35
Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with COILSIM1D Kevin M. Van Geem 1 Alexander J. Vervust 1 Ismaël Amghizar 1 Andrés E. Muñoz G. 2 Guy B. Marin 1 1 Laboratory for Chemical Technology, Ghent University - www.lct.UGent.be 2 AVGI www.avgi.be 2016 AIChE Spring Meeting 28 th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13 th , 2016

Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with COILSIM1D

Kevin M. Van Geem1

Alexander J. Vervust1

Ismaël Amghizar1

Andrés E. Muñoz G.2

Guy B. Marin1

1 Laboratory for Chemical Technology, Ghent University - www.lct.UGent.be2 AVGI – www.avgi.be

2016 AIChE Spring Meeting – 28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX,

April 13th, 2016

Page 2: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Change is inevitable

2

And it’s

usually for

the best!

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

1977 2016

Page 3: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

LCT’s steam cracking timeline

3

Pilot plant

starts operation

First simulations of

steam cracking

COILSIM1D’s GUI

implementation

First commercial

license sold

1974 1976 1978 2004 2015

First kinetics of

coke formation

2001 2006

Large expansion

of kinetic networkTLE model

2010

COILSIM3D,

continuous

expansion of

kinetic network,

Kinetic expansion;

Firebox and

convection models

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

2012 20162008

Implementation

of GCxGC

Pilot plant

revamped

Page 4: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

First there was a coil…

4

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Reactor Coil

Transfer Line ExchangerConvection section

Firebox

Long Flame Burners

Wall Burners

Page 5: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

… and now the entire plant

5

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Downstream

simulators

...

Upstream

simulators

Page 6: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Outline

• Introduction

• COILSIM1D: The Simulation Package

• New Features of COILSIM1D

• I/O files and Interfacing

• Conclusions

6

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 7: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Outline

• Introduction

• COILSIM1D: The Simulation Package

• New Features of COILSIM1D

• I/O files and Interfacing

• Conclusions

7

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 8: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Key elements of COILSIM

8

28th EPC, Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016

SIMCO

CRACKSIM

Furnace

Page 9: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

SIMCO: Feedstock Reconstruction

• A detailed model requires a

detailed molecular composition

9

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Gaseous feeds

Naphthas

Gas condensates

Kerosene

HVGO

VGO

Bulk properties /

Commercial indices

SIMCO

Molecular

feed composition

Detailed product

distribution

VOLATILITYPO

LARITY

nC12 nC13 nC14 nC15nC12

nC11

nC10

nC9

Biphenyl

Naphthalene

Validation by means of GCxGC

Page 10: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

SIMCO: Feedstock Reconstruction

Input given via the GUI

10

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Bulk properties :

• Average Molecular Weight

• Specific Density

• Elemental analysis

• PIONA

• Distillation data

• TBP

• ASTM D86

• ASTM D2887

Page 11: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Reactor definition

• Built-in library of commercial coil geometries

• ‘New coil Geometry’ tool:

• Dedicated correlations for enhanced heat transfer

of 3D geometries:

11

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

𝑵𝒖𝑫 = 0.242 𝑅𝑒𝐷0.645 𝑃𝑟0.4

𝑃

𝐷𝑒

−2.95 𝑅𝑒𝐷−0.23

𝐵

𝐷𝑒

0.0045 𝑅𝑒𝐷0.31

𝑇

𝑇𝑤

0.5

𝑵𝒖𝑫 = 4.11 𝑅𝑒𝐷0.326 𝑃𝑟0.4

𝑃

𝐷𝑒

−1.4 10−6 𝑅𝑒𝐷1.07

𝐷𝑖𝐷𝑒

Page 12: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Transfer Line Exchanger

• Various boundary conditions

• Dedicated condensation coke model

12

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 13: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Simulation Strategies

13

Profiles:

• Process gas temperature

• Tube wall temperature

• Heat flux to coil

Outlet conditions:

• Common severity indices

• Yield maximization

• Sensitivity analyses

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 14: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Simulation Strategies: Run length

14

Run length simulation:

• Dedicated radical coking modelso Catalytic regime can be included

• User-defined max TMT and/or max ΔP

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 15: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Outline

• Introduction

• COILSIM1D: The Simulation Package

• New Features of COILSIM1D

• I/O files and Interfacing

• Conclusions

15

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 16: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Kinetic Model for Steam Cracking

