27
FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A Project Presented to The Faculty of Humboldt State University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Business Administration Committee Membership Dr. Carol Telesky, Advisor/Committee Chair Dr. David Sleeth-Keppler, Committee Member/Graduate Coordinator July 2015

FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER

By

Boyan Boyanov

A Project Presented to

The Faculty of Humboldt State University

In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree

Master of Business Administration

Committee Membership

Dr. Carol Telesky, Advisor/Committee Chair

Dr. David Sleeth-Keppler, Committee Member/Graduate Coordinator

July 2015

Page 2: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

Abstract

FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER

Boyan Boyanov

Daily time series for the Euro and United States Dollar (EURUSD) currency pair were

examined for the presence of higher than average occurrences of continuation moves

after excessive price volatility. The goal was to assess the presence of high probability for

extracting consistent positive returns from the spot foreign exchange market, Forex. Short

assessments of the market players, analytical approaches, and trading strategies were

conducted from the viewpoint of a small independent Forex speculator. Both, upward and

downward momentum bias and positive returns were found for some of the discretionary

time periods. Differences between upward and downward momentum bias and returns

were observed. Without considering risk and trade management, the results represent first

step in designing a comprehensive trading routine.

Key words: momentum, spot foreign exchange market, Forex, volatility, momentum bias.

ii

Page 3: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

Table of Contents

Abstract ............................................................................................................................... ii

Introduction ..........................................................................................................................1

Assessing the playing field ............................................................................................. 1

Analyzing the market ...................................................................................................... 3

Technical analysis ........................................................................................................... 6

Technical based trading effectiveness ............................................................................ 7

Momentum and market efficiency .................................................................................. 8

Designing a Forex technical strategy based on momentum ......................................... 11

The Methodology ...............................................................................................................13

Results and Discussion ......................................................................................................14

Limitations and further research ................................................................................... 18

References: .........................................................................................................................20

iii

Page 4: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

List of Tables

Table 1. Upward momentum probability .......................................................................... 14

Table 2. Downward momentum probability ..................................................................... 15

Table 3. Cumulative returns based on momentum bias .................................................... 16

Table 4. Upward momentum bias and average returns ..................................................... 16

Table 5 Downward momentum bias and average returns………………………………..17

iv

Page 5: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

1

Introduction

Assessing the playing field

When it comes to participating as an independent retail trader in the spot foreign

exchange market, Forex, finding a profitable trading strategy might prove to be rather a

difficult task. According to The Bank of International Settlements’ (BIS) Triennial

Survey “trading in foreign exchange markets averaged $5.3 trillion per day in April

2013” (BIS, 2013). Retail trader activities represent a tiny increment of this daily

turnover. Nevertheless, with the widespread availability of retail Forex brokers offering

inexpensive access to “one-click” computer trading, the number of retail traders is

steadily growing, and thus the demand for robust and sustainable trading approaches.

Unfortunately, the ease of access to trading in the Forex market, along with

around the clock market activities, and 50:1 account leverage does not automatically

translate into positive financial performance. On the contrary, a study performed by the

French financial markets regulatory body (Autorité des marchés financiers, AMF) found

that between 2009 and 2013 89% of all the individual investors trading in Forex did not

make money (AMF, 2014).

There are many seemingly unresolvable disadvantages the small independent

trader has to face in the complex Forex world. Unlike large banks, the retail trader does

not have access to the direct interbank exchange rate quotes and spreads. Instead, she has

to rely on the accuracy and the integrity of the retail brokers. Unfortunately, in many

cases the retail brokers are dealing against their own customer. They are also known to

Page 6: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

2

manipulate the exchange rates and spreads. Because of liquidity issues retail traders

suffer from re-quotes and execution slippage. In addition they are charged fees and

commissions regardless of the quality and the accuracy of broker’s services. Furthermore,

the retail trader does not have the luxury of banks, funds, and other large traders of

having unlimited time, financial resources, expert advice, and access to processing

power.

