80
LS-DYNA Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA ® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation 16 January, 2013 Oasys LS-DYNA UK Users’ Meeting, Solihull

Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA®

Yun Huang, Zhe Cui

Livermore Software Technology Corporation

16 January, 2013

Oasys LS-DYNA UK Users’ Meeting, Solihull

Page 2: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

2

Outline

1. Introduction

2. Frequency response functions

3. Steady state dynamics

4. Random vibration and fatigue

5. Response spectrum analysis

6. Acoustic analysis by BEM and FEM

7. Conclusion and future developments

Page 3: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

INTRODUCTION 1.

3

Page 4: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

4

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_FRF

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_SSD

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_RANDOM_VIBRATION_{OPTION}

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_ACOUSTIC_BEM_{OPTION}

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_ACOUSTIC_FEM

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_RESPONSE_SPECTRUM

Frequency Domain Features in LS-DYNA

New keywords for frequency domain analysis

Page 5: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

5

Frequency domain vs. time domain

A time-domain graph shows how a signal changes over time

A frequency-domain graph shows the distribution of the energy

(magnitude, etc.) of a signal over a range of frequencies

Time domain analysis

Transient analysis (penetration)

Impact (crash simulation)

Large deformation (fracture)

Non-linearity (contact)

Frequency domain analysis

Harmonic (steady state vibration)

Resonance

Linear dynamics

Long history (fatigue testing)

Non-deterministic load (random analysis)

Page 6: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

6

Time domain excitation Frequency domain excitation

Fourier Transform

A given function or signal can be converted between the time and frequency

domains with a pair of mathematical operators called a transform.

dtethH ti )()(

deHth ti)(2

1)(

Inverse Fourier

Transform

Page 7: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

7

Vehicle NVH • Interior noise

• Exterior radiated noise

• Vibration

Vehicle Durability • Cumulative damage ratio

• Expected life (mileage)

Aircraft / rocket / spacecraft vibro-acoustics

Durability analysis of machines and electronic devices

Acoustic design of athletic products

Civil Engineering • Architectural acoustics (auditorium, concert hall)

• Earthquake resistance

Off-shore platforms, wind turbine, etc. • Random vibration

• Random fatigue

Applications of the frequency domain features

Page 8: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

8

Application of LS-DYNA in automotive industry

In automotive, one model for crash, durability, NVH

shared and maintained across analysis groups

Manufacturing simulation results from LS-DYNA

used in crash, durability, and NVH modeling.

Crashworthiness

Occupant Safety

NVH

Durability

Page 9: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

9

New Databases in Frequency Domain

Keyword *DATABASE_FREQUENCY_BINARY_{OPTION}

Database lspcode used for

D3SSD 21 Steady state dynamics

D3SPCM 22 Response spectrum analysis

D3PSD 23 Random vibration

D3RMS 24 Random vibration

D3FTG 25 Random fatigue

D3ACS 26 FEM acoustics

ASCII databases

FRF: frf_amplitude, frf_angle, frf_real, frf_imag

BEM acoustics: Press_Pa, Press_dB, bepres, fringe_*,

panel_contribution_NID,

SSD: elout_ssd, nodout_ssd, …

BINARY databases

Page 10: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

FREQUENCY RESPONSE FUNCTIONS 2

10

Page 11: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

o The concept of Frequency Response Function is the foundation of modern

experimental system analysis and experimental modal analysis

o Keyword *FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_FRF

o Express structural response due to unit load as a function of frequency

o Shows the property of the structure system

o Is a complex function, with real and imaginary components. They may

also be represented in terms of magnitude and phase angle

o Result files: frf_amplitude, frf_angle

o Support efficient restart

11

Transfer function

H(ω)

Input force

F(ω)

Displacement response

X(ω)

Introduction: FRF

ωFωHωX ωF

ωXωH

Page 12: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

12

Accelerance, Inertance Acceleration

Force

Effective Mass Force

Acceleration

Mobility Velocity

Force

Impedance Force

Velocity

Dynamic Compliance,

Admittance, Receptance

Displacement

Force

Dynamic Stiffness Force

Displacement

FRF formulations

Page 13: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

Harmonic point force excitation

A

B

a

b

t

13

Reference:

Bor-Tsuen Wang, Wen-Chang Tsao. Application of

FEA and EMA to Structural Model Verification,

Proceedings of the 10th CSSV conference. Taiwan,

2002; 131-138.