16

• Broadest kinetic model for steam crackingo 720+ molecules

o 43 radicals

o 300,000+ reactions

• Based on high level Ab initio data, and kinetics re-

fitted with experimental data (pilot and industrial)

Kinetic model 1D reactor model

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 17: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Kinetic Model for Steam Cracking

17

• Extended to include oxygenates

• Validated with an extensive data set

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 18: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Convection Section Model

1818

• Dedicated evaporation model

• Various configurations and tube materials supported

Geometry

Process streams

Flue gas side

Feed composition

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 19: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Convection Section Model

Illustrative case

19

• Liquid feed, SIMCO reconstructed

• 72 different components

• Different mixing points

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 20: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Convection Section Model

Demonstration case : Results

20

CIT : 580 °C

Bank name Duty pick up [MW]

Evaporator 7.28Economizer 5.95HTC 1 2.65HTC 2 2.53HPSS 1 2.48HPSS 2 2.78DSSH 2.89HTC3 3.53

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 21: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Firebox Simulation Model

• Flexible model:

– Geometry

– Fuel composition

– Various input conditions

– Burner arrangements

21

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 22: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Firebox, Reactor and TLE Simulation

• Illustrative Millisecond case:

Feed: 118.5 kg C3H8 / h

Dilution: 0.33 kg / kg

CIT: 630.5 °C

CIP: 2.35 bara

Fuel: 53.9 kg CH4 / h

22

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 23: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Simulated process parameters:

COT: 879 °CTLE outlet T: 446 °CFurnace efficiency: 43.2 %Bridge-wall temperature: 1138 °C

Firebox, Reactor and TLE Simulation

23

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 24: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Outline

• Introduction

• COILSIM1D: The Simulation Package

• New Features of COILSIM1D

• I/O files and Interfacing

• Conclusions

24

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 25: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

I/O files and interfacing

25

• Easy interaction with other software

• Human/machine readable I/O files:-Scripts for creation and result retrieval

of simulations.

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 26: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

I/O files and interfacing

Summary of main results displayed in GUI:

26

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 27: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

I/O files and interfacing

Plots for rapid result evaluation in GUI:

27

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 28: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

I/O files and interfacing

• Detailed result (output) files

• Easy to import in spread sheets

28

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 29: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

I/O files and interfacing

Batch simulations:- Manual (via GUI)

- Automated (via code scripts)

29

Clear overview of

performed simulations

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 30: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

I/O files and interfacing

Global plant optimization

Interface:– Translation of molecule names

– Extraction of process conditions

– Coordination of the interaction

30

Interface

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 31: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Example: C2H6 cracker case (incl. recycle) with Aspen Plus®

I/O files and interfacing

31

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Feed

100% C2H6

RecycleC2H6: 98.5 wt%

C2H4: 1.48 wt%

C3H6: 0.02 wt%

Inlet Effluent

H2: 6.00 wt%

CH4: 7.42 wt%

C2H2: 0.68 wt%

C2H6: 0.01 wt%

C2H4: 79.8 wt%

C3H6: 0.01 wt%

C4H6: 2.24 wt%

C6H6: 0.70 wt%

H2: 3.88 wt%

CH4: 4.80 wt%

C2H2: 0.44 wt%

C2H6: 34.8 wt%

C2H4: 52.2 wt%

C3H6: 0.50 wt%

C4H6: 1.45 wt%

C6H6: 0.46 wt%

Page 32: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

I/O files and interfacing

RTO• Demonstration case carried out at

demonstration unit in China

• Integration in an external package for

control of the unit

32

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 33: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Outline

• Introduction

• COILSIM1D: The Simulation Package

• New Features of COILSIM1D

• I/O files and Interfacing

• Conclusions

33

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 34: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Wrapping up

• COILSIM1D can now simulate entire

furnaces, all in one package, with one click

• Flexible, user-friendly and accurate

simulations

• Easy interaction with third-party software

34

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016

Page 35: Full Furnace Simulations and Optimization with …2016 AIChE Spring Meeting –28th Ethylene Producers’ Conference Houston, TX, April 13th, 2016 Change is inevitable 2 And it’s

Questions?

35

Ethylene Producers’ Conference, Houston-TX, Apr 13th 2016