32
NUMBER 176 SEPTEMBER 2017 Newsletter for the Association of Applied Geochemists www.appliedgeochemists.org continued on page 5 Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS FOR THEIR SUPPORT Robert G. Garrett 1 , Clemens Reimann 2 , Karel Hron 3 , Petra Kynčlová 4 and Peter Filzmoser 4 ; 1 Emeri- tus Scientist, Geological Survey of Canada, Natural Resources Canada, 601 Booth St., Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0E8, Canada; 2 P.O. Box 6315, Torgard, NO-7491, Trondheim, Norway; 3 Department of Mathematical Analysis and Applications of Mathematics, Palacký University, 17.listopadu 12, 77146 Olomouc, Czech Republic; 4 Institute of Statistics and Mathematical Methods in Economics, Vienna University of Technology, WiednerHauptstr. 8-10, 1040 Vienna, Austria. Introduction Geochemists have long been aware of the problems surrounding estimating correlation coefficients for their analytical data sets. Very often they just don’t make sense on the basis of the mineralogy of the sample material and our knowledge of mineral stoichiometry. The problem lies in the nature of geochemical analyses, they are relative measures reported in such units as weight %, parts per million (mg/kg), µg/L, etc., the sum of the parts, individual measures, add to a constant. Be- cause of the relative units it does not matter whether all the parts have been determined in the analysis, the problem remains whatever the number of parts determined, even just two. The problems related to correlations were recognized by Pearson as long ago as 1897. The first geoscientist to study the problem systematically was Felix Chayes (1960) a research petrologist who worked for the Carnegie Institution's Geophysical Laboratory and for the Smithsonian Institution. The true information in a geochemical data set lies in the ratios between the parts, and Tom Pearce (1970) was the first geoscientist to promote the use of ratios in petrology, leading to a number of diagrams that are effective in classification and genetic studies. The math- ematical groundwork for properly handling compositional data was laid out by John Aitchison (1984, 1986) with his exposition on the use of log-ratios. Since then numerous papers and books have been published on compositional data analysis, see for example Pawlowsky-Glahn et al. (2015) and the references in Reimann et al. (2017). Today a common approach in multivariate analysis, e.g., Principal Components or Factor Analysis, is to use a centred log-ratio (clr) of the data set prior to carrying out the analysis (e.g., Fig. 1). It might seem apparent then to also calculate the correlation coefficients on the clr-transformed data. However, this does not lead to consistent results, because clr variables are driven by their zero sum constraint. As a consequence, a negative bias occurs when correlation analysis in clr variables is performed. It is quite natural that different sub-compositions, i.e. subsets of the parts, for a data set do not yield the same correlation coefficients for the two parts of interest. The reason for this is the computation of the clr-transform involves dividing the value for each part (variable) by the geometric mean of all the parts in the subset for an individual sample; and different subsets for a sample will have different geomet- ric means. One can also express each clr variable as a (scaled) sum of all pairwise log-ratios with the respective compositional part – a kind of intuitive result, when all information in compositional data is con- tained in log-ratios. A careful choice of parts, involved in the analysis, is thus always necessary. A solution to the problem of negative bias of correlation analysis in clr variables has been proposed by Kynčlová et al. (2017) and involves the computation of symmetric coordinates, an extension of isometric log-ratios (Egozcue et al., 2003). The symmetric coordinates are computed as weighted log-ratios that take the total number of Figure 1. Principal Components Analysis for the clr-trans- formed Nockolds data set. Lithologies: 1- Alkali Granite; 2 - Granite; 3 - Quartz Monzonite; 4 – Granodiorite; 5 – Quartz Diorite; 6 – Alkali Syenite; 7 – Syenite; 8 – Monzonite; 9 – Monzodiorite; 10 - Diorite; 11 - Gabbro; 12 - Peridotite; 13 - Anorthosite; 14 - Nepheline Syenite; 15 - Essexite; 16 - Ijolite parts into consideration. This procedure has been demonstrated with two large sets of geochemical (environmental) soil data by Reimann et al. (2017). The purpose of this article is to demonstrate the pro- cedure and discuss the results for a small set of petrochemical data whose mineralogy will be familiar to readers. As such, this article is a tutorial rather than a contribution of original science. The data set of 16 ‘averages’ for common plutonic rocks was published by Nockolds

Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    23

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

NUMBER 176 SEPTEMBER 2017

Newsletter for the Association of Applied Geochemists

www.appliedgeochemists.org

continued on page 5

Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth

EXPLORE NEWSLETTER

WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS FOR THEIR SUPPORT

Robert G. Garrett1, Clemens Reimann2, Karel Hron3, Petra Kynčlová4 and Peter Filzmoser4; 1Emeri-tus Scientist, Geological Survey of Canada, Natural Resources Canada, 601 Booth St., Ottawa, Ontario, K1A 0E8, Canada; 2P.O. Box 6315, Torgard, NO-7491, Trondheim, Norway; 3Department of Mathematical Analysis and Applications of Mathematics, Palacký University, 17.listopadu 12, 77146 Olomouc, Czech Republic; 4Institute of Statistics and Mathematical Methods in Economics, Vienna University of Technology, WiednerHauptstr. 8-10, 1040 Vienna, Austria.

Introduction Geochemistshavelongbeenawareoftheproblemssurroundingestimatingcorrelationcoefficientsfortheiranalyticaldatasets.Veryoftentheyjustdon’tmakesenseonthebasisofthemineralogyofthesamplematerialandourknowledgeofmineralstoichiometry.Theproblemliesinthenatureofgeochemicalanalyses,theyarerelativemeasuresreportedinsuchunitsasweight%,partspermillion(mg/kg),µg/L,etc.,thesumoftheparts,individualmeasures,addtoaconstant.Be-causeoftherelativeunitsitdoesnotmatterwhetherallthepartshavebeendeterminedintheanalysis,theproblemremainswhateverthenumberofpartsdetermined,evenjusttwo.TheproblemsrelatedtocorrelationswererecognizedbyPearsonaslongagoas1897.ThefirstgeoscientisttostudytheproblemsystematicallywasFelixChayes(1960)aresearchpetrologistwhoworkedfortheCarnegieInstitution'sGeophysicalLaboratoryandfortheSmithsonianInstitution.Thetrueinformationinageochemicaldatasetliesintheratiosbetweentheparts,andTomPearce(1970)wasthefirstgeoscientisttopromotetheuseofratiosinpetrology,leadingtoanumberofdiagramsthatareeffectiveinclassificationandgeneticstudies.Themath-ematicalgroundworkforproperlyhandlingcompositionaldatawaslaidoutbyJohnAitchison(1984,1986)withhisexpositionontheuseoflog-ratios.Sincethennumerouspapersandbookshavebeenpublishedoncompositionaldataanalysis,seeforexamplePawlowsky-Glahnet al.(2015)andthereferencesinReimannet al.(2017).Todayacommonapproachinmultivariateanalysis,e.g.,PrincipalComponentsorFactorAnalysis,istouseacentredlog-ratio(clr)ofthedatasetpriortocarryingouttheanalysis(e.g.,Fig.1).Itmightseemapparentthentoalsocalculatethecorrelationcoefficientsontheclr-transformeddata.However,thisdoesnotleadtoconsistentresults,becauseclrvariablesaredrivenbytheirzerosumconstraint.Asaconsequence,anegativebiasoccurswhencorrelationanalysisinclrvariablesisperformed.Itisquitenaturalthatdifferentsub-compositions,i.e.subsetsoftheparts,foradatasetdonotyieldthesamecorrelationcoefficientsforthe two parts of interest. The reason for this is the computation of theclr-transforminvolvesdividingthevalueforeachpart(variable)bythegeometricmeanofallthepartsinthesubsetforanindividualsample; and different subsets for a sample will have different geomet-ricmeans.Onecanalsoexpresseachclrvariableasa(scaled)sumofallpairwiselog-ratioswiththerespectivecompositionalpart–akindofintuitiveresult,whenallinformationincompositionaldataiscon-tainedinlog-ratios.Acarefulchoiceofparts,involvedintheanalysis,isthusalwaysnecessary. AsolutiontotheproblemofnegativebiasofcorrelationanalysisinclrvariableshasbeenproposedbyKynčlováet al.(2017)andinvolvesthecomputationofsymmetriccoordinates,anextensionofisometriclog-ratios(Egozcueet al.,2003).Thesymmetriccoordinatesarecomputedasweightedlog-ratiosthattakethetotalnumberof

Figure 1. Principal Components Analysis for the clr-trans-formed Nockolds data set. Lithologies: 1- Alkali Granite; 2 - Granite; 3 - Quartz Monzonite; 4 – Granodiorite; 5 – Quartz Diorite; 6 – Alkali Syenite; 7 – Syenite; 8 – Monzonite; 9 – Monzodiorite; 10 - Diorite; 11 - Gabbro; 12 - Peridotite; 13 - Anorthosite; 14 - Nepheline Syenite; 15 - Essexite; 16 - Ijolite

parts into consideration. This procedure has been demonstrated with twolargesetsofgeochemical(environmental)soildatabyReimannet al.(2017).Thepurposeofthisarticleistodemonstratethepro-cedure and discuss the results for a small set of petrochemical data whosemineralogywillbefamiliartoreaders.Assuch,thisarticleisatutorial rather than a contribution of original science. The data set of 16‘averages’forcommonplutonicrockswaspublishedbyNockolds

Page 2: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 2 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

Paid Advertisement

Oreas-November-Ad2.indd 1 11/5/15 2:22 PM

We have the largest dedicated mining CRM production facility in the world, supplying over 1,200 customers in 105 countries. OREAS gold CRMs are the most homogeneous available, giving you peace of mind that comes with negligible sampling error. Our new line of SuperCRMs™ feature method specific certification of full ICP-OES and MS suites. Find out how OREAS can add value and certainty to your operations by contacting [email protected] now.

Page 3: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 3

Notes from the Editor

TABLE OF CONTENTSFinally,acorrelationcoefficientthattellsthe geochemical truth ...................................................................... 1Notes from the Editor ................................................................... 3President’sMessage ..................................................................... 4Seaweedasanexplorationmediumalonginletsonthewest coastofCanada.Part1:Methodsandresultsfrom JervisInlet ................................................................................. 13GeochemicalNuggets:IssueswithModernICP-MS Gold Data ................................................................................. 21AAG Councillor Elections .......................................................... 22AAG Regional Report: Ireland and United Kingdom .............. 23RecentlyPublishedinElements .................................................. 23Geochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis.................. 24AAG Student Support Program .................................................. 25AAGNewMembers ..................................................................... 2628thIAGSandResourcesforFutureGenerations2018 .......... 28HydrothermalOreDepositsCourse ........................................... 30Exploration’17 .............................................................................. 30Calendar of Events ........................................................................ 31

ADVERTISERSActivationLaboratoriesLtd. ........................................................ 8ALSMinerals ................................................................................ 6Barringer-TheBook .................................................................... 27BrunoLemiere .............................................................................. 4BureauVeritasMinerals. .............................................................. 4Olympus ......................................................................................... 11OREASCertifiedReferenceMaterials ...................................... 2RFG2018-CallforAbstracts ..................................................... 29RockLabs ....................................................................................... 12SciAps Inc. ..................................................................................... 7

Editor: BethMcClenaghan([email protected])

BusinessManager:PimvanGeffen1-604-681-6765([email protected])BackIssues:AAGWebsite(www.appliedgeochemists.org)

EXPLOREispublishedquarterlybytheAssociationofAppliedGeochem-ists,P.O.Box26099,72RobertsonRoad,Ottawa,ONCanadaK2H9RO.EXPLOREisatrademarkoftheAssociationofAppliedGeochemists.Type and layout of EXPLORE:VivianHeggie,HeggieEnterprises,Thornton,CO(303)288-6540;[email protected]

EXPLORE Publication Schedule QuarterlynewslettersinMarch,June,September,December

Deadlines for submission of articles or advertisements: Marchnewsletter:January15 Junenewsletter:April15 Septembernewsletter:July15 Decembernewsletter:October15

Information for Contributors Manuscripts should be double-spaced and submitted in digital formatusingMicrosoft®WORD.DoNOT embed figures or tables in the textdocument.Eachphotoand/orfigure(colourorblackandwhite)shouldbesubmittedasseparatehighresolutiontiff,jpegorPDF(2400resolutionorbetter)file.EachtableshouldbesubmittedasseparatedigitalfileinMicro-soft®EXCELformat.Allscientific/technicalarticleswillbereviewed.Allcontributionsmaybeeditedforclarityorbrevity. Formatsforheadings,abbreviations,scientificnotations,referencesandfiguresmust follow theGuide toAuthors forGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis(GEEA)thatarepostedontheGEEAwebsiteat:http://www.geolsoc.org.uk/template.cfm?name=geea_instructions_for_au-thors Inadditiontothetechnicalarticle,authorsareaskedtosubmitaseparate250wordabstractthatsummarizesthecontentoftheirarticle.ThisabstractwillbepublishedinthejournalELEMENTSonthe‘AAGNews’page.

