20
FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING REPORT FOR THE SPECTRA ENERGY TRANSMISSION PESH CREEK PIPELINE LOOP November 2009 5645 Prepared for: Spectra Energy Transmission Fort Nelson, British Columbia Prepared by: TERA Environmental Consultants Suite 1100, 815 - 8th Avenue S.W. Calgary, Alberta T2P 3P2 Ph: 403-265-2885

FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING REPORT

FOR THESPECTRA ENERGY TRANSMISSION

PESH CREEK PIPELINE LOOP

November 20095645

Prepared for:

Spectra Energy Transmission Fort Nelson, British Columbia

Prepared by:

TERA Environmental Consultants Suite 1100, 815 - 8th Avenue S.W. Calgary, Alberta T2P 3P2

Ph: 403-265-2885

Page 2: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page i

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page 1.0 INTRODUCTION AND PROJECT DESCRIPTION ......................................................................... 1 2.0 ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING ......................................................................................................... 3 3.0 MONITORING PROGRAMS............................................................................................................ 4

3.1 Construction Monitoring ...................................................................................................... 4 3.2 Operational Monitoring........................................................................................................ 4 3.3 Environmental Issues Monitoring........................................................................................ 4

4.0 PCEM METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................................. 5 4.1 Preliminary Work................................................................................................................. 5 4.2 Aerial Reconnaissance ....................................................................................................... 5

5.0 RESULTS/OBSERVATIONS ........................................................................................................... 6 5.1 Physical Environment.......................................................................................................... 7

5.1.1 Fill / Backfill Instability ............................................................................................ 7 5.2 Water Quality and Quantity................................................................................................. 9

5.2.1 Alterations of Natural Flow Patterns ...................................................................... 9 5.3 Vegetation ........................................................................................................................... 9

5.3.1 Loss or Alteration of Native Vegetation and Vegetation Important to Wildlife.................................................................................................................... 9

5.3.2 Weed Introduction and Spread .............................................................................. 9 6.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................................. 11

6.1 Literature Cited.................................................................................................................. 11

LIST OF APPENDICES Appendix A Post-Constuction Environmental Monitoring Environmental Alignment Sheets ............... 12 Appendix B Environmental Issues List from the Environmental As-Built Report for the

Duke Energy Field Services Canada Ltd. Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop .............................. 16

LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1 Regional Location of the Spectra Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop............................................. 2

LIST OF TABLES Table 1 Environmental Issues List ................................................................................................... 7 Table B-1 Environmental Issues List from the Environmental As-Built Report for the

Duke Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop....................................................................................... 17

LIST OF PLATES Plate 1 View of well-established grasses and shrubs along the right-of-way

(August 25, 2009)................................................................................................................ 6 Plate 2 View of trench line subsidence along the right-of-way from KP 3.3 to KP 3.8

(August 25, 2009)................................................................................................................ 8 Plate 3 View of trench line subsidence along the right-of-way from KP 3.3 to KP 3.8

(August 25, 2009)................................................................................................................ 8 Plate 4 View west of poor growth along right-of-way from KP 0.0 to KP 1.6

(August 25, 2009).............................................................................................................. 10 Plate 5 View of poor growth along right-of-way from KP 0.0 to KP 1.6 (August 25,

2009). ................................................................................................................................ 10

Page 3: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 1

1.0 INTRODUCTION AND PROJECT DESCRIPTION In February 2005, 806026 Alberta Ltd., as a General Partner of Duke Energy Field Services Canada L.P., a wholly owned subsidiary of Duke Energy Field Services Canada Ltd. (Duke), received the National Energy Board (NEB) Order XG-Z007-03-2005, pursuant to Section 58 of the NEB Act that granted approval for the construction of the Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop (the Project). In June 2009, Spectra Energy Transmission (Spectra), formerly Duke, was granted a variance to Condition 7 and Amending Order AO-5-XG-Z007-03-2005 was issued.

The Project consisted of the construction of approximately 16.5 km of 273.1 mm O.D. (NPS 4) sweet natural gas pipeline crossing the Alberta/British Columbia (BC) border approximately 100 km northwest of Rainbow Lake, Alberta and 160 km northeast of Fort Nelson, BC (Figure 1). The pipeline transports sweet natural gas from the existing Spectra Peggo gas processing facility in d-83-C/94-P-08 in northeastern BC, to the existing Nova Gas Transmission Ltd. (NGTL) Shekilie River North meter station at 10-04-119-12 W6M in northwestern Alberta.

The Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop was installed within a 20 m wide right-of-way, of which 5 m was shared with the existing Pesh Creek Pipeline right-of-way for 100% of its length. The existing Pesh Creek Pipeline was approved under NEB order GH-1-96. Additional temporary workspace was acquired where necessary for soils and slash handling at tie-ins as well as at crossing of watercourses and foreign pipelines. Aboveground facilities required for the operation of the pipelines included pipeline risers, valves, pig launcher/receiver and tie-in piping only, as sufficient capacity already existed at the NGTL meter station. Construction began on February 25, 2005 and was completed on April 12, 2005.

Spectra has committed to Post-Construction Environmental Monitoring (PCEM) of the right-of-way during the first and second complete growing seasons following construction. Spectra requested and received approval from the NEB to defer the commencement of PCEM until the 2009 growing season, due to delays in final clean-up of subsided areas along the pipeline right-of-way and ongoing delays in securing borrow pit soil for use in reclamation activities. This report presents the results of the first year PCEM program conducted on August 25, 2009.

Page 4: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

094P08 RGE. 12 W6M

TWP. 119

TWP. 118

ALBERTA

BRITISH COLUMBIA

SHEKIL

IE R IVER

5645

November 2009

FIGURE 1

SPECTRA ENERGY TRANSMISSIONPESH PIPELINE LOOP

0 0.5 1 1.5 2km

SCALE: 1:75,000

(All Locations Approximate)

SOURCES:

Date of Imagery: June, 2008SPOT 5 Satellite Imagery © 2008 CNES, Licensed by Iunctus Geomatics Corp, www.TerraEngine.com

Although there is no reason to believe that there are any errors associated with the data used to generate this product or in the product itself, users of these data are advised that errors in the data may be present.

LEGEND

BC Land System Grid

Alberta-British Columbia Border

Alberta Quarter Section Grid

Existing Peggo Gas Plant(d-83-c/94-p-8)

Existing NOVA GasTransmission Ltd.Shekilie North Meter Station

5645from3597_Fig1_PCRA.mxd

Constructed Pipeline

Page 5: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 3

2.0 ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING The Project route traverses forested Crown lands on level terrain within the Wetland Mixedwood Subregion of the Boreal Forest Natural Region in Alberta and the Boreal White Spruce Biogeoclimatic Zone in British Columbia (TERA Environmental Consultants [TERA] 2005a). Vegetation along the route ranges from black spruce muskeg with scattered tamarack on poorly-drained land at the west end of the route, to more upland, moderately to well-drained trembling aspen forest with scattered white and black spruce at the east end of the route.

The Alberta portion of the pipeline route lies within the Cameron Hills Uplands section of the Northern Alberta Uplands Physiographic Region. The BC portion of the pipeline route lies within the Great Plains Physiographic Region.

The forested lands traversed by the pipeline are deemed to have no agricultural capability. These lands consist of organic cryosolic soils located on a morainal till layer of clay and cobbley sand and gravel directly overlying bedrock within the southern fringe of the discontinuous permafrost zone.

The pipeline route traverses five watercourses, including the Shekilie River; all five are located in BC.

Page 6: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 4

3.0 MONITORING PROGRAMS A number of environmental monitoring procedures will be implemented by Spectra with the objectives of identifying potential or existing environmental issues and recommending, where warranted, remedial measures to address any outstanding environmental impacts. These procedures include: environmental monitoring during construction; frequent aerial line patrols; monitoring and pipeline right-of-way maintenance by the operations department following construction; and a third-party PCEM program.

3.1 Construction Monitoring

Environmental issues were monitored during construction to ensure that environmental protection measures were implemented and that the protection measures were effective in minimizing environmental impacts. An Environmental Inspector was assigned to the construction program to monitor all phases of construction, with particular emphasis on issues and activities which were considered to have the greatest potential for environmental impact.

3.2 Operational Monitoring

Operational monitoring includes regular aerial line patrols of the entire pipeline system. Any problem sites are noted during the patrols and corrective action is taken where necessary.

3.3 Environmental Issues Monitoring

A first year environmental issues monitoring program was undertaken during the summer of 2009 to examine any unresolved environmental issues and to identify any new issues related to reclamation. The purpose of the PCEM is to:

• evaluate the recovery of areas disturbed during pipeline construction;

• assess the status of outstanding environmental issues identified in the Environmental and Socio-Economic Assessment (ESA) (TERA 2005a) and the Environmental As-Built Report (TERA 2005b);

• identify any new environmental issues that may have arisen;

• visually inspect the right-of-way via late summer aerial reconnaissance for known, as well as previously unidentified environmental issues;

• recommend remedial measures to be implemented to address outstanding environmental issues in a timely manner; and

• update the Environmental Issues List (EIL) upon completion of the late summer aerial reconnaissance whereby the final EIL from the first year PCEM Report will provide the starting point for the second year PCEM program.

