Frank Et Al v. Walker Et Al

8/11/2019 Frank Et Al v. Walker Et Al

1/23

In the

United States Court of AppealsFor the Seventh Circuit

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

01234554 607#89 !" $%&9

&%$'("'))*+,--!%%!!*9

./

:;$?@AB$A $C =D%E$B%DB9!" $%&9

0!)!(1$("*+,--!%%$("*&

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

547>14 14G :4Y24HT40 '*9*+'(XG4;FG4G


2/23

* #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

T@C$A@ 47:240T06$(? ./ @$%?!69 *+'( 1&:& GD%O& 54aF:,/_(( J4&G& =D%& 7VA&

*/9 *+'(K9 %OQS U@BD@U9 *+'( 1&:& GD%O& 54aF:'''-'' J4&G& =D%&

7P]& '_9 *+'(K& 7CO@A A@E@D?DB] NAD@C% QBU QA]PM@BO9 ^@

%OQS@U OWQO DB`PBEOD$B&


3/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ _

WQ?@ ]$?@ABM@BO)D%%P@U VW$O$ FG% MP%O %V@BU ODM@ O$ QE)

\PDA@ B@E@%%QAS U$EPM@BO% J%PEW Q% NDAOW E@AODCDEQO@%K QBU

%OQBU DB RDB@ QO Q VPNRDE Q]@BES O$ ]@O $B@& i6$A M$%O ?$O@A%

^W$ B@@U OW@M9 OW@ DBE$B?@BD@BE@ $C MQhDB] Q OADV O$ OW@

jU@VQAOM@BO $C M$O$A ?@WDER@%k9 ]QOW@ADB] OW@ A@\PDA@U U$E)

PM@BO%9 QBU V$%DB] C$A Q VW$O$]AQVW %PA@RS U$@% B$O \PQRDCS

Q% Q %PN%OQBODQR NPAU@B $B OW@ AD]WO O$ ?$O@9 $A @?@B A@VA@)

%@BO Q %D]BDCDEQBO DBEA@Q%@ $?@A OW@ P%PQR NPAU@B% $C ?$ODB]&l

,,_ 1&:& QO '/-& 2W@%@ $N%@A?QOD$B% W$RU C$A =D%E$B%DB Q%

^@RR Q% C$A FBUDQBQ&

=D%E$B%DBc% RQ^ UDCC@A% CA$M FBUDQBQc%9 NPO B$O DB ^QS%

OWQO MQOO@A PBU@A OW@ QBQRS%D% DB56$8)961&


4/23

( #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

FG D%%P@U NS Q A@E$]BDn@U FBUDQB OADN@9 $A %D]B@U VW$O$ FG

D%%P@U NS Q E$RR@]@ $A PBD?@A%DOSK $MDO% %$M@ U$EPM@BO% OWQO

FBUDQBQ QEE@VO% J%@@ ,,_ 1&:& QO '/- B&'ZK QBU DBERPU@% %$M@

OWQO FBUDQBQ $MDO%& 2W@A@ QA@ $OW@A UDCC@A@BE@% DB U@OQDR9 NPO

B$B@ @%OQNRD%W@% OWQO OW@ NPAU@B $C ?$ODB] DB =D%E$B%DB D%

%D]BDCDEQBORS UDCC@A@BO CA$M OW@ NPAU@B DB FBUDQBQ&

2W@ UD%OADEO E$PAO E$BERPU@U OWQO56$8)961D% B$O E$BOA$R)

RDB] C$A OWA@@ VADBEDVQR A@Q%$B%& 6DA%O9 OW@ `PU]@ @%ODMQO@U

OWQO _++9+++ A@]D%O@A@U ?$O@A% DB =D%E$B%DB RQEh Q VW$O$ FG

OWQO OW@ %OQO@ ^DRR QEE@VO C$A ?$ODB]& 2WQO D% QVVA$mDMQO@RS

/o $C OW@ %OQO@c% _9_/,9Z-- A@]D%O@A@U ?$O@A%& 2W@ UD%OADEO

`PU]@ DB 56$8)9619 NS E$BOAQ%O9 @%ODMQO@U OWQO $BRS (_9+++

V@A%$B% @RD]DNR@ O$ ?$O@ RQEh@U QB QEE@VOQNR@ VW$O$ FG& (,- 6&

:PVV& *U ff,9 -+f J:&G& FBU& *++ZK& :@E$BU9 OW@ `PU]@ C$PBU

OWQO ?$O@A)DMV@A%$BQOD$B CAQPU JQ ADB]@A VA@O@BUDB] O$ N@ Q

A@]D%O@A@U ?$O@AK WQVV@B% %$ AQA@RS DB =D%E$B%DB OWQO OW@ U@)

%DA@ O$ A@UPE@ DO% $EEPAA@BE@ EQBB$O `P%ODCS QBS %D]BDCDEQBO

NPAU@B $B ?$O@A%& 2WDAU9 OW@ `PU]@ C$PBU OWQO ^WDO@ V@A%$B%

^W$ QA@ @RD]DNR@ O$ ?$O@ QA@ M$A@ RDh@RS OWQB $OW@A% O$ WQ?@

DB OW@DA V$%%@%%D$B @DOW@A QB QEE@VOQNR@ VW$O$ FG $A OW@ U$E)PM@BO% J%PEW Q% E$VD@% $C NDAOW E@AODCDEQO@%K OWQO MQh@ DO %DM)

VR@ O$ ]@O QB QEE@VOQNR@ VW$O$ FG& 2W@ `PU]@ C$PBU OWQO DB

HDR^QPh@@ ;$PBOS J^WDEW OW@ `PU]@ O$$h Q% Q VA$mS C$A OW@

^W$R@ %OQO@K /f&Zo $C ^WDO@ @RD]DNR@ ?$O@A% WQ?@ Q \PQRDCSDB]

VW$O$ FG $A OW@ U$EPM@BO% OW@S B@@U O$ ]@O $B@& 2WQO CD]PA@

D% /,&,o C$A NRQEh @RD]DNR@ ?$O@A% QBU /(&'o C$A 5QODB$ @RD]D)

NR@ ?$O@A%& 2W@ `PU]@ E$BERPU@U CA$M OW@ CDA%O O^$ CDBUDB]%

OWQO 7EO *_ ?D$RQO@% OW@ ;$B%ODOPOD$B QBU CA$M OW@ OWDAU OWQO

DO ?D$RQO@% OW@ L$ODB] 0D]WO% 7EO& 2W@ `PU]@ MQU@ MQBS $OW)

@A CDBUDB]%9 NPO OW@%@ QA@ OW@ M$%O DMV$AOQBO $B@%&


5/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ ,

T@C$A@ ^@ QUUA@%% OW@ %D]BDCDEQBE@ $C OW@ CDBUDB]% OW@

`PU]@ MQU@9 ^@ M@BOD$B Q C@^ OWDB]% OWQO OW@ `PU]@ UDU(9"

CDBU& 6DA%O9 OW@ `PU]@ UDU B$O CDBU OWQO %PN%OQBODQR BPMN@A% $C

V@A%$B% @RD]DNR@ O$ ?$O@ WQ?@ OAD@U O$ ]@O Q VW$O$ FG NPO N@@B

PBQNR@ O$ U$ %$& 4D]WO V@$VR@ O@%ODCD@U OWQO OW@S WQU N@@B

CAP%OAQO@U ^W@B OASDB] O$ ]@O VW$O$ FG%& :Dm $C OW@ @D]WO O@%OD)

CD@U OWQO OW@ %OQO@ ^$PRU B$O D%%P@ VW$O$ FG% N@EQP%@ OW@S

RQEh NDAOW E@AODCDEQO@%9 NPO OW@S UDU B$O O@%ODCS OWQO OW@S WQU

OAD@U O$ ]@O OW@M9 R@O QR$B@ OWQO OW@S WQU OAD@U NPO CQDR@U&


6/23

Z #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

%OQO@ $CCDEDQR% O$ D%%P@ VW$O$ FG% ^DOW$PO A@\PDADB] QVVRDEQBO%

O$ VA@%@BO QBS U$EPM@BO OWQO MP%O N@ VQDU C$A& :'%8$3?!!

