Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
FRANK RINN
INGENIEUR- UND SACHVERSTÄNDIGEN-BÜRO ENGINEERING- AND EXPERT-OFFICEUNTERSUCHUNG BÄUME, HOLZ, KONSTRUKTIONEN EXAMINATION TREES, TIMBER, CONSTRUCTIONS
ENTWICKLUNG MESSGERÄTE, SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT MEASUREMENT DEVICES, SOFTWARE
BERATUNG SEMINAR, SCHULUNG, VORTRAG CONSULTATION SEMINARS, TRAINING, LECTURES
T R E E - S A F E T Y R E P O R T
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH (FAGUS SYLVATICA)
KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK
2016 __ / __
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 2 / 18
C O N T E N TPage
1 Assignment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
2 Contacts, addresses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
3 Inspection and results. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
4 Summary and conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
5 References and further reading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 3 / 18
1 Assignment
In a visual inspection of the beech (Fagus sylvatica) in summer 2016, signs of fungal decay were
identified at the base of the trunk and between buttresses, most likely caused by Ustulina /
Kretschmaria deusta and Ganoderma. The tree stands directly on the College grounds, right next to
the bridge over the River Cam. This is one of the most prominent locations of Kings College where
many people walk by every day or pass the tree on a boat on the river. Consequently, it is very
important to check the safety of this tree. Because it is impossible to determine the amount of decay
in the tree just by visual assessment and to evaluate the loss in load carrying capacity and safety, a
technical inspection was contracted.
A thorough inspection should be carried out using stress-wave (‘sonic’) tomography (ARBOTOM®)
and root diagnostics (ARBORADIXTM) and, if required resistance drilling with calibratable, ‘real’
RESISTOGRAPH® devices.
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 4 / 18
2 Contacts, addresses
Tree Beech (Fagus sylvatica).
Tree owner King’s College
King's Parade
Cambridge CB2 1ST
United Kingdom
T: +44 1223 331100
www.kings.cam.ac.uk
Tree expert Steven Coghill
Senior Horticulturist of King's College
Inquiry 28.08.2016
Offer 13.09.2016
Order 15.09.2016
Inspection 20.09.2016 Assisted by Jason Mills, Writtle Forest Ltd, Ingatestone, UK
Result explained and presented on site
Report 8. October 2016
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
http://www.ohiodnr.com/forestry/bigtrees/tabid/4810/Default.aspxmailto:[email protected]://www.kings.cam.ac.ukhttp://www.busybeetreemd.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 5 / 18
3 Inspection and results
3.1 Location
The location of the tree is marked with a yellow circle in this picture from US-NASA earth view:
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 6 / 18
Here, in more detail, the crown extension partially over the river and bridge, can be seen:
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 7 / 18
From the Southwest direction, the West-East crown spread and the lean of the stem to the West
can be seen:
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 8 / 18
From the South and parallel to the river Cam, the corrected lean of the stem to the West is clear:
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 9 / 18
From North-East, the reason for the lean to the West (due to competition with neighbouring tree
in the East) becomes more clear:
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 10 / 18
3.2 Sonic tomography sensor at the tree
Sensors 4-3-2-1-17-16-15 on North: Sensors 9-8-7-6-5-4-3-(2)-1 on East:
Sensors 10-9-8-7-6-(5)-4-3 on South-East Sensors 11-10-9-8-7-6 on South
Sensors 13-(12)-11-10-9-8-7 on West Sensors 3-2-1-17-16-15-14-13 on West-North
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 11 / 18
3.3 Results of sonic tomography
Line graph, representing measured results: Cross sectional tomogram:
Relative changes in section modulus: The tomogram indicates the internal extension
of the decay, externally concentrating at the
fruiting bodies close to the sensors #16 and
#17.
According to the section modulus calculation,
the relative loss in load carrying capacity due
to the decay is below 25%.
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 12 / 18
The line graph of the root inspection indicates presence of root decay but no signs for urgent
danger:
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 13 / 18
3.4 Safety balance
Due to our age and growth development model, the safety reserve of the beech is at least 40%.
This conservative estimation is based on these aspects:
> Trees reach their maximum height at a certain age but continue growing in girth.
