Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
FORUM OUTPUT ON MOVING FORWARD WITH EIA IN MALYSIA IN THE NEW
DECADE
Organised by ENSEARCH in collaboration with Department of Environment
Malaysia on 18.02.2020 @ KGNS
Attended by 112 pax (attendance attached)
A KEYNOTE ADDRESS FROM PN NORLIN BT JAAFAR, DG OF DOE MALAYSIA
1. Try and minimize EIA activities through streamlining;
2. Improve decision making process through better EIA Guidelines for specific sectors;
3. Review of EQA will be done to have consistent terminologies and to be read together with
other legislations;
4. Schedule 1 and Schedule 2 EIAs will need public participation;
5. Assessment procedure might change with public display done first to reduce client charter;
6. NGOs input will be sought during TRC;
7. To promote good governance, an Environmental Professional Body is needed;
B PAPER 1 BY PN ROHIMAH BT AYUB, HEAD OF EVALUATION DEPARTMENT , DOE MALAYSIA
1. DOE has to look into balancing economics, development and social issues;
2. DOE wants good quality EIA report so that review can be easy; Data should be presented in a
truthful manner;
3. An Environmental Professional Board has to be realized so that fees can be charged and
consultants regulated peers;
4. Prescribed activities being looked into to possibly reducing number of activities listed;
5. Public display might be imposed prior to EIA submission so that stakeholders are engaged
and impacts stated can be mitigated in final report;
C PAPER 2 BY PN SARA OF WWF : REFER TO SLIDES (Refer attached)
D PAPER 3 BY IR MAZURA MAZLAN – REFER TO SLIDES (Refer attached)
E FORUM SESSION MODERATED BY MR SIRAJ
General comments by PN NORLIN
1. DOE will engage with more NGOs specific to the location or their particular expertise;
2. There should be a structured protem committee for the Environmental Professional Board;
General comments by NREB REP
1. To date 2600 EIA reports processed since 1994;
2. Only 1 schedule of prescribed activities;
3. Public review is done for all mega and sensitive projects;
4. 300 registered consultants;
General comments by JPAS REP
1. SEPA and WWF are NGOs that help out a lot with JPAS work;
2. Sabah has about 100 registered consultants;
3. Sabah has 3 categories of reports : PMM and EIA which is Special EIA or normal EIA
Q&A by Panel and participants
Shukri of Malakoff
Are there any legal requirement for how much of budget should be allocated for env
protection : Pn Norlin said it’s based on project as part of GSR;
How do you ensure DOE staff competency : Pn Norlin said all DOE staff have rigorous
training mirror image of industry competency, performance is reviewed and includes soft
skills and communication training
Tania of DHI
EIA should be done technically well as it is a good tool for decision making
Abdul Halim
Any possibility of Semenanjung, Sabah and Sarawak having a common registration scheme
Panel : Different laws prevails so cannot for now. MA63 will further enforced by individual
East Malaysia states
Hopefully Environmental Professional Board will address problems related to paymaster
syndrome and competency of Professional
Badariah
EO requirement be a mandatory requirement under Project Proponent and not contractor;
PP should be required to attend mandatory environmental awareness course with EiMAS;
AMR
Timelines are important to be observed for the good of the economy and for jobs creation in
the country;
Technical agencies inputs should be limited