=6$(7C 9) D,,5& ./ @$%?!69 *+'( =F /- pp ZZgf+& H$A@$?@A9

=D%E$B%DB A@E@BORS D%%P@U A@]PRQOD$B% A@\PDADB] $CCDEDQR% O$

]@O NDAOW E@AODCDEQO@% J$A $OW@A \PQRDCSDB] U$EPM@BO%K OW@M)

%@R?@% C$A V@A%$B% ^W$ Q%h C$A OWQO QEE$MM$UQOD$B $B OW@

NQ%D% $C WQAU%WDV& 4M@A]@BES 0PR@ '(9 =D%& 7UMDB& 0@]&

f+(N J7P]P%O _'9 *+'(K& :$ QO OW@ ODM@ $C OADQR DO ^Q% B$ WQAU)

@A O$ ]@O %PVV$AODB] U$EPM@BO% DB =D%E$B%DB OWQB DB FBUD)

QBQ9 QBU O$UQS DO D% @Q%D@A DB =D%E$B%DB OWQB DB FBUDQBQ&'

:@E$BU9 OW@ `PU]@ UDU B$O MQh@ CDBUDB]% QN$PO ^WQO

WQVV@B@U O$ ?$O@A OPAB$PO DB =D%E$B%DB UPADB] OW@ 6@NAPQAS

*+'* VADMQAS9 ^W@B 7EO *_ ^Q% @BC$AE@U JN@C$A@ O^$ %OQO@

`PU]@% @B`$DB@U DOK& GDU OW@ A@\PDA@M@BO $C VW$O$ FG A@UPE@

OW@ BPMN@A $C ?$O@A% N@R$^ ^WQO $OW@A^D%@ ^$PRU WQ?@

N@@B @mV@EO@Uq GDU OWQO @CC@EO UDCC@A NS AQE@ $A @OWBDEDOSq

2W@ A@E$AU U$@% B$O O@RR P%& 2WD% %PDO9 RDh@ 56$8)9619 OW@A@C$A@

D% Q EWQRR@B]@ O$ 7EO *_ Q% ^ADOO@B Ji$B DO% CQE@lK9 AQOW@A OWQB

O$ DO% @CC@EO% JiQ% QVVRD@UlK&

2W@ A@E$AU QR%$ U$@% B$O A@?@QR ^WQO WQ% WQVV@B@U O$?$O@A OPAB$PO DB OW@ $OW@A %OQO@% JM$A@ OWQB Q U$n@BK OWQO A@)

\PDA@ VW$O$ FG% C$A ?$ODB]& FC Q% VRQDBODCC% E$BO@BU Q VW$O$ FG

A@\PDA@M@BO @%V@EDQRRS A@UPE@% OPAB$PO NS MDB$ADOS ]A$PV%9

%OPU@BO%9 QBU @RU@ARS ?$O@A%9 DO %W$PRU N@ V$%%DNR@ O$ U@M$B)

':'%8$3?!! =6$(7C 9) D,,5&QBU OW@ A@]PRQOD$B% R@Q?@ MPEW O$ OW@

UD%EA@OD$B $C OW@ @MVR$S@@% QO OW@ G@VQAOM@BO $C H$O$A L@WDER@% ^W$

U@EDU@ ^W@OW@A Q ]D?@B V@A%$B WQ% QB QU@\PQO@ ERQDM C$A Q%%D%OQBE@ $AUD%V@B%DB] ^DOW OW@ B@@U C$A Q NDAOW E@AODCDEQO@& =W@OW@A OWQO UD%EA@OD$B

^DRR N@ VA$V@ARS @m@AED%@U D% B$O VQAO $C OW@ EPAA@BO A@E$AU9 W$^@?@A9 QBU

E$PRU N@ OW@ %PN`@EO $C Q %@VQAQO@ %PDO DC Q VA$NR@M EQB N@ U@M$B%OAQO@U&


7/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ f

%OAQO@ OWQO @CC@EO& 7EOPQR A@%PRO% QA@ M$A@ %D]BDCDEQBO OWQB RDO)

D]QBO%c VA@UDEOD$B%& TPO B$ %PEW @?DU@BE@ WQ% N@@B $CC@A@U&

2W@ RQEh $C @?DU@BE@ QN$PO ^WQO WQ% WQVV@B@U DB $OW@A

%OQO@% J$A @?@B DB =D%E$B%DB DO%@RC DB *+'*K M@QB% OWQO OWD%

EQ%@ D% DB OW@ %QM@ V$%OPA@ Q% FBUDQBQc%r OW@ VQAOD@% QBU OW@

UD%OADEO E$PAO WQ?@ OAD@U O$ MQh@ VA@UDEOD$B% QN$PO OW@ @CC@EO%

$C A@\PDADB] VW$O$ FG9 NPO OW@ VA@UDEOD$B% EQBB$O N@ E$M)

VQA@U ^DOW A@%PRO%&

YRQDBODCC% ^QBO P% O$ OA@QO 56$8)961 Q% Q EQ%@ DB ^WDEW

OW@A@ ^Q% B$ A@E$AU9 %$ OWQO OW@ :PVA@M@ ;$PAO WQU B$ CQEO%O$ ]$ $B& 2WQOc% B$O ^WQO WQVV@B@U& 7B @mO@B%D?@ A@E$AU

^Q% E$MVDR@U DB 56$8)9619 QBU OW@ UD%OADEO `PU]@ D%%P@U Q

R@B]OWS $VDBD$B& 2W@ `PU]@ DB FBUDQBQ OW$P]WO9 `P%O Q% OW@

`PU]@ DB =D%E$B%DB WQ% C$PBU9 OWQO *9E!?$O@A% ^$PRU N@ PB)

QNR@9 Q% Q VAQEODEQR MQOO@A9 O$ ]@O VW$O$ FG%XN@EQP%@ $C Q]@

$A DBCDAMDOS9 RQEh $C QNDRDOS O$ VQS C$A NDAOW E@AODCDEQO@%9 $A OW@

UDCCDEPROS $C $NOQDBDB] OW@M CA$M VPNRDE)A@E$AU% NPA@QP%

OW$P%QBU% $C MDR@% Q^QS DB $OW@A %OQO@%XQBU OW@A@C$A@

^$PRU WQ?@ O$ OAQ?@R O$ OW@ E$PBOS %@QO QCO@A @?@AS @R@EOD$B

O$ CDR@ QB QCCDUQ?DO $C @RD]DNDRDOS9 NPO E$PRU B$O Q%E@AOQDB W$^MQBS V@$VR@ ^@A@ DB OWQO EQO@]$AS& 2W@ OADQR DB =D%E$B%DB

VA$UPE@U OW@ %QM@ DBQNDRDOS O$ \PQBODCS&

2W@ CDBUDB]% B$O MQU@ QCC@EO W$^ O$ DBO@AVA@O OW@ CDBU)

DB]% OWQO ^@A@ MQU@& 2Qh@ OW@ E$BERP%D$B JNQ%@U $B OW@ O@%)

ODM$BS $C Q iMQAh@ODB] E$B%PROQBOlK OWQO _++9+++ A@]D%O@A@U

?$O@A% RQEh QEE@VOQNR@ VW$O$ FG& 2W@ BPMN@A D% \P@%OD$BQNR@b

OW@ UD%OADEO `PU]@ ^W$ OAD@U OW@ FBUDQBQ EQ%@ A@`@EO@U Q RQA]@

@%ODMQO@ Q% CQBEDCPR DB Q ^$ARU DB ^WDEW VW$O$ FG D% @%%@BODQR

O$ N$QAU QB QDAVRQB@9 @BO@A ;QBQUQ $A QBS $OW@A C$A@D]B BQ)OD$B9 UAD?@ Q EQA J@?@B V@$VR@ ^W$ U$ B$O $^B EQA% B@@U RD)

