1
U(D54G1D)y+[!#!#!?!" President Trump’s hospitaliza- tion with the coronavirus has cat- apulted this week’s vice-presiden- tial debate into the spotlight to an extraordinary degree, putting pressure on Vice President Mike Pence and Senator Kamala Harris to use this forum to reassure an anxious public they are prepared and qualified to step in as presi- dent. Mr. Trump’s diagnosis with a potentially lethal virus — and the fact that he is 74 and his Demo- cratic rival, Joseph R. Biden Jr., is 77 — was a stark reminder that ei- ther Mr. Pence or Ms. Harris could end up being president them- selves, as opposed to just leading contenders for the nomination in 2024 and beyond. For Mr. Pence, the debate on Wednesday will most likely com- pel him to account for the adminis- tration’s record on a virus that has now infected 7.4 million Ameri- cans — including the most pro- tected man in the country, Mr. Trump — and answer for his own stewardship as chairman of the federal coronavirus task force. For Ms. Harris, a former prosecu- tor, the debate is a chance to show that she is capable of being presi- dent in a national emergency, as well as to demonstrate that she can challenge the Trump record on Covid-19 without seeming overly aggressive against an ail- ing president. Depending on how quickly Mr. Trump recovers, his condition Prepared to Grab the Reins? A Debate Gains in Importance By ADAM NAGOURNEY and SHANE GOLDMACHER Senator Kamala Harris and Vice President Mike Pence are set to square off in a debate on Wednesday at the University of Utah. LEFT, PETE KIEHART FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES; MARK MAKELA FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page A8 WASHINGTON — President Trump sought to dispel any per- ception of weakness on Sunday with a surprise and seemingly risky outing from his hospital bed to greet supporters even as his doctors once again rewrote the of- ficial narrative of his illness by ac- knowledging two alarming episodes they had previously not disclosed. The doctors said that Mr. Trump’s blood oxygen level dropped twice in the two days af- ter he was diagnosed with the co- ronavirus, requiring medical in- tervention, and that he had been put on steroids, suggesting his condition might be more serious than initially described. But they insisted that his situation had im- proved enough since then that he could be released from the hospi- tal as early as Monday. The acknowledgment of the episodes raised new questions about the credibility of the infor- mation provided about the com- mander in chief of a superpower as he is hospitalized with a disease that has killed more than 209,000 people in the United States. With the president determined not to concede weakness and facing an election in just 30 days, officials acknowledged providing rosy as- sessments to satisfy their prickly patient. Determined to reassert himself on the political stage on his third day in the hospital, Mr. Trump made an unannounced exit from Walter Reed National Military Medical Center in the early evening, climbing into his ar- mored Chevrolet Suburban to ride TROUBLING FACTS FROM PHYSICIANS UNDERCUT TRUMP Taking Risky Ride to Project Optimism By PETER BAKER and MAGGIE HABERMAN President Trump left the hospital for a brief outing that some medical experts said was reckless and endangered Secret Service agents. ALEX EDELMAN/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE — GETTY IMAGES Continued on Page A5 President Trump’s doctors of- fered rosy assessments of his con- dition on Sunday, but the few med- ical details they disclosed — in- cluding his fluctuating oxygen levels and a decision to begin treatment with a steroid drug — suggested to many infectious dis- ease experts that he is suffering a more severe case of Covid-19 than the physicians acknowledged. In photos and videos released by the White House, there is hardly any sign that Mr. Trump is sick. But at a news conference at the Walter Reed National Military Medical Center in Bethesda, Md., Mr. Trump’s doctors said his oxy- gen levels had dropped to a level that can indicate that a patient's lungs are