8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

1/47

NFCRohzbj \zfzb| Ncqbpogboz Fllcrozf`hihzx Caahlb

Pbtcpz zc Lconpb||hcofi Pbvrb|zbp|

LCPTCPFZB LPHGB

JCK Mf| Zfebo \zbt|zc @bzzbp Zpfle Hz| R|bca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhcoFnpbbgboz|) `rz\mcrij Bqfirfzb

Baablzhqbob||

Jblbg`bp 0448

NFC'64'664

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

2/47

^mfz NFC Acroj

Rohzbj \zfzb| Ncqbpogboz Fllcrozf`hihzx Ca

^mx NFC Jhj Zmh| \zrjx

Mhnmihnmz|Fllcrozf`hihzx Hozbnphzx Pbihf`hihzx

Jblbg`bp 0448

LCPTCPFZB LPHGB

JCK Mf| Zfebo \zbt| zc @bzzbp Zpfle Hz| R|b caJbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz|) `rz\mcrij Bqfirfzb Baablzhqbob||Mhnmihnmz| ca NFC'64'664) f pbtcpz zc

lconpb||hcofi pbvrb|zbp|

Pblboz lf|b| ca lcptcpfzb apfrjfoj gh|gfofnbgboz mbhnmzbo zmbJbtfpzgboz ca Kr|zhlb| -JCK( obbjzc fttpctphfzbix troh|m foj jbzbplcptcpfzb lphgb/ Pblbozix) JCK mf|gfjb gcpb r|b ca jbabppbjtpc|blrzhco foj oco'tpc|blrzhcofnpbbgboz| -JTF| foj OTF|() ho~mhlm tpc|blrzcp| gfx pbvrhpblcgtfox pbacpg) fgcon czmbpzmhon|) ho b}lmfonb acp jbabpphontpc|blrzhco/ Ho Krob foj Ocqbg`bp0448) NFC zb|zhahbj co JCK| r|bfoj cqbp|hnmz ca JTF| foj OTF|)foj zmh| pbtcpz jh|lr||b| fjjhzhcofiahojhon|) holirjhon -6( zmb b}zboz zc~mhlm JCK mf| r|bj JTF| fojOTF| zc fjjpb|| lcptcpfzbgh|lcojrlz foj zpfle| r|b ca zmb|bfnpbbgboz|) -0( zmb b}zboz zc ~mhlmJCK gbf|rpb| zmb baablzhqbob|| caJTF| foj OTF|) foj -

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

3/47

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

4/47

Zf`ib|

Zf`ib 6; Org`bp ca Lcptcpfzb Lphghofi Tpc|blrzhco| zc Bflm JTFcp OTF Bozbpbj hozc `x R\FC| foj zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hcoapcg Ah|lfi Xbfp 044: zc Ah|lfi Xbfp 0448 61

Zf`ib 0; Org`bp ca JTF| foj OTF| Bozbpbj hozc `x Bflm R/\/ Fzzcpobx| Caahlb -R\FC(

Zf`ib

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

5/47

Tfnb 6 NFC'64'664

Rohzbj \zfzb| Ncqbpogboz Fllcrozf`hihzx Caahlb^f|mhonzco) JL 042:=

Jblbg`bp 6=) 0448

Lconpb||hcofi Pbvrb|zbp|

Fllcpjhon zc zmb Jbtfpzgboz ca Kr|zhlb -JCK() cob ca hz| lmhba gh||hco| h|zc bo|rpb zmb hozbnphzx ca zmb ofzhco| `r|hob|| cpnfoh{fzhco| foj tpczblzzmb tr`ihl apcg lcptcpfzb lcpprtzhco/ Ho ihnmz ca zmh| ncfi) JCK mf|tpc|blrzbj lcgtfox b}blrzhqb| foj bgticxbb|) f| ~bii f| lcgtfohb|zmbg|biqb|) acp lphgb| |rlm f| zf} bqf|hco) |blrphzhb| apfrj) mbfizm lfpbapfrj) foj `ph`bpx ca acpbhno caahlhfi|) fgcon czmbp hiibnfi flzhqhzhb|/

Mc~bqbp) cqbp zmb tf|z jblfjb) JCK mf| pblcnoh{bj zmb tczbozhfiixmfpgari baablz| zmfz lphghofiix tpc|blrzhon f lcgtfox lfo mfqb cohoqb|zcp|) bgticxbb|) tbo|hcobp|) foj lr|zcgbp| ~mc ~bpb rohoqciqbj hozmb lcgtfox| lphghofi `bmfqhcp/ Ho tfpzhlrifp) zmb afhirpb ca zmbfllcrozhon ahpg Fpzmrp Fojbp|bo) foj zmb f||clhfzbj ic|| ca zmcr|foj| cakc`| aciic~hon hz| hojhlzgboz foj lcoqhlzhco acp c`|zprlzhco ca kr|zhlb acpjb|zpcxhon Bopco'pbifzbj pblcpj|)6 mf| `bbo caabpbj f| f tphgb b}fgtib cazmb tczbozhfiix mfpgari baablz| ca lphghofiix tpc|blrzhon f lcgtfox/ Zcfqchj |bphcr| mfpg zc hooclboz zmhpj tfpzhb| foj f| fo fizbpofzhqb zclphghofi tpc|blrzhco cp jblihohon zc tpc|blrzb) JCK nrhjfolb fiic~|tpc|blrzcp| zc obnczhfzb fnpbbgboz|pbabppbj zc f| jbabppbj tpc|blrzhco-JTF( foj oco'tpc|blrzhco -OTF( fnpbbgboz|/ Zmb|b fnpbbgboz| gfxpbvrhpb lcgtfohb| zc ho|zhzrzb cp pbacpg lcptcpfzb bzmhl| foj lcgtihfolbtpcnpfg|)0 tfx pb|zhzrzhco zc qhlzhg|) foj lcctbpfzb ~hzm conchonhoqb|zhnfzhco| ca hojhqhjrfi| ho b}lmfonb acp tpc|blrzcp| jbabpphon zmbjblh|hco zc tpc|blrzb/ F| tfpz ca JTF| foj OTF|) tpc|blrzcp| gfx fi|cpbvrhpb f lcgtfox zc mhpb) fz hz| c~o b}tbo|b) fo hojbtbojboz gcohzcp zccqbp|bb zmb lcgtfox| lcgtihfolb ~hzm zmb fnpbbgboz/ JCK fojlcgtfohb| mfqb nbobpfiix ~cpebj zcnbzmbp zc |biblz gcohzcp|) `rz JCKibfqb| hz rt zc zmb lcgtfox zc bozbp hozc f lcozpflz ~hzm f gcohzcp zmfz|tblhahb| zmb gcohzcp| abb|) fgcon czmbp zmhon|/

6Zmb lcoqhlzhco ~f| rizhgfzbix cqbpzrpobj `x zmb \rtpbgb Lcrpz/Fpzmrp Fojbp|bo IIT q/

Rohzbj \zfzb|) 2:: R/\/ 181 -0442(/ Ho f rofohgcr| jblh|hco) zmb Lcrpz mbij zmfz zmb krpxho|zprlzhco| r|bj zc lcoqhlz Fpzmrp Fojbp|bo ~bpb hgtbpgh||h`ix aif~bj/Hj/ fz >42'4>/

0Zmb R/\/ \bozbolhon Nrhjbihob| jbahob f lcgtihfolb foj bzmhl| tpcnpfg f| f tpcnpfg

jb|hnobj zc tpbqboz foj jbzblz lphghofi lcojrlz/R/\/ \bozbolhon Nrhjbihob| Gforfi =@0/6 lgz/ o/6/

JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz|

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

6/47

JCK qhb~| JTF| foj OTF| f| fttpctphfzb zcci| zc r|b ho lf|b| ~mbpb zmbncfi| ca troh|mhon foj jbzbpphon lphghofi `bmfqhcp) tpcqhjhon pb|zhzrzhco zcqhlzhg|) foj pbacpghon czmbp~h|b if~'f`hjhon lcgtfohb| lfo `b flmhbqbj~hzmcrz lphghofi tpc|blrzhco/ Zmb r|b ca zmb|b fnpbbgboz| foj zmbf||clhfzbj gcohzcp|) mc~bqbp) h| ocz ~hzmcrz jb`fzb/ \cgb lcggbozfzcp|qhb~ zmb r|b ca JTF| foj OTF| f| bolcrpfnhon jh|pb|tblz acp zmb if~ fojafhihon zc jbzbp lcptcpfzb lphgb) foj czmbp| mfqb |rnnb|zbj f obbj zcbqfirfzb zmb baablzhqbob|| ca JTF| foj OTF| f| f zcci zc lcg`fz |rlmlphgb/ Arpzmbp) lcggbozfzcp| mfqb fleoc~ibjnbj gcohzcp| qfirb hobo|rphon lcgtfox lcgtihfolb ~hzm zmb zbpg| ca JTF| foj OTF| foj hoho|zhzrzhon lcptcpfzb pbacpg) `rz mfqb fi|c tchozbj zc lmfiibonb|

f||clhfzbj ~hzm gcohzcp|mht|) |rlm f| lcolbpo| pbnfpjhon tczbozhfiafqcphzh|g ho zmb gcohzcp |biblzhco tpclb|| foj vrb|zhco| f`crz gcohzcpfllcrozf`hihzx) cqbp|hnmz) foj lc|z|/ Ho fjjhzhco) gbg`bp| ca Lconpb||mfqb b}tpb||bj hozbpb|z ho rojbp|zfojhon zmb pcib ca lcrpz| ho |biblzhongcohzcp| foj czmbp f|tblz| ca JTF| foj OTF|/

