,'2.19*/ .)0 )*2 . $.4/.,')26

    ;< 732 =*3 $.#0 29.2 +*/ $*,' 1'*1&' #2 #$ . $.4/.,')26 >*3 ,'.) +*/ ?/*2'$2.)2$@A< B*C )*6 D ,'.) 29.2 #+ +*/ $*,' 1'*1&' 29' %/'.0 .)0 -#)' ./' *)&= . ,'2.19*/C

    -9#&' +*/ *29'/$E8.29*$ E29' %/'.0 .)0 -#)' ./' . $.4/.,')2F 29')C #+ 29'/'%' $*,' +*/ -9*, 29' %.&&'2 #$ . ,'2.19*/C 29'/' ,.= %' *29'/$ +*/ -9*, #2 #$',19.2#4.&&= ,*/' 29.) . ,'2.19*/E%32 /.29'/ . $.4/.,')26

    ;< D) 29' 8.29* $')$'@A< >'$6

    G G GA< D ,'.) 29.2 #+ -' 4*3&0 $.= 4&'./&= -9.2 #$ ,'.)2 %= 29' 1/*1*$#2#*) H29' %/'.0

    .)0 -#)' #$ )*2 I$*/2 *+J 29' %*0= .)0 %&**05F 29') -' $9*3&0 :)*- ,*/' .%*32-9.2 -' ,'.) -9') -' $.= '#29'/ 29.2 29' $-.) #$ H$*/2 *+5 93,.) */ 29.2 29'%.&&'2 #$ . $.4/.,')26

    ;< K'&&E9*- 0* =*3 2'&& 29' 0#++'/')4'@A< K9#49 0#++'/')4'@;< 7'2-'') . $.4/.,')2 .)0 . ,'2.19*/6

    G G GA< K.#2 . ,#)32'6 K' ./'C .+2'/ .&&C 2.&:#)( .%*32 29' 1'/L+*/,'/ */ 29' ./2#$2 */ 29'

    1*'2C */ . (#"') ,',%'/ *+ 29' .30#')4'6 >*3 .$: ,' 9*- D 2'&& 29' 0#++'/')4'%'2-'') . $.4/.,')2 .)0 . ,'2.19*/6 732 ,= .)$-'/ ,3$2 0'.& -#29 29' 1'/$*).)0 )*2 29' ,'$$.('6 >*3 .$: ,' 9*- D -*3&0 0'4#0' -9'29'/ . 4'/2.#) 0.)4' *). 4'/2.#) 0.= #$ */ #$ )*2 $.4/.,')2.& +*/ 29' 1./2#43&./ 0.)4'/6

    ;< M&& /#(92E%32 ('2 *) -#29 #26A< K'&&ED 29#): #2J$ . $*/2 *+ . $'4/'26;< >*3 ,'.) =*3 -*)J2 2'&& ,'@

    A< B*E#2J$ )*2 29.2 $*/2 *+ $'4/'26 D2J$ )*2 $*,'29#)( 29.2 *)' ,3$2 )*2 2'&&6 D2J$$*,'29#)( 29.2 *)' 4.))*2 2'&&6

    ;< K9.2 0* =*3 ,'.)@ K9= )*2@A< N'2 3$ $311*$' D .$:'0 29' 0.)4'/C HO#$$ PC 2'&& ,'C 29.2 0.)4' -9#49 =*3

    1'/+*/,E#$ #2 +*/ =*3 . $.4/.,')2 */ . ,'/' ,'2.19*/@5 M)0 &'2 3$ #,.(#)' 29.2D 4.) ,.:' 29#$ Q3'$2#*) #)2'&(#%&'6 R9' -#&& 1'/9.1$ 132 ,' *++ %= $.=#)(C H>*3$.- #2E#2 #$ +*/ =*3 2* 0'4#0'C #+ =*3 -.)2 2*C -9'29'/ */ )*2 #2 #$ $.4/.,')2.& +*/=*365 S/ $9' ,#(92 $.=C HR*,'2#,'$ #2 #$ .)0 $*,'2#,'$ #2 #$) J265S/ HT*- -.$ DC&.$2 )#(92@5732 #) .)= 4.$' $9' 4.) 9."' )* 0#/'42 4*)2/*& *"'/ 29' ,.22'/6

    G G G;< ;* =*3 ,'.) 29.2 .)=%*0= -9* :)'- 29#$ $'4/'2 -*3&0 9."' #2 #) 29'#/ 1*-'/ 2*

    %' . (/'.2 0.)4'/ */ . (/'.2 1*'2@A< B*C )*C )*6 D2 #$)J2 :' 29.2 .2 .&&6 D ,'.) +#/$2 29.2 (/'.2 ./2 .)0 /'(#*) .)0 .&& 29'

    /'$2 *+ #2 #$ .%*32 29#$ $'4/'2F %32 :)*-#)( 29' $'4/'2 #) .) */0#)./= 4*)$4#*3$ -.=

    -*3&0 )*2 (#"' 29' :)*-'/ 4*)2/*&6

    G G G

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    46/360

    "# "$%%&' ()$* )$+ )$,,-.-%/ 0- (-1- *1&2.3 *4 52.% 46* ()$* 7+41* 458 9-$.+()-. (- +$& *)$* *)- +($. 2+ 7+41* 458 )69$.: ; +$2% *)$* *)-1- 96+* +41* 45? +($.' $.%$.4*)-1 2. *)- ,)1$+- 7*)- +($. 52361- 2+ >+41* 45? )69$.:8 @.% .4( &46 $1-*$AB2.3 $

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    47/360

    !"# %&'()*+,&- ./(' 01 (2 021'324'56

    "#$%&'()* "#++,- .' /0 #1 /10'/12'34#'&()* 51 /10'/12'- 6, +(#)- /0 # (789#1#':), 8)/12/89(; "* ' &( +/02:A() %)#A/',3 F/'& '&( #889(3 4* B:- +(#); K( /1A(1'(+ /';"* J&H; "#++,- .&: /1A(1'(+ /10'/12'3

