41
Group Analytical Paper: Gender Equality in a Workforce OL690_G3063 Responsible Corporate Leadership

Gender Equality in a Wokrforce.doc

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Group Project: Gender Equality in a Workforce

Group Analytical Paper: Gender Equality in a Workforce

OL690_G3063 Responsible Corporate Leadership

Instructor:

Students:Dr. Katrina Elta Kerr

Dzenana Hanjalic-Zimic

Jieming WuTerm: 11TW3

Date: June 7, 2011.Table of ContentI. Introduction

II. Cultural Stereotypes

III. Access to Education

IV. Access to Special and Professional Opportunities

V. Recommendations

VI. Conclusion

References

I. Introduction

The perception according to which all human beings are free to develop their individual abilities and make choices without restrictions set by harsh gender positions and approving different manners where objectives and desires of women and men are considered, appreciated and privileged on equal basis is defended as gender equality. From the other side, some illustrate gender equality through justice in treatments on the basis of gender, which may possibly indicate either equal treatment or treatment that deviates but considered comparable in terms of human and civil rights, commitments, settlements or chances given to individual. Main purpose of this paper is concerning issues on gender equality in a workforce with focus on developed countries having in mind most of those nations around the world are facing with a noticeable gap in separating women from men at the labor market. Generally women have bottom level entrance to resources and opportunities in certain community. Women rarely have the opportunity to participate in decision-making processes in order to have certain effect on their lives and surroundings. The discrimination against women remains a common occurrence in todays society. Women are under the category with longer unemployment status and when it comes to recruitment , their employment rate and salary is lower.

Gender inequity is still at large extent in culture, education and professional opportunities especially targeting younger population of women. Even though this younger population of women are gradually giving more preferences to ` male occupations, they stay overrepresented in conventionally 'female' occupations, like teachers, secretaries, nurses and underrepresented in jobs with responsibility and the career oriented profession.

In the new and imminent working divisions there is a disproportion in the demonstration of women and men. A good example is use of new information and communication technologies where, regardless of their fast expansion, where women in general, take up positions at the bottom of ranking scale. In female dominated working divisions like health care, women work as nurses but a greater part of hospital managers and directors are men.

II. Cultural Stereotypes

Diversity in the workforce allows us to value and connect with other and different cultures in all places. It provides us with knowledge and testing our tolerance to anything that is different from our own world. Although there are many widely accepted and perceived definitions for a culture, the one that is commonly used and relevant to this topic is to explain beliefs and practices of a different nations predominantly where those values are strongly connected with customs and religion. According to UNESCO Mexico City Declaration on Cultural Policies (1982) more comprehensive approach was proposed defining a culture as a " whole complex of distinctive spiritual, material, intellectual and emotional features that characterize a society or social group. It includes not only the arts and letters, but also modes of life, the fundamental rights of the human being, value systems, traditions and beliefs "(p. 1).Commonly raised issues about gender equality initiatives are in close relation to culture. Ethical values incorporated with a working place are bringing up generally accepted opinion that enforcement of gender equality in a workforce should congregate with local culture. However, some cultural values in certain areas may bring some restrictions to that extent any effort done in actions for gender equality is considered very complicated and almost impossible to overcome. All over the world gender relation is shaped by a culture in a way that many characteristics describing women or man only. Differences and connections between genders are serious issues in a various cultures because they form not an individual daily life approach but also in the public or in the workforce as well. Certain cultural connotations are given to being a female or male and could be manifested in the workforce (Schalkwyk, 2000). Although some particular gender relations differ among nations and change over a time, in general, women have limited authority over a decision making process of their own existence in societies and consequently to these less independence and lower earnings. A meaning of gender differences is variable in accordance to many cultural change factors. Heller (2008) declared " low level of participation induces a widespread belief that women have a comparative advantage in housework rather than on the labor market"(p.2) but many recent studies has proved that there is their possible on 'equal basis' engagement in previously male-dominated positions such as law enforcement , medicine, engineering, military or professional sports. Wallace and Leicht (2004) argued that social equality, social freedom, multiculturalism, and gender equality over the years have been infiltrated into the discussion about workplace politics and have changed employees awareness of their rights. Since many communities and families act in response to societal and economic changes connected to new technologies advancement, globalization effects or environmental pressures due to these cultural adjustments take place. Heller in his research (2008) have tried to prove the fact that certain cultural transformation could have a long-term effects on economic development and gender inequality. These cultural transformations are consequences of intentional efforts to achieve adjustments in policies assigned by governments, legalizations and laws enforced and are frequently made by civil society hassle. Wallace and Leicht (2004) also declared "connection between religiously-based cultural values and societal attitudes is more complex and multidimensional" (p.5).There are various patterns of endeavor to influence attitudes about different cultural issues. In order to restructure cultural stereotypes about women the overall efforts made are focused on issues regarding total number of girls having opportunity to pursuit education in public schools, admission to regularly paid work and public approach to domestic violence. As we could see from the above stated discussion cultural values are constantly being redesigned in response to new requirements and circumstances of society.

