88
FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables Jacqueline Barnes Annemarie Freude-Lagevardi Leopold Muller Centre, Department of Paediatrics and Child Health Royal Free and University College Medical School University College London Sponsored and funded by the Mental Health Foundation Septermber 2002

from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF

CHILDREN AND FAMILIES

Volume 2 Tables

Jacqueline Barnes

Annemarie Freude-Lagevardi

Leopold Muller Centre, Department of Paediatrics and Child Health

Royal Free and University College Medical School

University College London

Sponsored and funded by the Mental Health Foundation

Septermber 2002

Page 2: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Contents Abbreviations used

Reviews

Table II.1 Overview of review papers

Theoretical models

Table III.1 Overview of theoretical models

Table III.2 NBAS studies

Table III.3 Psychodynamic model Studies

Table III.4 Attachment model studies

Table III.5 Transactional model studies

Table III.6 Psychotherapy studies

Table III.7 Support model studies

Table III.8 Ecological model studies

Participants

Table IV.1 At risk infants

Table IV.2 At risk parents

Table IV.3 Non risk parents

Table IV.4 New parents

Programme type

Table IV.5 Multi-method

Table IV.6 Group based

Table IV.7 Day care based

Table IV.8 Directed to parents only

Table IV.9 Directed to parents and children

Intervenor characteristics

Table IV.10 Professional home visiting

Table IV.11 Paraprofessional home visiting

Timing

Table IV.12 Prenatal programmes

Table IV.13 Birth started programmes

Table IV.14 Later started programmes

Page 3: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Duration

Table IV.15 Minimal (1 or few sessions)

Table IV.16 Short (up to 1 year)

Table IV.17 Long (more than 1 year)

Intensity

Table IV.18 Dose Effects

Table IV.19 Sleeper Effects

References

Page 4: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Abbreviations used in all tables model/theory: attachment (ATT)

developmental (D) ecological (EC) psychodynamic (PD) social learning theory (SLT) transactional (TRANS)

intervention: counselling (C) parent training (PT) Developmental Programming (DP) parent group (PG) home visiting (HV) Parent-Infant Relationship Treatment (PIRT) interactional guidance (IG) preschool (PS) marital guidance (MG) psychodynamic psychotherapy (PPT) mother-infant interaction approach (MII) Speaking for the Baby Technique (SftBT) mother-infant therapy (MIT) social skills training (SST) parent education (PE) Watch, Wait, & Wonder (WWW)

duration: weeks (wks) months (mths) years (yrs) reducing: from weekly to biweekly or monthly sessions participants: Hispanic (His) married (marr) low-risk (L-R) infants (Is)

Black (Bl) single/not married (s) at-risk (A-R) children (Cs) Caucasian (Cau) teenage (T) lowSES mothers (Ms) White (Wh) primiparous (primi) little education (lowEd) parents (Ps) African-American (AA) pregnant (preg) middle-class (m-c) mixed ethnicity (mix-ethn) non-organic failure to thrive (NOFT)

failure to thrive (FFT)

recruitment: maternity ward (MW) hospital (hosp) midwife (midw) community nurses (CN) records (R) health, education & social services (HES services) multiple/diverse referral sources (multi)

Page 5: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

provider: nurse (N) paraprofessional (para)

social worker (SW) professional (prof) home visitor (HV) multidisciplinary team (multi) health visitor (HeV) researcher (res)

psychologist (P) psychiatrist (PSY) dietician (D)

outcome: parents (P) abuse/neglect (a/n) improvement: +

mothers (M) attachment security (att) minimal improvement: (+) children (C) behaviour (b) no change relative to the control group: 0 infants (I) cognition/cognitive (c) negative change, performing worse than control group: -

development (d) health (h) interaction (between mother and child) knowledge (k) mental health (mh) personal development, e.g. job/training (pd) representational level, mothers perception of herself, the infant or others (rep) service use social support (s

Page 6: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.1 Overview of intervention models

1

2

3

4

5

6a

6b

7a

7b

8

9

10

Intervention Bonding Model

Brazelton NBAS

Parents as-Teachers

Psycho-dynamic model

Attachment Model

Developmental Guidance

Interactional/ Relational Guidance

Transactional Developmental

Transactional Interactional

Infant-led psychotherapy

Support Model

Ecological Model

Population Conditions Problems

Functional Behaviour parenting

LowSES Teen Ms parenting

Low SES Teen Ms parenting

Access to resources

Access to resources

Aimed at improving

M-I- relations

P-education

I-skills M-I-relations M-sensitivity/ responsiveness

M-I- relations M-sensitivity/ responsiveness

M-I-relations M-sensitivity/ responsiveness

M-I-relations M-sensitivity/ responsiveness

I-development I-functioning

M-I- Interaction I-development

M-I-relations M-sensitivity/ responsiveness

Methods Focus on

Extra contact

Exercises Exercises Representation Projections Transference

M-internal Working model

M-knowledge of I-development

Enjoyable Interactions Observing I-cues

Problem solving Concrete exercises

Problem solving I-led activity Joint discussion of observations

Housing, work Skills, C-care Self-help

Home visiting plus support method

Materials Use of video

Toys Video

Charts Reading material

Video

Location Maternity Ward

Maternity Ward

Home Clinic Clinic or home Clinic Clinic Clinic Clinic Clinic Home &/or Community

Home &/or Community

Who attends M, or dyad M, or dyad Individually mostly group

Dyad M, or dyad Dyad M-I dyad

Therapist’s Role

N/A Teacher Expert

Teacher expert

Expert facilitator Active listens Interpretation Secure base

Expert facilitator Active listens Interpretation Secure base

Expert informaton Non-expert ? facilitator Modelling Feedback

Teacher Modelling

Facilitator Secure base Information Assistance

Non-expert Facilitator Resource Secure base

Para/ professional support advocacy

Directed at Mother Parents Parents Dyad Mother/dyad

Mother Mother Mother Mother Mother Mother Mother

Infant’s Role

Direct Indirect Direct Indirect Indirect N/A or Indirect

Indirect Indirect Indirect Direct N/A N/A

Page 7: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table 111.2 Brazelton NBAS Studies

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Belsky 1985, 1986 PIFDP

NBAS active exposure to NBAS, Ms only vs couple

primi, Wh, marr obstetric practice E1:n=15 couple NBAS E2:n=15 Ms NBAS C1:n=15 C2:n=15 verbal report of NBAS

n=7/67 dropouts Pb+ interaction 0

Liptak et al. 1983 NBAS NBAS 1 session m-c, Wh, primi, <marr

hospital E: n= NBAS + routine care C1:n= 1 visit by author C2:n= phys. I-examination in front of M total n=75

n=9 refusals n=4/75 dropouts

Mb+ interaction0

Myers 1982 NBAS active P-exposure to NBAS-exam in hospital, Ms vs fathers only

1 45-60mins session primi, m-c, <Wh, couples

hospital E1:n= Ms NBAS E2:n= Fs NBAS C:n= no NBAS total n=42

n=2 Pk+, Pb+/0, Prepr(+)

Rauh et al. 1988 MITP TRANS intensive NBAS in hospital & home

3 months 11 1hr sessions (hospital: 7, home: 4 sessions)

Ps of LBW Is intensive care unit E1:n=25 LBW NBAS C1:n=29 LBW C1:n=28 normal BW

n=15 intensive care nurse

Ic+ Mrepr+

Widmayer & Field 1981 TRANS NBAS with/ without MABI (adaptation of NBAS for Ms)

birth-4 weeks 5 sessions

lowSES, Bl, teen, preterm

hospital, assessment at home

E1:n= NBAS + MABI E2:n= MABI C:n= questionnaire on I-development total n=30

researcher Id+, Ic+? interaction+

Wingerd Bristor et al 1984 parent coaching / skills training

birth-3 days (days 1, 2, &7 post-birth)

primi, mix-SES, intact families

private paediatric clinic

E:n=21 P-coaching C1:n=21 routine care C2:n=21 exp. decliners

n=23 Ib+/0 Mb+/0 Interaction+

Page 8: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables
Page 9: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.3 Psychodynamic model studies

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Carter et al. 1991 PD Mother-baby class

Case 1: 11 weeks Case 2: prenatal- 13 months

lowSES, teen Referral 2 single case studies

N/A, but case 2 irregular attendance

Therapist Id+, Imh+ Mb+/0 Interaction+

Cohen et al. 1999 WWW vs PPT

PD WWW vs PPT 5 months 1 hr wkly 8-18 sessions

Is <30mths with att, b, sleep, eat problems

C’s mental health centre

E :n=34 WWW C:n=33 PPT

n=6 4 I-mental health therapists

Iatt+, Imh+, Ic+ Mb+/0, Mmh+, Mrepr+ WWW>PPT

Cordeiro 1997 PD PPT 6-24 months 12-12? Sessions or more

Is<3 years with attachment,functional, behavioural problems

GPs, paediatricians

E:n=114 C: N/A

n=26 multi: PSY, clin. P, nurse

15.1%: not improved 56.5%: improved 28.3%: greatly improved Cs <24mths benefit more

Cramer 1998 Interactional Guidance (IG) vs Psychodynamic Psychotherapy (PPT)

PD, IG IG vs PPT 6 sessions (max. 10 sessions)

Is<30mths, functionally & behaviourally Disturbed

Child guidance clinic

E:n= IG C:n= PPT total n=38

n=6 Therapist Ib+/0 Mb+, Mrepr+/0, Mmh+ interaction+ overall IG=PPT

Green et al. 1981 PD HV, PPT, C, P-groups

5-36 months 6 sessions or more

abusing Ps Referrals E: n=79 multi-intervention C: N/A

N/A HV: multi-disciplinary

Ia/n+Mrepr+, Mb+ HV/combined approach effective dose effects

Kaukonen & Tamminen 1998

PD systems behavioural

Psychiatric I-family day-ward for all family members

3 weeks daily 9:30am-2pm

at/multiple-risk dysfunctional families

Referrals E:n=81 families C: N/A

Multi: nurses, PSY, family therapists

26% re-admission, 26% successful, 29% continued treatment

Leifer & Smith 1990 EC PD

MIT & PT 13 mths twice wkly 84 sessions

Ella & Tim aged 4 mths, FTT, M development delayed, depressed

Referral single case study N/A therapist Ic0, Iatt+, Ib+ Mb=+/0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+ pregnancies-

Lieberman et al. 1991

PD HV: MIT 1 year 1.5hrs wkly

lowSES, HIS, immigrants, anxious dyads

Paediatric clinic

E:n=29 MIT anxious C1:n=23 anxious C2:n=30 secure

n=18 HV: bilingual MSC psycholgists or SW

Ib+ Mrepr0, Mb+

Page 10: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.3 Psychodynamic model studies

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Muir 1992 WWW

PD Object relations

WWW 12 (8-20) sessions 50mins wkly

M & son aged 10.5mths, NOFT

Referral single case study N/A Therapist Ib+, Ih+, Id+ Mrepr+, Mb+

Muir & Thorlaksdottir 1994 WWW

PD Object relations

WWW 6-13 weeks 1hr wkly

Referral 4 single case studies

N/A Therapist

Proulx & Minde 1995

PD Group-based PT for fathers & Is

10 weeks 2.5hrs wkly

fathers unable to relate to toddlers

E:n=5 father’s & I’s group C: N/A

PSY, art therapist Fk+, Fb+

Robert-Tissot et al. 1996 PD PPT vs IG 9.3 weeks 6.1 (1-12) sessions

functionally & behaviourally disturbed Is, aged <30mths, mixSES, intact families

Child guidance clinic

E:n= PPT C:n= IG total n=75

n=10 refusals, n=37/75

IG: P & speech therapist PPT: 4 PSY

Ib+ Mb+, Mrepr+/0 interaction+ PPT=IG sleeper effects

Wright 1986 IDP

ATT PD Objects relations

home-based, outreach MIT

prenatal-3/4 years at-risk Ps with parenting problems, too distressed to get help

Referrals E: MIT C: N/A

N/A multi-disciplinary Profound changes in I’s most essential object relations

Page 11: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.4 Attachment model studies

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Anisfeld et al. 1990 ATT I-carriers vs seats lowSES, Bl, His, preg, primi

MW E=23 C=26

n=11 researcher Mb+ Ib+,Iatt+, Ic0

Bakermans-Kranenburg et al. 1998 behaviour vs representations

ATT MIT: behav. vs behavioural + representational level

3 months 1.5-3hrs 4 visits

primi, m-c, insecure Ms

records nurses

E1 :n=10 behav. E2 :n=10 beh+reprC:n=10

N/A HV: 2 authors Iatt0 Mb+ (E1&2) insecureM>behav dismissingM>repres

Egeland & Erickson 1990 STEEP

ATT HV: PPT + P-group

prenatal-1 year biwkly

at-risk, primi, lowSES, lowEd

E:n=74 C:n=80

Iatt0 Mmh+, Mb+, Mrepr+

Heinicke et al. 1999 UCLA

ATT other

HV + MIgroup prenatal-2/4 years wkly-reducinggroup: 17 (0-43)

preg, primi, lowSES, at-risk, ethn-mix

paediatric clinic

E:n=31 HV+MIgroup C:n=33 follow-up

n=6/70 HV: mental health professionals

Ib+, Iatt+, Ic0 Mb+, Mrepr+, Mmh0

Juffer et al. 1997 ATT HV: MIT + book vs book

3 visits interracially adopted Is

adoption agency

E1:n=30 MIT+book E2:n=30 book C:n=30 /

n=17 HV: 3 researchers with MSC

Iatt+, Ib+ Mb+ E2:0 effects

Kitzman et al. 1997 Prenatal/Early IP

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: 1 vs 2 years

prenatal-2 yrs 7(0-18) prenatal 26 (0-71)postnatal

AA, preg, primi, lowSES, single

obstetric care system

E1:n=228 2yrs HV +screen +transp E2:n=230 1yr HV +screen +transp C1:n=515 screen+transp C2:n=166 transport

4% at 2yrs HV: nurses Ih+/0,Ic0, Ib0 Mb+/, Mh+, Mrepr+/0, Mpd0 pregnancies+ service use0 (i.e. immunisations)

Olds et al. 1986

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: pre+postbirth vs prebirth

prenatal-2 yrs 1hr 15mins wkly-reducing8-9 prenatal 23 postnatal

Wh, preg, primi, teen, lowSES, >single

antenatal clinic

E1:n=116 HV pre+post birth + screen + transp E2:n=100 HV pre- birth + screen + transp C1:n=90 screen + transp C2:n=94 screening

19-21% HV: nurses Ih+, Ia/n+ Mb+, Mh+, Mpd+, Mss+ pregnancies+ aid+

Page 12: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.4 Attachment model studies Study Model Intervention Duration

Intensity Participants Recruitment Condition

n Attrition Provider Outcomes

Parr 1997 PIPPIN

ATT other

HV + PT-group Prenatal-18wks 1hr wkly

low-risk, >Wh mixSES, primi,

E:n=98 HV+groupC:n=114 waiting list

n=32 HV: PI-facilitators Mmh+, Mrepr+, Mb+, Matt+ Fb+, Fmh+, Frepr+

Siegel et al. 1980

ATT? HV vs early extended contact

birth onwards hospital: 5hrs daily 9 home visits

lowSES with normal vs complicated labour /pregnancy

Hospital E1:n=47 & 60 HV & ext. contact E2:n=50 extended contact E3:n=53 HV C:n=52 & 59 routine care

n=204/525 para-HV 200hrs training

Ia/n0 Mb(+) ext. contact only service use0 HV:null results

van den Boom 1994 ATT HV: behavioural MIT

3months 2hrs 3wkly

irritable Is, Cau, lowSES, primi

Hospital Midwives

E1:n=25 MIT + pre-assessment E2:n=25 MIT C1:n=25 pre-treatment assessment C2:n=25

100/588 with complete data

HV: author Ib+, Ic+, Iatt+ Mb+ interaction+

Wendland-Carro et al. 1999 ATT NBAS

video & talk re: M-I-interaction vs caregiving skills

1 hr only lowSES, primi, married

Maternity ward

E:n=17 video + talk re M-I-interaction C:n=19 video + talk re caregiving

n=2 researcher Mb+ interaction+

Wright 1986 IDP

ATT PD objects relations

home-based, outreach MIT

prenatal-3/4 years

at-risk Ps with parenting problems, too distressed to get help

Referrals E: MIT C: N/A

N/A multi-disciplinary profound changes in I’s most essential object relations

Page 13: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.5 Transactional model studies

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Barrera et al. 1990 TRANS RCT: HV:DP vs MII, pre vs fullterm

1 year 1-2hrs wkly-reducing, 23 (12-28) visits

Pre + fullterm, LBW, m-c

Maternity Ward

E1:n=16 DP, pre E2:n=22 MII, pre C1:n=24 fullterm C2:n=21 preterm

HV:4 infant therapists

Ib+, Iatt+ MII: att+ DP: b+ (pre=full)

Drell 1992 TRANS multimodal therapy : dynamic, behavioural, family approach

female toddler E. aged 2yrs, behaviour out-of-control

Referral single case study N/A therapist Ib+ Mb+

Rauh et al. 1988 MITP TRANS intensive NBAS in hospital & home

3 months 11 1hr sessions (hospital: 7, home: 4 sessions)

Ps of LBW Is Intensive care unit E1:n=25 LBW NBAS C1:n=29 LBW C1:n=28 normal BW

N=15 intensive care nurse

Ic+ Mrepr+

Widmayer & Field 1981 TRANS NBAS with/ without MABI (adaptation of NBAS for Ms)

birth-4 weeks 5 sessions

lowSES, Bl, teen, preterm

Hospital, assessment at home

E1:n= NBAS + MABI E2:n= MABI C:n= questionnaire on I-development total n=30

researcher Id+, Ic+? interaction+

Woolfson 1999 TRANS remediation (C),re-education (P), re-definition (P)

pre-schoolers with motor impairments

Convenience sample

E:n=15 C: N/A

n=3 multi-disciplinary team: teacher, nurse, physio/speech/occ therapists

Id+, Ih+ Mb+, Mrepr+

Page 14: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.6 Psychotherapy studies

Study Model Intervention Duration

intensity Participants Recruitment Condition

n Attrition Provider Outcomes

Carter et al. 1991 AMIP PD mother-baby class

Case 1: 11 weeks Case 2: prenatal- 13 months

lowSES, teen referral 2 single case studies

N/A, but case 2 irregular attendance

therapist Id+, Imh+ Mb+/0 interaction+

Cohen et al. 1999 WWW vs PPT

PD WWW vs PPT 5 months 1 hr wkly 8-18 sessions

Is <30mths with att, b, sleep, eat problems

C’s mental health centre

E :n=34 WWW C:n=33 PPT

n=6 4 I-mental health therapists

Iatt+, Imh+, Ic+ Mb+/0, Mmh+, Mrepr+ WWW>PPT

Cordeiro 1997 PD PPT 6-24 months 12-12? sessions or more

Is<3 years with attachment,functional, behavioural problems

GPs, paediatricians

E:n=114 C: N/A

N=26 multi: PSY, clin. P, nurse

15.1%: not improved 56.5%: improved 28.3%: greatly improved Cs <24mths benefit more

Cramer 1998 Interactional Guidance (IG) vs Psychodynamic Psychotherapy (PPT)

PD, IG IG vs PPT 6 sessions (max. 10 sessions)

Is<30mths, functionally & behaviourally disturbed

child guidance clinic

E:n= IG C:n= PPT total n=38

N=6 therapist Ib+/0 Mb+, Mrepr+/0, Mmh+ interaction+ overall IG=PPT

Drell 1992 TRANS multimodal therapy : dynamic, behavioural, family approach

female toddler E. aged 2yrs, behaviour out-of-control

referral single case study N/A therapist Ib+ Mb+

Egeland & Erickson 1990 STEEP

ATT HV: PPT + P-group

prenatal-1 yearbiwkly

at-risk, primi, lowSES, lowEd

E:n=74 C:n=80

Iatt0 Mmh+, Mb+, Mrepr+

Free et al. 1996 accuracy in interpreting C’s emotion: Ms with vs without psychotherapy

1 session of rating photographs

depressed Ms & their Cs, m-c, <Cau

day-care centre, P-groups, newspapers, advertising, clinics

E:n=43 depressed Ms with psychotherapy C1:n=10 depressed Ms without therapyC2:n=31 non-depressed Ms

psychotherapy increases accuracy in interpretation of (especially neg.) emotions in depressed Ms & their Cs

Green et al. 1981 PD HV, PPT, C, P-groups

5-36 months 6 sessions or more

abusing Ps referrals E: n=79 multi-intervention C: N/A

N/A HV: multi-disciplinary

Ia/n+ Mrepr+, Mb+ HV/combined approach effective dose effects

Page 15: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.6 Psychotherapy studies

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Kaukonen & Tamminen 1998 PD systems behavioural

psychiatric I-family day-ward for all family members

3 weeks daily 9:30am-2pm

at/multiple-risk dysfunctional families

referrals E:n=81 families C: N/A

multi: nurses, PSY, family therapists

26% re-admission, 26% successful, 29% continued treatment at local guidance clinic

Leifer & Smith 1990 EC PD

MIT & PT 13 mths twice wkly 84 sessions

Ella & Tim aged 4 mths, FTT, M development delayed, depressed

referral single case study N/A therapist Ic0, Iatt+, Ib+ Mb=+/0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+ pregnancies-

Lieberman et al. 1991 PD HV: MIT 1 year 1.5hrs wkly

lowSES, HIS, immigrants, anxious dyads

paediatric clinic

E:n=29 MIT anxious C1:n=23 anxious C2:n=30 secure

N=18 HV: bilingual MSC psycholgists or SW

Ib+ Mrepr0, Mb+

McDonough 1993 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

4 months HV: 3 visits, 6-wkly playroom: 12 sessions, wkly

Lisa & Sam Jr, aged 4 mths, NOFT

Referral 1 single case study N/A therapist Ih+, Imh+ Mb+, Mpd+ interaction+

McDonough 1995 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

1 hr wkly multi-problem, resistant families: 2 FTT-cases: 1 resistant, 1 cogn. limited family

Referral 2 single case studies

N/A therapist Ih+ Pb+, Pk+ interaction +

Minde & Tidmarsh 1997 PD MIT +/ PT +/ PPT +/ P-groups

<5->10 sessions

teen, Cau, m-c, <marr, Is with disruptive behaviour

C’s hospital E: n=57 C: N/A

N=3 multi: 20 staff Ib+

Muir & Thorlaksdottir 1994 WWW

PD object relations

WWW 6-13 weeks 1hr wkly

Referral 4 single case studies

N/A therapist

Osofsky & Dickson 2000 VIP

PD play therapy crisis intervention

10-12 months wkly (-reducing) & booster sessions

Cs with PTSD due to witnessing violence/M’s death, Carl & Chad Bobby

referral E:n=35 2 single case studies

N/A therapist

Proulx & Minde 1995 PD group-based PT for fathers & Is

10 weeks 2.5hrs wkly

fathers unable to relate to toddlers

E:n=5 father’s & I’s group C: N/A

PSY, art therapist

Fk+, Fb+

Page 16: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.6 Psychotherapy studies

