Fishing Game_Tragedy of Commons for WOD 2013

8/18/2019 Fishing Game_Tragedy of Commons for WOD 2013

1/5

Jalan Danau Tamblinganno. 78

Sanur, Bali 80228

Tel/Fax: +2 !" 28# !!8

$%mail: in&o'(oral)riangle(en)e

Traged* o& ommons

Fishing Exercise

S(enario -orld (ean Da* 20"!

ur seas (on)ain di1ersi)* o& s3 s4e(ies. 5uman 3as alread* made use )3e sea &or

)3ousand *ears. In some areas o& )3e 6orld e1en in Indonesia, )3e s3 (a)(3 sie is

ge))ing smaller and )3e uan)i)* o& )o)al (a)(3 is de(reasing o1er )3e )ime. Some

)radi)ional (ommuni)ies 3a1e made )3eir e9or) )o sus)ainabl* mae use )3eir s3eries bu)

*e) 3uman (rea)es ne6 s3ing gears or modies )3e gears )o (a)(3 more and more s3

&rom )3e sea. Fis3ing exer(ise game 6ill allo6 4ar)i(i4an)s )o learn abou) s3 4o4ula)ion,

s3ing e9or) and )raged* o& )3e (ommon.

T3e tragedy of the commons is )3e de4le)ion o& a s3ared resour(e b* indi1iduals,

a()ing inde4enden)l* and ra)ionall* a((ording )o ea(3 one;s sel&%in)eres), des4i)e )3eir

unders)anding )3a) de4le)ing )3e (ommon resour(e is (on)rar* )o )3eir long%)erm bes)

in)eres)s.

Objective:

To allo6 4ar)i(i4an)s ex4erien(ing )raged* o& )3e (ommon and managing s3eries s)o(

)3roug3 1arious a44roa(3 6ill ne(essaril* be im4or)an) &or sus)aining &ood se(uri)*.

Duration:

"< minu)e

Tools and Materials:

-


2/5


Sanur, Bali 80228

Tel/Fax: +2 !" 28# !!8


Color Code:

>$D ?rou4ers 3ig3 1alue in )3e mare), 1er*

im4or)an) i& lea1e mos) o& )3iss3es,

4ri(e &or e1er* s3 is @"00

A$- Trigger s3 middle 1alue in )3e mare),

im4or)an) i& lea1e some in )3e

o(ean

4ri(e &or e1er* s3 is @


3/5


Sanur, Bali 80228

Tel/Fax: +2 !" 28# !!8


. ead &a(ili)a)or 6ill be read* a) 3is/3er s)a)ion )o in)rodu(e )3e game and gi1e game

ins)ru()ions.

T3e game (onsis)s o& )3ree main sessions.

$a(3 4ar) 3as 2%! s3ing a()i1i)ies I 6ill be *our &a(ili)a)or &or )oda* and )3ere is ?ame Gas)er 63o 6ill lead *ou

)3roug3ou) )3e game. $a(3 grou4 6ill 3a1e ?ame Cssiss)an) )o 3el4 *ou (oun) *our

(a)(3 and re4or) *our (a)(3 )o ?ame Gas)er. lease sele() *our s3ing mas)er, )3e 4erson 63o are 1er* good in s3ingK

T3e 4ool 6ill be *our sea 6i)3 abundan(e o& s3

Aou 6ill be (om4e)ing 6i)3 o)3er grou4 )o (a)(3 )3e s3, )3e 6inner is )3e grou4 63o

(an (olle() )3e 3ig3es) number o& s3 6i)3 3ig3es) 1alues.o >ed s3 )3e mos) ex4ensi1e one, )3e 1alues is LSD "00 4er 4ie(e.

o Aello6 s3 is on )3e a1erage 1alue, i) is LSD


4/5


Sanur, Bali 80228

Tel/Fax: +2 !" 28# !!8


2 3e( )o )3e 4ool, 3o6 man* >$D s3 le&) in )3e seaN ?ame Gas)er 6ill add

"0 eggs )o )3e sea &or ea(3 >$D s3 le&) in )3e seai. I& )3ere is " >$D add < eggsii. I& )3ere are ! >$D add "0 eggsiii. I& )3ere are < >$D add "< eggs

! 3e( )o )3e 4ool, 3o6 man* A$- s3 le&) in )3e seaN ?ame Gas)er 6illadd < eggs &or ea(3 A$- s3 le&) in )3e sea

i. " A$- le&) add <ii. ! A$- le&) add <iii. < A$- le&) add "0

3e( )o )3e 4ool, 3o6 man* BC s3 le&) in )3e seaN ?ame Gas)er 6ill

add " eggs &or T- BC s3 le&) in )3e seai. 2 BC le&) add "ii. BC le&) add 2

Aou 6ill 3a1e one minu)e 4er s3ing e9or) and *ou 6ill 3a1e )6o s3ing e9or)s &or

)3is session. ?ame Gas)er 4lease lead )3e gameK

o For e1er* one minu)e s3ing e9or), (oun) )3e (a)(3 and re4or) )o ?ame

Gas)er

$E$$%O& T()EE

Ins)ru()ions:

Mo6 le) us (3e( our sea. 5o6 man* s3 are le&) in )3e seaN

To &eed all )3e s3ermen, ea(3 boa) 6ill need )o 3a1e a) leas) < s3 )o (a)(3.

lease no6 dis(uss &or ! minu)es 6i)3 *our grou4 and be)6een grou4 on 3o6 )o

(a)(3 )3e s3 )o be able )o &eed e1er*one in )3e boa).

! minu)es >ead* &or )3e nex) s3ing e9or)N

?ame Gas)er 4lease lead )3e gameK

o $a(3 s3ing e9or 6ill las) &or one minu)e.

o T3ere 6ill be )6o s3ing e9or) &or )3is session.

')*" +"

e)Os ga)3er and loo a) our s3ing e9or)s and (a)(3.

PPgo )3roug3 (a)(3 4er s3ing e9or) &or ea(3 grou4 and sessionPP

?ame Gas)er 4lease re4or) )3e (a)(3 resul) &rom ea(3 grou4. -3o is )3e 6innerN

-3a) 3a44en )o our sea and s3 in )3e rs) sessionN

-3a) 3a44en )o our sea in )3e se(ond sessionN

-3a) 3a44en )o our sea in )3e )3ird sessionN

T*,E (OME &OTE$

T3e sea is no) unlimi)ed so are )3e s3.

eo4le are )end )o s3 more )3an i) needs )o (a)(3 &or &ood and (ommer(ial

T3ere is al6a*s )enden(* )o (a)(3 more and more s3 &rom )3e sea, bu) i& i) is no)

regula)ed b*o Cllo6ing &or re4rodu()ion/re4lenis3men), )3e sie and abili)* )o re4rodu(e

6ill de(rease o1er )3e )ime, resul)ing on lo6 s3er* 4rodu()i1i)*.

o&


5/5


Sanur, Bali 80228

Tel/Fax: +2 !" 28# !!8


o >egula)ing s3eries resour(es need C-C>$M$SS, M-$D?$ CMD SI

63i(3 6ill allo6 managers or 4eo4le )o se) u4 rules Q regula)ion based on: imi)ing (a)(3 sie and gears

imi)ing )ime )o (a)(3 4en/seasonal (losure

San()ion and (om4lian(e

< o&

Documents

Fishing Game_Tragedy of Commons for WOD 2013