Transformations in gender relations are frequently disputable, since they have instantaneous connotation to every person . The Lancet (2010) published "tackling gender equality is complicated because it involves challenging many cultural norms and stereotypes". In certain positions in gender relations especially a role of wife and mother could be perceived as strong symbol of cultural permanence. Wallace and Leicht (2004) found "gender constitutes perhaps one of the most public arenas of cultural conflict between conservatives and progressives. Conservatives generally endorse traditional gender roles forwomen that center on domestic duties in the household and a subordinated economic role to men " (p.10). In order to eliminate or at least decrease the negative effects of discriminatory social structures keeping gender equality issues to be recognized a global challenge is to recognize and support more culturally sensitive and rights-based movements to gender equality (The Lancet,2010).

There are political movements focused on roles of women and trying to weaken resistance to western influences as result of blind devotion to cultural or religious values. On the other hand, national identity and religious values are important to many women and it is manifested by different groups in opposition. Those groups are focused on explanation of holy sacred citations and in order to reiterate principals supporting dignity and sovereignty of women. The observations concerning role of women and gender equality are usually supported by one person or a group and not immediately followed by others. Potential gender equality initiative involves plenty discussions with those involved in the issue, but also counting those working on this project as well (Schalkwyk, 2000). Gender equality initiators support women in the labor market to look for better opportunities and fairness in job rewards with man (Wallace and Leicht, 2004). Gender and cultural stereotyping is a problem that women involved into working force should deal with and being able to come across a number of complexities that could affect their performance in the workplace. Research has shown that women could deal with very stressful situations at working place and incorporate into their 'multitasking' efforts to become adequate leaders and negotiators (Jacobs and Schain, 2008). There should not be any cultural restrains for women in a labor force. Family friendly procedures introduced by employers would make significant advancement of working lives to a large number of women.

Jabos and Schain (2008) also claimed: "the issues that affect working women also affect working men. Employers now understand that remedying these problems would; therefore, benefit their entire workforce and increase productivity. This is especially true of family management issues. Family management is becoming the job of both parents. Workplace policies are beginning to reflect this. Various companies are attempting to apply flexible work arrangements to men as well as women. Men opting for flex-time; however, may have to overcome some perceptual problems which could affect their career advancement " (p.10).

The labor force would be better served by the less significant conduction of male-dominant cultures, instead stressing to diversities and possibilities that women are being capable to establish, often as its advantage.

III. Access to Education

As an essential social and economic resource in society, education corresponds to significant life opportunity for everyone. United Nations Population Fund (2010) published :

"Education is also critical as it is investment into developing a future generation that is capable of problem-solving, has appropriate social and occupational competencies and has the breadth and depth of knowledge to build a dynamic and innovative society" (p.57).

Disparities in education between women and men are considered as one of the largest limitation in gender equality. Differences between boys and girls at early stage are could make in return some negative consequences in area of education closely related to gender discrimination. Due to this unequal treatment of children in families certain social forces in some communities could provide better access of girls to schooling, making possible to them to catch up with boys in an significant aspect of life chance given by education. (Subrahmanian,2005). Melnick (2005) stated "Education is imperative for expanding ones horizons, for entrepreneurship, and to move away from dependency. Education is the cornerstone for overall development" (p.61,62).

In some rural areas, most often women do not have any alternatives and access to education and they are very economically dependent on men (United Nations Population Fund, 2010).

In those regions girls are expected to do household and farming everyday jobs. This factor is limiting education of a females to greater extent. Cocking a food, cleaning a house, looking after siblings or in some cases after sick and old family members are some of their on regular basis responsibilities that consequently keep them from schooling. Other obstruction for girls to pursue their education in rural areas is concerning their physical safety in particular when they travel a long distance to school. In the urban regions although there is a noticeable difference in the chances that females obtain for education or employment, statistics for girls are still low as compared to boys.