E@B%@% O$ UAD?@ CAD@BU%c $A A@RQOD?@%c EQA%K9 NPS Q N@@A9 VPA)


8/23

- #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

EWQ%@ V%@PU$@VW@UADB@ C$A Q %OPCCS B$%@ $A VDEh PV Q VA@)

%EADVOD$B QO Q VWQAMQES9 $V@B Q NQBh QEE$PBO $A EQ%W Q EW@Eh

QO Q EPAA@BES @mEWQB]@9 NPS Q ]PB9 $A @BO@A Q E$PAOW$P%@ O$

%@A?@ Q% Q `PA$A $A ^QOEW OW@ QA]PM@BO $C OWD% QVV@QR& ;$PRU

/o $C =D%E$B%DBc% ?$ODB] V$VPRQOD$B A@QRRS U$ (9(!$C OW@%@

OWDB]%q J:$M@ MQS WQ?@ VW$O$ FG OWQO D% B$O QEE@VO@U C$A

@R@EOD$B%9 %PEW Q% Q ?@O@AQBc% EQAU9 NPO OW@ A@E$AU U$@% B$O

%W$^ W$^ MQBS V@$VR@ ]@O OWA$P]W RDC@ ^DOW OW@ %$AO $C

VW$O$ FG OWQO =D%E$B%DB U$@% B$O QEE@VO C$A ?$ODB]&K #$B@)

OW@R@%%9 ^@ QEE@VO OW@ UD%OADEO E$PAOc% CDBUDB] DB OWD% EQ%@&

=WQO D% DO% R@]QR %D]BDCDEQBE@q

YRQDBODCC% U@%EADN@ A@]D%O@A@U ?$O@A% ^W$ RQEh VW$O$ FG Q%

iUD%@BCAQBEWD%@U&l FC OW@ A@Q%$B OW@S RQEh VW$O$ FG D% OWQO

OW@ %OQO@ WQ% MQU@ DO DMV$%%DNR@9 $A @?@B WQAU9 C$A OW@M O$

4!"VW$O$ FG9 OW@B iUD%CAQBEWD%@Ul MD]WO N@ QB QVO U@%EADV)

OD$B& TPO DC VW$O$ FG D% Q?QDRQNR@ O$ V@$VR@ ^DRRDB] O$

%EA$PB]@ PV Q NDAOW E@AODCDEQO@ QBU %OQBU DB RDB@ QO OW@ $CCDE@

OWQO D%%P@% UAD?@A%c RDE@B%@%9 OW@B QRR ^@ hB$^ CA$M OW@ CQEO

OWQO Q VQAODEPRQA V@A%$B RQEh% Q VW$O$ FG D% OWQO W@ ^Q% PB)

^DRRDB] O$ DB?@%O OW@ B@E@%%QAS ODM@& 7BU 56$8)961 O@RR% P%OWQO iOW@ DBE$B?@BD@BE@ $C MQhDB] Q OADV O$ OW@ jU@VQAOM@BO

$C M$O$A ?@WDER@%k9 ]QOW@ADB] OW@ A@\PDA@U U$EPM@BO%9 QBU

V$%DB] C$A Q VW$O$]AQVW %PA@RS U$@% B$O \PQRDCS Q% Q %PN)

%OQBODQR NPAU@B $B OW@ AD]WO O$ ?$O@9 $A @?@B A@VA@%@BO Q %D])

BDCDEQBO DBEA@Q%@ $?@A OW@ P%PQR NPAU@B% $C ?$ODB]&l ,,_ 1&:&

QO '/-&

0@]D%O@ADB] O$ ?$O@ D% @Q%S DB =D%E$B%DB&*[@O $C OW$%@ @RD)

]DNR@9 $BRS f-o WQ?@ A@]D%O@A@U& JFB AQ^ BPMN@A%9 (&*(f MDR)

*FB $AU@A O$ A@]D%O@A9 Q V@A%$B MP%O VA$?DU@ VA$$C $C A@%DU@BE@ J%PEW

Q% Q UAD?@Ac% RDE@B%@9 PODRDOS NDRR9 NQBh %OQO@M@BO9 $A A@%DU@BODQR R@Q%@K QBU

QBS $B@ $C J'K OW@ QVVRDEQBOc% UAD?@Ac% RDE@B%@ BPMN@A QBU @mVDAQOD$B


9/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ /

RD$B ^@A@ @RD]DNR@ DB *+'*9 QBU $C OWQO BPMN@A $BRS _&_'- MDR)

RD$B ^@A@ A@]D%O@A@U& 2W@ UDCC@A@BE@ D% QRM$%O Q MDRRD$B9 ?Q%O)

RS @mE@@UDB] OW@ BPMN@A $C A@]D%O@A@U ?$O@A% ^W$ RQEh VW$O$

FG& 1&:& ;@B%P% TPA@QP9 F!-96"!1 G9"'(4 $(1 F!4'*"6$"'9( H;

B!IJ F$7! $(1 K'*-$('7 L6'4'(J )96 B"$"!*M D9.!EH!6 NOPNJHQS

*+'_K&K 2WD% VA$V$AOD$B D% R$^@A OWQB OW@ /'o $C A@]D%O@A@U

?$O@A% ^W$ WQ?@ \PQRDCSDB] VW$O$ FG& =@ hB$^ CA$M A@]D%)

OAQOD$B UQOQ JQBU OW@ CQEO OWQO B$O QRR A@]D%O@A@U V@A%$B% EQ%O

NQRR$O%K OWQO $(; VA$E@UPAQR %O@V CDRO@A% $PO %$M@ V$O@BODQR

?$O@A%& #$ $B@ EQRR% OWD% @CC@EO UD%CAQBEWD%@M@BO9 @?@B

OW$P]W %OQO@% E$PRU MQh@ OWDB]% @Q%D@A NS9 %QS9 QRR$^DB]@?@AS$B@ O$ A@]D%O@A $A ?$O@ CA$M Q E$MVPO@A $A %MQAOVW$B@

^DOW$PO OAQ?@R $A %OQBUDB] DB RDB@& [@O DC **o $C OW@ @RD]DNR@

V$VPRQOD$B U$@% B$O V@AC$AM @?@B OW@ @Q%D@%O %O@V9 A@]D%OAQ)

OD$B9 DO D% UDCCDEPRO O$ DBC@A CA$M OW@ CQEO OWQO /o WQ?@ B$O QE)

\PDA@U VW$O$ FG OWQO OWQO %O@V D% VQAODEPRQARS UDCCDEPRO& 7

M$A@ VRQP%DNR@ DBC@A@BE@ ^$PRU N@ OWQO V@$VR@ ^W$ U$ B$O

VRQB O$ ?$O@ QR%$ U$ B$O ]$ $PO $C OW@DA ^QS O$ ]@O Q VW$O$ FG

OWQO ^$PRU WQ?@ B$ $OW@A P%@ O$ OW@M& 2WD% U$@% B$O DMVRS

OWQO Q B@@U C$A VW$O$ FG D% QB $N%OQER@ O$ Q %D]BDCDEQBO BPM)

N@A $C V@A%$B% ^W$ $OW@A^D%@ ^$PRU EQ%O NQRR$O%&

:$M@ $C OW@ UD%OADEO E$PAOc% $OW@A CDBUDB]% %PVV$AO OW@

E$BERP%D$B OWQO C$A M$%O @RD]DNR@ ?$O@A% B$O WQ?DB] Q VW$O$

FG D% Q MQOO@A $C EW$DE@ AQOW@A OWQB Q %OQO@)EA@QO@U $N%OQER@&

UQO@9 J*K Q =D%E$B%DB G@VQAOM@BO $C 2AQB%V$AOQOD$B FG BPMN@A QBU DO%

@mVDAQOD$B UQO@9 $A J_K OW@ RQ%O C$PA UD]DO% $C OW@ QVVRDEQBOc% :$EDQR :@EPAD)

