68
i . ! :-1 ; ! • I . i FURTHER ASSESSMENT OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF AN OIL CONTAINMENT BOOM IN CONFINING THE MERRIMACK GENERATING STATION DISCHARGE TO THE WEST BANK OF THE RIVER Prepared for PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY OF NEW HAMPSHIRE By NORI·1ANDEAU ASSOCIATES, INC. Bedford, New Hampshire April 1976 AR-1151

Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

.· i . !

:-1 ; !

• I

. i

FURTHER ASSESSMENT OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF AN OIL CONTAINMENT BOOM IN CONFINING

THE MERRIMACK GENERATING STATION DISCHARGE TO THE WEST BANK OF THE RIVER

Prepared for PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

By NORI·1ANDEAU ASSOCIATES, INC.

Bedford, New Hampshire

April 1976

AR-1151

Page 2: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

ABSTRACT

In order to comply with NPDES permit NH 0001465, the Public Service Company of New Hampshire has initiated studies of methods to confine the Merrimack Generating Station thermal effluent to the west bank of the river. An oil containment boom was placed experimentally near the mouth of the effluent canal and evaluated as to its effect­iveness in achieving the desired goal. Two different con­figurations were tested: one with a closed upstream end and one with an open upstream end. Cross-sectional temp­erature profiles obtained before and after installation indicated that both of the boom configurations failed to achieve the desired result. Deployment difficulties pre­vented the boom from containing water over a large enough area to be effective and much of the heated effluent bypassed the boom altogether.

Page 3: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

. , .,·.·.

-!

·. J

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. INTRODUCTION .....

II. METHODS AND MATERIALS

III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION.

A. FIRST BOOM CONFIGURATION.

B. SECOND BOOM CONFIGURATION

IV. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS ...

APPENDIX A. RIVER DISCHARGE DATA AS MEASURED AT GARVIN 1 S FALLS ........... .

APPENDIX B. AIR TEMPERATURE AND RELATIVE HUMIDITY AS MEASURED AT CONCORD AIRPORT

APPENDIX C. PLANT OPERATION DATA ........ .

i

PAGE

1

2

5

13

14

17

19

20

22

Page 4: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

LIST OF FIGURES

1. Overview of river showing sampling transects. Inset A shows first boom configuration and inset B shows second boom configuration. Plume Deflector Effective-

PAGE

ness Study~ 1976. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

2. Schematic diagram of a section of the oil containment boom used in the experiment. Plume Deflector Effective-ness Study~ 1976. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4

3. Cross-sectional profiles at selected transects for pre­installation date: September 5~ 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study~ 1976 . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

Cross-sectional profiles at selected transects for pre-installation date: September 8~ 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study~ 1976 ....... .

Cross-sectional profiles at selected transects for post-installation date: September 11~ 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study. 1976 . . . . .

Cross-sectional profiles at selected transects for post-installation date: September 15~ 1975. Plume Deflector Effect1 veness Study~ 1976 . . . . . . .

Cross-sectional profiles at selected transects for post-installation date: September 18~ 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study~ 1976 ....... .

Cross-sectional profiles at selected transects for post-installation date: September 22~ 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study~ 1976 ...... .

ii

7

8

9

10

11

Page 5: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

LIST OF TABLES

PAGE

1. AMBIENT RIVER TEMPERATURE AS DETERMINED AT TRANSECT N-5. PLUME DEFLECTOR EFFECTIVENESS STUDY, 1976. . . 12

2. PERCENTAGE OF TOTAL CROSS-SECTIONAL AREA BOUNDED BY 6T'S OF 5 F, 10 F, and 15 F. PLUME DEFLECTOR EFFECTIVE-NESS STUDY, 1976 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15

: '

iii

Page 6: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

FURTHER ASSESSMENT OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF AN OIL CONTAINMENT BOOM IN CONFINING

THE MERRIMACK GENERATING STATION DISCHARGE TO THE WEST BANK OF THE RIVER

I. INTRODUCTION

The Public Service Company of New Hampshire Merrimack Gen­

erating Station at Bow, New Hampshire discharges its cooling water into

the Merrimack River at a temperature between 5 and 15 F above ambient.

In response to the requirements of NPDES permit NH 0001465, it is de­

sired to confine this discharge to the west bank of the river so as to

maintain a cool water passage for fish near the east bank. In an

attempt to accomplish this, Coastal Services, Inc., of Boston, Massa­

chusetts, moored an oil containment boom in the vicinity of the dis­

charge canal. Two configurations were tested, and the details of each

are presented in this report. To assess the efficacy of the systems,

three temperature surveys were conducted: one before installation of

the boom, one with the boom in its first configuration, and one with the

boom in its second configuration.

l

Page 7: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

·.· 1 • I

I

. . I ._,

II. METHODS AND MATERIALS

In the initial deployment, the oil containment boom was to

extend from the upstream bank of the discharge canal outwards about one­

third of the distance across the river and then downstream to Transect

S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend­

ing below water level) was 5 ft deep (Figure 2). The second configura­

tion was unchanged except that the upstream end of the boom was placed

about 100ft offshore (Figure 1, inset b). The device was emplaced on

September 10, 1975. The configuration was changed on September 17,

1975, and the boom was removed on September 24, 1975.

Thermal cross-sectional profile surveys of ambient conditions

were conducted on September 5 and September 8, 1975, prior to instal­

lation of the boom. Surveys to evaluate the first configuration were

conducted on September 11 and September 15, 1975. Surveys of the second

configuration were conducted on September 18 and September 22, 1975.

Water temperatures were recorded at 1-ft depth intervals at six stations

across each of the following transects: N-5, N-1, Zero, S-1 through S-

6, S-8, and S-10 (transects are indicated in Figure 1). On September 5

and September 8 temperatures were measured using the temperature portion

of a Beckman RS5-3 Portable Salinometer (accuracy ±0.23 F or ±0.5 C).

The remainder of the surveys were conducted using NAI's Model 1001-T-2

dual-channel temperature recorder with YSI thermistor probes (system

accuracy ±0.5 F).

2

Page 8: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

GARVINS FALLS

DM1

0

I 0

SCALE:

I 1 Km

1 Mi I

FIRST CONFIGURATION

A OIL CONTAINMENT

BOOM

SECOND CONFIGURATION

B

SOU COOK RIVER

MERRIMACK GENERATING

PLANT

DISCHARGE CANAL

HOOKSETT POWER DAM

Figure 1. Overview of Merrimack River showing sampling transects. Inset A shows first boom configuration, and inset B shows second boom configuration. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study, 1976.

3

Page 9: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

WATER LEVEL BUOYANCY FLOAT

\ ·- ~ \ ....... /..._ - - .~::--...- -'- . ' - -- -~ -- -- _, ··""--···· • ~----.,_\..);-- --~c: -. ....... ·~-.~ .......

- =-~..,:_ -~~·.lp._:--:7:.-~::--=~.::Er-:-:-~·!::.,.·:--~ -~-B:-:;.::;., -:~:-: ::.•@ .. _..:::.:·-.. --·-'-:-Q.-,_. .. -::--··.-: 7·-'-"""'0 _;,.,..:!.'."7-=----·:.'·. ,--~--==- ·. __ ,_ t . 'IJ I ~ , "' ,, ·. '-\ ., - ,, ~---:.. _'\\ /.::\, '\ .\ . 1-·---'-""~---- -· .='-- -

.. . ' . . 5' . ·. \ ' ·, . . . '>- ' \ • :- :.. "Y .. ~... ·..:,. '~~..', ~ "'' '

. ,...... ....... ··~- ' ~, ·, I. '·, ·' ' _y_

-\. .''-.

RIVER BOTTOM ANCHOR · . \.

~ . . [" .. . ~ " .... '-~" -·;-..·::-· . ·-·-· -..·----··- ·-- r.:.-·-~- ~-.:-~::-~7>~:.;..::..~-:'. :-::.:..:. """-=:-.:·~~....:f:~--~:7'.: ~ ~'=='~::.~:--::.~-=:._.--:::-~-;,.;:' -..-:~-:~ ~.~ -~.:::.__,_,~:..-f=-~,~·-:==~-

Fivure 2. Schematic diagram of a section of the oil containment boom used in the experiments. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study, 1976. .t>

Page 10: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Cross-sectional isotherms for each of the thermal profile

surveys are shown in Figures 3 through 8. Each figure consists of cross

sections at Transects Zero, S-1, s-3 and S-5. Although more data are

available, the information shown in these figures is most representative

of the effect of the boom on the temperature distribution in the immedi­

ate vicinity of the discharge canal. The isotherms shown in the figures

are drawn such that they differ by 1.0 F increments above the ambient

temperature. The difference (~t) between each isotherm and ambient

temperature is also indicated, along with its actual value. Ambient

temperature is defined as the mean cross-sectional temperature at

Transect N-5. These temperatures are listed in Table l, and were com-

puted from the following relation:

n E T. X A.

i=l l l

T (l) n E Al

i=l

where T. 's are temperatures of the cross-sectional isotherms, A.'s are l l

areas bounded by the respective T. 's and the next lower temperature, and l

EA. is the total cross-sectional area. l

Each of the boom deployment configurations will be discussed

separately. It should be noted that Merrimack Station's Unit l was not

operating from 1817 EST on September 7, 1975 to 1835 EST on September 8,

1975 (see Appendix C). Thus the data obtained on September 8 were not

representative of general operating conditions. In addition Unit l was

down from September 12, 1975 to October 15, 1975, so data collected

during the last three surveys were also not representative. Therefore

5

Page 11: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

0-,

[ o-,. ~ .r-0

2-l !';:)""/ ./11//~/~ == 74ii'-....'\..'\.. '\ I

4-l ~ft ~---------- ---2~ /U.Cf...__ l (\\1\\\.1 I 4

-.

6 ............. r, ~ 8 ,~ X

,- - _..-----...,__

-y~,~ 1- 'f e___;o w w LJ_ .._.. 8 ......... LJ_ 8 ...__. :c

:c ~ ~ ~~ ~ 1- I f- :C B::i 10 L 3 B::i l;:: I 0 0 i a w .

1 __ o 12-l I 12

I I

L4 I l-4 14-l

I 14

A 16~ B

16-4 ZERO I 5 S-1

5

0 0

0~ L76.8 "'~'==- '---------11--788~ = J 10

2 2

I 4 4

......... ...--.. 1-w ffi 6~ l I ~2! t:: 6

21--;:::- l ~ •j ~r ~'~I ~ 3 ~ 8

:c...__.

~ J ~3 ~ _3 ~ ~ 10~ 10

I 0

12-l \ I 12

I I

14~ ~4 f-4 14-j \ / I

D 16-l <::_~

~ I 16~ S-5 I 5 • Figure 3. Cross sectional profiles at selected transects for pre-

installation date, September 5, 1975. Plume Deflector --~------------- ---- 0'1

Effectiveness Study, 1976. Ambient temperature = 68.8°F. ..

-------- ·--------------- ------ ----

Page 12: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

0 0

2

4

........ ..-.. Vl f- 6 w

0:: w

w 2f-LL w ~

8 ::c f-0.. w 10 c

12

I :::E .

..........

I :c f-

I ., 0.. r"w

I 0

i 14

A

r-4 I

16 ZERO

0

2

4

6

f­w w LJ... 8 ..........

:c f-lO 0.. w 0

12

14

16

B

S-1

0

Vl 0:: w

2f­w :!:

::c f-0..

3W 0

4

~--------------------------------------------------~5 ~--------------------------------------------------_._~ 0

2

4

f- 6 w w LL

8

::c f-0.. w 10 0

12

14

16

. -- -·

[ :~ 4

......... Vl

6 0:: w .........

,_ 2 t:i f-w I ::E: t:: 8 . ..........

I .......... i :c

f-~10 i 0..

r3~ 0.. w 0

I 121

"~ F4 l

I

16

?/ I / M/ n ~

~?/

--?2- 5 =----\ - 4 3_2 ___ 69--.....

0) 6?

D

S-5

,-68--

0

Vl 0:: w

2 f­w ::E ..__..

::c f-0..

3 w 0

4

5 ~------------------------------------------~5

Figure 4. Cross sectional profiles at selected transects for pre­installation date: September 8, 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study, 1.976. Ambient temperatu-re~·· 67°F.

-..J

Page 13: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

0

2

4

1-w 6 w LL..

:r: 8 1-CI... w Cl '10

12

14

16

0

2

4

...-.. 1- 6 w w LL..

:r: 1-CI...

8

~ 10

12

14

16

A

ZERO 16

B

S-1

0

(/) 0:: w

21-w ::E

:r: 1-CI...

3W Cl

4

J---------------------~~~~--------------------~5 J---------------------~~~----------------------~5

~a

I'_ r,s I ::J: ' I-L3 ~ I o

!-1

~4 I

:l J

6 -1-l.LJ

t:: 8

::J: 1-10 0... I

~ 12~ --1

14

16

\~~/ 8-------- 0

0

S-5

I 8 '--?2./

0

VJ 0:: l.LJ

2 1-l.LJ ::E

::J: 1-CI...

3 w Cl

4

~--------------~----------------------~5 ~------------------~------------------~5

Figure 5. Cross sectional profiles at selected transects for post­installation date: September 11, 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study, 1976. Ambient temperature= 64.l°F.

(X)

Page 14: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

0

2

4

f- 6 w w LL

8 :c f--0... w 0 10

12

14

IS

0

2

4

f­w 6 w LL ..._.. :c 8 t-o... w 0 10

12

14

16

A

ZERO

J / 64~) 66,3 / ./ 7 6 5

~ 4 /~ 63.3_/

ol ~ , 683/66.3/ \\ ~ ,~) ,,- /0 ' / /

l ~·~9_J./_d/<j --~ 683 69.3 ' ~ - -- - - .. - 66.3 ( (

2 ~j ~~--~--- -.. _ '-63.3 5~~3~\__

-~~ 9,10---J ~-4 43 8 -=~:__:-_____ ~ \ ~- '--7----. -~---~-:::--~--

0

...-... (/)

0::: 6 w ...-...

>-21-- I-

ll t.;J t;j 8

.._.. LL .._..

:c 1--:c 0... I- 10

3w o... I o ~ ' 12

4 14

16

6 "3 " - // L '---.__ /

-2~ :;:. 5- _ _____ _/ /

6/3 3- --1 ......

B

S-1

0

(/)

0::: w

21-w ::::::

:c 1--0...

3w 0

4

J---------------------------------------~----------~5 J-------------------------------------------------~5

S-3

0

] 4

...-...

~ 6 w ...-...

2 I- 1-Ww

;:,::: W 8l· .._.. LL

I~ ~ ilo 3 w 0... ow

0 - .. 12

f-4 14

IS

0

S-5

0

(/) 0::: w

21-­w ::::::

:c 1-0...

3W 0

~----------------------------------------~--~5 ~------------------------------------------~5 Figure 6. Cross sectional profiles at selected transects for post­

installation date: September 15, 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study, 1976. Ambient temperature- ;---59~ 3°F

1.0

Page 15: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

0

2

4

1-WG w LL

::cB I­C... w oo

12

14

16

0

2

4

1-6 w w LL ~8

::c I­C... W!Q 0

12

14

16

BOOM LOCATIJ~N-:J..

~9'--69.4/

c S-3

A

ZERO

10 I r-~

.......... V) r.r: w

21-w ::E --i ::c

! I­!-3E;:j ' 0

L4

I

ol J

70.4 /./

9/

4~ -""'! -65.4--5

' ------------- ~ 6 ~ 64.4------- 4-.......... I ~3 LJ I 63.4 __.---~ Bl 62.4 ___

2 ____

-- I / 61.4-----.._ ' I

~10~ -~ 121

"~ I 16l

B

S-1

I '-.. 70.4 10.4-10 '----!o~

0

V)

0:: w

21-w ::E:

::c I­C...

3w 0

4

L5 ~--------------------~~-=~----------------------~5

o ol

f,-' :~ I ffi ~=" 6~ r 21- w w w

I ~ .:::_ a1' I ::c ::c

I I- I-C... 0... 10-i

r3w w I

. "' "'12j 1-4

I 14J I

_J

IG I "1

.,.; I .~ ... / 6,8. 4 'i -------------=-

9 .

8

/6 5 -64.4----6?.4 / / 4

~/~3~.,\____ 2

~z~

D

S-5

2-::J

0

V) 0:: w

21-w ::E:

::c I­C...

3w 0

4

J-----------------------------~~--------~5 ~----------~--------------------------------~5

Figure 7. Cross sectional profiles at selected transects for post­installation date: September 18, 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study, 1976. Ambient temperature= 60.4°F, ·

--------~- .. ---·---- ----·

1-' 0

Page 16: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

0

2

4

1- 6 w w Lt...

:r: I­C..

8

~ 10

12

14

16

0

2

4

1- 6 w w LL

8 :c I­D... w 0 10

A

ZERO

~c

~'-l2~ I W !: : I-I C.. ·-3 w I o

I I 4

I I

i I 5

0

--Vl 0:: w

21-

i! ! :c I I-

~3Eb ' 0 I I­I

~4 I I

('l

'~ 4l __ J

J- I

w I W I .:::_ s I

tiJ w I o I

12l

"l . I IC I

0

Vl a: w

2 1-w L

:r: I­C..

3 w 0

4

~----------------------~~~----------------------~5

OJ

2

4

6 ......... 1- ...;

~ sJ ~'0~ ~ ~

::1

0

Vl 0:: w

2 1-w L

:c I­C..

3 w 0

16j S-3 v I 5 16

D

S-5 ~-------------------=--~------------------~5

Figure 8. Cross sectional profiles at selected transects for post­installation date: September 22, 1975. Plume Deflector Effectiveness Study, 1976. Ambient temperature= 60.6°F.

,_, ,_,

Page 17: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

TABLE 1. AMBIENT RIVER TEMPERATURE AS DETERMINED AT TRANSECT N-5. PLUME DEFLECTOR EFFECTIVENESS STUDY, 1976.

SURVEY DATE, At1BIENT 1975 Tn1PERATURE, F

September 5 67.8

September 8 67.0

September 11 64.1

September 15 59.3

September 18 60.4

September 22 60.6

12

Page 18: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

13

an assessment of the first boom deployment scheme will be based on data

from September 5 and Septerilier 11, whereas an assessment of the second

configuration can only be qualitative. Data pertaining to river dis­

charge and atmospheric conditions are compiled in Appendices A and B,

respectively. Because these conditions were not substantially different

from one sampling day to the next, it is felt that they did not cause

any unusual effects which would invalidate direct comparison of the

survey results.

A. FIRST BOOM CONFIGURATION

In assessing this containment system, a comparison of the

cross-sectional profiles obtained at Transect Zero is most interesting.

The post installation survey (Figure Sa) showed a pronounced horizontal

temperature gradient in the vicinity of the boom. On the east side of

the boom, the temperatures throughout the water column were substan­

tially cooler than on the west side. This large horizontal gradient is

not evident in the illustrations for the pre-installation survey (Figure

3a), indicating that the boom was effective in containing the effluent.

A comparison of the cross-sectional profiles obtained at

Transect S-1 shows a substantially different picture. In this case the

pre-installation data (Figure 3b) and the post-installation data (Figure

5b) were generally similar. In each illustration the isotherms sloped

fairly gently from the west bank to the east bank, and a sharp vertical

temperature gradient (thermocline) was present near the east bank. An

important difference to note, however, is that in Figure 3b the thermo­

cline is slightly shallower than it is in Figure 4b. This suggests that

a slightly greater amount of mixing took place after the boom was in­

stalled. Comparisons of the cross-sectional profiles for Transect S-3

suggest the same thing. The pre-installation illustration (Figure 3c)

shows a fairly shallow and pronounced thermocline, but the post-instal­

lation illustration (Figure Sc) shows a comparatively weak thermocline

and a smaller percentage of the cross section at or below the ambient

Page 19: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

temperature. The increased extent of mixing is similarly indicated at

Transect S-5.

14

Of further interest in assessing the boom's effectiveness are

the data presented in Table 2, which lists percentages of total cross

sectional area bounded by ~t's of SF, lOF, and 15F. Note that the areas

bounded by the indicated ~t's are greater at every transect on September

11 than on September 5. This was also the case for September 15 even

though only one power generating unit was operating.

The vast difference in boom effectiveness between Transect

Zero and points downstream is no doubt the result of the boom deployment

difficulties encountered by the crew from Coastal Services. Since the

boom skirt was five feet deep, the 200,000 gallon per minute discharge

from the effluent canal caught the boom with tremendous force, making it

impossible for the crew to moor it in the desired fashion with the

equipment they used. As a result, the actual configuration was such

that the boom extended about half way across the river and ended only a

few feet past the do\mstream shore of the discharge canal. Effluent

water was thus prevented from mixing with ambient water at Transect

Zero. However, it easily bypassed the end of the boom and, because of

the constriction presented by the boom, it was forced deeper within the

ambient water than it was when no boom was present.

B. SECOND BOOM CONFIGURATION

As previously noted, only general comments can be made regard­

ing the effectiveness of the second boom configuration. Once again, the

cross-sectional profiles at Transect Zero showed a much different temp­

erature distribution after installation of the boom; however, the post­

installation temperature distribution was not consistent from one survey

to another. For the September 18 survey (Figure 7a), the isotherms show

a fairly sharp upward slope from west to east, but there was no extreme

horizontal temperature gradient such as was present on September 11 and

Page 20: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

15

TABLE 2. PERCENTAGE OF TOTAL CROSS SECTIONAL AREA BOUNDED BY AT'S OF 5 F, 10 F,AND 15 F. PLUME DEFLECTOR EFFECTIVENESS STUDY, 1976.

TEMPERATURE INCREASE, F SURVEY DATE,

1975 TRANSECT >5 > 10 >15 - - -September 5 Zero 36.4 19.7

S-1 42.4 27 S-2 34.8 17.4 S-3 33.9 17.4 S-4 34.2 11.5 s-s 29.7 9.7

I September 8 Zero 21.8 7.6

S-1 26.1 6.0 S-2 22.3 S-3 26.1 S-4 21.1 s-s 22

September 11 Zero 55.2 32.1 4.9 S-1 57.9 22.8 S-2 62.9 13.2 S-3 60.4 27.2 S-4 59.3 17.3 s-s 64.6

September 15 Zero 51.7 33.9 S-1 53.8 11.9 S-2 52.5 S-3 56.9 S-4 59.4 s-s 48.6

September 18 Zero 41.9 26.4 S-1 57.3 3.1

,·,:: S-2 47.2 S-3 44.3 S-4 34.7 s-s 34.9 1.0

September 22 Zero 35.9 28.4 S-1 44.8 4.7 S-2 39 0.1 S-3 43.6 2.6 S-4 31.5 S-5 38.9 •

Page 21: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

15. However on September 22 (Figure 8a), the isotherms near the boom

were nearly vertical indicating a very strong horizontal temperature

gradient. It appears then, that this boom configuration had generally

the same effect at Transect Zero as did the first configuration.

At Transects S-1, S-3, and S-5, the post-installation data

(Figures 7b, c, d and 8b, c, d) all indicate a less-severe vertical

temperature gradient after boom installation than be£ore. Once again

this implies that vertical mixing was greater after installation of the

boom than before. Further evidence of this can be seen in Table 2.

16

Even though Unit l was not operating on September 18 and 22, the temp­

erature distribution was such that the areas bounded by SF, lOF, and lSF

6t's were greater after boom deployment than before.

Page 22: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

17

IV. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS

The data indicate that in either configuration the plume

deflector boom with a 5-ft deep skirt did not confine the discharge

plume to the surface waters near the west bank of the river. Although

it appeared to work reasonably well in the vicinity of its downstream

end, the net result was that the heated effluent mixed into the water

column to a greater extent than normal. Part of the reason for this

bypass problem was that the boom extended only a few feet beyond the

downstream shore of the canal. This was a result of the severe boom

deployment difficulties occasioned by the force of the effluent water on

the dee~ boora skirt. It may be that this problem would render ineffect­

ive any moored plume deflector.

Page 23: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

APPENDICES

Page 24: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

APPENDIX A.

RIVER DISCHARGE DATA AS MEASURED AT GARVIN'S FALLS

MEASURED FLOW - CFS DATE (average for entire day)

September 5, 1976 1866

September 8, 1976 1738

Septmeber 11, 1976 1795

Sep'tember 15, 1976 1529

September 18, 1976 1958

September 22, 1976 2352

Page 25: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

TIME

0053 0155 0255 0353 0456 0555 0653 0755 0855 0955 1055 1155 1255 1355 1455 1555 1655 1755 1855 1955 2055 2155 2255 2355

APPENDIX B.

AIR TEMPERATURE AND RELATIVE HUMIDITY AS MEASURED AT CONCORD AIRPORT

DAY 9/5 DAY 9/8 DAY 9/11

AIR REL. AIR REL. AIR TEMP. HU~·1. TH4E TEMP. HUM. TH1E TH1P.

53 93 0053 46 100 55 40 50 93 155 46 96 55 39 47 96 255 48 100 55 36 46 100 355 47 100 55 36 45 96 455 47 100 55 36 48 96 555 47 100 55 36 54 93 653 48 100 55 41 60 80 755 51 100 55 42 65 70 855 53 100 55 52 71 53 955 58 87 55 60 74 38 1055 61 81 55 68 75 36 1155 64 20 55 72 77 35 55 71 57 55 76 77 37 55 73 57 55 77 76 40 54 72 61 55 77 77 38 52 74 62 55 73 74 40 52 73 64 55 71 68 51 52 69 76 55 69 59 81 54 66 84 53 68 55 80 52 66 87 55 66 52 96 52 65 90 55 65 52 96 53 65 93 55 63 51 100 52 65 87 55 64 51 93 55 61 97 55 62

REL. HUM.

94 97 97 97 97

100 100 100

80 62 49 51 45 42 45 56 64 68 73 76 75 78 75 81

Page 26: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

APPENDIX B. (Continued)

9/15 9/18 9/22

AIR REL. AIR REL. AIR REL. TIME TEMP. HU~1. TmE TEMP. HUM. TIME TEMP. HUM.

r--------

0055 31 100 54 40 100 54 45 96 0155 28 96 53 42 100 56 44 96 0255 30 100 53 40 100 53 43 96 0355 30 100 55 41 100 57 43 93 0455 29 100 53 41 100 54 42 96 0555 29 100 54 41 100 52 41 96 0655 30 100 54 43 100 54 48 96 0753 35 100 54 46 100 53 56 83 0852 43 89 56 48 100 55 62 54 0953 52 61 56 55 83 54 64 56 1053 59 47 55 61 20 53 65 56 1153 60 44 56 66 54 53 68 49 1255 61 44 53 66 52 55 71 41 1352 62 44 55 65 56 55 70 42 1454 61 39 53 65 56 52 71 44 1553 60 44 55 63 60 55 70 46 1653 59 51 55 61 67 59 66 56 1753 54 64 55 58 75 55 62 70 1854 50 71 55 56 87 55 62 75 1953 48 77 55 55 90 55 60 78 2053 45 83 55 55 90 55 57 86 2158 46 93 55 54 97 55 57 86 2252 37 100 55 54 97 55 57 90 2355 36 93 54 54 97 55 57 90

Page 27: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

····'!

APPENDIX C.

PLANT OPERATION DATA

Page 28: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~I,'.'

J.ll.ll y

.,

.J

:; .,

,,

l\; ll 12 13 14 l'.i lC ll l~

l'J ..:~ ) , '· ~ :2 _j

I•Y'

,I , . . ,_

:hJ ~~~<G~ r.a:_wt~ -f.8_l_ ~~-~6~:- -'!-~~;;·-~~ ~~J~-~~- I C0~!:/~~~216 ~s ~~7 ~-~~~- :~- ~~J~ I. --~i21ST~··2~~_;;,,~: 1~ ijj~--~d~~-:7i"- ~-,,' .. JVO MOili ! MO.'J2 I MOll I I M06~ i TOTAl : CYC I CYC f CYC I CYC l CYC 1 CYC 1. C"(( ! TU~fl I fXTR 1. AUX. ! A\:X : fC 1-.t'.N i

._;,,, ,:,;o".s : RuN · STAR< ~ CO·'-h · :;oor 1 cvAL 1 2A , u I 2c I 20 1 2E i 2r. · 1 2G ! ~rE..v·•· i AIJ1. ! STEAM . S1EI\.M ' ..:ott 1

, rtE . BLOwG 1 . , 1 1 l 1 1• 1 1 sT£AM : 1 TO 2 , 2 ro 1 sruv,, I ' l · .f . . · I I

_!10£_. !\l_l)()_ l- _XlO ___ ; X~v __ i__,:<j_Q_+-_-X_l. _;_~l~J: ___ :X.)2.._ ~-~-j_ __ Xl_Q__! __ ~l-~-- -~!O_l___!<.i0_____L2(!_~-if1CNO __ i· X_l_O _j___X_IQ ._ x:o -~_x:oo .. ., XIO<)O 1.100 t XIO l XlOOO XIOO i X\0 CXIO 1 XIOOC L. X100 · liOOO i

7.7~_,4 -- 2~n~; .1 l1F3 · ·z-f~-- --- c2T-133'4 2184. :IT44.--3Io4- 3IT64 ___ 3I9i -3i4s--3m- -3i0o""n4-2 · --- :1 - ·s·~- -- 24---- s)t--:·s.:.~. :~c;~ 112S 2U C27 133!, 2~24 3124 30,84 3GI~8 3124 3124 16~0 3(;76 ·lf5c4 ~~ 102 s·~ 4°5 .:.·:·'.:~ I.L./1:, llC;.; d: G27 13~)4 DC:Z 32~0. 31G0 3124 3224 3200. 7G8 3148 lGGG ;j 104 !.3 ':<)

:1, 2 :.:-.,::~ lL2 2L'· r;n l:JI~G 11146 3CCJ2 3':148 3~12 312 1-t 3023 107G 3j3~ 1G28 ~ 112 7\ :~·n 17J~ 1~:2 ~S7 ::~. S27 135C 1412 2072 8~!1 2584 2G32 2GS5 120 2C~n 119~ 0 12~ ~~ 283 li•72 1~,; i t}:Jl :lJ G'27 1354 133G 2704 0 2G1G 271G 268E 0 2G4C lj78 ~ 12'+ 'l~ 21t;) L-•,0 L., ~:.;r, :-'i.~ C27 13'•0 13:.if. 27a0. 2G0 2G12 2700 2GS~ C 2C32 1114 (' ~:. 7C. }!1~ .'C7;J nJ.J L ~~~ :2lU. [27 l3G1; 1733 2D3G 1976 2-?52 2~1\)r, 2~32 920. 2872 1430 J 1\1° 12~ 3n:; c"JY )"IJ0 U 2 7 l.l\ 'i25 1338 23\14 ~ 332::: 3284 321{4 33CS 3324 3280 32 75 D44 0 G4 ~, 0 c.13 2'h2 :JJcu 117 1_, 210. G25 13Gir 2276,;j 3284 3244 3208 324~ 3284 325f 3Z3G 1941; fi0 · l:}r~ ~~~ 54)

~~~{ ~g~ n~~-·· .. ~i~--·--·~~+--Hti-~~~~~-~li~---}~~ ~~-a-~·¥d-~%~~ -~~~i-· ~~i-1~~-~---~- --- .. ·st-- · g · t-~~ 2911) 3091, 1130 209 G27. 1328 2276 3276 3232 3192 3320 3276 3248 3228 1940 ~ 2~ -0 393 291G 3070 1177 210 626 1354 2258 3256 3212 3172 3252 3256 3224 32~4 1944 0 3~ ~ 382 2885 3033 1170. 210 626 1358 2232 3320 3284 3240. 3364 32~8 3132 2768 l91~ 0 30. 0. 373 21s2. 2s02 1147. 209 626. B.s~ 2ltte 320~' 31ss 312s 330~ 3072 29"~4 2'i2e 1s22 0 10 o· 34~ 2sr2 3020 1165 210. G2s 1326 2222 3204 3164 3128 324a 3228 3192 3aG4 1s92 0. 10 0 366 27~2 2932 1150 209 626 13s2 21sa 3152 3112 3076 3196 3095 3Gs0 2sse 1sss ~s 34. ~. ~76 77g4 2944 11so 210. s2s 1336 2164 31oe 30&4 3032 312~ 3112 3112 3104 1sso 0 s0 o. 4C 2803 2958 1152 210 626 1338 2170. 3la4--J072 · 3~36 3160. 3112 3116 31PC 1360 0 42 10 411 2712 291~2 11!~7 209 625 1354 215~ 3076 3036 3~04 3132 3~84 3084 3~8~ 1854 ~. 40 10 1~1: ~s:2 2952 1152 21~ 62~. 135C 2112 31~8 3072 ~036 3164 3116 312~ 3112. 1856 9 34 4 42! L~1c 29c3 11se 211 G2E 13GO 21as 3132 3092 3a6o 3134 314B 3140 3i36 1ss6 a 44 4 437 _JJC. 3:~4 1183 21P G2G 1332 2284 3272 3232 3196 3320 3276 327G 3272 Jq38 ~ 50 ~ ~44

''J: :·::;r, :?:1-:'. ::;:~~ 15~13 3236\ 1~!15~~ 75(2 6G2G 7315 75!~') 7!;7: 5[:~~~1 7205\ !<?'1~. 7 11~Q GP. 10:1 0

. ~ -- \ ' ' \ - ... , . ;

'-/Jo.f' : 231 ' I

,:j,:.! ! I COI'It.> 1 I

TANK I l ,, ~i® I I J

., .. I

I

I i t I

I

I '\ '\._) .L..t; ,. . -, !_.r/ '>, r'Y) C\ , ,}. ( \ r')

(\. . .·. "" \ ' i'\) ..... : ' '\ ........ , ~ .... \ ...... ' "' \'\ . ........ . -,.. 1"\..J 1'.' ~ ..

~ '', .... ' 'l ,_)

"""

,---- T~67:- r:'t~-·-,::f. -,!- ,:~ --! !:l ·,~;;, r- - r .':c -~- :.t~:~~r:~:;, -,~: ~ SH:Y SEIV I $fJIV !HN 1 i I l 1 : PH 1 I

Gm STA srA nt sTA I srA J Flt.:~o t>H i ?H ' PH 1 T!E 1

XIClO XHiO X100 I ~100 XIOO I. XI~ - ~ XI XI:. j_ ~~J_-~~L-.:~r-L ___ _

Page 29: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~ , i, ~ I'

,,

L '1

. 1 'l -'-• I • ~ •·.

E . ' 4J

'-, .. I

l:; I"

L.',.J.

::'1 i2

·./<~.~-~~~--''·-rl. \'·· c· V ~,\I I < ...._,

U'P(; ~ !. iil1

C"!.:: ~-·<1 0(, ~' :-H6 ll)

. -- - ...... - _____ ... ______ -·-- - . - .. - -- ----- ---; - . ·--- -- ··-·

COA.l. Fl0'.-'1 ll!~ [ '.>IE.AM HOW 2:~ 1 214 ~; ... ~,s -; 7i6 -r·217-T--,,Ii -, -2,9-:- 2io -T-i2i- · ·212

l8S

?l3 .. ~.;;: ',': .',A.080 'IIC:·W3 Mvb'!

t~. ,·,11(, ,~ · •·w· : STAR I

6&7 .W_)f31

._;)M

r1<: :no

"tlc ·,•06·>

1 .>(lOT

fOfAl

c ... .JAl

oc : CYC CYC ; CYC CYI... ' CYC I lURB 1- ~XT!! AUX

28 ; 2<;: 20 , 2E 2F ! 2G ! STEAM ~ AUX ~TrAM S !fA.'~ I I : !.TEAN I TO} ': 1·:) I

C'rC.

lA

>.1·.•.1 x:•x: ": :_,

)(l()(iv

-: , ·. "" 'r' ,. . i ; 'l ': .J.~. ~~}'-'--1 1. ..... -..~-

.' 'I:-'~ ) : ;~ 2 ll'J .1

.-:~~:,c .Jl\;:: ur:;;

XIO

XlOO -.,. ' ~.J..-

l'~ l ~:

C2f; G2'. c::>r

BLO'"'G x: /,10

, -·),... .L> '- ,, EGI. l3C!1

X l(liJ 11.10 )'.10 i l'iO XlO ! XIO 1

XIO , XlO X1000 ! 1.10 X'O X1 l ·--·- ---- ----- ---~-----·-------L .. -- ·------ -----·--t------ -· -'<1000

23,~2 32~2' 325\, --3fil}' 22?~ 3:~4 32~? 312~ 2~:1~~ 3:?G0 32!~4 32C4

XlOO }(10 000: >.1000 XlOO

334~ -33~'f4 · --3~Kr. 335;, i%1: 1 331: 3268 327r 32C3 1941 2 J)3r, 3205 3292 J282 1J44 ~.

r-",.,­").) ~I _..j, ·.r< ~~

- 1 ~: ;1::.~~ L.'2 .~lJ li:?S E:jr' 2311: :::3:::.2 3':..1'~ 32111+ 33G4 332;) 3320 331G 1?1+8 J ';4 L 1 .. ·~ ~11..:. l!')J .:Tl ~:22 ~:-::3'" 22'J'• ">';32 "';30,~ 3~G!l ::392 331+0 33'>1~ 2%4 1048 ~ ~-2 .· 1•· 7.]',1 11"-:; 11': i'r l"?l'/ )"':r.~ 77'lr< ~·)'It• 7')!.) 337~ 33~? 372'' 310" l')r·, •\ !.') ~ -.-J - .. 1 .... _ 1. ~... .... ~. \...:...J ..),)..._ .... ~ ... '- ~..).)L •. ) ... '-.j~ J,_ ,... L; )~ ..) u ,._,'-.(• ...1-)~ ""' "-+L.

LJU:.1 ?l4C l::u~ 21.) li24 2.j2Ci ~~23" :J32!.. 328~ 32GG 337G 333( 334\i. 33S8 1974 ~ 44 7

• ·:2 3~:;11- 1:~1 2B G25 1322 231, 2~ 33!•!, 3312 327G 33% 3356 335G 339G 1~72 (.:. ~~~

:.

,.. 'c

0 ""'"'" ..,.,. ··~-·--·., •; ·;; ~-- .. ~;.,-~---........... ;z----;:::~·-·•<o-·---•'"00 ... o••o-••,Oo'oO~:~·..-.'•••~_;.,-··;.;-----:-;:"'-----····· ·'''•""•'·-----~..0~-------------CO.;.o -~ ...... •Op.o o -----· _,,,, .. ,..,._, ______ '•' '' • I--' ... •.:.. )J 4L .:.lJL d,! ub. 134'~ 232i j.JOc, 327u 3240 33G4 3328 3328 3356 19t::6 ~ 52 ~ ;: 7L ..:82ll lllt. 21~ 6211 l:JGI1 2082 5% 3352 3398 3424 3400 3352 )1t~4 1782 0 ~4 ?')C2 271:~ lllZ 21;). G25 1322 · 20G4 80 34d0. 335fi 3484 3452 31~12 3460 1735 0 70. J~ 1 i 2750 1115. 209 625 1340. 2066 40 3416 3372 3488 3464 34~8 3480 1736 0 30 . 2572 2718 11~4 209 629 1358 2038 ~ 3376 3324 344~ 3412 3388 34~4 1728 ~ 20 257G 2722 1102 209 626 1326 2038 ~ 3376 3328 3416 3416 3392 3452 1734 0 44 2s10 2716 1102 210 s2s 132~ 204~ ~· 3392 3344 33SO 3428 34e4 346~. t734 76 44 2)72 211a 1103 21~ 625 1340 2042 o 34~0 33s2 33sG 344e 34~s 34ss 1734 32 34 .. ~.:,~12 1134 no 626 Bsz 21oL 20n :s14a J1es 3160 3192. 3172 322~ 1so6 o 20 ~2~ 3~~92 210 626 132~88 3240 3208 3292 3288 3272 3328 1934 0 30 2~~C 3;:JSj l18t1 210 625 1343 226E 324C_._32~0· 3168 326~ 3255 3236 3288 1932 ~ 3~ 202:; 3042 1182 210 G2G 134G 2262 3244. 3200 ·3160 3256 32~8 3228 3284 19~0 0 60 .:'J2,~ 3;)e0 1136 2~9 G25 132G 22~ 328::; 3240 32G4 3296 3288 3262 3324 1~44 0 32 211G-3jZiLJ130 2jq 626 1316 227Z 32!JG 3212. 3180 3268 326t~ 3244 3300 ·1934 ~ '• . :. :.~. ::;_;:.;r. lJ 77 210 G27 1328--rf~ 3224 3176 3144 3232 3224 3212 3256 1'325 C 40 '?.)~G ~ :1,2 117'.: 21~ (.27 135ti. 22C2 324!: 32~~ 31G~~ 325G 321~4 3228 3280 192G r1 20 ,.,) ~, ~7 ':''"'"r. -r.~ 15''1 -211 1 531'0. r:5.,.r; 7"7 7 77~::: ?ri27 7"1':'1'1 "'"~'1 717-r \ 1 ·,.1., 1 ,,_ IL> -~~~ ;,,~ I• J-~l ~~~ "(~ h v.Jr k /•;\) '~~l~~

' "' ~- '-? ~· . t'j 1\~· C\; ~- ,. \;... f\ ~1 >-') '} \ 'l ~ -f.: '\) 0\ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

'd'

,~

~--- -----?OWP KW <:lft!I1Hil ,\MPH<f:~

4 2~

14 4V. 10

4 10 0 0 0 J

J ,., v

.J !J

,, •'

i. 6itJ ~ 677 blP. ;- 679

COM

Ti.!

J'- ~-- R~A~T- --~·V·A~ I>"O ; t-91 I r ·'>i• -, 6¢~ 666 ' ... u,; 668

j;. i RU~o.; 1 START

,·~"-I Gf~ STA STA '

...... ~ l ~ S£RV i SERV .:...Jf\r..""'l_

RUN ! STARi

5TA I STA SUV I SEI!V

EXC

FlfLD

GEN

PH

l

RUN STA.;>T l.OM

PH

1

Pl1 TIE

I'H I I

:)• >J FAI·

<o: STE.4.M

XIOO

X ~ CXJ0

!:5 ! ~~

'I, ... I•; .... I· r •, ~

~ 5 ~ I {""j tlo.•, , .. ~ '),

4~ 3 J:

)L

34; 318

314 30€ 3~7 324 386 393 40!1

422 43:", !t2

433 ~~G3

Page 30: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

· ... (

L.: ;, ~ '(

.J.

L'. l 1 J. .

13 11 ~ ..

-l '''

I

·.I..C.

"-..::~·>y·z_;::~ .. ,r.~JY r :\~iH·:.J -- ---r· --·· --- .. --co..a:C"FtoY.. -Lis ___________ .·- --T·- ST£Att.aow ':.t.::.

"'' ~0~ 68~ :.;6 : 6o7 t:·tla· ~ -2L;---·1,J ·-:- ii.1 -:-··.ii5-: ~io ·r·-i17·~-2-,s-·r·zr9-+--2w.,. 221 ~-2i2 -~-?n · ~::4 ;,r :.-.oao '.'.081 i M082; ... Otll i MOM I lOTAl 1

,_,( . CYC CYC: CYC: lY( CYC ere· i rv~te I EXTR 'I A:JX I AIJY >(;rA!' I ! j I I

•, ,;Q•_;:,) ~ur• ~1ARi •. CM soar ((),..,~ )', :<6 2C 2D )£ 1 2F 2G s:TEAM AUX . STEAM STEA!l -~>l

TIE BLOWG : I i , 1 SHAM ' I TO 2 I TQ 1 STft..H

x;Jw .'( 100 X I(' X,10 . : __ X!Q __ j_ .~'-- -~--)1._100 + X\0 .• _ _xlO L_~lo _ _l_ .X_l~ _ _j_ X 1_9 _ i_ ~1_9 __ __l _X_l_~--+ XJOOO + X)O i X_!O : ;...' 10 , Xl(J(l ;.. !

;r. i00J" ·'-" ! --1' ,..·,. .. ~·~~ .. - .. ;., ,.J. 1--~3 1i0~ L ~~~r\ L. 3. ">" '· ~ "'1 C- ·-,.-zrW . . .;3~~-4· - ~'J·f'·~---- 3'>71" rt2 ,-;-:-~11 ~ 0003"' . XI~~ - ".~-JOO r. -- ~X!'~ .. l.1 ,

r:~ ·.·0 _...._,~.., ,: . .!.,... l;L') •t.,l LL.:]'.; ~~~.... )~._ ~ ~ .) J t :J ). 1 JL\..14 ~ -. .J..) • J L V .J. • 4 ._,'-4·; -

· :·· - 7~' 'l"~ 0 1'" '·')r 17' 7 (' 22"r. 7 2"! 32~2 3"~'~~ 3"1nr 3"n~ 32-1 7 ~lr 1g"34 " 7 ' ·• •.r.,. . ... .. -·)) " l ...... ._ ~..J v.t....V .J.). u~,.. :J t) f. ) LJ.J\J ._:J-....• Lt"...,.J .~ ~ ,J) _) .J,-1 • )..J.

'~1:.. ;.iCS F7J 210. ~)29 1322 227'j 37.C~ 321C 3181< 32~0 3272 32112 33~~ 1936 ~ S·L ~ .':)'1

~ .. :t.2 11 JC 2L~ u2S 1~4S 22S!.t 321~~ 3Fl2 3152 321~2 3232 321G 32CS l:J3~ ~ ~0 '" ~;:; 7 :1:, ~~r;~ .a:1 2:i." G2CJ 133r 2274 32:-;2 3212 :nc4 3272 32'18 32112 32j:. 1<"13!• '~ 1: ·:. 1~~~

l''::t, 3~7j 1177 21~ G23 133:,. 227'• 32G4 321G 31~1• 327':> 32f4 321<8 33~d 193S J ': 1: '.r:t) - •, ., :::::s: 1172 il.l G2~ 1332 2252 c:j3232 318~ )E2 32118 3223 321G 32G-:: 1~J32 0 32. ·i I· '2

~J .. -p;· 11)•' :-•n r:;o 13~..~-G ""f'·'"! 7J,..,7) 32-::: 0 32"~ -) 7..~12 32311 376.!": 3-)·1~ 1g5r. 'j 11 " '·7' I, I I"')' '- lo..Ll

"- ~; ~ ·: .:. fll •·'-'·''' ·' .... 1

I. ll.::.....; '("\ .... """\

..:...:. . .J.J

2~j3

2210 r; Q7r Lv.JO

2t.3G :2222 '"""'("--:-'"'"' L.i.,_;~

L2Lt2 23:..13 "~ 32 !~ : s 3 ~~ 2S~:

,~ I -... U u ·- .~o,. •· v- U L. J... •...J U - .... l- - ~i ._ ..... ...., t ~ ..... ·~ • ' .. p I

513:;-llg7 211 G2!J 1334 2326~3332 3281~ 3252 3)G8 333~ 331G 337G 1!J82 C 1\ C 1,75 3Jt~s 11'84 ----"2u:·-· ·c·2·s-1"TI.22"274 ___ ):5I~·f'· 3·rs-e-)2·5·2-)3-43--32'Gf-.. 32023:f32- -r'<J2~------·6 --~ i:r:·--- -~ · ··_r'J 1

~7r3 112J 210 G28 1328 20[4 33~3 3316 328C 3376 29fi8 2452 1C88 1752 0 14 1~. . 375 2() ,_,..,

-'U L

2958 2%0 2922 2908 2'374 293G .5004 23G4 2930 2C18G 29J4

115CJ 1151 1155 llSO 1159 1156 117g 1201 119') 1208 120G 120G

2ld 529 1322 2214 3132 314j 3104 3208 3176 3156 3180 1880. 72 ~ c 4~7 210 G29 !322 2182 313G 3092 3P56 3168 3128 3116 3132 1874 0 10. J ~38 211 629 1332 2196 31G0 3103 3072 3196 3148 3128 3148 1886 0 10 0 437 210 629 1332 2210. 3172 -~132 3092 3220 3164 3152 3168 1e9~ 0. 1~ ~ lt2 7 211 G29 1324 2212 317G 3132 3a96 3228 3164 3156 3172· 1892 . 64 0 0 414 210 G29 1346 2196 3152 3108 3072 3208 3148 3128 3148 1892 0. 14 0 410. 210 G29 1330 2270. 3256 3216 317G 3320 3256 3236 3252 1904 0 ~ 0 426 211. 529 1308 2336 3356 33C8 3272 3412 3340 3328 . 3348 1q22 ~ 4 e 443 210 628 1344 2320 3328 }~4 3252 3388 3316 3304 3324 1908 0 0 c 454 211 609 1332 235~ 3372 3328 3292 3432 3368 3352 3368 1914 a 10. ~ 47C 210 G~4 1328 2356 3384 333~ 3296 34~G 3372 3356 3376 19~8 B6 4 0 487 211 G3C 135G 2348 3372 3324 3292 3428 3368 3342 3360 1901 ~ ~ ~ 4J4

L'>·:. 3 -.. )~ 12ltl 2l1 G31 1332 2372 34~~ 33(4 3328 3!tGrJ 3400 338'+ 33S8 l<JC:3 0 ;) J 5'13 .. :: :,:, 722:0 22;~~ 5~4 1S:ll.; )1~2~5411o\ JZ~j 771~9 7GGit 7943 78:12 77Cr:J 77~ l 4523 2 28 2 l~~S

. '-· l) ,,, \._) \) L..)

: l.f'

}:il

.~Al

•. ,)

'""'' HQQ

T

I

) . ':;:/. ·---: -.....: ...__ ::r- ~ L) ;} c--..: '? [.....;: c.; L-j L J

L:, t)., ~ rn "'' 1:'.!'-. -~. "~ ....._, .I • ...__, -...r-. ''0 ' '

...., . /\. i ~ ") It) '"") (\) ''\)

0J

. -- ..... --·-----;-··---··r-·--·-··· ··---- ·r----i CURRfNT --- ~---~'?:vr~ ___ KW._--r----7 -~ ~---"~~~~~

6/6 i 677 : 678 i 679 ; 1

69() ! 69) I

I QIJN 1 sr.o\.RT 1 coM 1! 1 RUN 5TART 1

o----,.---- ·- -~- .. ---·. I ~.4 I 665 M6

: EXC I GEN : lllJN

GEN II SlA I STA 1 TIE . I STA 5TA

SUY Sif!V I I I SQV 5Eii:V

x1oo l x1oo I x1oo , x~oo I i xtoo xtoo

t FIELD l PH J PH

l 1 1 XI I XIO

t

XI

Al.\PHIES t-6'

SfAw;

PH

1 Xl

068

COM TIE

i PH I

! XI I.

Page 31: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

••,l.

GA<L >'

7

.J