Example: Accelerance FRF

for a plate

Point A

Point B

Page 14: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

14

Point A

Point B

Mode Damping ratio (0.01)

1 0.450

2 0.713

3 0.386

4 0.328

5 0.340

6 0.624

7 0.072

8 0.083

Page 15: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

15

Example: nodal force/resultant force

Left end of the beam is fixed and subjected

to z-directional unit acceleration

Nodal force and resultant force FRF at the

left end can be obtained

Resultant force FRF

Page 16: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

16

Nodal force applied and

displacement measured Example: FRF for a trimmed BIW

Page 17: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

STEADY STATE DYNAMICS 3

17

Page 18: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

18

Harmonic excitation is often encountered in engineering systems. It is

commonly produced by the unbalance in rotating machinery.

The load may also come from periodical load, e.g. in fatigue test.

The excitation may also come from uneven base, e.g. the force on tires

running on a zig-zag road.

May be called as

o Harmonic vibration

o Steady state vibration

o Steady state dynamics

Keyword *FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_SSD

Binary plot file d3ssd

)(sin)( 0 tFtF

Background

Introduction: SSD

Page 19: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

19

Example: a rectangular plate under pressure

X-Stress

Page 20: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

20

Enforced Motion

Relative displacement method

o base acceleration loading is applied through

inertial force.

o total displacement (velocity, acceleration) is

obtained by adding the relative displacement

(velocity, acceleration) to the base

displacement (velocity, acceleration).

baserelative

baserelative

baserelative

uuu

uuu

uuu

Large mass method

o a very large mass mL, which is usually 105-107

times of the mass of the entire structure, is

attached to the nodes under excitation

o a very large nodal force pL is applied to the

excitation dof to produce the desired enforced

motion. ump

umip

ump

LL

LL

LL

2

Page 21: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

21

o the rectangular plate is excited by z-

direction acceleration at one end

o steady state response at the other end

is desired

o the excitation points are fixed in

loading dof

o the resulted response is added

with base motion to get total

response

o a large mass with 106 times the original

mass is added to excitation points using

keyword *element_mass_node_set

o to produce desired acceleration, nodal

force is applied to the nodes in loading dof

o the excitation points are free in loading dof

Relative disp. method Large mass method

Page 22: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

22

Phase angle Amplitude

Page 23: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

23

Example: auto model subjected to base acl.

Modal information

Number of nodes: 290k

Number of shells: 532k

Number of solids: 3k

Base acceleration spectrum is applied to

shaker table. 500 modes up to 211 Hz are

used in the simulation. The response is

computed up to 100 Hz.

Point A Point B

Page 24: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

24

Freq = 15 Hz Freq =25 Hz

Freq = 35 Hz

Page 25: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

RANDOM VIBRATION AND FATIGUE 4

25

Page 26: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

26

o The loading on a structure is not known in a definite sense

oMany vibration environments are not related to a specific driving frequency

(may have input from multiple sources)

oProvide input data for random fatigue and durability analysis

oExamples:

Fatigue

Wind-turbine

Air flow over a wing or past a car body

Acoustic input from jet engine exhaust

Earthquake ground motion

Wheels running over a rough road

Ocean wave loads on offshore platforms

Freq (Hz)

Acc

eler

atio

n P

SD

(g^2/H

z)

Freq (Hz)

SP

L (

dB

)

Loading: PSD or SPL

Why we need random vibration analysis?

2,

2

dff

dff

Introduction: Random Vibration

Based on Boeing’s N-FEARA package

Page 27: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

27

Card 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Variable SID STYPE DOF LDPSD LDVEL LDFLW LDSPN CID

Type I I I I I I I I

Default

Keyword

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_RANDOM_VIBRATION

The multiple excitations on structure can be

• uncorrelated

• partially correlated

• fully correlated

(cross PSD function needed)

When SID and STYPE are both < 0, they give the IDs of correlated

excitations

Correlation of multiple excitations

Page 28: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

The model is a simple pipe with 83700 elements and 105480 nodes. It is subjected to base

acceleration PSD 1) in x, y and z-directions uncorrelated; 2) in x, y and z-directions correlated.

28

RMS of Von Mises stress (the pipe is subject to x, y, z excitations, uncorrelated)

Example: pipe under base acceleration

Model provided by Parker Hannifin Corp.