An aerial reconnaissance was conducted by TERA personnel in late August 2009.

Page 7: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 5

4.0 PCEM METHODOLOGY The methodology for monitoring the status of environmental issues is based on the philosophy, and with the fundamental principle, that the success of land reclamation is measured against the representative (i.e., adjacent) site conditions with due consideration for construction norms at the time of the assessment. Where no known limitations to normal management and ecosystem function for that land type are evident during the PCEM, mitigative measures will be determined to be successful and the environmental issue resolved.

4.1 Preliminary Work

Preliminary work included a review of potential environmental issues as determined from the ESA, applicable construction documents (e.g., Environmental As-Built Report) and any other documentation of issues that were encountered during construction.

4.2 Aerial Reconnaissance

The aerial reconnaissance was scheduled to be conducted in late summer, when vegetation is mature enough for accurate identification and evaluation. A Reclamation Specialist was assigned to conduct the aerial reconnaissance of the entire pipeline construction right-of-way by helicopter to identify any additional locations warranting further monitoring (Appendix A). Parameters assessed during the aerial reconnaissance include slope movement, trench settlement, deterioration of erosion control devices, revegetation failures, improper waste or debris disposal and weed infestations.

Page 8: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 6

5.0 RESULTS/OBSERVATIONS An EIL was compiled from the Environmental As-Built Report for the Project and was reviewed prior to the late summer PCEM (Appendix B). This list provides a summary of potential environmental issues along the right-of-way prior to pipeline construction, clean-up and reclamation. Following the fieldwork, the EIL was updated (Table 1) to provide the current status of environmental issues and the mitigative measures planned to address unresolved issues.

During the aerial reconnaissance, it was observed that the pipeline right-of-way is recovering well, and that shrubs and grasses are successfully establishing along much of the right-of-way. A typical view of the right-of-way is provided in Plate 1. The following is a description of all unresolved environmental issues and the proposed mitigative measures to resolve these issues.

Plate 1 View of well-established grasses and shrubs along the right-of-way (August 25, 2009).

Page 9: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 7

TABLE 1

ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES LIST

Environmental Issues Location Mitigative Measures and Observations in 2009 Status Recommendations 1. PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT (a) fill/backfill instability Entire route • During the 2009 PCEM, subsidence was observed

from KP 3.3 to KP 3.8. Unresolved Repair and continue

monitoring for trench subsidence and for excessive crown loss causing altered drainage patterns and recontour where necessary.

2. WATER QUALITY AND QUANTITY (a) Alterations of natural

flow patterns Entire route • During the 2009 PCEM, subsidence was observed

from KP 3.3 to KP 3.8. Unresolved Repair and continue

monitoring for trench subsidence and for excessive crown loss causing altered drainage patterns and recontour where necessary.

3. WETLANDS (a) loss of wetland habitat Entire route • Wetlands are naturally regenerating following

construction. • During the 2009 PCEM, low-lying areas along the

right-of-way were observed to be consistent with preconstruction drainage contours.

Resolved None.

4. VEGETATION (a) Loss or alteration of

native vegetation and vegetation important to wildlife

Entire route • Areas of poor growth were noted from KP 0.0 to KP 1.6 along the pipeline route during the 2009 PCEM; however, vegetation establishment generally appears successful along the right-of-way.

Unresolved Broadcast seed with an approved native seed mix from KP 0.0 to KP 1.6. Continue monitoring the establishment of native vegetation. Control trees and shrubs, if necessary, to facilitate pipeline surveillance, by mechanical rather than chemical means.

(b) Weed introduction and spread

Entire route • No weeds of concern were identified during the 2009 PCEM program.

Unresolved Continue monitoring for weed growth and introduction.

5. WILDLIFE AND WILDLIFE HABITAT (a) Loss or alteration of

potential wildlife habitat

Entire route − See Vegetation element. Unresolved See Vegetation element.

5.1 Physical Environment

5.1.1 Fill / Backfill Instability

During the 2009 PCEM, subsidence was observed from KP 3.3 to KP 3.8 along the pipeline right-of-way (Plates 2 and 3). The remainder of the pipeline route appeared stable and no trench line settlement was observed. Repair of subsided areas along the right-of-way and continued monitoring of trench settlement and subsidence in 2010 along the entire right-of-way is recommended.

Page 10: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 8

Plate 2 View of trench line subsidence along the right-of-way from KP 3.3 to KP 3.8 (August 25, 2009).