> Wind load is determined mainly by tree-height (proportional to height³).
> Cross-sectional load carrying capacity mainly depends on diameter (proportional to height³).
> The safety factor of a tree, interpreted as a (mechanical) structure, is proportional to the ratio of
Diameter³ / Height³. As long as tree height and girth are growing similarly, this safety factor is
nearly constant. As soon as tree height growth stagnates, the safety factor increases annually more
than proportional, because being proportional to Diameter taken to the power of three - because
girth growth continues as long as the tree is alive. This is the major reason why old/mature trees
may be largely hollow but still safe, often even safer than young intact trees.
In addition and as a consequence of the studies on the required shell-wall to radius ratio of
approximately 1/3 for ‘young’ trees still growing in height with a central rot in a circular stem, the
natural tree architecture obviously inherits a tolerance for losses in load carrying capacity of approx.
20%.
In combination with the age-related aspects, the total safety reserve of this tree is approx. 60% in
minimum (due to the conservative estimation). That mean, as long as the loss in load carrying
capacity due to decay is less than 60%, there is no significantly increased probability of failure.
Consequently, I see no need for any action in order to reduce wind load for safety reasons.
More details on this topic can be found in the literature cited at the end of this report as well as in
the documents to be downloaded.
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 14 / 18
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 15 / 18
4 Summary and conclusion
Assignment: In a visual inspection of the beech (Fagus sylvatica)
in summer 2016, signs for fungal decay were identified at the base
of the trunk and between buttresses, most likely caused by
Ustulina / Kretschmaria deusta and Ganoderma. The tree stands
directly on the College grounds, right next to the bridge over the
River Cam. This is one of the most prominent locations of King’s
College, Cambridge/UK, were many people walk by every day or
pass the tree on a boat on the river. Consequently, it is very
important to check the safety of this tree. Because it is impossible
to determine the amount of decay in the tree just by visual
assessment and to evaluate the loss in load carrying capacity and
safety, a technical inspection was contracted. A thorough
inspection was carried out using stress-wave (‘sonic’) tomography
(ARBOTOM®) and root diagnostics (ARBORADIXTM). Resistance
drilling with calibratable, ‘real’ RESISTOGRAPH® devices was
found to be not required.
The tomogram indicates the internal extension of the decay,
externally concentrating at the fruiting bodies close to the sensors
#16 and #17. According to the section modulus calculation, the
relative loss in load carrying capacity due to the decay is below
25%. The line graph of the root inspection indicates presence of
root decay but no signs for urgent danger. Due to our age and
growth development model, the safety reserve of the beech is at
least ~60%, thus more than compensating the losses by decay.
Conclusion: Based on the obtained data I see no indication of a significantly increased probability
of stem breakage or uprooting.
Recommendation: A thorough inspection of the crown and installed cables should be carried out
before the end of 2017. Dead wood should be taken out annually. As long as the annual visual
inspection does not identify signs of additional, extended or new signs of decay, the next technical
inspection should be carried out in 2019 at the latest. In addition, I recommend a soil
improvement by a careful de-compaction in combination with injections of fertilizers and
mycorrhiza as well as mulching the root plate area. This seems to be one of the few things that
can be done in order to support an old tree in his defence against this kind of fungal decay.
Court registered tree-expert, inspecting and evaluating trees (tree-rings and
timber) since 1988 in terms of safety, growth, and wood quality.
Frank Rinn
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 16 / 18
5 References and further reading
Bräker, O. U. 1981: Der Alterstrend bei Jahrringdichten undJahrringbreiten von Nadelhölzern und sein Ausgleich.Mitteilungen der forstlichen Bundesversuchsanstalt Wien142, S. 75-102.
Gere, J. M. and Timoshenko, S. P., 1997, Mechanics ofMaterials, PWS Publishing Company.
Kaczka R, Malik I, Owczarek P, Gärtner H, Helle G, HeinrichI (eds.) (2009): TRACE - Tree Rings in Archaeology,Climatology and Ecology, Vol. 7: Proceedings of theDENDROSYMPOSIUM 2008, April 27th–30th 2008,Zakopane, Poland. GFZ. Potsdam, Scientific TechnicalReport STR 09/03, Potsdam, p. 205-210.
