Upload
buikhanh
View
216
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
List of cases filed on grant of MACP on Promotional Hierarchy
GRANT OF MACP ON PROMOTIONAL HIERARCHY:
LIST OF CASES FILED
The list of cases filed on the subject is given below for your reference.
S
L
O.A.No.,
CWP.No. SLP
Civil (CC) No
PartiesDate of
Order
Name of
courtRemarks
RAJPAL Vs UoI & Others
1
OA
No.1038/CH/20
10 (Advocate :
Mr. V.K.Verma)
Raj Pal s/o Tilak
Ram, CAT,
Chandigarh
31.5.2011CAT,
Chandigarh.
OA is allowed for
grant of MACP in
the hierarchy of
Promotional post.
2 CWP No.19387
of (O&M)
(Advocate :
D.K.Bhisnoi)
Union of India
represented by
DoP&T and
others Vs. Raj
19.10.201
1
High Court of
Punjab and
Haryana at
Chandigarh
Order dated 31-5-
2011 of Hon’ble
CAT, Chandigarh
is upheld. CWP
Pal and another.
filed by
Respondents
dismissed.
3
SLP No.cc-
7467 of 2013
against order
dated 19-10-
2011 of the
Hon’ble High
Court
Union of India
represented by
DoP&T and
others Vs. Raj
Pal and another.
15.4.2013Supreme
Court of India
SLP filed by the
Union of India is
dismissed
SANJAY KUMAR & Ors Vs UoI & Ors
4
OA
No.904/2012
(Mr.
M.K.Bhardwaj)
Sanjay Kumar,
UDC and 18
others Vs. UOI
nted byMinistry
of Defense and
others.
26.11.201
2
CAT,
Principal
Bench, New
Delhi.
OA is allowed for
grant of MACP in
next promotional
post i.e. Assistant
in PB-2+Grade
PayRs.4200.
5 W.P.(C)
4552/2013
UNION OF
INDIA Vs.
Delhi High Hearing Date
Court No. 5 Next
[PENDING]
(Mr. M.K.
Bhardwaj)
SANJAY
KUMAR & ORS.Court Date: 04/09/2014
M V Mahanan Nair Vs UoI & Ors
6 OA No.816/12
M.V.Mohanan
Nair, S/o
M.R.Vishwanath
an Nair,
Photocopier
CAT, Ernakulam
Bench & others
Vs Union of
India
29.1.2013
CAT,
PrincipalBenc
h Ernakulam
Bench
OA is allowed for
consideration of
MACP in the
hierarchy of
promotional post.
7
OP(CAT).
NO.2000 OF
2013 (Z)
UOI &
ORS. .Vs. M.V.
MOHANAN
NAIR
24.06.201
3
High court of
Kerala at
Ernakulam
In the result, this
original petition is
dismissed in
limine
8 Special Leave
Petition (Civil)
UOI &
ORS. .Vs. M.V.
Supreme PENDING
21803 OF 2014MOHANAN
NAIRCourt of India
9
OA No.1798 of
2014
Advocate : Shri
Yogesh
Sharma
Mahendra
Kumar Dubey,
S/o Sh. R.D.
Dubey, Working
as Programme
Executive, In
Doordarsan
Kendra, Delhi
VS UOI through
the Secretary,
Ministry of
lnformation &
Broadcastin
22.05.201
4Cat Delhi
OA is allowed for
consideration of
MACP in the
hierarchy of
promotional post
within a period of
one month
KISHAN SWARUP SHARMA Vs SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
AGRICULTURE
10OA
No.2548/2014
Kishan Swarup
Sharma,
31.07.201CAT, New OA is allowed For
consider the case
MA
No.2167/2014
(Advocate :
Shri
M.K.Bhardwaj
working as
PPO(E), Meerut
& 28 others V/S
Secretary,
Ministry of
Agriculture,
4 Delhi
of the applicants in
the light of the
aforesaid orders
PRADEEP KUMAR Vs SECRETARY MIN. OF INFORMATION &
BROADCASTING
11OA No.988 of
2014 MA
No.872 of 2014
(Advocate :
Shri M.K.
Bhardwaj
Pradeep Kumar.
AE (C) Rohini,
Delhi & 20
others VS
Secretary,
Ministry of
Information &
Broadcasting,
Shastri Bhawan.
New Delhi
22.03.201
4
CAT. New
Delhi
in view of the
above position. we
dispose of this OA
at the admission
stage itself with
the direction to the
respondents to
consider the
representations of
the applicants in
the light of the
judgment of
Punjab and
Haryana High
Court in CWP
No.19387/2011
(supra) as upheld
by the Apex Court
in SLP (CC)
No.7467/2013(sup
ra) and decide
their cases under
intimation to them.
The aforesaid
exercise shall be
completed within a
period of one
month from the
date of receipt of a
copy of this order.
There shall be no
order as to costs.
12O.A. No.
1834/2014
Advocate: Shri
Yogesh
Sharma.