Nevertheless, the large institutional traders and private funds have their own

challenges. Even in the most liquid markets, large market participants have to break their

trades into smaller packages so they don’t dramatically affect the price volatility. Chan

and Lakonishok (1995, Table I) show that “only 20% of the market value of these

packages are completed within a day and that over 53% are spread over four trading days

or more”. Meanwhile, the small retail trader is less likely to have problems with instant

market execution in a liquid market.

Furthermore, big market participants not only are struggling with anticipating the

market behavior but also have difficulties assessing their own market impact. Fama

(1991), and Chevalier and Ellison (1999) suggest that the bulk of the institutional traders

do not outperform the market based on their unlimited access to information.

Additionally, Holthausen and Verrecchia (1990), Keim and Madhavan (1996), and Hong

and Rady (2002) suggest that despite their efforts, institutional traders have little or no

idea of what will be the impact of their trading activities on the market.

In this light, we will investigate the chances of an independent, small retail trader

of extracting positive returns from the Forex market by finding and utilizing a simple and

Page 7: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

3

robust market approach. To answer this question, the introduction will offer a quick

overview of the different schools for analyzing the market and the associated challenges.

Further, we offer a basic idea of volatility and momentum to shed light on the elements of

a trading strategy. We describe our methodology in order to tackle the results and the

associated discussion. Finally, we offer a brief limitation overview and recommendations

for further research.

Analyzing the market

In order to capitalize on the market price fluctuations, the retail trader have to

decide on the level of discretion in his trading activity.

At first, he might try to guess the market direction by flipping a coin. He will soon

realize that in the best case scenario over a relatively long period he might break even not

considering the cost of trading (e.g., broker’s commissions, slippage, spread, taxes, etc.).

Later, he might try to use some of the inexpensive trading products ranging from “holy

grail” indicators, to “bullet proofed” trading systems, to black boxes. There is a general

lack of data showing a consistent profitability for any of these trading approaches.

Instead, the internet forums are filled with negative feedback about the profitability and

functionality of these bargain, “no-brainer” systems.

As time goes on, our retail trader might learn more about the different market

drivers, and he might attempt to forecast the market direction using some form of

fundamental analysis. First, he needs to be aware that each market has its own

fundamental drivers, structure, and participants. For example, Meese and Rogoff (1983)

Page 8: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

4

demonstrate that economic fundamentals which are predominant in the stock markets do

not drive Forex.

Important data considering Forex can range from central bank interventions and

economic policy changes, to inflation rate, to changes in import and export, and various

correlations between them (Neely and Weller, 2011), (LeBaron, 1999), and (Kawakami,

2013). For example, the retail trader might recognize that the ongoing U.S. Federal

Reserve “Quantitative Easing” program , combined with aggressive intervention of the

Japanese Central Bank in order to weaken the Japanese Yen, have arguably created a

long-term up-trending environment for the United States Dollar/Japanese Yen

(USD/JPY) currency pair. Furthermore, one can venture to speculate on how the recent

Swiss Central bank decision to unpeg the Swiss Franc from the Euro will cause an

instant, large drop in the Euro/Swiss Franc (EUR/CHF) exchange rate.

Lastly, the retail trader has to be aware of the relationships between stocks,

futures, and Forex. For example, Engel and West (2004) suggest that changes in

exchange rates influence macroeconomic fundamental variables. After extended review,

Clements and Fry (2008) conclude that “currencies are indeed driven by commodities, or

that commodities are driven by currencies, over the period 1975–2005.” (e.g., the

Canadian dollar is assumed to weaken as the price of oil falls).

In order to analyze fundamental economic data, the retail trader has to be aware

not only of the relevant relationships between major fundamental drivers and markets but

also she needs to accurately anticipate the magnitude of their impacts on each of the

traded currencies. General lack of resources or their timely access makes this process

Page 9: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

5

challenging. For example, the interest rate differential as a time series factor has one of

the biggest and longest predictive powers in the case of the USD/JPY pair (Kawakami,

2013, table 2). But timing its effect on short and mid-term market behavior is

cumbersome and impractical. The notions that news travels slowly (Daniel et al., 1998),

and is not reflected instantaneously by the market prices (Evans and Lyons, 2005) add

more difficulties to trading decision timing.