compromised. The symptom is seen in many patients with severe Covid-19. The president’s medical team also said that he had been pre- scribed dexamethasone on Satur- day. The drug is a steroid used to head off an immune system over- reaction that kills many Covid-19 patients. The drug is reserved for those with severe illness because it has not been shown to benefit those with milder forms of the disease and may even be risky. Because of the incomplete pic- ture offered by the president’s doctors, it was not clear whether they had given him dexametha- sone too quickly, or whether the president was far sicker than has been publicly acknowledged, ex- perts in infectious disease and emergency medicine said on Sun- day. “The dexamethasone is the Steroid May Signal a Severe Case By KATIE THOMAS and RONI CARYN RABIN Continued on Page A6 DOHA, Qatar — They are here to end their fathers’ war. On both sides of the negotia- tions between the Afghan govern- ment and the Taliban are nearly a dozen children of men who played key roles in the Soviet conflict in the 1980s that set off four decades of violence and loss. Some of their fathers have since died of old age, insurgents to the end. Some faced more violent deaths, blown up in suicide bomb- ings that have become a trade- mark of the war’s brutality. Many of the ones who have survived, their chests decked out in the medals and insignia of a conflict that has inflicted misery on mil- lions, grew rich — enjoying pal- aces, political fortune, massive wealth. But they still play hide and seek with death. Those fathers fought alongside each other to drive out the Soviets, then turned their guns on each other in the power vacuum that followed, waging an atrocity-filled civil war. Now, their children know all too well what is at stake as the United States military continues its with- drawal with the peace talks in Qa- tar still up in the air: If the Afghan It Was Their Fathers’ War. They Aim to End It. By MUJIB MASHAL Facing Legacies of Strife at Afghan Peace Talks Continued on Page A11 WASHINGTON — For months, Joseph R. Biden Jr. has gone to great lengths to model responsi- ble health behavior in the corona- virus era. He wears masks in pub- lic. He does not hold crowded ral- lies. When he gives speeches, re- porters sit at a distance from one another, with white circles on the ground to mark their turf. These actions have so far helped keep Mr. Biden healthy and able to continue campaigning while President Trump, who mocked masks and held large events, is now hospitalized with Covid-19. But beyond the public examples of safety precautions, Mr. Biden’s health protocols have remained largely under wraps, with his campaign saying little about what steps it is taking to protect the 77- year-old Democratic nominee. His aides will not answer ques- tions about whether Mr. Biden is tested daily; they say simply that he is tested “regularly.” Until this weekend, they had promised to in- form the public only if he had a confirmed positive case. Then, on Saturday night, after two days of refusing to provide details about Mr. Biden’s testing procedures, the campaign committed to re- leasing the results of all of his tests. He tested negative on Sun- day, his campaign said. Transparency has taken on new significance in the presidential race given the conflicting infor- Biden Is Facing Own Questions About Testing This article is by Thomas Kaplan, Apoorva Mandavilli and Katie Glueck. Continued on Page A8 For many weeks, public health officials had expressed concern that a second wave of the corona- virus would hit New York City, which until recently had achieved striking success in beating back the outbreak after a devastating spring that left more than 20,000 residents dead. On Sunday, with those fears growing, Mayor Bill de Blasio an- nounced an emergency crack- down, saying that he intended to impose new restrictions in 20 hot spots in Brooklyn and Queens that have been experiencing rising positivity rates. The plan is a major setback for New York City, amounting to the first significant reversal in the re- opening and offering further evi- dence of the challenges in curbing the