    4* @ +:1>' N1:.; M):?#?9, ?/?9/2#9;"* 0 )/%&';"* L&(1 B(.':1 +/+ E/1%: #1 &,8:'&(0/0 #E'() #99;4* I(0=/1+((+ &( +/+; K( .#0 # A(), %)(#' 02/(1'/0'; " * J&;

    "* "#++,- /0 #1 (789#1#':), 8)/12/89( '&( 0#6( '&/1% #0 #1 &,8:'&(0/03

    *L&/0 6('#9:%$( /0 )(8)/1'(+ ?, 8()6/00/:1 :E P:$':1 U V:; E):6 588):#2&(0 ': 51/6#9V:66$1/2#'/:1- (+/'(+ ?, L&:6#0 5; S(?(:N- OWXW

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    48/360

    "# $%&'()* +,- ./- 0,1-%2 3/, 4%%* &. 5)6/-5%414 -'1%4 -/ %76(&1. 4/8% 6&'-19,(&'4/8%-51.: +,- &. %76(&.&-/') 6'1.916(%;(1%.-1/.&( &:'%%8%.- +%-C%%. 491%.-14-4 -/ 4-/6-')1.: -/ %76(&1. -51.:4 &- & 9%'-&1. 6/1.-2

    D# E5%. 14 -5&- C5&- $%C-/. 8%&.-F @B =:'&>1-)? %76(&1.4 ./-51.: +,- 14 /.() & 4/'-/B B,(( 4-/6 &- -5% %.G /B & (1.% /B %76(&.&-1/.* -5%. 1.>%.-1.: :'&>1-) C&4 ./- -5%4&8% &4 1.>%.-1.: &. 5)6/-5%414* &.G 5% 9/,(G 4&) 5% G1G ./- B1.:/ &.)5)6/-5%4%42

    "# E5&-A4 '1:5-2 E5%'%A4 ./ %76(&.&-1/. /B &. %76(&.&-/') 6'1.916(%2 @-A4 (11-) 14 4,66/4%G -/ G/2 @-A4 ./- &. %76(&.&-1/. /B 5/C 1-

    G/%4 1-2D# H52

    D# D&GG)* C5&- 14 &. 1.4-1.9-F"# @-A4 & (&+%( B/' C5&- & 9%'-&1. +(&9< +/7 14 4,66/4%G -/ G/2D# J,- C5&-A4 1- 4,66/4%G -/ G/F"# N82 E5&- 14 & >%') G1BB19,(- 0,%4-1/.MD# O/ /.2"# K%((2 @-A4 4,66/4%G -/ 9/.-'/(;6&'-() 9/.-'/(;C5&- &. /':&.148 G/%42D# D/ 6(&.-4 5&>% 1.4-1.9-4F"# $/2 @B & +/-&.14- ,4%G -5% C/'G =1.4-1.9-*? C5%. -&(

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    49/360

    "# $ %&'() *'&+, -.) /0 )12 %&3 %&24 *'&+ /) 154 5 42607 5'% /) +/33624 /' &8%28 )&982428:2 )15) 42607 )12' /)4 +/336/'3 /4 85)/&'567 '&) /'4)/';)/:2,

    12' 5 ?4260@982428:5)/:2 /'4)/';)A /4 5 ;&')85%/;)/&', "# B2667 /)(4 5 4&8) &01560+5C 1&.42 &' )12 8&5% )& 5')18&9&D&891/4D,

    15)(4 E5%,"# -.) )12 %&3 D/31) *'&+ /) 15% 5 4260 5'% '&) *'&+ )15) )15) 4260 41&.6% E2

    982428:2%, $) +&.6% )12' E2 85)/&'56 )& '&) +/3362, F& /0 )12 %&3 4)/66 +/336247 )1/4+&.6% E2 /'4)/';)/:2, -.) /0 /) 6258'2% )& +/33627 )12' /) +&.6% '&) E2 /'4)/';)/:2,

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    50/360

    "# "$%%&' () *+, $-$*./& .0 *+, 1,-,) $-% 2+3./.)./,) $4.5* *+, $-$*./& .0 *+,6+.7, $-(/$78 9-% *+, :+&)(.7.1& .0 *+, 1,-,) $-% 2+3./.)./,) $4.5* *+,:+&)(.7.1& .0 *+, 6+.7, $-(/$78

    ;# +$* 0.77.6)="# ". &.5 *+(-B *+,(3 %,C,7.:/,-* 2.57% 4, $4.5* *+, %,C,7.:/,-* .0 *+, 6+.7,

    .31$-()/8;# @ %.-A* ,C,- B-.6 6+$* *+$* J5,)*(.- 6.57% /,$-="# @ %.= @* /,$-) *+$* *+, 2+3./.)./,) $-% 1,-,) 6.57% 4, 2+$-1(-1 .3 %,C,7.:(-1

    )./,+.6 6+(7, *+, 4$4& () %,C,7.:(-1' $-% *+, 2+$-1,) (- *+, 2+3./.)./,)6.57% 4, $4.5* *+, 2+$-1,) (- *+, 4$4&= F.-*3.77(-1 *+,/ .3 :$3*7& 2.-*3.77(-1*+,/=

    ;# +,& %. ).5-% 3$*+,3 7(B, 47$2B 4.?,)=;# E,)' 45* (0 2+3./.)./,) .3 1,-,) 2$- 7,$3-' *+,- *+,& $3, /52+ /.3, 2./:7(2$*,%

    47$2B 4.?,) *+$- $-&4.%& $* :3,),-* 4,7(,C,)= K2(,-*()*) $3, $76$&) $))5/(-1 .3+.:(-1 *+$* *+(-1) $3, )(/:7,' $-% *+,- %()2.C,3(-1 *+$* *+,& $3, -.*=

    "# E,)' "$%%&=

    "# "$%%&' () *+$* $- (-)*(-2*8;# @) 6+$* $- (-)*(-2*8"# 9))5/(-1 *+$* *+(-1) $3, )(/:7,=;#