~~~ ~ ·'"" 1 1 ...

J:,

- )

~7 1 '-' -0

~ I

' 't\~ •

#¥,19~ MERR!MACK STATION UNIT 2

WERC·Y ~WH COAL fLOW l~:) ~HAM FlOW l~· ·- 1 •• -- -- •••. ·-- .• - ·-- -----,-------·-·-~-- --- ., -- ---

cd~· t~s 686 687 6!l8 212 213 :1~ ; 215 , 21o 1

217 ' 21a 219

;,U 1,\.)b\J MO:l3 1>108.7 MOB 1 , MQI:l.: ;QTAL CYC C YC ' C'r'C i C'fC. ' CYC , CYC. CYC no rur;a

- -- -- . - ..,. __ -~21 77? ?:3 rxr~ Au:< -',·.x F() f < N

I I . CcN '-•RO>S ' RUI' ' ~TARl • COM ; SOOT ! COAl 2A I 2B . 2C ! 2D 1 2l '2F 2G S1EAM AUY. 'i<'fAIV S'fAY. iJ~·Il

:.Tli\N 1 ! I • ,

; lit . tlLOWG : I ' I : ') fb\f-1 I TO •·· J '2 ) r; ,

x1oo x1oo .: __ x:o -~_x_l~-'--~~o. 1_ x_1_ __ ~ XIOQ_f__luQ__l __ x_!o_j_~~~\J ___ ; XHi LJ5..'.P -~}(~~ _) xto ___ x1000 XlC• XIC " X~O-- > lo:J ~-Xl_if.;O, :. ______ XI~ _______ j __ XIO L ~-~~_L_. __________ -----:-;r--!t.l_tll? ________ --~ _ .. ><_,.:._XIO""OOO X lOOC X100 ' \XJO :

2~~,:- ':; 1 111 ::.~21 :!F1 • G2'J 132~ 24·.:2 345f 341G 33£,, 3512 3!;52 3112•., 34 . . 102 ,'1' ! -; . ."•,. ~J~C: U~:; ~~..: ' S22 1312 23'14 31!!-t2 31~:~1~ 33G8 31+% 34!!'~ 3412 3YlG l'JlG :.. )r.f~i 121~. 2 ~r. C17 Li5:J 23::11 31!32 33~2· ::>3:.S 3':7G 3~2:1 34r-:" 3YS lgJ:i . 'i 2l~; 1~ j'j ~;i7 Cl7 132S 23S8 34~~ 33G~~ 3324 3~!1-12 3YlC 33,> 337'• 1'10 "

;: . .:' -;"18 L~l: ~:JG C11? l3I1S 25ryC 31+4.J 3302 33~0 34-88 31.;32 31;"4 ~):~ l'J.;~ :'<c2 ·5;:1.:; 1:::.;· 2~'G 'il7 1314 237'J 31~:0 33G(; 332\J 3443 31t~~ 337f 33'JC 19~,~

' ..;. •1

(

~· -~ ,-(

" 22t:i, :;~~~ 12.~~ 2~7 :i17 133C 23S:1 ~337G 3332 3ZJ2 3420 33tl~ 33S2 Y572 lE% :~~~ 3~~2 12~C 207 Gl7 1338 235G ~3383 334C 33Cj 3432 337G 335C 337G 1233 3 '\;),~ :J~l8 121~ 309 Gl7 1322 2400\l 3452 3412 337G 3504 3440 342~ 3396 191!~ 0 -~::·,~ ?-~J6 ___ i2~-3~G0!J l31j 2408 3464 3432 3388-3438 34G8 3432 3420 -l':122 6 ~842 30J8 1214 303. 604 1318 2414 3484 3380 3412 3488 3480 3444 3456 1926 0 !lGO 292G 1215 303 505 1312 2382 3432 3400 3352 3396 3420 3396 3420 189~ 0 2722 2948 120G 3~2 605 132S 2370 3416 ,3368 3336 3352 3408 3392 342~ 1890 0 277G z04~ 12~4 3r3 603. 1342 · 2364 3412. 3368 3332 3332 34~4 3384 34~s 1sse o 2 7':1', 2'J5J 12~3 2~2 602 1320 2356 3396 3352 3316 3344 3384 3372 3392 1888 ~. ~78~ 2938 1203 2~1 602 1298 23G~ 34~4 3356 3324 3364 34~0 3376 3384 1888 0 27JS 2952 1193 201 603 1330 2328 3352 3312 '327G 3324 3344. 3332 3352 1882 0 2778 mL.1183 202 604 1340 ft.21.2__ 3276 -.;224 '3188 3264 3264 324R. 3264 1886 ~ ~7J3 2950 1173. 202 G04 1326 2232 ~ 3212 3164 3128 3220 3200 3188 3208 186j 0

,...,,"'( ~·

')~ ,,,, .... , .,., .)'; 'l'?

't:,. 4'J

4 .. ).t

20 10. 14 10 l:l.

;J I~ r1 ).<

4.

-~

J J

-<:

.. rC

-, (' ;J

) ~ ~

~)L r-,:'-

~·:7 ,J I /

-~ J,

"" t..J ' ... ..,. ~~ / I

------.r·----;-·c:-:.-,1 ·r.J\..1

~ ,. 0 ~ c ~ ,.

... ~ ;) c

415 403 339 372

3S6 3C4 352 356 ?-5~

~78C 2~3G 1162 ~02 G03- 1314 2188 3152 310e 3072 3164 3140 3124 3140 .1352 . :;:;,... 2J3~, llS7 2~Z G~2 1312 21711 3128 308r. 3Cl~3 313C 3124 31~~ 3124 185~ '7~~ :1:.: i1~3 202 G04 1345 2176 3132 308E 3052 314~ 3124 .3112 3123 1850

0 1('1 . ,.; . ' 3~1

1 4~2

· . ' ~:n·, :. l :L~2 2C3 CC3 13GI~ 227£ 328C 3232 3Bf 328f: 32c-~ 32:12 32f 3 J8r:. : · - ~ :: ~ ~ ~i ·:~2 1332 22'1!~ 33rl4 325C 321: 33,.;4 32~2 3?.7'2 :,zJ2 :~:;:

77 _,., •r,rz -l"r .... r~1a.. r,..,.,., 7n51 7"71i 0 'J'"" "~'I 7•'\·"'r.: "')14/ •r:-~ ·-·' JJ, .L·•· ) "·' l·'·~ (.l .;,.,~L -'1:? (>I~ v·~._ 0:'-TI b) (h~ -t:;)_.,

~ ' l\ ? "\ ~ ·~ . ~~~~~rr~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ "J ~

,.,,.

11

a ~

' tJ

]L llt ., •, _ _, , J, J. •

-·"

c 1~22

~i

~: ! ~ l l ~" I'-

.. f"'l-~'1

1 I'

.. / .- 1 -----r=.· - --- POWER --KW- -.. -- --l - --- p·. ------- .... --r-REACT KVAR:) j I .:l/11Rf:NT AMf'ERt~ l

• -6-76 I 677 ~- 67S-~-6j9~ ~ 1 I RUN I S'TART COM ,.

i r.I-N STA I STA m:

-b90 ! 691

~ RUN l START lj

I STA STA

!----____,.------·--- - . -- ------ • - -· ... -· ; b64 I 665 666 I b67 668

i ~XC ! G~N 11UN ·~TA!H COM

I FIELD I PH PH ' PH Tl~ I • I , • I PW 1

.!J'

(.,...~o_[

Page 32: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

!r'

\'·!

[_•,0. •, .,

1 . ~ .... ll 12 . , 1 I

1' ... .)

H:: l/ , ,.., ~u

ll ··. I

. l '~

' Vf.

'Mi:RR!l;t,::..u .. ST,t..1rv.'-J 'Ji,;, 1

- - - - - ..-i:"<f'<~",'f r:,\H COAL FLOW LBS ! 51EAM FLC\',

·:v. l.;b~ 6!3~ 68'J r-.~1 6b~ 21:? 21~ ;:;4 2'5 216 217 H!! 219 - t no n: 222

:, ·-I >t.CJoC' ,'J,()83 '''082 N.Oel MOIJ4 TC·TAt (~;_ C:C C'fC lYL ~1C CYC ere lvRo:! EXT~ AIJJ

GU" Gi<CSS ~I..'< STA><l COM 'iOOT COAL 2A 2b 2C 20 l 2f 2f 2G 51EAN. AU>. :. rEliM

Til BLOWG ' i S T~.A"'

X 10 ~-- )(!~. _XI~ j_ J5_10_ j __ XIO XlO . )(1 XIL'() I X!O . i- ---- - ·----- . - ~10 XIOX XIO .X ,.:x; \IOU <: i.l J<.IO

;..1000 XIOO XIO XIOOO ·[ X!OO )$10 OCiO j _ XlOOO

~~ ::; d::: .. 12~1 ,:~: ~:: l31G 2384 3l;~8 34:'4 33C4 3'~3G 34'+4 33SC 33'J2 1::0s .~::~.0 L~i;·~i 1:1~ 2~Z ~·N: 13:4 2JG4 3412 :1);.: 3328 338f. 34~:)4 332~ 33~Z 1~-2~ ::··,-. :·:::~ L~~-·~ .0.:"2 r,.,., 1:rr 2331~ 33(1· )312 327C 333:: 3352 333r; 33'JG 1?71 • ·J. ~;. ~J~ ~t 1.~·,\ .L ~~~~2 U;~··j 133~· 232lt 33U? 33~<~ 32G4 332~ J33G 33~lt 33Lf0 1S7~i L\.·._·:J 2J~~~ 1:;,.· ~-~2 .r~3 l)j,~ 2~~~ :~:!~It 3~2lt 31C3 323~. 3:~!~ 321}(; 32[!, l,?~!"t

~-.. ·--;:;:-;·:; -;-- , i "' ')''') r-<') 17·~·;.;-· ':}~---- '7"1 ~ 71nr 31ir' '1n" 3"'2" 7'l"r( 3')7') l"r" ...., . ' ' ) L ' \ ... -.. .... v ' I.- '-I - •I ' - ... .) .) .... I '- J~ 1 t u ~ ·,.) .L . t ..) ~ u .... . .J • • -" J L '- (.. .) ..... .._ . ' L ..) ·- ·. )

.:C·.L ~ )Jll J.l~i 2~2 C.J2 13~2 22~4 32G4 321G 3BI+ 3223 3256 324~ 32G:J 1f~~~ . .'J,,J i'l~-·. :2Jo 2~11 f~J 1332 2350 33SI~ 3340 3300 3381~ 3330 3360 33L;8 18GZ )I:; ·:,·;:;4- l2JS nG Gl5 13~13i.c'r3372 3328 3288 3380 33o8 3352 3372 1c:55 ? 312 2%J. 1205 207 616 13001 2342\ 3?;72 3320 3292 3376 33f0 3344 3358 1370 i81G 2972 1207 20G G16 1338 I 234j . 33GQ 3~24 3288 3376 3360 3340 3364 1872 27% _f~ 120::: 2'j7 616 1334_l1_;?]_~6 ."3312 3280 3372 3348 3332 3352 1872 27~C 2~SC 1199 206 616 1328~33~' 3276 3244 3340 3316 3300 3320 1868 2710 29S2 1200 207 616 1324 2316 3332 3228 3252 3348 3320 33~8 3321t 1872 2~v~ L9G0 12j4 206 617 1322 2334 3350 3308 3275 3372 33~8 3328 3348 18~0 2724 29r1C 12~3 207 Gl8 1308 2350 338~ 3332. 3296 339G 3372 3352 3372. 1884 2732 233G :197 2~5 517 1336 2312 3320 3276. 324a. 3344 3320 3300 332~ 1s74 2792 2944 1174 20G GlG 1330 ~ 3204--3156 31-2~ . 3220 3192 3180 3200 1355 :7:~ zg3J~ 1152 2~6 G16 1314 2150 31CO 3048 3016 3104 3084 3072 3~38 .1844 ~7~J 293r 11s0 201 GIS 1326 2154 31~4 3ess 3~20 3084 3095 3080 3096 · 1~62 ~~l~ 2~S~ 11~2 20G Gl7 1328 22CC 3168 3120 3088 3152 3164 3144 31G4 187E ~~:~-. 2J~:~ ll'o~ 2':\G G1G 1322 22111 3134 313G 3108 31G;' 3172. 3lr.O 312~ 1273

:,., ql .:.1.r~ 7 2 ~l G 1 S 1311; 222f l:;311JG 3152 3124 3241~ 31?3 317?. 3192 r:;;. G ~ ~ : . , 1 : . c; : .! 7 a 7 1318 2 7 3 r ~- 3 2 :J 4 31 s 0 3128 3 2 3 G 31 q z 310 4 3 2 ~~ ~ 1 e 8 s

' ' 7: ,., .. -·,,;·--:-~~-··-.:;·r----n.-,...---.. -r--.. --:-r-r~-..,~""""M'I')r-··-......,...,r"-·7· n~?··--.,-<:?.i'-::"--7"4' ----7--"-;1';1 '' ~': • 'i' • ....,. ~ • ·~ ... .., ._, •-+ ·' .._ - -t l • .,1l. · . .l ) \ J r )dA;) / J / I .,.. _l / I L :.; · l- J C ,, t: U .._) U I \,.. 1T 4 1l ~

I -,I l \) -:. ~ \:) .-. 'J ;:}, ' ' '

..:.,~ '1J ('...._ ,_) ' : "r'-? h; 21 , I . r-..., 1 - r- ....._. . '>) ,''l -;> ,' .. , "') 1'-:-..J ,,.._ r-.. \)

J.. r;.., '~'. ~ , V\ ~ ~ 'I '\. r}J ~ ' """' '1- '\-, 1'\ "h 1 _I ., ,.; 'I )

"-' .. ,<

,) -<

"I

:1 "' JJ

~

(' )J

0 0

76 ~ 0 0 0

a

0 ~ ~

£ .. (

1

rn Xl0

X100

"· • I

,'i;

7'.!,

.., . ~~. ., .)·

t .. T ,_. •

~~ 4 2::

30 20 2~ 14 0

24 1~ ~

4 ·~

}!~

1'• ~" ),.

'~ , ... i~ 0

:_,.'i. ~ , ... ---· -iO-Wf< KW ··;·

~--- 676·1

---z77---r-67s-- r-679-i ] .. :<tACT KVAilS

,-' ClJRPfNI 1--- --··-·· - -

Jl.V.?ER~:,

}j

GAc

lO~iC

~~ !

RUN i START ; COM II

GEN ! STA I! STA II Tl~ I ee.~u «tmV

r--69oT-m~ I I

' RUN I :>TART I I STA I STA I SCJl'V SfR'J I

1 664 · 665 o~,t,

i fXC GiN

1 r1ao J PH 1 1

~UN

PH

~6/

$TAP'

PH

r.O:)

::'?J A~ X

, H·A.V.

:<. 10

06¢

('•),\'

T If-

PH 1

rl

0 rl I.'

(1

0 j j

0 0 ,.. ,J ...,

. .... ~

<i

•Ji ,,

,. v

l-.:.

•c fA.,

~()1 ~

<. :r 'v"' Y. :cx.

•, 'Xl<J

! : '-~ ' ~

.• .'I

',., t

- d'

..,

' .., ,.. .... .')'

' \" -I~ •

338 384 351 34CJ 31~ 3 343 ~·4\. 34~

7 ;"j _.'.)

4~" :t27 ~l: ~ ., ? 14

': ;·1 ~ . 2 C·

Page 33: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~',j· j~/.t).r(.p lg;/0___ ''"-" 1 '";:~, v~;-;,;,_' · · -- - /_,.,--.· v r-- - --ENERGY KWH . . COAl FLOW lSS l STEAl·/, fLOW i.~

l . . --···-- --- --·---- ------·- -~----------- -----------------------_~----------- ---------~--- ---------------~---

(-8} 683. r-685 -:--~ 686 - i -6-S'i -r-688-- 212_1_ 213' ~"214 -r-n;-r -i\6--,1~ '2ti-1 2(a--r- 219_\_- 2i0 ____ i-ni -~;- -222- • m Ji• . I I .1 ! . f· f . j

·-.-.. "''' MO&o Moe:~ ! M082 1 Moat ! M084 1 lOTAl eve oc 1 eve CYC 1 eve I c·tc : eve i 1URB ! EXTR , Aux . .A',.'( 1 <tJ rM• G[t-.J GROSS ! RUN : START . COM SOOT I (;OAL ; 2A , 28 : ZC I 2D 1 2t · l 2f i. 2G ! STEAM ; AU)( . STEAM , SiEAM CO!L

: i i m i BLows; 1

' 1 i I r 1 I · ; 1 srt:AM : 1 ro 2 · 2 To 1 , sTEAM

,_ _ . x1oo L~-~~--: ~!?_j __ ~~o ___ Bti.-~ -j-~~--L~o _ _L -~o_; __ l'_IU_2.!_q___j_~p_j_~~-LJ<~-!'_(}()O_' _!.l~- i __ xto _ __j __ xto_ t X!Q9_ DAIL' xl?<XJ ____ j _________ xtoo _______ L_x1~---~~~ _i ____________________ !100 _____________ 1~1? ~j_x~~ I _x_!_O? ____ · xtooo_

1

J

I I

u

2R4E 23SS 1174 2~G G1G 132G 2234 321G 3172 313G 3224 3208 3192 3208 1884 C. 20 47~ 2~32 ~JJ~ 1131 206 615 1348 21q4 315: 3112 3084 31G~ 3144 3135 3156 1880 C 14 ~ ~:4 )254 30~G 11G4 2J7 G16 135!1 22JC 317: 312C 3088 3176 315G 3144 315~ 1S84 J 4 ~ 486 :':-.~G 3\'H ll~G 2d7 Glfi 1311• 221~ 3138 313G 31~4 319G 3130 3160 3180 1286 C 1 J. ~ 1182 ~,~4C 2%2 1157 7'10 Gl7 13LI 2JC1~ 3150 31~1; 3~72 31G~ 3136 3128 31li3 1370 0. S~ '1 1;]5 2250 JJJC 11SG 207 Gl7 1332 219~ 3164 311G 3d8~ 317G 3152 31~0 3152 1882 0 34. ~ 47 2872 3J24 115J 207 G17 1350 2204 317C 3124 3~92 3138 315G 3148 31G4 138G ~. 44 4 ~7 2374 3024 1153 207 616 1304 2210 3176 Jl32 3100 3200 31GB 3155 3172 1884 ~ 4~ 0 4~4 2~4G :~9G 1153 206 616 1342 219j 3168 31i0 3088 3184 3156 3144 3032 1880 0 34 ~ 4S3

1J LY~G 2JJG 1151. 207 GIG 1320 2180 3132 3092 3056 31GO 3128 3116 3116 1885 0 20. J ~50 ll 2840 2J8J 1138 207 617 1340 2138 3104 3052 3016 3116 3083 3072 2932 187~ 0 24 0 427 l2 2432 2576 1081 Z07 617 1330 1868 29P4 2848 282~ 2900 2884 2876 1452 1624 0 5~. 14 32 :3 2422 2564 1069 206 600 1336 1866 27~8· 2652 2620 2656 2684 2672 2672. 1620 ~ 30 10 275 l-1 2413 25GO 1069 207 615 1348 1872 270~ 2640 26~8 2612 2672 2664 2816 1618 72 50 2~ 263 l~ 2111G 2558- 1073 2j6 614 .1324 1874. 2812 2752 2712 2724 278~ 2772 2192 1620 0 2~ 4 ~55 1~ LS4G 2690 1097 207 617 1314 198~ 3060. 3008 2976 3~~4 3048 3032 1668 1710 0 34 4 273 17 2~18 3068 1152 206 617 13~8. 2196~3172 3120 3P88 3132 3152 3144 3152. 195~ 0 O. C 355 13 295G 3108- 116C 207 616. 1336 2228~ 3212--316~· 3128 32~0 3200 3184 3196 19§6 e G . ~ 368 ::r-- i1lc ""'3Pb0 1151 2C6 6!'7 1140 2lS8 3!S2. ~1J8 3'~6 3H6 31~4 3!32 rrtrrr!'91tt 0 o ~ 3r! 2~ 2S~G 3J5G 1151 207 611 1352 2182 3148 3l~C 3~68 312~ 3132. 3124 3136 1934 72 0 ~ 38J ~l J~4 3054 1152 206 617 l31G 2182 3144 3100 3C68 3112 3132. 3124 3136 '1938 0 1~ 0 398 ~2 Jl~ JCSO 1152 207 G17 133G 2186 3156 3104 3C7G 3116 3144 3132 314~ 1~32 0 14 ~ 4!5 ~3 lJlJ 3~G8 1155 20G 617 1336 2190 3156 3112 3080 312Lf 3144 313fi 3144 11J34 (. 14 ~~ 421

r , !.A ~·

~;3,' ll:J:. 2JG Gl8 1354 2164 3123 3(8(i 30'~8 30C~ 3108 31[.4 3115 lCJ:G :J 1~ ;; ';2'l '.1.' :~::-: n3:.. ';IJS 11477 320.1 \s11!~ 7425 73~c nn 73P3 73~9 73:.:- 7~3s l4tt4:L 1. :;3 s 07

1 '-> \) I ~ '~

'. ,,p ~3:

Gf'.L

•:ON:.l

TANK

-T

--;' ~ r:) J.. ~ ~ -~~ ·.~ -.,Sl ( '- ....... ~ .) --L ' _, '1' ,, I -

f ' "'· ~ ,_, '-.) ~ ''h '--7 ~) ').) . ? "'-) """) ' 0)

'6

rH --c~-- ~~~~u.~t,' .£:, l: ,~fj --f:fi::::: ~~------~~:----::;_ -~~ !f_-~:if'7~tl: ,~i-l G[N ., STA STA i TIE I STA I STA FIELD PH • ,H ! PH I TIE ;

SERV SERV I W1V SERV I I I I I 1 • i PH l I

Page 34: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

:l,'!

DAILY

i.

.,

·-'

~

J.J 1 , :...t

L.: !.)

14 15 1 ..

~ I

lcl lJ '1". _,., .., , ~- l

~2 .:__)

'!'1.",-\E

· .. ·. ,> J'..;'.~ .· '""J I l l"'" 5· · .·: - ./·'--' '··· .• :/r- L ) - . .

... ~---~~<:u\~ ,_ .. ~lf'.t•-.w,.-~ \...q'·-·. -

Er<fQGY _____ r'l.-t:l _____ ----·--- -~----------------- COAL FLow-~----- ----------T-- -----mA.ov-;f:i:ow-- tSS

- ·r r- r·-- ··t- ,_ ___ --···1·--""--·--· -~------ .. -- ·--, --·-- .. ---·-----1·----.i- -r __ ...:...._ ______________ ,--------

M7 :-tlJ . 6kl5 ' 6A6 ' 687 I 688 t 212 : 21J i 214 I ZIS ; 2\t I 111 I :/l~ ' 219 . };I) 221 I 722 I 27':, ! ~2~ :,_ r ~1080 /o/'06':> 1 MOB:> 1 MOSt

1 MO!l4

1: lOTAl : eve ~· CYC : eve : eve 1

1. eYe I eve : etc ' ~ur.s ' tXTP. AUX ALA rD FAN . l ' I ' I

,~EN -~I<O>S RU~< i START ' COM ; SOOT COAL I 2A ' 28 I 2C ! 2D I .lf I 2f 2G ' STEAM ' AIJX I ~f[AM ';l~,AY, COIL ' I TIE i BlOWG I I I ' 1 ! I ' ' 5\tAN I l TO~ 2 TO : STEAM I

XIQO •. Xl()() f -~0- l __ X10 ___ X!Q_t _ _2-_l __ t-_2(]()0~---~l_Q_ L_~_Q____._ __ ~_q__l_~,~- -~~L~~.L_X..!.Q__L~_lOOf?_ ~--~)Q __ J X!Q l. X_10_ .. _>sl_OQ_4

x1ooo ___ L ____ !'~c_>O-----------~~_j_x~ooo_l ________________ !~oo ___________________ l~o_()()()_L_!l(lOQ J ___ x1oo Xl(XX) J

-,;..,:, ·-. J 't

~d.~. ··; r ·, 1 '') - .i.L

t.)l,.)\.)

.: .. ~~4 L '-} ~- ~: 2 ~)I~ ~3:2L

L~S2

:ss..: 2s:,~

285G 28G4 2353 2

,.....,.., OLU

) • .. ) ""!' .­.... u.JU

2~'JL 21J:J4 2900 2g1G 29>:~11

L J~ ~~ .:J3~ ')--,'1:,

. ·~ ) l

CAP ,-- 2JI

Gt\l

'.ONU

'ANK

2S2~ J:i~ ~ 21) 7 C17. 132 G 2113 30t. S 301G 2n0 30;)4 3d4It 3~7JG 3 :l48 12 52 a

;Jc~ l!~G 2~Z GlE 133C 21g2. 3168 311C 3088 3112 315G 314C 3152 1932 J 3JG2 11S7 2~7 ClE 135C 2188 315G 3108 3030 312C 3148 3132 3144 1S2G J 3.~:s 1151 2~7 Gl0 135f 2170 3132 3\JS'l 3j~2 311G 3JlG 31f~: 31~3 FJ?? J 3~) t: 11):; 2~ 7 CIS 1350 218 C 315 2 3100 30G2 31~1C 313C 3124 313G 1": 2 0 ;;:~~~~ llSS 2,17 G17 1350 2192 315C 31C8 3~7G 31G~ 3148 3132 31 1•4 1')14 ~ 2CJ3'; E3<J 207 Gl7 133C. 213G 3r17G 3032 2992 3~% 3~5G 3~56 3~r:~ 1SE2 72 ~S7:!. 1133 207 G17 1364 2116 3040 2996 2968 30CB 3032 3020 3028 1e74 0 3000. 1137 207 617 1346 2144 308C 3040 3008 3112 3063 3~GO 3072 1888 G 3000 1147 20G 617 1334 2166 3112 3072 3040 3142 3103 3096 3100 1885 0 2908 1140 206 617 134~ 2154 3096 3048 3020 3128 3p88 3~76 3~80 1834 0 300G 1144 206 616 135~ 216~ 3108 3S64 3032 3136 3~96 · 3~84 3092 189~ 0 3011~ 1145 206 616 1360 2166 3120 I 3068 3032 3148 31~0 3~88 3100 lSSS 0 3C08 1143 207 616 13.20 2162 3108- 3060 3-~28 31t•8 :51013 3084 3M2 1888 C 2978 1142 207 616 1356 2154 3~88 3~56 3016 3132. 3092 3~75 3~84 1£88 ~ 2986 1142 207 616 1336 2158 3104 3056 3~24 3136 3~9~ 3080 3~88 189~ 0 3042 1147 206 51G 1348 21s0. 3128 3~ss :soss :nn . ._..3f24. 31~8 3124 1918 0 3054 1148 207 616 1328 2190 -3148--31~4 .. 3~72 3192 3136 3124 3132 19~4· ~ 3~50 1154 207 616 1360 219~ 3156 3104 3~64 3188 313fi 3124 3136 1932 0 30GB 1161 214 61~ 1334 2204 3168 3120 3092 3204 316a 3144 3148 .19h2 0. 3060. n5e 248 494 1358 2192 ~ 3152 · 31~8 3072 3180 3140 3132 314~ 1942 e~ 3,!78 llGl 23'• 4G4 1344 2204 ~ 3176 3124 3~88 3192 3160 · 3144 3152 19112 ~ ~ ,.S4-: .. 11.01: ____ ..7}~. ---~§.L_1JJL]?c£ll~_:n.f1.§.._211£__2_d8~_l130 .3;t.2.£~.- 2Pt!.±._.?.l~~~ J93f:~·----"·_Q_. :n11 ~- 1133 234 1>G4 133G 211~ 3·144 2988 2950 3r5G 3~23 3'110 3:2:1 l8St1 :~

72S: 27-:-':J :;;~3 1422 3223\ 520-~6 743~ 737,: n;: 752,~ 746J2 7432 7452.\ !•S?: 1

<:)',_ Lj" Cl:) \)',. ..,> : j' ,~ .... • ',- "'-·. "' ' ryl ' -." '(' 'l) ..!'- i'' <'<... •'\:· '"":! '~ 1'\ '\ ~ .._} ,,'- .... ')) ·""-

1'~ ~) ')_)" ..., :> ) /\-,

2C ~· ..... , .... 3G 41~ }!1

i4 42

4G

~

'-'

.I

I ~I

J

,..

r1 ~

70 ·< :; ' ;..·_

I; 0 10. 0 10 0

4 ~ 4 0 4 ~

14 ~ 4 0

2~ 0 0 1728

"

a. 672. 4 0

22. 0 ·2 j :~

~-· ·- ·- ~- ·-·. 4'f l'+ i;5 ,...,, 1

........ .1.

---T- ----1

1

u--T-:~,-- :,w'( :::---~~~- -·-·p--~ii;._c17v;i.iS

1 r:l RUN STAAT COM i ,

- - --:· - cURRffiT AMPE~ES

I I ' GfN STA I STA Tl2 l l STA j STA *'-' Sl:-iV $UV SERV

~--66:~--T--66:;;-- 1- -666 -r- 667·---·w.--: I 0''. i GEN ' IIUN ! START ! COM I

FIELD I PH i PH I PH ; TIE I I I I l • I PH 1 I

1: !) :.:·(" ~.Ju

1tS7 !·73 i•7G /,~..., .. ··-.

!;3l; 4<]')

!t55 422 407 395 383 374 367 357

:,sg 3G5 372 405

427 43S 443

I~ 3 7 11, ... --,_,-I

-

Page 35: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

r· . , /_;_,,_,,. ,f· ~~ .. · · C{ /- .(.~~dv ~I/ ~ vi _!. ' /~ fj .. {.:I,.] ___ ,- .