Plate 3 View of trench line subsidence along the right-of-way from KP 3.3 to KP 3.8 (August 25, 2009).

Page 11: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 9

5.2 Water Quality and Quantity

5.2.1 Alterations of Natural Flow Patterns

Trench line subsidence occurring along the pipeline right-of-way potentially interferes with natural drainage patterns and may also lead to impeded cross drainage across right-of-way. Monitoring of the right-of-way in 2010 is recommended to ensure that any regraded trench line along the route has settled but not subsided.

5.3 Vegetation

5.3.1 Loss or Alteration of Native Vegetation and Vegetation Important to Wildlife

Vegetation along the length of the pipeline right-of-way in Alberta and BC is recovering naturally, and low-growing shrubs and grasses were observed along most of the right-of-way during the aerial reconnaissance. Areas of poor growth were noted from KP 0.0 to KP 1.6 (Plates 4 and 5). Broadcast seeding along areas of poor growth from KP 0.0 to KP 1.6 with an approved native seed mix from KP 0.0 to KP 1.6 may be warranted. It is also recommended that the right-of-way be monitored in 2010 to ensure that the natural revegetation is providing adequate ground cover along the right-of-way and to monitor the establishment of grasses and ground cover along any areas of recontoured trench line.

5.3.2 Weed Introduction and Spread

During the 2009 PCEM, no weeds of concern were identified. Continued monitoring of the right-of-way for weed problem areas is recommended. The use of chemical control is not recommended for any trace to moderate densities of weeds occurring along the pipeline route. Successful revegetation occurring along the right-of-way appears to be currently outcompeting and preventing weed infestations.

Page 12: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 10

Plate 4 View west of poor growth along right-of-way from KP 0.0 to KP 1.6 (August 25, 2009).

Plate 5 View of poor growth along right-of-way from KP 0.0 to KP 1.6 (August 25, 2009).

Page 13: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 11

6.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS The results of the 2009 PCEM indicate that a high standard of environmental protection was achieved throughout the construction program. Environmental issues were immediately resolved when possible. The few outstanding issues identified in the EIL will continue to be monitored and the necessary actions taken until all issues are resolved.

The entire length of the right-of-way will be inspected during the 2010 growing season and will primarily assess the outstanding issues of trench and crown settlement and revegetation success along the right-of-way.

6.1 Literature Cited

TERA Environmental Consultants. 2005a. Environmental and Socio-Economic Assessment for the Proposed Duke Energy Field Services Canada Ltd. Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop.

TERA Environmental Consultants. 2005b. Environmental As-Built Report for the Duke Energy Field Services Canada Ltd. Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop.

Page 14: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 12

APPENDIX A

POST-CONSTUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING ENVIRONMENTAL ALIGNMENT SHEETS

Page 15: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(!(

!( !( !( !(!(

!(

!(

(#*

SH

EK

ILIE

RI V

ER

94P/08

EXISTING PEGGOGAS PLANT

(d-83-c/94-p-8)

MA

TC

HL

INE

SH

EE

T 2

KP 6.0KP 5.5KP 5.0KP 4.5

KP 4.0

KP 3.5KP 3.0KP 2.5KP 2.0

KP 1.5

KP 1.0

KP 0.5

KP 0.0

3B3A2B2A

1B

1A

LAND USE

DISPOSITION

RIGHT-OF-WAY WIDTH

EN

VIR

ON

ME

NT

AL

SP

EC

IFIC

AT

I ON

S

POST CONSTRUCTIONRECLAMATION

ENVIRONMENTALCONCERN

REVEGETATION

TRAPLINE: TR0755T015

15m

ORGANICTILL ORGANICALLUVIAL

SHEKILIE RIVER

TALL BLACKSPRUCE

BLACKSPRUCE

BLACKSPRUCE/

TAMARACK

BLACKSPRUCE

TAMARACK BLACKSPRUCE

TALL BLACK SPRUCEAND TAMARACK

BLACK SPRUCE ANDSCATTERED ASPEN BLACK SPRUCE BLACK SPRUCE

& TAMARACKRIPARIAN TALLWHITE SPRUCE

BLACK SPRUCE

FORESTED

SEED MIX A

GREAT PLAINS PHYSIOGRAPHIC REGION

ORGANIC CRYOSOLSORGANIC

CRYOSOLSALLUVIAL SILT,

SAND AND GRAVEL

FRINGE OF BOREAL CARIBOU HABITATBURB, BS, FDC, KC,

LSU, NRPK, TP, WSU FRINGE OF BOREALCARIBOU HABITAT

ASSESS THE NEED FOR STUB BERMS TO REDUCE THE EROSIONPOTENTIAL OF ORGANIC BACKFILL (10.0, DWG. NO. 3).