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Robert-Tissot et al. 1996 PD PPT vs IG 9.3 weeks 6.1 (1-12) sessions

Functionally & behaviourally disturbed Is, aged <30mths, mixSES, intact families

child guidance clinic

E:n= PPT C:n= IG total n=75

N=10 refusals, N=37/75

IG: P & speech therapist PPT: 4 PSY

Ib+ Mb+, Mrepr+/0 interaction+ PPT=IG sleeper effects

v. Hofacker & Papousek 1998 MIRIP

D MII + IG Cau, m-c, regulatory, attachment & autonomy/control disturbed Is

paediatrician E1:n=182 disturbed E2:n=63 younger C:n=49 non-disturbed matched

8.2 refusals, 4.9% dropouts

multi: paediatrician, developmental P, PSY

(Ib+ Mb+) description only serial & parallel methods

Page 17: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.7 Support model studies

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Davis & Spurr, 1998 Guidance and support

HV, manualised From referral (Mean 2.5 yrd) for 2-25 sessions (average 7.8)

Low SES , referred, behav probs and/or parent depression

Health visitrs, GP or self

E: n=55 C: comparison n=38 (routine care)

31% initially (60/87), further drop out 5

Specially trained HV or mental health worker

Mmh+, Mself esteem+ M Stress+ Mrep+, Home environment+ Cb+

Johnson et al. 1993 Community MP

support HV birth-1 year Low SES, primi health authority E:n=127 HV + routine care E:n=105 routine care

11% para-HV: 30 ethnic peers 4 wks training

Ia/n0 Mb+, Mmh+ service use+ (immunisation)

Lealman et al. 1983 support health visitor drop-in centre & telephone

birth-18 months wkly

At-risk non-Asian Is

E1:n=103 drop-in-centre, high-risk E2:n=199 social worker, high-risk C1:n=209 high risk C2:n=2291 low-risk

n=28 health visitor, social worker

Ia/n0/-, Ih0/- (!) service use0/- (!) null results

Luster et al. 1996 TIES

support HV: support/no PE

(birth?)-5 years wkly

LowSES, primi, teen

E:n=72 HV C:n=70 less intensive phone line service

6 para-HV Id0, Ic0 null results

Marcenko & Spence, 1994 support HV prenatally-1year wkly-reducing

Preg, AA, lowSES, at-risk for out-of-home placement

obstetric clinic E:n=110 HV+routine care C:n=77 routine care

n=58 para-HV: ethnic peer Mss+, Mmh+, Mb0 service use+ out-of-home placement0

McDonald Culp et al. 1998 teen vs adult

education HV 6 months 1hr wkly

Preg, low SES, teen & adult, <Cau,

health department

E:n=61 C: N/A

para-HV: 30hrs training

Mk+, Mb+ service use+ teen catch up on Mk

Spencer et al. 1989 SMFWP

support HV: support/no PE

prenatal-1 year Preg, at-risk, non-Asian, n=1288

2 maternity units E:n= support C:n= routine care

n=52 para-HV with personality/life experiences

Ih0 null results

Page 18: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.8 Ecological model studies

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Barth 1991 CPEP

EC HV 6 months 11 (5-20) visits

preg, mix-ethn, lowSES, at-risk

HES-services E:n=97 HV C:n=94 routine care

n=122 para-HV: ethnic peer

Ia/n0 null results

Black et al. 1995 EC HV with /without clinic

1 year 1hr wkly 19.2 (0-47) visits

LowSES, <AA, <single, lowEd, NOFT

paediatric primary clinic

C:n=64 HV + clinic C:n=66 clinic

20% not recruited n=14

3 para-HV Ic+, Ib+ Mb+

Black et al. 1994 SPICE

EC HV : MIT + clinic vs clinic

prenatal-18mths 1hr biwkly HV :12 (0-32) clinic:25 (0-75) mthly-reducing

LowSES, drug abusing, single, lowEd, <AA

prenatal clinic E:n=31 HV+clinic C:n=29 clinic

10% refuse n=27

2 community nurses

Ic(+)/0 Mb+ service use(+)

IHDP 1990 EC other

RCT HV + centre + MIgroup

birth-3 years wkly-reducing

LBW, preterm, ethn-mix

8 hospitals E1:n=377 HV+centre+group E2:n=330 El-low compliers C:n=512/608 follow-up

7% of recruited

HV: prof./ graduates

Ic+, Ih-/0(NOFT), Ib0, compliers<Ic+, Ib+ Mb+(HOME)

Kitzman et al. 1997 Prenatal/Early IP

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: 1 vs 2 years

prenatal-2 yrs 7(0-18) prenatal 26 (0-71) postnatal

AA, preg, primi, lowSES, single

obstetric care system

E1:n=228 2yrs HV +screen +transp E2:n=230 1yr HV +screen +transp C1:n=515 screen+transp C2:n=166 transport

4% at 2yrs nurses Ih+/0,Ic0, Ib0 Mb+/, Mh+, Mrepr+/0, Mpd0 pregnancies+ service use0 (i.e. immunisations)

Leifer & Smith 1990 EC PD

MIT & PT 13 mths twice wkly 84 sessions

Ella & Tim aged 4 mths, FTT, M development delayed, depressed

referral Single case study N/A therapist Ic0, Iatt+, Ib+ Mb=+/0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+ pregnancies-

Leifer et al. 1989 EC PD

PPT & PIRT 1-2 years ? Depressed Mae & irritable son Jr aged 2 mths, FTT

referral Single case study N/A therapist (PPT), occupat. therapist (PIRT)

Iatt+, Id+ Mmh+, Mb+

Page 19: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table III.8 Ecological model studies

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Margolis et al. 1996 EC ? HV + office vs office

wkly-biwkly Pre, primi, lowSES paediatric & family practice

E1:n= HV+office E2:n= office C:n=routine care

n=14/93 recruited

HV: 3 nurses service use+

Olds et al. 1986

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: pre+postbirth vs prebirth

prenatal-2 yrs 1hr15mins wkly-reducing 8-9 prenatal 23 postnatal

Wh, preg, primi, teen, lowSES, >single

antenatal clinic E1:n=116 HV pre+post birth + screen + transp E2:n=100 HV pre- Birth + screen + transp C1:n=90 screen + transp C2:n=94 screening

19-21% nurses Ih+, Ia/n+ Mb+, Mh+, Mpd+, Mss+ pregnancies+ aid+

Taylor & Beauchamp 1988

EC HV: PE birth-1 month 4, 90mins sessions

Preg, primi, mix-SES, mix-ethn, mix-Ed

hospital E :n= hosp & home PE C:n= routine care

n=12/42 HV: student nurse Mrepr+, Mb+, Mk+ interaction+

Page 20: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.1 At risk-infant

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Barrera et al. 1990 TRANS RCT: HV:DP vs MII, pre vs fullterm

1 year 1-2hrs wkly-reducing, 23 (12-28) visits

Pre+fullterm, LBW, m-c maternity ward

E1:n=16 DP, pre E2:n=22 MII, pre C1:n=24 fullterm C2:n=21 preterm

HV:4 infant therapists Ib+, Iatt+ MII: att+ DP: b+ (pre=full)

Black et al. 1995 EC HV with /without clinic

1 year 1hr wkly 19.2 (0-47) visits

LowSES, <AA, <single, lowEd, NOFT

paediatric primary clinic

C:n=64 HV + clinic C:n=66 clinic

20% not recruited n=14

3 para-HV Ic+, Ib+ Mb+ younger Cs benefit more (c+)

Cohen et al. 1999 WWW vs PPT

PD WWW vs PPT 5 months 1 hr wkly 8-18 sessions

Is <30mths with att, b, sleep, eat problems

C’s mental health centre

E :n=34 WWW C:n=33 PPT

n=6 4 I-mental health therapists

Iatt+, Imh+, Ic+ Mb+/0, Mmh+, Mrepr+ WWW>PPT

Collaborative Group on Preterm Birth Prevention 1993

Ed: preterm birth prevention + examination

prenatally for 16(?) weeks wkly examinations from 20-24 wks gestation

Preg, lowSES, mix-ethn, at-risk for preterm labour

3 hospital E:n=1200 high-risk + Ed + examinations C:n=1195 high-risk /

n=1011 refusals

nurses null results

Cordeiro 1997 PD PPT 6-24 months 12-12 sessions or more

Is<3 years with attachment,functional, behavioural problems

GPs, paediatricians

E:n=114 C: N/A

n=26 multi: PSY, clin. P, nurse

15.1%: not improved 56.5%: improved 28.3%: greatly improved Cs <24mths benefit more

Cramer 1998 Interactional Guidance (IG) vs Psychodynamic Psychotherapy (PPT)

PD, IG IG vs PPT 6 sessions (max. 10 sessions)

Is<30mths, functionally & behaviourally Disturbed

child guidance clinic

E:n= IG C:n= PPT total n=38

n=6 therapist Ib+/0 Mb+, Mrepr+/0, Mmh+ interaction+ overall IG=PPT

Davis & Rushton 1991 PAS

other HV : support wkly 7.8 (2-25) sessions

LowSES, mult-risk, Cs with multi-problems

HES-services E:n=55 HV-support C:n=38 /

36.8% HV: health visitor, clin. medical officer

Ib+ Mb+, Mmh+, Mrepr+/0

Page 21: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.1 At risk-infant

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Drell 1992 TRANS multimodal therapy: dynamic, behavioural, family approach

Female toddler E. aged 2yrs, behaviour out-of-control

referral single case study N/A therapist Ib+ Mb+

Field et al. 1980 RCT HV: pre vs fullterm Is, teen vs adult Ms

1/2hr biwkly Low SES, Bl, teen, single, preterm

E1:n=30 preterm teen C1:n=30 fullterm teen C2:n=30 fullterm teen C3:n=30 preterm adult C4:n=30 fullterm adult

10% HV: trained interventionist & student

Ih+, Imh+, Ic+? Mrepr+, Mb+ interaction+

Grantham-McGregor et al. 1991 JS

HV : nutrition with/without stimulation

2 years 1hr wkly

LowSES, growth stunted Is

health clinic E1:n=32 stunted, nutr&stimul E2:n=30 stunted stimulated E3:n= nutrition C1: n=33 / stunted C2:n=32 / non-stunted

para-Hv: ethnic peer Id+

Hancock 1998 HV based on Iwaniec (1995)

more than 1 year

Amy aged 2.5 yrs, FTT, emotionally abused

referral single case study N/A HV: health visitor Ib+, Ih+ Mb+

IHDP 1990 EC other

RCT HV + centre + MIgroup

birth-3 years wkly-reducing

LBW, preterm, ethn-mix 8 hospitals E1:n=377 HV+centre+group E2:n=330 El-low compliers C:n=512/608 follow-up

7% of recruited

HV: prof./ graduates

Ic+, Ih-/0(NOFT), Ib0, compliers<Ic+, Ib+ Mb+(HOME)

Juffer et al. 1997

ATT HV: MIT + book vs book

3 visits Interracially Adopted Is

adoption agency E1:n=30 MIT+book E2:n=30 book C:n=30 /

n=17 HV: 3 researchers with MSC

Iatt+, Ib+ Mb+ E2:0 effects

Page 22: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.1 At risk-infant

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Leib et al. 1980 stimulation sensory enrichment programme

Birth – hospital discharge ?

preterm Is, Wh, m-c, neonatal intensive care unit

E:n=14 stimulation C:n=14 routine care

nurses Id+, Ih0 (weight gain)

Leifer et al. 1989 EC PD

PPT & PIRT 1-2 years ? Depressed Mae & irritable son Jr aged 2 mths, FTT

referral single case study N/A therapist (PPT), occupat. therapist (PIRT)

Iatt+, Id+ Mmh+, Mb+

Leifer & Smith 1990 EC PD

MIT & PT 13 mths twice wkly 84 sessions

Ella & Tim aged 4 mths, FTT, M development delayed, depressed

referral single case study N/A therapist Ic0, Iatt+, Ib+ Mb=+/0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+ pregnancies-

McDonough 1993 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

4 months HV: 3 visits, 6-wkly playroom: 12 sessions, wkly

Lisa & Sam Jr, aged 4 mths, NOFT

referral 1 single case study

N/A therapist Ih+, Imh+ Mb+, Mpd+ interaction+

McDonough 1995 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

1 hr wkly multi-problem, resistant families: 2 FTT-cases: 1 resistant, 1 cogn. Limited family

referral 2 single case studies

N/A therapist Ih+ Pb+, Pk+ interaction +

Muir 1992 WWW

PD object relations

WWW 12 (8-20) sessions 50mins wkly

Jan & son Troy, aged 10.5mths, NOFT

referral single case study N/A therapist Ib+, Ih+, Id+ Mrepr+, Mb+

Oates et al. 1995 KEEPSAFE

HV + preschool 1 year biwkly

abused Cs multi E: n=24 C:N/A

N/A HV: therapist Ib+, Ic+

Osofsky & Dickson 2000 VIP

PD play therapy crisis intervention

10-12 months wkly (-reducing) & booster sessions

Cs with PTSD due to witnessing violence/M’s death, Carl & Chad Bobby

referral E:n=35 2 single case studies

N/A therapist

Puckering et al. 1996 MP

empowerment

Mellow Parenting group intervention (MP)

4 months wkly

Linda & Andrew aged 23mths, M-I-interaction & eating problems

single case study: MP

N/A MP-therapists Ib+ Mb+, Mmh+/0, Mrepr+, Mpd+

Rauh et al. 1988 MITP TRANS intensive NBAS in hospital & home

3 months 11 1hr sessions (hospital: 7, home: 4 sessions)

Ps of LBW Is intensive care unit

E1:n=25 LBW NBAS C1:n=29 LBW C1:n=28 normal BW

n=15 intensive care nurse Ic+ Mrepr+

Page 23: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.1 At risk-infant

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Robert-Tissot et al. 1996

PD PPT vs IG 9.3 weeks 6.1 (1-12) sessions

Functionally & behaviourally disturbed Is, aged <30mths, mixSES, intact families

child guidance clinic

E:n= PPT C:n= IG total n=75

n=10 refusals, n=37/75

IG: P & speech therapist PPT: 4 PSY

Ib+ Mb+, Mrepr+/0 interaction+ PPT=IG sleeper effects

Ross 1984 HV : PE birth-1 year Premature, lowSES, mix-ethn

medical centre E:n=40 HV-PE premature C:n=40 matched premature

n=5 HV: nurse, paediatric occ. therapist

Ic+, Imh+, Id0 Mb+, Mrepr0

Schanberg & Field 1987 stimulation tactile kinesthetic stimulation

10 days 45mins daily

Premature, LBW neonates

hospital E:n=26 t/k- stimulation C:n=routine care

Ib+, Ih+, Id+ service use+cost-effective early discharge

Seifer et al. 1991 Interaction trans-disciplinary model

Ps counselling & video interaction coaching (IC) for Is with developmental disabilities

10 months IC: 6 sessions P-group: wkly

Is with developmental disabilities

multi: e.g. hospitals, practitioners,

E:n=23 IC + Ps counselling group C:n=P-group, no IC but video watching

P, SW Ib+, Id+ Mb+,

Spencer et al. 1989 SMFWP

support HV: support/no PE

parental-1 year preg, at risk, non-Asian, n=1288

2 maternity units

E:n=support C:n=routine care

n=52 para-HV with personality/life experiences

Ih0 null results

v. Hofacker & Papousek 1998 MIRIP

D MII + IG Cau, m-c, regulatory, attachment & autonomy/control disturbed Is

paediatrician E1:n=182 disturbed E2:n=63 younger C:n=49 non-disturbed matched

8.2 refusals, 4.9% dropouts

multi: paediatrician, developmental P, PSY

(Ib+ Mb+) description only serial & parallel methods

Widmayer & Field 1981 TRANS NBAS with/without MABI (adaption of NBAS for Ms)

birth-4 weeks 5 sessions

lowSES, B1, teen, preterm

hospital, assessment at home

E1:n= NBAS + MABI E2:n= MABI C:n=questionnaire on I-development total n=30

researcher Id+, Ic+? interaction+

Page 24: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.1 At risk-infant

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Woolfson 1999 TRANS remediation (C),re-education (P), re-definition (P)

pre-schoolers with motor impairments

convenience sample

E:n=15 C: N/A

n=3 multi-disciplinary team: teacher, nurse, physio/ speech/ occ therapists

Id+, Ih+ Mb+, Mrepr+

Wright et al. 1998 PP

HV 1visit or more NOFT, <2yrs health district E:n=95 HV+routine care C:n=109 routine care

complex HV: research nurse, health visitor, dietician

Ih+

Page 25: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.2 At risk parents

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

ABECEDARIAN Ramey & Campbell 1984 Horacek, et al 1987

HV, nutrition & educational day care centre

HV: 3 years, 15 sessions/yr centre: 5 years 6-8hrs daily

lowSES, Bl, single, cog. disadvantaged

hospital & social services

E1:n=41/25 pre-school & school E2:n=24 pre-school E3:n=21 school C:n=44/90 low-risk

20.7% overall teachers Ic+ Cs with more services benefit more (dose effects)

Black et al. 1994 SPICE

EC HV : MIT + clinic vs clinic

prenatal-18mths 1hr biwkly HV :12 (0-32) clinic:25 (0-75) mthly-reducing

lowSES, drug abusing, single, lowEd, <AA

prenatal clinic E:n=31 HV+clinic C:n=29 clinic

10% refuse n=27

2 community nurses

Ic(+)/0 Mb+ service use(+)

Booth et al. 1987 HV : MIT vs didactic/info (test of 2-step model)

prenatal-1 year

n=95 preg, Wh, multi-risk

health department

E1:n=44% MIT E2:n=56% didactic/info

nurse Mb+, Mmh+ interaction+ dose effect

Carter et al. 1991 AMIP PD mother-baby class Case 1: 11 weeks Case 2: prenatal- 13 months

lowSES, teen referral 2 single case studies N/A, but case 2 irregular attendance

therapist Id+, Imh+ Mb+/0 interaction+

Field et al. 1980 RCT HV: pre vs fullterm Is, Teen vs adult Ms

1/2hr biwkly

lowSES, Bl, teen, single, preterm

E1:n=30 preterm teen C1:n=30 fullterm teen C2:n=30 fullterm teen C3:n=30 preterm adult C4:n=30 fullterm adult

10% HV: trained interventionist & student

Ih+, Imh+, Ic+? Mrepr+, Mb+ interaction+

Field et al. 1982

HV-based PT in I-stimulation vs nursery-based paid PT-training

birth-6 months HV: biwkly nursery: 4hrs daily

lowSES, Bl, teen E1:n=40 HV PT E2:n=40 nursery PT (teacher aide) C:n=40

N/A HV: psychology student with exp-teens as teacher aides

Ih+, Id+, Imh+, Ic+ Mpd+ pregnancies+ dose effects sleeper effects

Page 26: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.2 At risk parents

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Free et al. 1996 accuracy in interpreting C’s emotion: Ms with vs without psychotherapy

1 session of rating photographs

depressed Ms & their Cs, m-c, <Cau

day-care centre, P-groups, newspapers, advertising, clinics

E:n=43 depressed Ms with psychotherapy C1:n=10 depressed Ms without therapy C2:n=31 non-depressed Ms

psychotherapy increases accuracy in interpretation of (especially neg.) emotions in depressed Ms & their Cs

Green et al. 1981 PD HV, PPT, C, P-groups

5-36 months 6 sessions or more

abusing Ps referrals E: n=79 multi-intervention C: N/A

N/A HV: multi-disciplinary

Ia/n+ Mrepr+, Mb+ HV/combined approach effective dose effects

Leifer et al. 1989 EC PD

PPT & PIRT 1-2 years ? depressed Mae & irritable son Jr aged 2 mths, FTT

referral single case study N/A therapist (PPT), occupat. therapist (PIRT)

Iatt+, Id+ Mmh+, Mb+

Leifer & Smith 1990 EC PD

MIT & PT 13 mths twice wkly 84 sessions

Ella & Tim aged 4 mths, FTT, M development delayed, depressed

referral single case study N/A therapist Ic0, Iatt+, Ib+ Mb=+/0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+ pregnancies-

Lyons-Ruth et al. 1990

HV: prof vs para-professional visitors

13.3 (9-18) mths 1hr wkly 46.7 visits mthly drop-in hour

lowSES, depressed, inadequate Ms

HES-services E1:n= prof HV+P-group E2:n=10 para HV+drop-in-hour C1:n=10 / high-risk C2:n=35 / community Is/non-depressed Ms

n=9 para-HV: ethnic mothers, prof-HV: MSC-psychologist

Iatt+, Ic+, Mb0 para=prof service

Luster et al. 1996 TIES support HV: support/no PE

(birth?)-5 years wkly

lowSES, primi, teen E:n=72 HV C:n=70 less intensive phone line service

6 para-HV Id0, Ic0 null results

Page 27: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.2 At risk parents

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

McDonald Culp et al. 1998 teen vs adult

education HV 6 months 1hr wkly

preg, low SES, teen&adult, <Cau,

health department

E:n=61 C: N/A

para-HV: 30hrs training

Mk+, Mb+ service use+ teen catch up on Mk

McDonough 1995 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

1 hr wkly multi-problem, resistant families: 2 FTT-cases: 1 resistant, 1 cogn. limited family

referral 2 single case studies N/A therapist Ih+ Pb+, Pk+ interaction +

Minde & Tidmarsh 1997 PD MIT +/ PT +/ PPT +/ P-groups

teen, Cau, m-c, <marr, Is with disruptive behaviour

C’s hospital E: n=57 C: N/A

n=3 multi: 20 staff Ib+

Nye et al. 1995 MRCOP

RCT HV: PT&MG of Ms vs both Ps

10 months wkly-biwkly 28 sessions

Cau, alcoholism court records re drunk driving

E1:n=20 PT Ms E2:n=22 PT both Ps C:n=23 /

n=10 (E2) HV: MSc P or SW

Ib+

Olds et al. 1986

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: pre+postbirth vs prebirth

prenatal-2 yrs 1hr15mins wkly-reducing 8-9 prenatal 23 postnatal

Wh, preg, primi, teen, lowSES, >single

antenatal clinic

E1:n=116 HV pre+post birth + screen + transp E2:n=100 HV pre- birth + screen + transp C1:n=90 screen + transp C2:n=94 screening

19-21% nurses Ih+, Ia/n+ Mb+, Mh+, Mpd+, Mss+ pregnancies+ aid+

Wagner & Clayton 1999 PAT

education HV + case management + PE

prenatal-2 years

SV-PAT: lowSES, <Latina Teen-PAT: lowSES, teens

SV-PAT: E:n=298 HV C:n=199 Teen-PAT: E1:n=175 HV + PAT + case management E2:n=174 case management E3:n=177 PAT C:n=178