Submissions should be sent to the Editor of EXPLORE:BethMcClenaghan

Email: [email protected]

EXPLORE Newsletter Advertising Rates (Effective Jan. 2016)

ANNUAL CORPORATE SPONSORSHIP USD CAD Fullyear $2,500 $3,425

Includes: Access to AAG membership listCompanylogoonfrontcover

EntitledtoB&Wpricesforcolouradvertisements

ADVERTISING RATES – PER ISSUE (QUARTERLY) USD CAD

Fullpage(B&W)241hx190wmm(9.5hx7.5win) $1,050 $1,440Fullpage(Colour) $1,260 $1,725Halfpage(B&W)241hx89wmm(9.5hx3.5win) or124hx190wmm(4-7/8hx7.5win) $575 $790Halfpage(Colour) $685 $9401/3page(B&W)241hx51wmm(9.5hx2win) or178hx89wmm(7hx3.5win) $455 $6251/3page(Colour) $545 $7451/4page(B&W)124hx89wmm(4-7/8hx3.5win) or241hx41wmm(9.5hx1-5/8win) $325 $4451/4page(Colour) $390 $5351/8page(B&W)60hx89wmm(2-3/8hx3.5win) $205 $2801/8page(Colour) $250 $340Businesscard(B&W)51hx89wmm(2hx3.5win) $55 $75Businesscard(Colour) $65 $9015%discountforfullyearsubscription -15% -15%

Pleasedirectadvertisinginquiriesto:PIMVANGEFFEN

([email protected])

NewsletterNo.176 September2017

EXPLOREissue176includestwotechnicalarticles.ThefirstiswrittenbyBobGarrett,ClemensReimann,KarelHron,PetraKynčlováandPeterFilzmoseranddemonstrates a solution to the problem of negative bias of correlationanalysisusingasmallsetofpetrochemicaldata.ThesecondarticlebyColinDunnandRickMcCaffreyde-scribestheuseofseaweedasanexplorationmediumwithanexamplefromthewestcoastofCanada. EXPLOREthanksallthosewhocontributedtothewritingand/oreditingofthisissue:SteveAdcock,SteveAmor,DennisArne,AlArsenault,SteveCook,PeterFilzmoser,BobGarrett,KarelHron,KateKnights,PetraKynčlová,ChrisLawley,DavidLeng,RickMcCaffrey,PaulMorris,RyanNoble,andClemensReimann,DaveSmith,PimvanGeffen,andPeterWinterburn. Beth McClenaghanEditor

Page 4: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 4 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

President's Message

Paid Advertisement

+1 604 253 3158 | [email protected]/um

Bureau Veritas MineralsYour Solution for Exploration & Mining Industry

■ Assaying and Geochemical analysis■ Metallurgy and Mineralogy■ Spectral Services■ Mine Site Laboratories

MyfirstPresident’sMessageinExplore(March2016)wasabitofanintroduction,butalsohighlightedmypathintoservicefortheAAGandthecollaborativebenefitsthatIhadgainedfrombeingastudentmember.IbenefitedgreatlyfrombeingastudentAAGmemberandIencourageallofyouthatinteractwithstudentsof

appliedgeochemistrytoencouragethemtojoin.TheAAGhasasmaller,collegiate-feelforappliedgeochemistryandwearekeenerthanevertobuildourstudentmembers.IwillreviewafewoftheperksofbeinganAAGstudentmember.Firstly,itisonly$10USandincludessubscriptionstoourjournal,Geochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,ournewsletter EXPLOREandanumberofstudentfocusedawardsandprogramsincludingoneforanalyticalsupport.Itislessexpensivethanapintofbeer(inPerth)andyougetafullyearofvalue.TheAAGoffersomevaluablestudentfundingandsupportservices. These include: 1)Analyticalsupport(in-kind) 2)Conferencetravelfunding 3)Conferencepresentationandpublicationawards 4)Abstractfeefunding Theanalyticalsupportprogramenablessomeresearchsamplestobeanalysedatourparticipatinglaboratorypartners(Actlabs,ALS,BureauVeritasMineralsAcme,BureauVeritasMineralsUltratrace,IntertekGenalysis,andLabWest).Theseanalysesareperformedforfreeorsignificantlyreducedcosttothestudent.TheAAGfacilitatesdeservingstudentstogettheneededanalysesdoneandourcommitteealsoassistsingettingthisresearchpublishedinourjournalGEEAortheEXPLORE newsletteratalatertime.AfulllistofsupportedresearchisshownlaterinthisissueauthoredbyPaulMorris. ConferencetravelfundingisofferedtosupportstudentattendanceprimarilyatourInternationalAppliedGeochemistrySymposia(IAGS).ThenextsymposiumisinVancouverinJune2018aspartoftheResourcesforFutureGenerationsmajorconference(RFG2018http://rfg2018.org/)andwehopetosupportanumberofstudentsfortheirconferencefeesandpoten-tiallysometravel/accommodationcoststoasetvalue.TheAAGisalsoofferingstudentpaperandposterprizesattheupcom-ingIAGSinVancouverthanksinparttooursponsorsSGSMinerals. Finally,theAAGexpectstoreimbursestudentsforallabstractfeesincurredbysubmittingtotheRFG2018ifthestudentispresentinginanIAGSaffiliatedsession.FulldetailsandmoreareavailableonourwebsiteorwillbeupdatedshortlyastheRFGprogramdevelops.https://www.appliedgeochemists.org/ YoucanseeitisworthyourtimeasastudenttojointheAAGandbecomeinvolved.AsamemberoftheAAG,ifyouknowanyappliedgeochemistrystudents,pleasepassthisinformationontothem.TheyarethefutureoftheAAGandIwould

liketoseeabigincreaseinstudentsandearlycareerresearchersatthenextIAGSinVancouver.Iwillbeencouragingtheconfer-ence organisers to give preference to student presentations if spotsarelimited.Ihopetomeetmanymorestudentspromi-nentlypresentingtheirresearchinVancouveranddevelopingthenecessarycollaborationsforastrongfuturecareerinappliedgeochemistry.

Ryan NobleAAG PresidentEmail: [email protected]

Bruno Lemière, Ph.DGeochemist

Field analysis, metrologyand data consultant

Site instrumentation � Laboratory engineering �Data analysis � Training and know-how transfer

www.monitor-env.com36 venelle des Vaupulents - 45000 ORLEANS - France - +33 6 95902134

Operating also from New York, Montreal, Brussels or London

Paid Advertisement

Page 5: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 5

Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth… continued from page 1

continued on page 6

(1954)asoxidepercentages.Morerecentcompilationshavebeenmade,buttheNockoldsdatasufficesforthedemonstration.TheoriginaloxideshavebeenconvertedtocationpercentagesandH2O+ to OH-,seeAppendix1(seedigitalversionofAp-pendix1ontheAAGwebsite).

Data Analysis Forallthefollowingcomputationsandgraphicalpresentationsversion1.1.14oftheR(2017)package‘rgr’(Garrett,2017)wasemployed.TographicallyillustratetheinterrelationsbetweenthegeochemicaldataandthelithologyaPrincipalCom-ponentsAnalysis(PCA)wasundertakenfollowingacentredlog-ratiotransformation(function‘gx.mva.closed’),seeFigure1(function‘gx.rqpca.plot’),whichwasannotated(colouredtext)withthelithologicalabbreviationsoutside‘rgr’.Theendmem-bersandoutliersinFigures2to4weresimilarlyannotated.Functionsin‘rgr_1.1.14’,‘xyplot.tags’inconjunctionwithfunction‘gx.symm.coords.mat’,candirectlydisplayplotstaggedbytext,suchaslithologicalnames. Thefirstprincipalcomponent,PC-1,explains74.7%ofthetotalvariabilityinthedataset.HighSi,Alandalkalimetalfelsic,quartzo-feldspathic,rocksarecharacterizedbynegativePC-1scores,whilefemic,ferromagnesianmineral-rich,rockshighinMg,Fe3,Fe2,MnandTiarecharacterizedbypositivePC-1scores.Incontrast,alkalicrockswithhigherCa,NaandPcontentsarecharacterizedbynegativePC-2scores.Thepathfromfelsicintrusives,e.g.,generallygranitic,tofemicrocks(gabbrosanddiorites)followsa‘NW’to‘SE’trend.TwoSideficientrocks,olivine-andpyroxene-richperidotite,andneph-eline-andalkalipyroxene-richijolitebothplotas‘outliers’off-trend.Theessentiallymono-mineralicrockanorthosite,withdominantplagioclasefeldspar,plotsproximaltoAl,KandNaclosetothemaintrendinthedata. Thedefaultprocedureinfunction‘gx.symm.coords.r’calculatesSpearmancorrelationcoefficientsforthesymmetriccoor-dinatesderivedfromtheinputdata.SpearmanrankedcoefficientsarepreferredoverPearsonproductmomentcoefficientsastheyprovidebetterestimatesofcorrelationfordatapairsthatvarymonotonically,i.e.thedatapointsvarysympatheticallyorantipathetically,butnotnecessarilylinearly.Furthermore,anymonotonictransformation,e.g.,logarithmic,hasnoimpactontheSpearmancoefficientastheranksremainthesame.ForExploratoryDataAnalysis(EDA)anysystematicdatarelationshipisofinterest,evenifitiscurvilinear;shouldmodellingberequiredlinearizingtransformationscanbesought. Thecorrelationmatrix(Table1)containstwosetsofSpearmancoefficients,theuppertrianglecontainsthosebasedonthesymmetriccoordinatescomputedafterKynčlováet al.(2017),andthelowercontainsthosebasedontheinputdata.Alternate-ly,Pearsoncoefficientsmaybeselected,andthefurtheroptionexiststoapplyalogarithmictransformationtotheinputdata,which has been common practice amongst applied geochemists.

Discussion Silicon(Si)isthedominantpartinthedatasetwithcationpercentagesvaryingfromsome20%,ijoliteandperidotite,to34.5%,alkaligranite(seeAppendix1).ReadingdownthefirstcolumnofTable1,theSpearmancoefficientsareallnegative,butforK.Asthedominantpart(Si)increasesmostoftheremainingpartshavetodecreasetomaintainconstantsum.YetfromthemineralogyoftheserocksweknowthatSi,Al,NaandKincreasetogetherinfelsicrocksastheamountsofquartz,andalkalifeldsparincrease,togetherwithwhitemicas(OH),attheexpenseoflessSi-richferromagnesianmineralsrichinFe,Mg,TiandMn,suchasdarkmicasandamphibolesthataremoreabundantinfemicrocks. ThismineralogicalrealityisreflectedintheSpearmancoefficientsbasedonthesymmetriccoordinatesdisplayedacrossthefirstrowofTable1.ThenegativesymmetriccoordinatecorrelationsforMg,Fe2,Fe3,Ti,MnandCareflectthesympatheticrelationshipbetweentheseelementsinferromagnesianmineralsfromamphiboles,throughpyroxenestoolivines,astheyincreaseinabundanceinfemicrocks.Thisincreaseisattheexpenseofquartz(Si),albitic(Na)andorthoclase(K)alumino-silicatefeldspars,andisreflectedinpositivesymmetriccoordinatecorrelationsbetweenSi,Al,Na,KandOH,and,asagroup,theirnegativecorrelationswithMg,Fe2,Fe3,Ti,MnandCa.

Table 1. Spearman correlation coefficients for the Nockolds data set. Upper triangle based on symmetric coordinates, lower triangle based on raw data

Si Al Fe3 Fe2 Mg Ca Na K Ti Mn P OHSi 0.87 -0.58 -0.38 -0.66 -0.55 0.56 0.74 -0.79 -0.40 -0.16 0.71Al -0.44 -0.54 -0.67 -0.82 -0.44 0.77 0.75 -0.80 -0.42 -0.27 0.60Fe3 -0.79 0.36 0.45 0.54 0.22 -0.22 -0.13 0.46 0.84 0.08 -0.19Fe -0.74 -0.04 0.80 0.93 0.51 -0.88 -0.59 0.67 0.41 -0.06 -0.23Mg -0.76 0.00 0.76 0.98 0.71 -0.86 -0.77 0.92 0.44 0.11 -0.30Ca -0.78 0.54 0.63 0.57 0.64 -0.32 -0.76 0.82 0.10 0.09 -0.30Na -0.13 0.77 0.20 -0.28 -0.30 0.21 0.64 -0.68 -0.25 0.01 0.47K 0.66 0.06 -0.30 -0.56 -0.63 -0.63 0.29 -0.74 -0.30 0.47 0.41Ti -0.79 0.37 0.94 0.84 0.83 0.71 0.13 -0.36 0.41 0.15 -0.35Mn -0.77 0.19 0.84 0.76 0.70 0.37 0.06 -0.37 0.78 -0.21 -0.01P -0.40 0.40 0.75 0.49 0.50 0.62 0.30 0.00 0.79 0.37 -0.62OH -0.51 0.23 0.41 0.50 0.52 0.34 0.10 -0.48 0.54 0.53 0.17

Page 6: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 6 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

continued on page 8

Paid Advertisement

• Rapid, low cost, Pb isotope analysis

• Low detection limits with multi-element ICP-MS

• CoreViewer™ Technology

• Data integration with 3D modeling

• Industry leading hyperspectral technologies

The Global Benchmark

For more information, scan this QR code or visit www.alsglobal.com | Phone: +1 604-984-0221

Breaking Boundaries with Innovative Solutions

Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth… continued from page 5

Datainspectionandinterpretationisoftenfacilitatedandimprovedbygraphicalpresentations,function‘gx.symm.coords.plot’undertakesthattask.TheclassicexampleofproblemswithcompositionaldataistheHarkerdiagram,whichdatesbackto1909,forplottingvariousoxidesagainstsilica.Silicon(Si)andAlarethedominantcationpairsforeachofthelithologiesintheNockoldsdataexceptperidotite(Mg&FereplaceAl),andAl-richijoliteandnephelinesyenite.TheplotforSiandAlispresentedinFigure2.