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    51/360

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    52/360

    "# $%&' ()*+,& * -../ 01%&+2.34 *3/ &52%3+2&+& )*6% +*78%/ * -9%*+ /%*7 *:.1+ 2+4 ;*823-72&+& .< &%=*9*+% 23&+235+& *3/ +)%3 71;=23- +)%; +.-%+)%9 *-*23'

    ># ?1+ @)*+,& +)% *3&@%9A"# B%77' C+,& 3.+ 012+% 57%*9' ?1+ .3% +)23- 2& 5%9+*23# ()*+ %D=7*3*+.9E =92352=7%&

    ;1&+ :% 3.+ ;17+2=72%/ :%E.3/ 3%5%&&2+E'># F3/ +)*+ ;%*3&A G7%*&%A"# C+,& +)% 2/%* :%)23/ ;.3.+)%2&;H+)*+ +)% 2/%* .< .3% :2- I./ 2& +. :% =9%# C< 2+ @%9% :2- %3.1-)'"# L.' C+ ;%*3&K># F9% +)%9% :2- 23&+235+& *3/ 72++7% 23&+235+&A

    "# B%77H*& * ;*++%9 .< # C &%%H728% )*623- .3% :2- I./ +. %D=7*23 +)% 1326%9&% *3/ 7.+& .< 72++7% N2;=&M .9N-.:723&M +. %D=7*23 +)% &;*77 +)23-& +)*+ )*==%3'

    "# B%774 E%&' O*+)%9 728% +)*+'># ?1+4 >*//E4 ).@ /. +)%E 71;= +)23-& +.-%+)%9 +. ;*8% +)% :2- 23&+235+&A"# B%774 2/3,+ E.1 &*E&.;%+)23- 728% +)*+A

    "# $%&4 C /2/ &*E &.;%+)23- 728% +)*+'

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    53/360

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    54/360

    "# $%&'( )( (*+, (-.( /,0/1, -.2, . %/,3).1 4)55)3+1(6 .70+( 7,)&8 079,3()2, .70+( (-,:0*, .&):.1 /.*(% 05 (-,)* &.(+*,;

    &6-0? &4 )( )% ,.%6 50* /,0/1, (0 7, )&(,11,3(+.116 079,3()2, )& 1.&8+.8, .&4 .70+((001%;

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    55/360

    "# $% %&'(# )*++' ,- .+/0*. *1*23-4/&5 -% 6/-.'"# , 7%&8- 9&7*2.-:&7'(# )*++; -4* *0-/1* -4/&5 :&7 -4* 2*.-' ?&7 -4*& /&./7* -4*

    02*:-92* -4:-8. @:7* /& -4* @%7*+ %< /&-*++*0-; +:&59:5*; :&7 -%%+.; /- /. &:-92:+-4:- A92A%.* =/++ *1%+1*' B%%+. :2* *0-/1* .-9

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    56/360

    "# $ %&'() *'&+ +,-.- )& /-01'23# 4-552 3& %.-678 0& /9 &::&81)-8;"# ?,- &5% @&5* 1%-62 A&2 ?,-9 %&'() :.-%1B) ),- @C)C.-2 3.-678 6.- 8&.) &@

    8C8:-'%-% 1' )17-2 ?,-9 %&'() ,6D- 6'9 )-'8-823# EC) 1@ 6 :-.8&' 18 [email protected]% &@ 8&7-),1'0 +,1B, ,- *'&+8 +155 ,6::-' )&7&..&+F ,-

    710,) %.-67 6/&C) 1) )&G'10,);"# H-.)61'592

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    57/360

    "# $%& '() *+* ', -.() &'/&0 1', *2,/3 4(%5* '/6, 7,,. &,55+.8 '+3 &'/& &',92(:,;;(2; )(%5* ;'((& '+3 *().< =() *+* ', -.() +& )/; +2(.+40

    ># =33< 1', /.;),2 +; ', *+*.?& -.()< 1', *2,/3 *(,;. ?& '/6, / 5/7,5 (. +& &( ;/@ +&+; +2(.+4< A.* )',. 9,(95, /2, 7,+.8 +2(.+4 +. )/-+.8 4(.6,2;/&+(.B &',@ (:&,.*(.?& &,55 @(% &',@ /2, 7,+.8 +2(.+4# J,55B @,;< A; / 3/&&,2 (: :/4&B &',@ *(< $%& D?3 .(& ;%2, +&?; &', ;/3, &'+.8K"# L( (.< =() *( &',@0 A.* )',.0

    ># J,55< E(% -.() '() / 9%99@ 5+,; (. '+; 7/4- /.* 92,;,.&; '+; 7,55@ &( / 7+88,2*(8< 1'/&?; ;(2& (: +.6+&+.8 &', 7+88,2 *(8 &( /&&/4-< $%& +& )(2-; +. &', (99(;+&,)/@< D& ;&(9; &', 7+88,2 *(8 :2(3 /&&/4-+.8# M'B :(2 3/.@ 2,/;(.;< 1,22+&(2@B ;,NB :((*K"# "/**@B @(%?2, &/5-+.8 5+-, +.;&+.4& &',(2@< D &'(%8'& ), /82,,* .(& &( *( &'/ A55 2+8'&< $%& )'/& ;(2& (: /. /.;),2 *( @(% )/.& &( &', F%,;&+(.B )'@ /.+3/5;

    :+8'&0"# J,55< "( &',@ *,/5 +. (99(;+&,;0># M'< E,;< A 5(& (: :+8'&+.8 ,.*; %9 +. ;(3, ;(2& (: 9,/4,O3/-+.8< A.* 4,2&/+.5@

    95/@:%5 :+8'&+.8 +; 9/2&5@ / )/@ (: /::+23+.8 :2+,.*;'+9< M2 *+;4(6,2+.8 (22,*+;4(6,2+.8 :2+,.*;'+9# D *(.?& -.()< $%&B @(% -.()B *2,/3; *( .(& /5)/@; *,/5 +. (99(;+&,;7)59 ,' )& -5)599:4:5% &4 )75 &9,/6 -.)6 )75 ':>7) -54&95 )75 5G,86 75 7,% , ':>7)8,95 :' +7:=7