Mattheck, Claus und Breloer, Helge 1994: The bodylanguage of trees. A handbook for failure analysis. Researchfor Amenity trees No. 4, HMSO Publications Centre. London1994. ISBN 0-11-753067-0.
Niklas, Karl J., Spatz, Hanns-Christof 2012: Plant Physics.Univ of Chicago Press. ISBN-10: 0226586324.
Rinn, F. 1988: A new method for measuring tree-ringdensity parameters. Physics diploma thesis, Institute forEnvironmental Physics, Heidelberg University, 85pp.
Rinn, F. 1990: Device for material testing, especially wood,by drill resistance measurements. German Patent 4122494.
Rinn, F., Becker, B., Kromer, B. 1990: Density Profiles ofCon i f e r s and Dec i duou s T r ees . P r o c eed ingsLund-Symposium on Tree Rings and Environment, LundUniversity.
Rinn, F. 1993: Catalogue of relative density profiles of trees,poles and t imber derived from RESISTOGRAPHmicro-drillings. Proc. 9th int. meeting non-destructivetesting, Madison 1993.
Rinn, F. 1994: Resistographic visualization of tree ringdensity variations. International Conference Tree Rings andEnvironment. Tucson, AZ, 1994. Printed in: Radiocarbon1996, pp. 871-878.
Rinn, F. 1994: One minute pole inspection withRESISTOGRAPH micro drillings. Proc. Int. Conf. on woodpoles and piles. Ft. Collins, Colorado, USA, March 1994.
Rinn, F. 1994: Resistographic inspection of building timber.Proc. Pacific Timber Engineering Conference. Gold Coast,Australia, July 1994.
Rinn, F., Schweingruber F.-H., Schär, E. 1996:RESISTOGRAPH and X-Ray Density Charts of Wood.Comparative Evaluation of Drill Resistance Profiles andX-Ray Density Charts of Different Wood Species.Holzforschung Vol. 50 (1996) pp. 303-311.
Rinn, F. 1996. Resistographic visualization of tree-ringdensity variations. In: J.S. Dean, D.M. Meko, and T.W.Swetnam, eds., Tree Rings, Environment, and Humanity.Radiocarbon 1996: 871-878.
Rinn, F. 2011: Basic Aspects of Mechanical Stability of TreeCross –Sections. Arborist News Feb 2011, pp. 52-54.
Rinn, F 2012: Basics of typical resistance-drilling profiles.Western Arborist. Winter 2012.
Rinn, F. 2013: Detecting Fungal Decay in Palm Stems byResistance Drilling. Florida Arborist. Part I: Spring 2013. PartII: Summer 2013.
Rinn, F. 2013: Shell-wall thickness and breaking safety ofmature trees. Western Arborist. Fall 2013.
Spatz, H.-CH., Bruechert, F. 2000: Basic Biomechanics ofSelf-Supporting Plants: Wind loads and gravitational loadson a Norway spruce tree. Forest Ecology and Management,135, 33-44 (2000).
Spatz, Hanns–Christof; Niklas, Karl J.: Modes of failure intubular plant organs. Am. J. Bot. February 2013.
T e l e w s k i , F . W . a n d J a f f e M . J . 1 9 8 1 .Thigmomorphogenesis: Changes in the morphology andchemical composition induced by mechanical perturbation insix month old Pinus taeda seedlings. Canadian Journal ofForest Research 11:380-387.
Telewski, F.W. 1995: Wind Induced Physiological andDevelopmental Responses in Trees. IN: "Wind and Trees".M.P. Coutts and J. Grace, eds. pp. 237-263. CambridgeUniversity Press, Cambridge.
Telewski, F.W., Gardner, B.A., White, G., andPlovanich-Jones, A. 1997. Wind flow around multi-storeybuildings and its influence on tree growth. IN: PlantBiomechanics 1997: Conference Proceedings, 7-12September 1997, The University of Reading, UK. Vol. I pp.185-192.
Young, G. H. F., J. C. Demmler, B. E. Gunnarson, A. J.Kirchhefer, N. J. Loader, D. McCarroll: Age trends in treering growth and isotopic archives: A case study of Pinussylvestr is L. from northwestern Norway. GlobalBiogeochemical Cycles. 05/2013; ISBN: 0886-6236.
