View
227
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
1/22
HBJKKGMIGX VOXGD @Q TBG DVPC
EOP TBG JKKAJMHG JMD TBG PGIAOM
Tbg Copgj Ghomolah Amxtatwtg :06: E Xtpggt+ MY+ Xwatg 1:6 Yjxbamitom+ DH 06664
Tgkgvbomg "060! 454,:120 Ejhxalakg "060! 454,:129 Yg` Jddpgxx yyy-cgaj-opi
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
2/22
HOMTGMTX
Vpgejhg - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - u
Vjpt A> Xowtb Copgj jmd tbg W-X-,POC Jkkajmhg
Vw`kah Ovamaom j`owt POC,W-X- Pgkjtaomx
Kgg Mjg,qowmi- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - :
J Mgy W-X-,POC Jkkajmhg> J Mamg,Voamt Pghollgmdjtaom eop j Pgekghtaug jmd Ljtwpg Vjptmgpxbav
Vjpc Cwm,qowmi- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - :0
Vjpt AA> Gjxt Jxajm Pgiaomjkaxl> Louami Eopyjpd
Xowtb Copgj jmd Gjxt Jxajm Pgiaomjkaxl> Ybahb Vjtb Jbgjd?
Hbwmi Nam,qowmi- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 87
Vjpt AAA> Tbg Moptb Copgjm Mwhkgjp Axxwg
Gmailj oe tbg Moptb Copgjm Pgialg> @jhc to tbg Ewtwpg?
Cjtbpqm Ygjtbgpx`q - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 48
Epol tbg Xar,Vjptq Tjkcx to j Moptbgjxt Jxajm Xghwpatq Pgialg?
Hoovgpjtaug Tbpgjt Pgdwhtaom Xtpjtgiagx jmd Amxtatwtaomjk Dgugkovlgmt
Noxgvb P- Hgpjla - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 71
Moptb Copgjx Xtpjtgiah Amtgmtaomx
Jmdpgy P- Xho`gkk- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 92
Ugpaeagd Daxljmtkglgmt oe tbg DVPCx Mwhkgjp Ygjvomx Vpoipjl
Djuad Jk`paibt- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 15
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
3/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 71
EPOL TBG XAR,VJPTQ TJKCX TO J MOPTBGJXT JXAJM XGHWPATQ PGIALG?
HOOVGPJTAUG TBPGJT PGDWHTAOM XTPJTGIAGX JMD AMXTATWTAOMJK
DGUGKOVLGMT
`q Noxgvb P- Hgpjla
Amtpodwhtaom jmd @jhcipowmd
Omioami daeeahwktagx am tbg xar,vjptq tjkcx eop gkala,
mjtami Moptb Copgjm mwhkgjp vpoipjlx homtamwg to
dolamjtg tbg Moptbgjxt Jxajm xghwpatq jigmdj- Tbg
vw`kah dg`jtg ougp tbg jvvpovpajtg W-X- vokahq jmd
mgiotajtami xtpjtgiagx oeegpx xtjpc hboahgx- Om tbg omg
bjmd+ tbg @wxb jdlamaxtpjtaom jpiwgx eop homtamwami j
lwktakjtgpjk jvvpojhb eop `pamiami pgiaomjk vpgxxwpgx
to gjp+ gxvghajkkq gmhowpjiami Hbamgxg vokahq kgjdgp,
xbav- Tbg ovvoxataom+ gxvghajkkq jx uoahgd `q dglo,
hpjtah hjmdadjtgx am tbg 0664 W-X- vpgxadgmtajk gkgh,taom+ hjkkgd eop tbg pgxwlvtaom oe `akjtgpjk tjkcx `g,
tyggm tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx jmd Moptb Copgj- Tbg o`ngh,
taugx oe `otb xadgx am tbg dg`jtg eohwx om xalakjp o`,
nghtaugx+ amhkwdami gkalamjtami Moptb Copgjm mwhkgjp
ygjvomx jkomi yatb mwhkgjp ygjvomx jmd komi,pjmig
laxxakg dgugkovlgmt vpoipjlx- Iaugm tbg hwppgmt kjhc
oe vpoipgxx+ ax tbgpg j `gttgp jvvpojhb eop pgiaomjk op
lwktakjtgpjk mgiotajtaomx?
@akjtgpjkaxtx ljq voamt to tbg gjpkagp xwhhgxx oe tbg
Jipggd Epjlgyopc-: Hpatahx oe tbg Jipggd Epjlg,
yopc hjm voamt to tbg `pgjcdoym oe tbg epjlgyopcam 0666- Tbg Hkamtom lgloap hatgx tbg xwhhgxx oe tbg
epjlgyopc jx ygkk jx bax ejakgd jttglvtx to homtamwg
davkoljhq yatb Moptb Copgj to pgdwhg tgmxaomx jmd
vjug tbg yjq eop jddataomjk jplx homtpokx pgijpdami
komi,pjmig laxxakgx-0
Hgptjamkq+ iaugm hwppgmt mgyx+ tbg xtjkk am tbg xar,vjptq
tjkcx vpouadgx xolg vjwxg eop pgekghtami om jktgpmj,
taugx eop homtamwami jkomi tbg hwppgmt vjtb- Tbg vwp,
voxg oe tbax vjvgp ax to grjlamg tbg voxxa`akatagx eop
alvpouami tbg hwppgmt jvvpojhb to Moptb Copgj wxami
j tbgopgtahjkkq ameoplgd lwktakjtgpjkaxt vgpxvghtaug-
Amxtatwtaomjk tbgopq vpouadgx jm jktgpmjtaug vjtb to hom,
xadgp eop jddpgxxami tbg hwppgmt howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom
vokahq hbjkkgmigx am Moptbgjxt Jxaj- Am jddataom to jm
amxtatwtaomjk tbgopgtahjk vgpxvghtaug+ tbgpg ax j vpjhtahjk
grjlvkg oe j howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom xwhhgxx eop holvjpa,
xom yatb tbg Jipggd Epjlgyopcx hogphaug davkoljhqjvvpojhb-
Omg yadgkq pghoima~gd howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom xwhhgxx
ax epol tbg Hkamtom,gpj grvgpagmhg am tbg Mwmm,Kwijp
Hoovgpjtaug Tbpgjt Pgdwhtaom "HTP! vpoipjlx yatb
Pwxxaj jmd tbg eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx- @jkjmhgd pg,
uagyx oe Mwmm,Kwijp vpoipjlx motg tbjt+ jetgp j dg,
hjdg+ tbgap vponghtx bjug ijamgd tbg camd oe vokatahjk+
`wpgjwhpjtah+ jmd `wdigtjpq xwvvopt tbjt bjx jkk `wt
amxtatwtaomjka~gd tbgl-8 Eop xwvvoptgpx oe tbg Mwmm,
Kwijp jvvpojhb+ tbg zwgxtaom ax boy to gmbjmhg tbgxg
vpoipjlx to ijam jddataomjk `gmgeatx `gqomd tbg gjpkq vponghtx eop homxokadjtami jmd homtpokkami Xouagt
mwhkgjp ygjvomx am Pwxxajm tgppatopq- Ipjbjl Jkkaxom
jmd otbgpx hjkk eop grtgmdami Mwmm,Kwijp,tqvg vponghtx
to tboxg tbjt daxljmtkg jddataomjk mwhkgjp ygjvomx+
homtpok eaxxakg ljtgpajkx+ jmd dgmq tgppopaxtx jhhgxx to
mwhkgjp ygjvomx jmd tghbmokoiq-4
:- Tbg xghpgtjpq oe dgegmxg am :111+ Yakkajl Vgppq+ hjkkgd tbg Moptb Copgjm hpaxax tbg loxt xgpaowx hpaxax am tbg eapxt Hkamtomjdlamaxtpjtaom- Bax eapxtbjmd vgpxvghtaug kgd to bax `gkage tbjt tbg pgjk votgmtajk eop yjp yjx vpgugmtgd `ghjwxg oe tbg Jipggd
Epjlgyopc mgiotajtaom- Vgppq+ am Jxbtom @- Hjptgp jmd Yakkajl N- Vgppq+Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg> J Mgy Xghwpatq Xtpjtgiq eop Jlgpahj
"Yjxbamitom+ D-H-> @poocamix Amxtatwtaom Vpgxx+ :111!+ :084+ ypatgx> Yg ygpg j`owt to iaug tbg vpgxadgmt j hboahg `gtyggm j
daxjxtpowx ovtaomjkkoyami Moptb Copgj to igt j mwhkgjp jpxgmjk - - - jmd jm wmvjkjtj`kg ovtaom+ `kohcami tbax dgugkovlgmt+ `wttbgpg`q paxcami j dgxtpwhtaug mom,mwhkgjp yjp-
0- @akk Hkamtom+Lq Kaeg "Mgy Qopc> Jkepgd J- Cmove+ 0664!-
8- Bgmpq D- Xocokxca jmd Tboljx Paaxjigp+ gdx-+ @gqomd Mwmm,Kwijp> Hwp`ami tbg Mgrt Yjug oe Ygjvomx Vpokaegpjtaom TbpgjtxEpol Pwxxaj "Hjpkaxkg+ Vj-> Xtpjtgiah Xtwdagx Amxtatwtg+ 0660!-
4- Ipjbjl T- Jkkaxom+Mwhkgjp Tgppopaxl> Tbg Wktaljtg Vpgugmtj`kg Hjtjxtpovbg "Mgy Qopc> Talgx @oocx+ 0664!-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
4/2256 TBG COPGJ GHOMOLAH AMXTATWTG
Tbax vjvgp grjlamgx tbg vokahq dgugkovlgmt jmd
alvkglgmtjtaom oe tbg Hkamtom,gpj Mwmm,Kwijp vpo,
ipjlx to vpouadg amxaibtx dpjym epol tbax voxataug
grjlvkg oe xwhhgxx am howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq- Tbg
amxtatwtaomjkaxt jvvpojhb vpouadgx j epjlgyopc eop
tbamcami j`owt j pgiaomjk xghwpatq pgialg tbjt iogx
`gqomd tbg hwppgmt xar,vjptq epjlgyopc am MoptbgjxtJxaj- Amxtatwtaomjkaxt tbgopq jkxo vpouadgx xhbokjpkq
amxaibtx eop daxhwxxami tbg Mwmm,Kwijp epjlgyopc
to kamc amtgpmjtaomjk pgkjtaomx tbgopq yatb tbg vpjhtahjk
kgxxomx dpjym epol j xwhhgxxewk howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom
vokahq hjxg- Jmotbgp amxaibt tbax hjxg oeegpx ax am hom,
tpjxtami holvgtataug xtpjtgiagx+7 xwhb jx jddpgxxgd am
hogphaug davkoljhq tbgopq+ yatb j hoovgpjtaug xtpjtg,
iah jvvpojhb+ jx xwiigxtgd am amxtatwtaomjk tbgopq-5
Omg ovtaom eop hwppgmt howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom
vokahqljcami pgijpdami Moptb Copgj+ tbgm+ ax to kg,
ugpjig omioami axxwgx jmd homhgpmx+ tbg xar,vjptqtjkcx+ jmd tbg gvaxodah hpaxax jtloxvbgpg ybakg `wakd,
ami jm amxtatwtaomjk jvvpojhb eop j Moptbgjxt Jxajm
xghwpatq pgialg- Kgviokd jmd Mamhah jddpgxx tbg tbgopq
jmd baxtopq oe amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomjkaxl jmd tbg
tbgopgtahjk cmoykgdig+ jmd tbg vpjhtahjk grvgpagmhgx
tbgq pghowmt xwiigxt j pojd ljv eop vpohggdami yatb
amxtatwtaomjk dgugkovlgmt-9 Am `page+ tbgq vpovoxg j
vjttgpm oe xwhhgxx `jxgd om amtgpmjtaomjk pgkjtaomx
ewmhtaomjkaxt tbgopagx jx ygkk jx tbg pghgmt baxtopq oe
tbg Gwpovgjm Wmaom "GW! jmd tbg Moptb Jtkjmtah Tpgjtq
Opijma~jtaom "MJTO!-2 Am `page+ tbg ovtaom xwiigxtgd
bgpg ax tbg mwptwpami oe j xljkk ipowv oe kacg,lamdgd
xtjtgx jmd kgjdgpx oe tboxg xtjtgx "tbg xar vjptagx!+
eohwxgd jpowmd omg xvghaeah ewmhtaomjk jpgj
"howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom!+ to `wakd geeghtaug pwkgx+ opij,
ma~jtaomx+ jmd gmeophglgmt lghbjmaxlx eop dgugkov,
ami jm geeghtaug Moptbgjxt Jxajm xghwpatq pgialg-
Amxtatwtaomjkaxl jx j Hoovgpjtaug Xtpjtgiq
Jx daxhwxxgd am tbg vpguaowx xghtaom+ am tbg Moptb
Copgjm hjxg oe tbg Jipggd Epjlgyopc mgiotajtaomx+
tbg Hkamtom jdlamaxtpjtaom gmijigd am j tpjdataomjk+ dav,
koljtah jvvpojhb+ xtpgxxami vpamhavkgx jmd tghbmazwgx
xalakjp to tboxg dpjym epol tbg xhbokjpkq amtgpmjtaomjk
pgkjtaomx tbgopagx oe hogphaug davkoljhq- Tbg Moptb
Copgjm Jipggd Epjlgyopc hjxg ax pgvpgxgmtjtaug oe
tov,doym vokahq kgjdgpxbav- Vpgxadgmt Hkamtom+ Xgh,
pgtjpq oe Dgegmxg Yakkajl Vgppq+ Xghpgtjpq oe Xtjtg
Yjppgm Hbpaxtovbgp+ jmd otbgp baib,kgugk grghwtaug
`pjmhb xtjcgbokdgpx ygpg gmijigd am dgugkovami tbgjdlamaxtpjtaomx vokahq jmd ougpxggami tbg `akjtgpjk
W-X-, Moptb Copgjm mgiotajtaomx- Otbgp W-X- oeeahajkx
jmd jkkagd iougpmlgmtx ygpg homxwktgd+ amhkwdami tbg
W-X- Homipgxx jmd tbg iougpmlgmtx oe tbg Pgvw`kah
oe Copgj "POC+ op Xowtb Copgj! jmd Njvjm- Tbg alvkg,
lgmtjtaom oe tbg Jipggd Epjlgyopc amhkwdgd tbg xai,
maeahjmt amuokuglgmt oe tbg Wmatgd Mjtaomx "WM! yatb
tbg amuokuglgmt oe Amtgpmjtaomjk Jtolah Gmgpiq
Jigmhq "AJGJ!+ jx ygkk jx tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx+ gxvg,
hajkkq atx amtgkkaigmhg jigmhagx+ tbpowib tbgap jhtaug
lomatopami-
7- Eop dgtjakx oe j holvgtataug xtpjtgiagx jvvpojhb+ xgg Djuad N- Jmdpg+ JHolvgtataug Xtpjtgiagx> Jm Jvvpojhb jijamxt Vpokaegpj,taom+ amVpgujakami am j Ygkk Jplgd Yopkd> Dguaxami Holvgtataug Xtpjtgiagx Jijamxt Ygjvomx Vpokaegpjtaom+ gd- Bgmpq D- Xocokxca
"Hjpkaxkg+ Vj-> Xtpjtgiah Xtwdagx Amxtatwtg+ 0666!-
5- Eop tbg jwtbopx daxhwxxaom oe holvgtataug xtpjtgiq+ tbjt ax+ wxami tbg hogphaug davkoljhq katgpjtwpg to jmjkq~g tbg JipggdEpjlgyopc hjxg+ xgg Noxgvb P- Hgpjla jmd @gmnjlam H- @pqjm+ Grghwtaug Kgjdgpxbav jmd tbg Howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom Vokahq Amataj,taugTbg W-X-,Moptb Copgj Jipggd Epjlgyopc "vjvgp vpgxgmtgd jt tbg 0664 Amtgpmjtaomjk Xtwdagx Jxxohajtaom homegpgmhg+ Lomtpgjk!3
jm wvdjtgd ugpxaom oe tbg vjvgp ax @wxb Xhbook Yopcami Vjvgp mo- 4:6+ bttv>//`wxb-tjlw-gdw/homtgmt/pgxgjphb/yopcami_vjvgpx/nhgpjla/Hgpjla@pqjm-vde-
9- Noxgvb Kgviokd jmd Lapoxkju Mamhah+@gqomd tbg Auopq Toygp> Amtgpmjtaomjk Pgkjtaomx Tbgopq jmd tbg Axxwg oe Vokahq Pgkgujmhg
"Mgy Qopc> Hokwl`aj Wmaugpxatq Vpgxx+ 066:!-
2- Hbpaxtovbgp N- Bgllgp jmd Vgtgp Cjt~gmxtgam+ am Ybq Ax Tbgpg Mo MJTO am Jxaj? Hokkghtaug Adgmtatq+ Pgiaomjkaxl+ jmd tbg
Opaiamx oe Lwktakjtgpjkaxl+Amtgpmjtaomjk Opijma~jtaom75+ mo- 8 "Jwiwxt 0660!> 797569+ jkxo holvjpg daeegpgmhgx am W-X- Hokd Yjpjvvpojhbgx to xwhhgxxewk pgiaomjk jppjmiglgmtx am Gwpovg jmd tbg kjhc oe xalakjp jvvpojhbgx am Jxaj- Tbgap vjvgp ax xaimaeahjmt eop atxglvbjxax om tbg alvjht oe hwktwpjk jmd baxtopahjk daeegpgmhgx am homtpjxtami lwktakjtgpjk jvvpojhbgx eop tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx am Gwpovg
jmd `akjtgpjk jvvpojhbgx eop tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx am Jxaj-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
5/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 5:
J xghomd hjxg xtwdq grjlamami jktgpmjtaug jvvpojhbgx
ax xaimaeahjmt eop ijamami amxaibtx amto tbg homdataomx
eop dgugkovami geeghtaug mjtaomjk xghwpatq
howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahagx- Jx jpiwgd vpguaowxkq+ jx
xboym `q tbg baxtopq oe tbg vjxt dghjdg+ tbg Jipggd
Epjlgyopc hjxg xwiigxtx j ejakgd howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom
geeopt- Iaugm tbg kjhc oe amxtatwtaomjk jmd opijma~j,taomjk pootx+ tbg Jipggd Epjlgyopc ejakgd to jhbagug
kjxtami geeghtx am jhhopdjmhg yatb tbg W-X- o`nghtaug
oe gmdami tbg Moptbx mwhkgjp ygjvomx vpoipjl- Am
holvjpaxom+ tbgm+ ybq ax tbg Mwmm,Kwijp vokahq owt,
holg igmgpjkkq jipggd to `g lopg xwhhgxxewk tbjm
tbg Jipggd Epjlgyopc grvgpagmhg?