4 t' , . 4. -- - --- -- -- ------·- --- - ----------- -----·- --- -

ENERGY KWH COAl FLOW lDS . STEAM ROW l~ ) <.8:.-.-- --b&J ·- 6i;5- ~ 686_1_687-r 688 f 212 ! 213 T 214 , 21s 1 216 ·r2i"J"rm ~-2i94·---m-j2il--r 222--~- 223 · r n4 ;

'I'·" ,., r M.oa0 1 Moe::J I' M082 ! Motl I MOM 1 TOTAlf)Yc 1 eYe eve I ;:Jere I ere t CYC l CYC i ru~e i EXT!?. 1 AUX i AUX ! FD FAN ' GEN GRoss : RuN . START 1' coM sooT COAL 2A : 211 2c 20 lE 2F 1 2G 1 ~TEAM j AUX 1 srrAM : ST!!.AM , co,L ,

1 / ' TIE ~OWG . I STEAM I TO 2 'J TO l 1 5TfAM '

' -- ·- ''"" . _x•oo __ ; __ ,,_j_ _X] 0 XIO Xl XlOO XlO I XlO I X 10 1- XlO . - XlO I XIO I XlO J ~""'-+--'" I mX!~~o -+--x 1<!<_ I L ?_A:tY_, Xl\)Q() _ -~----~~ XIO XIOOO, __ XlOO __ ~O~L~1~:=] ____ X100 ___ 1 _X~~J

' .L

-.)

lt ,. .)

2 8G2 3~11C llGC :?3~G 24 7;1 lCSG lSlZ 1G48:- 92S t.:, 73 3~3~ ll4:J dlG 3070 11G0 22 ':!if 3;14 !.': llGS

7 2~24 3078 1171 : ~912 3CCG 11~9 _ ~902 3C5G llGG

1~ 2~12 3dG3 1178 11 L92o 3078 1169 12 2942 3084 1169 ::.::; • 2~li!O 3032. 117~ 14 294G 3088 1170 !~ 29J2 3056 1166 L 2~GG 3020 1160 l/ 288G 3040 1162 10 2890 30)0. 1165. 19 280G 3C5C 1179 2J 2112 3076 1183 ~1 ... .J3J. 3094-_ ll9lt 1.~ -··- ~·:J22 -3.G7S-ll9S

.., '· ' ...... , ..,,..,r,., .ll4 .)\ .. t

~~~J~ y.~.~~2

r-·· . ' I I .J 7, ' ,

..:.. ·~ ~

1J. 0 7 117!) 277G

23.4 233, 234 233 234 234 233 234 234 233 233 233 234.~ 233 233 234 233 299 309 31~ 3~9 2158 2CG 2~7 5Gl

c:~P _) ~3

GAL

:OMJ I '\NJo... I

--- . --1 ----r--·

I •,j,•t

I I

464 1328 2204 3172 312~ 3088 3192 3156 3148 315C 1914 0 46 C 4G7 464 1358 1784 2?.64 1524 21s~. zsGs 284~ 2032 283G 1570 1 44 zv 335 4Gs 1348 1304 2s92 26~ 2s~4 2584 zss4 e 2548 1112 , 4f 44 1s1 4Gs 1332 2220 3236 3184 3156 3232 3232 2936 322j 1928 o 32 3a. 493 4G6 1328 2216 319G 3148 3112 3184 3184 3172 3176 192G 0 43 4 SOG 4GG 13G4 2194 3164 3116 3084 3152 3143 3140 3148 1916 0 42 24 506 466 1348 2210 3180 3140 31~4 3172 3172 3164 3176 1922 ~ 44 4 504 465 1332 2200 3176 3124 3~92 3152 3164 3148 3152 1918 0 . 3~. 10 5C1 465 1354 2188 3148 31~8 3068 316g 3132 3128 3136 1922. . 0 14 10 491 465 1334 2228 34~3 3160 3124 322'• 3192 318~ 3192 1922 0 34 4. 48~ 465 814 2205 31/6 3128 3~88 3192 3164 3152 3160 1922 0 42 1~ 445 466 0 221~ :us~ . 3135 3;J9o 32~0 3Iss 3160 3168 1924 0 3a. 0 422 46s . a 220s. 3112_ ,3132. 3~92 3192 31~s 3152 3160 191s 0 34 4 4~2 466. 62 221~ 3184 •'3136. 3l~d. 3196 3164 3156 3164 192~ 0 14 94 377 455 13~6 \2f84 3146' . 3G'92 . -3064 . -3164 . '3128 . 312fS .... 5128 . 1912 • 0 4 4 363 464 1352 ~158 ·3116 3060 3~24 3124 3~95 3084 3G92 1910. ~ 4 238 35~ 465 1352 2174 3132 3UB~. 3~t;8 3148 3116 31~8 .3112 1918 ~ 0 · 430. 342 595 n46 . ~19~ 31S6 -~1G4 ·.·3~72 3168 3140. 3128 . 3136 1W4 . -~ - 14 1~~ 342 s1s 1360 ~242 ~22s 3180 3144 3244 3212 3204 3208 t93a s. 22 ~ 357 615. 1316 2264 hS252 3212 3176 3276 · 3248 3236 324~ . 1935 0 20 ~ 370 615 131s· 23i~.§3324 3276 3240 333G 3316 33a0 33~4 1940 0 30 ~ 386 ~1344 2318 3344 -3300 3264 33D8 3332 3320 3324 193G o·- 2t 0 ~r-615 1350 2313 3348 33~0 3256 33¢4 3336 332~ 3328 193q 0 24 ~ ?:92 615 1358 2268 3268 3224 3184 324S 3256 3248 3252 1Sj2 n 26 C 38G

1219 277j l52Ct~ 759G 7134 739G 7€02 7562 7174 7551 \4436 0. l6 103 ~78 ~ ~ ~ ~ ''-' ~ ~ q ., .-~ o..· - ~ : ~ ~ "' ,-, -; Jl (.;, l

-676

.. I

Gf.N

(') '\ ~~ ~ 'i\) ~ s 1'\ (_; ( 1 I . ,

? J rq ;;; ~ ~ 1\j ~

POWtl KW RfAC'T 677 67i 679 690

RUN $TART COM RUH

STA STA TIE STA

S!:llV av SU\1 ,, --- .. ~-

--KVAlS

691.

STI'\ItT STA satV ·-~- --

(; 3 "7 \ )

~ (1 l' I ' :;, t: '

" I 3 ., I 1 ,: '

---r-· --- --- -,-1

r·-- --r~-~,~__,AMPERE~-r---i· I 664 60S b66 I 667 I 668 I I

FXC GEN RUN I $TAitT COM ! FIELD PH PH PM TIE ! : ··• -~• ~- l vi• • ~. l I

Page 36: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

,,;· ·,·,c . ,,.-. --~ . ' . ·' - ···l't:_. ' ,/· J ' l I ~. .... .1:: ~.

'i ~

, .. lt..i\ :-..111'\/-\';,.. : ... ...;•r\I!V ...

Di\Hl

u

I

l . , .!..'

1 , " .. 12 :3. 'I, l.'t

J !, . ./

:.J

17 "j '• .J..-.i

:·J I

.:.\.! ., ' ..... .:..'.!.

''I'

(,•:::

K~~ -- ---- --- - r-· .. ·--·---- -.--- --co-.L-flQW .. - lBS ____ --- ·· ---- --,------STEAM flo·..,,·- --lt,~ ----- · --

·•- -·-- .. -----·· .,.____ -·-·-····- -r-·-··-•·-r·-·--·-- 1 -·-• -· -· f"· • r -~ • • ·- --•-~--- T-- -•- --....,.-- ----68~ Ct!6 6137 I 638 ' 212 : 21~ I 214 ' :215 : 21~ 1 217 : 218 :.!19 I ~20 I 221 I 2'11 ! 223 I 22-4

.V.\Yd'J ..... 082 t.10d1 ! MOU..t : 10TA\. ' CYC I C'YC CYC i CYC j CYC , CYC <YC : TURf! j EXTR ! AU.X: , Al.i<, 1 FD rAN

Rv: 5TAP' .... oM ·oo• 1 COAt , 2A 1 :.zs 2c , :.:o 2t. ~ 2F 2G STEAM I AUX I SltAM STEAM ~ COIL

f,_,Ei'CY

t-f!] i "l,'.)Fy)

-..JtN. GQC~."· I

Xr()() .<JOO ' .. + _ ~~c _____ XIO ~. X!_9_J _ _x 1 ~-+ .. J<_loq_ ; ___ >~.2 ... l~ ~0 _ _1_ ~o-. L.l'J.~ ·_LxlO _ ~ __ !-_1_9 _ l_ x 1_0 _t_ !-1_000 ~. _x_1_~ ~<! .. j_!-_l_<;~ _ _j _ X!.Q<?__

Ttl: ; BL.OWG : I : I i ' ' ' STEAM±' l TO 2 ' 2 TO 1 I STEAM

Xl(l()O j _ XlOO ____ ._j_ _ _x~~ X1 000 _[ ___ .. _ ·---- ----- ___ X_l_CJ? _____ ---------- ___ _ _ _ _; -~-10 ~_l ~-:>00 ______ ~-~~-- ___ _L XIOOO

. .l\.1 L. ;;:.~". z:·c G~:- n2z· :: Ct; 3320 327G 3240. 32!J2 3308 32<;C 33~1t 13% c L '; ~...-~ ~.J ; · ll !2 ;.:'~7 r,1c 1352 2 3!, 3202 3/4~ 3212 3252 3233 32G8 377C lCJ\12 0.

' • r ... - ' '17 1·•r:n 2 .,,. ..,~2' 3~7" ~"!.;" 327r 7 3 1 ') 3""~') 7 3" 11 ln:<g r' .. ~L..', ) ,_;., .·...:. )/ ... ~'..; t, )Jv . .,.) .J:J 4 £. L. )i. ·~ U ..J l,v L:J- ...J -..... :J\) )..1

-( :, ~ :. . : ••: 1: · 3 2 ~ 7 C l G E ~ S 2 2 '1 3 3 312 3 2 C 3 3: 3 2 3 2 (1 S 3 3 0 ~~ 3 2 r:: 2 3) ~ C 1 ':1 12 r. ~

tl2 4~ 34 10

: .. ::;r; ll.)3 :~C C.1G 1348 22C2 32CJ2 3241; 3212 3252 3284 32G? 327C l'HC C 3G

:i , . " ~

,. '.J

~ -'·· ;~ ~.~:~.:, E· 'l 2~7 c;lG 13C3 2238 32% 325G 3220 3258 3283 3220 32[;4 EllS 0 24 0

402 4~~ 401 4C3 411 4}g

.'2'.•!; - '!,S l:!J'] ~~:_. GlS 1340 Z2G4 32G~ 3220. 3188 3232 3250 3211i; 32)2 }.g14 0 1~ ~ 1;2 ~.<:-;~. ;:~32 1123 2Ci.~ 611 1352 2260 325G 3215 3176 32!}0 3243 323f 32t~0 1918 ~ 14 n 425 ~CC' ~:38 ll72 2~G Gl5 1346 223G 3224 3180 3140 3196 321G 3196 32011 1912 0 24 0 422 .._,_,;_, ·.,~q2 un 20c 615 Bss zzsz 3236 3200 3160 3240 3232 3216 3228 1916 a 10 4 416 ~~i2 3J44 117lt 207 61G 1350 2252 3244 3192 3160 3248 3236 3220 3223 1914 0 4 0 412 2872 3021~ 1170 206 617 1368 2234 3212 3172 3136 3220 3204 3196 3196 1912 ~ ~ ~ 4~5 !H90 3042 1174 207 G15 1348 2252 3240' 3196 315~ 3256 3232 3216 3228 1920 0 50 4 397 21~: 3CG0 117G 206 617 1344 2258 3248 3204 3164 3272 3240 3228 3236 1928 ~ 4 0 398 ~8J2 3044 llG~ 2~7 617 1348 2236 3216 3176 3140 3232 3204 3196 3204 1918 -- . ~~ 0 ~38 ~~92 3050 1171 2~G 617 13G5 224~ 3224 318~ 3140 3244 3212 3204 3208 1946 f lQ. ~ 436 2~32 3CS4 117G 207 617 1332 2266 ~3260 3212. 3176 3276 3256 3236 3240 1962. 0 4 ¢ 439 294C 3092 1174 207 619 13G6 2264 ~ 3256'- 3220 3176 3284 3252 3228 3240 196~ 0 . 10 ~ 1~5~. i'~_~Q.- _3Wit ... .l.~9~£Q.G .• 61JL.J.35G_2i_f.? ~ ??1!..3 .3.?.~1t_3Z.§.Ll3§LI3_4i 332i 3)36 19f&----J_8 14 .~ J;;_?_3_ L'J:JJ. ~1~4 lf53 ze7 G19 00 2314 3"'332 3284 3244 3356 332 330 · 3315 . 1952 . ~ 24 o 4 79 ,:<l'' 3;;p llJ:' 2C6 617 1346 23~0 3312 3260. 322j 331:~ 33~r. 3280 3292 1928 0 14 4 48 ~28~ 3~~~ llEG 206 G18 1336 2288 3292 3248 32jS 3312 328~ 3268 328~. 1918 0 10 0 510

., .. ;;~:::2 11~:0 2~7 G17 1382 22GO 3255 32J8 3172 3268 3244 3223 3232 1908 0 16 P 522 ' 3 ': :, , 1r ~:~7 :.J.CJ 1335 225R 3252 321'14 31~8 32G·:i 324j 3228 3232 1r:"g ~ sr. Hl 524 . -:-·) ,.--:-.., 411' 1!·7rl ~7 1 •" '"I'"'~ 7"5·"1 7744 7r:5'· 784' 7°"9 77'P' 7{'13\4"15 1 r.:- " lt1!C' ,_ .J.. ',·._ .· -•-.)/ .. ..) -'-I . )_•t,. \J ~;)~ U ,; , 4 ' ..J Ut- } U ,1 'f:J L. !·..1

' L I I

~"' I ~ (" L- ' ) '-. .,.., I '" ~? .,- ) J. ·l' ·.'

C~i'

,~.

GA~

CONl)

--r·----··

, f'\ 1\• . I ~· .· . J

r\<"' ~: \ ~~ . '" "' \J\ \)--, ,/'\, •J\ \-1'), ......_ ,.,_., \)\' ' •. 1

) . ) .) /'\ '>) "'·-' ') ' )

~

'd~ ~ '.\ ,x

"'))

-rl. -- -~~·· o7:·l- .~"-·It~::, I ,:-11. GEN STA Sr.t. TIE I

I S[~V S~V .

T 'RiA ct . . -J(..,-.A.i?S. T- -·--,- - ... -.. . . . - cliifNr--AMI'fREs -· - - - :·-

t-m-T69l"""'l r-"'T .,, I ... I "'I ... ---j l ltt.'N j STAll exc

1

GfN I RUN sTAJtT I COM 1

I' STA I ~TA I FIELD PH PH PH I TIE : $-UV SlRV I 1 1 I I. I PH 1 I

Page 37: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~~1e

r, \\t

[\~ii "f

~

~ '

1:.: ,.., '·)

. ~ , . ~· 1, _,. . , " "'" l'l

•- 1

~~..'

' '

~--r~'" ~ o , \·a\~~ Nit:.RfW>w.--r- ST h1 .-v,\1 LJ. .. . .2

ENERGY ~'WH --- - - ~-~ --·- - - - - -- --COAL-FLOV-1 ----LBS ·- --- I STEM'. fLOW

•'Al2 683 68'; 68~> bS7_T_6llB _ _,__ __ 1h····--il:l·-,-i14 '215--:.-1i6-~ ·2-!7 ---:ila·-r--21-9 •·-na·'--221 1··n2 · ' ' I I . I

NET 1 MOBO M0\13 M082 1 MOB I ! M084 : TOTAl ;,. ' ( cr::: : CYC ' CYC . CYC CYC. . CYC 1 VRB EXTR .<>.U>.

I;~·

:'? I

A. ~

C£1'\ I G'<O:.S RUN 5TA11l 1

COM : SOOT ; COAL 1 2A 21l 1 2C 20 2E Lf- ZG SHAM AVIC 'oTlf..',• o 1 fA~· i TIE : BLOWG I I ' ~ :· I I . STfM~ I 1<: l ·. 'C '

,v,: 00 ; __ ~ :__()? __ ~ X 10 _X ~-0 _ .i .. ~!0 _11_ X_~ ---t _ X_!OO ___ ~-~~~--_!_ ~.!2 __ j _X _1_9 ____; _ ~l_Q__j__X 10 _L.!<~O .L . .!- lQ_ -~ v•'· i\J"X ~ . XJ.G X t:, > : .;

X\000 _ l_ _ _ ~~-~------ , __ !~~--LX-~~~_L _____ --·--- ________ ..... ~ -----------· _______ .J!lO_OC-0 _: Y.IOOO X.lOO

{. u ')[

.~ .. ' ..J 4 •I

-' J'i ···'('I:

•. •,,.. I

3 0 s 2 . 11 'J 4 : :; 7 :: 1 'J 13 5 2 2 n '+ 3;;:' ·.1 '3 2 G 4 3 2 :.: c 3 n J 3 2 s 3 2 ~ ~ 2 s 0 1 (') :. ·: ,;_~s~ lE:J L.;7 u::; 13-% 2272 3220 3Z3C 32C4 32;:~ 327 :;20" 2C4 :1,::, -:;:,!;i llP: 2r,7 C17 137i; i?r·0 32C:! 32Li ?il7G 3223 32!~?. 32'3'" 3.~!;.~. lQrl~. )T:3 1177 .2\1C Cl7 137S 2254 <::.)'3257 32~;: 31CI! 3222 323C: 322:~ 3232. 10.~j

·< ' .,·, .. :,I_

'. r I•;.

J -:.~

(I

'- )~ ~ . : ') ~. 2 -' 'J;~ :r

3~74 lL:. 20S Gl7 13/(i 22n~3200 324:~ 3102 3272. 3~::-C :2~-c 3~.~4 lJlC '" ~:f ,. ~\;'!G-11-ll 207 Cl7 1350 23')4!:? 332.1 327C 3232 331C 33~:; 3:S2 33~1: l?l.3 s~" ~~; .

,:_ ~- u

' ' ..... •.•U\...o

227G 287G 287:; 281.)8 223C ~ ~}J~

2£']4 .:.o7~ ·)"' r . "- ~) J \.}

r''J4 ~~<!.~ ·11' I ·- _, ,) ~ .

·, •)• .._ -'..J',.;

I.; ' :~

)

c /.p

'1.)•

I;,~...~

.:oNo 1

~~~(-Jftz ~i0~~-~-~3~~~~3~-~~~~~~2. :zs~~~-·- -~---~-- · 1~ 3;JC~ ll7'• 206 Gl7 1364 2280 327G 3240 3200 329G 3272 3200 32G3 1912 3G38 1171 207 G17 13GG 22G4 3264 3215 317G 32G~ 3244 323G 3244 l~~~f 30~8 117G 207 617 1348 2280 3230 3.240 32C4 32g2 3272 3260 32G~ 1912 3CZ8 11G5 206 618 1364 2218 3196 3148 3116 3204 3180 3172 3176 19d8 3~30 llGS zg7 618 1364 2226 3208· 3164 3124 3208 3196 3184 3188 191~. 305~ 1172 207 615 135~ 2242 32Z8' 3184 314~ 3232 322~ 32~1~ 32~8 1916 3048 1170 209 618 1364 2242 3228 3188 3152 32~8 322j 32~8 3212 19~8 3C54 1170 211 G25 1348 2246 324~ ~0~ 31G~ 3176 3236 3220 3228 1~12 3J42 llSl 211 629 1342 2262 3250 322~ 313~ 3204 32G4 32ij0 3248 191~ 3C22 1165 211 629 1344 222~ 3196_ 3152 3112 3188 3200 3180 3184 1~1~. 3~C3.-11G5 211 629 1364 2214 3192 3144 3108 3172 318" 3168 3172. 1912 3~43 1177 211 628 13(G 2254 3248 32j~ 3164 3228 324~ 3224 3236 193~. 306~ 11s2 211 C3l 1352 2276 327G 3236 3196 32G~ 328C. 325~ 3zea· 1~3~ :~00 1182 211 G30 1338 22i8 3284 32 1~0 32:)0 3248 3230 32S~ 32~8 1r'l3~ :;~~,::: ll/5 2~7 Gl8 1378 2243 32:.;} 32~4 31G0 313::: 323G 322!.t 3223 112;; ~' ·:.c :.171 '2:'7 :.il~ 13% 2232 32~!~ 31S4 3140 315G 321!: 32(::1 32·J: : 'J~Z ~ " ~- :. : l 7 .' ~ j 7 D G J3 '• f. 2 2 3 ~ 3: 3 2 31 :; 1-< 31 !; [; 31 ~ I; 3 2 ~ ~ 3 2 r' 8 3 212 l 0 :.' ·"'

I ··i.B i:-::2 ,,sg l'•C'l 32S9 \ 51~16t 7~:Js n:Jz 7c<7 7747 nr,s ns1 n~.!~ l !;S'J~ ~ ? ,~ ~ ~ !{ ~ ~ ~ ~ :.::> ~ ~ ""' "" ~ ~ ~~~ 'ry ~~~

~-

0 0 0 p

~ c

0 0 0

0 ri ,J

~ ,, i,; ,. :.. ~ ... ~

G

f:r1 -'"' "(" .:u

20 26 20. ~~

14 4 ') ci

'- '' 1~

4 t,.

)~.

:1.4

; ".' .-.; .- '/ ,....., .!J

~

l~ ., J 0

1 " (1

:J r< . ~

.. ... 4 ! ~

·t

2 ~~ r< .I

r:

" '•

., --T-- -

I r---------·-POWE.R ''Kw --- ~----· ' REA(;T 1(\I,A.IcS C\.!Pil.(.';l ANfT··t·

1

~ ' I

f6761-67i_T_ 6761-~79 . '-- 690 -r- 69-, -I ~· i RUN i START I . COM RUN I START

1 GEN ! sr.-.

1. ST.A

1. TIE STA 1 srA

-~A., ."'"" SlRV I SERV

.... ~-----..,.-- -. I M·~ j 6¢!, o~.~

I EXC

I FIHC '

c;u, PH

~i,;N

PH

\

'o7 ">6€ ~; o..~: ~ .:.:;/1.•

,.,. !I[

r'M I

•ox 1 1 v. 1

:·).1,

~ r; l 1\,

CCJt C)Tfta..N.

~ '<Xl -~: 000

.J:·. -,_.

37_ j ;

_ .. ·. '.;

~.

-' •. ro r;

.... · .l J

... ~ I""

!l1S 4 7~

4( 114~ f, -rr "-''

425 l~ 2 ~

:,: I , ' ..... I -' _,_

48 :.1 ~'~ 1 7 -' rl

Page 38: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

>.

.> ~_!. .:C· P2f . cr- ~- ti::-. · . ;:kE

.~~~-r~:· J t ; __ · j· ~~ MERRif.AACK SfATION UNrT 2

D;;!c

i-------- -r ------- --------- -----~-----~-- -------- ---------~-- ------------------- -----------· ---- .. -- -. I · £t<HGY Y-WH COAl. FlO.V t&S STEAM HOW la5 :

I TIME l :~! :~ T ~::II M:2 jr· M:l- ~~--,r--T~~::-r--~~~-~~~~ i ~~~ T,-~~-Jr::: l;;~ nc j' TUJ<& I. €~~~. ~-:x---r-~~~ ;F~2;~r·J ! ~ i ' GEN ; GRO!>S 1 RUN START 1 coM I ~~or COA~2A ! 2! L2C 20 :Zf 2f 2G S.Tf.AN, 1 AUX 1· STEAM 1 STEAM

1 COIL ! wt-

. : j I TIE 1 3LOWC . . j I :Sl'IAM I TO 2 I 2 TO l ' STE..t.M I

fo;;<LY i- '•oo,,L ""' I "~ j__','ioo L '~-iio N,:: J\1.0~~·~-- '" I ;,·~ _!!.~_o__L~J_!<!"_i~~~ 1 ~~-·-2~19_J<X; xio __ j ~~~ t-Y~! L------·-· _ . ..- ___ .. _ --~-----'-- --~----·------·--·--- rr Q _____ ...... ____ c_ ____ . _ ~

1 2908 30GC llC~ 237 GlS 135C 2240 3232. 31~2 3152 3176 3228 3212 3216 1922 0 50 1~ 50 1~ 2 2913 :;o?c~ nn 2J1 oo 1351, 2::'4\"i 32~~c 3I9c. 3152 31L,rl 3228 3220 322d 1922 :t4 s0 10 sEE 3 l.IJ5l;. 302G ll7i 2~17 Gll 133d 2252 3244 3200 3164 32:!.6 323G 322C 3232 1924 ~ 3G ll: 53G 1~ 4 2J0G 3~5J 11C7 207 Gl!• 1334 2234 3223 3184 3140 31GS 322~ 3234 3212 1912 0 ~0 38. GlZ l~ 5. 289~ 30Sj, 117~ 2:7 Gla 1344 2252 3252 3212 3168 31n5 3240 3224 3228 1914 ~ 8~ 20 G3C 1~ G 2914 3dG6 1175 2lli' 573 1372 2256 3261• 322~ 318¢. 3152. 3256 3244 3252 1910 0 52. 34 Gl:2 E 7 2d&~ 304~ 11G7 207 544 1352 2243 3236 3192 3148 3176 3228 3212 32i0 1888 g 54 50 G60 19 8 2358 301~ 1172 207 553 135~ 2230 3220 . 3176 311~0 316~ 32!18 3196 320ft 1878 ~· S8 G4 G49 lS 0 2872 3024 1165 20S 555. 1356 2220 3288 316S · 3124 314g 3196 3184 3192 1888 0 66 74 632 19

10 2ss2 3040 1169 201 s92 1382 2232 :sz32 3192 :s1s2. :nos 322" 32~4 3212 1e9s . 76 s2 54 561 J.S ll 2878 3030 1164 _2.07 ·-- 583 UB.2 2212. ,32l1~_ . ..3J,64 ... 312fi __ 3;&6B ... ..3U11.' . ..3U4 ... 3l8.4·.- 139[.~---- !l .. 78_ .. 4f.l. 46tL 19 12 zss4 3036 n5s 2~1 s6s 1:ss0 •. 22u 3212 31Gs 3128 3~ss 3212 _3lss 31ss -19~2 e 30. 21t uo 19 13 zso0 3052 1111 2~1 ss0 1352 223s 3224 3176 3136 . 3142 321G 32~$ 32~4 1910. e 34 14 393 19 14 28 78 3030 11G2 206 587 1356 2216 ... :nsil 31h8 :U£!4 _ .~16 3116 . ill~ .1172._ lS14 ___ .G .. 26 30 366 . 194 1s 2898 3~50 1163 2~6 590 1348 2222 32~~ 31S2 1.12 3212 3184 3172. 3184 192~ , . ~ zr, 4 348 194 1s 2886 3038 1169 2~1 s1~ 1326 224~. 322e 3180 314~ s2s2 ~2~s 3200 3212· 1924 u 14 0 343 1 17 2902 3054 1171 206 571 1334 2270 __ 326~-... .3224 .. 3liHL ... 3.2.S8 __ 32.6~L.321Jit. 32.k8 ·1932 L 24.. ... 4 351 E 13 2914 30G8 1191 206 569 1336 232S ~35? 3312 ~268 3364 3349 3324 3332· ~942 6 44 1~ 361 1~

---19~91G 3CG8 11~0 206 57~34P 2334 3364 3320 3284 3336 3356 3336 3548 1942 0 36 ~ 373 1~ 20 2864 3018 1182 207 593 1346 2290 33~4 32G4 3228 3228 330~ 3288 3296 1920 0 38 4 382 lS

21 23'. 2 2JS4 117G 20G 53G 1336 2278 3292 3248 3212 3216 328a 32G8 3272 19~2 ~ ~ 20 338 1~

~~ ~~~~· ~~~1 11~~ ~s~ ~~~ H~~ ~~~~ ~~1~ ~~~~ ~~~~ ~~~~ ~~~% ~~~~ j1~~ 1~1~ ~ H i~ %~~ r 0 2oG2. 3C2~ 11C4 ~ G07 1382 2230 3224 3176 3136 3176 3208 3192 3204 1898 0 24 4 412. 13 J vn:. n::(; ;:,n:J 4'!6 I40G 3249 sr~os 7304 7702 7G04 767~ 778L- 7747/ 7753,. 4538 1 103 ss 114'~ !::~

t; \b r "1,? cS ~~)'? dJ \"-:;> (J 1\,"q- 'l ~ .. ' <1''0 \ 3~ ') 3('' \ /)_'{, I ~:tY 11 v J )C. ) J

~·5~~ -d-l'UJt? .

nil I 1 .. o'' t~n 1111s cl~ · or;a tWI ~ -~- t;U --~,'7-~a-·. ·;; - ·- -r-c"Ai -~- -- ·- ---,----~-] I'OWiR" •w lv.cT .v.... JTI C\.Q~T--- ~5-----J ··-···-----

mmmmmmmi;.,,[~,~,:,,LmmmmJmmmm;mmnmmmmmJmmmmmm mmmmmmLm~mmL~~m:mm>~mm >mmmmmm '""~~!,,,;,~~>,mmmm,;;,;,,,,,';5,: mm::>~mmLm=m•L~:~>~mL;,;,~m,Lmmmmt:::

Page 39: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

-t-D ' .. . L 1'"''• .. ~ -. -- 2__ -~--- MERRIMACK STATION UNIT 2

ENEIIG'f ___ "K'NH--------,- " .. --·--· ·--- coA'C'i:l'o\~- - ;:s; ..... --- ------- ---,- . ----STEM\ FLOW -LBS-- I--

6;_,;, 633 1-685-- T-68l, r-68~- oaa- j---2li --: ii1T __ 2t_4 nv.E ' N< r .-. .. ooo I MOil'J ! Moa2 1 MOll I M064 i TOTAl eye I CYC

GEN GRO.>S i RUN I START I COM SOOT I COAt I 'lA 1 26

;Y.1~--~-~~~-l_r::; p~~T::~-:;~~. · 1-:;~·r::~-~-;;~ :,~i;:. l . :lC I 2D 2E I 2F .11 2G ! STEAM I AUX ! STEAM l STE/oM COil i v

i 1 1 \ i TIE 6LOWG : ,

b-~~l~- X~OOX_l~~IOO _t-~1~ ~ --~/~- XlO ~~j~_±_x~~_j~~~-u>--~ i ! STEAM . 1 TO 2 I 2 TO l i '>lEAN. I

X)Q._J_~_~o- ELL x1o I x!_o ! ~~ '--~~_Q_J~!.o_,L~lo_J __ )(loott' )

. 2 ~

)

' ., j

G -I C· 0

~

10 11 12 lj

}I,

15 lJ 17 18 19. ·J:' ,{,,_·

21 2'2 2~

' _, ____ .. ,_..._... ..

XIOO XlO oo:i'i XlOOO I XlOO .'<1000 - ------ -- _=! ______ J____ • --------------------- --

.!.:3 7 • 237 • .-'0GC '"'nr-r L ,_.i..~ 0 ·) ~ ,. '1

~..,.,•..; t;u

:I ).J

~ !(~ ,:)1 -,; L (1GG Lf.7(1

22GG 2875 2876 2832 2EB2 2204 2$9~ 2S90 2892. /~f'J4

.2~.J2

3022 1163 2~7 G17 1342 22~4 3264 3212 317G 2988 324C 3232 3244 1894 0 3022 1110 201 s16 133C 22~s 3272 3232 3192 2992 326& 3zsz 3256 1ssa a 3018 117J ;i_:i? G17 1342 22C:: 32!12 3252 3212 3:J7f~ 3280. 32CS 327r; 1338 0 :J02C 117!J :·.17 617 1344 2<;~C 3324 3284 32''8 321G 33Hi 3304 33(8 1838 j 3020 1181 ZJG 617 1320 2308 334C. 3300 3260 · 322C 3336 3316 3324 1892 0 3022 ll7G 2C7 611 134S 2238 3324 32&4 3248 32j4 3316 3304 3312 1~06 68 3022 1173 207 617 1322 2204 3320 3276 3240 313E 3316 3300 3308 1902 Z6 3018 llGG 206 617 1338 2285 3308 32G8 3228 3138 3300 3284 3292 1~~2. 0 3022 llGG 208 618 1336 2278 3296 3252 . 3212 3212 327G 3264 3272 1900 0· 3018 1173 2~6 616 1348 23~2 3320 3276 3236 3276 3312 3300 3300 19~8 0 3028 1165 2~6 . 617 1312 2278 3284 3241} .3201l 321t0 3212 3264 3268 1908 0 3028 1163 2~6 616 1314 2284 3296 ·3252 3212 3244 3284 3276 3230 19~8 76 3034 11G6 205 618 130S 2286 3292 3256 3216 3256 3288 3276 3284. 19~2 0 3034 1167 206 618 1338 2284 3296 3252 3212 3256 328ij 3272 3280 19~~ 0 3036 1177 2~7 618 1330 2300 3320 ~76 3236 3284 3308 3292 33~~ 1908 0 3042 1178 2P7 618 1314 2320 3344 33PO 3264 3312 3336 3324 3332 1924. 0

--- I 3044 1181 207 618 1324 2326 3356 3312. 3272 3324 334~ 3332 3332 1932. 0 3044 1175 207 618 133~ 2330 3360 3316 3276 3324 3348 3336 3340 1932 0 3048 1184 207 619 '1356 2346 3384 3340 3300 3352 3372 3356 3364- 1944 ~ 3046 1185 207 616 1342 2338 3372 3328 3292 3340 3356 3348 3352 1933 0

r~1 2 3045 llS!t 2~'7. 613 1334 2332 33fi4 332~ 3276 3323 3352 333G 334~ 1J2S 0 !2'04 )~~8 1137 2e7 615 1326 23 ·(1 ~332C 3340 33CO 3352 3372 3356 3364 l'):s 0 ,~s·:~ . 3~46 1130 2,..7 Cl3 1334 ~:.3~~ 33% 33S0 3312 3308 338£ 33fi4 337G 19';2 C ~:,'-!:, 13Jsc· 12'.i~ :>H 617 23~!:~ 311:~r 33G3 3328 330~ 33% 3380 338:' llli1f' ~. ·--.-,-~-..,7--;-'7-..,..---;:;-'(1°, ·-r"· , 11 m~"""' 79-:~ 7'13, 7'l'" l .. ~~.J ~

l_l_ 1. I ..... v-...L. •, ;·.~ ~C. .. ·.~ _, .; . ..): ... ~ _ :J .... -Ju ..,j; ..)

~ !:; -b ~ ;~ ;; 0 ~-~- ~ ~ ~ \)\ ~ '~ "' ~ ~ ) "J ~ ~ ~' ~ 6 . A) 'lj )

l~6

50 40 24 20

. 34 46 34

40 40 20. 50. 14 lt.

14 24 1~ 0

10 14

4 0· ~ ...

55

14 10 14 1'1 14 14 10 20

10 4 ~ ~.

14 0

~ 0 4 0

0 ~ ~

368 %2 rfcc, 19::

U7 41~

'-+17. !t17 1;15 :.22 3Q" .o

.39G 1' 377 11

369 1' 364 363 352

51 171 1

372 385 409

441 1 !+C4 4S~ 4CE 47S ': r ••

t]""'"i'\

,M, ~ E~ : --l--r· ·1 - I .~:T ~!W~·~:~--;,-----r1,.'!CTI-;:.T--l~'-~~~--~~ =~r.~ f:!~, T-c: l .._.,. ~T& .t.T& Til' STA STA . fiELD PH I Pti I PH ~ TIE I

- - ; ~ I

"-i !

Page 40: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

t'uo~.oiL ~i.kii·~L \,..\..I. v! !'[\•i ~·.,...,, .. .:· --i 411'~

MERRff-1,/lCi< STATION UNI1 2

ENERGY r. • .,H ~ ---- -- - --- --coA"l"FLcvi · - u;s·--- - ---------- \---- ---sri.\.M flow-- l~s - r 6<3? ~'3 6&5 ;· 686 ·:·--6ai-'-6iia t i\2 .m- 21 .. T2Js_l __ 2!6 - 217-T2ls' -ii~210 -r-221--r-n:~·-----;----2;:3 1 -n,-· f·-z NET : WJIJO i MOeJ : MOB2 ! MOBI ! M~ : TOTAL ! nc Vt'C i eve I o<. oc

1

. cjc eve j TURB J EXTR 1 AUX AUX FD FA"' Fl

r;u~ GROSS 1' RuN i STAill 1 COM 1 SOOT I COAL j ~;, .IB I 2C I 20 2E 2F 2G 1 STEAM \1 AUX !' STEAM · STEAM

1 COIL , w

: : liE ! BLowe 1 . 1 1 · , . • sn:..w. 1 To 2 : 2 ro 1 STEA.~

1 ~I'XJ x.1oo_ • _x~o _l x_!SI __ j_ ~1_0_-t ~~----L~lQ<:I _ _L_~-'0_ .____E_t?_ j_2'__1()__-J x_1_9 __ [_ ~~o__j_~10 ~~~- ~~~_J __ 'UQ_ __ t _!l<L L](_IO __ J __ xle<!_+_x_ ),\(1()() ----~~~-r __ _j __ !_l~-~~-X__J~J-l1- --··--- -----------"-'~--- ·-----.l~\~-~~2?00 1 ____ !1~ ____ j_~~~ j __ _

11/l•i.

r-;,:; I l'

r, , l: '+

I _, , • I I L . 2 ;J''i 3~ 4C : 1:'~!: 2SG 518 13~2 234li 3332 32S3 3376 33G4 33S2 33G0 1 'J32 .l

:J t1 ~ r:. :~ 75 , >-' " ·~· ..

c 10. 71 ~73 lj .J--f

~ :.,:., )~:!:C ~llj~) :23S :.G:; E2S 33:'• 3250 33!+8 3335 332li 3332 1122 "'' .. ,.,, ,.),·' --· 'G7 17 !4 <JI\ --n· 3-rt-< 7 37'1 -3r.:2 37 r:2 1n7 4 ,:_ _, -· • .) 1- '+ ::., .... _' _' • ·, ·• •• _) ! .J) -\ '-' ) L J L ) () ~-: .) ... ) :> XJ :J )

0 1 "' ~ .. 1:.73 1

-1-1 ),) .. 2u·1, -~ 11!4 :-:;4 I~G3 1338 32S\: 3211c 332S 3312 33C4 3308 1918 : 2 :1;,1 3~~~~ S 11 !J:? 235 !1G 1 1352 23 ~~ 3312 32 72 3235 331G 33C4 3292 3314 l'Jl~ J 14 l!t vn

'-' ~~~·, 3~5l 117J 234 4Gl 1322 2260 325~ 32dS 31G3 32G0 3240 3228 3240 1902 0 10 3:3 517 I . 2 j.,;: 3~lS1; 1::./3 234 :;Gl 1330. 2242 3232 3188 3152 322d 3220 3208 32~8 l'L0 0 20. 34 534

~~J4 3C5~ 1173 235 466 13G5 2Z40 3236 31C4 3144 3204 3215 3204 3212 1903 0 32. 44 328 ~ 2894 3050 1172 2~4 463 1346 2230 322C 317£ 313G 3184 3204 3196 3192 1906 0 14 20 493

G0. 10 14 466 ~ 2~ lli 445

1.: 289G 3050 llG4 235 lt66 133~ 22~2 31S(~ 3140 31~~ 312lt 3172 3156 316~ 1912 : ~ 2:JSC 3042 1171 235 462 135~ 2230 ~22.4 · 317.6 . 3136 3168 32~8 _ 3196. 3192 1924

~ 4 14 --~~~- ~~;~ ~5%-- H~~ H~ --¢&~~}~1 3~a-~4 ~f~4 3~8 3m6 3i'H~}~-~-..,,.:r-........ -w--u--u---------~ 432 ___

' .tJ

J../

. '-

..