White, John 1998: Estimating the Age of Large and VeteranTrees in Britain. Forestry Commission. Edinburgh.
Winnistorfer, Paul M., Wimmer, Rupert 1995: Application ofa drill resistance technique for density profile measurementin wood composite panels. Forest Products Journal, Vol. 45,No. 6, p. 90-93, June 1995.
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 17 / 18
L I T E R A T U R E F O R D O W N L O A D
Lectures on tree diagnostics: http://download.rinntech.com/Rinn_TreeSafety_2016.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_TreeDiagnostics_2016.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_WoodAnatomy_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_WindLoadAndPruning_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_TreeRingAnalysisInArboriculture_2012.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_InternationalTreeInspection_Status_2014.pdf
Vorträge über Baumdiagnose:http://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Oberhof_FehlerInDerBaumUntersuchung_2016.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Regelwerke_Baumuntersuchung_2014.pdf
General publications on tree stability:http://download.rinntech.com/RINN_CrossSectionShape_WesternArborist_Spring_2016.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_TreeSizeRelations_WesternArborist_Winter_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_WhenIsABottleneckDangerous_WesternArborist_Summer_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/Goodwin_on_RINN_HollowStems_ArbMag_Feb_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_ErrorCalculationInTreeInspection_WesternArborist_Summer_2014.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_TreeWindLoad_WesternArborist_Spring_2014.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_MatureShellWalls_ISA_WesternArborist_Fall_2013.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_ArboristNews_Feb2011.pdf
Fachbeiträge über Baumstabilität:http://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Holzzentralblatt32_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_BAUMZEITUNG_Klarstellung_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_BAUMZEITUNG_Flaschenhals_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Baumzeitung_03_2013.pdf
Example tree report:http://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Oak_2013.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Sedona_2013_CaseStudy.pdf
Beispiel-Gutachten:http://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Blasbach_Baumunfall_Gutachten_2004-5.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Obertshausen_Unfall_2002.pdf Allgemeine Grundlagen der Baum-Untersuchungen:http://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_DS_DIN1319.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_AFZ_Dez2006_Fehlerrechnung.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_ZurFehlerrechnungInDerBaumkontrolle_ProBaum_1-2006_S12-20.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_GrundlagenDerFehlerrechnung.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Regelwerke_Baumuntersuchung_2014.pdf
Resistance drilling:http://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_InterpretingResistanceDrillingProfiles_WesternArborist_Fall_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_TypicalTrendsInResistance_ISA-AN_Feb2014.pdf
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
http://download.rinntech.com/Rinn_TreeSafety_2016.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_TreeDiagnostics_2016.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_WoodAnatomy_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_WindLoadAndPruning_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/Rinn_TreeRingAnalysisInArboriculture_2012.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_InternationalTreeInspection_Status_2014.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Oberhof_FehlerInDerBaumUntersuchung_2016.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/Rinn_Regelwerke_Baumuntersuchung_2014.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_CrossSectionShape_WesternArborist_Spring_2016.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_TreeSizeRelations_WesternArborist_Winter_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_WhenIsABottleneckDangerous_WesternArborist_Summer_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/Goodwin_on_RINN_HollowStems_ArbMag_Feb_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_ErrorCalculationInTreeInspection_WesternArborist_Summer_2014.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_TreeWindLoad_WesternArborist_Spring_2014.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_MatureShellWalls_ISA_WesternArborist_Fall_2013.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_ArboristNews_Feb2011.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Holzzentralblatt32_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_BAUMZEITUNG_Klarstellung_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_BAUMZEITUNG_Flaschenhals_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Baumzeitung_03_2013.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Oak_2013.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Sedona_2013_CaseStudy.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/Rinn_Blasbach_Baumunfall_Gutachten_2004-5.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Obertshausen_Unfall_2002.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_DS_DIN1319.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_AFZ_Dez2006_Fehlerrechnung.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_ZurFehlerrechnungInDerBaumkontrolle_ProBaum_1-2006_S12-20.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_GrundlagenDerFehlerrechnung.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/Rinn_Regelwerke_Baumuntersuchung_2014.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_InterpretingResistanceDrillingProfiles_WesternArborist_Fall_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_TypicalTrendsInResistance_ISA-AN_Feb2014.pdfmailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