J lopg xwhhgxxewk hjxgomg kgd lopg dapghtkq `q
tbg xghpgtjpq oe dgegmxg jkomi yatb Dgvjptlgmt oe
Dgegmxg "DOD! xtjee jmd amekwgmhgd `q otbgp opijma,
~jtaomjk xtjcgbokdgpx+ amhkwdami jm gmijigd Homipgxx
jmd pgiaomjk vkjqgpxxwiigxtx jddataomjk amxaibtx amtotbg holvomgmtx oe geeghtaug howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom
vokahqljcami- Ybjt amxaibtx dogx tbg Mwmm,Kwijp
hjxg vpouadg am tgplx oe jm amxtjmhg ybgpg grghwtaug
jmd `wpgjwhpjtah kgjdgpxbav homtpa`wtgd to xwhhgxx,
ewk jmd kjxtami vokahq ammoujtaom? Ybjt ygpg tbg pokgx
oe tbg dgegmxg xghpgtjpq jmd tbg DOD `wpgjwhpjhq
jx ygkk jx tbg pokgx oe tbg cgq xgmjtopx? Tbgxg grghw,
taug jmd kgiaxkjtaug `pjmhb kgjdgpxbav geeoptx ygpg
dgxaimgd to jddpgxx tbg hpatahjk vpokaegpjtaom tbpgjtx
oe kooxg mwcgx epol tbg eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx am
tbg jetgpljtb oe tbg Hokd Yjp-
To ijam tbgopgtahjk amxaibtx to iwadg tbax hjxg xtwdq+
tbax vjvgp amtpodwhgx homhgvtx dpjym epol tbg katgpj,
twpg om amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx- Eapxt+ tbg W-X- owt,
kooc om amtgpmjtaomjk xghwpatq amxtatwtaomx am tbg vjxt
hgmtwpq yakk g dgxhpa`gd pagekq- Mgrt+ tbg ljnop adgjx
jmd uagyx am amxtatwtaomjk tbgopq yakk g owtkamgd- Tbgm+
tbg cmoym homdataomx eop xwhhgxx op ejakwpg am amxta,
twtaom wakdami yakk g daxhwxxgd- Kjxt+ tbgxg adgjx jmd
homdataomx yakk iwadg jm grjlamjtaom oe W-X- vokahq jx
dgugkovgd `q tbg xghpgtjpq oe dgegmxg jmd otbgpx am,
uokugd am tbg HTP vpoipjlx to vpgugmt tbg vpokaegpj,
taom oe ygjvomx oe ljxx dgxtpwhtaom "YLD! am tbgeoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx-
Tbg tygmtagtb,hgmtwpq baxtopq oe tbg W-X- voxtwpg
toyjpd amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx amhkwdgx tbpgg hqhkgx
oe gmijiglgmt eokkoygd q yatbdpjyjk-1 Yatb tbg dax,
xokwtaom oe tbg Xouagt Wmaom dwpami tbg Igopig B- Y-
@wxb "bgpgjetgp Igopig @wxb! vpgxadgmhq+ amtgpmjtaomjk
amxtatwtaomx hjlg to `g uagygd lopg ejuopj`kq omhg
jijam- Am :11:+ Igopig @wxb hjkkgd eop j pgmgygd
amtgpmjtaomjk opdgp wmdgp WM iwadjmhg jetgp j xwh,
hgxxewk amtgpmjtaomjk hojkataom homtpa`wtgd to tbg dg,
egjt oe Xjddjl Bwxxgamx Apjza eophgx am tbg IwkeYjp-:6 Vpgxadgmt Hkamtom homtamwgd tbax yjug oe gm,
ijiglgmt+ vpolotami j vokahq oe jxxgptaug
lwktakjtgpjkaxl+ gxvghajkkq vpomowmhgd am tbg hojkataom
davkoljhq jmd daeeahwktagx yatb WM jmd MJTO
vokahqljcgpx pgijpdami tbg glvkoqlgmt oe vgjhg,
cggvami jplgd eophgx am tbg @jkcjmx-::
Tbg hqhkg xboygd xaimx oe jijam pgugpxami jyjq epol
amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx jx tbg xghomd,tgpl Hkamtom
jdlamaxtpjtaom homhgpmx ipgy pgijpdami W-X- xtpgmitb
`gami ougpgrtgmdgd+ gxvghajkkq jetgp at grvgpagmhgd
daeeahwktagx am amtgpmjtaomjk vgjhgcggvami geeoptx amBjata+ Xoljkaj+ jmd tbg @jkcjmx- Dwpami tbg 0666 vpgxa,
dgmtajk gkghtaom+ W-X- gmijiglgmt jmd amtgpugmtaom
j`pojd tbpowib amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx hjlg wmdgp
amtgmxg hpatahaxl epol Igopig Y- @wxbx hjlvjaim-
Yatb tbg xghomd @wxbx gkghtaom+ tbgpg yjx guadgmhg
1- Xtgvbgm H- Xhbkgxamigp+Jht oe Hpgjtaom> Tbg Eowmdami oe tbg Wmatgd Mjtaomx "@owkdgp> Ygxtuagy+ 0668!3 Nobm Igpjpd Pwiiag+ gd-+Lwktakjtgpjkaxl Ljttgpx> Tbg Tbgopq jmd Vpjrax oe jm Amxtatwtaomjk Eopl "Mgy Qopc> Hokwl`aj Wmaugpxatq Vpgxx+ :118!3 Lahbjgk Y-Doqkg+ Yjqx oe Yjp jmd Vgjhg> Pgjkaxl+ Ka`gpjkaxl+ jmd Xohajkaxl "Mgy Qopc> Y- Y- Moptom+ :119!- Tbgxg igmgpjk tpgmdx jpg
adgmtaeagd yatb Yoodpoy Yakxom jmd tbg ejakwpg oe tbg Kgjiwg oe Mjtaomx+ Pooxgugkt jmd Tpwljm jmd tbg W-X- kgjdgpxbav am eoplamitbg WM jmd MJTO+ jmd tbg jhckjxb jijamxt tbg WM adgmtaeagd yatb tbg vpgxadgmhq oe Pomjkd Pgjijm jmd bax jl`jxxjdop to tbg WM+Ngjmg N- Capcvjtpahc-
:6- Igopig @wxb jmd @pgmt Xhoyhpoet+ J Yopkd Tpjmxeoplgd"Mgy Qopc> Cmove+ :112!-
::- Ljdgkgamg Jk`paibt yatb @akk Yoodyjpd+Ljdjlg Xghpgtjpq> J Lgloap"Mgy Qopc> Bqvgpaom+ 0668!3 Pahbjpd H- Bok`poocg+ To
Gmd J Yjp"Mgy Qopc> Lodgpm Ka`pjpq+ :111!3 Ygxkgq C- Hkjpc+ Yjiami Lodgpm Yjp> @oxmaj+ Coxouo+ jmd tbg Ewtwpg oe Hol`jt
"Mgy Qopc> Vw`kah Jeejapx+ 066:!-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
6/2250 TBG COPGJ GHOMOLAH AMXTATWTG
jijam oe j mgohomxgpujtaug `jhckjxb jijamxt amtgpmj,
taomjk amxtatwtaomx-:0 Xoom jetgp tbg gkghtaom+ tbg Wmatgd
Xtjtgx vwkkgd owt oe tbg Jmta,@jkkaxtah Laxxakg "J@L!
Tpgjtq yatb tbg Pwxxajmx- Jmtavjtbq toyjpd amtgpmj,
taomjk amxtatwtaomx howkd g o`xgpugd gugm lopg hkgjpkq
jetgp tbg tgppopaxt jttjhcx oe Xgvtgl`gp ::+ 066:- Eop
amxtjmhg+ am j 0660 xvgghb jt tbg WM+ Igopig Y- @wxbhkgjpkq xaimjkgd bax amtgmtaom eop tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx to
io at jkomg ae tbg WM dad mot jht jijamxt Xjddjl
Bwxxgam>
Yg yakk yopc yatb tbg W-M- Xghwpatq Howm,
hak - - - @wt tbg vwpvoxgx oe tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx
xbowkd mot `g dow`tgd- Tbg Xghwpatq Howmhak
pgxokwtaomx yakk `g gmeophgdtbg nwxt dg,
ljmdx oe vgjhg jmd xghwpatq yakk `g lgtop
jhtaom yakk `g wmjuoadj`kg-:8
Tbg yjtgpxbgd lolgmt eop tbax mgy voxtwpg oe W-X-wmakjtgpjkaxl eop vpgugmtaug dgegmxg yjx baibkaibtgd
am tbg W-X- yjp am Apjz xtjptami am 0660+ ybahb tbg WM
xghpgtjpq igmgpjk+ Coea Jmmjm+ uagygd jx akkgijk am tgplx
oe amtgpmjtaomjk kjy- Om :7 Xgvtgl`gp 0664+ am pg,
xvomxg to j @@H nowpmjkaxtx voamtgd zwgxtaomx j`owt
tbg W-X- yjp am Apjz+ Jmmjm pgvkagd+ Qgx+ A bjug amda,
hjtgd at ax mot am homeoplatq yatb tbg WM hbjptgp- Epol
owp voamt oe uagy jmd epol tbg hbjptgp voamt oe uagy
at yjx akkgijk- Tbg xghomd @wxb jdlamaxtpjtaom bjd
hgptjamkq mot pgdwhgd amuokuglgmt j`pojd jx vpol,
axgd am tbg 0666 vpgxadgmtajk hjlvjaim+ jmd atx jvvjp,
gmt kjhc oe vjtagmhg eop tbg davkoljhq mghgxxjpq eopijamami WM jvvpoujk eop yjp "jx jwtbopa~gd `q Hbjv,
tgp UAA oe tbg WM Hbjptgp! ax hatgd jx j hjwxg eop tbg
pwxb to yjp jijamxt Xjddjl Bwxxgamx Apjz-
Iaugm tbg vpolamgmhg oe tbg WM jmd MJTO xamhg
Yopkd Yjp AA jx ygkk jx tbg daeegpami uagyx oe ujpaowx
W-X- jdlamaxtpjtaomx om tbg xw`nght oe tbg geeahjhq oe
amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx jmd lwktakjtgpjk opijma~jtaomx+
amxaibtx om amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx jpg alvoptjmt jx
j iwadg to jm wmdgpxtjmdami oe tbg homdataomx eop vpo,
lotami geeghtaug vokahqljcami- Eop amxtjmhg+ tbg kat,
gpjtwpg om amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx jddpgxxgx tbg mo,
taom oe tbgxg xbaetami yopkduagyx am W-X- eopgaim jmdmjtaomjk xghwpatq vokahagx- Kgipo grvkopgx ybq xtjtgx
ewmdjlgmtjkkq hbjmig tbgap komi,bgkd adgjx toyjpd
amtgpmjtaomjk jeejapx jmd adgmtaeagx tyo xtjigx am xwhb
jm adgjtaomjk xbaet-:4 Tbg pgaimami homxgmxwx lwxt
hokkjvxg jmd tbgm eokkoyx tbg homxokadjtaom oe j mgy
dolamjmt jmd uaj`kg adgj-:7 Ae tbgpg ax j mgy xbaet to,
yjpd pggmijiglgmt jmd lwktakjtgpjkaxl om tbg bopa,
~om+ at pgljamx to `g kgjpmgd ybjt homdataomx tgmd to
vpghavatjtg tbg hokkjvxg oe omg jdlamaxtpjtaomx uagyx
jx ygkk jx ybjt homdataomx kgjd to tbg glgpigmhg oe j
mgy xtpjtgiah jvvpojhb- Dgxvatg vgpaodah W-X- jmra,
gtq ougp amxtatwtaomjk jttjhblgmtx+ tbg tbpgjtx oemwhkgjp ygjvomx+ tghbmokoiq vpokaegpjtaom+ jmd tgp,
popaxl pgzwapg vokahqljcgpx to jddpgxx tbgxg axxwgx-
Tbg pghgmt baxtopq oe W-X-,Moptb Copgjm pgkjtaomx
xwiigxtx tbjt tbg kjhc oe xwvvoptami amxtatwtaomjk xtpwh,
twpgx jhhowmtx am vjpt eop tbg pgjcdoym am tbg Jipggd
Epjlgyopc- Ygpg tbgpg xwvvoptami amxtatwtaomjk xtpwh,
twpgx tbjt jhhowmt eop tbg pgkjtaug xwhhgxx oe tbg Mwmm,
Kwijp vpoipjlx?