Figure 2. Plots of the Nockolds data for Si and Al as a pseudo Harker diagram (left) and as symmetric coordinates (right)

TheHarkerplotontheleftshowsthefamiliarnegativerelationshipimposedbythecompositionalformofthedata,withthemineralogicalandgeochemi-caloutliers,peridotiteinthelowerleft,andnephelinesyeniteandanorthositeatthetopwithhighestAl.Incontrast,theplotbasedonsymmetriccoordinates(Fig.2,right)demonstratessympatheticallyincreasingSiandAl,withtheultramaficperidotiteremaininganoutlier at the bottom of the plot. The other two upper outliersareofinterest,themostextremeisAl-richanorthosite,andthelessisnephelinesyenite,whichlies in the felsic to femic trend observed in the PCA (#14inFig.1).ThedifferencebetweenthetwoplotsissummarizedinthedifferencesbetweentheirSpearmancorrelations,-0.44fortheHarkerplotand0.87forthesymmetriccoordinateplot,aconvincingreversal.Inthis case the Pearson correlation is of interest. It is sur-prisinglypositive0.18(withalogarithmictransforma-

tion)fortheHarkerplot,however,thisisduetotheinfluenceofthehighleverageoutlierperidotite,andinviewofthegraphic(Fig.2,left)totallymisleading.ThePearsoncorrelationforthesymmetriccoordinatesis0.69,essentiallyunchanged. AsimilarreversalcanbedemonstratedwithCaandNa,thetwocationsintheanorthite-albiteplagioclasesolidsolutionseries(Fig.3).

Page 7: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 7

Paid Advertisement

Page 8: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 8 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

continued on page 9Paid Advertisement

Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth… continued from page 6

Figure 3. Plots of the Nockolds data for Ca and Na (left) and as sym-metric coordinates (right).

The standard plot on the left demonstrates little variationinNa,exaggeratedgraphicallybythepresenceof the low Na peridotite at the bottom. The two highest Nalithologiesarenephelinesyeniteandijolite,alkalicrocks.Theexpectedantipatheticrelationshipbetweenthetwoplagioclaseendmembers,andtheincreaseofanor-thiticmembersinfemicrocksversustheincreaseinalbiticmembersinfelsicrocksisnotapparentduetotheroleofSiandAlasdominantpartsintherockcompositions.Theplotofthesymmetriccoordinates(Fig.3,right)illustrateswhatweknowas‘true’onthebasisofmineralstoichiom-etryandpetrology,astrongantipatheticCa-Narelation-ship due to the plagioclase solid solution series and the observed mineralogical variations between felsic and femic rocks.Peridotiteremainsanoutlieratthebottomoftheplot,andtheupperright-mostoutlierisanorthosite,and

thelessextremeisijolite.SummarizednumericallybytheSpearmancoefficients,theuntransformeddataarepositivelycor-related,0.21,andthesymmetricallytransformeddataarenegativelycorrelated,-0.32,asshouldbeexpectedongeochemicalgrounds. AfinalexampleisoneinvolvingKandTi,aminorelement,i.e.between1and0.1%inthecomposition,whichclarifiestheirrelationship,Figure4.

Figure 4. Plots of the Nockolds data for K and Ti (left) and as sym-metric coordinates (right).

Thestandardplotontheleftshowsagenerallyanti-patheticrelationshipbetweenKandTi.AstobeexpectedasK-richfelsicrocksarepoorinTibearingmineralssuchasbiotite,ilmeniteandrutileandfemicrocksarerichinTi-bearingbiotites,amphiboles,andotherferromagnesianminerals,butpoorinK-richminerals.Therearetwooutli-ers,lowTialkaligraniteandhighTiessexite,aSiunder-

saturatedrockdominatedbyplagioclasefeldsparandpyroxene.Theplotbasedonsymmetriccoordinates(Fig.4,right)ismuchtidier,themainmassofthedataplotswithinamoreconfinedbandduetothereducedinfluenceofalltheremainingpartsinthetotalcomposition.ThehighTisymmetriccoordinateoutlier,-0.30,isessexitewhichhasthehighestTicationpercentage;thelithologyinthelowerrightcornerisalkaligranite,whichfromitsmineralogyofabundantorthoclase(K)andminimalbiotite(Ti)plotsasexpected.Summarizednumerically,therawdataSpearmancoefficientof-0.36hasbeenimprovedto-0.74throughthesymmetriccoordinatesremovaloftheeffectofthecompetingpartsinthecompositiononapartthatisaminor/trace contributor to the composition. TheNockoldsdatasetcontainsonlymajor(Si,Al,Fe,Mg,Ca,Na&K)andminor(Ti,Mn&P)elements.Itisusedhereasanexamplebecauseoftheeaseofitsinterpretation.Manyresearchers are under the wrong impression that compositional dataeffectsonlyexistwhenworkingwithmajorelements.Ithasoftenbeenassumed(includingbytheseniorauthorinthepast)

Page 9: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 9

continued on page 10

Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth… continued from page 8

thatasimplelogarithmictransformationofminorandtraceelementdataissufficient.TheexampleofTiabovedemonstratesthattheeffectisnotrestrictedtomajorelementconcentrations.ThedominantlytraceelementstudyofNorwegiansoilsbyReimann et al.(2017)demonstratesthatequallystrongeffectsareexhibitedfortraceelements.Compositionaleffectsarepresentinwateranalyseswheretheconcentrationsareusuallyreportedinµg/L,threeordersofmagnitudelowerthanppm(µg/g),andtheymustbetreatedappropriatelyinordertoobtainacorrectrepresentationoftheinterrelationshipsbetweentheparts(Flemet al.,submitted).Itisofnoimportancewhetherornotmajorelementsaredetermined,theeffectisinherentinthe data – in their relative units.

Conclusions Ithasbeendemonstratedhowtheuseofsymmetriccoordinatesleadstocorrelationcoefficientsthat‘tellthetruth’andprovidenumericalexpressiontoourobservationsofthemineralogyoftheigneousrockandthestoichiometryoftheirminer-als.Furthermore,thegraphicaldisplayofthesymmetriccoordinatesgreatlyimprovestheabilitytointerprettheresultsinageoscientificcontext.TheexampleofSiandAlclearlydemonstratestheadvantageofSpearmancorrelationsoverPearsoncor-relationsinthiskindofexploratory(EDA)investigationbythereductionoftheinfluenceofhighleverageoutliers.Important-ly,theresultspresentedgobeyondcorrelationanalysis.Theydemonstratethatsimplebivariatescatterplotsarenot‘simple’atallwhenworkingwithcompositionaldata.Thetruerelationsbetweentwopartsonlybecomesclearwhentheirsymmetriccoordinates are studied. TheNockoldsdataaresimpleinstructureandtheunderlyingpetrologyandmineralogyarewellunderstoodandthisisthereasontheyareusedhere.InterpretationoftheReimannet al.(2017)expositionforC-andO-horizonsoilsfromaNorwegiansurveyisfarmorecomplex,andcompoundedbymajorvariabilityintroducedbyvaryingratiosofminerogenicandorganicfrac-tions within the individual soil samples. Correlationcoefficientsaresometimesinferredtoimplycausalrelationshipsbetweenthevariables,orpartsforcomposi-tionaldata.Thiscanbedangerousasbothmeasuresmaybeunrelateddirectly,butthroughathirdmeasure,‘alurkingvari-able’,thatmay,ormaynot,havebeenmeasured.Theresultofthisisthattheinferredcausationcanbefalseandconclusionsdrawnerroneous.Giventhis,itisevenmoreimportantforscientistsworkingwithcompositionaldatatonumericallyestimateanddisplaybivariaterelationswithouttheinfluenceofthecompositionalnatureoftheirdata. Itistobehopedthatthisprocedureofworkingwithsymmetriccoordinateswillbeincorporatedintothecommonsoft-warepackagesusedbygeochemistsandotherusersofcompositionaldata.TofacilitatetheirusetheRscriptsforthethreesymmetriccoordinatefunctionsareincludedindigitalAppendixdatafiles3,4,and5ontheAAGwebsiteandanexampleoftheiruseinAppendix2;andifRisunavailableorinappropriatetheprocessingflowandlogiccanbetranslatedintoamoreconvenient language for the user.

Acknowledgements TheauthorsgratefullyacknowledgetheconstructivesuggestionsofChrisLawleyandPimvanGeffenforimprovementstothe article.

ReferencesAITCHISON,J.1984.Thestatisticalanalysisofgeochemicalcompositions.Mathematical Geology,16,531-564.AITCHISON,J.1986.Thestatisticalanalysisofcompositionaldata.ChapmanandHall,London,U.K.,416pp.CHAYES,F.1960.Oncorrelationbetweenvariablesofconstantsum.Journal of Geophysical Research,65,4185-4193.EGOZCUE,J.J.,PAWLOWSKY-GLAHN,V.,MATEU-FIGUERAS,G.&BARCELÓ-VIDAL,C.2003.Isometriclogratio transformationsforcompositionaldataanalysis.Mathematical Geology,35,279-300.FLEM,B.,REIMANN,C.,BIRKE,M.,FILZMOSER,P.&BANKS,D.Submitted.Graphicalstatisticstoexplorethenatural andanthropogenicprocessesinfluencingtheinorganicqualityofdrinkingwater,groundwaterandsurfacewater.Applied Geochemistry.GARRETT,R.G.2017.‘rgr’:AppliedGeochemistryEDA.https://cran.r-project.org/package=rgr.KYNČLOVÁ,P.,HRON,K.&FILZMOSER,P.2017.Correlationbetweencompositionalpartsbasedonsymmetricbalances. Mathematical Geosciences,49,777-796.NOCKOLDS,S.R.1954.Averagechemicalcompositionsofsomeigneousrocks.GeologicalSocietyofAmerica,Bulletin65, 1007-1032.PAWLOWSKY-GLAHN,V.,EGOZCUE,J.J.&TOLOSANA-DELGADO,R.2015.Modelingandanalysisofcompositional data.Wiley,Chichester,U.K.,272pp.PEARCE,T.H.1970.Acontributiontothetheoryofvariationdiagrams.Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology,19, 142-157.PEARSON,K.1897.Mathematicalcontributionstothetheoryofevolution.Onaformofspuriouscorrelationwhichmay arisewhenindicesareusedinthemeasurementoforgans.ProceedingsoftheRoyalSocietyofLondon,LX,489-502. R2017.RProjectforStatisticalComputing.https://www.r-project.org/(lastaccessedMay21,2017)

Page 10: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 10 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

REIMANN,C.,FILZMOSER,P.,HRON,K.,KYNČLOVÁ,P.&GARRETT,R.G.2017.Anewmethodforcorrelation analysisofcompositional(environmental)data-aworkedexample.Science of the Total Environment,607-608,995-971.

Appendix 1

The Nockolds igneous plutonic data set as used in the report

ALKG - Alkali Granite; GRNT - Granite; QZMZ - Quartz Monzonite; GRDR - Granodiorite;QRZD - Quartz Diorite; ALKS - Alkali Syenite; SENT - Syenite; MNZN - Monzonite;MZDT - Monzodiorite; DORT - Diorite; GBBR - Gabbro; PRDT - Peridotite;ANRS - Anorthosite; NPLS - Nepheline Syenite; ESXT - Essexite; IJLT – Ijolite

Appendix 2

Examplescriptsforusewithsymmetriccoordinatesfunctions

ItistakenthatthedatatableinAppendix1(seedigitalversionofAppendix1onAAGwebsite)hasbeenconvertedtoa.csvfileandimportedintoRasadataframe.Notethattherecanbenomissingentriesinthedatatable,ifavalueismissingthecolumnmustbedeleted,orasuitablevalueimputed: >nockolds<-read.csv(“D:\\mydata\\nockolds.csv”)

TogeneratethecorrelationmatrixwithSpearmancoefficients,uppertrianglebasedonsymmetriccoordinates,lowertrianglebasedonuntransformeddata,Table1,thedefault: >gx.symm.coords.r(nockolds)

TogeneratethecorrelationmatrixwithPearsoncoefficients,uppertrianglebasedonsymmetriccoordinates,lowertrianglebased on log transformed data: >gx.symm.coords.r(nockolds,method=“pearson”,log=TRUE)

TogeneratetheSi-AlplotsinFigure2,notethatSiisinthesecondcolumnofthedataframeandAlinthethird: >gx.symm.coords.plot(nockolds,2,3)

Similarly,fortheCa-NaplotsinFigure3,withCaintheseventhcolumnandCaintheeighth: >gx.symm.coords.plot(nockolds,7,8)

Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth… continued from page 9

Lithology Si Al Fe3 Fe2 Mg Ca Na K Ti Mn P OHALKG 34.53 7.28 0.55 0.88 0.16 0.51 2.60 4.26 0.120 0.039 0.061 0.444GRNT 33.70 7.33 0.60 1.30 0.31 0.95 2.29 4.53 0.222 0.046 0.079 0.500QZMZ 32.33 7.74 0.85 1.76 0.60 1.75 2.49 3.80 0.336 0.046 0.087 0.510GRDR 31.27 8.29 0.93 2.01 0.95 2.54 2.85 2.55 0.342 0.054 0.092 0.614QRZD 30.93 8.23 0.95 2.66 1.17 3.32 2.89 1.18 0.372 0.062 0.092 0.651ALKS 28.92 8.95 1.62 2.04 0.58 1.82 4.05 4.91 0.348 0.085 0.083 0.500SENT 27.77 9.06 1.53 2.20 1.22 2.90 2.91 5.42 0.497 0.062 0.166 0.595MNZN 25.88 8.77 1.80 3.56 2.21 4.83 2.60 3.88 0.671 0.101 0.192 0.566MZDT 25.55 8.99 2.28 4.18 2.38 5.00 2.79 2.29 0.653 0.108 0.188 0.566DORT 24.24 8.68 1.91 5.42 3.69 6.00 2.49 1.10 0.899 0.139 0.153 0.755GBBR 22.61 8.91 1.78 6.16 4.86 7.91 1.68 0.46 0.791 0.139 0.105 0.604PRDT 20.35 2.11 1.76 7.65 20.52 2.47 0.42 0.21 0.485 0.163 0.022 0.717ANRS 25.50 13.61 0.58 1.13 0.50 6.88 3.46 0.88 0.312 0.015 0.048 0.595NPLS 25.89 11.27 1.69 1.55 0.34 1.42 6.56 4.43 0.396 0.147 0.083 0.906ESXT 21.92 9.03 2.53 4.62 2.93 6.78 3.78 2.19 1.684 0.124 0.209 0.916IJLT 19.91 9.77 2.80 3.26 1.94 8.13 7.09 2.12 0.845 0.155 0.663 0.528

Page 11: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 11

Paid Advertisement

Handheld XRFThe next generation of portable XRF analyzers for geoexploration

Rugged. Revolutionary. Productive.