    75 5G 7:8 )7,) )75

    :9&':= :' +,*:'> =&'E591,):&'6 )750 &4)5'%&'() )5// 0&. )750 ,95 -5:'> :9&':=2

    @# J&2 ;7,)(1 )9.52 $ ,/+,01 )7:'* :)(1 1&9) &4 =9.5/2"# K512 $) &4)5' :12@# @,%%06 ,95 ,':8,/1 5E59 :9&':= &9 1,9=,1):=B"# J&2 $ >.511 '&)2 3.) $ ,8 '&) 1.95 )7,) )7&15 ,95 C.:)5 )75 +&9%1 +5 17&./% .152

    L$9&':=M ,'% L1,9=,1):=M ,95 +&9%1 4&9 )75 ,',/01:1 &4 8511,>5 8,)59:,/ :'

    /,'>.,>52 F'% ,':8,/1 %&'() 7,E5 /,'>.,>52 $)(1 59

    %&>2 ;7,)(1 1&9) &4 :'E:):'> )75 -:>>59 %&> )& ,)),=*2 3.) :) +&9*1 :' )75 & 49&8 ,)),=*:'>2

    @# K512 $ 1552 $) :1 , 1&9) &4 .15 &4 & *'&+ )7,) )75 /:))/5 %&> :1 1,0:'> )75 & *'&+1 , /:))/5 8&95 ,-&.) :) )7,'

    )75 -:> %&>2 F'07&+6 )75 /:))/5 %&> %&51 '&) >:E5 ,'0 1:>',/1 )& 17&+ )7,) 75*'&+12 I5 &-E:&.1/0 =&./%'() %& )7,)2

    @# ;75' :)(1 /:*5 )75 %95,812 ;7595(1 '& /,-5/ )& 1,0 )7,) )75 %95,8 :1 %5,/:'> :'&

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    59/360

    "# $ %&'() *+,-+ .+%%'(. /01+*&+-+2 "-+31/ 4+35 '( 0660/'%+/7 3(4 3('135/ 4+35 '(0660/'%+/7 3(4 (+'%&+- 83--'+/ 539+5/ %0 /3: *&+( %&+: 3-+ 4+35'(. '( 0660/'%+/2

    ;# 80D-/+ (0%L(0- 40 3('135/2;# E55 -'.&% %&+(2"# M+%,/ .0 938) %0 %&3% 4-+312 $%/ %0%35 +>>+8% 0( %&+ 13( *3/ %&+ /31+ 3/ '>

    /01+904: &34 /3'4 %0 &'17 N O:0D '( 3 >'.&%+- 653(+, '/ (0% +GD35 %0 O:0D '( 3(0-35 +B312, N

    ;# H+/2 FD% %&+ 4-+31 4'4(,% /6+55 %&3% 0D%2 $% 0(5: /3:/7 N:0D '( 3 >'.&%+- 653(+2 $%5+3J+/ 0D% %&+ N(0%7P 3(4 '% 5+3J+/ 0D% %&+ '(/%-D8%'0( %0 80163-+ %&+ 4-+31 *'%&/01+%&'(. +5/+ 3(4 '% 40+/(,% /3: *&3% &+ /&0D54 80163-+ '% *'%&2

    "# E55 -'.&%2 M+%,/ %3)+ %&+ N(0%P >'-/%2 $/ %&+-+ 3(: N(0%P '( 3('135 9+&3J'0-?;# '-/% /&0*'(. &'/ >3(./

    3(4 %&+( (0% 9'%'(.?;# H+/2 R01+%&'(. 5')+ %&3%2"# FD% *&3% 390D% %*0 3('135/? A&+:,4 90%& &3J+ %0 /&0* %&+'- >3(./2;# H+/2

    "# E(47 '% /++1/ %0 1+7 %&+: 1'.&% 1'/D(4+-/%3(4 +38& 0%&+-7 3(4 .+% '(%0 3 >'.&%2;# H+/2 A&+-+ '/ 35*3:/ %&3% 43(.+- *&+( :0D 4+35 '( 0660/'%+/ 3(4 40 (0% 0-

    83((0% /3: *&3% :0D 3-+ 40'(.7 +/6+8'355: *&+( :0D 40 (0% )(0* *&3% :0D 3-+

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    60/360

    "#$%&' () *+, ,-. /%$0/12 3#+1" 4%#3 ,-/, ,-.5 6/7." ,-.$7 8/%&2 $% #7".7 ,# 2/59:; 3#%) N#' *.L/+2. $,) D.2' *+, ,-/,

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    61/360

    "# $%%&'()*+,-./0 /-12 34-5 + *-,+%4'& )1 .+6-.-7 +1 + *-,+%4'& ), 6-8'*-1 +1)*).-2

    9# $57 ),:1 ,4+, .+6-.)5; ,4+, + 7&-+* .-+4- 7&-+* ?'=.7 *-5,)'5 ,4- B&=), +57 %'11)6./

    ,4- 6+8,-&)+ 6=, ?'=.7 5', *-5,)'5 ,4- 5+,)'52 >4- 7&-+* -.+6'&+,-1 '5 ,4-&-.+,)'514)% 6=, 7'-1 5', )7-5,)B/ ,4- ,4)5;1 ,4+, +&- &-.+,-72

    9# 9+77/0 8'=.7 /'= *+A- + 7&-+* B'& *-F"# H'= *-+50 '5 ,4)1 &-8)%-F G'2 I-,:1 ,+A- ,4- %)-8- 'B 4+, ?'&7 ,4- ?&),-& )1 =1)5; .),-&+../0 +57

    ,4+, '5- ?'&7 ,-..1 /'= ?4+, +.. ,4- &-1, )1 +6'=,29# $57 )5 + 7&-+*F"# >4+, ?'&70 ,''0 ?'=.7 4+4-/:&- 6',4 'B ,4-* %&-1-5,2

    9# E=, 7'5:, ,4-/ -

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    62/360

    "# $%&'% ()*+, - ./)0% 0)1 )( 1/2+34 2+ 5)66)+ 7%1.%%+ ,8%-64 -+, -+26-07%/-'2)89 :/%; 7)1/ ,%-0 2+ )