ANSYS LS-DYNA

Freq (Hz)

Acceleration psd (g^2/Hz)

5 0.01

40 0.01

100 0.04

500 0.04

1000 0.0065

2000 0.001

Max Von Mises RMS stress (MPa)

ANSYS LS-DYNA

99.4 100.7

Page 29: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

29

RMS of Von Mises stress (the pipe is subject to x, y, z excitations, correlated)

ANSYS LS-DYNA

Max Von Mises RMS stress (MPa)

ANSYS LS-DYNA

140.3 142.4

Page 30: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

30

The tube was fixed to the shaker tables using

aluminum blocks which surrounded the tube

and were tightened using screws.

Shaker table A Shaker table B

CH 6

CH 3 CH 7 CH 5 CH 1

x

y

z

CH 1

Tube thickness = 3.3 mm

Example: shaker table

Courtesy of Rafael, Israel.

Base acceleration PSD load

Page 31: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

31

Page 32: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

32

GRMS=1.63 g^2/Hz

Hz g^2/Hz

10 0.001

20 0.003

40 0.003

80 0.02

120 0.02

200 0.0015

500 0.0015

Input PSD

A cluster server is analyzed

by LS-DYNA to understand

the location of vibration

damage under standard

random vibration condition.

Example: cluster server

Page 33: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

33

1σ 3σ

U (mm) 0.78 2.34

Sv-m (MPa) 41.2 123.6

Dis

pla

cem

ent

S

tress

It is found that the 3

Von-Mises stress is less

than the yield stress of

the material (176 Mpa).

Maximum values

Page 34: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

34

Nodes: 800k

Elements: 660k

Modes: 1000

Model courtesy of Predictive Engineering

MPP Random Vibration Analysis

Page 35: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

35

• Keyword *FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_RANDOM_VIBRATION_FATIGUE

• Calculate fatigue life of structures under random vibration

• Based on S-N fatigue curve

• Based on probability distribution & Miner’s Rule of Cumulative Damage Ratio

• Schemes:

Steinberg’s Three-band technique considering the number of stress cycles at the 1, 2, and 3 levels.

Dirlik method based on the 4 Moments of PSD.

Narrow band method

Wirsching method

Introduction: Random Fatigue

i i

i

N

nR

PDF (probability density function)

Typical SN (or Wöhler) curve

Page 36: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

36

S-N fatigue curve definition

• By *define_curve

• By equation

aSN m

)log()log( NbaS

SNLIMT Fatigue life for stress lower than the lowest stress on S-N curve.

EQ.0: use the life at the last point on S-N curve

EQ.1: extrapolation from the last two points on S-N curve

EQ.2: infinity.

• Fatigue life of stress below fatigue threshold

Source of information: http://www.efunda.com

N: number of cycles for fatigue failure

S: stress

Page 37: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

37

Steinberg’s Three Band Technique

Standard Deviation Percentage of Occurrence Number of cycles for failure

1σ stress 68.3% N1

2σ stress 27.1% N2

3σ stress 4.33% N3

3

3

2

2

1

1][N

n

N

n

N

nDE

0433.0)0(

271.0)0(

683.0)0(

3

2

1

TEn

TEn

TEnE(0): Zero-crossing frequency with

positive slope

Reference

Steinberg, D.S., Vibration Analysis for Electronic Equipment (2nd edition), John Wiley & Sons, New

York, 1988.

Page 38: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

38

Time of exposure: 4 hours

Frequency (Hz)

PSD

(g2

/Hz)

Z-acceleration PSD

PSD = 2 g2/Hz

100.0 2000.0

Example: Aluminum bracket

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

1.E+03 1.E+04 1.E+05 1.E+06 1.E+07 1.E+08 1.E+09

No. of cycles

Str

es

s (

Ks

i)

S-N fatigue curve

Nodes constrained to

shaker table

Aluminum 2014 T6 = 2800 Kg/m3

E = 72,400 MPa = 0.33

Page 39: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

39

Accumulative damage ratio (by Steinberg’s method)

RMS of Von-Mises stress (unit: GPa)

(given in d3ftg) (given in d3rms)

Page 40: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

40 Model courtesy of CIMES France

Aluminum alloy 5754 = 2700 Kg/m3

E = 70,000 MPa = 0.33

Base acceleration is applied at the edge of the hole

Acceleration PSD (exposure time: 1800 seconds)