FRANK RINN
TECHNICAL TREE INSPECTION: BEECH, KING’S COLLEGE, CAMBRIDGE / UK 2016 18 / 18
http://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_BasicsOfResistanceDrilling_WCISAWinter2012.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_ISA_Florida_PalmArticle_2013.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_BasicsOfResistanceDrilling_Holztechnologie_2012_03.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_PracticalResistanceDrilling_Holztechnologie_2013_04.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Holzforschung_1996.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/EcksteinSass_HaRuW_1994.PDFhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_ResistographicVisualizationOfTreeRingStructures_RADIOCARBON_1996.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/25YearsResistograph.pdf
Bohrwiderstandsmessungen:http://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Bohrwiderstandsprofile_Baumzeitung_05_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_RisserkennungMitRESISTOGRAPH_Holztechnologie_04_2015.pdf
Sonic tomography:http://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_CentralDefectsInSonicTreeTomography_WesternArborist_Spring_2015.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_SonicTreeTomography_SCAToday12_2014.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/ConceptosBasicosDeTomografiaSonicaEnArboles.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/SIEGERT_PICUS_vs_ARBOTOM_2003.pdf
Schalltomographie:http://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_2004_Holzanatomische_Grundlagen_der_Schalltomographie.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Zahlenskalierung_von_Schalltomogrammen.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_Kleine_Schalltomographiefarrbenlehre_AFZ_08-2007_s404-405.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_AFZ12-2008-630-631_Wurzeldiagnose_mit_einem_Schalltomographen.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_StatischeHinweiseImTomogramm_2004.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_HolzanatomischeGrundlagenSchalltomographie_2003.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/RINN_TechnischeGrundlagenSchallTomographie_2003.pdfhttp://download.Rinntech.com/SIEGERT_PICUS_vs_ARBOTOM_2003.pdf
FRANK RINN, ÖBVS, DIPL.-PHYSICIST / VDI REGISTERED TREE EXPERT [email protected]
HARDTSTR. 20-22, 69124 HEIDELBERG, GERMANY TEL (+49) (0)6221 71405-0 FAX -234 WWW.RINNTECH.COM
423 S. 8TH CT., ST. CHARLES, 60174 ILLINOIS, USA TEL (+1)(630)-3772477 FAX-4856133 [email protected]
http://download.rinntech.com/RINN_BasicsOfResistanceDrilling_WCISAWinter2012.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_ISA_Florida_PalmArticle_2013.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/Rinn_BasicsOfResistanceDrilling_Holztechnologie_2012_03.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/Rinn_PracticalResistanceDrilling_Holztechnologie_2013_04.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Holzforschung_1996.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/EcksteinSass_HaRuW_1994.PDFhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_ResistographicVisualizationOfTreeRingStructures_RADIOCARBON_1996.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/25YearsResistograph.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Bohrwiderstandsprofile_Baumzeitung_05_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_RisserkennungMitRESISTOGRAPH_Holztechnologie_04_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_CentralDefectsInSonicTreeTomography_WesternArborist_Spring_2015.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_SonicTreeTomography_SCAToday12_2014.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/ConceptosBasicosDeTomografiaSonicaEnArboles.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/SIEGERT_PICUS_vs_ARBOTOM_2003.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_2004_Holzanatomische_Grundlagen_der_Schalltomographie.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Zahlenskalierung_von_Schalltomogrammen.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_Kleine_Schalltomographiefarrbenlehre_AFZ_08-2007_s404-405.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_AFZ12-2008-630-631_Wurzeldiagnose_mit_einem_Schalltomographen.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_StatischeHinweiseImTomogramm_2004.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_HolzanatomischeGrundlagenSchalltomographie_2003.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/RINN_TechnischeGrundlagenSchallTomographie_2003.pdfhttp://download.rinntech.com/SIEGERT_PICUS_vs_ARBOTOM_2003.pdfmailto:[email protected]://WWW.RINNTECH.COMmailto:[email protected]
1 Assignment2 Contacts, addresses3 Inspection and results4 Summary and conclusion5 References and further reading