FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY. SHALL NOTBEUSEDFOR ... · will notreinstate any ofthe RNC appeals pending inthe Second Circuit (lead case Bell, etal. v.City ofNew York, etal., 12-cv-4420Y,which

MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY.THIS IS NOT AN ADMISSION OF FAULT ANDSHALL NOT BE USED FOR ANY PURPOSE OTHER THAN THEPARTIES' CONFIDENTIAL SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS

Following numerous settlement conferences before Magistrate Judge James C. Frands, IVarising out of the Republican National Convention lawsuits (the "RNC cases") pending before theHonorable Richard Sullivan in the Southern District Court of New York, the following terms for asettlement are agreed to subject to the parties' agreement on the remaining outstanding terms (e.g.,class notice, timing of release of joint media statement, etc.) which the parties will hereafter attemptto resolve in good faith and in an effort to reach a final settlement agreement incorporating theagreed-upon terms. '

1. The following plaintiffs are parties to this settlement agreement:

Ca) The 430 plaintiffs'idèntifled in the list annexed hereto as Exhbit A [collectively, the"Grid Plaintiffs"];' '

(b) The 5 plaintiffs identified in the April 8, 2013 letter from Michael Spiegel to theCourt, specifically plaintiffs Hacer Dinler, Kate Freitag, Valerie Kaur-Brar, KathleenO'Reilly and Joshua Russell (collectively, the "5 Outlier Plaintiffs") - as toattorneys' fees, costs and expenses only;

(c) The four (4) non-accepting plaintiffs identified in the October 10,2013 letter to theCourt, specifically Andrew St. Laurent, Steve Ekberg, Robert Seigel, and HowardGale Ccollectlvely.the "4 Non-Accepting Plaintiffs") - as to attorneys' fees, costs and

~ ~~~ exRenses onlJ'. ' '_'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~_

(d) All named plaintiffs and all class members (in all certified classes) in the case ofMaeblamara v. City 'ofNew York, 04-cv-92l6 (the "Class Plaintiffs").

, l ,;

(b) $5,001,011 in total to all counsel for the Grid Plaintiffs, the 5 OutlierPlaintiffs, and the 4 Non-Accepting Plaintiffs, as set out in theattached Exhbit B for any and all attorneys' fees, costs and expenses

2. The City agrees to pay the following in consideration for the dismissal and release of all claims ofthe Grid Plaintiffs and the Class Plaintiffs, including claims for attorneys' fees, costs and expenses,and dismissal and release of any claims for fees, costs, and expenses to the date of this Memorandumof Understanding by the 5 Outlier Plaintiffs and the 4 Non-Accepting Plaintiffs:

(a) $6,3~':S,869 in total to the Grid Plaintiffs, as set forth in the attachedExhbit A.

(c) $6.6 millíon in total to the Class Plaintiffs and Class Counsel (the"Glas's Fund"). Defendant City is entitled to l 00% reversion on allunelalmed monies by the Class.

The Class Fund shall be paid as follows:

related to these RNC cases. The 5 Outlier Plaintiffs and the 4 Non-¡,

Accepting Plaintiffs do not release their claims for attorneys' fees,costs and expenses incurred, ifany, after the date ofthis Memorandumof Understanding.

(d)

i. $4 million to the Class Plaintiffs, subject to 100%reversion to the City for all unclaimed monies.

ii, $2.6 million to class counsel Beldock, Levine, andHoffman LLP ("BLH") and Moore & Goodman LLP("M&G") for all attorneys' fees, costs and expensesand costs of class administration.

iii. All attorneys' fees, costs and expenses related to thelitigation of the two separate lawsuits brought by BLHon behalfofBrian Portera and Jessica Rechtschafferare included in, and satisfied by, the payment ofattorneys' fees to BLH and M&G in the Class Fund.

3. Payments made by the defendant City to plaintiffs and counsel will be made in individualamounts. With regard to dlspersàl of attorneys' fees, the City agrees that some of the fees may bestructured, and any counsel reqùesting structured dispersal shall prepare and submit necessarypaperwork to the City regarding sU'èhdispersal.