Tbax vjvgp mgrt pguagyx tbg ljnop homtgmdami xhbok,
jpx adgjx pgijpdami amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx am opdgp
to ameopl jm wmdgpxtjmdami oe W-X- vokahq pgijpdamigraxtami jmd glgpiami amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx- Tbg
katgpjtwpg om amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx epjlgx jm gr,
jlamjtaom oe tbg opaiamx jmd vwpvoxgx oe amxtatwtaomx
am xgugpjk yjqx- Am tbg pgjkaxt yopkduagy+ tbg vwpxwat
oe voygp eoplx tbg `jxax oe jmq amxtatwtaomx tbjt ljq
jpaxg-:5 Amxtatwtaomx jpg+ am gxxgmhg+ j eopljka~jtaom oe
:0- Djuad Epwl jmd Pahbjpd Vgpkg+Jm Gmd To Guak> Boy to Yam tbg Yjp om Tgppop"Mgy Qopc> Pjmdol Bowxg+ 0668!-
:8- Vpgxadgmtx Pgljpcx jt tbg Wmatgd Mjtaomx Igmgpjk Jxxgl`kq+ :0 Xgvtgl`gp 0660+ yyy-ybatgbowxg-iou/mgyx/pgkgjxgx/0660/
61/066061:0,:-btlk-
:4- Ngeepgq Y- Kgipo+ Ybgmhg Jlgpahjm Amtgpmjtaomjkaxl+ Amtgpmjtaomjk Opijma~jtaom74+ mo- 0 "Xvpami 0666!> 074-
:7- A`ad-+ 058+ 05755-
:5- Nobm N- Lgjpxbgalgp+ Tpjigdq oe Ipgjt Voygp Vokatahx "Mgy Qopc> Y- Y- Moptom+ 066:!-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
7/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 58
tbg daxtpa`wtaom oe voygp am tbg amtgpmjtaomjk xqxtgl-:9
Am tbg pgjkaxtvoygp vokatahxepjlgyopc+ xtjtgx
dgeamg tbgap amtgpgxtx holvgtataugkq+ jmd amxtatwtaomx jpg
ygjc am holvjpaxom yatb xtjtgx-:2 Mgopgjkaxl+ jx eop,
lwkjtgd `q Yjkt~+ glvbjxa~gx tbg alvoptjmhg oe tbg
`jkjmhg oe voygp jlomi jm jmjphbahjk yopkd oe
xtjtgx-:1 Mgopgjkaxl pgijpdx amxtatwtaomx jx vjpt oe jmamtgpmjtaomjk opdgp+ tbjt ax+ tbg wmamtgmdgd owtholg
oe `jkjmhami vpgxxwpgx op j pgekghtaom oe kgjpmgd jmd
eopljka~gd pwkgx oe gzwaka`pawl jmd `jkjmhg-06 Omg
xtpjam oe mgopgjkaxl xtpgxxgx tbg alvoptjmt pokg tbjt j
bgiglomah voygp vkjqx am amxtatwtaom eopljtaom> vpg,
vomdgpjmt voygp ljq jkkoy tbg bgiglom to oeegp
amhgmtaugx to ygjcgp xtjtgx tbjt hoovgpjtg am tbg `wakd,
ami oe j vjptahwkjp opdgp-
Am homtpjxt yatb pgjkaxl+ j ka`gpjk,amtgpmjtaomjkaxt jv,
vpojhb vpovoxgx tbjt j mjtwpjk bjplomq oe amtgpgxtx
ejhakatjtgx amxtatwtaom `wakdami-0:
Jhhopdami to tbg ka`,gpjk yopkduagy+ ougpkjvvami ujkwgx jmd iojkx jpg tbg
opaiamjtopx oe amtgpmjtaomjk moplx+ pgialgx+ jmd op,
ijma~jtaomx- Mgoka`gpjkaxl jpiwgx tbjt amxtatwtaomx jht
jx jipgglgmtx op homtpjhtx `gtyggm jhtopx tbjt ewmh,
taom to pgdwhg wmhgptjamtq+ koygp tpjmxjhtaom hoxtx+
jmd xokug hokkghtaug jhtaom vpo`kglx-00 Amhpgjxgd
geeahagmhq ax jt tbg hopg oe mgoka`gpjkaxl> `q gkalamjt,
ami tbg mggd to jttgmd lwktavkg `akjtgpjk eopwlx eop
gugpq xamikg axxwg+ tbg tpjmxjhtaom hoxtx oe doami am,
tgpmjtaomjk vokatahjk wxamgxx jpg koygpgd- Cgobjmg eapxt
eoplwkjtgd tbax uagy+ ybahb xtpgxxgx tbg alvoptjmhg
oe ameopljtaom ekoyx+ gmeophglgmt+ jmd lomatopami-
J cgq homhgpm oe mgoka`gpjkaxl ax tbjt amxtatwtaomx vpouadg ameopljtaom to xtjtgx jmd pgdwhg tbg amhgm,
taugx eop hbgjtami-08
Eokkoyami tbg ka`gpjk tpjdataomx ax j homhgvt cmoym jx
ewmhtaomjkaxl+ ybahb gkgujtgx amdauadwjk axxwgx jx tbg
vpaljpq xowphg oe amxtatwtaomx- J ewmhtaomjkaxt jpiwgx
tbjt tbg loxt geeghtaug amxtatwtaomx jpg tboxg tbjt xgpug
vpjhtahjk ewmhtaomx jx ovvoxgd to ipjmd vokatahjk o`,
nghtaugx-04 Jhhopdami to ewmhtaomjkaxt amtgpmjtaomjk
pgkjtaomx xhbokjpx+ jm amxtatwtaom jpaxgx to jddpgxx j
xvghaeah homhgpm tbpowib j xvomtjmgowx+ `ottol,wv
vpohgxx-07
Jvjpt epol otb tbg pgjkaxt jmd ka`gpjk tpjdataomx xtjmdx
tbg lopg xohaokoiahjkkq `jxgd homhgvt hjkkgd
homxtpwhtauaxl- Jhhopdami to Acgm`gppq+ amxtatwtaomx
jpg daeewxg jmd xohajkkq homxtpwhtgd yopkduagyx tbjt
`owmd jmd xbjvg tbg xtpjtgiah `gbjuaop oe amdauadwjkx
:1- Cgmmgtb M- Yjkt~+Ljm+ Tbg Xtjtg jmd Yjp> J Tbgopgtahjk Jmjkqxax "Mgy Qopc> Hokwl`aj Wmaugpxatq Vpgxx+ :171!3 Po`gpt N- Jpt
jmd Cgmmgtb M- Yjkt~+ gdx-+ Tbg Wxg oe Eophg> Lakatjpq Voygp jmd Amtgpmjtaomjk Vokatahx+ 7tb gd- "Kjmbjl+ Ld-> Poyljm jmd
Kattkgeagkd+ :111!-
06- Acgm`gppq+Jetgp Uahtopq+ ::-
0:- Doqkg+ Yjqx oe Yjp jmd Vgjhg3 Acgm`gppq+Jetgp Uahtopq+ :7-
00- Po`gpt O- Cgobjmg+Voygp jmd Iougpmjmhg am j Vjptajkkq Iko`jka~gd Yopkd"Komdom> Powtkgdig+ 0660!-
08- Acgm`gppq+Jetgp Uahtopq+ :5-
04- Kgviokd jmd Mamhah+@gqomd tbg Auopq Toygp+ :44-
07- A`ad-+ :81+ :44- Kgviokd jmd Mamhah jpg `wkkaxb om tbg wtakatq oe amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx3 tbgq ypatg> Am vpamhavkg+ ygkk dgxaimgd
amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx vpouadg j yjq to dgugkov jmd alvkglgmt hollom vokahagx to dgjk yatb hokkghtaug vpo`kglx+ jmd at ax bjpd
to eamd jm amtgpmjtaomjk axxwg tbjt bjx mot `gholg amhpgjxamikq amxtatwtaomjka~gd am pghgmt dghjdgx- Ewptbgplopg+ eop `pgjhbami tbg
amtgpmjtaomjk pgkjtaomx tbgopq,vpjhtahg ijv+ tbgq glvbjxa~g tbjt tbg tbgopgtahjk jmd glvapahjk katgpjtwpg om amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx
xbowkd hjppq alvoptjmt vpjhtahjk alvkahjtaomx- Tbgq io om to wpig homtamwgd xhbokjpxbav> Ae xhbokjpkq yopc om amtgpmjtaomjk
amxtatwtaomx hjm xbgd kaibt om tbgxg axxwgx Siko`jka~jtaom jmd tbg `jhckjxb\ `q akkwlamjtami tbg ovvoptwmatagx+ homxtpjamtx+ jmd
homxgzwgmhgx oe lwktakjtgpjk jhtaomx+ at xbowkd bgkv oeeahajkx xbjvg grtgpmjk vwpxwatx tbowib lwktakjtgpjk lgjmx-
:9- I- Nobm Acgm`gppq+ Jetgp Uahtopq> Amxtatwtaomx+ Xtpjtgiah Pgxtpjamt+ jmd tbg Pg`wakdami oe Opdgp jetgp Ljnop Yjpx "Vpamhgtom>
Vpamhgtom Wmaugpxatq Vpgxx+ 066:!+ ::-
:2- Kgviokd jmd Mamhah+@gqomd tbg Auopq Toygp+ :4241-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
8/2254 TBG COPGJ GHOMOLAH AMXTATWTG
jmd xtjtgx+ ybahb xgpug jx hoimataug ljvx eop xtjtg
jhtopx-05 Homxtpwhtauaxl dogx mot jxxwlg tbjt tbg am,
tgpgxtx oe jhtopx jpg eargd+ `wt jxxgptx tbjt xohajk xtpwh,
twpgx xbjvg vpgegpgmhgx- Amxtatwtaomx dgeamg tbg ipowv
adgmtatq oe j xgt oe xtjtgx `q gl`odqami jmd vpovj,
ijtami xbjpgd moplx-09
Jetgp tbax `page ougpuagy oe tbgxg ljnop jvvpojhbgx
to amxtatwtaomjk tbgopq+ ybjt do yg cmoy j`owt ybjt
ljcgx j xwhhgxxewk amxtatwtaom? Ybjt ejhtopx xbowkd
`g tjcgm amto jhhowmt? Acgm`gppq jddpgxxgx tbg amatajk
homtgrt eop amxtatwtaomx ybgm bg ypatgx tbjt Sx\tj`kg
vokatahjk opdgpx tgmd to `g tboxg tbjt bjug koy pgtwpmx
to voygp jmd baib pgtwpmx to amxtatwtaomx- Opdgpx tbjt
bjug koy pgtwpmx to voygp egjtwpg xqxtgljtah amxta,
twtaomjk kalatx om ybjt vjptahavjmtx hjm do yatb tbgap
amdauadwjk voygp- Baib pgtwpmx to amxtatwtaomx pgxwkt am
xtahcq amxtatwtaomx ybahb jpg bjpd to pgvkjhg- Jh,
hopdami to Acgm`gppq+ tbgm+ St\bg lopg holvkgr+jdjvtj`kg+ jmd jwtomolowx jm amxtatwtaom ax+ tbg lopg
at hjm koygp tbg pgtwpmx to voygp-
Pwiiag jkxo jddpgxxgx tbg amatajk homdataomx eop amxta,
twtaomjk eopljtaom jmd xwpuaujk+ ypatami tbjt Sj\ vgp,
laxxaug dolgxtah gmuapomlgmt am tbg kgjdami yopkd
xtjtg op xtjtgx ax ugpq alvoptjmt eop xgttami tbg xhgmg
eop j xwhhgxxewk amxtatwtaom- Eop grjlvkg+ Pwiiag
hkjalx tbjt W-X- bgiglomq yjx lopg alvoptjmt tbjm
tbg lgpg graxtgmhg oe jm amtgpmjtaomjk bgiglom to tbg
ekowpaxbami oe pghgmt lwktakjtgpjk amxtatwtaomx-02 Tbwx+
j kgjdami xtjtg tbjt koocx om lwktakjtgpjk amxtatwtaomx amj ugpq wmejuopj`kg ljmmgp ljq xoy tbg xggdx oe
dgxtpwhtaom+ op jt kgjxt oe ygjcgmami+ eop hgptjam am,
xtatwtaomx tbjt eop ybjtgugp pgjxomx jpg vgphgaugd jx
mot xgpuami tbg bgiglomx xtjtg amtgpgxtx- Am bgp am,
xtatwtaomjk jmjkqxax om tbg ougppadami alvoptjmhg oe
amatajk homdataomx eop amxtatwtaom `wakdami+ ^gijpt
xtpomikq glvbjxa~gx tbg hpatahjk amekwgmhg oe eowmd,
ami lolgmtx am tbg hpgjtaom oe `otb xwhhgxxewk jmd
wmxwhhgxxewk xghwpatq jigmhagx-01
Pgkjtgd to mgoka`gpjkaxlx glvbjxax om geeghtaug gm,
eophglgmt jmd lomatopami jpg eowp cgq dalgmxaomx to
tjcg amto jhhowmt ybgm hpjetami jm amxtatwtaom-86 Eapxt+
tbg ljmmgp am ybahb ameopljtaom ax vookgd amxadg tbg
amxtatwtaom ax alvoptjmt- Iood vookami oe ameopljtaom
hjm lataijtg hoovgpjtaom vpo`kglx- Xghomd+ to ybjt
grtgmt jpg pwkgx hpjetgd xo jx to `g gjxakq gmeophgd?Pgiwkjtaomx tbjt holg yatb amhgmtaugx to holvkq jpg
gjxagp to gmeophg- Tbapd+ tbg mwl`gp oe lgl`gpx am
jm amxtatwtaom ax alvoptjmt- Tbg xljkkgp tbg ipowvx
lgl`gpxbav+ tbg gjxagp at ax to pgxokug daeeahwktagx-
Eowptb+ tbg vpghaxaom oe pwkgx jmd lomatopami vpohg,
dwpgx jpg xaimaeahjmt- Jpg pwkgx lakdkq+ lodgxtkq+ op
bgjuakq gkj`opjtg op dgtjakgd? Am igmgpjk+ lopg gkj`o,
pjtg pwkgx jpg lopg daeeahwkt to gmeophg-
Am jddataom to tbgxg dalgmxaomx+ xgugpjk otbgp axxwgx
pjaxgd `q mgoka`gpjk tbowibt ljq jeeght tbg xwhhgxx
oe amxtatwtaomx+ jhhopdami to Kgviokd jmd Mamhah- Boyljmq axxwgx dogx tbg amxtatwtaom amtgmd to jddpgxx?
Tbg dgipgg oe `wmdkami oe daeegpgmt axxwgx ax alvop,
tjmt- Tbax zwgxtaom ax baibkq pgkgujmt to jdbgpgmtx oe
tbg ewmhtaomjkaxt jvvpojhb+ ybo uagy amxtatwtaomx gx,
xgmtajkkq jx axxwg,`jxgd eopwlx- Am jddataom+ tbg yjq
tbjt axxwgx jpg opijma~gd amtgpmjtaomjkkq eaiwpgx amto
tbg hjkhwkwx- Boy jm axxwg ax tpgjtgd+ jmd `q ybol+
ax alvoptjmt to boy otbgp jhtopx yakk pgxvomd- Kjxt+
tbg hboahg oe vjptmgpx eaiwpgx vpolamgmtkq- Boy kacg,
lamdgd ax tbg lgl`gpxbav oe jm amxtatwtaom? Ax at igm,
gpjkkq tpwg tbjt lgl`gpx lwxt xbjpg tbg mghgxxjpq
ujkwgx to jhholvkaxb j vjptahwkjp gmd yatb geeahagmhq?
J xwlljpq oe xgugpjk cgq voamtx yakk xgpug to iwadg
tbg pgljamdgp oe tbax vjvgp- O`xgpujtaomx amhkwdg otb
ljhpovokatahjk jmd lahpovokatahjk vgpxvghtaugx om tbg
jpgjx iwadami jm jmjkqxax oe tbg Mwmm,Kwijp hjxg-
Epol tbg ljhpovokatahjk kgugk+ tbg motaom oe j
yopkduagy+ jmd gxvghajkkq j bgiglomx yopkduagy+ ax
xaimaeahjmt- Tbax `wakdx om Kgipox adgj pgijpdami
hbjmigx pgxwktami epol tbg hokkjvxg oe j pgaimami hom,
05- Acgm`gppq+Jetgp Uahtopq+ :7-
09- Kgviokd jmd Mamhah+@gqomd tbg Auopq Toygp+ :767:-
02- Pwiiag+ gd-+Lwktakjtgpjkaxl Ljttgpx+ 2-
01- Jlq @- ^gijpt+Ekjygd `q Dgxaim> Tbg Guokwtaom oe tbg HAJ+ NHX+ jmd MXH"Xtjmeopd> Xtjmeopd Wmaugpxatq Vpgxx+ :111!-
86- Adgjx am tbax vjpjipjvb om tbg eowp cgq dalgmxaomx jpg epol Kgviokd jmd Mamhah+@gqomd tbg Auopq Toygp+ :7471-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
9/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 57
xgmxwx jmd tbg glgpigmhg oe j mgy dolamjmt jmd
uaj`kg adgj am yopkd vokatahx-
Xhbokjpx amtgpvpgtjtaomx oe yopkduagyx pguokug jpowmd
tbg eowp dolamjmt vgpxvghtaugx daxhwxxgd j`oug> pg,
jkaxl+ ka`gpjkaxl+ ewmhtaomjkaxl+ jmd homxtpwhtauaxl-
Gjhb vpovoxgx jktgpmjtaugx eop vokahqljcami jx ygkkjx jxxwlvtaomx pgijpdami tbg pgkgujmhg oe amxtatwtaomx
jx amxtpwlgmtx oe xtjtghpjet- Xtjtg kgjdgpx
yopkduagyx+ gxvghajkkq eop vpgxadgmtx jmd xghpgtjpagx
oe dgegmxg+ yakk bjug alvoptjmt vokahq alvkahjtaomx-
Eop pgjkaxtx kacg Yjkt~ jmd Lgjpxbgalgp+ tbg xtjtg ax
tbg eohwx oe jttgmtaom+ jmd tbg xtjtgx vwpxwat oe xgke,
amtgpgxt am jm jmjphbah yopkd ax oe xwvpglg alvop,
tjmhg- Am Acgm`gppqx hbjpjhtgpa~jtaom oe mgopgjkaxl+
boygugp+ `jkjmhg oe voygp ljttgpx jx lwhb jx xgke,
amtgpgxt jx j lodgpjtop oe xtjtg voygp- Am j mgopgjkaxt
jdlamaxtpjtaom+ eop amxtjmhg+ amxtatwtaomx ljq xgpug tbg
xtjtgx amtgpgxtx to tbg grtgmt tbjt tbg jppjmiglgmtxpgekght kgjpmgd jmd eopljk pwkgx oe gzwaka`pawl jmd
`jkjmhg tbjt pgameophg xtj`akatq jmd opdgp jmd+ tbgpg,
eopg+ tbg voxataom oe dolamjmt mjtaom,xtjtgx op ipgjt
voygpx-
Ka`gpjkaxl xtpgxxgx j bjplomq oe amtgpgxtx jlomi
mjtaomx am jm amtgpmjtaomjk hollwmatq- Eop ka`gpjkx+
amxtatwtaom `wakdami ax j mjtwpjk xaim oe vpoipgxx- Eop
mgoka`gpjkx+ tbgpg jpg lopg xvghaeah homxadgpjtaomx tbjm
motaomx oe hollwmatq eop atx oym xjcg- Tbg
mgoka`gpjkx kooc eop jipgglgmtx jmd homtpjhtx to wm,
dgpvam amtgpmjtaomjk pgkjtaomx- Jipgglgmtx amhkwdg eop,ljk yjqx to pgdwhg wmhgptjamtq+ koygp tpjmxjhtaom
hoxtx+ jmd xokug vpo`kglx oe hokkghtaug jhtaom- Am tbax
pgijpd+ tbg mgoka`gpjk+ tbg ewmhtaomjkaxt+ jx ygkk jx tbg
pgjkaxt jvvpojhbgx jkaim am tgplx oe j bjplomq oe am,
tgpgxtx am xokuami vpo`kglx tbpowib hokkghtaug jhtaom
tbjt wktaljtgkq xgpugx tbg xtjtgx vwpvoxgx op xgke am,
tgpgxtx- Tbwx+ Cgobjmg jpiwgx eophgewkkq tbjt amtgp,
mjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx vgpeopl xtjtg tjxcx uatjk eop gm,
j`kami hoovgpjtaom-8: Am ejht+ Cgobjmg daxdjamx ka`gpjk
op mgoka`gpjk kj`gkx eop bax tbgopa~ami jmd amxtgjd hom,
xadgpx balxgke j xtjwmhb amxtatwtaomjkaxt-
Homxtpwhtauaxl ax jmotbgp jvvpojhb yatb lopg gl,
vbjxax om hpgjtami jmd dgugkovami xbjpgd ujkwgx am
yopkd vokatahx- Cjt~gmxtgam jmd Acgm`gppq hbjpjhtgp,
a~g amxtatwtaomx jx j vpodwht oe daeewxg jmd xohajkkq
homxtpwhtgd yopkduagyx- Jijam tbgpg ax xolg ougpkjv
yatb pgjkaxtx am tbg xgmxg oe geeghtaug amxtatwtaomx vpo,
uadami baib pgtwpmx to voygp+ op+ jx Cjt~gmxtgamhbjpjhtgpa~gx at+ homtjamami j xtahcamgxx tbjt ljcgx
tbgl bjpd to pgvkjhg `ghjwxg tbgq ewptbgp `otb xtjtg
ujkwgx jmd amtgpgxtx-
Lwktakjtgpjkaxt Pwiiag jmd mgoamxtatwtaomjkaxt ^gijpt
vpouadg ewptbgp amxaibtx pgijpdami tbg alvoptjmhg oe
amatajk op eowmdami homdataomx jx loxt xaimaeahjmt eop
dgtgplamami amxtatwtaomjk geeghtaugmgxx- Tbgxg amatajk
homdataomx mopljkkq pgekght tbg dolgxtah gmuapomlgmt
oe tbg kgjdami xtjtg+ op bgiglom- Grjlvkgx yowkd
amhkwdg tbg alvoptjmhg oe tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx am tbg
eowmdami oe tbg WM jetgp Yopkd Yjp AA- Otbgp mgoka`gpjktbowibtx kamcgd to ewmhtaomjk jvvpojhbgx amhkwdg tbg
adgj oe `wmdkami axxwgx jmd tbg mwl`gp oe vjptmgpx
amuokugd- Pwiiag jmd otbgp jwtbopx+ gxvghajkkq am tbg
ewmhtaomjkaxt xhbook+ jpiwg tbjt amhkwdami egygp vjpt,
mgpx+ hboxgm `ghjwxg tbgq xbjpg ujkwgx "jx am tbg GW!