~ J.~ ~1)"4"2-r ~- ._ . 20 1~ 418

56 10 20 424 0 30 14 !~24

1163 235 46G 136;1 220S 3200 3140 3112 3120 3172. 3168. 3168 1914 20J4 _ __, 1164 235 ~67 134~- 2208~ 3204 315C 3116 3~8~ 3188 3176 -3172 1916 289~ 1171 235 467 1332 2230 3228 3180 314~. 3144 .3208 3204 32~~ 191~. ~~9~ 1162 234 467 1344 2208 3196 3148 31g4 3124 317G. 3168 3168. 1916 za .. 1~ 14 412

0 10 1~ 42J 0 2~ 14 442

0 24 34 4G3

2~~~ 11G3 234 467 1342 22C8 320C 3148 31~8 3124 3176 ' 3163 31G4 1918 ;_ ~ ~>,_; \3C4 1+ l1S4 235 458 1348 22l!t-3204 3156 3116 3124 3192 3176 3172 19~6 2:-:_;2 )~T,~ 11G3 234 459 1348 -LfOG 3200 3155 3112 3076 3184 3172 3168 191\.l r . . ':· 3:':4!; 1 ::.riCJ :-.>34 453 1336 2222 3215 317G 314:. 3Cl% 3208 319G 3192 l'J28 0 24 2C I; 75

, ~ ·-;:_:·,:· nn 235 442 133!. 223!• 323G 31r;2 3152. 3132 322C. 3212 3208 1s<J~ 0 1,4 '1fi 1..• • 4"" "-

" 2!.. 1C '.f4 ,.. ::; : S ~- : l r; G :2::; 4 :, 5 2 E 61+ 2 21 f: ? 2 C ~! 315 G :; 1 : S 3ll ~ Lt 3 U' 4 317 5 317 G 1 (_) 11 r:; ;) 71, 34 . , .... ., '-,J_j

1 I' Jl4 ln-~4 ~4

·-' 3cl.r: ::.E,!~ ns 1•43 :l.34C 2:.:~:( 31% 3i.S2 3112 31'{ 1, 3U:4 3172 3172 ~19:)'.'

·:,.:: 7~ L· 2S: 7 SC.:.i 1113 3222 \'53':if.- /774 7fi5!, 757 7G551

7738 7712 77113 45:J~

r 7 r y -, '0 ~ c) -~' ~" \ :'J· ~:' ": ~ '-l I ~ \ \!\_ ~- ~ ~ -~~- \\ !J -;,) .

? \j "J ~ '\) 'J~ r~' ').,

;:!'I~

~3i i 676 677-r--6';6 679 6-'~ t.9l --~ ---1--T·-~- --f.owE~- r.i/·---~-1--;EACT'K-IA~-

i I -... : I ....... ~ RUN I START 66• 66.5 I c.co 667!- -~ r

---~ C\JRM'NT AMPt:~ES- ·-.--- - ~--- . T

!XC em l Rur-~ j s~Ar<T .I '-0:.'' I ·j

1

Page 41: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

p

PUBLlC-SEtNlCE CO. OF NEW HP,},,PSHIRE

. \ [_ -,tt

: "". ..... ,. '. MfRRIIAACK STATION UNIT 'l

EN·E-i1GY- --KWH----- - ---;- -- ---- --- -- -·--------coAi:"FL.OW---~------ ----:------- -ST~ FLOW- laS ________ ---

.~: · M:-~ .:, : ::, 1 .. ::- -.:.-! ,!~:-.r~-r ~:~1- ~~~-~~~-~~~ .-r~~~-;- ~~~ ~~~ ;~8-T E~T~ -~-;~~ -·

1

.- -~-~~ ~~-;~2~: G~'ll C.R055 i RUN I START I COM SOOT ! COAif2A I 28 2C 2D I 2E 2f 2G STE~ I AUX tTEAM STEAM COiL

· , TIE BLOWG . l • STEAM 1 TO 2 2 TO I ' STEAM x1oo_ xt~~-~~~J _ _:<lo_l_x_!_Q__t--_x, ___ j~QO- x1o I x10 x1o J x1o l_XIO x1o x1o xlooo±_~t_Q__ ~l_o_L_~_l_?_J __ ~JQO__

X!OOO XIOC l XIO I X\000 XlOO XIOOOO XIOOO XIOO 1 XIOOO - --- 1._- - - -- ------J.---~-- - ---- -- __ __L ______ --~ -

r , '} ~

OA·c'l

LS'1J 3(i,~ :171• 235 lj:! ·::1 132G 22"18 3232 3138 3148 3180 322·1 32~8 3204 189~ 0. 3~ 1:: 5l'J i0(_)1j 3G~~~ llG~ 'J-:- l" ,__;;; 427 134G 2218 3212 3156 3132 3104 3204 3192 3102 1895 0 72. 44 s~s ... ..; ·JL. ~~~;s\1 lb J ;.:)t, 1354 2222 3224 3180 3140 30G4 321G 32CC 310C 1891< lG 44 3(~. )41 ~ ~. ·.~ : ) .:, It (. ll~~ 2)5 222;:1 3212 3158 3132 3120 319F 3188 3188 1884

,. ,, 55 20 573 I) \' l ~ ~ ' r ~~ ,''

.} ............ l.J ..lt)..Jj:... llCC 235 2214 3192 314C 3104 3208 3172 3164 3160 1886 0 ' 56 34 583 2218 ~31% ~i'J~ 3~S~• n;~·~ ')":'C:

~:.;;) 315G 3112 -. ·)O(lr 'r;!·(ot

~i-,.:.. ... ,J,JL...JJ(.,. -'-t;~J( ,...,J-r 11 1 +6\}faJ{.t.d:..2J:lY:,t!.JU ...IQJS§ ,.1~ 22f'4 21.18 - -- --- . -- ---· ---- ---- ... - ......

l~c-

105§ bo 1llB~l§8 3l~i 3112 1778 2888 l48 . 27~96

- j _ 28~2 295G l1 283~ 303G : l 28011 3040 L

-, . -.... Lt

-,

.:.f.-1 ., _, 1 r· J.(;

•• -1

2~eo 0...,,,

'-u/0

2.::70 2882 2378 28S4 ~<:73 L 'J -:\_, u.u

?~7~ ~ ': ,, ,;

L ' ...;

3J34 3034 3031! 3C36 3032 3038 W32 3"""1'"1

)J..IL-

3032 7(' ~I· J,:_,,

1157 234 1175 234 1159 235 11G9 235 1170 234 1170 23G 1170 235 1166 235 1159 235 1157 235 1151) 235 1158 236 ESP. 235

217~ 3124 2872 3100 445 1336 2240 3228 3172 3144 416- 1370 22~8 :uas· ' 3128 31~0 422. -1358 2206 3184 . 3124 3~96 424 1366 2206 3180 3124 3"92 439 1350 22~4 3176 3120 3C96 43{1 1326 2206 3188 --~124 . 3~92 434 1332 2230 3212. 3156 3132 439 1372 22~6 3184 3124 3096 450" 134C 220G 3168 3115 30~6 439 1366 21'98 3168 31~8 3~83 437 1330. 2200 3172 3116 3088 429 137C 21% 3120. 312C 3092

3212 3172 3172 3172. 1890 0 32 54 5'J8 3212 313G 3172 3168 1m 0 70. 54" r-:[15 2'900 286~ 2~i!8 zm l~ 0 0 34 !U ,23 3212 3176 3048 3152 lS46 ~ ~ 338 497 3252 3216 319G 3204 1894 0 0 326 5~1 3208 - 31611 3148 315.6 . 18-98 ~ 0 -- 27~ 484 32~4 3160 3148 3152 1398 0 ~ 254 474 3204 316~ 3148 3152 1892 ~. 14 6~ 461 3184 3160 3148 3152 1888. a 44 14 4G6 3176 3168 3152" 3156 1880 0 1~ - 34 459 3228 32~0 3184 3188 1886 ~ 30 3~ 456 3196 3164 3156 3156 1296 0 24 24 456 3184 3156 3144 3144 · Y1~4 0 30. 4 lt61 3172 31SG 314"' 3144 1894 0 32 1~ 4EJ 3172 3156 3144 3144 1392 0. 24 2~ 493 3123 315G 31t;4 3144 1°~4 11 I1G 3~ S33

4~~~ •• \.I.-.

... 1'1, ... ~ ' ...Ji,•

11 -- ~~P. 1f~p f:~ ... .J"J. 4:J B~~ ~r~ ~±9t ~!~~. 3 !1§,~ 3 ~i~2 3 !1~() 3 !~R~ 3 !i~4 1 i1~~ ~ sa, r~ 5"'' "'0 ..J < ,lh 1.. -~ ' t ' ~~. 4

~ ·.· ~;l,. _.I ~ • ' ' I ll'~: 23f: 41;1 134(1 2212 32;1!. 3141: 3J lC · 3152 318C

; '· - n:·:, :7~'0 S'"4 1~:3; 3244 I 52G,3& 7G34 7343 7:..31 7C ~~ 1 7!:J4 I I I ~ 0 ~) "":) {""J .<) (\\ J

'\\· " ~-,\" '\' \ \:\ I~ '"_i· '\. '.~ '1 {J )·J '1/ .,

, CAP

:--- ~J~I: -! --~---· T----1 ~ c---P-0-Wf-R--K.W-~---]~EACT

I 676 I t-:'!.71 __ .::~. I ~~.l I .. -:-:~90~ .... ---r• ---:-.::-:_ .:-il

3172 74r.'"]

I ')..) "' ' ',, ,,

t\_i

31~<3 l~f?.

75r:~s \44 J: _) \ ,..,)

'\.· '\'

'I

,i 1)

" ,.

sr. ~a r- :;:: 3 ~. :19:, l z :. :.,

f11 (' ( ),~' '

1 '--~1 -:;; ,

) 1 1 I

-1--, {_ - / ()_(_/ .... 1

I ' .J V7 ', '-- --·- ---cuuEf.lr- -- NW£5----r----

664 I (165 - I 606 I 667 -----r-666--1 r..~:u o••~ I c1'A~ I r~ I

Page 42: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

.· .. ·" .. ··. ~:-:~. ' .,._. ' . -· u.,•e ____ S, Jl~ 1 ;=-- t·Gt i~ ::---- --+-. 'J

MERRIMACK STAT.tON -uNIT 2

·- - ---- --- --··--

i Tift.!:

ENfRG'r rwH : COAt FLOW li!.s i SHAM fLOW l!\S -6ai·:~;-T·-·~a5 ·; '686.! 687- 6118"' t--:fli--T-1i3--~-2l-4 -:--:if5--.-216--r-·21.T-T -2-le·-,---ii9--~ iio'"' .. '221. T n?·-. -2.2~ 224

I I I I ' I . ' I ' . Nfl I MOSO MOG3 M062 MCi!l MOI!4 j lOTAl f CYC , C-YC. j CYC I CYC · ere , CYC : CYC ! H .. i!B EXTR "U.ll: AUX FO FAN 1 GEN ; GRo;.s J RuN j START ! coM soo! · COAL

1

2A 1 2s 1 2c 1 10 .j 2E 1 2F j' 2G j snAH Aux i ~rEAM , 5'~AA< ' cc:L v

[_DAI~Y

! l I I liE I 8LOWG • I I J I i 5TEAM ' 1 TO 7 l 2 TO 1 I STU..M

-~~~ ~~4-x.!_O __ ~ ~-!_0 ____ .. '1.-.l.Q __ ~- -~-~ _ _J ... _Xl_Q9 __ ,---~LO _ _i_~.!.2_-J __ ~10 _ -~~-j_~ _1_2.1_0---L.....!<_l~-i ~L~-- _X l_Q_ : _ )(_1_9_ j_ XlO i XlCO __

_XlO?CJ ____ L ______ ·- XlOO ____ .. J ___ x~o ___ L_X_l~l __ --------- -~------_X~~-----------------· XlO ~-- _!l~ XIOO Xl'X'V

1 2 :Y

-~

~~ C [2G 2se4 ..• 0 ~ ~ ~- ...... l.J ''•"' ;, t. •JU .. t

3Cl!C 1109 3C38 11G2 3~110 llC~ 3038 llCl

., 7 r -'- -·.) l;:_";( l:J 4 !, 235 411 [\ B~~ "'l-:"- f.,- ('l 13 70 ~ J .. ,:.; .....

~'3: t r·1 ! l ~ ' J.. E5r

222G 322~ 2221~ 3212 " . ..., r\,... LL·:U 31J2 ?'' "r ... L'•'-" 3l'JC

3Hi~ 31G!; 3 :i.i+ ~ :-, 1 ') ..J..i.....JL.

313S 3123 31;j~

1882 1 or.z 1:3%

31')1 3120 317C ..J.i.c•i) • .J.i.(.•o i_:jj;;

0 0 ;.,

rY

"'" LV '1;~ ~,,

1,1 ••. t

!: -1

'• 1.

',~l r)1

--~ 7 r· -, ~

I 1

-- :.\l.~~l 3:134 11~2 z::, tr::S 134;i 22~C 3l:J2 3l3C 31~4 3132 317fi 31G~. 31G8 1383 r1 ·'

3It 2~ L; J -~ s:-:J

cl

I ,)

'j

1~. ll 12 n 1:.. 15

2SS2 Lt: 8 c~ 287G 10"· ,, '- ~)·-,)

:~900 2906 2908 2912 2910 29la

:- i-:-r _})J.Jv

304;} 3030. 3054 305G 3062 3CG4 3068 3066 3068

11~8. 23( ~Cl 1348 ~202 3188 3132 3104 3108 3176 315G 3150 1232 11~7 235 4GG l3GO 219G 318C 3128 3096 30U2 3164 3152 3148 1886 llG3 1167 11G3 11G1 1165 1159 11G2 1168

23G 236 249 2G0 260. 260 260 213~

455 1348 2212 32C4 3152 3116. 31C8 3192 3176 3175 1895 464 1342 2218 3212 3156 3124 3128 3200 3184 3188 1898 479 1338 2220 322~ 3160 3132 3112 3200 3188 3188 1894 503 1336 222~ 3216 316~ 3136 312S 320~ 3184 3192 1E~4 5~0 1342 222~ 32~8 "3156 3132 3120 3204 3184 3192- 1898 499 1326 z216 3204 3140 3112 31sa 3184 3168 3172 1sgs 4~9 l33G 2214 320~ 314~ 3116 3164 3184 3168 3176 1922 49g 136U 22~0 32pa '1qg 31~4 3~~~ stgf ;,~, sz;~ 1~l~

~

c 0 0 0 0 ~ ~. ~ ~

8~

.. l '"tu

24 2fi 24 24 20 2~ 14 20 2U

7,­-'>· ')~ L\J

/, " .... ,, 64 34 '24 10 24

4 14

='!'~ : (;)

:c,: G73 G34 538 J 45fi J ~31 ] :..23 ] 41~ ]

\:)'

__...ll.._3.n.L 3pGB 1153 259 511 ;3§p -~~~ .. \3tl~ ~;'-J2 3Jf. .. s 3!~.¢ 3JJ.~ 3.!_8.0 3121 1J,?2 _ @ 24 20 419 18 2010 3066 11G4 260 514 1334 2214 32~8 3148 3124 3132. 3192. 3172 318¢ 1918 0 24 10 ~20 1::: 2J2G 30G4 11G4 2G0 515 1370 2224 3220 3164 3140 3140 32~0 3188 3192 1934 ~ CC L :~3:1 2J 2:lJ4 3062. 1177 259 503 1352 2268 3280 3224 3200 3212 3272 3252 3252 1921~ 0 1~4 · 2:) 4C4 21 20C3 30GS 1182 26~ 512 1330 22?e 32% 3236 3212 3232 328j 3261~ 3268 191·.~. ~ 50. ~~1 ': ?'J 1 =2 21JG 30C4 1180 2G~ 512 134G 2292 331G 325G 3224 3248 33j8 3284 3284 10:~ r 44 20 ~:~ 23 2·).)2 3;'G2 1192 25~ s:.:s 1372 23~4 3324 3276 3243 32G4 3320 3304 33W1 1~~[ J It'~ 7

·" )S) J 2'J~IJ 3,~ij;_~ ll'J8 2S'J :J17 13SJ 231C 33113 32C!G 32G3 327G 334~: 33211 33:20 1!)13 0 :54 ~-.'

" . ·. ,07 7331 28J2 Ci0 1107 3135 l ,35!f1 77~0 7G~ 75r 75~ 771~ 707~ 7C~2 i '•57E ~ '' ·'3 1 ,.,

{'\~ ~ ~- "( ~ {i ~ ': "~~~-(\~~~ -t ~ . ')) ~ "') ~ '1-_)

__ 1 ____ . -~-~A!_ __ l_ I 231 r

: ME : GAL I'

. CONO

----~---r --i -:.1 ~!~·1·~;~ 1

· ~ ~1, ~::~ ,' '.;~T1 - - r ~ ;-~r-:,-::~ r:~r, ~,~ -~~ ; --- : . I GlN STA STA TIE I j ~" STA f FU!lD I PH PH I PH I. Tlf l I

Page 43: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

MtRRli\~.ACK STATION UNIT 2

r,\\'rl . I' -·~--- .. - ... -' -co.iurto\v.:·---lbS- ·--- ~ --- -----r-- ..... ---- ~ri:Mt.-f.i:c_w ___ l;;; ···- : .. e86 · t-el ·c'ilt! ~ ·i,:i-·T---i13 ____ !2l.;·-r·v5__,.--.m--[--il7~il!TTt9·\--m--r--2ii-·T222·-···2n : 22~-l

M082 MQt:l ! M004 . TOTA.l : ere 1 oc 1 qc j CYC 1 CYC j CYC 1 CYC 1 TURB l E.Y.U ~ AU:X 1

Avx I m fAN i <,t<< GP.'.)~ ~lll•! I START ' COM i 500T I COAL \1 7A ! 28 I 2C ,. 20 ' I 2E l 2F i 2G I 5Tf.M', I AUX I ST£A/,O. I STEA.!A I COIL !

1 : m 1 3LOWG 1 1 1 l I 1 5T'EAM I 1 ro 2 : 2 •o 1 STEAM j

'· :.:A:ro:IOO + Y~O __ [ _!~W-.~~~10 _t-~~ i~~;t~l: _j_-=~!0_-=-~~ ~---~1~ XlO XW ·- --~0 _r-j·~~rx~;_r~xj~-Xl: _[{j: __ t

r.~r ~·c 'l

'1 c?J ca: .. ,~; /,IQ!JC :'.'.09'3

~\ . '

·.:~;., L:;:;; .:: ~· . .'' 511 1352 2340. 3380 333G 3312 3276 3334 3354 33!+8 1916 C !~1. 3~ G3l \;~-.: L?.~. .:·il 511 1344 23Ll6 338r1 334C 3312 3344 3388 3354 33411 1926 C L;J 2:. C25

3 ·r~ 17~~ 2Gr 503 13Gf 2332 33R8 3312 3284 3324 335S 334~ 333r 1922 J 72 30. 6~5 _, _:, '-~ l·; _:_::1. 498 134C· 231+6 3388 33i•C 33\13 332·j 33?tj 33G4 3%8 ltJi3 G )4 2~ 531

·, . : r·. ,! ' :• ~ ~ .' :~ ~ : • 13 5 G 2 3 5 2 3 4 0 C 3 ~ 1+ 0 3 3 1 G 3 3 3 2 3 3 g 2 3 3 72 3) 7C 1 g E· ~ 4 4 14 S Cl3 '_; ~ '.-; i.· ~'l _:~~ 13G~ 235R 33g2 33fi0 3328 3344. 3400 3384 3384 191G (j 3d. 20 Gl3

.'.• ,_ >:t :; 1:~.>1 2Cl 1344 2358 3388 3356 3332 33!~~ 34~4 3380 3380 1918 0 34 20. C124 ~ :-~ · ~~~< : 2":·.7 253 1348 2394 3400 343G 3396 340£) 3488 3428 3396 1938 0 2~ 20. 031

:~· ~ ·5~~;~ 12~3 2GC 2352 ~3396 3352 3320 3308 3396 3372 3388 1926 0 tt0 1~ 571 '!:lc'J jJb2 1200 2340;,3384 3336 3304 3252 338~. 3364 3380 19:!.8 0 16 30 496

. .. :'JJL 3061; . G~}}'~3416 3376 3348 3252 3424 3392 3396 1922 0 ~ 24 450 ·--~:-:·----=-~-~·r-"1~~- ·.:. .) u '~4!4., 'J!~a- ~r~P'~rt~n~~}J'it> 0~-r;-~r

1 ('

" " • ~I

! ,.,

) '

·Yl

7: :3'':~ 31lC2 1205 266 529 1350 2352 3412 . 3356 3332 3264 34~4 338~ 3~-2 19,28 0 1~. 44 423 '_ r~;-~ 3~::;8 12as 2G6 529 1362 2356 3416 3364 3340 3276 34~8 3384 3364 1930 36 ll~ 4 424 .:~;,'.;0 3~~53 1204 2G5 528 1374 2355 3412 3356 3332 3280 34~8- 3384 33-84 1938 ~ . 0 P 424 2 ~ :1::! 3J52 1201 2G7 526 1354 2354 3416 3364 3332 3264 3408 3328 .. 338~ 193-:6 0 4 . · 0 428 .. :,~ns 3050 1205 266 512 135~ 234~. 3392 ~--33ft.8 )315. 3220 .. J38_S_ 3}64 ._:5_376. __ 193'2 . ~. 24 ~ 424 lg~J 3~GC 1200 266 522 1338 2322 335a 3308 3280 3236 335S 3336 3352 1934 ~~,. 24 0 42~

~~ 1 4 3~54 1190 266 s21 1354 22s2 3364 32s2 3228 3158 3292 3280 330e 1922 4ns' 30 0 442 ?Gt;L 3'JS6 llr8 266 523- 1372 2232 3304 3252 3220 3176 3292 3276 33~0. 1926(/-;/6, ., 34 0 421~

_·=~!:~ ~>::: llCS 2G7 521 134!t 2272 328~ 3236 3212 31G8 3280 ·3264 32Se 1912 3£Jtd 20 4 472. '·<·:. :.:.',::; 1:.:.::0. 2G7 523 1352 2254 3256 3212 3180 3156 3252 323B 3256 1026'- 3 IJ8 14. 10 4:'2

-~·~. ~B: :GG 527 1376 2246 3241~ 3196 3168 3148 3236 322f~ 32fd+ 1')36· 3$8 · ·' _, ~ ~ .L~::: I.GG S17 1372 2234 3228 3180 31118 313G 3228 3208 322ll lC124 3 T.S

4C. '"' -;-<i 4 .JIJ

_) J!'.!: ,~~; ..;34 121;C 325G \5S857 8074 79G7 7S:JC 7:;18 80~5 8C24 3031 \462>' D3

\ l-; 'J 0 t"" ') L.) I ''J tq n. o.. \ _., ~~ ,.-;) "' ._,., -''J . \ \i )\ ~- lll ' ~

R~J-~ ~~~~~~

C'.J <:" ~..l

';)

·----- -----,--·-· --,------ roWr:'R--K"W-----T----l~EAcr KvARi-~- --~--- - cVRRH.ri- -.AM~Es -----r ! ~ j67o 1 671

1

, 6n 1 67.91 ~- 690 I 691 l 1 66-4T6¢5T ~ -T 667 -T~-1 I RUN START COM liiJN START fXC GfN I RUN : STAR1 i COM

I ~ c.n. I su STA l Tic I STA I STA l Flfi.Il 1 PH i PH l PH • j _TIE_ I c ~

':J

·~~r ... \

5~' •' 517

122C

-···1 ' I

Page 44: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

,I·

J,Mf

.. _· _:. >;:_;\.. 'd ... Ci· >( .)H!:-~

MEf'R~MACI< STATION UN!T 2

" -- - Er-.EP-GY- ---KWH - -- T -- -- - ---- - ---- .. c'O.Ai. fcOW- - -L!!i ____ --- ------ r- - ::.of:AM fLOW

68; 683 '---6~5. :--686 i- 667 -·- ;dB : - 2l:2 ... ",2j3- ·: 214 --; --·:m· '--2\~-.. ill "T 'zja -l 'fi9--- [ '220 1 721

CtN C.Y.O:;s : RL1N START : (QM i SOOT ! COAl ! 2A I 28 ! 2C 20 2t ; 2f ! 2G . STEAM : AUX

'122 AUX

I STrAM I 1 TO 2

L8!:>

72')

A\.X

:'2M r:;o ~AN

STEAM CS iL

2TO i <fEAM \',

.'IEr ' MOf>u 1 M083 ! M082 1

Moa1 j MOO.. i TOTAl ! ere :. ere / eve eve eve (, .:yc i eve

1

. TUII8 / EXrR

I I ! TIE i 1!-LOWG ~ I I I I ' STlAM ·'I()') X 1 :>0- ; . !_10 J -_)(10 L. ~9--+ _?< _!_ __ .LX 1~ _-1,-_ X._l2 .. .L . ~l_O _.._ __ X 1_0- X 10_ l -~~\! .. L:5~0 __ [ .. .::!2- ,.i. X 1t'o.1 ~- X lO f

XIO XIO >''(VI X ' t·.

I Df.ll' l

~l!)('() "'00 I X10 I X1000: XIOO : XiOOOO; XIOVU ••·-·- ··-f•r••·-·--·J--- •0' ·----·-·•··-·--- ·-·•··--·••••---•••••---

! XIOO i\!000 .

l' 1 -..

:' ~ r·

' ' . i. •• ./,

2~j~J

" - .. ..,L.• •

..... :.] • '_!

( .""\ -, .. -..1 J\,

.. : .. n2 28);.: :!. ')iJ~ /l~J. ~ J~~~~

.. ,J '- /:/~ ~ .... ,.,-; (

L: .. -v 17 :2J~2

l~ 2012 >J:~

'1 ~ ~ '.J- '-'

--------.. -~ ......... -·'• . -I . "' ~

..

(t..,p

23:

111~~ GAl

7', • r· r 1 _) · ••• '~J <-

..... ·~..:

) ''·' ... (

.;,.'I.;"

.50C3

a~. 1 1 I

J..l.. ' ., 1 ('i-. j,J..,_'

1,..,_ • I I

1175

..... ·I- '"1 l - • ., J ,; :; l ... l L.

-:; .lC ll7'J ~:--::iG 1171 3CG~; 11 T3 3~5G lES 3!:·53 1168 3:53 11~7 )J[J 1159 3CS6 117J 305e .11G7 3058 11G6 3r::;s use } 1 C5 117) 3r·cz nn

'' ' •,1,

·;r ~ ~I.. J

")•'"

.2~~ 7 !6G

2GG 2G7 2G7 2G7 266 266 266 267 266 2GG 267 266 267 267

:,2::; 522 ~,,.,

:~L~

r:"' 'l :.> ,_ :.~

52'il

... :" ;o ('I

.J..-' .. J..;

135 4 13S4 1372 136G

2?32 ')'Jl I" ~L'1'',

22 ~;--~ Z220 2224

32n 3'1"0 ~'-"

3'2 7?. 322~ 32ZB

31 ,,., .J...VoJ

31:'~ 3224 3172 316!1

315Ci 3 1--~

.l.-'·~

31'Ji 31!tlf 3132

52G 13G2 221G 31<JE. 3144 312~ 529 1352 2226 3212 3160 313C 528 1352 221G 3192 314~ 312~ 530 1348 2210 3192. 3140 3112 52S 1352 2204 3180 ~32 3100 525 135d. 2206 3188 )140 31~8 523 1370 220~ 3184 3136 31~4 530 1354 2198 3184 3132 3108 531 1340 2208 3188 313G 3112 656 1346 2202 317G 3l28 31~0 931. 1~96 2194 3176 3124 31~0 945 - 0 2202 .3192 313G 31C8 95B ~ 2202 ~3188 3128 31~0 913 ~ 2208 ~3184 3124 31~4

~,,Jl~·)- :il7_; 2r:7 279 22 4 '31n 3124 3100

31;;c 317(; ..,,-rr )~) '

3112 31l}~

3I:t3 31GG 3142 3132 3124 3112 3068 3044 312'• 3120 3076

3020

32::J 322!: ·-s2G2 7'11~ ..J._ ... v

32Cn

3184 3204 3184 3180 3168 3176 3172 3172 3176 3164 3156

3168 3152 3156

32\JS ~~lZ 7"1:" .Ji . .JL 7 ') .- '1 .)L.. t i.

3102

317G 3B2 317G 3168 316~ 3168 3164 3160 3164 3156 3136

31S0 31.5r. 3156

3222 322.~ 7 ('('>

I i,.)L.

3 l: 3208

1~14 11)""1 -.J-L.

, "1' 0 ... L. ·..)

1:'/2 191G

3192 1918 3212 1312 3l<J2 1912. 3134 1918 3176 1918 3180 1914 318~ . 1924 318~ 1914 .3176 1924 3172 192~ 3172 1916

318~ 1910 )172 1f1~l~ 317~ l'jl!~

3164

3 .~-.. , ..J,c' ..

=-~ ~!t .. ,.,.. ... ~ -.J·

'l •:Tft" ) ·.) ~·

3lW

3 33~ 3 $0 3 Zi8 3 Jl4 3 a.o 3 134 3 !E8 3 &76 3 1:2Lt 3 9t8

3312 4 n.z 4 712 4 JS4 4 li 11

3!; 11.; ~~~ , -~ • .I

10.

~r ),,

14 24 1~.

4 1€ 1~ 22. 34 ~(I ,.I :~

4 14 , ,, ... ..., £.4 )!+ .

,. ,, r •

.. , ,,. ,L • ..~.

l'l

lC 4

3Lt

14 4 4 0 a :~

(i

,, .,

~

"' " .. rl

1~

~2) ·- ~ .... ) : ... " .- t• ~'\

.'J. 5 ~ ,, 553

~4~. 531 522 5Ctf 473 466 1;1.;4

424 UG 4l!t 413

416 '>25 ~)3

453 7r.-r .· J .:• ~·, . )f~ 4Jj3 ·'-tf :r, 1~ 7~~

. ... • ! '7 1 2r. 7 7~G ~ 2204 31 7r 7 l"'n 3"n,. 31r:r ..,1'· 0 1~"' '· t·1 , .. , -' • ).l .A.. .l - V J ~ I tJ ~ ,. ..) ._ tJ ~· ...t '"' ::> .J J 'r .' L' <; •· •

]"

,·, i-'

:1.F~ ~- :~

--- T i

2GI 701 C 22C·.~ 31CS 3J zn 3~~8 31G8 3141! 3ll;4 ~.·_~,0 1: ~; 1 227S '531J,.D 7S(:; 11 7:::i~f8 7~~2. 752~1 705 7r12

,-\ I . ..., ..-, ~ I) ')::. ~ (' I'-., ~ ">- . " ,,) " ,.

•, ~ "' . "- /\.'"' '..\:; I , .. • ' I'\, :..-, ),-1 '\ ') ,-. ·- ) "1 "'7 ') ') -

" ·:::. \

":~

'Y\ ...... ~

'":\ '\) "))

1 :) ..... 7r15!t' \ 4 ·'7

.... \ I

·, ~"r.· ., ~

'-I'\

;. ~:I

·E!f

~~· c 5:i

]" 1 .

7 ) _,. -:} ! -· I

-- --· ·- - .T - ··----------- .. ---------------r---·---------- ... ·---,------ -- .. --- _ ... ·-- ·---· l r-·----r-_!!!W-r:f2 -~w~_j ~~EA~CT KVARS I i---c..--l·-'_1:'!~~ ·--~~R~-- r- ---

• 676 ' 677 678 679j 6i'O G91 ~ I 664 b65 . ~66 i 667 I 068

I RUN STAaT COM I I '~~~~ $~~T I . I .~~.'.. . Gmf•~ ! R~JN i S!::?T ;. c~:

'; 7 .·

.... , r r; . _. ) -

'..J

r.

! I"

1 1

1 1 1 1 1 1 , "' , J. 1 . l

, ...

Page 45: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

li'wV

l> .'...: t ~

.)

, ' .. ~ .. ,. .i.:l

l r· . .)

!7 , .­.J.u

'1

l

., --.J

,.

- -~-

PUBLIC SERVICE CO. Of· NEW H.~J..-\PSHIRE .' ...

· MF!!Rlh.-\ACK STATION UNIT 2

lNE'<.>~ - KW"I -- r··-- --- - -- --COALFtev/ las Sll.A OW lSS I

el'.l <.d3 I te5 686 r --6iil--' 688·---~ --212- r·2J3 --~-214--T2f5--·-v6-l:-N'. MOO() I ,'¥\Oil3 _i MOB2 i MOB I MQ6.¢ I TOTAt i CYC i CYC I CYC I ·CYCJ •;rr--. Gflo:.s RU~'< 1 START .:.oM SOOT : COAL \ . 2A 1 26 I 2C~20

: • TIE I>LOWG : 1

q)J XIOC -~ XI~ __ L__x10_,_l_ X.!_<) __ 1

_X_l_ __ ~-~~~ j XH>- l XlO ·, XlO Xl_sl_

:..100J x1oo , _____ L x;o __ L ~~~-: ______________ -~~~---

;-r ;~ \ ro2;~N i '; M I STEAM ; COIL I w

2 2 TO l ! SITAM

0 ' XIO ! X 100 ! X --x too-- --r--x-Joc:o·j---·- ---~~~-- --

217 218 l\9 , lZ> r 221 ,

CYC eve CYC TURS I EX.lR I .2£ 2f 2G Slpt.M AUX

SITAJd XlO XlO XlO X lOCO X1~

XlO 000 XlOOO --- -

':·:. ' :; . ~s 1 1 0 ') ""r 735 ~ 2230 3216 3Jfi8 3136 3204 3192 3188 320~ 1938 4 ~2 t1C 14 \ 515 1 ~ ' - .. ..... i i...t .. d

I ~ • .... ,, ., ., - ... L:C 783 J 21% 3168 312C 3088 3148 3152. 3144 3156 1926 4 ;!i6 20 1 S.:i5 1 .... ~ .1. ' )'.}_i u J.l',;/

_; I~- 7 r"';, ; 1' -:) ..:_,, 7 77!1 d r· -~" 317G 3128 3jf)2 311;4 31S6 3152 3164 1916 3 8!8 42 14 559 1 ../ '.: _) l) . ' ' -v~

:. Ji:. 7 ~ ~ ..., ll7( ,. ~ 77C \i 2'20G 3188 313G 31~1; 3136 3168 3160 3176 1906 3 ~3 42. 20 58~ 1 ) • ' ~.J '·)I

->JL' .... (' ~- ~ _;._ . .JJ llu7 26G 785 ;J 2208 3192 3140 3112 3116 3176 316~ 3180. 19¢2 3 !lt4 4.6 34 533 1

.. >11 ', -,.· r-,.., lFS 2G7 725 0 2204 3188 3140 3104 3096 3168 3160 3176 1916 3 gj4 30 20. 537 ~

··' ,'.J. J ,, ',,,

llGZ 25G 714 0 2195 3176 3124 310~ 3M2 3160 '3148 3168 192~. 3 ~6 14 2~. 5% J ... • ' \.,/ .I ~)

/ ~t \. ~.,:, )~)p.<~ 1171 2G7 776 0 2212 319G . 3152 3116 31i~ 318~ 3176. 313& -l.Sl~ . 3~.2 24 54 ... 597. J , , "'r•

L 11Ju 5P:J2 1160 2G7 815 0 2206 3192 3144 31,18 3li2 3l72 . 5168 3176 '19~6 ;~e 2~ 54 533 1 .?'1) ~ 31~:: If }1 -7

...... l..) 2G7 797 ~ 221~ 3192 . 3152 3116 3104 318iJ . 3.172 3184 1916 ·3 9l~ 1~ 64 Sl~3 . r) r 1 ' 1) 3):;c 1~-- .. 26.3.. ~1 0 2236 .3232 3188 3152 .. _ 3132~ 322~ ··3212 322;f. 1914- . 3 ~0-- - 24 - lij - 5~3r J L ;J.,..

21!~ 3052 .. -'ilG9 263 810-- 0 ~~ss 3Z~Z21J5192 fis632-sz--n44 3750J.s~J"~: s S).t-- ~ qC-cr;-: 4.) l~tl2 _, ·r..- ll7G 260 922 ~ 2274 3292 3235 3204 3192 3272 . 3264 l7S~ 19~2 4 ~~n. 34 ~ 417 ~

.)•_.·)0 . 2 ~ 1 1 ': 3~~·G 1133 260 876 0 2292 3312 .3268 3236 322~ ... 33~~ 3296. 33$~- .1922-. -4-~'2 .. -·- 2Ql 1{1 lill .· . - ~

24:.c 257G 1091 26~ 826 0 1928 3~~~ -1148 2916 29~~ 2976 2760 2984 163&. 3 112. 14 14 294 l43G 1554 918 259 670 0 1230 256~ G 2484 2136 2535 "48 . 2544 1~5S 3 ff~ 32 3~ 24 l\;5~ 1152 855 260. 734 - a 1008 256~ - 0 -2472 .. ~- 25-21- . .. 0--2532 - .a.~4 . 2~~- . 4S 42 ~ 1U2. 1233 S83 261 90G 0 1104 27~0 0 26~4 41'1 2664 0 2664 932 2 5;,~ 34 84 7 .! : s 1? ');.,tJ0

t_.• .. )I.,) 1177 2G0 952. 0 2128 3244 2376 318¢ 3140 3264 2848 3224 1740 3 ~2 30. 10 371 )(' ' - '( 1 , 12C8 2G0 %9 0 2258 3276 3252 3188 3132 3256. 3228 3260. 1902 4 ~8 ~4 ~ 459 L0'.: 1 t ~,.. ... .._

v : •. • "'! ~) lZll ·2GC ~52 0 2268 3284 3260 3196 3172 3264 321~~. 3254 191G. r~ l38 24 10 456 J..., .J '-

' - -t I r. l21C: ,,,-·"'\ 841 0 228G 3304 3280. 3220 3208 3284 3254 3292 191:1 4 ~~+ 34 1~ 475 _, ~· ~ ! 't '- (J ......

, 1 -.r • ~ •"'\ I ... '""''! 25') 792 j 2238 3240 3216 3152 3140. 3212 3lq6 3224 l~J~ 3 9>2 4"' 2C 4G9 , i'.; ... :'-"+ l. t.. ).' .. ,.: .1..