4. The attached Final Joint Statement (Exhibit C) shall be released to the media at an agreed-upon date and time after endorsement of the first Stipulation of Settlement by the district courtjudge, and it shall not be released before such agreed-upon date and time. Furthermore, nocounsel for the parties to this agreement shall make any unilateral statements to the media relatedto the RNC litigation or the settlement thereof before such agreed-upon date and time.

5. The terms of the Stipulation of Settlement shall contain, inter alia, the settlement clausescontained in the form settlement agreement used by the Special Federal Litigation Division at thetime the plaintiffs' cases commenced (releasing the defendants from claims "which were or couldhave been alleged in this action"), including but not limited to, that there is no admission ofliability by either side and that the stipulation shall not be admissible in, nor is it related to, anyother litigation or settlement negotiations, Plaintiffs shall not be required to submit Affidavits re.Status of Liens. However, the proceeds of the settlement for all plaintiffs are subject to allapplicable liens.

6. .Notice to Class Members. Such notice wíl1 be subject to the City's approval and willinclude, inter alia, the necessity to file aclaim within a specified time period.

l; .<

'II. ,

, ,

7. This settlement does not include the following seven (7) plaintiffs in any respect: KaitlynTikkun, Yusuke Banno, Brian Conley, Noel Grosso, Matthew Smith, Annette Karlin, and JosephCarranza (collectively, "Non-Participating Plaintiffs").

8. Plaintiffs Michael Schiller, Ftancesca Fiorentini, Robert Curley, and Neal Curley (Schiller v.City of New York, 04-cv-7922)', as well as Ashley Waters and Anne Mauer (Din/er v. City of NewYork, 04-cv-7921), agree to accept the terms herein given the Defendants' representation that theywill not reinstate any of the RNC appeals pending in the Second Circuit (lead case Bell, et al. v. Cityof New York, et al., 12-cv-4420Y, which were withdrawn by defendants. At the time the settlementdocuments are filed for these plaintiffs, the Defendants agree to notify the Second Circuit in writingthat they will not be reinstating the appeals. Nothing herein shall limit any future appeal byDefendants in the remaining cases of the Outlier Plaintiffs, Non-Accepting Plaintiffs,or Non Participating Plaintiffs.

Jeffrey A. Rothman Rose Weber

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY.THIS IS NOT AN ADMISSION OF FAULT ANDSHALL NOT BE USED FOR ANYJ>URPOSE OTHER THANTHE PARTIES' CONFIDENTIAL SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS

Dated: New York, New York-Noveillbct'- ,2013

Ûe(:""-A~Zr... Ci)

AGREED TO AND ACCEPTED BY:

MICHAEL A. CARDOZOCorporation Counsel of theCity of New York

Attorney for Defendants100 Church StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 35 'S32

BELDOCK LEVINE & HOFFMAN LLPAttorneys for Plaintiffs99 Park AvenueNew York, New York 10016(212) 490-0400

I.l, BYl

MICHAEL L. SPIEGELAttorney for Plaintiffs11 Park Place, Suite 914New York, New York 10007(212) 587-8558

NEW YORK CIVIL LIBERTIES UNIONAttorneys for Plaintiffs125 Broad StreetNew York, New York 10004(212) 607-3300

BYL, _Michael Spiegel

JEFFREY A. ROTHMANA ttorney for Plaintiffs315 Broadway, Suite 200New York, NY 10007(212) 227-2980

ROSE M. WEBERAttorney for Plaintiffs30 Vesey Street, Suite 1801New York, NY 10007212-748-3355

By: __ -- ~~~,

By: _. _~'''~_'_'."",""",'/h"'"'''æ","~ ..."...~~"",,_.