Casey
Look into Auditor registration scope as there is none in the expert fields;
Auditors have not been receiving any feedback form DOE on their performance
LIST OF PARTICIPANTS
1. GOBINATHAN KUMARAN NAIR
PRESIDENT ENSEARCH
2. GEETHA P KUMARAN VICE PRESIDENT ENSEARCH
3. TAN POH AUN HON SEC GEN ENSEARCH
4. JENNY TAN TREASURER ENSEARCH
5. MR SIRAJ ABDUL RAZACK COUNCIL MEMBER ENSEARCH
6. DR SUBRAMANIAM COUNCIL MEMBER ENSEARCH
7. ZAIPUL ANWAR ZAINU COUNCIL MEMBER ENSEARCH
8. YBrs PUAN NORLIN BINTI JAAFAR
DIRECTOR GENERAL
JAS
9. DR NORHAZNI BINTI MAT SARI
DEPUTY DG JAS
10. PUAN ROHIMAH BINTI AYUB
DIRECTOR JAS
11. TUAN AZLAN BINTI AHMAD DIRECTOR JAS KL
12. PUAN SHARIFAH ZAKIAH KETUA PENOLONG PENGARAH KANAN
JAS NS
13. PUAN AZLINA BINTI HAJI OMAR
PEGAWAI KAWALAN ALAM SEKITAR KANAN
EIMAS
14. TUAN HEDZIR BIN ZAKARIA
KETUA PENOLONG PENGARAH KANAN
JAS SELANGOR
15. TUAN WANDI YADZID BIN HAJI YAAKOB
KETUA PENOLONG PENGARAH KANAN
JAS KL
16. TUAN SHAM IZZUDI BIN MAT HUSSIN
KETUA PENOLONG PENGARAH
JAS
17. SARADAMBAL SRINIVASAN
PROGRAMME OFFICER (POLICY & ADVOCACY)
WWF MALAYSIA
18. MR TSAI KOH FEN ACTING ASSISTANT CONTROLLER (ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION)
NREB CONTROLLER
19. MOHD IRFAN MOHD AMIN - ALS GLOBAL
20. ROHAIEZA BINTI RAZALI - ALS GLOBAL
21. MUHAMMAD KHAIRUL ZIYAD BIN MOHAMAD ZAID
ENVIRONMENTAL OFFICER
PEMBINAAN IKHASAS-MERAK SDN. BHD.
22. MAZURA MD MAZLAN CONSULTANT TRI ECOEDGE SDN BHD
23. LEONG SOOK FONG PRINCIPAL CONSULTANT
TRI ECOEDGE SDN BHD
24. PETER HO YUEH CHUEN CONSULTANT TRI ECOEDGE SDN BHD
25. FAIZAH OTHMAN ENVIRONMENTAL OFFICER
CIRI SELASIH SDN BHD
26. TSEN KING FOH DIRECTOR SUSTAINABLE RESOURCES MANAGEMENT SDN BHD
27. NG TIONG SHENG EIA CONSULTANT UNITI ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS (M) SDN. BHD.
28. BADARIAH BINTI AWANG KECHIK
DIRECTOR PERUNDING ALAM
29. RAMKUMAR MANAGING DIRECTOR
GSR ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANCY SDN BHD
30. MOHD HASRI BIN OMAR PRINCIPAL CONSULTANT
O&E TECHNOLOGIES SDN BHD
31. SHAMSOL AZHAR BIN ISMAIL
MANAGING DIRECTOR
ECO SYNERGY SOLUTIONS SDN. BHD.
32. NUR FAEZA BINTI SUFA'AT SENIOR MANAGER ECO SYNERGY SOLUTIONS SDN. BHD.
33. ROSHAM KADIMAN BIN SAMSUDIN
DIRECTOR PINNACLE ENGINEERS SDN BHD
34. ABDUL HALIM BIN ALI HASSAN
MANAGING DIRECTOR
PERUNDING UEP SDN BHD
35. MD ZAHAR MOHAMAD DIRECTOR YARRA ENVIRO SOLUTIONS SDN BHD
36. SAVITRI A/P S.RAMIAH ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
RAMBOLL MALAYSIA
37. ABD RASID BIN JAAPAR SENIOR GEOLOGIST
GEOMAPPING TECHNOLOGY SDN BHD
38. HERLINA AB AZIZ EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
PEERS CONSULT (M) SDN BHD
39. MD DZAID ISMAIL - PEERS CONSULT (M) SDN BHD
40. MUHAMAD AZAHAR BIN ABAS
SENIOR LECTURER UNIVERSITI MALAYSIA KELANTAN
41. AU CHOON WAI SENIOR MANAGER - ESH
SUNWAY CONSTRUCTION
42. AHMAD ZULHILMY BIN AHMAD YUSRI
ASSOCIATES GEOLOGIST
GEO SOLUTION RESOURCES
43. AHMAD NIZAM BIN HASAN PRINCIPAL GEO SOLUTION RESOURCES
44. LEONG YAN PING ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
ENVASIA SDN BHD
45. EDWARD WONG FAI HUNG PRINCIPAL CONSULTANT
ENVASIA SDN BHD
46. NOR SYAFIQAH BINTI PADZIR
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
ENVASIA SDN.BHD
47. PUVANESURI SANDERA SAGAREN
DIRECTOR FANLI MARINE AND CONSULTANCY SDN BHD
48. MUSHAIYARAH BINTI MOHD BISHRI
ENVIRONMENTAL EXECUTIVE
PERUNDING ALAM
49. NUR ARINA BT MUHAMAD AFFANDI
EIA CONSULTANT EUROPASIA ENGINEERING SERVICES SDN. BHD.