Two key indicators of possible womens achievement are education and employment. They are presenting current women's path way to gain economic power that is strongly connected to gender equality. However, Berik, Rodgers and Seguino (2009) stated "educational and employment equality are good for growth, there remains a possibility that this does not ensure equality in other dimensions of material well-being, including wages and security of income stream"(p.23). According to Subrahmanian (2005)" measuring gender equality in education is conceptually demanding, and will necessitate focus on a far wider range of indicators than may be suggested by focusing on education alone, or defined in a narrow sense "(p.396).

According to Federal-Provincial/Territorial Ministers Responsible for the Status of Women in Canada (1997) , "education has very positive returns for women and is particularly important for their future economic well-being" (p.10); while Wach and Reeves claimed (2000) "if female workers have less education than male workers their earnings would also be lower" (p.20). Denying education to girls put social and economic development in the backward position while investing in those, pays off to large extent because consequently, well educated women invest more in their children's health and education (United Nations Population Fund,2000).

There are certain methods has to be introduced in order to promote gender equality to become meaningful in developed societies closely related to education process. One of them is the commitment of government to ensure the national, regional and local approach to educational institutions and establish social mobilizing programs of that will promote importance in education on an ongoing basis. Good example of this could be compared with China, a fast developing nation. Historically, being a highly patriarchal society there are some significant distinctions In China, in the parent's objectives for daughters versus sons. Status of women and their access to education in as China was unjust for centuries. Formal education was required only for boys. Significant change has been made by implementing 'one child policy' providing equal urban family investments in education for girls as well (Veeck, A.,Flurry, L.A, & Jiang N. ,2003).

Having gender inequality in modern societies should be avoided in the education system and not only female but even male pupils and students should be treated on same conditions regardless the culture of community and teachers. Gender equality is also necessary in education in order to establish societal and national prosperity. According to United Nations Population Fund (2010) " In the longer term, young people, once reintegrated and given the benefits of education and training, have the best chance of insuring that their communities and countries can develop in peace " (p.48). IV. Access to Special and Professional Opportunities

Generally, these issues are covering differences in career opportunities, enclosure or segregation in the events organized by employers and any dissimilarity in the behavior toward daily activities of employee, based on their gender ( Piderit and Ashford, 2003, p. 1478).

Many research studies published are illustrating examples of women being underrepresented in higher level jobs in relation to men. Escriche and Pons (2009) demonstrated a two-level job hierarchy, dividing a working career of individual to two types: family and work oriented employees. The basic distinction between them is that family oriented employees experience a greater disutility from effort on the job at the beginning of their working careers. In order to gain great professional outcome and loyalty by their employees the organizational support in establishing good work/family policies is highly recommended. In their study they have shown that "women are less likely to apply for jobs with promotion possibilities, but when they do, women are just as likely to succeed as men" (Escriche and Pons,2009, p.1).

Younger population of women in most cases are those that compensate the cost of job market elasticity. Being young, in the complicated phase of change between education and working life, this age group usually has jobless rate two times higher than older workers group. This younger age group is also under the additional stress of their employers that take advantage of their weak working practice under the excuse of enabling them to obtain necessary professional experience.

Efforts to improve access and opportunities to better working conditions and increasing women's wages in developed countries are important family wellbeing. Since there are more single mothers every day, being underpaid and provided with lowest type of jobs at the labor market from the other side, could have a direct impact to child poverty. Everyone should be given chance to explore and pursuit for career options based on her own abilities, education and expertise. Many gender related barriers prevent women from accessing the highly paid jobs.

Tyson (2011) wrote in her article that education in a time of global recession possibly will not anymore provide a clear direction to economic success. Tyson (2011) have compared statistics of U.S. labor market in connection to higher education of women and its relevance to increased wages within a period of 40 years "In 1970 only about 22 percent of female workers had attended some college or had a college degree. By 2010, that figure had increased threefold to nearly 67 percent of all women in the work force, while the percentage of women with less than a high-school degree had declined to less than 7 percent from about 34 percent" (para.2) and regardless of remaining discrimination and gender inequality, nowadays, women are able to considerably advance their incomes through higher education (Tyson, 2011) .