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    63/360

    ! #$%& ''( )*%+ $,- #$&&.%, /,0,&1%*2*3*45

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    64/360

    !"# %&'(&)* %+,(-.( -,/ 0.1234+5*,*3236

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

    H9@ '() *+)+ ,- +*.( +/+0)1+ ,- .#0)2,34)+5 E* D$*$()6 ./ .7 ,*-.7$ /' 5'*7/(,5/ 717/$&7'3 /#.7 7'(/ ,*/.6 /#$ A('06$&7 -#.5# /#$1 )($ +$7.D*$+ /' $6,5.+)/$ #)B$ 0$$* 56$)(613'(&,6)/$+C )*+ 7' 3)( )7 E 5)* 7$$= /#$ 5)/$D'(.$7 +()-* ,A 01 /#$ 2'&&.//$$ #)B$0$$* 5'*7/(,5/$+ *'/ .* ($3$($*5$ /' )*1 7A$5.3.5)661 +$3.*$+ A('06$&7= 0,/ /' /#('- )D$*$()6 6.D#/ '* J/#$ A('06$&K '3 )55,6/,()/.'*= -#.6$ /#$ A('06$& ./7$63 ($&).*7B)D,$G

    H?@ L('& /#.7 ./ 3'66'-7 /#)/ ',( .&&$+.)/$ *$$+ .7 *'/ 7' &,5# /#$ 5'*7/(,5/.'*'3 ) 7$/ '3 5)/$D'(.$7 -#.5# -.66 /#('- ) 6.D#/ '* )66 /#$ A('06$&7= 0,/ ()/#$( /#$75#$&)/.5 3'(&,6)/.'* '3 /#$ A('06$&7 .* 7,5# ) -)1 /#)/ /#$1 &)1 0$ 7$A)()/$61.*B$7/.D)06$G

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

    HT@ U$ &)1 )D($$ /#)/ )*7-$(7 )($ 0)+61 *$$+$+ /' /#$7$ N,$7/.'*7 '3)+&.*.7/()/.'* )*+= 3,(/#$(= /#)/ ) 7/,+1 '3 5,6/,($ 5'*/)5/7 .7 6.F$61 /' D.B$ /#$7$)*7-$(7= S,/ ./ .7 )6&'7/ 5$(/).* /#)/ /#$ 75.$*/.3.5 3'(&,6)/.'* '3 /#$ A('06$&7 '3 5'*V/)5/ -.66 *'/ 3'66'- /#$7$ 6.*$7G E/ .7 )7 .3 .* /#$ 5'*7/(,5/.'* '3 5)/$D'(.$7 3'( /#$ 7/,+1'3 5(.&.*'6'D1 -$ 7/)(/$+ -./# ) +.5#'/'&1 '3 .*+.B.+,)67 .*/' 5(.&.*)6 )*+

    *"#$ -#'6$ 5'*/('B$(71 '3 -#.5# /#.7 )(/.56$ -)7 ) A)(/ #)7 0$$* ($A(.*/$+ .* !"#$%& ()"*+$%(,"+- $+./$+ 01 W),6 S'#)**'* )*+ L($+ W6'DG S,/ /#$ (.AA6$7 '3 /#.7 5'*/('B$(71 #)B$ 6'*D7.*5$ +.$+ +'-*= )*+ /#$ )(/.56$ .7 .*56,+$+ #$($ '*61 3'( ./7 A'7./.B$ 5'*/(.0,/.'*7G E/ .7 ($A(.*/$+=,*5#)*D$+= 3('&./%- M(/.56$ 9::= R'6G XXXR= 9:;

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    65/360

    "#"$%&'&"() *("+, &"+--+, ./(. $0% 1$&-"$- 2(1 /('3-%-+ 4#% ( )#"5 2/&)- 67./&1 8-%7 (..-'3. .# +-4&"- ( 9$%&'&"() .73-:;

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

    -$#"#'&$ 93/-"#'-"(; (%- 93%&'(%7:;

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

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    66/360

    "#$% $%#& '()*+,-). /) +*0 12/ 321)( *1 *-$)(1*$#5) &3%)+) 62( $%) &$740 26321$*3$ '%)12+)1*8

    9:; !"#$% #' ()% *+,-*./ 0 &7

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    67/360

    "#$"%"$&'() "# '(( *+,-. /*#+-0+)1 2-.- 3- 4&)+ 5- 6.-6'.-$ +* 7"#$ +,'+ +,- "#,-.-#+(*8"/ *7 *#- /&(+&.- $"77-.) 6.*7*$(9 7.*4 +,'+ *7 *+,-.)1 :.*4 +,") 6*"#+ *7 %"-3 3-),'(( )--; 7*. -0'46(-; +,'+ 3,-# "#$"%"$&'( < 8"%-) ' $."#= +* "#$"%"$&'( >; +,'+5-,'%"*. ") /*#)")+-#+ 3"+, *+,-. #*.4) *7 5-,'%"*. *5+'"#"#8 3"+,"# +,- 8.*&63,"/, /*#+'"#) < '#$ >1

    ?,") ')6-/+ *7 +,- "+9 *7 +,- 5*$9 *7 5-,'%"*. 6'++-.#) 4'9 5- .-)+'+-$ "# +-.4)*7 ' )+'#$'.$"@'+"*# *7 +,- /*8#"+"%- ')6-/+) *7 +,- 6-.)*#'("+"-) *7 +,- "#$"%"$&'()1A- 4'9 )'9 +,'+ +,- 6'++-.#) *7 +,*&8,+ *7 +,- "#$"%"$&'() '.- )* )+'#$'.$"@-$ +,'++,-". 5-,'%"*. '66-'.) +* +,-4 !"#$%&!'