pandemic. The city over the last month had taken several strides forward, allowing indoor dining for the first time and be- coming the first major school dis- trict in the country to bring chil- dren back into its public schools. But under the new restrictions, Mr. de Blasio would close all schools — public and private — in nine of the city’s 146 ZIP codes, as well as all nonessential busi- nesses. Indoor and outdoor dining in restaurants in those areas will not be allowed. “Today, unfortunately, is not a day for celebration,” Mr. de Blasio said. “Today is a more difficult day.” The nine areas have large popu- lations of Orthodox Jews — com- munities where the virus has been spreading rapidly and where pub- lic health officials have struggled to persuade many residents to ad- here to guidelines on mask wear- ing and social distancing. Those areas all have had posi- tivity rates in recent days of more than 3 percent — and some as high as 8 percent — in contrast to the city’s overall rate of about 1.5 per- cent. Public health officials have been worried that the uptick in cases would jump from Orthodox neighborhoods to others, leading to a resurgence of the virus across the city. In another 11 ZIP codes, the city New York City Adopts Targeted Shutdowns as Hot Spots Emerge This article is by Dana Rubin- stein, Daniel E. Slotnik, Eliza Sha- piro and Liam Stack. Continued on Page A9 Rolling Back Reopening in 20 Neighborhoods Is a Major Setback “We are moving backward fast” a year after an authoritarian ruler was ousted, a former protest leader said. PAGE A10 INTERNATIONAL A10-13 Change Is Fleeting in Algeria In a documentary, the naturalist David Attenborough maps how steeply the planet’s biodiversity has diminished over his lifetime. A review. PAGE C6 ARTS C1-6 ‘A Life on Our Planet’ Londoners’ lax regard for coronavirus rules is a contrast to the revered concept of the city’s grit in World War II. PAGE A12 The Limits of a City’s Legacy You can still safely celebrate the ghoul- ish season, but trick-or-treating and other fun may have to be modified to protect against Covid-19. PAGE A4 TRACKING AN OUTBREAK A4-9 Halloween Boos and Don’ts Embracing rooftop panels to save money, homeowners have turned the coal-loving country into a powerhouse of renewable energy. PAGE B1 BUSINESS B1-7 Australia Goes Solar Tennis players at the French Open face limits on their movements in Paris. But at a hotel near the Eiffel Tower where they are staying, members of the public can get rooms. PAGE D1 SPORTSMONDAY D1-7 A Bubble That Really Isn’t HUMILITY’S BENEFITS Positive tests among the presidents’ allies show why politicians are advised to be humble. Washington Memo. PAGE A7 CREDIBILITY LOST The president’s physician confessed that he had misled the public, losing the trust of some of his peers. PAGE A6 Cases on health care and religious objections could offer early clues about how much the court shifts. PAGE A16 NATIONAL A14-17 Supreme Court’s Next Move This weekend, teams of activists can- vassed Florida to register ex-felons before a deadline on Monday. PAGE A17 Restoring Voting Rights MICHAEL REYNOLDS/EPA, VIA SHUTTERSTOCK Organizers in Washington set up 20,000 chairs on Sunday to honor 200,000 victims of Covid-19. Seating Those Who Are No Longer Here Pay-advance apps have been down- loaded millions of times, but the service comes with question marks. PAGE B1 The Cost of an Early Payday A renowned educator who battled rac- ism, Lucy Diggs Slowe empowered women at Howard University. PAGE B8 OBITUARIES A20, B8 Overlooked No More W.N.B.A. players realized the power of not saying the name of a team owner, a United States senator who criticized their activism, Kurt Streeter writes. Sports of The Times. PAGE D1 Who’s Left Unsaid Matters Aaron E. Carroll PAGE A18 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A18-19 Late Edition VOL. CLXX .... No. 58,837 © 2020 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, MONDAY, OCTOBER 5, 2020 Today, passing morning showers, af- ternoon sunshine, seasonable, high 68. Tonight, mainly clear, low 56. To- morrow, mostly sunny, high 70. Weather map appears on Page D8. $3.00