'! -~ 7 ~ _, 1-:1. " 'J i\ ') 21-0 703 0 2232 3221J- 32~0 3136 31SO 3lq2 318~ 3212 1398 4 134 20 H+. 467 -''~·- 't j.._)p•L . ,~ . 7l'i :2 7~ l fj yj. 11)43 0 i+IJ81 7~37 6464 734~ 5g3? 7492 5G40 750~ 4255 915 70 55 1052 1~ y ~ \ C\ 0 '). \ s, 3;r.,, il' \J' :P I r;b.' ~~ 'I"· '1, 0, I ~~- :) ..;

J .I

-

g/\9~~ - ·-·--······...-·

c_r,t> :- ·--·-r----- --T----r--·~--r POVnR--KW-· . i t·~;-Kv~ I ~--- . ~~m : ~I:S - --1-··-- r ,- ~-n --~ I I r-·-676 ! W ~s I bl'l ~· j 6)1 ~ I ~-. j :~. j .. ~: ... ! ~-~ j

Page 46: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

: . w~;:~u~v.\<::~; ~:f/',11~'4 w.Ja ,~

----,--~- ------ . ·:1 . . -. ..:---:.,o: .. ....-;:.~.!., ... : --~ L ENU<G'I' KWH J • <:pAL IJH[ .• ~~ . . . I • S1il<i'J. IW'IY us

- 11 1 212 2lJ au ~F-.-· ~~r -,w- --'iir ait ~ lll 1· ttl -pv-r 21 ..

lTAL ere ere eve nc eve etc ere T'..:B &n · Al.IX 1 .~ux i FD FAN

'T II <0>\l 2A ,. 1C ,.,, ,. " . "' .,...,. - lllw. I '"""' t COIL 'JG ST~ 1 TO 2 2 TO 1 STEAM

XI® XlO XlO XlO 'lOO • XlO X\0 Xlf!_ Xlet.\1) XIO ~10 XlO_ X 100

XlOOO )U:JO · ·. "tXIO~ Y.l«:: Xl/JC' XlOCO .. I - _J_

. c;. .__. .:: t,-;.. ~:, fUJ.-;,, ·oaie .•

;. '~~~~------_. _______ _

1 ~892 3C4~ 1212. -259 792 0. 2258 3264 323E '318~ 3:Z12. :5215 ·· 3216 324~ lS~S 4ll4 l!f 4 4C~ 2 zs00 3P46 1201 zs~ st:z 0 2238 3232 3212 3144 · 31!0 32is-- 3lsa 3216 1908 4 J3a 11~ 4 46i 3 ~898 3045 1207 2G~ 848 0. 2258 3256 3232. ~-3164 3132-.. -3~2 32.12. 3240 l9~S -~154 34 4 l 4 2334 3032 12~6 259 916 0 2256 3252 3228 3168 32&8. 323~ 3204 .3236 19~4 4B2 1~ 20 47: 5 2906 3054 1211 260. 9~2. 0 2274 3280 3252 ' 3188 '$272 3256 3224 . 3264 19~8 te88 31i- r. 4! G 2918 3~G6 l2[j1 259 8..84. -~ 2252 3248 322~ '"316f' ~3i36. 322lt 3196-.3232 191~ le24 --30 4 ~i 1 2898 3044 1192 26~ 915_ 0 2222 32P8 3180. ~116 ii03 318~ 3156. 3134 1986 ~76 . 34 0 4! s 2906 3052. 1194 259 867 ~ 2232 3224 3lfHl ·nzs 3'2U' 3lsa 5172 32g4 1s12 4 3}a 20 4 4s·

)

9 2882 3028 1191 260 _ . ss0 _ __ u 1215 ,ngz _'31tts _ _31JS:_ ~a':£11;:: ll%2 .3..111.3. _ 311!$ .. m~l. 'crt.. __ __ 1! . ... 14 . · 45: 10 29~4 3~76 1205 304 887 . 0 22B2" 3292 3264 ,2~4 32'~5 (, .311Z. 3Zq,~ ·.3~~~ :t034 4 2~4 2~ l~. ~56

~ n 2942 3~94. ugg. 3~6 92~t - . e. 2l14~; :1.2a~; , ~~z~a : 1:t?z( s-~-~G ~'::l1f!!()~tli~- :;-j':J .. <r~.:t~~~·~:lt.i:~,J - · zv . . p . ~t~~ ;~ -~~~~:-2!,~,I ---~w~- ~ :;;~:~.~~it:~~~i~:~~;-~t-~:i:~~~!{.r~-~ii~(-l:~~f~~t,:t~i~J;?J:;~-; :_-\b:~~:-~ :;'.:~;~~t'{~~:::iu ~-~~~

:Ji.· ·.t

!e~-'· ~ _ _. ... t: ....... _ Jii

ait --~~tt· ~

~ ·~ ~~·· · ·.:1·~ .· i..C.~o· .)~J.~· ~:-,~~- ~~l .. ~·:· J"t.. ·t·-*> '"~:1~:.?'t)~~-~.:!'J.~}~~;:~~~~f.~,~~~~-~ .. :~·~·-.·~:_}:·~~~~·:t.t.",;~~··(0.·~<-r.: :~~ .. ;\x; _;~. ~-.-~J~~ ·. :,: ~ ~~r:J( ; ·fi 20 2926· 3076 U&i) · 3'SS ·:. 951: · .. · f · 2z:~· 3?'-q-'-· · ·}·J.,t-.;· ~··'Jli.f":'-.~l't'-'f';.,':"it~'~"~":;.~,,,.-~1-'.~?--r ·. 'il.'::·~"' :···.'~; .• ~ ·<··,f·r -~.:: . . 'fi.- .i r · ,,:.) • .43

, · •. ·.. . . . ·. g~·~"' ~ •·~~:·. -~~;·.r. ~~~;t/;>~~~~-:::~~~·~~;.~¥1~·-.'i. ·~~~~-~:6~; ~~~:. ~~·;·~-~~~r:-~*~;,·1· :1·~;··-:\;.;~ ''..' .... ~t.:-~ ··~' ,' .~--~ .~' tf. 21 2912 3~~ -1175 ------3t4--.9.a9-':---------22~S·· .3-l$.4-. .31:\.)J.:. __ .$1" .. ~,:.:.;.:..~~":'4 h ·· ... ~~ .. a..< • ..;.;.~-..r.-..,c~l:l-"'---- ~~._ ... .._-r.- . 22 2932 3082 1179 305 lS59 . ~ 2222 3216 318~ -~lf}-~ 3-l~~ -~ ll$ : . ·31Sf4 ·:t.:hl2 . 1935: 4 .. ~12 · ltl ·. · . 1;§ 44 23 zes2. 3000 usa 3~3 97~ ~ 2194 ~176 :>1.32 ~~12:' 31~f--· :n~ts 31211 : ~14-S.: 1~:zs -t~ 'E:J?-1 . 24 0 44 0 290G 3056 nn 305 713. 0. 22p2. 318~ 3152.. J~- 3.148 :_nss. 313i·:. 316~.: l93G. ·.·-~s - _2f.L la 4. 0 s 75 605 233 60 168 ~ 439 635 628 616 'G2.B 63~ 625 . 631-. 385 83 4 1 s:

1{p. J 8 '. -~

-~~,·

• ' . ~ ' "' ./· -~ . , .

. ·. ~ .. I ~~ ~· .J~:

' '.. "I

-~ • ' • • • ! i: ~ .•

~----~ CAPn-j r-£3'il . I I 1 TIME I' GAl. I ( COND

I'O'mrc r..w . .. . .' \-!,.fA.Cl · &~t~j I omm -= 1- , -j 6ll• 4n .,..~.- :" ,· ·,J.

1. tl',i{.-:J'.·:.··.,~··':.::..~·w ·e.(.~ 1 ato' w e._,..

IWN $1Mr. . ~ ' ~1 ' ' ' f,~-- . ( ~t~Uf" ~: . • t;ti;:..J C;;,;i .. ftilU $1/•.l'T COM I 0 '> . • • t- ! , ·.., - • . o. ' ' • • " ~· . ..- ""·._, • .,_ ,• • • If ' ~

_GiN 1 UA ,~1A ,. > 1<~.~- ·., ··:·~".' ·.~- ~~;:. ._ · -~"~'j r-._ .. · f~1!.;JJ .j ,t'V <. ta fi.tl 1 m .! ,,.,,.' J. _,., ., ---·· . .• . L . ',. ,.,.;,[.,,,._..,_ .,, ,.l ..... , ',,. J ..... j ., I "" .I

Page 47: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

·-~

);,J

1 -) 3 ... .: ~ iJlt. •#'.~ ~

c.i.2 : 6ti;.i

: ~.,.[ I ,..;, ' I 11\0i.O ' G .. N I GROSS

I I I ! . XJOO : XIOO r·- ~---:J -- ---------l IJ.>.i,Y J X1000

1_

3 i920 29Z2

3070 30iC

• •. ,f ··.:,"'

£HUGY ~ ..... 11 1 «>J.L ~7 ~ 1 ·- $\~ H.0~1 w- ·- ·· ·- · . ·-·-·· -- ···--· - -·--.---·.-·----,----~-- ~ --r---'6$5---r- ~ 6M-T-ii2 ___ ..-2ll-- r-f~"-- f 2.ro I :t:!! 4.1!! :r.u ; 12.o

• HJU fXT?. II J:jp.. ALiX ' ro fAN I :;n;.VA. i ~ S"fi.";;.\1\A ! SW.M l COil , ~ !TU-M I TO 2 j 2 fO I ~1tAM

w -1rr ~~~-T ;,'~ I J~ . M003 MOi:2 ~I #l.oiA, !CTI\4.

CYCICYC ,.CfC

RUN· nAjl COM $OCT cxw. 2A 2& ~lit: l\;t l[ ~f

TIE ii.O'Mi Xld'_L~IO ·X.!!_ XIO XlO XlO Xl XlOO lUO XlO XlO

XlOO X\0 XI@ • Xl~ X 10 OiJO 1 X 1(100 XlOO 1 X 1 e:JO - -- ----- ----------- ~- -----'----

f X\0 bX~-t-:~;o XlO XIO XIOO_

-------'--- -- _....__ ___ _ 1188 1U2

304 3S5

'

851 6J9

0 224~ '3236 32~8 31"4 '.'32~8 e 211a 32CU 3li8 '3111 '3'i'Oi

j.

3212 31£8 3216 1934 4 23~ 4 4 443 3Ui 3lt;3 31SZ l!J32 4 !!~ 10 IJ 4¥i

'V"' 4 2918 30GG 1174 305 742 ~ 2206 318S 3164 3t.i)0 3144 3164 3136 :5164 1934 4 332 24 14 41~: 5 2936 3085 1188 304 733 0 2228 3218 31&4 1126 3164 3188 3161 3188 lq~0 4~1 22 4 44~ o 291~> 306& 1176 3E!S 100 0 22~4--- -.nsa 316¢ .. :s~~05 :na~ 316w _ 314~·-· 3154 1934 4 B2 24 t~ 44' 7 2924 3074 1177 3~4 810 U 2218 32~4 3176 3i12 31C~. 3184 315~. 31SS 1936 4~U. 1~ 0 45( 8 293G 3086 1194 3S5 93~ J . 226- 3272 3236 11&. 321$ 3248 322g 3244 1938 ~ V~ 0 10 441 9 2344 3094 118~ 3S4 ---S85 P---123-S-"-- 324~ 32U.- ~.ISS.- 31'$$ 322.~ 31SB--..3224 1942 ~ :S2. - -1~. 4 44'

. 1~ 2'332 30s2 1179 304 987 . ' 221t . ::s1~4 3175 -?I!G ·, ~~4 _ >ls~. 316~. 31ss 1936 If Be 1~. . 0 431 11 2910 3~58 ·ll12 . 3~5 .. 94\l ~ :U~:.:i~3J1£h1 31S:t. ·•.1f;?.r"2 .:'ft£n-! Jl52~ ·;l~i&.:"'• llES 1934 L;lt\S 11J a 4: 12 293 r: YJ106 u··tl!r!: ."11:~5. 9,$.t. . ~ '>';:li;~'!'•')l"'1'"l1··~"'··~ ~~"'1,··~·'-''.i~·.,;'t'H">"li-·'ll:'!~"·';,:(l)';'.-<"el' 'fgr,d 1,1"/1<! ·fl IS f,'l·'

U JJ)O . . 1-AJ~•..-,)ff-7 .~ .. ~""~ .. ;~~:>·--...-·::--~-~~}Jj.-~~~~ · . .-.~_o:;/..Y~~-··J-:-~·-...;\l'~.-;-~.5,-~~~':-~~~.~-:J.:--~ltJ....:.r -.J. ~)S- ....... ~ .a..•t -· --·-~-- -P-- . Jt.-LI

--U ....... o .... f_;155 ___ 31~2.-.:ll~~ , ;,~~ .· ·-'-~i~:~::·:~,2·}·~~;"~;:t:·:Yr~?. ,,~l~t:·t::;~, /Jl;:)1gJ, ... :-' 3:t~~~t{~-~~t~:F-t~~';;,JL1~~~1.:...:..tg~~L.. ~· ·~~~;~ 14 2926 307~ 1l.':r:s~-,~v~~ · -' · ··$f~·. <::'-~-'4·~ ,,~;;.-.·i;;::;;t,;:-;;''r'·:·, '":~">'J,'~-;~~.n,·:~,t:5.t·n:,)J~'t':;;';-~;,~) 'fn;_s ~.t:a· ·: .r:-r;~~ i(~J l5 2 93 z 3-~a0 WL --3~- u~~~l:f~~:h~,n~::1;~~:S:~;;~~:i~!ci~<t,:.;;ii~~~:~I~t{~t~~f~:~~~,;~~b:i;,~i;i~L~.u -4-~Zl '- .l~"':l?~ ----~ -- 3!J 18 1254 13"4 blil:"l.- 'l~i!!l ,.,,l!..,t\.·. :''i:'f'.t~·,:•.>; .. ·;c,;i-';:;!\•f;~Z}.·,.·11?.~~:~::~:::(.of'(: .. ~ ... :~~~·-::J·:·;' '~'fE~_:-..I-<~;·r!<,:'~:·;-}.~· .. ;>t;, .. lCl~!a. 'll'.t~? ·.·· r~... A 37 4 , "t...... 4-i'P _ .. :&.1.::/. !t;,.;;-14!_..,.••.t,:.~ ,~-!Y:~,v .... ~(£. Yi'•~' .. '"'«'lif'."{A.~~--/l"''fi.c~:,;.-.l",.r;"'"~fl".·..,I,J-•. ~·'•~·~-""-~~·'vi•<'~~O:."I_,;...- .,- -.J----.-l.1 "'I J~~-- 'II;~ ~ 19 29~4 3~66 llt!5 ": ·3~"4·}~ ''f}~t%' .t'~<~}:;r.).-.~r;·.: .'~;.:':~·-'"~;;:;;g':- ')·p,~-·,-.F,·; :;:~:/':1.:.;;·:::.~ ·31\}:.t;_,..,gt~;.,:•}<~i,:J.~,r 194? '1t i;··~, · 1:~ 0 371

2 rt 292 a -:t1~ o *'~ -t ~ ~~~--~·~~- -~·it:;r./!1-.;~: · -··~#_~-~:;;:-:; ·~~::;~~~·'··~~--~~?i:/:.~<~r~.::.·~.·f~~~;· ~1/-~~r~;;~-:,ll>-~: f:;l~~~f;~:·>·.' ~7-:~::~~· -~·*_.:~~ if;;f{ ,_·iJt1·t·;~r<~·-:::~.;;~_::. · n~-: ~ ·!J:·_· ~~~ · •r 1 ~~ . · '!}t .V.~!-; v . u ..... ~~ · ~,.;:......~~k-~~··~~ ......... _ ... ~-.~:5>~ •• ;~:-~:~:·.~!Z;.:~ ~.-~$4.:t :f}o+:.,,··-.r.·:-~'!i.~~~-~'ii,..~~--q~·..,~·r."""'1"'t-·(.·r:.·-·.J~..,.~·l~M.;.tt.- ·~-...:o¥~~~-.p.. ..... ~-----~-v-- · - ·v-... -~~

"1 291:2 'f/'{94. ll·"·iJ~' ··...,!1·::~.~-· ·.1!::4" '". ·<tit'."'·". ·k.,-;;, ,; ''':;.;.; 1t'"'" ,,.,,.t ,_~,, . ., ·' ::. 'k,,.;;:_. •... ,: f .. ··:.~·.·.'""t: ,:. '>~tJ>,·r: 'f'·"--'. ·.,c,; ? ... , ... , .. ;...,,;, ~ ··-. l"'' t:: 3· F·f, . :· t. '·¢r• 'l1"' L J .JJJ • tO I J-fj~:.· ..... ~t; ·.-~~..t.J:JEJ- ·):~~-:;;~;·"'?-'"·:~·~:~:ti_~~ \11~< ;;·---. .. ::~J..;;i..ti.:i~<-;;t·l:·..;:./~;;-;.J.J~·~,.oliliJi;.;.~.~ij.'. -~v.~~~~~} ~~!0 t ~4q ... :: ..; . ...,,. ' :r!

22 2940 3102 1111 •. \·"S~· · -~, .. fi~ :u:z.z.~:~:~{~~~-~:"~~;z~:::;3ZWJ{; )'_S;l~;S\~-:~:t.'S·&$.:: ~21..2 . .33.£~- · ':~·li' 19M~ 3 !Jf} . '4 ~ 37 23 2312 3S74. .lllL-~---Ul---~2~t,:t~ta~~31~~--ll1s . .;:_!J1!;!~{;:~U8 1~-2---- 3;3.2.-.. ~- _ ~ 3 u 2ss5 304& 1157. ~s 6~4 · .13~2 21~- ··. ~175 3144 .'·!:Jfa .. 31~1.:· 3148 31>2 --"31t~ 1936 3 ~s f3 0 37 ;; 1s14 1979 752 19S ;sa "8s':. 'J.547 22~ 221tt · ·711"4 21sa · 2219 · 22ils 2221 1313~ 157 1 2 2s

r---rcAJ>

! r- J3l-OAL I Tl,\1.£ CONO

I i TAtJI{ ~ ·. ·~:.-.. f.·

- -··· . .:....._..:. __ - ... . ... - . -·-·

.. . . - ··- ___ .. _____ _

,. ,__, .•no

•'•

.,.. . ~ .. ~... ....

/· :/' -~-·· :~: ''f'