Contact your local Olympus sales representative or visit: www.olympus-ims.com/vanta

Olympus is a registered trademark, andVanta and Axon are trademark of Olympus Corporation. The Bluetooth® word mark and logos are registered trademarks owned by Bluetooth SIG, Inc. and any use of such marks by Olympus Corporation is under license.

*With optional fan. Fan is IP56 rated. Operates continuously at 33 °C without the fan. **M series analyzers are IP64 rated.

Rugged - Vanta analyzers can withstand a temperature range of -10 °C to 50 °C (14 °F to 122 °F)*

- Drop tested and IP65 rated** for durability in harsh environments

Revolutionary - Accurate, repeatable results in seconds for instant geochemistry and mineralogy

- Axon™ technology for higher count rates per second and excellent limits of detection (LODs)

Productive - Intuitive software features designed to maximize user throughput

- Data are easily exported via optional Wi-Fi, Bluetooth®, or USB for streamlined data delivery and archiving

ExploreNewsletter_201707.indd 1 7/13/17 7:05 AM

Page 12: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 12 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

Standard equipment

Mechanised systems

Combo systems

Reference Materials

Automated Systems

ROCKLABS is a global innovator in sample preparation equipment. Our New Zealand ingenuity combined with technical excellence positions us at the forefront internationally. We design and manufacture systems, equipment and certified reference materials which transform the processes of metals and minerals research, mining and exploration organisations around the world.

• On-site service and assistance along with spare parts and after-market support in most countries.

• Extensive range from bench top ring mills and sample dividers through to large combination crushers, pulverisers and fully automated systems.

• Reference Materials division is the world-leading producer of high-quality, globally certified laboratory standards for the Gold, Silver, Platinum , and Palladium industries, which provides vital quality assurance and quality control management.

• We have a team of chemists and a statistician to advise and assist in the use of reference materials and analysis of results.

LEADING INNOVATION IN SAMPLE PREPARATION EQUIPMENT

www.rocklabs.com

Paid Advertisement

Page 13: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 13

continued on page 14

Seaweed as an exploration medium along inlets on the west coast of Canada. Part 1: Methods and results from Jervis InletColin Dunn1 and Rick McCaffrey2

1Colin Dunn Consulting Inc., North Saanich, BC ([email protected]); 2Vancouver, BC - formerly of Acme Labs, Vancouver, BC ([email protected])

Seaweedsaremarinemacroalgaeofwhichmorethan40,000speciesareknown(Vinogradov1953);approximately650speciesarefoundinnortheastPacificoceanwaters(Gabrielsonetal.2000).Theycanbeclassifiedintothreemaingroupsaccordingtotheirhabitatandcolour:1)greenseaweeds(ClassChlorophyceae),mostlyfromtheuppertidalzone;2)brownseaweeds(ClassPhaeophyceae),mostlyinthemid-tidalzone;3)redseaweeds(ClassRhodophyceae),mostlyfromthelowtidalzone.AlongthefjordedinletsofwesternNorway,GreenlandandCanada,byfarthemostcommonseaweedsintheintertidalzonearethebrownrockweeds(Fucus spp.),alsoknownaswrackorbladderwrack.AlongthesouthwesterncoastofBritishColumbia(BC),CanadathemostcommonspeciesisFucus gardneri(Fig.1).Itgrowsto40–50cmwithirregularlydichotomousbranchesandisattached,generallytorock,byadiscoidholdfast.Thisholdfastispurelyphysicalanddoesnotaccessthecompositionoftheunderlyingrock.Colourvariationisfrompaletodarkyellowishgreen,gettingdarkerasitdriesoutbetweentides.Itcommonlyhaspaleoliveairbubbles(bladders)nearthefrondtips.

1a

1b

1c

1d

1a

1b

1c

1d

Figure 1: Rockweed (Fucus gardneri) in intertidal zone off the south-east British Columbia coast and collecting samples for analysis.

Rockweed chemistry applied to mineral exploration and environmental monitoring Variousresearchershaveexaminedthechemicalcompositionofrockweed,includinggeneralstudiesbyBlack&Mitchell(1952)andBollinberg(1975);andlocalstudiesfromGreenland(Bollingberg&Cooke1985),Wales(Fuge&James1973,1974),Ireland(Cullinane&Whelan1982),Sweden(Forsberget al.1988),England(Bryan&Hummerstone1973;Morris&

Page 14: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 14 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

Bale1975),Norway(Sharp&Bölviken1979)andUSA(Yang1991).AcomprehensiveguidetoseaweedsofBCisgivenbyScagel(1967). ExperimentationontheelementabsorptionofrockweedandmanyotherspeciesofseaweedfromthecoastofsouthernBC,wasconductedbytheGeologicalSurveyofCanadaintheearly1990s(Dunn1990;Dunnet al.1993)andanoverviewpub-lishedasachapterinabookonmetalhyperaccumulatorplants(Dunn1998). TheruggedcoastlineofBCwithitssteepcliffsintothemountainoushinterlandandmanyincisedstreamsthatdrainintotheseaprovideachallengetomineralexploration.However,wherestreamscutintotherockstheyinheritthechemicalsignatureofthoserocks.Ifastreamcutsthroughmineralization,thewatersbecomeslightlyenrichedinelementsassociatedwithsuchmineralization.Thestreamwatersemergeintothesoundswheretheirmetalcontentscanbereadilytakenupinthenearbyrockweed.Withtheseprinciplesinmind,asamplingprogramwasdevisedtocollectrockweedjustseawardfromwherethestreamsmeetthesea.Therationalebeingthatiftheseaweedisrelativelyenrichedinacommoditymetal(and/oritspathfinderelements)thiswouldgenerateafocusformoredetailedfollowupintothemountainstolookforthesource–usingotherprospectingmethodssuchasstreamsediments,streammossmatsorthestreamwatersthemselves. Todate,threeareashavebeensampled–alongtheshoresofmuchofJervisInlet;aroundtheshoresofTexadaIsland;andaroundHoweSound(Fig.2).Samplesfromthelatterareacollectedin1990includedcoastalareasdown-drainagefromtheformerBritanniaCumineandwerefoundtocontaindramaticallyhigherconcentrationsofCuandZnthansamplesfromthesamesitescollectedin2015,attestingtotheefficiencyofthesteadyclean-upeffortsoverthepastquartercentury.ThisarticledealswithJervisInlet;subsequentarticleswillfocusontheotherareasatalaterdate.

Figure 2: Survey areas - 1) Jervis Inlet; 2) Texada Island; 3) Howe Sound on the west coast of British Columbia (Google Map).

Sample Collection and Analysis A45footocean-goingyachtgaverelative-lyfasttransportalongthecoasttothepro-posed sample sites. On approaching a planned samplestation,arubber‘Zodiac-style’boatwitha10HPmotorandatwo-personcrewlaunchedfromthemooredyachttotheshore.A suitable site for collecting a seaweed sample suchasacliffface(Fig.1,bottomright)oraflattishrockypromontory(orbeach)wasvisuallyidentified.Cuttingthemotorenabledtheboattodriftuptothesamplesite,or(ifneeded)thecrewtogetonshore(Fig.1,topleft).Afreshsampleweighingabout100gwaspluckedfromtherocks(avoidingthesmallholdfaststructureatthebase).Bar-nacles,musselsorothersmallshellfishwereremoved; the sample was placed in a Hubco “NewSentry”spunboundpolyestersamplebag(7”x12.5”),andthedrawstringpulledclosed.Sampleswereoven-driedat80oC resulting in upto80%massreductionduetowaterlosswithvariationdirectlyrelatedtoexposuretimeinsunshinebetweenhigh-tides.Eachdriedsamplewasreducedtofinepowderinacoffeemillpriortodigestionofa0.5galiquotinmodifiedaquaregia(1:1:1HCl–HNO3 – H2O)at95°Cfor1hourandanalysisbyICP-MSandICP-ESfor65elements(methodVG101-EXT+REEatAcmeLabs/BureauVeritas,Vancouver).Aseparatealiquotwasalsoreducedtoashbycontrolledignitioninafurnaceheldat485°Cfor16hoursandelementconcen-trationsdeterminedbythesameanalyticalmethods(methodVG104-EXT+REE).Theashyieldfromthedrymaterialwas15-20%withthemedianandmeansbothcloseto16.5%. Analyticalresultsshowedthattheashingprocessresultedinnolossofmostelements;totalvolatilizationofHg,moder-atelosses(upto30%)ofAs,FeandSeandminorlosses(<10%)ofCd,Cr,Ge,SbandSn.NearlyallsamplesreportedbelowthemethoddetectionlimitsforBe,Bi,In,Nb,Pd,Pt,Ta,Th,Tl,WandmostoftheHREE.PrecisiononblindcontrolsampleswasextremelygoodwithRSDsbetterthan10%forallelementsexceptthosewithconcentrationsclosetodetectionlevels(Au,Be,Ge,Hf,In,Re,Se,Te,W,ZrandsomeoftheHREE).Pbindrysampleshad28%RSD,largelybecauseofsomedriftintheanalyticalsequence.Precisionoffieldandlaboratoryduplicateswassimilartothatobtainedontheblindcon-trols.OfrelevancetothisstudyisthatthenaturallyhigherReinthefieldsamplesgeneratedbetterprecisionthanthelowerconcentrationcontrolsamples.Concentrationsreferredtointhefollowingtextandplotsarefromtheanalysisofdrytissues,sincetheashingdidlittletoenhancedistributionpatternsandsowasdiscontinuedforthesucceedingsurveys.

continued on page 15

Seaweed as an exploration medium along inlets on the west coast… continued from page 13

Page 15: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 15

continued on page 16

Location ThesouthernendofJervisInletislocatedabout100kmnorthwestofVancouverandsnakesnorthwardfromSalteryBayfor75km(Fig.3).ThereisroadaccessasfarasEarlsCoveatthesouthernendoftheInlet,butnoroadsortrailsextendfar-thertothenorth,requiringboataccess.

Seaweed as an exploration medium along inlets on the west coast… continued from page 14

Figure 3: Location of Jervis Inlet. Source Google Maps https://maps.google.ca

Geology ThelowerJervisInletareaisindeeplydissected,mountainouscountryinwhichthemaindeepvalleyshavebeeninvadedbythesea.ForanextensivedistanceupthecoastofBritishColumbiathereisasystemofinletsthatpenetratethemountainsforvaryingdistances,resultingintypicalfjords(Bacon1957). BedrockisprimarilyJurassictoTertiaryquartz-dioriteandgranodioriteoftheCoastPlutonicComplex,overlainlocallybybasalts,andesitesandvolcaniclasticrocksandsomeLowerCretaceousGambierGroupsediments.Quaternarydepositsfillsomevalleys.FordetailsofthebedrockgeologymapofBritishColumbiathereaderisreferredtohttp://www.geosciencebc.com/i/pdf/Maps/NVI/NVI-1-1_geology.pdf Becauseoftheextremeruggedness,sometimesdenserainforest,andoverburdenofvariablethickness,detailofthegeol-ogyispoorlyknown,andtodatelittlehasbeenfoundtosuggestthatthegraniticrocksofthesurveyareawarrantfurtherattentionbyprospectors.However,afewstudieshaveshownthatrocksoftheJervisGroupcontainsmalldepositsofCu,Zn,PbandAu.Localoccurrencesofmolybdenitearereported.Twoaditsintoasmallstockofgabbro-dioriteonthewestsideofUpperJervisInletintersectedquartzveinsandquartz-filledshearzonescontainingAu,Ag,Cu,PbandZnmineralizationandasingle40cmsectionyielded0.72oz/tAuwithminorCo,CoandBi(Laird2008).

Seaweed (Rockweed [Fucus]) Survey TheJervisInletsurveywasconductedinAugustof2013.Sampleswerecollectedfrom47stations,mostlyatintervalsof2-5kmalongtheshore,withadditionalsampleswherestreamswereseendrainingintothesea.Includingcontrols,atotalof60samplesweresubmittedforanalysis.The7splitsofarockweedcontrolsampleshowedthatanalyticalprecisionwasverygoodwithRSDsmostlybetterthan10%,exceptforafewelements(e.g.heavyREEs,Au,Hg,andGe)thathadconcentra-tionsclosetothedetectionlimitsoftheanalyticalmethod,yieldingRSDsmostlybetterthan30%.Similarly,thereproducibil-ityofthefieldandlaboratoryduplicatesvariedfromgoodtoexcellentforalmostallelements.

Results Table1summarizestheelementconcentrationsinthe47samples.Rawdataarelistedinadigitalfile(AppendixA)thatispostedontheAAGwebsite(https://www.appliedgeochemists.org/index.php/publications/explore-newsletter).Background

Page 16: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 16 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

Seaweed as an exploration medium along inlets on the west coast… continued from page 15

GoogleEarthimagesonwhichthedataareplottedinFigures4,5and6areintentionallyprovidedatlowresolutioninordertoshowthecontrastbetweenlandmassandwater.Mostelementsexhibitafairlynormaldistribution,withafewoutliersofwhichthemorenotableisasinglesampleyielding83.8ppbAuwhichismorethan2ordersofmagnitudehigherthantheme-dian.AnalysisoftheashedsampleconfirmedthattheAuishighlyanomalous.Itssourceisunknown.

Table 1: Element concentrations in dry rockweed.