On the other hand, having unlimited resource access does not guarantee a

successful market performance (Fama, 1991) and (Chevalier and Ellison, 1999). Foster

and Viswanathan (1994) show evidence that the less informed trader “can make sharper

inferences from the order flow than the market maker about the extra information.”

Changing economic dynamics and opposing expert views might further dampen

the results of fundamental forecasting and lead to contradicting assumptions about market

volatility, direction, and timing. This is even truer when it comes to analyzing the impact

on markets by complex cultural, political, social and natural events and processes.

In the last decades the theory of behavioral economics is taking new look at how

human decision making influences financial markets (Mullainathan and Thaler,

2000). Pring (1997) points out that “prices in any freely traded market are determined

more by the attitude of traders to the emerging fundamentals than by the fundamentals

themselves. This means that markets (I.e. price trends) are essentially driven by

psychological forces.” Overexposed rumors might trigger enormous price gyrations while

seemingly important economic news might be ignored by the market participants.

Page 10: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

6

Technical analysis

“Learn from the past, live in the present, hope for the future.” Albert Einstein

Instead of trying to analyze the market effects of complex events and processes,

the small retail trader might spend her scarce resources on analyzing the price movement

in relation to itself, or perform the so-called technical analysis.

The technical approach to investment is essentially a reflection of the idea

that prices move in trends which are determined by the changing attitudes

of investors toward a variety of economic, monetary, political and

psychological forces. Since the technical approach is based on the theory

that the price is a reflection of mass psychology (“the crowd”) in action, it

attempts to forecast future price movements on the assumption that crowd

psychology moves between panic, fear, and pessimism on one hand and

confidence, excessive optimism, and greed on the other. (Pring, 1991, pp.

2-3)

A good example of the effect of “mass psychology” is institutional herding, the fact

that “institutional investors' demand for a security this quarter is positively correlated

with their demand for the security last quarter” (Sias, 2004). Looking at the phenomenon

Dasgupta et al. (2011) suggest that “institutional herding positively predicts short term

returns.”

On its own right, technical analysis assesses the price behavior separate from the

underlying economic and social forces. In order to assess proportions and relations

Page 11: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

7

between time and price changes, this approach might use various tools like Japanese

candlesticks, Fibonacci numbers, harmonic relations, and fractals to name few. As a

result, technical approach believes that statistically significant repeatable patterns could

be used to effectively predict future market movements.

Technical based trading effectiveness

Although technical analysis has been used for centuries to anticipate market

direction, the academic literature on the topic is somewhat split and inconclusive. On one

hand, predicting markets by looking at historic prices directly contradicts the weak form

of the efficient market theory (Fama, 1970). On the other hand, it is hard to know in

advance which set of technical rules or tools would be the most suitable for testing

different market conditions. This often leads to data snooping bias (Kuang et al., 2014).

Even when the bias is statistically eliminated the results vary over time and on different

markets. Levich and Thomas (1993), and Neely et al. (1997) find that although technical

trading was successful between 1976 and 1990 the returns declined in late 80’s and early

90’s. Pukthuanthong-Le et al. (2007), and Neely and Weller (2013) find that currently,

rule based profits are predominantly present in the emerging markets. Furthermore,

LeBaron (1999) claims that the technical rules are mainly profitable in the presence of an

active central bank intervention.

As a starting point, many successful traders use some form of technical analysis

of price and volume but take their trading decisions on “gut feeling”. Due to their highly

Page 12: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

8

discretionary “instinctive” origin, those positive trading results cannot be confirmed and

repeated by using the systematical scientific approach (Aronson, 2006).

Momentum and market efficiency

The technical trading techniques can be divided into two general groups:

momentum and mean-reverse. The momentum strategies rely on price accelerating away

from its mean: average price, average return, interest rate differentials, or any other

relevant average. On the contrary, the mean-reverse techniques take advantage of the

“rubber band effect”, or the tendency of the price to revisit the relevant mean after

“stretching away” from it.