FROM PHYSICIANS TROUBLING FACTS · 10/5/2020  · PAGE C6 ARTS C1-6 A Life on Our Planet Londoners lax regard for coronavirus rules is a contrast to the revered concept of the city

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: FROM PHYSICIANS TROUBLING FACTS · 10/5/2020  · PAGE C6 ARTS C1-6 A Life on Our Planet Londoners lax regard for coronavirus rules is a contrast to the revered concept of the city

C M Y K Nxxx,2020-10-05,A,001,Bs-4C,E1

U(D54G1D)y+[!#!#!?!"

President Trump’s hospitaliza-tion with the coronavirus has cat-apulted this week’s vice-presiden-tial debate into the spotlight to anextraordinary degree, puttingpressure on Vice President MikePence and Senator Kamala Harristo use this forum to reassure ananxious public they are preparedand qualified to step in as presi-dent.

Mr. Trump’s diagnosis with apotentially lethal virus — and thefact that he is 74 and his Demo-cratic rival, Joseph R. Biden Jr., is77 — was a stark reminder that ei-ther Mr. Pence or Ms. Harris couldend up being president them-selves, as opposed to just leadingcontenders for the nomination in2024 and beyond.

For Mr. Pence, the debate on

Wednesday will most likely com-pel him to account for the adminis-tration’s record on a virus that hasnow infected 7.4 million Ameri-cans — including the most pro-tected man in the country, Mr.Trump — and answer for his ownstewardship as chairman of thefederal coronavirus task force.For Ms. Harris, a former prosecu-tor, the debate is a chance to showthat she is capable of being presi-dent in a national emergency, aswell as to demonstrate that shecan challenge the Trump recordon Covid-19 without seemingoverly aggressive against an ail-ing president.

Depending on how quickly Mr.Trump recovers, his condition

Prepared to Grab the Reins?A Debate Gains in Importance

By ADAM NAGOURNEY and SHANE GOLDMACHER

Senator Kamala Harris and Vice President Mike Pence are set tosquare off in a debate on Wednesday at the University of Utah.

LEFT, PETE KIEHART FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES; MARK MAKELA FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page A8

WASHINGTON — PresidentTrump sought to dispel any per-ception of weakness on Sundaywith a surprise and seeminglyrisky outing from his hospital bedto greet supporters even as hisdoctors once again rewrote the of-ficial narrative of his illness by ac-knowledging two alarmingepisodes they had previously notdisclosed.

The doctors said that Mr.Trump’s blood oxygen leveldropped twice in the two days af-ter he was diagnosed with the co-ronavirus, requiring medical in-tervention, and that he had beenput on steroids, suggesting hiscondition might be more seriousthan initially described. But theyinsisted that his situation had im-proved enough since then that hecould be released from the hospi-tal as early as Monday.

The acknowledgment of theepisodes raised new questionsabout the credibility of the infor-mation provided about the com-mander in chief of a superpoweras he is hospitalized with a diseasethat has killed more than 209,000people in the United States. Withthe president determined not toconcede weakness and facing anelection in just 30 days, officialsacknowledged providing rosy as-sessments to satisfy their pricklypatient.

Determined to reassert himselfon the political stage on his thirdday in the hospital, Mr. Trumpmade an unannounced exit fromWalter Reed National MilitaryMedical Center in the earlyevening, climbing into his ar-mored Chevrolet Suburban to ride

TROUBLING FACTSFROM PHYSICIANSUNDERCUT TRUMP

Taking Risky Ride toProject Optimism

By PETER BAKERand MAGGIE HABERMAN

President Trump left the hospital for a brief outing that some medical experts said was reckless and endangered Secret Service agents.ALEX EDELMAN/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE — GETTY IMAGES

Continued on Page A5

President Trump’s doctors of-fered rosy assessments of his con-dition on Sunday, but the few med-ical details they disclosed — in-cluding his fluctuating oxygenlevels and a decision to begintreatment with a steroid drug —suggested to many infectious dis-ease experts that he is suffering amore severe case of Covid-19 thanthe physicians acknowledged.

In photos and videos releasedby the White House, there ishardly any sign that Mr. Trump issick. But at a news conference atthe Walter Reed National MilitaryMedical Center in Bethesda, Md.,Mr. Trump’s doctors said his oxy-gen levels had dropped to a levelthat can indicate that a patient'slungs are compromised. Thesymptom is seen in many patientswith severe Covid-19.

The president’s medical teamalso said that he had been pre-scribed dexamethasone on Satur-day. The drug is a steroid used tohead off an immune system over-reaction that kills many Covid-19patients.