OS BPMN@A& 0@%DU@BO% EQB A@]D%O@A NS MQDR $A OWA$P]W Q :V@EDQR 0@]D%OAQ)

OD$B G@VPOS J%$M@$B@ OAQDB@U NS Q MPBDEDVQRDOS O$ E$RR@EO ?$O@A A@]D%OAQ)OD$B C$AM%K PBODR *+ UQS% N@C$A@ QB @R@EOD$B& 2W@S EQB A@]D%O@A DB Q MPBDE)

DVQR ER@Ahc% $CCDE@ PBODR OW@ 6ADUQS N@C$A@ QB @R@EOD$B& 7BU OW@S EQB A@]D%)

O@A QO Q V$RRDB] VRQE@ $B @R@EOD$B UQS&


10/23

'+ #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

=@ WQ?@ M@BOD$B@U OW@ E$PAOc% CDBUDB] OWQO *&(o $C ^WDO@

QUPRO A@%DU@BO% DB HDR^QPh@@ ;$PBOS U$ B$O B$^ WQ?@ DB

OW@DA V$%%@%%D$B @DOW@A Q \PQRDCSDB] VW$O$ FG $A OW@ U$EP)

M@BOQOD$B B@@U@U O$ ]@O $B@& J2WD% D% OW@ %QM@ OWDB] Q% OW@

VA$V$%DOD$B OWQO /f&Zo U$ WQ?@ Q VW$O$ FG $A OW@ \PQRDCSDB]

U$EPM@BO%&K 2W@ `PU]@ @%ODMQO@U OWQO (&,o $C NRQEh% QBU

,&/o $C 5QODB$% RQEh N$OW& TPO DC /o $C @RD]DNR@ ?$O@A% RQEh Q

VW$O$ FG9 OWD% B@E@%%QADRS M@QB% OWQO M$A@ OWQB WQRC $C @RD]D)

NR@ ?$O@A% ^W$ RQEh Q VW$O$ FG U$ WQ?@ Q NDAOW E@AODCDEQO@ $A

$OW@A \PQRDCSDB] U$EPM@BO% QM$B] OW@ CQMDRS A@E$AU%& J


11/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ ''

VW$O$ FG ^$PRU B$O B@E@%%QADRS VA@?@BO OW@%@& 3@ $N%@A?@U

OWQO OW@ MQB E$PRU WQ?@ %PNMDOO@U Q VW$O$E$VS $C WD% U@)

E@Q%@U ^DC@c% VW$O$ FG& 2W@ %OQO@ QR%$ E$BO@BU@U OWQO A@\PDA)

DB] DU@BODCDEQOD$B $C ?$O@A% QO OW@ V$RR% VA$M$O@% VPNRDE E$B)

CDU@BE@ DB OW@ DBO@]ADOS $C @R@EOD$B%9 NPO OW@ `PU]@ C$PBU OWQO

OW@A@ D% B$ A@RQOD$B N@O^@@B ?$O@A)DU@BODCDEQOD$B %OQOPO@% QBU

VPNRDE E$BCDU@BE@& FO C$RR$^%9 OW@ `PU]@ E$BERPU@U9 OWQO =D%)

E$B%DBc% 7EO *_ %@A?@% B$ R@]DODMQO@ VPAV$%@&


12/23

'* #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

2W@ UD%%@BODB] dP%ODE@% ^@A@ B$O DMVA@%%@U NS OW@ N@B@)

CDO% OW@DA E$RR@Q]P@% O$PO@U& dP%ODE@ :$PO@A J`$DB@U NS dP%ODE@

>DB%NPA]K W@QV@U %E$AB $B OW@M9 U@@MDB] OW@M PB%PN%OQB)

ODQO@U QBU QO QBS @?@BO O$$ M$U@%O O$ `P%ODCS QB QVVA@EDQNR@

NPAU@B& ,,_ 1&:& QO **_g_f JUD%%@BODB] $VDBD$BK& JdP%ODE@

TA@S@A9 ^W$ QR%$ UD%%@BO@U9 UDU %$ N@EQP%@ DB WD% ?D@^ OW@

VW$O$ FG A@\PDA@M@BO UD%E$PAQ]@U O$$ MQBS V@$VR@ CA$M

?$ODB]b W@ UDU B$O `$DB dP%ODE@ :$PO@Ac% ?D@^ OWQO OW@ RQ^

%@A?@U B$ ?QRDU VPAV$%@&K FB OWD% RDOD]QOD$B9 VRQDBODCC% VA$)

UPE@U OW@ O@%ODM$BS $C Q V$RDODEQR %ED@BOD%O ^W$ Q]A@@% ^DOW

dP%ODE@ :$PO@A9 QBU OW@ UD%OADEO `PU]@ C$PBU Q% Q CQEO OWQO OW@MQ`$ADOS $C OW@ :PVA@M@ ;$PAO ^Q% ^A$B] QN$PO N@B@CDO%

%PEW Q% N@OO@A A@E$AU h@@VDB] QBU VA$M$ODB] VPNRDE E$BCD)

U@BE@& HQSN@ OWQO O@%ODM$BS ^DRR @?@BOPQRRS V@A%PQU@ OW@

dP%ODE@% OW@M%@R?@%9 NPO DB $PA WD@AQAEWDEQR `PUDEDQR %S%O@M Q

UD%OADEO E$PAO EQBB$O U@ERQA@ Q %OQOPO@ PBE$B%ODOPOD$BQR `P%O

N@EQP%@ W@ OWDBh% J^DOW $A ^DOW$PO OW@ %PVV$AO $C Q V$RDODEQR

%ED@BOD%OK OWQO OW@ UD%%@BO ^Q% AD]WO QBU OW@ MQ`$ADOS ^A$B]&

2$ VPO OWD% DB R@]QR@%@9 ^W@OW@A Q VW$O$ FG A@\PDA@M@BO

VA$M$O@% VPNRDE E$BCDU@BE@ DB OW@ @R@EO$AQR %S%O@M D% Q iR@])D%RQOD?@ CQEOlXQ VA$V$%DOD$B QN$PO OW@ %OQO@ $C OW@ ^$ARU9 Q%

$VV$%@U O$ Q VA$V$%DOD$B QN$PO OW@%@ RDOD]QBO% $A QN$PO Q

%DB]R@ %OQO@& dPU]@% EQRR OW@ RQOO@A VA$V$%DOD$B% iQU`PUDEQOD?@

CQEO%&l


13/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ '_

OWQO VW$O$ FG A@\PDA@M@BO% VA$M$O@ E$BCDU@BE@9 Q %DB]R@ UD%)

OADEO `PU]@ EQBB$O %QS Q% Q iCQEOl OWQO OW@S U$ B$O9 @?@B DC *+

V$RDODEQR %ED@BOD%O% UD%Q]A@@ DOW OW@ :PVA@M@ ;$PAO&

YW$O$ FG RQ^% VA$M$O@ E$BCDU@BE@9 $A OW@S U$BcOb OW@A@ D%

B$ ^QS OW@S E$PRU VA$M$O@ VPNRDE E$BCDU@BE@ DB FBUDQBQ JQ%

56$8)961E$BERPU@UK QBU B$O DB =D%E$B%DB& 2WD% M@QB% OWQO

OW@S QA@ ?QRDU DB @?@AS %OQO@XW$RUDB] E$B%OQBO OW@ NPAU@B

@QEW ?$O@A MP%O N@QA O$ ]@O Q VW$O$ FGX$A OW@S QA@ ?QRDU DB

B$ %OQO@& 6PBEOD$BQRRS DU@BODEQR RQ^% EQBB$O N@ ?QRDU DB FBUD)

QBQ QBU DB?QRDU DB =D%E$B%DB J$A OW@ A@?@A%@K9 U@V@BUDB] $B

^WDEW V$RDODEQR %ED@BOD%O O@%ODCD@%9 QBU ^W@OW@A Q UD%OADEO

`PU]@c% CPBUQM@BOQR N@RD@C% JWD% iVAD$A%9l Q %$EDQR %ED@BOD%O

^$PRU %QSK QA@ M$A@ DB RDB@ ^DOW OW@ MQ`$ADOS $B OW@ :P)