The presence of market momentum is a not well understood phenomenon. Ever

since the “momentum effect” was “noticed” by De Bondt and Thaler (1985) it has not

ceased to challenge the market efficiency theory (Fama, 1970). According to this theory,

markets fully reflect any available information and quickly incorporate every relevant

news. Thus, the price instantaneously incorporates the underlying factors and, as a result,

behaves in random fashion. These market behaviors make any prediction obsolete.

Therefore, technical analysis, or looking at previous prices, and fundamental analysis, or

looking at the underlying drivers, are deemed useless.

The market efficiency theory has been challenged both, by consequent academic

research and by active market participants. For example, here is what Warren Buffet has

to say in reference to his value investing approach in a speech he gave in Columbia

Business School, May 17, 1984:

Page 13: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

9

There seems to be some perverse human characteristic that likes to make

easy things difficult. The academic world, if anything, has actually backed

away from the teaching of value investing over the last 30 years. It’s likely

to continue that way. Ships will sail around the world but the Flat Earth

Society will flourish. There will continue to be wide discrepancies

between price and value in the marketplace, and those who read their

Graham & Dodd will continue to prosper. (Buffet, 1984, p.13)

Soros (2010), the man who broke the Bank of England, claims that “the crash of

2008 also falsified the Efficient Market Hypothesis because it was generated by internal

developments within the financial markets, not by external shocks, as the hypothesis

postulates.”

In the last decades, new research finds that certain market behaviors, such as

momentum, continue to cause market inefficiencies. More recently, Okunev and White

(2003), Miffre and Rallis (2006), Fuertes et al. (2013), Jostova et al. (2013), Munira et al.

(2008), and Evans and Lyons (2005) not only suggest the presence of momentum in a

variety of markets but also most of them find that the phenomenon provides consistent,

positive excess returns.

Investopedia defines market momentum as “the rate of acceleration of a security's

price or volume.” Once the direction is defined, the idea is that it will continue as long as

Page 14: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

10

“the force is greater than the resistance”.1 The greater and the longer underlying market

force is applied, the more persistent the trend will be.

Market momentum steams from few directions. De Bondt and Thaler (1985) show

evidence of the tendency of market participants to buy “winners” and sell “losers” which

contributes to the above mentioned “institutional herding”. Furthermore, any type of

relevant news can trigger lasting effects on markets. Evans and Lyons (2004) suggest that

“currency markets are not responding to news instantaneously.”

News arrivals induce subsequent changes in trading in all of the major

end-user segments. These induced changes remain significant for days.

Induced trades also have persistent effects on prices. (Evans & Lyons,

2004)

Additionally, volatility, or higher than average price fluctuation, is an important

force for setting the market in motion. Chan (2013) finds that the volatility in Forex is

1 Classical mechanics explains momentum as a result of the mass and velocity of an

object. Higher velocity and bigger mass will result in larger momentum. It would take a larger or longer

initial force to move a heavy object and it will take equally large or long opposing force to stop the

momentum. The larger or longer the push and the larger the object’s mass the bigger the momentum. The

law of conservation of momentum is considered to be stated by the English mathematician John Wallis in

his 1670 work, Mechanica sive De Motu, Tractatus Geometricus: "the initial state of the body, either of rest

or of motion, will persist" and "If the force is greater than the resistance, motion will result". (Scott, J.F.

(1981). The Mathematical Work of John Wallis, D.D., F.R.S. Chelsea Publishing Company. p. 111)

Page 15: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

11

higher than in the stock market, and it has a much higher kurtosis. Long periods of

seemingly drifting rates are followed by short seismic moves.

Soros (2010) suggests that trends are the result of positive feedback loops:

In a positive feedback a distortion in the participants’ view causes

mispricing in financial markets, which in turn affects the so-called

fundamentals in a self-reinforcing fashion, driving the participants’ views

and the actual state of affairs ever further apart. (Soros, 2010)

Soros (2010) further suggests that the resulting momentum is one of the

components of a market bubble in the making.