    B5C)**+%,$-+ &./+%,. "* 01$,2 D# )+&$9"#8 +,- /&(+&.- 7.*4 +,") 6*"#+ *7 %"-3; 3- '.-/*#/-.#-$ +* ),*3 +,- -4*+"*#'( )-++"#8 *7 '(( +,- $-+'"() *7 5-,'%"*.1 A- ),'(( )--+,- 3,*(- 5*$9 *7 5-,'%"*. ') ' /*#/-.+-$ 4-/,'#")4 *."-#+-$ +*3'.$ '77-/+"%-)'+")7'/+"*# '#$ $"))'+")7'/+"*# *7 +,- "#$"%"$&'()1

    ?,") ')6-/+ *7 ' /&(+&.- 4'9 '()* 5- $-)/."5-$ "# +-.4) *7 ' )+'#$'.$"@'+"*# *7

    '77-/+"%- ')6-/+) *7 +,- 6-.)*#'("+"-) *7 +,- "#$"%"$&'(); 3,"/, '.- )* 4*$"7"-$ 59+,-". /&(+&.- +,'+ +,-". 5-,'%"*. ") +* +,-4 -4*+"*#'((9 /*#)")+-#+1

    B/C3%"1"4$% 01$,2 2-.- 3- ),'(( )-- +,- 3,*(- 5*$9 *7 5-,'%"*. ') ' 4-/,'#")4*."-#+-$ +*3'.$ +,- 6.*$&/+"*# '#$ $")+."5&+"*# *7 4'+-."'( *5E-/+)1

    B$C 567"1"!"#$%&! &18 ./&,$&! 01$,2 2-.- 3- ),'(( )-- +,- 5-,'%"*. 6'++-.#) '))/,-4'+"/'((9 *.$-.-$ '//*.$"#8 +* +"4- '#$ 6('/-1 A- ),'(( )-- < ') 8"%"#8 +,- $."#=+* > F5-/'&)- "+ ") G'+&.$'9 -%-#"#8 "# +,- >(&- >*'.1H

    B-C 9"%$"!"#$%&! 01$,2 2-.- 3- ),'(( )-- +,- 5-,'%"*. *7 +,- "#$"%"$&'() ') *."-#+-$+*3'.$ +,- "#+-8.'+"*# '#$ $")"#+-8.'+"*# *7 +,- 4'E*. "+; +,- I.*&6 ') ' 3,*(-1A- ),'(( )-- +,- 8"%"#8 *7 $."#=) ') ' 7'/+*. 3,"/, 6.*4*+-) +,- )*("$'."+9 *7 +,-8.*&61

    BJJC D# '$$"+"*# +* )+&$9"#8 +,- 5-,'%"*. *7 4-45-.) *7 +,- ,*4*8-#-*&) 8.*&67.*4 '(( +,-)- 6*"#+) *7 %"-3; 3- 4&)+ -0'4"#- ' #&45-. *7 )&/, 8.*&6) +* $")/*%-.+,- -77-/+) *7 )+'#$'.$"@'+"*# *7 +,-)- %'."*&) 6*"#+) *7 %"-3 "# +,- 6-*6(- 3- '.-)+&$9"#81 A- ,'%- )+'+-$ '5*%- +,'+ -%-.9 5"+ *7 5-,'%"*. 4&)+ 5- .-8'.$-$ ')

    6.*5'5(9 .-(-%'#+ +* '(( +,-)- %"-36*"#+); 5&+ +,- 7'/+ .-4'"#) +,'+ )*4- 6-*6(-) '.-4*.- "#/("#-$ +,'# *+,-.) +* )-- '#$ 6,.')- +,-". *3# 5-,'%"*. ') F(*8"/'(H *. F7*.+,- 8**$ *7 +,- G+'+-1H

    BJKC A"+, +,") =#*3(-$8- *7 +,- /*#$"+"*#) 3,"/, *5+'"# "# ,*4*8-#-*&)8.*&6); 3- ),'(( 5- "# ' 6*)"+"*# +* -0'4"#- +,- 6.*/-))-) *7 7&)"*# *7 +3* $"%-.)-8.*&6) "#+* *#-1 A- 4'9 -%-# 5- '5(- +* 6.-)/."5- 4-')&.-) 3,"/, 3"(( -"+,-.6.*4*+- *. .-+'.$ )&/, 7&)"*#; '#$ 6.-$"/+ +,'+ ' +.'"+ 3,"/, 7"+) +,- 7"%- ')6-/+) *7"+9 /'# 5- '$$-$ +* ' /&(+&.- 3"+,L*&+ *+,-. /,'#8-)1 D7 "+ $*-) #*+ 7"+; +,-# 3- /'#)-'./, 7*. '66.*6."'+- 4*$"7"/'+"*#) -"+,-. *7 +,- /&(+&.- *. *7 +,- +.'"+1

    BJMC :6+ +!$4$1&,$"1 "* "1+ "7 ;",6 #7"0/. ?,") -#$ .-)&(+ ") 6-.,'6) )/'./-(9 3*.+,)+&$9"#8; 5&+ 3- ),*&($ '+ (-')+ -0'4"#- '#9 4'+-."'( +,'+ ") '%'"('5(-; +* $-+-.4"#-3,'+ )*.+ *7 -77-/+) )&/, ,*)+"(- '/+"%"+9 ,') &6*# +,- /&(+&.- *7 +,- )&.%"%*.)1 D+ ")6*))"5(-; 7*. -0'46(-; +,'+ +,- 6'++-.#) *7 5-,'%"*. '))*/"'+-$ 3"+, -("4"#'+"*# *7*+,-. 8.*&6) 4'9 5- '))"4"('+-$ "#+* +,-". /&(+&.- )* +,'+ +,-9 '.- "46-((-$ +*-("4"#'+- 4*.- '#$ 4*.-1

    BJNC

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    68/360

    "#$%&'()*+',* (-&%')'). -#&/##) ."(0,* (1 ')2'3'20%$* /'&+ 2'11#"#)&'% -#+%3'(",%&")*4 %)2 $%" &( 5()*'2#" /+%& $'.+& &+#*# "#$%&'()*+',* &+"(/ 0,() /+%& %"#6("# 0*0%$$7 5%$$#2 85()&%5&*9: ;3#"7 %)&+"(,($(.'*& /+( +%* -##) ') &+# 1'#$2 +%*+%2 (,,("&0)'&7 (1 *&027'). *05+ 2'11#"#)&'% ."(0,*9

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

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    69/360

    "#$% "#$%&'($%)* &'()*' +,-./0(12'032 4,/5,,1 *+()32 6.1 4+(.7-8 4, 6-.22090,701/( /5( 6./,*(+0,2: 28;;,/+06.- .17 6(;3-,;,1/.+8: /'02 2)470 '.1 .770/0(1 /( /'02: /', N.+=0.1 '02/(+0.12 '.