SV-PAT: 43% from programme 27% from evaluation

para-HV Id0, Ih0, Mk(+), Mb(+), Mrepr (+) dose effects

Page 28: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.2 At risk parents

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Ware & Osofsky 1987 MIP

HV + drop-in-centre + 24hr-telephone line

birth-30 months HV: wkly-reducing centre: wkly

mix-ethn, teens E: n=54 C1:n=24 routine care C2:n=28 non-engagers

30-40% 2/4 HVs

para-HV Ia0, Ic+/0 Mb+ interaction+/0 sleeper effects overall null results

Widmayer & Field 1981 TRANS NBAS with/ without MABI (adaptation of NBAS for Ms)

birth-4 weeks 5 sessions

lowSES, Bl, teen, preterm

hospital, assessment at home

E1:n= NBAS + MABI E2:n= MABI C:n= questionnaire on I-development total n=30

researcher Id+, Ic+? interaction+

Page 29: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.3 Low-risk families

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Belsky 1985; 1986 PIFDP

NBAS active exposure to NBAS, Ms only vs couple

Primi, Wh, marr Obstetric practice

E1:n=15 couple NBAS E2:n=15 Ms NBAS C1:n=15 C2:n=15 verbal report of NBAS

n=7/67 dropouts Pb+ interaction 0

Liptak et al. 1983 NBAS NBAS 1 session m-c, Wh, primi, <marr

hospital E: n= NBAS + routine care C1:n= 1 visit by author C2:n= phys. I-examination in front of M total n=75

n=9 refusals n=4/75 dropouts

Mb+ interaction0

Myers 1982 NBAS active P-exposure to NBAS-exam in hospital, Ms vs fathers only

1 45-60mins session

primi, m-c, <Wh, couples

hospital E1:n= Ms NBAS E2:n= Fs NBAS C:n= no NBAS total n=42

n=2 Pk+, Pb+/0, Prepr(+)

Taylor & Beauchamp 1988

EC HV: PE birth-1 month 4, 90mins sessions

preg, primi, mix-SES, mix-ethn, mix-Ed

hospital E :n= hosp & home PE C:n= routine care

n=12/42 HV: student nurse

Mrepr+, Mb+, Mk+ interaction+

Wingerd Bristor et al 1984

parent coaching / skills training

birth-3 days (days 1, 2, &7 post-birth)

primi, mix-SES, intact families

private paediatric clinic

E:n=21 P-coaching C1:n=21 routine care C2:n=21 exp. decliners

n=23 Ib+/0 Mb+/0 interaction+

Page 30: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.4 New Parents

Study Model Intervention Duration

intensity Participants Recruitment Condition

n Attrition Provider Outcomes

Bakermans-Kranenburg et al. 1998 behaviour vs representations

ATT MIT: behav. vs behav + repres level

3 months 1.5-3hrs 4 visits

Primi, m-c, insecure Ms

records nurses

E1 :n=10 behav. E2 :n=10 beh+repr C:n=10

N/A HV: 2 authors Iatt0 Mb+ (E1&2) insecureM>behav dismissingM>repres

Belsky 1985, 1986 PIFDP

NBAS active exposure to NBAS, Ms only vs couple

primi, Wh, marr

obstetric practice E1:n=15 couple NBAS E2:n=15 Ms NBAS C1:n=15 C2:n=15 verbal report of NBAS

N=7/67 dropouts

Pb+ interaction 0

Daro & Harding 1999 HFA

HV prenatal-3/5 years wkly or less

at-risk, mix-ethn, mix-SES newborns

E: high-risk C: low-risk

Varied, no pattern

HV: professionals with degree

Ih+/0, Ia/n+/0, Id0 Mpd+/0, Mss0 interaction+ service use+/0

Egeland & Erickson 1990 STEEP

ATT HV: PPT + P-group

prenatal-1 year biwkly

at-risk, primi, lowSES, lowEd

E:n=74 C:n=80

Iatt0 Mmh+, Mb+, Mrepr+

Hardy and Streett 1989 HV: PE + telephone line

birth-2 years 40-60mins wkly-reducing

LowSES, <Bl, <primi, <single

E:n=131 HV C:n=132 routine care

n=27 para-HV: ethnic peer

Ih+, Ia/n+ service use+

Johnson et al. 1993 Community MP

Support HV birth-1 year low SES, primi

health authority E:n=127 HV + routine care E:n=105 routine care

11% para-HV: 30 ethnic peers 4 wks training

Ia/n0 Mb+, Mmh+ service use+ (immunisation)

Kitzman et al. 1997 Prenatal/Early IP

EC, ATT Other

RCT HV: 1 vs 2 years

prenatal-2 yrs 7(0-18) prenatal 26 (0-71)postnatal

AA, preg, primi, lowSES, single

obstetric care system

E1:n=228 2yrs HV +screen +transp E2:n=230 1yr HV +screen +transp C1:n=515 screen+transp C2:n=166 transport

4% at 2yrs nurses Ih+/0,Ic0, Ib0 Mb+/, Mh+, Mrepr+/0, Mpd0 pregnancies+ service use0 (i.e. immunisations)

Page 31: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.4 New parents

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Liptak et al. 1983 NBAS NBAS 1 session m-c, Wh, primi, <marr

hospital E: n= NBAS + routine care C1:n= 1 visit by author C2:n= phys. I-examination in front of M total n=75

n=9 refusals n=4/75 dropouts

Mb+ interaction0

Luster et al. 1996 TIES

Support HV: support/no PE

(birth?)-5 years wkly

LowSES, primi, teen

E:n=72 HV C:n=70 less intensive phone line service

6 para-HV Id0, Ic0 null results

Margolis et al. 1996 EC ? HV + office vs office

wkly-biwkly

pre, primi, lowSES

Paediatric & family practice

E1:n= HV+office E2:n= office C:n=routine care

n=14/93 recruited

HV: 3 nurses service use+

Myers 1982 NBAS active P-exposure to NBAS-exam in hospital, Ms vs fathers only

1 45-60mins session

primi, m-c, <Wh, couples

Hospital E1:n= Ms NBAS E2:n= Fs NBAS C:n= no NBAS total n=42

n=2 Pk+, Pb+/0, Prepr(+)

Olds et al. 1986

EC, ATT Other

RCT HV: pre+postbirth vs prebirth

prenatal-2 yrs 1hr15mins wkly-reducing 8-9 prenatal 23 postnatal

Wh, preg, primi, teen, lowSES, >single

Antenatal clinic E1:n=116 HV pre+post birth + screen + transp E2:n=100 HV pre- birth + screen + transp C1:n=90 screen + transp C2:n=94 screening

19-21% nurses Ih+, Ia/n+ Mb+, Mh+, Mpd+, Mss+ pregnancies+ aid+

Parr 1997 PIPPIN

ATT Other

HV + PT-group prenatal-18wks 1hr wkly

low-risk, >Wh mixSES, primi,

E:n=98 HV+group C:n=114 waiting list

n=32 PI-facilitators Mmh+, Mrepr+, Mb+, Matt+ Fb+, Fmh+, Frepr+

Wendland-Carro et al. 1999 ATT NBAS

video & talk re: M-I-interaction vs caregiving skills

1 hr only lowSES, primi, married

Maternity ward E:n=17 video + talk re M-I-interaction C:n=19 video + talk re caregiving

n=2 Researcher Mb+ interaction+

Wingerd Bristor et al 1984

parent coaching / skills training

birth-3 days (days 1, 2, &7 post-birth)

primi, mix-SES, intact families

Private paediatric clinic

E:n=21 P-coaching C1:n=21 routine care C2:n=21 exp. decliners

n=23 Ib+/0 Mb+/0 interaction+

Page 32: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.5 Multi-modal/method interventions

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

ABECEDARIAN Ramey & Campbell 1984 Horacek et al 1987

HV, nutrition & educational day care centre

HV: 3 years, 15 sessions/yr centre: 5 years 6-8hrs daily

lowSES, Bl, single, cog. Disadvantaged

hospital & social services

E1:n=41/25 pre-school & school E2:n=24 pre-school E3:n=21 school C:n=44/90 low-risk

20.7% overall teachers Ic+ Cs with more services benefit more (dose effects)

Baker et al. 1999 HIPPY

HV + preschool + P-groups vs preschool

2 years HV: 30-60mins biwkly P-group: biwkly

<AA, limited Ed Ps & preschoolers

3 sites E:n=37-63 HV + preschool + P-group C:n=32-66 preschool

9-28% for sites para-HV varied for cohorts/sites Ic+/-

Bakermans-Kranenburg et al. 1998 Behaviour vs representations

ATT MIT: behav. vs behav + repres level

3 months 1.5-3hrs 4 visits

Primi, m-c, insecure Ms

records nurses

E1 :n=10 behav. E2 :n=10 beh + repr C:n=10

N/A HV: 2 authors Iatt0 Mb+ (E1&2) insecureM>behav dismissingM>repres

Brayden et al 1993 HV + indiv. C + P-groups

prenatal-2 years HV: mthly groups: 44 biwkly, 5 prenatal

preg, lowSES, at-risk

hospital E:n=141 high-risk C1:n=122 high-risk routine care C2:n=264 low-risk routine care

10-20% para-HV multi-team

Ia/n0/- (!) service use+ null results

Drell 1992 TRANS multimodal therapy : dynamic, behavioural, family approach

female toddler E. aged 2yrs, behaviour out-of-control

referral single case study N/A therapist Ib+ Mb+

Egeland & Erickson 1990 STEEP

ATT HV: PPT + P-group

prenatal-1 year biwkly

at-risk, primi, lowSES, lowEd

E:n=74 C:n=80

Iatt0 Mmh+, Mb+, Mrepr+

Grantham-McGregor et al. 1991 JS

HV : nutrition with/without stimulation

2 years 1hr wkly

lowSES, growth stunted Is

health clinic E1:n=32 stunted, nutr&stimul E2:n=30 stunted stimulated E3:n= nutrition C1: n=33 / stunted C2:n=32 / non-stunted

para-Hv: ethnic peer Id+

Page 33: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.5 Multi-modal/method interventions

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Green et al. 1981

PD HV, PPT, C, P-groups

5-36 months 6 sessions or more

abusing Ps referrals E: n=79 multi-intervention C: N/A

N/A HV: multi-disciplinary

Ia/n+ Mrepr+, Mb+ HV/combined approach effective dose effects

Hardy and Streett 1989

HV: PE + telephone line

birth-2 years 40-60mins wkly-reducing

lowSES, <Bl, <primi, <single

E:n=131 HV C:n=132 routine care

n=27 para-HV: ethnic peer

Ih+, Ia/n+ service use+

Heinicke et al. 1999 UCLA

ATT other

HV + MI-group prenatal-2/4 years wkly-reducing group: 17 (0-43)

preg, primi, lowSES, at-risk, ethn-mix

Paediatric clinic E:n=31 HV+MIgroup C:n=33 follow-up

n=6/70 HV: mental health professionals

Ib+, Iatt+, Ic0 Mb+, Mrepr+, Mmh0

IHDP 1990 EC other

RCT HV + centre + MIgroup

birth-3 years wkly-reducing

LBW, preterm, ethn-mix

8 hospitals E1:n=377 HV+centre+group E2:n=330 El-low compliers C:n=512/608 follow-up

7% of recruited

HV: prof./ graduates

Ic+, Ih-/0(NOFT), Ib0, compliers<Ic+, Ib+ Mb+(HOME)

Juffer et al. 1997 ATT HV: MIT + book vs book

3 visits Interracially adopted Is

Adoption agency

E1:n=30 MIT+book E2:n=30 book C:n=30 /

n=17 HV: 3 researchers with MSC

Iatt+, Ib+ Mb+ E2:0 effects

Leifer & Smith 1990 EC PD

MIT & PT 13 mths twice wkly 84 sessions

Ella & Tim aged 4 mths, FTT, M development delayed, depressed

Referral single case study N/A therapist Ic0, Iatt+, Ib+ Mb=+/0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+ pregnancies-

Margolis et al. 1996 EC ? HV + office vs office

wkly-biwkly pre, primi, lowSES

Paediatric & family practice

E1:n= HV+office E2:n= office C:n=routine care

n=14/93 recruited

HV: 3 nurses service use+

Minde & Tidmarsh 1997

PD MIT +/ PT +/ PPT +/ P-groups

<5->10 sessions teen, Cau, m-c, <marr, Is with disruptive behaviour

C’s hospital E: n=57 C: N/A

n=3 multi: 20 staff Ib+

Nye et al. 1995 MRCOP

RCT HV: PT&MG of Ms vs both Ps

10 months wkly-biwkly 28 sessions

Cau, alcoholism Court records re drunk driving

E1:n=20 PT Ms E2:n=22 PT both Ps C:n=23 /

n=10 (E2) HV: MSc P or SW Ib+

Page 34: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.5 Multi-modal/method interventions

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Oates et al. 1995 KEEPSAFE

HV + preschool 1 year biwkly

abused Cs Multi E: n=24 C:N/A

N/A HV: therapist Ib+, Ic+

Scott 1998 behavioural

individual +/or group behavioural therapy

indiv: 12 hrs median group: 12 weeks, 2hrs wkly

Ps with serious parenting problems

description C: N/A

therapist Ib+

Seifer et al. 1991 Interaction trans-disciplinary model

Ps counselling & video interaction coaching (IC) for Is with developmental disabilities

10 months IC: 6 sessions P-group: wkly

Is with developmental disabilities

Multi: e.g. hospitals, practitioners,

E:n=23 IC + Ps counselling group C:n=P-group, no IC but video watching

P, SW Ib+, Id+ Mb+,

Sokol et al. 1980 M&I prof &/or para

HV+PE+ antenatal care

lowSES, preg, 2yr cohort

hospital E:n=3307 C:n=1679

HV: professionals, community health aides

Ih+, Imortality+, Ipreterm+

St.Pierre and Layzer 1999 CCDP

HV + PE birth-5 years HV: 30-90mins wkly/biwkly PE: 30mins biwly

lowSES, mix-ethn, disadvantaged

21-24 sites E: n=2213 C:n=2217

64% all sites at 5 yrs

para-HV null results in all domains

v. Hofacker & Papousek 1998 MIRIP

D MII + IG Cau, m-c, regulatory, attachment & autonomy/control disturbed Is

paediatrician E1:n=182 disturbed E2:n=63 younger C:n=49 non-disturbed matched

8.2 refusals, 4.9% dropouts

multi: paediatrician, developmental P, PSY

(Ib+ Mb+) description only serial & parallel methods

Page 35: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.5 Multi-modal/method interventions

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Wagner & Clayton 1999 PAT

education HV + case management + PE

prenatal-2 years SV-PAT: lowSES, <Latina Teen-PAT: lowSES, teens

SV-PAT E:n=298 HV C:n=199 Teen-PAT: E1:n=175 HV + PAT + case management E2:n=174 case management E3:n=177 PAT C:n=178

SV-PAT: 43% from programme 27% from evaluation

para-HV Id0, Ih0, Mk(+), Mb(+), Mrepr (+) dose effects

Ware & Osofsky 1987 MIP

HV + drop-in-centre + 24hr- telephone line

birth-30months HV : wkly- reducing centre : wkly

mix-ethn teens E :n= 54 C1 :n=24 routine care C2 :n=28 non-engagers

30-40% 2/4 HV s

Para-HV Ia0, Ic+/0 Mb+ interaction+/0 sleeper effects overall null results

Wasik et al. 1990 CARE

HV: PE + day centre vs home PE

birth-6 years wkly-reducing

at-risk, Bl, single

E1:n=14 HV-PE + day care centre E2:n=23 HV-PE C:n= /

9% HV: teachers, SW, nurses

Ic+ Mb0

Widmayer & Field 1981

TRANS NBAS with/ without MABI (adaptation of NBAS for Ms)

birth-4 weeks 5 sessions

lowSES, Bl, teen, preterm

hospital, assessment at home

E1:n= NBAS + MABI E2:n= MABI C:n= questionnaire on I-development total n=30

Researcher Id+, Ic+? interaction+

Page 36: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.6 Group-based interventions

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Baker et al. 1999 HIPPY HV + preschool + P-groups vs preschool

2 years HV: 30-60mins biwkly P-group: biwkly

<AA, limited Ed Ps & preschoolers

3 sites E:n=37-63 HV + preschool + P-group C:n=32-66 preschool

9-28% for sites para-HV varied for cohorts/sites Ic+/-

Brayden et al 1993 HV + indiv. C + P-groups

Prenatal-2 years HV: mthly groups: 44 biwkly, 5 prenatal

preg, lowSES, at-risk hospital E:n=141 high-risk C1:n=122 high-risk routine care C2:n=264 low-risk routine care

10-20% para-HV multi-team

Ia/n0/- (!) service use+ null results

Egeland & Erickson 1990 STEEP

ATT HV: PPT + P-group

Prenatal-1 year Biwkly

at-risk, primi, lowSES, lowEd

E:n=74 C:n=80

Iatt0 Mmh+, Mb+, Mrepr+

Green et al. 1981 PD HV, PPT, C, P-groups

5-36 months 6 sessions or more

abusing Ps referrals E: n=79 multi-intervention C: N/A

N/A HV: multi-disciplinary

Ia/n+ Mrepr+, Mb+ HV/combined approach effective dose effects

Heinicke et al. 1999 UCLA

ATT other

HV + MI-group Prenatal-2/4 years wkly-reducing group: 17 (0-43)

preg, primi, lowSES, at-risk, ethn-mix

paediatric clinic

E:n=31 HV+MIgroup C:n=33 follow-up

n=6/70 mental health professionals

Ib+, Iatt+, Ic0 Mb+, Mrepr+, Mmh0

IHDP 1990 EC other

RCT HV + centre + MIgroup

Birth-3 years wkly-reducing

LBW, preterm, ethn-mix

8 hospitals E1:n=377 HV+centre+group E2:n=330 El-low compliers C:n=512/608 follow-up

7% of recruited

HV: prof./ graduates

Ic+, Ih-/0(NOFT), Ib0, compliers<Ic+, Ib+ Mb+(HOME)

Leifer & Smith 1990 EC PD

MIT & PT 13 mths twice wkly 84 sessions

Ella & Tim aged 4 mths, FTT, M development delayed, depressed

referral single case study N/A therapist Ic0, Iatt+, Ib+ Mb=+/0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+ pregnancies-

Minde & Tidmarsh 1997 PD MIT +/ PT +/ PPT +/ P-groups

teen, Cau, m-c, <marr, Is with disruptive behaviour

C’s hospital E: n=57 C: N/A

n=3 multi: 20 staff Ib+

Page 37: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.6 Group-based interventions

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Parr 1997 PIPPIN

ATT other

HV + PT-group Prenatal-18wks1hr wkly

low-risk, >Wh mixSES, primi,

E:n=98 HV+group C:n=114 waiting list

n=32 PI-facilitators Mmh+, Mrepr+, Mb+, Matt+ Fb+, Fmh+, Frepr+

Proulx & Minde 1995

PD group-based PT for fathers & Is

10 weeks 2.5hrs wkly

fathers unable to relate to toddlers

E:n=5 father’s & I’s group C: N/A

PSY, art therapist

Fk+, Fb+

Puckering et al. 1994 MP

empowerment Mellow Parenting group intervention (MP)

4 months wkly

hard-to-reach Ms with severe parenting problems

varied E:n=22 MP n=7/29 MP-therapists Ia/n+ Mb+ interaction+

Puckering et al. 1996 MP

empowerment Mellow Parenting group intervention (MP)

4 months wkly

Linda & Andrew aged 23mths, M-I-interaction & eating problems

single case study: MP

N/A MP-therapists Ib+ Mb+, Mmh+/0, Mrepr+, Mpd+

Scott 1998 behavioural individual +/or group behavioural therapy

indiv: 12 hrs median group: 12 weeks, 2hrs wkly

Ps with serious parenting problems

Description C: N/A

therapist Ib+

Seifer et al. 1991 interaction, trans-disciplinary model

Ps counselling & video interaction coaching (IC) for Is with developmental disabilities

10 months IC: 6 sessions P-group: wkly

Is with developmental disabilities

multi: e.g. hospitals, practitioners,

E:n=23 IC + Ps counselling group C:n=P-group, no IC but video watching

P, SW Ib+, Id+ Mb+,

St.Pierre and Layzer 1999 CCDP

HV + PE-group birth-5 years HV: 30-90mins wkly/biwkly PE: 30mins biwly

lowSES, mix-ethn, disadvantaged

21-24 sites E: n=2213 C:n=2217

64% all sites at 5 yrs

para-HV null results in all domains

Strayhorn & Weidman 1991

P-group training in interaction

0-12.5 hrs training

lowSES, mix-ethn, Cs with behaviour problems

varied, e.g. Head Start

E:n=50 extensive training C:n=48 pamphlet

n=21 research assistant Ic0, Ib+ Mb+

Page 38: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.7 Day care centre studies

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

ABECEDARIAN Ramey & Campbell 1984 Horacek et al 1987

HV, nutrition & educational day care centre

HV: 3 years, 15 sessions/yr centre: 5 years 6-8hrs daily

lowSES, Bl, single, cog. disadvantaged

hospital & social services

E1:n=41/25 pre-school & school E2:n=24 pre-school E3:n=21 school C:n=44/90 low-risk

20.7% overall teachers Ic+ Cs with more services benefit more (dose effects)

Baker et al. 1999 HIPPY

HV + preschool + P-groups vs preschool

2 years HV: 30-60mins biwkly P-group: biwkly

<AA, limited Ed Ps & preschoolers

3 sites E:n=37-63 HV + preschool + P-group C:n=32-66 preschool

9-28% for sites para-HV varied for cohorts/sites Ic+/-

IHDP 1990 EC other

RCT HV + centre + MIgroup

birth-3 years wkly-reducing

LBW, preterm, ethn-mix

8 hospitals E1:n=377 HV+centre+group E2:n=330 El-low compliers C:n=512/608 follow-up

7% of recruited

HV: prof./ graduates

Ic+, Ih-/0(NOFT), Ib0, compliers<Ic+, Ib+ Mb+(HOME)

Kunkel 1981

SLT others

individual residential therapy

18 months Cs: daily families: wkly

abused children aged 4-12yrs

referrals E:n=24 C: N/A

N/A therapists Ca/n+, Cmh+ 83% successful

Oates et al. 1995 KEEPSAFE

HV + preschool 1 year biwkly

abused Cs multi E: n=24 C:N/A

N/A HV: therapist Ib+, Ic+

Wasik et al. 1990 CARE

HV: PE + day centre vs home PE

birth-6 years wkly-reducing

at-risk, Bl, single E1:n=14 HV-PE + day care centre E2:n=23 HV-PE C:n= /

9% HV: teachers, SW, nurses

Ic+ Mb0

Page 39: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.8 Directed at parents only