Finally, Zhang (2010) finds that additional volatility might be induced by the

activities of the so-called high-frequency trading. During the active session hours, trading

software is placing, cancelling, or executing massive amounts of orders at any given

moment.

Designing a Forex technical strategy based on momentum

The effective momentum trading method has to ultimately rely upon simple and

robust approaches derived from “objective observation and statistical inference”

(Aronson, 2007). The strategy must be intuitively dynamic, adopting the market volatility

changes which implies simplicity and sophistication. Since the strategy is aimed for use

by the average retail trader, it needs to be easily recognizable and repeatable. The applied

rules have to be simple and as objective as possible.

Page 16: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

12

The retail trader can start with a small account which can be actively traded 24

hours, five days a week and is easily accessible through highly leveraged brokerage firm.

In order to avoid lack of liquidity they can use the EUR/USD pair.2

Furthermore, the strategy test should not require expensive technology, software,

specialized economic or technical knowledge. The rules also need to reflect the

assumption that the average retail trader does not have unlimited trading time. Even if

they did, Miffre and Rallis (2006) and the AMF (2014) found that more frequent trading

leads to worse financial outcomes.

2 According to the AMF study (AMF, 2014), the EUR/USD was the most traded currency pair with 24.1% daily average turnover in April of 2014.

Page 17: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

13

The Methodology

The focus is to study well established currency pair with high liquidity facilitating

market participation and reducing risk of trading. The goal of the study is to assess the

direction of the market flow in relation to the 20 day average outliers in the EUR/USD

currency pair. The analysis is based on a sample of daily high, low, and closing quotes of

the EUR/USD pair over the period from January 2nd, 2004 to January 30th, 2015. The

complimentary data was downloaded from www.Global-View.com. The calculations and

data analysis were made using Excel spreadsheets. First off, the daily high-low ranges are

averaged over a 20 day rolling period. After normalizing these periods, the ranges with

two standard deviations and higher are filtered out. Upward momentum is assumed when

the closing quote is in the top 25% of the daily range, and vice versa for the downward

momentum. The last step is comparing the future price levels with the anticipated

directional bias of the daily outliers. Using Fibonacci numbers, different daily forward

periods are sampled to detect the highest probability “winners”.3

3 The use of Fibonacci numbers is based on the belief in their universal importance. Leonardo De Fibonacci de Pisa (b.1170-d.1240) described his number sequence findings in “Liber Abaci” (“Book of Abacus”) He used the sequence to predict a rabbit population reproduction. The Fibonacci ratios of 0.168 and 1.168 are found in the pyramids of Giza dimensions as well as in science and nature.

Page 18: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

14

Results and Discussion

For the period between January 2nd, 2004 and January 30th, 2015 there were 113

days with ranges bigger than two standard deviations. Twenty one of these days had

ranges bigger than three standard deviations. Of the total, 49 days closed in the upper

25% range and 50 days closed in the lower 25% range. When compared to several future

price changes, the following distribution occurred:

Table 1. Upward momentum probability

The second column of Table 1 and Table 2 displays the total number of times

price closed in the momentum direction for the particular time period. The third column

of Table 1 and Table 2 shows the “# of Occurrences” data as a fraction of the total

number of abnormal volatility occurrences (total of 49 for up momentum and 50 for

down momentum). An upward bias, or ratio higher than 50% (in green), was found in the

first, 89th, 144th, and 233rd day following the abnormal volatility. In turn, there was more

Time Period In Days

# of Occurrences

% of Total Occurrences

1 25 51.02% 2 24 48.98% 5 24 48.98% 21 22 44.90% 55 22 44.90% 89 27 55.10% 144 29 59.18% 233 27 55.10%

Page 19: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

15

than 50% probability of continuing downward momentum for the first, second, fifth, and

21st day after abnormal volatility (Table 2).