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    70/360

    "#$ %&'%()$ (* +#$ %'$)$,+ -'+./0$ .) +( )&11$)+ %'(20$3) -,4 0.,$) (*.,5$)+.1-+.(, '-+#$' +#-, +( )+-+$ +#$ -,)6$')7 2&+7 +$,+-+.5$087 )&11$)+.(,) 3-8 2$(**$'$4 -) +( +#$ *-/+(') /(,+'(00.,1 )/#.)3(1$,$).)9

    :-; A?-3%0$) (* +#.) +8%$ (* )+-2.0.@-+.(, -'$ %$'#-%) /(33(,> "#$ )=&.'$ .) ., -%'$4(3.,-,+08 /(3%0$3$,+-'8 -,4 ,(+ -06-8) /(3*('+-20$ '$0-+.(,)#.% 6.+# #.)5.00-1$')7 2&+ .* #$ %-'+./.%-+$ ., 5.00-1$ /'./B$+ :- )833$+'./-0 '.5-0'8; 2&+ (,/$ -8$-'7 +#.) 3-8 #-5$ - /&'.(&)08 4.)%'(%('+.(,-+$ $**$/+ &%(, #.) '$0-+.(,)#.% 6.+#

    +#$3>:2;

    :/; D&+ +#.) 6(&04)$$3 +( 2$ -+ 2$)+ - 5$'8 6$-B 4$*$,)$9 (, +#$ (,$ #-,47 .* 6$ /(,).4$' +#$ $**$/+) (*)833$+'./-0 )/#.)3(1$,$).) &%(, +#$ '$/.%'(/-0 2$#-5.(' %-++$',)7 6$ )$$ +#-+ +#$0-++$' +$,4 +( 2$ 0$)) -,4 0$)) $?#.2.+$4> "#&)7 -) +#$ .,4.5.4&-0) /(3%().,1 +#$,-+.(,) (* A&'(%$ 2$/(3$ 3('$ -,4 3('$ .,5(05$4 ., +#$.' )833$+'./-0 .,+$',-+.(,-0'.5-0'.$)7 +#$8 1'-4&-008 0$-5$ (** 2$#-5.,1 ., - '$/.%'(/-0 3-,,$'7 4$0.2$'-+$08'$4&/.,1 +( - 3.,.3&3 +#$.' *('3$' '$/.%'(/-0 /(33$'/.-0 2$#-5.('> EF, +#$ (+#$'#-,47 .* 6$ /(,).4$' +#$ $**$/+) (* /(3%0$3$,+-'8 )/#.)3(1$,$).) &%(, +#$'$/.%'(/-0 2$#-5.(' %-++$',)7 6$ )$$ +#-+ (,$G#-0* (* +#$ '$/.%'(/-0 %-+G+$', .) 0.-20$ +(

    0-%)$> H#$'$ *('3$'08 2(+# 1'(&%) $?#.2.+$4 2(+# I -,4 J7 - )8)+$3 1'-4&-008$5(05$) ., 6#./# (,$ (* +#$ 1'(&%) $?#.2.+) (,08 I7 6#.0$ +#$ (+#$' $?#.2.+) (,08 J> K&/# -, (&+).4$ $0$3$,+ 3-8 2$ $.+#$' - )832(0./ .,4.5.4&-07 -,$,$38 %$(%0$ (' )(3$ =&.+$ .3%$')(,-0 /.'/&3)+-,/$L+#$ 0.(, 6.00 0.$ 4(6, 6.+#+#$ 0-32 .* (,08 .+ '-., #-'4 $,(&1#> D&+ .+ 3&)+ 2$ ,(+$4 +#-+ 6#$'$ +#$ (&+).4$$0$3$,+ .) - %$')(, (' 1'(&% (* %$')(,)7 +#$ '$0-+.(,)#.% (* +#$ /(32.,$4 1'(&%) C-,4 D +( +#$ (&+).4$ 1'(&% 6.00 -06-8) 2$ .+)$0* - %(+$,+.-008 )/#.)3(1$,./'$0-+.(,)#.% (* (,$ (' +#$ (+#$' +8%$> A?-3.,-+.(, (* 3&0+.%0$ )8)+$3) (* +#.) B.,4 .)2-408 ,$$4$4 -,4 $)%$/.-008 6$ ,$$4 +( B,(6 3('$ -2(&+ +#$ )8)+$3) :$>1>7 3.0.+-'8

    5C /(3%0$+$ )+&48 6(&04 2$ )&2G4.5.4$4 .,+( )$%-'-+$ )$/+.(,)7 $-/# +'$-+.,1 (,$ (* +#$ -)%$/+) (*+#$ %#$,(3$,->

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    71/360

    "#$%&%'"#$() #* +"#'" ,"$ -#(,.%,#.* ./ 0$%(.*&1#,2 #( 3.-#/#$- #* ,"$ 3#--1$ 4%.50( ./,"$ "#$%&%'"2 62 0$%3#,,#*4 ,"$ #*-#7#-5&1( ,. $8"#6#, %$(0$', &*- (563#((#.* #*-$&1#*4( +#," "#4"$% 4%.50( +"#1$ ,"$2 $8"#6#, &(($%,#7$*$(( &*- 0%#-$ #* -$&1#*4+#," ,"$ 1.+$%9

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

    :DE) ;* '.*'15(#.*= +$ 3&2 ,5%* ,. ,"$ 0%.61$3( ./ ,"$ &-3#*#(,%&,.% /&'$- +#," &61&'A@+"#,$ '51,5%$ '.*,&',9 F#( /#%(, ,&(A #( ,. -$'#-$ +"#'" ./ ,"$ $*- %$(51,(