Nhqbo zmb jh|lr||hco |rppcrojhon zmb|b fnpbbgboz|) zmb \r`lcgghzzbb coLcggbplhfi foj Fjghoh|zpfzhqb If~) Lcgghzzbb co zmb Krjhlhfpx) Mcr|bca Pbtpb|bozfzhqb|) f|ebj r| zc zb|zhax ho Krob 0448 co JCK| r|b fojcqbp|hnmz ca JTF| foj OTF|)< foj ho Ocqbg`bp 0448 co h||rb| pbifzbj zczmb |biblzhco foj r|b ca hojbtbojboz gcohzcp| ho JTF| foj OTF|/ : ^bpbtcpzbj zmfz JCK jbzbpghobj ~mbzmbp cp ocz zc r|b JTF| foj OTF|) foj~mfz zmb zbpg| ca zmb|b fnpbbgboz| |mcrij `b) `f|bj co JCK| Tpholhtib|ca Abjbpfi Tpc|blrzhco ca @r|hob|| Cpnfoh{fzhco|)2 f| ~bii f| czmbp aflzcp|

^b acroj zmfz tpc|blrzcp| mfj fjmbpbjzc zmb Gcpacpj Gbgc nrhjfolb ho |biblzhon gcohzcp| pbvrhpbj rojbpfnpbbgboz| bozbpbj hozc `bz~bbo Gfplm 044= foj \btzbg`bp 0448/Mc~bqbp) ~b fi|c acroj zmfz tpc|blrzcp| cp zmb Caahlb ca zmb JbtrzxFzzcpobx Nbobpfi -CJFN( ~bpb ocz ariix jclrgbozhon zmb |zbt| zmbx zccezc |biblz gcohzcp|) foj ~b pblcggbojbj zmfz zmb Jbtrzx FzzcpobxNbobpfi fjctz hozbpofi tpclbjrpb| zc jclrgboz `czm zmb tpclb|| r|bj foj

pbf|co| acp gcohzcp |biblzhco jblh|hco| zc fqchj zmb fttbfpfolb caafqcphzh|g foj ho|zhii tr`ihl lcoahjbolb ho gcohzcp |biblzhco/ Ho Frnr|z0448) JCK b|zf`ih|mbj |rlm tpclbjrpb|/

If|zix) ~b pbtcpzbj zmfz lcgtfohb| ~b |tceb ~hzm hjbozhahbj lcolbpo|f`crz zmb gcohzcp| lc|z) |lctb) foj fgcroz ca ~cpe lcgtibzbj) foj zmfzJCK mfj ocz libfpix lcggrohlfzbj zc lcgtfohb| hz| pcib ho fjjpb||hon|rlm lcolbpo|/ Nhqbo zmfz JCK pbihb| co gcohzcp| zc f||b|| lcgtfohb|lcgtihfolb ~hzm JTF| foj OTF|) libfpix lcggrohlfzhon zc lcgtfohb| zmbpcib JCK ~hii tifx ho fjjpb||hon lcgtfohb| jh|trzb| ~hzm gcohzcp| ~crijmbit holpbf|b f~fpbob|| fgcon lcgtfohb| foj `bzzbp tc|hzhco JCK zc `boczhahbj ca tczbozhfi h||rb| pbifzbj zc gcohzcp tbpacpgfolb/ ^bpblcggbojbj ho crp Ocqbg`bp 0448 zb|zhgcox zmfz zmb Fzzcpobx Nbobpfijhpblz fii ihzhnfzhon lcgtcoboz| foj R/\/ Fzzcpobx| Caahlb| zc b}tifho hobflm lcptcpfzb JTF cp OTF ~mfz pcib JCK lcrij tifx ho pb|ciqhon |rlmjh|trzb|) nhqbo zmb aflz| foj lhplrg|zfolb| ca zmb lf|b/=

>Jbtrzx Fzzcpobx Nbobpfi Lpfhn Gcpacpj) JCK)\biblzhco foj R|b ca Gcohzcp| ho Jbabppbj

Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz| foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz| ~hzm Lcptcpfzhco| -Gfp/ >)044=(/ Zmb Gcpacpj Gbgc pbvrhpb| R/\/ Fzzcpobx| Caahlb| foj czmbp JCK ihzhnfzhco jhqh|hco|

zc b|zf`ih|m fj'mcl cp |zfojhon lcgghzzbb|) lco|h|zhon ca zmb caahlb| bzmhl| fjqh|cp)lphghofi cp |blzhco lmhba) foj fz ibf|z cob czmbp b}tbphbolbj tpc|blrzcp) zc lco|hjbp zmblfojhjfzb|~mhlm gfx `b tpctc|bj `x bhzmbp tpc|blrzcp|) lcgtfohb|) cp `czmacp bflmgcohzcp|mht/ JCK lcgtcoboz| fpb fi|c pbghojbj zc aciic~ abjbpfi lcoaihlz'ca'hozbpb|znrhjbihob| foj zc lmble gcohzcp lfojhjfzb| acp tczbozhfi lcoaihlz|'ca'hozbpb|z pbifzhco|mht|~hzm zmb lcgtfox/ Ho fjjhzhco) zmb ofgb| ca fii |biblzbj gcohzcp| gr|z `b |r`ghzzbj zc zmbCaahlb ca zmb Jbtrzx Fzzcpobx Nbobpfi -CJFN( acp ahofi fttpcqfi/

=JCK jhj ocz lcggboz f| zc ~mbzmbp zmbx fnpbbj cp jh|fnpbbj ~hzm zmh| pblcggbojfzhco)

`rz tpcqhjbj zblmohlfi lcggboz| pbifzbj zc zmb pblcggbojfzhco) ~mhlm ~b holcptcpfzbjho zmb |zfzbgboz f| fttpctphfzb/

Tfnb : NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

9/47

Ho zmh| pbtcpz) ~b jh|lr|| fjjhzhcofi ahojhon| |holb crp zb|zhgcohb| cof|tblz| pbifzbj zc JCK| r|b foj cqbp|hnmz ca JTF| foj OTF| foj zmb pcibca zmb krjhlhfpx) holirjhon; -6( zmb b}zboz zc ~mhlm JCK mf| r|bj JTF| fojOTF| zc fjjpb|| lcptcpfzb gh|lcojrlz foj zpfle| hz| r|b ca zmb|bfnpbbgboz|) -0( ~mbzmbp foj mc~ JCK gbf|rpb| zmb b}zboz zc ~mhlm JTF|foj OTF| mfqb lcozph`rzbj zc JCK| baacpz| zc lcg`fz lcptcpfzb lphgb)foj -) 02

8Zmh| fnpbbgboz ~f| |bfibj `x cpjbp ca zmb lcrpz/ ^b c`zfhobj f JCK tpb|| pbibf|b

jb|lph`hon zmb ebx zbpg| ho zmb fnpbbgboz/

64mzzt;##~~~/if~/qhpnhohf/bjr#mzgi#ih`pfpx|hzb#nfppbzzS`xlcgtfox/mzg5

mzzt;##if~tpcab||cp|/zxtbtfj/lcg#~mhzblciifplphgbS`icn#jbabppbjStpc|blrzhcoSfnpbbgboz|#5 mzzt;##~~~/lcptcpfzblphgbpbtcpzbp/lcg#jbabppbjpbtcpz/mzg/

Tfnb 2 NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

http://www.law.virginia.edu/html/librarysite/garrett_bycompany.htmhttp://lawprofessors.typepad.com/whitecollarcrime_blog/deferred_prosecution_agreements/http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/whitecollarcrime_blog/deferred_prosecution_agreements/http://www.corporatecrimereporter.com/deferredreport.htmhttp://www.corporatecrimereporter.com/deferredreport.htmhttp://lawprofessors.typepad.com/whitecollarcrime_blog/deferred_prosecution_agreements/http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/whitecollarcrime_blog/deferred_prosecution_agreements/http://www.law.virginia.edu/html/librarysite/garrett_bycompany.htm

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

10/47

~bpb lcgtibzbj fnpbbgboz| zmfz pbvrhpbj lcgtfohb| zc ho|zhzrzb fo bzmhl|cp lcgtihfolb tpcnpfg/ Ho fjjhzhco) 62 ca zmb 02 lcgtfohb| ~bpb pbvrhpbjzc mhpb fo hojbtbojboz gcohzcp5 ~b hozbpqhb~bj cp c`zfhobj ~phzzbopb|tco|b| apcg ibnfi pbtpb|bozfzhqb| cp lcgtihfolb caahlhfi| acp 04 cazmb|b 02 lcgtfohb| ~mc mfj eoc~ibjnb ca zmb JTF foj OTF tpclb||)66foj hozbpqhb~bj 66 ca zmb|b gcohzcp|/60 Ho fjjhzhco) ~b pbqhb~bj JCKnrhjfolb pbnfpjhon zmb tpc|blrzhco ca `r|hob|| bozhzhb| foj |tceb zc JCKmbfjvrfpzbp| caahlhfi| holirjhon \bohcp Lcro|bi zc zmb Caahlb ca zmb JbtrzxFzzcpobx Nbobpfi) F||clhfzb Jbtrzx Fzzcpobx Nbobpfi) Jbtrzx F||h|zfozFzzcpobx Nbobpfi acp zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco) \bohcp Lcro|bi zc zmbF||h|zfoz Fzzcpobx Nbobpfi acp zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco) Lphghofi Jhqh|hco