Table 2. Downward momentum probability

Time Period In Days

# of Occurrences

% of Total Occurrences

1 29 58% 2 30 60% 5 31 62% 21 31 62% 55 19 38% 89 20 40% 144 15 30% 233 14 28%

Higher than 50% ratio, or bias gives some evidence of different than random

behavior. Based on the results, there are some noticeable differences between upward and

downward momentum bias. The upward bias is short lived and it is segmented. The

downward bias is more tenacious and uninterrupted. It also starts right after the outlier

day and continues up to the 21st day. The observed differences suggest either the presence

of various underlying drivers, or different intensity of the causal forces for upward and

downward price movements.

In practice, the observed variances should be considered while choosing how long

to hold on a trade. For example, the findings suggest that there is a higher probability of

positive return if the long trade is closed either the next day, or sometime between the

Page 20: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

16

89th and the 233rd days. In contrast, the best holding period for the short trade would be

between the first and the 21st day.

Table 3 shows the cumulative returns from upward and downward momentum if a

trade was initiated in the direction of the momentum bias, and it was held for the given

daily periods.

Table 3. Cumulative returns based on momentum bias 4

Days 1 2 5 21 55 89 144 233 Up 3.47% 0.94% -5.20% -45.81% -36.08% 21.00% 28.03% -14.14% Down 3.84% 4.94% 14.41% 28.92% -7.98% -19.12% -68.95% -77.07%

It is important to notice the inverted nature of returns from long and short trades.

In fact, the highest return (in green) from short trades in day 21 coincides with the lowest

return (in red) from long trades for the same holding period. Contrariwise, the second

worst short trade return (in red) in day 144 coincides with the highest return (in green)

from long trades. It is also important to notice the periods with worst returns for both

directions. These statistical results can be further used for studying mean-reversal

behaviors.

Next, we attempted to find the best trade periods by combining momentum bias

with average trade returns. In order to find higher probability trading results, the positive

return needed to coincide with more than 50% momentum occurrences for the same time

period.

4 Total cumulative return was not considered because of the different characteristics for upward and downward momentum bias.

Page 21: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

17

Table 4. Upward momentum bias and average returns

Days 1 2 5 21 55 89 144 233 Upward Bias

51.02% 48.98% 48.98% 44.90% 44.90% 55.10% 59.18% 55.10%

Average Returns

0.07% 0.02% -0.11% -0.93% -0.74% 0.43% 0.57% -0.29%

According to Table 4, the best holding periods for the long trade (in green) were

one day, for 51.02% probability of average return of 0.07% per trade, 89 days, for

55.10% probability of average return of 0.43% per trade, and 144 days, for 59.18%

probability of average return of 0.57% per trade.

For the exception of day one, the results for the short trade showed different

pattern.

Table 5 Downward momentum bias and average returns

Days 1 2 5 21 55 89 144 233 Down ward Bias

58% 60% 62% 62% 38% 40% 30% 28%

Average Returns

0.08% 0.10% 0.29% 0.58% -0.16% -0.38% -1.38% -1.54%

The best holding periods (in green) for the short trade were one day, for a 58%

probability of average return of 0.08% per trade, two days, for 60% probability of

average return of 0.10% per trade, five days, for 62% probability of average return of

0.29% per trade, and 21 days, for 62% probability of average return of 0.58% per trade.

The findings suggest that, given the momentum bias, there is an uninterrupted

higher probability for positive returns if a short trade is held between one and 21 days.

Page 22: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

18

Considering the disadvantages of being a small, retail market player, and in order to

minimize the risk of market exposure, it is appropriate to suggest that the retail trader

should be on the market for the shortest amount of time. Thus, it is more suitable to trade

in the direction of downward momentum because in 62% of all cases the profitable trade

would last for no more than 21 days and could extract an average return of up to 0.58%.

In contrast, in order to achieve the maximum average return of 0.57% per trade, in

59.18% of all cases, the short trade would be held for up to 144 trading days. In reality,

this time period equates to more than seven calendar months.

Limitations and further research

Although the results are encouraging few considerations must be made. First of

all, the research should not be seen as a ready-to-trade system. The momentum strategy is

only the first step of situating the odds of trading. The statistical relations between

excessive volatility and price fluctuation can be used as initial directional bias. In order to

capitalize on the findings, more detailed actionable trade and management plan has to be

designed. The proposed methodology is only tested in one market and with one currency

pair. In order to find broader market application broader market instrument research is

necessary.