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Bakermans-Kranenburg et al. 1998 behaviour vs representations

ATT MIT: behav. vs behav + repres level

3 months 1.5-3hrs 4 visits

Primi, m-c, insecure Ms

records nurses

E1 :n=10 behav. E2 :n=10 beh + repr C:n=10

N/A HV: 2 authors Iatt0 Mb+ (E1&2) insecureM>behav dismissingM>repres

Belsky 1985, 1986 PIFDP

NBAS active exposure to NBAS, Ms only vs couple

Primi, Wh, marr obstetric practice E1:n=15 couple NBAS E2:n=15 Ms NBAS C1:n=15 C2:n=15 verbal report of NBAS

n=7/67 dropouts Pb+ interaction 0

Black et al. 1994 SPICE

EC HV : MIT + clinic vs clinic

prenatal-18mths 1hr biwkly HV :12 (0-32) clinic:25 (0-75) mthly-reducing

LowSES, drug abusing, single, lowEd, <AA

prenatal clinic E:n=31 HV+clinic C:n=29 clinic

10% refuse n=27

2 community nurses

Ic(+)/0 Mb+ service use(+)

Collaborative Group on Preterm Birth Prevention 1993

Ed: preterm birth prevention + examination

prenatally for 16(?) weeks wkly examinations from 20-24 wks gestation

Preg, lowSES, mix-ethn, at-risk for preterm labour

3 hospital E:n=1200 high-risk + Ed + examinations C:n=1195 high-risk /

n=1011 refusals nurses null results

Davis & Spurr, 1998

Guidance and support

HV, manualised From referral (Mean 2.5 yrd) for 2-25 sessions (average 7.8)

Low SES , referred, behav probs and/or parent depression

Health visitrs, GP or self

E: n=55 C: comparison n=38 (routine care)

31% initially (60/87), further drop out 5

Specially trained HV or mental health worker

Mmh+, Mself esteem+ M Stress+ Mrep+, Home environment+ Cb+

Free et al. 1996 accuracy in interpreting C’s emotion: Ms with vs without psychotherapy

1 session of rating photographs

Depressed Ms & their Cs, m-c, <Cau

day-care centre, P-groups, newspapers, advertising, clinics

E:n=43 depressed Ms with psychotherapy C1:n=10 depressed Ms without therapy C2:n=31 non-depressed Ms

psychotherapy increases accuracy in interpretation of (especially neg.) emotions in depressed Ms & their Cs

Kitzman et al. 1997 Prenatal/Early IP

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: 1 vs 2 years

prenatal-2 yrs 7(0-18) prenatal 26 (0-71)postnatal

AA, preg, primi, lowSES, single

obstetric care system

E1:n=228 2yrs HV +screen +transp E2:n=230 1yr HV +screen +transp C1:n=515 screen+transp C2:n=166 transport

4% at 2yrs nurses Ih+/0,Ic0, Ib0 Mb+/, Mh+, Mrepr+/0, Mpd0 pregnancies+ service use0 (i.e. immunisations)

Page 40: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.8 Directed at parents only

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Liptak et al. 1983 NBAS NBAS 1 session m-c, Wh, primi, <marr

hospital E: n= NBAS + routine care C1:n= 1 visit by author C2:n= phys. I-examination in front of M total n=75

n=9 refusals n=4/75 dropouts

Mb+ interaction0

Myers 1982 NBAS active P-exposure to NBAS-exam in hospital, Ms vs fathers only

1 45-60mins session

Primi, m-c, <Wh, couples

hospital E1:n= Ms NBAS E2:n= Fs NBAS C:n= no NBAS total n=42

n=2 Pk+, Pb+/0, Prepr(+)

Olds et al. 1986

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: pre+postbirth vs prebirth

prenatal-2 yrs 1hr15mins wkly-reducing 8-9 prenatal 23 postnatal

Wh, preg, primi, teen, lowSES, >single

antenatal clinic E1:n=116 HV pre+post birth + screen + transp E2:n=100 HV pre- birth + screen + transp C1:n=90 screen + transp C2:n=94 screening

19-21% nurses Ih+, Ia/n+ Mb+, Mh+, Mpd+, Mss+ pregnancies+ aid+

Wagner & Clayton 1999 PAT

education HV + case management + PE

prenatal-2 years SV-PAT: lowSES, <Latina Teen-PAT: lowSES, teens

SV-PAT E:n=298 HV C:n=199 Teen-PAT: E1:n=175 HV + PAT + case management E2:n=174 case management E3:n=177 PAT C:n=178

SV-PAT: 43% from programme 27% from evaluation

para-HV Id0, Ih0, Mk(+), Mb(+), Mrepr (+) dose effects

Wendland-Carro et al. 1999

ATT NBAS

video & talk re: M-I-interaction vs caregiving skills

1 hr only LowSES, primi, married

maternity ward E:n=17 video + talk re M-I-interaction C:n=19 video + talk re caregiving

n=2 researcher Mb+ interaction+

Page 41: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.8 Directed at parents only

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Widmayer & Field 1981

TRANS NBAS with/ without MABI (adaptation of NBAS for Ms)

birth-4 weeks 5 sessions

LowSES, Bl, teen, preterm

hospital, assessment at home

E1:n= NBAS + MABI E2:n= MABI C:n= questionnaire on I-development total n=30

researcher Id+, Ic+? interaction+

Wingerd Bristor et al 1984

parent coaching / skills training

birth-3 days (days 1, 2, &7 post-birth)

Primi, mix-SES, intact families

private paediatric clinic

E:n=21 P-coaching C1:n=21 routine care C2:n=21 exp. decliners

n=23 Ib+/0 Mb+/0 interaction+

Page 42: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.9 Directed at parents & children

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Kaukonen & Tamminen 1998

PD systems behavioural

psychiatric I-family day-ward for all family members

3 weeks daily 9:30am-2pm

At/multiple-risk dysfunctional Families

Referrals E:n=81 families C: N/A

multi: nurses, PSY, family therapists

26% re-admission, 26% successful, 29% continued treatment at local guidance clinic

Kunkel 1981

SLT others

individual residential therapy

18 months Cs: daily families: wkly

Abused children aged 4-12yrs

Referrals E:n=24 C: N/A

N/A therapists Ca/n+, Cmh+ 83% successful

McDonough 1993 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

4 months HV: 3 visits, 6-wkly playroom: 12 sessions, wkly

Lisa & Sam Jr, aged 4 mths, NOFT

Referral 1 single case study N/A therapist Ih+, Imh+ Mb+, Mpd+ interaction+

McDonough 1995 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

1 hr wkly multi-problem, resistant families: 2 FTT-cases: 1 resistant, 1 cogn. Limited family

Referral 2 single case studies N/A therapist Ih+ Pb+, Pk+ interaction +

Muir 1992 WWW

PD object relations

WWW 12 (8-20) sessions 50mins wkly

Jan & son Troy, aged 10.5mths, NOFT

Referral single case study N/A therapist Ib+, Ih+, Id+ Mrepr+, Mb+

Muir & Thorlaksdottir 1994 WWW

PD object relations

WWW 6-13 weeks 1hr wkly

Referral 4 single case studies N/A therapist

Powell & Grantham-McGregor 1989

HV 2 years wkly, biwkly, or mthly

LowSES, <Bl, <lowEd, <single

Health clinic E1st study:n=152 wkly or mthly HV E2nd study:n=58 wkly HV Cs: n= no HV

8.5% (1st study)

para-HV: ethnic peers 8 wks training

Ic+ dose effects sleeper effect?

v. Hofacker & Papousek 1998 MIRIP

D MII + IG Cau, m-c, regulatory, attachment & autonomy/control disturbed Is

Paediatrician E1:n=182 disturbed E2:n=63 younger C:n=49 non-disturbed matched

8.2 refusals, 4.9% dropouts

multi: paediatrician, developmental P, PSY

(Ib+ Mb+) description only serial & parallel methods

Page 43: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.10 Home visiting professionals

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

ABECEDARIAN Ramey & Campbell 1984 Horacek et al 1987

HV, nutrition & educational day care centre

HV: 3 years, 15 sessions/yr centre: 5 years 6-8hrs daily

LowSES, Bl, single, cog. disadvantaged

hospital & social services

E1:n=41/25 pre-school & school E2:n=24 pre-school E3:n=21 school C:n=44/90 low-risk

20.7% overall

teachers Ic+ Cs with more services benefit more (dose effects)

Bakermans-Kranenburg et al. 1998 behaviour vs representations

ATT MIT: behav. vs behav + repres level

3 months 1.5-3hrs 4 visits

Primi, m-c, insecure Ms

records nurses

E1 :n=10 behav. E2 :n=10 beh + repr C:n=10

N/A HV: 2 authors Iatt0 Mb+ (E1&2) insecureM>behav dismissingM>repres

Barrera et al. 1990

TRANS RCT: HV:DP vs MII, pre vs fullterm

1 year 1-2hrs wkly-reducing, 23 (12-28) visits

Pre+fullterm, LBW, m-c

maternity ward

E1:n=16 DP, pre E2:n=22 MII, pre C1:n=24 fullterm C2:n=21 preterm

HV:4 infant therapists

Ib+, Iatt+ MII: att+ DP: b+ (pre=full)

Booth et al. 1987 HV : MIT vs didactic/info (test of 2-step model)

prenatal-1 year n=95 preg, Wh, multi-risk

health department

E1:n=44% MIT E2:n=56% didactic/info

HV: nurse Mb+, Mmh+ interaction+ dose effect

Carpenter et al. 1983 SIP

HV: high vs low-risk

birth-7 years biwkly-mthly

general population, high-risk Is

records E: HV high-risk C: low-risk

n=1/2000 HV: research health visitor

I-mortality+

Daro & Harding 1999 HFA

HV prenatal-3/5 years wkly or less

at-risk, mix-ethn, mix-SES newborns

E: high-risk C: low-risk

varied, no pattern

HV: professionals with degree

Ih+/0, Ia/n+/0, Id0 Mpd+/0, Mss0 interaction+ service use+/0

Davis & Spurr, 1998 Guidance and support

HV, manualised From referral (Mean 2.5 yrd) for 2-25 sessions (average 7.8)

Low SES , referred, behav probs and/or parent depression

Health visitrs, GP or self

E: n=55 C: comparison n=38 (routine care)

31% initially (60/87), further drop out 5

Specially trained HV or mental health worker

Mmh+, Mself esteem+ M Stress+ Mrep+, Home environment+ Cb+

Egeland & Erickson 1990 STEEP

ATT HV: PPT + P-group

prenatal-1 year biwkly

at-risk, primi, lowSES, lowEd

E:n=74 C:n=80

Iatt0 Mmh+, Mb+, Mrepr+

Page 44: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.10 Home visiting professionals

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Field et al. 1980 RCT HV: pre vs fullterm Is, teen vs adult Ms

1/2hr biwkly

LowSES, Bl, teen, single, preterm

E1:n=30 preterm teen C1:n=30 fullterm teen C2:n=30 fullterm teen C3:n=30 preterm adult C4:n=30 fullterm adult

10% HV: trained interventionist & student

Ih+, Imh+, Ic+? Mrepr+, Mb+ interaction+

Field et al. 1982 HV-based PT in I-stimulation vs nursery-based paid PT-training

Birth-6 months HV: biwkly nursery: 4hrs daily

LowSES, Bl, teen

E1:n=40 HV PT E2:n=40 nursery PT (teacher aide) C:n=40

N/A HV: psychology student with exp-teens as teacher aides

Ih+, Id+, Imh+, Ic+ Mpd+ pregnancies+ dose effects sleeper effects

Gray et al. 1977 HV vs routine care

birth-2 years wkly

preg, at-risk Ms hospital E:n=50 high-risk HV C1:n=50 high-risk routine care C2:n=50 low-risk routine care

N/A HV: public health nurse, & lay health visitor

Ih+, Ia/n0, Id0 Mb0 service use 0 (immunisations)

Green et al. 1981 PD HV, PPT, C, P-groups

5-36 months 6 sessions or more

abusing Ps referrals E: n=79 multi-intervention C: N/A

N/A HV: multi-disciplinary

Ia/n+ Mrepr+, Mb+ HV/combined approach effective dose effects

Hancock 1998 HV: Iwaniec (1995)

1-2 years biwkly-monthly 12 sessions

Amy, 25yrs, FTT, emotionally abused

referral single case study N/A HV: health visitor

Ib+, Imh+ Mb+, Mmh+

Heinicke et al. 1999 UCLA

ATT other

HV + MIgroup prenatal-2/4 years wkly-reducing group: 17 (0-43)

preg, primi, lowSES, at-risk, ethn-mix

paediatric clinic

E:n=31 HV+MIgroup C:n=33 follow-up

n=6/70 HV: mental health professionals

Ib+, Iatt+, Ic0 Mb+, Mrepr+, Mmh0

Huxley & Warner 1993 CIP

HV: MIT vs routine care

prenatal-3yrs at-risk, parenting problems

multi E:n=20 MIT+routine care C:n=20 routine care

n=20 HV: public health nurse

Ia/n+, Ih+ Mb+, Mrepr+

IHDP 1990 EC other

RCT HV + centre + MIgroup

birth-3 years wkly-reducing

LBW, preterm, ethn-mix

8 hospitals E1:n=377 HV+centre+group E2:n=330 El-low compliers C:n=512/608 follow-up

7% of recruited

HV: prof./ graduates

Ic+, Ih-/0(NOFT), Ib0, compliers<Ic+, Ib+ Mb+(HOME)

Page 45: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.10 Home visiting professionals

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Juffer et al. 1997 ATT HV: MIT + book vs book

3 visits interracially adopted Is

adoption agency

E1:n=30 MIT+book E2:n=30 book C:n=30 /

n=17 HV: 3 researchers with MSC

Iatt+, Ib+ Mb+ E2:0 effects

Kitzman et al. 1997 Prenatal/Early IP

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: 1 vs 2 years

prenatal-2 yrs 7(0-18) prenatal 26 (0-71)postnatal

AA, preg, primi, lowSES, single

obstetric care system

E1:n=228 2yrs HV +screen +transp E2:n=230 1yr HV +screen +transp C1:n=515 screen+transp C2:n=166 transport

4% at 2yrs HV: nurses Ih+/0,Ic0, Ib0 Mb+/, Mh+, Mrepr+/0, Mpd0 pregnancies+ service use0 (i.e. immunisations)

Larson (1980) Pre- vs postnatal visits

HV: pre- vs postnatal visits

prenatal-15 months 10-11 visits 1 prenatal visit

preg, Engl/French Canadian, working class

hospital E1:n=pre- & post-natal visits E2:n=post-natal visits C:n=

n=25 HV with degee in psychology

Ih+ Mb+ interaction+ postnatal visits not enough

Lieberman et al. 1991 PD HV: MIT 1 year 1.5hrs wkly

lowSES, HIS, immigrants, anxious dyads

paediatric clinic

E:n=29 MIT anxious C1:n=23 anxious C2:n=30 secure

n=18 HV: bilingual MSC psycholgists or SW

Ib+ Mrepr0, Mb+

Lyons-Ruth et al. 1990

HV: prof vs para-professional visitors

13.3 (9-18) mths 1hr wkly 46.7 visits mthly drop-in hour

lowSES, depressed, inadequate Ms

HES-services E1:n= prof HV+P-group E2:n=10 para HV+drop-in-hour C1:n=10 / high-risk C2:n=35 / community Is/non-depressed Ms

n=9 para-HV: ethnic mothers, prof-HV: MSC-psychologist

Iatt+, Ic+, Mb0 para=prof service

Margolis et al. 1996 EC ? HV + office vs office

wkly-biwkly

pre, primi, lowSES

paediatric & family practice

E1:n= HV+office E2:n= office C:n=routine care

n=14/93 recruited

HV: 3 nurses service use+

Nye et al. 1995 MRCOP

RCT HV: PT&MG of Ms vs both Ps

10 months wkly-biwkly 28 sessions

Cau, alcoholism court records re drunk driving

E1:n=20 PT Ms E2:n=22 PT both Ps C:n=23 /

n=10 (E2) HV: MSc P or SW

Ib+

Page 46: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.10 Home visiting professionals

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Oates et al. 1995 KEEPSAFE

HV + preschool 1 year biwkly

abused Cs multi E: n=24 C:N/A

N/A HV: therapist Ib+, Ic+

Olds et al. 1986

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: pre+postbirth vs prebirth

prenatal-2 yrs 1hr15mins wkly-reducing 8-9 prenatal 23 postnatal

Wh, preg, primi, teen, lowSES, >single

antenatal clinic

E1:n=116 HV pre+post birth + screen + transp E2:n=100 HV pre- birth + screen + transp C1:n=90 screen + transp C2:n=94 screening

19-21% HV: nurses Ih+, Ia/n+ Mb+, Mh+, Mpd+, Mss+ pregnancies+ aid+

Parr 1997 PIPPIN

ATT other

HV + PT-group prenatal-18wks 1hr wkly

low-risk, >Wh mixSES, primi,

E:n=98 HV+group C:n=114 waiting list

n=32 HV: PI-facilitators

Mmh+, Mrepr+, Mb+, Matt+ Fb+, Fmh+, Frepr+

Puura et al. 2000 EEP

EU/WHO

HV + need/risk assessment

prenatal-onwards 1pre- & 1postnatal assessment wkly sessions

n=1000 at-risk & low-risk families in 5 countries

E1:n=50 no-need/low-risk E2:n=50 in-need C1:n=50 no-need C2:n=50 in-need

N/A HV: primary health care professionals

not available yet

Rauh et al. 1988 MITP

TRANS intensive NBAS in hospital & home

3 months 11 1hr sessions (hospital: 7, home: 4 sessions)

Ps of LBW Is intensive care unit

E1:n=25 LBW NBAS C1:n=29 LBW C1:n=28 normal BW

N=15 intensive care nurse

Ic+ Mrepr+

Ross 1984 HV : PE birth-1 year biwkly-monthly

premature, lowSES, mix-ethn

medical centre E:n=40 HV-PE premature C:n=40 matched premature

n=5 HV: nurse, paediatric occ. Therapist

Ic+, Imh+, Id0 Mb+, Mrepr0

Sokol et al. 1980 M&I prof &/or para

HV+PE+ antenatal care

lowSES, preg, 2yr cohort

hospital E:n=3307 C:n=1679

HV: professionals, community health aides

Ih+, Imortality+, Ipreterm+

Page 47: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.10 Home visiting professionals

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Taylor & Beauchamp 1988 EC HV: PE birth-1 month 4, 90mins sessions

preg, primi, mix-SES, mix-ethn, mix-Ed

hospital E :n= hosp & home PE C:n= routine care

n=12/42 HV: student nurse

Mrepr+, Mb+, Mk+ interaction+

Teerikangas et al. 1998 other HV: family counselling

5 years 50 sessions

mixed-risk maternity clinic

E:n=54 HV counselling C:n=46

High HV: psychiatric Nurses

Imh+

van den Boom 1994 ATT HV: behavioural MIT

3months 2hrs 3wkly

irritable Is, Cau, lowSES, primi

hospital midwives

E1:n=25 MIT + pre-assessment E2:n=25 MIT C1:n=25 pre-treatment assessment C2:n=25

100/588 with complete data

HV: author Ib+, Ic+, Iatt+ Mb+ interaction+

Widmayer & Field 1981 TRANS NBAS with/ without MABI (adaptation of NBAS for Ms)

birth-4 weeks 5 sessions

lowSES, Bl, teen, preterm

hospital, assessment at home

E1:n= NBAS + MABI E2:n= MABI C:n= questionnaire on I-development total n=30

researcher Id+, Ic+? interaction+

Wright et al. 1998 PP

HV 1 visit or more NOFT, <2yrs health district E:n=95 HV+routine care C:n=109 routine care

complex HV: research nurse, health visitor, dietician

Ih+

Page 48: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.11 Home visiting – lay workers

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Baker et al. 1999 HIPPY

HV + preschool + P-groups vs preschool

2 years HV: 30-60mins biwkly P-group: biwkly

<AA, limited Ed Ps & preschoolers

3 sites E:n=37-63 HV + preschool + P-group C:n=32-66 preschool

9-28% for sites

para-HV varied for cohorts/sites Ic+/-

Black et al. 1995 EC HV with /without clinic

1 year 1hr wkly 19.2 (0-47) visits

lowSES, <AA, <single, lowEd, NOFT

paediatric primary clinic

C:n=64 HV + clinic C:n=66 clinic

20% not recruited n=14

3 para-HV Ic+, Ib+ Mb+

Brayden et al 1993 HV + indiv. C + P-groups

prenatal-2 years HV: mthly groups: 44 biwkly, 5 prenatal

preg, lowSES, at-risk

hospital E:n=141 high-risk C1:n=122 high-risk routine care C2:n=264 low-risk routine care

10-20% para-HV multi-team

Ia/n0/- (!) service use+ null results

Duggan et al. 1999 HSP

HV 3-5 years 1-4 visits mthly

lowSES, mix-ethn, at-risk Is/Cs

statewide agency

E:n=373 HV C1:n=270 / C2:n=41 / testing ctrl

51% & 12% para-HV Id+/0, Ia/n0 Mb+/0, Mpd0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+/0 service use+/0

Grantham-McGregor et al. 1991 JS

HV : nutrition with/without stimulation

2 years 1hr wkly

lowSES, growth stunted Is

health clinic E1:n=32 stunted, nutr&stimul E2:n=30 stunted stimulated E3:n= nutrition C1: n=33 / stunted C2:n=32 / non-stunted

para-Hv: ethnic peer

Id+

Hardy and Streett 1989 HV: PE + telephone line

birth-2 years 40-60mins wkly-reducing

lowSES, <Bl, <primi, <single

E:n=131 HV C:n=132 routine care

n=27 para-HV: ethnic peer

Ih+, Ia/n+ service use+

Johnson et al. 1993 Community MP

support HV birth-1 year low SES, primi health authority E:n=127 HV + routine care E:n=105 routine care

11% para-HV: 30 ethnic peers 4 wks training

Ia/n0 Mb+, Mmh+ service use+ (immunisation)

Page 49: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.11 Home visiting – lay workers

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Luster et al. 1996 TIES

support HV: support/no PE

(birth?)-5 years wkly

lowSES, primi, teen

E:n=72 HV C:n=70 less intensive phone line service

6 para-HV Id0, Ic0 null results

Marcenko & Spence, 1994 support HV Prenatally-1year wkly-reducing

preg, AA, lowSES, at-risk for out-of-home placement

obstetric clinic E:n=110 HV+routine care C:n=77 routine care

n=58 para-HV: ethnic peer

Mss+, Mmh+, Mb0 service use+ out-of-home placement0

McDonald Culp et al. 1998 teen vs adult

education HV 6 months 1hr wkly

preg, low SES, teen&adult, <Cau,

health department

E:n=61 C: N/A

para-HV: 30hrs training

Mk+, Mb+ service use+ teen catch up on Mk

Powell & Grantham-McGregor 1989

HV 2 years wkly, biwkly, or mthly

lowSES, <Bl, <lowEd, <single

health clinic E1st study:n=152 wkly or mthly HV E2nd study:n=58 wkly HV Cs: n= no HV

8.5% (1st study)

para-HV: ethnic peers 8 wks training

Ic+ dose effects sleeper effect?