Example: beam with predefined notch

Page 41: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

41

RMS Sx = 35.0 MPa at critical point

Analysis method Expected life Damage ratio

Experiment 7mn 25s -

Steinberg 4mn 10s 7.19

Dirlik 5mn 25s 5.54

Narrow Band 2mn 05s 14.41

Wirsching 5mn 45s 5.08

Chaudhury & Dover 6mn 03s 6.03

Tunna 4mn 06s 7.31

Hancock 22mn 18s 1.35

CODE RMS Sxx

ANSYS 33.5 MPa

RADIOSS® BULK 35.7 MPa

LS-DYNA 35.0 MPa

Page 42: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

42 Cumulative damage ratio by Dirlik method

Cumulative damage ratio by Steinberg’s method

Damage ratio = 5.540

Damage ratio = 7.188

Page 43: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

43

Experiment setup

Failure at the notched point in experiment

Page 44: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

44

Initial failure area

A model from railway application

The structure is subjected to base acceleration defined by the International Standard

IEC61373 to simulate the long-life test. This standard intends to highlight any weakness

which may result in problem as a consequence of operation under environment where

vibrations are known to occur in service on a railway vehicle.

Example: support antenna

Page 45: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

45

Area 1 - damage ratio = 25.5

Area 2 - damage ratio = 3.45

Area 1

Area 2

Page 46: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

46

Initial Damage Ratio

Card1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Variable MDMIN MDMAX FNMIM FNMAX RESTRT MFTG RESTRM INFTG

Type I I F F I I I I

Default 1 0.0 0 0 0 0

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_RANDOM_VIBRATION_FATIGUE

Card7 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Variable FILENAME

Type C

Default d3ftg

Define Card 7 if option FATIGUE is used and INFTG=1.

INFTG Flag for including initial damage ratio.

EQ.0: no initial damage ratio,

EQ.1: read existing d3ftg file to get initial damage ratio.

FILENAME Path and name of existing binary database (by default, D3FTG) for

initial damage ratio.

Card 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Variable SSID STYP

Type I I

Default none 0

VARIABLE DESCRIPTION

SSID Set or part ID

STYP Set type:

EQ.0: part set ID, see *SET_PART,

EQ.1: part ID, see *PART,

EQ.2: segment set ID, see *SET_SEGMENT.

Page 47: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

47

Time of exposure: 4 hours

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

1.E+03 1.E+04 1.E+05 1.E+06 1.E+07 1.E+08 1.E+09

No. of cycles

Str

es

s (

Ks

i)

S-N fatigue curve

Edge fixed to

shaker table.

Acceleration

PSD = 1g2/Hz

for 1-2000 Hz

RMS - von mises for x-acl PSD RMS -von mises for z-acl PSD

Page 48: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

48

Damage ratio for x-load only

Damage ratio for z-load only

Damage ratio for x+z load

Dirlik method is used (MFTG = 2).

1.152e-01

6.019e-01

7.171e-01

Page 49: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

RESPONSE SPECTRUM ANALYSIS 5

49

Page 50: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

50

Introduction: Response Spectrum

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_RESPONSE_SPECTRUM

Use various mode combination methods to evaluate peak

response of structure due to input spectrum.

The input spectrum is the peak response (acceleration, velocity

or displacement) of single degree freedom system with different

natural frequencies.

The input spectrum is dependent on damping (using

*DEFINE_TABLE to define the series of excitation spectrum

corresponding to each damping ratio).

Output binary database: d3spcm (accessible by LS-PREPOST).

It is an approximate method.

It has important application in earthquake engineering, nuclear

power plants design etc.

Page 51: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

51

Capabilities

oSRSS method

oNRC Grouping method

oCQC method

oDouble Sum methods Rosenblueth-Elorduy coefficient

Gupta-Cordero coefficient

Modified Gupta-Cordero coefficient

oNRL SUM method

oRosenblueth method

Mode combination

oBase velocity

oBase acceleration

oBase displacement

oNodal force

oPressure

Input spectrum

o Logarithmic

oSemi-logarithmic

o Linear

Frequency interpolation

oBINARY plot file: d3spcm

oASCII files: nodout_spcm, elout_spcm

Results

oCivil and hydraulic buildings Hydraulic dams

Bridges

High buildings

oNuclear power plants

Applications

Page 52: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

52

Example: multi story tower

60 m /15 story tower

Loading conditions Base acceleration input spectrum

Mode combination method SRSS

Damping = 1%

Frequency (Hz) Acceleration (m/s2)

0.1 19.4

5.0 22.23

10.0 24.10

15.0 25.5

20.0 26.6

60

m

Page 53: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

53

Z displacement results

Page 54: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

54

Von Mises stress results

Page 55: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

55

Example: arch dam

o 464.88 feet high

o Rigid foundation

o Subjected to x-directional ground acceleration

spectrum

The pseudo-acceleration spectrum of El

Centro earthquake ground motion (=5%)

The 1940 El Centro earthquake (or 1940 Imperial

Valley earthquake) occurred on May 18 in the

Imperial Valley in Southern California near the

border of the United States and Mexico. It had a

magnitude of 6.9.