It is also recommended that more detailed exploration is needed to discover the

most profitable trade holding periods. Additionally, a separate study about the impact of

daily volatility with three standard deviations from the mean on momentum might give

deeper insight and additional practical applications. In order to draw a complete picture,

Page 23: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

19

it is also necessary to investigate the presence of mean-reversal market behaviors and

their trading applications.

Further research is needed to investigate the drivers characterizing the upward and

the downward momentum behavioral differences. Also, designing and perfecting a

trading system with an entry point, a profit target, and a stop loss is crucial ingredient of

the systematic approach to trading. On the choice of particular rules, Neely and Weller

(2013) find that 90% or more of the technical rules produce the same signal and they

switch its direction at approximately the same time.

Finally, this work does not address the exposure to systemic risk, nor any other

risk. According to Karbalaee (2012) volatility caused market risk remains the main factor

for ruin in retail Forex. Further research is needed to assess the risk reward ratio of

momentum based trading system.

Page 24: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

20

References:

Aronson, D. (2006). Evidence-Based Technical Analysis: Applying the Scientific Method and Statistical Inference to Trading Signals (1st ed.). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Autorité des marchés financiers, AMF (2014) Study of investment performance of

individuals trading in CFDs and forex in France. AMF. Retrieved from: http://www.amf-france.org/en_US/Actualites/Communiques-de-presse/AMF/annee_2014.html?docId=workspace%3A%2F%2FSpacesStore%2F96c52a14-3900-464f-8fff-7d4700ff37e3

Bank for International Settlements, BIS (2013). Triennial Central Bank Survey. Foreign

exchange turnover in April 2013: preliminary global results. BIS. Retrieved from: http://www.bis.org/publ/rpfx13fx.pdf

Burnside, C., Eichenbaum, M., & Rebelo, S. (2011). Carry trade and momentum in

currency markets. Annual Review of Financial Economics, 3(1), 511-535. Buffet, W. (1984). The superinvestors of Graham-and-Doddsville. Hermes, the Columbia

Business School Magazine. Retrieved from: http://www8.gsb.columbia.edu/rtfiles/cbs/hermes/Buffett1984.pdf

Chan, E.P. (2013). Algorithmic trading: winning strategies and their rationale (1st ed.).

Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Chan, L.K.C., and Lakonishok, J. (1995). The behavior of stock prices around

institutional trades. Journal of Finance, 50, 1147-1174. Chevalier, J. & Ellison G. (1999). Are some mutual fund managers better than others?

Cross-sectional patterns in behavior and performance. The Journal of Finance, Vol. 54, No. 3. (Jun., 1999), pp. 875-899.

Clements, K. W. & Fry, R. (2008). Commodity currencies and currency commodities. Resources Policy, 33(2), 55-73.

Daniel, K., Hirschleifer, D., & Subrahmanyam, A. (1998). A theory of overconfidence,

self-attribution, and security market under and over-reactions. Journal of Finance, 53(6), 839-1885.

Dasgupta, A., Prat, A., & Verardo, M. (2011). The price impact of institutional herding.

The Review of Financial Studies, 24(3), 892-925.

Page 25: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

21

De Bondt, W. F. M. & Thaler, R. (1985). Does the stock market overreact? The Journal

of Finance, 40(3), 793–805. DOI: 10.1111/j.1540-6261.1985.tb05004.x Engel, C. & West, K. D. (2004). Exchange rates and fundamentals (No. w10723).

National Bureau of Economic Research. Evans, M. D.D. & Lyons, R. K. (2005). Do currency markets absorb news quickly?

Journal of International Money and Finance, Elsevier, 24(2), 197-217. Fama, E. F. (1970). Efficient capital markets: a review of empirical work. Journal of

Finance, 25(2), 383–417. Fama, E. F. (1991). Efficient capital markets: II. The Journal of Finance, 46(5), 1575-

1617. Foster, F.D. & Viswanathan, S. (1994). Strategic trading with asymmetrically informed

traders and long-lived information. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 29(4), 499-518.