Apfrj \blzhco Lmhba) foj ^mhzb Lciifp Lphgb Lccpjhofzcp acp BCR\Fpbnfpjhon tcihlhb| foj tpclbjrpb| pbifzbj zc zmb r|b foj cqbp|hnmz ca JTF|foj OTF|/ \holb ~b |biblzbj f ocotpc`f`hihzx |fgtib ca JCK caahlhfi|)lcgtfox pbtpb|bozfzhqb|) foj gcohzcp| zc hozbpqhb~) zmb hoacpgfzhco ~bc`zfhobj h| ocz nbobpfih{f`ib zc fii JCK ihzhnfzhon lcgtcoboz|) R/\/Fzzcpobx| Caahlb|) lcgtfohb|) foj gcohzcp| hoqciqbj ho JTF| foj OTF|/6

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

11/47

fnpbbgboz| bozbpbj hozc `bz~bbo ah|lfi xbfp| 044: foj 0448/ F| jh|lr||bjf`cqb) ~b hjbozhahbj zmb JTF| foj OTF| bozbpbj hozc jrphon zmh| zhgbtbphcj apcg JCK jfzf) flfjbghl tftbp|) foj ^b` |hzb |bfplmb|/ ^bc`zfhobj jfzf co zmb org`bp ca lf|b| ahibj fnfho|z `r|hob|| bozhzhb| `xR\FC| foj zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco apcg BCR\F| Ibnfi Hoacpgfzhco CaahlbObz~cpe \x|zbg -IHCO\() foj zmb Jhqh|hco| Frzcgfzbj Lf|b Zpflehon\x|zbg -FLZ\(/ Zmb jfzf co zmb org`bp ca lf|b| ahibj fnfho|z `r|hob||bozhzhb| zmfz ~b c`zfhobj apcg zmb|b jfzf`f|b| holirjbj `czm lcptcpfzblphghofi tpc|blrzhco| foj JTF| bozbpbj hozc `x zmb R\FC| foj zmbLphghofi Jhqh|hco/ Acp bflm ah|lfi xbfp) ~b lcgtrzbj zmb org`bp calcptcpfzb lphghofi tpc|blrzhco| `x |r`zpflzhon crp lcroz| ca zmb org`bp

ca JTF| bozbpbj hozc `x fii zmb R\FC| foj zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco apcgIHCO\ foj FLZ\ jfzf co zmb org`bp ca lf|b| ahibj fnfho|z `r|hob||bozhzhb|/ ^b lcoahpgbj ~hzm BCR\F foj zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco zmfz crplcgtrzfzhco| ~bpb fllrpfzb/ ^b fi|c pbqhb~bj jclrgbozfzhco acp IHCO\foj FLZ\) foj |tceb ~hzm jfzf |tblhfih|z| ho BCR\F foj zmb LphghofiJhqh|hco pbnfpjhon mc~ lf|b| hoqciqhon lcptcpfzb bozhzhb| fpb pblcpjbj hobflm |x|zbg/ ^b jbzbpghobj zmfz zmb jfzf ~bpb |raahlhbozix pbihf`ib acp crptrptc|b|/ ^b fi|c pbqhb~bj jclrgbozfzhco co) foj |tceb zc hoacpgfzhcozblmocicnx |tblhfih|z| ho) JCK| Kr|zhlb Gfofnbgboz Jhqh|hco pbnfpjhonJCK| tifo| acp zpflehon JTF| foj OTF| ho f lf|b gfofnbgboz |x|zbglrppbozix rojbp jbqbictgboz acp JCK| ihzhnfzhon lcgtcoboz|) holirjhon fiizmb R\FC|/ ^b lcgtfpbj JCK| zpflehon tpclbjrpb| ~hzm lphzbphf ho|zfojfpj| acp hozbpofi lcozpci ho zmb abjbpfi ncqbpogboz/62

Zc f||b|| mc~ JCK gbf|rpb| zmb b}zboz zc ~mhlm JTF| foj OTF| mfqblcozph`rzbj zc JCK| baacpz| zc lcg`fz lcptcpfzb lphgb) ~b pbqhb~bjJCK| 044>'0460 \zpfzbnhl Tifo foj zmb lcppb|tcojhon Tbpacpgfolb fojFllcrozf`hihzx Pbtcpz| acp ah|lfi xbfp| 044> zmpcrnm 0448 foj Flzhqhzhb|Pbtcpz| acp JCK| Lphghofi Jhqh|hco Apfrj \blzhco acp ah|lfi xbfp| 044>foj 044=/61 ^b fi|c |tceb ~hzm \bohcp Lcro|bi zc zmb CJFN pbnfpjhon zmb|zfzr| ca JCK| baacpz| zc gbf|rpb zmb baablzhqbob|| ca JTF| foj OTF|)foj ~hzm zmb |fgb |biblzbj lcgtfox pbtpb|bozfzhqb| foj gcohzcp| ~blcozflzbj zc fjjpb|| fii crp c`kblzhqb| pbnfpjhon zmbhp tbp|tblzhqb| co

62NFC)Hozbpofi Lcozpci; \zfojfpj| acp Hozbpofi Lcozpci ho zmb Abjbpfi Ncqbpogboz)

NFC#FHGJ'44'06/ NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO/AIMD-00-21.3.1http://www.gao.gov/cgi-bin/getrpt?GAO/AIMD-00-21.3.1

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

12/47

mc~ zmb baablzhqbob|| ca zmb|b zcci| ghnmz `b|z `b gbf|rpbj/6> ^blcgtfpbj JCK| lrppboz gbf|rpbgboz tpflzhlb| ~hzm zmb pbvrhpbgboz| cazmb Ncqbpogboz Tbpacpgfolb foj Pb|riz| Flz ca 688 \zfz/ 0=2/

68NFC#FHGJ'44'06/

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

13/47

c`kblzhqb|) f| ~bii f| cob ca zmb z~c pbzhpbj R/\/ gfnh|zpfzb krjnb| ~mcmfj cqbp|bbo JTF| foj zmb Lmfhp ca zmb Krjhlhfi Lcoabpbolb Lcgghzzbbco Lphghofi If~/00

^b lcojrlzbj zmh| tbpacpgfolb frjhz apcg \btzbg`bp 044= zc Jblbg`bp0448 ho fllcpjfolb ~hzm nbobpfiix fllbtzbj ncqbpogboz frjhzhon|zfojfpj|/ Zmc|b |zfojfpj| pbvrhpb zmfz ~b tifo foj tbpacpg zmb frjhz zcc`zfho |raahlhboz) fttpctphfzb bqhjbolb zc tpcqhjb f pbf|cof`ib `f|h| acpcrp ahojhon| foj lcolir|hco| `f|bj co crp frjhz c`kblzhqb|/ ^b `bihbqbzmfz zmb bqhjbolb c`zfhobj tpcqhjb| f pbf|cof`ib `f|h| acp crp ahojhon|foj lcolir|hco| `f|bj co crp c`kblzhqb|/

@flenpcroj

Aflzcp| Lco|hjbpbj ^mboR|hon foj \bzzhon zmbZbpg| ca JTF| foj OTF|

F| tfpz ca hz| gh||hco zc jbaboj zmb hozbpb|z| ca zmb Rohzbj \zfzb|) JCKlcozpci| fii lphghofi tpc|blrzhco| ho ~mhlm zmb Rohzbj \zfzb| mf| fohozbpb|z) holirjhon zmc|b fnfho|z lcptcpfzhco|/ Tpc|blrzcp| jblh|hco| cohoqb|zhnfzhon) lmfpnhon) foj obnczhfzhon f tibf cp czmbp fnpbbgboz ~hzmpb|tblz zc lcptcpfzb lphgb| fpb nrhjbj `x JCK| Tpholhtib| ca AbjbpfiTpc|blrzhco ca @r|hob|| Cpnfoh{fzhco|) ~mhlm ho|zprlz tpc|blrzcp| zclco|hjbp ohob aflzcp| ~mbo jbzbpghohon mc~ zc zpbfz f lcptcpfzhco|r|tblzbj ca lphghofi gh|lcojrlz foj tpcqhjb nrhjfolb co ~mbo zmb ohobaflzcp| gc|z fttpctphfzbix fttix/ Zmb tpholhtib| fi|c tpcqhjb f org`bp caflzhco| tpc|blrzcp| gfx zfeb pbnfpjhon f lcptcpfzhco) holirjhon jblihohonzc tpc|blrzb) bozbphon hozc f JTF cp OTF) cp lphghofiix tpc|blrzhon zmblcptcpfzhco/ Fllcpjhon zc zmb tpholhtib|) JTF| foj OTF| fpb fo hgtcpzfozfizbpofzhqb zc jblihohon tpc|blrzhco fnfho|z f lcptcpfzhco foj c`zfhohonzmb lcoqhlzhco ca f lcgtfox zmpcrnm tpc|blrzhco/ Zmb ohob aflzcp|) fojb}fgtib| ca zmb gfoobp ho ~mhlm zmbx hoairbolb zmb tpc|blrzcp| lmchlb|ca flzhco) fpb |mc~o ho ahnrpb 6 `bic~/ 0