The drug is reserved for thosewith severe illness because it hasnot been shown to benefit thosewith milder forms of the diseaseand may even be risky.

Because of the incomplete pic-ture offered by the president’sdoctors, it was not clear whetherthey had given him dexametha-sone too quickly, or whether thepresident was far sicker than hasbeen publicly acknowledged, ex-perts in infectious disease andemergency medicine said on Sun-day.

“The dexamethasone is the

Steroid May Signala Severe Case

By KATIE THOMASand RONI CARYN RABIN

Continued on Page A6

DOHA, Qatar — They are hereto end their fathers’ war.

On both sides of the negotia-tions between the Afghan govern-ment and the Taliban are nearly adozen children of men who playedkey roles in the Soviet conflict inthe 1980s that set off four decadesof violence and loss.

Some of their fathers have sincedied of old age, insurgents to theend. Some faced more violent

deaths, blown up in suicide bomb-ings that have become a trade-mark of the war’s brutality. Manyof the ones who have survived,their chests decked out in themedals and insignia of a conflictthat has inflicted misery on mil-lions, grew rich — enjoying pal-

aces, political fortune, massivewealth. But they still play hide andseek with death.

Those fathers fought alongsideeach other to drive out the Soviets,then turned their guns on eachother in the power vacuum thatfollowed, waging an atrocity-filledcivil war.

Now, their children know all toowell what is at stake as the UnitedStates military continues its with-drawal with the peace talks in Qa-tar still up in the air: If the Afghan

It Was Their Fathers’ War. They Aim to End It.By MUJIB MASHAL Facing Legacies of Strife

at Afghan Peace Talks

Continued on Page A11

WASHINGTON — For months,Joseph R. Biden Jr. has gone togreat lengths to model responsi-ble health behavior in the corona-virus era. He wears masks in pub-lic. He does not hold crowded ral-lies. When he gives speeches, re-porters sit at a distance from oneanother, with white circles on theground to mark their turf.

These actions have so farhelped keep Mr. Biden healthyand able to continue campaigningwhile President Trump, whomocked masks and held largeevents, is now hospitalized withCovid-19.

But beyond the public examplesof safety precautions, Mr. Biden’shealth protocols have remainedlargely under wraps, with hiscampaign saying little about whatsteps it is taking to protect the 77-year-old Democratic nominee.

His aides will not answer ques-tions about whether Mr. Biden istested daily; they say simply thathe is tested “regularly.” Until thisweekend, they had promised to in-form the public only if he had aconfirmed positive case. Then, onSaturday night, after two days ofrefusing to provide details aboutMr. Biden’s testing procedures,the campaign committed to re-leasing the results of all of histests. He tested negative on Sun-day, his campaign said.

Transparency has taken on newsignificance in the presidentialrace given the conflicting infor-

Biden Is FacingOwn Questions

About TestingThis article is by Thomas Kaplan,

Apoorva Mandavilli and KatieGlueck.

Continued on Page A8

For many weeks, public healthofficials had expressed concernthat a second wave of the corona-virus would hit New York City,which until recently had achievedstriking success in beating backthe outbreak after a devastatingspring that left more than 20,000residents dead.

On Sunday, with those fearsgrowing, Mayor Bill de Blasio an-nounced an emergency crack-down, saying that he intended toimpose new restrictions in 20 hot

spots in Brooklyn and Queens thathave been experiencing risingpositivity rates.

The plan is a major setback forNew York City, amounting to thefirst significant reversal in the re-opening and offering further evi-dence of the challenges in curbingthe pandemic. The city over thelast month had taken severalstrides forward, allowing indoordining for the first time and be-coming the first major school dis-trict in the country to bring chil-dren back into its public schools.

But under the new restrictions,Mr. de Blasio would close allschools — public and private — innine of the city’s 146 ZIP codes, as

well as all nonessential busi-nesses. Indoor and outdoor diningin restaurants in those areas willnot be allowed.