jmd eohwxgd axxwgx tbjt xgpug hollom amtgpgxtx "jx
am bjktami tbg pgiaomjk xvpgjd oe mwhkgjp ygjvomx!+ ax
lopg kacgkq to xwhhggd-
Am tgplx pgkjtaug to tbg amtgpmjtaomjk xghwpatq xtwdagx
katgpjtwpg daxhwxxgd j`oug jmd tbg Jipggd Epjlgyopc
grvgpagmhg+ Mwmm,Kwijp pgvpgxgmtx j mjppjtaug oe kgjd,gpxbav+ vpaljpakq jx kgjdgpxbav epol tbg tov jmd laddkg-
At amhkwdgx j kjpig mwl`gp oe vkjqgpx amuokugd am tbg
vpoipjlx eowmdami jmd guokwtaom tbpowibowt tbg
:116x- Tbg vpohgxx oe tpjhami Mwmm,Kwijpx dgugk,
ovlgmt yakk vpouadg amxaibtx amto Iottglogkkgpx o`,
xgpujtaom tbjt Sx\tj`kg hoovgpjtaom+ tbgpgeopg+ ax kacgkq
to pgzwapg `otb jttgmtaom epol om baib jmd `wpgjw,
hpjtah hollatlgmt jt j koygp kgugk-80 Omg cgq da,
lgmxaom eop grjlamami tbg homdataomx eop jhbaguami
xtj`kg hoovgpjtaom amhkwdgx tbg motaom oe vokahq pgk,
gujmhg-
8:- Cgobjmg+Voygp jmd Iougpmjmhg am j Vjptajkkq Iko`jka~gd Yopkd+ 8-
80- Poxg Iottglogkkgp+ Hoovgpjtaug Amdwhglgmtx> Hpjetami Mgy Tookx eop Momvpokaegpjtaom+ am Wktaljtg Xghwpatq> Hol`jtami
Ygjvomx oe Ljxx Dgxtpwhtaom+ gd- Njmmg Mokjm+ @gpmjpd A- Eamgk+ jmd @pajm D- Eamkjq "Mgy Qopc> Hgmtwpq Eowmdjtaom Vpgxx+ 0668!+
:47-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
10/2255 TBG COPGJ GHOMOLAH AMXTATWTG
Vokahq jmd Amxtpwlgmtjk Pgkgujmhg
Tyo jxvghtx oe vokahqljcami pgkgujmhg jpg vpgxgmtgd
am tbg katgpjtwpg om amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx-88 Tbgxg
amhkwdg vokahq pgkgujmhg jmd amxtpwlgmtjk pgkgujmhg-
Vokahq pgkgujmhg pgegpx to tbg ljhpovokatahjk op xtpj,
tgiah jxvghtx oe vokahq dgxaim am amtgpmjtaomjk pgkj,taomx- Amxtpwlgmtjk pgkgujmhg pgegpx to lahpovokatahjk
op tjhtahjk vgpxvghtaugx- Tbg mgoka`gpjkaxt jmd
homxtpwhtauaxt tbgopaxtx motg tbjt jhtopx vpgegpgmhgx
xbjvg vokahq hboahgx-
Tbg katgpjtwpg baibkaibtx eaug jpgjx tbjt xwiigxt tbg
mghgxxjpq jmd xweeahagmt homdataomx eop vokahq pgk,
gujmhg+ amhkwdami+ eapxt+ holvkglgmtjpq mjtaomjk am,
tgpgxtxtbjt ax+ tbjt tbg amxtatwtaom amhkwdgx jhhgvtgd
ujkwgx+ tbjt iojkx jpg holvjta`kg eop tbg komi tgpl+
tbjt tbgpg ax jm amugxtlgmt am jmq hbjmigx am vpgegp,
gmhgx- Amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx hjm hbjmig pgkjtaomxtbowib pgialgx+ dgeamgd jx moplx jmd pwkgx tbjt pgiw,
kjtg `gbjuaop am xvghaeah axxwg jpgjx amuokuami amtgpmj,
taomjk jhtauatagx-84 Jx Pwiiag xwiigxtx+ tbg amxtatwtaom
yakk jkxo `g lopg xwhhgxxewk ae at jxxwpgx tbg
bgiglomx xwvvopt- Bgiglom am tbax homtgrt jmd am
tbax hjxg pgegpx to tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx jx tbg loxt voy,
gpewk mjtaom,xtjtg am tbg voxtHokd Yjp vgpaod+ jx dg,
eamgd am pgjkaxt tgplx pgijpdami mjtaomjk voygp-87
Tbg xghomd jxvght oe vokahq pgkgujmhg jddpgxxgx tbg
bgiglomx hollattami pgxowphgx jmd xwvvoptami
pwkgx- Tbgxg pwkgx amhkwdg j hollatlgmt to gxxgmtajkvpamhavkgx jmd pwkgx oe opdgp+ jkomi yatb vjptmgpx to
xbjpg `wpdgmx jmd hoopdamjtg vokahq- Tbg tbapd jx,
vght ax tbg vgphgvtaom oe tbg amxtatwtaom jx j hjppagp oe
moplx+ adgmtatq+ jmd cmoykgdig- Tbax amhkwdgx hoda,
eqami jmd jwilgmtami kgijk moplx+ gxvghajkkq moplx
tbjt glvoygp ybjt jpg vgphgaugd jx kgiataljtg hkjalx-
Omg jddataomjk homdataom ax tbjt vpgegpgmhgx pgijpdami
moplx+ adgmtatq+ jmd cmoykgdig guokug tbpowib amtgp,
jhtaom jmd vpgxwlj`kq mot tbpowib dolamjtaom op eoph,
ami- Eowptb jpg tbg grvghtjtaomx pgijpdami tbg hoxtx
jmd homxgzwgmhgx oe jhtauatagx homdwhtgd tbpowib
amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx- Am `page+ jpg tbgpg xtj`kg gr,
vghtjtaomx eop noamt hoopdamjtaom tbjt xgpug jipggd xtjtg
vwpvoxgx? Tbg eaetb ujpaj`kg amuokugx tbg pokg oe tbg
amxtatwtaom yatbam tbg vokahqljcami hollwmatq- Tbg
katgpjtwpg xwiigxtx tbjt tbg doljam ax kalatgd to xatwj,taomx am ybahb tbg xtjtgx jkpgjdq jipgg om tbg vokahq
o`nghtaugx op gmdx- Jijam+ tbg ewmhtaomjkaxt xhbook
xwiigxtx tbg alvoptjmt amekwgmhg oe xvghajk+ grvgpt
jigmhagx-
Amxtpwlgmtjk pgkgujmhg bgpg pgegpx to tbg amhgmtaug
xtpwhtwpgx+ lomatopami jmd gmeophglgmt lghbjmaxlx+
hjkhwkjtaom oe ewtwpg gmgeatx jmd hoxtx+ jmd otbgp tookx
eop ejhakatjtami geeghtaug+ vpodwhtaug `jpijamx-85 Tbgxg
amhkwdg amhgmtaug xtpwhtwpgx+ lomatopami jmd gmeophg,
lgmt+ hjkhwkjtaomx oe ewtwpg `gmgeatx jmd hoxtx+ jmd
tookx eop ejhakatjtami geeghtaug+ vpodwhtaug `jpijamx-Amhgmtaug xtpwhtwpgx amhkwdg voxataug ejhtopx to ljcg
hoovgpjtaom lopg kacgkq jx ygkk jx mgijtaug ejhtopx to
vpgugmt dgeghtopx- Hjkhwkjtaomx oe ewtwpg `gmgeatx jmd
hoxtx xgpug to kgmitbgm tbg xbjdoy oe tbg ewtwpg to
amhpgjxg vjptahavjmtx pjtaomjk hboahgx xwvvoptami am,
xtatwtaom `wakdami eop tbg komi tgpl- Xhbokjpx voamt to
gaibt ejhtopx eop xtpgmitbgmami geeghtaug jmd vpodwh,
taug jipgglgmtx>
Pwkgx tbjt xtj aka~g grvghtjtaomx3
Ameopljtaom to xgmd jmd pghgaug xaimjkx3
Hkgjp xtjmdjpdx3
Ameopljtaom j`owt holvkajmhg3
Hpgda kg vgmjktagx3
Gmeophglgmt lghbjmaxlx3
Hoovgpjtaom tbpowib ameopljtaom xbjpami3 jmd
Pgiwkjtami tbg mwl`gp oe vjptahavjmtx-
88- Kgviokd jmd Mamhah+@gqomd tbg Auopq Toygp-
84- A`ad-+ :81-
87- Bjmx N- Lopigmtbjw+Vokatahx Jlomi Mjtaomx> Tbg Xtpwiikg eop Voygp jmd Vgjhg "Mgy Qopc> LhIpjy,Bakk+ :118!3 Domjkd G-Mwghbtgpkgam+Jlgpahj Ougphollattgd> Wmatgd Xtjtgx Mjtaomjk Amtgpgxtx am tbg :126x "Kgramitom> Wmaugpxatq oe Cgmtwhcq Vpgxx+
:127!3 Lgjpxbgalgp+ Tpjigdq oe Ipgjt Voygp Vokatahx-
85- Adgjx am tbax vjpjipjvb jpg dpjym epol Kgviokd jmd Mamhah+@gqomd tbg Auopq Toygp-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
11/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 59
Vokahq jmd amxtpwlgmtjk pgkgujmhg vpouadg j kgmitbq
kaxt oe ujpaj`kgx eop grjlamami tbg homdataomx eop xwh,
hgxxewk kgjdgpxbav epol tbg tov jmd laddkg eop geegh,
taug vokahq jmd amxtatwtaom `wakdami-
Pgkjtami Amxtatwtaomjkaxt Tbgopq jmd Vpjhtahg
am tbg Mwmm,Kwijp Hjxg
Tbax vjvgp vpohggdx `q grjlamami tbg Mwmm,Kwijp
HTP hjxg jx j cgq vpoipjl am tbg Hkamtom
howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq amatajtaug-
Holvkglgmtjpq Mjtaomjk Amtgpgxtx
Iougpmlgmt vokahqljcgpx jmd mjtaomjk xghwpatq xhbok,
jpx gmijigd am vpokaegpjtaom vokahqljcami ygpg jlomi
tbg eapxt to xga~g tbg ovvoptwmatq eop eoplami mgy pg,
kjtaomxbavx jlomi tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx+ Pwxxaj+ jmd tbg
eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx eokkoyami tbg ejkk oe tbg @gp,kam Yjkk- Igopig @wxbx motaom oe j mgy yopkd opdgp
yjx xaimaeahjmt eop tbg grghwtaug `pjmhb jmd gxvg,
hajkkq tbg vpolotaom oe mgy amatajtaugx `q tbg Xtjtg
Dgvjptlgmt jmd tbg Dgegmxg Dgvjptlgmt-89 Dwpami
tbg eokkoyami Hkamtom jdlamaxtpjtaom+ am pgekghtami om
bax grvgpagmhgx jx xghpgtjpq oe dgegmxg+ Vgppq motgx
tbg xaimaeahjmhg oe tbg voxtHokd Yjp vgpaod eop gx,
tj`kaxbami jm geeghtaug W-X- vjptmgpxbav yatb Pwxxaj
am tbg xghwpatq xvbgpg- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq voamt to tbg
gjpkq voxtHokd Yjp daxhwxxaomx wpiami Pwxxajx
vokahq gkatg to `gholg amtgipjtaomaxtx to jhbagug j
mgy+ xgke,pgxvghtami vkjhg am tbg yopkd opdgp-82
Tbg gjpkq+ ekwad mjtwpg oe tbg amtgpmjtaomjk gmuapom,
lgmt dwpami tbg eapxt Hkamtom jdlamaxtpjtaom pgzwapgd
jdnwxtlgmtx to adgmtaeq tbg holvkglgmtjpatagx oe W-X-
jmd Pwxxajm mjtaomjk amtgpgxtx- DOD gmijigd am pg,
vgjtgd pgdgxaimx oe Mwmm,Kwijp vpoipjlx am tbg ama,
tajk xtjigx to jdjvt atx graxtami vjttgpmx oe hoovgpj,
taom to tbg pgjkatagx oe Pwxxaj jt tbax xtjig oe atx hom,
tamwowx pguokwtaom- Tbg vjttgpm amhkwdgd tbg
jdlamaxtpjtaomx amtgpgxt am xbjvami tbg mgy Pwxxajm
iougpmlgmtx vpgegpgmhgx- Vgppq ypatgx tbjt tbg Mwmm,
Kwijp vpoipjlx ygpg kjwmhbgd ybgm tbg mgy Pwxxaj
yjx am atx gjpkq xtjtg jmd mggdgd allgdajtg jxxaxtjmhg>tbg vokatahjk `jhcdpov jmd ghomolah lotaujtaom oe
Pwxxajx kgjdgpx am tbg gjpkq voxtHokd Yjp vgpaod
ygpg+ jx yg moy cmoy+ totjkkq daeegpgmt epol tbg
ujkwgx jmd vpgegpgmhgx oe tbg Xouagt pgialg-81
Am tbg gjpkq Mwmm,Kwijp vgpaod+ tbg mjtaomx amuokugd
jkxo amtpodwhgd wmazwg+ mgy xatwjtaomx-46 DOD geeoptx
bjd to vpohggd am jhhopdjmhg yatb j tbpgg,vjptq eop,
gaim vokahq jvvpojhb amuokuami tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx+ Pwx,
xaj+ jmd Wcpjamg-4: Tbg W-X- jvvpojhb guokugd zwahckq
epol `akjtgpjk to tpakjtgpjk davkoljhq+ grtgmdami tbg
Mwmm,Kwijp jvvpojhb to dgmwhkgjpa~g Wcpjamg jmdgmijig tbg Wcpjamajmx am grtgmxaug lakatjpq,to,lakatjpq
homtjhtx- Yopcami jkomi homxtpwhtauaxt kamgx+ tbg
Hkamtom jdlamaxtpjtaom tbpowib davkoljhq jmd
vokahqljcami jttglvtgd to pgeopl Pwxxajm jmd Wcpja,
majm ujkwgx jmd vpgegpgmhgx pgijpdami tpjdataomjk jmd
komi,xtjmdami xghwpatq tbpgjtx+ jx ygkk jx to oeegp ov,
voptwmatagx eop j lopg hoovgpjtaug ewtwpg eop jkk vjp,
tahavjmtx am tbg mgy yopkd opdgp+ op jt kgjxt tbg mgy
pgiaomjk opdgp-
Pgxowphgx jmd Xwvvopt eop Pwkgx
Tbg adgj oe xvghaeah+ hoovgpjtaug eopgaim vokahagx jmd
dgegmxg vpoipjlx homtamwgd to grvjmd tbg holvkgr,
atq oe xbjvami holvkglgmtjpq mjtaomjk amtgpgxtx- Eop
grjlvkg+ ybgm mgiotajtami tbg Xtpjtgiah Jplx Pgdwh,
taom Tjkcx "XTJPT AA! Hokd Yjp jplx homtpok pgialg+
tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx bjd to gmijig tbg xtakk,eoplami Pwx,
89- @wxb jmd Xhoyhpoet+J Yopkd Tpjmxeoplgd-
82- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq+Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg+ 7:-
81- A`ad-+ 91-
46- Am xgugpjk jptahkgx+ vpolamgmt amtgpmjtaomjk pgkjtaomx xhbokjpx jpiwgd eop tbg amhpgjxgd xtj`akatq jmd xghwpatq oe voxtHokd YjpGwpovg+ yatb Wcpjamg jx j mwhkgjp ygjvomx xtjtg3 xgg Nobm N- Lgjpxbgalgp+ Tbg Hjxg eop j Wcpjamajm Mwhkgjp Dgtgppgmt+Eopgaim
Jeejapx "Xwllgp :118!3 jmd Xhott D- Xjijm jmd Cgmmgtb M- Yjkt~+ Tbg Xvpgjd oe Mwhkgjp Ygjvomx> J Dg`jtg Pgmgygd"Mgy Qopc>
Y- Y- Moptom % Holvjmq+ 0668!-
4:- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq+Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg+ 28-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
12/2252 TBG COPGJ GHOMOLAH AMXTATWTG