50. ZETY AKHTAR EIA CONSULTANT EUROPASIA ENGINEERING SERVICES SDN BHD
51. PUA HOCK WEI ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
EUROPASIA ENGINEERING SERVICES SDN BHD
52. ELIN EMPAU PEGAWAI KAWALAN ALAM SEKITAR
JABATAN PERLINDUNGAN ALAM SEKITAR
53. RAHIMAH BINTI HJ. AHMAD
ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROL OFFICER
ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION DEPARTMENT
54. SHEILA SHARMA MANAGING PRINCIPAL
RAMBOLL MALAYSIA SDN BHD
55. ZAIDI BIN ZIN ENGINEER I.Z. ENVIRONMIND SDN BHD
56. SIVAKUMAR A/L CHINNASAMY
DIRECTOR CSK MURNI SERVICES SDN BHD
57. CHOW PUI HEE MANAGING DIRECTOR
SAMAIDEN SDN BHD
58. FATIN NABILA BINTI MD ROSLI
CONSULTANT RAMBOLL MALAYSIA SDN BHD
59. SOON YONG ENN CONSULTANT RAMBOLL MALAYSIA SDN BHD
60. NURUL AIN BINTI SAPEIA ENVIRONMENTAL EXECUTIVE
WIRANDA (M) SDN BHD
61. TANIA GOLINGI HEAD OF DEPARTMENT,
DHI WATER & ENVIRONMENT (M) SDN BHD
ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT
62. NURUL AUJI BINTI MOHD JIMMY WONG
EXECUTIVE MALAYSIA RAIL LINK SDN BHD
63. NURASYURA YASMIN BINTI MU-AS
EXECUTIVE MALAYSIA RAIL LINK SDN BHD
64. ENG WENG HONG ENVIRONMENT CONSULTANT
NORTH BORNEO ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES SDN. BHD
65. YONG WAI YEN SENIOR CONSULTANT
EUROPASIA ENGINEERING SERVICES SDN BHD
66. SYED MOHAZRI BIN SYED HAZARI
DEPUTY HEAD OF DEPARTMENT
DHI WATER & ENVIRONMENT (M) SDN. BHD.
67. SAIFUDIN BIN TAMZIS MANAGER AYAMAS INTEGRATED POULTRY INDUSTRY SDN. BHD. (FEEDMILL DIV.)
68. AZYANTEE BINTI GHAZALLY
SENIOR CONSULTANT
EUROPASIA ENGINEERING SERVICES SDN BHD
69. ALEX LIM SWEE YONG SUSTAINABILITY OFFICER
CIMB BANK BERHAD
70. NOOR HARNIZA BINTI HARIS
PRINCIPAL CONSULTANT
HAZA ECO CONSULTANCY AND SERVICES
71. KEE CHONG YEE EIA CONSULTANT EUROPASIA ENGINEERING SERVICES SDN BHD
72. TEW KIA HUI INTERNATIONAL CONSULTANT
VT SOIL TECH PROFESSIONAL
73. LOH TONG LOY CONSULTANT GREEN EARTH CONSULTANCY & SERVICES PLT
74. NORHADILLA HADIB EIA CONSULTANT DIZ ENVIRONMENT GREEN CONSULTANT
75. NORAISHAH MD ZAMANI EIA CONSULTANT DIZ ENVIRONMENT GREEN CONSULTANT
76. FENNYSHARTY HAZLI EIA CONSULTANT DIZ ENVIRONMENT GREEN CONSULTANT
77. MOHD IRFAN MOHD AMIN HSE PROJECT ADVISORS
ALS TECHNICHEM (M) SDN BHD
78. DR. MOHAMMAD ISMAIL BIN YAZIZ
DIRECTOR WIRANDA (M) SDN BHD
79. MUHAMMAD ZAIDY BIN ABU TAMIN
MANAGER MASS RAPID TRANSIT CORPORATION SDN BHD
80. MICHELLE SEE YEN MAY ANALYST ERE CONSULTING GROUP SDN BHD
81. TAN KIM FONG PRINCIPAL CONSULTANT
AGV ENVIRONMENT SDN BHD
82. ALYA ALJAFRI ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
UNDP
83. NOOR ZAHARAH BINTI ZULKIPLI
ENVIRONMENTAL EXECUTIVE
VELCRO ENVIROTECH SDN BHD
84. MUHAMAD ARIEF BIN MUHAMAD ZUBIR
ASSISTANT CONSULTANT
VELCRO ENVIROTECH SDN BHD
85. AMIRUL RAHMAN BIN ZAMRI
ANALYST ERE CONSULTING GROUP SDN BHD
86. RAJA NUR ASHIKIN RAJA ZAINAL
DIRECTOR ERE CONSULTING GROUP SDN BHD
87. OMANTARAM KANGARAJOO
ENGINEER GLOTEQ RESOURCES SDN. BHD.