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

14/47

Ahnrpb 6; Mc~ zmb Tpholhtib| ca Abjbpfi Tpc|blrzhco ca @r|hob|| Cpnfoh{fzhco| Hoairbolb Tpc|blrzcp| Jblh|hco| zc JblihobTpc|blrzhco) Bozbp hozc f JTF cp OTF) cp Tpc|blrzb ca zmb caabo|b

Ib|| tbpqf|hqb

Oc mh|zcpx

Ib|| jh|lic|rpb foj lcctbpfzhco

Ib|||bphcr|

Ib||fjbvrfzb

Ib||fjbvrfzb

Ib|| lciifzbpfi lco|bvrbolb|

Ib|| baablzhqb

Ib||flzhco|

Ib|| tbpqf|hqb

Ib|| jh|lic|rpb foj lcctbpfzhco

Ib||fjbvrfzb

Ib||fjbvrfzb

Ib|| lciifzbpfi lco|bvrbolb|

Ib|| baablzhqb

Ib|| tbpqf|hqb

Ib|| jh|lic|rpb foj lcctbpfzhco

Ib||fjbvrfzb

Ib||fjbvrfzb

Ib|| lciifzbpfi lco|bvrbolb|

Ib|| baablzhqb

\crplb; NFC fofix|h| ca JCK.| Tpholhtib| ca Abjbpfi Tpc|blrzhco ca @r|hob|| Cpnfoh{fzhco|/

Lphghofitpc|blrzhcoJblihofzhco

Oco'tpc|blrzhcofnpbbgboz

Jbabppbj tpc|blrzhcofnpbbgboz

Ib|| tbpqf|hqb

Gcpb lcctbpfzhco

Gcpb fjbvrfzb

Gcpb fjbvrfzb

Npbfzbp lco|bvrbolb|

Gcpb baablzhqb

Ib|| mh|zcpx

Ib|||bphcr|

Gcpb flzhco|

Gcpb tbpqf|hqb

Gcpb |bphcr|

Ib|| lcctbpfzhco

Ib||fjbvrfzb

Ib||fjbvrfzb

Ab~bp lco|bvrbolb|

Ib|| baablzhqb

\cgb mh|zcpx

Ab~bp flzhco|Pbgbjhfi flzhco|`

\hghifp gh|lcojrlz

^pconjchon ~hzmholcptcpfzhco

Tpb'b}h|zhonlcgtihfolb tpcnpfg

Tpc|blrzhco capb|tco|h`ib hojhqhjrfi|

Lhqhi cp pbnrifzcpxboacplbgboz flzhco|

Jh|lic|rpb ca ~pcon'jchon foj ~hiihonob||

zc lcctbpfzbf

Lciifzbpfilco|bvrbolb|l

Ofzrpb foj |bphcr|ob||ca zmb caabo|b

f^hiihonob|| zc lcctbpfzb holirjb| lcctbpfzhco ho zmb ncqbpogboz| hoqb|zhnfzhco ca zmb lcgtfox|

fnboz|/

Tfnb 64 NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

15/47

`Pbgbjhfi flzhco| holirjb baacpz| zc hgtibgboz fo baablzhqb lcgtihfolb tpcnpfg cp hgtpcqb fo

b}h|zhon cob) tfx pb|zhzrzhco) cp jh|lhtihob ~pconjcbp|) fgcon czmbp zmhon|/lLciifzbpfi lco|bvrbolb| holirjb jh|tpctcpzhcofzb mfpg zc |mfpbmcijbp|) tbo|hco mcijbp|)bgticxbb|) foj czmbp| ocz tpcqbo tbp|cofiix lritf`ib) foj fox hgtflz co zmb tr`ihl fph|hon apcgtpc|blrzhco/

F| tfpz ca JTF| foj OTF|) lcgtfohb| fpb nbobpfiix pbvrhpbj zc lcgtix~hzm f |bz ca zbpg| acp f |tblhahbj jrpfzhco ho b}lmfonb acp tpc|blrzcp|jbabpphon zmb jblh|hco zc tpc|blrzb cp jblhjhon ocz zc tpc|blrzb/ Zmb|bzbpg| mfqb holirjbj;0:

gcobzfpx tfxgboz||rlm f| pb|zhzrzhco zc qhlzhg| ca zmb lphgb) acpabhzrpbca zmb tpclbbj| ca zmb lphgb) foj gcobzfpx tbofizhb| hgtc|bj `x JCK5

pbvrhpbgboz| zmfz zmb lcgtfox hgtpcqb cp bomfolb hz| lcgtihfolbtpcnpfg5

pbvrhpbgboz| zmfz zmb lcgtfox mhpb) fz hz| c~o b}tbo|b) fo hojbtbojbozgcohzcp zc f||h|z zmb lcgtfox ho b|zf`ih|mhon f lcgtihfolb tpcnpfg)pbqhb~ zmb baablzhqbob|| ca f lcgtfox| hozbpofi lcozpci gbf|rpb|) fojjbzbpghob ~mbzmbp zmb lcgtfox mf| czmbp~h|b gbz zmb zbpg| ca zmbfnpbbgboz| -Zmb fnpbbgboz| zxthlfiix pbvrhpb gcohzcp| zc tbphcjhlfiix|r`ghz ~phzzbo pbtcpz| zc zpfle zmb lcgtfox| tpcnpb|| ho lcgtixhon ~hzmzmb zbpg| ca zmb JTF cp OTF/(5 foj

b}zpfcpjhofpx pb|zhzrzhco tpcqh|hco|) ~mhlm fpb tfxgboz| cp |bpqhlb| zccpnfoh{fzhco| cp hojhqhjrfi| ocz jhpblzix faablzbj `x zmb lphgb/ -JCK h||rbj

nrhjfolb ho Gfx 044=~mhlm ~f| holcptcpfzbj hozc zmb Rohzbj \zfzb|Fzzcpobx| Gforfitpcmh`hzhon zmb r|b ca zbpg| pbvrhphon tfxgboz| zclmfphzf`ib) bjrlfzhcofi) lcggrohzx) cp czmbp cpnfoh{fzhco| cp hojhqhjrfi|zmfz fpb ocz zmb qhlzhg| ca zmb lphghofi flzhqhzx cp fpb ocz tpcqhjhon|bpqhlb| zc pbjpb|| zmb mfpg lfr|bj `x zmb lphghofi lcojrlz/02 Fllcpjhon

0:Ho crp Krob 0448 zb|zhgcox) ~b pbqhb~bj zmb zbpg| ca 2> JTF| foj OTF| zmfz ~b

jh|lr||bj ~hzm tpc|blrzcp| fz zmb 6< JCK caahlb| ~b |biblzbj acp crp |hzb qh|hz| fojhozbpqhb~|/ \bb fttbojh} H acp zmb zbpg| holirjbj ho zmb|b 2> fnpbbgboz|/

02R/\/ Jbtfpzgboz ca Kr|zhlb) Rohzbj \zfzb| Fzzcpobx| Gforfi 8'61/

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

16/47

zc JCK) zmb r|b ca |rlm zbpg| lcrij lpbfzb flzrfi cp tbplbhqbj lcoaihlz| cahozbpb|z cp czmbp bzmhlfi h||rb|/01(

Krjhlhfi Fttpcqfi caJbabppbj Tpc|blrzhco|

OTF| zxthlfiix fpb ocz ahibj ~hzm zmb lcrpz) `rz ho|zbfj fpb gfhozfhobj `xJCK foj zmb lcptcpfzhco/ Co zmb czmbp mfoj) JTF| fpb zxthlfiix ahibj ~hzmzmb lcrpz) ficon ~hzm f jclrgboz zmfz hjbozhahb| zmb lmfpnb| zmfz zmbtpc|blrzhco mf| `pcrnmz fnfho|z zmb lcptcpfzhco/ Zmb \tbbjx Zphfi Flz |bz|zhgb ihghz| acp zmb qfphcr| tmf|b| ca zmb lphghofi kr|zhlb tpclb||acpb}fgtib) f jbabojfoz| zphfi gr|z `bnho ~hzmho >4 jfx| ca lmfpnb| `bhonahibj cp zmb jfzb ~mbo zmb jbabojfoz fttbfpbj `bacpb zmb lcrpz foj

qhcifzhco| ca zmb|b zhgb ihghz| gfx pb|riz ho zmb jh|gh||fi ca zmb lf|b/0>

Mc~bqbp) zmb \tbbjx Zphfi Flz fi|c holirjb| tpcqh|hco| zmfz fiic~ acplbpzfho jbifx| zmfz jc ocz lcroz zc~fpj| zmb flz| zhgb ihghz|/ Rojbp cob cazmb|b tpcqh|hco|) lcrpz| mfqb zmb frzmcphzx zc fttpcqb zmb jbabppfi ca ftpc|blrzhco trp|rfoz zc f ~phzzbo fnpbbgboz `bz~bbo zmb ncqbpogboz fojzmb jbabojfoz/0=