EXTENSIVE LENGTH OF ORGANIC TERRAIN. SHEKILIE RIVER

TLUS #1

ENVIRONMENTAL NOTES

1:20,000

REF: REV.

3

ENVIRONMENTAL ALIGNMENT SHEET1 OF 3

SCALE:

DATE:November 2009

APPR.:REFERENCE

REVISIONSNO. DATE DESCRIPTION BY CHKD APPR

5645

PHOTO SOURCE: Copyright Valtus Imagery Services Ltd., 2004. All rights reserved.

DATE OF PHOTOGRAPHY: 2002 0 100 200 300 400 500 m

0 Dec. 2004 NEB Application TGG BS1. Site specific environmental concerns and the corresponding environmental protection measures are positioned above the respective location on the photomosaic.

2. Bracketed numbers refer to corresponding sections in the EPRP text where more complete instructions are provided. Additional environmental protection measures are outlined in Sections 2.0 to 14.0 in the EPRP text.3. Avoid constructing during excessively wet or thawed conditions (3.0). Rip compacted subsoils to a depth of 30 cm or the depth of compaction, whichever is deeper. If soils are thawed, postpone ripping of subsoils until soils refreeze (10.0).4. In low-lying wet areas, walk frost in on work side (6.0). Retain nonmerchantable timber, where warranted, for use as corduroy (5.0).

Remove corduroy during clean-up.

5. Seed disturbed forested portions of the right-of-way with the appropriate seed mix.12. CLI (Canada Land Inventory) classes are described in Section 5.0 of the ESA.

EN

VIR

ON

ME

NT

AL

SE

TT

ING

SURFICIAL GEOLOGY

SOILS

SURFACE AND GROUND WATER

VEGETATION

FISH AND WILDLIFE

HERITAGE RESOURCES

PH

OT

OM

OS

AIC

SC

ALE

1:2

0,0 0

0

/

DA

TE

OF

PH

OT

OG

RA

PH

Y:

200

2

PHYSIOGRAPHY

SOCIO-ECONOMIC FACTORS

Land Use:

CL = cleared land

Fish Species

BS = Brook Stickleback

BURB = Burbot

FDC = Finescale Dace

LKC = Lake Chub

LSU = Longnose Sucker

NRPK = Northern Pike

TP = Trout Perch

WSU = White Sucker

REFERENCE DRAWINGS

DWG. No.1 Plan for Timber Salvage Deck Site

Strippings Salvage(Frozen Conditions)

DWG. No.2

DWG. No.3 Stub Berms

DWG. No.5

DWG. No.6

Watercourse Crossing -Bore or Punch

Watercourse Crossing - OpenCut of Minor Muskeg Drainages

DWG. No.4 Watercourse Crossing -Horizontal Directionally Drill

Clean-up Points

Constructed Pipeline

Existing Pipeline

Peggo Gas Plant

#* Traditional Land Use Site

NOVA GasTransmission Ltd.Shekilie NorthMeter Station

! Clean-up Points

Kilometre PostKP 0.0

SEED MIX A

MULCH SOIL AGGREGATESAND SPREAD ACROSS ROW

MULCH SOIL AGGREGATESAND SPREAD ACROSS ROW

MULCH SOIL AGGREGATESAND SPREAD ACROSS ROW

SEED MIX A

1 Sept. 2007 Post Construction Reclamation Assessment CI OD

SPECTRA ENERGY TRANSMISSION

PESH PIPELINE LOOP2 Nov. 2007 PCRA - Revision to map CI OD

3 Nov. 2009 Year 1 PCRA TGG AI

Plate 2

Plate 4

Plate 5

Plate 3

Page 16: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

(

((#*

#*

SH

EK

ILIE

RIV

ER

94P/08

MA

TC

HL

INE

SH

EE

T 1

MA

TC

HL

INE

SH

EE

T 3

KP 9.5

KP 9.0

KP 8.5

KP 8.0

KP 7.5

KP 7.0

KP 11.0

KP 10.5

KP 10.0

KP 6.5

98

5

4

7B7A

6B

6A

3B3A

LAND USE

DISPOSITION

RIGHT-OF-WAY WIDTH

ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIFIC

ATI O

NS

POST CONSTRUCTIONRECLAMATION

ENVIRONMENTALCONCERN

REVEGETATION

PHOTOMOSAIC

SCALE

1:20,0 0

0 / DATE O

F PHOTOGRAPHY: 200

2

TRAPLINE: TR0755T015

15m

ORGANIC

ASPEN/BLACK SPRUCE BLACK SPRUCE

TALL BLACKSPRUCE PATCHES

ORGANIC/TILL

MINOR MUSKEG DRAINAGE (2)