X-directional acceleration

Page 56: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

ACOUSTIC ANALYSIS BY BEM/FEM 6

56

Page 57: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

57

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_ACOUSTIC_BEM_{OPTION}

Available options include:

PANEL_CONTRIBUTION

HALF_SPACE

Introduction: BEM Acoustics

SSD

Structure loading

V (P) in time domain

V (P) in frequency domain

Acoustic pressure and SPL (dB) at field points

FFT

FEM transient analysis

BEM acoustic analysis

User data

Page 58: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

58

BEM (accurate)

Indirect variational boundary element method

Collocation boundary element method

They used to be time consuming

A fast solver based on domain decomposition

MPP version

Approximate (simplified) methods

Rayleigh method

Kirchhoff method Assumptions and simplification in formulation

Very fast since no equation system to solve

Page 59: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

59

N

j

j

j

N

j

Pp

dn

Gp

n

pGPp

j

1

1

)(

)(

real

imag

inar

y

p pj

O

Projection in the direction

of the total pressure

Acoustic Panel Contribution

Page 60: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

60

Radiated Noise by a Car

Freq = 11 Hz

Freq = 101 Hz

The radius of the sphere is 3 m

Sound Pressure Level distribution (dB)

Page 61: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

61

Freq = 11Hz

Freq = 101 Hz

6 m

3 m

The plate is 0.2 m away from the vehicle

Sound Pressure Level distribution (dB)

Page 62: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

62

Half-space Problem

r

eG

ikr

4

r

eR

r

eG

rik

H

ikr

H

44

Free space Green’s function

Half space Green’s function

p r

r’

S

HHn ds

n

GpGviP )()(

Helmholtz integral equation

RH = 1: rigid reflection plane, zero velocity

-1: soft reflection plane, zero sound pressure (water-air interface in

underwater acoustics)

The reflection plane is defined by *DEFINE_PLANE.

Page 63: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

63

Muffler Transmission Loss Analysis

Wi

Wt

t

i

W

WTL 10log10

TL (Transmission loss) is the difference in the sound power level

between the incident wave entering and the transmitted wave

exiting the muffler when the muffler termination is anechoic (no

reflection of sound).

Page 64: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

64

pi

pr

P1 P2 P3

Muffler

Anechoic

Termination (Z=c)

po

Muffler P2

v2

P1

v1

Three-point method Four-pole method

Incoming wave is given as

1

21

12

2

)](sin[2

1 ikxikx

i epepxxki

p

o

i

o

i

s

s

p

pTL 1010 log10log20

2

2

1

1

v

p

DC

BA

v

p

o

i

s

s

DcCc

BATL

10

10

log10

1

2

1log20

Where, si and so are the inlet and outlet tube

areas, respectively

21

21

21

21

/

/

/

/

vvD

pvC

vpB

ppA

1,0|

1,0|

1,0|

1,0|

12

12

12

12

vp

vv

vp

vv

The four pole parameters A, B, C, D, can

be obtained from

Page 65: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

65

1. F. Fahy, Foundations of Engineering Acoustics. Elsevier Academic Press, 2001.

2. Z. Tao and A.F. Seybert, a Review of Current Techniques for Measuring Muffler Transmission Loss.

SAE International, 2003

0

10

20

30

40

0 1000 2000 3000

Tra

nsm

issi

on

L

oss

(d

B)

Frequency (Hz)

Plane Wave theory [1]

Experiment [2]

LS-DYNA (Three-Point Method)

LS-DYNA (Four-Pole Method)

Cutoff frequency for plane wave theory f =1119 Hz

Muffler transmission loss by different methods

References

Page 66: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

66

Double expansion chamber

Page 67: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

67

Z. Tao and A.F. Seybert, a Review of Current Techniques for Measuring Muffler Transmission

Loss. SAE International, 2003

References

Page 68: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

68

*BOUNDARY_ACOUSTIC_MAPPING

Card 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Variable SSID STYP

Type I I

Default none 0

VARIABLE DESCRIPTION

SSID Set or part ID

STYP Set type:

EQ.0: part set ID, see *SET_PART,

EQ.1: part ID, see *PART,

EQ.2: segment set ID, see *SET_SEGMENT.