Scarr & McCartney 1988 MCHP

HV: PE (vs book)

2 years biwkly 46 visits

lowSES E:n=78 HV-PE C:n=39 /

7% refusals n=4 re data

para-HV: ethnic peers

Ic(+) Mb(+) null/ceiling effects

Siegel et al. 1980 ATT? HV vs early extended contact

birth onwards hospital: 5hrs daily 9 home visits

lowSES with normal vs complicated labour /pregnancy

hospital E1:n=47 & 60 HV & ext. contact E2:n=50 extended contact E3:n=53 HV C:n=52 & 59 routine care

n=204/525 para-HV 200hrs training

Ia/n0 Mb(+) ext. contact only service use0 HV:null results

Spencer et al. 1989 SMFWP

support HV: support/no PE

Prenatal-1 year preg, at-risk, non-Asian, n=1288

2 maternity units

E:n= support C:n= routine care

n=52 para-HV with personality/life experiences

Ih0 null results

St.Pierre and Layzer 1999 CCDP

HV + PE birth-5 years HV: 30-90mins wkly/biwkly PE: 30mins biwly

lowSES, mix-ethn, disadvantaged

21-24 sites E: n=2213 C:n=2217

64% all sites at 5 yrs

para-HV null results in all domains

Page 50: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.11 Home visiting – lay workers

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Wagner & Clayton 1999 PAT

education HV + case management + PE

Prenatal-2 years SV-PAT: lowSES, <Latina Teen-PAT: lowSES, teens

SV-PAT E:n=298 HV C:n=199 Teen-PAT: E1:n=175 HV + PAT + case management E2:n=174 case management E3:n=177 PAT C:n=178

SV-PAT: 43% from programme 27% from evaluation

para-HV Id0, Ih0, Mk(+), Mb(+), Mrepr (+) dose effects

Ware & Osofsky 1987 MIP

HV + drop-in-centre + 24hr-telephone line

birth-30 months HV: wkly-reducing Centre: wkly

mix-ethn teens E: n=54 C1:n=24 routine care C2:n=28 non-engagers

30-40% 2/4 HVs

para-HV Ia0, Ic+/0 Mb+ interaction+/0 sleeper effects overall null results

Page 51: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.12 Prenatally started programmes

Study Model Iintervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Barth 1991 CPEP EC HV 6 months 11 (5-20) visits

preg, mix-ethn, lowSES, at-risk

HES-services E:n=97 HV C:n=94 routine care

n=122 para-HV: ethnic peer

Ia/n0 null results

Black et al. 1994 SPICE

EC HV : MIT + clinic vs clinic

Prenatal-18mths 1hr biwkly HV :12 (0-32) Clinic:25 (0-75) mthly-reducing

lowSES, drug abusing, single, lowEd, <AA

prenatal clinic E:n=31 HV+clinic C:n=29 clinic

10% refuse n=27

2 community nurses

Ic(+)/0 Mb+ service use(+)

Booth et al. 1987 HV : MIT vs didactic/info (test of 2-step model)

Prenatal-1 year n=95 preg, Wh, multi-risk

health department

E1:n=44% MIT E2:n=56% didactic/info

nurse Mb+, Mmh+ interaction+ dose effect

Brayden et al 1993 HV + indiv. C + P-groups

Prenatal-2 years HV: mthly Groups: 44 biwkly, 5 prenatal

preg, lowSES, at-risk

hospital E:n=141 high-risk C1:n=122 high-risk routine care C2:n=264 low-risk routine care

10-20% para-HV multi-team

Ia/n0/- (!) service use+ null results

Collaborative Group on Preterm Birth Prevention 1993

Ed: preterm birth prevention + examination

Prenatally for 16(?) weeks Wkly examinations from 20-24 wks gestation

preg, lowSES, mix-ethn, at-risk for preterm labour

3 hospital E:n=1200 high-risk + Ed + examinations C:n=1195 high-risk /

n=1011 refusals

nurses null results

Daro & Harding 1999 HFA

HV Prenatal-3/5 years Wkly or less

at-risk, mix-ethn, mix-SES newborns

E: high-risk C: low-risk

varied, no pattern

professionals with degree

Ih+/0, Ia/n+/0, Id0 Mpd+/0, Mss0 interaction+ service use+/0

Egeland & Erickson 1990 STEEP

ATT HV: PPT + P-group

Prenatal-1 year Biwkly

at-risk, primi, lowSES, lowEd

E:n=74 C:n=80

Iatt0 Mmh+, Mb+, Mrepr+

Page 52: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.12 Prenatally started programmes

Study Model Iintervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Heinicke et al. 1999 UCLA

ATT other

HV + MIgroup Prenatal-2/4 years Wkly-reducing Group: 17 (0-43)

preg, primi, lowSES, at-risk, ethn-mix

paediatric clinic

E:n=31 HV+MIgroup C:n=33 follow-up

n=6/70 mental health professionals

Ib+, Iatt+, Ic0 Mb+, Mrepr+, Mmh0

Huxley & Warner 1993 CIP

HV: MIT vs routine care

Prenatal-3yrs at-risk, parenting problems

multi E:n=20 MIT+routine care C:n=20 routine care

n=20 public health nurse

Ia/n+, Ih+ Mb+, Mrepr+

Kitzman et al. 1997 Prenatal/Early IP

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: 1 vs 2 years

Prenatal-2 yrs 7(0-18) prenatal 26 (0-71)postnatal

AA, preg, primi, lowSES, single

obstetric care system

E1:n=228 2yrs HV +screen +transp E2:n=230 1yr HV +screen +transp C1:n=515 scrreen+transp C2:n=166 transport

4% at 2yrs nurses Ih+/0,Ic0, Ib0 Mb+/, Mh+, Mrepr+/0, Mpd0 pregnancies+ service use0 (i.e. immunisations)

Larson (1980) Pre- vs postnatal visits

HV: pre- vs postnatal visits

Prenatal-15 months 10-11 visits 1 prenatal visit

preg, Engl/French Canadian, working class

hospital E1:n=pre- & post-natal visits E2:n=post-natal visits C:n=

n=25 HV with degee in psychology

Ih+ Mb+ interaction+ postnatal visits not enough

Marcenko & Spence, 1994 support HV Prenatally-1year Wkly-reducing

preg, AA, lowSES, at-risk for out-of-home placement

obstetric clinic E:n=110 HV+routine care C:n=77 routine care

n=58 para-HV: ethnic peer

Mss+, Mmh+, Mb0 service use+ out-of-home placement0

Margolis et al. 1996 EC ? HV + office vs office

Wkly-biwkly

pre, primi, lowSES

paediatric & family practice

E1:n= HV+office E2:n= office C:n=routine care

n=14/93 recruited

HV: 3 nurses service use+

Olds et al. 1986

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: pre+postbirth vs prebirth

Prenatal-2 yrs 1hr15mins wkly-reducing 8-9 prenatal 23 postnatal

Wh, preg, primi, teen, lowSES, >single

antenatal clinic E1:n=116 HV pre+post birth + screen + transp E2:n=100 HV pre- birth + screen + transp C1:n=90 screen + transp C2:n=94 screening

19-21% nurses Ih+, Ia/n+ Mb+, Mh+, Mpd+, Mss+ pregnancies+ aid+

Page 53: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.12 Prenatally started programmes

Study Model Iintervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Parr 1997 PIPPIN

ATT other

HV + PT-group Prenatal-18wks 1hr wkly

low-risk, >Wh mixSES, primi,

E:n=98 HV+group C:n=114 waiting list

n=32 PI-facilitators Mmh+, Mrepr+, Mb+, Matt+ Fb+, Fmh+, Frepr+

Puura et al. 2000 EEP

EU/WHO HV + need/risk assessment

Prenatal-onwards 1pre- & 1postnatal assessment wkly sessions

n=1000 at-risk & low-risk families in 5 countries

E1:n=50 no-need/low-risk E2:n=50 in-need C1:n=50 no-need C2:n=50 in-need

N/A primary health care professionals

not available yet

Sokol et al. 1980 M&I prof &/or para

HV+PE+ antenatal care

lowSES, preg, 2yr cohort

hospital E:n=3307 C:n=1679

professionals, community health aides

Ih+, Imortality+, Ipreterm+

Spencer et al. 1989 SMFWP

support HV: support/no PE

Prenatal-1 year preg, at-risk, non-Asian, n=1288

2 maternity units

E:n= support C:n= routine care

n=52 para-HV with personality/life experiences

Ih0 null results

Wagner & Clayton 1999 PAT

education HV + case management + PE

Prenatal-2 years

SV-PAT: lowSES, <Latina Teen-PAT: lowSES, teens

SV-PAT: E:n=298 HV C:n=199 Teen-PAT: E1:n=175 HV + PAT + case management E2:n=174 case management E3:n=177 PAT C:n=178

SV-PAT: 43% from programme 27% from evaluation

para-HV Id0, Ih0, Mk(+), Mb(+), Mrepr (+) dose effects

Page 54: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.13 Birth started programmes

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Belsky 1985, 1986 PIFDP

NBAS active exposure to NBAS, Ms only vs couple

primi, Wh, marr obstetric practice

E1:n=15 couple NBAS E2:n=15 Ms NBAS C1:n=15 C2:n=15 verbal report of NBAS

n=7/67 dropouts Pb+ interaction 0

Carpenter et al. 1983 SIP

HV: high vs low-risk

birth-7 years biwkly-mthly

General population, high-risk Is

records E: HV high-risk C: low-risk

n=1/2000 HV: research health visitor

I-mortality+

Duggan et al. 1999 HSP HV 3-5 years 1-4 visits mthly

lowSES, mix-ethn, at-risk Is/Cs

statewide agency

E:n=373 HV C1:n=270 / C2:n=41 / testing ctrl

51% & 12% para-HV Id+/0, Ia/n0 Mb+/0, Mpd0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+/0 service use+/0

Gray et al. 1977 HV vs routine care

birth-2 years wkly

preg, at-risk Ms hospital E:n=50 high-risk HV C1:n=50 high-risk routine care C2:n=50 low-risk routine care

N/A HV: public health nurse, & lay health visitor

Ih+, Ia/n0, Id0 Mb0 service use 0 (immunisations)

Hardy and Streett 1989 HV: PE + telephone line

birth-2 years 40-60mins wkly-reducing

lowSES, <Bl, <primi, <single

E:n=131 HV C:n=132 routine care

n=27 para-HV: ethnic peer

Ih+, Ia/n+ service use+

IHDP 1990 EC other

RCT HV + centre + MIgroup

birth-3 years wkly-reducing

LBW, preterm, ethn-mix

8 hospitals E1:n=377 HV+centre+group E2:n=330 El-low compliers C:n=512/608 follow-up

7% of recruited

HV: prof./ graduates

Ic+, Ih-/0(NOFT), Ib0, compliers<Ic+, Ib+ Mb+(HOME)

Johnson et al. 1993 Community MP

support HV birth-1 year low SES, primi health authority E:n=127 HV + routine care E:n=105 routine care

11% para-HV: 30 ethnic peers 4 wks training

Ia/n0 Mb+, Mmh+ service use+ (immunisation)

Lealman et al. 1983 support health visitor drop-in centre & telephone

birth-18 months wkly

at-risk non-Asian Is

E1:n=103 drop-in-centre, high-risk E2:n=199 social worker, high-risk C1:n=209 high risk C2:n=2291 low-risk

n=28 health visitor, social worker

Ia/n0/-, Ih0/- (!) service use0/- (!) null results

Page 55: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.13 Birth started programmes

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Leib et al. 1980 stimulation sensory enrichment programme

birth – hospital discharge ?

Preterm Is, Wh, m-c,

neonatal intensive care unit

E:n=14 stimulation C:n=14 routine care

nurses Id+, Ih0 (weight gain)

Liptak et al. 1983 NBAS NBAS 1 session m-c, Wh, primi, <marr

hospital E: n= NBAS + routine care C1:n= 1 visit by author C2:n= phys. I-examination in front of M total n=75

n=9 refusals n=4/75 dropouts

Mb+ interaction0

Luster et al. 1996 TIES

support HV: support/no PE

(birth?)-5 years wkly

LowSES, primi, teen

E:n=72 HV C:n=70 less intensive phone line service

6 para-HV Id0, Ic0 null results

Myers 1982 NBAS active P-exposure to NBAS-exam in hospital, Ms vs fathers only

1 45-60mins session

Primi, m-c, <Wh, couples

hospital E1:n= Ms NBAS E2:n= Fs NBAS C:n= no NBAS total n=42

n=2 Pk+, Pb+/0, Prepr(+)

Ross 1984 HV : PE birth-1 year biwkly-monthly

Premature, lowSES, mix-ethn

medical centre E:n=40 HV-PE premature C:n=40 matched premature

n=5 HV: nurse, paediatric occ. therapist

Ic+, Imh+, Id0 Mb+, Mrepr0

Schanberg & Field 1987 stimulation tactile kinesthetic stimulation

birth-10 days 45mins daily

premature, LBW neonates

hospital E:n=26 t/k-stimulation C:n= routine care

Ib+, Ih+, Id+ service use+ cost-effective early discharge

Siegel et al. 1980 ATT? HV vs early extended contact

birth onwards hospital: 5hrs daily 9 home visits

lowSES with normal vs complicated labour /pregnancy

hospital E1:n=47 & 60 HV & ext. contact E2:n=50 extended contact E3:n=53 HV C:n=52 & 59 routine care

n=204/525 para-HV 200hrs training

Ia/n0 Mb(+) ext. contact only service use0 HV:null results

Page 56: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.13 Birth started programmes

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

St.Pierre and Layzer 1999 CCDP

HV + PE birth-5 years HV: 30-90mins wkly/biwkly PE: 30mins biwly

lowSES, mix-ethn, disadvantaged

21-24 sites E: n=2213 C:n=2217

64% all sites at 5 yrs

para-HV null results in all domains

Taylor & Beauchamp 1988 EC HV: PE birth-1 month 4, 90mins sessions

preg, primi, mix-SES, mix-ethn, mix-Ed

hospital E :n= hosp & home PE C:n= routine care

n=12/42 HV: student nurse

Mrepr+, Mb+, Mk+ interaction+

Wagner & Clayton 1999 PAT

education HV + case management + PE

prenatal-2 years SV-PAT: lowSES, <Latina Teen-PAT: lowSES, teens

SV-PAT E:n=298 HV C:n=199 Teen-PAT: E1:n=175 HV + PAT + case management E2:n=174 case management E3:n=177 PAT C:n=178

SV-PAT: 43% from programme 27% from evaluation

para-HV Id0, Ih0, Mk(+), Mb(+), Mrepr (+) dose effects

Ware & Osofsky 1987 MIP

HV + drop-in-centre + 24hr-telephone line

birth-30 months HV: wkly-reducing centre: wkly

mix-ethn teens E: n=54 C1:n=24 routine care C2:n=28 non-engagers

30-40% 2/4 HVs

para-HV Ia0, Ic+/0 Mb+ interaction+/0 sleeper effects overall null results

Wendland-Carro et al. 1999 ATT NBAS

video & talk re: M-I-interaction vs caregiving skills

1 hr only lowSES, primi, married

maternity ward E:n=17 video + talk re M-I-interaction C:n=19 video + talk re caregiving

n=2 Researcher Mb+ interaction+

Widmayer & Field 1981 TRANS NBAS with/ without MABI (adaptation of NBAS for Ms)

birth-4 weeks 5 sessions

lowSES, Bl, teen, preterm

hospital, assessment at home

E1:n= NBAS + MABI E2:n= MABI C:n= questionnaire on I-development total n=30

researcher Id+, Ic+? interaction+

Wingerd Bristor et al 1984 parent coaching / skills training

birth-3 days (days 1, 2, &7 post-birth)

primi, mix-SES, intact families

private paediatric clinic

E:n=21 P-coaching C1:n=21 routine care C2:n=21 exp. decliners

n=23 Ib+/0 Mb+/0 interaction+

Page 57: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.14 Later started programmes

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Baker et al. 1999 HIPPY HV + preschool + P-groups vs preschool

2 years HV: 30-60mins biwkly P-group: biwkly

<AA, limited Ed Ps & preschoolers

3 sites E:n=37-63 HV + preschool + P-group C:n=32-66 preschool

9-28% for sites

para-HV varied for cohorts/sites Ic+/-

Carter et al. 1991 AMIP PD mother-baby class

Case 1: 11 weeks Case 2: prenatal- 13 months

lowSES, teen referral 2 single case studies

N/A, but case 2 irregular attendance

therapist Id+, Imh+ Mb+/0 interaction+

Cohen et al. 1999 WWW vs PPT

PD WWW vs PPT 5 months 1 hr wkly 8-18 sessions

Is <30mths with att, b, sleep, eat problems

C’s mental health centre

E :n=34 WWW C:n=33 PPT

n=6 4 I-mental health therapists

Iatt+, Imh+, Ic+ Mb+/0, Mmh+, Mrepr+ WWW>PPT

Cordeiro 1997 PD PPT 6-24 months 12-12? sessions or more

Is<3 years with attachment,functional, behavioural problems

GPs, paediatricians

E:n=114 C: N/A

n=26 multi: PSY, clin. P, nurse

15.1%: not improved 56.5%: improved 28.3%: greatly improved Cs <24mths benefit more

Cramer 1998 Interactional Guidance (IG) vs Psychodynamic Psychotherapy (PPT)

PD, IG IG vs PPT 6 sessions (max. 10 sessions)

Is<30mths, functionally & behaviourally disturbed

child guidance clinic

E:n= IG C:n= PPT total n=38

n=6 therapist Ib+/0 Mb+, Mrepr+/0, Mmh+ interaction+ overall IG=PPT

Davis & Spurr, 1998 Guidance and support

HV, manualised From referral (Mean 2.5 yrd) for 2-25 sessions (average 7.8)

Low SES , referred, behav probs and/or parent depression

Health visitrs, GP or self

E: n=55 C: comparison n=38 (routine care)

31% initially (60/87), further drop out 5

Specially trained HV or mental health worker

Mmh+, Mself esteem+ M Stress+ Mrep+, Home environment+ Cb+

Drell 1992 TRANS multimodal therapy : dynamic, behavioural, family approach

female toddler E. aged 2yrs, behaviour out-of-control

referral single case study N/A therapist Ib+ Mb+

Page 58: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.14 Later started programmes

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Free et al. 1996 accuracy in interpreting C’s emotion: Ms with vs without psychotherapy

1 session of rating photographs

depressed Ms & their Cs, m-c, <Cau

day-care centre, P-groups, newspapers, advertising, clinics

E:n=43 depressed Ms with psychotherapy C1:n=10 depressed Ms without therapy C2:n=31 non-depressed Ms

psychotherapy increases accuracy in interpretation of (especially neg.) emotions in depressed Ms & their Cs

Grantham-McGregor et al. 1991 JS

HV : nutrition with/without stimulation

2 years 1hr wkly

LowSES, growth stunted Is

health clinic E1:n=32 stunted, nutr&stimul E2:n=30 stunted stimulated E3:n= nutrition C1: n=33 / stunted C2:n=32 / non-stunted

para-Hv: ethnic peer

Id+

Green et al. 1981 PD HV, PPT, C, P-groups

5-36 months 6 sessions or more

abusing Ps referrals E: n=79 multi-intervention C: N/A

N/A HV: multi-disciplinary

Ia/n+ Mrepr+, Mb+ HV/combined approach effective dose effects

Hancock 1998 HV based on Iwaniec (1995)

more than 1 year

Amy aged 2.5 yrs, FTT, emotionally abused

referral single case study N/A HV: health visitor

Ib+, Ih+ Mb+

Kaukonen & Tamminen 1998 PD systems behavioural

psychiatric I-family day-ward for all family members

3 weeks daily 9:30am-2pm

at/multiple-risk dysfunctional families

referrals E:n=81 families C: N/A

multi: nurses, PSY, family therapists

26% re-admission, 26% successful, 29% continued treatment at local guidance clinic

Leifer & Smith 1990 EC PD

MIT & PT 13 mths twice wkly 84 sessions

Ella & Tim aged 4 mths, FTT, M development delayed, depressed

referral single case study N/A therapist Ic0, Iatt+, Ib+ Mb=+/0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+ pregnancies-

Lieberman et al. 1991 PD HV: MIT 1 year 1.5hrs wkly

lowSES, HIS, immigrants, anxious dyads

paediatric clinic E:n=29 MIT anxious C1:n=23 anxious C2:n=30 secure

n=18 HV: bilingual MSC psychologists or SW

Ib+ Mrepr0, Mb+

Page 59: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.14 Later started programmes

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Lyons-Ruth et al. 1990

HV: prof vs para-professional visitors

13.3 (9-18) mths 1hr wkly 46.7 visits mthly drop-in hour

lowSES, depressed, inadequate Ms

HES-services E1:n= prof HV+P-group E2:n=10 para HV+drop-in-hour C1:n=10 / high-risk C2:n=35 / community Is/non-depressed Ms

n=9 para-HV: ethnic mothers, prof-HV: MSC-psychologist

Iatt+, Ic+, Mb0 para=prof service

McDonough 1993 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

4 months HV: 3 visits, 6-wkly Playroom: 12 sessions, wkly

Lisa & Sam Jr, aged 4 mths, NOFT

referral 1 single case study

N/A therapist Ih+, Imh+ Mb+, Mpd+ interaction+

Minde & Tidmarsh 1997 PD MIT +/ PT +/ PPT +/ P-groups

<5->10 sessions

teen, Cau, m-c, <marr, Is with disruptive behaviour

C’s hospital E: n=57 C: N/A

n=3 multi: 20 staff Ib+

Muir 1992 WWW

PD object relations

WWW 12 (8-20) sessions 50mins wkly

Jan & son Troy, aged 10.5mths, NOFT

referral single case study N/A therapist Ib+, Ih+, Id+ Mrepr+, Mb+

Muir & Thorlaksdottir 1994 WWW

PD object relations

WWW 6-13 weeks 1hr wkly

referral 4 single case studies

N/A therapist

Osofsky & Dickson 2000 VIP

PD play therapy crisis intervention

10-12 months wkly (-reducing) & booster sessions

Cs with PTSD due to witnessing violence/M’s death, Carl & Chad Bobby

referral E:n=35 2 single case studies

N/A therapist

Powell & Grantham-McGregor 1989

HV 2 years wkly, biwkly, or mthly

lowSES, <Bl, <lowEd, <single

health clinic E1st study:n=152 wkly or mthly HV E2nd study:n=58 wkly HV Cs: n= no HV

8.5% (1st study)

para-HV: ethnic peers 8 wks training

Ic+ dose effects sleeper effect?