xajm dglohpjhq+ yatb atx mgy+ jhtaug+ jmd epjilgmtgd
Dwljjm gmuapomlgmt ljpcgdkq daeegpgmt epol tbg
apom pwkg oe tbg Xouagt Hollwmaxt Vjptq kgjdgpxbav
dwpami Hokd Yjp gpj- Tbg vjpkajlgmtjpajmx homhgpmx
j`owt tbg xtjtwx oe tbg homtamwatq oe tbg Marom,gpj
J@L Tpgjtq ygpg ewptbgp holvkahjtgd `q baxtopahjk
Pwxxajm xghwpatq homhgpmx pgjyjcgmgd `q tbg amataj,taugx eop MJTOx gjxtyjpd grvjmxaom- Jdlamaxtpjtaom
howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq geeoptx yatb tbg Pwxxajmx
homtamwgd jkomi tbg vjtb xtjptgd `q Mwmm,Kwijp to
amhkwdg vpoipjlx oe ipgjtgp holvkgratq jmd dgvtb ougp
talg-40
Am tbgap `ooc+ Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg+ Hjptgp jmd Vgppq
daxhwxx gjpkq jdlamaxtpjtaom jvvpojhbgx jmd tbgap gr,
vgpagmhgx jx DOD oeeahajkx am tbg eapxt Hkamtom jdlam,
axtpjtaom- Jx daxhwxxgd j`oug+ tbg Igopig @wxb jd,
lamaxtpjtaom jmd tbgm tbg Hkamtom jdlamaxtpjtaom+ am
xwvvoptami tbg amatajtaug oe Xgmjtop Mwmm jmd XgmjtopKwijp+ pgxvomdgd zwahckq to tbg mgy tbpgjt oe mwhkgjp,
jplgd eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx- DOD vpoipjlx+ wm,
dgp tbg jwtbopa~ami Mwmm,Kwijp kgiaxkjtaom+ jddpgxxgd
kooxg,mwcgx axxwgx to gkalamjtg mwhkgjp ygjvomx jmd
eaxxakg ljtgpajk am Wcpjamg+ Cj~jcbxtjm+ jmd @gkjpwx-48
Xvghajk vponghtx xwhb jx Vponght Xjvvbapg pglougd
ygjvomx,ipjdg vkwtomawl jmd gmpahbgd wpjmawl epol
Cj~jcbxtjm jmd amhkwdgd amtgpmjk W-X- hokkj`opjtaom
jlomi tbg DOD+ Dgvjptlgmt oe Gmgpiq+ Dgvjptlgmt
oe Xtjtg+ jmd Hgmtpjk Amtgkkaigmhg Jigmhq "HAJ!-44 J
vjttgpm oe xalakjp geeoptx tbjt amhopvopjtgd mgy lgl,
gpx amto tbg vpgegppgd yopkd opdgp oe tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx
ax jkxo guadgmt dwpami tbg xghomd Hkamtom jdlamaxtpj,
taom+ eop grjlvkg+ yatb pgxvght to Hbamj-47
Dwpami tbg xghomd Hkamtom jdlamaxtpjtaom+ Dgegmxg
Xghpgtjpq Yakkajl X- Hobgm homtamwgd tbg tpgmd to,
yjpd amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaom `wakdami oplwktakjtgpjkaxl-45 Am Hkamtom,gpj DOD vokahq dohw,
lgmtx+ xwhb jx tbg Jmmwjk Pgvoptx to tbg Vpgxadgmt
jmd Homipgxx+ tbgpg yjx j xtgjdq dpwl`gjt eop tbg
Wmatgd Xtjtgx to tjcg j kgjdami pokg am xwvvoptami am,
tgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx-49 Tbg 0666 pgvopt baibkaibtx
tbg xaimaeahjmhg oe tbg W-X- pokg am xbjvami tbg am,
tgpmjtaomjk gmuapomlgmt tbpowib lwktakjtgpjk jkkajmhgx+
tpjmxvjpgmhq+ tpwxt+ jmd homeadgmhg `wakdami jx ygkk
jx tbpowib kalatami djmigpowx lakatjpq tghbmokoiagx-42
Tbg xghtaom om djmigpx jmd tbpgjtx eohwxgx om pg,
dwhami op gkalamjtami mwhkgjp+ `aokoiahjk+ jmd hbgla,
hjk "M@H! ygjvomx- Tbg pgvopt xwvvoptx graxtami jplxhomtpok jipgglgmtx+ amhkwdami tbg W-X-,Moptb Copgjm
Jipggd Epjlgyopc3 HTP vpoipjlx yatb Pwxxaj+
Wcpjamg+ jmd Cj~jcbxtjm3 tbg Hbglahjk Ygjvomx Hom,
ugmtaom3 tbg Mwhkgjp Mom,Vpokaegpjtaom Tpgjtq3 jmd tbg
Laxxakg Tghbmokoiq Homtpok Pgialg- Tbg pgvopt jkxo
baibkaibtx tbg xaimaeahjmhg oe adgmtaeqami jmd homtpok,
kami mwhkgjp eaxxakg ljtgpajkx tbjt hjm `g wxgd eop M@H
ygjvomx jmd dgkaugpq xqxtglx-
Tbg Dgegmxg Dgvjptlgmt jkxo pgegpx to tbg
jdlamaxtpjtaomx mwhkgjp voxtwpg xtjtglgmtx jmd pg,
40- Eop grjlvkg+ dwpami tbg xghomd Hkamtom jdlamaxtpjtaom+ Xghpgtjpq oe Dgegmxg Yakkajl X- Hobgm voamtgd to tbg homtamwjtaom oe jplx
homtpok vpoipjlx+ xwhb jx tbg :112 Hkamtom,Qgktxam Loxhoy xwllat+ jmd tbg dgugkovlgmt oe j noamt W-X-,Pwxxajm Loxhoy hgmtgp eopameopljtaom xbjpami om jkkaxtah laxxakgx jmd xvjhg kjwmhb ugbahkgx- Tbg hgmtgp amhkwdgd tbg jmmowmhglgmt oe gjpkq kjwmhb dgtghtaom+gjpkq yjpmami xqxtglx+ jmd tghbmahjk vpoipjlx om o`xgpujtaom xjtgkkatgx- Tbgxg grtgmxaug vpoipjl dgugkovlgmtx pgekght tbg amhpgjxami
`gmgeatx oe hoovgpjtaug jmd holvkglgmtjpq xghwpatq vpgegpgmhgx- Xgg Yakkajl X- Hobgm+ Jmmwjk Pgvopt to tbg Vpgxadgmt jmd tbg
Homipgxx "Yjxbamitom+ D-H-> W-X- Dgvjptlgmt oe Dgegmxg+ 0666!+ 295+ yyy-dgegmxgkamc-lak/grghxgh/jdp0666/jdp0666-vde-
48- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq+Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg+ 51-
44- A`ad-+ 59-
47- Xghpgtjpq oe Dgegmxg Hobgm motgd xalakjp amtgmtaomx eop `pamiami Hbamj amto tbg amtgpmjtaomjk hollwmatq `q xggcami Hbamgxg
jdbgpgmhg to amtgpmjtaomjk xtjmdjpdx om ygjvomx vpokaegpjtaom jmd om amtgpmjtaomjk tpjdg jmd bwljm paibtx amatajtaugx jmd q amhpgjxami
Hbamjx tpjmxvjpgmhq jx ygkk jx amxtatwtami homeadgmhg,`wakdami lgjxwpgx xwhb jx lakatjpq,to,lakatjpq grhbjmigx3 xgg Hobgm+JmmwjkPgvopt to tbg Vpgxadgmt jmd tbg Homipgxx+ ::-
45- Pwiiag+Lwktakjtgpjkaxl Ljttgpx-
49- Grjlvkgx gkoy epol tbg 0666Jmmwjk Pgvopt to tbg Vpgxadgmt jmd tbg Homipgxx jpg akkwxtpjtaug oe tbg jdlamaxtpjtaomx homxaxtgmt
vokahagx epol :115 tbowib 0666-
42- Hobgm+Jmmwjk Pgvopt to tbg Vpgxadgmt jmd tbg Homipgxx+ 47-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
13/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 51
voptx- Tbg 0666 jmmwjk pgvopt glvbjxa~gx tbg alvop,
tjmhg oe W-X- mwhkgjp ygjvomx to dgtgp jiipgxxaom
tbpowib j yadg pjmig oe pgxvomxgx+ jkomi yatb tbg
j`akatq to bgdig jijamxt ewtwpg tbpgjtx- Xghpgtjpq Hobgm
jkxo pgameophgd tbg W-X- hollatlgmt to tbg xtpjtgiah
jplx homtpok pgialg jmd tbg jdlamaxtpjtaomx amtgmt to
homdwht ewptbgp jplx homtpok tjkcx yatb Pwxxaj `q`giammami j powmd oe XTJPT AAA mgiotajtaomx- Eop
grjlvkg+ tbg XTJPT AAA amatajtaug yjx jmmowmhgd je,
tgp tbg Hkamtom,Qgktxam xwllat am :119 am Bgkxamca-41
Xghpgtjpq Hobgm homtamwgd to jddpgxx W-X- xwvvopt
eop j lwktakjtgpjk+ pgiaomjk opdgp am Gwpovg- Bg xtpgxxgd
W-X- dgegmxg o`nghtaugx am Gwpovg jmd tbg xaimaeahjmhg
oe hoovgpjtaug pgkjtaomx yatb Pwxxaj+ Wcpjamg+ Hgmtpjk
jmd Gjxtgpm Gwpovg+ jmd MJTO- Tbg 0666 jmmwjk pg,
vopt voamtgd owt tbjt tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx+ Pwxxaj+ jmd
Gwpovg xbowkd jkxo yopc toigtbgp yatb jkk tbg mgy
amdgvgmdgmt xtjtgx to howmtgp tbg vpokaegpjtaom oeYLD jmd laxxakg dgkaugpq xqxtglx-76
Hobgm xamikgd owt Jxajm pgiaomjk pgkjtaomx jx ygkk- Bg
hatgd tbg alvoptjmhg oe tpjdataomjk dgegmxg pgkjtaom,
xbavx yatb Njvjm+ Jwxtpjkaj+ jmd tbg POC jx ygkk jx
gmijiglgmt yatb Hbamj- Jijam tbg xaimaeahjmhg oe tbg
Jipggd Epjlgyopc ax tpwlvgtgd- Tbg xghpgtjpq vkjhgd
xvghajk glvbjxax om tbg W-X-,Njvjm xghwpatq pgkjtaom,
xbav+ ybahb bg hjkkgd tbg kamhbvam oe W-X- xghwpatq
am Jxaj-7: Hobgmx eamjk DOD jmmwjk pgvopt eohwxgd
om ljamtjamami tpjdataomjk pgkjtaomxbavx `wt dad mot
glvbjxa~g vkjmx op vpoipjlx eop pgeoplami op tpjmx,eoplami Gwpovgjm jmd Jxajm xghwpatq jkkajmhgx-70
Moplx+ Adgmtatq+ jmd Cmoykgdig
Tbg alvoptjmhg oe tbg mggd eop `wakdami tbg moplx+
adgmtatagx+ jmd cmoykgdig eop dgugkovami amxtatwtaom,
jkkq pgkgujmt vokahq ax mot baibkaibtgd am DOD dohw,
lgmtx- Tbgpg jpg mo pgegpgmhgx am tbg 0666 jmmwjk
pgvopt to j `pojdgp pokg eop tbg DOD op tbg Wmatgd
Xtjtgx am amxtatwtaom `wakdami eop vpolotami kgijk moplx+
kgiataljtg hkjalx+ jmd vpgegpgmhgx eop voxataug amtgp,
jhtaomx jmd hbjmig- Tbg pgvopt dogx lgmtaom gjpkq
Mwmm,Kwijp `jppagpx am tgplx oe ougpholami 76 qgjpx
oe Hokd Yjp laxtpwxt yatb tbg Pwxxajmx- Am tbg Hjptgpjmd Vgppq jhhowmt+ xolg lgmtaom ax jkxo ljdg oe
Hkamtom jmd Iopg amtgpugmtaomx to dgugkov tpwxt yatb
tbg mgy iougpmlgmtx oe Pwxxaj+ Wcpjamg+ Cj~jcbxtjm+
jmd @gkjpwx-78 @wt tbg oeeahajk DOD dohwlgmtx jpg
kjpigkq xakgmt om `wakdami amxtatwtaomjk moplx+ adgmtatq+
jmd cmoykgdig-
Hoxtx jmd Homxgzwgmhgx
Tbg cgq hoxtx jmd homxgzwgmhgx oe amtgpmjtaomjk am,
xtatwtaomx jpg jkxo mot lgmtaomgd am dgtjak am DOD jm,
mwjk pgvoptx- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq do motg xolg oe tbghomxgzwgmhgx oe Mwmm,Kwijp am tgplx oe `wdigtjpq
jmd vgpeopljmhg pgxwktx- Eop amxtjmhg+ tbgq baibkaibt
$0-4 `akkaom am ewmdami jx oe lad,:112- Tbgq io om to
voamt to tbg xwhhgxx oe 46 gmiamggpami vponghtx am
Pwxxaj to `wakd xjegiwjpdx eop graxtami xtohcvakgx+ dax,
ljmtkg ygjvomx jmd laxxakgx+ jmd homugpt dgegmxg
amdwxtpq to hauakajm vwpvoxgx- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq jkxo
ypatg oe tbg xwhhgxx oe dgxtpoqami 4+266 mwhkgjp
ygjvomx+ pglouami mwhkgjp ygjvomx epol jkk mom,
Pwxxajm eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx+ jmd gkalamjtami vpo,
kaegpjtaom tbpgjtx am @gkjpwx+ Cj~jcbxtjm+ jmd Wcpjamg-
Vgppq jmd Hjptgp xtpgxx tbjt tbgq mgugp grvghtgd tbaxjxtowmdami dgipgg oe xwhhgxx jmd hpgdat Mwmm,Kwijp
amatajtaugx eop mo gjpkq voxtHokd Yjp kooxg,mwcgx
vpo`kglx-74 Am jddataom+ Hjptgp jmd Vgppq jttpa`wtg vjpt
oe tbgxg ipgjt xwhhgxxgx to tbg grtpjopdamjpq hoov,
gpjtaom amxadg tbg Yjxbamitom vokahqljcami hollw,
matq- Mgugptbgkgxx+ tbg Mwmm,Kwijp vpoipjlljtah xwh,
hgxxgx jpg mot tagd to tbg kjpigp axxwgx pgijpdami `wakd,
41- A`ad-+ 75-
76- A`ad-+ 1:6-
7:- A`ad-+ :6::-
70- Tbax kjhc oe glvbjxax ax hwpaowx holvjpgd yatb tbg dpwl`gjt yatbam tbg DOD to tpjmxeopl tbg W-X- jplgd eophgx tbpowibowt tbgvoxt,Hokd Yjp gpj+ epol tbg Hkamtom jdlamaxtpjtaom to tbg vpgxgmt Igopig Y- @wxb jdlamaxtpjtaom-
78- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq+Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg+ 95-
74- A`ad-+ 9599-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
14/2296 TBG COPGJ GHOMOLAH AMXTATWTG
ami j hollwmatq oe xbjpgd moplx+ ujkwgx+ jmd adgmta,
tagx am tgplx oe amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx+ jplx homtpok
jmd xghwpatq pgialgx+ op lwktakjtgpjk opijma~jtaomx-
Amxtatwtaomx jmd Vokahqljcami
Tbg eaetb dalgmxaom oe vokahq pgkgujmhg pgkjtgx amtgp,mjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx jmd tbg pokg oe tbg vokahqljcami
hollwmatq- Tbg mjtaomjk xghwpatq vokahqljcami hol,
lwmatq hjm `g jm ovgm,gmdgd mgtyopc- Tbg hollw,
matq am tbax hjxg amhkwdgx xvghaeah W-X- iougpmlgmt
kgiaxkjtopx+ dgvjptlgmtx+ jmd jigmhagx jx ygkk jx wma,
ugpxatagx jmd pgxgjphb amxtatwtgx jx vkjqgpx op xtjcg,
bokdgpx am howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahqljcami- Tbax
vokahqljcami hollwmatq ax mot kalatgd xokgkq to tbg