Figure4showsthatAgandAsaremoreconcentratedtowardthesouthernendoftheinletthaninthenorthernarmsug-gestingasourceofmetalenrichmenttotheeast–perhapsfromthevalleyindicated.

continued on page 17

Page 17: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 17

Seaweed as an exploration medium along inlets on the west coast… continued from page 16

Figure 4: Ag and As contents in oven-dried rockweed determined by ICP-MS.

SILVER ppbDry Fucus

Equal number 33 to 63 25 to 33 21 to 25 18 to 21 2 to 18

Valley draining large area

5 km59 ppb

ARSENIC ppmDry Fucus

Equal number 20 to 27 17 to 20 14 to 17 12 to 14 0 to 12

5 km

Valley draining large area

Atthenorthendoftheinlet,wherethereisanabundanceofwaterandsedimentdrainingfromtwolargestreamsthatextendtothenorthandnortheastthereisarelativelystrongsignature,comparedtotherestoftheinlet,ofCu,Mo,Ni,Co(Fig.5)withassociatedFe,REEandUsuggestingapossiblemineralizedsourceupstream.Althoughtheevidenceisscantforpredictingthetypeofmineralization,asimilarsuiteofelementsoccursinironoxidecoppergold(IOCG)deposits.However,Aulevelsarelowintheseaweedfromthisarea.Theotherareaofrelativeenrichmentisinthesouth,coincidentwithsitesofAgandAsenrichmentsouthofthevalleyindicatedonFig.4.

Rheniumconcentrationsinvegetationaretypically<1ppbRe,butinbrownseaweedtheycanbemuchhigher.Highen-richments(thousand-fold)ofRerelativetoseawaterhavebeenreportedalongtheCaliforniacoast,anditwasconcludedthatbrownalgaeactsasabiologicalsinkofReinoceans(Yang1991).ThehighestconcentrationsofRe(upto43ppbRe)areatthesouthernendofJervisInlet.Itissurmisedthatahigherconcentrationoffreshwaterfromstreammeltwatersdrainingfromthemountainsinthenorthernpartoftheinletresultsinstratificationoffreshwateroverthedenserseawater.ThesimilardistributionpatternshownbyNaisfurtherindicationthatthenorthernwatersarelesssalinethanthosetothesouth.SimilarpatternsareexhibitedbySandK.

Summary and Conclusions ThebrownrockweedFucusgrowsinabundanceintheintertidalzonesofthenorthwestshoresofCanadaandtheUSA,andiseasytocollectbyboat.Whereastreamflowsoverorthroughmineralizedbedrock,thewaterscanbecomeslightlyen-richedinelementsassociatedwithsuchmineralization,andmanystreamsemergeintothesoundswheretheirmetalsignaturescanbereadilydetectedintherockweedcloseby.Seaweedanomalouslyenrichedinacommoditymetal(and/oritspathfinderelements)canprovidefocusforamoredetailedfollowupintothemountainstolookforthesource–usingotherprospectingmethodssuchasstreamsediments,streammossmatsorthestreamwatersthemselves.

continued on page 18

Page 18: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 18 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

Seaweed as an exploration medium along inlets on the west coast… continued from page 17

COPPER ppmDry Fucus

Equal number 1.95 to 5.58 1.62 to 1.95 1.45 to 1.62 1.29 to 1.45 0.01 to 1.29

5 km

MOLYBDENUM ppmDry Fucus

Equal number 0.17 to 0.39 0.14 to 0.17 0.13 to 0.14 0.11 to 0.13 0.01 to 0.11

5 km

NICKEL ppmDry Fucus

Equal number 4.9 to 11.6 3.9 to 4.9 3.4 to 3.9 3.2 to 3.4 0.1 to 3.2

5 km

COBALT ppmDry Fucus

Equal number 0.97 to 3.19 0.63 to 0.97 0.51 to 0.63 0.42 to 0.51 0.01 to 0.42

5 km

Figure 5: Cu, Mo, Ni and Co in oven-dried rockweed determined by ICP-MS.

continued on page 19

Page 19: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 19

Seaweed as an exploration medium along inlets on the west coast… continued from page 18

Figure 6: Re, Na, S and K oven-dried rockweed determined by ICP-MS.

RHENIUM ppbDry Fucus

Equal number 25 to 43 21 to 25 16 to 21 8 to 16 1 to 8

5 km

SODIUM %Dry Fucus

Equal number 1.9 to 2.8 1.6 to 1.9 1.4 to 1.6 1.1 to 1.4 0.0 to 1.1

5 km

SULPHUR %Dry Fucus

Equal number 1.88 to 2.59 1.73 to 1.88 1.63 to 1.73 1.50 to 1.63 0.01 to 1.50

5 km

POTASSIUM %Dry Fucus

Equal number 2.25 to 2.76 2.13 to 2.25 1.99 to 2.13 1.70 to 1.99 0.01 to 1.70

5 km

continued on page 20

Page 20: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 20 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

Seaweed as an exploration medium along inlets on the west coast… continued from page 19

Forty-sevensampleswerecollectedfromtheshoresofJervisInletfromwhichdistinctzonesofrelativemetalenrichmentswereidentified:1. Ag,AsandseveralothercommodityandpathfinderelementsontheeasternshorestowardthesouthendoftheInlet;2. Cu,Mo,Ni,CowithassociatedFe,REEandUatthenorthernendoftheInlet,suggestingapossiblemineralizedsource

upstream;3. HighenrichmentsofRe(withcoincidentNa,SandK)thatareprobablyrelatedjusttothewatersalinity,sincebrown

seaweedsareknowntobebiologicalsinksofReinthesea;4. LocalenrichmentsofAuwithcoincidentpathfinderelements.

Acknowledgements WethankBethMcCaffreyforherassistanceinthecollectionofsamples;JohnGravel,SteveAdcockandBethMcClen-aghanforreviewingthisarticle;andgratefullyacknowledgetheassistanceofTerri-LynnFergusonandtheanalyticalsupportprovidedbyAcmeLaboratories/BureauVeritas,Vancouver,BC.

ReferencesBACON,W.R.,1957.GeologyofLowerJervisInlet,BritishColumbia.BritishColumbiaDept.ofMines,Bulletin.39,153pp.BLACK,W.A.P.&MITCHELL,R.L.,1952.Traceelementsinthecommonbrownalgaeandinseawater.Journal Marine Biologists Association of the U.K. 30,575-584.BOLLINGBERG,H.J.,1975.Geochemicalprospectingusingseaweed,shellfishandfish.Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. 39,1567-1570.BOLLINGBERG,H.J.&COOKEJr.,H.R.,1985.Useofseaweedandslopesedimentinfjordprospectingforlead-zinc depositsnearMaarmorilik,westGreenland.Journal of Geochemical Exploration. 23,253-263.BRYAN,G.W.&HUMMERSTONE,L.G.,1973.Brownseaweedsasanindicatorofheavymetalsinestuariesinsouth-west England. Journal of the Marine Biology Association U.K. 53,705-721.CULLINANE,J.P.&WHELAN,P.M.,1982.Copper,cadmiumandzincinseaweedsfromthesouthcoastofIreland.Marine Pollution Bulletin. 13,205-208.DUNN,C.E.,1990.ResultsofabiogeochemicalorientationstudyonseaweedintheStraitofGeorgia,BritishColumbia.In: CurrentResearch,PartE,GeologicalSurveyofCanada,Paper90-1E,347-350.DUNN,C.E.,1998.SeaweedsasHyperaccumulators.In:BROOKS,R.R.(ed)PlantsthatHyperaccumulateHeavyMetals, CABInternational,UKandNY,119-132.DUNN,C.E.,PERCIVAL,J.B.,HALL,G.E.M.&MUDROCH,A.,1993.ReconnaissancegeochemicalstudiesintheHowe Sounddrainagebasin.In:LEVINGS,C.D.,TURNER,R.B.&RICKETTS,B.(eds.)ProceedingsofHoweSoundEnvi- ronmentalScienceWorkshop.CanadianTechnicalReport,FisheriesandAquaticScience.189,89-95.FORSBERG,Å,SÖDERLUND,S.,FRANK,A.,PETERSSON,L.R.&PEDERSEN,M.,1988.Studiesonmetalcontentin the brown seaweed Fucus vesiculosusfromthearchipelagoofStockholm.Environmental Pollution. 49,245-263.FUGE,R.&JAMES,K.H.,1973.Traceelementconcentrationsinbrownseaweeds,CardiganBay,Wales.Marine Chemistry. 1,281-293.FUGE,R.&JAMES,K.H.,1974.TracemetalconcentrationsinFucus fromtheBristolChannel.Marine Pollution Bulletin,5, 9-12.GABRIELSONP.W.,WIDDOWSON,T.B.,LINDSTROM,S.C.,HAWKES,M.W.&SCAGEL,R.F.,2000.Keystothe benthicmarinealgaeandseagrassesofBritishColumbia,SoutheastAlaska,WashingtonandOregon.Phycological Contribution#5,UniversityofBritishColumbia,DepartmentofBotany,189pp.LAIRD,J.,2008.ProspectingreportontheMalibuGoldProperty,JervisInlet,BC,NTS92J4West,15pp. http://aris.empr.gov.bc.ca/ArisReports/30084.PDFMORRIS,A.W.&BALE,A.J.,1975.Theaccumulationofcadmium,copper,manganeseandzincbyFucusvesiculosusinthe BristolChannel.Estuarine Coastal Marine Science 3,153-165.SCAGEL,R.F.,1967.GuidetocommonseaweedsofBritishColumbia.BritishColumbiaProvincialMuseum,Dept.of RecreationandConservation,HandbookNo.27,330pp.SHARP,W.E.&BÖLVIKEN,B.,1979.Brownalgae:asamplingmediumforprospectingfjords.In:WATTERSON,J.R.& THEOBALD,P.K.(eds.).GeochemicalExploration1978,AssociationofExplorationGeochemists,Rexdale,Ontario, 347-356.VINOGRADOV,A.P.,1953.TheElementaryChemicalCompositionofMarineOrganisms.SearsFoundationforMarine Research,YaleUniversity,NewHaven,MemoirII,647pp.YANG,J.S.,1991.Highrheniumenrichmentinbrownalgae:abiologicalsinkofrheniuminthesea?Hydrobiologia,211, 165–170.

Page 21: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 21

Geochemical NuggetsIssues with Modern ICP-MS Gold Data

InrecentyearsboththeYukonGeologicalSurveyandGeoscienceBChaveundertakenthere-analysisofarchivedstreamandlakesedimentsamplescollectedduringtheNationalGeochemicalReconnaissance(NGR)Program.Thisarchivedmate-rialhasbeenanalysedusingadiluteaqua regiadigestionfollowedbyanICP-MSinstrumentalfinish.Theseprogramshaveprovidednewdataforavarietyofimportantpathfinderelementsatimproveddetectionlimitscomparedtowhentheoriginalanalyseswereundertakenupto40yearsago.Thesenewdatahaveallowedforarigorousmultivariatestatisticalanalysisofthedatatobeundertakenwithinthecontextofdrainagecatchments(Mackieet al.,2015)andhavegeneratednewexplorationtargetsthatarecurrentlybeingactivelyexplored. Unfortunately,itisacommonmisconceptionthatthenewICP-MSdataarenecessarilyofsuperiorqualitytothehistoricaldata.Whilethisconclusionisjustifiedforthemajorityofelementsincludedinthetypical51elementanalyticalsuite,itisnottrueforelementssuchasAu,andpartialresultsonlyareprovidedforotherelementssuchasZrandBa.Ajudiciousmergingofbotholdandnewanalyticaldatafromthesehistoricalsamplesiswarranted. ObtainingreproducibleanalysesofAufromstreamsedimentsamplesisparticularlydifficult(seethearticlebyArneandMacFarlaneinEXPLORENo.164usinganexamplefromtheYukon).TheICP-MSre-analysisofsamplesinrecentyearsuseda0.5galiquotof-80mesh(<177micron)samplematerial.TheprecisionoftheAudataisparticularlypoor,inspiteofalowerlimitofdetection(LLD)of0.2ppb. ArecentreviewofICP-MSdatafromtheYukonre-analysisprogramisprovidedbyMackieet al.(2017).Originalrefer-encematerials,fieldduplicatesandblindduplicatesincludedintheoriginalsurveyhavealsobeenre-analysedtoprovidea

comprehensive(albeitpoorlydocumented)setofqualitycontroldata.Thepoorreproducibil-ityoftheICP-MSAudatacanbeillustratedinseveralways.Thecertifiedreferencematerial(CRM)CANMETSTSD-1wasincludedinmanyoftheYukonsurveysre-analysed.IthasaprovisionallycertifiedtotalAucontentof8ppb,sowellabovetheLLDoftheanalyticalmethod.However,thissuiteofCANMETstreamsedi-mentreferencematerials(STSD-1through4)waslikelyneverintendedtoprovidereliableAuvaluesandsoprobablywasnotpulverisedandmixedinthefashionofamodernAuCRM.Inthiswayitmaybemoreanalogouswithatypi-cal stream sediment sample collected from the field.

Atotalof185ICP-MSanalysesofCANMETSTSD-1fromtheYukonNGRprogramgivesaverageandmedianAuvaluesof11.6and4

ppb,respectively.Figure1illustratestheextremerangeofAuvaluesobtained,from1.1to368.7ppb,withacoefficientof variation(CoV)of315%.ClearlynotthesortofperformanceyouwouldwantfromaCRM!Further,asimplescatterplotoforiginalversusanalytical(blind)duplicates(Fig.2)showsaverypoorcorrelation,witharootmeansquaredCoVof64%.BothplotsareindicativeofthepoorprecisionofthenewICP-MSAudataingeneraland emphasises the fact that the data should be usedwithcaution.EvenasamplewithslightlyelevatedbackgroundAuvalues(e.g.STSD-1)canyieldhighlyanomalousAuresultsandrealAuanomaliesmaybemissed.Inthiscasethepath-finderelementswillbemoreinformativethanthedesiredcommodityingeochemicaltargeting.