Please refer to Figure 1. ((Bureau of Labor Statistics,2010,p.4)

Figure 1. Percent change of constant-dollar median usual weekly earnings, by educational attainment and gender 19792009

In accordance to above stated discussion, statistics reported, average earnings for women with full-time employment in 2009 was approximated to $657, or 80 percent out of $819 earnings what is estimated to their male counterparts. Since the first year that has been taken in this research, was 1979, data available estimated 62 percent of average earnings of women as compared to men. (Bureau of Labor Statistics,2010)Please refer to Figure 1. (Bureau of Labor Statistics,2010,p.3)

Figure 2. Womens earnings as a percent of mens, full-time wage and salary workers, 19792009 annual averages

" The occupational distributions of female and male full-time workers differ considerably. Compared with men, relatively few women work in construction, production, or transportation occupations, and women are far more concentrated in administrative support jobs" (Bureau of Labor Statistics,2010, p.2).

Please refer to Figure 1. (Bureau of Labor Statistics,2010,p.4)

Figure 3. Distribution of full-time wage and salary employment, by gender and major occupation group, 2009 annual averages

Society should be aware of the fact that the labor market have certain benefits from educating women by growing their knowledge and expertise desirable for entry into the more productive and well paid professions. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) (2011), in its report on Womens Earnings and Income, noted that gaps in earnings between females and males vary from country to country.

Please refer to the following Figure 4. which observes earnings of women compared to wages of men. Sample is taken for age group from 30 to 44 years old for all educational levels (Catalyst,2011, p.7).

Figure 4. Earnings of women (ages 30-44) as a percentage of mens earnings

An important step in the process of attaining gender equality and decent work is to introduce and promote positive policies by employers in order to help workers to get fairly wages and maintain normal family life (Bureau for Gender Equality,2005). According to them positive policies and practices "include part-time working, flexible contracts, job sharing, working from home, enhanced maternity leave and pay, paternity leave, parental leave, and childcare provision" (Bureau for Gender Equality,2005, p. 9).Main reason for gender disparity is that organizations are most commonly responsible for nominating female candidates to serve on higher ranked positions.

As with governments and employers initiatives and good practices these gender issues also have well-known arrangements in unions and have expected support from union leaderships. Above plenty positive examples of country's good practices given in this study, we choose Canada where " the Auto Workers Union has a long-established Womens Department which leads on gender equality throughout the union, plus several other structures to help women become active in the union (e.g. local union womens committees, womens networks, and the CAW Council Womens Committee)" . (Bureau for Gender Equality, 2005, p. 14). Globally, women have insignificant influence in public policies decision making process at the local, regional or national level and it is usually at large extent affecting their lives and living

conditions (Melnick, 2005). Women are now graduating from college and graduate school in larger numbers than men and entering the labor market in equivalent numbers. But at each stage of advancement, males are at least two times as likely as females to move forward. '"Only 11 chief executives of Fortune 500 companies are women, down from 15 in 2010, according to Catalyst Inc. a nonprofit women's research group" (Blumenstein,2011, p. R.1).

One Chinese survey also has showed in 1994, there are 12 million women government officials which are 32.59% of the total; but only 10.69% of women can become to the higher posts above the county level (Chinamoves toboost status, 1995) .

"Marginalization of women is unethical on several counts. Excluded from political power, women are unable to participate in decisions that shape the consequences of their own lives, thus precluding them from a full exercise of their humanity as members of society" (Thompson, 2008, p.93).

Even though laws are equal to everyone but have small effect in practice in some nations because of their mainstream cultures an awareness of womens right is insignificant and make women feel helpless particularly in some developing countries where the judicial system has not completed and is constant subject to change. (In the Public Interest, 2009).

Please refer to Table 1. which demonstrated, according to International Comparison website (2011) results of different surveys on gender equality by country and focuses on each countrys promotion of not only womens rights, but women in positions of power . Retrieved from http://international-comparison.quarryvillage.org/intl_comp_files/sheet008.htm

Table 1. Overall international comparison statistics on gender equality in developed countries around the world

Society does not give importance of women, their involvement in communities, or the kind of job that they do. The employment hierarchy often prepared by men to provides males with the utmost occasions. Treating females in a same way as men appear to be relevant in written documents but it is not effective in practical sense, because of the fact that both begin to work and contribute from uneven positions. Altering societal approaches could assist to pass valid gender equality to both sides concerning society and the labor force.