Peter G. Farrell

FOR S~-:TTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY.THIS IS NOT AN ADMISSION OF FAULT ANDSHALL NOT UE USED FOR ANY PURPOSE OTHER THANTHE PARTIES' CONFIDENTIAL SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS

Dated: New York, New YorkNovember ,2013

AGIÜr,ED TO AND ACCEPTED BY:

BELDOCK LEVINE & HOFFMAN LLPAttorneys for Plaintiffs99 Park AvenueNewYork,NewYork 100]6(212) 490-0400 /


A ttorney for Defendants100 Church StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 356·3532

MICHAELL. SPIEGELAttorney for Piaintiffs11 Park Place, Suite 914New York, New York 10007(212) 587-8558

NEW YORK CIVILLIBER TIES UNIONAttorneys for Plaintiffs125 Broad StreetNew York, New York 10004(212) 607-3300

Christopher Dunn

By: ,_..._..._.w'" .",.~_.",w,.,~,··=

Michael Spiegel

JmTp'R:EY-A--;-ReTHM-AN----:'c'-----RGSE-M.-W-gßIîR~------Attorney for Plaintiffs Auorneyfor Plaintiffs315 Broadway, Suite 200 30 Vesey Street, Suite 1801New York, NY 10007 New York, NY 10007(212) 227-2980 212-748-3355

A. RothmanBy'.,~"",,,,,,,_. ~,.,'"."'''''''w'm'''.''...='''".w."w_,,.,,''"_",.,,'''_· ..__ ."

. Rose Weber

By:~~~~ ~~.Christopher Dunn

FOR SE'ITLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY.THIS IS NOT AN ADMISSION OF FAULT ANDSHALL NOT BE USED FOR ANY PURPOSE OTHER THANTHE PARTIES' CONFIDENTIAL SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS

Dated: New York, New YorkNovember t: \ , 20) 3

AGREED TO AND ACCEPTED BY:

BELDOCK LEVINE & HOFFMAN LLPAttomeysfor Plaintiffs99 Park AvenueNew York, New York 10016(212) 490-0400

By: -------Jonathan C. Moore

MICHAEL A. CARDOZOCorporation Counsel oftheCity of New York

Attorney for Defendants100 Church StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 356-3532

By: c ___'

Peter G. Farrell


By:.

NEW YORK CIVIL LIBERTIES UNIONAttomeysfor Plaintiffs125 Broad StreetNew York, New York 10004(212) 607-3300

JEFFREY A. ROTHMANAttorney for Plaintiffs315 Broadway, Suite 200New York, NY 10007(212) 227-2980

By:-::--:::::-~~-.- -....".Jeffrey A. Rothman

ROSE M. WEBERAttomeyfor Plaintiffs30 Vesey Street, Suite 1801New York, NY 10007212-748-3355

AGREED TO AND ACCEPTED BV:

¡I¡l

I

FOR SETTLEMJ~NT PURPOSES ONLY.THIS IS NOT AN ADMISSION OF FAULT ANDSHALL NOT BE USED FOR ANV PURPOSE OTHER TI-IANTHE PARTIES' CONFIDENTIAL SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS

Dated: New York, New YorkNovember , 2013

BELDOCK LEVINE & HOFFMAN LLPAttorneys for Plaintiffs99 Park AvenueNew York, New York 10016(212) 490~0400

By:~~~~~_~Jonathan C.Moore


Attorney for Defendants100 Church StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 3~6-3532

MICHAEL L. SPIEGELAttorney for Plaintlffs11 Park Place, Suite 914New York, New York 10007(212) 587-8558

BY:Y,.~_ ..~,m, , .. ",__ .. ·w.WW".'" '_~_. _._ ,

Michael Spiegoi

NEW YORK CIVIL LIBERTIES UNJONAttorneys for Plaint(tfs125 Broad StreetNew York, New York 10004(212) 607-3JOD

-JE Jll"R riY-Ä,-RO'1'T:IMAN ...---~-_-Attorney jol" Plaintiffs315 Broadway, Suite 200New YOI'k, NY 10007(212) 227-2980

By: _ ...,...""'"""",_",,. - __-- ...Jeffrey A. Rothman

__ ßüSE_M, WEBERAttorney jol" PlaintifJ's30 Vesey Street, Suite 1801N ew York, NY 10007212-748-3355

By::"""__,,.,.,._-,-e-----,rViichaelSpiegel -

Christopher Dunn

"

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY.THIS IS NOT AN ADMISSION OF FAULT ANDSHALL NOT BE USED FOR ANY PURPOSE OTHER THANTHE PARTIES' CONFIDENTIAL SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS


AGREED TO AND ACCEPTED BYi

BY::.~ -4

Jonathan C. Moore


Attomey for Defendants100 Church StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 356-3532

BELDOCK LEVeNE & HOFFMAN LLP -Attorneys for Ptatnuffs99Park AvenueNew York, New York 10016(212) 490.0400

By: .'.~·-·~Pe-te-r-G-.-Fm--e~ll-----


NEW YORK CIVIL LIBERTIES UNIONAttorneys for Plaintiffs125 Broad StreetNew York, New York 10004(212) 607-3300

JEFFREY A. ROTHMANAttorney for Plaintiffs315 Broadway, Suite 200New York, NY 10007(212) 227

Byr, .., .éffrey A. Rothman

ROSE M. WEBERAttomeyfor Plaintiffs225 Broadway, Suite 1607New York, New York 10007(212) 233-5633

By: """""",_~ __ ==-"...".-,-_.......'Rose Weber

FOR SETILEMENT PURPOSES ONLY.TIllS IS NOT AN ADMISSION OF FAULT ANDSHALL NOT BE USED FOR ANY PURPOSE O'fHER THANTHE PARTIES' CONFIDENTIAL SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS


AGREED TO AND ACCEPTED BY;

BELDOCK LEVINE & HOFFMAN LLPAttomeysfor Ptatnuffs99 Park AvenueNew York, New York 10016(212) 490-0400

Byz.,,__ ~~ __ """"""",~~ _ _..Jonathan C. Moore


By:~..~~~~~ ~Michael Spiegel

JEFEREYA .RÛ-THMAN-- ..Attorney for Plmnttjfs315 Broadway, Suite 200New Yo~ NY 10007(212) 227-2980

By:.~ __ ~~~~~~~~.Jeffrey A. Rothman .

MICHAEL A. CAROOZOCorporation Counsel of theCity of New York

A ttorney for Defendants100 Church StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 356-3532

By: ,.,.__--,.,.__- --_Peter G. Farren

NEW YORK CIVIL LIBERTIES UNJONAttomeys for Plaintiffs125 Broad StreetNew York, New York 10004(212) 607-3300

By:,-,--~ __.____Christopher Dunn

.... _~_RO_SE.MLWEBER . _Attorney for Plaintiffs30Vesey Street, Suite 1801New York, NY 10007212-748-3355

By:. ~U I'N\ '~ ..._Rose Weber ...

ALAN D. LEVINEAttorney/or Plaintiffs80-02 Kew Gardens Road, Suite 302

N~w 11415

ALAN H. LEVINEAttorney/or Plaintiffs99·Hudson Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 10013(212) 739-7506

By: ,~""",-""",-',' ,-,",,,,,,....~..;;;;.;.;...;.~Ajan H. Levine

SCOTT A. KORENBAUMAttorney/or Plaintiff111 Broadway. Suite 1305New York, New York lO006(212) 587·00 l &

BY:,,...,.;S_· c'-'o-tt"'K~""'Jo"'_re""'n-:"b"""au-m"_' -""' ... ~

STEPHAN PESKINAttorney for Plainttffs20 Vesey Street ,New York, New York 10007(212) 964-1390By:,~~ ,,,_.,~==~

SiéphanPeskhi .e :

JOHN W. UPTONAttorney for Plaintiffs217 Broadway Room 707New York" NY 10007(212) 233-9300

- 5 •

LAW OFFICES OF SUSAN'D. TAYLORAttorneysfor P¡aintiff~

Úth 1'1575 Madison Ave.l< oarNew York, New York 10022(212) 671-0122

JAMES 1. MEYERSONAttomeyfor Plaintiffs64 Fulton Street. Suite 502New York, New York 10038(212) 226:.33[0

By: __ ~~~~James Meyerson

MARTIN STOLARAttorney for Plaintiffs351 Broadway, 4th FloorNew York, NY 10013

By:.~~~=-~~~~~~Martin Stolar

KAREN WOHLFORTHAttorney for Plaintiff299 Broadway # J 700New York, NY 10007

By: ~m""M_"';'_' _m;,;;";,';.-;',.~",_,,,.,.~'''~· """=:0';;"''';;''',Karen Wohlfarth