“Today, unfortunately, is not aday for celebration,” Mr. de Blasiosaid. “Today is a more difficultday.”

The nine areas have large popu-lations of Orthodox Jews — com-

munities where the virus has beenspreading rapidly and where pub-lic health officials have struggledto persuade many residents to ad-here to guidelines on mask wear-ing and social distancing.

Those areas all have had posi-tivity rates in recent days of morethan 3 percent — and some as highas 8 percent — in contrast to thecity’s overall rate of about 1.5 per-cent. Public health officials havebeen worried that the uptick incases would jump from Orthodoxneighborhoods to others, leadingto a resurgence of the virus acrossthe city.

In another 11 ZIP codes, the city

New York City Adopts Targeted Shutdowns as Hot Spots EmergeThis article is by Dana Rubin-

stein, Daniel E. Slotnik, Eliza Sha-piro and Liam Stack.

Continued on Page A9

Rolling Back Reopeningin 20 NeighborhoodsIs a Major Setback

“We are moving backward fast” a yearafter an authoritarian ruler was ousted,a former protest leader said. PAGE A10

INTERNATIONAL A10-13

Change Is Fleeting in AlgeriaIn a documentary, the naturalist DavidAttenborough maps how steeply theplanet’s biodiversity has diminishedover his lifetime. A review. PAGE C6

ARTS C1-6

‘A Life on Our Planet’

Londoners’ lax regard for coronavirusrules is a contrast to the revered conceptof the city’s grit in World War II. PAGE A12

The Limits of a City’s Legacy

You can still safely celebrate the ghoul-ish season, but trick-or-treating andother fun may have to be modified toprotect against Covid-19. PAGE A4

TRACKING AN OUTBREAK A4-9

Halloween Boos and Don’tsEmbracing rooftop panels to savemoney, homeowners have turned thecoal-loving country into a powerhouseof renewable energy. PAGE B1

BUSINESS B1-7

Australia Goes SolarTennis players at the French Open facelimits on their movements in Paris. Butat a hotel near the Eiffel Tower wherethey are staying, members of the publiccan get rooms. PAGE D1

SPORTSMONDAY D1-7

A Bubble That Really Isn’t

HUMILITY’S BENEFITS Positive tests among the presidents’ allies showwhy politicians are advised to be humble. Washington Memo. PAGE A7

CREDIBILITY LOST The president’s physician confessed that he hadmisled the public, losing the trust of some of his peers. PAGE A6

Cases on health care and religiousobjections could offer early clues abouthow much the court shifts. PAGE A16

NATIONAL A14-17

Supreme Court’s Next Move

This weekend, teams of activists can-vassed Florida to register ex-felonsbefore a deadline on Monday. PAGE A17

Restoring Voting Rights

MICHAEL REYNOLDS/EPA, VIA SHUTTERSTOCK

Organizers in Washington set up 20,000 chairs on Sunday to honor 200,000 victims of Covid-19.Seating Those Who Are No Longer Here

Pay-advance apps have been down-loaded millions of times, but the servicecomes with question marks. PAGE B1

The Cost of an Early Payday

A renowned educator who battled rac-ism, Lucy Diggs Slowe empoweredwomen at Howard University. PAGE B8

OBITUARIES A20, B8

Overlooked No More

W.N.B.A. players realized the power ofnot saying the name of a team owner, aUnited States senator who criticizedtheir activism, Kurt Streeter writes.Sports of The Times. PAGE D1

Who’s Left Unsaid Matters

Aaron E. Carroll PAGE A18

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A18-19

Late Edition

VOL. CLXX . . . . No. 58,837 © 2020 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, MONDAY, OCTOBER 5, 2020

Today, passing morning showers, af-ternoon sunshine, seasonable, high68. Tonight, mainly clear, low 56. To-morrow, mostly sunny, high 70.Weather map appears on Page D8.

$3.00