BLACK SPRUCE WITH ASPEN PATCHES ASPENASPEN AND

BLACK SPRUCEDENSEASPEN

ALLUVIAL/TILL ALLUVIAL ALLUVIAL/MUSKEG ORGANIC TILL TILLORGANIC

FORESTED

GREAT PLAINS PHYSIOGRAPHIC REGION

ORGANIC CRYOSOLS

FRINGE OF BOREAL CARIBOU HABITAT

ASSESS THE NEED FOR STUB BERMS INSTALL IF WARRANTED

EXTENSIVE LENGTH OF ORGANIC TERRAINMUSKEG DRAINAGE

TLUS #2

EN

VIR

ON

ME

NT

AL

SE

TT

ING

SURFICIAL GEOLOGY

SOILS

SURFACE AND GROUND WATER

VEGETATION

FISH AND WILDLIFE

HERITAGE RESOURCES

PHYSIOGRAPHY

SOCIO-ECONOMIC FACTORS

Land Use:

CL = cleared land

Fish Species

BS = Brook Stickleback

BURB = Burbot

FDC = Finescale Dace

LKC = Lake Chub

LSU = Longnose Sucker

NRPK = Northern Pike

TP = Trout Perch

WSU = White Sucker

REFERENCE DRAWINGS

DWG. No.1 Plan for Timber Salvage Deck Site

Strippings Salvage(Frozen Conditions)

DWG. No.2

DWG. No.3 Stub Berms

DWG. No.5

DWG. No.6

Watercourse Crossing -Bore or Punch

Watercourse Crossing - OpenCut of Minor Muskeg Drainages

DWG. No.4 Watercourse Crossing -Horizontal Directionally Drill

ENVIRONMENTAL NOTES

1:20,000

REF: REV.3

ENVIRONMENTAL ALIGNMENT SHEET2 OF 3

SCALE:

DATE:November 2009

APPR.:REFERENCE

REVISIONSNO. DATE DESCRIPTION BY CHKD APPR

5645

PHOTO SOURCE: Copyright Valtus Imagery Services Ltd., 2004. All rights reserved.

DATE OF PHOTOGRAPHY: 2002 0 100 200 300 400 500 m

0 Dec. 2004 NEB Application TGG BS

Clean-up Points

Constructed Pipeline

Existing Pipeline

Peggo Gas Plant

#* Traditional Land Use Site

NOVA GasTransmission Ltd.Shekilie NorthMeter Station

! Clean-up Points

Kilometre PostKP 0.0

ASSESS THE NEED FOR STUB BERMS.

INSTALL IF WARRANTED

1 Sept. 2007 Post Construction Reclamation Assessment CI OD

SPECTRA ENERGY TRANSMISSION

PESH PIPELINE LOOP

1. Site specific environmental concerns and the corresponding environmental protection measures are positioned above the respective location on the photomosaic.

2. Bracketed numbers refer to corresponding sections in the EPRP text where more complete instructions are provided. Additional environmental protection measures are outlined in Sections 2.0 to 14.0 in the EPRP text.3. Avoid constructing during excessively wet or thawed conditions (3.0). Rip compacted subsoils to a depth of 30 cm or the depth of compaction, whichever is deeper. If soils are thawed, postpone ripping of subsoils until soils refreeze (10.0).4. In low-lying wet areas, walk frost in on work side (6.0). Retain nonmerchantable timber, where warranted, for use as corduroy (5.0).

Remove corduroy during clean-up.

5. Seed disturbed forested portions of the right-of-way with the appropriate seed mix.12. CLI (Canada Land Inventory) classes are described in Section 5.0 of the ESA.