VA@M@ ;$PAO $A OW@ UD%%@BO&

=D%E$B%DB)%V@EDCDE CDBUDB]% 19 MQOO@A O$ %$M@ D%%P@%b DC

OW@ NPAU@B $C ]@OODB] Q VW$O$ FG DB =D%E$B%DB ^@A@ MQO@ADQR)

RS ]A@QO@A OWQB OW@ NPAU@B DB FBUDQBQ9 OW@B =D%E$B%DBc% RQ^

E$PRU DBU@@U N@ DB?QRDU ^WDR@ FBUDQBQc% %OQBU%& TPO B$ $B@

%P]]@%O% OWQO VW$O$ FG RQ^% VA$M$O@ E$BCDU@BE@ DB FBUDQBQ

NPO B$O =D%E$B%DBb OW@ UD%OADEO E$PAOc% CDBUDB] E$BE@AB% OW@BQOD$B Q% Q ^W$R@& J2W@ V$RDODEQR %ED@BOD%O ^W$ O@%ODCD@U QO OAD)

QR A@RD@U B$O $B WD% $^B ^$Ah9 $A @?@B $B ^$Ah DB Q A@C@A@@U

%EW$RQARS `$PABQR9 NPO $B :O@VW@B 7B%$RQN@W@A@ . #QOWQBD@R

Y@A%DRS9 G9"! >6$31 '( "C!


14/23

'( #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

VA@?@BO@U Q WD`QEhDB] $A QEO $C O@AA$AD%Mb B$ $B@ @?@B QA]P@%

OWQO DO WQ%& HQ]B@O$M@O@A%9 m)AQS MQEWDB@%9 QBU $OW@A O@EW)

BDEQR A@%$PAE@% CDBU ]PB%9 hBD?@%9 QBU @mVR$%D?@%& J6DBU OW@M

CA@\P@BORSr MQBS V@$VR@ ^W$ V$%%@%% VW$O$ FG OAS O$ EQAAS

OW@%@ DO@M% $BO$ VRQB@%&K TPO OW@ VPNRDE)!!%*%QC@A ^W@B @?@)

AS$B@ MP%O %W$^ Q VW$O$ FG9 ^WDEW MQh@% OW@ A@\PDA@M@BO

Q AQOD$BQR $B@& Y@AWQV% OWQO D% ^WS N$OW %OQO@ QBU C@U@AQR `P)

UDEDQAD@% A@\PDA@ VW$O$ FG $C V@$VR@ @BO@ADB] E$PAOW$P%@%9

@?@B OW$P]W DO D% OW@ MQ]B@O$M@O@A% QBU $OW@A O@EWBDEQR

]@QA9 B$O OW@ FG9 OWQO CDBU% OW@ ^@QV$B%&

FC OW@ VPNRDE OWDBh% OWQO VW$O$ FG MQh@% @R@EOD$B% ER@QB@A9

OW@B V@$VR@ QA@ M$A@ RDh@RS O$ ?$O@ $A9 DC OW@S %OQS W$M@9 O$

VRQE@ M$A@ E$BCDU@BE@ DB OW@ $POE$M@%& 2W@%@ QA@ %PN%OQBODQR

N@B@CDO%&


15/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ ',

JQK #$ ?$ODB] \PQRDCDEQOD$B $A VA@A@\PD%DO@ O$ ?$ODB] $A %OQBUQAU9

VAQEODE@9 $A VA$E@UPA@ %WQRR N@ DMV$%@U $A QVVRD@U NS QBS :OQO@$A V$RDODEQR %PNUD?D%D$B DB Q MQBB@A ^WDEW A@%PRO% DB Q U@BDQR $A

QNADU]@M@BO $C OW@ AD]WO $C QBS EDODn@B $C OW@ 1BDO@U :OQO@% O$

?$O@ $B QEE$PBO $C AQE@ $A E$R$A9 $A DB E$BOAQ?@BOD$B $C OW@ ]PQA)

QBO@@% %@O C$AOW DB %@EOD$B '+_+_JCKJ*K $C OWD% ODOR@9 Q% VA$?DU@U DB

%PN%@EOD$B JNK&

JNK 7 ?D$RQOD$B $C %PN%@EOD$B JQK D% @%OQNRD%W@U DC9 NQ%@U $B OW@ O$)

OQRDOS $C EDAEPM%OQBE@%9 DO D% %W$^B OWQO OW@ V$RDODEQR VA$E@%%@%

R@QUDB] O$ B$MDBQOD$B $A @R@EOD$B DB OW@ :OQO@ $A V$RDODEQR %PNUD)

?D%D$B QA@ B$O @\PQRRS $V@B O$ VQAODEDVQOD$B NS M@MN@A% $C Q

ERQ%% $C EDODn@B% VA$O@EO@U NS %PN%@EOD$B JQK DB OWQO DO% M@MN@A%

WQ?@ R@%% $VV$AOPBDOS OWQB $OW@A M@MN@A% $C OW@ @R@EO$AQO@ O$VQAODEDVQO@ DB OW@ V$RDODEQR VA$E@%% QBU O$ @R@EO A@VA@%@BOQOD?@% $C

OW@DA EW$DE@& 2W@ @mO@BO O$ ^WDEW M@MN@A% $C Q VA$O@EO@U ERQ%%

WQ?@ N@@B @R@EO@U O$ $CCDE@ DB OW@ :OQO@ $A V$RDODEQR %PNUD?D%D$B D%

$B@ EDAEPM%OQBE@ ^WDEW MQS N@ E$B%DU@A@Ur &69.'1!19 2WQO B$OW)

DB] DB OWD% %@EOD$B @%OQNRD%W@% Q AD]WO O$ WQ?@ M@MN@A% $C Q VA$)

O@EO@U ERQ%% @R@EO@U DB BPMN@A% @\PQR O$ OW@DA VA$V$AOD$B DB OW@

V$VPRQOD$B&

2W@ `PU]@ A@E$]BDn@U OWQO M$%O EQ%@ RQ^ E$BE@ABDB] OW@ QV)

VRDEQOD$B $C e* E$BE@AB% ERQDM% OWQO AQEDQR ]@AASMQBU@ADB]

WQ% N@@B @MVR$S@U O$ UDRPO@ OW@ ?$O@% $C AQEDQR $A @OWBDE]A$PV%& :@@9 @&]&9 TC96(H364 ./ W'(4%!*9 (f- 1&:& _+ J'/-ZKb 5C'+

*9E ./ F9!E!69 ,+' 1&:& _-+ J'//'K& FB W'(4%!*OW@ dP%ODE@% N$A)

A$^@U BDB@ CQEO$A% CA$M Q :@BQO@ E$MMDOO@@ A@V$AO J$CO@B

EQRR@U OW@ iW'(4%!*CQEO$A%lK Q% OW@ %OQBUQAU C$A QVVRSDB] e*&

2W@ `PU]@ C$PBU OWQO RDB@ $C EQ%@% PBW@RVCPR C$A %DOPQOD$B%

DB?$R?DB] @RD]DNDRDOS O$ ?$O@& 2W@ `PU]@ A@E$]BDn@U OWQO Q

%@VQAQO@ RDB@ $C e* EQ%@% U$@% DB?$R?@ @RD]DNDRDOS QBU WQ% E$B)

ERPU@U OWQO C@R$B)UD%CAQBEWD%@M@BO %OQOPO@% U$ B$O ?D$RQO@ e*

@?@B OW$P]W OW@%@ RQ^% WQ?@ Q UD%VQAQO@ DMVQEO $B MDB$AD)