Page 60: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.14 Later started programmes

Study Model Intervention Duration Intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Proulx & Minde 1995 PD group-based PT for fathers & Is

10 weeks 2.5hrs wkly

fathers unable to relate to toddlers

E:n=5 father’s & I’s group C: N/A

PSY, art therapist

Fk+, Fb+

Puura et al. 2000 EEP

EU/WHO HV + need/risk assessment

Prenatal-onwards 1pre- & 1postnatal assessment wkly sessions

n=1000 at-risk & low-risk families in 5 countries

E1:n=50 no-need/low-risk E2:n=50 in-need C1:n=50 no-need C2:n=50 in-need

N/A primary health care professionals

not available yet

Robert-Tissot et al. 1996 PD PPT vs IG 9.3 weeks 6.1 (1-12) sessions

functionally & behaviourally disturbed Is, aged <30mths, mixSES, intact families

child guidance clinic

E:n= PPT C:n= IG total n=75

n=10 refusals, n=37/75

IG: P & speech therapist PPT: 4 PSY

Ib+ Mb+, Mrepr+/0 interaction+ PPT=IG sleeper effects

Scarr & McCartney 1988 MCHP

HV: PE (vs book)

2 years biwkly 46 visits

LowSES E:n=78 HV-PE C:n=39 /

7% refusals n=4 re data

para-HV: ethnic peers

Ic(+) Mb(+) null/ceiling effects

Seifer et al. 1991 Interaction trans-disciplinary model

Ps counselling & video interaction coaching (IC) for Is with developmental disabilities

10 months IC: 6 sessions P-group: wkly

Is with developmental disabilities

multi: e.g. hospitals, practitioners,

E:n=23 IC + Ps counselling group C:n=P-group, no IC but video watching

P, SW Ib+, Id+ Mb+,

Page 61: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.15 Minimal/very brief programmes lasting for one/few sessions

Study Model Intervention Duration

Intensity Participants Recruitment Condition

n Attrition Provider Outcomes

Belsky 1985, 1986 PIFDP

NBAS active exposure to NBAS, Ms only vs couple

primi, Wh, marr

obstetric practice

E1:n=15 couple NBAS E2:n=15 Ms NBAS C1:n=15 C2:n=15 verbal report of NBAS

n=7/67 dropouts

Pb+ interaction 0

Juffer et al. 1997 ATT HV: MIT + book vs book

3 visits interracially adopted Is

adoption agency E1:n=30 MIT+book E2:n=30 book C:n=30 /

n=17 HV: 3 researchers with MSC

Iatt+, Ib+ Mb+ E2:0 effects

Kaukonen & Tamminen 1998 PD systems behavioural

psychiatric I-family day-ward for all family members

3 weeks daily 9:30am-2pm

at/multiple-risk dysfunctional families

referrals E:n=81 families C: N/A

multi: nurses, PSY, family therapists

26% re-admission, 26% successful, 29% continued treatment at local guidance clinic

Leib et al. 1980 stimulation sensory enrichment programme

Birth – hospital discharge ?

preterm Is, Wh, m-c,

neonatal intensive care unit

E:n=14 stimulation C:n=14 routine care

nurses Id+, Ih0 (weight gain)

Liptak et al. 1983 NBAS NBAS 1 session m-c, Wh, primi, <marr

hospital E: n= NBAS + routine care C1:n= 1 visit by author C2:n= phys. I-examination in front of M total n=75

n=9 refusals n=4/75 dropouts

Mb+ interaction0

Myers 1982 NBAS active P-exposure to NBAS-exam in hospital, Ms vs fathers only

1 45-60mins session

primi, m-c, <Wh, couples

hospital E1:n= Ms NBAS E2:n= Fs NBAS C:n= no NBAS total n=42

n=2 Pk+, Pb+/0, Prepr(+)

Page 62: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.15 Minimal/very brief programmes lasting for one/few sessions

Study Model Intervention Duration

intensity Participants Recruitment Condition

n Attrition Provider Outcomes

Schanberg & Field 1987 stimulation Tactile kinesthetic stimulation

10 days 45mins daily

premature, LBW neonates

hospital E:n=26 t/k-stimulation C:n= routine care

Ib+, Ih+, Id+ service use+ cost-effective early discharge

Strayhorn & Weidman 1991 P-group training in interaction

0-12.5 hrs training

lowSES, mix-ethn, Cs with behaviour problems

varied, e.g. Head Start

E:n=50 extensive training C:n=48 pamphlet

n=21 research assistant

Ic0, Ib+ Mb+

Taylor & Beauchamp 1988 EC HV: PE birth-1 month 4, 90mins sessions

preg, primi, mix-SES, mix-ethn, mix-Ed

hospital E :n= hosp & home PE C:n= routine care

n=12/42 HV: student nurse

Mrepr+, Mb+, Mk+ interaction+

Wendland-Carro et al. 1999 ATT NBAS

Video & talk re: M-I-interaction vs caregiving skills

1 hr only lowSES, primi, married

maternity ward E:n=17 video + talk re M-I-interaction C:n=19 video + talk re caregiving

n=2 researcher Mb+ interaction+

Widmayer & Field 1981 TRANS NBAS with/ without MABI (adaptation of NBAS for Ms)

birth-4 weeks 5 sessions

lowSES, Bl, teen, preterm

hospital, assessment at home

E1:n= NBAS + MABI E2:n= MABI C:n= questionnaire on I-development total n=30

researcher Id+, Ic+? interaction+

Wingerd Bristor et al 1984 Parent coaching / skills training

birth-3 days (days 1, 2, &7 post-birth)

primi, mix-SES, intact families

private paediatric clinic

E:n=21 P-coaching C1:n=21 routine care C2:n=21 exp. Decliners

n=23 Ib+/0 Mb+/0 interaction+

Wright et al. 1998 PP

HV 1visit or more NOFT, <2yrs health district E:n=95 HV+routine care C:n=109 routine care

complex HV: research nurse, health visitor, dietician

Ih+

Page 63: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.16 short duration prgrammes lasting up to one year

Study Model Intervention

Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Bakermans-Kranenburg et al. 1998 behaviour vs representations

ATT MIT: behav. vs behav + repres level

3 months 1.5-3hrs 4 visits

Primi, m-c, insecure Ms

records nurses

E1 :n=10 behav. E2 :n=10 beh+repr C:n=10

N/A HV: 2 authors Iatt0 Mb+ (E1&2) insecureM>behav dismissingM>repres

Barth 1991 CPEP EC HV 6 months 11 (5-20) visits

preg, mix-ethn, lowSES, at-risk

HES-services E:n=97 HV C:n=94 routine care

n=122 para-HV: ethnic peer

Ia/n0 null results

Black et al. 1995 EC HV with /without clinic

1 year 1hr wkly 19.2 (0-47) visits

lowSES, <AA, <single, lowEd, NOFT

paediatric primary clinic

C:n=64 HV + clinic C:n=66 clinic

20% not recruited n=14

3 para-HV Ic+, Ib+ Mb+

Booth et al. 1987 HV : MIT vs didactic/info (test of 2-step model)

prenatal-1 year

n=95 preg, Wh, multi-risk

health department

E1:n=44% MIT E2:n=56% didactic/info

nurse Mb+, Mmh+ interaction+ dose effect

Cohen et al. 1999 WWW vs PPT

PD WWW vs PPT 5 months 1 hr wkly 8-18 sessions

Is <30mths with att, b, sleep, eat problems

C’s mental health centre

E :n=34 WWW C:n=33 PPT

n=6 4 I-mental health therapists

Iatt+, Imh+, Ic+ Mb+/0, Mmh+, Mrepr+ WWW>PPT

Cramer 1998 Interactional Guidance (IG) vs Psychodynamic Psychotherapy (PPT)

PD, IG IG vs PPT 6 sessions (max. 10 sessions)

Is<30mths, functionally & behaviourally Disturbed

child guidance clinic

E:n= IG C:n= PPT total n=38

n=6 therapist Ib+/0 Mb+, Mrepr+/0, Mmh+ interaction+ overall IG=PPT

Davis & Spurr, 1998 Guidance and support

HV, manualised From referral (Mean 2.5 yrd) for 2-25 sessions (average 7.8)

Low SES , referred, behav probs and/or parent depression

Health visitrs, GP or self

E: n=55 C: comparison n=38 (routine care)

31% initially (60/87), further drop out 5

Specially trained HV or mental health worker

Mmh+, Mself esteem+ M Stress+ Mrep+, Home environment+ Cb+

Davis & Rushton 1991 PAS

other HV : support wkly 7.8 (2-25) sessions

lowSES, mult-risk, Cs with multi-problems

HES-services E:n=55 HV-support C:n=38 /

36.8% HV: health visitor, clin. medical officer

Ib+ Mb+, Mmh+, Mrepr+/0

Egeland & Erickson 1990 STEEP

ATT HV: PPT + P-group

prenatal-1 year biwkly

at-risk, primi, lowSES, lowEd

E:n=74 C:n=80

Iatt0 Mmh+, Mb+, Mrepr+

Page 64: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.16 short duration prgrammes lasting up to one year

Study Model Intervention

Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Gray et al. 1977 HV vs routine care

birth-2 years wkly

preg, at-risk Ms hospital E:n=50 high-risk HV C1:n=50 high-risk routine care C2:n=50 low-risk routine care

N/A HV: public health nurse, & lay health visitor

Ih+, Ia/n0, Id0 Mb0 service use 0 (immunisations)

Green et al. 1981 PD HV, PPT, C, P-groups

5-36 months 6 sessions or more

abusing Ps referrals E: n=79 multi-intervention C: N/A

N/A HV: multi-disciplinary

Ia/n+ Mrepr+, Mb+ HV/combined approach effective dose effects

Johnson et al. 1993 Community MP

support HV birth-1 year low SES, primi health authority E:n=127 HV + routine care E:n=105 routine care

11% para-HV: 30 ethnic peers 4 wks training

Ia/n0 Mb+, Mmh+ service use+ (immunisation)

Lieberman et al. 1991 PD HV: MIT 1 year 1.5hrs wkly

lowSES, HIS, immigrants, anxious dyads

paediatric clinic E:n=29 MIT anxious C1:n=23 anxious C2:n=30 secure

n=18 HV: bilingual MSC psycholgists or SW

Ib+ Mrepr0, Mb+

Marcenko & Spence, 1994 support HV prenatally-1year wkly-reducing

preg, AA, lowSES, at-risk for out-of-home placement

obstetric clinic E:n=110 HV+routine care C:n=77 routine care

n=58 para-HV: ethnic peer

Mss+, Mmh+, Mb0 service use+ out-of-home placement0

McDonald Culp et al. 1998 teen vs adult

education HV 6 months 1hr wkly

preg, low SES, teen&adult, <Cau,

health department

E:n=61 C: N/A

para-HV: 30hrs training

Mk+, Mb+ service use+ teen catch up on Mk

McDonough 1993 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

4 months HV: 3 visits, 6-wkly playroom: 12 sessions, wkly

Lisa & Sam Jr, aged 4 mths, NOFT

referral 1 single case study

N/A therapist Ih+, Imh+ Mb+, Mpd+ interaction+

McDonough 1995 IG Interaction Guidance (IG)

1 hr wkly multi-problem, resistant families: 2 FTT-cases: 1 resistant, 1 cogn. limited family

referral 2 single case studies

N/A therapist Ih+ Pb+, Pk+ interaction +

Page 65: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.16 short duration prgrammes lasting up to one year

Study Model Intervention

Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Muir & Thorlaksdottir 1994 WWW

PD object relations

WWW 6-13 weeks 1hr wkly

referral 4 single case studies

N/A therapist

Nye et al. 1995 MRCOP

RCT HV: PT&MG of Ms vs both Ps

10 months wkly-biwkly 28 sessions

Cau, alcoholism court records re drunk driving

E1:n=20 PT Ms E2:n=22 PT both Ps C:n=23 /

n=10 (E2) HV: MSc P or SW

Ib+

Osofsky & Dickson 2000 VIP PD play therapy crisis intervention

10-12 months wkly (-reducing) & booster sessions

Cs with PTSD due to witnessing violence/M’s death, Carl & Chad Bobby

referral E:n=35 2 single case studies

N/A therapist

Parr 1997 PIPPIN

ATT other

HV + PT-group prenatal-18wks 1hr wkly

low-risk, >Wh mixSES, primi,

E:n=98 HV+group C:n=114 waiting list

n=32 PI-facilitators Mmh+, Mrepr+, Mb+, Matt+ Fb+, Fmh+, Frepr+

Puura et al. 2000 EEP

EU/WHO HV + need/risk assessment

prenatal-onwards 1pre- & 1postnatal assessment wkly sessions

n=1000 at-risk & low-risk families in 5 countries

E1:n=50 no-need/low-risk E2:n=50 in-need C1:n=50 no-need C2:n=50 in-need

N/A HV: primary health care professionals

not available yet

Rauh et al. 1988 MITP TRANS intensive NBAS in hospital & home

3 months 11 1hr sessions (hospital: 7, home: 4 sessions)

Ps of LBW Is intensive care unit

E1:n=25 LBW NBAS C1:n=29 LBW C1:n=28 normal BW

n=15 intensive care nurse

Ic+ Mrepr+

Robert-Tissot et al. 1996 PD PPT vs IG 9.3 weeks 6.1 (1-12) sessions

functionally & behaviourally disturbed Is, aged <30mths, mixSES, intact families

child guidance clinic

E:n= PPT C:n= IG total n=75

n=10 refusals, n=37/75

IG: P & speech therapist PPT: 4 PSY

Ib+ Mb+, Mrepr+/0 interaction+ PPT=IG sleeper effects

Page 66: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.16 short duration prgrammes lasting up to one year

Study Model Intervention

Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Ross 1984 HV : PE birth-1 year biwkly-monthly

premature, lowSES, mix-ethn

medical centre E:n=40 HV-PE premature C:n=40 matched premature

n=5 HV: nurse, paediatric occ. therapist

Ic+, Imh+, Id0 Mb+, Mrepr0

Seifer et al. 1991 Interaction trans-disciplinary model

Ps counselling & video interaction coaching (IC) for Is with developmental disabilities

10 months IC: 6 sessions P-group: wkly

Is with developmental disabilities

multi: e.g. hospitals, practitioners,

E:n=23 IC + Ps counselling group C:n=P-group, no IC but video watching

P, SW Ib+, Id+ Mb+,

Siegel et al. 1980 ATT? HV vs early extended contact

birth onwards hospital: 5hrs daily 9 home visits

lowSES with normal vs complicated labour /pregnancy

hospital E1:n=47 & 60 HV & ext. contact E2:n=50 extended contact E3:n=53 HV C:n=52 & 59 routine care

n=204/525 para-HV 200hrs training

Ia/n0 Mb(+) ext. contact only service use0 HV:null results

Spencer et al. 1989 SMFWP

support HV: support/no PE

prenatal-1 year

preg, at-risk, non-Asian, n=1288

2 maternity units

E:n= support C:n= routine care

n=52 para-HV with personality/life experiences

Ih0 null results

van den Boom 1994 ATT HV: behavioural MIT

3months 2hrs 3wkly

irritable Is, Cau, lowSES, primi

hospital midwives

E1:n=25 MIT + pre-assessment E2:n=25 MIT C1:n=25 pre-treatment assessment C2:n=25

100/588 with complete data

HV: author Ib+, Ic+, Iatt+ Mb+ interaction+

Page 67: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.17 Long duration programmes lasting for more than one year

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

ABECEDARIAN Ramey & Campbell 1984 Horacek et al 1987

HV, nutrition & educational day care centre

HV: 3 years, 15 sessions/yr Centre: 5 years 6-8hrs daily

lowSES, Bl, single, cog. disadvantaged

hospital & social services

E1:n=41/25 pre-school & school E2:n=24 pre-school E3:n=21 school C:n=44/90 low-risk

20.7% overall teachers Ic+ Cs with more services benefit more (dose effects)

Baker et al. 1999 HIPPY HV + preschool + P-groups vs preschool

2 years HV: 30-60mins biwkly P-group: biwkly

<AA, limited Ed Ps & preschoolers

3 sites E:n=37-63 HV + preschool + P-group C:n=32-66 preschool

9-28% for sites

para-HV varied for cohorts/sites Ic+/-

Black et al. 1994 SPICE

EC HV : MIT + clinic vs clinic

Prenatal-18mths 1hr biwkly HV :12 (0-32) Clinic:25 (0-75) mthly-reducing

lowSES, drug abusing, single, lowEd, <AA

prenatal clinic E:n=31 HV+clinic C:n=29 clinic

10% refuse n=27

2 community nurses

Ic(+)/0 Mb+ service use(+)

Brayden et al 1993 HV + indiv. C + P-groups

Prenatal-2 years HV: mthly Groups: 44 biwkly, 5 prenatal

preg, lowSES, at-risk hospital E:n=141 high-risk C1:n=122 high-risk routine care C2:n=264 low-risk routine care

10-20% para-HV multi-team

Ia/n0/- (!) service use+ null results

Carpenter et al. 1983 SIP

HV: high vs low-risk

Birth-7 years Biwkly-mthly

general population, high-risk Is

records E: HV high-risk C: low-risk

n=1/2000 HV: research health visitor

I-mortality+

Cordeiro 1997 PD PPT 6-24 months 12-12? Sessions or more

Is<3 years with attachment,functional, behavioural problems

GPs, paediatricians

E:n=114 C: N/A

n=26 multi: PSY, clin. P, nurse

15.1%: not improved 56.5%: improved 28.3%: greatly improved Cs <24mths benefit more

Page 68: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.17 Long duration programmes lasting for more than one year

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Daro & Harding 1999 HFA

HV prenatal-3/5 years wkly or less

at-risk, mix-ethn, mix-SES newborns

E: high-risk C: low-risk

varied, no pattern

HV: professionals with degree

Ih+/0, Ia/n+/0, Id0 Mpd+/0, Mss0 interaction+ service use+/0

Duggan et al. 1999 HSP HV 3-5 years 1-4 visits mthly

lowSES, mix-ethn, at-risk Is/Cs

statewide agency

E:n=373 HV C1:n=270 / C2:n=41 / testing ctrl

51% & 12% para-HV Id+/0, Ia/n0 Mb+/0, Mpd0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+/0 service use+/0

Grantham-McGregor et al. 1991 JS

HV : nutrition with/without stimulation

2 years 1hr weekly

LowSES, growth stunted Is

health clinic E1 :n=32 stunted, nutr&stimul E2 :n=30 stunted stimulated E3 :n= nutrition C1 : n=33 / stunted C2 :n=32 / Non-stunted

para-HV: ethnic peer

Id+

Hancock 1998 HV based on Iwaniec (1995)

more than 1 year

Amy aged 2.5 yrs, FTT, emotionally abused

Referral single case study

N/A HV: health visitor Ib+, Ih+ Mb+

Hardy and Streett 1989 HV: PE + telephone line

birth-2 years 40-60mins wkly-reducing

lowSES, <Bl, <primi, <single

E:n=131 HV C:n=132 routine care

n=27 para-HV: ethnic peer

Ih+, Ia/n+ service use+

Heinicke et al. 1999 UCLA

ATT other

HV + Migroup

prenatal-2/4 years wkly-reducing group: 17 (0-43)

preg, primi, lowSES, at-risk, ethn-mix

paediatric clinic E:n=31 HV+MIgroup C:n=33 follow-up

n=6/70 HV: mental health professionals

Ib+, Iatt+, Ic0 Mb+, Mrepr+, Mmh0

Huxley & Warner 1993 CIP

HV: MIT vs routine care

prenatal-3yrs at-risk, parenting problems

multi E:n=20 MIT+routine care C:n=20 routine care

n=20 public health nurse

Ia/n+, Ih+ Mb+, Mrepr+

Page 69: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.17 Long duration programmes lasting for more than one year

Study Model Intervention Duration

intensity Participants Recruitment Condition

n Attrition Provider Outcomes

Kitzman et al. 1997 Prenatal/Early IP

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: 1 vs 2 years

prenatal-2 yrs 7(0-18) prenatal 26 (0-71)postnatal

AA, preg, primi, lowSES, single

obstetric care system

E1:n=228 2yrs HV +screen +transp E2:n=230 1yr HV +screen +transp C1:n=515 screen+transp C2:n=166 transport

4% at 2yrs nurses Ih+/0,Ic0, Ib0 Mb+/, Mh+, Mrepr+/0, Mpd0 pregnancies+ service use0 (i.e. immunisations)

Kunkel 1981

SLT others

individual residential therapy

18 months Cs: daily families: wkly

abused children aged 4-12yrs

referrals E:n=24 C: N/A

N/A therapists Ca/n+, Cmh+ 83% successful

Larson (1980) Pre- vs postnatal visits

HV: pre- vs postnatal visits

prenatal-15 months 10-11 visits 1 prenatal visit

preg, Engl/French Canadian, working class

hospital E1:n=pre- & post-natal visits E2:n=post-natal visits C:n=

n=25 HV with degee in psychology

Ih+ Mb+ interaction+ postnatal visits not enough

Leifer & Smith 1990 EC PD

MIT & PT 13 mths twice wkly 84 sessions

Ella & Tim aged 4 mths, FTT, M development delayed, depressed

referral single case study

N/A therapist Ic0, Iatt+, Ib+ Mb=+/0, Mmh+/0, Mss0 interaction+ pregnancies-

Luster et al. 1996 TIES support HV: support/no PE

(birth?)-5 years wkly

lowSES, primi, teen E:n=72 HV C:n=70 less intensive phone line service

6 para-HV Id0, Ic0 null results

Lyons-Ruth et al. 1990

HV: prof vs para-professional visitors

13.3 (9-18) mths 1hr wkly 46.7 visits mthly drop-in hour

lowSES, depressed, inadequate Ms

HES-services E1:n= prof HV+P-group E2:n=10 para HV+drop-in-hour C1:n=10 / high-risk C2:n=35 / community Is/non-depressed Ms

n=9 para-HV: ethnic mothers, prof-HV: MSC-psychologist

Iatt+, Ic+, Mb0 para=prof service

Page 70: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.17 Long duration programmes lasting for more than one year

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Olds et al. 1986

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: pre+postbirth vs prebirth

prenatal-2 yrs 1hr15mins wkly-reducing 8-9 prenatal 23 postnatal

Wh, preg, primi, teen, lowSES, >single

antenatal clinic E1:n=116 HV pre+post birth + screen + transp E2:n=100 HV pre- birth + screen + transp C1:n=90 screen + transp C2:n=94 screening

19-21% HV: nurses Ih+, Ia/n+ Mb+, Mh+, Mpd+, Mss+ pregnancies+ aid+

Powell & Grantham-McGregor 1989

HV 2 years wkly, biwkly, or mthly

lowSES, <Bl, <lowEd, <single

health clinic E1st study:n=152 wkly or mthly HV E2nd study:n=58 wkly HV Cs: n= no HV

8.5% (1st study)

para-HV: ethnic peers 8 wks training

Ic+ dose effects sleeper effect?