.•

' 1·

.,,

/ ... )..,

,\' J ".1 1'1 '0·

~~~ X'W .~ , --~ Kv~' -Q}g~-f..NJtii~--- ---f ·-· . ·;. ~-.~~~ ... - .... -iii~· ._<diJ .., .... ~9·. _ ~ i9l ~~-,--~~---bl.O ·r·WI~ia-:

;•'.'. ,. '·.';·.'I :... ·,· ;'J ~· f.~o,':i:..~. ~·.i'~Jl! . ·. ~"(:-;,~ ' ;):;·-..,.: . 'f~!i'~' Sfl.l(f EXC ! G~N I' RL!N St.UT I COM I •' · l""i"".(i~r.-• • "• • I ~ • 1 o II --' I ~ t •"• ~ ~ • • ! •' -~- ·-·-.:· ~ ~··~A .l. ~··,' -·. $·•'. 'f',-.:.,o.·~· ·,-~ SVA· • - .,.,w PH : l"tt l'tl TIE I

. ' .• >.-: .. :,'. ·.,··-:·t~; •H"J-' :~',.'t..·.~ .. ~~~'.l':··,,~~,-;·;,F"W'. '... .. I I I : .. r .... 1 ~,-·J>-:-.> .•. :_. :·::,,·-:t,·~:·:~: .. ~~:~;.l<, }< :, ~<-::-.J·~---:.,•ti;'-·, -;~:~~ ;f':':1;f. · -~-' . .-. : ..•.. ,. -<r- . t I 1 1 PH 1

1,

- " ~ - '"¥.'£ ,.•~ ' ~ c'I.;/.S'<'":l.-$.~, .,..f." . .:, tlf•,'-"J~4'J ,-;:.,_.·.·,:._.\.~· '~-_.· ·V1 1 '·' ',X)O , X1 .- ·~~ 1'(\

Page 48: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~)· --~·--·~ 1- .... ~l- .> .. ··' · ... · D.sl~ --~i.:.f' ~ I1975

7 .... -.-:1·,_ '; :· . -. ~ ...... -· . '- ··~ ·' ·,IV~~ru}t~U STA.'t!Ct~ Ui{lY "4 '-·. ·•

,z,_.

t.~·

~-'

~'t

1 ]

2896 3058. 1179 '304 2920 3082. 1171 3SS

., -

. COAL f.t.l)l.~ u;- · . sw-.. <~. azy.14 w COAL k,l:;,l.~ UJ i.e t 212 213 %14 l:U .. ~..-- ~M l~b t:t w r :m ! n2 r m I 22.-t iU YQTAL CYC C'I'C Cl'C CYC CVC: C'\C CY;; 1\;l';:.l fXm I AUX l AUX I FO Fi'J

:IT COAL 2A 21 a<; • SiJ • H· . Z1 W ~~ I ~ I lr~ I STD./1\ f COIL

213 I %14

I l:U .. ~ ... ~M l~b t:t

CYC I c~c Cl'C CYC eve: C'\C CYi;

2A a<: .Sil ' ... Z1 w ILOWG i a~;,;;;:.M 1 l l'O 2 I 2 TO I I STlM

xtoo xto x1o · xto xTa x1o x1a xto • x1cr-J 'lit~'~ I '519 I x1~x_1oo_ XIO I XIO I · XlO X Tit X10 x1a XU} • Xl~ XIOOO " Xl~ . ' >:10 ~~ I )(J~ I X~ XI COO

3232 32~8 114! 3164 322\! · ll91 322li 1S~4 4 li6 321!$ 31S8 31~!1 · 31tJS 3lsa 3111 :sz~a 13~-a ~ ~a

4 2~.

... .or-,. - ..... -· --. . ··- - --- . -~ - - - -

~ 38 e 38:

4 29~2 3064 1169 304 G07 1328 221~ 3192 3164 3104 3132 3176. 3152 3184 1942 4~4 10 ~ 38' 5 2924 3076 1172 3~3 6~9 284' 2222~ 3216 3134 3124 3148 3188 316& 3200 1944 4 i}56 10 4 _391 G 2932 3~94- .1173 304 609 13~ 22"~-"~~ 3212 3195 '5128 1155 -32~4 - 5176- -1212-- -1S4!L 4-Jln . 4 %3 39.

_ --~r-zy~-)lfbriib~tsr5WSDPr2zflr:ir~n;~158311fs3I24-3Y723Is1-ffa4-i9"4~4'i32--:!~.,..-3-0' 1y 8 2896 3058 1182 305 6£19 1306 2235 3224 32~~ 3145 31'G4 3216 31.88 3112 lSf!t4 1{(:;5 p 94 ' 39'

~~

9 "'~918 3rt8!1 1175 3r1J, t:dO .. ,._,.,_ . "t"t ... l!f 3224. 31"'·'-• ·•'·13~ ·~-1'-52' 'P<~.f!l( .,, ~<>1 '$("·'~•J J.'"'·', ... li V}\1 fl ,.!, . 39 "' p JJ . ,.., __ 4.1~n .• ...£..U.L- -&..L~l/1----· - '.:i!J-._, .u. .• ...;;\ ---.JI..Z.:Ui-~--.J~ ....... 4~~-- ~·~----"'.At.l~.-- '-'~· ·-"'·•-.

10 29-26 3~88 1178. 3~5 6P9 · Ul. 2232 3224. _ )20~ · "'$~~i~if '· 3l!?E .. ~~~-- '1li~ ;. 3:Z0~L- 1~3~~ ;;~Jg · .. S 94 . 35! 11 2908 3G7~ 1111 3~'-i · 61, 'lllS !?J~ 31t:~··i . 'rt~ ·;~ ~":Q·7'1"$ 't"-1'i?''l':~· -\1~'\lt•~ >r..~P·;: , s: · · t''.t:'""' . · · ~ -_,.- tJ"f ·""3;~··

12 29~~ 3~62- -IDl----l:s ·:·:::~~;~~ft!~:~~~f\t~~~1~&~~§i:J~~~fi~-:~~{~~~Trj~:;::~-; :''. . _· -~~:+~~:~~{~+~d1.,·~.:~:,tp 13. 29~8 3~10 1~.12 3~~t4 . G~;t· ~.ttli\lt·•. _ ... :.t~'+ .,,~.:...:.- '.' ""'-': ~.,;J., "':~:~·! ~.'),,., ,·.;;:'.'i,'-;V!.•(f•""'Y !" .;].•· -i .:" :. ,, ' ''{~<',.;: 'fo:•.;"_(/ ', ·,f.;~ . ..-··;, 14 2918 3110 !'4 11a9 ' T•"s : . !:{!.11'. , <It><;;·;~; ''·-"'!"-''}. 'r,+;t::.<.:• ,; ~-\' 'i• "r,- 1- '"i<. 'i·'··~:. -i~ ~< .. :_, .. r· .. :tf>:•··i;; i fl~;., ;i;.··-· ·_ -.·, >,. :- . ,. ,· · ')' ·-:1 .- . <: -;~., ·" • .--.- . ~~ '<>J·,:.,

JIOJI Q .JV . . ·, J \-fui'~ ~~4~~- : .. ~.-·fj .. .:ii:,(:I··~"J;p..:_.;:;'!o-..~~. _.:A.>~~!_:. r~i·~-·~~>4 _.·.:._;.~~':t~~~f:.w~-~~,.\ ·~-~; :,· .··.··-~.:-... ~-.';·:.7· -F·t; :..;.~: ... : ._ •. · ~ >t;.: ._• .. ~ ~ ,.·v.,~·J

15 2892 3;!54- ---ll66 .. ~ -3$&--r:~-~~---UU'-~~~:il:~?~~.;51JO~~~~;l.S.~:~.;;.~:~:}_~;f~1~~~~~·;i'~~¥~~;}_,.~·--.~-~".~:·-~·:>~-.:;~:>; . ··~:.·~.-:/:ry·:·~,~: ... \_;~~4--~~,.._~Jl-~ 16 2838 3GS0 1169 3~' Sil&. 1"''·' 'll: • ~·,;''1~ · "'i1· '"'· -~ . .;,.,. 0 ~ ,, '-~":: '' •• ,~_ •• ,, ·'-""f''-"'·'~'i·"""t· 1'·· ·,. · · t.·· · - ·"..; -·'-l f' ' ~ .... , ·

,. . ..·-- ~ -. · ~- y · ~~~:1-ctl·~ .• ~.:. ···-~~~;~-~t .. ;- ~~-~;1~?-r.~·~·~: :··£:~~~·~\_~:~~~:-~t:~l~~,~-i~}~~:/'\~\~ ·· .::~~;~---~'~~~-,;~ '•-~~-~:· .. ·· J~_, . . !' :~-· ·-i~-:1~/~.f:- ~;~-.. -~ ~· ·:·/·t- h~~ ·~ .;-~~ 17 2906 3tlo~ 1169 :;;14 6-.ri.t. ll.Jl·:~ta3·-·3:lr.-~..:-·,;';.J:g;, '!l.<.tY.~-~~"'~!~t~·Jt';;..;."":~·!J;,;..;;·.·<.·JJ;_.:}~··",,,,, ., ..• , .. ,:1 ,;. .• ~,·--" ·i;)7' .,_._.

18 292ri 3do>t ll"i'\1 'f/'11:: _l:t;ic·__ -.~ 1{_.;.. . : ~l,l'!_G. ··_·12;::-:;.:-& ..• ,._.,i ~·!'! : ~...__~~-• :t"i{'i;:~\'; ,· 'S'l~"'. "'l{;': •i '_• ._., ·'_ ,>•>:·_:-/:·.-;, -.-_. ~~'·!_··· .. · .. : ::,I; __ · ,·.:'+ '::_ ·" ~:_·~-- :,-;J. . ·' 'i:(·:• Sl · JlO'- ~---- · -J~-"~~~-:...1:. ... l',._.~._.;, ........ ·.~~~~.lo.~ · ~-..?t~~; ... _~i-'·~~·,-.-·-·-:noc·:r:~·~·~<.o'···."r.·-.> .~.~: ... ·.:;" ~-,~·''";."""",.__,.~.,_..._~lW-./o•.

19 2918 3~BS li69 3~4 -6ti9 ·;12fi3 : :·zl~H~-\ )1~5 ~·$:~1~ >14~' ~_,~%.:~!;.~ iJli,L: )1~ifV'':;%~~;,~:~.::.:::.·i~·;ft2lli;: .. ~: :~·- ~<: ~-0. -· ~5: 2'1 zgnz 3"'64 116n ·-s>lis . i-~1'1 .. ~-.!1-· 2;,·.;,, .... ~,, .. _\-'·-;' ~r?···e:;,·· ·\;'·::'•.c..: .• ·-';}_~'<;j,,;;• ·.\:i~"'H·::."'_ :'\\ttl.''' :l;y~_--,'l~;·,~--.e~";.'",'«'lo ~ ;;;;·+· ;~._ •. ,;._ ·. .·,~ y,..;

t:J V JJ 0 J<O Ui/0 ~~lril Lj;l&. ;,J,¢-p.~ ·::.Ji.\.:a·· ;;)·;;;·fJ . ... _ ~4.0~• ~.l.UJ~ .. -· .. '·..-dl~(, . ,.;J,~-tiJ; · ·J,.~;:.t~t. . ·:rt~;(~', ..L4 , 'ii ~-.C.~

21 2914 31176 117fj 3d4 cr:g .,ft416 .,,...,.,. .,..,,fl.. '£.'!''' '\"'t:.-.1,·. 'll.l-''4 '.f~'"~~ 'lf'i'f.>'\l .,,.,,,.- """'!1'1 r... ,,,.,. .,IIi} f! ""' JJ · 'P- t:l -- -Vji • -.I.-I'.~P--4.4.,~J,· ~...1.9-~~--<N.-'..._..·.il ~ .. :.~~--..,,t.tJ.,._,~-~...-J· .,.s.. ... ~~- ·~~~- -4-!f.'- --·- .V - -'1-,.l.l

22 2s9o 3052 1164 3es s~g 1332 22~2 3176 3152 ;~gs · 312s ·· 316~ 314~ :Slf.;S. ·'1.:!:.2 '56~ 4 G 41~ 1:~. 29o2 3064 111~ 304 s10 B~~ 221~ 3192 31£4 .31~4 312s 3176 3148 3:ta~ 194~ "~1· 2l} e '-'!.i: J 292v 3082 1112 304 61~ 1304 2226. 3224 31.88 .3132 3128 _ 32~~ .. 317.5 3UJS. -19~2. 4C~. 30 :. t~s: J G982 7370 2810 73~ 1450 3~42 \5324.5' 7691 7528 7486 7534 7649 7591 7656,4667 Si\;l 29 ~7 9~

t . ~ ,_. ~ ' ~ f~ . ~- b ~?. . . ... \J'f ~ ~ ~ ~ I {{ ~- ~ 'Z)~\0 1 % ~ ~ ~ ., ~ "> ')) \~0\

. ----- - ·- ...... --· . -·- . .... .. _. ____ .. -----·-- ------- "._., ____ ",~---- --. . . ' -.\' "

'\\)" "\."p ,. '!>o~

\ /";>:)-...\

---r-- ---~-CAP r --,---J Tl~f i ~~~ l' I I \.C:NP ........ . . '

' ~ ,.

• ~ ~t. --_ 8 .. - :~~u ~'"'AUB .. S?.!.~--· ~.,,..,~_ t .,.. I . . -,n 61~ .. W"i • ~':" ""'' ·., _. ~-<~ o>\14 • M;;.: ~~ ~~ ' . ~ ' I ' , « ,.

' t~'?'~ ; ' S!tlt;.' . Ct,:.;r. ': ~' •. ,, . -. ;ik!MJ J ~~r . ·- ~ .. ' .4'~4; . ~t~) 't,;Jl, (r.P~ r C:~;'t I ... - .. J. ""' 1 $tA , ,,; .,,., ·, ~,.,. ·· ,;l,, .,, .x~." 4· ' j c~•;;;; .... t;:, , , ,, fl''' :L ,,,,. n ' , ,

Page 49: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

. ..-,..r te --

. '. :-; ·~ Nl• .J \• •

.. · MER~Ii/.AC~ ~IA1tUN l.il'ill ~

, ,,M, , ~~ :. ~~'),. ~~·~ :i~: ~ l~::.l,~~~:.'i 7:~ ~~~~~ l ~~~j~ ~?r·-:::- 1 ~~f'J-~;-t~~TI ~:~r'fft i=;ff- ~ "'';;" ·: ' GfN II G!lOSS RUN START l ~~ ! SOOT COAL lA I 28 l 2C 20 l :n 2f 2G SllAM AUX I STEAM ! STI'AM '! CCIL I;

: ~ f.\.OWG ~ . STEAM I T02 2TO 1 STrAM

i """ ""',ka~'Y!O I:-·:~.,- ~'- ;_. ;;1:: ---~'-- X!O -- ~~ -~X"____:__ X!O I .~~o:J_.~~ L"~~ ~" _-b~:.l ' ... )

j

!1

2JlJ 307G 1212 312 619 1312 2334 3376 3352 3292 3272. 336d 3332 3368 1948 4 ~~ 4 4 444 2~34 31CO 1205 31! 621 133~ 232G 3364 3336 328~ 3264 3344 3324. 3352 1956 3ffi8 l~ 4 450 :3~4 3110 1202 ~10 622 1310 2316 3348 3316 326¢ 32G8 3324 33~4 3336 1956 3 ~0 24 ~ 44E 29L; 3l2G 1205 310 621 1326 2330. 33G4 3340 3280 3284 3352. 3328 3~52 1962 ~04 26 n. ~51 29IJ2 3H;8 1202 312 G22 1336 2304 ~3324 330~ 324~ 3258 3308 32R0 3316 1954 3 9~4 30 45G 2fJl+f 3112 1197 311 C22 133C 2292 ·~ 330r.' 3276 32Hi 3280 3292 3254 3292 l!J5S :£16 3~ '+6;

7 2CJGH""'l28 H~' I ~ • 24 3 . q 4[,g -·-:;~--2-;i0.. riG L· 3 6 44 zs 3 21 328 3256 32ss 196 3 ~s 1i n:

S ~jGO 3124 1195 311 622 1328 229~ 3304 328~ 3224 3256 3288 32£4 3292 1960. 3~4 24 470 l. ~ :: ))2 3096 1197 312 623 1308 2284 3292 3264. 3208 3272 3272 3252 3284 1936 3 9l4 20 464 :1 2~02 306G 1177 312 624 1318 2238 3228 32~0 3146. 3216 3298 3184 ·3216 1914 3&8 20. 455 1..:: zse2 3046 1176 312 623 .134!.- ma 3212. 318S -llU--3204 .. 31U.--.. 3168 .. 3ZU.:.l91G _ .3.•j.. 2~ -. 457 u 2932 3096 ns6 312 sz4 1324. 22se 32se. 3232 3172 · ·32s2 . 3236 321& 32~4 .1§4~ 3132 14 14 454 14 2912 3\176 1184 311 622 1346 227ft. 3272 324~ :. 318" 3264 3252 3224. 32S6 19-~· 3J6g 1'+ ~ 44i lS 2930 3094 1196 311 622. 1324. 2304. . 3312 .. 32Sl--'323Z~-.5~16. 3.3~4- .. J%76 ... 33Sl8 .• --19.3.2. .3 :as_- 10 .. _ fl..- . .A43 :-:: 291~ 3082 1192 312 s22 1346 2294 33g4 3280"' "'3216 :ne4 328fi. 3264 3361 1926 3 Pl2 4 o tt3s ~~ 2C90 3054 1199 310 621 1319 23~8 3324 3296 .' 3236 · 3324. 33li. 328;i l3l2 1926 3 ~2 2~ · 4 443 18 2904. 3068. US1 311 . 622 . 1312- 1286 ..:..3292--:'"3.2.64 . .,..32fU......ID2- .. 327.0. 324B .. 3284. --l9U-3.m.& ·-. -·'- --· -L. ll4~ 19 2914 3078 1190 312 622 1298 23~2 3316 3288 3232 3312 3296 3272 33(JG 193§ •. 3 ~4 3P 4 457 20 2898 3062 1189 312 62} 1362 2296 3308 3284 3224 3292 3296 3268 330~ 1926 3$4 1~ 4 461 ~1 LJ12 3076 1191 312 623 1348 22as 32ss 3272 32Bs 32se 3284 3256 .3284 1926 3~2 ~ .0 4ss 2L L320. 3084 11~1 311 G22 1356 2284 33~~ 3268 32~8 3244 3284 3256 328~ 193G 3 o6 1~ 0 461 )3 2020 3084 1186 311 623 1352. 2276 3284 3256 3192 3244 3268 324~ 3272 1924 3~4 14 4 458

2:·1t.~ 30G0 1184 311 623 1368 2266 32G8 3240 3184 3224 326~ 3228 3260 192~ 4 <16 10 4 465 ,-, lL 71;13 2ti52 747 1493 3195 \ 5496(f 7926 7862 77lh 7S48 7886 7825 7900) 4651 ~1 31, 10 1:19'3

~ ~~ ~ { ~ -f (:) ~ ~ \ ~ t't.~· ~- ~ ~'ti ~ .;! b~ ~ "'\ ~ '"b ~ ~ ~ 9\ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

..

?,

. .;

. --· r--·- ·--- -·- -· -~··----REACT KVAIS CURM!HT AMP9£S . · 690 691 64oo4 ~ CI06 667 66i.

liJI'f START I . uc GiN t\JN START .I ccw $TA 5TA ',t'IJU?, PH Mi.. ' .PH • ! TIE

: _-CAP-_J--r--r---J31

, , ; GAl l 1 ~ .. '/. i ' ('"t"'\~1"'1

T-~ POWfR KW

~"'T 6n I t1c t 619 llll'f STArT COM GiN SlA $tit . .. Til

Page 50: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~--~- '' l '<' ''11;: ... ' i , •• .. :"'-..;, -11>, - . .., __ .w. ll -----

M~RIMAtK SlAfiUN UNII i.

r· - ----£rif"RGY----~wi1----------~----·- ---- ----:co..\L"FLC>W Las - ·mAM-ilow--- t.Ls -- ·1 • 6!1~ -6s3 ! ·· 685 -·T -6u·T-t~e1f-66a--t--212--T2f31214_1_215~T-i'• 217T·--2ilni9h20 -l2£1TI22--~-223-r-:,;··- i

TiM[ ; N([ ' MOSO : M083 I M082 ! MOSI I MQ6.t ! TOTAL II oc : CYC L:' CYC CYC l CYC -1 C:lYC : CYC I lLJall It EXTR ! 'AUX' ! AU. X I FO FA' N.; : I GEN I GRO:>S I RUN START I COM SOOT~ COAL 2A : 28 2C I 20 I 2f 2f 20 SlfAM I AUX I STIAM I StEAM I COIL ! : ! TIE BLOWG I ' STEAM I I TO 2 I 2 TO 1 SliM\ l ~ ---- -~-Xl~_j_-~~~Q_j~'!_O ___ I ~10 t XI 219'Lt-~-!L L ... '!!•.. XIL..J. .... • XIO ! XIO '10 XI"'!!_).. X\0 I X\0 ... L1"0 ·l £_00 ___ 1 I _DAILY • ~~~ _____ ]_ ______ ---~100 ____ _xJO__J__!IOOO -------~(I(J_ XlOOOO I_ XIOOO X100 __ XI~_;

_ 2~08 3C7'1 120t 312 G24 1352 2308 . 3332 3304 3248 3284 3312 3288 3320 1926 4 ffi4 4 0 473 2 ~s:~ 3:S4 1192 311 G23 1358 22q8 ~3312 3284 3228 323C 33~~ 3272 330E 1926 4 ~8 n 10 471 3 2J3G .31!)2 12~3 311 S21i 1358 2326~ 335G 3322 3268 3308 3340 3316 3344 1930. 3 PJ2 4 14 470

-- '1 2 1,;2. 3GG.8 . i1g3 . 3i2 G23 13C3. 23P4 "J3z4 -~~~ n4't'=,~ ffl~""13it '!922 ·~ 156' "~=n"F-7 47!1 :; 2'\:~ . 3~71~ 1115 311 522 1352 2312 334~ 325C 325G 33~3 3321~ 33~~ 3332 19ZG 3 ~~ 31 t1 !18~ .; L.33j 3CJG ll'JG 311 623 1354 2314 333G 3300 3256 330~ 332~ 330~ 3332 1q32 3 ffl2 11~ 24 ~74

r ·~

J 'lj

:1 J.L

13 i!l

15 , ' ~-'

l7 16 19 2;.; 21 .. ~ ~

~JJ8 3G72 1185 311 G23 1368 2233 330~ 3272 3216 3268 3284 3256 3295 1928 4re4 24 10 47G 2~14 307e 11sJ 311 s23 135s 229n 3304 3272 3216 3zss 3zss 3zsa 3292 102~ 3$0· zs 4 473 289G 3CG~ 118& 312 624 1364 2276 3288 3260 3204 3232 3272 3248 3272 1922 4.8 3Q za 476 2J~2 3CG8 1206 313 624 1~58. 2320 3344 3320 3268 3276 3336 3308 334¢ 1924 3$2 24 10. 482 2910 3076 1194 312 624 ~~8 2292 3312 3280 3228 3240. 3296 3268 3304 1922 4~6 20 20 479 zg2s 3094 1194 312 623 1350 230C 0 331S 3292. 323&-. . .3250 .. 33"4 3280. .3312 1924 4 ea 14 ° ~ 474 2932 3096 ngs 312 622 BG0 2292 33~~~ 3280 3224 ·3260 3292 3264 33aa 1924 4 m~ 20 20 474 zg10 3076 119~ 313 624 1376 22se 3292 3264 32as 3236 3272 3252 .3280 1222 316 20 ~ 485 2920 308G 12~3 311 - 62.2 ~·136S . 2332 3368 3332. '32!0.--331&. 3356. 3324 .3356 .1926 4 ~~ 14.-- ~ 484 2~JcO 3068 121s 312 624 1372 23Sf 3432 34f4 · 3352 3396 3424 3384 3a.es 1932 4 zs 0 ~ 493 2SiJ8 2976 1226 312 623 1368 2404 3456 3428 · 3428 .3ft56 3518 )4t'S 3368 1390 44SS 4 0. 502 2792 2962 1237 312 . 623 1362 -4436 .3468- 3~0: 3412. -3532 .3564.: ... -344~ . 338fL 1$11 4li8-.. .li - 4 - 507 2818. 2986 1222 312 624 1364 2396 3436 3412' 3416 3444 3472. 34~4 3368 18!0 42i2 24 ~ 508 2838 30i)G 1227 312 623 1374 2ff16 3472 3444 .· 3444 3476 35~9 34211 3392 1898 3 ~0. 14 4 516 281C 2980 1235 312 622 1380' I 2432 3500 3472 3464 "35P8 3536 3444 3396 .lS98 4 212 30 4 520 : Z.i6 2976 1234 312 G24 1370 2424 3476 3456 3456 3488 352C- 3436 34i5 1892 3 g:oz 10 ~ 52'' :8J4 2Y74 1237 311 624 1372 2438 3500 3492 3468 3524 3556 3444 3396 1898 4V6 20. 0 52 27( 1• ::~n2- 1228 312 623 1386 24~6 3440 343G 3428 34G3 3500 34C8 3380 1872 4 ~~ 24 j Si~ -~.~ 'ci 73~lc 2298 71f8 1495 3275 ls~~~ 8100 8037 795C 8~4!1 8118 an01 8020 \ 45'3S <iS ~., 14 1175

r'ri r"? ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ " ~ ~ ~ - { - ' ,_ f\:) ~ ~ . "' ~ "'). ~ " <a ~ ~~~~~

--, --- 1~~;~ -l I I ! GAL

ltEACf KVAIS 6'90 691

- -~------ -··-·- ---C\JRft'NT AMme.s I ~ 665 ti66 667 668 ixcml IWNTSTART 1

1

COM

·-----PO-WEI KW =r ~-u~,-r~,~n~~~~=~~~

IIJN START I CqM l Ill'.£ \ CONO

IIUH STAIT $TA STA

. UMI. SAV · fiEIJ) PH pt( PH I T If I

• 1 l I l l PH 1 l GfN I STA -~~- . I T~ •.

Page 51: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

::: ~··= .:!. __ . _,.;.-;" /. :~,~j:·;__z;rJ-/ i ; I

"'· ' · i,..,£~-Gv KWH ________ -,---- co~ FLow uu ---~ ·51·e;:M R.ow w-- · 1 '"· "' r '"~ : "' '- '" T'"' ~-t-"o-:-,;--1 '"-l m~ I ,i.--~21,- r-iii- r ·2,9· --t--m-··T··--n~·-1 271·--rn3-,.....--22 ... : '· ' MDCC ~"'' : MOb2 ; MOil j """' 1 ToTAl : eve 1 m , eve eve eve I eve ,· eye II tuRa

1

. exn ! ~o.ux 1 Aux ! ~o FAN !

Cf!'. GROSS I f.UN I STAiiT I COM I SOOT ., COAL I 2A I 28 ~2C 20 2'£ 2F 2G STEAM AUX I STEAM ST!AM I COil II ! TIE ' 6lOWG • ~TEAM I TO 2 2 TO 1 STEAM

f ~ - • ' .oo - X!"!_. ~~-"" ~~ l._XI9 j__ '\'P--j ".l::--l-~~·~ I_ '-.!LL~•P "" . XIO I XIO XIO _L XIO I XI~ XIO I'~Jf, X ... J -~;;;--! r;A

1.'i : _x!OOO ___ L _____ .. ~~----- ~?_j__Xl~----------- XIOO ~~t_X_~~t:--~--~--j

. .. ....... . . ,. ....... ...... J ~U:~RIMA<-1< STAHUN vlrJ!T 2

l. .:G4~-'· :.U:j~ :!.217 311 623 13G4 23E·O 337G 3350 336~ 3388 3416 33It8 3342 1818 3 1?8 4~ 20 I~E9 i~L~ 27L~ 121G )12 £24 1382. 2364 3392 3364 3358 3372 3424 33G4 3354 18j2 4 VG 40 34 431 --~ .4 277.: 1207 311' C24 137G 2332 3352 3323 3328 3256 3392 33211 334~ 1793 4 3+~ S0 14 442

't ~~l~ j73~ 1.191 311 G24 1382. 228~ 3238 326~. 3264 3176 3312 3?Gj 3275 177~ ~72 28 1~ 442 ~· ?P". ~83G 12 1)6 311 G24 1372 233:i 33GC 3332 3336 3280 3338 3328 3340 1814 4 l)G 4G 4 464

:1~2. 2:7G llgR 311 f23 13Ej 231C 332f 32~G 3300 32GC 3356 3300 3312 1822 3$2 14 14 47G 2!72 2938 :195 311 G23 1366 2316 3332 3300 33~0 3264 3356 33A9 3316 1844 4 ~2 52 ) 4~1 ~743 2Jl2 llS3 312 624 1364 2270. 326tl 3232 3232 3208 3288 3232 3248 1f2G ~8~ 6~ 14 479

J. 2782 2943 lEH 312 624 137G 2288 3284 3256 3260 3240 3316 326~ 3272 1848 4 :56 14 30 48G l ,' 20~2 3020 1213 312 624 1356 2354 3380 3356 3356 3l4~ 3412 3343 336(1 19~2 4 :!16 20 4~-. 502 u ::r;n 3~44 ngs 313 625 nsa 2326 3336 33~a · 3316 3296 3372 3312 3336 190~ 4 tns 34 .'+ 493 ~2 L':i To 3044 12Cl 312 624 137.2 _ .2328 .3344 __ 3312 . 332..11 _. 326& .. 3312 332P .. 3336 190~- 4 ~8 _ 30. -· . 4. 5~7 !3 2878 3044 1199 312 623 1366 2322 3336 3308 339~ 3268 3364 33~8 3328 18~8 418 14 20 516 1 't 2 8G5 3032 1196 312 623 1366 23~8 3316· ' 3284 - :s2as :·'3250 334~ 3288 '33-04 i89s 4 112 1~ 10 s21 :_:) 2ss6 3020 naG 312 . 623 ·.Bas 22.u ... 3275-.. 32uQ . 3244 .. 32U · 33~a· .•. 3244 . 3264 -1&92.. .. 1(144 .14. . 20. s21 L :>8G8 3032. 1187 312 621 1376 2278· 3272 · 324- :5244 3232- 3296 3244 3264 1894 4 J'4 3G 20 515 !7 2S74 3J40 1197 312 621 136a. 2312 3388 32B~ 328~ 326& · 3332 3276 3296 1898 4~8 '34. 1~ 516 :s 2874 3038 1182 311 621. 1364 2270 •. :S26L32:S().< .. J24&l .: 3l8J 329.2c-·- 3235 ... .32-52- 1294 __ :.aaa _ 40 . 14 510 .i.~ 28ti4 3028 1181 312 621 1374 2258 ~3244 322g . 3~20 . 3164 3272 322~. 3240 1892 1Q.l6 14 IJ 513 2,; 2 90G 3072 1191 312 621 1382 2290 '}.33P~ 3268 3272 3196 . 3324. 3268 3288 1928 3 ~8 3(j 24 517

~~--.... --~~~*-~~~~ ii~~ ~i~ ~~r 1m ~~~ i~~~ ~~ ~3iHm-m~ ~~~-, 1~~ . n~~ . it --lt ~-M--~ ~~~: 3JG~. 1182 312 f21 138G 27fi4 3256 3232 3232 3152 ~292 3232. 3252 192G 4$2. 24 30 510

:':r 3J7J 11:~ 312. G21 1372 2276 326R 32~0 3240 3224 3300. 324~ 3250 1~28 4 ~0 20 20. 5~0 ' /' ·.: 7J 3 7 '2G3 7!i 3 J 491~ 32'J2 \ 5530~ 7946 7870 7884 77~1 801f 7378 791~. I 449G ~~j 7': 38 ll_i~'

I ~ "~ ~ 9 L:,J -~ ~ ~· ' I I - !"\. '~i ,'? ~ "":,, ~' IX ' "') \},. ~\. "' ~ ':) ") <')-~\ "J '\) \l\ i~ \\ '-"- ) ~ If) . ~ "J

'~Mr

·-· -t~~ ~]·----- -:·-----r·----- -~-;:-;:wu ~: -:~--~-.-:ocr ~::~ ----~- 664 1 60~J.JR1R~~ ;u.m-rs----:;~-----r GAL . , , RUN START8C»>. WH START fXC

1

GEN lfVN , COM r COND I I " G£N STA STA Tic • STA STA FIElD PH 1 PH PH TIE

1 TANK I .&~•v ~'ltv ., UlJN !SI\I. · 1 t 1 ,... 1

Page 52: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~l~e ~~ti~, ~-~-~f!-~~-~0-~ _ _ ~~ --~- __ --~~ _____ . -,_:t<ll_v __ --- .;;;,. :_,_;:_A Ul .. --- -,- _____________ _

ENERGY KWH ~- COAl FLOW 111:> t STEAM FLdW LB~ 6~; 6G3 r·--685 -r- -686. ]" 681 --r-·688 ._ 212 213--T -2i"4" • 2l5-T-2)6- ~-- 2ll- '2ii-· -2i9- -I- 220 -T--221 f-i2f - 72" .':4

f",'.f . ~•tr . NOBO I MO(I'J \ M082 !- M081 : M064 TOT~CYC \ CYC eve I CYC CYC r eve 1 CYC i Tl 1RB I EXTI! I AUX AuX ' rl' f~"-1 I

G~r-.. 1 -.;Ro:.s ! Rur. START - cow. 1 sooT I c~L\ l . 2A 2e 2:J 20 · 1E 2f ! 2G 1 STEAM I AUX I STEAM STEAl.~ . corL 1 I m BLOWG ,

1 l · 5TfAM 1 ro 2 2 TO 1 • 'E~

_ ~ _ , .. ,. U.!"9J , , , --~Ll -~·,.,_ r·~·~· 1

• "'' 1 "Ll_., .,. 2 ·~ _ , _ "'" I .,. , ... L., coo 1 __ X_1 o 1 x, o _J _ _2(_!_9 ~ _ x too_ 1.

DAILY " __ ~~- _t _______ XIOO _ ---~ XlOOO ---- XIOO --------~~~---XIOOO I _ _!1?0 __ , Xl~-:;_ :,: J\. 2 :J~CS 11~13 311 C21 1374 2284 327G 3248 3252 323f 33'18 3248 3ZG3 l'J2G ~~ l30 34 ., ~ :J 7 L .c~ )::, 3.:G2 l1J1f 311 :":21 1324 2256 324; ~212 3216 /-)lC:~ 3~()5 321G 3228 1':1 22 3 ~'," 114 j_c; ::17 ~ 2 rL.J ~-;:~ n:_i) 3H CB 1376 227r 325r: 3232 3232 32:.2 3208 3228 3243 J.934 4 j_G 2~ I;' :;1' ·· .::'J3J :;VJII ll~J :ill GlQ l36G 2278 32f.8 324J 3244 3~:~ 321JG 3240 32G~ ICE3 3 :r~ 24 ::· ;_~~ .) - .J12 3070 llo5 311 Gl3 1382 22G4 3252 3224 3224 32l2 ::i2SC 3220 323G 1:1lG 4 lS 34 3'. ~:12

_ H8 3.jU 118S 312 ClQ 138G 2272 32G:1 3232 323f 323~ 3ZSS 3232 32S2 P311 3 :E8 11 3.. SJ?. I 2~2C 3~)J 1180 31~ G2C. 1364 2284~3272 3248 32!18 32:,F 33·14 3243 32G 11 1'134 4T>4 2~ 14 =--~". " ~JL 3~ 74 .i.li'[, 311 . Gli3 138G 226G~ 324l; 3224 3228 3232 3276 3224 324C 1q32 3 $C· 54 ~4 j"S J ~9:.i4 3J9£ 1165 312 621 1372 2282~ 3272 3244 3240 32C!I 3"3~10 3244 3264 1938 3 $~ 24 3::1 I~})

.. r;· -:! 1Jh '10'~~- ... .tm ,.. ~Jr' ~n-,~"1~ 2~~~ ._~11~· 5~4'8 3252 3'-Gt 3304 r2lt~-,~~4 l!Bd 3 ~0. 1rl 1e 494 11 2396 3060 1177 312 621 13n 2252 -3228 320~ '3204 3216 32GO 32~ · 3220 1926 3 ~2 10 L: 483 1: 2870 3032 1168 312 620 1386 2226 3200 3172 .3172 ~-3136 3224- 3168 . 3138 1924 3$0 10 24 471 13 2912 307G 1179 312 621 1374 ~,26~ ;. 3256 322~ • ~Z2Jl . 3160 328~ 3224 324~ 1938 3 $6 10 24 4G3 14 2740 2900 1142 312 622 1371 2.128_ 3064 • .3032 r ::S.C~e- . 2968 3~88 3640 3~56 lt16 3 mG 24 74 439 15 2 75G 289G 1141 311 621 ·lJit . -2~o,.~; ;w!Q. 3~iU&.:· -l~-~:,J$1~ 31N -!118-- .3~61 1818 3 914- 14 2~ 439

.. ,. ·:' ..... · ·~·:·\~ ·." . . _: ~""

, ~ .._ I

J.O

19 )

r} ,,

~1 ,.

LL 1-_:;

I f"'r • -0--14

2358 2358 2380 23G8 . ., ,- ,.... ... .:.. l .. d.Jv

.2::. ~. s ,.... (' r\) .~ v \.... '-

3006 3020 3020 3042 303C )~.;3li

3C5~ 31~G

1159 1166 1168 1167 llGS 1164 1170 117)

311 62t 1370 22u 3192 3lso :--.,u.r.- 3124 311 621 1378 . .;.,223" ·• 32~8 3176. ~,.-1184 .. 3140 312 621 1366 ~2238-'~,-~-3220-3188 >;;$1t& -, 3152 312 622 1372 '~23C.. ·:- 3208 318~ <-'318J 3155 312 621 1372- - 2228 - -32~~ 316& .31'76: 3136 311 619 1366 2234 321G 3176 3188 3132 311 621 1366 2246 3224 3lq6 3196 31~4 311 G20 13GS 226~ 324a 3216 3224 31g~

'·... 72'32. 2314 747 14£3 3295 \537iH 7724 7653 7661 7sr;:;

L c 1..;, t, ~ ~ ,.., ...., ~ 'V

~· ....; rt fl'). 00.. ~ ~ ~ -~ ~ ~ ') "lJ ")) 0

322~ 3160 318~ 1872 3232 3172 .. 3192 1896. 3244· 3192 3208 l8S4 3236 3184 32~0 19~~ 3228 '3172 3192 1896 3244 3184 3208 1896 3252. 320~ 3220 1~~~ 3276 322j 3240. 1893 7790 7656 769~ \45~r

& c ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ')j ~ '?

'))

3 gJ~ 38)6 4 ~8 4 ~8 3~8 3$6 3 'lld 3 C])2

3>1

34 3~ 2e 16. 14 54 14 1~ t;;7

4~ 14 t~4

1~ sc 34 -~4

';(

445 450. 452-41,9 44? 1;43 ~~1

'35 I~' 113~~

nM' ~ ~~: : -- r II, ---r--T 616 !!,'" .:,l ~ 11~0~-·.;:: I ,-~ ~~l"i~f.~:r -,:r 1 (vND , I .. G£N STA STA TIE srA j nA mw I PH I PH I ~>H TIE i :

1 TANr I uav uav . . t.mV suv 1 1 1 ~ PH 1 t ..... , • .. ' •

Page 53: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

De"!!•' ~J~7tCf7:{ MERiliMACK STATION UNIT 2

E: ::~:~·- ~~:·J~~f:w~, ;:··-G::T~~:~,' -~: ~-~:: -r0~~1~:£?~1• ~~:-~-~~~~{E~t~r£~T~r~ ;,Ri·~_;~: I f~E I BlOWG! ~ I . . I tTEAM~T02 i 2 TO l I STEAM

XIOC ! Xl~ .!.JP.- L-~~ _J_XlO XI I XJ.Cl9_ XlO -~O~L- ~-!LL~.!il-~10 XIO -~~~- XIO Xl_q_L_3!9-+_:<I_~ x1ooo __ .... __ xi_O<? _____ .. _x!_~_j_!'~- _____ ---------·------~~~------------- -----i~~-o~- -~~~ --~'?0 ... --L~~-

r.··-

C'Ar• •

._ .. :' -· ::~'32 H7iJ 311 ~~1 1371~ 2238 3212 3124 312£ 31rl0 3243 3134 3204 H:94 3 tJ72. 4:\ 14 :,2r; - ; . .) -~~ lL~ :;1•2 ClS l3C!1 2242 3224 3l'J2 3196 3172 32~2 3138 32::8 1398 3 'bG I;:. 3,!. Ill

, .. .-.wr;. 3·~t uzg JU &l!l n£a 22~ 3m :s1z4 nrs 31~ 32iS 31!~ 32a~ IBCJ~~ 3 !lrl 31 ~~ ~~3 ·'• :.7~ )..,l1,_ : ~;::; :.:11 E:l7 13Gii 223C 3220 3184 31J2 311;3 32!:1~ 31.)8 321'3 1.8% 3 538 2·~ )4 1~25

... 7C ->:.::: 117·3 312 Gl5 1371) 2236 32~8 318·:; 319: 31fl~ 32!/ 31~11 320~ l:.'Jt-; 3TL; -~ 11; ';33 _ :.~ :: · s: 117 11 -~11 n5 nc:; 221;4 3215 31RS 31% 3131~ 3252 3~ 'l2 32:~r 12'J3 3 JJS 1~ 3:~ 43~

~·N' 1 =·-~~:·, ll7; :11 G19 1352. :242 3216 319G 3196 31r; 3248 31% 3212 1S96 3 ]0·. 14 30. L,31 ,_, ~L. ·:,· r, 1107 311 Gl5 13G2 2258 3244 3212 3220 3184 -j-2-n-42lfi_ 3236 rqrJ2 3 <132 ~1 54 42C .,.:~;;:_;4 "5 •:;:.; 1139 312 612 135S 2276 3276 324~ 324'~ 32~4 32% 32'+4 3164 1M4 4 ~4 1~ 1~ ~12

.. l . ._.: ~- ),:54 1n2 312 G05 1352 2278 3276 3243 3252 3176 3301* 3252 3268 1904 4 mz 20 1! 1101! . ~ h '3~38 1182 311 614 1352 2258 3248 3212 322~ 3160 3276 3224 324~. 1904 3 ID2 10 0 393 .:8:G 3~50 1137 311 621 1362 2276 3268. 3240 3248 3192 . 3300 3244 3264- 19~4 4 ~2 14 ~ 389 _Yl2 3U6G 1189 311 621 1354 228~ 3264' .3236 3244 326~ 33~e 3240 3256 1926 4.$2 4 ~ 376 2Jl~ ~~s~ 1192 311 620 1354 2294 3284 3256 3264 3zaa· 331€ 326~ 32BS 1934 4az 4 94 367

~ )

~ _,

.:.sJ4 3,:158 1184 311. 621 '!36~ 227~ 3252 3224 3232 3248 3284 3228 3244 . 193~ 3 ~g 20 0 365 . ; .' ), :·, 3"'70 1188 311 621 1350. 2286 3292 3260 3264 3196 3308 326~ 3284 1934 3 ~6 4 10 362 ~v ~~lG 308U 1188 312 62~ 1352 2290 ~3288 3268. 3272 3184 3328 3268 3288 1938 3~~ 1~ C 358 lJ ;":'2 3UGD 1183 312 62i--;H~~27z-3.24.·4 324.8 3158 3304 321•.$. 326& 193. "-· ij IZt1 4 4 382

- :i- :~i~·· ~~jd -i~ ~H ~ 35 ·"'-

4 ~HiH#HRH~t~ ~f~~- ~~~~jf j~~ if ~ c6g ::> _. ·L 3t.~C:2 nn 311 62~ 1354 22sG 3244 3216 3216 317G 3268 3216 3232 1936 3 an 11. o tt22

'..,~.

:-~r: :·~~ :177 311 E22 1370. 2252 3236 32~4 3212 3176 3264. 3212 3224 1923 4$0 14 ( ~2G ~ •. ~ :o;·· -.~· U82 311 G21 13G2 2274 3272 324r1 3240 32·1C 32q2 324~ 325n lq2? 3 ~6 i0 ~~} '+'15

. : ;-~~.:, ~.~3S 71;7 llte3 3255 \542J.~ 77'08 7713 773( 7G37 7857 772S 77CS \ !;595 J;~ 33 :~:- ~75

~ ~~~~~ ~~

.;,,. .. 231

(;Al

COND

'j --·---1-- -

l I ! I

1"6 • I . • ......._. ,..;_ '-) ~ • o-.. "') -...s ~ ~ W.;)

~ ~ C() ~ ~ ,., '? ~ "' "1 n, /\') "" ra

-------.-- -·- r·--- --' ---- ·- -- ---·-- ___ .. ,_- -· ·-r--·. REACT ~~::vAJs I 1 c~~T AMPERES 1

::1 691 I 1664 I 00~ T ~T-667 [668- .. 1 STAIIT I I tXC. 1 ~EN l RUN j' START I COM STA fiELD 1 PH PH PH • ) TIE

·-r:-- ________ ] ___ _ 1

POWER KW ·

~ 6n j 671 1 6~9 ~ I RUN j START I COM

G£N I SlA ST4 Tl£

Page 54: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

_ .... ;•' . -. t- - '- --~

. . . .. . . . .. ·- .---:. - 0< ''" ..:.. ; ... •..._··

-··' t

• ( } ·"I .' \ ... ...-

.;. Dlltf> _____ -· ~- '_. ::!.:.! :~ ___ MER~IMACK STATION UNIT 2 . r· -·---~ - -- - -- -- ----tNER-Gr ____ "Kwti ___ ---------r-------- -·-------coAC"Ftow--w---------- --~--------sre"AH~o'N- -l:ss

• ,, .. i E~: ~~r~:,r~:J~:,-r:r:,; ,;; i ~:~-~rl~ ~:T~;~ ·-1- ~2;{·-r T::

--· --· -~-- - 'T"- -- I. ---·

221 , 212 1 223 ! 224 EXTR I AUX i AUX ; FD FAI

2E 2f 2G STEAM AUX SltAM I STEAM I COIL

I . I "'±i~ ±= XIO XIO. I XIO • XIOOO s~~: I 1 ;~/ 2;1~ 1 I s~~~ 1----- _ Xl~ __ j_~_l_~_j_-~ Xlq_ _X~ XI ~LOQ_ Xl<?._l_Xl<; _.!.!.Q_ XIO

L DAILY - -~~~ _____ j _____ ---~100 ---- >O~J.~~~ --- -----~-----·-· XIOO XIO 000 -·-- --"----+------ _XIOOO_ I Xl~-----1.~1~

l .::8'J4 7 ~:.., llOJ 71., ~2;t 137d 227G 32["4 37.44 3244 3212 32::JF 32!111 32GC l'J24 j ,]_ ~ '· ; '· ::s ~ ,,·:;> J .J,-.L .... ~ . ''"' •1 3~.-S'i llJ: 311 Cll 13 31~ 227!; 3Zf·4 324; 3244 320~ 3292 3240 32SC 1028 3 ~~ I,; 14 '· ':" i..u:J~

,.._, 3. ~~C)~. 3.JC4 1197 311 G21 l3C!1 2338 3355 3328 3)22 3312 33~4 3322 334~ l'J3~ 4 1'~ lC. 3\ •r -. .) 4 ~ ,,. ICI _,..~, .· ::.1 s~1 ?.E 51( 1372 ~3 ·:r. 33;i3 ~234 37f.8 32G3 334r! 3233 33~'4 1 Cl :.>2 4 ~s 3!~.

.. j,~ . ' .. .

. , r~ t ~,1)4 110.~ 312 597 13CL :314 332F: 320f. 33C. 325S 3356 "'"1'f1:\ 331G lS24 3 71C 4 s· '.!""'' l...v .... ~ .JJ'.J • ,,.,_:,

~Jl~ ::::74 liS: ::ill Gl~ 13G~ ')c'l') ;...J.:..~

777r ..I.J.) ·'

37''"1 .J.!.- 3312 32.5C 33G: 3312 3332 193'~. 3 aJ2 4 , '· '-+71 ..... 7 2Jl2 -; ~1 7 G lie~ 312 5G4 1374 2312 331:- 3288 3296 32G4 334B 321'12 33ri8 1930 4 r~ 1~ lU 471

..:X2 3v72 1187 311 570 1358 231~ 3320 3292 3288 32Sj 3348 3292 3312 . 1928 4 Iir' tJ 24 !I g: ~:9~.- 3_JC4 11J0 312 Gd3 1378 2306 3308 3280 3288 3252 3340 3284 3304 1930 4128 4 14 4G

1~ LZ~"Je 30C4 1207 312 575 1366 2352 3372 3344 3348 3332 3408 3348 3368 193~ 4 E4 20 2:J 44" 11 2Jl8 3084 1201 312. 6~4 1374 2350 3372 3344 3352 3312 3404 3344 3364 1934 4 :E0 1~ 3~ 42! 12 2!)16 3QB2 1205 312 . GlS 1362 2342 336& . 3336 .3344. 3288 3392 334i!- 3364 1~~6. 4 ~fi 14 24 41~ l:i 289~ 3:)64 1192 312 61~ 1374 z3oe 33d0 . 3272 3276 3248 3336 3272 328"8. 193~ 0 4 ~4 1~ 14 4~~ '. 2C"JJ6 3070 lli:S 312 613 137~ 2268 326~ 3228 3228 320~ 3288 3228 3244 1928. 41.28 4 10 4~{ l't :;.s d~~ 3CG4 1179 312 592 1364 2244 3224 3196 32(1~ 3164 3252 3196 . 3212 l93~ 4 fitS 0. .e 391 lu 2896 3060 1173 312 559 1374 2222 3192. 3164 3168 3136 3224 3164 . "3184 .1932 4136 14 1(3. 39~ :7 2910 3C74 1184 311 535 1366 2252 3236- 3204 3212 3184 3264 3204 3220 .193-8" 4 G32 4. 10 3Ci~ , ~. 2920 3082 1170 312 589 1374 2222 ~31~2 3lse 31&4 3148 3220 3164 .. 318~ .1936 3$4 14 4 39~ ... v

3134 3188 3124 3236 3184 2.iPI 1038 4 (B4 14 1~ 4Ci 3i"t6 3ir;8 3ii2 J2Hs , .. 1

3 a;o 13. ...

3152 316"8 1934 4 4 3] 31t~4 31Ei4 3C7G 3224 31134 318tl 1934 4 U6 24 3·:' IJ 4 ~

~ .... 2');;1, ~(GG l17(J 311 596 1334 2215 3188 31G4 3168 3080 3224 31G4 3134 1J2rl 3 95d .34 , ,"'( 4;,~ L. i.. •

' 1

.. i _; r --: ~, 3:.ss 1171 312 592 13q2 221d 317G . ·-· .'"t 311~8 3143 31~1! 32~0 3152 31G4 1 f)F-. 3 !J)G )!; )4 ' ~c

~I . ' . -I ... '"\·" ll7l 313 S""C' 14)J 22~4 3164 3132 3132 3136 3183 3132 3148 1"1 .. 4 :56 ~~~ ,11 '""": &- ... l, •• ~ .. .",:...(. uu ~ . ......... 'r .. 73:3G L&!,l 74t 1427 3235 15115~ ~ 7e4:! 7776 77':.4 7f:15 7ql3 7778 78~6 \ 4G2n

·r;c~ "7? ~'l , t"fr- , ,_.,J ... !L. "- •' _.;I

~ 0 ~ "!? <:;:)

~· ~-~ ~ o-. . ~ ~ ~

I . ~

........

~ "' ~ o-..

'1j ~ ~ ~ "? 1 'U ".l

,_..: -~~~:; ----~~-T~f:-r:., ,:=r---------.,.

F~ I il: r.~J.:T--REACT KVAU

690 I _691 ~ . SiAAT

Page 55: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

:.~·...__ --.- - ._:__ -~.:_;- ; ." '::._-~·-· . .. ·. . -- - . -·- ------- --- ------- - ---------------- --- --,.-- --~------ ... ·-- --

[~EilGY ~~;WH I . COAl flOW LIS . ! STEAM FLOW LaS

: .• ,.~ •. ~~--~- }~~ -r.~:3- ~M6~:2-·! M:·,l ~:~ -. ~~~:L-r~~ -r~~~J· ~~~ . r~;~- l ~~ T-~ ! c2:~;- ::a j r~2T~ , .. -;1~- -T .~~~ : r iJz:~N-Gt::. : G>IOS-5 Rl!N ' START I COM ., SOOT COAl I 2A I 2:l2C I 20 l 2E L:f _kG ~STeAM I AUX STEAM • STEAM I COil ! I TIE 6i.OWG . I STEAM I I TO 2 I 2 TO : I STEAM

'o•nv t':"'XJ2oo"~J~"~-:: ~;; 1-~~o_ i fu-l :~~+=~~o-:_-~ xl•--=~~~-:_i!'~--~--£L x•o ___ _:_ x~~~j x~; j ~-o-~-~~~-j- x~~j 1 /204 3SS~ 1176 312 5GC 13~2 2222 ·3184 31SG 31G~ 3172 3208 3160 31711 1'320 4 ~0· 34 21! ''83 ~ t91D 30JU llBU 312 5~6 1395 2236 3204 313S 3li6 3192 323S 318~ 3196 l93S 4~~ 20 l~ 515

' _:·;~;:: y::;s 118!1 ~12 :i'J8 14n 221l• 3176 3148 31S2 31C8 32M. 31'-•8 31E4 1924 4 n2 3:) 71• 519

:,; 2Jl!• 3;;n 1132 312 545 1396 2224 3183 3IG•: 31G8 317G 3212 31G0 3l:t1 1')2G 4 '£0. 20 C!, :.3'~ ,. 2S..iW 3/J4 llO 312 Gl9 139G 2232 ~32.)~ 31G£ 3172 3122 3228 3172 3192 1gy~ 3 ~~ 1e. ·~·~ :;53

II')

2'=!;~ :n~~:: 1127 ~12 621 1394 224C~32~4 320r 32~(1 313~ 3242 3200 321G 1CJ3!; 41'4. 30 /It Gl7 ~---~-2~.- .. :::;~~-c- Trs!r·· · 3ir .. ··-m 1394 224-o 3izr-!Iss 3El2 31S4 3244 3iss 32o4 193c= 4 12s 3G an E'23 ~:! ;\.: 3~.J34 1185 313. G20 1406 2224 3184 31G4 31Gb 3134 3216 316C. 3176 1922 4:12 44 8(J' 555

1 . :")':•; 3(r:";4 1183 313 613 1396 2246 3216 3188 3192 3232 324!1 3184 32~~ 1918 4128 10. 252. 432.

1l iJ3~• 3C38 1180 313 6041402 2242 3216.3184 3192 320fl.32il.& 3188 3200 1932 4$~.--.0 258.· 431 1~ 2Jl4 3078 11s3 312 sgz 1392 22s4 3236 32Ds 3212 3196 32~~ .32ea 32ze 1924. 4•s g 224 412 :3 iJ2B 3094 12PO 312 563 1390. 2322 3332. I 3312 3312· 3264 3354 .. 3312 3324 193-2 4 liS ~ 180 394 ~. 2918 3034 12C6 312 612 l31l8 2346 336d .... 3331 .. 334~ · 3344 .J3£S., ... 3332..,. 33.56. l922. 4.2&4 4 0 386 lJ 2880 304G 1208 312 619· 1~94 2338 3356 3328.3332 330~ 3384 3,28 3348 1986 4Z3 24 0 377 :, . ~s ·,c 304G 121s 312 613 1384 2372 3408 3376 338~. ·;.nGs 3432 3'72 338;! ~916. 4 ~~ , 20. . ~ · 368 ~I 2352 3020 1212 312 592 139~ .. 2344 33S~ 3332 .. 3532. '336~ .3388 3328;- 3351. l9S4. 4 Z5 ,_ 10 0 -366 .. ::.... nJ0 2936 1201 311 599 1385 23~6 33~8 -~272 3276 3312 3328 3272 · 3292 1878' ·4 ~0. 4 4 359 lJ ~256 3022 1207 111 611 1390 234C ··3352. 3324 3324 336~ 3384 3328 3344 1918 4~4 14 0 41S .:..., • 23~G 3072. 1206 3ll !i19 _ 1392 2332 . 3336- 3312 . 3316 33.56 . 3368 3312 ·. 3332, 1936 4 lt4 34 0 458 ~l 2B7~ 3044 1193 311 c2e 1400 2280 3268 324~ 324~ 3264 3296 324g 3256 193~ 4&6 2~ 14 476 ~: LJ~~ 3074 11~2 312 G20 1398 2294 3232 32GP 32GC 3280 3316 ·3256 3276 1945 4 ns 30 14 493 .: :~ .:Jlb ~~~G 12Ei 312 C2l 1396 2372 3404 3384 33E\J 3l;·.l4 3432 336S 33li3 1945 4 252 24 1: S19 ~ ~~~2 Z3~~ l~Qa zqa lGIZ 130G 5~93 ~aas J~gg i&~G 1s2s 1es2 lJ96 Jn!0 ~e11 4 ~g a& 1u~ li3a

C"<F

2:.1.

\\l GAL

CON ['I

!ANI(

XIM

$$()30 ~- ~~ ~· J.... ~ - 1-.j~.! lp ~ ~- ,. ,~ ~- ~ [~ s \) ~') (A ~"' ~· ;,~ )\ r:z

\• '? '9 ~ <'- ~ \}\. ~ ~

'\ d

---- r··---~--b76 -~~Wf_R_ 6~-- ~-::=r----,~CT K:~~ I r-=;-,:~UR~~ AM~~---, :e- ~-- ---··1=

l ltUN TI~r COM mUN $TART EXC I GfN RUN START coo ~ GHol STA I STA Ttl . I' $TA STA I . . FIELD ,.H ffl PH I TIE

SERV SEiV ,$9V S£RV . . 1 1 l ~ PH I .... _... .. .. -- -·--~ .: ___ ' '· . ' .

Page 56: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

._.(·. '::·__:_: ~·.·:. . -:· · .. Mf~RIMACK 5rATION UNif 2

·._ ...:......::.

u~,e · --~·-·-·-··- - .:71~ --·-[ · :- - - -- ·- -- ~-- i:NiR-Gv -- -KwH · ------- --·-r -------- . coAt fl.~ lll ---:· snAAA FLow -l!IS. - · --

i ! ·- t82 -~ ---68:11- '68s ___ l6e6- ;· -6ii_1 __ b88 ·i -212-~---iEi "lii4--T2TS--f216-217 211 ---ri9j 220 221 m -22-J_j __ ~ ''"·' , "" · ~oac 1 MC03 l Moe> I •o01 ! M08« i rom I e>c I cYC c'c I <>< nc C\'C eve I TLU "'" .wx l /I.IJX 1 FD F·