01Fllcpjhon zc zmb R/\/ Fzzcpobx| Gforfi) zmb |blzhco jcb| ocz pb|zphlz zmh| tpflzhlb ho

ihghzbj lhplrg|zfolb|/ Zmb|b holirjb; 6( zmb jbabojfoz| c~o jblh|hco) crz|hjb ca zmblcozb}z ca f tibf fnpbbgboz) jbabppbj tpc|blrzhco fnpbbgboz cp f oco'tpc|blrzhcofnpbbgboz) zc rohifzbpfiix tfx gcohb| zc f lmfphzf`ib) bjrlfzhco) lcggrohzx cp czmbpcpnfoh{fzhco cp hojhqhjrfi5 0( lcggrohzx pb|zhzrzhco tfxgboz| gfjb trp|rfoz zc 6= R/\/L

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

17/47

Zmb Org`bp ca JTF|foj OTF| Mf|Nbobpfiix @bbo Ib||Zmfo zmb Org`bp caLcptcpfzbTpc|blrzhco|) fojJCK Pblbozix @bnfo

Zpflehon Hz| R|b caZmb|b Fnpbbgboz|

JCK| R|b ca JTF| fojOTF| Tbfebj ho Ah|lfiXbfp 044>) Zmbo Jblihobj)foj R\FC| Mfqb R|bjAb~bp JTF| foj OTF|Zmfo LcptcpfzbTpc|blrzhco| ^mhib zmbLphghofi Jhqh|hco Mf|R|bj f`crz zmb \fgbOrg`bp ca Bflm

JCK mf| gfjb gcpb apbvrboz r|b ca JTF| foj OTF| ho pblboz xbfp|)bozbphon hozc acrp fnpbbgboz| ho ah|lfi xbfp 044< lcgtfpbj zc f mhnm ca ) fizmcrnm r|b jblihobj ho ah|lfi xbfp| 044=foj 0448 ~mbo JCK bozbpbj hozc 0: foj 0< fnpbbgboz|) pb|tblzhqbix/Fllcpjhon zc JCK caahlhfi|) zmb jblpbf|b ho zmb r|b ca JTF| foj OTF|lfoocz `b fzzph`rzbj zc fox |tblhahl pbf|co `blfr|b JCK h| f pbflzhqbfnbolx foj b}tbphbolb| airlzrfzhco| ho zmb zxtb| ca lf|b| zmfz cllrp bflmxbfp/ Mc~bqbp) zmb caahlhfi| oczbj zmfz ah|lfi xbfp 044> fttbfpbj zc `b fof`bppfzhco `blfr|b zmb r|b ca JTF| foj OTF| ho ah|lfi xbfp 044> ~f||hnohahlfozix mhnmbp zmfo ho fox czmbp ah|lfi xbfp/ Ahnrpb 0 `bic~ jbthlz|zmb org`bp ca JTF| foj OTF| `x ah|lfi xbfp/

Tfnb 6< NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

18/47

Ahnrpb 0; Org`bp ca JTF| foj OTF| Bozbpbj Hozc `x JCK) tbp Ah|lfi Xbfp

Org`bp ca JTF| foj OTF|

Ah|lfi xbfp

\crplb; NFC fofix|h| ca JCK jfzf/

4

2

64

62

04

02

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

19/47

lcptcpfzb tpc|blrzhco| hz trp|rbj/08 Acp b}fgtib) R\FC| trp|rbj figc|z6= zhgb| gcpb lcptcpfzb tpc|blrzhco| zmfo JTF| foj OTF| apcg ah|lfixbfp| 044: zc 0448/ Acp zmb |fgb zhgb tbphcj) zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hcotrp|rbj 4/8 zhgb| gcpb tpc|blrzhco| zmfo JTF| foj OTF|) cp pfzmbp 6/0zhgb| gcpb JTF| foj OTF| zmfo tpc|blrzhco|/ Fllcpjhon zc LphghofiJhqh|hco caahlhfi|) roiheb zmb R\FC|) zmb org`bp ca JTF| foj OTF| zmbjhqh|hco mf| bozbpbj hozc ~f| |hghifp zc zmb org`bp ca lcptcpfzbtpc|blrzhco| hz lfpphbj crz acp z~c pbf|co|/ Ahp|z) zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hcogcpb cazbo mfojib| lf|b| fnfho|z ifpnbp grizhofzhcofi lcptcpfzhco|gfoxca ~mhlm gfx mfqb abjbpfi lcozpflz|zmfo zmb R\FC| jc/ Tpc|blrzhco ca|rlm lcgtfohb| gfx mfqb |hnohahlfoz lciifzbpfi lco|bvrbolb|) |rlm f| zmb

hof`hihzx zc lcozpflz ~hzm zmb abjbpfi ncqbpogbozf aflzcp tpc|blrzcp| fpbzc lco|hjbp `f|bj co zmb Tpholhtib| ca Abjbpfi Tpc|blrzhco ca @r|hob||Cpnfoh{fzhco| ~mbo jbzbpghohon ~mbzmbp zc bozbp hozc f JTF cp OTFqbp|r| tpc|blrzb/ \blcoj) zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco mfojib| fii lf|b|hoqciqhon qhcifzhco| ca zmb Acpbhno Lcpprtz Tpflzhlb| Flz) foj acp ~mhlm zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hcomf| bozbpbj hozc JTF| zc hgtpcqb lcgtfohb| lcgtihfolb/

08Zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco foj zmb R\FC| fpb pb|tco|h`ib acp cqbp|bbhon lphghofi gfzzbp|

rojbp zmb gcpb zmfo 844 abjbpfi lphghofi |zfzrzb|/ Zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco jbqbict|)

boacplb|) foj |rtbpqh|b| zmb fttihlfzhco ca fii abjbpfi lphghofi if~| b}lbtz zmc|b|tblhahlfiix f||hnobj zc czmbp jhqh|hco|/ Acp ho|zfolb) fllcpjhon zc JCK) zmb LphghofiJhqh|hco mfojib| fii lf|b| hoqciqhon qhcifzhco| ca zmb Acpbhno Lcpprtz Tpflzhlb| Flz) 62R/\/L/ >=g) >=jj'6 zc '=aa/ Zmb R\FC| lcojrlz gc|z ca zmb zphfi ~cpeholirjhonlphghofi lf|b|ho ~mhlm zmb Rohzbj \zfzb| h| f tfpzx/ Czmbp JCK ihzhnfzhon jhqh|hco| zmfzmfqb bozbpbj hozc JTF| cp OTF| |holb ah|lfi xbfp 688< holirjb zmb Fozhzpr|z Jhqh|hco) ~mhlmmf| bozbpbj hozc zmpbb fnpbbgboz|5 zmb Boqhpcogboz foj Ofzrpfi Pb|crplb| Jhqh|hco) ~mhlmmf| bozbpbj hozc z~c fnpbbgboz|5 zmb Ofzhcofi \blrphzx Jhqh|hco) ~mhlm mf| bozbpbj hozccob fnpbbgboz5 foj zmb Zf} Jhqh|hco) ~mhlm mf| bozbpbj hozc z~c fnpbbgboz|/

=g) >=jj'6 zc '=aa/

Tfnb 62 NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

20/47

Zf`ib 6; Org`bp ca Lcptcpfzb Lphghofi Tpc|blrzhco| zc Bflm JTF cp OTF Bozbpbj

hozc `x R\FC| foj zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco apcg Ah|lfi Xbfp 044: zc Ah|lfi Xbfp 0448

R\FC| Lphghofi Jhqh|hco

Ah|lfi xbfp 044:

Tpc|blrzhco|f

08> 2

JTF| foj OTF|`

: 6

Tpc|blrzhco| tbp JTF cp OTF >:/< 2/4

Ah|lfi xbfp 0442

Tpc|blrzhco| 1

Tpc|blrzhco| tbp JTF cp OTF 66/: 6/ NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

32/47

apcg tfpzhlhtfzhon ho tibf `fpnfhohon `bz~bbo z~c tfpzhb| ho f lf|b foj`bihbqbj zmfz obnczhfzhco| cqbp JTF| ~bpb |hghifp zc tibf `fpnfhohon/26