ALAN D. LEVrNEAttorney for Plaintiffs80w02 Kew Gardens Road, Suite 302Kew Gardens) New York l ]415(718) 793~6363

By: ,_~,_ ..~..__Alan D. Levine

LAW OFFl.CES OF SUSAN D. TAYLORAttorneys tor Plaintiffs

, j' "I575 Madison Ave. ro' 1 FloorNew York, New York 10022(212) 6?I:¡OI22

By: ,~-"C""._""'''''.'7''';';'+;;'~~_",,~

Nonnan Best

ALAN H. LEV1NEAttorneyfor Platnttffs99 Hudson Street, 14th floo!'New York, New York 10013(212) 739~7506

By:

SCOTT A. KORENBAUMAttorney for Plaintiff'Il Park Place, Suite 914New York, New York 10007(212) 587~0018

JAMES J. MEYE.RSONAttorney/or PlaintiffsNAACP1065 Avenue of tile Americas, Suite # 300New York, New York 100'18(212) 344~7474, Ext. 129.

By: ~" ,~~ __ .James Meyerson

By: ~,'"-,_..",,__ ~.Scott Korenbaum

MARTIN STOLARAttorneyfor Plaintiffs351 Broadway, 4th FloorNew YOl'k, NY 10013

S1'EPHAN PESKINAttorneyfor Platnttffs20 Vesey StreetNew York, New York 10007 KAREN WOHLFaRTH(212) 964-1390 A ttorneyfor PlaintiffBy:~~,w,c_ .. ""'=.....r-r-~-~~~~----------c2.!){)-gF0adway-#-1-700---~

Stephan Peskin New York, NY lO007

JOHN W. UPTONAttorney/or Plaíntiffs217 Broadway Room 707New York.Nv 10007(212) 233-9300

John Upton

- 5 -

ALAN D. LEVINEAttorneyfor Plaintiffs80-02 Kew Gardens Road, Suite 302Kew Gardena.New York 11415(718) 793c6363

LAW OFFICES OF SUSAN D. TAYLORAttorneys for Plaintiff.9

'th575 Madison Ave.10 FloorNew York, New York 10022(212) 671-0122

By:_Alan D. Levine

By: _......,....".__,..~_~_Susan Taylor

ALAN H. LEVINE By:.-,---=-=~==c--Norinan Besf·

SCOTT A. KORENBAUMAttorney/or Plaintiff11 Park Place, Suite 914New York, New York 10007(212) 587·00]8

By:~ """""'"'~_Scott Korenbaum

JAMES I. MEYERSONAttorney for Plaintiff.'?NAACP1065 Avenue of the Americas, Suite # 300New York, New York 10018(212) 344-7474, Ext. 129.

By;~~~~.__~ _James Meyerson

STEPHAN PESKINAttorney for Plaintiffs20 Vesey StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 964-1390By:.=~===~~.

StephàriPeskiri

By: _..._~~ _'Martin Stolar

MARTIN STOLARAttomeyfor Plaintiffs351 Broadway, 4th FloorNew York, NY 10013

KAREN WOHLFORTHAttorney for Plaintiff299 Broadway # 1700New York, NY 10007

JOHN W. UPTONAttorney for Plaintiffs217 Broadway Room 707New York, NY ]0007(2] 2) 233-9300

By: Ä-~""=""~._,,~~=--~ ___John Upton

By:,.. ...Karen Wohlforth

ALAN H. LEVINEAttorney far Plaintiffs99 Hudson Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 100t3(212) 739-7506 ;

By: "'_"_~~......._~ _. Alan H. Levine

Norman Best

ALAN D. LEVINEAttorney for Plaintiffs-SO..02Kew Gardens Road, Suite 302Kew Gardens, New York 11415(718) 793~6363

Byt ~=_~_Alan D. Levine

LAW OFFICES OF SUSAN D. TAYLORAttorneys for Plaint@575 Madison Ave.l OthFloorNew York, New York 10022(212) 671-0122

By: __ ~~,..,,__-"--;.;.......;.;.~.Susan Taylor

SCOTT A. KORENBAUMAttorney for Plaintiff11 Park Place, Suite 914New York, New York 10007(212) 587~0018 J

By: .... --::- ...-Scott Korenbaum

JAMES I.MEYERSONAttorney for Plaintiffs,NAACP1065 Avenue of the Americas, Suite # 300New York, New York 10018

7474, Ext. 129.