Card 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Variable SSID STYP

Type I I

Default none 0

*BOUNDARY_ACOUSTIC_MAPPING

Purpose: Define a set of elements or segments on structure for mapping structural nodal velocity to

boundary of acoustic volume.

Page 69: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

69

Mesh A: 20 30 (600) Mesh B: 15 20 (300) Mesh C: 7 11 (77)

Mesh A 16 min 34 sec

Mesh B 10 min 10 sec

Mesh C 6 min 49 sec

CPU time (Intel Xeon 1.6 GHz)

Also mesh for structure surface

Page 70: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

70

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_ACOUSTIC_BEM_ATV

Acoustic Transfer Vector can be obtained by including the option ATV in the keyword.

It calculates acoustic pressure (and sound pressure level) at field points due to unit normal velocity of each surface node.

ATV is dependent on structure model, properties of acoustic fluid as well as location of field points.

When ATV option is included, the structure does not need any external excitation, and the curve IDs LC1 and LC2 are ignored.

ATV_DB_FIELD_PT_* (decibel due to unit vn at each node) ATV_FIELD_PT_* (complex pressure due to unit vn at each node) ATV_DB_FIELD_PT_FRINGE_* (user fringe plot file for decibel due to unit vn at each node)

Output files

Page 71: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

71

ATV is useful if the same structure needs to be studied under multiple load cases.

n

j

nmnmjmmm

nijiii

nj

nj

m

i

V

V

V

V

P

P

P

P

2

1

,,2,1,

,,2,1,

,2,22,21,2

,1,12,11,1

2

1

Need to be computed only once

ATV at field points 1-m, due to unit normal velocity at node j

Change from case to case

1 2 m

Page 72: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

72

Acoustic FRF

Unit force excitation

Driver ear position

A simplified auto body model without any inside details

Analysis steps:

1.Modal analysis

2.Steady state dynamics

3.Boundary element acoustics

All done in one run

Page 73: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

73

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_ACOUSTIC_FEM

Introduction: FEM Acoustics

1) FEM acoustics is an alternative method for simulating acoustics. It

helps predict and improve sound and noise performance of various

systems. The FEM simulates the entire propagation volume -- being air

or water.

2) Compute acoustic pressure and SPL (sound pressure level)

3) Output binary database: d3acs (accessible by LS-PREPOST)

4) Output ASCII database: Press_Pa and Press_dB as xyplot files

5) Output frequency range dependent on mesh size

6) Very fast since

One unknown per node

The majority of the matrix is unchanged for all frequencies

Using a fast sparse matrix iterative solver

Tetrahedron Hexahedron Pentahedron

Page 74: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

74

Excitation of the compartment (1.40.50.6) m3

by a velocity of 7mm/s

Observation point

Model information

FEM: 2688 elements

BEM: 1264 elements

Example: compartment

Page 75: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA Pressure distribution

f =100 Hz

f =400 Hz

f =200 Hz

f =500 Hz

75

Page 76: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

76

Introduction

Nodal force 0.01N is applied for frequency range of 10-20000 Hz.

Diameter 10mm, length 31.4mm This edge is

fixed in x, y, z

translation dof.

To solve an interior acoustic problem by variational indirect BEM,

collocation BEM and FEM. The cylinder duct is excited by harmonic nodal

force at one end.

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_SSD

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_ACOUSTIC_BEM

*FREQUENCY_DOMAIN_ACOUSTIC_FEM

or

Example: cylinder

Page 77: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

77

FEM Model

BEM Model

dB at Point 1

dB at Point 2

Point 1

Point 2

Page 78: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

78 f =20000 Hz

f =5000 Hz

f =15000 Hz

f =10000 Hz

Acoustic pressure distribution (by d3acs)

Page 79: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

CONCLUSION & FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS

7

79

Page 80: Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA - Oasys Software Do… · Frequency Domain Analysis in LS-DYNA® Yun Huang, Zhe Cui Livermore Software Technology Corporation ... Ocean wave loads

LS-DYNA

80

A set of frequency domain features have been implemented,

towards NVH, durability analysis of vehicles and other vibration

and acoustic analysis

Frequency Response Function

Steady State Dynamics

Random Vibration and Fatigue

BEM & FEM Acoustics

Response spectrum analysis

Future work

SEA method for high frequency acoustics

Fast multi-pole BEM for acoustics

Infinite FEM

Fatigue analysis with strains

Feedbacks and suggestions from users Thank you!