ReferencesARNE,D.&MACFARLANE,B.,2014.Repro-

ducibilityofgoldanalysesinstreamsedimentsamples from the White Gold District and

Fig. 1. Summary of aqua regia ICP-MS analyses of a 0.5 g aliquot of Canmet STSD-1

Fig. 2. Scatter plot of analytical (blind) duplicates for Au analysed by aqua regia ICP-MS using a 0.5 g aliquot of -80 mesh stream sediment. continued on page 22

Page 22: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 22 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

Issues with Modern ICP-MS Gold Data… continued from page 21

EachyeartheAssociationofAppliedGeochemists(AAG)needsmotivatedandenergeticAAGFellowstostandforelec-tiontothepositionof“OrdinaryCouncillor.”Fortunately,eachyearsomeofourmostoutstandingFellowsareready,willing,andabletomeetthischallenge.However,thisyearI’msendingthistoALLMEMBERS,toencouragethoseMembersthathavetheexperienceandenthusiasmtobeinvolved,toconvertyourmembershipstatusandlooktomakeabiggercontributiontotheAAG(seethewebsitefordetails). ThisistheannualremindertoAAGFellows(andMembersthatcouldbecomeFellows)thatweneedyourparticipationon Council. It is our sincere hope that this email might entice more people to step forward for election to this important posi-tion. IfyouarenoteligibletobecomeaFellow,butwanttobemoreinvolved,pleasesendmeanemailmessageaswearelook-ingtogetmoreofourjuniormembersactiveintheAAGandotheropportunitieswillbecomingavailable. Councillor Job Description TheAAGBy-lawsstatethat“theaffairsoftheAssociationshallbemanagedbyitsboardofdirectors,tobeknownasitsCouncil.”TheaffairsmanagedbyCouncilvaryfromreviewingandrankingproposalstohostourbiennialSymposiumtoapprovingapplicationfornewmembershiptodevelopingmarketingstrategiesforsustainingandgrowingourmembership.TheseaffairsarediscussedanddecisionsmadeatCouncilteleconferencesusuallyheld3-4timesperyear.Eachteleconferencelastsabout1hour.Inaddition,thereisoftenarunningemaildiscussionaboutaselectedissueortwobetweeneachteleconfer-ence.Soforacommitmentofabout5hoursofyourtimeperyear,youcanhelpinfluencethefutureofyourAssociation.Ifyouwanttospendmorethantheminimumtimerequired,thereisplentyofopportunitytodosothroughcommitteeassignmentsandvoluntaryeffortsthatgreatlybenefittheAssociation. Qualifications and length of term TheonlyqualificationforservingasCouncilloristobeaFellowingoodstandingwiththeAssociation.PleasenotethedifferencebetweenbeingaMemberofAAGandbeingaFellow.AFellowisrequiredtohavemoretrainingandprofessionalexperiencethanaMember.ConsulttheAAGwebsite,Membershipsection,forfurtherdetails.IfyouarenotcurrentlyaFel-lowandhaveaninterestinservingonCouncil,pleasegothroughtherelativelypainlessprocessofconvertingtoFellowshipstatus in AAG. EachCouncillorservesatermoftwoyearsandcanthenstandforelectiontoasecondtwo-yearterm.TheBy-lawsforbidservingmorethantwoconsecutiveterms,althoughsomeonewhohasservedtwoconsecutivetermscanstandforelectionagainaftersittingoutforatleastoneyear.ElectionsareusuallyheldinOct-Novoftheyearforatermcoveringthefollowingtwoyears.OurnextelectionwillbeinOctober-November2017forthetermof2018-2019. How to get on the ballot IfyouareinterestedinsubmittingyournameforconsiderationforelectiontoAAGCouncil,simplyexpressyourinter-esttotheAAGSecretary(DaveSmith,email:[email protected])byOctober15,2017andincludeashort(nomorethan250words)summaryofyourcareerexperience.Thissummaryshouldincludethefollowing: •Yourname •YearthatyoubecameaFellowofAAG •Earthsciencedegreesobtained,yearofgraduationofeach,andinstitutionofeach •Employment—listmajoremployersandstateyearsworkedforeach,e.g.1980-1990,andtypeofwork •PositionheldaspartofAAGorotherpastcontributionstoAAG •1-2sentencesaboutyourprofessionalexperiencesinappliedgeochemistryAllthatisaskedisthatyoubringenergyandideastoCouncilandarewillingtoshareinmakingdecisionsthatwillcarrytheAssociationforwardintoasuccessfulfuture.Welookforwardtohearingfromyou. Ryan Noble,President, Email: [email protected]

AAG Councillor Elections

DawsonRange,YukonTerritory,Canada. EXPLORE, No. 164,p.1-10.MACKIE,R.A.,ARNE,D.C.&BROWN,O.,2015.Enhancedinterpretationofregionalstreamsedimentgeochemistryfrom Yukon:catchmentbasinanalysisandweightedsumsmodelling.YukonGeologicalSurvey,OpenFile2015-10.MACKIE,R.A.,ARNE,D.C.&PENNIMPEDE,C.,2017.Assessmentofregionalstreamsedimentcatchmentbasinand geochemicaldataquality.YukonGeologicalSurvey,OpenFile2017-4,29p.Acknowledgment ThecompiledqualitycontroldatashownherewerekindlyprovidedbyWayneJackaman.Dennis Arne, CSA Global Pty. Ltd.

Page 23: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 23

Recently Published in Elements Volume13,nos.3and4

AAG Regional Report: Ireland and United Kingdom, June 2017

InIrelandthenationalTellusprogramme,acombinedregionalbaselinesurveyofsurfacegeochemistryandairborneradiometricandtraditionalgeophysics,iswellunderway.TheIrishgovernmentisbackingacceleratedcoverageofthewholecountry,andtheregional-scalesurveysofstreamsediment,streamwaterandsoilinorganicgeochemistryarenowcompleteacrossaboutonethirdofthecountry.GeologicalSurveyIrelandareundertakingthesurveystorecognisedhighstandards,applyingmulti-elementanalyticaltechniquesandrigorousqualitycontrol.TheworkisinconjunctionwithlabsinIrelandandintheUK.Theprogrammeisconcurrentlyfundingexternalresearchprojectsinareassuchasagriculturaldataapplications,understandingprospectivityanddepositmodelling,andisassistingsurveygeologistsinrevisingthestategeologicalmaps.Theprojectisreleasingitsdatafreeofchargeandfreelytoall,asitbecomesavailable.Seemoreatwww.tellus.ie,includinglinkstothebook‘Unearthed’whichstoriessomeoftheimpactsfeltfromsurveyresultstodate. ThegeosciencessectorinIrelandhasseenahugeboostinthelastyear,withtheIrishCentreforResearchinAppliedGeosciences‘iCRAG’nowsupportingdoctorateandpostdoctoralresearchinappliedgeochemistry.Earlycareerscientistsareworkingontraditionalsubjectssuchasenergy,groundwaterquality,criticalrawmaterialsandmineraldeposits,aswellasthesociallicensetooperateandpublicperceptionofthegeosciencessector.Ingeochemistrytheresearchareasincludesedi-mentandoreprovenanceandisotopicanalyticalapplications.Seewww.icrag-centre.orgformore. TheBritishGeologicalSurveyandUniversityofNottinghamhavelaunchedtheirCentreforEnvironmentalGeochemis-try,ahubcombininginorganic,organicandisotopegeochemistryanalyticalfacilitieswithdomesticandinternationalappliedresearchprojects.www.environmentalgeochemistry.orgdetailstheirwork. ThegeologicalsurveysinIrelandandBritainarecontributingtoaEuropeanUnionledconsortiumoncriticalmaterialsandmineralsdatabases,theMinerals4EUProject.AimingtoenhancemineralsinformationandsupportEuropeanmineralsdevelopment.Seewww.minerals4eu.euforupdates. TheUKandIrelandminingsectorsareprogressinganumberofprospects.SRKConsultingUKLimitediscurrentlyas-sistingDalradianGoldLimitedwithgeochemicalskillsrelatedtothedevelopmentoftheCurraghinaltgoldprojectinNorth-ernIreland.SRKhavebeenresponsibleforsupervisionofbaselinesamplingandgeochemicalassessmentaswellaslaboratoryandonsitetestingofrockweathering.Thisworkwillbeusedinsupportofengineeringandenvironmentalstudies.DrakelandsMine(formerlyHermerdon)fortungstenandtininCornwallisnowreopenedbyWolfMineralsLimited.ThiscoincidedwithlatestgeochemicalmappingcompletedbytheBritishGeologicalSurveyinsouthwestEngland.TheBolidenTaraMineintheIrishMidlandsisactivelyexpanding.UptakeofexplorationlicencesinIrelandisgoingstrongwithlead-zinc,gold,copper,platinum and lithium targets.

Kate Knights Geological Survey of Ireland; Email: [email protected]

Rock and Mineral Coatings: Records of Climate Change, Pollution, and Life TheJuneeditionofElementsisanintriguingonethatlooksatrockandmineralcoatingsandhowtheyretainarecordofpastclimates,beusedinarcheology,ormayholdevidenceoflifeonMars.TheAAGnewsinthisissuecontainsanupdateonGEEAbyKurtKyserandintroducesCo-editor-in-Chief,BennedettoDeVivo,aswellasasummaryofthearticleon“Theuseofautomatedindicatormineralanalysisinthesearchformineralization–Anextgenerationdriftprospectingtool”thatappearedtheMarchissueofExplore.

Boron: Light and Lively The August edition of Elements is dedicated to all aspects of the element boron.Inthisissue,AAGnewsconsistsofamessagefromthePresidentandanabstractfromtheJuneEXPLOREarticleentitled“EvidenceofGeother-malActivityNeartheNazkoVolcanicCone,BritishColumbia,Canada,fromGroundandSurfaceWaterChemistry”.

Dennis Arne, CSA Global Pty Ltd; Email: [email protected]

Page 24: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 24 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

Thelatestcontentisnowavailableat:http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/currentMay2017;Vol.17,2

Thematic set article: IAGS Tuscon 2015IntroductiontoIAGSTuscon2015volumeRobertBowellGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,v.17:61,firstpublishedonMay16,2017,doi:10.1144/geochem2017-003http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/17/2/61.extract LithogeochemicalclassificationofigneousrocksusingStreckeisenternarydiagramsCliffStanleyGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,v.17:63-91,firstpublishedonMay16,2017,doi:10.1144/geochem2016-463http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/17/2/63.abstract ArsenicandmercurycontaminationrelatedtohistoricalgoldminingintheSierraNevada,CaliforniaCharles N. AlpersGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,v.17:92-100,firstpublishedonMay16,2017,doi:10.1144/geochem2016-018http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/17/2/92.abstract Assessmentofsupergeneuranium-vanadiumanomalies,MeobBaydeposit,NamibiaR.J.BowellandA.A.DaviesGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,v.17:101-112,firstpublishedonApril4,2017,doi:10.1144/geochem2015-406http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/17/2/101.abstract Geochemicalpredictionofarsenicattenuationfrominfiltratedheapleachdrainage,DaisyMine,NevadaR.J.Bowell,J.Declercq,R.Warrender,A.Prestia,J.V.Parshley,andJ.R.BarberGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,v.17:113-123,firstpublishedonDecember8,2016,doi:10.1144/geochem2016-423http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/17/2/113.abstract MetalmigrationattheDeGrussaCu-Ausulphidedeposit,WesternAustralia:Soil,vegetationandgroundwaterstudiesR.R.P.Noble,R.R.Anand,D.J.Gray,andJ.S.CleverleyGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,v.17:124-142,firstpublishedonDecember16,2016,doi:10.1144/geochem2016-416http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/17/2/124.abstract Integratedstudiesofsoil,termites,vegetationandgroundwatertounderstandmetalmigrationattheKintyreUdeposits,Western AustraliaR.R.P.Noble,A.D.Stewart,G.T.Pinchand,T.C.Robson,andR.R.AnandGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,v.17:143-158,firstpublishedonFebruary16,2017,doi:10.1144/geochem2016-439http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/17/2/143.abstract Urbangeochemistry:SisakinCroatia,along-lastinghistorical,urbanandindustrialcityAjkaŠorša,GoranDurn,JosipHalamić,StjepanHusnjak,VesnicaGarašić,andMartaMileusnićGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,v.17:159-163,firstpublishedonAugust23,2016,doi:10.1144/geochem2015-395http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/17/2/159.abstract DendrochemistryandsoilclaygeochemistryappliedtoexplorationfordeepUmineralizationattheHallidayLakeProspect,AthabascaBasin,CanadaP.Stewart,T.K.Kyser,D.Griffiths,andL.LahusenGeochemistry:Exploration,Environment,Analysis,v.17:164-181,firstpublishedonDecember13,2016,doi:10.1144/geochem2015-386http://geea.lyellcollection.org/content/17/2/164.abstract