STEPHAN PESKINAttorney for Plaintifft20 Vesey StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 964-1390

·-~iYt---:-- -.. __o

... Stephan Peskin

By:;;.;.;...---'"-_--.~~-_-_.Martin Stolar

KAREN WOHLFORTHAttorney for Plaintiff

-- ~-299Hr6áClway 1rrnJUNew York, NY 10007

JOHN W. uPTONAttorney far Plaint{fft217 Broadway Room 707

." New York, NY 10007 '(212) 233-9300

By \ ._,_______,_____,~~--JohnUpton

By:~~~-=~ __ ~=---. _Karen W()hlfarth

~5 -

JOHN W. UPTONAttorney for Plaintiffs217 Broadway Room 707New York, NY 10007(212) 233-9300

By:....;,_.....".."",--__ _,....,.., """"""",,Karen'Wohlforth

ALAN D. LEVINEAttorney for Plaintiffs80-02 Kew Gardens Road, Suite 302Kew Gardens, New York 114 t 5(718) 793-6363

By:-A~l-an-D-.~L-e~vi~ne--------

LAW OFFICES OF SUSAN D. TAYLORAttomeysfor Plaintiffs575 Madison Ave.IOih FloorNew York, New York 10022(212) 671-0122

By:--.. __ ""'-- ""'-- _SúsanTayïor

ALAN H. LEVINEAttomeyfor Plaintiffs99 Hudson Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 10013(212) 739-7506

By: _~--::-:::~""":""""_....__..,..,Alan H. Levine

By: ...., _Norman Best

SCOTT Af KORENBAUMAttorney for Plaintiff11 Park Place, Suite 914New York, New York 10007(212) 587-0018

JAMES 1. MEYERSONAttorney for PlaintiffoNAACP1065 Avenue of the Americas, Suite # 300New York, New York 10018(212) 344-7474, Ext. 129.

By:~, __ ~ ."...."".James Meyerson

MARTIN STOLARAttorney for Plaintiffo351 Broadway, 4th FloorNew York, NY ]0013

By:

STEPHAN PESKINAttorney for Plainttffs20 Vesey StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 964-1390a:y;"""",~~;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;~~ ............~, ' Stephan Peskin

By: __ ~-::--:- ___"Martin Stolar


Byf~, _"""""'_""""""'_""""""",__, " john Upton

ALAN D. LEVINEAttorney for Plaintiffs80~02 Kew Gardens Road, Suite 302Kew Gardens, New York 11415(718) 793~6363

ALAN H. LEVINEAttorney for Plaintiffs99 Hudson Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 10013(212) 739~7506

SCOTT A. KORENBAUMAttorneyfor Plaintiff11 Park Place, Suite 914New York, New York 10007(212) 587~0018

By: ~'w~,_,~~~~_~

Scott Korenbaum

STEPHAN PESKINAttorney for Plaintiffs20 Vesey StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 964~1390

Stephan Peskin

JOHN W. UPTONAttorney for Plaintiffs217 Broadway Room 707New York, NY l 0007(212) 233-9300

Upton

LAW OFFICES OF SUSAN D. TAYLORAttorneys for Plaintiffs

th575 Madison Ave.lO FloorNew York, New York 10022(212) 671~0122

Susan Taylor

By: _ • ,~ "%",,,_,_,,,,,,,,,,,,,,~.

Norman Best

JAMES I.MEYERSONAttorney for PlaintiffsNAACP1065 Avenue of the Americas, Suite # 300New York, New York 10018(212) 344-7474, Ext. 129.

James Meyerson

MARTIN STOLAR

KAREN WOHLFORTHAttorneyfor Plaintiff299 Broadway # 1700New York, NY 10007

By:~ .Karen Wohlfarth

-5 -

ALAN D. LEVINEAttorney for PlaintiffsBO-02 Kew Gardens Road, Suite 302Kew Gardens, New York 11415(718) 793-6363

By;·~,;~w~~~_,_"~_,__""""=",,,,,,_,.,,;,~,_,.