Although both females and males may perceive and address gender equality issues due to accessibility to higher ranking positions and opportunities at labor market it is considered that women's actions meant to raise equality concerns may have diverse connotations in male dominated society. According to Piderit and Ashford (2003) "people may be more likely to ascribe self-serving motives to women selling gender-equality issues than they would to men selling these issues on behalf of women" (p.1479).

The role of corporate strategies should be incorporated with implementing the gender equality in order to provide identical opportunities in the workforce. Generally speaking, widely accepted dedication to gender equality is deficient, because of continuous modifications in the market place and its environment, although strengthening the position of certain group of women, might be unfavorable to others. V. Recommendations

Gender equality all over the decades is considered as an ambition, a vision, and maybe a soon to become a reality apprehended by many working women. Gender equality is the objective that can be accomplished neither by public in general nor by the individual, in order to initiate proper gender equality in the workplace, there is an assignment that must be commenced by both sides functioning on mutual interests.

As stated above, gender equality and the renovation of gender standards, is requiring total participation. Implementation of laws and policies promoting anti-discriminatory practices are significant but still in most of cases not as much as necessary. Renovation of gender standards requests to take place on individual involvement, within communities and families. This also strive for a local national but also an international institutions involvement at large (United Nations Population Fund , 2010).

Legislative principles of equal rights for men and women and protection of women's special roles and interests including rights to give equal contribution in politics, culture and education, labor market, property, personal and family life should be established in legal system and constitution of a country. A good example of developing country that was affected by transition to market oriented economy is China, with establishment of a legal system with the Constitution as its basis and the Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Women's Rights and Interests as its main part; it includes some 10 pieces of legislation, more than 40 administrative laws and regulations and over 80 local laws and regulations guaranteeing women's rights and interests. (China publishes white paper on human rights, 1995).

While legal framework for gender equality in developed countries is reasonably well-developed, accomplishing fairness in practice, particularly in cost-effective conditions, has demonstrated as very complicated task. Gender equality requires most suitable and reasonable treatment in relationships between women and men, taking into consideration all positive and negative aspects, differences and similarities in order to achieve the best solution for this universal problem.

Non-governmental organizations are an significant instrument for identifying and alleviating troubles concerning gender discrimination at the grassroots level. Their effort are important in providing adequate mechanisms for information sharing, network establishment and implementation of the gender advocacy. Since the situation of women has been historically measured against predominated male standards proposals concerning gender equality with influence of NGO's in a socially responsible environment are:

1. Improvement of access of women to spheres of influence traditionally dominated by men and persuade them to allocate responsibility in female dominated region. This also engages overcoming different stereotypes and prejudices eliminating discriminatory obstructions which stop individuals from recognizing their own potentials in all aspects of life. 2. Correction of underestimated activities where females prevail. It calls for equal assessment of the customs in which women diverse from men, with high respect to their own rights and alternatives given to every human being. A good practice of this will help in supporting a better sharing of society's costs and benefits (Federal-Provincial/Territorial Ministers Responsible for the Status of Women ,1997).

3. Each corporation could be considered as ethical instrument with the responsibility to approve gender equality as priority to their corporate citizenship and social responsibility.

It could be also useful to look alternatives for some new cost-effective partnerships between large companies and small businesses that provide women with desirable flexibility and legitimacy in a workforce (Thompson, 2008).VI. Conclusion

Gender equality lead to the idea that all human beings, both men and women, are free to build up their personal capabilities and make different individual choices. All these is possible but there are most common limitations in attaining this idea, settled by cultural stereotypes, inflexible positions due to access to education and many prejudices in the area of professional development. The purpose of this group paper was to explore those limitations in developed countries and find the best possible recommendation for gender equality.

Legal protection of womens equal rights is essential, and should be the most basic way for the society to respect women. Especially in the developing countries legal protection can lead social and working communities to recognize the importance of gender equality.

Beside establishing well performing legal system there are many other steps women individually or group oriented could obtain in order to become successful and provide the best opportunities for themselves. Gender equality leads to an increased numbers of females in the workplace. The influential role of gender equality on economic growth is most directly demonstrated in the involvement of women in the labor force. Gender equality within a workforce is a process that requires a lot of time and cannot be attained overnight but in modern society and developed countries there are well defined actions particularly focused on reducing the discrimination between women and men. Beside crucial stance following legislatives and laws against discrimination, our recommendations were involvement of non government organizations, improved access to education, correction of overall societal behavior and corporate responsibility and sensibility towards women's rights.References

Schalkwyk, J. (2000, June) . Culture, gender equality and development cooperation. Canadian International Development Agency (Cida),5 p.