OD@%& JT$OW NRQEh% QBU 5QODB$% QA@ M$A@ RDh@RS O$ WQ?@ C@R$BS

E$B?DEOD$B% OWQB QA@ ^WDO@%&K :@@ >$66$?C$( ./ W6!49'6!9 Z*_

6&_U //+ J/OW ;DA& *+'+K J@B NQBEKb B'EE9(* ./ W$%.'(9 ,f, 6&_U


16/23

'Z #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

*( J'%O ;DA& *++/Kb K$;1!( ./ &$"$?'9 ((/ 6&_U _+, J*U ;DA& *++ZK

J@B NQBEKb 29C(*9( ./ W9.!6(96 9) >%96'1$9 (+, 6&_U '*'( J''OW

;DA& *++,K J@B NQBEK& TPO OW@ `PU]@ U@@M@U QRR $C OW$%@ U@ED)

%D$B% DAA@R@?QBO O$$9 N@EQP%@ M$%O C@R$B)UD%CAQBEWD%@M@BO

RQ^% VA@UQO@ OW@ L$ODB] 0D]WO% 7EO&

2W@ `PU]@ OW$P]WO OWQO e* $CC@A% OW@ N@%O ]PDU@ O$ DO% $^B

DBO@AVA@OQOD$B QBU @MVWQ%Dn@U OW@ APR@ OWQO RQ^% MP%O B$O

iA@%PROjk DB Q U@BDQRl $C OW@ AD]WO O$ ?$O@& 7EO *_ WQ% %PEW Q

A@%PRO9 OW@ `PU]@ E$BERPU@U9 N@EQP%@ ^WDO@ A@]D%O@A@U ?$O@A%

QA@ M$A@ RDh@RS O$ V$%%@%% \PQRDCSDB] VW$O$ FG%9 $A OW@ U$E)

PM@BO% B@E@%%QAS O$ ]@O OW@M& =@ WQ?@ M@BOD$B@U $B@ %OQ)

OD%ODEQR UD%VQADOSr /f&Zo $C ^WDO@%9 /,&,o $C NRQEh%9 QBU /(&'o

$C 5QODB$% EPAA@BORS V$%%@%% @DOW@A \PQRDCSDB] VW$O$ FG% $A

OW@ U$EPM@BO% OWQO ^$PRU V@AMDO =D%E$B%DB O$ D%%P@ OW@M&_

JFB $OW@A ^$AU%9 OW@%@ A@]D%O@A@U ?$O@A% WQ?@9 $A EQB ]@O9

VW$O$ FG% ^DOW$PO Q%hDB] QBS VPNRDE)A@E$AU% $CCDE@ C$A QBS

QUUDOD$BQR U$EPM@BO9 %PEW Q% Q NDAOW E@AODCDEQO@&K FC DB%O@QU $C

Q%hDB] ^W$ WQ% @DOW@A VW$O$ FG% $A OW@ U$EPM@BO% A@\PDA@U

O$ ]@O OW@M9 ^@ Q%h $BRS ^W$ WQU \PQRDCSDB] VW$O$ FG% Q% $C

_ =@ WQ?@ ]D?@B OW@ V@AE@BOQ]@% $C V@A%$B% ^W$ WQ?@ OW@%@ U$EP)

M@BO%& YRQDBODCC% @mVA@%% OW@ CD]PA@% UDCC@A@BORS9 ]D?DB] OW@ V@AE@BOQ]@% $C

V@A%$B% ^W$ RQEh OW@ U$EPM@BO% J*&(o $C ^WDO@%9 (&,o $C NRQEh%9 QBU

,&/o $C 5QODB$%K9 OW@B UD?DUDB] $B@ V@AE@BOQ]@ NS QB$OW@A O$ SD@RU QB

@mVA@%%D$B %PEW Q% iA@]D%O@A@U TRQEh ?$O@A% DB =D%E$B%DB ^@A@ f+o M$A@

RDh@RS OWQB ^WDO@ ?$O@A% O$ RQEh Q UAD?@Ac% RDE@B%@ $A %OQO@ FGl J5157; TA&

*K& 2WQO D% Q MD%P%@ $C UQOQ& GD?DUDB] $B@ V@AE@BOQ]@ NS QB$OW@A VA$UPE)

@% Q BPMN@A $C RDOOR@ A@R@?QBE@ O$ OW@ VA$NR@M& FC //&/o $C ^WDO@% WQU

VW$O$ FG%9 QBU //&fo $C NRQEh% UDU9 OW@ %QM@ QVVA$QEW ^$PRU SD@RU OW@

%OQO@M@BO iNRQEh% QA@ OWA@@ ODM@% Q% RDh@RS Q% ^WDO@% O$ RQEh \PQRDCSDB]FGl J+&_ s +&' t _K9 NPO %PEW Q %OQO@M@BO ^$PRU MQ%h OW@ CQEO OWQO OW@

V$VPRQOD$B% ^@A@ @CC@EOD?@RS DU@BODEQR& 2WQOc% ^WS ^@ U$ B$O UD?DU@ V@A)

E@BOQ]@%&


17/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ 'f

OW@ OADQR9 OW@ UD%OADEO `PU]@ @%ODMQO@U OWQO /*&fo $C ^WDO@%9

-Z&-o $C NRQEh%9 QBU -,&'o $C 5QODB$% UDU& 6DBQRRS9 OW@ `PU]@

C$PBU OWQO DO ^$PRU N@ WQAU@A C$A NRQEh% QBU 5QODB$%9 $B Q?)

@AQ]@9 O$ ]@O OW@ U$EPM@BO% OW@S B@@U9 N@EQP%@ C$A OW@ CD?@

S@QA% @BUDB] DB *+'' %$M@ f,o $C =D%E$B%DBc% ^WDO@ A@%D)

U@BO% WQU N@@B N$AB DB OWQO %OQO@9 ^WDR@ $BRS ,/o $C NRQEh%

QBU (_o $C 5QODB$% WQU N@@B N$AB OW@A@& >@OODB] NDAOW E@AODC)

DEQO@% CA$M $OW@A %OQO@% D% WQAU@A OWQB ]@OODB] OW@M CA$M

=D%E$B%DB9 OW@ `PU]@ C$PBU& 2W@ U@ED%D$B $C OW@ :PVA@M@

;$PAO $C =D%E$B%DB QBU OW@ %OQO@c% B@^ A@]PRQOD$B% MQS A@)

UPE@ OWQO NPAU@B NPO EQBB$O @RDMDBQO@ DOb V@A%$B% ^W$ A@RS$B OW@ ^QD?@A VA$E@UPA@ %ODRR MP%O QVVRS C$A DO9 ^WDEW M@QB%

OWQO $B Q?@AQ]@ NRQEh QBU 5QODB$ A@%DU@BO% MP%O CDR@ M$A@

VQV@A^$Ah OWQB WDO@ A@%DU@BO%&

7ROW$P]W OW@%@ CDBUDB]% U$EPM@BO Q UD%VQAQO@ $POE$M@9

OW@S U$ B$O %W$^ Q iU@BDQRl $C QBSOWDB] NS =D%E$B%DB9 Q%

e*JQK A@\PDA@%b PBR@%% =D%E$B%DB MQh@% DO (!!1%!**%;WQAU O$

]@O VW$O$ FG9 DO WQ% B$O U@BD@U QBSOWDB] O$ QBS ?$O@A& #$A

UDU OW@ UD%OADEO E$PAO CDBU OWQO UDCC@A@BE@% DB @E$B$MDE EDA)

EPM%OQBE@% QA@ QOOADNPOQNR@ O$ UD%EADMDBQOD$B NS =D%E$B%DB&2W@ `PU]@ @mVRQDB@U WD% CDBUDB]% OWD% ^QSr iOW@ A@Q%$B

TRQEh% QBU 5QODB$% QA@ UD%VA$V$AOD$BQO@RS RDh@RS O$ RQEh QB

FG D% N@EQP%@ OW@S QA@ UD%VA$V$AOD$BQO@RS RDh@RS O$ RD?@ DB

V$?@AOS9 ^WDEW DB OPAB D% OAQE@QNR@ O$ OW@ @CC@EO% $C UD%EADMD)