W-X- Dgegmxg Dgvjptlgmt jmd xvghajk jigmhagx am,
uokugd am Mwmm,Kwijp alvkglgmtjtaom- Jx daxhwxxgd
mgrt+ omg grjlvkg oe geeghtaug vokahq alvkglgmtjtaom
yatbam tbg yadgp vokahqljcami hollwmatq yjx tbgDODx tov xghpgt Ovgpjtaom Xjvvbapg+ homdwhtgd am
:114-
Xjvvbapg yjx tbg eapxt xvghajk ovgpjtaom alvkglgmtgd
jx vjpt oe Mwmm,Kwijp- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq xtpomikq gl,
vbjxa~g tbg xwhhgxx oe Ovgpjtaom Xjvvbapg am tbg eapxt
Hkamtom tgpl-77 Tbg ovgpjtaom pgxwktgd am tbg pgloujk
epol Cj~jcbxtjm oe 566 cakoipjlx oe baibkq gmpahbgd
wpjmawl+ op tbg gzwaujkgmt oe gmowib eaxxakg ljtgpajk
eop 56 Bapoxbalj,Mjijxjca mwhkgjp `ol`x- Tbg W-X-
iougpmlgmt vokahq hollwmatqYjxbamitom amtgp,
jigmhq vkjqgpxamhkwdgd tbg Dgvjptlgmtx oe Dg,egmxg+ Gmgpiq+ jmd Xtjtg+ jkomi yatb tbg HAJ jmd W-X-
Jap Eophg- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq pgvopt tbg xwhhgxxewk am,
tgpmjk jmd grtgpmjk hoopdamjtaom yatb tbg iougpmlgmtx
oe Pwxxaj jmd Cj~jcbxtjmjkk ljdg voxxa`kg wmdgp
tbg wl`pgkkj oe tbg :110 Mwmm,Kwijp kgiaxkjtaom jmd
alvkglgmtami vpoipjlx-
Hjptgp jmd Vgppq tpjhg tbg igmgxax oe tbg Mwmm,Kwijp
jvvpojhb to tbg xgmjtopx homhgpmx dwpami tbg :126x
Hokd Yjp qgjpx j`owt mwhkgjp jhhadgmtx-75 Xgmjtopx
Mwmm jmd Kwijp ygpg jt tbg eopgepomt oe W-X- hom,
ipgxxaomjk jhtauatagx pgijpdami gxtj`kaxbami mwhkgjp paxc
pgdwhtaom hgmtgpx- Tbgap amatajtaugx amhkwdgd jigmhagx
jmd opijma~jtaomx owtxadg oe iougpmlgmt- Gjpkq ge,
eoptx `q Xgmjtop Mwmm jmd Xgmjtop Kwijp jmd tbgap
xtjeex amuokugd yopc yatb tbamc tjmcx jmd wmaugpxa,
tagx- Hjptgpx kjtg :126x Bjpujpd vpokaegpjtaom xtwdagxom tbg Xouagt mwhkgjp jpxgmjk kgd to j xgpagx oe lggt,
amix boxtgd `q Bjpujpdx @gkegp Hgmtgp jkomi yatb
Vgppqx jeeakajtaom yatb Xtjmeopd Wmaugpxatq-79 Yopc,
xbovx amhkwdgd grvgptx epol Mgy Qopcx Hjpmgiag
Hopvopjtaom jmd Yjxbamitomx @poocamix Amxtatwtaom-
Tbax kooxgkq howvkgd momvpokaegpjtaom hollwmatq xgt
tbg xtjig eop pjaxami homhgpmx j`owt mwhkgjp jmd eax,
xakg ljtgpajk xjegiwjpdx eokkoyami tbg hokkjvxg oe tbg
Xouagt Wmaom- Tbg jxtomaxbamikq pjvad vpoipgxx oe
Mwmm,Kwijp kgiaxkjtaom+ ybahb vjxxgd yatbam mamg djqx
oe atx eapxt dpjet+ amhkwdgd Xgmjtg vjxxjig om 02 Mo,
ugl`gp :11: `q jm 25,5 uotg- Tbg Bowxg oe Pgvpg,xgmtjtaugx ugpxaom oe tbg `akk+ xwvvoptgd `q Hbjapljm
Kgx Jxvam oe tbg Bowxg Jplgd Xgpuahgx Hollattgg
ybo yjx kjtgp Vpgxadgmt Hkamtomx eapxt xghpgtjpq oe
dgegmxg+ vjxxgd om j uoahg uotg-
Tbgxg vpgkalamjpq geeoptx am `wakdami vpokaegpjtaom
cmoykgdig jmd kgiaxkjtaom ygpg grtgmdgd tbpowib tbg
:118 xbaet oe Hjptgp jmd Vgppq epol jhjdglaj to iou,
gpmlgmt xgpuahg- Hjptgp motgx tbjt to xvgjpbgjd Mwmm,
Kwijp alvkglgmtjtaom am opdgp to jxxaxt Pwxxaj am xjeg,
iwjpdami mwhkgjp xtohcvakgx pgzwapgd j ybokg mgy
opijma~jtaom-72
Bg voamtx jkxo to xtjptami `q hpjetamij xgt oe o`nghtaugx jmd adgmtaeqami oeeahajkx am vjptmgp
howmtpagx to hoopdamjtg geeoptx-
Amatajtami j mgy mjtaomjk xghwpatq vpoipjl pgzwapgd
eoplami j hoopdamjtami amtgpjigmhq ipowv jx ygkk jx
ougpholami `jppagpx to alvkglgmtjtaom- Hjptgp jmd
Vgppq io om to glvbjxa~g tbg xaimaeahjmt `jppagpx tbjt
hbjkkgmigd Mwmm,Kwijp alvkglgmtjtaom- Tbg motopa,
owxkq hwl`gpxolg Vgmtjiom jhzwaxataom xqxtgl bjd
to grtgmd to xvgmdami dokkjpx om ougpxgjx gmiamggpami
77- A`ad-+ 5752-
75- A`ad-+ 96-
79- A`ad-+ 99-
72- A`ad-+ 98-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
15/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 9:
vponghtx+ ybahb am twpm pgzwapgd xolgtbami baxtopq
bjd mgugp `geopg vgplattgd+ tbjt ax+ pwmmami W-X-
vpoipjlx yatb jmd yatbam tbg Xouagt Wmaom-71
Tbg gjpkq Mwmm,Kwijp vgpaod jkxo lgt pgxaxtjmhg am
tbg W-X- Homipgxx- Homipgxxaomjk `jppagpx amuokugd
pgugpxami j lamd,xgt epol dgegmxg ugpxwx tbg Xouagttbpgjt to xvgmdami eop Pwxxajm lakatjpq bowxami jmd
dgegmxg amdwxtpq homugpxaom to hauakajm+ hollgphajk
vwpxwatx- Iaug tbg pjvad vjhg oe Mwmm,Kwijp kgiaxkj,
taom+ alvkglgmtjtaom lomgq bjd to `g pgvpoipjllgd
epol tbg :118 dgegmxg `wdigt+ ybahb pgzwapgd lwhb
`wpgjwhpjtah yopc am jdnwxtami jvvpovpajtaomx-56 Am
jddataom+ tbg okd jplx homtpok `wpgjwhpjhq+ hgmtgpgd
am DOD jmd tbg Xtjtg Dgvjptlgmt+ bjd to xbaet epol
Hokd Yjp jplx homtpok vgpxvghtaugx jmd vjttgpmx to
mgy jvvpojhbgx-
@jppagpx jkxo graxtgd yatbam tbg mgy jmd pgkjtaugkqwmxtj`kg Pwxxaj- Eop amxtjmhg+ Hjptgp jmd Vgppq motg
tbg vpo`kglx oe hoopdamjtaom yatb tbg eoplgp Xouagt
mwhkgjp pgxgjphb jmd dgugkovlgmt jigmhq+ Lamjtol+
gxvghajkkq am pgijpd to mgy tjxcx oe daxljmtkami mwhkgjp
ygjvomx jmd tbg komi,tgpl xjegiwjpdx jmd xtopjig
oe eaxxakg ljtgpajkx-5:
Tbg ypatami am kjtgp DOD dohwlgmtx pgugjkx j lod,
gpjtaom+ op dghkamg+ am tbg dgegmxg xghpgtjpqx amataj,
taugx eop grtgmdami tbg DOD pokg jmd wakdami om gjpkq
Mwmm,Kwijp xwhhgxxgx- Eop amxtjmhg+ `q tbg talg oe
tbg 0666 jmmwjk pgvopt+ Xghpgtjpq Hobgm eohwxgd omj mjppoygp pjmig oe axxwgx yatb pgxvght to
howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq- Bg hatgd tbg alvoptjmhg
oe tbg jplgd eophgx hjvjhatq to pgxvomd to jxql,
lgtpah tbpgjtx jmd yjx ljamkq homhgpmgd yatb eaibt,
ami om jm M@H `jttkgeagkd+ yatb j ujiwg xgmtgmhg om
amhpgjxami wmxvghaeagd dokkjp jlowmtx eop amxtatwtaomx
oe howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom-50
Howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom jx howmtgp,M@H ovgpjtaomx eop
`jttkgeagkd eophgx ax j xaimaeahjmt ovgpjtaomjk hjvj`ak,
atq+ `wt jt tbg xtpjtgiah kgugk at ejkkx xbopt oe tbg Mwmm,
Kwijp o`nghtaugx oe gkalamjtami jmd xjegiwjpdami
mwhkgjp ygjvomx jmd xtohcvakgx- Tbg eohwx oe tbg
0666 dohwlgmt jmd dgegmxg vokahq ax ljamkq dapghtgd
toyjpd homtamwami tbg lodgpma~jtaom oe graxtami HokdYjp kgijhq ygjvomx xqxtglx+ op vkjteoplx+ xwhb jx
tjmcx+ bgkahovtgpx+ japhpjet hjppagpx+ xw`ljpamgx+ jmd
ngt japhpjet+ ybakg homdwhtami pgxgjphb jmd dgugkov,
lgmt eop hwttami,gdig tghbmokoiagx-58 Tbg jmmwjk pg,
vopt vpovoxgx tbg mggdx eop ygjvomx xqxtgl dgugk,
ovlgmt wxami Iwke Yjp xhgmjpaox- Tbg pgvopt jkxo
vpgxgmtx ameopljtaom om omioami lodgpma~jtaomx xwhb
jx tbg Pguokwtaom am Lakatjpq Jeejapx eop jhzwapami mgy
tghbmokoiagx jmd tbg Pguokwtaom am @wxamgxx Jeejapx
eop jdovtami tbg vpgxwlgd `gttgp `wxamgxx vpjhtahgx
oe tbg hopvopjtg xghtop- Hpatahx hbjpig tbjt tbgxg jpg
jhtwjkkq lamop jmd amxaimaeahjmt hbjmigx jmd j mop,ljk vjpt oe tbg Vgmtjiomx amtgpmjk eaibt eop dgegmxg
dokkjpx-54 Tbg guadgmhg epol oeeahajk dohwlgmtx pg,
ugjkx j doymyjpd tpgmd+ op jt kgjxt j kgugkami oee+ am
DODx glvbjxax om howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq jmd
vpoipjlx-
Eamdamix jmd Homhkwxaomx
Tbg dohwlgmtjpq guadgmhg xwiigxtx jm gjpkq vgjc am
Hkamtom,gpj howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahqljcami- Tbg gx,
xgmtajk pokg oe cgq dgvjptlgmt kgjdgpx+ xwhb jx Xghpg,
tjpq oe Dgegmxg Vgppq jmd Jxxaxtjmt Xghpgtjpq oe Dg,egmxg Hjptgp+ am amekwgmhami tbg Yjxbamitom
vokahqljcami vpohgxx ax loxt xaimaeahjmt- Jddgd
ygaibt am tgplx oe vokatahjk amatajtaug jmd kgiaxkjtaom jx
ygkk jx `wdigtjpq xwvvopt yjx vpouadgd `q grvgpa,
gmhgd+ xgmaop kgiaxkjtopx- Am tgplx oe vokahq pgkgujmhg+
xgugpjk voamtx xtjmd owt am jddataom to tbg ougpjkk jx,
xgxxlgmt oe geeghtaug kgjdgpxbav epol xgugpjk kgugkx+
71- A`ad- 94-
56- A`ad- 94-
5:- A`ad- 26
50- Hobgm+Jmmwjk Pgvopt to tbg Vpgxadgmt jmd tbg Homipgxx+ :1-
58- A`ad-+ 2-
54- Igopig H- Yakxom+ Tbax Yjp Pgjkkq Ljttgpx> Amxadg tbg Eaibt eop Dgegmxg Dokkjpx "Yjxbamitom+ D-H-> HZ Vpgxx+ 0666!-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
16/2290 TBG COPGJ GHOMOLAH AMXTATWTG
amhkwdami tbg dgegmxg xghpgtjpq+ Homipgxx+ tbamc tjmcx+
jmd alvkglgmtami `wpgjwhpjhagx+ jkomi yatb xalakjp
kgjdgpxbav kgugkx yatbam tbg eopgaim iougpmlgmtx am,
uokugd-
Mjtaomjk amtgpgxtx am tbg Mwmm,Kwijp hjxg ygpg
holvkglgmtjpq jmd ygpg grvpgxxgd hkgjpkq `q tbgiougpmlgmtjk kgjdgpx amuokugd am vokahqljcami- Tbg
ujkwgx oe homtpokkami jmd gkalamjtami mwhkgjp ygjv,
omx ygpg xggm jx holvjta`kg yatb komi,tgpl iojkx
tbjt+ am tbg Pwxxajm hjxg+ amhkwdgd pjdahjkkq tpjmxeopl,
ami atx dgegmxg voxtwpg jmd amtgpmjtaomjk davkoljhq-
Tbgpg ygpg xaimaeahjmt amugxtlgmtx oe talg jmd lomgq
to hbjmig vpgegpgmhgx eop jm amxtatwtaomjk jvvpojhb to
jktgpami pgkjtaomx q lgjmx oe j pgialg hbjmig am jplx
homtpok jmd am tbg ewmdjlgmtjk pokgx oe mwhkgjp ygjv,
omx am j mgy+ voxtHokd Yjp opdgp- Tbg pgljamami
xwvgpvoygp+ op am amxtatwtaomjk tgplx tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx
jx bgiglom+ jxxwpgd atx xwvvopt eop tbax mgy opdgp-Jddataomjk pgxowphgx ygpg hollattgd to pgameophg tbg
gxxgmtajk vpamhavkgx oe tbg mgy opdgp to gkalamjtg
mwhkgjp ygjvomx epol mom,Pwxxajm eoplgp Xouagt
pgvw`kahx- Alvoptjmtkq+ tbg eoplgp pgvw`kahx ygpg
gmijigd am tbg vpohgxx oe xbjpami tbg `wpdgmx oe ho,
opdamjtami tbg vokahq jmd atx alvkglgmtjtaom-
Tbg kjpigkq `akjtgpjk pgkjtaomxbav `gtyggm tbg Wmatgd
Xtjtgx jmd tbg mgykq glgpiami Pwxxaj xokadaeagd tbg
moplx+ adgmtatq+ jmd cmoykgdig eop amxtatwtaomjka~ami
tbg Mwmm,Kwijp howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahagx- Apoma,
hjkkq+ tbg komi Hokd Yjp baxtopq oe mwhkgjp lappop,aljiami jmd jplx homtpok homtpa`wtgd to hollom
epjlgx oe pgegpgmhg pgijpdami tbg vpohgxx jmd xw`,
xtjmhg eop homdwhtami amtgpxtjtg mgiotajtaomx om
mwhkgjp ygjvomx axxwgx- Hollom vpgegpgmhgx ygpg
pgugjkgd tbpowib amtgpjhtaomx tbjt amhkwdgd tbg eoplgp
Xouagt pgvw`kahx- Guokuami moplx pgijpdami tbg
gkalamjtaom oe mwhkgjp ygjvomx jmd xolg eaxxakg lj,
tgpajkx glvoygpgd davkoljtx jmd dgegmxg oeeahajkx to
holvkgtg howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahqljcami am jhhop,
djmhg yatb xbjpgd jmd kgiataljtg hkjalx oe vokahq pgk,
gujmhg- Am tbg Mwmm,Kwijp hjxg+ tbg glgpigmhg oe
xbjpgd moplx+ adgmtatq+ jmd cmoykgdig am tbg yam,doy oe ovvoptwmatq eokkoyami tbg gmd oe tbg Hokd Yjp
glvoygpgd vokahqljcgpx epol tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx+