2 Nov. 2007 PCRA - Revision to map CI OD

3 Nov. 2009 Year 1 PCRA TGG AI

Plate 1

Page 17: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

(

(

#*#*

AL

BE

RT

A

BR

ITIS

H C

OL

UM

BIA

94P/08MA

TC

HL

INE

SH

EE

T 2

KP 11.5

EXISTINGNOVA GAS

TRANSMISSION LTD.SHEKILIE NORTHMETER STATION

9

43

119-12-6

119-12-6119-12-6KP 16.5

KP 16.0

KP 15.5

KP 15.0

KP 14.5

KP 14.0

KP 13.5

KP 13.0

KP 12.5KP 12.0

98

10

7A

7B

LAND USE

DISPOSITION

RIGHT-OF-WAY WIDTH

ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIFICATI ONS

POST CONSTRUCTIONRECLAMATION

ENVIRONMENTALCONCERN

REVEGETATION

PHOTOMOSAIC SCALE 1:20,0 00 / DATE OF PHOTOGRAPHY: 2002

TRAPLINE: TR0755T015

15m

TRAPPING AGREEMENT 99

TILL TILLORGANICORGANIC ORGANIC TILL ORGANIC TILL TILLORGANIC ORGANIC TILL ORGANIC TILL TILLORGANIC ORGANIC TILL

MINOR MUSKEG DRAINAGE

ASPENBLACK

SPRUCE ASPENBLACK

SPRUCE ASPENBLACK

SPRUCE ASPEN BLACK SPRUCE ASPEN BLACK SPRUCE ASPEN

BOREAL CARIBOU RANGECLI UNGULATE CLASS 6 MOOSE

CLI WATERFOWL CLASS 7

FORESTED

GREAT PLAINS PHYSIOGRAPHIC REGION

ORGANIC CRYOSOLS

FRINGE OF BOREAL CARIBOU HABITAT

NORTHERN ALBERTA UPLANDSPHYSIOGRAPHIC REGION

MINOR MUSKEG DRAINAGE

MUSKEG DRAINAGE

ADHERE TO CARIBOUPROTECTION PLAN

BOREALCARIBOURANGE

MUSKEGDRAINAGE

TLUS #3 AND #4

ENVIRONMENTAL NOTES

1:20,000

REF: REV.3

ENVIRONMENTAL ALIGNMENT SHEET3 OF 3

SCALE:

DATE:November 2009

APPR.:REFERENCE

REVISIONSNO. DATE DESCRIPTION BY CHKD APPR

5645

PHOTO SOURCE: Copyright Valtus Imagery Services Ltd., 2004. All rights reserved.

DATE OF PHOTOGRAPHY: 2002

SPECTRA ENERGY TRANSMISSION

PESH PIPELINE LOOP

0 100 200 300 400 500 m

0 Dec. 2004 NEB Application TGG BS

EN

VIR

ON

ME

NT

AL

SE

TT

ING

SURFICIAL GEOLOGY

SOILS

SURFACE AND GROUND WATER

VEGETATION

FISH AND WILDLIFE

HERITAGE RESOURCES

PHYSIOGRAPHY

SOCIO-ECONOMIC FACTORS

Land Use:

CL = cleared land

Fish Species

BS = Brook Stickleback

BURB = Burbot

FDC = Finescale Dace

LKC = Lake Chub

LSU = Longnose Sucker

NRPK = Northern Pike

TP = Trout Perch

WSU = White Sucker

REFERENCE DRAWINGS

DWG. No.1 Plan for Timber Salvage Deck Site

Strippings Salvage(Frozen Conditions)

DWG. No.2

DWG. No.3 Stub Berms

DWG. No.5

DWG. No.6

Watercourse Crossing -Bore or Punch

Watercourse Crossing - OpenCut of Minor Muskeg Drainages

DWG. No.4 Watercourse Crossing -Horizontal Directionally Drill

Clean-up Points

Constructed Pipeline

Existing Pipeline

Peggo Gas Plant

#* Traditional Land Use Site

NOVA GasTransmission Ltd.Shekilie NorthMeter Station

! Clean-up Points

Kilometre PostKP 0.0

ASSESS THE NEEDFOR STUB BERMS.

INSTALL IF WARRANTED.

1 Sept. 2007 Post Construction Reclamation Assessment CI OD

ASSESS THE NEEDFOR STUB BERMS.

INSTALL IF WARRANTED.

1. Site specific environmental concerns and the corresponding environmental protection measures are positioned above the respective location on the photomosaic.

2. Bracketed numbers refer to corresponding sections in the EPRP text where more complete instructions are provided. Additional environmental protection measures are outlined in Sections 2.0 to 14.0 in the EPRP text.3. Avoid constructing during excessively wet or thawed conditions (3.0). Rip compacted subsoils to a depth of 30 cm or the depth of compaction, whichever is deeper. If soils are thawed, postpone ripping of subsoils until soils refreeze (10.0).4. In low-lying wet areas, walk frost in on work side (6.0). Retain nonmerchantable timber, where warranted, for use as corduroy (5.0).

Remove corduroy during clean-up.

5. Seed disturbed forested portions of the right-of-way with the appropriate seed mix.12. CLI (Canada Land Inventory) classes are described in Section 5.0 of the ESA.