Czmbp| `bihbqbj zmfz jblh|hco| ho zmb JTF tpclb|||rlm f| ~mbzmbp zcbozbp hozc f JTF ho|zbfj ca tpc|blrzb) |bz zmb zbpg| ca zmb fnpbbgboz) cpjbzbpghob ~mbzmbp f lcgtfox mf| lcgtihbj ~hzm cp `pbflmbj fofnpbbgboz~bpb arolzhco| ca zmb b}blrzhqb pfzmbp zmfo zmb krjhlhfi`pfolm/ Acp b}fgtib) cob krjnb oczbj zmfz ha f krjnb jh|fnpbbj ~hzm zmbtpc|blrzcp| jbzbpghofzhco zmfz f lcgtfox mfj lcgtihbj ~hzm zmb JTF)zmb krjnb| frzmcphzx zc pbar|b zmb tpc|blrzcp| pbvrb|z zc jh|gh|| zmbhojhlzgboz foj tpclbbj ~hzm tpc|blrzhco h| rolibfp/ Zmr|) npbfzbp lcrpzhoqciqbgboz ghnmz lpbfzb f tpc`ibg pbifzbj zc zmb |btfpfzhco ca tc~bp|

rojbp zmb Lco|zhzrzhco) f| ~bii f| homh`hz tpc|blrzcp| jh|lpbzhco ho zmbhplf|b|/ Fllcpjhon zc JCK caahlhfi|) JCK jcb| ocz mfqb f tc|hzhco co~mbzmbp npbfzbp krjhlhfi hoqciqbgboz ho zmb JTF tpclb|| lpbfzb||btfpfzhco ca tc~bp| h||rb|5 mc~bqbp) JCK `bihbqb| zmfz krjhlhfihoqciqbgboz ho zmb OTF tpclb|| ~crij lpbfzb lcolbpo| pbifzbj zc zmb|btfpfzhco ca tc~bp| `blfr|b oc krjhlhfi pbqhb~ h| hoqciqbj acp OTF|) f|zmbx zxthlfiix jc ocz hoqciqb lcrpz ahihon|/

zmb fjjhzhcofi zhgb foj tpclb||b| f||clhfzbj ~hzm lcrpz hoqciqbgboz) |rlmf| mbfphon|) ~mhlm gfx |ic~ jc~o zmb JTF tpclb||5 foj

krjnb| ifle ca eoc~ibjnb foj b}tbpzh|b f`crz zmb lf|b cp hz| |r`kblzgfzzbp) |rlm f| zmb ctbpfzhco ca fo boqhpcogbozfi gfofnbgboz |x|zbg fzf ~f|zb~fzbp zpbfzgboz tifoz) ~mhlm tpc|blrzcp| ho zmb lf|b gfx mfqb

|tboz xbfp| jbqbicthon/

Fllcpjhon zc JCK) JTF| foj OTF| lfo `b hoqfirf`ib zcci| acp ahnmzhonlcptcpfzb lcpprtzhco foj mbithon zc pbmf`hihzfzb f lcgtfox) fizmcrnm r|bca zmb|b fnpbbgboz| mf| ocz `bbo ~hzmcrz lcozpcqbp|x) holirjhon vrb|zhco|f`crz zmb baablzhqbob|| ca zmb|b zcci|/ JCK mf| zfebo |bqbpfi |zbt| zc`bzzbp zpfle hz| r|b ca JTF| foj OTF|) |zbt| zmfz ~hii `bzzbp tc|hzhco JCKzc gcpb fllrpfzbix pbtcpz zc Lconpb|| foj zmb tr`ihl co zmb org`bp cab}h|zhon JTF| foj OTF|) zmb crzlcgb ca zmb lf|b|) foj zmb zbpg| ca zmbfnpbbgboz|/ Mc~bqbp) ~mhib JCK mf| |zfzbj zmfz JTF| foj OTF| fpbr|bari zcci| acp lcg`fzhon foj jbzbpphon lcptcpfzb lphgb) ~hzmcrztbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb|) hz ~hii `b jhaahlriz acp JCK zc jbgco|zpfzb zmfzzmb|b fnpbbgboz| fpb baablzhqb fz mbithon zmb jbtfpzgboz flmhbqb zmh| ncfi/Gcjbi| b}h|z zmfz ~crij fiic~ JCK zc lpbfzb |rlm gbf|rpb|) holirjhon

Lcolir|hco|

26Abjbpfi Prib ca Lphghofi Tpclbjrpb 66 |zfzb| zmfz fo fzzcpobx acp zmb ncqbpogboz foj zmb

jbabojfoz| fzzcpobx) cp zmb jbabojfoz ~mbo mb cp |mb jcb| ocz mfqb fo fzzcpobx) gfxjh|lr|| foj pbflm f tibf fnpbbgboz) `rz zmb lcrpz gr|z ocz tfpzhlhtfzb ho zmb|b jh|lr||hco|Abj/ P/ Lphg/ T/ 66-l(-6(/

Tfnb 0= NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

33/47

gbf|rphon ~mbzmbp f lcgtfox pbbonfnb| ho gh|lcojrlz cqbp zmb icon'zbpg cp jrphon zmb lcrp|b ca zmb fnpbbgboz cp ~mbzmbp f lcgtfox|rllb||ariix gbbz| zmb zbpg| ca hz| JTF cp OTF/ @x jbqbicthontbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| zc bqfirfzb JTF| foj OTF|) JCK ~hii `b `bzzbptc|hzhcobj zc nfrnb ~mbzmbp zmbx fpb baablzhqb zcci| ho jbzbpphon fojlcg`fzhon lcptcpfzb lphgb/

Zc f||b|| hz| tpcnpb|| zc~fpj gbbzhon hz| |zpfzbnhl c`kblzhqb ca lcg`fzhontr`ihl foj lcptcpfzb lcpprtzhco) zmb Fzzcpobx Nbobpfi |mcrij jbqbicttbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| zc bqfirfzb zmb lcozph`rzhco ca JTF| foj OTF|

zc~fpj| flmhbqhon zmh| c`kblzhqb/

Co Jblbg`bp 62) 0448) JCK tpcqhjbj ~phzzbo lcggboz| co f jpfaz ca zmh|pbtcpz) ~mhlm ~b jh|lr||bj ~hzm zmb F||clhfzb Jbtrzx Nbobpfi Lcro|bi acpCJFN foj zmb ^mhzb Lciifp Lphgb Lccpjhofzcp acp BCR\F co Jblbg`bp6>) 0448/ JCK fnpbbj ~hzm crp pblcggbojfzhco/ Zmb arii zb}z ca JCK|~phzzbo lcggboz| h| holirjbj ho fttbojh} HHH/

Pblcggbojfzhco acpB}blrzhqb Flzhco

Fnbolx Lcggboz|foj Crp Bqfirfzhco

Ho hz| ibzzbp) JCK |zfzbj zmfz zmb jbtfpzgboz r|b| f qfphbzx ca zcci| zcflmhbqb hz| gh||hco ca tpczblzhon zmb tr`ihl apcg lcptcpfzb lcpprtzhco) fojho |cgb lf|b|) JTF| foj OTF| fpb fttpctphfzb zcci| foj caabp f org`bp ca`bobahz|) |rlm f| zmb fqchjfolb ca obnfzhqb lciifzbpfi lco|bvrbolb| catpc|blrzhco foj lcoqhlzhco zc lcgtfohb| foj hooclboz zmhpj tfpzhb|/

JCK fnpbbj ~hzm crp pblcggbojfzhco zmfz zmb Fzzcpobx Nbobpfi jbqbicttbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| zc bqfirfzb zmb lcozph`rzhco ca JTF| foj OTF|zc~fpj flmhbqhon hz| |zpfzbnhl c`kblzhqb ca lcg`fzhon tr`ihl foj lcptcpfzblcpprtzhco) foj pblcnoh{b| zmb qfirb ca fttpctphfzb tbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb|ho zmh| fpbf/ JCK jhj ocz zmhoe zmfz zmb Ncqbpogboz Tbpacpgfolb fojPb|riz| Flz ca 688< -NTPF( ~f| f pbibqfoz f lphzbphco acp zmb jbqbictgbozca tbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| acp JTF| foj OTF|) |zfzhon zmfz hz pbvrhpb|fnbolhb| zc jbqbict tbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| acp `pcfjbp tpcnpfg flzhqhzhb|)

|rlm f| zmc|b |bz acpzm ho fnbolx `rjnbz|) foj ocz acp zcci| |rlm f| JTF|foj OTF|) ~mhlm fpb r|bj ib|| apbvrbozix foj fpb ofppc~ix jbahobj zcpblzhax |tblhahl ~pconjchon/ ^mhib ~b fleoc~ibjnb zmfz NTPF jcb| oczpbvrhpb zmb jbtfpzgboz zc jbqbict tbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| fz ibqbi| `bic~zmb tpcnpfg flzhqhzhb| |bz acpzm ho zmb fnbolx| `rjnbz) ~b fi|c oczb zmfz ftpflzhlb fgcon ibfjhon cpnfoh{fzhco| ~mbo hgtibgbozhon pb|riz|'cphbozbjgfofnbgboz tpflzhlb| lco|h|zboz ~hzm NTPF mf| `bbo zc jbqbicttbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| acp bflm cpnfoh{fzhcofi ibqbi) ~mhlm lcrij mbitgfofnbp| foj |zfaa rojbp|zfoj mc~ zmbhp jfhix flzhqhzhb| lcozph`rzb zc

Tfnb 08 NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

34/47

fzzfhohon cpnfoh{fzhco~hjb |zpfzbnhl ncfi|/ Fi|c) zmbpb fpb czmbp lphzbphf hofjjhzhco zc NTPF zmfz ~b lhzbj ho crp jpfaz pbtcpz|tblhahlfiix) zmb|zfojfpj| acp hozbpofi lcozpci ho zmb abjbpfi ncqbpogboz~mhlm |zfzb zmfzfnbolhb| |mcrij b|zf`ih|m flzhqhzhb| zc gcohzcp tbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| fojhojhlfzcp| foj hgtibgboz lcozpci| fhgbj fz cpnfoh{fzhcofi tbpacpgfolb/Fjjhzhcofiix) ~hzm pbnfpj zc JCK| lcggboz zmfz JTF| foj OTF| fpbpbifzhqbix ab~ ho org`bp) ~mhib zmfz gfx `b zmb lf|b acp zmb R/\/ Fzzcpobx|Caahlb|) f| ~b |zfzbj ho crp pbtcpz) zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco mf| bozbpbj hozcf`crz zmb |fgb org`bp ca JTF| foj OTF| f| zmb org`bp ca tpc|blrzhco|hz mf| trp|rbj/