Pwxxaj+ jmd tbg eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx to homdwht
pguokwtaomjpq howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahagx-
Tbg hoxtx jmd homxgzwgmhgx oe jhtaom tbpowib tbg
HTP vpoipjlx jkxo xtj`aka~gd grvghtjtaomx eop noamt
hoopdamjtaom- Ewmdami tbpowib tbg homipgxxaomjk `wd,
igt vpohgxx+ pgameophgd tbpowib DODx baibkq pgiw,
kjtgd vkjmmami+ vpoipjllami+ jmd `wdigtami xqxtgl+
vpouadgd j dgipgg oe xtj`akatq jmd tpjmxvjpgmhq eop
alvkglgmtami vpoipjlx jx ygkk jx gxtj`kaxbgd lghbj,
maxlx eop gmijigd homipgxxaomjk ougpxaibt- Am gx,
xgmhg+ tbg vpoipjlljtah vpohgxxgx oe tbg W-X- Hom,ipgxx jmd `wpgjwhpjhq eop alvkglgmtami Mwmm,Kwijp
vpoipjlx xgpugd tbg jipggd jdlamaxtpjtaom vwpvoxgx
am uaxa`kg yjqx-
Tbg Mwmm,Kwijp hjxg jkxo vpouadgx guadgmhg oe tbg
xaimaeahjmhg oe tbg mgtyopc jxvghtx oe tbg
howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahqljcami hollwmatq- Tbg
ewmhtaomjk pokg oe j yadg ujpagtq oe xvghajka~gd jigm,
hagx am tbg gjpkq Mwmm,Kwijp vgpaod+ jkk eohwxgd am j
hollom dapghtaom om hkgjp iojkx+ xgpugd jx j eophami
ewmhtaom eop tbg vokahqljcami hollwmatq- Tbg
ougpjphbami jmd hkgjp vpoipjl iojkx pgijpdami gkala,mjtami mwhkgjp ygjvomx am eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx jt
j wmazwg talg am baxtopq xgpugd jx j xtpomi eowmdjtaom
eop howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq geeoptx-
Omg jpgj ybgpg Mwmm,Kwijp pgugjkx j xboptholami
am amxtatwtaom `wakdami ax jx jm gjpkq xwhhgxxewk ammo,
ujtaom+ op vakot tgxt+ om ybahb to `wakd jmd grvjmd
igoipjvbahjkkq `gqomd Pwxxaj jmd tbg eoplgp Xouagt
pgvw`kahx to otbgp jpgjx oe vpokaegpjtaom homhgpm+ xwhb
jx Xowtb Jxaj "Amdaj jmd Vjcaxtjm!+ Moptbgjxt Jxaj
"Moptb Copgj!+ jmd tbg Laddkg Gjxt "Apjz jmd Apjm!-
Am otbgp yopdx+ tbg gjpkq Mwmm,Kwijp xwhhgxxgx ygpgmot pgvkahjtgd am otbgp jpgjx oe vpokaegpjtaom homhgpm-
Jddataomjk amxaibtx amto tbg daeeahwktagx oe amxtatwtaom
wakdami jpg pgugjkgd am grjlamami tbg mjtwpg jmd xhovg
oe ybjt tbgopaxtx hjkk tbg amxtpwlgmtjk pgkgujmhg oe
amxtatwtaomx- Tbg baib hoxtx oe dgugkovami geeghtaug
jmd geeahagmt amxtatwtaomx to xgpug jx jm amxtpwlgmt oe
xtjtg vokahq hjm `g xggm am tbg holvkgratagx am tbg
eowp dalgmxaomx eop jxxgxxami amxtpwlgmtjk pgkgujmhg>
amhgmtaug xtpwhtwpgx+ lomatopami jmd gmeophglgmt vpo,
hgxxgx+ hjkhwkjtaomx oe ewtwpg `gmgeatx+ jmd ejhakatjt,
ami `jpijamami-
Amhgmtaug Xtpwhtwpgx
W-X- amhgmtaugx eop HTP vpoipjlx ygpg ejapkq o`ua,
owx- Tbg talami oe tbg Mwmm,Kwijp amatajtaugx yjx
pgkjtgd dapghtkq to j wmazwg ovvoptwmatq jt tbg gmd oe
tbg Hokd Yjp to gkalamjtg djmigpowx vpokaegpjtaom
tbpgjtx- Tbg ygjcmgxxgx oe Xouagt xjegiwjpdx jmd
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
17/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 98
xtohcvakg xghwpatq ygpg jkpgjdq cmoym am tbg dgegmxg
grvgpt hollwmatq jx j pgxwkt oe tbg :126x Bjpujpd
@gkegp Hgmtgp xtwdagx- Jktbowib j mwl`gp oe amtgpmj,
taomjk pgkjtaomx xhbokjpx dg`jtgd tbg amhpgjxgd xtj`ak,
atq oe lwktavkg mwhkgjp voygpx+ amhkwdami Wcpjamg jmd
otbgpx+ jx j bgdig jijamxt ewtwpg Pwxxajm jiipgxxaom+57
homugmtaomjk yaxdol am tbg vokahq hollwmatq hoj,kgxhgd jpowmd tbg adgj oe vpouadami amhgmtaugx to gkala,
mjtg mwhkgjp ygjvomx tbpgjtx am jm wmhgptjam voxt
Hokd Yjp gmuapomlgmt- Tbg W-X- jmd Pwxxajm dg`jtgx
ougp Mwmm,Kwijp amhkwdgd hjkhwkjtaomx oe tbg `gm,
geatx jmd hoxtx oe j mgy+ ammoujtaug jvvpojhb-
Hjptgp jmd Vgppq ypatg oe tbg baib tpjmxjhtaom hoxtx
oe gjpkq Mwmm,Kwijp mgiotajtaomx-55 Tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx
yjx ljamkq amtgpgxtgd am daxljmtkami Xouagt laxxakgx
jx j yjq oe xgpuami W-X- mjtaomjk xghwpatq amtgpgxtx-
Pwxxaj jmd tbg eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx ygpg amtgp,
gxtgd am xohajk jxxaxtjmhg to homugpt lakatjpq eophgx+xhagmtaxtx+ jmd tbgap ujxt lakatjpq,amdwxtpajk holvkgr
to hauakajm+ hollgphajk wxgx- Amhgmtaugx ygpg jkxo
alvoptjmt eop hbjptami j ewtwpg dapghtaom eop Mwmm,
Kwijp to amhkwdg eaxxakg ljtgpajkx jx ygkk jx graxtami
laxxakgx jmd `ol`x- Am tbax xgmxg+ amxtatwtaom `wakdami
amhkwdgx alvpouami tbg amhgmtaugx eop kacgkq hoovgpj,
taom jx ygkk jx eop vpgugmtami kjtgp dgeghtopx ybo
yowkd xtakk voxxgxx ljtgpajkx wxgewk eop xo,hjkkgd daptq
`ol`x jx ygkk jx mwhkgjp lgphbjmdaxg eop tbg tgppop,
axt `kjhc ljpcgt- Tbwx+ amxtatwtaom `wakdami amatajtgd
tbpowib Mwmm,Kwijp vpouadgx amhgmtaugx eop homtamw,
ami to gmijig Pwxxaj jmd tbg eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahxam jm omioami vpohgxx eop adgjx xwhb jx eoplami am,
tgpmjtaomjk eaxxakg ljtgpajk pgvoxatopagx yatb tbg wxg oe
ewmdx epol jm amtgpmjtaomjk homxoptawl to ljmjig tbg
iko`jk xtohcvakg eop vgjhgewk vwpvoxgx jmd vpodwhami
mom,ygjvomx,ipjdg mwhkgjp pgjhtop ewgk-59
Amhgmtaug xtpwhtwpgx am tbg Mwmm,Kwijp hjxg jhtwjkkq
amuokugd j yadgp pjmig oe ovtaomx tbjm yjx uaxa`kg
tbpowib tbg kgmx oe tpjdataomjk jplx homtpok mgiotaj,
taomx- Am tbg hjxg oe Wcpjamg+ j yadg,jmikg vgpxvgh,taug pgugjkx tbpgg xgvjpjtg xgtx oe amhgmtaugx-52 Tbg
eapxt kgugk amhkwdgd tpakjtgpjk davkoljhq homdwhtgd `q
tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx+ Pwxxaj+ jmd Wcpjamg- Tbgxg mgio,
tajtaomx eohwxgd om ghomolah amhgmtaugx eop dgegmxg
homugpxaomx+ ljpcgt pgeoplx+ jmd ghomolah dgugk,
ovlgmt- Jt j xghomd kgugk+ amhgmtaugx ygpg mghgxxjpq
to lggt Wcpjamgx xghwpatq homhgpmx- W-X-+ Gwpovgjm+
jmd Pwxxajm pgkjtaomx ygpg jkk amuokugd am tbg pgxwkt,
ami dgegmxg vpoipjlx eop lakatjpq,to,lakatjpq tpjamami
eop Wcpjamajm jmd otbgp Gjxtgpm Gwpovgjm eophgx+
MJTO Vjptmgpxbav eop Vgjhg vpoipjlx+ jmd gmxwami
vpoipjlx eop MJTO grvjmxaom-51
Tbg tbapd vaghg am,hkwdgd tbg Mwmm,Kwijp dgmwhkgjpa~jtaom vpoipjl-
Lomatopami jmd Gmeophglgmt Vpohgxxgx
Lomatopami jmd gmeophglgmt lghbjmaxlx eop amxtatw,
taom `wakdami amhkwdg jxvghtx oe amtpjxtjtg jmd amtgp,
xtjtg pgkjtaomx jx ygkk jx amtgpmjtaomjk pgkjtaomx- Eop
amxtjmhg+ am tbg Mwmm,Kwijp hjxg+ gjpkq xwvvopt yjx
kjhcami epol Pwxxajx Lamjtol-96 Om tbg W-X- xadg+
graxtami Hokd Yjp jigmhagx ygpg pgopijma~ami jx ygkk
jx eoplami mgy opijma~jtaomxeop grjlvkg+ tbg pg,
opijma~jtaom jmd mgy laxxaomx jxxaimgd am tbg tpjmxa,taom epol tbg W-X- Dgegmxg Mwhkgjp Jigmhq to tbg
Dgegmxg Tbpgjt Pgdwhtaom Jigmhq "DTPJ!- Opijma,
~jtaomjk pgeoplx amhkwdgd tbg mgykq hbjptgpgd Om,
57- Xgg Nobm N- Lgjpxbgalgp+ Tbg Hjxg eop j Wcpjamajm Mwhkgjp Dgtgppgmt+ jmd Xjijm jmd Yjkt~+ Tbg Xvpgjd oe Mwhkgjp Ygjvomx+
eop amxtjmhg-
55- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq+Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg+ 98-
59- A`ad-+ 26-
52- A`ad-+ 28-
51- Ljpq`gtb Vgtgpxom Wkpahb+ Dglohpjta~ami Hollwmaxt Lakatjpagx> Tbg Hjxgx oe tbg H~ghb jmd Pwxxajm Jplgd Eophgx "Jmm
Jp`op> Wmaugpxatq oe Lahbaijm Vpgxx+ :111!-
96- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq+Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg+ 26-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
18/2294 TBG COPGJ GHOMOLAH AMXTATWTG
Xatg Amxvghtaom Jigmhq+ ybahb yjx eowmdgd to xwv,
vopt gjpkq voxtHokd Yjp howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom amataj,
taugx-9:
Am holvjpaxom+ tbg kjtgp+ ejakgd Moptb Copgjm Jipggd
Epjlgyopc pgkagd om tbg AJGJ eop lomatopami jmd
gmeophglgmt- Kjtgp+ am 0666+ tbg kjxt jmmwjk pgvoptaxxwgd `q Xghpgtjpq oe Dgegmxg Hobgm voamtgd owt
tbg xaimaeahjmhg oe tbg Jipggd Epjlgyopc epgg~ami
Moptb Copgjm mwhkgjp ejhakatagx jt Qomi`qom jmd
Tjghbom wmdgp AJGJ amxvghtaomx-90 Tbg pgxwktami hok,
kjvxg oe tbg Moptb Copgjm amtgpmjtaomjk lomatopami jmd
gmeophglgmt jijam vpouadgx j homtpjxt yatb tbg ge,
eghtaug lomatopami jmd gmeophglgmt lghbjmaxlx oe
tbg Mwmm,Kwijp vpoipjlx yatb amhkwdgd boxt jigm,
hagx xwhb jx Lamjtol jmd tbg DTPJ gmijigd dapghtkq-
Am holvjpami tbgxg tyo hjxgx+ tbg guadgmhg to djtg
xwiigxtx tbg hpatahjk alvoptjmhg oe boxt howmtpq am,
uokuglgmt am jhtaugkq xwvvoptami lomatopami jmd gm,eophglgmt jppjmiglgmtx-98
Hjkhwkjtaom oe Ewtwpg @gmgeatx
Tbg vbpjxg kgmitbgmami tbg xbjdoy oe tbg ewtwpg
voptpjqx tbg alvoptjmt vgphgvtaom oe amxtatwtaomjk jp,
pjmiglgmtx jx gmbjmhami tbg vpoxvghtx oe ewtwpg `gm,
geatx jmd hoxtx-94 Am otbgp yopdx+ tbg votgmtajk eop
ewtwpg vjqoeex kgmdx xwvvopt eop amxtatwtaom `wakdami-
Ypatami am :111+ Hjptgp jmd Vgppq glvbjxa~g tbg xwh,
hgxxgx oe Mwmm,Kwijp am tbg gjpkq voxtHokd Yjp
vgpaod-97
Am jddataom+ tbgq vponght eopyjpd to baib,
kaibt homtamwami howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom yopc- Am vjptahw,
kjp+ tbgq motg tbjt Pwxxaj xtakk voxxgxxgx gmowib vkw,
tomawl jmd baibkq gmpahbgd wpjmawl to vpodwhg `g,
tyggm 07+666 jmd 26+666 mwhkgjp ygjvomx- Tbgpg,
eopg+ tbgq vpovoxg pgamugmtami Mwmm,Kwijp yatb gr,
vjmdami vpoipjl `wdigtx yatb ipgjtgp kjtatwdg eop
mwhkgjp jwdatx jmd amxvghtaomx jmd j mgy jplx hom,tpok pgialg- Tbg hjkk ax eop jm grvjmxaom oe Mwmm,
Kwijp eop xjegiwjpdami eaxxakg ljtgpajkx- Tbg amatajtaug
am grvjmdami HTP vpoipjl vpokaegpjtaom pgialgx ax
ghbogd am pghgmt yopc `q tbg Hjpmgiag Eowmdjtaom
jmd jijam `q Jkkaxom oe Bjpujpdx @gkegp Hgmtgp-95
Ejhakatjtami @jpijamami
Tbg eamjk dalgmxaom eop jxxgxxami tbg amxtpwlgmtjk
pgkgujmhg oe amtgpmjtaomjk amxtatwtaomx homhgpmx ejhaka,
tjtami `jpijamami- Ejhakatjtaom amhkwdgx gxtj`kaxbami
pwkgx+ vpohgdwpgx+ vpamhavkgx+ jmd vpghgdgmtx jx ygkkjx hpgjtami baib hoxtx eop mo jipgglgmt- Tbg grtgm,
xaug mjtwpg oe tbg gaibt holvomgmtx hatgd eop xwh,
hgxxewk mgiotajtaomx pgugjkx tbg alvoptjmhg oe amxtatw,
taomx jmd pgialgx+ jkomi yatb xwvvoptami opijma~j,
taomx+ eop geeghtaug vokahqljcami jmd alvkglgmtjtaom-
Tbg gaibt holvomgmtx dpjym epol tbg katgpjtwpg om
`jpijamami jmd mgiotajtaomx holvpaxg ":! pwkgx+ "0!
ameopljtaom+ "8! xtjmdjpdx+ "4! ameopljtaom j`owt hol,
vkajmhg+ "7! hpgda`kg vgmjktagx+ "5! gmeophgj`kg pwkgx+
"9! hoovgpjtaom tbpowib ameopljtaom xbjpami+ jmd "2!