Scarr & McCartney 1988 MCHP

HV: PE (vs book)

2 years biwkly 46 visits

lowSES E:n=78 HV-PE C:n=39 /

7% refusals n=4 re data

para-HV: ethnic peers

Ic(+) Mb(+) null/ceiling effects

St.Pierre and Layzer 1999 CCDP HV + PE birth-5 years HV: 30-90mins wkly/biwkly PE: 30mins biwly

lowSES, mix-ethn, disadvantaged

21-24 sites E: n=2213 C:n=2217

64% all sites at 5 yrs

para-HV null results in all domains

Teerikangas et al. 1998 other HV: family counselling

5 years 50 sessions

mixed-risk maternity clinic E:n=54 HV counselling C:n=46

high HV: psychiatric nurses

Imh+

Page 71: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.17 Long duration programmes lasting for more than one year

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Wagner & Clayton 1999 PAT education HV + case management + PE

prenatal-2 years

SV-PAT: lowSES, <Latina Teen-PAT: lowSES, teens

SV-PAT E:n=298 HV C:n=199 Teen-PAT: E1:n=175 HV + PAT + case management E2:n=174 case management E3:n=177 PAT C:n=178

SV-PAT: 43% from programme 27% from evaluation

para-HV Id0, Ih0, Mk(+), Mb(+), Mrepr (+) dose effects

Ware & Osofsky 1987 MIP HV + drop-in-centre + 24hr-telephone line

birth-30 months HV: wkly-reducing centre: wkly

mix-ethn teens E: n=54 C1:n=24 routine care C2:n=28 non-engagers

30-40% 2/4 HVs

para-HV Ia0, Ic+/0 Mb+ interaction+/0 sleeper effects overall null results

Wasik et al. 1990 CARE

HV: PE + day centre vs home PE

birth-6 years wkly-reducing

at-risk, Bl, single E1:n=14 HV-PE + day care centre E2:n=23 HV-PE C:n= /

9% HV: teachers, SW, nurses

Ic+ Mb0

Page 72: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.18 Dose effects

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

ABECEDARIAN Ramey & Campbell 1984 Horacek et al 1987

HV, nutrition & educational day care centre

HV: 3 years, 15 sessions/yr Centre: 5 years 6-8hrs daily

Low SES, Bl, single, cog. disadvantaged

hospital & social services

E1:n=41/25 pre-school & school E2:n=24 pre-school E3:n=21 school C:n=44/90 low-risk

20.7% overall teachers Ic+ Cs with more services benefit more (dose effects)

Booth et al. 1987 HV : MIT vs didactic/info (test of 2-step model)

Prenatal-1 year n=95 preg, Wh, multi-risk

health department E1:n=44% MIT E2:n=56% didactic/info

nurse Mb+, Mmh+ interaction+ dose effect

Field et al. 1982 HV-based PT in I-stimulation vs nursery-based paid PT-training

Birth-6 months HV: biwkly Nursery: 4hrs daily

Low SES, Bl, teen E1:n=40 HV PT E2:n=40 nursery PT (teacher aide) C:n=40

N/A HV: psychology student with exp-teens as teacher aides

Ih+, Id+, Imh+, Ic+ Mpd+ pregnancies+ dose effects

Green et al. 1981 PD HV, PPT, C, P-groups

5-36 months 6 sessions or more

Abusing Ps referrals E: n=79 multi-intervention C: N/A

N/A HV: multi-disciplinary

Ia/n+ Mrepr+, Mb+ HV/combined approach effective, Cs with more services benefit more dose effects

IHDP 1990 EC Other

RCT HV + centre + MIgroup

Birth-3 years Wkly-reducing

LBW, preterm, ethn-mix

8 hospitals E1:n=377 HV+centre+group E2:n=330 El-low compliers C:n=512/608 follow-up

7% of recruited

HV: prof./ graduates

Ic+, Ih-/0(NOFT), Ib0, compliers<Ic+, Ib+ Mb+(HOME)

Nye et al. 1995 MRCOP

RCT HV: PT&MG of Ms vs both Ps

10 months wkly-biwkly 28 sessions

Cau, alcoholism court records re drunk driving

E1:n=20 PT Ms E2:n=22 PT both Ps C:n=23 /

n=10 (E2) HV: MSc P or SW

Ib+

Page 73: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.18 Dose effects

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Powell & Grantham-McGregor 1989

HV 2 years wkly, biwkly, or mthly

Low SES, <Bl, <lowEd, <single

health clinic E1st study:n=152 wkly or mthly HV E2nd study:n=58 wkly HV Cs: n= no HV

8.5% (1st study) para-HV: ethnic peers 8 wks training

Ic+ dose effects sleeper effect?

Wagner & Clayton 1999 PAT

Education HV + case management + PE

prenatal-2 years SV-PAT: lowSES, <Latina Teen-PAT: lowSES, teens

SV-PAT E:n=298 HV C:n=199 Teen-PAT: E1:n=175 HV + PAT + case management E2:n=174 case management E3:n=177 PAT C:n=178

SV-PAT: 43% from programme 27% from evaluation

para-HV Id0, Ih0, Mk(+), Mb(+), Mrepr (+) dose effects Latino benefit more Cs with more services benefit more (dose effects)

Ware & Osofsky 1987 MIP

HV + drop-in-centre + 24hr-telephone line

birth-30 months HV: wkly-reducing centre: wkly

mix-ethn teens E: n=54 C1:n=24 routine care C2:n=28 non-engagers

30-40% 2/4 HVs

para-HV Ia0, Ic+/0 Mb+ interaction+/0 sleeper effects overall null results engagers benefit more (dose effect?)

Page 74: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.19 Sleeper effects

Study Model Intervention Duration

intensity Participants Recruitment Condition

n Attrition Provider Outcomes

ABECEDARIAN Ramey & Campbell 1984 Horacek et al 1987

HV, nutrition & educational day care centre

HV: 3 years, 15 sessions/yr centre: 5 years 6-8hrs daily

LowSES, Bl, single, cog. Disadvantaged

hospital & social services

E1:n=41/25 pre-school & school E2:n=24 pre-school E3:n=21 school C:n=44/90 low-risk

20.7% overall teachers Ic+ Cs with more services benefit more (dose effects)

Field et al. 1982 HV-based PT in I-stimulation vs nursery-based paid PT-training

birth-6 months HV: biwkly nursery: 4hrs daily

LowSES, Bl, teen E1:n=40 HV PT E2:n=40 nursery PT (teacher aide) C:n=40

N/A HV: psychology student with exp-teens as teacher aides

Ih+, Id+, Imh+, Ic+ Mpd+ pregnancies+ dose effects sleeper effects

Olds et al. 1986

EC, ATT other

RCT HV: pre+postbirth vs prebirth

prenatal-2 yrs 1hr15mins wkly-reducing 8-9 prenatal 23 postnatal

Wh, preg, primi, teen, lowSES, >single

antenatal clinic E1:n=116 HV pre+post birth + screen + transp E2:n=100 HV pre- birth + screen + transp C1:n=90 screen + transp C2:n=94 screening

19-21% nurses Ih+, Ia/n+ Mb+, Mh+, Mpd+, Mss+ pregnancies+ aid+

Powell & Grantham-McGregor 1989

HV 2 years wkly, biwkly, or mthly

LowSES, <Bl, <lowEd, <single

health clinic E1st study:n=152 wkly or mthly HV E2nd study:n=58 wkly HV Cs: n= no HV

8.5% (1st study) para-HV: ethnic peers 8 wks training

Ic+ dose effects sleeper effect?

Puckering et al. 1994 MP

empowerment Mellow Parenting group intervention (MP)

4 months wkly

hard-to-reach Ms with severe parenting problems

varied E:n=22 MP n=7/29 MP-therapists Ia/n+ Mb+ interaction+

Page 75: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Table IV.19 Sleeper effects

Study Model Intervention Duration intensity

Participants Recruitment Condition n

Attrition Provider Outcomes

Puckering et al. 1996 MP

empowerment Mellow Parenting group intervention (MP)

4 months wkly

Linda & Andrew aged 23mths, M-I-interaction & eating problems

single case study: MP

N/A MP-therapists Ib+ Mb+, Mmh+/0, Mrepr+, Mpd+

Rauh et al. 1988 MITP TRANS intensive NBAS in hospital & home

3 months 11 1hr sessions (hospital: 7, home: 4 sessions)

Ps of LBW Is intensive care unit

E1:n=25 LBW NBAS C1:n=29 LBW C1:n=28 normal BW

n=15 intensive care nurse

Ic+ Mrepr+

Robert-Tissot et al. 1996 PD PPT vs IG 9.3 weeks 6.1 (1-12) sessions

Functionally & behaviourally disturbed Is, aged <30mths, mixSES, intact families

child guidance clinic

E:n= PPT C:n= IG total n=75

n=10 refusals, n=37/75

IG: P & speech therapist PPT: 4 PSY

Ib+ Mb+, Mrepr+/0 interaction+ PPT=IG sleeper effects

Strayhorn & Weidman 1991

P-group training in interaction

0-12.5 hrs training

LowSES, mix-ethn, Cs with behaviour problems

varied, e.g. Head Start

E:n=50 extensive training C:n=48 pamphlet

n=21 research assistant Ic0, Ib+ Mb+

van den Boom 1994 ATT HV: behavioural MIT

3months 2hrs 3wkly

Irritable Is, Cau, lowSES, primi

hospital midwives

E1:n=25 MIT + pre-assessment E2:n=25 MIT C1:n=25 pre-treatment assessment C2:n=25

100/588 with complete data

HV: author Ib+, Ic+, Iatt+ Mb+ interaction+

Ware & Osofsky 1987 MIP HV + drop-in-centre + 24hr-telephone line

birth-30 months HV: wkly-reducing centre: wkly

mix-ethn teens E: n=54 C1:n=24 routine care C2:n=28 non-engagers

30-40% 2/4 HVs

para-HV Ia0, Ic+/0 Mb+ interaction+/0 sleeper effects overall null results

Page 76: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

References

Altepeter, T. S. & Walker, C. E. (1992). Prevention of physical Abuse of Children Through Parent Training. In D. J.Willis, E. W. Holden, & M. Rosenberg (Eds.), Prevention of Child Maltreatment: Developmental and Ecological Perspectives (pp. 226-248). New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Anisfield, E., Casper, V., Nozyce, M. & Cunningham, N. (1990). Does infant carrying promote attachment? An experimental study of the effects of increased physical contact on the development of attachment. Child Development, 61, 1617-1627

Baker, A. J. L., Piotrkowski, C. S., & Brooks-Gunn, J. (1999). The Home Instruction Program for Preschool Youngsters (HIPPY). The Future of Children, 9, 116-133.

Bakermans-Kranenburg, M. J., Juffer, F., & van Ijzendoorn, M. H. (1998). Interventions with video-feedback and attachment discussions: Does type of maternal insecurity make a difference. Infant Mental Health Journal, 19, 202-219.

Barnard, K., Morisset, C. E., & Spieker, S. (1993). Preventive interventions: enhancing parent-infant relationships. In C.H. Zeanah (Ed.), Handbook of Infant Mental Health (pp. 386-401). London: The Guildford Press

Barnett W.S. (1995). Long-term effects of early childhood programs on cognitive and school outcomes. The Future of Children, 5.

Barrera, M., Doucet, D., & Kitching, K. (1990). Early home intervention and socio-emotional development of preterm infants. Infant Mental Health Journal, 11, 142-157.

Barth, R. (1991). An experimental evaluation of in-home child abuse prevention services. Child Abuse & Neglect, 15, 363-375.

Behrman, R. E. (ed.) (1993). The future of our children: Home visiting. Los Altos, CA: The David and Lucile Packard Foundation.

Belsky, J. (1985). Experimenting with the family in the newborn period. Child Development, 56, 407-414.

Belsky, J. A. (1986). A tale of two variances: between and within. Child Development, 57, 1301-1305.

Benasich, A. A., Brooks-Gunn, J., & Clewell, B. C. (1992) How do mothers benefit from early intervention programs? Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 13, 311-362.

Black, M. M., Nair, P., Kight, C., Wachtel, R., Roby, P., & Schuler, M. (1994). Parenting and early development among children of drug-abusing women: effects of home intervention. Pediatrics, 99, 440-448.

Black, M. M., Dubowitz, H., Hutcheson, J., Berenson-Howard, J., & Starr, R. H. (1995). A randomized trial of home intervention for children with failure to thrive. Pediatrics, 95, 807-814.

Page 77: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Black, M. M. & Krishnakumar, A. (1998). Children in low-income, urban settings: interventions to promote mental health and well-being. American Psychologist, 53, 635-646.

Booth, C. L., Barnard, K. E., Mitchell, S. K., & Spieker, S. J. (1987). Successful intervention with multi-problem mothers: effects on the mother-infant relationship. Infant Mental Health Journal, 8, 288-306.

Brayden, R. M., Altemeier, W. A., Dietrich, M. S., Tucker, D. D., Christensen, M. J., McLaughlin, F. J., & Sherrod, K. B. (1993). A prospective study of secondary prevention of child maltreatment. The Journal of Pediatrics, 122, 511-516.

Bronfenbrenner, U. (1974). Is early intervention effective? US Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Office of Child Development publication No. (OHD) 74-24. Government Printing Office.

Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human development: experiments by nature and design. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Bryant , D. M. & Ramey, C. T. (1987). An analysis of the effectiveness of early intervention programs for environmentally at-risk children. In M.J. Guralnick & F. C. Bennett (Eds.), The effectiveness of early intervention for at-risk and handicapped children (pp. 33-78). New York: Academic Press.

Bush, D. W. & White, K. R. (1983). The efficacy of early intervention: What can be learned from previous reviews of the literature? Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Rocky Mountain Psychological Association. In Snowbird, UT.

Carpenter, R.G., Gardner, A., Jepson, M., Taylor, E. M., Salvin, A., Sunderland, R., Emery, J. L., Pursall, E. & Roe, J. (1983). Prevention of unexpected infant death. Evaluation of the first seven years of the Sheffield Intervention Programme. The Lancet, 1(8327):723-727.

Carter, S. L., Osofsky, J. D., & Hann, D. M. (1991). Speaking for the Baby: a therapeutic intervention with adolescent mothers and their infants. Infant Mental Health Journal, 12, 291-301.

Casto, G. & Mastropieri, M. A. (1986). The efficacy of early intervention programs: A meta-analysis. Exceptional Children, 52 (5), 417-424. US: Council for Exceptional Children.

Casto, G. & White, K. (1985). The efficacy of early intervention programs with environmentally at-risk infants. In M. Frank (Ed.), Infant intervention programs: Truths and untruths (pp. 37-50). Binghampton, NY: Harworth Press.

Casto, G., White, K., & Taylor, C. (1983). Final Report 1982-83 work scope. Logan, UT: Early Intervention Research Institute, Utah State University.

Clewell, B., Brooks-Gunn, J., & Benasich, A. A. (1989). Evaluating child-related outcomes of teenage parenting programs. Family Relations, 38, 201-209.

Cohen, N. J., Muir, E., Parker, C. J., Brown, M., Lojkasek, M., Muir, R. & Barwick, M. (1999). Watch, wait, and wonder: Testing the effectiveness of a new approach to mother-infant psychotherapy. Infant Mental Health Journal, 204 (4), 429-451.

Page 78: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Coie, J. D., Watt, N. W., West, S. G., Hawkins, J. D., Asarnow, J. R., Markman, H. J., Ramey, S. L., Shure, M. B., & Long, B. (1993). The science of prevention. A conceptual framework and some directions for a national research program. American Psychologist, 48, 1013-1022.

Collaborative Group on Preterm Birth Promotion (CGPBP) (1993). Multicenter randomized, controlled trial of a preterm birth prevention program. American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology, 169, 352-366.

Combs-Orme, T., Reis, J., & Ward, L.D. (1985). Effectiveness of Home Visits by Public Health Nurses in Maternal and Child Health: an Empirical Review. Public Health Reports, 100, 490-499.

Cordeiro, M. (1997). Treating infants and mothers in psychic distress: a mental health program for infancy. Infant Mental Health Journal, 18 (2), 145-157.

Cox, A. D. (1997). Preventing child abuse: a review of community-based projects I: intervention on processes and outcome of reviews. Child Abuse Review, 6, 243-256.

Cox, A. D. (1998). Preventing child abuse: a review of community-based projects II: issues arising from reviews and future directions. Child Abuse Review, 7, 30-43.

Cramer, B. (1998). Mother-infant psychotherapies: a widening scope in technique. Infant Mental Health Journal, 19, 151-167.

Daro, D. A. & Harding, K. A. (1999). Healthy Families America: using research to enhance practice. The Future of Children, 9, 152-176.

Daro, D. & McCurdy, K. (1994). Preventing child abuse and neglect: programmatic interventions. Child Welfare, LXXIII, 405-430.

Davis, H. & Rushton, R. (1991). Counselling and supporting parents of children with developmental delay: A research evaluation. Journal of Mental Deficiency Research, 35, 89-112.

Davis, H. & Spurr, P. (1998) Parent counselling: An evaluation of a community child mental health service. Journal of Child Psychology & Psychiatry, 39, 365-376.

Dietrich, A. J. & Marton, K.I. (1982). Does continuous care from a physician make a difference? Journal of Family Practice, 15 (5), 929-937.

Drell, M. (1992). A multimodal treatment strategy for behavior problems in toddlers. Infant Mental Health Journal, 13, 231-244.

Duggan, A. K., McFarlane, E. C., Windham, A. M., Rohde, C. A., Salkever, D. S., Fuddy, L., Rosenberg, L. A., Buchbinder, S. B. & Sia, C. C. J. (1999). Evaluation of Hawaii’s Healthy Start Program. The Future of Children. Home Visiting: Recent Program Evaluations, 9 (1), 66-90.

Durlak, J. A. & Wells, A. M. (1997). Primary Prevention Mental Health Programs for Children and Adolescents: A Meta-Analytic Review. American Journal of Community Psychology, 25, 115-152.

Page 79: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Egeland, B. & Erickson, M. F. (1990). Rising above the past: Strategies for helping new mothers to break the cycle of abuse and neglect. Zero To Three, XI, 29-35.

Farran, D. C. (1990). Effects of intervention with disadvantaged and disabled children: A decade review. In S. J. Meisels & J. P. Shonkoff (Eds.), Handbook of early childhood intervention (pp. 501-539). New York: Cambridge University Press.

Field, T., Widmayer, S., Greenberg, R. & Stoller, S. (1982). Effects of parent training on teenage mothers and their infants. Pediatrics, 69, 6, 703-707.

Field, T. M., Widmayer, S. M., Stringer, S., & Ignatoff, E. (1980). Teenage, lower-class, black mothers and their preterm infants: an intervention and developmental follow-up. Child Development, 51, 426-436.

Fink, A. & McCloskey, L. (1990). Moving child abuse and neglect prevention programs forward: improving program evaluations. Child Abuse & Neglect, 14, 187-206.

Finkelhor, D. & Strapko, N. (1992). Sexual Abuse Prevention Education: A Review of Evaluation Studies. In D. J. Willis, E. W. Holden, & M. Rosenberg (Eds.), Prevention of Child Maltreatment: Developmental and Ecological Perspectives (pp. 150-167). New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Fonagy, P. (1998). Prevention, the appropriate target of infant psychotherapy. Infant Mental Health Journal, 19, 124-150.

Free, K., Alechina, I. & Zahn-Waxler, C. (1996). Affective language between depressed mothers and their children: The potential impact of Psychotherapy. Journal of American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 35, 783-790.

Fuerst, J. S. (1992, April). Why Head Start is not enough. Newsweek.

Fuerst, J. S. & Fuerst, D. (1991). Chicago experience with early childhood program: The special case of the Child Parent Center Programs. Unpublished manuscript. Loyola University, Chicago.

Garland, C., Swanson, J., Stone, N. W., & Woodruff, G. (1981). Early intervention for children with special needs and their families: Findings and recommendations. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 207 278 ed.) Seattle, WA: Washington University.

Gomby, D. S., Larner, M. B., Stevenson, C. S., Lewit, E. M., & Behrman, R. E. (1995). Long-term outcomes of early childhood programs: analysis and recommendations. The Future of Children, 5.

Gomby, D. S., Culross, P. L., & Behrman, R. E. (1999). Home visiting: recent program evaluations - analysis and recommendations. The Future of Children, 9, 4-26.

Goodson, B. D. & Hess, R. D. (1975). Parents as teachers of young children: An evaluative review of some contemporary concepts and programs. Stanford, CA: Stanford University, Department of Psychology.

Gough, D. (1994). The literature on prevention. Child Abuse Review, 3, 317-322.

Page 80: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Grantham-McGregor, S. M., Powell, C. A., Walker, S. P., & Himes, J. H. (1991). Nutritional supplementation, psychosocial stimulation, and mental development of stunted children: the Jamaican Study. Lancet, 338, 1-5.

Gray, J. D., Cutler, C. A., Dean, J. G., & Kempe, C. H. (1977). Prediction and prevention of child abuse and neglect. Child Abuse & Neglect, 1, 45-58.

Gray, S. W. & Wandersman, L. P. (1980). The methodology of home-based intervention studies: Problems and promising strategies. Child Development 51 (4), 993-1009.

Green, A. H., Power, E., Stenebrook, B., & Gaines, R. (1981). Factors associated with successful and unsuccessful intervention with child abuse families. Child Abuse & Neglect, 5, 45-52.

Halpern, R. (1984). Lack of effects for home-based early intervention? Some possible explanations. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 54, 33-42.

Hancock, P. (1998). Emotional abuse treatment and prevention, a specialist health visitor’s intervention. Child Abuse Review, 7, 58-62.

Hardy, J. B. & Streett, R. (1989). Family support and parenting education in the home: an effective extension of clinic-based preventive health care services for poor children. The Journal of Pediatrics, 115, 927-931.

Haskins, R. (1989). Beyond metaphor: efficacy of early childhood education. American Psychologist, 44, 274-282.

Heinicke, C. M. (1991). Early family intervention: Focussing on the mother’s adaptation-competence and quality of the partnership. In D. G. Unger & D. R. Powell (Eds.). Families as nurturing systems: Support across the life span, 127-142. New York: Haworth.

Heinicke, C. M. (1995). Determinants of the transition to parenting. In M. H. Bornstein (Ed.). Handbook of Parenting, 3, 277-303. Mahwah, N. J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.

Heinicke, C. M., Beckwith, L., & Thompson, A. (1988). Early intervention in the family system: a framework and review. Infant Mental Health Journal, 9, 111-141.