F| zc zmb |tblhahl zxtb| ca tbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| JCK lcrij fjctz) ~btpctc|bj ho crp jpfaz pbtcpz zmfz JCK ghnmz gbf|rpb ~mbzmbp zmblcgtfox |rllb||ariix gbz zmb zbpg| ca zmb fnpbbgboz cp ~mbzmbp zmblcgtfox pb'caabojbj) f| z~c tczbozhfi gbf|rpb| ca zmb baablzhqbob|| caJTF| foj OTF|/ Ho hz| lcggboz|) JCK hjbozhahbj |cgb ca zmb |fgbihghzfzhco| f| ~b jhj ho crp pbtcpz pbnfpjhon zmb r|b ca pblhjhqh|g f| ftbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb/ \tblhahlfiix) JCK |zfzbj zmfz hz ~crij `b jhaahlriz zcjbzbpghob ~mbzmbp f lcgtfox pblhjhqfzbj ha zmb lcgtfox| |r`|bvrbozqhcifzhco ~f| jhaabpboz zmfo zmb cphnhofi qhcifzhco zmfz pb|rizbj ho zmb JTFcp OTF/ Mc~bqbp) JCK |zfzbj zmfz zmb pblboz baacpz| rojbp ~fx `x BCR\Ffoj zmb Lphghofi Jhqh|hco zc zpfle zmb jbtfpzgboz| r|b ca JTF| foj OTF|foj gcohzcp zmb jh|tc|hzhco ca zmb|b fnpbbgboz| ~hii mbit JCK eoc~~mbzmbp zmb lcptcpfzhco mf| ariahiibj fii ca zmb zbpg| ca zmb fnpbbgboz)eoc~ibjnb zmfz lcrij `b r|bari hoacpgfzhco acp zmb jbtfpzgboz f| hzjbqbict| hz| tbpacpgfolb gbf|rpb| acp JTF| foj OTF|/

^b fi|c pblbhqbj ~phzzbo lcggboz| apcg zmb Fjghoh|zpfzhqb Caahlb ca zmbR/\/ Lcrpz| -FCR\L( co Jblbg`bp 6>) 0448) foj zmb arii zb}z ca zmbCaahlb| ~phzzbo lcggboz| h| holirjbj ho fttbojh} HQ/

FCR\L ho hz| lcggboz| bgtmf|h{bj lcolbpo| f`crz npbfzbp krjhlhfihoqciqbgboz ho zmb r|b ca JTF| foj OTF|) holirjhon lcolbpo| f`crzlco|zhzrzhcofi foj czmbp |btfpfzhco ca tc~bp| h||rb| lcozfhobj ho zmb

pbtcpz) foj |rnnb|zbj zmb|b `b nhqbo npbfzbp bgtmf|h|/ ^b gfhozfho zmfz~b mfqb fllrpfzbix foj c`kblzhqbix pbtpb|bozbj zmb qhb~| ca tpc|blrzcp|)lcgtfox caahlhfi|) gcohzcp|) foj krjnb| f| tpb|bozbj zc r| ho zmb lcrp|b cacrp pbqhb~ foj mfqb pbaiblzbj zmb|b h||rb| ho zmb pbtcpz/

Tfnb

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

35/47

F| fnpbbj ~hzm xcrp caahlb|) ~b tifo oc arpzmbp jh|zph`rzhco ca zmh| pbtcpzrozhi 0: jfx| apcg hz| jfzb) roib|| xcr tr`ihlix foocrolb hz| lcozboz|bfpihbp/ Fz zmfz zhgb) ~b ~hii |boj lcthb| ca zmh| pbtcpz zc zmb FzzcpobxNbobpfi) zmb Jhpblzcp ca FCR\L) |biblzbj lconpb||hcofi lcgghzzbb|) fojczmbp hozbpb|zbj tfpzhb|/ Zmb pbtcpz ~hii fi|c `b fqfhif`ib fz oc lmfpnb cozmb NFC ^b` |hzb fz mzzt;##~~~/nfc/ncq/

Ha xcr cp xcrp |zfaa mfqb fox arpzmbp vrb|zhco| f`crz zmh| pbtcpz) tibf|blcozflz gb fz -040( 260'=>>> cp ifpbolbbDnfc/ncq/ Lcozflz tchoz| acp crpCaahlb| ca Lconpb||hcofi Pbifzhco| foj Tr`ihl Faafhp| gfx `b acroj co zmbif|z tfnb ca zmh| pbtcpz/ Ebx lcozph`rzcp| zc zmh| pbtcpz fpb ih|zbj ho ftt/ Q/

Bhibbo P/ IfpbolbJhpblzcp) Mcgbifoj \blrphzx foj Kr|zhlb H||rb|

Tfnb

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

36/47

Ih|z ca Pbvrb|zbp|

Zmb Mcocpf`ib Tfzphle K/ IbfmxLmfhpgfoLcgghzzbb co zmb KrjhlhfpxRohzbj \zfzb| \bofzb

Zmb Mcocpf`ib Kcmo Lcoxbp|) Kp/LmfhpgfoLcgghzzbb co zmb KrjhlhfpxMcr|b ca Pbtpb|bozfzhqb|

Zmb Mcocpf`ib \zbqb LcmboLmfhpgfo\r`lcgghzzbb co Lcggbplhfi foj Fjghoh|zpfzhqb If~Lcgghzzbb co zmb KrjhlhfpxMcr|b ca Pbtpb|bozfzhqb|

Zmb Mcocpf`ib Apfoe Tfiicob) Kp/Mcr|b ca Pbtpb|bozfzhqb|

Zmb Mcocpf`ib @hii Tf|lpbii) Kp/Mcr|b ca Pbtpb|bozfzhqb|

Zmb Mcocpf`ib Ihojf Z/ \folmb{Mcr|b ca Pbtpb|bozfzhqb|

Tfnb

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

37/47

Fttbojh} H; Zbpg| ca 2> JTF| foj OTF|Pbqhb~bj foj Jh|lr||bj ho Krob 0448Zb|zhgcox

Fttbojh} H; Zbpg| ca 2> JTF| foj OTF|Pbqhb~bj foj Jh|lr||bj ho Krob 0448Zb|zhgcox

Zmb zbpg| ca zmb 2> JTF| foj OTF| ~b tpbqhcr|ix pbqhb~bj acp crp Krob0448 zb|zhgcox holirjbj; 6

jrpfzhco| pfonhon apcg < gcozm| zc 2 xbfp| -Cob ca zmb 2> fnpbbgboz| ~bpbqhb~bj jhj ocz |tblhax zmb jrpfzhco/(5

gcobzfpx tfxgboz| pfonhon apcg * JTF| foj OTF| ~b pbqhb~bj holirjbjlcgtihfolb tpcnpfg pbvrhpbgboz|) ~mhib 60 jhj ocz/(5

pbvrhpbgboz| zmfz zmb lcgtfox mhpb) fz hz| c~o b}tbo|b) fo hojbtbojbozgcohzcp zc f||h|z zmb lcgtfox ho b|zf`ih|mhon f lcgtihfolb tpcnpfg)pbqhb~ zmb baablzhqbob|| ca f lcgtfox| hozbpofi lcozpci gbf|rpb|) fojjbzbpghob ~mbzmbp zmb lcgtfox mf| czmbp~h|b gbz zmb zbpg| ca zmbfnpbbgboz| -Z~bozx'|h} ca zmb 2> JTF| foj OTF| pbvrhpbj lcgtfohb| zcmhpb hojbtbojboz gcohzcp|/(5 foj

b}zpfcpjhofpx pb|zhzrzhco tpcqh|hco|) ~mhlm fpb tfxgboz| cp |bpqhlb| zccpnfoh{fzhco| cp hojhqhjrfi| ocz jhpblzix faablzbj `x zmb lphgb/ -Acrp ca zmb2> JTF| foj OTF| ~b pbqhb~bj holirjbj |rlm zbpg|/ Mc~bqbp) JCKh||rbj nrhjfolb ho Gfx 044= tpcmh`hzhon zmb r|b ca zbpg| pbvrhphontfxgboz| zc lmfphzf`ib) bjrlfzhcofi) lcggrohzx) cp czmbp cpnfoh{fzhco| cphojhqhjrfi| zmfz fpb ocz zmb qhlzhg| ca zmb lphghofi flzhqhzx cp fpb ocz

tpcqhjhon |bpqhlb| zc pbjpb|| zmb mfpg lfr|bj `x zmb lphghofi lcojrlz/(

6Acp zmb trptc|b| ca crp Krob 0448 zb|zhgcox |zfzbgboz) ~b pbqhb~bj zmb zbpg| ca zmb 2>

fnpbbgboz| ~b jh|lr||bj ~hzm tpc|blrzcp| fz zmb 6< JCK caahlb| ~b |biblzbj acp crp |hzbqh|hz| foj hozbpqhb~|/ Zmb lphzbphf ~b r|bj zc |biblz zmb|b caahlb|) foj zmr| zmb 2>fnpbbgboz|) fpb jb|lph`bj bfpihbp ho zmh| pbtcpz/