BQOD$B DB QA@Q% %PEW Q% @UPEQOD$B9 @MVR$SM@BO9 QBU W$P%)

DB]&l *+'( 1&:& GD%O& 54aF: ,/_(( QO u''/& 2W@ `PU]@ UDU B$O

E$BERPU@ OWQO OW@ %OQO@ $C =D%E$B%DB WQ% UD%EADMDBQO@U DB

QBS $C OW@%@ A@%V@EO%& 2WQOc% DMV$AOQBO9 N@EQP%@ PBDO% $C

]$?@ABM@BO QA@ A@%V$B%DNR@ C$A OW@DA $^B UD%EADMDBQOD$B NPO

B$O C$A A@EODCSDB] OW@ @CC@EO% $C $OW@A V@A%$B%c UD%EADMDBQOD$B&

:@@9 @&]&9 :'%%'?!( ./ =6$1%!;9 ('- 1&:& f'f J'/f(K& :@EOD$B *JQK

C$ANDU% UD%EADMDBQOD$B NS iAQE@ $A E$R$Al NPO U$@% B$O A@)


18/23

'- #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

\PDA@ %OQO@% O$ $?@AE$M@ %$ED@OQR @CC@EO% $C VAD?QO@ UD%EADMD)

BQOD$B OWQO QCC@EO OW@ DBE$M@ $A ^@QROW $C V$O@BODQR ?$O@A%&

:@EOD$B *JNK O@RR% P% OWQO e*JQK U$@% B$O E$BU@MB Q ?$ODB]

VAQEODE@ `P%O N@EQP%@ DO WQ% Q UD%VQAQO@ @CC@EO $B MDB$ADOD@%&

JFC OWDB]% ^@A@ OWQO %DMVR@9 OW@A@ ^$PRUBcO WQ?@ N@@B Q B@@U

C$AW'(4%!*O$ RD%O BDB@ B$B)@mERP%D?@ CQEO$A% DB ?$O@)UDRPOD$B

EQ%@%&K FB%O@QU e*JNK O@RR% P%r i7 ?D$RQOD$B $C %PN%@EOD$B JQK D%

@%OQNRD%W@U DC9 NQ%@U $B OW@ O$OQRDOS $C EDAEPM%OQBE@%9 DO D%

%W$^B OWQO OW@ V$RDODEQR VA$E@%%@% R@QUDB] O$ B$MDBQOD$B $A

@R@EOD$B DB OW@ :OQO@ $A V$RDODEQR %PNUD?D%D$B QA@ (9" !U3$%%;

9-!( O$ VQAODEDVQOD$B NS M@MN@A% $C Q ERQ%% $C EDODn@B% VA$)

O@EO@U NS %PN%@EOD$B JQK DB OWQO DO% M@MN@A% WQ?@ %!** 9--96+

"3('"; OWQB $OW@A M@MN@A% $C OW@ @R@EO$AQO@ O$ VQAODEDVQO@ DB

OW@ V$RDODEQR VA$E@%%l J@MVWQ%D% QUU@UK& 7EO *_ U$@% B$O

UAQ^ QBS RDB@ NS AQE@9 QBU OW@ UD%OADEO `PU]@ UDU B$O CDBU OWQO

NRQEh% $A 5QODB$% WQ?@ R@%% i$VV$AOPBDOSl OWQB ^WDO@% O$ ]@O

VW$O$ FG%& FB%O@QU OW@ `PU]@ C$PBU OWQO9 N@EQP%@ OW@S WQ?@

R$^@A DBE$M@9 OW@%@ ]A$PV% QA@ R@%% RDh@RS O$3*! OWQO $VV$A)

OPBDOS& 7BU OWQO U$@% B$O ?D$RQO@ e*& FB ?$ODB])UDRPOD$B EQ%@%9

EDODn@B% RPMV@U DBO$ Q UD%OADEO EQBcO @mOADEQO@ OW@M%@R?@% @m)E@VO NS M$?DB]9 %$ ER@?@A UD%OADEO)RDB@ UAQ^DB] EQB UD%QU)

?QBOQ]@ MDB$ADOD@%& TPO 7EO *_ @mO@BU% O$ @?@AS EDODn@B QB

@\PQR $VV$AOPBDOS O$ ]@O Q VW$O$ FG&

2$ OW@ @mO@BO $POE$M@% W@RV O$ U@EDU@ ^W@OW@A OW@ %OQO@

WQ% VA$?DU@U QB @\PQR $VV$AOPBDOS9 ^@ MP%O R$$h B$O QO 7EO

*_ DB D%$RQOD$B NPO O$ OW@ @BODA@ ?$ODB] QBU A@]D%OAQOD$B %S%)

O@M& FC NRQEh% QBU 5QODB$% U$ B$O ]@O VW$O$ FG% QO OW@ %QM@

CA@\P@BES Q% ^WDO@%9 OWQO ^DRR A@UPE@ OW@DA A@RQOD?@ %WQA@ $C

?$ODB] DB =D%E$B%DB& TS W$^ MPEWq =@ U$BcO hB$^9 N@EQP%@JC$A A@Q%$B% ^@ WQ?@ E$?@A@UK DO MQS N@ OWQO OW@ V@$VR@ ^W$

U$ B$O ]@O VW$O$ FG% QA@ QR%$ OW$%@ R@Q%O RDh@RS O$ ?$O@ ^DOW


19/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ '/

$A ^DOW$PO VW$O$ FG%& 4mV@AD@BE@ CA$M $OW@A %OQO@% ^$PRU

W@RV O$ PBU@A%OQBU OW@ CPRR @CC@EO9 NPO OW@ A@E$AU RQEh% OWQO

DBC$AMQOD$B& TPO ^@ U$ hB$^9 CA$M UQOQ VPNRD%W@U NS OW@

;@B%P% TPA@QP9 OWQO NRQEh% U$ B$O %@@M O$ N@ UD%QU?QBOQ]@U

NS =D%E$B%DBc% @R@EO$AQR %S%O@M Q% Q ^W$R@& FB *+'* f/&Zo $C

=D%E$B%DBc% @RD]DNR@ ^WDO@ B$B)3D%VQBDE A@%DU@BO% ^@A@ A@])

D%O@A@U O$ ?$O@& 2WQO S@QA9 -'o $C OW@ %OQO@c% @RD]DNR@ NRQEh

A@%DU@BO% ^@A@ A@]D%O@A@U O$ ?$O@& J


20/23

*+ #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

NRQEh%9 OW@B OW@ A@]D%OAQOD$B %S%O@M O$V O$ N$OO$M ?D$RQO@%

e*b QBU DC ^WDO@ OPAB$PO $B @R@EOD$B UQS D% *o WD]W@A9 OW@B

OW@ A@\PDA@M@BO $C DB)V@A%$B ?$ODB] ?D$RQO@% e*& H$O$A)?$O@A

A@]D%OAQOD$B9 ^WDEW MQh@% DO %DMVR@ C$A V@$VR@ O$ A@]D%O@A NS

EW@EhDB] Q N$m ^W@B OW@S ]@O UAD?@A%c RDE@B%@%9 ^$PRU N@ DB)

?QRDU9 N@EQP%@ NRQEh QBU 5QODB$ EDODn@B% QA@ R@%% RDh@RS O$

$^B EQA% QBU OW@A@C$A@ R@%% RDh@RS O$ ]@O UAD?@A%c RDE@B%@%&

J2W@ UD%OADEO `PU]@ EDO@U ^DOW QVVA$?QR9 *+'( 1&:& GD%O& 54aF:

,/_(( QO u'+* B&_*9 Q %OPUS E$BERPUDB] OWQO DB HDR^QPh@@

;$PBOS f_o $C ^WDO@ QUPRO%9 (fo $C NRQEh QUPRO%9 QBU (_o $C

3D%VQBDE QUPRO% WQ?@ ?QRDU UAD?@A%c RDE@B%@%b OWD% DMVRD@% QB@\PQRRS RQA]@ UDCC@A@BE@ DB A@]D%OAQOD$B AQO@% P%DB] OW@ M$O$A)