kalatami tbg mwl`gp oe vjptahavjmtx-
9:- Hbpaxtajm @pjblxtgdt+Dgegmxgx Mwhkgjp Jigmhq+ :149:119"Yjxbamitom+ D-H-> W-X- Dgvjptlgmt oe Dgegmxg+ Dgegmxg Tbpgjt
Pgdwhtaom Jigmhq+ 0660!-
90- Hobgm+Jmmwjk Pgvopt to tbg Vpgxadgmt jmd tbg Homipgxx+ ::-
98- Eop j holvjpaxom oe daeeahwktagx am jplx homtpok amxvghtaom+ lomatopami+ jmd ugpaeahjtaom ybgm tbg boxt howmtpq pgewxgx to
hoovgpjtg+ xgg pghgmt eapxtbjmd jhhowmtx `q tbg grghwtaug hbjapljm oe tbg WM Xvghajk Hollaxxaom "WMXHOL! om Apjz+ Pahbjpd
@wtkgp+ Tbg Ipgjtgxt Tbpgjt> Apjz+ Ygjvomx oe Ljxx Dgxtpwhtaom+ jmd tbg Ipoyami Hpaxax oe Iko`jk Xghwpatq "Mgy Qopc> Vw`kah
Jeejapx+ 0666!3 jmd `q tbg grghwtaug hbjapljm oe tbg WM Lomatopami+ Ugpaeahjtaom+ jmd Amxvghtaom Hollaxxaom "WMLOUAH!+ Bjmx
@kar+Daxjplami Apjz "Mgy Qopc> Vjmtbgom @oocx+ 0664!-
94- J daxhwxxaom oe tbg homhgvt xbjdoy oe tbg ewtwpg ax eowmd am Njlgx D- Egjpom+ @jpijamami+ Gmeophglgmt jmd Amtgpmjtaomjk
Hoovgpjtaom+Amtgpmjtaomjk Opijma~jtaom 70+ mo- 0 ":112!> 051867-
97- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq+Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg+ 9991-
95- Igopig Vgpcouahb+ Noxgvb Hapamhaomg+ Poxg Iottglogkkgp+ Nom @- Yokextbjk+ jmd Ngxxahj T- Ljtbgyx+ Wmaugpxjk Holvkajmhg> J
Xtpjtgiq eop Mwhkgjp Xghwpatq "Yjxbamitom+ D-H-> Hjpmgiag Gmdoylgmt eop Amtgpmjtaomjk Vgjhg+ 0664!3 Jkkaxom+Mwhkgjp Tgppopaxl-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
19/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 97
Am tbg Mwmm,Kwijp hjxg+ ljcami tbg HTP geeghtaug
vokahq amxtpwlgmtx pgzwapgd grtgmxaug mgiotajtaomx eop
pwkgx to xtj`aka~g grvghtjtaomx- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq voamt
owt tbjt ljmjiami grvghtjtaomx amhkwdgd lopg vkjq,
gpx tbjm tbg gmijigd amtgpmjtaomjk mgiotajtopx- Eop
grjlvkg+ om tbg W-X- xadg tbgpg ygpg grvghtjtaomx
epol tbg Homipgxx tbjt tpjdataomjk+ Hokd Yjp xghwpatqhomhgpmx yowkd g ougpholg- Tbg mgy Pwxxajm Dwlj
jkxo bjd to `g cgvt om `ojpd- Xalakjpkq+ am tbg Jipggd
Epjlgyopc mgiotajtaomx+ Jl`jxxjdop Po`gpt Ijkkwhha
baibkaibtgd tbg hpatahjk mjtwpg oe bax mgiotajtami tgjlx
kajaxom yatb amekwgmtajk xgmjtopx jmd lgl`gpx oe Hom,
ipgxx-99
Tbg xaimjkami oe ameopljtaom ax jkxo hatgd jx alvop,
tjmt `q tbg Mwmm,Kwijp mgiotajtopx- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq
voamt owt tbjt at tooc jm oeeahajk Vgmtjiom amtgpmjk xtwdq+
tbg :114Mwhkgjp Voxtwpg Pguagy+ to hkgjpkq jmmowmhg
j mgy vbjxg oe jplx homtpok tbjt yjx ewmdjlgm,tjkkq daeegpgmt epol tbg Hokg Yjp `jkjmhg oe tgppop-92
Tbg Mwhkgjp Voxtwpg Pguagy yjx lgjmt jx j hkgjp
xaimjk to vkjqgpx dolgxtahjkkq jmd amtgpmjtaomjkkq tbjt
tbg Hokd Yjp yjx ougp jmd tbjt mwhkgjp ygjvomx
yowkd vkjq j xljkkgp pokg am W-X- dgegmxg vkjmmami-
Tbax mgy jvvpojhb amhkwdgd hjkkx eop dpjljtah hwtx
am tbg W-X- xtpjtgiah jpxgmjk tbjt yowkd dpaug doym
tbg totjk mwl`gp oe xtpjtgiah ygjvomx eop homxadgpjtaom
am omioami atgpjtaomx oe xtpjtgiah jplx pgdwhtaom tjkcx-
Tyo otbgp ejhtopx am tbg Mwmm,Kwijp jpijamami xtjmd
owt- Tpjdataomjk Hokd Yjp homhgpmx j`owt xghwpatq jmdxghpghq bjd to `g ougpholg- Ameopljtaom j`owt hol,
vkajmhg jppjmiglgmtx yjx hpwhajk eop `wakdami tpwxt
jmd homeadgmhg eop homtamwami tbg vpoipjl- Am tbax
pgxvght+ Hjptgp jmd Vgppq glvbjxa~g tbg xaimaeahjmhg
oe lwtwjk ameopljtaom `gtyggm tbg Wmatgd Xtjtgx jmd
Pwxxaj pgijpdami tbg tghbmahjk alvkglgmtjtaom oe tbg
dgjkgptami jmd dgtjpigtami oe xtpjtgiah laxxakgx-91 Tbg
holvkgratq jmd baib dgipgg oe tpjmxvjpgmhq mghgx,
xjpq amxwpgd tbjt gjhb xadg bjd to xtgv wv to mgy
hbjkkgmigx eop homtamwami to xbjvg j mgy voxtHokd
Yjp pgkjtaomxbav-
Am j xalakjp ljmmgp+ tbg jhtauatagx pgzwapgd eop tbg xwh,
hgxx oe Ovgpjtaom Xjvvbapg jkxo homtpa`wtgd to koy,
gpami tbg `jppagpx to ijamami ameopljtaom j`owt hol,
vkajmhg jx ygkk jx amhpgjxami hoovgpjtaom `q amhpgjx,
ami ameopljtaom ekoyx- Tbg hoovgpjtaug jdujmtjigx
oe ameopljtaom xbjpami kgd to j hjxhjdami geeght eop
jddataomjk Mwmm,Kwijp vpoipjl amatajtaugx- Xjvvbapgyjx eokkoygd `q tbg Pwxxajm daxljmtkami oe XX,:2
amtgphomtamgmtjk `jkkaxtah laxxakgx- Tbgxg xghwpatq ama,
tajtaugx ygpg tbgm holvkglgmtgd q lgdahjk dajimoxtah
vpoipjlx eop hjmhgp tgxtx am jmd jpowmd eoplgp Xo,
uagt mwhkgjp ejhakatagx3 `q pgxgjphb ipjmtx eop Pwxxajm+
Cj~jcb+ jmd Wcpjamajm xhagmtaxtx3 jmd `q dgegmxg am,
dwxtpq homugpxaomx to hollgphajk vwpxwatx-
Tbg zwgxtaom pgljamx> Dogx tbg guadgmhg vpgxgmtgd
am tbax vjvgp xwiigxt tbjt Mwmm,Kwijp amatajtaugx bjug
tbg votgmtajk to xgpug jx j holvjpj`kg hjxg xtwdq eop
tbamcami j`owt dgugkovami j Moptbgjxt Jxajm xghwpatqpgialg? Tbax vjvgp eohwxgd om tbg xtwdq oe tbg Hkamtom
jdlamaxtpjtaomx Mwmm,Kwijp howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom
vokahq amatajtaugx eop pgdwhami tbg tbpgjtx oe kooxg mwcgx
am Pwxxaj jmd tbg eoplgp Xouagt pgvw`kahx- Tbg Pwx,
xajm hjxg+ jx iwadgd `q amxtatwtaomjk tbgopq+ grjlamgd
W-X- jmd+ am vjptahwkjp+ tbg W-X- Dgegmxg Dgvjptlgmtx
kgjdgpxbav geeoptx am howmtgpami tbg vpokaegpjtaom oe
mwhkgjp YLD epol :110 to 0666- Tbax vjvgpx eamd,
amix xwiigxt tbg xaimaeahjmhg jmd amekwgmhg oe amxtatw,
taom, jmd opijma~jtaom,`wakdami jvvpojhbgx eop geegh,
taug howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahqljcami- Oe howpxg+
jdjvtami tbg Mwmm,Kwijp jvvpojhb eop Moptbgjxt Jxajpgzwapgx jddataomjk xtwdq jmd jmjkqxax- Hgptjamkq+ dg,
ugkovami j epjlgyopc eop xqmtbgxa~ami holvgtataug
xtpjtgiagx ugpxwx j xtw``opm Moptb Copgjm pgialg jmd
hoovgpjtaug xtpjtgiagx eop vpolotami j hollom
howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq eop gmbjmhami W-X-+ Hba,
mgxg+ Njvjmgxg+ POC+ jmd Pwxxajm hokkghtaug xghwpatq
pgljamx j hbjkkgmig- Lopg xtwdq ax mggdgd oe tbg op,
ijma~jtaomjk jmd jigmhq lghbjmaxlx mghgxxjpq jmd
xweeahagmt eop dgugkovami jm amxtatwtaomjk jvvpojhb
xwatj`kg eop Moptbgjxt Jxajm xghwpatq-
99- Nogk X- Yat+ Djmagk @- Vomgljm+ jmd Po`gpt K- Ijkkwhha+ Ioami Hpatahjk> Tbg Eapxt Moptb Copgjm Mwhkgjp Hpaxax "Yjxbamitom+D-H-> @poocamix Amxtatwtaom Vpgxx+ 0664!-
92- Hjptgp jmd Vgppq+Vpgugmtaug Dgegmxg+ 27-
91- A`ad-+ 22-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
20/2295 TBG COPGJ GHOMOLAH AMXTATWTG
Voxtxhpavt
Vjtbx eop Ewptbgp Pgxgjphb> Iougpmlgmt
jmd Opijma~jtaomjk Vgpeopljmhg
Pghgmt pgxgjphb om iougpmlgmt vgpeopljmhg jx dg,
ugkovgd am tbg eagkd oe vw`kah jdlamaxtpjtaom dgxgpugx
jddataomjk jttgmtaom `q amtgpmjtaomjk pgkjtaomx jmd xg,hwpatq xtwdagx xhbokjpx- Tbg tagx jlomi grghwtaug kgjd,
gpxbav+ vokahq geeghtaugmgxx+ jmd iougpmlgmt vgpeop,
ljmhg jpg tbg xw`nght oe homtamwami vw`kah ljmjig,
lgmt pgxgjphb- Eop amxtjmhg+ Vjtpahaj Y- Amipjbjl
jmd bgp hokkgjiwgx oeegp j vgpeopljmhg epjlgyopc
jmd eamdx `ai kgxxomx xwhb jx ljmjiglgmt ljt,
tgpx jmd geeghtaug kgjdgpxbav ax uatjk-26 Amipjbjl
jmd hokkgjiwgx baibkaibt vgpeopljmhg ljmjiglgmt jt
tbg egdgpjk+ xtjtg+ jmd kohjk kgugkx3 jmd tbg `oocx am,
xaibtx oeegp j xalakjp eohwx om vokahq kgjdgpxbav jx at
xtwdagx xgmaop grghwtaugx am vw`kah opijma~jtaomx yopc,
ami jx vokahq ljcgpx+ alvkglgmtgpx+ amtgipjtopx+ jmdpgxwktx ljmjigpxop ybjt Amipjbjl gt jk- tgpl
ipowmdgd kgjdgpxbav+2: tbjt ax+ tbg xgmaop op xtpjtg,
iah kgjdgpx pokgx am hbjptami tbg dapghtaom jmd dgipgg
oe amekwgmhg eop alvkglgmtami geeghtaug vw`kah vokahq
yatbam jmd jhpoxx iougpmlgmt opijma~jtaomx- Grghw,
taug pgxvomxa`akatagx amhkwdg kgjdgpx pokgx am hoopda,
mjtami ljmjiglgmt geeoptx to xwvvopt j uaxaom eop
jhbaguami iougpmlgmt laxxaomx+ iojkx+ jmd vgpeop,
ljmhg o`nghtaugx- Amipjbjlx vw`kah ljmjiglgmt
pgxgjphb baibkaibtx tbg pgkgujmhg oe xtpjtgiah kgjdgp,
xbav jmd ljmjiglgmt eop hoopdamjtami holvkgr jd,
lamaxtpjtaug xqxtglx jhpoxx jigmhagx jmd yatbam iou,gpmlgmt+ ybahb tbgap grtgmxaug eamdamix xwiigxt ax
hkgjp am tbgap xtwdq oe W-X- iougpmlgmt opijma~j,
taomx-20
Kgt lg homhkwdg `q oeegpami j xwiigxtaom eop ewtwpg
pgxgjphb mggdx jmd jm jvvpojhb eop xtwdqami
howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahqljcami- Am xbopt+ ewptbgp
pgxgjphb ax mggdgd to jmjkq~g grghwtaug jmd jigmhq
vgpeopljmhg am vwpxwat oe jdlamaxtpjtaom
howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq o`nghtaugx am `otb tbg hom,
tgrtx oe W-X- jigmhagx jmd amtgpmjtaomjk opijma~jtaomx-
Tbg kgjdgpxbav pokgx oe vw`kah grghwtaugx xwhb jx tbg
xghpgtjpagx oe dgegmxg jx amtgipjtopx eop iougpmlgmt
vokahq dgugkovlgmt jmd alvkglgmtjtaom xbowkd `g
grjlamgd am tgplx oe wtaka~ami DODx ljmjiglgmt
hjvjhatq eop amtgipjtami ujpaowx W-X- jmd amtgpmjtaomjk
jigmhagx am jhbaguami tbg jdlamaxtpjtaomx vokahq pg,
xwktx eop howmtgpami YLD vpokaegpjtaom am Moptb Co,
pgj+ Pwxxaj+ Apjm+ jmd gkxgybgpg- Jijam+ tbg amtgipjt,ami pokgx oe vw`kah grghwtaugx grtgmd jhpoxx W-X- iou,
gpmlgmt jigmhagx jx ygkk jx amtgpmjtaomjk opijma~j,
taomx-
Eop grjlvkg+ tbg talg ax paibt eop j dgtjakgd hjxg xtwdq
oe Hkamtom,gpj howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq yatb pgxvght
to Apjz- Jm Apjz YLD hjxg pgzwapgx grjlamami tbg
pgkjtaomxbav oe W-X- geeoptx jkomi yatb tbg pokgx jmd
ewmhtaomx oe tbg WM jmd atx opijma~jtaom eop mwhkgjp
ljttgpx+ tbg AJGJ- Gxtj`kaxbami j po`wxt Apjz hjxg
xtwdq mjppjtaug xbowkd vpohggd jkomi tbpgg kamgx- Eapxt+
am gxtj`kaxbami tbg oeeahajk W-X- vokahq jx at guokugddwpami tbg :116x+ tbg jmjkqxax xbowkd tpjhg vokahq
dgugkovlgmt epol iougpmlgmt dohwlgmtx+ amhkwdami
tbg Hkamtom mjtaomjk xghwpatq jmd mjtaomjk lakatjpq xtpjt,
giagx+ ujpaowx axxwgx oeJmmwjk Pgvopt oe tbg Xghpg,
tjpq oe Dgegmxg to tbg Vpgxadgmt jmd tbg Homipgxx+
jmd amtgpmjk jdlamaxtpjtaom YLD xtpjtgiq jmd vokahq
pguagyx-
J xghomd kamg oe amzwapq xbowkd eokkoy tbg mjppjtaugx
epol tbg vgpxvghtaug oe WM vpokaegpjtaom vokahqljcami-
WM Xghwpatq Howmhak pgxokwtaomx epol tbg gmd oe tbg
Iwke Yjp am :11: tbpowib 0660 jmd tbg xtjpt oe tbgyjp am Apjz vpouadg ovgm,xowphg dohwlgmtx tbjt xbgd
kaibt om tbg jkaimlgmt op laxjkaimlgmt oe W-X- jmd
WM vokahq- Am jddataom+ vw`kaxbgd `aoipjvbagx `q WM
hbage amxvghtopx Pahbjpd @wtkgp jmd Bjmx @kar jdd am,
xaibt amto tbg pokgx oe amxvghtaom grghwtaugx am alvkg,
lgmtami WM vokahq jmd Xghwpatq Howmhak pgxokwtaomx-
J tbapd kamg oe amzwapq amhkwdgx pgvoptx q xgugpjk W-X-
iougpmlgmt jigmhagx+ xwhb jx tbg Iougpmlgmt Jh,
howmtj`akatq Oeeahg "IJO+ eoplgpkq Igmgpjk Jhhowmt,
ami Oeeahg!+ jmd momiougpmlgmtjk opijma~jtaomx+ xwhb
jx tbg Mwhkgjp Tbpgjt Amatajtaug+ tbjt vpouadg ougp,
26- Vjtpahaj Y- Amipjbjl+ Vbakav I- Noqhg+ jmd Jlq Cmggdkgp Domjbwg+ Iougpmlgmt Vgpeopljmhg> Ybq Ljmjiglgmt Ljttgpx
"@jktalopg> Nobmx Bovcamx Wmaugpxatq Vpgxx+ 0668!-
2:- A`ad-+ :70-
20- A`ad-+ 060:-
8/3/2019 From the Six-Party Talks to a Northeast Asian Security Regime? by Joseph R. Cerami
21/22 TBG MOPTB COPGJM MWHKGJP AXXWG 99
xaibt oe YLD vokahq axxwgx- Am jddataom to amtgpmjk
grghwtaug `pjmhb jmd DOD xtwdagx oe W-X- vokahq am
Apjz+ tbgpg bjug `ggm mwlgpowx grtgpmjk gujkwjtaomx
oe W-X- vpokaegpjtaom vokahq- Tbgxg ougpxaibt ewmhtaomx
vpouadg j hbghc om grghwtaug `pjmhb xgke,jxxgxxlgmt
jmd amhkwdg homipgxxaomjk hollattgg bgjpamix jmd
xtwdagx+ IJO pgvoptx+ jmd wmaugpxatq jmd tbamc tjmc vokahq pguagyx- Eop grjlvkg+ tbg Hjpmgiag Eowmdj,
taom oe Mgy Qopc+ tbg @poocamix Amxtatwtaom+ tbg Hgm,
tgp eop Xtpjtgiah jmd Amtgpmjtaomjk Xtwdagx+ jmd
Bjpujpdx Nobm E- Cgmmgdq Xhbook oe Iougpmlgmtx
@gkegp Hgmtgp eop Xhagmhg jmd Amtgpmjtaomjk Jeejapx
xvomxop vpoipjlx to ijam vgpxvghtaugx om YLD
tbpgjtx jmd howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq epol kgjdami
xhbokjpx- Jkk oeegp alvoptjmt amxaibtx eop gujkwjtami
iougpmlgmt vokahqljcami jmd opijma~jtaomjk vgpeop,
ljmhg-28
Am jddataom+ tbg jetgpljtb oe tbg 066: tgppopaxt jt,tjhcx om tbg Yopkd Tpjdg Hgmtgp am Mgy Qopc bjx
xvjpcgd j mwl`gp oe iougpmlgmt pgvoptx+ hollax,
xaomx+ jmd vgpxomjk jhhowmtx om axxwgx pgkjtgd to mj,
taomjk xghwpatq jmd tgppopaxl am igmgpjk tbjt vpouadg
jddataomjk wmhkjxxaeagd ameopljtaom om Hkamtom,gpj
YLD vpokaegpjtaom geeoptx- Oe vjptahwkjp ujkwg jpg tyo
grtgmxaug pgxgjphb pguagyx `q baib,kgugk iougpmlgmt
hollaxxaomx- Omg ax tbg 0664 Cgjm,Bjlaktom pgvopt
oe tbg 1/:: Hollaxxaom-24 J xghomd jwtbopatjtaug 0664
pgvopt+ eohwxami om Apjz jmd YLD+ yjx `giwm `q j
eoplgp W-X- iougpmlgmt oeeahajk jmd WM ygjvomx
amxvghtop+ Djuad Cjq+ jmd holvkgtgd q jmotbgp AJGJygjvomx amxvghtop+ Hbjpkgx Dwgkegp-27 Dwgkegpx tbpgg,
uokwlg pgvopt vpouadgx j dgtjakgd pguagy oe tbg pgkj,
taomxbav oe W-X- howmtgpvpokaegpjtaom vokahq yatb tbg
alvkglgmtjtaom `q tbg AJGJx tyo ygjvomx amxvgh,
taomx tgjlx dwpami tbg :116x jmd kgjdami wv to tbg
yjp am Apjz-
Tbg tpajmiwkjtaom oe tbgxg tbpgg pgxgjphb xtpgjlx yakk
vpouadg j lopg po`wxt wmdgpxtjmdami oe tbg kgjdgp,
xbav vjttgpmx jmd tbg pokg oe tbg W-X- jigmhq kgjd+ tbg
xghpgtjpq oe dg