I • GEN I GROSS I 1\IJN START I COM I SOOT ,. COAL I 2A j 211 2C 2D 2f 2f .2C STEAM AUX STEAM . STEAH. I co 1 1 1 ! J m . BLowe; J . STEAM 1 ro 2 2 ro 1 I sm ~- - r'- X]_~ ..l -~~---L~ ... _j_ _X_I_t:" ___ _E...O_t1 -~!..-n' ~!P!Lt )!.\0 XIO I XIO . XIO XIO XIO XIO XI~ 10 XlO i Xl(

1 DAILY XlOOO 1 XlOO XIO XIOOO -- ____ __.__ _____ .. - _l _____ -----·----------- -- . - ------------------. I XlO ow I X lOW I XIW

l 2s~~ ;o~a 1211. 312 eta. 14P~ 2380 3§~s 33aa 33aa 31SG 34~0 33sa 3i60 1s12 4~9 s~ ~a s 3 ~G24 27:8 1133 ,311 617. 139S 22r4 3163. 313G 3136 3142 31~8 3132 3148 1750 4 ~8 54 7~ 5 '; 27T0 7'3':4 J:::: 311 fil3 14i12 2354 33C8 33C4 3364 33&4 3415 3356 3372 1866 4120 4~ ~C 6 '> /2,71; :J(t,!, 1~'<2 312 014 14:.1\~ 2lll8 347G 3452 3444 34G8 35j8 3428 3420 191~ 4 "!l2 24 ~:n 6 G 2~7~ 304~ 1~35 312 Cl2 1400 24~0 3444 3416 3416 3432 3472 3400. 3415 19~8 4~~ 24 5C 6 7 288~ 3~50. 1221 312 GlG 1398 234G 335G 3332 3336 33GO. 3388 3332 3352 1898 4~2 24 3~ 6 c- 2370 3~.;1:G 1213 312 . El3 1308 2328 3332 33~8 3312 3332 336~ 33~8 3328 19C0 4 ~0 24 2J. G J 2£9C )~CI. 1204 312 Gl7 llfJ4 2280 3264 3236. 3240 3264 3296 3236 3256 1914 4 724 24 30 6

1r 29~6 3072 12d2 312 £17 1402 226213252 3220 322P 3212 3272 322~ 3236 1916 4~4 .24 10 s --· 11 2.9JZ., ..2JDQ l'G9 313 Gl8 1398 12268~2272 32rs 3240 :uza 3'CQ 3240 3260 1926 4 656 j0. 1~ 't'

12 292C ~34 1183 312 618 1398 2252 3244· 32 8 3212 3152 3264 3208 3228 1920 4»4 · 34 10 41 13 2384 3048 1182 '312 .613. 1396 . 2224 .3212- 3172. 3184 3972 -ID2-. 3180. 3196 .. 1912 ... ~~----30. - .. 'tl-- ll lt, 28~~ 3~5~ 1188 312 619 1388 2245 3243 3212 3212 3t:JS4 3272 3212 3228 1918 4 .]ttJ . 20 0 3 lS 2~~4 3JG8 1185 312 616 1388 223~ 3216 3188 3192 3e72 '324, 3188 32~8 192~ ~E4 . 4 0 3 lG 2 8 7G 3~l~ ~ 1180 312 606 . 1386 2204 318~ 3148 3148 3Gtlrf 32Ca 3148 .. 316.8 _1912 fl. GilL _24.. ~ ...3. 17. 2CGC 3024 1182 312 6~6 1384 22~8 3184 3152. 3156 3~56 32~8 3156 3172 19U . fl~l iJ ~ lo 2870 3C34 1178 312 613 1384 2195 3156 3124 3124 3116 3184 3124 3140 190S 3 U 24 . a 3 1r: 2873 30't2 1179 . 312 sea. 13sa .:2192. .. 3132.:.3112, 310& ... 315.11.~.3164 ~nt2 ... 312..8~ . .l9~ll--~~llil.~.U..:. ~ . ..1 20 287G 304j nso 312 612 1392 21ss 3132 3104 3104 : 3156 316~ · 31~8 3120 · 19i2 · 3$4 :'' .. 26 4 4: Ll 2876 3040 1183 312 .607 1390 2198 3148 3116 3116 . 3172 3172 3116' 3136 1912 4152. -~ 4 4 i2 ~8S2 305~ 11S5 312 GlO 1400 22~2 3152 . 3124 3124 3176 318~ 3124 3144· 1908 3$5- 34 4 4 ~- 2~~f :sc 1185 311 615 13Ga 2196 3144 311G 3116 3176 31G4 311G 3132 191~. 4l2 1~ ~ ~

!870 ;:,:, llS1 312 G09 1382 222!~ 313~ 3148 3152 32~8 32~8 3148 3164 1qlj 4 2)6 24 C 4 ·.~;;;? 2~,4 :..c7:; 748 1472 331~7~54361 7804 773G 7738 7714 78G8 7730 7771 \4564 g}3 62 lllf 11:

() -:-- ··~. .:"'.. c.... I~ /L. . • 1 ~ \,., r-..'-J -.....'-l V) .. . . \ ..,.. ... 'v ')' -.) ' ..... ........ . ;;.,...·

... . ~ • • "-Jt I , !"\) -,~ ,.,.'-"..; ~ ~ ~~ ~) ~ ~ ~~) .v ~ '\_) '1:) ~ 0) t''r) "r; )

'?>

. -~ -----r--- -,-- r .,. c·~w"-.:f~T--..---R:CT --·--··--- --·-r-('.A p kVARS Cu;m;NT AMmfS _ .. 6iA~ 23: 691 66-4 665 666 ...,

liME GAl I .. I IWN START . COM RUN 'TART EXC GI!N IUN STMT co."

I CONO ' . GfN !"'.:, "~ . Tlf . !"! STA Flti.O PH PH PH Tlf:

I 'fAII.JV C:&e\1 .. I • 1 ...... '

Page 57: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~ J! " - ..... ~~-=-u- 1. ·>r _j·- '..­- - \. L~ _"'-'<!.

J ;;;,!/<1· •. ...._.\:'

r~:,J.

luAil; \..--·--

.... . ;

1 ') ....

. '

1

- 1

TIME

-------·, -·- . ----- -- --- - ·--· ENERGY KWH COAL FLOW l&S ! ~TiA'i• ;-~'.J'r'v LbS

:.·., --~~11· 112 114 115 116 li7!118 175_l176 177 I 178 l!i I 2 3 I 4 l 6 I I·:-~ I .. • , Nt' 1 Mon M07l M07u M073 M074 [ M075 M079 I Mo7s M077 1 M076 tOTAL 1 eve ·eve. j eYe Mf\IN DP .v. 1. EXlP. ,. a·

- GU< II GROS:. RUN COM YARD SilO CAll .l\·253 l' A·253 P·145. J I'· !.45 COAl f lA IB I IC \ SHAM i AUX AIJ) l.H(C, I SHIV SERV COAL AREA HTG OUT IN OUT . IN i I I I . I "rl AM I ~ fEAJA ! ~

X100 j XIOO X10 X10 XI X0.1 XI (100 XlOO XIOO XlOO XIO _[ XlO XIO XIO X1000~Alli Xl_(!____j __

r XlOOO XlOO XIO Xl XIO X1000 XIOOO ! X100 XlO 000 XICN --~-- ----------

I

, I

7 v

-.. I)

) -) ,.

':· L ~ )

I ~~ ... !-

. I

7:,2 . -· ,, 4

" .'..)_.

':'Sl -~ '

) .) ._

r:.s ?Llt I "I\ 211 ?~

'-,., 'I >' ~

I· ·) , ·~ . ..l ' . 1

I ~ ~~ ~;

')[ r ·- I

2!f7 ~!: 7

3£. -:z:· ..' ·t

31 :' 1·

! •

)l .,~

3] - .... :·.;. 31 ~? )~

:s :~

32

....

,, .; ,, ,.·

,J

I

'.!

l ~-(\" '" \•

~; J7 :3.)

'.' j 1 '-'J.,.J

t .. 44 '5 ~ 7

.I ).<

,.

·' :•

,,

1;1 q

3c:; 3u3 .. :; :. 3 ;7 L. ')~-;

J

;)

u

-· ,J

" f1

550 Jlit

ss 3~1;

:n 3l

22S 1S7

Lii 1; ~

b3 lS~

l•'il l

,., ·\

., "'

')'j,-;

1 7 15

1 •- I

.L)·i

l57 Li 7

...... • .'J!

•1 ·7 L ,­lS .. 1 :}

l ') '· ' ., \ ..-.~. , ""· ..

• ,/·I j, '

2·r-J ~· l \~ = ~

' 'r ..L .I . _.. ~

I r I ~ .I • '

' I If ~ ~

. '' . r.r.

5 ··, I'--~ 52t: 303 4r.:- lv2S j U3 : 340 " 372 171 3J 1.11 ~/!; l:J'., , 1: ~. J 1 u ' 7 ~ 7 ·n 7 c ~~ 2 11 ~ J ,~ ~- j 2 · · 1 ~ 7 ~ ~ s :: 2 ~ 1 : s 4 n ~ 7 (J 3 2 u c 2

J 7 :,,_,c ll.-._. /2L: 3\:5 52'3 10::>4 .0 ~;~(; J ():)8 2'J2 3:i3 2~3 .. ,3,.1 ~: Flrl ·' l'''l ll''t 7"'2 27 1

.,-.., 47·· .. C34 " '""'"""29" ~·1 zrl , .. 4 ,_ 'I l, Ot 1- 4 L-:;)L. 0 ;; . .• J.)._'·'o )1 )y j ::.) , l..J\.1..•

-~~., __ _1~~'? .11f:7 __ 71.3 . 243 .ilL_ 34 0 GlS 873 ~-289 . _3~0 289 335 o~ 1:.;c ~f't ns~ 1rrs· 11.s 246.. 32 . l. .. 0 , -r-sw-~2S4~s- --·-zs7-ci3r;· - - ;~ ··1;

~C7 1J03 1176 719 279 328 619 0 1149 0 523 S 865 284 295 286 333 0 lCC :_u Li ;~ 11131 715 29!t 42~ ·· 893 0 , 1172 ~ . 402 8G8 zas 2-95 288 335 c 938 :~ U 1~ C3 11G5 710 246 · 30 :n _ 0 1195 j . lt77 ~- 857 281 295 281 321. ~ 916

·y l~C5 1147 70G 245 30 31 0 1157 0 475 0 839 277 286 276 311 0 912 ·\7 l~l7': llH 71G 243 n 31 0 1186 0 478 ~ 851 279 292 281 315 0 %\ ~C7 1~~ ~ 1171 720 211S 3C 31 0 12Ei ~ ttQO ~ ~61 283 291t 231~ S24 ) :,, :G7 lJCl · 114-:! 707 243 3fJ 31 --~v 127~ 0 503 ~ C42 275 1 .238 279 2j2 ;} 1,.\'

:.,.7 LJ?O: 1J 73 721 21~5 30 2G 0 13JC ~ 4511 0 857 281 293 2b3 J2€ .. 1~;::, : ~ 7 1.' ;.:. 11 n 122 - 211 233 szs ~ 1355 J 472 J 212. 285 2% :;21 22s o 1

7 1· -~ l1C5 717 3()2 4'):1 ~56 ~: 1373 1l ~~~7 C 857 282 :2~2 2S3 ~17 '\ 11 I 1. -~i lF? 715 ~89 390 7!;1 :; U57 J :,-3~ S!:il 22J 291 :.::L :;17 1 ~ L.·: 110~ c.r3 7115 -;;,; 31 ) 133:... v 454 .) v~7 2~c ?.77 zc.:t i-7.~ ·- 1

':·;·;r )r.-;'1 ;3" !2- 7"'-l r\ ")f'3·! ., lJ'n '~ 1..,-,.,o._ ';<'r: ·1··· ::_:If) 1-··_r; 1.-:·: ':'-'l~l •• :; J... .._ ~:> ~• .J '-- IJ .v, '41V ~:; •. J •••• J :;>,1 '"'' ~; ••

, 11 1\.., ' D-o ,.\~J AlfJ · ?':J 1

~)' ,. v ..1

., .

...

/{\· C{:,; U( 4

r . --M!SC flOW CAI'ACilY I

11 POWER K.W

. 1~ lW 100 REACT K.IJAAS CVR~Nl AMPE

I I I 14 5 18

lN l CF LIS GAL E

I sa fO COM>

DCI T AID NET TANK

19 1:21 122

fT ltVN COM RUN COM a04 SUMP

OVI ST A Si'RV

. · . : ' 11:100 :: 1 X~ .. STA SERV sav X100 XlOO

"•-"' . .(" . -. ~~. ·:'- ., ·~-·

96 GEN PH 1

?7 ·;e-START I IILN

PH 1 1 PH l

.. \,~, ._!.~~:~ ~

Page 58: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

J -:__:·.~.~-, I~)~---: .

,/

COAL FLO'I ·----- ---T-

lBS i ~:E.A.lf r~.-:.,.,•. ~Y. ···-- ··--t---

; I I •.: I !4 . I~: ! 11/ ·. · i I M:.;~} .',IOi, ! •,IC7J MOi.l

,>.: ·.:ROc'> RU;o.; I :...c·r-,~ ~ YA~D

""''I i7-.-1'i'Si-175. . 176 I 177 178 l 1!> 2T t M074 I '11075 I MOlY .'11078 MOll M076 I TOTAL CYC . SILO ! ::AR I A-253 A 253 J P·l45 '"' I IN

--304 _...; ___ 6·T··-·; I •

' . I eve eve 1 Y,A't' . ·~ ...... , , xrR 1

1B 1 1c , >TtAAt : o.ux ! A"'· . 1 I H.' , : Sf Rl' \ '.>ERV i COAL

•-- ---- ~ _•._!_~·_j '1_0U_ 1_~~~_j ___ ~;.Q.._. ___ f-~-~ ~~\,lY __ L... ___ i_ __ _:· ~·---- ____ x_!L-o __ __L_xw

P-145 I C.OAL I ARt A H TG OUT IN I OUi .. p9±tE_-- XlOO XlOO i XIOO • XIOO j XIU X10 ~

Xl XlO XlOOO I >'.1000 --. L I ! ,HAM I ':TU-N'· I

~1c:!_ ~ :.£. .. ~V~~-: . _.: 1 . J.. 'I!' ~-. X~~------~,'\ 1\J O?:O.t.... X :,,J

l J

I

·;

I'

I '"' •

~ ~ I :. -~- :;

~L:i ,.1 ...

·; '; I •·

'ii 5 '•

~· '- -,..,~

.. ~ 3 ~

I 1 ' -, ~' =I· 7 - ' ., 31 31

I

.L ... I

~-· \

' ,· j_ . '

-. 7:

l~:l 1 ,_ ;·:

' .. 1 1 I . . -'1

. .:. -

:::.) IL

... , I .._ ,

.. •. ··t

t7 , ... 7, .•

L 7,J ')'"Y'j -I .. :2 I, ) !, )(

s.:t. 1:2'; 713 ~~~ 5~4 112~

7,; .. 1

;::;·~ 11' 248

3l

r· ,J

" "'

,J

J337 13.7 l.!.;i 113 1 f.l 121C

1) tj\~

•' 127:> U72

') ,(

" ~

\_,

" ~

I

"

··n !.71 !•53 4!.;3 1~ 7 5 53o

I • " .., "' ' . .. .;

>' ,.J .-< J

;)

j .3[1

• f '~ .... ~. J

7;J3 7A ~5 '• ~ ,. '

,).)..,

.!.27 2t3

' ~· ,

~I I

2!, 7 ~ ~ 1 Ln. -, . ')

..:.~-

28 :: .J u.)l.. ~ C4S

7: ;} J ~)'] 222

~.-.

-'.-

...,..,

.:.. I --'

~ J'j ''I·'" ... • ; J - ' ~ ..._ ~ ..J

1 .,) L tJ :·_, 2·.J .j

) , .. ,, ... '

n

., .. '- ~-

..... > :, ~) .: ·''

',. f.- J

- -:; - -. ' J, ": _ ..

.. '.I .,

J'

J ' -

L:-.,, .... ~ 'f

·) . - ~) .. •I r-) . : '') ·.

("') ~ ,­.. \,-• l 11 73 7l 3 ! I, r: l1 .' ·n J 1171 \; 7 51 r; ? G 3 2 i

, , .... 11·· 711 ~·.-- 3'' 31 r~ ll'J' 7~G ·) ·'s' ~2s1 ""'4 z: 7 '"' I ... . ~ • I., . .... ., ) 0 iJ v .L • (.., ' ' ~· J v ·' ..... ) ,.J

~-- ~ .. -.1~; .. ···111Z' 713 271 2 t, 41~ ~ 1176 714 ;; SG4 232 29G 23C :,;:;

'- 7

7 7 'I I

' I

. 7 . r /

l)~- 1173 i23 3~1 474 837 0 1272 0 7GG d 855 281 292 z; 2 236 288

1 . 1 l ' ' l.,~l

l. ::s lL~ 11,') 11~7 1 t:·~

1; :4 1103 1171; 1173 ll .... v

n~~l

11 _;;1

11 .. _:3 :1. ll~~-:

• • ' J ~ 1 -~ ,. 1 1 ,

7::!J 71 .

• .J

718 7:1 727 7?? -~

721 723 7 'ln

/.. . 7:'1

7l :' ~ 7 l ' 4. "',.

247 52 ~3 ~~ 1149. 0 734 J 375 28~ 3~0 :~~~~ ·24 31 d 1013 . j: 702 -~ 373 2e7 2·s3 24t 2G 31 n 001 0 1:1 0 ~7J 28G 29G 32G G9~ 12G9 ~ SG7 0 650. 0 27~ 284 2lS 317 6~G 1188 0 1003 i. G36 j 872 .2~6 293 %7 54= 925 0·~ 940. 0 645 ~ 87) 290 2~9 24C 2G 29 ~ 9GO C 629 a ~7G 2~2 3)0 254 10G 1G2 0 1047 0 ~43 0 817 283 300 ')Qr" - '-~57

:' 1! ~­,-, f '

l!lC C91 1 1117 ~ 524 -~ 377 237 2n~ 132 21C : llf8 j 5G9 0 CGl 2SC 2J7 23 31 v 13~~ ~ 4CJ 37~ ~S7

~ ?7S7 ~ 14C7 \ 1 ;~z, S71;

\\ 1'\\j ,. AJ "Jry

~ ,'L, ·l·'"'r') _,,.....

~

: ~~ c \.'

~ -.. I~

~..,

l)

.;>.G:i> lo9 71 /0~ I DOD.

,.,'=",.. -u~

~~7 287 zsu 288 2j9 2~1 2-:•r u.

')!11 - .....

'j./~ 1 c'\'

,~

~ t 1 1oS7 1 B7~ _

2) .,_ o~-1 "'.' 23~ •0 31 33S ~42 8~2

3~2 ~47

:.~3

~; : .. 1 . 3 :·

1 )j I

~'

"' ' ,.,.

.) ·' ,. ..

0 .~

!

r<

,, ,, ,. A

,j

j

0 ~

_;

J' '' -,;.,

.~ i : ~ l ~~

' } , , •, I

i. • I'

j. J .;

1.J~f: r.o ,I ·V.J

("' C' :J _ _, r,..,.

.. ..!

:'4~ ,.-­J) ~

ss~

9S '~ nt"'' .,. .JV

1. I ,,

,.I ~;. ~

1 . ' ..

l. 7

-------·m··· --- T~A r iS

;:;)(., ~ -~ l

-; 81~ --\ ---~---·--- _ .. ______ ·-· -~:_~~ I (UIIRf~J.:__ .... ~\~(

B\7L ,,~~s· FlCW

r-- ···---' : i 14 5

I 1: i CF I LSS

r ; Sfl 1 FO I;(L) I .AIR I NET I I GAL

CONO TANK

~CITY

19 106 FT

CR04 G£N SUMP

Vtnt\

POWER KW REAl

1121 1 9t. 1 .97 : ~~

corA ' I GtN 1 sTART I PL~-< SERV Ph 1 I PH 1 I H i

XlOO I X.J Al l Xl

107 108 121

RUN COM RUN STA SRV STA

SERV SERV XIM X1QO XlOO

Page 59: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

:t.- ?':._J~?tf.::.'::::/_I_L_;;.:i_/ S ~ MERRIMACK STATION UNIT I & SUBSTATION

- - ----·-··- -- --. ---------- fMRGY--~;-- I COAl rww - lS~ [.

-;~,-r-1ii--:-- ,,~---T--i-,-5--~

'W J :.'.072 i MOll I M070 i q·---.. ,---·-,- I l

"f \~· ·~uv. u

I.J.

.H[ c •

i

Glh \ \,RO~S . RU•-J I COM I . I S[RV ~E~\1 I

,...::·~: l~-~--~.!.9- -~·~ J '1\.)(;i• I XIOO .. _ - -~- -------- .

. ' .__, 1 .,.

L ,

~ 1 - )

7 ·;. '-.

I • • .1.

-,1 / 71 .

' I

.~ , ~ _c;

21: tl 2l, ~ 21JII

I 117 · I I 8 I 175 ) M07.1 I MC75 ! Y-079

RD I SilO (AR A-253 •Al I AREA HTG OUT

.. 1 I J\0.1 Xl XlOO

XlO ·)t•

'-'

2) ..,. ~ ...

"'"

I XI

'1

31 ) ~~

31

XlO -·

·1 . , ,, ~·~ )J

;,

I:,t:C B::i!1 17_'1_

J..J.

1~5(

176 177 M078 f..\077

A-253 P·l45

IN . OUT'

XIOO XIOO XIOOO

r< _.) , . ,. -< )

0

47f t;72 :l ~1 -'iCl

178 M076 P-145

IN XIOO

. .J

·1

;l

IS

TOTAL

COAL

XlO

XlOOO

:1(2 :~(4

3GS 370

i---.--3 CYC I CYC

lA 1 ii!

XIO ..<10

231, ,. (" 7 ,.v .J

283 2::5

XlOO

..., '~ I! '- .... t

/:.~ '1 ; ~ (

- '" ,...,,,...

I

4

CYC

IC

XIO

--2;):; L•. v 'l r ~

.:.u ..1 .., ~. ~t..,"J

~ .. : ~ / . ~~ 2 ! : t, 7 : ~ 3 :. ~ 13 1 !J ; , r ~ 6 G 2 ~ .. ~ ~ J c 2: '• 1 1 I~ , ~ 2 r ~ 1 ~~ r: ~ ~ 4 1 ~ I, ) !~ ': \.~ f. 5 :0 3 2"' :- 2 3 G

I

Mt 1m

I I e r; 1 ,;p, ~.' ; EXTR

AM ! :·J-' AI,X

J •!' .·.··' ' qrAM Xil oc. I < .: x. 10

XlO --:-:-r··· ------ .. -·. ---~J '.•00 ..

\,• ·,, _

l- ,. u .) ' ..

.. r v ,, , .

)

c l I' 7 .

v -,:_...

- ' ....... J -

, , r 1 .:.. -

1 1 . ' - - ·' ...

ll ~·. . ' -" l)

I l ~ .. ·::" 3?C 7H :!.3~: r' 132S :J :J32 :~ o7'~ 22C 2~1 r;;. ·jf' ' . . I 1 1·· . ., . ' ., "2 1 - "· ·' - ~5 ·" ,. 5 r 11 .. c- " '<: ~ • ' 1 '· .. .. J

--: I I - • l . .:. • . : ) "' v >· ) :; 'j v •_;, - ;) 0 ' ) -" J - .; J ..... 0 :::>

' f • ~ .• , - r L ,. -I - - . • , 3 r. t i .., 3,.., r' ,, ,... r ? -.I .., - r. 'l.., -· ._;· /L· L .L ~; ) •. TE!'>t'· .L-i ..; J ·. ~ ,. "v,, _._:.; '- J~; .:..vl.

1 ; 1 n i:. n:· ~';= s2 31 31: 1~01; o :;23 ·1 s:::-:o L.n 2'!5 233 l' -~ l ~ 72 711 '2S7 1.S4 31 5!J2 g32 0 747 J SG0 282 2•)3 2E5 ; L.·; · :L·3 71:. 255 l4G 31 1174 :;71 C 73j ~ ·~G3 233 23:) 285

0)::'

·;3 1: ~31 7d

0.1,_,

~3)

I 1 ~ ~: 1, . '

~ .... ;::: c 1:-'?v ~21;/.j

I 'J} >; : 1 /''j 717 2!:2 2j8 30 11 <)4 903. ~- 734 0 8G5 223 ?'JS 287 331 ·; 1212 11-Jj ll:J~

l: 1" ! ; 171, 724 2Gl 17(; 48 2932" I ~93 0 6~0 0 867 283 'l07 287 S3'J lil~ 1174 715 247 2E 32 2382 · lJIG · ~ 671 J ~61 282 293 284 831

llll 111;. 715 24': 22 31 2378 958 o G73 · 1l · ... ss6 no 291 283 1;3'1 lll i, 1173 717 323 G~3 1312 238!1 931 ~ 649 0 864. !.-,22'~ 29£ 284 332

s '}

~j

';J

111 114r·

1122 i 1 1 :·1 117 •' 720 32J 64(i 128~ 1430 ___ 330. ~ : 593 . o. :' 857 ~ 282 {92 223 83~ ~.7 l;,u~ 1172 715 322 G9G 12':·'J 0 387 0 594 0 o59-~222 295· 282 £30 J .:'lG

. -·--7-f;, C1G 117.; 711; 23J 320 593 (. 061 5 SG9 0 BG4 2811 2S5 235 ~35 :IT'

'j'-;

f

:1t.~ T

7 1L,__ 11:~: 715 252 CJO 174 0 ~71 · 0 570 0 87~ 235 · )>) 285 33C ·· 1Et~ ·. i : ,·· 3 11 7G 721; 3JG 522 1C72 v Hl23 . 0 577 · r; 861 2,;3 L93 2~S :;3C , 1:

' - 1 ..., . J 1 ")I r 2,.. 3 r· r' 1 1 2 5 f". r - " rl "G r 2" r:; ·) '. ~ 2 - ,. - ~ -! l J I - '; 4- ; (. lJ •.J • •1

./ ;,.) J :J,;. ~ 0 f:.J 0 ..- ~ 1 ~\ I) l) lJ ) )

· 77 ;- 1 ::'l;:i n 31 ; 11::>'1 '1 !;% :i pr.3 20~ !'.''J :::s3 =-.. .' · '· · I ·; · · · ' :· 7 1 · ~ r · 1 ' ,. " .., ~ 0 r: 1 r • .. 3 ·i ( 2 '' 7 ? r: "' ; ' • · .. , :- ~ '· 1 7. " • l ~ ,.·,~ :J J ••C J • , .. l ·. o.) ,) I• l ...J l..h... IJJ U" \ . 'J•

~ 0 I ~ ~· . -) ., . '~ .... · -a-·

\) J '1"' .i{' ::f. \ J .)

) "")

-~;::c·i-~~~ ---l--, ' 1'1 i 5 t

(f- I LB$ !' &a 1 fO

/·!II I N£T

-T 'io.PACITY

I 1s I t9 '

fiAL I FT CONO Cll04 T..A~W' C.tt.U.D

. POWER r.w REACT KVAAS Cl

106 107 101 121 122 96 RUN COM RUN COM GEN

(U!l.l STA SfiV · STA sav PH I . ' .......... ,,~: ----···

.!

13 .~·. 12 !;C

~ ._• !f ~I

IIREI\il AMPERES

ST:~~ ,: R~~~ Tl PH I PH 1

Page 60: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

,I.''

...... ·-< •. ..;..: ~.·· >·:...;.· -~·- .:. · . !_·:

ENERGV KV.H 'I·--:---:~: ; --~ i4"TI --~~-----r );'6' r-,)7T- -,; ::

i I { ' .

. ~11 r-.t· M07t : MOll i r-~::,;c ' N'073 : M0/4 l r.•.r,,_ c:.. i G~05~ Rl.1N i CON I 'I'ARD ~ILO I :.•p

LHlC· I S~RV ! Sf.~V I COAL AREA I rlTC:.

, _____ _j i-"'-~~~J-~ X.!E_L_~- __ x_l_ xo~ _L_x __ ~-~~~L~ __ j___ ___ j __ _:~:~£•; ___ X~-- _ _] __ XlO XI __ l__~_l•) __ _

, I

- r 1 J 1 7 ~ ~-J 1 :: :_ I • • Z ~.~ J ~ 1

• "J 1 ' n } l ·;- ~- • { :· ?, :' 1.1 ~ ~ ) 7

. ' '

~ I ;

., .... . '~

.: J I I I ~ :.,· •") ~I ' '

:17/ ~,

·, " 1 . .1.-1

'1'" ,, [ ... ., "l.J

., ~ • • f,

i~~ 1 ~: 7' ~

.•.)

.l 7L

'1 7 . )

r, . .,

,,, " I .)

""\r ,I

) , . ~I,. ; ).J

"'~-

i ·~

r ~ . ' . ~ . , r r, r . v ..

1!'": J0 1.::~

7 1

- lYil:RR!t • ....-1"-,( S1' ...... ·l·l l. ----'--· : & ~1k 1

------------------r--·----------·--·--··-·---·- ·- r· , .:::oALFlOW •% ' ~:r.:.t•t.

-11·5-~· 176-T-171-~;- 1;.61·- ~T--2-T-·:··--r-~--!--0 ---'1-079 M078 ul-/.07 1 ! '/-07:, ' IOIAL i CYC. ~ ··yc : (Y( ; •.~A IN. : .~,.•.-.

J..-253 A-153 P-14:. ; P-i<l~ t COAt I iA I ol) ' I' ! ·-~lA..... .-• )

cur L tN out · 1 IN ; 1 ,

_!(100 XlOO X)_~ X~OO XIO XlO _j_ '-'-" .L _!~~ _ i! t•J~-l- ~-!' __ ______ !~00 XlOOO --~_::.· _______ .....:::_,~_ooo_L

121) lll:!i 1 1r~ l. .. ,_;

1 1 ~ ) ..... -~:.77-

~ "' "\I -J..v'

L:27 n~ ·:57

J

.)

I . • J

-.7.:. 7': I

·,

. ~ ... ~. L-v ··7 ~ .,

I ';- 7

. '/ 1

'' -

,:;_ l 7.

'3F ~ . .)

~...,·..)

~ l :? 12r ~· ~~.,

I .. F2 5tt 31 ~1:7 r< I

,,,,_ ' .. .) ., \, "" - ... -, .~

.) -,, . 7 :~') 126':- 75) ll1'i 3C )~ ., 1~11 713 -:.1·· 3' 1 ~ :~· .

.,. il' .. fl

. . - :.--·7-:F3--I27·~·:.--75{- 140 28 3 I' 93 GS;; 3L }11 ---~: l,.., :; .,

~

T 'f! (

-_,-7 ll...i' 12G4 75( llt3 52 31 ·. q3~ C r·34 t ~ 31·~ )•j) :~: J J7 lL:J 12H 1Sl1 11~2 26 4S . , ~ 951 · ~i C3~

C7 L'.15 •tul5 71~ 24J ·22 31 .-· 917 0 GU J J58 351

3i~7 292 2~1

317 3·~3 S31

~ J ,• , I

'.JL t

lJ~l 11[3 711 239 22 3~ 0 u22 ~ G71 27'j

. ~ !~.P37 11!h 7?2J 3!22 Ggfls l~g~3 j~ 7 1~s1 1179 719 325 734 1432 o __ ~ C 7 1105 llSo 721 241. 34 · 5S

1 11 ,; ~. nc;2 723 nc 2G 3~ l J .• ~ 1192 7Jl 3J3 !:i28 lJC'J . 1 ', ll.l 717 7!,-.., 2G 3·~

1. ~ .- '· J. • '1 n : ~; ·i

v , .....,, "" ~ J • ~ y:.l.

2~ ' 7 . 'I.) lt

.. , '. •.).

ij

;-;

-~

"'

"

367-_,gg 932·

(J 10 ~12

J7'j u:-;1 ,~2-.,~..,: :}

,,, ,. ·, .: '•.) I

,_ __ ' I

'iiSC rtOW --~-~TjS

H, i c~ 1 :~ E f sa 1 Fo

- -~- ------y-. - .,.----··------...----(A"A(IlY ' I I

1& 1 19 j 1 I (,;A~ i IT I

. COND ! CR04 ' ! . i - . -.. : "-Hllll ! .L .. I

o, IJ

·ii 973

J

~ J

f,f~' 7'Sv :

1 o\ 3j7z 761 0 3G3

-~ )7:>~ ~ ''1!. r· ' ' ''75 .. ,J! J ) 0 73~1 ,J ~7J

~ .. , .. ~ r,~

;.,.• ;; ,./ ,J :: (. .... -~"7! ' ~).)

, . I , ~.) •• J ·' I :lJ &

\) ~ ~ ~

22G 2S3

284 3G~

23C. ')I"'· - :J.:

2(J" I) "1.-1

- ·=··. ~~ ~ !)

t{ f

,, -~J1

~:::!J7 2£~

nr. 2\''i

~ ' • I• ) ~ .:

,., .. ~ / ' ',.

( '"":)

'\"

9"

· POWlR--Kvi .. ---r-­. ,06,-107-r -,;_.s- , --riiE,:--:1 ~-:.~-r·;-

·2·--·t-· ,,..7 -·' I I 'II !

RUN i (0""·

GfN l STA 1 ~fR¥

j . '•!-'.- i I RUN CC·M ' <.r;. '::>FR·/

sav j I .. l_ ,.,..,. XlM l

')"! ,,,..,. 231 ~~~-~

L )1.

23) 237

20C 2,] '.·

') -:·( j

i ~I t>"

~LJ

.-......,7 .)_..)

n,,,

'(, 3 i ,, 3~ ,.- .. ·- ..>:> : ,. 7

~' L :,

" ' '.

_,

'· ::..4

CLt' ~ ..... ' · ---:;;.,--r· '

I 1 C.E': Si .. ~: I ·'rl ~H I

I i I

...

1 J

~. ~~ ·~

T .. ~ ~

J. '

1 ~;-

, , .l.l..'

1~~ 1 '1 ~.

1 ' •

,_.,

,_ ···'"1

Xl ;.·.~

Page 61: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~.'' --,;·~··:-~ ~, i -r-r ?-...._) .. , '"R:..;Y ..... H · r ··-cOAL-::;; -- --Ll~~-- ···+-r --~,f"N , uw . ,

I ' r--,~7 ' --1,·; ···- ,-~--: 116" ., --:~7·-T-11&'-117'5T176rn ~76 ·-1:- 15 I 2 T-3--~ t-:1- ·::, f' " ·.c• ' '1/o.v.'~ , MOll I 'v\0/l' l MU71 I M07t j M075 l ':·:~~ 1 ,-~078 / MOll 1 '1\0!t• IOTAL [ CYC I CYC ! CYC ' MAl~ 1 r,D"'J fXH f

Jc. . ,.>C .. 1

~: .r-, t rc.:.\ ~ Yf,Ro SILO [ eM ! t>.-7~3 i A "!.3 i r 145 1 P-1•:5 cot.t • 'A l !B j IC I Sl(•\M 1 A1JA \ A''' ~rrn1 1 ·,f~.- 1 cOAL' t.R[A j HlG I CuT 1 11. · CtJT I IN j i : I 1 :rAMi )~tt>.V 1

--- _, , -~ ~u.::_,_ L~'.:':J __ .,__ ~~-L-~..!..Q .... _t, .. .!~-+=~ --+--~- ± YIOO I X1~_j_510~~·~q . ....;. _ _!~_~_j_..2.'..:l __ 1 . ..:.' ~j _!~009_ i .. ~IC'_j -~!l __ J _ c ·".ll'r __;_ !~!}'·' ___ __ l_ ____ ~I~C ____ j_.:_~? X~_,<JO XI~-- 1 Xl~j_- XIOO _____ !_~~~--~-- ----~:.9'_1------

i 7

;j{

' :'·7

• 1

• i

\1

'I

··-: 1 ~

1 · r I'

' I ~

i' 7 l

"7 . ") .

. J, ~ ""~ , I

- ·'.; )'

L ·•

) (

r.,-.)

'")

>r

r • .1

2) ... •• , •'I

) '2

~ 1 :;, ,., J ~

.. ' ~ ~

3 '·'..,

1, :., r

·' . -. , "r 'I-

1) ,, s :!. -: !"' 1 ~ .. ..:. } c.

l ~ ]r " ' ., . J •, I

J l h 1 '") ' -"'·. ·'· ...

.;

,1,· 'i!:, _;l .2 13~ .-ss ,J

-~ :~ . "717 ~,/ !;I: :':') : \)t".'"; C .. ~·- JlL~ __ __IL~-~~:1__ 34 2'"lt, \J ·~0~~ J

1 ., ~ 7 117: 71 tf 2l; 4 2 2 17 ~ ~j 1 J 0 2 J

1.~5 11/C 71[ 21i4 3~ 30 0 93.8 0 1 ·' ·:1, :117 72G 244 23 4G 0 sg1

: i.' 7 Ln 1110 ns 2112 30 32. • 0 700

( v

L;,;i; 1E7 724 241 ·2G 3J 0 51•8 p 1~:: 1174 716 29F 4CO ~~9 0 795

1 ; C)l 1173 7!3 315 F.3:1 132€: 0 802 . 7 1~)1 11;4 717 119 c~c 13ss ~ 767 :'\

v . · . ..,

7

1 ; = ,, 117 3 7 21 2 7 9 3 3 2 c 7 4 0 , --7 7 9 J · r; 1 117 3 7 H 2 4 E 5 4 7G 0 g !j r. !''~ ll7t. i'12 :?C:C,· !,1-C 1·:\~3 il :?23

1 1 (' .•

11 'il 715 71

1 • " ;

ift2

! '*-:: :· 2 :~

') r. ·- ' "''"; !.0

i ,}_)

3~ - (. ., ' ,...., r ~· J,. •

) _-j

''C7 1 ·""' r 1"'\ .I.\ 4. ••

""-:" :7 'J

i.l 11

" j; -j

0

9

f .....

_, . . . , ' :)·!~,

1 -~·

~)I·

:; 7"

]7, ',

~. i 1 ,, 1 ..

• I I

. 7. 7 ~;

·r. . 7 j

. 7. •' I

n

~, ", r

2'.v '\•',

"I •· •., I / 'j

) .~.

.:' _.

, ... , :·, 7

-:I-.. . I

, -, ( ' •• ' • ·" ! 'l ' ,,, 7 I . : - l, :. '\1 L J ) ' )

7 ~~ l .... ; ~ .j ..., L ~~ :~ ~ ~~: 1 ~:-r .. , ··rr '$:!' '.l"~ 2c' .u.. ~ 'J....,·· 4.-J• .'J

7-;;t. .~ ..~C3 205 2 JJ~ 73;:

r o~ '-'-'V

;.!

~ 59(.

0

621 -~

G33 5CG·

571 j ::G:J )) :;::;;

5ti I; . ,.,., • ~ _t ,·

1\

" ..

0

:'

:;cs z:;,s i:?l; 361) 235 293 0 :{f.0· 282

3:)3 279 293 J 3C~ 2Sl 852 2~;,)

~r,p 281 2%

29~-2~2 i57 221

35f: 279 zrt, :::;~ 2~·~ ")~1

' I ~~:.;f . r ,

- l

:~:-·7 1: ,.

-.)

1 . '' I''J

\<'1 .. 1 j ,-. 1"'1

. '/ .... •' ' 1

~·: I

1.) '·

~

~-I

"'',., '"

,..,,- 7

- ,I

.'\'

1

' ..

-I.. I~

,, .,

:~ i '/

J ~ ::t

.~ ii 1

l. I ,

) ..

.t ~. I

.i

1 , . ~ 7 ~: 7 ·,. ~ ,; ,) . - : l' ~{;lt ~31 ~j--~"J32

2s c nv 2Ui 23-j

293 285 2:31 2L4

294 2t.) 282

206 4 3 ')~ U.•

..... j )

""t I : ~:

83:1 62~

C:3~ 228

.... "'\­( .......... ·

l' , .. • ~ l ... ~

-:: ll ;)·

,)

82G J

(' ..... 0))J

,, i.

ri ;..

t.l r , J ...

04\.1 ~ . "

93~ r

.\1 ·""? _._ r .- ~~ . VJ•

1~3t-

1142 lH2 1131. 1 1 ' r .1. •

:. 71 ~

'"~ \~"'J "J .... - ... 1 • I

">·,

~--- ~~C-f~~T-=-==r·--c-- C~PACITY--

1-r--~------..--- ~--!'"~W£R- !_~lr·- ·--~'!~'-;~~~\~·:~~ ~----

, ' 14 5 I I 18 I 19 I I 106 I 107 I 108 I :2; I i~2 ' '· cc ! l~S GAL fT • II I RUN ~OM I 1:!\.!N ' COiot

< ~r, 1 fO COND cao.c GfN STA SfRY ' 'ilA I S£RV . 3Hl I Alii ! NET I TANK SUMP I I ~fRV I S(ilV

• ·--~-'--+--~lOC ! XlO I x'100 XO.I I XlOO l(IOO XlOO l I XlUC I X100

,--- - " ............ ..

L- -- _ _;y~~~~~: __ . 96 : 7/ ! I I

I r-,N , Sl.l'><f j i'H ; Pn 1

i I

Al.•?rl.i~ ·-.;~ ., Rl \ p~

' ~; I ;., I I \. : , I l L ___ .L _ ___l ____ _

Page 62: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

\ '···cc '.- - ·c C '·.1' ...,- '"--- ·-- c

_x:.,j ----v~· r L.:· l \ f ... --~ --~---- --- ---- ------ --- ---- ---------------------·---- ----------r·----- ------r----- ---- --

: ENtRGY KWH COAL 0 LOW LBS I ~: fEw.l ~t ·,'1',\

( v<, ~ -,,j~---il-2j-,l;·.,~-1-i5-T1i6--T-;-i7j--,\a! 17~;]6im 178--+--,5 I. z ! 3 -t~-"'1,--) 7---~ " i T ',' 'li I l\~1 I M072 I MOll 1,~070 I M071 '1107~ I 1/1075 M079 ' M078 . INJ77 M076 I IOIAL CYC I CYC CYC ~ MAIN I ';f' ·,1 ! '.>.JR

; i -.';EI. ' (;R05S I RUN ! COM I Y:\RO i ::OilO ! CAR A-253 I A·253 P-145 P-145 COAL lA l II! K II STEAM : - A(J)( ; ,:.:x I I CHE~• i I ' SERV 1 ocR\1 I COAl I AREA ' HoG OU1' L'N OUT IN I .. TEAM I ·,r(AN, I l ~ x100_ 1 x1o ~+~!_ x~_x1 x1oo x1oo x1oo. Xloo ·XIO x1o ~ xto 1 x1o ~~_l_x~ _L_ ll1_o __

I _?~IL~ L ___ _j ___ _:;.:_!.lOO ____ ! ____ Xi~-- I X10 r ~:.__j _ _x1o XIO:OO XJOOO XJOO XIO oeoL _____ ~ou __

J.l

;

t ' ' 1 r

.. ,

...

,-~. ---

11 ~.· r

. '-, I l ~

I

1 '- ~

L ., , 1 ., . .... 1

1} rl. 1 I, '7 1 J -' ·:

.;_, ~~'

71' r::

7l3

., . '

.. , ,.,

..:· . .:.

... ,,, ": -... /

.,.:

")'

"":-#'

31 J. .. · ~ 1 - ' ~ L :' !: 1 ; ... · ~. 1

'2" )

';'; ( 1 l :J L 1 ~ ~~ • • I 1 r: ~- ~; J f • ~ ., f)

.: 7 1 . ~ J 1 1 - 7 · 2 53 1 r l ) 1·

7 l J >' ; ' : c 7 ; 8 31 '~ 7.1 _) 1177 .. I 1 .. / :1.1 ~~~~, 37:. n·; 1111

1 ~ ·~ 2 } F 4 7: :_ 2 :-: ~ 21 I~ 31

3!

:: J

•) -c.

1 1 '" .J,. ..... J

~ 1 Jr< , ' .;.. ,., .

1 ""!'" ~ ' ) j

l'/53 1 "- ':' "'"' ~

1 r·'.., ..JI

.1

:; llJl '135

~ !,~·;

·<

d ,;

'j \ .• ' - w ... , • -

)!')' ' ...... . .......... ; ..

_ ·· 3ii 1t )

:;]!, (' ..,..,· 3 7 ;; 3 l'' '

' 1,1 J, \

) 1!12 I

.~'5.i1 ,,

!:75 ...

c• ;, :; '' .- , .' -1

~·) 2 ... ,,..1 ) . ""r-p, ' ',} )

:51 ~: ')

~- 5 '\ '\

_._:I

~51 ~~1 L,;·,

,~

,:. . ~ .; "~ ·,

I ''

ns ~4D

27 j , "','

:_:;] ') r .

. '

I") 7•,

•· I

' ' ' '

·'1 - ...

2' )

~,·"'.., ·"l ~ ,

a:.' J

I .. -

.. ,,

il . '

~ .. ~ . ' ~ -~ :_i ~' 7 ~

,.-· L<,V

""..., <, 4:0~

~:i4

'l' ...

"I

,,

1 ~.

J .. ' ..

} ~

lli ' , "')"1 11'/'' ]··r. r·-z "1'' (2 ' "'_-'.. 1-'.,:; -----· .:. II:.J __ LLt L "-- '- ,:J - ~. ~ ·-~ j ~ -- ... --- ---- -,; I-·~ " -- '

,.,7 Ld7 117.T~ tTit 2!4 51 o .~9 n 4rt o 352 2n i§r 2~.} . (·t'; ~ tr4J ~r7 1~03 1175 714 29Q 508 671 0 661 0 ~34 0 853 28~ 292 281 83J 0 ll ~r7 10~2 1175 /21 337 8C4 1328 -~ 812 ~ 435 0 855 280 290 285 33j 0 10G4

.. G7 ll~J 1lo2 715 3Pl: 5JG 1058 J 779 G 442 0 851t . 279 292 ~83 ~31 0 1 n "7 ll:iJ 11:;3.. 719 243 32 48 0 7~3 j 45() ~ 343 277 283 273 tj ~5 ~ 7 1(99 llHl 712 245 26 30 0 847 0 499 0 350 280 290 28~ J3: .~1,7 l't.l~;:: llb\i 713 242 2C 3j 0 379. ~ 516 ~ · · 645 276 28S 281 ::-F;

.:: c 7 1~~;:; 1181 715 2'::1 2G 31-- :! 9'4 ~ 4'10 ~ 31~2 277 237 27o :r/ 11 J j 11S3 721 24LI 2S ~~ ~' 744 C lt5d 0 348 277 29'3 221 ~3(;

·\

"' -l j

~3~

~

... ,/ 11 :n 11.33 71C - 247 7S B7 j 227 v 1;78 J t;l;o Z7J 2SJ 279 (I J)

1 .'/ l1 ~:, 7V 314 ~j(J 13'~~ ~· :)70 0 • 4:-:7 J 1;3 . 2n 'h ,_, 2 I''; ] . ' ll; 1 717 ? :; 3 11:: 3";.:

7 ~ ~:;;- 117::> 7ii•, 2~~~ n ·n ,i~ :71~ -3~ ~lq 7°1 . ~ '

-~ 1~rc

::~5

-1 v

[)

1129 ;. 1:\117

115!~ ;i

~ 1117

;t.c

J I /; ~1}~

(}.,_~ \;;.

?77 k43

-.jr,~

(":) ~

"l I\)

r; 'J .:)

275 1.. ; ~:

~

~ )

~ ' . . ' " .... 2:. '.

~ ~: l 0 .....

~ "'·'\

. )l .;. '3!''

2. ,; ,. '""'-, ._, ('

"'

S7 :r~c

(• .....

·-

1

,., J.

-- -l CAPACiTY ----···---

~ MISC rLCW REACT KVARS -- -~---c-:uR"~Nr-· --A"-1'1

: 5 ll 14 I

l LBS FO I IYFT

TN , CF

E l sa ~~~ T i .diD

18 ! 19 l CAl I FT

~ CONO Cll04 I T•Nr' <:.!!Mil I

108

COM

SflV

121 122

RUN COM STA 1 SfiW

SEQV

196- 1 97--r-l ~

I GfN j' STARr , RLN

PH I I PH 1 ! PH I

Page 63: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

)\It .....__ -;7-/F- -it ~~L9 :7s MERRII\'\ASK ST,6.T!ON UNH I &~UBSTAI:Ur>~ li

ENEP.GY "WH COAL fLO'•v LSS ~TEAMt.~-" l~ r ····--·-- ·-·--·· - --......... -- ..• • - -- -....-------;-- - --·-·----.... ····----~ --

s .:J i I · 3 ----1118 --,---- t 1'-n 15 I

--176 178 2 :J ' I : l 11 t l ·~ i I i4 1! 5 f 116 i

T ,,., • I Ntl . M0:2 ~ NC71 M070 I M07'J I : ,1· - ... i 'OEN l ;..l<()~.~ : RUN I -.O~Y\ YARD '!

~---- ---------

1r MAIN !' lJRUY ! EX1 R

STEAN. AUX I AUX

I i7 i 18 j 175 M078

1 {1074 I M07':> M079 M077 M076 lOlAL CYC CYC ()

SilO i CAR A·253 A·253 P·l-45 P-145 COAL lA IB IC • IH-(, I , I SERV SER'I COAL

f----~ _· ~ -~~~ j __ y_:_09 __ ~ -~10 _j___XJO -~--* 0 o.: ~ Y ' I I I''~'' , ; ~ ' 00 X 1 0 •---- t --- .L .. - -~·+ j-- -- .-ft<.-r. ___ , .........,__ ·11tr -- -

,, , ... v .· -~I L .•

i "-1 r" '.\ ~· <,TEA!.',

X100<i I ''" _, ~ 2 0 .. -, i )( I 0 000 .j.... - _:Y:__l_OIJ ~

c, , : I .• I ·

~REA HTG CUi IN OUT· IN XO.l X1 XlOO XlOO XlOO XIOO XlO XlO X10 XIO -

Xl XIO X\000 XIOOO . XIO - \J ;; -:ti-s-!--~ 7 :>u I I L. r ~1!; 0

·v

. lJ

1 ' . )

·, ·'

/ l ..1 .} .1 i -) ' i~ 1,... ) :I .) ,) ~.)

I

~ I (" -,

I

. •I -I

- "1 .• I

l ~ ' • ~ -, l'~) •i:,)

ll .. 1 1 7 I L )

~-.o 1;,:,~ 11C.3 7~G t ~: r ·_\ "• .... •tJ

1 ' 'I 'l =· .~ ~

245 l,

-;;1 31

72.

l'.l77 . 'J

) 1Ji:5 3<3 ~ 1021

~ 1 l.J:? ;; ? 3::, J 2 j : ~: {~ ~ 2

r< ,, J3'/ .~3 3 ,. :: )!t

335

i..l.)

;_ J"j

::'?0 :72

274

') ,, -.... ~...u ,~~

-0 .::·

7_71

.: ' -+

J.dL~

1 ··:_y ~; '- ·-u 3·;5 5:~2 ll:JC :·: L.lC ~·47 27J '2:',7 i ' .. 7 , l 7 ~ ::- r: 1 <;· 11 r n "\ lri 7..., rl -:> ~ 7 . ? 7 t: . ; <: r - • I ) 1 ... J 1-i J :J '-' \. _, ..., ~~ U ,., (J) J - ...., :J c..~ .. J

. ' 't"'7 ')1. 7 '!.' -· )...... fi 1 :('9 r; ''4" ,"? 27'' 2-: .... ~ ._ ' ' ' L .. ~ Lf J - () l. ).J ).) :J v D v .. ') J u u

.:h :n

~ ,· !,

n.:, 27~

;·; ... -~,L

?ll 2.:;1

., -~ !

.J ... ~t ,. ..., L ... ,

·1" ':. ') ...

0 L•~ ...... v)l

~ ~~? .~

I J .} ~}

lJ7: 721 24't 22 51 0 1C71 351 ~ 28j :!00 281 S3:! f :!"'.,. -1Y·)---··r'~"'l-_..,':!-~2·r-?-J. ~ ~n 0..-54 -?·~K zn? 2-,:? 33"j

J_..J ,_._ ..... 4-rr ~· .. J> l.~'J.l .., ... v~ J.... ....,~_

,.

lL~

J ·'

l~

- 1 .!.J

1 • J. )._,_

} . q ~ 1 . \ ') ~' . .l.i I'

vCl 1 )l.J4 1177' 721 312 5C~ 13.!6 0 1129 0 ~53 28\J 2C)l 282 83U

~ ll~ -~~ 1;1:;;.

(: 1;

- 7 7

. , I

:.-; : I

~ G'i !.)',;- 1! 7C) 722 243. 32 64. I 0 1136 c 85G 4.£1 2S3 232 23~ 1 '-~i 11-:1 7'2·"- z:;s . . :.s 30 o 121~ 0 ass 281 2n2 U:? 333 ~

1. ;i u,.J 722 2t13 28 :n c1 1287 ~ ~-- ass .. 281 293 281 33G 11 .. : 11 :3- ; 23 21: ~ n 31 c 1255 0 353 279 291 233 d3C

;' ~7 ,, r7

v I

1 ...

,;, j '

lo .1C

Cl2 :.)

;_;;t7

,, ·J]

i ,,. ..._.._I

..,, .. J

esc G!•

~ .,

-:

0 ·'

-~ :. 1

:1

C3~j 242 2G G2 527 2f'

0 EH 2G

3~ 30

25 {j~11 274 G32

c GI•;J 582 1351

SG~ 34 r:~')

:1 -·: , .. :::

- r.: #f

) " :

3:' } ') 1

G0

~ 0

c n

j 0

0

1~84 ~ 633 258 958 0 48 24 . ~f)g 0 ~ 0

932 953

(i 1(13 1J7C

1): ( n ;_ :1 .) -

~ tj

:1 ~ 0

J ' 15~!7 I -)

1\ rf'

~

.(

!J

0 o·

49'J

I

,; >-·

~_)

~< 8

,.~

0

~·1 0 ')

."1\. r

'!

0

253 ')!) -v

d

-< v j

-< ' ,.

0

117 ·1

-;

-, )'

l~j

llJ ~ ) 1 i, :~1.;

,:) \ ·}

')) ~J

; ...

!1T~

43

:"i w

.1 •J

.~

"

~

0 rQ'J • .i ~ -..I

0 C'(

'"~')

51~

"c·· _) 1•

0 .;

-I

7-.J

7 I -·r I·'

--..

I-------,---·----------...-- ~- -~POWER r.w REACT r-..VAR~ --·~-----c0R'R~-N-t ___ AM~! l MISC FLOW i I ! 14

I Tl/y'.f I 1N f

(F

ss

5

l!IS

FO

CAPACITY

18 I l9 1- GAl FT

COND CR04

100 1 101 RUN

G£N I STA .~v

108

COM SfRV

12\

RUN STA

SEQV

COM CEN I' START ! f(!}N

122 I '.16 1 97 -~--qg-·

S~V · PH I PH 1 I PH 1

· l I

Page 64: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

~ r f' S 1"1/t ..... . .)

Date _

f.

' S"' I--I I r.; : 1

I liME l INT I ~ ~t-r-112 I :1 M072

N GRCX>S

I Xl DO X100 bd CHEer I

J.-L X 1000 ___ .1_

.J

i J

; I

.l I

. 7

,:c7

.,(,7

(. c 7 ..J.:,7

-::7 '"'·~ 7

. , ...... ,J I

, .... ,... ... ~~-10] !~ L33

.;,\.;l I \ ... ..., ~'> :> j

:,; r I

..

l~l.J

~ l~S7

,.J

D S7 1 ., .- .. _.)\.).;,

1 .;:: 1 u l 7

1105 lJ43

J It 7 ,,..,....._"' ..... !t..J

~.52 :iolt

...,

1ass 0

li53G ,, ).1

'i w

0 ~~

'~ lt7 17;~

SSJ SC7 '"'t ~ I

·n i

s t3 :s

))

'. ~

ENERGY 1;Wi1

114 115 116 117 118

M071 M070 M073 M074 M075

RUN COM YARD SILO CAR SERV SERV COAL AR1:A t;iTG XlO X!O XI X0.1 Xl

J

sr.

.. J

xioo X10

5G5 2C

X1

~ . ~~-

X10

'· J ~c~ 22 31 r< .. ( 5C~ 2:3 )t ·)

0 5G4 28 31 ~ 5G5 23 31 0 .~ \.)

0 Q 0 0

G (18 42[ 1920 ~ 4G4 454 10~7

291 4G3 1130 0 243 7S

245 170 31 186 38 31

0 47

a 0

0 ~ 1~4 ; 24 :n

c n

0 106 28 31 0 117 33 47 6 243 2G ~1

~ 377 26 3j 0 523 5~4 1272

0 54fL · 334 ·· 968 0 5111 26 30

4~3 1C5 23 27

J 0 0

r. (~ 1

!;~2 ::; -~ ,J fll G14 lG~ 24~ 5€i2

~ ... 13 l j..~ ~~ 721 :<.5 IS: 7 J ·' ll r;~- 734 2115 23

7 l ;,·; l}j',: 722 24 1+ /_[;

.J lj:.. _: 'i27 0:Jl 33~ 7~~.

1! ••r 31 31

'I ,.

PUBL!C SERVICE: CO. Of NEW HAMPSHIRf

MERRIMACK STATION UNIT I & SUBSTATION

r ' 175 176 i77 178 15

M079 M078 .\\077 M076 TOTAl·

A·253 A-253 P-145 P-145 COAl OUT IN OUT IN

XlOO XIOO XIOO XlOO XlO

COAL FlOW l8S 2 3

CYC CYC

lA IB . XlO X10

.j

CYC

IC

X10

..,.- -.- -w-- tss T- -- ST~JV. FlO :-8 II FD F

X CO AM I i.TE1

0 1 MAIN

5TEAM

G_~1 XlOOO XlOOO XlOO ~ X 0 XlOC

l'J112 ~L4 ':3~;

0 900

0

J

~55

0 1011

·' ,;

0

0 S93 735 0

779 0· 848 884 -' ~ . -8%

823 0

~ 0

320 0 792 .. 3

-4 734 0 7~6

~ 877 0 913

92G 0 (~ tJ3!J

(: 1 'l3~ ~ ] 1 )5 ~ 12G4 !147 r· ,,

3r2 3?J 26ij

' ~·

(J ") i:: 3 ~·1 ' ~· 'i oJ

!:i 0

332 1;52

:J

J

41J9 0 ~. 5~

478 0 487 0

.... 0- -492- . 493 ~

459 ' 441J . . ·fl 0 435 0 441

~ 525

c

J

}J

·. v J

~

r' ,_;

~J

,.. ~

0 ~

0 ... ~ ~

. ;... ~·-

~

0

0

2~ !} 142

9 . 125

0 rl ).)

0 0· 0 0

0

"' .;

0

,)

0 0

,) ,. 1,;

(i 0 ~ 0

0-. ~ J ~

r<

~

0

w :~ t1 ~

~) .. ')

0 0 c a

0 0 ~

0

lil

0

.J

J J

·' •j

0 ~j

< 'l.i

0 i}-

0 ¢

•J 0 ~I

0

~

r ,, 0 0

'· "'

(J

0 t c

~ 0

c j

(o

~

312

-, ~ .~ j

I L. ... _,., I I "'

77 ~ 1

JuL :J

~ L':. ..

j.!

732 732 0

7""' .., .... 7-." ( ....... U.2 0

"' ' ,, L·.

7 732

1 7 1 1

78 1:'

1 , ...

:;4 t< !J l; r

47: \j 51;!; j 153

·379 190 s

0 ,.z"-8 fl 142 125

153 53 23 7 G (~ ·. r ~ • J .:.

