41
FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL-SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE INTERFACES Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE INTERFACES, April 4th, 2012 April 4th, 2012 Ecole Polytechnique Ecole Polytechnique

FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL-

SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE.

M. GabayM. Gabay

Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE INTERFACESIntensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE INTERFACES,, April 4th, 2012April 4th, 2012

Ecole Polytechnique Ecole Polytechnique

Page 2: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Jean-Marc Triscone Andrea Caviglia Stefano Gariglio Nicolas Reyren

A. Fête

M. Rozenberg

A. Barthélémy, M. Bibes

A. Santander-Syro

Page 3: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

From diffusion to reconstruction…to confusion

Band inversion (t2g orbitals dxy dxz, dyz)

(Electric field?) confinement on STO side (mind the dielectric constant)

The carrier concentration puzzle

It takes two (types of bands) to tango

The Band story

Page 4: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE
Page 5: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Conduction depends on

Nature of the layers in contact (SrO/AlO2 vs LaO/TiO2) Oxygen pressure Mobility Temperature # of LAO layers

Page 6: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Nature Materials 7, 855 - 858 (2008)

A 2DEG can also be produced at the surface of pure STO

A.F. Santander-Syro. Et al, Nature 469, 189, 2011

Page 7: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

A.D. Caviglia, S. Gariglio, N. Reyren, D. Jaccard, T. Schneider, M. Gabay, S. Thiel, G. Hammerl, J. Mannhart, J.-M. Triscone, Nature 456, 624 (2008 )

A.D. Caviglia, S. Gariglio, N. Reyren, D. Jaccard, T. Schneider, M. Gabay, S. Thiel, G. Hammerl, J. Mannhart, J.-M. Triscone, Nature 456, 624 (2008 )

DiffusionDiffusion SO metalSO metal

Horizontal scale: use conductivityat given T, to compare phase diagrams from different samples

Page 8: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

A strange insulator regime

Surface reconstruction that avoids polar catastrophe

A few oddities revealed by transport measurements in LAO/STO heterostructures

A weird quantum critical point

A dumbfounding parallel magnetotransport

Page 9: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

|ei

For the electronic states For the Cooper pair state

Ioffe-Regel criterion for localization: kFl~1

Rs=h/e2

Rs=h/4e2

In fact localization at T=0 in 2D even if kFl>>1

Page 10: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

d (~2-7nm)

Drude part d < l (~ 5nm) Weak localization part d < Lin, Lso, Lh (~50 nm) Interaction part d <(D(ħ/kBT))1/2

From measurements of Rsheet, n2D and MR

Page 11: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Courtesy of A. Caviglia1.12≤kFl ≤4 as T varies from1.5K to 20K

Page 12: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Courtesy A. Caviglia

Page 13: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

In the strongly underdoped regime kFl~1

Page 14: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE
Page 15: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Band inversion (t2g orbitals dxy dxz, dyz)

(Electric field?) confinement on STO side (mind the dielectric constant)

The carrier concentration puzzle

It takes two (types of bands) to tango

The Band story

Page 16: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Band inversion (t2g orbitals dxy dxz, dyz)

(Electric field?) confinement on STO side (mind the dielectric constant)

The carrier concentration puzzle

It takes two (types of bands) to tango

The Band story

Page 17: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE
Page 18: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Band inversion (t2g orbitals dxy dxz, dyz)

(Electric field?) confinement on STO side (mind the dielectric constant)

The carrier concentration puzzle

It takes two (types of bands) to tango

The Band story

Page 19: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE
Page 20: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

STO LAO

z

Page 21: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

et al, Nature 469, 189, 2011

Page 22: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

xz, yz orbitalsextend deeperinside the bulk

Page 23: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE
Page 24: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Band inversion (t2g orbitals dxy dxz, dyz)

(Electric field?) confinement on STO side (mind the dielectric constant)

The carrier concentration puzzle

It takes two (types of bands) to tango

The Band story

Page 25: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Appl. Phys. Lett 94, 222111 (2009)

Courtesy of A. Caviglia

Page 26: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

pO2=10-5 mbar10 uc

Page 27: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 056802 (2011)

pO2=10-3 mbar

10 uc

Page 28: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

pO2=8 10-5 mbar

Tc=0.12K

Page 29: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE
Page 30: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Band inversion (t2g orbitals dxy dxz, dyz)

(Electric field?) confinement on STO side (mind the dielectric constant)

The carrier concentration puzzle

It takes two (types of bands) to tango

The Band story

Page 31: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 226802 (2009)

pO2=1.33 10-5 mbar10 uc

Page 32: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE
Page 33: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

A.D. Caviglia, S. Gariglio, N. Reyren, D. Jaccard, T. Schneider, M. Gabay, S. Thiel, G. Hammerl, J. Mannhart, J.-M. Triscone, Nature 456, 624 (2008 )

A.D. Caviglia, S. Gariglio, N. Reyren, D. Jaccard, T. Schneider, M. Gabay, S. Thiel, G. Hammerl, J. Mannhart, J.-M. Triscone, Nature 456, 624 (2008 )

DiffusionDiffusion SO metalSO metal

Page 34: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

T=1.5K

Perpendicular magnetoconductance for different gate voltages

A. Caviglia et al PRL 104, 126803 (2010)

WL correction to conductivity in the diffusive regime

A large spin-orbit effect is uncovered

BSO =0/4D SO

Bel =0/4D

Bin =0/4D in

Page 35: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

Rashba spin-orbit coupling

ħSO = ESO~ 2EkF1/SO =SO

m* =( h2/E)√ BSO/0

H=( ExP ).

(Drude)=-(WAL)-e-e)-(Super)

Page 36: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

m*max ~2.2me

Page 37: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

PRL 106, 166807, 2011

ns~ 1014cm-2

xz, yz orbitalsextend deeperinside the bulk

Page 38: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

BRashba=( ExP )

xy band is isotropic in xy planeModel xz,yz bands as 1D, xz is // current

At Γ point, Exz~EF; Exy<<EF

/ = - 1/8 (/EF)2

Page 39: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

B=7T

Courtesy A. Fête

Page 40: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE
Page 41: FROM STRANGE INSULATOR TO SPIN-ORBIT CONDUCTOR: UNVEILING ORBITAL- SELECTIVENESS AT THE LAO-STO INTERFACE. M. Gabay Intensive course by A. Millis: OXIDE

A. Caviglia et al PRL 104, 126803 (2010)