14
Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice: a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice: a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful

and democratic world

Page 2: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

The term “justice” is easy to convey in a discussion of individual rights

Criminal law violation – “lawbreaker was brought to justice”

Civil rights violation – “this will deny their right to vote”

International human rights violations—“injustice by dictator X in arresting his political opponents”

Page 3: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

The term “justice” is harder to convey in a discussion of “social justice”

Common for undergrads to misinterpret “social justice” as meaning “socialism”

We can define social justice as “Increasing equity of risk and resource distribution among different social groups”

Page 4: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Examples of social justice

Examples:•Environmental degradation: low-income communities should not bear greater health risks than high-income communities•College admissions: black students should not be admitted at lower rates than white students•Health budgets: men’s disease should not be funded at a higher rate than women’s disease

Page 5: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Critics of social justice

•Individual responsibility: if more people in low-income communities choose to smoke, they should bear responsibility for that choice•Meritocracy: If my grades are high it is due to my talent and hard work; thus college admissions should reflect that and nothing else.•Reverse discrimination: prostate cancer and breast cancer occur at about the same rate, but funding for breast cancer is about double that of prostate cancer

Page 6: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Critics of social justice

“Democrats want to fight over who gets the biggest slice of pie, but we Republicans want to bake a bigger pie for everyone”

Page 7: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Confusion over social justicein the case of Open Source Software

Kevin Kelly is wrong: Open source software does not fit the category of “socialism”

Yet it is relevant to “social justice” – how do we resolve this contradiction?

Page 8: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Socialism is based on distributive social justice

1) Money appears to be a self-generating source of value 2) Actually money disguises the true source of value: self-generating capacity of labor

and nature 3) Capitalism extracts self-generated value, creating injustice and alienation4) Capitalism raises profits by "externalizing" costs, damaging health and environment

Page 9: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Liberalism is also based on distributive social justice

1) Socialism attempts to return that surplus value by state ownership2) Liberalism attempts to return that surplus value by taxes

Page 10: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Open Source is a case of generative social justice

Page 11: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Generative justice reconfigures the flow of value: from labor back to labor

Previously the software developers labor value can be privatized (extracted) But Open Source ensures that value is available to its source of generation via the public commons

Page 12: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Generative justice reconfigures the flow of value: from nature back to nature

Previously nature’s value can be privatized (extracted). But Critical Growing (Lyles) ensures it is available to its via the natureculture commons.

Page 13: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Why should small scale waste recycling be better than large scale industrial

waste systems?

Because the small-scale case offers greater opportunity for Generative justice

Page 14: Generative Justice versus Distributive Justice : a crucial distinction for guiding engineering towards a more peaceful and democratic world

Generative social justiceIncreasing the public capacity for self-generating

practices and resources

Social entrepreneurship: capital at the service of social justiceGenerative public spaces: Community gardens, muralsGenerative technologies: DIY, Maker-faire, Arduino, fan fiction, citizen journalismGenerative educative practices: Recovering heritage, history, futures