~~~3 0 0 l~i':r:) ~\ 491~ 214

(~ 13 ') Hi

317 15211 zl/1 . ;,~)

71 ~ 'l

)•

:t, !"'""";",.. ,, .l)I.J ··: v 83:>

t72 27~ 2~ ~~ 215 7',7

=~'~} ~1 ~ I:.IJl "' '·' La( ~ I

., .; lf4;.. ,/ 0 it0 27o 2< ::d 1''7'. \ .. { 38.q Jt..) ).J '--...1 1 ~' 1'." .~ 1 'I.· f

Jl\·~ ~~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~ :1 ~' ,j

~-. r){J 0 rJ 0 . /it8~'--, ) ' ~-·

t':' -~~--":J/ / -~· .I '11 -----. / / _, '1'1' · )-it.luo_~l .1. -8

·:. ) -'.

Li

I, : \ !,, ,.. I .. 'i'

·' ·' . ,... I : -'\_ .. _... /'

rf '-'': j...)

-----"')

:." I '· \ ··. \ ~ .. J

_, \ C.--~-ow-~-::---~,., flO~ 1 1 CAJ'~COY 1 1 1 , _ .. ,., r-~,""~ .. -

1 , CUlliN! "'-"'"~

' ! I I~ o; IR HI \06 I . 1Q1 I 10i 121 I 1:22 I 96 I 97 I 9S ~ RlcN 1 ~

Page 65: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

Ti'>'i.

~- ---i [__EAllY_j

;

~

, '

. .., r· r , ~ f'-t I ..._ / :j r::.. '~ l.._ ...., ._,) .,..J I

MERRIMACK STATION UNIT I & SUBSTATION

'"T ~~· -i._/li:~~~,f~~~· ,II ~~~{ ~~;,~1~, '~~~· ·~I;·;~, .( !i~·~ if~ -~fr ... -i~}: ~: i'o:~l',;,"'i ~, 1 ;:!: r~::· rE,, U<ELK I SERV ~fRV COAL AR(A HTC OU1 IN OUT IN I '>I<AM I SllM'.

~QO- ~1_00 _ _!_l_~-~J_O __ _2,1_ _____ ~2__1_ X1 ___ X)9Q X~100 XlOO X10 X10 XI~ XIO ~I?W_)_~ ___ _l -~1_2.._ ____ j_ ___ ~i?_i?_~---- XIOO _x1~j-~- XIO X1000 XIOOO XlOO ---~-~~[ ____ _)'~?() __

•r• .,.,.., ,, .. .., '7~- '~'? 7.'' ~· "'J?7J ~ll711 '· '"() ) '. ! ~ "' I ~'"'~ i. .... :.· . , .! \..,. . I ... ; ) ~· t ' ..... 1 " . ~- J l , ·, ) .

· 1 · · 4 .. 1 -r ·· -, ") ·"" • 7 ··-, '' t .. .., ~ 11 f, 1 ··· .- .-wl./ ~·1. lLi. ,,/ •. '+4 •-- ,·l ~ 1,_._)) J .,5., .. --. ..,._ ()JJ

) 1 I ' 1 ] . I "1 ") 7 • ! - r -1 i 11 '"1 ) ! ~ 7. j ' I ! I .I .! ') ., • I - I) 1.. v ) ,, ' ·,; IJ .v 'J

,- --- . . ,. -. ,....,. ''"'' ., .. . -,' r. . I •' .-. I .- .... / ,· ,., '"'~ ..... ,, ·"'1·""'!1 . ,·- .. ;; I 1 ,./11 llJv !_" L·l- 2..~ .)v : 114, ,.1 t;:>)._.... j; .;)7 Lvl ~J... L~J "JJ

.. 7 1.;7~ ll)' 7';.,! '21;7 'iv 7:... ,. 1172 ; c,.';'j ' i' '·3:~ ~~~2 ::~J2 2 '• ._,j:) - / · - .., - - · /"1 • , I ·- " 1 " ,.. -r """ r ""' "' ...., I • :; __ , L711 Jb7 ,::J 312 'JJ4 1311 J 122'J ..; ·o2\_- ·· ::,..~3 u:.; .!.:.-·~ ,.1 )·,

c:._ i L-n llS4 721 2:13 t;4G 1::-33 ,, 1238 S12 ~- 0)1! 2~.: l. 1z· .v.- J_

'2 r~ L ,., r·, ') ... :·lr_; ~' l) ~ 1 -· ..,~

221 2)) -: ·1 '- 1 -, •• t,.). - ) ..

.:.52 2d 2'; .: .:.1 ,, )

, . ")

j •. ) ...

·~~7 1 73 n:o:; n~ ?·:3 r~z2 o7~ ~ Ul2 '371• ;~ ss~ zr 213 2.·;1 ~35 ._.;I U73 1138 721 ::::~ 2'·: 31 0 lJl~l; ~ 8GI.1 232 296 ~o2 '::3) _.o 1· 1

-~Cl 1J7 ~ 11C2 729 253 lUG 31 ·0 lJS~, J zr', 2c5 t:9G 20~1 "3'~ :r7_ U7~ 11C2 .. · 725 254 114 31 ~ IJ67 j70~~C 2(),' 23G 33C · ~- 1~

• .-d ___ ~;:-]--r;;·i--flGF 120 -gj ·131! ~1 1 ~ ~91; 76-- 28} 21'i9-2§6 2% ;; j ::7 1 3) llG3 7'28 245 . 3j 32 . 0 1J59 275 2£7 ··3~~~ 288 S3G ,; 1;.i~

j )

1 ., • I

L

- 7 1 ~73 1F2 12"0 21;G . 31~ 1:7 . 0 91J2 873 22G 298 289 339 ) CJ:' -~ 7 ltHh.i 1163 723 245 32 31 f} 951; · · 874 28fi 301 287 81t2 -~ 1 ~,:

~C7 1JS2 llES 72G 245 2~ 31 0 888 ~ 372 287 298 2~7 S42 ~ =1 Ei~:J Tf7,, · 731 299 . 49~ n1s -- o ·932 j ' 2az- 2s9 3vl 2~: c,~2

C r 7 1 ~25 llG9 738 ,31!J 57'• 1353 ~ 1125 0 a'7G 2~- 2!?9 280 1.:12

-;

l " I

.:..~7 1~3S 1 lC!J 727 2-47 30 45 ;; llr.Jj ~ g·30 2Sl 2!)3 291 ::112 1 1-:·; .··7 ~JJ: llG" 72!~ 245 28 27 p 1135 0 37L 237- 2':9 28:.: Cl;l

~.' / 1 . 2.) rv l"lCG 725 2811 352 884 0 1\133 0 371 287 297 227 ;;~~·: ) l.J.

,I

:7 l .:3 11C7 73J 251 lrJ2 '?37 0 C''J3 ~ 37i"'. 2E3 29S 2:12. ,~:,: ,, L_,_ .. z llCG 72G 25\ 1)'; 213 ~ 11:-'3 J :374 2SG 2'Yl 2~:·.: .:';2 ll

:.,:.-: n.~~ 7n 2!,.3 n 31 ~ 13~.:: ~Gu ns :~·~f ?.3:i ,:;~ 113 ', '· '' ·2 -, · '' 1·11'" ~-? r: -:; 7 \: ..., •:" •' 1 r 1 r1 .'' / ') '· ~ ) r..., : Ill ' ;_ ·7 " · 1 •.. lv.• -.... ,_ _.._:,) . _ 1l·. ..; -·· .- ,, ~ ~•''-'0\ ,,, , • ,, _ .• ~·

0 I ~· V \. \:) I ' rv,·

,-j' ~:r- <) "0..' 1} '1)' ')

,\ ,\

- -_.)

_./ L.

REACl KVARS ---T -·------ ----.

CI!RRENT t:..N

106 101 121 122 I COM RUN COM I •r.au '!iTA :>fRV G?&l--,.'T-~

:~ J STARr : Rl.. li I 1 PH 1 I 1-'H

Page 66: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

'.;·-

·-- ,-

:I ; :, , -~ 'J '-4 ....

: ~ -.1 ••

~-(f;..~~~4~~,.~ -·. l~rr . . -~ t!-~ -· • .• "' .. lS ·~ v .

i ·-

'v:, r--- -- ,---- - -r-;-15

ENEl!GY ~WH

116 . 117 118

PUBLIC SERVICE CO. OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

MERRIMACK STATION UNIT I & SUBSTATION

175 176 177 . 178 15 2 3 4

~~~A¥1 ~·-ow LES

' i jiJ I \J2 I 1141 TiMt I !NT l NET I M072 M071

I I i G:JN GR05$ RUt-;

COAL fLOW - LBS =;=:r 170 M073 M074 M0 7 5 M079 IJ.I:>78 MQ77 M076 TOTAL CYC ((( CYC I N

1M YARD SILO CAR A·253 A·2.53 P·\45 P-145 COAL lA IB IC Sl

b - -r- -7 _T_s __ t '.Al~i l \)~liM I lX!R li

E.AM Jj;ux ! ~ux . Ci1ECK ~ERV

; __ ~~ J_~IOO ~o~'- J ___ x~j ! --~~l:.:':__j_ -- _L_---2:: (.;:)(.; --r I >; 10

w COAL A~A HTG OVT IN OUT IN 0 XI X0.1 XI X100 X100 X\00 XlOO X\0 XIO XIO XlO )\

X\0 XI XlO XIOOO XIOOO X\00 )( 11 s·!AM I 5TEA-"'

~~0- >: ID __ l_~O __ _j _m.:. ____ XIC•) __ _

l.J

------------------, . 7 L <: 1 : ' :. / _ :1 i 11 S 3 ·.1 3 2 :: 13 :) 6 0

"' : ~ 1 11 ·, 73.; 24:; n 31 .:! 1333 ,) _ .:. 1 1· ::: i :·, ~ '2 1.:. 7 3 .-.: ') 2 c' 17. Sl+ r ., ..,

" r:·: ,_: ~~7 31 31 J !24G -· I ...

-. J) :il:_. '/,~} 21i-1 I;C C3 ;i 1236 7 .1 11·s 731 )13 5o2 13~2 ~~ n1rG - ~~

;r

I,-..-(

4 •.• ~ ...

J

';7:i 473

:.II; '_, ) '.1

4G5 ~

0 ~ J

l

-o·~5 ~ ·:J

\J.l..

.~57 233 en ~ ... -

.. j I .j 7L ~ I I

. . ~ : .. -~ 72:. 3.:1 ld~ t, 1 J ~0 . ~ 13 4R ;~ '3 '73 2:::..;

.::. ~~:..

!.J i 2 ~1 :qz

/.J9 ')('!>' • v

,.,( ... ' •' •v

1 r~ n---, 723 3J3 L1n 1:1~8 o '1019 0 27d . 2':)7 i' l. ,./ 1171 720 251 56 119 ~ B.38- -· 876 ~ 29~4 2:

2r:7 ):·:.

n ,,,-

.. -'

_:·] :~ ~35

:sc 2~: !~

2"'·1 ?"I _..),

226

tl

.:.>.)

( 1;} ,, 'J ~d

~ 1 ·)It!

.~ ~ "';

v~·,

1 '·'"'-

,_·

1 --"-4..J..t

137_ , , -. l ') >·

1··: J ; 7 ~

1:,::~ 1 I ~ (

' ')

·.- 1 1 _: :1 ~r 7:.7 Z45 34 31: & 1~6 . 233 344 ·j 12~:3 -r--·;~,-····rr~"::: 72s 2s7 nF. . 215 p~· . •• " .. 89 .~:1+2 ..; 121c 7 1· .~:J 111~9 B5 25G ·116 · • 158 · 9· lti21'··-· ···+J- 5~4 29:1 8'•2 J lCeG

l- ~. . 1171 727 30i1 512 301 ~ 1027 - 0 518 3C~ 291 :;4s . U34 .: ; 1l :, lFS 731 251 5G . 127 2296 1079' 0 SOG 299 291 048 ) l;..;Ct; ·:. i -i.lli lli:.i...--'7"59 21~6 · 22 ( '· 32 23fiB -lli!3. · · •· 0 519 · -· 3~~ · 292 o43 iJ li:Jc\L

'· ry llll Ill'S 737 2G8 204· · 4S3 178i lt33 ~ S27 3~3 291 844 0 103E : 7 l"'JC 117t: 73d 31C 586 l4f~2 32 ll9~ 0 ~CJl 3~1 293 S42

.. ~! Jl 117,, 'iz5 2'n 376 949 u ·1179- .J ·s66. zgg nCJ bL.2 0 1:)1 :.

·i 1 ~ :1 727 25J 23 31 . o 12;19 o 573 2<J:J 2o3 : !i 2 .~

1'~~1[ f'; 11·~ 7'2"~ :r." 2G 27 ~ 12~0 0 u,2 j f:77 2S?

.1. •• :. • l: , 72:5 273 28j GGo 0 11S2 ;) -·.-----:-~L~-- 7:J 2Ct'J 1·}2 45t- J 1182 .~ >.

\ \

1 1, . ]:! 7 :2~:) 11 11 2•)1_ J 121+2 ' ' 1 1 ; '- 7 ., . ;; ', :.; Z [ ) 2 'J 13 G r;

! i I;:, ~ 3 .; :: L, 7j r_s 7 ... ,,, tl '2L57

391 D 279 2Z3 )JJ J" :>L5 2':2 ~ 5~5 ~ ":~

~! ~ 2 0 ~, 7 ~- 2~-! 12~1 o\

·'

\''1'•3 .. ~ ~

~

~ ~

. ·- ,,

~ ~-

1)

'

3 ~j: 3\J;) -.•. 1

,,~ .·

!{.~(;

!17

~ i\) ~ ~

! - -~~,~~c F-l~~ ·-J· "! .:"P~CITY __ j· j j j ___ P~W~~- "": ___ j ] R_E_~cr 1Kv:s j

COM

2("f'} v J

L j·t-i 2 :·: -. ~

),_ .: " ' / :J

. ) ; I l '\)

C'\ ~

."')

. : t, :.~

u'-1_ _ .. , .. .. : ~,.,

,.

\!

11 ~ !, 1 ~~ 1 : ... -~

1:

...;..... ___ -~~~~-A~ I ~a.. I START I ~~~

Page 67: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

:..____•

(' · =~ 1 • 1CPtJ • • _·,( lAt.JI

PUBLIC stRVlel: CO. b1= N~ HMJtPSHIRE

MERRIMACK STATtON UN!T I & SUBST/\TION

-- T--·- r·- ---- --- - ---1 51) h

T M( I INT I I ' CHECK 'I I I

i I I X IDA~i I L.-. -- _, _____ _l_

ENE-RGY KWH COAl ,i.OW UIS STW/. fLOW L&S --ll 112 I 14 115 11() 1 17 118 175 176 1n 17& 15 2 3 .c 6 7 8

El M072 M071 M070 M073 M07J. M075 w:rn r.\078 M077 M076 TOTAL CYC eve CYC MAIN DRUM £XTR f-[ . N GROSS RUN COM YARD SILO CAR A·253 ,6,·253 P-145 P-145 COAL lA II K STEAM AUX AUX I

SERV SERV COAL ARt: A HTG OLJT IN OUT IN STEAM STEAM s 100 XlOO X10. XIO XI X0.1 XI XIOO XIO~ XlOO XlOO XlO XlO XlO XlO XIOOO XlO XlO

X 1000 XIOO XlO XI XlO XlOOO XIOOO XlOO XIO 000 XIOO '

: '".7 1 . llC1 7 -~ •) 2L7 ,. 31 J 13g3 0 4G3 0 Ro4 290 3~3 291 83(i i 13:>) •• J I~ . . . ~' -'· ,;

an 1;17~ 110 731 21~(; 30 31 G 1379 ~ 475 0 876 288 30~ 288 836 0 14711 :. : I }.., .. 2 , 1 - ~ 7'25 21t{l 2S :s: ... 13C3 )

: ,, , ;1 ~33 2'J0 -~03 2go J3r: 'i ll.t2 _; J..' J -tu~ .,., ..,_ ...

1J7~ 11C2 .,._,,

250 3'j 31 j 1311 t~ 1179 ;; ~3ft 291 3.:1 292' b3C 11,;.)4 ' ~- j.l

r, 8£;7 1030 1163 721 247 42 Sl ~ 1321-· e 492 9 sas 291 3~2 . 292 836 !) 141 1~70 1F3 727 312 532 1293 0 1331 0 5jl.j. ·u 884 291 3~3 29~ ~38 ·~ 13~C I

~ 1 .. 7~ 11C2 720 304 436 1131 c 1163 ~ 5G\1 0 880 289 3JP 291 842 li 1514 '-' I

Sh7 1099 1183 728· ··29~·· -448··109> ... 0 1.071·- .. ·0- - ~11-·-- ..,.--~- &9~ --295---- 3f};- -··195- · ·Sfi~----- t1· -l-4-S2 .:; •: 7 1107 1189 731 252 44 332 100. 945 0 563 ~ 90"1 296 1v1 293 861 0 1536 JC7 1133 llS7 734 260 . ll4 322 29G4 923 a 521 0 ~3 Z99 3~7 297 857 0 1394

i 1 :~c7 1133 1187 727 265 l7'; .. -3u1·. 2~1ir. .. · 96s ______ 0- 5~7- -·- -! .. - §V)-· ·z-98-- · 3·ps · 297 ___ ssG 0 11

1.: st 1 U3c u90 J:sd 2s1 . I:5n . 22~4 1~1,1 o . 472 !l ··s¢~ . 29s ~J{) 199 ssr a ~fit B oG7 11113 1198 7-43 · 25t-~-- · ·98 · · 31· · 29Sil} ·1~13--- ··- 4- --.. 491-- ·· --e-----9~-· --J00 -.;.-.;~g._. ~g.. -·U2 :--0- 92 1<; ..!.57 111 g 12i'i2 744 252. 92 50 258 1145 ~ 507 0 913 3~0 311 3~2 8G6 0 86G 1~ ~~7 11~3 1137 733 300. 476 1D84 0 109~ 0 49~ B 89~ 296 304 294 854 ~ 856 1~, ~C7 103;:) 1173 727 31&-- 64kJ· 1476 0 1~3J -~- 5~4 0- 387. 2'91 302 -294 841 0 8 Li v i L~~. llh 731 27'J 32C 7~G 0 1103 ~ 52;) 0 904 297 309 298 81+3 0 b04

.. :·; 1~) s 117 I; 738 21+3 26 31 0 1124 0 571 0 907 299 303 299 842 u S2C .' 7 L1Cl 1171 72£ 243 26 32 f-1 11~5 0 597 0 900 298 3f)fi 296 842 1 G211 ' / ~ .. 1 1171; 7,:6 2114. 25 27 0 112G 1J 503 {) 397 296 3% 2S5 Sl1!.t v :Jl2

- l ~~~ 1,,~: ll~S 7'2:; z;.l') 2112 ')!1~ 0 1111 'J 5G5 :) 895 29C: 3\.l~ 294 C:43 ) ~:.:: 7 1 _·57 1171 727 23) )?_(. 771• .1 1F·7 d 3f.'1 0 90C 295 307 29C: .~112 \, :,,'

r1 L. ·: llh' 73;J 249 2r 32 ',; 12~S ·~ ';27 ~ 'J~1~ zc•3 3~C 2JS 0!11 ~I

, 1 -~~. nn n-- 247 zc 32 ; 1273 n r:n ~ · ('11 zJs 311 3,~1 ;):c ": -'3 2'21 !?!,~~ 0)3 4!;1 07C 1?.34 272,~ ~ 1153 ~ 215 7\JR 733 10J 2:-Bl

' . ~ '! .-rA1.0 ~D ' tl) · ?' l ~)

.. :,; :/I .. ~--~

/016", D

··r ---- :7.~~ I I . n.PA.CITY I I I l PQWitfl KW l I lfACT KV~ I .I ~~NT , ~'>'.PER~

Page 68: Further Assessment of the Effectiveness of an Oil Containment … · 2015-07-20 · S-1 (Figure 1, inset a). The boom skirt (that part of the boom extend ing below water level) was

l> ';.-.. ''~"- . 8 ... ,. -. r· r-< . l-- ·r:.-- . . t-4-- -MERRIMACK ST A ilON UNit 1 & SUBSTATION

"' \. .... ,, i \.)

---·-·--~~ -·--------- ----------- ... ~--

(i~ERGY VWH . COAl FLOW \.!IS I SHAH. 1 L0>'· l~S , -- 11 T. ,.~- !---;~:;---:--,,.,---,---,-,6-~-i-ill---~18- m 1 176 m ,,a 15 z 3 1 4 ~--;T-s-r-·

i·'·'£ :I'IT Nll II ·'1'07?. ! MOll I M07~0· ! '/',(1!3 Y-0/4 I M075 MOr:l M07B M077 M07b fOTAL CYC CYC I CYC ,, MAIN I :JR\"·Y. I EXT~ ! H.l

; -· ·- G!::r. ' GRO:O~ . I<UN I COM VAR(J SilO I CAll A-753 A-'253 P·145. P-145 COAl lA IB I IC ' STEAM I AUt I AU.<. : c 1 I d[u

1 : 1 SERV 1 ~EP.V COAl AREA HTC OLI'T !N OUT IN · , I '''-"'•' 1 ;,;~,v,<. : S'

f----j ;_!.lOO_~~(,O __ ..__~Q- -~Q Xl__ XO.l XI XIOO XIOO X100 XIOO XlO X10 .<1() XlO l XIOI.iC~ _ _!:I0 i }.''.1--L_.l

~-~Y_: ______ _j_ _ _.Y_t'20~----~----~00 __ _._ ~ Xl j _ XIO XIOOO XIOOO );tOO 1 XlO Oi)~j_-----~,<,1_~--

7 1

j n,,

t' l~ .I

ll :~

I

r .. ll.7

·'";1,•. ')'

. ; ' ') , ,-i~ ·_; 21,';

:1 / l .. ~ 7)) 2'.4 ._ ... 2[

31. 3/

3:: -, ) ,_ ,,

I

''•

-<: 1!_'11 1"'i") ..l-hJ-

P41 12;)7 ,..,

.. \_I

'1

'·"/ ll :J lL:~ 7)3 ~ \. Jl,l; 2Ci:~ ~j 12.GC~ .. ·.~ ll._ lLi 13~' ~1:-: 3!. lVil -' · I ll. ·' Ji :;, _ 7 L 'J :' [:.: l:.J j [t l; ~J

,,·7 U 1:. 1L7 7'23 257 134 300 ., 8 c,J lLJ) 137 73) 2!;!: 1•0

I. ( .. 7 1 1 ;·. lS ::, 7:3) 21l6 . ~4 30 lL .-;r,·i 11J4 rf1.;0 "~ 729 241 3G 31 .

---,-·:·;~ .. --.M "rr ·r?1;-rrfi\ -·ns 242 34 _n ~. 0·~~ 1~.;3 (1137_ Inc: 21~3 3s 31 ! .• ' I 1. J. \.J [ '-.) 1 ?J ) 7 31 2 4 G 4~ lj ~

r·7 11~7 ll'?IJ~ 72G 21t5 28 32

~

J

J

31

0

1231 11J2

-~ 11J3

~ j

. ~ 11C2. ~ 1013 364- 0 m

0 1043 ~ 0 0 avz

0 123~ 0

... ll

!•7r; l!01~

'· .~· ~ L-r\,o.

q

4SS

4[~;

47( 0

I

,)

5G7 ~ 591 ~. 554

436

~ 0

4S8 i1

{) ,,

c ·7 lJ'! L1 1177 72(; 254 13:' :!J0 ~L 122& ~ 521 ~ . I

'I

~;r; 7 lJo:J 1 Eo 713 309 57:1 1325 3r 7 1~7" llCC 71C 237 38C 913

7 1 · r 11 : 7:1 :r1s ~s 31 !1:: 72J 0 '3 ~~ 2!

I ~! - .' 7 ~ 2 2 ~· J ? r 31

f'(

'.J

·'?· ~'!..! 2': ':)1 ;J r:r,:·. 2:: 31

-} 31 , 7 •. .,.) r -· -· ...

,,.

~ 1139 :l 1031

11CJS · C 11/5 1J23 \~:J (

r·r ~ 5 ~

2)"3

'i tJ

~ 544 . ~ 572

575 .1 584 ·J 5 71 :.

j~J 'I J

.•• !)

1L'7

',)

~37

--··, - - · ,,,,c rl0~ -· - --~-----r· CAPACOTY -~ t--i- I..S I 5 .. r---- 1~19

n; ~ cr I tss l -~~~- ~!!. l-T POWEt KW

106 t 107 RUN

GEN I STA

108

COM SfRV

J

Jli ':·11 j

~lL J

1; •· I

.,.1 •I-'

2'·1:.~ JlC 3,1~

glJ

..... , ,, )~L.

31.1 3' r•

311 nc

.) I: 7, -, ~

3F -·., ),.· ...

~L'

S·.~ l '.

") I

. ' ., . v.J-i

)')]

~jS 2~8 :J~lr ., 2~3 , -;..~~ i

~ ~ ~ -I.J"•t

:;, :· ~! ;·

(' '· ... 904 20~ 3~~ 2]( 357 9~G 297 309 30J 858 ':1{ 0 . 902 295 30G 501 ~55 r' ..

\'l 9~1 296 307 2SJ 354 . 0 ~% 307 301 Z52 ~ 90G

8'

4~19~ . ~05 2~ t51 j 874 902 297 308 297 35C 0 SSG 901 298 307 29E 857 0 snJ

894 294 305 295 s~s r: 8~c 385 291 3.~4 29~ 8~:i 0 (~!~0

~ '833 29~ 300 .291 841 ~ 0 ~G 288 . 3J0 2,q3 Stll C 1

87!i :!72

.; c: l~ 'I r ·1 •t .. .)

~) •' '·

287 - 293 29C ?39 j 1~~: 2~G

22:: Ji': lf .,

.;

2JC 2cS ~:z.7 \! 1;.·:;•.: ~) ~ ;; 2 ~ :; ~ J 7 1 , ''I

17~ 115 -:-::., ~1 !-....... i ,J

;J lf. .)! .,

,

l b)\ I

r?

"~" :. ),

~

r;·:

~J lc ·, .: i:;

ax? ~'\ -~

\: ,.~)

~

~'

""\

=' -

----- 1------r-------------------IU:ACT KVAAS CURirENT 1' ..... \Ptl<

"'Tit-- 122 1'!:6--r7 1 98

RUN (QM l i GEN l STAf<T I R'vN SlA SHV j 1 PH 1 PH •\ · r:•:

rr-.A~~., •