88. KUMAR ANNAVOO MANAGING DIRECTOR
HEXAMATICS ENVIRORICH SDN. BHD.
89. AMIR IRFAN SUFI BIN SHUIB
EXECUTIVE (ENVIRONMENT)
PETRONAS
90. NOOR KHUZAIFAH BT AWANG GHAZALI
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
ECOGREEN ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANCY
91. AZROL BIN ALI MANAGING DIRECTOR
ECOGREEN ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANCY
92. IR DR CASEY NGO SAIK PENG
PRINCIPAL CONSULTANT
R-SYNC TECHNICAL RESOURCES SDN. BHD.
93. DATO HALIMAH HASSAN DIRECTOR GREEN ENABLE TECHNOLOGIES SDN BHD
94. WONG SUH CHUEN ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
YELLOWSTONE ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANCY
95. TAN XING KANG SENIOR COUNSULTANT
ERE CONSULTING GROUP SDN BHD
96. SHAHRUL ANUAR BIN MOHD SAH
PROFESSOR SCHOOL OF BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES
97. MOHD NAWAHIDUDIN BIN MAHAMAD ISA
MANAGING DIRECTOR
NILAIMAS SERVICES
98. RAHEMMI SYAZADI BIN ZABIT
SENIOR EXECUTIVE, SAFETY, HEALTH & ENVIRONMENTAL
FIMA TECHNOLOGY SDN BHD
99. NAZRI BIN TALIB HEAD OF ENGINEERING
FIMA TECHNOLOGY SDN BHD
100. LOO AI CHOO DIRECTOR SMHB ENGINEERING SDN BHD
101. ROHIMAH BINTI ALI HSE EXECUTIVE KLCC PROJEKS SERVICES SDN BHD
102. AZLAN SHAH BIN AZIZ HSE EXECUTIVE KLCC PROJEKS SERVICES SDN BHD
103. NIK NORULAINI NIK AB RAHMAN
SENIOR CONSULTANT
PULTEX ENVIRONMENT SDN BHD
104. AMIRUL ASYRAF AZIZAN ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
WIRANDA (M) SDN BHD
105. JUDY KUEH JOO KHENG ASSOCIATE GLOBAL WATER CONSULTANTS SDN BHD
106. MOHD SABKI SHUKRY BIN JALALUDDIN
- MALAKOFF ENGINEERING SDN BHD
107. NOOR HAFIZAH BINTI KUSNIN
OPERATIONS DIRECTOR
AMR ENVIRONMENTAL SDN BHD
108. AMMAR BIN MOHD RASHID MANAGING DIRECTOR
AMR ENVIRONMENTAL SDN BHD
109. MUHAMMAD NAZRIN MUHAMMAD NAJIB
- ECOGREEN ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANCY
110. CHENG CHI WEI COASTAL AND
MARINE
MODELLER
DHI WATER & ENVIRONMENT (M) SDN BHD
111. HUNG YEE HON - GREENWICH ENVIRONMENT SDN BHD
112. NUR ARIF IBRAHIM - INDAH WATER KONSORTIUM SDN BHD
END
Attached pictures of event