Geochemistry: Exploration, Environment, Analysis

Page 25: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 25

Initiatedin2011andremodelledin2015,theAssociationofAppliedGeochemist’sStudentSupportProgramlinksap-pliedgeochemistrystudentswithanalyticallaboratoriestohelpstudentsdefraythecostofacquiringgeochemicaldataassoci-atedwiththesiswork.AAGactsasanintermediarybetweenappliedgeochemistrystudentsandparticipatinglaboratoriesbyassessingapplicationsandrecommendingthosewithmerittosupportinglaboratoriesforin-kindsupportintermsofsampleanalysis.Inturn,studentsareobligedtopublishtheirresultsandincludeanacknowledgementtotheAssociationandthesup-portinglaboratory. Theprogramhasgraduallyexpanded,intermsofboththenumberofparticipatinglaboratories,andthenumberofstu-dentsreceivingsupport(Table1).Sixlaboratoriesarenowinvolvedwiththeprogram,Actlabs,ALS,BVMinerals(Perth),BVMinerals(Vancouver),Intertek-GenalysisandLabWest.Acheckoflaboratorywebsitesshowsthattheyofferarangeofana-lyticalservicessuitabletobothmineralexplorationandenvironmentalassessment.ThelikelihoodofanapplicationreceivingsupportfrombothAAGandanyparticularlaboratoryisincreasedifareasonableamountofworkisrequested.Inmanycases,thein-kindsupportisacomplementtodatageneratedfromothersources,ratherthanthecompleteanalyticalrequirementsof the thesis. Thecapacityoflaboratoriestosupportthistypeofprogramisinpartdeterminedbythestateofthemineralexplorationindustry.Accordingly,AAGacceptsthatthelevelofsupportforitsprogramcanfluctuate,withnoguaranteethatanapplica-tionendorsedbyAAGwillresultinworkbeingcarriedoutbyaparticipatinglaboratory.However,thegrowthinthenumberofprojectsbeingsupported(Table1)showsthatlaboratorieshavecommittedtothisprogram.Theprogramnowsupportsadiversityofresearchprojects,intermsofgeographicaldistributionofrecipients,anddiversityofthesistopics.EarlyrecipientsofsupporthavefulfilledtheirobligationsbypublishingtheresultsoftheirworkwithappropriaterecognitiontothesupportinglaboratoryandAAG. About15yearsago,theAEGbecametheAAG,emphasisingtheAssociation’srecognitionoftheenvironmentalaswellastheexplorationapplicationofgeochemistry.Althoughthemajorityofsupportedapplicationsarerelatedtomineralexplo-ration,arecentadditiontotheAAG’sStudentSupportProgramisSoniaMulongo’sMScthesisworkontheenvironmentalchemistryofsoilsinLubumbashi,DemocraticRepublicoftheCongo. ThisAAGprogramnotonlyaimstofosterthescienceofappliedgeochemistry,butalsooffersappliedgeochemistrystudentstheopportunitytolearnthroughpersonalexperienceaboutgeneratinggeochemicaldata.Allparticipatinglaborato-riesarestaffedbyskilledanalystswhocanprovidevaluableadviceonthemostsuitableanalyticalapproach,itselfavaluablecontributiontothethesiswork.TheapplicationformandconditionsofsupportforthisprogramcanbefoundontheStudentspageontheAAGwebsite(www.appliedgeochemists.org).

Paul Morris,AAG Education Committee; Email: [email protected]

AAG’s Student Support Program

Student Institution Country Date Degree Thesis Title Supporting Laboratory Status Publication

Xin Du University of Western Australia Australia 2011 PhD Particle size fractionation and chemical speciation Chemical Geology, 330-331, of REE in a lateritic weathering profile in Western Australia Intertek-Genalysis Completed 101-115 (2012); EXPLORE 157.Andrew Lucas University of Western Australia Australia 2011 PhD Evaluating the diffusive gradients in thin films technique for the detection of multi-element anomalies in soils Intertek-Genalysis Completed EXPLORE 161, 1-15 (2013)Marcus Phua University of Melbourne Australia 2014 MSc Petrogenesis of the gabbroic intrusions hosting magmatic Ni-Cu-PGE sulphides at Melba Flats, western Tasmania BV Minerals (Ultratrace) Completed SEG conference abstract, 2015Enerst Tata University of Buea Cameroon 2014 PhD Felsic plutonism, hydrothermal altertaion and granite- relatred gold mineralization, Batouri gold district, SE Cameroon: geochronology and geochemical constraints Intertek-Genalysis Submitted to GEEAMatthew Bodnar University of British Columbia Canada 2016 MSc Mapping chemical dispersion above a buried VMS in a till covered terrain, Lara VMS deposit, Vancouver Island, Canada ALS Victor Vincent Modibbo Adama University Nigeria 2016 BSc Geological investigation of sediment hosted sulphide of Technology deposits of Azara-Akiri-Wuse Area, Northcentral Nigeria. ALS Pradip Singh Potosino Institute of Scientific Mexico 2016 PhD Nature of petrological, geochemical, geochronological and Technological Research settings and evolution of the Bundelkhand Greenstone Complexes, Bundelkhand Craton, India ALS Hamid Zekri Ifsan University Iran 2016 PhD Geochemical variation in regolith and anomaly detection over the Pitchi blind Pb-zn deposit Actlabs Anthony Chukwu University of Nigeria Nigeria 2017 PhD Petrology of Precambrian basement rocks and Ta-Nb pegmatite mineralization in Akwanga areas, northcentral Nigeria Intertek-Genalysis Chinedu Ibe University of Nigeria Nigeria 2017 MSc Geochemical studies on Precambrian basement complex rocks around Katchuan Ode, southeast of Ogoja, southeastern Nigeria BV Minerals (Ultratrace)

Sonia Mulono University of Lubumbashi Dem. Rep. 2017 MSc Mining exploitation impact on the soil of Lubumbashi of the Congo city: an environmental approach BV Minerals (Ultratrace)

Page 26: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 26 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

FellowsFellowsarevotingmembersoftheAssociation.AAGmembersandnon-membersmaybecomeFellowsatanytime.SeetheAAG website to download a membership conversion form.

Helen Waldron40GriffithWayThornlie,WAAUSTRALIA6108Membershipnumber#3347

MembersMembersarenon-votingmembersoftheAssociation.Membersmustbeactivelyengagedinthefieldofappliedgeochemistryatthetimeoftheirapplicationandforatleasttwoyearspriortothedateofjoining. Mr.ZhengYangInstituteofGeophysicalandGeochemicalExploration84JinguangRd.Langfang,Hebei13CHINA065000Membership#4358 Mr.Shi-qiTangInstituteofGeophysicalandGeochemicalExploration84JinguangRoadLangfang,Hebei13CHINA065000Membership#4359 Student MembersStudentMembersarestudentsthatareenrolledinanapprovedcourseofinstructionortraininginafieldofpureorappliedscienceatarecognizedinstitution.StudentmemberspayminimalmembershipfeestobelongtotheAssociation.

SeanA.MundreonStudent,BrockUniversity64TupperDriveThorold,OntarioCANADAL2V4C8Membership#4340

GabrielLauzon6700BoulevarddesmilleilesLaval,QCCANADAH7B1C9Membership#4357 Philip DalhofGraduate StudentColoradoStateUniversity648BrewerDriveFortCollins,COUNITEDSTATES80524Membership#4361

Dr. Yulia UvarovaCSIRO: Principal Research Scientist26DickPerryAve.Kensington,WAAUSTRALIA6151Email:[email protected]#4318

Alicia VerbeetenHarris PlaceKalgoorlie,WAAUSTRALIA6430Membership#4360 LindaM.GlassGlass Geological ConsultingP.O.Box248Samford,QLD4520AUSTRALIAMembership#4362

AAG New Members

Association of Applied GeochemistsStudent Membership

$10 US

Encourage a student to join!

Page 27: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 27

BARRINGER - THE BOOKExploration, Remote Sensing, Environment, Analysis, SecurityThe 1960’s and 70’s were marked by an explo-sion in mineral exploration and remote sensing technology. A leader throughout this period was Dr. Anthony (Tony) Barringer and his team at Barringer Research Ltd. (BRL). The highly suc-cessful airborne geophysical methods created at BRL are well known while the contributions to exploration geochemistry and many other fields are not. This book documents the many advances in geochemical theory, as well as the ground, airborne and remote sensing techniques plus analytical methods that were conceived and developed under the leadership of Tony Barrin-ger. Innovative concepts backed by pioneering research funded by BRL on the movement of metals in rock, soil and vegetation remain im-portant areas of investigation. Tony Barringer’s ability to bring together a diverse team includ-ing geologists, geochemists and physicists with electrical, optical and aeronautical engineers under one roof, provide leadership, a highly stimulating environment and financial support, was truly remarkable. This led to ground break-ing advances in a number of different fields, including: exploration geochemistry for miner-als and oil and gas; environmental monitoring from the ground, aircraft and space; and civilian and armed forces security. The underlying scientific principles for many of the inventions, now upgraded with modern electronics, are still considered state of the art. One of the many inventions from the BRL “incubator” described in this book is Ionscan, the drug and explosive screening device used in most airports today, which was conceived and developed by BRL in conjunction with technology for the detection of mineral deposits.

Hard Cover book, including shipping US$ 68.00*, **Soft Cover book, including shipping US$ 58.00*, **International shipping is by surface mail, for air mail please add US$ 20.00/ volume

*Note, for US$48 and US$38 or $C65 and $C55 respectively (to avoid shipping charges) there will be limited number of both the hard and soft cover books available the MDRU booth at Roundup in Vancouver (first come first served) or directly available in Van-couver for a limited time from [email protected] **Note there will also a very limited number at the MDRU both at the PDAC. To reserve your copy for pick up at the MDRU booth please email [email protected] at the latest by Feb 22nd.

HOW TO ORDER:ASSOCIATION OF APPLIED GEOCHEMISTS. All payments must be made in one of the following formats: bank draft, personal cheque (drawn on a US$ account), or money order made out to the Association of Applied Geochemists, sent toAAG Business Office, P.O. Box 26099, 72 Robertson Rd. Nepean, ON, Canada K2H 9R0Tel: 613-828-0199 Fax: 613-828-9288Email: [email protected]

Do you need a receipt? Include self-addressed envelope and US $2.00, otherwise your cancelled cheque or bank statement is your receipt.

Is your cheque drawn on a bank outside the U.S.A. or Canada? If yes, add US $15.00

Page 28: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 28 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

continued on page 29

TheAAGhaspartneredwiththeResourcesforFutureGenerations(RFG)2018ConferencetobeheldinVancouver,BC,Canadabetween16-21June2018toholdthe28thIAGSsymposiumasanintegralcomponentoftheRFG18conference.The4-dayconferencecoveringEnergy,Minerals,WaterandtheEarthisexpectedtoattractmorethan5,000peopletoVancouvertoattendtheconference.ThiswillprovidetheAAGwiththeopportunitytoshowcasethroughspecificAAGsessions,theadvancementsandapplicationsofgeochemistryinthespheresofexplorationandenvironment. ElevenspecificAAGappliedgeochemistrysessionswillbechairedbyAAGmembers.Detailsofthesessionsareprovidedbelow.ItisanticipatedthatthecallforabstractswillopenonAugust1,2017andwillcloseonJanuary15,2018.SubmissionsofabstractstotheAAGsessions,aswellasregistration,shortcourse,andfieldtripselection,willbehandledthroughtheRFG2018websiteathttp://rfg2018.org.Theabstractsubmissionprocesswillallowtheselectionofthespecificsessionsforsubmissions. AAG members are encouraged to submit abstracts to the appropriate AAG sessions. Registration at the conference will allow AAG members full access to the complete RFG18 technical sessions. A series of ShortCoursesandFieldTripsarealsobeingcompiledbyAAGforinclusioninRFG18;furtherinformationwillbeprovidedinthe near future.

AAG Sessions at the RFG18 Conference:

Analytical Technology in the search for minerals: Space to the Lab to the field.-Recent,experimentalandproposeddevelop-mentsintechnologyasapplicabletothediscoveryofnewmineraldepositsandenvironmentalstudieswithemphasisonchemi-cal,mineralogical,isotopicandspectralanalyticaltechniquesincludingremotesensing,laboratoryanalysisandfieldanalysis.

Big-Data: Integration, Management and Regional Scale Surveys-Explorationcompanies,geologicalsurveysandminingcompaniestypicallyowngigabytestoterabytesofgeochemicalinformationwithassociatedattributes,muchofwhichispoorlyexaminedbeyondsimplenumericaltreatmentsforlimitedcomponents.Recentadvancesinthetreatmentofdatasetsusingadvancedtechniques,includingHyper-cubeamongstotherswilldemonstratethroughcasestudiesandresearchexamples,howtoextractmaximumvaluefromregionalscaleanddetailedminescaledatasets.

Exploration Case studies - Out of the Box Concepts, methodologies and practices-Casestudiesofmineralexploration,bothpositiveandnegative,withanemphasisonapplicationofgeochemistry.Inparticular,thoseemployingout-of-the-boxcon-cepts,modelsormethodologiesthatdemonstratenewadvancesinmineralexploration,discovery,riskabatementandcostreduction.

Exploration Undercover - Techniques, Technology and Strategy-Demandsformineralresourcescontinuetoaffectsocietywithhighmetalprices,skillshortages,governmentalpolicychanges,andbillionsofdollarsinresourceinvestment.Thediscov-eryofnewmineralresourcesrequiresincreasingrisk,increasingcosts,andincreasinglyeffectiveexplorationtechniques.Ex-plorationactivityitselfisincreasinglyfocusedindifficultlocalitiessuchasthosethatlackoutcrop,arecoveredbytransportedsurficialmaterialsoraredeeperinthecrust.Asaresult,thedemandtodevelopnewandimprovedgeochemicalexplorationtechniquesandstrategiesishigherthanever.Thissessionwillincludepapersreviewingstateofartprogress,newconcepts,technologies,casehistoriesandexplorationstrategicpathsaimedatdiscovery.

Footprints of giant orebodies - Mineralogical, Spectral and Geochemical vectors to Discovery - Across the globe there hasoverthelast5yearsbeenseveralmajorresearchinitiativesdirectedatdevelopingfullyintegratedgeological,mineral- ogical,chemicalandgeophysicalfootprintsoflargeorebodiesbeyondvisiblealterationtosocalledcrypticeffects(e.gAMI-RA,CMIC).Thissessionisintendedtodrawtogetherkeypapershighlightingintegratedmodelsandtheirapplicationtoexploration.