Heinicke, C. M., Fineman, N. R., Ruth, G., Recchia, S. L., Guthrie, D., & Rodning, C. (1999). Relationship-based intervention with at risk mothers: outcome in the first year of life. Infant Mental Health Journal, 20, 349-374.

Heinicke, C. M. & Ponce, V. A. (1999). Relation-based early family intervention. In D. Cichetti & S. L. Toth (Eds.). Rochester Symposium on Developmental Psychopathology. Vol X: Developmental approaches to prevention and intervention, 153-193. Rochester, NY: University of Rochester Press.

Helfer, R. E. (1982). A review of the literature on the prevention of child abuse and neglect. Child Abuse & Neglect, 6, 251-261.

Helfer, R. E. (1987). The perinatal period, a window of opportunity for enhancing parent-infant communication: an approach to prevention. Child Abuse & Neglect, 11, 565-579.

Herbert, M., Sluckin, W., & Sluckin, A. (1982). Mother-to-infant 'bonding'. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 23, 205-211.

Page 81: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Hewett, K. D. (1977). Partners with parents: The Home Start experience with preschoolers and their families. (Rep. No. DHEW Publication No. DHEW OHDS 78-31106). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare

Hodnett, ED. & Roberts, I. (1999). Home-based social support for socially disadvantaged mothers (Cochrane Review). The Cochrane Library [On-line].

Holden, E. W., Willis, D. J., & Corcoran, M. M. (1992). Preventing Child Maltreatment During the Prenatal/Perinatal Period. In D. J.Willis, E. W. Holden, & M. Rosenberg (Eds.), Prevention of Child Maltreatment: Developmental and Ecological Perspectives (pp. 17-46). New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Horacek, H. J., Ramey, C. T., Campbell, F. A., Hoffmann, K. P. & Fletcher, R. H. (1987). Predicting school failure and assessing early intervention with high-risk children. American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 26, 5, 758-763.

Huxley, P & Warner, R. (1993). Primary prevention of parenting dysfunction in high-risk cases. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 63 (4), 582-588.

IHDP (1990). Infant Health and Development Program: Enhancing the outcomes of low-birth-weight, premature infants. A multisite, randomized trial. JAMA, 263, 3035-3042.

Iwaniec, D. (1995). The emotionally abused and neglected child. Identification, assessment, and intervention. Chichester: Wiley.

Johnson, Z., Howell, F., & Molloy, B. (1993). Community mothers' programme: randomized controlled trial of non-professional intervention in parenting. BMJ, 306, 1449-1452.

Juffer, F., Hoksbergen, R. A. C., Riksen-Walraven, J. M., & Kohnstamm, G. A. (1997). Early intervention in adoptive families: supporting maternal sensitive responsiveness, infant-mother attachment and infant competence. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 38, 1029-1050.

Karweit, N. L. (1994). Can preschool alone prevent early learning failure? In R. E. Slavin, N. L. Karweit, & B. A. Wasik (Eds.), Preventing Early School Failure: Research, Policy, and Practice. (pp. 58-77). London: Allyn and Bacon.

Karweit, N. L. & Wasik, B. A. (1994). Extra-Year Kindergarten Programs and Transitional First Grades. In R. E. Slavin, N. L. Karweit, & B. A. Wasik (Eds.), Preventing Early School Failure: Research, Policy, and Practice. (pp. 102-121). London: Allyn and Bacon.

Kaukonen, P. & Tamminen, T. (1998). The psychiatric infant-family ward at Tempere University Hospital. Infant Mental Health Journal, 19 (2), 168-179.

Kendrick, D., Elkan, R., Hewitt, M., Dewey, M., Blair, M., Williams, D., & Brummell, K. (2000). Does home visiting improve parenting and the quality of the home environment? A systematic review and meta analysis. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 82, 443-451.

Kitzman, H., Olds, D. L., Henderson, C. R., Hanks, C., Tatelbaum, R., McConnochie, K. M., Sidora, K., Luckey, D. W., Shaver, D., Engelhardt, K., James, D., & Barnard, K. (1997). Effect of prenatal and infancy home visitation by nurses on pregnancy outcomes, childhood injuries, and repeated childbearing: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Medical Association, 278, 644-652.

Page 82: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Kunkel, B. E. (1981). Successful nurturing in residential treatment for abused children. Child Abuse and Neglect, 5, 249-255.

Lamb, M. E. & Hwang, C.-P. (1982). Maternal attachment and mother-infant bonding: A critical review. In M. E. Lamb & A. L. Brown (Eds.), Advances in Developmental Psychology Vol. 2 ed., Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

Larson, C. P. (1980). Efficacy of prenatal and postpartum home visits on child health and development. Pediatrics, 66, 191-197. Lazar, I. & Darlington, R. (1982). ‘Lasting effects of early education’, Monographs of the Society of research in Child Development, 47(2-3), Serial No. 195. Lealman, G. T., Haigh, D., Phillips, J. M., Stone, J., & Ord-Smith, C. (1983). Prediction and prevention of child abuse – an empty hope? Lancet, 1, 1423-1424.

Leib, S. A., Benfield, G. & Guidubaldi, J. (1980). Effects of Early Intervention and Stimulation on the Preterm Infant. Pediatrics, 66 (1), 83-90.

Leifer, M., Wax, L.C., Leventhal-Belfer, L., & Fouchia, A., et al (1989). The use of multitreatment modalities in early intervention: a quantitative case study. Infant Mental Health Journal, 10(2), 100-116.

Leifer, M. & Smith, S. (1990). Preventive intervention with a depressed mother with mental retardation and her infant: a quantitative case study. Infant Mental Health Journal, 11, 301-314.

Levitt, E. & Cohen, S. (1975). An analysis of selected parent intervention programs for handicapped and disadvantaged children. Journal of Special Education, 9, 345-365.

Liaw, F. (1991). The efficacy of early intervention for low birth weight infants: What works, how, and for whom? unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Michigan.

Lieberman, A. F., Weston, D. R., & Pawl, J. H. (1991). Preventive intervention and outcome with anxiously attached dyads. Child Development, 62, 199-209.

Lipsey, M. W. & Wilson, D. W. (1993). The efficacy of psychological, educational, and behavioral treatment: confirmation from meta-analysis. American Psychologist, 48, 1181-1209.

Liptak, G. S., Keller, B. B., Feldman, A. W., & Chamberlin, R. W. (1983). Enhancing infant development and parent-practitioner interaction with the Brazelton Neonatal Assessment Scale. Pediatrics, 72, 71-78.

Lojkasek, M., Cohen, N. J., & Muir, E. (1994). Where is the infant in infant intervention? A review of the literature on changing troubled mother-infant relationships. Psychotherapy, 31, 208-220.

Luster, T., Perlstadt, H., McKinney, M., Sims, K. & Juang, L. (1996) The effects of afamily support program and other factors on the home environments provided by adolescent mothers. Journal of Applied Family & Child Studies, 45, 255-264.

Lyons-Ruth, K., Botein, S., & Grunebaum, H. U. (1984). Reaching the hard-to-reach: serving isolated and depressed mothers with infants in the community. In Cohler & Musick (Eds.), Intervention with physically disabled parents and their young children. New Directions for Mental Health Services No. 24 (pp. 95-122). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Page 83: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Lyons-Ruth, K., Connell, D. B., Grunebaum, H. U., & Boetin, S. (1990). Infants at social risk: maternal depression and family support services as mediators of infant development and security of attachment. Child Development, 61, 85-98.

MacMillan, H. L., MacMillan, J. H., Offord, D., Griffith, L., & MacMillan, A. (1994a). Primary prevention of child physical abuse and neglect: a critical review. Part I. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 35, 835-856.

MacMillan, H. L., MacMillan, J. H., Offord, D. R., Griffith, L., & MacMillan, A. (1994b). Primary prevention of child sexual abuse: a critical review. Part II. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 35, 857-876.

Marcenko, M. O. & Spence, M (1994). Home visitation services for at-risk pregnant and postpartum women: A randomized trial. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 64 (3), 468-478

Margolis, P, Lannon, C., Stevens, R., Harlan, C., Bordley, W. et al., (1996) Linking clinical and public health approaches to improve access to health care for socially disadvantaged mothers and children. A feasibility study. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 150, 815-821.

McDonald Culp, A., Blankemeyer, M., & Passmark, L. (1998). Parent education home visitation program: adolescent and nonadolescent mother comparison after six months of intervention. Infant Mental Health Journal, 19, 111-123.

McDonough, S. C. (1993). Interaction Guidance: understanding and treating early infant-caregiver relationship disturbances. In C.H.Zeanah (Ed.), Handbook of infant mental health (pp. 414-426). London: The Guildford Press.

McDonough, S. C. (1995). Promoting positive early parent-infant relationships through interaction guidance. Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 4, 661-672.

McGuire, J. & Earls, F. (1991). Prevention of psychiatric disorders in early childhood. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 32, 129-154.

Meisels, S. J., Dichtelmiller, M., & Liaw, F.-R. (1993). A multidimensional analysis of early childhood intervention programs. In C.H.Zeanah (Ed.), Handbook of infant mental health (pp. 361-385). London: The Guildford Press.

Minde, K. & Tidmarsh, L. (1997). The changing practices of an infant psychiatry program: the McGill experience. Infant Mental Health Journal, 18, 135-144.

Moxley-Haegert, L. & Serbin, L. A. (1983). Developmental education for parents of delayed infants: Effects on parental motivation and children’s development. Child Development, 54, 1324-1331.

Muir, E. (1992). Watching, waiting, and wondering: applying psychoanalytic principles to mother-infant intervention. Infant Mental Health Journal, 13, 319-328.

Muir, E. E. & Thorlaksdottir, E. (1994). Psychotherapeutic intervention with mothers and children in day care. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 64 (1), 60-67.

Myers, B. J. (1982). Early intervention using Brazelton training with middle-class mothers and fathers of newborns. Child Development, 53, 462-471.

Page 84: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Nye, C. L., Zucker, R. A., & Fitzgerald, H. E. (1995). Early intervention in the path to alcohol problems through conduct problems: treatment involvement and child behavior change. Journal of Consulting & Clinical Psychology, 63, 831-840.

Oates, R.K., Gray, J., Schweitzer, L., Kempe, R.S. et al. (1995) A therapeutic preschool for abused children: the Keepsafe Project. Child Abuse & Neglect, 19, 221-230.

Olds, D. L., Henderson, C. R., Tatelbaum, R., & Chamberlin, R. (1986). Improving the delivery of prenatal care and outcomes of pregnancy: a randomized controlled trial of nurse home visitation. Pediatrics, 77, 16-28.

Olds, D. L. & Kitzman, H. (1990). Can home-visitation improve the health of women and children at environmental risk? Pediatrics, 86, 108-116.

Olds, D. L. & Kitzman, H. (1993). Review of research on home visiting for pregnant women and parents of young children. The Future of Children, 3, 123-165.

Osofsky, J. D. & Dickson, A. (2000). Treating traumatized children: the costs of delay. Zero To Three, 20, 20-24.

Parr, M. (1997). Description of a study evaluating a new approach to preparation for parenting for women and men in the transition to parenthood (Hertfordshire Longitudinal Study, 1989-1993). Unpublished report.

Patterson, D. M. & Barnard, K. E. (1990). Parenting of low birth weight infants: A review of issues and interventions. Infant Mental Health Journal, 11, 37-56.

Pfander, S. & Bradley-Johnson, S. (1990). Effects of an intervention program and its components on NICU infants. Children’s Health Care, 19, 140-146.

Powell, C. & Grantham-McGregor, S. (1989). Home visiting of varying frequency and child development. Pediatrics, 84, 157-164.

Proulx, L. & Minde, K. (1995). Un groupe pour pères et enfants. Psychiatrie, Recherche et Intervention en Santé Mentale de l’Enfant (P.R.I.S.M.E.), 5, 191-200

Puckering, C., Rogers, J., Mills, M., Cox, A. D., & Mattsson-Graff, M. (1994). Process and evaluation of a group intervention for mothers with parenting difficulties. Child Abuse Review, 3, 299-310.

Puckering, C., Evans, J., Maddox, H., Mills, M., & Cox, A. D. (1996). Taking control: a single case study of Mellow Parenting. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 1, 539-550.

Puura, K., Davis, H., Papadopoulos, K., Tsiantis, J., Ispanovic-Radojkovic, V., Rudic, N., Tamminen, T., Turunen, M-M., Dragonas, T., Paradisiotou, A., Visakou, S., Day, C., Roberts, R. & Cox. A. (2000). The European Early Promotion Project: A new primary health care service to promote children’s mental health. Unpublished document, University of Tampere, Finland.

Ramey, C. T., Bryant, D. M., & Suarez, T. M. (1985). Preschool compensatory education and the modificability of intelligence: A critical review. In D. K. Detterman (Ed.), Current topics in human intelligence Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. (pp. 247-256).

Page 85: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Ramey, C. T. & Campbell, F. A. (1984). Preventive education for high-risk children: Cognitive consequences of the Carolina Abecedarian Project. Special Issue: American Journal of Mental Deficiency, 88 (5), 515-523.

Rauh, V. A., Achenbach, T. M., Nurcombe, B., Howell, C. T., & Teti, D. M. (1988). Minimizing adverse effects of low birthweight: four-year results of an early intervention program. Child Development, 59, 544-553.

Raven, J. (1980). Intervention as interference – CORE 4, Fiche 5, E13.

Reader, L. (1984). Pre-school intervention programmes. Child: Care, Health, and Development, 10, 237-251.

Roberts, I., Kramer, M., & Suissa, S. (1996). Does home visiting prevent childhood injury? A systematic review of randomized controlled trials. British Medical Journal, 312, 29-32.

Robert-Tissot, C., Cramer, B., Stern, D. N., Serpa, S. R., Bachmann, J-P., Palacio-Espasa, F., Knauer, D., De Muralt, M., Berney, C. & Mendiguren, G. (1996). Outcome evaluation in brief mother-infant psychotherapies: Report on 75 cases. Infant Mental Health Journal, 17 (2), 97-114.

Ross, G. S. (1984). Home intervention for premature infants of low-income families. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 54 (2), 263-270.

Rossi, P. H. (1992). Assessing Family Preservation Programs. Children and Youth Services Review, 14, 77-97.

Sandow, S. A., Clarke, A. D. B., Cox, M. V. & Stewart, F. L. (1981). Home intervention with parents of severely subnormal pre-school children: A final report. Child: Care, Health and Development, 7, 135-144.

Scarr, S. & McCartney, K. (1988). Far from home: an experimental evaluation of the Mother Child Home Program in Bermuda. Child Development, 59, 531-543.

Scarr, S. & Weinberg, R. A. (1986). The early childhood enterprise: care and education of the young. American Psychologist, 41, 1140-1146.

Schanberg, S M. & Field, T. M. (1987). Sensory deprivation stress and supplemental stimulation in the rat pup and preterm human neonate. Child Development, 58, 1431-1447.

Schorr, L. B. & Schorr, D. (1988). Within our reach: Breaking the cycle of disadvantage. Garden City, NY: Doubleday/Anchor.

Scott, S. (1998). Intensive interventions to improve parenting. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 79, 90-93.

Seifer, R., Clark, G. N., & Sameroff, A. J. (1991). Positive effects of interaction coaching on infants with developmental disabilities and their mothers. American Journal on Mental Retardation, 96, 1-11.

Shonkoff, J. P. & Hauser-Cram, P. (1987). Early intervention for disabled infants and their families: a quantitative analysis. Pediatrics, 80, 650-658.

Page 86: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Siegel, E., Bauman, K. E., Schaefer, E. S., Saunders, M. M. & Ingram, D. D. (1980). Hospital and home support during infancy: Impact of maternal attachment, child abuse and neglect, and health care utilization. Pediatrics, 66, 183-190.

Simeonsson, R. J., Cooper, D. H., & Scheiner, A. P. (1982). A review and analysis of the effectiveness of early intervention programs. Pediatrics, 69, 635-641.

Slavin, R. E., Madden, N. A., Karweit, N. L., Dolan, L. J. & Wasik, B. A., (1994). Success for All: A comprehensive Approach to Prevention and Early Intervention. In R.E. Slavin, N. L. Karweit, & B. A. Wasik (Eds.), Preventing Early School Failure: Research, Policy, and Practice. (pp. 175-205). London: Allyn and Bacon.

Sokol, R. J., Woolf, R. B., Rosen, M. G., & Weingarden, K. (1980). Risk, antepartum care, and outcome: impact of a maternity and infant care project. Obstetrics & Gynecology, 56, 150-156.

Sparling, J., Lewis, I., Ramey, C. T., Wasik, B. H., Bryant, D. M. & La Vange, L. M. (1991). Partners: A curriculum to help premature, low-birth-weight infants get off to a good start. Topics in Early Childhood Special Education, 11, 36-55.

Spence Boocock, S. (1995). Early childhood programs in other nations: goals and outcomes. The Future of Children, 5.

Spencer, B., Thomas, H. & Morris, J. (1989). A randomized controlled trial of the provision of a social support service during pregnancy: the South Manchester Family Worker Project. British Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 96, 281-288.

Spivak, H. R., Bonanno, R. A. & Cracknell, M. (1980). Patient and provider factors associated with selected measures of quality of care. Pediatrics, 65 (2), 307-313.

St.Pierre, R. G., Layzer, J. I., & Barnes, H. V. (1995). Two-generation programs: design, cost, and short-term effectiveness. The Future of Children, 5.

St.Pierre, R. G. & Layzer, J. I. (1999). Using home visits for multiple purposes: the Comprehensive Child Development Program. The Future of Children, 9, 151.

Strayhorn, J. M. & Weidman, C. S. (1991). Follow-up one year after parent-child interaction training: effects on behavior of preschool children. Journal of American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 30, 138-143.

Taylor, D. K. & Beauchamp, C. (1988). Hospital-based primary prevention strategy in child abuse: a multi-level needs assessment. Child Abuse & Neglect, 12, 343-354.

Teerikangas, O. M., Aronen, E. T., Martin, R. P. & Huttunen, M. O. (1998). Effects of infant temperament and early intervention on the psychiatric symptoms of adolescents. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 37 (10), 1070-1076.

van den Boom, D. C. (1994). The influence of temperament and mothering on attachment and exploration: an experimental manipulation of sensitive responsiveness among lower-class mothers with irritable infants. Child Development, 65, 1457-1477.

van den Boom, D. C. (1995). Do first-year intervention effects endure? Follow-up during toddlerhood of a sample of Dutch irritable infants. Child Development 66, 1799-1816.

Page 87: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

von Hofacker, N. & Papousek, M. (1998). Disorders of excessive crying, feeding, and sleeping: The Munich Interdisciplinary Research and Intervention Program. Infant Mental Health Journal, 19, 180-201

van Ijzendoorn, M. H., Juffer, F., & Duyvesteyn, M. G. C. (1995). Breaking the intergenerational cycle of insecure attachment: a review of the effects of attachment-based interventions on maternal sensitivity and infant security. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 36, 225-248.

Wagner, M. M. & Clayton, S. L. (1999). The Parents as Teachers Program: results from two demonstrations. The Future of Children, 9, 91-115.

Ware, L. M., Osofsky, J. D., Eberhart-Wright, A., & Leichtman, M. L. (1987). Challenges of home visitor interventions with adolescent mothers and their infants. Infant Mental Health Journal, 8, 418-428.

Wasik, B.A., Bryant, D.M. & Lyons, C.M. (1990) Home visiting: Procedures for helping families. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage Publications, Inc.

Wasik, B. A. & Karweit, N. L. (1994). Off to a Good Start: Effects of Birth to Three Interventions on Early School Success. In R.E. Slavin, N. L. Karweit, & B. A. Wasik (Eds.), Preventing Early School Failure: Research, Policy, and Practice. (pp. 13-57). London: Allyn and Bacon.

Wasik, B. H., Ramey, C. T., Bryant, D. M., & Sparling, J. J. (1990). A longitudinal study of two early intervention strategies: Project CARE. Child Development, 61, 1682-1696.

Wasik, B. H. & Roberts, R. N. (1994). Survey of home visiting programs for abused and neglected children and their families. Child Abuse & Neglect, 18, 271-283.

Weikart, D. P., Epstein, A. S., Schweinhart, L., & Bond, J. T. (1978). The Ypsilanti preschool curriculum demonstration project. (Vols. Monograph Series No. 4) Ypsilanti, MI: High/Scope Educational Research Foundation.

Weissbourd, B. (1993). Family support programs. In C.H. Zeanah (Ed.), Handbook of infant mental health (pp. 402-413). London: The Guilford Press.

Wendland-Carro, J., Piccinini, C. A., & Stuart Millar, W. (1999). The role of an early intervention on enhancing the quality of mother-infant interaction. Child Development, 70, 713-721.

White, K. & Casto, G. (1985). An Integrative Review of Early Intervention Efficacy Studies with At-Risk Children: Implications for the Handicapped. Analysis and Intervention in Developmental Disabilities, 5, (1-2), 7-31.

White, K. R., Mastropieri, M., & Casto, G. (1984). An analysis of special education early childhood projects approved by the Joint Dissemination Review Panel. Journal of the Division of Early Childhood, 9, 11-26.

White, K. R., Taylor, M. J., & Moss, V. D. (1992). Does research support claims about the benefits of involving parents in early intervention programs? Review of Educational Research, 62, 91-125.

Page 88: from pregnancy to early childhood9 - Mental Health …...FROM PREGNANCY TO EARLY CHILDHOOD; EARLY INTERVENTIONS TO ENHANCE THE MENTAL HEALTH OF CHILDREN AND FAMILIES Volume 2 Tables

Widmayer, S. M. & Field, T. M. (1981). Effects of Brazelton demonstrations for mothers on the development of preterm infants. Pediatrics, 67, 711-714.

Wingerd Bristor, M., Helfer, R. E., & Coy, K. B. (1984). Effects of perinatal coaching on mother-infant interaction. AJDC, 138, 254-257.

Woolfson, L. H. (1999). Using a model of transactional developmental regulation to evaluate the effectiveness of an early intervention programme for pre-school children with motor impairments. Child: Care, Health & Development, 25, 55-79.

Wright, B. M. (1986). An approach to infant-parent psychotherapy. Infant Mental Health Journal, 7, 4, 247-263.

Wright, C. M., Callum, J., Birks, E. & Jarvis, S. (1988). Effect of community based management in failure to thrive: randomised controlled trial. British Medical Journal, 317, 571-574.

Wylie, C. (1994). What research on early childhood education/care outcomes can, and can't tell policymakers. (Rep. No. ISBN-0-908916-65-5). Wellington: New Zealand Council for Educational Research.

Yoshikawa, H. (1994). Prevention as cumulative protection: effects of early family support and education on chronic delinquency and its risks. Psychological Bulletin, 115, 28-54.

Zeanah, C. H., Boris, N. W., & Larrieu, J. A. (1997). Infant development and developmental risk: a review of the past 10 years. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 36, 165-178.