Alan D, Levine

ALAN Ho LEVINEAttorney for Plaintiffs99 Hudson Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 10013(212) 739-7506

BY':"'~"'~'''''''''"~''W",_""w&,,,,,m,,',,~,,,_,,m, __ ,,,m

Alan H. Levine

scorr A. KORENBAUMAt/omey for Plalnttff11 Park Place, Suite 914New York, New York 10007(212) 587~0018

BY~':'"~,;,w ,m~_",_,,, ", '

Scott Korenbaum

STEPHAN PESKINAttorneyfor Plaln/ij}'s20 Vesey .New(21By

York 10007

~:

n

JÓHN W. UPTONAttorney for Plaintiffs217 Broadway Room 707New YOI·k.NY 10007(212) 233-9300

By; ,'~~=_~ -'=~~ __=:

LAW OFFICES OF SUSAN D. TAYLORAttomeysfor Plaint(f[s

th575 Madison Ave.lO FloorNew York, New York 10022(212) 671-0122

By: '~"~_' ''''0'' __ ~'_'--~''

JAMES I.MEYERSONA uorney for PfaíntiffsNAACP1065 Avenue of the Americas. Suite # 300New York, New York 10018(212) 344-7474, Ext. 129.

MARTIN STOLARAttorney for Plainttffs351 Broadway, 4th FloorNew York, NY 10013

KAREN WOHLFaRTHAl/omey fOI' Plaintiff299 Broadway # 1700New York, NY 10007

" 5 -

By:~,.~~_. ..--_'"~Alan D. Levine

By: __ . ,. --Susan Taylor

,_,W -" v, ......... - .....

ALAN H. LEVINEAttorney for Plaintiffo99 Hudson Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 10013(212) 739~7506

BY:>w~ __ ~_"~_,:>W'!",,"m __ "Alan H. Levine

Norman

JAMES 1. MEYERSONAttorney for Plaintif¡:..64 Fulton Street, Suite 502New York, New York 10038(212) 226-3310

SCOTT A. KORENBAUMAttorney for Plaintiff11 1 Broadway, Suite l305New'York, New York 10006(212) 587-0018

By: .Scott Korenbaum

MARTIN STOLARAttorney for Plaintiffs351.Broadway, 4th FloorNew York, NY 10013

STEPHAN PESKINAttorney for Plainiiffs20 Vesey StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 964-1390By:. .. _.__ ".._~_~_

Stephan Peskin

By: _"_...-_~.. Martin Stolar

KAREN WOHLFORTHAttorney for Plaintiff299 Broadway :# 1700New York, ] 0,007

lOI-IN W. UPTONAttorney for Plaintiffs217 Broadway Room 707New York, NY 10007(212) 233-9300

ALAN D. LEVINEAttorney for Plaintiffs80-02 Kew Gardens Road, Suite 302Kew Gardens, New York 11415(718) 793-6363

By;' "Alan D. Levine

ALAN H. LEVINEAttorney for Plaintiffs99 Hudson Street, 14th FloorNew York, New York 10013(212) 739-7506

SCOTT A. KORENBAUMAttorney for Plaintiff111 Broadway, Suite 1305New York, New York 10006(212) 587-0018

Scott Korenbaum

STEPHAN PESKINAttorney for Plaintiffs20 Vesey StreetNew York, New York 10007(212) 964-1390B Y :~~,".mw,.~"~ •....w.~,,_.~~,~m~,w~~w'w""'_""'wm ...,"-

Stephan Peskin

LAW OFFICES OF SUSAN D. TAYLORAttorneys for Plaintiffs

th575 Madison Ave.lO FloorNew York, New York 10022(212) 671-0122

Byt .'~"'""",. ~~_~~~~~.. Norman Best

JAMES L MEYERSONAttorney for Plaintiffs64 Fulton Street, Suite 502New York, New York 10038(212) 226-3310

James Meyerson



Documents

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY. SHALL NOTBEUSEDFOR ... · will notreinstate any ofthe RNC appeals pending inthe Second Circuit (lead case Bell, etal. v.City ofNew York, etal., 12-cv-4420Y,which