Geometallurgy: Exploration-Evaluation-Exploitation-Environment -Thissessionwillexaminetherollofgeometallurgyandgeochemistrythroughthecompletebirth-cradle-gravecycleofanorebody,documentinghowit'susecaneffectivelyreduceriskandcostananearlystageofexplorationthroughevaluationandminingthroughtotheimpactofgeometallurgyonwastedisposalandmineclosure.Thesessionwillcompriseakeynoteplusselectedcasestudiesoftheapplicationofgeometallurgy,in particular novel or unconventional applications in natural resources.

Hydrocarbons in the exploration for metaliferous and none-metaliferous deposits-Hydrocarbonshaveshownconsiderablepotentialasanexplorationtoolforthediscoveryofmineraldeposits,howevernotwithoutcontroversy.Throughcasestudiesandrecenttechnologicaladvances,thissessionwillpresentrecentresultsontheapplicationofhydrocarbonsinmineralexplo-ration.

Hydrogeochemistry: Environment and Exploration-Applicationofwatergeochemistryasbothatooltosearchforwaterresourcesandmineralresourcesinadditiontothegeochemistryofcontaminatedwatersandtheirmitigation.Thesessionwillcoverresearchanddevelopmentofnewtechniquesandtechnologiesinadditiontoapplicationcasehistoriesofhydrogeo-chemistryinexplorationandremediation.

28th IAGS and Resources for Future Generations 2018

Page 29: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 29

28th IAGS and Resources for Future Generations 2018… continued from page 28

Micro to Macro-biogeochemistry: Exploration, Processing, remediation and the Environment -Biologicalsystemsplayaincreasingsignificantroleinmineralexploration,mineralprocessingandsiteremediationexploitingnaturalinteractionsandprocesses between geological materials and biological processes. This session will present recent progress and new innovations in the utilisation of natural processes in resource development.

Mineral Exploration in Extreme Environments-ExplorationGeochemistryinhyper-arid,tundra,tropical,highaltitude,sub-oceanicandextra-planetaryrequiresitsowntechniquesandtechnologies.Thissessionwillbedevotedtoresearch,develop-mentandcase-historiesofmineralexplorationinthesediverse,significantlymoreimportant,yetproblematicenvironmentswithanemphasisonappliedgeochemistry.

Stable and Radiogenic Isotope systems: Applications in Exploration and the Environment-Modernanalyticaltechnologyhassubstantiallyreducedthecostofisotopicanalysistothelevelofroutineanalysis,inadditionnewsystemshavebecomecom-merciallyviableandtheknowledgebaseandunderstandingofarangeofisotopesystemsisnowwelldocumented.Thissessionwilldemystifytheapplicationofisotopesinexplorationandtheenvironmentthroughsolidcasestudiesdemonstratingtheirvalueaddedbenefitintegratedwithotherinformationinthedecisionprocess.

ARD in Mining and Civil Construction.Acidrockdrainage(ARD)andmetalleaching(ML)arepotentialhazardsthatshouldbeassessedatanearlystageinplanningmajorexcavationsforresourcedevelopmentorcivilconstruction.Potentiallyacidgeneratingmaterialscanbepredictedbasedonstaticandkinetictesting.ThisSessionwillpresentcasestudiesbothex-perimentalandfield,demonstratingpracticalmitigationandmanagementofARDinminingandconstruction.

Peter WinterburnNSERC/Acme Labs/Bureau Veritas Minerals Industrial Research Chair in Exploration Geochemistry,Mineral Deposits Research UnitUniversity of British Columbia; Email: [email protected]

Page 30: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 30 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

Hydrothermal Ore Deposits Course

The Departments of Earth Sciences at the University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Canada and Laurentian University, Sudbury, Canada are pleased to announce the 2017 Joint Modular Course in HYDROTHERMAL ORE DEPOSITS, which will be held at the University of Ottawa October 21-28, 2017.

The course will feature 4 two-day modules to be presented by Dr. Mark Hannington (University of Ottawa), Dr. Daniel Kontak (Laurentian University), Dr. Matthew Leybourne (Laurentian University), Dr. Richard Goldfarb (Consultant), Dr. Jeremy Richards (Laurentian University), Dr. David Burrows (Vale), Dr. J. Bruce Gemmell (CODES), Dr. Steve Piercey (Memorial University) and Dr. Robert Seal (USGS).

Oct 21 & 22 A Practical Guide to the Ore Elements, Minerals and Fluids Oct 23 & 24 Orogenic Gold Deposits and Porphyry-Related Systems Oct 25 & 26 Epithermal Systems and Iron Oxide-Copper-Gold Deposits Oct 27 & 28 Volcanogenic Massive Sulfides and Ores in Surficial Environments

The course is open to graduate students from any university as well as professionals in industry. Graduate students registered in the course may be eligible for credit toward their degree programs. Industry participants may receive credit toward professional training requirements.

More information is available at https://science.uottawa.ca/earth/short_course

Exploration ‘17 October 21 to 25, 2017, Toronto, Canada

Exploration ‘17 is the sixth of the very successful series of DMEC decennial mining exploration conferences, which have been held in the seventh year of every decade starting in 1967. The theme of the Exploration ’17 confer-ence is “Integrating the Geosciences: The Challenge of Discovery”, featuring a multi-national, multi-disciplinary technical programme, exhibition, work-shops and field schools.

www.exploration17.com/About.aspx

Program Schedule

Oral presentations are by invitation onlyhttp://www.exploration17.com/Program-Schedule.aspx

Page 31: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

EXPLORE NUMBER 176 PAGE 31

CALENDAR OF EVENTSInternational,national,andregionalmeetingsofinteresttocolleaguesworkinginexploration,environmentalandotherareasofappliedgeochemistry.Theseeventsalsoappearon

the AAG web page at: www.appliedgeochemists.org.

Pleaseletusknowofyoureventsbysendingdetailsto:Steve Amor

GeologicalSurveyofNewfoundlandandLabradorP.O.Box8700,St.John’s,NL,Canada,A1B4J6

Email: [email protected] Tel:+1-709-729-1161

continued on page 32

201717-20SEPTEMBER SEG2017.BeijingChina.Website:www.seg2017.org/17-22SEPTEMBER 28thInternationalMeetingonOrganicGeochemistry.FlorenceItaly.Website: www.houseofgeoscience.org/imog/17-22SEPTEMBER AppliedIsotopeGeochemistry12.CopperMountainResortCAUSA.Website: www.iagc-society.org/AIG.html18-19 SEPTEMBER 19thInternationalConferenceonGasGeochemistry.RomeItaly.Website: www.waset.org/conference/2017/09/rome/ICGG18-22SEPTEMBER 11thInternationalKimberliteConference.GaboroneBotswana.Website:www.11ikc.com24-29SEPTEMBER 23rdInternationalSymposiumonEnvironmentalBiogeochemistry.PalmCoveQLDAustralia. Website:www.iseb23.info3-5OCTOBER WilliamSmithMeeting2017:PlateTectonicsat50.LondonEngland.Website:www.geolsoc.org.uk/wsmith179-10OCTOBER AnnualInternationalConferenceonGeological&EarthSciences.Singapore. Website: www.geoearth.org9-13OCTOBER 14thInternationalSymposiumonBiomineralization.TsukubaJapan. Website:www.biomin14.jp21-25OCTOBER Exploration‘17.TorontoONCanada.Website:www.exploration17.com21-28OCTOBER Shortcourse-GeochemistryofHydrothermalOreDeposits.OttawaONCanada. Website:science.uottawa.ca/earth/short_course22-25OCTOBER GSAAnnualMeeting.SeattleWAUSA.Website:www.geosociety.org/meetings/2017/31OCTOBER- 10thFennoscandianExplorationandMining.LeviFinland.Website:fem.lappi.fi/en2NOVEMBER 6-7NOVEMBER JanetWatsonMeeting2017:TheFutureofContaminatedLandRiskAssessment;stakeholderperspectives. LondonEngland.Website:www.geolsoc.org.uk/jwatson176-11NOVEMBER 9thInternationalConferenceonGeomorphology.NewDelhi,India.Website:www.icg2017.com6-11NOVEMBER ShortCourse:FluidsintheEarth.NaplesItaly.Website:tinyurl.com/yb6qf6o717-18NOVEMBER15thSwissGeoscienceMeeting.DavosSwitzerland.Website:geoscience-meeting.ch/sgm201723-26NOVEMBER InternationalConferenceonComputationalChemistryandToxicologyinEnvironmentalScience.Taichung, Taiwan.Website:theochem.wikispaces.com3-8DECEMBER AmericanExplorationandMiningAssociationAnnualMeeting.Sparks/RenoNVUSA. Website:tinyurl.com/m99kskj7-8DECEMBER 19thInternationalConferenceonNuclearandEnvironmentalRadiochemicalAnalysis.SydneyNSW Australia.Website:tinyurl.com/jsh9gsu

20188-13JANUARY 2018WinterConferenceonPlasmaSpectrochemistry.AmeliaIslandFLUSA.Website:tinyurl.com/mrvbqwa22-25JANUARY MineralExplorationRoundup2014.VancouverBCCanada.Website:roundup.amebc.ca11-16FEBRUARY 2018OceanSciencesMeeting.PortlandORUSA.Website:osm.agu.org/201818-21FEBRUARY AustralianExplorationGeoscienceConference.SydneyNSWAustralia.Website:www.aegc2018.com.au4-7MARCH Prospectors and Developers Association of Canada Annual Convention. Toronto ON Canada. Website:www.pdac.ca/convention8-13APRIL EuropeanGeosciencesUnionGeneralAssembly2018.ViennaAustria.Website:www.egu2018.eu2-4MAY InternationalConferenceonGeology&EarthScience.RomeItaly.Website:http://geoscience.madridge.com

Page 32: Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the ......Finally, a correlation coefficient that tells the geochemical truth EXPLORE NEWSLETTER WISHES TO THANK OUR CORPORATE SPONSORS

PAGE 32 NUMBER 176 EXPLORE

CALENDAR OFEVENTS... continued from page 31

16-21JUNE ResourcesforFutureGenerations(Energy,Minerals,WaterandtheEarth).VancouverBCCanada. Website:rfg2018.org.SeeannouncementincurrentissueofExplore.8-13JULY Geoanalysis2018.SydneyNSWAustralia.Website:2018.geoanalysis.info 12-17AUGUST Goldschmidt2018.BostonMAUSA.Website:goldschmidt.info/201813-17AUGUST 22ndGeneralMeetingoftheInternationalMineralogicalAssociation.MelbourneVICAustralia. Website:www.ima2018.com28-31AUGUST 15thQuadrennialIAGODSymposium.SaltaArgentina.Website:www.iagod.org/node/7613-15SEPTEMBERSIAMConferenceonMathematicsofPlanetEarth(MPE18).PhiladelphiaPAUSA. Website:www.siam.org/meetings/mpe1816-21SEPTEMBERIWAWorldWaterCongress&Exhibition2018.TokyoJapan.Website:tinyurl.com/ybpmakrc14-18OCTOBER AustralianGeoscienceCouncilConvention.AdelaideSAAustralia.Website:tinyurl.com/zqxc6n225-26OCTOBER Sampling2018.LimaPeru.Website:www.encuentrometalurgia.com/Sampling-2018

Gwendy E.M. Hall, Treasurer 110 Aaron Merrick Drive Merrickville, ON K0G 1N0 Canada TEL: +1-613-269-7980 email: [email protected]

David B. Smith, Secretary U.S. Geological Survey Box 25046, MS 973 Denver, CO 80225, USA TEL: (303) 236-1849 email: [email protected]

Al ArseneaultP.O. Box 26099, 72 Robertson Road, Ottawa, ON K2H 9R0 CANADA,

TEL: (613) 828-0199 FAX: (613) 828-9288, e-mail: [email protected]

THE ASSOCIATION OF APPLIED GEOCHEMISTSP.O. Box 26099, 72 Robertson Road, Ottawa, Ontario K2H 9R0 CANADA • Telephone (613) 828-0199

www.appliedgeochemists.org

AAG COMMITTEES

COUNCILLORS

Brazil João Larizzatti [email protected] Brian Townley [email protected] Xueqiu Wang [email protected] Europe Pertti Sarala [email protected]

Southern Europe Benedetto De Vivo [email protected] Asia Iftikar Malik [email protected] Africa Theo Davies [email protected] and Republic of Ireland Kate Knights [email protected]

Ryan Noble, President CSIRO P.O. Box 1130 Bentley, Australia 6102 TEL: +61 8 6436 8684 email: [email protected]

Steve Cook, Vice-President Teck Resources Limited Suite 3300, 550 Burrard Street Vancouver, BC Canada V6C 0B3 TEL: +1 604 699 4329 email: [email protected]

New MembershipNigel Radford, [email protected] Awards and MedalsMatt Leybourne [email protected] BennPertti Sarala Romy Matthies

AdmissionsNigel Radford, [email protected] EducationPaul Morris, [email protected]

SymposiaDavid Cohen, [email protected]

2016-2017 Dennis Arne Mel Lintern Romy Matthies Paul Morris Erick Weiland Matthew Leybourne (exofficio)

AAG COORDINATORS

AAG Student Paper PrizeDavid Cohen, [email protected]

AAG WebsiteGemma Bonham-Carter, [email protected] Coordinator: Tom Meuzelaar, [email protected]

Geoscience CouncilsDavid Cohen, [email protected]

GEEAKurt Kyser, [email protected]

EXPLOREBeth McClenaghan, [email protected]

ELEMENTSDennis Arne, [email protected]

AAG Regional CouncillorsStephenCook,[email protected]

2017-2018 Dave Cohen Ray Lett Tom Meuzelaar Juan Carlos Ordóñez Calderón Renguang Zuo

OFFICERSJanuary - December 2017

AAG BUSINESS MANAGER