2 Nov. 2007 PCRA - Revision to map CI OD

3 Nov. 2009 Year 1 PCRA TGG AI

Page 18: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 16

APPENDIX B

ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES LIST FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL AS-BUILT REPORT FOR THE DUKE ENERGY FIELD SERVICES CANADA LTD. PESH CREEK PIPELINE LOOP

Page 19: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 17

TABLE B-1

ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES LIST FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL AS-BUILT REPORT FOR THE DUKE PESH CREEK PIPELINE LOOP

Environmental Issues Location Mitigative Measures Implemented During Construction Status Proposed Post-

Construction Measures 1. PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT (a) fill/backfill

instability Entire route • Grading was minimized along the route with the pipeline loop

paralleling existing pipelines and temporary workspace occupying adjacent pipeline rights-of-way. Maximum grade width was approximately 12 m.

• Muskeg portions of the right-of-way were levelled and due to the slow and poor drainage of these areas, erosion control was not a concern.

• Backfilling operation was kept as close as possible to lowering-in activities.

• Due to the frozen condition of the soil, no trench compaction was done, and the excavated material was piled over the trench line in a crown.

Unresolved Monitor trench line settlement and right-of-way contours.

2. WATER QUANTITY AND QUALITY (a) alteration of

natural flow patterns

Entire route • The right-of-way was recontoured to restore the preconstruction grades and drainage contours.

• Breaks were left in the trench crown at obvious drainages to minimize interference with natural drainage.

Unresolved Identify areas of ephemeral drainage, ensure drainage patterns were maintained during reclamation and monitor trench line settlement.

3. WETLANDS (a) loss of wetland

habitat Entire route • Existing linear disturbances were paralleled to minimize the

amount of new disturbance along the pipeline right-of-way for 100% of its route.

• Construction occurred during frozen ground conditions. • The right-of-way was recontoured to restore the preconstruction

grades and drainage contours.

Unresolved Monitor wetland restoration.

4. VEGETATION (a) loss of vegetation

important to wildlife

Entire route • Minimal clearing (approximately 20 ha) was required as the right-of-way paralleled existing clearing for 100% of its route.

• Clearing was done with mulching machines and there was no burning of cleared woody debris.

• Existing pipeline rights-of-way were used for temporary workspace.

Unresolved Monitor the success of the revegetation program.

(b) weed introduction and spread

Entire route • All equipment arrived onsite clean of any debris. Unresolved Monitor right-of-way for weed problem areas.

5. WILDLIFE AND WILDLIFE HABITAT (a) loss or alteration

of potential wildlife habitat

Entire route • Minimal clearing (approximately 20 ha) was required as the right-of-way paralleled existing clearing for 100% of its route.

• A small amount of timber was left un-mulched but cleared in order to be used for habitat berms.

• Existing pipeline rights-of-way were used for temporary workspace.

• The right-of-way was recontoured to restore the preconstruction grades and drainage contours.

Unresolved Monitor the re-establishment of low-growing shrubs and grasses on the right-of-way.

(b) auditory or visual disturbances of wildlife

Entire route • Construction activities were completed by April 12, 2005. • Construction adhered to the Caribou Protection Plan filed with

Alberta Sustainable Resource Development.

Resolved None.

(c) mortality Entire route • Construction activities were completed by April 12, 2005. • Construction adhered to the Caribou Protection Plan filed with

Alberta Sustainable Resource Development.

Resolved None.

6. SPECIES AT RISK (a) auditory or visual

disturbances of wildlife species at risk

Entire route • See Wildlife and Wildlife Habitat element -- See Wildlife and Wildlife Habitat element.

Page 20: FIRST YEAR POST-CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL …

Spectra Energy Transmission First Year PCEM Report Pesh Creek Pipeline Loop November 2009 / 5645

Page 18

TABLE B-1 Cont'd

Environmental Issues Location Mitigative Measures Implemented During Construction Status Proposed Post-

Construction Measures (b) mortality of wildlife

species at risk Entire route • See Wildlife and Wildlife Habitat element -- See Wildlife and Wildlife

Habitat element. 7. HUMAN OCCUPANCY AND RESOURCE USE (a) disruption of other

resource based industries

Entire route • Forestry and other oil and gas companies were notified of the Project and construction schedule.

Resolved None.

(b) disruption of hunting and trapping activities

Entire route • Local trappers and outfitters were notified of the proposed Project and activity schedule prior to commencement of Project activities.

Resolved None.

8. ACCIDENTS AND MALFUNCTIONS (a) hydrocarbon spill

during construction or operation

Entire route • All spills were to be reported immediately to the Chief Inspector and, if warranted, appropriate government agencies.

Resolved None.

(b) rupture of foreign lines

Entire route • All foreign pipelines and existing buried utilities were exposed with hydrovac trucks prior to construction of the Project.

Resolved None.