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

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    72/360

    !"# %&'()*+(,-. *, /0*,1*,2 3456- 74.()8(9%-0,5:52*;3:

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    73/360

    "#$% & "'( '%')*+,%- .#$ /'.0.$1%( 23 /'1.1,4-$(5 3$'.#$1(6 & 7,-#. 1$'))* -$. '%'%("$1 21 ' 8,. 23 '% '%("$1 .2 .#$ "#2)$ /9++),%- 89(,%$(( 23 /'..$1% '%4 1$-9)'1,.*,% %'.91$: ;%4 391.#$16 .#,( 8,. 23 7*(.,

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    74/360

    "#$% "#$ &$'()$* +,-)& .$ /-%(0#$&1 2(0 ,+% 3*4&$ +,-)& &$'$%& #(5 .-" "#$ ,"#$*0+,-)& 0"4*" 4 .*4+)16

    7 "#$% .$34% ),,8(%3 ',* 5,*$ 9,%9*$"$ 940$0 +#(9# 9,-)& .$ 9,5/4*$& +("# "#$9,%"*40" .$"+$$% "#(0 0:0"$5 4%& ,-* ,+%1 7 04(&; $4*"#+,*50; ),.0"$*0; 54%; $"91@1B

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

    .$"+$$% "#$ 0-99$00(A$ 0$35$%"0; "#4" $49# 0$35$%" +,-)&; (' (" 9,-)& >7 0/$48),,0$):@ ',*5 4 #$4&; .-" "#4" "#$ %$G" 4%"$*(,* 0$35$%" /*$A$%"0 "#(01 H-*"#$*; "#(0&:%45(9 40:55$"*: (% "#$ *$)4"(,%0 .$"+$$% 0-99$00(A$ 0$35$%"0 (0 *$')$9"$&5,*/#,),3(94)):I +$ '(%& (% 5,0" 0-9# 4%(54)0 4 0$*(4) &(''$*$%9$J+#4" (0 94))$&5$"45$*(9 &(''$*$%"(4"(,%J.$"+$$% "#$1 0-99$00(A$ 0$35$%"01

    F#$(* 4//$%&43$0; "#,-3# "#$: 94% .$ 0#,+% ", 9,%',*5 ", 4 0(%3)$ .40(90"*-9"-*$; &(''$* ,%$ '*,5 4%,"#$* 40 +$ 3, &,+% "#$ 0$*($01 >F#$ )$30 ,' "#$ ),.0"$*/*,A(&$ 4 '45()(4* $G45/)$ ,' "#$ 0,*" ,' "#(%3 7 5$4%1@

    7% 9,%"*40" +("# "#(0; (% "#$ *4&(4)): 0:55$"*(94) 4%(54)0; "#$ 0$35$%"0; 4**4%3$&4*,-%& "#$ 9$%"$* )(8$ 0$9",*0 ,' 4 9(*9)$; 4*$ -0-4)): 4)) 4)(8$1

    E0 7 04:; +$ &, %," 8%,+ 5-9# 4.,-" "#$ 0$35$%"4"(,% ,' 4%(54)0; .-" 4" )$40"#$*$ +40 $%,-3# ',* 5$ ", "48$ .498 ", "#$ /*,.)$5 ,' 74"5-) 0,9(4) ,*34%(K4"(,%1 L:

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    75/360

    "#$ %&'() *"+ ,-# '.+/ 0*&12 * +344#",3*,3'" '4 0' 6-# 73.%&30 8*,-#&2 $*"+#&'44 3" '&+#& ,' 9# !"##$%$&'( :(, *0'"% ,-# ;*,0(./ $-#" ,$' %&'()2 3" * *.5 ;" '(& 2'>3#,?/ 43223'" ,#"+2 ,' 9# -#,3>*. @* 4'..'$3"% *4,#&',-#& +'>,&3"#2 '& 0'A/ 9(, 3" ;*,0(./ 43223'" 32 &*,-#& 2>-320*,3> @* 4'..'$3"% *4,#&',-#& .#*+#&2 $3,-'(, >-*"%# '4 +'%0*A5

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

    6-(2 #-?/ ,-# ;*,0(. -*.(23'" 0? #"=(3&?/ 3"4.(#">#+ 9? 0*"? ',-#& ,?)#2 '4 0*,#&3*./$3.. %' '" ,' .''1 *, ,-# 0*,,#& 4&'0 ',-#& )'3",2 '4 3*..? ,-#)2?>-'.'%3>*. )&'9.#02 '4 $-#,-#& * )#"># 4'& 2?00#,&3>*. &*,-#& ,-*"*2?00#,&3>*. .*,3'"2-3)2 >*" 9# 30).*",#+ 3" ,-# 3"+3-S +#&332# 4'&0(.*,3'"2 '4 ,-*,',-#& 2>3#"># 3" ,#&02 '4 $-3>- 3, 32 )'2239.# ,' ,-3"1 0' 4&(3,H4(..? *9'(, '(& '$"0*,#&3*.5

  • 8/13/2019 Gergory Bateson - Steps to an Ecology of Mind

    76/360

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

    3 -(&,9 &- %#$'/ 5+ 0)&1 -# 4)7 -()- 3 $4+ -(+ ),)'#6&+4 &, 4#2+ .$1$4'7 )54-1).-0#12A-()-= )4 0#1 >)4$..+44&*+@ %&-( 4#2+ )54-1).- 2+),&,6 %(&.( 2)9+4 &-)??'&.)5'+ -# 5#-( 4#1-4 #0 .)4+4:

    C(&4 51&,64 $4 -# ),#-(+1 *+17 &2?#1-),- 2#-&0 &, 27 -(&,9&,6A) ()5&- #0.#,4-1$.-&,6 )54-1).-,4 %(&.( 1+0+1 -# -+124 #0 .#2?)1&4#, 5+-%++, +,-&-&+4D ),/ -#

    &''$4-1)-+ -(&4 3 .), .