8/12/2019 Genuine Dispute in Arbitrati (1)
2/7
Page 22012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 35107, *
10 of 100 DOCUMENTS
SLEEP FOR HEALTH, LLC, Plaintiff, v. CARDIO SLEEP SERVICES,
INC., Defendant.
Civil No. 10-!00 "R#$%$&'(
)NITED STATES DISTRICT CO)RT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NE'
*ERSE+
2012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 35107
&a 1/, 01, Deided
&a 1/, 01, Filed
NOTICE NOT O! PU"LIC#TION
CO)NSEL 213 o$ SLEEP O! %E#LT%,LLC, a Ne& 'e$se( )iite+
)iai)it( -oa/(,P)ai/tiff, Co/te$ Defe/+a/t LENN !.COC%!#N, COC%!#N
SC%ULT4, ESS.,P!INCETON, N'.
o$ C#!DIO SLEEP SE!6ICES, INC., aDe)a&a$e -o$o$atio/,
Defe/+a/t, Co/te$C)aia/t P#UL ". "!ICIELD, "!ICIELD DON#%UE, !I6E!
EDE, N'.
*)D4ES !O"E!T ". ULE!, U/ite+ StatesDist$i-t '+ge.
OPINION #+ !O"E!T ". ULE!
OPINION
8Do-. No. 19:
$)4LER, U/ite+ States Dist$i-t '+ge
T;is atte$ -oes efo$e t;e Co$t o/ t;eotio/ of Defe/+a/t Ca$+io
S)ee Se$+ge/t as toDefe/+a/t?s -o/te$-)ais i/ a -o/t$a-t
+isteet&ee/ Defe/+a/t a/+ P)ai/tiff S)ee o$ %ea)t;,LLC
8=P)ai/tiff= o$ =S%=:. Defe/+a/t, i/ its
otio/, see@s e/fo$-ee/t of a/ a$it$atio/ a&a$+i/ its fa
8/12/2019 Genuine Dispute in Arbitrati (1)
5/7
Page 52012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 35107, *e/tit)e+ to atto$/e(s?
fees.
#. Defendant>< Clai? of #ea 9; Plaintiff a< a
Defen< Clai? of Antii@ato;
#eaT;e a$t( asse$ti/g a $ea-; of -o/t$a-t =;as
t;e $+e/ to s;o& t;at t;e a$ties e/te$e+ i/to a
8/12/2019 Genuine Dispute in Arbitrati (1)
6/7
Page 92012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 35107, *
IV. CONCL)SION
o$ t;e fo$egoi/g $easo/s, Defe/+a/t?s otio/fo$ sa$( >+ge/t is
;e$e( 4RANTEDas to
t;e e/fo$-eai)it( of t;e Ma$-; 31, 2011a$it$atio/ a&a$+,
DENIED as to Defe/+a/t?s$eBest fo$ atto$/e(s? fees asso-iate+
⁢ $si/gt;e e/fo$-ee/t of t;at a$it$atio/ a&a$+,
a/+DENIED as to t;e Bestio/ of &;et;e$ P)ai/tiff
ate$ia))( $ea-;e+ $io$ to Defe/+a/t?s a))ege+a/ti-iato$( $ea-;.
#/ a--oa/(i/g O$+e$ s;a))isse to+a(.
Date+ 31512
s !oe$t ". g)e$
!O"E!T ". ULE!
U/ite+ States Dist$i-t '+ge