Tfnb

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

38/47

Fttbojh} HH; Org`bp ca JTF| foj OTF| `xBflm R/\/ Fzzcpobx| Caahlb foj JCKIhzhnfzhon Jhqh|hco

Zf`ib 0; Org`bp ca JTF| foj OTF| Bozbpbj hozc `x Bflm R/\/ Fzzcpobx| Caahlb

-R\FC(

R\FC

Org`bp ca JTF|foj OTF| bozbpbjhozc f| coix caahlb

Org`bp ca JTF|foj OTF| bozbpbj

hozc kchozix ~hzmczmbp caahlb Zczfi

6 \crzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Ob~ Xcpe 04 < 0 4 >

1 Ocpzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Lfihacpohf < 0 2

> ^b|zbpo Jh|zphlz ca Qhpnhohf < 6 :

= Ocpzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Fif`fgf 6 6 0

8 Lcooblzhlrz 0 4 0

64 \crzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Gh||h||htth 0 4 0

66 Pmcjb H|ifoj 6 6 0

60 Bf|zbpo Jh|zphlz ca Qhpnhohf 4 0 0

6< \crzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Cmhc 6 6 0

6: Ocpzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Nbcpnhf 6 6 0

62 ^b|zbpo Jh|zphlz ca Gh||crph 0 4 0

61 \crzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Zb}f| 0 4 0

6> Ocpzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Ob~ Xcpe 0 4 0

6= Bf|zbpo Jh|zphlz ca Fpefo|f| 6 4 6

68 \crzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Lfihacpohf 6 4 6

04 Jh|zphlz ca Lcirg`hf 6 4 6

06 Ocpzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Aicphjf 4 6 6

00 \crzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Hiihoch| 4 6 6

0< \crzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Hojhfof 4 6 6

0: Ocpzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Hc~f 6 4 6

02 ^b|zbpo Jh|zphlz ca Ebozrlex 6 4 6

01 Bf|zbpo Jh|zphlz ca Gh||crph 6 4 60> Ocpzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Gh||h||htth 6 4 6

0= Ob~ Gb}hlc 6 4 6

08 Ocpzmbpo Jh|zphlz ca Cmhc 4 6 6

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

39/47

Fttbojh} HH; Org`bp ca JTF| foj OTF| `xBflm R/\/ Fzzcpobx| Caahlb foj JCKIhzhnfzhon Jhqh|hco

R\FC

Org`bp ca JTF|foj OTF| bozbpbjhozc f| coix caahlb

Org`bp ca JTF|foj OTF| bozbpbj

hozc kchozix ~hzmczmbp caahlb Zczfi

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

40/47

Fttbojh} HHH; Lcggboz| apcg zmb Jbtfpzgbozca Kr|zhlbFttbojh} HHH; Lcggboz| apcg zmb

Jbtfpzgboz ca Kr|zhlb

Tfnb

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

41/47

Fttbojh} HHH; Lcggboz| apcg zmb Jbtfpzgbozca Kr|zhlb

Tfnb NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

42/47

Fttbojh} HHH; Lcggboz| apcg zmb Jbtfpzgbozca Kr|zhlb

Tfnb

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

43/47

Fttbojh} HHH; Lcggboz| apcg zmb Jbtfpzgbozca Kr|zhlb

Tfnb

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

44/47

Fttbojh} HHH; Lcggboz| apcg zmb Jbtfpzgbozca Kr|zhlb

Tfnb :4 NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

45/47

Fttbojh} HQ; Lcggboz| apcg zmbFjghoh|zpfzhqb Caahlb ca zmb R/\/ Lcrpz|Fttbojh} HQ; Lcggboz| apcg zmb

Fjghoh|zpfzhqb Caahlb ca zmb R/\/ Lcrpz|

Tfnb :6 NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

46/47

Fttbojh} Q; NFC Lcozflz foj \zfaaFleoc~ibjngboz|Fttbojh} Q; NFC Lcozflz foj \zfaa

Fleoc~ibjngboz|

Bhibbo P/ Ifpbolb) -040( 260'=>>> cp ifpbolbbDnfc/ncq/

Ho fjjhzhco zc zmb lcozflz ofgbj f`cqb) Eph|zx O/ @pc~o) F||h|zfozJhpblzcp5 Khii Bqfolmc5 Zcg Kb||cp5 Jfohbiib Tfejfgfo5 \fpfm Efl{gfpbe5Kfobz Zbgec5 Fgfojf Ghiibp5 Efzmbphob Jfqh|5 foj Gfojfof Xcr|bah gfjb|hnohahlfoz lcozph`rzhco| zc zmh| pbtcpz/

Tfnb :0 NFC'64'664 JCK.| R|b ca Jbabppbj foj Oco'Tpc|blrzhco Fnpbbgboz

NFC Lcozflz

\zfaaFleoc~ibjngboz|

-::4>2=(

8/14/2019 G.A.O. Report on Deferred and Nonprosecution Agreements

47/47

NFC| Gh||hco Zmb Ncqbpogboz Fllcrozf`hihzx Caahlb) zmb frjhz) bqfirfzhco) fojhoqb|zhnfzhqb fpg ca Lconpb||) b}h|z| zc |rttcpz Lconpb|| ho gbbzhon hz|lco|zhzrzhcofi pb|tco|h`hihzhb| foj zc mbit hgtpcqb zmb tbpacpgfolb fojfllcrozf`hihzx ca zmb abjbpfi ncqbpogboz acp zmb Fgbphlfo tbctib/ NFCb}fghob| zmb r|b ca tr`ihl aroj|5 bqfirfzb| abjbpfi tpcnpfg| foj tcihlhb|5foj tpcqhjb| fofix|b|) pblcggbojfzhco|) foj czmbp f||h|zfolb zc mbitLconpb|| gfeb hoacpgbj cqbp|hnmz) tcihlx) foj arojhon jblh|hco|/ NFC|lcgghzgboz zc nccj ncqbpogboz h| pbaiblzbj ho hz| lcpb qfirb| cafllcrozf`hihzx) hozbnphzx) foj pbihf`hihzx/

Zmb af|zb|z foj bf|hb|z ~fx zc c`zfho lcthb| ca NFC jclrgboz| fz oc lc|z

h| zmpcrnm NFC| ^b` |hzb -~~~/nfc/ncq(/ Bflm ~bbejfx fazbpocco)NFC tc|z| co hz| ^b` |hzb ob~ix pbibf|bj pbtcpz|) zb|zhgcox) fojlcppb|tcojbolb/ Zc mfqb NFC b'gfhi xcr f ih|z ca ob~ix tc|zbj tpcjrlz|)nc zc ~~~/nfc/ncq foj |biblz B'gfhi Rtjfzb|/

C`zfhohon Lcthb| caNFC Pbtcpz| fojZb|zhgcox

Cpjbp `x Tmcob Zmb tphlb ca bflm NFC tr`ihlfzhco pbaiblz| NFC| flzrfi lc|z catpcjrlzhco foj jh|zph`rzhco foj jbtboj| co zmb org`bp ca tfnb| ho zmbtr`ihlfzhco foj ~mbzmbp zmb tr`ihlfzhco h| tphozbj ho lcicp cp `ifle foj~mhzb/ Tphlhon foj cpjbphon hoacpgfzhco h| tc|zbj co NFC| ^b` |hzb)mzzt;##~~~/nfc/ncq#cpjbphon/mzg/

Tiflb cpjbp| `x lfiihon -040( 260'1444) zcii apbb -=11( =46'>4>>) cpZJJ -040( 260'02/

Cpjbp| gfx `b tfhj acp r|hon Fgbphlfo B}tpb||) Jh|lcqbp Lfpj)Gf|zbpLfpj) Qh|f) lmble) cp gcobx cpjbp/ Lfii acp fjjhzhcofi hoacpgfzhco/

Lcozflz;

^b` |hzb;~~~/nfc/ncq#apfrjobz#apfrjobz/mzgB'gfhi; apfrjobzDnfc/ncqFrzcgfzbj fo|~bphon |x|zbg; -=44( :0:'2:2: cp -040( 260'>:>4

Pfitm Jf~o) Gfofnhon Jhpblzcp) jf~opDnfc/ncq) -040( 260'::44R/\/ Ncqbpogboz Fllcrozf`hihzx Caahlb) ::6 N \zpbbz O^) Pccg >602^f|mhonzco) JL 042:=

Zc Pbtcpz Apfrj)^f|zb) foj F`r|b hoAbjbpfi Tpcnpfg|

Lconpb||hcofiPbifzhco|

Lmrle Xcron) Gfofnhon Jhpblzcp)xcronl6Dnfc/ncq) -040( 260':=44R/\/ Ncqbpogboz Fllcrozf`hihzx Caahlb) ::6 N \zpbbz O^) Pccg >6:8^f|mhonzco) JL 042:=

Tr`ihl Faafhp|

http://www.gao.gov/http://www.gao.gov/http://www.gao.gov/ordering.htmhttp://www.gao.gov/fraudnet/fraudnet.htmmailto:fraudnet@gao.govmailto:dawnr@gao.govmailto:youngc1@gao.govmailto:youngc1@gao.govmailto:dawnr@gao.govmailto:fraudnet@gao.govhttp://www.gao.gov/fraudnet/fraudnet.htmhttp://www.gao.gov/ordering.htmhttp://www.gao.gov/http://www.gao.gov/