?$O@A VA$O$E$R&K [@O DO ^$PRU N@ DMVRQP%DNR@ O$ A@QU e* Q%

%^@@VDB] Q^QS QRM$%O QRR A@]D%OAQOD$B QBU ?$ODB] APR@%& FO D%

N@OO@A O$ PBU@A%OQBU e*JNK Q% QB @\PQR)OA@QOM@BO A@\PDA@)

M@BO J^WDEW D% W$^ DO A@QU%K OWQB Q% QB @\PQR)$POE$M@

E$MMQBU J^WDEW D% W$^ OW@ UD%OADEO E$PAO O$$h DOK&

6$A OW@ %Qh@ $C QA]PM@BO9 R@O P% VPO QRR $C OW@ C@R$B)

UD%CAQBEWD%@M@BO EQ%@% O$ $B@ %DU@9 @?@B OW$P]W OW@S $CC@A

%OA$B] %PVV$AO C$A $PA A@QUDB] $C e*9 DB ?$O@A)\PQRDCDEQOD$B%DOPQOD$B%9 Q% QB @\PQR)OA@QOM@BO A@\PDA@M@BO& 2WA@@ QVV@R)

RQO@ $VDBD$B% WQ?@ QVVRD@U e* O$ ?$O@A)\PQRDCDEQOD$B APR@%

$OW@A OWQB C@R$B)UD%CAQBEWD%@M@BO %OQOPO@%r W9(X$%!X ./ ,6'X9+

($9 Zff 6&_U _-_9 (+(g'+ J/OW ;DA& *+'*K J@B NQBEKb LC'9 B"$"!

59()!6!(7! 9) D,,5& ./ K3*"!19 #$& '()_-ff JZOW ;DA& :@VO& *(9

*+'(K9 %OQS@U PBU@A OW@ BQM@ K3*"!1 ./ D,,5&9 #$& '(7__Z

J:& ;O& :@VO& */9 *+'(Kb QBU V!$43! 9) @9E!( G9"!6* 9) D96"C

5$69%'($ ./ D96"C 5$69%'($9 #$& '()'-(, J(OW ;DA&


21/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ *'

QVVA$QEW& 2W@ 6$PAOW ;DAEPDO QBU OW@ :DmOW ;DAEPDO9 NS E$B)

OAQ%O9 C$PBUW'(4%!*PBW@RVCPR DB ?$O@A)\PQRDCDEQOD$B EQ%@% JQ%

U$ ^@K QBU A@%OQO@U OW@ %OQOPO@ Q% EQRRDB] C$A O^$ DB\PDAD@%&

TQ%@U $B $PA A@QUDB] $C OW@ VRQDB RQB]PQ]@ $C OW@ %OQOPO@ QBU

A@R@?QBO :PVA@M@ ;$PAO QPOW$ADOS9 ^@ Q]A@@ ^DOW OW@ :DmOW ;DA)

EPDO OWQO Q :@EOD$B * ?$O@)U@BDQR ERQDM E$B%D%O% $C O^$ @R@M@BO%r

v 6DA%O9 iOW@ EWQRR@B]@U w%OQBUQAU9 VAQEODE@9 $A VA$E@UPA@c MP%O

DMV$%@ Q UD%EADMDBQO$AS NPAU@B $B M@MN@A% $C Q VA$O@EO@U

ERQ%%9 M@QBDB] OWQO M@MN@A% $C OW@ VA$O@EO@U ERQ%% wWQ?@ R@%%

$VV$AOPBDOS OWQB $OW@A M@MN@A% $C OW@ @R@EO$AQO@ O$ VQAODED)

VQO@ DB OW@ V$RDODEQR VA$E@%% QBU O$ @R@EO A@VA@%@BOQOD?@% $C OW@DA

EW$DE@&cl K3*"!19 *+'( =5 (f*(f+_9 QO u*( J\P$ODB] j,* 1&:&;&

e'+_+'JQKgJNK9 C$AM@ARSk (* 1&:&;& e'/f_JQK)JNKKb

v :@E$BU9 OWQO NPAU@B iMP%O DB VQAO N@ EQP%@U NS $A RDBh@U O$ w%$)

EDQR QBU WD%O$ADEQR E$BUDOD$B%c OWQO WQ?@ $A EPAA@BORS VA$UPE@

UD%EADMDBQOD$B Q]QDB%O M@MN@A% $C OW@ VA$O@EO@U ERQ%%&l Q1&

J\P$ODB] W'(4%!*9 (f- 1&:& QO (fK&

V!$43! 9) @9E!( G9"!6*9 %RDV $V& __g_(& =@ QA@ %h@VODEQR

QN$PO OW@ %@E$BU $C OW@%@ %O@V%9 N@EQP%@ DO U$@% B$O UD%ODB)

]PD%W UD%EADMDBQOD$B NS OW@ U@C@BUQBO% CA$M $OW@A V@A%$B%c

UD%EADMDBQOD$B& FB ?$O@)UDRPOD$B EQ%@%9 OW@ U$MQDB $C W'(4%!*9OW@ ]$?@ABM@BO DO%@RC UAQ^% OW@ UD%OADEO RDB@%b B$ $B@ @R%@

N@QA% A@%V$B%DNDRDOS& TPO DC ^@ ^@A@ O$ QU$VO OWD% QVVA$QEW

C$A OW@ %Qh@ $C QA]PM@BO9 $PA VRQDBODCC% ^$PRU CQDR QO OW@ CDA%O

%O@V9 N@EQP%@ DB =D%E$B%DB @?@AS$B@ WQ% OW@ %QM@ $VV$A)

OPBDOS O$ ]@O Q \PQRDCSDB] VW$O$ FG&

YW$O$ FG RQ^% WQ?@ N@@B V$RDODEQRRS E$BO@BOD$P%& 56$8)961

A@MQAh@U $B OW@ QVVQA@BORS VQAOD%QB BQOPA@ $C OW@ UD%Q)

]A@@M@BO N@O^@@B OW$%@ ^W$ CQ?$A QBU OW$%@ ^W$ $VV$%@

OW@%@ %OQOPO@%& 2W@ R@QU $VDBD$B %OQO@Ur iDC Q B$BUD%EADMDBQ)

O$AS RQ^ D% %PVV$AO@U NS ?QRDU B@POAQR `P%ODCDEQOD$B%9 OW$%@

`P%ODCDEQOD$B% %W$PRU B$O N@ UD%A@]QAU@U %DMVRS N@EQP%@ VQA)


22/23

** #$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/

OD%QB DBO@A@%O% MQS WQ?@ VA$?DU@U $B@ M$OD?QOD$B C$A OW@

?$O@% $C DBUD?DUPQR R@]D%RQO$A%& x 2W@ QVVRDEQOD$B $C OW@ %OQO)

PO@ O$ OW@ ?Q%O MQ`$ADOS $C FBUDQBQ ?$O@A% D% QMVRS `P%ODCD@U

NS OW@ ?QRDU DBO@A@%O DB VA$O@EODB] wOW@ DBO@]ADOS QBU A@RDQNDR)

DOS $C OW@ @R@EO$AQR VA$E@%%&cl ,,_ 1&:& QO *+(& 2WQO D% OAP@ $C

=D%E$B%DB Q% @RR&


23/23

#$%& '()*+,- . '()*+,/ *_

G@OQDR% $C OW@ DB`PBEOD$B U$ B$O MQOO@A9 W$^@?@A9 ]D?@B

$PA E$BERP%D$B OWQO 7EO *_ U$@% B$O ?D$RQO@ @DOW@A e* $A OW@

;$B%ODOPOD$B& 2W@ `PU]M@BO $C OW@ UD%OADEO E$PAO D% A@?@A%@U&

Documents

Frank Et Al v. Walker Et Al