Fuertes, A.-M. Miffre, J., & Fernandez-Perez, A. (2013). Commodity strategies based on momentum, term structure and idiosyncratic volatility. Journal of Futures Markets, 35(3), 274-297.

Holthausen, R.W. & Verrecchia, R.E. (1990). The effect of informedness and consensus on price and volume behavior. The Accounting Review, 65(1), 191-208.

Hong, H. & Rady, S. (2002). Strategic trading and learning about liquidity. Journal of

Financial Markets, 5, 419–450. Karbalaee, A. (2012). Risk and Return in Retail Forex. Available at SSRN 2246076. Jostova, G., Nikolova, S., Philipov, A., & Stahel, C. W. (2013). Momentum in corporate

bond returns. The Review of Financial Studies, 26(7), 1649-1693. Kawakami, K. (2013). Conditional forecast selection from many forecasts: An

application to the Yen/Dollar exchange rate. Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, 28, 1–18.

Keim, D., & Madhavan, A. (1996). The upstairs market for large-block transactions:

analysis and measurement of price effects. Review of Financial Studies, 9, 1–36. Kuang, P., Schröder, M., & Wang, Q. (2014). Illusory profitability of technical analysis

in emerging foreign exchange markets. International Journal of Forecasting, 30(2), 192-205.

Page 26: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

22

LeBaron, B. (1999), Technical trading rule profitability and foreign exchange intervention. Journal of International Economics, 49(1), 125-143.

Levich, R. M., & Thomas, L.R. (1993). The significance of technical trading-rule profits

in the foreign exchange market: a bootstrap approach. Journal of International Money and Finance, 12(5), 451-474.

Meese, R. & Rogoff, K. (1983). Empirical exchange rate models of the seventies: do they fit out of sample? Journal of International Economics, 14(1–2), 3-24. Miffre, J. & Rallis, G. (2006). Momentum Strategies in Commodity Futures Markets.

Journal of Banking & Finance, 31(6), 1863-1886. Mullainathan, S., & Thaler, R. H. (2000). Behavioral economics (No. w7948). National

Bureau of Economic Research. Munira, S., Muradoglu, Y. G., & Hwang, S. (2008). Can common components eliminate

momentum returns? SSRN. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1130612. Neely, C. J., & Weller, P. A. (2011). Technical analysis in the foreign exchange

market. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. Working Paper 2011-001B. Retrieved from: http://research.stlouisfed.org/wp/2011/2011-001.pdf (2011-001).

Neely, C. J., & Weller, P. A. (2013). Lessons from the evolution of foreign exchange

trading strategies. Journal of Banking & Finance, 37(10), 3783–3798. Neely, C. J., Weller, P. A., & Dittmar, R. (1997). Is technical analysis in the foreign

exchange market profitable? A genetic programming approach. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 32, 405-426.

Okunev, J., & White, D. (2003). Do momentum-based strategies still work in foreign

currency markets? Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 38(2), 425-448. Pring, M. J. (1991). Technical analysis explained: the successful investor's guide to

spotting investment trends and turning points (2nd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill. Pring, M. J. (1997). Martin Pring on Market Momentum (1st ed.). New York: McGraw-

Hill. Pukthuanthong-Le, K., Levich, R.M., & Thomas III, L.R. (2007). Do foreign exchange

markets still trend? The Journal of Portfolio Management, 34(1), 114-118.

Page 27: FOREX STRATEGY FOR THE RETAIL TRADER By Boyan Boyanov A

23

Sias, R. W. (2004). Institutional herding. The Review of Financial Studies, 17(1), 165-206. doi: 10.1093/rfs/hhg035

Silber, W. L. (1994). Technical trading: when it works and when it doesn’t. The Journal

of Derivatives, 1(3), 39-44. Soros, G. (2010). Anatomy of a crisis. Retrieved from:

http://www.georgesoros.com/interviews-speeches/entry/anatomy_of_a_crisis_-_the_living_history_of_the_last_30_years_economic_theo/