Mohd Hamid
Hussain,
Working as
APRO
(Defence),
Sr.Grade Group
B Officer In the
office of: DPR,
Ministry of
Defence New
Delhi- & 34
others VS UOI
through the
Secretary,
Ministry of
Information and
Broadcasting,
23.05.201
4
Central
Administrativ
e Tribunal
PrincipalBenc
h New Delhi
In view of the
aforesaid
submission made
by the applicants
and the
documents
available on
record. we
dispose of this OA
at the admission
stage itself with a
direction to the
respondents to
consider the case
of the applicants in
terms of the
aforesaid orders
within a period of
two months from
the date of receipt
of a copy of this
order. if the
applicants are
similarly placed,
they shall also be
treated alike
OM PRAKASH Vs SECRETARY, NCERT
13OA 864/2014
Advocate: Shri
M.K. Bhardwaj)
Shri Om
Prakash
NCERT, New
Delhi VS
Secretary
(NCERT) New
Delhi
12.3.2014Central
Administrativ
e Tribunal
PrincipalBenc
h, New Delhi
In view of the
above position. we
dispose of this OA
at the admission
stage itself with
the direction to the
respondents to
consider the
representations of
the applicants in
the light of the
judgment of
Punjab and
Haryana High
Court in CWP
No.19387/2011
(supra) as upheld
by the Apex Court
in SLP (CC)
No.7467/2013(sup
ra) and decide
their cases under
intimation to them.
The aforesaid
exercise shall be
completed within a
period of one
month from the
date of receipt of a
cop of this order.
14W.P.(C) NCERT,New 14.07.201High court of CWP filed by
3608/2014
Delhi VS Shri
Om Prakash &
others
4Delhi at New
Delhi
Respondents
dismissed.
BABU RAM VS UoI
15O.A.
1281/CH/2012
ADVOCATE:
SHRI ROHIT
SETH
Sh. Babu Ram,
working as
Upper Division
Clerk, working in
the Central
Administrative
Tribunal,
opposite
Shivalik View
Hotel, Sector
17, Chandigarh
VS UOI
09.05.201
3
CAT
CHNDIGARH
BENCH
allow this OA in
terms of the view
obtained in terms
of the view
obtained in the
OA.
1038/CH/11and
the judgments
(Annexures A-11
to A-13). The
compliance of the
order must ideally
come about within
two months from
the date a copy of
this order is
presented in the
office of the
competent
authority.
16CWP No.
24279 of 2013
U.O.I. .Vs.
BABU RAM &
ORS.
07.11.201
3
HIGH
COURT OF
PUNJAB &
HARYANA
see order of even
date passed in
CWP No.24278 of
2013 (UOI and
another versus
Smt.Reeta Devi
and another
17
Special Leave
to Petition
(Civil)10435 OF
2014
U.O.I. .Vs.
BABU RAM &
ORS
Supreme
Court of IndiaPending
DHIRENDER SINGH & Ors Vs UoI
18Civil Writ
Petition
U,O.I. .Vs.
DHIRENDER
07.11.201High Court Of
Punjab &
For orders, see
order of even date
No.24253 of
2013 Date of
Decision:
SINGH & ORS. 3Haryana At
Chandigarh
passed in CWP
No.24278 of 2013
(Union of India
and another
versus Smt. Reeta
Devi and another).
19
Special Leave
to Petition(Civil)
…. 10436 OF
2014
U.O.I. .Vs.
DHIRENDER
SINGH & ORS.
Supreme
Court of IndiaPending
20O.A.
12/CH/2013 By
Advocate:
Mr.Madan
Mohan
Smt. Reeta
Devi, Senior
Library
Attendant, CAT
Bench.
Chandigarh.
Versus Union of
India
22.05.201
3
Cat
Chandigarh
Bench
After going
through the
judgment passed
in the case of Raj
Pal (supra), we
are in full
agreement with
the learned
counsel for the
parties.
Accordingly, the
present original
application is
allowed in same
term as of Raj Pal
(supra).
Consequently, we
quash the orders
at Annexures A-1
& A-2. The
respondents are
further directed to
grant the benefit of
2nd MACP in the
pay band of
Rs.9300-34800
with grade pay of
Rs.4600/- from
1.3.2009 (which is
the pay scale of
next post in the
hierarchy). The
respondents are
directed to comply
with the judgment
within a period of
three months from
the date of receipt
of a copy of this
order.
21CWP No.
24278 of 2013
Union of India
VS Smt. Reeta
Devi, & and
others
07.11.201
4
High Court Of
Punjab
&Haryana
CWP filed by
Respondents
dismissed
22
Special Leave
Petition(Civil)
22181 OF 2014
U.O.I. & ORS.
Vs. REETA
DEVI
Supreme
Court of Indiapending
NARAYAN KALITA Vs UoI
23O.A. No. Narayan Kalita Date of CAT OA is allowed. for
040/00052/201
4
CPWD
Guwahati VS
UOI
Represented by
Secretary GOI,
Ministry of
Urban and
Develoment
order
25.06.201
4 Date of
Delivery
of Order
7.8.2014
Guwahati
Bench
grant of MACP in
the hierarchy of
Promotional post.
Respondent is
directed to grant
scale of pay (PB-
3) of Rs. 15600-
39100 + Grade
pay 6600/-
24
OA( 1727/2014
) was filed by
CPWD
Engineers‘
Association in
regarding
MACP as per
promotional
hierarchy on
19.5.2014
CAT,
Principal
Bench, New
Delhi on
next date of its
hearing has been
fixed by CAT on
24/09/2014
25
case filed by
the Junior
Clerks of
Railway -OA
No. 1509 of
2013
CAT Kolkata
next date of its
hearing has been
fixed by CAT on
8th Dec. 2014