Wallace, M., & Leicht, K. T. (2004, February). Culture wars in the workplace? : Cultural antecedents of workers' job entitlement, Work and Occupations, 31 (1) , 3-37.

The Lancet. (2010, June). Gender equity is the key to maternal and child health (Editorial) , 375(9730), 1939.

Hiller, V. ( 2008, October). Gender inequality, endogenous cultural norms and economic development, (Preliminary Draft) . Centre dEconomie de la Sorbonne, Paris

Jacobs, P., & Schain, L.(2008, October) . Professional women: the continuing struggle for acceptance and equality, Journal of Academic and Business Ethics,98-111

UNESCO (1982). Culture. Normative Action. Mexico City Declaration on Cultural Policies. World Conference on Cultural Policies. Retrieved from http://www.unesco.org/culture/laws/mexico/html_eng/page1.shtml

Berik,G., Rodgers, Y.M. & Seguino S. (2009, July).Feminist economics of inequality,development, and growth, Feminist Economics, 15(3), 33 p.

Subrahmanian, R. (2005, June). Gender equality in education: Definitions and measurements , International Journal of Educational Development,25(4), 395-407

Veeck, A.,Flurry, L.A, & Jiang N. (2003). Equal dreams: The one child policy and the consumption of education in Urban China, Consumption, Markets and Culture, 6(1), 8194

Federal-Provincial/Territorial Ministers Responsible for the Status of Women(1997). Economic

Gender Equality Indicators. ISBN 0-662-26159-3, 71 p.

Wach H. & Reeves H. (2000, February). Gender and Development: Facts and Figures.

ISBN 1 85864 382 1, 44 p.

United Nations Population Fund (2010). State of world population 2010, from conflict and crisis to renewal: generations of change, ISBN 978-0-89714-974-7, 116 p.

United Nations Population Fund (2000). The state of world population 2010, Lives together

worlds apart [Press Summary], 4 p.

Melnick V. L. (2005), Her Story: A Continuing Struggle to Reach Gender

Equity, The Role of Women in World Peace & The Role of Men and Boys in Gender Equity, Womens Studies Review, 58-68Tyson L.D. (March 11, 2011). Education and Women in the Labor Market, [Blog Article] Retrieved from http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/11/women-and-their-wages/Escriche, L., Pons, E. (June 14, 2009). Who moves up the career ladder? A model of gender differences in job promotion [Preliminary draft], 27 p.Bureau of Labor Statistics, (June, 2010). Highlights of Womens Earnings in 2009. U.S. [Report 1025], 90 p.

OECD, (2010). LMF5: Gender Pay Gaps for Full-time Workers and Earnings Differentials by Educational Attainment, Retrieved from http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/29/63/38752746.pdf

Catalyst, (2011). Womens Earnings and Income. Retrieved from http://www.catalyst.org/publication/217/womens-earnings-and-income

Bureau for Gender Equality , (2005). Gender Equality and Decent Work, Good Practices at the Workplace, International Labour Office (ILO), 121 p.

Piderit S.K., Ashford S.J., (2003). Breaking Silence: Tactical Choices Women Managers Make in Speaking Up About Gender-Equity Issues, Journal of Management Studies 40:6, 1477-1502

Thompson, L.J. (2008, January). Gender equity and corporate social responsibility in a post-feminist era, Business Ethics: A European Review, 17(1), 87-106

International Comparison (2011) . Gender Equality, Retrieved from http://international-comparison.quarryvillage.org/intl_comp_files/sheet008.htmBlumenstein R. (2011, April). A Blueprint for Change, A Wall Street Journal Report, Retreived from http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704415104576250900113069980.htmlIn The Public Interest. (2009, June 29). Chinadaily.com.cn. Retrieved from LexisNexis Academic database.

Chinamoves toboost status of women as U.N. world conference approaches. (1995, August 8). The Toronto Star. Pg. A14. Retrieved from LexisNexis Academic database.China publishes "white paper" on human rights; Text of White Paper on human rights 1995BBC Summary of World Broadcasts, Retrieved from LexisNexis Academic database.

GREEN: Countries ranking first or second in statistic RED: Countries ranking last or second to last in statistic

11